← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick Town Council Reviews Capital Improvement Program and Funding Options

2026-11-09 · 1h 59m · Source: 2026.11.9 Town Council CIP Workshop (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Public Comment
[0:06] Chair/Presiding Officer: Good evening, everybody, and welcome to the November 9th Town Council Capital Improvement Program Workshop, hosted by the Finance Committee. That's why yours truly is up here. I'm going to do a little round-robin here of who's present, and that would include, from my far right, Counselor Richard Ellis. Councillor James Ecker, Councillor Kim Anderson, Councillor Corey Peralt, Assistant Town Manager Jay Astle. I'm Steve Weems, Chair of the Finance Committee, Town Councillor, Town Manager Julia Henze. Councillor McDonald is expected sometime shortly. shortly. Councilor Kathy Wilson is on Zoom and who Ramona and Councilor Ramona Timi has joined us. She also is on Zoom. I think I mentioned Councilor Hicks is unable to be with us this evening. With that out of the way. Let me ask the town manager if this workshop was properly noticed. Yes, it was. Thank you very much moving right through this agenda with equity number two is adjustments to the agenda and public comment are there any adjustments that anyone wants to make seeing none i am going to take some public comment but do a little bit of a change of strategy here and take any public comment that anyone wants to make now and then again end so when we have time at the end a couple of citizens have suggested that it would be useful to have a public comment opportunity after the presentations at these workshops and i think that has some merit and therefore we'll split the public comment into two pieces here just in case anyone's here now and eager to comment you're you're up and seeing none we will close the public comment period and I'm going to turn this over to the assistant town manager to introduce this evening's first functional workshops. Thank you Chair Williams. Tonight we have [2:48] Ryan Layton: joint presentation by the engineering and public works departments so Ryan Layton public works director and Laura Smith project engineer. [3:01] Chair/Presiding Officer: Oh and just before they begin the rest of the agenda will include the presentations by engineering and public works, but then a further presentation on optional funding of the capital improvements program by our town manager. All set? Indeed. Go ahead, please. [3:24] Ryan Layton: Good evening. I'm Ryan Leighton, the public works director. [3:27] Laura Smith: I'm Laura Smith, project engineer. [3:30] Ryan Layton: We're going to present this long list of projects that are ongoing together because there's quite a bit of overlap between public works and engineering. And as you may know, with our town engineer currently unavailable, Laura's kind of been thrust into the spotlight for this. And so we've been working together on shepherding these projects forward and try to give you some updates on some existing and some proposed new projects. So with that, we'll start working through the presentation. And go ahead. [4:03] Laura Smith: We're going to start with a list of culvert stream crossings. The first couple that I'll talk about are both part of the Mayor Brook watershed, and a couple of the other culverts that Ryan will talk about later are also in this watershed, but the Mayor Brook is an urban-impaired stream, and the entire watershed is within the town of Brunswick, so it's kind of a unique opportunity for stream stewardship. The town has had many studies done in this watershed. We have a watershed management plan, and the recommendations in the plan are replacing many culverts. Two of those are the Richards Drive culvert and the Sparwell Lane culvert. They both received funding through a 319 grant program through Cumberland County Soil Water Conservation District. So we have full designs for both of these culverts. They were put out to bid in 2024, and the bids came back much higher than we anticipated, so we didn't proceed with construction at that time. So now we are asking for construction funding for $450,000 for the Richards culvert. So this just kind of shows some of the sheets from the design. The purpose is to upsize the culvert so that it can pass larger storms and improve the wildlife habitat in the stream. You can kind of see the profile of the old, or sorry, the cut section of the existing culvert in gray, just a small circular pipe, and we'd be replacing it with a box culvert with a naturalized stream bed. Spurwell Road culvert is very similar. We also had the design funding through a 319 grant, and same as Richard's, we put it out to bid kind of at the same time. So the bids were too high. We didn't proceed. We're asking for construction funding estimated at $1 million. This one is more involved, more expensive. We're also hoping to improve the road curvature and profile during this project, and there's more utility conflicts for this one. You can just kind of see the current condition of the culvert, really steep embankment, a lot of erosion happening. And we would be kind of improving the curve of the road here. You can see it's a dip and a curve at the same time. So while we replace this culvert, we want to try to improve that a little bit. That just shows the existing profile of the road, dotted line, and then the proposed roadway in the black line. Bunganuck Road culvert is an old culvert. It was constructed in 1948, and it's just at the end of its functional life. It's been rated as structurally deficient by the DOT in the last several biannual studies that they do. We have 60% design plans to replace the culvert with a bridge, and that would allow us to widen the road and provide for future bike lanes. In this location, we are asking for 2.2 million for estimated construction costs. We have applied for grants and did not receive them through the main infrastructure adaptation fund. We kind of just found that out last week, that we did not receive that funding and [7:58] Councilor: this just shows. Excuse me, Laura, is there a [8:03] Chair/Presiding Officer: further story associated with our inability to get either of those grants that were listed you mentioned for Sparwell? Yeah, we did not get like a [8:14] Laura Smith: score sheet or anything explaining why. I know that the volume of grants that were applied for like far exceeded the funding that they had available. I know that the main focus of the grant is increasing storm resiliency for climate change impacts, and on Bunganuck Road the capacity of that culvert is actually already meets the 100-year storm, so that one wasn't a great fit for the grant, but we figured we would apply anyway. And so that's the details that I have on that. We didn't get much information other than we didn't get the grant. [9:01] Councilor: Can I ask as well? You used the word insufficient. It was deemed as insufficient. What does that mean? I mean, I know what the word technically means, but what does that mean from an engineering perspective? Sorry, structurally deficient. [9:13] Laura Smith: Structurally deficient, yes. Yeah, it's a steel culvert, and it's rusting and failing. I don't know if... [9:21] Councilor: And so that would potentially impact the road above it? Is that what the concern is? [9:27] Laura Smith: Yeah, that would be the concern, that it could wash out. You can kind of see the rust and coming through the rust. It's harder to see, but, yeah, some of the road-based material could start eroding through, basically. That's just a picture of what Bunganuk Road currently looks like. So clearly that road is not in the best condition and we would like to be able to widen it to provide for bike lanes. [10:05] Chair/Presiding Officer: I'm sorry I'm not on duty very well here. I'm sorry I was also slow to raise [10:10] Councilor: my hand wasn't another selling point of the Bunganuck proposal was that it would put the bridge on state responsibility for maintaining versus a culvert which would be less expensive [10:23] Laura Smith: but our responsibility to maintain yes in general if the bridge span meets certain dimensional criteria for the dot they do take it over we're kind of in ongoing conversations with the dot about whether this one would qualify but that 's the goal so [10:51] Ryan Layton: I'm going to talk briefly about a couple other smaller culverts one of them is the river road culvert. This one actually is inspected, similar to Bunganuck, is inspected by the DOT on a regular basis and is deficient and does need to be replaced. $75,000 was appropriated in the current fiscal year for design and permitting, and we're in the process of obtaining a scope of services from an engineering firm to assist us with the design, permitting, and ultimately putting that project out to bid the next two are kind of tied together mainly because they're included in the Cumberland County hazard mitigation plan which was a little bit of news to us a couple years ago so we put them in the CIP a couple years ago and this is again just a couple culverts this one's on Pleasant Hill Road which is actually a dual set of culverts and based on where they're located in the kind of the dip in the road they have potential for overtopping during significant rain events so we 've we've programmed them into the cip so they're on the radar to be addressed but there's not a specific time frame at this point and the same would go for highland road which is another they're a smaller set of culverts and again same idea kind of in a dip in the road in the fields out there on highland road So we've included them as part of our capital improvement plan so that way we can work them through the schedule. That's it for culverts that we have. [12:33] Chair/Presiding Officer: There's a question here, Brian. [12:34] Councilor: Yeah, quick question on these culverts. So when they get replaced, do they all need to meet the StreamSmart standards in terms of installation? [12:45] Ryan Layton: I would say most likely based on their locations, yes. [12:48] Councilor: Okay, because that last one, I recall, the exit of it is pretty high above, not Highland, Pleasant Hill Road. Yeah, the exit sits pretty high above the stream bed there. [13:03] Ryan Layton: Yeah, and that particular one, we're looking to see, I mean, I'll be quite honest, we have a culvert that we purchased several years ago that's sitting up at Grammar Processing Facility. If there's any way that culvert will fit in this location, I think that's something that we're trying to evaluate right now in potentially either one of these locations. But we haven't gone through the engineering effort to determine if it's a suitable replacement for either one of these spots. [13:32] Councilor: Right. And just one other question. I'm just looking at this versus the draft CIP. piece so what's recommended for funding is simply the engineering for this at this point not the actual culvert replacement correct yeah all right thanks i think that's kind of going to be the [13:49] Ryan Layton: theme on a lot of these projects is and i think that 's what we've been doing over the past several years is let's get the design you know underhand first with a smaller kind of chunk of the pie and then that'll really inform what we need to ask for construction funding number one but also just so that way we can keep phasing some of this stuff through again that's kind of the it for discussion on culverts the next item we had to talk about was kind of road maintenance and i'm going to kick that off a little bit as you know every year we go through and do a spreadsheet on which roads we're going to pave every year A lot of those decisions we made based on a lot of just anecdotal conversations, just a lot of it is our guys that drive the roads on a regular basis, especially during the winter. Some of the feedback we get there, obviously some of the citizen recommendations that we receive that kind of weigh in on that. The goal, as we've mentioned I think last year, was to move to more of a data aspect of that, and that was for us to update our pavement condition ratings. The last time our pavement condition ratings were updated were in 2019, so we went through that effort this summer with a firm, and we hope to have the results of that effort by the end of November, and then we'll come back to the council, probably as part of the public works budget presentation, and kind to discuss the paving plan, so we don't have a paving plan in this presentation tonight. Our intent is to go through the research or the data that we get back from this effort and then have a place to start I guess, and then we'll we'll take the feedback and kind of work together to figure out what that plan is going to look like for the next couple years. Throughout all that, I mean, we do actively work with sewer water to try to coordinate our projects. We'll talk about Noble Street later, but Noble Street's a prime example, that's a project that's kind of in the queue based on work the sewer department wants to do, along with obviously the condition of Noble Street. At the same time, we've been, as you know, with the Main Street project, we tried to do what we can do based on the funding to address sidewalks, curbing, drainage when possible, and then improvements for the other modes of transportation, bicycle, pedestrian, so on and so forth. This is kind of the history of where we've been. That's the old PCI rating map, just threw it up there as a placeholder and just kind of a teaser on what we're what we're expecting when we when we get the new version. Again, every road will be rated based on this criteria, and then we can have something that will help drive our planning process for the next four or five years, excuse me. [16:54] Chair/Presiding Officer: Ryan, and how many how many miles of roads do we have to maintain? 147. 47? 147. Thank you. [17:05] Ryan Layton: This is the history of what the paving budget is has included for the last several years. Again, we ran into some issues. I think last year was the one we'll talk about a little bit later on with Wildwood, where that project was too much to really ultimately fit within the paving budget. If we were to do all the streets at one time, which we felt there was some real added benefit for doing that, so we've kind of taken a step back and, quite frankly, to where we were many years ago, where we would have major capital improvement projects, road rehabilitation and major road reconstruction projects would be funded separately, kind of like Jordan Ave and some other projects, and then leave this budget for doing more of the routine maintenance type efforts, that's that's a little less and less invasive. And as part of all that and planning and trying to move the trying to maximize our dollars, we've done very well working with Maine DOT utilizing their municipal partnership improvement program, which is the MPI program, and that's a 50-50 match on state eligible roads for projects. The Main Street project we just completed this past summer was an MPI project, 50-50 split between the town and the state. In the CIP book, there's a MPI project tab, and we've listed out kind of where we're at with current projects as well as where we're looking to go with the next round of projects, and some of them we'll talk about a little bit later on. Actually, right now. I forgot we had this one, so we have applied for Federal Street or in the process of applying for Federal Street section. We have applied for Union Street, which is section out here from McKean to the to the railroad crossing, and then the next project kind of that we see in the queue right here were Harpswell Road culvert as well as some improvements to Harpswell Road, and then River Road, and then we've got some additional Main Street project plans for the future, but some of that stuff we're holding off on based on some of the work that DOT is going to be doing in town over the next couple of years and just the way things can sequence through the MPI program, and we're on to Union Street, so [19:57] Laura Smith: Union Street is a project that we've just applied for the MPI funding. The intention is to redo the roadway, improve drainage, and in particular, improve pedestrian safety on Union Street. You probably are all familiar with Union Street. It has really large curb cuts, so cars can just pull in and out of businesses, kind of a disorganized way. It makes it pretty unsafe for pedestrians and bicyclists. So the intention is not only to fix up the pavement roadway surface, which you can see is in pretty poor condition, but also the intention is to close off some of those large curb cuts and put in more sidewalk on the that's the north side of the road. So this is part of our 50% design plan, so the plans are in development, and we're looking to move toward construction. [21:03] Councilor: Just a quick question. Is it all of Union Street, or is it a section of Union Street? [21:07] Laura Smith: It's from the railroad crossing to McKean Street. [21:10] Councilor: To McKean. Okay. Thank you. [21:20] Ryan Layton: Got to keep our notes in order here. Who's back and forth? So I mentioned, again, the Harpswell Road culvert and sidewalk. Well, Harpswell Road itself, the culvert, and then an addition of sidewalk as you're coming out of town. Again, it's not in the next couple years. I guess we don't have a date yet for when this would happen, but we estimated the design around $200,000. And, again, that's based on the efforts that's happened on Jordan Ave. that's kind of where our benchmark came from and then same with the with the construction estimate the we potentially have some options for breaking that project up into two discrete projects with DoT applied to different for two different MPI grants. that's kind of how we did the Main Street the way we did that was two different applications and then we kind of did it all together. so if we can if we can finesse the program enough to do it that way that 's kind of what would be our goal didn't mention it on the previous slide but right now we are capped at a seven hundred and fifty thousand dollar match so we would want to try to break that up and maximize the use of those fifty percent funds. this isn't in going back to the mere brick watershed this is kind of the first culvert in major culvert that really needs to be addressed and then we would work our way upstream Main Street being the next kind of major roadway culvert same idea for this one intended to be an mpi project we knew It was going to be, we knew it wasn't going to happen right away, which is why we went through the Main Street project the way we did. But this is that we would come back and do this culvert at some point. We're into major road reconstruction projects, kind of what we talked about, the projects that we've pulled out of the paving plan to become more of a discrete project on their own. Noble Street originally made the paving plan because sewer department is looking to replace a sewer line there. I think everybody knows the condition in Noble Street. It's been on Public Works radar because we wanted to do something with the sidewalk, but there was no good answers on how to address that based on where the sidewalk is located in relation to some of the houses further up towards the hotel and what you have for space for a potential sidewalk and slopes and this that and everything and everything else. So it was it was deemed the best bet would be to just look at the street holistically and figure out what the best course of action is. The fact the sewer, it's a narrow street anyway, so the fact the sewer department will be going through there, it's it's the opportune time to kind of work together with that department and do a project together. We have done some design effort to this point and we did have a neighborhood meeting back in September and got some pretty good feedback from that meeting. So, again, that's a project that's ongoing, and just, I mean, like I said, I think we all know what it looks like. [24:28] Laura Smith: Stephen Drive is in Cook's Corner, and it is currently not a through street. It's privately owned, and it connects at Gurnett Road but ends before Thomas Point Road. It's part of our Cook's Corner revitalization plan to create another connection between Thomas Point Road and Gurnett Road. Currently, Thomas Point Road only has one connection, which is at Bath Road, and that's a known high-crash intersection. So creating a through-street connection between Gurnett Road and Thomas Point Road would alleviate the intersection of Bath Road and Thomas Point Road. So we currently are in the design phase and working with the private owners of the land that Stephen Drive is currently on to transfer that to the town and to build a full through street that would be a complete street with a 10-foot multimodal pathway. And it's kind of the first phase of being able to improve Thomas Point Road. And we have applied for a BPI grant that's a business partnership initiative, which is a kind of a third, a third, a third cost share with the town, the DOT, and the private business owners. [25:59] Chair/Presiding Officer: Cushing Street. Excuse me, Laura, is that one of those one-third, one-third, one-third deals? Yes, that's right. [26:08] Laura Smith: Yeah, and we just submitted that application toward the end of October, so we're hoping to hear about that sometime soon. Cushing Street is a road sort of similar to Union Street that just has really wide open curb cuts. It has drainage issues, sidewalk issues, so we have done survey for the road and have sort of some conceptual ideas of how to improve that, but it's very early stages of design. You can just see the poor pavement condition and all that wide-open street-to-parking-lot interface. So as I said, we've done survey and sort of have some concept-level ideas of how to close off some of those curb cuts. Additionally, as part of this project, you can see, I think, if I go back to the map, it's kind of hard to see, but on the south side of Cushing, there's a yellow strip that's a right-of-way into the Nathaniel Davis Park. And so the goal would be to create a pedestrian access crossing the railroad, and you would be able to go from Cushing Street into the park. So that's included in this project. And this just shows the blue dots are catch basins, stormwater catch basins, and the blue lines are stormwater pipes. There's kind of some complicated drainage infrastructure on Cushing Street that we would be addressing as part of this project so [27:57] Ryan Layton: As you're all aware, Wildwood was a project that was, we had intended to fund last year through the paving plan and realized that was not going to work from a financial standpoint based on our goals for what we wanted to do in Wildwood. So that's a project that we pulled out, but in the last couple weeks we've finalized some more intensive repairs with a contractor. We shimmed about nine hundred and twenty five feet of road and they've replaced, we had a couple different curb issues, we had some Curbing where there was no sidewalks, we did about 600 feet of just curbing and then in that area, and then we had another hundred and seven, another seven hundred and sixty feet of curb and sidewalk sections that we addressed that were kind of spread out in the. We just went in and tried to pick the worst areas to try to address what we could in the interim with the intent that we would move forward when budgets work for us to be able to do the neighborhood in full with some drainage improvements. And then all new granite curbing with new sidewalks and basically try to get that neighborhood all taken care of at one time. I should have kept going through the slides instead of just looking at my notes. This is taken from that PCI rating that we had. Again, this is from 2019. It didn't get any better between 2019 and this past year. So some of those greens likely are definitely not green at this point. Point. But again, just being able to zoom in on that neighborhood, it really can kind of give you an idea once we have the accurate PCIs that we can, you know, if everything in that area was orange, yellow, or red, then it would be, you know, it would help justify the reason why that neighborhood we selected to do. And that's kind of like in a snapshot why we really wanted to get the PCI ratings updated townwide. Now we're on to Longfellow. Sorry about that. [30:16] Laura Smith: The next several that Ryan and I will talk about are roads that we know the roadway condition is bad. The sidewalks aren't ADA compliant. There's drainage issues. These are projects that we have, they're on our list as known problems, but we haven't started doing any design for yet. The design money currently and in the future construction money you can just see the ponding issues, drainage issues on the road surface. The sewer department did a project here recently, and so there's a trench of, you know, new pavement the whole length of the road. We weren't able to do the full road width at that time, but we're. We're hoping to do that soon. McMillan Drive is very similar. Really poor pavement condition, poor drainage condition. So we're asking for design funding for a consultant designer to help us improve the road. Columbia is very similar. The sidewalks in particular on Columbia are in really bad condition. And we kind of have the constraints of beautiful mature trees and utility poles just presenting obstacles to the design and how we would improve the sidewalk. Thomas Point Road, back on Cook's Corner, very related to the Stephen Drive project. Once we have that through-the-street connection via Stephen Drive, we can do some more improvements on Thomas Point Road. We can't really do Thomas Point Road until we do Stephen Drive because again there's no other way to get onto Thomas Point Road so doing a total reconstruction at the Bath intersection there would just be no other way to get in and out of Thomas Point so we need to do Stephen Drive first and then we can do more improvements on Thomas Point. This project is for the first 0.4 miles which would get from Bath Road to the Tedford housing property. So the intention would be to put in sidewalks, close off curb cuts, and just generally improve that section of road. You can just see the pavement condition currently. [33:01] Chair/Presiding Officer: Laura, what's that distance again? [33:04] Laura Smith: That was 0.4 miles. [33:12] Ryan Layton: Bowker Street is a project that's been kind of on the books for several years at this point. We have gone through full design. The project has not been put out to bid at this point. There haven't been construction funds allocated for this project just yet. There is still some question marks on exactly what direction we want to head, I think, is part of the reason for the delay. We've got competing issues, as typical, with mature street trees that are impacting the sidewalk. Walk. But on the other side of the street is a whole row of utility poles that kind of forces our hand into what we have for usable space. So there's been a couple of different alternatives, I think, that were reviewed by the design firm. But we haven't kind of gotten to the point where we've made a final selection to move forward. You may recall that a couple of years ago, we did overlay the street with a low-cost shim just to, again, buy us some time, which I guess has been a blessing and a curse. It's bought us some time, but we haven't made a further decision on moving forward with the project. So that's just kind of where this one is. It's a little bit of limbo at this point. The biggest thing I think would be to maybe start the utility coordination phase and see about the possibility of moving utility poles. But again, I'll just say that we're kind of in limbo at this point with this project. This is, again, looks great now that we've overlaid it. But we still haven't been able to address the sidewalk, which is the biggest issue. But the street trees are the biggest issue with the sidewalk. So that's kind of the problem where we're at right now. And this is just showing you the cross-section of what we had with the design plans. It did include making a little bit of a better intersection approach at the Pine Street end of this, but again, it's a narrow right-of-way road with quite a bit of competing priorities. Princess Point Road is a road that we constantly get requests about addressing, and I think you'll see in the following picture why. The hard part for us is that the whole road really needs to be addressed, and it's a long section and it's quite expensive, or estimated to be quite expensive. But you can see it's a road that's in dire need of attention. Again, it's how do we fit all these competing projects into the – that's what Jay is going to figure out for us, right? And then try to get this addressed. I mean, their options are to piecemeal it, but where do you start and stop? I mean, that's kind of one of the issues. Old Penneville Road is one that we heard loud and clear that the neighbors don't want paved. So what our thought process was is to look to try to improve the gravel road that's there. And again, this is... The intent would be to just... If we feel pretty comfortable that we could probably just raise the road and achieve what we want from a better roadway, we just really need to work at what the conflicts are with the driveways that are along that stretch of road. And then Peterson Lane is one of the other gravel roads that we had brought forth when we when we proposed paving gravel roads, and it seemed like the folks on Peterson Lane were supportive of pavement, but again, it's a it's a bigger ticket construction item and it's one Of those things, it's like as we go through all these projects, it's like where do we fit it all fit it all in what you can I [37:07] Councilor: Ask on that Peterson Lane, is that presently a town road, the gravel portion [37:11] Ryan Layton: Yes, okay, there's a section at the very beginning of it's paved for a couple hundred feet, and then the whole rest of it's gravel. Okay, it's all and the gravel. This [37:25] Laura Smith: little neighborhood, Greenleaf, Stimson, and Androscoggin Street are all in very poor condition and have quite a bit of drainage complications going on. On Greenleaf is a pretty steep hill, and it's currently just the drainage system is just, you know, kind of sheet flow down the road. And at the bottom of the hill is catch basins that go into the closed drainage system. And then the outfall is at the end of Androscoggin Street, and that outfall has quite a bit of, it's a very steep bank, and it's eroding. So this project includes upgrading the pavement on the roads, improving the drainage system, and kind of stabilizing the banks at the outfall of the stormwater system there. I do want to note, it's not listed on this slide, but it's in your packets. We're asking for $200,000 for design, and then the construction would follow. Middle Bay Road is a road that we've received requests to widen, to put in bike lanes, better bike facilities. It is kind of complicated by existing utility poles on the road and the location of the existing drainage ditches. So we have completed a survey for that project and are requesting design funding for that. You can just kind of see the location of utility poles on both sides of the road in various sections of the road, and then some extreme ditches in certain locations of the road. It's just a long winding road, but it is frequently used by bikers. Before [39:26] Councilor: we move on to that, can I ask a question? You mentioned term shimming on a couple of the projects, particularly the one where I think I recall, was in the Wildwood neighborhood. Does shimming suggest that there'll be a final overlay on those, or is it not necessarily suggest that? Is shimming maybe the, not a long-term solution, but the middle-term solution that we're looking at? I mean, DOT calls light capital paving when [39:51] Ryan Layton: they use like a sand mix type of, and do a drag shim. Basically, we did something very similar, but with a more robust aggregate in the asphalt. But it really was just they shimmed the road. I mean, they paved the whole thing curb to curb, but it is just to try to fill in the ruts. And there's not a second coat that will be going down. This is just an intermediate step that we could take until we could go back and do the road correctly. [40:18] Councilor: And you had mentioned the one that you showed up there. You did specifically use the term overlay, but that would be one that... [40:24] Ryan Layton: It was basically the same thing. Yeah, I mean, it was a 1.5 shimmer overlay. I mean, we only went once, and we just did what we could do to address some of the ruts, but we didn't shim it and then come back again and do a second coat. Okay. Next, we're getting into some of the other projects that we're involved in. The Androscoggin Riverwalk is a project that's been on the books for, well, since I think 2012. Or 13, somewhere around then. In 2017, I guess I should have started here. 2017 was when a feasibility study was approved. Funding was obtained through DOT. And you can see through that list there the different steps that we've taken between then and November 1st of this year. We submitted our final design package to DOT for a final review. Once we get their review and make any changes that they want, then the project will be eligible to go out to bid for construction, which is slated to be sometime at the beginning of January with the intent that the project is constructed during this upcoming construction season. There's a number of reasons why DOT has been very supportive of this project in trying to get it completed sooner than later at this point because you may have heard that they did have some funding decreases recently. This is one of, for our project manager, this is one of two projects that actually has continued through. So they see the benefit of finishing this section, but it also ties into some future DOT projects, mainly the pool table, which you may have heard of, and then the cabot in the Route 1 connection. They'd like to get this pedestrian project done and over with before then. I think partially so that way that facility will be there for added options in terms of pedestrian movement during construction. But also just so that way there's not any overlapping construction windows as far as that's concerned. This is just the project originally started at 10 foot wide multi-use path. And that was estimated to be about two and a half million dollars back in 2025. DOT capped the project limit for that to $1.5 million, meaning that they're willing to pay 80% of the $1.5 million, and that was the extent of it. Working with the Riverwalk Committee, we worked our way down to a 5.5-foot-wide asphalt sidewalk. Walk, but it does include new granite curb, new guardrails, and tried to meander away from the roadway the best that we could and to try to meet some of the original goals of the Riverwalk Committee. The latest estimate is that just over a million dollars, and again that's being reviewed right now with hopes that we can proceed with advertisement and [43:45] Chair/Presiding Officer: We'll go on to another. Excuse me, Ryan. Yes. That was for Section A on that map you showed, right? [43:53] Ryan Layton: Yes. That would be Section A, the green section down below. Section B would be accomplished as part of the pool table project. [44:04] Chair/Presiding Officer: And anticipated when and for the timing of the pool table project. [44:12] Ryan Layton: 2028, but do not hold us to that. I [44:18] Councilor: have a question about that project as well, if I could chime in. [44:23] Chair/Presiding Officer: Yes, go ahead, please. [44:26] Councilor: So with the MDOT cap being at 1.5, is that like because of the 2.5 roughly original estimate? So now that we have it down to a million, the MDOT cap is also lower, or are we, like, missing out on, you know, a wider, better path that we could potentially have if we, you know, push the project to get the estimate closer to 1.5? [44:56] Ryan Layton: Part of it is that the original, the 1.5 was based on a different stopping point. This project, they ended up stopping. We matched our two projects, the pool table project and this Riverwalk project, and there ended up being some additional savings to the Riverwalk portion of the project because we shortened it, so that way the entire Riverwalk portion was in right away, already owned by the DOT. DOT. We have added some additional couple of things. We've added that estimate includes the guardrail design that the Riverwalk Committee was looking for, which is more of a timber with a steel back to it instead of your typical roadway guardrail. DOT is still evaluating whether or not they'll approve that. It has been used in other applications. So that's. That's a slightly more expensive guardrail option. But the other thing is that $1,014,000 doesn't include the inspections and construction engineering portion of the project that will also be on top of that construction estimate. So we were still staying below that 1.5 cap, but also there was very little that you could do to the trail to make it wider. We tried to make it wider in portions where they could. But the biggest issues that we ran into is by widening it at any point, especially that area that's got the red line there, you start getting into building a very expensive retaining wall, and that was what really kind of drove the price up significantly to that $2.5 million. So I think that we recognize the question in understanding wanting to maximize the funding that we can obtain from DOT. I think that we are doing that with this project where we're at. And it's still just an engineer's estimate at this point. So we've got to see how the bids actually come in, especially based on the work that has to be done adjacent to Route 1 in that section. And it has to be night work. So there's still some question marks when it actually comes back from a bid standpoint. [47:02] Councilor: That makes a lot of sense. Thank you so much. Councilor Ecker. Yeah, on that project, maybe this is a question for the assistant town manager. So I'm looking in the CIP. There's Combined million dollars more for design in 2728 Right on the projects recommended for funding. Where's the rest of this? [47:28] Ryan Layton: The word design I've actually had a cross staff. So that was a mistake for draft one. I'll have it amended for draft two. And what was the question? Where's the other DOT money? I'll have to answer that in a few minutes. Okay, this [47:57] Laura Smith: is the McCoy Road, Mere Point Road, Main Street intersection at the southern end of Main Street. It's kind of a large branching Y intersection that's hard for bicyclists and pedestrians to navigate, so we would like to do a study to just see what other options for reconfiguring that intersection might be. We've broken it into a feasibility preliminary design study, and the consultant would present a few options to us. We would ask them to consider kind of reconfiguring to be closer to a T intersection, which would be safer, or to consider the possibility of a traffic circle there. And then after we looked at what options are even feasible given the traffic there, bus turning movements going to the high school, all of those considerations, we would move on to the final design after that. Council parole just curious if there's been any thought to making [49:02] Councilor: McCoy Road be the major connector to Main Street rather than Mere Point, because in my thought that would alleviate a lot of the traffic that gets stopped at the intersection coming from the high school because they have to wait for Mere Point to come rather than if McQuaid could, have that, then there'd be no backed up traffic, right? [49:28] Laura Smith: We would, we would kind of look at all that. Consider if a signalized intersection would help. We do have the average daily traffic accounts for those roads. So I think that the near point road has the higher volume of traffic currently. So that's kind of the preferred, you know, through street length. [49:50] Councilor: I mean, I understand that, but the problem is that there's two times a day where traffic is really backed up significantly. So even though Muir Point might have more overall traffic, it's spread out over the entire day versus McCoy. So I'm just curious if for anybody that has had kids at the high school we've wondered [50:18] Laura Smith: that for 31 years now. Yeah, I'm I'm sure and we would definitely include assessing whether a traffic signal there which could you know give preference to McCoy at those high traffic times of day, if that would be feasible, what impacts that would have on the surrounding roads. [50:42] Councilor: Councilor Ecker. Just quickly, I know at a recent school board meeting, we looked for some feedback on some of the work that the town is doing. And I think, McCoy, this intersection down to the high school was, I think, one of their, at least the feedback we got immediately at the meeting was this was one of the two priority areas for them. And just looking quickly, this is being put off not till next fiscal year, but it's in the CIP for the year after to do the engineering. I think last year it was going to be done in 27-28. So I'm just curious if we're pushing this down the road further to do this design work or if it's something we can look at. [51:41] Laura Smith: I don't have an immediate answer for that. I see Jay looking at his. [51:46] Ryan Layton: Yeah, we can consider it. Yeah. Okay, great. [51:53] Chair/Presiding Officer: It did sound like a management question. Definitely was. [52:02] Ryan Layton: We're almost to the end. Church Road, Pleasant Hill Road intersection, same deal. It's just one of those intersections that you'd never design an intersection like that now. Now. Maybe not ever. Again, from a priority standpoint, don't know where it'll fall when it comes to putting together the full CIP package, but it's one of those, I mean, the whole point of the CIP is to make sure we have these projects so we don't forget about them. And I think that's the biggest reason why this one is there. And I think probably the same with this next one, which is Collinbrook Road hacker in Durham, which has got a signal that works most of the time but it's not very reliable that we know of and is definitely better technology now and it's just one of those areas that it needs to be evaluated on what the right approach is what's available and you know ultimately what it would cost and when we could afford to do it so it's again another one of those we've put on the radar do we have any [53:06] Councilor: Commentary on this being a resident of hacker road and yeah the signal stinks because half the time it's blinking and nobody's coming and the other half you oh it's not blinking and you pull out and then someone's coming over the hill to greet you just I'm just really curious like do you have any ideas of some of the things that they're looking at just because it is it is It's terrifying to pull out some days from there. [53:35] Ryan Layton: We have, I mean, that signal is maintained by one of our contractors, and that's, I mean, it's one of those, I mean, he brought it up to us. I mean, if we can't get this to work, then we're going to have to replace it with something else. So I guess, again, we haven't gotten to the point where we have any funding in the budget to address this specific location, but it is certainly an area that we know is of concern and at some point we need to address. [54:10] Laura Smith: This project is the design funding request for putting in a hybrid beacon at the town commons on Harpswell Road to have a safe pedestrian crossing to connect from the town commons to the perimeter trail. So that would be, it kind of looks like a traffic light, but the lights are only lit up when a pedestrian has pushed the button. Then they'll you know get ready to turn red so that the pedestrian can cross and when there's no pedestrian the lights are just off so because of the speed on Harpswell Road that's kind of the necessary technology for that location I [55:00] Ryan Layton: Did see in draft one that the public works facility was no longer recommended and I had a chat with the town manager assistant town manager and we rectified that but the public works facility still highly recommended from the public works standpoint so just in just a brief just wanted to add it in here again it's a project underway we are working with the with the task force and we do have a public hearing or public meeting scheduled for December 17th so progress is still continuing it is still Most certainly a priority, and look forward to moving forward with that project. And with that, I think we've exhausted the slides. Any questions we can answer also? [55:44] Councilor: For all, I'm actually — Counselor Ellis may have said this in some other sitting, but he certainly mentioned to me, I thought it was a great idea, in regards to the public works department and your efforts to take on maintenance or increase the maintenance that you're doing. Have you guys looked at potentially doing, like, that piece off-site? What I'm thinking of is there's an, not abandoned, but empty building on Pleasant Street where Brunswick Ford was, and has there been any thought, like, outside the box to maybe do it at a location like that? Just, and it's okay if there's not. It's just, when Councilor Ellis said that to me, I'm like, wow, that's a great thing to think about, whether or not it works for you guys is a totally different story. [56:39] Ryan Layton: I would say when it comes to that, I mean, well, number one, we did hear a rumor about that. I'm not sure what sources it came from our standpoint, but it's my understanding that building may lack the headroom that we need, which is problematic where we're at already, and I'm not sure that building would solve that issue. The other part of the whole fleet management spinoff was that it was going to be an incremental change so that way we could move forward at a pace that was, at the time, kind of match where we were at with the facility. But also just there's a lot of, you'll see when we come to the budget this year, it's how do we divide those departments and what stays with public works, what goes with fleet management. And then, you know, then there's another whole year of that, you know, that learning curve. So I think that we haven't really looked too far about trying to divide and conquer as far as that's concerned, because we also frankly need the — we prefer the overlap. We are their biggest customer and will continue to be their biggest customer. So, I mean, I'm not sure that 's – it's not something that we really dove into with any sort of serious thought process. [58:01] Councilor: General question, and not on that topic, but on a different topic. So you went through a lot of roads today, and I know that there are other ones within the capital improvement plan that are laid out in future years and what have you. Is there a tool or something that we have that shows, like, when roads were last paved and when people might even expect? So if you're not on the wish list for the next five years, when might you expect to see? And the reason I ask is I'm now realizing, as much as I responded to a constituent on this issue about the road that I actually live on, I'm now realizing that I gave them bad information and that we're only doing a portion of that road, which would not include hers, which I'm going to have to go back and let her know. But is there something that sort of lays that out as to, like, when we anticipate getting to other areas of town or if it's just if you're not on list? We don't even know. Is that kind of well. I think that's kind of, I mean, we've kind of in years past [58:58] Ryan Layton: We've always just kind of gone to that, what the road, the paving plan was at the time, which is just spreadsheet form that makes it to the CIP yada, and then, I mean, a prime example, Lunt Road wasn't on our radar very, you know, at the beginning of some of the more recent paving plans. But after having been out there and witnessing it and, I mean, the sheer disaster that the road was, I mean, for us, we put it to the top because it needed to be done. But that flies in the face of trying to trying to make these decisions from a data-driven standpoint, which is again why we said whatever was in the CIP before you may just want to take it with a grain of salt at this point until we finalize payment condition rating effort so that way we have the most up-to-date information so we can make decisions moving forward that are more clear and transparent and everything else. So I think to answer your question, a long way of answering a question, but ultimately that PCI data lives in our GIS. We have a very capable GIS administrator. We can take that data once it's there. We can, the goal will be that it's continuously updated with, you know, we just went out and did however much of Main Street, the pavement condition rating, then it comes back because they drove it before we did it, is going to show that Main Street's in rough shape, but it's going to be on us to make sure That we have that section updated with our by the GIS administrator so that way the layers that we show to the public on that application are accurate. [1:00:44] Councilor: Yeah, because it makes it I will say this is my own problem I've got to deal with now. My section of my road is being paved, hers is not, and so I'm going back with that, and I noted that you I'll deal with that, but I don't and again so what I'm hearing is that none of these are approved improved anyways, right? Like, this is the plan, and I know it's a program, but we have a plan for the roads that we're going to tackle. But what I'm hearing you say is we put in our best for this year, and this is where we think we'll be in the next four years, but all of that is fungible, and as we see road conditions get one way or the other, we'll replace it. I did notice, though, and this was a new thing for me just in looking at this, you have a mechanism of a moratorium on certain roads that was introduced, I think, fairly recently to control costs and what have you. So there are certain roads that we could say with pretty strong certainty that we won't be doing these roads in the next X years depending upon which road it is. Is that something that you guys are still using as a control standard? I think December 2025 was the last time I saw a document on that published. [1:01:46] Ryan Layton: What we do is before each season, before we finalize our list, so we're developing our bid specs, advertising for bid. When we've gotten to that point, we send out letters to all the abutters along those stretches of road to say, look, we've got a road project coming through this summer. If you need to do any utility work in the street, sewer, water, natural gas, whatever it is, you should plan to do it right now because that road will be under a five-year moratorium after we've completed our work. And that's kind of the approach that we've taken. And so some of those ones that you'll see on the moratorium list are ones that we have done within the last five years. And again, back to your problem, it's not always the whole section of road that's on that, right? I mean, it's a section that we've done, not the whole road. So, I mean, that may be a confusing point. I guess I haven't looked at that layer recently to see how that shows, if it shows just a section or if it shows the whole thing. But that's something that we can provide clarity for. [1:02:49] Councilor: The other thing I would say is these documents aren't always synchronized, and that's understandable as to why they get that way. Like if I look at one document from 2025, it might show one thing. If I look at the draft CIP that we're looking at now, it's going to say a different thing. If I look at last year's CIP, it might say something entirely different. And so it's just, again, I'm probably going to convene with the town manager just to make sure I can get a more accurate answer for my constituent as far as her section. Councilor Ecker. Just a comment. You said it at the beginning and it might also help councillor Ellis here I'm not sure if it's the issue of it, but the paving schedule is not in here yet [1:03:27] Ryan Layton: So that was by design this year Yeah until we could and again we talked about it internally that you know It made sense that by the time we should have this information Hopefully by the end of the month give us you know at least the month of December to kind of Digest it and work together to develop what we think the plan should be I mean, part of it is that having that data, we can kind of figure out, based on whatever we're going to anticipate for funding, we can try to address how we can spread that out. But then we'll hopefully have a draft proposed, however you want to classify it, suggestion that we'll bring when we start doing department presentations for the regular budget. We'll present the paving one at that time. [1:04:21] Chair/Presiding Officer: Assistant Town Manager Astle. [1:04:24] Ryan Layton: Councilor Ecker, can I answer your question about the Riverwalk? Were you asking about because the DOT cap was $1.5 million and the project is only a million and we're showing $800,000 from that, it's because the project is only in a million dollars even though DOT's cap is $1.5 as we have it estimated it's only a million dollar project so and the requirement for the project is a 20% local match so we're we're roped into providing a match it's not that they would pick up all of it because their cap is at 1.5 oh yeah sorry draft 2 has that changed yeah, sorry. Sorry for the confusion. [1:05:16] Councilor: Stop reading the reports. Please read the reports. [1:05:25] Chair/Presiding Officer: I'll have to admit, I'm a little confused about that now because I thought you made some commentary about there's some add-on cost to the million that would bring it up closer to, I don't know, all the way to a million and five, but substantially higher for other elements of the project that aren't in the current estimate? [1:05:45] Ryan Layton: It the only thing that isn't in there is construction engineering and that's only a small portion of what would be remaining. Thank you. Go ahead Assistant Town Manager Rastel. Yeah I was just going to add and Councilor Williams you probably know this because you've been part of some of those Riverwalk conversations and meetings. We did talk about some public art installations as part of this section of the Riverwalk that would always have been add-on and the local match or local funding would have to pick up that cost. DOT was never going to pay for those amenities that weren't integral to the project. [1:06:29] Chair/Presiding Officer: Thank you for that clarification. Anybody else? Looks like you can escape. Thank you very much. Thank you for the nice presentation. Thank you. And now that takes care of our presentation from engineering and public works, an excellent one. We're going to turn to the town manager for her presentation on optional funding CIP. I can't wait to hear this one. So it's interesting how that's phrased, optional funding. Funding, it's actually an optional presentation on funding. So this was meant to be fit in if there was time, and it does seem like there's time, but it isn't really optional funding so much as optional presentation on funding. So I know Larry has it as well. This was something that I prepared. So the piece of paper you have in front of you says October 15th. We did not do it then, that was a busy night, but this is more of a general presentation on lots of questions that we often get. Like how do projects even get into the CIP? How do they get funded? What are the funding sources and how do we figure that out? So I'm going to move on through. Please stop me with any questions. So the first slide please, next slide please. Oh, sorry, this is one. So people have ideas, and if a project that comes from a committee or a department or often it is generated by staff that notice or are hearing complaints or see an opportunity, if the project is $100,000 or more, or it's part of reserves, or has operating costs of $25,000, it's eligible to go into the CIP. So that project, I'm sorry, I shouldn't have done this live. When I've done this on my own, I can click it myself. So it goes from a committee or a concept. It goes to the manager's office, and we start this process in August, and that is when the manager's office sends out a memo saying, time to bring your CIP projects, bring them all, fill out these forms that are at the back of the CIP, and get them. Them. So obviously, before they get presented, we do need to do some analysis. We need to figure out some level of cost. And so that is done usually by departments, with consultant's help, or really our engineering department does a lot of that. And you'll notice that particularly some of these are fairly rough estimates, particularly the section, the ones that are still in development. Then they get into the CIP, and that's when we start this process. And they get into the CIP document, and that's supposed to be a picture of all of you sitting at the bottom there, until they are actually adopted. The CIP gets adopted in the spring. Reminder, it doesn't actually fund anything by itself. This is a capital improvement program. It is meant more to be indicative that we are capital planning. We are doing capital planning. And the funding is done separately. So now we're going to get into that. So the different methods of funding. The primary ones, debt is for large projects, usually over a million. And as you know, any debt borrowing requires an ordinance with a public hearing and council adoption. General revenues, this is revenues raised in the annual operating budget. This is for the reserve funds. And if you remember, our reserve funds are meant to replace existing vehicles, equipment. Equipment, to do sort of routine or larger than routine repairs to facilities. We also have a reserve for IT because IT is one of those where you're going along with not much cost and then you have a year with a lot of cost. So establishing a reserve with level funding from year to year where you can then save up and to do these projects without having to issue debt. The next one, general fund balance, this is for smaller projects if the fund balance is available. And that is general fund unassigned fund balance. And this is, you'll see lots of these projects in here. There have been years when we didn't have general fund balance, and so pretty much everything had to be funded through debt. Debt. The 2017 debt is composed of a bunch of little projects. We've been lucky in the last seven, eight years to be able to use general fund balance for smaller projects and not have to issue debt. TIF revenues, yeah. [1:12:21] Councilor: Can you define smaller? [1:12:24] Chair/Presiding Officer: Currently, it's at less than $500,000. You know, we're looking at some of these that are in here, you know, I think like 850,000 for Noble Street. I don't think we're going to be able to swing that from general fund balance. I suspect when we look at the next CIP draft, we're not going to be able to make that from general fund balance. That would have to be issuing debt. We are, we are just finished our audit. Our unassigned general fund balance is within the target range. Oh, I'm, I'm getting ahead of myself. Let's keep going. So TIF revenues, we can talk about this more. TIF districts vary. The development programs define what the TIF revenues can be spent on. And we try to maximize that as much as we can in the capital improvement program. So next slide, please. So talking about debt. So some people feel like debt is not a good thing. However, it is an extremely appropriate and suitable use of funding for municipalities. This is typically for major investments, capital infrastructure projects. They're very expensive up front and too expensive to pay for within a single year's budget. It. We also are not in the business of saving up the taxpayer money because really the taxpayer's money should be in their pockets as long as possible. So we don't generally, other than for reserves, which is meant to be an ongoing steady stream, we don't save up for large projects. There's also this concept of intergenerational equity, which means that the people who are paying for it are the people who are using the asset. So if you build a new fire station, you wouldn't want to save up for that, because that means that the people who've paid for it may not even be here anymore. Whereas currently, we're paying debt service on a fire station that the current residents are getting the benefit of. So that's intergenerational equity, and it's an important concept in municipal finance. So next slide, please. This is our existing debt. These are the bonds that we currently have outstanding. I mentioned the 2017 GO bonds. That was actually a collection of different projects. But for all the others, they are sort of standalone projects. 2010 elementary school is Harriet Beecher Stowe. The police station was in 2013. School renovation, the school revolving renovation fund, that's very small, but that is a main municipal bond bank program where a large portion of the, It was partially a grant and then a 0% loan paid back over five years, and we're almost finished paying that last one off. Again, the 2017 GO bonds. 2020 elementary school was Kate Furbish. 2022 was the fire station, the new fire station and a fire truck. And the 2022 property acquisition, that was McCoy Woods. woods. The graph is meant to indicate what is paid for. This is debt service, so this is what we pay on this existing debt every year. And the dark blue is what comes from the general fund budget, so is raised from taxes. The light purple is the school subsidy. The state subsidizes part of the Harriet Beecher Stowe Debt Service. And the orange is TIF revenues. And so, for example, in the 2017 bonds, part of that paid for renovation of what is now the People Plus building. And that could be paid for with TIF revenues. So that's what that was. So that's our existing debt that we are holding as of this past June. [1:16:49] Councilor: I have a question, if I may. With these, like I understand the generational equity question, is do we get penalized if we were to try to pay any of this off early? [1:17:03] Chair/Presiding Officer: So that's one of the things about issuing municipal bonds. That isn't an option. Got it. You can, under certain circumstances, you can refund some of the debt, but generally it's not, that isn't one of those things. When people buy municipal bonds, they want to buy that guaranteed income stream. Heard. Next slide, please. So this is authorized but not issued. There have been a few bond ordinances over the last two years, a few years, actually. The first one was for the tower, which, as you know, was authorized by many of you weren't even around. It was a couple of years ago, but that truck takes a long time to build, so we have not issued that debt. We haven't had to pay anything for it, and we won't issue the debt until we pay for it, which I think we may receive in 2028. I'm looking at our finance director. It's been four years in construction. Jordan Avenue culvert and reconstruction was authorized to be paid from bonds. That one can – the debt service can be paid back with TIF revenues, so that shows up in orange in this graph. Public Works Facility Phase 1A, 4.7, that was authorized last December. And then the Engine 1 replacement was just authorized, I believe, just in July or – and in June this year. And that one we will be receiving sooner. So of that $11 million in authorized debt, $3.2 can be paid from TIF revenues. And so this is the adding that estimated debt service on the authorized debt to the existing debt. [1:19:08] Councilor: Can I ask with the TIF revenue as the source, do those end in 2037 20, 37, because that's the longest length of our TIF zones or because that's the longest debt that we have serviced through TIF revenues? [1:19:23] Chair/Presiding Officer: That's because we're estimating 10 years on that particular bond. So you can see the third column, fourth column from the left is the assumed bond years. You know, these are obviously estimated. That's for Jordan Avenue. We're estimating paying it back in 10 years. It could be longer. I don't love to do roads longer than 10 years because by in 10 years they already need work [1:19:50] Councilor: so it's it's yeah what do you happen to know offhand what is our longest committed tiff zone [1:19:59] Chair/Presiding Officer: at this point oh tiff zones and [1:20:05] Councilor: when i say longest committed like they have expiration dates on them too yeah the cook's corner tiff the last year is 47 48 okay that's the that's [1:20:14] Chair/Presiding Officer: It's the second to last slide here. Okay. [1:20:16] Councilor: Oh, I'm skipping ahead. Sorry. [1:20:20] Chair/Presiding Officer: Yes, we do have to line that up, obviously, right? You can't, you know, project out debt service if the TIF isn't there to pay it. That does remind me to ask a further question about TIFs. Is there anything that's happening that's noteworthy at the state level about just the policy around having TIFs and whether they're still approving TIFs? And if there's any movement in terms of state policy on that subject. So the Department of Economic and Community Development at the state definitely wants municipalities to use this. Economic development tool. In general, if there's any movement, I would say they're trying to loosen up the eligibility of using TIF revenues. Certainly affordable housing, they've been really sort of pushing that as a good use of TIF revenues. We're also trying, they're trying to expand the use of TIF revenues for municipal facilities. It's still pretty tight. It's really mostly for public safety facilities, and the other piece that seems to be expanding a bit is recreational trails. So I think what the state is seeing is that people can't – well, municipalities can't always spend their TIF revenues, and so they are trying to loosen that up a bit. But we're not seeing any pulling back on the use of tax increment financing. So next slide. There we are. Are we done talking about debt for a little bit? Please do stop me and ask questions. So unassigned fund balance, this is really a great source. Our CIP policy says funding from unassigned general fund balance should be consistent with the town's general fund balance policy, which is nice when they refer to each other. So the policy of the town of Brunswick is to have unassigned fund balance. Now, unassigned fund balance is fund balance that isn't promised for something else. It's not something that has been dedicated to be used next year against the budget or to pay for other projects or something else. It is what is seen as our current surplus. And our policy states that we should maintain 16.67% of revenues, that amount to 25% of general fund revenues. It equates to between two to three months of operations is what that is. And the policy states that amounts in excess of the minimum shall be used for capital improvements or other one-time expenditures, and it also states that amounts over the maximum can be used against the budget or for one-time capital improvement, but that's only over the maximum. I guess I should change the slide and put that in there. This is one of those things that changed not very long ago. So what though, this is how we – next slide please – this is how we have used general fund balance in the past few years. So you can see that I have starting unassigned fund balance over and under the top of the target range and then over under the bottom. So in 23, 24, we were below the top of the target by 545,000, but over the bottom of the target by 6,685,000. The next year, things got even better. This year that just ended,, so this year that just ended, this is unaudited. That's the red number. We're right in the middle of the target, pretty much right in the middle. Four million under the top, 4.4 million over the bottom. But then this also shows how those balances were used. In 25-26, we used quite a lot of general fund balance for a lot of CIP projects. That was more than we've used before, over $2 million for CIP projects. This past year, meaning the year we're in, Richards Drive culvert for $450,000, $100,000 to design Noble Street, $465,000 for windows at the high school, and $205,000 for one of the heat pumps at the Harriet Beecher Show School. So that was what general fund balance was used for in the year we're in right now. So next slide. And this is a graph of where our unassigned general fund balance has been, with the green line being the top of the range, the yellow line being the bottom. And you can see we're pretty much right in the middle at this point. This graph appears in the back of the budget book every year. So this is one of those things we do track when we're talking about the budget. Next slide. Excuse me. Could I back you up just to the money you were just on for a moment? Sure. Just noting that the bar chart shows the $21,776,000. That's right in the middle of the range that you talked about earlier. But it says it's for 2026. And on the prior page, it shows for 2627. So just help me out and help everyone else out with when that's measured. Good question. So it is the starting balance for 2627. It's measured on June 30th, which is the same as July 1. So, effectively, so it's measured on June 30th every year, and so when I say 2026 audited, I mean unaudited, it's June 30th of 2026, which is the starting balance for 26-27. So, on the previous page, it's starting balance, and on that page, on the graph, it's ending balance. So the starting balance for the current year we're in, just talking this through to see if I actually understand it, was the $21,776, which is in the middle of the range. And we've committed to spend in our current year budget $1,220,000. So actually, that was approved last year. And so you committed last year, so it's already been removed. The number you have to work with now is the $21,776,000. So that's your starting balance. So when you approve a budget, and you did, this was last May, and you appropriated general fund balance for those three projects or four projects, [Councilor: They were] taken out of unassigned before June 30th. They no longer were unassigned. Now they're assigned. Right. Exactly. Exactly. Right. So the 21,776 is real money. That's what you have to work with in this CIP and budget year that we're working on right now. All right. Right. Any other questions on that? Yes, Councilor Farrell. [1:29:12] Councilor: Just trying to wrap my head around all this. So the $21,700,000, that's in the unassigned fund balance. And you want, like the goal is to have two to three months of that equal to two to three months of operating expenses. Expenses does that mean operating expenses for the entire town budget including the school? Yes. Okay, this [1:29:49] Chair/Presiding Officer: unassigned, I mean the school department has their own restricted fund balance that's theirs, but this unassigned fund balance is for our entire town including the [1:29:58] Councilor: the school department. Okay, it is just trying to like, I'm just, and this is might be ignorance on my part, like that, well I guess the school can't have money, I mean they have some, but not, they're, they're only allowed to put into their bucket money that they can then like pull to use. It's a much smaller amount because they're not allowed to hold this kind of money. [1:30:32] Chair/Presiding Officer: Yes, so the school department has a maximum that they're allowed to hold in their fund balance as defined by the state, right? So they can't hold more than a certain amount, whereas the towns has their own fund balance policy, and our fund balance policy is not out of line with others. There are some, the rating agencies would love it if we were up more like 30%. But that is just whenever I talk to the agencies, I say, no, this is better for Brunswick. I mean, we don't have the sort of, when you're looking at a fund balance policy, you're trying to think about what are the stressors, what are the risks. We don't have, like, one huge taxpayer, for example, that would mean, like, if we did, we might want to, you know, we'd keep an eye on that. Yeah, I think one thing you could say is that, and I'll get to Councilor Ecker, is that even though the fund balances, unassigned fund balances at both the school department and the town are used for similar kinds of projects, mostly capital and larger one-times, the purpose of the fund balances are completely different. And so I'll just leave it at that. And Councilor Ecker, you want to get in here? [1:31:54] Councilor: I was just going to say for the new counselors, I mean, we just went through a revision and clarification of the policy this past year or last year. And to make sure it was clear, it included the schools in the total budget, $100 million. So it includes the subsidies we get, too. So it's a pretty good amount of money. Well, when I looked at it, and I was thinking it was separate, and I was like, well, the math isn't mathing. But then I was like, but if I multiply that by five, then that's $100 million, which is what our budget is. Good mathing. [1:32:37] Chair/Presiding Officer: So I would say you can see that over the past couple of years, we've used the fund balance pretty well. And so we're in the middle. We're still working through the capital improvement program. I think the amount that's in this draft is not going to fly. We know that. I think it's $3 million. That isn't going to work. So that's not what I would recommend, obviously, if the Council wants to spend $3 million. But it would drop us down into a lower area, particularly with where we're going with this budget. Our budgets have been tight the last few years, so we aren't generating more surplus. I'm not seeing revenues flowing in quite the same way. So, yeah, I think we're going to – I wouldn't be recommending using more probably than about a million in general fund balance for the CIP this year. So we're going to have to pick and choose. Councilor Aurelius. [1:33:42] Councilor: As I was noodling through this, the thought that is persistently on my mind is, well, how or why wouldn't this be used for, we have it for purposes of one-time projects, but how or why couldn't it be used to buy down taxes? And as I've worked through that, at least in my head, if you think about operationally, like funding the fire department, we have an extra half a million dollars in there, we decide to use that. Well, next year we might not have that extra half a million, and now you've got an operational burden that you've got to find half a million dollars to fund. Is that the only reason that those types of things are excluded from that, or are there other things that I'm not contemplating? [1:34:19] Chair/Presiding Officer: That is absolutely the main reason. You don't use one-time balance for ongoing expenditures. If you use 500 now, you're going to make up that 500 next year plus whatever. [1:34:33] Councilor: ever. I remember that was a difficulty. Again, when serving on the school board, there was a fairly hefty surplus from the Navy years, and how you tapered that down was important because you were constantly battling. If you use too much, well, then when you get to next year's budget, what are you going to do, right, when you don't necessarily have as much left there? And so I guess it's the same type of thing on a year-to-year basis with this. It would be great to have a half a million or let's say 600,000 to buy down a point, but next year then you're stuck in a hole on that exactly, unless you're willing to cut services and that's that's a completely different conversation, right? Yeah, then just you're exactly right in the hit if you will. [1:35:14] Chair/Presiding Officer: Yeah, that is exactly what the fund balance policy is trying to say. The other piece in the fund balance policy is it specifies that ideally is the fund balances available we use a one percent of a one percent on the tax rate, the amount that would be one percent on the tax rate from fund balance every year, and so that is going up a little bit every year and that's something we've been able to do the last few years, so that just tie it to one percent of a tax rate, and so I think this year it was $626,000, right? It was used from unassigned fund balance to this. Did I actually put that in the slide? Oh, so use an annual budget, $786,000. So there's another number in there. Oh, so there is another number in there. What else did we use it in the budget? I have the budget right here. Now I'm curious. I think that $776,000 is in addition to the $1,220,000. Yes, it is. Yeah, $786,000 was. So we were probably paying for another one-time usage. I can't even remember this. It was just last May. It was $125,000 of something else. Yeah, it was a 1% plus something. It was 1% plus something. She's going to try to figure it out. [1:37:09] Councilor: Weren't we building in the cost for the recode from this? Or did we do that in the previous one? [1:37:21] Chair/Presiding Officer: That might have been it. [1:37:22] Councilor: Because we built in, I think it was around $100,000 for consultants to be able to implement the recode, and it was coming from unassigned fund balance because it was a one-time expense. [Chair/Presiding Officer: That sounds right.] And I'm like 90% sure that it was around $100,000 that it was budgeted. I used to remember all this stuff. The collective brain. Exactly. [1:37:53] Chair/Presiding Officer: There was some logic to it. That's what I know we did, too. Within policy, for sure. Yeah. [1:38:01] Councilor: Yeah, I know that we used unassigned fund balance. I just can't remember if it was last cycle or the cycle before that. They're blurring in my head. But I know that we used unassigned fund balance for it. Yeah, the cycle before, I think we used it for the comp plan. Didn't we pay for a consultant for the comp plan? [1:38:16] Chair/Presiding Officer: And for some of the reval as well. Yeah, that's right. Right, so maybe it was something else. [1:38:22] Councilor: It was probably reval the first time and then comp plan the second time. [1:38:25] Chair/Presiding Officer: Maybe, yeah. And then the recode this year. Yeah, that may be what, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Clear victory on that. Nobody rocked a boat now. We figured out where we went. Back to the manager. Are you ready to move on to tax increment financing? Next slide, please. Yes. So this is a state program. It's governed by state statute. It is meant to be an economic development tool. It is meant to incentivize development and use the funds to offset the results of development. So both, right? So when you have more development, you may have more infrastructure needs. And sometimes when you want development, you need to invest in infrastructure and that type of thing. But it is also meant to lead to other community desired outcomes. The town has a TIF policy and CEA policy that defines what desired outcomes Brunswick has, increased job creation, affordable housing, that kind of thing. So the other piece, of course, is by having a tax increment financing district. You are sheltering some tax valuation, and that provides benefit because it means that our state aid is higher and our county tax is lower. So the taxes generated by new development can be spent on eligible uses. And so the next slide. So these are our five TIF districts. We administer Brunswick Executive Airport and Brunswick Landing TIF together. They are essentially twins. They cover different areas, but they have exactly the same development program. And so these are the elements that are that the TIF revenues can be spent on. You'll note there's a lot of infrastructure in here, road improvements, public safety. The downtown TIF is a transit oriented TIF, meaning we can use those funds on buses and trains. For example, this TIF supports our train station visitor center. Economic development, general economic development is in here as well. Recreational trails is important. That is seen as a benefit that TIF revenues can be used on. So whenever we are looking at the projects in the CIP, I'm always looking to see, can it be funded with TIF revenues? That is one of the things we always look for. And then in the next slide, these are some of the things that we've spent TIF revenues on over the last 16 years. Credit enhancement agreements is always a big one. As you know, our main credit enhancement agreement is with MIRA. And the redevelopment of the former Naval Air Station was a classic use of tax increment financing because there was no taxable value there when the Navy was there, and so we have been able to capture all the value that has been generated in the Executive Airport and the Brunswick Landing and classically the need to redevelop that land. It was a prime use of TIF revenues, which is why the expectation from the very beginning was that Midcoast Regional Redevelopment Authority would benefit from that, because they do not have taxing authority. So the bulk of that has gone to MIRA. The other TIF revenues have gone to the inn just here at the end of Station Avenue. Well, actually, it's on Noble Street. So Station Ave was built with TIF revenues. This was when the downtown development TIF was created, was created because of developing this area that we are in right now, Station Avenue, this entire development. That was all funded with TIF revenues. So that's Station Ave. That's the second one there, $1.5 million. Over the years, we've been able to pave qualified roads. That's quite a chunk of money, $2.3 million. That's public safety vehicles, $2 million. Bus services, $2 million. You heard earlier today from Public Works and Engineering about the Municipal Partnership Initiative grant from Maine DOT. Many of those roads are eligible to be funded with TIF revenues. So we try to, whenever possible, do our match, a 50% match of the MaineDOT grant with TIF revenues. And we've spent $2.6 million on that so far. [1:43:50] Councilor: Would TIFs be relevant or usable for something like a water service or sewer expansion, given even, like, the PFAS issue at the base? Would bringing public water down Coombs Road be an option? [1:44:11] Chair/Presiding Officer: It could be. I think, you know, that one of those things is, you know, that isn't town infrastructure, that water. We did put in the Old Bath Road water line, which now is owned by the water district. We're always a little careful about spending TIF money on non-town assets, so we would have to ask about that. We'd have to figure out what the nexus is, if it would benefit. Well, and one traditional use to fund that was through the credit enhancement agreement with MIRA. In other words, they get their credit enhancement revenues and then spend it on fixing up their own infrastructure. Right, if it's on Brunswick Landing. But if it's Coombs Road, that's an interesting question, right? It's a town road with water district infrastructure under it. And actually, the water main goes down most section of Coombs Road. So is your question, could we connect people to the water district to that? [1:45:25] Councilor: the tip revenues it's just i in general the idea of service expansion both water and sewer throughout the town would be helpful both like sewer side is more the mccoy bay issues but then water is obviously the base side so i was just curious if it was even an option i get it's complicated because they're quasi municipal entities but if you're getting creative in how to fund such a thing i was just curious if it was an option yeah maybe what we do is we always refer [1:46:02] Chair/Presiding Officer: to our council our legal council on this and then very often she will go and talk to decd because all of these things we want to make sure we're following the letter of the law the decd doesn't check up on us every year but our auditors definitely do and whenever there's a question they say where'd you get approval for that so [1:46:32] Councilor: can i ask there's a rule that i was not aware of with this until just recently about five minutes ago on the town of falmouth page they talk about restrictions with tiffs as well in the state of maine that you're limited to no more than five percent of your acreage and we're sitting at about 3.3 so we're within that but it's also five percent of your total valuation and i'm curious if you would happen to know offhand where are we in sort of consuming that [1:47:02] Chair/Presiding Officer: that amount. I don't know that. I know we're not near the threshold, so it's not a worry, [1:47:07] Councilor: but I could figure it out. Yeah, it's not as though I'm suggesting, hey, I got a great new idea for a TIF zone over here, but just curious what our capacity is with that. And also, quite frankly, if this is an economically advantageous shelter, what really got me looking down this line was because it shelters, communities that take advantage of this are getting advantage. Communities that don't are subject to disadvantage when it comes to state subsidy, be it school or what have you. And so where do we sit in our ratio of how much we're protecting in shelter versus the other towns that we're competing with for state funding was kind of the notion I was getting at. And I'm not necessarily suggesting let's make it a goal to get to the 5% caps. But any amount that we're under that, another town could be getting more of a share than we are as a result of us not being in that capacity. [1:48:04] Chair/Presiding Officer: That's true. I haven't looked at that. That's an interesting question. I know South Portland has a lot of TIFs. They have many. I don't know if they have large ones. Like, right, it's the total valuation now. [1:48:19] Councilor: And it was interesting, the other restriction on it. I'm just terrible. I was doing AI over here, too, with it, too. Apparently, 2% acreage is also a restriction within one TIF zone, and so I was surprised by that because I would have thought the Mira TIF zone would have exceeded that, but I guess it doesn't. [1:48:36] Chair/Presiding Officer: So we have a bit of an exception within the Mira TIF zone because it's in a pine tree zone. Okay. And so we were able to don't have to stick to that. [1:48:48] Councilor: It definitely got approved, so I'm not worried about it from that perspective. Yeah. [1:48:54] Chair/Presiding Officer: So I guess this is my last slide, and this is the list of what we spent it on. We can look – do you have any other questions? We can go into a lot more detail about TIFs. I didn't put a lot of slides in here, but. [1:49:14] Councilor: Not really a question, more observation, having been a part of the town budget process since 2001 and what I found back in the early days turn of the century oh my god I thought I'd say that it was always interesting when the school in the town would present their budget and the town struggled to find funding for these kind of projects and what a great tool it's been for the town, for the municipal side, to find these projects. Because I know there was always, you know, initially the school didn't do a great job, but then the goal became, you know, to put more money into infrastructure and facilities management and stuff. And the town, because it had so many competing hands, it definitely struggled. And so what I appreciate is what a great job we've done. I mean, obviously it's not perfect, but we've done such an improvement over the last 25, 26 years to start finding a way to do this without increasing the tax bills. And so I know out in the town of Brunswick, not everybody feels that way, but it's amazing, you know, that we've been able to utilize this tool as something definitely that has helped the municipal side do a lot of great stuff and better take care of our community with that. It's also growing, too, which is a nice thing. It kind of indicates that it's doing what it was designed to do in these districts where, again, it's over, I want to say it's like 5 million now a year is coming in these TIF districts, whereas just a few years back it was under 2. And again, if you're looking at the level of growth that you're seeing on Mira, where you're seeing new development out there with a variety of people, as well as even the one that we were just looking at on Main Street here with the development, which is bringing more property online and offsetting property tax burden for people who are already here. I mean, again, it really demonstrates that if it's executed right, it has huge benefit. It doesn't mean that you have to spend on everything, and again, I'm sure that we would disagree on some of these projects. Well, maybe this shouldn't have been a priority or something else should have been, but at the end of the day, it is allowing you to get to things that you might not otherwise have been able to get to because it's encouraging growth in revenue. [1:52:13] Chair/Presiding Officer: I will say, you know, I'm not looking for new projects. I'm trying to find ways to use these funds for things that we would do anyway, right? I mean, right? I mean, it's easy to say, oh, you can use this for this shiny new thing. But ultimately, what we need to do is replace what we have first. And then so that is one of the great things because, you know, the Brunswick Landing and Brunswick Executive Airport TIFs allow us to use money on roads, major roads here that are not on the Brunswick Landing. And that has been great. I mean, that's what the paving qualified roads is, 2.3 million. Which is, I think, the fourth down in that list. That is using just for regular paving. I mean, and plus the MPI match, $2.6 million. So these are not special new things. These are just using TIF revenues that have sheltered value for things that would otherwise be paid for by taxes, by the budget taxes. I'M CONSCIOUS THAT TIFF REVENUES ARE ALSO TAXES. Yeah, I've been educated. The town manager put serious effort in educating me on this. SO MY COMMENT WOULD BE TO KIND OF TAG WITH WHAT SHE JUST SAID AND THAT IS THAT WHETHER IT'S GENERAL FUND CURRENT YEAR REVENUES OR UNAPPROPRIATE OR UNASSIGNED FUND BALANCE OR TIFF for revenues the primary not the only this is part of my education the primary source is the is the property tax payer so the use of those funds even though there are different sources or different buckets the source is essentially the same source and should be looked at that way when you think about how you're going to spend it i mean a six hundred and something thousand expenditure is one percent on the tax rate at some point in time somewhere the other thing is that i think this is true when you look at the you asked councilor ellis asked about when what's our longest running tiff district here 19 1948 2048 when they end we still have all the tax revenues that were being generated in those TIF districts what we lose is the state shift in additional benefit when the TIF district expires but and that has to be taken into account, but it's not, we are literally losing any of our own revenues, we're losing some subsidy from other towns and communities in Maine. [1:55:02] Councilor: Is that on that particular front, is the state committed? I mean, so in as much as, because I know we have these districts until 2048 or 47, sometime way into the future that only my children will see. [1:55:17] Chair/Presiding Officer: So Downtown Development TIF is in 40, Seahawk and the ones on Brunswick Landing are 43, and then Cook's Corner is 48. [1:55:27] Councilor: But the shelter portion of that, benefits on municipal rev share predominantly and state subsidy for education on those two things, could that potentially ever be a policy change, that they decide that it doesn't do that anymore? Like, how hooked into this is the state in regards to that being the policy of the state? Like, could a new administration change that? [1:55:50] Chair/Presiding Officer: So it would involve changing the calculation of the ED-279, for example. You know how the ED-279 uses the state valuation? And that state valuation number doesn't include the TEF valuation. And so that means it's lower than it would be if the TIF valuation was in it. So the way it could change would be if they changed the ED-279, the way that's calculated, to not include it. Or to just, yeah, to sort of change the, I know you've looked at the ED-279 and how they calculate state aid to education. And it has a number of different things, different factors. And the state valuation, the property valuation is just one of the factors. So if they change the ratio of how those factors are considered or something like that, could change it. The same with revenue sharing. That considers population and valuation. And relative to all the other towns in Maine, if they change the formula, that would change it. [1:56:55] Councilor: And changing that, the only reason I ask the question is I think it's a technical risk, but I would think it would be politically hugely unpopular to make that change. And I would bet that they would face pretty large lobbying from major cities like South Portland and a variety of other places if anyone were to ever choose that. But it is technically, it's because of statute that could be changed if somebody were so unwise as to do that. [1:57:18] Chair/Presiding Officer: But it is one of the major reasons that tax increment financing is promoted for that benefit. I mean, we estimate that we're, for this year we're in, the benefit is $4 million for Brunswick in 26-27. [1:57:31] Councilor: And I guess I'd point out, too, it's developed out of the Department of Economic Development, and so the purpose of it from the state's perspective is to encourage growth is what it is and to encourage development. And so, and we are seeing that, so it's. It's working. Yeah, it's working. [1:57:50] Chair/Presiding Officer: Everyone tired out? Anybody else? No one seems happy. Okay. We're still in the middle of our policy on unassigned fund balance, so we can go home. [1:58:09] Councilor: Chair Weems, you need to turn your microphone on. Excuse me. [1:58:15] Chair/Presiding Officer: I won't repeat that, but I will take a motion to adjourn, made by Councilor McDonald, seconded by Councilor Ecker. All those in favor? Thank you, everybody. Oh, wait,, wait,. Hold it. I was going to ask if there's any other public comment to maintain our integrity to the modified agenda. I don't see any, so I will close that period and accept the motion to adjourn. Good night, everybody. Good night.