Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:07] Mayor: Hello, everybody, and welcome to the Finance Committee meeting of Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026, hopefully an auspicious day in our democracy. It is a voting day, so it is auspicious in its own right. with me today at the dais from my right deputy finance director diane lathrop town manager julia henzie finance director darian plant myself i'm steve weems district seven town counselor and chair of the finance committee richard ellis district one town counselor and Jamie Ecker, District 2 town councillor. And welcome anyone who might be with us right at the moment or viewing this meeting later. Was this meeting properly acknowledged or properly noticed? Yes, it was. And are there any adjustments to the agenda? Seeing none, I'll give my disclaimer right now, And that is that I just blew into town from an emergency business Situation and I'm entirely unprepared for this meeting. So I'm expecting all the other participants to carry me through the day And with that Any public comments in the room we have had a request or at least a Communication that says that in general It may be a better practice to have public comments at the end of our agendas, particularly when they're dealing with just in general. And that's a change we may make. I think it makes a lot of sense. But for today, we're going to do the public comment right now. I see no one in the room.
[2:24] Public commenter: That might not work for marathon council meetings, putting them at the end.
Public Comment
[2:32] Mayor: Yeah. So I'm going to close the public comment period and move to a review of the minutes of the last two meetings and open up the floor for any changes to the minutes that you see are necessary or desirable for the minutes for September 29th. Excuse me, September 28th. I'll be happy to entertain a motion.
[3:01] Councilor Ecker: motion to approve the minutes of September 28th motion made by
[3:06] Mayor: Council record seconded by Councilor Weems too late there. All those in favor. Thank you. Moving to the minutes of October 7th. Same drill. Anybody see anything of necessary for a change?
[3:28] Councilor Ecker: Councilor, I would just only say they're very
[3:31] Speaker D (unidentified): comprehensive this might be my best one yet yeah they
[3:38] Mayor: are excellent seeing no request for change do I have a motion to approve the minutes of October 7 motion
[3:48] Councilor Ecker: to approve the minutes of October 7th Thank You councillor Ecker and seconded
[3:53] Mayor: by councillor Ellis any discussion all those in favor minister approved and with gratitude to the finance director for doing such great minutes. All right. I'm going to now turn it over to the town manager because I don't see our guest for the first part of the agenda item here. Or maybe on Zoom. Oh, there he is. So, Manager Henze, would you please take the gavel and lead us through the meeting at this point?
[4:26] Town Manager: Sure. I'd be happy to. So, this is the funky microphone. phone. I'm going to be a little careful. So we are lucky to have Tim Gill from Runyon Kirsten Willett here. We finished up our, they finished up their field work two weeks ago. And he's going to talk to you about it. And I know he always welcomes questions and comments. So this is Tim Kim Gill, he's a partner at Runyon Kirsten Willett, and
[5:00] External Auditor (Tim Gill): he's on Zoom. Hello, and thank you for having me. Sorry I couldn't be there in person, but I have a lot of responsibilities this time of year. It's a very busy audit season. Julia has asked me to kind of run through the audit process for 2026. So what I'm going to do tonight is kind of briefly go over the background of what an audit is and what we do. and just kind of go over quickly some of the things that we've found so far. So the audit process is not complete. We were there, as Julia said, two weeks ago. We still have to kind of go through and finish reviewing the big ACPR. That's quite a daunting task, but the majority of the test work and everything else and looking at the details and the invoices, that piece is all mostly done. but first off you know what is an audit designed to do an audit is designed for us as auditors to give an opinion on the financial statements as to whether or not they are fairly presented in accordance with all accounting standards and principles the way we give you that opinion is not by reviewing every single transaction we don't go through 100 transactions we do a sample based approach and the way we pick our sample is a risk based assessment process and the way that we assess our risk is through discussion with management through some historical knowledge also through review of policies and procedures and then testing those policies and procedures to kind of get a sense as to whether or not they're operating effectively one of the byproducts of that risk assessment process is that we're able to offer some insight recommendations to the town and say okay you know you could improve this you can prove that or any items that might just improve operating efficiency or minimize risk even further anytime that we have comments were required to put them into three categories the most severe being a material weakness these are items that you really want to pay attention to and you want to have a correction plan as soon as possible the next level down is a significant deficiency so not quite as severe but something you still should take note of and develop a correction plan with the timeline being a little more generous and then lastly there's just kind of all other comments just general recommendations really right now where we stand in the audit process we are not projecting any material weaknesses or significant deficiencies so that's not a guarantee. Again, our audit procedures aren't complete, but it's unlikely that something will pop up at this point that would jump to those levels. We do have one recommendation regarding the cash receipt process of the town office. The procedure calls for a secondary review of cash receipts, like a secondary cash count. We found that those cash counts weren't necessarily being documented. So even though we believe they were being completed as auditors, unless we have documentation, we can't prove that. So the recommendation there is really just to kind of make sure you document your procedures and leave an audit trail to prove that you're doing your checks and balances.
[8:32] Mayor: Excuse me, Tim. What was that? Did you note what the what was covered by that finding? Was it cash receipts did i understand you say that receipts at the town office thank you really
[8:48] External Auditor (Tim Gill): at any location we'd like to see you know segregation of duties checks and double checks and making sure that those procedures are documented to prove that they occur
[8:59] Town Manager: and we can go into the specifics about that and what the process is and i mean it is just a case of it's happening it just wasn't initialed by two people right but now we well i'm not going to
[9:12] Mayor: jump in here jump in whenever you feel like it please all right go ahead tim sorry for the
[9:21] External Auditor (Tim Gill): interruption sure i will note that there were some comments last year if you were in on this meeting or a presentation or by the reports we had some comments related to journal entry reviews at the school we tested those again this year and found out that was corrected did and our recommendations were implemented. Also, as part of the audit process, we do test your federal expenditures of the grants that you receive. So, we call a single audit. And there's a very similar risk assessment process where we do not test 100% of all your federal grants. We figure out which ones are considered material and significant or what are considered major programs and we test those major programs for compliance with various allowability reporting and other requirements specific to those grants. So last year we tested the ARPA grant and local entitlement and we had some findings and comments. This year the ARPA funds are pretty much all gone so those aren't really a continuing item that we have to follow up on the local internal program itself didn't meet the threshold this year to be considered a major program so we didn't follow up necessarily on those issues it was related to obtaining proper suspension and debarment procedures and documenting those as well through discussion with the management over there at the school we believe those procedures have implemented and our recommendations have been taken seriously. As far as for this year in 2026, we only tested one federal grant, which was the congressionally mandated project for, geez, what's that project?
[11:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Old Bath Water Extension. Yes, that is correct. I was trying
[11:25] External Auditor (Tim Gill): to figure it out in my head, but you guys have a better memory than me. So that was quite a big project for the year. There really wasn't a ton of transactions related to that. It was really just a small handful, but they were big dollar amounts. So we went through and we tested that program. And as of right now, we don't have any findings or issues to report related to that. So that is kind of a summary of the audit process and some of the findings and recommendations that we have that were generated as our risk assessment procedures. Again, the final step here to complete the audit is to go through the act for the financial report prepared by management and verify all the numbers in there match up with what we've tested and verified in our test work and making sure everything's presented properly in accordance with all the relevant standards. That's quite a lengthy document. I have to continue going through that and reading through that but that's the last step in the process before we issue our reports and then you will get those financial statements as well as any necessary reports on the uniform guidance the single audit or our recommendations those will all be in some smaller written reports any questions on the audit process good
[12:54] Councilor Ecker: council record my job which screen do we look at i guess I do. So thank you for that overview. I just want to make sure I'm clear. So there were no material weaknesses and no significant deficiencies thus far?
[13:15] External Auditor (Tim Gill): That is correct, thus so far, yeah.
[13:17] Councilor Ecker: And the one item about the cash receipts that just falls in the other category?
[13:23] External Auditor (Tim Gill): Yes, that's kind of the cash, all kind of other comments, pretty much just a general recommendation. I like to call it the slap on the wrist comment.
[13:35] Councilor Ecker: That's quite amazing in some regards, I imagine. So I guess credit goes to our staff for being so thorough.
[13:50] External Auditor (Tim Gill): Yes. I mean, historically, we've had very few comments here at the town of Brunswick. And any time that we do have comments, we generally always see them corrected. and they are not considered repeat comments the following year.
[14:06] Mayor: Yeah, that's great. Counselor Ellis.
[14:10] Public commenter: Question. You mentioned in the process, and it makes perfect sense, that you would look at the biggest areas of risk or exposure within your audits. Is there anything that looks through a sampling of other procedures on a periodic basis so that you don't wind up with a collection of squirrels that could eat you up, if you will? You know, I mean, like I know there are littler processes, but do the smaller processes ever get reviewed in these audits?
[14:38] External Auditor (Tim Gill): Yes. So without boring you of some of the details, you'd be surprised. Those other areas are not completely ignored. We do still select samples from those areas. It's just that samples from those areas are smaller. Okay. And there is a rotational process where we both go through some of those smaller areas and test them every third year just to make sure that our understanding and those areas are in compliance with what we know as far as the staff's procedures. So they aren't completely ignored. Excellent. Thank you. Tim,
[15:17] Mayor: Steve Williams here. Did you say or could you opine on or at least forecast when the final reports might arrive on the manager's desk, your final audit? it sure
[15:35] External Auditor (Tim Gill): so julia's already prepared the acber and prevents presented us with a draft as i said i've got to go through that and kind of verify that all those numbers match up to the documentation and the test work that we've done and then also review it for the appropriate accounting standards and format and all that stuff once i do that i usually kick comments back to Julia or Darien and they'll correct those give them back give us back corrected reports I verify the corrections and then I kick it off to our technical reviewer who goes through it one more time and that's usually a partner here in the firm that has no association with the audit and they'll go through the reports one more time usually they find one or two things that we've missed usually at that point nothing significant or major and then And once we get those all cleaned up, we can issue final reports. So that process, and as it plays out, probably going to issue reports near the end of November or at the beginning of early December.
[16:42] Mayor: That'd be great if we had that time frame. A little fuzzy on last year, but it was a little bit under the wire, as I remember.
[16:50] Town Manager: Yes, we really need it done by the end of December. I'd love to have it done by Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving. Tim, you also mentioned you're still waiting on the 2026 Compliance Supplement.
[17:01] External Auditor (Tim Gill): What is that? So every year, the Office of Management and Budget, a federal office, issues a Compliance Supplement. And this is specific to that single audit I spoke of regarding the federal grants that we test. Basically, they give us a little cheat sheet slash roadmap map to auditing specific grants. It's quite a lengthy document. It doesn't encompass all federal grants, but it encompasses some of the larger programs that a lot of the towns do have money flowing down to them from. And so that uniform guidance compliance supplement guides how we test and audit programs under the federal standard. Usually the requirements don't change too much from year to year, but every now and then I'd like to throw a little mix-up in there. Due to some of the staffing and budget cuts at the federal agencies, some of that review of that compliance supplement for 2026 has been delayed. Usually we have it by May, so we're going on quite a while without it now. And technically, we cannot issue our single audit report until we get that compliance supplement. So this might be a unique scenario this year where we have to issue the financial statements and our government auditing standards reports separately from the Uniform Guidance Report, which typically we do not like to do, but we can do it in certain instances.
[18:43] Mayor: I'm sure there's no way to predict or forecast when you'll see that document.
[18:48] External Auditor (Tim Gill): No, we get updates from the AICPA and other entities kind of trying to predict what the office will do and when they'll finish their final review. Those predictions last said August and August has come and gone and then they said October. So right now those predictions are not too reliable.
[19:12] Mayor: understood so at least you have a process for dealing with that if it delays things unnecessarily or beyond the point of just the split arrangement you just talked about makes a lot of sense to me at least and i'm sure others any comment on that manager henzie no of course we'd love to
[19:36] Town Manager: to have the ACFER finished as soon as possible. We also will be working on the PAFR, which is the Popular Annual Financial Report, and we're also getting going on the continuing disclosure for our bonds. So that is, I don't know if you remember it from last year, but it includes this document but is more as well. So we're starting on that to try to get that done. I'd like to have it finished. The other piece that we pretty much wait until the auditors are done before we roll the year in our financial software which means everybody's waiting for us to roll that year and I like to get it done I mean it'd be nice to get it done soon I probably could do it now but just in case they find something that we want to change we'd like to wait but yeah so the only other thing I would ask Tim that every year the GASB comes out with new pronouncements would tim would you talk about the i guess it's gatsby 103 a little bit yeah
[20:45] External Auditor (Tim Gill): yeah the standard setters at the gatsby the governmental accounting standards board they very rarely take a year off so usually every year there's a new change in accounting standards So last year it was a change in the standard with GASB 101 as it related to how you estimate and value your approved vacation and sick time. This year it's a change in reporting mostly. Specifically, they've kind of fine-tuned and changed some of the ways that the reports look. The management discussion and analysis section has gotten a little bit more specific. Some of the budget to actual information that's in the MD&A, the management discussion analysis section, that's being moved to what's called required supplementary information. So it'll be kind of further back in the report, as will the budget to actual financial statement itself. That'll be moved to the back of the report, even though that's probably the one that most of us care about. They deem that supplementary information and kind of gets pushed to the back. So really not huge changes in terms of how any one asset liability or revenue gets valued. It's more of a presentation. And the management discussion and analysis section will focus more on kind of like an analysis in a greater way than it has in years past.
[22:25] Town Manager: So I'm looking forward to his review of our MDNA because I'm not sure. I mean, we tried, but trying to follow the standard. But I'm interested, Tim, when you read it, if I've done it, we've done enough. We'll see.
[22:42] External Auditor (Tim Gill): So, yeah, in the first year, there's always, you know, some risk that something gets missed. risk. With GASB 101, it was last year, it was quite, I would say it was a more significant risk because the way that the liability was being valued was being drastically changed. And this year, the risk, I would say, is much less because it's not really changing any of the numbers. It's just changing the format and presentation. And, you know, this is new to us as well you know we have sample templates that are provided and some guidance that's provided as well so we just gonna check what julia has done against those templates and ours our understanding of the standard but i will also be interested myself to see once we go through that process and submit the act for if they come back with any comments there i hope not me
[23:44] Mayor: too I think it's unanimous without doing a poll. Procedure question, are we going to at some point here release Tim and then go over the annual comprehensive financial report?
[24:07] Town Manager: Yes, that was my thought. He doesn't need to sit here and watch while I sort of give you a tour and talk about what the actual numbers are.
[24:15] Mayor: He will have his chance to review, I know.
[24:18] Town Manager: I always appreciate our auditors because they're the ones who really look at it and appreciate and value our work.
[24:26] Mayor: So do I understand the changes that you mentioned, I got the acronyms wrong here, but in the governmental accounting standards guidance, I guess, that it was moving this kind of discussion up more to the front as the most important thing and the actual financials sort of moving towards the back? as corroboration in some way of the management analysis? Is that kind of the philosophy here, Tim?
[24:53] External Auditor (Tim Gill): So the management discussion and analysis is typically at the front of the reports. It provides a narrative view and highlights of the year kind of in a more understandable format. format. The deeper and further back you go in the audit reports or the financial statements, rather, the more detail you're going to get, which can get overwhelming and confusing to some that aren't used to that information. So previously in the management discussion analysis, which is at the front, there was a budget to actual discussion. Additionally,, in the front of the financials, there was a set of basic financial statements with a budget to actual statement there with the table and showing you your variance for the year. All that information is being moved, not to the very end, but more towards the back after the notes to the financial statements. I guess they just wanted to put more emphasis on certain items within the financials themselves and making the management discussion and analysis more focused on the analysis side of things and then the budget to actual stuff is I guess in their minds deemed less important so it gets It's moved more towards the rear. I don't really necessarily agree with all the changes because a lot of people use the budget to actual more than any other statement in the financials. But I am not a standard setter, so I just follow what the standards are.
[26:41] Mayor: Fair enough, as we hope you will. Any other further comments or questions for Tim? Go ahead, Councilor Ecker.
[26:51] Councilor Ecker: Just while we have him, I'm just always curious, just kind of benchmarking ourselves against other communities. And you probably do a lot in Maine and could give us some perspective. Are there are there as you do these audits, are there common areas where communities have challenges?
[27:14] External Auditor (Tim Gill): Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. One of the first thing that pops into mind is specifically kind of within the school department and the school activity funds, which are generally managed kind of at the school level, usually by principals and the secretaries there. those activity funds, although compared to the, town as a whole, generally are not that large, but they are usually decentralized areas with less oversight, which is where we tend to find a lot of, items or issues, you know, missing documentation, missing signatures, things of that nature. and we have tested those as part of the audit process this year and didn't have any of those findings so that is very good so that's one of the most common things that we find another common item we find is segregation of duties kind of as a whole really one of the most common comments that we put into our reports because as people get more sensitive to you know rising budgets in towns and school districts. A lot of times the pressure is put on the administrative offices to kind of shrink those functions and limit the personnel in those departments, which inherently creates a segregation of duties issue where sometimes you have one person doing a lot of things that ideally you would have separated out so that you can minimize life risk and you would have those second set of eyes on transactions and you'd have checks and balances in place. So that's another very common issue that we see. But here there's proper procedure in place and adequate segregation of duties in most areas in the town here. So we don't find that in Brunswick.
[29:11] Councilor Ecker: All right. So those are the two general areas that stand out that are They're common, I guess.
[29:22] Mayor: That's why we have our financial staff working 16-hour days. I'm just kidding.
[29:32] Public commenter: At least I hope I'm kidding. Just from having experience on the finance side on the school department, their staff, it's a financial difficulty for them as well. I will say those activity funds I know have gone through multiple iterations of At one point in time, they tried to encourage parents to set up their own independent nonprofits, and it's a distinctive challenge. I think that creates risk as well because turnover of parents, like, for example, for a high school, let's say, football boosters organization, guess what? It's every four years, and you're out. And so continuity within those organizations, it's hard to get continued support to have a treasurer for a nonprofit and what have you. My understanding is that may have come back in some of those activity funds in recent years that they tried to push out, but now some of them have come back in. Is that an accurate statement?
[30:28] Town Manager: I know they did really try to push all of those booster type out, and they really are just keeping the sort of club, you know, that are controlled with a faculty advisor who is then, you know, So they're trying to distinguish between the funds that are controlled by families and the funds that are controlled by town staff, school staff. And so there's a secretary who is required to – who can only write the checks. And, you know, so they're really – and for the last few years, we haven't had the problems that were arising when where's the receipt, you know, that kind of thing.
[31:07] Public commenter: And even before the problems, I think there were headaches. and so i think that it's always been a distinctive challenge and like i said i don't know i think if anything what the approach to outsourcing it or putting it off is at least doesn't co-mingle it with monies that the town is responsible for whether or not it solves the underlying accounting problem of and i'm not pointing fingers anywhere but if a specific fund that's raised by parents is being properly handled or not i don't know as to where it solves that problem.
[31:38] Town Manager: No, but it isn't our problem.
[31:40] Public commenter: Yeah, exactly. That's what I would say. So I would say that in that regards and the fact that we're responsible for our own personal audits, it probably does make sense to keep those things as much as possible off books.
[31:52] Town Manager: It's also interesting that the business office and the school department doesn't really even track that anymore. It goes right from the schools, the junior high and the high school, right to Darian. so they just the business office wanted nothing to do with it and it was difficult for
[32:09] Public commenter: them too because i will say that having had the experience of having not myself but a spouse who was a leader within one of those organizations there was also the complaint from the back side that we go out and spend stuff and then our reimbursement for that is like forever right and so not every parent in town can afford to front some of the things that they do and so that was a difficulty as well, but anyways.
[32:36] Councilor Ecker: I have one other question.
[32:38] Mayor: Excuse me, anything else for Tim? One other question.
[32:42] Councilor Ecker: In the case of Brunswick, our staff is producing the ACFER, right? And then the outside auditor is reviewing that. And how is that done in other towns or municipalities in Maine? Is it normally done that way, or is it a blend with the use of outside firms, or how is it accomplished?
[33:10] External Auditor (Tim Gill): Yeah, so in Brunswick, as long as I've been associated with the audit here, the town has always prepared their own set of financial statements. They've always gone through the above and beyond to get the award for the ACRA. other towns and school districts don't necessarily take their financial reporting that far it's not worth their time I guess I would say the majority of the towns and schools we go to do have us as auditors prepare the financial statements for them, maintaining somebody on staff who has the knowledge and skill able to prepare a complete set of financial statements is really difficult, and especially with all the changes in GASB standards and other standards, maintaining that expertise is difficult, especially with all the other responsibilities. So usually, we as auditors prepare the financial statements for, I would say, the majority of our towns and schools as an added service.
[34:22] Councilor Ecker: Okay. And last question, maybe for the manager. How many years in a row have we won this award? Since 1999.
[34:31] Town Manager: Wow. I know that because we write it in the report. And a few years ago, I stopped counting. I just put the first year because that was easier, and then I don't have to change it.
[34:45] Mayor: All right. Outstanding. Well, it's quite an achievement. It really is. Anything else for Tim?
[34:55] Town Manager: I'll just say thank you to Tim. it is always a real he's really great to work with I learn a lot he's a great resource for us as well because he has to know all these Gatsby standards and so we use that whenever we can I thank you Tim thank you and I'll send
[35:17] External Auditor (Tim Gill): that right back to you and the rest of the staff there in the finance office it 's a lot to get all the information we need for the audit process and to prepare those financial statements. And so the town does it very well and we appreciate them being ready every year for us.
[35:38] Mayor: That's a heck of a good note to end on. And so thank you very much for the time that you spent with us today, Tim. I won't make any other gratuitous comments us, except we wish you hope that the further guidance from OMB, if that's where it comes from, comes in on time, and we can get unified statements together on a reasonable time frame, but understand you don't control that. Thanks for joining us. All right. Have a good night. You too. Well, that was both encouraging and illuminating. So I'm going to turn it back to you, Manager Henzey, and the gavel, both literally and figuratively, and lead us through the review, you and Darian, through the annual comprehensive financial report at the level you want us to deal with it today.
[36:44] Town Manager: Well, that's partly up to you. I would like to sort of describe where things are in the, and maybe we can dig into particular questions or not. As Tim mentioned, there's the section that is called Required Supplementary Information is bigger than it was last year. It has the budget to actual. So this starts on page 82 of the document, And it is, as Tim says, the budget to actual, which is what most of us in towns really look at, has become smaller, which I think is sad. But it is in here. It's not at a level of detail that it used to be, but it's at least in general is here. And then the notes to the RSI is where there's a discussion about what revenues were over, what expenditures were under, and how the fund balance landed and all of that. So that's in the notes to RSI. And a lot of that used to be in the manager's discussion analysis, which is the beginning of the report. So maybe I'll just walk through. So the whole thing starts with a letter of transmittal, which starts on page one and is really just meant to be kind of an overview of the town and the general sort of, it has a section about major initiatives over the past year and relevant financial policies. So this is kind of a look at Brunswick in general, our economy, our financial condition, and then major initiatives. So this year I talked about Central Fire Station, the Mark, the downtown streetscape, none of these surprising to you, Jordan Avenue, Public Works Facility, Hawthorne School, two Columbus acquisitions, Stephen Drive Extension, and the Brunswick Executive Airport, AFFF discharge. I felt that I needed to mention that a second year because it still looms large. So, these are, you know, this was just, it's brief, it isn't meant to be exhaustive, but it is sort of, if somebody just picks this up and wants to find out what Brunswick's been doing for the past year, these are some of the big ones. And anyone could say, maybe I should have put some different ones in, but this is what I put in there. Following the letter of transmittal is our certificate that we received for the last year. And then there's, yeah, the certificate starts, it's page seven, yeah, I mean, it doesn't have a page number on it, but it is what they send us. Jamie, do you not have your mic on? He's waving at me. Jim's waving. Okay, good. So I will just say that this format, this sequence, is what is required to receive this certificate. So we have to have a letter of transmittal, we have to have the little organizational chart, the elected appointed officials, and then comes the financial section. section. So this is very much in a format that is required. So we are judged on whether we're following the format as well as the contents. So getting into the financial section, I think the first thing is the auditor's report, which you see a bunch of blank pages there if you're in the PDF, because we don't have it yet. And then comes the management's discussion and analysis. And this, as Tim described, is meant to be the narrative of the financial, what happened financially. It is much less, it has things about what projects happened and what capital assets were added, but all from the lens of the financial impact. impact. It starts with the government-wide financial analysis and then goes more into detail in the funds, and I'll talk about that a little bit more as we get further along. It distinguishes between governmental activities and business-type activities. So business-type activities are enterprise funds, so the train station, the processing facility, and Maripoint wastewater those and then the gets into the funds and then it has sort of summaries of capital assets and debt and then it does have whole section about economic factors and next year's budgets and rate so it's a an opportunity to talk about what the financial pressures on the town are what the response has been, what decisions have been made in response to financial questions. Obviously, we're affected by the state, so there's some discussion about state aid, state aid to education, state revenue sharing, all of the different state programs. Stop me any time. Yes? [Mayor: I wouldn't dare.] I'm on a roll, huh? You are.
[43:10] Mayor: Just keep us informed on the page numbers as you go through and make your comments.
[43:15] Town Manager: Oh, okay, yep.
[43:17] Public commenter: Just as I'm parsing through this as you're walking through the sections, what specifically is a resource that is unspendable? So we're talking about fund balances that there's $4.8 million that's classified as non-spendable. Yes, okay. We just have a piggy bank with a lot of pennies in it. [Mayor: Page number, Rich?] That would be on page 23. and roughly second to last paragraph.
[43:45] Town Manager: It's on statement three, right? Or are you in the paragraph?
[43:48] Public commenter: I'm in the narrative, but as I was reading through the narratives here and it was describing the governmental funds, so it's the second to last paragraph on page 23.
[43:57] Town Manager: Yes. It talks about... So non-spendable is... So we're talking about funds in this case, so like the general fund, the capital project funds, special revenue funds. Non-spendable means it's either an inventory where you can't spend it, 's stuff that you can't spend, or it's long-term advances, right? So when the general fund advances money to a capital project fund, the general fund shows an asset, right, because they are owed the money, but it's not spendable. It is money that is like a receivable. It's like a long-term loan or something like that, which is considered non-spendable. So it's going to be inventory or advances. The other piece is the corpus of an endowment. We book that as non-spendable as well. Okay.
[45:03] Public commenter: Does it fluctuate much year to year, or is it pretty stable in what are non-spendable?
[45:09] Town Manager: So it can fluctuate. It really mostly depends on how many advances we have out to other funds, right? It did fluctuate pretty significantly this year because the downtown streetscape, which was originally approved to be issued through debt,, our former treasurer determined that it made more sense to advance it from the general fund rather than borrow money. So there's a big advance that is mostly that. And that will be paid back over, we're hoping, within seven years or so from TIF revenues. Originally we were going to issue debt for the Downtown Streetscape and then pay the debt service with tiff revenues in this case we are advancing the funds from the general fund and then paying it back with tiff revenues so that it did make a major jump this year the other advance is to the mayor point wastewater program so as you know we have this small little sewer system out at the end of mayor point and a number of years ago there was a big cap it was capital project and the fund didn't have the money so there is an advance that's only about
[46:28] Public commenter: 30 000 now so there's not a whole lot of endowment corpus in there has to stabilize this
[46:38] Town Manager: as a no there no and in any case yeah it's yeah it 's not a lot where's the non-spendable So on page 75, and this is in the notes, this is, you can see the non-spendable column. So $3.7 million is advances to other funds. $54,000 is inventories and deposits. There's $50,000 that's a deposit. That's a long story, but we can talk about it. And then in permanent funds, that's the endowment. Okay. Continue. Continue? Okay. So getting into the basic financial statements, which start on page 32.
[47:44] Public commenter: I'm just having a chuckle. The answer to my question was actually in the book, sort of. Non-spendable fund balance cannot be spent. It seems sort of circular. It does seem circular.
[47:57] Mayor: Isn't that what's known as a circular statement?
[48:06] Town Manager: So we look at the financials in two different ways. You know, on day-to-day, we're used to fund accounting in governmental, right, where you're not really thinking about your long-term debt or your capital assets or anything like that. You don't think about depreciation. Governments really are working like we're working from a right-now checkbook, right? So that's most of the book is that, but these two, the first two statements, one and two on pages 32 and 33, are meant to represent government-wide statement of net position. So it's separate again into governmental activities and business-type activities. But if you look at that balance sheet on page 32, you see capital assets in there. so we are required to value all our roads all our buildings all our vehicles everything that is over five thousand dollars and we meant we need to depreciate it and you know so there's an exercise that we go through it's the least favorite part of the entire audit and brandon never would want it to take it over and darian still doesn't want it i don't really want it either but i've been doing it for 20 years diane right welcome aboard it's it's it's one of those things you know you have to go through all the all everything that was purchased in the whole year and then figure out what to capitalize and when you're talking about road work you know it's a it's a real question like was this a full reconstruction did they replace storm drainage because we have to count you know catch basins and pipes and things too so it's anyway well speaking of roads where are they on this statement in infrastructure and you're going to say that number is ridiculously low but so what happened was when i think it was in 1990, I forget exactly when it was, but when we first started having to do this, and it was in the 90s, I think, or late 90s, or very early 2000s, the town hired somebody to come and do a survey of all the roads, estimate when they were built, and put a value on them. And we are still using that as the base. and so the way the way this works you its acquisition cost so it 's not a really meaningful numbers which is part of what makes it so aggravating to do because you don't feel like you're actually coming up with a good number right it one thing if I really felt like these numbers were telling me anything but if I look and I say there's only 28 million dollars in roads and bridges and streetlights, and curb, and sidewalks, and drainage, storm drainage. It's ridiculous. Yeah, I know, and that's net of depreciation. Now, some of our buildings, you know, were purchased. We don't have as many of the really old buildings, but, I mean, our public works has been fully depreciated for, like, I don't know. 60 years. Right,.
[51:40] Mayor: yeah i was going to say it isn't at a depreciation or maybe it's too high
[51:48] Town Manager: well i don't know right but you can't sell a road either so like how would you how do you value that i mean you value it based on what it costs to build it when you build it so when i when we for example when i capitalized matcha the downtown streetscape this year and i based it on what we paid for it, right? And just broke it up by block. I mean, I wasn't super like how many actual square feet. It was linear feet by block and called it good. And the auditors said that was good enough. And the big numbers in there, doesn't matter exactly how it's lined up. I also was careful to retire the old sidewalk that was in the list.
[52:35] Mayor: So the nub of it is you can't have a complete financial statement without a statement of net financial position, so you have to have one. Exactly, yeah.
[52:49] Public commenter: So is this listing of assets, is this a part of, and I'm probably not going to get the name right, but MEMIS, or do you keep this in a giant spreadsheet somewhere?
[52:57] Town Manager: So some of it is in MUNIS. MUNIS, there we go. But the infrastructure is in a giant spreadsheet. Okay. That's how we got it. And it doesn't make sense to add all of those assets. There's a crazy number of assets. It's easier just to keep it in a spreadsheet and depreciate every year.
[53:19] Mayor: So turn to page 33, more interesting than page 32.
[53:25] Town Manager: Oh, yes, you're an income statement guy. Yes, exactly right. So this is an interesting presentation of an income statement. And the goal is to see what each of the functions, net of associated revenues, costs the town. It's an interesting thing here. Keeping in mind that anything that is spent on capital assets gets removed from this, right, because it gets capitalized. So you're not seeing the cost of, when you look at those expenditure expenses, they call them expenses when they're talking about in these statements, expenditures in the funds. So when you're looking at the expenses here, you're not seeing anything that was spent on capital. So our total governmental activities is $117 million. IF YOU REMEMBER, OUR BUDGET, WHICH IS JUST PART OF IT, IS 101 THIS YEAR, OR THIS YEAR WE WERE IN. I THINK WHEN WE LOOK AT THE STATEMENTS THREE AND FOUR, IT'S GOING TO MAKE A LOT MORE SENSE. IT'S MUCH MORE LIKE WHAT WE LOOK AT MORE TYPICALLY. YOU ALSO SEE THERE'S ONLY INTEREST ON LONG-TERM DEBT HERE, BECAUSE THE ACTUAL PAYMENT OF prints on principle goes against the liability that sits on the balance sheet.
[55:15] Mayor: So looking at that 123 million at the footing, total primary government, is that not a reasonable figure to describe the total scope of our activities as an enterprise? Not an enterprise fund, but as an?
[55:37] Town Manager: As an organization. As an organization. So take a look at page 35. So this is a more normal-looking income statement, and this is for the governmental funds. So it doesn't include what was spent in the enterprise funds, but it includes everything that was spent on capital as well. IT ALSO INCLUDES THE TOTAL AMOUNT WE SPENT ON DEBT SERVICE. SO EXPENDITURES ARE 121 MILLION. AND THEN THERE'S OTHER FINANCING USES AND SOURCES, WHICH INCLUDES TRANSFERS. SO IT'S DIFFERENT, ISN'T IT? SO REALLY, IF YOU LOOK AT THE 117 MILLION COMPARED TO 121 million. There's a chunk that doesn't get counted as expenses if you're looking at it on the government-wide statement, because some of it was capital, some of it was basically payment for debt service, payment on principal debt. debt. Those are the two big ones. There's a lot of other things as well. When we're going to the government-wide, we have to book a liability for our pension and what is called other post-employment benefits, and that hits the expenses, but it doesn't hit our expenditures in the funds because we aren't paying for our pension yet, right? But if you need to book a liability for a future pension liability, that will hit your financials on the income statement. You also book compensated absences, meaning accrued sort of a liability for, this is Darian's favorite, figuring out what liability to use for accruals. One
[58:17] Councilor Ecker: observation, if I can make it on page 35, the overall there. So that's a good place to see how much of our revenue is TIF revenue. So it's about 8% of our total revenue is TIF revenue.
[58:38] Town Manager: Tax revenue. 8% of our tax revenue or total?
[58:42] Councilor Ecker: Excuse me, 8% of our total revenue for taxes is TIF revenue.
[58:48] Mayor: Yes. Where do you see that?
[58:51] Councilor Ecker: Top line under revenues. Taxes. Taxes. It's got two columns there. It's good to kind of see that rolled up. Yeah.
[59:04] Town Manager: And so when we're looking at these statements, there's a formula where we have to determine what is major fund and what is not. So you'll see there's the general fund is always a major fund. And then you see the fourth column over other governmental funds. Those are not major funds. The tax increment financing doesn't have to be a major fund, but we have chosen to make it that. And this is partly for this reason. I think it is good to see it there. It doesn't have to be. But we have been reporting it that way. I like to see it there. So capital improvement projects hasn't been a major fund until the downtown streetscape and the large liability with the advance to the general fund. So this is the second year that it's a major fund. Previous to that, it was in with the other governmental funds because it didn't have much of a liability. You know, the money flowed in and out, and it also didn't have huge expenditures every year. We've had some big capital expenditures in the last couple of years, and not just on downtown streetscape, but as Tim mentioned, the old Bath Road water was a big one.
[1:00:25] Councilor Ecker: So can we just run through that line for a second, the intergovernmental? so into the general fund the 30 million is that school what that is mostly state aid to education and then the capital improvement is that like mpi projects or is that the borrowing you're
[1:00:46] Town Manager: talking about that no that is not borrowing intergovernmental means it comes from a government Yeah, so it's a grant that is primarily old bath road water Okay
[1:00:58] Councilor Ecker: so where does where does like the money for like an MPI or BPI projects? Is that the other?
[1:01:07] Town Manager: Yes, that's in the in other So do you want to dig drill down into the detail on these? So let me just tell you where you can find other so starting on page 98 So if we're looking at the income statement, it's 99. So that shows the total other governmental funds, and that ties to that column on Statement 4. So it's non-major special revenue, non-major capital projects, and non-major permanent. And then if you keep going, so page 101 breaks down the special revenue into three sections, the recreation programs, the town-restricted programs. So that's all special revenue funds, grants, and things for the town. And then school-restricted programs, that's Title I, all of their grants and their restricted funds, as well as school nutrition is in this number, too. And then if you go into Statement C, which is page 103, this breaks down the capital project funds. Impact fees, public works projects, the capital reserve fund, and then New Island Rentmentary School, which is this annoying little amount left over from the Bowdoin contribution. But so one thing that's different this year is that the school department has capital reserves. And so their capital reserve is in this capital reserve fund this year. however we describe it as restricted as opposed to committed so these categories of fund balance non-spendable restricted committed and assigned those are levels of i don't want to reuse the word restriction but limitations on how they can be used so non-spendable can't be spent restricted can only be spent for its intended purpose as defined by an outside agency or by law. So any funds that are appropriated through the budget process for the school department are then restricted for education. That process can't be reversed. However, there's also committed is the next layer down. So when the council appropriates money for a capital project, you have committed it. You as counselors can reverse that. So it is reversible. A committed is reversible by the organization. And then assigned is a more flexible. It is meant to indicate intention of how things would be spent. And it's meant to give, so we use, for example, we use the capital improvement program to indicate, like, ooh, you know, we really should hold out this much because we're planning to use it in future years or something like that. So it's more flexible, but it is meant to indicate a planned use. I know I'm just talking. Rabbit hole. I know. There's lots of them.
[1:04:49] Public commenter: If I'm jumping back to page 35 where we were talking about intergovernmental again, and just looking at the main state for the Brunswick Public Schools, and this year the adjusted local contribution was about $19 million. Would this also include Title I, Title II funds? Would that be in that $30 million number?
[1:05:13] Town Manager: Not in $30 million. Title I and Title II don't go into the general fund. That's in the other governmental funds. That's right. Okay.
[1:05:20] Public commenter: Right. Would our municipal rev share also be in that? Yes. Okay.
[1:05:25] Town Manager: So for the detail on that, turn to page 82.
[1:05:33] Mayor: The detail on what, Julia? Page 82. Yeah, but what are we looking at the detail on?
[1:05:39] Town Manager: We're looking at the intergovernmental and the general fund. Okay. So 82 is where the budget-to-actual statement is. And so you can see what... So the biggest one is state education subsidy. Revenue sharing is in there. And then there's something called a main PERS contribution. So this is the amount that the state pays for our teachers' retirement. So we never see it, but we do have to record it as a revenue and as an expenditure in this statement.
[1:06:22] Public commenter: And again, this is probably details that we don't need to get into this, but now I'm on a net with this. So if I'm looking at the main EPS where I went to see what they got, it literally says that the state's going to give the school department $19,065,000. But as I'm looking at this one, it's showing that the state education subsidy was $17,500. Or actually it was $18,500. Oh, and variance, $900,000. And so there, that's close to what the final number would be there. Hold on, that's the variance between the final and the actual.
[1:06:53] Town Manager: So which year are you looking at? This is 25-26.
[1:06:56] Public commenter: Yeah, so I'm looking at the 26 of Brunswick Public Schools, which is not the 27 one, which is the one for the year we're currently in. So the way they filter it on here, it's the fiscal year. Yeah, and so again, they're saying on here, it's 18-3 for the adjusted state contribution, but then down the oh never mind so
[1:07:20] Town Manager: the EPS would have said 17551 the original
[1:07:24] Public commenter: one if they hadn't updated it's 18386 is actually what the adjusted state contribution here is the number I was looking at which was wrong was the at a hundred percent EPS which is that's a whole different kettle but what they said they were going to pay us was 18.3 million it's 18.5 18.5 so we got more because of that additional i think they threw in like 140 at the end of the legislative cycle or something like that wasn't that going to be for the year we're in is that for this year okay so who knows what that minor variance is but okay so that is not close to that number and so that goes okay. And is the main PERS, does that cover both town staff and school staff? Just teachers. Okay. Is there a retirement plan that the town staff is on? Okay. Well, yes. But it's not handled in an intergovernmental revenue way, like this is a pass along to cover that?
[1:08:32] Town Manager: Yes. That is paid for in our budget. In our budget, yeah. Right, so in each of the, if you look at the budget, you'll see that there's. The expenditures there. Yeah, under every department, you see wages, and then you see, like, a Medicare, health insurance, and main PERS. What else? Deferred comp sometimes. Yeah, no, it's paid for. This is just for teachers, right? Yeah. Yeah, I don't believe it.
[1:09:02] Public commenter: Because the funding's coming from, again, in this case, an intergovernmental source. Okay,
[1:09:09] Town Manager: thank you. And the next page, of course, is the expenditures by function, budget to actual. And then the very last page of that section shows that our general fund balance in total went down by $2.7 million. [Mayor: Page, please.] Page 84.
[1:09:48] Mayor: Yeah, let's focus on that one just for a moment.
[1:10:00] Public commenter: Did you say $2.7 million? Yeah. Where am I?
[1:10:04] Town Manager: So if you're on page 84 in the actual column, the third line from the bottom, net changes in fund balance. Okay.
[1:10:18] Public commenter: I felt like that meme of the husband looking for ketchup in the refrigerator, and it's like right there. It's like the number's right there in the middle. I was like, seriously?
[1:10:28] Town Manager: So the way this schedule works, that first column is the original budget. And you can see that as budgeted, we anticipated our fund balance, the general fund balance would go down by $4.6 million. That is the amount of fund balance used to offset taxes, right? right? So it was like 3,250,000 from the school and 900 and something from the town. I have those numbers here. Yeah, it was 920,000 from, the unassigned fund balance and the school had used 3,250,000. So that, so when you set up the schedule, you're expecting to make a balanced its budget to use some to have the fund balance go down but actually it only went down by 2.7 million and that far column on the right is where you can see where the surplus came from
[1:11:40] Speaker D (unidentified): if
[1:11:46] Public commenter: i'm moving back a page to 83 i was making a false assumption here essentially that my contemplation was that school departments can only spend what they're appropriated they can't be up and over that number because that's sort of I think how their budgeting works but as I'm looking at this the original budgeted amount for the school department was 57.7 and then it finaled at 59.5 for variants of 1.8 million so I thought again the reason I was going to counter between the two like with the town we can always after we approve our budget appropriate more budget and, you know, we're asked to vote on that sometimes to make that. And so sometimes the proposed, the budget that's a final budget, it gets altered through the year that you're in. But the school department, I didn't think that they had the ability to alter from that number. But what would that $1.8 million be?
[1:12:38] Town Manager: Okay. So there's two different things going on right there. Yeah. One is that we had to add in the main PERS contribution. Okay. Because they gave it to us and we spent it. I mean, we never saw it. But it is a true cost of our education. So you have to take $4.7 million there. That is offset by the fact that debt service, when we budget, we budget the school's share of debt service as a school expenditure. But truly, it is a town expenditure. So for these purposes, we have to remove the school debt service from their line and put it down into the debt service line. So there's $2.9 million. So that 1.8 is the difference between 2.9 and 4.7.
[1:13:27] Public commenter: So the general, so I'm not saying it's an accounting trick. It's an accounting thing that happens. But at the end of the day, the budget that's approved in June for the school department, that is max of spend. Whereas town, that's the budget that we approve, but we also have the ability to alter down the road.
[1:13:46] Town Manager: Within the budget. We can't, bottom line, not. Okay. But, I mean, we could also appropriate funds out of TIF balances, for example. Right, exactly. Yeah. But the town council does, at the end of the year, we ask you to move things around between functions, right? And so because sometimes there's more expenditure in this department than that, and so we do this. You remember, we do that right at the end of the year.
[1:14:17] Public commenter: I think they do similar, but I think they're restricted to how much of an adjustment they can do on that. Yeah, exactly.
[1:14:24] Councilor Ecker: Question. Just staying on that same page, 83, just so I understand the thread that Councillor Ellis was on. On education, is that to the far right, that $2.4 million, is that a net position? Does that go to their unassigned, their equivalent of unassigned? Yes.
[1:14:49] Town Manager: Yeah. So that is money that was budgeted to be expended but was not spent. Okay. So they underspent their budget by $2.4 million. Okay. Which is not untypical. I mean, that's a fairly common number that we see there. About 5%. So what ends up happening is, so that stays in there restricted for townwide. We call that restricted for education. So that amount stays in restricted for education. And as well as anything that they get in the revenue side that is more than was budgeted, also goes to restrict for education. So one of the things they did, however, was they transferred $3 million out of the general fund into the capital reserve. It's still restricted, but it's not in their general fund anymore. So their general fund a year ago, their restricted for education was $8 million, and at the end of this year, it's $5.5 million. Unrestricted. Well, it's school fund balance. It's $5.461 million. And that number is, I'll show you where it is, it's on Statement 3. age 32. Actually no 34. Sorry. So in the general fund column down in the fund balances section you see restricted and education. The 5 million 461 139.
[1:17:02] Public commenter: I'm going to want to go back to our old reports to see. I believe that number used to be ginormous when we had Navy payments coming in at one point in time because I remember in those first years that I was on that body, we were trying to draw that down judiciously. But I remember it being described as a fairly significant number, so I'd be curious to see how much more significant it was back then.
[1:17:29] Town Manager: Yeah, well, I have charts.
[1:17:33] Public commenter: That you got awards for going back to 1999. That's right. Just
[1:17:49] Mayor: a comment. Going back to page 35, I'm just glad to see the top line there on taxes with the tax increment funding number as well as the general fund number, just because it says what we all know is that we actually raised $73 million in money on the property tax. whether it goes in the TIF account or the general fund account. So in a street justice sense, or some sense, it's all the same money. It's just kind of being book-kept and hoarded in one place or another. Not hoarded, but used from different accounts. It's all taxpayer funding. And the TIF projects aren't really a separate revenue source. They're a separate accounting device to pay for things with TIF revenues.
[1:18:56] Town Manager: Yes. But don't ever forget the benefit of tax shelter. Right. I mean, I think what you're seeing in the general fund, the revenues would be almost $3 million lower. lower. So the fact that we put it in a different column here and use it differently does have a benefit in the general fund.
[1:19:23] Public commenter: And I'm not to play devil's advocate, but that's presuming that there's purpose for it in the restricted structure that you created for it. Like if you didn't have purpose for it, then you are hoarding money that you really aren't making good use of. But I don't I don't think that we've reached that point in any of our TIF zones.
[1:19:41] Town Manager: So what we would do if we got to that point where there really wasn't any use for the TIF revenues, we just wouldn't capture them. So we wouldn't capture that value in the TIF district, and then that value would go to the general fund. I mean, you'd lose the benefit of the tax shelter, but...
[1:20:04] Public commenter: Yeah. You'd be able to put the money to use versus having it...
[1:20:08] Town Manager: Right. I mean, our latest calculation was every dollar in the TIF fund, you might as well give up 50 cents, 60 cents. Actually, it was like 70 the last time I did that. Yeah, it was crazy.
[1:20:24] Public commenter: It's interesting, too, not to skip ahead if you were going to go here anyways, but just because I know that I've gone to these pages before. If you skip ahead to page 130 on there, 's a lovely 10-year table that talks about the governmental activities tax revenue by source for the last 10 fiscal years. And one of the columns is TIF property taxes, which gives you a really nice view on growth and even to a certain extent, which was not to be unexpected, with the revaluation in 2026 retrenchment because commercial property values getting a different share. But it's a good way to get a sense for where we've been in the last decade on these different revenue sources.
[1:21:06] Mayor: Yeah, my point in pointing that out was just simply to say that or observe that the source is the same, property tax revenue. There is the sheltering element, which is extremely valuable. But the source is the same, and the expenditures are basically for the same type of items. that we need to fund with tax revenues is in the general fund and gets the same degree of care of what it should be spent on is in the general fund column. The only major difference being, A, the benefit that we get from doing it in the first place, and, B, that there are some limitations on where you can spend it according to the documents of the particular TIF. but it's the uses and the sources and the uses are quite similar that's my
[1:22:00] Public commenter: only basic point on that I might add a C to your thing too I mean it's kind of demonstrates the value if you think about Brunswick a big chunk of our TIFF is the landing right and it to me it illustrates the growth that we are experiencing in those areas I mean if you look just in the last 10 years shifting that from the 1.8 million in property taxes to the 5.4 million to me that's a nice green flag to the level of development that's occurring out there and with the different parcels that are coming online and contributing to budgets and a good way of growth as well. So the shelter is great, the use is great, but it's also, I love the fact that we are seeing growth in a thing that a decade ago I think was a big worry for the town that we're losing a Navy base and 3,000 employees, woe is us. And if I read correctly within the narrative of your report, We're already reporting, I think it's somewhere in the neighborhood, 2,600 or 2,700 employees that are generated in that area. So to me, it's a wonderful success story of a particular TIF district for the town and for the people who are working on that in Mira.
[1:23:08] Mayor: Well, the big dirty secret is when we do TIFs, we shift tax burden to other communities. Yep. All right, continuing on. Sorry for some of those digressions.
[1:23:24] Town Manager: Well, I think the other thing, you know, sometimes we spend so much time on the budget that we forget that there's all these other things happening, right? I mean, TIF is one thing, but then, you know, the Capital Improvements Program, how much we're spending in that. I mean, it, again, comes from all basically the same source. Our main source across the board is property taxes and then grants. And so the intergovernmental revenue is an important one to look at. I mean, we've got $7 million in grants this year, which I'm still on page 35. Yeah. So if I look at under the Capital Improvement Project and the other governmental funds on the intergovernmental revenues, $3,102,000, $3,325,000. I guess that's six and a half million. Okay. So as well as, you know, charges for service. So charges for service are fees that people pay for whatever it is. It can be to buy a building permit or something like that. Over in the intergovernmental funds, a lot of it is recreation programs. No, under charges for service. Yeah. In other governmental funds. I know. It's confusing. Intergovernmental, other governmental. Yep. Right. So this is kind of a good snapshot of the whole government, governmental activities. activities. I mean, if we're getting into the, so if you keep going on here, so I will say, I didn't go over this at all, but at the bottom of page 34 is a reconciliation between statement three and statement one. So this tells you how, what's different between the balance sheet government-wide and governmental funds. For example, capital assets, $116 million, other long-term assets, and long-term liabilities. So that is a reconciliation that takes you from the total on Statement 3 to the total on Statement 1. The same thing happens on page 36, which reconciles statement four to statement two. And in the notes, there's much more detail about what makes up these numbers. So if you're really curious, starting on page 51 of the notes is a reconciliation of government-wide and fund financial statements. And so A details the difference between statements one and three, and then B details the difference between statements 2 and 4.
[1:26:47] Public commenter: So a question I was going to ask during the audit, but I thought I'd best not. I'd wait to this moment when we didn't have the auditor right there. So you have a ton of numbers in this document, and you mentioned building upon some of the stuff that's there. I mean, these look very similar format. How do you ensure that, oh, yeah, I did go in and update on page 51 the second number on this thing. Like, is there some audit process that literally checks through to make sure that each of these numbers are flipped or altered or modified?
[1:27:19] Town Manager: How do we do this? Is that human eyes? So it all has to tie. It's a great big puzzle. Okay. But, yes, this level of the notes have to match these numbers. It just is attention to detail. tail and then the auditors will go over this with a fine tooth comb they will find every comma that is out of out of whack they every dollar sign we're missing and where'd you come up with this number that should be this and so hopefully there's not too many of those but so i am we're confident that these financial statements are accurate like because we've tied them every which way and I know the numbers are good we've matched it all to the to the financial software and just the fact that I can go from the governmental to the government wide which is its own puzzle and then explain how that's that's a big thing that it's kind of a major milestone in this process but all of these numbers there could be mistakes in here but hopefully the God the auditors will find in the notes.
[1:28:31] Public commenter: It's part of what we pay them for, right? Yeah.
[1:28:33] Town Manager: Yeah. I mean, in most cases, they'd be putting together these things, but we like to do it.
[1:28:42] Mayor: Let me ask a question about a couple of big picture, a big picture element here. One is we know, because we heard from Tim, corroborated that we're one of the few communities in Maine that handles this level of accounting detail, correct? [Town Manager: Or financial reporting.] Or financial reporting. And in conversations between the two of us, you have mentioned to me that one of your goals is to update the vintage of our accounting software, bring in, maybe I misunderstood, that there was enough elements in here that were significantly enough out of date that you'd be well-served to have a new generation of accounting software. Did I completely misunderstand that? And if I did, if you recall that conversation, what the heck were you trying to tell me?
[1:29:43] Town Manager: I think I was probably talking about the budget because I'm not sure Darian agrees, but I would love it if we didn't have to do the budget in Excel. sell. We've been doing it that way for ages. What happens is, and then we put all the numbers into Munis. You were talking about the budget now. You're refreshing me. Yes. So it isn't that our software is perfectly modern, and I think we could just use it more for the budget. Darian likes the book she likes how it looks we're having this conversation but she also was the one this year who said wait a minute why do we have to input everything manually to munis if you have it in excel i can massage it and maybe i can figure out how to import it and she did it took some work but in my opinion that's the wrong way we right now we have every department has their own Excel workbook that has each account as a tab and then a summary page. And they fill that all out and then they send it to us. And then this lovely woman goes and takes all those summary pages and she inputs them into the big budget workbook that you're used to. Right. Right. Where... You do it pretty fast. She's been doing it for many years. and it is it's and then any changes that happen you know we have to change one cop yeah
[1:31:25] Speaker D (unidentified): darian you can chime in i was gonna say maybe that's where my hesitation lies about getting rid of the book because i know how much the counselors love that so i wouldn't want to be the one to tip over that apple cart
[1:31:42] Councilor Ecker: well isn't there a way to report out of munis in a format that's similar to the book we get today
[1:31:48] Speaker D (unidentified): or is not possible i'm sure there is it's not something that we have explored or tested but i believe that's something we're going to do this budget season is start making that transition
[1:31:59] Town Manager: so my idea is that instead of each department going into and putting into excel they go right into Munis. They put in the budget module, they put whatever detail they need for each line and then it's in there. And then we could print the detail from there. It won't look as pretty. You know, maybe we can dump it into Excel and change the font and make it look nicer, but it isn't going to be, we're not going to have the same, like right now you can see,, you know, we have this many firefighters at this cost. You have everybody's salaries in there. That will be harder. Like, I think that's what Darien is saying. You're used to seeing exactly how many personnel you have for each department and what their wages are. You're going to see total wages and you're going to see benefits. You're going to see all the same detail lines. You may just not have the extra stuff that we put in there. Yeah. The biggest hurdle is getting the departments to use MUNIS. Oh, well, that will be another hope. Yeah.
[1:33:06] Councilor Ecker: But this process is underway right now to convert to that approach.
[1:33:11] Town Manager: Well, we haven't started because the budget hasn't gotten going.
[1:33:18] Speaker D (unidentified): So last year we explored it a little bit more. So we've been doing conferences and training days to try and find what the capabilities of our software that we already have and how can we become more efficient and maximize so last year we learned about a separate module that we already have where we can take what's in the excel spreadsheet and import it all in one swoop rather than diane spending three days entering it manually and then through that process that was the high level quick big win when we were doing that training and then the next step is being able to go in and enter all of those things so we took a really big step last year and what we were able to use the software for. So I'm pretty optimistic that even we could get pretty granular with the lines, but I'm not going to promise that, but I'm going to say perhaps.
[1:34:11] Public commenter: You mentioned, again, to me I was even surprised when you talked about the departments doing entry into Excel. And I'm sure I'm envisioning this wrong, and I'm sure I'm turning our town into busy town. I don't know if you're familiar with the little children's book. Like, I'm sure Chief Brilliant isn't, for example, either riding the fire trucks or doing the spreadsheets. There's somebody who does it for— Oh, he's doing the spreadsheets. He is doing the spreadsheets, okay.
[1:34:33] Town Manager: He's the one who does the spreadsheet. Yeah, because— He's the best.
[1:34:37] Public commenter: So they are true administrators, then, knowing the software and what have you. The people who are in those department head roles are expected to be familiar with business office tools.
[1:34:49] Town Manager: Yeah, some are better than others. Yeah, always. And some have very strong administrative staff. And, of course, each department have different strengths than the others. We're not a one-size-fits-all organization. Yeah, can't be. If you're a police officer, you have a very different mindset than a clerk or something.
[1:35:14] Public commenter: So you adapt to the staff you have and play to strengths.
[1:35:18] Town Manager: They're good at what they do for a reason, and we have to adjust otherwise 100 yeah so that's probably what i was talking about i know that darian also was well you want to talk about the acfer idea i don't we didn't
[1:35:36] Speaker D (unidentified): haven't tested it let's get them guess let's hear it so tyler tech is who we have all of our software through and they have a bunch of different modules some that we have some that we don't And we signed up for the ACFER Statement Builder. So that is a tool where essentially we are able to export the data that we have in our account detail from Munis. We import it into this separate cloud-based software, and we set it up where we code each account to. Is it a governmental fund, proprietary, fiduciary? And in a perfect world, it takes all of that information, and once you import it, will pull it to the correct lines on the correct statements, and it takes a lot of building and a lot of coding. We worked on the 2025 statements to try to see if we could get them to match. Some interesting things happen if we do a manual adjustment during kind of our government-wide adjustments. They don't always reflect when that import happened. So it's not perfect yet. We made a lot of progress on it. But in a perfect world, not only would it import into the statements, we could set up the notes where whatever is in the statement would automatically populate in that place in the notes. So there's a lot of potential there. But it's a work in progress.
[1:37:10] Town Manager: and then Gatsby goes and changes the format yeah they do that you have it all set up and then they change so I mean for example if we're gonna compare 25 this 125 to 26 there's different numbers on the statements and you know we've now moved all the budgetary to a different place I've moved the notes around so if they would like just settle on something that would be nice so I sense we are burning out on this and I also need to go vote so if you have any particular questions as you're perusing through this council Ellis pointed out the statistical tables at the back yeah right yeah ten years of trending which is which is interesting that is something that is useful before that if you're moving backward or combining statements so as Tim said there's more detail the further back you get and then they sort of roll up toward the front The RSI, there's a bunch of tables in the RSI about pension and OPEB, which is other post-employment benefits, which actually takes up a huge amount of the notes and is effectively meaningless to anybody, pretty much. Like, you know, the concern about governments going bankrupt because of pension obligations really got the Gatsby's attention. And it was only, I don't know, seven years ago that they started really requiring all this disclosure about your pension situation. So the town and most other municipalities in Maine are part of Maine PERS. And Maine PERS is adequately funded. We're not in a risky state. We do book a liability, but we're not. You can read all the notes all about it if you like. I wrote them, and I didn't even really read them. It is good. Anything else catching your eye?
[1:39:59] Public commenter: I'll have questions later. Okay.
[1:40:02] Mayor: Well, I'll just check in with a general statement here. Again, I don't know how much value it has, but it's incredibly reassuring that we can have a conversation like this in this room with our staff and how knowledgeable you are. And I wonder, I have to wonder, and it's probably the old banker in me, I guess, maybe, that this comes from, and that what could go wrong? and I worry about our capacity and our capability moving forward into the longer term to continue to function at this level of excellence in our staff.
[1:40:51] Town Manager: Well, it depends on what you're talking about. I mean, what Tim said and what they audit is the operations, our financial operations. We're in good shape, and I don't think you have to worry about that. Like we have very good procedures in place. We have experienced and conscientious staff. If you're talking about generating this kind of statement, it isn't essential, right? That is not something, whether we do it or not, like if we get an award or not, it's not really, it's not the end of the world. Nobody's going to come and slap us. Yes, the rating agencies love it, but is it going to make that much difference? No, it's not going to be a crisis. When I've said to Darian, maybe we just don't have to do an ACFER, and she does not like that idea at all. So, I mean, I think we're exploring, like, what sort of support she is going to need after I go. I mean, will it be a couple of years of me coming back and helping, or will it be hiring an outside firm? Will it be getting the auditors to help the way they do for most of the other towns in Maine? It's it you know, so just as a reassurance The fact that we have a clean audit is really what's important the fact that the auditors don't find problems that all they can say Is when you when two people review something you should both initial it That's not a problem. We can do that, right? So if that's any reassurance, I think the system that's set up, the people we have, the people we hire, and will continue to, are smart people, conscientious, high integrity. And so that's what really is important, is keeping the day-to-day stuff clean. Yeah. And whether we have these fancy reports. I want to say one more thing, and that is that this council, this finance committee, cares about unassigned fund balance. So at the end of this year, our unassigned fund balance was at 20.95% of revenues, which, as you know, your range is 16.67 to 25. So it's pretty much in the middle. It's right in the middle of your range.
[1:43:16] Mayor: And what page are you on there?
[1:43:18] Town Manager: Well, I mentioned it a few times. Hold on. And the number was
[1:43:23] Mayor: 20 point what? 20.95.
[1:43:27] Town Manager: I talk about it a few times here. So it's on page 24 in the manager's discussion MDNA I think it's also in the notes but the notes are so confusing 24 in the MDNA it's the easiest place to find it probably put it in the letter of transmittal too don't I yeah on page four in the letter of transmittal say that one again on page four in the letter of transmittal all right so you'd probably already seen it the magic 20.95 can
[1:44:25] Councilor Ecker: I ask one more question. Councillor Weems is great at getting us up into the clouds and looking down. But I was curious about one thing when I was looking through this. And it goes to the schedules in the back. What page am I on? 134, where it shows the principal taxpayers. taxpayers. Is there, well, how do I say this? Bowdoin does not pay taxes, but they do contribute significantly. Is there a place where that's noted in the ACFER on their contributions?
[1:45:12] Town Manager: Not specifically, no. There's, if you're looking at the tax, if you're looking at statement four, it falls under taxes because we count it as payment in lieu of taxes even though it's a voluntary contribution. So on, yeah, so if you look on page 82, that's where payment of lieu and taxes is. It's $529,000 for the year, which was primarily Bowdoin. But we don't call that out. There's a lot of things we don't specifically address.
[1:45:57] Councilor Ecker: So page 82, let me just look at that real quick. And where is it?
[1:46:02] Town Manager: Up in the taxes section. Payment in lieu of taxes is one of them.
[1:46:09] Councilor Ecker: Okay, and that you say is primarily It's primarily Bowdoin. Yeah. Okay.
[1:46:19] Town Manager: Yes, there's a bit from Brunswick Housing Authority. The other thing that doesn't show in here is Bowdoin's contribution, $250,000 annually. That shows as a donation into Capital Project Fund. So it would show on page 103, $285,000 coming in as donations. That's $35,000. What is that? Oh, that is $35,000 as part of the franchise-free agreement, and then $250,000 from Bowdoin College.
[1:47:06] Public commenter: Is there any comparative standard? I'm thinking of other communities that might have, like, a major—think down to, I think it's New Haven, where Yale is, for example, huge, right, in that area. And actually, the town where my children go, Elon, North Carolina, it's huge. It's, like, a large portion of the town. Are there any practices where communities maybe call that out specifically? Because I know that we tend to get questions about that regularly, and I know that they contribute, but we don't really have clean insight into something that we could point to say, hey, for nonprofits, Bowdoin being the largest of those in the town, this is what they do contribute. Because I know, for example, they contributed to the playground, for example, at KFS. And so those types of things, do other communities do anything in regards to, I guess, more standard accounting process to account for that? Because I can't imagine, you know, the people in New Haven, for example, are always questioning whether Yale gives enough, and the people here are questioning whether Bowdoin gives enough. I'm just curious if there's a way to head that off, not head off the question at the pass, but to be able to see into it to see, well, what do we actually feel about what the real number is that's being contributed?
[1:48:20] Town Manager: So not in this format necessarily because this is fairly codified but we certainly during budget season this question has come up I mean I know when we were talking about the reval that came up a lot and we showed some various graphs of what they've contributed other than other than Brunswick Housing Authority which we by statute can ask for a payment in lieu of taxes where Whereas with Bowdoin, it's really a voluntary contribution, and Bowdoin's the only nonprofit that gives us anything. The hospital doesn't, none of them, others do. So we did talk about it during the budget season, but it could be something we could talk about again. There's no, like, I mean, there's a lot of detail that isn't in here.
[1:49:13] Public commenter: Yeah, certainly. I'm just thinking, again, of that one, because it does seem to be a place where people go with dark thoughts. And I will also say, just in pure interest, I mentioned my children going to Elon North Carolina. I was reading an article about that, where for them it's almost an existential dilemma, because the college has become so physically big within the community that the roads that are needed And the services that are needed in the town to support this huge campus far exceeds the capacity of the limited number of actual residents who live in the town of Elon. And so it's a financial dilemma that this town is dealing with that how do we manage this relationship because there's just not enough people actually living here to offset all the public services that we have that we need to support a school being in this area. So we're not at that point. I mean, Bowdoin is big, but not that big.
[1:50:09] Town Manager: Actually, Bowdoin's relatively small, right? Particularly in relation. The college I went to was bigger than the town, too. And, you know, coming here, it's a different.
[1:50:19] Public commenter: Yeah. What are they, like 1,800 or something? Right.
[1:50:22] Mayor: Well, in the interest of making sure that we don't keep anyone in the room from voting. Yes, that's me. I will be happy to call it a day and ask for a motion to adjourn.
[1:50:33] Public commenter: I'll make a motion to adjourn.
[1:50:36] Mayor: Second motion made by Councillor Ellis, seconded by Councillor Ecker. I assume there is no discussion. All is in favor. We are adjourned. Thank you and good evening.