← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick Conservation Commission Reviews Water Projects and Approves Minutes

2026-11-04 · 1h 15m · Source: 2026.11.4 Conservation Commission (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Good afternoon. This is the November 4th, 2026 meeting of the Conservation Commission. I'll call this meeting to order. The first item is the approval of the October meeting minutes. And hopefully you guys had a chance to look those over. I didn't see anything that needed correction. [0:30] Speaker B (unidentified): I had a quick question that came up as a result of your email, and I just wanted to confirm because I've seen it both ways. but I just want to check with John and with Jan. Do you prefer to have the doctor title in front of your names because the person that has helped us with transcribing minutes... [0:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Whatever you do, if you want to make things consistent... [0:53] Speaker D (unidentified): I honestly... Microphone? [0:55] Speaker E (unidentified): Microphones. You don't care? I don't. It's not how I really see myself. Okay. I'd rather be just this guy here. [1:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Tree eye. Tree eye. Just to clarify to everyone watching, you should still call a medical professional IF JOHN OR JAN ARE IN THE BUILDING WITH YOU. THANKS, RACHEL. [1:15] Speaker A (unidentified): ALL RIGHT. DO ANYBODY HAVE ANY COMMENTS ON THE MINUTES OTHER THAN THAT? ALL RIGHT. TAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE. [1:26] Speaker F (unidentified): I MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES. SECOND. SECOND. [1:31] Speaker C (unidentified): ALL IN FAVOR? SECOND. I'M ABSTAINING BECAUSE I WASN'T HERE. OKAY. [1:38] Speaker A (unidentified): SO THAT PASSES. the next item is tree ordinance update of which we don't have any yeah so when i just [1:49] Speaker B (unidentified): want to keep a consistent effort to have these on the on the agenda but where it says zero minutes that just means there's no updates it's still not gone through upper town management it's still not yet gone to the staff review committee so yeah if it's less confusing i can take it [2:07] Speaker A (unidentified): off. No, I think that's good. I think we want to keep that at least in the forefront. Unless, John, you have any updates? [2:15] Speaker E (unidentified): I had talked to Dennis two weeks ago and there was nothing new to report. It's still sitting with the lawyers and others. [2:25] Speaker G (unidentified): Council Member. Yes, maybe Ashley, you might have an update on when they do think it might kick out? I've been [2:33] Speaker B (unidentified): asking for prior to each meeting for the past four or five months. Since August I guess I have in my notes. Yeah. All right. Yeah. Noted. So I do consistently ask a week or so prior, but it's the same. Okay. If anything, you will get the copy of the draft as soon as it is prepared, because this commission would like to, it's my understanding, the commission would like to write a letter of support for the ordinance once it goes to council. [3:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Next, conservation easement inspections, which we don't have any currently scheduled Yeah, [3:16] Speaker B (unidentified): they've been unseasonably warm, but I'm looking to start scheduling them from either mid, starting maybe mid-November into December. So, I'll reach out to both you and Vlad. I know Marco was interested, but just to make sure I understand what your availability is in terms of scheduling would be good for me. Okay. [3:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Next, fieldwork initiatives, the sawtooth parcel, which we have. [3:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so I put that on the agenda because, in short, it's related to the tax parcel conversation. We had to delay the inspection of, well, the walk of one additional parcel on Bath Road because we were waiting for permission and insight as to how best to access it. So there is still one landlocked parcel we need to review, but with that said, I also didn't want to necessarily review everything too in-depth until we also had Sandy and Kevin available. So we are going to push that collective final review until the December 2nd meeting, which we had otherwise planned to do sawtooth. So I think what I'll do is just establish a very quick poll and get a preference for folks' general days and times in terms of availability, and we can simply schedule, similar to last year, schedule a date, and whoever can attend is obviously welcome to. [4:58] Speaker A (unidentified): and again that's removing the white pine that we don't want in the pitch mine area and the sawtooth parcel next to the runways at the air station any questions on that so hopefully we'll get a good window and enough folks out there to clear the we did half last year so we'll do the other half and i forget exactly what time [5:26] Speaker B (unidentified): I believe it started maybe around 3.30, or possibly 2.30. I know that it gets dark, obviously, around 4.30. So do folks perhaps want to relay preferred days so I can cut down on the number of options I provide, or is a general poll just preferred, open to discussion? [5:55] Speaker E (unidentified): General poll, I think, is just fine. just like you've been doing with everything. Okay. [6:03] Speaker A (unidentified): And certainly if someone can't be there right at the start but can come a little later, then that works too. All right. The tax parcels conservation value that Ashley just alluded to, she and I and Marco went out yesterday, were able to get to three. Like she said, the fourth one does not have any public access to it, So we've got to work on a butter to get access to that parcel. Two things here. First off, these are parcels that the town is trying to figure out if there's conservation value so they can decide what to do with them. It appears that folks didn't pay taxes. [6:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so they defaulted on the taxes. so the town has acquired them and again just to review we are asked to observe and weigh in on the conservation value of the property from what i've gathered from the manager's office i think unless it's a property that so that shows exceptional natural resources value and thus would warrant a conservation easement i think the intent is to probably value them appropriately and sell them however we can do so by with also placing restrictions on the property or you know certain easements so for example a mandatory buffer if there is a river or wetland running through the property things of that nature so we can establish protections covenants what-have-you that are put in place before selling it did you want to show any i'll bring up the photos do you maybe want to [7:59] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah go over your thoughts on it sure we visited one smallish parcel on greenwood road that is sort of just past wally staples place as you're heading out of town and it's right when Greenwood takes a turn, so it's sort of triangular and bordered by the railroad tracks in Greenwood. More than half of that is marshy and wet. [8:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Larry, could you promote me to panelist so I can share my screen or give me permission to share? [8:40] Speaker A (unidentified): There's a pond. Keep going. There's the inlet that basically a culvert from under the railroad tracks comes in, and there's a culvert that goes under Greenwood Drive that goes out. There's very little, if any, buildable area between the railroad tracks right there and then the inlet coming in and the sort of marsh pond area. [9:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Trying to share my screen now. [9:11] Speaker A (unidentified): It's, I think, probably primarily sort of a stormwater management kind of site, so it's got conservation value there. Of course, any open space is good, but it's really too small to qualify as a major. [9:23] Speaker B (unidentified): open space behind you it's displayed up on the screen I can also pull up so what Kurt was mentioning is so these are some of our town GIS layers you can see that parcel up in the corner here where the red dot circles it goes down to the McCoy Bay watershed kind of starts at the headwaters, so I believe we had mentioned it having value as, you know, stormwater management buffer. These are maps from U.S. Fish and Wildlife's wetland mapper, so you can see that the blue half is the pond, and then the green half is marsh area. On our town GIS site, it is considered or labeled as unbuildable. Let me see if I can pull up some. I have to share my screen again, apparently. Might be the other one. Give me one second. Okay. So this is the property itself. So this is a video showing, I don't know why it's going so slowly. I think it's the zoom but essentially it directly abuts the train tracks so not a lot of space there is some i think there's a lag hang on one second there it is so essentially where the property line falls is where the marsh starts. So [12:05] Speaker A (unidentified): a property like that, if the town isn't going to hold it and sell it, might be somewhat attractive to the abutter if they want a larger parcel, but generally it's not going to have a lot of value. [12:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Do we need to think about the water part, though, the storm water [12:28] Speaker B (unidentified): part? So we're not making a decision today. We're just kind of giving you an update of what we saw we'll continue this conversation right after we get the fourth parcel abby will we'll [12:38] Speaker A (unidentified): note what we saw at each site so we'll that'll be one thing that will the primary thing that we'll include and then i think town council will decide yeah sorry i just i was not at the [12:52] Speaker G (unidentified): last meeting so i said i'm assume the commission got the context to why these are here that this came to the council, and the council decided not to just put these on the market, right? [13:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Right. Yeah, okay. I was just kind of expressing all options that were explained to me. Right. [13:16] Speaker A (unidentified): The other two parcels we saw were almost right across the street from each other on Coombs Road. [13:26] Speaker B (unidentified): If you want to keep talking while I work on pulling that up. [13:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I was pulling mine up. We started with 38 and 9, which it's got Gurnett Road on one side, Coombs Road, and then a little short connector on the other. And this was a very interesting property. It's really a deep depression. I'd say maybe 20, 25 feet below the road. [13:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you prefer I share the photos first instead? So, I mean, these are essentially where the properties are. I'll give you a little bit of context. So they were directly across from one another in the context of where they are in the watershed. They are located in red up in the upper left corner, and then that drains down to the New Meadows River. river. And this, the larger of the two properties does have a stream going through it and a good amount of marsh. We also saw deer sign, turkey sign. So there is some wildlife presence there and it definitely serves as more than just stormwater infrastructure. It's a natural habitat that I would say does have some natural resources value, but there are also, I will show some photos, but there are two culverts that flow beyond the property, so there is also value from a stormwater perspective. And prior to the next meeting, I will compile or update the PDFs to include the photos. We just didn't have time. So this is the smaller of the two. It's essentially, as Kurt mentioned, seems to be a catch for stormwater, We weren't able to discern from this perspective whether or not there was a culvert leaning across the road. So that's something I intend to follow up. [15:36] Speaker A (unidentified): And that's a little bit of a distorted perspective from that shot because in the middle there, you see that sort of like greenish area is pretty far down. You'd have to, well, I don't know if you could scramble down. It was so steep, and getting out of it would have been difficult, too. [15:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, I mean, we could also see it from where we were standing. [15:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, so we didn't want to go down. But it seemed like an active spring. [16:05] Speaker B (unidentified): I wonder if it'll show. I tried to take a video of it, but it was actively bubbling. [16:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Cool. And we're in an extreme drought, So I'm sure that is a little more vibrant during wetter periods. [16:19] Speaker B (unidentified): And then this is the start of our observations for the larger parcel. So that is one of the culverts. I'm not going to focus on the video because it tends to lag, but there are culverts leading out of the property. There was, I believe, red-winged blackbirds that were possibly in the marsh area, corner pen. [16:44] Speaker A (unidentified): And that lot is about four acres. Yeah. And I'm going to say maybe a quarter to a third of it could be built upon. It's really heavily forested, closer to the road. And there's a lot of hummocks, so there'd have to be a lot of site work to develop that. But it is possible. But there seemed to be a lot of conservation value in at least making sure the streams and the marsh area were protected. I think that's a summary of the... [17:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, and like I said, we'll kind of summarize this information for our next meeting. I'll add the photos so that you can see a bit better. I also, I didn't see any, using the beginning with habitat mapper, I didn't see any evidence of known mapped species, significant wildlife, flora, fauna, et cetera. But I am going to reach out to IFNW and just see if they can't give us an unofficial confirmation. Sometimes they like to provide reference to what has been observed within a four-mile radius in the past. Again, not necessarily entirely accurate. We wouldn't have that information unless we surveyed the property in some more official capacity. but that's not something that we're going to do at this point. [18:14] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, go ahead. I'm trying to get a sense of where this is really. I'm wondering, I see that it's somewhat close to the Navy Base Superfund site, the picnic pond there. You don't think or do you think that there's any connectivity there between what we're looking at? I mean, is there – is that a source for the water you're looking at here? [18:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Where did you say it was near that you saw? [18:52] Speaker E (unidentified): The Superfund site on the Navy base, the picnic ponds. [18:57] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, I would have to – I didn't look at that Zoom. I just kind of connected it in terms of where it was. [19:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I wouldn't be surprised, but we should pull the string on that. [19:15] Speaker G (unidentified): I think the back of that might abut the former naval air station property. And Coombs Road was one of the areas that was believed to have been impacted over time. [19:33] Speaker B (unidentified): So your question was just whether or not it is fed by or is fed to? [19:37] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I guess my thinking goes towards, is there connectivity in some way? And if so, then that might influence my opinion on that landscape. For example, if water from the Superfund site is feeding into there, that would both make me a little bit concerned about the quality of that water itself and then about, for example, what responsibilities and liabilities we might have as that, or if there's some effect on the conservation values of it because of that connectivity. [20:15] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, I could definitely inquire, but I think we were just asked to, you know, just advise on the natural resources perspective, but I can ask if that's a factor that would impact any considerations that we have. [20:32] Speaker G (unidentified): anything that might have come from the formal former naval air station operations the navy has responsibility over that water so that we know so they might [20:48] Speaker E (unidentified): they might have some responsibility to clean or to amend the situation if we find desire in keeping it or making use of it in some way [21:02] Speaker A (unidentified): One more thing. There are three, and I wish Mark were here because he was studying them and probably took a measurement of them, three large culverts that go under Coombs Road at the outlet where it drains off. And it looked like they were put in since the road was last done because you could see the cuts. So it looks like they were compensating for a lot of flowage at some point probably in the spring, with three culverts that were that big and put in recently. So that was just interesting speculation, I guess. Any other questions, comments? All right. Next, in the watersheds and runoff section, Ashley's going to go over town projects. [21:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, thank you. you so updates for the coffin ice pond natural fishway so the project manager i have been working with lauren pickford from trout unlimited she is currently out on maternity leave i believe returning either beginning of or middle of december but i have someone else that i am working with in the interim his name is matt streeter he is the project manager and does a lot of project management and coordination for Trout Unlimited he has worked on much larger projects as well as facilitating their process through the review or development review process so I'm working with him to move forward with project design permitting etc we anticipate bringing the project I think for hopefully for public presentation either in December or possibly early January and then we would hold essentially like a public meeting inviting all relevant committees I know that the Recreation Commission was interested given their involvement with coffin ice pond property but obviously we would invite this Commission and you know rivers and coastal whoever else wants to attend make sure we incorporate any questions considerations that they might have concerning the property I know that all wetland property boundary surveys etc have taken place so there are efforts it's moving forward in order to prepare that packet we also got some good news as part of our way of getting additional funding and support Trout Unlimited applied for and received with town support received a $25,000 grant to assist with the design of the Harpswell road culvert which is just downstream of Coffin Ice Pond to make sure that any work on the pond and that fishway doesn't overload the culvert that is immediately downstream so those will be the planning will at least be in conjunction with that. Still waiting on additional details Matt had asked me to connect him with both Jay, our town engineer, and public works director, Ryan Layton, to make sure that any town planning efforts are also incorporated in consideration of that design. So, yeah, just a lot of talking. Are there any questions or concerns about that aspect? Cool. Yeah, McCoy Bay Water Quality Study. So it was presented to council Monday evening. Jamie, I don't remember if you would like to maybe recount the final vote, but essentially the myself, David Page, who was a task force member and being escorted us, our consultant from FBE, gave a presentation, took public comment, answered questions from the council perspective. There was a proposal, which maybe I'll let Jamie and Jan talk a little bit more about, but the study itself ultimately did pass, and the water quality task force will be sunset, and then we will move forward on figuring out the best way to prioritize and implement the recommendations that are included in the plan itself. I believe the final vote was five to two? Five to four. Sorry,. [26:04] Speaker G (unidentified): So the motion that was suggested motion to council was to accept the report and sunset the committee. There was a lot of accolades around the table about the quality of the report, the good science that was done. There was a bit of discussion after Q&A amongst the council to not sunset the committee because the work was believed to be great, But the thinking was to have them remain standing to complete the recommendations, which some thought was in the charge as it was written. So that motion failed 5 to 4. And then it went on to the full council, the original motion, passed 7 to 2. That's what it was. Yeah. So seven in favor, two against. [27:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. Jan brought up an interesting suggestion after, I don't know if it was the day after or maybe two days after, but concerning involving this committee or some aspect of a working group in order to help facilitate implementation and prioritization. I did make sure to relay the suggestion to town management who still supports the sunsetting of the task force but i indicated that after discussion just to understand you know maybe what aspects this committee would want to be involved in they are certainly happy to take any suggestions or consideration into advisement and incorporate this committee in some kind of capacity in order to help facilitate implementation. So we don't need to necessarily create an entirely new committee. It's my understanding that town management is okay with this committee itself [28:15] Speaker C (unidentified): essentially helping to facilitate those actions. I have an update on that from Sandy Stott. He suggested that we work a smaller group, a working group that's time limited, maybe, you know, for two months or something, to work in conjunction, two people from our commission and two people from Rivers and Coastal Waters, to look at the recommendations were kind of global, I'd say. And so what the councilors seemed to be asking is could we both specify those recommendations a bit more and prioritize them, and that would be very useful. The discussion at town council, some of the people were saying, well, we don't really need the task force to do that because we have conservation commission that could do it but actually since our charge both of our charges ours and rivers and coastal waters involve watershed protection the idea would be for our committees to work together to sort of solidify those recommendations [29:18] Speaker B (unidentified): and prioritize them yeah and that is what I relayed to upper town for town management and to my director and to that they have clarified that four or more would constitute a working group that would require publicly noticed meetings and they're not interested in allowing that it basically just be a continuation of a committee in a different form so since we already have this committee we have a representative from rivers and coastal and i know marco has been quite interested in this study we can certainly maybe discuss that more but it was explained to me that we are not facilitating the establishment of a new working group. However, they are happy to support whatever aspect of this committee's involvement in doing similar work. [30:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, then, however this is appropriate, and you know I don't know the ropes, but at some point I would like to move that a subgroup of our committee, including Marco and Abby. [30:18] Speaker B (unidentified): I think we have to ask him first, but yeah. Pardon? So I think we would have to have him here present for that discussion, but that, yes. Okay. [30:26] Speaker C (unidentified): A subgroup of this committee, including someone from Rivers and Coastal Waters, be charged with looking at that report, formulating more specific recommendations based on it, and prioritizing those recommendations. [30:45] Speaker B (unidentified): So we can definitely go through the report. where I know that the presentation itself had a lot of specific recommendations, so I will be sure to get all of those materials to you, and maybe perhaps by our December meeting, which I believe is on the 2nd, we could get into those items and specific details. I would just, before we make any specific changes or charges here, I think town management would want to see what is being proposed. [31:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Maybe you want to comment on that because I thought that what council was saying is that the recommendations were rather global or vague. [31:27] Speaker G (unidentified): That was the discussion. They were global, and there was concern expressed that although the report was great, it lacked what the next steps were exactly to follow through on these recommendations. and I'd be happy to maybe work with Ashley and speak with the town manager about what might be appropriate. I think the handbook, a working group that, in my understanding, that doesn't define a working group because everything would have to come back to a committee for an actual decision, and it's not a quorum. [32:14] Speaker B (unidentified): I meant if it was constituting this commission and then a different committee, the combination of which. [32:21] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, someone would have to decide that. So I think outside this meeting, between now and the December meeting, we could have a discussion with the manager's office about that and see what might – I think it's a good proposal that warrants some discussion. [32:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Maybe one of the first steps I can do, because I know that there were specific items that were listed, including short, medium, and long-term timeline in the presentation. So I've made a note. I'll compile a list of what the recommendations were, what the specific related actions were, and whether or not a timeline was specified or recommended. Send that to you all, and you can perhaps review it and make comments and determine where you feel like it should be made more specific or where you see the proposed working group getting involved. involved, having that insight prior to scheduling that meeting would be helpful, just so we can understand, you know, what kind of involvement or role you all would see in use of this working [33:25] Speaker C (unidentified): group. Yeah, I think that would be good. I believe that I have a copy of the, how many pages, 65 of them? Sixty pages. Yeah. I think we all have a copy of that report. And just as an example, one of the recommendations was less nitrogen should be going into McCoy [33:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Bay. Right, but then the presentation provided more specific ways to implement that. [33:52] Speaker C (unidentified): That would mean that we would put less nitrogen into the bay. So those are kind of more general than how do we go about doing that? is really, it's the how and it's the priorities. And I know there's a timeline, but there were things that Bina talked about, such as someone asked her what her highest priority would be for the recommendations, and she said, educate kids. Now, maybe people think, I mean, I do educate kids on STEM, so I'm all in favor of that. But maybe in terms of prioritizing it, that's a long-term, you know, 15 years from now, a 10-year-old is going to be able to make decisions about fertilizers. But what's going to happen soon and now? And it really does relate to the work that Abby and I have been doing. And so I think it's a natural, and if Jamie and you and the town manager could figure out, I know we'd be happy to help in whatever way we could. [35:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so I'll still put together this list, and we can decide what information is missing, get your opinions on what should be prioritized and when. One note I did also make is what was referenced in our presentation to Council on Monday is these recommendations, all of which are in alignment with both the comp plan and the climate action plan, both documents of which I believe have recommended timelines I know that since the climate actions plans passing and the lack of available funding has pushed back the timeline for some of those recommendations but the climate action plan itself and to some degree I would imagine the comp plan has timeline recommendations so maybe just making sure that whatever timeline is either specified for the McCoy Bay water quality study could maybe make sure is in alignment with the town's other accepted plans I'm sure there might be some overlap it might not totally overlap but yeah so sounds like I'll put together that document and I was going to reach out probably at some point next week and maybe we can discuss when would be a good idea to set a meeting with management and perhaps a few interested representatives from this commission. [36:35] Speaker C (unidentified): Sound good? But you guys will meet with town management first. [36:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, but I mean, if one of you would like, as the person that suggested this involvement of the working group, if you'd like to be present, if possible. [36:54] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll definitely make it a priority to meet in the next couple weeks with Ashley in the manager's office on this. and I think it would be good to have this on the next Conservation Commission agenda. That's my plan. [37:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, good. So it sounds like a good plan to get on that sooner rather than later and get it on December. Any further questions, comments? All right, next item, pesticides and fertilizers and working group update from Abby and Jan, including their report to town council. [37:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, so some of you were at the town council meeting, so I won't go into too much detail because I want to be sensitive to you already hearing it. But basically, we presented a report to the town council about the background work that we've been doing towards the goal of developing a watershed protection ordinance for Brunswick. And the exciting thing is that we've been working with friends of Casco Bay who have lent their support and guidance and are involved with helping the six, well, helping towns who are in the process of developing these protective ordinances do so. And ultimately, we as a group are going to try to develop a simple kind of decision tree or foundation or template ordinance that other towns could use to get a jump start on protecting their own lands and waters. And that's been very exciting for us to be part of. So, as an update, I want to tell you that there are six towns that already have ordinances, and we've interviewed those towns and found that basically the impacts of having a working ordinance have been positive, that people, including pesticides applicator people and landscape companies have been willing to comply, and especially in South Portland and Cumberland, where in Cumberland they're developing their ordinance now, but especially in South Portland, there are programs on the ground whereby trained people go into neighbors' yards and guide them to how to transition away from nitrogen-loading chemicals and go to less harmful ways of creating landscapes and biodiversity. So Cumberland is working on an ordinance, and they already have deep resources on their website through the Yardscaping Program. And what I was told by South Portland is that programs on the ground, like the two that I just cited, have been very good ways of connecting neighbors and creating alliance among their towns. And that we noted that in terms of the fear of passing an ordinance and not having a way to enforce them, we've been told that it's these programs, these supportive programs and educational outreach that are the tools that make these ordinances useful. useful. So we will continue to work with Friends of Casco Bay and it would be wonderful if Coastal Rivers and Waters, you know, a couple people on their committees and us on my working group could collaborate more and help each other forward on this and the foundation for our work is obviously the climate action plan and the comp plan and the surveys that have been conducted in the past that gave us the information that most of Brunswick wants to have protective protections for the land and water and also hopefully the results of this survey yes and the results of this [41:58] Speaker C (unidentified): upcoming survey abby before you go on could i just say that yeah the friends group is an advocacy group and an environmental group there's 10 towns in the in the casco bay area nine of them Our 5,000 people or more, six of them have ordinances. So we in Brunswick and Freeport are trying to play a little bit of catch-up here. And in their recent newsletter, they talk about this advocacy work that they're doing and how they're helping different towns. So we'll be meeting with them and representatives from towns that have ordinances and those that don't yet for a workshop in a couple weeks to go on with this. And we expect that this group will continue to meet to help each other out, provide resources, suggest strategies, and so forth. [42:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Could I ask a clarifying question? So the workshop, is this being hosted by Friends of Casco Bay, you said? Yeah. Okay. Could you send me the information on that so I can maybe attend possibly? [43:05] Speaker C (unidentified): Or yeah, they have they want to limit it home because the room is small But and we want to get but we can send you the information [43:15] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so I would like that. Thank you [43:20] Speaker G (unidentified): That's okay Just a question so that the surveys out right now, right? [43:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you are we ready to move on to the next item? I can oh, I'm sorry Yeah, that is next I just want to make sure you go out. You're excited though. Yeah [43:32] Speaker G (unidentified): Just want to make sure it got announced. I'm sorry. Yeah. No that was next [43:36] Speaker B (unidentified): next. I appreciate the enthusiasm, though. Spoiler alert. Yes, this pesticide, sorry, the Watershed Protection Ordinance Community Outreach Survey is live. It's kind of embedded under the Environment and Sustainability page under Town Services. So I had to wait until today when the election ended, but in short, I will make sure to publicly advertise that on the town's homepage. I'm going to send out an email blast. It's going to be included in the Brunswick Buzz. I'm going to be reaching out to folks I know that have extensive outreach. BTLT, other organizations have been pretty great about supporting these initiatives and sharing them in their public newsletters in the past so we'll be we'll be working on doing so the town manager's office asked that we keep it open until December 18th just to make sure that we could get it included in the next update for the Brunswick buzz as well as make sure you know it doesn't fall to the wayside with the upcoming coming holidays but that where is it so if you look under town services and you go to environment sustainability and under the watersheds tab you'll see a tab for pesticides and fertilizers i can't change well so i guess maybe we would want to finalize what that is called because when wherever we link the survey that link we can't necessarily change it so if there is a better way of trying to make that front and center that's just what was currently in existence so that's where the link is but in short it's under the pesticides and fertilizers tab we're calling it the watershed protection ordinance outreach survey the link is live the deadline is specified. And in short, it's to help us update our land care ordinances, land use ordinance, seeking actionable steps to reduce chemical runoff, safeguard ecosystems, promote a healthier future, et cetera. I think maybe what I'll do is also take some of the language in the handout that Jan and Abby created for council and make sure that's included there because those had a lot of really great vision points so yeah we'll be sharing it with anyone in the public that you know owns property utilizes those products we'll be sharing it with businesses locally institutions basically anyone and everyone that either utilizes it or provides services in town that utilize these products. It's a pretty, I would say, comprehensive survey. There are very few required questions, but the majority of them are going to be incredibly helpful and useful as we move forward in terms of prioritizing public support, understanding what kind of education and outreach REACH initiatives, you name it. It's a pretty well-encompassing survey. Any questions? Before I babble. [47:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Next, under Brunswick Watersheds, free to hand or update. Vlad, is there any update? [47:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I can just update. Did you guys already get the update about the fish kill, I'm assuming? [47:26] Speaker B (unidentified): I get the automated emails, but if you would like to maybe share with those who might not. [47:30] Speaker E (unidentified): So for those that didn't catch it, last month on the downstream fish run of this year's migration, the timing was such and the management of the dam was such that a large number of the fish ended up running through the turbines, and it resulted in a pretty significant fish kill of thousands of fish there's no way of really knowing because most of them were chopped up pretty small and their pieces were just floating downstream all that was really countable was what washed up on shore which is a fairly small part and that was looked to be in the thousands of fish so we're probably talking about a pretty major kill. This has happened before, so this is not a one-off. It happened about 10 years ago. I'm not sure exactly, but it was in that range. And Brookfield had done a study or had studied what happened and came up with what they thought were going to be management strategies that would avoid it happening again. Again, it obviously didn't work out, and we do know how it results. It's a release of water from upstream that results in a surge of fish arriving at the dam at the wrong time for the turbine management, and the turbines have to be turned off in order to allow those fish to get through without being killed. that didn't line up correctly this year so anyway it's the main thing reason i bring this up is that it's a real-time example of the issues with dam management there are solutions to fish passage and the brunswick dam but this is an example of existing management strategies is failing so we get a attrition and loss of fish on the upstream migration because roughly one percent of the fish that arrive at the dam well one to eight percent of the fish that arrive at the dam make it up the ladder and then are transported into the watershed shed. So we're losing a large number on that end of the cycle. And then those that do reproduce and their offspring migrate back out to sea periodically are getting killed. Now, what we're seeing in that fish kill was an extreme event, but this is happening all the time. It's just that this was an extreme event, which resulted in a lot of the fish bodies piling up on shore. But in any given fish run on the return, there is a proportion that are going through the turbines. That's just part of operating. So we lose them on the way up, we lose them on the way down, and I think that the hope is that we can do better on that. There is a second round of studies and analysis going on in the re-licensing process, and that will be released, the results of that will be released at the end of December, at the end of the year, and there will be a window for comments and responses to the next steps. steps. The last thing I guess I would point out, just so people are aware, is that Brookfield has submitted a preliminary request for a license extension or re-licensing. And so the process is underway, progressing, and there will be an official application early next year probably what I think of what I heard was about February March but it things are going to start accelerating pretty fast and so in order to keep up with the decisions and the proposals and then be able to make comments we're all going to have to be paying close attention to the to the steps as they come because most of the cycles are about 30 day 30 day comment periods and then it moves on to the next step. Yeah. [52:19] Speaker C (unidentified): What do you think the role of the Conservation Commission should be? I mean, should we act as individuals, go to the meetings? Is there a formal role that you're thinking for us? No. [52:29] Speaker E (unidentified): In the past, I've updated the commission because the town has voted in support of the advocacy of improved fish passage through the relicensing process. And so I think the thinking was that this is on the town's radar, and we want the various committees that are responsible for these issues to be informed about it. But at this point, there's no specific action. the main thing that I would guide people towards is to educate themselves learn about it there are plenty of resources out there for that free the angio which is our local grassroots organization that is working to be an intervener in the process and to be an advocate in the process for fish passage is spending a lot of time gathering that information and making it as readily available as possible I'm actually giving a talk tomorrow on campus at Bowdoin at 1230 it's open to the public if people are interested they're welcome to come and you can go to the free the Andrew web page which also has a place where you can submit your email for regular updates and then there's also the Brunswick Dam Resource Library that is a place where a lot of the basic materials are being held and you can actually access it like a library. So there are ways to get informed but then there are also ways to stay in the cycle and soon to be volunteering too because I know that FTA is looking at expanding past just engagement with the FERC process but also moving towards a public engagement strategy that will allow people to be more forward-leaning in this process and not just responding to the FIRT process. [54:52] Speaker F (unidentified): Vlad, it would be wonderful, since we all share emails, it'd be wonderful if you could prod us a little bit, because, you know, we all have things and keep us on point that's just a horrible story about the turbines yeah [55:10] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm happy to happy to share I can I can easily share some of the materials that recently came through the pipes and as well as guide us on who we should write to or what we should say or yeah I appreciate that I part of the initiative that FDA is just getting ready to start up is a legislator and administration information and advocacy push. So that we have found that as soon as people know what's going on, it's an easy lift. It's like they're all on board. It's just about making sure that people are informed. and that's exactly what the response was when the issue was first brought up to the town council. They were supportive right away. So it's just about getting out there and doing the legwork. [56:09] Speaker B (unidentified): If I could also, on that note, related to, for example, your talk, if there are any initiatives that need support that are also obviously in alignment with this commission, I have a board which you can always send advertising materials or links that you want shared and facilitated. And obviously, you know, the town has some protocol in terms of what can and cannot be shared. But if there is any question in your mind as far as, hey, this would be great to share or publicize, I've, you know, posted or circulated Bowdoin sustainability or environmental events before, happy to do so for anything that is obviously congruent with this committee's interest in charge so please feel free to send that and anything else you all might have my way I appreciate [57:00] Speaker E (unidentified): that and I'll just throw in that I just had a long day of teaching my students in my class is actually working on this project also and one of my groups actually wants to design a tabling infrastructure for sharing this information and BTLT is an FTA partner but their farmers market now is shutting down so the idea came up about tabling at some places just out in Brunswick and about getting permission to do that kind of thing and the thinking was since the town is on board with the initiative that they probably would be amenable to allowing a certain amount of tabling in some locations so if that's the case then I think some guidance on that could be helpful for us as to what spaces are that can take that kind of... [57:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, we can definitely talk in terms of any events or spaces, maybe get a little more information from you in terms of what kind of events, but you and I can talk more so after the fact, but I am on board. [58:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, thanks. Next is General. Is that Trout Unlimited Updates? Yeah. [58:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so essentially there's no updates on the telemetry study yet. I did get an update from Gene McKenna. Is he the president of the Mary Meany Bay chapter? I forget who is currently. [58:27] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe he is now, yes. [58:30] Speaker B (unidentified): He did let me know that they did a second annual macroinvertebrate study with students at Brunswick Junior High on a stretch of Merritt Brook behind the school. students were engaged, hardworking, cataloged many catastrophes, nymphs, two stickleback minnows, and numerous sow bugs and red worms. A great day for students teaching and TU volunteers. Quoting directly from Jean. So if there are any kind of educational opportunities that we would like to seek to get students involved in, I've done work with Child Unlimited before. I've met with representatives from the Coffin School who are on board with whatever kind of educational events we want to facilitate. So we have beans to reach kids and plan more events if that's something of interest. [59:21] Speaker C (unidentified): I have a comment about that, which is it goes both ways. So Andrew, I can't remember, Copens is his wife's name. I don't remember his last name. But he is a biology teacher at Brunswick High. And he's doing, his students are doing eelgrass studies down at McQuaid Bay, which seems very relevant. And also that somehow we could link their work with the water quality study in McQuaid. They should at least have the executive summary so that they can ask more questions about what can we do to help. [59:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I believe I've linked the study or the executive summary online. However, you said you had his email. If he ever expresses interest in coordinating with the town or pursuing an event that has town support, I've emailed him before, so he should have my contact info, but you are always welcome to email him and CC me so we can get the conversations rolling. I'm always super happy to do community outreach events, especially if it's education with kids.
New Business
[1:00:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, good. Last item on the agenda before our new business and public comment is updates from other town committees or town council. [1:00:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Just if left it open-ended because I didn't know if we would be here. No. [1:00:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, okay. Any new business anybody wants to bring up? Adrienne? [1:00:52] Speaker D (unidentified): Jess, Ashley, is there an update on the Arbor Week proposal? [1:00:58] Speaker B (unidentified): No, not yet, but would you like to share? Sure. [1:01:05] Speaker D (unidentified): So a more light-hearted item on the agenda. When John and I were on the tree committee, one of the charges of the tree committee was to celebrate Arbor Week. week. And so there's a proposal that we conduct an outreach program, an engagement program with the town. And the idea is that we select or we ask Dennis, who's the town arborist, to select five interesting trees in the town. And then we profile them on the town's social media and then as we approach Arbor Week we ask the town to vote on their favorite tree and sort of just bring awareness to the trees of Brunswick get some engagement I was just looking at some of our objectives here I think it aligns really well with like somewhere in here it says improve outreach and community involvement so it's light-hearted and easy I think for the town to implement, but that's the proposal. [1:02:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Have you brought this up to Dennis at all? No, I was [1:02:22] Speaker D (unidentified): waiting to hear. Oh, okay, sorry. I wasn't quite sure what the protocol was. [1:02:26] Speaker B (unidentified): I appreciate you asking. So Dennis, while the Conservation Commission has absorbed the responsibilities and gained two members of the previous tree committee, Dennis is still essentially our point of contact for any tree-related, Arbor Week-related support. So I usually only loop him into meetings, agendas, and updates when it's necessary for him to attend, since I obviously am here every month regardless. regardless. So what I would say is, you obviously have my full support. but I would say email Dennis, explain the same idea and just keep me CC'd and we can start to facilitate that. but it sounds like we would probably need some more information and possibly some advising from our town arborist, Dennis Wilson. but he and I can coordinate and provide support as needed. But, you know, as long as you keep me CC'd, you have my support to, you know, start following up with him directly. [1:03:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Sorry, I thought I'd clarified that. No, that's fine. That's great. Thank you. I can do all that. But then in terms of implementation. [1:03:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. So Dennis and I, so once we kind of get recommendations and information from Dennis, as far as what next steps would look like. He and I will start to help and facilitate support as needed. I don't know yet what those steps look like. It just depends on what Dennis suggests that we, either what information is needed or would guide us in terms of what we need to do in order to facilitate that idea. This is my first foyer into tree committee-related efforts, so I will provide support to the best of my ability but I think maybe just some input from Dennis to get us going would be a good way to start okay that sounds great and then [1:04:28] Speaker D (unidentified): and then you'll connect with the town social media group and they'll yes wait super thank you okay [1:04:36] Speaker A (unidentified): anything else before public comment all right anyone [1:04:47] Speaker B (unidentified): like to come up for public comment please state your name I know you're both residents. [1:04:53] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm Bruce Cantner, Brunswick resident. I like to drop in once in a while. It's always very informative. And I also tend to communicate around different little areas of different groups sometimes in this widespread town government. And it's also daunting. I just still processing Vlad's comments about the fish loss. It's just horrendous. And I also happen to be on a two-hour site walk just before here with the planning board out at the Avalon Woods proposed development, which in my mind is kind of a disaster. I'm to speak outright forthright. But we walked for two hours. You may know it's this piece of land that borders the Crystal Springs and borders all the longer time development on Arrowhead Way, Arrowhead Road. It's 300 feet wide, and it's like 4,500 feet long. I tell you, it took us over an hour just to walk the length of it. And I don't need to go into it, but there's some issues around water, vernal pools and streams and so forth. Otherwise, it's pretty straightforward, except that it does impact enormously the two sides, current developments and Crystal Springs. I hope somebody on this commission is a little bit in touch with it. That's why I mentioned it, and I also, again, feel how much you have to deal with. So I came tonight mainly because I have been really concerned and trying to follow developments with the pesticides, with the watersheds, and with McCoy Bay, all of which in one way or another I feel are very interconnected. And I'm just going to add one quick note to Vlad's great comment about the Coombs Road piece you're looking at and PFAS. I've been working pretty steadily the last two years on the effects of the Superfund site, And I can tell you that is very much in the watershed, whether it's geologically down in the fractures or whatever. One of our members had to replace their whole well on Coombs Road. So that water that looks so lovely bubbling up out of that property, I hope somebody will really test it. It's not a difficult thing. So back to my interests. I note on your agenda under C, the three topics here are pretty much listed. at McCoy Water Bay, Pesticides Fertilizers, and the, well, Brunswick Watersheds. So I'm going to try to be brief here, I know. I support all the work that's happening on the watersheds, and I want to commend Abby and Jan for their excellent presentation at Monday's council meeting. I missed it. I've been reviewing it today. It takes a while to get through, and I couldn't get quite as far as Councillor Ecker's motion to continue this work, so I don't know the details of the discussion, but I sure would support that. It was an excellent report by the Water Quality Group, and there were some really, big omissions for me. It was very general suggestions, but I won't go into it because of time here, but I'd like to see somebody in the town continue to work on this, dive deeper into it, and even name what things are omitted in that report. One example is separating the nitrogen that comes from septic systems rather than just as general runoff, a key point. And again, there's a process here of different groups in town talking to each other. Dan Devereaux's Marine Resources did a lot of work on that a couple years ago and that wasn't mentioned as far as i know so i'll stop there but i'd like to see that continued and it wasn't clear tonight in your conversations i think ashley has an agenda i think councillor eckert had a slightly different version jan had a different version makes me want to go to talk to the town manager about it but i don't want to take her time the other thing is i just you know the work on the pesticides combined with the watershed shed ordinance. It's so important. And I just want to encourage you, whatever you can do, to keep that going. And again, I know there's so much work that everybody, especially volunteers on committees, want to do. I understand somewhat the purpose for the new survey, but I just can't help going back to the Climate Action Plan. It's clearly stated in there, and you did great work surveying people for that not very long ago citizens the majority want more protection even though it gets controversial and I know I know you know the controversies always come up and that's an opportunity to have dialogues so I hope there will be workshops with the new council in the new year councillor Hicks has said she's going to push for that with more citizen participation how do you get people out you know I look at the audience tonight night i know so there's my little slightly broad wandering of topics that are of concern to me my hopes that you'll continue your good work on this and find ways maybe to bring a few more people in on the side who might want to contribute to this i have been working a bit with abby on this and it's very exciting this necklace around here you know it's like the Emerald Necklace in Boston. [1:10:37] Speaker F (unidentified): The Casco Bay Necklace. [1:10:39] Speaker H (unidentified): Casco Bay Necklace. All these towns that are doing this work. Let's join in with them and make a cooperative effort. Watersheds are bigger. Bigger than just these few we have here in Brunswick. And nobody quite knows exactly how they interconnect. And let's look at our region. So thanks for your attention. [1:10:56] Speaker B (unidentified): I appreciate it. Thank you for some clarification. Dan's septic survey analysis was incorporated into this study. he was heavily involved so we did incorporate those aspects. There's no necessarily difference in agenda it's just in terms of how we're going to facilitate the execution of the recommendations that were included in the plan but I wholeheartedly support the efforts to do so. We're just it literally just passed on Monday so we're still working out what doing what moving forward with those recommendations will look like and the pesticide fertilizer or watershed protection ordinance survey that we're calling it i know that i have been requested by council in the past to do the survey i was when abby and i first brought the prospect of i think so long ago when we were looking at just the shoreline protection overlay but you remember when we went to planning board and we were proposing very, naively proposing a draft ordinance without having done any outreach whatsoever. We were put on blast by planning board to make sure that those efforts would include outreach and consideration. So while I do understand it's a little tedious, the survey is now live. We will execute it and make sure that we take into consideration public We're not necessarily going to allow public comments solely to dictate what we do, because obviously we want to find compromise, but the goal being to do what's best for the environment and the ecosystem, that is first and foremost my charge, just to clarify. [1:12:38] Speaker A (unidentified): And I'll just add another clarifying thing, primarily because there's some new folks. But if there isn't a new development proposed if we get involved if the Planning Board requests our involvement Or if there's a conservation aspect of it either easement open space Whether it's through deed restrictions a homeowners association whatever tool available, but if there's certain density advantages that a developer can take by setting aside some land for conservation and we'll be and planning board then is supposed to consult with us and we do a site walk with them and talk about that so those are sort of the two ways that we get involved with development there have been instances where [1:13:23] Speaker B (unidentified): planning board has requested just insight from this commission so if it's not something that you know is directly relevant to our charge again as kurt said if there is a conservation easement proposal or open space proposal as part of the development application, this committee is directly and automatically involved. However, if the planning board has questions or the public petitions planning board to seek the advisement of this commission, that is also a way that you can compel their involvement. So that's my recommendation, I think, to your point. Thanks. [1:14:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other public comment? Is there anybody online? Councilor Hicks was there for some of the meeting, but not anymore. Nobody waiting? [1:14:13] Speaker B (unidentified): No one raising their hands. All right. [1:14:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So take a motion to adjourn. That was quick. Second? Second. All in favor? Okay. We are adjourned. Thank you.