Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:06] Speaker A (unidentified): good evening welcome to the november 2nd town council meeting in brunswick my name is jennifer hicks i'm the vice chair of the brunswick town council i'm calling the meeting to order and we'll do a roll call counselor ellis rich ellis I'm just going by the cheat sheet. Councillor Ecker? Here. Here. Councillor Anderson? Present. Councillor Perrault? Here. Councillor Timmy? Present. Councillor Weems? Yes, here. Councillor McDonald is on Zoom. Yeah, I'm here. And I don't think we have Councillor Wilson. And, of course, I'm here. I think Councillor Wilson will join us in our executive session. Is this meeting been properly noticed? Yes, it has. And I ask that all electronic devices either be turned off or put on silence. And we're going to be, I'm asking for a motion to go into executive session 1MRSA4056C, acquisition of real property or economic development. Do I have a motion? Motion made by councilor Ellis. Is there a second? Councillor Ecker is second. Any discussion about going into executive session? Okay, I'll call a vote. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Perl. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor McDonald. Yes. And the vice chair is a yes. It's unanimous for all those who are present. to go into executive session we'll be meeting in room 206 thank you welcome back everyone we just our town council just came back from our executive session and we are now ready to start our regular town council meeting again november 2nd and we are we have all counselors present we have two on zoom kathy counselor wilson and counselor mcdonald i'd like to ask that we rise if you're willing and able for the pledge of allegiance thank you so i am jen hicks i'm vice chair i'm filling in for chair mcdonald tonight he is on zoom so you'll have to put up with me tonight but i will read what chair mcdonald reads each time during our meetings as chair I ask while we hold this space together we treat every we treat every person here with respect and compassion as we serve our town are there any adjustments to the agenda no not seeing any are there any announcements of the council councillor Timmy yeah
[1:03:34] Speaker B (unidentified): so I promised a constituent I'd bring this up there were some pushy canvassers apparently on Main Street recently, which I saw a post from one of the businesses there about as well. So if anybody experiences something like that, please feel free to contact Brunswick PD, because, you know, there are limits on what, you know, they were feeling intimidated by these people. So the other thing I wanted to mention is that signs are not allowed in the right of way. So as an example, although this is not the only situation where the right of way applies, if you have a house that has a sidewalk in front of it the sign needs to be behind the sidewalk assuming that it's a town sidewalk i've actually noticed some houses moving their signs to the correct side of the sidewalk recently which is great but signs should not be like right alongside the road and like i think any case certainly in most cases and definitely not
[1:04:31] Speaker A (unidentified): on town land as well thank you anyone else with announcements counselor ecker yes i guess
[1:04:42] Speaker C (unidentified): first i'd like to ask the manager i have a little update on the public works task force work i could do it right now or i could wait till your report i think that now would be great okay thank you so related to the public works task force that was set up this summer. We just completed our sixth meeting of that task force. We're making great progress. Progress includes finalizing a list of additional information needs to define the facility scope and scale. That is now in staff's hands to develop the requested information. We've drafted a list of ten preliminary site selection criteria. We're working on waiting for those criteria as well to create a site selection matrix and we've initiated work on a two-tiered site screening and site selection process where we're going to look at the universe of sites and winnow it down to the ones that make the shortlist to score in keeping with the responsibilities in the council charge on Thursday December 17th at 630 we'll have our first public meeting to get feedback on the work to date so that's Thursday December 17th it'll be right here so that is a good opportunity for people who have been involved in this or curious about it to come weigh in look at the work that's been completed to date and provide feedback so that's the update I would just invite councillor Anderson and councillor Timmy if they have anything to add since they're both sit on that task force thank
[1:06:25] Speaker A (unidentified): you I heard there's homework in this task Sounds pretty grueling. So thank you for that update. I look forward to hearing more in December. I will make a quick announcement. I want to just thank everybody who attended and who were involved in the Brunswick Landing community meeting that was held on October 22nd. Brunswick Landing is in District 5, which is my district. It's a diverse, dynamic, and challenging location for, I think, in lots of ways, but filled with a lot of opportunity. And I think we have opportunities to make this a part of the community that we feel really represents who we are. We had over 50 people in attendance. We had two developers, a management company that works with the residents on Brunswick Landing. We had representatives from HOAs. We had representatives from Brunswick United for a Safe Environment and Brunswick Area Citizens for a Safe Environment who are very knowledgeable about the environmental risks on campus. campus and i think we made some headway at least in making connections with each other and becoming a little bit more aware of each other's perspectives on various issues regarding you know quality of life traffic safety and i intend to have another meeting like that in the in 2027 just to continue the momentum to check in with progress and the town staff that attended i really appreciate jay astle and julie erdman providing clarification on the role of the town in trying to address some of these challenging issues so again very grateful and felt like we made some progress in our lines of communication. You can reach out to me at jhicks at brunswickme.gov if you would like to be on a communications email list, because I will be sending out updates on email based on what I'm getting back from residents who have made some progress on some of the issues that they discussed that night. so I'm happy to add anybody to my email list and I appreciate people's interest in these types of issues okay that's enough for me now we can move it to move on to public comment public comment is a time for people to speak about non-agenda items it's three minutes per speaker we have 30 minutes for this session. If we need more time, we'll do another session after we're done our town business. Please follow the code of conduct, share your name and town and pronouns if you like. And if you want to follow up, fill out the response sheet, which we have near the doorway, or, you know, contact, you can certainly contact me at jhicks at brunswickme.gov of if you need a follow-up so and then if you do want to speak if you want to line up that would make things move along and we'll also have people on zoom speak if they feel that they would like to say something so you're up paul hi
[1:10:00] Speaker D (unidentified): my name is paul whitcomb i live in brunswick i'd like to talk about the proposed redevelopment at 53 to 69 main street there are three major considerations that I hope that the town council will add scrutiny to, concentrate on that I don't think are being addressed at all by Mr. Holman or Ryan Burns. These three aspects of this project are air pollution, water pollution, and the condition of the soil itself. The EPA estimates that an average dry cleaners will produce 560 gallons of waste liquid per year. The limited subsurface investigation completed in April of this year by TRC Environmental identified these chlorinated solvents, both PFAS and VOCs in the soil, especially perchloroethylene. I talked to Michael Mars of the Department of Environmental Protection just today, and I asked him what kind of air contamination we can expect when this soil is uncovered, covered when the tarmac is taken off and the soil is disturbed probably to a depth of 100 feet past the water table. And he said he didn't think that was going to cause any serious risk. I disagree with that. I disagree with that and I think you need to ask for the data. I asked him about the water table that flows from 17 feet to 19 feet underneath the surface that flows directly to the Androscoggin River 80 feet away, I said, is the disturbance of that soil going to cause any increase in the amount of the...
[1:13:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Go ahead and finish. You can finish what you had to say. You got another couple seconds there.
[1:13:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. The third consideration, the river needs to be monitored. The third consideration is where these 700 dump trucks full of contaminated soil are going to go to. The RCRA program needs to be monitored closely, and right now it is probably going to be up to the citizens, the Friends of Mary Meeting Bay, the Friends of Casco Bay maybe, because I really hope that the Town Council will take these considerations much more seriously. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:13:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else in the room? Okay. Okay. Do we have anybody on Zoom? I don't see any hands for public comment. Okay. So it looks like we have everybody who wants to speak, So I'm gonna close public comment. I'm gonna move into Managers report so manager Hensie you're on
[1:14:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank You council Hicks. So I'll start by reminding everyone that tomorrow is election. It's at the Recreation Center 220 Neptune Drive Polls will open at 7 a.m. And our old clothes at 8 p.m The town clerk isn't here tonight night. This is traditionally the night that she gets to take off because she'll be working probably all night tomorrow night. She did want me to remind everyone that absentee ballots have to be turned in by 8 p.m. tomorrow. They can be dropped off in the box outside or brought into the clerk's office, but 8 p.m. tomorrow is when absentee ballots. She did tell me that they have already had 8,069 returned, which is a lot of absentee ballots. That's more than in the last presidential. She wasn't saying that more people are going to vote, she was just saying that this is a very heavy use of absentee ballots this year. She said that 8,348 have gone out, 8,069 have come back. So that's a lot of absentee ballots, and as you know, they were working all last the last several weeks on that so there's been some questions about election security you have a question council williams yes you know just a quick
[1:15:43] Speaker F (unidentified): question are those 8 000 some odd ballots are those absentee ballots do that include the people that came into town hall to vote yes thank
[1:15:56] Speaker E (unidentified): you so there's been question about security at election we're not there is no federal monitors are expected in brunswick south portland and lewiston are do have federal monitors we don't expect any there are other election monitors that are there any questions about the fran smith is our main election warden and she has several deputies and they're responsible for the proper operations of the election there will be police special details that the wardens can call on if there is some need if there is any question of a disturbance or intimidation or anything like that the warden is the one who can ask the police to take action and of course police do it chief stewart always says if you see something that appears to be criminal or dangerous always call the police if it's at the election the police will then confer with the warden before as part of the process. Are there any other questions about that? Councilor Perrault? I just want to
[1:17:09] Speaker G (unidentified): remind everybody that I looked it up just so that there's no confusion by anybody out there in case someone that is not part of Brunswick law enforcement shows up in a military or law enforcement guard but there are specific laws that make this kind of action unlawful for ice or any other federal agency to come in sending ice or any other armed federal agent to the polls is illegal because federal law bans federal officers from interfering in elections it's also illegal for law it's it's also illegal because federal law bans troops and armed federal agents from being deployed anywhere an election is held and so i just am so concerned i don't want any of our residents to feel intimidated or to decide not to vote because there's a concern of that and i know that there's a lot of people out there that have a lot of distrust in a lot of the law enforcement authorities. But to remember that we, Brunswick is going to do our job, which is preventing any federal agent. And just a reminder that the National Guard was called up. The executive branch last week called up all 50 states. so they are considered federal agents right now so even if it's a main National Guard they are being directed by the federal level which would mean that they are not allowed to enter to be a part of our local election so
[1:19:03] Speaker E (unidentified): moving on capital improvement program we've begun the workshops on the CIP I have attached the schedule again here the next workshop is next Monday November 9th I believe you'll be hearing from oh I didn't write it down public works in engineering thank you this is the this is the woman who makes these nice lists for me thank you Deb so and the I will put more copies of the CIP out I see that the pile has diminished so we will make sure that there's copies it's just the first draft as a reminder there will be multiple drafts during
[1:19:46] Speaker H (unidentified): this process does that traditionally get put online as well i thought i had difficulty finding it so that's probably a me issue but is it currently online the draft okay you have to
[1:20:00] Speaker A (unidentified): use your mic okay thank you just so people can hear it's going to be on the website tomorrow okay so
[1:20:11] Speaker E (unidentified): next announcement brunswick executive airport master plan update public meeting is scheduled for Thursday, November 19th at 5.30 p.m. and it'll be right here. The materials will be posted on MIRA's website and we will also put it in the Our Agenda Center. I will remind you again before this actually happened. Another thing, Brunswick Development Corporation, the council will recall that you appropriated $50,000 in TIF revenues to be used for the Facade Improvement Grant downtown. BDC is currently accepting applications and I have the link to BrunswickDevCorp.org where you can find the application. We're encouraging people to apply. What else do I have here? And then, again, I'm going to try to do a general update. Sort of something i started to a month ago and i will continue i'm going to start by letting our deputy
[1:21:19] Speaker I (unidentified): parks and rec director make a short announcement yes thank you i just wanted to say thank you to everyone that came out on saturday to celebrate halloween with us our 59th annual monster mash down main street was well attended as well as the tent retreat afterwards and then just a quick shout out that to the Brunswick PD and fire for always helping and making sure the parade was safe and then this weekend we have our 59th annual ski and skate sale if you're looking to sell anything in the sale stop by the rec center on Saturday between 9 and 4 p.m. if you're looking to buy some stuff stop by on Sunday from 1 to 4 thanks so
[1:22:01] Speaker E (unidentified): in my updates I would also like to offer a report from the Conservation Commission. We have a number of members here, Environmental Planner Charleston and members of the Watersheds Working Group. We're going to talk about the Healthy Watersheds Ordinance that's in the works.
[1:22:25] Speaker J (unidentified): Thank you, Town Manager Henze. I'm going to allow the members of the Working Group to speak first.
[1:22:33] Speaker K (unidentified): Hello, Councilors. I'm Jan Mokros. This is Abby Sewell, and we're both part of a working group for the Conservation Commission. We're going to just talk briefly about some background research that we've done, and we're going to show you a map as well, and you have a handout in your packet. We've shared our update with Sandy Stott, who's the chair of our commission, and he's endorsed it. So we are collaborating with Friends of Casco Bay on some of this research, And they've informed us that six of the ten towns in Casco Bay have a pesticide ordinance or will have one in all likelihood by the end of the year. Those are labeled in green or, in a couple cases, yellow. So they start with, well, do we start with Cape Elizabeth? Is that down there?
[1:23:25] Speaker G (unidentified): Cape Elizabeth, South Portland,, Falmouth, Yarmouth, and Harpswell. and Harpswell is green, and Yarmouth and Cumberland are pending, meaning they're working on it.
[1:23:37] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, and at least one of those, Yarmouth, expects to have one by the end of this year. So the other towns, we've got two in red, and those are Freeport and Phippsburg, which is fairly small. They really haven't started doing much work yet on an ordinance. And Brunswick, which is labeled in orange, which has started doing some work. We found that towns with ordinances report that they raise the bar of environmental awareness and provide structure for transitioning to better land care practices. And towns differ in how they enforce these ordinances, but mostly they rely on public education. So it's not a matter of police people going out and enforcing it. so we've also interviewed key individuals in several towns who are leading the work on these ordinances there's often questions as a new ordinance starts as you may imagine but the majority of residents and also landscaping businesses and other businesses comply or have embraced the ordinances once they've gotten going what about brunswick so our working group is meeting with Friends of Casco Bay to begin drafting our own ordinance. The Friends group is eager to provide resources, assistance, ordinance templates, whatever we need. We've also in Brunswick had at least two dozen educational events since the beginning of 2023 to increase public awareness, both on conservation issues and how to transition to healthy landscaping practices. In just the summer of 2025 alone, there were five events, including a pesticide ordinance update, an event on pollinator gardens, another one on stormwater pollution. We do have a list if you want to see it, but it's not comprehensive. Just because we have so many good partners here, like Brunswick-Tops and Land Trust, there have been a lot of events. We're very fortunate in that way. And finally, we feel that Brunswick Climate Action Plan and the Comprehensive Plan both provide a foundation for this work. The surveys that were conducted for these initiatives found that most residents here support our efforts to protect watersheds and environmental studies lend support as well. Abby asked me why I had put these green dots on my shirt and then I had I forgotten to take them off well not really because I really would like to put a green one on Brunswick Abby's going to talk a little bit more about our vision for the ordinance
[1:26:21] Speaker G (unidentified): yes and in terms of the map we would love to turn all those beads green so the vision that we have for the Brunswick Watershed Protection Ordinance is to protect to protect our watersheds and to protect our future. And here's our vision statement draft. We all live in one of Brunswick's eight watersheds, large land areas that capture rain and snow melt and funnel it into all of our streams, wetlands, rivers, and bays. Everything we put on our land drains into the water beneath and around us. Everything and every town is connected. To protect our and other species' futures, we must come together to protect our watersheds. The goal of this ordinance would be to protect personal and family health, to protect our marine economy and the many lives that depend upon lands and waters, to protect drinking water and coastal waters, reduce the use of unneeded pesticides, fertilizers, and excess road salt, to help residents care for their properties in safe practical ways based in science and to carry out the goals of the brunswick comprehensive plan and climate action plan thank you and
[1:27:51] Speaker J (unidentified): then to round off those updates thank you both by the way in order to facilitate drafting an ordinance which to be clear we do not yet have a draft ready. We are at the beginning stages of this, though all of the work that Jan and Abby have done will be pivotal in order to put together what is best for and representative of Brunswick, but the representative part comes into play in the form of a survey that is, in fact, currently online. My director has taken it herself. We are finalizing clarifying instructions, but the survey itself will be live tomorrow at 5 p.m. and will be open until about December 18th to make sure that we can get it in the Brunswick buzz, make sure it distributes as widely as possible townwide. And in short, it will essentially have questions that address values and concerns, user preferences, level of support, considerations for regulations, waivers, educational needs, all of that beautiful, information. It'll target commercial stakeholders, so landscaping companies, property managers, garden suppliers, you name it. And we'll also have questions that are important and directed towards residents, homeowners, renters, landlords, students, anyone who works in Brunswick, et cetera. So the town website, which if you all have the handout, it has the link at the bottom of the handout. out there are extra copies outside of the council chambers on the table if folks want access to that as well but we'll again make sure to publicize it widely on the town website via the buzz our social media and really anyone who's willing to help share the link as well and with that i will or we will accept any questions that you might have
[1:29:46] Speaker H (unidentified): Any questions councillor Ellis so these communities that are dotted here on this chart They're not collaborating in any sort of way are they and I guess as a follow-up to that I'm just wondering if they are why is West Bath not Contemplated as a dot as they sit across the river from my house, right?
[1:30:05] Speaker G (unidentified): West Bath is considered smaller And so we chose the towns that are most like us either between five thousand and twenty five hundred but we are aware of West Bath being, we would love to have West Bath in the necklace. We have been in conversation since August with Friends of Casco Bay, and on November 17th, we are having a forum moderated by Friends of Casco Bay with various representatives from the various towns. And by the way, that map doesn't include the lowest, the Cape Elizabeth dot, which doesn't show in here, but it's there. Anyway, it's going to be an exciting forum, again, moderated by Friends of Casco Bay, who's been very supportive, and with representatives from these other towns because there's a lot of similarities in my review of the different ordinances that are in existence and the ones that are being written. It's basically very similar content and organization in terms of categories such as findings and waivers. It's all similar. similar so we are just starting to work on that part of it does that answer your question
[1:31:27] Speaker H (unidentified): I think it does and it makes me very happy to hear that you're actually doing benchmarking and looking at what other people who have already treaded into this are doing and looking at it came up oddly enough this past week in the rivers and coastal waterways commission meeting the need for this came up there were a couple people who were strongly saying why haven't we done this yet And so it's good to see that we are moving forward and that we are looking to see what some of the best solutions were. One of the topics that get raised in that meeting, too, and I won't speak to the science of it one way or the other, but car washes. Not necessarily professional car washes, but apparently people are worried there's a burgeoning trade of people who will come to your house and wash your car. And apparently there are issues with that as well.
[1:32:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Good to know. I'll make a note of that. Yes, and just as watersheds connect everything, we're really excited about the concept of all the coastal towns connecting and being in communication.
[1:32:30] Speaker J (unidentified): Any other questions? No? Everyone feels informed? Great. Thank you.
[1:32:39] Speaker E (unidentified): So I'll just continue with my general update, but I'm going to maybe chop a few things out of this. So I sort of just want to talk about some of the things that are going on. One, they're not always top of mind, but I do want counsel just to be aware of things that are always happening in the background. So one is the environmental covenants related to EUICA, since we're talking about the environment. Uniform Environmental Covenants Act is an act that is intended to help parcels be protected and the restrictions on parcels stay with them. And this is something since 2025 Maine statute has included a requirement that all property held by MIRA is subject to the EUICA, meaning that these covenants need to be placed on these parcels. And this includes the town. So the town has been working with DEP. So what it is a covenant that is granted by the landowner to Maine DEP to establish activity and use limitations that run with the land, no matter who owns the land. And they're recorded in the Registry of Deeds, and it's meant to be an extra layer of protection by giving DEP the enforcement authority. So the town is currently working with DEP on a EUECA for the parcel, the recreation center and MARC parcel, which was, I mean, and at the same time, MIRA, of course, is working with DEP on a number of others, including the quarry area. If you remember, the quarry is intended to come to the town, but we will not accept it until the EUECA is placed. So that's just something that's happening in the background. And I'll keep you posted. I'm hopeful we'll push it forward. I'm going to skip ahead. Zoe Court. As of Friday, Deputy Chief Sheen reported that in three of the four mobile homes that were condemned, the required repairs have been made and the residents have returned home. So this was in the news, and that was – I just wanted to give that. On the fourth mobile home, the tenant is cleaning up the home so that the repairs can be done. and then once the repairs are done, the tenant will reoccupy the home. So that is moving along, and just wanted to give that update. And then finally, finance committee is tomorrow at 4 p.m. I invite counselors other than the finance committee to come because the auditor, or auditor Tim Gill, will be there to talk about the 25-26 audit. it. The Finance Committee has been given a draft of the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, that lovely thing we all love to read. But we welcome questions. The auditor especially does welcome questions and comments from councillors. As a reminder, the auditor works for the council. And that's all I have right now. Councillor Ecker.
[1:35:50] Speaker C (unidentified): just a quick update I didn't get my hand up earlier before but the airport master plan has been put online by Mira it was put online last week so that's available for review right now on their website and it's the it's the completed report I
[1:36:14] Speaker A (unidentified): have a I guess a communication I wanted to share just for those who are listening out here and you know beyond. I do get a lot of questions about leaf pile alternatives and I know we are in the height of leaf season. I personally don't rake my leaves until the spring but a lot of people certainly do pick up their leaves now and there has been a lot of question about what can the town do to make up for the loss of the pile on water on industrial road we do have a pile on graham road but that's for some people that's a big i guess no pun intended big hall to get out there and so i have brought this up to you as in our manager conversations and i have pitched the idea of you know what would it look like to hire pickup service so i'm just saying there's there's conversation about this it's It's well known with me and staff that, you know, this is something we might want to, we do need to think about, address, and maybe even bring forward to the council of some alternatives. So I wanted to throw that on your plate.
[1:37:28] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, I'm actually meeting with one hauler tomorrow to see what that would cost and sort of how that program could be designed. It's something Brunswick has not ever done, but we're going to look into it.
[1:37:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I appreciate that, and it will cost money, so that's why, as a council, we have to think about that, but if it's an important enough service and adds significantly to quality of life, then we probably need to think about that. Any other questions for the manager? Okay, I'm going to move into public hearings. THE TOWN COUNCIL WILL HEAR PUBLIC COMMENTS. ITEM 124, THE TOWN COUNCIL WILL HEAR PUBLIC COMMENTS TO CONSIDER APPROVING PHASE TWO OF A HOUSING ASSISTANCE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT FOR BRUNSWICK BAY COOPERATIVE AND WILL TAKE ANY APPROPRIATE ACTIONS. SO THAT WOULD BE THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PROJECT MANAGER. I NEED TO OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING. THIS IS SO, AND PUBLIC HEARING HAS BEEN OPEN AND WE'RE ASKING PROJECT MANAGER ADAMOWICZ TO OPEN THE PUBLIC Manager Adamowitz to come up and give us some information. Thank you. Good evening, Town
[1:38:40] Speaker L (unidentified): Council. Christy Adamowitz, Economic Community Development Project Manager. This is the continuation of the CDBG housing assistance application that we are in the process of doing for Brunswick Bay Cooperative. This is Phase 2 of the application, and Phase 2 is basically doing the planning approvals environmental review making sure that this town is operating above board honing in on the budget for their project their project is replacing the 16 failing septic systems in their community there's 92 residents there they bought their community and became a resident owned community a number of years ago and they've started to replace their failing septic systems, and these are the final 16 that need replacing. Everybody wants the community to move to sewer. However, they have a leaking water system problem, and because sewer rates are based on water consumption, they'd be paying higher than they should for their sewer system. And because these septics are failing and need immediate attention, the short-term solution is to replace them. The medium-term solution or the medium-term goal is to fix the leaking water and then long-term is to get them onto sewer. So they are applying. The grant is $500,000. They have the match. They're not asking for any money from the town council. It's just customary that CDBG applications go through the town. There's government-to-government type grants, and so communities can't apply for them for themselves. So the ask is for the council to have this public hearing and approve the contents of the Phase 2 application so that we can get that into DECD and help this community get on to those septic systems.
Public Comment
[1:40:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Are there any questions on the council regarding this item? Okay, I'm going to open the floor to public comment on this item. If you would like to speak, you can come up to the podium. I do see someone. I don't see anybody on the floor, but I do see someone on Zoom. So I'll go ahead and take a comment from Kristen. Kirsten. I'm sorry. Sorry, I got your name wrong. You're Kirsten?
[1:41:06] Speaker M (unidentified): Yep. Kirsten Brewer. I'm a technical assistance provider for the Brunswick Bay MOBA Home Cooperative and just wanted to say thank you to the council for your past support and a big thank you to Chrissy of the Town for helping with this application. We are working through the final design and permitting and looking forward to proceed with this project. And if there's any particular questions I'm happy to try to answer them. Thank you.
[1:41:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else either Zoom or on in person? Okay seeing nobody wanting to speak I'm going to close the public hearing and I'll take a motion for this item.
[1:41:57] Speaker N (unidentified): Thanks Kim. I move to approve phase two of a housing assistance community development block grant for Brunswick Bay Cooperative. Second. Thank you.
[1:42:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Second by Councillor Teemee. So the motion made by Councillor Anderson, second by Councillor Teemee. Any discussion on this item? Seeing none, let's take a vote. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Peralta. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor MacDonald. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Yes. And the vice chair is a yes. It's unanimous in favor of this motion. The motion passes.
[1:42:49] Speaker H (unidentified): Just a point of order. Yes. I don't think we need to change it. Are we supposed to vote first to waive our standard procedures, or does that matter? Is that just ceremonial? I just want to make sure that the vote counts, I guess.
[1:43:02] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe that's for ordinances. And this is exactly why we have Fran Smith, who's zoomed in here. She zoomed in. Go to bed. So, Fran, you will chime in if we're wrong.
[1:43:12] Speaker H (unidentified): So it's only on ordinances. Yes. Okay, thank you.
[1:43:14] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, it's only on zoning ordinances. So, like, resolutions, things of that nature don't need it.
New Business
[1:43:21] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Okay, we're on to new business. Item 125, the town council will hear a report regarding the McCoy Bay nonpoint source study and consider sunsetting the McCoy Bay Water Quality Task Force, and we'll take any appropriate actions. So we have a McCoy Bay Water Quality Task Force member. I guess we have Environmental Planner Charleston to get us started.
[1:43:47] Speaker J (unidentified): Thank you so much. Welcome, and thank you, everyone, for joining us to discuss the McCoy Bay Water Quality Study. For those who don't know me, my name is Ashley Charleston. I'm the town environmental planner, and before we get started, I wanted to extend a deep thank you to Paul's Marina, town staff, and other committee members, FBE as well, for all the field sampling and hard work that went into this study. Next slide, please. So from the town's perspective, this project is all about improving our understanding of a resource that is both important environmentally as well as to the people who live, work, and recreate in the area. Water quality is influenced not only by what happens along its shoreline, but what happens upland of that shore as well. Activities through the surrounding watershed, including how land is developed, managed, et cetera, how storm water moves across the landscape, and how nutrients and other pollutants enter our waterways all have an impact on the bay. And this study essentially gives us an opportunity to look at those connections more systematically and establish a stronger scientific foundation for future decisions. Next slide. So why was this study needed? Because it's been a long time in the making. It was intended to take one year. It's ended up taking two. So a quick recap for those who are new on the council as well as in the audience. Water quality concerns in McCoy Bay have been documented for decades at this point. Nitrogen and bacteria, which are carried by stormwater runoff and groundwater from surrounding land uses, have been identified as potential contributors, and this study itself confirms that nitrogen is a year-round problem, but I'll let our consultant get a little more into that. Elevated fecal indicator bacteria have contributed to shellfish closures, harvesting restrictions, et cetera, while algal blooms and shellfish mortality have continued to raise concerns about the bay's health. And that, coupled with our changing landscape, existing development, future growth, and land management decisions, all influence, again, how pollutants move from the watershed into the bay. So with this in mind, town staff sought to fill the information gap by establishing a better baseline of data and an understanding of pollutant sources in order to inform effective and targeted responses. Next slide. I'll try and recap this very briefly, but in short, following this call to action and information, the council established Delmaquette Bay Water Quality Task Force, who you will hear from one of its members. This task force was established in June of 2023 in order to help organize and guide the work. It brought together not only municipal representatives, but individuals with expertise in relevant scientific fields. These individuals assisted in helping develop a scope of work, which our consultant then performed, again, meant to establish a baseline of water quality conditions and evaluate the effects of existing and future land uses and model nitrogen and fecal indicator bacteria loadings in our watershed. An important part of this effort is to understand how the study can inform real-world municipal decisions. As a municipality, we have a responsibility to protect our natural resources and the interests of our growing community. And having better information about water quality and pollutant sources will help evaluate those responsibilities together. So, in short, the study is intended not only – it's not intended to suggest that any single land use or activity is necessarily responsible for the impact on the Bay in its entirety and the challenges that it experiences, but rather it provides a more systemic way or a systematic way to evaluate potential contributing sources. And then the value of that work is how we use that information moving forward to guide ordinance updates, land use decisions, et cetera. So without further ado, I will turn it over to our consultant to walk us through the study itself, which includes fieldwork findings and recommendations. presentations.
[1:48:10] Speaker P (unidentified): Thank you, Ashley. Next slide, please. I am Bina Skordas. I work at FBE. I used to have Ashley's position here at the town of Brunswick. Good to see many of you. I also used to live here. I just moved a little bit further south, and I missed my marsh. I lived in Woodward Cove over by West Bath as well, and now I'm working on a project at West Bath, and they're very interested in the pesticide ordinance so we'll connect all the dots today okay my this presentation is a little long but we're gonna have fun get through it answer questions and so just to get everyone a little organized here the McCoy Bay watershed you'll see it in the map here and tonight we're gonna talk about you know a couple different points so you'll see BG which is bunganuck stream WP which is actually called great goalie which I had never heard of great goalie but it's on a map and it drains into wharton's point so it's actually on here as wp because that's where it drains to and then rm is a unnamed stream that's near rossmoor road so these are all you know that's where we did our sampling sites and the reason we chose these sampling sites in coordination with the task force to try and get an understanding of where all those you know point sources could be non-point sources could be and how it drains into the watershed. Okay, so as Ashley mentioned, there are two concerns that do behave differently. So we have nitrogen and bacteria. So nutrients, of course, are essential for life. But excess nutrients, oh, sorry, next slide. Excess nutrients throw a coastal ecosystem out of balance, right? So algae and other organisms grow fast, and that kind of shifts that food web and can harm things like eelgrass or other life. And then bacteria, as we know, often comes from poop, a fecal indicator of bacteria. And so why this matters is it threatens public health. So this is a public health problem. So these are two things that we look at a lot when we do watershed management plans or do any water quality monitoring in fresh or estuary environments. So what we're seeing is nitrogen is peaking in wet and dry weather and bacteria is really after a storm. So you'll see that in the data here in a minute. Oh, next slide, please. So how does pollution reach the bay? So sources on the land could be from septic system, farms, lawn fertilizer, pets and wildlife, roads and roofs, that stormwater runoff. And as Ashley mentioned, it's runoff as well as groundwater. And then it goes into our streams and then it goes into our bay. And so it's really important to think about what are those non-source point pollution areas and how can we best address them as a holistic. You know, it's not, as Ashley said, it's not one person is at fault here. And there's no fault. We're just a lot of people trying to live in an environment, and we've got to figure out how to do it best. Next slide, please. So how did the study work? We stowed in a lot of streams for a lot of hours, and when we were in the streams, we were sampling nutrients and bacteria at five different stream sites that I showed earlier. We tracked flow with water-level loggers and flow measurements, and then we sampled the base. So we did a lot of water and sediment sampling at tidal sites within the bay itself. And then when we were on the farm site, you'll see we had some control sites on the farm. And just to back up a tad, the initial study didn't include any sampling of the farm sites. And then due to some public comments and concerns, we did include that in the study, which was helpful to see sort of how oyster farms do impact or not the bay. And it was really fun to talk with folks at Bowdoin and other places to see what data is out there. There have been a lot of studies on this in the last few years, and so we were learning a lot as we went, which was fun. And then we did some modeling and estimated the loads of today and also did a build-out analysis for the watershed as well as the town. [Speaker F (unidentified): Next slide. so] just to like i don't know this graph might be a little bit confusing but that goes up by 10 so it's a log scale so you'll see you know the blue line is when it's a dry weather event that we sampled and this is bacteria and then the red line or orange line whatever is when it's a wet weather event and so you'll see that this you know as the scale jumps it goes up by quite a bit. And I think the value that we was 236 is what's acceptable for this area. So you'll see in dry weather events, bacteria levels are well within that. And then for Bunganook and Wharton Point, you'll see that those jump up quite a bit. And that's what we're recognizing as a problem, an indicator of a potential problem. Next slide. So nitrogen, however,, is more of a year-round. We're not seeing those big spikes during rain events, and the streams generally sampled over the recommended level. And there's not a marine nitrogen standard, so we use the 0.32 milligrams per liter as the recommended threshold, which was previously decided on between scientists for eelgrass beds for their health. And because nitrogen stays high between those storms, managing stormwater alone won't really solve it. So it's more about a septic system, fertilizer use, land management, those all sort of feed into this and matter. Next slide, please. So different areas, different problems, as I've kind of alluded to. So Wharton Point had some of the highest nutrient, high nitrogen, high bacteria after rain. Farms and development on sandy soil is what is pretty prevalent in this area. Rossmoor Road Stream, this had the highest modeled nitrogen per acre, a lot of sandy soils in that area, so it's able to carry that nitrogen into the groundwater easier. Bunganuck Stream had the highest bacteria after the rain, and then the direct drainage, sort of that bottom area where it starts to get into Freeport, had most sediment load and highest phosphorus loads. next slide so if the ocean were the main nitrogen source we would see the opposite pattern but because the you know nitrogen was higher at low and outgoing tides the largest storms was sampled in may like end beginning of end of may so these point to that both patterns point to the watershed. So I think we're what I'm trying to say here is that it's the problem is on the land not in the bay. Next slide please. So conditions in McCoy Bay generally bacteria were generally low as you saw it's under that threshold that we're worried about and that's due to dilution. So once it hits the, you know, once the nutrients hit the ocean water, it really turns it up and dilutes it quite a bit. Within the bay itself, nitrogen was elevated and it did rise after the rain and oxygen and pH do meet state standards, which is good. So yes, dilution does occur, but it doesn't remove the sources upstream, obviously. Okay. Next slide. Just to touch more on the oyster farm, this was important, and I've learned a lot about this from folks on the task force like David Page, who have really helped us understand what were the decades-old problems with shellfish die-offs in McCoy Bay itself. And so I think this is just from the report. I'm just going to read it because it's easier. But poor water quality is unlikely to be tied to the Muir Point Oyster Company farm the farm comparison was limited there were only two dates with paired farm and control data so that's also a limitation of the data higher algae readings at the farm may reflect calmer water around farm gear that collects drifting algae rather than pollution source but the report does not claim to have a proven cause the current study does not point to the farm as the primary cause or the primary solution So just a reminder that the data is limited, but what we do have, it would appear the farm is not impacting the bay more so than other things, based on especially the history of what we've seen happening within McCoy Bay over the last many decades. Okay, next slide. So then we modeled pre-development, current, and full build-out scenarios. scenarios and what we saw was that loads generally increase with development not every sub basin moves in the same direction you'll see the Rossmoor road it looks like it goes down that's just a margin of error it effectively stays the same and so the way that and I guess that's because development shifts water from flow to soils to surface runoff so just don't worry about that actually it's not worth our time it stays the same whereas like great goalie wharton point really you'll see like a 58 rise i think and that's driven largely by we modeled that there would be a lot more shoreline septic systems based on what's allowed within that area and then pre-development totals were similar to today in the model because sandy forested soils also deliver natural nitrogen and within the report it sort of explains this in you know table 10 if you want to go check it out but I think the biggest thing here is that when we look at modeled you know data obviously more development causes more problems but if we do smart development we have smart problems to solve okay next slide we're not going to get into the build-out too much today either I think this is something this we created this as a tool for the planning department as they are you know finishing up there as they finished up their comp plan and sort of thinking about where is development where does it make sense and how do we how do we look at that in an environmental standpoint and so with the McCoy Bay watershed just looking at what's allowed based on ordinances open land what's available you know 37% of that land is still buildable so there is a lot of opportunity to build out McCoy Bay and So it's something to think about as you guys develop ordinances and encourage growth. Next slide, please. So, again, using build-out and land-use planning, it can guide development review and really set those conservation priorities, I would say, are the two biggest assets of it.
[1:59:36] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, we'll leave it there. Next slide, please.
[1:59:43] Speaker P (unidentified): A planning tool, not a crystal ball. Same thing as I just said. Okay, next slide, please. so what can brunswick do today so i'm gonna provide a couple possible town actions these are not mandates there's nothing here that i'm saying you have to do by any means by accepting this plan it's just helpful to not have a plan that just is online and looks pretty i want it to be able to live and breathe and hopefully guide the town to do some fun projects so, you know, thinking about how is water quality impacted in stormwater capital projects I think is an important thing to consider. Mapping those priority drainage areas and outfalls and encouraging, when it says disconnecting roof and driveway runoff, thinking about the cars, washing cars. So, sure, wash your cars, but maybe do it on the grass or have it in an area where it's going to run off into a lawn or something, not straight into the stormwater drain and straight into our stream. So it's really just having those buffers, whether that's a rain garden below your gutters, whether it's, you know, a barrel, whether it's just creating more green space so it's not just water rushing down on impervious surface and into our streams. Next slide, please. Reducing nitrogen entering groundwater. water. So again, the report recommends that we inspect, maintain, and upgrade older septic systems, prioritize Rossmoor Road and the Wharton Point watersheds, focus on shallow ground water near tidal waters. And this is one that I would say folks here are already doing quite a great job at with the septic outreach. Obviously you heard already tonight, there's some great work going on there. And I know that Dan Devereaux and crew have developed that map of a lot of the septic systems, which that's a huge task. A lot of towns have no idea how many people are on septic, where the septic is, what the age of the infrastructure is. So that's great you guys have that. I think you're at a great point for that and just trying to help folks understand how to maintain their septic systems and what it means to maintain their septic systems and the importance of it. Next slide, please. Work with farms and other landowners. It doesn't need to be an onerous task. It doesn't need to be something that you're telling someone they need to do something different, but really creating those opportunities to have a partnership with large landowners, especially farmers, and bringing them funding through the USDA NRCS cost share program. So we do this a lot. We help, you know, there's a lot of recommendations in our watershed management plans that are very engineered solutions, right? There's also the most bang for your buck is talking to people and getting funding to farmers and making sure that they are utilizing the tools that they have available to them to reduce their pollutant load in our watersheds. Next slide, please. Protect wetlands for shoreline buffers. Again, you guys do this amazing. I remember one of my first days here, Steve Walker was telling me that Brunswick has like the most conserved land of any town in Maine. And I was like, it's so cool. And it is. I think it's amazing to think about how much green space is in this community, right? And I think you get, I think the town, that's an important aspect of the town. That's why people live here. And I know that you're all working on that and just trying to remember to keep those connected habitats and the importance of those. Next slide, please. So again, see it all connects. Reduce extra fertilizer and manage pet waste. So thinking about how you could enact sort of a new policy around that, or at least just educating more folks on pesticides and fertilizer, helping people understand, you know, what happens if they don't pick up their dog poop and why it all matters and how we can all be part of the solution. Next slide, please. Keep monitoring and measure your progress. I know it's important for especially folks at DEP to make sure that they know What you're working on and how you're staying, you know? You don't want to get in trouble with DEP over here because then you'll be sort of forced to do a lot of the cleanup whereas right now you could just Do it and stay ahead of the game and not have to have to do a full nine element when on some of these watersheds next slide So a phased approach sort of just putting all that together. So in the near term keep monitoring share stormwater tips coordinate with each other i know that's something every town is always working on right but making sure that everyone's sort of working together towards a shared goal that's the great thing about a plan that's a great thing about a climate action plan you know we have all these plans so let's put them together and work towards a good path forward medium term really like some stormwater retrofits would be really cool and some outreach with septic you know septic owners and farm landowners identify those wetland and buffer opportunities and review ordinances of course and then longer term just continuously tracking those results measure changes seek funding and revisit those priorities as you as you get more information and then I'll pass it over to the great David page
[2:05:13] Speaker D (unidentified): okay
[2:05:21] Speaker Q (unidentified): I'll be very brief I just wanted to say a few things really as a wrap-up to speak to the way in which this project was conducted which I think is very exemplary. As part of the project, initially the McQuay Bay Water Quality Task Force was formed. It was set up by the Town Council on June 5th in 2023 to develop, review, approve the final RFP for this project, participate in selecting the consulting firm, and finally to participate in an ongoing, as an ongoing participant review of the study with results presented to the town council at the end, which is what we're doing tonight. And I want to note that the membership, you know, consists of people who have worked together before. Jennifer Hicks, of course, Steve Weems, non-voting members of the task force, but participated very heavily as council representatives. Kristen Feindel, watershed management of the Water Quality Bureau at DEP. Heather Hunt, project manager, Cumberland County Soil and Water Conservation District, me, David Page, Professor of Chemistry, Emeritus, Bowdoin College, and finally Benjamin Twining, Senior Research Scientist at Bigelow Laboratories in Ocean Sciences. These four professional people have worked together before, for, and their areas of expertise covered all the bases, and so it was a very fortuitous choice of people. And before I say anything more, I just want to also acknowledge Ashley Charlson, and just as every orchestra needs a good conductor in order to be a good orchestra, Ashley was amazing as far as providing us with the planning officer's answer to Arturo Toscanini. She was great. I'd also like to acknowledge the fact that within this building there is a tremendous amount of talent. The town engineers participated very constructively, Dan Devereaux, members of the planning office, and it was very much a sort of a team effort across the board. And for me, it was a very satisfying experience. Next slide, please. As you've heard from Bina, the final report really reflects the constructive interaction between FB Environmental and the Mack White Bay Water Quality Task Force. And I think it's a good model for future projects of this sort, the way it was handled. And as Bina said, there are sources, episodic algal blooms as a result of nitrogen and bacteria entering the bay, incidents causing shellfish mortality and fecal bacteria contamination. And again, the report identifies the near, medium, and long-term measures to improve the health of the bay. And I think they're very much worth examining and following. And finally, the last slide, I said I'd keep it short, is the question, why Mackoy Bay? Bay. What is special about myquoit Bay that causes it to have these problems? Well, as Ably showed, that there is inputs of nutrients, particularly nitrogen and bacteria, and what's important to note is that the Bay itself is its own worst enemy because it's It's very shallow, it has very extensive mudflats at low tide, because if you look at the mouth of Mack White Bay, there's that little kind of island sticking out from the Freeport side, and then there's the tip of Muir Point on the Brunswick side, and that constrains the flow of water in and out of the bay. So the flushing time for Makhoi Pei has been estimated between 5 and 15 days, depending on rainfall. And that means a lot of the same water kind of sloshes in and out. And that's not a good thing in a shallow bay like Makhoi Pei, because it allows stuff to accumulate in the upper parts of the bay particularly. And so in addition to the narrow mouth, all these things make it prone to algal blooms, promoted by terrestrial runoff and warming temperatures. And so we at Bowdoin back in the day, I remember very well the 1988 incident where the bay went totally anoxic and basically killed everything in the bay. This was well before the oyster farms, by the way. And since then, there have been periodic algal blooms and anoxic events, again, relating to warming water and nutrient and bacterial inputs from watershed sources. And so you've had ongoing loss of eelgrass habitat, And the other thing to think about is that the continuing warming of bay waters and the hotter summers present an added risk factor for a bay that is prone to having anoxic events due to overgrowth of algae due to too many nutrients. And so we had incidents in, what, 2017, 2022 was the last big incident, which was after the oyster farm, but the others were before the oyster farm. So it's kind of a, not even in my mind, a question about the role of oyster culture and what happens in the inner part of the bay. And finally, I'll just close by saying that Middle Bay, if you look on the other side of Muir Point, has remained relatively healthy, mainly because it's well-circulated and well-flushed, whereas kind of the topology of Matcoit Bay makes it very difficult to avoid these incidents. So I'll thank you for your attention, and, again, thank you to Ashley and Bina for a very, well-conducted project.
[2:14:04] Speaker J (unidentified): Any questions for task force members or consultant or town staff?
[2:14:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Or councillors? Yes. Yep. All of the above? Yes. Yeah, are there any questions on the council for – Councillor Ecker?
[2:14:19] Speaker C (unidentified): I have a few to start with. First of all, it's a great report that was created by the consultants in the task force, so really a great piece of work. My questions around nitrogen go towards septic systems. And maybe a question for Ms. Skourdis, how accurate are the models that estimate how much nitrogen is transmitting into the water, into the soil making its way to the bay from a well-functioning septic system do we have a good level of comfort of what that is no I would say the models are
[2:15:00] Speaker P (unidentified): tricky do you want to speak to that at all I feel like you have a lot of thoughts on modeling no not to put you on the spot but hi
[2:15:13] Speaker R (unidentified): I'm Kristen Feindl with Maine DEP and I was on the task force so I work in watershed management I mean, being as right with models, it's a model. But there's been a lot of studies about septic systems and nitrogen that comes from them. So nitrogen moves with the water. So the phosphorus usually will stick with the sediment, so that usually doesn't move as much, but the nitrogen will move. Of course, it's all about what kind of soil it's in, so that's why sandy soils would have more of a risk of it moving. So I don't really have a better answer, but just a little more information.
[2:15:49] Speaker C (unidentified): So I guess part of the answer is it doesn't treat all the nitrogen, even if it's working well.
[2:15:58] Speaker R (unidentified): Yeah, so in general, I mean, and I don't know if there's any experts on septic systems here, but they're not designed to treat nitrogen. So generally they do not unless they are put in a way that has, you really need like an algal, bio-algal mat and vegetation, you know, certain kinds. You need to design it that way usually. they're they're built to get rid of the bacteria so right just to follow up there
[2:16:26] Speaker C (unidentified): with that is there any benefit and is there any kind of science-based approach to how often septic tanks should be a pumped or be inspected yeah i don't want to give details
[2:16:42] Speaker P (unidentified): at this moment because i don't have them right in front of me and i don't want to misspeak but i think providing that information town-wide will be really important, and yeah, we make a lot of septic system, healthy world fact sheets, so we can definitely share those with Ashley, and she'll distribute widely.
[2:17:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Councillor Tini. Yeah, so one thing I noticed, it's interesting, we heard from the Conservation Commission subcommittee working on watershed protection ordinance and the same night that this came to us. And I noticed that their ordinance goals include reducing the use of unneeded fertilizers. So that should be very helpful, I would think. I'm also really glad that we also are dealing with the grant for Brunswick Bay because that appears on the map that we got from the conservation commission folks to drain into equate pay my question is why is there no mention of pesticide in this because there's like a press herald article that's cited at the end which mentions pesticide in its relation to die offs i think was talking about it in terms of nitrogen but yeah is that a significant factor here or is it really like the fertilizer that is making these particular impacts yeah i guess it's more of a
[2:18:18] Speaker P (unidentified): scale and so i would say pesticides definitely have an impact to watersheds but i think in this watershed we were looking at the biggest land use types and that's why we focused more on
[2:18:29] Speaker B (unidentified): the fertilizer piece thank you and then i guess looking at some of the things that we can do about this i feel like one of the hopefully lowest hanging fruits would be the internal pieces of this so reaching out to brunswick high school about how they're taking care of their athletic fields seems like something we should probably try and do up front i guess anybody
[2:18:58] Speaker F (unidentified): else Yes, thank you very much for an excellent, piece of work. I can guarantee you that had nothing to do with my participation on the task force. I have two questions, I think. You may have already covered one, but in terms of the nitrogen loading as a problem, in a chronic perpetual problem, is there an allocation of that loading to septic systems in all other sources?
[2:19:42] Speaker P (unidentified): Is there an allocation of, like, can you pull out how much, like what percent is the septic's fault? No, but probably pretty high. But yeah, we didn't do any DNA tracking. Sorry, say that again. We didn't do any DNA tracking, so it could be, you know, the beavers the it could be all i guess that's bacteria but thinking about the nitrogen i think it's really i think it is highly i think septics are high highly probable problem but i don't think this study can point out that it's 60 septics causing this sorry all right well i
[2:20:22] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it would be useful to have some information about that, because it leads me to my second question, and that is that it kind of relates to that, because maintaining a septic system is a good practice, but if it's not really going to treat the nitrogen loading, there's not a lot that people can do about that aspect of the problem, which leads me into my second thing, which is that I think there's a huge amount of support. I know there's a huge amount of support for protecting our bays, in particular McCoy Bay. And at the same time, we're all offenders, at least those in the McCoy Bay watershed, of the problem to one degree or another. So is there a, do you have any recommendation of a best approach to getting people voluntarily to take action and clean up
[2:21:24] Speaker P (unidentified): their act and their impact on the watershed start with the kids i know that when you get students engaged they come home and tell their parents all about why it matters that they do the thing and i think when we i know that you know outreach and education sounds fluffy but it's really important and I think a lot of the times people don't know what they don't know and we assume it's out of neglect but often it's out of just ignorance and so I think really helping people get up to speed or out what the problems in their communities are and what their solutions are around it you know and also it all costs money so getting people to you know maintain their septic system might not be actually feasible and so really providing that support and making sure people know what they do need to do and what the benefits are of doing it and what resources are out there to support them to follow up.
[2:22:22] Speaker J (unidentified): Also, if I could offer a quick clarification, there was, when we were discussing the initial RFP and what aspects of sampling we wanted to incorporate, there was, the question was raised as far as whether or not we wanted to pursue DNA-specific sampling so as to discern between what was coming from animals like pets or beavers versus septic systems, i.e. people, but that would have exploded the cost of the study quite drastically, and so it was decided to not necessarily distinguish between those two, unfortunately.
[2:23:01] Speaker F (unidentified): Just one further follow-up. Can I interpret that broadly as a pitch for a really strong process of public education?
[2:23:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, thank you
[2:23:16] Speaker C (unidentified): Did counselor agree you have another question? I do just to follow up counselor we have stimulated another one from me And your answers about the septic systems and how much they may contribute versus other sources Help me understand how we got to the build out loadings that we showed on the screen before how was that derived
[2:23:43] Speaker P (unidentified): Great question. Let me see if I have the right answer. My very smart colleague did the build-out because she's a build-out queen. So let me just make sure I. So let me see the build-out. So what they did when they were looking at the build-out was they were really looking at if you have this parcel of land. oh you don't have to well i guess you could go to the slide 15 it really when we looked at the parcel land and we said okay this is these are all the areas that you could develop on today if we had if a developer came in and had all the money and wanted to develop on every area where there was allowed so it's all infill it's just wherever they could go and that's how they decided the build out so she put in all the ordinances all the setbacks and everything and then she put a little dot everywhere where there was a potential for a structure and then with that said okay which ones would be on sewer which ones would be on septic which ones you know what would the impacts be and then from there decided that 's how so it's really where were where was the most buildable area and you know the wharton point area had more area to build upon so that's where that number got bigger was that there was more buildable land available so they could develop that more so than they could Rossmoor Road area it's already sort of maxed out in terms of what could be included in development does that make sense it does a good map in the thing that I wish I had on here that shows all the little red dots and you'll see it almost looks like a blob of red in some of the areas and that's just because there's so many dots that could be structures whereas outside you'll see you know more dispersed dots because of, you know, setbacks and stream regulations, et cetera.
[2:25:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I guess what I'm getting towards, so each dot contributes so much in nitrogen is what the assumption has made. Correct. Okay. All right. Last question. You know, we just had one of the biggest die-offs of shellfish in the town's history, and, you know, direct cause, the phytoplankton. but would, the Bay have been more resilient, from, that die off if, there were less nitrogen or other stuff going into the Bay?
[2:26:23] Speaker P (unidentified): More resilient? Yes. would it still occur? Probably. It's just at, what level would that occurrence be? Right. I think if we can do everything we can do to decrease our vulnerabilities, but I think at the end of the day, as David Page eloquently stated, it's a shallow area and it takes a long time for that water to flush out. We've got to live and we've got to flush our toilets. There's only so much that we can do in that area, but what more can we?
[2:27:02] Speaker H (unidentified): Councilor Ellis. I am by no means a scientist, but just having listened on the coastal rivers, coastal waterways can be one of the other things, factors, it's hard to predict. Winds can affect, particularly with algal blooms, depending upon patterns and what have you. And so sometimes there's a convergence of conditions, atmospheric, that can drive these situations to happen. And not that, again, being smart and not dumping a lot of nitrogen into the watershed, that's not what I would be suggesting. but there's just a lot of multi-factors that go into this that create these the event that happened in 88 and then the event that happened this year and it would be so cool to be able to
[2:27:40] Speaker P (unidentified): sample in every type of event right whether it's high tide big storm low tide big storm big rate of it you know every type I just wish we could sample and everything just to sort of see how the bay reacts to different events and what that means and how we're influencing it but it's It's hard to capture it all. Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you.
[2:28:00] Speaker H (unidentified): No,, you're fine. And I also appreciate the presentation. It brought me back to learning about the nitrogen cycle, keeping aquariums for most of my life. So it was like, yeah, we need some anaerobic bacteria to throw out there is what we need, right?
[2:28:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I just have a question. I was on the committee, so I was privy to a lot of this information ahead of time. But I am interested in, I mean, I mean, FB Environmental provided some recommendations for the town. I guess now the ball is in our court. Being our environmental planner, Ashley, I wondered if you had initial thoughts about what this town should do with those recommendations or what you see happening now that we have this report in hand.
[2:28:49] Speaker J (unidentified): I mean, I was pretty involved in, you know, the conversations that took place with the task force and in between drafting the final report as well as the summary document that I believe was included in your packet and is also available outside if anyone is interested. But I think being a really kind of the table that established the short, medium, and long-term goals or based on, you know, recommended actions I think is a great place to start. We've essentially already started pursuing those actions. So I think we're well on our way and I think that involving relevant committees And I think you know making sure that we have those conversations in order to incorporate them into future CIP capital improvement plans Budgeting things of that nature, you know, I don't necessarily have an immediate answer right now but we essentially indirectly have already started pursuing the recommendations that are included here so I think that making sure we keep those lines of communication open with town staff I know that members of the task force I am essentially in regular communication with them on other projects anyway and they're always incredibly helpful and responsive to questions that we have. So I think that between the combination of the proposed implementation of those recommendations, I think we're essentially already well on our way. But I don't want to overstep and speak to what my director or town manager might have in terms of how they see this moving forward. But I wholeheartedly support the way in which it was laid out and
[2:30:42] Speaker A (unidentified): recommended. Great. I hope this is the beginning of the conversation, not the end, for sure, even though it was a three-year process. And I do want to say the reason why it took so long was because of the weather, which was interesting. We needed rain in order to do this properly. And so this was supposed to be done a year and a half ago. And we finally got the rain we needed and got the data that was required. So I appreciate the patience as well.
[2:31:12] Speaker J (unidentified): One thing that would help is a boat. If I could put in a wish list item for Christmas. A boat.
[2:31:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, yeah. So I'm going to, seeing that there's no other questions on the council, I'm going to open the floor up to the public comment. If you would like to speak, come on up to the podium and state your name and town, and you have three minutes. And I'll also take people from the Zoom world as well.
[2:31:40] Speaker S (unidentified): good evening steve walker 900 river road i certainly hope that you will accept this report as recommended by the brunswick conservation commission and more importantly i hope that through report acceptance the political will in this town will finally be moved to the cumulative weight of multiple comprehensive plans an open space plan a climate action plan, etc., all reflect in public sentiment spanning more than two decades to adopt more stringent land use controls before we're faced with even more bay closures, urban impaired stream expenses, stormwater flooding issues, let alone declines in local biodiversity and ecosystem functions. Two key recommendations of this report that Bina summarized very well. One, protect and restore wetlands and floodplain storage areas. And two, maintain and enhance forested riparian buffers along tributaries. Both of these can easily be addressed through no regrets, very little cost to the town, natural resource updates to our ordinance that have already been recommended in the reports I referenced further. and have been recommended since the early 2000s without action. First, change our stream protections from a fairly loose 75-foot structural setback to a 100-foot no-disturbance setback, and two, actually move the wetland ordinance voted on unanimously by this town council three years ago to go into effect as soon as possible. Both actions are based on sound science and long-standing guidance promoted by state resource agencies. Draft ordinance language has already been prepared, vetted, and ready for public consideration. Of course, we also need to prioritize other things like stronger rural forest land protections throughout town, but let's start a systematic reprioritization of local natural resource protections with these two and provide our extremely vulnerable aquatic resources with the safeguards they deserve and, again, are long overdue. We don't need to put this off for another drawn-out and costly zoning ordinance rewrite or recode process. The language is in place. The discussions have been in place. Please, let's act. Climate's about to kill us. We're going to see a lot more growth pressures with more people moving to Maine. So the time to implement these things is now. We shouldn't wait any longer. The last thing I want to say with 18 seconds left is aquaculture took a beating before this process, the McCoy Bay Aquaculture Projects. It's good. While this isn't a clean slate, it's great to have this information in hands showing that they are not the cause. But as our climate action plan the state climate action plans shows is part of the solution through natural filtration
[2:34:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else who want to speak?
[2:35:00] Speaker S (unidentified): Blaine Lund commercial shellfish harvester, Brunswick Not in full belief, I thought this study was supposed to be really impacted around the oyster farm You know, there was a lot of good information there. I didn't hear anything about core samples or scoping of the bottom of the health underneath the farm.
[2:35:20] Speaker C (unidentified): That's where a lot of the problems start. And
[2:35:26] Speaker S (unidentified): when you have an unhealthy bottom under an oyster farm, which there was no proof, nobody did scoping or sampling of the bottom from what I understand. If there's a lot of feces from the oysters at the bottom, smothering the bottom, it can create a high nitrogen load. We had no rain for these blooms. 21, it was 21 or 22, we had no rain. It wiped out Bunganut. This one, we had no rain, and it completely wiped out McQuaid Bay. They were saying like 20% could be left. Well, I surveyed it. I found six clams from McQuaid Bay to Bangana. There's no clams. It's basically gone, decimated. $7 million worth of clams. Rather, the farm might not be the culprit, but maybe the nitrogen load underneath of the high-density amount of oysters on top. So I would say that needs to be looked into. It's a low, not a lot of water, really constricted. five to 15 days i think i heard that it takes to flush out well if it's so constricted and mcquay bay is known for problems of this why would we constrict it more does anybody think that could be you know contribute to a problem or make these blooms worse that's it i hope that is looked at if there's any questions i mean i've been around digging and since I was 10 years old, so I've seen most of it. I had
[2:37:14] Speaker T (unidentified): a quick one. I'm Matthew Corbett and resident of Brunswick, and this is a great piece of work. It's fascinating and sobering. If I'm understanding it right, it seems like a properly maintained septic system still doesn't mitigate nitrogen input to the bay. So with the impending development in Brunswick, you know because we're the sixth or seventh fastest growing community in Maine can we make a case that new development should be should go on sewer and how much is a household on sewer more favorable than a household on septic that's probably not possible to get an exact number but it's got to be better I would assume that may be a hard thing to pull off to sort of limit development to areas that can go on sewer but it seems like septic even properly maintained septic systems they don't treat nitrogen so more development is going to be more nitrogen in the bay i would agree the bay the clams are the bay that i think there's a lot of problems you know it's coming from all directions so what can we do but it's true the shellfish are pretty much gone I live on the bay and they're pretty much gone that may be back in a decade or so but the future is concerning because the growth is so fast and a lot of it's gonna be on septic and I know so I think mr. Walker said it best I think his recommendations were spot-on thank you
[2:38:54] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah being if you want to go up with Blaine we just very quick this is we don't usually do this sorry I know
[2:39:14] Speaker S (unidentified): everyone wants to point out septics well I will say one thing since I'm a clammer digging polluted areas down towards Portland I've dug on the deprivation crew and you have the Portland in wastewater and then you have yarmouth and those are both closed only to being able to deporate dig they go through a filtering process it's some of the thickest clamming you'll ever see in your entire life which you probably don't want to hear that but that is the truth they like poop gotcha they're
[2:39:47] Speaker P (unidentified): also well flushed i did just want to we did check sediment we did some sediment sampling yeah so we checked the mud under the farm for the buildup of oyster waste and we had control sites and sites within the oyster farm and it actually measured lower in some instances than the comparison site so the data was interesting to say the least and I agree I think we should have more data I wish we could sample again like I was saying in every type of situation because I think you know runoff is one issue but there is you know it as David it's all connected right the five to fifteen days of flushing like let's get into day five, six, like let's look at what happens and then at day 15, like I wish we could really measure at every day of that and really understand what the problems are, but limited data set. Great.
[2:40:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Counselor? Anybody else? Yes, Counselor Ecker.
[2:40:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, is there more public comment?
[2:40:46] Speaker A (unidentified): It doesn't look like it, so I'll go ahead and close public comment if no one else is wanting to speak, and I'll bring it back to the council. Probably should do a motion before
[2:40:57] Speaker C (unidentified): we do discussion or did you have another question for I it's it's a comment I can leave it for when we have a discussion at the motion all right so I would like
[2:41:10] Speaker A (unidentified): to ask for a motion for this item anybody you want me to do it or Kim oh, thank you.
[2:41:25] Speaker N (unidentified): Sorry. I move to accept the McCoy Bay Nonprofit, non-profit, non-point source study and sunset the McCoy Bay Water Quality Task Force. Is there a second?
[2:41:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Councillor Perreault? I saw you there, MacDonald. I'll get you next time. Discussion? Councillor Ecker?
[2:41:54] Speaker C (unidentified): I definitely want to accept this report it's a it's a great report it's a great foundation for us to develop our action plan out of but what I'd like to do is not sunset the committee and I'll tell you why I'm thinking that and maybe there's another avenue but that's just my thought right now before this dream team breaks up I'd like to see more specifics to exactly what the ideas we should be working on more actionable items that are prioritized we have some good buckets up there and in the report part of the original charge and responsibilities was to brainstorm ways in which to use these study results and make recommendations to the council as how to address the noted non point source pollution problems in the study results. Clearly, nitrogen, it was right in the report, is the highest issue. It's described as chronically elevated in dry and wet weather conditions. We've heard tonight septic systems, amongst other things, don't treat nitrogen. It's just going to go up as we build out. And I would rather be in a space where we're more proactively effectively at least getting the ideas on the table as were expressed in some comments such as ordinance changes. There are septic systems that do treat nitrogen. They're available right here in Maine. As a matter of fact, one entity that sells them is based here in Brunswick. So it's more expensive than the standard septic system. but I would like to see just this not just disappear for a while I'd like to see us just get a little further we've got some great minds on this committee just another couple meetings to just get those brainstorm ideas out and then so we can we can have a process by which we can prioritize them and start acting on
[2:43:57] Speaker A (unidentified): them. Great. Counsel McDonald.
[2:44:03] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, thank you. Continuing, I guess, piggybacking a little bit on Counselor Ecker, I'm kind of a no and, I suppose. I think that, so we are getting ready to do the recode process for the comprehensive plan. This was the last piece that I was waiting for before bringing forward that charge. I've been talking to the manager right along, waiting for this task force to have its report and recommendations and it feels like in order to make this as part of like a comprehensive look as to everything that we're doing we'll kind of make trade-offs because that's ultimately what this is going to be is trade-offs and values on how we want to develop the different zoning i guess pieces of things to me this doesn't feel like it feels like the committee has you know let out their charge and that giving this to staff to Shepherd through the process of recode in the bigger scheme of things to allow us to kind of weigh all of those different I guess priorities of the town I think would be appropriate so like I don't think it should die here by any means and I do I think the committee I think the committee is a really great work and I do think that the you know town staff has the appropriate contacts of you folks to be able to pull you in as necessary but I personally think that it would make sense to sunset at this point to then carry that football into this next one, because really my goal is to bring forward that task force for the next meeting. So that way we can start getting those process going. But that's just, I suppose my two cents.
[2:45:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other thoughts, counselor Timmy?
[2:45:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. I mean, I think that 's a, it's an interesting idea. I wanted to mention that according again to this map, which is just so helpful to have right now. It looks as though almost the entire McCoy Bay watershed is in the rural district, or at least will be once the new comprehensive plan map comes into effect. And since we now have a rate of growth ordinance that limits our rural zone growth to like two dozen units across our entire rural area each year, that should dramatically reduce the number of, you know, homes on septic since a lot of the growth zone is served by sewer, which is encouraging, I think. but to the question of like do we need to keep this task force around i think the question is will we be able to tap these people's experience for the recode process or is that work going to go to other people who might not be as versed in those specific, specialties?
[2:47:11] Speaker A (unidentified): I, my thinking is that this task force has done what we've asked them to do. They've completed their tasks. I think that we've certainly have grounds to build, I mean, we have a, we have a conservation commission. We could give direction to the conservation commission to take this report and do something, you know, monitor or take some next steps based on their recommendations. But I'm really surprised, Councilor Ecker, that you would like to keep a committee going. This is a new one for me. It is, they're all good committees. But I do think that, I mean, this committee only met, I don't know, less than 10 times, and it was very focused. And these are people, these are pretty busy people who were really given specific tasks. I think, in my opinion, the next steps are really about what the town's going to be doing and how we're going to apply some of this information. It sounds like we have some momentum around a draft ordinance. It sounds like we have some conversation about, as a town, how do we help people upgrade their septic systems? I mean, it's money. money. Septitech creates wonderful septic systems that denitrify effluent. It's like buying a small house and putting one of these in. How do we work on a legislative level to really push? I'd like to put some energy around more of a state approach to addressing septic because we're definitely not the only town or the only part of Maine that has septic issues. So I almost think the ball's in our court as a town, as a council. We have the report and the recommendations, and maybe we need to sunset this committee, but we come back with a recommendation or a proposal or an agenda item for one of our coming meetings that say we want to institute, we want further action on one of these items of recommendation. That's where I stand on that.
[2:49:24] Speaker F (unidentified): Councilor Weems. Yes. I'd like to just pick up on that thread and I think push back on it a little bit. And that is, I do think we're teed up here to take some action. God knows after two decades we need it. And hopefully we will take it. But I don't think we have a binary choice here. As Vice Chair Hicks just pointed out, the task force only met a few times. They are definitely a powerful group of knowledgeable people. And when we bring forward something to implement best practices is on this front, think how good it would be to be able to ask this task force to meet and weigh in on whether they think the recommendations that have been put on the table are good ones or not and how they could be approved. And I think that this group as a group of individuals can of course testify, but as a body the task force would have a tremendous amount of credibility and be of great assistance to us in that process. So for that reason, I think we can and should press ahead with the formation of the recode process and all the other steps that we say we want to take and have these folks ready and able and willing to comment when the time comes on the progress we're making. So
[2:51:02] Speaker A (unidentified): is there an amendment that someone wants to make on this motion to reflect this?
[2:51:09] Speaker C (unidentified): I'll make the amendment, which would be to accept the report.
[2:51:16] Speaker A (unidentified): And eliminate the sunset? Yes. Do we have a second? So Councillor Weems seconds that. I'm going to...
[2:51:27] Speaker H (unidentified): Discussion? I'm not opposed to it. What I would say from hearing this, I would love to see an approach where there seems to be a lot of remediations that we've either talked about in the context of this report, or as former Councilor Walker had indicated, we talked about a decade or more ago and potentially had teed up ordinances. What I've always appreciated in tackling problems is if there was some intelligent body that was able to Pareto these things to tell us the things that will have the most impact on it, because there are probably hundreds of things that we could do and, you know, that aren't bad things. But what I think we really need to focus on, because it sounds like things aren't moving, is what are the top 10 things we can do right now that would have the greatest impact on that? because it takes time to work through these things. And so I'm not opposed to having this body, but for me, how we're going to tackle this, whether it's the McCoy Bay water quality or any other of the environmental challenges that we face in this town, I'd love to have somebody who knows what they're talking about helping us formulate that list of, here are the biggest ones that you should focus on now. And it's not to discredit ones that might be further down the list, but I'd like to tackle the big things now.
[2:52:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else with a comment? My comment is maybe asking the task force if they're willing to continue being a task force. So I don't know who would want to speak on behalf. I don't know if Planner Charleston wants to weigh
[2:53:08] Speaker J (unidentified): in. I do want to clarify that I appreciate the recommendation. This was not discussed in the last meeting. It is the understanding of task force members that once this report concluded, so would their involvement in this process. That being said, David Page is on a committee that I staff. He's on the Marybrook Watershed Committee. I'm in regular contact at least probably once a week with Kristen Feindel and Heather Hunt from Cumberland County Sewer and Water. So we already do have pretty consistent communication and I don't I understand the premise of the suggestion I don't think that the task force members would necessarily be opposed to perhaps an additional meeting but I'm not going to speak on behalf of them as far as their continued interest in staying on this task force or committee so if that is the prerogative of the council I do understand I would have to double check with them because it, again, was not discussed.
[2:54:16] Speaker A (unidentified): And basically what we're asking is, we're just saying we're going to accept the report and then we can probably negotiate what the task force does, or discuss what the task force does after that, if this motion passes. But I see, Councilor Anderson.
[2:54:32] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, I think I'm more in lines with what you were saying, Councilor Hicks, that the task force has seen through what they were asked to do, and these people are busy and we they've done what we've asked them to do so we should respect their time and their expertise and let them move on and but they are still available to us through staff and we have a Conservation Commission so we have other committees that we can hand this task
[2:55:08] Speaker B (unidentified): ask off to yeah and go ahead oh counselor timmy i tend to lean towards just doing the motion as originally proposed but i do think if we do go the approach of the amendment you know my preferred way of handling that would be it's the job of the chair to appoint people to the task force so i would think it would also make sense for the chair to reach out to the people on the task force between now and next meeting or whatever and get their feedback on whether the task force should continue kind of fleshing out that piece of the charge that counselor ecker quoted earlier because it sounds reasonable in the sense that you can interpret that in various ways and you could interpret it in a more expansive way saying that we should really break down these specific actions we can take but yeah getting that feedback would definitely be critical for because like you can't have a task force if the task force members aren't available to be on it you want to point out it was difficult to schedule our last
[2:56:25] Speaker J (unidentified): meeting it took it almost a month because of all of these experts incredibly packed schedules so it was not without struggle at times, understandably. Counselor Wilson.
[2:56:37] Speaker U (unidentified): Yeah, I will vote no against the amendment other than however I say it. I'm going to vote in favor of the original motion that includes the sunsetting. And then if something comes up in time, we know how to figure that out and find people again. And it's not like they're running away. way. So I most definitely will vote for the original motion, which I don't think we've
[2:57:08] Speaker A (unidentified): actually made yet, but anyhow. We did, and we're just working on the amendment right now, and then we'll get, yep. So, Councilor McDonnell. Oh, yeah, we did. I'm sorry. That's okay.
[2:57:22] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, I think just to echo other folks, the way that I see it is that if we have more staff time wrangling a committee compared to more staff time actually doing, implementing the committee recommendations and reaching out to the relevant experts. That's where I, guess, kind of place myself. I'm consistently, you know, aware of staff capacity and bandwidth and having them continue to wrangle a committee that, you know, has hypothetically, I guess, up to interpretation has completed their charge. It is, I feel like I'd rather just have our staff just start working on ways to implement things rather than, you know, wrangle a bunch of folks that are busy doing their lives who didn't expect to continue on after this point.
[2:58:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Councilor Weems? Yes, thank you. I think it's a red herring what Councilor McDonald just said. We've got a great report and thank you so much for that work. in that report, all we'd be doing tonight is not sunsetting the committee this evening. We can sunset the committee the next meeting if we feel like it. And we're not asking the staff to do anything different that focus on the implementation stuff. And if there's a reason to kill off the committee in a week or a month or whenever, ever, we kill it off, but in the meantime, we just let it go on and see if there's a role, and people rally around that idea. If we sunset it, 's gone forever as a group. Councillor Ecker.
[2:59:08] Speaker C (unidentified): So I'm not looking to put anyone in indentured servitude forever here. This report gets us 95% of the way there. I do not see this as a heavy lift. I also note that we have many committees that have never been formally sunsetted that are listed as inactive. So I just think that while we got this brainpower, even if the meeting isn't for two months, sure, it takes time for staff to arrange a meeting. But we're just going to the next level to, as listed out in the charge, to make a bunch of recommendations and prioritize them from their view. That's it. So after that, it's up to the staff and council to accept and implement those. So having been on many committees, I don't know that this is a heavy ask. Now, if some members can't serve, then the Appointments Committee could find others, like we do all the time. So I'd just like to see us get a little further with this so it's much easier to really take action when we need to instead of waiting another five years.
[3:00:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Are we ready to vote? Okay. Voting on the amendment. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Anderson. No. No. Councillor Perot? Yes. Councillor Timmy? No. Councillor Weems? Yes. I'm not keeping. Are you counting? Yep. Okay. Good. Councillor McDonald? No. Councillor Wilson? No. And the Vice Chair is a no.
[3:00:58] Speaker N (unidentified): Five to four, no.
[3:01:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Five to four. The amendment does not pass. We're back to our original motion to accept the McCoy Bay Nonpoint Source Study and sunset set the McCoy Bay water quality task force. Any other discussion on that motion? Okay. Yes. Are you saying that it did not pass? So the amendment did not pass. So we're back at voting on the original. Okay, that's fine. Okay, the original motion. And if there's no other discussion, we'll go ahead with a vote. So Councillor Ellis? Yes. Councillor Ecker? No. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Peralta. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. No. Councillor McDonald. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Yes. Councillor and the Vice Chair is a yes. So we're at a, is it five to two? Seven to two. Seven to two. The motion passes. So the wonderful report has been accepted and the task force has been sunsetted, but we may, we'll be talking more about this, you know, for a while. So thank you very much for all that and appreciate all that information. Okay, item number 126, the Town Council will consider adopting a resolution authorizing the transfer of $180,200 in previously appropriated general fund balance to fund the design and construction administration services and Environmental Services for Phase 1, Tier 1D of the Midcoast Athletic and Recreation Center, MARC project, and will take any appropriate action. I will ask the Economic and Community Development Director, Costello, to introduce this item.
[3:02:56] Speaker V (unidentified): Thank you. Sally Costello, Director of Economic and Community Development. Thank you, Chair Hicks. I am here following a CIP presentation that was last Monday about the next phase of the MARC, The Midcoast Athletic and Recreation Complex is the name of our 10-acre site that we are in the implementation of the master plan. I'm here tonight to follow up with you on a resolution, a town resolution, that would fund this next phase, which we're calling Tier 1D, for the design and construction administration. Next slide, please. these. So this is the master plan. I think you all remember this from last time, but just so the public can see it. We have made some progress on the site. We have, as I've mentioned, we're going into our fourth phase. The first one was the pickleball courts, the skate park, and the perimeter trail, and then the big meadow basin that is for our stormwater management. The second The second phase was the first playground for the young toddlers and the zero to two-year-old. I'm sorry, zero to five-year-old. And then this phase that we are almost complete, if you've been out there recently, we built two basketball courts and the sports lighting that lights all the existing facilities. Well, the basketball courts, the pickleball courts, and the skate park. so a significant part of the site is now available for people to come and use after hours so we can really have much more robust programming out there. And the lights have not been energized because we're setting the transformer this week, and so they should be, I think, ready to go. I think it was the 7th is the date that they will be actually active, but we may hold off until we have our groundbreaking of the new facilities to actually flip on the lights. So I'll leave that up to Sabrina Best, our deputy director here. And so this next, you can see that we have our basketball courts and our tennis courts, those were flipped, and that was so that we could not have to go forward with the next phase of the stormwater, which is where that parking lot is over to the west side there. But now we are looking at what would be the most useful needed facilities on the master plan. And what we are hearing from people is that the playground is really a big need. You know, some of these playgrounds have been demolished with other developments that have happened close by. And I know we are working through that process and bringing back a playground. but I think we can never have too many. The one that we have right now is really having a regional draw. People are coming from all over just for that playground, and we think the same thing is going to hold true with the playground element that we're proposing for this next phase. Next slide, please. So there are three components to this next phase that staff brought to the Rec Commission, and that was on October the 15th. We came, Sabrina and I, to the rec commission with three concepts that had the same three elements, the elements being the playground, which would have a splash pad, the playground being that blob that's the red blob. The circle there is the splash pad. What's in between that, number two there, is a shade structure, which we've we just built a shade structure for the that goes between the basketball courts the pickleball ports courts and the skate park really because we had the users tell us that this was something we really needed and then that we worked into our budget fundraise for that and we actually had the user group the pickleball main pickleball association actually donated 13 000 towards that structure. Subsequently, you know, our deputy director has said that, you know, we really need to be having shade structures for many of the elements there. So we worked that into the program and then this is the natural grass field. So some of the design considerations that we talked to the rec commission about were field orientations. So we had one of them that had, you know, an east-west. This is the recommended orientation for fields, according to CHA, who is our sports facility designer. We had separation of the elements. Some of the elements, mainly the splash pad and the playground, were kind of spread out with a walkway. There were three different configurations. This one actually had more green space than the others for just kind of sidelined play and watching what's going on in those fields because it will likely be very programmed with a lot of different activities for youth, different youth games. And then the shade structure, which I just mentioned. So this was, there were three, and this was the one that the rec commission believed was the best option for us to move forward with. Again, they all had the same elements. They just had sort of some different configurations. So I think there was a pretty high, and Sabrina can talk about this too, enthusiasm about not only the elements, because I think these elements are going to get really good use right away, and because the pool item is such a big one, even though that was a very important number one element in the mark that was rated in our community process, it's also a very expensive one. So having a water element here I think is a really positive thing for the master plan. Next slide, please. So as I mentioned, we went to what are the next steps for the – to have a 2027 project. It's really been the goal of staff to have something come forward in the master plan every construction season. So we've done our best, and it's been – fundraising has really been the limitation. But we've had a lot of grants that we've been able to get, And we've worked very well with stakeholders, and we've used some town funds like rec impact fees and others. So we've been able to, I think, accomplish a lot. But what we are thinking that we can – this new phase is actually a $1.4 million estimate, so that is a pretty hefty lift. But we are ongoing in our fundraising, and we think this is something we can achieve. so we went to the rec commission we did the cip presentation now we are here to talk about this advancing the design and of course that has a cost we're working with cha who's our sports designer we have a an estimate from them for their contract of 132 000 and we worked with our town manager to identify a source to pay them which she has in the resolution that's before you. It's coming from another project that did not move forward, $180,000. There was, I think, $180,000. Is that right? Because I wasn't sure if I saw $180,000 that we would like to move in this resolution for this project. $132,000 for the design and construction management. That takes us all the way through planning and development, getting it permitted, getting it bid and then actually the construction management of it so we 've been working very well with this team and so we're really confident they know the site very well and as you know it's a brownfield site so that's really important to understand that extra money that's in that 180 is really for us to have to hold out really kind of as a nest egg in case there is something we need to call in our environmental consultant about we have had a few things that we've We've added to some of our phases where we needed to bring our consultant out so we would have money to be able to carry over and use if there is something that we need to have tested or we need to have some of his consulting services on. So I mentioned the fundraising is ongoing. We feel really good about some of the potential sources out there and some stakeholders that we think are going to likely work with us. once we have our budgets and we are further along with our planning and design we would come back and we have our sources together then we would actually come back to have town council authorize this project because obviously we can't move forward until you authorize we need an ordinance to authorize any project over a million dollars so we'll come back to you again we think the planning and development process is going to be about four to five months the phase one was all the way through 65%, but some of these elements we're bringing up, they need to be brought from zero to 100. So that is why it's about a four- to five-month process. And then we think the bidding will be in March and April, and we'd like to have a construction season, you know, summer into the fall. So we think we can complete that by the fall. So next slide, please. And that just leads me to any questions you might have.
[3:12:46] Speaker A (unidentified): I'LL TAKE QUESTIONS FROM THE COUNCIL. COUNCILOR PERRAULT?
[3:12:51] Speaker G (unidentified): THIS IS FOR TOWN MANAGER. WHAT PROJECT DIDN'T GET DONE?
[3:13:04] Speaker E (unidentified): SO BACK IN 2023, I BELIEVE IT WAS, IT WAS THE STANWOOD McKean Street improvements. So it was $190,000 actually. Part of it did get done. The rapid flashing pedestrian beacon on McKean Street and those pedestrian improvements at the end of Stanwood on McKean, that did get done. The piece that met with resistance was I don't know if people know, but there's sort of a town right-of-way that goes sort of between parcels and it goes sort of from baudwell street it goes back between it and the idea was to make that into a proper multi-use path it is used sort of informally but the idea was to make it into a proper paved accessible multi-use path it met with serious resistance from the neighbors and it did not go forward and it has been enough years now that and i've been looking at this amount of money and i thought we need to just repurpose this at this point if that ever comes up again it'll go through its process and we'll refund it or fund it again so that's that's why i'm recommending in this case i haven't done this before typically if a project if there's is leftover money from something, the way the ordinance is always written is that it reverts to the general fund if it came from the general fund. And this did come from general fund balance in spring of 23.
[3:14:49] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, and then if that wasn't there, because I remember when the presentation was for this, or maybe I'm remembering something totally different, but the last time we talked about the next step in this was that was the development and design money not included in that or am i totally off base i'm just wondering why all of a sudden are we getting this and have had to take money out of the general fund like i don't remember
[3:15:29] Speaker V (unidentified): when we talked about it before that was so there's been different sources we've used rec impact fees for design before right so what i'm saying like what happened all of a sudden that we
[3:15:40] Speaker G (unidentified): need to do that i mean you it seems like you are ready to go with this and like why wasn't this already established before now that this is where these funds were going to come from so part of
[3:15:54] Speaker E (unidentified): that what's different about this particular phase 1d is that it was not already in the original design this is something of a pivot the next it right I mean you most of the other elements that you've seen have already been designed to 65 percent this one hasn't been really designed yet this is starting at zero and so this is what the rec parks and rec commission have sort of said we can't do an artificial turf field right now we'd rather do this and they've come up with this idea. So in most of the cases, there was already some design that had been paid for by previous councils from other sources. This one, there is no design funding. And what we do find is that it's really hard to raise money for design. You can raise money for construction, but actually getting grants and raising… For pre-development is very difficult. Yeah. Yeah. So, and that's why, I mean, we could also ask to use impact fees, but I think the REC Commission would like to save the REC impact fees for the actual construction.
[3:17:11] Speaker H (unidentified): Councillor Ellis. I'd like to ask, so I know that this, you mentioned the turf field, the synthetic turf field, that's been taken off the table with that. Is that where the difference, I think that I heard, taken off the table for now for 1D, the difference between what was in the capital improvement program which totaled i think to 5.6 million and i think you said it will be a 1.4 million dollar number okay so if i'm looking at that 1.4 with the old number all of that other stuff was tied to either impact fees donations grants or general obligation bonds so there was bonding there let me answer that so the 1.4 what
[3:17:51] Speaker V (unidentified): am i looking at so let me answer we actually were hoping we were thought we may come back and ask for even a bond like we put that in to say to finish off phase one this is what we need if we're going to do and what was left out of phase one was the primary thing was the turf field the turf field the tennis courts because we move the tennis courts and then we needed if whenever we do that quadrant we were going to have to do that big storm water management so that was a that was that number that we came to the cip to put in there to say this is this was what we would need to finish off this final part of the phase one of the mark so the impact the reason i'm
[3:18:29] Speaker H (unidentified): asking this is the so you mentioned you don't do this often and i'm just going to paint a hypothetical scenario theoretically that money could also flow through into next year's budget and be used to offset tax impact is that accurate no because what it would happen is it
[3:18:46] Speaker E (unidentified): would go back to general fund balance and be unassigned general fund balance and there is there's a policy around how that is used right so and you know you're going to hear on tomorrow about where that sits right now right so it isn't it isn't just it would it is authorized to go back
[3:19:07] Speaker H (unidentified): into the general fund balance that's that's what councils authorize and so again part of the again notioning that i was doing with this there's no other funds that this could come from there's There's no other TIF funds or things that – but if it's not going to come back and, again, help our conversations in May be easier, then I'm not sure it's any different than a TIF carryover.
[3:19:30] Speaker E (unidentified): It's more similar to appropriating general fund balance for a capital project or a project like this. So this is the other thing you could do is do an emergency appropriation of general fund balance for this. But in this case, we talked to the town attorney, and because it has already been appropriated by the town and the council is committed to capital projects, the council has the authority to just transfer it from an existing capital project that isn't going to happen to another capital project.
[3:20:05] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, and I'm okay with the mechanics of being able to do it. It's just the choice. Like, if you were to have told me that we could use that $180,000 to lower property taxes by a quarter of a percent next year, that would be a consideration, right? It sounds like it's not, directly anyways. Not technically, no. Right. And in the original proposal for what was in the capital improvement plan, there was the $320,000 that was targeted on the larger number, $320,000 that was targeted for impact fees and $1 million that was targeted out of donations and grants. Those don't come out of that. that are we with the 1.4 million number are we expecting those to carry through as numbers
[3:20:43] Speaker V (unidentified): that's a whole different that's a whole different those are different elements but i will say that we have looked into we have a variety of sources i can't say what they are now but we're talking to stakeholders we have done very well in getting grants on this project for i mean the entire master plan we have used we have not gone to general fund we have used we have gotten lwcf grants twice we have you know we've worked with our stakeholders and we've raised money so okay
[3:21:09] Speaker W (unidentified): yeah thank you counselor
[3:21:13] Speaker B (unidentified): timmy yeah primarily i have process questions here so are you saying that like we can have because obviously this appropriation in the first place had a public hearing and the public weighed in on that appropriation within the context of what it was originally funding so like we can have a public hearing to authorize funding for something and then we can, without a public hearing, take those funds. And as long as it's like still a capital project, we can just spend them on something else without another public hearing.
[3:21:44] Speaker E (unidentified): So this was part of the capital improvement program, which had its public hearing. And then the council appropriated money for the first things in their project. Yes. And, well, this is what our legal counsel has told us, is that because it's unused, it isn't going to happen. It can just be a transfer. I will say this. We haven't done this before. I mean, it is new, and I did have to talk to her. But it was a source of funding that otherwise would go back to the general fund, and the council would then see it in the unassigned fund balance. but it was an opportunity to find some funding in a fairly short period of time so that this process could go forward so
[3:22:36] Speaker B (unidentified): i guess yeah the goal here is just expediency to not have to wait i guess what would it be like two or four more weeks to schedule a public hearing to, you know, pay for this out of unassigned fund balance, right? Like, if we weren't doing it through this unique process that we haven't done before.
[3:22:59] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, and it's difficult out of general fund balance because usually that needs to be an emergency if it's not part of the budget or the capital improvement. I mean, we could open the budget up again, which would be another public hearing.
[3:23:15] Speaker B (unidentified): so right it's yeah and then the other question this one actually relates to the project i guess is in general i'm much in more in favor of a natural turf field but also we know that the soil there on the landing is very contaminated and natural turf requires a lot of watering, has the impact of the equivalent of a lot more rain, so to speak, through that contaminated soil been looked at in terms of what that does to flush that into, I assume,
[3:23:58] Speaker V (unidentified): the water table there? We have had an environmental consultant with us for the entire time. They have looked at every phase and given us whatever we have to do that goes. And when we go through planning and development, we have to go through DEP, the Navy, and the EPA. So once this gets designed, we'll know exactly what has to go under that field. So I can't answer that question right now. But I'll tell you, like, for the turf field, that was a heavy water collection, right, for the turf field. I'm not sure what's required for the natural grass. We also are building the site up, like, four feet. We don't dig down. we've been doing avoiding and you know handling each one of these phases with extreme care and that's why we had it that was our first hire and the first money we spent was on our environmental consultant when we started our master plan so that we could you know because we're dealing with the brownfield site so you're not wrong to ask that question but I just can't answer exactly what will be because that's what we're moving into is the design so we know on the full phase one which has been designed up to 65 percent but these are other elements that
[3:25:01] Speaker B (unidentified): weren't in phase one yeah great just because i mean the things you mentioned are about like compliance with legal requirements and when all of that pfas not this leak but originally that was all totally legally compliant at the time so looking at the effects of something in a more general manner than just does this comply with current regulations i just so you know when
[3:25:26] Speaker V (unidentified): When we had the PFAS spill.
[3:25:28] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm talking about pre-spill, like when the military continues to use it for decades and decades.
[3:25:32] Speaker V (unidentified): We had the mark tested, and we had them come out and do sampling and everything around the air quality and stuff. So we have had that site. We've had some oversight after the spill on that. But thank you.
[3:25:48] Speaker G (unidentified): Councilor Perot. well just really quick in regards to when i know you had the like steps to move forward when was it that you were hoping to do it because i'm just wondering what budget is it currently in our budget are we going to wait until after july 1 to start the building of it that's i'm just curious like where are we because i know you said it was going to go out
[3:26:16] Speaker V (unidentified): We're hoping to bid it out in the first quarter of the year and then to start in the summer.
[3:26:23] Speaker G (unidentified): So July 1, so it would be in next year's budget?
[3:26:27] Speaker V (unidentified): Yeah, but we're going to hopefully raise, you know. Right,.
[3:26:30] Speaker G (unidentified): But still, would it fall under our capital improvement? I mean, we have to approve it, so where is it going to be?
[3:26:38] Speaker E (unidentified): So if the council approves this design tonight, it's going to go into the next draft of your capital improvement plan. The construction is still not approved, it's not funded, it's not anything. So I think probably by January we will have pulled together all of the funding sources, hopefully.
[3:27:01] Speaker V (unidentified): If we get started, we have a four- to five-month process for just getting through planning and developing.
[3:27:06] Speaker E (unidentified): So it is definitely still going to come before the council. Not everything falls into the capital improvement plan schedule. This one is outside a lot of the things because it wasn't part of the normal phase one mark. But it will certainly be talked about more during all these CIP workshops.
[3:27:29] Speaker V (unidentified): And I think I did have the slide that I mentioned how much the estimate is right now with the 1.4 for the CIP, yeah.
[3:27:39] Speaker H (unidentified): Councillor Ellis. I was just going to say if we were ready for a motion,
[3:27:43] Speaker S (unidentified): I'd make a motion. Yeah, go ahead.
[3:27:47] Speaker H (unidentified): I'd like to... I had it right here, and then it shifted on me. Hold on a second. I'd like a motion to adopt a resolution authorizing the transfer of $180,200 in previously appropriated general fund balance to fund the design and construction administration services and environmental services for Phase I-Tier 1D of the mid-coast athletic and recreation center mark project motion is made by councillor ellis
[3:28:18] Speaker A (unidentified): is there a second councillor ecker second sorry kathy that's all right i will get you guys any discussion
[3:28:30] Speaker F (unidentified): council reams yeah i'm i'll be voting in favor of this although a little bit reluctantly because of the process but i just want to note that there will be there will be some movement in the capital improvement program to bring in i think we discussed this at the last meeting on the cip workshop bring in some funding for the implementation of this phase from underdevelopment to recommended, which won't approve it because it would have to be voted on later when adopted. But I'm a little skeptical that given the scope of the improvements here, particularly the natural turf field, that 'll get lined up in time to fold into that process. So stay tuned for what actually is practical here you know as sources are looked for implementation of the project and I need
[3:29:37] Speaker A (unidentified): to say that I completely forgot to offer a public comment and I'm sorry about that so yeah I know do I need to pull back my motion all right so if there is any public comment I would love to have anybody come up to the podium him? No? And I don't see anybody on Zoom. Okay. I'm sorry about that. I'll get that next time. All right. So we're back to our discussion here on this motion. Anybody else? I'd like to say that I'm happy that the planning team, you know, the folks who have been involved, certainly led by director costello have had the opportunity to do pivoting i think the original plan was a good one but i think as we've gone along and i've been involved in this for the past three years getting feedback seeing how things look once they've been implemented and built and then realizing maybe the money's not where we need it and yet we still need to make progress and I'm really interested in seeing some of these elements being considered because like a water a splash park I think there's a real need for that so I do appreciate having that this opportunity to start moving the you know moving the ball in this design so I'm in favor of this and I actually think the mechanism for finding funding was clever I mean it is a capital project and it's transferring money from one place that we didn't want that we didn't have support and we're bringing it to a place where we do need it and i think you know maybe time will tell but it seems like it was money that we wanted a ca we that was voted to be a capital money for capital project and that's what this is and so like i said i'll support that anybody else okay. Are we ready for a vote? Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Peralta. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor McDonald. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Yes. And the Vice Chair is a yes. It's unanimous. Support, nine to zero. Thanks. Okay. Item 127. 2027, the Town Council will consider setting a public hearing for November 16th, 2026 to amend Appendix A, Zoning Ordinance of the Municipal Code of Ordinances, Chapter 4, Section 4.2.2, to allow the Planning Board to waive or modify the maximum impervious surface coverage requirement for municipal facilities and will take any appropriate action. I'll ask the Planning and Development Deputy Director, Dillaman, who is on Zoom, to introduce this item.
[3:32:48] Speaker X (unidentified): Hi, this is Jimmy Dilleman. Can everyone hear me? All right. Yes. Great. So I wish I could be there in person tonight, but I'll just keep my presentation brief and then I'm happy to answer any questions. And I'll just have a slideshow pulled up. Meanwhile. So tonight, staff are introducing proposed zoning amendments that would allow the planning board to waive or modify the maximum impervious surface coverage requirement for municipal facilities. When specific criteria are met and you can go to the second slide
[3:33:24] Speaker E (unidentified): So we aren't seeing the slides yet. Hold on
[3:33:33] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, we have them now great
[3:33:38] Speaker X (unidentified): So the proposed amendment would give the town more flexibility to improve existing municipal properties These facilities are often located in developed areas with public infrastructure But have limited space to accommodate operational needs Allowing greater flexibility at these sites would help the town make more effective use of its existing facilities as needs grow. As an example of why this is needed is the Brunswick Police Station, which is currently seeking to provide additional parking for department operations. But the site has reached the maximum impervious surface coverage allowed in the GR 6 district. district. In drafting these zoning amendments, staff incorporated some of the planning board's feedback so that instead of providing a broader exemption for municipal facilities, the impervious surface coverage requirement could only be waived or modified if the town engineer has submitted a written recommendation finding that stormwater impacts can be addressed or are adequately addressed. And two, the planning board determines based on an alternatives analysis submitted with the development application that no reasonable alternative would accommodate the intended municipal use or facility on the lot. So all other applicable development and environmental requirements would remain in effect and the town would remain responsible for addressing any stormwater impacts from any additional impervious surface, next slide. And so recently on October 13th, the planning board reviewed the proposed amendments for consistency with the town's comprehensive plan and found them to be consistent. The proposal supports the comprehensive plans vision of improving access to necessary public services and facilities. It also advances key policy area H, which encourages the town to maintain, improve to improve and plan for future municipal facilities. Allowing improvements to existing municipal sites rather than requiring acquisition or development of additional property directly supports this policy direction. The amendment is also consistent with key policy area A, which encourages directing development towards areas where infrastructure already exists and is specifically aligned with Action A5, which calls for refining dimensional standards within the growth area. Last slide. And so tonight, staff are seeking to introduce the proposed zoning changes to the council and are seeking to set a public hearing date for November 16th. With that, Julie and I are happy to answer any questions.
[3:36:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you for the presentation. Any questions? Councilor Ecker.
[3:36:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Deputy Director Dielman, how is this proposal different than the one that was in our packet two or three months ago? So
[3:37:01] Speaker X (unidentified): I believe the key difference is the criteria of having the two criteria, the one for having the town engineers signing off on that the stormwater impacts will be adequately addressed, and that the alternatives analysis is now a specific submission requirement from the town would need to provide that would need to be reviewed by the board to justify the need for modifying or waiving the requirement I
[3:37:44] Speaker W (unidentified): would just add to that too that the previous revision was more of a blanket approval it allowed the town to exceed that impervious surface limit without any info from the planning board.
[3:38:05] Speaker C (unidentified): A quick follow-up. So in this case, they don't have to approve it. They may approve it. Exactly. Okay, thanks.
[3:38:14] Speaker H (unidentified): Councillor Ellis. Can I ask, and this is hypothetical, if the police station wasn't where it's at and we were looking at that corner there for some sort of business development and a non-municipal building was looking for the same waiver can you walk me through what the process would be for that entity as versus what we're proposing here for the town and it could
[3:38:38] Speaker X (unidentified): be either jimmy or mr dealman yeah so i don't think a waiver would be possible this the idea with municipal facilities is it's such a much more infrequent type of land use and it's providing a public benefit and there's only you know limited number of sites that the town has available to provide you know to do its work that it's it would be a waiver only possible for municipal facilities so a
[3:39:15] Speaker H (unidentified): business would never there's no process by which they could go through to get this wave today if they wanted to okay i don't believe so no and just share my concern for that is trying to look at this from a metaphor perspective when legislators implemented law related to spam for example where you know the canned spam act you can't send unsolicited emails to people, they excluded themselves from that process. And I worry about where we're creating two sets of standards, one by which businesses would have to comply with and ones by which we would need to comply with. And I appreciate there's limited place to put things for the town, but that's similarly true for businesses that are trying to locate in advantageous places. And so I'm not sure how I'll vote on this, but I just wanted to share that I worry about creating two systems one for us and one for other people that just doesn't necessarily sit great with me I
[3:40:23] Speaker C (unidentified): do have a oh go ahead I'm sorry I think just another thing to
[3:40:27] Speaker X (unidentified): add is I think knowing that the town can provide that assurance that it can it can review and address any stormwater impacts resulting in an area in the future, and that's its charge to oversee the public infrastructure, etc. I think that's why we felt more comfortable with the exception being limited to that use.
[3:40:56] Speaker H (unidentified): Could a business not provide that same assurance?
[3:41:01] Speaker X (unidentified): It could. It would just, it would be more, potentially there'd be greater number of uses and I mean there's I think that there's much more limited amount of municipal facilities that operate so we didn't we wanted to just keep it to that one my
[3:41:27] Speaker A (unidentified): my thinking is that public benefit I guess plays a little plays a role when it comes to municipal needs but I wonder if in the presentation during the hearing, you might be able to provide some specifics about what the approach you take to address stormwater, kind of the modifications you have to make to still adequately address stormwater impacts with this change, just to have a better understanding of what does that mean, that stormwater is going to be managed adequately, even though it's not complying with our you know it's getting a waiver from an ordinance that we have in place just for my clarification counselor anderson sorry if i already missed this somehow but
[3:42:24] Speaker N (unidentified): would this also be could this be addressed through contract zoning
[3:42:34] Speaker X (unidentified): it was it's a little more awkward for the town to pursue that because it would be essentially a contract with itself So I think our attorney had advised this as more of a neater way of approaching that. I think it's very, it's not very typical that towns will do contract zoning for their own sites.
[3:43:00] Speaker W (unidentified): Makes sense. That's what I was going to say. She was not thrilled with that idea. We proposed to that.
[3:43:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Councillor Teemee. me but if a business wanted to make such a trade-off and say we'll take care of any like second order you know negatives they could request contract zoning if in a certain circumstance the public could outweighed it so like there is still a way for businesses to get this form of exception in the right circumstances that right that's correct thank
[3:43:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Councillor Pearl.
[3:43:41] Speaker G (unidentified): I just, I think one way that we cause problems in town is by waivers and making exceptions. And there was a reason why we developed the impervious regulations. And I just very strongly feel like we all need to live with it like at some point the regulations and ordinances that we put up as a community either we need to rethink how we're doing everything or we need to follow the rules that we set for ourselves and so i just i have a problem with us deciding to make an exception for ourselves because we didn't do a good job when we planned our police station.
[3:44:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other questions? Go ahead, Councillor Ecker. A question.
[3:44:51] Speaker C (unidentified): In the case of the police station, which is why this is coming up, is there physically no way they could meet, or is it just a sacrifice of parking spaces, or what's the trade-off there?
[3:45:05] Speaker W (unidentified): They actually, when they went through development review originally, they were able to get a reduction in impervious surface for putting in pervious pavement. So they are technically beyond their maximum impervious, but they were allowed that reduction.
[3:45:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, but in terms of going further to meet the existing requirements, there's nothing, there's just physically no way they can do it? No. We're not giving up something like parking spaces or some other area to comply with the regulations?
[3:45:46] Speaker W (unidentified): Jay, Assistant Town Manager Astle will answer that question.
[3:45:54] Speaker Y (unidentified): Jay Astle, Assistant Town Manager. Correct. Correct, there's no way that they could develop the additional land that we purchased a year ago for this purpose to meet, as Director Ehrman said, they're already over their maximum, and we are looking to develop the full extent of what we just purchased. So that's not 100% because there's setbacks, But it's it's well over that I forget what it is a 50 or 60 percent whatever the maximum is yeah
[3:46:31] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm just trying to frame this a little bit They could come comply, but they won't be able to use it for the full purpose that they yeah the correct I had any idea how much they'd have to give up to do that
[3:46:42] Speaker Y (unidentified): Yeah, what it was it for that zone is it I want to say it's 60 is a 50 percent 50 percent
[3:46:49] Speaker C (unidentified): 50 percent has to be
[3:46:52] Speaker Y (unidentified): pervious remain pervious yeah okay and how much do they want to use like 90 percent of it okay all right but they're they're the whole purpose of this is they are they their parking situation is grossly inadequate most hours and days of the week if you've been over there i won't apologize for past decisions of placing the police station there on a parcel that size but it is what it is and the nature of the work that they do and the number of visitors that they have to the police station now warrants additional parking without question thanks
[3:47:32] Speaker U (unidentified): councillor wilson and then councillor teamy since this isn't a public hearing would you
[3:47:40] Speaker A (unidentified): like a motion i think we have one more question for the planners and then we'll get motion so counselor timi so
[3:47:52] Speaker B (unidentified): in the language along with the requirement that stormwater impacts can be adequately addressed and the alternatives analysis there like does that i'm trying to understand at the moment they have to have the pervious pavement to allow for the water to pass through it right would they still need to do that after this is passed or is there a way to make this like require those extra steps because that is a very like friendly way of working around those limitations that seems like it would be a missed opportunity if that wasn't also required when getting a waiver like this i
[3:48:46] Speaker X (unidentified): i think as part of the alternatives analysis they could the board the board would probably question the amount of impervious that is proposed and if there was an alternative to be able to keep some pervious, to the extent possible, keeping as much impervious surface on site, that would be relevant to their review of the alternatives analysis. So I think that's certainly within their purview to try to, you know, manage whatever that reduction is to their requirement.
[3:49:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. All right. looks like we don't have any other questions so council wilson would you like to make a motion
[3:49:41] Speaker U (unidentified): sure thanks i would like to motion to make a motion to set a public hearing for november 16 2026 to amend to amend appendix a which is zoning ordinance of the municipal code of ordinances Chapter 4, Section 4.2.2 to allow the Planning Board to waiver or modify the maximum impervious surface coverage requirements for municipal facilities. Motion is made by Councillor Wilson.
[3:50:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there a second? Councillor Ellis seconded. A discussion on this matter? And I should say that I got it right this time. There's no public comment when you're setting a hearing, so I didn't forget.
[3:50:25] Speaker H (unidentified): it. Councillor Ellis. I just want to say that I'm supporting moving this to a public hearing. It gives me more time to think about it and also to contemplate the concerns that I have. But I don't know how I will vote when it comes to the final.
[3:50:38] Speaker C (unidentified): And Councillor Ecker. Quickly, I'm in a similar camp and it just, it really, I have trouble with this because if we as a town and our engineering can certify that it will meet the quantity and quality standards, then why shouldn't anybody be able to do that? And we want to grow denser in the growth zone, so wouldn't we want to use more of that property if, in fact, we can meet the quality and quantity standards? So that's why I'm having a little trouble with this, because if we can do it, why can't anyone do it? So I'm going to vote for it to go to public hearing, but I don't know how I'm going to vote when we get to the end.
[3:51:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Councilor Timmy? Okay, Councilor Reams?
[3:51:28] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm going to join the parade here a bit. As a friend of mine used to say, I feel strongly about this both ways. But I do think there's an equity issue here. So my suggestion would be, I'll vote for setting a public hearing, but my suggestion would be to particularly tune up the language about what adequately managed means It seems kind of like not much of a standard. Does it mean zero environmental impact or impact, you know, work on that phrasing a little bit and also address the question about why not for anyone who has a good commercial project if it's got zero environmental impact and it's fair and it can be done, why not? So get a better answer for that one, other than there are just very few municipal facilities.
[3:52:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Councillor Timmy? Yeah, I don't know how I'll vote either, but I do support it going to a public hearing. And I also wanted to just say that I really appreciate the kind of change in structure of this from the previous draft that we saw, both in the additional, you know, rules here, but also from moving it from two separate footnotes into a single bullet point, which I think makes it much more understandable for most people.
[3:52:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Are we ready for a vote? Okay. Oh, I'm sorry. Councilor McDonald.
[3:53:03] Speaker O (unidentified): Donald. Yeah. thank you. Just, I guess hearing folks, I suppose trepidation or, cautiousness, I suppose in, the wake of this ordinance of, you know, let's move it forward to public hearing, but we still have questions. Would it be more prudent to do some type of workshop to better understand instead of going to public hearing and doing this process? I just figured out you use this as a pause point to ask the question.
[3:53:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Councilor Ecker? We've kind of been workshopping it a bit right here, I think, in some ways. Yes, you have. So staff hears our concerns, and this root concern that a couple of us have expressed, I think maybe there's a different way to handle this that also meets our comprehensive plan goals we want denser growth in the growth area if this is an artificial thing that we had in there from years ago to have so much pervious surface or impervious or less and if in fact there is a way to handle it and meet the quantity and quality standards without having to go that far then we should be looking at it for any development I think so maybe staff needs to ponder that question we can send it to public hearing but we're gonna roll the dice and
[3:54:34] Speaker A (unidentified): have a public hearing and see how that works out we may end up with a workshop after all
[3:54:39] Speaker H (unidentified): counselor ellis i was gonna say too for me that it's not the complexity of the issue that i'm struggling with because it's not all that complex and ask it's more the philosophical again, you know, what's right for the not right for the but right for me type of thing that I'm struggling with And I don't know as to where a workshop is gonna help me figure that out. Okay
[3:55:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Appreciate that. Okay and counselor parole. I am going to vote. No
[3:55:08] Speaker G (unidentified): Because I do not think that this is the right way for us to proceed with this either We change how we do it or The town lives within its own rules
[3:55:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Thank you. All right. Let's call a vote. Counselor Ellis. Yes. Counselor Ecker. Yes. Counselor Anderson. Yes. Counselor Peralta. No. Counselor Teamey. Yes. Counselor Weems. Yes. Counselor McDonald. Yes. Counselor Wilson. Yes. And the vice chair is a yes. So it's eight to one. This public hearing has been set for November 16th. Thank you. Item number 128, the Town Council will consider setting a public hearing for November 16th, 2026, to extend the data center moratorium and will take any appropriate action. I'll ask the Planning and Development Director, Erdman, to introduce the item.
[3:56:09] Speaker W (unidentified): Hi again. On June 1st of this year, the Town Council adopted a 180-day moratorium on the siting, permitting, construction, or operation of new and large or expanded data centers with an electrical capacity of one megawatt or greater. I'm here tonight because the end of November marks the expiration of the six-month moratorium. An extension will be necessary to provide the Town with additional time to evaluate the potential impacts of these facilities and consider appropriate regulations. In early August, the Town Council held a workshop to discuss data centers and potential approaches to regulating them. At that meeting, staff presented a preliminary draft of potential zoning regulations for the Council's initial consideration. The draft was intended to illustrate one possible regulatory framework and facilitate discussion of key policy questions including whether and what to what extent data centers should be allowed in Brunswick and what facility sizes if any may be appropriate. The town attorney had previously advised staff that pursuing a prohibition on large data centers would require an in-depth analysis of potential impacts of these facilities to support the town's approach. For this reason it was presented as an alternative option to requiring and contract zoning for large data center uses at the august workshop a majority of counselors favored an outright prohibition of major data centers rather than an approach focused on regulating their development and operation to date planning staff have reached out to several potential consultants but have not yet identified a professional available and willing to perform this analysis but we continue to work towards this end extending the existing moratorium would provide the town with additional time to identify and retain a qualified consultant to evaluate potential electrical grid impacts and other relevant infrastructure considerations as well as assess the potential environmental and community impacts associated with major data centers staff recommends that the town council schedule a public hearing for november 16th to consider extending the existing data center moratorium to allow sufficient time for the town to obtain the necessary technical expertise, evaluate potential impacts, and work with the town attorney to develop ordinance language for council consideration. And I will take any questions you might have.
[3:58:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Director Erdman.
[3:58:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Council Perot, do you guys have any idea, will the additional six months be enough? I mean, I just want to make sure. I know I'm not at all questioning your efforts at all. I just want to make sure that we don't run out of time before we have something in place. So what are your thoughts?
[3:59:05] Speaker W (unidentified): I really don't know. Another thing that we'll continue to do is check in with other communities and see where they're at with drafting their language, their ordinance language. I know there's at least 15, maybe 20 municipalities now that have moratoriums on data centers in Maine. So we're not the only ones working on this problem. So we will do our best to try to figure it out as efficiently as possible.
[3:59:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we know if the legislature will work on this? Or do we have anybody know of any of that?
[3:59:42] Speaker W (unidentified): So there's the main data center advisory council, but they are working on language for really large data centers. I think it's 20 megawatts or greater, which is certainly nothing that we want to see here. Okay, great.
[3:59:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Also, previously Representative Arford said that even if something were to come in, it would be next summer, you know, towards the end of their session at the earliest before anything. Because I'm not sure that they'd be able to bring back what they had passed at the end of the last session. And depending on who is elected tomorrow, whether or not that would be supported or vetoed again.
[4:00:29] Speaker H (unidentified): Other questions? Councillor Ellis. Again, I'm going to support this going to public hearing. I just have one question on this. So we have an existing data center in Brunswick, First Light, and this moratorium calls for one megawatt. has anyone reached out to them since we've enacted the moratorium to understand their actual capacity to ensure this isn't cutting them off from their existing service that they've already been providing for it
[4:01:00] Speaker W (unidentified): wouldn't cut that it wouldn't change anything from what they're providing right now if they were to expand okay then the moratorium would prevent them
[4:01:08] Speaker H (unidentified): from it so it doesn't they aren't gonna have to shut down tomorrow because we said okay that's what i want to make sure because great thank you not
[4:01:20] Speaker A (unidentified): seeing any other questions i'll we don't have we won't have public comment because we're setting a public hearing so i'm asking for our motion council mcdonald yeah
[4:01:34] Speaker O (unidentified): i moved that we set a public hearing for november 16th 2026 to extend the data center moratorium motion made by councillor mcdonald
[4:01:43] Speaker A (unidentified): and second by Councillor Wilson. I'm sorry. Any discussion? I know. Any discussion? Not seeing any, let's take a vote. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Perrault. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor McDonald.
[4:02:08] Speaker U (unidentified): Yes. Councillor Wilson. Most definitely yes.
[4:02:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Vice Chair is a yes. It's unanimous, 9-0 for setting the hearing. Item 129, the Town Council will consider appointments to the Town's boards and committees and will take any appropriate action. Councillor Anderson is the Chair of the Appointments Committee, and she has a report to offer.
[4:02:36] Speaker N (unidentified): So we met on Monday, October 13th, interviewed six individuals for five committees and our following recommendations are for the housing committee we recommend Celeste Yacowanis my apologies to a reappointment to a three-year to begin November 5th, 2026 and end November 6th, 2029. And to appoint Melissa Fosciato. Again, my apologies for her reappointment to a three-year term to begin November 5th, 2026 and to expire November 6th, 2029. To the personnel board, we recommend Russ Reed read to a reappointment to a three-year term to begin January 12th, 2027, and to expire January 12th, 2030. For the Zoning Board of Appeals, we are recommending Santiago Zadiza as an associate member for the balance of a three-year term to begin immediately and expire December 18th, 2029. And to the Shellfish Committee, We are recommending Audrey Kubler to a balance of a three-year term to begin immediately and expire May 1st, 2027. And then lastly, we have the Sustainability Committee with Austin Skeens to a three-year term to begin immediately and expire January 1st, 2030.
[4:04:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Are there any additional nominations? I will open the floor for public comment.
[4:04:44] Speaker S (unidentified): Blaine Lund, Shellfish Harvester. I've been on the committee before, and I feel like there's some weird vendetta against, for some reason, for you guys allowing me. Have you guys paid attention to who shows up to the commercial shellfish meetings? I'm the only harvester there. I come to every meeting. A lot of the input that you guys get that come up through the committee is from me. a lot a lot of the items i think we just had what did we just do for the ordinances i think the ordinance changes were due last meeting for the council a lot of those recommendations were from me so what is the vendetta of you guys allowing me back on the committee when i used to serve on it i think six years ago when i'm the only one involved in it i
[4:05:40] Speaker C (unidentified): would kind of like some answers tonight if possible we don't normally do a back and forth
[4:05:46] Speaker A (unidentified): during public comment so you made your comment and if we have members of the committee who wants to weigh in I'm happy I'm happy to have I mean it's just we won't be doing it back and forth that's fine okay well comments and then
[4:06:01] Speaker S (unidentified): we're just kind of strange that I'm the only harvester that comes to the meetings and out of everybody on the board besides dan i think i've been in this town longer i grew up doing this so to get no justification from anybody of why no one's allowing me on when there's two open seats and two people applied is a little strange and shoot me an email i guess to why I'm not allowed that'd be great is
[4:06:41] Speaker N (unidentified): your email over there or do we have your friend has my
[4:06:43] Speaker S (unidentified): email okay
[4:06:47] Speaker H (unidentified): thank you counselor Ellis what I would say to if you're willing to wait for another five minutes I would be willing to speak to you after the meeting anybody
[4:06:59] Speaker A (unidentified): want to any other public comment I don't see anybody on zoom so I'll close public comment and then we don't make a motion, we just do a vote on the slate, but if there is anybody who wants to make any comments before we do that, I'm happy to have them do it. Okay, so we'll go ahead and I'll call a vote on the slate for the nominations for committees. Councilor Ellis. Yes. Councilor Ecker. Yes. Councilor Anderson. Yes. Councilor Peralta. Yes. Councilor Temi. Yes. Councilor Weems. Yes, councillor McDonald. Yes
[4:07:43] Speaker U (unidentified): councillor Wilson yes, and
[4:07:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, and vice chair is a yes. So the slate is Slate is Approved accepted, okay Consent agenda approval of minutes new special amusement license and American Legion game of chance anybody have any questions or want to comment on that? Motion to approve the consent agenda. Councilor Ecker moves. And then the second is Councilor Anderson. Raise of hands for supporting the consent agenda. I see all of us with hands up. Great. And then I believe the next step is motion Just a motion to adjourn the meeting, anybody? Motion to adjourn the meeting. Okay, that's Ecker, and then seconded by Ellis. Raise your hand in support. Good night.