Brunswick Public Works Task Force Sets Site Selection Criteria and Screening Process
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): good afternoon and welcome to meeting number six of brunswick public works facility task force on this note remembers we have all current members present counselor anderson jackie cutford and counselor teeny and jamie after the chair and staff members present before we get into the agenda are there any adjustments to the agenda very one we'll launch right into well before we go to the reviewing the minutes i'll just say there is a we're going to have to end about 20 past five due to an executive session that's at 5 30 in this room so i think we'll be able to do that and still have community tonight for public comments so review of the minutes of our last meeting october 26th do i have a motion to approve motion by kelsey anderson seconded by concertini discussion i have a couple corrections i'd like to add to it first off i think the minute should have attached to it the document that was circulated draft to the site selection criteria so that would be good to have as part of the record and on page two under next steps last line WHERE IT SAYS COMPATIBILITY. IF YOU HAVE 100 POINTS, DO YOU ALLOCATE 5, 10 POINTS, OR IT SAYS 15 MINUTES. I THINK THAT'S SUPPOSED TO BE A MINUTE. THEN UNDER REVIEW SCHEDULE FOR UPCOMING MEETING MILESTONES, THE FIRST SENTENCE, OUR NEXT THREE MEETINGS, WE WILL FINALIZE, IT SHOULD SAY THE PRELIMINARY SITE SELECTION CRITERIA. as was identified we'll bring up in this agenda we're not finalizing it until after we get public feedback at the upcoming meeting in december those are the couple items i had does anyone have anything else so approve the units as amended all those in favor it's unanimous okay item number two review the site selection criteria so we started talking about this at the last meeting and we're on this document where it says draft number two of the site selection criteria and just thought we'd spend a little more time on this because one item was identified around number two that we don't have a and we probably can't land on a ideal acreage because we don't have the final scope requirements done for the project and that will probably be done i'm thinking meetings post december when we look at potential services that we might want to see add or have room for because our charge is supposed to look at both the base option and an option with extended services. So that's the introduction to that. I don't know if people have any other comments on that or any of the comments on the criteria in general.
[4:22] Speaker B (unidentified): So under the Tier 1 site screening, one part of that is like approximately immensely developed service areas and it has distance and travel time to key service areas travel time seems quite obviously as an
[4:44] Speaker C (unidentified): important thing but what
[4:49] Speaker B (unidentified): would be a situation where the distance matters and travel time is not equally like increase you know what i mean like if travel time is low and distance was high why would that matter you
[5:04] Speaker D (unidentified): know for instance when we're doing sidewalks and the majority of the sidewalks this area of town and the equipment we have they're back and forth a lot materials for racing or that sort of thing not something that can't be overcome with different alternatives as I would say but again just based on our current operations that's the way that it functions so
[5:30] Speaker A (unidentified): those little tractors don't go that fast on the highway certainly not I guess I see what you're
[5:37] Speaker B (unidentified): saying it's like a slower moving vehicle like the travel time would be based on like a car
[5:42] Speaker E (unidentified): I think situation yeah I mean well yes I guess I mean if you put a sidewalk doctor saying travel
[5:49] Speaker F (unidentified): on the sidewalk so the effects of traffic are somewhat alleviated although they don't always travel on the sidewalk when possible i understand but i think what you're like i can there's probably a sale for other vehicles though where like distance can be a little bit further but because there's zero traffic or like one stoplight that maybe that distance isn't such a big deal because there's no traffic but someplace else that distance is closer but traffic is a problem right that might be in greater hardship right yeah that might be right so it's the other
[6:27] Speaker B (unidentified): direction yeah but i think i can see the kind of edge case where that would be useful to still take into account distance itself i have one other part in tier one which was oh yes actually that's what Jamie already talked about with the kind of adequate you were talking about in
[6:49] Speaker A (unidentified): terms of tier two though right yeah so just to be clear we had a place on the agenda to talk about that two-tiered site selection process sorry yeah we're talking about that just these ten criteria to see if we're this may be a little confusing to some of the audience but we're talking about trying to finalize this as best we can on a preliminary basis we would finalize post the December 17th public meeting once we get feedback but on these criteria are there any other comments besides what was redlined there, maybe acreage.
[7:38] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, go ahead.
[7:40] Speaker F (unidentified): I'd say about that developable acreage, I think we do know, absent some of that more detailed information about square footage needs for public works now and future, and also some other potential uses. We know that there's a floor. yeah right and what's the floor the seven acres yeah i'd probably say it's higher than that like we know what seven acres gets us that's our existing site with maybe a little bit more maneuverability in it i think that exercise that we had done i don't know a year ago, of looking at other public works locations and similar communities and sizes. There's a range of sizes, but you can see there's a very definite floor for those. And not that 's, you know, let's just say it's 10 acres and you could go would end at eight maybe but at least you know sort of instructively you know it's not five acres you know that right it's not anything between zero and seven so like you would you could be able to i think still use that in a in a very helpful way yeah but right i mean you'd have to wait until you got somewhat down further down the process if there was a parcel that was maybe sitting right on that floor or close to it where you're like well we need to figure out what are the future public works needs what else might we want to co-locate or other services that public works might feasibly take on then you're going to really kind of look at maybe that site in particular to see you know is that still too low or it could be a bad but i think it's to me it's a very it's very much a tier one because you're going to get rid of a lot of stuff right it's based on like you know it's too low right the actual criteria would be
[9:47] Speaker A (unidentified): tier one yeah other people's other thoughts on this i have a few i just maybe clarify the word developable to me means something so we could we could find a 30 acre site and there's There's a high-value wetland going right through the middle of it and other setbacks. So when you do your quick analysis on it, you may be less than seven acres that are developable, you know, on that quick cut. So it's not looking for any site that is seven acres or more. It's looking for seven developable acres. And configuration of that seven acres can make a difference, too. You know, is it a perfect rectangle or is it like the parcel on Woodside Road that's being developed, you know, it's 300 feet wide and, you know, 1,200 feet long? That can make a difference. So I just want to give that context to what we might be thinking of there. And the third thing I'd say is all these things would be weighted. That's one of our tasks for today. day. So in the final site selection, perhaps there's a minimum. It's got to be. Maybe we agree to that, there's got to be a minimum. But something that has, you know, 10 developable acres versus eight would score higher on that criteria. So that's all clear to people and people agree with it then maybe i'll just turn back to staff and do we do we feel today that we could say it we can set a floor on that developable acres at that at that seven
[11:51] Speaker F (unidentified): i mean if you're going to look at so and maybe this would be worn out in a weighted system of scoring yeah possibly but if you're going to move to me you're not going to go move for another there has to be some appreciable benefit to moving in terms of size that doesn't mean that 's the only benefit but i don't think that you would go through the travel if it wasn't going to be a you know whenever that worthwhile increase in a great
[12:24] Speaker A (unidentified): yes that's a it's a great point so we could just maybe given the intro to this do we if the committee agrees maybe we just take that under advisement for right now since we haven't finished some of the work from the information needs and the scoping to know that 's and what the added options might be to really pick a number yet but staff council at this point is it's probably going to have to be we're going to look for sites with a minimum of 10 acres so it's if our lack of a better yeah do people generally agree with that we don't have to pick a hard number right now except just under advisement i think the one i'm thinking
[13:10] Speaker C (unidentified): about is that there has been a cut there have been a couple of people who brought up the possibility of multiple sites and that I know would be a lot to try to figure out but also like that I think would have to come before site selection that conversation if we're going to go down that road because then that would open up different
[13:39] Speaker E (unidentified): sites yeah what
[13:46] Speaker F (unidentified): I would offer that I think you do need to figure you to figure that out with some certainty because you're at you're looking for two five acre parcel that's a heck of a lot different than one ten acre I will say that we operate in front of position that it will be in a single site everybody would be located physically in the same location whatever small benefits might be achieved from separating some aspects of what public works does and having that in a satellite location I think are dwarfed by the logistical and personnel management issues that come with having two and costs of having two different flights
[14:43] Speaker A (unidentified): but it feels like we should have the conversation we should have a structured conversation just on that topic and maybe there's some community homework or staff homework to bring some both anecdotal but also some analytical data to that conversation in terms of those operational impacts I mean some of it's intuitive but perhaps there's some other data to bear on that discussion that would help the committee make a decision on whether or not we're looking at multiple sites or keeping that option on the table. Does that sound right? And I think we could I mean I'm just I'm just going to be later in the meeting but I kind of mapped out a little bit of the schedule for the rest of the year and that's probably a conversation we can have sooner rather than later before the december 17th meeting so anything else on
[15:50] Speaker F (unidentified): this or okay go ahead i'm sorry i know i knew what you were gonna ask and so can we talk about the neighborhood compatibility yes my gut says that there's no neighborhood that is compatible with this type of operation where i can't i can't think of one and i can't think of any resident that lives in the neighborhood that would say that yes our neighborhood is compatible with this type of abuse and so while i think it's an important thing to consider or look at i guess that isn't the answer like there is no neighborhood that's
[16:30] Speaker A (unidentified): about at all well wouldn't it pay around in waiting criteria i'm sorry go ahead two things
[16:36] Speaker B (unidentified): though i mean one spot that had been discussed at one point was back road farley road that long site which has certainly its drawbacks but there are no residences other than like across route one from it so arguably that would be like an example of a neighborhood that would be compatible because it's not a neighborhood but i also think it might just make sense to kind of look at it the way we do with site availability and say like relative neighborhood compatibility or relative impacts because what you're trying to do is just filter out you know like the really obvious ones like the worst of the you know the neighborhood with the worst impacts or the most
[17:28] Speaker F (unidentified): impact yeah i see that i would say like for that the old bath road site it isn't just residents right there's businesses around there that might think that okay well you know when martin's point used to where there's a daycare that they're now at the old martin's point yeah right and also there's a 200 something unit place across from medical center drive that's getting built that's across the tracks from it as well so I know you're saying I think there is sort of slight differences but I think if you talk to anybody in a potential neighborhood I think with 100% accuracy they would say like that's not compatible like this who's who 's going to raise their hand and say I want public works to come to my backyard that just find that as a resident i find it hard to imagine anybody saying that and if we do score it or wait it i think it would come through but if they're all going to be zeros in the neighborhood then what's the point of having i guess if it's right if everything is if there's no impact to the score
[18:41] Speaker E (unidentified): are there other comments on this topic i guess i would just add i mean this is not
[18:50] Speaker C (unidentified): an area of my expertise but i mean i think that's part of what zoning is for right too is like you know we're in we're in a particular situation on industry road where we have a residential zoning zone with a industrial zone like inside of that broader you know boundary line of that residential zone so there are also growth the growth there are so what is the correct term here is growth mixed use zones that can help us with that decision making as well
[19:31] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah i would i would just say that i'd be an advocate for keeping it on the list i think that it's an important topic i think how we wait it is important and then how it gets scored is important it gets scored on a relative basis you know some may get scored higher than others even if it's the difference between a zero and a one And I'd also, maybe it's good to remind ourselves that the site selection process we're going to talk about a little later in the agenda, you know, kind of this tiered process, and eventually getting a shortlist in sites, it's a tool, the matrix, to help us compare information consistently. but it doesn't replace decision making and judgment so there's got to be some judgment into like both what gets on that short list and then how it's scored and then how we interpret that so just because something may score marginally higher it may directionally inform us but it doesn't take the place of some judgment in terms of what the committee might recommend and i'm not saying we're going to go against that but that's part of part of the use of the tool it's just to really inform us in a quantifiable way but not an absolute way i
[21:16] Speaker G (unidentified): think it takes like part of the i think we should keep it because it takes part of the why we're here boxes i mean one of the statements. It's in the charge. It's in the charge. And one of the statements throughout the spring was that people felt like Industry Road was chosen without thought to the neighborhood. And I know from conversations with staff that 's not true. And so it might not have ended up in writing at some point in the in their presentations but i know the thought was there and so i think it's important that in this process we put it in writing because that's what people have consistently asked really
[22:08] Speaker A (unidentified): good points counselor anderson really good all right any other topic any other questions on that particular item are there other items that need further discussion or are we ready to approve this on a preliminary basis. No other comments? All right. Can I add one?
[22:37] Speaker F (unidentified): No, please do. Can we make them as bulleted items as opposed to numerical? It signals to me that it's in like a prioritized order, you know, one through 10, I see numbers. I feel like it tells me proximity to density of developed service areas is the top one of these 10 things. I know it's a small thing, but is there any danger with just making that vote? Unless it's intentional that they're...
[23:07] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not intentional, but my organizational reference would be numerical because it's easier to reference. And then if we need to disclaim at the top that they're unprioritized, we could do that.
[23:18] Speaker F (unidentified): Or what about using letters instead of numbers? Oh.
[23:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Once the wait-throw statuses are going to form the problem, right? Yeah.
[23:25] Speaker F (unidentified): Maybe, but if this document is a standalone document, it's easy for everyone to reference.
[23:31] Speaker B (unidentified): And the public is going to be looking at this when they come to the workshop. So I definitely think they're very useful to have that note because I really agree. I don't know, but I think a lot of people think so very easily and interpret it as prioritization.
[23:49] Speaker G (unidentified): Maybe you guys have to print letters and a note.
[23:57] Speaker A (unidentified): strong feelings about this i'm not against putting a disclaimer note at the top i just think it's easy for people when they call or write or stand up with a podium to say criteria number three i have these questions about or c whatever just reorder it alphabetically a hundred.
[24:19] Speaker G (unidentified): I think that's
[24:27] Speaker D (unidentified): the way to do it. I'll start coming up with different titles. I didn't hear you full term. I said read. I just said put the list in order alphabetically and then put your number next to it.
[24:42] Speaker F (unidentified): And say that it's listed alphabetically, not in prior.
[24:45] Speaker B (unidentified): make it like really obvious that it's not put in some specific order for any reason okay why don't
[24:54] Speaker A (unidentified): we do that we can do that i would just give a disclaimer and we will we will change the order based upon the first letter in the title
[25:09] Speaker C (unidentified): how's that okay can i ask one question before we finalize those preliminaries which is just that i guess i'm wondering how this dovetails with the two-tiered site selection process if i know we're discussing that later but in terms of process and sort of simplicity i guess or understandability to everybody here and in town like is this gonna be the one that we reflect on are we discussing whether or not we're taking on a two-tiered i guess i'm just not quite sure
[25:49] Speaker E (unidentified): about that piece like yeah i think you know what maybe
[25:55] Speaker A (unidentified): a good thing to do is to go right now go on to item number four that's on our agenda to talk a bit about that and come back to it i was imagining that this is this is for the second part of the food gear process and we'll find wise insights that's what i a short list so why don't we if people are good with this we could practice for the minute and go back to it and where we'll leave it is right at this moment as we've talked about adding a disclaimer about this non-priority unprioritized list and we'll we'll stream over this based upon the first letter first word per staff suggestion
[26:42] Speaker B (unidentified): probably pull the alphabet because people can do start with the letter c
[26:47] Speaker A (unidentified): okay and we'll just keep going until we get to another day let's let's let's let's park that for the moment let's pivot on to the two-tier approach so some homework was sent out around this and some references i want to give credit to Jackie on this, who did, I put forth one thing, but she came up with a better rendition of this, looking at some really good reference points in terms of how other communities or firms that specialize in public facilities, how they go about it. and so I thought we'd take a little time on the agenda to,, discuss that, and see if there's agreement of going, towards a two-tier, process. And that two-tier, just to be clear, would be first tier would be identifying all the possible sites based on some subset of these criteria. And the second would be a short list of ones that pass through that screening process. The first screen would also be on basically, at least this was put forth on a kind of pass-fail basis. Does it meet the criteria or not? So the first part of the process of screening would be, as I envision, it would partly be a GIS desk exercise looking at available parcels that meet a certain set of criteria. and then going through them you know such as acreage and or zoning i guess it's allowed in every zone is that what i heard before i believe if you look at the table municipal
[29:01] Speaker D (unidentified): services are pretty much maybe so yeah because then there might be water very i don't know
[29:08] Speaker F (unidentified): what's going on with the fire right on the table and that is that a rural natural resource
[29:12] Speaker E (unidentified): but essentially yeah
[29:20] Speaker D (unidentified): I don't know if this is the right question at this point which I doubt it is but we're talking about lots you could have a cluster of lots that could make up an appropriate size how are you going to put that right that's a perfect example and again maybe I'm too far in the lead right now on that I'm just in the mind we're already picturing how what we're going to do from our end in comparison to GIS. It's going to give her a set of criteria and say build the person out. That's why I don't know how you... Oh, we won't break that enough, but again, I think it's pretty cool. Let's see if we can break it down.
[30:03] Speaker A (unidentified): It's a really good question. Yeah,
[30:10] Speaker B (unidentified): it doesn't have to be a single parcel. It can be multiple. I mean, you could potentially even like, you know, across the street, depending on what how things were giving up or, I mean, you wouldn't want it to have somebody in between the two parts, but if it was like really close, it kind of takes a lot of the issues of the multi of like the, splitting it up, you know, they become less intense than they would be if it was like other sides of town or something.
[30:39] Speaker D (unidentified): I don't want to say that because that's what we, I mean that's what we went through this exercise one time already, which is if you get all these lots together, then they'd be a potential option. But then there was reasons why those lots would never be combined to have a deal. So yeah, that's why I think that's, that's, that's, that's just something to think about.
[31:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Well, maybe,, maybe we talk a little bit about this, the, what that screening criteria might be maybe that's a good discussion i mean i've been imagining it's a couple obvious ones might be lot size distance to what we call operational hot spots it's almost maybe a staff could probably weigh in heavily on this but i've imagined it's like a dumbbell in most Cook's Corner and downtown. And it's got to be within such a distance of, you know, that diagram. It's my wife. She always rings for me. And Jay, at the last meeting, you threw out the idea of some derivation of number one, two, four, five, and nine being, like, screening criteria. [Speaker G (unidentified): Which are?] Yeah, so on this sheet, and then I think to get the juices flowing, and jackie and i put together these two things for tier one tier two approach
[32:45] Speaker C (unidentified): and the ones that you've been sent j are in the in the tier one okay yeah little floss loss screening so the idea i think there is that there's not weights assigned to those because it's just like it's either it is yeah it is or it isn't yeah
[33:05] Speaker D (unidentified): I know it isn't in that tier one with the traffic and accessibility. It's number four on this sheet. It's not in tier one. Yeah, all right.
[33:17] Speaker C (unidentified): But it is the proximity. Is that covered under proximity to densely serviced areas like distance and travel time?
[33:25] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, that's how I read it. It's like the traffic and accessibility seem more like what public works impact would be. Right.
[33:34] Speaker C (unidentified): which is sort of then that is covered again on the back under tier two if you wanted to then kind of like that's not like a the impact of public works on traffic is not necessarily a make or break it's like a how big of a problem yeah or not is that going to be yes would that
[33:54] Speaker A (unidentified): make sense yeah i mean you steph can weigh in a bit more on this but what i just described before kind of this kind of dumbbell approach with the connecting between the universal sites if we're saying we're looking for you know that 10 acres let's just say you start and we get a map back that shows that and through you know native knowledge we know there's adjacent undeveloped lots or something like that would that help with what you're talking
[34:30] Speaker D (unidentified): about well that's kind of how we did it the first time here was we have a map that was made for us with the location of all our of basically the infrastructure that we're responsible for and where it was located and at that time in relation to where we're at which is why again which is why nine at the time ranked high from our evaluation was because it was the closest is what that we invited them to that cluster that we had on that so we have the semblance of what you're saying it's a little bit different than how you're describing it but I mean it's the basis of it's there so for us to do something around that isn't too difficult it's a bit of a weird
[35:20] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm imagining maybe I'm not close enough to it but I'm imagining it that first screen, if we can agree on that diagram of what the area is then it's probably not going to be 100 sites. It may not even be 30 sites. I don't know. Less than that. Yeah. And I don't know that we need that many criteria to do that first screen, like maybe the idea of some derivation of 1, 2, 5, and 9 covers it in
[36:12] Speaker C (unidentified): here as well. Oh yeah, well the ones in red are direct, are from the art list.
[36:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah, I wouldn't, I wouldn't take what we produced here as gospel, this was just, you know, to throw out there.
[36:37] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I think those are the ones that would make sense for a pass-fail.
[36:40] Speaker A (unidentified): For the kind of pass-fail. I think the bigger piece of work is what's the area we're looking at. What do we draw out as the area we're looking at? What's that radius or distance in that diagram that we're willing to look at? It
[37:11] Speaker F (unidentified): was probably going to be proximity, doesn't have to be existing utility there, but it has to be some distance to the stubbed end of sewer, water, reef bays, right? Because you can probably absorb some cost if sewer ended over there, but we want to build over here, right? You can make that connection, and that would make full difference in your cost, but it's It's a feasible distance, because I wasn't going to say what growth zone is, and that's kind of what growth zone is, but it isn't completely growth zone. It's probably some areas outside growth zone that you could probably, and I can't think of any off the top of my head, but where you could say, okay, well, we're 1,000 feet from the end of that sewer, because sewer had built out for the growth zone, and so now sewer is right at the edge of growth zone. We're at that growth zone, but maybe the numbers work financially. some of the other of the of the that first tier just trying to think like distance to the things matters but that's a little bit squishy you know kind of like ramona was saying earlier in terms of sometimes the distance isn't that bad as long as traffic it's okay right but, yeah, it seems like the utility might be the thing that's the firmest of the variables.
[38:50] Speaker A (unidentified): So I wonder if the thinking might be trying to cut down the pass-fails to a manageable number of criteria, derivation of those criteria. if it's a minimum acreage of 10 acres or staff has knowledge or we can see on the map i'm imagining the map comes back to the committee where we can see if there's adjacent lots or not to your point right and if we said it's it's either it's got to be some distance from where
[39:35] Speaker F (unidentified): do you want to drop in downtown you know remain pleasant yeah i think you look at that all of your infrastructure like that just did and whatever that trying to
[39:56] Speaker D (unidentified): overlap it with something that's already in existence with like the zoning stuff just because it kind of looks like that i mean it's basically, you know, it's almost to the Jordan Path Road intersection out to, you know, the on-ramp to 295 and down Main Street to Main Street-Mare Point-McCoy intersection. Yeah. I mean, over to Church Road and then over to Sills and Rutschel Road is really kind of the core.
[40:30] Speaker G (unidentified): Is it possible to get his screen up there?
[40:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, are you looking at a map?
[40:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Is it like a static map or did you, is it?
[40:38] Speaker D (unidentified): No, it's the PDF. It's in the, if you go to the, if you go to the task force folder, the task force, and then it must be the task force. It's not in there. PDF, PDPW context map.
[41:24] Speaker F (unidentified): So in the public works, maybe in the GAP information, back in the common, I'm looking
[42:31] Speaker A (unidentified): at someone else's file folder. go back to the
[42:42] Speaker D (unidentified): can you go back up
[42:44] Speaker F (unidentified): within public works or I mean on your department or the common
[42:48] Speaker D (unidentified): on the common drive public
[42:52] Speaker G (unidentified): works facility one public
[43:04] Speaker D (unidentified): works facility study task force information we're trying to consolidate all the stuff which we've been coming out of these different this
[43:42] Speaker C (unidentified): is what the gis person
[43:45] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah this is a lot earlier this is what we have them do from all our facility stuff this was recommended to date this visually but this basically shows up where all the blue lines of the storm drain systems decide you get the main street most of the sidewalk stuff as well if you zoom in it's it's kind of all well there's a little legend on the left so here what we got we're almost the crosswalks are sidewalks of a parking lot so that green street got its own orange because yes
[44:17] Speaker A (unidentified): so is there anything it doesn't show stuff on the landing mirror or show a portion of landing
[44:26] Speaker F (unidentified): Correct. No, we don't have anything like that for us now.
[44:31] Speaker D (unidentified): And that's 100% a fair discussion point.
[44:37] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, it gets us right back into the question of what are we aiming for? You know, like, are we trying to plan for what public works are going to have to be taking on, you know, 10, 15 years from now, 30 years from now? we don't know when that transfer will happen but we know that plan is for at some point those pieces of infrastructure to become town infrastructure yeah i guess i would offer up
[45:03] Speaker F (unidentified): it's going to be a while not because of a willingness but just the cost implications and the magnitude of the financial investment that would need to be made to deal with any of the roads in particular. And that doesn't just mean paving. That's stormwater infrastructure. It won't be one bell swoop for sure. And the required financial investment will likely need to be borne inviting several entities in partnership. It won't be just homeowners associations or the town or even the state that will likely require federal money. And if anybody has had experience trying to acquire federal money or anything for the size or magnitude of money that we would need, the prospect of that is that's not five years or ten years and you know maybe by thirty years we'll have taken over the majority of things there but it's not you know like little bits and pieces here and there over the next five or ten years aren't gonna tip the scale toward Cook's Corner and I guess with my point it's that's a lot
[46:33] Speaker A (unidentified): And what exactly is showing, okay, it's stormwater, streets, crosswalks, I guess, dots or street signs.
[46:45] Speaker F (unidentified): I mean, the bulk of that, Ryan, is in terms of repeated work requirements. Roads are everywhere, but there's a concentration of roads, obviously, in the growth area. And when I say roads, for them, that means patching roads, paving projects are larger. Those can happen anywhere and are more discrete projects, not the ongoing ones that require the time and effort of public works personnel. And then stormwater. So catch basins, that's repair, cleaning, any other type of maintenance, replacements.
[47:33] Speaker D (unidentified): And a majority of our hand work is for straight, or for painting, and it's also sidewalk, yeah, sidewalks. Sorry.
[47:41] Speaker G (unidentified): So in the topic of what we're trying to come up with is like, my understanding of looking at this map is the idea of coming up with a radius of where we would like public works facility to be located, correct? Yeah, so
[48:00] Speaker A (unidentified): So the initial screening, what's the screening? It doesn't say, we're not saying we're going to put it there, but for the initial screening, how broad do we want to look?
[48:10] Speaker G (unidentified): So if you were like, where do we drop the pen?
[48:14] Speaker A (unidentified): That was your question. Yeah, and I was imagining it. I was kind of imagining it was a, in my own mind, it was kind of a rectangle starting west of downtown. and going out the hips corner. That's what I was imagining because I was thinking about this mostly in terms of population too, not just what they work on.
[48:44] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, I don't think population really impacts public works so much as the infrastructure
[48:51] Speaker A (unidentified): supporting it. Yeah. Because there's plenty of population
[48:55] Speaker B (unidentified): that are relying on infrastructure that isn't making the health
[48:59] Speaker G (unidentified): right that's right that's right so my where i was going to go with that is like what if we said put the point drop the pin at bath road and main street and then do like a
[49:15] Speaker A (unidentified): whatever two mile radius what's the scale on that and that way you're
[49:21] Speaker G (unidentified): start to get if not completely get landing in there Yeah, but
[49:35] Speaker E (unidentified): it's true that we have any good sites.
[49:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, but the bridge is complete that we can acquire them.
[49:47] Speaker G (unidentified): I mean, there's an island. I see that we could I'm sure you can fit there. So that's my proposal.
[49:58] Speaker E (unidentified): Just the attitude conversation.
[49:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, Tim oil radius. And it's a little hard to tell what that would be. But it looks like it goes to Cook's corner.
[50:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think that actually, yeah, so 8,000 feet is probably, yeah, I would say that 's...
[50:12] Speaker G (unidentified): I don't know, maybe that's too big, maybe two miles.
[50:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, there's a big portion of it north that isn't us.
[50:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, we've got a half circle.
[50:27] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, if you tried to put the pin in the direct middle of where you would get that two-mile diameter circle it would basically be like the end of like fine or chamber run or something which was like just on the west side of the base where you get that little yeah like right there that's what like that would be the very middle of like a two mile diameter circle that encompasses like other than those little bits at
[50:58] Speaker A (unidentified): very bottom pretty much everything in balloon it looks a little smaller than the scale on the bottom of the page but i'm talking about radius well yeah so i said remote society so if you went from basically from sales to the entrance to the new the hanford
[51:22] Speaker B (unidentified): I guess the question is, are we waiting towards, you know, are we trying to encapsulate everything or are we waiting in towards where you have a density of things? I mean, I hear it says a densely developed service area at Switch.
[51:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. And again, this is for Tier 1, so it's not trying to be picking our final set.
[51:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Right. So on that note, like if we're doing that, like number, if we're thinking number one, we're basically looking at proximity to density-developed service areas, right? So then once we, I guess I would just say if we cast a broader net, then you deal with the waiting in the second round, right?
[52:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, and many things may fail in the first round.
[52:21] Speaker C (unidentified): So there's also, I mean, I guess that.
[52:27] Speaker A (unidentified): It goes back to a, not to make the discussion more difficult, but it goes back to the point raised earlier, too, about the idea of two summits. If there's a site downtown, resurfacing downtown, and then a larger site to encompass the majority of everything else and expansion someplace not right downtown. So it may help illuminate that discussion, too, if we're looking at sites that are – I guess one question. I know this could go down a rabbit hole. But when people go out to work, absent weather events, when they go out to work, do they go out for the day?
[53:19] Speaker D (unidentified): Typically. Some of the crews, depends on the...
[53:22] Speaker F (unidentified): The older days, we came back for a break, said goodbye.
[53:25] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. No, we made a different economy.
[53:29] Speaker A (unidentified): That's the most part of it, we've had a lot of people out on Lund Road, they were working
[53:34] Speaker D (unidentified): out there, the crew that was assigned out there, we left in the morning unless they had to come back for something, or run to get materials somewhere else and typically were gone for the day.
[53:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, and so like normal summer work, like maintaining storm drains or whatever, you're doing maintenance on them, do they go for the day?
[53:55] Speaker D (unidentified): That's a little different. It depends. I mean, one of the, you know, if the patient's bleeding drunk, it always comes back because it has to fill up with water at Public Works before it goes back out to do their, you know, periodically through the day depending on how much water they
[54:11] Speaker F (unidentified): use per day. Yeah, okay. And some of those, and this is project specific, but whoever was there at the tour for Public Works in the back where there's materials piles. So for some jobs, there are certain vehicles, not all vehicles, and not all personnel that are coming back to fill up Rancho jobs. I also just wanted to point this out because it seems obvious to me, but it might not be obvious to everybody, but there's like three walls that prohibit really efficient travel in Brunswick. The first one in the vertical north-south, I mean, there's sort of the main street, central artery, like going from one side to the other, it's hard to get through that wall, traffic, patterns, roads. The other one is Cook's Corner. There's a wall between outer East Brunswick and then sort of East Brunswick proper and coming back in town. So wall here, wall here, and then the Church Road sort of Pleasant Street to 95 Ramp is the western wall. And navigating those walls, each one of those walls is time consuming. Anybody knows this, right? If you're trying to drive around Brunswick. And I will say, not as a plug for where we are at McGinney Road, But one of the benefits of that site is you can navigate those walls, two of the walls anyway, fairly easily. You can get past the Main Street wall because you can get on to Mill Street and go, or Pleasant, to go to Western Brunswick. You can come down Federal or Main Street to go south. And you can hop on Route 1 and get to Cook's Corner and be there fairly quickly to navigate that wall. all i was just thinking as we're thinking about that two mile radius from a point dropped anywhere here is and we'll figure this out probably in the story you know as we dive down but just spatially in terms of town i think everybody knows this driving around but i just wanted to point it out that's a really critical thing that impact movement with within the town and when we talk about two sites one of the obvious candidates to be a standalone or if portion of the stand-alone is fueling. Fueling isn't just Public Works, right? It's everybody else. And again, I know that we'll kind of fish this out as we go down through this process, but just kind of struck me looking when you look at the physical representation of infrastructure and how easy to maneuver around is.
[57:08] Speaker A (unidentified): So, I'm kind of the mind to think broader on this first screening just to see what that turns up and i think there's limitations to going really far south anyhow due to watershed protections and stuff like that but i would like to see i guess something that's a mile to the to the west Well, a mile west of that point that was picked before the Bath Road Main Street intersection, and then going almost like a block out to Cook's Corner, you know, a rectangle out there, maybe as far as the hospital, just to see in that rectangle. angle and then I mean it's going to be pass fail on some of this stuff but we're going to have to really burrow into a couple of these criteria to understand and we're also going to have to layer on this two site potential option as well in the same thing but I can't imagine it's going to be a huge universe of suns that's going to show up there unless staff has some judgment that it's going to be a hunt, it's going to be hundreds
[58:39] Speaker D (unidentified): the only other lot you're going to pick up before going to the hospital is going to be that crooked property unless you're talking I'm not sure how long your rectangle is I'm not sure how wide your rectangle is from that standpoint
[58:53] Speaker A (unidentified): on school I was also looking down on the south side of the road too there as well towards the hospital But if we pick that intersection as one end, and we picked a mile west of downtown as the other end, and then come a mile south from that intersection, just square it off and look at that block, does that seem to make logical sense? Can you reiterate that? What's that mean? Can you reiterate those? So I would make, I would, the Androscoggin River isn't conforming to my linear mind, but that's the northern boundary. The western boundary would be a mile west of downtown, or at that point. We talked about the point of Bath Road and Main Street. And so there's a vertical line north-south going on that. That's the western edge. The southern edge is a mile south of that intersection. And it's east-west going all the way.
[1:00:17] Speaker G (unidentified): That's Pleasant Hill Road, by the way. What's that? I happen to know. It's Pleasant Hill Road.
[1:00:21] Speaker A (unidentified): And then it's going east to a north-south line that's at the entrance to the hospital.
[1:00:33] Speaker B (unidentified): i think by cutting it a mile to the west of the path road main street intersection we're limiting ourselves pretty heavily because that doesn't even get us to church road and to the snow dump i mean yeah like not even like not even close i guess like almost three miles to the snow dump so how far how far sorry not to be that was the road down but yeah like to get to the snow dump you'd probably be looking at like it's like two almost
[1:01:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Almost two miles. So two miles west and effectively two miles east.
[1:01:07] Speaker B (unidentified): I think that makes a lot more sense.
[1:01:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Which is where we're starting.
[1:01:12] Speaker B (unidentified): We're basically back to two miles west. Just not a circle.
[1:01:15] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not a circle. It's a square with a squiggly line on top. Is that? And is it two miles south as well? Probably. Might as well. Okay. Let's get two miles from that pinpoint. point do we have a do we have agreement on that look for sites for tier one do
[1:01:46] Speaker B (unidentified): you need a do we need a motion i would like to go a little bit further to the east with that circle i think because that's a square it's a rectangle okay fine whatever shape it is the eastmost boundary of that if you go two miles that is not quite to average it's just they're going to
[1:02:11] Speaker A (unidentified): the medical center drive yeah that's not a circle sure not a circle okay so
[1:02:18] Speaker E (unidentified): sorry i mean polygon i don't know because i don't have a scale on it
[1:02:24] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah to the medical center and then two miles to the west from that point
[1:02:31] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah it's about three miles okay so to medical center drive which is out here right and then you're saying two miles south takes you down to mccoy woods that's right into that right in the block do we want to go that far south i'm not getting two miles road is one mile from yeah i live on the corner oh sounds like it came this right so we're going we're going we're going to medical center drive we're going two miles west yeah right and so how far south do we go that's the interstate you're saying kim
[1:03:11] Speaker E (unidentified): you're how you're you're from here yeah so maybe it's only one and a half miles south then
[1:03:20] Speaker A (unidentified): is there a reason is there a reason not to go further i know we're we're going to get in the
[1:03:27] Speaker E (unidentified): mccoy watershed we'll be able to tease that out when we get to the point yeah that could get
[1:03:32] Speaker A (unidentified): screened right out okay so we'll go two miles south from here all right so it is it is a
[1:03:42] Speaker E (unidentified): Rectangle with the one before the blind Jackie go ahead no I was just drawing in my mind
[1:03:51] Speaker A (unidentified): okay so do we have agreement on that do we want to take a vote on that because that's the that's the rectangle or is it clear enough that 's what we're going to do I move that we accept the rectangle the non-rectangular rectangle a second on that second all those in favor okay and you know what it is right jake i got it you better read it
[1:04:15] Speaker E (unidentified): it's just the gis that would be like to put it down
[1:04:20] Speaker D (unidentified): ballpark what you just said we're talking basically from highland road back over to main street down to roughly middle bay road a little bit further and then over to
[1:04:31] Speaker A (unidentified): medical center drive yeah a big rectangle with a squiggly line on top that'll be easy all right okay so we got that done in that i want to watch the time here i've got number one down do we want to while we're on the set selection on tier one are we in general agreement with the studio process basically a screening step followed by a site selection with a more detailed site selection hospital screening stuff and site selection can you
[1:05:15] Speaker B (unidentified): clarify the difference between tier two and our scoring process yes so is it like it's like
[1:05:25] Speaker E (unidentified): an extra layer or filter before it gets to scoring sites? So various different things that we sent
[1:05:35] Speaker A (unidentified): out, I mean they call this different things, but they all kind of use the same kind of process. High-level screening, often on a pass-fail basis on some very simplistic criteria, often a desk exercise not a not doing site visits and then the ones that pass move on to the actual site selection and the waiting matrix okay so it's just literally like that yes that we're already talking about yeah the first level is pass fail based on I think generally where we're headed is for a criteria. We may have to tease those out just a little more. And those that pass, they check those boxes, then go on to this and the waiting criteria to be ranked. Does that make sense to everybody? So we're all in agreement with that. So I think the only thing missing at this point is the is what those criteria are for the screening and i think we've talked about four of them for the tier one screening or the tier one tier one screening versus there too with site selection and pass fail screening we talked about what is currently, one on this sheet, one, two, five, and nine. We decided to talk about leaving traffic and accessibility out for the time being.
[1:07:21] Speaker B (unidentified): I think those are the right numbers that has failed.
[1:07:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. The one thing that is on our first list that we haven't talked about yet is whether or not site availability should be on that pass-fail. I guess I don't know enough about – I think it hasn't been suggested yet, but should that be pass-fail?
[1:07:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, it actually has been suggested right in the criteria, because one criteria is what we thought would be available on reasonable terms without a hostile takeover, without eminent domain.
[1:08:00] Speaker C (unidentified): Right. So I guess my question is, that in the Tier 1? Like, is that a pass-fail or a weighted later-on consideration?
[1:08:11] Speaker A (unidentified): It's a good question. We may have some insights into that in screening, but I don't know that we'd want to go, if there's 30 sites, and go call them 30 people and ask them. I think we might want to wait for the second round.
[1:08:26] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I think that it would not be critical in Tier 1. one because you know i mean forget about the fire station but you go right back to the fire station and for whatever reason it's the term of that selection of lots purchased together yeah
[1:08:44] Speaker A (unidentified): and then mine was the best spot for the fire station does that take any taken by the minute
[1:08:49] Speaker D (unidentified): domain we didn't have to based on the way we could the way the negotiations went yeah i mean,
[1:08:59] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't know. But if you had rolled it off, that's like, these are properties that people own and are not currently putting on the market, then you would have missed that opportunity. And so the same thing could potentially happen here where, you know, and we would miss it if we put it in as a tier one filter.
[1:09:16] Speaker E (unidentified): Depending on how you crafted it, of course. Yeah, I think I'd
[1:09:22] Speaker A (unidentified): be inclined not to put it in tier one and just see what makes the short list
[1:09:27] Speaker F (unidentified): before we start talking to property owners about anything yeah it could be artificially limited that's f you based on conventional availability you'll end up with zero cents
[1:09:45] Speaker D (unidentified): i think the only thought that i would recommend and i don't know how you probably go further than just a suggestion but we said 10 acres what is our minimum piece of the pie to make up that 10 acres that we want to make because we can go evaluate 15 lots and say there's 10 acres right there and this perfect location but it's 15 that lots that are already developed so how do you yeah does that mean just looking at knowing how it's going to happen on the back end with the
[1:10:19] Speaker A (unidentified): So we're going to run out of time on this. It feels like we should have spent a little more time talking about it. I think if we're generally agreeing that those are the four criteria, maybe pick a vote on that. I think at the next meeting, the homework for the following meetings will be for people to flush out what are the criteria we're looking for, pass, fail, you know, like numbers Or, like Jay was saying earlier, utilities. Is it major utilities have to be within 1,000 feet, 750 feet? What's the number? We're going to have to come up with some real definitive criteria for these things. And maybe staff can come with their ideas at the next meeting as well. Everyone gets homework this time. you want to take a vote on establishing those four as the as the tier one site screening criteria that'll be what's on the sheet here one two five and nine Second? Second from Council Anderson. All those in favor? Great. Okay. So I'm going to leave it there. We will get, just so you know, there'll be homework on that. There will be also homework on the weighting criteria for student individuals on this sheet, which I will send out in the format that we approved with the disclaimer, to come up with how you weight these, using 100 points as a total. And at the next meeting, if I could ask staff to provide their perspective on what they
[1:12:19] Speaker D (unidentified): I only have one comment and I've been waiting for the right time to bring it up as far as this is concerned, but a lot of the reason why we're here is questions about data. So how do we make sure that this rating criteria is not subjective, that it's not, I think this one should you know we've all done these kind of exercises where you know and it is it's like sometimes it's yeah what was that number going to be so i mean that's my only question is how do we make the rating criteria be something that's very straightforward and doesn't doesn't take a lot of opinion into the into the mix that it's it's it's i don't want to say pass fail but somehow to make sure that it's very clear what that criteria is and how it's applied.
[1:13:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, I think it's a great comment, Ryan. I think that's probably part of University of J's homework to come back. I was imagining part of this might come together after the public meeting. We're not gonna finalize this criteria, but when we start getting the data from needs back, requests back from staff on some of this other stuff, that might help with that. okay we're gonna we're gonna stop there and take public comment we're at quarter past yep notice no one to give public comment could you give your name down residence and
[1:14:00] Speaker G (unidentified): my name is paul luther i'm from front of the way everything i've heard tonight indicates to me and everything that i've learned beforehand indicates to me that we can seriously consider leaving the public works facility at Interscreen Road. Before any consideration can be made about how much space we need, how much acreage, and the criteria involved in that, we have to determine exactly what the problem is. And that has not been ascertained. It has not been determined exactly what the problem is. The Public Works Department does not have an increasing need. We won't be taking over Brunnhilde. The number of roads are going to stay the same. The population has increased 8% in the last 30 years. We can expect similar numbers. numbers, there is this claim of public works increasing needs is a lie, a fallacy. They can remain at their present position while maintaining their operations, do the necessary, determine what the necessary upgrades and maintenances are, and perform them. what i'm recommending to this committee is you devote an entire meeting to determining how policy changes can make the public works department work at nine industry road the most contentious and consequential consideration that we have is the location of the fuel. That can be maintained at its current place. If we cannot maintain the public works integrity and the traffic flow with the current administration at public works, we need to find a new director who can. This is a policy issue, not an infrastructure issue. shoot. Proximity. Subtitle, Residential Proximity and Childhood Leukemia Risk. The 100-meter danger zone. Studies investigating residential proximity to fueling stations consistently show that children living within 100 meters of these sources face a significantly higher risk of developing in childhood cancers, particularly acute lymphoblastic leukemia, the most aggressive and infeasible. That's Powers Health, a regional leader in northern Indiana. This from the National Institutes of Health. Residential proximity to mixed petroleum fueling sources. Residential proximity to mixed petroleum fueling sources reveals a stark pattern for childhood leukemia, primarily driven by VOCs like benzene that evaporate during fuel handling. Proximity gradient. I think I read this last week and I have to read it to you again. This is the most critical part of the information that I have because this station 75 feet away indicates an extreme risk. When 100 yards is the bellwether, that's the perimeter which they have established. The closer the child lives to the fuel source, the higher the incidence rate. A meta-analysis examined in control station proximity found a combined relative risk of 1.66 for childhood of leukemia. This means the exposed group has a 66% greater chance of experiencing leukemia. Traffic-related air pollution. Systemic reviews confirm that postnatal residential traffic exposure, of which diesel particulate is a major component, is associated with a summary odds ratio of 1.53 for childhood leukemia. [Speaker C (unidentified): Answer] type, lung cancer, strength of evidence regarding diesel-petroleum proximity, very high strength of evidence, lung cancer. Childhood leukemia, including acute lymphoblastic leukemia and acute myoblastic, moderate to high strength of evidence, strong proximity gradient in localized residential studies. And that goes on to bladder and prostate cancer. The bottom line, while this is National Institutes of Health, while diesel fuel sources are an established cause of lung cancer due to particulate matter emissions. The most compelling data regarding proximity and leukemia points toward children living within 250 meters of active fuel hubs. We have to remember the gradient. We're talking about 75 feet here, people. stay awake. This risk is largely attributed to localized chemical super pale pipe emissions blended with volatile benzene vapors released during fuel distribution. Now, temperature inversions. Brunswick main experiences micro-scale temperature inversions along the Andeslagan the river very frequently occurring on an estimate estimated 100 feet to 200 nights per year north dakota state university temperature inversions track vehicle exhaust including diesel and gasoline fuels close to the ground loma linda university school of public
[1:21:09] Speaker A (unidentified): health mr wickham can you start wrapping up so maybe one other person who might like to speak I
[1:21:17] Speaker G (unidentified): can't read your minds, but you're going to have to start taking this data seriously. You're going to have to start contacting me and at least pretending. I'm sorry. You're going to have to show some interest in this. Or, I think that you look back on this and see that you have failed and that you were cowards. I don't know what your impetus is for ignoring this. I don't know what it is. It could be economic in some cases. Maybe it's just apathy. I hope that I never become jaded enough to disregard what the professionals are telling me from sources all over the world.
[1:22:33] Speaker E (unidentified): Is there any more questions? No. Okay.
[1:22:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Do I have a motion to adjourn?
[1:22:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Motion to adjourn. Second. All those in favor?