Brunswick Rivers Commission Reviews Algae Bloom and Dam Fish Kill
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): so that it will be able to be played. Hello, Kathy and Doug, are you online? Can you hear us?
[0:09] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, I can hear you.
[0:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, I can hear you.
[0:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Perfect, thank you. Marco's coming in a little bit late, so I'm going to start the meeting. And so it's 6.02. Anybody that will be watching this, welcome to the Rivers and Coastal Waters Commission. We have a relatively short agenda tonight. It's mostly updates and sort of people will be queuing us in on what's going on down on the Interscargill River. I did send out a memo on the committee update. So we don't have any minutes for tonight's meeting. meeting and I apologize we're a little behind the eight ball on this one just because of scheduling and timing the conflicts and room changes and meeting time so get ready for the shuffle this fall and into budget season and stuff like that you know that we'll be sort of like jockeying up and down so just be aware of that if happens that it doesn't get on the agenda Linda, please, by all means, walk upstairs to this room. Let's do a quick round of introductions. We'll start with those folks on line first. Kathy, then Doug.
[1:40] Speaker D (unidentified): It looks like they're on mute. Kathy's on mute.
[1:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Hello, I'm Doug Niven.
[1:49] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm a citizen alternate. And
[1:53] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm Kathy Wilson, a representative from the Town Council.
[1:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Perfect. Thanks.
[2:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Jeff Worships, a representative.
[2:03] Speaker F (unidentified): Rich Ellis, a Town Council representative.
[2:07] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm Sue Stablefor, I'm a citizen representative.
[2:10] Speaker G (unidentified): Rachel Spadafore, citizen representative.
[2:13] Speaker A (unidentified): And I'm Dan Devereaux, the Coastal Resource Chair. People are texting me, by the way. Welcome to the meeting. Thanks for coming. I'm sorry about not being down in our normal spot. Like I said, this is the time of year where they start to have a lot of balls in the air. And we're not a high-priority committee, so we get sort of bumped around. Chris just texted me, and he said, must have never gotten the link. He's listening, but he can't talk.
[3:03] Speaker B (unidentified): I will say that if you go to the town site you can't the it comes up the link but you can't click on it and that's if you go to the Brunswick town site because that's where I first tried before I found my email just it's there but you can't click on it just letting you know so the public would have a hard time.
[3:28] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, the public will only be available in recording, right? Is this a live meeting room?
[3:33] Speaker A (unidentified): No, this will only be available in recording. Chris, I just brought you on.
[3:38] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I think I'm in now. Can you hear me? Perfect.
[3:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, we're past the public comment. I don't see anybody, but we'll give them a second opportunity. If anybody out there, I don't see anybody in the room. skip down to the harbormaster's report and it's on you chris go doing
[4:04] Speaker E (unidentified): this from my phone is not the easiest thing the only thing i had is just a update on the floats coming out so the water street floats are coming out november 23rd and then we're taking the bollards out the following day on the 24th the mirror point floats tentative date for those are thursday november 12th and then sawyer park when the park closes december 1st those will be coming out and that's really all I have for right now.
[4:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Does anybody else have any questions for Chris? [Speaker B (unidentified): No thanks Chris.] We'll go down now to the Coastal Resource Manager's report. Real briefly I sent a bloom update along with the agenda item but what else the coastal resource office has been doing is we're we're still reeling from the bloom right now we're working with bigelow labs noah dmr down in harpswell applying for several different grant opportunities for rapid response grants to understand this type of phytoplankton. Also, looking back into the history of this, I found something that was really interesting. There was a bake hill in 1988 where most of McCoy Bay died. I think most of we all are aware. There's a study that's out on that. When I got to looking at the study, and then I got to bird dogging some of these names of different species of phytoplankton and stuff the 88 kill was blamed on oh gyrotium era rachel was probably which later on changed later on they that species had changed names a couple times and so what was interesting was i got to talk to a researcher who actually wrote some of that paper or knew somebody who wrote some of that paper and they said that this is likely the same species because everything is so it's almost identical down to the dates. So now if we know it's the same species, then we can look further, like why is this happening 40 years later in McCoy Bay, and why does this happen in McCoy in Middle Bay? Why are these areas susceptible? Does it have something to do with nutrient cycling? Does it have something to do with tidal fluctuations, water stratification, all of that different types of stuff? So that's what we're kind of trying to figure out, you know, why it's showed up here in those numbers again. It's been around in the water for, well, DMR says they identified it in 2017. And I'm saying, no, you didn't. It was identified in 1988. It's been around a long time. So, you know, how does a big bloom like that happen? What starts it? What conditions does it need? Things like that. more we can learn about it, the more opportunity we may have to mitigate those things.
[7:36] Speaker H (unidentified): Are you going for federal grant or state grants? Federal grant, rapid response grant, and then we're going for...
[7:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Are they still existing? I mean, is this through the DEP or Ocean Atmosphere?
[7:47] Speaker A (unidentified): National Ocean Atmosphere Administration. Well, things like this happen, and they have the opportunity to give good money to people who are going to tell them more information about the species. They do it to try to understand more about it.
[8:09] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean, a lot of stuff has gotten defunded, even in that agency.
[8:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, these aren't gigantic grants. There are $50,000 grants, $50,000 grants, things like that for rapid or slow and speed.
[8:24] Speaker H (unidentified): So we do slide under the radar.
[8:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I guess. I mean, I don't know where it is in terms of the, I think, due date is November 6th. We're also in partnership with the Heart School and Friends of Casco Bay to apply for a Casco Bay estuary grant that will expound upon the environmental monitoring that Friends are already doing with support from Friends of the Heart School. We started a phytoplankton monitoring network or system here locally in my office this year. It just so happened in April we started. So we started to not necessarily look for craniums, but just look at the assemblages, look at the communities, try to understand what we got here naturally, categorize them so when we see stuff on our annual monitoring that's out of character, we can kind of figure out, you know, what's going on in the water at a point where we can't see.
[9:32] Speaker G (unidentified): Go ahead. Just out of curiosity, who was the researcher that worked on that paper in 1988?
[9:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Chris Hiney and Ellen Hogg. I can share it if you want. Yeah,, I'm just curious. yeah and it was peter conway from bigelow who we've been working with that i reached out to and sent him the report and i'm like man everything in this report is almost spot on with what happened you know 20 26 40 years later he's like you know and this is what i found out and so he looked at it and he had to go to a researcher and call the researcher or sent an email to the researcher that actually wrote it because she said that the plating on the Sedgwick plate looked like great it looked like what used to be called gyrode and mickey motorway she goes it looked like that but there had never been any cases of that in the Gulf of Maine and in these waters. So they went to the more familiar species that is here all the time and used that. But in reality, it was probably Mickey Montoya that hurt in 1988. So we've been busy doing that. We were supposed to go out this week and start to do mortality surveys we did in McCoy Bay, we did mortality surveys in Thomas Point Beach, both the state and us, and it's about 40% mortality of the harvestable product. And so harvestable soft-shell clams, you can't say 40% mortality over the whole thing. It's just soft-shell clams seem to be hit the hardest, soft-shell clams in the room. So, but standard mortality over a harvestable crop is usually around 30% anyway, just across the board with harvest mortality, then you've got predation and things like that over the course of the year. So this does elevate it, but it doesn't elevate it in Townsend Point Beach, where I can assume that it's going to elevate it in McCoy Bay, because I've never seen anything like McCoy Bay, Townsend Point Beach, seen do this before, similar mortality events, but never in McCoy Bay. So I expect McCoy Bay to be a lot worse, which was started this week, but everybody got sick, so we're all inside trying to not. We should probably be outside, but we're going to probably start that next week. Or when the tides fall, we're losing light. It's this time of year to work on the water. It's very difficult fishing. We're going to roll back to class. It's going to be dark at 1 o'clock. But anyway, so that's pretty much the Coastal Resource Manager report. I did do one, and I'll do one for Marine Resources, and the Marine Resources meeting has been canceled. So first update is the Carinia-Mickey-Moya boom. I don't think we need to talk about that unless people have questions. I did send out that really brief memo. it's gone, we're not picking up any cell counts of it anymore, but it was impressive. I have never seen a bloom like that and that far out, you know, goes about past the three mile line, it was just amazing. It stretched down to Massachusetts, right? Yeah, from Cape Cod to Newfoundland and everything in between it's it's a really unique because we have unique geology here and i think with the right winds and the right dynamics and conditions i just think that our southerly facing bays like mccoy and middle bay if we have strong southwest winds which we did have in the month of september all the way up to the where we did a big wind analysis up until They'll probably have shipped late September to Northwest. But the whole time the boom was cooking offshore, it was the Southwest. We were just blowing it right up into the face of these bays. So whereas the neck, Harpswell Neck and the New Meadows are a little bit more protected. The opening's a little bit smaller. And some of the bays are not as south-facing there, and they're protected by other things. So, Mirrorpoint Bay out in front of Commissioner Bush's house didn't get hit as bad. So, a lot of our guys, you'll have noticed, a lot of the local guys have shifted their efforts over there. So, and we're trying to manage those with the other committee and how much effort is too much effort. And how do we deal with it going forward? So, but it's gone. But we don't know for how long, 40 years, 40 days, four hours, the bloom accelerates really quickly. That's some interesting data because we were able to track from the beginning of the bloom to the end of the bloom. So you can see it go, you know, it just blooms and then it dies and then all the after effects.
[15:03] Speaker C (unidentified): So how long do you think it would be until we go back to the before times? It was a very productive band, right?
[15:15] Speaker A (unidentified): McCoy was really productive. As a matter of fact, it's probably the most productive I've ever seen it. I think it hit all size classes in McCoy Bay. So it takes a soft show playing two and a half years to reach out of a size. And then you still have the algae mats that are laying on the mudflats that are now starting to break up. And it's not all for loss. I mean, not everything died in McCoy Bay, but I suspect that there's going to be significantly higher than 40%. We had 64,000 bushel earmark to be harvested out of McQuaid Bay this year and they so far the landings that and our local landings that isn't as accurate because we just implemented that program but around four or five thousand is the rest is gone so what I try to tell people with fishermen because now they'll shift over to Catlin Shore where they'll still dig similar amounts they won't have access to that puts more pressure on Catlin Shore, but when you have banner years like this in the fishing industry, the fishermen that are consistently professional, they count on banner years because what they do is they take that money and they put it aside so that it pays for when there's not banner years, because the fishing industry, it's not like farming, it's not like this or like this or however you want to make the bar go. It's this, and you really don't have a choice. So good, really good professional fishermen work here, count on those banner years to be able to push them through the lean years. So that's pretty much all I have on the boom. Unless you have any questions, any questions.
[17:14] Speaker F (unidentified): And say, if you're able to, if you're fortunate enough to study from the 80, and I'd be curious to see the reason. Yeah, absolutely. A quick thing on this, and you mentioned the timing, which is my thought from an economic perspective. There was an article in the 2020 Portland Press-Herald about that event that basically talked about it completely devastated the local soft-shell clan and co-op populations requiring decades of proactive seeding replenishment programs
[17:38] Speaker C (unidentified): and watershed management correctly.
[17:39] Speaker F (unidentified): So decades sounds like a big thing, so it'll be interesting to see what this particular incident's rebound will be if it's the same sort of time period to recoup or recover yeah well
[17:55] Speaker A (unidentified): we were looking at a really productive i mean i've been here for 30 plus years and i had never seen the bay populated like that before so getting back to where it was previously where you're looking at five to eight thousand bushels of harvestable product per year probably two or three four years but to get it back to like the bear of McCoy Bay you're looking at a longer-term effect probably a decade but it is healing and it's amazing how fast and if you go to the same spot every day low tide amazing how fast it heals people don't understand how much of water comes in and out of that bag all the time so she's she's mother nature is known for healing she's just not known for swiftness and doing it quickly you know based on human
[18:55] Speaker H (unidentified): state cut off work exactly but of course yeah that's very true
[19:02] Speaker A (unidentified): a thousand years maybe so we're working on it we'll continue to provide updates when we can i'll probably likely provide a mortality update to the town council at some point so they can understand we put in provisions into the shelfish ordinance that allow for exigent circumstances. When we have an event like this, we're going to be asking the town council to move this forward. When we have an event like this, it sort of freezes the program, freezes the license numbers until we can get a grip on what we have for standing versus using the evaluation that we've already completed while we were two-thirds done with the evaluation. So that's all I have on the Carinia update. The next item on the agenda, does anybody else online have anything on that bloom update, Doug?
[20:03] Speaker E (unidentified): No, I think you did a great job summarizing it, and that's wonderful.
[20:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Scary, but wonderful.
[20:09] Speaker A (unidentified): And one thing that we should recognize is that Doug and the Burtises over in the New Meadows both allowed access to their monitoring buoys, real-time monitoring buoys, so we're able to watch temperature, the floor fill, anything else move through the system. Really interesting to see that pop up. So thank you very much to the, most of those oyster farms now have these devices on them. So next item is the McCoy Bay water quality update. This is a study update. I attached that, I sent that out with a one page summary. Like I said, I wasn't involved in this because it did have parts of it did test the oyster company which I'm involved in so Ashley Charlson the environmental planner so sort of coordinated all that with FB environmental it took a long time to get it done because it hasn't been in a crowd the last couple years really I mean we haven't had these events that we needed to understand the flow the storm water flows into the and get good actually really good that so it took a couple years to get it done, I think, and it's a decent study. It doesn't really, there's another study in LaCroix Bay from the 1988 kill that spurred a nutrient study similar to this. Klein-Schmidt did it. Essentially, this is saying the same thing that study that it's really unique drainage system that whole western side and i've been preaching this for a long time it absorbs nutrients differently than say a river system or the new medics river or something just due to the geology the presumptive clay the sands the soils the creeks the elevation to the higher elevation to the lower elevation. So it's more about nutrients. It's a high nutrient bay. And being a high nutrient bay is why it is a high shellfishing bay, because it supports the phytoplankton assemblages that are needed. the problem is that when you have more nutrients than you do you know that filtration system or that a flux of fluctuations can handle and disperse that's when you do it and so that's completed go ahead sue i know you have a question yeah it
[23:10] Speaker D (unidentified): doesn't have to be right away but i broke some things to margo asked us you know or the things we wanted to talk about and I had written back to him but it isn't here so I just said you know what how can what are the actions permission can take based on the study and in particular you know the conservation committee's been working on at least thinking about doing a watershed protection act aka limiting fertilizers and perhaps road salt and considering what's contributing to this problem. So I guess I'm wondering, you know, how can we get behind this? It seems like this would be a wise thing to do, start educating our population even more about the use of fertilizers on lawns. I'm living in a community that is completely oblivious of any environmental concerns whatsoever, so ever which we've really tried some of us have really tried to address and gotten nowhere within the condo system right the board doesn't want to hear it the property manager doesn't want to hear it and so we're trying to look at a broader way to get people to wake up and say you know
[24:29] Speaker H (unidentified): we're contributing to this and it's got to stop so well i think where our support comes in as
[24:36] Speaker A (unidentified): just that as verbal support, you know, if and when the time comes and they look at the watershed planning more in terms of trying to develop it around a new code in, I can't remember, recode, that's what it's called. When they try to develop it around the recode, that's where I think we're really effective in terms of supporting those changes at the council level. Because, of course, Council is ultimately going to have to be the ones that adopt.
[25:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Right. Right. But why is nothing happening? I mean, the tariffs have already passed in Portland, South Portland, Yarmouth is in the stages of doing that, and we're sitting here with nothing apparent being done.
[25:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, we're just coming off. The climate action plan was done last year. The comp plan was done this year. Both of them have been approved.
[25:41] Speaker D (unidentified): And they all support taking action. Exactly.
[25:45] Speaker A (unidentified): And if you talk to the planning director, there is an effort to do a recode, and maybe Rich knows more about this than I do. But they, this, and it'll be done professionally and gone, the zoning codes will be gone through with a fine-tooth comb and take in some of those recommendations from the comp plan and climate action plan into account when those rules are developed.
[26:13] Speaker F (unidentified): That is the next step. But I know that the comp plan, quite frankly, is only, I know it's been worked on for forever, but it was only just recently adopted, like within months. And so what I've been hearing since that point is that is 100% the next step is the zoning changes that they're looking to then support what the findings in that work. So, and that's what, from what I understand of it, more of a technical process than it is, you know, deliberating, you know, what should the ordinance be. I think it's people in the planning office having to literally go through, like, here's all the setup in the town and what the zoning criteria are. It isn't so much people like me sitting at a table making decisions. I mean, that work's got to be done before it comes to us to approve it. Right.
[27:00] Speaker A (unidentified): and sometimes that work gets you get bogged down in that work because they part and parcel that stuff and i mean nothing's slow enough or nothing's fast enough i mean
[27:09] Speaker D (unidentified): it's not and i think people don't like it's gonna be people that don't like it i mean people that are making their money spreading fertilizers on lawns and doing traditional quote traditional lawn care are gonna have to you know i mean it's easy for me to say we gotta change but I understand that it's going to affect livelihoods, too. Right. And they'll see it from a really different perspective. And I get that.
[27:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. And I think that we have, with the Conservation Commission and the work that's been done prior, have built up a really solid base of all of those ordinances. Abby Sewell, who's on the Conservation Commission, is BERT. Those two are BERT. We're dogging all these documents, putting together some really good stuff that I've seen. Me too. And it's climbing up. It's climbing up. It'll get there eventually. But again, those public discussions are going to have to happen. And it's the same. This study right here supports both of those.
[28:19] Speaker D (unidentified): So I guess what I'm thinking is, you know, what can we do at this point in time except to point out just what you said? Just say, we'd like to bring it to your attention that the most recent water quality study just released supports what has already been discovered in the 100 major documents published, you know, within six months, the last six months. And, you know, can we get going here?
[28:47] Speaker F (unidentified): To be clear, so I can go back to my body and where I have leverage, your thoughts are specifically related to fertilizer ordinances in other towns and how other towns have implemented specific fertilizer ordinances?
[29:03] Speaker D (unidentified): They've been called pesticide ordinances in other towns. Portland, South Portland, Falmouth, Yermuth.
[29:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, but that's kind of like the umbrella term, right? It's pesticide, but it's also herbicide.
[29:15] Speaker H (unidentified): It's also a fertilizer, and it's on those septic systems,
[29:22] Speaker A (unidentified): and other things that put nutrients in the water outside of just fertilizers.
[29:28] Speaker D (unidentified): So the suggestion has come up that it be called a watershed protection ordinance because that's really what it is.
[29:35] Speaker G (unidentified): That's a much better name. Yeah.
[29:37] Speaker D (unidentified): So that's sort of been put forward as a better name. but what you know what do we need to do what kind of help is needed here to get going and the last i've heard is you know i'm not i don't want this to sound blameful i'm not blaming anybody i don't understand but i keep hearing from people on the conservation committee that oh ashley wants to do a survey we can't do anything until we do a survey why would we be doing another survey there were tons of public meetings and survey opportunities for both the big plans that were just adopted the climate action plan and the town comp plan and we've got tons of public input from both of those right so what's the deal about having to do a whole other survey that's about my pay grade
[30:29] Speaker A (unidentified): and who would answer that question probably julia or the director of planning who was directly in charge of the environmental planner in my office i think i think the reason is we don't want to put the horse before the cart in this situation if we can wrap this all up or is the cart before the horse Maybe we should want to put you. You want to put the horse? Right,. That's what you need to do. And so, and you need to do it, and it needs to be timed with the other changes. I mean, what they're going to put an RFP out for a consultant to come in, I believe, look at this RICO, because it involves.
[31:21] Speaker D (unidentified): So the word recode is code for?
[31:26] Speaker A (unidentified): A review of the total zoning ordinance.
[31:29] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. And what you can and can't do within it.
[31:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. It changes things. It catches things up to where they are today. The last one we did was in 2017, I think. And that was processed. It took almost a year to get that time because they go section by section. And those are the discussions. And I'm in alignment with you guys about thinking, And like, well, what about a separate watershed protection ordinance that's outside the zoning code? I offered that the last time when I tried to take the ball up the court and really got the public discussion going. Yeah. In nowhere. Because. That's not something that they didn't seem to want to do. but during the recode process, that stuff like that, we can bring up to say, shouldn't we pull this out aside separately of the zoning ordinance so that people that want to do something in the watershed that, and I'll just use this as an example, we'll build it back on the coastal islands. They can go there and they can see what they're allowed to do and what they're not allowed to do instead of going to the zoning ordinance which is a huge document. Right. I mean, we've worked on
[32:48] Speaker H (unidentified): trying to put all this together.
[32:49] Speaker D (unidentified): I remember all that hassle. I mean, I remember going to meetings about that and thinking, oh my god, I don't understand this.
[32:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. So, you know, I mean, those are the, that type of stuff needs to be
[32:59] Speaker D (unidentified): brought up during the recovery process and there's so there's no appetite for doing it separately i
[33:04] Speaker H (unidentified): think these other towns have done well there wasn't back then there may be now but back in there those two plans were they were developed we didn't have so what can we do what how do we
[33:13] Speaker A (unidentified): move this from i think you're doing exactly what you should be doing is continually bringing it up and putting it on top of on top of the pile and saying what can we do we need to move this forward and eventually it'll get there but it's not going to be with a snap of the fingers it's not going to be without this without public discussion more public discussion than what
[33:36] Speaker D (unidentified): happens in this room yeah so whose attention julie erdman okay that's fine so is it 's
[33:43] Speaker H (unidentified): appropriate for us as individuals sure i mean i mean i could certainly i mean yeah i mean i mean
[33:50] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, as long as you're just asking where things are in the process, I think that's a good idea to reach out to Julie. Okay. So we now have an assistant, Jimmy Dillman is the assistant manager.
[34:03] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I know Jimmy. He's a great guy.
[34:05] Speaker A (unidentified): She may push you down to Jimmy. I don't know. Depending on how much she's got going on. All right. But I would reach out to her and say, where are we going? What are we doing? Because in reality, I probably should have that information had I known that these questions would have been asked i would have found out like where are they in that process right now
[34:24] Speaker D (unidentified): well let's just bring for me is the publication of yet another study i mean how many studies are we going to have to have before we say listen you know let's not wreck one of our major assets and it's going to take everybody thinking about this and making some compromises about how we take care of our lawns and how we discharge our sewage and what we you know what runs into our roads you know what are we doing washing cars out in the middle of the roadway instead of using the car wash where the stuff goes through the sewer system you know i mean stuff like that no i totally hear you so it's gonna it's gonna take getting people on board here to understand this is This is major, and it impacts us all.
[35:12] Speaker A (unidentified): And if you keep moving it to the top of the pile like you have been, you and me and Dan have been doing, I think that I don't think there's anything wrong with that.
[35:21] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm sorry. I'm not saying anything. I'm making a point.
[35:23] Speaker F (unidentified): And the only thing that we've already put to studies, you want to make sure that the steps you're taking and the things that you are doing aren't actually having any causative impacts on what the problems are. right without the data to say like you've mentioned a couple of things like car washes is that what's causing the problem was there something that we're not contemplating that's actually a bigger driver problem that this is where you get i'm not yeah i don't think the car washes in commercially i'm saying i don't know without a study like what is the nature if i were to take all of the things that are creating toxic water in our water How would I parade those factors into finding those things that make up 80% of the problem
[36:06] Speaker C (unidentified): and then attacking those first to actually have maximum impact?
[36:10] Speaker F (unidentified): So a study is good to find that out if that's what the study is to do. The study is just to have somebody come in and tell you what you already know, that 's
[36:18] Speaker H (unidentified): a type of problem. Yeah, I think we can do that.
[36:21] Speaker G (unidentified): Maybe we're clear evidence of not just correlation, right? Yeah. Yeah.
[36:27] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah and they may not be able to get that
[36:30] Speaker G (unidentified): right, yes, that's a free
[36:32] Speaker F (unidentified): sometimes you gotta go with the best yeah
[36:36] Speaker A (unidentified): and a lot of the stuff you can find is free it's available online, it doesn't have to be pertinent to like the town of Brunswick, I mean there's studies on road salts, there's been studies on septic systems, there's been studies on pesticides and their impacts
[36:49] Speaker D (unidentified): well the fact is that what runs into our roads does not go through the sewer system, you know, it doesn't get treated it. So whatever we dump on our roads or runs off our roofs into the street goes right into the land and the water. It sure does.
[37:06] Speaker A (unidentified): It's the clay. Go sideways. You're right.
[37:11] Speaker H (unidentified): That's why I brought up washing cars.
[37:13] Speaker D (unidentified): I don't know the problem.
[37:16] Speaker A (unidentified): It could be a big problem because nowadays you have car cleaners that are coming like they do in other states come right to your house so i've already seen those systems set up in coastal yards where a guy has a van he sprays the car down with whatever that white stack is washes it off and he does it right there in the homeowner's driveway so things like that
[37:42] Speaker H (unidentified): we need to be in front of my neighbors doing so you know yeah so there's businesses now that are
[37:50] Speaker A (unidentified): starting off to do that and I mean if they're operating with environmentally friendly chemicals then fine but if they're but if it's not which is probably not if this is about so all of this new stuff we have to address and it will be done through RICO like there shouldn't be shooting ranges in the coastal protection zones shooting ranges and they've been approved in coastal protectionism so you've got accumulation all that lead that's being built up from expired ammo in a bank that's essentially leaching off into it so those types of things just we have to get in front of and hopefully we'll be able to have time to do that with the recode process and it set up meeting with Julie, she'll fill you, Julie or Jim, they'll fill you. Anything else on that study in particular? Just to note, cover this up, they didn't point, to a mere point, they did a lot of studying on the farm itself. They did identify that there are some areas where the algae is a little bit higher but it's likely because of the it's the number one there's there's a big filter there so it's you know and it's slowing down some of the current so and build up but as suspected most of the pollution that's coming into macquarie is driven by our what
[39:26] Speaker F (unidentified): through the watershed processes so
[39:29] Speaker C (unidentified): the study I'm sorry I haven't read it but the study indicated like you know percentages of all these pollutants here is of nitrogen
[39:38] Speaker A (unidentified): is a big percent no I don't think the study did that no it's not like a nitrogen cycling study it's more of like a watershed study yeah, Kleinschnett was more of a nutrient uptake, and I was just like, how's this happen in the bay type thing? And I'll share that too, but it's in a PDF, and that's a lot of pages. So I've got two things, 88, Bloom, 92. So if nobody has any other questions on McCoy Bay, any questions online? Nope. DeAndre Scoggin Fishkill has been in the news and Commissioner Bush he's part of the Free Leandro he's also part of Trout Unlimited and works closely with Chip Spees who is kind of the leader of Free Leandro I've seen a lot of press on it, I've also followed a lot of comments on the press and there's a lot of comments like well you know it happens it's a hydropower you know what are we going to do want to tear out that dam and so i think that you know free the andro might want to get out in front chip did a really good job of getting out in front saying that 's not our purpose isn't to try to eliminate the hydropower my purpose is to try to help the fish get around the hydropower and what's working right now it's not working so jeff go ahead and explain what
[41:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so I'm going to assume that we're going to pretty much notice the big picture here on the early morning of hours of October 10th on Saturday. Actually, on Friday, I could start my story there. On Friday, the people who run the dam at Savattis Lake notified Brookfield, who operates the dam here in Brunswick, saying they were going to do their seasonal annual drawdown it's not unusual to take the water level down in a lake in the fall to prepare you know for winter so this is something that happens and good on them for letting brookfield know that this is going to be happening because it's predicted it's been predictable that male lives and other There are critters living in an area where we force it downstream because there's more water coming down.
[42:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Is there a dam on the lake? Is that what happens? A dam release?
[42:27] Speaker C (unidentified): You can imagine that some of the stronger critters there are able to withstand that release, but the young of the year, alewives are this big. It looks like something came out of your sardine can. can't. So they don't have the ability to really do anything but go with the flow. And that's exactly what happened. They went with the flow. And when the flow came to the Brunswick Dam, so the dam operators, upon hearing that they were going to, they shut down the turbines until they didn't. And so one turbine remained running for four hours. Now, when a turbine is running, particularly for a fish running downstream, there's a lot of current that's forced into that turbine. It's a big suction. It's churning,, churning,. And the way that the dam is constructed, there is a downstream fish passage of the dam. Just between two of these turbines, it's so ridiculously designed. But there's actually nothing attracting tracking efficiently to the downstream passage when you've got those turbines going on. Years ago they took the turbines offline for some time and the downstream push passage worked perfectly because that's where the suction was if you will. So not so this time. And so the big question here is why did this one turbine get turned back on and remain on for four hours. If you've seen the pictures of these fish, you've seen decapitation. Another thing that happens when a fish goes to the turbine is that there is a huge pressure drop. At the top of the turbine, the pressure is this, bottom of the turbine is that. So when a fish has a bladder, the pressure drop is such that the fish basically explodes. So that's essentially what happened here along with the habitation. Yeah, so Free D'Andro in front of me, I know I know Freedy Andro immediately filed a complaint to FERC about the event. You might also remember that Brookfield's undergoing a relicensing of that dam. So this was, you know, this is a very unfortunate event. But if you could have an unfortunate event like this at any particular time, you really wouldn't have it now. because it does draw attention to the problem that has been in existence since that dam was built.
[45:20] Speaker D (unidentified): You want to have it now, not Brookfield. Sorry? You want to have it now, not Brookfield.
[45:28] Speaker C (unidentified): So the question is, why did the turbines come back on? And I should commend you if you have not yet read this article. This is the most comprehensive article I've ever found on the topic here. It can be a little snarky, but nonetheless, it's a very good read. And the guy's fair, if he's snarky. So, I also want to draw attention to the fact that Representative Enquiries is on this. And he posted to Facebook, I am following closely the story of the latest fish kill at the Brookfield Hydroelectric Dam by Fort Andrews. So far, it seems like further confirmation that the fishway does not work, just as Spreedy and Groh has asserted. I support their efforts at the federal level to include major fish passage improvements as a condition of relicensing. Additionally, I do plan to submit legislation specific to this site regarding the state-level clean water certification. Let me stop right there. During the federal process of dam relicensing, the state department of environmental protection gets the way in on what's known as a water quality certification this is the only tool that the state has and there have been there have been very successful cases where a state has said no you're messing with the water too much here you can't pass your water certification water quality certification and so the license is held in advance until that issue is incredible so that's the lever that the state has and dan wants to make sure that level that lever is pulled that's great hydro cannot be considered clean renewable energy he says if the people who operate the power plants can't fulfill their basic promises around fish passage the reason this matters so much is that there is a major difference and overall environmental quality when fish passage is done correctly. You, of course, also get a huge boost in the strength of the food chain that we all benefit from, directly or indirectly, through an increase in bait fish. Alewives, River Herring are very popular with the lobstermen. They are the go-to bait. It would be so much easier for everyone involved if Brookfield would just agree to listen to advocates gets and use its vast resources to truly accommodate this passage rather than fighting so hard to do the bare minimum. If you're going to extract a profit from our river, then you need to take care of this is an entirely reasonable ask of any major energy firm like Brookfield. Very strong statement from Dan. Very strong. And this morning, the latest on this, morning, because Free the Angro submitted the complaint to FERC, has now just turned around now on October 20th. So this is 18 days later from the spill to Fishkill, asking Brookfield to explain themselves. In order for us, and I'm reading now from a letter from FERC to Brookfield, in order for us to review the causes and events surrounding this fishkill, please file a report with the commission identifying the following information. One, the operational status of the downstream fish passage facility during the time surrounding this incident. Two, project operation before, during, and after the incident, including any operational difficulties or abnormal river conditions. Three, any observations you have regarding the fish kill and your conclusions regarding what caused it to occur. Remember, why did that turbine turn on? Four, any action you took immediately upon learning of the incident, and five, documentation of any consultation you've had with state and federal agencies regarding this incident. So FERC is finally doing its job. And that gives you, now you're up to date on what I really want to talk about.
[50:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Friends of Mary Meady Bay filed a lawsuit against Ruffield have you heard about that so that's also in the process I tried to look for Ed Friedman's contacts and I should have them but I yeah he's the ED of Friends of Mary Meady Bay it would be nice to get him to come in and talk because I mean also I've read throughout social media and in the news that this you know this doesn't happen very often and you know once every 50 years or something like that 's that's bs i've seen this happen at least twice in my career here where we've ended up with that ls downstream of the dam so this
[50:47] Speaker C (unidentified): article here that i just put and don't you have to view brings a great point the dam has to shut down for an extended period of time, whenever there's major fish passage.
[50:57] Speaker G (unidentified): There's a lot of major fish passage.
[50:59] Speaker C (unidentified): It's a 19 megawatt dam, whatever it is. It's a very strong dam. This dam generates a lot of electricity. So Brookfield is now not getting any revenue from that dam when it's offline. They can't have it to the grid. So you would think it would behoove them to do Fishmasters. But everything we're seeing on Brookfield is like we're going to do, we're going to try to do the bare minimum on this. Bare minimum. So we'll see how well it goes. Well, they're reporting to their investors.
[51:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Excuse me? They're responsible to their investors. That is exactly,
[51:41] Speaker C (unidentified): if you go to the Brookfield site, that's exactly what you see. Green energy, green energy, double-digit return on your investment. Count. Take it to the back. We have to remember that these rivers are our river. I'll get up my soapbox in a second. They belong to all of us. They belong to all the creatures in the river. They belong to us as a population, as human beings. Brookfield uses it with impunity just to mess with it and draw whatever profit they can from it.
[52:16] Speaker A (unidentified): That's it. If you haven't been to Savatis Lake during the Elwha run, I would recommend going up there. It's really interesting to watch the fish move and to see the amount of fish that move
[52:28] Speaker F (unidentified): through there. Who controlled that body of water? The town of Savatis?
[52:32] Speaker A (unidentified): The town of Savatis, yeah.
[52:33] Speaker F (unidentified): So they were kind enough to give the heads up, but is there anything required? That's part of it. Okay. So that's part of it. Okay. And again, not being a biologist, I'm amazed that the resolution to this was going to be to turn it off for some period of time. How do you know how long it's going to take all those guys pushed out of the lake to get downstream? It sounded like it was almost like a day or two.
[52:55] Speaker C (unidentified): They do count the fish passage here in this article area. It's designed for 85,000 shad and in 2023, 14 passed. So they do count these fish.
[53:12] Speaker F (unidentified): So I mean, just with this one event,, I'm saying. So we know that there were a bunch of them coming out. How do they know how long it's going to take that bunch of them to get through that they could then turn it back on? Like, when would have been a safe time for them to turn it back on?
[53:26] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't know, but I would imagine it was based upon past
[53:29] Speaker A (unidentified): history, I think.
[53:31] Speaker G (unidentified): The point is, it's their job
[53:33] Speaker F (unidentified): to figure that out.
[53:34] Speaker A (unidentified): And they did shut it down, but they didn't shut down one of them for four hours during this period, and that's what really smoked them.
[53:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Correct. So, and it's not just alewives, it's American eels, it's lamprey, it's shad, you get a small, very small profit, maybe, I don't know, 13.
[53:54] Speaker F (unidentified): And the reason for the question is, as a layperson, I would have thought, well, there's probably constantly fish coming down through, but there's probably seasonal bubbles where you get more coming through than others. But I would not have, I would have thought that those seasonal bubbles, per se, say, would have been like weeks of fish going through there, which the operational concept of turning off the dam for weeks, I can't imagine that's financially feasible for them. So why aren't you figuring out the side path to that? If it was something that happened to the fish all day for one night and you were done? Yeah, okay. October 23rd, every year we'll turn it off and the fish keep coming, but that's not how fish work. No,.
[54:39] Speaker C (unidentified): And there are probably, just for the sake of this conversation, a half dozen of solutions to this problem. Fish-friendly turbines, natural-like fishways, and any combination you dare of. You can shunt fish to the fish pattern. So there's a lot of different ways they can do it. Each one of these things has a cost.
[55:06] Speaker F (unidentified): And, of course, they're looking at the regionalizing costs of that. Right.
[55:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. With the automation and technology now, you would think that you would be able to control that whole passage with one switch, to be honest with you, because there's a series
[55:23] Speaker H (unidentified): of dams that run through it.
[55:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Brookville has 30 days to respond to the first form for more information, to essentially tell us how this happened. Yeah.
[55:35] Speaker A (unidentified): somebody fell asleep at the wheel I think
[55:40] Speaker F (unidentified): I'd be curious what their expectations for the plan was too like even if they had operationally turned them all off how long were they anticipating having them off for like I can't imagine it would have been indefinite but
[55:52] Speaker C (unidentified): it could have been 48 hours
[55:55] Speaker F (unidentified): or something like that right but would that have been enough coming back to this not knowing how fast the because again a week later could you have had just as many fish coming through and getting killed anyways. It's kind of, let's say, I don't know enough about the migratory behaviors. I could talk about trout, but I can't talk about anything.
[56:18] Speaker G (unidentified): It sounds like part of it was also maybe migration against, you know, it sounds like it wasn't fully a natural language. Adds another layer of responsibility.
[56:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Moving on. Thank you, Jeff. Set December meeting date. You remember our meeting falls in line with Thanksgiving and Christmas
[56:45] Speaker D (unidentified): these last two months.
[56:46] Speaker A (unidentified): If you guys want to have a meeting in December, we're going to have to look at December 7th through the 11th and 14th through the 18th. As long as you don't mind having it here, it's probably not going to be a problem to get it. Skip November and have, that's typically what this commission does, it skips November and then has one meeting, a rescheduled meeting in December. Oh, I see.
[57:25] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah are you thinking of a wednesday a december wednesday like the
[57:31] Speaker H (unidentified): second for the ninth of the sixteenth will be the ninth of the sixteenth yeah ninth of the
[57:35] Speaker A (unidentified): sixteenth that's what i'm thinking do you want to want me to i mean i don't know what's available so i can check those two dates are you is that copacetic with everybody going to be around
[57:51] Speaker C (unidentified): then you're always going to be away yeah and i thought the 16th book worked for me yeah
[57:57] Speaker D (unidentified): find out if we have a room and then there are other people that are here so i can do that so and corey should probably weigh in yes
[58:12] Speaker G (unidentified): do you know where when that response comes out from brookfield where we might go yeah so
[58:19] Speaker C (unidentified): There's a federal site where you can track all things Brookfield, all things Brook. Each one has a particular case number. You can sign up for that, enter your case number in, and get RMS feeds or something.
[58:38] Speaker A (unidentified): What's the case number for this one?
[58:40] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't know, but I can certainly find it.
[58:42] Speaker D (unidentified): So Brookfield's response will be in the public domain?
[58:46] Speaker C (unidentified): All this stuff happens in the public domain.
[58:48] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll just wave that one over there. All right, so I'm not seeing anything else, motion to adjourn.
[59:06] Speaker C (unidentified): I'll make a motion to adjourn. Seconded.
[59:14] Speaker A (unidentified): We're out. Thanks, guys.
[59:19] Speaker H (unidentified): John is always quick with his sentence.