← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick Housing Committee Reviews Poverty Data and Mobile Home Park Issues

2026-10-28 · 2h 17m · Source: 2026.10.28 Brunswick Housing Committee (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:01] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm calling the order. The housing committee meeting was the meeting properly noticed? Yes, it was. Good. We're still missing a couple of our committee members that I have not heard anything. Here comes one of them. so i'm gonna let's go through introductions of the people who are here and then we'll proceed with the agenda so celeste let's start with you if you don't mind oh okay celestia oh my microphone celestia iguanas vice chair of the committee [0:48] Speaker B (unidentified): dory fournier from the united way of midwest maine i'm here today we're going to team with this post-6 counselor and that is me corey prall [0:58] Speaker C (unidentified): district quarantine council member and he's on to the housing committee this thing our [1:05] Speaker B (unidentified): housing committee member and maybe spencer white housing committee member and community [1:13] Speaker A (unidentified): you know sally castello i'm the director of economic and community development and staff Carol O'Donnell, Chair of the Housing Committee. [1:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Melissa Pompanzato, Committee Member. [1:28] Speaker A (unidentified): And Secretary. And Secretary. And unfortunately Ben had a conflict today, so he is not able to be with us, but I'm sure we'll watch it afterwards. We can encourage you to do so, because we have a wonderful presentation today. first item I want to get to is the minutes, and then we're going to adjust the agenda some, so that Doreen can do her presentation and go on with the rest of her workday if she does not want to stick around for our meetings. We do have a very full agenda, so I'm going to try and keep us on time. So, you thought everybody should have a copy of the minutes from last meeting. They thought they had gotten posted, but on the website, but for some reason they didn't. So if you just want to take a minute and take a quick look and see if there's anything you have a question about or want to change. I will say that we had a lot [Speaker D (unidentified): of very presentation] it was just kind of documenting that we had three presentations [Speaker C (unidentified): I have] a motion to accept the minutes Marcia I'll move second I'll second all in favor yes thank you okay so that being done I would like to turn the floor over to Doreen and go to Douglas. [3:35] Speaker B (unidentified): And there's a question. Thank you so much. So as I mentioned, I'm with the United Way of Midcoast Maine. We cover Brunswick and Harpswell, Second Rock, Lincoln and Ross counties. We're also part of a greater group of United Ways called United Ways of Maine. And some of this data comes from data that we purchased collectively with help from the John T. Gordon Foundation. And that bubbles up to United Way Worldwide, where we are a member of BAME, a used BAME member. And so Alice is what I'm going to be talking about today. You might be surprised to see Saginaw County on the screen. We do use that as a proxy for Brunswick because Brunswick's more like Saginaw County than it is the rest of Cumberland County. But I did give a couple of handouts because I couldn't help myself. Cumberland County is what you have for your information. I can do a little crosswalk with SAC. And then I did a very brief snapshot report about ALICE in Cumberland County. It's just a two pager, which I thought you might find helpful. So what is ALICE? It is an acronym for Asset Limited Income Constraint and Employed. So these are people who work for a living and they may be single, they could be with a partner, they could have one child, they could have two children, two children in child care, they could be retired. There's a whole bunch of people who are basically allies and non-neighbors of family members, people who work with. these are people who make just enough that they don't qualify for state or federal benefits but they don't make enough to have a very good savings account and if there's trouble in any part of their world like maybe a child is up and they don't have a sick day then they have to take a day without pay or maybe their car breaks down and they don't have enough funds to cover the light bill to get the car fixed in order to continue to work so it is people who are really struggling to get by so thank you and i'm going to read because there's a lot of information that i want to make sure i get accurately most of you might be or maybe not but familiar with the federal poverty level that's where most folks can qualify for federal benefits this alice grouping is has been under the radar for a long time and a group called united ways of northern new jersey got funding to look at the data and they pull from census they pull from bureau of labor statistics all kinds of places to say what's actually happening with those folks who aren't getting help and so they pulled together lots of information we were We're the 27th state to buy the data. We just came out with a new data set from 2024. So, again, this is two years late. But we got it in 2026. And in 28, we'll get 26 data. So, we expect to see a change within the next round. But for now, this is an accurate picture of where folks stand. can and as I said could be anyone that a clerk someone who's a gas station attendant maybe a caregiver sales people cashiers folks who are a lot of times making under $20 an hour and having to have multiple jobs so in your day-to-day getting here you said you got a cup of coffee that person might be Alice as well they do make our economy run but they do have to make very difficult choices along the way so we can move along and sometimes it's hard to make choices what am i paying and what am i not paying it might be heating bill versus food child care maybe i need to do it reduced hours to stay at home do i pay the rent or get my medication you know these kinds of stories we do have a partner in it's called heart of Maine United Way they're based out of Bangor but they cover I think five counties in Maine they have the video so I wanted to oh yeah the wrong thing is in there so there's a link to a woman single mom do you want to play that yes as you queue it up I'm gonna step it up people So Home United Way did this for the State of Maine report that came out in 2026, and she's going to tell her story. She has a couple minutes left, but I want to hear from someone. This isn't actually a pitch to give Bank Wars United Way money. So if we could pull back to the slideshow. So let's look at more data that's specific to our community. So actually, this is where I pulled up the numbers, oops, the next slide, sorry, hold on a second. again. I didn't figure it would play. So again, this is what we know for households in poverty in Saginaw Hawk is 12%. In Brunswick, it's actually 9%. And Alice in Saginaw Hawk is 22%. But in Brunswick, it's 36%. So household unequal, that's a total of 46, is what we call below the Alice threshold, meaning those who are in poverty and those who are in Alice. So it's actually a little worse in Brunswick specifically. Covenant County throws things off a little bit because that's 136,000 people versus the town of Brunswick, which last time it was close to the 20s. It's funny too, okay. You have to be a Brunswick resident, actually. So that's why I do tend to use the second one because it looks a little bit more like it, but that's a lot who are struggling. one of your handouts that i gave you is it's this colorful one and it shows that alice in cumberland county anyways 28 inside your pockets 22 percent 12 percent are in poverty inside your house like nine percent in cumberland we do have some very affluent areas right [13:06] Speaker A (unidentified): nine percent in poverty how much was the alice 36 yes for a total of 46 [13:14] Speaker B (unidentified): So, worse in Brunswick than how the data is collected. Yeah, they, there's a whole bunch of sources. So there's Bureau of Labor Statistics, there's census, there is, demographic information. I can get all of those. It's a very well vetted methodology to collect this data. [13:40] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm mostly just curious about it because I don't see the underlying data in my life very much, but it's really interesting to me. [13:49] Speaker B (unidentified): I've used these tables in my research for more than a decade. If you really want to see the data sets, they're available online. Yeah, including the hospital survival budget. So that second handout that I gave you with the arts on the first page, it shows you what they call a survival budget. And we'll get to that in a second. But that just shows you how much you need to exist, not to get ahead, not to thrive, but just that survival. So I wanted you to see that for Cumberland County as well. Okay. So, and I know that like in Bath and Topsom, we have a greater number of people who are Alice, but it's Richmond and Georgetown that have the highest percentage of people. So in Maine altogether, we're at 40% of us are Alice, which is a huge number. We can go to the next slide. Right. So I'm just trying to look here. I can see some data sources in the way. yeah some of it is just some i can certainly send a list of all the citations too so what does it look like in saginaw county under 25 years old the number is a staggering 79 percent are alice which is mind-boggling and single female headed but in cumberland county it's it's worse it's actually single female headed and male headed single male headed are i think close to 60 percent each i think when you're like 61 percent 65 and over in cumberland county 52 percent in sagatahawk county it's only 43 i mean i say only 43 but still almost half of us what's interesting is if you look at just this comparison mdi that single female headed household with children under the age of five it's like 95 percent yeah so even mdi that it feels like it's flush with a lot of cash when you disaggregate the data and look at specific cell populations and other adverse population are single women over the age of 65. Once you lose that second social security check or other income. Right. So what we know is it's hard to make ends meet. And we know that the state is already old because gas prices are very different. Eating well is very different. Food is very different. So we are expecting more struggles as we move forward. Actually, if you want to go to the next slide. But it does span all ages, genders, races, ethnicities, living in urban areas, suburban, rural communities. is in maine franklin county has the worst numbers from 2024 at 49 the lowest is which i was surprised i haven't gone from county myself but that's pretty rough and even in crumberland county 16 of households live paycheck to paycheck in the town of crumberland center but involved when it's 51 and as i mentioned brunswick is 46 %. So there's some pretty big, wide spreads. That's why Cumberland County is so hard because there's such a big spread of people with means versus people who are really struggling. So the next one is really that, what I was saying when things don't head up, the next slide. so a family of four needs to make ninety thousand dollars if you just receive if you're just at the federal poverty level you're making thirty one thousand which is terrible the combined wages for two full-time workers one being a teller one being a cook makes sixty eight thousand so you can see that there is a discrepancy and this chart that i gave you for cumberland county breaks out a bit more on what that survival budget looks like it's assuming for example housing is 2100 that's not unreasonable for Cumberland County which is why I printed the Cumberland County data because I thought Saginaw Hawks rents were quite a bit lower and I didn't think that was as accurate as down here just across the bridge but child care at 1600 it's almost 1700 a month food 1600 a month transportation 800 and i'm guessing that's much higher i have checked in with folks and the 2024 data looks pretty reasonable for that time frame we don't have a lot of updates for 2026 data yet because we're still in it i think taxes at 900 so you need a lot more than we have we and folks have to make 52 dollars and 46 cents as a couple per hour and many Alice families do not so can that housing seems really low as a percentage [19:03] Speaker A (unidentified): of somebody's budget like that really just doesn't bring true seems really it almost seems like this is yeah on the on the left yeah when I see it as a percentage of someone child care is [19:15] Speaker B (unidentified): more than but on this list it's less yeah you remember these are aggregate numbers right. Yeah. And so when you disaggregate the data, right, or if you were to look at a different average, like not the mean, but the mode, right, the mode is the most frequently occurring number on the data set. We would see something different. Like, what is this? What is the range of the curve? That's probably a pretty spiky curve that gets you to that low number, which means there's a lot of people or it could go like this. right so there's a lot of there's a lot of people on the with high-end housing right and then you've got that 40 percent who have a different level of housing when you mix it all up and divide by the number i think that's how you get 2100 a month and then there's also the reality of cumberland county which is a really bizarre county in some ways because when you actually look at what like where wait where income comes from cumberland county as a whole the number one source of income in a household is not wages coming to money it's assets earned from investments is the number one source of income so we have this very bizarre [20:27] Speaker A (unidentified): are. I know we have a lot of that in Brunswick too, though, because we have an older county. We have an older county. We're kind of looking, we're kind of separating, she's talking about Saginaw saying we're like them, and I'm saying, I think we're a lot like them. [20:44] Speaker B (unidentified): And some part of you will see as well, like you have a lot of older households who might own their home, or you have a lot of people who bought 10, 15, 20 years ago have low interest rates. The reality for those folks in terms of what their housing payment looks like is very different to what people entering the housing market looks like today. So always look at these as an average, the mean, right, where we've just tumbled them all together and divided them. And so the only thing it's really good for is not telling you what reality is on the ground, it's just to make comparisons. That's all it does. It's silly. Like we can now compare what the profile looks like to some degree from Cumberland to Saginaw to Franklin to pick your county right that's all it's good for it's not actually telling you what it looks like on the ground for the average ordinary person and that's mean so if you look at that [21:33] Speaker C (unidentified): and that housing is much higher this is 21 41 times 12 i know that's a big question though yes like this is showing and i mean yeah this is 20 grand for child care versus 15 for [21:49] Speaker B (unidentified): housing it's just a comparison no i'm just saying that 's other counties that's all i'm [21:56] Speaker C (unidentified): saying but it's like oh yeah a roasted brownie yeah no but it's important i show the video i [22:03] Speaker A (unidentified): hear what you're saying yeah but not everybody's a statistician or no right you know we got to be impactful to how we make decisions town council makes decisions and that's not telling the story that we all know maybe for maine it's showing like this you know across the board but we need to be drilling down and saying no it's really we should do this yes we should do that yeah [22:24] Speaker C (unidentified): like not like housing is 25 yes yeah it must be higher than child right here right yeah [22:31] Speaker B (unidentified): which is why i brought both yeah right because i know it's where we got from not your first trip to the rodeo yeah i know yeah this is so hard but as a point for regarding snap so federal poverty level which was studied 1200 families have to decide like you know yes we can apply we can be eligible for snap but there's a whole lot of other things that we're not going to be able to cover like internet at home or a phone plan and maybe their children need that to help with school it becomes very difficult for families when you look at that poverty line again to reinforce the point it's the same federal poverty line for all lower 48 states only Alaska and Hawaii get a different poverty line so again we're mixing Maine up with Mississippi with California with Massachusetts to get to that line so that's why for a lot of entitlement programs like school lunches for example and we had to worry about that in the state of maine they'd say well if you're 200 of the federal poverty line you'd be eligible for that program right because they know right that for maine wasn't always in the bracket where there was a big gap between wages and cost of living right but we are there now relative to where we were 20 years ago so again these are for comparing ourselves to other places and those federal poverty guidelines certainly it all it does is basically show you where the united states is once it's all tumbled together and how we how we draw comparisons and then if we're going to use it as a threshold we often move that line in order to get to some things resembling reality yeah and i [24:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Where would heating fall under that from a household? [24:27] Speaker B (unidentified): That's calculated in your housing payment. When we calculate, when the federal government is looking at your property housing, it's your heating, your electricity, and your, not all utilities, because the internet is not considered a utility. [Speaker C (unidentified): That's under technology.] But it's considered all utilities to run your household. [24:46] Speaker E (unidentified): I just would like to say that there's a lot of discussion about the increase cost of living and I just feel like if we're a public body talking that we really should be focusing on wage stagnation as a message because prices of things are going to rise over time what's not rising is wages and so I feel like there's just this obsession with affordability and the cost of things but the problem is that people aren't being paid more and when you look at people's income over time in America we're so flat which is a policy decision by the federal government on a daily basis to repress wages on behalf of corporations so that's just what it is and like i am very exhausted in this political news cycle of caring about how expensive everything is it's really not that things are expensive it's that people don't make enough money to pay for things but like if you look at a chart a year ago it was no if you look at a chart cost of goods it's over time is a much more gradual increase than the flat line of wages in america oh yeah so costs are going to rise i just would like people to really think critically publicly and speak publicly about wage stagnation and not the cost of things because the cost of things always goes up a little bit like that and yes we have seen some certain things increase but if we're not talking about wage stagnation that's the whole ball game so then we can talk about [26:10] Speaker B (unidentified): child care policy, health care policy, and certain costs that we might have. I think it's in the end. I think it's in the end. There's some things I think that we should be talking about. [26:20] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, and specifically on housing and the context of that statement, we did just see a presentation like two months ago or something that showed that ratio over time of housing expenditures versus income over time and where you really saw brunswick spike in unaffordability start to occur was when wages started stagnating i mean it showed a pretty consistent increase in the cost of housing but it just all of a sudden wages kind of capped when housing didn't and the one other thing i would add is i mean those have our own minimum wage so it's at least locally here it's not entirely you know the fault of the federal government that our wages are not increasing it is a state decision not to continue increasing our and [27:12] Speaker C (unidentified): i'd like to get back to sorry [27:14] Speaker A (unidentified): because remember we've got a lot on the agenda next slide is insufficient wages [27:28] Speaker B (unidentified): the working age people only 40 percent are working full-time they only have a full-time job 45 percent of workers in maine's most 20 common jobs couldn't make ends meet and let's see of the 20 most common jobs in the state nine paid less than 20 per hour in 2024 24. So an hour in the winter 20 would be 40,000 annually working full-time. So it's no surprise that workers in this job, 45% struggle to make it. [27:56] Speaker A (unidentified): That does shock me. 40% working age people [Speaker B (unidentified): are salaried.] And that's because of a lack of jobs that are salaried. That's a threshold. [28:10] Speaker C (unidentified): So we're not talking about the people that have hours that are working full-time. [28:25] Speaker B (unidentified): that's an economic issue and not every job can legally be classified even if you're working full-time you can't legally classify it as a salary position because it's dependent on the nature of the work itself exactly right yeah and so that's part of the issue we've constrained drained ourselves from policy from giving people some sort of journey and what's going to be in [28:48] Speaker C (unidentified): the buying package right but i think like having been in all kinds of different jobs and organizations through my time like i don't always feel like a salary job is the best thing right because sometimes the people that are doing hourly below them have opportunities to make more so the a salaried person has more responsibilities, but it's locked into a certain it's guaranteed, but you know, whereas in most jobs even hourly people are guaranteed that they have to work 40 hours you know, like that's part of the agreement and stuff, so I'm not sure that being a salaried person is all that's correct [29:33] Speaker B (unidentified): I think I'd want to know what, how many people are getting work done salary [29:38] Speaker C (unidentified): So the next slide shows... [29:45] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll come back for some questions I really would like for you, Tori. [29:51] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, wages over time, the income, and what we have seen over the last, I think that's a little bit more than a decade, a decade and a half, the poverty level was going up, went down, was going up again. Alice has taken a little bit of a nosedive in let's see so the number of households living in poverty in Saginaw County went up by 30 percent the number of Alice households decreased by three percent so it did dip two percent in Saginaw County which again I was surprised to [30:29] Speaker C (unidentified): see but there was like right after COVID started though we had a correction in wages because everybody was you know having a hard time finding people and things got corrected and it was we had that moment everything was great and then the inflation came crashing in and it wiped out any gains that we had like everything kind of corrected itself just that we were making more money but everything was costing more so it didn't really matter [31:00] Speaker B (unidentified): so why do i share this information other than to get people upset one thing is that you're policymakers and so if there is a threshold that you are looking at you can go to united for alice in maine and look at the data yourself you said you've used it in your research i know of non-profits that use it when they're doing grants because they can say in the town of county or in vega we can we can show this is what our community he's looking at there is very limited data for brunswick what i gave you is what we know because it doesn't get they do a little bit by zip code which was what this alice county report that two-stager that i've made use that has brunswick is the second town down so it does show you breakfast specific and then that colorful this one that one also shows the Remember, some of it's for the county, but some of it is for Farnsworth. So I just wanted you to have that in case you need to tell your story a little bit differently. One of the things that we work on collectively across the state as United Ways of Maine, they made one. So we came together and thought about, all right, to your, I can't remember whose point, about wages and employers. It's tough to go to employers to say, well, raise your wage, Bob. right because that's very difficult for a business to do and we need to be in partnership with businesses so what we have tried to do is find some low-hanging fruit that employers are already doing i did i don't have the employee toolkit ready to share but there is one that is have been developed but i did pull out some things that are being done in midpost that are considered best practices. One of them, Coastal Enterprise here in Brunswick uses blind hiring to remove identifying information from resumes during early screening, which is reducing unconscious bias. What we didn't get into is folks who are either, like we had said, are older or folks of non-whites, they often are hit harder with owls. They're struggling more. And so what they're trying to do is a blind hiring process. Many applicant tracking systems support this, letting teams focus on skills and qualifications, not just the demographics. So there's one. Fair chance hiring broadens access to opportunity by evaluating candidates based on relevant skills, experience, and job-related competencies. Another one, L.L. Bean introduced an early emergency assistance program called Bean Cares, which is administered by a third party and is fully funded by L.L. Bean. The process offers grants up to $2,500 to cover an IRS-approved emergency situation, such as unexpected medical costs, storm damage to a home, car accidents, death-related expenses. There's some strict IRS guidelines, but they have given that to their employees. Another one, Interscropping Bank has a PTO bank where employees can donate to help others who need time off not much of a hardship for the bank i was [34:31] Speaker A (unidentified): going to say that 's not doing anything i didn't get them it was it was an offer it was [34:36] Speaker C (unidentified): already there yeah it's just shuffling around like when businesses are like you know ask you to donate every time you buy something and then they end up giving the money and everyone's [34:48] Speaker B (unidentified): like oh yeah but in practical terms like my father and my sister-in-law both work the federal government when my sister had a baby my dad was not using his pto and he gifted like a month of it to her and that was a godsend for my brother and sister-in-law and not all employees but you're [35:06] Speaker C (unidentified): not going to pat the federal government on the back for that you're going to pat your dad on [35:10] Speaker A (unidentified): the back no but not all not all employers do that we tried to do that in the university of maine system when i worked there and we didn't get it so i mean i get it but i think the point [35:23] Speaker C (unidentified): is very valid that has nothing to do with the company that's the important that's why it's [35:28] Speaker B (unidentified): so frank when we need for like everybody can do this and yeah we be expressed which is why we're trying to share what is my degree doesn't kind of notice i think you were making a point during [35:37] Speaker A (unidentified): that this is i'm always willing so yeah this is like just a low-hanging fruit so you really want to at least assist people even if it does even if it's not them being with it to allow others to Samaritan. Yes. I love that idea. [35:51] Speaker E (unidentified): That's our internal generosity there. I know. [35:53] Speaker C (unidentified): I know. I know. Let's do another week. [35:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Another one is called Route and Schedule Alignment. Public transportation is not the strongest. [36:03] Speaker A (unidentified): In Maine in general, I will not single out [36:07] Speaker B (unidentified): In Maine, public transportation is a little weak. So you could work collectively to ensure routes and schedules aligned with shift times and work locations. BIW General Dynamics expanded Lewiston to Bath service through Maine's workforce transportation pilot launching the Blue Line Express. It gained funding through workforce transportation pilot program. So again, a local,. Is that part of workforce transportation pilot program? What's the? It's the workforce transportation pilot, and I don't know if that's federal, but I can find that out. I mean, using some of their contract money. I think that's what they did with the housing part and what i think the child care like that and then another one is a direct service model it's called employer run or employer funded transportation including shuttles van pools carpools connecting employees to free or reduced cost bicycle ownership and maintenance go maine does provide carpool and cool rag matching they also i don't know if people know this but if you work remote they give you benefits for that because they say hey thanks for keeping off the road and you can get incentives and you can i think there's i don't know all the incentives but i was quite surprised that going was that robust so they've been running around doing their thing for a while there are a lot more examples again that was just employers from mid-post i'm trying to get access to the entire employer toolkit i don't have approval yet to use it but what we're trying not to do is to say hey employers you're messing this up we're trying to say what can you do can you think creatively some give a paycheck ahead if someone's in a jam some have a little low cost or no cost loan that you could take, maybe $500 if you need to get your tires replaced, and then you're slowly paying back through payroll. So there are some of those kinds of activities that employers can do, and we're encouraging them. I also wanted to let you know, related to housing, is our board of directors just approved, and we're just now sending out the information. We're going to be able to do a match for heating assistance until the end of December. They're $70,000, so any raise. We will have it matched up to $70,000. It's to commemorate our 70 years in business as United Ray. So we're pretty happy about that happening. And we give to nine different organizations who give out heating assistance. Definitely folks who cover Brunswick and Harpswell. That's in your service area. I also have 2-1-1 quick cards. This is just how you get to 2-1-1. there's four different ways text calling email or going online these are free i've made them evergreen so i don't have to deal with the teeny tiny numbers anymore it's just my topic so if the town of brunswick would like some i can leave some behind or anybody else if you have another place you want to bring them you're certainly welcome to them and i'm the gal who will bring that to you if you need more and i know i've taken up more than my 30 minutes right [39:24] Speaker C (unidentified): we interrupted you a lot [39:29] Speaker E (unidentified): to a program of what an employer can do Bowdoin will pay up to 10% of the down payment if you buy a house up to $500,000 price point up to 50k for all benefits eligible employees and I think it's a really good model I actually helped them develop it for what I helped their finance director develop it and it's a good model for employers to think about how they feel In a difficult housing market, there are different ways that employers can do it. But helping your employee buy a house, I mean, from Bowdoin's perspective, it means they're going to stay. It's a commitment. They have to be in a certain radius of Bowdoin. Is that a grant? It is a forgivable grant. So it starts as a full loan, and then by 10 years, you're fully vested, and they forgive it. So if you were to leave after seven years, you would owe them the discrepancy of. [40:22] Speaker C (unidentified): It's prorated over time. Yeah. [40:25] Speaker E (unidentified): But their goal is that it's for long-term employees. It's a great program. Matt Orlando. [40:31] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. And it's only done with the advantage. [40:35] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I saw him at the garden party and he said, our program is so successful that Bowdoin is at risk of becoming a bank. in several years wow i'm about to double check that answer with him i think that's what he said [40:52] Speaker B (unidentified): he's quite willing to share that story i would love to have this part of our [40:56] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah because that's the main sharing and it's on there i'm not a voting employee i'm a realtor i just helped them i went to matt orlando five years ago and just said you keep sending people clients my way and they're struggling to buy houses these are voting yeah because they have a lot of debt and we're in a competitive market and then we started with an appraisal protection idea but we ultimately it came to a down payment assistance and so you can be faculty staff you just have to be a full-time benefits eligible employee to get it and it's only done through two local banks the partners are bath savings and cannabis savings but it's on their website it's their home buyer program yeah you can i can send you a link to it [41:35] Speaker B (unidentified): and that used to be on our board yeah it's cool i don't know how long i you know it's something [41:41] Speaker E (unidentified): they've been trying we saw other colleges around the country were doing it they hire a lot of academics who carry a lot of debt like they look good they have good income and credit but they have four hundred thousand dollars in student loans and you know there's like it's they it's [41:57] Speaker B (unidentified): tricky so and i think in that up and back there's i think five different apartment buildings that are multi-unit, that are just for BIW workers. [42:06] Speaker E (unidentified): I think that sometimes employers can come up with, employers might have the capital that a person might not have. [42:15] Speaker A (unidentified): That's a whole different thing. Or could they? [42:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm just curious. [42:24] Speaker D (unidentified): I think certain industries make more money than others. Yes. Yeah. [42:38] Speaker E (unidentified): I would like other employers to know, you know, yeah, I would like to share with everyone, [42:49] Speaker A (unidentified): because I think there's a lot of different options that people just aren't aware of. [42:53] Speaker B (unidentified): What we hear from human resources are we need people. [42:56] Speaker E (unidentified): we could not have people yeah it's a house and you help them buy a house they're less likely to leave your organization i think it's a mutual i think it's an investment in that absolutely i [43:06] Speaker A (unidentified): just remember lois saying that because a lot of the nurses couldn't afford housing you know not to say that you could do that but just try to think of other ways to assist different industries and i agree like the hospital is very different from both but just to say that i wish [43:21] Speaker C (unidentified): I think it would be beneficial, though, considering how many people work for small businesses in the state and in the area, because these big organizations have deep pockets and small businesses do not. so how can a small business potentially help you know without you know cutting them off at the knees that would be really good down payment assistance so but you know small business themselves yeah right so maybe a state level program right yeah you know but that's what i think because i mean if we did percentage-wise like how many people [44:11] Speaker E (unidentified): work for small businesses small businesses pay into a fund that their employees could then go tap for like down payment assistance or closing cost assistance i mean even five to ten k can make the difference between whether or not sometimes someone can buy the property right [44:25] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah so i would tell you that our abu program that's we you know we yeah brunswick was the [44:31] Speaker A (unidentified): only one that was able to get those done but we and we can only do five because it was just a pilot but i mean that leveraged their ability to do it right you know up to ten thousand dollars [44:40] Speaker C (unidentified): right but that doesn't something like that i mean that helps an individual person but like a large scale right on when you have a big organization like that's a great draw for people who don't want to work with them but for the small businesses that they want they're competing for those people but what are some of the ways that they can potentially help like if Even if it's just like open doors, you know, to find access to some of those things. But that would be an interesting thing to see. [45:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Could something like, could BBA do something with schools? [45:17] Speaker E (unidentified): I know, I was just wondering, could you take small businesses and have them make an annual or monthly contribution into a housing fund that their employees could then go be eligible to apply for a grant in a housing process? I'm not sure who would structure it or how it would be, but it's important. [45:31] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, post-COG. [45:36] Speaker C (unidentified): region or a state yeah it would just be an interesting time from the states to like
Unfinished Business
[45:43] Speaker A (unidentified): before you leave the last answer something she wanted to mention or ask it's not germane to the topic of this but in a way it is i was i was losing the whole train of thought of what the presentation was for and i wondered if sometimes we can just limit questions to the end of the presentation because i was kind of yeah right yeah i understand right one of our agenda items when we get into the everyone yeah under old business we've got two items that deb is here too no but while we can you stay i was gonna i was gonna suggest we do the financial but we can do the financial report then we'll go into old business and then we'll let you go first okay all right that works for me because the financial report it's not all that a long report you know we obviously have not given out a grant recently so we don't have much change you know a little bit changes in our in our interest that we are and so that's not really earth-shattering but there are two things i wanted to mention you can see our balance of 307 596 we do have a potential request coming from the Hawthorne School redevelopment because we, the town's council approved awarding that door yard and part of their proposal was to request a affordable housing support fund grant to help leverage main housing funds because it helps them score better on their application, similar to what we've done with others. The Tom's Point Road affordable housing being one. So that, I just want to show you that once your fact gets done early you know in the next some several months then you know obviously it leaves us with not too much money there i did come to the town council cip this monday where one of my requests is for 325 000 to come into this fund so i did request that last year and i did not before if i'm hopeful this year that it will so i just wanted to let you know that i went back and made that request in the CIP. So other than that, nothing really to report on the financials. Any questions for me? OK. OK. Hi, Fran. Hi, Fran. Hi. I'm sorry. Not yet. We're just moving into old business. We adjusted the agenda to let Doreen do her pre-simplification first. So, old business, okay, let's skip to GA Maximums and Zocourt, and then we'll come back to earlier items in that agenda. Yeah, so we've got Deb Crocker here, who's our Director of Human Services. I asked her to come talk about a couple of things. She went before the Town Council on the GA Maximums, but also a situation that we've had in one of our local home parks, Zocourt, which we're going to kind of tag team on that because there's there's kind of the property issues but then there's also the human services and assistance piece so but i'm going [49:22] Speaker B (unidentified): to let deb start with the ga maximum every year late september early october the state will send me for our area new GA maximums for housing, we can help pay for oil, electricity, burial even, cremations, and so food, household supplies, baby supplies, anything like that for basic necessity and every year consistently it does increase it doesn't increase a lot but what they do they take the numbers area median income and they do a formula which has an area rentals of what they should be according to what people make which should be 30 percent of their income, but as we know, housing is much more than their income. So rentals may be in the $2,500 range, but I'm only, I think the maximum for one bedroom is $1,400 or thereabouts. So that did increase this year, but they also do have calculation on the area median income for of our GM maximums, overall maximum. So the overall maximum, it could be, so last year it was $13.17 and it went up maybe $70 from that this year. And that's the most that you can make to qualify for general assistance under the income. It goes up a household of two, household of three, household of four. It increases about $70 or thereabouts. that's a monthly a monthly of what you can make to be able to 1387 for this yeah is your [51:29] Speaker D (unidentified): monthly income as a single person as a single person it doesn't seem like much but that is [51:34] Speaker B (unidentified): that if they're formal this is probably this is after taxes this is your net income right We always look at the income if they tell us they're first-time applicants and they don't have their pay stubs with them. So we'll take a verbal from them, 20 hours, $60 an hour, so we calculate that, and then we subtract what their taxes would be, and then we use that. them and then so there's two ways you can qualify one is through your income and one is through your expenses so one is a deficit and one is an unmet need so we look at the deficit first that's your income if you do not qualify under that then we look at your expenses and if your expenses are higher than what your income on. And we do the calculation of how much of an unmet need you might have. And most people qualify under that. And we always look at the emergency first. [52:49] Speaker A (unidentified): And what is your need? [52:51] Speaker B (unidentified): Is it rent? Is it CMP? And if we can't make the full rent, then we kind of look at everything else. and maybe make a determination okay what if we paid your cmp bill what if we gave you a food voucher that would free up some money to help pay for your rent so we spend a lot of time with clients to try to find a good path for stabilization and then we also do some financial help you know we talk to them about their finances we look at their bank statements and it's never patronizing it's only there to help and we so we're meeting everybody with as much kindness as we can because times are tough and you know sometimes you don't know where you're spending money or where that money might be going and so we look at all of that and we just give some financial advice, and one thing to know about GA is that it is a short-term program, and we're the program of last resort, so if there's other resources out there, we're going to point you in that direction. We're going to meet your emergency first, and then talk about what else is out there that might be able to help you, so if you need heating assistance, We might help you get 100 gallons to get you through. And then we're going to set you up with Opportunity Alliance for Light Heat or the Wood Bank or any other sources that we can help you with. [54:34] Speaker A (unidentified): It's a 30-day application. [54:36] Speaker B (unidentified): You can come in after the 30 days and see if you might qualify again. We do put requirements on the eligibility. eligibility so if you're only working 20 hours we might say it would be best if you worked full-time and can you show us that you know you're working that path if you can't for health reasons we take an a doctor's note so i mean it's not a forceful thing if you can't literally do it then we ask you know that your doctor to attest that you're not able to work full-time and if there's only one person in the health group that's working and the other person might be able to work then we require that other person who is also asking for assistance that they should you know work and there's other requirements like if we've said given you the resource for opportunity alliance then have you called to set up an appointment and as long as you've met the requirements and you can come back usually we only see a client maybe one time two three times max and we do have long-term people that are just really struggling they're only on a very fixed income SSI or SDI and their rents are high and they still qualify but as long as they're meeting the requirements they can come back time and time again if they [56:10] Speaker A (unidentified): then if they're you have to go to the town council to get approval to raise those so yes and then do you how do you know how much to raise does that come from like the state or the need or how does that how do you come to the number okay the state will send them to me i get i get [56:29] Speaker B (unidentified): something like this every year that shows me all the maximums this is the maximum amount that i'm allowed to assist anybody with i can't go over those maximums but i think the question is when it goes to council to determine how much money to allocate to this now we're looking at the number of people who have to be served so there's the maximum that you know they qualify for can't go over that but then how many people you anticipate in the upcoming year and that's going to be just like a look back period how many people did we serve previously and what are we forecasting for this year and what have we spent before and what have we and is that a reasonable guesstimation of what we anticipate being in the upcoming year so i have a budget yearly budget and it usually is aiming high because we never know it is a required program every municipality has to have a general assistance program and so it doesn't matter if there if you ask for $15,000 a year and you go over that you're still required that's why we kind of aim high if we don't use it we don't use it and most of the time I don't have to use the money that I'm asking for what was last year I think it was about 90 something that was in my head and before that the year before that, it was higher because during COVID time, it was, it was high. And ever since then, it's kind of dropped a little bit. I mean, our housing. So was that 90k your direct assistance? And was there a frontline item for admin costs? That's the total. Well,, I mean, admit costs for their... The cost of administering the program. Yes, exactly. That was just the program. Yeah. And so what happens is every single month, I have to do a state report and send it to the state. They know how much I'm allocating for assistance. They will... They reimburse us 70%. [58:48] Speaker A (unidentified): The town is 30%. so that's therefore why it went to the council yes and then can a town decide that they want to contribute more and yes [59:09] Speaker B (unidentified): it's a very complex progress it has to have it has to go a survey has to go out to the they have to look at you have to find a number that you want to add to it and then it has to go to the community they you know and they have to have public comment for that and then the calculations have to be agreed upon through the state so you have to fill out the form it gets to go to the state because they're still going to reimburse that so they have agreed to it But I don't know of any town that have done this or needed to, because the needs are really being met to the best of our ability. Because if we remember that it's a program of last resort, so we're not seeing some, if we were seeing people consistently long term and I mean, with such, then it might be. but being as we only see once three times you know we have maybe a handful of people that we see consistently or they may be stable and then next year they may have another new so they can always call us and you know make an appointment see if we qualify i think part of the issue is the eligibility requirements can be very narrow. So if you look at those income retirements and get into the light of the previous conversation around the Alley's population, universally across the state, it's not specific to Brunswick at all, right? There's a lot of people who are in hardship but ineligible for general assistance. And Angie Lardy and I are actually doing an analysis right now because one of our legislative agendas what's on our look for the state animals council to continue with care one of the key pillars of our legislative agenda is to re-examine as we do every year i mean da reform is legislative every year made equal justice are probably the policy leads on this but there 's also not only is there a discrepancy between what the state statute and thus each municipal ordinance permits as a program of last resort right there so a lot of needs are going unmet by people who are ineligible not by the people who are eligible right there's also 492 ways that this is being implemented across the state and one of the interesting data points and this comes from the office of family assistance 24.5 annual report i'll send you a copy if you're very keen to look at it is that portland or cumberland county collectively accounted for 50 58.1 percent of ga disbursements but they only represent portland is like only 6.1 percent of the total for cumberland county and even when you take portland out the average spend what we're looking at it trying to try to get drop comparisons right so the average spend in cumberland county was like almost a thousand dollars in assistance if you look at other municipalities like we figured out there's like this equity line waterville has one of the biggest gaps for example like our average spend per household is only 44 so there's a wild swing in terms of how it is administered across the state. One thing that I clued on to what you were saying is like you take a verbal, there's municipalities who do not take a verbal and they'll deny the first attempt at determining eligibility if you can't provide all of the documentation. And OFI has a rule book in terms of how it's supposed to be administered. But again, there's like 492 municipalities who have to administer this thing and they're all doing it very different ways. Cumberland County holistically is getting the lion's share right even though they don't have a lion's share of the poverty in the state and so what that's an indication of is that there is not a consistent we're not administering it consistently and that's leaving people across the state at the cold but importantly for service center communities like a brunswick right very often when you go to the state house to wrangle with legislators on these issues. Portland gets most of the money, but we can all see that they're not most of the population when we look from out of state. That creates a lot of frustration, so there's little incentive for legislators to revise these things because Portland has figured out how to maximize revenue generation for them, but none of the rest of us are doing it. For service-centered communities like a Brunswick, part of what I would argue is that we have to get whatever brunswick whatever portland is doing to maximize utilization of that benefit like i want to know how they're doing it so that we can serve a greater proportion that's not to say that you're doing it wrong like i just don't know what they're doing no you're not and i think this is the thing right ofi approves a lot of ways people are doing it right but they have not yet said clearly No, you all have to be doing it in this exact same manner so that we can go back to the legislature and say it's being administered in the exact same way in all 492 municipalities. And there's some municipalities, like, these are small places, but they don't spend anything. I think up in the county, like, their average spend is like $11 per household, right? Again, if it's almost $1,000 in Portland, Cumberland County, and it's only $11,000, that tells you that there's inconsistencies. But OFI will tell each one of those municipalities, you're past your audit. You've done what you're supposed to do. So I think there's other questions that we need to ask, like how many denials? What are the reasons for the denials? Oh, I have to give those numbers as well. And I'm going to say that when we do get audited, it is a very,, very detailed audit. it and they and we have the program well pack that keeps all of that information in the same and there's reports that i can pull up at a whim and so our numbers are good yeah and it's not a criticism of you at all and i can tell you knowing portland i served on the board with the portland director and he explained everything he's they've got more resources there they're a bigger hub they're a city they've got more taxpayer money to be able to pour into that they work directly with the shelters and all yes so they do because they choose to work with the shelters and there's only two municipal three i think not a bit of hurt is using different money but so we're talking about presumptive eligibility in that regard right so yeah they have figured out how to leverage general assistance in order to fund shelters it is remarkable how many municipalities refuse to do that like they just there's 38 shelters across the state and only four are benefiting from that particular line of statute we have the most population in this area and we are cumberland county but we're not in we have our own maximums because we our area median income is much different than if you even to go over to Freeport or you know Falmouth or Yarmouth all it's more money that way or less money here so our maximums are different so I think this is all very interesting I'll come to [1:07:14] Speaker A (unidentified): you I this almost sounds to me as if we should have a separate agenda item for this especially maybe after you and Andrew get your analysis done it might be interesting to for you to present that and for Deb to be at that meeting so we can sort of talk strategies as well I'm just cognizant of the time and we still have a lot [1:07:41] Speaker C (unidentified): to talk about. So I don't forget it just out of curiosity because Deb said that the GA is for just more like short term or one-time thing so is it have we looked at is it that so many of the other communities have more people that are on regular assistance and not invoking the other the short-term insistence and that this our area has more intense one-time or emergence of needs that's I'm just is there a way to see if that might be one of the components as to why you're such [1:08:30] Speaker A (unidentified): a different you know that's where the Alice data sort of dovetails like this the general consensus [1:08:36] Speaker B (unidentified): among people who research general assistance is I guess I would say the hypothesis is and I will say you need data to test these things and last just in the emergency session Maine Municipal Association and the continuum of care we're all on the same side which never happens because the legislature had passed a bill in the previous session to say we need to have a new data reporting system because right now 492 municipalities are sending 492 reports to OFI there's not like a central place where they collate the data where we can like really run rigorous tests and so there's supposed to be investment they didn't allocate any money though right and so and so OFI went and said we would the deadline was in January don't we're not going to meet that deadline because there's no money or we can't find a way to build this data system so please get rid of it we all went and said please don't get rid of it because we have questions that can only be answered if we can actually collate the data otherwise 492 data sets of this scale because let me just say welfare directors across state retain a lot of records there's just no way for us to do that analysis unless there is a central place where it's all going so there are again policy decisions that help us from really digging in and our i would say you know those of us who are interested in general assistance reform our gripe is not with the welfare directors in the state who have very difficult job right most of them are executing it to the best my standard the real issue is you can't get into Rome strategic change without the data and we just there's lots of data but it's it's so scattered yeah you can't draw the correct inferences right and try to make a difference yeah so I was on the board i did we 've worked so hard to get that half and make that happen because there is a system called that the hhs uses asus program which i can get into in the back door but i can't see anything on this side it's there it is there all they have to do is open up a little area of where GA can access and everybody from GA can get right in there we can communicate with each other and records can be from everybody can be just gathered in that one place there's so many efficiencies to be like this is going down the rabbit hole but I definitely think [1:11:21] Speaker A (unidentified): so let's break that in again [1:11:23] Speaker B (unidentified): this is definitely if you're interested in looking at meeting that house housing needs of that house population general assistance is a key tool and strategy i think it's functioning as intended right now but i think what we a lot of us on the advocacy side say well it's no longer fit for purpose that's why we need to get data so that we can actually because remember this stuff was designed like in previous centuries all right so we need to get fit for [1:11:53] Speaker A (unidentified): purpose for the tunnel was anything else fun to you yet oh there's lots [1:11:59] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah we've still got a lot going on here so court so court and then i think i want to go [1:12:09] Speaker A (unidentified): to france yeah we'll go to france but so court as you know is a is a mobile home park and it is a smaller mobile home park, which, you know, was one of the ones that we had not under our mobile home park ordinance because, from our understanding, it was – there were no lot rents. We've just discovered there may be, and we're not going to talk about that today, but there may be at least one that we know about. out but more importantly what happened from an inspection that was done by our fire department is that we and i don't know if there's also just people calling that were alerting us to this and that maybe we can talk a little bit more about that but let me just say there are 22 mobile homes in so court six of those 22 are condemned so that leaves about 18 that could be occupied two of them were recently sold and are going through renovation so 16 of the original mobile home parks left to be occupied, but one unit recently was condemned, leaving just 15 mobile homes. Of those 15 units, they were all inspected. Four of those were condemned. This is an out-of-town. By the way, this is an out-of-town. Yes. [1:13:23] Speaker B (unidentified): Just for those of us who are... Behind the college, you know, Hopswell Road, it's kind of wise off. There's a laundromat right here. It's awesome. It's like Hamilton. [1:13:34] Speaker A (unidentified): to yeah but this is an out-of-town owner so four of those were condemned during our inspection one is having repairs made and that will be reoccupied one is under purchase and sale agreement but it actually was sold as in as is with no water in the units so now our department private department is saying no go on that like that is condemned until such time that the water address okay so the reason i wanted to kind of go through those numbers with you is because the rental registry i just want to make the larger point that the rental registry is really important and i'm so glad we have this tool this did not come up specifically about the rental registry but i'll tell you now they are all registered units and we would have been able to act as a municipal body much faster it took three to four weeks for us to even be able to act on this because we couldn't get a hold of the owner we could not get past the you know property management team and so you know now we do have those contacts and we are able to be much more you know nimble that way and have a municipal response so i will say there's a big response it involved the state as well and i'll let deb talk about that we did have to rehouse people temporarily etc but just so you all know that we're on it we are on it and this is we've got we've got some really good tools but i'll let dev talk about what [1:15:01] Speaker B (unidentified): happened on that how many total did you say sally i heard four then i heard six how many [1:15:06] Speaker A (unidentified): there were let's see there were six that okay six that were condemned just right off the back [1:15:12] Speaker B (unidentified): from the 22. well there were two that were already condemned and they're not right they're doing more [1:15:18] Speaker A (unidentified): they're they're not they don't have anybody living there yeah right okay right i put that down to the six. So anyway, but of the 15 that were, you know, that number I talked about, that were inspected, another four of those were condemned. So, and then, anyway. So that's a total [1:15:36] Speaker B (unidentified): of six or ten? Sorry. We have six right now? That were condemned. We have six total that are condemned. Two that were already. Two that were already. So we have four that were working. And actually one of the four, they were able to get their repairs, which was were the floors repaired within a day i think they did it and they just didn't want to be they were scared and i understand that but they didn't want to they have dogs and they the problem with placing people in hotels is they don't know who yeah so they just they got their repairs done and they were not displaced at all so it was just three families so can you talk about the state yeah okay so well first just a little backstory josh and i and codes went out spent the day i was there to provide support resources and let them know that they could come you know we'll do an application and see where they fall for assistance help and so out of the four three families we had to place in a hotel very quickly so i couldn't see them on that day so we did a presumptive eligibility to get them through the night and then the next day they came in to see us and so at that point i knew My limitations were, because there was a new law for general assistance as of last year, that we are not allowed to assist more than 30 days in a 12-month period for short-term housing, which is a hotel, campground, anything short-term. And then you have to qualify for those 30 days. so it kind of limits what i'm able to help if there's income in the home we take all of that into consideration so one of the families had no income and they were actually they have rental housing helping them pay their rent so we what we did there was we did the application They qualified for two weeks in a hotel room. And then I spoke with Greg Payne and Adam Rhea, and we came up with a plan to bridge the gap where GA falls short, they could help assist with these families so they can stay in a hotel. so we're kind of working together and the family that i just mentioned could come back in 30 days they could qualify for another two weeks but that's their 30 days so after that if they're still not in their home then it'll you know i am in contact almost daily with main housing and the governor's office and we're trying to you know make sure that bridge stays there but it is short term you know so we have to really and I'm working with the families calling them daily or they're calling me and telling me how they're you know what's happening with the repairs and I think we're getting closer we're getting closer the one home that was that they bought they and they just spread the land had no water they moved in March it was they were promised water, and they had no water since March. And they're such people that they didn't want to make waves, so they just kind of just went like this. And so they used the bathroom at the laundromat, and then they went to the rec center to take showers. And so every time they tried to reach out to the property manager or the owner, they would not get an answer. So it's just very frustrating. and then you keep your head down because you don't want to be evicted so and then there's the one family had electrical issues and the electrician said that it was so bad that it could have gone up and then that's been fixed their floors are now being fixed one of the bedrooms was the living room was done the bedrooms and the bathroom needed to be done and it was weeks before they could get anybody to even answer them or come out so that you know josh has been trying to put some pressure on that and when he does things start to happen and then they kind of wean off again so this week those floors should be done by the end of the week hopefully and then maybe the family can look back in from there but a re-inspection has to be done at that point and then the last family the two weeks she's going to come in next week and we'll do another application she'll qualify for another two weeks and then that the 30 days is done but like i said main street housing is bridging the gap thankfully [1:20:59] Speaker A (unidentified): and so it's a good coordinated response that i will say it just highlights where we things we never knew what were happening and how these how people are just taking these terrible conditions on because they're fear of eviction you know so this is a good opportunity for those families [1:21:16] Speaker B (unidentified): to take advantage of the for the critical home repair program if you have to they have to so they're all renters sorry yeah another word on that would just they bought the home in march and we've established all those resources for them we also i encourage them to contact have country rule and so they're working very closely with country rule cory and then [1:21:47] Speaker C (unidentified): what if anything is the town doing to hold the landlord i mean to me this person should be [1:21:58] Speaker A (unidentified): fined so let me tell you what josh said they the state is going they have an like the district attorney or assistant district attorney this they will be going after the MRT director [1:22:09] Speaker C (unidentified): I understand but that's like if you're saying will be I mean that doesn't do anything like it to me and again this is my lack of knowledge in this area to me this is something that [1:22:26] Speaker E (unidentified): there should be a penalty [1:22:27] Speaker C (unidentified): the town should be able to assess it immediately so that the landlord or the property manager whoever is responsible for that it should be marking you know adding up from day one so that these poor residents well i think the emergency [1:22:47] Speaker A (unidentified): situation of keeping them housed is like number one and i think yeah how do we get so you're right you're not wrong about like we had to identify get the owner and now like josh is saying apparently, you know, he's saying to me that the landlord is making these fixes, but, you know, it sounds like it's a lot of work to stay on them to continue to make sure these things are being done. And then on top of it, what is the, you know. [1:23:11] Speaker D (unidentified): But not just that. I mean, he's making a map. Oh, yeah. [1:23:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Like, these are not things that just happened. Oh, yeah. One day that they woke up and their floor was disintegrating or the electrical system was going to explode. like this is long-term neglect that you know now that we're aware of it should be that the town and maybe we need to create an ordinance for that we are holding these slumlords [1:23:39] Speaker B (unidentified): because that's what that is so this is exactly what's needed a lot of people don't realize that there is common law an implied warranty of habitability exactly the problem is there's no enforcement for it because you have to go to court and none of these people have access to court. It's not a fast solution. So yes, the right exists in law. There's an implied warranty of habitability written into every single [1:24:07] Speaker E (unidentified): rental apartment. The point is different. As a town, we could pass an ordinance that says if you violate basic safety and health for your tenants, you can be fined under civil ordinance in the town. We could issue fines. exactly questions like the rest i'm sorry the first question is do we currently have any basis to assess fines on a landlord brandy you know or for not providing they have a little out there [1:24:33] Speaker D (unidentified): but i will tell you in the conversation that i have with john i'm sorry not john josh can we define who josh is for josh is the fire chief but he's also the health officer at the time so i think it's actually under the role of health officer in the situation and in the conversation i had with him about the court he did mention the fact that they incurred a fine because i mean i'm not complying oh that's horrible understandable right but there's also i mean there's there's steps i mean and again i don't know enough i know enough to be dangerous but i know that there are mechanisms in place and again it goes back to the you know what the council wants to do and he was really unsure and he put fines that were [1:25:21] Speaker C (unidentified): applicable to what was allowed when we weren't even right you know so we should as a council [1:25:27] Speaker E (unidentified): maybe look at adopting an ordinance something that is not here you assess more robust penalties [1:25:33] Speaker C (unidentified): on like a service level or penalty as an example yes this is a big body yeah okay so sorry [1:25:42] Speaker A (unidentified): we've got 35 minutes left okay and you've got until several things to get [1:25:49] Speaker C (unidentified): to Ramona and then Melissa I got into it they're actually already but I wanted to [1:25:57] Speaker D (unidentified): know Debbie mentioned putting at least one of them in touch with I'm truly go are you talking about the whole bunch of people or just everyone that we met with [1:26:06] Speaker B (unidentified): on that whether they were condemned or not i gave them a list of resources and i encouraged them to qualify because every single one of those residents said that they had issues getting [1:26:20] Speaker D (unidentified): anything repaired in the home because i mean it sounds like you know they all were paying rent on properties that were not actually rentable exactly yeah i mean going into some of these homes [1:26:34] Speaker B (unidentified): I was walking up the stairs and I felt like oh my god I'm gonna go through the stairs and the windows were cracked a little bit you know and this at the beginning of the year they the landlord sent a message to everyone they had paid the in the heat was included in their rent this year they were not going to do that so now everybody on top of the $1,500 rent was going to have to pay the heating cost it's going to have to pay the heating cost so not only did they do that but isn't that an increase in what they're getting for rent now it depends on what's in the leaks and if they have a lease renewal that excludes it then it's no longer included and so this is where understanding, right? Lawyers, y'all say what's in the paperwork, right? It's including all, it depends on what's in paperwork. So every time somebody renews, their renewal under the new lease is going to be excluded. I think that an ordinance is going to have to address all of these things because people are not taking legal advice. Like who takes legal advice to review your rental contract, right? Before you sign up. Okay, yeah. [1:27:58] Speaker D (unidentified): which was so in our ordinance for mobile home park rent stabilization that we've asked there was a section not about that stabilization that was about like which they applied to parks that like this where people aren't renting just the land they're like renting the whole unit obviously in there the fines were structured in such a way that like if there's a timeline that has been kind of agreed to and the park owner is not complying with that 's when the fines start getting levied and they were like per day fines if i remember correctly it sounds like that was what was just being described of like oh like when we get on them about it, they start fixing it, and then they just kind of stop until [1:28:47] Speaker C (unidentified): we get on to them about it again. [1:28:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Isn't that exactly the case? [1:28:50] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't know. We can look at that. [1:28:53] Speaker D (unidentified): That's a very force behind this. It sounds like we already have. I'm not sure whether [1:29:01] Speaker A (unidentified): the fines were in that section, though. So I think we've got to look into that. There was something in there, but I just want to... We'll have to look. We'll talk to our attorney on that. [1:29:13] Speaker B (unidentified): exactly what I was going to say which is great and I just want to remind our committee that we had dismissed fines for this first year and some were concerned so I just want to keep that in mind when if and then we talk about dismissing fines that's true [1:29:28] Speaker A (unidentified): we did that for the rental we [1:29:33] Speaker D (unidentified): did something for the rental [1:29:35] Speaker B (unidentified): we had a safety thing yeah [1:29:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Celeste and then I just want to say that I was at the block conference two weeks ago and she doubled me aside hold on folks okay he pulled me aside to specifically talk about Zoe for and he was appalled by what had happened and he wanted it to be put out in the news it was in the news so this is why I think we brought this here I think the bigger picture is we need and I want and talked to Greg Payne about this, and hopefully they'll work on it. And we've worked on it, and our ordinance is giving the tenants protection because these, like you said, if it didn't happen overnight, and why weren't the tenants feeling secure enough to come to the town and say what was going on? You could put all the fines on, [1:30:30] Speaker C (unidentified): but you didn't know about it. [1:30:32] Speaker A (unidentified): And so if you don't know about it, you can't help these poor people that are afraid they're going to be evicted. And so what we need are protections for retaliation. Again, one more thing. Maybe we don't have to be. I don't think it's just mobile. I think it needs to be. So that's why we do need a better fix, not just for this, but for maybe it's a separate. Well, maybe related to the rental registry. Maybe to the registry. [1:31:00] Speaker C (unidentified): We should not be. OK. [1:31:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Katie, and then. I did a lot of research, eviction, talked to a lot of tenants about eviction and about, I think one of the key things that's missing from the whole calculus is people with lived experience of the problem. Oftentimes those of us around these tables are coming up with the ideas of how to solve the problem. One of the things that came out of my research specifically was that for a lot of tenants, they're not framing what they have as a legal problem. They think it's a different kind of problem. and so I would recommend that as we think about enforcement we also have to think about the tenant experience holistically we need you a lot more research I'm sorry a lot more outreach I'm gonna do a ton of outreach and we need to have people doing the outreach who are members of the community it can't come from external people who look like me and talk like me it really needs to come from within the community and we have to figure out how to compensate people for doing that i think when we go yeah just say yeah anyway okay well thank [1:32:11] Speaker A (unidentified): you deb do you have any final word you wanted to share on this topic you know continuing to [1:32:19] Speaker B (unidentified): support the families and it's been a lot of work thank you thank you thank you about that [1:32:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I'm concerned about Fran and some other responsibilities this week. I've been going to those and eventually I'm going to be worked on and soon just be fully Fran's committee, but we did have our first hearing and I did want her to be able to come. Yeah. [1:32:54] Speaker D (unidentified): We have mobile home parks, as you know, that are currently qualified and that have to go, if any increases in their grants, have to go through the board. Two of them, the board in Coastline, I believe, came in at the 4.4% increase, which was allowed, so they didn't have to go to the board. I'm going to be aware if I did say I ended up coming in the fourth with four plus an additional nine dollars and sixty cents per mobile home, regardless of what you were paying for. We had so that required a hearing. We've met, we've met total of three times prior to get ready for October 13th. We held a hearing where, first, they made the agency folks have an opportunity to present their case as to why they felt they should be able to charge additional amount. But then there was also an opportunity for tenants to speak and present some facts that they may have had on the situation. At the end of that, luckily, our talent attorney was there and did a great job, and she's writing up things. the board made a decision to deny that so they will not be able to charge the additional nine point nine dollars and sixty cents per month per month per month per unit regardless of what you were paying so for some people that was between a five and six percent increase depending on the amount you were paying for that prior to that it was very interesting it is we did we saved it resumed it so if anyone hasn't watched it was a very interesting meeting to watch i would say it was a good process it showed they gave them an opportunity and again you know the case was not strong enough i'm not saying it would be other times it would be strong enough you know and i know i've been asked actually by a couple of tenants the next step and as far as so under our view that they would be able to charge in the 4.4 percent which is what was allowed under the c how that goes as far as state requirement of the 90 days so in other words if they now have to re-notice the folks say now it's going to be [1:35:07] Speaker A (unidentified): they don't know that they're even challenging the 90 day notification because not everybody the letter said the first but not everybody is saying they received oh that was the second issue [1:35:20] Speaker D (unidentified): that was the issue of if now that they can charge a lesser or they can only do the 4.4%. Do they have to be noticed? Is it another 98? That's a really big question on the board question. And what Sally is referring to is that many of the tenants that September 1st notice became that they did not receive it in a timely manner. Our town attorney, we did not. It was actually something that had to go to the town manager. She's actually the person that does the enforcement of it as the ordinance. and the attorney deemed that was not something that would prohibit the that wasn't something that she felt that we could enforce as far as the board so that [1:36:02] Speaker A (unidentified): even went to the state level and the state attorney would not also would not take a position so [1:36:08] Speaker D (unidentified): right so that piece of what we were so that I just don't have the answer to that question I might reach out to because I know she was also working on that and find out I'll reach out to the state I just [1:36:18] Speaker A (unidentified): have been slightly busy [1:36:26] Speaker C (unidentified): I was so impressed by the board they were phenomenal the questions that they asked the care that they took it was it was wonderful I was sitting in the back of the room the whole time and I thought that they did such a great job and not just because I was happy with the outcome from the questions were very thoughtful and they certainly listened to everybody the second one during this whole process i feel like we should go back and better define that 90-day piece because i think that really because there's not there's some ambiguity to it that no offense but the property management took advantage, I think, of the fact that they should have either been certified so that it could be designated as to what day it was sent out. Or they should have mailed it out so that it got to the people by the 1st. And from my opinion, understanding it. So I think we need to go back in and fix that piece of the ordinance. [1:37:33] Speaker D (unidentified): And what I will say is, the 90 days is not actually referenced in the ordinance. It's the state statute. but it would have been nice [1:37:42] Speaker A (unidentified): that weighed in on that [1:37:44] Speaker D (unidentified): so I think maybe we should define [1:37:48] Speaker C (unidentified): what we say should happen so that it's not a question again because I think that I think there's a difficulty [1:37:56] Speaker D (unidentified): whenever you file anything with the United States Postal Service having absentee ballots there's no guarantee if they had mailed it out [1:38:06] Speaker C (unidentified): but if it had been certified they could have proven that they had sent it out on time. Yes. And I think that's what we live to do. [1:38:15] Speaker D (unidentified): I think I hear about this a lot, and it is basically, unless you're like, you know, get like a, somebody to serve the meal. It really probably gets very expensive and difficult to, really require, I mean, we could require it, but, standardizing it to like, you have to show proof that you mailed all of these out on a certain day. We have that. We have that. It's interesting. That's a great point. Because in the ordinance, part of it, they had to give a 12-day, at least a 12-day notice of the period that was occurring. And they actually did provide us something that through they had gone and done this mailing at the first time. So they could, in fact, we could have even defined that, and that would have illustrated that they had mailed to you. That's what I want. That's what I want. [1:39:04] Speaker C (unidentified): but for the 90 day i thought that they did not have proof that they did not no they did not [1:39:10] Speaker D (unidentified): they had proof that they did the 12 days oh yeah there's no reason that we couldn't do that [1:39:16] Speaker A (unidentified): could not make that because right and then yeah if that is actually that is actually probably the other one that did submit did it two weeks ahead of time so we were fine right and they were They're like, well, why did they have it on the 1st? Like, the last day that you could actually... [1:39:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Because you don't receive it on that day. Right. I just... I don't think that they're good news. [1:39:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Brief,, brief, please. Did you say 1 or 2? Sorry, just 1 hearing? 1 hearing. I don't know what's in the relevant state statute or ordinance. There is, however, an implied contractual term in the United States. It's called the postal rule. and it does mark the date that something is sent as the date that the 90 days in this case would be activated and if the council wants to change that they would have to specifically note that either an ordinance or it would have to be something they require to be updated on visas [1:40:15] Speaker C (unidentified): that are available post office is no longer putting post marks anybody that brought their [1:40:21] Speaker B (unidentified): envelope in there was nothing on there and so it's incumbent upon the person relying on it to demonstrate proof that's how it worked right out in court yeah all right so we'll have to work [1:40:32] Speaker C (unidentified): on that yeah that's what i think would make life easier we've got three other items yeah i just didn't finish the one thing okay like about we've got actually several other items the other [1:40:45] Speaker D (unidentified): piece about that notice is that some people say that they didn't receive it at all so like taking that into account in our notice thing you know some people like it was sent to their old address even though the landlord really should know where they live because they rent the property to them like there's some pretty obvious kind of mistakes that were made in that process that seem like they should be something that the town can take input from thank you yeah thank you appreciate it i'm going to go into them yeah go ahead yeah we're just running through these [1:41:20] Speaker A (unidentified): So this is, okay, actually, I'm going to let Chrissy do CDBG phase two. Perfect. [1:41:27] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, we're doing a council on Monday for a public hearing on the CDBG application phase two for Brunswick Bay Cooperative to replace 16 family subject systems. [1:41:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Only if you want me to do that one. Any questions on that? No. [1:41:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. And then, not much. We signed an MOA with Dory Art, so that sort of secures the project for them, and we're working on figuring out some of the details, and then kind of start the purchase and sale [1:42:03] Speaker C (unidentified): agreement. Do you have any idea how long the process might take? [1:42:07] Speaker B (unidentified): That depends on, it could, you know, it depends on a lot of things, so I don't know. know we would like it to be quickly the central fire station took a year but the front fire [1:42:20] Speaker A (unidentified): station was special so i don't this one might have some nuances too so i would say just that we will hope to have a better and more robust report next month did they i'm maybe i'm [1:42:32] Speaker C (unidentified): wrong but like we talked about that auxiliary building did they want to get that started [1:42:38] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah their plan was to get that done a year before the rest of the building but again there's i think a lot of moving pieces we'll have a much better report next time okay thomas point road [1:42:49] Speaker A (unidentified): affordable housing that's the shareholder project 23 thomas point road just so people know that you know that was there was a petition against the approval for the there was an amendment that was brought to the planning board and it was it was but the basis was it has to do with certain Cook's Corner design standards being met. And at the time when they first went through and got standing with their planning board approval, it was in 2024. And it took two years for them to get through all of their planning development approvals and get their financing and everything. And in that time frame, within that time frame, a few months after they were approved, actually, the Cook's Corner design standards were approved. So anyway, they came back with this amendment. It had to do primarily with their stormwater and having stormwater on site. They had a very expensive stormwater system that was underground collection, and it was over-designed. And so it helped, you know, it made their project costs go up, and they were able to find out that it was over-engineered. So they went back to this other system, and then a few other things happened, changes happened. And so then there was a petition about Jennifer Navarro that it didn't meet all Cooks Corners. So they had it got remanded back, that was the zoning board appeal, got remanded back to the planning board. Our staff worked very hard, literally going through every Cooks Corners design standard and showing how it met those standards. And the planning board approved that and then it got petitioned again by Jennifer Navarro I went back to the zoning board appeals, and it ended up that was, what is the correct term? I guess it was deny the appeal. So that was not needed. So it was a four-hour meeting. I stayed for the whole meeting. During our town council meeting, I was in the first hour, and she stayed for the whole thing. Yeah. I never made it to the town council meeting even though I wanted to but I thought it was important to stay for that hearing and [1:45:03] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah what was the split [1:45:05] Speaker A (unidentified): what was the split so there were two people who had [1:45:18] Speaker B (unidentified): we could probably look at the minutes right [1:45:20] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah you probably could [1:45:22] Speaker A (unidentified): there were two people specific items. Yeah. And one of the people that one item in the in the appeal that didn't think that the other had several concerns. But now it's asked, Yeah, does it go back to the bleeding? It went back to the I think it goes back to Okay. Did it already go back to the planning board? I don't know. I'm not sure what the next step is. I'll double-check that. It's already come back to the planning board. Jennifer does have the option to go to court to appeal the appeal, if you will. [1:46:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, but that's going to be my right. Yeah. [1:46:21] Speaker A (unidentified): The circuit court, but the superior court, superior court or supreme court. I'm not sure what that was, but anyway, she would have to pay for it. [1:46:29] Speaker C (unidentified): She would. That would be costing her money. It would. Yeah. [1:46:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Because she's just in yourself representing yourself. Yeah. Any questions about that? So the next item, and then I do need to leave time for committing comments because we've got three people reporting on a lot of things and I don't see any public unless yeah oh other than Poppy just raise her hand she will probably have something that she wants to share in your packing the materials that you have, there is a list of potential goals and strategies for 2026 and 2027, for that year span. Sally, Celeste, and I and Chrissy met and drafted and brainstormed about where we see the things going what we think are some of our priorities there's a ton of stuff we could do and these are the things that we thought surfaced to the top or rose to the top look it over if you have ideas or feedback you want to provide email Sally and me and you can call me Celeste too and we'll bring them back at a future meeting. [1:48:09] Speaker C (unidentified): Is the raise the $250,000 in addition to like... [1:48:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, now that was just... I mean, I asked for more. Yeah. But that was, you know... [1:48:16] Speaker D (unidentified): So that is $325,000. Yeah, that's right. [1:48:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. I will say that... Okay, so last year I said that I thought this was going to be... That was going to be a variable policy and it absolutely was. I would like to see there... I mean, affordable housing has obviously so many strategies and so many it's so layered with different things that we need to address we i'd like to see some a little bit of balance on having some policy stuff some preservation stuff some production you know fundraising like having if we focus on everything though we focus on nothing so that's why we kind of pick some things that we thought might just be things that we could actually accomplish and things that maybe we need to get back to right so but also we this is all of us as you know sort of the staff and the leadership you guys might have other thoughts on that so we're not expecting you to react today but just to know that we're trying to we just want to keep it to a list that is really achievable we don't want to have all these things and then we don't make any we don't strive on anything so just think about even things you heard today like i was thinking wow okay one of the things we did want to have one policy it was great to get something every year so what if it is the thing that we just talked about going back and looking at a policy that addresses how do we say this in such a negative way, but it is. How do we go after people who are not being good landlords, who are really having egregious things that are happening and not just for mobile homes but town life. We're uncovering a lot of things because of the work we're doing and how do we have some corrective action there, whether it's care or sick or a combination of both. That could be an example of an ordinance and there's other things that we're working on i'm working on something with poppy right now that kind of overlaps in this area we found with the rent review board that we had we don't have the ability to protect information like economic development i have in this field we have these statutes state statutes that we can cite that takes us into an executive session we don't for our boards don't have all that protection which is hard because we want our board our boards and committees to have wholesome understanding of what's going on so they can make really good decisions. But we can't say to the other side, we can protect your information and therefore they don't give it to us. And so we're working on, like with POPI, to say, how do we make some tweaks in that state law that allow us so that they can sign our boards, let's say, boards and committee can sign a non-disclosure so we can take them in an executive session and give them all the information so that they can have better [1:50:51] Speaker B (unidentified): information to have. [1:50:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Can you clarify the examples [1:50:54] Speaker A (unidentified): examples of that type of information well that so that like an example would be for the rent review board they might not give us all that like landlords might not give us all their information about their some of their like some of their financials right like their business financials and so we can't get to you know because we can't protect that information whereas I can ask for that in economic development, and I do, because we don't just give because people ask. We verify, and I don't get into the whole spiel about that. But I'm just saying, like, our boards and committees don't necessarily get that same advantage to be able to get that information. So I'm just using the grant review board as an example, because the landlord may have offered up some things, like, on their reserve accounts. And we could have actually examined the documents, but they could just talk about it. We didn't get to examine it. So, you know, it's that verification piece that doesn't give you a lot of confidence, or at least the board, they just kind of, it becomes more subjective, which we don't want to do, especially in cases like that, are impacting people's lives and how, you know, how they might, how we might say, yeah, you actually, there is a real reason, let's say, that they needed to make some kind of an improvement that was a reasonable improvement because we examined their financials, for example. I mean, when they changed what line items. Well, that was an example. Yeah, they moved, they adhered to move, you know, things around from capital expenditures to, you know, operating, you know, like, and we had no way to say whether this was true. Right. So, or whether it was standard accounting, standard accounting practice. [1:52:40] Speaker B (unidentified): So are you suggesting that we review these and we are going to discuss the next meeting? So you'd like input by then or what's the. [1:52:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, anytime you can send input to Carol and I and Celeste and we can just I mean, I think we should do one or two. I mean, you can just you can just see all of us. But just to say that, well, you know, this is just a start, but we do we'd like to have something like some goals for this group. Yeah. You know, we want to have some direction this year. [1:53:09] Speaker B (unidentified): And we're going to discuss it at the next meeting. Yes, I just want to give people a tip. Yes, thank you. [1:53:12] Speaker A (unidentified): That would be great. Yes. Okay, so here's what we have left. Celeste has a couple of things that she wants to report on. Melissa wants to give an update on the Warming Center. I had a couple of quick, just very brief things, and I gathered poppy. [Speaker D (unidentified): And our meeting.] And just quickly, when I looked at the next meeting date, november 25th i realized that's the day before thanksgiving yeah so and then i looked at december which would be december 23rd so we're looking at maybe not meeting in november but having a meeting possibly december 9th or 16th so to keep it to a wednesday so we got to check on room availability but just you know you don't have to answer this right now yeah we are missing a couple of members anyway. But look at your calendars and let us know if either or both of those dates are possible for you. So that way, you know, we're not I feel bad that we're skipping you. I'm actually going to be gone that whole week. But I also think that six weeks isn't that bad, right? And I'll give us time to get more done. So Celeste, why don't you give us your two updates? Okay, just really quick. MOCA, the main office of community affairs, has taken over manufactured housing and they're looking to rewrite the rules and laws on that. They're going to be reporting to the legislature in January 2027. So they've had some public meetings and it's way too much to even report. So if you're interested, just go online and check out MOCA, what they're doing. The good news is that the Attorney General's Office has hired a new person just to address housing issues. And Pintree Legal hired a new person to work with the lawyers that handle client cases. And MOCA is going to have a point-of-contact person to help residents know where to go. That is the biggest thing, is knowing who to talk to when you have a complaint, when you have a problem. So they're going to be working on that. Main Office of Community Affairs. Main Office of Community Affairs. Yeah. It's that new office. [1:55:34] Speaker B (unidentified): I just define acronyms generally because it's always something he does. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. [1:55:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And then your other was rock training. Rock training. Oh, I went to the resident-owned community training, and we're dealing with a lot of the same infrastructure is huge. A lot of the local home parks have failing septic systems. Some aren't on-town water. Some are. And how do we pay for it? So that's a huge issue that we're hoping that the legislature maybe can get some funding to help with the infrastructure where they get that money from i don't know and greg pain talked about putting fees on people that are building mobile home parks and people that have affordable housing if they don't have enough units they will pay a fee like ten thousand dollars for each unit they don't have so there are ways i think it was out-of-state to have to pay like higher transfer taxes out-of-state. Yes, that's something we had to go through before, too. So, yes. So, the usual problem is we need funds. Where are they going to come from? We can't keep putting it on homeowners' taxes. But it was great training, and if I get reappointed to the housing committee, I hope to get more involved with Augusta and the legislature. Thank you. You're the resource. True. Both Melissa and celeste are you both have had your okay i'm going to sign you in an ad and yeah thank you thank you okay [1:57:26] Speaker B (unidentified): melissa by the time we meet next the warming center will be open at 110 anyway it'll be open calling that russell's place we are going to start calling russell's place yes it's just one tiny way and it'll be run by tedford november 15th to the april 30th and i want to thank every all the organizations that have come to support the warming center and any guests that need warmth and shelter i think this winter please know that we also are making a list of places just to be warm because a lot of people kind of a lot of inflation this year on ways to stay warm and so look for information on the gathering place hours where anyone can go to [1:58:14] Speaker A (unidentified): be warm and places to be warm this winter man just add that me chrissy and i met with mary connelly and with abby king at least on their board and they have asked us to assist with the cpg i'm telling the counselors and it's a fifty thousand dollar they're they've big talk to the ecd and this would be for special social projects and so it's up to fifty thousand dollars so we did get a tour of the space it's really nice you guys if you ever get a chance you should go look at it 's got it's fully renovated with bathrooms upstairs they're separating families from the general population they've got you know bathroom facilities and showers and a little pitch a big kitchen area actually it's really and they have a check-in area for people which i think will help on the security side and even as you know they came to the council for money on the security so i think it's really a great fulsome response to some of the issues that they had last year and that was a very difficult year for everybody including the people who you know are that working for the town and the police and everything so including the people that need to be more well that needed to be one all of it until around first year throwing things whatever but i feel like they've really done a great job in like can i withdraw those things and we want to be part of the solution so we're going to [1:59:33] Speaker C (unidentified): help with the cbg so okay hit the town council well i what i didn't understand at the meeting like we didn't really put that request forward like that's what i didn't understand so i'm not sure like how that's going to be the funding request the 25 000. oh yeah like we didn't know what you did on that we didn't do anything yeah that's what i did with the I don't think you could check the time control yeah so but that's my only like I didn't I was kind of surprised like that we didn't have a motion or something like that I was kind of [2:00:07] Speaker B (unidentified): waiting to see what the next steps were yeah okay I'm going to infer the DECD stands for Department of Economic and Community Development thank you I was taking that role but what I wanted to mention was not for this year but perhaps for plans if there's warming center funds for next year I watched the October 6th Biddefer city council meeting it's available online where they had a very long 45 minute conversation around homelessness and it's very easy to find they have a nice table of contents attached to their videos I encourage everybody to go and watch one of the things that they talked about which I think runs what you talk about is the fact that for their warming center they do not refer families there but importantly they also do not use general assistance housing funds for single adults they make a strategic decision to reserve general assistance funds for households with children and refer single adults to other resources in that case seeds of hope from their warming center distinct one of the things that i would like to see brunswick do is understand the developmental needs of households with children it's not appropriate for them to be in a shelter it's really not a congregate shelter I'm excluding Tedford housing out of it in their program but I would love for us to watch what happens in Biddeford ask questions about what they're doing in Biddeford they also just FYI are allocating $455,000 of municipal funding to sustain the warming center which I think is something I we'd like to see more municipalities contemplate but just note how they're talking about homeless response how they're allocating municipal resources for community outreach and how they're thinking about leveraging assets in the community to meet the specific needs of different sub populations we would like to clarify that the town did write for a grant and so yeah [2:02:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, we did help with the acquisition. [2:02:11] Speaker B (unidentified): The gathering place is owned, so no rental costs happen every year. And families are absolutely, the hope is they don't go to the warming center. There's a location if they come, but we are working for the Coastal Youth Center, who has the state funding to work with families. So the hope is that there's a team that intervenes and takes management before the family gets there or the next morning and divert them to some other place yeah and it's not and this is why i say not for this year right but i think it's an interesting conversation we've had long conversations about general assistance how to use it and all the rest of it that there's a lot of intersections for some of these things i'm just curious to see biddeford has been on radar in terms of they don't have a year-round shelter in york county so they're having to come up with some creative ways to meet needs it's just an interesting strategic level conversations that i think align with some of the things that we're talking about and i just stay curious people watch [2:03:13] Speaker C (unidentified): that 45 minutes very entertaining i would just really quickly like to say that from my perspective that they're good for them assuming because she said there's no other facility in what county is all these service centers i think that the state should be providing assistance to the service centers because the surrounding communities where these people are coming from are not providing and so then it's the community that has the service center that is funding everything and that is wrong and i mean i'm not advocating that brunswick not do that but what i'm advocating for is on the state level is that should be acknowledged and that there should be funds dispersed to those service centers in lieu of the fact that the surrounding communities are not helping the service center community provide those services and i think that's a big thing because [2:04:14] Speaker B (unidentified): yes pick your service center community i go to all of them and they all have the same deep-seated concern and I would love to see more service center communities come together [2:04:25] Speaker A (unidentified): and advocate for change at the state house yeah okay my two quick announcements one I was up at the University of Maine over three weeks ago and got to meet with or with the new engineering building that is now coordinating with the advanced structures and composites program. And I talked with them about the 3D printed homes. They are still in prototypes. So they had some, the prototype that they had out for about two years now, I think, they recognized some problems that developed with that prototype. They're working on other materials they might use. They have this project lined up in Brunswick, Baymoor area, and they're going to have to do that in phases and see how, you know, build three, see how they do, give it a little time, build three more, et cetera. So point being that the 3D printed home through the university and the system is not a viable option for any of us to be considering in the near future as something to do here. The other thing I wanted to mention, and I won't embarrass Katie, you heard some wonderful discussion between katie and doreen this afternoon if you would like to hear more on friday november 13th at 6 p.m at first parish church we're doing a windows on housing forum both doreen and katie are on the panel that will be interviewed by our senior pastor and also Jamie door who was here recently and Hadley Austin who is very helpful with people who are experiencing homelessness all are welcome and it will be in our sanctuary is there like good something that you can email us I have something that I emailed out to the whole collaborative and I will forward it to the housing committee. Housing committee. And this I'm putting back down on the bulletin board downstairs. Okay. I know we're over time. The only thing I want to say is I've had the – Can you come up to the table so we can hear you? [2:07:16] Speaker C (unidentified): The only thing I wanted to mention, and just to really want to thank you all, you're doing such an excellent job with all the issues you're dealing with. The only thing I would add to any of this is that I don't know how the general public interacts with this committee. You know, town council meeting where people step up to the podium during the first time hour. And I'm seeing more and more constituents that I'm engaging with just either having concerns related to housing or the one I just quickly wanted to share with you. about a constituent who lives on [street], two young women, and their landlord is refusing to repair the heat. So for less than a week, they've been without any heat. I was able to find out that the codes enforcement process, I think today the codes enforcement officer was finally [2:08:03] Speaker B (unidentified): able to show up. But even [2:08:04] Speaker C (unidentified): when you follow all the rules, we're talking at least a month before anything can be done to compel a landlord to do anything about it. And even then, they can just refuse. I mean, the enforcement of these issues is really bleak and so i'd like to see some this is an ask i have all of you some mechanism for the public to engage with this committee that would be this may not be possible it would not be owners for you number one because you're all here serving the public giving up your time etc and not owners for the public it could be something on the website the town of brunswick website just when you i don't know when you advertise your meetings if you have a message or concern for the committee to consider you know you somewhere because i'm just really i'm a state legislator i have no agency here other than to listen to people and pass it along and i'm encouraging people but we're going to encourage them to go to the codes office but still i think you should you're you're taking more and more of a role of really important role in our community around housing and i think you're doing such a great job it would be great if we could communicate more directly i have concern with that because it's [2:09:26] Speaker A (unidentified): another place that we have to monitor and like respond back to i still i think the mind that we have this committee i think that any public member can come and we can continue to encourage people to come. [2:09:38] Speaker B (unidentified): And we can also just insert there all of our meetings on the front page of the website [2:09:42] Speaker C (unidentified): on the calendar. Well, then maybe when you do your public comment time, instead of putting it at the end of the meeting, putting it at the beginning, because I was very interested in everything you talked about. But I don't think a member of the general public could sit through the meeting and know [2:09:57] Speaker A (unidentified): it until the end. Yeah, that's not a bad idea. Yeah, that's not a bad idea. [2:10:02] Speaker C (unidentified): But I totally get how, what a gift your time is for our community, and I wouldn't want you to take on anything. [2:10:09] Speaker A (unidentified): And it's not that we don't want to hear it, but honestly, we would refer those kind of issues to all the planning, like to that department. And so that's the only thing, is like, this is a working committee, and obviously any public can attend, and they should feel free to do that, and also give public comment. [2:10:26] Speaker C (unidentified): And I'm sure with people, all these field streets and things. yeah right so yeah my constituents but anybody just in general right and you're also right and [2:10:38] Speaker A (unidentified): then they can they then they do anyway like bring stuff that their constituents say so maybe referring them to the counselors and then the counselors can you know either bring it up at [2:10:47] Speaker C (unidentified): the meeting or like refer stuff to them so the only other thing i want to mention was since we're about to know who our legislators are going to be for the 133 will all be decided next Well, at some point, it could all be voted on. [2:11:04] Speaker E (unidentified): It's going to be an election day. [2:11:05] Speaker C (unidentified): And I was thinking it'd be so wonderful because you're all so engaged. If sometime, either in January or that was convenient to your schedule, I could help you arrange for either a Zoom conversation or a conversation. I don't know if Representative Geer would be willing to come here, but she, you all think you know that is the chair of the housing committee. She's amazing. she is so engaged with the public she's so she's so robust and taking on and i think it would be great for you to have a conversation for it that would be great yeah that'd be great maybe we get a little prepared for that too so i hope that you have questions i'd like to see the state do and by i'm saying january because we would want a sense of what the bills would be that you might be interested in right and i was just thinking you know i'm all about inspiration so if you're [2:11:56] Speaker A (unidentified): interested we can talk about it and i can help when the bills have to be submitted though that [2:12:02] Speaker C (unidentified): we don't know that it's either going to be the very end of december or the first week for two of january yeah it's a ways off still oh you mean there's a year or jam no but then you said it's a ways off that's not a way off that's so that's very quick to me i mean basically what i'm thinking you guys you have a one meeting before that right that's true and you're my age [2:12:27] Speaker B (unidentified): and the meeting should be on the night right for that now because yeah if we want if we want to if we want one of our legislators to put something in like we have to have it decided by the beginning of december so they have time to get something drafted i mean closure is one thing right but hearing from something else yeah i just want to say like i'm totally agree [2:13:03] Speaker C (unidentified): i think i would love to have us try to do something but i concern my concern with having representative bollock here to do it or the optics because we are actively working with her family and there's already concern that she's getting the favors or whatever [2:13:23] Speaker A (unidentified): and the reason that she would be appropriate though is she's on the housing i understand that [2:13:31] Speaker C (unidentified): but i don't want people to think that he's going to come and work with us on the house and then like because there's going to be a narrative about something and i don't want her to deal have to deal with that you know because that's not what's really happening but there's going to be i 'm just saying i think there's going to be some optics there's already a problem like with some people in town thinking that it's inappropriate you know for her to get some housing committee money for the project that they're doing on there even though i mean i do not i'm not at all you know but i'm just saying i think we should be careful about inviting her in particular because it's still in the process of her project getting approved can i just add this if she was if you invited her to report out on bills of interest that the committee is doing that's one thing if you were to invite her to report out on her own bills that she's doing that's where i think you could potentially people i don't think we should but it should be careful to make sure that we don't but the only reason i didn't think of representative because she the chair has a responsibility to the whole committee that individual members don't and this chair is particularly good at what she doesn't communicate in public but Cheryl would also be possible yeah well I may [2:14:53] Speaker B (unidentified): be looking here from all y'all right in terms of what means it because sometimes there are things that we talk about that do not actually end up in HED right so one of her bills that she's been an advocate for I have to reach out to her source of income discrimination that's not even HED that goes to judiciary there are places and general assistance goes to HHS so I think that if we have sort of areas of interest hearing from you, hearing from Cheryl, hearing from Dan hearing from Matt we could just have the delegation in terms of what is the landscape going to look like in Augusta this year, what are some of the things that we are advocating for? What are some of the things you can track? I certainly have access to a bill tracker that's coming out of HED. But other things that are in other committees, I don't know. We might be interested in transportation bills, for example, right, that are germane to housing, affordability, and access livability. So if we're going to have a legislative priority, I think it's always good to hear. and that maybe that we yeah everything absolutely just to say what's on the okay from the agenda [2:16:08] Speaker A (unidentified): i think i have a suggestion all this stuff sounds really good but we only have like two hours for meetings have you ever had like a housing retreat when i was on my motoring we had a retreat where we talked about goals and it was a little bit longer and it could be at some [2:16:54] Speaker E (unidentified): Maybe that's an executive session rule or something. We can ask. [2:16:57] Speaker C (unidentified): But it just seems like it would be a good strategy. [2:17:00] Speaker E (unidentified): We have a goal that, like, anytime you create more members of a group. [2:17:02] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah,, learning how to get in touch with each other. [2:17:06] Speaker A (unidentified): It just seems like it would be something where we could really focus on goals [2:17:11] Speaker B (unidentified): and degrees and educating ourselves on the scope of it. Yeah, exactly. That's what it is. [2:17:18] Speaker C (unidentified): But I don't think that's true because I think it has to be publicly noticed but like we could have like a community meeting where they've invited and three represent like three council members are going to go it has to be publicly noticed because there's going to be three council members there but it doesn't necessarily have to be here and televised so i think there's a difference like we can we can check on what exactly those would be [2:17:43] Speaker A (unidentified): do i have a motion to adjourn so moved second all in favor yeah thank you okay thank you [2:17:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you for taking so much time.