← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick Planning Board Approves Pier Project and Mixed-Use Development

2026-10-27 · 3h 48m · Source: 2026.10.27 Brunswick Planning Board (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. Welcome to the October 27th Brunswick Planning Board meeting I'll introduce everybody who's here currently Rob Burgess vice chair of the planning department Steve Walker next to Rob Allison Harris on my near left director of planning and development Julie Erdmann and our land use planner Matthew James, and I think Jimmy Dillman may be zooming in, our assistant director of planning, and I expect Laura Hatmaker to be here in the near future. We have four cases before us tonight, and the first is case number 2624, Elaine and Ken Crowe, peer replacement and shore stabilization. We tabled this project on October 13th, and they're coming back to us with some more details. Case number 25-001, Jones Farm Estates, the Major Development Review Final Plan. Case number 26-32, 53-69, Main Street Mixed-Use Development, named the J. This is a Major Development Review Final Plan. And case number 2523, Avalon Woods, Woodside Road Residential Subdivision, we're having a workshop based on the latest information that the developer has given to the staff review committee and to us. Matt, would you introduce our first project? We [2:00] Speaker B (unidentified): have case number 2624, the Elaine and Ken Crowe Peer Replacement and Shoreline Stabilization Project. The Planning Board will remove from the table and act upon a major development review, sketch, and final plan application submitted by Springtide Marine on behalf of the property owners, Elaine and Ken Crowe, for the replacement of a residential pier and dock and shoreline stabilization project. The subject property is located at 73 Minutes Shore Road, Map MP5, Law 12, and within the Rural Protection 1 Zone, as well as the Shoreline Protection Overlay, Shoreline Protection Overlay Stream Protection, Shoreline Protection Overlay Resource Protection, Flood Protection Overlay, and Rural Protection Stormwater Management Overlay Subdistricts. [2:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Matt. I'll make a motion to remove the project from table. Do I have a second? Second by Steve. All those in favor? that's unanimous of the board members present we've already deemed that the project is complete so we will go with that previous motion Brad you go ahead Alexis come on up and thank you very much for the work that you've done in the last two weeks, I appreciate it, and I think it's been – it's a lot clearer than it was before. Great. [3:47] Speaker C (unidentified): So we're going to talk about our parts of the project individually. So in terms of the peer stabilization project, we did do a supplemental analysis clarifying why we had designed the system as we did. So, and in the analysis, I don't want to review it in detail, but we, I think that we neglected to mention initially that there was like a large rock obstructing or like preventing a shorter pier, and as well as some of the reasons behind wanting to have the dock be easier to service seasonally, and also prepared for storms, and then also the increased access of the gangway slope. And I'm prepared to answer any questions that you might have. All right. [4:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Rob, you would like to start? [4:58] Speaker D (unidentified): No, I thought the added material was helpful to understand, particularly the location of that offshore rock the alternative might have been to try to remove that which would have done more to disturb the coastal immediate environment than just extending beyond it you know the slope of the ramp was understandable in terms of being able to not only safely access the float but also to remove the dock or the gangway in the event of storms so the just one question the length of the structure that's being replaced compared to this can you comment on how much further extended this is so [5:56] Speaker C (unidentified): the I believe it's 38 feet is a total extension so it would be replacing a four-foot permanent pier and a 32-foot gangway with a 38-foot pier and a 40-foot gangway. I'm terrible at doing math in my head, but I believe that is what the number came out to. All right. [6:21] Speaker D (unidentified): No, I really didn't have any other questions about it at this point, bill that it seemed that the issues we were concerned about are largely addressed okay steve [6:37] Speaker E (unidentified): thank you bill i too would like to thank you for the additional work last time i asked for the clarification that this was actually insignificant wildlife habitat you did that and you provided an alternatives analysis which i also requested which you know i think given the significance of tidal Weidenberg waterfowl habitat. We should expect the same from future applicants. So I thank you for setting the bar. It's important that we show the need to put structures or lengthen structures in this habitat type because it is declining and there are cumulative impacts. So kudos to the work you put in and I've got no further questions. [7:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Alison, anything to add? [7:24] Speaker F (unidentified): No, thank you. I did watch the last presentation, even though I wasn't here. But thank you. The materials you provided were very clear. All right. [7:36] Speaker A (unidentified): I agree with all of my colleagues. And as I said before, I think you really made it very clear why you need the pier extension and the float extension and for servicing it not to be able not to need to have to service at a king tide when it's an emergency I think is a huge different makes a huge difference so thank you for your part and Ryan I Yep. Come on up. You did a great job, too. [8:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Thank you. Well, I'm glad that's a mutual feeling. Ryan Russell with Willie C. and Sons Landscaping. We provided the letter with the outline. Just as clarification on some of the standards of the DEP, we provided the shoreline stabilization and coastal riprap standards and eligibility, which we designed to and adhered to and got approval on. specific to that was the five foot setback to the property line which we did modify the plan tapering the riprap so it's not so perpendicular to shoreline and added some native vegetation on that end of the property and again just meeting and i provide a photograph of that pin which is which is visible there the valuation of the softer shoreline stabilization or the biodegradable material we didn't feel as applicable in this location due to the ledge presence across whole shoreline and be able to maintain hold materials there without pinning things to the ledge and just the exposure of the roots and putting other biodegradable material there didn't seem like it was the best fit and just holding moisture into roots that are exposed we felt like the that's I don't want to say typical but the alternative of rip rap shoreline stabilization seemed the most appropriate for this case the riprap size that was an error on the plan previously intended to say three to six inch riprap we've put six inch minus on the plans and i think that addressed the comments that we saw last time so apologize for the error and your the opportunity to come back and make some clarifications so i don't know if there [9:53] Speaker A (unidentified): any questions from anybody thank you for that Laura hat makers joined us do you Alexis just gave a brief overview of their changes and we've gone around the room would you like to make comments on the pier and now Ryan just was speaking so you didn't miss anything that he said pretty much so [10:21] Speaker H (unidentified): first for we're talking about the pier right now so I'm kind of rock hazards usually can be addressed through like buoys that's usually what's done in a lot of lakes just kind of curious as to why that wasn't thought of as a potential way to address that navigational hazard? [10:50] Speaker C (unidentified): I think it's because of the actual clearance. We just didn't feel that moving the float closer to the rock hazard would provide adequate clearance for a boat to navigate there. Like right now, I believe it's about a 20 foot clearance and shortening that even with a buoy, it's still like quite a tight area to navigate so I think it's just we had not thought about a buoy but I do I we do believe that the area is too narrow even [11:33] Speaker H (unidentified): if it were at what it currently is if [11:41] Speaker C (unidentified): it were at if it were to remain what where it currently is, a buoy would likely be sufficient. However, I think that there are other design issues with the current pier that make extending it a better choice than building it as is. [12:08] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I looked through your submission. I actually really appreciated how you laid it out. It was very neat, very organized. I mean, reviewed quite a few peer projects. That's one of the better alternative analysis that I've seen. One thing, and this might be just my ignorance, how does the TIDE prevent removal of the gangway? [12:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, so my husband is the engineer, but the TIDE, so he would be much better at explaining this. But how it is currently designed, when you're removing the float and the gangway, you have to wait until, like, for the first part of that, the gangway has to be attached to the pier. And it needs to be raised to a point, like a lever, such that, like, it can begin to tip. and the way it is currently designed you cannot achieve that without a very high exceptionally high tide. The new design has reworked that geometry such that kind of lever effect is possible at a much wider range of high [13:36] Speaker H (unidentified): tides or like all like higher tides so there's no possible to have any kind of mechanical assistance like some kind of a pulley system or a lever to help get that little bit over so that then you [13:48] Speaker C (unidentified): can pull it backwards we do use mechanical assistance so that is with a mechanical assistance including a boat helping and winches and things like that okay and then i think the rest of [14:04] Speaker H (unidentified): of my questions are more for shoreline stabilization, so. [14:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Go ahead and continue on shoreline stabilization. [14:17] Speaker H (unidentified): So the next question I had, and forgive me if you've said this, and I was just walking in a little late. So overland erosion sources potential, have those been addressed? Like just the idea of like when you have fresh water come down, it freezes, thaws, some of the soil comes away with it. [14:37] Speaker G (unidentified): especially where it exits out of the base there's really no uphill erosion from surface coming from uphill on the site and we are adding right now it's a lush essentially lawn coming down to the shoreline where the trees exist there's existing some understory native some dying material we're supplement supplementing that buffer 10 feet into the lawn area per the tep standards to absorb and create a vegetated buffer from any erosion coming down towards the shoreline. There is a gap to go to the pier, for example, but that's not where the erosion is. That's like a ledge outcropping. [15:14] Speaker H (unidentified): Sorry, I'm more talking about like groundwater influence, because if you have just lawn, the groundwater kind of just... [15:23] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, but the lawn is coming down to what we're... So the lawn's coming downhill, and we're putting a buffer where the lawn meets the tree's existing root system and creating a 10-foot buffer coming into the lawn. So we're taking out a section of the lawn to enhance the vegetated buffer to absorb any groundwater or anything that's coming down the slope. Anything that would be coming through the root system or underground coming into that eroding soil is going to be held by the installation of the riprap and the material we put in to stabilize the voids. I don't know if I'm getting to your question. [15:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, you are, but I'm not sure if that necessarily needs to be addressed. with rip rap might just actually improve with just the buffer plantings did the sorry just [16:11] Speaker G (unidentified): the wave any high tides or wave action is what's hitting the eroding soil so that's under the overhang of the eroded soil so the water that's coming up is hitting the exposed soil it's not coming from the top and coming down through it's the underside that's undermining the trees that's where the problem is i'll [16:33] Speaker H (unidentified): have to glance at those photos a little more carefully but it looked a little bit i wasn't it was kind of hard to see with all that just because it was in snow so a little hard to see what was going on but it did look like there was some groundwater influence actually happening in that area but like i said it's hard to see in the photos. Has there been, did you address the potential for erosion on neighboring properties? [17:03] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes. The five foot setback standard from the DEP standard, we addressed by maintaining that five foot setback with a riprap, have tapered it back as opposed to being perpendicular to the shoreline and did an angled taper and are installing some supplemental plantings in that gap from the end of the riprap to that property pin which is located and which was photographed. So we're buffering the edge of the riprap in that five foot gap with native vegetation as opposed to just abruptly stopping the riprap at a perpendicular to the shoreline. [17:35] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay and then the other one was, the PBR standard number three met where it talks about that there has actually been erosion occurring at a rate of one foot a year or five feet in a given storm because it doesn't I wasn't sure if that had been met or not all I can say is from the [18:02] Speaker G (unidentified): visual impacts it appears that way and what we submitted to the DEP per their standards they accepted what we provided in the descriptions we gave so that was the extent of the analysis than the descriptions that we gave and that was the basis of the approval which let us come here year so specifically measuring years and when erosion started where it is now it's pretty extensive now so the history of it and backdating i don't have exactly but there's significant roots exposed and undermining of the overhangings mature oak trees so that's the overall concern [18:39] Speaker H (unidentified): okay and sorry i just saw acceptance of the application i didn't see approval that's what [18:44] Speaker G (unidentified): it's called it's accepted the permit by rule notification is accepted implicitly or explicitly this was implicitly accepted okay which implicitly kind of means they ran out of time and there's their law says that they have i wanted to differentiate yeah i mean it's according to them either way it's accepted unfortunately but this was this was we responded to comments from them got feedback and then it was accepted so they did spend time looking at it thank you that's what i [19:11] Speaker H (unidentified): I also wanted to get at as to whether it was a, oh, the staff didn't get to it potentially or if they'd actually seen it. [19:18] Speaker G (unidentified): It's unfortunate with the DEP, but it happens sometimes. And some people, I wouldn't say get lucky, but it's one of those things you, 20 days, no word is good word. [19:25] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, that concludes my questions. Okay, thanks. Steve? [19:33] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, one just out of curiosity is that DEP required the 10-foot buffer planting? Is that standard when there isn't a compliant shoreline zone distribution of trees? [19:48] Speaker G (unidentified): If you're doing any rip-rop stabilization, you have to do the buffer. Okay. If it's not existing, you have to meet it there. If it's already existing, I don't think you have to enhance. But in this case, there wasn't 10 feet, and we're just enhancing the vegetation that's there. [20:05] Speaker E (unidentified): Nothing to you. I wonder why they stop at 10 feet. They should go further back. But anyway, no, thank you. That's enlightening. I appreciate it. Rob? Allison. [20:19] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't have any further comments. I think you placed the pins and tapered the riprap into the neighboring shoreline, and it looks like a good project. project. I'll open comments or questions up to the public. Seeing nobody in the audience, and the screen is black, so I don't think there's anybody online. I'll bring it back to the board for comments or questions. Okay. All right. It's back. I see no hands up. Okay. Okay, I'll close the public comment. So draft motion three, I'd like a motion that the waivers are approved. The waivers are survey submitted, stamped for final plan, submittal by a professional surveyor with a current license by the State of Maine Board of Licensure for professional surveyors. And the second waiver is boundaries of all lots and tracts with accurate distances and bearings locations of permanent monuments property identified as existing or proposed and ryan identified all the pins on the property and what was the survey the [21:58] Speaker G (unidentified): pins were existing before we started it's just it's visible and it's visible on site we didn't do any survey work additional to right on what was there when we started the [22:07] Speaker A (unidentified): project so i'd like a motion for the labor waivers steve and second by rob all those in favor that's unanimous of the board members present thank you and then i would like what is now motion four it's stated three on our findings of fact i'd like a motion that the planning board approves the major development review application for the residential pier and shoreland stabilization on the property located at 73 minot shore road map mp5 lot 12 as outlined in the application with the following conditions matt would you do the honor of one that the board's review and [22:54] Speaker B (unidentified): approval does hereby refer to these findings of fact the plans and materials submitted by the applicant and the written and oral comments of the applicant their representatives reviewing officials and members of the public as reflected in the public record any changes to the approved plan not called for in these conditions of approval or otherwise approved by the director of planning and development as a minor modification shall require review and approval in accordance with the brunswick zoning ordinance two that prior to the review of any building permit the applicant shall submit a letter from the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife attesting to the fact that no important animal habitats will be endangered by the proposed development. Three, that prior to the review of any building permit the applicant shall submit a letter from the Maine Natural Areas Program attesting to the fact that no important plant habitats will be endangered by the proposed development. Four, that prior to the review of any building permit the applicant shall provide an approved copy of the Maine Department of Environmental Protection and National Natural Resource Protection Act permit to the director of planning and development five that prior to the re review of any building permit the applicant shall obtain a shoreland protection overlay permit from the code enforcement officer six that prior to the review of any building permit the applicant shall obtain a flood hazard development permit from the code enforcement officer and seven that prior to the review of any building permit, the applicant shall obtain a Rural Protection and Stormwater Management Overlay Permit from the Co-Enforcement Officer. [24:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Matt. Do I have a motion to that effect? Motion by Laura, second by Rob. All those in favor? That's unanimous of the board members present. Thank you, Alexis. Thank you, Ryan. [24:40] Speaker G (unidentified): One question. Are those conditions, those we sent to us, are those found on the website? [24:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, we can send those to you. Okay, thank you. Moving [24:58] Speaker A (unidentified): on to case number 25-1. Jones Farm Estates. [25:06] Speaker B (unidentified): The Planning Board will review and act upon a major development review final plan application submitted by Belanger Engineering on behalf of Bob Walton of Labby Construction and the property owner, Jones Farm Estates, LLC, for a 13-lot subdivision on a new dead-end road. The subject property is located on Lisbon Road, Map 1, Lot 70, and within the Rural Farm and Forest, or RF, zoning district. [25:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Chris. Hi. How are you? Good. Thanks for coming. [25:36] Speaker I (unidentified): Thank you for having me. My name is Chris Planger. I'm a civil engineer working on the Jones Farm Subvision Project off of Lisbon Road. I'm here with the owner, Bob Walton. Last time we were here, the environmental planner asked for a vernal pool study be conducted. We did complete the study in the spring. We did find a significant vernal pool on site. It was adjacent to Lisbon Road, as shown in the plan. [Speaker J (unidentified): The road is] going to be private, 20 feet wide. The length is around 1,100 feet, which meets the ordinance requirements. We've got road impervious areas about 0.86 acres, which triggers a DEP stormwater PBR. We did get all necessary DEP permits in hand. Stonewater PBR, NRPA, impact with it for activity within 250 feet of vernal pool and the pond outflow pipe we needed a permit as well. We did obtain all those permits. There are no wetland impacts on the project. We do have a 14th lot. It's a non-buildable lot. It's an open space lot. It's the open space somebody had requested from the board in the past that the open space be set on its own lot, which we were able to do. Those are the major changes that I've outlined since you've seen us last. I'll be happy to answer any questions you might have. Okay. Thank you. Before I come to the board, [27:19] Speaker A (unidentified): The staff has reviewed the application and determined that it's complete. I'd like a motion that the planning board concurs with planning staff's conclusion that the basic major development and review application materials have been submitted and that the application is complete such that the board may proceed with substantive review of the application and identification of any further information required from the applicant. Do I have a motion by Allison, second by Steve? All those in favor? That's unanimous of the board. All right. Rob, would you start? [27:57] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, thank you very much. And this looks, you know, very well thought out and planned. I did have a question about the retention pond and the exit from that into sort of a nascent stream wetland area. Can you talk about the rate of outflow from that retention pond and, you know, what the volume of water is going to be flowing into that otherwise kind of almost inconsequential stream at that point and what impact that might have? [28:36] Speaker I (unidentified): Well, we've designed a filter pond, so most of the storms will allow water to go into the pond, fill it up, and filter into the ground, filter into the underdrained pipe. So we suspect the outflows outside that pipe will be minimal for most storms. We wanted to put the pipe closer to the bottom of the hill so it didn't erode as things were leaving the site. We did rip-wrap and put a plunge pool at the outlet to try to keep those things intact. We did have DEP review it for us, and they did give us a permit for a PBR for the outfall pipe. [29:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. No, thank you for that. I guess the infiltration is really the important part on that, where a lot of that collected water in the retention pond will supposedly percolate out rather than being sent out through an overflow pipe. [29:39] Speaker I (unidentified): Right. The sediment will be trapped in the pond, and it'll slowly dissipate out to the stream, basically. [29:47] Speaker D (unidentified): That's all that I had at the moment. Okay. Allison? [29:56] Speaker F (unidentified): I just had a couple of questions. Just for the record, it seems a whole lot shorter, but do you know what the distance is from Lisbon Road to the end of Haystack? I mean, it's well under 1,500 feet, surely. [30:10] Speaker I (unidentified): Haystack Lane is roughly 650 feet. Okay. And so you've got a couple hundred feet from Lisbon Road to the intersection. Just less than 1,500. Just for the record. [30:21] Speaker F (unidentified): The other thing, we've talked about this before, not necessarily with you, But Ashley raised the issue during the staff review committee about the no-cut areas in lots 9 and 10. And the question is how to make sure that lasts in perpetuity and what the best mechanism for that is. And I think the possibility was raised of the HOA documents, but also I would think that it could also go into the deeds for those lots, too, that specify the no-cut zone. And, again, I turn to my colleagues here. Is this something that should be marked out before the lots are sold just so it's clear what the no-cut zone is or something like that? [31:13] Speaker I (unidentified): out i will say that on the plan yeah the green shaded areas right were non-open space no cut [31:22] Speaker F (unidentified): zones right that i understood but the question is just for the purchasers of lots nine and ten a decade from now or 20 years from now how do they know that is to be undisturbed and whether that goes into the deed or the homeowner's agreement or whatever i guess it should be shown [31:41] Speaker I (unidentified): on the plans for sure so they can reference those we could say something in the deeds as well okay and we did and we did mention in the hoa documents to respect those buffers right [31:55] Speaker F (unidentified): but and i do appreciate your documentation because it's very clear and easy to follow so that was very helpful to me i also just had a question and you may have told us before but i've forgotten. Are you just selling the lots and let people build, or do you have a developer who's going to build all [32:15] Speaker I (unidentified): the homes? The lots will be sold. I'm not sure exactly who's going to build them. I don't know if Bob has any comments [32:23] Speaker K (unidentified): on that. We do have an exclusive builder. They'll be the building company, and Ray Labby & Sons will be the excavation company, solely. [32:32] Speaker F (unidentified): So they'll be, yeah, okay. That was my question, and I noticed that you want the waiver for the 10-caliber trees. Is that because you intend to clear-cut all the lots at once, or are you going to cut as the lots are sold? [32:50] Speaker I (unidentified): We're going to cut as the lots are sold. Okay. For sure. [32:54] Speaker F (unidentified): So there may be some indication of where the buildings actually sit, because it's just the idea of preserving some of the trees that are already there that are worth preserving. [33:05] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah. In the HOA docs, it specifically states that there's no clear cutting. Minimal trees will be cut per lot. You're going to clear enough to put your house in and your septic system. So, the idea is to keep them wooded and keep a buffer between the lots. [33:22] Speaker L (unidentified): Great. That's appreciated. Thank you. [33:24] Speaker A (unidentified): So, the waiver for the 10-inch trees is basically for the roadway? [33:28] Speaker K (unidentified): Roads have been cut. [33:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, it has been cut. [33:31] Speaker K (unidentified): It was cut back in 2008. Oh, okay. [33:37] Speaker F (unidentified): So do we need the waiver at all then? Well, I don't know. Do we? If the road's already been cut and they're going to do it on a house-by-house basis? [33:49] Speaker A (unidentified): And the HOA says minimal cutting. [33:52] Speaker M (unidentified): I would say maybe not. If there's no tree removal that's happening on your part, it's just tree removal that's happening later as the lots are developed. [34:07] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm not sure I get. [34:08] Speaker M (unidentified): Are there any truths that are going to need to be removed to build the road, to construct the road? [34:14] Speaker I (unidentified): Since I moved Haystack Lane to avoid the vernal pool, there is some cutting that needs to do at the end of that road. The beginning, I think, is in the same spot, so we should have minimal cutting required for the road, but there may be some. [34:31] Speaker A (unidentified): So we need the waiver for that. [34:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Got it. That's all I have. Laura? [34:38] Speaker H (unidentified): I guess a comment to your concern. Something that maybe could be done would be along buffers, especially for the stream setbacks as well, since that's such a nice long buffer, is maybe to have some kind of marker, whether that's like a raised pin. I know some companies have done that. Some have done boulders. Something that kind of demarcates, hey, this is where your no-cut zone starts, just because you know it's not typical that somebody's gonna measure out where they want to put you know their garden bed or something like that to that signs of that nature for protection of [35:18] Speaker I (unidentified): verse buffers in these areas something like that could be done we can require a surveyor stake the buffer before they do anything on the lot yeah [35:31] Speaker H (unidentified): just something more permanent usually as a landowner myself being like hey it's nice to know where things start and end if I have certain restrictions on my property. Sure. Okay. [35:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Good. Steve. I might suggest taking it a little bit further going back to Allison's lot 9 and 10 concern. You do a great job on lots 1 through 13 of keeping the actual lot lines outside of the resource buffer i understand it's probably tight here but at a minimum on nine and ten i would suggest revising the plan to at least take the building envelopes outside of that because on the sheet i'm looking at the building envelopes extend into the no clear area so they weren't [36:21] Speaker I (unidentified): intended to do that at all i figured yeah don't yeah the green areas are not to touch so yeah so [36:27] Speaker E (unidentified): So you might want to fix that on, I don't know which sheet this is, it's the first one in the package, sheet 2 of 15. Good point. So that would help, clarifying that the building envelopes are outside of the buffer. I would strongly encourage keeping the entire lot out and having the no clear area within the open space where it's possible. And then similarly on lots, I always blow that word, similarly, lots 7 through 12 you do have the building envelopes outside of the setback but is there any potential to have the lot lines snugged up to that resource buffer just trying to get you know away from the concern that yes i know you have the homers homeowners association document that looked good to me but you always have you know the landowner who wants to keep pushing you know so i don't know if it's possible i would recommend either pulling the lots out of the resource buffers completely and at minimum clarifying that lot nine and ten building envelope [37:38] Speaker I (unidentified): we did we did try to clarify it as best we could in the plans the green shaded areas are non-open space areas and they cannot cut in those areas yeah i mean i would just add them to [37:51] Speaker E (unidentified): the open space but if there's reasons not to I'll go with it as long as we got the homeowners association documents tight that's all I had [38:02] Speaker I (unidentified): Rob you're [38:09] Speaker A (unidentified): good alright I like what you've done with the road and the 250 cut zone as Taylor Lund said in staff review I think that's great that you've you've kept Cutting away from that and I think as Steve points out if it at least on nine and ten getting those the houses the Coverage out of that No cut zone So the potential house Positioning out of that cut zone would be great. [38:49] Speaker I (unidentified): I did on the last sheet of the plant set. I kind of gave you my version of the envelopes there certainly could be tweaked but the white areas are woods to remain on site i basically would like to give them 25 feet around the house basically for whatever lawn patios what have you but beyond that i want to keep it wooded well that looks i mean that looks [39:14] Speaker A (unidentified): good your envelopes on that i didn't i didn't look at that page actually so bill [39:27] Speaker D (unidentified): i one thing i did I did want to say, to compliment you on the HOA documents, I think they were very detailed and prized prospective buyers of lots, what kind of costs they could anticipate for maintenance, and not only for maintaining the road, but also snow plowing and other community activities. And I think that's very important from a consumer perspective since this will be a private road, and, you know, maintenance responsibilities will lie with the homeowners. So great job on that, I thought. [40:14] Speaker I (unidentified): Kudos to the attorney on the language, and I supplemented it with potential costs, and I'll tell him you said that. in [40:26] Speaker A (unidentified): the stormwater pond when you talked about sediment is there any will there be any long term maintenance for there and for the silt fence at the outflow there is a maintenance plan [40:44] Speaker I (unidentified): in effect for that very reason okay the filter will eventually fail yeah so it'll have to be The sediment will have to be scraped up, the filter replaced. Usually it takes 20 years or so, depending on the quality of the water going through it. And then when it stops infiltrating, then that's really the time it needs to be replaced, and the maintenance outlines that. [41:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Thank you. [41:12] Speaker D (unidentified): And, Bill, I thought to that end, I think there was an estimated cost of $42,000, $45,000, dollars and that was amortized over 20 years as part of the thank you rob i read the first
Public Comment
[41:26] Speaker A (unidentified): couple of the snow plowing cost and the road maintenance cost and i didn't get to that i guess so i appreciate it i 'll open it up for public comment and actually i just have one [41:40] Speaker H (unidentified): more question so and this is you know you've definitely done a great job of as we've said trying to protect the resources my only last request would be could that hammerhead on haystack be flipped so that it's just out of that critical terrestrial habitat and then moving that lot slightly farther back since it doesn't appear to really overlap the stream buffer i didn't want [42:04] Speaker I (unidentified): to extend the road into the adjacent property i looked at options to try to flip it to stay completely out of it but putting the turnaround through the middle of lot 8 just was problematic and it didn't offer a good layout like I said we moved the entire route out of the habitat area we are adding open space typically allows up to 25% when it's minimized. So DEP looked at it. They thought we did a great job [42:48] Speaker H (unidentified): minimizing and they approved it. Like I said, it was a very nitpicky ask and probably amounts to maybe one tree, but you know, just figured I'd ask. [43:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Good to ask. All right. I'll open it up for public comment or questions anybody in the audience looking around anybody online with hands up we have Frank Guidi and Leslie Otto or Otto if you wish to make a comment or ask a question raise your hand seeing no hands I'll close the public comment come back to the board for further comments or questions steve [43:43] Speaker E (unidentified): go ahead yeah no i just wanted to you know follow up on some of you have said what a good design this project is and it really is you've done a great job of avoiding having resources within lots there's no wetlands in the middle of lots or dividing lots the open space is contiguous to town property so I think it's a good model, and I appreciate the work you guys did. [44:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Anybody else? No? Seeing that, I'd like a motion that the following waiver is approved, a plan showing all 10-inch caliper trees to be removed as a result of development proposal. Motion by Allison, second by Steve. All those in favor? that's are you getting your hand up I couldn't see your hand that's unanimous of the board members present and last I would draft motion three I'd like a motion that the planning board approves the major development review application for the subdivision on the property located at 0 Lisbon Road map 1 lot 70 as outlined in the application with the following conditions. [45:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you, Matt. One, that the board's review and approval does hereby refer to these findings of fact, the plans and materials submitted by the applicant, and the written and oral comments of the applicant, his representatives, reviewing officials, and members of the public as reflected in the public record. Any changes to the approved plan not called for in these conditions of approval or otherwise approved by the director of planning and development as a minor modification shall require review and approval in accordance with the Brunswick zoning ordinance to that the performance guarantee for the proposed road and stormwater improvements shall be reviewed approved by the town manager and finance director and in place prior to breaking ground on the project three that the homeowners association covenants be reviewed by the town attorney and recorded prior to the sale of any lot within the subdivision. and four that prior to the review of any building permit the applicant shall provide a revised plan showing all building envelopes outside of the no [46:03] Speaker A (unidentified): cutting areas Thank You Matt do I have a motion to that effect Rob second Steve all those in favor that's unanimous of the board members present thank you very much thank you guys good luck on the project moving on to case number 26 32 53 to 69 Main Street mixed-use development the J the [46:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Planning Board will review and act upon a major development review final plan application submitted by LJ be engineering on behalf of the property owner 53 Main Street Associates LLC for a mixed-use development with 34 residential units first floor commercial space and subterranean parking the subject properties are located at 53 to 69 Main Street, Map U-13, Lots 121 and 123, and within the Growth Mixed-U-6 Zoning District and the Village Review Overlay Sub-District. Thank you, Matt. [47:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Before I come to you, Ryan, the staff has reviewed the application and determined that it's complete. I'd like a motion that the Planning Board concurs with Planning Staff's conclusion that the basic major development review application materials have been submitted and that the application is complete such that the board may proceed with substantive review of the application and identification of any further information required from the applicant. Do I have a motion to that effect? Motion by Laura, second by Allison. All those in favor? That's unanimous of the board members present. Ryan Barnes, welcome. Thank you. [47:59] Speaker N (unidentified): Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Board, for hearing us again tonight. Next slide, please. We're going to try to do this a little bit quicker than we have in the past, just since I think all of you have heard it at least twice now. So we're going to go through a brief project introduction. I'm going to walk you step-by-step through the ordinance just on how we meet each of the different requirements. We'll discuss some of the conditions that were included in the draft just to see if we still think they are necessary, and we'll obviously take questions at the end. Next slide, please. And so as you mentioned, I'm Ryan Barnes with LJB Engineering. We're here to try to help get this project through. It's been a very great project. It's been a longer process than we anticipated, but we really do think it's going to be great for the community once it's done. Tonight with me, we have Dave Holman representing 53 Maine Associates and Catherine Lermond representing Archetype Architects for the architecture portion of the project. And on the team, we also have a landscape architect, Dry LA. There isn't much landscaping associated with this project, but we wanted to really make sure that whatever we came up with and developed would fit very cohesively in with the proposed streetscape project the town is proposing. Next slide, please. The proposed project consists of 34 residential units on the top three floors of the building. There's eight commercial spaces totaling around 10,000 square feet on the first floor, and then below that in the subterranean area is parking that will accommodate at least 38 parking spaces. It may or will have the ability to expand, but it will have a minimum of 38 spaces. Next slide, please. Next slide again. Again, I'm just going to kind of step through the different requirements in the zoning ordinance just to try to make it easy for everyone tonight. So next slide, please. So reviewing the dimensional standards required for this district. We are in the GM6. We're in the Village Review Board, and we're also within the newly adopted Main Street Overlay District. the only dimensional requirement we didn't previously meet was for the building height that has been addressed through the MSO which we will discuss when we get to the end of this presentation. Next slide please. One concern that was raised during the early review of the project by staff was that there was a right-of-way line from main DOT shown going through the existing building. We've reached out with Tahith Cowan, the head of property office for the main DOT, reviewed the issue with him and there is no concern from his part. They would just assume right away up to the face of the building. So essentially we can build within that existing footprint without concern from main DOT. And another comment that was raised at council, but I didn't have the answer at the time, was how the proposed signal project would affect this corner. As of right now, the plans that are being proposed by TY Lin have all of the signal equipment at opposite corners of the intersection. section. So the only thing that would be at this corner would be the pedestrian push buttons and signals. So that's just the one short pole with the head on top of it and the push button that beeps at you. Not the big signal mast arm, not the cabinet. So all of that would be free to provide a more aesthetic appeal to the front of the building. Next slide, please. I'm going to hand this over for a natural historic to Catherine Lamont. [51:22] Speaker O (unidentified): Just to speak to the chimney swifts that we have discussed that are in the chimney on the existing building, the proposal that we are bringing is that prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the developer will ensure that a suitable chimney swift nesting structure is made offsite, whether it be that chimney across the street on Main Street made higher so that they would accept it, or the chimney at the school would be modified so that they would accept that chimney, and this would be done and reviewed by the Director of Planning and Development and accepted. And also what we said before was that before the chimney is either capped or removed, we will ensure that the SWIFTs have migrated for the year and the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife has agreed to look at it with us to make sure that is the case. Next slide, please. Just talking about the history of the site, how we got approval to remove the existing buildings, we went through an analysis of what has happened on this site over the years. When we looked at it back in the 1800s, you can see on the top left-hand corner where the arrow is indicating, that is the building that currently the first floor still exists, but the upper levels were a pitched roof form of wood that burned. So in the 1930s and 40s, you can see in the lower left-hand corner, it was replaced with the form of the structure that exists today, a two-story building with a flat roof. And then at the other end of the site towards Dunlap, you see that what was a gas station became the cleaners, so these buildings have all been heavily modified over the years, and they relate to the sidewalk in a different way than what we are looking to do with our proposal. Next slide, please. So finally, here are the images of what exists on site today. We have mostly vacant and very underutilized buildings. Because of both the gas station and the cleaner building, we have a brownfield site that is requiring the VRAP, and as I said, that the buildings toward Dunlap were designed for the car rather than the pedestrian, so we will be reworking the relationship of building to street. [53:29] Speaker N (unidentified): Thank you, Catherine. Moving on to the next slide, please. One of the comments that was brought up that we actually overlooked because of how it was situated is the fact that there is a tree on the property that meets the requirements requiring a donation or a contribution to the tree fund. The applicant is willing to pay that tree fund, But I did want to just point out that the current tree has, that's the refrigerator unit for the restaurant sitting on it. And it's leaning pretty precariously towards the abutting property. So probably not high value and probably actually more of a hazard tree. If there's a way to waive the fee, that'd be great. I don't know if this town arborist has had a chance to review it. I'm not an arborist, but I'm guessing the tree is not going to survive. Next slide, please. So as far as flood hazard mapping this location is on high ground, so it's not located within the flood zone mapping next slide, please We have the ability to serve letter from the Brunswick sewer district We're working through the entrance fees with them on that based on what the usage will be but that's all in progress Brunswick tops and water district also has provided us with a Ability to serve letter and we're working through fire flow testing with them now just to finalize the fire protection design Solid waste for this facility will be handled through a licensed hauler, either directly from the building where they're planning on having the residential waste held periodically until it is removed, and possibly sharing of a dumpster that currently exists in the rear of the site. One other thing to point out is that their CMP transformer for this site will actually be in a vault just because of the proximity to the building. As a result of that, it doesn't require screening because it is below grade. so we would just ask the condition number 10 of the draft conditions be removed since it is below grade and no longer requires the screening we did not note that quite as clearly as we could have so we do apologize for that next slide please so next item within the ordinance is stormwater quality stormwater standards so pollutant loading the ordinance does require treatment on sites of this size that are being redeveloped but because of the nature of this development that becomes really challenging we're essentially taking a lot that is building and parking lot today converting it all to building so there's no place where anything can be installed but the good news is that they're also by doing so reducing the pollutant load just by the nature of what we're doing so main dep actually has a redevelopment standard on pollutant ranking. We went through and did the pollutant ranking for this site. And usually, if you have a site that is zero or better, percentage-wise, you end up not having to do any additional treatment. In my 25-plus years of doing peer reviews, normally that redevelopment standard's a 1% to 2% change. This one's actually 34% improvement by just reducing the parking lots and putting in buildings. So you're reducing drips from cars, you're reducing chloride loading, you're getting the rainwater that's going directly into the storm drain system so you're not getting and transporting all of those pollutants that normally would be hitting parking lots and hitting other things. It comes with the added cost of a parking garage but it is a fair trade-off so we would hope that would satisfy the requirements of the town. For storm water quantity there is a slight increase around 0.1 0.14 CFS that's only because the a portion of the building at 53 Main Street's gutters still are combined by law we have to remove that from the sewer system and put it into the storm drain system it is a negligible increase that increase I mentioned does not include the fact that there is going to be a portion of the roof that is green which will further reduce it we just typically don't like to utilize that as a reduction because of the fact that they are maintenance we they are high in maintenance so we just know that what they're able to treat isn't always consistent but again very negligible increase into the system and hopefully when they redesign the system for the CSO they took it into account and while we're on this topic I'll also just briefly touch on the pollutants that are on the site obviously it's a heavily contaminated site we are working closely with the program director for the v-rap program chris redmond as well as chris dyer with sivian mahar sivian mahar has currently completed the phase one study and they're working on the phase two study for the project once that's complete we'll move into doing the v-rap application that's when we'll determine if or what mitigations are required to be able to do the work and all of those mitigations will be included and we do agree that obviously should be submitted to the town so that they're aware of what the requirements are but that's all in progress everything's being done on the up and up we're following dep's role on that one next slide please again as far as landscaping there isn't much for the site there is a small alleyway to the back that we do plan to dress up so that it is a little bit of an amenity for the property owners at least looking out from the balconies the front area and the side area is all town property but we are working closely with the town on coordination with the landscaping for that and the design as well next slide please residential recreation fees the applicant agrees to pay those fees as they are described in the ordinance so that's an easy check the box next slide please for circulation and access to the site the site does not generate enough traffic to require a turning movement permit from the main DOT so one hasn't been applied for the development is actually predicted to produce relatively low volume of traffic in this area next slide please access to the straight seat will be from Dunlap Street it's the light gray kind of rectangle in the top right hand corner of the screen that will be the entrance to the parking garage that sits about 80 feet from the crosswalk and the intersection giving some additional room for stacking next slide please so one concern that was raised during the most recent review is how that garage system works so the garage allows for one up or one down at a time has signals on both ends so the residents trigger the signal doors go up they go down or if someone's coming up they'll have to wait for the length of time it will take someone to come up and turn it's a one-way street so it literally early will be, come up and turn. You won't have to wait for anybody. So to look at if there are any design concerns with that, I looked at how much traffic there is on the existing street versus how much is coming in and out of the development. So the average annual daily traffic, so the traffic in one day for Dunlop Street, is 265 vehicles, which means your peak hour is probably around 27 vehicles, which means you're averaging a car every 2 and a half minutes plus or minus in the am peak hour you have six vehicles entering so roughly one every 10 minutes you have 19 vehicles exiting roughly one every three minutes in the pm it's the reverse you have 15 coming in so once one every four minutes and nine going out so roughly every six and a half minutes so because of the fact that the traffic is so light and limited and the fact that we have significant space for stacking up to three-plus vehicles, we don't feel that a condition is necessary to have to review that in the future. In fact, even though I'm a qualified traffic engineer, I still requested one of our corporate professional traffic operations engineers review this. And his first question was, why am I looking at this? So it's a minor requirement. We understand the concern. But we did take a look at it, and it is very unlikely to be an issue. I know from the existing sandpiper one from people speaking with people that go there regularly They rarely see anyone coming up or down when they're going in the opposite direction So that is condition 9 if there were to be considered to be removed next slide, please parking and loading Contract zone was approved on October 19th the applicant will be meeting the requirements of that zoning and There is a sufficient space in the garage to accommodate what was done with that. So all of the parking requirements for this have been addressed through this contract zone next slide please we did provide a lighting plan it does meet on lighting there was one fixture that was required to be a slightly higher lumen than is typically desired i guess but unfortunately because of its location and the fact that it's illuminating the garage doorway it needed to be a little bit brighter but it is just illuminating kind of the pavement area between the two commercial spaces so although not ideal it is necessary to help provide safety at that location so that people coming in and out can see pedestrians next slide please with that i'm going to hand it over to katherine to talk all things pretty about the building to [1:02:46] Speaker O (unidentified): speak to the architectural compatibility these are the updated elevations again just showing that on the streetscapes the mason main and dunlap we're carrying the masonry with the store surrounds And then when you go around to the rear elevation, it switches to shiplap. This was a historically common move, where you take the more elevated materials, the more expensive materials, and place them on the streetscapes. But it also speaks to the surroundings, to the commercial buildings on those streetscapes, and then redirecting toward the residential multifamily in the rear. Next slide, please. When we look at the building on the street, we can see that both the materials and the forms are directly related to their surroundings even though we're still being a design of our time and this project is bringing a higher public use to the site we're bringing commercial and outdoor space back to the sidewalk and we're encouraging the pedestrian activity on this main street downtown in terms of public safety we are using the v-rap to address the brownfield site and then the new construction is being built to passive house level so not only are we addressing the environment around the building and under the building but also the environment inside the building. Next slide, please. Stepping a little bit further back, we can just speak to the fact that this is economic revitalization for the town. We're creating a larger tax base by increasing the downtown population, and that also increases the patrons to both the new commercial spaces that will be in the building as well as the existing commercial spaces elsewhere. In terms of public accessibility, the new sidewalk area is being totally rebuilt and being made usable by the public, and then the interior spaces, both the commercial at the ground level and the residences above will all be fully accessible in terms of having access into the building, the elevator up, and we are both type B and type A units. Next slide, please. Finally, we go to the Mason and Main Street image, and we talk about how we are sensitive to our historic surroundings. It's really important to us that we're revitalizing a major corner downtown, just as we talked about with the looking ahead at what Brunswick was trying to do in revitalizing the other major intersection this one brings this intersection back and the materials and massing again are recognizing the neighboring buildings and these are uses and a sighting that are more fitting to what a downtown wants to be like this than the existing buildings but again it's of its own time thank [1:05:14] Speaker N (unidentified): you next slide please neighborhood protection requirements don't apply to the site because there are no abutting one or two story or I'm sorry one or two unit buildings next slide please as far as signage goes you'll see I've highlighted in yellow the areas where the tenant signage is anticipated to go exact shape size color is unknown at this time because the tenants are still unknown as tenants become purchasing these properties they will have to come in through planning and development you go through codes to get the signage approved per ordinance in addition to that they are hoping to you use the J&J sign into part of their signage as well. The condition of it is unknown since it obviously sits 20 feet up in the air at the moment. But if it's viable, once they remove it, they're hoping to reincorporate that into the sign for the building itself. Next slide, please. As far as noise, smoke, dust, odors, vibrations, unlicensed vehicles, motor vehicles, lighting, we meet all of those ordinances. I will also just say that there are obviously construction components to several of those as well. within the construction documents the contract will be responsible for meeting state standards on all of those items and town standards as well next slide please as we've mentioned a couple of times the HOA documents for this site are still in development they will be reviewed by town attorney once they are completed in that as far as maintenance of site features that will be the responsibility of the property owners and they're the residents and the tenants of the building it'll be spelled out in that who's responsible for what and where so all of that will be reviewed as a condition of approval next slide please financial and technical capacity was included or the current version was included with this package we do understand that as the project becomes finalized and begins actually getting ready to expend funds on the construction that there will be a final review of that documentation prior to the issuance of the building permits next slide with the acceptance of the contract zone there are no administrative adjustments requested for the project next slide as far as the dimensional requirements that are specified within the new Main Street overlay as a result as we mentioned earlier we didn't previously meet the height requirement but we now do meet the height requirement we're actually slightly under it but we meet all the other requirements within that next slide as far as the building height information and other features we meet all of those requirements as well next slide so as far as open space goes there isn't because it's all building a lot of open space outside of the building but to offset that the applicant is putting in several amenities for the residents within the building they'll include are anticipated to include a gym golf simulator conference space just shared community space as well as a patio on the roof and then just for other amenities within walking distance so within a quarter mile there's 250th anniversary Park the new bridge with the outlooks Veterans Memorial people plus the mall sidewalk access to the swinging bridge and sidewalk access to the Androscoggin River bike path next slide please. The HOA documentation is currently under development. As we said, it will include the particular items that were raised as concerned, which include solid waste, water, sewer, facility maintenance, and other items that are typically included within HOA documents for this type of building. Next slide, please. So again, just going through the draft conditions, we do request that three nine and ten be removed we are willing to accept them if that is desired but we just feel that they're not applicable based on the revised plans and with that we'd be happy to open up to questions [1:09:17] Speaker H (unidentified): sure i don't really have any questions but thank you for the update on everything and the swifts especially best of luck with relocating them [1:09:30] Speaker E (unidentified): no thank you great project as i've said before i would you know go along with three nine and ten conditions being taken off the books and i do want to thank you know you don't have to do anything with the swiss but as a team you've taken that on and i think it's going to be a great amenity for the downtown to keep that population and of course for the ecology of our area if I had my druthers of course I would push to for the chimney across the street because there is a history of use there unlike the high school and I think it could be brought into use quicker so we don't miss a whole migratory season while things are being constructed before you get the occupancy certificate so that would be my suggestion but again great project and thank you for taking that chimney swift issue so seriously absolutely [1:10:25] Speaker N (unidentified): And the applicant is still obviously working on different ways to do it, other groups to work with for funding of it as well, since obviously, as you noted, it's not a requirement. But we do want to be conscious of the need within the community. [1:10:43] Speaker F (unidentified): I just had questions. I'm more out of curiosity than anything. I, too, agree it's a great project. I'm looking forward to seeing it completed. I think I may have asked this before, but given the garage area being rather tight, how is fire and a fire emergency handled down there? There's no way any of the equipment, the fire equipment, can get down there, is there? [1:11:12] Speaker N (unidentified): Typically, they don't enter buildings, period, whether they're subterranean or not. Even garages? Typically, no. They'll bring in their equipment with their hoses and apparatus from the door. [1:11:24] Speaker F (unidentified): And there's a sprinkler system and stuff down there, of course. Okay. There was a lot of discussion, I noticed, I guess it was at the staff review, about bicycles, accessibility of bicycles. Had you thought about e-bikes at all? I mean, they're heavy. You couldn't load them onto racks or anything. Would they just be parked at the end of somebody's space? [1:11:46] Speaker N (unidentified): I mean, if it was my parking space in a small vehicle, yeah, I would put my e-bike in front just so that it's protected, so no one hits it. But I know that we are reviewing possibilities. Right now, we're going through the final or not final, but continued iterations of the parking lot layout. And we are looking for kind of quote-unquote dead spaces within that zone that we could put additional bike racks as well. [1:12:08] Speaker F (unidentified): And for an e-bike, do you take the battery off to charge it somewhere else, like a garden tool? You can do either. either you can leave it on or okay so you don't have to be next to a plug-in okay i noticed on the garage plan you showed just grayed out 10 lifts potential lift sites but in fact any of most of those parking spaces can accommodate lifts correct all of them can accommodate lifts [1:12:37] Speaker N (unidentified): with the exception of the tandem spaces so the ones that are okay the ones near the door yeah, the ones that are too deep, then they wouldn't have it so that they could drive through. [1:12:46] Speaker F (unidentified): Now, this may be an HOA question more, but I looked at the trash situation, and I saw where the recycling trash room is. How does the hauler get the trash that's in the compacted trash or whatever is stored there? It seems like there's just a people door between it and the outside. [1:13:06] Speaker N (unidentified): side the trash is going to be most likely in carts so they would just be taking it out through the rear access they are working on an agreement with the doctor's office so that they can just take it out through the rear access and load it into the truck there okay and come on up and [1:13:24] Speaker O (unidentified): i was just going to say what we do is we always coordinate with the garbage company that's going to pick it up and make sure that we have an oversized door that will meet the carts that [1:13:32] Speaker P (unidentified): are in the space so that's it so the people door is wider than normal yes okay thank you and [1:13:37] Speaker F (unidentified): and the dumpsters on the other side of the building right that's on mason street yeah potential dumps yeah they're right behind restaurant dumpster yeah bolus yeah and then i didn't see i did see the letter from norway savings i didn't see any project budget in there [1:13:55] Speaker P (unidentified): is that deliberate or what that was actually a condition that we were coming up with that there should be a project budget and a commitment letter yeah okay thank you and then on the first floor [1:14:11] Speaker F (unidentified): plan i gather that little garden off of next to the garage door is really just to be observed from above it's is it not it's not one tenants are going to spend any time in it's designed to [1:14:25] Speaker N (unidentified): be a place where you wouldn't mind walking through it will be a gated access so okay i was wondering [1:14:30] Speaker F (unidentified): you can get to it from the street the residents could residents okay great on [1:14:39] Speaker P (unidentified): the ground floor what's the hidden room can [1:14:43] Speaker N (unidentified): i give it away dave has a strong desire to have hidden rooms in all of his buildings so it's basically open up the bookcase and there's something that the residents know about that anyone walking by wouldn't know about and inside will be some easter egg for using the sci-fi term because i am a little bit of a nerd of a pinball machine video game something in there that the tenants can use as well as the golf simulator okay got it charming thank you [1:15:13] Speaker F (unidentified): and,, the last thing is I didn't understand that whole thing about air rights. [1:15:23] Speaker N (unidentified): air rights have to do with, I mean, is that to give you the height or? [1:15:29] Speaker O (unidentified): So the way it works is when you build on a property line or near to a property line per the building codes, you can only put a certain percentage of opening based on that distance. So what we've done in other jurisdictions and what we talked about with the code enforcement for your town, is that if there is an air rights easement in place for a certain swath of air above it where the neighbor agrees to not build, that means that you can basically extend your property line distance and have more openings on the building. Yeah. For me, with air rights in New [1:15:59] Speaker P (unidentified): York City, I wasn't quite sure, but it's basically the same concept. It means nobody can build right [1:16:04] Speaker O (unidentified): up against those windows, and it has to do with life safety, but it also makes for a nicer living [1:16:08] Speaker P (unidentified): living space right okay and i think that's it thank you very much thank you allison thank you [1:16:15] Speaker A (unidentified): rob yeah [1:16:18] Speaker D (unidentified): thank you maybe i'll be the last person to say great project but i'm really pleased to see this question about the green roof and what that will consist of because i know it's been sort of mischaracterized as a roof it's really plantings up on the roof or can you elaborate a little bit on that design? [1:16:42] Speaker N (unidentified): It'll be a combination of both. So along the patio area, there will be planters that the residents maintain, but there will also be a living roof component, but I don't know the right terminology. [1:16:52] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, we don't do the final design on them. We work with a landscape architect, but they tend to be sedums because they have much easier keeping, but it allows for a soil that actually filters the water, and it makes a nice greenscape. We have them on some of our buildings in Portland, and they've lasted over the years, and they're quite lovely. Great. [1:17:09] Speaker D (unidentified): And there are, on the west roof, the pitched roof, that will have solar panels on that? Allison's question about the garage lifts, you've answered. On the lighting side, the one thing that was absent from any of the discussion was the color temperature of the lamps. They are clearly going to be dark sky compliant, downward facing, but the color temperature was not addressed. And we don't have a specific requirement in the ordinance, but we have routinely asked applicants to consider keeping them at 3,000 Kelvin or lower. And I noted that on the spec sheets, all of the fixtures you're considering have that option. option. The other thing is you did mention the bug ratings, the backlight, uplight, glare characteristics, and obviously being fully downlit, there's no uplighting, which is great. But there are ratings also for glare. And I guess I would just say in choosing those fixtures, I would encourage you to be mindful of a lower bug rating on the glare side. [1:18:34] Speaker O (unidentified): I was just going to, we do have a professional lighting designer on this, so I will give her that feedback, but she's very careful with all of this, so I would trust she would. Great, thank you. [1:18:43] Speaker N (unidentified): And I'll just reiterate that I wrote the lighting policy with you when I was here, and I rejected the first set of lights they sent us, so I said, Rob won't like that, try another one. So I do know that has been addressed, and that concern won't be an issue. The 3,000K shouldn't be an issue at all. the only one I and it shouldn't matter either but just I'm not sure if the one above the parking [1:19:04] Speaker D (unidentified): garage had the well it could be 2600 lumens but still the color temperature yeah I just don't I [1:19:09] Speaker N (unidentified): can't recall if that cut sheet had that as an option or not yeah so okay [1:19:16] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you thank you again for the all the work you've done on the project I think it's going to be a great addition to town. When Allison mentioned the e-bikes, it occurred to me that something in the homeowners association documents might stipulate that anybody having e-bikes make sure that the brand of e-bike has a UL listed battery, because in New York City, as I'm sure you're aware, A lot of fires have been in high-rises, and it's because of off-brand batteries, mostly. And the UL batteries sit for years without ever having a problem. So, yes. [1:20:12] Speaker D (unidentified): One other question. Just on the retail space on the ground floor. Is the condo association going to cover the whole building and, in a sense, have these people as tenants to them, or is that going to be owned separately by? [1:20:31] Speaker N (unidentified): Those are commercial condos, so it will all be part of the same condo association. [1:20:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, so those will be sold to the retailers? [1:20:41] Speaker N (unidentified): Yep. Okay. So everything will be under one association? Correct. Great. Thank you. [1:20:47] Speaker A (unidentified): and I am in favor Steve mentioned it I'm not sure who else did I'm also in favor of doing away with conditions 3 we're deleting condition 5 now 3, 9 and 10 5 is redundant to 7 so we don't need it And, you know, if you so choose to donate $1,400 to the Towns Tree Fund of your own volition, that would be great. I don't think we need to require it. With that, any other questions before I open it up to the public? Seeing none, I'll open it up for public comment or questions. Anybody? Come on up and state your name and come on up to the podium. Hi, [1:21:51] Speaker L (unidentified): my name is Paul Whitcomb. I'm from Brunswick. I see three major considerations, certainly potential problems with this project. One is the air impact, the air pollution impact as the construction proceeds, the displacement of the soil, the excavation. Certainly, air quality control monitors need to be in place. the effect of perchloroethylene is just what you don't want at one of the major intersections in town. Dizziness and lightheadedness, headache, sleepiness and drowsiness, confusion and impaired speech, visual changes, unconsciousness, these the pedestrians crossing the street on main street are depending on the mental acuity and sobriety of the drivers of the motorists there in april of 2026 trc conducted an lsi limited submitted subsurface investigation at this site and found pervasive VOCs, including perchloroethylene, in the soil samples all the way past the water table. The water table resides from 17 to 19 feet. Although those samples were not above the state-mandated maximum, they were pervasive. The water table runs north into the Androscoggin River. During this excavation, the river needs to be monitored to make sure that the displacement of this soil does not cause a huge increase in the perchloroethylene and other VOCs. seas. The other consideration that I have is the soil displacement. I know that they're using the RCRA program through the state to monitor, to oversee the life cycle of the hazardous waste, but I'm going to be paying particular attention to where these 700 dump trucks full of contaminated soil are going. The electronic database, manifest tracking for all offsite shipments, I'm going to be paying particular attention to that. My main concern, outside of the fact that I won't be able to see the sky from any direction because of the height of this thing, is the air pollution, is the release of the toxins in the soil. This is a huge amount of soil. Has LJB or Holman Homes or any of these entities ever conducted this type of excavation with this level of toxicity at this concentration before they have not spoken on their experience in dealing with this type of contamination this close to so many people that their building would be fine if it was not on such a contaminated spot. Councilor Hicks mentioned a couple nights ago, she said, I'm paraphrasing, but she said, I have a lot of family members that are in the development field, and the one type of site that they won't touch is a dry cleaner's. So the LSI that was conducted by TRC said chlorinated solvent impacts in groundwater and indoor air were previously identified in every core sample, every geoprobe that they took, every sample. And like I say, they went down past the water table. [1:27:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Mr. Wickham, you've gone on for more than three minutes. [1:27:07] Speaker L (unidentified): Okay, all right. Wrap up, please. Okay, fine. They need to be able to predict what the level of toxicity is when they release these VOCs from the soil. They need to be able to predict what the concentration is and what the effect on the population is going to be. I don't understand the reason that they chose the most toxic site on Main Street to begin their construction. destruction. I would seriously doubt many of their assertions. Thank you. [1:27:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Whitcomb. Ryan, do you want to respond? I think you already have stipulated that you're working with DEP and taking their lead. [1:28:06] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, but just to answer a couple of the questions that were asked, yes, we have experience with this. different contaminants different issues everywhere can't disclose it because i have other clients with agreements i'm working on two and contaminated sites currently for the in the city of portland both of them in pretty high profile areas so yes we have experience with it but that's also why we bring on trc to help us with a preliminary view it's why we're working with sm me stevie and mahar for the phase one the phase two that i thought that was me for a minute to. Are my three minutes up, sir? The phase two will include additional exploration. That's actually what they're working through right now is mapping what will be done for additional testing. Everything is going to be done based on DEP standard, EPA standard. We're going to follow the rules. Everything will be tracked the way it's supposed to be done. So yes, we're experienced with this sort of effort. Thank you. [1:29:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else in the audience? No, not now. Come on up. [1:29:14] Speaker Q (unidentified): My name is Peggy Siegel. I've lived in Brunswick for just under 25 years, and I currently live in the Sandpiper. And many of the questions, I almost feel like if you want to ask me questions about how it's working right now in the Sandpiper, by this same developer, I can answer those. The bike storage, the garage operation, the lighting, everything that I've experienced is superior. The building is superior. I mean, the construction of the units, the building itself, the common spaces, and everything that's provided for residents makes me really excited about having this in Brunswick, particularly at this high-profile location, and a location that's going to be very exciting for the residents, as well as providing commercial space that will be beneficial to all Brunswick residents. I have had a very positive experience with this developer and with everything at the Sandpiper, And I am very excited. I've been talking to people about this building, people outside of Brunswick, because this is something that is really satisfying after living here for 25 years to see this come to Brunswick. We're really lucky. Come on up. [1:31:06] Speaker R (unidentified): Hello. My name is Fred Horch. I live on [street]. And I just want to say that it's great, I think, to get this site taken care of. And I think digging out the soil for a parking garage is actually, I think, one of the best ways to deal with this problem. If you don't deal with it now, you're going to have to deal with it later. So I appreciate the concern the gentleman expressed about what happens during construction. And so good oversight and good rules are helpful there. But if you think about the long term, what we want to do with this site, I think digging a big hole and taking care of all that soil in a good way with a good developer is really a wise thing to do. So I hope you all approve the project, and I hope the town gets behind it. [1:31:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else in the audience? Come on up. [1:32:03] Speaker S (unidentified): My name is Courtney Leavique. I'm not a resident of Brunswick, but I do have commercial property downtown very near the site. And, I mean, the project looks fine. It looks a little imposing. I'm a little concerned, obviously, during the construction period what that's going to do to that end of town. I think that's going to be kind of interesting. But my bigger concern, really, I had brought up, I think, I came to the wrong meeting last week, brought up an issue of parking. My building is on Bank Street, so I've had, I think I've had the building for 23 years, so I have a pretty bird's eye view of parking issues in Brunswick, particularly downtown. And it really is, I mean, a lot of the week, it's like vultures circling, trying to get spots, and there's a lot of frustration. And I know people park at Norway, and people will park down in CEI. And I think, you know, the businesses don't seem to mind too much. I don't know what the liability is if somebody falls in their parking lot. My driveway, no one's tried to park there yet, so that's good. But I walked this town. In fact, I walked over here tonight. And I think you have real issues with pedestrian crossings. If you've ever crossed over to Bangor Savings from that corner, anybody done that lately? You are taking your life in your own hands because you have to look behind. behind, you have to look up front, you've got to look to the side. And people are very distracted. This building is going to be another distraction, certainly in the short term, perhaps in the long term. So, I mean, I think I've ran into people last week from Connecticut, and they were going to cross Main Street. And I said, you should be very careful crossing Main Street. And they looked at me a little funny. I said, no, you should really. And this was Friday noontime, and they went across one of the bigger ones. I ran into them later, and they said, we're glad you said something because we had to go like this at some point. There's very little presence on Main Street as far as making sure. I mean I see people jaywalk too. That's also a problem. I see runners run through things but there's very little surveillance as far as making sure cars are going slowly. I mean I call it the Main Street mammaries but people fly over those. I think they've gotten to be kind of fun to go shooting over those things and I think I was reading through the last meeting, which was, I think, 67 pages, and it mentioned something about bikes. I hope not on the sidewalks. So I do have a big question about, are bikes going to be allowed on the sidewalks? [1:34:31] Speaker M (unidentified): Bikes are allowed on the sidewalks in town. [1:34:34] Speaker S (unidentified): Really? Yes. So they don't have to follow the rules of the road? [1:34:39] Speaker M (unidentified): Not necessarily, if they're on the sidewalk. [1:34:41] Speaker S (unidentified): Interesting, because I think that really is dangerous. Like, when I'm walking, I hear someone blow their hand and say, on the left, and they're coming fast. I just, I don't know. I'm very, careful. I think you're just asking for trouble. I think, in fact, I know it's a little radical. I would say no bikes on Main Street. You have federal and union. You come off side street, you walk your bike. You're going to, I think you're just asking for real problems, especially e-bikes, because they're heavy and they're fast. I see people biking fast, and that's my common in the long term. Like I said, I don't live in the town, but I walk every day probably four miles downtown. I'm going to walk back to my office after this. And like I said, I'm super careful. I have flashlights. I have things in my hand. I have flashing things on whether it's daytime or not. But I think that corner in particular, you just put in an extra flashy, which if you're looking, there's the pedestrian flashy. You have the flashy above. If you add another flashy here, year. I don't know how drivers are going to determine which one belongs. So I think you have a real issue on that corner pedestrian-wise. That's my two cents. I think parking, you have an issue in this town, which I think you're going to have to address sooner than later. And that was it. Just I think those are things to be aware of because you're pushing this as a biking and walking venture, which is great. Like I said, I walk every day. But I think you're not putting in enough safety, whether people need to walk better, which they do, but I think people need to drive better, and they need to park better. So I think the parallel parking, whether you're losing two spaces or more, people have to be able to parallel park. We're all going back to driver's inn. So that was my two cents. [1:36:34] Speaker A (unidentified): anybody else in the audience either of the people on online all right seeing nobody I'll close the public comment come back to members of the board for final questions or comments Allison I would just say having recently moved [1:37:02] Speaker F (unidentified): from downtown I share the concerns about pedestrian safety but I do I do believe that the improvements that DOT is planning at the corner of Mason is supposed to enhance pedestrian safety a bit. But, Ryan, maybe you know what those plans are. [1:37:21] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, and I'm not going to take credit for it or blame for it. T.Y. Lynn will be doing a project to fully signalize that intersection again, which will be coordinated with the signal just up the street from them. When they do that, there will be pedestrian-actuated crossings so that they will have better visibility and safer crossing times for going across Mason and Main at that location. [1:37:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else? No? All right. With that, we'll go to motion number two, and I'd like a motion that the following waivers are approved. [1:37:58] Speaker M (unidentified): Bill? Excuse me. Chair. Chair, we have some revised waivers there in that respect. I think probably waiver number one would not be applicable if the condition of the tree is such where it doesn't require it. And I can read the revised waiver, too, if that's all right. [1:38:22] Speaker A (unidentified): And you're probably pointing this out, but the second waiver, I was just going to reference Ryan Layton's recommendation that it be approved. So you probably are already on top of that. [1:38:39] Speaker M (unidentified): What we have is that the Planning Board grants a waiver from Section 4.5.4C to allow the applicant's alternative approach for improving stormwater quality and from Section 4.5.4D for stormwater runoff quantity requirements based on the materials and findings stated in the October 27, 2026 Planning Board packet. [1:39:04] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Do I have a waiver to that effect? Do I have a motion for a waiver to that effect? Motion by Laura, second by Steve. All those in favor? That's unanimous of the board members present. And I would like a motion that the planning board approves the major development review application for the mixed-use building on property located at 53 to 69 Main Street, map U13, lots 121 and 123, as outlined in the application with the following conditions. And I think we all, did we all agree that three, we're removing five anyway, that three, nine, and ten could be dispensed with? Okay. Okay. Leaving out three, nine, and ten. [1:40:15] Speaker M (unidentified): Okay. That the board's review and approval does hereby refer to these findings of fact, plans and materials submitted by the applicant and the written and oral comments of the applicant, their representatives, reviewing officials and members of the public as reflected in the public record. Any changes to the approved plan not called for in these conditions of approval or otherwise approved by the Director of Planning and Development as a minor modification shall require review and approval in accordance with the Brunswick Zoning Ordinance. Two, prior to the review of a building permit application, the applicant shall submit approved DEP voluntary response action program documentation to the town planning director. And three, no building permit application shall be reviewed prior to the effective date of the contract zone for the property effective on November 18th, 2026. and four prior to the review of a building permit application the applicant shall pay the appropriate recreation facilities impact fee as established in section 20-203 of the brunswick code of ordinances five prior to the sale of any unit the applicant shall submit governing documents for an hoa or equivalent entity establishing responsibility for maintaining all site features the governing documents shall be subject to review and approval by the town attorney and shall be recorded prior to the sale of the first unit six prior to review of a building permit application the applicant shall submit additional information about the garage signalization including specifications and an updated elevation to the satisfaction of the planning director and the town engineer and seven prior to the review of a building permit application, all easements and any encroachment licenses shall be obtained and submitted to the Director of Planning and Development. Eight, modifications to the underground parking layout may be administratively approved by the Planning Director, provided that at least 38 parking spaces are maintained. 9, prior to the review of a building permit application, the applicant shall submit a funding commitment letter from Norway Savings Bank or other evidence of financial capacity in an amount matching a submitted proposed project budget. And then the last one was something that was mentioned by the applicant. It was a condition about chimney swifts, which is not something that the ordinance requires. And is that something that, okay. And we will leave it at that. [1:42:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. We have nine conditions now. Okay. All right. Do I have a motion to that effect? Motion by Laura, second by Allison. All those in favor? That's unanimous of the board members present. It's a great project. Good luck. It's going to be a great anchor for downtown. Yes. We're going to take a quick break. Yes. [1:43:30] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm kind of sad to see Jones Farm go. That was the first application I ever got here. Yeah. This one was? No joke. [1:51:00] Speaker A (unidentified): We're back in session. We have case 25-23, Avalon Woods, the Woodside Residential Subdivision. We're having a workshop tonight, and we're going to hold the workshop on a major development and review final plan application submitted by the Sebago Technics on behalf of the property owner, Wiley Enterprises, LLC, for a 100-unit subdivision consisting of 36 single-family lots and eight two-story multifamily buildings with eight units in each building. A new public road has been designed to provide access from Woodside Road with sidewalks, a connection to Arrowhead Drive, and three connections to existing trails. The subject properties are located on Woodside Road, Map 22, Lots 9 and 180, and within the Growth Residential Zoning District, the Shoreland Protection Overlay Sub-District and Shoreland Protection Overlay Stream Protection Sub-District. [1:52:07] Speaker F (unidentified): Bill, if I may? I just want to disclose to my colleagues and the public that I live at Thornton Oaks, and I'm a shareholder there. I have a cottage, and the Thornton Oaks property abuts this development. I've sat on this board throughout, and I plan to continue unless you'd like me to recuse myself. [1:52:31] Speaker A (unidentified): No, we would like you to continue, I think. I see nods all around. Okay. Owens? [1:52:40] Speaker J (unidentified): Good evening. My name is Owens McCullough, civil engineer with Sebago Technics, here tonight on behalf of Wiley Enterprises, LLC. With me is Matt Pamphil from our office, one of our land planners. We've been in front of this board a few different times. We've had some public meetings, some prior workshops, made a number of refinements, and then now have proceeded with our full application for major subdivision review with the board. So tonight I think there's a very large packet of information that has been submitted and provided, but I think tonight at staff's recommendation was we have a workshop so that we can kind of go over what the changes have been, what the updates are, and where we're at with it. So we're here tonight just to make a presentation, a workshop, and gather some information from you folks. Next slide, please. As the chairman indicated, the project is located in the growth residential four zone, which allows up to six units per acre. Our parcel is about 24.6 acres with frontage on Woodside Road. and then access will be from Woodside Road and a right-of-way connection to Arrowhead Drive. This zone allows for both single-family and multifamily housing with some footprint requirements and some height requirements, which we've worked within. Next slide, please. This is a rendering of the current development plan. It includes a traditional residential subdivision in the front two-thirds of the property. That will include 36 single-family house lots, a public access road all the way through, 24-foot wide, curbed public sewer, water, underground electric, telephone communications. It will have street trees along the road, which is a requirement in the land use code. And then within the development, there will be some stormwater BMPs. One of the lots, well, I'll actually show it on two crosshatch areas, which will include some stormwater BMPs in those areas. One's an underdrained soil filter, the other's a gravel wetland. The large cross-hatched area towards the back of the site, at one point we were looking to put single-family houses on that lot, but instead we've decided to focus just on using that for stormwater management. So that cross-hatched area that you see up there will be in part the stormwater and then and the rest will be undeveloped land within the development. Also, then, at the back third, a little more than a third, we're proposing to do 64 multifamily housing units. Those will consist of 42-bedroom and 24 one-bedroom units for the total of 100 units between the multifamily and the single family. That also kicks in the 15% requirement for affordable housing, which will include 10 units within the multifamily housing, and I'll explain more of that here in a few minutes. The calculation for the allowable density on this property is 115 units, but practically speaking, it works for 100 units, so that's what we've moved forward with. As I indicated earlier, it'll all be public water and sewer. We've been in contact with both the Brunswick Tops and Waters District and the Brunswick Sewer District. We've provided them plans, they've provided review letters, they've given us their capacity, ability to serve for the project. The water line will come down from Arrowhead Drive down on Woodside Road, come down through the development and connect back into the lower portion of Arrowhead Drive to provide a looped system. And sewer will tie into a manhole at the end of Arrowhead Drive. The Brunswick Sewer District has provided us with a review letter. They're asking for a contribution to do some pump improvement projects on their pump station that's off Arrowhead Drive. The applicant's agreeable to do that. I think it's in the $30,000 range for those improvements. For stormwater management, there'll be a subsurface drainage system within the roadway. We'll collect that drainage to catch basins. Those will discharge into under-drained soil filters, gravel wetlands. There's some smaller BMPs on some of the lots, all detailed out on the rather large plan that we had submitted, and those will collect, treat, detain the runoff so that we're at pre-development rates or below when they discharge. Permitting, this project requires a main DEP site location, a Development Act permit, and an NRPA permit. Those both have been submitted. We, back in, I think it was September, we had a public informational meeting at the library in June. Was it June? Oh, it was the workshop here that we had with, yeah, okay. So it was back in June, and then we filed those applications after that. Those are all submitted. submitted. The lots in the development will range from about 7,400 square feet all the way up to about 29,000 square feet, depending on the lot location. And again, it's all intended to be a public road and sidewalk. Next slide, please. This is a little more zoomed in on the single family subdivision. A couple of things to note on the common property line with the Woodcove development. We're proposing a 25 foot buffer, which is the green shaded area that comes down along the backs of lots five through 12, Lots 1 through 4 will be a larger buffer because there's a wetland up there and we're going to stay 25 feet off the wetland. So that's why that all shows as green on the plan. And then as you come down from lots 12 through 20, there's a 75-foot buffer that includes the first 50 as a no-disturb. they're between 50 and 75 there's the opportunity to remove trees consistent with the shoreline zoning requirements basically has to do with the point systems within those developments and we've already done a tree survey over the whole property which is included in the application and then as you move further down lots 20 21 22 and 23 we'll go back to the 25 foot buffer although practically we expect the development will happen more in the front part of those Lots and then what's labeled is lot 30 38 that lot is where the storm Stormwater is going to be, and it's a no-development lot other than for stormwater and buffering. That's why that area is shown on there. Within the subdivision, there'll be one wetland intermittent stream crossing. That is located down at the lower part of the site across from the large cross-hatched area. That location will have a box culvert installed embedded into the soil substrate to provide for basically stream smart crossing and passage through that. And those are all detailed on the development plans. We did have a site walk with Sam Shepard from the Maine DEP a while ago. And we walked and looked at the wetlands and looked at the development area. Just so that he was familiar with it the William O'Connor from Longview partners who did the wetland mapping on the property attended that site walk also What came away from the site walk was I think general concurrence with? What he saw out there for wetland mapping that Sam Shepard from the main DEP the project will include approximately 3,300 square feet of wetland alteration, very small, pocketed wetland areas. We've tried to work around, frankly, as much or all the wetlands that we reasonably could. Down at the sort of the area that is linear, and it says raised sidewalk crossing, I had the opportunity to meet with Margaret from the Land Trust out there and one of her associates. We walked those areas. I appreciated the opportunity, too. And what we're proposing to do is at that location create a connection over to the trail system. It would be a mid-block crossing in the road. So if you look at the details of the plans, we're proposing that to be a raised sidewalk in that location, sort of like a speed table, but with a sidewalk and striped on top of it. And we're also proposing to put in some of the flashing beacons that somebody can push, and it'll signal a crosswalk in that location. that configuration also will help tends to keep traffic moving a little bit slower through these residential roads especially with the raised speed table next slide please the next slide provides an overview of the multifamily housing units those will include single bedroom and two bedroom units within the development the breakdown is I think it's 42 and 24 one-bedroom units we're providing parking the land use code requires one space per bedroom first for one bedroom apartments and requires two parking spaces for two bedroom units in total the ordinance requirement would be 104 parking spaces but we're going to provide 119 basically an additional 15 spaces for visitors or potential additional need for it 's kind of funny some of the communities they want you to have less parking to try to force less reliance on vehicles other communities prefer for a little more parking your land use code has one per one bedroom two for two bedroom but we built a little extra reserve capacity into it we're also showing on the if you look at the detailed plans up where it says lot 39 which is the multi-family development 11 EV-ready parking spots up there. And each of the building units, which is detailed more on the landscape plans and site plans, there'll be exterior bike racks at each of the building units. Sidewalks work all the way around the parking lot with connections to the building entries. A detailed out landscape plan is included in the package which includes trees, plantings, and includes ground plantings. When we were before the board previously, I think we had shown on the lower end some infringement into that lower wetland. under this configuration, basically with a little bit more of an S-curve through the development with the connection to Arrowhead Drive. We were able to move the development out of that wetland area, so we'll have no wetland impact down there. That area will remain undisturbed, undeveloped, with the exception of a proposed trail connection down to the lower end of the site. There's another trail down through there, down at the bottom of the site. The plan includes a dumpster enclosure that's plan bottom to the right across from Building 6, sidewalks around to each of the buildings to connect to each of the units, A DRIVEWAY ACCESS BACK OUT ON TO AVALON WOODS ROAD. AND THEN WE HAVE A SECOND RAISED SIDEWALK CROSSING. THAT RAISED SIDEWALK WILL BE IDENTICAL TO THE OTHER ONE I JUST DESCRIBED WITH THE FLASHING BEACONS. AND THAT WILL PROVIDE A CONNECTION THROUGH THE DEVELOPMENT TO ANOTHER POINT OF A PROPOSED TRAIL CONNECTION over to the land trust property and then we're providing another one in yellow that goes down through the site and connects in so there'll be two points of connection the arrowhead drive connection i might as well address this now i know there's been a lot of conversation around that the Applicant's Legal Counsel, and it's included in your package, back in 1986 there was an agreement made with the development, Wood Cove Associates, that traded some land and some drainage for the right to access Arrowhead Drive. So that was in a record deed easement, and the attorney put together a legal summary of what that is, and we included that deed in the right-of-way. So that was contemplated through, apparently, a negotiation back in 1986. Next slide, please. For the multifamily units, These are the growth residential four zone allows for multifamily, but the zone put in a restriction of you can't have more than a 5,000 square foot building footprint. I think that was likely put in there on purpose so that it keeps the mass, the size of any multifamily buildings to a smaller size, and the height limitations of that zone still apply, which is 35 feet. So we're working with all of that, and as you may, when we were before the board, it's been quite a while, there was some conversation about trying to do something more residential in style, more residential, and look for these buildings, so the developer worked with his architect to come up with building elevations that include dormers, shake shingles, window penetrations in it, sloped roofs like a chimney or cupola on top, simulated chimney, many porches on the buildings and other architectural features to try and make the massing of the building more smaller in scale. And all of our buildings are under the 5,000. Actually, one's like 4,936 square feet and the other is like 4,200 square feet, depending on whether it's one- or two-bedroom units. When I was last in front of the planning board, I think we had a rendering up that showed a palette color that was more of a gray tone, and I think there was some questions about can we have different color schemes, different mixes of colors so they don't all don't look alike so in working with the developer these are some samples we can do a two-tone look on it we can do a traditional white building with a gray and a black roof greens light blues the developer is willing to mix and match the colors up so that it's just not one complete, one monotone look in the color. So they are working, willing to do that. We hope that these will provide a little better look. Next slide, please. This is the floor plan of the multifamily buildings. Remember, they're two stories. The one-bedroom units are 926 square feet with a 3676 footprint. And then the two-bedroom are 1131 square feet, 4900 square foot footprint. Two levels, porches or balconies, depending on when you're on the first floor or the second floor. and then a stairway entry from two points up into the building. Generally one bathroom, two bedrooms, one bathroom, one bedroom, a kitchen, dining, living area. Next slide, please. One of the other conversations we've had was to undertake a traffic impact study, which was completed in a full report included in the application. Our traffic engineer followed the trip generation manual for the Institute of Traffic Engineers to assess the trip generation rates for the development. Then looked at a study area outside the development that included Woodside Road as well as intersection at Woodside Road at Church Street and Woodside Road at Pleasant Hill Road. the ite generated that the development would generate about 64 77 and 69 trips in the a.m p.m and saturday peak hours respectively that's below the hundred trip ends that would require state permitting so we're below that threshold traffic movement counts were completed actually, last year in October, those were at the intersection of Church and Woodside, and Arrowhead, Pleasant Hill Road, and Woodside Road. Our traffic engineer confirmed, because our company is actually doing the work for the Thompson Land Trust Farmer's Market, that it was in operation when they counted the trips. Those were done last October. a.m. peak, p.m. peak, and then Saturday when the peak hour was expected on the Saturday. The roadways in the project area are classified by DOT as a group one roadway, which is basically an urban road. And then when we calculated the trip generation rates, the traffic engineer applied the MDOT seasonal adjustments that accounts for the timing I mean, in the peak of the day, that calculation is all in the traffic engineer's submittal. We also factored in either unbuilt or in-process developments that we were aware of in the traffic impact statement study. That includes Woodside private street development. I believe that was two residential lots from what we could find. The village on Pleasant Hill, 23 single-family, Hancock Lumber Redevelopment, and Wilbur's Woods Subdivision, which was 21 single-family homes. So the traffic engineer considered those developments. ONE INTERESTING THING OF NOTE WAS THE PLEASANT HILL ROAD INTERSECTION WAS FORMALLY CLASSIFIED AS A HIGH CRASH LOCATION PRIOR TO THE INSTALLATION OF THE ALL WAY STOP, WHICH SINCE THAT TIME THE DATA SHOWS THAT IT IS NO LONGER A HIGH CRASH LOCATION. SO THAT TRAFFIC IMPROVEMENT SEEMS TO BE WORKING WELL. Next slide, please. The findings of the traffic study, so part of the study looks at the speeds of traffic on there. The recorded travel speeds were consistent with the 35-mile-an-hour posted speed limit. That's based on the 85th percentile. That is a calculation used by traffic engineers to identify the median speed through that area The proposed as I indicated the proposed development was expected to generate 64 trips 77 and 69 and am PM and Saturday peak hours They measured site distance at the development, and based on the speed, the site distance is adequate at the proposed location. If you remember, we originally had the access sort of splitting the lot at the intersection of Woodside Road, but we shifted it over after some additional conversation. A CAPACITY ANALYSIS WAS ALSO COMPLETED, LOOKING AT THE CAPACITY INTERSECTIONS IN THE ROADS. THE ANALYSIS WHICH FOLLOWS THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ANALYSIS PROCEDURE DETERMINED THAT IN THE FUTURE BUILD CONDITIONS IT'S SIMILAR TO THE NO BUILD CONDITIONS. ALL MOVEMENTS WERE ANTICIPATED TO HAVE AN ACCEPTABLE LEVEL OF SERVICE OF C OR BETTER. Many of the intersections are B or A. The traffic, the turning movements didn't reach the threshold where we would need to consider a left turn or right turn in lane. And then lastly, as I said earlier, the only high crash location in the area was Pleasant Hill Road. but since they went to the four-way stop the data the last year's data since they put that in has shown that it's fallen below the high crash level so it's much better now last slide please so tonight we're really here to continue the conversation at a workshop level we appreciated meeting with staff we gather a little bit of feedback with staff. We'll follow up with some of their questions, most of that. We're going to meet with the wetland scientists, is meeting with the environmental planner. I think, Julie, correct me if I'm wrong. Is it next week? I think it's next week, right? So we'll be meeting with her. She had some questions, so we'll meet with her to go over that. And at this point, we've filed our state DEP permit and NRPA permit, which, as you probably all know, will take some time to get through. But we want to use that time wisely and get to you with a workshop presentation and gather some additional feedback. So thank you very much. [2:20:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Owens. before I come to the board to start discussion I asked Julie a while ago if we could have a site walk and she's organizing that and I guess she'll put out times that we can all agree on hopefully and members of the public are welcome to join in any site walk that we take and the other thing I'll just put out there that I have read the traffic study and I think it is lacking in some areas and after our discussion I have proposed or I might I will propose that we asked for a third party traffic impact study to verify the findings of Sebago Technics and we have to vote on that as a board to approve that and then we can do it so let's start discussion who would like to begin Laura? [2:22:15] Speaker H (unidentified): Sure so I just want to start by saying thank you for the recap appreciate you going through It's a very, thick packet, so it's always nice to have a good refresh. So the last time we saw this project, we had 45 single-family units and six eight-unit apartment buildings. So can you just kind of explain why it's transitioned to a larger development and why the shift away from single-family to apartments? [2:22:51] Speaker J (unidentified): When we started the grading drainage utility design and then we looked at the connection to Arrowhead Drive, the road that was up there on the screen now has this sort of like an S curve over there before it went further down and up and around so we could fit some more single family lots in it. After some discussion with the developer, we felt that it made more sense to do a few more single – to do a few more apartments, a few less single-family house lots. It's still our density, I think, was still over 100 originally on the last one. I think it was 93 at that point. That's right, because we were like 111, and then we went down to like 93, and we settled on 100. Sorry about that. So we ended up in that scenario. The other thing, too, that I failed to mention in detail was that we're going to end up having to provide 10 affordable housing units within this 15%. So the shift increased the number of affordable housing, which is 80% of the adjusted mean income. And there's a calculation in the application that shows that. We also set it up specifically, and there's notes on the plan, and will be in the covenants, that there will have to be one affordable unit per building. So there's eight, right? So that means that we couldn't just do one building of all one-bedroom apartments. They'll be affordable for two bedrooms, too. So every building gets an affordable unit, and then two additional ones interspersed within them. So we were, after going through all this, we felt that this made for a better approach down through there. Hopefully that answers. [2:25:07] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, and that's typically how we like to see affordable housing, you know, interspersed, not just all kind of isolated to one area that's kind of going. [2:25:17] Speaker J (unidentified): All in one bedroom, right? Yes. [2:25:20] Speaker H (unidentified): No, we like to see a variety for that. Also, just kind of thinking about that, so I did kind of look at the rent exercise that you had. Is that what they're basing? Are they basing the rent of a one- or a two-bedroom off of a four-person household? [2:25:42] Speaker J (unidentified): Matt and I talked about that just a few minutes before. [2:25:44] Speaker H (unidentified): Or was that just a thought exercise? [2:25:45] Speaker J (unidentified): That was just a thought exercise. size. If there's a one bedroom and one person lives in it, would use, I think there was a table that showed one, two, three, four, five, six, and it would be based on the one, whatever that family number is. If it's one person, I suppose two people could live in a one bedroom, but it would be based on the actual number of people. And Julie, you'll have to help me because honestly,, I don't know how the town, I guess at the time, they must be some sort of monitoring process so that make sure that we're giving you the affordable house or the affordable unit. And if it's a one-bedroom, we'll have it in our bylaws, too. But if you have anything to add. [2:26:32] Speaker M (unidentified): You would have to have someone monitor the affordability for you. Okay. The town wouldn't do it. You'd have to hire somebody to do it. [2:26:42] Speaker J (unidentified): We'll make sure that gets documented into the affordable bylaws. I think there's even a requirement for that to be written into the documents. [2:26:59] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay. And then the other thing is it's been brought up a few times in some comments that the transitioning into Arrowhead, that was not necessarily or did not appear to be part of the traffic study as to how that would impact that neighborhood in particular. So that was a concern that was raised. Could you speak a little bit more on that? [2:27:24] Speaker J (unidentified): So I did talk to the traffic engineer. He indicated that when they do these analyses, is they look at the likelihood, the probability of which way people will go. So if you – it's about 2,300 feet of road back to Woodside through our development. If you go the other side through Woodside, it's a much longer route to take, and people will notoriously take the shorter route. So his prediction was that almost all of that traffic would go up to Woodside Road. Now, that doesn't mean that if somebody has a home and they have kids or friends in the next subdivision that they might go through to visit people in between the subdivisions. But the expectation was most of the traffic would come up through, and I can have him write more about that. [2:28:22] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, and I think especially the concern was that the vast density of the housing now is towards the end of the road, and you have the connection to Arrowhead right there. And I can see, especially as morning traffic might pile up at one side, that people will go the other way, even if it's a little longer, because maybe they're not waiting as long to turn, if you get what I mean. So it might be valuable still to look at both, especially since that's the turn in and that's the area that's going to be most impacted by that character change. change. Another thing is, I do like that you're adding in the raised tables to kind of help calm traffic. The S curve will also help with that. It might be nice to have that on the other side of the entrance to help calm traffic that's coming out of the apartment complex and going into Arrowhead. So that might be another consideration, is to have that second speed table just a little further away or have an additional one, maybe whatever seems like a good fit. so the, next thing I wanted to talk about, has to deal with mere Brooke. Chris isn't here, so I feel like I have to stand up for her. Chris, thank you. Yeah, well, I'm not a stormwater engineer and so I will do my best to help with that but in terms of just wanting to make sure that we're limiting the amount of pesticide herbicides that are traveling into that stream potentially it would be nice to see on the HOA something that restricts the use of those two elements I know that as a town we are you've been there's been chatter about having that as part of something more townwide but it would be nice to see that in an HOA just to limit more sources of potential contaminants to Mare Brook and in the HOA section 3d there's some kind of a dangling fragment of a sentence okay just I don't think it meant it's meant to be there it looks like it was from a template and then it didn't get deleted. But the other thing was, you said that the potassium standard would be satisfied through the Mayor Brook Fund. Is there a potential, however, to rather than just pay a fee, is there a potential to just eliminate that? And kind of what was the thought process behind, or how is that not possible to do? I just would appreciate some explanation. [2:31:23] Speaker J (unidentified): Well, my understanding is that the Mayor Brook Fund, the Watershed Management Plan, allows for the collection of monies based on the amount of impervious surface that would go into a fund that could accumulate with other funds to do, I don't know, a culvert crossing or some larger project, as opposed to a developer going up on, say, Woodside Road and maybe doing some sort of BMP along the road to collect some drainage. The idea is that it would be more holistic, and I think most communities that I've experienced will want to see that fund, take that money. And then, Julia, I honestly am not 100% sure what you, in the watershed management plan, if there were priorities of what that money would go to. I assume there are. Most of them do. So that accumulates funds to do a more holistic approach to watershed management. [2:32:33] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm aware. I'm just curious as to what was the excess, kind of if you could explain what the excess is. And where it's situated, why was the decision made to not treat? [2:32:51] Speaker J (unidentified): We're treating 95% of all the runoff from the development, over 80% of the development area. But even meeting the DEP standard, we cannot meet the requirement for the urban impaired watershed. You can't get there just doing the basic standards, so you would either have to go off-site somewhere else in that development and treat a small fragmented area to treat that runoff, or communities will adopt a CFOP, Compensation Fee Utilization Plan, that they can collect money and do a more holistic approach to watershed management. and if I'm I may not be doing that as much justice as Julie or Matt could explain but I [2:33:47] Speaker M (unidentified): Think you're doing great. Okay. I Don't really have anything to add to that [2:33:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Then the other thing is also related to kind of limiting that effluent is What is your plan for snow storage? Where is that thought to be? I'm apologize if it was in the plans and I'd missed it But where is that planned? Is there anything that is going – I know one of the things I brought up last time was the idea of lowering salt usage to the extent that makes sense for safety. but what is basically kind of trying to consider other potential sources of pollution and where those are planning to be stored and what thoughts you have on that. [2:34:41] Speaker J (unidentified): So the snow storage probably is more on the single-family lot. People push it up on their driveways, normal stuff there. But down in the multifamily housing, we fully expect that the management company, because they'll have a management company that will plow and maintain that area. If we get a heavy snow, they will have to remove that snow to keep the parking open. There's some landscaped meeting areas, but we don't have a lot of snow storage. And we've actually talked about that internally, and it would have to be removed. We just need the space for the parking. [2:35:22] Speaker H (unidentified): And that makes sense, just making sure that was part of your game plan. In terms of salting, any thoughts? Boy. [2:35:33] Speaker J (unidentified): Well, if the road gets turned over to the town, that would be a question for the Public Works Department on public policy. [2:35:42] Speaker A (unidentified): But if it doesn't? If it doesn't. But they wouldn't be plowing the parking lot of the town? No. [2:35:48] Speaker J (unidentified): So the parking lot, so there's a couple of things to think about down there. Slip and fall is a big deal. I did an expert witness on a court case for Maine General Health a few years ago that literally they sued because the person who fell sued the hospital because they felt they did not properly salt or put enough salt or sand down. There's a whole liability issue around all of that, and I don't know what to say other than if they could change tort law or change the laws that people wouldn't be able to, because the liability is a big deal in these developments. So salt, I mean, we can try to have them manage the salt as much as light as it can. [2:36:40] Speaker H (unidentified): Or just use of things that are not as damaging. Like there's levels of different substances that you can use, some that are more or less friendly than others. So an effort to look at what would be a better alternative for Mayor Brooke based on what the needs are for that would be a good idea. [2:37:10] Speaker J (unidentified): Okay. We'll take a look at that. [2:37:13] Speaker H (unidentified): And then the last thing I wanted to bring up is just it looks like a couple of the lots are just, I think it's specifically lot 21 and 22, just looks really broken up by that very large pool that's in the middle of them. just kind of wondering why that doesn't get kind of why those lots are still kind of crossing that wouldn't it be easier just to have that kind of tucked elsewhere I know you guys have probably looked at a few different versions of how to lay that out and it may not be possible but just [2:37:52] Speaker J (unidentified): wondering what your thoughts were on that it's a fair question we looked spent a lot of time I'm looking at how to work the lots out which and we did make a number of adjustments here and there in the lots which I'm glad you asked because I didn't mention this that leads to the next thing in the plan which you don't always see on subdivisions we actually did a grading plan and prototype and we put houses and garages and typical layouts on all the lots because we wanted We wanted to see, based on the roadway elevations, the utilities, the sewer and water through it, how that would translate into a buildable lot. You know, does that mean daylight basements? What does it mean for garages? So we actually did a mass grading plan, which was quite an exercise. It took a fair amount of time to do it, but it's it got it gets a lot to what you were Speaking to see how each of those lots might lay out And those building envelopes could work around those wetland buffers and those areas and that's all in and we did make Adjustments to lots we did about as much as we possibly could and we wanted to keep a buffer on the lots Well, it basically goes 1 through 23 on that backside because we had a shoreline protection overlay district in one spot there. And then we wanted to create a 25-foot no-disturbance buffer along the lots that weren't in there. so we literally went through an exercise of moving lot lines adjusting where building windows would go and trying to grade out driveways and houses and see what they would all look like i'm not saying that somebody wouldn't want to build a different house but we wanted to know we wanted to vet it and know that it was doable in fact there's a note on the plan that i asked to put on it's on the subdivision plan sorry the code enforcement officer may kick me for this but I suggested, South Portland does it too, I suggested in there that when somebody comes in to get a building permit, that they have a lot plan and show what the grades would look like on those lots. I wanted to give some teeth to, besides to put all that work into that grading plan. [2:40:22] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, no, that makes sense to make sure each lot was buildable, which was part of that question, because some of them got a little wonky looking with the shape. And then the last thing I probably if you were listening to any of the earlier discussion is just kind of another concern for the resource buffers just having some kind of physical marker usually on the lot can be helpful for landowners to know where their no cut disturbance is to help ensure that buffer actually stays a buffer and doesn't become lawn by attrition. [2:40:56] Speaker J (unidentified): I was listening to that. Usually we have to put pens or markers along those that said, that little cap that says wetland buffers, and I'm not sure I have that note on the plan. So I did hear that. [2:41:10] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm going to stop talking now. Okay, thank you. Rob? Hi, Owen. [2:41:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Hi. Can you talk about, I know we'll be out there for a site visit, but I'm curious. The cutting that was done out there, did that impair the intended buffers that are designed into this plan? In other words, did the cutting go closer to the lot lines than the buffer that's being suggested here? [2:41:48] Speaker J (unidentified): I'm going to suggest that we did a tree survey out there, and it's in the plans that shows all the trees. I think it's, what, over 10 inches that you have to locate. So we did a complete tree survey, and there's quite a bit of tree growth that's left out there. And we've staked the center line of the roadway out. And I'd almost suggest that you have to see it. I think a site walk's a good idea to see it, and you'll be able to judge for yourself what it is. But it's not like a clear-cut, denuded piece of property. It's more selective. But, again, what I say, I think it would be better for you to see it. [2:42:30] Speaker D (unidentified): How far back behind these apartments is the property line? I mean, we've always had pictures of the development part, but in relation to the entire lot, how far is there undisturbed area between the end of the apartment buildings And then the next property line, I guess it would be to the east. To [2:43:00] Speaker J (unidentified): the east. So that would be, unfortunately, do you have the, could you maybe put my sketch plan back up there? I just wanted to make sure we're talking about the same location. So are you talking about this area back here? Yeah,. [2:43:24] Speaker D (unidentified): And I'm assuming that diagonal line is the property line of the abutter, or the common property line. [2:43:32] Speaker J (unidentified): Yes, this is the... [2:43:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, that I've got. I'm talking about to the right, yeah. This one? Yeah. Oh, okay. [2:43:41] Speaker J (unidentified): I don't have an exact measurement here, but... [2:43:48] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I mean, you know, from here I can see it looks like about 25% of the line. [2:43:53] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, it's a pretty healthy distance, probably 400 or 500 feet maybe. [2:43:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, all right. I was just trying to get a better mental image of where this – I would agree that in the discussion with Laura, too, about marking these buffers from cutting because, again, that could happen easily and perhaps innocently and defeat the purpose of trying to maintain that buffer. Is there going to be a common builder for these projects, or are individual lots going to be sold and people find their own builder? [2:44:44] Speaker J (unidentified): I've asked the developer, and it could be either. And I apologize. I wish I could give you a defense, but it could be either. The developer could just sell the lots and let other developers build it or could opt to build some themselves. So I'm sorry. I'm not trying to be evasive. [2:45:02] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, no,. I mean, it just seems to me that if it's choose your own, there's got to be some good surveillance to make sure that every new home builder that comes in there understands all the rules and regs and observes them. So I would I would be concerned, more concerned or want more sort of restrictions to or obligations to communicate certain things to, you know, new develop new builders as they come onto the scene. i and i'm looking at this map it just seems to me that you know just because you can you know squeeze a hundred units here you know should you and i look at lot 24 lot 37 these are tiny little triangles and then i look at the lots that have a lot of wetland associated with them like 29 and 30, 20 and 21, 22, and just saying, you know, if you consider just leaving those as green space and not getting tangled up with the resource, the wetland resource. Well, I mean, honestly, this seems like, you know, just trying to squeeze out every possible opportunity And, you know, really, I don't know if, you know, I know it's maximizing profit for the developer, but, you know, looking at the compromises that are being made, it just occurs to me that there are probably options to do almost as much as you want to do without impacting the resources as much as is outlined on this plan. [2:47:00] Speaker J (unidentified): The only reason, so the wetlands that we're impacting is a small triangular area, about 365 square feet on Lot 6. Lot 29 and 30, that was a dug pond, a man-made wetland, and DEP said they wouldn't take jurisdiction over that because that was a man-made one. Okay. So that one will just get filled in. And then moving down across the property, the next wetland is for the road crossing. That's down around lot 19 and 20. Yeah. And then we kept the rest of it. And then we have another wetland crossing down it across from the stream and the big preserved area that's on the site. It's sort of in that linear piece of the road. [2:47:54] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, there's 21 and 22. That are pretty affected by a wetland, if I'm interpreting this map correctly. [2:48:03] Speaker J (unidentified): Yes, and we're not proposing to impact any of those wetlands, which is why we went through this whole exercise of doing grading plans for the lots and showing how the grades with the roads would fit and work, because I actually had to bring the road up in elevation so I could get utilities down to the backside so I can get appropriate cover over it and storm drainage. So we recognize that, and I usually don't go to that extent, but I had to on this one because I needed to be able to understand that it was achievable. [2:48:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, you know, it's not my place to debate this with you. I mean, it's your choice. It's just that it occurred to me that maybe some of those things could be sacrificed for green space and not get tangled up in those wetlands. But that's all I had though. Thank you. Okay. Thanks Steve [2:48:59] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you Bill, thank you for your presentation Here's Steve Walker the conservationist about to say this but you know This lot is in our growth area and has been designated in the growth area for multiple comprehensive plans So I'm not gonna say hundred Lots absolutely go for it But I am gonna say keep that in mind that we have limited develop a little property in the growth area This is where we want growth for purposes of conserving more significant resources in our rural zone. But that said, I would agree that a lot, what is it, the one with the big wetland there, 121 or 22, I can't think. But there's a, you know, you have a floating chunk of the building envelope to the north of that wetland. I think you could probably delete that and add a little more green space there. I like the grading plan. I appreciate the work that went into that. And I would encourage, you know, when you get to the next phase of coming before us, that you snug up building envelopes where you can around to avoid resources. Because I like the layout, the location that you've proposed of buildings and garages in that grading plan. I know you're not about to say that's the final, they've got to go there, they've got to be that shape. but the more you can push future build out in that direction, I think it does make a lot of sense, and it should make it easier for future developers. So I'm glad you went to the code enforcement officer. You're going to have the... [2:50:33] Speaker J (unidentified): I know. I may not be his best friend after this, but I think they've got to have that. [2:50:37] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I would agree, too, and that provides more information about where the resources are. In the buffer, the 75-foot buffer, I would encourage you to keep that no-cut and not try to play this, you know, 25 feet you can do the point system and 50 is no. I would make the whole thing no cut and avoid the hassle of having to enforce cutting restrictions in that 25 feet. You got the opportunity to have a good conserved strip there, and I think that would be a good thing to do, especially for the Arrowhead community to the north. I do agree, traffic, let's have it peer-reviewed, and let's specifically look at flow-through into the Arrowhead Drive subdivision if that hasn't been adequately covered. What else? I think that's about it for workshop-level comments. But overall, I think you're going in the right direction. All right. Thank you, Steve. Allison. [2:51:47] Speaker F (unidentified): my colleagues have pretty much covered everything that I was going to ask. I did have a question, and perhaps I just missed it in that whole grading scheme, but do you know how much ledge there is, how much blasting is going to be involved, if any? I mean, maybe we'll know more when we go out on our site walk, but I was just curious about that. [2:52:13] Speaker J (unidentified): Yes, thank you. So there's going to be some ledge removal that's going to have to happen on the property. When we walk it in the sidewalk, I can show you areas where the ledge is at the surface. We did do a Class B soils study, which meant I sent our soil scientists out, and they dug some test pits and looked at the overburden in the ledge, and they did find areas where there's ledge. So there's going to be utilities likely will have some ledge. We're trying to do work mostly with fill conditions down through the site, bringing fill in as opposed to ledge removal. But there's going to be some ledge removal. And in our DEP application, we included a blasting plan in there that follows the requirements of the state around that. But I'm not going to tell you there's not going to be blasting because there will have to be some. So they may even be able to hammer some of it, but some of that ledge looked pretty solid. And what I think I find is blasting is quicker instead of listening to that hammer being on the ledge. [2:53:26] Speaker F (unidentified): My other question was about construction during when the apartment buildings are being built. because I'm assuming you can't stage, store construction materials or anything like that in either of the protected areas on either side of it. So you'll be confined to the area where the apartment buildings are for all of your material storage and everything. And I was just wondering what your plan is for just managing that. It seems like a very tight space. You do have the parking lot area, I suppose, in the middle of it, but during construction, I'm just concerned about that. [2:54:20] Speaker J (unidentified): We're not expecting that all buildings would be built at the same time. They'll have to build the parking lot and the access in there and stub the utilities in, But the expectation is the apartment buildings would be built over time down there. So where some of the apartment buildings will be, that area would be available for temporary staging or storaging. But eventually the site will get really tight down through there. And like most contractors, when it starts to get tight like that, they're going to come in daily. They'll have to consume some parking spaces initially while they're there during the day, but the expectation would be the materials, what they're using to build would be. [2:55:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Because they just can't go to either side. [2:55:12] Speaker J (unidentified): No, it'll be, yeah. [2:55:15] Speaker F (unidentified): And I guess I, too, the thing that just leapt out at me when I look at the site plan is these awkward lots with wetlands right smack in the middle of them. And it's just, I,, it's just, I, it just, it makes me uneasy. But because I don't know how those wetlands, particularly the significant vernal pool, will end up really being, well, the vernal pools will be protected. That's all. pegs and all of that yes and homeowner agreements and deeds i mean they'd have to be in the deeds of course too but still that concerns me and other than that i agree with everything else i think we need a third party traffic study and certainly all the road roads and intersections around they're carefully studied we've had so many issues over the years with traffic on pleasant and Hill Road, for instance, and we all share the concerns of the public that have come before us. So I really would like that careful look at that. [2:56:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Owens, so it looks like you can have gravity sewer all the way down to your arrowhead connection. Do you need a force main for the apartment buildings? [2:56:52] Speaker J (unidentified): No, we can achieve gravity. You can. Okay. [2:56:57] Speaker A (unidentified): And you can get the coverage you need over the sewer lines with having raised the road you mentioned? [Speaker J (unidentified): We can, yeah.] A member of the Arrowhead neighborhood wrote a very thoughtful letter yesterday, Nathan Hintz, or Hintze, and he reminded me of many of the questions we asked, we as a board asked on March 10th, and whether some of them had been addressed or talked about. I don't know if you've seen the letter yet, but I think it's well worth you looking at and studying the reasons that Mr. Hensie believes what the record shows and why it matters and how you might make this project better. I think the Rob's comment on having fewer single-family houses, I really, I like having the opportunity to have affordable housing, but I see the massing of these buildings as huge and not really compatible with the neighborhood protection standards. And when I mentioned the possibility of a third-party traffic study, I think in the traffic engineer manual, some of the studies cited for single-family developments were the last studies were done over multiple cities, but in the 2010s. And in the multifamily, it was 2020. And nowhere in your traffic counts does it really talk about what the impact to the Arrowhead Drive neighborhood will be. They have zero impact today. All the other Woodside Road, Church Road, McKean Street, Pleasant Hill Road all have traffic on them. And in part of your traffic study, you counted the Pleasant Hill Road development, the latest with 23 houses, as having a negligible impact. And you mentioned several other, Wilbur's Woods is having a negligible impact. But there is a cumulative impact to all of those things, as well as the school on Baraboe and Hancock. There is an overall impact to the traffic movement. And your project is going to contribute almost entirely whatever change in traffic is to the Woodside development. and I can't agree and believe that you can make the assumption that most of the traffic will just go straight up the road. If you're down at the apartments, it would seem to me that there's at least a 50% chance, and you have 404 movements, 202 in and 202 out. I mean it's conceivable that you could have 100 extra cars a day going in and out of Woodside and I would find that unacceptable for those neighbors I mean it would change the whole tenor of the neighborhood and I think there's a question about whether in building construction when you do a renovation or a major change to a building, you trigger having to upgrade codes. I'm not sure that we do that on our roads, but I think Mr. Hensing mentioned and I thought about, are the roads in the Arrowhead Drive neighborhood code compliant to today's heavier vehicles? And I just don't know. I'm I think it's a it's a concern and it's a valid question that I think you and the developer need to answer I Had another question about is the developer building and main in going to maintain ownership of the apartment buildings Or is that going to be is that also not determined at this point not determined, okay? Let's see I don't think I have any but I And I found Mr. Hintze's letter very informative and convincing, so I hope you'll look it over and take it to heart. With that, if there are no other comments, I will open the floor up to public comments. We're going to limit comments to three minutes. If anybody wants to come up and speak, we're glad to have you up. and as Owens has said we probably are going to have another workshop we're going to have a site walk so we've got more opportunities to talk about the project. [3:02:56] Speaker T (unidentified): Hi I'm Brett Jocelyn I live at a 48 Woodside Road so I'm directly across the street from this particular development so just kind of listening tonight there's a few notes that I kind of took there's a lot of concern about mere brook and the pollution this particular ledge that you guys are talking about i believe starts in that on that property and runs into my property i know i have a legend on my property and that's right where my well is so i have a lot of concern about pollution and the runoff and what's going to end up happening with to my drinking water so then the traffic study i just i don't know i can't understand the traffic study personally because in that traffic study it said that people are going 35 miles an hour I live on the road it's not possible they even just coming around from church going towards Pleasant Hill people are speeding in front of my home there's been an increase an increased amount of traffic just with the construction that's happening across from Crystal Springs and the development going on Pleasant Hill so with that being said I have noticed an uptick in traffic so this road could not handle 100 units it just it just can't it's it's it's a dangerous road I'm I see people walking up and down the road all the time and I see them jumping into onto my property because it's a long winding road and people are just flying down the road it's it's it's crazy so just in the last 10 days I was almost t-boned twice leaving my driveway and I was almost rear-ended trying to pull into my driveway the case when I was almost rear-ended it the person went around me and to across the double line now and into the left line and the left lane there and there's a hill there so you couldn't even see that there was a car whether a car was coming or not so it's incredibly dangerous so I did request that a separate traffic study, something I wrote to the board here. So I really appreciate you guys doing that because I would like to see that happen. And then another piece to the traffic, you know, the road was moved over. It was directly in front of my house originally for the first plan, and it was moved over to the right. Right. But if based on this particular traffic study and the theory that most of the homes or most of the cars are going to be going to Woodside Road, that means most of those cars are going to be shining their headlights in my bedroom and also in my in my living room. So I have a huge big living room. I don't know. I'm just going to say, what if it were you, know, having you know all these cars all of a sudden a completely dark location shining their headlights and in your you know home so and then there's a piece to was that it yeah just finish up if you okay yeah there's a piece to light pollution i can't see how packing as many families in on the smallest location you possibly can isn't going to create a ton of light pollution. So that is a major concern of mine. That's it. Thanks. Okay. Thank you. [3:06:30] Speaker U (unidentified): Okay. Good evening. I'm Nathan Hintz, [address]. Our lot backs up to lots 20 and 21. Thank you for your time tonight. I have a few points. Many are about inconsistencies. First, the Arrowhead connection. I'd ask you to consider what section 4.8.1d lets you weigh, whether connecting 64 apartments to the end of Arrowhead would disrupt the character of our neighborhood. On October 14th, the town's deputy planning director said he did not yet know how to reconcile the apartment design with the existing neighborhood condition. The Tractate study submitted assigns no trips to Arrowhead because it says Woodside entrance is a shorter distance. We've measured both routes from the apartment parking lot, and they're about 3,300 square feet, I mean 3,300 feet each. Now, I won't tell them how I got that number. You'd have to actually go and check out the neighborhood in order to figure out how people come and go. Arrowhead will see dangerous increase in traffic. This presents a strong case that increased travel and the proposed design are not compatible with the current neighborhood. And this side note is like the other presentation brought up something for me. The application says the neighborhood protection standard in this section 4.12 doesn't apply because this isn't a mixed-use district. That limit is in 4.1.2, 4.12.2. The general standard is in 4.12.1, says development shall be compatible with existing neighborhood single or two-family dwellings, and it applies everywhere. The applicant never addresses it. I ask the board to have the applicant respond to it directly. Second, the stream behind our house, it's drawn in three different places. The town zoning map now shows that the stream, the jurisdictional stream corridor running through our house. The 2024 survey puts the packed property line with a 75-foot cut setback. The 2025 plan, made after the land was cut, calls it a ditch and drops the setback. In fact, it runs on just our side of the property line and has carried water every season for 18 years we've lived there, including this month in a drought. The consultant's own report says the DEP can confirm it. We've asked the DEP to come look for it. Third, the construction traffic. The planned note says all construction vehicles will use Woodside Road unless otherwise authorized. But in the October 14th meeting, the engineer told staff the road and arrowhead connection will get built first, access to the construction area, and for water and sewer. We'd like to know which it is. A few smaller ones. The water and sewer letters are for the old 93-unit plan. The wetland delineation is dated three different ways, 2024, 2025, and 2026. HOA declaration refers to the town of Falmouth and doesn't mention the no-cut buffers. And the Stonewater Report cites a 2016 email in York County rainfall, and that it will cause flooding on my property. Perhaps they want to hire me as a consultant to find their errors in their application. None of these are huge on its own, but together they mean the record isn't accurate. And you'll be asked to make findings from it. In March, you asked for good questions. Councilor Harris asked for summer farmer's market travel counts. Wasn't done. Councilor Walker said the stream buffers should be common open space because they're left to homeowners. Enforcement is out the window. Wasn't done. Councilor Mattson said the Arrowhead connection concerned her because it takes traffic through an established neighborhood. These were the right questions and the neighbors are grateful you asked them. They are still not answered. These are inconsistencies and omissions that were fined by my untrained eye so I can only imagine what else is incorrect. It makes it challenging to advocate without all the information. Bottom line, we are not opposed to the homes on this land. Single family homes that fit the neighborhood, we'd welcome. Thank you. Thank you. [3:10:03] Speaker V (unidentified): That was a lot. You get all that? Yep. This is a recording. Lucky. My name is Grant Probst. I live at [address]. We moved there in 2020. It was hard enough to move there in a pandemic. During that time, I had a four-month old and a four-year-old. Due to no fault of our own, we had a house fire at that period of time, and we had to move to harris seek it during the pandemic and live at a hotel for seven months well the house is getting rebuilt so you know we've got a little bit of a story the woman that lives next to us she's an older lady her she's widowed you know so everybody in our little community does whatever we can do to help her out right i cut a tree by a power line so it didn't cost her two thousand dollars i'm from central maine it's not a new thing for me to cut a cut a piece of wood for somebody and the year before that I filled in a large hole between the two properties because the houses down on that side of Arrowhead are built up on like piles of loam because the area was all wetland and possibly shouldn't have been permitted in the 90s when it was right so there's a little concern about what kind of water will get forced into our neighborhoods and how the water will build up at the bottom with the size of the development at the bottom I mean I speak at plenty of town councils I'm I'm a labor leader, you know, and I love affordable housing, you know, and I don't think it was an accident. I mean, it's forced here, you know, and people need homes. We want to see people in neighborhoods. But right now, when I get home out of work, when my wife comes home, my daughter is six now. My son is nine. There's no traffic at the bottom of the road, right? We go out. We play in the road. We take the soccer net out. We play and we'll move it when a car comes, which is pretty rare. you know so to think that we're exposing a place that we have anchored in to you know hundreds of cars new cars coming through and not saying that there's gonna be hundreds of cars but you know people who are building aren't gonna want to stack up dump trucks on one road they'll be pickup trucks they'll be building crews they'll be dump trucks they'll be dirt you know it's like a it's a total societal change for my kids you know and I want other people to have family you have a house for their family too i feel strongly about that but within reason you know we've seen four plans tonight three of the plans were great this one needs some work you know we understand it's in the in the growth district but and we like to have access to the trails we're not dealing with a really good community partner i see no playgrounds i see no community space what i do see is a no trespassing sound sign at the end of the arrowhead drive so we can't access the trails that we used to be able to i do see an area where a whole bunch of trees were cut and there was no notice to the community about what was going on so now me and my kids we leave our house we don't go to the end of the road we go around down the power line when that was available because they were rebuilding that this year in the winter time when we walk by the retention pond that exists now it's not always frozen it could be cold as get out right It'll be open because of the road pollution that comes through the storm drains. The town of Brunswick repaired one of the storm drains that's in my neighbor's yard. So I've fixed a hole that was due to wash out in between my house and the neighbor and my other neighbor's storm drain washed out and the retention pond doesn't freeze. So if you want to do a study about pollution and what a large development would do in the neighborhood, then you should check out the retention pond after a major storm this winter if we actually get some rain. so super tough spot for me i want families in homes i want i love this town but if there was a lower interest rate when this thing all came above i realized you got a mandate and what you got to do in a growth area and if there was 2.65 interest rate out there we would be gone we wouldn't mess around to see how this is going to go because how it has started i don't think it's going to change throughout the process we've got a we've got a non community person and a whole bunch of people here from the community saying that they don't want it the way it is but they're saying we don't not want building we just don't like what's happening now thank you thank you my [3:14:35] Speaker W (unidentified): name is Jeff Austin I'm a director butter if you see where I'm flashing the light right here that's my where I'm flashing the light is my house look at where the egresses are to the parking lots with 120 cars not to mention ubers ubereats FedEx UPS look at the egress from those two parking lots and where those headlights are gonna go 120 literally my bedroom there's no opportunity for buffer that's where they're putting storm water detention, 120 cars in and out of my bedroom. It is pitch black there right now, come to my house, it is pitch black. I don't own the property, he's entitled to develop it. I can live with a single family home in my backyard. I cannot live, I'm not talking property value. It is unlivable to have 120 cars with an egress aimed at your bedroom. you wouldn't do it. You wouldn't do it to yourselves. I'm not qualified to render an opinion on their attorney's letter that the easement that may have been granted by the subdivision that I live in somehow connects this property to the existing subdivision. I'm not qualified to give you an opinion. I don't think that obviates the obligation of you to look at whether it should be connected under your discretion. You have discretion whether to connect a road. Whether an easement was granted by a private party does not seem to me to take away from your ability to review whether you should use your discretion to connect the end of Arrowhead Road to this development. I think you should not until he presents to you a compatible development. Find for me anywhere in the town of Brunswick where you have a subdivision of single-family homes and a 120-car paved parking lot in the middle of it. Find me one. I don't think it's ever been done because no planning board would have ever approved it. Don't approve it now. This is unreasonable. The lower part of this development is completely unreasonable. reasonable. Please, you'll make my house unlivable if you aim to egresses, not to mention what we learned tonight. Dump trucks full of snow. They can't plow it. They're going to have to haul it out of there in trucks. Unlivable with that in and out all night long. Do you remember the snow No storms from last year. I won't get any rest. I don't mind single-family homes. As I said the last time we met, if you're going to connect the spine of Arrowhead to this development, connect the body. Make it consistent. Otherwise, this is a Frankenstein. One last comment. I didn't, as a direct abutter, I didn't get a notice of this meeting. I heard about it through the neighborhood. could we get sort of individual notices for the site walk? That would be appreciated, if possible, for a butters. [3:17:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm seeing nod from the... [3:18:01] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, I would just note that normally how it works is that we send out a butter notices when we receive an application and when there's a public hearing being scheduled. Because a site walk would be separate from a regularly scheduled meeting such as this, [3:18:19] Speaker W (unidentified): We can make it a point to send out. I'd appreciate that indulgence because I appreciate that you've had a very long Don't get me started on stormwater. I Have pictures of my child in pools up to here with stormwater because we are already the bottom of one subdivision I'm already collecting the stormwater at the bottom of one subdivision now. You're gonna put a second one It's unreasonable please don't make my home unlivable thank you [3:18:59] Speaker X (unidentified): okay hi everybody I just want to start by saying thank you so much to the board for all your time and hard work and to the staff because this is this is hard and we are like really getting to know each other over the course of this like we've all been here quite a bit. I took some notes during this part of the conversation. I'm Erin Baltus. I live at [address]. About parking, two spots per two bedroom, one spot per one bedroom. I understand that meets the requirement and the additional 15 spaces added. So that's about 14, 15% addition. But the high cost of housing in general suggests that couples will be in those one bedroom units. That's why I live with my husband and the likelihood don't tell me I told you that and the likelihood of these spaces getting gobbled up Are high plus people will just naturally Park where there is space So look at the size of today's vehicles people are just gonna not squeeze into spots It's gonna be spillover under the bottom of Arrowhead There's no reduction in overall impact on Woodside Road traffic last time we were talking about this development We were talking about 93 units. It's back up to 100. And I don't think there was mention of the impact on the Woodside Church Road intersection. So I really appreciate the board chair recommending that outside traffic study. So thank you. And I hope that can look at pedestrian and bike activity in all these areas as well. Because my family, and I know a lot of the families here, are out on those roads all the time. And that's how it should be in our part of town. I recognize there's a 40-year-old deed stipulation getting access however that doesn't likely address or encapsulate the nature of what has changed between the mid to late 80s and where when that agreement and the Arrowhead neighborhood was built and the deed restriction created in this level of housing density and impact in the general neighborhood additionally if this is all based on the premise of HOA management there are a lot of operating assumptions here about out a future HOA's ability to manage this very dense fairly complex property collectively which could have a significant future impact on the adjacent neighborhoods. So I appreciate the comment noting that there's no plan for who builds and sells the final houses like that right there is a huge it's a huge issue. Additionally I don't know that we've talked too much about the transient nature of apartment residents. They're not owners. They don't have the similar stake in the neighborhood as the other residents so this increases this element of connectivity to Arrowhead and I agree with you know Nate's assessment earlier the proposal includes essentially a speed table in that raised sidewalk addition that doesn't exist in the Arrowhead neighborhood and let's just say you know yes that initial drive of Avalon Woods is a short distance to Woodside but it's getting slowed down and like we all vary our driving routine team from time to time, right? So the margins of difference in these road lengths are so low. You get a bus stop, a snow bank, anything. People are going to find another way, and that's going to be through our neighborhood. Following up on the board member's comment earlier, it was so refreshing to hear this. Just because you can squeeze in 100 units, should you? No. Let's be clear. I'll finish very quickly. This development gives up the quality of the transitional rural the rural nature of this part of town it gives it up it sends the signal that's over this is the largest proposed development since the base redevelopment it's proposed for a part of town with no adequate public transit or pedestrian access to services and I just ask this planning board you've been very thoughtful in this please just at some point here we have to say no like this proposal does not meet the standards thanks thank you hi my name is Olivia Chrisette I live at [address] and also co-own 37 Woodside which are those lots that abut up near the top and yeah thank you so much I will try to be really quick I did send in like a pretty extensive letter so I'm not gonna go into that but I think just a couple things on lot number six I'm just really glad you're doing the site visit because we own that acre that abuts on there and there is like a running stream I have to put like little boards across it to like get across that so I think it is extremely wet in that area and I think that you'll see that very much I'm very concerned about the stormwater management in this proposed development the other thing I just want to mention is I just I agree so much with my neighbors that we want to see more housing and the single-family houses are consistent with that design but I just still can't understand how this is a legal proposal like it just doesn't seem legal to be able to put the apartments in this area because of section 4.1 2 1 with the zoning ordinance that Nate mentioned so I haven't really heard more questions about that because I just don't understand how this is actually a legal proposal but thank you all for listening and for doing your due diligence and your work [3:24:29] Speaker N (unidentified): i appreciate it thank you good [3:24:37] Speaker Y (unidentified): evening my name is gino ring i live at farty willow grove but prior to living at willow grove i spent 25 years living at six arrowhead drive and one of the reasons it wasn't the only reason but one of the reasons my wife and i decided to move was this development slammed up against us there was no warning bulldozers came in and bulldozed this whole stretch of land. Since then, we've been to numerous meetings because I don't not only believe this is good for where it's located, I don't think it's good for the town of Brunswick because if this developer bullies his way through, then why won't others come along and try and do the same thing? I agree with all of what I heard here tonight from my fellow neighbors. I'm not opposed to single-family dwellings. The apartment's got to go. They're just not compatible with Arrowhead and all that whole subdivision. And I agree with my friend and neighbor, Jeff. It isn't just about property value. It's about the quality of the lives that we've chosen to build here in Brunswick. And these aren't our neighbors. They're not here. They're not going to come here. They don't answer the questions that have been asked of them. Very nice presentation, very smooth, very pleasant. I thought the mention of the legal document was a veiled threat. It's not like, oh, you have any choice in this. We have legal rights here. Please. So I've always felt from the very beginning that this was a rather hostile group of people coming in to want to build here. That's just my opinion. But, again, if you want to build single-family units that are compatible with our neighborhood, board but the departments are just i just don't get why it's even considered so anyways thanks for and i appreciate all the work you guys do appreciate you listening to us thank you [3:26:35] Speaker R (unidentified): yes and i appreciate all the work you do too my name is steve weems i'm a resident of the part of brunswick where this project is located and i'll be very brief this evening i have submitted I do want to say just straight out that I share and feel the angst of the people you've heard from tonight from the near neighborhood. I want to focus just briefly on the apartments part of this project. And my basic question is, where are the apartments in the neighborhood of this subdivision? In the neighborhood, where are they? The number and density of proposed apartments are particularly egregiously out of character and clearly incompatible with the owner-occupied homes in this neighborhood. This should, on its face, disqualify this part of the project. Thanks for an opportunity to address you this evening. Thank you, Steve. [3:27:46] Speaker M (unidentified): Hi, my name is Laura Hartz. I'm a resident of 40 Arrowhead Drive. I know it's late, and my neighbors have presented concerns that you're considering. I just wanted to raise for the board, I have a question about the right title and interest that the developer has with respect to the access easements. the 1986 deed that was provided by the attorney for the developer says that the access rights are reserved for the benefit of the grantor's remaining property and i'm just curious you know between 1941 when the grantor received the property in 1986 how much was deeded out and you know second question developer here has cobbled together two lots how can it be that two lots from separate title chains can be benefited by access easements that supposedly only related to one lot previously. So this is more of an open-ended question. I really like the suggestion of an independent review of the traffic study, and I wonder if we could also see an independent review of the right title and interest, maybe the [3:29:02] Speaker A (unidentified): town's attorney. We'll ask our town attorney. [3:29:04] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, that would be great. [3:29:18] Speaker Z (unidentified): Hello. My name is Ashley. I live at [address], directly across the street from this development. I just want to come up here and put another face so that you guys see, you know, this is affecting a lot of us. And when you go for your walk, when you're looking directly into the woods where you're going to be going, I ask every one of you to please turn around and look behind you because that's my house. you will be able to see my side door that I go in and out of every single day you'll be able to see into my bay window right into my living room you'll see my tv my bird and my bedroom is the last window all the way to the right of that my home you know it's just ridiculous this whole thing I don't understand the whole apartment thing I mean we all understand why but it's just I don't know how we have yet to see a plan that suggests any other possible development of this of single-family homes You know, I why aren't we seeing that it's ridiculous he's assuming that he's going to be able to move forward with this and from what everyone has said and shown it Just doesn't fit. It doesn't seem like it's legal. It's not within the ordinance you know the other big thing is definitely the traffic remember they said most of the traffic is going to be entering from Woodside so that is directly in front of my driveway I mean it's a few feet off it's from here to here that's it my driveway is right there it's dangerous getting out of it as it is there's been a increase of traffic because there is more development I also live on Barabo. I work on Barabo. I travel Pleasant Hill multiple times a day. I have to see the poor farmer trying to go with his tractor down the road, and everyone's speeding around him because he's just trying to go to his field, and there's so much more traffic. People are not driving 35 miles an hour. You know, I'm just echoing what everybody else said. Like I said, I just want to put another face out there that, you know, this is really impacting people's lives that already exist there for someone that has no investment in this community outside of making money thank you scott [3:31:48] Speaker AA (unidentified): robertson my family and i live at [address] i have three kids two with special needs they play in the streets play in the neighborhood walk to the bus stop you know bike to their friends houses and I appreciate a lot the ask for a outside traffic study the idea that I agree that I'd face value some of the traffic it does look like it's the natural inclination of people to want to go down the straighter route however I do question whether that took into account the speed tables as well as the blinking crosswalks. Depending on the time of day, if a lot of kids are traveling, trying to get to bus stops, that may tie up traffic quite a bit. It may be, or for whatever reason, you know, just natural inclination, a lot of traffic may come down the airhead side of things. And just, you know, I don't have a problem. the owner can develop the property that's right we need more houses people need places to live don't have a problem with that but just to echo some of the earlier comments the giant apartment buildings just do not line up with the rest of the neighborhood and so i just asked that you would take that into account so thank you thank you anybody [3:33:23] Speaker A (unidentified): else in the audience here like to make a comment ask a question seeing now we have one hand raised could you identify yourself and megan [3:33:38] Speaker AB (unidentified): roberts yes hi it's megan roberts i live at [address] which is right in front of lots of 15 and 16. and i have two categories of comments that i was hoping to share. I realize it's late. The first category is around water management, storage, stormwater, drainage, all the concerns my neighbors have shared. I wanted to add a few things. First, I have some concerns about the tree survey, and I'm hoping that on your site visit, you'll be able to bring some independent scrutiny to that tree survey. Owens McCullough has at various meetings here and other meetings around this mentioned yard interests as part of the reason for selective cutting. And in an email to me on July 28th, and among other reasons for cutting down trees within the 75-foot setback, he mentioned to provide, quote, improved rear yard area, which I don't believe is permitted under the shoreland zoning requirements. so I would really like extra attention to be played paid to the point system that they are using, and to make sure that it is being strictly followed. I also really appreciate the concerns that the board was sharing tonight around enforcement around that stream setback. And I have a question about why lot 14 is being used for drainage management instead of using the entirety of the stream setback. So instead of designating one lot to drainage management, I would like to request that instead the stream setback be used to remove the possibility of noncompliance. I know how hard it is to get anything to grow in that area because, as you can see from the map, like I said, I live right in front of lots 15 and 16. Whoever had my house before me cleared all the way back to the stream. It is very, difficult to get anything to grow in a shady, very damp area. I have tried to plant more trees and shrubs to increase privacy, since we've known for years now that there will be a development back there. So the prospect of somebody potentially not following those rules is distressing. The second category, like many of my neighbors, is around traffic. I find it laughable to assume that people won't use Arrowhead Drive, and I appreciate the skepticism the board brought to that claim tonight. night. I would like to reiterate that any increased traffic would destroy the character of our neighborhood, which, as many of my neighbors have testified, is quiet and calm and safe for children to play. I would like to implore that the board please waive the connectivity requirements, and if not, that they push the developer to incorporate meaningful and impossible-to-ignore improvements. These would include raised tables along the length of Arrowhead to make sure that if and when there is increased traffic, that at least those people cannot drive above 25 miles per hour. To add speed limit signs to Arrowhead Drive, there are not currently any, and to set that limit at 25 miles per hour. And on Woodside, I think part of the reason why there's this discrepancy between what the traffic study finds around the speed and what we, the people who live in the area, report feeling like Woodside is like is because Woodside is very narrow. I bike to work year-round, and so I spend a lot of time cycling on various Brunswick roads. Woodside is the closest feeling to Union Street, I would say. So if you're more familiar with that part of town, imagine that Union Street had blind curves and the speed limit was 35 miles per hour instead of 25 miles per hour. Somebody going 40, which is not unexpected, feels really dangerous if you are a pedestrian or a cyclist. Safety improvements would include lowering the limit to 25 miles per hour, painting white lines on the side of the road to make clear where the edge is, and also placing signs on the road reminding drivers that there is a state law I'm requiring a 3 foot clearance with all cyclists and pedestrians and then finally there's been so much talk about how enthusiastic the developer is about connectivity and that 's the justification for having this road that so many neighbors are opposed to but I would just note how little they seem to care about connectivity when we're talking about cyclists and pedestrians there are no connections between the two neighborhoods other than the road our trail access is very limited while theirs is plentiful. So they have all of these advantages where they can access the trails at many points. We have testified how much we really appreciate the trail network. There's been no dialogue, zero interest in increasing that kind of connectivity. So again, I would just stress there's no benefit to this connection for us. There are only downsides. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you. [3:38:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Somebody else has his or her hand raised? No longer. Anybody else online? I'm seeing no hands raised. All right. I will close. Anybody else in the audience? One last look. I'm seeing nobody. I'll close the public comment. Come back to the board for final quick comments or questions. Anybody? I think you've heard a lot of very good and constructive comments tonight, and the reason I would like a third-party traffic impact study is because yours was dated June 10, 2026, And its 147 pages appear comprehensive in its volume of material, yet it lacks much of the data that's particularly relevant to the Avalon Woods impact on Arrowhead Drive subdivision. And I think that's critical, and you discuss contributing roads, traffic counts, speeds with respect to the DOT 85 percentile sampling method, And I find we've had anecdotal evidence, and all of us have also contributed anecdotal evidence in the past, that the 85 percentile doesn't really give us a clear indication of actually how fast people drive in real time. We all see it, the bicyclists, the walkers, we all see it. And it's hard to convince the state that 's how they should control speed limit signs, but that's how they do it. And they will tell us when we ask, and I've asked the town engineer and the people in the planning department and public works and the police department over a period of years, you know, can we lower speed limits? Well, they'll do a traffic study, and then they might raise the speed limits because traffic is moving faster than the posted speed limit. That's nonsensical to me, that the DOT works that way, but that's the way they work. The other thing about your traffic study is the peak times of traffic from 7 a.m. to 8 a.m. and 4 to 5 in the afternoon. 7 a.m. to 8 a.m. doesn't pick up all the morning commuting traffic and the school traffic going to our schools. I mean, you have to have a much wider window there. And in the afternoon, it needs to start when school gets out at 2.30 and when people start leaving work. And now the shift work at BIW is no longer a 7 to 3.30 day or a 7 to 4, 6.30 to 4.30, whatever times they work on cascading shifts very often. And so I think we need a broader study group, and that's why I'm asking the board to vote to opt for a third-party traffic impact study. That's all I'll say for right now. Thank you all for your comments. And I'd like – do we need a show of hands or a yes vote? I'd like to propose that we ask for a third-party traffic impact study and all those in favor. That's unanimous of the board. Thank you all for coming. Thank you for your interest. There will be notice when we have a site walk, and we'll try to keep you informed of future meetings. and when we have another workshop and thank you all for coming out right let's see any [3:43:13] Speaker F (unidentified): i lost my agenda go ahead sure go ahead i just want to take a quick moment to thank the planning staff for these beautiful comprehensive plan books and to congratulate the staff on their award who granted they gave you the award gave us the award you with the award it's an [3:43:36] Speaker M (unidentified): award from knee Kappa which is the northern New England conference of [3:43:43] Speaker P (unidentified): American Planning Association or the New England that's pretty impressive so it's not just main Vermont and New Hampshire anyway thank you this is gorgeous thank you and useful much and thank you [3:43:55] Speaker M (unidentified): Congratulations to everyone who participated. [3:43:58] Speaker A (unidentified): And thank you to the two members on our board who were on the Comprehensive Plan Committee and the rest of the Comprehensive Plan Committee. We have on our second meeting in November is on schedule for November 24th. We're wondering who's available. Laura is not available. It's a tough week. Rob is available. I should be okay and I should be too we may not have a meeting anyway but we wanted to know so they'll be four of us here possibly Chris great and Matt did send Kelly has resigned Kelly has officially resigned oh I didn't know you weren't here oh I missed that one last week oh dear yeah so we're down a member [3:44:51] Speaker M (unidentified): Matt did send out an email today with dates for a site walk for the Avalon Woods project so just check your email [3:44:58] Speaker A (unidentified): you did oh good [3:45:00] Speaker B (unidentified): still need to hear from Bill Steve and Chris I've proposed four dates and you know I was hoping for business hours with daylight [3:45:15] Speaker M (unidentified): savings we are thinking we probably want to try to get [3:45:17] Speaker F (unidentified): out there a little already what daily savings ending though next sunday next sunday [3:45:22] Speaker B (unidentified): morning yeah we'll be yeah standard time right yeah so i put out november 4th november 5th november 9th and 12th as some early options those would be kind of the [3:45:40] Speaker A (unidentified): ESAP options. The 12th is the only one that I [3:45:44] Speaker B (unidentified): can't make. The 12th is looking not great. Rob and Allison cannot meet at the same time and Laura is not available. The 9th nobody can meet at the same time. The 5th right now seems like Rob and Allison are available but Laura is not. [3:46:11] Speaker A (unidentified): What's your date? The 4th. The 4th on the... [3:46:14] Speaker H (unidentified): The most open. That's like my very open day. [3:46:17] Speaker A (unidentified): How can anybody else meet on the 4th? Yeah. Yeah. I can do the 4th. [3:46:26] Speaker F (unidentified): I can do the 4th too. I ask not to because I'm working the polls all day into the night. Right. But I will drag myself over there. [3:46:37] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Let's do it on the 4th if we can. [3:46:43] Speaker F (unidentified): I probably will need a nature walk after a day at the gym. [3:46:47] Speaker H (unidentified): And the 5th, I could be available. I just don't know yet because we're still waiting to hear back about whether or not something's happening on that day. Once I hear back, I might be available then. [3:47:00] Speaker A (unidentified): When you hear, that would make Allison's life easier. The rest of us can make the 4th. Okay, so Laura will contact you, and you'll sort out the... [3:47:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, if we're going to send public notices out, I'll want to know for that week, like by tomorrow, essentially. [3:47:18] Speaker A (unidentified): When will you know? [3:47:21] Speaker H (unidentified): We're interviewing applicants for... [3:47:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Why don't we just do the 4th? [3:47:25] Speaker H (unidentified): We're just waiting to hear back from this one as to what date and time. [3:47:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Let's just do the 4th. If you can make it on the 4th, let's do that. and what time you decide is whatever is fine. [3:47:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, if everybody's available all day, I think something, you know, 10 o'clock or... [3:47:44] Speaker F (unidentified): 7 o'clock in the morning, I'll still be up. [3:47:48] Speaker H (unidentified): All right. You might be up, I'm not. We're already past my bedtime. [3:47:54] Speaker A (unidentified): We are, for sure. All right, thank you very much, everybody. We're adjourned.