Brunswick Sustainability Committee Discusses Waste, Data Centers, and Energy Projects
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Good afternoon. My name is Tom Rump. I'm chair of the Sustainability Committee, and this is our October meeting. I am a member of the Stationary Energy Working Group, and we usually start with introductions, starting with Chrissy.
[0:26] Speaker B (unidentified): Chrissy Edemunds, Economic and Community Development Project Manager and Staff Liaison of the Sustainability Committee.
[0:34] Speaker C (unidentified): William Whites on the Transportation Subgroup.
[0:40] Speaker D (unidentified): Mark Battle, also on the Transportation Subgroup.
[0:48] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm Joe DeRivera from the Solid Waste Subcommittee.
[0:53] Speaker F (unidentified): Karen Topp, I'm on the Transportation Working Group.
[0:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Tucker Favreau, I'm also on the Solid Waste Working Group.
[0:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, great. Thank you. Now we'll start with my agenda, which I forgot to print, so I have it on my phone. Let's have some administrative items review and confirm the agenda. Does anyone have any amendments or suggested edits? Joe, you had something you wanted to add?
[1:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Just if I could have a couple of minutes to talk about the delays in our External Producer Responsibility Act.
[1:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, great. Any other changes? Okay. Okay, I wanted to report that Bob and I did table at the Senior Health Expo at the Rec Center a few weeks ago and it was a, we got in at the last minute because somebody canceled, one of the presenters canceled so we were able to get a table. And we had a pretty good, it was a good crowd and we talked with many people and handed out materials. materials, and I would say that overall it seemed to be successful. We did reach some people. Worthwhile next year? I think so. One thing I'd like you to think about, if in the past, Steve Wood was sort of our lead on the tabling stuff, and stored the materials, and came to maintain contact with the People Plus, which does the Health Expo, and the Downtown Association, which does the barbecue, which are the two major events that we've done in the past. And I was hoping someone would agree to step up and take that responsibility, so unless someone's ready to step up right now, I'll ask that you think about it, and maybe we can make a decision next meeting. The final thing in terms of administrative items, I did get clarification from Chrissy. I had asked her a question about the scale at the Graham Road facility, which was there when the landfill was open and apparently is no longer there. Chrissy, can you clarify for us what happened to the scale?
[3:23] Speaker B (unidentified): It was removed and not replaced. [Speaker A (unidentified): Was it sold?] I don't know. Okay.
[3:30] Speaker A (unidentified): I just ask because if you had a chance to take a look at the proposed solid waste strategy from five years or six years ago, one of the things it asked for was to retain the scale when the landfill was closed as a potential use for a transfer station, if that made sense. I left a message for Jay earlier today because I wasn't able to talk to him and asked him if he could help me understand why it was not retained, and I did not hear back from him.
[4:06] Speaker B (unidentified): That was a cost issue. The town didn't want to spend the money to replace it or retain it.
[4:16] Speaker G (unidentified): So, okay.
[4:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Was that area demolished or something? or was there I don't know what the cost of retaining it would have been okay we had talked last time about recycling audits and Chrissy was going to talk to Jay and the folks from Casella and Tyler was going to talk to eco main I have not heard back from Tyler I don't know Chrissy if you had
[4:51] Speaker B (unidentified): any success if you want to provide I know you're on the same subcommittee so if you want to provide the update, you can interrupt, but I'll just say that I did meet with Tyler and, yes, Tyler, Tucker, about it, because Casella can do one whenever we want, but I think that the solid-based subcommittee just needs to identify their goals first. When I was working in a past life at NRCM, I was doing, helping communities do a lot of these and the context is almost always in schools as an educational tool for students because they have this contained waste stream in their school environment that it's almost like a microcosm and it's really easy to sort of like educate and then sort of see those results and so that's really where those waste audits were most impactful. I know that in the papers a while ago, pre-COVID, I think that, you know, there was this bigger effort, I believe in South Portland by EcoMain to do community, like neighborhood scale waste audits and educate in that way. But, and that was a, that was part of this bigger initiative with a, with sort of a goal and a strategic plan behind it. So I think my conversation with Tyler was about thinking about that and identifying what the goal of it would be and the other the other thing about that is there is the main DEP does have an annual solid waste report and it does show a breakdown of residential waste and Brunswick's not going to be that much different from it you know we're all buying the same stuff we're all shopping in the same store so like on a large scale it's not so dissimilar so you can't also look at those numbers and have a pretty good sense of what Brunswick's would be as well. So there's just that to think about as well.
[6:51] Speaker A (unidentified): So my recollection was one of the reasons that we were thinking of doing this is because of the complaints we'd gotten from a resident about people putting inappropriate materials into recycling bins. And that, as I understand it, I may be wrong, but I think in the contract with Casella that they do offer to do periodic monitoring, of recycling bins to determine if people are recycling the appropriate materials or not. And I'm wondering if people feel that's worth doing or not. Did you guys, Tucker, did you
[7:29] Speaker C (unidentified): and the working group talk about that? I think we talked a little bit. I mean, one of the big holdups we had was the whole ECO main thing, since we're part of the swap program, making sure we're actually looking at our stuff, not things that are being swapped back and forth. so yeah the last i had seen i had gotten the update from tyler that him and chrissy had a meeting to talk through these things and that he wanted to re-meet to kind of convene and see based upon that discussion if there's still something our subcommittee wanted to recommend in detail but yeah if it would have to at this point we do think it would have to be through casella right just to make sure we know numbers that we're getting now we'll also have to look into the dep thing though and see the statewide that would be interesting for us to look at as well, obviously.
[8:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, we'll give you general ideas of what people are recycling, I guess, by material type or something. But I think it would be worth thinking about doing something, maybe starting with the schools, if working with Casella to do that, because Casella picks up at the schools as well, right? Yeah.
[8:34] Speaker E (unidentified): Christy, I was wondering, did Tyler have a chance to talk with you? One of the things we talked about was educating apartment buildings and yes we are having success with Thornton Oaks Tyler and I did
[8:48] Speaker B (unidentified): not talk about that at our meeting but I'd say that education is something that the community
[8:54] Speaker A (unidentified): needs and that is a very good thing that this committee could do Tyler had tried repeatedly to contact the folks at Atlantic Point which are the major apartment places out there at the base and was not successful.
[9:11] Speaker E (unidentified): Has he done that in the last month, you know? No.
[9:14] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, I know we're dipping a little bit into the working group stuff, but the last thing you sent me today around lunchtime was a note saying that they talked with Zoe again about Thornton Oaks, and that things do seem to be actually progressing in a positive direction now, but that was the last I had...
[9:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I had gotten a note from Zoe indicating that she'd talked with Tim May and that they had scheduled a time to begin okay so that is happening which is great okay ramona can you unmute yourself i'm here yeah i was wondering if you have any sense of where the council's at in terms of the solid waste management plan discussion that we had a couple times ago about whether to think about updating that i don't think that there's
[10:13] Speaker H (unidentified): there hasn't been any official discussion like within a council meeting about it i know that i briefly spoke to a couple of other counselors but at this point i don't think there's any
[10:28] Speaker A (unidentified): official update from the council okay because at one point there was a proposal from the finance committee or something that we revisited, but I guess that didn't go anywhere?
[10:42] Speaker H (unidentified): They definitely never sent anything to the full council. I don't know whether they just talked about it in a meeting or took some sort of action in the finance committee, but yeah, nothing ever came to the full council.
[10:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. I can check back with the Finance Committee to see if they plan to do anything. Okay. Tucker, is there any updates on the AI Data Center stuff?
[11:14] Speaker C (unidentified): I haven't heard anything on that recently. I do think it's a good question to ask because I think the moratorium ends in December or is it January that the
[11:22] Speaker B (unidentified): moratorium ends? I don't know that, but I did ask Julie Erdman for an update. Oh, yeah, that'd be great. Okay. So she said that they are looking for a consultant for a grid capacity analysis. They haven't had a lot of consultants come to them for that. They did have one, but they wanted to sign a nondisclosure agreement, but the town didn't want to do that. So they're still looking for that consultant.
[11:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. So it sounds like maybe there's going to be an extension to the moratorium at this rate, I would think. I don't know, Ramona, I don't know if anybody's discussed that in the town council about are we running up against timelines for having that prepared before the
[12:06] Speaker A (unidentified): moratorium ends or not so chrissy are you saying that the planning boards planning commit teams work is not progressing because they're looking for a consultant or something is that what i'm
[12:18] Speaker B (unidentified): sorry i would say that the search for the consultant is progress and that it is progressing
[12:24] Speaker A (unidentified): and that is their but they haven't begun drafting anything at this point that i don't know Okay. So, Ramona, do you have an update from the council end?
[12:36] Speaker H (unidentified): So nothing has been further discussed on the council about that. And I'm trying to remember exactly what the meeting date was when we passed it. I think it was late July or early August, which would mean that the expiration date would be coming up in the next few months. So I would, if there has been nothing really drafted at this point, I would be kind of surprised if, you know, anything was complete at that point, considering how long some ordinances do take. So it would not surprise me if there was a further extension, but I have not heard anything about a further extension either at this point.
[13:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, that would probably have to be passed in the next couple of months, right? If it ends in December or something. Okay. Joe, you had something you wanted to talk about?
[13:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I was concerned, I've been concerned about the delay in implementing our external producer responsibility law. The state? Yes. And because this would really help us a lot. It would not only reduce the amount of material coming in, but it would also give us money for our recycling program if we could get it going. And this is in the hands of the Department of Environmental Protection. And they did a nice job creating a sort of – the next thing that needs to happen is they need to hire somebody to oversee the program, a so-called stewardship organization. Well, so they drafted sort of a job description for this organization, and things looked good until the information technology office got involved. And they decided that, well, there's sensitive data here, like sales, amount of sales from different companies, fees, schedules, et cetera. So there's got to be some kind of provision to have the right information released. least. So they changed the description of what was required. So when bids got opened back in June, the way they were supposed to do, nobody bid on account of nobody knew exactly how to have the information technology and the skills to meet the new set of requirements. All right. So we're now back another year. And now the Department of Environmental Protection is supposedly conducting interviews with everybody because now they've got to talk to the Office of Information Technology and the different companies, you know, to try and redo this so that they'll have a workable proposal that can be bidded on. And it's pretty clear that this is time-consuming, and it's pretty clear also that there's a certain amount of foot-dragging going on. And so I talked with Vanessa Berry about this. You know, Vanessa Barry's on the National Resource Council, our sustainability person on the National Resource Council, on the Natural Resource Council of Maine. And she said what would really help is if we sent a letter. And she suggested it could be addressed to the Department of Environmental Concerns, and she gave the commissioners names. But it should be signed, she thought, by either the town manager or the public works director or a joint letter with the select board, saying that the town of Brunswick was very interested in this program and could they move it forward and also indicate that we want to participate in it because I guess we haven't formally said that we want to participate in it we have and we have been the town of Brunswick
[16:51] Speaker B (unidentified): has been advocating for that law since its very inception so we could absolutely do a letter like that. Oh good. I do. I actually worked on passing that law. I was at an RCM in Vanessa's role passing that law. So I'm very proud of that law and I hope it works out for the state. So yeah, we could absolutely get, do you, would you be willing to draft a letter with Vanessa's guidance? That would be very helpful. And you can email it to me and we'll
[17:20] Speaker F (unidentified): get it signed. Oh good. Yeah. Thanks. Can you tell me the name of what, 's the name of this law or program?
[17:26] Speaker E (unidentified): Vanessa Berry is the Director for Sustainability in the Natural...
[17:34] Speaker F (unidentified): NRCM. The whole, what are we talking about here? The program is the...
[17:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Extended Producer Responsibility.
[17:39] Speaker E (unidentified): Say that again? No, External Producer Responsibility.
[17:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Extended Producer Responsibility.
[17:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Extended Producer Responsibility.
[17:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, my gosh. Extended Producer Responsibility.
[17:52] Speaker E (unidentified): It is complicated. And even I've left out a lot of detail. Okay, great. Thank you, Joe. Oh, I had one other request. I don't know how to work this. But, Christy, again, I tried to sign up for our hazardous waste disposal. And I actually managed at 11 o'clock in the morning to get one of the few last spots on the first day of requests. It's obvious that a lot of people, we need more time for people to sign up or more hours for hazardous waste disposal. Is there anything we can do about that?
[18:35] Speaker B (unidentified): I can e-mail the public works director and ask him. Oh, good. I'll eagerly await his reply. So your request is more time to sign up for hazardous waste disposal?
[18:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Or more slots. I suspect it might be a budget issue.
[18:49] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't know in terms of the cost. The number of slots was probably carefully decided upon.
[18:54] Speaker A (unidentified): There's always been a short window.
[18:57] Speaker E (unidentified): How do we get more budget? Because it's important, because people can't dispose it there. They'll dump it in the woods, you know?
[19:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, no, I could tell him your comment and see what happens to it.
[19:09] Speaker E (unidentified): I look forward to how much money is needed.
[19:14] Speaker A (unidentified): I suspect it's not cheap getting rid of hazardous waste, having done some in the past in my work.
[19:22] Speaker H (unidentified): if i could just chime in briefly on the data center question again at the moratorium i double checked and it was passed on june 1st and it looks like 180 days with the length of the moratorium from june 1st would be november 28th so we have almost exactly one month until the moratorium would expire if not renewed so i kind of i would expect to see something before the council before then but i haven't heard of anything yet are you willing to check with
[19:50] Speaker A (unidentified): the council chair and let us know? Okay, great. Thank you. All right. At that point, we have our working group reports. And Bob is not here from the stationary energy group. I can report that we as I think I mentioned the last meeting, we were successful, we appear to be successful in getting Thornton Oaks interested in the multifamily recycling program. program. Zoe was able to come in person to make the presentation, which was helpful, I think. And so I think they're going to be starting that. I think it's like an eight or 12-week program, and they're going to be starting in the next month or so. So hopefully we'll hear more about that. The other thing that Bob was, what we were working on was this energy, sort of like an energy cafe thing, sort of like what the thing that Abby did with his sustainability cafe when she was with us. And there has been a series of webinars sponsored by the Midcoast Regional Planning Group about that. that, and most of them have had presentations from different towns that have done it, and every one of the ones that has talked has had a staff person from the town as the lead on the program, which I think would be helpful. I think it's tough to do as a voluntary group, but we will continue to sort of monitor that and see whether we can bring something forward to the committee. So that's what I have from the solid waste scoop other than what I reported on earlier with the tabling work at the Senior Health Expo.
[21:52] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm sorry, the webinars from the Midcoast who? Our regional planning. Regional planning about recycling and sustainability?
[22:01] Speaker A (unidentified): They're about setting up voluntary groups to help meet with people to talk about energy efficiency and how they can improve the weatherization of their homes and other issues like heat pumps.
[22:16] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. Thank you. Okay, Mark. Sure. It took us a while, but we met as a working group. and there is the ongoing saga of the bus stop, bus shelter.
[22:39] Speaker A (unidentified): That still happens, still going?
[22:40] Speaker D (unidentified): But it's still alive, and Karen had some data from the links talking about that or revealing that site was the likely site, which is at the corner on Federal Street and Center Street, is one of the, it's the third or fourth most heavily used stop in town. Really? So it's a promising location in that regard. That's right, isn't it, Karen?
[23:14] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't have the data in front of me. I'm not sure if it was third or fourth, but fourth, fifth, something like that. Somewhere.
[23:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, it was an appropriate spot for a shelter, or should it ever come to pass. We talked about the idea of an EV promotional campaign, and it definitely seems appropriate to piggyback on the statewide EV month, which rolls around every September. So we've set that aside for now because it doesn't seem like it's something that we should work on for the next 10 months. And we'll come back to it with a few months' notice rather than a few weeks. But the thing that caught our eye was the opportunity for electrification of the school bus fleet. And I talked to a member of the school board who was interested in pursuing that. and there is a an initiative at the state level that of course the web materials that they have date back to times when money was more available that's when the materials were put together but it the website is still up there 's a case study with seer bus lines in Old Town about how successful they've been as a private provider of school bus transportation for the town of for the city of old town or whatever it is the municipality school district and they've they seer bus lines has bought their own electric bus they've put in the charging infrastructure and appears to be operating very successfully do you know what kind of bus it was with a bluebird it's a thomas bus oh okay where are they there and it was sold It's sold out of Kennebunk, I think, and my understanding is that it's the standard Thomas school bus frame structure that everyone uses, and then another vendor puts the powertrain in, the battery pack and the electric motors, and apparently it's been running very successfully, according to the website. site. It all looks great. It is also probably a year or two old, the web information. So I've called SEER bus lines to find out what the latest is from them. If things look as promising as they appear, then it seems like it's worth going to talk to the school department or school board and see how receptive they are to investigating further. So that's something we're thinking about at this point.
[26:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so did you talk to Cyr?
[26:15] Speaker D (unidentified): I called Cyr, and I was put through to Nick Cyr, I think, and left a message with him. He hasn't gotten back to me yet.
[26:23] Speaker A (unidentified): I can report that several months ago there was a workshop sponsored by one of the planning groups that came across my desk and I forwarded it to the superintendent this may have been last year and he said that in response that he mentioned that they have several propane buses now that you know produce less greenhouse gases at least from the bus end and that from a financial perspective a capital perspective right now their priority was on rebuilding the bus garage which has that been funded do you know ramona which chrissy it made it through planning board review not maybe
[27:11] Speaker B (unidentified): counselor timmy knows about the funding whether that was funded last year or if it is going to be or if they're looking to fund it this year i'm i believe there was some sort of special
[27:25] Speaker H (unidentified): fund that they had set aside. So I don't know whether that already contains enough money for the project or not. But I think just generally in terms of this discussion, my understanding is that they've been working very hard, as Tom was saying, on converting the fleet over to propane buses my assumption is probably pivoting partly through there to do also electric buses might be you know a difficult sell they're also like i think that they have i know at one point they had a sustainability subcommittee i don't know whether that is still a thing within the school board but there is some differentiation between the school board and the municipal, you know, government directly. So I'm not sure exactly how that fits into the charge of this committee, but there might be, you know, a way to collaborate there.
[28:29] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm not sure. Do you know, Ramona, if you would be willing, since the latest communication we've gotten from the school department is that they want us to communicate through you and not directly to them, whether you can check and see whether there are maybe you know this chrissy whether they're planning for the bus garage includes at least putting in the infrastructure that would allow if they ever chose to do electric buses to be able to put in charging for them i could ask
[29:01] Speaker B (unidentified): someone in the planning department about that because their plan would show that would
[29:05] Speaker A (unidentified): be i would seem to be smart to do that now when we were talking about the work that bath acid done with parking lots, which we haven't made much progress on, one of the options was just to put in the three-phase power by conduit so that if you do decide to put in charges later, it's a lot less expensive than having to tear up all the concrete and everything. Chrissy.
[29:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Anything else? Yeah. Yeah, there's this upcoming workshop on transportation in Maine, and William was interested in going. Are you going to be able to do that?
[29:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, I am registered to go. Excellent.
[29:49] Speaker F (unidentified): And when is it? The 17th. Of November? Yes. Okay, great. Excellent.
[29:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Okay. That's it for transportation. Tyler is not here. I don't know, Tucker, whether you have anything else to report from the Solid Waste Working Group.
[30:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I think we've already kind of covered a handful of things that we were going to discuss anyways. But we did meet on 6 October. We all kind of talked through quite a few topics. In some ways, it was kind of reorienting ourselves to all of the various efforts that have been going on, because there's been quite a few that we've been looking through. In terms of the audits, we already kind of talked about that. So I won't go through too much of that. We did talk about for this idea of trying to get more of the larger buildings on these programs. We realized that we haven't really talked to, like, the Brunswick Housing Authority a whole lot. From what I understand, there was a point in time when perhaps you and maybe Tyler went down and talked to the Housing Authority directly. Yes. But there was a question of if we've ever actually talked to the Housing Authority committee through the town government and what role they have to play in any of that.
[31:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Housing committee? No, I haven't. we did not talk through the housing committee okay we went and met with the operations guy and the
[31:10] Speaker C (unidentified): head of the brunswick housing authority okay so yeah that was kind of our question is we didn't fully know the scope of that i mean we can read it online right but what's online oftentimes isn't yeah a reflection of reality so we don't know if there is a role to play there and if it's worthwhile for us to reach out to them and ask them what their idea is for these programs and if that's something they've ever discussed before as a committee. But, again, we didn't want to do it too early if we hadn't actually had that discussion here about whether that would be appropriate for us to do or not.
[31:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you have a perspective on that, Ramona?
[31:43] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, so just to clarify, because it is a little confusing, Brunswick has a housing committee, which is focused on housing issues, supply side type stuff primarily, and also housing preservation. But that's occasionally may interact with the housing authority, but it is very separate housing authority. Then there is the Brunswick Housing Authority, which has a board that is primarily appointed by the town of Brunswick, but it is like a separate, like quasi municipal entity. I definitely think that talking to the Brunswick Housing Authority Board would be a good way of advancing sustainability goals, probably more so than talking to, you know, like the people in charge of like maintenance or type of things because they may or may not have like the authority on their own to make big changes in terms of how that stuff is handled. obviously they could bring stuff to the board but it sounds like the sort of question that probably would have to go to the board anyway so i think it would be worth checking in with i don't you said that you spoke to one of the people i think tom who was involved in the housing authority do you happen to remember who that was
[33:09] Speaker A (unidentified): i don't remember her name is a woman who's the head of the housing authority and there was a guy
[33:14] Speaker H (unidentified): that is the operation director yeah she met with them yeah i'd recommend maybe reaching out to the board itself i mean the executive director i think is kind of like our town manager where you know that's obviously a very good person to talk to but that is a staff person and speaking to you know the board president or somebody on the board to maybe bring the issue up within a board meeting might make a lot of sense.
[33:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you know who the chair of the board is, or is it on the town website, I assume?
[33:46] Speaker H (unidentified): I believe it's mentioned on the town website, but I'm also happy to send an email introducing whomever on the Sustainability Committee should be introduced to them.
[33:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I'd be happy to talk to them.
[34:01] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, I'll make that intro.
[34:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, great. Thank you.
[34:05] Speaker C (unidentified): And thank you for the clarification, Because I'm going to continue to make that mistake between the housing committee and housing authority, probably, unfortunately. The other thing that we've talked about a little bit here is the agri-cycle program. And, you know, we have two drop boxes here in town. We've been talking about expanding it to a third one. I believe Chrissy and Tyler spoke about that as well. The data that we have really does seem to support advocating for a third location to do this. and prior to the meeting it's not new data but i put the data in a graph of how many residential tons and last year we were upwards of 290 tons through the ag recycle program i mean it's it's it's pretty big at this point and so i think for us it's no longer a question of whether or not we should recommend third one it seems like we should the question is where to make that recommendation and it sounds like right now there's been talks about either town Hall, or was it Coffin School was the one?
[35:01] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so I've been in talks with people at the school department about putting one at the Coffin School, and they're into it, so we're waiting to hear back about logistics of that, and questions that people might have, and working through the kinks of actually bringing that site online.
[35:19] Speaker C (unidentified): So, I mean, that's, I don't know if we have to do anything formally at this point, since It seems like everybody's on board and it's working through, but as far as we're concerned, yeah, that's our recommendation at this point is to move forward with that and ask the town council to actually take action if everything seems to work out or if they even need to.
[35:36] Speaker B (unidentified): No, I don't think so. I think we just got to iron it out with the school department. We have money in a climate action plan fund for this kind of thing, so I think we can just sort of get it going once.
[35:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I happened to be out when we went to the rec center for the health expo. I walked over to the drop-off site there, and they've done a nice job with the sort of kiosk and stuff, explaining to people what it's all about, and there are like three bins there now, I think.
[36:05] Speaker F (unidentified): So, I'm sorry, you said it's going through the school department?
[36:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, they're proposing a third site at Coffin School. There are currently two sites, one at Public Works, one at the rec center.
[36:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, a coffin school, all right.
[36:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, only because it's a school, yeah. As part of this, though, I think there are pieces we talked about, and earlier we talked about this education piece in general. And, you know, I'm relatively new, so I've only been tabling at one event so far. But it seems like people keep asking for these programs, and they don't know that these drop sites exist where they are. And so I guess our question that we kind of talked about a little bit here is, beyond tabling at these events, what other avenues do we have for awareness and education of these things? Is it a matter of asking for a post on Facebook?
[36:53] Speaker A (unidentified): We can put a post on our, we have our notify me group, right, for the sustainability committee. So I was gonna suggest that maybe if the solid waste working group is willing to draft something up, we could run it by Chrissy to see if it could be posted on the notify me board. which goes to people who have voluntarily asked to be notified of town events and such. Does that make sense to you, Chrissy?
[37:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, yeah, we can certainly do that. Do we have any idea how many people actually are signed up for that list right now?
[37:33] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't. No, but our IT department would be able to get us that.
[37:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. Because I just worry that 's great, but I feel like the people who are part of that list would probably already know.
[37:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think it would be helpful if we could send it to the general notify me site, not just the Sustainability Committee. So does Deb handle that? So Deb Young in the manager's office is the lead on that. But you should go through Chrissy as a staffer. Right.
[38:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. Just sort of as like a general rule. If you could copy me on all communications about Sustainability Committee-related things, that would be smooth things over a lot.
[38:12] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. And I think the only other thing to kind of wrap it up is you were passing around the information for recycling. We had received, well, recycling is generic. Reusable. Utensils. Take-home containers. Right. So I think we're going to keep looking into that. I was supposed to look into that, and then I went traveling and then got food poisoning and did not read into any of these things because I was recovering from that, which is a joy.
[38:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, if you want to take that one, you can. I'd like to have one of them back. Okay. But it has a thing on it so you can get onto the website and find out whether there are other businesses in town that are doing it. Right. Or whether Wild Oats is the first. They may be the first.
[38:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, and I might reach out to some folks I know at Wild Oats to ask them what the process was like to get into that and how it's working for them.
[39:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I don't know. It's pretty new, I think. I don't know how many people are signing up. I haven't signed up yet, but I would hope to since I go there a fair amount.
[39:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Joe, do you think I missed anything? Do you think that's pretty good for what we discussed? I think you covered it. Okay, cool.
[39:14] Speaker B (unidentified): That's it for us. Okay. Can I tag along? Can I have a tag on? I have my own solid waste initiative here at Town Hall. Okay. Let's hear it. Well, the bathrooms have a lot of paper towel waste, and so I've been looking for ways to divert that. I was surprised, and it's unfortunate, but maybe this is not a surprise to some of you, but Agri-Cycle won't take them. Really? Yeah, I've learned that it's just not a good source of material for their digester. The digester doesn't like it. It doesn't promote.
[39:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Too much carbon or something?
[39:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, it's not nutritive enough, and it also can contain the soap that can harm the enzymes or biodegradable bacteria in the digesters. Because it's weird. Usually when you want to divert waste, you need a very pure. like the pure the source of waste you have the better right like if you don't have to separate the better but here i have this very pure source of waste because those trash cans it's all it is paper towels and i can't figure out where to get it or take it so i might you know give garbage to garden a call next because i've run into that dead end with agrocycle but that was also why we just started talking about the third food waste location as well because we were in touch with them about this other thing. So if you have any ideas about how to divert those paper towels.
[40:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So those are not recyclable through our normal recycling? No, not currently. Because they're contaminated?
[40:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, you just, you know, they don't recycle the, like, paper towels at, like, EcoMain.
[40:48] Speaker A (unidentified): I do put, I know that the Garbage to Garden will take regular paper towels. It's not overdue.
[40:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I think that the problem, part of the problem is the quantity of them. There's just big bags of them every day. So the other alternative is to eliminate the spores altogether, but that would be a cultural thing that we would have to sort of...
[41:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Get to go to the blow dryers, yeah.
[41:09] Speaker B (unidentified): We do have blow dryers already, but they're not really that well used. So that is my pet project in the solid waste realm that I'm trying to work on, and I'll come back a year later with...
[41:20] Speaker A (unidentified): The solid waste group, I'm sure, would be happy to work with you. Okay. Okay. That's all I have on my agenda, unless anybody else does. Let's see, we have a member of the public here. Did you wish to speak?
[41:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes. Okay. I'm sorry. Are we done with energy and sustainability? [Speaker A (unidentified): You mean the...] I had an update from John Monaghan.
[41:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, yeah,, right. I'm sorry. Yeah, if you can give an update from John Monaghan, that would be great. I'm sorry, just be a few minutes.
[41:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Very brief. So we reached out to him because he was going to get back to us in October. right he's still you know dealing with whatever medical issues so he said mid -november so i think that will be sort of a turning point to know whether or not he wants to take this work
[42:08] Speaker A (unidentified): on or not yeah for those new like joe john monahan is an engineer that bob howe knew from his previous work who did commercial energy audits of buildings and the town had has contracted with him to do a sort of a sort of a basic energy audit of five or six different town buildings but then he's had some health issues in the last few months so he hasn't we had a snafu with him not getting paid initially and then that got straightened out and now he's been having some health issues so we're waiting to see whether he's going to be able to do it Thank you. Okay. You're on. Mr. Whitcomb, is it? Yes. If you could come to the podium so you can be on the TV also.
[43:12] Speaker H (unidentified): Your microphone is muted. Do you mind hitting the little button at the very base of the mic? Thank you for that.
[43:19] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm new to addressing town government, so I'm still trying to understand I understand the perspectives and the approach of this committee to the various issues. Is it appropriate at this meeting to speak on the data center proposal in general?
[43:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, you can. This is not the primary entity dealing with that issue. It's the planning department and the planning board. Right.
[43:51] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. I would just like to briefly make one recommendation regarding that. I understand from what you were saying before the moratorium ends on November 28th. I think what I would like to do is to garner your support to produce a referendum, a public referendum on this project to permanently end it. And I haven't spoken to anyone in the public who is actually interested in having a data center in Brunswick. I do understand what you said, Mr. Rumpf, about the goals and the points that this committee is involved in directly. But I would like to ask that you support and encourage a referendum on the construction of a data center, maybe especially unofficially. If you're on the phone talking to, let's say, a member of the town council or the planning board or any of the other boards or committees or commissions, I just ask that you support that. I think this is the most efficient way of promoting sustainability because this data center would be a major setback for any type of sustainability. It's just antithetical to any type of sustainable life in Brunswick. So that's all I have to say.
[46:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Well, we have discussed data centers a lot in this committee, and Tucker has done some work for us on research on data centers and how to make them more sustainable. And ultimately, we hope to provide some input to the planning department when they are in the process of drafting an ordinance. We as a committee are advisory to the town council, So I'm not sure it would be appropriate for us to step outside of that at this point before the town council has had a chance to act and advocate for a particular other approach. Typically, a referendum is initiated by people who aren't happy with what the town council has done. So my own sense, I don't know if Ramona, if you have any perspective on this, but my own sense is that would be a little premature at this point to be advocating for a referendum. for banning all data centers. We recognize that there are different impacts depending on the size of the data center, depending on whether they use renewable energy or not, whether their water use is renewable in a closed-loop system, those sorts of things, and then there are sound issues and other things. There's a lot of issues, for sure, around data centers, but at this point, we have not... Well, our specific authority doesn't tell us to do that, though we can comment to other entities within the town where our role is an advisory to the town council.
[47:43] Speaker G (unidentified): OK, I'll find another mechanism to promote that then.
[47:47] Speaker D (unidentified): OK. Thank you. Ramona.
[47:49] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I did have a little bit of an answer there. While it is true that the public can initiate a referendum, the council also can initiate a referendum, especially if there's like a decision that they want the public to make instead of them directly. I don't know whether that approach is quite necessary here, because from all the discussions that happened amongst council, it kind of sounded like everybody was not in favor of there being data centers in Brunswick. But I very much agree with Mr. Whitcomb that I haven't also not heard from a single member of the public in Brunswick that thinks anything other than we shouldn't have those here. You can definitely, if you rewatch the meeting where we discussed the moratorium, every single person who spoke was against the idea of having data centers in Brunswick all across the political spectrum. but i also wanted to just say i mean like the whole idea of sustainability committee being advisory to council advice is usually best given before a decision is made so i wouldn't say that there's a particular downside in having the sustainability committee tell the council their opinion on something it's kind of the job of the sustainability committee to do that but like i was saying on this particular issue i don't i just don't know that it's going to matter all that much because that is where the council seems to be other than the referendum part
[49:36] Speaker A (unidentified): which you know may not be needed if the council is where you say mr whitcomb who do you know Do you know who your counselor is for your district where you live? Counselor Cheney. Oh, okay.
[49:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, there you go. You're awesome. Can I make just a point of clarification about process? So this committee has already reviewed the ordinance and provided the feedback to planning. So that sort of opportunity has been taken by the committee. I imagine that going forward, if you wanted additional input, it would be through letters or individual input at the planning board review level and the town council review level.
[50:22] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. I wasn't aware that we had.
[50:24] Speaker A (unidentified): I knew Tucker had sent some comments in and Bob had sent comments in.
[50:27] Speaker B (unidentified): We had that whole meeting. We had like an hour meeting about it. We had a whole discussion about it.
[50:31] Speaker A (unidentified): But you told us at that time that it was premature for us to try and have impact on the regulations.
[50:39] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that, no, I mean, we did come to the agreement that information was passed on. And I don't want to downplay the work of other people. I mean, Mark has done some really good work with writing up stuff that was really well received by the council. Bob has done a lot of work as well. And that the council has reviewed that, and it sounds like a lot of stuff that we've talked about has been passed to the planning board to incorporate, you know, as advisory guidance, things that are going on there. But so I just – I appreciate that my name gets mentioned when we talk about AI data centers, but I am one little part, and I don't want to downplay the work that other people have been doing for this.
[51:18] Speaker D (unidentified): and I just to pick up on something you said Chrissy my understanding was what we were commenting on and reacting to was not an ordinance it was a set of questions that the planning board had for us in the context of developing an ordinance language isn't that right
[51:34] Speaker B (unidentified): it was the draft ordinance it was a draft ordinance it was two meetings ago yeah there
[51:41] Speaker C (unidentified): There was a draft ordinance that covered minor data centers. And there was questions about whether or not something would be written for larger ones. But those questions did come from a draft for an ordinance that would address that. Okay.
[51:57] Speaker B (unidentified): And, yeah, so we had added that 30 minutes to the regular meeting, went through it. I think we spent an hour on it. I recorded all of your commentary, sent it over to Julie Erdman. Right. Okay. And that was your input. I'm not saying that's your only input. I'm just saying that, you know, going forward, the next time, if you want to provide input, it would be at the planning board level or town council level. Okay.
[52:25] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. And Ramona's on top of it as well. So hopefully she's going to check and see whether the moratorium is going to be extended and what other actions that council might take and let us know.
[52:40] Speaker H (unidentified): I've already sent the email to the Council Chair, and I will forward the reply to you, Tom, and then you can maybe distribute that out via Christy to the rest of the committee.
[52:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Great. Thank you. [Speaker G (unidentified): Thank you, Ramona.] Any other business? If not, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn.
[53:06] Speaker D (unidentified): I move we adjourn. Second.
[53:09] Speaker A (unidentified): All those in favor? Okay. Looks like it's unanimous.