← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick Residents Seek Town Takeover of Private Roads at Landing

2026-10-22 · 2h 15m · Source: 2026.10.22 Brunswick Landing Community Meeting (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): An AV issue, but I also wanted to let everybody know that we do have a lot of people here who have a lot of answers, or maybe even just some more information, maybe not answers, but more information about Brunswick Landing, the changes that are occurring, the problems that we have been facing, the potential solutions, some of the stuff's not necessarily solvable yet. yet, but tonight's purpose is to really focus on hearing each other, putting faces to names, understanding who's kind of in charge of what, and with it being such a complex place and so many moving parts and so many lives kind of affected by this part of the community, I think it's just tonight I'm hoping that people walk away maybe knowing more, feeling a little bit more heard, maybe, like I said, getting some answers or getting an update you didn't have before, feeling a little bit more empowered to take next steps on things that you're most concerned about. So I'm going to go ahead and just introduce people here who are going to provide some brief updates for this group, but I'm really focused on making sure that this meeting is we give enough time for questions and answers to at least get things, you know, you feel like you're getting some clarity on some of these issues. I'm not promising that you're going to feel like all your answers or all your issues are going to be addressed, but we're going to try really hard. And the fact that we have people here who have agreed to attend and provide updates dates and answer any questions that you folks might have, I hopefully will help us move the needle a little bit on some of the challenges and opportunities that we face on Brunswick Landing. So I'm going to start on this horseshoe, introducing people. At the very end, we have Brian Benfield. He is the, he works for Foreside Management, who is hired by most of the, well, he's hired by the master HOA for Brunswick Landing, and Foreside Management has other employees that help, I think, have been hired by HOAs as well. So someone who's kind of in charge of keeping track of the budgets and also projects that are happening on properties that the Master HOA is in charge of. And next to him we have Nat Prouty, and he is a representative from Jones Street who sits on the Master HOA. And also, the company is the manager of several different apartment buildings. And he'll talk more about their ownership and their management on Brunswick Landing. And then next to him, we have Kevin Bunker, who is president of Developers Collaborative, who is the owner of a few of the apartment buildings on Brunswick Landing, is also the owner of the property, or is going to be the owner of the property that's going to turn into Saratoga Road. And just a side note, there is a development plan sketch out that's on that table that everybody's welcome to look at when we're done tonight. And then continuing around the horseshoe, we have Jim Howard. He is the president of Priority Real Estate, and that is a company that owns a lot of property, has a lot of ownership on Brunswick Landing, has done a lot of development already, commercial development on the landing, and is looking to do more, and so is here to talk more about what he has. And then to my left we have Julie Erdmann, she's the Director of Planning and Development. That's right,? Yeah. I just called it Planning, the Department of Planning, but it's also Planning and Development. And she has been pretty engaged with some of the more recent issues, although you've been Director for just a few years. So her tenure is not included in the earlier years where there were some really big decisions made on Brunswick Landing, however, very aware of them, so can speak to that. And then Jay Astle, who's our assistant town manager and has also been very involved in conversations with the Master HOA and MIRA and kind of connects all the dots when possible. So we also are expecting Dan Stevenson, who is the executive director of MIRA, the Midcoast Redevelopment Authority. who they own, as you know, land, and is also in charge of a lot of the roads on the landing, and I'm hoping he'll be here ASAP. I'm going to have to give him a call. So are we set with? All right, Dan Stevenson. You get to come up to the horseshoe right next to me. Okay, great. So are we set? Yeah. So we're going to get into updates from the various folks who are in the know, I guess you could say. So we're going to start out with, I guess, the first person I ever made meaningful contact on Brunswick Landing telling me about what was going on and things he had concerns about. I should also say, let me do a little bit of housekeeping. We have a lot of people here in person, which is wonderful. We also have people on Zoom. And so when we get to the point of Q&A, I'm going to be managing, I'll be focused on managing that, so we can get, you know, an equal amount of people speaking here in person and also on Zoom. So for those who are on Zoom, we will not forget you. I see there's several people logged in, so I just wanted that to be clear. And I would like to complete our meeting tonight as close to 7 o'clock as possible. So, like I said, everybody can get home. But my intention is to not end the conversation once this meeting is over. My hope is that the conversation will restart. I would say one thing, or continue after this meeting, one thing I neglected to do was create a sign-in sheet. And that is a huge problem. so I'm gonna maybe quickly we'll figure one out because I do want to know who did come today and also I can put you on my email list I do send out occasional email news updates just to keep people in my district up to date on what's going on in town and so the sign-in sheet can actually if you can just indicate that you'd like to be on that list I'd love to have you on that list. Okay, so I'm going to get things started with our first presenter, and that's the person I was just explaining is one of the first people I had a meaningful conversation about the challenges of what's on Brunswick Landing, and that's John Roberts, and he has put a slideshow together. He's actually not a resident of Brunswick Landing anymore, but he's very committed to making it a place where everybody is getting what they need, and so he's going to provide an update on the work he did to get to move some needles here thank you now [8:12] Speaker B (unidentified): it is okay for those of you who don't know me name is john roberts i'm a retired navy captain was stationed here in brunswick for a number of years over my career i ended up liking brunswick so much we moved back here we have some vacation property in harpswell but i owned a condo on brunswick landing for four years. We just sold it a few months ago, but we still really love Brunswick, landing. And I have been involved with the town, the Master HOA, and other folks in dealing with all the 16 roads that belong to the Master HOA, and the fact that they're privately owned, and many of them are really used in a very public manner. And so that's what I'm going to focus on tonight, is one particular road. And that's this one that we're talking about here we're looking for a municipal owner a benevolent municipal owner who's willing ready and able to take over a very nice privately owned road that's being publicly used it's right in the center of great public recreational facilities right smack dab in the middle of brunswick landing and all we're looking for is a municipality to say we'd love to take that road over And that's where we're going with my direction here. Hopefully, I can build the case where it's a slam dunk. So anyway, let's move on a little bit about the next slide. First, I think it's important for us to understand who is this Brunswick Master HOA. For those of you who don't live there, and maybe some of you who are, don't understand the full complexity of it. It's made up of four distinct neighborhoods of privately owned condominiums or townhomes. Hopefully I'm not in the way of anyone. Mariners Landing, Woodland Village South, Woodland Village, Lupine Circle, and 74 single-family homes soon to grow to over 100 when Saratoga Street is completed. So you can see there's 294 homeowners, if you will, that reside on the base. that are part of this master homeowners association. In addition to these privately owned properties, there are 152 commercially owned rental units. They belong to Jones Street Developers out of Boston, and as Jen indicated, Jones Street also owns a number of other apartment complexes, but it's important to understand, the only ones that belong to the master association are the ones that Jones Street owns, and those are Haven East and Haven South. There's another Haven, I don't know, is it South by Southwest or whatever the name of it, there's another Haven, but that is not part of the Master HOA. And that's important because the Master HOA is the one footing the bill for maintaining all the roads within the Master HOA, which we'll get into here in just a moment. The other commercial property owner is Kevin Bunker with Developers Collaborative. He owns the properties in the yellow there. It's 60 units, I believe, in the five buildings that are, again, rental units. So altogether, it's 446, soon to be over 500 owners and tenants that are paying their way through the Master HOA for the maintenance of roads throughout the association. One thing that I should mention that's important is Jones Street. The Master HOA has a declaration just like any other homeowners or condo association has filed with the state. It has rules and regulations and bylaws and all the rest of that sort of thing. Well there's still a declarant, basically the guy in charge, and that's Jones Street. So, Jones Street, by edict of the sale, when they purchased their property from Brunswick Landing Venture, they were granted, in perpetuity, a majority vote. So, any decision made by the master association is ultimately controlled by Jones Street. While we have representatives from the other neighborhoods voicing opinions on the board of Directors. Again, Jones Street has 51 or more percent of the vote on all matters. Okay. Let's go to the next slide, if I can, please. All right. Let's take a high-level look at Brunswick Landing. And if you were to take a poll of all the cars and trucks that come on the base and you were to say, why are you, where are you going and what are you coming to do on the base, I think we would find that people come either because they live here on the base. I keep saying base, former Navy base. Either they live there, they work there, they recreate there, they come to the recreational facilities, maybe they come to eat there at a couple of the restaurants, and there's probably a few other reasons. But for the most part, that's why they're coming. So for those that work here, this is kind of the core of the developed area for Brunswick Landing. That's where most of the businesses are, whether it be on the flight line, along the hangars, and over here at Hangar 6, but all the buildings in this area. So that's where most people are going. going. Granted, Allagash is another road that is not on this map, and that's becoming more developed as time goes on, but that's up here off the map and not concern to us because we're looking at Neptune. Here's Neptune, excuse me, Neptune, and so there's three ways to access the base. If you're coming in from the north, you're coming in on Fitch off Old Bath Road. If you're coming in from the south, it's going to be on Orion, which actually turns into American League, if I'm not mistaken, down by the golf course. Or you can access Brunswick Landing from the east on Landing Drive. I should note that Landing Drive is, in fact, a town of Brunswick-owned road. They put it in when the base closed and the Mirus started. So Brunswick basically paid for that road to be installed. So there are now three ways to get onto the base. If you look at the other two, now Neptune is not an access point directly onto the base, but if you notice the dotted blue line, this is a typical path that many, motors take to get onto the base. If they're coming up from Harpswell Islands, if they're coming in from Bath, they're coming in on landing and they can either go straight onto Fitch or they can turn left onto to Neptune and work their way down this way. So there's two major thoroughfares. They're kind of parallel, if you will, between Fitch and Neptune. They both have the same start point up here, roughly, at that corner, and they have a similar terminus down here at Orion. John? [15:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes? I want to just say, if you can, I want to give enough time for everybody to provide an update, so you got about four or five more minutes? [15:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. Okay. Well, we're going to put it in overdrive. Okay, let's, we'll go to the next slide. Okay, the people that come to live here, this is where they are, and it's important. Look at the Master HOA. There's the footprint of the Master HOA. All those rental units, condos, single-family homes. All the yellow areas are the other rental apartments that are not part of the Master HOA. Let's see if we can get the next one here. There we go. People come to play here. Where are they going? You see in the purple here the Brunswick-Topsail Land Trust bike trail located right on Neptune. The rec center, which is growing in size, is on Neptune. And the MARC, a regional facility, not just for Brunswick residents, we're inviting residents from the entire mid-coast area to come onto the basin. How are they getting there? Oops, let's go back, see if we can't do that. There we are. They're either coming on Fitch or through landing, and a lot of them are coming down and through the Master HOA privately owned road on Neptune. And that's our concern. And it's not just people in cars. There are businesses that are located down here. The Hunger Prevention Program has food trucks coming in and out all the time bringing in foodstuffs for those who need it. Coastal Shores and Coastal Landing right here the assisted living and independent living they have a full restaurant service so their suppliers their vendors are coming in on Neptune Drive right through our neighborhoods again with heavy trucks which is accelerating the wearing of the road that we're paying for? [17:43] Speaker A (unidentified): About two minutes. Pardon? Two more minutes. Two minutes. All right. We've got a clock cooking [17:49] Speaker B (unidentified): here. Okay. So they come to recreate. Five. There's a rec center, the bike trail, and the we talked about those. Let's move on to the next one. All right. So who owns Neptune? That's a good question. You may remember last winter, somebody wrote a letter to the editor of the newspaper favor saying, hey, I damaged my car while driving on the Brunswick Landing, and who the hell owns the road, because I want to get some reimbursement. Well, they couldn't find out, because nobody knew. Well, guess what, folks? There are five different owners for that one road. Five. Mira still owns a very short section right up here, where it butts up against Orion. Jones Street owns this portion, because they purchased the Pegasus Apartments, now Haven, whatever. Coastal Shores just recently took over ownership of their portion of the road. Brunswick Landing Venture, the original developer of all the Master HOA, still owns this portion. And then through a sleight of hand a couple years ago, Kevin Bunker ended up owning this portion of Neptune from BLV. How he got it is another story. So there's five different owners. Now, the important thing, though, to remember is the master HOA is only responsible for the maintenance of this portion right here, where it's white and the orange, if you will. But we are paying the freight to maintain it and to plow it and have been for, you know, a number of years. All right. Let's move on to the next one here. Yes. [19:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. All right. This is going to blend in. Yeah. Yeah. A couple more minutes. Okay. Okay, you got updates too, but all right, but make it, you know, we'll keep it on the fast track here. [19:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, if I can get to the next slide, please. Here we go. All right, my pitch is for the town of Brunswick. [19:49] Speaker A (unidentified): John, just a little closer to the microphone, too. I'm afraid people online aren't hearing, so yeah. All right. [19:56] Speaker B (unidentified): This is a copy out of the main, or excuse me, the Brunswick Code, Section 14-188. Let me read it for you in the back where you may not be able to see it. notwithstanding the provisions of any other section thereof, the town may at any time accept any street whenever the general public interest so requires. The cost of said street may be borne by the said town. So that's where we're making the point that Neptune Drive is clearly in the general public interest for the town to assume ownership. Now, let's take a look at why that is. First of all, it's a principal road within Brunswick Landing. You saw that. You've got Neptune, you've got Orion, you've got Fitch. Those are the three key ones that are bringing traffic in and around. It's already a high-volume traffic pattern, if you will, and it's growing as the mark grows. We've gone from just pickleball and a skate park, now it's basketball, there's going to be hockey and swimming and everything else eventually. So it's just growing in the amount of traffic that's coming through a residential neighborhood. [Speaker C (unidentified): There's three] recreational facilities, as I've already pointed out, the bike trail, the rec center, and the mark. Commercial trucks coming in on a regular daily basis, wearing the roads down. It's a shortcut. Anybody who knows who lives out on the other side of town, you come in the gate back by the, or the former gate by the golf course, and you can cut right through to Cook's Corner without having to mess with going through downtown or Old Bath Road. And the last point, just oh, by the way, and it's a place that everybody comes to vote. So the entire town of Brunswick is invited to Neptune Drive one time a year or maybe a couple times a year going through our neighborhood, even though they put up signs that says, please, here's a way to get to the voting booths. Everybody in Brunswick knows that's the shortcut. cut next slide please okay this is the last one what we're proposing is a year ago we met with the town the engineer the staff and everyone and said here's an engineering study we paid thirty some odd thousand dollars here's the condition of the roads here's the what needs to be done to bring them up to the town standards and everything, and that's going to take some time because we're still waiting on part two of that engineering study for the stormwater system that's accompanying that. So we're saying Neptune is a unique and a very special case, and it falls under this Municipal Code Section 14-188 in the best interest of the general public. The condition of the road by our engineering standards is poor, but it's been completed they recommend what is called a mill and fill basically grind off the top coat a little bit and put down three more inches and bring it up to town standards and it's going to cost about three hundred thousand dollars the town looked at that report and they agreed to us here in this building a year ago that the report was accurate it correctly described the condition of the roads and they agreed with the estimate for the cost to bring them up to town standards. So that has already been accepted by the town as a living document for the condition of the roads. We're now just working on the stormwater system. There's a requirement that any road that the town takes over has to have some kind of tissue connectivity to another road already owned by the town. Neptune does not quite meet. It hits Forrestal and they're about 200 feet down the road. Forrestal has an intersection with Landing Drive so it would require that the town would take over about 200 feet of Forrestal in order to meet that requirement so they don't end up with a street by itself. What we're asking for and we can hope the town staff, I was hoping Julie was going to be here, would make a recommendation to the town council to accept ownership of Neptune Drive under the town code for acceptance of a street in the general public interest. We've been sitting on this thing for 18 months. We've been talking about it. It's time to move on. We don't have to tie Neptune to all the rest of the streets. let's get Neptune done now and we can work on getting the other streets in the months coming that's all I have questions not questions yet we're gonna [24:55] Speaker A (unidentified): move on to I'm gonna ask Mina who is on the master HOA and also the president of her Mariners Landing HOA just to if you can do a lightning round of just top issues that you would like to just bring up as part of the master HOA's work [25:14] Speaker D (unidentified): You can see why we missed John on the master HOA. So at Mariners, president of Mariners Landing Condominiums Association, we have 126 units. We have five concerns. One is the road ownership, which John has already addressed. We're the only residential HOA that owns its six roads within the HOA. And we have two concerns. One is public safety. We have neighboring neighborhoods. We have neighborhoods around us that our roads are the right of way to their neighborhoods. And so we have residents from those neighborhoods going through at 30 to 40 miles an hour, and the speed is 15. So speeding is a huge concern. And without, I realize that Brunswick police aren't allowed to watch for speed on privately-owned roads. And so we're asking that, you know, what can we do about this? Without radar detection, there's little we can do to enforce the speeding through our neighborhood. The road maintenance and repair that owners, the 126 owners can't cover the deferred road maintenance or the repaving when that's needed and the town of Brunswick is receiving, well just from Mariners Landing alone, over $500,000 a year in real estate taxes and with all the other development on the base it's considerably more than that and so we're asking that the town consider taking over ownership of these streets second is the playground three playgrounds were removed for increased development they serviced mariners landing and single-family homes around us three years later those playgrounds have not been replaced we were promised bigger and better playgrounds a lot of families bought into the community because of the playgrounds the third thing is property line discrepancies as a result of several different errors at different levels there are currently 23 mariners landing units that have back fences that are two feet over the property line the developer surrounding developer hasn't any intention of developing that property and we would like the town to help us to remedy that oversight it could be as simple as a redrawing the property lines water metering we don't have individual water meters currently our owners are paying $88 per unit per month for water and for a lot of single owners they're ending up subsidizing families of five and six that are using a lot more water so we would appreciate if that timetable for the water meters could be moved up into our units fire sprinkler updates we found out this year this is the last item that our systems are over 20 years old and because of changes in requirements for antifreeze It's going to cost the owners $5,000 per unit to upgrade the fire sprinkler systems. And since town code says that units of three units, buildings of three units or more require sprinkler systems, we want to know what the town does to make sure that the maintenance is done on these systems And, you know, what enforcement and help can we have in getting those systems upgraded? In general, I just raced through this, but in general, we appreciate all the support that we're getting. We're a new association, a new HOA, and we're looking to get these issues resolved. and that's it that we hope that Brunswick landing is that remains a great place to live and work thank you I should say that we do have chief Stewart [30:00] Speaker A (unidentified): police chief Stewart here and fire chief Ken brilliant here too so at some point maybe speak to the safety question and speeding issue on the landing but I [30:14] Speaker D (unidentified): want to I have to leave early but Nicole Tenney who's the vice president is here and will can stay for the question-and-answer period perfect thank [30:24] Speaker A (unidentified): you thank you very much okay I'm gonna move us along here I'm gonna since we're still talking we've been talking about the HOAs and master HOA again we have the management company and the majority owner and majority vote on the board sitting here and there's a few things that came up that you might be able to speak to but for sure maybe get more clarification on the latest on the road upgrade assessment and any strategies or updates about maintenance of the infrastructure that the master HOA is responsible for and just your how you operate in that in that way to make sure that roads and infrastructure are getting maintained properly thank you sorry make sure your microphone's on is the right is the green [31:19] Speaker E (unidentified): light on there you go thank you so to john's point we had met with the city last year trying to get the city to take over the roads we were asked to do an engineering study we did that and then we were after the fact asked to do a stormwater drain survey so immediately we contacted grill Palmer and they had told us we're working on it we'll get it to you by April we followed up with them several times and we have yet to receive anything so we're at a little bit of a standstill there so that's that's really the most recent with the roads was hoping someone from [32:04] Speaker A (unidentified): from grill Palmer I know you mentioned it's now lj ljb engineering now yeah right so that [32:13] Speaker E (unidentified): also goes hand in hand just with road maintenance and safety so another component of this to address minus point the speeding so we reached out to the city earlier this year is about July proposing putting a Jersey barrier on Neptune Drive basically just with the concerns of speeding people without, that aren't in the association, driving through the neighborhood recklessly, a lot of complaints throughout the association that this was a recurring problem. The concern from the town for the Jersey barrier, which, you know, totally understood, is emergency vehicle access. So with that in mind, we obviously didn't end up doing the Jersey barriers. What we did was we put up speed limit signs, just enforcing the 15-mile-an-hour speed limit. We put up speed bumps, and in regards to road maintenance, that also plays into the town potentially taking over. So we have patched potholes and done what we can, but from our perspective, if the town is about to potentially take everything over, it's very expensive to maintain the road. So we are making it as good as we possibly can right now patching when needed Yeah, those are all updates anything I'm missing Another last component might add to address your point. So the playgrounds. Yes, that absolutely has been a discussion So we have our meeting on Monday. We've been speaking with developer and associated parties they are providing quotes and along with the defined scope so it's a work in progress we're going to speak about it more on Monday with the master HOA meeting and look forward to that discussion [34:07] Speaker A (unidentified): just a quick question just to prompt you a little bit more about how you your ongoing like approach to keeping the I mean you have a lot as John's map shows there's you have a lot of infrastructure as a master HOA to keep to maintain. So is there a budget set aside each year to do that maintenance? Is there a lot of deferred maintenance going on right now? Is there a plan to create a bigger budget for maintenance and then maybe even upgrading roads so they can be taken over by the town? What's the strategy related to Master HOA's work on that? Yes. So we coordinate a budget every year with [34:50] Speaker E (unidentified): foreside and we absolutely do have repair and maintenance we try to limit deferred maintenance and I want to say just about every year our budget for road maintenance is increasing so something we're trying to you know stay on top of as much as we possibly can and maintain the roads and maintain the [35:13] Speaker C (unidentified): community as we're in this holding sure that's we're in this holding pattern to do it where it was up to town standard in terms of the grade and the overlay. So that would increase, and we're not willing, I don't think it's prudent to spend the money on a smaller overlay until we know. So unfortunately, with Stephen Bushy holding that off, it is just prolonged. I mean, we're happy to, I actually am getting quotes for Neptune in the single-family homes just in case we keep kicking this can down the road because as it stands that's probably the worst span that we have hence why I you know we did speed bumps we didn't do speed tables so there's concessions that are made to make sure that 's at least safer for them did people are I had as we were putting in those speed bumps I mean I had someone going over 30 miles an hour right after they were done kind of waving at me you know in a tundra and I was absolutely floored but so you could see we're sort of it you know in between a rock and a hard place making the decision whether or not you do a one and a half inch over it or if you're gonna do a three inch to come up to town standard so we are fixing every pothole that we have we're also making sure that we're not spending money erroneously on that but we're happy to spend the money as soon as the town makes the decision either way if i could just add to that [36:48] Speaker F (unidentified): the you know the steve bushy thing and the study that we did the first study and then we're asked to do a second study that was like a global study of all the storm water just like it was all the roads but john's john's kind of honed the point down to just neptune being the biggest problem and the biggest one all that requires us to understand is neptune and there's any storm water that's associated with neptune so i don't know that if there was a will there would be a way to do neptune it's just that what we got was we think it's a good idea probably that's we want to work toward that in the future but there's just so much we don't know right now and boy it's going to take a long time so the question is can we hold out long enough as the whole town's using the road and we're paying for it to thread that needle between waiting for the fullness of time for that to take place. So it's a complicated issue, but I think the brilliance of what John is saying is that focusing on Neptune cuts a lot of the extra complication out and maybe allows us to focus on an incremental strategy of which Neptune obviously has to be the first piece if any of it's going to get done. So I think that maybe there's some action that can be taken on a more limited basis if there was the will to do so and take it seriously. [38:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I've been asked very wisely to ask you to, I know I introduced you earlier, but if you can just say your name and where you're from again and just go down and also Nat, if you could do that as well. [38:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Brian Benfield, Foresight Management. Okay. [38:24] Speaker E (unidentified): Nat Prouty, Jones Street Residential. [38:26] Speaker A (unidentified): And then Brian, did you have anything more you wanted to share or provide updates? Or Nat, any more updates on your end? [38:33] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that covers it. I mean, I'm sure we're going to get questions, so at that point, if there's any specific things that we did over, we'd be happy to answer. [38:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. I have Playground as part of your update, but maybe I'll pass it over to Kevin. He might have more information. So, Kevin, if you just introduce yourself again, and then you have the floor. [38:49] Speaker F (unidentified): Kevin Bunker with Developers Collaborative. Lived in Brunswick until two years ago, from 07 to two years ago. ago, done only a little bit in town, did the 60 units that asylum seekers have been living in for the past couple of years, was a big part of the Tedford shelter that got done. And now I have the Saratoga Street development under contract, so there's an update on that. But building on the point that was just made, the playgrounds issue is a complicated issue. There were two playgrounds that were sort of clouded on the plans to replace the ones that were taken down one of them is on mariners landing land and one of them is on land that i bought and the sleight of hand john was referring to i don't know if he meant mine or presidiums or blvs but what happened when i bought the land for the apartments it came with saratoga it came with neptune and it came with all kinds of interstitial land in between just because of the strange way the original subdivision was done so i ended up with these chunks of land one of which had like a clouded gray note with the word playground to be replaced on it. And so that is a pretty good place for a playground. But it hasn't been done yet for a number of reasons, one of which is that I have not allowed it to happen yet. We're working on that, allowing that to happen now. There are more issues to that than probably we have time for here tonight. But I don't think Mariners Landing is intending to build their playground or not. but we're intending to build mine and what's what's going on there is Chris Rhodes from Presidium has agreed that they have the cost responsibility for it but the expectation is that I'll donate the land for it to happen and it was it's tricky because the one of the elephants in the room is at Jones Street and Presidium don't always see eye to eye on everything and so there's a lot of negotiation back and forth on roads and common elements and different things and I didn't want to get caught up in the middle of that so we but we had a nice exercise recently with the path that was put in between Guadalcanal and Intrepid I get that right yeah so there was a path that was on the plan that never got put in either the what might be helpful for all you to know and this applies to Saratoga as well generally speaking the original developer Presidium BLV whatever they go by was putting in all the infrastructure and then the individual developers were developing their lots and so this path somehow kind of fell in the cracks and also that ended up on my land so when it came time to build the path i got stuck with part of it and i went to chris and said hey this was probably supposed to be your path let's at least split it so we did we split the cost built the path and what i didn't want to do was build a path for everyone to use and then i would have the liability because it happened to be on my land, so we worked with the association to sign an easement that became effective as soon as the path was completed, so I didn't have to worry about whether or not there would be an argument when it was done. So that allowed me to feel good about paying for the path, my half of the path, contracting to have it done, building it, and now that automatically becomes part of the association's common elements and is maintained by the association. so we have a we have a path no pun intended of how to do that now and we can we think we can pursue a similar path forward with the playground whereby we'll agree what the playground will be what will be in it who will do it and then we'll have this document do a similar approach where as soon as it's done it will become part of the association so we've made some good progress on that I suspect I'm mostly here tonight talk about Saratoga which is behind Neptune. So the Chris Rhodes of Presidium was getting ready to kind of give up and he tried to sell it to Lonnie Graver and Lonnie didn't want to buy it. And so I was just sitting there watching it not get built and thinking, boy, this is a lost opportunity right in the middle of all this development for some starter homes, which is something I'm becoming more and more interested in. I do a lot of affordable housing, mostly apartments, a lot of try to do sort of socially minded development and this seemed like a too good of an opportunity to let slip something that was already permitted and available for development so I put it under contract to buy it and hoping to build a neighborhood of starter homes there and as and in preparation for that we've cut down all the trees which I know has made some people unhappy but walking that area now it seems clear to me that it's destined to be a part of brunswick and it's destined to be a part of the neighborhood and you know i'm looking forward to doing that and making it fit in well and maybe tweaking the plan we walked the site yesterday adding some trees doing what we can do there are also a lot of grading issues i was a former city planner and coming in to the brunswick landing development you know i've lived in brunswick but mostly worked elsewhere in portland and elsewhere and when i became involved in the developments, it struck me how much was happening so fast with, frankly, not all the regulation and oversight that I was used to seeing in other communities. And so you kind of get what you get when that happens, when the market is really good and you've got a lot of aggressive, smart people with a lot of money developing things quickly on 50-year-old, however old that infrastructure is. It's kind of a predictable situation that we all find ourselves in now, and part of the issues over at Saratoga are grading issues and the way things were done on Neptune just to get houses up and sell them that has created some of the issues that hopefully I'll be able to stitch in and make better with some of the things I'm doing, at least certainly not make them any worse. So I'm looking forward to doing that and trying to be a good member of the community But I am I am not ashamed to say that I think that's a good spot for housing and that land Should be developed or I wouldn't have proposed to do it [45:13] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm gonna keep moving around and next to me is Jim Howard who is the president of priority realty real estate? So the floor is yours [45:22] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, I'm Jim Howard president of priority group. My office is in Topsom. I live in Topsom You may have seen a lot of our signs around Brunswick Landing. We've been developing out there for the past 13 years since the base closed, and Jennifer has asked me to just sort of give you an outline of the properties that we own and what our development plans are for the future. Currently, you may be familiar with the Rusty Lantern Market. We developed and own the Rusty Lantern Market out at Brunswick Landing. 2 Admiral Fitch, where Dermatology Associates and Reyes is, 150 Admiral Fitch, Vivid Cloud, we own that building and lease it to Vivid Cloud. We own 119 Purrington, where Sight Lines and Green Tech is, 243 Neptune, so we understand your road issues, where Northeast Ambulance and Shoreline Detailing is. We own 122 Orion Street, which is where Atlantic AV and Skorto have their offices, the Martins Point Land on the old Bath Road, 46 Burbank, which is where Maine Maritime Academy is now, where Wayfair used to be. We own 16 Burbank, which is where Pathway School is, a school for kids with autism and learning disabilities. facilities, 62 Pegasus Street, where Pettengill Learning Academy is, and the Veterans Resource Center. And last January, we finished up on 16 Katahdin Drive, the new Stark Systems manufacturing building that's there. So we've made some substantial investments over the last 13 years at Brunswick Landing. landing. We do have some properties that we own that will develop in the future. Lot 60, 61, and 6C, for those of you who don't look at the Navy maps all the time, that's the land that's at the entrance to the landing at 2 Admiral Fitch, where the first airplane is across the street. We're Allagash. We have about 14 acres there. Lot 11, which is next to Vivid Cloud, Right along Admiral Fitch where we've got a 10,000 square foot building permitted. No customer yet. Lot 15, which is Schooner Drive, which is next to Stark Systems. We're in the process of permitting a 15,000 square foot building there. Lot 18, which is at the corner of Admiral Fitch and Pelican. It's a grass lot right now. that's for future expansion for Maine Maritime Academy in the future. Lot 24 future expansion for Maine Maritime Academy also. We own lot 63 off Katahdin Street which would be future expansion for Stark Systems and we own the land behind, we own Line Drive the road which is behind Vivid Cloud in the land behind Vivid, Line Drive, over to Stark Systems, where we've been working on permitting three buildings for a business park there. We've also owned and permitted and built and sold to Bar Harbor Bank, their building that's at the property. Did the same thing with Dunkin' Donuts, owned that, permitted it, and built it, and sold it to Dunkin'. We own the Sunray Animal Clinic building for five years and sold it to Sunray. Assisted on the land that Evita is on helped and assisted them in permitting their project and sold them the land and we also owned lot 7 and lot 28 which is all of the apartments along Admiral Fitch that Jones Street owns now we own those permitted those and sold those to jones street and our company built them for them so we've done a lot of brunswick landing over the last 13 years environmental considerations well we follow all the guidelines from the navy and the dep in the town of brunswick on all environmental guidelines that are there if you're specifically talking about my famous dirt pile that's sitting out behind line drive which is which is soil 75% of that soil we brought in when we built a stark systems building. That's not soil That was already on site and got dug up 25% of it is the soil that got removed when we built stark systems building So the Navy doesn't allow us to move dirt around Brunswick Landing from property to property. So that soil needs to sit there covered, which is now loaned, and we have ceded it, which meets the DEP guidelines for letting it sit there, and we will flatten those piles out when we get our permits for the three buildings we want to build, and we will build buildings on top of them. But other than that, I just want to make a note, because often people ask about the environmental mental concerns. And I'm sure most of the people in the room are aware that in order for the Navy or MARA to sell us a property, the federal government has to have done a phase one and phase two on those properties. That's called a FOST, the finding of suitability for transfer. And they need to clean them up. So when we get a property and we get to buy a property, That property has been cleaned and cleared by the Navy and the DEP for us to build on. There are often very strict guidelines that we have to follow in order to build on properties, and some properties have more restrictions than others. [51:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. We're going to have Q&A when everybody's finished their updates, and then we'd definitely like to hear people's thoughts, and they would have to be at the podium. [51:41] Speaker G (unidentified): And the Navy is still testing properties, but they're not still testing properties that we've already purchased. There is property that they intend to sell in the future that they're doing testing on. And we'll assist them with any properties that we have that they think that they want to do additional testing on in the future. So just for anybody to know, I listed off a lot of stuff that we've done, things that we're doing. You know, anybody wants to reach out to us. We often hear through town staff that people have questions or comments about what we're doing. And we're pretty accessible to anybody that would like to come either call me on my cell phone 751-9998, email me at my email address, which is jhoward at priorityrealestategroup.com, or please walk into my office building on 2 Main Street in Thompson, just to the other side of the new bridge and visit with us, and we're happy to answer any questions at any time for anybody. [52:46] Speaker A (unidentified): And there will be time to ask more questions regarding this. I want to move on to Dan Stevenson, executive director of MRRA, Midcoast Regional. Thank you for being here and thanks for providing updates. [53:06] Speaker H (unidentified): I apologize. I did come in a couple minutes late. There is a number of things on this list, and in lieu of time, I'll move through those pretty quickly. I'm sure there will be questions as well. So let's start with the airport master plan update. There's been a lot of questions over that over the last several months, quite frankly. When is that going to happen? I will give you an update tonight. I also have Jim Nall here, the airport manager, is out there in case any airport questions come up this evening. We have a tentative meeting scheduled for 5.30 p.m., Thursday, November 19th, in town council chambers. It's tentative because we still have to make sure we can secure the room. We should have that done either tomorrow or no later than Monday. We will make sure we put it up on our website. We will make sure that the town city councilors also get that once we finalize that date. But right now, that's a Thursday, 19th of November. [54:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you just say quickly what the airport update process or master plan update is? [54:12] Speaker H (unidentified): So there were a number of chapters in that. The airport master plan is required by FAA periodically because the airport receives federal dollars. And we have a very low match at 2.5% on the state, 2.5%, so we can gain a significant amount of grant money to put into capital needs on the airport. And I'm going to tell you what one's coming up on another thing just in a moment. And with that, they have essentially oversight and final review authority because they're the ones requiring the plan. So after a few chapters were done each time, Representative Guy Rural from Du Bois and King was the company that was hired to complete the plan. These are the final two chapters. And the reason why it took so long to get to what we call the final public meeting is FAA had to approve one of the chapters, and they had to go back and forth a few times with that to get it to a point where it's not a final document, it's a final draft. That will be available to the town and on our website Monday of next week. So people that want to look at it and review it, they'll have two and a half to three weeks to do so before the meeting. The next item, property sales and transfers for development. LD 1637, I'm not going to go into the detail because of the time. There was a piece that was approved by the state legislature that said that properties owned by MIRA need to go through the Uniform Environmental Covenant Act. So all of our properties require covenants on them that they did not before. I will say a lot of what we're doing is required through the Navy process as well. When you heard Jim talk about that FOST earlier when they transfer. However, we still are working with the DEP. That's a lot of work to get done. So how do we get that work done? Because it goes through DEP. We've recently, over the summer months, hired a firm, St. Germain, and that's their first body of work that they're going to do on our behalf, working with Mira staff as well as DEP. We have a lot of properties to do, So bear what this is going to take time, but we're going to be working over the 2027 calendar year To get that done with respect to property transfers. We have a couple sales that are on our board meeting next week You can look them up It's you know, one of them's eight venture have and then we have another one's a former realm The former mess hall building they've been in the works for a very long time We're finally getting those to sale You can just the documents up everything's up on our website. You can go look at those, but what else do we have to transfer? Mira right now owns a proper approximately nine eight or nine, but I'll just say how about ten parcels many of them are small parcels We do not own any large parcels anymore for large development Mira is a redevelopment Authority and we also own some utilities Our goal is to sell those parcels for developers, such as Kevin Bunker and such as Jim Howard, so they can develop them, not us coming in as developers. But as Jim had mentioned earlier, as part of that process, those come with a FOST. So when we also have to sell at fair market value, we have to have appraisals done on the properties that we sell. Why do we do that? part of when Mira was created the Navy gets a 25% commission on property sales so we just can't run around making these side deals out there we have them appraised we have an arm's-length transaction and we make the sales appropriately that are approved by the Mira board any development that's done on those are subject all of the same regulatory environments and land use controls that are either through the town, through the DEP, through the EPA, and even the Navy. And the reason for that is many people in this room know the Navy has the responsibilities to monitor all the groundwater on campus. So the next item on the list is infrastructure and stormwater system upgrades. You heard about, what, one or two roads tonight and how difficult it is to do and how expensive it is to do. We own 26 miles of roads. It's very, expensive. It's very difficult. I've thought long and hard about how do we tackle this. I think most people in this room could say, hey, I can tell you, know, go down Admiral Fitch. Why don't you start there and then go to Orion? But it's a little more complex than that because of below-grade concerns with stormwater. so we have a couple of things happening we have had some recent camera work done as part of our stormwater management plan that is was recently approved this year for airport property then if anyone here is attended any of the RAB meetings the Navy has actually been doing a lot of camera work on some of the below grade drainage I don't have their reports yet but in order to get a lot of this work done requires partnerships not any one entity can come up with the funds to get that work done and my goal is to continue to work with the existing camera work we have for below grade continue to work with the navy prioritize what roads and draining systems we can do first have a phased approach at looking at those conditions try to find out where there are resources available to get those done i don't have a lot of information in front of me today day quite frankly that's very heavy lift we're going to continue to work on that moving forward with reese many of you in this room probably know we are not in the sewer business anymore that's been transferred out to the sewer district right now we meet monthly with the water district and we work to keep get our systems up to standards for them to take over which they agreed they will do that's not happening in the near future i can't give you a date or a timeline but I can tell you it's certainly more than two years but we meet with them regularly and make the upgrades as needed as we move as we move forward on that I think PFAS I'd like to jump right into PFAS discharge and abatement many people out there know that we with the EPA we have a consent agreement with them with a number of dates of what we would do since the release, the PFAS, the Triple F release on campus. Everyone clearly remembers that. But we were subject to a couple of things. One is working with the EPA, meeting what we need to do with them, as well as a representative of Ancalese drafted a bill, LD 407, which basically said you have to remove all the A Triple F you have on campus. That has been done. that has been well documented and it's been out in the press what is that state what does that mean it means you cannot have another release or spill like you witnessed in hangar four there's no there's no more a triple f out there however pfos as you're aware is now on the circle list so we are subject to either cleansing those systems in the hangars or replacing them. So why haven't we done that today? We needed to do due diligence. We were allowed to conduct that due diligence. We hired a company called ECT2 and they actually cut a section of pipe in one of our hangars so they could do some testing with some proprietary chemicals they have plus a separate one with just water. I know there are members of people in this room and maybe you online that, no, you can't clean the pipe. You're going to have the rebounding, and it's going to continue to come back. For us, just to cleanse Hangar 5 is a half a million dollars. That is not financially feasible as an alternative to do. So what does it cost to replace all the pipe? Millions of dollars. Because it's not just a matter of, say, replacing some oil-water separators, because you have piping in the ground. You're going to continuously get that rebounding, and those dollars either don't make it economically sound or feasible to do it. So with the information that we have today, we are working now with Filtrate. We think we have a plan for success that meets the intent of Representative Ankles, of what the federal government wants us to do as well as other members of the community that have concerns about that. We believe, and we're doing the due diligence now, if we put filtration systems for PFAS, four of our oil water separators, we can test when it's going in and we can test when it's coming out and we can keep those quarterly tests going. We still need to find out what is that going to cost MERA to get those installed and what's the timeline early indications are more than a half a million less than a million i don't have that but we're working on that diligently right now to try to find out what that would cost us to do that and then we would do ongoing monitoring and clearly the media that you used inside to filter out pfas that has to be replaced on a regular basis that's the plan we're doing now I've also discussed that with Representative Ankeles. He told me it was okay to state publicly that he's going to continue to work with me over this legislation and negotiate something that can work in conjunction with the direction we want to move with the EPA now on that. And then, oh, future events on Brunswick Landing. I will say, I can be really quick on this in light of time. the first one is the Blue Angels that would normally be scheduled to come in 2028 are now 2029 and the reason why we're looking at 2029 quite frankly is because the inboard runway is getting resurfaced in 2028 so it doesn't work even if that were something that were desired and there'll be more time to negotiate the contract with them to address some issues that have come to my attention with some member business members on campus the second and oh when I talked about the inward inbound runway getting surfaced I'm doing this because Jim sitting over there is that we receive quite a bit of money from FAA to get that done and that is on their list in that year something that you have heard and we're very excited for is a two to three two to three day music festival coming out on the campus. We work with a company called Tri-State Collaborative and they don't have a ground lease with us right now. They have an option on a ground lease. We really want adult suspenders on any kind of agreements we have out there. That was initially planned for this summer. That's been pushed out a year. It's being planned for the summer of 2028. We don't have a date on that yet because Tri-State Collaborative is still working to get an operator right now. As we have more details that come to us and an operator is involved, we will then make sure we have some kind of, at a minimum, a public process so people can come out, you can introduce who they are, and you can bring your concerns similar to a meeting like this. But we're just not ready for that at this time. Great. [1:06:35] Speaker A (unidentified): I wanted to get into Q&A and also want to ask for forgiveness to our staff if it's okay if we go a little beyond 7 o'clock if we're about 15 minutes behind here so I'd like to add 15 minutes to the clock if we can so we can have a good amount of time for Q&A. I appreciate everybody's updates, information, and I do want to say, as far as the future events on Brunswick Landing, or events going on in Brunswick Landing that become problematic as far as traffic goes, I know that the town is also conducting a few events on the landing as well, and that's voting, the one that's coming up most recently, November 3rd. we are now voting at the rec center and I know that causes some concerns around traffic and so I don't know I know Fran our clerk's not here but I know we've put signs up to get people directed so that they're on like Admiral Fitch Road and Orion and not cutting through the neighborhood but I Jay I wondered if you could speak quickly about plans for us to make sure that traffic is directed correctly during voting day? [1:07:51] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, so we do put signs up, directional signs, to lead people into Brunswick Landing via Admiral Fitch and then to the rec center. I'd also just add that absentee ballots is a real thing. You can do that through October 29th here at Town Hall. We have a significant portion of our voting population in Brunswick that votes via absentee. that's an option. So it isn't like all voters go to the rec center to vote in person. But yeah, I mean, we try to mitigate any problems with traffic that we can foresee and then deal with them as they're happening as well. But I would say that when we did it in the summer, which is a much smaller election, that seemed to work okay. We were able to work through some kinks in that, and I think we're good to go for November. I would say that if anybody has any [1:08:44] Speaker A (unidentified): thoughts about how we can do better in getting traffic directed please be in touch with me because it's a lived experience for you folks whereas we're just you know people who don't live on the landing don't understand completely what you might be seeing so I wanted to put that out there okay so now we have time for Q&A and so the way I'd like to work it is to start in the room and maybe go for 10 or 15 minutes with folks who are here. And so the deal is you've got to stand at the podium. You've got to be on camera, because we all want to hear you. And we want this to be on the record. And we want this to be dialogue. So if you're interested in speaking or asking questions, if you could line up behind the podium, that would be great. And then after about 15 minutes, I'm going to go to Zoom and get people on Zoom to ask their questions. If it's just a comment, if it's a question for anybody here, just direct it to whoever you like or if you think anybody can answer it that's fine if it's just you want to make comments i'm going to keep it to three minutes so we can have enough time and if there's more time at the end and you have more to say i might be able to fit in another round of your questions so let's start with that and then we'll we'll keep it going as we need so thank you very much hi my name is nicole tenney and i'm the vice president of [1:10:04] Speaker J (unidentified): of the Mariners Landing Condo Association board. Sorry, I'm nervous, I'm not a great public speaker. My point of being on the board for the past three years has been safety, has been number one. And I know Myna brought this up a little bit, but our issue in Mariners Landing are the abutting properties, which would be the DC apartments and the Jones Street apartments. We can find our own residents and hold them accountable, But I work very closely with both management companies and they are great with working with us. There just doesn't seem to be a lot of ramifications for those residents who are causing speeding on our neighborhood. They are causing parking issues at bus stop times, impeding traffic. We are not able to, we would not be able to get through an ambulance through Hornet Street if we wanted to in the morning and at night, in the evening. we have a lot of safety issues we have no help from the town no help from brunswick pd because we're private streets so i would like some answers at one point from the two apartment department buildings you know management companies we just have no help with this regarding the playground i know there was some discussion about the town donating a playground and thank you if that does happen we were just we were promised a bigger better new playground I've been here for eight years as a renter then as an owner and we have I don't have children myself I've seen families grow and there's no central meeting place I know that the playground will be going in but it's just really sad that it's taken this long when people have brought in, developers have brought in so many children to our community. So I'm just asking when you speak in the master HOA to keep it open, the meetings, to keep it open to listen to what the representatives from the HOAs are bringing to you. We have a lot of issues with the children having nothing better to do in our neighborhood, sometimes causing issues and vandalism. So I just wanted to bring that up. And we don't have any, we're not going to be building a playground on our property. We do not have the money for that, and we're looking into a minor modification for that. About the events coming into Brunswick Landing, we had a huge issue with the last, with the air show. People were cutting through from Harpswell. People could not get through our neighborhood. Again, if an emergency vehicle was trying to get through, they would not have been able to. Seconds count in emergency situations, and people couldn't leave their homes. So it's been a running joke that Brunswick Landing is like the Wild West, and it's lawless, and it really is. And it's very sad, and someone's going to get hurt. And I hope that you hear this today, because Mariners Landing has a lot of problems. I have seen kids almost get hit, pedestrians almost get hit, people running stop signs almost running over children, people walking their animals. We have a big problem. And I hope you all listen because something is going to happen. And I'm very passionate about it because I come from a field of EMS where I've seen a lot of bad things happen. And it will happen. [1:13:46] Speaker A (unidentified): I personally like the clapping. I just want people to consider it might be intimidating. This is nerve-racking to go up to the podium, so just keep that in mind, but I'd like to get a response quick before we get to the next question speaker, so Kevin, did you want [1:14:03] Speaker F (unidentified): to say something? Yeah, I can respond to that. A lot of good points, a lot of truth there. I think what we're dealing with here, and I alluded to it earlier, it's a little bit of the fruit of the poisonous tree here there were a lot of promises made and there was a lot of development and a lot of just i think i might have been the one that came up with the wild west thing i was certainly one of the early promulgators of that the you know there are there are two playgrounds again that were drawn and no one up here no one in this room was the one that promised those playgrounds would get rebuilt and one of them ended up on mariners landing land kind of by accident and one of them kind of end up on my land by accident and you just said we need a playground we haven't had a playground for eight years as supposed to be one on our land we don't have the money we're not going to build it so I am gonna build mine but there's I've also paid all my recreation fees of you know there's a there's a lot going on there that just because the way this whole project developed with not enough I's dotted and T's crossed when and it was happening that we're all dealing with now. And I don't think it's really any of the people who are here now that created most of these issues, where we are trying to solve them and we are taking responsibility. Because when I bought that land, I knew I was buying not only an opportunity to try to save some lives, which is why I did it, but I knew I was buying a lot of problems with it because of the way it had been done. And so I'm trying to fix them, but I'm also So trying to not hold people accountable, because it's not my job to hold people accountable, but try to widen that conversation to say, look, this is, if you look at this from a planning perspective, a 30,000 foot level as an outsider coming in, the future of this area is it is going to be incorporated in the town of Brunswick. And I think the town, not the people that are here now, but the previous administration certainly, I think had their head in the sand quite a bit and was just kind of hoping it would go away and not take the tax revenue but not take any of the responsibility and sooner you've heard a lot of numbers getting thrown around half a million a million 300 this and that sooner or later those costs are going to have to be paid by someone and the reason that governments exist is to provide common and public goods that individual citizens can't and we're in this in-between spot now where brunswick landing and the homeowners association and others and mira are carrying the load for all these things that frankly the rest of the town benefits from whether it be directly in terms of driving on neptune or the other roads or indirectly in terms of the tax revenue so it's a big it's a lot of development and in some ways a big success story but it's also kind of a big mess and we have to retroactively try to rip out the messes and fix it and I'm responsible for some of them to try to help fix them because they're on my land but there's a lot more going on than just you know bad developers not building playgrounds [1:17:03] Speaker G (unidentified): great Jim and then Nat I thought that the maybe Chief Stewart can [1:17:12] Speaker A (unidentified): actually Chief Stewart if you don't mind coming up and maybe making a few comment about this just go Bruins Chief go Bruins Yes, please. [1:17:22] Speaker G (unidentified): I thought that the legislature passed a law that said that you could police Brunswick Landing, and that you had the right to do that, even though that it was private. [1:17:34] Speaker I (unidentified): So the roads owned by Mera, yes, we can enforce that. [1:17:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Only the roads owned by Mera, so not the neighborhoods. [1:17:40] Speaker I (unidentified): No, and also the speed limits on Mera property can only be posted by Maine Department of Transportation. Okay. All right. So just because it sounds great to drop it to 15, it has to be done through the state. What about private roads? We can't enforce private road speeds. [1:17:58] Speaker A (unidentified): But do private roads, can they make their own speed limit? [1:18:02] Speaker I (unidentified): They can. Okay. But they can't be enforced. They can't be enforced. But he can't enforce that. Right. Okay. [1:18:07] Speaker A (unidentified): And so if there is a, I mean, obviously the fire, and if there is an emergency, obviously, all emergency personnel, they're responsible for addressing emergencies on Brunswick Landing. Correct. It's the speeding, specifically, that you cannot enforce anything on private roads. Correct. Okay. That's not owned by a mayor. Okay. [1:18:31] Speaker G (unidentified): As a commercial developer out there, even though your issues are more residential, we're with you on these issues. The town needs to put a plan together to take over your private roads as well as Mara's private roads 13 years ago They told us they'd probably get this done in three years right with 13 years later Every property owner at Brunswick Landing pays in a road maintenance fee We paid in almost a hundred and fifty thousand dollars last year for the properties We own to help Dan maintain the roads that are there and they he does the best he can with the budget that he has but those roads need to be turned over to the town and it should really start with Neptune which is just heavily used by the public so thanks [1:19:15] Speaker E (unidentified): chief thanks and then Nat you said you wanted yeah so I think Kevin made a very good point of we inherited a little bit of a mess and really we're trying to make the best of it I know the issue with the playground that was brought up so just from a master HOA perspective once the playground is built we are required to maintain it but we aren't involved with the development of it so we've been coordinating with Kevin and group and we're we're getting there and we've also heard your concerns I know mine has brought it up with the safety concerns and we've tried to find solutions we've reached out to the town with the Jersey barriers we've put in speed bumps, and we are making proactive steps to meet everyone's needs and asks. [1:20:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, so would Nat, would you be, would the Master HOA be willing to do a walkabout with some of the residents to say they can show you specifically what concerns they have and maybe if there's ideas around increasing safety on these roads? [1:20:28] Speaker C (unidentified): We're more than willing to do speed bumps in Mariner's Landing, but I believe that they didn't want us to. [1:20:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah,, I'm sorry. Actually, yeah, go ahead. That's good. Yeah. [1:20:41] Speaker J (unidentified): We've discussed speed bumps, and, you know, a lot of people, they would be great for traffic calming, but also I met with Jim Flood years ago, and he said it would be bad. People are going to complain because there's going to be too much noise. We just like there's a there's a lot of reasons that people are some people are for him Some people are against them. My issue is that we are a private community a hub of all of the all of these man, all these like I'm so sorry all of these rentals and There's no ramifications for your renters coming through our private association where we own our roads when they're coming through and I call your management teams and they're great, but they're like, we don't have anything in our leases. We can't find them, we can't do anything. So, where are we with that? We can find our own people, and we do all the time. We're extremely strict in our, we would be a gated community if we could be, but we're not. So, I'm asking the two of you, where are we gonna go from here? You know, we've had so many issues with this, And especially as development has started, it's like people just don't understand that they cannot do the things they're doing within our neighborhood. And like I said, something will happen. And then we're going to be back here and we're gonna be like, why didn't we do anything then? It will. I don't want it to, but I see near misses almost daily and it's your residents. I want to say 90% of the time. [1:22:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Okay, so I wanna keep moving on questions, but I wanna make sure that we put a pin on that. There's a connection between the renter community and Mariners Landing and safety. So, Paul, go ahead. [1:22:33] Speaker K (unidentified): Hi, my name's Paul Whitcomb, I'm from Brunswick. Which of you is the representative from Midcoast Redevelopment? Oh, okay, thank you. Would Mr. Howard earlier suggest tested that the Navy has already completed phase two for all of the existing buildings on Brunswick Landing. Have you provided those test results to Brunswick United for a safe environment? [1:23:05] Speaker H (unidentified): What I can say is we want to be a little careful with some of the terminology. When you hear phase one and phase two, you typically hear about those where you have Brownfields properties. properties. What they're talking about here is Navy tests on what they call an EDC, which could be multiple properties. So what the Navy does is conduct all this testing over periods of time. That's public record. And whenever they transfer that property to us, they transfer it with something of a finding of suitability of transfer. That's called the FOSS. Those are public documents. If you need copies of those, we can get those to [1:23:40] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay, yeah, I would like the FOSS, particularly the readings of PFAS, the two types of PFAS, PFOS and PFOA, those two specific types. I would like those readings for every building on Brunswick Landing. I would like those results. I would like to speak primarily to the residents of Brunswick Landing, and keep this first quote in mind. Although the EPA defines the limit of PFAS in drinking water as four parts per trillion, It also establishes that there is no safe level of exposure. The two main types of, the worst types of PFAS is PFOS, which has a longer name, and PFOA. PFOS consisted of 77% of the measured compounds in the 2024 release. lease. You deserve to know what's underneath your building and on the grass around you. There has been no hydrology map that I have been able to find that no hydrology map of Brunswick Landing. That's a problem because without that knowledge, We don't know how far that the contamination has spread. The Navy is still testing, but, again, there is no safe exposure level to that. Thirty-five private wells were tested initially by the DEP. We don't know if testing is continuing. I don't and at which levels and I'd like to know if fish, bird and tissue tests are still being conducted. The only ones I think that are testing at this point for those type of tests is the Friends of Merry Meeting Bay and the Friends of Casco Bay. [1:26:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Paul, Dan said he had a response to one of your points, so we want to fit that in as well. [1:26:09] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, go. The one request is still a little unclear to me that you want. What I would request that you do is you can send me an e-mail, I'll leave my card here about specifically what you want because the amount of time, energy and data you're asking for us to get with my staff, I prefer it come through a FOIA request. Because it's not clear when you say PFAS testing, is it groundwater, is it buildings, is it I want all of it, sir. I'd like to finish my answer, please. Because it's not that easy. When we are in compliance... [1:26:47] Speaker K (unidentified): Those documents should be in existence already. [1:26:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Please don't interrupt if you want him to finish what he's saying. [1:26:57] Speaker H (unidentified): The Navy, DEP, and EPA don't just mandate testing. It would be like going to every house in this community and every commercial building in the town. You're making an assumption that P4 and PFAS is now on the circle list that every single building and property has some level of testing to it. What I can tell you is if you send us a request through Forrest specifically what you're looking for, we can hone down and get you that information. Just to say I want everything is not helpful to me at this point, especially this evening. I'd be more than willing to make a meeting with you outside of this meeting and talk and go through all that information as well, if that's helpful. [1:27:42] Speaker A (unidentified): And can you finish up your statement and then I need to move on to our Zoom. We'll have people behind you, but also get on to Zoom questions. [1:27:51] Speaker K (unidentified): I want those documents. I will be in touch. We have to hold them to this. this. We cannot let them get away with this. June 23, inspection. Eastern Fire of Auburn inspected hangar number 4 fire suppression systems and identified several dangerous problems requiring immediate attention, which the MRRA did not address due to the high cost. June 2024, warning email, Barry Prescott of Eastern Fire in Auburn, inspections manager, sent an email to Eric Perkins. [1:28:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Mr. Wickham, you've got to finish up because I want to get to other questions. [1:28:43] Speaker H (unidentified): I need to respond to fire safety, please. please. In our hangars right now, the fire safety plan that we have in place with the fire suppression systems we have now are approved by the state fire marshal's office and the town of Brunswick fire chief. I want to be clear about that. Thank you. [1:29:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. I'd like to move in. You guys, you'll get your turn, but I want to get into zoom. So hang there. If anybody on zoom is interested in asking a question raise your hand I see Ella Tabaski to speak so can bring Ella on please hi [1:29:23] Speaker L (unidentified): there can you hear me yeah we can hear you yeah okay excellent thank you everyone for thank you a council member for hosting this and thank you to everyone for being present I do have a question regarding the master HOA and transparency issues, I attend the majority of my HOA board meetings. I'm a resident of Mariner's Landing, and what's being reported to me at those meetings is that there's only one HOA board member for Mariner's Landing allowed to be present at the master HOA meeting. There's apparently no, I don't know, secretary or leadership right now to take minutes and circulate them to our HOAs. And I would like to know why this is acceptable and what can be done to make sure that there is increased transparency into the decision making that's happening at the master. [1:30:30] Speaker E (unidentified): Nat? Sure. I'll address that. [1:30:33] Speaker A (unidentified): And then speak a little closer to your mic so she can hear you. Yes. [1:30:37] Speaker E (unidentified): Excuse me. So we've got Myna taking the meeting minute notes. And just want to quickly walk through the structure of the master HOA. So it's set up a little bit different than your traditional condo HOA association. So we're essentially bound by the recorded declaration and all the bylaws. So within Declaration 9.3D, each sub-association seats a director, and the director's job is to keep everyone's voices in their own sub-community and relay that message back to the master HOA. So this is just the setup of this association, which, again, is a little bit different from what most people are used to see. [1:31:26] Speaker M (unidentified): So [1:31:29] Speaker A (unidentified): are you saying that people who are not on the board aren't really able to be in those meetings to listen in? [1:31:40] Speaker E (unidentified): Correct. That's how it's set up. And the sub-association, everyone has their own director. They go to the master HOA meetings, but they voice the concerns and other thoughts of everyone within their sub-association to us during those meetings. [1:31:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Ella, did that answer the question, or did you have any? [1:32:03] Speaker L (unidentified): I see your hand up. It certainly doesn't answer the question about the minutes and what's being circulated. My understanding, though, please feel free to correct this, is taking them her own minutes, but she is not the secretary, nor are they circulated to anyone. So you're saying, I guess, that as a master, you're not required to do that. It's the responsibility of every individual board representative to do that to their residents [1:32:32] Speaker E (unidentified): No, we can certainly you know get those two apologies for that but we are taking me to meeting notes and they're available upon requests and Thank you for your concern. Well, we'll make it right so Nicole [1:32:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Nichols you're on are you on the master? Are you represent? You're gonna be president of Mariners Oh, we'll see. Oh, okay. [1:32:59] Speaker J (unidentified): But so Myna does take the minutes for our association. And I'm pretty sure they should be on our portal. And she does a good job reporting back to us. I'm not sure what happens with the other associations. But there are issues with transparency. There are a lot of people that would like to know more. As the vice president, I can't even go to those meetings. So unless Myna doesn't go. So, you know, there are a lot of people who are very upset that we're paying into a master HOA, and they're not able to Zoom in. [1:33:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Heard. Heard. Okay. Thank you. I'm going to do one more Zoom, and then I'll do another in-person comment. I saw BA. My screen's dark, but I think someone named BA has got their hand up. [1:33:46] Speaker N (unidentified): Yes, that's me. Hi. Thank you for this meeting, and thank you for letting us attend by Zoom. I have I live on Neptune and I do have a lot of concerns about the town taking over the road I lived here before you put up this temporary speed bumps and it was incredibly dangerous and busy and I would like to know if you do have in discussions with the town what is the plan to keep Neptune from returning to that problem it was the volume the speeding it's now a nice neighborhood people walk that wasn't a possibility so I'd like to make sure that you know it doesn't just turn into okay now it's a town road anyone can go on it 's now a viable cut through and here we go hmm [1:34:31] Speaker A (unidentified): who's who can respond to that maybe Brian did I feel like in [1:34:37] Speaker C (unidentified): the discussions we will talk about speed tables at that point and keep that same sort of speed calming that we have currently and push it forward. [1:34:48] Speaker A (unidentified): One thing that needs to be thought of is that if Neptune is a town road, then it's a town road and that there will be, I mean, people are driving on it now. I know they're already using it. It's hard to know if they're going to have increased volume once it becomes more open and connected to other town roads. It is kind of the other side or there's a cost of- It can be policed. It can be policed and that's right. So, okay [1:35:15] Speaker N (unidentified): However, police aren't there 24-7 right? Right, but we have we have other tools [1:35:21] Speaker A (unidentified): We have speed signs than in the town. I live on a [1:35:24] Speaker N (unidentified): Mean nothing. I would say that the speed tables the temporary speed bumps have been incredibly effective I love them. Okay, I'm hoping something similar comes into play and then the other quick question I have is how would I get a copy? as a homeowner of the declarations, because I have never been able to find them. [Speaker A (unidentified): The homeowner declarations?] The declarations and covenants. They're available. [1:35:52] Speaker C (unidentified): They should be available on Appfolio with your portal link. [1:35:59] Speaker B (unidentified): What is she asking, though? For Mariner's Landing or the master's? I would assume master's. The master's declaration is, you know, go ahead. [1:36:06] Speaker N (unidentified): I'm looking for the master, because I'm not in a condo. I'm in a home. Okay. [1:36:11] Speaker A (unidentified): So be in touch. Should she be in touch with you Brian? Yes. Okay be in touch be in touch with Brian Benfield at Forsyth And I yeah and just be in touch if you can't find it I can I have all their contact information everybody so get in touch with me if you can get in touch just as a [1:36:29] Speaker F (unidentified): Public service announcement. I'm guessing if you all had title work done on your houses in your deed There'll be a reference to book and page and those documents are filed public information at the registry of deeds so you all in theory should have seen that stuff when you bought your house doesn't mean you did doesn't mean you looked at it if you saw it but it should be in your deed the book and page that is located on yeah I did some research online and at [1:36:56] Speaker N (unidentified): least with my abilities I could not I could get to the register of deeds but not to the deed well you get to some amendments but not you have to go you'll [1:37:07] Speaker A (unidentified): You'll have to go up, John, just very quick, if you needed to say real quick, but I want to get to the next question. [1:37:12] Speaker B (unidentified): I found the original and the two amended declarations in the Cumberland County records, and I have them digitally. I will pass them to Brian, who then, in turn, can put them on their portal, perhaps for [1:37:25] Speaker C (unidentified): other people. They're actually shared. I can see the master declaration. I haven't clicked on it, but it's available to the owners. Under Governing Documents in AppFolio. [1:37:39] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. I'm ready for an in-person question. If you want to share your name, that would be fine, but it's up to you. [1:37:46] Speaker O (unidentified): I'm Kristen Wallenberg. I am a resident at Woodland Village South. I currently am the secretary of the board. Also just took over John's treasury duties on the board as well. So I appreciate, Ella, your question because that was one of the questions that I was going to have. So I just want to reiterate that Mariner's Landing's representative is also Woodland Village South's representative, also Woodland Village's representative. So we all don't individually are not allowed. When John left, he was the representative, Mariner's Landing took over, and we don't have access. [1:38:26] Speaker P (unidentified): I am. You are? Woodland Village. I am now. Okay. My first meeting will be Monday. [1:38:31] Speaker O (unidentified): Okay. Okay, well, that's news to me. So that brings up my second question, communication. So we all pay in to the Master HOA. There's a fiduciary responsibility to all of us to communicate with us. Our president of our association, Tina Baker, she has emailed Brian multiple times. She has asked our other four-side representative multiple times to get a budget not a yearly budget We're talking about monthly expenditures. What are you spending our money on because we're not seeing things being done in our neighborhoods That should be done. And so there's a fiduciary Responsibility that I just want to state publicly that we have been trying to get this information We've been tried to get the meeting minutes and we have not been responded to so That's really important if we want to reign in this wild west, then communication is important and the master HOA needs to be communicating to the individual developments. Second, another point to the town, it seems like the town's giving permits to all of these development companies, commercial real estate companies, to increase development and commercial footprint on Brunswick Landing. But what is the plan for the traffic implications that this is now going to create for all of us that live there that pay taxes and are trying to make this our home we have additional houses going in it just seems like the town has not only a responsibility to take over the road the town also has a responsibility when providing these permits and allowing these things to be built to also look at the consequences of what this is going to have for the entire landing so i just wanted to make sure that was said publicly thank you thank you i can i can address a little [1:40:34] Speaker F (unidentified): bit of that i happen to know a little bit about that so the when the certainly when the brunswick landing subdivision that i'm part of was approved there's what's called a traffic movement permit which was had to come from the state so all the when something is approved at the planning board traffic is one of the criteria that you'll see if you look that the town has to look at so it was prospectively looked at what the traffic impact would be you can't get an approval for a property really anywhere without assessing what that traffic might be and trying to account for it in your development whether it's putting in a stoplight or an extra lane or different things building sidewalks whatever that is that's typically thought about whether it's done properly right or wrong it's typically part of an approval and i'm not to defend the association I'm a member of the association, and I get to go to the meetings, and believe me, there's nothing nefarious taking place there. I get to vote, and it's outperformed my expectations, because when I bought the land, I knew that Jones Street controlled the association, and they didn't have to let any of us join the board. they could have just frankly if they wanted to be evil developers they could not listen to any of us and still charge us money and we'd have to pay it that's the way those documents are drawn up they're drawn up very unfavorably to everybody in this room except those guys as a condition of the sale they negotiated that and it's it's amazing the power that they have but they have not exercised that in a bad way they've they've let us all come on they've listened to us they listen to John. They listen to me. They listen to Mina. And it really runs as if we all had power and impact that we technically, legally do not have. So I appreciate that there's all these homeowners that don't get to come to the meetings and don't know what's going on and aren't. But I can just say from what I've seen is that they are trying to be community members and trying to be collaborative. And there's a lot of issues. I'm not saying there aren't, but I think they've done a really good job of including us when they haven't necessarily had to do that if they didn't want to. So that's all. I just wanted to say that. [1:42:48] Speaker C (unidentified): And we were just talking. We will put that on the agenda for Monday and talk about the disclosure of the financials, the monthly financials. And I mean, it's obviously going to be up to Jones Street, but it is on the agenda for Monday now. [1:43:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Okay. And, you know, again, this is not the end of the conversation. And I'm hoping that we can have these open,, you know, discussions in the future. I'll take another comment from in person, and then maybe jump back on zoom. Thank you. My name is Ralph keys. I'm a resident [1:43:20] Speaker Q (unidentified): of Brunswick, not on Brunswick landing, but I live to the west of it. I'm a neighbor to the west. And I had a number of comments. But in the interest of time, I'll be very brief. The landing redevelopment has been characterized as a mess, and we've talked a lot about the dangers of traffic and miles per hour. The real insidious problem here is parts per trillion, and I'm talking about PFAS and the other CERCLA Superfund substances that may be infiltrating our water and our soil. Very quickly, I visited a veterinarian with our kittens last year and asked about, do you see any evidence of harm in the animals in Brunswick? and their response was our radiologist can't believe the amount of kidney cancer we find in our pets and i watch you folks walking your dogs out there should be signage there should be public health advisories that there may be a problem with this stuff we don't know it for sure and i'll leave it at that it's not a question it's just a comment thank you for hosting this [1:44:18] Speaker A (unidentified): meeting and through your attention and i want to point out also that we do have members of Brunswick, so Ralph's part of Brunswick United for Safe Environment, and I know that they have occasional meetings, certainly good communication, so I encourage people in this room and on Zoom to plug in, and I can help people plug into that organization. There's also, I mean, one thing that's really important is that landowners understand the land use controls that are, if you are living on Brunswick Landing, and there's paperwork, where there's some information as you walk out on the table over there and that everybody should understand the limitations of, because groundwater shall not be touched on the landing, that if there is any construction or any sort of, I mean, it can be touched, but it needs to be treated because it's assumed that it's always, as you know, is always contaminated. contaminated. So there's procedures that need to be understood by landowners. And there's concern that a lot of, you know, property people who live in those properties don't understand or don't know about that. And we want to make sure more people know. And so we can make that connection too. So please reach out to me and I can take some paperwork, but also I can connect you to the backseat in Brunswick United. So, sir, I'll take your call. Yep. [1:45:48] Speaker R (unidentified): and then i'll jump back to zoom after you everyone thanks very much for hosting this my name's fahim guadri my wife and i nancy live on intrepid street and i think this question may be directed to kevin we're in the white house right on number 19 beside the utility shack and now with the development the new road at saratoga i guess the question is when we look back at the original plans it implies a road now coming onto Intrepid Street from Saratoga and my question is that going to happen and if so you know is there something you can do to protect our home from having cars driving toward our home on that you know with respect to the road design yeah so nothing is final because [1:46:42] Speaker F (unidentified): i guess approved plans can always be changed but what i'm doing is i'm buying a set of approved plans and permits that were issued in like 2022 and again that was part of a big planning process i guess somewhat robust in determining where all the roads should be and should not be for traffic flow and other things so i don't have the latitude right now as it stands to not build that road if i want to build the development i have to build that road now do i think it's strictly needed for what i want to do probably not do i know if the town would let me eliminate it and not build it i don't know that either i don't i don't i don't know the traffic analysis that went into the original design of the larger area well enough to know whether that is something that's feasible i'm happy to look at that but right now what that's what has to be built if something is going to be [1:47:32] Speaker R (unidentified): be built and i guess with that kevin i appreciate the answer if the road is going to happen are you able to explore realigning it so that it isn't you know direct headlights into our living room and in bedroom so it's really in the spirit of trying to protect you know what we thought we bought type thing yeah i mean there's a little if i think i know what area you're talking [1:48:00] Speaker F (unidentified): about and there's a little right away right i don't know how many how many degrees that little piece of road could be moved to prevent that i just don't know how possible that is to be honest [1:48:12] Speaker A (unidentified): with you could there be barriers like trees or things to block intrusion are you 're you're [1:48:21] Speaker F (unidentified): across the street from where the road will dump out exactly so they would have to be on his property then if they were going to be trees or a fence or whatever yeah maybe [1:48:32] Speaker A (unidentified): we could work something out so you're open to this being an ongoing conversation with butters yeah on a regular basis as you're going through the process plus a lot of things maybe Julie you can explain a little bit about what would be next for the Saratoga project I mean there's some permits there's some approvals that still need to happen from the town I think there [1:48:57] Speaker S (unidentified): might be some permit transfers that need to happen for the project and I think they're just one condition of approval for financial capacity I think the rest of the conditions of approval for the project were met so if there are any changes that the developer wants to make to the approved plans those would have to go through the proper channels whether they be minor modifications or if they're larger and neat planning board review does [1:49:26] Speaker A (unidentified): the tree ordinance that we passed last year have any bearing on [1:49:31] Speaker S (unidentified): this project no it would only be the ordinance that we had in effect when the project was [1:49:37] Speaker A (unidentified): approved in 22. but i've already talked to kevin and he's we've talked about the possibility of adding some more trees to the plan or some flexibility to create a little bit more of a greener space so it's not just a bunch of boxes that don't have anything going on beyond that. [1:49:57] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I did send the plan to my landscape architect after the meeting and he hasn't had a chance to look at it yet and there are limited, if you've seen the plans right over there on the table, there are limited opportunities to put lots and lots of trees back in but there are some And we're happy to, even though there aren't trees on, there's six little trees around the end of the hammerhead there. And that's all that's on the plan. But we're happy to build more, to plant more where we can fit on there. [1:50:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Larry, I can't see the screen. So has anybody else raising their hand on Zoom? Okay. Did you have another question? Because there's someone behind you. I want to make sure I got their question as well. That's fine. [1:50:36] Speaker R (unidentified): What I'm hearing is, Kevin, you're open to connecting on this topic. [1:50:39] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, it'd be good to get your contact info so we can talk directly about that. It's not imminent that I'm going to build this road, so we have some time, but I don't want to lose track of it either. Sounds good. [1:50:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks very much. Great. I'll take another question on [1:50:57] Speaker T (unidentified): the podium. Hi, my name is Raquel Gibson. I live on Neptune. So I have a few brief questions. First, for the Master HOA, is there a published asset management program or capital improvement plan somewhere, or at least a printed one somewhere? [1:51:20] Speaker E (unidentified): We would have to check that and see what the documents say. As far as an asset management plan, I'm not quite sure what you're referring to there. We have the budget. [1:51:34] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah, it would be something that lists what assets the HOA is actually responsible for maintaining and sort of what the renewal periods are for those assets, how long they're supposed to last, what condition they're in, that kind of thing. [1:51:50] Speaker E (unidentified): That would be in the covenants and documents that they're in the folder that Brian mentioned. [1:51:56] Speaker T (unidentified): Okay. So nothing that's maintained on a regular basis and the asset management plan would just take that and update it regularly yeah i would have to check i mean asset management is [1:52:09] Speaker E (unidentified): a day-to-day type of thing so yeah let me let me check on that as an association member what [1:52:19] Speaker F (unidentified): i've seen is that there's certainly in the covenants it talks about all the all the things that the association is tasked with maintaining you know in text and then every year when the budget comes up, there is some discussion about, hey, this needs to get done this year, so let's put in some money for this. But to your point, what I haven't seen is sort of a 20-year depreciation schedule of that. I don't think that exists. Okay. [1:52:44] Speaker T (unidentified): Second question for the HOA. Is it possible to put the master HOA minutes in Appfolio? I'll let you think about that. You don't have to actually answer. [1:52:55] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't need to think about it, absolutely. You can. It would be up to them whether or not we do that. And that and that just went on the agenda for Monday. So I think in that same discussion, it would make sense to discuss to talk about the financials as well and whether or not that could be put up there. And you have Justin behind you who advocate for that at that meeting. [1:53:14] Speaker E (unidentified): OK, perfect. Yeah. And I just want to make it clear, like, you know, I grew up from Boston to meet with everyone. That's important to me. It's important to Jones Street. To Kevin's point, like we don't have to do all these things, but we want to we want to make the community better. we want to work with you guys so I just want to make that very clear like requests and different things that the community has wanted we have tried our best to adhere to that and to hear everyone's thoughts and issues so we're committed to working with the community going forward I just [1:53:47] Speaker T (unidentified): really want to make that clear I think we understand the next set of duo of questions are kind of together is there anywhere online where the plans are available for phase three specifically saratoga but also even like phase two i'm guessing there the town has [1:54:10] Speaker F (unidentified): them i've you know i haven't been able to find them on the time i have to scroll back to like [1:54:15] Speaker S (unidentified): march of 2022 yeah the only place they would be located would be in the planning board packet at that meeting that they were approved could we have certainly yeah could we create a section on [1:54:25] Speaker A (unidentified): the town planning another job but if you maybe some of the pertinent yeah for the brunswick landing project that would be pretty great [1:54:37] Speaker T (unidentified): and then associated with finding those plans what is sort of your vision of how saratoga road's going to get constructed i know you're just now cleaning out the land are you intending to like you know cruise through it and build the road and go straight into building houses is this going to be sort of a longer process that you're [1:54:59] Speaker F (unidentified): envisioning or once it starts and i don't have a start date but once it starts hopefully sooner rather than later would build the road all at once and then construct and sell about six houses at a time six seven houses at a time probably three or four tranches of houses that's the that's the [1:55:16] Speaker T (unidentified): goal the business plan right now is there like a time frame associated with it or i would love to [1:55:22] Speaker F (unidentified): to start working on the infrastructure this winter, but there's a lot of issues I have to figure out between now and then. And if you talk to any developer, when they want to start and when they start are often two different things. I'm gonna do my best to do it as quick as I possibly can. I suspect it'll take longer than I want. [1:55:40] Speaker T (unidentified): No offense, but great. [1:55:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Fair. All right, thank you. And this won't be the last time we'll have Kevin talking to the community about what's going on. Just FYI. All right, Justin. [1:55:53] Speaker P (unidentified): My name is Justin Boggs, and I am the president of the Woodland Village Association, which is off of Neptune. So I have a really short question. People got through most of the stuff I wanted to ask, but mine actually, she kind of teed it up. It's going to be a little while before all of that gets developed. And I walked the site last night, I think, while we were out walking our dog to see what was going on and i saw all of the silt stuff silt fence and everything that's gone in it looks really good there's still a lot of open dirt there and there's an open culvert that's kind of part of that creek bed that has been exposed with everything is there a plan to bind the soil hydro seed anything like that to keep some migration from happening it's going gonna happen even with all that silt stuff it'll happen if it isn't stopped at kind of the source and then we'll get fugitive dust next summer because it'll all dry up and blow around and [1:56:57] Speaker F (unidentified): yeah there's an and i kevin clark hasn't got to talk yet he's from sight lines and i brought him here in case there were engineering questions that i didn't want to misspeak on and say something wrong at a public meeting so he can correct me if i'm wrong i 'm generally confident in the answer and that is that there's a winter construction stabilization for erosion sedimentation control that we have to do and it involves hay which couldn't go down today because it was too windy but another one of the options is to use the basically the chewed up mulch as the medium so one of those two things yes is part of the part of the requirements to stabilize the site [1:57:37] Speaker P (unidentified): okay yeah it just seemed there was a plan I saw some of the stuff last night but the whole sequence wasn't a part of it so I think I generally have that [1:57:46] Speaker F (unidentified): right Kevin okay thank you one word I got you for one word yeah you can yeah [1:57:58] Speaker A (unidentified): let me sit right next to him and just introduce yourself Kevin the other Kevin [1:58:03] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, the other. I'm always the other Kevin. Kevin Clark from Sightlines. And yeah, there is a road control plan for winter stabilization. And there's also third party inspectors, and that's Flycatcher, which they're an environmental firm. and so they've been out to the site reviewed it and Take it into consideration all of their recommendations in addition to what the plan was So it's not going unmonitored [1:58:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Jim at all, okay, you're right next to me and I don't see you when you're putting your finger or you okay. All right [1:58:50] Speaker U (unidentified): Take the next question. My name is Peggy Siegel I live at the Sandpiper on the landing. I was interested, Jim Howard, in your comments about the soil piles and the 75%, 25% figures. I also, when I moved into the Sandpiper, it was about the time that the apartments along Admiral Harry Rich were being constructed right across from my windows. And it's great that you're here tonight to be able to answer any questions from Jones Capital, because I have some questions about that. I watched it every day. And I'm interested with all of the future development that Jim, Howard, you've talked about, and certainly Kevin Bunker has also talked about, what was the process with moving the soil. I watched it out my window being excavated and I watched that soil being moved. What was the process? You had left the soil piles on your property. I'm interested, I watched the soil being moved when Jones Street capital residences were building those apartments along Admiral Harry Bridge. So I was curious about that process. [2:00:32] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll refer back to the FOST and our deeds, which are our environmental guidelines when we develop a property. There are no two properties out there that probably have the exact same environmental guidelines put on them. Some of the lots you can move the dirt and do whatever you want on them. some of the lots you can't some you can build housing on some you can't so you really have to be specific to a lot read the faust for that specific property and then that will guide you as to what you can and can't do with the dirt so you could see some lots pile it up and move it some lots in the in with like with stark we're not allowed to take it off the property so we need to reuse it on the property if you go over to flight deck they have a big berm now around their parking lot when they put in their EV charges they couldn't take the dirt off their lot so they had to do something with it so it became a berm around their parking lot so that knows there's there's no generic answer for what goes on we really have to look at each property and then that's what [2:01:35] Speaker U (unidentified): you're doing with those ten that you mentioned correct looking at each one individually yes because I was interested in Ralph keys comment about people walking their dogs we see people walking their dogs and probably getting into water and getting into soil and people don't know that might be dangerous for their dogs and I just wondered about that about this the excavation and the excavated soil. Yep. [2:02:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I have attended several RABs. I've been in conversation with a lot of the Brunswick United folks and the FACSI, and signage does come up every time about just awareness. We want to make sure, there's a real push to make sure residents, users of Brunswick Landing are aware of, know the ponds the you know just the unknowns and i've been thinking about what ways the town plays a role in maybe creating signage or mirror we need to figure out if we came up with a plan to put up some more to put up some signage around this so people have more information right now there's really nothing there's no information about the status or the history of the property so people can be informed. So I would like more of that and figure out who, a lot of times it's, is it the Navy, is it Mira, is it DEP, is it the town? That's where it gets a little tricky and I wanna get to the bottom of that and figure out who's responsible for making, town's ultimately responsible, make sure people in town are safe. Seeing no one else at the podium, I'm gonna and I thank you for staying longer than it was scheduled But I wanted these questions to can you know to have people have chance to ask the questions I did say on the agenda. I wanted to talk about next steps and that's true the obvious next steps are Mayor is having their next board meeting on the 28th and that is open to the public it is at [2:03:54] Speaker H (unidentified): It's in the classroom at tech place that was rehabilitated over the last year. It can hold as many people right now that's in this room. And we've got some new technology in there. We've tested once. You can do Zoom? [2:04:08] Speaker A (unidentified): We're testing it again. Yes, we can. So that's on your website? [2:04:14] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, the packet and the agenda just went up today. Okay. And what time? 4 p.m. Okay. So that's on your website? And there's ample parking outside of Tech Place. And if we need to draw a little map up for someone, we'll gladly just let me know. [2:04:27] Speaker A (unidentified): And there's public comment, opportunity for public comment or questions? Yes. [2:04:32] Speaker H (unidentified): The way Mirrors run its boards, you know, for a long time before I even ever showed up, was that there is an opportunity at the end for public comment. Okay. [2:04:45] Speaker A (unidentified): And then Master HOA is having their next board meeting on Monday, and it sounds like there's going to be a couple extra steps taken to make sure the minutes are available, and maybe there's a few questions that follow up answers to some of the questions. I'm happy to be a hub or a portal for that information. I think we have a sign-up sheet that went around, so I would have your contact information, And my plan is to have a follow-up, you know email to everybody after this meeting So I think there were a few questions about where some of these documents are located and making sure that maybe there's good communication flow and maybe if there's some if you have some suggestions on becoming more efficient with your communication that would be helpful and then Saratoga as Kevin if you are willing as I mean I when there's things that the council has to or the planning board has to approve we obviously there's information public notice about that but I'd say if there's any information that you want a butters to know I'm happy to be that I would like to hear so in an ideal world I would have liked to have heard from you before you took your trees down we don't require that we don't as a town we don't we didn't require that but we are all neighbors we all live in the same community and we care and so maybe above and beyond communication is what's called for right now and i will be happy to serve as that central piece so that we i can get as much information and make connections as much as possible so if that's okay with you, I'd appreciate that. And then airport master planning, master plan update meeting tentatively November 19th. Once we have that set, it will be on the town calendar because it will be here in the council chambers and I will make a point of getting the notice out there so people know about that. Any other next steps that are, John go to that podium. [2:07:00] Speaker B (unidentified): Did I say Neptune? Yeah. How about next steps on Neptune? Yes. Jay, the town staff, are we ready to move forward with that? [2:07:09] Speaker A (unidentified): So here's what I'm proposing for that. I need to sit down with Jay as a town representative and to, now we've gotten, you know, this, we've heard a lot of these pieces, but they've all been presented at one time tonight. I'd like to get a little bit more update from the town side. My commitment is to have a, I'm going to have a follow-up meeting with Julia, Jay, and find out what's next on the, what I can get moving on that front from the town. [2:07:45] Speaker B (unidentified): We would like to hear the results of that meeting. Yes. We want to keep this thing moving. I agree. [2:07:50] Speaker F (unidentified): You know, we could do a referendum. Pardon? We could do a citizen's referendum. That's how they do it in Portland. [2:07:59] Speaker C (unidentified): I could also focus Stephen Bushy on merely Neptune to push. I mean, there's some missing information right now still [2:08:06] Speaker B (unidentified): I think this town can take a close look at Neptune in its current existing state But at least make a commitment to say yes We are going to take this to the town council with a recommendation [2:08:19] Speaker A (unidentified): But it's you 're talking about one part of your you're talking about one part of Neptune not the entire road [2:08:25] Speaker B (unidentified): So all of Neptune, okay So it's in the best interest of the town of the general public to take the whole damn road [2:08:32] Speaker A (unidentified): So we need to know what the storm people plowing it today [2:08:36] Speaker B (unidentified): You're gonna have one entity responsible for the whole darn thing and we need more we knew that I'll push you need that drainage [2:08:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Specific part. Yeah, so we're not waiting for the ancillary roads at this point [2:08:47] Speaker A (unidentified): That's the next step is to get that piece from the engineer that's what that's what the town needs that can just a [2:08:53] Speaker B (unidentified): little further down the road we need to keep moving thank you hi [2:09:02] Speaker V (unidentified): sorry real quick on that who has a teeth to enforce these things say it again who has the teeth to enforce the developers to do what they say they're gonna do Neptune they had developers develop our lots they say we're gonna do the road we're gonna do the drainage it got passed off now you got a lot of your plate now this sucks for you, right? Why didn't we hold the people beforehand accountable? Who has the teeth besides getting lawyers? We're not gonna get lawyers. How can the town hold these people more accountable? What is that solution? I mean, one thing is, I mean, sorry Kevin, but not offering any occupancy in the new houses until they can get the first stuff done. Who has that teeth? I don't, you don't even [2:09:41] Speaker A (unidentified): tell me. I just want you to... Well, Julie's, it looks like Julie's gonna say [2:09:44] Speaker V (unidentified): say something. Because it's not, it's a Spider-Man meme. You guys have probably seen it pointing at each other. Who's doing what? That's all I've been hearing for the past three years. We are [2:09:55] Speaker S (unidentified): in the process of talking to engineers about taking a look at what has gone wrong on Neptune, or at least the houses along Neptune when they were developed, what happened with the grading and the stormwater issues so that we can pinpoint exactly what's wrong. That's the idea of looking into it, is to try to hold someone responsible for it. So we're... Sure. [2:10:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Right,. The person that's probably wreaked the most havoc is not here. Well, [2:10:36] Speaker S (unidentified): I will note that our review process looks different now than it did back then. Kevin's project is already approved, but we're aware of the types of issues that have come up, and we'll be monitoring those more closely. [2:10:53] Speaker A (unidentified): So the transparency is through me. You know where I am, and this sounds really shameless, but I am running for another three-year term, November 3rd. I'm unopposed, but that doesn't matter. I know there's you know, I would like your you know, I'd like your confidence that You put me back in for another three years and this is a priority for me to stay Keep this kind of transparency communication information sharing at this level. It's kind of been a slow Launch into this and but to me this is the standard now and how we communicate Because it's just gotten to be to the point where I'm just like this is crazy It is crazy. And I'm sorry. I'm really sorry for all the folks on the landing have gone through a lot, and they're still going through a lot. And I'm not saying it in a way of like all you, but we all have to understand that we all are living in, even though we may be building, not living there, living there, not building, but the fact is that we're all neighbors and we all impact each other, and all the activity on the landing even if in the commercial areas affect the residential area and that was a point that I wanted to bring today as well and we understand that and ultimately in my opinion the town has a final we're the last we're the last line of defense for community members because your taxpayers and you're paying and I understand you and you're paying it your HOA fees and I understand that you folks are paying cam fees to Mira and Mira's got things that they need to be doing and so it's we just have to keep this and then we have you know unknowns we have investigation environmental investigations going on that we don't know what's actually going to come out of that we're still kind of moving the train's still moving down the tracks even though we don't know a lot of things so the but who's who's who's got the teeth i don't know the teeth but who's got the ultimate accountability, I see it as the town has to ensure that something, that you folks are moving, progressing and finding clarity and resolving what we can. Some things, the horses out of the barn, I would call it was a bit of a dark period in our planning department. We didn't actually have a full, we weren't fully staffed. We are now. Now we've passed more ordinances since I've been on the council around development than I think we've had in a long time. And I'm, I'm really proud of some of the ordinances we've passed, but unfortunately they're not, you know, for the past development doesn't, doesn't matter, but for the future development, we have, we have more teeth, we have more tools. [2:13:40] Speaker F (unidentified): From my perspective, this is a, is sort of painful and semi uncomfortable as this meeting is. is it's the healthiest thing in terms of communication I've seen in a long time. Because when I came in to do my project, frankly, the town manager tried to stop it. You know, he didn't want the asylum seekers coming here because he was afraid of his budget. And they're here, and I think it was a good thing, and I'm glad I did it. But now I'm in the association meetings, and we don't know what the town will do. We want the town to understand our issues, but we feel like the town's over here, and we're over here, and they don't understand our issues. And Mariner's Landing feels like the master HOA doesn't understand their issues because they're not at the meetings. And it's good that we're all here at a meeting and able to talk about this stuff. Because, again, if this ultimately is going to be part of the town of Brunswick in all ways, all those barriers and walls have to come down. So I think it's a good step tonight to hear. At that meeting a year ago, when we talked about the roads, we heard for the first time the town officials expressed some sentiment that we see your point. and ultimately it'd be nice if those roads could be part of brunswick but maybe but it was still there and it Was the first time we'd heard it and this to me feels like another step in that direction. So There's a lot of These types of meetings probably still to go but I appreciate you Calling it because I think ultimately it is a healthy a very healthy meeting that we've had tonight. So I hope we can build on it [2:15:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Thank you. with that unless there's any real pressing less comments thoughts questions I'm going to call it for tonight I'm really hungry but I this was for me I felt I appreciate you guys the commitment the concern your interest in this community I it feels great to be in the room with this group and thank you for giving me this opportunity and more to come so please be in touch and I will be in touch with you thank you