Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:19] Speaker A (unidentified): sure all
[0:35] Speaker B (unidentified): right all yours all
[0:38] Speaker A (unidentified): right i am calling the meeting to order and i don't think we have any public so no public comment approval of the minutes help from the meeting held on september 15th i'll move to approve those jackie are you going to keep us all in line here or what i'm going to do my best
[1:28] Speaker C (unidentified): The minutes have been approved and seconded, as I believe.
[1:32] Speaker A (unidentified): All in favor, aye. Aye. Do we want to postpone staff update?
[1:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, but we do stuff in court first.
[1:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so let's jump right into battery ordinance.
[1:48] Speaker D (unidentified): All right, can you all hear me? Yes. Yes. Okay, let me share my screen.
[1:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, I have to make sure you get permission to. What's that? I got to make sure. Ken, there we go. Now you should be able to share. Let
[2:13] Speaker D (unidentified): me turn up my volume a little bit. So, by the way, before we begin, what's the, remind me of the timeline of all this again. again like when would you like once we're done what's the process and what does that look like time-wise so I think I want to send it back to planning and you know have them look at it and
[2:43] Speaker B (unidentified): ideally would have some type of a public meeting that the energy committee would host to that we would allow maybe people abutting the Bisson farm or any general public to come in and hear a presentation and comment and then as a result and that ideally that meeting would be sometime before christmas i'd say okay and then we'd have things ready to give to the planning board at some point by mid-january at the latest and they can start working through their process
[3:14] Speaker D (unidentified): whether does that make sense or yeah no that's fine i think we're really close i you know i just have some i was just talking to josie i want to we've got a lot of i mean we've got a pretty large library of materials we've been working through model you know many town bylaws and articles and but i do want to i want to blanket more and with respect to some of these sections and just pull the best language from that we can so i'm going to set my team of four next week on various tasks and i just want to make sure we had time but it sounds like we do
[3:56] Speaker E (unidentified): what about attorney review i don't think we necessarily have to have that at this stage
[4:03] Speaker B (unidentified): so if you wanted to use your next november meeting to bring this back one more time before the group and in the meantime kurt will be doing his stuff and planning can look at it again and comment to warn kurt if needed so then at your november meeting would be maybe final changes before the public hearing then we'd schedule a public meeting sometime in december probably not too close to christmas but maybe in the middle of the month and then as a result of that meeting if there's any more changes we can make those and then give it to the planning board and then will
[4:36] Speaker A (unidentified): there be an attorney review yeah as part of the planning board's process or either before or
[4:43] Speaker B (unidentified): during so they would definitely get reviewed by the attorney but i don't think we necessarily
[4:47] Speaker E (unidentified): that we have to have that before planning okay that's great to know great yeah that would be
[4:54] Speaker D (unidentified): good yeah that makes sense because we're you know we're pretty good on the land use planning side but you know the planning board a lot of that as you know is very local and things change depending on what town you're in so it was very helpful to talk to planning about how they wanted it to look even if it didn't entirely make that much sense in my logical mind which because they wanted everything you know to be honest they wanted so what we did was the basic change they made two basic changes one of them was and they were big ones but not that big one of them was they wanted everything in section new section 6.20 they didn't want like i was like i was envisioning a process where our new definitions someday would be put into the definition section as part of the amendment process and our new you know some of our new site performance standards would be blended in with you know a section and they were like nope just look at what we did for solar and do everything whether it be submission requirements or performance standards or decommissioning or definitions like we want it all in a new 60.20 so that was fine i mean it actually made life a lot easier i just used that as my template and that's why i didn't want to give you a red line because the whole thing would have been red because everything was in a different spot and the other thing they said was they didn't think their planning board did well with tons of discretion they tended to defer that not like it they would rather have so and i get it now they'd rather have sort of concrete guidance in the bylaw instead of saying you know this is you know they can waive the decommissioning bond for special circumstances in their sole discretion or they can call two batteries one battery if they feel like the developers trying to game the system in their sole discretion they're like they would rather have you just list out the circumstances to the extent you can so i tried to i tried to do that and then the only the other one was just you know and we and i did go through it they wanted to make sure like we just weren't duplicative since really we're just saying anything in the site plan review anything in the condition to use permit that still stands this is all in addition sometimes it's a substitution but mostly this is an addition so i did take out some things that seemed duplicative but and just try to simplify it as you can see it's it's a lot of the preamble language i'm like listen we are amending the zoning bylaw in accordance and i took out some of the constitutional references that i got from different documents from other towns in maine that had used them and just thought let's just keep it simple and if the lawyer wants to reference the state constitution that gives the you know the town the right to amend their bylaw i'll let him do that i'm not a maine lawyer i think you
[8:00] Speaker B (unidentified): got the right whether or not you're supposed to say it yeah i know i was like it was getting
[8:04] Speaker D (unidentified): too fancy i'm like i like it nice and simple let's just go through and keep it tight so i mean i should well i wish i could split my you know let me try this just because this might make it easier for me to do this because i have a unless it's hard to see then it might not be easier can you see what i'm trying to do i need to reshare my screen yes you can see that so this just shows you the changes and i'll pull over the comments but yeah i mean kind of nitpicking with you know some of the stuff they wanted me to take out and we don't have to go over every change but this was just a matter of simplifying stuff you know like i took out this language in b the determination as to what is more restrictive shall be made solely by the planning board they're like you know it's inherent in the language that they have the right to make that determination i was thinking this would just be more guidance for them like if there's a conflict with another section of the code it's up to you but they're like just leave that alone don't don't give the planning board so much general authority like that and i see generally their point so i struck that because i think they have that anyway the battery so i put in here and over here i reserve the right to look at the battery definition one more time only because i was being a little bit too lawyerly like we talk about battery and batteries here but we really don't mention them anywhere else i took this from a model bylaw and so i you know i tried to incorporate the word battery in the battery energy storage system definition i think it works i just want to make sure we're not including i think we talked about last time everything to do with storage like whether it's hydro or something else we're talking really lithium ion or certain types of you know certain types of battery energy storage system techno technological storage systems really i just want to make sure we're being specific enough here but i think we're close one of the so here's a here's a material point material discussion tier one tier two tier three tier four it runs the gamut i've seen so when it comes to fire safety there are there's there used to be a threshold in 855 nfs 855 at 600 kilowatt hours so a bunch of towns put tier ones up to 600 kilowatt hours because after that the batteries got a little fancier with a little better fire protection enhanced safety measures that's been dropped i think it's going to get dropped to 20 in 2027 version 20 seemed really low that's like you're really only dealing with residential batteries at that point so some towns had 600 one town actually was at 20 another town was at 100 right now i think i'm comfortable with 250. they all have to meet those fire safety measures by the way even if they're just going for a building code or a building permit like it doesn't mean they just don't have to go through site plan review and the conditional use permit process they still have to go in front of the inspector and show that they meet all the various requirements so from a land use perspective 250 which comes from some of the model bylaws seems to make sense that's a it's a pretty big battery it's it's bigger than residential it's not it's bigger than small commercial so you're probably going to start to be in the standalone category there but one of the things i'm going to have my students do i've got like 10 bylaws i wanted to pull like 30 and i wanted to pull them every single definition so we can see how they do the tears because there's just too much variation i thought we were the only ones doing tier four that was like i you know and one of the planners made the point like well if you're going to make all of everything over tier one that's sort of non-accessory go through the conditional use permit process what's the point of having so many tiers and i was like that is a good point and we do stand alone so i did i did try to break it down into three basically the tier twos being all the you know all the standalone distribution system connected batteries and the tier threes being the big ones you know i up to five megawatts i sort of consider distribution you might have them bigger but it's like 10 megawatt hours or connected to the distribution system above 250 and tier threes or like everything above that everything above 10 megawatt hours or if you're connected to the transmission system and i think it works i went back and forth on this like for hours and but I do want to just do a bigger survey I want to do like 30 bylaws and see where other towns are at because I said I've seen like three or four
[14:02] Speaker E (unidentified): different versions of this so would like for example Kurt a grocery store or something put if they decided to put up some battery storage systems they could potentially fall under a tier one?
[14:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Is that a small commercial? Like an IGA or a small independent store would probably put a 250, like a huge one would probably be, you know, it would probably be in the 500 or so category.
[14:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Like maybe an industrial facility.
[14:39] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, or like a big super stop and shop or something which had a lot of electrical usage would want a bigger one.
[14:46] Speaker E (unidentified): Could bump up to a tier two.
[14:48] Speaker D (unidentified): and the other thing too is you know we had which lends to this discussion we had a section as you can see well and by the way before i move on just to tackle this quickly as we go in order i did we talked about developers gaming the system and piling on like you know four you know 10 50 kw batteries and saying listen we're we're a tier one because each batteries HBAS is below 50 and how to stop them from gaming that so I just put in some actual language instead of leaving it up to the discretion of the board and I think it does it you know and I pulled this from other bylaws which I was happy to see that other towns had addressed this also so I
[15:31] Speaker E (unidentified): think I'm sorry for it no go ahead does that what if a entity was to stagger implementation of battery storage systems so what if i put in a 200 one year the next year another 200 another 200 does the does the bylaw talk to that as far as like an aggregate for a parcel
[16:01] Speaker D (unidentified): or some something of that i mean it kind of does i could we talk about phasing i think that would be considered phasing doing one now one in two years but i could make a note to maybe make that a little tighter you know to make it clear about if they do something like that because that does happen and people expand but i think the language is pretty good i took this i think from lee massachusetts they had some language that said multiple bess installations should not be intentionally divided separated or phased for the purpose of avoiding the applicable tier or permitting requirements which i think is was pretty good but we can take a look at that too and maybe we want to include yeah that sounds pretty good actually yeah like that yeah but anyway back to the tier so we did we had a we had a category as you can see we called it building integrated uses and they were really accessory uses but we were i was using language from you know the model bylaws and you can see the massachusetts bylaws called a building integrated but the is the planners like we have accessory uses they're defined why don't you just build off that term since that's that's what everyone's comfortable with so i put in here i kind of took the i said be a best facility installed within or on or directly adjacent to an existing primary building on the same lot and that the system is primarily designed to serve and not i'm going to put primarily serve let me just say that again the electric power grid may constitute an accessory use i had two questions as i was looking at this morning and these are questions i was asking myself and i'm asking you guys too which was does it belong long in the definition section or should be included as a tier one because the theory behind an accessory use is a you know what we're getting at is if you're a grocery store and you want to have backup power and it's a 400 kilowatt hour you're just going for a building permit because we respect that and we know you need it and we're not going to make you go through site plan review in the conditional use permit process you still need to go and get all your fire safety stuff done but that's sort of the theory it's like every other accessory used it's kind of permitted as a right with a building permit i didn't i didn't put in like we had talked about in the planners that recommended we include batteries connected to solar to substations and things like that but i kind of like our theory from last time which is like i get it from if you're an energy policy person but if you're a land use person why you know it's like i they still are a big land use impact and i think you know it's not a heavy lift to get a conditional use permit it's a couple days of drafting i'm like in the submission i'm like i still think those even though that's a good spot for them and we encourage them later i don't want to i mean it's nonsensical to say a battery connected to a substations accessory because those are the ones
[19:33] Speaker B (unidentified): that are huge you know yeah i think you're right and i think if we're trying to get the neighborhoods comfortable with that there's enough check safety checks i think you're right that should be separate from the just going yeah we put something in there that says that's where we'd
[19:50] Speaker D (unidentified): like them you know but we don't necessarily don't get a free pass you know you still have to come in front of the board it might be an easier time in front of the board but you still have to come
[19:57] Speaker B (unidentified): in front of the board yeah and i
[20:02] Speaker D (unidentified): have to make it somewhere clear and that this goes where it goes in the in the proposed bylaw that these are building permit only you know because that's it
[20:13] Speaker A (unidentified): just gets too complicated i mean do we i don't want to re litigate this but like why do we even need an accessory category and like if there's an accessory vest that's larger than a tier one I still feel like it implicates all of the safety stuff and yeah what is the purpose of it I guess yeah because if you're a residence
[20:47] Speaker D (unidentified): you're gonna be in tier one if you're a small business you're gonna be in tier one. I feel like having the pressure from the, you know, the, folks, the policy and the planners like accessory uses. And there is some, you know, there are like the American planning board or whatever it is, wrote this article. They, it was all about, and there were a few that were like talking about encouraging the installation of these things. These things are good. Some people think they're good. Some people hate them. and that we should encourage them so it's like that balance like if you're going to use them it'd be great to have them used as also as a backup source which is if they're tied to a building you know that's part of
[21:34] Speaker A (unidentified): like from a community perspective i think we care about safety we care about noise and just the impact and like yes if it's associated with a building there's already a structure there and it's probably can't be too big to begin with but i mean maybe we could say i
[21:57] Speaker B (unidentified): think the politics of it are that stephanie's right and i think if we don't get people feeling there's enough regulation of these that they're going to be safe people aren't going to vote in favor of the
[22:08] Speaker D (unidentified): ordinance so yeah i don't mind listen we had originally talked about taking it out i mean i remember that and i think i 'm fine with that too and i think you know that might seems
[22:24] Speaker E (unidentified): to me that the tier one size definition encompasses most of a reasonable accessory yeah i agree
[22:33] Speaker B (unidentified): if that's that makes sense we just burned down their business as opposed to the neighbor's house
[22:38] Speaker A (unidentified): why don't kurt let's let's earmark that for just saying you know discussing with the planners
[22:48] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah i'm gonna have i'll have i'll have a student again review one of the things they'll do is review all the 20 or 30 model not model bylaws but town bylaws out there to see how they treat accessory uses and again if they're not to say we're not better than that we might be on a
[23:09] Speaker B (unidentified): better track i mean ultimately you're the expert in this you know you've been doing this
[23:14] Speaker D (unidentified): more than any of us have i think no i get it 's we're all experts now i mean i'm just i'm just researching and using my you know whatever i've gotten in terms of experience i mean but some of these are you know the accessory issue as well as i do given this discussion we're having that's the that's the issue but i kind of see the logic 250 kwh in the town like topso might be good enough to cover accessory uses maybe not in a town like hartford connecticut or something maybe you know they need to leave room for bigger stuff in industrial zones you know they don't want to be bothered with applications that seemingly do good things for i don't know i don't know yeah
[24:02] Speaker A (unidentified): i like it though i guess that's the other lever we have maybe in the industrial zone
[24:08] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah i mean you could in the industrial zone tier twos are special permit only or something yeah or site plan review only sorry yeah so that's another level yeah we can always i think
[24:22] Speaker B (unidentified): in the future too loosen this up i think it's better to have more review as it starts you know
[24:28] Speaker E (unidentified): know so tp so people get comfortable with it and stuff yeah that's not a bad process either see what happens after a few of them go through the process right i was gonna ask her actually like i didn't see that zoning matrix thingy oh they just removed or yeah that's because you have it
[24:51] Speaker D (unidentified): and i like took it from your bylaw just as an example and i got a comment that i think she said she was great too i'm just i'm not i think it was like this is incomplete why did you leave some zones out and i was like it was just like an example like you know when i when we were going through the first meeting like you're going to event the power and the bylaw is what zone you're going to allow you know when you put a p next to tier ones or you put a special permit next to tier one well all i guess in theory all the zones will have a p for tier one but for tier two it's whether you put a you know a p a site plan review or a conditional use permit that's where the you know so this wasn't this was kind of meant in the other version to be example purposes only or for
[25:39] Speaker B (unidentified): like discussion purposes but i'd almost rather see the solar farm be accessories to the battery storage than the battery storage be accessory to the solar farm because i think there's more concerned with the battery storage of the solar farm yeah in either case yeah we're not gonna
[25:58] Speaker D (unidentified): we decided i think we're all comfortable with like a battery and a solar farm or a battery coming after a solar farm is going to have to go through the new permitting process which by the way that's normal like that's what's happening in massachusetts like that's not i'm in great barrington on two sites and i'm going through getting ready to go through at some point a special permit process it's and they're all they're old solar sites with batteries coming in
[26:24] Speaker A (unidentified): on them they're not giving me a toss carl are you saying that the table isn't in the new version and
[26:31] Speaker E (unidentified): we need to put it in the new version is that what you're saying i don't know i don't i noticed it wasn't there i could make it again what was sky's comment about i don't think i think i was
[26:47] Speaker D (unidentified): and again i was just putting it in there as sort of an example for you all to show you that the real determinations are going to come when you fill this out and i was going to leave that to you because i don't know your zones as well as you do but i think she said i didn't include i think there's more than r1 r2 up to bdp there's more zones and yeah i think we
[27:09] Speaker A (unidentified): we want this table in but we need to just make sure it includes all this and in the end this
[27:16] Speaker B (unidentified): might actually be put in a different place because next week the sky's going to meet with the planning board to update our table of uses in general so I could see that before that gets to town meeting at some point in January February whatever we do with this piece may get incorporated to that table so
[27:36] Speaker E (unidentified): this might not be in the final text right here but yeah let's let's keep it keep it with the
[27:42] Speaker D (unidentified): draft so we remember to fill it out okay i'll i'll make a note and i'll double check that all the zones are the different types of zones are in there she made the comment i'm like i didn't i didn't mean it to be like the final it was more like you know hey we don't need to get too deep into the details because every zone where you have a tier three is going to be a condition of use permit it's going to be cup so you know and yeah so i just reorganized it like the solar so the submission requirements i just added stuff that wasn't in there they liked you know stuff like so this language so that llc's just can't hide we get to know who is the real company behind them nothing too dramatic that i changed that they commented on as far as submission materials let's try to where was it in here i think it was up here yeah right here yeah i changed regional transmission organization to independent system operator to make in the narrative report but they wanted me to they didn't weren't crazy with F and G over here, evidence of local labor in town comprehensive plan. I forget the comment about the town comprehensive plan in particular. Well, they said that the zoning needed to,
[29:21] Speaker A (unidentified): like it's the town comprehensive plan. That would be the responsibility of the zoning of the town,
[29:28] Speaker D (unidentified): not individual projects. Right. Yeah. And I've, I've had circumstances where I've had in my narrative description you know i did the work it does you know but it was also like i think the planning board wanted to me to demonstrate that i was in compliance with their comprehensive plan in addition to them having done it with their rezoning five years earlier so i just i remember i've had to write i had to write stuff like that up before that's why i put it in but they said take it out so it's fine you know in labor that was that was a reach so i put i just put in here you know in a description of any other benefits to the town after the host or good neighbor agreements you know i kind of added like tell us what else you're going to do so that kind of covers that and they're all listen they're all going to say we're gonna use local labor to the extent they're qualified it's like standard language i left this stuff out here on the right the boundary survey stuff that was all pretty well covered in site plan review i mean there's a whole section on what should be in the map i was just getting particular but to keep it neat i didn't none of these things were material they're all kind of in there in one form or another I'm trying to think what else. Did I make any changes to technical environmental reports? Not really. It was just kind of a list of the different plans and then the performance standards, which they're going to have to demonstrate, come later. So in the dimensional requirements, obviously there's dimensional requirements in the bylaw itself for each zone, but this is kind of a meaty section. not many bylaws talked about height. and I don't, frankly, I don't know enough about the engineering of these types of batteries to know if you'd really want to stack them super high. I intuitively, it seems pretty stupid. but, you know, some of your height dimensional requirements in many of your zones are like 75 feet, a hundred feet, even in some of the residential zones are pretty high so like i took it out but then i was reading like i think it was like i think it was like chesterfield had just a simple statement like yeah it was like the height of any structure associated with the best shall not exceed 35 feet like that was it for their height and i'm like i kind of like that simplicity like you gotta we're not that worried about it but we're gonna you gotta keep them shorter than you know
[32:26] Speaker B (unidentified): a three-story house or something like that was it two meetings ago we had that power engineer that lives next to the farm that happened to join us i think he said it isn't so much the batteries it's like it's the connections to the transmission line that are really tall right so that any structure associated would probably cover that although 35 may or may not be enough
[32:50] Speaker D (unidentified): that's not enough for a big tower connecting to a transmission line
[32:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Maybe as you do your review of the 30 ordinances, maybe see how people treat that. Maybe they have a separate height standard for the batteries versus the connecting structures or something.
[33:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. You know, and we did I did so there's somebody brought up a good point with what we're about to go into for I'm just going to this is just as a reminder, which was, you know, you might want to be careful about the setbacks because they're like the way it's worded is if you have a battery you like say on the one you were looking at on the farm theoretically you like and the property next to it was owned by central main power and it had a big tower on it you don't want to have 100 foot setbacks with respect to the tower you want the setbacks to go away right the power is going to be servicing the property so it was a similar issue where we had to carve it out and i think i drafted something here i put the planning board may waive these setback requirements for abutting properties that contain a generation facility meaning solar substation or transmission or distribution lines that are directly utilized in the interconnection or operation of the VAS. So, yeah, I thought it was pretty good, but that's sort of the theory I think we're talking about with height. Like, by the way, these height restrictions don't apply to telephone poles, you know, that carry books and the alarms on them.
[34:37] Speaker E (unidentified): How do you feel about the setback requirements in relation to the performative requirements of the studies? studies, always study that kind of thing, you know, is, does this, you know, if, and maybe this is more of a general question too, is do the, do the minimum setbacks potentially go above and beyond what's going to be found in, a noise study, for example? I think so, because they're
[35:15] Speaker D (unidentified): concerned with more than just noise you know a lot of the setback requirements were definitely way beyond what you know the noise is it more like you know fire spreading yes it's honestly josie can tell you it's a rationality i mean and visual impact maybe visual and like worry i mean so i pulled up some stuff just for fun as i was looking at it like this was chesterfield you know had a and this was interesting i didn't mind some of this first they had a 200 foot setback from property lines on all sides of the lot which is which is big by the way but then they also had a different setback from private and public water supplies which i thought was interesting that's why i kind of put it in my notes to revisit that because that's generally i mean a private water supply is tough because the wells you know but in amherst you know they were up to setbacks from residential zoning districts should be minimum of 500 feet you know some of the some of the bylaws were yeah some of the bylaws were like you talked about like they should be the regular setbacks in the zone like and some of them were even on the east coast were getting like 500 200 300 and i was like it was clearly the 500 it's got to be you know sort of a rational fear of fire noise contamination visual you know property value yeah amherst is a little amherst new york though yeah but these are just two examples we have like we have like 10 of them i just perused just quickly to go through and see how they treat setbacks how do they treat this and i
[37:11] Speaker E (unidentified): 100 feet if you have a 100 foot square property what is that acreage do we know it's 200 what is it 20 000 square feet that's a half an acre yeah oh okay so it's not like you know i don't know i'm just thinking like say market basket wanted to put in a tier two are you all of a sudden is it like i'm just making that up like is that then because buffalo wild wings is down the road like you can't they're they're gonna be but clearly not there's that's like plenty of that's plenty of
[37:47] Speaker B (unidentified): space or a hundred square feet is what ten thousand so that's about a little under a quarter
[37:54] Speaker D (unidentified): of an acre yeah but that's that's if you take a hundred on like you know everywhere it really shrinks your ability to but I mean what we could I mean the other thing I mean I mean isn't this the appropriate spot where you give the planning board the planning board may increase setbacks due to special circumstances isn't this the one spot where like it's sort of like tough planning or you've got to use your common sense here it's a it's a market basket it next to a buffalo wild wings nobody cares if there's a 500 megawatt you know kilowatt hour battery there you don't need to give them a 200 foot setback in this case but if it abuts like you know an elementary school or a bunch of homes where people are freaking out then stick to the original setbacks in that zoning district you know so you're proposing plenty
[39:01] Speaker B (unidentified): board can lower the setbacks or plenty more could raise the setbacks right i'll maybe take out the
[39:07] Speaker D (unidentified): battery specific setbacks and you know we say here all best shall at a minimum meet the primary structure setbacks of the underlying district and i don't know does it make sense to take that out
[39:19] Speaker B (unidentified): i don't think we're going to get our neighbor to the farm comfortable with that if it's a 35 foot
[39:24] Speaker D (unidentified): setback or something but we give them the right to increase it but i guess you're right i mean i say this is the one point in the bylaw where we push back on my planner friends and say we need them to have discretion because in some instances this is going to be nonsensical
[39:39] Speaker B (unidentified): either too big or too small you know i almost kind of like the 200 and then give the planning board the ability to lower it either because of as you pointed out it's going to be right next to the transmission line or because they can be convinced that safety reasons allow it to be lowered but i think if we went less than 200 we're going to have people near the farm really concerned i
[40:07] Speaker A (unidentified): mean i think like if you looked at a whole bunch of other bylaws and it was sort of all over the place i feel like 100 like what you put is sort of middle of the road right it's not 500 but it's also not 35 right and the and that just applies to neighboring residential right
[40:30] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah and some of the guidance from like the american planning board they wrote this like four-page article on it they were like setbacks should be the same as that you know it's in the zoning district it's in and it's like but again that was very pro battery and the reality is there is fear you know and these and legitimate if they do catch fire yeah like from a residential
[40:50] Speaker A (unidentified): lot a hundred feet like just that feels fine like that doesn't feel like too much and it doesn't necessarily feel like too little to me yeah and if you're a big bass if
[41:06] Speaker D (unidentified): you're one of those transmission tied ones i mean with 100 containers there yeah you're you're talking like five acres of batteries i mean is that is that enough you know with towers connecting to a
[41:22] Speaker B (unidentified): transmission system maybe it's 200 for tier three and 100 for tier two kind of leave it the way it
[41:30] Speaker D (unidentified): is for now and we'll keep and we'll keep looking i said i want to this is one of the things that got me thinking i'm like i would love to look at more than just 10 different towns and their bylaws i'd like to have a student go through and just literally give me a chart just setback requirements from property lines for 30 towns in the eastern u.s and we can really look at it yeah
[41:51] Speaker A (unidentified): i think as long as we have the data to back up what we put in here whether it's you know the
[41:57] Speaker D (unidentified): average of 30 that we've looked at and we looked at one we went and i told you we i sent you that picture we visited one in south royalton vermont that it was i don't know 100 feet from the house an old dirt road leading up to it was 25 feet from the solar not connected to it and we stood right next to it and i didn't hear a thing you know i don't know if it was operating and but it's like you know so that's the reality but the fear is yeah i mean i think it's fine i mean i think let's keep this for now and let me come back with a with a graph for you guys showing you what every eastern town we could find does for setbacks and then we can
[42:45] Speaker B (unidentified): we can decide and that would be good for the public media too to be able to show that graph
[42:50] Speaker D (unidentified): one thing that people really get worked up about yeah i saw those noise blankets i included them in the and the noise section yeah they had these they had these thick noise blankets and almost like those green things you have around like tennis courts to stop the wind but they were thicker and they were like gray and i put that in there as an option just to remind the planning board that those things exist and i mean hopefully they would have the you know they would hire for a big battery or something significant hire a consultant so really who knows all this stuff and i did put that in up here a general statement that for anything the town can hire an expert okay so we'll put a pin in on setbacks we'll leave it the way it is but we'll come back with a research project for you just an excel spreadsheet showing you what all the different towns have done yeah i took out the language about discretion as we talked about they said that's just too much discretion and i think i think a good lawyer would say you're not giving enough direction to the applicant so that it's i don't want to use the word constitutional but it might be unconstitutionally vague like they this one except the guy lawyer
[44:27] Speaker B (unidentified): would flag because he's done that before in some of our yeah they want to come in and know what
[44:30] Speaker D (unidentified): they have to meet to get their project and if you leave it like whimsical then it violates some theories i'm just i remember all their comments so performance stamp they thought this was vague but i'm fine i kind of like it located constructed installed and operated to minimize potentially adverse impacts to nearby properties i thought that was fine i decided to keep but i think it's yeah josh said it was a bit general but you know i think i pulled that from another section of their bylaws so and then this is where i added the preference but we you know we did this last time for best to be next to solar any other generation or a substation you know we're not going to give you a pass you're not considered accessory but that's yeah we get it that's a smart spot to put it minimize streak some of these things i'm just going to go through the changes so they didn't like the discretion remember i talked about developers will often come in and say okay we'll put in all the arborvitaes you want and you and you show up at the site on the day they're done with construction and they're six inches tall because they wanted to say so i put in they have the discretion to not do that and they're like don't give them discretion just tell them how much so they recommended this language of an average height of six feet which i thought was fair you know and staggered you know staggered in multiple rows to cover gaps but the site plant does the site
[46:18] Speaker A (unidentified): plan like if the say the height of the project is 20 feet does is there a requirement for the vegetation to eventually be 20 feet or no it's just six feet like that's the start essentially the minimum i
[46:44] Speaker D (unidentified): mean capable of providing effective buffering and shall be installed to obscure views of bass and pertinent structures from abutting residential properties or as required by the planning board i probably should take that out i mean that kind of it kind of says it's the whole point of it is to obscure views
[47:15] Speaker A (unidentified): views it also makes it sound like they have to make sure the buffer is six feet it doesn't or average six feet could they have it be taller at the time well this is at the time of
[47:30] Speaker D (unidentified): installation josh
[47:35] Speaker B (unidentified): actually is a licensed landscape architect when he came to us he left the firm when he was practicing so i think he's pretty good with the that's why he came up with the double row and all those things yeah we
[47:54] Speaker D (unidentified): could say minimum height too because you're really not going to want anything shorter than that no maybe that'll signal the planning board
[48:02] Speaker B (unidentified): that you can do minimum but i think you probably can't really cost effectively buy 15 foot trees
[48:10] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah i mean yeah i mean it's a lot it's a lot it's very expensive to plant these things but it's not a huge site it's not like a solar site where you're going to be doing it around like a 20 acre site it's but i think putting in minimum and just making sure they're installed to obscure views of bass and we make sure it's at the time of installation i think that i think that's pretty good and
[48:44] Speaker B (unidentified): most of these are if they're the size of like little storage units
[48:49] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah i mean i'm trying to think the ones we've seen six feet wouldn't do it i would say 12 depending on you know depending on whether you're looking down at it or whatever i that's that's it's really just i mean if it's all flat and you're looking at i would say you'd want it
[49:06] Speaker B (unidentified): to be like 12 or 15 feet high at the end of the day and our bodies grow pretty quick so in a few
[49:12] Speaker D (unidentified): years they probably would be want to put a minimum and make it eight yeah that sounds good it we've had to plan them i mean and they're you know eight's not bad we i mean i remember one on a solar site it was 14 so i think it's you know the fence is seven feet a foot above the fence this seems reasonable to start yeah that's all fair i'm sorry for jumping off there
[49:41] Speaker E (unidentified): quickly before i jumped off i wanted to just give a little bit of context i thought it was interesting when you guys walk out of the town hall from the door to the if you're looking straight ahead towards the fire department or the police department it's 125 feet across the parking lot to that building so just give just in our as it relates to the discussion before about
[50:10] Speaker F (unidentified): the yes it's gonna feel close it's gonna 200 feet is gonna feel close if you're
[50:17] Speaker D (unidentified): next to a five acre big battery facility you know we'll pull that we'll pull the data for you and make it easy we'll send it out before the meeting so you have it that'll be we're gonna meet on Monday and we'll we'll get to work on that shouldn't be a huge task so we've got a pretty big library already so all right we just talked about the vegetation what it needs to be at the time of installation we didn't we wanted to take again that planning board discretion i had built in fencing i didn't do too much with it 's all sort of governed by state you know what i gotta leave myself a reminder be consistent that's i called the main something electrical code is the right name for it I still want to call the state electrical code here if I use it formally in another section and yeah as Josie said we noticed there was a soundproof acoustic screen at the one we visited and I'm like you know they've got the right to put that in anyway or to force that but I just put I put a section in here that was the only change the planning board may require the fencing to include a noise reducing or sound proof acoustic screen they made a comment over here that they you know they were happy we put in these noise standards above and beyond what's in the code but they were worried about well i can show you they were worried about tom made a comment about include a requirement to document operational compliance follow-up annual biannual other I've never seen I've never seen a project be forced to go out every few years and do a new noise study that's why I didn't do it and I never saw that in another bylaw but like we don't want to be too you know too
[52:36] Speaker B (unidentified): your code these things his reason for that is he doesn't really have the capability to measure noise right and so i think he'd rather have them have to produce a report saying they're in compliance than them having to or us having to go hire a consultant to try to measure the noise so maybe as maybe half meet them halfway and something like they have to produce a report initial report and then if we get complaints we've got the ability to ask for a subsequent couldn't report for or something although they don't have to come back every year right they just have to do it the first time okay
[53:25] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah and then there's i mean there's plenty of ammunition in your code i think if they're in violation of the noise and they don't do anything about it that's covered i think it's like 225 six and seven or something it's the question is how
[53:47] Speaker B (unidentified): would find every violation i think he's trying to save himself from having to deal with complaints
[53:52] Speaker D (unidentified): that he doesn't have a way to yeah so i think that's a good idea i think they've got i think making it clear that not only do they have to do the testing but i'll refer back to the submission requirement they've got to do a new sort of acoustic noise assessment you know at the direction of the code enforcement officer and issue a report demonstrating they're not in violation and if they are steps to you know steps to address it that sounds good okay we didn't do anything here it's all pretty simple everything's got to be underground unless they can't be underground you know bedrock or it's a telephone pole that has to be there to connect to the grid lighting's i think i took this lighting i don't know if i took it from your statute your code but it's pretty standard just low to the ground shielded not on at night unless it's motion detected i took some i changed the sign language a little bit just because one of the bylaws one of the ordinances had you know they wanted one sign at the gate identifying the owner and emergency contact number and then they wanted that sign they a mandate that the sign be updated if the if the contact information changes but everything else is kind of code and then there was a no advertising section too which i liked you could put one sign up saying it's owned by next era whatever but that's it like you're not going to put big banners all over your site and use it as so that i don't know if we had that in there before but one of the towns had it in there that i liked i like that so environmental containment standards again we are not engineers and it makes me nervous getting too specific and i noticed a lot of the other bylaws didn't get too specific either because there's an enormous amount of literature both ul listings and electrical codes that deal with these things So a lot of the towns just said, you've got to comply with the state electrical code, the state fire prevention code, the building code, NFPA standards, and UL standards, which I liked. It kind of puts the onus on them. And ultimately, our consultant will ensure that. But then I threw in some of the towns did listings specifically. specifically the big section of the code is the 855 National Fire Protection Association 855 is the one the big one that everybody says you have to reference and that's the one you know that where the 600 kilowatt hour versus the 20 is getting debated so I just said you know best installation shall comply with all applicable versions of that in all other applicable fire safety standard standards including where applicable these different ul listings as opposed to what i did last time over here which was just be really specific and i was like i don't want to be specific because i'm not an expert like i've read this stuff just to make sure it vibes but i thought it was just it was a other towns have done this and i thought it was a more prudent approach for a zoning bylaw and jeff is the 855 the one that
[57:43] Speaker B (unidentified): you wanted to make sure we listed because the state hasn't actually adopted it yet right okay
[57:47] Speaker D (unidentified): so you did a good job all right good and then they sometimes did have the fire chief you know may require reasonable additional project specific measures necessary which i like
[58:00] Speaker B (unidentified): i'm sorry in addition to this though we probably have to list it out in the fire prevention Jim has adopted because that's where the codes are actually adopted too okay so but that's i mean
[58:11] Speaker C (unidentified): that's easy one line
[58:17] Speaker B (unidentified): so you have to stick a pin in that so we know to do that and
[58:24] Speaker A (unidentified): that's your to-do list for the spring yeah make sure that gets on the one i
[58:33] Speaker D (unidentified): don't think i made tracking yeah i don't think i made any changes other than h because that came from john who said you may also want to identify who has the ability to shut down the system and is responsible for notifying the utility so that's a pretty good idea which seems like it should be in there no matter what but putting it down is not bad there was a they, we were just reading about a fire over in Chutesbury, Massachusetts, an inverter fire. And it doesn't make a lot of sense. I think the guy who wrote us was a little bit, I don't know, I wouldn't say crazy, but a little bit upset emotionally. But he said that the fire had happened. No one told the planning board. They told other departments in town didn't issue like a release report to dep and so now it's become like a you can read about it there's a couple articles about it big to do and what was released and when and so i think that kind of communication like you know and i guess i guess and again i don't want to pretend i know that much but i guess one of the things that's key with some of these fires is not to spray them with water right away because that makes sure the chemicals in these inverters, transformers, and batteries don't migrate a great distance. You wait, actually, before you shoot water at them. But that process just reminded me there has to be a better system in place. And by the way, the only reason I said it didn't seem like he was too emotional is because I don't see why they would have gone to the planning board. The planning board job is done. i think they would have had to go into the you know building inspector or the fire chief but
[1:00:42] Speaker E (unidentified): i assumption with the what you just said about the spraying it with water is what motivated the private and public water supply setbacks that we were talking about previously yeah and i
[1:00:57] Speaker D (unidentified): guess you know one of the articles i was reading about a couple hours ago they i guess you know, it's common practice to have, you know, around, especially like your transformer on a solar site to have it, you know, not just on a cement pad, and have a little containment system, but also to have it on rocks, to make it slightly less pervious. And the slow the flow if it does, you know, you do get a rainstorm. So I just, you know, I'm like, we could build that in here but like i'm sure there's like 50 things that are recommended in 855 and other codes that we haven't thought about so it's sort of a dangerous road to go down in the zoning bylaws try to you know but you know you know what maybe we'll see if we have time to do that this week too i mean i've done this so i'm not doing this for the first time check other bylaws but i'll just say and see about things like more like where are they is it an 855 or is it in the state fire prevention code i'll be curious site access oh they just made a comment in site access that they've got a pretty thorough section, not quite as detailed, which talks about dead end roads, 185, 8B13. I looked it up. Again, it's not as thorough, but it seems like it tackles the same exact issue. So as long as the fire chief is okay with what I put in here, which was a reference to that section and be designed to accommodate the turning radii of the local department's largest fire apparatus. So it wasn't just that, but I referenced 85B13 and took that out because the planning group was like, you should take out everything that's duplicative, which I think is smart. But yeah, I've got, you know, financial surety is a funny thing i some bylaws require it some just want a decommissioning plan the question i have the big question is obviously we want a very good financial surety for a tier three but what about for a small you know tier two battery next to market basket you know do we do we make them post cash seems much but maybe not you know i don't know and if we're going to put all tier twos and threes, more or less under the conditional use permit?
[1:04:25] Speaker B (unidentified): I was talking to someone the other day that was buying a property locally that's sitting next to a solar farm. And the guy just wanted to buy the place he's going to put a convenience store on. And the guy selling wants to sell the solar farm, too, that's leased. And the lease is $25,000 a year. year and the guy was willing to sell it and it's a 20-year lease that's left the guy was willing to sell it for fifty thousand dollars and the guy buying the convenience store didn't want it and they finally agreed that he'd take it for twenty thousand but what that tells me is the only reason I can think you would be willing if you have that lease to sell it for a lot less than you're expecting in payments is because you're worried you're going to be stuck with the decommissioning because someone's not going to have the money at the end to pay to get rid of
[1:05:18] Speaker D (unidentified): the interesting the yeah that's weird i'll i'd buy 25 000 a year i'll take it for 20.
[1:05:27] Speaker B (unidentified): that's insane i think it's important to have the financial security because yeah we just found out the solar farm that the town has a piece of or we buy a power purchase agreement from is being sold i think for the second time since we've had an interest in it so i think things are going to be changing quickly as far as ownership potentially and we don't want to just have some sole asset llc that owns the thing that we've got no way to get our money back if they don't right
[1:06:00] Speaker A (unidentified): decommission it like you're supposed to yeah because what the heck are we gonna do with a big 10 megawatt battery right and that probably useless here too is a big battery
[1:06:12] Speaker D (unidentified): At least a solar farm, you can, you know, you can you can swap out, you know, put it out to bid. Somebody will swap out the panels and run it again. But I think the battery after 10 years is shot. So we'll look up the other bylaws again. I want to do more research on that. But that's my only real concern is like, are we being too draconian for small? Do we actually are we going to actually ask them? The planners wanted me to take out the bond language. language they would rather have a cash deposit escrow or letter of credit they said just cover the bond in other forms as may be found acceptable it's in other spots in the code so I said that's fine I'd rather not have a bond either but maybe for certain circumstances a bond is fine this is that section by the way if that lists all the penalties in the code 225 65 and 66. it gives the town the right to like issue fines, remove things like that. I don't know. We went through this financial surety stuff last time. Did I change anything? I think I had the financial surety last time. Yeah.
[1:07:33] Speaker A (unidentified): So we only have five minutes left.
[1:07:36] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm pretty close to being done. You want me just to wrap it up? I didn't change that much. Highlight reel. Yeah. It looks like all the stuff on the red you looked at last time. So don't worry, these aren't changes I've made. I just brought this up so you could see the comments. Again, they did not want the planning board to have the right to waive things generally. So I took that out, including this conditional use for site plan review approval waivers, which i agree with that was just being too creative and then on the ownership change which was the last one they were a little bit worried because we had revocation authority if they didn't notify the town if the owners changed and what would that mean would that mean it was abandoned it would make it complicated it was triggered decommissioning so i just changed to give a little more flexibility so that if a new owner didn't notify the town within 30 days, you know, the town may pursue any and all remedies, including revocation, but it wasn't required to. They could void the conditional use permit and all other local approvals and underlying conditions and re-estate of a void conditional use permit may be subject to the same review and approval processes for new applications under the code theory being like this was an awful site and got picked up by a new owner like and they didn't tell you for 90 days you could be you got a little leverage to fix things but if it was a good site and it was just an oversight you'd like it's the same site it's the same battery they just shifted it to a new owner it's fine we forgive you know just a little bit of not an automatic like your permits are
[1:09:44] Speaker B (unidentified): a vote because that didn't make it i think the other reason that's good is it's like you see that in foreclosure documents is you want the lend the lenders want to be able to decide what they call the default rather than having them automatically and they have to deal with it so
[1:09:57] Speaker A (unidentified): i think that's good so kurt when can our planners review this again do you want to do what you were going to do next week with your team of four and then have our planners review
[1:10:13] Speaker D (unidentified): view again that would be great let us you know we'll i'm gonna set josie and her colleagues out to just josie's compiling the new bylaws as of like three hours ago and i'm gonna divide it up i'm gonna just give them like one topic like one of them's gonna have setbacks put it in one of them's gonna have and that shouldn't be more than like what if we have the documents i think we can get that done in like a week so tell them a couple weeks we can get them a new document and then, you know, I can either talk to them, you know, whatever, you know, and then come back to you guys for your November meeting. And we should be, you know, I feel pretty good about it after today. I spent a lot of time looking at other towns bylaws and you can just see how varied they are, but it was, it was a good exercise.
[1:11:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. That sounds good. Thanks for all your
[1:11:12] Speaker B (unidentified): exactly josie you guys are doing a great job yeah it's really shaping up it's good it's you know
[1:11:19] Speaker D (unidentified): like we're we're yeah we're good at this stuff and we're you know experts if you will but like it's also like it's you learn a lot you know like you learn a lot about batteries and everything by going through this process so when's your next meeting do you have it set november 17th Okay. Oh, that's right. Because this one I pushed off because I was in Puerto Rico is very,, very excited about batteries down there.
[1:11:49] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm excited when we take a power down there.
[1:11:52] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, it's all about stabilizing the grid and the batteries are good for that when you have a lot of solar power. All right. So, 12th of November 17th, I will mark it down.
[1:12:08] Speaker A (unidentified): so maybe the week of november 9th we can meet with the planners yes i
[1:12:18] Speaker B (unidentified): don't think we're necessary let's say for some reason that this conflicts that can't happen i don't think it would necessarily be the end of the world if we invited the planners to the meeting on the 17th then we did it all live
[1:12:28] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah or it could be that we circulate the draft and they're like yep we've addressed everything maybe they don't even have much more to say yeah no they were good they were they were pleasant to
[1:12:42] Speaker D (unidentified): deal with it wasn't like this sucks i can't believe you're messing with our bylaw like this it was it was totally you know constructive so whatever works it
[1:12:52] Speaker B (unidentified): would be nice to kurt if you or someone else from the group could be available when we have that public meeting in december when we can try to work the day around your schedule yeah we'll come out for that we'll
[1:13:04] Speaker D (unidentified): drive out for that for sure and
[1:13:09] Speaker A (unidentified): then the crier if we want to advertise the meeting in the crier what's the deadline for getting that in november 50th november 15th so can we communicate via email to coordinate yeah to pick a date and draft the announcement for the you think that's okay so we'll do that over email before november 15th so maybe current if you guys could
[1:13:35] Speaker B (unidentified): kind of look at your schedules and like you probably have some finals too i'd imagine early december maybe suggest some dates in mid-december that might work or something okay yeah all
[1:13:48] Speaker D (unidentified): right josie we'll talk about that when the finals are and all that but i don't i don't have to worry about finals i'm just teaching clinic students this semester so it's fine with me whatever works great well we've got our marching orders and then we'll get this off to the planners and we'll come back with some good data for you guys so you can see and have some backup at town meeting for our reasoning for some of these things awesome thanks again
[1:14:18] Speaker B (unidentified): thanks a lot all right thanks everyone okay bye i think we'd actually send postcards we send to
[1:14:27] Speaker A (unidentified): like a butters of things yeah do you want to do that in addition to the carrier so for this
[1:14:32] Speaker B (unidentified): is probably anyone that applies to Piston Farm or the streets, you know, West Wind, Turkey Run, it's one with Lion Woods on the other, Jesse Lane. Some of the people, some of the streets that nearby would spend the postage on that because it's better to invite them now and get their comments in rather than wait, have it on up here at Town Beat and not at Heard. That's pretty cool.
[1:14:58] Speaker A (unidentified): And so for the postcards, we would probably have a little more time than the Cryer deadline. line right you guys have something you we as long as you know the date and the location you guys would yeah we don't need we don't need to draft that per se okay we just did some pretend
[1:15:17] Speaker B (unidentified): for growth because we're having a meeting on november 4th to talk about the design for the road but it probably something relatively small it was basically something like proposed battery storage ordinance at one point there was a proposed facility for the Bisson farm that may be future one so we're inviting you specifically anyone the town is welcome but something like that so we'll have a short paragraph we can do and put in the postcard okay at
[1:15:55] Speaker A (unidentified): that time I want to be respectful of everyone's time we just have the you know the kind of updating the webinar page on the website and I think the ball's in your court on that okay right Carl because you sent you sent Mark what he needs to update the web page
[1:16:22] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah it was a few weeks ago it doesn't include I've realized last night I it includes anything from the invasive plants presentation yet but we could always scalp that in because i know jackie you probably didn't have time to put that together but maybe stephanie you sent something out today as a draft well that's that's the social media post
[1:16:56] Speaker A (unidentified): right i've drafted the social media post but we don't want to publish we don't want to put that out there until there's a web page for people to go to find the link and the resources was that on me to do to add to that i can't remember because i thought that you had already drafted invasive plant stuff for the website no i don't remember let me go through and find what
[1:17:22] Speaker B (unidentified): what Carl did draft get it in let you guys know when it's in so you can look at it and then if we
[1:17:26] Speaker A (unidentified): need and then if we need to update for the okay so I think yeah so that sounds like good next steps so I don't think we're ready to do our social media posts until that's until we've sorted all
[1:17:36] Speaker E (unidentified): that and Mark you can access the Google Drive is that I think so yeah correct okay I'll define I think I linked it. But if it's, if it's not working, then just let me know.
[1:17:53] Speaker B (unidentified): What, I'll just chime in it wasn't working for me. So, I think I would let it at one point.
[1:18:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I don't think you have access I can try and know.
[1:18:06] Speaker E (unidentified): No, we'll let you in, Jeff, we'll let you in. I got all sorts of things you can look at.
[1:18:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, and then Nick, do we need to do anything right now for the community power or yeah, solar community power education session that we tentatively have in the spring? Do we need to talk about that or can we really keep focused on the battery stuff i think we should just stay focused on
[1:18:37] Speaker F (unidentified): the battery thing i have lost my contact over there so i'm digging at another contact i think she left the company or something so i'm kind of working on that so no rush okay
[1:18:53] Speaker A (unidentified): well i think that was everything on our agenda other than this any staff updates and any
[1:19:00] Speaker E (unidentified): introduction of new topics i think i did the staff update actually because i mentioned that
[1:19:04] Speaker B (unidentified): our solar farm that the energy committee had us get signed up for five years ago was being sold but it really doesn't affect us too much because our agreements are being honored as they were so okay that's and just executed the contract but thanks for carl's help to get the new furnace at the Public Works and they're working on that. So I think that's it.
[1:19:28] Speaker E (unidentified): Broken ground, so to say.
[1:19:30] Speaker A (unidentified): And then Jackie, the data center thing, is that an education session or were you thinking that there would be some other work related to that, which definitely would not be within our charter?
[1:19:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Right, I would be reluctant to do an education center. I was thinking center program without a whole lot more research, but you know what I was wondering is I'm seeing so much about it, and there's a just a lot of discussion pro con, you know, wrapped up with the Ai thing and I just wondered if that's something that at some point the energy committee should be thinking or the town let's put it this way the town should be looking at and at some point if they start to look at it that whether we should be involved which would make sense I think but one of the things that i saw is that the maine conservation voters has been working with towns writing well i think mostly moratoria the wording for moratoria to be voted on and that's what i thought maybe the town should be thinking about this before we get hit with a proposal that's all but that would be that I think as I mentioned in the email back the planning
[1:21:05] Speaker B (unidentified): board is it's on their radar to think about yes you mentioned that I also don't think there's that much of a risk of probably just about any town in Maine unless you have a real good power source getting a data center just because our rates are so bad in Maine so they're not going to put their data center in Maine and pay the rates so right okay if you do a moratorium it's mostly a temporary period of time so you can draft some ordinance that's right I think right now we're better off leaving that in the planning board's hands because like it's on their radar as far as
[1:21:37] Speaker E (unidentified): the table of uses and that's okay a good place to leave it for that so what when it's when you say
[1:21:43] Speaker A (unidentified): it's on their radar what does that exactly mean what will they be doing considering whether the zones they would want to put them in or not and things so any community members that wanted to influence or comment weigh in on that should talk to the planning board we had someone
[1:22:03] Speaker B (unidentified): come this past summer that said I was involved I being that person that I need with the group that did the moratorium in Brunswick and so now I want to have a moratorium they're actually from top zones so why did you have more terms of brother I don't know but they wanted to have more toward here and what I told them as I said again I don't think there's that much risk because we have such horrible electric rates you're not going to build one here because you can't afford it but if you wanted to you could address the select board and ask that they consider it but if you look at our things to draft ordinance for right now i think there's many higher priorities i think there's a hysteria in some ways around the data centers and in the states dealing with it on their level too so I think I tend to let the state deal with I'm sure this legislature is going to be addressing it let them deal with it with their level and I can tell you I've had you know there's no one right now planning data centers atop so and I think I think it's not likely to be so bad so I don't think we have to and if you wanted to address it you would need to go back and ask for a new charge because that isn't something that this committee
[1:23:19] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah and i don't think they have the bandwidth right now to take on anything more until after the town meeting in may and that's that's when our charge is up anyway so maybe jackie in the new year we just start talking about what the new charge could look like for this committee and plan to get that in place by June of 2027.
[1:23:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Actually, one last update I forgot is Rose has got an application from a potential new member who I think just moved into Highland Green and is a retired nuclear engineer. So if we were gonna have a data center discussion, it would be good to have him because the things I've heard, the times that they make sense is they have to have closed loop so you're not continuing bringing water out of the ground and you have to generate more power than you use and so maybe small nukes or something would be that but those sound like two pretty good thresholds is you're not taking power from the grid you actually have a potential to give some back at best but at worst you're not using
[1:24:32] Speaker A (unidentified): of our website so yeah and then short term jackie if you want to like maybe start building out a library of things that you're encountering yes i've already started that just like starting to educate because i just haven't i haven't read anything about this stuff so if we want to if we want to start thinking about the next charge i think let's start amassing materials to inform
[1:24:59] Speaker E (unidentified): form that decision okay yep all right i've studied how much how many homes we could heat with the waste energy from the data center maybe we can use it for district heating exactly
[1:25:17] Speaker A (unidentified): all right i think we're gonna just skip over review the agreements and we'll have those outlined in the minutes okay and the next meeting is November 17th and then we have some coordinating via email on Cryer timing for a potential meeting with the planning folks if that makes sense and when the vls vlgs folks are available for the December and I'm happy to help make sure those things get accomplished in the next couple of weeks. All right, we are adjourned.
[1:25:58] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm gonna stop the recording. Have a good day. Have a good night.