Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[8:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you hear us? I can hear everybody, but you can talk right now.
[8:36] Speaker B (unidentified): You got to hit the little button. There we go.
[8:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So these are working? Yeah, there we go. Okay, good. All right, so this is our Board of Appeals workshop. You can see we have a full attendance. We're missing a few people, but we're going to start anyway. This is not a regular meeting. This is a workshop to do a little training and revise our bylaws. Okay. So these are on. So that's good. So these are on, yeah. So as I was saying, what was I saying? Oh, yeah, you were saying how it's been less and less in the ordinance.
[9:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, yeah, there is not very much about the Board of Appeals in the ordinance. I mean, if you really want to know a little bit about what we're statutorily authorized to do, that's in the state law.
[9:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. OK, so this is a good summary of that is the MMA manual. Yeah. Yes.
[9:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. The MMA. Generally, they try to keep their stuff covered with any changes to this state law. But this area in terms of like DeNovo review versus appellate review, that's something that's left optional to the Bruce to the. And so, this recent change essentially reduced the scope of our review authority on an appeal. And you know, it takes some complication out also, but you know, there you have it. But that's, I think that's the only change. Change, I always was struck that there's very little about instruction to the Board of Appeals in the zoning ordinance. You know, it's kind of left to our bylaws. Right. Well, and when you
[10:46] Speaker A (unidentified): read the MMA, so Bruce, we've started, but that's okay. We're just. Oh, I thought it was time council going to come or anything like that. Okay, I didn't invite her. Oh, all right. Okay, I mean, we can, sorry, I didn't mean to say it that way, saving the taxpayers. Okay, yeah, it could be a first of, I'm not going to say several, but maybe one or two where we, you know, we kind of, so I've been on the board since 2020, and this is the first time we did this, so let's start there. And this is a public meeting, yes, so it's, it's broadcast, but, you know, it's not a regular meeting, and it's not hearing or anything, so I mean, we have to do it that way, but that's all. So we did it. There's been a notice that we were having a meeting properly, and off we go. So just what you have there, I, this is a, it's kind of a hodgepodge of stuff, but we'll kind of, We were just kind of talking about the bylaws. Bob was saying about little has been changed.
[12:04] Speaker C (unidentified): Is this redlined against the existing bylaws?
[12:08] Speaker A (unidentified): No, it's draft, but all it is I put it in Word. Okay. So I took what was, you know, if you had one off the website or if you looked at it there. Yeah. So it's now able to be edited. I don't know, from my recollection, I don't know, Bob maybe can add into here, my recollection of what I'm going to say would need to be updated here in this document is one section is having to do with the secretary and the recording secretary. I mean, it talks about a stenographer and it's not really current, but I mean, we could we could modify that I know what 's a good way to go through this should we
[13:00] Speaker B (unidentified): just go through like each section yeah you know I think if you if you if you scan through it you might find something that will stand out as that doesn't seem to be the way we do it or you know and one of the things is you know when you talk about officers and duties I can I can tell you know I mean I was off the board for about two years maybe but I had been on continuously for about 17 or 18 years so in that period of time we never had a
[13:47] Speaker A (unidentified): secretary the 18 years period yeah and that continued because I think I joined just when you stepped down right and then yeah and what we did have we had
[14:03] Speaker B (unidentified): someone analogous to Liz but was it was a part-time position Rene Johnson was handling the office work in terms of filing and scheduling and all of those kinds of things at the direction of the chair.
[14:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, she took care of the public notice.
[14:22] Speaker B (unidentified): That's right. She took care of the public notice. And during the meeting, we had a recording, I guess you would call it a recording secretary, but essentially analogous to, I think you just had a young lady join, or you've got somebody?
[14:44] Speaker A (unidentified): We had Brianna Lewis.
[14:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, we had Brianna.
[14:47] Speaker A (unidentified): And now we have Patience Horton, who does several boards. Patience, yeah. And she, well, her approach is a little different from Brianna's. I mean, what she considers her role. So that's fine and in fact she basically wants to kind of work as close to Robert's rules as she can in the way of creating minutes she just goes down through and make sure the right information is included you know that if you were to read I don't think I included it here but she mentioned a section of Robert's rules and I printed that out and reviewed it and yeah it's pretty straightforward you know the way you have to create minutes you know where when you know who was there who spoke you know was attendance taken all that stuff in the beginning and then basically it's a summary of what happened right
[15:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Right. Right. And, you know, in terms of minutes, it's not a, it doesn't have to be, it isn't because nobody has the time or money for a verbatim record of what we're doing. So it's going to be a summarize.
[16:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I did. I mean, so you sell it. I gave you. You know, and so I last week I had some spare time and I actually took the three or two and I think it was two and a half hour training course I saw my
[16:40] Speaker A (unidentified): certificate I think I took it in 22 I'm not sure it's very different so I 've
[16:45] Speaker C (unidentified): given you know Paula markup of sure and yeah I mean it's important to show I think that we go through when we're say judging criteria for approval of something you know if there are four or five eight criteria whatever spelled out that we have considered each one that we've either voted on each one or decided that the appeal or the request failed enough that we don't have to go further but we think you know that our decision-making is reflected and then when someone says something we should be clear who it was that was saying it if it's you know in the minutes yeah it doesn't have to be I don't think that's
[17:28] Speaker B (unidentified): to be much more than that I mean it's you know the thing is there's always been historically and I'm not suggesting we have to do it exactly the same way but only there's always been two sets of documents kind of going on there's been the minutes which who's in the room you know because those things are those were important sometimes in appellate rights and the ADB you know did somebody participate in the hearing or you know that sort of thing but then there's also what we have but we have finally determined so these are some they say they're final so they're i when we didn't have a person who was creating the record sometimes i backfilled that so i found some of these on my computer at home these are from like probably 2007 or thereabouts kind of time frame so and but typically those they're they're a summary But they try to get whatever it is we considered So there was documents, you know, we because we're not we're not identifying exhibits You know, we don't require that when we get a packet we didn't have the items in the packet identified with Anything like that? Okay, but in the summary of our findings of fact I have we always try to include a list of what was there So that's the first part of that is a listing Yeah, the packet and what's submitted to us by people that were at the hearing
[19:12] Speaker C (unidentified): It does seem like some duplication because they were they were pretty emphatic during this long course, you know, that the minutes should also reflect all that, you know, so because the courts reading the minutes as much as the findings of fact, right? You know, so how we got, like, for example, you know, we, interestingly, we often sort of take for granted that someone has standing, or that they don't have standing. They said, oh, no, you've got to vote on that, you know. Right.
[19:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Like, for example, that would be. Oh, so.
[19:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Was there a discussion about that?
[19:55] Speaker C (unidentified): About that they that you should not as a chairman be put in the position of, you know, seeming like you determine something because that's, you know, that puts that's a bad thing for your role, right? You're put in an awkward position that way. The board should, you're voting on it, you know, it's one thing after another, and that should all be in the minutes, whereas that might not turn up in the, I don't know whether it does in the findings of fact. I'm gonna
[20:21] Speaker B (unidentified): To learn. Well, I have stuff to learn about findings of fact. Well, see, the findings of the findings of fact were because we've done things sort of a, we don't generate it. Did I see those pop, is that the ones you were in, many cases under examples, I've seen there's there's a thought process that the board would generate the findings of that at the meeting itself. Okay, we never found there was ever time to do that properly. Okay, so they were always done in a draft, and then the following meeting that Draft would be revised and then voted upon. So you we actually have two votes in most cases. This is an interesting complication, by the way. So you've got the vote at the meeting and then in the findings of fact get approved the next meeting. All right. Yes, and now excuse me, just stop you a second. So the votes you're
[21:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Talking about is the vote at the meeting is the vote on the motions. There's
[21:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Actually I don't know if it's if there's on the bottom of those, but there is, it would sometimes there would be, you would see a note, it would say that they were approved at a particular meeting by a vote, and the vote recorded for the approval of the minutes and the findings of fact. So you're right, the minutes have always struck me, they're sort of duplicative.
[21:52] Speaker C (unidentified): It's overlap, for sure.
[21:53] Speaker B (unidentified): They're overlap, but the minutes never had any of that detail in it. Coming back from the things like standing, the decision on standing, usually if you look in there, you'll probably see a note that, you know, it was determined there was standing, that's a relevant fact. It's it's yeah, I think they were usually as a kept separate section or separate item on there, that the same thing with it, you know. Some of these go back pretty far, so I clean them up through the years. We got It's got a little bit better, I hope. But if there's not a determination of standing, there should be one. Timeliness also. So I wanted to get those down in writing, and then subsequently they'd be voted upon when you're approving that whole thing. So you've got the standing, you've got the timeliness, who is present, you know, in terms of who is voting on any motions. If there were multiple motions, they would be recorded. So are you are you suggesting that the minutes need not contain information only if we can figure out a way to get a person doing minutes, they you know, if you cover those things in the hearing, yeah, okay, on the floor of the hearing, and you can clean, you know, You can keep your thoughts organized enough. Yeah, then they could be right in the minutes, and it would be in Okay. So then you wouldn't have to do it twice. But just keeping with the practice of how it was done, because we didn't have, I mean, I went for a long time where I wasn't getting Anything back from the person who was doing your minutes, doing the minutes, okay? So I was writing minutes and findings, right? Which is, by the way, is a fair amount of work. I was sitting there listening to the videotapes and stuff like that, you know, at 3 in the morning, you know, they get to be old, I'll tell you. That's why I left the board when I did. I was burned out.
[24:16] Speaker C (unidentified): It was interesting, I mean there is overlap, and it seems at first it seems sort of like wasteful to me that there be overlap, and yet the same, like from what, again from what I learned and just instincts, you know, you know, you've probably done minutes in other contexts over the years. You know, it seems like to not have in the minutes that, for example, standing was considered and this determination was made, right, that's like a, it's a big gap, you know, it's not a
[24:49] Speaker B (unidentified): good record of the meeting at that point but generally speaking yeah you know in defense of that if you had the findings of fact more than just a simple findings of fact there's quite a lot all of that other stuff is in there for sure so when the when a court is considering it they 've got that as a summary And the minutes were really very humbling. So the minutes you might just say someone standing was discussed and someone testified and so forth.
[25:25] Speaker A (unidentified): So an oppression I've had, like, go ahead.
[25:30] Speaker B (unidentified): What I was going to say is it doesn't have to be that way. It has been.
[25:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, you had several factors that dictated that, the recording secretary.
[25:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, and I sort of inherited how it was being done, too.
[25:45] Speaker A (unidentified): But my impression kind of from some of the superior court things we've had where it went off and then it came back was that the minutes weren't really that important to the court.
[26:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Right. Oh, that's interesting. So, yeah, that course was just, you know, it was very, it's a very different take on that. But that's, you know.
[26:11] Speaker A (unidentified): And then, you know, if you consider, like, in the manual, okay, now these people, these attorneys that run that course are working, you know, they're the people that keep this up to date. This is only an excerpt from it, but having to do with the findings.
[26:27] Speaker B (unidentified): One of the things, I think, Bruce, my thought on it was this board here in York was not able to get a set of minutes that had all of the detail in it and be revised enough to be voted on. So I think they developed a system in the findings of fact that all.
[26:54] Speaker A (unidentified): To put the votes there.
[26:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, the votes, the people.
[26:57] Speaker A (unidentified): If you look at this one in particular, like, for instance, I include these in. These are ones from, what's the date of this one? So, you know, you start out, okay, here's who the appellant is, and then you have, you know, what did we have that we had in our packet, okay? Right. This is the one that says sample. It's Mark Lawrence. I don't know if you remember this one. It was up near 95 there that where he put the foundation in and it was too close to the, oh yeah, I agree, I do. So this was a minor dimensional variance thing. So basically here's the first, the first paragraph gives us or the second paragraph gives us what it is we had to look at, okay, all the different documents, then they, you know, they were asking for a minor dimensional variance and that it says exactly what he wanted, he needed to have that setback reduced to 47 so that easily what it was the Corner of the foundation was too close to the to the right of way. So then the relevant section is the ordinance. That's so these are basically you're starting with the simpler facts and you're moving to the more important ones. So you so you guys would be in favor of sort of a lighter style of minute ticking, right? Well and in all that and looking to the work that patients has to do the if as you can see. So then you have the relevant facts, you know, all the different things, you know how it came about that he did that, you know, that the state-owned part of the land and you know was it had been turned over to the town and all that. And then further so then as far as the standards for accepting the variance, so here we in the meeting we went through each one and voted on them. So you can see the different four standards there and everybody voted and then and then it was approved. And then from this so then we had a motion at the end to approve the variance with conditions. Well I guess we didn't have any conditions, it was just changing that number. We had another one which I have which I also gave you, it's the one with the red. That one had conditions but in any case you know that's what's adequate for I think for the court. I mean if this was for whatever reason if we denied a variance or an appeal and they went to the Superior Court, you know, this is the kind of information they want. So that all makes sense. There's only one like one
[29:51] Speaker C (unidentified): thing that I would you know at least in some circumstances if I were a judge I'd be asking you know what did what did the parties say. See that's that's that's
[30:06] Speaker B (unidentified): what has been in the in the minutes, yeah. There have been sometimes off and on the minutes have contained that information, yeah, depending upon who is the they don't really have a title, their recording secretary I guess, but depending upon how much detail they chose to put in the minutes that may be there or may
[30:32] Speaker C (unidentified): not. Well you know so that's sort of I'm making this comment sort of without regard to who write something down or how many people then put eyes on it and revise it. Just like okay so here you know you made a determination that it was impossible to make a return on the property if not for that variance. What was said to make you reach that conclusion, you know, that seems like something the court will want to know.
[31:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, typically just specifically on that particular one, you know, it had to do with a distance to the road. And actually we had to continue that because we didn't, we didn't have a definite reply from the town that the town actually owned that land, because it had been owned by the state. It was, it was something that was picked up when they built 95. So along 95 they had all these lots of land that the state ended up, I guess, taking by eminent domain, I don't know. But for whatever reason, the state owned it, and then at some point in time they had turned it over to the town, and the town, you know, just had it there. And I guess what, they weren't using it as a, the homeowner or the owner of the land wasn't allowed to measure to where he needed to measure, he was prevented by that little, it was just a slice of land. And as it turned out, that's why, that gave us reason to say, oh, wait a minute, that's never gonna be developed. You can use that and we'll vary the setback the three feet you need.
[32:24] Speaker B (unidentified): One of the things I think in the findings of fact, I mean, you've got the relevant law and then relevant facts. When you see facts in there, it's not that's what we were told, it's that's what we accepted and found, documents that were provided, the testimony, right, yes. You know, sometimes testimony is contradictory, mm-hmm, okay, but what goes on this sheet is what we decided is the facts to base the decision upon. So that's, you know, so it's a decision document, really. So I don't know that it's, you know, from that point of view, it's a little different than the minutes. The minutes are, the minutes really, if they were, you know, depending on how extensive they are, they would really be what was presented to us, period.
[33:20] Speaker A (unidentified): You know, I don't know if it came up in the-
[33:23] Speaker B (unidentified): And what was discussed by us in addition.
[33:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't know if it came up in the webinar, but the one I took, I found these documents in my packet that I had gotten from them back when. And it's a few articles having to do, and the title says, Minutes Are Not Findings. And so over the years, court cases have ended up in Superior Court, and they had found that boards of appeals and even planning boards had been just relying on their minutes as their findings. And they had remanded many cases back to those people and said, no, you have to write findings. And then that's where, like if you look at this section of the manual, it comes back and it's findings of fact and conclusions of law. So when a question in my mind never segregate it, sometimes they will run together. Exactly in my mind I'm realizing our findings, the way we write them, is basically, well, it's a little bit of findings, a little bit of facts at the beginning, and also a mixture of this is the law we used, because when we say the relevant section of the zoning ordinance, that's so that's basically the law. Yeah.
[34:46] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I think that's important. I mean, fine, you know, as long as the court with those two documents can reconstruct everything it needs to do, then.
[34:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, well, the thing about, I guess, from a practical point of view, Bruce, you've got, at least in my experience, we have not had support with someone who is a reporter. Right. I mean, if you had a court reporter, I mean, you know, they summarize things. They know what 's going on with the case. So they'll they'll get They'll give you a summary that is useful for purposes of supporting the determination But generally we get something that is kind of whatever came across the microphone
[35:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I don't think there's any question that whoever Try whoever takes down whatever we're calling them a stenographer whatever it is you know someone on the board then has to look at it and massage it into it you know right whatever format you guys like i've had
[35:48] Speaker A (unidentified): the conversation i've been having with patients because she's i'll have to say she's expert at this because she's been doing it for a while and does it for many different boards is you know i don't i don't know if we want her to necessarily have to put all the detail of the votes, she can indicate in the minutes there was a motion and a vote, and the vote was
[36:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. So again, when I did what I did, which now seems like it was overkill for the style you actually want, but regardless of that, I wasn't saying, oh, Patience didn't do her job. It's impossible to take all that down.
[36:29] Speaker A (unidentified): well and she and i had a conversation with her about that and she was a bit defensive of it when the first time we had a conversation then after some reflection she realized yeah that's going to be okay yeah the approach right well yeah i mean and again it
[36:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Wasn't like it was just okay here's where the end result like so the farther she can get us along the path to having the content in that we need. So that, for example, to do what I did, I had to go back, look at the video, and say, okay, who was saying that? There were a couple moments when someone said something and I couldn't remember who said, you know, so okay, went back and did that, and I found it. The more she can get in some of that detail, I don't think she has to record, you know, Paul voted yay and Bruce voted yay, whatever.
[37:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, and to that point, so I'll go to the next, so she did the minutes for this last, the administrative appeal, the hedger appeal, and she had trouble understanding some decisions, and then I said to her, oh, I'll go in and I'll look and I'll get you the answers. Well it wasn't so easy you know when you realize when she's trying to do the minutes and you realize okay during the meeting we needed to be much more clear about I mean she mentions about things as simple as people's names yep luckily in that case they were all butters so I just went into the GIS map yeah I kind of remembered the names and I found all the names for her and you know who they were what their address was and all that, but.
[38:21] Speaker C (unidentified): It's got to be a collaborative effort. You know, we can't expect 100% from any person who is in real time trying to take all this down.
[38:28] Speaker A (unidentified): And in addition, findings of fact don't capture when we start the meeting by when we vote on minutes and such and such. They're not in findings of fact. They're in the minutes because that's where they're supposed to be.
[38:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Right, because you're voting on the findings of fact from another meeting. Yeah. Okay so you want to get a part yeah so that's all in minutes yeah that's what it is and
[38:54] Speaker C (unidentified): On timing the course did they talked about timing the preparation yeah I was like no that's what we do you know I guess some boards have the resources there's someone present and by the time
[39:07] Speaker B (unidentified): The meeting's over oh this they can sign off yeah you know I mean we I go back to a long time ago I was in the JAG business and we do if a court-martial was a special court-martial well the record was going to be summarized okay on the other hand if it was a general court-martial and then and there was confinement for over a particular period of time then it was going to be verbatim okay so we would have court reporters that were enlisted tech specialists. And they were not trained like a court stenographer. Rather, they were trained to work with a steno mask. So they had opened my tape recording of what was going on. But in the steno mask, they were recording who was speaking, the times.
[40:04] Speaker A (unidentified): That's wild. Did you ever know that from the?
[40:07] Speaker B (unidentified): So, you know, they then, you know, so you could, if you had to put the record back together again after they prepared it, you could see, you know, what was coming from the steno mask and what was open mic in the courtroom. And, you know, the two of those things put together is what created the record. And then they were actually at that time, so long ago, they were hand-typed.
[40:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So that was tape recorded so that the testimony would be through a mic and then the steno mask was another mic and it was they were on like separate tracks on the tape.
[40:52] Speaker B (unidentified): You would have to go back and forth and listen to two tapes.
[40:56] Speaker C (unidentified): It was at the age of the typewriter too so you had two tapes and.
[41:01] Speaker B (unidentified): You know at that time was early days of word processing so the word processor was a IBM Selector typewriter that had a mag card reader attached to it and so you would create a magnetic record that they would print out a draft of somebody have to sit down and read that you have to read that mark make changes to it so forth yeah it you know yeah.
[41:34] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean there's I mean it to me like what does the secretary the secretary do if there's a secretary right the secretary would be the person that gets the raw whatever the sonographer typed up she did her best he did her best his best whatever it is and then the secretary who has you know more knowledge of how the board works and how it decides and has taken notes and we all take notes but whatever massages that into the minutes that you want. And then, I presume, the findings of fact also then get prepared. And however much content you want in one or the other, that's not even time. But on the timing thing, it was interesting. So they said sometimes had the real time. By the end of it, they could pretty much sign off. Others, they did, it was still interesting. There was sort of an expectation that something was really close to final form and like within a few days they yeah they had it but you know we take longer but I don't know how they do it you know we I think this is the best we can do here right with the resources we have available well.
[42:45] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, that's that's the caveat. I mean, if you have someone that works full-time doing support for this board, you know, well, there you're going to have that in time for the next meeting. You know, we don't have a lot of time between the first meeting and the second meeting of the month.
[43:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. So. Yeah, that's a crunch, the way it works. Sometimes you have, like this last month, we had three weeks until between, what was it, September and the October meetings. There was a long gap. So, you know, that's at least okay.
[43:20] Speaker B (unidentified): I've got another. Yeah, that helps out a little bit.
[43:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, but instituting the record of decision that I've been doing now for the last two meetings takes the heat off of preparing the findings of fact, although they still need to be prepared. And if we had a variance, we definitely need to have them done because the person needs the variance to –
[43:44] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm not remembering this exactly, so pardon me. I have notes at home and I should have brought them. But the moment that something is approved, for example, the recordable document for a variance or the findings of fact, that's when the party's appeal period begins. So you actually do want to delay approval of those documents until they are really ready. It's not from the time we take the vote. It's from the time we issue the document. Him into the so it's helpful to the parties. Yeah, how much time do they have
[44:24] Speaker A (unidentified): to go to Superior Court afterward? It's is it 45 days? So yeah, and this is something I've getting gotten tripped up on a few. Well, first of all, is the record of decision, so that's seven days. Yeah, so that's why I created different
[44:46] Speaker C (unidentified): from, you know, variance is one thing and a denial of an appeal is another thing. And so if their appeals period, I forget how it goes, but they trigger the appeals
[44:54] Speaker A (unidentified): period. You mean a reconsideration? Well, reconsideration is, yeah, well, that's for
[45:00] Speaker C (unidentified): us, right? That's our ability to reconsider, right? Well, no, they have to
[45:04] Speaker B (unidentified): request it. They have ten days to request reconsideration, and then we have to make a decision on the reconsideration within, I don't have it off the top of my head. I'm getting old. Here it is. I used to have it off the top of my head.
[45:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you know where it is in there?
[45:34] Speaker B (unidentified): 10 days, the request for reconsideration is 10 days from the decision.
[45:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, so that's right at the meeting.
[45:42] Speaker B (unidentified): That's it, at the meeting. So they have 10 days,
[45:45] Speaker A (unidentified): within 10 days they have to
[45:46] Speaker B (unidentified): And then the reconsideration by the board has to have been completed within 45 days of the date of the vote on the original decision. So sometimes this one, if you miss a meeting, you can be in a real bind.
[46:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, that's what's happening to us. We had a reconsideration a year or so ago, and if we don't schedule it, 's almost like you have to schedule, even if you don't have applications, you have to schedule a meeting. Because if something happens where you have a reconsideration boom, it just drops in there and you have to treat it or you're going to run out the timeline. Well, the other thing too is
[46:30] Speaker B (unidentified): if you're doing the practice like we do where you have a draft findings of fact that are voted on at the next meeting, you know, findings of fact from one meeting, they're, they're reviewed by the board. Any changes put in and then voted on, right? You need to get that accomplished so that the, if there's an appeal, that 's if they go to the Superior Court. They go to the Superior Court. Yes, that goes with them. You know, I mean, it's been, I've seen it done. Without it, you know, they file the adb appeal based upon what happened at the, at the meeting and then maybe they amend their file. How does that work? So a person
[47:18] Speaker A (unidentified): walks away from here with an denial, is there a form like with the Superior
[47:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Court that they can complete to know what happens? Well, as the section under Maine law is ADB, Maine General Law is something or other ADB. And so they file a pleading with the Superior Court and I think, you know, there's probably a standard pleading form, but it's the narrative of it is done by the attorney or by the individual, whoever is filing the appeal. So there is no, I don't think there's a form per se, so much as somebody has got it in their word processor and, you know, they are all.
[48:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Does it have to have like a legal format? Because you see how, you know, the documents are, have for the courts, they have this very standard. [Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, I think.] Payout, you need an attorney to complete that for you, basically, in order to make a pleading?
[48:30] Speaker B (unidentified): No, you can probably get enough information from the clerk of the court to let you know what their rules are that they normally follow. And there's general standards for pleadings from the Superior Court, and you just format it that way. Once you once you've done the first one you know they all kind of become more similar. Bruce, your experience with our appeals, you've been involved with like an ADB appeal in maybe in another state? No, so this is my first experience with
[49:19] Speaker C (unidentified): all of this stuff. Okay. Yeah, so my law practice has been completely unrelated to all of this. Oh, as was mine. Yeah, so this is a, I'm learning as I go. My end use. Yeah, all that, never, touched that stuff. Mine was government contracting. Yeah, so I've done a little bit of that, but more, you know, corporate and regular business contracts and so this is only okay. But so actually in light of the discussion that we were having, I'm sorry I didn't catch what you were just doing, but it seems to me like D&E in this draft in these bylaws they're very specific about what a stenographer does versus and I might be more general like I might say the secretary is responsible for the keeping of all of these things and the creation of these records and let the mechanical workings of how the sonographer works with office staff and so on be a little bit more fluid because
[50:18] Speaker B (unidentified): it's not happening this way. Yeah, what's written here is not happening and as far as I can
[50:24] Speaker C (unidentified): tell, yeah, never did never did and probably never will, you know. Right, and then paragraph E seems to there seems to be a lot of overlap between D and E. I'm not you know I haven't quite put my finger on it yet, but you know all board proceedings versus a record of all resolutes so there's sort
[50:41] Speaker B (unidentified): of like there's overlap there and again there's a stenographer and a secretary. Yeah, like the last
[50:51] Speaker A (unidentified): they the secretary shall also see that the stenographer arranges proper and legal notice of hearings that it doesn't happen that way, right? I mean we should put in what actually happens
[51:03] Speaker C (unidentified): shouldn't we or just be more general like see that these things are done, you know, and then and how it happens can change. You know, right now it seems like office staff does a lot, you know, and the stenographer does other things.
[51:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, and the chair does a lot of these things. And the chair does a lot, yeah.
[51:21] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, there's never been a secretary, which is, you know, a secretary is a member, a permanent member of the board, huh? Well, we haven't had one of those. But in addition, we haven't always had a stenographer either. No.
[51:38] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that your bylaws should be such that when you can take advantage of resources like a sonographer, you do so. If you don't have one at a particular time, you're not in violation of your bylaws. You just don't say it in the bylaws.
[51:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, that's a good point, to get drafted that way.
[51:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, this is super specific.
[51:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, and because it was so specific and it hadn't been being followed, right? Right, I know at least in my time when I was chair, you know, it didn't trouble me a great deal because first off, I know nobody was gonna pay the, nobody was going to fund it. Right. So, and people don't work for free a lot of times.
[52:22] Speaker A (unidentified): F is, this is really, the way the town does it is the town contacts the chair and says, here's your budget, do you need any change? And basically it's and that's a lot I mean from my business experience that's a lot how it worked with your like if you had a department in a company in a company the you know the financial department's going to send you a note and say yeah we're getting ready to put the budget together here's your budget yeah what changed you know what you mark it up and get it back to us and then it gets included in the draft budget and then goes from there.
[53:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Usually in your budget cycle, you're going to give somebody what your spending was the previous year, however much detail is appropriate, and then they're going to come back with a proposal for the coming year.
[53:25] Speaker A (unidentified): And my experience with the town and with the Board of Appeals is there are two things that we spend money on. We spend money to send out a butter notices, which is very expensive, and then we pay the recording secretary to do their job. In both cases there are expenses we're never hitting our budget.
[53:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Does our body cover like a share of Liz's time or something like that?
[53:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I expected that to be the case, but it's not. Not the case. And it wasn't before, I think, at one time. Because we had Renie Johnson for years. Yeah.
[54:14] Speaker B (unidentified): Renie was secretary for the Board of Appeals and the Harbor Board. Right. Okay. Okay, so she was in both the Board of Appeals and the Harbor Board's budgets, a piece of her, I believe. And I never knew anything on the salaries, so I don't know what the allocation was. It had been allocated, obviously, from the accounting section of the town, and so we got an allocation, right not the exact not necessarily the exact 50 split or whatever. In addition, we would get some billing for the postage, okay. Now right now the board of appeals actually had separate lines in the budget and they were never hit, they were never hit, and I don't think they exist anymore. Now it's like I think that's been folded into the codes, it's either in code or
[55:20] Speaker A (unidentified): planning or even that's all just one big bucket, even code and planning, although there's a lot of employees there, so I'm I'm wondering how they actually account for that, like when
[55:35] Speaker B (unidentified): when I first became but it doesn't affect board of appeals when I first became chair I remember getting a copy when they were proposing a new budget. I got a copy of the budget with a with a you know maybe one or two lines, that's all it is still, what of appeals, and asked to comment on it, which you know since you know we know where the allocations are coming from you really don't have a year ago I went
[56:01] Speaker A (unidentified): in and met with is it Wendy as the financial director and we talked about the very things I'm just mentioning. I never see where at that time Brianna's time is accounted for and I never see where the postage is accounted for, which is the two big things that we do, and it was like okay yeah now since then I
[56:28] Speaker B (unidentified): think probably since you became chair not tonight at your behalf but there's I believe that there isn't really a separate Board of Appeals line in there anymore.
[56:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, there is still a line. Oh, is there? Yes, there is, yes. All right, then I'm incorrect. In fact, it's still there, and it has about $2,000 in it, but nothing ever hits it.
[56:50] Speaker B (unidentified): It used to be substantially larger than that.
[56:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, well, it isn't anymore. So I think over the years, whoever was running the finances, maybe it was, I forget her name, but going they just nailed it pushed it in with another group another budget because it was too small to account for, that's probably what it came comes down to, like if the postage is like a few thousand dollars in the whole size of the town budget they just said well let's let's account for it over here because they have to code all those expenses, so it's a matter of sub
[57:28] Speaker B (unidentified): accounts and then sub-accounts that are going to be consolidated as they roll with us.
[57:33] Speaker A (unidentified): So that's F. That's the whole thing with F. It can be modified. We don't give it to the selectman. We give it to the financial director, and that's how the town does it.
[57:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, we'll provide to the appropriate town official. Town official, yeah. but
[57:56] Speaker A (unidentified): so I wanted to come back to that the discussion about standing you know in this timing timeliness the timeless is pretty easy thing you know can't you count the days you just make sure you measuring from the same plan but I was reminded and I happen to be because I have I put all the forms in a thing here just so i could look back at them once in a while the if the person is if the appellant is not the landowner they have to complete this form and honestly when i thought about it i was like i haven't seen that form in a while although i have to think back who the we did there was something who like for instance the kuzak yeah one we had you remember i thought two ago yeah i think that he was not the property owner yeah so he should have completed this form
[58:59] Speaker C (unidentified): you know i you know i don't know right i don't know the answer to what you're saying except it seems to me that someone comes and presents the same information to us and we hear it that should also be okay right like you yeah well but I wouldn't deny somebody standing based on the form bureaucratic requirement that they might
[59:23] Speaker A (unidentified): have omitted well we had that with the Wigley Bridge one the fungus yeah we had a long discussion about standing there because he was not a he was not he was not the property owner no he was in a butter yeah so he needed to complete this form he had to show that he had a direct and personal injury remember that's what he had he had completed some sort of statement okay he wrote his own yeah and so that's where mary kind of chimed in and said the substances it's not the right form but he presented it yeah you
[1:00:06] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, I mean, some of the case law, it uses the words particularized injury. Right. Okay. Exactly. And that's what you need to be able to show that for standing, if they're not in a butter, you know, that they have a particularized injury. You know, for example, in the newspaper, I don't. A tree.
[1:00:27] Speaker A (unidentified): A tree. Yeah, she lost out because of that.
[1:00:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Because she lost out on standing. She couldn't prove no particularized injury. Exactly. Well, there's a four-step test, apparently, according to the newspaper, because the thing I was, you know, obviously that was not an appeal that went to the Board of Appeals. That was an action. Yeah. It was an appeal, an ADB. She claimed it to be an ADB appeal. That's what the newspaper said. It was an action. But it was an action and a decision by the town, not by us, not by going through the Board of Appeals. But in any case, it still has to be able to show that they have standing.
[1:01:16] Speaker C (unidentified): But, you know, just back to the forms. So, like, who prepared the forms? Like, you know, is there anything in the ordinance that says they have to fill out X form? No. Right. So I think you wouldn't want to be put in the position of someone going to Superior Court and saying, I was denied an opportunity to have my appeal heard because I didn't fill out a form. Even though I was there and ready to tell them all the reasons I had standing, they didn't even want to hear that. I didn't fill out a form. That form is probably something someone prepared because it's convenient. It helps everybody to get the information.
[1:01:51] Speaker B (unidentified): I think we can require the form to be filled out. Yeah, but if we haven't done so, you know, or made it clear that it was a requirement, right, I mean.
[1:02:01] Speaker C (unidentified): you could you could say go fill it out we'll put you on the agenda for a future meeting you could do that right then it's up to you know like board members are prepared they've read the materials they're ready to go other people have shown up you could do that right well and i 'm i think
[1:02:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Think back to accepting somebody's standing as just being an abutter, an abutter to the property. And that's not necessarily enough.
[1:02:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, it depends on, like, the ordinance has a definition. And that night, that man with the Wiggly Bridge thing, it seemed to me, looking at the definitions in the ordinance, seemed to me that he had standing. But I might have been wrong. That was my thought.
[1:02:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, in the ordinary course of events, a direct abutter is going to have standing. But I think you're exactly right. I don't think that's always true because there may be certain things that simply being in close proximity, touching the corner of the property, may not give you that particularized injury. It's the test that's in the statute that counts. Yes.
[1:03:13] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, yeah. I mean, yeah. There could be different situations. I think that night, all he had to prove, it seemed to me, was he was either a direct abutter or he was within a certain distance and all that.
[1:03:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, that's the rule about so many feet.
[1:03:30] Speaker C (unidentified): And there was some debate about that, the facts.
[1:03:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, but as an administrative board, you can probably rely 90% of the time, if they're a direct abutter, they're going to have standing. Right. 90% of the time. But there might be...
[1:03:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Does that mean they have direct and personal injury?
[1:03:46] Speaker B (unidentified): By default, I mean there's, there's an implication that if you're direct a butter that whatever the person is doing that you're appealing, you know, may have an impact on you. I was likely to have an impact on you because you're
[1:04:01] Speaker C (unidentified): very close, suffered or will suffer. Yeah, I mean, I can go grab it, but it seemed to me like there were two, there were two ways to achieve standing. One was being in a butter, and the other was being able to show that you stood to, you know,
[1:04:15] Speaker A (unidentified): be harmed. Yeah, well, there are two here. I don't know if you want to go down that your actual use or enjoyment of your property will be adversely affected by the police project, or to show some other personal interests which will be affected, directly affected, which is different from that
[1:04:34] Speaker C (unidentified): suffered by the general public, right? So that seemed to me that's a complementarity, or It would be hard, like, if someone is a direct abutter, the fact that they, you know, it's probably enough, right?
[1:04:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, well, I mean, if you think about it, say you get something that's an aerosol, okay? It's, you know, well, if you're a direct abutter, you're probably more likely than anyone else in the town to be affected by the aerosol, if that was the case. case. So, you know, as I said, perhaps in most cases, there are going to be, you know, parallels, very, close. But there may be a circumstance in which an argument can be made. And sometimes there's case law that is what the court uses to determine, you know, does this amount to the particularized injury or not? And, you know, I mean, you have to take, you know, I've, if there's attorneys involved at our meeting, they'll sometimes present case law like that, right? Okay, we haven't had that in a while. No, we haven't, but I think we will in
[1:05:46] Speaker A (unidentified): our, there's a, there's a instance in our next meeting where you'll get the information, but I've seen the packet, and yes, it's presented by an attorney.
[1:05:59] Speaker B (unidentified): And sometimes they will end up getting information presented to us, and we'll have to make a determination on what the law is within the bounds of what they've presented to us. But it's like in a variance, for example. you know in the variance situations there 's always the question about you know is that a reasonable return you know well there's lots of case law are out there yes it's pretty well established but you know we get lots of arguments that you know they don't bear out they don't pay any attention to the state's case law they still go for the yeah and yeah i was even yeah
[1:06:54] Speaker C (unidentified): In this in this webinar there was, it's a strict standard Portland case maybe, but someone had built the whole building and it was too close, it was over the setback, and they said you lose. They did not grant the variance. Yeah, we had one up on Mountain Road.
[1:07:15] Speaker A (unidentified): It was like two years or so ago as this couple it poured a foundation. Did they pour it or it was they bought the land and it was already existing I think or something. They wanted a variance because it was it violated the setback. Yeah.
[1:07:39] Speaker B (unidentified): But you know, I mean the thing is does it you know, does the property but it's usually the reasonable, you know, he lacks a reasonable return. You know, that, you know, if you can put a picnic table on it, that's been, that's been, that's been determined. [Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, exactly.] You don't have to be able to build a house on it.
[1:08:05] Speaker D (unidentified): I can't buy that. Sorry.
[1:08:12] Speaker C (unidentified): Like this case in South Portland, it was the builder had made an error. It wasn't even them. It wasn't their architect. It was just a human error. And I don't know what the aftermath was. It would be interesting to go for, like, did the builder's insurer respond on that? Like, what happens? They must have had to tear down that structure, substantially modify it.
[1:08:37] Speaker B (unidentified): But the occasion that you have to have this structure removed or what have you is, you know, I can tell you if it makes you feel any more comfortable. In the time I've been on the board, that's been a very, exceptional, odd circumstance. And, you know, out of I don't know how many cases, you know, I can think of maybe one or two.
[1:09:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Where a building had to be. Something had to be. Oh, where it was.
[1:09:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, where there was no variance that could be granted and, you know, the building was over a line, and usually there the problem becomes your own fault, you know, and, you know, there have been a couple of those in York, but not many.
[1:09:23] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, you have to imagine this, again, I'm just, whatever, this case struck me so much because at various stages, town inspectors would have come and signed off on things. Right. And at no point did anyone spot this, and they completed the structure, and then they were told they needed a variance, and they couldn't get it. That must have been, again, it's like life-changing for those people. Anyway.
[1:09:50] Speaker A (unidentified): That becomes a hardship but I guess
[1:09:53] Speaker C (unidentified): but it's not the kind of hardship that
[1:09:55] Speaker B (unidentified): if it's if it's if it's not by the owner or by one of his predecessors if it's by the owner or one of his predecessors an interest then you're stuck you're stuck you know you can't doesn't meet the criteria now sometimes you know their towns may act to fix those situations or, you know, but, anyway.
[1:10:25] Speaker A (unidentified): So, like, for revising the bylaws, I mean, does it make sense that we would go off each and have our own edit and then come together?
[1:10:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. We have people on here I'm sure each of us would like a moment to you know but I mean generally speaking I would say you know I'm thinking of like corporate balance to like so I look at something like you know we're gonna hold a meeting every second and fourth Wednesday of the month you know if one day you want to have one week you have to have it on a Tuesday you know and you give adequate advance notice to everyone and whatever well that's it where's that oh yeah so does it go on to have well My only point is sometimes bylaws can be too prescriptive like corporate bylaws always used to do they would say the annual meeting will be you know the second tuesday of march every year and you just knew 95 of your clients we're never ever going to do that right and so instead you know more modern bylaws we'll say like in massachusetts it's you got a hold of within the first six months after the end of your fiscal year right okay so in other words the more flexibility you can offer to yourself yeah the better because you're not hurting anyone right there's still notice requirements and but it's all that so it's just things like that i don't think there's anything you get you've got
[1:12:07] Speaker B (unidentified): you've got you know this some things in here before you before you take them out and it and it doesn't include what we were just talking about but there are some things that are that are actually required by the state law exactly you have to go in the bylaws yes yeah well i mean yeah i guess they probably should be just so somebody doesn't stumble into it well
[1:12:31] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, yeah, so I noticed, for example, we've got, like, the hardship stuff in here. I don't know. Is that a requirement, that it be in the bylaws of the board, or is it just to get every board member thinking more about it?
[1:12:40] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it's just to get everybody thinking about it, but I don't believe that it's accurate right now. There is an error in the bylaws that got pointed out to me. I forget who pointed it out. Maybe Michelle. Page three.
[1:13:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Is that in the appeal procedure?
[1:13:06] Speaker C (unidentified): It's on page three of the file.
[1:13:08] Speaker B (unidentified): it's on yeah it's on page three and above the meeting section oh
[1:13:21] Speaker A (unidentified): this is all the idea of how to we treat a variance yeah it seems like an odd thing to put it before standards are
[1:13:30] Speaker B (unidentified): there so maybe they don't even need to be but there's a there's they may not need to be but there's there's a slight there's a slight difference in the wording between that and
[1:13:42] Speaker C (unidentified): in the ordinance code. See, this is the sort of thing that gets you into trouble, like get trouble, I mean, I'm overstating the case, right? But I mean, is it important to duplicate that in your bylaws? I don't have an answer, you guys know more than I do.
[1:13:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I would say no, because the trumping, or the document that overrides is the ordinance.
[1:14:04] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so you know, I look at bylaws as this teaches, you know, tells us how we're gonna,
[1:14:10] Speaker A (unidentified): to some procedural things right yeah we're gonna operate so it's like why
[1:14:23] Speaker C (unidentified): would you have these minutes and defining effect I guess I don't know
[1:14:30] Speaker B (unidentified): well in addition to that you also have the state law yeah which is what
[1:14:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Would state law dictate what should be in the bylaw?
[1:14:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, state law dictates what's supposed to be in the ordinance, and what's in the ordinance is turning up in the bylaws. So, you know, there's not too many new ideas in the world. [Speaker A (unidentified): No,, exactly.] But I'm trying to remember what the language was that was pointed out to me. And it was like, oh, son of a gun, that's been there all that time and we didn't notice it. I
[1:15:16] Speaker C (unidentified): mean, the appeals procedure and all this sort of thing is right in here.
[1:15:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh yeah, appeals procedure and board decisions, so 18.8.3. Right.
[1:15:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so if you look at 18.8.1.2, just goes back to the discussion we were having earlier, the board shall keep minutes of its proceedings recording the vote of each member on each matter coming before the board minutes of the proceedings and all writings so anyway just to say there is a requirement that we put that information in the minutes too it's right there in the audience I mean it's just not stuff necessarily
[1:16:04] Speaker A (unidentified): That makes sense, but this says that it has to be in the minutes, so it's.
[1:16:17] Speaker C (unidentified): You.
[1:16:18] Speaker B (unidentified): What we're trying to do, if you really want to get it back to be clean, it's a pretty careful scrubbing that it needs quite a lot of time to do the review. And that's probably the reason why it hasn't been done recently.
[1:16:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, because if we were to modify 18.8.1.2, that requires, like, planning department has to revise this and has to go to the...
[1:16:50] Speaker C (unidentified): Are you assuming, what, it gets revised and then what goes to the town meeting? Is that what happens?
[1:16:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Let's go to a town meeting. Yeah. Yeah, now on the other hand, you know, having just voted, you know, we had changes to the zoning ordinance that was in the
[1:17:14] Speaker A (unidentified): in the in the ballot the I just voted on, yes, I was having to do it the wireless.
[1:17:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Now I obviously I knew I knew generally some background on that, but I didn't know exactly what the changes were because what goes to the voter is a real summary. It's really just the edits. It's just the, yeah, it's just the edits. So, you know, I looked at it and I said.
[1:17:41] Speaker A (unidentified): You don't have any idea what the context of that is?
[1:17:45] Speaker B (unidentified): No, and so I didn't vote on it, I just.
[1:17:47] Speaker C (unidentified): I did vote on it because I could figure it out, but I mean the
[1:17:52] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I well, I wasn't confident that I remembered what it was dealer was, you know, the informational mailer
[1:18:00] Speaker C (unidentified): was not very informative. It was one thing at least that I had stained on.
[1:18:04] Speaker A (unidentified): They would have to write a lot in order to make clear to a voter why they would that's what why that was on the you know, you know, I you when I sent out the decision of the court to reverse, did that make sense, then the change of the ordinance, did you make a connection
[1:18:25] Speaker C (unidentified): to that? I did, it was it was something about, you know, it was basically to say
[1:18:32] Speaker A (unidentified): that the you know what the court said, the court said that as soon as you put the wording of our ordinance dictated that as soon as you set an antenna on top of a water tower. The water tower is the antenna. It's the antenna.
[1:18:50] Speaker C (unidentified): It had to do with whether the fencing was required. Like, if you were to put the cell tower on its own, there was a requirement for fencing around it. But in this case, the fencing was already there, and it was not built to that requirement. And so it wasn't the required fencing. Exactly.
[1:19:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. They said, oh, yeah, that's not so important.
[1:19:11] Speaker B (unidentified): They were basically saying, wireless communication facility, you know, this means what, well, in the in the ordinance as it was drafted, it was out to the fence line really, and but the fence was already there.
[1:19:23] Speaker A (unidentified): So if you go back to the each of the changes, if you go between the Reversal of the court and the change that was in the voter guide, every one of those changes had to do with what the judge has to enable that.
[1:19:43] Speaker C (unidentified): To go forward. Yeah, yes, yeah, I could tell what they were doing and I was all for it. So there was another one, I can't remember now. There's another one where I was like, I don't know what the context is for this. Oh yeah, I don't understand which is better.
[1:19:59] Speaker B (unidentified): And I'm just going to abstain. I couldn't, yeah, there's been several that have been like that.
[1:20:03] Speaker A (unidentified): You've seen, you see the green way, the whole document, yeah. Well yeah, we had that was voted on, yeah. Imagine how many people actually understood once they see, once they see.
[1:20:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Some of those buildings up, they'll understand the implications. I went by, I.
[1:20:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Went by the one that we had the appeal on and they got the whole dug, yeah, they do, the trees gone and there was a big old tree there and there's another one.
[1:20:37] Speaker B (unidentified): On Cross Street that's, yeah, I think they've started to work on that too, haven't they? I don't.
[1:20:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Know, I don't know, but when the building is built then wow, yeah, shocking, yeah, it's big.
[1:20:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I mean it uses the entire drive along there, yeah, it's, it's, it's going to look like wow.
[1:20:56] Speaker C (unidentified): That's a big building. The bylaws, you know, in the manual and there's guidance here on what, oh there. Yeah, so you know page 17, so in the absence of a local ordinance or charter provision of the contrary, any administrative board like an appeals board can and should adopt written bylaws to govern non-substantive housekeeping matters. Such bylaws generally did not need to be approved by a legislative body. Anyway, it seems to me like you don't need to regurgitate in the bylaws stuff. That's already in the audience.
[1:21:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Which, probably out of just convenience in creating this back in 04, they just included the stuff, but it's really not, shouldn't be there because it could get revised.
[1:21:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, that's right, that's right. You know, I mean, you could have, you know, as stated in the zoning ordinance. Because obviously if it got removed from the zoning ordinance, then it's not gonna apply anymore anyway. So exactly, but if you get into, try to get into too much detail in here.
[1:22:05] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, exactly, okay, again, you know, if ever the town member, we, you know, that main law allows for a relaxation of this hardship criteria, right, you know, the, and see that ever happen, if this town ever were to adopt that, all of a sudden our bylaws need to be revised, yeah.
[1:22:23] Speaker A (unidentified): So just as an example of why it shouldn't be in there.
[1:22:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Set yourself up for that. And their wording is perfectly good in housekeeping. Exactly right. Yeah.
[1:22:39] Speaker A (unidentified): I wanted to ask a question about something else I included in here. And that's for Bob because maybe he knows from the history. Why do we have an official record in addition to the certification for variance? I
[1:22:57] Speaker B (unidentified): don't know the answer to that. Okay, just an additional document. It's like, I'm not sure. No, they're only, it only applies to a variance, right? Okay, and the official, the actual certificate is what gets recorded at the
[1:23:19] Speaker A (unidentified): registry, is it not? Yes. Okay, well, and it has the, it has the page for the, for the clerk to
[1:23:29] Speaker B (unidentified): yep. So that's, that's not the official record. That's the certification. The official record, so there's the two. Is like a restatement of the, of the decision. Isn't the official
[1:23:45] Speaker C (unidentified): records of minutes and the findings of fact? Is there something in addition? You
[1:23:49] Speaker A (unidentified): know, we create it, we create another document, and it's like, okay, what is that
[1:23:55] Speaker B (unidentified): for? Yeah, and I'll be honest, at the time I first encountered it, you know, because it was probably after I became chair, I asked the same question, and I never got to an answer of it, and I said, well, what the heck, just keep doing it, just keep doing it. If they've been doing it for as long as the board has been in existence, and it had been, you know, a long time. Well, because when you look down through, you can see it
[1:24:24] Speaker A (unidentified): it's got finding a fact, and it's got conclusion, and it's got the judgment, and basically the decision. Yeah, and it's really, that's in the findings of fact. Yeah, the only, the only thing
[1:24:37] Speaker B (unidentified): that I could say about it is that perhaps some of the courts have gone back and looked for something that was an itemized, this,, this,, this,. But I never found out who asked for it, and I haven't found any authority in the ordinance for it.
[1:24:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so I'm looking now and I can't. No.
[1:25:02] Speaker B (unidentified): But it was definitely there before I came along, and you know, you've probably been doing it. Yeah, we haven't had a half a dozen
[1:25:14] Speaker A (unidentified): maybe of over the four years or so. The other thing which kind of when I'm looking at this, it's, I'm asking, when we do a findings of fact, should we be indicating on that findings of fact who was present, you know, because this indicates who is present, who is not voting, who was absent.
[1:25:40] Speaker B (unidentified): The findings of act? Yeah.
[1:25:41] Speaker C (unidentified): To me, that's the sort of thing that would go in the minutes, right? And the findings of act would just be the board determines as follows, right? Okay, yeah. You know what I mean? Yeah, really, that's. No, in.
[1:25:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Because it is in the minutes who's present. It doesn't say who's not present, or maybe it should.
[1:26:00] Speaker C (unidentified): The minutes certainly should say who's present and maybe who's not present,
[1:26:03] Speaker A (unidentified): but then it should say who's voting how and who yeah who's that who's associate and who's yeah who was named to vote as a member yeah because that's a housekeeping item
[1:26:16] Speaker B (unidentified): there were a couple of findings of fact that I had a samples that I that I did I give them oh here they are they're old ones from yeah like I said I think they're from 2007 yeah in this case the vote on each item was recorded by who voted yeah on
[1:26:55] Speaker A (unidentified): the ones I've included here this these go back to like 23 but in that one, we did list those, just, you know, the votes.
[1:27:07] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, like, you know, you had a motion, and then there was a motion, I think, that was probably failed. [Speaker A (unidentified): To deny, okay.] And then there was another motion, you know, and this one was withdrawn. And then this one here was the one that succeeded. And then there's the vote of who voted on it.
[1:27:28] Speaker A (unidentified): and you know it's interesting that I don't remember that kind of a series of motions happening ever in any of the meetings we've had since 2020 you probably haven't but you know when
[1:27:44] Speaker B (unidentified): when you call for a motion you know say all right you know somebody came to make a motion you can make a motion for the Roberts rules you can make a motion for discussion or you can make a motion for a vote, right? So in this case, we might have, we had, the board would split sometimes. We weren't always unanimous. And so what that, you can see that maybe the subsequent motion, the one that had one that failed, but then there's one that's after it, which may have changed the wording.
[1:28:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, okay. It failed because it didn't have a majority. Okay.
[1:28:27] Speaker B (unidentified): You couldn't get the majority of five. So, you know.
[1:28:32] Speaker A (unidentified): You know, still, in those, since I've been on the board, I don't ever remember a case where we had, we didn't get a majority.
[1:28:42] Speaker B (unidentified): No, see, it used to happen pretty regularly.
[1:28:45] Speaker A (unidentified): You guys didn't get along, or what was the deal?
[1:28:48] Speaker B (unidentified): we did in fact but we had we on the board at the time when I first joined the board we had people that came from a very different perception about what was what was a property owner's rights okay and it generally it generally it boils down to you know you after you've been on the board for a while you get an idea where people's coming from there was some people they had strong tendencies to property owners rights control you know and that this ordinance restricts a property owners rights so We're going to be strict on these on the application of the ordinance, okay, because it's infringing on an individual property owners rights. There are some other people who believe that, you know, as a collective society, the ordinance is written to protect that, so they're going to more broadly interpret the ordinance, and that's where we usually split. And now, I guess you could say, you know, it was up to the selectmen to select, you know, board members that board members that reflected a balance or reflected, you know, and yeah, in that period did you have
[1:30:11] Speaker A (unidentified): I recall, maybe it was Mike Swant that maybe mentioned it too, that the select board basically chastised the Board of Appeals for not deciding properly?
[1:30:28] Speaker B (unidentified): There was, and this was before I was a member, and Mike was an associate at the time. Okay, he was relatively new to the board, but they had an issue where I believe that the board was criticized for being too willing to grant variances.
[1:30:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, that's what it was. That's how it was.
[1:30:54] Speaker B (unidentified): Now, this is hearsay. I wasn't there.
[1:30:59] Speaker D (unidentified): I've seen a lot of change. It was at one time you went to the appeals board and you were granted the appeal. Right. And then it flip-flopped, so it was the pendulum approach. It was, okay, now we're going to refuse everything.
[1:31:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, I think, you know, when I came aboard, Mike's spot was chair at that point in time. And, you know, Mike, I think, had kind of a balanced viewpoint.
[1:31:30] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, he's obviously. Very much so. You know, and. Fair.
[1:31:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, fair. and but he was willing to look at the law, you know, as what's what's the case law that you know how are we supposed to be, you know, we send people to the MMA training and all that sort of stuff as to what is the case law, and we're really one of the things with that decision-making comes down the most is on variances, because yeah, you know, the variance is okay in we're going to allow in this circumstance that you don't need to follow the law, you know, what's in the ordinance, it's going to be a little bit different for you because you it's an unreasonable hardship, and therefore, you know, we're going to give
[1:32:20] Speaker A (unidentified): some relief to the and then once you yeah and with that not in the case of a minor dimensional but in a general variance then you needed conditions to
[1:32:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, like we had logging road there that one was yeah, you know, you could put some conditions on it, you know, I mean. Like on, I will honestly say that it's very easy to grant a variance. Okay. That might not be what the law says you should be doing. But as a member of the Board of Appeals, you have to use your judgment based upon the evidence that's come before us, right? So we have a certain level of discretion. But our discretion is really fettered by those tests. And like you said, Mitch, if you're really liberal on this thing, I'm always going to give the benefit of the doubt. Well, you know, then you're going to have, like the tie goes to the runner, the tie goes to the owner, but, what can sometimes happen is, you know, when it's, it's, and I, 'm, I have an example of this, from, experience, but I, won't, but it is, say you're in the shoreland area and you've got a shoreland setback and somebody makes a case for, you know, there's a small upland section on the lot, okay, and, you know, all they need is a wetland crossing, a relatively modest wetland crossing with a modest amount to fill, you know, you can make the case, well, okay, you know, we should, because the lot is, all you're going to be is putting a picnic table on that thing, or you can build a small house you know and others when you get to shore land you know you've
[1:34:24] Speaker A (unidentified): got some extra. Is that the thousand foot footprint and all that? Exactly right.
[1:34:29] Speaker B (unidentified): But earlier on that wasn't there. I guess I could put it in 2003 but you know the thing is if we don't grant the variance on it the property is substantially, you know, now especially the reality of these things in York is that anything that is buildable has become very valuable. If it's not buildable, it's, you know, nobody wants to pay the taxes on it, never mind how valuable it is. So the determination of is it a hardship, you know.
[1:35:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Will it give a return?
[1:35:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, to give a return is an important matter. I mean, I'm sure you probably, in your previous life, you probably ran into those kinds of things.
[1:35:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I can remember, yeah, it would seem like in a case where, for instance, like you said, you have a lot and somebody comes along and wants to buy it and wants to build something, I would think the board would be apt to grant that variance then what I've seen with when there's an existing structure and they want to do something to that structure and it affects setbacks that's when it even they're like you know if
[1:36:03] Speaker C (unidentified): They buy the land and there's any other use that's possible my picnic The picnic table. The picnic table. The ice cream stand. The hunting ground.
[1:36:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I can remember one we had, this is now going back, maybe you weren't back on the board yet. It was over by Scituate Pond where it was a lot and they wanted to build a house, but it had to be that thousand square feet, but we went back and forth over a couple of meetings where they had to go off and modify their plan to orient the house, and we still had to give them a variance. But they oriented it to the...
[1:36:47] Speaker B (unidentified): In order to minimize the amount of variance that you had to grant. Right, exactly.
[1:36:50] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, that. Hey, guys, I have found some guidance in this manual about minutes and findings of fact. Okay. So I was starting on page 38 about minutes. minutes. So the statute requires a record, blah,, blah. Record may be written or not. It can be audio, whatever. But at minimum, it must include date, time, place of meeting, list of the board members who are present or absent. Right,. All motions and votes taken, including a list of who voted for or against the motion.
[1:37:20] Speaker A (unidentified): That's in the Roberts rules even. Yeah.
[1:37:24] Speaker C (unidentified): And so on. Then when you get to the findings of, this is page 47, the findings of fact and conclusions of law that's more of a collective thing so you know we conclude that you know without a variance this person will not have you know any return here's the reason why you know we don't necessarily include who voted and all that stuff so it seems like maybe we need to put a little more information in the minutes than we were discussing earlier maybe a little a little less than the findings of fact than in the sample. The samples are some of them that at least, yeah, we don't need to necessarily a court who voted for it. It's more of a collective finding, which seems to me, it's almost like you've got a record of a trial, and then you've got an order at the end, or a ruling at the end. So that's, so anyway, if you want to take a look, it's.
[1:38:21] Speaker B (unidentified): This is guidance in the MAA?
[1:38:22] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, it's in the manual here, page 38 and page 47.
[1:38:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I put 47 in the copy that I did, but yeah. Well, yeah, it's a matter of, you know how you can see the, like that, where you list the, we do a roll call vote. Our ordinance says we have to do that. You know, I had been, and I think the other boards do that too, because patients reminded me, you know, you shouldn't do a, what do you call that, not a, show hands, show hands, you got to do a roll call.
[1:39:01] Speaker B (unidentified): She wants to have it, she wants to have it on the tape.
[1:39:04] Speaker A (unidentified): So, then she would record the roll call in the minutes, but in the findings of fact, all it has to say is, it was a vote of 5-0-4-9.
[1:39:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Or not even that, just that the board finds.
[1:39:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Voted to approve or disapprove or whatever.
[1:39:20] Speaker C (unidentified): I think from what I'm reading here. It's just the board the board. Yeah, the board has found that Okay, you know Okay, yeah I think I think we can I mean I'm sure you're not doing any harm if you put too much information
[1:39:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Just a matter of being consistent
[1:39:40] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, the one thing too is Yeah, I certainly have no problem with it being in the minutes and in being there. Taking it out of there, though, means that you have to go to, you have to look at two documents in order to find out what the answer is to the...
[1:39:55] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. Well, you know, I mean, I have to believe that a court is going to look at both, but I don't know.
[1:40:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, they also have to, you know, they also, we usually recite in the findings of fact On that sheet, we usually recite that the matter has been recorded in the recording as part of the record.
[1:40:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, like when we had a, I think it was the AT&T, when they first remanded that back to us last March, I think I asked Mary, I said, so how do they work? when they when somebody makes the appeal not appeal but like files that appeal with the court what does the court look at and I said to Mary did they get like did we there's a town send them everything that the Board of Appeals looked at like our little our packet plus the minutes plus the
[1:41:05] Speaker B (unidentified): findings and plus what was submitted by anybody at the hearing that we consider the packets part
[1:41:09] Speaker A (unidentified): of the official record yeah so they review that yeah no but i guess i was asking myself well who goes about the trouble of sending all that it should be the town right yeah i think so
[1:41:24] Speaker B (unidentified): well whoever the appellant is you know has to send has to collect it themselves
[1:41:31] Speaker A (unidentified): and send it because we don't really provide it oh yeah they provided it as part of their appeal yeah that's true they provided it they have it already
[1:41:40] Speaker B (unidentified): in and town council in defending the matter is going to make sure that
[1:41:46] Speaker A (unidentified): everything is there right okay yeah and that would be also the minutes and the
[1:41:51] Speaker B (unidentified): Findings, yeah, and you know, because what some, you know, say for example you've got one of these things that has two parties to the matter, you know, your property owner and the abutter and in the town, well you need to make sure that both parties may have submitted stuff to us, and so even though it might not have been in the original packet, you know, they were giving stuff to us at the hearing and we considered it, therefore it's gonna be there. That's why I said, you know, in a in a court proceeding each of those documents is
[1:42:36] Speaker C (unidentified): identified as an exhibit, it's very tightly, you know, review, yeah, but in the
[1:42:52] Speaker B (unidentified): In the case of something, an administrative proceeding like this, it can't be at the expense of the level of thoroughness that you have in a court proceeding. So all of those things that the court, however, considers on the appellate record are incorporated at that point, I'm sure.
[1:43:12] Speaker C (unidentified): So we talked about the biddance. We talked about findings of fact. And you guys have mentioned there's something else called an official record. What does that look like?
[1:43:23] Speaker A (unidentified): For a, I gave you a copy. For a, it looks like you have the two having to do with, there's official record and then there's a certificate. This thing here, okay. And so this was the same, this was that same variance I put the finding back then too.
[1:43:46] Speaker C (unidentified): So, yeah, like it seems to me this official record is sort of a.
[1:43:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Looks like an outline of the findings of fact or of the minutes, you know, it's all it, yeah, who is there, right, members parties of to the action, and then the votes, yeah, I mean this is just me sort
[1:44:08] Speaker C (unidentified): of spitballing here, but if you if you've looked you've looked you can't find any basis for this
[1:44:13] Speaker B (unidentified): I didn't at the time, yeah, so I mean it's it's probably 15 years ago that I, yeah, but so maybe
[1:44:19] Speaker C (unidentified): we look again but maybe we find that this isn't necessary, this is the guiding document because it gets required, which one, the official record certification, the certification, yeah, that's the one that goes to the registry, right, but this is a so-called official record, maybe you don't need to do well because you have the minutes and you get the findings of fact, well you know as far
[1:44:41] Speaker B (unidentified): as I know it doesn't go anywhere other than the town's file, exactly, along with the other documents. And you know it could be that it was something that was a, you know, practice 30 years ago, and it's and it's been just rolling forward. And say that I couldn't find any reference to it. But it was consistently done. I do I can tell you that, and then I this would see I really wish that
[1:45:16] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, we'll have to ask Mary, but I mean, because I'm certainly not, you know, a land use lawyer. I wouldn't even know. But it seems to me like this is the recordable, this is the document that's going to go and get recorded, the registry deeds. I don't know why you'd be including information about what board members were there and how they voted.
[1:45:37] Speaker A (unidentified): We have that, yeah, and that's on our certification.
[1:45:41] Speaker B (unidentified): It's also, I think, probably any witnesses are probably recorded in there, aren't they?
[1:45:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Or is that the official? Yeah, parties to the action.
[1:45:48] Speaker C (unidentified): That needs to go on the recordable instrument?
[1:45:49] Speaker A (unidentified): So that was the member that was a builder mark Lawrence. Yeah, and then Harry was there. Yeah, you know some someone then and then this is a this is a job when you're trying to prepare these. Yeah, they also have who the who was notified. So what about you know that in this record is send a butter notices to and on some of them like the one for wiggly bridge that was a lot of people. Yeah, it's like okay is that really necessary but i guess it is because you have to
[1:46:31] Speaker C (unidentified): prove that you notified them but how many layers of i mean what i would suggest
[1:46:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Just in the sense, my recollection is not as good as it used to be in my prior life. I would suggest that we run some of it before we delete documents. Run it by Mary. Run it by Mary, right? And see if she recollects or any of us.
[1:46:59] Speaker C (unidentified): Or also, like, you know, how it seems to me like if you're going in the registry deeds, you want to know, is there a variance? What does the variance say? Right. maybe when it was granted you guys of course when it was granted whatever if you need to then find like i really want to know who voted for against that variance you know i'm not sure that should be in the registry of deeds that's something you can find because you can find the minutes for that hearing that meeting you know on the public record
[1:47:30] Speaker B (unidentified): that the town was not earlier on yes records of what was done by the board yeah I think they back before is computerized it's all you know now it's been scanned and so forth but I mean sometimes it was difficult to locate a case decision you know the file you know I'm not saying I know I'm just saying it
[1:47:54] Speaker C (unidentified): It strikes me as funny.
[1:47:56] Speaker A (unidentified): But that was the big question. Yeah.
[1:47:58] Speaker B (unidentified): But, you know, I mean, if somebody's going back looking, well, was this granted defectively? And, you know, you're looking for as much information as you can get. But I don't know. Like I said, I couldn't find a reason that official record document exists. I just, you know, other than that it had been being done for at least 20 years before I came along.
[1:48:24] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, right, I mean, right. And if we can't get advice one way or the other and I can't show that I'm right, then yeah, we keep going the way. Well, you know, I think Mary
[1:48:39] Speaker B (unidentified): probably, she'll know. Yeah, I mean, you know, she is, she is, she is a, you know, land use, your lawyer is very, this is her specialty area, so it
[1:48:53] Speaker C (unidentified): just strikes me is really funky that you go to the registry deeds and you'd find this. Oh, it was at the York Library
[1:48:58] Speaker A (unidentified): at 7 p.m. Well, you know, it says you gotta list the place where it was. I mean,
[1:49:05] Speaker C (unidentified): that's the, in that case, if that's what, yeah, it's required, that's required. Yeah.
[1:49:13] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, I really don't know, Bruce, as far as I, you know, you suspect and I suspect that some of this is redundant. Yeah. You know, and it's, you know, it's been created over the years, you know, like barnacles on the bottom of the boat. You know, they just kind of grow there and they kind of slow it down. So it might be our opportunity to fix some of that.
[1:49:39] Speaker D (unidentified): That, like you're saying, 20 years down the road, if they have to authenticate, you know, that document is not a forgery or something.
[1:49:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, you know, I mean, Lord.
[1:49:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, that's a notarization, you know, that's, you know.
[1:49:54] Speaker B (unidentified): Lord knows that none of us that voted on one of these things is probably gonna remember it clearly.
[1:50:02] Speaker C (unidentified): You're not giving yourself enough credit, Bob. You remember a lot.
[1:50:12] Speaker B (unidentified): But, I mean, you know, in some cases, the one thing that's pretty sobering, frankly, is when I started looking back, I was looking at some old decisions and stuff like that. There's the names on there, and, you know, quite a few have passed away. You know, it made me feel, you know. Old. Old.
[1:50:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, shit. Yeah, that's what happened.
[1:50:38] Speaker C (unidentified): And there is guidance on these recordable certificates as well, page 51, which I haven't read yet, but here it is.
[1:50:46] Speaker A (unidentified): I'll have to look at it. Is that how they have it, recordable certificates?
[1:50:50] Speaker C (unidentified): No, it says after making the decision, notice of decision, variance certificate to be recorded, starting on page 51.
[1:50:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, and then in the back of the manual, in the appendix, there's all kinds of template things. Yeah, things, and these, I don't know that there's an official record in there, but there is a certification that the template kind of goes pretty much with what, I don't recall.
[1:51:19] Speaker B (unidentified): I suspect that one was probably made from using a template like that. But the official record, I don't know.
[1:51:30] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll get an opinion.
[1:51:32] Speaker B (unidentified): You have color in yours. Where'd you get that?
[1:51:37] Speaker C (unidentified): I paid extra yeah this was in the webinar I took actually yes the examples
[1:51:47] Speaker B (unidentified): of hardships and so okay yeah did when you did the webinar did they give you a
[1:51:50] Speaker C (unidentified): new MMA manual no this was an on-demand one you know there was an older but it was on demand so I still have to figure out whether I need to do I need to like get a certificate of completion or anything?
[1:52:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, they'll give you one for that class? Yeah. Yeah, I have one, I got one, yeah.
[1:52:10] Speaker C (unidentified): And then I think I still need to do a special something on the FOAA, which I still haven't done.
[1:52:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, that one's simpler, I think. I did that, 's a kind of a, that's a town thing. Everyone has to do that one. For you. There's the freedom of information. Yeah,.
[1:52:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I think that's, well, it's probably state law.
[1:52:37] Speaker A (unidentified): I think you have to do it every so often.
[1:52:40] Speaker B (unidentified): I've reinterpreted it for you through the town.
[1:52:43] Speaker A (unidentified): There's a time, and you do it online.
[1:52:48] Speaker D (unidentified): So that's the only thing I've done online.
[1:52:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you just do that? You must have just done it. Well, I did.
[1:52:55] Speaker B (unidentified): You went down here to take your. Two and a half years ago.
[1:52:58] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. I'm second to him now. okay oh yeah i've aged it out on my last term but i'm still here
[1:53:12] Speaker A (unidentified): i actually didn't go through that training oh that the town will pay for that how long was it
[1:53:21] Speaker C (unidentified): bruce was it three hours or it was two and a half or three hours i can't remember yeah this is a video yeah but it wasn't just on FOA it was the whole like it was you have a leader and this discussion and there were two attorneys who presented and it was recorded yeah it's totally recorded yeah this was just on demand but I was
[1:53:49] Speaker B (unidentified): able to listen to it you didn't do it in person no I was just at home
[1:53:56] Speaker C (unidentified): I had I had a I remember I'll tell you what was going on is my wife was having company over like lady friends and I was holed up in there the one that this was a recording of such a course so there were people and those people were able to submit questions by chat and they were answered in real time yeah so
[1:54:31] Speaker B (unidentified): You know what though, that's, I think I've done it twice, and the other side of Dayton was hosting. Okay. Yeah. And they always seem to be so far away. The thing
[1:54:53] Speaker A (unidentified): is, thing is, it's cuz Maine is so large, the center of the state is. Yeah, the
[1:55:07] Speaker B (unidentified): The other side, it's along the Saco River there. Good dairy there, if I recall.
[1:55:16] Speaker D (unidentified): Used to be a lot of dairies, yeah.
[1:55:19] Speaker B (unidentified): I used to go up there and get milk. Sunny, something. They bottled milk in glass bottles.
[1:55:30] Speaker D (unidentified): They had the ski area, they had cross-country skiing.
[1:55:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, we used to bring the kids there once in a while.
[1:55:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. Yeah. So there are samples of certificates to be recorded here. It's page 355. It's very, it doesn't include. Really simple. Yeah, it just, I, you know, the secretary of the board, you know, for the town of whatever, on such-and-such a date, you know, the variance described below is granted, citing the law and the provisions of the ordinance, property owner, property description, variance and conditions. Yeah, but I'm just saying I don't think you don't have to include, like, the roll call votes and who was present and who was not present.
[1:56:26] Speaker A (unidentified): What's more important is, so the one I have there, that one, that was minor dimensional. If you have a general variance like we had on logging road there, was a lot of conditions. Oh, sure. Yeah. They came out of code, and then where we allowed to vary the requirements of the ordinance. But we wanted to be specific about it. Remember how they had the vegetation on the side of the gravel driveway? Because it was crossing over wetland. So there was a lot of, yeah.
[1:57:05] Speaker C (unidentified): No, I'm not saying they're necessarily that brief.
[1:57:08] Speaker A (unidentified): That goes with the land. Right. So the fact that driveway can never be paved. Right. Yeah.
[1:57:17] Speaker B (unidentified): And the problem with those kinds of things, you know, is that future conditions may change, you know. Oh, I didn't know. Even the water course might have moved.
[1:57:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, maybe it's completely flooded.
[1:57:39] Speaker D (unidentified): It's like a vernal pool, if you suspect that it's no longer a vernal pool, they'd have to test it three years in a row and not come up with the species and then it could be de-categorized. To them, yeah, because we're probably going to see a lot of from the changes that were made last May that were pointed out in our last issue, because now they look at the vernal pool map on Stella, the vernal there, yeah, but you know it affects all the abutters, so this is your lot and you've got the vernal pool, but now this guy, this guy. And if there's two vertical pools, then you start getting those 200-foot radiuses crossing each other. It's like people are looking for variances.
[1:58:39] Speaker B (unidentified): They will be looking for variances. Yes. Generating variance business.
[1:58:48] Speaker D (unidentified): That's the pendulum again.
[1:58:54] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, when you change the rules, it just all of a sudden made a lot of issues that weren't there before. Yeah. Yeah. You know, I don't know the history of it, but in my own neighborhood, you know, at the time, my the neighborhood zoning plan for the neighborhood was approved on the subdivision at the subdivision plan, it must have been approved with half acre lots required. Well, then I believe that they found that they couldn't get septic systems in a half acre. This is a long time bigger. This is it. Yeah. So most of the neighborhood is has got combined lots, you know, the houses are built on two lots, sometimes three lots in order to meet the requirements, but you know, then you go look out into the surrounding areas and I don't know how many vernal pools are out there, but there's a lot
[2:00:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Up in your area? Yeah.
[2:00:15] Speaker D (unidentified): Because they didn't identify vernal pools for, you know, and it was just wet ones.
[2:00:21] Speaker B (unidentified): In 1973, they didn't.
[2:00:25] Speaker D (unidentified): So that hit probably in the 90s. Yeah. Yeah.
[2:00:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, this was probably a good discussion. Yeah. It seems like it was productive, but.
[2:00:41] Speaker C (unidentified): So the outcome is you want us to look at the bylaws? Yeah.
[2:00:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Suggest so we'll do a review, so I'll send out a maybe a like a I have the word, my word documents, I'll send it out if you want to work on it that way, that's one way, and at least where I'm, where
[2:00:55] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm after having gone through all the discussions and looked at this and all that, you know, subject to all of your going back and double checking whatever, it seems to me like, yeah, maybe the minute should be a little more thorough and the findings of fact a little more, the findings of affecting conclusions of law, without including all the voting information and all that stuff necessarily. And then here's a good template for a recordable certificate that includes even less information. And then it all sort of makes sense. Then you can see how they all fit together
[2:01:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Without necessarily overlapping too much. Yeah. The interesting thing is that like that official record document that you have there, I think that was only done for variances, right?
[2:01:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, that's all I found.
[2:01:42] Speaker B (unidentified): It seems extraneous.
[2:01:51] Speaker C (unidentified): That's something that's Mary. That seems like an added document that's not required. So that point I raised with you also, that I found, it was, it was in here about alternates and their roles at hearings. So I was looking at this, and it said, basically, alternates should only be permitted to speak or ask questions to the extent that anyone public can do it as well. So I've been talking too much as an alternate or alternates in general. We aren't really your alternate now. We, you know, so that was interesting, and I don't know what we're supposed to do now. Do we get up and go over there? I don't know that I agree with that. I
[2:02:50] Speaker B (unidentified): think that at least from the administration of the Board of Appeals, you know, I'm, I'm an unusual alternate. Yes, okay. So and I'm guessing that after my term is expired, I will have expired.
[2:03:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, OK. Let's hope not. This is very depressing, Bob. No,, no.
[2:03:14] Speaker B (unidentified): But what I am thinking is that allowing an alternate to participate in the discussion, obviously they can't vote or anything of that sort. But participating in the discussion and giving you their ideas isn't giving you anything more than a member of the public would give you, so but it does give an alternate some method of participating in the board so that you don't want somebody, because I think I was an alternate maybe four or five years before somebody left the board, and I and I got, I got nominated to be a regular member, so you know you want to keep a person's interest while they're learning, while they're learning about how the board operates. You want to have, you know, give them, you know, because sometimes they may have an idea, and you know, if you're sitting on the board you say, well no, that's not really, you know, but the discussion is going to be useful in their learning experience. Sure.
[2:04:29] Speaker C (unidentified): As long as you guys have thought it through, then great. I just, I found that as I go.
[2:04:33] Speaker B (unidentified): I have seen, and I remember discussing that with Mike Swant. Yeah. A long, time ago. And, you know, we weren't, we haven't, I have not seen anybody on an appeal ever,, ever criticize the fact that the halterings were allowed to discuss and to remain on the bench. But obviously you want to have them be a little careful. You don't want to have a zealous advocate on one side or the other. I think rather it's judicious, and I don't think it throws any problems, but it is important from a training point of view. And a retention point of view as well. Because, I mean, if you had somebody that sits here for, you know, four or five years and nobody talks to me and you could have the opposite, you know, they showed up at the first meeting and I had to vote.
[2:05:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. I was really hoping that first time I came, people were slow to show up and I was worried. You're going to put me on for real.
[2:05:51] Speaker D (unidentified): I had to get over my fear quickly.
[2:05:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, it worked out. It worked out.
[2:05:59] Speaker B (unidentified): So our assignment is to go through the bylaws and mark up anything we think needs to be changed.
[2:06:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. And I think we can share that one together at some point. All right. Good. Good. Great. Oh, you're giving those back to me?
[2:06:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, I was thinking you probably wanted to.
[2:06:21] Speaker A (unidentified): I never need them, but I should.
[2:06:23] Speaker B (unidentified): I thought you probably wanted to give them to Michelle. That's the extra. Oh, yeah.
[2:06:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. You've got a set that's, that's, oh, sure. I don't know where all these keys go to. They look like they go to file cabinets. Some of them go to those, oh, those cabinets back there, that's over there. Nobody ever locks them. Then there's the door key to the library. Nobody ever locks that either. So I guess if you wanted to come in on when they're closed, you have the key to the library.
[2:06:45] Speaker B (unidentified): They used to be always locked. Yeah, you know, and you know, I do remember having some meetings where we couldn't get the name tags out because I didn't have a key and they were locked in the drawers over there.
[2:06:59] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm still anonymous here. I don't have a name tag. Oh, yeah.
[2:07:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Liz has to do something about that. I'll remind her. You can use one of the old tags.
[2:07:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Save it for someone else's name.
[2:07:17] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. We can let our... Look at that. It's right out there. There we go.