Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[13:01] Councilor: We've talked about this idea for a while now, and it really boils down to taking a look at a particular piece of land in town and making sure that there is a viable path forward to construct affordable town-owned housing on Stiles Way. The object of this exercise is not to burden the taxpayer. It is to be self-funded either by a bond, issued bond, TIF funds, and the income from the rental units themselves. As we all know, with any mortgage, the first year is the most painful, and the last year you're pretty excited that I'm paying this thing off. And so, like anything that you pay off, you know, even if it's a car, you hope to have some life left in that car if you make the last payment. But more importantly, with real estate, when you own it, you have that luxury of reducing the rents below market share, you have the luxury of setting aside that money, that income come for upkeep repairs that sort of thing or funding a another project so I really I don't think there's much more that I could say and I think bill has done a great job of laying out what the committee would look like the players that are involved and so first of all thank you all for comments you made they appreciate it so you to think that when we had that last workshop that discounted the comments that you guys made in there right what we're what the thought process is here is that this is to build to put together a committee to create some simple ideas right what an affordable housing for all ages right would look like then it's to build a financial model right to understand how that work and if it's even feasible it's not an endorsement of the project in any way right it's not intended to be an endorsement of the project it's not intended to finalize design it's just really to get the basic components in place so that we can understand if this thing is viable so we can understand if this if this is even a viable option the affordable housing piece which TIG put together a great overview of you know what that's I think the steps are right work to solve the affordable housing issue throughout the community you know both here and broader actually right so what we thought of and You saw the email, I if you've read the email I sent last night. Sorry, short notice was, you know, there's kind of multiple legs of the stool. This looking at this to understand if the town-owned property route, right, developing a facility on with our own dollars is a financial possibility, feasible, is one. You know, the other components of affordable housing are going to be what's going to happen with 1829, and then there's also the associate, right, the private developments, for example, that are happening. Under one other stuff that went on, you know, that the cops built out on Rooster Ridge, etc., right, those are all components of how we're going to make this work. All this I think is rip, or all this was intended to do was understand the feasibility of this, and then I think the other key to doing this is to make sure that this is a short duration committee, right, this is not meant to be a two-year study of all the of all the options. I think we've done some of that work already in the comp plan, right. Put some of that stuff together and looked at it. I think the previous affordable housing committee did some of that work as well, so I think we've got the basis in there to do this, and again this is just, this was just intended as we put this together to be the creation of a financial model to test feasibility, just for reference to, I know we talked with our friend Steve Moriarty a little bit and he helped us kind of change this around a little bit and help to focus the work to focus this in with. This goal in mind, again for a small committee, financial feasibility, and again not endorsing a project, just understanding if this is actually an option and it's a model that we can use in the future. So I'll stop there, I. Just had a couple mechanical pieces to it. The draft resolution or draft proposal you saw suggested a seven member committee. I had actually asked Matt to draft the initial was a nine member committee, and I still, if we end up putting a council liaison on that who does not have a vote in it or a planning board member that does not have a vote, I would I think that a nine member committee is more appropriate than a seven member committee, but we can discuss that further. I'm. Good questions, thoughts, Lily. I have a question, so this is for feasibility, I imagine it's information gathering. What exactly would they need to vote on to. Where you need a particular any action by the council or any committee that is created by the council requires a vote to move that ahead. We can't just create a committee and without the support of the council and that requires an action. So maybe Lily it would be to it's a good clarification point maybe it would be to you know provide us with the financial model and you know a ranking matrix right where they tried to put together some of the requirements and the deliverables in this document and maybe that could be right we can work that out so that would be what they would vote on refine the language so that would be the vote. Okay if this is like a discovery thing I would figure they would just give us all the options and then we would make a choice based on that as a council if they're not looking at a specific project then what would they be voting on that's like my question is because here it's like this is feasibility Bob mentioned Stiles way specifically this document talks about IDing and screening town-owned sites so I'm still a little confused about the scope if this is looking all over town if this is. Looking at Stiles way if it is a very specific project if it is rentals that are town-owned and managed like Bob is saying if it is something different and what exactly we're doing here because if you're talking about a vote that sounds to me like presenting one single end product to the council to act on rather than amassing data and options to give to. The council to make an informed decision so I think I would rather see it as amassing data and options right and that's why I kind of wrote that in the deliverables and again if there's some sort of parliamentary reason or parliamentary thing that we have to have a vote on something so be it then we need to work on that language but to my mind it's just an advisory it's an information gathering exercise versus a recommendation because I don't think with all the other pieces that right we have. To consider in here that this committee should necessarily make a recommendation it is just intended to be a information gathering exercise so yeah I don't I don't know what the parliamentary reason or parliamentary piece would be for that agree with that Bob are. You thinking of a single project, so the council, the document here, town of, come on, affordable housing committee proposed structure, charge and work plan. This is what I see is what we would vote on. This is a proposal, if you will, it lays out, I think pretty clearly, what it is, the structure is, what the goal is, and so we would be voting to move this forward to, you know, entertaining the applications to fill the committee. The, not the Auditor's Committee, but the, anyways, I don't have a date on this, but if I can back it out here. October 27th draft affordable housing committee. So I mean we all, I think we had a paper copy of this in front of us, I don't, but it's the same as in the workshop information about the bottom of our packet for workshop we got, I think basically what you're looking at, and Lily was your question, what does the committee vote on, yes, yeah, okay, so not what the council votes on, but what a committee would deliver to the council, and if it has to come up with a vote or has it right, has to provide something I think that again lays out the charge of the committee here, also it's if they, you know, core policy parameters to define work plan and discussion gates, deliverables, governance, administration, term and reporting, did you have something, I mean I don't want to get too far into the nitty-gritty details before we've really established that the overarching scope is the way to go, but you know we have here in deliverables at the end, you know, final report with a clear recommendation, proceed with conditions, undertake further study, pursue an alternative model, or do not proceed. That reads to me as, you know, we're, there's a particular project that we are looking at, all so if we do get to that point, I'd want to sort of change that if it's more of a we're gathering data and here's the data, as opposed to, you know, we think you should proceed with x or proceed with caution with x kind of thing, like that's much more of a to the reach to me, more project specific. I do really like, and I don't, maybe it should be sort of more enshrined later on, it says minority views may be included in the final report, I like that, you know, so if we have a seven member and it's four three, it gets all we see is the four, we don't see Three view on things or nine five or not nine five but five four or anything like that. I if we're going more with anything with recommendations I'd like to see that. If it's all just data in theory data's data is data and there wouldn't be a minority with the data but I would still like to see that possibility there for you know this information wasn't included and this is why or whatever it is to make sure that we get a full breadth of what the committee be looking at. And then another question. This might be more for you Matt. Are town committees by statue or anything like that limited to town residents? Just if we don't have the specific expertise or you know we have the expertise but they would also probably be really interested in building something if we went forward with it this would kind of preclude them from conflict of interest of providing said expertise at all to be able to look outside the town potentially for that and not limit the options for.
[26:13] Town Manager: People in town if it's a town committee it has to be resident. They need to be a resident of Cumberland and then but you can always pull in outside experts to help as a resource but they as far as a voting member or a member of a committee they have to be a resident of town.
[26:32] Councilor: So Bill let me ask you this question. Yes sir. Yesterday I was I was down in Westbrook for friends that hadn't been home for quite a while. Anyways out of the blue this woman comes up to me I hadn't I've never met her I don't know who she is she starts blistering me about the taxes and the cumble and the same stuff we get all the time but she's right. What are the we've got we've got a bridge that's out that's got to be repaired we just had a we got a whole section of town. The well is horrible. Tig and I have met with these people and then we just were coming off the heels of the revaluation. What's the optics of doing this? The optics to the residents of Cumberland to say we know you're we're not we're not jumping on your we're not paying for your water or fixing it doing this and we know you got a bridge out here. The school is killing Filling us in taxes, revaluation. I don't know anybody that went down. I know I didn't. No, I didn't either. I don't know anybody here that went down. Everybody's adjusting now. And here we are starting a project whose sister project was defeated just a couple years ago. Overwhelming. I mean, blown out of the water. And I mean, what are the optics on that? So I would throw it at you. throw it at you it's a great question so the optics here's a couple of thoughts on that is again this is just a study to understand what it is right and part of the study is understanding how it could be self-funding and not be a burden on taxpayers right that is kind of the key component of this right we know that there's some tif funding coming right in a few years that is going to be restricted to transportation projects and affordable housing projects right so this could be a funding source right that you know unless legislature changes how that money can be spent then this is maybe right a an opportunity to understand how that those funds could be utilized I will say that you know in the surveys that we did for the comp plan right and continuing to see it 's a major it was a major topic of discussion and took up a lot of effort in that plan and I also think too that it is you know it's a it's a nationwide issue and certainly it is an issue for folks who work right for workforce in the town they can't afford the house, they can't afford a house in town, so and then you know if we do this and it's right town owned and again we're working to avoid extra burden on the taxpayers, but it provides an opportunity for senior housing as well as workforce housing, right? It's something for all ages, so that's kind of how I want to look at the optics is like again we're not committing anything, we're thinking of some concepts building a financial model to understand if this is a viable option. We read, we as a council don't have to do a thing with this, right? If we you know if the committee comes back and says this is the greatest thing since they spread in two years from now or tech you know in a year from now the taxes are right or worse which they likely will be, you know we don't, this does not commit us to moving forward with it, is just an information gathering piece, so that's kind of does that help like no it does of course i really do appreciate your answers your reply to this and just one quick statement i wouldn't i wouldn't depend on any project have us depend on the tiff funds because if we i think the tiff funds certainly would qualify to help bruce hill in those neighborhoods because it would open up some housing opportunities up there so I could I see us wrestling this council wrestling what we're gonna do with those tip funds because you know I don't speak for any other council, but there is no higher priority than for me and getting water up to those people and If that's the way the structure works, right, then you know that's that's one of those that's the consideration I think we're gonna have to weigh and make, thank. just a follow-up again because i'm i hear what's being said but i'm still looking at this draft charge of this committee and it's contradicting what's being said so one is it's just gathering data we're not held to anything there's not a particular project of mine but then it talks about it's a very specific project bob's talking about a stylesway project it's specific enough to where there's going to be a final report with a recommendation like andrew said to proceed with conditions further study do another model or don't proceed at all so that to me doesn't sound like information gathering so i still need more specificity on this thing to understand what's actually being asked of us to do with this committee if it is going to go forward and then part of that is who's going to be on it talks about some sort of engineer who has experience with lots of things including finding whether a site is capable of housing talking about wetlands and site surveys but this is a volunteer this isn't an engineer this isn't someone we're paying so I question whether the data we gather may not have a lot of efficacy or it could be faulty because you've just got some engineer person and as of all on a volunteer basis not being paid to go look at sites and gather data i'm wondering if this shouldn't be left to a committee but instead it should be council driven like we have a clear agreement that we want to look into developing housing specifically on styles way with a project in mind and then we pay to have an engineer go and scope it out we have a finance director on hand who can tell us about the financial feasibility we have matt who has data we also have the old housing task force data that did a lot of prior work on housing in general so we have all this at our disposal already i'm concerned that having it as a volunteer basis we're going to have data that isn't correct to begin with and then we end up pursuing something and then find out that it's a lot different or just Different enough from what the committee found. And then also I understand it's just a committee, we don't have to act. But there's a lot of sunk cost fallacy that goes along with these kind of things. So putting it forward, doing the work, having all those people do all that work, just for the council to, you know, chuck it in the trash, which has happened in the past. But it's, I just want to make sure that we're going into it with a very clear goal and we're all on the same page, not kind of just throwing it to a committee and then seeing what happens. So for me, I just need more development on it. I'm curious in everyone's mind what has changed since 70 of our town voted down the other project on town on land. What has changed? I'd say for me, we don't know why the vote was no for that 70 percent. Was it no because of that project but another project would have been yes, or was it no because any thing down that path would be a no? And this I think would give us more information on, or something like this would give us more information to then, you know, if we did move forward, you know, you could use flash vote, you can use other ways to sort of suss out the answer to that. Was the 70 a no because they didn't like the location, the size, whatever that was for that specific project, or was it more of a broad, you know, we don't want that path being trodden again? I'm guessing it's more on the former because we have comp plan data and all of affordable housing is an issue and all. So it's like I think there could be appetite for affordable housing in the town along a model like this, possibly another location, possibly with a different setup. If it's something where we can show with good data that it's not going to add to the tax burden in the sense of, you know, taxes go because we have to pay to build it and all, that might be more feasible. If we can use the tip fund, if we use rent to cover, you know, maintenance costs and capex expenses going forward and all, that might be more feasible. It might very well not be, I don't know, but I think, I don't think that we can say that one project means the whole idea was rejected, because we have other data that says the whole idea is very much not rejected and that people want it but Also gets into the definition of affordable housing. Like when people say that, are they saying they want affordable housing based on HUD's definition and rent and all that, or are they saying that I want my taxes to go down, my house is not affordable, or my neighbor's house or friends or whatever is not affordable, and I need it to be more affordable. And that's that's an issue too with like the way the comp plan was worded. I don't know if you can get that answer from that, you know. For me, I think you asked the question what changed. We've got West Cumberland, we've got Route 1, all those apartments. So I think the council has done their work on affordable housing. We've opened up two projects that are affordable housing, and it was done through private funds, not through town. So for me, the objection on the town side hasn't changed, but we've allowed private sector to come in and they've done a good job. So Bob go ahead. This is all over the place, but you know the town had an opportunity from 30 some years ago to buy a bunch of foundations across the street Hawthorne Court, and we took a chance and we built a formal senior housing there. It's been a huge success. The waiting list is a mile long for people who want to get in there. So there is demand for this type of housing. There would be demand for housing down on Stiles Way. The idea that, you know, how much data do we need? We really are looking at a very specific question. Question is this a viable project that can be funded without impacting the tax base, three different means. So it's not a it's not a it's not a big leap to get there. What we need is we need, you know, we put our request for people to serve on boards where we're not necessarily saying hey do you want to serve on the board if you know nothing about it. Sometimes we get those people. But a lot of times we get, particularly the Lands and Conservation Committee, if you look at the resumes of people, some very talented people who want to serve in the community who side up to serve on these boards. If you look at the depth of the Board of Appeals, very talented legal minds on that. People have been there for 30 years. So it's not like we're We're asking for, you know, if I wanted to do a study on dental care, I wouldn't want to be on that committee. You know, I'd want a broad range of health professionals. And so when we're looking at a charge here, we want somebody with construction background, commercial construction background. Background, you know, Stories, Grovers, Chase, you know, somebody that's done projects. We want somebody with a banking background who knows a little bit about, you know, bond market and things like that. We know we want funding mechanisms, and yes, we can have people on that board that don't have any more skill set than being a member of the community and willing to study hard and help bring that, you know, decision about. But at the end of the day, what we really should be thinking about how we vote is this comes forward with a positive recommendation. Are we prepared to build a project down there? You know, it's, and I don't think we should just say let's, let's let the committee come back to the recommendation and then bury that for five years. You know, I want to build something down there if the numbers add up, and this is a viable project. Let's get on with it because the demand is there. You know, it doesn't take a lot of digging or driving around to the businesses in this community, the people who work in this community, sons and daughters, you know, of our peers who have no place to live and like a place to, like to get a foothold in the community. So it's a mechanism of providing that first start. And as Bill pointed out, it's not just workforce housing, it is housing. So you know, yeah, we can fall back and say we got our, you know, butt kicked up here on the ball fields, and sure enough. But you know, I think, you know, this is a, this is a different proposal. It's town-owned. I think the, you know, I don't, I don't think we have to defend this a lot. It's, we might be instead champion it's moving it forward. Jeffrey, so just listening to everyone, just I'm listening to everyone. A couple ideas have come through my head. You know, we have on Skyline Drive a project that is modeled after a project in Westbrook, and I guess what I'd like to think is that developer should be able to give us the cost to build that structure in a place without wedge, because I think in Westbrook it was built without wedge. So in terms of the math equation that we're trying to solve, trying to find out your cost to build something, Bob should be pretty easy if we can get That information on the developer, so then it turns into, because we already know the land cost, if you're hypothetically thinking Styles Way, then it turns into an operating model, and then it's a math equation, and you know you still have a committee, but I think if I think if we take it in a sense of let's look at duplicating that plan, that kind of streamlines things a little bit. It takes some of the variables out of it because from listening to Lily, I remember, you know, earlier you talked about the scope being almost too big. I think that narrows the scope, and then it answers the ultimate question, what is the impact on the taxpayer? It's just an idea. I'm throwing it out there. Maybe I'm all wrong. But maybe that kind of is something that streamlines things a little bit because my other my initial idea was actually consulting with you know a contract that's done a bunch of development projects, but what's what position does that put them in if they want to bid on doing this down the road, so just a thought. So are we looking at a specific project, are we looking at a wider you know town-owned land anywhere, trying to think, because I'm hearing both, I'm hearing that we're looking at everywhere that is town property, but then we're also looking at a specific project on Styles Way, and those are others. I think we need to choose one, and that's going to make it a lot easier for us to make a decision based on everything if we're going path A or B, thank you, because I do I agree with there's a little bit of inconsistency there because I did put in here right, you know, give us a matrix kind of with options, so you know reality, yeah, I think the reality is there's not a lot of town-owned property that would work for this, but I do think it might be right, it's if nothing else it we could do an inventory of sites, right? And we could have something that, you know, was, you know, based on criteria, right? A matrix that said, this site, well, it works, but maybe it's not in the growth area, or it doesn't have sewer, or it doesn't have water, right? And then that would, you know, it would it would give a broader field of consideration to go through and do this. But you know, I don't know, I know the town pretty well and I know there's not a lot of other town pieces of property that would probably go forward with it. So you know, I'm happy to have us look at and screen some other properties to see if that would be workable. But I think we could do that, but we would evaluate it based on some established criteria and then we could right focus on an area from there. Maybe that's a way to go, I don't know. Yeah, I 'm not sold, I don't think that, and I and I mentioned this in my email, but I think that there are a lot of other avenues that we have not looked at. All we haven't looked at things like deed restrictions, we haven't looked at ad use, we haven't done the due diligence. And I know not everyone was on the council when we went through this, but we did the research on the data. The town said like it said that 64% of people were in favor of affordable housing, and I moderated four listening sessions during that period at Valhalla, people screaming, people crying, and I can't endorse a project that I think is, Mike, you said it the last thing, you said it's like Groundhog Day, and it is to me, and it tore our council apart, it tore our community apart, and I can't go in good faith and say hey we're going to give this another go when we haven't looked at other things like our zoning, like what the private sector can do, like I want to exhaust or at least do that solid due diligence on other options, because I can't go back to the town and say yeah I didn't learn anything from three years ago, here's another one. I 'm not convinced that things are that I'm not convinced that anything has changed within our community. I think that people feel even more of the pinch right now, and our tax bills were, I think when they did the math a couple years ago it was going to hit people at like 36 or something. 36 is not a lot of impact to the taxpayer. Well I guess the question is where do we go from here. The one thing I don't want to see, the school is happy if they get a 51 to 49 vote even though half the people are against, half for four, and they're happy. A second, I don't want to be the school board. If we're gonna go forward with something I'd like to see the whole group, me personally like to see the whole group on board, and you're right, take it was horrible, so awful, it was, you know, I didn't like standing against the project and Shirley and we Have people that were absolute on the council that I mean it was like it was very personal. Someone mailed me a toilet seat like someone sent me a toilet it in the mail you know like it's like that was it didn't bring out like I don't think anyone disagrees that we have to like we need to figure something out because the affordability is the problem but I don't think this needs to be the knee-jerk reaction of what we do first when we haven't looked at what other parts of the country are doing what other tools are in our tool belt. Hannah Pingree was just elected and she said that her biggest thing is going to be affordable housing like what tools are going to come out of the governor's office I don't know I just I don't mean to be a downer on it like but if you don't you have to we learned a lot from that experience and Jeff So I'll just I'll share with everyone where I sit and this is a tough one for me because it's no secret I bought a house on Morrison's Hill you know 13 some odd years ago I was coming out of a divorce and I had to start my life over. I could have bought other houses in Cumberland there was houses I looked at on Farwell Avenue everything else that was just a better deal that I took advantage of at the time when I was younger so you know I am sympathetic to the need but at the same token I also look at if our actions drive current residents out of this town by tax by tax increases and tax burdens what have we accomplished and I think of people on Bruce Hill Road about water Bruce Hill Road's part half of it's in West Cumberland you know those are the people I represent I think of a bridge on Mill Road I think of Grilly Road that you know we need to do something with so I look at all that but at the same token Bob and Bill you have put a lot of effort into this and it's been passionate and a lot of hard work and it's great that we're doing that it's it's great to have the vision so what I can tell you I will support is let's run the numbers let's get the information but not a long-term committee, something six months before this council flips, no commitment to doing anything, but at least give the chance to answer the question that Bob has about the sustainability of his vision. Is it something that's financially possible? And if it's not, then we've answered Bob and Bill's question, and we move on. I agree with what you're saying, Tig. Hannah did that. Was one of her campaign initiatives affordable housing for the state of Maine. I'm curious what she's going to do. I also don't think it's fair to not, you know, look at what our peers have done or tried to do. And to me, I look at it as we're down to the point where we need to do a math equation. If we can streamline it, Bob, like I suggested, with the looking at the plans and the cost to build what's on Skyline Drive, and then looking at your rent based off of that, I don't think you're going to need a lot of time, and I will support that. But if we start to go in a different direction, I have a harder time wrapping my head around it. Thank you. So again, we still haven't defined what this is. I'll say it again, talking about a concept, and then we also have Bob saying I want to build down there, I want to build housing down there. We know this is Bob's passion project, building housing on Styles Way. It has come up multiple times. So that needs to be what this focus is if we're going to go down this path, not try to do two things at once, make it broad, and then meander our way back to a Styles Way project. Like, if that's what we're doing, commit like drill down on the scope, and instead of talking about housing in general, talk about how to make Stiles Way make sense, how to have mixed use, how to have, you know, care for the people living there, depending on who's living there. And then in that case, still, I don't agree with doing that at this time. Like what's changed since a few years ago? Costs have skyrocketed for one. We have a project going on Route One that's gonna have like what, 200 units or something. Like I'd like to see where that goes, if that fills a void for residents who want to downsize and are going to move into something that is cheaper market rate, but small and therefore much cheaper than what you'll find in town. So there are like a lot of different variables happening right now. And I don't want to just do it because we waited so long. We just need to do something. I'm bored or I want to get it done now. Like that isn't good enough for me. We know the need. Like Tig said, we have not looked at the ADUs, looking at how we can tweak ordinances even further to make it easier for people to split lots and whatnot and infill, develop, or feasible. And this is all part of a comp plan that still is not being implemented. So it's, I just think, and people say this all the time, but it is really bad timing. I'd like to see how things improve in the next couple years financially for building, first of all, and then how developments that are already happening in town are gonna shake out, and then if that is going to change the need that we have right now. And also we've got changes on at the Housing Authority level as far as wait lists and price changes and things like that, and things that are supposed to help get people through wait lists or trim down the wait list at least, so that it's only for people who actually need that level of senior affordable housing. So just I'm a wait and see right now. I don't, I don't endorse it as it is. Bob, you had your hand up. I haven't heard of and I don't know of another property that we have that is suitable for this type of construction. You know, water, sewer, electric. This is the only viable property that we can look at that will get us down to the affordability number. And I think we all agree, you have to listen carefully to just to hear that agreement, but, you know, limited scope of a project. I think that's easy to get there, you know. The other things we've talked about tonight are just as important, and it requires us putting our shoulder to the wheel to share that, share the vision, if you will. You know, we talk about taxes, we talk about a cost-sharing agreement, but what we're really talking about is a review of a charter between two towns and a school. But are we really ready to talk about what we really feel, and that's containing the cost of the tax rise? Is that, can we come into agreement that we want to talk about consolidation with other communities to help drive that cost down? Do we want to talk about expansion of collaboration? You know, we talk about health care. We're all waiting for that number to come in because, you know, it's always, well, we don't know what the health care cost is. Well, what if we combine our health care buying power with, you know, five other communities. You know, what does that do for us? You know, at some point, we can't wait for Augusta. We have to tell Augusta we're moving ahead. Facilitate us moving in that direction. It's a, there's always going to be a road in town that needs repair. That's just the nature of a community. There's always a building that needs a roof on it. There's always windows that need replacing. There's always a fire truck that's wearing out. Fundamentally, this is an opportunity for us to make a difference in people's lives. So I don't think it's a big ask. I don't think it's a, I don't think it takes a long time to get there. And, you know, I can't wait to see what, you know, if it's if it's no go it's no go well quick question for you if we had to move or build a town building a new public works a new town hall and I'm thinking down the future what land other than styles way would we possibly use because we were here when we tried to look for a brush dump and a salt shed. And that was over almost three years from start to finish. The only viable piece of property that we have is Stiles Way to expand town services. We have Twin Brooks. You want to put a new town garage down? We've talked about putting a school down there, you know, in the past. we've talked about a couple other things you know there is no deed restriction on twin Brooks to prohibit the town from utilizing it in a matter that was necessary for the community we have a five acre civic a lot behind public works that's still remains viable well yeah you can't do anything else on the public works property you can't do anything because of the landfill that's not part of the civic lot right but you've got i mean i'm looking we're looking at a playground down here and we're getting inundated and you think we're going to put a public works garage down there you asked me what other opportunities were there you know i fair enough you're right so bill and bob how would you guys like to proceed from here so we can take some kind of sure so I like the idea of being very specific I tried to keep it open right but again if we have too many things in here to consider it's hard for committee to do its job in a quick point period of time so I do think you know looking at the styles way as a piece whiz would be the charge here to understand what the cost model would be and once you build it you could use it somewhere else right you know so that's the that's my thought process you know i realize that there are real reasons all the way around why you guys don't want to reopen this and then i can see the see the pain in your eyes right yeah i can imagine it did i imagine it does and I give Tig a lot of credit because she took the brunt of it but I can tell you there was a lot of hurt feelings and on this council that never healed yeah and I don't want to go down that path again so I'm not even like I'm not Against going down that path if we truly feel like we have exhausted all of the other opportunities, but I don't think that we have done that work. We haven't looked at ADUs, we haven't looked at deed restrictions, we have not done that work yet. And so to just go straight to this in my mind is like it's, I don't want to say lazy, but it's kind of like, all right, we kind of did this before, we know what the process is, we've got a parcel in mind, you know, like there have to be other options out there and I think that we need to do that due diligence if we're going to come to a point where we're going to reopen this can of worms, and it may not be a can of worms, but let's at least do the work of looking at what other parts of the country are doing, what other parts of Maine are doing, because there's, it there's data out there, if there's projects out there, are best practices out there, like am I wrong, does anyone else feel like we've really done that due diligence on other models? I can, I mean, I'm looking at the task force from 2023 and they say right in here, like look at tiny homes, like co-housing, like we haven't looked at manufactured housing, we haven't looked at a lot of the things that have been recommended and that exist. This is like, again, this is Bob's project, this has been Bob's project, and so I don't want to just do that because it's, you know, someone has a strong feeling about it and just wants it, like that's not good enough for me, need to, and so if you want to have a committee that goes way broad and is going to just again information gather and be real broad, like what takes saying, like looking at trends and possibilities, good, because there are still things that we can do that don't require any funds exhausted, any shovels in the ground at all, that can still help make affordable housing in town. I mean there's a, just, I mean, I guess one thing we all got to remember is if we stick with running the numbers right, we're not approving anything, and it kind of answers Bob's question, because financially, if it doesn't make sense to me, I'm done, it, you know, but it's like I kind of curious to know, so it's that's that's why I'll favor a narrow scope and see what they check out at, I mean it's hard for me to turn my back on somebody's put all the effort in that he has, well I guess I mean trying to read the tea leaves here, we're probably a fourth three, Bill and Bob, do you guys want to, do you guys want to try to go forward with a 4-3 board, that's what you got, or Narrow the scope of it and come back with a really specific plan that we can then get into more and refine. I would say I thought that's what we had initially, and then we kind of broaden it out a little bit, so I went back to it, the initial proposal, right, tweak that. I mean, we have this like mock-up of some buildings on a map, like it's no, I mean, in the initial proposal that we put together in August, right, I mean, the two pages of bullet points, yeah, the word its initial work plan, right, was meant there. So it seems to me, I'm not feeling, you know, certainly there's some strong opposition here. I don't think that this is a vote to support this one way or the other. I think it is a component of understanding how we solve the affordable housing issue. We have a lot of work to do on zoning, subdivision, a lots, tiny houses, and everything else. This is just a piece that will give us some more information as to what the options and levers are we have to help solve that, right, it's not so, yeah, if you, if there are folks that want to make some tweaks in here, I'm happy to have them do that if that would help make this go better. I don't want to sit here and, you know, we've been talking about it really since August, right, you said it wouldn't go this long either. I know, I know, yeah, maybe how about this, I don't want to do this, but if there's folks that are willing to go and take a crack at narrowing this up, I've looked at it three or four times, if there's someone else who wants to take a crack at narrowing this up and being more specific, I'm certainly willing to table this and look at it again. All did that hurt, yeah, exactly, all right, I'm all set. Okay, it's five minutes of, we'll take a break till seven, and thanks for, all right. Good evening everybody, welcome to the Monday, November 9th, 2026, come on, town council meeting. I'll call the meeting to order. First item is the approval of the minute from October 26. Motion to, sorry, I'll be happy to provide you the motion to approve the minutes from October 26. Second, all those in favor, the next item is the business organization highlight, but before I start that, I just want to take a quick moment and thank the veterans of our community. The 11th is Veterans Day, and you know, the, we have a lot of holidays throughout the year and a lot of days recognition, and it's, it's important. We have a veteran Bob on the council. Personally, my father served, father-in-law, and my son just got done serving six years overseas, so it's, it's an important day of recognition, so Thoughts and thanks are out to all the veterans. Hey, Mike. Yes, Lily. Too is a veteran. What's that, Lily is a veteran? As am I. Oh, and I didn't even get the day off either. Yeah, thank you. Nice and Bill, we were just asking that if you were over there and I got it, so but thank you all. It doesn't go unnoticed. So the next item up is the business organization highlight. Every town council meeting we invite a local business to come up, tell us what they do, services they offer, where they are, and so on. So this week I am proud to introduce and have asked her to come up my friend Brenda Pitcher. She is the owner of Cumberland Baking and Catering. Brenda, if you come up when I When I saw Brender last week I said do not come into hand anyways. Thanks for coming in tonight, Brenda. Thanks to
[1:14:03] Brenda Pitcher: See you all, thank you. Good evening members of the town council and neighbors. My again my name is Brenda Pitcher and I am the proud owner and head dishwasher of Cumberland Baking and Catering. We're a small business that grew out of the very heart of this community. We focus on made-to-order treats, custom handcrafted desserts tailored exactly to our clients preferences. We also customize catering events. We do not have a published menu of items. I like the approach of listening to clients and needs And wants and crafting a menu accordingly. A little background of how we started. In 2010 I started participating in the farmers markets focusing just on baked goods, and as my personal situation changed I was offered commercial space in 2014 that allowed us to scale up and serve even more people in the area. Then came the spring of 2020 and we halted business as usual for 18 months. We pivoted as most small businesses did and a new avenue of custom catering fall into our laps. People wanted to Gather but most function rooms were still closed. We'd offered a service of going into people's homes and offered custom eats for their friends and family. Today Cumberland Baking and Catering operates a specialized made-to-order business run directly from my home. This model allows us to add personalization into everything that we create. If you are thinking of planning an upcoming event we would love to help you with your next celebration. Thank you for allowing me this opportunity to speak this Evening and thank you for continuing to make our town a place where small businesses and families can
[1:15:44] Councilor: Thrive. Thank you. Know Brenda, I think this council can testify how good your food is. Yes. Big supporters, I appreciate that. Yeah, I just wanted to say thank you. I adore your approach of listening and kind of figuring out. It also has to be kind of fun for you to, like, creatively, I would imagine, to be able to brainstorm and get great
[1:16:06] Brenda Pitcher: feedback from that, because we don't want to be that black and white and cut and dry. I want to listen to your knees and what time of year are we having things
[1:16:13] Councilor: Well, you execute beautifully, so I can't even imagine what kind of wacky needs you get, but I'm sure it'd be really cool to see all the different things you do
[1:16:21] Brenda Pitcher: But always say yes and we figure it out. If you figure it out, you can find me online, you can find on social media. Yes, that's where I am. Thank you, and I live
[1:16:31] Councilor: right down the street, anybody. Thank you, thank you very much. Absolutely, don't, thanks for coming. Yes, I'll hand this down. Next item is the manager support, Mr. Manager. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good evening, council
[1:17:01] Town Manager: Good evening, folks. Good to see you all this evening. Thanks for coming out, taking some time. A number of folks have had the chance to sit down with over the past three or four weeks for, so that'd be the first item that I have in my manager's report tonight is a Mill Road bridge update. Many folks may have already heard some of what I'm about to say, but if you haven't, then I hope this provides some updates as well as the most information that we have at this point in time. So I've reached out to maine dot with several follow-up questions concerning the Mill Road bridge including the basis for its recommend its access recommendations and potential options to accelerate replacement we're dedicating considerable efforts to this and to finding a workable solution for the town and for Mill Road residents during our meeting with Ben Foster of the main DOT and Chris Bolduc our public works director and my assistant manager Ben indicated that the bridge would be reduced from its current 30 ton posting a three ton limit. Closure to vehicular traffic was recommended because of the risk of vehicles exceeding that limit and because the town could not conduct snow removal operations without exceeding the proposed posting. They did the full closure as money as everybody knows last Thursday, so they did put that in place, and they have eight foot jersey barriers that they had not high but wide that they placed. There is some space along the margins that looks negotiable for pedestrians and challenging for bikes but doable. However, pedestrian and bicycle access was not discussed with the Maine DOT at that meeting. Maine DOT subsequently advised that there should be no pedestrian or bicycle traffic on the bridge but indicated that the town could allow such use if it chose to assume liability. I've asked the main DOT to explain the engineering safety and liability considerations supporting that recommendation, particularly given that pedestrian and bicycle traffic would not approach the three ton limit. You can have the Tour of France ride through there and you wouldn't be able to hit that, so you can understand my perplexity. I've also emphasized that this position leaves the town to arbitrate the issue and creates a difficult situation with residents. It's just not fair. So we've been pushing back on that. I have asked whether Maine DOT would consider a cost-sharing arrangement or allow the town to fund the full replacement cost if the town wished to pursue engineering and replacement sooner than currently programmed. We're seeking a clear understanding of any pathway to advance the project outside of the current schedule, which is unclear, and that's concerning. I know the state has, you know, multiple bridges with multiple communities with higher car counts that may be higher priority to them because they've got a full state to consider, but it's important to us and our staff has reiterated that point. It, you know, it's the one bridge that we don't have in town that's not open, so, and it's a critical connection between the neighborhood, so we've tried to emphasize that point. We're seeking a clear understanding of any way, any pathway to advance the project outside of the current schedule. We've also requested that Maine D.O.T. share with Chris and I the substance of its discussions with Representative Mitchell and Senator Pierce, which they met two weeks ago, including whether alternatives or funding alternate opportunities were discussed. This includes programs such as an MPI, which is a Municipal Partnership Initiative, which is how we funded the recent work that took place on Route 100, so that, you know, like, well, can we expedite that? And I think I will say Representative Pierce and, sorry, Representative Mitchell and Senator Pierce are looking on advocating for us. In that position as well, so I think that's a live, a live item, given the considerable interest from the council, which has been acute and intense and very supportive, as well as the Mill Road residents. I've requested a Maine D.O.T. workshop or presentation as soon as possible. The request identified November 9th, which is tonight, obviously they're not here, but the 23rd of November as preferred opportunities, because the sooner the later, the sooner the better, sorry, not the sooner the later, the sooner the better, but I also identified December 14th and the 28th as alternatives if November is not feasible. I have not received a response outside of, just I did get a response from the Commissioner just stating that he's going to get together with his team to discuss and we should hear from them. I did a follow-up again last week to follow up and say is there any updates, and he said they've had a couple of bridge incidents where people had run into bridges, and he's gonna get back to me, so I will continue that outreach until we get something on the schedule. So we have taken it very seriously, and it's a, it's a very important item to staff as well, so it's not on, it's not falling on deaf ears, it's, it's critical to us, and as soon as I get that information or response back from Maine DOT, I will share that with the folks that I've spoken with, and I know there's a good distribution that you all have in the neighborhood to hopefully get that through, and we'll put it out on our website as well so we'll try to share as much information as soon as and accurately as it comes into the office, so that's kind of where we're at from the operations standpoint at this point, so you know just about everything that I know at this, at this stage. Another hot-button item is the CMP Portland transmission upgrade project. CMP will be meeting with Cumberland residents at a community workshop on this Thursday, November 12th, from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. here in council chambers. There are additional details on the website relating to that issue. They're hosting these meetings across the greater Portland area. Tonight they're in Westbrook, and they have got us scheduled for next, or this Thursday, and they have others in the region that they're, they're hosting, but more importantly here on this Thursday, also Linda Ball, the CMP president, will also attend the Cumberland Town Council workshop on November 23rd, so we have that confirmed, they're gonna Answer additional questions regarding their CMP's plans for their transmission project upgrade as well as have a brief presentation kind of outlining the details of what they're planning. So please put that on your dance card. We successfully closed on the land parcel acquisition at Twin Brooks on last Monday. So that is done and done. Very, happy to have that done. And the assessor's already received the deed from the Cumberland County Registry, so he's working to butt that into our into our property so that's great news the winter recreation brochure was released last week and offers a wide range of programs for all ages. Residents are encouraged to review the brochure and explore the available activities. Now if you missed the first couple dates of the Friends of the Prince Memorial Library book sale tomorrow is your last opportunity so please keep that on your dance card as well. The Friends of Prince Memorial Library have been hosting their biggest book sale of the year. Final day is tomorrow, November 10th, from 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. Residents are invited to fill a bag and make a donation. So tomorrow's your last chance for this year. Legislative outreach. I did reach out to our recently re-elected state representative, Christina Mitchell, regarding amending two areas of law in the upcoming session. One is to amend the TIF extension law to allow the use of funds from extended TIFs to be for affordable housing and or transportation. Right now it just says or without the and, so it's either one or the other but not both. Where it currently states affordable housing or transportation, so we're trying to get that fixed. The other concept is to amend the law requiring solar projects to abut the properties they benefit and to allow the exporting of solar energy to non-abutting sites if the project is for municipal and or school use and for multi municipality and or multi-school unit benefit. Councilor Vale had done some research on that working with revision and that's been a challenge overall so it may find a way for schools and towns to find affordable electricity as we all are converting to less fossil fuels and a way to have that. We've done a great job here in town with our solar field expansion and what we have, but if we could find ways for other towns as well as schooled units to benefit from that, would be great. Finally, I have an election update. An enormous amount of pride in the residents of Cumberland at last week's polls. 85% of active voters turned out to vote. That's enormous. That's 5,782 voters. Approximately 3,800 voters participate in the absentee voting process and 2,000 voted on election day. That is a huge point of pride, so well done, kudos to Cumberland, and a special thank you to our clerk's department, by our town clerk Jennifer Doughton and her team of Jen McNeil, Paige Thurlow, and Allison Clark. They did amazing work for the whole election window, from day to day and in and out with all the folks. An additional thank you to all of the volunteers who helped in the processing absentee ballots as well as staff the election day tables. That's a lot of work and we couldn't do without our good volunteers. And finally a thank you to our public works and police departments for managing the traffic flow. It was truly a team effort. I'm really proud of how our whole team worked together. So that's all I have this evening, Mr. Chairman Matt, if you'd extend the
[1:27:09] Councilor: appreciation of the council to all your folks because it was, it was smooth, it really was, and very much appreciated, and there's a lot of work. Thank you. Thanks, Bob. I also want to thank, that I voted for a long time and this was the first time that I saw the public works staff out front, and you know, I just sensed their sense of pride for being there, and their, you know, they, it was just great to see them there and their participation. It was like you said, it was all hands and it was, it was great. Thank you. Thanks. Thank you, Council Bill. Pile on with like thanking the PD for being so active in the parking lot because there are a lot of close calls, so that traffic directing was very helpful. No, thank you.
[1:27:58] Town Manager: I know chief was back there but he's, I know he's watching downstairs, so thank you for that.
[1:28:06] Councilor: Two things. One, continuing the praise for election. I've sat at the tables, it's fantastic. If people are interested in voting or in working the polls, they're always looking for volunteers. But switching over to the bridge, do we know or have any information about the last time it was actually inspected? And I think that's sort of something that I'm guessing that there's understaffed and there are a lot of bridges in Maine and all that, but I doubt that it got to the condition that it's in two years. And sort of what happened there, and if we can get maybe our reps involved with digging into that, of how often they are actually able to invest, you know, look at these bridges and inspect them, and so we don't have the, it's great, it's great, it's great.
[1:28:58] Town Manager: It's horrible, you have to shut it down now. Yeah, I think that's a great point, Council McGoon. We did, let's see what I had here. We did receive their most recent inspection report, and I've shared that with a couple, a couple of folks to share. We got a response back, but I have not seen these inspection reports yet. We've requested them, but we haven't seen them yet, that they were, they said the prior inspections of the structure were performed on 8 5 of 24, January 24th of 23, and April 8th of 21. We have not seen those reports yet, so we've requested to see those as well, to see if they can show and track the changes over time. That's, that's pretty much where we're at now, but we did see the most recent one, and I mean, like this was probably, and folks could probably correct me if wrong, it's got to be six or seven years, maybe eight, that they put up the barriers along the rails that had deteriorated. So this is more than that, maybe 10. Okay, maybe 10 then, yeah, time goes by fast, so but yeah, I mean. That's, that's the most recent activity that I've, I mean, I run on it and ride on it myself, so but yeah, we're, we're still trying to get all that as well, to just kind of say okay, let's, let's track this, and we gotta get, we gotta go, we gotta go, gotta move this forward. Matt, we appreciate this is a council.
[1:30:25] Councilor: Priority, and we appreciate you making a priority as well, so thanks. And thank you, we're frustrated. All right, Jeff, go ahead, man. Have we had any luck securing some turnarounds for spaces for plow trucks that alternatively could be used for school buses if SAD 51 chooses to? Is that anything we've just been accomplished, I'd be able to accomplish? I know one of the concerns from the residents was the school bus pickup on Blanchard Road going down the hill there, and I don't really blame them, so I didn't know if we had any luck in that area.
[1:30:57] Town Manager: I know Chris has had some really productive conversations with getting a turnaround for town vehicles on the Blanchard Road side and been working with property owner at the end to try to secure that. And basically we need to, we need to get an easement in place and a couple other things, but those have been productive conversations. So Chris has been really working hard on that, on that side of it. As far as how the school runs their bus routes, like we don't have really, we don't have, I mean I could give you my opinion on it but i don't like we don't run the operation of the school buses but hopefully if we can have that and make that as a known element that 'd be something that they could also consider thank you
New Business
[1:31:41] Councilor: Okay, all right, the next portion of this meeting will be going into public discussion. Public discussion is for comments on items that are not on the agenda. Comments are limited to five minutes per person. Rebuttal comments will be limited to two minutes. Public discussion topics may be brought up again under new business for further council discussion. Is there anybody here from the public that would like to talk about something that is not on the agenda? It is not for tonight. I mean, we wanted an overview, which the manager just gave. Sure you can. Please, if you just go up to the mic and introduce who you are, where you live.
[1:32:36] Harold Skelton: My name is Harold Skelton. I live at [address] in Cumberland. That's on the Route 100 side of the bridge. Just to kind of bring you folks up to speed on what's happened, it's been going on a week now that the bridge has been closed. I think most of our Mill Road residents, we're adjusting our patterns and finding a way around it comfortably enough to immediate concerns, I guess. One is pedestrian and bicycle access across the bridge. A lot of people walk the length of the road daily, frequently with our neighbors and friends on the road. There is bicycle traffic regularly down the road and across the bridge. It is possible today to pick your way through the barriers and get across the bridge, but I think it would be really Helpful to all of us. It'd be different, you know, you'd have to carry a bicycle across it. I think it'd be really helpful to all of us if we could just get, you know, a sidewalk with opening in the barriers. It just be a matter of repositioning the barriers slightly and pushing them aside so, you know, financially it's not a big ask. It's a couple of hours of public works time probably. I have heard concerns raised about liability. I'm really not sure where that comes from. I mean, the only way I can conceive of any significant liability issue is if someone thinks the bridge is going to collapse under pedestrian traffic, and that's just completely unrealistic. That's not gonna happen. So I'm not sure, I don't really, I'm not aware of any anything that prevents the town from simply rearranging the barriers and giving us some space to walk through side by side with our friends and neighbors or ride a bicycle through, give us a reasonable opening. That's one point I hope to make. The other I guess is replacement of the bridge, and you know there are various opinions about that. I know of at least a couple of people on the road who are fine with the bridge being closed. It slows traffic, it's quieter. I understand that view and certainly respect it. I appreciate that myself, but I and I've heard from one neighbor who feels that it's not a good use of taxpayer money to rebuild the bridge, we can live without it. But I think the sense of most of our neighbors and most of the people in the Mill Road community are that we'd like to have a passable bridge, be able to drive from one end of the road to the other, shorten the trip into town, into Yarmouth. So, I guess that's with respect to everybody's varying views, I think it's at least important. I'm glad to hear that the town is working toward the possibility of a new bridge, at least. The DOT has effectively said, you know, there's billions of dollars, literally billions of dollars of infrastructure projects with the DOT that, you know, my wife was out there when the DOT was out there one day, and they basically said, we're never rebuilding a bridge here, you know. Get used to it. It so if it's gonna happen, I think it's gonna have to be a town impetus. One final thing, I just don't know who to bring this up to, so I'm gonna raise it here. The DOT installed some signage, particularly on the Route 100 side, bridge out, you know, through traffic, etc. They put it so close to the corner of Route 100 that by the time you can free your attention from making the corner, you're already past the sign. So if that sign, for that sign to be useful in any way, it really needs to be moved, you know. 100 yards further down the road, and again, I don't think the D.O.T. is coming back to do that, so it's probably our job. I think other people may have
[1:36:53] Councilor: a few things to say. Thank you very much, Matt. Do you want to respond to any of that? Maybe it will help so people won't have to come up and repeat the same. Yeah, we can explore getting
[1:37:04] Town Manager: in there with a loader if we can and to shape things around. I think that's, I mean, no, delicately from one side and then the other, but no, seriously, I think we can look at that. As I'm sorry, so it doesn't go off, so we can look at that as a potential thing. We can augment it by the sign thing. Yeah, just, I mean, just enough, a little bit to get some space, and then the sign thing, we can get out there tomorrow to take a look at that if it's going to be moved around. Yeah, when they, after they first shut it down, they had like no signage up, so we hustled pretty fast. Hey, we need more signage here because people got to get in there, and then they gotta try to figure out where to go with it. We are looking at some other options that might be able to help us in the, like, closer term, but not any point we can say anything about that because it's been kind of trial balloons thrown out here, so waiting for responses on either short-term, short-term solutions versus long-term solutions. But then I'd really like them to just say, can we, can we engineer something and get, you know, if the town's going out to bonding on a larger project, we can get that alignment at the same time. We could accomplish a lot because it's a, you know, I mean, bridges are at least a 50-year element, and you do a 20-year bond on something like that and you get 30 years to the plus side, and it makes it fiscally affordable. So we are looking at every option that we can. The liability thing, yeah, we just need to get that one way or the Other like I said in my run my manager's report when they told us it's at three tons like we could all just go out there right now and jump up and down and wouldn't approach half of that. So that's kind of the silliness of where we're at. So we're trying to work on that side of it. Thank you Matt. We'll go back to
[1:38:58] Councilor: public discussion. Please come up introduce yourself and where you live.
[1:39:04] Sarah Crisp: Good evening my name is Sarah Crisp and my husband and I own the mill and the house on the hill on the corner of Mill and Mill Ridge. And I want to say I really appreciate all the attention and the counselor coming out to talk with all our neighborhood about this issue. So it's not gone unnoticed and we really appreciate it. And I just had this one thought when you were talking about the bus. I think that somebody should drive a big bus down there and try and turn it around in the mill driveway because it could be really tight. So that was my only thought so thank you very much. Thank you very much and thanks for the kind words.
[1:39:50] Councilor: Anybody else please come up my
[1:39:57] Graham Zorn: pen's running out of ink so I don't have much to say. I'm Graham Zorn I live at [address] so part of the Mill Road neighborhood and I have a 10 year old daughter about to be 10 she'll be 10 next week. She just learned how to ride her bike down Mill Road, find friends on the other side, just in time for the bridge to be closed. So along those lines, you know, town manager, I heard you talk about some pitches for legislative fixes. It seems like one of the gaps we have here that may have led to part of this is a gap in data on non-motorized uses of infrastructure. That's a problem now for this. It could be a problem in future for other infrastructure projects in the town of Cumberland something to consider in your conversations. It's certainly something that I'm going to raise with my elected representatives that non-motorized uses be considered in infrastructure decisions as well as just community connectivity. I mean there are neighbors that are we're on opposite sides of that divide we are now a divided neighborhood. My daughter cannot get to her friends on the other side without a far more perilous route that I don't think anybody would send a nine- or ten-year-old to do. So that's one point. I appreciate the discussion of pressing for details on liability. Liability for what? I spend my day thinking about liability. I'm a lawyer. I don't understand it. And that's always the question, is liability for what? It's a scare word. We all worry about it. We should worry about it, but I'm glad to hear you say that, and then just a another request for the council, town staff, public works, maybe, but you know this is our community. Cumberland has many neighborhoods and communities. Are there other bridges out there that we have the same problem, that, you know, I know the town relatively well, I can't think of another one, but let's take a look at that and make sure that there isn't some other lingering time bomb out there waiting to divide a neighborhood, so Anyways, those are my thoughts. Happy to be a resource for the council. Had a nice conversation with Councilman Needs about this. Appreciate the support, but you have the neighborhood behind you. Let us know if there are things that we can help you with, and we're behind
[1:42:14] Councilor: you. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else from the public? Please come up. Hey,
[1:42:27] Legaya Atwood: there. My name is Legaya Atwood. I live at [address], pardon me, and I also have two small children, seven and nine, and we are part of that group who are now forced to go to the end towards Blanchard, and we have a pack of very active children, active boys who like to push and run and whatnot, and we are concerned very much about, especially with the winter coming right now, we've made do with what we needed to do, and we understood that the bridge needed to be closed, of course. We also believe that you know, we'd like to be able to be connected to our community just the same way. I'm not necessarily opposed to the bridge being closed to vehicular traffic. I'm sort of the opinion that it might be nice to have it be a little quieter, but either way I can understand both positions. I do think in my sort of dive down the, you know, rabbit hole looking at different things, my in-laws live in South Thomaston, and I know up in that area there's actually a case that's sort of being tossed around in a Community not exactly the same thing because that bridge, it's the Mount Batty bridge I believe, in Camden area, where it literally divided a community, and the same situation is sort of going through the council there and trying to decide, well, how do we deal with this? In that case they had to take down the entire bridge because the bridge under structure was not going to be possible to rebuild, it was very old, but that doesn't prevent necessarily the idea that you could have a pedestrian walkway if you had to take it down. In this case I don't think anyone, everyone is saying that the bridge needs to come down because, like you said, you could easily go have 3,000 pounds of humans jumping up and down, and it's very unlikely that this bridge is going to go anywhere for many, years, certainly with enough time to find other solutions to reinforcing that or making sure it stays safe for humans to cross over. When I first moved here about four years ago, the very first thing that happened was I got stuck at the end of my driveway because of the snow banks, and I met my first friends in the neighborhood that way, so it is a community and I think that should be taken into account when it comes to making decisions about the bridge. And also if you go to the main gov as Graham said, if you go to their you know dot gov website, part of the whole premise of the you know D.O.T. is to encourage bikes and different ways to, they have a whole web page about it and how important it is to communities, to the air, to the you know to the flavor of a neighborhood, and I think we all in that neighborhood would agree it's very nice, many people use it, they walk their dogs, and I've spoken to many neighbor neighbors. I did ask a FOA request for information, same information that you got, I haven't received any of that, and I did attend the school board meeting last week to also mention to them, I've also mentioned to Mr. Gray and the school board that we do have concerns about that and we should find solutions for the children before it snows, so it's very pressing for us, and I think that we just want to make sure it's on record that you know this is important to us as a community. Thanks so much.
[1:45:59] Councilor: Thank you very much. Anybody else? Good.
[1:46:15] Mark Isaacson: Evening. I'm Mark Isaacson. I live on [street], about a mile from the bridge. I walk across it about three times a week. It's great, I love it, and I'm hopeful that you'll be able to widen that track a little bit so people can get across. You can get across now on foot, but not very well with a bike. If we do nothing, eventually the bridge will have to be removed, and I think that's the least attractive of all the options, because then bikes will absolutely not get across and pedestrians will have to choose by either go around or pick their way across the rocks, which is not exactly a safe solution. My suggestion is that the feeling seems to be about mixed as to whether we should replace it for vehicular traffic or not. Clearly it will be expensive, so my suggestion would second the prior speaker that we seriously consider just making a new pedestrian and bicycle bridge there in place of the vehicular bridge. The vehicles can, you know, pretty readily find a way to go around, but it's tough for bicycles and especially for pedestrians. I am NOT a structural engineer, but I spent most of my adult life building structures in and around the water. I have a strong suspicion that those about existing abutments would be perfectly fine for a pedestrian bridge, and therefore the cost of building such a bridge is probably a fraction of what the cost of a new vehicular bridge would be. And that way we might answer some of the complaints about wasting the time town's money on a structure that's not really needed. So I thank you for your attention. I hope we find a way. Appreciate it very
[1:48:03] Councilor: much. Is there anybody else want to be heard on public discussion? If not, Jeff, do you have a, do you want to take a brief moment? Sure, I was gonna speak on the Mill Road bridge during new business, but I guess where my head it goes of this is I'd really like to keep the pressure on main DoT. I continue to think we need to look at a out-of-the-box solution in terms of replacement for vehicular traffic. It's, you know, I've seen plenty of bridges on logging roads up in Aroostook County that would probably make one of MDOT structural engineers sick to their stomach, but somehow they handle 250,000 pounds at 80 miles an hour. So I don't know, they're doing something right up there. I'm not looking to design a bridge on a napkin, but, you know, I really suggest we challenge Maine DOT and utilize their engineering arm. I mean, they may not have funding to go out and replace this, but they have engineers on staff. And what can we build that may not be the traditional design with, you know, three foot tall steel girders and everything else that meets 300,000 pounds? But we were, we were all right with 30 tons before the closure. If we could get to 50 tons, we'd be better. We wouldn't have the restriction from public safety vehicles. And could we do it with precast concrete instead of, you know, the traditional function? Look into doing something like that. I don't know what their engineers are going to respond to that, but we're looking to use their brain power, not their funding. And I'd like to think maybe they could be willing to flex a little bit and consider doing something like that. And then once we realize, okay, well, we can design a precast structure, then we can look at a cost. Then it's, it's how does it all fall in line with everything else? So to me, it's like the engineering is the first step of this. And if you can't fund it, Main Dot, can you at least design it? And what do we have for options? So I'd like to really see if we could push on that in that direction. Thanks, Jeff. Before everybody leaves for tonight, I just want to say thank you for coming in. We hear you loud and clear. It's not going in one ear and out the other, I promise you. We just had a discussion of housing, we brought it up. I don't think we have any kind of meetings that we don't talk about Mill Road and the bridge. So I just want you, we hear you, please. So and thank you all for coming in, we really appreciate it. The next, the next item is legislation and policy item 26 dash 120 to hold a public hearing to consider an act on amendments to chapter 315 zoning section 71 residential care facilities of the Cumberland code of ordinances as recommended by the Planning Board it's
[1:51:13] Bridget Perry: all yours, Bridget. I'm back with ordinance changes. Bridget Perry. I'm the director of planning. Let's see. So we started looking at this because we have a residential care facility that's looking to expand on Route 1. The Heron House is looking to build actually another building behind the Heron House that they're going to call the Frederick House. But the residential care facilities ordinance that was in place restricted that development, and it wasn't going to be allowed under the site coverage provision, which as it stands today says that no more than 10 percent of the site can be covered by a building. So the existing here in house is nine and a half percent coverage of that four ish acre lot. So in thinking about the comprehensive plan and what the town would like to see, I thought that was way too restrictive, and we want more residential care facilities. So I went to town on this ordinance, removed that restriction, and while I was there kind of just took out all the stuff that was super complicated and made things really difficult, and I reviewed that with the code enforcement officer and he was totally on board, and so was the planning board, and now you have it. Any
[1:52:41] Councilor: any questions from the council for Bridget Andrew? There's some T's I want to cross. Yeah, in the reserved units bit you took out a whole bunch of language at the very end of that, this is a section F paragraph, and just said the immediate household income as determined by Department of Housing and Urban Development. Do we need to put in there, you know, for this area or something like that, because HUD has different determinations of 80 of the median household income for Carmel County or Greater Portland area, or you know, do we need
[1:53:22] Bridget Perry: that more specificity in there? Quite frankly we can strike that last sentence if you want to, because we define affordable units according to state law in the zoning definitions. Could
[1:53:39] Councilor: I interpret that as to main care, the
[1:53:49] Bridget Perry: affordable right I can't tell you that 's not my expertise it should be required to serve at least 10
[1:53:58] Councilor: percent of its units for affordable unit units, and you know, at some level that equates to main care. You know, once you reach a certain level of lack of income if you will, then you revert to main care and the state picks up the difference there. So I'm just, you probably don't have an answer, and I don't know if I do. Not, can I jump in here, please? Typically it does. They look at a whole range of asset needs, right, in there, and it's pretty hard for facility, to my experience, to deny someone Medicaid or main care. That there's no science on that, but just past experience, that's that's the way it's worked. Any other question? Go ahead Bob, you got something else? No. Any other questions of Bridget from the council before I turn it over to the public? Can I make a comment please go ahead I just wanted to say thank you Bridget as you remember from our comprehensive plan one of the things that we are supposed to be thinking about is our zoning doing what it should be doing and is it unnecessarily complex so I know that we're talking about one specific thing but i really do appreciate the housekeeping and making things more understandable and accessible for everybody because that's a good thing you know we should be able to understand it shouldn't be overly complex So thank you for the effort this is a public hearing. Is there anybody from the public that would like to come up make a comment on this item or ask Bridget a question? See none. I'll turn it back over to the council. Any more comments concerns? I'll entertain a motion. I'll give you one I move to amend chapter 3-1-5 zoning section 71 residential care facilities of the Cumberland code of ordinances is recommended by the planning board. Second. All those in favor all [Town Manager: right item] 26-121 to hold a public hearing to consider and act on a warfing out permit for seven Broad Cove Way.
[1:56:31] Town Manager: Mr. Manager. Even Mr. Chairman, actually we have Chief Rumsey is here to kind of tee this up as well as I believe Ellie is here from Flycatcher who is the consultants on the project as well to answer any questions, but Chief Rumsey can give you the update from the coastal waters
[1:56:52] Chief of Police: commission side of it chief the floor is yours thank you mr chair counselors and mr manager i think you have a memo in your packet regarding recent meeting by the coastal waters commission they held their meeting on october 14th during that meeting we conducted a site walk of the site of this proposed new pier ramp and floats down at 7 broadcove way following the site visit we returned here to council chambers and held a public hearing and then a coastal waters commission meeting and for those that haven't gone through that process, we have town council, we have town ordinance excuse me that sets out the requirements for application review for these warfing out permits. So we provide these, provide this list of items that are in the ordinance for the coastal waters commission to take a look at, compare what's required by our ordinance to what's in the application. The coastal waters Commission satisfied themselves that this application was compliant with the ordinance and following their Discussion they unanimously recommended approval of the permit to you folks for your consideration. So I'm happy to try to answer any questions that you might have. If they're technical questions I'm going to quickly pivot to Ellie because she's been the I wrote down her title environmental specialist from Fly Catcher on this project and she could answer questions about erosion control and some of the you know the materials that go into the structure or anything like that you might be curious about
[1:58:30] Councilor: Is there any questions from the council for the chief or for Ellie? See any this is a public hearing is there anybody from the public that would like to be heard or ask the chief or Ellie a question? Seeing none I'll bring it back to the council any comments really well put together packet that's why I don't really have any questions. It's very detailed any question I had it was already answered. The only silly thing I noticed is that on the Army Corps of Engineers the signature doesn't match the actual name below the signature block. We know that you did a very thorough review any other questions or comments from the council Bob again very thorough application. I was on the Coastal Water Commission involved with a couple of the applications in the past and so this is this is well prepared well thought out and well engineered. I think that if anybody was paying attention or not paying attention when their mind was drifting, if you looked at the layout and that wharf and the pier and the gangway it would be easy to construct a gangway or better yet take it up to Mill Road and you would have your pedestrian bicycle access across the bridge. Not much money. money. So, you know, just to make the point, you know, to provide pedestrian and bicycle access is not very expensive. Great. Is there a, you got a motion, Bob, while you're Okay. I would move to approve the wharfing out permit for Seven Broad Cove Way as recommended by the Coastal Waters Commission. Is there a second? Second. second any further discussion all those in favor great thank you chief thank you Ellie we appreciate it and thanks for the great job on the application thank you packet the last item is 26-122 to consider an act on a town council resolution opposing the issuance of a certificate of public convenience and necessity for the CMP Greater Portland transmission
[2:00:58] Town Manager: upgrades as submitted Mr. Manager Thank You Mr. Chairman and Council, based on the last Council meeting and direction from the Council was to come forward with a resolution for the Council to consider at this evening's meeting. I will say I, we have good friends next door in Falmouth and they had a nice document that gave me a good structure to work off from, and so use that as kind of the skeleton to frame this resolution for the Council to consider this evening, and that's what we brought forward. I did, I received a call this afternoon from CMP's Jay Chase to ask about it and if and what the Council's direction was. I said, well, Council directed me to bring this forward, and so I provided him with a copy of the resolution so they have that now in hand. But if Council takes the action this evening, tomorrow morning when I get to the office, if not tonight before I leave, it'll be submitted to the MPUC as part of the public comment that's been provided, as the town with an intervener status has the ability to provide that info, so it is after their deadline. However, there's still the opportunity I think to provide that, so that'll be the next action if the Council decides to go forward with
[2:02:14] Councilor: this tonight go ahead andrew matt can you just remind us what the certificate of public convenience and necessity for the cmp greater portland transmission upgrades like opposing that what would that actually do that is that the pucs if they say yes to this then the project goes
[2:02:33] Town Manager: forward or anything? Yeah, in its current form, yeah. And you know, they look at that, they're the regulatory authority that would bless or deny the ability for them to expand to the complexity and the intensity of what they're looking to do. They're basing it off the entire grid and what they perceive that their needs are versus, but the PUC is looking that from, they're supposed to be, let's, I'll find a nicer way to describe it, they're they're the umpire in this, and they're going to look at that and say, is this really needed or is it not really needed? And they're, it's their job to take in all that public input as well as the technical data and the and CMP's argument in favor of, as well as contradictory information that they're provided by folks who have, you know, either their property has easements across it or they about it or they're impacted one way, one way or the other from this expansion and the intensity of what this is looking to be. So that's kind of why they're looking at that now trying to determine if that certificate of need is legitimate or not is
[2:03:43] Councilor: There any other questions or from of Matt from the council is there any comments from the council on this go ahead bill I would say I think that the key wording in here is the council opposes the issuance of a certificate of public convenience necessity for the transmission upgrades as submitted and urges the PUC to further examine the need and scale the proposed improvements, consider practical alternative solutions and routes. I think that's the key piece here is that I don't think CMP has done a great job of presenting what the alternatives are and I know that when we discuss with them in the workshop last November right I mean it was just a discussion but there were certainly discussion around ruse in the rail corridor go and do this and right so right there's other opportunities here I do also think that there are technical solutions I know there are technical solutions that can be applied that would ruse the right-of-way requirements etc or at least maintain them at the same level as where they are without expanding it so yeah so that's I think the wording is good thank you this is a public hearing is there anybody in the public wants to be heard on this see none I'll bring it back to the council any go ahead Lily so I'm glad we're doing this and we are a little late to the game but I'm glad we're doing it now instead of not at all and being an intervener in this case allows us to submit testimony and that is a special thing to be able to do because we are directly impacted portland and falmouth are also very strongly against this the important thing here is that the public utilities commission is reviewing this case based on forecasting and data models that cmp themselves have provided to the Public Utilities Commission and by law it does not require an independent third party verification or technical review the only resource you have to do that is experts in the community like for example Kay Aiken with the Alliance for responsible infrastructure which is basically the only group right now that is representing everyone that's affected by this it's always better to do this as a group they actually prefer that they prefer interveners to join up to make the proceedings easier. So this isn't like some fringe group. This is like the group of people who are impacted by this. They are working with towns and residents to try to get them involved in the process because the communication with CMP has been absolute garbage, and I've said this to them. There have been changes to their plans, amendments to supposedly the plans that were directly impacting people to the point where eminent domain could have been an issue. They tweaked their design, posted it into the docket back in August, didn't notify anyone affected by it at all. Not a phone call, not a letter, nothing except a boilerplate postcard about come to an open house to learn more about this project. Doesn't say how extreme it is or how it will impact people. And these models that CMP have used were based on old forecast data back from I believe 2022, and the models have not been rerun since. And since then the demand has actually decreased for CMP's products because of other things that have come out with, you know, like solar battery backups, other things that people are using instead of having to rely on CMP's energy. And again, remember that they profit off of this project. They have no incentive to lower the cost at all. The more expensive it is, the more they gain, more their shareholders gain. So it is up to like local experts and people who know things to be able to look at the data and the models that they're using to be able to fact-check them. And they have not been forthright with that data. They have not rerun the models, they have not released this data. Some people have been able to request, like I don't know if it's under an NDA or something, but basically you have access to this confidential data to be able to run your own forecasts and whatnot and see if the data holds up. But again, you're working with inaccurate data, so it's like garbage and garbage out. And essentially we're just being told to take our word for it, like we're good, we've we've done our homework on ourselves for a project that we want to go forward, it's fine. And we're not going to tell you about the impacts yet. After it's approved, then we'll get to the part where we get to do impact studies and deciding and looking at alternate methods. And of course once this thing is approved, that's it, like they have been given the go-ahead. Like what is the incentive to actually sit down with communities and individuals and find a better way? There is not one. So I think this is why it is so important that we're doing this and we're getting involved. And we have the CMP open house on the 12th, 6 to 8, and I encourage anyone who comes to talk to CMP, write down what is said, because nothing that is said in that workshop is going to make it into the public record. And you don't have to be an Intervener to make a public comment, you can go to the MPUC website to submit. It's like a really awful link that I can't even describe, it's just like garbage. But if you google MPUC CQM, it's their case management system, you can create an account and then you can look up the case, it's 2025-00276, and you can submit a public comment. And in that public comment, if you do go to the workshop, I recommend you write down who you talked to, when you spoke to them, what you asked, what they had said to you, and put it into the public record. I'm glad we're going to have a workshop on the council level so that it can be televised and therefore it is in the public record. And I recommend that after that we have essentially a transcript of what went on to that meeting and we submitted ourselves a testimony into the docket, because there's all this information going around, there's conflicting information. CNP will tell in private counselors, whistlers from somewhere one thing, and then you see something else go into the docket. What they responded to us tonight in their email showing the three alternative routes that they looked at doesn't include the alternative route that they themselves put into the docket in August showing that it would reroute away from affected people in Cumberland. They're still using an outdated image that shows either it's outdated, actually, or they've updated it to where they've gone back on what they were going to do, and so those people are still affected, including my neighbor across the street that's basically going through their house. So it's, there's conflicting information, there's a lack of information, they have not been transparent, the communication with the community has sucked. So like all of this I'm obviously very upset by this because this is like, it's just the wrong way to do it, and I'm glad we are calling it out and we're on the record. We're asking for questions, trying to get answers, and even still the answers they gave us via email tonight were insufficient and they're essentially the same answers given to Falmouth. So I'm hoping that they can clarify what I've asked them to clarify regarding the route that now looks like they've undone that thing and Cutler and residents will be even more affected, and they can revise their response and put that in the docket so it's in the public record. Anybody else from the council? Is there, I'll entertain a motion. Be happy to give you one. Item number 26-122 to consider an act on a town council resolution opposing the issuance of a certificate of public convenience and necessity for Central Main Power Great Greater Portland when transmission upgrades is submitted. Second. All those in favor. All right, new business TIG. Tomorrow Mr. Sturgis and I are taking a field trip to the Portland Water District for their annual meeting. Is that what it is, annual assessment update where we meet?
[2:12:33] Town Manager: with them annually to look at what they're looking at for infrastructure improvements for the sewer as well as our water system so we're there to advocate for some additional
[2:12:44] Councilor: information about what addressing some of the west cumberland water issues would be like if it is appropriate at some point maybe we could have a workshop to obviously matt and i can give a recap of what we find out tomorrow but if there's will at the council level maybe like we could have a workshop and kind of talk about options and seeing some nodding heads so i just wanted to throw that out there before i surprised everybody and because miss hanken is here tonight i wanted to throw a fun project idea out that whitney actually brought up a couple years ago so we've lost our beloved bulky item pickup week but now we have our bulky item drop off which we also love but i think when at one point you had gone to a conference right i can i don't know if you want to come up and talk about it but i can just regurgitate but if you want to come up and talk about it you can too would you 'll you'll you will articulate it much better than I will and sorry I didn't give you any heads up on this but you
[2:13:51] Speaker Q (unidentified): are here so opportunity strikes so yes I went to a conference a couple of years ago where a small town in the Midwest now I can't remember exactly where it was held a like community yard sale this is this is the project we're talking about right okay yeah called the community yard sale where essentially people would all kind of sign up and say that they were going to have a yard sale on this same day and the municipality made a map for people that they shared out so that people could get rid of I mean, you could, you don't have to sell things, you could also just give them away. But they made a map for people that they shared out to residents and everybody around so that people would know, you know, you could go to Main Street and you could go to the west side for this thing, and you'd have, you know, essentially just an idea for people to have a way to get rid of the things that they're holding on to without just dumping them, but also for people that want to hold a yard sale and make some money. And all we would do as a staff is make a map and then share that out for people so people could go in, we could make like a sign up, people could go in and sign up, and then we'd make the map, we'd put it out, and then whoever wanted to go could go to whichever spot they wanted to and help residents kind of get rid of those things. So that was the idea, and I think with
[2:15:16] Councilor: like the, because we don't have the pickers anymore, because we're, you know, so people aren't putting stuff right outside, so we've lost the pickers. So if we did something like this maybe a week or two before bulky item, people would know, and then the stuff that doesn't get taken or sold, then they could bring to bulky item, and that might also help with like one man's trash is another man's treasure, right? And so that's also going to help with all the ways, like maybe there'll be less waste at bulky item because someone, it's someone's new treasure anyway. So I, thought that might be a fun thing that we could think about. Yeah, she got kid, I mean, I can keep going, but I will not. I have a question. Can I ask a question about that? Me, you? Yeah, you first. So I was zoning out a little, sorry. Recovering from that freak out I had earlier. So is this like a virtual map? Like you drop a pin, someone's house, you click the pin, and all the list of stuff that they're going to have pops up? How does it work?
[2:16:19] Speaker Q (unidentified): I mean, that's how they did it, was kind of a virtual map. app. I do think there was a printed version probably available in their town hall. So as much or as little information as we want to do it, where we're talking about it so far in advance, it's probably something we'd want to start having people sign up for in the summertime so they're prepared for it in early fall, but we've got plenty of time to figure out how we would want to do that for us, and I can reach out and try to get an example of how it's worked for other municipalities, but I'm also Thinking our director of planning and sustainability just left, but I know she'd want to get involved where it's something to make our community a little more sustainable as well. So we could play with it however we want. We don't have to do it how other people have done it, but this is super
[2:17:02] Councilor: exciting. I think we should do this, like, as long as the weather holds, multiple times a year, Andrew. If we did go down this path, could we add one more thing to your plate, and that just advertising, you know, getting the word out and at all? Because, you know, individuals doing it through their own channels would be great, but also the town, you know, other towns would be aware and could potentially
[2:17:25] Speaker Q (unidentified): drive more interest and make it more successful. Oh yeah, I wouldn't have mentioned it unless I thought I would be the one doing it. So thank you. Thanks. What? Yeah, you're good too. Yeah, I just
[2:17:38] Councilor: with it the there was a big estate sale on main street a couple of months ago and it was wild and just really fun to see so many neighbors there so many people and it was a heartbreaking situation that family went through but it was my neighbor and i now have their beautiful sundial and it feels really nice it's something that i look at every day and i love it feels like a little piece of their neighborhood is now is still with us and so i think that those are like kind of small things but they're really nice, and I don't know, I just think it would kind of add to our community a little bit. So I would love to work with anyone who wants to work on it. Sounds like Brittany and, or sorry, Bridget and Whitney, I just combined their names, would be up for it. So nice to stay in the neighborhood, Bill. Just thinking on the two things, actually, and you'll probably hate me for bringing up one, but I'll bring up the easy one first, Mill Road. I'm curious if when we consider this, if you know an option could be just a single lane bridge, right, you know, that it's wide enough for bus and, you know, plow truck whatnot to get through. Maybe it's potential to reduce some cost. You know, Jeff and I are both sitting here on our computers thinking of solutions right that we've both seen in practice. So I do think there's opportunity to do something there that's probably not super high cost or at least limited cost. And I guess the other one is I know we've all been getting a lot of emails about the playground at Twin Brook. and just curious where we need to where we need to go on that what we need to do to answer concerns you know I hear folks concerns but I'm also the opinion that you know we've been at this for quite a few years and that you know we have playground equipment maybe there's some tweaks that can be made with landscaping or something like that but i think the i think the broader community is quite supportive of it and has been for years and there has been a process maybe it hasn't been the best process in the world, and things could be improved. You know what, I don't know, I just, it is what it is, here we are, and are we going to move forward with it or not? So not sure what the best way to go is here from a procedural piece or if we need to do anything, but be curious to hear what others think.
[2:20:25] Town Manager: Mr. Manager. Sure, I'd be happy to jump in, Mr. Chairman, if I may. Go ahead. You have, we are still looking at alternatives that we have in the park as far as, and we have a meeting on Thursday with a number of the, number of the email authors that the council has received to kind of follow up from a meeting that we had just two weeks ago as well, and we had already planned to meet this week with them to advance that. So we're looking at, you know, potential for other locations within the park that or that may, that may be more suitable, or so we'll look at all different options, from plantings, if it stayed where it was originally proposed, to do plantings around that to help, or to look at other locations within the park that might [Councilor: might be] more productive. So we've got, we're on it. We're trying to find a, I guess you could say, a negotiated space forward. Good, Bill?
[2:21:32] Councilor: Jeff? Sure. So start off with $20 for the food pantry. We'll start off with $20 for the food pantry. I'll get it right eventually. playground you know bill brought it up but i had a couple thoughts on that i did have a meeting with some residents over the weekend that expressed some concerns about the playground and i think you know part of the approval happened at a unfortunate time where we transitioned between two town managers and may have been some other stuff that happened where the communication could been left less than ideal not saying that's your fault matt it just happened to be in a transition period so i think That's unfortunate. Just, I think it's something that we should always keep in mind when we have some of these committees and stuff moving forward. Ultimately, we've already ordered this stuff, and you know, I understand the citizens' desire for a playground, and you know, I've been pretty much a lifelong resident here, and when you look at the aesthetics of what we purchased, I gotta be honest with you, to me it doesn't really fit the openness of Twin Brooks. It doesn't fit the royal characteristics of the community, be quite honest with you. I think it belongs down to Fun Town in Sawco, but we've bought it, we own it. I'm not going to spend thirty thousand dollars or twenty five thousand dollars to send it back and return it. We got to put it in the ground, but with that all being said, you know, I just wonder if there's another location in Twin Brooks that isn't exactly visible as soon as you pull in there, because the next thing is, do you put the Ferris wheel up next to it? You know, could we use some tree screening if we have to stay at that location? But honestly, I think over by the paved pathway in the maintenance building might be a more appropriate location. We'd probably have to clear some trees, but pretty familiar with Twin Brooks to help build it. I think just might be something we may want to explore. And that's my thoughts on the playground. Other than that, I just want to say thank you to all the veterans in the community for their service and what they've done for us over the years, and that's all I have for this evening. Yes, I guess thinking about Wednesday at Veterans Day, I've never taken the day off. You know, I've always thought, you know, I would be a slacker if I took Wednesdays off, took Veterans Day off, because in my own mind that, you know, You know, these are the people that served our country, and it would be wrong for me to take the day off, but I will honor them. And those of us who, you know, the three of us here, and all the ones that I do know, veterans, you know, most of us don't really think about it in that sort of sense. We did a period of time in our life where we did something for our country, and then we put it behind us. We put our civilian clothes on, and we moved on, and I don't think of it much very often. Occasionally, I do, and just the other day, I was thinking about some of my experiences. And they were, you know, in a hot engine room, you know, wiping down a boiler, welding on a steam pipe or something like that. But it's a part of who we were. Sometimes it's, for a couple of guys I know, it was a defining moment in their lives. Most of us don't view it like that. It was a time in our lives, but for some, it was a defining moment in their lives. And so, certainly, we want to honor them. On a completely different note, I know that there was an email sent out by GPCOG asking us to fill out a survey from what we experienced and questions that we wanted answered regarding consolidation of services and better ability to save money in the long run. So I hope everybody filled that out, and that's all I have. Thank you, Bob. Andrew? This is the last time you'll hear me ramble on about this, but on Thursday at 6.30 at Valhalla, the LCC will be hosting its landowner open house. Last year it was a smashing success and I think we're expecting nothing less this year. There's going to be a host of organizations there to help with questions about managing forests, managing grasslands, invasives, all sorts of fun stuff, and really informative for that. And I would just like to thank the voters, you know, 85, I'd heard 78 was amazing but 85 is beyond. Saw somewhere online that the state of Maine was 60 something percent and surpassed the last midterms which was a record, and it's just really nice to see whoever, anybody voted for, that people are getting out and making their voices heard, and just want to echo your comments about thanking the staff for the early voting, the day of, and thanking the volunteers that made that all possible. We're number one in the country, really, Maine had the highest turnout in any state. 66 percent. Yeah, Lily, amazing. Even all those people are still smaller than my hometown from San Diego. I'm just kidding, at least the county. But I like the percentage, that's nice, that's nice. Is this the first meeting we've had since Halloween? Isn't it? Yes. I just wanted to say, like, I'm one of those people that drives to the center for my fun because there's nothing going on my street. It's dark and weird and there's like one person that comes to our house, so I went and hung out in the center on Pinewood Drive and I ran it to take I was just as a banana and it was fun time that's all I have to say. Everyone was careful driving down the street was a little bit busy there were like people everywhere in the streets it was crazy but it was fun time and nothing crazy happened from what I saw so maybe it was later in the night but great job everyone and then yeah what you're saying about Veterans Day I get that Bob like how for some it's like their whole lives like I'm a veteran this is like my identity and then some you just kind of do your time and go that's kind of like the latter is what my situation is like I had a desk job like I was an Intel analyst I'm not like nothing ultra exciting when you think of the military especially in the Air Force most people do not fly planes but they always ask you but yeah like it's not really something I reflect on a lot because it there was a lot of negatives about it and it like destroyed half of my body but it's gave me at least the knowledge that I'm really good at analyzing things and researching things and writing reports and stuff and I've kind of brought that over here sometimes so it's been beneficial so it has its ups and downs but it's experience I appreciate for sure so that's cool thanks veterans and whatever way shape or form your service took. Playground wise I pulled up all these big packets that were given to us when we went over this the last couple meetings ago I don't remember when it was but this has been brought up a couple times and it's I think the location was chosen because it kind of like straddles the soccer fields and I think it's like when you have the soccer games and the community soccer it's like you have all these kids running around not playing soccer and they're there to watch games but if you stick it over by the barn there's a place in between so the people who are there for the games but also have kids they've got somewhere to put them and it's kind of like keeping them busy which I don't know if that's necessarily a good enough reason to put it someplace it's just for soccer games so yeah I don't know what you'll come up with as far as positioning goes and then screening for sure and shade like I know there's shade sales in this design but just you can obscure a lot of ugly plastic with thoughtful plantings and landscaping and it might take a while to grow might be worth splurging for a couple big screening objects while you wait for the rest to grow but I'm kind Of with the others, as far as I know. I think we're on the same page as far as, like, we bought this thing, we have the thing, now it's just making the thing the best it can be with what we have. So I appreciate all the work you've done reaching out multiple times to people who have concerns. I mean, valid concerns. And it just feels like one of those things where it's something gears in the making, but there are lulls and periods of silence where there's not a whole lot of messaging to the community of like, hey, this is a thing, there's a committee that's like charged to researching this thing and coming up with an idea, and the council's approved it and looked at it. So it's, it again reminds me of Cape. How every week Cape puts out like a little summary of council decisions, like how they voted on stuff, what came out. I don't know if something like that would be more helpful, just getting stuff on people's radar more. I know we have the Cumberland Crier, and I don't know if it's worth putting in just a few bullet points every week of kind of like what the decision, what the decisions were, and then maybe like next time what will be discussed, or a month from now we're gonna be voting on some big thing we've been working on for multiple years. Like, here are some resources, like go research it and give your public feedback, not like the day of the decision, but like along the way. So, and I know people are busy, it's difficult to get people involved, and you only find the information if you're looking for it, and that's kind of the hard part with this kind of thing. But again, I appreciate all the work you've done on this map. Just, I've got two real quick things and we'll call it. Congratulations to the girls volleyball team, state champs. And last but not least, I want to thank Shirley Story King and the whole crew that collected signatures for the school issue, the funding. A lot of hard work, a lot of time away from home, and thank you for doing well by our community. That's all I have. Thank you to the veterans, and I'll entertain a motion. Anything else, Matt? You're good? Yes, sir. Good. Motion to adjourn. Motion to adjourn is there a second? All favor. Good night, folks, and thank you. Good night.