Harpswell Planning Board approves wharf expansion, continues disputed relocation
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] It's with Dan. Yep. Okay.
[0:03] All right.
[0:03] All right.
[0:04] Welcome everyone to the meeting of the Harpswell Planning Board October 21, 2026 meeting. I'm going to call the order to meeting to order. I'm Dan Holbek, chair of the board. Please join me rising for the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:23] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:39] All righty. We have a number of matters on the agenda. We have one matter of old business and four matters of new business that are going to be before the board tonight. before doing that, we have to declare a quorum.
[1:00] We have Lori and Jim who are regular board members who are coming in by way of Zoom. Courtney, who's a the vice chair, is here. I'm here. And we would like to welcome Allison. our brand new member.
[1:21] She is an associate member, but because we we have a five We need four for a quorum. Five members can vote. And when a regular member isn't here, the alternate becomes a voting member. So, tonight you are a voting member. To the extent that the since this is your first meeting, to the extent you feel comfortable voting, fine.
[1:43] by all means, just feel free to ask questions or anything like that as well. So.
[1:49] Thank you.
[1:49] Okay. And also, our town planner, Margaret McIntyre, is here. Okay. we have We would typically start with old business, but we have one matter of new business where there are two attorneys here. And so as to not to take up any more of their time, we are going to first consider
[2:12] item 26-10-04.
[2:16] Karen and Dennis Rue, owners, Durigo Custom Constructor Structures, applicant. Jay Scofield, representative. This is map 50, lot 94, 181 Indian Road. Consideration of the board's exercising jurisdiction to review of an application to reconstruct a non-conforming
[2:38] structure. Margaret, would you give us a little
[2:44] background on that?
[2:46] yes, this is a project on Indian Rest Road. the property abuts Indian Rest and a paper road known as Abenaki Road. we actually reviewed a project two houses to the east a couple months ago, maybe last month, I can't remember. and I do have some site visit notes to read to you.
[3:07] present at the site visit, which occurred on October 13th, was Karen and Dennis, the owners, their builder, plus their builder and their excavator, abutters Mark and Douglas, town staff Margaret, Tony, and Tim, planning board Courtney Snellings.
[3:28] We observed the dwelling, which is non-conforming to Indian Rest Road at the top of the lot. The lot slopes steeply towards the water. The applicant showed the proposed site for relocation of the structure towards the downhill north end of the lot. The septic will be replaced in the new location of the septic was shown, which will be at the downhill north end of the lot.
[3:50] The lot is covered with grass and low lying vegetation and will not require the removal of any trees or shrubs to accomplish the relocation. It was really rainy that day.
[4:01] Okay.
[4:02] Really wet.
[4:03] Okay, thank you. there are a number There always a number of issues anytime that we're talking about rec
[4:14] reconstructing or re or moving a non-conforming structure. Here we have a particular legal issue which is one that talks about the proximity to a paper road. in this case we have a road that was described as a paper road back in 1900.
[4:36] it has never been built. but the question for SEPA purposes is whether the structure must be set back from the inside of the paper road or from the center line. And that is where the issue among the lawyers has been going back and forth. We had [4:58] materials the last which of I received about an hour and a half ago. so what I since the lawyers are present, I do want to give them an opportunity to speak and then we can determine based on that whether we want to actually hear the thing or to have time for us to do the kind of review that we typically do when we have more than an hour and a half to do so.
[5:24] So, may I hear the attorney from the petitioner first?
[5:35] Good evening, chair and members of the board. May it please the board? I'm going to speak only to the issue of Abenaki Road right now.
[5:41] Could you identify yourself by name, please?
[5:44] Gerald Scobie. I'm here for the applicants, the Rios.
[5:46] Thank you.
[5:47] Pardon me. Thank you for clarifying that for me. I'm going to speak only to the issue of Abenaki Road right now, and the position is as set forth in our initial application,
[5:58] and my letter that supported that application submitted by Dirigo Structures dated September 30th, 2026. And in all due respect, there hasn't been a whole lot between the attorneys because I only got anything related to Abenaki Road from the abutters today, and then something again about 45 minutes ago. the issue with Abenaki Road was already before this board when the K Hills submitted their application.
[6:23] My understanding, and it's upon my information and belief, so I don't want to state it as a full certainty, is that legal counsel for the town addressed that issue and determined that the property owners owned the road to the center line of Abenaki Road, and therefore it could be used for setback purposes. My also understanding is that the K Hills submitted their application for the board, and just like in this procedure, any abutter would have been given due notice of that.
[6:50] Those abutters within that area would have been both the McCoys and the Chisholms who are represented by counsel here tonight. they didn't object then in the K Hills application move forward and was approved by the board without objection related to anything with Abenaki Road. Now, because it's the Rios, there is an attempt at some selective enforcement of something that this board has already determined, and I don't think it's appropriate.
[7:15] so, my position on behalf of the applicants would simply be that the board's already determined that issue, and it can rest on its prior findings and its prior advice from its legal counsel because the issue is the same, and to the extent that the appellants or excuse me, the abutters wanted to brief that, they could have done so back in July or before, and they certainly could have done so before today by paying.
[7:41] So, thank you very much. If you want other things for now, I'll address that, but I'm just addressing Abenaki Road for the purposes of this.
[7:50] Thank you, counselor. yeah, I know here from the attorney from the for the abutters.
[8:04] Hi. thank you for hearing us first. You didn't have to do that. I'm Kristen Collins. I represent the Chisholms and the McCoys, the abutters on either side of this project. this has been a somewhat quick turnaround. We've been kind of calling the planning office, sorry, for weeks and weeks to make sure that we knew when this application was actually filed, but we did only get it in hand probably 10 days ago.
[8:27] and in order to even write the letter that you had today, I had to run deeds back to 1900 for the association and for this property and do a fair amount of legal research to understand this issue. and that's just how this goes sometimes when you get a limited amount of time. so, you have a letter in front of you in which I raised two, I think, very interesting but deep legal issues.
[8:54] I understand from Margaret that as to this issue of the paper street, the town attorney has not opined. the planning board, I understand, granted an application kind of on this theory, but that has no binding effect on this application. You've got different arguments being made by different parties. and I think that you need a legal opinion from the town attorney on this given everything.
[9:19] my issue with it is first off, I don't think it's as clear-cut as the applicant is making it sound that they own to the center line of that road. We have an association here that has held title to that road and to the common area next to it since 1900. I gave you the deeds that show that. They actively manage those areas as an association.
[9:43] And in effect, what the applicant seeks to do is to take property that the association assumes is its own. So, I would think you would want to hear from the association on that matter. I don't know if they were involved in the prior application. But more simplistically, and I think this is the question primarily for the town attorney, is I'm sure you've had banged into your head in multiple trainings,
[10:05] that when it comes to right, title, and interest, you only look at the four corners of the deed that's in front of you, and it's not your job to be a judge and to resolve title issues. And you have a deed in front of you that says these applicants own lot 23 as shown on that 1900 plan. When you look at the 1900 plan, it very clearly shows lot 23
[10:29] as abutting and not including any portion of that Abnaki Road. So, I think you're stuck with the deed that's in front of you. and right before I left to come here, I actually found a case that came out of the town of Harpswell. I'll pass it out, but in that case, the town had an applicant,
[10:52] not in this development, but in a different one, where they were relying on the same theory that they owned the center line of a paper street. And what the board said is you can't do any work until you revise the deed or you show us a deed that actually shows us that you own that area. We're not going to rely on your statement
[11:12] that you own that area. So, the court upheld that determination. And, a violation when the a butter, I mean, when the, applicant didn't do as told. So.
[11:28] So, that's question one. You have a deed that doesn't show that they own this area. They've given a legal theory, but it is not a legal determination from a judge. They've not gone out and reformed their deed to include this area. legal issue number two, which I think almost conveniently eliminates the need to consider
[11:50] legal issue number one, is and I hope you got my revised letter, which includes more discussion of this.
[12:01] The home as it sits today, the existing home, is legally non-conforming, but it's legally non-conforming under the basic land use ordinance, which has a setback of 20 ft on the sides. What they are seeking to do is to demolish that structure and to build a new one,
[12:22] which also will not comply with sideline setbacks, but those are different sideline setbacks under the shoreline zoning ordinance. So, what to the extent they're grandfathered, they're grandfathered under the basic land use ordinance and violating those setbacks. What they are seeking to do is to create a new structure, which has new violations of a different ordinance.
[12:47] I think that's really important, cuz when it comes to shoreline zoning, we do not allow new non-conformities. And I think this is. It'd be one thing if the building were already in the shoreline zone, and they were looking to rebuild and relocate it within that zone, but you've got nothing there now, nothing violating those shoreline setbacks.
[13:09] So, now we're going to put something there that violates those setbacks and wasn't already there. So, I think that is different than the usual equation and something that probably you could benefit from legal counsel on, apart from my own. so, that would be my suggestion.
[13:31] don't take either of our word for it on either of these issues. This is the first you're hearing this project. It's not a meaningful delay to just put the pause on it. Get an opinion on these issues and come back the next time. Thank you. And I do have some other Actually, I have some questions on the application.
[13:52] but, it sounds like for now you kind of wanted to decide whether you want to proceed. So, I can hold on those or up to you.
[14:01] Yeah.
[14:04] Okay. having received your analysis today and then finding out that what you had submitted first had to be revised, so we got a revised letter from you. And then now you're giving us another new case. You know, I had enough trouble going through Driscoll and Fournier as it was.
[14:26] and reviewing its application to the Paper Streets Act without that. I would suggest to the to the board that this be continued until our next meeting. and have
[14:47] all legal arguments prepared for us 2 weeks before that following meeting. Yes.
[14:58] Can you before you continue it, can you take jurisdiction of it, please?
[15:04] Yeah.
[15:04] Thank you. Cuz technically, you have 40 days to make a determination on the on the conformity of the relocation. So, take jurisdiction and then that stops that clock.
[15:17] Okay.
[15:17] Thanks.
[15:18] [15:18] And that's on if you want to do it, 's there In the draft motions.
[15:23] Okay.
[15:23] Okay.
[15:24] [15:27] Or did Do Would you like to read it? I
[15:29] I would love to read it.
[15:30] pull that one up here.
[15:31] I move that the planning board exercises its jurisdiction as outlined in section 10.3.2.4 of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance and 10.3.2.3 of the Basic Land Use Ordinance for the review of the application of Dennis and Karen Reuse conformance with the standards of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance and Basic Land Use Ordinance to reconstruct a non-conforming structure on lot 94 of map 50.
[15:58] Okay. I will make that as the motion. Is there support for that motion?
[16:03] Second.
[16:04] Seconded by Courtney. Okay, then I'm going to ask for because we are on Zoom, I have to get a verbal yay or nay on that. So, Jim.
[16:19] You're muted.
[16:22] Jim Babarsky, I.
[16:24] Lori.
[16:25] Lori Falcone, I.
[16:28] Courtney.
[16:29] Courtney Schnelling's, I.
[16:32] Yes.
[16:33] Okay, state your name first.
[16:35] Allison Hawks.
[16:35] Just because it we're on Zoom, that's why we have
[16:38] And Dan Holback, I. That motion succeeds five to nothing, which means that we will be taking jurisdiction. the issues that both counsel have raised I would expect that both of both parties would address those. in addition to that unless I am looking at the paperwork
[17:04] incorrectly, it looks like the proposed building is no closer to the paper road than it's to abutting neighbors. And so, if there's if that is something that wishes to be addressed, we can also talk about that. [17:21] I don't know what you mean. Can you say that again, please?
[17:26] The homes that are built on both sides
[17:28] Yep.
[17:29] have a distance from the paper road.
[17:32] Right.
[17:33] The new one will be no closer than the two that are already existing.
[17:39] I think the difference is that those are existing legally non-conforming houses.
[17:44] Okay.
[17:44] Right.
[17:46] But
[17:46] Just like Just like the reuse is at the other end of the lot.
[17:50] Yeah. but there are So, you know, we've we've got a number of issues. Also, I don't see anything that says that the paper road was ever accepted by the town. If you have something on that, I'd like to see that as well. but I would like to see the res- [18:12] the arguments of counsel 2 weeks before our next meeting. If you get them to Margaret, I can take a look at them and then refer them to town council if required and take it to the MMA, the Maine Municipal Association, also if required. If that sounds
[18:33] appropriate, I'm I'm kind of taking a the bull the bull by the horns here. But if that's acceptable, I would actually I would entertain a motion to continue this matter until our November meeting.
[18:50] I move that we continue this matter to the November meeting.
[18:54] Okay.
[18:55] Yes.
[18:56] Second.
[18:57] Seconded. Okay. Jim?
[18:59] Jim Babarsky, I
[19:01] Lori.
[19:02] Lori Falcone, I one question I have is that is 2 weeks going to be long enough for the town council if we need the town council
[19:14] Mhm. to weigh in. Cuz it seems to me of course I'm not an attorney. It seems very complex to me quite frankly. Now I'm sure for any attorney it's like yeah. But I'm just wondering we don't know what the town attorney's schedule is.
[19:32] Yeah, but if we get that if we get the materials we can al- always take what we have and present that to the attorney beforehand as well. But I just want to make sure that both parties have an opportunity to address the issues that the other ones have raised. Okay, based on that we're continuing our vote.
[19:52] Yep. So I Do you want me to second it now or just say
[19:57] voting on it. So
[19:58] Oh yes.
[19:59] Who seconded it? Courtney moved.
[20:01] Yes.
[20:01] Who seconded?
[20:02] No, you did. No.
[20:03] Thank you.
[20:03] Allison did.
[20:04] Okay.
[20:04] Sorry. Courtney Snelling's aye.
[20:07] Dan Houlihan's aye.
[20:08] Allison Hawks' aye.
[20:12] Okay. So this meet- this matter will be heard then at our November meeting. I apologize to any of others who came here thinking that we were going to get to the merits of this. but you know, this is one of those cases that we run into from time to time where we just don't have the material in sufficient time to make an appropriate decision.
[20:36] Right.
[20:37] So we will hear this matter then at our November meeting and I look forward to the briefs from council.
[20:45] That's November 18th.
[20:46] November 18th at 6:30.
[20:51] All right.
[20:53] Okay, thank you. All right. The next item on the agenda is a matter of old business and that is
[21:05] I just lost it here.
[21:15] Gunpoint.
[21:16] Yeah, I'm just pulling it up. That is item 26-09-04,
[21:22] the Point LLC owner, Flycatcher LLC applicant, map 37 lot 31 368 Gunpoint Road. This is a greatest practical extent review and consideration for the application to tear down and reconstruct a non-conforming structure.
[21:42] this matter is a continuation of a we had a public hearing on this matter once before. since then there was also a a second site visit. So, perhaps let's start with the what we had from the second site visit.
[22:04] I can I can
[22:05] You got it?
[22:05] Yeah, I'm sure, why not?
[22:07] Okay, so reconstruction of a non-conforming dwelling. in addition to the people that we that were mentioned before who attended, the codes officers and the planner and me. [22:26] Oh, wait, I'm looking at the wrong one. let me see. So, Tim Forrester, Kelly Waddle, Debbie Forrester, [22:38] No relation.
[22:39] No relation, I know. I almost said that. To well, the codes officers and Margaret, so those were the additions. the septic needs to be rebuilt due to tree root intrusion. This was discovered. And a plan will be supplied. New septic field will be 20% larger than the one.
[23:01] Most of the new construction is within the 75-ft setback. Flycatcher noted that the square footage is no more than is currently within the setback, but it is further back from the shore, about 56-ft back. Many trees will need to be removed to build the new structure.
[23:23] That's it.
[23:25] All right.
[23:29] Hi, good evening. I'm Tim Forrester with Flycatcher here on behalf of the applicant. I think I concur with the conclusions from our site visit. I think it might have been a little cold and wet out there that day as well. so, the property owner, Jack Dostie, is also available online. Jack, if there's anything you want to say, you should just raise your hand.
[23:53] hopefully, you can do that, and then we they they should have allow you to speak. but, to summarize the project, he has an They have an existing cottage that sits right on the ledge, right on the shore. It's 12 and 1/2 ft from the highest astronomical tide. and they'd like to relocate that structure.
[24:14] so, we looked at other places on the property and determined that, in the applicant's opinion, the least practical to the greatest practical extent, sorry, was to move it to the other side of the septic field. and in doing so, there are actually 12 trees that would need to be removed.
[24:39] there's plenty of opportunity to replant more trees within the property. Correct that the septic system had one of the one of the issues about the trees is that the roots are growing into the septic field. so, Brady Frick was out and redesigned a new plan, new septic field, new tank.
[25:00] And that would be larger and more accommodating than the existing one. I think it was 240 or 260 gallons per day. what's the number that he they calculated? a little bit about the existing structure and deck totals 1,135
[25:21] square feet, all of which is non-conforming. The proposed new deck and new structure would only have 706 feet within the 75-foot setback. So, it is less non-conforming than the existing structure. [25:41] One of the things that I tried to point out while on-site and also within the plans, which is some of the constraints within the property. There's a lot of ledge. There's there's a low-lying area that's all below the FEMA flood elevation. so, we were trying to keep the building up out of that area.
[26:04] there's existing structures, existing road setbacks. the general shape of the land and when you apply the 75-foot setback from the highest astronomical tide, when you apply that, you know, on an arc in a cove area, it tends to, you know, really eat up a ton of property. So, there is a small sort of bubbled out area, which we did try to capitalize on to keep as much of the structure outside of 75 feet as practical.
[26:33] So, I think that's the quick summary of it, and I'm happy to answer any questions.
[26:41] I have a couple questions.
[26:42] Yep.
[26:43] First of all, the design that we got from your office for the septic, this is not my fight to fight, but it is for 180 gallons per day.
[26:52] It would be a That's the old
[26:55] This one dated 10/8/26, 180 gallons per day. So, just so you know.
[27:03] No.
[27:07] Jack, the new one was for I thought I thought there was a number of 240 or 250 gallons per day.
[27:14] 260 gallons a day.
[27:16] Yeah.
[27:18] That's just a
[27:19] I guess I'm not sure why it's there. [27:20] Okay. That's just what we got from the office. Okay.
[27:23] Sounds like something we can work on.
[27:24] the other question I have is what Do you know the square footage of the proposed house? You said it was going to be in the setback, but what's the square footage of the whole thing?
[27:37] I put it down here. I only calculated the area within the setback, not the dimensional area of the cottage itself.
[27:44] All right.
[27:45] so, but the point we were trying to make was that any expansion
[27:52] is going outside of the 75-ft setback, we're still below the original size of the house within the setback.
[28:01] This just gets to an argument that I like to get into with the planning board, which is when you look at the relocation of a structure, you relocate the structure and then look for areas to expand, not expand and then relocate. And it's a distinction that we get into about. So, just something to consider.
[28:24] Okay.
[28:28] You were You came to the site the first time.
[28:30] I came to the site the first time. I was not there at the second one where we looked at where you looked at
[28:36] site.
[28:37] Okay.
[28:37] Just wetter.
[28:38] Yeah, I and just to elaborate on that, there was just it was incorrectly originally staked out. so, we restaked out the lot for the second site visit.
[28:49] Yes.
[28:50] And they also staked out the 75-ft setback, which was helpful.
[28:53] Yep.
[28:54] Okay.
[28:56] All right. I note from your from the recommendation from the, planner
[29:09] is that the recommendation
[29:12] [29:17] is that, the proposal does not meet the setbacks to the greatest practical extent. Would you, elaborate on that?
[29:28] Yes. I feel like the relocation is well thought out. Obviously, they you know, it's a good spot that they have chosen, but I don't think that they have met the burden of proof that it can't be put somewhere else on the site. They do have over 2 acres. I know a lot of it's in the flood zone, a lot of it's in the setback, but not all of it's in the flood zone and not all of it's in the setback.
[29:54] So, I think that there we lack this justification of why it can't be relocated within the setbacks.
[30:07] Yeah, I would have liked to have seen a building on I know you referred to that. I would have liked to have seen a possible building envelope. We didn't walk the entire property.
[30:16] Yeah, and I'm just looking at it from the site plan, which is flat.
[30:19] Right.
[30:21] Yep. So, we had the site visit and I guess I thought that was the intent of the site visit was to cover that. And if we didn't cover enough of the property, then I apologize. I did try to elaborate on the site plan by showing the setbacks, the flood zone, and everything else, then all of those constraints, I did read
[30:42] Margaret's recommendation and then just try to figure out, you know, all right, where's where was she coming from here cuz I didn't have a chance to address it with her prior.
[30:51] Okay.
[30:52] and I think perhaps what it was cuz when we stood on site, we looked up the old road and the question was asked, you know, why can't you do something over there? and in that area, you can see the 75-ft setback comes all the way up over the road and then on the other side of it is a complete drop-off down into that lower valley area of the flood zone within the upland part of the property.
[31:19] So, it's just not it's not anything you could build upon. and then the other really limiting factors here are you know, the proximity to existing utilities. You know, there 's a well, there's a septic. any other location within the property is really it's just ledge that you can't get power, water, and you can't get a septic up in there.
[31:44] So, that's those are the reasons why those areas were excluded. and we do feel that, you know, he's done a good job to meet the intent of the ordinance to the greatest practical extent given the limitations within the property and the existing infrastructure.
[32:06] I would just add that we are not obligated to take the flood zone into account when we look at greatest practical extent. It's not one of the one of the factors. I think it's logical to include it, but it's not one of the list one of our list of factors.
[32:24] But we can certainly when we're when we are addressing greatest possible extent, we can certainly even though it's not required, we can certainly consider that.
[32:35] Thank you.
[32:36] Consider not building in it, is that what you
[32:38] Exactly.
[32:39] It's just it's hard when you have 2 and 1/2 acres. It's hard to see that there can't be another building envelope that would actually meet what we need.
[32:52] Unless you live in Harpswell.
[32:55] Thank you.
[32:55] that's that's what we tried to tried to demonstrate with the plan and by you know, pointing it out. I did try to mark up on here, you know, I just made a dummy version of it in a pencil sketch, but you know, this area here is the these are all the setbacks that apply within the property and then the flood zone eats up at least half of that.
[33:19] In my opinion it would be silly to build a house in the flood zone when you know that we're only going to have increased sea level rise and in those past storms water blew up past the pool and all the way out through that whole area. so it just doesn't seem like a doesn't sound like a very practical idea.
[33:40] and then the only other area of land within the property is this section of it's forested land and it's all exposed ledge and it sits up high and it drops off into the valley below. So you know, if you were to put a house on there, I don't even know how you'd do it. you'd have to blow the whole thing up and build and then you still wouldn't have water, sewer, or power.
[34:07] So
[34:09] Okay. Jim or Lori, do you have any comments on that?
[34:16] I do not.
[34:19] No. No, I mean I'm I'm looking at the site plan and I can I can see what he's talking about. There's not a whole lot on this that's available to build on. I wasn't at the sidewalk, but building on ledge obviously would be a monetary issue.
[34:39] I'm trying to get utilities to it, so for me it makes the most sense where they're trying to put it. Yeah, I don't know how the other board members feel about it.
[34:51] I would agree.
[34:55] Okay, I see Jack, you did you
[35:00] did you want to make a comment? I saw that you weren't muted right now.
[35:05] I'm just taking it all in. Thank you very much for your time.
[35:09] Okay, thank you.
[35:10] Can I ask a question?
[35:11] Yeah, sure Allison.
[35:13] So I'm just looking at the non-conformance part of the ordinance. I'm just curious as to where this wouldn't why this wouldn't be allowed. So it I mean it to me when I'm reading this it says that you can add to a non-conforming, right? And that's okay. As long as it doesn't make it non more non-conforming.
[35:37] Yes, you can add 30% to a non-conforming structure, but let me read you the relocation standards. Hold on just a second.
[35:57] if the reconstructed or replacement structure is less than the required setback, it shall not be any larger than the original structure except as allowed pursuant to section 10.3.1 above as determined by the non-conforming footprint of the reconstructed or replaced structure at its new location.
[36:17] So you take the original footprint, you relocate it, and then you look for areas you can do your 30% expansion without making the structure more non-conforming.
[36:27] But they don't want to relocate it, right?
[36:30] They do. They just don't want to move it. But here's the part that I think we're really getting at. if the total footprint of the original structure can be relocated or reconstruction reconstructed beyond the required setback area, no portion of the relocated or reconstructed structure shall be replaced or constructed at less than the requirements
[36:52] setback requirement for a new structure.
[36:55] That was hard to read.
[36:56] Yeah, cuz it's coordinates is pretty
[36:58] Right. And it is a challenge because
[37:01] That's why I said I don't think that we met this burden of proof of saying there's nowhere else possible in the 2.5 acres to take this original footprint, the 7 1,100 square feet, and put it somewhere else.
[37:14] Okay, but at the time that we the at the time of the original site plan visit of the site visit, and I assume at the second one, did anyone from the from the board or you take a look at other areas to say, "Hey, this is an area that might be more
[37:35] more compliant or yeah."
[37:40] I
[37:40] Yeah, we kind of looked we looked up the road.
[37:43] I think it was according I think you would you would have I think you know you looked up the
[37:48] I looked up the
[37:49] path, if you will, and I responded to you that the 75-ft setback crosses over that
[37:54] And there were trees
[37:55] that's where the ledge drops off on the other side.
[37:57] So when we were talking to you after the first meeting and said you take a look at where these setbacks are and see what you can do to move it, we were just looking at that one area. Is that right?
[38:09] in the original meeting, yes.
[38:11] Yeah. Okay.
[38:12] Well, also I think the survey was incorrect the first time around, right? Because the first plan that was shown did have s- a s- much smaller part that was still non-conforming, but the bulk of the structure
[38:28] I
[38:29] it was pretty good, but now it's
[38:31] I have to be honest, I don't remember what the snafu was. I think it was surveyed correctly and potentially not laid out accurately by the property owner and then when I when I pulled measurements, I'm like, "This isn't adding up." So, that's when we realized the issue and we reinstated it with the surveyor.
[38:51] Right, but it doesn't look as good to us the second time around as it did when there was a you know, the snafu.
[39:00] [39:01] Yeah, thank you.
[39:01] But it did go from 14 ft to 54 ft.
[39:05] Right.
[39:05] Right.
[39:06] And
[39:08] I think there is a section in the ordinance, too, that does talk about, you know, some of the other factors there. you know, in determining whether a building relocation meets a setback to the So, it I in my issue was that the definition of greatest practical extent and what the planner was just reading
[39:30] was under the relocation replacement section, which only says greatest practical extent and then it doesn't provide any context of how you was determine that. But in prior section in the ordinance, it does. Says, you know, in determining greatest practical extent, that's when you can take those other items into consideration. So, well, septic, utilities,
[39:51] setbacks, whatever, what have you. So, that 's why the those are the criteria that we were using in trying to establish where it should be.
[40:02] Okay, before we go any further, is there anyone in the audience who would care to comment or on this application? Always want to make sure that I don't forget that. That's kind of an important component of all of Okay. Hearing none, what is what's the pleasure of the board?
[40:26] Yeah, it's a tough one.
[40:33] Anyone?
[40:35] What?
[40:39] Lori?
[40:42] Jim?
[40:45] Where's Jim?
[40:46] I'm
[40:46] Oh, there he is.
[40:47] Okay, I'm not
[40:47] Can you hear me?
[40:49] Okay, I'm not hearing any. [40:52] Can you hear me?
[40:53] Yeah.
[40:54] Yeah.
[40:54] Okay, great.
[40:59] Yeah, I mean, I would say it's a tough one. I think the keyword, practical extent, you know, practical is very important here. You know, if there's a bunch of trees on that one flat area, and you know, I think the spot that they chose is the best practical spot, and it sounds like from the site walk, it would be tough to find another spot for it on that property, despite it being 2 acres.
[41:24] So.
[41:26] I would agree.
[41:27] feelings.
[41:28] Yeah.
[41:30] Okay. hearing that, [41:38] I would move that the planning board finds that the proposal for the construction of a non-conforming dwelling on map 37, lot 31, meets the setbacks to the greatest practical extent based on the findings that the
[41:59] proposed new dwelling
[42:05] is situated in a in a position
[42:09] that will greatly decrease the non-conformity
[42:16] and be located in an area that is
[42:22] consistent with its proposed use.
[42:28] Glad that's you and not me.
[42:30] Is there support for that motion?
[42:32] I would second that.
[42:35] Was that Jim?
[42:36] It was me.
[42:36] Yeah, Jim Jaborski. I would second that. But I'll second it.
[42:41] So is there any discussion? Yes.
[42:43] Yes.
[42:44] I actually have a question for Margaret.
[42:50] Where did you see another building envelope? Because this seems to be and I think this is a good sticking point. But I would be interested to know did you see a building envelope, another one that do you have something in mind that would work
[43:07] There is an area
[43:10] here
[43:13] in the northeast corner I guess of the lot that meets the setbacks and isn't in the flood zone and doesn't look super steep. And to Jim's point, which is not what you asked, they have to cut down all the trees in the area to accomplish the relocation, all the trees in that area of the setback.
[43:33] And it's still going to be built in the flood zone. So to use that building in the flood zone as an excuse or not as an excuse, as an argument that Sorry. The I'm trying to process what Tim's saying. The relocation is still going to be in the flood zone. So it will be less in the flood zone than the existing one. But it's still over that 14-ft flood zone line.
[43:57] So wait, you're talking about a new possible building envelope that would be in the flood zone. Oh.
[44:04] No.
[44:06] Right. So if I can approach I can show you what I mean.
[44:10] I need all the help I can get. Thank you.
[44:12] sure Margaret, that's the area that you were kind of questioning.
[44:15] Yeah.
[44:16] So, it's it's this area right here.
[44:19] Okay, and it's not that I'm saying that it's buildable.
[44:22] Here's the town road and then this is their driveway coming into
[44:25] Right. Right. Right. Right.
[44:28] They This is an easement area and a 25-ft setback. And then the 75-ft coming this way. And when you get here, you drop off into this valley in both directions. So, my point about this, I'll just go back to the line.
[44:45] Okay, well, show them. Yeah, please show them, too.
[44:47] So, that's that's the area that it's on the full-size plan. So, you're looking at a zoomed-in portion over here.
[44:55] Right.
[44:56] This is the whole 2-acre parcel. And this is the area that Margaret was asking more information about.
[45:02] So, it's the red one with the question marks.
[45:05] Yeah.
[45:05] Mhm.
[45:06] And I to clarify, I'm not saying that it's buildable. I'm saying that they haven't proven that it's not.
[45:12] It's a burden of proof question.
[45:14] Yeah, and
[45:15] Okay, how would that be done, if I may ask?
[45:20] Just saying.
[45:21] that was the part that I would try to elaborate on this evening that there are no utilities over there. it is all ledge and it's not like it's easily workable ledge. it, you know, there are high spots, low spots. on the back side of it, drops straight down, so it's it's simply not a logical location to build a house.
[45:44] and you and there's no way you can ever get a septic over there. so, sure, I could build a house, but I don't have a septic. I'd have to rerun power. I don't have any water. They have an al- an alternative location that does work for a septic field. It already has water, it already has power, and it is
[46:06] more is less non I always say it wrong.
[46:11] It you know, it in our opinion, it is it meets the ordinance to the greatest practical extent. We've gone from a 14-ft setback to a 54-ft setback. And you know, the numbers are less. So, or the square footage within the shore line within 75 ft is less than what currently exists.
[46:31] So, in general, that area is it's simply not suitable for building in all aspects. You could build a house, but you couldn't put anything you couldn't get any septic there.
[46:44] Now, the tank is a little closer than it should be, is it not? It's 7 ft as opposed to 8 ft.
[46:50] So, I'm not a site evaluator, so I'm not fully I'm not fully versed in what it should or should not be. I can tell you that Brady Frick came out and redesigned a new system for it. so,
[47:07] and I think Jack, maybe you can comment to this, but it was to the structure, not to the deck. So, I don't think this I don't know if that setback applies to the deck piece. I think it applies to the house itself.
[47:19] Sometimes it's hard to tell on these little sheets, at least for me.
[47:24] I need a magnifying glass to look at some of these things.
[47:27] I need more.
[47:28] Yeah. I couldn't find one, so.
[47:33] The plans from the surveyor are printed on
[47:36] Oh, so that's the deck.
[47:38] Yeah.
[47:38] Okay. Yeah, no, I couldn't tell it was a deck.
[47:43] I need it to be marked deck for me to know. Thank you.
[47:46] Yep.
[47:48] We're we're a little bit limited here because we really don't have written findings and conclusions to go along with that. Was that the Was my motion sufficient for that?
[47:58] Yeah.
[47:59] Okay.
[48:00] Yes. So, wait. It's moved and seconded.
[48:02] Okay, it's been moved and seconded. is there any further discussion?
[48:09] All right, I'll call for a vote. Lori?
[48:13] Lori Falcone, I.
[48:15] Jim?
[48:20] Jim Babarsky, I.
[48:23] Allison?
[48:24] Allison Hawks, I.
[48:26] Dan Holback, I.
[48:29] Courtney Snellings,
[48:33] a reluctant I.
[48:35] Nate? Motion passes five to nothing. The conclusions of law, I move that in light of these findings of fact, with consideration given to the supporting documentation, the planning board reaches the following conclusion. The planning board finds that the application of the Gun Point LLC
[48:57] has met the standards of the Town of Harpswell Shoreland Zoning ordinance, and it approves the proposed reconstruction and relocation of the non-conforming cottage at 368 Gun Point Cove, subject to the standard terms and conditions of approval.
[49:19] Is there support?
[49:21] Second.
[49:22] Any further discussion?
[49:25] Lori?
[49:27] Lori Falcone, I.
[49:33] Jim Babarsky, I.
[49:35] Allison Hawks, I.
[49:37] Dan Holback, I.
[49:38] Courtney Snellings, I.
[49:40] It is approved five to nothing.
[49:42] Thank you very
[49:43] for all your work on this. This was This was difficult.
[49:46] Yeah. Yeah.
[49:47] But we're happy that we can let you proceed.
[49:52] All right. Thank you very much.
[49:54] And we'll look for the revised septic design.
[49:56] Okay.
[50:01] Thank you very much, everybody.
[50:04] Yeah. All right.
[50:06] Thanks.
[50:06] Okay. Next
[50:11] Where are we here?
[50:14] Maybe a wharf, perhaps?
[50:16] Next item of business are two that are fairly related. Items 26-10-01, Baumgardner Realty LLC, Glenn Lobsters applicant. That's map 22 lot 53W43 Abner Point Road. Consideration of an application for a conditional use permit to reconstruct a bait building on commercial
[50:43] wharf. And then also 26-10-02.
[50:48] We'll vote on these separately. But a lot of the things are going to be similar, which is Baumgardner's Realty LLC, owner Glenn's Lobsters applicant. Also map 22 lot 53W43 Abner Point Road, which is a site plan amendment consideration of an application to reconstruct and expand a commercial wharf.
[51:12] So,
[51:15] shall we start with the site
[51:20] Absolutely.
[51:20] the site visit? And move from there.
[51:23] Let me see where that is.
[51:27] Okay.
[51:31] All right. owners, Rebecca and Hank Baumgardner. these are the people who were there. Planning Board, I was here. And also Debbie Forrester. as for town staff, Mark Margaret McIntyre, the town planner. And the two codes officers, Tony Simmons and Tim Clark. [51:51] the project would be to extend the current commercial fishing wharf to allow boats to access the wharf at all tides, which is not possible now, and permit use of heavy machinery such as a forklift. The wharf will be extended by 48 ft and built of concrete. The stone area the current stone area will be replaced with pile lines, ultimately decreasing the area of the ocean floor that's directly impacted by the wharf.
[52:21] The wharf will be raised 1 and 1/2 to 2 ft above what it presently is. Some floats will be removed. The remaining floats may extend 1 to 2 ft further into the boat launch area. I guess we've actually had Is it two neighbors? It says one neighbor.
[52:42] We've had two neighbors that have Or is it still just the one who will be impacted by this project agrees?
[52:50] The neighbor directly to the south signed off on the project.
[52:53] Right. Okay. and the owners have been working with DEP on the design so that it meets all DEP requirements. So hopefully that's all accurate. Okay. Thank you.
[53:10] All right.
[53:13] Do you
[53:15] So this project is obviously very complicated. They need to do any work in the shoreline, you need a list of approvals. they are working on their DEP approval, but during that process they're they finalize their designs and so they're going through the town approval process. [53:36] to replace a bait house or any structure over a wharf. It's The flood ordinance limits you to 200 square feet. And the flood ordinance doesn't recognize replacement or existing non-conforming structures. So basically, if they're replacing it, has to meet the new standards.
[54:00] They did go to the Board of Appeals in September and got approval for a variance to one section that you'll see in the findings of fact.
[54:16] As far as the conditional use part goes, but all of this is the conditional use section is all the flood ordinance.
[54:23] All right. the we will accept the finding of the Board of Appeals incorporate that by reference in our findings. so representative Let's see. Representative want to speak to it?
[54:41] I can speak to whatever you'd like. They can speak pretty much everything that I'm going to, but
[54:51] I'm Sean Baumgartner. So I guess our dilemma here our issues are A, the first thing that we had go to the Board of Appeals for, which was to build our structure back. It is not 100% it's 1 foot bigger than the existing building is now. it will be
[55:12] should be much better off with any storms or any floods or anything we're going to incorporate moving forward. So it will be a foot and a half to 2 feet higher on that end, which was submerged definitely during our January storms. And then there'll be a 6-foot concrete
[55:33] wall. So the foundation of the building will be the first 6 ft are going to be concrete. And then wood structure on top of that. and the first floor is strictly a cooler for our bait. And our second floor is going to be the you know, same thing as it's been for the past 80 years. small office and a just little storage area.
[55:58] the extension of the wharf is to try to accommodate the fishery I guess. kind of need to have access,
[56:10] you know, throughout the day. So, if you can't have access for 4 or 5 hours a day, you've kind of limited yourself to what you can do. And the way that the bait fishery is now, to secure bait and get bait, you have to be able to work at any tide cuz most of your local baits coming by boat, not via truck.
[56:31] So, have to have a way to unload it. Other than that, I don't have much to say. I mean, in a perfect world, you know, the stone's been there for well over 100 years.
[56:45] Yeah.
[56:45] [56:47] it would be great to accommodate a way to keep it in structurally sound. So, but it's it's not, you know, doesn't seem to be that world. So,
[56:59] other than that, I can answer questions about the process or, you know, construction process, but
[57:07] Well, I went and did a lot of photography during those storms. In fact, there was one a couple of years ago where you had where it was the elevation of the water was kind of problematic as well. So,
[57:21] Oh, absolutely.
[57:21] We can well understand that.
[57:23] Mhm.
[57:24] Okay. Are there any questions or comments from the board before we go through the standards here.
[57:34] No. No.
[57:37] Okay. I move that the planning board finds that the application of Glenn's Lobsters LLC meets the following approval standards of the flood management ordinance for conditional use permit based on findings that are incorporated by reference [57:57] by the prepared by the town planner on October 16, 2026.
[58:05] These include article 6 Roman numeral 6A that all development be designed and adequately anchored article 6.R9
[58:23] conditional use shall be limited to low value structures. And that is it. Are there any questions of on the proposed recommendations from the town planner?
[58:44] Are there any comments from members of the audience?
[58:48] Did you Were they accurate?
[58:51] What's what accurate?
[58:52] The findings.
[58:53] I think so.
[58:54] Will you step up to talk? Yeah. I just some of them some of the findings that you have to make in this section are a little more technical, and so I wanted to make sure that they're not agreeing. I didn't make something up that they don't want to agree to.
[59:08] As to height of fuel tanks?
[59:11] Yeah. I said that they're going to be elevated out of the flood zone, but I wanted to make sure that was correct.
[59:16] correct.
[59:16] Okay.
[59:17] Yeah. So, our tanks will be higher than they are now, obviously. And they'll be in concrete.
[59:27] I'm happy to give you your time. I just figuring out what you were reading from cuz I couldn't figure
[59:31] Yeah, but Well, that was really interesting. I made the motion, never asked for a second.
[59:36] Second.
[59:36] Okay. Any discussion from the board?
[59:42] No.
[59:44] If not, I'll call for a vote. Lori?
[59:49] Lori Falcone, I.
[59:52] Jim?
[59:53] Jim Babarsky, I.
[59:55] Allison?
[59:55] Allison Hawks, I.
[59:57] Dan Holbert, I.
[59:59] Courtney Snellings, I. I have to say the work that you guys had to do for this was
[1:00:08] impressive. No, it really it really was. No,. It was It was impressive.
[1:00:15] Get a different word for it.
[1:00:16] also It was also very clear. Thank you.
[1:00:19] Yeah.
[1:00:20] Yeah. I know nothing about warf building or whatever and this was It was very clear and I appreciated that. Clear and thorough.
[1:00:28] I did forget that there's a letter from Anna Butter that we should enter into the record.
[1:00:33] Does that apply to this one or does it apply to the next motion?
[1:00:37] Both of them. Can I just read it?
[1:00:39] Sure.
[1:00:39] What? dear members of the planning board, as local neighbors we write to express our support for the proposed reconstruction of Glenn's Lobsters. We believe small businesses are vital to the character and economy of our town. We fully support their project and respectfully ask the planning board to give it favorable consideration. Thank you for your time and service to our community.
[1:01:01] Sincerely, Richard and Darlene Layman on Luby Drive. There was also another supporting letter. That's the one I was talking about.
[1:01:11] I think that's from the director Butter who signed off on the project.
[1:01:17] Oh, isn't that important as well?
[1:01:20] That's already That's already part of the record.
[1:01:23] Oh, okay. Okay.
[1:01:24] Because that You know, this one didn't need to
[1:01:26] That one's required by ordinance. That They have a butter sign off.
[1:01:30] Okay.
[1:01:30] Okay, in light of these findings of fact with consideration given to the supporting documentation in the record, I move that the planning board reaches the following conclusions. The planning board finds that the applicant, Glenn Lobsters LLC, has met the standards of the town of Harpswell Floodplain Management Ordinance. The planning board approves the application for a conditional use permit
[1:01:53] at 43 Abner Point Road, which is tax map 22 lot 53, with the following conditions of approval. One, the approval is not final until such time as final plan showing all conditions of approval and any waivers granted have been signed by the chair of the planning board. The approval is based on the approved plans and all submissions and information provided by the applicant at final approval,
[1:02:18] whether referenced in any findings or conditions of approval. Two, the approval is dependent upon and limited to the proposal and plans contained in the application and supporting documents submitted and affirmed to by the applicant. Any variation of the plans, proposals, and supporting documents, except de minimis changes as determined by the town planner, that do not affect approval standards is subject to the review and approval of the planning board prior to implementation.
[1:02:48] Three, a conditional use permit issued under the provisions of this ordinance shall expire if the work or change involved is not commenced within 180 days of the issuance of the permit by the planning board. Four, the applicant will apply for and receive a flood hazard development permit for minor development
[1:03:09] for the reconstruction and expansion of the wharf from the code enforcement office in addition to the conditional use permit for the bait house issued by the planning board. There a second?
[1:03:21] Well, before you do that real quick, Glenn's Lobster's LLC, does it need to be It's not Glenn's Lobster LLC, right?
[1:03:32] it's Baumgardner Realty LLC is the owner. Glenn's Lobster's is company, but
[1:03:37] Does it Do you want to correct that?
[1:03:40] I put Glenn's Lobster's as the applicant.
[1:03:42] Okay. Cuz there's a lot of different I get it cuz I have the same thing going on with mine, too, but does it And not LLC? Man. That's just the wharf part, but the LLC
[1:03:57] part. So, the real Yes.
[1:04:00] So, it should be Baumgardner Realty LLC. Correct?
[1:04:05] The applicant Glenn's Lobster's LLC representing Baumgardner LLC.
[1:04:11] Glenn's Lobster It's not a LLC.
[1:04:14] S corp. Yeah. So, Glenn's Lobster's is a what?
[1:04:18] An S corp. Not an S corp. Not an LLC, yep.
[1:04:21] Glenn's Lobster's Incorporated representing Baumgardner Realty LLC.
[1:04:26] I just want to make sure the wording doesn't screw it up later and it doesn't match to what you're supposed to have.
[1:04:34] Well done. First meeting, you're already contributing well.
[1:04:37] Blame it on the day.
[1:04:37] Okay. There Was there a second to that motion?
[1:04:41] No.
[1:04:42] I'll second it.
[1:04:43] Okay. Seconded by Lori. All right. call for a vote. Lori.
[1:04:49] Lori Falcone, I.
[1:04:52] Jim.
[1:04:53] Jim Babarsky, I.
[1:04:54] Allison.
[1:04:55] Allison Hawks, I.
[1:04:57] Dan Holbeck, I.
[1:04:58] Courtney Snellings, I.
[1:05:00] That motion passes five to nothing. So, the conditional use motion has been adopted. The second one that we have is the
[1:05:13] site plan amendment.
[1:05:16] [1:05:23] I think if we were going to be technical, this could have gone to staff review committee because it's an amendment a small amendment, but since they were already coming here, we're doing it here instead.
[1:05:34] Okay. we have findings of fact under conformance with shoreland zoning standards.
[1:05:49] And again, these are are were prepared those findings were prepared by memo from the town planner on October 16, 2026. So, I move the planning board finds that the application of Glenn Glenn 's Lobsters
[1:06:14] LLC not LLC corp Inc.
[1:06:19] You could just say Glenn's Lobsters.
[1:06:22] Well, I would you know, but since it's a
[1:06:24] We've gotten this far though, I guess.
[1:06:25] Let's yeah, let's make it consistent. representing Baumgardner
[1:06:33] Realty.
[1:06:34] Realty LLC
[1:06:36] Yep.
[1:06:36] meets the following approval standards of the shoreland zoning ordinance sections 15.3
[1:06:43] and that includes sections 15.3.1
[1:06:48] through section 15.3.11.
[1:06:56] Is there a second?
[1:06:58] Second.
[1:06:59] Any discussion?
[1:07:03] Hearing none. Lori?
[1:07:06] Lori Falcone, I
[1:07:08] Jim
[1:07:14] Jim Babarsky, I
[1:07:16] Allison Hawks, I
[1:07:18] Dan Holbeck, I
[1:07:19] Courtney Snelling, I
[1:07:22] That motion is adopted five to nothing. the site plan review ordinance conformance with submission requirements I suppose so move that the application for the amendment of an approved site plan meets the submission requirements of section 14 of the site plan review ordinance based on the information provided by the applicant
[1:07:46] the complete list review by the town planner dated 10 16 26 and the granting of waivers which are not required to determine compliance with the standards
[1:08:01] which is sections 14.1.8
[1:08:05].2.2,.2.3,.2.4,.2.6,.2.7,.2.9.2.10,.2.11 14.3.2 and 14.3.3
[1:08:22] Is there a second?
[1:08:25] Second.
[1:08:26] Any discussion?
[1:08:27] Yes. you're missing the first page of the application.
[1:08:35] Sorry, my mic got We didn't get the first page of the application. So, I made all those completeness standards with the understanding that I would ask you for that one page. So, sorry. It's like they're just the planning board application page. So, if you could get that to us then this will really be correct.
[1:08:55] Okay.
[1:08:55] Okay, thank you.
[1:08:57] Good. Any discussion?
[1:09:00] No.
[1:09:02] All right, Lori.
[1:09:04] Lori Falcone, I.
[1:09:07] Jim.
[1:09:08] Jim Babarsky, I.
[1:09:10] Allison Hawks, I.
[1:09:11] Dan Holback, I.
[1:09:13] Courtney Snellings, I.
[1:09:15] All right, motion passes five to nothing. Findings of fact conformance with site plan review standards. I move that the planning board finds the following standards are met since they were met in the 2003 site plan review approval by the planning board and no changes are proposed and those sections are listed and incorporated by reference.
[1:09:39] Is there a second?
[1:09:42] I'll second it.
[1:09:44] Oh.
[1:09:44] I think Lori said something.
[1:09:45] Lori seconded it, okay. Any discussion?
[1:09:49] No.
[1:09:49] Ready for a vote, Lori?
[1:09:52] Lori Falcone, I.
[1:09:54] Jim.
[1:09:55] Jim Babarsky, I.
[1:09:56] Allison Hawks, I.
[1:09:58] Dan Holback, I.
[1:09:59] Courtney Snellings, I.
[1:10:01] Motion passes five to nothing.
[1:10:05] I move that the planning board finds that the application of Glen Lobsters, Inc. and Baumgardner Realty LLC meets the following approval standards of section 15 of the site plan review ordinance based on the findings that are incorporated into this motion by reference and that is sections 15.1
[1:10:28] through section 15.22.
[1:10:35] Again, those recommendations made by the town planner by memo dated October 16, 2026.
[1:10:44] Is there a second to that motion?
[1:10:47] I'll second it.
[1:10:49] See, Lori wants in.
[1:10:51] Yeah, okay. Any discussion?
[1:10:55] Call for a vote,
[1:10:58] Lori Falcone, I.
[1:11:00] Jim.
[1:11:01] Jim Baborsky, I.
[1:11:03] Allison Hawks, I.
[1:11:04] Dan Holback, I.
[1:11:06] Courtney Snellings, I.
[1:11:08] Motion passes five to nothing.
[1:11:13] Okay, get all the way down here.
[1:11:15] Can't flip my pages fast enough, Dan.
[1:11:18] I can't even keep up with you. I have no idea where you are.
[1:11:20] Okay.
[1:11:21] Right, conclusions of law.
[1:11:22] Yeah.
[1:11:23] On page seven.
[1:11:24] Yeah. I just was scrolling until I got to it.
[1:11:27] I see it.
[1:11:28] Okay. under conclusions of law, I in light of these findings of fact with consideration given to the supporting documents in the documentation in the record, I move that the planning board reaches the following conclusion. The planning board finds that the applicant Glenn's Lobsters, Inc.
[1:11:50] representing Baumgardner Realtor LLC has met the standards of the town of Highland site plan review ordinance and the shoreland zoning ordinance. The planning board approves the application and site plan amendment for the expansion of a commercial wharf and replacement of a bait house at 43 Abner Point Road
[1:12:11] with the following standard conditions of approval. One, the approval is not final until such time as final plans showing all conditions of approval and any waivers granted have been signed by the chair of the planning board. This approval is based on the approved plans and on all submissions and information provided by the applicant at final approval, whether referenced in any findings or conditions of approval.
[1:12:34] Two, the approval is dependent upon and limited to the proposal and plans contained in the application and supporting documents submitted and affirmed to by the applicant. Any variation from the plan proposals and supporting documents, except de minimis changes as determined by the town planner, that do not affect approval standards is subject to the review and approval of the planning board prior to implementation.
[1:12:57] Three, the applicant shall obtain all necessary state and federal approvals before the applicant commences any land use activity pursuant to the site plan approval and shall comply with the requirements of those permits and approvals. Four, all work shall be completed
[1:13:17] in accordance with best management practices for soil erosion and sedimentation control. Five, one copy of the notice of decision must be recorded by the applicant in the Cumberland County Registry of Deeds within 45 days of approval and the book and page number provided to the code enforcement officer.
[1:13:37] Failure by the applicant to report or record the notice of decision shall void the site plan approval. Six, the applicant will work with the code enforcement officer to ensure compliance with the erosion control plan. Is there a second?
[1:13:55] Second.
[1:13:57] It has been moved and seconded. Any discussion?
[1:14:01] Call for a vote. Lori.
[1:14:03] Lori Falcone, I.
[1:14:05] Jim.
[1:14:06] Jim Babarsky, I.
[1:14:08] Allison Hawks, I.
[1:14:10] Dan Holback, I.
[1:14:11] Courtney Snelling, I.
[1:14:13] Motion passes five to nothing.
[1:14:17] Congratulations.
[1:14:18] Thank you.
[1:14:20] We
[1:14:22] You know, there are times when we considered ourselves to be a working waterfront community. There are times when it's really a pleasure to see to it that 's really promoted.
[1:14:32] yeah, I hope so. I mean, it's it's It's dying, so there needs to be some access in the town, for sure.
[1:14:40] Yeah.
[1:14:41] And we're running out of options to keep that access alive. We should have those poppers right now. Like, we should just pop some stuff out here like a little party.
[1:14:49] It's not over. Still got
[1:14:50] Like we had it.
[1:14:51] This is this big thing getting in our way. That's
[1:14:55] That's a lot.
[1:14:56] Feels like it's coming together so.
[1:14:58] Okay.
[1:14:59] So we'll get you a notice of decision to record at the registry. The chair has per the flood ordinance, the chair has to sign a letter saying that you guys can't get flood insurance for the bait shed because it's in the flood zone. you will record at the same time you do the notice of decision from planning board, you can do the one from board of appeals.
[1:15:21] and then next steps for the town are the harbor master and codes and then select board at the end.
[1:15:30] No. No I don't think any of them have been scheduled.
[1:15:33] Okay.
[1:15:33] Yeah.
[1:15:35] I had met with Darcy but I don't know that.
[1:15:39] So the typical procedure is that Darcy has to Darcy will prepare a memo for the select board that says she doesn't think the application she'll vote on whether or not it will have any impacts on fishing, fowling, or navigation.
[1:15:54] Oh yeah.
[1:15:54] And that will be based off her conversations with the marine resource committee, the fisheries committee, and the harbor and waterfront committee.
[1:16:01] Yeah we're going through that with the DMR right now so in Augusta.
[1:16:05] Perfect. Well they're doing it here on the local level too.
[1:16:08] That's great.
[1:16:09] So she'll review it with all of her committees, she'll sign something, and then that will be submitted in the final packet to the select board who have to make the final determination on your impact of fishing, fowling, and navigation.
[1:16:21] Yes.
[1:16:24] That's not up to me.
[1:16:28] Well anyway so yeah we Yeah and I think we'll need state approval as well not DEP but department of marine resources. Cuz they issued us a permit once and
[1:16:41] Oh so now you get to keep going back for amendments?
[1:16:44] Now we do, but they it expired and it is now I think this time when we resubmitted it rose some red flags, so we had to make a few changes or see what they're going to do, I guess, but All right. Thank you.
[1:17:02] Thanks, guys.
[1:17:03] All right.
[1:17:03] Good luck with your project, you guys.
[1:17:05] Thank you.
[1:17:07] Good luck with Sean.
[1:17:13] Okay. We are to the last item of the business, and thank you very much for your patience as we've gone through some interesting stuff tonight. This is item 26-10-03,
[1:17:27] the Mary Susan Leahy Trust 93 Oker Style and Road Map 664 Lot 14, reconstruction of a nonconforming structure. the lot is located at 93 Oker Style and Road, 83,000 square feet or 1.19
[1:17:48] acres, located in commercial district one and commercial district two, and subject to the shoreline zoning ordinance. The unique parcel was created by combining a barn lot and house lot in 2025. The result of this merge creates a lot with 442
[1:18:09] feet of combined frontage on Ridley Cove. The lot is bisected by Oker Style and Road and Rocky Hill Lane. The setback requirements of the shoreline zone are 25 feet from all property bound- boundaries and 75 feet from the highest astronomical tide. There are no road setbacks in the shoreline zone.
[1:18:31] The lot is developed with a single-family home as well as a barn and garage/greenhouse.
[1:18:37] The applicant proposes to tear down and rebuild the home in exactly the same location as the existing structure with a 238 square foot reduction in footprint. The home is non-conforming in regards to the 75 foot setback from the upland edge of the wetland.
[1:18:58] Okay.
[1:18:59] Would you like to hear about it?
[1:19:00] I'd like to hear about the site visit, yeah.
[1:19:02] All right. So, 93 Oakhurst Island Road, reconstruction of a non-conforming dwelling. in addition to the usual culprits I've named before, the owner, Mary Susan is it Lay?
[1:19:20] It's Layhe.
[1:19:21] Layhe? Okay, thank you. was there, and then a butter, Gina Salwen, trying my best with the names here. and I was the planning board member, as well as the staff. we observed the non-conforming dwelling, the construction of a large shed in the middle of the lot, and the barn.
[1:19:45] There is little vegetation near the house. The property owner also owns an abutting property where she lives. The highest point on the lot is in between Rocky Hill Lane and the barn, and the whole island slopes outwardly toward the water from that point.
[1:20:04] Okay. So,
[1:20:10] Okay, Margaret?
[1:20:15] no, I think she covered it.
[1:20:17] Okay.
[1:20:17] Yeah. She, Courtney.
[1:20:22] Okay, would you like to describe the project for us?
[1:20:26] I'd be happy to do so. And I'd like to just note that my neighbor, Peter Darling is here. He is the grandson of the person who built the house that I want to restore. He is my neighbor three doors down from me. So, I just wanted to acknowledge he's here.
[1:20:46] And, Yep. This is on your on the front page of the application. This is a picture of the house as it was built. It was built in 1904. And, this picture was probably taken in 1907 or 1908 from the looks of the little boy that's the age of the boy that's sitting
[1:21:09] Okay. Can you go back by the microphone cuz
[1:21:12] Oh.
[1:21:13] otherwise they can't hear what you're saying.
[1:21:15] sorry.
[1:21:15] You just You can just hold it up from back there.
[1:21:17] Okay. In any event, this is the house and what I would like to do is there's an L on the house and you can see the L if you look at the second page of the application.
[1:21:33] the house is like rectangular and then a little rectangular L on the east side that was used, I think, as a sunroom and there was a bathroom put in more modern times. And, so I'm proposing to remove that completely and to be able to reconstruct the house so it looks exactly like this when it's done.
[1:21:56] As though somebody if somebody were back then and they came and looked, they might say, "Oh, it looks a little bit more improved, but but it's exactly the same thing." All of architectural features will be exactly as shown in the original plan. That's the project. [1:22:18] I As was noted, I purchased the house next door. It's a small cottage on way less than an acre. it's called the Sunrise Cottage and I purchased it in 2018 and that's lot it's map 64 lot 16.
[1:22:39] I received approval from the planning board to rebuild that little cottage exactly where it was, which was 26 ft from the high water mark. there was some comment made by someone from the Conservation Commission at the time that recommended that it move back more from the shoreline.
[1:23:07] But the board in their decision said that they that had been commented on but it was not part of the recommendation that I should have to move it at all. I did end up moving it a couple feet further away. and I did have a requirement that I had to return the vegetation
[1:23:30] keep the vegetation that was there and I have done that. I've done more than that. So I'm I'm I'm very much in favor of not doing anything that would harm the shoreline and that's that was true then and that's true with regard to this application as well. I did submit
[1:23:53] through a representative Diane Ployd who does this kind of work, I did submit an application to the state for a permit by rule to be able to have them approved taking down the structure and not doing anything
[1:24:15] that was would damage, take trees down or that sort of thing. And I have that. That came that came in after I submitted my application. But I have copies of it here and I'll I'll give it to you so that you can see those. I also put in this packet I made a bunch of packets up and I'm sorry some of the people are not here to actually be able to look at it, but I put my the 2018
[1:24:41] approval for 89 Oak Crest Island Road for my little cottage. And then I also put a copy of the permit by rule issued on October 6th, I think. Also,
[1:25:02] I have put in a copy of an easement which I put on the property the barn lot specifically. I put a preservation easement that would restrict me or anybody else from ever doing any kind of residential and or commercial development on the barn lot.
[1:25:25] And that's important because some of the concerns that have been expressed by the planning department or some of the recommendations that maybe I could move that property from where it is over to the barn lot.
[1:25:45] That would not be permitted. I can't do anything that is residential or commercial on the barn lot. And I put a copy of that preservation deed in this packet as well.
[1:25:59] Can I ask you a question while you're going
[1:26:01] Sure.
[1:26:01] through that? so you asked for that preservation deed for the barn. Is that correct? The one that you're referring to? Okay.
[1:26:10] Yes, that's that is correct. And I can Should I give these to you, Margaret?
[1:26:18] You can hand them out.
[1:26:19] Oh, okay.
[1:26:21] Who can explain to me what a permit by rule is, Mr. Attorney? I'm looking at you cuz I don't know what it is.
[1:26:28] by rule is a permit from the DEP for use for work in the shoreland zone. There's kind of two levels when you're talking about the national resource the national the natural resource protection act. there's a the NRPA permit, which is the tier there's three different tiers. So, that would be for typically is for any new construction
[1:26:49] in the shoreland zone or over the resource. and a permit by rule is like a mini NRPA permit and it's typically for replacement structures. so, or work adjacent to the to the resource. So, because this is not over the high water, it qualifies.
[1:27:09] So, basically she's saying telling the DEP, "I'm disturbing the soil." And she's made they're making agreements to what erosion control and stuff they're going to do in that area.
[1:27:21] Thank you.
[1:27:22] You're welcome.
[1:27:22] Very much.
[1:27:23] So, it's like a mini DEP permit.
[1:27:24] Okay. Great.
[1:27:28] And for those of you who haven't I don't know if this is going to be able to be viewed by people, but you certainly have it in your packets. I took and I outlined the lot that I and there's the house that I want to retain and I put in yellow here the part that's going to be taken down.
[1:27:51] I also I drew I put red lines where the roads are. And also I put a yellow line around the 75-ft line on where it's on the barn lot. So, if I could if I had the right to do anything
[1:28:11] on the barn lot in the way of residential development. It would have to be in this little area. And I point that out because the planning director has said that I'm assuming that's what you were referring to, Margaret, when you talked about an option to move the house somewhere else.
[1:28:33] Yes.
[1:28:34] Yeah. So.
[1:28:40] So, what I did in preparing for coming here tonight, I went through on planning director's memo regarding my request. she pointed out 10 different
[1:29:00] bullet points on page two about my application's conformance with the standards of the ordinance. And what I did was I went through
[1:29:16] them one by one and I would like to comment on them. the first bullet says the setbacks are 25 ft from the property boundaries and 75 ft from the upland edge of the coastal wetland. And that is true. The second sentence of that bullet says, "While the unique shape of the property
[1:29:40] and the vast frontage create an unusual buildable area, there is a large building envelope that spans the center of the property." And that's the part that's under the easement. so, I really can't do anything in that area in the way of moving the house. And I wouldn't want to do that anyway.
[1:30:01] The whole reason I purchased the barn lot was to prevent somebody from putting a house up there that would look down on all of our houses that surround that barn lot. So, not only was I always skeptical of wanting to have a any kind of house, I certainly wouldn't do it myself.
[1:30:24] and now I can't. the second bullet says the replacement structure will remain non-conforming in regards to the setback from the HAT. that's the high tide line, I think.
[1:30:41] and that is true. it will still remain non-conforming, but it is going to be a lot less non-conforming because I'm taking off that L. and the impact of that [1:31:02] when the L is removed, the non-conformance from the high water line is reduced by about 1/3. From 30 ft from the HAT to being 45 ft from the HAT, and that shows on the plans that were submitted.
[1:31:26] [1:31:29] Bullet point three, the area where the L is slight slopes towards the Excuse me, the area where the dwelling is slopes towards the water. The area within the building envelope is relatively flat. And I'm assuming that reference to the building envelope is referring to the barn lot.
[1:31:49] the L does the area where the L is does slope toward the water. The area where the old house is mostly level, not 100% because as you get closer to the L, there is a slope towards slight slope towards the water.
[1:32:07] Bullet point four says, "There is greater potential for soil erosion if the dwelling is replaced in the same location." and I if I were replacing, I don't think that's accurate, at least the way I see it.
[1:32:28] If the building were replaced on the if it were able to be replaced on the barn lot.
[1:32:38] The building would be taken down. the entire building would be taken down. If the building is rebuilt the way I'm planning, hope I will get approval to do it. I will take the L down and I will still take the rest of the building down and put the new building in its place. So, I don't see that there is much difference, in erosion that would occur as a result of the replacement, whether it's replaced
[1:33:09] on the site it's on now or whether it's replaced on the barn lot.
[1:33:16] Can you use the same foundation or is that would have to go to zero. I mean, this was built long enough ago. I don't know what the foundation is.
[1:33:24] Well, the foundation on the west side is pretty much rocks. And they every time there's a storm because the because I'm lower than the road, every time there's a storm, the water that comes in there through those rocks is incredible. It's
[1:33:45] it really would not be practical to try to keep that foundation. There are as you get further towards the east, towards the water, there is they did replace some of the stones at some point with a cement block.
[1:33:59] Mhm.
[1:33:59] And I suppose you could keep that. But it just seems highly impractical. Given the it 's down there are sis- it's like cisterns. There's there's I think they collected water down there one time actually. that's what people had probably had to do on islands in the old days was collect water wherever they could.
[1:34:23] So it's like a little swimming pools or goldfish ponds that down there in that basement. It's really not something you'd want to keep. And it's creating a lot of moisture problems in the upstairs as well. The next one it her bul- the bullet point five there appears to be no structures on the lot or abutting lots that would be negatively impacted by the project and I think that is true.
[1:34:52] The next one, the septic system was replaced within the past five years and is located to the northwest of the barn. And that is true. After I bought that property when I bought that property my own house, I used to look out on a white pipe
[1:35:12] that was right next to the water. It was the septic effluent where it came out that went the from the from 93. There was also a broken place on the house next door to mine. 99 not mine to
[1:35:34] to the south of my house. 99 Oak Crest Island Road that was right up against the shore that was broken. I decided I didn't want to swim in the with the water. Everybody swims in the summer. We all swim in the cove there. So, as long as I was going to replace
[1:35:56] the septic for 93 Oak Persimmon Road, I put a septic plan in place, and I showed that was shown in the in the showing that we had. I showed where the septic new septic field is now on the barn lot, and both my neighbor, Christina Hatch's house at 99 Oak Persimmon Road and 93
[1:36:23] Oak Persimmon Road, the house that I want to replace by this application, they're all hooked up to that new septic system. And in addition, there is additional capacity that we built at the time, so that if something ever goes wrong with my 1995
[1:36:43] septic system for my own cottage, I have space in that septic field that I can hook my own up to that.
[1:36:54] [1:36:58] Okay, bullet point number seven, little if any vegetation will be removed as part of the project, and that is true.
[1:37:06] number eight, it appears that the total footprint of the original structure can be reconstructed within the buildable area. That would maybe be true. I mean, I 've never tried to fit it in there, but because easement, the preservation easement, nothing residential can go over there. [1:37:28] and the number the ninth bullet says the proposal does not attempt to make the structure more conforming to the 75-ft setback from the upland edge of the coastal wetland. and I 'm not sure that's quite accurate because I'm I am coming up away from the from the [1:37:50] HAT line by 260 square feet and I will be 45 feet away from the HAT line rather than 30 feet, which is what it was originally.
[1:38:10] So, and then number 10 is again a repeat. The total foot The total footprint of the original structure can be relocated or reconstructed beyond the required setback area. And that again, because of the easement that exists on that property, that is not [1:38:32] can't happen. So, it 's my hope that the planning board will allow me to do this project. I think it's a good project. I'm very interested in preserving as much of the character of the island as I possibly can.
[1:38:53] and the historic nature of it. And I believe that this project, as well as what I did with the original cottage that I have are as well as the reconstruction of the barn on the old barn, the old cow barn. I've reconstructed it on exactly the same location it was originally when it was originally constructed in the early 1900s.
[1:39:20] So, I would ask the planning board to please consider what I'm presenting and to allow me to move forward with the project. Thank you.
[1:39:33] I have a question about what these blue
[1:39:37] I couldn't read anything on there. Is that Is it say easement? Does it Do you mind to help?
[1:39:44] Do you want me to hold it? Oh, yes, please. It's at the first page of
[1:39:49] Okay, so what she's looking at, this was in the application packet. And what it is This shows the barn lots up here. the house lot that I'm trying to rebuild on is right here. These blue lines are easement lines.
[1:40:10] I had to give an easement to my neighbor, Christina Hatch, when I gave her access to my septic system. The state required that. And so my whoever the engineer was for that drew that for me. It goes right along
[1:40:31] the old road. It's underneath the old road. I think what you saw when you went on the on the tour. And it goes over it crosses my cottage lot. And then it goes across a little triangle. Actually, my neighbor Peter Darling, he owns a little piece of this. And then it goes up to a septic field.
[1:40:52] This is all approved by the state. And I did give her the easement. So, that's what you're looking at.
[1:40:57] Yes, having been to the property, I can say it's very confusing. It's very it's as you can see here with the easement and the road and whatever it was challenging.
[1:41:13] So.
[1:41:18] Okay. Are there any other questions or comments from the planning board?
[1:41:26] I guess the first question, you know, this is the first time that I obviously saw the preservation easement.
[1:41:35] Mhm.
[1:41:35] Which severely limits the buildable area. is there
[1:41:45] and having not been on that sidewalk myself, is that, I just I need to find out from you what you think about the, about whether it is appropriately to reconstruct the structure where it is. Is it
[1:42:05] or whether
[1:42:06] I mean, if having learned about the barn situation now, I mean, I know Margaret I was going to ask the same question. Like, exactly where would you put where would you put it, but you didn't know that there was a special situation with the barn and that now nothing can be built there. Is Am I correct on that?
[1:42:29] I Yes and no. It's noted on the, survey. Subject to preservation easement. So, I reached out, to Jeff Callanich, the Shoreline Zoning Coordinator, probably 3 weeks ago and asked for his guidance and I reached out to him again and he doesn't have an answer and he's reached out to Augusta to try to find an answer cuz this is not clear cut and this is not something that we typically consider.
[1:42:56] I would note that the preservation easement has been on that lot for less than 2 months. It's It's really It was completed just before the planning board application was submitted.
[1:43:09] But, anyways, that aside, I don't I didn't exactly know how to handle it and I tried to find the answer cuz I thought this might come up, but I have not received, any good guidance on it.
[1:43:21] I mean, what I'm seeing is a person that has a house that is non-conforming
[1:43:29] and she's making an attempt to make it more non more less I knew I was going to screw that up. Less non-conforming by taking off a section that is actually closer to the hat. So, she's taking that off. And so, my question would be
[1:43:50] if she cannot move the house someplace else cuz there are these easements and whatnot, it seems like she's making things better rather than worse by her plan. And I actually got a tour of the house. And you know, inside and it was questionable as to whether we were going to make it out alive.
[1:44:12] But, it does if she really cannot move it, I mean I understand what Margaret's saying if there's a buildable envelope, it should be there, but I don't see where there's a buildable envelope. It was a very as I said, a very confusing and complicated thing with the Darling house and then her cottage and then you go up kind of a hill and there's a barn and
[1:44:37] septic. But, it seems like there's an attempt to correct a situation that we would be happy to correct. If by taking off that section, basically she's kind of moving the house away from the water. Well, if she's not moving it, she's just re- just replacing it.
[1:44:59] So, that's my comment.
[1:45:01] That's kind of where I was at. I'm at the same spot you are.
[1:45:06] Okay. Well, at that at this point, you know, we also have the option we have the with the option to not accept jurisdiction and just to leave it to codes.
[1:45:24] Is that so? you know, we can we can go through the whole process here or say that based on what we have seen and what you've discussed and the and the easement that we should just leave this matter to code enforcement office. Is that
[1:45:47] Is that something that that you would wish to consider? Yeah, Jim.
[1:45:53] I was going to say yes. I think we can consider that.
[1:45:59] So, what does that change? Can you just give me a quick of what's what's the difference if we do or they do?
[1:46:09] The planning board's review, if I may jump in, the planning board's review, this jurisdictional review, is very limited. All that you are allowed to look at is does the relocate does the reconstruction and relocation of the structure meet the setbacks to the greatest practical extent. And, the ordinance gives the planning board that if you are replacing
[1:46:32] a structure by more than 50% of the assessed value, it comes to the planning board. You get the option to take the jurisdiction of over that limited scope, the conformity of the relocation, or we can remand it to codes. Either way, it's going to go to codes for compliance with the rest of the ordinance. but you have this limited scope that you can look at.
[1:46:55] So, if you don't want to look at the relocation, then it will be findings that the code office will make.
[1:47:01] But, if you guys want to, then you decide on the location and then that is a decision that is not up to the codes office to make in the end.
[1:47:10] I mean, we've already kind of talked about the location though, haven't we?
[1:47:13] Right, you know, and often when we take jurisdiction, one of the reasons is because we have a question, a serious question about side No, not side yards, but questions about whether it could reasonably be located better and all that.
[1:47:33] Or like a legal question. Sometimes it's because we have written findings with a notice of decision. Sometimes I feel like if it's a more controversial application, it's better for us to take jurisdiction so we can have that written findings that people can appeal if they if they want to.
[1:47:52] And it's also more important for us if if we had a number of angry neighbors there who were who were talking, you know, it's a if it was clearly going to have a potential negative impact on the rest of the neighborhood, we would want to weigh in on that and let the neighbors talk about that.
[1:48:12] It's a it's a better process because it's a public forum. where codes you don't get notified about the project till the building permit is issued if ever. But here you get everybody gets notified and then everybody can have their voice be heard.
[1:48:27] And they all had an opportunity to be heard here.
[1:48:30] Yeah.
[1:48:31] Yeah.
[1:48:31] And I can say I can add well, I think Mr. Darling could speak for himself, but I can also say that there are a number of neighbors abutting me that said, "Do you want me to come and support you at this?" And I said, "I didn't accept that. I said, 'You don't need to I 'll I'll go it on I'll go it on my own.'" So, but I think there is general This is a This house has been here for 122
[1:49:00] years. And it's a charming It would be a charming house if it weren't in such disrepair. And I think everybody realizes in the neighborhood, which is the island, that that 's the proper place for it. So, I think that's why you didn't have anybody objecting.
[1:49:23] Okay.
[1:49:26] Well, hearing that, I'm going to move that the planning board decline to exercise jurisdiction of this applicant and remand the matter back to codes.
[1:49:41] Second.
[1:49:43] Any discussion? Lori.
[1:49:46] Lori Falcone, I.
[1:49:50] Jim Bobarsky, I.
[1:49:52] Allison Hawks, I.
[1:49:54] Dan Holbeck, I.
[1:49:55] Courtney Snellings, I.
[1:49:58] Thank you very much.
[1:49:59] It did you know the idea of redoing the facade of the front to keep the character of the of the past is really a great idea, too.
[1:50:09] Thank you.
[1:50:10] Much success to you.
[1:50:11] Thank you very much.
[1:50:12] Yeah, appreciate your
[1:50:13] It's charming. I'm glad
[1:50:15] you're not planning to put up a McMansion there, but something that fits where it has been.
[1:50:22] Thank you for that. That's nice.
[1:50:23] very much. Thank you all.
[1:50:27] All right, that I think ends all of our
[1:50:32] all of the applications for this evening.
[1:50:37] Planners update.
[1:50:40] I provided everyone with a memo.
[1:50:44] I don't know if I put it on the website. So, if you didn't pick up a binder, I'm not sure that you got it. I can't remember now.
[1:50:49] No, and I had my binder, so I don't know what you're
[1:50:52] It's in the front It's on the front page. Flip to the front page. If you give me a copy, I'll read it to everybody. Keep going. Oh. It was right It was right there.
[1:51:04] I don't know what you're
[1:51:07] This one?
[1:51:07] Allison's got it.
[1:51:08] Good.
[1:51:08] I'll read it to
[1:51:09] Looks like someone's got it. Great.
[1:51:12] Oh, very good.
[1:51:13] I've got so much paper here. Seriously.
[1:51:16] Blame it on the paper.
[1:51:17] I do love paper, but
[1:51:19] All right.
[1:51:20] So, I was approached by Kelly Hughes and George Abbott
[1:51:25] Oh, yes. Now I know.
[1:51:25] at the Itty Bitty Coffee Shop. and they're they were interested in putting a coffee roaster in the existing shed. the place that they get their coffee roasted from is closing and they're going to take over the business and they just want to put the roasting machine in the existing shed. So, we talked about all the standards, you know, it's not going to change parking, it's not going to change the number of employees.
[1:51:49] It's not going to change, doesn't need more septic capacity. so I just wrote a memo that said, on September 23rd, 2026, the applicant proposed installing a coffee roasting machine in the existing shed on the property. The project will not change the use of the property, will not require the construction of or expansion of a structure,
[1:52:13] and will not impact the parking. The installation of a coffee roaster in the existing shed is considered a de minimus change and does not require further review by the planning board or associated staff review committee. So, I just want everybody to know that.
[1:52:29] Yeah. I saw that, so I gather that I was there this morning
[1:52:35] Oh, wonderful.
[1:52:36] as it so happens. so I gather that the trailer that is coffee colored is not the roaster because that is, you know, a parking space.
[1:52:48] I don't know about the trailer, sorry.
[1:52:50] Well, I was like, -oh, if this is if this is the roaster and it's not taking up parking,
[1:52:57] Right.
[1:52:57] it actually
[1:52:58] It's supposed to be in the shed.
[1:52:59] Well, I don't know what a coffee roaster looks like, so
[1:53:02] It doesn't look like a trailer. I work for Wicked Joe. they look they look like something that looks like a coffee roaster, so I wouldn't worry.
[1:53:11] Okay, good. Cuz I thought what would be the chances I would be there and get the memo. Okay.
[1:53:19] other updates,
[1:53:24] we're talking a lot of about a lot of short about a lot of ordinance amendments. The Housing Committee is having a workshop tomorrow with the Select Board at 4:00 to talk about the housing-related ordinance amendments that they're proposing. specifically, the Select Board had one of their goals, their 2026-27
[1:53:47] work goals, was to change the minimum lot size for a lot within a subdivision from 80,000 sq ft to 40,000 sq ft. and we brought that up with our housing consultant that's helping with our ordinance amendments. And we've talked about the pros and cons. Would it affect all subdivision lots in the whole town?
[1:54:09] So, that would be existing and new? Or would it with you had a subdivision lot that was existing at 80,000 sq ft, it wouldn't affect you and it would only affect new subdivisions. So, there's all these questions and implications for each way you can interpret it and you know, the density and whatever.
[1:54:31] So, we're going to have a a workshop with the Select Board tomorrow to discuss it at 4:00 if anybody wants to join.
[1:54:39] Okay. After the last meeting we had with the Housing Committee, I decided to do some deep dive research
[1:54:47] Okay.
[1:54:47] about the minimum the difference between
[1:54:56] ordinances and state statutes in terms of how it affects subdivisions in respect of covenants.
[1:55:04] Mhm. The answer in Maine in particular is that restrictive covenants win when compared to a town ordinance. So, if the town ordinance says this is the minimum square footage area, but the
[1:55:25] restrictive covenants say it's more restrictive covenants win. It's more It's the whichever is
[1:55:35] more restrictive, right?
[1:55:36] Yeah. Yeah. However, on a state statute, the state statute wins. So, if we say that on our in our subdivision and our bylaws say that I'm going to use a ridiculous example, but if our if our bylaws or our restrictive covenants say that we can't keep cattle on our property,
[1:56:02] but the state statute mandates the ability to do that, the state statute would win. So, the question always becomes now when the town is enacting these ordinances, are these ordinance amendments as mandated by the state,
[1:56:23] or are they additional things that we wish to accomplish? And that may be a very with a number of these things concerning housing and density, that may be a very important thing coming forward because a lot of subdivisions do have minimum square footage requirements and that sort of thing.
[1:56:45] So, I was a bit surprised because that the supremacy of state statutes is something that is really been expanding. So.
[1:56:58] That I think that's why when we do a subdivision review, we have to find all the state statutes are met in addition to our local ones.
[1:57:07] Yeah, but I'm talking about Yeah, we certainly do that going forward, but in terms of grandfathering, you know, to say, "Hey, our subdivision was established 50 years ago. Those weren't requirements." Those requirements can change if the state statutes require.
[1:57:24] Mhm.
[1:57:24] Mhm. Really?
[1:57:26] Yeah.
[1:57:26] So, if the state statute said subdivisions now will be 40,000 square feet.
[1:57:35] Yeah.
[1:57:36] Really? So, state could go to current subdivisions and say, "Haha, you've got actually two lots there."
[1:57:44] Well, they can make
[1:57:46] That's interesting.
[1:57:47] you know, we're getting we get complicated there, but you know, when basically if the state has ruled you aren't going to be able to override it by way of restrictive covenants or subdivision.
[1:57:59] Interesting.
[1:58:00] Yeah, but Dan, what about other things that come into play like subdivisions that may have access to town water and sewer versus wells and septics. I mean, wouldn't you think that would have to come into play?
[1:58:18] Well, yeah, but
[1:58:19] Not for us.
[1:58:20] You know, what I guess the issue is the state statute clear about this is the standard?
[1:58:29] If the state said, you know, if the statutes are silent about it No, but you know, there are there are always going to be practicalities that you can argue that there could be an exception, but those exceptions are granted very, seldomly.
[1:58:48] Mhm. Yeah. So, I think we talked about this at our workshop, but you know, the big change on the ordinance and the legislation is allowing ADUs in the Shoreline zone.
[1:59:00] Right.
[1:59:00] So, we're continuing to discuss what that those approval standards would look like. yeah.
[1:59:08] Okay.
[1:59:08] I think that's basically it for now.
[1:59:12] All right. Is that it for your
[1:59:15] Sure.
[1:59:15] report then?
[1:59:16] think of it. I got so much in my brain, I can't think of anything.
[1:59:19] Okay. That's fine. Yeah, you're short tonight. what about the approval of minutes?
[1:59:26] What about them? I sent them out diligently. Except, I don't think the last one got is finished, but the rest of them got sent out.
[1:59:34] Okay. But, we are we are going to move to approve the minutes of what meetings? And now that I just closed my computer.
[1:59:42] July 15th, July 21st, August 10th, August 19th.
[1:59:46] Okay, I move that those minutes be approved. Is there a second?
[1:59:51] Second.
[1:59:51] Discussion?
[1:59:53] No.
[1:59:53] Lori?
[1:59:55] Lori Falcon, I.
[1:59:57] Jim?
[1:59:58] Jim Bobosky, I.
[2:00:00] Allison Hawks, abstain.
[2:00:03] Good. Dan Hoback, I.
[2:00:05] Courtney Sellinger, I.
[2:00:08] All right. Is there any other business? Questions, comments from the board? If not, this meeting is adjourned.
[2:00:15] Thank you for coming, Allison.
[2:00:17] Thank you, guys.
[2:00:18] Have a good night, everyone.
[2:00:19] Good night.