← Back to MaineScanner

Mount Desert Planning Board Approves Tennis Club Expansion After Continued Review

2026-11-12 · 56m · Source: Planning Board November 12, 2026 (Town of Mount Desert (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Hey, call to order the town amount deserve planning board meeting for November 12, 2026. I'll come aboard I'll kick it off with some planning board at introductions and we could all say, or we are in our role on the board. I'll take it off as him. [0:24] Speaker B (unidentified): William handling and planning board chair and I'm Tracy Keller. I'm the vice chairman. [0:30] Speaker A (unidentified): and Alton regular member Dan Burke alternate member Alan Kimberly regular member Gil Marshall as regular as I get and online we have Meredith [0:46] Speaker C (unidentified): Randolph I'm an alternate member now all right great to see you Meredith welcome [0:51] Speaker A (unidentified): welcome aboard thanks yeah right there you go let's soldier on next item is we've got some minutes from the 28th view and approve I don't have a copy of them okay I have right here there [1:11] Speaker B (unidentified): you go I don't know you just want to know who's here I move approval there you go second that [1:18] Speaker D (unidentified): all those in favor aye and let's soldier on do we have to since heidi is off-site do we have to say that you seconded it and gail yeah motion heidi can you hear us [1:40] Speaker E (unidentified): i can it sounded like gail made the motion and ann seconded did i get that all right [1:49] Speaker A (unidentified): all right we miss anything heidi let us know i promise thank you all right here we are item three on the agenda tonight we have a conditional use approval application this is continued from the 14th of october and it is conditional use approval application 17 2026 owner is the Northeast Harbor Tennis Club the applicant agent is Paul moniak and Ben Kyman from Haley Ward location is a tennis club road Northeast Harbor tax map 27 lot 32 Zone Village residential one and the purpose is section 3.4 commercial outdoor recreational facilities remove one tennis court and construct a 60 by 30 Terrace and lawn area within the footprint add two new tennis courts relocate existing driveway entrance from Millbrook Road to Tennis Club Road improve the existing parking area provide bike access along Tennis Club Road adding maintenance path along southern edge of tennis courts and adding vegetation and landscaping in select areas and was this 1 advertised in the butters? No,, it was not because it's a continuation. It was 8, which was tonight. There you go. Any conflict of interest on the board here? All right. And the continuation, the board and the applicant agreed to was that was real primarily relative to section. Section 683 and 684, and with that, I'm going to turn it over to the app. [3:40] Speaker F (unidentified): Good evening board and came in representing the applicants tonight. I'm going to get right into it. We can kind of pick up our discussion from last time. I just want to make sure that you guys get an updated plan. We did, you know, so. So to address 6A3 and 6A4, we sent in an email correspondent with the police chief where he indicated that he did not have an issue in the past. He said that there was only a few instances of somebody calling in for parking complaints. Complaints you should have received a copy of that as well. The other, the other part of the discussion was parking. We took another look at the parking and I know we discussed at one point leaving the entrance out onto Millbrook Road. We decided from a traffic standpoint it was, it was more prudent to move it, keep that entrance coming out onto Tennis Club Road, which is a just a local road, and instead of the, Collector Road of Millbrook, from a traffic engineering standpoint that is a, much more stable intersection. And also we were allowed, we were able to increase the parking with this arrangement as opposed to going out onto Millbrook. So we have, we've adopted some standard parking calculations which are included on the plans, which is two spaces per, court, and I believe it was six spaces per one thousand square feet of building area, which equates to 43 required spaces for the project. We provided 53. On this, on this plan here, we have some overflow parking and we've also included a bike path coming from no road to maintain pedestrian access to the site without having to go through the intersection. The other point that we wanted to address, which is what I handed out earlier with the parking plan for events that the club has developed, they want to make sure that they are good neighbors and they're being proactive in developing that internal plan so that they can address any neighbor's issues and make sure that the surrounding community is not impacted by their events. So with that, I would leave you to continue. In [6:36] Speaker A (unidentified): the context of the 6 request, was there any correspondence with the town regarding the impact on town services? [6:47] Speaker F (unidentified): That was the police chief letter. Yep. I think that was the primary focus of that based on the comments that the board had. Got it. [7:01] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes. Yes I achieved one out Tuesday he was going to go look at it and I haven't, I sent him an email this morning asking if he's had any comment and I didn't hear back from him. Okay. [7:18] Speaker G (unidentified): I think the first year we did have, we had some big events and we were a little overwhelmed, but [7:25] Speaker H (unidentified): since then we have put like orange traffic cones on one side of the street to make sure people can, we can still get through and only have the parking on the side, Heidi. [7:38] Speaker A (unidentified): You know who just said that? [7:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, we have to identify ourselves. Yeah, I do not, I, it would be good to identify. Yes, I heard no name, Stephanie Reese. Yep, oh, okay, thank you. [8:00] Speaker F (unidentified): The manager of the club. Yep, yeah. [8:05] Speaker A (unidentified): That was the, yeah, during the public comment, is there anybody online to just, there are three participants, okay, yeah, that was, that was the hot topic of the public comments last time was just the congestion and along the road and working and all that, and hence we arrived at the continuation just for a bit more information on six eight three and four, and so with continued, so we opened and closed public comment last time, they came back with additional information for six eight three and four, do you guys feel like we can soldier on? Yes, sure, I'm [9:01] Speaker H (unidentified): move we find the application complete. Here you go. [9:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Second that. All right, all those in favor, I move we use the short form to [9:11] Speaker H (unidentified): process this application. I'll second that. 's Galen and got [9:19] Speaker A (unidentified): that, Heidi, I [9:21] Speaker E (unidentified): I have that. Thank you. All those in favor. All right. [9:26] Speaker H (unidentified): And I move, we approve the application, Gail. [9:32] Speaker A (unidentified): 2nd, that, and then we press the pause button and we go through the review of the application, and so we're using the short form checklist. I've got it right here in front of me. Got that application. I got my land use ordinance. We're all following along here. [9:54] Speaker H (unidentified): We should call it short or not short. [9:59] Speaker A (unidentified): That's true. Well, thankfully where you guys are in the shoreland zone, we're only doing 6A and B or so. Let's get to it. Right. So, we're looking at 6A, general performance standards, and we are on section 6A1, compatibility, and this is where we look at the physical size. The applicant says the lot's total of 8.68 acres, visual impact, the development is already in existence, and proposed improvements are not anticipated to cause any additional visual impacts. Impacts proximity to other structures. The development is already in existence. The distance the nearest of budding building is 17 feet from the existing maintenance building on site. Density of development is already there. The density is for 4,267 square feet of building area over 378,105 square feet resulting in 1.12 percent coverage. So C application erosion and sedimentation control. We've got a whole separate narrative on this and it's an in Appendix B, and it's in the plans provided as well in Appendix G. And so there's not any questions about that. I'm going to say C, application. 6A3, here we are. Highway safety. The applicant says the development is already in existence, only the driveway entrance is being moved from Millbrook Road to Tennis Club Road. They don't anticipate that the proposed improvements will increase additional traffic or cause unreasonable congestion. And for the record you guys have a follow-up from the police chief on that and we've got that on record and we have an amended site plan that's been submitted as well [12:16] Speaker I (unidentified): Well so unless there's any further discussion my I have a question. The application still states 31 spaces. Do we need to change that out with 43. [12:31] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't think so but you've got the [12:33] Speaker H (unidentified): Bargaining special yeah we can do that and the math which is 51. It's 50. [12:40] Speaker F (unidentified): 53 is required. [12:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so we don't need that amended in the original application additional document. All right. So. I'm going to say, see application 684 impact on town services. The development has an existing connection to town's water and sewer facilities. There's no significant increase in the amount of water and sewer demand. Therefore, they don't anticipate the proposed improvements to create any significant burden to the town facilities and the Chief's letter kind of speaks to that as well. Any discussion? Questions? Going to C, application then. Land suitability, 685. So the applicant says that the site is currently developed, no evidence of the above-mentioned adverse environmental impact has been identified. Proposed improvements are not anticipated to result in any adverse environmental impacts. Appropriate erosion sedimentation control measures will be implemented and all this for construction in all disturbed areas will be stabilized following the completion of improvements and they've got a whole nrcs soil report in appendix c. Are you still waiting on permits [14:24] Speaker H (unidentified): That's in the wetland area. Okay. So that's. [14:28] Speaker F (unidentified): I would expect that to be a condition. Yeah. [14:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. 6, 8, 5, land suitability, see application. 6, a, 6, lighting outdoor. The applicant says, and a, there's no new lighting proposed. So, and a 6, a, 7 storm water. There's a whole stormwater narrative provided in Appendix D with questions on stormwater. [15:13] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm just hoping there won't be a quiz in that. [15:17] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to say C, application, 688, vegetation. The development is already in existence. Consistence, vegetation removal will be limited to the area required for the proposed driveway and parking improvements. They don't anticipate the tree removal within 25 feet of Tennis Club Road to exceed 25%. Any slash generated during construction will be properly removed and disposed of. So see application. 689, dust, fumes, vapors, odors, and gases. The applicant says the proposed improvements are not anticipated to generate dust, fumes, fly ash, fumes. Generate dust, fly ash, fumes, vapors, odors, or gases. Temp may occur during construction. However, appropriate control measures will be used to minimize those emissions. So, see application. Application so the findings of fact are presented by the applicant and the attached application and the conclusion of laws that have proposed uses in compliance with all standards of section 6a for which the standard has been met. Yeah, so moved. Second. And all right, all those in favor. Here we go. Section 6A. Here we go. Section 6B. Specific performance standards for activities and land uses. 6B1, agriculture is an A. 6B7, excavation or filling. And the applicant says it says that there is some earth moving needed as part of the proposed work. Cotton fill is needed for construction purposes. And please refer to Appendix G for the grading plan, showing the extent of the excavation and filling. So there aren't any questions about excavation or filling. Going to say, see application. 68 fences and walls up and states that there is an existing chain link fencing. There is an existing chain link fencing as part of the existing development. New fencing of the same kind will be installed as part of the proposed work. Dumpster enclosure fence is proposed. Fencing meets required setbacks and does not obstruct highway visibility. And I assume there's a separate construction permit for the fence. [18:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Is the fence around the dumpster a solid fence, Ben? Yes. Okay, that's the only section. How high is it? [18:21] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, I believe 6 feet. That's the only 1 that will be in a comment. [18:26] Speaker B (unidentified): The chain, like, it's not really consider the fact. [18:30] Speaker F (unidentified): More than solid, but it is not solid. If it's just the chain link fence. [18:35] Speaker B (unidentified): Then it's more open than solid. It's not a fence. [18:42] Speaker A (unidentified): See application. 6016 sign regulations. Applications applicant says NA 6B 18 you're not proposing a cell tower NA 6B 19 animal husbandry 2 there's no chickens involved to be 20 mobile food vendors I think there's in food trucks allow involve and hey 6B 21 it's not a rooming house NA it's 6B 22 it's not a hotel or a motel NA 6B 23 there are no solar arrays but the findings of fact are that the proposed use will include none of the specific activities or land uses described in section 6B except for 6B7 and 6B8 and the conclusion law is that section 6B is not applicable except for section 6B7 and 6B8 for which the standard has been met [20:03] Speaker H (unidentified): So moved by Gail. [20:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Second by Ann. [20:06] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. All those in favor? Aye. [Speaker D (unidentified): All right.] That's Section 6B and 6C, Shoreland Zoning Standards for Review by Planning Board. And that is not applicable because you guys are in Village Residential 1. [20:28] Speaker H (unidentified): I move we find Section 6C and 5. 5 9 to be and if not applicable because it's not in the shoreline zone effect is that all [20:40] Speaker A (unidentified): those in favor same with 5 9. Y'all said five minutes today yeah I think I saw it and then [20:51] Speaker H (unidentified): the permit conditions the retainer well you need the fence permit and then from enforcement person officer and you need any other agency permits that are applicable to this project do we don't need to articulate them you need that sorry we don't need to articulate [21:11] Speaker B (unidentified): which permits they need but then you know I mean mainly it's the DEP yeah for the insulin impact yes they'll do road opening which will deal with that in the driveway yes new entrance but mainly just the DEP approval because that's back in the wetland for the proposed tennis courts On that Ben and I will be in that. [21:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, we don't need to condition the construction. Just a new. Okay, so, Heidi, you got that as the permit condition. [21:49] Speaker E (unidentified): Oh, I'm sorry, I've been typing and you've probably heard me the whole time. Fence permit and DEP approval regarding the wetland is what I have. Would you like them worded differently? [22:00] Speaker B (unidentified): You can remove the fence permit. Okay. [22:03] Speaker H (unidentified): Because that happens internally. It's just the outside agencies. All right. Sounds good. [22:13] Speaker A (unidentified): So there we are. Do you want to press play on your 8-track again? Yeah. Yeah, ready. All right. Yeah. All right. So they're press play, but go back to the approval vote. All those in favor of approving the application with the said permit condition. Hi, congrats. Thank you for thank you for responsiveness. [22:42] Speaker H (unidentified): And I also have to give a shout out for this massive. All these nice. [22:46] Speaker A (unidentified): It's nice you want it back yes there's a souvenir thank you someone use it in the woodstove [23:03] Speaker D (unidentified): What's fresh tennis career so I have hit a tennis swing straight through the painless [23:13] Speaker A (unidentified): It's the backside it's like it's straight through right through it if you hit it perfect [23:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Was semi-pro for one match I lost six one six oh yes there you go I hung out my racket [23:34] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah she had to play yeah that's pretty awesome [24:17] Speaker D (unidentified): Thing here that the pool it's all done following the reopening well thank you [25:04] Speaker G (unidentified): More things. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. [25:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Hey, well, on to item 4, is there any other we can discuss. [25:24] Speaker G (unidentified): Folks, we're going to finish our major got a soldier on here. [25:37] Speaker I (unidentified): So may I say my question was unable to winner to end the meeting that was on a Monday evening that discuss like a thing to know what the disposition of that. [25:57] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, that's what it's like. [26:01] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, I wasn't there either. And I don't know if that should be discussed. All I was told is that there are organizations that this is Heidi and I cannot hear with the other noise and going on. [26:19] Speaker E (unidentified): I can't hear a word you guys have said. Sorry. Thank you. [26:25] Speaker G (unidentified): There we are. All right. [26:30] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm not, I don't know if that should be discussed. I'm okay. Not discussing it. Yeah, we just don't know. [26:38] Speaker B (unidentified): What's going to be said here, but I want to talk to you about the next meeting. [26:42] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, but we are less before we do that, we do have a land use advisory committee meeting on Tuesday. Okay. We. My feeling at this point is that we, 've got a bunch of proposed changes that are that are state statute driven. And we probably ought to just deal with those in the form that NOLA has presented them and move on, except that we have the big question that we need to get opinions about, and that is, if we are going to be required to allow much greater density on certain lots, certain types of lots, and much more building on those lots, but the state's statute has not done anything to indicate, the state statute, which is driven by the desire to provide more available housing, does the town want to add other Sections that would somehow limit or restrain what all that greater concentration is going to be available for? For example, do you want a 5,000-foot lot in which somebody can build four units and then just rent it out short term? Do you want Do you want any to propose ordinance restrictions on any of that? Do you want? I, in some ways, I think if we think about it separately for now, we got we got to do what we got to do, and then what should be the policy that gets proposed to the town on the use of those changes? I mean this my understanding is that the State felt as though they didn't want to. They weren't. They weren't saying you couldn't put those restrictions on, but they didn't want to add them, because towns are in all kinds of different situations all over the State. So they didn't they didn't want to prescribe that but there is some recognition that towns and areas like ours have that issue. [28:40] Speaker D (unidentified): I know some states have put regulations yes in some states I know Massachusetts just had [28:46] Speaker H (unidentified): a referendum on a lot on whether or not they should allow or require the allowance of greater density and they just on lots and they just the voters just loaded it down but that's neither here nor there we didn't go through that process there appears to be a push for a short [29:03] Speaker B (unidentified): short-term rental ordinance again there's no way it's going to be able to come to 20 27 town [29:10] Speaker H (unidentified): meeting and that's something we discussed at which meeting was that it was at whether it was comprehensive plan or I think it was comprehensive and I said the same thing I said that may be desirable on the part of some and I think there are some select board members and David was at our meeting, our comp plan meeting. And I said, we're not going to accomplish that this time. It requires too much discussion and too much. [29:37] Speaker B (unidentified): And it had to have expired when they pushed the one that was done. [29:40] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, I don't think that's the end of the discussion. I think that's a data point that we should learn from. It doesn't mean we can never do anything. It's not what I'm saying. Yeah. But it needs lead time, and it needs discussion. It needs to be. [29:56] Speaker B (unidentified): And this and we have enough to do we have too much to do this year yes we're being forced to you know like Gail just said you know change our lot sizes and stuff and to allow more density of development and we got to put some standards in place in growth mostly in growth areas right [30:13] Speaker H (unidentified): That have sewer and water, so it is of limiting impact, but it could be significant impact, but most lots are going to be allowed to have the additional dwellings on them. [30:26] Speaker B (unidentified): Can you attach restrictions for like the 365 does with affordable housing, where these, if you're allowing the reduced lot size, you're attaching that to? I don't, I don't know if we can, because that's what's being allowed. We're not looking at bonus densities for development. This is what is being handed down by the state. It doesn't have to go to every piece of property. Pretty, it doesn't have to go to the planning board for review. This is what they're telling us that [30:57] Speaker H (unidentified): we have to change our ordinance to accommodate. However, doesn't mean, according to my comments, what I'm hearing from Noel, it does not mean that we cannot ourselves try to craft some limitations on the use of that greater density, so it doesn't turn into just an opportunity for somebody to buy a lot and, you know, a 5,000 square foot lot and put four dwellings on it that they rent out. [31:22] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean, Mar Harbor did that, and they were right out of the gate as soon as LD 2003 was proposed. ADUs that take advantage of that dimensional discount, so to speak, have to [31:33] Speaker G (unidentified): be used for year-round rental or personal use. [31:36] Speaker H (unidentified): Right,. So I think there are ways of doing that. I think what we, in our head, what we need to do is figure out how we want to figure out what we want to propose to the town about that, but in the meantime we got to just kind of tick off the box that says yeah, here's what the, here's what the language that we're required to pass is, and now let's move on to figure out if there's anything we want to rethink that the town should consider adding to that to help to help solve what the conference, if you come to the comprehensive plan public meeting which is going to be when, next Thursday, next Thursday at the library at six o'clock. You are going to have the opportunity to see the proposal that is likely to come out of the comprehensive plan, which is going to really focus in ways that most comp plans don't, on getting a specific housing program generated. And it would require the town to, what we're thinking about is the economic development committee, which is kind of on hiatus, that an economic development and housing committee would be generated. And that committee would and the town would have specific responsibilities for serving what exactly could be done. There's a whole set of rubrics that you would expect within the next 18 months after the passage of this to happen, and a report back to the community about what housing opportunities, specifically housing opportunities, not just building new buildings, but housing opportunities that would allow the possibility of more affordable and available housing. So that 's that's like the assertive focus of the proposed comp plan, because we keep passing Tom plans that say we're afraid that nobody can afford to live here. And so this isn't this will be an attempt to try to propose ways in which the town could actually be working. And we've had Alex that are most of the all these meetings when we're talking about this, too. And he's got some specific ideas. And so in light of that, we're gonna have that, we're likely if it passes, we're likely to have this comprehensive plan that says that the town's land use ordinance, and needs to be guided by what the comprehensive plan is proposing, which is laser focused on availability and affordability. So this would be entirely consistent with that to think about how you might want to structure, there's any boundaries on greater density proposals. So it's a lot of fun. That's where we're at. [34:34] Speaker B (unidentified): So now if you guys could attend, I mean, we'd love to have your input to those advisory group committee meetings, because it is advertised as a planning board meeting, too. [34:46] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, so well that's, that's on Tuesday, and then on Thursday is the comp plan public meeting, which is at the library at six, I think, I think it's, well maybe if like the meet and greet and look at posters and stuff, that's a five, that's off the top of my head, and then the actual meeting is at six. It would be good to come. I hope some people do come. [Speaker C (unidentified): Luzo at 6-2?] Luzo's at 5. Sorry, thank you. There? Here. Luzo's here. Right here. On Tuesday. On Tuesday. And then the comp plan public meeting is Thursday. That's a different committee. So that is that. That anybody have any words of wisdom you want to share on this [35:47] Speaker G (unidentified): Because it's really for the meeting, for the meeting. Yes. [35:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, any concerns or, anything else, it would be good to know, it'd be good to hear. So there's, there's my song and [36:05] Speaker B (unidentified): Answer about that Kim, you look like you have something. Well your next meeting is jam-packed. [36:14] Speaker H (unidentified): There's gonna be no time for cookies if that's the case, honey. [36:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Or extra cookies, so get on the next one, December 9th. Yeah, okay, cookies. So we have currently two conditional use applications that we've received, but we have two more coming. And then I received a subdivision amendment, but I don't know if that's going to make that meeting, because I received information that I told a property owner before we adopted our new subdivision ordinance. So now they have to fill out the application, which we need to work on that application, because it just totally doesn't make sense for some of the applications that people are like the last one you did where somebody was merging land, and so their law, that application makes no sense, right? And the same thing is happening with this subdivision, that two property owners own a lot in a subdivision, and there's a big chunk of land behind them that they're going to divide and merge it with their lots that are in the subdivision. So, and so it's going to obviously change the lot sizes, and so that application makes no sense. I've sent it to them, I haven't heard from them yet, and one property owner has submitted like a survey from Donald Benson, and I haven't heard from the other person yet, but if we don't [37:48] Speaker A (unidentified): get through all of that in one night, are we gonna have to continue it? You can either, I mean, are we obligated to continue it in the same month, because we [37:59] Speaker B (unidentified): tip, there's no obligation. No, there is no obligation, but you do have people that probably want to, maybe want their application heard, you know, in the same month. It's kind of difficult because of the holidays. Yeah. You know, you can certainly ask the applicants, do they mind being pushed to the January 13 meeting? And if they kind [38:27] Speaker H (unidentified): of growl and stuff, I mean, you can certainly, you know, continue it to. Do you have a sense of the complexity of the various applications? [38:37] Speaker B (unidentified): I do. So one of them is establishing a service. This is three construction business in Hall story. So I'm not sure how that's gonna go. And then a fence for the golf club. They're asking for the waiver of the six foot setback from the edge of the town's right of way. Town of Mount Desert application for the utility, public utilities and for the sewer mains and manhole replacements within Jordan Pond Road. They're going in different locations, different sizes, different material. So, and they're also going in people's, you know, rights of ways across their properties of that. And then ringing point, they're looking to remove all the retaining walls along the water to make the look from the water or to the shore ledge like natural ledge. And then the two, the two applications which are going to be separate for the subdivision because they had two different laws. Oh yeah. [39:55] Speaker G (unidentified): It's only five hours, okay. [39:57] Speaker I (unidentified): well so bill proposed maybe we'll do it the following week on wednesday i mean that's you [40:06] Speaker B (unidentified): know like you say first ask the applicants yeah you know is you have any objection being pushed to the 13th i mean i'll explain especially if people are going to be away for the holidays [40:17] Speaker A (unidentified): historically it's only once in december yeah you know right let's stick to that [40:25] Speaker B (unidentified): yes okay once in the summer in december oh december i was like what I think it always, you know, like I said, if somebody actually, you know, is waiting on waiting on this approval to get financing, or I don't know, like, I said, just ask the applicants. [40:51] Speaker H (unidentified): So, it's December 9th is the schedule. [40:56] Speaker B (unidentified): And if it snows, it'll be canceled. Yeah. Anyways, I suspect if it, you know, you get a lot of snow, but that doesn't mean you can't. I mean, you could, I mean, the only way that you could continue these if you get a snowstorm and it's canceled is you have to meet and then continue them to a date, otherwise they would have to go to the next meeting because I have to redo all the advertisements and notices again hopefully doesn't snow but mother nature you can't predict her that sounds great such a nutshell and gail i expect cookies [41:48] Speaker H (unidentified): think i think there's got appropriate double batch for that one [41:54] Speaker A (unidentified): did we do it well i have one more i just want to you know i have some concerns about the way [42:02] Speaker H (unidentified): in which we processed the tennis club application and my concern is that i think it i wish that i had thought at that meeting to say look it would be nice to have somebody from the operational side of the tennis club here maybe we should continue it and get them to come and address some or be able to respond to some of these concerns rather than one person shows up and I'm not in any way shape or form questioning the veracity of anything that was asserted to us I'm not but one person showed up And then we jumped on that and May started making demands for some very specific changes to their proposal. Now I'm glad they've had people here tonight who could deal with that. And maybe it's something in the future if somebody's submitting something like this, we want to say maybe just not send the engineer because if there are questions that come up. But I thought it was a and I still think it was a bit heavy for us to in the posture that we had the application in to start strongly suggesting specific changes to their plan. I personally think it would have been better and I wish that I had thought to say it rather than just voting against the motions to say, you know, maybe bring someone back in maybe continue this and bring someone back in to address any concerns that maybe people may be expressing and that's I just wanted to say that I just I felt we got out over our skis just a little bit I think all sounds that all is well that ends well but for the future for me that felt like a learning experience so thank you and I might be [43:59] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, as chair, I mean, over the last 11 years, I mean, we've navigated a lot of those kind of tough moments of very focused comment that can often steer the ship all over the place. And I think just the primary focus of the board is to be as measured and by the book as we can be, but I think we're also a very human board. So the applicant filed a complaint to the town manager about that, and I talked to Alex about it too. Alex wasn't writing us on how we handled it that night. And he was surprised. Why is he being contacted about that? And I was a little taken back because I felt like the applicant went and circumvented the process and rocked the boat and goes to Alex. When typically in the past, the chair has been the avenue that kind of feedback is funneled through. I mean, the quarry or the Hewitt subdivision, whatever the hot topic is at the moment. So I think that was a little circumventing the normal channels that, you know, we go through here. I don't, you know, and then relative to us asking for specific information. I mean, if you look at the motion we made, we asked them to return for more information on 683 and for highway safety and impact on time services. And as we are, we're talking through 683 and talking through, you know, site development and parking, and 683 specifically mentions off-street parking, you know. In the past, we've had specific discussions like that, but we didn't, our motion and final motion and vote on that wasn't for them to return with an updated site plan showing 10 more parking spaces. Basis. It was look at 6A, return with more information for 6A3 and 4. And comparatively to what we've endured through the quarry and Heel Way, especially the quarry when we had a tremendous number of concerned direct abutters. We listened to them. We were very measured with their input. But we had on occasion also asked for very specific information of that the applicant needs to return back to us with. I mean, if it was consultants or amended plans or whatever it was. And I feel like the board has the leeway to ask for that. But we've, again, we've just got to be extremely measured in how we make that ask. And I don't feel like we stepped out of the normal operating parameters with this application. And I didn't get the sense that the town manager thought we did either. [47:27] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I haven't had input from that. This is all me, like, thinking through about this because it just didn't feel right to me. I mean, I would say that given, if you're ever the engineer sitting here listening to us discuss, listening and sitting with us talking about the map and the specific parking spaces and specific areas in which you could put other parking spaces and shuttle buses and the whole thing that actually transpired around that motion, you'd have to, I would think it would be surprising if they would come back and not feel as though they had to do those specific things that we talked about even if they weren't articulated in the motion and I just those are the things that are more focused on us being kind of careful about especially when there was no one else here who could address the complaints there was nobody and like I said, one of the things we could do is when somebody's going to come to a meeting and they've got something like this, maybe think about, depending on your operation, should you be just sending the engineer? Or should you actually have somebody who manages the place or to address operational concerns? I think that would have helped. I think that [48:43] Speaker B (unidentified): would be perfectly reasonable. [48:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. I mean, part of me looks to the applicant and how they could have bettered that presentation. And I think, you know, I think anytime there's an agent who is not the owner, okay, I mean, circumstances are circumstances, but I think the presence of the owner is excellent PR for a project, and especially in the context of public comment. You know, and we would, you know, on those previous, I mean, Meredith knows she was there for all of it on the glory, having, you know, is having the owners there sitting there with the legal team and having a face to the application, I thought was huge. And Meredith, you have your hand up. [49:39] Speaker C (unidentified): I just was gonna say I think the only thing I got, well, we discussed it during that review, that the conversation went from a concern to looking at the site map to proposing solutions. And but when we got to the resolution or, you know, the vote of it, we did back it off from saying that we had solutions for that. I feel like it's a natural human inclination of somebody proses a concern and everybody starts speculating as to solutions to the problem and I, that's the only thing, but we, I feel like you throw ideas around, but it's just when you get to the resolution or asking for more information, that we, that everybody keep in mind of it's not our job is to come up with solutions or proposed solutions. A concern was brought up, we asked them to come back with more information and it was a concern about a specific section of the application. So I feel like it in the end it was completely handled appropriately, but it's it's the inclination to have even discussing having restrictions on the application that there was an inclination to try a suggestion to pass it that night and just put some requirements on the application. But that required that we have solutions when we're not the ones that need to come up with solutions. [51:27] Speaker H (unidentified): Correct. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely correct. And, the, but going back even further than that, when you have, again, I'm not questioning the veracity of the statements that were made about, activity around the club at all. But when you get one person who shows up and makes a lot of very specific and serious complaints and you have no one else, the tendency to simply adopt those as the only version of events can sometimes get you into trouble. And I, again, and I don't need to repeat it again, but if I were the engineer sitting here and I left this meeting, I would think I got to come up with some more parking and I've got to do this and that. I think we were, I think under the circumstances with what a small amount of information we had, we were a little too quick to be too specific about what we think they need to do in order to get us to do business for them. Them and I'll just I'll just live with that and I appreciate everybody thinking about it and [52:31] Speaker A (unidentified): And like I said also well that ends well and I thought it ended well with the specific wording we had final motion and the vote on that you know and it would have been terrible if we [52:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Had just ignored this woman's concerns I mean that's why we're a planning board so that people can bring their returns forward and that we address them you know and it's hard to [53:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Delineate that threshold I mean is it one or is it three or is it five I mean where does the validation begin and end and you know and that's was a major source of feedback to the board throughout the quarry process because everybody had something to say and about the quarry and one person would say one thing and two or three would say something else and you know I felt you know that you know was well we're we're still bored of human beings and we are within often in the context of public Comment and you know you got to wade through that and then you gotta okay you gotta measure where you go with that and that really extended the process of it all but I tell you the town and the and the residents of the town that were affected by that application would have been even more riled up if we hadn't had gone through that. [54:16] Speaker H (unidentified): Right. Fact-finding is very difficult. Fact-finding is very difficult. And what I'm suggesting is we maybe should have done more fact-finding. I mean, we should have asked them to continue it. We should have asked them to continue it and bring somebody in and get multiple perspectives on this and then figure out where we land. [54:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Remember, we gave them three options, too, of how it could play out. And they chose the continuation option, I think, which was the most enabling option for them. And here we are, and they have their approval. [54:51] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I think we're fine. Like I said, all's well that ends well. But just from my thinking about how we process it, I'm going to be trying to in the future figure out ways to figure out how to do fact-finding that helps us get to where we need to go before we start jumping in and proposing changes. And then I'll forget all of that when we're in the heat of the moment, I'm sure. But I appreciate your hearing my concerns. [55:23] Speaker I (unidentified): Any [55:25] Speaker A (unidentified): other motion [55:32] Speaker H (unidentified): to dismiss have a good thanks. I'll second that one. [55:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Motion to dismiss motion to adjourn and seconded it. All those in favor. I did it. [55:49] Speaker G (unidentified): That's cool. Good night. Good night. Good night. Good night. See you, Meredith. I can't see it right now. Sorry. There we go. It was blocked. I couldn't see it. Okay.