← Back to MaineScanner

Bangor Historic Preservation Commission Discusses Viewsheds and Land Development Code

2026-11-12 · 32m · Source: Historic Preservation Commission 11.12.26 (City of Bangor YouTube)
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Unfinished Business
[1:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I need to get in. Yes, there's no camera. No camera? Oh no, now I'm wearing my good shirt. I can put my hat back on. Yes, you can. Okay, welcome to the November 12th meeting of the City of Bangor Historic Preservation Commission. My name is Nathaniel King. You can't see me, but that's who I am. To my left is Katie Coe, and to my right is Rebecca Fretke, and Matthew white camp and peter key point and from the city we have matt altiero and ann krieg there we go i do not have my script to read but so we are going to skip that part and go right into the business of this meeting there are no objections there are not fantastic so first piece of old business i have is the approval of the meeting minutes from the october 8 2026 meeting i will entertain a motion to approve those meeting minutes unless anyone has a correction for them. [2:50] Speaker B (unidentified): I move we approve the October 8th minutes as they stand. Seconded. [2:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. Yes. I abstain. And I vote yes. Okay, they passed. And then the next item of business is adoption of findings and decisions for 28 West Broadway. I [3:14] Speaker C (unidentified): move we adopt the findings and decisions for 28 West Broadway. Second. Yes. [3:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes. Yes. [3:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, that concludes the old business. We will move on to the other business item on the agenda is to discuss view sheds in slash of historic districts. The purpose of this discussion is to get an idea from commissioners of areas they have in mind for important view sheds of historic districts and or sites, as well as how these areas might be treated in the new land development code. I can add some to that. Please elaborate. [3:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Elaborate. Some communities will do things like a corridor designation, you know, like the Broadway corridor, or something like that would require infill development to, even if it's just outside the district, to not impede upon that corridor. Some, you know, because the idea is that, especially in a place like Bangor where you're starting to see a lot of infill, is to make sure that infill is respectful to the scale and historic significance of a corridor. So, I mean, I'm thinking of Broadway for us because that's more of a corridor-like district where your other districts are a little bit more neighborhoods, but still the same kind of concept is there because, you know, as people do those infill projects, just making sure that, you know, that their project isn't sort of overwhelming the historic building next to it. [5:03] Speaker C (unidentified): When you say infill, do you mean like ADUs that are now permissible through the state? Or do you mean, what is that? [5:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Like infill means like somebody has an oversized lot and they're going to add another house on their property. because we 've changed density allowances under the state recent state legislation so there aren't really single family neighborhoods in Bangor anymore so most neighborhoods often have you know some double lots and places like that where they might be able to put an extra house on it in terms of like residential neighborhoods and like in the downtown some communities will do you know like right now your downtown development district does not have a height requirement that really hasn't been an issue, but again, as you know, some infill development even in your downtown happens. Is there a concern in some cities, it's a concern that if there's a high rise that kind of towers over, you know, a three-story historic building next to it, that might be an issue, and it's a balance. I mean, obviously, you know, we want housing in Bangor. As you know, housing is really the top issue that we deal with in economic development and planning, so you know, there's, we have to try to try to do a delicate balance between the two, because you want to see infill, but you also have these historic districts that are really significant and important to the city. So you know, I'm, we're here to try to get some idea from you, like, is that something you want staff to look into making those recommendations in the land development code and the term view shed I [7:05] Speaker B (unidentified): presume it's sort of like a watershed in the sense that it's where you're looking here, yeah. [7:14] Speaker D (unidentified): So if somebody was doing an infill in the Broadway corridor, for example, like when you stand at any point on Broadway and you sort of look west, but yeah, west, most of the houses are about at the same setback, for example. Right. So if somebody was doing an infill, you would kind of want them to respect that same setback, even though the setback requirement might be only 10 feet in that underlying district. So you might say, OK, in the Broadway corridor, we want, you know, infill development to kind of hold that line so that corridor stays intact. [7:56] Speaker E (unidentified): So it's not blocking, like a house that's set much closer to the road, it's not blocking that view of the subsequent houses in that corridor. I think that makes a lot of sense. [8:06] Speaker C (unidentified): But also those would individually go before HPC if they were in the historic district, and therefore could individually be noted to be like, for this particular project, this seems appropriate, or this particular project, this could be pushed back. Is there any reason to have a generalized rule rather than respect the future committee to be able to make the same decision? [8:29] Speaker B (unidentified): You had mentioned the concept of the viewshed essentially maybe not being just in the district, but how it would really reflect on it. Based if you were to say you were putting up a 14-story building with I don't know something you know big fountain on top with something right next to the historic district is that what you [8:54] Speaker D (unidentified): had an idea of yeah well like a place on lower Exchange you know where the courthouses you know if something happened over there that's not really you know there's no historic buildings around it but if you know if something if somebody wanted to do an infill sort of like in one of the parking lots that are right downtown and they wanted to do the 14th story that might be more of an imposition on the buildings around that yeah I think it would be a good idea yeah I think and if it's codified then you get away from what Katie's con comment was yeah how would we [9:39] Speaker E (unidentified): define the view shed for these districts well I guess we should look at your different [9:50] Speaker D (unidentified): districts like the I mean the I think of the Broadway corridor as one just because it is that district really follows a significant sort of corridor that goes right from your downtown out whereas like you know the West Broadway area I mean that's more [10:12] Speaker E (unidentified): of a neighborhood but again a lot of those houses are on Union Street and Hammond right so you know you could you could block yeah so I guess it's kind of looking at those major thoroughfares because within the district you know if someone builds something on Cedar Street you know that's not that comes with HBC but if it's on you know Union Street or Hammond Street on the opposite side so it's not technically within the Whitney Park district then I think we need to kind of find that what the view shed is and then we can move from there and you can use tools in RTIS that [10:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Can help you do that kind of stuff too. We have to look at these sheds and then my day job we look at the projects that we're planning especially some watershed projects and things like that. Yeah sometimes if you have a larger large dam your viewshed might be miles when you're rural. Yeah like an example of like a large tall building it doesn't necessarily have to be in the historic district to compete on the shed of say the standpipe right. You can see it from several different points in the city. So if you're at a point in the city where you can see the standpipe and someone erects a building in between your viewpoint in that standpipe you obstructed the [11:32] Speaker D (unidentified): shed that was the other yes thank you for reminding me because that's the other one is some communities that have a significant steeple or in the case of Bangor might be the standby that there are that there actually are requirements about blocking the views from that because [11:51] Speaker A (unidentified): I would even argue that like your view shed of downtown Bangor say from the bridges that go over across the Bonobo River that views that vista of Bangor from you know from that bridge or whatever if you were to put something that interrupts that vista again a modern apartment complex or something like that now you've kind of created an effect on that on that vista or on that landscape and then it doesn't even get into cultural effects or traditional cultural properties sacred sites so I mean There's there's a lot of components a few more than just like corridor because you know there's there's ways that you can mitigate the corridors and like that we get creative as camp as a commission as a city. Yeah I think going out west how many cell phone towers look like giant pipe trees. Yeah exactly but it mitigates that giant thing on the landscape and does sort of blend in so you're making a good point Nate so I think it's [12:51] Speaker E (unidentified): Like I do think that like the view shed of downtown Bangor like you brought up like the Lord Exchange Street area if someone did put up a 10 or 15 story building like that you could be blocking the view doing one of the steeples of the churches or that would be great housing [13:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Exactly and that's where we've got to find balance. Yeah right it's how do we preserve the viewscape the view shades how do we preserve the best says while still being able to generate [13:26] Speaker B (unidentified): So with the Hbc. Basically, we also try to balance historic issues with the practicality of the situations that you have. It's sort of the same kind of idea, and I like the idea of having something in which there is input on the part of Hbc. regarding viewsheds for historic areas. [13:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, and I think that's where going in with, because I know y'all have GIS folks in the north of the city, is going through GIS and using some of the software and some of the capabilities it has that you can identify in landscapes. And also MHPC is a great resource for this, because any of our projects that deal with landscape effects, we send it to them for review. I think Megan's the one who looks those over. [Speaker E (unidentified): So that's it.] A good thing but we can identify sort of those important moderately important and you know maybe not less important but less important you know areas of where like okay this isn't going to really be an effect compared to well you know Jim Bob wants to put this apartment complex right by the stand by you know whatever so I think we might want it as a community too it's a good point to get way into neighborhoods and stuff like that I think I think public comment on this it would be really important yeah it would be important to have but I think our first step is definition of these areas defining because I mean you could you could get to the nitty-gritty with landscape in these historic districts to where you could say well if you put anything in your backyard that is viewable from the street or goes above your fence line you've now impacted of the viewshed is the way we define viewsheds my line of work is if I have that if that chair is a historic building the middle of this table is a road and I'm standing on the road looking at that building if we put a greenhouse in between the road and that building I've just destroyed that viewshed or impacted that now I have to account for that in the 106 planning if you're in an urban environment it gets much more difficult because now you have multiple structures where we're also looking at not just historic districts we're looking at structures greater than age of 50 years old it can get real snowballing real awesome urban You have many more points of perspective. Exactly, you do. You have the road, you have streets, you have from the structure proper and things like that. So it's, I think, defining what the city would consider the view sheds, defining like impacts. Are we only limiting this to like line of sight of historic districts? Are we limiting this to, are we making it beyond that? Are we talking about, you know, or a direct interruption of the viewshed, or are we talking about like, you know, if I can see the back of Stephen King's house and he wants to clear cut the trees behind it, is that, we consider that landscape effect, and what are we defining as an event for the landscape? Is it just building a structure, or is it, you know, any changes in changing any modification? I think flushing out the left and right lateral limits on it would be good, but I think also looking at how the SHPO office like identifies these effects and how they maybe mitigate them at their level and seeing what might apply to the municipal level. And this is one of those times I don't think we can copy all four of them, so I hope they know what they're doing. Down there we got a lot more district stuff than we have, but we also do, to kids point, we don't want to completely paint ourselves into a corner to where we, you know, we only have three [17:12] Speaker E (unidentified): story complexes. Exactly, but that's, that's where I think the GIS software is really going to come [17:18] Speaker A (unidentified): in handy, is that you can, you have altitudes, you can, you know, build landscapes. Yeah, and I will, I'll ask our FPO what it was she used when she was at Kentucky to do a lot of the watershed viewshed analysis. Did she actually add something that, I don't know if it was a Python script or what it was in NGIS that could use all the aerial imagery and generate these viewshed maps? Apps like the film that was in the films and was freely available. She used it. It was probably free because the government didn't want to pay for things. Use files. Yeah, that's a good idea. If we define like the [17:56] Speaker E (unidentified): the point of the perspective point, like the middle of the Chamberlain Bridge or something looking downtown, we could say like, well, a five-story building doesn't inhibit it really in any way. [18:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. But a 10-story building. Or it could be, you know, is it building is so many, so much size, but are they also like attempting to make it blend with the landscape, right, are they with making that cell tower a pine tree type situation and having to blend with the structures in line [18:23] Speaker B (unidentified): With it, so one of the things, I mean, obviously identifying areas is really important. If you're asking, do we think that there should be, we should be addressing the new sheds regarding historic farmers, I think you're getting the answers from all of us that yes, yeah, that's number one. But two, the concept of developing these, you know, what the viewsheds are, how you define them, where they are. But then the next question is, okay, once you've done that, what is your procedure and protocol in terms of addressing infill that may be obstructive to those things? How do you evaluate it? Who has the authority to look at it, et cetera? In other words, are we saying, you know, if we're talking about historic areas and the views I did there, that should we be expanding for per chance the hbc aspect in terms of including that in the [19:16] Speaker E (unidentified): hbc's, you know, purview, or does that go on any other committees? And you can also codify like [19:23] Speaker D (unidentified): you could say, you know, certain streets, you know, the height requirement would be this, you know, or you have to step back, you know, if it's a, if you are adjacent to a historic district in the downtown, your building has to step back a little bit before you can go to x number of [19:47] Speaker A (unidentified): stories. So I just hollered at the San Francisco rules fpo and she said that in art pro there is a view shed tool in our program you can use. Okay, so the city should be able to either have that or get that. Yeah, be able to take the city, yeah, I'll be able to look at that. Yeah, so you need sort of [20:07] Speaker D (unidentified): a point of, like you were saying, the middle of the bridge, like what is your, what are your points of reference, right, from, yeah, defining those. Yeah, like even with the standpipe, you know, at what points of the city is the view of the stem pipe important to you? Yeah, well, and also it's not [20:27] Speaker A (unidentified): just the human built landscape, it's still natural landscape as well too. So you know, there's, you know, what there is around natural landscape around Bengal, but if there was a view of something, for example the river, yeah, building something out of shrubs, a few of the rivers and things like that, you can take that as a fact natural use case, not just the urban [20:53] Speaker C (unidentified): being all the way able, being able to see all the way out towards Clifton at the top of Union [20:58] Speaker D (unidentified): Street hill and at the golf course, that kind of thing, if you can see it from the Knox bridge. Oh, yeah, I see what you're saying. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. [21:14] Speaker B (unidentified): But I also made like your idea of as developing these ideas, what viewsheds, which areas prioritizing them is important. Yeah. I mean, certainly there are, as you said, the Standpike is a great example. [21:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, and it's national registered listed. It's not just local, but it's a national registered property. [21:35] Speaker E (unidentified): That's all of us standing on the phone. Well, right. [21:39] Speaker B (unidentified): And from the standpoint of prioritizing which structures we would hope to see some sort of regulatory process specific to, that makes sense because it's going to take a while to do whatever we're going to do with this and then defining those things for each is going to take time as well but fine starting with the [22:01] Speaker A (unidentified): ones that most important yeah well and this is also thinking about like what our as a commission left and right lateral limits are you know we're going to kind of be pushing up against that if we have somebody outside of district constructing something but it's affecting the future of something within a district exactly well that's why you have to codify right that's why we need to have that codified in there as opposed to in your yeah because we can't do that as an ad [22:28] Speaker D (unidentified): font no yeah that will get us in a world yeah and i don't know if i even want it to be [22:36] Speaker C (unidentified): a restriction but more like a recommendation like it could be considered like if they are doing these projects that it turns out that somebody realizes it's going to cut off their view that they should be able to be allowed to bring that for the planning board or us and say hey this is cutting off what i appreciate about my city well i think we should be open to that input [23:01] Speaker B (unidentified): but i also think there should be a structure that there is a review of you know any major project going on that may you know yeah it wouldn't be sort of like say only ad hoc if you're [23:12] Speaker C (unidentified): understanding sure it's just i don't know when i think about housing or i think about commercial development in the city i think those are things that we greatly prize and that i don't necessarily want to create a ton of restrictions stopping them from happening yeah but there [23:35] Speaker B (unidentified): there should be a process for dialogue with it with the development of it because there well may be options no things that can be done in a mitigating way of you know the developer whoever's doing it doesn't care about historic [23:51] Speaker C (unidentified): anything and they often have the money but don't want to spend it so having the ability to demand it a little time they wouldn't even come before us they wouldn't even hear our point of view [24:03] Speaker D (unidentified): So maybe there's like around a historic district there's a area of influence, yes it gets created and then you know sort of like what we do with the historic districts when somebody everybody buys a property historic district we have a letter that goes out to them welcome kind of thing and you know maybe we do a welcome letter with the you know area influence like hey you bought you know the Whitney Park you know district and this is why it's significant and [24:39] Speaker A (unidentified): With that GIS tool you could establish those buffers and be like yeah you may not be within then Whitney Farm your property is within the viewshed of said historic district so please understand any construction for any may require some additional review from this renovation commission if it is determined by the city this could constitute a viewshed impact or something like that yeah then you kind of got a slupper zone of where you know if you're like right up close to the district then it's a Little more sensitive so as you get further away and you're identifying those structures where it's like you have a house in the middle of a property a cluster of houses like that's honestly not going to be an effect compared to if I'm across the street from you know the entrance of West Broadway or something like that might be you know a little bit better way than you have on that it's publicly accessible as well the city's GI you can stay in it on that yeah you can stay in it and then You know it helps the city also track what address is parceled over there. [25:43] Speaker E (unidentified): And if we define those buffer zones, we can send, like you said, a letter, but we can also notify them that we're talking about this. [25:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Oh yeah, definitely. We'll do some workshop. I just didn't want to do a workshop until you kind of garnered your interest and tried to figure out what areas are important to you for us to take a gander. [26:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Can we define VISTA's -historic? [26:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Well it depends on if you're looking at the just the historic part or the cultural part I mean Bangor has a historic waterfront the view of that watershed itself is historic the view may have changed yes we don't have boatloads of ships of masts and everything but that vista of the water of the river is still culturally significant and you can make an argument that it could be culturally significant to the Wabanaki or to the pre-contact tribes. And also again, if there are, and I don't know that Baymore has anything, but if they were to be identified, if there were hills or overlooks or anything that were considered sacred sites or sites of traditional cultural significance, we would need to know those things so we can make sure that we're accounting for those in the planning process as well. And those, again, you know, maybe really be identified by members of the tribe and outside nation. So I can tell people when I do the training, they dictate to us, not us dictating to them. Right, no, that's true. But I think you were going to say something. [27:23] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that this is what you said, but more technical terms, that our GIS could be updated to have that information on there the same way that it says it when it's a historic house. [27:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah,, we can kind of trip the meter on, like if somebody's purchasing so I'll be able to I mean obviously you do something in advance but I'm just saying as you go forward yeah we would want to notify new owners yeah and this is [27:51] Speaker A (unidentified): just part of the thanksgiving city you can just ask if you know somebody wants to come into town and tear down a dilapidated building to then build you know something where they want to tear down the hall and build this big you know student housing complex if you see in the south right like okay or don't put that there does that affect the this interview scape or anything like [28:12] Speaker C (unidentified): that right like it's sorry what year was the mall felt is that technically in store 78 [28:18] Speaker A (unidentified): it's only those are out almost you got two years exactly fire it up now get the caterpillars out that's right but I mean still that's right it's just it's things the city can ask and the gis stuff wouldn't be able to incorporate that as a start for the city to be able to kind of understand but you're also going to want to think about those I think it is important to take the natural the natural sites into account because it's still an important part of the city's history and city's character and community and we don't want to think of just like our lived experiences like the past that experience is going that's us starting to get all the way that yeah I'm a big believer that you should take into account the natural [29:03] Speaker B (unidentified): landscape you're doing well if you include you know park areas that are common as well like cascade park or something like that yeah I think I brought all that up when you're talking [29:14] Speaker A (unidentified): About listening to the parks, right? Yeah, what about the, you shut that back? Yeah, exactly, I wrote down parks. Yeah,, okay, so sub-surface impacts almost back, check for the meeting. I said the word archaeology committee, it's on the record now. [29:41] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, but I think, I think everybody will do some more work on it then and bring back some things. [29:46] Speaker E (unidentified): For you to think about, I appreciate you bringing this to us, it's a really important conversation. [29:50] Speaker D (unidentified): To take, well, we'll rewrite, as you know, we're doing a rewrite of the land development code, so this is a good time to have these conversations and, you know, try to get it right. [30:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I will, when I get the information from our federal preservation officer, I'll shoot, yeah, that would be great, that way it kind of gets you pointed in the right direction. [30:14] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I worked in a community where no building could be taller, it was just one church steeple made, you know, the elevation couldn't be over that, it's a very new thing to do. Yeah, it was in Danvers, I thought there was too, I thought you could build a structure over like downtown, there's no higher restriction, yeah, because the telephone building. [30:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Is not so much higher. [30:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Nothing says character of a college town like just apartment complexes as far as endless, all with the same variation of the map name of the past stock, raise your back ridge, the apartments are reading back comments, the comments that raise. [31:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Your back row, well, okay, yeah, so we'll, we'll keep working on this and bring back some more thoughts, more, and then we can talk about if we're on the right track, and if we are, then we can talk about doing a public workshop, yeah, that'll be January, February, we can really start. [31:33] Speaker E (unidentified): Defining the areas. Yeah,, [31:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Good. Defining that archaeological sensitivity in the city of Bangalore. [31:43] Speaker D (unidentified): I wrote that down too. That triggered me when somebody said Wabanaki. I was like, oh yeah, gotta look at those sites. Yeah, you gotta get those archaeological sites. [31:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Yeah, thank you. Amazing. Is there any other business anyone would like to bring from the commission other than get your friends to join? We have one vacant seat. We may have a second vacant seat coming soon, so. [32:14] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't get any established. [32:16] Speaker B (unidentified): You put yourself in the established. [32:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. I'll try. I'll write the leave.