← Back to MaineScanner

Bethel Select Board Approves Liquor Licenses and Forms Community Safety Committee

2026-11-04 · 2h 21m · Source: Select Board 11/04/26 (Bethel Maine Live via W.H.A.T. (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:39] Good evening, everybody. I'd like to call our select board meeting for Wednesday, November 4th to order. We have a quorum with all five select board members here tonight and we're joined by Sharon Jackson, our town manager and Tracy Walker, our town clerk and Courtney McPherson, our code enforcement officer and Jim, you're just Are you 're just here to enjoy the meeting? [1:05] Oh, yeah. I like that. [1:08] [laughter] [1:08] I would introduce you. [1:12] All right. Could you all join me in the pledge of allegiance? [1:18] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [1:31] [clears throat] [1:37] So, our first order of items is to make an adjustment to our agenda and we need a motion to take action to add 8K to the agenda, which is a request by Richard Tumin to be placed on the board's agenda to discuss his notice of unresolved setback violation at 1 Mill Hill Road. [1:58] I'll make a motion to add 8K to the agenda as stated. [2:03] Second. [2:05] Any further discussion? [2:07] I'll do [2:08] I mean I mean it perhaps if it does get put on maybe moving it up a little bit [2:16] Yes. Yes, that's a good idea. [2:18] before we get into the you know discussions that are you know not with other people. Maybe after F maybe? I don't know. [2:30] Mhm. [2:32] Which is [2:32] So you want to call it 8F? [2:34] There is 8F. [2:36] Or 8G? [2:38] Actually I'll do 8G. [2:40] Mhm. [2:40] And then everything else gets [2:43] So I'll amend my motion to add the items to the agenda as 8G and adjust everything below that. Is that all right with you? Do you have anybody else coming who [2:56] No. [2:57] Okay. [2:57] No one else. [2:58] Okay. All righty. so all those in favor? [3:04] But and all those opposed? Okay, so it's four to one. four A's and one nay. [3:13] So Does Oh, it has to be unanimous [3:17] unanimous to add to the agenda. [3:25] So what do we will we have the [3:27] agenda items I would ask that this be placed on the next meeting agenda item. [3:32] Or is that [3:33] Or you could also have him speak under public comment public comment. Does that work? [3:39] Could you do [3:40] It did so it did It has to be a unanimous decision by the board to be added. So the options are [3:48] [clears throat] [3:49] you could talk about it during our public comment time or we can have it on the agenda next time. Or plan to have it on the agenda next time. [3:59] so does talking about it in five preclude being on the agenda next time also? [4:06] No, definitely. [4:08] Sure. [4:12] What was it? [4:13] so, he's going to talk during the public comment time. [4:19] All right. so, we have a Next on our agenda is a public hearing and it's to take questions and or comments to consider a liquor license renewal for the Mountain Laurel, which is located at 43 Main Street. So, I will open the public hearing. [4:43] Are there any questions on Mountain Laurel? [4:49] Seeing none, I will close the public hearing. [4:55] Back to the public hearing. [4:56] [clears throat] [4:56] It's 6:04. [5:03] All right. so, now we are to the public comment time. So, if you could please state your name and the time you're from for the record and So, [5:16] I'm going to have a public comment. [5:17] Is there anything else who's here to make a public comment? [5:22] So, if you would like to do that, you could do that. [5:25] Sure. I'm Richard Duman. My wife Laura and I live at [address], which is right next to the Chapman Inn. And the reason I wanted to be on the agenda is I have a couple of reasons. Do you Do you have the thing that I that I wrote that I sent to you? So, I don't know if you've seen it or not, but basically just the story is that the town issued a permit [5:48] that is guaranteed a violation. The permit The permit was for a 6-ft deck that was to fit into a 14-ft space. And that violated the setback. It was Since it was built as a permit, it can't be appealed after it was built. So, the deck today sits 2 ft inside the setback. [6:10] And my question is what is that the procedure that were that town accepts? So, when I come back, that's that's the answer I'd like to get if I can. What is the town's what duties the town have to enforce the setback after issue a permit to violate it? [6:31] Understood? Does that make sense? [6:35] I think it's I can I I mean, in preparation thinking that you would be on the agenda, I had I mean, I did talk to the lawyer today and I think I told you in an email that we have no authority in this issue. So, there's [6:56] really nothing that we can do. And you went to you went to the appeals board and they made a decision. and they did tell you that the next step is to take your case to if you want to pursue it to go to the superior court. [7:13] So, but okay, I know all that. And I don't I don't deny that the that the appeal was not timely. I do think that there's plenty there's plenty that went on that would definitely make an 80 80B appeal viable, but the reason I was come back is that what the what I understood the appeal board was saying was that I couldn't I couldn't appeal the permit. [7:40] My question is the setback violation a thing that just happens whenever someone gets around that by having a permit for it? And then so, I'd like that question answered. I think it's fair to have that answered. How we have that How was it the town issued its own permit to violate its own [8:01] ordinance? Is that not a reasonable question? [8:05] With all due respect, we really can't help you. It is not in It's not in our word ability to help you. We have to [8:13] I think you could answer the question. And this is longer than I think it is explained. I just wanted to know what you wanted. [8:18] It's not for us to answer. [8:20] You can't answer the question that code enforcement that setback. [8:26] The code enforcement [8:28] officer. [8:28] Right, but [8:29] And so if you had a an appeal on the on based on that permit you got 30 days to go to the code enforcement officer. And if she saw a violation, then she would have brought the violation to us. [8:46] I know it is it is what the law says. It doesn't make sense to me though that someone can get a permit in the first place that violates the town ordinance. That's That I think is worth the investigation on the part of the town. How did that happen? Does it happen all the time? [9:03] Can I speak? [9:06] I think so. according to the lawyer, there was no violation that was issued. The permit The building permit was issued based on the code enforcement officer's decision to issue the permit to build the deck in the same footprint. [9:29] There was nothing showing any setback at the time. And [9:35] I know that. Why is that not the requirement that [9:39] It wasn't required to present that information at the time. And according to the attorney, she has given instructions to as to her opinion that this board cannot discuss that, get involved with that. And just like Sarah said, she recommends that the next course of action has to be for you to appeal your case to superior court. [10:07] But this board cannot get involved in any decision that was made by the appeals board because as far as she is determining is that is over with because the building permit was not appealed after 30 days. [10:29] The building permit was based on a deck that was removed. That deck was never permitted when it existed and was gone for 4 years before they built. I think it's wrong how long and the way that this all went down and I think it should be addressed to this select board. [10:43] But you never brought that information to the attention of the board until after the 30 days. [10:50] So for me, reading everything, getting feedback from people, having calls, walking by the site, this some of this doesn't even pass the straight-face test. And I know as you said to talk to the attorney today, Sarah, [11:11] I'm surprised it was done as an individual, but regardless, one of these things that I would like to see the board do is to talk with our attorney to please explain it further and what is the impact to Baffle? I she's using the Giuliano for a case and I get that. [11:32] You can't There's a building permit and you just can't take it away and do another building permit. But there's seemingly an encroachment there. I don't think any of us can deny that it's within the 10-ft setback. So does that mean you wait 30 days on anything that's applied for, given permission for, approved, you wait 30 days and then there's a violation [11:59] and you don't have an opportunity to address that? [12:02] That it isn't it's being built by the what was in the building It's being built by what was in that permit. [12:11] It's It should be being built. It says right here on the building permit application 10-ft setbacks. I mean when you read it more, it's based on a tax card. It has no property lines put on it. And you traditionally and I don't know what the articulate information is, [12:31] [clears throat] [12:32] but you just don't base it on a tax card. And as far as I understand, there's no grandfathering in land use. So like I think there's a series of things here, but in regards to the attorney and the impact for future I 'd really like her to [12:52] you know, come to a board meeting or have a Zoom to try to understand that. I mean, that's what it seems like to me. And it's and it seems like when you even read the motion that it seemed like that's what the people in the audience at the hearing was hearing from our attorney. [13:12] So I 'd like to learn more about that actually if you just say there. When you read the motion, there's a paragraph in there that the people attending the hearing makes note that the people attending the hearing seem to be partial to the applicant. Most notably, the impact of the advice given by the attorney. [13:33] What does that mean for future applications and approvals? [13:40] What Mary also explained is that there were two There was an attorney at the appeals case representing the CEO and one case we representing the appeals board. Both attorneys ruled on the same thing. All I can tell you is what I gave you that she replied to, but she advised the board not to get involved [14:02] and that you have no authority over this case. The next course of action for this particular case needs to go to superior court to be ruled on. And you have no jurisdiction to make any decisions or get involved in this case. And if you don't want to take her advice, [14:23] then she said that's your choice. But that's why Sarah called her this afternoon. [14:28] Right. That would be nice to hear. That would That would have been the question I would have asked. So, this is I wanted to understand the advice that was given and how it applies in the future. And I would like to put that on our agenda for the next time to have a conference call or have her join us to understand that impact. [14:49] Because in my very simple mind, it sounds like if you don't say anything within 30 days, a building permit what Wait, you have up to 2 years to enact with the building permit. That was really You have 5 years to build within that period. So,, he's like 7 years [15:10] if and if you if they don't start building until year four and there happens to be a violation, does that mean we can't enforce the violation? [15:23] So, maybe you need to go back and the code needs to be looked at the But in going and how future one is acted on is not the same as how this one can now be acted on because, according to the attorney, the case is closed and [15:44] you all know that you cannot get involved in decisions made by the appeals board. [15:50] Right. [15:51] I don't disagree with that either, but I think part of what is being asked here is that we do look into that process. [15:58] Yeah. [15:58] Yeah. [15:59] Try to maybe avoid it in the future. [16:01] And that's what I'm looking at right now. [16:03] And that's that's that's my request. And to it what Well, we have it here and maybe we come back and be on the agenda next time to talk about it more. Is yes, our involvement is we can't go and tell the enforcement officer to go and force something, right? We can't do with that. If the code enforcement officer finds a violation, then they have to bring it back to us and we take on the rest of rest of that. [16:26] So, I understand that. And I don't And that And what I was just asking, I don't think he's doing that. I have two other thoughts. And again, it's not getting involved in this case, but it's learning from it and it's is one that the board consider a resolution. [16:44] Give your opinion. You give a statement on it. It's not getting involved in the process, but you just give a statement. Again, it's it 's hard to walk by there and see that there's not an encroachment. Do we admit that there's an encroachment? just say a statement about it and that's it. [17:06] So, that's something to think about that I'd like to bring back to the next meeting. The other is to perhaps ask a independent third party to look at the whole process. What recommendations What recommendations can come out of it so [17:26] we don't seem to be in this situation. [17:30] I would ask the board to please think about that and we have this as an agenda item at the next meeting. [17:36] I would ask you to think about not the next meeting because Sarah's not going to be here. And I think that would be unfair to Sarah not being here. she's al- already stated that she's going to be on vacation. You're going to be chairing the next meeting. And if this discussed issue needs to be discussed with this a full board. [17:55] Yeah, I think Sarah can speak for herself, but and it's in it's it's it's it's rhetorical. It's rhetorical in that whatever the next meeting is, you know, the attorney and then discuss these and if we want to do the next meeting the first meeting in December, I mean, we may or may not. [18:14] Yeah, so I mean, we may we may have somebody out. Always have somebody out of town during the holidays. [18:18] I mean, right, with that. I think I think the impact that this has had on the town and it's kind of tearing it apart. is there anything of processes that we can look at? I mean, sitting here, we take oaths to uphold the [18:39] code and there's seemingly an encroachment right there. I mean, how do we look in the face of the rest of our town's people? So, spending some time on this, I think is important. the town the town won. What did we really win? [19:01] And I know it might not be something that would help Mr. Mr. Tommen, but I think for me to put it out there to try to look at this, try to improve it, try to learn from it, is, is something that the selectmen can do without being involved directly in the [19:24] I appreciate that, Michelle. I think I've been kind of racking my brain of like, what can we do? Because it does not feel right to recognize that there's an encroachment here and there are things that we cannot do that are not within our power, but what can we do? What is within our power? And I appreciate those suggestions and I think [19:45] even if we even if there's not much we can do in this particular case and I want to share appreciation for how much work you all have done in explaining and outlining everything that has happened. and I think that it is our due diligence to go down those roads, continue to discuss it, and see which of these pathways [20:09] could help us ensure that this doesn't happen again. [20:13] And I'd like to speak on that. I appreciate the suggestions, also, but I do believe that they should be directed to the planning board and not to the select board. The select board does not have a ruling over those items. They never have and they should not. We're two different We're two different boards. [20:36] And as far as the encroachment, [20:39] that was there when the [20:43] building permit was pulled out and you didn't know that then when the building permit was pulled out and you were on the list to be notified of what was being done? [20:53] That's correct. There's no way to know that. There were no There were no dimensions in the packet that was sent to the planning board. There was no mention of the deck at the planning board. [21:04] You didn't know what the setback was on your property. [21:07] Of course I did. [21:08] Well, then that should have been obvious to you then. [21:11] the dimensions [21:12] The building permit was pulled out. [21:13] the If I saw the dimensions on the permit, [clears throat] how would I know that it was a setback violation? [21:20] Because you knew where your setback was. And you're saying that they're encroaching on your on your setback. [21:29] I don't understand that question. [21:33] I know. I do believe that it's a planning board item and it's not it's not a select board. [21:38] She brought it up. I It's I think that [21:42] I know, but I think we aren't I just don't want us to like take it up. [21:46] That's the thing I brought up. [21:47] This situation should not have even come in front of the select board and you've been notified [21:50] quite a bit several times also. [21:53] I know. We shall Do you Did you [21:56] This is a common sense question. [22:00] Are there others? [22:01] Got to say who you are though when [22:02] I am Jeff Black 7 Mill Hill. No butter on the other side. [22:11] My question is when the permit was issued, there were no dimensions aside from it would be put back the way it was. [22:20] Exactly. [22:20] It was not. So, you couldn't appeal it in 30 days because you know where they were going to build it. He didn't have an encroachment on his property until they built it to whatever dimension they wanted because the dimension was not on the permit. The other simple question I have is the code enforcement officer [22:45] an employee of the town of Bethel? [22:50] Yes. [22:51] Yes? Yes? [22:52] Yes. [22:53] You have an employee who's not doing her job. Code enforcement is very simple. [22:57] I'm going to ask the chair I'm going to ask to speak to this and with the permission of the select board the code enforcement officer is not going to be talked about in this room as far as not doing her job because that cannot happen. [23:13] Okay. [23:14] I'm going to recommend to this board that this discussion stop and that the next time you discuss it is in this room with the town attorney advising you of what the legal situation is before anybody gets in trouble. That is my recommendation to this board. Sarah, you're the chair. [23:34] That's my recommendation based on everything Sarah said to you and to me. [23:41] It's not a discussion to be [23:42] think I think we're getting yeah we cannot talk about town employees during [23:47] Thank you very much for your time. [23:49] Yeah. so we will [23:53] And then the public comment I guess. [23:54] Yeah, any other any comment? Okay. Thank you. [23:59] I dismiss. [24:01] You can you're welcome to stay. [24:05] All right, thank you all. [24:06] Yeah, thank you. [24:22] Our next item is the discussion on the minutes from our meeting on Wednesday October 21st. [24:36] Does anyone have any edits? [24:50] One. in item and this might be a little bit nitpicky, but in item G Is it AG 6G? [25:01] AG where we talked about the community safety ad hoc committee well we didn't we did table action. I would love like it to be included that we received positive feedback from department heads that were present. [25:19] Yeah. [25:19] Who I believe were fire, rescue [25:23] school superintendent [25:24] school superintendent and public [25:26] works [25:26] social worker and [25:28] school social worker [25:29] and public works. [25:30] Did you get those? Do you have the list in there? [25:33] Okay. [25:33] Thank you. That's all I have. [25:43] I make a motion to approve the minutes of Wednesday October 21st, 2026 with amendments. [25:51] Second. [25:53] I just have a question. [25:56] I didn't have a chance to look Tracy, were the last minutes with the conditional approval for the October 7th was that addition put in for the approval for the town meeting? [26:11] Say that. [clears throat] Sorry, I'm talking with [26:14] So at the last minutes that we had [26:16] Yeah, I made those changes after that meeting and then did this one. [26:20] Okay, and it's posted, right? Yeah. I didn't have a chance to check. I just wanted to make sure. Is that [26:26] Sure it is. And what I did was crazy. [26:28] in the chain? No,, I [26:30] I believe it's my [26:31] Well, now I want to try to make you [26:34] It's fine. [26:34] [26:35] That was just my question. [26:38] We say They were just a in the staff members president had Shane White, but it's Shane Wilson. So. [26:48] Okay. [26:48] And he's the right guy. [26:52] He didn't make that mistake. [26:54] But it had Well, it had Wilson later, so it's fine. [26:59] And then the only other type Sorry, I should have told you typos earlier, but on 8B, I think it's 16 Spring Street, not Sprint Street. [27:17] Yep. And just on 8L, no. [27:25] Yeah, 8L when we said we're going to do [27:34] sending the ORC request form and ask ORC research the data center ordinance process. Did we Did we set a date for that or [27:44] No, and I didn't set a date for that request yet, either, just so you know. [27:48] Okay. [27:48] I did talk to Jim about it. [27:52] Is there I just since we only have 180 days, I was just wondering if we should pick a time that they would be ready to come back to us. [28:04] But they were We were kind of seeking their advice, right? Whether to pursue or not, right? Is that it? Cuz like have we need more towards like a ban, and we were like so [28:15] They were just going to I thought they were just going to check with other towns to see [28:19] and size and stuff like that and let us know what their Okay. [28:24] thoughts were, right? [28:25] Yeah, I just I mean, I just say if we I wasn't sure if we I feel like with it only being 180 days, we're we're going to need to keep sort of You [28:33] can come back in here sometime. know. [28:36] So, when I talked to it was under the understanding that you were going [clears throat] to be looking at it and then bringing some options back, right? [28:44] Yeah. Yeah, I'd rather not fight them on it just cuz [28:50] I'm hoping I'm hoping the state does something. And then we'll go look into it. [28:58] Okay. I'll be ready. Sorry. To accept the minutes. All those in favor? 5 to 0 and the motion passes. [29:13] All right. We're going to move on to the town manager's report. Meeting schedules. All meetings are subject to being rescheduled. To confirm, check your calendar on the town website. The wreck board meets the first Tuesday of the month at 6:30. Our do the second and fourth Tuesday of the month at 5:30. [29:34] Airport the second Wednesday of the month 4:00 to 6:00 at the airport. Conservation the fourth Wednesday of the month at 4:00 p.m. Planning board the second and fourth Wednesday of the month at 6:00 p.m. However, the next planning board meeting will be Thursday November 12th at 6:00 p.m. due to [29:56] Wednesday the 11th being Veteran's Holiday. The select board meet the first and third Wednesday of the month at 6:00 p.m. Comprehensive plan meetings the next will be November 19th and December 17th. I forgot to add 17 in there again. 5:30 to 7:00 and those are Thursday night. [30:20] The [clears throat] next Board of Assessors meeting is next Thursday. excuse me, next Wednesday next Thursday, November 12th. Town department enclosures. Wednesday, November 11th, all town departments will be closed for Veterans Day. Wednesday and Thursday, November 25th and 6th, all that town departments will be closed for the Thanksgiving [30:44] holiday. Thursday, December 24th, all town departments will be closed at noon and closed Friday, December 25th for the Christmas holiday. In your packets, I've included the warrant number 23 for payroll dated 11/3, the monthly department [31:04] I had reports for October. public works, last meeting I gave you the rest of them. July through October monthly financial reports. The election results that Tracy printed off today, those have been posted on the town website. [31:24] And I would like to thank the three clerks from the office and the election workers for their efforts working at the polls until midnight last night. This was a very long day for what they had to do and what they did was appreciated. I also contacted Major Da- Dana Thomas Thompson after our last meeting [31:48] at the Oxford County Sheriff's Department and asked if he could send copies of incident reports he did when [clears throat] we had patrol coverage. He did send me the law incident total report from June 1 26 through October 26, and the law incident total report [32:10] by reported offenses from January 1 of 2026 through October 20 6 of 20 6 and I gave you hard copies in your packet. Yesterday, I called Major Thompson at Oxford County to talk to him about an incident that happened at the polls yesterday [32:32] and I did let him know about that yesterday. I asked for coverage at the polls due to safety reasons for the employees there from noon until 8:00 p.m. last night. The coverage wage is a $111 an hour for that. [32:53] after what happened at the polls the warden did call the county to report the incident and the individual was asked to leave the voting area. He then came here and proceeded to start in here. I had to go out and intervene when he was verbally [33:16] being abusive to one of the four of us that was working in the office here. so I called to see about getting coverage. Major Thompson did have the deputy that was assigned to this area by the county to come over to the the polling area and stay unless he had a call he had to go out on before noon time. [33:41] He said that he had put two workers on from noon until 8:00 last night in case anyone required assistance at the polls. and I did lock the front door after that gentleman left here yesterday because everyone was afraid that he would come back based on everything he was saying. [34:06] the Conservation Commission installed the window dressers which are inside storm windows. That's a fancy version of what they're called today. [34:16] They're right there. [34:16] What I'm talking about they were called storm windows on the outside. but you can see them right there. They look pretty good. they installed the blinds in all the windows in the back room where the citizen is and they've installed some of the ones in here. And they'll finish the other ones that will be installed in the next week or so. [34:39] Thank you. [34:42] Thank you, Sharon. Any questions for Sharon? [34:47] So, I was I was like, "Wait, Jayce. Like, this is going down in the place." Did he come back in again? [34:54] No. [34:55] No, he screamed out in the parking lot. We were on the phone [34:57] phone with the state at the time about the whole issue and the state [34:59] Yeah. [35:00] heard him. [35:01] Yeah, he was he was gone by the time I finished voting. He was he was long gone. And you were you were looking for John and [35:09] called the police and the [35:10] So, I just wanted to say, I think you've handled it well. you're you guys when I came in, I mean, everybody just kept moving and it didn't really disturb anything. So, it was good and you tried to talk to him and voices started to raise and we didn't [35:26] He can't [35:27] Yeah. Yeah. So. [35:28] a fun thing. [35:29] Hey,, I appreciate and that's the only thing you [clears throat] can do is to call the police. [35:38] observation and some feedback that I had and I appreciate that police be there for safety first. But, I did have a little bit of feedback that some of the voters were a little bit intimidated with the deputy sitting there. Just FYI, I just That's a little bit of feedback that I had. [35:59] when they went to go vote. And just ironically $111 an hour and whatever Sharon had in the email, $888 for the day or afternoon, if we had a deputy here already at 171,000, that's probably about $470. [36:21] That would have been cheaper for the day. So, just a comment. Thank you. [36:28] So, just to respond to all of that, a lot of towns there were notices given out during the election time that due to safety reasons towns might want to think about having police coverage at their elections due to a lot of these things going on. [36:52] A lot of towns who have their own police departments, they chose to have an officer there. I voted in the town I live in, there was an officer stationed at the door and I think knowing what does go on it does make [37:12] I can appreciate somebody feeling intimidated but I think the safety factor of the workers comes is very important. And I had [37:22] so scared. I mean honestly cuz you don't know I mean the things that he said when he was out it you can't it was very scary. And I usually take quite a bit but I honestly didn't know if he might come back and there was a lot of people in there not only my me and the girls here but do we have volunteer you know there was a lot of people in there. [37:43] I'm I thank them for coming and anybody came in they you know I think I heard one or two people saying oh there's cops here and then other people go yeah well don't you expect this day and age or should be you know but I mean it gave us more peace of mind we still were worried all day but just on our it would [38:01] My comments weren't made to make you [38:04] just wanted to say our side that we want to say thank you. We appreciated it. It made us feel better about being there all day. Yeah I mean it just cuz I would what do you do weird you don't have any weapons [38:16] You handled it well and yes I'm just providing some feedback that I had gotten back from some constituents that's all I'm doing. [38:25] And I think this is something that the public safety committee could also consider of thinking about like is this the kind of thing we would want to set up regularly or is there some is there a is there a different alternative like there are folks who are trained in de-escalation who aren't necessarily cops who would have that same intimidation factor [38:46] but making sure that you all have someone that you can defer to cuz you've got your hands full enough. [38:52] Yeah. [38:53] And beyond just the situation, having someone who is trained in de-escalation and able to handle that situation is really important. So, I think these are the exact kind of scenarios that we're hoping to have like preemptive plans for. [39:09] And I agree with that. I think that's a good idea. but given the situation as it unfolded [39:16] Yeah, not critiquing the decision. I think that was the decision that needed to be made. [39:20] And I'm thankful for you guys for having the conversation. [39:22] I think it probably would see less intimidation if it didn't happen to be a sheriff's election, too. That probably that may I don't know, it may have played a role in there. [39:31] Yeah. [39:32] Yeah. [39:32] Their perception of what was going on. I but the other thing if we wanted to plan ahead, if we do want that, we can obviously reach out to the sheriff's office, but we could also try the state police. they would it would be just as expensive if not more, but that would be an option, too. But I agree. I think it was what you guys did was absolutely fine. [39:55] It's the It [clears throat] was their only option. [39:57] Yeah, and you handled it well and that's great and we'll look at it in the future. [40:03] When I stepped in, the officer was not really obviously sitting [40:07] I think it was a cruiser out front. [40:09] -huh. [40:09] Oh, and Did they park [40:11] No. [40:12] I think [40:12] Well, when they came back, they switched. [40:16] Okay. All right. [40:18] We would have been criticized if we didn't have any police officer there, too, so it doesn't really matter which way we go. [40:27] All right. thank you, Sharon, for your reply. We're going to move on to business item just [40:33] a quick question. So, has the airport rescheduled or are they going to still meet on [40:38] No, they're still going to meet. [40:39] Okay. All right. [40:41] Yeah, actually what they're going to They're not having a meeting. What they're going to do is have a workshop. [40:49] And that plan is no not sorry. The conservation commission is meeting on the Monday the 23rd the in November because the office is closed on Wednesday the 25th. The 24th. Whichever it is. Okay. So Monday 11/23. [41:10] And that sorry I have the calendar so it's all set. [41:12] Okay. [41:14] All right. [41:15] [41:17] So business item 8A we need to take action to approve a liquor license renewal application for the Mountain Social located at 43 Main Street. [41:28] So moved. [41:30] Second. [41:32] Any questions about the application, comments? [41:38] The only The only comment if the applicant was here was to I think this is the one. It is No, wait. This is not the one. No comment. [41:53] Are we ready to vote? All those in favor? Five to zero and the motion passes. [42:05] we're going to take action to approve a liquor license renewal application for Steam Mill Brewing located at 96 Sunday River Road. [42:13] So moved. [42:14] I'm sorry I didn't hear [42:16] Who said they moved [42:17] Second. [42:18] Okay. [42:20] Any questions or comments on this application? [42:23] Yeah, this is just a comment if James was here I would and he probably knows on his state of Maine BLT license here it has Albany Township Maine 04217. [42:42] But I think that's where he lives. That's where we send all of his bills to. [42:46] 96 Sunday River Road, Albany Township, not Maine. It's the license goes to the location. And that often happens. When you put 4217 and you get Bethel and Gilead. So, that is just a I'm sure he knows that he knows it, but that's it. [43:04] I may I have a question. Do they actually brew still on Mechanic Street? Does anybody know? [43:11] Last time I talked to them they were, but that was [43:13] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They don't They don't do anything down there anymore. [43:18] [snorts] [43:23] Ready? [43:23] Okay. [43:24] All those in favor? 5 to 0 and the motion passes. [43:30] we have ABC action to appoint Lloyd Sweet W. Sweetser to the Board of Appeals through December 31st, 20 28. And you have his application in front of you. [43:55] This is the only opening on the board. The other four positions are filled. [44:06] I'll make a motion to appoint Lloyd Sweetser to the Board of Appeals. [44:11] Second. [44:14] I have that just a question about the Board of Appeals. Do they only meet when there is an appeal? [44:20] Yes. [44:22] And they don't meet cuz I watched the recording of the Appeal Board meeting. It sounds like they hadn't met since 2024. [44:29] It's been probably 2 and 1/2 years. they have been the next Board of Appeals and Planning Board training is December [44:42] 12th, maybe. It's It's in December. And Emma sent all of them the information. They're all going to be Well, three of them so far have committed that going to be attending that training. Board of Appeals manuals have been have been ordered for all of the five that are on the Board of Appeals. [45:05] There are four currently who will get the Board of Appeals manuals. And I did talk with them. And recommended that they all take the training. And also let them know that the appeals board manuals have been ordered for them and they would be called when they come in. [45:27] Great. [45:28] That's great. [45:29] Yeah. [45:29] Thank you. [45:30] You're welcome. [45:35] Just a comment, he's applied for two positions and I thank him for that. I think with his background for me he fills a need for the community in the budget committee. So I'll probably voting no on the appeals one, but [45:55] next one I'll be voting for placement. [46:00] She share the love. [46:01] Share the love. [46:02] You're feeling like there shouldn't someone shouldn't be on multiple committees? [46:06] Yeah, I just want to share the love. Yeah. [46:08] And he's got he's got the he's got the background that can serve us the community better. What is [46:14] Do we have somebody else for Board of Appeals? [46:17] Can I speak on that? We have had this opening now for quite a while as we have had several committees that have several openings. It's not as if people are lining up at the door to fill these. And I personally feel that it's important if somebody applies for a committee, we have other people who are on more than one committee. [46:41] And unless we have a policy denying that I'm sorry it disagrees with what you say Michelle, but I think that it's important to fill the committees so that they're not open because then we run into situations. We almost had a situation with this appeals board meeting where we were not going to have a quorum because one of the board members [47:04] was going to be disqualified because of the relationship with the appellant. So, it's important to have a full committee. So, I just wanted to offer that. [47:14] Thank you for your full feedback. I was I was just stating my thoughts and people can vote the way they want to vote. Right. And I don't even have to None of us have to offer an explanation of how we vote, but I wanted to. [47:28] Thank you. Are we ready to vote? All those in favor? [47:35] All those opposed? And so, the motion passes four yays and one nay. [47:44] Now, we're going to move on to take action to appoint Lloyd W. Sweetser to the budget committee through December 31st, 2027. [47:54] I'll make a motion to appoint Lloyd Sweetser to the budget committee. [47:58] Second. [47:59] Any further discussion? [48:02] All those in favor? Five to zero and the motion passes. Thank you. [48:09] Now, we're going to take action to accept the resignation of Travis Woolsey from the planning board and the budget committee effective October 3rd, 2026 and you have a copy of his resignation letter on the table. That's was in your original packet. [48:30] if you wanted to give me a minute to read it. [48:36] I did make you aware of this at the last meeting because he had given it to me before the last meeting and I wanted to let you know that he had sent the email resigning from both committees because he is going to be moving. And I let you know that it would be on the agenda this week to accept it. [48:58] I'll make a motion to accept the said resignation. [49:02] Second. [49:04] Any further discussion? All those in favor? 5 to 0 and the motion passes. [49:13] We're going to take action to accept the resignation [clears throat] of Corina Walter from the Bingham Farce Committee effective October 27th, 2026 and you have that resignation email in was in your original packet. [49:29] make a motion. [49:31] I'll make a motion to accept the resignation. [49:34] Second. [49:35] Any further [49:39] comments or questions? [49:43] All those in favor? 5 to 0 and the motion passes. [49:49] Okay. [49:52] And now we are going on to 8. Sorry, I read off that I didn't say there was a wrong number. [50:01] No, we didn't [50:01] No, because we didn't think right. Never mind. Sorry. I thought all the resignations So we have another one, right? We have another one, right? But it's not on the agenda. [50:12] What one? [50:13] Scott Frazier. [50:14] Oh, no. That's That's Brad Walters. That's the Water District one. [50:18] That's under J. 8 J. [50:20] It's for the [50:21] Okay. Well, if that's all the resignations, I just wanted to thank all of them for their time and the work that they put in. I just publicly appreciate that. [50:32] Thank you. [50:39] all right. So, we're on to 8G, which is action to approve the proposal for the Community Safety Ad Hoc Committee. [50:51] Did you make any changes? [50:54] I did not make any changes. [50:57] No changes, but we just need to approve it at this meeting. [50:59] Yeah, I would like to [51:03] I mean obviously the timeline is not going to be as written. cuz the timeline had us had the committee starting in September. I still think I don't I was looking at the other day I don't think we need to bump things in the timeline. but [51:22] I would like to propose that we edit the timeline to just say because it's technically November. in phase one where it says September to October 2026, just change that to November 2026. Select board adopts the charge, appoints members, and holds an organizational meeting. [51:43] [51:46] So it's from September to November and you'd make that [51:49] I can make that change. [51:50] And then send that. Okay. [51:52] And then would the next line still be November through January or [51:58] [52:00] Yeah, actually you know what? Let's collapse those two and just say September through January 2026. Select board adopts the charge, appoints members, holds an organizational meeting, and committee begins stakeholder interviews. So we'll just collapse all of that and not try to designate exactly when those pieces are going to happen. [52:20] Does that work for everyone? [52:22] That's okay. [52:23] It's a projected timeline. [52:25] Yeah. [52:25] Right. It could make that ebb and flow. [52:27] Right. Yeah, I just don't want the committee to start [52:30] feeling like we might be behind. [52:32] And so would you propose it's okay to approve it based on changing a proposed timeline that still could change, too? [52:40] Yeah, I think so. [52:42] Okay. [52:42] Yeah. [52:46] I hope that's okay with that. [52:51] I good to make a motion on that. [52:59] So I 'm approving to [53:03] accept the proposal put forth for the committee. safety ad hoc committee with that one timeline? [53:13] I second. [53:15] Any further comments? [53:18] All those in favor? Five to zero and the motion passes. Can I get a copy of that? [53:25] Thank you for doing that, by the way. [53:26] Yeah. Yeah, of course. Thank you all for your input. It's very helpful. [53:31] Now we just have to do it. [53:32] Yeah. [53:34] and then our next A H is to approve a community safety ad hoc committee and how many members to appoint to the committee. [53:45] So I think what we talked about at our last meeting was to use the regular application form, committee application form. and [53:55] looking at the list, we're thinking seven to nine members. So we'd want to have one member from each of these four seats. and then our other additional members would be school counselor, [54:16] behavioral health professional, and then community seats. Does that all sound right? [54:22] Yes, it does. So we would need to approve seven to nine members and make two to three of them open to have to the commit to the community and they fill out the application. [54:40] I think we have everyone except for the four seats, we probably I guess we can kind of decide, do we want to have everyone apply? Fill the application. I think our process typically has folks fill out the application. [54:54] Yeah. [54:54] So we maybe shouldn't wave that. [54:56] Yeah. [54:57] I wouldn't. [54:57] So we would have everyone So we would have everyone, even the seats would fill out [55:02] the application. [55:03] You don't think so? [55:04] No, it would just be a split. Well, for me, what I propose is they inform that select board that they separate four C, fire C, that EMS rescue seat, and it sounds like they want some sort of law enforcement seat. And then I would [55:25] you know, the fifth seat I would collapse the school counselor behavior health into one. That makes five. And then I would put two at large. So, you have a committee of seven. [55:41] So, to add on to that, Mark Kenny, he he had recommended And what was her name that was here? [55:51] Kristen [55:52] Kristen Powell, because she's the you know, [55:55] [clears throat] [55:55] she's in that position at the school and does all of this. [55:58] Mhm. [55:59] So, I think it might be a good option because she's willing to do this with Mark. [56:05] Great. [56:05] That those two not do Well, Mark wouldn't do an application anyway. [56:10] No. [56:11] But, Kristen wouldn't also do an application. She would fall into that position. [56:16] if she does the school counselor behavior health professional, that would be number five. So, the first five not have an application. [56:26] Yeah. [56:27] And then we just accept applications for two at large. And that makes a committee of seven. It's an odd number. It doesn't start to grow I think getting too more large than that. Doesn't mean that they can't bring in resources or you know, and stuff, but [56:47] But, you don't think having like a substance use professional I feel like that is a good idea to have [56:53] I think we're saying that Kristen and [56:55] Spillane [56:56] Yes. [56:57] Cuz she is. [56:57] But, I think that I think we could I'd like to maintain a flexibility. I agree with everything about the seats. I think we would appoint Those would be appointed recommended by the agencies that they're representing or the corners that they're representing. I'd like to maintain some flexibility with the exact number that we're appointing. [57:19] just based on the number of applications we get, who we get. I think it would be interesting to try and seek some additional applications from someone who has the behavioral health substance use maybe outside the school. so that we have multiple perspectives there. [57:39] That I guess that's what I was asking about is I think Christine would be great at this the kid perspective but [57:47] I think there's a couple of them at the health center. [57:50] Mhm. [57:50] Yeah. [57:51] I can reach out there. [57:52] And yeah, there's definitely [57:54] So how many if we post this online that we're looking for community members are we going to say how many we're looking for at large? [58:07] I would say it's still two to three. [58:08] Two to three? [58:09] I wouldn't open it up much more than that. That still keeps us within our seven to nine window. [58:14] I mean cuz you may not get anyone from the fire department who wants to do it. Or we obviously don't have a police department so but I do think we could still use these and that's kind of I guess how I envision it was just using these as criteria. And so if we had 10 people we could you know narrow it down with some of that but [58:35] I think that's fine. I think it makes sense to leave some flexibility because again if somebody if we don't fill it from the fire department then we might as well fill that seat [58:45] with somebody else. [58:46] with somebody else who maybe they're a retired firefighter. [58:48] Right. [58:49] Well it would it would have a fire background. I mean and I appreciated Dave's review of that saying that the these are institutionalized [59:00] perspectives which are important and that's why I would look at the five appointed takes care of that is very important and then the two at large. It's nice to let the public know we're doing two, we're doing three. This is what we've got put in [59:21] and I just like being clear and concise to the public so it doesn't cause any confusion later on. That's all. [59:31] So, I think sounds like we're on the same page. I think what we want to do is send out specific invitations to each of these institutions to basically appoint who they want in their seat. and then we want to invite Kristen Powell to be a part of it and then we also want to start [59:52] advertising for the two to three at large seats. Does that sound right? [59:57] How are we going to get the law enforcement representative? [1:00:03] That's a great question. [1:00:05] How are we going to get the law enforcement rep? [1:00:08] Yeah. I did ask that question. that we were looking for someone. I haven't gotten an answer back yet but [1:00:17] Go to the county? [1:00:17] Yeah. [1:00:18] Okay. I think maybe we can get an interest. [1:00:22] Well, that might be one that gets again, that's why I said retired or something. That one you might just end up filling with your three or two seats. [1:00:34] So, yeah. I guess [1:00:36] And I will try to attend some of this but I just I can't be on the committee. I don't have time so But I would like to participate and if you guys have questions and stuff, I'm happy to. And if you're if you're doing a meeting where you're going to specifically be talking about law enforcement stuff, I certainly love to be there so [1:00:56] So, that's the other way to be able to do it is [1:01:00] [clears throat] [1:01:00] have four designated seats not have the law enforcement [1:01:09] seat designated have three at large and then invite who law enforcement. might get more participation from them if they're invited to certain meetings. It's another way to [1:01:27] It's a fall I mean it's a fall back, which we can definitely do if we don't get the seats filled. which I think we can do for any of the seats if we don't get them filled or if someone has to drop out or anything like that. [1:01:44] But I'd like to since this is what we voted in, I'd like to try and [1:01:47] Right. So, maybe we have [1:01:52] Then for me, I propose going back to our five and two at large. [1:02:02] But I thought we were going to look for a substance abuse substance use professional. Would that be one we appoint or and we go out and find or do we put that in as we're looking for three at large with one of them with hopefully one person having expertise in behavioral health and substance use? [1:02:28] Or [1:02:30] or maybe we have four designate like the school counselor could be the up in the top four and then the we could say we're looking for four at large and we hope that two of the four [1:02:45] one would have experience with law enforcement and the other [1:02:53] behavioral health and substance use. [1:02:57] I don't want to get too complicated. [1:02:59] I think a lot of this is going to depend on what applications we get. I think it makes sense to reach out to these four institutions, let them know that there are seats on this committee should they want to fill them. And then seek to fill the other additional pieces that we said that we wanted to fill here. [1:03:21] and I think reaching out to the health center is a great idea for the behavioral health. [1:03:25] I think that's an important [1:03:27] Yeah. [1:03:27] important one. [1:03:28] I agree. and then [1:03:31] And I don't see a problem with going for two to three seats [1:03:34] Yeah. [1:03:34] at large. I really I don't see a problem with that. [1:03:37] Yeah, I think we're kind of splitting hairs a little bit. [1:03:39] Yeah. [1:03:39] And I'd like to get this out and moving and see what we get back and [1:03:44] The other piece to to keep in mind is rescue fire. They all have training and such and some of this behavior or the substance abuse and stuff like that. So I just FYI. They come with a lot of background and training those positions. [1:04:08] So Mark Kenny did commit that he would serve on this committee. So did Kristen. She's a social worker in the school and I think that's important. And Dave was the chief of rescue. He is the one that wants to fill this seat. I have not talked to Mike, so I don't know what [1:04:30] He If I recall correctly, he said he or somebody [1:04:35] He would [1:04:36] somebody to do. So I think we invite them and say now's the time. And count on those roles being those seats being filled. [1:04:54] So then it's one So then it's Kristen. [1:05:05] Mhm. So we basically have four mostly committed [1:05:10] Yeah. [1:05:10] participants between Mark Kenny Dave someone for fire and Kristen Powell. [1:05:18] Right. [1:05:18] And that's what I was saying, if we had those four are kind of committed, then we have four other seats that we can open up. Yeah. But, we may want to like kind of like we did with comprehensive plan, like if you have some expertise in this, that would be really help- like maybe we just list some of these things. [1:05:40] Mhm. [1:05:40] If the If you have expertise, that would be very helpful. [1:05:45] So, if we just posted on the news section that we're looking for [1:05:51] anyone who's interested in being on this committee to fill up an application. [1:05:55] Oh, yeah. [1:05:56] And then once you get your applications, then you can decide how many you want to put on and who has qualifications and who does. [1:06:02] Just put this on the [1:06:03] How about that? [1:06:04] Yeah, just if they read this, then they'll definitely know what to do. [1:06:08] All right. I'll do that. I'll do that. And I'll wait till you send that to me, and that's how we'll do it. [1:06:13] Can we say I was thinking about timeline, does it feel reasonable to say if applications are due November 25th, that gives two weeks two full weeks. And then we could look at them at our meeting on December 2nd. [1:06:31] Does that feel reasonable? [1:06:31] Yeah. [1:06:32] Great. [1:06:33] Isn't that a holiday? Is that going to mess up if we have any holidays in there? [1:06:37] Oh, yeah, the 25th is the 25th. [1:06:40] It's the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. [1:06:42] Are we not meeting that day? [1:06:44] The 25th? [1:06:44] No. [1:06:45] No, we don't meet on that day. That's the 25th. [1:06:48] Oh, right. [1:06:49] Right. So, I would do that Wednesday before Thanksgiving. [1:06:52] I think that's what that day is. [1:06:53] Is it? [1:06:54] Yeah, the 25th is the Wednesday. [1:06:55] Yeah, it should be. [1:06:57] Okay. [1:06:57] But, they're due that day. [1:06:58] And we don't have a meeting that day. [1:07:00] No, we're not meeting till December 2nd. So, that would give us time to receive them. Actually, Thursday, November 25th is Thanksgiving Day. [1:07:10] So, maybe the 26th. [1:07:11] The 24th or the 25th. [1:07:12] No, we're off. Do you have a calendar handy? [1:07:17] So, [1:07:20] The is the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. Are you Are you all back in here on Friday after Thanksgiving? [1:07:29] No. [1:07:29] No, it can't be. [1:07:30] No, that's too soon. [1:07:31] So, when would we [1:07:32] So, I've got those dates wrong on my report. [1:07:35] Well, you have Wednesday and Thursday. [1:07:37] No, but we're off Thursday and Friday. [1:07:40] Oh. [1:07:41] Oh, so you are here Wednesday. [1:07:43] Yes. [1:07:44] Okay. So, if we make them When were you thinking if you had thought about this, when we would get our packets for that December 2nd meeting? We definitely [1:07:56] I don't know what you're [1:07:57] Yeah, okay. [1:07:58] [laughter] [1:07:58] It's reasonable. [1:07:59] Because I'm taking Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday off of that week. [1:08:03] Oh, of the that Thanksgiving week. [1:08:06] Yeah, I always take that week off. [1:08:08] What if we make them due that Friday? And we would receive them that Monday, and we could review them for our meeting on Wednesday. [1:08:16] Most likely you would get your packets that week on Monday. [1:08:19] Does that seem affordable to the second? [1:08:20] I think you'd get them [1:08:22] They could come in by that Wednesday. They could come on a Wednesday. You don't need to be prepared by then. [1:08:25] Oh, right. No, I would That's why I Yeah, that they you know, they came on [1:08:30] Wednesday. [1:08:31] [laughter] [1:08:32] Let's just keep [1:08:33] Keep it Wednesday. [1:08:35] So, I need to adjust that. [1:08:36] but we may not see them till that Monday. [1:08:38] We wouldn't see them till Monday. [1:08:39] Right. So, we'll keep it due Wednesday the 25th, cuz that's the last day that office is open. And then we will likely see them that Monday. [1:08:48] Works for me. [1:08:48] Great. [1:08:51] Thanks, Joe. [1:08:52] So, [1:08:53] So, this will go on latest news, and should we do a Facebook? [1:08:58] We'll We'll put it on the town website, and we'll put it on Facebook as well. [1:09:03] And do you want to also reach out to these department heads to just get contact information? [1:09:08] Yes, I will. [1:09:09] That's great. and for the health center, I can do that outreach if that's helpful. [1:09:17] Yeah, okay. [1:09:24] Seriously, sorry, one other thing. If anyone knows and Andy I'm specifically looking at you for like retired or like folks who are involved in law enforcement somewhere who might be a good fit if you want to think about outreach like targeted outreach there. [1:09:41] Yeah. I will. [1:09:43] They don't have to be from Bethel. [1:09:47] I would say like Oxford County. [1:09:49] Yeah, I it'd probably be best but at the same time [1:09:52] Yeah. [1:09:53] I don't think so. [1:09:54] Yeah, I think [1:09:55] Yeah. I think the active duty guys are their schedules are too crazy and they I mean we could add there are some that live in town. [1:10:02] Mhm. [1:10:03] But I not optimistic that they'd be able to do it cuz their schedules are just all over the place but I'll certainly ask around. [1:10:12] Mhm. [1:10:12] Right. [1:10:13] So Pat brings up a good point. I think we just assumed these people would be from Bethel but law enforcement could be from Oxford or from the county. [1:10:30] Okay. [1:10:31] All right. [1:10:31] Mhm. [1:10:32] Okay. And then I guess we can't really say that either because Kristen Powell doesn't live in Bethel. [1:10:43] But she's a South 24 [1:10:45] Mhm. [1:10:46] representative or [1:10:47] Mhm. [1:10:48] Yeah. So these would be for the whatever the two three four seats whatever you're looking for. [1:10:56] I was kind of thinking I would look for somebody who wasn't who lived in Bethel to serve on it but not necessarily somebody who worked like in Bethel like if they live here but they work in you know Oxford Boston [1:11:09] Or vice versa or something. I mean yeah. It's the it's the expertise as far as the law enforcement that we're looking for. [1:11:17] And this is something that came up in all of our conversations around the county contract which is like this is not just a Bethel conversation. And I don't think we're necessarily cuz it's tricky because part of it is geared towards what needs to be in the Bethel budget. That's That's like the ultimate goal of the outcome of the committee. [1:11:38] But the conversation can't be restricted to just Bethel. So [1:11:43] No, and I foresee that part of it part of this whole timeline will be a conversation potentially with the regional pieces. But again, just for me when I'm putting that into the public to be as clear as possible of what we're looking for and they have the expectations. It's [1:12:03] I don't know. My experience is unmet expectations is the is the worst thing. [1:12:10] [laughter] [1:12:12] Is this something that we should bring up at the the joint select board meeting? [1:12:22] Yeah, definitely. Are you not I think we've mentioned that we're doing this. [1:12:28] Maybe we should address it at the next one which is what January [1:12:32] January, yeah. December. Yeah. [1:12:38] Okay. So then [1:12:42] So we would be making a motion to accept a And how we I guess I [1:12:49] I don't know if we need a motion. [1:12:50] Okay. Well [1:12:51] Do we? [1:12:52] To start to [1:12:54] to approve the amendment any meeting numbers? [1:12:58] But that's in the proposal that we're [1:13:00] an ad hoc committee. So it probably is best that we identify the ad hoc committee. Its mission is in here. Its scope and mission and timelines are here. [1:13:14] And I would think that [1:13:15] Just hoping the ad hoc committee with no number of people. You're going to determine that basically after you get the applications. [1:13:24] It sounds like it. I disagree that approach, but I'm just one. [1:13:30] We made a motion to approve that. Yes. Yes. So I think that's it, right? It lists the range of committee members. I this is the proposal. This is the proposed committee composition. I think our charge, if you look back at things, is that we can form an ad hoc committee. And I think we need to form that. [1:13:52] Its scope and timeline is this. And that probably get put in a motion. So I'll make a motion to establish a community safety ad hoc committee charged with researching and reporting on the town's actual community safety needs as outlined in the approved proposal. [1:14:13] Second. [1:14:15] Is there any parameters for what we're looking for? Is it seven or nine or what? [1:14:25] And to establish a committee of seven to nine members as outlined in the proposal. [1:14:34] Second. [1:14:37] Is that okay? [1:14:38] Yeah, I mean we're we're already determining that what, three or four of them are Again, I just looking for clarity. [1:14:48] So four of them [1:14:48] I mean if people we get 20 applications of people saying you got seven to nine members and then they come and we're like, yeah, but we're we already have four because we're planning That's all. That's all I'm saying. I know I'm being picky, but it's clear clarity for the public. [1:15:05] Yeah, so that we're approving that. [1:15:09] seven to nine members with two to three at large. [1:15:14] Yes. [1:15:15] And the rest identified by how we how we select [1:15:20] So okay, just to restate the whole motion. [1:15:23] Hopefully that is recording, right? [1:15:25] All of this is recording. making a motion to establish a community safety ad hoc committee charged with researching and reporting on the town's actual community safety needs as outlined in the proposal and establishing a committee of seven to nine members made up of [1:15:46] designated seats and two to three at large committee seats. [1:15:55] Second. [1:15:56] I did. [1:15:58] All right. You ready to vote? All those in favor? Five to zero and the motion passes. [1:16:07] So, I'll make those updates and email [1:16:11] the updated version of the memo. Post it. [1:16:15] [clears throat] [1:16:16] Thank you very much. You got all of that, Tracy? [1:16:23] [laughter] [1:16:24] And you can still send me what you have. [1:16:26] Hey, pirate. My bad. [1:16:27] Yeah. [1:16:28] You did good. [1:16:30] All [clears throat] right. Now, we're going to move on for action to approve the select board policy for email and written communication. Do you have a copy? I don't have a copy. [1:16:41] I will make a motion to approve the select board policy for email and written communication as written. [1:16:47] Second. [1:16:49] So, can you just clarify for me? I know I missed a meeting and I think that's where a lot of it was talked about. So, what version is it? Cuz it I think the latest version I have includes this yellow piece here which says this includes but a limit to and I thought I saw some chatter with the attorney that was to take all these take all that out. [1:17:14] The one that's in your packet that I included in your packet and online is the revised version that Sarah sent me and it includes the yellow highlights. Yes. [1:17:28] to put this in? Okay. [1:17:29] Yes. [1:17:30] I don't know. I don't know what you have in front of you. [1:17:32] But yes, that's the [1:17:33] was we decided we wanted to kind of we said it. We were going to keep that list of things just so that people had an idea of what's may not So, we said this includes but is not limited to and is subject to. [1:17:48] That same act. [1:17:50] Yeah. [1:17:50] Okay. [1:17:51] And then we took out there's something about common sense and we took that out. [1:17:55] Yeah, I saw that. I saw that. [1:17:57] Those were the only two things that I think [1:18:00] And when the attorney had approved it before, that was when you added this board added the yellow. So, I sent it back to Mary and said can you take a look at what the board added in yellow? And she okayed that. So, I sent that to Sarah. [1:18:20] She took all the yellow highlights out and that's what I included in your packet. [1:18:26] You took these yellow highlights out? [1:18:28] I took the highlight out. The highlight the yellow out. [1:18:33] The color. [1:18:33] Not the words, just the [1:18:35] Not the words. [1:18:35] Okay. Yeah, I was going to say you [laughter] take the highlight out is it is it is struck from the thing. It is it the content stays. [1:18:41] The content stays and the yellow stays. [1:18:44] Yeah, I'm looking at this one that doesn't have yellow on it. [1:18:48] Yeah, well this is what it is but when I you know, going in sequential it says the yellow is what select board suggested but I think Mary had suggested eliminating the list of what is confidential. So, we're going with our list. I get it. [1:19:03] Yep. [1:19:04] Thank you. [1:19:09] So, we have a motion and a second. Are all those in favor? [1:19:13] Five to zero, the motion passes. [1:19:17] Thank you, Sarah. [1:19:19] We'll shred the red. [1:19:20] Another copy. [1:19:21] And now that we've finally approved it, can go on the website near our emails. [1:19:26] Yeah. Okay. [1:19:29] All right. [1:19:33] All right, so now we're going to discuss filling the water Bethel water district seat on the Bingham Forest Authority Committee and Sharon gave us a letter from 2025 where the Bethel Water District did say that they were had voted to vacate that seat on the authority [1:19:56] So, we're okay to move forward now, right? [1:19:59] So, at the last meeting Michelle asked if I could get a letter from the water district that they didn't want to participate before Scott Frazier got done, he called me and sent me this letter which I gave to this board at that time. [1:20:19] stating [clears throat] that the water district had taken a vote not to participate anymore and Reggie was the one at the time. And so, I just pulled it out of the file and I didn't recontact them because they had already voted to do this. So, that's what I'm providing you with and then [1:20:42] when Peter was here last week, he asked again [1:20:47] there's not going to be a representative if you determine hire putting on someone else because they needed people and Corrina just got done so they only have three now. [1:21:02] So, the next steps now that they've vacated their seat is I propose giving the giving this to the ordinance review committee so they can strike the language, add the language [1:21:16] to be proposed for an amendment change. [1:21:22] for the yeah, description of the Bingham Forest to them. [1:21:28] What is that? [1:21:28] What do you [1:21:29] it's in the code that there shall be a five-member Bingham Forest Advisory Committee. One member shall be a member of the Bethel Water District and they're trustees elected by the board but and the other four will be at large, appointed by select board for a three-year term. Each member shall you know they'll be both on your knee and no more than one member from your knee. [1:21:51] In the event the number of members of the building of forest supplies your committee is changed by town meeting action. So we need town meeting action to change it then the select board will be authorized to appoint and remove members of the committee at its sole discretion. [1:22:04] So we should fill out the ORC form with that request. [1:22:08] So there's paperwork. [clears throat] [1:22:09] Yeah. [1:22:13] Who does that? Sharon, who does that? [1:22:16] Okay. [1:22:17] So I guess I make that motion to send this to ORC for language to come back for us to consider to get it on the path. [1:22:29] Second. [1:22:30] I 'm looking at the Why is that the chair doesn't do that? [1:22:35] Just a question. [1:22:36] The chair of the building of forest committee? [1:22:38] The chair of select board fill out the paperwork for the ORC. [1:22:42] Oh, I can do that. [1:22:44] I mean like Sharon doesn't have the authority to do it. [1:22:47] It's also the select board that's making the request. So I think it makes more sense to come from us. [1:22:54] I don't think it matters to me. [1:22:57] You said we should I make that other one too? What was the other one that we need? [1:23:00] The data access strategy. [1:23:03] Yeah, why not? I think that was already done, right? [1:23:06] I Oh, no, I just had a conversation with [1:23:09] Oh, okay. [1:23:10] I didn't actually fill out the form. We just discussed it which was and one of the things we discussed was they would review it but they would also be looking at the state. [1:23:23] Okay. So I could do both of those in writing. I could if I can get the form before I leave tonight I can bring it in tomorrow. [1:23:29] Just do [1:23:30] What's the thing Fell it is on the website. [1:23:32] Yeah, I supposed to be up. [1:23:34] It is. [1:23:34] It is a Google form? [1:23:35] It's not that we can fill out the form but it's like a digital form. [1:23:39] Okay. Okay, and it's on the website? [1:23:41] Yes. [1:23:42] Yeah, it's supposed to be on the PDF that you fill out right now. [1:23:45] sent it to the ORC committee. [1:23:46] Okay. [1:23:49] Did you go out and voice your opinion to them? [1:23:51] Yep. [1:23:53] And what was the reasoning for having it put on the website? [1:23:59] So, that if anybody can [1:24:01] fill it out. [1:24:01] Fill it out. [1:24:03] A member from the public. [1:24:04] So, if a member from the public wants to do something, they have two avenues. They come to us and ask and we go out the form. Or they go and get a petition. Do something. [1:24:18] That's not what it said. That's not what the form says. The form states that if somebody from the public wants to make a recommendation for a change, then they submit that to the manager and the manager submits that to the select board to review. [1:24:37] Right, cuz it's the select board is the gatekeeper, I guess that's what I'm saying. And [1:24:41] Just to let you know, the it can bubble up that way, right? But the individuals always have the option to go and do a petition if they want to have something changed. Cuz the board doesn't have to do it. So, there is [1:24:58] All it is a tracking form so [1:25:00] I know. [1:25:01] So, yeah. [1:25:01] Yeah. [1:25:02] You guys say [1:25:03] Yeah. [1:25:04] Who are they designating their vote? I can't even remember who it was five years ago. [1:25:08] Yeah. [1:25:09] Or it was a year ago we had to look it up. [1:25:11] Yeah. [1:25:11] No,, no, it's a good tracking of the genesis of where the inquiry came from. Is it is it is it a good thing to have? [1:25:18] Yeah. [1:25:18] And yeah. [1:25:19] See, if you if you have the way they set this up, if somebody from the public wants to make a recommendation for a change, submit it to the manager to submit to the board, the only time that doing a petition should come into play would be if the board said, "No, we're not going to do this." So, that shouldn't be in my opinion shouldn't be the first recommendation [1:25:50] is that they first have to do a petition. That would be at the end if they're denied. Right. [1:25:56] Yeah. [1:25:57] If they I just [1:26:02] want to recognize how it comes from. Is the genesis of an individual, it generates from the planning board, it generates from whoever. That's the background of it. and it doesn't preclude an individual going out and doing a petition. It doesn't It doesn't require us [1:26:24] needing to have it pursued either. So. [1:26:26] I guess I just that they would need to fill out the form to bring to them. [1:26:31] That's the first step. [1:26:32] Yeah, that's that's just our That's just our rules. They can come and sit in public, you know. [1:26:37] No, I know, but that's why it's on the website. Okay. [1:26:40] It helps, like Jim said, keep track of everything. Okay. [1:26:45] All right. so we don't have [1:26:51] a quorum. [1:26:54] So, we're going to go on to [1:26:55] Did we vote on that? [1:26:56] No. [1:26:57] There's a motion and a second. [1:26:58] Yeah, I think we should actually vote on it. [1:27:05] We need a motion. [1:27:06] We have a motion and a second. [1:27:08] Yeah, we have a motion and a second, you just need to hear the vote. [1:27:10] Okay. All those in favor? Five to zero, the motion is [1:27:14] passes. [1:27:23] All right. [1:27:25] We'll move on to warrants and I'll make a motion to approve AP warrant number 22 in the amount of $520,107.49. [1:27:38] Second. [1:27:41] Any questions or comments? [1:28:04] It was on the second page the land surveying near the top of the page is that for [1:28:13] a fire bureau? [1:28:17] Say that again. [1:28:18] sir. [1:28:19] on the second page it's it's not the first item but the second item down land surveying for $9,900. [1:28:28] That's all to do with the upgrades invoice for West Manlius ambulance. [1:28:34] Okay. [1:28:39] All those in favor? Five to zero and the motion passes. [1:28:46] can I move on to I'll make a motion to approve AP warrant number 24 in the amount of $52,449.65 [1:28:56] and that part is on your table tonight. [1:29:01] Second. [1:29:04] Any questions? [1:29:10] On page [1:29:14] three. [1:29:16] United Training Center [1:29:22] and that's like maybe for David. Is that for recertification or new certification? [1:29:33] $2,800. [1:29:35] It's AMT classes for Dave. [1:29:38] So he's updating his license. [1:29:40] He's re- recertifying. [1:29:42] Yeah. No, I think he's updating it. [1:29:44] Oh, he's taking [1:29:45] I think he's an EMT. [1:29:46] EMT. [1:29:47] Yeah. And now he's becoming an advanced EMT. [1:29:49] Yes. Okay. He's He's an EMT before and now he's training to be an advanced [1:29:55] Advanced. [1:29:58] So new stuff. [1:30:00] Very good. Thanks. [1:30:13] Okay, all those in favor? Five to zero and the motion passes. Okay, we're on to select board items. [1:30:25] I don't believe ORC did not meet last week because of everything building being utilized. So yeah, I don't have anything. I won't I will I will say since I know it's a month away now, but I will not be here the first week of December for that meeting. [1:30:44] That's ORC meeting? [1:30:45] No. Select board meeting. [1:30:47] Select board meeting or whatever meeting it [1:30:49] Yeah, three weeks. [1:30:51] That's That was probably a good call, wasn't it? [1:30:53] Yeah. [1:30:54] It might be. [1:31:02] for future agendas [1:31:06] I don't know if I'm just not seeing it, but the emergency response plan. [1:31:11] When is that supposed to be on our radar? [1:31:14] It's due to come back to me with your recommendations on November 30th. [1:31:21] Okay, great. So it's not on an agenda, but we do have a deadline for our plan. I was going to show should we write like write on into the booklet that you gave us? Like make comments, like handwrite comments in [1:31:33] Yes, in the one I gave you. [1:31:34] In the blue folder. [1:31:34] Yes, do your recommendations, markups right on that. And then I'll actually add this under future agendas that this is due on the 30th. That way [1:31:49] That would be helpful. [1:31:50] It'll be right there. [1:31:51] Thank you. And then you gave us sort of along the same lines of this you gave us this last the fire department [1:32:05] using mutual aid agreements. And you also asked us to read through that and make comments. Is there [1:32:14] There isn't. Mike didn't have a timeline. It was just what they revised and he said it would be coming back to the board for approval when he gets it back. it's been given to the other towns. I guess it hasn't been updated in 20 years. And it will be when it gets to this cycle four that Bethel signs, it will just he'll let me know when that's going to be. [1:32:41] So, that's why I gave it to you. [1:32:43] Okay. But, we should have read it soon and if you have any [1:32:47] Yeah. [1:32:47] And then anything we have concerns with, give it to him or you? [1:32:52] You can give it to me or you can give it to him. If you give it to me, I'll get it to him. [1:32:56] Is he coming back at a later date to a meeting? [1:33:00] He's not going to come back until it's time for Bethel to sign it. And he doesn't know when that's going to be. The way I understand it is circulating to the different towns that have to sign it right now. [1:33:13] Okay. [1:33:16] Yeah, they're pretty good with mutual aid. [1:33:18] The the other piece I'm not sure if it comes under this, but maybe they're kept all together is that [1:33:28] Wurtsboro has an agreement with Bethel cuz we take on Burr Hill on there where it splits. so [1:33:41] There's [1:33:41] There's something there, too. [1:33:43] Yeah, we they cover [1:33:47] they cover that side of Burr Hill typically primarily. I mean, now if like if it's a house fire or something, they're all we're all going no matter what. [1:33:55] Yeah, right. [1:33:56] and Jim, correct me if I'm wrong but they do Bird Hill. That side of Bird Hill which is actually Macungie Brook Road. So, it's Macungie Brook Road that they're covering over there and then the Bethel section of 232. And then Greenwood we cover Irish Neighborhood Road primarily for Greenwood. [1:34:19] And I don't think Greenwood really covers anything for us. [1:34:25] What's that? Yeah, cuz we cover the rest of Bird Hill even though I think they cover the first 200 ft. [1:34:35] There is actual There is an actual agreement on that one. [1:34:41] That's a separate agreement. [1:34:42] Yeah, there is an actual separate agreement on that one. [1:34:46] There was something written years ago. [1:34:48] Yeah, not too long ago. [1:34:51] It was probably updated but I don't remember it was. [1:34:55] Cuz it covers ambulance too which I believe. Like I believe Bethel Rescue covers the Irish Neighborhood section of Greenwood and then because Weststock uses Pace now, Pace covers the 232 section of Bethel and I guess I don't know about Macungie Brook Road or not. [1:35:12] that falls under green That's the Greenwood side so that falls under Pace. [1:35:18] So it would just be nice to maybe have a meeting and sort it all together. This was I think specifically with the other town not necessarily a like a mutual agreement on this one but there was there were roles that were outlined you know with Stock and Greenwood. [1:35:31] And we do the same thing with Wyalusing too. [1:35:36] So [1:35:37] So I can How about if I ask Mike to come by? Just to keep it all together. The details showing [1:35:45] who covers what within Greenwood, Weststock and Bethel. [1:35:50] There's a There's an actual agreement that I remember coming to the board here at one point. Yeah, it's actual. [1:35:57] All right. [1:36:02] Correct. [1:36:03] I Do you have anything in contact with this? [1:36:07] Michelle, do you have anything? [1:36:08] just with the assessor meeting coming up next week, I haven't looked at the packet. I didn't know for the 2027 engagement letter for the assessor, if it's available, if it if the assessors could have copies to look at it before we have this up here. [1:36:26] Yeah. Does he just do it automatically? [1:36:30] it comes from his office, but I haven't seen it yet. [1:36:39] When it comes, I usually give it to the board, but I have not seen it. [1:36:44] All right. I can ask. [1:36:45] All right. [1:36:46] I just for timing wise, I'm just [1:36:50] thinking about that. [1:36:55] If I understand correctly, is there 's a planning board meeting coming up where 1 Mill Hill will be addressed again in regards to reviewing the hot tub? [1:37:09] Next meeting. [1:37:10] Next meeting? [1:37:12] Which is the 12th, because the 11th is Veteran's Day, so it's going to be on the first, right? November 12th. [1:37:19] But are they also reviewing the heat pumps? [1:37:22] No,, the heat pumps were approved. [1:37:25] No, there is there's three things that are on that agenda. Do you have your packet with you today? [1:37:30] Yeah. [1:37:31] I think this is a might be election, so just my hands might be election days. That is the hot tub. [1:37:44] That's okay. I was just wondering about the heat pumps, if they were in the original review or not. [1:37:50] They were. [1:37:51] In the original review? [1:37:52] Yeah. [1:37:55] Yeah, so in the original plans, they were. [1:37:58] All right. So, as far as if they're meeting those original plans. We can look at up. [1:38:05] Yeah. [1:38:06] Okay. So, any building has to have heat pumps? [1:38:10] I'm 99% sure. [1:38:12] Well, I was just going to ask about this one. It has to be it's either a historical society or on the national register. So, I didn't know if the if the town office got its heat pumps. [1:38:26] And you don't have to answer it now. Just could come back. I don't know what the answer is. [1:38:30] Yeah. [1:38:32] So, what's your question? I'm confused. [1:38:34] so, for the Mill Hill project, I was wondering if the heat pumps were reviewed. And it sounds like they were and they were good to go. [1:38:46] I'm 99.9% [1:38:49] sure they were on the original plan. [1:38:51] Okay. [1:38:52] In those locations. [1:38:54] And they're not on this agenda for the planning board. [1:38:58] No, I don't think they I think they were already reviewed. And I just don't know what the what any action is [1:39:06] on it. The two things that are on it are the [1:39:13] enclosing [1:39:16] the [1:39:19] bulkhead. [1:39:20] Yes, that's what it was. [1:39:21] Because the water was going to run right down on the bulkheads, so they just roofed over it and they decided to enclose it and make it look more presentable. [1:39:33] Isn't there a third thing now, Jim? [1:39:36] [1:39:41] I think it's I think it's written right in the [1:39:49] Let's [1:39:50] It There was There was the hot tub, the deck, and the [1:39:55] Oh. [1:39:56] and the [1:39:59] I'm not 100% sure. [1:40:02] Oh, I can't do that. The deck is not on the planning board agenda. [1:40:07] The deck was on the original plan. [1:40:10] Right, but it's not on this agenda for this week for the planning board. [1:40:14] I was just asking about the heat pumps and [1:40:16] No, the heat pumps are approved 99% of that. [1:40:21] Or, you know, and I didn't know if there was any alterations to them that had to be done. So, I can look on the original application for that. Thank you. And then that reminded me of the town office had a review for the heat pumps. [1:40:38] So, where is that in the code that heat pump? [1:40:42] That's in our code that heat pumps have to be The national register and the historic districts they get reviewed by the planning board and it's for outside. So, if you cut into an outside wall then it comes under the purview for approval. [1:41:02] It don't if [1:41:09] You bring up You bring up national [1:41:14] I don't know if that was a [1:41:15] That was just my understanding. This was [1:41:17] It's a historic district. [1:41:18] But it is in a historic district. Well, a historic district gets done differently than regular [1:41:25] Yeah. [1:41:25] cycle. [1:41:27] I know. I Right. Right, like I read through that this week, but I Yeah, cuz it's mostly the outside. [1:41:33] Yeah. [1:41:33] It's just it's it's the outside purview that [1:41:36] It's only 200 ft, so you can have half the house not in the district, which is really weird. [1:41:45] But there's borders or something. But [1:41:47] Yeah. [1:41:49] All right. Well, thank you. It sound It sounds like the town office had me And on Mill Hill, they were on the original application. Thank you. That's all I have. [1:42:01] Okay. I had a few things. I just wanted to remind us that if you want to add anything to the agenda like I mean if you haven't said anything like tonight that you get it to Sharon by the Wednesday before our next meeting so that cuz she has been pretty about getting [1:42:22] the packet out to us on Fridays that so it really helps if you have anything that you want to give to her add to the agenda if you could get that to her on Wednesday. [1:42:34] And [1:42:37] [1:42:40] just for fu- future agendas can we still keep the property use form and requirements deal with that or something like that? Like [1:42:54] I'll add that to the future agendas. [1:42:56] Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And then [1:42:59] Right. [1:43:00] Yeah. Right. Like the using town property. [1:43:03] Yes. Yeah. [1:43:04] Okay. And then And then thank you Sharon. You sent us the letters to agencies and social services that you've sent out already, right? You sent us three of them. [1:43:16] Yes. [1:43:17] But I was wondering [1:43:21] So so people I just wanted to clarify for myself. Do those agencies have to request that letter or [1:43:35] or and I think we send it to or agencies and social services that have requested before, but what if there is an social or agency that hasn't ever asked before? I feel like it would be fair for us to allow them to send a letter. So I was just wondering how that happens cuz I think we usually just send it to people who've asked before. [1:43:58] So anyone who received money in fiscal year the previous fiscal year will automatically get that letter to fill out. Anyone who sends a request for funding, I would send that letter to fill out. Okay. [1:44:14] So, that there are I think there are I know somebody asked me last year, well, how would I know to request money? And I don't you know, like can is that something we can put on the website? Like if you are social service agency and want to request money for fiscal year 2018 that they write to you and request that letter. [1:44:37] I don't know that not that we want to open up. [1:44:40] Yeah, that's what I'm afraid of is cuz that's where it was a couple years ago. And I just remember seeing the town warrant a few years ago and it was like just never ending and it never [1:44:52] I mean Yeah. I mean maybe we can figure out that if we if we put some kind of a an official cap on it then we can do something like that and we could put in there that you know, this is what we [1:45:05] Yeah, we're not guaranteeing we could say we're not guaranteeing anything but just I feel like we need to be fair in who we can apply. [1:45:14] I think that's what we wanted as an agenda item to talk about. Yeah, what we were going to do. [1:45:20] Yeah, so that's our asking to be on the future agenda. [1:45:24] And I noticed I guess we might have to hustle on that because I noticed there were three there, right? There were three [1:45:32] I've already done three. [1:45:34] Right, and their deadline is December 31st 2026. So, [1:45:40] To get it in is December [1:45:42] I think so. [1:45:43] They have to get their information to me by December [1:45:45] Is that every organization has to get it to you by? [1:45:47] Yes. So, those three there had received funding last year. So, I sent those out. And if there are new requests, then I'll send a request I'll send that information to them to fill out. [1:46:05] so, is this just for agencies in social services or are we also including others that got money last year? Nonprofits. [1:46:16] Anyone who received money funding last year under social services and agencies will get one of those letters. [1:46:27] So, they're going to get that [1:46:28] fairly soon because the deadline is December [1:46:31] Yes. And those three got it because I got a letter from them already. [1:46:36] Good luck with that. [1:46:37] Yes. And so, anyone who has never requested or well, anyone that has never requested, I would send that to them and tell them that in order to be considered, I need this information. [1:46:54] So, the social services and agencies is that including like the historical society, the library? [1:47:01] All of them. [1:47:03] Cuz those I see those as nonprofits versus the social services and agencies. So, I just wanted to [1:47:08] they all get it. All of that category. There's two categories that get [1:47:13] Yeah. Right. [1:47:14] There's two categories. I just want to make sure that they're all that they're all going to get that letter. [1:47:18] Yes. [1:47:18] Okay. All right. So, that'll have to go out soon, too. And [1:47:21] Okay. [1:47:22] We want to talk about it and some of the nonprofits [1:47:25] But if the deadline's that soon, then is there a way to I don't I mean, I understand not opening it up to have huge numbers applying, but I do feel like it needs to be fair. So, I [1:47:38] Yeah, okay. [1:47:40] I think it'd be worth having a conversation about. I remember like the last the last time we made this distinction, we only recommended funding for groups that had received funding in the in the past, which I don't think is fully fair. It's kind of like a catch to avoid having more applications than we can handle. [1:48:00] so, I think we need a different plan. [1:48:03] So, maybe the deadline could [1:48:04] Well, I think that's different what you're talking about. The select board, well, the joint budget committee, which consists of the budget committee and the select board, both agreed who was they were going to approve funding for. [1:48:18] Mhm. [1:48:18] So, that's separate. You can approve funding for whoever you want, whether they received funding before or didn't re- When I get requests, they all go to the joint committee. Whether they have submitted a request in the past, received money, or not. Then, you as a joint committee in your own voting decide who's going to get it. [1:48:44] So, that's separate from sending out the letters. [1:48:48] Right. No, I understand that. [1:48:50] But, it may be helpful to have some if we're going to have criteria to let them know what we're going to use to make our decisions. So, maybe we push the deadline back to January 31st and have a little [1:49:02] That's That shouldn't be done. I 'm going to ask you not to get involved in deadlines or anything like that. [1:49:08] Well, just so that we can have the criteria the criteria that we have to have to use to decide. [1:49:15] Yeah, that's [1:49:15] Yeah, well, I think that's if Sharon's deadline is the 31st, that's the deadline we have to work with. [1:49:20] And I mean, if there's something you want changed in the letter, then okay, but no one has ever said anything about that. [1:49:27] No, I think the letter is fine. [1:49:29] That letter was given to the board when it was put together 2 years ago, but [1:49:34] I think it's more about who it goes to. [1:49:36] Yeah, I thought they wanted to I was looking at the agenda item to kind of look at it again. I mean, I was surprised that the letters had already gone out, you know, in August, you know, which is fine. for me, I'm just playing catch-up. but I thought there was specifically that you wanted to have specific financial information in there. [1:49:56] Yeah, I think that was it. I don't [1:49:59] There is financial information that they have to send in. [1:50:02] but, to be to be pedantic, [1:50:05] [clears throat] [1:50:06] the deadline is the deadline. And so, we know so we can help enforce that. If we had somebody come in, you know, later on and I said, "Just getting the information out." and it is it is December 31st is close [1:50:26] but we already have it out there for three letters so [1:50:30] Yeah, I don't think there's anything wrong with the letter. I don't think I wouldn't propose changing any of that so much as who is invited to apply is the question that I think that we need to determine. Is it an open call or we just inviting folks who we've identified before and make that determination and have a reason for that? [1:50:49] So my question to you is why do we need to invite people to apply? [1:50:55] And then not invite them to [1:50:56] well, I thought you thought that you could send [1:50:58] Well, no. I 'm not inviting anybody. I'm not inviting anybody. I'm giving these letters requesting financial information as a courtesy to those who applied last year in case they want to apply again this year. And if someone didn't apply last year or if somebody didn't get funding last year and sends [1:51:23] a request this year, then I'm going to send them that information. Now it's up to them to decide if they want to send the information in but I don't think that we should put a notice out saying all of these organizations and list what they might be and say if anybody wants to apply for funding [1:51:46] cuz that's what I'm hearing [1:51:48] I get it. I get to clarify. [1:51:50] Yeah, no. I think the eligibility. [1:51:52] Yeah, I think what we do now is fine but I just there may I think they there may be I don't know one or two groups who don't even know that 's a possibility. And so how do they know that they could write to you and say I may want to request money. How do I do that? [1:52:11] They're all willing I mean they're all invited to request the money without us telling them that. No, I know. Well, [1:52:21] I know. We don't have to tell them that. I mean, they 're If they need the funding, they're going to they're going to they're going to apply for it. [1:52:27] Right, but if they don't think about it till budget season, it's getting close and the deadline is December 31st. [1:52:34] Well, I think this is kind of why it needs to be an agenda [1:52:38] I don't want Yeah, we shouldn't go down talking about all this tonight. So, yeah. So, [1:52:42] Can I tell you also discuss that we're putting a cap on it? [1:52:45] Yeah, well, we have to discuss it. [1:52:48] That's another agenda item to talk about. Yeah. [1:52:50] Yeah. So, you're welcome to have it next time. [1:52:53] We have to have the budget committee in on that decision. [1:52:56] No. If there's going to be a cap on it, no, we don't. [1:52:59] Right. If we put a put a policy in place, we may want their input. [1:53:07] It can impact the It can you know, it can impact the general fund. [1:53:15] You can get their input on it, but [1:53:17] I think we need to have a conversation just about whether or not we want to put a cap on it. That's that's a whole you know, and then the amount and all of that. [1:53:25] And the ball's already down the hill, so we're we there may be only so much that we can do during the confines and then we'll park it for the next year as well. [1:53:35] We don't have to accept anything that's coming. I think the select board has talked about the past 2 years, just like Jim said, with the budget committee of putting a cap policy with a cap on it. That's the meeting that's never happened is the select board meeting to decide if they're going to have a policy [1:53:56] and cap an amount. That's how I remember it. I would ask that you just let me put something on the website saying that any of these social service agencies, by whatever they're called in the budget, if you are looking to request money in the fiscal year 2018 budget, [1:54:19] I need to get your request by a certain date so that because there's financial information that is requested and asked the selectmen not to [1:54:30] that's exactly what I was asking. That's exactly what I was asking you is that you put it out there so that they at least [1:54:37] Let them know. [1:54:38] people. Yeah, new people. [1:54:40] Yeah, we're we're going to reach out to everybody who's who's gotten it. Three people have gotten it so far. yeah. [1:54:48] Yeah, but just so like if there's you know, there's one new organization or something [1:54:53] I'm not arguing I think [1:54:55] But I yeah, I would actually [1:54:56] I think it [1:54:57] I'm not asking to change the letter or anything at this point here. [1:55:00] No, it's just that we wanted to have this as a conversation at some point and include all these things and [1:55:08] I'll just put a notice out there stating that if anyone any of these organizations I'll write it up accordingly that financial information is requested by 10/31 and to contact the town manager for what is required. [1:55:27] Are these for new people or the ones that [1:55:29] These are going to be for anybody [1:55:30] And that hasn't already [1:55:32] Okay. [1:55:32] This is separate. This is for anybody. This is to I think take care of what they're talking about [1:55:38] Yeah. [1:55:39] and those that haven't already applied for [1:55:44] And just send the letters out to the others. [1:55:47] Probably wouldn't be a bad idea to think about the insurance of putting it somehow that there's no guarantee. [1:55:55] Right. And that's that's states that's in the letter actually. [1:56:00] Yeah. Okay. I didn't want to I'm sorry. And then And so if you if it makes sense for you all I just because I'm not your next I would be fine with you talking about it and making a decision next meeting cuz if the deadline's the 31st and you need to have [1:56:16] Well, the cap decision I don't think has to happen by the 31st. [1:56:19] The what? [1:56:20] If I want to put a cap on the amount. [1:56:22] No, that would [1:56:22] I think that we have a lot more time to [1:56:24] I think now that Yeah. [1:56:25] That's figured out, there's a lot more head space. [1:56:28] See, a lot of these dates I have to back up because if I have to have the budget in March, the beginning of March, which actually is very early. then I have to back Right. back things up when I need to get information. [1:56:46] Yeah, I don't I don't I don't disagree. Yeah, I don't disagree about any of that. I just for me having that information ahead of time is great. And we did change it a little bit cuz traditionally they had to have that information in sometime in January. And I think even last year it was like February 13th or something. So it 's fine. [1:57:07] I just like to be informed of it. [1:57:10] And that way it's in the budget. Well, it's in the budget binder with your budgets and all of their financial information is given to you at that time in the binder. [1:57:22] And then we just know for next year if there's any conversations that we want to have around it is that we're going to have it earlier. [1:57:34] and and then just another future agenda item is just us starting to work on the wastewater treatment plant and covering that. those capital costs or figuring that all out that I don't want to keep kicking it kicking it down the road. [1:57:54] Right. [1:57:55] And I think also added to our goals, too. [1:57:57] Mhm. [1:57:58] A shorter-term goal, but added to the goals as a [1:58:01] Okay. [1:58:02] And we are still planning to do a workshop on December 14th. [1:58:07] Yeah, and I have that. [1:58:08] Okay. Yeah, on there. [1:58:09] On the agenda for sure. And the time. [1:58:19] Right. So [1:58:26] Right. So we have on next our agenda is an executive session. [1:58:33] And so, if anybody would [1:58:35] I make a motion we go into executive session regarding MGL 30A 405 section 6A. [1:58:48] Do we have a written [1:58:49] We have a written Yeah. [1:58:50] Yeah. Yeah. [1:58:56] [clears throat] [1:58:57] For a personnel matter for the purpose of discussing a complaint filed against employee. [1:59:05] Second. [1:59:09] Any discussion? [1:59:14] I guess I'm just having a little trouble with going into executive session on this because I'm not sure we have the basis that we have a real complaint, but if you that's just something that's [1:59:31] I don't really see that we have a written complaint either. She was told that or they were told [1:59:40] we shouldn't have had Yeah. But, I mean I just based on a motion, I'm not for me personally, I am feeling a little uncomfortable with discussing a complaint because I don't I'm not sure it's there. [1:59:57] I agree. [1:59:58] That was probably my first question once we went into executive session, I guess, but I don't know how else how else you deal with it. [2:00:06] Yeah. I know, so maybe we should [2:00:08] No, I don't know the answer to that. [2:00:10] I would say at this point there's nothing to deal with. [2:00:13] Well, that's [2:00:17] No, I would disagree. We have a constituent that has concerns. And the attorney, you know, wrote the motion. And [2:00:29] why do we need to have a complaint in order to discuss these concerns? [2:00:34] Okay. [2:00:35] So, I guess can we change Can we change the language there or I mean it's [2:00:40] Well, this citation came from the attorney. [2:00:42] Yeah. [2:00:46] Because the other citation was the town manager's performance review and there's nothing in [2:00:56] that was listed that identifies any performance review needed of the town manager. And this is no acknowledgement on the part of the complainant and the com- person complaining doesn't list what the complaints are. [2:01:13] Yeah, I don't feel like [2:01:14] So, [2:01:15] From what I see, they were told that they could make a complaint and how to do that. [2:01:18] And they did not. [2:01:20] And there was a there was a protocol for two of the meeting. I all I can you know, I just reiterate there's a there's there's a concern there that was that was shared and I would like to just learn more about it and perhaps [2:01:41] not have that situation happen again. [2:01:44] What situation happened again? She doesn't say what happened. [2:01:49] we have going to executive session. [2:01:56] We don't know what the concerns are. That's the whole [2:01:58] Yeah, and yeah. [2:01:59] There is no written complaint. [2:02:04] She's she stated her position and what drives a constituent to have that position? [2:02:12] Because they didn't get the answer they wanted. That's what drives that. And I guess I would like to ask the question. I've issued several citations to this board of complaints that this board has never addressed. Why are we going to address someone's complaint which [2:02:35] it's being termed a complaint. There's no complaint in it when I have very specific concerns about complaints that I have filed on behalf of my staff being verbally attacked, and now the attorney being verbally attacked, and this board has never taken any action to discuss it. [2:02:54] we've been actually we've been advised by our attorney that if an employee feels threatened and if the attorney feels threatened that they are to call the police. That's the action that we've been given. [2:03:11] And make sure you address it downtown. [2:03:13] Well, it's it's up to the person who's who's who feels it. Absolutely. If they if they feel that. But, I think we're getting off the subject here. I'm I'm just I'm just very concerned, and I wanted to hear the other side. to have that sort of situation [2:03:34] where constituents don't feel that they can [2:03:39] talk with the town office I think is very concerning. [2:03:44] Yes. [2:03:45] Well, let me let me just say this. Since this is about me, I choose to discuss it in open session. [2:03:55] So, we [2:03:55] Yeah, I don't know if that's that's fine with me. [2:03:59] My only question is [2:04:01] Oh, yeah. [2:04:02] So, you seem to know what the complaint is about and the rest of us don't. [2:04:06] All I know is that they had an issue. They didn't feel that they could they could talk or present information [2:04:15] I've read what it what you wrote. [2:04:17] So, yes. And I just wanted to hear back from you imagine [2:04:21] coming up with something else that you have more issues involved than what we were told today. [2:04:27] Can we really do this in open session? [2:04:30] If it's [2:04:30] about me, and I say yes, it does. We can to about this in open session. [2:04:36] Yes, we can. [2:04:37] We're going to need to have We're going to need to talk about the emails. [2:04:41] Yes. [2:04:43] That's okay. And that is not [2:04:45] it's it I mean, it's they're public record. [2:04:49] It would be, you know, in between in between the [2:04:53] [clears throat] [2:04:54] two of them. [2:04:55] So, who went to the attorney to get this written up? [2:04:59] I went to the attorney and I asked about the motion because the motion that Michelle gave was to go into executive session to discuss town manager performance review. What is my performance being What performance is being [2:05:22] And you asked what to put in on this. It's personal. I'm not challenging anything. All I'm wanting is wanting to hear what your perspective is. [2:05:31] And I have no problem with saying that in open session. [2:05:34] that's fine. That 's fine. [2:05:38] And the other thing is [2:05:42] And then, her husband chose to bring a request to me and this board to me. She didn't want She didn't feel comfortable at having me acting as the liaison between her and the board. Yet, on Monday, I received a request [2:06:06] being the liaison between me and the board. There's no complaint as far as I'm concerned. [2:06:11] I think And I again, I 've not seen this employee. I get it's a concern. We've had concerns come before. And that's very concerning to me if a constituent doesn't feel that they can talk to the town manager. The only people we can talk to is the town manager. And I wanted to hear her perspective. [2:06:32] What would drive somebody to say that they don't feel comfortable going to [2:06:39] I have no problem with talking about that in open session. [2:06:43] Yeah, this is fine. And you did, you said because they didn't get what they wanted. And and I just didn't know if there was another way to handle it. Could it have been handled differently? Could this whole thing been avoided if it was handled differently? [2:06:56] Before we go any further, I made a motion to go into executive. We need to vote on it. [2:07:03] All those in favor? [2:07:06] I don't All those opposed? [2:07:14] Do you want to address anything else? [2:07:15] I would like to address something, yes, because that email that was sent to the chair was shared with me. And prior to that email being sent to Sarah, I met with that woman once. Only once did I ever have a conversation [2:07:37] with her, and that was on September 1st. With both her and her husband. Never even knew what she looked like until September 1st, when I met with her in this meeting room and the code enforcement officer about a complaint that she had filed on August 26th. [2:07:58] And then I received an email from him requesting an urgent meeting that day on that Friday, the 28th. I wrote back and I told them that due to the lateness of getting that request, I was unable to meet on that Friday, [2:08:20] and the code officer was also unable to meet on that Friday. He sent the request at 11:30 Thursday night. At 9:00 the next morning, he sent a follow-up email. It was pretty hard to get back to an email that's sent at 11:30 at night, and then a follow-up the next morning at 9:30. [2:08:43] So, I wrote back and I said that we were not available on that Friday due to other commitments that we had made, and on and I listed three dates that we could meet with them. So, it was September 1st, and we met in this room. [2:09:03] And I didn't even know why I was being asked to be in that meeting because it was a complaint that he had with the code officer. So, as courtesy, I met with them. And I listened to the complaint. There was no other way to have handled this. We met, they stated their case. [2:09:26] Courtney stated her case back with them. There was an agreement made as to what they were going to do, and they left. That's the only time I ever had any verbal conversation with either one of them, or had any email correspondence with them. For the next month of September, [2:09:47] I was either sent an email directly, or I was copied on an email, and in the month of September, 25 emails I was either copied on or sent an email from that from those that party, okay? That's a little bit excessive [2:10:08] as far as I'm concerned. I never responded to any emails to either one of them, so I never had any conversations, whether it was verbal or in writing, other than when freedom of access requests were asked for by two other individuals. [2:10:30] I res- They were sent to me. I was copied on them anyway. I responded as the freedom of access officer, and I stated, "Your request has been received." when I got it and I respond I checked with the the staff who had to provide that information [2:10:53] and asked when can this information be available? How long is it going to take you to get all of this information together? Because there was a lot of information. I responded back and I said your information will be replied will be sent to you by end of day on whatever day it was [2:11:14] which is the protocol for that. That information was then sent to the individuals by the date. In fact, it was sent before the date there. But for what was written in that email there's no justification for anyone writing that email [2:11:38] when they had one conversation with me verbally and never any email conversations with them. So when I looked at it, was [2:11:48] I have no idea what the problem is. [2:11:54] And I think and I don't I don't see it [2:12:02] I don't when you say they said they weren't comfortable talking to the town manager. I don't really see that in the email and I do feel like I responded with [2:12:12] It does say yes in there. [2:12:14] But I just wanted to hear you know, that's this was only one side. So I wanted to hear the manager's side and she has her has her side of it. She doesn't know why they would do it. I just I'm just trying to figure out why would why a constituent would take the time to write that. [2:12:34] That's all. And we heard from her side and I just don't know if there was anything that could have could have been done differently. you as a result of that [2:12:47] I mean, I think my response was that if I mean, I tried to lay it out and say like if you do have a complaint, what to do. So, we I mean, and that may come. [2:12:57] And maybe I'm wrong in this, but it almost it seems like the complaint is just to get it in front of the board. Is what I feel like the complaint against the town manager in this case is made as a means of getting it in front of the board, of getting the other issue in front of the board is what I'm picking up here. Now, there is there is this other part where [2:13:18] I know it does say we're not comfortable giving Sharon any information at this time, but it doesn't say why. [2:13:24] But why? [2:13:25] I don't know why I would share. [2:13:26] I know. That's what I That's what I wanted to hear. [2:13:28] And there was your side. So, there was never any question brought to me about bringing information to the select board. Cuz I would have told him the same thing I tell everybody else. Get me the information, I'll give it to them just like I did when they did when the gentleman brought me the information in on Monday and asked [2:13:54] He came in with it and he said, "I'm requesting that I be placed on the select board's agenda." And I said, "Do you have" and I saw it was in his hand, so I looked at it. I told him at that time that the agenda had already been set. [2:14:14] It was addressed to the select board and to me. And that actually was the second time I had a verbal conversation with him other than in the meeting that room in the room that day. And so, I said, "I will check and see if this can be added to the agenda." I also told him that it had to be a unanimous vote. [2:14:34] I took his phone number down. I was very cordial and I don't think he could say I wasn't. And I told him that if it wasn't voted unanimously by the board, that was part of the code that he could be heard under questions and comments from the public, which is what I said here tonight when it wasn't [2:14:58] when it wasn't approved. So, I have I have really bent over backwards accommodating this situation. And I can't tell you, and I don't mind saying this, I can't tell you how many hours I have spent [2:15:18] on this because every email that came to two other staff members that I was copied on, I read thoroughly over and over again, highlighting everything that I needed to highlight. And when Sarah brought this to me, I was just totally dumbfounded it. [2:15:39] Sarah responded back and told them what the procedure was. There was nothing that was issued after that. I have people that come in and they're not happy with me because they don't like a decision I made. [2:15:56] That happens all the time. I [2:16:03] I can't help it if I'm making a decision based on what I feel the decision should be made, whether it's in code or it's part of a procedure or whatever, and then if they don't like it, then they've got a right to be angry because they're not getting the answer they want. [2:16:26] But I never had any communication with either one of them until that one meeting. [2:16:32] Yeah, no, this is what I wanted to get feedback on. Some something drove them to take that time and state what they state stated in there. And so we have their side right there. I wanted to hear your side if there was any you could pinpoint other than [2:16:48] We don't have their side. I'm sorry. I have to disagree. We not have their side. She does not say why. She says that she would give us the give the information if they're allowed to do so. [2:17:00] Yes. [2:17:01] And I think I think if you really read between the lines, they're they're really digging at Courtney. [2:17:10] And of course, Courtney is under Sharon. So, [2:17:17] So, our employees here so this is why I'm just trying to find out more information. Sharon responded to it. [2:17:26] like to look at these things ahead of time if we have a chance. That's why I didn't want to call it a complaint. And the only way we can talk to our manager about these things would be you know, who is under performance personnel matter since we had to state something. So, that's what I was struggling with. I just wanted to have a conversation and like I said in there, we heard her side of it. [2:17:48] We heard her side of it. you know, we have it. Is there anything that could be done in the future so we don't get 25 emails or whatever it is and [2:17:58] we did say here are the steps so maybe you know, [2:18:01] Right. And I didn't say anything ahead of time cuz this was all in the appeal [clears throat] but afterwards, you know, and we dressed it you addressed it with you know, we didn't actually talk to the attorney. Got it through Sharon. so, that's Yeah, if they if they if they wanted to file a complaint [2:18:21] in that manner, then they were welcome to do so. You gave me the steps. I don't feel that we should be prohibited about talking about something until we have a complaint cuz maybe we can avoid things. So, I thank you for your feedback on [2:18:42] your side of what it is of your interactions. I appreciate it. That's what I That's what I said that's what I wanted to talk about and that's [2:18:52] So, just to clarify another point, too. In the email, it referenced me and another employee. So, by asking you "What is your motion?" It was to draw out who do you want to talk about? Because you couldn't talk about another employee. [2:19:14] Only me. So. [2:19:16] talked with you. So, that's that's why I just wanted to learn more. And that's why when I was doing an executive session, because if another employee's name was mentioned then we would be in executive session to cover ourselves. So, thank you for the feedback. [2:19:36] it doesn't sound like we can really do anything about it in the future. but we're all we're aware of it and we know how our constituents can be. but Okay. Thank you for the conversation. [2:19:51] I mean, do you have thoughts on the future so that [2:19:55] Well, my thoughts on the future go back to the agenda items that I wanted to talk about, which is more of the process. I'd like to learn how that time with the attorney, conference with the attorney to learn the impact of her advice on the decisions for the future. [2:20:16] And then I'd also like to have an agenda item, like we had talked about of maybe issuing a resolve just to state what our opinion or our statement is on it. and if we wanted to have an independent review to look at our processes, come back with recommendations [2:20:41] on how can we do this better next time? So, I'd like those as future agenda items. [2:20:49] Okay. [2:20:52] Thank you. [2:20:57] I make a motion we adjourn. [2:20:59] Second. [2:21:00] All those in favor? 5 to 0 and the motion passes.