Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:02] Speaker A (unidentified): here we go we will bring the meeting of the board of assessment review and i will start with introducing myself i'm alan kimberly and everybody else can introduce themselves i'm kevin walsh i'm gail marshall jerry miller katie pepper there we go a minute because we don't have like we don't have an applicant we and we can do the hearing
[0:33] Speaker B (unidentified): without the applicant but and then we do need somebody to take minutes and then she'll be back
[0:38] Speaker A (unidentified): applicant is i know there was no apparently can't write but it is being recorded it is that's good we can fall back on that like i can try to take minutes no you have to you shouldn't do that we can fall back on the recording we'll fall back on the recording then yeah heidi i think has done that actually for us well with that in mind i think our first order of business is we have to re-nominate jerry for his position because you've never got seconded didn't ah i nominated jerry as a second as a vice chair all those in favor all right passed gail marshall and keating pepper yeah we should say that a lot when we're yes we should say that so i guess now we're going to go to the business at hand which is the request from anc martin to have her property reassessed and i believe i have been told that she has to they have to state their case and we have we have their paperwork to this procedure
[2:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Chairman, can I just state that I have met Ann in the past. She was a friend of John Carter's and I've been to that property 3-5 years ago. They wanted to some evaluation. I never gave him a number. It was in its unfinished condition at the time. I had previous years tried to buy the lot from them, and we were going to build up there, and they never sold me. obviously never sold me the lot and never really had any price on the property as it sits but i have had contact and i have had interest in the property and if we have a problem without my vote
[2:47] Speaker A (unidentified): i will abstain from the vote and we do so i guess you can okay great i move we accept the
[2:55] Speaker D (unidentified): recusal of king for this all those in favor i'm gail marshall by the way and did we say
[3:03] Speaker A (unidentified): jerry miller again did you second is recusal okay yes you are you're in the clear i'll be here and i appreciate that so
[3:17] Speaker B (unidentified): so i think there's some swearing into the parties whoever's testimony swear and tell the truth
[3:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, thank you. And there's no one else.
[3:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, the applicant is moderate.
[3:38] Speaker A (unidentified): We don't have any minutes. But we won't, I don't think we have the minutes ready to be approved. So we don't have that. We've introduced ourselves and we swear in a parties. Any people who give testimony and now we have to. To review the standards, procedures and summarize legal standards, which boards operate.
[4:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I need to read all this entirely up here.
[4:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, we'd last time, but the chairman moved that we accept the standards as ready.
[4:28] Speaker D (unidentified): Oh, you can't, but because you refuse us all right now, but it's a good idea. Okay.
[4:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, I would move that we accept them as written.
[4:39] Speaker D (unidentified): I see Gary Miller. Yeah, Marshall. I second that motion. And just to clarify, are we talking about the adopted May 23, 2007 Board of Assessment Review Rules of Procedure and Standards?
[4:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. All those in favor. All those against? Nothing. Okay. So we've gone through all that and we don't have anybody here to applicant. The applicant is not present.
[5:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, the order of presentation. The assessor would go first.
[5:29] Speaker A (unidentified): The assessor or the assessor's agent will explain the assessment evaluation methods used, any abatements previously granted, and present other background information.
[5:42] Speaker D (unidentified): I guess the question we have to ask is if we start this now, right now, and this person comes in 10 minutes later, are we going to let them do it all over again? And we're going to have to explain the procedure and all of that versus pausing for a few minutes. That's up to you, of course, but I just wonder if we get this rolling and then she shows
[6:08] Speaker E (unidentified): up. if she if she does show up in 10 minutes we should start over again yeah i agree but if she doesn't show up she was i assume knew that when the time was
[6:18] Speaker C (unidentified): well that's just one thing though it's you know it stated that the meeting starts at
[6:24] Speaker E (unidentified): six o'clock yeah so yeah i would i wouldn't say that it's all right to start and
[6:30] Speaker A (unidentified): if we have to start again we start again okay yes i concur thank you okay
[6:38] Speaker B (unidentified): i'm kyle avila i'm your assessor this meeting was duly published the notice was published on october 15th this is a legal public hearing this abatement request i wanted to start going over a little bit about tax administration and tax law in maine it's kind of governed between a combination of legislative law and case law assessor is appointed by the local select men sworn in annually by the town clerk i am recertified annually by the state as a certified main assessor number seven two six dash three i'm authorized by statute under title 36 six sub chapter five which is the administration of tax program abatements abatement law is governed under title 36 subsection 841 appeals are covered under same title 36 subsection 843 so they are very clearly defined legislative requirements under those statutes most importantly the legal presumption is that the assessment as determined by the assessors is valid until the taxpayer proves it is manifestly wrong there's a slew of supporting case law that supports this city of biddeford v adams 1999 more recently yusuf versus town of raven 2001 town of southwest harbor v harwood in 2000 and these cases go back to the early 1900s supporting that the assessment as determined by the assessor is valid until the taxpayer approves that is the manifest favor not enough for the taxpayer merely to show the assessors have made an error in judgment it must come forward with credible affirmative evidence of just value the courts have determined just value to be market value city waterville versus waterville homes southwest harvard v harwood person seeking an abatement based on an error in valuation has the burden of proving the assessed value is manifestly wrong taxpayer must be able to prove indisputably that the true value of property was substantially overestimated City of Waterville versus Waterville Homes, Newsome v. Raymond, Southwest Harbor v. Harwood. So now that's covered the statute that I'm operating under, the case law that supports assessors in their roles. I wanted to go over the basic procedure that I do for assessing the construction, right? So in assessing, April 1st is the snapshot date each year. that's called the assessment date so as close to april 1st as practicable i begin the first step in the assessment process which is to update existing records regarding the nature amount and value of all taxable property that's from title 36 subsection 708 so in late march i send out construction questionnaire percent complete form to all permit holders and i request it's a calculation to come up with a percent complete for a typical house under construction i send them to all permit holders there is an invitation for the property owner to set up a mutual agreeable time for me to go and inspect the interior a lot of times the that invitation gets declined and i'm forced to do the inspection from outside i'm sorry the assessor has no legal authority to trespass on the property where the owner denies access in such instances the assessor should make the most accurate listing possible from the closest allowed point if insufficient information is available it is not unreasonable reasonable to assume the highest estimate of property characteristics commensurate with what has been specifically viewed if i can't get inside i estimate owners who refuse to allow the assessor to properly inspect the property jeopardize success of subsequent appeals of the assessment covered under title 36 subsection 706a where the time the assessor has the right to request information if the property owner is unwilling to provide the information and they are denied the right to appeal so after i get the data i do my site inspection i come back to the office and i enter the building information into the assessing software and that includes sketching the perimeter the floor plan the outer perimeter is where we measure from and then we code those shapes depending on what the features are if it's an unfinished basement it's a first story a second story wood deck covered porch all those features are coded at that time right so more light no I'm just moved off my place so once the sketches in and all the characteristics the numbers of bedrooms number of bathrooms are in there's a depreciation page where you put in the year built and the code that it's under construction what's the percentage complete and that percentage number takes what it would be valued at 100 complete and just basically reduces it by that percentage as part of the depreciation until it's finished and so this is an annual process that i'll do for a house that's under construction send them the same form every year get an update on the percent complete updated in my system hopefully get out to inspect the interior but not always and that's kind of what happened in this case i do want to enter into the record something that i neglected to include in my memo to have copies for the board it's the list of all the properties in town that are under construction currently but this is the april 1st list of other buildings that are under construction similar to this case so it just shows the percentage complete doesn't show the valuation information because a lot of that i'm not sure would be relevant because you would be comparing to there's a lot of mansions going up and so those values wouldn't be relevant in this case but just to show that this is a standard procedure to assess a building when it's not complete to some value as of april 1st each year i also wanted to enter into the record of the memo that i supplied you last time explaining the timeline of the assessment on this particular property and there's a few exhibits that i wanted to highlight so the history on this particular property was lot was split created in 2022 the owner applied for a building permit i went out in the spring of 2023 i did get a response from the owner as far as the percentage complete but i did not get an invitation to do the interior it was a handwritten go in any time there's nobody there i have a policy of not going in buildings alone and so i do my inspection from the outside of that way
[15:29] Speaker D (unidentified): i just asked what you're looking for would you tell the applicant that or the
[15:34] Speaker C (unidentified): property owner that your policy is that you wouldn't go in if they were to call and tell
[15:40] Speaker B (unidentified): me that yes right oh yeah this was a handwritten letter i did not so in 2023 i did my first inspection from the exterior in the list of exhibits goes the percentage complete form returned by the owner that would be the exhibit 3.2 do you want to just look at this briefly we can just go through so each line in this table are we all looking at the same thing yep share my screen so you can see which one of this calculation is a phase of the construction and i asked you to say well how much of this space is done all done it's 100 for that step and then just to the right of that the percent of total we add all those up at the bottom you know if it's a if that phase is at 50 and it's a score of two i would give it a one that was all add up that first year the house was on site it was pretty you know obviously unfinished and it calculated to 60 percent complete and so that's what i used for that year assessed it at that property card that subsequent assessment came in at 183 and a lot of that was what's that work i pulled most of the information off of the building permit as far as the bed and pound we'll notice there's two bedrooms two baths which keep note of that so we'll come back to that follow up in 2024 sent the same letter got no response at all did a drop-in site inspection because i got to look at them anyways whether the owner participates or not and from visual inspection from the outside i assessed it 90 complete And in 2025, last year, I got a response from the taxpayer suggesting the percent complete was somehow lower than the prior year, but no interior inspection scheduled. So again, I was left to estimate. Not much changed. I left it at 90% complete based on my visual inspection. Wasn't able to get inside. I didn't see anything that had changed, and so I left it at 90%.
[19:06] Speaker C (unidentified): Not the 83 that's written on, or the 1425, or is that the different page? Exhibit 6.
[19:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. That's the owner's estimate.
[19:23] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, that was the owner. Yeah, that's the owner. Right. Okay.
[19:25] Speaker B (unidentified): And the visual inspection from the outside didn't look like it was much different, so I left it at 90%.
[19:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Is that right if I ask the question? How can, if it was 90% and then starts going down every year for us completion of it, if it hasn't changed?
[19:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Good question. That's why I left it at 90%. I think they were starting to see since the site, the construction had stopped. this i don't want to guess what they were by they said it was less all right so in this year 2026 percent complete form was answered with a handwritten letter saying there was no change and this was from the son chris carter who let me know that john carter had passed and that the project was on hold for divorce proceedings divorce
[20:30] Speaker C (unidentified): proceedings for a dead man he's a power of attorney
[20:39] Speaker B (unidentified): john bird son our attorney project on hold no change since last year and then he gave me his contact [Speaker D (unidentified): and] then i got an email from ann the parent new owner former wife of the general living permit we started building the house and we tried to schedule the interior inspection in april of 2026 but we were mutually unable to make that appointment and it just fell through we couldn't find a time that worked when i was out inspecting and so didn't hear back from her from that point and so made my inspection from the outside again but she did on that telephone call explain a lot of her concerns about the damage of transport the damage that had been done since it had been sitting idle for a couple of years and i was willing to buy that okay it's sat i've seen houses uninhabited and how fast they fall apart and so i knocked down the percentage completely taking her word for it sight unseen so that's when i think down 83 okay 80 sorry and i committed the taxes in 2026 at a new site repeat that reduced to 37 roughly 37 not yet no okay not yet that was just the my guess without having seen the interior based on her description and then committed the tax as of july one and then and then she requested it informal so as an assessor i like to take an informal approach to start somebody has a problem with their valuation come see me we'll talk we'll try to resolve it at the informal level if there's no satisfaction then i ask them to formally appeal or apply for an abatement and so in the informal stage she requested that i do in other words pointed out in an email a list a laundry list of issues my response and these are in the exhibits my response was i need to get inside to verify to all of our points i mean the dash were falling off i could see that i was you know i adjusted for that but the interior stuff i really needed to see it and so that was my
[23:31] Speaker C (unidentified): letter exhibit 12 sent on july 14th and the email from her sorry is exhibit 11. yeah yes one of her emails yeah the one you just referred to and she wants to go from a value of $304, $400, down to zero, $200.
[23:50] Speaker B (unidentified): She was requesting the value to be zero. Yeah. I was able to make my inspection. I had her builder was there with me, as well as the deputy code officer. Interestingly, I asked the builder, well, if you had to guess what percent complete this is and how much it takes to finish it, what would you say? he said 80 85 so he agreed with the percentage that i had on record there's exhibit 12 response to her okay so here is the percent complete form so when i go to inspect i bring one of these forms with me and you know fill it out right there on site and the stuff she was talking about the severe damage and the weathering was not apparent this house is a modular house a hairline away from being done walls were covered there was a there was some there was a few features like there was a door jam that was out that needed to be installed there was a strip on the floor that needed to be finished because it's the seam where the two modular pieces come together they hadn't finished that but i didn't see if there was furniture in there all the fixtures were in when was this july in july okay and so i came up the 83 based on that inspection because you know the interior drywall there were some stuff that needed to be fixed so i put in 90 same with the other features there but then i also recognized recognize this was an unusual situation because the utilities are in there's a septic system there is power holes outside the house there is a well dug but none of them are actually hooked into the house so the utility systems are there they're just not tied in so they need a plumber to come in tie it in put it on check for leaks same with the power same with the septic you take
[26:10] Speaker E (unidentified): pictures when you're doing an inspection i do right
[26:14] Speaker B (unidentified): so at the bottom of this form i noted that the you know for this unusual situation i took off 10 on the percent complete to recognize that the utilities were in but weren't actually hooked up and so that's 73 is what i issued as an abatement so here's some notes changed a few of the features on the interior like the flooring there was no tile it was actually vinyl and carpet and then i took off the heat fuel so it was gas i took it off because it wasn't hooked up same with the heat type it was hot water but it wasn't tied in so i took that off but one thing isn't it still the same
[27:02] Speaker C (unidentified): it's the same type of heat there's baseboards in there yeah so that's still the same type of heat it doesn't matter but they didn't have the furnace in
[27:13] Speaker B (unidentified): so i took it off i was trying to help just like yeah you're doing you i thought you were being very fair my husband's property shouldn't you know have the wherewithal to come in and swoop in and get done and so i wanted to recognize the what was there in the state that it was in one thing that didn't help her was there's actually three bedrooms in this house the permit said two bedrooms the septic systems rated for three the layout of the floor plan there's three bedrooms so that didn't help that actually brought the value up a little but then i adjusted or sent the fleet down taking out the utilities so she did get on the right side of an abatement and so i did drop the value issued that abatement and
[28:06] Speaker C (unidentified): this is these photos when was this card updated i mean if i was looking for photos of this
[28:12] Speaker B (unidentified): yes that's this is it there's like that was this year this is a deck on that yep they were trying to so they were stairs but they're construction stairs and they had been blown off and they were kind of put back in place just so we could get inside but there's
[28:30] Speaker A (unidentified): a problem along the side that this is yeah and there's also now a meter on the corner of the building which is showing there's electricity in that meeting as of april 1st there was
[28:45] Speaker B (unidentified): was not okay so that'll be next year i'll pick that stuff up is that the side deck line on the ground there that was presumably would be the deck to go to the left side of the house okay so the side that they're talking about we were actually we were there that's the deck
[29:03] Speaker C (unidentified): because there's a section of the roof that's like kind of there was like a short little deck on the other side of the house that's the short deck because they tore that off and put a bigger deck
[29:14] Speaker A (unidentified): on did you do a site visit yes we did a site visit you didn't report the site visit and it wasn't on the agenda yeah we had we may have i had it i may have to excuse myself and circle back did they publish it but that was coming up site visit
[29:33] Speaker C (unidentified): if i know from our previous meeting which was would have been in the minutes of this but we
[29:40] Speaker B (unidentified): have to put it in the newspaper oh i didn't know i didn't see the notice in the paper
[29:49] Speaker A (unidentified): you get the notice because you got an email i have the notice and it said potential site visit
[29:57] Speaker B (unidentified): at five i thought gail had piped in and said no site visit i didn't need a site visit and then
[30:04] Speaker D (unidentified): three of us said we didn't need a site yeah i said i did but then oh you did sorry yeah if you
[30:10] Speaker E (unidentified): guys if it was advertised that there was going to be a site visit then they can talk it does not say
[30:16] Speaker A (unidentified): in our ad that there is a site question i think you need to all right that isn't something you're
[30:23] Speaker B (unidentified): not you didn't do oh great i have pictures i would like to see the pictures of this depth but i mean that feature is minimal on the satin fishing okay pattern decks are not but why don't you continue with your yes please thank you and so she was awarded an abatement reduce the building value from 3044 to 267. she asked for an explanation of what changed so I removed the exterior debt from the sketch because I think in our inspection in July that back deck wasn't on and that would be next year's inspection anyway the contractor was about to finish those so that's why you saw the deck on the back that would have changed the flow they would apply to next year's valuation anyway correct yeah okay change the flooring type change the heat fuel change the heat type change the bedroom town and then the appreciation for the percent complete went down from 80 to 73 percent and that's the card after I made my changes so that on the lower right this is that covered deck you were seeing yes yeah that was on i did keep that one yes she's now on the ground in the picture that's the that's the deck on the other side and then she wasn't satisfied and so it's her right to i asked her to do a formal abatement application no new information in that application just finished utilities severe your modular structural fractures unobserved the damaged sub flooring i didn't see that i didn't see any water intrusion in the house at all and so i denied that formal abatement request and that was her feel to you all i did want to counter to her points in her appeal to you new because it changed now she does have a building value she's her opinion of the total property value should be 400 000. so that gives a nominal building value of 50 000. no supporting information where she came up with 400 000. I haven't seen a sale for 400 000 on
[33:16] Speaker C (unidentified): detail and meters is there a any documentation but because that's a module on what the cost of
[33:24] Speaker B (unidentified): that module was the permit application has a cost of construction that the applicants can or can do not have to fill out that said three hundred thousand there's a line on my percent complete forms for the cost of construction one of those forms said 200 000 so I'm seeing modulars three to four hundred thousand this size is about the going rate I don't have documentation she didn't submit any documentation for the cost of the module and you're allowed to pull information
[33:58] Speaker C (unidentified): within like a five mile radius of houses that are isn't that how that usually works for us how you
[34:04] Speaker B (unidentified): My values are based on national pricing. It's a table that's built from Marshall and Swift, which is a big company. So it has nothing to do with our area. It's around the country and gives you regional costs. And that's what all assessors basically use. So the industry standard for coming up with construction costs. That's why our building values look so off. We're using national pricing when local construction costs are one and a half to two times higher than what those report yes and so in her reasons for requesting an abatement she made my arguments for me that the town's records confirmed the structure is not complete fully functional residents completion factor has been reduced that's her argument or yeah but not the zero not zero it was 90 in 2025 the response suggested 78 but never verified by the interior inspection so i left it at nine percent 2026 it was 80 on the original assessment again no inspection but over the phone description so i adjusted it 80 to accommodate her over the phone description 73 following the july 2026 inspection yeah i did my inspection and that's that's what i calculated for percent complete so these are her points on item 15 in her formal abatement application she says the adjusted property card this is a building assessment of 267 and a total assessment of 612 200 despite property lacking essential systems and remaining substantially unfinished It's a matter of opinion. My informed opinion is it is substantially finished. And there's small bits to get it complete. Your law inspection resulted in town changing heat fuel from gas to not. And system from hot water to not. Or other demonstrating that the home is not in a condition comparable to a finished residential structure. structure it was not valued as a finished residential structure impact on market value the properties in complete state and absence of utilities the cost of completing the unfinished work which should what I've asked her to give me an estimate how much do you think it's there's a phrase in assessing what's the cost of here you have an issue with the property how much is it going to cost to get this finished i can use that as a basis for making an adjustment on no information on how much it's going to cost to finish the cost of correcting deficiencies so she did include some estimates from her contractors yeah i roughly totaled them up to about 140k i'm not exactly sure what a lot of that work is covering it's just got some numbers and date inscriptions whether that was done before april 1st or not i'm not entirely sure but from what i've seen in those estimates about 140k in contractor work but we're not exactly sure of what but because there's structural issues modular transit damage i did not see that on my inspection it looked fairly sound to me but it was just not finished modular you got two halves of a house that come together just seam that runs down the end it'll it takes a little bit of cosmetic work well the
[38:20] Speaker C (unidentified): foundation work has to be done
[38:24] Speaker B (unidentified): it has a full foundation yeah yes so that has to have this foundation it's 77 000 i guess it's already done yeah and the plumbing shows is paid there's no owner's opinion of value is 400 But, that's really just her opinion about it. not founded in sales or, critical.
[38:52] Speaker D (unidentified): She hasn't presented any appraisals or anything like that I've seen.
[38:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Sure, that's my case. the question before you. Is did she prove that the assessment is manifestly wrong? wrong. I hereby request the appeal to identify.
[39:19] Speaker E (unidentified): And we have her request that she sent in right with all these pictures.
[39:28] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, those pictures are there but there's no identification of when they were taken or what they represent or I mean and the kids are cute.
[39:39] Speaker C (unidentified): No, based on, in my opinion, based on your inspection, when you finally get to get in to get a better evaluation, I don't see where an abatement is warranted. I concur.
[40:02] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean, she obviously has the burden of proof, and it's a substantial burden. she has to that's the manifestly unjust kind of standard that 's a significant burden to have to meet and it's clear from the procedures of case law that the ball's in her court to do that why she's not here or we don't know but we can't and we just can't take anything from that so i don't know what we have to do except because we can't question her about any of this stuff i agree i don't i don't see how what we have to go on to justify finding that she has met a substantial burden to prove that this is inaccurate plus to me
[41:01] Speaker C (unidentified): over the years it looks like the assessors has been more than fair with reductions right i built them and he was not allowed in the sea to give a fair evaluation i
[41:23] Speaker D (unidentified): mean behind this there appears my guess is that there's a this folks have had a struggle kind of build this you gotta complete this but that's that's kind of then yes fortune it doesn't add into what the
[41:41] Speaker C (unidentified): value of the property is yeah i don't think that isn't any baron almost yeah that's not what we're here to say it's about the value of the property sure and the value originally especially being You know, the first one at 90%, and me, I had a hard time figuring out how can it be at 90% one year, and now it's slowly going down, and that's due to lack of completion. But the building is still roughly, you know, even at 85% is complete. complete right they've
[42:27] Speaker A (unidentified): actually gone backwards with removing that deck yeah and then half finishing another one would at this point would we take a vote well we have a motion section 10 of the procedures section 10 of my procedures we have a motion to close the yeah we
[43:00] Speaker E (unidentified): are deliberating engineering that's what we're doing the
[43:06] Speaker B (unidentified): hearing and commence deliberations yeah have we deliberated
[43:11] Speaker D (unidentified): well we sort of need to state that we have you need to state that we closed that here in the evidentiary part of the proceeding that's close we've got the data that we're going to have to
[43:23] Speaker A (unidentified): deliberate on so you need to like affirm for the record that state i shall close deliberations
[43:32] Speaker D (unidentified): at this point it's kind of like when bill says public hearing i'm going to close public hearings
[43:37] Speaker C (unidentified): that's what we're doing and
[43:42] Speaker B (unidentified): then we deliberate let me deliberate and you'll be wanting to have a summary finding of fact right that you'll all vote on
[43:51] Speaker A (unidentified): and then we need the basis for oh my god we need one of those long motions
[43:56] Speaker E (unidentified): i do not have to make a long use for it i have the findings of fact
[44:03] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah that the well
[44:06] Speaker E (unidentified): building is essentially 83 complete and now we need a motion that's one of the findings of fact that the other one of the findings of facts i would say is that there was no evidence presented by the appeal of ellen to prove any discrepancy in the
[44:32] Speaker A (unidentified): appraisal right yeah that's next and then there's no based on based on the evidence and testimony
[44:40] Speaker E (unidentified): presented yeah by pedro and that there was once again malicious and there's no evidence of
[44:48] Speaker A (unidentified): manifest error and there's no finding that's manifest here there's no finding of discrimination
[44:55] Speaker D (unidentified): there's no finding of elimination fraud or illegality in the in the actions of the assessor to the other possible grounds for an abatement so am
[45:24] Speaker A (unidentified): i supposed to realize that so you're making
[45:26] Speaker D (unidentified): taking that in the form of a motion yeah what was the fourth thing you said oh no evidence of
[45:32] Speaker E (unidentified): discrimination no manifest error no just you know no discrimination that we find that it is
[45:40] Speaker B (unidentified): in fact 83 complete no
[45:45] Speaker E (unidentified): evidence by the appellant to be contrary to that finding and that they offered no additional new information that applies additional new information And also, this is a finding the fact that the appellant didn't appear. I would think you should put that in there. Yeah. That the appellant did not appear at the hearing or. Right, but the fact that it didn't appear, she didn't appear doesn't make that judgment. Right? No, but part of the, it is 1 of the facts. Okay. It's a hearing and she wasn't here.
[46:25] Speaker A (unidentified): no one was here to represent them so there's five besides
[46:33] Speaker C (unidentified): the packet that they sent aside from the
[46:35] Speaker B (unidentified): packet but no live which we weren't able to question if i may i would recommend striking the finding the fact that the percent complete because i did actually assess it at 73
[46:48] Speaker D (unidentified): so these are the three standards i said we know with no finding
[46:58] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay, what's the three that needs? Yeah, they're not easier than the findings of fact would be one. Property was the burden of proof is this is to prove that it's manifestly wrong. And in that there are three parts. The property was substantially overvalued. There was unjust discrimination and the assessment was fraudulent, dishonest or legal.
[47:25] Speaker B (unidentified): legal. Those are three findings of fact.
[47:28] Speaker E (unidentified): To prove that there is no manifestly wrong behavior. And then I think we should also include the no new evidence was offered by the appellant
[47:44] Speaker B (unidentified): to justify changes. So that's four. And
[47:51] Speaker E (unidentified): that's enough. And then based on that, based on those findings of fact, is denied, I would, I would move
[48:00] Speaker A (unidentified): to deny it so is that 's the motion that we have and it's based on those four most
[48:07] Speaker E (unidentified): findings of fact we should move to deny okay then we i would move to die yes i will second
[48:12] Speaker A (unidentified): it kevin walls all those in favor aye no other discussion opposed
[48:19] Speaker B (unidentified): there we go and one abstention yes one obsession one exception Get that here
[48:26] Speaker C (unidentified): we go. Well, that's 30% of these appeals. I will have we make a motion, which I was about to say. So, yeah.
[48:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Order we'll do is we'll write up the safety and somebody will. Formally, I can pop in and we'll mail it.
[48:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Send me a note on my, email. email i haven't gotten out of my phone yet but i've been too scared to try it thank you
[48:58] Speaker E (unidentified): well i would move to adjourn i will second that motion
[49:02] Speaker A (unidentified): hi thank you thank you carl hey thanks for being