Pownal Planning Board approves Pollock subdivision amendment, reviews mobile home park sketch
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:03] Okay. welcome everybody. this is the Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 Town of Panel Planning Board meeting. this is the call to order. say what?
[0:20] Public hearing.
[0:21] yeah. So, we're I'm going to start the planning board meeting first and we'll just have the public hearing embedded within it. I'll just follow the agenda. first, we'll start with introductions. my name is Todd Melon. I'm the chair.
[0:39] When the secretary,
[0:41] Mercedes poor, vice chair,
[0:44] Ryan Stornelli, member.
[0:47] Yeah, go ahead, Tim.
[0:48] Tim Giddon, CEO.
[0:50] we do have a quorum, so we'll go ahead and get started. The first order of business is to continue on with the Pollock subdivision amendment number three regarding Caleb's way. [1:08] we've met the ordinance requirement for the notification of a butters. we had our sitewalk earlier today. this will constitute the public hearing for the amendment. I don't know there
[1:29] if you if you guys want to say a quick word about the project, you can keep it short. We've already talked about this. you can have a couple of minutes.
[1:40] Sure. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And ladies and gentlemen of the board, my name is Michael Skolnick, permaning attorney for the applicants. do want to thank the board for the conducting their sitewalk earlier today as well as allowing us to amend our application since the last meeting so we can present you with some additional information that you requested.
[2:00] we did hear the board's comments at the last meeting and we revised the narrative and plan based on that to address your concerns. I also want to thank the town's planner who did a great job at outlining exactly what was changed and the status of this project in her memo. Just to go over those just to be brief as well.
[2:22] in the narrative itself, we did outline the four separate waiver requests that we're going for. Those were the reduction of the 20 foot minimum pavement width to 16 feet, the reduction of the 4ft minimum shoulders for the road to two feet, the removal of the shoulders at the wetland crossing itself to save wetland impacts.
[2:46] And then the relocation of the turnaround from 60 ft away that's required by your ordinance to 97 ft from the terminus of the road. that's also to reduce wetland impacts wherever possible at this there on the plan itself. this plan was expanded to the entire Pollock subdivision instead of just focusing in on the roadway itself.
[3:10] that was at the request of the board and also lists the four waiverss that were requesting on the plan itself. And lastly, we did hear the board wanted a note in the plan. We added note 16 which says that if any of these lots were to be divided in the future or any change to the road then they would have to come back before this board for review.
[3:32] At this point I think we addressed all of the concerns that we heard from the board at the last meeting. we're more than happy to answer any questions that the board has though.
[3:42] Thank you.
[3:45] Tim, did you have any comments that you wanted to make before I open it up to the public?
[3:50] no. I think that everything speaks for itself. I think Natasha's memo lays it out well. Okay.
[3:58] Is there any public comment?
[4:03] Okay. Having heard none.
[4:14] having heard none at 605 will close the public hearing on the public subdivision amendment number three and we will now start the business meeting of the planning board. the first order of business is the secretary's report
[4:35] approval of the September 16, 2026 regular meeting minutes. Did anybody have any comments, concerns? Yes. [clears throat]
[4:46] I just wanted and thank you both for doing a great job on these minutes. I just wanted to correct add Isabelle Lee to the guests. She should be listed as a guest. the Pollock is spelled with a P O L O C K instead of a CK on page one.
[5:07] And Frasier is spelled F R A S E R on page one. So, we'll get those names straight. And then Isabelle on throughout the document is called Isabella and her name's Isabelle. So, if we can just make those name changes, that'd be great.
[5:24] Okay,
[5:26] I move. did anybody else have any other comments? No. I move that we accept the meeting minutes as amended.
[5:35] Second that.
[5:37] All in favor.
[5:40] Motion passes.
[5:45] Old business. We'll move on to the Pollock subdivision. Mercedes, I'll have you take over this portion if you don't mind.
[5:59] first of all, I'd like to thank the applicant and all of their representatives because the note section on the new plan is very thorough and exactly what I think was missing in former plans for this subdivision. So, that really helps us both document what we're talking about and lay the path moving forward and lay a great example.
[6:24] I think I would like to make a motion that finds this application complete.
[6:32] Tim, did you have any concerns about
[6:35] second?
[6:36] Oh, yes. I second. Yes.
[6:39] Okay. Discussion on that? [laughter]
[6:42] No, I find it complete as well.
[6:43] Okay.
[6:45] Okay. Do I have to read the exact motion that she proposes?
[6:49] I think I would.
[6:50] Okay. All right. I 'd like to amend my motion and I'd like to make a motion to find the amended subdivision plan for the Pollock subdivision on behalf of Brian and Christine Fraser located on tax map 3 lot 60.05 complete in regard to the submission requirements.
[7:10] Second.
[7:12] All in favor?
[7:13] I.
[7:14] Any opposed?
[7:18] Motion passes.
[7:20] Okay. And then tonight it was nice because we got to see these four requested waivers in kind of insuti in terms of where they were. The applicant is asking for four specific waivers, two related to the specs of the road, one related to the shoulders at that wetland crossing, and then moving the hammerhead terminus length back from the end of that public road a little bit further to
[7:50] get it out of the wetland. And that was helpful to see at the sitewalk actually today. so as for the four requested waivers,
[8:03] I would I would like to I am in favor of granting those waivers and I will make motions as to their as to each one.
[8:14] Yeah, why don't we
[8:15] Okay.
[8:16] make a motion for each one.
[8:17] Okay.
[8:18] And then I would it's it's nice that Natasha has the quoted part. So, I think you probably just need to read the quoted part as the waiver because that is in the applicant's words.
[8:36] Are you looking at page three?
[8:38] I am
[8:39] of Natasha's w memo
[8:41] on the memo.
[8:42] Yeah.
[8:45] Page two.
[8:48] Oh, I was looking at page three.
[8:53] Oh, okay. Yeah. Yeah, we can do that.
[8:55] It's a little bit shorter, I think.
[8:56] Yeah.
[8:57] Okay. as we talked about last meeting and then moving forward, I would like to make a motion to wave the geometric standard under the p public and private roads ordinance, section 16, appendix A, item two, wherein the minimum width of the payment is 20 ft for a minor deadend street 600 ft or less, but 16 feet here is to be allowed.
[9:23] I second. Any discussion?
[9:31] All in favor? I.
[9:34] None opposed. Motion passes.
[9:37] I would like to make a motion to wave the geometric standard under the public and private roads ordinance section 16 appendix A item 7 wherein the minimum width of the shoulders is 4 feet for a m minor deadend street 600 ft or less but two feet is to be allowed here.
[9:57] I second.
[10:00] Any discussion? No. All in favor?
[10:04] I.
[10:04] Motion passes. I would like to make a motion to wave the geometric standard under the private and pro public and private roads ordinance section 16 appendix G wherein the shoulders are a requirement under the geometric standards for minor streets figure but shoulders are permitted to be omitted at the section of the proposed wetland crossing in this subdivision in this amendment.
[10:30] I second. Any discussion? No. All in favor? I
[10:36] motion passes.
[10:38] I would like to make a motion to wave the geometric standard under the private and public roads ordinance section 16 appendix D article 8 wherein is required that a turnaround is to be located within 60 ft of the terminus of a dead-end road for the geometric standards for turnarounds figure but 97 ft will be allowed here.
[10:59] I second. Any discussion? No. All in favor? Motion passes.
[11:06] All right.
[11:10] In Oh, yeah. Sorry.
[11:11] no. Go ahead.
[11:12] Okay. In terms of the entire application, I would like to make a motion to approve the amended subdivision plan for the Pollock subdivision. On behalf of Brian and Christine Frasier located at tax map 3, lot 60.05 based on the application materials, plan sets, application, applicant testimony, and the findings of fact and conclusions of law in the planner memo dated October 21st, 2026
[11:39] with modifications as detailed in the no
[11:43] no. I think we should [11:47] go backwards,
[11:48] go back,
[11:49] okay,
[11:50] just briefly and just make it a habit of running through the conclusions of law. [11:57] which is [11:58] okay page four
[11:59] the brutal part where we just go through each one
[12:02] okay
[12:04] and just I'm trying to make a habit of that because in your motion to approve it suggests that we have gone through that which we have not
[12:14] which we have not in this case because this is an amended subdivision and we're not talking about the entire subdivision do we have to go through the conclusions of law that don't pertain to the actual amendment or do we have to say those are not applicable here?
[12:34] Just read through it and do not app not
[12:38] so still hit them. Okay.
[12:43] Sorry.
[12:43] Nope. I'm loving this. [laughter] Welcome to the dramatic reading tonight. so you would like to go through the conclusions of law on this one?
[12:51] I'd like to go through the conclusions of law.
[12:57] And is each one a vote separately?
[13:00] No.
[13:01] I think you can just
[13:04] go through them.
[13:04] Okay.
[13:06] What we found
[13:08] are there do we have to discuss these as a board or does anyone want to look at these before we start that?
[13:14] I think we've all looked at them and that we feel that they are all met. If somebody has one that stands out as a problem, what what I want what I suggest to do is read each one.
[13:35] [13:37] say what you feel because you're the one that's gone for this.
[13:40] Say what you feel how this [13:45] how this particular conclusion of law is impacted by this subdivision or not impacted. and then if there is discussion anybody on the board just speak up. Otherwise, I'll just let you run with it.
[14:00] Okay.
[14:02] having reviewed both the application and going through last meeting and the sitewalk and especially looking at the resubmitted materials tonight.
[14:18] In terms of this amended subdivision application,
[14:24] I am suggesting the board find that the proposed subdivision will not result in undue water or air pollution.
[14:37] The proposed subdivision will have sufficient water available for the reasonably foreseeable needs of the subdivision. This is only adding a house in an existing lot and we're really talking about the road here. So that should not be something that
[14:55] I think this would be an NA and
[14:57] Oh, you think it's an NA? Okay.
[15:02] Yeah.
[15:02] Natasha did not, but I think you're absolutely right. Yeah, she didn't flag this as an NA because the lot was already on the direct one. [clears throat] I think Tim is absolutely right and this is not applicable. I agree.
[15:16] Okay. The proposed subdivision
[15:21] again will not cause an reasonable burden on existing water reply because that lot was existing. This is not applicable to this amendment.
[15:31] The proposed subdivision will not cause unreasonable soil erosion or reduction in the capacity of land to hold water so that a dangerous or unhealthy condition may result. The plans submitted are thorough and in line with Army Corps of Engineers in all of the specs.
[15:50] The proposed subdivision will not cause unreasonable highway or public road congestion or unsafe conditions with respect to the use of highways or public roads existing or proposed.
[16:04] No one drives on this road.
[16:08] The proposed subdivision
[16:11] will provide for adequate solid and sewage waste disposal. There is plenty of land on this lot
[16:18] and not applicable. All right, I'm catching up with you, Tim. I'm just talking about the road.
[16:24] Seven would be not applicable.
[16:27] Okay. Do I have to read it, though?
[16:29] no.
[16:32] Seven is not applicable to this amendment.
[16:38] say eight is not applicable.
[16:42] Should we say it is a private road? Should we say that? Because it's not going to prov [clears throat] make any more burden on the public services. Even though we're extending a road, it's not going to impact Yeah, I'm going to say that one. Yeah, I'm going to say that one. The proposed subdivision will not place an unreasonable burden on the ability of local governments to provide municipal or governmental services as this amendment is a private road.
[17:08] The proposed subdivision will not have an undue adverse effect on the scenic or natural beauty of the area, aesthetics, historic sites or rare and irreplaceable natural areas. The applicant has attended to the wetland issues and the waiver in terms of the reduction of roast sides also speaks to this.
[17:30] The proposed subdivision is in conformance with the duly adopted subdivision regulation or ordinance, comprehensive plan, developmental plan or land use plan as their amendment has met all of our requirements.
[17:47] So the question though is the original subdivision doesn't necessarily meet that right.
[17:51] No but that is not the fault of the applicants.
[17:57] Yeah.
[17:57] So on that one the waivers actually make it you grant in the waivers makes it compliant.
[18:03] Yeah.
[18:03] okay. So it is in conformance.
[18:08] Yes.
[18:08] The waivers apply. Yes.
[18:10] And that's what I said right? I said is.
[18:13] Yes.
[18:13] Yes. Okay.
[18:17] the subdivider has adequate financial and technical capacity to meet the above stated standards.
[18:23] Can we talk about that for a second?
[18:25] Sure.
[18:26] Because I [clears throat] guess I didn't see anything. I might have missed any application and I know we're supposed to talk about
[18:35] guarantees which would speak to that having that financial capability.
[18:43] the roads built. So, it's not
[18:47] we can only talk about the amendment,
[18:48] but it's not really
[18:50] it's it's built to this to the final layer of surface surface gravel. So, it's it's 99.9% built.
[19:03] Yeah. So, it's it'd be one thing if it hadn't started.
[19:07] Yeah.
[19:07] They've they've already built it to the standards. So, I don't know that it's important at this point. As much as I agree with
[19:16] with the comment of us needing to have a performance standard to have to make sure that money is available for sure,
[19:26] but the when you look at the road, the project's pretty much done and so putting the finishing touches on it shouldn't be a big deal. Yeah, that's the that's the only way I was looking at it. I was thinking about that as well.
[19:42] For sure.
[19:43] The CO is conditioned on that. Like that has to be done before you'll issue a CO, right?
[19:48] So, I guess that's our last little air protection,
[19:50] right?
[19:53] 12 is not applicable to this amendment.
[20:00] 13 is not applicable to this amendment.
[20:05] All freshwater wetlands within the proposed subdivision have been identified on any map submitted as part of the application regardless of the size of these wetlands. I think this application does a very thorough job of not only identifying the wetlands but explaining the remediation and especially that new covert.
[20:32] I think 15 is not applicable. Any
[20:37] river, stream, or brook within the within or abuing the proposed subdivision has been identified on any maps and submitted as part of the application.
[20:49] The proposed subdivision will provide for adequate storm water management. That is the largest covert I have ever seen. [laughter] [clears throat]
[21:02] In the opinion of our consulting planner, 18, 19, 20, and 21 are not applicable to this amendment.
[21:11] Okay.
[21:13] Is there any other comment from the board about any of the conclusions of law?
[21:21] Okay. I think you can go back to your
[21:28] the motion.
[21:29] All right. Should I make the motion and then we discuss these separate items because there is a little bit of I think there might be some discussion here.
[21:37] Yeah, let's let's go ahead and do that. Make the motion.
[21:39] Okay.
[21:42] I'm going to make the motion to approve the amended subdivision plan for the Polloc subdivision on behalf of Brian and Christine Frasier located at tax map 3, lot 60.05 based on the application materials, plan sets, applicant testimony, and the findings of fact and conclusions of law.
[22:01] I want to [gasps] I don't want to get you through the whole thing. Approve with conditions.
[22:07] Oh, okay.
[22:11] That's in the last part there.
[22:12] Yes.
[22:13] Yes. Dated October 21st, 2026 with modifications as detailed in the following conditions of approval. Yeah. Would
[22:25] you like me to say these or do you want to discuss these?
[22:28] Go ahead and say.
[22:29] All right. Motion.
[22:30] The proposed conditions of approval are to revise the final plan to add a note referencing all conditions of approval. Two, prior to the issuance of a B building permit, the applicant shall provide the following to be reviewed by the town attorney and receive select board approval for A, performance guarantee based on a construction cost estimate to be provided by the applicant.
[22:56] B, the inspection fee equal to 2% of the cost of the required improvements or pay an inspection fee equal to the estimated cost of inspection by the town engineer or consulting engineer. and C and the form of these funds shall be provided through an irrevocable letter of credit, a bond or in cash.
[23:20] So, Oh, so sorry. I second.
[23:24] Second.
[23:24] Okay, let's talk.
[23:26] Yeah.
[23:26] Okay.
[23:28] I think that's another NA.
[23:30] Yeah.
[23:31] Yeah. I think these are options for you guys that
[23:36] we're talking Yeah. Now we get to discuss. So once we make the motion, we now we get to discuss. Yeah.
[23:40] Y
[23:41] thank you for that.
[23:42] Y
[23:44] as we just discussed, I mean obviously number one needs to be in as part of the conditions, but I feel like number two
[23:58] more or less has been met because of the current condition of the road. So the need for the performance guarantee personally I don't think is really necessary.
[24:17] Yeah, I agree. Just as long as Tim verifies that the root as the top layer.
[24:23] So do we want to alter that? So number two would be instead of the performance guarantee language, the CEO approves
[24:40] u final road condition prior occupancy permit
[24:45] prior to o occupancy permit so they can continue to build before they put the final layer.
[24:56] Agree on that would be the
[25:00] I believe so. Well, [25:08] they already have I guess they already have the notes on the plans, but yeah, I think I would I think I would just leave that.
[25:24] Point of clarity. Tim, do they have a building permit? And we're looking. So this is really for an occup is the is should the motion actually say for the issuance of an occupancy permit?
[25:35] Right.
[25:35] Should Yeah.
[25:36] Yeah. So rather than a building permit.
[25:38] So CEO will
[25:43] approve
[25:46] final road condition.
[26:01] Do you have a restated member?
[26:03] So I'm I would like to amend the motion that number two CEO will approve final condition of the road prior to issuance of an occupancy permit.
[26:19] this is where I always I am I am definitely not a a master of Robert's rules. So, I'm a little unsure of Do we have to if I if we amend that?
[26:39] [26:44] second
[26:46] and then can we just say as amended?
[26:51] Can I make
[26:52] Yeah, please. [clears throat]
[26:54] I don't think we need to do anything with this one because we've already discussed that the road is already built and accepted as we viewed tonight, acceptable as we viewed tonight. Right.
[27:07] I think that having the road finished is part of my job before
[27:14] regardless
[27:14] and you don't have to say it.
[27:16] Right. Okay. That's fair.
[27:18] Okay. So, we will just remove two al together. I move that Why don't Why don't we just start over?
[27:29] Okay. Can we put in the notes? I think that because we've been talking Oh, I just want to make sure that we're talking for the notes in this particular case because the amendment is already built that this financial piece is not applicable to this amendment. And
[27:49] I just want to make sure we're saying that very clearly as we've been talking about
[27:54] performance
[27:55] in the notes of the meeting.
[27:56] Exactly. That's what I mean. In the notes of the meeting, I just want it stated because of the nature of this particular application.
[28:02] Yes.
[28:03] Okay.
[28:03] Right.
[28:04] So,
[28:05] yes, John.
[28:10] And then we can and then we can redo the motion.
[28:14] Okay. Right. Yeah. Thank you.
[28:18] Okay.
[28:18] I withdraw my amendment.
[28:20] I withdraw my motion.
[28:22] Yeah. [laughter]
[28:26] All right. I would like to make an emotion.
[28:32] [laughter]
[28:33] I'm feeling very emotional about this. I would like to make a mo an a motion to approve the amended subdivision plan for the Pollock subdivision on behalf of Brian and Christine Frasier located at tax map 3, lot 60.05 based on the application materials, plan sets, applicant testimony, and the findings of fact and conclusions of law in the planner memo dated October 21, 2026
[29:00] with
[29:03] stop.
[29:05] No,
[29:05] we're not making any
[29:08] conclusions of law. with the following conditions.
[29:14] [29:14] I thought we were going to keep one
[29:18] I don't Okay. Yep. Sorry. Go ahead.
[29:23] Okay. With the single modification as detailed in the following condition of approval. One to revise the final plan to add a note referencing all conditions of approval
[29:38] which they've already done. They've already done.
[29:41] Yeah.
[29:41] Yeah.
[29:42] We can take out that second. Do you want to just take out the second?
[29:46] All right. Let's just put a period after 2026,
[29:49] please.
[29:49] Perfect. Okay.
[29:51] Don't say something
[29:54] recorded in this meeting because we changed the planner memo.
[30:09] because she said that in the motion as part of the motion. So I second discussion. So I think I think because she referenced it.
[30:20] I think that's all in the record.
[30:22] Okay.
[30:23] Because we went through each of the conclusions.
[30:26] So that's why that's important to just go through all of those.
[30:30] Yep. [30:33] any further discussion?
[30:37] All in favor? Any opposed? And none opposed. Approval. The motion passes.
[30:47] Thank you guys. So if you want to take a five minute break and sign the plans and then somebody from the Fraser group can take them to the note deeds and get us the bud page number.
[31:37] Yeah, it's the second page. Sorry. Sorry.
[31:42] Yeah,
[32:01] listen.
[32:06] I'm sorry.
[32:10] Yeah, that's it. Okay. I thought something didn't look right here. So,
[32:36] it's the second place.
[32:39] There we go. That's better.
[32:42] That's Yes.
[32:49] Yes.
[34:38] Okay. on to new business. we have a sketch plan, I believe, from Shane Brady. If you want to come up and introduce your plan and what you're thinking and all that good stuff.
[34:53] Did you bring a new one or same one?
[34:55] It's the same one. Do you have it or
[35:02] I'll just talk a little bit about it until Tim gets back at the
[35:07] [35:10] stuff full size.
[35:16] so I'm here tonight to talk to the board a little bit about the project. I moved the location to down by the cemetery [clears throat] in front of my house. fits pretty well. There's plenty of sight distance left and right. The lots basically flat. and
[35:38] why I'm here is wondering if the board would entertain doing a sitewalk before the application. just cuz I feel like if we do a sidewalk, it'll be in the middle of winter and you won't get to see much if there's snow on the ground. [35:59] and then the next question is it falls under the threshold for D again because it's not over an acre of impervious surface and if the board would based on the condition of the site wave the requirement for the storm water management plan
[36:20] because that's a big factor in the design of the project.
[36:29] I would say at u while we're waiting on the plans that at this stage
[36:35] this is purely justformational
[36:39] both really you presenting us with information and
[36:44] and at this at the sketch plan phase according to the ordinance we're we're not really making any decisions about the future project at all.
[36:56] Okay. So, I don't know how much guidance regarding D stuff like that's that would be down the road a bit. definitely not at the sketch.
[37:12] Okay.
[37:12] Plan phase. We're not we wouldn't be talking about waiverss
[37:16] right at this point.
[37:19] We're talking about just generally about your plan.
[37:23] Okay. So,
[37:27] so the plan is what does the plan look like?
[37:30] Tim just got back, but that is basically five double wides with optional garages. [37:53] a 34
[37:57] No. that's less than a five acre site. the main parcel is 38 acres and we're going to cut that lot off of it to develop a mobile home park.
[38:11] So, is this a separate lot from the 38 acres?
[38:14] Yeah.
[38:20] So this is going to have to be the this is the original piece or the mother piece is part of a previous subdivision. So [clears throat] the subdivision previous subdivision is going to have to be amended to create this lot. [38:41] one two sorry. So this will be the third. the other option is to allow a mobile home park on a parcel with a different kind of dwelling unit and then I wouldn't have to cut any lots. But I feel like that'd be more involved and complicated than
[39:10] this
[39:11] Allen Road. Sorry about that. So, if you're are you familiar with the cemetery on Allen Road?
[39:18] Yeah. So, if you take a right at the post office, you got one house and then you get the cemetery and then it's right there right before you go up to the top of the hill.
[39:28] Okay.
[39:29] It's right across the street from where the guy sells firewood.
[39:36] So, this would be single Right.
[39:47] Park is one
[39:48] lot,
[39:51] right?
[40:10] So, in the in the ordinance it talks about, are these square footages is that for the dark lined is that the area of that
[40:23] the square the square footages on that are shown on each lot includes the buffer. So, it's the overall density of the park. the actual building it there's I'd have to look at again.
[40:45] So if you take the buffers out of each lot they're just over 12,000 square feet.
[40:58] So what's what's the 23,000 say for this law? What's that a measure of? that measures but it includes the buffer.
[41:09] Okay.
[41:13] that's the building envelope inside the actual lot.
[41:19] so the dash line sideways like the trees on the 20,000 square
[41:28] on the sketch plan when the engineer drew these counted the buffers and you're not allowed to count the buffers and square footage of the lots.
[41:40] So all that would be corrected on
[41:43] preliminary plan with the correct numbers and the correct amount of square. So on a on a on a preliminary plan, the actual lot would not include the
[41:57] buffer. Buffers.
[41:58] Yeah.
[42:00] because I'm pretty sure you can include roadways, buffers, and there's something else that you can include in the
[42:11] lot size.
[42:14] And then the dashed
[42:18] lines inside the lot is the building envelope.
[42:22] Okay.
[42:31] And then the septics are the like little ghost out lines towards the edge of the property.
[42:45] So there are two septic is it one here and I see a big rectangle. Is that septic?
[42:51] Yeah, that's so there should be three of them.
[42:55] So Shane, we you and I discussed this before that a shared system cannot be within the lots according to the state regulations. So you're going to relocate these septic systems. They're not going to be the same as what's going on this plant,
[43:13] right? They're the septic engineers are working on it right now. It's either going to be offsite like my last submission or the lot sizes are going to be 20,000 square feet and they'll be on site.
[43:28] So, this plan is
[43:30] it's a general layout, but it's rough.
[43:34] Yeah. I should have the engineers talked about having everything ready for November 4th.
[43:41] Okay.
[43:42] So, what do you want from us right now?
[43:46] Is it possible to, meet on the lot and have you guys look at it before? Okay.
[43:55] I don't know that makes too much sense, right? I'm just thinking that if it's like the middle of January or February, we're not going to be able to see
[44:07] the lawn if there's snow on the ground was my biggest concern.
[44:11] So, in the ordinance under Scotch plan, you can have a sitewalk.
[44:15] Yeah,
[44:17] you want one.
[44:20] I feel it's a little difficult to have a sitewalk without a plan that helps me understand where the things are that we're looking at. So,
[44:30] [44:34] yeah, there's a little bit of a taper. [44:40] yeah, but it's relatively flat. there's three trees up towards the third unit on the left, but it tapers back towards the roadway and it goes underneath the cvert to go across the driveway that's offsite.
[45:04] Shane, are you going to be asking for any waivers?
[45:08] so the only waivers that I would ask for or
[45:15] would be the sidewalks again with the lights and then storm water which I can have the storm water plan drawn up and done. but given the site conditions I don't think that it's really beneficial or it won't impact without it.
[45:35] So you in your buffers you show trees on the roadway side but you don't show any buffer. You show the buffer itself but you don't show fence or trees on any of the other lot lines.
[45:53] That would be the other waiver that I'd ask for.
[45:57] You didn't mention that.
[45:58] [45:59] what would you be asking for a waiver? a waiver on the vegetation on common property because we own all the property around
[46:12] the proposed lot cut. So, I'm not opposed to shielding it or having a visual buffer on the main road, but I don't think it's an adequate use of money to
[46:26] [46:27] Okay. because the only person it would affect is us.
[46:34] Yeah. but in the ordinance it says residential area. So I'm not sure on
[46:41] it says undeveloped residential.
[46:47] That's where I was confused on the cemetery part of it because I'm not sure how it would be classified or
[47:00] So I don't know. I don't know. [47:08] so I think [47:13] the plan still [47:21] seems like it has a fair amount of moving parts right now, right? so the other than other than like you're thinking about doing something in this location,
[47:38] right?
[47:39] But how and this may be like a general layout of what you're thinking about doing in this location. [47:51] I think this is it's a it's a it's a sketch plan. [48:01] you 're asking for some waiverss which we'd be open to hearing about. [48:12] I don't I don't think at this point it would make sense to and I'm open to opinions from the board, but I don't know that it would make sense for the reasons that Mercedes was talking about to do a sidewalk at this stage. I get that winter's around the corner,
[48:34] but does anybody else have an opinion other than Mercedes?
[48:40] I'm just thinking about the value of the board's time, the public's time. It'd be nice to see like this a bit more laid out before we do a sitewalk.
[48:54] I agree. Particularly wanting to see where the septic
[48:58] Yeah.
[48:58] of surface waste disposal is located
[49:02] with [49:05] not sure what the agenda is for next month. if I
[49:09] talked about it again,
[49:10] okay, if I got a complete application and put this on a site actual site plan and had Wayne survey it out, if I had all that done by November 4th, would the board consider looking at it for the November meeting, even though it doesn't meet the one-mon deadline.
[49:34] And then
[49:35] this would be considered old business at this point. Correct.
[49:39] Right.
[49:40] So that's two weeks.
[49:42] Yeah.
[49:42] Okay. So it wouldn't Okay.
[49:45] I wasn't sure whether it be in a sketch plan if it counted as new or old business.
[49:50] We're Yeah, we're talking about it. So it's
[49:52] becomes old business.
[49:54] Okay. Yeah, cuz I the engineers are pretty confident on having a complete packet put together by the fourth.
[50:02] Okay. So then that would get us into November. What? December before
[50:10] Yeah. I wouldn't like seriously Shane, I wouldn't be like thinking about like let's get the thing done first.
[50:19] Yeah.
[50:20] We've kind of been through this. Like let's get the thing done well and bring it back for before us. And the better that thing is done, the faster things move. but there can't be a lot of, you know, I know you [50:42] want to have certain waiverss. and those should be very clear what exactly what waivers you're looking for, why you're looking for those waivers, and then we can talk about what the value of those waivers and board can have a discussion.
[51:00] Okay?
[51:01] Everything should be buttoned up, eyes dotted, tees crossed. And the more you have that prepared, the faster things move. Okay.
[51:13] We have to keep asking you for stuff.
[51:16] Would it be all right to do like a complete packet that matches everything in the ordinance and then ask for the waiverss and if the waivers are granted then it could get taken off the site plan.
[51:32] I didn't I didn't understand that question.
[51:35] Yeah. so if I just designed the whole project with the intention on no waiverss and then if the board did want to grant a waiver, I could take it off the site plan or have it
[51:48] I think that would be a fair way to do it, right? Because then you'd have the plan assuming assume the waiverss aren't going to pass,
[51:56] right? Because I'd rather have it designed once and not have to change and change. [52:05] I would if you design it to meet the ordinances to the best of your ability and then you can always ask for things to be taken away,
[52:15] right?
[52:16] Okay.
[52:16] We could make adjustments.
[52:19] So, just to clarify, Shane, that then if waiverss were granted, then you would have to go back and have the plan redrawn to the condition that it was granted to,
[52:29] right? But it's easier to take away than it is to add. because the
[52:38] like if you plan for having a storm water management plan then it's a lot easier to lay everything out because that's the biggest
[52:49] hurdle on this.
[52:53] Okay.
[52:54] So I'd make a recommendation that the board
[53:00] has Shane used Natasha and I for guidance to get all of this ready for you. So once we think it's ready, then we will allow that would be I would say that would be a given that you use the CEO and Natasha and follow their instructions and that makes the process much smoother for you.
[53:26] because they are our advisors. so I would listen to them carefully.
[53:33] Okay.
[53:34] If you want a smooth process.
[53:36] And then there's also an issue with the existing subdivision
[53:42] because there was
[53:46] teeding to a butters that was done because of property line disputes. do you guys want to see that or can we or do you want to just see
[53:56] I think that's probably a
[53:59] So th this is again this is going to have to be two different applications, two different subdivisions. So the application to amend the existing subdivision is going to have to include all those changes and those will be either you know we'll look at them and that will that plan will be approved.
[54:21] So all of those are captured. Okay. All those lot lines need to be captured and whatever is approved is the way it's supposed to be on the ground at the time it's approved.
[54:32] So Tim, let me let me ask a question. If there is and this goes to you too as well Shane if there's any question about not wanting to put the cart before the horse. this lot that we're looking at unlike the previous project where it was
[54:56] not a separated out lot, but it was a parcel a portion of a lot that was rented out to the applicant. In this case, this is going to be a separated out lot. Am I clear about that?
[55:11] Yeah. Yes.
[55:12] And so, is there some question? So that would be a separate amended subdivision.
[55:19] That would be an amendment to that subdivision. And then this is going to be
[55:23] and then this would be a completely different
[55:26] a new application.
[55:27] So if there's any question about whether or not that there's going to be any difficulties there should that project be worked on first before we start looking at this or Can those things move along in tandem?
[55:48] We can. Why don't Natasha and I and Shane sit down and go over the lines that were moved and make sure that it meets everything meets the ordinance and state requirements there. And if there we don't find any issues, then I think they can go in tandem.
[56:04] Okay. Yeah, that would be that would be the way I would do that. That would be like separating out that lot should be the priority before we start getting too carried away within a totally different project.
[56:21] Just to clarify, step one is to build two parts
[56:34] and I think they can happen at the same time. So we'll
[56:38] right I mean well
[56:40] procedure-wise in the plan you know when we're looking at it when the planning board's looking at it you're going to have to look at the revised subdivision first and then look at this at the same time.
[56:51] Yeah.
[56:51] So the revised subdivision should be simple.
[56:55] Okay. Okay.
[56:57] We need a plan.
[56:59] Yeah. Correct. Yeah. Okay.
[57:08] Welcome. [laughter]
[57:12] Does that sound all sound all right to you? Does that make sense?
[57:15] Yeah, it does.
[57:16] Use your resources.
[57:17] Yeah. And is there anything you guys would like to see on the revised subdivision plan or do you want to leave it up to Natasha and Tim
[57:28] and you?
[57:29] Yeah.
[57:35] I think we definitely want the buffers, but like this is showing 15 foot space deciduous trees. I think for an actual visual buffer in past applications, we've had staggered evergreens,
[57:47] right? So, we probably want like more of a wall buffer versus heavily spaced small trees that are going to drop in the fall.
[57:59] I am curious too as we're moving forward this is a very visible lot. So, we were talking about no buffers where it's not the main road, but when you are approaching this property, it's just a very visual lot, including from the cemetery. And because this actually says vegetated buffer,
[58:19] I think I just want a little bit more attention and clarity about those the buffers that are going to exist on the two side boundaries. so as it sits right now, the lot goes from our driveway all the way to the post office.
[58:41] and there's quite a good vegetated wall on the property line by the cemetery. And then on the other side of the driveway, which is probably a 40ft spacing, there's a good row of trees that locks the majority of everything. because even our house that sits back in the field, you can only see it
[59:06] for a short window when you pass a driveway.
[59:09] I just can't see it here. Yeah. And you're saying you're vegetated and you were saying I don't want vegetation there. So I just want clarity here. [59:18] yeah, that doesn't necessarily solve our issue here because that ownership could change and someone could cut that down in the future on their lot, which I'm exposes this lot if there is no buffer that's part of the actual lot that we're talking about. So, we're usually we're trying to build those buffers on the lot we're talking about, not so using pre-existing on a budding or adjoining lots.
[59:45] Would it be [clears throat] easier if I made the lot bigger to encompass the I think I think you should come up with the plan.
[59:57] Yeah,
[59:58] that was a brief like that's the way the ordinance is written and so the board is just simply expressing what the ordinance actually says. So again, I would I would follow the ordinance with your plan and then ask for any waiverss that vary off that ordinance because these guys are just talking about what is there in the ordinance.
[1:00:23] Yeah.
[1:00:23] So that's all.
[1:00:26] Okay.
[1:00:26] So yeah. So when you can get everything together, we're happy to hear about it.
[1:00:33] Okay.
[1:00:34] Okay. So, I would like to bring up since we were talking about the cemetery, the [clears throat] language in the ordinance. So, just so Shane has some guidance on this one.
[1:00:43] it's on page 73 of the ordinance
[1:00:52] 604
[1:00:55] C
[1:00:57] 7 or C8, excuse me. C8 and it's A2
[1:01:06] about undeveloped residential land that is owned at a residential density of less than half of the proposed in the park. So both of and one also talks about residential land and I think the Shane has a good point that the cemetery is not residential
[1:01:26] across the road is
[1:01:30] some people live there. [laughter]
[1:01:33] They are residing
[1:01:36] [clears throat] is municipal owned. Yes.
[1:01:40] Cemetery commission owned.
[1:01:41] Yeah. As part of the municipality. Okay.
[1:01:46] All righty. Well, we look forward to hearing what you have next time.
[1:01:51] Thank you.
[1:01:52] Yep. Thank you.
[1:02:07] And now on to the other fun stuff. Can I go backwards for one minute? I think Shane's still in the room. [clears throat]
[1:02:21] and Tim, just because we're just talking. We're just talking. can you go one can you go one paragraph down from that in terms of buffer strips and then into B? because I'm I'm just thinking about the 20 foot the 25 foot buffer because it's talking about a visual screening and the screening shall form an infected visual barrier along the exterior lot lines of the park except driveways and so that 's kind of
[1:02:51] more my you know just because of the sight lines of this. I just want to make sure I'm understanding and we'll drive out there. So when you're in buffer strips but go down to B on 73. [1:03:10] does the residential non-residential cemetery feature actually impact those first 25 ft of a buffer which is I believe the hashmarked part of that map.
[1:03:30] Do you think the hash marks were 50 feet? I thought they were 25.
[1:03:38] Right. That's I'm talking about the first 25 which is not the 50 foot like
[1:03:45] because it just doesn't have those same qualifications in B as much.
[1:03:50] Mhm.
[1:03:50] You know.
[1:03:53] So you I don't understand. Oh, I'm saying all of those all when it talks about the 50-foot buffer, it has those qualifications like I, double I, triple I, but then when you get to the B and you're talking about the first 25 ft of the buffer, it seems like it's talking about
[1:04:14] the external
[1:04:16] [1:04:19] effect. Exactly. Effective visual barrier along the exterior lot lines of the park. So I don't see those same qualifications in B that I do in the 50 feet. I don't see the same qualifications for 25 feet that I do for 50 feet. I think it's just something I'd like to a as we move forward on this. I just want to make sure I'm understanding and we're looking at here.
[1:04:42] Okay. I think it's a point taken and when we're working with Shane, we can
[1:04:47] Okay. Yep. Regardless of who lives there
[1:04:50] or resides there. [laughter] Oh.
[1:04:55] Okay.
[1:04:58] next order of business is [1:05:05] the ordinance work that Tim has been working on.
[1:05:25] So, in an effort to keep ordinance work moving along and since the first conservation subdivision is still in our memory, I started working on some things that I had highlighted and redlined in the conservation subdivision that need had been questioned and need some work.
[1:05:50] So, I put this together for that. So,
[1:05:56] would you like me to just run through it?
[1:05:58] Yeah, let's let's roll through it. I think we're doing really good on time, so I think it'd be well worth spending a little bit on this stuff.
[1:06:10] Excuse me. So,
[1:06:13] 906 A2.
[1:06:19] So the this is more a question that came up as to [1:06:28] the cart and the horse and which one came first.
[1:06:31] and in statute actually the timeline is laid out so there isn't a lot of leeway there on what we can do. And actually I think that if we compare the statute to what is written here, we might be over the limit in an area.
[1:06:53] So but I need to flag that with the attorney and ask his opinion on it.
[1:07:01] But I just point out that it cannot, you know, by statute it needs to be that way.
[1:07:06] So I'm sorry. I was trying to find where you would say
[1:07:13] can you repeat that for me? I cannot
[1:07:16] by state statute or by
[1:07:18] state
[1:07:19] I cannot multitask.
[1:07:21] So
[1:07:23] the within 45 days after the formal submission of a preliminary plan
[1:07:31] should the be 30 days by statute. So right now we have 45 days.
[1:07:36] Yes. And in statute it says it should be 30 days.
[1:07:40] Yes.
[1:07:41] So 45 days makes no sense because you don't meet within twice within the 45 days.
[1:07:47] Right.
[1:07:47] So that's just an area that needs to be correct.
[1:07:50] Yes.
[1:07:52] I think 45 days appears in other areas of the ordinances too when we've talked about how makes no sense.
[1:07:59] Makes no sense because you can't get there.
[1:08:01] Right.
[1:08:02] Right. But that means you really need to make the decision at the next planning board meeting.
[1:08:07] It this
[1:08:08] it [snorts] holds our feet to the fire.
[1:08:10] So this ordinance being complicated as it is really the statute doesn't allow you any more time on it. It doesn't doesn't say unless you have a complicated ordinance. [1:08:22] and this is the state statute. This is the state statute
[1:08:26] and but what it does say is that if all parties are agreeable to it, you can extend those deadlines.
[1:08:36] So again, that was just a question that came up about the ordinance. So I tried to answer that question.
[1:08:51] 906A2
[1:08:53] within 45 days after a formal submission of preliminary plan is what's currently in an ordinance and it should be within 30 days by stat state statute number 4433B. B.
[1:09:15] Okay.
[1:09:19] So, so what you're saying is where we have 45 days, it should be 30. Is that am I correct? Okay, got it.
[1:09:32] which makes more sense from the way the planning board works because we meet every 30 days anyway and 45 doesn't really do anything for us.
[1:09:44] Correct.
[1:09:50] So the another question of came up of you know when should a public hearing be held?
[1:09:56] Yeah. and in statute it says
[1:10:03] you're jump you're jumping now, right?
[1:10:06] can the number of days approved in conceptual plan be increased? Statute 44035
[1:10:15] decision time limits municipal reviewing authority shall within 30 days of public hearing or if no hearing is held within 60 days of a deterine of determining the received a complete application or within any other time limit that is otherwise mutual agreed to.
[1:10:35] Okay. So that's that's kind of answers the question on public hearer and no public hearings and the timeline of where they should come.
[1:10:46] Okay. And you say you said conceptual plan but I think you meant preliminary plan
[1:10:53] because conceptual plan is a sixmonition.
[1:11:01] Yes. Correct. Okay.
[1:11:05] Can you remind me the timing of the public notice of a public hearing? Like this, it just feels very fast all of a sudden. [laughter] so is it two weeks?
[1:11:15] It's less than that.
[1:11:16] Oh, okay.
[1:11:17] If I'm wrong, procedure, I think it's 10 days.
[1:11:21] There's also public notice has to go in at a certain period of time ends up being public notice part in the
[1:11:32] in a paper of general circulation. that.
[1:11:35] Okay.
[1:11:36] but the timing of that ends up being almost one to three weeks.
[1:11:40] Okay.
[1:11:40] Because of the way the papers operate right now, we need extra time to actually get it in the paper, which nobody is reading.
[1:11:51] Seriously.
[1:11:53] Okay. Yeah. Right. Yes. [laughter]
[1:11:59] Okay. So, moving on. If there's no more questions on that, the open space section in 908 is confusing and long. It should be condensed and clarified.
[1:12:12] And if you look at the open space section of 9008,
[1:12:20] it kind of runs to everything kind of runs together. for instance,
[1:12:29] on page 132,
[1:12:33] under B, and there's a paragraph that starts out, if a homeowners association is to be formed, it shall be incorporated, da. That actually shouldn't doesn't belong in that spot. I you know, you 'd mentioned that but I may be reading this
[1:12:58] differently because they're talking about ownership of the open space by a homeowners association.
[1:13:06] Mhm.
[1:13:07] and then they talk about the homeowners association. I didn't know if that was directly pertaining to the association's responsibility for open space. But when I read that, I don't see anything
[1:13:27] in that paragraph that refers to open space. But then it goes on to list responsibilities of
[1:13:39] [1:13:40] an association outside of open space.
[1:13:43] It does mention like the following. So, I almost read this as [1:13:51] this should be another subheading that didn't quite get made because these the one, two, three, and four underneath that paragraph all have to do with maintaining the association's responsibility for maintaining the open space,
[1:14:11] right? And the way that it was interpreted in the Stson farm f subdivision was that was part of the that criteria in the I through six [snorts] was just part of open space not part we didn't separate it out from the homeowners agreement. Mhm.
[1:14:32] So that you know for instance [1:14:37] number four the 51% the developer shall maintain control of the designated open space and facilities and be responsible for the maintenance until at least 51% of the development lots and units have been conveyed and so on that we were interpreting that the
[1:14:58] world river conservation trust needed to that applied to them as well where it doesn't. It only applies to if a homeowners agreement is holding the open space,
[1:15:09] right?
[1:15:10] So that's the end of the paragraph. There's a colon. The association's document shall specify that colon and then all those romanets apply strictly to that correct previous paragraph. So I think it's I think it's okay.
[1:15:24] Yeah,
[1:15:25] it's only because it's like right from the top. it can be owned by a land trust. You know, it could be one, two, or three. And then this is saying if it's an HOA, you know, you've got that paragraph and then these are specific criteria that must be specified. So, it only applies to an HOA ownership.
[1:15:41] Yeah. And so, it should all be under that original I the three I's where it says ownership by a homeowners association. So everything we're looking at that paragraph and the following five Roman numerals that should all be indented
[1:16:01] indented.
[1:16:02] Yeah, it could be
[1:16:03] indented under three. So it's clear that is a subparagraph of
[1:16:09] HOA.
[1:16:09] yes B3 the original B3 [clears throat]
[1:16:15] that B3 I and then and then further Yeah. Yeah, I think that works too. I mean,
[1:16:24] but then that would be clear that it's it's only falling under the homeowners association subp paragraph.
[1:16:33] I think I think it and you know there are some there's more that needs to be clarified and perhaps shortened. [1:16:45] under let's see
[1:16:52] under open space management plan
[1:16:56] [1:17:00] where is this CI
[1:17:05] is there anything in those five that does apply to the other one or do they all only apply to the
[1:17:15] Like, do any of these apply to a land trust?
[1:17:26] I don't I don't see anything there.
[1:17:38] Yeah. So again, I mean, you know, because it's not indented and not clear that it's part of the home, I think it just needs to be more clear.
[1:17:46] Yeah, that would help for sure.
[1:17:47] Yeah,
[1:17:48] it's just we've got way too much nesting here, but that's
[1:17:52] there's a lot in here that, you know, could be cleaned up.
[1:17:55] [1:17:56] Tim, that whole paragraph about the homeowners association, does that have anything to do with open space or should that go over to where we're talking about the HOA? that well it's part of open space it talks about a open space within it but the open paragraph I believe
[1:18:17] [1:18:19] I'm not sure that whole paragraph like from the paragraph of if an homeowners association is to be formed all the way through
[1:18:30] like that all doesn't seem to apply to open space
[1:18:33] correct
[1:18:33] so like I would I'm wondering if we take that whole paragraph off.
[1:18:37] Well, I guess
[1:18:38] or put it in HA.
[1:18:39] Well, I think that ties to four in there, right? So, it's saying you need to have this HOA form before final subdivision approval because if it's an HOA and tell yourself 51% of the lots, it's the developer's responsibility to maintain that open space to the required standard. So, you have to have an HOA, you know, subject to everything that's in there,
[1:19:00] right? But do you think that paragraph needs to be there or does that need to be where we're talking about HOA the just the par I think like I triple I they all need to be there but when you're actually talking about what an HOA does that go over to the HOA section
[1:19:17] it might be redundant we have to read them but I think for the purposes of administering the open space especially on the front end you need to have like those are requirements of an HOA to have some sort governing document to oversee the open space. So, it's yeah, it's dense. It's probably redundant, but it's also you need it to manage the open space.
[1:19:41] I think it's very conf confusing because it talks about things other than open space in that area.
[1:19:45] Yeah. Like if I have an HOA, I have an HOA and I'm going to go to the HOA section and read about what an HOA is.
[1:19:52] But you could just have it say the last sentence there. Basically the association's documents shall specify that and just delete everything before that should be covered. All that should be in the homeowner association.
[1:20:06] We have a very detailed homeowners association like all to do.
[1:20:11] So that then we need to compare this with that to make sure nothing's being left out.
[1:20:16] But then I think we can reduce this.
[1:20:18] Y do you have a comment?
[1:20:39] This is [1:20:41] okay.
[1:20:50] Oh yeah.
[1:20:52] relationship.
[1:20:56] Yeah. Yeah.
[1:21:00] Yeah.
[1:21:18] make sense to
[1:21:20] I think that can be clarified
[1:21:24] more. [1:21:31] so under open space ownership I dedication of open space to suitable land trust dedication two dedication of development rights of open space to a suitable land trust with ownership by the private individual or homeowners association. Three, ownership of open space by a homeowners association which assume assumes full responsibility for the maintenance
[1:21:57] with the open space production deed restrictions enforceable by the land owner in the subdivision.
[1:22:05] any owner of the separate land, parcels of Button, the open space or mun or the municipality.
[1:22:32] So third party
[1:22:43] No kill.
[1:22:54] So, do we need something?
[1:22:56] I'm not reading that into this. So,
[1:23:00] yeah. [laughter] So, yeah, this whole section just needs a lot of work. And
[1:23:04] well, I think that actually flags another issue. Three is not specific to HOA only. that has like three or four scenarios. So that whole se that subsequent thing can't get knocked under it because like it ends right or a municipality. It's saying it could be an HOA, it could be a municipality or it could be a deed restrictions enforceable by any land owner.
[1:23:24] So that's I'm reading four different things there, right? Maybe five and three.
[1:23:29] So it's more than just HOA.
[1:23:30] So I think that's why HOA is not indent underneath that. Do you think HOA should be like four like IV and then if HOA and then you list all of those things because we do require a draft like I'm I'm just wondering. Yeah, I see what you're saying though because it's talking about different
[1:23:50] That's a good cleanup though.
[1:23:51] I think I think I disagree.
[1:23:57] Okay. Because what I'm the way I'm reading it is the ownership of the open space by a homeowners association which assumes full responsibility for its maintenance
[1:24:14] with open space protection deed restrictions enforcable by any land owner in the subdivision. It's enforcable by any owner of separate land parcels abudding the open space and it's enforcable
[1:24:29] by the municipality.
[1:24:32] Yeah. So I think that all that's laying out where what John was talking about that if the open space is given to a land trust then it's enforcable by the municipality
[1:24:50] where this is saying explicitly that the if homeowners association is taking over all of these all of these different entities can enforce
[1:25:06] the protection maintenance of the open space. And then you have again you have that paragraph outlining the homeowners association.
[1:25:19] Should I or I have language saying that it's enforcable by the municipality in these under these points or is that expressly said somewhere else?
[1:25:51] I don't know.
[1:25:57] Yeah.
[1:25:58] Yeah. I was going to suggest it. Let's
[1:26:12] right.
[1:26:17] So why don't because we recognize the problem.
[1:26:21] This is a good area I think to get Isabel.
[1:26:24] Yeah. And
[1:26:26] if you know, again, if anybody has an idea of how they would like to see it better, just send it over to me and I'll compile it and then Isabelle and I can go through this and see if we can figure out it
[1:26:39] Okay. Yeah, that's fair.
[1:26:40] Better.
[1:26:41] Yep.
[1:26:44] She knows this stuff in a level that's beyond me. So, I'm I'm interested to hear what she thinks of it.
[1:26:52] Yeah. just cross referencing stuff more than restating it could work too.
[1:26:55] Yeah.
[1:26:57] So the other thing under open space is again C
[1:27:05] III on page 133 includes detailed standards and schedules of maintenance for the designated open space including maintenance of vegetation.
[1:27:17] Describe detailed
[1:27:24] That's something that the attorney had a hard the attorneys had a hard time with is because the management plan that was presented by Royal River Conservation Trust didn't have a lot of detail to it because they're still evaluating it. So there isn't a lot of detail there. So the if it says detailed, it's supposed to be detailed.
[1:27:48] So my recommendation is just take details out.
[1:27:54] So just include standards and schedules for maintenance
[1:28:00] or either that or we describe the details that need to be in there.
[1:28:05] Yeah.
[1:28:08] My suggestion would be
[1:28:20] Yeah. Even if it's something basic.
[1:28:24] Yeah. We've got something.
[1:28:27] Yeah.
[1:28:32] I don't disagree with that. I just think that when this comes up again, when another conservation subdivision comes up,
[1:28:40] we're going to have to work with the land trust a lot sooner than we did this time. Mhm.
[1:28:44] And yeah, the well the idea of like when is a detailed plan due ver like do we need a detailed plan right away or is it saying at some you know at a certain point in the process we expect a detailed plan or you know yeah
[1:29:00] it says underneath that and legal review it has to be reviewed yeah
[1:29:05] by legal and it also says prior to final approval the planning board by the planning board. The applicant shall submit for review by the town attorney any restrictions, covenants, conservation easement, deed restriction, homeowners association documents or other legal documents,
[1:29:27] blah blah. Excuse me for not going on reading the whole thing.
[1:29:33] The key there is prior. I think we have to remember that because
[1:29:38] honestly the last three months have not been easy. Yeah.
[1:29:43] there's a lot there were a lot of things that the attorney did not agree with in the plan or some things specifically that he didn't agree with and again the homeowners agreement wasn't detailed enough. and there were other things that came up that were flagged and that needs to be
[1:30:05] there need according to the attorney that plan already needs to be amended. Yeah, that was I mean that was one thing that kind of stuck out to me is like that we never actually had a draft of a conservation ease for the open space, right? We just had sort of a generic one or two page management plan, but it should have been
[1:30:22] the actual conservation they plan to file,
[1:30:25] right, as a deep restriction on the property versus like here's conception what we're going to do with it. Mhm.
[1:30:32] So my recommendation going forward is
[1:30:36] we move legal
[1:30:39] legal review into earlier into the process and also we don't approve we don't sign on the dotted line until it has had all the reviews. It's all finished. I know we liked, you know, we were trying to move the project along, but it really the project just started.
[1:31:00] So, it really wouldn't and we would have had time to fix the plan other rather than having them come back and amend the plan.
[1:31:09] So, you're saying there's enough issues now. They might have to do that. they are going to have to amend the plan
[1:31:14] if well in the future I'm wondering if working with a third party creates extra complications are future applicants potentially just going to put open space under homeowners in the original plan and then if they want to donate it later to a land trust they would then amend it then and then they don't have to have a third party hold up the process Like
[1:31:42] I don't know.
[1:31:43] I think
[1:31:47] No, you're perfectly fine.
[1:31:48] Should be up there though.
[1:31:50] Microphone. [laughter]
[1:31:53] I think that the town can negotiate a relationship with what land trust have management agreement management agree to
[1:32:08] certain details.
[1:32:10] Yeah. Then the town can fine want to get that prior
[1:32:21] has to be
[1:32:26] my recommendation
[1:32:32] in the future.
[1:32:35] Yeah. What I wonder if there's we're kind of creating a in some ways a little bit of a guidance document for open space management. If the lawyer is going to have consistent concerns about a homeowners agreement, do we have a guiding kind of document for homeowners agreement that the lawyer
[1:32:57] will address whatever the lawyer, you know, would potentially find? It doesn't have to be detailed in every section, but what you know what the things that are holding up the lawyer currently. It can you [clears throat] know provide guidance so that they can get through the process quicker and not have a lot of back and forth. provisions,
[1:33:17] but the I mean, if you look at the
[1:33:22] homeowners association documents, that should be a relatively regardless of us
[1:33:32] passing a project like that, a homeowners association is literally a document that could be altered and that shouldn't require any further board review. Excuse me. So, I don't I don't know that I see
[1:33:55] an issue with us saying like for certain things pending lawyer review. I don't know that has to be buttoned up because that just they're arguing about words.
[1:34:08] I think if you put the open space in a homeowners agreement, then it's going to need a lot of review.
[1:34:14] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. If we're getting back to that. Yes, for sure. Okay.
[1:34:19] And I think too when if it's going to be a homeowners association with open space, they still need a management plan. And so I think it's almost worse for a homeowners association to come up with a management plan for open space. So I think that's especially when we want a little bit more guidance or a dock because it's one thing for Royal River to do it.
[1:34:41] It's another thing for a nent homeowners association away to see overseen. Can we strike that? Like we probably had this conversation, but maybe we had to.
[1:34:52] Yeah.
[1:34:53] Allow that.
[1:34:53] Well, I mean,
[1:34:56] what if they don't have a partner?
[1:34:59] Yeah. We can't make them sell land to a third party.
[1:35:02] Well, they're donating.
[1:35:04] Yeah. Whatever. I mean, I don't if
[1:35:08] that's a true independent third party that can administer it to a standard. Right. So it like Royal River, it could be the main farmland trust.
[1:35:16] It could be, but if they don't like if it's a situation where it's
[1:35:20] Yeah.
[1:35:20] they don't want to if you can't find it, then
[1:35:25] yeah, I mean
[1:35:25] maybe we tear this
[1:35:27] like in the event that you cannot find a suitable third party land trust,
[1:35:31] we will consider an HOA. That should be kind of
[1:35:34] I mean it does
[1:35:35] it does I mean this idea of what are we expecting from a detailed management plan of the open space are we I mean obviously there's things we would like to be done with open space but in a way
[1:35:53] is it really our place to be super hands-on and what and how they manage the open space in that we're saying you can't build on this land and it's part of the HOA But like how much should we be telling if as long as it's open space is not building on it, 's technically open space and like how much should we be really telling them this is how you need to manage this open space you know like the buffer zone areas I can see there's a management thing but the
[1:36:23] open space in general it's like we said you couldn't build there it's preserving that area for wildlife and there's potentially even some things you can do beside besides that. but like is it our place to say to be really hands-on the open space no matter who is controlling
[1:36:40] the comprehensive plan? It talks a lot about open fields and fields have to be mowed and I think that's something where that and I know Royal River struggled with like how often do I have to mow this. I think that if we're talking about open space and we're aligning it with the concepts of the comprehensive plan, something that's existing as an open field right now, I think we would want to say like
[1:37:02] why? But I'm saying if their management plan was right now this field, but actually we want it to become a forest. We don't want to mow it every year. Why aren't they allowed to let that become a foreskin and why are we forced to leave it in you like
[1:37:19] point of a comprehensive I mean a conservation subdivision was we were trying to preserve elements of this town in alignment with the comprehensive plan and I think that is sightelines and I think that 's what was supposed to go into the narration of a conservation subdivision. So I think if you know and I think especially if you look at some of our recent properties
[1:37:40] like that was the whole selling point was those open places that we were trying to preserve in this town. So I think it also is very much related to the property that they're on. But I'm not sure I'd want to say you get to do anything with it especially after we work through a conservation subject. I'm not saying they can do anything with it, but I'm saying
[1:38:00] like
[1:38:02] so
[1:38:03] I looked at as preserving undeveloped like undeveloped land versus open space. To me, I was thinking more like they're not building houses on it. So, it could be an open field, but it could become for like
[1:38:17] that would be I totally understand what you're saying, but this kind of gets back to that's their management plan.
[1:38:26] Yeah. Yeah. Saying like
[1:38:27] I'm saying their management plan could say we want to duh. Yeah,
[1:38:31] that's fine. So that could be their management plan, but that's what they would
[1:38:35] say is their management plan. And I think John's idea of having the
[1:38:40] conservation commission come up with some level of detail that some minimum level of detail that we as the planning board can present to an applicant. one that we don't have to come up with. I don't want to do it.
[1:38:58] Yeah.
[1:38:59] Time.
[1:39:01] So, we'll let somebody else do what they feel is an appropriate plan, but it should be like the minimum getting to your plan.
[1:39:11] Yeah.
[1:39:12] And then they can do whatever they want after that. But they these are the minimum standards for maintenance that the town wants applied and then and then we can go from there. But I think that's a great starting point. because I do think you need some level of detail
[1:39:33] in the management plan
[1:39:37] and exactly but how much I know that's
[1:39:40] saying detail
[1:39:41] we'll leave that
[1:39:42] wasn't enough.
[1:39:42] Yeah.
[1:39:43] Well, it may exist somewhere like there might be a main standard or a federal statute like because look at five, right? So it's talking about if you want a timber harvest, you need to have a forest management harvest plan defined by title 36 blah. So somewhere else it exists and tells you what a sufficient harvest management plan is. So maybe that exists for
[1:40:03] conservation management plan or open space management plan. So that's probably the easiest thing is to see if there's something to reference. addressing concern once you apply for something
[1:40:19] now.
[1:40:22] So your desire of course to become forest may not be complex may not be complex.
[1:40:44] You don't want to do it. You don't want to set it up. You can do whatever you want. That being said, I think that the land owner who is donating the land or provoking the land needs to have some say.
[1:40:59] Yeah.
[1:41:00] Yeah. I mean, I like what you're saying of like if you are going to, you know, cut trees on it, you need to follow a forest plan. If you're going to do agriculture on it, you need to follow an agriculture plan. But also this idea of like yeah in some ways I'm like well if you want to just have it be wild like that and it that is a planet itself but like not that you have to if it's a field now you have to keep it a field or there you know like we're preserving
[1:41:28] everything the way it is exactly. It's like no land evolves over time.
[1:41:32] I think it just has to conform with the plan that they present us. And the thing is sometimes the plan that they present us and I think we've seen this has certain features and some of those features do need to be maintained. So if they're presenting it on their plan as such I think we have to I think it is incumbent upon us to say okay who is going to do this? [1:41:54] okay let's move on to your next item Tim.
[1:42:00] Okay. Lot [clears throat] density in section 9008 needs to be clarified. I think Brian did a pretty good job in the midstream of the process, but I think that if it was more clarified in the ordinance, it would be a lot easier
[1:42:21] to go through this process. And there are some things that we're still questioning even as we're going along, such as the one the calculation using the minor subdivision. My question is how strict or of an interpretation is required i.e. can an exist in de developed watts be used or ignored?
[1:42:44] Does the site distance for a private road need to be used or ignored? So those were questions we were trying to hash out during the middle of going through this. And I think if the ordinance clarifies that, it'd be a lot better for the next one. that almost needs like its own little hour to go through and debate and talk through because you get
[1:43:09] Could we have Yeah. and we could go on for a while with these. I mean, we all have our opinions, but I think maybe what it would be helpful if it's possible is to have somebody like Isabelle
[1:43:29] work what she feels is appropriate for this sort of ordinance. And this is she may look at this and say, "This is oddball and it really needs to be hashed out." But I think if she actually gives us an outsiders, we're pretty embedded. I mean,
[1:43:51] we all were involved in writing this ordinance. I'm wondering if having somebody like Isabelle read through these questions, come up with what she feels would be appropriate, and then we can look at it. And at least from the planning board's perspective,
[1:44:13] you kind of have a place to start. that was developed by a professional. Not to say that the ordinance wasn't it was
[1:44:25] Yeah. I mean, she could provide this as my recommendation or she could provide two things saying if you want to address it X, Y, and Z way, then you could do it this way. And if you want to address it ABC way, you could do it this way. And then we can have some back and forth on which one we want. But
[1:44:42] essentially a second opinion.
[1:44:44] Yeah.
[1:44:45] On something that was given to us. When it was given to us, we read this and not that we rubber stamped it, but there was a lot there and we took it on faith that it was
[1:45:06] all buttoned up. there. Something like this is never going to be perfect on the first try. It's just not possible.
[1:45:11] Yeah. Like we had contemplated the existing lot, right?
[1:45:15] No way. It was going to be perfect first year.
[1:45:17] Keeping the lots. Can you pretend they're not there and then they stay, right? I mean, that's kind of the thing where it's like, well, yeah, probably not.
[1:45:22] I don't think that you
[1:45:25] that language something like that.
[1:45:28] Like each of those scenarios be explicitly stated. That's our issue like across the ordinances.
[1:45:32] I think yeah, you can just say strictly follow or not. I mean, if you don't strictly follow it, you're going to be doing different things for different applications, and that's not good.
[1:45:46] I don't think that 's a good practice to get in.
[1:45:49] So, strictly follow would exclude you from pretending a lot doesn't exist and a house doesn't exist. Like, you can't put a line through it,
[1:45:55] right?
[1:45:55] Yeah. which is
[1:45:56] you were going to do a minor subdivision and you had a road going through your house. the road go you
[1:46:01] well we saw this actually with I guess but the victory thing right that was the reason you couldn't do it you had 600 feet of frontage but there was a house in the middle so you can't just so I think yeah we maybe minimally for now just aster but strictly follows maybe one clean way to close it
[1:46:21] yeah I mean that was
[1:46:24] yeah I know we got back for but yeah the idea was what could you actually build under the current rules. And if you're doing stuff ignoring rules to throw in more lots, then it's kind of like, no, you can't really build that many. Like the point, we don't want you to spend
[1:46:45] entire month, you know, on this thing. It is a quick sketch to get an estimate of how many lots you could build. But like, yeah, you can't just pretend that all these other rules don't apply. Yeah. So the thought by the board is to follow that the minor
[1:47:06] subdivision ordinance strictly.
[1:47:09] I think so. But I mean I'm still interested if
[1:47:15] if there's an outside expert who has an out, you know, a way that it makes sense. But yeah, maybe the easiest thing is to just be strict
[1:47:27] and then [1:47:30] would that be waverable?
[1:47:35] I don't think so. Right. Because you want to follow
[1:47:38] Yeah.
[1:47:38] what was there before? That was our intent.
[1:47:40] Yeah.
[1:47:43] Because you'd be wavering to get more,
[1:47:45] which is not really what the intent was.
[1:47:48] Yeah. Right. If you if you're following it strictly, you're not making any waivers. So, you know, we're if they were coming in for a minor subdivision, you might wave the road width for one or something like that. If you're you're thinking of this as a strict
[1:48:08] guidance, then you're not waving anything.
[1:48:12] Okay. So, what we're really talking about, I just want to pause because I want to make sure that I'm understanding. What we're really talking about is when they're splitting up those lots in the imaginary world, according to the minor, they can't be building on unbuildable land, existing lots, existing houses, or roads that could never be built.
[1:48:35] but they can be using all of the open space that they then will have to conserve later in order to get that final number. I think that's a very fair way to approach it in terms of really looking at the land that they could build on. So, it's almost like that you could be building lots on. Yeah. I just want to make sure kind of summing that up.
[1:48:57] You just think that somehow, you know, maybe just the word strictly
[1:49:01] in there would clarify this.
[1:49:04] Yeah. Do you think all of that is lined out in minor? [sighs] Like do you think all those rules are in minor? like if we're strictly is it is it really there?
[1:49:16] Not clearly, but mostly like because that's what we went through like we were pointing to those things like you had to chase it through other areas to like you had to go to that chart to see net residential. It's like oh but it's 90,000 square feet but you know 20,000 of that is a wetland in the corner. Remember that? So it's like so it's there it points you to it but you had to go and find it but it was it's not like just go to that section everything is outlined
[1:49:38] scattered still. So the other thing I had under lot density is [clears throat] the lot size under 90,000 square feet needs to be clear i.e. when exactly do we require the use of an advanced wastewater treatment disposal system? Should it be tied to soil conditions? Should a contingency plan be required for lots of a half acre under
[1:50:00] lot density in section 504 needs to include language to include this clause that's from the attorney because that's what needs to be amended.
[1:50:12] The way the attorneys interpreted the ordinance what page is what page is that bit on? But who typically approves any waste management system? Is it you know like
[1:50:26] so the problem is what the if you go to you said it was 134
[1:50:33] 134
[1:50:35] 3A.
[1:50:42] So
[1:50:42] you have it right in front of you.
[1:50:44] Yeah. Can you can you just read that what it says?
[1:50:46] Sure. The minimum lot size may be reduced to 1/2 acre as long as the applicant submits a plan for an advanced wastewater treatment disposal system.
[1:50:57] So the attorney's interpretation was
[1:50:59] literally
[1:51:00] Yeah. So anything under 90,000 square feet would require an advanced water wastewater treatment system.
[1:51:10] Well, I'm just
[1:51:13] the
[1:51:14] saying it
[1:51:15] with any house though, like in order for someone to move in, somebody has to inspect, right, the system.
[1:51:22] So,
[1:51:23] or
[1:51:23] in 504. Yeah. Our minimum lot size is 90,000 square feet.
[1:51:29] Yeah. Anything below that doesn't qualify for. And what this is saying,
[1:51:37] Yeah. Yeah. Clean it up,
[1:51:39] make it consistent.
[1:51:41] No.
[1:51:41] Right.
[1:51:42] No. What this is saying is the minimum lot size may be reduced to one and a half acre as long as the applicant submits a waste water treatment plant. Anything under 90,000 square feet, not down to a half an acre is the way I think it was meant to be, needs to have a wastewater treatment system.
[1:52:04] Advanced.
[1:52:04] Advanced. Sorry. So that's the literal interpretation of that.
[1:52:16] So I actually have been working with the attorney already on trying to fix this.
[1:52:20] Yeah, I'd be interested to just see what that's got to be fixed obviously. and I presented a couple of ideas. and he got back to me today saying that he would prefer that be strict stricken out of 908 completely and be addressed in 504.
[1:52:44] So, I stared at 504 for about a half an hour and went got up and took a walk. [laughter] I don't know how you can do it. I think this is an Isabel thing.
[1:52:56] Yeah.
[1:52:57] [1:52:59] no, that would be crazy to put it in 504.
[1:53:01] That's that's what he his suggestion.
[1:53:04] I would that gets back to the problem that Brian was talking about with the minor subdivision where bits and pieces are here or there. The only way you're going to have a minimum lot size under 90,000 square feet is literally only in the conservation subdivision.
[1:53:25] So I would I would say anything about that under 90,000 square feet should be under the conservation subdivision. Don't you think?
[1:53:40] What about the mobile home parks? Do they have what are their requirements for
[1:53:45] under their
[1:53:46] I know but I mean do they have
[1:53:49] like sept what 's their small slot side and what's their septic
[1:53:52] requirements whereby or you can go lower than that with city water
[1:53:58] what's yeah what's their septic requirements for things
[1:54:02] if so if the septic is on the lot its own lot then it needs to be 20,000 square feet which is the same state requirement for a house. Yeah,
[1:54:12] the state's requirement for a minimal size building buildable lot is 20,000 square feet.
[1:54:19] We require more, but and that's that's the other thing I got to get to that the attorney pointed out is the reason why we require more is under 504. I didn't finish that, but it goes up from it goes down to 5,000 square feet if you have public water and sewer. So, that 's in state regulations.
[1:54:40] Yeah. So the table on 504 like at the top says minimum lot size with on-site sewer and water, right? Single family dwelling is 90,000 square feet. So I think to Todd's point, keeping it there either that add like another column for conservation subdivision versus the table or keep it there, but yeah, clean it up to anything less than 90,000 square feet requires the advanced waste water.
[1:55:04] So, what Ben pointed out to me when I when we were going over this, he said the next page, 41, B, minimal net residential area. If you read that paragraph, Pel doesn't want anything less than 90,000 square feet because we want to preserve our waters. And
[1:55:26] so it's the conservation commission, the conservation subdivision is contradicting what is there.
[1:55:36] But I think we're balancing that with the amount of open space that we're preserving around that. Like I think that's the whole point. So I think that whole idea that if this is within the conservation subdivision and I think m and Isabelle is the person to do this but I'm wondering if we map it out in 908 but we have a reference to
[1:55:57] in 504 that says except in conservation subdivisions because I don't want to have the specs in two different places but I see not
[1:56:09] not having some kind of reference and having these very strict things. because I think it this is only going to happen in a conservation subdivision surrounded by 60% open space.
[1:56:21] So to defend Ben and myself.
[1:56:25] Yeah. [laughter]
[1:56:27] When you cluster septic systems together, that's where you get the pollution,
[1:56:31] right? But that's why it's got to be advanced.
[1:56:35] So every system's got to be an advanced system.
[1:56:38] But not every system
[1:56:39] it's under 90,000 square feet. But is every conservation subdivision? Well, I think yes, I think. But some of them are not going to be that small. Like it's only when it's going to be that small, right?
[1:56:51] It doesn't say that [laughter]
[1:56:53] cuz right now the plan says only once you get to half acre and under.
[1:56:59] Doesn't say that.
[1:57:00] No, it doesn't.
[1:57:01] I think that was
[1:57:02] Oh, that I thought it did [laughter]
[1:57:04] intent, but it doesn't.
[1:57:06] Oh, it needs literally it doesn't say that. But we're not allowing anything under a half acre.
[1:57:13] So the h right half acre is the minimum lot size
[1:57:17] in a conservation subdivision but nowhere else.
[1:57:20] Nowhere else
[1:57:21] other than mobile home park.
[1:57:22] And so I guess the question is do we set some sort of standard? Do we want to keep that? So, if it's under 90,000 square feet
[1:57:35] and advanced because we are
[1:57:38] I'm wondering though with this idea of I'm interested if mobile home parks are dense and they're addressing the septic issue there. It's
[1:57:48] true. like whatever is probably acceptable for a mobile home parks at the equivalent density we should allow in a conservation subdivision and not have it more ownorous necessarily than a mobile home park because the state has determined that whatever you know requirements for mobile home parks that is an acceptable
[1:58:10] septic system in that density already. yeah. So, I'm wondering if we need if there's not like advanced wastewater treatment disposal system language in a mobile home park, why are we requiring it potentially in this situation?
[1:58:30] So, there could be some instances where somebody would be proposing to have a mobile home park in an area where the soil conditions wouldn't be adequate.
[1:58:39] Yeah.
[1:58:40] For that.
[1:58:41] Well, that's what I'm saying. like can we steal that the in some ways the requirement language in a mobile home park and apply it to this? So like whatever mobile home parks requirements are around what the soil is and duh, we kind of can use that as the requirement for
[1:59:01] a conservation subdivision. I think the other thing in a mobile home park is that if your lots are down to 20,000 square feet, you have to have some type of a water supply, a private water supply. There's a well that's supplying all the homes.
[1:59:18] Here's here's an expert.
[1:59:21] Well, I'm I'm actually sorry, Shane. what I'm what I'm going to do is I think what's great what we're doing right now is flagging these potential issues, but we are definitely not going to be solving those tonight. So, why don't we keep rolling through these
[1:59:40] and then, I think Tim, because we're starting to come down to our deadline of, what we need to get to the select board to get on the town warrant. we should really start flagging the ones that this has got to we got to we got to hammer this one out.
[2:00:01] We got to hammer that one out.
[2:00:02] This is one of them.
[2:00:03] This is one of them. agreed 100%. So, let's create a list of the things that we really need to hammer out. and then if we need to, which seems likely, and we want to do a workshop, we can take those
[2:00:23] that chunk and really
[2:00:28] get it finalized and hopefully have Isabelle look at it prior. and then we have something that we can really work with because we're we're not going to we're not going to solve all these tonight. But let's Oh, yes, sir.
[2:01:00] So whatever feel
[2:01:17] Okay, got it. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
[2:01:20] Don't know if we're there yet.
[2:01:21] Yeah. I was just gonna say, but we can
[2:01:24] give us that.
[2:01:26] Yes.
[2:01:27] So, I' I've been in communication email with Isabelle and Isabelle's going to watch these meetings. So, she's hearing us right now. So, [laughter]
[2:01:39] yeah.
[2:01:43] We could put the definit.
[2:01:46] Okay. Yeah, we can do that.
[2:01:49] And you're out. We're We're going to be out.
[2:01:53] Have a good night.
[2:01:54] shortly. [2:01:57] Okay, moving down the list then. I mean, that's a definite we need to do something there.
[2:02:02] Yeah.
[2:02:02] moving down the list to get through it. should there be a second sitewalk before the final approval?
[2:02:13] I we had a sight walk in the with 20 inches of snow and didn't seal it. I don't want to I don't want to do a mandatory sitewalk though. I'd rather have sitewalks be optional than required
[2:02:30] because there's certain times where it's like, no, we know this property and we know this project and we don't need to do a second sitewalk and it just adds more time and delay. And then other times where yeah, maybe the first time we went out and it was completely different conditions and we want to do it. So yeah, I'm I'm hesitant to require it. I think you can have like
[2:02:53] a bullet point of it that you know says the planning board will you know make a determination if a you know a second sitewalk is necessary.
[2:03:05] I think you can pick a lot more up if you see pins on the ground or you know flags on the ground which we didn't see.
[2:03:12] I Yeah, I agree. But I also don't want to give everybody more work when it's
[2:03:17] in the conceptual or the pre-application part of that, whatever ordinance calls it. You don't see that because they're not even
[2:03:25] Yeah.
[2:03:26] And that's when we call for a site.
[2:03:28] Yeah.
[2:03:29] We should definitely give ourselves the option though. So someone can't push back and say, "Oh, this isn't in there. You can't make us go back out and do all this." So we should definitely say at our discretion if there's material changes.
[2:03:38] So you we have to have a public hearing in the final.
[2:03:41] Yeah. Why not do like we did today? Schedule a sitewalk public hearing.
[2:03:46] Yeah,
[2:03:47] I would I would put a May.
[2:03:50] Yeah.
[2:03:51] Rather than a shell.
[2:03:52] Okay.
[2:03:54] I think especially if the site plan changes significantly. I
[2:03:59] and if these are continue are going to continue to be large, I think for public transparency, a sitewalk is never having the option of a sidewalk is never a bad idea. I'd rather be able to say, "No, we don't need it." rather than, "Oh, shoot. We really do and we can't make them do it."
[2:04:16] We should have had one.
[2:04:17] Yeah, we I think it probably would have been.
[2:04:21] So, should survey pins be required in the ground
[2:04:26] before final approval?
[2:04:27] I would say
[2:04:27] it's just past practice.
[2:04:29] Yeah, I would say so
[2:04:30] because right now it's not.
[2:04:32] I would say so. Whether or not we're doing a sidewalk or not,
[2:04:36] whether we're doing a sidewalk or not, we don't require survey pins to be in the ground. So,
[2:04:43] that's all done after approval.
[2:04:46] And those are the lot lines that are on the final plan.
[2:04:52] Okay. Okay. again, legal review should be part of 907, I believe, which would put it back
[2:05:05] 907.
[2:05:07] What is 907?
[2:05:08] Review procedures in
[2:05:10] the final. It's the final plan.
[2:05:12] It's in the final plan.
[2:05:14] And where is it now, Tim?
[2:05:17] It's mentioned after
[2:05:21] open space.
[2:05:23] Oh, okay. I see.
[2:05:25] In 908.
[2:05:26] Yeah.
[2:05:30] So we would have saved a lot of back and forth and a lot of time if legal review happened sooner when the final plan gets here have that reviewed.
[2:05:41] So it does say under 908 the first line is prior to final approval
[2:05:49] the applicant shall submit.
[2:05:55] Should we just change that to must?
[2:05:59] Shall is must.
[2:06:01] Yes. Shall.
[2:06:04] Okay. [2:06:07] so with the with the sitewalk then may it should be May.
[2:06:11] Yes.
[2:06:12] Shall. So they should have, but I think what we did is did we have a
[2:06:23] was there a condition? That's what we did.
[2:06:28] We did a condition and legal review spotted a lot of things or you know a lot of things that were not right that they didn't think were right and followed the ordinance. So, if that is reviewed earlier under final submission,
[2:06:49] the attorney will have a chance to review that the same time we're reviewing it and those will get flagged sooner.
[2:06:57] So, I guess we because it says prior to final approval.
[2:07:03] Mhm. Everything should have been reviewed by the town attorney, but it's actually our fault for not making sure that was completed. So that was that was a excuse me, a rookie
[2:07:25] misjudgment perhaps by us. I don't think it's a pro I don't know that it's necessarily a problem with the ordinance.
[2:07:42] No, the applicant would need to submit their documents
[2:07:50] because I feel like at that point our mission as the board was to try and finalize the plan
[2:08:05] [2:08:08] so that they could move forward.
[2:08:12] So I don't want to spend a lot of time on I just recognize that it's it needs to be done sooner in the process than the end. So, so you're suggesting, but if you put it into,
[2:08:27] I guess what I'm saying is if you put it into
[2:08:31] 907
[2:08:33] review procedure for
[2:08:35] the final plan
[2:08:36] for the final plan
[2:08:37] in that is
[2:08:38] you could put in that list
[2:08:41] just move it to that because it's basically there, but it's just in a different location.
[2:08:46] It's further. Yes.
[2:08:47] But it's b it's it's basically it's hidden. It's one of those things where it's hidden deeper,
[2:08:52] right?
[2:08:52] But it really needs to be done
[2:08:54] sooner
[2:08:54] at the final plan according to the existing limit.
[2:08:58] Okay.
[2:08:58] Yeah.
[2:08:59] Okay. So, let's do that.
[2:09:10] Yeah.
[2:09:13] So that's, you know, that's another Isabelle question is, okay, what do we do? Here's the state statute.
[2:09:23] Could this be changed?
[2:09:26] Okay.
[2:09:27] [2:09:30] so there needs to be an escrow account set up to pay third party review, peer review, consultants, and stuff like that. Yeah,
[2:09:42] it was difficult this time because we 're supposed to pay we're supposed to hire the consulting company but we didn't have any money.
[2:09:52] So Jim ended up giving us a check and we you know for it knowing how much it was going to be we cashed the check and then we paid the consultant. So, there needs to be an escrow account. Yeah.
[2:10:06] Up front
[2:10:07] at some point. And I think I put in it should be
[2:10:12] What should the number be?
[2:10:14] 906A is what you proposed.
[2:10:15] 906A is what I put in there.
[2:10:18] but what should the number be? Yeah.
[2:10:22] Yeah. So, I think that
[2:10:24] and should that be
[2:10:25] That is a good question. I think [clears throat] that we can pick a number and anything that doesn't get used gets returned.
[2:10:32] Okay. Yep.
[2:10:36] Yeah, that's kind of what I was thinking. I mean, these are million-dollar projects
[2:10:41] and it can be worded in a way that, you know, once it gets down to $2,000, then it needs to be replenished back to $5,000 or whatever.
[2:10:50] So, that's that I've seen that before.
[2:10:53] What was the number 10,000?
[2:10:57] I don't say double. I mean if you have a conservation easement an HOA that's a lot of legal review plus like D
[2:11:07] right you can pay I mean all that can be paid out of this but [2:11:15] this is more to cover the as we're going through the process these are the you know the town has to spend money and it's not necessarily the final but it's throughout the whole process. So if you want if you want to make a number for the whole project then go right ahead.
[2:11:37] He does. He does.
[2:11:38] They do. Yeah. That's another reason.
[2:11:44] I don't know.
[2:11:44] Does the town attorney just send them a bill or they send the town a bill?
[2:11:48] The town.
[2:11:49] They do.
[2:11:50] What did the charge?
[2:11:52] I think he's at 200 and I'm not sure. 200 something dollars an hour.
[2:11:57] Oh,
[2:11:59] what has he charged us so far? I don't know if we've got the final bill yet because he's not done.
[2:12:09] Yeah. I you know
[2:12:14] I don't know if we're complete with the plan or not but Northstar plannings we separated out all the bills and Northstar plannings for Stson Farm was over $12,000
[2:12:29] but that's not built into being recouped
[2:12:32] in here either that the cost of doing business.
[2:12:35] Yeah. So, you know, that's something when the select board is going through fees, they need to look at that. They
[2:12:42] maybe for conservation subdivision, we should be charging more.
[2:12:45] Yeah.
[2:12:46] Yeah.
[2:12:47] Yeah. Certainly. Okay. Yep. I think that's a good idea. All right. Moving on.
[2:12:59] add amendments to the subdivision or 902 suggestion. So 902
[2:13:08] is
[2:13:11] lists the types of subdivisions that we have. It only has two. It doesn't deal with amendments.
[2:13:21] Yeah.
[2:13:21] To subdivisions. We need to find we need to put in something that deals with how do we how do we handle amendments to subdivisions. So,
[2:13:31] and I think that can this question can go on for a long time.
[2:13:34] That's why right we're not going to do it.
[2:13:36] So, I just pointed out [laughter] that
[2:13:40] this is one I am going to put down. this one definitely needs to be looked at.
[2:13:51] So, moving on. consider adding the requirement of a sprinkler system as an option under 9088. that would be instead of or in lie of a cyestern or fire pond. other towns and I put in a link there to Freeport's ordinance on it. Other towns require
[2:14:12] sprinkler systems in developments.
[2:14:14] We're not but we're not requiring sprink
[2:14:25] or
[2:14:25] Yeah.
[2:14:26] sprinkler and you know they have to be monitored. they have to.
[2:14:29] Yeah. As long as the fire department thinks that's an option of equal, you know, value basically, then yeah, well, might as well give it the option and they can use it or not.
[2:14:41] And I asked Jesse if he would be okay with that and he looked at it and he said he would be okay with it. He'd want to tweak Free Port's ordinance some, but one advantage that Heath has with the system is it's there for the neighborhood. Yeah.
[2:14:55] Yeah. So,
[2:14:56] well, yeah, that's interesting.
[2:15:00] Yeah. Sprinklers fail. Like the pump's dead or something. There's no power.
[2:15:03] It's a maintenance thing.
[2:15:05] Yeah.
[2:15:06] So, they have to be.
[2:15:07] Yeah.
[2:15:09] So,
[2:15:11] which one is cheaper?
[2:15:14] Like, aren't sprinkler systems super expensive?
[2:15:17] So, it's going to be expensive for the developer.
[2:15:19] Yeah.
[2:15:20] Yeah.
[2:15:20] He's going to have to put that in up front.
[2:15:22] Yeah. A sprinkler system can be paid by
[2:15:26] the home. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Less interest.
[2:15:30] I don't know. Maybe we shouldn't give it [laughter] the option because then the developer should be like
[2:15:35] I get to save money and we have a less
[2:15:38] some a system that doesn't actually that helps less people.
[2:15:40] To be honest, I like the idea of having a sistern.
[2:15:44] Yeah.
[2:15:44] Because it's it's a neighborhood thing.
[2:15:46] Yeah.
[2:15:47] You know.
[2:15:48] Okay.
[2:15:50] Yeah. redundant I
[2:15:52] that was that was a question actually from Peter
[2:15:58] so that's why I put it in here
[2:16:00] it's fair
[2:16:03] [2:16:06] subsections 9088 are labeled wrong8
[2:16:30] Fire.
[2:16:32] It's getting late. Maybe we should quit. [laughter]
[2:16:42] eyeballing it. It looks
[2:16:45] right. I'll I'll do some thinking on that one.
[2:16:48] And that's that's a [2:16:52] just an edit
[2:16:55] job, right?
[2:16:56] It's like Yeah. Okay.
[2:16:57] So, sections 909 through 912 applied to both minor and conservation subdivisions. some of the language or requirements are repeated or it makes it sound only part of the conservation subdivision. So there's we just I need to go through there and flag those and pull them out.
[2:17:18] And then
[2:17:19] I think we need to figure out a way to renumber this so it's obvious that those sections go to both,
[2:17:27] you know, it can be in the head of the section. they apply to both minor and
[2:17:34] Okay.
[2:17:34] Conservation because that was confusing. A lot of people were putting that in with the conservation subdivision rather than and not putting it in the minor
[2:17:49] stuff like that. Tim is like get a clawed subscription like use the best model like it will spit that out. It'll compare and reumber and suggest all that stuff.
[2:17:58] I'm not supposed to use that.
[2:17:59] Really?
[2:17:59] Yeah. It's account policy.
[2:18:02] That's it. Save so much time and effort here.
[2:18:05] Talked it. Oh, he's gone.
[2:18:07] You could put it in the car.
[2:18:10] Amen.
[2:18:13] Yeah, exactly. Give it this whole thing and the ordinance and it'll just
[2:18:19] So 910A needs to be created. The current town attorney requires an irrevocable letter of credit for performance guarantee.
[2:18:31] All performance guarantees need to be approved by the attorney and the select board. So why don't we just fix that instead of saying bond or d irre
[2:18:43] that way there's like Jim already went out and got approved for bonds. Yeah.
[2:18:48] When the attorney said no I don't want that. I wanted them. So it was confusion. Okay,
[2:18:56] it's easy enough.
[2:18:57] And throughout the entire ordinance, bond is used in the wrong context.
[2:19:03] Okay. Yeah.
[2:19:04] So, that needs to be looked at.
[2:19:08] oh. 910D.
[2:19:20] That should be 911
[2:19:25] in my opinion.
[2:19:29] Oh yeah, it literally says final approval.
[2:19:34] If you turn the page
[2:19:35] Yeah.
[2:19:36] 911 final approval and reserved.
[2:19:38] Yeah. Yeah.
[2:19:39] So I think it just never got plugged in there.
[2:19:42] Yep, that's fair.
[2:19:44] [2:19:48] 910 D1
[2:19:54] upon
[2:19:57] 910 so it's D1 under final approval and final filing upon completion of the requirements in section five and six above where's five and six
[2:20:10] oh yeah right I think that was cut and paste
[2:20:15] from somewhere else and I don't know what it means Okay. [laughter]
[2:20:21] Yeah. So, is that 's potentially an Isabel thing?
[2:20:26] Yep.
[2:20:27] Okay.
[2:20:30] And you can see that I've highlighted on mine, not on yours, that throughout this whole section 910, the select board is called the select boardman.
[2:20:42] Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We want to fix Yeah, we want to fix that.
[2:20:46] Yep.
[2:20:49] Yeah. Yeah. D is labeled as the department of something else.
[2:20:56] Improvement. Yes.
[2:21:02] All right. so as always, thank you. [2:21:08] yeah.
[2:21:10] so what I'm going to propose that we move forward to the and I'm just abbreviating this Tim. I think you'll get the gist.
[2:21:19] Y
[2:21:20] [2:21:24] in order. Well, I think I marked the first two ones, but those are more clerical things. But if you want Isabelle to review those, I'll put those on the list. so, under
[2:21:45] just take this and do the check marks on
[2:21:48] Yes.
[2:21:52] [2:22:00] yes. So,
[2:22:04] open space.
[2:22:08] Yep.
[2:22:09] And then I have a
[2:22:14] both one and two. into [clears throat]
[2:22:18] I think adding may to a second sitewalk that
[2:22:26] clerical
[2:22:28] review survey pins in the ground. Yes, but that's
[2:22:36] clerical.
[2:22:38] You agree?
[2:22:39] Yes. Yes.
[2:22:42] we're view Yes. That's just moving. Do you want Isabelle to review that? The legal review section should be part of 907.
[2:22:52] We need to figure out where we need to put it.
[2:22:54] Okay. So, I'll put Yeah. I'll check that. A check is
[2:22:57] for Isabelle.
[2:22:59] Yes. Is to it.
[2:23:00] Yes. Do it.
[2:23:09] Escrow account. I'm going to put that as a check. Yes.
[2:23:15] It'll be interesting to see what she talks about for add amendments to subdivisions to section 902. Tim had a suggestion, but we should have his I'll review that. [2:23:31] I adding the requirement for sprinkler systems. I'm putting as a no and just leave it as is. Yeah.
[2:23:44] We can always revisit
[2:23:48] [2:23:53] yes
[2:24:06] I don't know you didn't mention 909 the variances in waiverss it's very broad
[2:24:11] just saying
[2:24:12] just
[2:24:13] [laughter]
[2:24:17] There's a lot of leeway there and you know this came from the attorney as well. There's a lot of leeway there that legally may not
[2:24:24] Okay. Let's let Isabelle look at that.
[2:24:26] Yeah.
[2:24:28] And [2:24:32] [2:24:35] 9008 is that a clerical thing? That's town attorney requires irrevocable letter of credit or is that just like put the words in?
[2:24:44] I think that's just put the words in.
[2:24:48] that's just the words.
[2:24:52] I think I think just moving 910D to section 911. It's just moving words.
[2:25:00] And yes, you may want Isabelle to look at 910D1 to figure out what it's supposed to say,
[2:25:08] right?
[2:25:09] Yes.
[2:25:12] I move that we do those things.
[2:25:14] Second.
[2:25:16] We submit those things to the select board.
[2:25:21] I just emailed one other thing on driveways. I don't know if we want to get to it tonight, but maybe next time. But I think that one's important too, so we don't see what we've been seeing the last few times.
[2:25:30] Yeah,
[2:25:31] to close loopholes. I just like some adjusted language to the definition and then tying it all together at the start of subdivision to make it more clear that an access way serving two lots or less.
[2:25:44] That should be clear.
[2:25:45] Is a driveway doesn't afford road frontage just doesn't work. and just tie like the four different disparate definitions together into a succinct.
[2:25:55] Yes, I would I would agree to 100% that we should look into and clarify driveway right of what a right of way is. [2:26:08] yeah, I didn't go after right away, but that's another but it's kind of implicit, right? I mean, right away has to be from one person to another. Yeah. If it's on your own mod, it doesn't work. and then just driveway,, road, private way, all these things are interchangeable. So, they need to just loop them all under like access way and just tie that across.
[2:26:26] I think this might be a good discussion to have with either Isabelle or Natasha. I mean, there are
[2:26:35] norms, standards that the planning
[2:26:39] can we can we just float that out there?
[2:26:41] Yeah.
[2:26:41] And put that on the scribble that one down. Yep.
[2:26:47] I think we just have to make sure the 300 feet is really what we're talking about in those things. Like today we were walking 300. That's how many of those lots got their 300 ft. So I think it's we just have to be careful that we're not hamstringing developers as well to get into these areas.
[2:27:10] Well, it's just it's conforming with what's in the language. It's tying together. I mean, it's just it's not explicit, but it's there. Yeah,
[2:27:16] I personally don't think you can do it as is, but this would help just codify that and make it more clear. So, I just again I just emailed it around. So, it's like a red line against the driveway definition and then
[2:27:29] yeah,
[2:27:29] a new leadin to section 900 because we mentioned like in the definitions and driveway standards, but they all cross reference and overlap and nothing is really clear.
[2:27:53] I don't know if we have time or you want to go over back to the backlog recommendation is if nobody's had time to review it, we can
[2:28:03] Yeah, let's do that. so I guess this would be a good time to
[2:28:08] [2:28:15] yeah, I'm going to do that in a sec. do Tim, do you feel when do you feel it would be appropriate or needed to do a to potentially have a workshop?
[2:28:35] think we're at that stage yet?
[2:28:39] [2:28:41] I think December after we get more on back on this might be more productive rather than
[2:28:48] Okay.
[2:28:49] So
[2:28:50] So maybe after November where we are in November, maybe think about doing
[2:28:55] December.
[2:28:55] Early December.
[2:28:57] Okay.
[2:28:59] Yeah. [sighs] [2:29:02] early to mid.
[2:29:03] Yeah. Okay. Yep. Yeah. Yeah. Agreed.
[2:29:07] any communications.
[2:29:12] Okay. public comment
[2:29:20] all the I know the board has already gone over a lot tonight. while you guys are looking at the conservation subdivision, would the board
[2:29:31] thinks it think it's reasonable to add like a density bonus for elderly housing or 55 plus community communities? mostly because the aging population in town and the comprehensive plan does mention something about promoting [2:29:52] 55 plus communities.
[2:29:54] Did we leave we I recall us talking about there being affordable housing bonus type of density bonus maybe. I don't know if we actually included that in the ordinance or is that something that we were going to think about revisiting. I can't recall, but I believe
[2:30:16] that there was something about trying to get it to make sense and work out because
[2:30:27] [2:30:29] ultimately we were trying to That's a that's a fair point
[2:30:37] and point taken. [clears throat]
[2:30:39] [2:30:40] I have a question though for you, Shane. Are you are you talking about within the conservation subdivision or a standalone ordinance?
[2:30:47] Within the conservation subdivision because as the town does it right now, once you get past the fourth law cut, no matter when the law cut was done, it makes it a conservation. and therefore, we're going to see a lot more conservation subdivisions come forward in the future.
[2:31:08] And I think a developer would want to take advantage of that and it would promote them not basically promote developers to put in 55 plus communities which would benefit the town, the community. And
[2:31:26] what do you see as the bonus? more lots less overhead on the town and
[2:31:35] I mean what would the bonus be to the developer?
[2:31:39] like the Stenson farm their overhead to put in the nine was it nine or 10 lots?
[2:31:46] 10 lots. So if they could get 15 lots but limit it to a 55 or older they would get five extra lots. So you'd increase the density over what would be allowed with a minor subdivision,
[2:32:00] right? But it would still work with a comprehensive plan because I think there was a study or a vote done in that the town would promote elderly or comm. Yeah,
[2:32:18] I remember we did discuss it and we decided it was too much to take on at that moment. Yeah.
[2:32:25] But also with all the changes in the ADU regulations, it's
[2:32:30] Yeah.
[2:32:30] we're going to be [clears throat] able to effectively increase
[2:32:35] I guess I would call it density.
[2:32:37] Yeah.
[2:32:38] Yeah.
[2:32:39] It's not only ADUs, it's, you know, two houses on a lot.
[2:32:42] Right. Duplex.
[2:32:43] That is why we punted because that was how we're having that conversation, too. We're like, well, it's already there and it's coming, so it's already going to double. Yeah.
[2:32:49] So, we don't want to just keep adding to it.
[2:32:52] That's a shake out. But I don't think you'd be able to like if you did halfacre lots you wouldn't be able to meet the setbacks if you did ADUs or second dwelling on that lot
[2:33:07] potentially size.
[2:33:10] Yeah.
[2:33:10] Well, thanks for that. Thank you. Oh, and I would say for anybody listening at home, we welcome feedback on, you know, are there things in the ordinance that could use improvements or things we you'd like us to discuss. I think that's a good example of something of is there an affordable housing or senior affordable housing
[2:33:32] some type of bonus to make it easier to build housing more affordably in general. is a interesting thing to discuss and interested also in people's recommendations of looking at our current ordinance. What do you think is actually a way to tackle that that that follows our comprehensive plan and doesn't have
[2:33:56] insane growth but still addresses those concerns?
[2:34:00] Yep.
[2:34:02] any other discussion?
[2:34:09] next month's agenda.
[2:34:16] Yep. That'll be under old business. Any new business?
[2:34:22] [2:34:25] not that I can
[2:34:27] see.
[2:34:29] I think I did enough.
[2:34:30] Yeah.
[2:34:34] no, nothing I can think of for new.
[2:34:39] And so the deadline for new business is now. Okay.
[2:34:45] Yeah. All right. so we should be able to spend a fair amount of time depending on what comes up of the old business. We should be able to spend a fair amount of time. So, the more that hopefully if you and Isabelle can get together.
[2:35:05] Yeah. I'm not sure what her schedule is.
[2:35:07] Yeah. Right. Okay. Well, hopefully we can make something happen.
[2:35:12] All righty. The other thing, you know, if I can arrange a meet with Isabelle to go over some of this stuff, I'd like to have somebody from the board that was involved in writing the ordinance.
[2:35:26] Yeah.
[2:35:26] Just because his I don't have the history and I think that would be important. So I'll put it out there when I schedule a meeting and
[2:35:35] everybody here was involved
[2:35:37] as long as only two of you show up. One or two it's fine.
[2:35:43] Okay. Yeah. Just reach out. all righty. I move that we adjourn the October meeting of the 10.
[2:35:53] Second favor amendments.
[2:35:58] Give it