← Back to MaineScanner

Gray Planning Board Approves Durgin-Woods Subdivision Plan Despite Board Split

2026-11-12 · 1h 28m · Source: Planning Board Meeting | November 12, 2026 (Town of Gray (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[13:21] Speaker A (unidentified): And you're live. We're [13:24] Speaker B (unidentified): live. Yep. All right, good evening. Welcome everyone to the November 12th Planning Board meeting for the Town of Gray. First up is roll call. Melinda, how's that? David, am [13:45] Speaker C (unidentified): I live? Oh, I think so. Yep. [13:50] Speaker B (unidentified): David, and I'm Dan Cobb. Also present, Charlie is excused this evening, so it will be just the three of us. All right, first up is approval of last month's minutes. Are there any comments or corrections to the October minutes? Or motion to accept as presented. Motion to accept as presented. Second. Any discussion? All in favor. Unanimous. Okay, next up is information exchange. I believe Kristen, you have some things. Sure. I think we just wanted to update the board that [14:34] Speaker D (unidentified): the Village Transformation Project update meeting with DOT did take place on October 13 and was well attended, and their preliminary designs for that project are expected to be finalized in March 2028, so you can stay tuned on that and those details and the project images and things like that are available through the town website. What's their next like public sharing is at [14:58] Speaker B (unidentified): that time when their plans are that you just referenced? Or I don't know the next one yet. No, [15:04] Speaker D (unidentified): nope, this was the most recent one, and then maybe we'll hear about one before March of 2028, but we'll see. And then the Growth Management Ordinance, well, we did staff received input from Town Council on amendments to that on October 20th, and I'm working through the updated draft that incorporates the council's amendments with legal right now, so that will be coming back to you sometime soon, probably within the next couple months, and we'll go through another public hearing with the board. And I do have a couple updates specific to the 224 Shaker application [15:41] Speaker B (unidentified): tonight when we get to that. Okay, sounds good. I have a one question. I saw some, I read some reference to some review of zoning ordinances that the Ordinance Review Committee is doing. I've not heard of that. Do you care more about what they're? Yeah, the rezoning work, like to redo the zoning for the entire town, had been pursued as you may [16:08] Speaker D (unidentified): Recall I think it was like 2024 or 25 there were public meetings about that process that our community development director Doug Webster at the time had done a lot of work on kind of reconfiguring the zones and what they would have for you know sizes and uses and so on and had brought that to the public to get public input and that process was well underway. It got a bit stalled and he has since retired and there are some other elements that were going to be done by an outside entity that are still undone so it's been a little bit in limbo. The ordinance advisory committee wanted to take a crack at reviewing the work that had been done to date and see how they want to move forward. Okay so that's picking that work up yes [16:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Thanks any information from the board council [16:58] Speaker E (unidentified): I would just say that we received from the Acting Town Manager Lauren Aslan, the council received proposed budget for FY 28 and that will kick off our discussion of the budget and probably beginning in December. The goal this year is to try to have that conversation early and often and to avoid some of the big last-minute decisions that happened last spring for this current fiscal year. That's it for me. All right. [17:33] Speaker B (unidentified): So with that, we'll move on to the business of the evening. So first up is continued business. This is a request by Andrew Gervais of Durgin-Woods Development, LLC, represented by BH2M Engineering for planning board preliminary plan review of a proposal to create the 53 lot phase Dergenwood Subdivision on the 144 plus or minus acre Gervase property at Tax Map 41 Lot 13-20-01 to include a portion of the abutting 25.28 plus or minus acre Alex Rogers property at Tax Map 41 Lot 13-20-02 off Ramsdale Road in the Rural Residential and Agricultural Zoning district. This proposal is subject to major subdivision review and just before you get started a bit of background so Kristen had called me and requested or I think the applicant had requested to come back this evening specific to getting more guidance from the board on the potential or proposed connection to Tamara Ackley. So I know when we got talking about that topic, Melinda had to leave the meeting and wasn't present. My understanding is the applicant wasn't clear on the direction and would like more specific clarity. So is that accurate? Adjacent. What's that? It's accurate adjacent. It's accurate adjacent, okay. Yes. So that's my understanding of what you're after, and we're not looking to review everything tonight. We're here to talk specifically tonight on that one topic. Correct. [19:29] Speaker A (unidentified): And I'd be happy to go into it if the floor is mine. [19:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, the floor is yours. Thank you. [19:33] Speaker A (unidentified): My name is Austin Fagan. I'm here representing Andy Jervis, Durgan Woods Development, LLC. So, yeah, a development that has taken place since the last time we saw you. I know that we had spoken about connect connectivity to Tamarack and there was a likelihood that you folks would be looking for some sort of emergency gate or something of that nature in order to divert traffic away from that area. I believe since that time Kristen and other staff have come up with the determination that if it is a gated area it would still be considered a dead end, and therefore would not really act as a second means of egress for the property, which would make it no longer meet the requirements of the ordinance for having over 25 lots, with the current design that is. So I think the idea is giving the board the understanding that gating that will make it so that it's technically not a second means of egress, and we will either have to go back to the drawing board if it is not allowed or come up with some sort of alternate solution. One thing that we did want to bring up with the understanding that this is going to be impacting roadways is that this is a phase project so you know it's not like 52 lots are coming in right away and there's going to be the additional traffic going to the road. It's a phased approach and he had just done another project that you may recall Male Mills which was a 13-lot subdivision. That took from final approval, which was November of 24, to the last house is going to be being built here soon. So it'll be over two years by the time that will be complete, which would be about equivalent to each phase of this project. So it'll be two to three years between phases. It could be four to six years before they even connect into Tamarack. So, though we understand the want to not impose on the abutting properties, a fair amount of effort and time and resources were invested to get that connection based on staff recommendations and asks. So, we just hope that the board will take that into consideration for us to move forward with the design. [21:55] Speaker B (unidentified): I have to ask you a question. One of the suggestions, so you're right, that was an idea that came up to explore, so thank you both for looking into that. One of the other suggestions, and I observed some of it I think after the meeting, was collaboration with the neighborhood and feedback. Did you undertake any more feedback [22:19] Speaker A (unidentified): that gathering after and outside of the meeting? Or we have not moved forward at any stage just with this, you know, Kristen made it pretty clear pretty soon after the meeting that this would be the case, so we haven't moved forward with any design changes, any, anything because it would be a major redesign of the project. If yes, sorry, did you seek or receive any additional [22:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Is there any additional feedback from the providers? We have not. Okay. All right. So, is that it for what you're after tonight? Yes. Okay. Yeah. So, that's the background is we didn't really land at a definitive place for them and they need some certainty so they can move forward one way or the other. That's the short answer. And I think what I'm going to do before we start, Kristen was kind enough to cite the appropriate section of the ordinance, and I think I'm just going to read that for everyone's benefit, including ours, because this is basically what we need to make our decision on, is what's in the ordinance. So, this is from general internal subdivision street standards. All internal subdivision streets shall meet the following minimum standards. One, the street or street systems of the proposed subdivision shall be designed to coordinate with existing, proposed, and planned streets. Wherever a proposed development abuts unplatted land or a future development phase of the same development, the street right-of-way shall be extended to the property line as deemed necessary by the planning board with input from the town planner and town engineer to provide access to abutting properties or to logically extend the street system. If possible, local streets in the subdivision shall connect with surrounding streets to permit convenient movement of traffic between residential neighborhoods, to reduce service vehicle mileage, to permit looping of utilities and or facilitate emergency access and evacuation. But such connections should not have the effect of encouraging the use of such streets by substantial through traffic unless the street is designed for such purposes. So that's our guidance, yeah. [25:12] Speaker C (unidentified): I have some thoughts. Okay, I just want the public to know that I was present for only a portion of the October meeting because I was remote and with a tenuous connection, but I did listen to deeply and closely the YouTube video of the meeting. So I heard all of the public comment and all of the conversation that I was not present for. And clearly there's a lot of passion and interest. And I really want you to know I heard it all. And I appreciate your patience with me not being able to be present, but I am here now. out and I also heard that, I know that folks were like, I wonder what Melinda thinks, and I was there, so sorry about that. My first thing I would say is, as you reread that, and I appreciate you doing that, is a couple of things jump out at me, and in preparation for this meeting I also looked at the traffic study more closely, and I see that the language of this ordinance is sort of in the shall, you know, it must be done, which is why the town staff suggested that, you know, strenuously suggested, and what I see here is that our sort of the caveat for us is such connections should not have the effect of encouraging the use of streets by substantial through traffic, and my understanding of through traffic is traffic that isn't associated with either neighborhood but is using the streets as a cut-through. And I'm aware of this because I used to live in a subdivision that was on a dead end street and an adjacent subdivision was developed, and because there was a nearby intersection that was deadly there were a disturbing amount of t-bone intersections, it was the Libby intersection with 25, you've probably heard of it, like it was bad. We knew that vehicles would, even though you think who would want to do this, well if you get to avoid a deadly intersection you do that. And so this came up, like this was, this was in my life, I had, I was standing in your shoes, and it ended up that planning board decided not to make it drivable because of the cut through, but what they did do was preserve, they Ended up paving a walkway, but preserve it so that when the intersection was repaired, which it is now, there was a possibility of having it be drivable and emergency vehicles could drive it immediately, like they could drive it right now. And so I have this sort of personal experience that I definitely wanted to share with the public and with the board. But as it relates to this particular intersection, I don't think, and the developer's agent can correct me if I'm wrong, but when I look at the traffic study, there's no expectation that anyone that doesn't live in one of these subdivisions is going to be on these roads. It's simply the new subdivision and the existing subdivision are going to be mingling. And, you know, existing subdivision can cross over into the new one. Your friends can visit. The kids will visit without needing to go on the main road, which is the main benefit of having these interconnected subdivisions is you don't need to use the main roads for it. Kids that are bicycling, and in this case, one of the beautiful things, is not only can your folks in your subdivision cut across into the new one, but they can then cross the road into Thayer Brook and in theory they could drive their bikes or on their feet all the way to Hannaford all the way to Libby Hill because those trails connect all that way which is epic and was not an option for us but is really exciting I think would be wonderful for the community to have that as an option so I Wanted to share that my personal experience the other thing I wanted to flag based on the traffic studies again correct me if I'm wrong, but the rating of the Tamarack and Hemlock Lane intersections are currently at an A. They will stay at an A in terms of performance. And the amount of extra trips generated for those two subdivisions, and this is material that is in the public record, correct me if I'm not saying it correctly, but that the increased performance or the change is minimal. I think it's like 0.1% of total vehicle changes for Hemlock Lane and Ramsdale, and Hemlock and Tamarack is 1.5. And the [Speaker E (unidentified): So that those] Two intersections will be impacted very minimally because again it's just the two subdivisions meshing together. And so it would I would I will absolutely be in favor of that if we need to issue a waiver. But I'm one vote on this board and we work collaboratively. But I would I would strongly suggest that we do facilitate and require interconnection in this case. So, off my soapbox now. Thank you for your thoughts. [30:55] Speaker B (unidentified): David, any thoughts? [30:57] Speaker F (unidentified): I didn't bring my notes for some reason. That's fine. But if I remember correctly, it was the two trees on the other side, right? Across the street. [31:07] Speaker A (unidentified): I believe that was on the Hemlock intersection, yes. Oh, the Hemlock? Yes. [31:12] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, so there was that concern, the speed, and the extra traffic going on 202. That was the three biggest things I got from the meeting. Yes. [31:23] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so we're not covering the 202 ram-style intersection. [31:28] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, we can't do that. [31:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Tonight we're only talking about the interconnection to Tamarack. [31:37] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, so I was thinking that we don't really interact with the tree thing. But can I'm just gonna throw it up so if you if you could work with the town to get rid of those trees or mitigate that and the speed do we put up a four-way stop sign at the intersections or do we you know work with the town or whatever to see what we can do to get the speed under control so that it makes it less dangerous there? I mean that's just my thought. [32:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I believe the speed issue is on Ramsdell Road itself since it's just a you know pretty much a straightaway all the way through. [32:23] Speaker F (unidentified): That's what I'm talking about. Yeah [32:25] Speaker A (unidentified): absolutely and that's something that we'd be happy to discuss with the town. I know Andy has said if there's traffic calming methods that can be done that's great. I know you know things like speed bumps are terrible for plowing and public works is not really a fan of it. But in terms of that if there are ways that we can make it better for everybody respecting private landowners with the trees and things of that nature yeah just to follow up with you up on [33:00] Speaker D (unidentified): The tree question I did speak with the public works director and he did advise that the trees that folks were raising concern about regarding the site distance at that intersection with Hemlock that they had been on the list to be cut because of that concern but the town the budget didn't allow for those to be dealt with in that fiscal year so they're probably a couple years out at this point but they are on the list to improve site distance at that intersection that would match the timing of the [33:29] Speaker B (unidentified): potentially yeah yes okay he did respond this one didn't know all right thank you so I'll give some initiative here's what I'm thinking I'll give my initial thoughts and I know we've already had public comment on this project and it's not scheduled for tonight but I would like to open it up again specific to this topic if there's anyone that would like to speak to it because I think it's important it would be important to me if I lived there I'm gonna offer a second track at public comment specific to the connection and then after that we can do our deliberations and give them an answer if that's amenable to you too yep sounds good okay all right so one initial question or thing that I want to clarify and this is referring back to the ordinance section that I read so Tamarack, right now, extends to the property line, correct? Dead End, the public road, and it extends... [34:41] Speaker D (unidentified): Almost to the property line, which is why the developer had pursued just a little piece of easement to do that connection. And that easement agreement is in your packet. I'm sure they can speak to that in more depth if you have more time. Yeah, okay. [34:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. Okay, so it's very tough because I see both sides of it. And I've been trying, this is my basic concern, is that you made a lot of great comments about the interconnectivity, the new off Ramsdale Road access that folks on Tamarack gain to Thayer Brook by going the other way. The thing that I'm challenged with and is concerned to me are the folks that on a daily basis are going about their business or work store whatever leaving this subdivision leaving Ramsdale Road and going somewhere and coming back and what amount of people are going to start instead of going out their own subdivision road they're far enough in yours that they're going to go out the other way and use Tamarack and that leads to the you know the ending part of this ordinance which is having the Effect of encouraging use of the streets by substantial through traffic. So that's my challenge, and that's what I haven't liked about it all along from the first time. And unfortunately, I shouldn't say unfortunately, it is in the ordinance, and the guidance that you got was the correct guidance that you should get, which is to follow the ordinance. And the unfortunate part is you guys were here several times, but there was not any public attendance at those meetings. And this is a train wreck that I saw happening, and now it's coming to fruition because folks learned about it after a lot of momentum had been invested in this to follow an ordinance. So it is what it is, and we're here now. I don't, that's why I don't love the connection, and that's why I was working hard to try and come up with ideas like, hey, could we gate it, could we meet the ordinance but not encourage people to go that way and go through your own subdivision. Looks like that's not going to work. I think the challenges, and even though I personally don't like it, 's in the ordinance, and I would have a real challenge asking them to do rework to not meet an ordinance. It's like, yeah, it's like the same idea as a waiver where it's, yeah, essentially it would be if we told them no, you have to change it, we're saying go do a bunch of work and spend a bunch of money and redo this to be less compliant with ordinances. I 'm so I'm challenged with both things. That's where I'm at for now. What I'd like to do is offer, if any folks would like to provide comment, we'd be happy to hear it. Needs to be specific to the connection to Tamarack because that's the only thing that we're considering tonight. [38:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Cheney, can I ask one question, because this might actually, so I also was noticing the substantial, like what is substantial? Please correct me, I am not as well versed as you are in reading traffic studies. As I read this traffic study, in the build condition it has basically in the peak hour an additional or 1.3 vehicles in the peak hour, and the current condition no build is 1.2. Is that right? I believe that's a factor you're looking at. Okay. So in the... What's the number of vehicles in the build condition, full build-out versus not build, that we're looking at? So that we can judge. [39:13] Speaker B (unidentified): How many trips per day, I think, is what... Okay, that's a good one. [39:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Right? Yeah. So the review looks at peak hour trips, and it was specifically the peak hour trips that are coming from the development, specifically directed to Tamarack in the a.m. hour. So out of all of the a.m. hours in the peak, approximately 17 vehicles would leave the Durgan Woods subdivision to go down that way per hour in the peak hour. Yes, so many go the other way, the other way. So there would be, let me see, 46 trips, and also that means it would be 29 going the other way directly onto to Ramsdell Road through internal roadways, probably like a 60 40 split or something. Yeah, and in the pm hour it's greater, it's 23 trips, so that would be six additional trips from the am, and there would be 59 overall trips, which means that there would be 36 going from the subdivision [40:20] Speaker C (unidentified): through its own roads directly to Ramsdale. That's very helpful. I could not, that I did not get this. Okay, thank you. So I [40:32] Speaker B (unidentified): really have a problem with people that purchased and built their life on a dead end road with that expectation. There's no good answer here because I really have a problem with that, but we have an ordinance that we need to go by. So I'd love to, please, if anyone wants to speak specific to this, now is your chance to take an opportunity. Please go to the mic. [41:05] Speaker G (unidentified): Let us know your name. My name is Bill Lint, and I live at [address], which this new road would go in just past my next door neighbor. Beyond the end of Tamarack, we have a landowner way down in the back on a dirt road who has rental properties. He has tenants who come up, and as soon as they come off the dirt onto the pavement, they go whipping by our house 35 miles an hour sometimes. I've spoken to many of them. Most of them haven't understood. If they see me out in the yard, they slow down. But I see them when I'm looking out my window, and they're still flying. So what's going to stop all these people from coming out of the new Tamarack entrance here of doing the same thing? We've got tons of kids in the neighborhood. This gentleman, Paul Burrows, right here, has grandchildren that ride on our streets all the time. They come over onto our streets because it's a lot safer than riding on Ramsdell Road. They'd get run over on Ramsdell Road. There are people that drive on that road going 50 60 miles an hour And that's no exaggeration we've all seen it that 's my biggest problem and you got all these geological studies and everything else, but are you gonna tell me that having? 56 wells drilled over here in this area isn't gonna affect our water, or all the wastewater going into the ground isn't going to affect our otherwise water too. That's, that's my biggest problem with this whole idea. I can't understand what, why this couldn't have been done without making this come off a Tamarack. Thank you. Anybody else? Hi. [42:55] Speaker H (unidentified): My name is Kim Fenton. I live on the corner of Ramsdale Road in Hemlock Lane. So to add more cars coming from Tamarack to Hemlock at the stop sign, there is just unbelievable. I can't, I can't even imagine the cars coming out of that, out of this to that stop sign, and my driveway is right there, right on the corner. I've had enough time backing out of the driveway, coming to the stop sign, and then watching the people come down Ramsdale Road at 50 miles an hour, and we have a driveway across from Rams. From Hemlock, right across from Hemlock, you have another driveway right there, then you have Paul Boroughs' driveway, just there's like two of them that come towards Hemlock way, and it's just, it just doesn't make sense to have all these people or cars traveling on that, our dead-end road, and Walks a dead end, and Tamarack's a dead end. I mean, I've been there for forty to forty five years, and they're gonna to disrupt our life to make, to make it miserable. My kids grew up there. I have two houses on. Ramsdale Road, I have two rentals on Ramsdale Road that I own, and those kids that live in that house can't come out on Ramsdale Road on their bicycles. Thank. [44:55] Speaker B (unidentified): You. Anybody else? Okay. [Speaker I (unidentified): ] Sure, go out back to the mic though, please, so people online can hear. I. [45:11] Speaker G (unidentified): i don't understand why can't we have two entrances on ramsdale road if it's necessary by ordinance to have two entrances to the subdivision why was it planned like this it probably looked good for the lay of the land for these guys setting that up or whatever but it's no thought about what happens to the reason i moved to tamarack lane is because i used to live at [address] my kids were little and that was over 20 years ago and it was scary then because when i moved into 76 ramsdale Road, the pavement ran out just past my next door neighbor's house, and it was dirt beyond that. [45:55] Speaker B (unidentified): That's my question. So the short answer to your question is that in the ordinance it requires interconnection to existing streets where possible. So that's how they were guided to make that intersection, to make that interconnection, because it existed. I think you said you received one piece of public comment via email, correct? I did, yes. Why don't you go ahead and I think you want to [46:29] Speaker C (unidentified): read that. I do want to read it because email, for those of you who live and breathe it in your daily lives, was down today thanks to Outlook being down. So I, this public comment is actually from my son who wanted to share some thoughts about a similar situation that he experienced, and he wrote it to me first and then he sent it by email, which is probably waiting in the ether to hit Kristin's inbox when Outlook comes back. Dear members of the Planning Board, I am writing in support of a road connection through the proposed Dorgan Woods subdivision. I'm a resident of 173 Yarmouth Road, Gray. He lives with me now and I have a perspective on this decision that I believe is worth sharing. Also his name is Thaddeus Shane. I spent all of my childhood living in a neighborhood comparable to the one proposed, Gateway Commons in Gorham, Maine, which I encourage anyone, if you are curious about two adjacent subdivisions, to visit it, and you will see what it's like on Timber Ridge. Until 2010, the neighborhood was not connected to any other network of roads besides Route 25. Since then, a separate subdivision called Wagner Farms was built, creating a path between it and Gateway Commons. This connection allowed for significantly safer access to the trails and the local elementary school than had been afforded previously to the existing subdivision. I was able to ride my bike all the way to school while only needing to cross one busy road. Once, the route was almost totally clear of traffic. People from the two neighborhoods began to walk their dogs and bring their families to the fields and playgrounds at the school. A connection through the Durgan Woods would offer the same benefits here. It would give families safer access to the surrounding area. That connection made my childhood better and strengthened our community. I urged the planning board to approve this road connection and gives Durgan Woods the same opportunity that I had growing up. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Fattiest Shane [48:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you. There's no other public comment. I'll close the public comment. Last chance. Okay, so we're off to our deliberations. Do you have any additional thoughts before we [49:07] Speaker C (unidentified): So 17 sounds like a lot per peak hour over the course of an hour. Is that 17 like spread? Is it like a car pulls up, a car pulls up, like how does that get interpreted? I'm just trying to help the public and me honestly understand what does 17 peak hour feel like. And the other question I have is I'm looking at the subdivision plan and from this subdivision one of the things I like about it is the road is not straight so it's curvy which discourage the traffic calming you know it makes people go slower plus this is a residential subdivision and they're probably people a lot like the other people and the residential subdivision. And presumably, they will, although it's not always the case, that they will drive cautiously and carefully because it's the same kinds of people. They're going to care about kids, maybe even as their friends. I bet you it is. They're not really going to want to run over Kimmy Sue's daughter. But what is 17 like in a peak hour? Can you give everyone a sense about that? How is it spread? 17 cars like, and all of a sudden they're all, I don't know. [50:28] Speaker A (unidentified): So the way it's described in the review that was done by VHB is that it would be, you know, one vehicle every three or four minutes, potentially. You know, there might be some stacking where a few vehicles are coming at once, but on average it would be a vehicle every three to four minutes in the peak hour. It is not going to be consistently like that throughout every hour of the day. As you know, there's fluctuations in when people are coming and going. During the day, mostly, people are at work or out, so there likely wouldn't be any significant traffic changes during the work day or the school day. Additionally, you know, this subdivision is proposing an open space that'll have to have some open park area. There's gonna be sidewalks throughout the whole thing so if you know kids want to get there and go up to the park or get onto the sidewalks and go to the trails that will also be an opportunity that's provided by the development. The [51:24] Speaker C (unidentified): the roadway does the existing subdivision have sidewalks how wide are those roads the existing [51:34] Speaker A (unidentified): roads for Tamarack I do not have that information at hand but I could get that for you and what's [51:42] Speaker B (unidentified): what's the current traffic on Tamarack was that looked at separately or no it was not [51:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Looked at separately, I mean realistically from this area there would only be one lot past it. On average, a house provides, or a single-family residence produces 10 trips per day. So it may add a fraction of a vehicle in the peak hour for the one vehicle that's at the end of that roadway right now. [52:10] Speaker B (unidentified): What I was getting at was what's the change on that road. And now your 17 peak is additive to what was more what I was getting at. [52:20] Speaker A (unidentified): I also don't have that information, but I can get it. I think you would. [52:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, there is a no-build condition here. [52:28] Speaker A (unidentified): That is that is correct let me do [52:33] Speaker C (unidentified): You want my topic oh you got it too I just can't read it [52:39] Speaker H (unidentified): Apparently trip [52:55] Speaker A (unidentified): 100 so right now and thank you for pointing that out currently it says that in the AM there are 13 peak hour trips and in the PM there are eight [53:18] Speaker C (unidentified): If I'm reading that correct from the chart I trust you on that because I can't so [53:28] Speaker B (unidentified): The 17 that you quoted is it additive or that would be an additive yes it's 13 plus 17 more than doubling I have another [53:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Question maybe this is for staff so I'm reading the ordinance and it says shall not have the effect of encouraging the use of streets by substantial through traffic my interpretation of through traffic is traffic that is not affiliated with either subdivision so it's cut [54:09] Speaker D (unidentified): Through is that accurate I don't agree with that interpretation okay I think there's there's some room for interpretation I think it does the earlier piece does speak to permit convenient movement of traffic between residential neighborhoods and I think that some of that would lend to your interpretation this is between residential neighborhoods like you said it's not another one cutting through it to get to like another street on the other side type of through traffic right [54:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Which is they don't live there they don't have right they have nothing to do [54:45] Speaker D (unidentified): With the place they're just using it to as a cut through effectively but you could it's up for interpretation but I would read it that way personally because of the use of between residential neighborhoods which is the situation here [55:03] Speaker B (unidentified): My interpretation is that anyone is going to take the shortest and fastest route to get to the end of Ramsdale Road that they can and they're going to figure out what that is and they're either going to go out through their own subdivision or cut through this connection based on which one's easier [55:19] Speaker C (unidentified): And faster, I agree with you, and that's why there's two entrances is to intentionally divide the traffic so all of it doesn't get pushed out of one. And the requirement is there has to be two roads, so I totally agree, right, but if [55:32] Speaker B (unidentified): They didn't make that connection, they would have two entrances within their own subdivision. That's the difference, that is the difference. There's no impact to the neighbors with this. Half of the impact is imposed on someone else. [55:51] Speaker C (unidentified): They neither get the impact nor the benefits of interconnection. [55:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, I mean, you mentioned some benefits, right? There's open space that they have access to. There's a back way to Thayer Woods. I mean, there are some benefits. Okay, we've got to give them an answer. [56:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Can I ask one more question? Sure. This is to kill me. So can you show me on your map what exists right now for Tamarack and what has to be built to connect? So right now, that's it. And all the above that is new road. [56:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Everything hatched in gray underneath the colored hatch. [56:56] Speaker F (unidentified): So getting back to the speed mitigation, can you put speed mitigation like towards the end of that road? Because I mean now you own the subdivision, so can you in your subdivision put speed mitigation, can we require that, so [57:10] Speaker A (unidentified): That would really be a call of Public Works, I believe, since they're maintaining roads at loud by them. I know Andy has stated that he'd be happy to add traffic, you know, measures to slow things down if that's possible. It would just be at the mercy of Public Works if few wells that they'll be maintaining for [57:33] Speaker C (unidentified): The, you were just reminding me of that road, so it's of course you have to, you're, we're trying to dodge wetlands, keep our open space, there's other things to be considered, but the road, the blue part of the road on your plan, one thing that makes traffic go slower is when roads are not straight. Could that road get more of a bend in it without making everything all a mess, like, or no, not really, so what we were [58:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Trying to do was avoid passing the trail as much as possible so that can stay open and be more or less direct as perpendicular as possible crossing. Yeah, additionally this is a hill that goes, you know, straight like this, so it's, there's not much opportunity with the stream crossing, we have requirements or passing in the most accessible spot, the least amount of [58:30] Speaker C (unidentified): Impact things of that nature. But even so, it's not like it's a big old straightaway like the some of the people that are gonna be connecting are coming from the yellow and the left side of the blue, so they're not on the straightaway. They're making the right and then ready to make a decision. I guess the only question I [58:56] Speaker B (unidentified): have is what maybe the Kristen what sort of traffic calming or slowing measures are feasible in a case like this, like stop sign even though it's not unfortunately you're not like coming to an intersection or a right angle, so there would be a stop sign right here. Okay, so there already is going to be a stop sign [59:21] Speaker A (unidentified): got one each way. Okay, well so there wouldn't be a stop sign going into here, but there's one coming out. I was looking backwards on the first one, so it would be on this side, on the right hand side. Yeah, but yeah, so there will that will be a stop sign controlled intersection. Each side has to stop. No, just traffic coming on. Okay, traffic leaving Tamarack doesn't have to stop. Correct. So Tamarack would just come through and go on its way. Much like a right-hand turn at most team sections. [59:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, gotcha. Okay, well that's a calming message. A calming message right there, a stop sign. Is [1:00:05] Speaker B (unidentified): there anything you can do with that intersection geometry to increase its inconvenience? [1:00:11] Speaker A (unidentified): I have a better description. It is meeting at a 90 degree. What's up, it's it's meeting at a 90 degree intersection, which is the best way to well which what causes it to need a stop sign, and also you know if they don't slow down they're gonna go off into the woods across the street, so that would be the traffic coming. Realistically all [1:00:34] Speaker B (unidentified): right, so we need to we're not like voting, but we need to basically give them a direction and stick to it, like who [1:00:45] Speaker C (unidentified): wants to start. I think I think we should we should require the [1:00:52] Speaker B (unidentified): essentially the guidance would be leave the plan as proposed. [1:01:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Where are you at David? I mean it meets the intent of the ordinance and that's what we're here for. If there's further traffic mitigation that's going to have to come from the rest of the town. I mean we're doing everything that we can according to the ordinance, so it meets the intent of the ordinance. I'm good with it. That's all I go by the ordinance. Yeah, they want the ordinance different needs to be changed. Yeah. [1:01:27] Speaker B (unidentified): Extremely reluctantly, in line with that, I don't love it. I don't think the benefit is that great, but it's the ordinance and we shouldn't really be forcing something different. In this case I'm gonna vote against it just to give the neighbors a voice so [1:01:57] Speaker C (unidentified): Do we need, I guess it's two to one, go ahead
New Business
[1:02:04] Speaker B (unidentified): and continue. And that's the will of the board is to continue with the plan as proposed. Thank you for, thanks for coming back, appreciate you. Okay, thank you. All right, move on to the next one. Where are we? This is new business. Oh no, it's not new business, this is continued also. This is a preliminary plan review, 224 Shaker Road LLC subdivision. This is a request by 224 Shaker Road LLC for preliminary plan review of the proposal to create a four lot subdivision on the 20.37 plus or minus acre parcel at Tax Map 13 Lot 15-15-00 at 224 Shaker Road in the Rural Residential Agricultural zoning district and Stream Protection Shoreland zoning district. This proposal is subject to major subdivision review and shoreland zoning requirement. Welcome back. Thank you. So let us know what's new. [1:03:20] Speaker I (unidentified): Several things. Let me try to get this going, but essentially the open space I've looked at a couple different ways and I think I've come up with what I think is a pretty good compromise. It appears to be available if my screen can be brought up. I apologize, I'll go to the plan in the meantime if [1:04:28] Speaker C (unidentified): you want to. Okay, what, which plan and what we have is what you want to talk [1:04:33] Speaker I (unidentified): about the subdivision plan first would be the third sheet in. Okay, essentially what I wanted, I [1:04:44] Speaker A (unidentified): can't see your computer now so that should be working, just [1:04:50] Speaker F (unidentified): give me one second here. I've [1:04:53] Speaker I (unidentified): expanded the open space to provide a little bit of a leg behind the back of the street and develop any there we're not crossing with any improvements or bridges or anything like that, more or less lot area for lot three, but for the most part used by open space. We've had deliberation about the right-of-way and they're in that so that those areas are not basically occupied as well as counting towards our open space in which I've accommodated. If you were to look at page five it shows more of the Improvements that will be in the open space and I do have some photos that I can show you of what where that basin is and essentially gives you a couple visual cues as to how big it is in terms of how tall the berm is and such, but I think we can, I mean, I think we should talk about the shape and the size of both, we'll open space before we go into further details, but as that was the biggest comment. Do you [1:06:33] Speaker C (unidentified): want to start? I need to be, I need my recollection refreshed. So what we were troubled by last time was carving off the connection to an abutting parcel or a road which may or may not ever get built and excluding that road area from the open space because it was it was overlapping is that correct am i remembering that correctly [1:07:01] Speaker I (unidentified): Sort of it still would remain overlapping but I've made the open space large enough to accommodate [1:07:08] Speaker C (unidentified): that area being lost in the future gotcha that's that's what I'm recalling okay all right So if this road is ever built, there will still be a compliant amount of open space. [1:07:18] Speaker I (unidentified): Yes, as well as the stormwater pond. That does not, although it is occupying space within the open space, the area that it occupies isn't being double counted. I've accounted for it in another plot, so that essentially that easement area, the right-of-way easement area, if I were to subtract those out from the open space, I'd still be making the 5%, exceeding it. [1:07:40] Speaker F (unidentified): You might have just said this. What did you sacrifice to accommodate the more open space? [1:07:47] Speaker I (unidentified): I just made it a little larger, and I extended it up across the stream as well. So now, whereas before we had it ending here, I've extended it up in an L shape so that it borders, it follows the property border further into the site. [1:08:09] Speaker E (unidentified): Is there a stream crossing? [1:08:12] Speaker I (unidentified): There's no crossing proposed, there's no improvements proposed in this area, it's just open space that's covering that area. [1:08:19] Speaker F (unidentified): And if that road goes through, it does still go through the open space, right? It does. [1:08:23] Speaker I (unidentified): It will continue right through there, however, like I said, that easement area, if I were to deduct that out of this open space, I would still meet my five percent. [1:08:34] Speaker F (unidentified): You'll still have continuous open space? Correct. [1:08:39] Speaker I (unidentified): With access will be stoke maintained because we'll have access along that entire portion of that new road as well now. So I guess moving forward from that, I think the only other big items that I want to discuss are we don't really have an ability to serve from the gray water district. We've been working very well with the gray water district. I believe they've approved our plan. We did have some communication that indicates that they've approved it, and I believe at my request the water district superintendent reached out to Kristen today. [1:09:30] Speaker D (unidentified): Kind of not just having you guys rely on my word, he did, he did give his verbal ability to serve. He just isn't around. He's on vacation, so he couldn't get the letter out, but he did verbally confirm that they do have the ability to serve this project. [1:09:45] Speaker I (unidentified): In addition to that, we had an archaeological phase one survey done for the site, and they located a grist mill, which was shown previously on the plan, as well as remnants of a foundation in this corner right in front of our neighbor's house. So in addressing MHP's comments with regards to that, they are requesting that we preserve a 50-foot buffer to those no disturbance area. In the case of this we're about 300 feet, in the case of this grist mill we're about 200 feet. The grist mill will remain in the open space and we'll be adding a conservation easement around this corner on lot one to protect that area as well. We will continue to work with MHPC through this process. It's similar to a DEP process where it's a standalone permit. However, we'd be open to a condition of approval that no construction, no whatever the condition is, no final, we can't come back till we have that adjusted final, etc. But I'm confident that we'll be able to address all of MHPC's review comments and [1:11:04] Speaker B (unidentified): And I think we already have. [1:11:07] Speaker I (unidentified): And then the last item that I really think would be an outstanding concern, and it's something that Kristen has brought up in the past, we still don't have a test pit log for test pit six. It's at the back corner of lot four. Since we did the test pits in July and August, we've kind of changed the subdivision around. Things have changed. The septic system for lot one is kind of twisted and pulled up the hill a little bit, and it's reflected in the hydrogeo assessment. This one is in the same, more or less, location. This one's in the same location. This one's in the same location. We still need additional test pits to confirm those locations with our HHG 200s, but we do have passing test pits on each one of the lots. And in addition to that, we did receive a review of our last submittal through engineering, and their comments seemed to confirm that our stormwater is okay. I did goof, and I double-counted forested area in a watershed that I broke off to evaluate the stormwater filter, so our model's a little too conservative. I've got about 100,000 square feet of woods that I shouldn't have in my model. In my developed conditions, it will actually reduce our flows, but we already have decent flows at this point in time. I will make that change, but aside from that, I don't see any changes that are pending that review. Okay. [1:12:53] Speaker B (unidentified): So you have a number of recommended changes from staff and consulting engineer. You're in agreement with all of those, you've either met them or intend to? [1:13:04] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I can go through... [1:13:07] Speaker B (unidentified): No, you don't? No, okay. Yeah, we absolutely can. You don't want to talk about anything that you disagree with? Nothing detailed. [1:13:14] Speaker I (unidentified): There are no details that I can't address. I think the biggest ones are just making sure our open space is in the right spot, like you guys like it, and getting our ability to serve letter. We have a meeting to confirm the cost for the plan but I don't have the ability to serve yet but it's interesting Bill's just been away on vacation all month. [1:13:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah so my recollection was open space and then there was some discussion around how much buffering they needed which we should give some guidance on also. That was what I remembered as my concerns were the double counting so to speak of potential future road right away and stormwater pond but he's addressed it and seems fine to me what he's got [1:14:04] Speaker I (unidentified): I do have some images I can show you of the filter basin two location and it gives you a sense of where it is and that's a steep hill so in this I'm on this edge of it looking this way down towards the next flag. The flag in the distance, right about here, the orange flag represents about the top of berm elevation. So as I come around, you can kind of see, relative to the ground, how much higher the pond berm will be. And for the most part, the stakes are four feet tall and I'm knocking them into the ground six to eight inches. And in the worst case we had one stake in the ground with six inches over the top of it. Everything else was below that 40 inches. I also would say in this photo, although it's tilted, you can see the stone wall in the very background to give you a sense of how far that pond is from the property limit. The [1:15:14] Speaker C (unidentified): stone wall being the property limit, it is [1:15:18] Speaker I (unidentified): So, that flag right in the foreground is the one that is essentially double-tied, indicating that six inches above that flag is where a grade is. That's coming back up the hill towards this slope here. That's looking back towards that last flag. Fairly flat area. It does show some topography and in general sloping, but very easy to build a berm in this location to capture all that storm water. [1:16:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so I think you're good on the open space. The buffering, to me, I remember some discussion around tree planting like along Shaker Road or whatever, and I mean that it doesn't seem necessary to me. [1:16:24] Speaker C (unidentified): Are you, is there clearing along Shaker Road? No, there's not. [1:16:28] Speaker B (unidentified): No. We had some discussion at the meeting around it, and I remember the testimony either from the owner or from the neighbor was it was pretty well wooded, which is shown on the plan here. And you can see that it's all behind that build-out. I don't, personally, I don't really see any need for additional. [1:16:57] Speaker I (unidentified): Administratively we need to indicate that 's also the 50 foot front yard setback as well as the scenic road buffer. No cut. So that's been added to the plan. I did reference center road in the first round, but it's been changed. [1:17:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. [1:17:17] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm in agreement that we wouldn't need any buffering on the road. I do have a question, and I see that the clear area, your little squiggle line around the where the dwelling units are, I assume is the limit of your clearing, right? Yep. And but there's no indication of any sort of a tree in for each of the dwelling units, a street tree for them. I know it's a big wooded area. There's woods nearby. But even if you put a small tree that grew big later, adding one tree for each of these dwelling units, is that an option? [1:18:05] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm sure we could accommodate some sort of landscaping. [1:18:09] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm not talking like fancy landscaping, like give these poor people one tree. [1:18:13] Speaker I (unidentified): Well, I think we're limiting our tree clearing pretty tight to our grading limits. So you're not going to have a dwelling that's more than 40 or 50 feet from the forest in the actual tree line. You know, out on the road, I wouldn't think this road would require street trees, especially since... [1:18:36] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, that's fair. Most of it's wooded back. [1:18:38] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, even within the right-of-way, we have a wooded forest. Yeah, that's fair. So I,, I, not that I wouldn't, encourage nice landscaping in this area. I don't think street trees would be appropriate due to the utilities. Yeah, you're right. [1:18:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Withdrawn. That's a good point. Plus, who knows what they want? Maybe they want a crab apple. Who knows? Let them pick their own tree. They can put one in if they want. [1:19:03] Speaker I (unidentified): I,, I generally think that these are going to be very nice structures, and I think they're going to the effort of not just disturbing and laying down moment seed. I think they will have edges and things like that edge treatment around the building, but again I think that at the same time this is a fairly wooded area. It will I don't [1:19:29] Speaker C (unidentified): want to. I get it, you're good, not withdrawn. I mean essentially what I want [1:19:36] Speaker I (unidentified): to say is that once this is cleared I'd like to say it maintain this because we get the saplings that come back that are one or two inch that fill in slopes and impact septic systems and things like that. And then we have more problems. So those are my concerns. But if it's landscaping, if it's like a spruce or some sort of ornamental tree as front yard, I think that would be appropriate. [1:20:01] Speaker C (unidentified): But let them do it. You don't need to do it. [1:20:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. Anybody have anything else? [1:20:11] Speaker F (unidentified): One thing tonight. What's that? I have one thing. So this is not for you. It's probably more for Kristen and Ann. So we have these subdivisions keep coming in wanting connection to the water supply for the town. So if we need a new tower, say, in the future sometime, or a new whatever you want to call it, to hold water in the future, the entire town's going to have to pay for it with taxes. [1:20:40] Speaker D (unidentified): No. We're not the water district, so the town and the water district are two totally separate entities. So it would be I would assume through your water bill. Yeah, right. So I'm just I was [1:20:52] Speaker F (unidentified): just gonna say do we have like fees for the people that want to do these subdivisions to help pay the further cost in the future usually my [1:21:04] Speaker D (unidentified): understanding is the benefit of the subdivisions is that they're running more water line that could potentially be connected in the future but they have to pay for their own water line like they have to pay to run their own water line and they have to follow the specifications of the water district which is why they have this these conversations with the water district and they have to get the ability to serve where the water district says yeah we can take them on without needing big infrastructure improvements that the whole, all the rate payers would have to go in on. But that is probably a question better directed to the water district themselves. How do you handle, I did ask them the point, did they have [1:21:39] Speaker F (unidentified): they didn't have an answer. They said they should bring it up, so I did. Yeah. [1:21:44] Speaker D (unidentified): They are separate entities. I don't know what council have there. They are [1:21:49] Speaker E (unidentified): separate I mean I don't think so I mean there's I 'm I haven't had the experience on my six and a half years on the council of this coming up so I can't say definitively but I they are separate entities and usually what happens is that costs are shared with all the rate payers who belong to the Portland, the Graywater district. [1:22:15] Speaker C (unidentified): The other thing that I might add on that is the nature of water is a little different, especially in Maine, other than like, say, power, right? So it takes a thing, but there is a lot of water. Maine is like the Saudi Arabia of water, which is not to say it's endless and we shouldn't squander it, but just because you keep adding more doesn't necessarily you need to, you don't need to, you're just pulling it from under the ground and it gets filled in from other places, from the rain and whatnot. So it's not surprising to me that we can keep adding and adding and adding and there's ability to serve as long as the pipes get built, although it seems like there would be an end, it might be quite far out. Right, well, [1:22:57] Speaker E (unidentified): droughts notwithstanding of course but I mean I think the water district does do projections about future development and does things like upgrades water lines like there 'll be some work done on Yarmouth Road heading towards Yarmouth you know so to upgrade water lines to make them wider and long you know to accommodate not I'm not only existing customers but future [1:23:22] Speaker D (unidentified): anticipated growth as well, and there to your point about developers being responsible. There was a project that came that didn't go through, but that was a large several dwelling units, and there was talk from the water district about potentially needing to have them help pay in for like pump stations and stuff like that. So that would be a discussion at that time if the water district felt that their ability to serve a particular project was another level. I didn't see it in, I just didn't see it in the ordinance. [1:23:51] Speaker F (unidentified): So that's why, right, brought it up. Yeah, there's, I mean, they thought it was a great idea when I brought it up to them. It was a while ago, but I brought it up to them, and they thought it was [1:24:01] Speaker B (unidentified): great idea, and I said, well, I'll bring it up. Yeah, the subdivision ordinance only references what [1:24:08] Speaker D (unidentified): they need to do for water, that they have to have a potable water supply, and that they have to have fire protection, but no, it doesn't speak to. You does any ordinance speak to that [1:24:18] Speaker B (unidentified): this is a question about paying for it? No. Yeah, I think, well, they need to get their letter of ability to serve, so the district's not willing to, right, give that letter, then that would come with infrastructure cost potentially, right. Okay, I'm going to bring us back to our business at hand, which is a finding of completeness for the application. Mr. Sherman, yeah, I move [1:24:50] Speaker C (unidentified): to find the application by 224 Shaker Road LLC complete for 401.7.1e. This proposal is for preliminary plan review of a proposal to create a four lot subdivision on the 20.37 plus or minus acre parcel at tax map 13 lot 15-15-00 at 224 Shaker Road in the rural residential agricultural zoning district and stream protection shoreline zoning district. This proposal is subject to major subdivision review and shoreland zoning requirements. Is there a second? I'll second [1:25:22] Speaker B (unidentified): any more discussion? All in favor. That is unanimous. Okay, and now preliminary plan [1:25:32] Speaker C (unidentified): approval. The outstanding look capacity to serve and other things can still be handled in final, so we're conditions on the back five covers five covers that. Okay, we don't need any extra ones, I think they are already all covered. Is that fair to say? Do we agree on that? Okay, yeah, I move to approve the application by 224 Shaker Road LLC for preliminary plan review of a proposal to create a four lot subdivision on the 20.37 plus or minus acre parcel at tax map 13 lot 15-15-00 at 224 Shaker Road in The Rural Residential Agricultural Zoning District and Stream Protection Shoreline Zoning District. This proposal is subject to major subdivision review and shoreland zoning requirements and is subject to the following conditions listed one through seven in the board memo dated November 2nd. [1:26:47] Speaker B (unidentified): 2026. Second. Any discussion on that? All in favor? That's also unanimous. You're on your way. Thank you. Except [1:26:59] Speaker I (unidentified): for the process, we do have an abutter here. I don't know if he has anything to say tonight. [1:27:08] Speaker B (unidentified): I didn't realize you were in a butter and it's not public comment so but we'd happy if you want to step up. We have time before we adjourn. All good. All right, well thank you very much for your time. Motion. All in favor. All right, close the meeting.