Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): It would have been late Sunday's early. Yeah, that's awesome. It's nice. The point is the condition of the beach. If you look at those photographs and wander over there.
[0:14] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, not a stitch of, yeah.
[0:17] Speaker A (unidentified): You'll see that it's a primary concern. Very handy. These are very helpful.
[0:25] Speaker C (unidentified): These are what, careening?
[0:27] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah,. Yeah, take a look.
[0:29] Speaker C (unidentified): It's about the beach. I remember those days.
[0:32] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, I remember those days. It's about the beach.
[0:34] Speaker F (unidentified): What? It's the beach, not the boats.
[0:37] Speaker A (unidentified): It's about the beach. The beach. What used to be the beach.
[0:43] Chair: Oh, man, this is a disaster here.
[0:47] Speaker C (unidentified): I just want a coffee.
[0:51] Chair: All right, are we live? Okay, thank you.
[0:55] Speaker H (unidentified): Do we have Zoom?
[0:56] Chair: How do we do that? Nobody's joined yet. Okay, it would be Nancy. Okay, and Steve, but he's sitting here, so I guess not. Okay, today is, oh, Nancy, let's see what she has to say. Meeting ID, do you know what the meeting
[1:21] Speaker A (unidentified): is? He's trying. He used to, he used to carry very free from uneven ridiculous boring handling and towing salvage submarine testing. When did you
[1:36] Speaker C (unidentified): get rid of that? So yesterday. No, I don't remember it from, say, 88 on. Okay, I just sent that to her. 1988, was it around? Okay,
[1:51] Speaker H (unidentified): ready? You can keep browsing.
[1:56] Chair: Good morning. This meeting of the Town of Camden Harvard Committee on November 10th is called to order. This is a public meeting. Minutes are recorded. Meeting is broadcast on Zoom and recorded for YouTube replay. Please turn on your microphones. Public commenters, please step up to a microphone. Roll call. We have, I think, everybody, and Nancy is trying to Zoom in and it's not working. You compare the ID to this latency achieve.
[2:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Just focusing on the condition of the beach. All right.
[2:49] Chair: Ron is here. Peter is here. Nancy will be here. I think we have everybody in attendance today. We're just waiting for Nancy. Nancy, I'm sure she'll get connected soon here. Microphone's on. Phone call. Confirm voting members. I think everybody's here, so we don't need an alternate. Let me try to get Nancy in here. Is that correct? Yeah. Are you able to email her? No, you can't. Okay. All right. Meeting minutes assignment, Nancy, was this time. Richard, you are assigned for these minutes. Will you accept that responsibility?
[4:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, do I have a choice? No.
[4:16] Chair: You say that every time. Thank you, Richard. Confirm next meeting date, December 10th, 8 a.m. Does anybody think of anything crazy going on that day? Shouldn't be a no voting no anything, so we'll plan on that December 10th. Public comments
[4:44] Speaker I (unidentified): on non-agenda items. Yes, Ron brought in these photographs to illustrate the
[4:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Extreme contrast between the condition of the beach in the late 80s and the condition of that same location today. And it's a extreme difference. Beach is gone and we're left with a boulder field.
[5:12] Chair: What is that Sherman's? [Speaker A (unidentified): That's library park.] Oh, okay, I haven't seen them yet. Head of the harbor.
[5:19] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think this is pertinent to the conversation regarding the process or project that's going on at the head of the harbor with regard to the park and the seawall and the dam and all of that. This should be part of the conversation and we should be part of the conversation. The library committee has either been assigned or usurp the total control the situation that they had the harbor and that to my mind is totally inappropriate. This is something that should be discussed at the harbor committee level and also at the select board level so that we don't end up with a similar situation that we got into at the snowball where we were spending millions of dollars and it was grossly mismanaged and I can see we're setting ourselves up for a similar scenario with this project at the head of the harbor. So then they've moved the approach to the Windjammers proposal, but they're claiming that it's 99% complete or 90% complete. And I've heard from at least two of the Windjammer owners at the head of the harbor who assert that they were not considered. They were not asked what they thought of the impact, what they thought the impact would be of moving their approach, the floats from the park to their facility. They should have been consulted and we should have been consulted prior to that change being made in their proposal that the library committee has put forward. So I think this should be front and center on our conversation whether we have it today or whether we put it on the agenda for a future meeting. We're using up our time re revisiting the aberronences when perhaps we're watching something happen and we're not but we're not being involved in it. So my advice is that we put this on the agenda and give it the consideration that it's due.
[8:04] Chair: I think rather than putting it on the agenda, we should, I mean, I think it would it be, I know Steve, you had a meeting with the, I remember I was down at the Harbor and you said, hey, want to come over? There's a meeting with the Windjammers and Jeremy. Me and the so obviously that wasn't enough. It was one brief meeting, but that would have been nice. It would be nice for us to have, yes, we can put it on. I don't mean to not put it on the agenda, but what could it also be appropriate for me to email whoever needs to be emailed to say we would like to know when these are happening so we can be involved. We think that the harbor committee should know what's what's going on. I don't know, get just so we have the opportunity to
[8:51] Speaker D (unidentified): be part of it. I think I think that it could make a motion right now after that the pictures and everything and I think it is I think it is important if they're about to do to do something pretty big change to that area. I remember this is an advisory group. So you might want to take a vote to then go to the select board and say that we have, I wouldn't call it an emergency advisory, but we'd like to put this on the front burner for you guys, a select board to make sure that we're involved to help advise you with pictures like this
[9:38] Chair: And even sitting at the meetings to say, wait, hey, have you considered this?
[9:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, exactly. Because, you know, I don't know the extent of what they're doing. We had three meetings about how they're going to change lighting. And they talked about rising, you know, bringing up the area right where that, you know, granite wall is, the rock wall. They didn't say anything about you know like how could they make it so the waves or action doesn't draw the defined particles out like you know like Ron is saying. So it would be good to have someone there and be involved. Nancy can you mute yourself like Ron is saying so it would [Speaker F (unidentified): be good thank] you. I think that's the best thing to do because remember we're an advisory group so we want to get this information to the select committee. I am muted.
[10:30] Chair: Okay, we were getting some feedback. I wasn't, that's all. Hi, Nancy.
[10:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. Where they are in this is, you know, they're in the, obviously, the planning stage. So it would be great to get, you know, that to, I think Amon is one of the top guys that's doing it. We met. Who? Amon.
[10:57] Speaker B (unidentified): It's an engineering research group.
[11:00] Chair: Yeah I mean I do think it's yeah go Peter I think it's important to get involved at least
[11:05] Speaker B (unidentified): On following up and Ron's suggestion, and I think we have an obligation to take advantage of, he's got some historic, yeah, you know, stuff, and if we could make a copy of those and get those into a packet, but we did to follow up on Steve and Ron and our own minutes from a month ago, we talked about a workshop. So this is an opportunity to not just go to the select board, it's to go to the town, to the library, to all of these groups that are affected and say to the select board, plan a community-wide workshop and get these people on record, presenting material and listening to the different, quote, advisory groups, whatever you want to call us, but the public needs to be, the select board, the community needs to have an open forum for this as opposed to, well, we'll have a little workshop. We'll have three people down at the dock to talk about this. We brought this up a month ago, a workshop. That it was in coordination, you know, hang on, it was in coordination with what we're talking about today, article four and article five. This is, it's, it's all about the harbor, it's all about moorings, it's all about, it's, it's, it's entirely appropriate to have this brought up today and to go to the select board and say we need, we're talking about ordinances in article four and five.
[12:44] Chair: Steve is the difference because, like, I know they had, you know, at the library all of that for that was like harbor resiliency and stuff. Is it the difference because this is private owned by the library, is that where it hasn't been as much involvement? I'm just wondering, not owned.
[13:01] Speaker A (unidentified): By the library, that property is owned by the town and the town is, was the library committee was granted the authority or the responsibility of maintaining the grounds. Another part of this conversation is that without the permission that was granted by the library committee some time along about the same time those pictures were taken, mid to late 80s, I'd have to research that, but we wouldn't have that access to those three windjammer births that was granted by the library committee and they are now designated as windjammer births, but if the library and so we, I can't emphasize enough how important it is that we respect that decision by the library committee. To allow access from the park to those wing jammer berths and how that if that were to be revoked what a dramatic impact that would be on the
[14:18] Speaker F (unidentified): Wing jammer birds there's, there is no, I mean, just as a process point, this is a agenda item, so, Madam Chair, I don't know how much discussion you want to allow.
[14:30] Chair: Yeah, I think we should. I mean, it's kind of coming up fast, so.
[14:33] Speaker F (unidentified): But there is no intention on any part to either move those berths or get rid of access. There is discussion, my understanding, there is discussion of the encroachment into the park that has happened and where vehicles get stored and where gear gets stored. And some of that is being renegotiated. Yeah, but there is no intention to remove births or access to births for those with jammers, that's never been part of the conversation. I didn't suggest that it was. Okay, I just wanted to, I'm
[15:07] Speaker A (unidentified): just saying, I'm just pointing out that those, that access is there by the auspice of the library committee, that's all I'm saying, and that needs to be respected, so, yeah, whatever, I don't
[15:22] Speaker F (unidentified): I think that's what I'm saying. I don't think there's any discussion that would change.
[15:28] Chair: Peter, did you have something else to, sorry, I interrupted you. I wanted some clarification that was, I was confused. Okay.
[15:33] Speaker D (unidentified): So I think the one thing, the takeaway from this is that Ron's right. He brings up a point. First of all, for me, when I think about this, someone obviously said, hey, let's rebuild the park in a different way, and that started going off. Now we're being brought into a, you know, the windjammers were brought in twice now to say what do you think of this, and they're, and so they said to the windjammers, well, we know that you guys park here even though you're, you know, the agreement you have for the town says you can't park here, but they can, they can load and unload, but I said, well, organically over the past 30, 35 years, it's just kind of come to this where they kind of, they kind of need to, but let's work together, and we are, we're having conversation about how this is going to work. Maybe give them a, they're getting clever about it, how they're going to do it. They know that in the two parts of the season where they're loading on, you know, things like sales and stuff like that, they have trailers down there, and so we're in the process of doing that, but I think the important thing is that we do get involved to say, well, if you're going to be doing something like this, let's make sure, like Ron said, that you're doing it in a way that doesn't make it so we lose that beach in the next, hopefully you could do it so you fortify it so fine particulates don't get lost like Ron's pictures show. Yeah, Ron
[17:09] Speaker A (unidentified): This was, I brought this up as a non-agenda item, and I think this was right. We're getting BEING WAY TOO FAR INTO THIS, GIVEN THAT IT WAS A NON-AGENDA ITEM AND THAT USUALLY ON THOSE NON-AGENDA ITEMS THERE IS A STATEMENT MADE AND NOT OPEN TO FEEDBACK. AND THIS IS A HARBOR COMMITTEE MEETING, NOT THE HARBOR MASTERS MEETING, SO I WOULD LIKE THAT TO BE RESPECTED. Just to add to my non-agenda.
[17:44] Chair: I find it very helpful to get some context on non-agenda items. I know not everybody does, but go on, Ron, I think it's helpful.
[17:53] Speaker A (unidentified): When at the time, just for reference, the Stephen Tabor was moved five times in the history of her working in Camden Harbor. The Mary Day was moved five times, sailed from five different locations IN THE INNER HARBOR. OTHER SCHOOLNERS HAVE BEEN MOVED TWO OR THREE TIMES IN THEIR EXPERIENCE IN THE INNER HARBOR. WHEN THE LIBRARY COMMITTEE GRANTED ACCESS TO THAT SPACE WHICH HAD YET NOT BEEN CREATED, PRIOR TO THAT ACCESS BEING GRANTED BY THE HARBOR COMMITTEE, WE HAD ACCESS FROM AMERICAN BOAT HOUSE TO THREE WINDJAMMERS. ONLY ONE OF THOSE BIRTHS FELL INTO A SITUATION WHERE THE TOWN WOULD HAVE JURISDICTION OVER THE SPACE THAT IT OCCUPIED. CONDITION AS SET RIGHT NOW, THE TOWN HAS JURISDICTION OVER ALL THREE OF THOSE SPACES BECAUSE THEY'RE IN FRONT OF TOWN OWNED PROPERTY. THE POINT I'M MAKING IN THAT PART OF THE CONVERSATION IS that we had reached a point where the town needed to make a decision. Do we want these windjammers to be here or don't we? That was the basic question that needed to be answered. It was answered by the library committee by saying, they said, yes, we think these windjammers should be here. So they provided access to that space that was created. I think we're at a similar impasse today where, and I get crystals, that there is no intention, but I would like to hear that from first party, not secondhand. I WOULD LIKE TO HEAR WHAT THE INTENTIONS ARE FROM THE LIBRARY COMMITTEE AND THE PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS THAT THEY HAVE CHOSEN TO BE THEIR COHORTS IN THIS PROCESS THAT THEY'RE ABOUT TO EMBARK ON. I THINK IT'S CRITICAL THAT WE NOT MOVE FORWARD WITHOUT THERE BEING SOME PARTICIPATION FROM THE HARBOR COMMITTEE AND ANYONE ELSE IN THE COMMUNITY WHO HAS A GENUINE INTEREST IN THE conversation, that it not be allowed to be determined by a small group of people who are handpicked by a previous administration. We have a new administration, and I think that administration should express its concerns regarding what's about to happen at the head.
[20:43] Chair: of the harbor so what can we do ron to move to do we want to just be invited to meetings what i guess i need a it'd be nice to have some guidance on an action item here what we can do to get involved i'm happy to say hey we want to be part of this do i have to go to select board do i
[21:05] Speaker A (unidentified): I think the select board should take the responsibility to organize a public forum in which this is all openly discussed by members of the community who are concerned and have an interest in this project moving forward.
[21:27] Speaker F (unidentified): With all due respect, that happened in August, facilitated by the library committee and the park board.
[21:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Exactly. Facilitated by the people who have usurped the power. But are they looking for feedback?
[21:43] Speaker F (unidentified): They were looking for feedback, right? They accepted feedback. They took public comment. They are running the project in coordination with town staff currently. Crystal, I was at that meeting
[21:54] Speaker A (unidentified): and it was not an open forum. They provided cards on which you could make recommendations. Recommendations, there was, there was a lot of speaking going on, but it was being done by the library or hand-picked people that they had chosen to represent this project, but there's some other
[22:11] Speaker F (unidentified): town staff involved, I understand, but where we are now, and again, I mean, we are now, sorry, it's not my meeting, madam chair, but we're half an hour into a harbor committee meeting discussing unrelated related process. Both Jody and Jeremy are actively involved in the project from the town side, they're reporting, the board chair is getting updates, the whole board is getting updates from Interflow, I mean, the project is going forward, and there has been a lot of public input. Personally, I think we
[22:51] Chair: need to tell, I can send a, just, it doesn't need to be a vote, doesn't, I say to something to select for and say harbor committee would like to be involved. Personally, I can mention it this evening under, yeah, I don't report, I'm happy to, I don't think it's a thing that I think, and then we can, and then in those, if one of us are able to go to those, or Ron, if you're able to go to those, then we can say bring on these up and say hey, we need to, I'd like to have a public forum, I think this is important, but first of all, we need to get on the loop with what the conversations, so Chris, so that would be great if you could mention that, yeah, and then I mean, I do think we need to get involved, and first of all, we need to find out when conversations are being had, so let's do that meeting. Any other non-agenda items
[23:43] Speaker A (unidentified): I just want to reiterate that the conversation thus far and this conversation has been going on for ten years has been systematically orchestrated by a certain aspect of and a certain group of people with a certain agenda and a certain perspective. It has in fact not been opened up to, yes, there's been meetings that were open to the public, but they were always supervised by either Merkak, the Citizens Advisory Group, which is now somehow, we don't know what they're doing anymore or whether they've been, in fact, disbanded. That conversation hasn't been, there's a lot of information that has not been forthcoming.
[24:37] Chair: Ron, I think we've got to get involved and bring that information I think people don't know about it unless it's put out in front of
[24:44] Speaker A (unidentified): them and challenged the point that I'm trying to make is that rather than these meetings being supervised by a group that is partial to a certain outcome I think these meetings open public meetings and there should be a series of them not just one that they should be organized by the select board and the that the conversation be put out there that this is a public forum put forth by the select board not a private citizens group with
[25:26] Chair: a certain agenda right but they have been granted
[25:30] Speaker I (unidentified): kind of. By a previous administration.
[25:33] Speaker A (unidentified): We have a new administration. But remember,
[25:35] Chair: we can all have our opinions, but if it doesn't get heard, that doesn't mean it wasn't
[25:42] Speaker A (unidentified): given. I understand that. I understand that.
[25:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Ron, if you and I want to have this conversation. I'm just trying to use our time efficiently.
[25:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, right. Okay, that would be fine. But if there's going to be rebuttal to my comment, then I'm going to reserve, since I initiated this non-agenda conversation, I'm going to reserve the last word.
[26:08] Chair: Okay. I am happy to try to find out how we can get in the conversation, but I cannot schedule a select board public forum. So this is what I can do. I'm happy to hear suggestions, Ron, if you want to email me or chat with me about what more I can do, but I don't know what else I can do with my chair power and also my personal time. So you're heard and we hear it and we want to move forward with that in the meeting. So we're going to go to the meeting minutes approval October 2026. Nancy did those. Does anybody have any edits on Nancy's minutes? I thought I had one. Let's see if I can find them in my pile of papers here. I had them somewhere. You have them right here. You stole the minutes? No, I lost my minutes. I might have, that's okay. I think we just need to change Michael Scaling's spelling.
[27:37] Speaker H (unidentified): I think there's a K in there.
[27:40] Chair: There the only other thing I noticed the committee discussed seeking Toby as a second alternate I would also add not necessarily to any alternates and I think it was more on any alternate rather than specifically I know there were some comments about Toby or about having you know asking him but I think it was saying hey we could use another alternate what else I thought there was one more thing. Another spelling, Dockware. It's Dockware, right, Steve? [Speaker B (unidentified): Dockwa, W-A.] But it's Dockware, isn't it? No, it's Dockwa. Oh, it's Dockwa? Yeah, that's it. Oh, never mind then. Dockwa. Does anybody else have any changes to the minutes? I'm just still trying to find mine here. Chris, so you've got to teach me how to use an iPad. I think that was all my edits was that can I see that one Ron did it have writing on it oh yeah okay I would make a motion to approve Nancy's October minutes any further discussion all in favor all right five zero moving on to harbor fees those aren't on the agenda for tonight Chris oh do you know if they'll be on for I mean, do we want to take more time to look at these or should we
[30:01] Speaker F (unidentified): New speaker it comes up in February. New speaker oh, really? New speaker okay.
[30:08] Chair: I thought it was coming. It said the end of November.
[30:10] Speaker F (unidentified): New speaker I think they sort of get presented. New speaker okay. New speaker
[30:15] Chair: So I think maybe we can just briefly touch on them and probably need a little more time to look at them. I just linked them to the site. I'm not sure how much people had time to look at them. Also I did print out if anybody wants a copy of what we had sent you know in January of last year that what we had you know after kind of our dinghy surveying and whatnot what we had suggested so those you know we had put a little thought into those so those might be good to compare to what is happening because it's hard to compare to something that we had already looked at and suggested so I can it's I can make a copy you can have that right now Richard well there's this too yeah we'll make Some copies of that. Does anybody have anything, if they were able to look at it, that would be something. Yes, Steve. We're talking about the fee, fees, harbor fees, because they will be looking at those. I don't think we should spend as much time as we did last time. Well, maybe because we got ignored. But I also, you know, I would plan on, I would plan on being at the meeting and saying so when they say we're going to send a memo that says this is what we suggest for fees advising, and then one of us or myself sits at the meeting and when they're brought up, if they throw them out the window, we say wait a second. Yeah, so yes.
[31:50] Speaker C (unidentified): What we seem to do every year is look at some automatic inflationary increase in fee. And I think given the current mood of the country, the town, et cetera, that we basically keep the fees the same. I also think that we should get rid of what I consider just not relevant, that, you know, we're selling space, we're renting space, and then discounting rowboats or boats without a motor, whatever, just discounts our space. Space. And I don't see any reason to do that. The space for a rowboat is just as valuable as the space for an inflatable with a motor on it. And in fact, if we're looking at this as source of income for the harbor, the committee, the town, whatever, then it denies us income to improve our dinghy storage facilities.
[33:02] Chair: So you think that whether it has a motor or not, it should be the same.
[33:08] Speaker C (unidentified): And the third thing is, it's not quite connected with the same fees, but looking at Article 4. Article 4.108-10 is an article about the Harbormaster removing boats and getting involved in a troubling situation. And what it says in there is that the Harbormaster shall charge the approved fee set by the town. Well, there are no approved fees in that list, as far as I can see, for strange situations. The only fee that seems to be approved in that list of removal is for removing a dinghy, so that if it's a more difficult situation, a bigger situation, we don't have a mechanism, either an hourly charge or a reasonable charge created by the harbor.
[34:09] Chair: Is it usually hauled by somebody else if there's a larger removal issue? You know, it's, it's, I didn't know if it gets, if somebody's boat sinks in the harbor, I, yeah.
[34:24] Speaker D (unidentified): Unfortunately, are you full, are you pulling it? We've only had one boat sink, and that, and I, the person Ian Cushing never answered any phones and just left his boat there, and so we
[34:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Had to take care of that at price. Well, I mean, I think that as I read the language in the code, is because you don't know what the fee is going to like if you're talking about a 40 foot boat or an 80 foot, like you don't know what that cost is going to be. So it's going to be that we figure out what the fee, if it's a big boat you figure out the fee and that goes to the town, the
[35:00] Chair: town says yes, that's what we'll charge them. So the town would still be setting it, wouldn't be
[35:04] Speaker F (unidentified): covered by not having a general statement. I think it the tank, the town says the harbor master shall truth charge the approved to be paid by the master owner of the vessel, which charge together with the cost of crew and or equipment for removing that vessel to make, I mean, that it says okay, the town if you know, whereas a ding, I mean to remove a dinghy means we're grabbing that thingy and sticking it wherever and we know the public works puts in their trucks and we store it somewhere if
[35:34] Chair: it doesn't have a permit. So but by saying that's a set by the town, does that mean Steve has an issue and he has to come get town approval before he does anything for that? I mean, the board that
[35:43] Speaker F (unidentified): can be, it just can be okay. Yeah, that can be harbormaster and town managers say you know yes, if it's a 50-foot boat we're gonna have to bring a barge in where you know it's going to be
[35:54] Chair: they're gonna you're gonna give a quote and they're gonna say that 's what it's gonna
[35:57] Speaker F (unidentified): okay approval of the fee can happen after the yeah and i think i think that 's a little bit you know when we're looking at our fee schedule these are service fees like these are what we're charging people for use of something or to your point like for boring things that's rental and so it's a little bit different to have a set this is what we've decided these things cost but the to me that language in 10810 covers
[36:30] Chair: any different situations. Okay thanks Steve. Well I guess my last thing is just my annual
[36:37] Speaker C (unidentified): objection to various rates for the size of a motor but discounts from an electric motor.
[36:47] Chair: Got it, the over 20 extra over 20 extra. I think hey Liz, yeah, oh it's, I just it was Steve you said I didn't want to interrupt you one second Nancy. Yeah okay go ahead Nancy, thank you.
[37:06] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, I would just like to go back to last year. Our intent was, we had asked that resident fees not go up, and I think that would, you know, I would still like to see that resident fees not go up. However, I do think that there is room for more revenue if needed in what we charge for trans-ins. I think that the boats less than 40 feet could go up to $4, 47 could go five. I think a Harbor float could go up to maybe 70. I think the cruise ship dockage could go up more and they're not gonna flinch. So if there has to be revenue, if they want an increase in revenue, I would like to see it come from that rather than from Camden residents who are already paying enough in taxes.
[38:07] Chair: Nancy would you type up your actual dollar recommendations because I know you or would they be the same well it I mean it sounds like you have specific numbers it'd be great to see those for next time. Yeah, I'd be happy to just because I end up researching that
[38:25] Speaker J (unidentified): and we're we're I think I think we could come up there sure I'd be happy to type something up just
[38:31] Chair: Just kind of just a brief, what those numbers might look like.
[38:36] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, okay, no problem.
[38:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Liz, will our December 10th meeting be in the right timing to change this and present it to the-
[38:51] Chair: Chris, do you think we should have that finished by our December?
[38:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think if you can have this-
[38:58] Chair: Yeah, I mean, I think with all the work we did before, Or I'll email out that old document that Elliot had done just to reference maybe the changes we had done before if anybody wants to look. I mean, I don't think there's going to be so much we need to talk about it for meetings and meetings.
[39:13] Speaker C (unidentified): No, I think it's just December 10th. Yeah. Recommendations.
[39:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Yes, Ron. A couple of things. I agree with Steve that we should keep the rates the way they are in this current financial situation. i don't agree that we should eliminate the discounts for electric motors and rowboats i think those are there to incentivize people to row as opposed to using internal combustion engines and i understand this is this is these warm fuzzy tree hugging perspectives but I, FOR ONE, WOULD LIKE TO SEE MORE PEOPLE ROWING AND LESS NOISE FROM OUTBOARDS AND LESS POLLUTION FROM OUTBOARDS, SO THAT'S JUST MY PERSONAL PERSPECTIVE, AND I THINK THAT'S WHY THAT'S HERE. THE OTHER THING IS WE CAN'T BASE OUR RECOMMENDATIONS ON WHETHER OR NOT THE HARBOR IS MAKING MONEY making enough money or are we using the harbor as a as a cash cow to help with income to be channeled into other aspects of the town budget and we won't know that and i appreciate steve pushing towards getting some sort of a insight into how much money do we actually make from the harbor how much money does the town actually realize in terms of income and what are the expenditures and without knowing that, we can't know whether or not our rates are too high or too low, without
[41:08] Speaker C (unidentified): a cost. Well, we do know that. I mean, I've presented that in previous meetings of talking about the income that is directly attributable to the harbor and the expenses that are directly attributable to the harbor. And based on projections of the 26th budget, ultimately, the harbor contribution to the general fund is $204,840. The general fund, yeah, well, that's where the money goes regardless. I've lobbied for a personal harbor committee checkbook.
[41:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Eight copies of that, thank you. So what about expenditures? [Speaker C (unidentified): Well, the expenses] coming far.
[42:10] Speaker C (unidentified): The harbor expenses are $264,750. The harbor revenue is $469,600.
[42:22] Chair: I don't want to get too far into that because we're making, we're doing some good bullet points here on the fees to help for next time. That's an important, but separate issue. So I have Nancy's thoughts. She's going to send us some, Steve Gold, Ron, Richard, do you have anything to add? And you don't have to right now. Peter, do you have anything to add at the moment? And Steve's making some copies of our last recommendations.
[42:53] Speaker B (unidentified): The only comment I have is that I did a little homework and going through chapter four of our ordinance, the harbor ordinances. And it is good that we're looking at fees regarding how dinghies and how floats and how moorings are managed. So we have an opportunity to clean up, it's down the road, but this is a good discussion that we're working on. I think we probably could maybe even make the rules of a dinghy and some of these recreational boats smaller. Why does it need to be X feet long? Why does it need to have this much beam? If we're trying to satisfy space management at the same time of you charging a fee, you've got people out there who violate all of our rules. Oh, no. Many people violate rules for no, with no real penalty. And they maybe that could be even put in the ordinance that, oh, by the way, we're going to start giving you a ticket. I know it's technically mentioned in there ages ago, but maybe this is a time to start because it's because it's near impossible sometimes to get in. To some of these docks with some of these boats that people.
[44:26] Chair: Are you talking about the dinghy dock? Yeah. Yeah, so there are a couple large boats in there that we've been discussing. I had a kind of a thought that...
[44:34] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll just leave it like that. It looks like Nancy has a comment.
[44:39] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, back on the fees, we have a charge for moorings. I didn't think the town rented out transient moorings. Is Steve not there anymore?
[44:54] Chair: He's just making some copies for me. He'll be right back.
[44:57] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah. To my knowledge, I didn't think we run it out transient moorings. Let's see.
[45:08] Chair: That's for, I don't think that's for, oh, transient moorings.
[45:13] Speaker A (unidentified): It's in the ordinance. It's in the ordinance. If you're not going to be using the mooring, you're required.
[45:18] Chair: Oh, so that would be transient is actually saying not the mooring holder.
[45:23] Speaker A (unidentified): For a period of three days or more you are required to notify the harbor master that you will not be using your mooring and he is at liberty to rent that mooring to somebody if he
[45:33] Chair: So chooses and I think that's interesting and that price I don't think it's done well that price is also to say if I'm not going to be on my mooring I can collect for kind of a rental but it can't be more than the value of that is that why that fee is kind of what I think it typically gets done
[45:56] Speaker F (unidentified): If it gets done we've talked about it even here before it's it's like for three weeks or something it's not an it's not transient in the sense that we often think of it being an overnight one or two nights it's like it's that's I think where yeah where they sort of categorize those people of like I'm going to have my boat in Camden for three weeks and I'm going to rent someone's mooring and
[46:23] Chair: When Steve gets back I'll ask for clarification Nancy yeah I just find that confusing I find it
[46:29] Speaker F (unidentified): Confusing it's it's it's what probably should be something other than transient I think yes Ron
[46:34] Speaker A (unidentified): What makes that fall into the transient designation is that the town is capable of providing RADIO OR TELEPHONE COMMUNICATION, SHORESIDE SERVICES WHICH INCLUDE TOILET AND TRASH AND RECYCLABLE REMOVAL. SO IF THE TOWN CAN PROVIDE THAT, THEN THEY ARE IN A POSITION TO CHARGE FOR TRANSCENT MOORINGS. And privately owned mooring, if you're not going to use it, you're required to notify the harbor master that you're not going to use it. Then he is at liberty to rent that mooring, rent your mooring to a transient customer.
[47:17] Chair: Right, but he can't rent it for more than that and make extra money. That's why that fee is kind
[47:21] Speaker I (unidentified): of there. I'm not saying that the fee makes no sense. No, it's, it's not the owner that's renting
[47:27] Speaker A (unidentified): the mooring, right, transient. It's the town that's renting the mooring, your mooring, to a transient
[47:34] Chair: but that's the price that they can rent it for. If there's a, if there wasn't a fee for it, then there would be no guidance, right? I think we better get clarification. Yeah, he'll be, he should be right. Oh, here he comes coming in the door. Thank you, Steve. I've sent you out at the wrong time or just the right. Nancy has a, Nancy's wondering about, so we have under moorings, we have transient under 40 and over 40. What does the town rent moorings? She was saying that they don't normally rent moorings, but is it if somebody leaves for a couple weeks, you could technically rent out their mooring. There's a fee for that, 325 and 375, usually yearly fees. Yeah, I think those are yearly fees, right? So when would that be applicable? The fee schedule has
[48:27] Speaker F (unidentified): both because it's, it is a little confusing. It should have per night, per year. Well,
[48:37] Chair: Steve's thinking about that. What I'm passing out is the, our recommendations when Elliott was chair for what we had done, kind of that, all that dingy work.
[48:50] Speaker A (unidentified): That 325 is obviously an annual fee that is charged by the town to a transient mooring owner. Transit mooring owners, i.e., whether it's PG Willey, there needs to be shoreside facilities in order for you to qualify as a transit mooring provider. And
[49:16] Speaker E (unidentified): both Wyman Morris and McLaughlin have some number of moorings that they rent on them.
[49:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Because they provide those shoreside services and they provide the radio contact. Yeah.
[49:28] Chair: Scott Rocknack has four, but the fee is there because you can't rent it for more
[49:36] Speaker I (unidentified): than using more than anything else. The fee is what the town receives from the
[49:41] Speaker D (unidentified): transient mooring owner. Yeah, so look, obviously there's residential moorings where you're not allowed, you have your personal boat on it, but if you want a transient mooring like Laman Morris has a lot of transient moorings, they're, they're charged $325,000 if it's under 40 feet. If it's over 40 feet, it's...
[50:00] Chair: Oh, so it's the booking agent can apply for a transient mooring. Correct. Okay, so it's not talking about somebody renting it for three weeks. It's talking about, okay, Lyman Morse is going to apply for a under 40 mooring that they can rent out because they're a booking agent and they will pay the town $325,000. Per year. Per year. Does that make sense, Nate? that i mean that makes sense though it's not clear in that but it's clear in the definitions
[50:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Look at what transient means in the definitions and you'll understand that they have certain obligations that they need to fulfill in order to qualify as a transient mooring.
[50:42] Speaker J (unidentified): Owner, it's just, I find, I get it, I just find it the way it's worded it makes it sound like.
[50:49] Chair: The town is running out to me. I would have a parentheses that says only to be, you know, it can only be purchased or rented by a booking agent. That's the only people who are allowed to do.
[51:04] Speaker B (unidentified): That. Can you, can you put in parentheses on this list booking agent? Yeah, I mean, that would be, would.
[51:11] Speaker A (unidentified): That be, is that, well, it isn't a booking agent, it's not, it's not a booking agent doesn't provide buying the shoreside services?
[51:21] Chair: I think they have to. Yes, they do. They have to be a booking agent. We went through this over the summer. To be able to rent out the mooring like that or Harbor Float that this was, a booking agent has to have those same criteria. Okay.
[51:36] Speaker B (unidentified): So Artisan has two or three moorings out in front of Steamboat, but they can't rent them out. Is that correct? They use them for their own boats. I think they're service moorings.
[51:51] Chair: So in order for them to rent them for a profit or as a business or to recoup their money, they have to have those shoreline services.
[52:05] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think a service mooring is required to have those shoreline services.
[52:09] Speaker F (unidentified): That's just they can put a customer vote on it and not.
[52:13] Speaker E (unidentified): While they're repairing the whatever.
[52:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Or just to keep it in the harbor for our customer. But it's not, there's no offer.
[52:22] Chair: So I think putting something about the fact that you need to be a booking agent to rent to apply for that is fine.
[52:27] Speaker J (unidentified): Not here it wouldn't be. When I do my fee thing, I'll try to come up with some verbiage for that.
[52:34] Speaker A (unidentified): No, we can't. I was just confused. You can't change the verbiage of the definition of these.
[52:44] Chair: Well, we've clarified it for us. Make it a little more clear.
[52:47] Speaker J (unidentified): There. Oh yeah. But other people looking at it would be confused. I would think.
[52:53] Speaker D (unidentified): I don't think they would be when we've got, we've got non-resident moorings. We've got resident moorings. We've got service moorings. We've got transient moorings, but you could figure out if you want to put something in a star asterisk or something,
[53:06] Chair: then fine. Or that can be feedback to the select board that we found that a little confusing if
[53:10] Speaker C (unidentified): they want to change something we can also lose you know without having to change an ordinance you know which takes a channel vote we can't change what we put in the permit application you know as a reminder so if you're applying for a transient mooring in that application it can be a reminder of what you have to provide you got to do x y or a reference to the ordinance
[53:38] Chair: that's cool I wouldn't bother but okay any anything else that we want to go over otherwise I think we would everybody get their thoughts and next month we can you know feel free to email the group your thoughts so we can look at it before the meeting and we can try to finalize make some votes on what we think we'd like to advise the select board to take a look at
[54:06] Speaker B (unidentified): I'd like to just make one comment that we're working on section four and five and I just have learned it took me all morning to read section four and five and there's this is I'll try to write it down and send it into to the group but there's many ordinance sentences that state the Harbor master has jurisdiction doing X, Y, and Z, but at the, in the same sentence or the sentence before it says it's the authority of the select board. So in a couple of instances, the authority is given to two bodies, the Harbor master and the select board, which is incredibly confusing. And it would be, I think wise for us if the select board wants to be the authority then we should remove this harbormaster as a as a decider in some of those and i've i've highlighted them and i'll circle them there's two or three it's not it's nothing it's not a personal it 's just that many of our ordinances
[55:21] Chair: are decided by the select board I wonder if it's that I mean I'd have to look but yeah I wonder if it's, so the ordinance and stuff is, a lot of it comes down to this is what's on paper and then Steve gets policy. Well, interesting,
[55:39] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you. Yeah, Ron. The ordinance gives the responsibility to Habermaster or the select board to establish policy.
[55:57] Chair: Yeah, we'll look at the sentences, Peter. Let's get the, you know, it'd be nice to read them. I don't have them right in front of me. Highlighted, but I'd love to see them any more on fees. I want to get through one other thing. Do we want to just take a look at these fees and bring back some feedback and we're going to get it done in December? Okay, moving on. We're actually going to bump up memorial benches because I think that should be brief, Steve, and I think Jimmy wanted us to talk about that today. There were two memorial benches that did not pay the 10 year maintenance fee. The town mailed out invoices for maintenance in June and then certified letters in September. So that have one was received, I guess, and one wasn't picked up and they haven't responded or paid anything. Things, so there's the memorial bench policy and so Jimmy highlighted number nine. The harbor committee also reserves the right to place orphan benches into the sponsor the bench program and then it gives some information about sponsor the bench. If we don't choose to do that it would then just not be there anymore. So Steve, you have some thoughts on this.
[57:28] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, there's only one bench, right?
[57:29] Chair: I have two, Emory and Lincoln.
[57:35] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, Desmond, Emory, Snowe. The reason we bring it up is because the Harbor committee, I'm guessing 15 years ago came up with an idea that if there is a bench that has significant meaning to the town, then the harbor committee can vote to basically take that bench over and have the town pay for it. So there's one here, Irving Lincoln, he's probably a fantastic gentleman, but he doesn't have a significant meaning is I don't remember who he is. So, but Desmond Emery Snow, that might be one you could at least talk about. Desmond was Dave Emory's father of course, Dave just passed away, so I mean this we brought it up just wanted to bring up to you guys because you do have the authority to do that. I'm not saying you think it's that's the appropriate branch, I mean you know usually it would be like a an old harbor master or a town manager from 20 years ago that everyone knows like oh we can't get rid of
[58:45] Chair: that bench. I think it's a tricky thing to do one and not the other, you know. I don't really no it's
[58:50] Speaker D (unidentified): you know it's just again it says if the bench has significant meaning remembrance and you guys can say okay well we're now going to put this into a new kid well we're going to say the town take it over so I'm going to so I don't want to get rid of it without making sure you guys knew it. Now these two benches may maybe these neither have significant meaning to the harbor
[59:12] Chair: So the sponsor event program is designed to provide a way for citizens of Camden to preserve serve enduring symbols of Camden Harbors history by sponsoring named benches that no longer have a source of funding. While the Harbor Committee will decide which benches go in to sponsor a bench, the program itself would be administered by the town office.
[59:37] Speaker A (unidentified): So was it Desmond's bench that's...
[59:39] Chair: They can continue sponsoring a bench by paying the town. They can have the bench return. Correct. Yeah, hang on, Ron. I'm just... It's Desmond Emery.
[59:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Desmond Snow, I'm Erving.
[59:50] Chair: Desmond, okay, and then this other one. Did I give you, what's that one, Steve?
[59:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, this is a different person.
[59:58] Chair: This is Erving Lincoln.
[1:00:03] Speaker A (unidentified): It was probably David that was managing the bench for Desmond.
[1:00:08] Speaker D (unidentified): Him and his sister, I believe.
[1:00:09] Chair: Yeah, I asked, the first thing I said to Jimmy was, do we make a phone call so we can get some clarification? Have they not sent their check-in? Have they lost you know have they personally I like to say would you like to continue this it says they have three choice they can continue sponsoring they can have it returned or they can put the bench into a sponsor a bench program so to me I'd like clarification but that they we don't they sent the certified mail and that's what they do to notify the person so I didn't get an answer of no they don't want to continue the bench it would be nice to know we don't need this bench anymore and then It makes our job a little easier but I don't personally know who to contact
[1:00:55] Speaker D (unidentified): Or that's not no it's again it's a if this committee doesn't you know say put one of the benches in or any other benches then we probably just wait another so many months and then
[1:01:09] Chair: Remove the benches significant historical yes okay determine if the named bench is of significant historical value to the sponsor the bench well
[1:01:26] Speaker A (unidentified): My opinion is that both Desmond and David every
[1:01:30] Speaker I (unidentified): Fulfill the requirement of significant the bench is just for that it's not David just for it's for
[1:01:40] Speaker D (unidentified): Desmond Emory snow but I would myself be able to easily get some money up from locals and we could put another plank on that same bench and his loving son, Dave Emory underneath it. And I think that would be more than appropriate.
[1:01:56] Speaker A (unidentified): That would be my thoughts too.
[1:02:00] Chair: I don't know either of them personally or in their historic. So it's, it is hard. I don't have an opinion. I would have loved to know if the family members have any desire to continue the bench. I think if people think it sounds like the Desmond one sounds important and I
[1:02:16] Speaker D (unidentified): would kind of and given a chance they may if we can get if maybe they didn't get that certified
[1:02:21] Chair: one of them was not certified was not picked up so I think that we should try to contact to make sure that what their thoughts are personally I think it'd be nice to get an answer yet yes or no
[1:02:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Well I could have Jimmy do that again making the contact and then bring this back to this committee next month or whatever and we can make the decision then let me see the other one the
[1:02:43] Chair: Lincoln one do you know this person Steve I didn't have the pleasure of knowing that gentleman
[1:02:48] Speaker D (unidentified): I remember when 2016 when it was built yeah
[1:03:11] Chair: I don't have a you know I think it's let's do that I think it's tricky to have a personal opinion about it when there's
[1:03:19] Speaker D (unidentified): Well it's if the time it comes back to us after trying the town trying to reach out again to Desmond's remaining family, then we can have a discussion. I'm sure Peter and Ron and I, we can persuade you to realize that Dave and Desmond were, you know, an intricate part of. I mean,
[1:03:39] Chair: I would default to voting on it. I mean, if you guys, it sounds like you think it was important and I would probably do a yes vote, but if we want to reach out, can we reach out to, both of them? I'll go walk down with you and we can talk to Jimmy. Does that sound, Does anybody have other thoughts? Crystal?
[1:03:58] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I think that our goal should be to try our best to keep benches in place. I mean, this is some group. Somebody wanted them. Yeah, there was an effort. So before we take it out, we should do our best. But there is a point where you know I think moving to trying to get somebody else to adopt a bench
[1:04:26] Chair: is that should be the next yeah I mean it sounds like Irving Lincoln it doesn't sound like he had significant historical ties to the harbor but somebody chose to get a bench for him so I think we should try to find out their thoughts before we move on so let's do that good okay yeah I mean
[1:04:44] Speaker F (unidentified): I think just as a general, you know, these are memorials of somebody. It would be kind of like saying, well, I don't know who died in that tombstone, so we'll just, you know, like, yeah, just because we don't really know what, yeah, like we don't want to keep paying the expense, but we should err on keeping those memorials before. Yes, I agree. All right, moving on. Oh.
[1:05:15] Chair: No, I lost my agenda. There it is. What's next ordinance? So we had, we have article four things that Steve Gold has noted, and then we have our article five with Steve Gold in red and Nancy in blue. The colors do not mean anything, and then green, and then Steve's in green. So the other thought, so now we have 20 minutes. We want to decide what we want to submit to any ordinance changes in the near future, and I don't have huge opinions on it. I think, you know, I think we have some notes here. I do think the fishermen's float verbiage needs to be, to me that's the big one, to get our mooring workers and barge workers to be applying for the correct sort of permit for that area. Yeah, Nancy.
[1:06:43] Speaker J (unidentified): Oh, I was just going to mention, I think that's the big one, and if you look at my blue, I think the, if you just add something at the end, vessels engaged in the commercial marine industry may use the floats when unoccupied by fishermen and by permission of the harbor master.
[1:07:01] Chair: Boom, that would take care of it, and Steve had some, a whole, I mean, you had that kind of a whole sentence. Does everybody have that? So you were saying that the fishermen float would read, okay, so it has commercial full-time fishermen would be top priority, then current permit holders, so if there was a new commercial full-time fishermen they would get precedence over, well, yeah, okay, so current permit holders, Camden residents, non-residents, part-time fishermen, and current permit holders, and then steep and then we have Camden resident, there's a whole, a whole triage here, and then Steve wrote, okay, the first, I'll read this if everybody doesn't have it in front of them, the first eight floats that are just north of the town overnight floats serve as egress to the town small boat marina will be designated as commercial fisherman floats. These floats will be managed by the harbor master in a way that maximizes the use of this system and always ensures that the permitted users have a fast and safe way To perform the necessary tax tasks needed for their business. The north side of this eight float system may be used for permitted dinghies. The use of these floats shall be by permit issued by the select board to applicants holding a commercial fishing license or running harbor related marine business under the following order of preference. So then you would add commercial marine business. So, you're basically just changing it to commercial fishing or harbor-related business and then putting commercial marine business. As for submitting this to the select board for a recommendation, I mean, Crystal, you'd know this. I've never done this before. I mean, we don't necessarily have to write out exactly how it should be written. And we're saying this is, I mean, I assume, you know, other people know how to write ordinances and we would be saying, hey, this is, we'd like to recommend that the fisherman float be changed and then kind of submit what you had said. Like, we want to add that.
[1:09:21] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm suggesting a draft of language concept and then...
[1:09:27] Chair: That's kind of then for them to...
[1:09:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Planning and legal and... Okay.
[1:09:33] Speaker E (unidentified): SOMEHERE IN THAT DISCUSSION THAT WAS REQUIRED FOR PART-TIME FISHERMEN. I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S A COMMERCIAL OR NOT.
[1:09:41] Chair: I think they have to be commercial.
[1:09:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I think there's some distinction between part-time and recreational. Somebody's going to come along and say that I'm a part-time fisherman because I have my five traps.
[1:09:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Well that's why you have to have a there's that's why it says commercial yeah it says it says
[1:10:03] Speaker F (unidentified): commercial and commercial part-time meaning someone who has a full commercial license but that may not be their primary source of income but there are difference when you apply for a
[1:10:14] Chair: fishing license there the five traps is it's not commercial right so there is a distinction
[1:10:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Could I just get clarification on something? Fisherman floats, okay, basically form a U, so it's all the way around. How are we going to deal with, if we should deal with, the issue of overnight dockers on commercial floats?
[1:10:50] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, that's, I think I also changed that. That I have another, I think I added something else that addresses that. I mean, basically it says that the Harbormaster will maximize the use of these floats as long as it doesn't impede any of the actual, you know, commercial actions.
[1:11:14] Chair: These floats will be managed by the Harbormaster in a way that maximizes the use of this system and always ensures that the permitted users have a fast and safe way to perform necessary tasks needed for their business. Yeah, so it doesn't
[1:11:27] Speaker D (unidentified): say, I mean, this is, I'm adding stuff that I've never said before because it literally doesn't say anything. And you're probably referring to the fact that over the years I've let the fishermen at the end of the night leave their boat there. It's not, first of all, there's an implication
[1:11:47] Speaker C (unidentified): patient, you're saying that I'm annoyed about your letting. I'm not concerned about your letting. I am concerned about that the way it's being used now, it's not just occasional. One or two boats are dominating it. And are we producing enmity between the other lobstermen? If there seems to be a general understanding, this is my spot. Do we have a problem? Do you have complaints from other lobstermen?
[1:12:20] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean, I don't have any complaints now. I do have a complaint that during the beginning of the season, when all the moorings are going in, then sometimes there's some friction. At least there was four years ago. I've solved that. So right now, there's no problems. You know, if there is a problem, I can just say, don't leave your boat there.
[1:12:42] Chair: But I don't think there is a specific, like nobody has a certain, it's not like the day sailor dock
[1:12:47] Speaker H (unidentified): where we have certain time slots and no, but there is a situation there now where there
[1:12:53] Chair: is an understanding sort of this is, so we would hope that if somebody else feels they could
[1:12:59] Speaker D (unidentified): you use it without getting well, I, yeah, and if we think this an issue, I could, I could address it. I mean, I can, I came up with an idea that, I mean, I like it and I think you guys do too, that at night there's a couple fish, fishing boats there, it's pretty, the visitors like to take pictures of them, but if two, the only two that really want to do that, I've always started to do that and they've and whether or not they feel it's their spot, I don't know, they never come to me and say that's
[1:13:27] Chair: my spot, they know it's not. I do know that Owen, who's the newer fish, does he keep his boat there generally? Because he would be one that he fishes a lot in the evening, you know, because he does a different job, but would want to make sure he feels he can, yeah, come in and if there's a boat sitting there without anybody able to move it, yeah, so but I mean, I could, I think I added
[1:13:50] Speaker D (unidentified): Something I don't think I actually put it in that, but we could come up with things. If there are more boats that want to do that, right now there isn't, then we can come up with a fair way of how that happens. You're only, you're allowed to so many nights a season to have your boat there overnight, right? And if it's, if you, oh, you've just left it there for a month straight or two weeks, whatever, we, whatever how many permits boats we have, we can now divvy it up and say, well, 17 week season and you each get eight nights, you can stay there, right?
[1:14:16] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm wondering if it was a problem.
[1:14:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, right now it's not, but thanks for bringing it up because it could become a problem.
[1:14:23] Speaker J (unidentified): Do we have boats that just, I mean, some of these fishing boats just keep their boats there whether they're fishing or not?
[1:14:31] Speaker D (unidentified): The answer is yes.
[1:14:34] Speaker J (unidentified): So is a permit fee appropriate really for the overnight dockage that they're getting, or full-time day dockage?
[1:14:45] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, again, they don't have that dockage. It can be revoked at any moment. But no one else is asking for it, so I haven't said don't put your boat there.
[1:14:53] Chair: So I'd say there'd be an issue if so-and-so is leaving their boat there all the time, somebody else isn't able to use the spot.
[1:14:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Again, if one of the other six permanent holders comes to me and said, I want to put my boat there, then I can go to the person that has and say, you've already used up your time, and so now you'd better share this.
[1:15:11] Chair: But as of right now no one has, so there's no system because there hasn't been an issue, hasn't
[1:15:16] Speaker D (unidentified): been an issue. But I can have one ready in case there does. I mean, in my head I already have an idea of like, you're only allowed so many nights at the dock, and I'm gonna, I'll tally it up and you've already had your nine nights, so go back to where you belong. How we do it at the day sailor
[1:15:31] Chair: dock is, you know, there's only two spots and there's, well for sure six, seven of us, you know, they're, if we, if we know we need it for a specific reason, we would communicate with the other day sailors, so that could be something that we provide all the fishermen with, other fishermen I mean, I'm sure they have it, but other fishermen's information in case they need to communicate. If that communication isn't polite, then we would get involved personally, but that's
[1:15:57] Speaker B (unidentified): how we do it on the day sailor dock yeah peter but when but steven why not just write that in to the ordinance before you have an issue you just said you got 17 weeks you got eight nights just why not just be proactive instead of waiting for somebody to complain just make it so you trade that rotational opening because it's fair that's just my yeah
[1:16:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I think we're, we're back to the point that I try to make, is that it's the difference between policy and ordinance. It's a very clear distinction. And as it stands right now, it's that the policy is established by the harbor master, which I think is entirely appropriate, given that he's the guy that understands what's going on down there and can make a fair judgment as to the allocation of the use.
[1:16:54] Chair: Yeah. I wouldn't want to say, okay, you can only use it for eight nights out of the season because it's fair, and then have it be empty the rest of the time just because we put it in the ordinance, I think.
[1:17:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Steve's recommendations, this sentence is fine the way it is. I'm a little confused on we're adding a number three commercial marine business, and so where is one and two? It's, so this is the priority list. Yeah, number one is, number one is commercial full-time fishermen, yeah, you know.
[1:17:31] Chair: I think in the actual ordinance, I thought it copied and pasted correctly, but it looks like it didn't, so okay. Yeah, so commercial full-time fishermen is number one, and then there's a, b, and c underneath that. A, b, current permit holders is a, so commercial full-time fishermen is priority. Under that you have, you look at the current permit holders first, then Camden residents.
[1:17:56] Speaker I (unidentified): Then Camden non-residents, so at each annual renewal, current permit holders are given priority.
[1:18:03] Chair: of commercial full-time fishermen correct and then number two is commercial part-time and then we have abc as well so a non-resident full-time fisherman is going to have priority over any
[1:18:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Part-time fishermen. Okay, well I think the only stumbling block here is that if you follow this in a strict like chain of occupancy or priority, non-residents.
[1:18:36] Speaker I (unidentified): Are above commercial marine businesses, right, because it has to, its current.
[1:18:42] Chair: Priority is commercial fishermen, right, so it, we're adding this because that's what's, what's happening and we think it's appropriate, but I think like under federal regulations we have to provide that space for commercial fishermen, correct, resident or non-resident.
[1:19:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, okay, so we're seeing that as these non-residents are in fact commercial fishermen.
[1:19:09] Chair: Or commercial part-time fishing, every single one of the applicants has to have a commercial fishing license. We're saying you could not have a commercial fishing license and have a commercial marine business, but you're going to be on the bottom of the totem pole. And that's not, and we're kind of thinking that's probably not going to be a huge issue because there's a little overlap in those people and unless there's a space issue. Correct. Okay.
[1:19:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. Yep. I don't see, I just wanted to get that, get that out and have it clarified so that the commercial marine business is the third on the list.
[1:19:49] Chair: I guess. Yeah. Is that how it's supposed to be? Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
[1:19:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, what's supposed to be is what we're adding this. I mean, prior to this, there was no consideration of it as a marine-oriented business.
[1:20:07] Chair: And they were applying under their commercial fishing licenses. So we're clarifying.
[1:20:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, yeah, it just so happens that the two gentlemen that do the marine, actually both, Toby is a fisherman and he does a big share of the inspections. And the two of our marines are both commercial fishermen and they do another share of the moorings.
[1:20:29] Chair: Right. So say we have somebody else comes from who knows where coming in and say, I have a marine business. They're not going to get over Toby who has both of these things.
[1:20:38] Speaker A (unidentified): That kind of, yeah, right, so there was a third company that wanted to come along and do mooring inspections, they could apply commercial fishermen but they could consideration at the bottom of the
[1:20:49] Speaker D (unidentified): list. Exactly. Yeah, so
[1:20:54] Chair: I think, well, the other part of this, let me just, yeah, go ahead Ron.
[1:20:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I think it's a good suggestion that we're limiting the number of floats that are considered fishermen floats, whereas in the prior ordinance in the OS, the existing ordinance, there is no limit, it just says east of, it's very, yeah, very nondescript. Yeah, so your recommendation is limiting it to the fishermen's floats to the first eight float, the first
[1:21:23] Chair: day. Yeah, but that doesn't necessarily mean permits does it? No, that's just the use right.
[1:21:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. We're going to share the, they're going to share that space based on Steve's recommendation. And on the north side,
[1:21:37] Speaker D (unidentified): I mentioned you can put dinghies on the north side because it's shallow over there. So are
[1:21:46] Speaker A (unidentified): we in a position to start taking votes on our recommendations or are we going to put that off?
[1:21:55] Chair: We can. I mean, we can take a vote if we'd like to submit that this be considered for ordinance review for edits. I know there were other suggestions that people thought we should go, you know, you and Jeremy thought we should make sure we have all our suggestions first. Yeah, I would, I would personally, I think everything, I wouldn't go. Yeah, do we have any, you know, I just think that's gonna, we'll have to keep plugging away at it. If we get to the point where we have to submit this, then we should, if we don't get much
[1:22:30] Speaker A (unidentified): else, we could do a non-binding vote. I mean, what I'm concerned about is that we're going to go, we're going to set up a situation where we start having the same conversation over and over again on each of these individual items, when in fact we could maybe just say, okay, you know what, we all agreed that Steve's recommendations were a good addition, and just have that sort of
[1:22:50] Speaker I (unidentified): we're going to vote to add so. Well, I'm just saying, just so that we don't have to. Yeah.
[1:22:57] Chair: We can move on from the fisherman float conversation.
[1:22:59] Speaker D (unidentified): What Ron's saying is we come back next month. You could start and saying, well, just remember, we voted on this already. It's done.
[1:23:05] Chair: So I'm going to make a motion to add to our list to submit to the select board, amending the fisherman float to add commercial marine business as a number three AND SUBMITTING SOME SUGGESTIONS FOR VERBIAGE TO THE SELECT BOARD FOR ORDINANCE REVIEW. [Speaker J (unidentified): I SECOND.] DISCUSSION, YEP, RON.
[1:23:37] Speaker A (unidentified): I WOULD, UNLESS WE HAVE A REQUIRED, I MEAN, UNLESS SOMEBODY NEEDS TO HAVE MORE CONVERSATION ABOUT WHAT STEVE'S RECOMMENDATION IS, WHY CAN'T WE JUST ACCEPT STEVE'S RECOMMENDATION?
[1:23:50] Chair: well because we're i 'm not submitting this is what i want you to change it to
[1:23:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Right, Chris, so we're saying this. Well, you can, well, you can't, but also, I mean, you can also
[1:24:00] Speaker F (unidentified): simply i mean it's in the minutes that this discussion that you all came to some agreement on this one and so my i think steve's word words sound great you don't necessarily need a formal motion to you but in sort of you know in like two or three meetings when you've gone through a few other things and you can sort of say okay here's our based on look at the minutes here 's where we found common ground and then you let's just do a formal vote so i'm
[1:24:28] Chair: going to change my, I'm going to make a motion to accept Steve Pixley, Harbor Master's amendments for consideration to the select board for an ordinance change for 108-18, fishermen's floats, adding a number three in green on my document. I second.
[1:24:54] Speaker A (unidentified): So we're going to, you're not saying that this is a non-binding vote.
[1:25:01] Chair: I'm saying that we are going to submit this when we have all of our ordinance changes. This one has been talked about. We shouldn't have to visit it again. We're saying, I'm going to put on a little document that says, these are all the things we would like to let the select board know that we've talked about. This one is fishermen floats. Okay.
[1:25:21] Speaker A (unidentified): I guess I agree with Steve. I don't think we should do it piecemeal. I think we're not.
[1:25:26] Chair: I'm not gonna send it to the select board. Right.
[1:25:29] Speaker F (unidentified): You're just saying this motion is simply saying that one's done. We all agree.
[1:25:34] Chair: Yeah, I'm not gonna send this till we have everything. And then we're gonna have a bulleted points to the select board a memo that says, these are all of our changes.
[1:25:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So we're going to have a vote that we've had this conversation.
[1:25:46] Chair: We're going to vote on every single piece and then put it together.
[1:25:50] Speaker A (unidentified): We all agree that this one should be amended to Steve's recommendation.
[1:25:56] Chair: Yes. And that doesn't mean that the select board is going to copy and paste it into the ordinance. They might have to change some wording and whatnot.
[1:26:07] Speaker H (unidentified): So we have a motion.
[1:26:11] Chair: We have a motion, we have a second, any further discussion, all in favor of putting this on our conclusion concluded list, all right, we have a five zero, that's going on the list, great, I think that's important because no matter what we get done that one can be submitted, we can try to as much as we get done in time for them to be submitted, yes, not only that, it's a morale
[1:26:40] Speaker H (unidentified): ral booster, it gives us a sense of accomplishment, all right, so next time we have, I don't think
[1:26:49] Chair: we need to do an ordinance workshop now that we did something, so everything else, I mean, you know, everything else in the ordinance, it's kind of feels like much smaller changes, so let's go through, you know, we've already started going through them, we can try to figure out what is important that we feel we need to talk to the select board about, we're gonna finalize fees next time, that's gonna be the priority, and then we'll discuss ordinance if we have to, and memorial benches, we can hope to, we'll go over
[1:27:27] Speaker I (unidentified): there and hope to have some more answers, this probably should have gone in with my non-agenda
[1:27:33] Speaker A (unidentified): of comments because they signed it sort of fits but recently there was an extensive conversation at the select board regarding giving granting a 10-year lease to service providers out there the what is it the snow dogs and what was the other one side country so yeah so the current SELECT BOARD AS OPPOSED TO PREVIOUS ADMINISTRATIONS HAS CHOSEN TO EXTEND A AND IT WAS IT'S APPARENTLY NON-BINDING THE CONTRACT IS CAN BE BACKED OUT OF BY EITHER PARTY BUT AT LEAST IT SENDS THE SIGNAL THAT THE SELECT BOARD IS APPARENTLY WILLING TO MAKE A COMMITMENT TO A 10-YEAR
[1:28:30] Speaker I (unidentified): period for these so they don't have to redo it every year well the primary point is that if they
[1:28:38] Speaker A (unidentified): were if they want to make capital improvements they can go to the bank and say i have a 10-year agreement with the town here we pushed several years ago when we and i'm not sure how that It appears that there was, in fact, an ordinance change where it appears that there, as I can tell, that the ordinance says that we are granting three-year leases to windjammers and day sailors. I'm suggesting at this point that if we're willing to give a 10-year commitment, the town is willing to give a 10-year commitment to lease-eating.
[1:29:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Hot dog salesmen. Hot dog salesmen.
[1:29:24] Chair: You think we should be more than three?
[1:29:26] Speaker A (unidentified): why wouldn't we be willing to make a commitment to it's a good point windjammer owners yeah who have a significantly larger investment in their significantly larger capital investment and it's critical because we are at a point again where we need to decide whether we want windjammers in this harbor or don't we and we have six spaces that are designated as windjammer births but there's no guarantee that they stay as windjammer births in perpetuity they only exist because they only exist by definition i don't see any clear description in the ordinance that they are in fact designated as windjammer births that's one part of it the other part of it is that we are at a crossroads where one schooner is very actively for sale the price has been lowered where and we need to decide do we want that schooner to stay in camden or are we willing to let her go the way of so many other schooners either going to rockland which has happened to two schooners that used to sail out of camden and Two other schooners that left business, so we're we're we're facing a dwindling number of windjammers in the town of Camden. And unless I, my perspective is that unless we take some sort of proactive approach towards trying to help them remain here, then we'll lose the rest of them. And from the standpoint of the prospective buyer for one of the windjammers here in Camden, if they can't go to the bank and say I have a 10-year lease, or maybe it should be a 20-year lease, it's been granted to me by the town, the bank's not going to take that loan application seriously, because they're going to look at and say, what, you've only got a three-year three-year commitment from the select board that you can operate from
[1:31:43] Chair: that location, three, yeah, three years is pretty brief, and it's always, I mean, it can always be, if you if you do something wrong you're going to get it taken away anyway, it's brief if you're
[1:31:54] Speaker I (unidentified): applying for a 30-year commercial loan, right, is that something we can do in our ordinance
[1:32:00] Speaker J (unidentified): review to increase the lease time?
[1:32:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Well, I'm not sure how that happened, but we did succeed from increasing the lease time from one year
[1:32:12] Speaker D (unidentified): to three years. That was five years ago? Six years ago?
[1:32:16] Speaker A (unidentified): It was recent. But up until six years ago, whatever it was, all of the schooners only had a guarantee of one year at a time. So we made some movement in what I consider to be a good proactive direction, but I think we're at a turning point in the town of Camden where we run serious risk at losing the rest of the schooners that we still have if we don't make some sort of really dramatic effort to encourage them to stay here in the town of Camden. And I think the most affirmative way that we can do that is to extend the lease period, and it should be, and if as I say the select board is willing to grant a 10-year period to a snow dogs and whatever I forget the name of the other side country, then we should be willing, we need to be willing to make a commitment. No, it's a good point. To the windjammers and the day savers.
[1:33:19] Chair: That's in an ordinance somewhere with the...
[1:33:22] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah, it's in... It's 10819B. It says... 10819B. It says, the select board may elect to permit the use of these slips by windjammers by a lease or written rental agreement for a term not to exceed three years.
[1:33:38] Chair: So, Ron, I can put that on...
[1:33:40] Speaker A (unidentified): That's in the ordinance.
[1:33:44] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, it says in the ordinance not to exceed three years.
[1:33:46] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, we can change that. Well, we could, we could advise them to probably, I think, I think, I think Ron already has us to agree with that, so I think we should bring it up next time. Yeah, does a 10
[1:33:57] Speaker E (unidentified): year lease mean that we're committing the rental fee stay the same for 10 years? No, because
[1:34:05] Speaker F (unidentified): you can have something that says it goes up one percent a year, or I mean that's whatever, every three years. I would just, I would just make, I would just make the
[1:34:30] Speaker A (unidentified): recommendation that we take it a step further than they did with the agreements at the Snowball, that they be binding, that the agreement that was made regarding the Snowball leases is non-binding. That was my, that's what I took away from the select board meeting. What do you mean by binding? Well, that the contract could be reneged on by
[1:34:54] Speaker I (unidentified): either party, that it was not a binding contract. Well, I would say it's right now if a day, what
[1:35:02] Chair: you know, I know about the day, so if a day sailor is non-compliant with something, well, that's a
[1:35:07] Speaker F (unidentified): different, that's a different thing. Yeah, this was, they are compliant. You mean that I, that then when I, when it's renewed, or that they can walk away in year six?
[1:35:18] Speaker A (unidentified): no it as i understood it the way it was described at the select board meeting was that it was a non-binding contract that either the town or the lease soar could walk out of the contract with no well there's cause i mean there 's
[1:35:40] Speaker F (unidentified): there has to be cause. I think my reading of that leaves their head like it can't be terminated for no reason. Okay, well, the Windjam releases issued to a vote or an owner. Well, that's
[1:35:54] Speaker A (unidentified): another part of the conversation that needs to be had, because it should be transferable to the owner.
[1:36:01] Chair: Well, it's kind of both. But when Lazy Jack got sold, it was a conversation. You can't just, my understanding was Gus couldn't just walk on without coming to select for it.
[1:36:14] Speaker D (unidentified): It's to the vessel. And obviously, if any owner comes in, they have to then they have to reapply as a yes. Combined kind of just like if someone wanted to change boats, they'd have to say, OK, this is, this leases for this boat. Oh, so I think it's for both, really. If the owner changes, you've got to go for it. I think it's both.
[1:36:32] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that if a schooner were to sell and that schooner was already entered into a contract, a 20-year contract with the town, that contract should be transferable.
[1:36:45] Chair: Yes. But the person needs to be.
[1:36:47] Speaker A (unidentified): But then the person, the new owner, would need to reapply and put his name on that contract. Track, but I think it's so, what I, what I think is important is that the town make a commitment to preserving the schooners that are, that are here and do whatever we can to attract other schooners to come in and occupy the empty windjammer spaces that we have, because there's a stands right now. I think we have two empty windjammer spaces. I mean, we'll get two, but remember there was this
[1:37:21] Speaker D (unidentified): The same owner owned both boats, though it be.
[1:37:23] Speaker F (unidentified): You've got to include some non-compete clauses in sail agreements there.
[1:37:29] Speaker A (unidentified): But if you go back far enough, you'll understand that the green boats, yes, there were three vessels that were owned by one person. Prior to that, there were three separate schooners in that space that were owned by three different individuals. So it can work. That's when those spaces were established. List, yes, yeah, we had to, we had to walk over. Stephen Taber was on the inside, Adventure was in the middle, Mary Day was on the outside, so there's a bit of coordination there it is
[1:38:01] Speaker F (unidentified): Interesting though to Ron's point, like the language about leases does not specify a lease to an individual or a boat.
[1:38:17] Speaker J (unidentified): So we'll need to look at that at the next meeting.
[1:38:21] Speaker F (unidentified): Adjacent Harbor Park and windjammer berthing slips by lease shall be used only for sailing vessel which are not operated as day sailor. Select board may elect to permit the use of these slips by windjammers by a lease or written rental agreement for a term not to exceed three years. In the event that the berthing slip is not being used by the vessel to which the slip has been leased is the only phrase that says the vessel, but that's the only phrase that gives indication, but it does give indication of leaning towards the vessel. Yeah, you immediately move into like Lawyerville. Yeah, you know, they take over. It doesn't, but it currently doesn't. Yeah, it currently does not specify either the owner or the boat, so it's sort of a, yeah, that's in the negotiation of
[1:39:09] Chair: The lease itself, which would be hairy if you have the vessel approved and the person buying the vessel thinks that, yeah, that's the only thing that we get. Okay, anybody have anything else
[1:39:20] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, I got a quick one, two quick things, Liz. Yeah, just in our next meeting, under action items, can we make Steve Gold had a proposed harbor income and expense report, can we make sure we get add that to the agenda? Also, Jeremy was going to provide us this could be at the end to updated public at the updated public access survey for us to review. I just don't want them
[1:39:49] Chair: to drop off. Good point, good point. Down, I do want to get the fees done first next time, but
[1:39:55] Speaker J (unidentified): yeah, those are, but just to make sure it happens and
[1:40:03] Speaker C (unidentified): Steve, yeah, have we discussed chapter
[1:40:07] Chair: four or is that we will today? We finished the fisherman floats. Chapter four will be in the future. We're going to adjourn for today, but that we all have your edits now, which were a good starting point. I think I made a few notes on my ordinance. I will email you a copy of
[1:40:29] Speaker C (unidentified): THAT FINANCIAL ANALYSIS. OKAY. AND YOU CAN EMAIL IT AROUND. OKAY.
[1:40:40] Chair: ANYBODY ELSE? NO. MEETING ADJOURNED.