← Back to MaineScanner

York Zoning Board Denies Administrative Appeal for 5 Stella Lane Property

2026-10-28 · 1h 53m · Source: Appeals Board 10/28/2026 (Town of York (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[6:58] Speaker A (unidentified): to order tonight this is the october 28th 2026 meeting of the york board of appeals tonight in attendance we have most of our members but i'll go through them just so we have we do have a quorum tonight normally there's eight members of there are eight members on the appeals board only five of them are regular members so the regular members on my on my left ken churchill and then on my right mitch picard matt lovo and michelle marion myself Paul Selleckane chair tonight one of our members is feels compelled to recuse themselves that's Matt Lovo so in his place I'm going to name Bruce Landay on the end there as a member tonight so that'll make the five members of our board, five voting members. Tonight we have approval of minutes, actually of our October 14th meeting. And then we have a matter, Tom Hedger, for Stella Lane requests administrative appeal, response to code opinions from September 21st, 2026. six the property in question is five stella lane cape netic maine map five lot 14 s so beginning here tonight i 'm going to start with some minutes that we actually had in our last meeting if i can pass those down so bruce needs one here one for Ken okay so these were these minutes I get everybody these minutes were actually on our agenda for the last meeting and that was a matter administrative appeal having to do with are brought by Michael Kazuk for 49 nine main street requested administrative appeal failure to deny permit due to character based codes cd4 encroachments storm drain runoff and sewage public safety and no off-street parking the property in question was is 51 main street york main map 23 lot 120. so this board members was part of our package for that meeting I inadvertently did not have us discuss and review and vote on it so we'll do it now maybe I'll give you a minute to review those or okay [Speaker B (unidentified): we] have we have just to amend the street name anything else findings yes we reviewed the minutes in the last meeting can anything no so I'll entertain a motion to accept these findings of fact that's a Bruce I'm sorry you're making a motion made the motion and can I have a second i was here at that meeting so yes i second that okay we have okay so then i'll take a roll call ken yes bruce mitch yes and yes for michelle i think that's more than five zero because matt voted yeah because i was it says i was in attendance so bruce shouldn't have voted [12:48] Speaker B (unidentified): on this then I would yeah okay I don't vote on this I only vote on the matter [12:55] Speaker A (unidentified): tonight so then we have a 5-0 these findings of fact for Michael Cusack is accepted okay our other minutes from the last meeting which we are reviewing tonight there are anybody have any edits for it I do but I'll well [Speaker B (unidentified): I don't have] the line numbers on my copy but for starters Robert LaSalle's was present at the meeting so I would make no more absent so yeah so you were present so we'll correct that and add him to the people that were present and I have a correction of Matt's the spelling of Matt's name then further down on the so number four, approval of findings of fact, just the spelling of the applicant's name was an extra E. Further down, let me see. I didn't have any other corrections. Does anybody else have corrections for that? Mr. [14:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Chair, did you correct the address on that one in the mapping lot? Remember, and the agenda was wrong. I just want to make sure you got the right [14:38] Speaker A (unidentified): 40 Eureka And 14 garrison point I think yeah So no anything else Yes, [14:50] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah, so I had lots of comments can you I Just felt there was a general problem that you know they failed to indicate who was saying what? what statements were made that seemed to be like objective findings of fact, when it was actually one party arguing a particular position over the, you know. Okay. And so none of that was reflected. [15:13] Speaker A (unidentified): So, well, wait, that's good. This is a new recording secretary, so her style maybe is different, and if we need to review that, maybe could you cite an example? [15:30] Speaker B (unidentified): at the moment I can't they're all in the email that I sent you but basically you know there was savings like such-and-such a thing is true and it was actually I recall one of the parties saying that so it didn't reflect who is saying what didn't include the board members votes on particular factors in you know the criteria for offer for the variants for example right that was on [15:59] Speaker A (unidentified): on the second one, the garrison point. [16:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, there was no one specific thing where if you fixed it, I would've felt like, oh. [16:08] Speaker A (unidentified): So what do you suggest maybe for the? [16:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Sharing the feedback with the stenographer and seeing if they can be improved. Okay. That was, but I'm not voting on this, so that was my one [16:26] Speaker D (unidentified): note I have. I'm not voting on it as well, but on line 51, which is where it's talking about in 1997, Crystal Turner obtained a variance for the original house from the Shoreline Wetland Permit Review Committee. It was actually obtained a variance, comma, for the original house as recommended by the Shoreline Wetland Committee. Obviously, the variance was granted by the Board of Appeals. can't shoreline wetland committees can't give variances oh i see so let's see what should that [17:04] Speaker A (unidentified): say then obtained a variance from the board of appeals well you could salting from an approval [17:11] Speaker D (unidentified): of the right that would be fine for [17:27] Speaker A (unidentified): the original so she obtained a variance comma from the board of appeals comma for the original house for the original house as recommended by the review [17:41] Speaker D (unidentified): committee they're they're an advisory committee that they would be advising right so they [17:49] Speaker A (unidentified): ended up they reviewed the background and then suggested to the board of appeals to approve Right. Right. Okay. I made that note. Okay. Any other changes? The point well taken, Bruce, and I'll have a conversation with the recording secretary about that. So then I would entertain a motion to accept these minutes for October 14th as amended. [18:23] Speaker E (unidentified): I'd make a motion that we accept the minutes as amended. [18:26] Speaker A (unidentified): so mitch is making a motion to accept the minutes do i have a second ken seconds that and then i would have a vote ken yes [18:41] Speaker B (unidentified): not you bruce is he refused for the whole night then i vote no vote no okay and michelle [18:55] Speaker A (unidentified): are they acceptable as is based on the discussion well we can rewrite them and bring them back we don't have to accept them tonight then if people are feeling strongly about it 's a new secretary so we can there [19:20] Speaker F (unidentified): should be attributions for major points then i think we shouldn't accept it and just edit it to give some attributions [19:32] Speaker A (unidentified): okay so then we're gonna have to come back for that yeah okay if i get a word document i'm happy to give it a go and okay well we can work with her on it and you can make suggestions all right [19:47] Speaker F (unidentified): could look at the transcript i mean we also have the transcript yes we do right yeah okay [19:53] Speaker A (unidentified): well these don't have to be accepted tonight necessarily we can move it on and bring it back in our next meeting so we're going to table it table it for now unfortunately the next meeting is until december 9th but that's that's just going to be the way it is so we'll we'll table it for tonight and move on okay so as I mentioned on our agenda tonight we have just one matter I'll read it again it's Tom Hedger for Stella Lane requests an administrative appeal response to code opinions from 9 21 26 property in question five stella lane cape netic maine map 5 lot 14s and just for the record we had this board reviewed a administrative appeal four years ago on this property so right around this time of year. So the board has a complete package from the appellant. We need to decide before we begin discussing this matter two points. Is the appeal timely? And then does the appellant have standing so as far as timeliness the appellant has cited an email message from september 21st 2026 so in that case the matter as it stands is timely the appellant has brought the matter in a timely way it's within the 30 days required question in my mind and for the board is does the appellant have standing that's right the email came in came in later did it wasn't in the package that was sent today I have the email here well since the board hasn't received it I'll I will read it so it 's dated so september 21st it's from harry norton to tom hedger and carol dini carol and tom i wanted to address you both regarding five stella lane and what you both believe is a zoning violation also i have prepared a full assessment of the property which you may or may not already be aware of i am attaching it here for your convenience to be to maybe alleviate your other concerns regarding the concern about the setback i have spoken to town council the 200 foot frontage requirement to the building the principal building is being met at 5 Stella Lane. I believe the point of confusion may be that the 200 foot requirement does not establish the building envelope, rather it is an exception that applies if the applicant can demonstrate that the lot can accommodate the required 200 foot frontage. Further, the lot itself remains subject to the 50 foot front setback and the 30 foot side and rear setbacks required by the applicable zoning I hope this helps clarify the issue and then he goes on to talk about that the email came in on a Sunday and he didn't reply until the next day so that 's the message so what is the board's position can I [24:48] Speaker E (unidentified): just ask a question I'm just does it need to tie back to the permit date [24:53] Speaker G (unidentified): instead of an email date my [24:58] Speaker E (unidentified): question I mean we always talked about within a [25:01] Speaker A (unidentified): permit date not necessarily well the application that the procedure the application doesn't indicate anything else but the date of the email of this message this email message there are I mean he appeals from an action of the [25:25] Speaker B (unidentified): code enforcement the email could be an action I was just concerned about I wanted to make sure like you know did the email just recap what was already stated in august in the letter and i think it does something new i think i think it's therefore the appeal is timely [25:44] Speaker A (unidentified): you think it's timely i think it's timely yeah oh yeah timely but the i so if we're agreement agree about timeliness can you good with that everyone is yeah The question then remains, does the appellant have standing? In this case, he's an abutter, and so then he would have standing to bring an appeal. So we can move forward, and we'll have the appellant come up and speak to us about his appeal. Do [26:33] Speaker H (unidentified): you guys mind if I set this up? [26:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Make it a little bit clearer. [26:37] Speaker A (unidentified): kind of go through things maybe put it over here unless you need to refer to it from [26:45] Speaker H (unidentified): I will ask you to reference a few pictures inside of the packet but I don't think you're gonna it's gonna be necessary to go through whatever it is 85 pages of it or something so [27:13] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah okay before you start when you start please just introduce [27:17] Speaker H (unidentified): yourself again please i sure will let me put this up and i'll i'll do it okay my name is tom hedger live at forestella lane and i'm the one that made the appeal so you know i think i'm gonna i think we should be able to get through this pretty quickly but that's just my opinion they say a picture is worth a thousand words hopefully i don't need that many i just wanted to be clear when we go through tonight code has mentioned my use of maine statutes and one of the reasons our used maine statutes are the rules that were applied as it as it applies to the wetland setbacks and the wetland setbacks are under the natural resource protection act which has been mandated to the state and has been codified and then sent down to the town so the town has to meet those minimum standards you guys probably already know that you already realize what the wetland setbacks are and the requirements are so i did use the main statutes there because those are the minimum standards you know and i think it's pretty clear if we take a look at this is actually mr ribera's survey okay this was done by civil consultants and wetland setbacks were actually identified by a soil scientist so we can see here clear winterfoot wetland setback west side and of course down below it shows the 200 foot width mark necessary for a home on a cul-de-sac but that's represented fairly clear here all the sketching that's done inside i think for the so this was from his survey it's in your packet the entire survey but i blew it up so we can get a better look at it so according to civil consultants the survey or certified surveyors that came in here these are the setbacks there's a second survey inside of your packet as well and that was done by anderson livingston anderson livingston had the exact same fine wetland setback and those setbacks again the wetland setbacks were established by now this is a more frequent or maybe a more current picture what's missing from this build site here is actually the roof and i took the data points of the measurements from the survey and kind of superimposed them here i'm sorry it wasn't in autocad or solid works or anything like that but it's pretty damn excuse me it's pretty darn close to this entire bill's envelope being superimposed on here so we know a few feet this entire area here is inside of the weapons this entire area here I highlighted this area because I'm going to refer to a junkyard that was that was actually put in place in 2023 so that's not wetland setback but it was the area where a junkyard was so i think it's pretty clear right here that you can see there's been a lot of activity in those setbacks now i'm going to ask you if you can a moment here this is in your booklets the 2018 picture kind of shows you it's fully coerced so that's this lot right here next picture b2 and that one's interesting so if you look closely at the 2022 picture the lot was cleared you'll notice that it's been pretty heavily cleared granted this is a picture probably from the winter it's been pretty heavily cleared into the wetland setbacks and what's really easy to notice is up in the northeast corner there you see an entire parking area that was cleared and filled with gravel Now, the parking area, as of August, it's still there. It's still filled with gravel, and it's still in the way to accept that. One of the other points, and we'll refer to it a little bit later, and I circled it, and it might be a mystery to you, is the foundation that's in that build site. It just goes more to a pattern. This entire foundation was installed, obviously, sometime between 2021 and 2022. And when I searched the archives for permits, there was no permit. It kind of goes through a pattern. We know the wetland area has been cleared. We know that a foundation has been put in and cleared. We know that the wetlands have been filled and to this day have not been restored and are actually being used as a parking area. So that's all being used right here for parking. And that's been, you know, that's been part of the complaint is that those wetland setback areas have been cleared. When you look at this, I don't think it's gonna take a lot to really understand that certified land surveyor, certified soil scientist, underfoot wetland setback, underfoot wetland setback, parking area cleared, wetland setback area, and you can see there's a lot of buildup in here. And when we get on to the discussions with Junkyard, you're gonna continue, you're also going to see the activity that's going on behind here and i want to make note because as i go through this there's this entire area has been our point of contention all constantly because we own this abutting property right here and since all of the screen has been removed it looks like this has been used as a staging area and a storage area for timber gum garbage and so aside from the entire wetland area not the entire but a big portion of the wetland area being cleared it's also being used as a staging area for materials waste gum things like that so like I mentioned this picture is worth a thousand words I think this picture as well as an additional survey in there from Anderson Livingston both really respected, certified land surveyors, kind of make it pretty clear, okay. Now this isn't me, this is Mr. Brouwer's home. So that's what we get into when we start talking about the clearing of the wetland. I'm going to jump around a little bit. I'm going to move on to the, so that, yeah, let me be clear. So there's basically four points of contention here. Clearing up the wetlands, jump yard, building a structural addition to a previously permitted home in the area, and an erosion control issue as well. So I think that display up there, I think it's really obvious that there's been a lot of clearing in the wetlands. The next item I want to go on to, if it's okay, is the covered porch. And I took some recent pictures, too. For all you guys, that's all right. [35:54] Speaker A (unidentified): We can share one. [35:55] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I've got a bunch of them here, but I didn't know how many more to make. Do you want to pass them along? Sure. Sure. So this covered porch looks like it kind of began around maybe sometime before August 8th. If you want to go through and look at the picture that Code had previously, you can actually see sonitudes that have been installed for this covered porch. So that's what's there right now. So we called. We said, hey, wait. This is his permitted home that he's building. building, how is he allowed to build, and it's not a deck, it's actually a fully covered porch, as you can see in that picture. How is he allowed to build that? And we were encouraged because the first response we got, let me back up a second. So this setback here is in the code, and I think you have a copy of it. It basically says anything on a cul-de-sac act can have no less than 50 feet street front circumference of the cul-de-sac provided the lock width at the location where the principal building is to be constructed is at least equal to the distance normally required for street or for lock frontage in that zoning district pretty easy way to look at in other words the home has to be built beyond or in back In fact, our survey by Kindle Survey says the exact same thing. A neighbor's house, Grease Deli, same exact thing. Their survey by Moody, the house has to be built. Civil Consultants, same thing. Building Envelope, front setback, 200 feet. And that's the same thing from four independent surveys that say the exact same thing, and they're consistent with the front setback, which we have a lot with, is 200 feet. includes the front porch, because our front porch is in the same mark on the 2M beach, so is the D&E's at 3 Stella. I think that's really, clear. So we became concerned that the deck was being constructed. So we cited, I think, a phone call, and they got a response, and I guess it was a verbal discussion that Cove would have with the above. I paraphrased the response. When the permit was written, the porch was missed. It's been over 30 days. I cannot rescind it, but what I can do is read it. It's a 3-foot-old bounce ride. It's not like it's being used for later. Your instruction starts up again. This was resolved. Reach out to code. Code then came back with what you read in the email. Regarding the concern about the setback at Stoke-on-Wood Town Council, the 200-foot frontage requirements of the principal buildings being met at 5-7-0 Lane, the lease not established building envelope, whether it's an exception that applies, if the applicant can demonstrate that the lock and accommodation are ultimately subject to the 50-foot front, side rear setback required by you know in neither I think code had some more time to look at it and the most recent response seems to acknowledge the front setback requirements for homes on the cul-de-sac and res too so they seem to acknowledge that but while the primary step structure is within the front step backs there's a large structural addition beyond the front i don't believe it's permanent and certainly to extend beyond a setback would require a variance i mean that's what you guys do right I saw you a couple months ago, and it was really, I just have to say that it was really impressive. There was a gentleman here looking for a setback on a deck from Norwood Farms. And I was watching, I was like, this is really fascinating, because it was kind of how I thought, hey, this is how it should work. You presented it, there was no other alternative. You guys, you know, you grilled them, everything went through there. And, you know, eventually it was granted because it looked like there was no other opportunity to realize somebody has been allowed to build a relatively large structure in addition to his home. I mean, there's a lot of people that have applied for variances and permits and everything else. [41:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, we'll address that. Excuse me. We'll address that. Code is going to follow you, and then they're going to present. then so once if you have more you can continue we'll we'll address that with the code when okay yeah that's all I ask yeah so [42:17] Speaker H (unidentified): we've covered the clearing of the wetlands covered the regarding, if that stays on there, a small piece, the junkyard. [Speaker I (unidentified): So when] it comes to the discussion of the junkyard, I know there was another reference made to my citing these statutes. So I contacted our attorney and wanted to discuss what definition applies, local zoning of the state, and this was his response. [43:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Who's speaking here? Who's speaking? Who is that? Oh, that was Mayor Powell. Matt Powell. Yeah. [43:35] Speaker H (unidentified): He said Maine uses statutory preemption in certain land use areas under Title 38-4352 municipal zoning ordinances, and they must be consistent with this chapter and cannot impose requirements that conclude with the state law. This means that if a local ordinance's definition or rule contradicts a state-defined standard, state definition of control. In Maine, the state's definition of a junkyard is Title 38. 3752 is the authoritative definition for state-regulated junkyard matters and it overrides the town definition in those contexts. Townsmen still have their own definitions for local purposes, but they cannot override the state statutory definition when state law applies. So based on statutory preemption, the code is required to rely on state and Maine definitions. So there was an investigation done at the property on August 8th, which I really do appreciate because it was detailed and I really appreciate the response. But it seems to have missed a rather large area. I think if you remember, I was discussing the area to the left of those green storage tents and the shipping container and the storage shed. If you look at the bottom poster to the left of that, what's to the left of that are those two pictures up there. One of them is dated August 10th, which is two days after the investigation. There's not a single picture in the investigation that reflects that. it's discarded lumber it's discarded scrap it's storage it's also in the wetland setback that wasn't included and i'm sorry it got missed it's kind of hidden behind that and the reason we see it is that's the part that abuts our property that's the part we've been really concerned about so that was august 10th and just to update on august or october 3rd i wanted to show that there's been a fair amount of activity back there you know bulldozing moving dirt moving things around so the activity is still ongoing in that area so to me and according to the definition that looks like a junkyard and one of the things i wanted to refer back to is if you look in your pamphlet there's a picture of quite a bit of garbage here a lot and that was in 2023. i got they became very alarmed by that now you'll have to understand i have a little bit of a trigger mechanism when it comes to hazardous waste i used to own an industrial property out in the state of washington i had a small neighbor next door that was a plating operation and they spilled a minor amount of chemicals those chemicals permeated the ground drifted underneath my property and when i went to sell that property they did a soil sample and found that we don't use those chemicals didn't matter i was on the hook for drilling monitoring wells as well as remediation for half a million dollars just to clean that up and it only took of parts per billion in some cases so some of the containers that you see in that picture and i don't know how many are there they're basically it's a solvent-based petroleum-based roofing contact material or roofing or foundation material it's heavily filled but its carriers are stoddard solvents and benzene those are really nasty chemicals they don't biodegrade readily they percolate and they will work their way down whether or not any got in there i don't know but it's irresponsible look anybody in middle school will tell you that 's [Speaker E (unidentified): wrong you] know and it's it's it's disappointing so when I continue to see the activity yes I do have a little bit of a trigger warning I get a little bit worried about it because beyond that area the slope is unbelievable it just right down into the wetlands and right back into the rush swamp and into my property so I'm concerned about that I think it I think I have a reasonably good reason to be concerned about that and I'm also concerned and I'll just I'm just about finished there's a big one of his tents I guess still has I don't know if it does or not there's a number of five gallon pails in there so it goes kind of to the same concern I don't know what's in them I don't think anybody can know what's in them unless you took a sample I mean even an SDS probably wouldn't tell us what's actually in there but it I was I guess it was referred to that these are common household items that's a lot of common whole household items and they're right next they're in next to the wetlands and frankly if you're going to store that amount of chemicals i don't know if you should be doing it in res too but if you're going to store that there ought to be spill retention there should be a berm there should be a cofferdam you know i'd like to see what those are at least preferably i wouldn't see them on the property but at least some spill retention would be nice to have in that area so finally the last thing i get to is the berm control i was just concerned because throughout the construction of the area there hasn't been sedimentation and berm control which is required in the 2022 picture that we talked about before you can see that a berm is there a berm is there that's great but if you look to the picture on the top right on the board that's where the berm was it's not there anymore so erosion and sedimentation control isn't in place which would kind of be nice with what's been happening in the past and potentially some of the chemicals that might be sitting there so i'll finish up with one last thing how extending to abutting properties. We own the significant vernal pool. We have to take care of it. We're the stewards for it. We've looked after it. I was notified by the DEP, I think it was probably June, that hey, you need to take care of this because it extends into the other property. [50:22] Speaker A (unidentified): So are you talking about a vernal pool on your property or on this property? [50:27] Speaker H (unidentified): It's on my property, but the new rules about significant vernal pools was passed in may 17 2026 now extend into abutting properties so the 250 foot mark from the high water mark of the vernal pool extends into the abutting property and there's a 100 foot section where you can't even touch it so if you look at that you'll see off of the york main gis map kind of green grid area there is the 200 approximately the 200 foot mark from the 250 foot high water mark so it's enclosed in there and then i took the survey and just using some data points and the scale was able to kind of sketch that out and you can see that from the soil scientist high water marks the 200 we have this in our in our package here No,. Actually, it was what Liz sent out, that last picture. [51:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Would you just come over and demonstrate where that is? Yeah, absolutely. What you're talking about? [51:38] Speaker H (unidentified): So, significant borough pools have a lot of... [51:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Is that crosshatch area? Yes, right here. Okay. [51:45] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay. We own this property, and we own this one, and this is an approximation of the... [51:52] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah,, that's it. Yeah. [51:55] Speaker H (unidentified): And when I was notified by it, I was going through the rules, and, you know, we've done everything we can. In fact, we haven't touched this one. There's a small pathway where we had to build permission DEP. They said, you don't really need that, but we're glad you asked. So we have a little pathway that can go through there. It's actually a very pretty area. But because this is a semi approximation, I used the survey which reflects the soil scientist high watermarks on my vernal pool. And from the high watermark 0.1 and 0.2, you just extend that out. you can see a great deal the area is now under the covered by the regulatory requirements from the dep in the nr it's like a wetland setback yeah so i've contacted the dep i've reached out to them i said look with the new rules our properties surrounding properties would you mind coming out let's do a site visit let's see where we're at let's see where we're at here everywhere and see what rules work but i know it's a really heavy regulated requirement there so i've asked them to come out so we all understand what we need to abide by the rules and regulations and this just developed [53:17] Speaker D (unidentified): do you know if that's going to make a lot of your lot not buildable yeah [53:24] Speaker J (unidentified): and you have a designated group to oversee the vernal pools no we do that ourselves [53:30] Speaker H (unidentified): But we had, on our other lot here, we had extensive discussions regarding soil retention, erosion, sedimentation drift, and we, abiding by their mitigation advice, we put in a kind of a natural block, wall, because it's a really steep slope and it goes down to that area. so i mean i know what the rules are they've sent them to me but i thought it's better to have somebody from ddp come out so with the with the recent advent of what's happening here so we so we know where we're at you know for mr rivera's sake for our sake for everybody's sake you know just let's just get it out there and going forward now that he knows i know I know, let's be good stewards, we take care of this. And I'm sorry I couldn't get that to you, sir. [54:26] Speaker A (unidentified): I apologize. So that's fine, yeah. Are you finished with your presentation? Yeah, that's where I'm at. [54:31] Speaker H (unidentified): You know, just to be fair, I've only talked about a few. [54:34] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll have you back if we have questions. What's that? We can have you back to the podium. Sure,. So we're gonna hear from Code right now. [54:41] Speaker H (unidentified): You can leave those. I think Code has been great. I think Code has been more than fair. yeah we think they're good too thank you [55:00] Speaker A (unidentified): hi yes [55:13] Speaker C (unidentified): good evening mr. chair and members of the Board of Appeals I'm Harry Norton the director of code enforcement and this is Greg McGlashan he's my assistant code enforcement officer I would like to say thank you to mr. Hedger I have spoken with multiple DEP members about this property and I did receive an email this morning from Derek sorry that's Derek's the other DEP member he disclaimed the junkyard conversation but Robert Dinerge he's our DEP representative and he said that the vernal pool rules were in place differently when the building went up obviously because the new rules went into place in May and there's no new impact to the vernal pool. So there's no issue with what is currently going on because it's already been an envelope since 2022. It looks exactly almost identical. In fact, the trees have kind of grown around it a little more and they just planted an amazing amount of trees. I think you see those in my pictures in my response. [56:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Can I just stop you for a sec? So, cause we have so much information in these packages. is how maybe it would help to start with the august 6th i think it was a memo wasn't really [56:26] Speaker C (unidentified): a decision i assume so i was well i was going to start with that but i also felt and greg and i have talked about this multiple times because i you know he actually has a great opposing opinion which is why i like him so much we were thinking like i did i agree it's not a decision but did you want to discuss it to make everyone feel better is what i wanted to know because [56:46] Speaker A (unidentified): we'll come to the vernal pool that was the last part of his yeah i know but i guess my question [56:50] Speaker C (unidentified): is are you referring to the fact that my write-up wasn't exactly a decision it was just addressing [56:55] Speaker A (unidentified): the actually i'm trying to just trying to figure out here what decision was made well that's where i'm going maybe you could start by explaining whether or not there are any code violations on the property today in my opinion because i just did another drive-through on friday the 23rd and [57:12] Speaker C (unidentified): and I've sent all my pictures to DEP. They know what the property looks like, so I was getting a second confirmation, but I honestly do not feel like there's a problem here, but I understand that the structure, this has been going on for five years, and I do know I've had buildings go up even longer. 487 Shore Road comes to mind. That took about six, seven years, and it's a massive project. People don't like when construction projects go on too, long, but it is happening, and they've worked, you know, they built the ADU, and they built their house and they are trying to live in retire and yes they're almost done with their project but no they've done so much replanting that the path of like just regular pointing not replanting just to create a border they've cleaned up trash so that 2023 photo that he was showing you has been clean up it's currently a garden bed I have pictures of it that's from the 2023 i couldn't get it into the packet fast enough obviously because it was friday but i do he has taken quite a bit of time on that property and what was cleared in that picture is still the same as it's been since 2022 on our gis like it hasn't been more impacted so in my opinion no there's no issue here there was no violation so [58:32] Speaker A (unidentified): a couple of questions does the house currently have an active building permit it absolutely does it was written in april of 2025. okay the impelments bringing up this room addition this what is that construction so in the setback or is it so i so that is so that is a note under the table i think [58:57] Speaker C (unidentified): i provided into the powerpoint but it's note number letter it is note letter e which allows you the exception to have a lot on a roundabout because you can't have more than you have to have the frontage you have to prove that you have the frontage to accommodate what would a normal lot would build would be so it's supposed to be where the principal structure sits and in this case it would be 200 feet we could all draw it three different ways because it's according to our ordinance it says point to point and in this case the points are tilted but I didn't make that argument because again a surveyor did show a 200 foot mark what also isn't cleared here is where it actually sits the single family dwelling it just says a principal structure does it say at the front of it does that the middle of it does it set to the end of it nobody actually has discussed this it's just written as you need to meet the front setback first for your principal dwelling and mary costigan our town attorney stated to me that doesn't set the building above she disagreed and said that doesn't set down the building envelope it just shows that you can build it's a dwelling in that setback of 200 feet somewhere on the lot you have to be able to show that is considered meeting your frontage sounds [1:00:17] Speaker E (unidentified): like that's a requirement for a buildable lot you got it through the planning board and setbacks would [1:00:25] Speaker C (unidentified): would come well these lots were created in 1986 so i don't you know i just know the building permit came in the late 2020 yeah okay i mean you know that you know a long-term development so i feel like i'm not answering your question paul mr chair sorry the so [1:00:52] Speaker A (unidentified): so the fact that they're building this porch that's not in violation i mean of their no it also within their building envelope it's a to in the opinion of our town attorney that is [1:01:07] Speaker C (unidentified): perfectly acceptable to build right there and it's also not the principal structure is technically a porch but it is attached so i would consider it the principal dwelling yes it sits where it's supposed to sit okay and also it had been well over 30 days even if this let's say hypothetically i was wrong it's been well over 30 days and i still think i'm right at first i did react the way i reacted he is correct mr hedger i did in fact say at this 200 foot mark we would have to talk to the owner which we did and i told him to wait as i talked to my attorney every single monday so i waited to speak with our town attorney and i did and i gave the answer i gave and here we are okay [1:01:50] Speaker A (unidentified): so i'm gonna i have a few of the points here that he's made maybe you can discuss the clearing of the lot i know this is four years ago probably or more but were there any violations in the clearing of the lot the only violation we ever have were i would say i wouldn't [1:02:08] Speaker C (unidentified): say the word violation i just say it's a it was a problem and it was addressed is that henry foundation sealer it was a tar substance product that was in a can it had been used it was discarded onto a wood pile with a bunch of other trash they were getting ready to like in the construction in a construction site you put it you make a pile of trash and you throw it away or you have a dumpster they put it in the shoreline zone it was too close to the wetlands i agree so i was like you know we had dep come down and they agreed we they had it removed they tried they cleaned it up and it's that's the only time we've ever been down there with the ep that's the only time i ever felt there was something that i needed to address but as far as clearing cutting [1:02:49] Speaker A (unidentified): trees down there were they were within their rights to cut the trees they did whatever was [1:02:56] Speaker C (unidentified): done in 2022 i wasn't there but i can tell you that it was done and it was it was that's been the envelope for four years and we haven't seen any new cutting we've seen you planting so [1:03:08] Speaker A (unidentified): So the idea to have the pile of trash, which the appellant refers to as a junkyard, and tents with pails inside. [1:03:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I want to discuss that part. That was closed in a complaint a few years ago. It's actually in your packet. It's one of the several complaints. Inside the buckets, there are five-gallon buckets, and I saw the Facebook post years ago. There aren't any drugs in it, and there's no chemicals. It's just building materials. It was like brackets, nails, stuff you need for building a house. It was just neatly organized in a tent. Yes, that did exist. And as for trash piles, those are organized piles of lumber. I mean, every job site has a clean pile of lumber. If you're a good builder and it's covered and it's sitting there, they're going to use it. If they do not, I imagine they're going to sell it. I don't know what their plan is. [1:04:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Okay, erosion control. Now, again, we're talking four years after they started building. [1:04:08] Speaker C (unidentified): So when it was being built, you saw the massive berm of where the wetlands is, which is down. The contours actually go toward the back of 5 Stella. I just looked at the contour map, and that had a massive berm along it, and there was no digging done since the foundations went in. Like, it's not moving the earth enough to... It wouldn't need erosion control. [1:04:33] Speaker A (unidentified): so the berm was installed before they built yep and that's i didn't confirm it was still there but i don't think it was ever removed by the way it served its purpose and it's now been removed [1:04:44] Speaker C (unidentified): not that i'm aware of but i gotta look into it but either way there's i mean it just looks like yeah we just got the new gis maps it's not it's covered in trees so i'm trying to figure out [1:04:57] Speaker A (unidentified): where exactly it is but you did visit the site there i thought when was that in august yeah well [1:05:04] Speaker C (unidentified): back i did it in august and i did it again just recently on friday so i just took pictures from where i was standing i took a picture of where that area is there is a garden bed and then just the organized materials he's right it's all sitting along the edge okay and then the [1:05:23] Speaker A (unidentified): the discussion about the vernal pool yeah when was this actually when did this take effect this so may 17th of this year this year yep so it would not apply to anything that we're talking [1:05:37] Speaker C (unidentified): about tonight correct but if for example if they decided to start messing around with anything else on their property that buffer is treated like a limited res so there which is a shoreland sub-district and it allows it creates a 250 foot buffer and when you're a hundred feet to the actual vernal pool like the epicenter you cannot do anything in there without a special permit from the actual DEP so it's treated very similar to our limited res where we don't want things being built [1:06:06] Speaker A (unidentified): within a hundred feet so limited res would apply to any lot that's saying not built in that area and if they wanted to build it now applies yes and there's a [1:06:17] Speaker C (unidentified): 25 percent 75 buffer area in the 100 to 250 and they get very strict if you do anything in 100 feet if they allow it i just wanted to be clear there's that is the new guidance that's the new language anybody [1:06:31] Speaker B (unidentified): else have any questions for barry bruce yeah i'm just so relying on the visual that mr hedger put up first with the setbacks yep if you look at that you know and you look at the wetland setbacks clearly there was an area cleared outside of it is your argument that might not be permissible today but since it's done i'm saying a long time ago i'm saying [1:06:58] Speaker C (unidentified): if it was so i wasn't again there when it was first written but if the clearing occurred because of construction that's a different that's between the code officer at the time and what was done and you have to do a arborist report like if you came in today to try to do the same thing we'd be asking for harvest report replanting plan what are you removing what are you putting back and as you get closer and closer to wetland obviously becomes you can't even take out the tree unless it's storm damaged or dying and then you gotta prove to us that it's dying usually pictures are great they're falling over it's a great indicator it's dead but having said that i'm not i again i wasn't there when it was first being done but i imagine they never stopped the project they went out there several times on inspections I can only rely on my code officers and my predecessors okay and if it's within the building envelope it was good to go well but [1:07:57] Speaker B (unidentified): so if we look at that you know behind there didn't seem necessary for any building it was just an area that was cleared [1:08:06] Speaker C (unidentified): that also that area on the right side yeah so that was there since 2022 and i'm not sure about that one as well i would i would i would also say that would have been something i would have liked to have discussed as well because if it was through my office because which it was but if the predecessor or whoever allowed that it's been there since 2022 i could argue that yeah maybe you should bring it back to the 100 foot mark but it's just i don't know if because the permit the original permit for this area was already you've signed off on so the code officer that did that saw that everything was fine not that it is I'm just arguing that this is what happens in the field sometimes we have tried to nip this but if it was signed off by a previous officer I have to allow what was there and signed off on yeah and but it's something we should be catching we've missed this a couple times and we're getting better but errors do happen okay so i would argue i would argue this was probably yeah it's just it's an oversight so it's out of scope of the appeal i wouldn't say well i mean what again what is this appeal about so because i mean i agree with you but i don't i have a permit for this porch in this house i wouldn't say it's i'm not saying you're i get your point but I'm not saying, hey, this is 100% good to go. I'm just saying I can't do anything about it. [1:09:38] Speaker B (unidentified): So the porch was permitted? [1:09:41] Speaker C (unidentified): The porch was permitted as part of the permit in April of 25. [1:09:44] Speaker B (unidentified): It was permitted in 2025, so the time to appeal. [1:09:47] Speaker C (unidentified): That would've been a great time to appeal, 30 days later, yep. [1:09:50] Speaker J (unidentified): Do you know when the tubes were put in? [1:09:52] Speaker C (unidentified): The tubes were put in recently. [1:09:53] Speaker J (unidentified): Recently, and they were inspected and everything? Yep, they were precast. [1:09:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, were they precast? No, they're. Sorry, I hadn't been out there. say it again i was trying to remember if it was precast or if it was actual sonotubes it was sonotubes so i did have a my most recent trip this friday i do last friday i do have pictures of the porch but again i couldn't just last minute throw a bunch of pictures at you okay [1:10:20] Speaker B (unidentified): mr hedger mentioned an unpermitted structure he looked in the yeah i got to look into that as [1:10:25] Speaker C (unidentified): well they get a look in my office say I do see this here I don't that's the porch yeah how'd you yeah that's what we were asking about so this [1:10:39] Speaker B (unidentified): was it was not permanent that's permitted yes it's permitted so what was [1:10:43] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't know thank you all right thank you so much yes this is a porch and it was a pro sorry this is permitted in 2020 that's correct okay there's a part [1:10:55] Speaker B (unidentified): of the building permit for this house but so was something was something done that was not [1:10:59] Speaker C (unidentified): permitted there was well that's what i was going to say so he was talking about this building next door or next to it looks like it's like a barn or garage or shed storage shed i do need to look at that i don't know i need to look in my office to see if there was a permit and if there isn't a permit it will be an after the fact permit which we charge 100 extra dollars to make sure it actually sits where it needs to sit in the structure rules, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. So, I was gonna say, I think there is, but I just didn't have it off the top of my head. All right, that's, yeah. So, it has been made, I've been made aware that yes, we did in fact write a permit for that. Are you Mr. Rubera? I'm sorry, I just couldn't remember off the top of my head. [1:11:41] Speaker E (unidentified): Just to clarify on the building envelope, it still follows the sidelines until it's 50 feet. front setback and 30 foot setback so that building envelope follows 200 foot requirement is for the planning board it's required to make those lots so according to minimum that they according to mary the building envelope extends to the front of the lot that's barry says it does not establish that 's correct yeah from the cul-de-sac that is correct [1:12:19] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah but also they like I said this could be written better as Barry has [1:12:26] Speaker E (unidentified): said to me so but that's another we're mixing up planning board requirements for a lot well that's funny setbacks so the setbacks you know are clear to me but probably not to everyone it's still that particular like that [1:12:44] Speaker C (unidentified): particular item would have gone through my office because it didn't go through [1:12:47] Speaker E (unidentified): planning board but yes it is generally to create the lot because this is a planning board subdivision [1:12:53] Speaker C (unidentified): from way back it's actually i don't even think the planning board weighed in on its 1986 subdivision that was just registered prior to any of the like it didn't have any boards weigh in on it i saw the 1986 plan yeah i [1:13:10] Speaker E (unidentified): mean it was before the met those requirements which have changed over [1:13:14] Speaker C (unidentified): years and that's why i think this whole thing came up when they went to build them to make [1:13:18] Speaker A (unidentified): sure everything was compliant so yeah any other any other questions for code let's see moving on here we can maybe hear from or [1:13:39] Speaker D (unidentified): you might want to have okay [1:13:43] Speaker A (unidentified): so maybe mr hedger could come up and would you like to respond to our discussion yeah i've got the permit here [1:13:55] Speaker H (unidentified): just basically which basically states a 2300 foot square foot three bed two bath single family dwelling on here and it in the permit dates it doesn't even show that sonitudes are checked off so it's pretty safe to go under the assumption that no deck or no porch was ever was ever planned it's not even in the permit so i don't know how it's in the permit when it's not in the permit i guess i have a question about that it also goes to the point that somebody's going to need to contact anderson livingston kimball surveying moody and maybe civil consultants to let them know they don't know what they're doing no that's i speak no i mean no i'm just trying to make a we disagree with that i know i know okay i just i guess i relied on the professional land certified land surveyors to assess the building lot and that's how i came up with the 200 foot setback with ours neighbors and the two surveys first [1:14:57] Speaker A (unidentified): please reply to the interpretation of code as far as the 200 well that's that you brought that to us yeah they've replied what's your rebuttal to that [1:15:11] Speaker H (unidentified): well that it basically says the primary structure needs to be built where the lot width meets, and this is right in code, meets the street frontage requirement. See, our lots don't have a 200-foot street frontage, so we have an exception. I think that's where the confusion comes in. The exception is made for us because we're on a cul-de-sac, and as long as we build our houses 200 feet back, or excuse me, not 200 feet back, but where this the street frontage of 200 feet in the width were allowed to build there so that's that's the that's the exception that's discussed and our house is that way our neighbor's house and the two surveys show that as well and i honestly i don't know if the town attorney's a land surveyor or not i have no idea but that's that's in code but that's you know so that's my, you know, like it or not, that's my interpretation and the interpretation from four surveys. [1:16:16] Speaker A (unidentified): We're here to address an administrative appeal having to do with porch. Yeah. That has nothing to do with the fact that these people built this house four years ago. [1:16:29] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, the house isn't done. [1:16:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, it doesn't matter. It has an active permit. [1:16:34] Speaker H (unidentified): No, I understand that. I just didn't, I was, I'm confused. confused is telling us that the work is permitted for the for the porch yes so beyond that front setback that's laid out in the i guess it's i was relying on the certified land surveyors and their assessments don't make sense oh no i know that 's where i got confused [1:16:58] Speaker B (unidentified): you have mr norton saying the permit contemplated it included the porch and we have mr hedger saying the permit doesn't. So that's like an issue of fact that I would like to, you say that the permit. I mean, I have it right here. And the porch is there. [1:17:17] Speaker C (unidentified): The porch is right here. [1:17:18] Speaker B (unidentified): So that was a 2025 permit. [1:17:20] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I just didn't see the sonotubes checked and I was relying on the certified field system. Was just relying on the land surveys that were done. So it came into question and of course his first response, like you said, added to the confusion. So we went back and looked at that as well. [1:17:39] Speaker B (unidentified): But the time, so the time to appeal that would have been in 2020, within the 30-day window. [1:17:45] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, we just never saw the, we never saw the debt go up until 1st of August. [1:17:51] Speaker B (unidentified): He's showing us that permit shows. [1:17:54] Speaker C (unidentified): April 14th, 2025. [1:17:56] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah,, that's the one I've got here too. Okay. [1:17:59] Speaker C (unidentified): We're all on the same page, so. Anything else? [1:18:04] Speaker H (unidentified): yeah i just sounded the significant vernal pool i do have the wait a minute oh i'm sorry [1:18:10] Speaker A (unidentified): vernon pools are not in discussion here tonight because it does not apply here [1:18:16] Speaker H (unidentified): got it i'll rely on dep when they come out to do an assessment [1:18:22] Speaker A (unidentified): fine okay right would mr ribera like to comment at all from the podium him my [1:18:43] Speaker G (unidentified): name is mark ribera i'm the resident at five stella my wife jessica is here with the rest of the neighborhood and all the individuals building the house with me there you go five years ago we came up looking for a spot to build here i've been a police officer for 44 years i semi-retired four years ago to come up and buy this property and build the house i had just finished a term as a board of selectmen and this has been our dream i've built many structures i've been a carpenter for a long time i even ran a program with other police officers called hoods in the woods where we took juvenile delinquents we taught them woodworking skills and we built things and we had a sawmill and it's a nationally recognized program so i've been building things for a long time in fact if you can see some of those pictures it's a post and beam and it's were timber framers and those were cut on a sawmill I actually moved the timbers half of the timbers that were on the property at the hedges complaint I brought him over a friend's house and I've tried my best to accommodate all the different things that he said over the years which are egregious to say that somehow I'm environmentally irresponsible and there's chemicals leaking that's ridiculous I'll admit that can was there because by code you have to waterproof your foundation and I left it out in the back of the foundation that is now a garden that pictures from three years ago and to paint me as somebody who has a disregard for life is ridiculous in fact when a concrete truck was coming up the road it tore down the wires live wire to blue transformer and mr hedger pulled up in his in his car behind it and is screaming and yelling with live wires next to them and i came over and got him out of the car because i have critical incident management skills and i got him out of the car and there's there's witnesses right here tonight who were there i think we got to move well you allowed him to tell a story about his environmental thing and about life excuse me let me talk for a second i'm sorry sir just calm down [1:21:02] Speaker A (unidentified): we 're listening to your story please just tell it in a civil voice and we'll stick with that okay [1:21:10] Speaker G (unidentified): okay thank you so on june 6th i believe right jessica i'm working on my house and i turned around and mr hedger's behind me uninvited we both kind of surprised each other he asked me if told me he was selling his property and that he would appreciate it if there's a few things that i could remedy so i asked him what would you like me to do to remedy something that's disturbing you so we went out he showed me a bunch of things i said listen i'm going to get a permit in a few days a burning permit and we're going to burn all this scrap so i got we i had my son come up with all his buddies we got all the scrap together we got the burn permit i start burning he calls the fire department on me and the fire department comes out said there's nothing wrong so I just kind of showing the intent of this is not his altruistic view of protecting nature or being a good neighbor it's it's to hurt us it's to punish us there's only been one violation and Harry said it wasn't even a violation he asked me to clean up the debris that was in the back other than that every inspector that's been out there has commented on the quality of the construction the quality of the products the neatness of our building and this is just this has just been a nightmare for us and there's a lot of people here tonight to support us to claim that some of these pictures are so dated and you can select pictures and having been a police officer i know you can sway things with pictures but there's other pictures that refute that so we've planted over 40 to 50 trees at like 300 a piece to create a border along one whole side and almost half of the other side to create privacy to beautify a lot and at this point we're so close the power was just turned on my electrician terry's been working with me for years john said that's one of the finest constructed buildings he's ever seen and he's been doing this for years so i take pride in what i do and i and i'm i'm offended and hurt that somebody could have so much ill will towards us that they tried to stop us from building our dream house for five years and it was evident in the beginning when they first came out and told me and this is relevant because when you make a complaint it matters what your motive is for making a complaint plane so i'm working in the front of the house and i'm accosted by the neighbors here and saying you're not the kind of people that you live in this neighborhood you don't make enough money you should dig a hole in a lot and bury yourself in it you just don't belong here and before you recruit that i'm a policeman and there's video evidence of that because i'm not a fool i know how to get evidence but okay i'm sorry stick with the state standard here please i am passionate about this chairman i understand that's obvious and you could feel that okay thank you and we my wife's even afraid to go out into the yard and you know i'm tired of coming in the house crying because she feels like a stranger in her own yard in her own house and we got a steel like two three years ago harry yes were you saying here for the accessory dwelling unit yeah so we already have it we already have a ceo to be building and we're building another structure which i've done 60 to 70 of the carpentry myself and that's been out for like a year and a half so i built two homes there and to say it took a long time i know that 's what infuriates them but it's a beautiful spot the realtor is here today and he's thinking that it could be worth two million dollars and that's pretty much something for a police officer and his wife, who's a special ed teacher. And I'm 72 years old, I've seen a lot of things that I just wanted to get away from, and I love it here. I just wanna live out the rest of my life in peace and finish my house. Okay. Thank you, guys. [1:25:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, thank you. Yeah, we don't need applause, please. Okay, is there anyone else in the audience? This is a public, excuse me, this is a time for a public comment on this matter. Anybody else in the audience would like to say anything? Okay. Yes, come up and introduce yourself, please. [1:26:04] Speaker K (unidentified): Evening. My name is Jonathan St. Onge, owner and operator of Mainley Electric. Mark's an electrician. And all I can do really is to speak to the quality of these two people. Didn't start out as friends. It was purely a professional relationship. Went over there, helped them with a few things, you know, decided to continue working with them, wiring the new house. And we're personal friends now. And I can say those two are two of the only people in my 12 years of being an electrician that I've just had a personal relationship afterwards. The construction of the property, of the house, both houses, like he said, fantastic construction. I've roughed in houses and seen framing and framing inspections for the last 12 years. and it's one of the best constructed homes that I've ever seen the finished work mark does it all himself high quality materials it's beautiful and like he said with the timber framing he's doing a great job it's a beautiful house they're wonderful people he's a police officer she's a school teacher you know they're important to the community they're nice people and kind of been along for the whole process and it is difficult to see how upset that they get with their neighbors giving them as hard of a time as they are whether it's legitimate or not it's it's hard to watch them you know they take it to heart they care about the people around them and they care about what they're doing I just hope this whole gets resolved the way it should Okay. That's all. Anyone else? [1:28:04] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah. Hi. Can I add something? Go ahead. So my name is Dave Dini. I'm the owner at 3 Stella Lane. So I just, all I wanted to say on two points was we built our house about five years ago. Moody Construction built our house. our house was built within the building envelope that was on the survey I would like my house built in a little bit different way so it's interesting know that the building envelope doesn't really matter and that Moody construction didn't really know he could move the house around like I guess I'm a little bit confused how he talked about he doesn't have to live within the building envelope that we had to live within and then the other thing is we did talk a little bit about the tree clearing mr. Moody made it clear to us that you cut down any more trees than what you're allowed to on this map and you're gonna get fined so we couldn't cut down the trees we wanted we had to live with what was there and then within a year later a lot next to us gets clear cut to the ground no fines no accountability that's all i have got a question yep are you affected by the vernal pool is that i mean it would be on the other side of his lot so i don't i don't i'd have to get out of measuring tape and measure it out i'm not sure okay so we had to live within our setbacks our building envelope we couldn't cut down the trees we wanted but other people don't [1:29:56] Speaker A (unidentified): have to live by those rules i guess okay thank you thank you i wasn't going to say anything my name is graham duck wait a minute okay now introduce yourself when you get to the mic sure [1:30:14] Speaker L (unidentified): and my name is Graham duck my partner and our four kids live in the neighborhood with both parties involved and what is your address my address is 19 uplands Lane so we are kitty corner to both parties we can actually see both well we can see Tom and Lisa's home mmm during the winter I'm a commercial banker my wife is a chief revenue officer for a health technology company we moved admittedly to the ugliest home in the neighborhood about four years ago and we've been renovating since so we've been you know working on our project ourselves we moved the neighborhood because it embodies everything we want out of life it's a beautiful neighborhood beautiful homes quiet private great neighbors and all those things have remained true Tom and Lisa have been very nice to me and my family so I hate to take sides I really do but Mark and Jessica are the exact neighbors we want they're kind they take our kids in mark uses his own equipment to service the road so he has a tractor he mends the potholes uses it on gravel uses it on diesel which as we know is very expensive right now mark drove by and saw me struggling with a home project middle of the day hold his truck over jumped out helped me finish it right on the spot Lord knows what he had to do that day so I came here to learn and listen about what's going on between the neighbors because it actually it affects us and I didn't want to take sides but based on that last presentation I'm a bit confused and maybe you guys can help me out this presentation went all over the map didn't seem to focus on a porch focused on a vernal pool and something else focused on environmental waste which was disproven several years ago the even the zoning board here refuted all the claims that were made so i'm curious as to what's actually happening here and i'm asking you has there been a pattern of this type of complaints in our neighborhood i believe there probably is based on this conversation so the last thing i'll say is i've been on this property mark's property many times so have my kids i'm in all with the craftsmanship and i'm in all with the abilities that mark has and i'm sad to see this go this far it is very tidy it's very clean they take very good pride in their property and I'd like to see this resolved and ended but I don't like to see good people's names smeared and distruths or false accusations being made in front of your counsel so thank [1:32:56] Speaker A (unidentified): you just to confirm so your name again is Graham duck it's pretty easy okay because we had a we had another letter from another job if you were the same one yeah thank you for that thank you okay [1:33:18] Speaker H (unidentified): i just have 15 seconds i'm the appeal just want to clear something up i just want it cleaned up i want the area in those setbacks that's all we've been asking that's all we've made clear can you please clean up the property in the wetlands That's pretty much it Because I didn't know because I didn't have an understanding they made it pretty clear Code has made it clear to be honest with you that 's the primary complaint all the other stuff That's gone on has been previous what I want before the board is I? Really just would like to see that area on the other side of the tents where my property abuts and those pictures are current You know you can come out tomorrow or something if you want to look It's just kind of hoping to get the trash cleaned up in that area [1:34:12] Speaker J (unidentified): yeah and that 's it okay thank you well excuse me hello you can leave if you can't wait [1:34:23] Speaker A (unidentified): for your turn please leave if you can't be quiet you can go outside okay seriously if you want to speak i'm sorry come up sorry who's speaking who's speaking now don't keep pointing at her tell her to stop she said okay well i can't hear her from here proper decorum is you don't speak [1:34:45] Speaker H (unidentified): at all okay understood that 's all we've wanted seriously and yeah there's been discrepancies and stuff in the past but before the board right now you know i think it's you guys have looked like you've cleared up the porch maybe i don't know if that's your decision and all we've and we've said this to mark in the past and yeah things got rough can you really just would hope that you could kind of finish the property and clean up that area on the abutting side that's it that's it thank you good [1:35:25] Speaker M (unidentified): evening my name is teresa ole and with my husband my three kids and my mother-in-law kathleen we reside at [address] up lindsley we have a letter from you yeah so i just want to i know you have a letter that states essentially our story and our observations but i just want to repeat what i think is important and what is not echoed and repeated by our neighbors graham and jacqueline which is that we have been visiting this property at least once a month sometimes more often for four years unannounced visits our children running down there to say hi to some of their favorite neighbors and at no time have we seen anything that resembles a junkyard chemical spills odors trash anything like that if there were we wouldn't be visiting we wouldn't be sending our kids down there to visit our neighbors it has always appeared an immaculate and safe construction site every single time that we visited announced or unannounced and i also want to say that we are proud to have people like mark and jessica in our neighborhood we're thankful [1:36:27] Speaker A (unidentified): that they're there thank you thank you anyone else okay we'll close the public hearing what's left here what is the where's the board thing that can have people's opinion [1:36:51] Speaker B (unidentified): first so the vernal pool thing clearly it's a new it's a new regime that didn't apply at the time any of this is being done yeah so the vernal pool issue I think we've dealt with the new rules did not apply when any of this is being done the porch appears in the permit visually we've seen that the porch appears in the permit i just as a as a person as someone who has neighbors and you know you i guess i wouldn't necessarily expect everybody to go and inspect every new permit when it's issued nevertheless i guess the time the window for mr hedger to apply to appeal that permit was last year not this year so it seems like it's good there seems to be a question that maybe there's some other structure that's unpermitted but mr norton thinks that can be dealt with after the fact it turns out it was permitted it was pretty bad okay so no one permits pressure so on the erosion control every does everyone agree that the berm served its purpose and now [1:38:02] Speaker A (unidentified): it's gone or do you disagree i think i asked i asked harry the berm was there and it's no longer [1:38:08] Speaker C (unidentified): there I did not confirm that there was there or not on site but I can tell you that it was there for quite some time I don't know if it was ever raked back into the ground but it looks like trees have grown around in the most recent [1:38:21] Speaker J (unidentified): shot so maybe it did its job but there's no more shifting of soil so not over [1:38:26] Speaker B (unidentified): there don't so it's irrelevant yep and then we get to the junkyard which has been cleaned up well it just doesn't meet the definition was a junkyard yeah without even addressing that there's nothing today yeah if I am allowed to [1:38:41] Speaker C (unidentified): write up a junkyard it's in our ordinance yeah but not today whatever [1:38:45] Speaker B (unidentified): was there in those pictures I would say that there's still piles there they're [1:38:49] Speaker C (unidentified): neatly organized I just want to be clear that they are still there but they are organized around the outside and I mean I've seen worse job sites okay I think [1:38:59] Speaker B (unidentified): the only question I have this is just like I haven't I was not prepared with having done the research because I didn't understand the chronology, the tree clearing. So, you know, that, I mean, I'm interested in the fact that it was done, again, it would seem to me that if it was not permissible at the time, then the appeal window or whatever, the time to protest would have been some time ago, yes. [1:39:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Agreed, and I, again, because I wasn't there, I don't know what was talked about onsite. I just don't, I could do a FOIA request. [1:39:35] Speaker A (unidentified): There's a process for that in code where if there's overcutting, they bring in a registered arborist, they analyze what was cut, what was permissible and what wasn't, and they map a plan for the homeowner to replace the trees. [1:39:54] Speaker C (unidentified): And I wanna be clear, I'm very serious about tree cutting. We just issued one of the largest fines for tree cutting in this town, so I take it seriously. [1:40:09] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. Based on that, I think, you know, we said the appeal was timely because it was in a reaction to an email, but as we break down the items, it turns out what the appeal really is, it's an appeal of various actions that took place some time ago. [1:40:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Some time ago, yes. [1:40:27] Speaker B (unidentified): And therefore not timely. [1:40:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you have anything to add? [1:40:30] Speaker E (unidentified): I just wanted to talk about that 200-foot dimension that everybody's referring to, and that's not the setback, but that's where the primary part of the house has to be. The building envelope still follows the contour of the lot with the setbacks from the wetlands. [1:40:54] Speaker C (unidentified): I'll see if I want to speak into your microphone next time. You were a little quiet. [Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, okay.] I think we heard you though the 200 foot setback yes that was a concern for me [1:41:14] Speaker J (unidentified): it's all about making sure in compliance of all the permits I wasn't sure about the shed but Harry confirmed that there was a permit for the shed that everything was done with the tubes, with the inspection, and the porch, or the deck that was put on the house was all permitted and met the setbacks. So for me, those were the issues that go towards me for the appeal, and so they seem to be all met to me. [1:41:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Michelle? [1:41:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Every question I had was answered in this discussion and with Harry, so now I don't have any questions. Okay. [1:42:03] Speaker A (unidentified): So then, I would, I will, Robert, did you have something to say? [1:42:10] Speaker D (unidentified): Only, you know, obviously I'm not brooding on this, but as an alternate, my only comment about it. Sorry. that's all right that's all right that's what happens when you're the ultimate but the only thing i can say is it seems like this is an administrative appeal of the action or inaction of the code office okay at the time of that letter was there something the code office didn't do or should have done you know or the opposite everything is fine. Yes, I'm sorry, what I'm saying is this is an administrative appeal of an action or inaction of the code enforcement officer because administrative appeals have to be made within 30 days of the time of the incident that's being appealed. So it really comes down to was Harry required to do something or did he do something 30 days within that 30 day window of the time of the appeal? That being the case, because many of these things we've talked about have continuing effect, but they're not necessarily something that's happened in that 30-day window. So that's really, I think, what the board is looking at, and we've been hearing that most everything has been met. that's as I'm sitting here that's what I 've heard that's my you have to attach [1:43:44] Speaker A (unidentified): it to something in time yes thank you yeah and I had a similar position when first reviewing this appeal from the standpoint that we have to decide that there was a decision and then the timeliness of the appeal has to do with the decision well that decision can be a non-decision or inaction by the code enforcement group and so yes I would be reviewing it from the standpoint of whether or not or did code perform all the things they should have done and they did they do it in a timely fashion so i having heard everyone i'm prepared to have a motion on this on this appeal please okay [1:44:51] Speaker F (unidentified): i move that the administrative appeal brought by tom hedger of four stella lane regarding the response to code opinions from 9 21 26 20 26 pertaining to the property at 5 Stella Lane Cape netic main oh three nine oh two map five lot not 14-5-S is denied. [1:45:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? Can I have a second? I'll second. So Ken, motion was made by Michelle, seconded by Ken. Then I'll have a vote, Ken. Yes. Bruce. Yes. Mitch. Yes. Michelle. Yes. Chair votes yes. administrative appeal is denied the vote is 5-0 thank you so thank you yeah did we have other code business other than we have three matters coming in [1:46:38] Speaker C (unidentified): December that's just be prepared for that 's our next meeting is December [1:46:44] Speaker A (unidentified): 9th. There are three now? Yeah. Well, I don't know if that, we both think one of them is on the [1:46:49] Speaker C (unidentified): bubble and it's probably going to go away, but there's three currently on the docket. So, yep. [1:46:55] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Okay. I think we're good here. So, we're also going to have a, we're gonna sorry we're gonna have a workshop sorry can we have the discussions outside please we're trying to finish our meeting so [1:47:45] Speaker J (unidentified): for well this guys can you please let us finish our meeting thank you so this [1:48:01] Speaker A (unidentified): is new information for the new information for the board I mentioned the last meeting about I mentioned last meeting about what did I mention workshop you weren't even there so I mentioned about that and I've researched to find a date because all of these dates are usually filled up and we don't have anything in November so I've set aside November 12th it's a Thursday I mean can people it'll be 7 o'clock it be here maybe spend a few hours reviewing our bylaws and also reviewing the documents for everyone yes I [1:49:15] Speaker J (unidentified): think our next meeting is what December 9th yes I think I will be out of town I think that's when we leave I'll double check if it's the night well you can just let us know I'll let you know and then i'll let you know about i'll just go home and check my calendar and all right well [1:49:41] Speaker A (unidentified): i'll be i'll text you yeah i'll be sending out a note i'm absolutely not good my president my company's coming to visit so maybe we can work without you and then yeah sure okay we'll have to catch you up well and then as far as whatever review we do with the bylaws we'll make edits and then we'll hold on it in a regular meeting. [1:50:09] Speaker J (unidentified): Paul, is this our own workshop or we bring in like the planning board? No, just us right now. [1:50:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Just us, okay. But we can generate like a list to like you've mentioned about meeting with planning. Definitely. [1:50:22] Speaker F (unidentified): And I could comment right on the bylaws and give them to you, my comments. Oh yes, absolutely. [1:50:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, sorry, was that you? Oh, that's your person. [1:50:31] Speaker B (unidentified): So our focus is gonna be the bylaws? [1:50:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, no. Also, the documents that we produce resulting from meetings. So, well, our reporting secretary is doing our minutes and she does a good job and we have to kind of refine what she's doing. But then after that, findings of fact, and then the variance documents. [1:51:02] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Chair, so Liz also wanted to bring it up, the fees, if you wanted to talk about the fees for an appeal, because some of the mailers are so expensive. I don't know. We bring it up every year when you guys talk about it. I'm just going to bring it up. I've just brought it up and put it down. [1:51:20] Speaker A (unidentified): I have brought it up to the financial director. Okay. And actually, I'm not sure where all that gets charged. It's maybe to your budget. No,, no. [1:51:30] Speaker C (unidentified): we don't have to worry about that i just wanted to make sure you were good this is about you [1:51:38] Speaker B (unidentified): so if you win the appeal [1:51:42] Speaker J (unidentified): that's different the only thing i asked for harry i'm going to be on this board let's get [1:51:49] Speaker A (unidentified): me a beach stick out here i'll check let me i'll research that and let everybody know that dates back i think yeah four years ago when joe good point because there's a schedule of fees with [1:52:01] Speaker B (unidentified): the town jenny was your request for a beach it's probably select board that's that's it i don't [1:52:05] Speaker J (unidentified): get it because the this is supposed to bring the selectmen get paid everybody in the town hall gets paid we're volunteering we get all the stuff i see you on a freebie and at least throw us a [1:52:17] Speaker A (unidentified): beach sticker right okay we're getting close to the end here i think thank you thank you to Harry and thank you all can I have a motion to adjourn all in favor then should we need a second for that second thank you