← Back to MaineScanner

Rockport Budget Committee Reviews EMS Operations and Regionalization Options

2026-11-03 · 1h 44m · Source: 2026-11-03 Budget Committee Meeting (Town of Rockport (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Jeff's the most powerful person in this room. Jeff is. Walker, would you turn your mic on? [0:13] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't know. Is there an on? [0:16] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't know. You're on, you're on. Hey, good evening, everybody. We're going to call the meeting to order for the Budget Committee tonight. This is great. I haven't seen this many people since I don't know when. And I'm sincere with that. please you guys can come anytime you want to come it's great as you can see we've got a pretty big turnout tonight for the EMS and we'll get right here to the EMS real shortly just want to go through a few housekeeping things my goal is to get everybody up here that wants to speak so I'm just kind of kind to ask a quick show of hands so i can try to figure out how much time people need and you can change your mind you can say if you don't put your hand up now and you want to speak again later just still come up but roughly how many we got that want to speak okay so freedom to the mic when you guys get ready okay i don't have any special announcements we got a committee that works hard i know there's a lot of thought out there this is my personal feeling and opinion there's a lot of thought out there of different opinions on what we're doing we're here for the town really here for the town so this is really good to see this many people it's really good so speak up tell us what you're thinking we're all working for the same goal here is to keep everybody safe and happy, you know, in the town. Okay? So no special announcements. The board, any of the board have any special announcements? You guys going around? John, anything special from you guys? No? No? Sam? No? [2:11] Speaker D (unidentified): I would just add, we did talk about a survey to have some budget questions on the town survey. So we just introduced that today at the polls, and it's on the town website on the home page so people can sign up to be part of [2:26] Speaker C (unidentified): the pool for surveying great how long will that window stay open for well for [2:33] Speaker D (unidentified): the first it's gonna be open forever really as long as we're doing it but we want to get up to a critical mass so we're the first survey that's there is kind of a sample survey if you will it's kind of survey light just to show people how it works and then we keep it open for about 60 days and hopefully we'll have my hope is we'll get easily 200 or more people to sign up to be part of the [2:58] Speaker C (unidentified): pool great and they can sign up town office if they want right online right online okay did everybody hear that you guys all got that back yeah we [3:09] Speaker D (unidentified): had it on a postcard with a QR code so people could do it right there on their phone if they wanted to we didn't sign anybody up at the time at the polls we just gave them the information and said you know scan this and register so [3:24] Speaker C (unidentified): everybody any questions on that one and everybody out there and Jeff's TV land please take advantage of that give us your thoughts any other announcements any other thoughts no okay public comment now nobody wanted to speak a minute ago and you guys can speak afterwards if you want all the EMS is going to give us presentation if anybody wants to speak up now you're welcome we've got a microphone that Jeff says is wired and ready to go if you guys are content to hang out then you're welcome so we'll move into the EMS I'm Rick mitchell anybody that doesn't know i'll ask you guys to give your names and a little bit of your background and then give us your packet i guess it's going to be up here for you guys to read and up here for us floor is yours when you get ready okay sure i'll go ahead and [4:28] Speaker E (unidentified): start my name is joseph moore i live in scotts road here in rockport i'm a member of the rockport fire department as a disclosure i work full-time for the city of rockland fire department as a lieutenant paramedic i've been asked to speak tonight just to give the group here a little bit of history as to how we get to the point of the town having its own ems service for folks that aren't aware we were serviced by a community-based private non-profit organization until 2013 at that time that service dissolved it went out to bid and it was contracted by a private for-profit company that served the four towns of Camden, Rockport, Hope, and Lincolnville from 2013 until 2024 when we started our own service. There were a lot of things over time that brought us to this point. It wasn't a rash decision. It wasn't anything that was jumped to. There were consistent failures over time of the system that was in place simply because this was a service provided by a private for-profit service that needed to make money, and not condemning anybody for that, but when there are bills to be paid, they did what was needed to pay those bills first, and that was not responding primarily to the calls within the four communities that they had a contract to serve. We had issues of coverage not meeting the town's expectation, multiple increases of the contract over time it increased by my notes from when we first put our program together 12,000 was the first cost the first year of the contract the year that we terminated the contract it was would be two hundred and fifty three thousand dollars with no increase in service no increase in the provision of coverage or licensure or anything like that there were actually there was a far greater use of mutual aid these issues were brought by the chiefs of the four towns to the service communication was poor often the responses weren't really meeting what we were looking for answers weren't provided corrections weren't provided so in 2023 i began speaking with Chief Peasley about where we were headed as a town and he told me that the direction was moving with Camden and Rockport to create a service together is a December of 2023 Camden had chosen to do something different but we were on the trajectory and looked at the looked at the statistics we looked at what we weren't getting for a service in this town what the people in the town felt they wanted i've been a provider ems provider in this area for the last 30 years moved i moved away for a little bit came back in 2021 started noticing a lot of the failures that were existing in the community volunteered to be a part of the creation of that service we started doing our homework as to what that would look like for the town we looked at the financial impact of it we looked at what the staffing levels would need to be the equipment costs we initially became a first responder service started responding to calls and then moved forward into a transporting service we held multiple meetings over the course of that two-year time period where the service was created to what we have today there was significant public support they obviously supported us very significantly when they voted for it would have been it would have been nice if we had been able to look at regionalization or look at a more cooperative service but that's just not the way that it worked out and chief peasley had the responsibility to make sure the service was provided for the citizens of the town of rockport and that's what i was in support of in my participation there have been many conversations over the over that 12 to 13 years that northeast Mobile Health was our provider about trying to pursue a regional focus and those conversations seem to only go as far as to quell the complaints and then it went back to what we were getting for a service before and that's that was what pushed ultimately pushed things to this point so that's a little bit a little bit of the history there and [8:59] Speaker F (unidentified): I'll let Corey take it from what we're doing right now thank you Joe so my name is Corey Bonnevie. I serve as the B-shift paramedic and EMS supervisor for Rockport Fire Department full-time status. I was hired at the inception of our new agency. Joe Moore sat on the board that interviewed me. I've been a paramedic 25 years. I've served in metropolitan, tactical, wilderness, rural, and urban settings. I also served as the EMS deputy chief of Liberty Fire Rescue and still serve as the capacity of a senior medic and advisor over there. there. My points tonight are going to be to build upon the presentation that's been put together on the screen. And as we go through, obviously what's written is definitely going to be the objective facts. I will attempt, as best I can for everyone in this room, with the consideration that people here listening don't work in this field, I attempt to elaborate it and given my history, I would hope that my opinions would be considered as informed ones. With the Rockport EMS schedule, what we do is a 24-hour shift followed by 48 hours off, another 24-hour shift, and then four days off. This is a very common schedule, standard across the country. Many agencies use it. There's nothing really out of the ordinary. That's just to give you guys an idea of how we function on a day-to-day basis with a cycling shift rotating a day forward each week. Our staffing is staffed by our firefighter, EMT, and a paramedic, meaning Rockport Fire Department provides paramedic or advanced life support coverage to every single patient that we interact with. This is not something that was guaranteed in the past. This is something that is guaranteed now and we've held that standard since our creation. No full-time members live in Rockport. Given EMS shortages and staffing of EMTs and paramedics in the country, it is not a feasible thing to simply say that we would prefer that we have all our paramedics live in the town. That would certainly be ideal but it's in no means realistic. Our crew members do reside in Fairfield. That's the furthest one away. Two of our full-time paramedics reside in Union, I, myself, and Appleton. We also have members in Thomaston, St. George, Hope, and Owls Head. That's going to be important as I get a little bit further down. So remember the shift staffing and where the folks live as I continue to elaborate, please. And I will reiterate, if there's any questions as I go on, feel free to raise your hand or speak out. With our main EMS license renewal, the licenses for the station and the ambulances that we currently run are renewed annually for both our rescues, the chief's vehicle, and any apparatus that may respond to EMS calls. That's a standard upheld by the state. No service is exempt. We all have to adhere to it. As far as our personal training, which was something that people wanted to be elaborated on, our paramedics require a minimum of 60 hours of continuing education for each licensure renewal. Main EMS determines which education qualifies and the applicable requirements, meaning we have to submit the classes that we take. We can't simply say, hey, we did this. There's certain accredited hours that have to be issued. These classes also cost money to the provider that we ourselves have to pay for in order to maintain that we renew our license. There is no grace period if the hours are not met, licensure is terminated or suspended until arrangements have been made. Inter-facility transfers. This is where I'm going to spend a little bit more time. This inter-facility transfer was something that we did incorporate later on into our plan of action and operations. The previous service that Joe mentioned is also a transfer agency. I myself have worked for hospital-based departments and private agencies, and in a situation where people are already in the medical care system, insurance balls have started rolling, things are obviously on foot, there is a certain amount of bills to be paid with transfers. However, when you're a for-profit service, and as Joe remarked on, when it comes to paying the bills, what ends up happening is that transfers get sent out. Not all these transfers are local. There are hospitals all over the state with specialty resource centers. Psychiatric patients most often go all the way to Fort Kent. Serious medical patients, burns, strokes, heart attacks often go to Portland or sometimes even Boston. This is not something that Rockport can afford to do, robbing its town of emergency medical services. And when I say emergency medical service I mean 9-1-1 dispatches for the people that dial 9-1-1. However, it is a common trend among areas in the state and abroad where 9-1-1 is dialed and ambulances and I speak from personal experience where I was dispatched to a life-threatening myocardial infarction or a heart attack in Livermore Falls and my ambulance was sitting in Rangeley, Maine. Anybody who's a familiar with Franklin County knows that on a good day that's an hour and 20 minute response time and it just so happened that night it was snowing luckily enough they got an ambulance there about 35 to 40 minutes after they called someone luckily cleared now we have a protocol for our inter facility transfers we do bill for our inner facility transfers you'll find further down in this presentation that the figures have been submitted for your review. However, given the standard and the foundation that we built this department on from the outcry of the citizens of Rockport, Maine, we made the promise and we have upheld it consistently that EMS services would not be interrupted when it comes to getting a transfer. So as it is, as it has been thus far, our transfers, if we do them, are only local thus far. That's been a standard. So case in point, example, from Penn Bay Medical Center to a Windward Gardens, something like that. We have 30 minutes to assemble a crew. The way this works is that Penn Bay will call our station. The medic on duty will answer the phone, they'll say we need a transfer. Surprise, we have transfer agencies, Maine Health has their very own transfer service dedicated to nothing but Maine health transfers from Penn Bay. Well, surprise,, they're out. There's no ambulances to be had. Northeast can't do it because they're out. So they call Rockport because we have nothing and our ED is overflowing. What we have here is a cascading and snowballing issue to where the entire medical system gets degraded and bogged down, for lack of a better term, given this type of problem. When Penn Bay's full of beds, they have to find a place to put these people and when there's nowhere to put them, they still are mandated to provide them with a nurse and medical attention if need be. This is a tremendous strain on the entire medical system. So they call us and they ask us, can you do it? And we say, well, give us a few minutes. And what we do is we get on an app that we're all signed up on and we send out a text to a certain crew that has the proper training, the proper skills, the proper certification level, and the ability under main EMS licensure to drive an ambulance and we make a request need a crew for a b c from point a to point b and it's either an advanced or a basic level call at that point we wait for response from our full-time and per diem employees now we're fortunate in rockport as that we have paramedics three of which full-time live in appleton and union one of which now lives in hope and then our other crew members thomason in Rockland, Owl's Head, such as that. We have per diems that live in town, Joe Moore himself has another paramedic that is available. If we can, we will. Our secondary ambulance is what does that. Our primary ambulance stays in town, which is our brand new model. Our secondary ambulance does not do extended transfers. Case in point, it's old. We got it at a very marketable price. We're lucky to have it and it has been of valid use. However, it is not the type of unit that we want driving to Maine Medical Center at any distance. We've had mechanical failures on it, even on local trips. As it sits right now, it's in the shop right now for repair. So that limits us on our distance, finding a crew and our secondary ambulance. It should be noted that this year I worked in conjunction with our medical director and got us approved in the eyes of Maine EMS to do paramedic inter-facility transfers. Now, these are financially very lucrative at a rate of sometimes four to one is the cost effectiveness of a standard BLS transfer back to a nursing home or something local. However, the problem is, that we simply don't have an ambulance right now that can go out of town and do it. We keep our primary ambulance in town for the people of Rockport because it's dependable, it's well-maintained, as all our rigs are maintained, but it's just got far less road miles on it and is a fine top-of-the-line unit so any questions thus far about how we handle our inner facility transfers okay i want to reiterate that at no point does rockport fire department ever interrupt 911 or emergency services for an inner facility transfer whatsoever speaking of that with our with our prompt response times i will mention that currently our average response time, given the way we've set up our operational standards, is roughly about seven minutes. A good response time average in the state of Maine is anything under 11. We're beating that by several minutes. I also work for Liberty. It's not uncommon to have a 40-minute response time. I used to work in Rangeley. That could have been an hour and 10-minute response time. So running at about 7.2 minutes right now,, the citizens of Rockport are being extraordinarily well served. That's a number that actually exceeds the national standard, I might add, and that's factoring in quick response times of larger cities and places like I used to work, Raleigh, North Carolina, South Central Los Angeles, and other places like that. When it comes to coverage and special events, we also provide mutual aid for Northeast Medical Health Services, Warren EMS, Union EMS, Rockland EMS. Special event coverage is also part of our department's duties and includes all high school football games, other special payoff sporting events, local world races, Donut Festival, and YMCA events. It should be noted for some of these special events there are times given the profundity of the event going on, aka for example the Donut Festival, places where there are a high yielding number of potential patients walking around children pets people a lot of things going on we will staff a second unit to have there as a dedicated unit for the event now even though that's happening we also make sure that our on-duty crew is present however the on-duty crew is still committed to 9-1-1 services for the everyday citizens of rockport maine same thing goes if we just have a standard full-time crew on post at a football game for Camden Hills they're there but if it's not a larger event if that ambulance gets a 9-1-1 dispatch because someone's down 9-1-1 for a valid emergency we will respond now the reason why I make mention of those standards being made is when it comes to EMS there's something we're talking about in school and a lot people are actually quite aware of it. It's called the golden hour. It's a very cliché term that's tossed around a lot, basically stating that the first hour of a medical emergency is the most important thing. That's where your most effective treatment is going to take place. However, there's a lesser known unit of time that we're taught in school as well, and it's called the platinum 10 minutes. This is why we maintain full-time EMS staffing in Rockport. In the first 10 minutes, especially with a stroke, a respiratory emergency, cardiac arrest, this is when the most difference is going to be made. After 10 minutes, your chances of survival drastically diminish. And most of our emergencies that we respond to that are true emergencies in their nature are extraordinarily time sensitive. Strokes, your brain starts dying immediately. Within three to five minutes, you're not getting those neurons runs back, a person in a respiratory emergency in those first 10 minutes will quickly go into respiratory failure. For a lot of our elderly population, that's a game changer. If we can get there in the first 10 minutes, stop a patient from having to be intubated, which is often a death sentence for people, respiratory infections are going to follow. So being there in the first 10 minutes by upholding these standards that I've just mentioned is how we're achieving the gold standard in Rockport, Maine. and having worked in other rural areas and areas in Maine the Rockport citizens are being very well served comparatively speaking to what many rural and even urban citizens in Maine are used to as far as providing EMS services to more towns this is an issue that has been raised now one thing that must be considered is that these surrounding areas which we do serve actively right now this is the mutual aid I talked about if an ambulance is not available in Rockland and they're out it happens quite regularly the closest unit in proximity given the expertise of Knox County dispatch as we call them the eye in the sky they will dispatch a mutual aid town to respond this is a national standard there are no exceptions we had to build this before we were able to get started in the eyes of main ems to uphold patient care standards for the citizens of the state of maine and nationally speaking as well so mutual aid is already there however becoming contracted with another town has several different implications number one first and foremost these towns are currently contracted with other services as rockport was once contracted and we simply can't do anything with that at this point in time negotiations discussions can be had however until their contracts run out and their townspeople want to have a vote on it and decide if they want to move in a new direction and start a new contract simply nothing can be done at this point the other side of that coin is a potential ugly one and when i say ugly i mean death of a citizen. And I say that very objectively. When you look at broadening your horizons, and I've worked for agencies that have had no other choice but to do this, Waldo County, just given the nature of the rural beast that it is, things are rather spread out. It's a tough bear to manage. Knox County is well covered as it sits right now. It works well as it sits right now. Our mutual aid agreements are working and everyone is playing their part. If Rockport was to take on Hope or Lincolnville, being our two most close proximate areas, most feasible to take over, the problem with that is our call volume would drastically increase, Not by a couple of calls a year. That's not so much concerning as the time an ambulance is taken out of service when this occurs. Rockport is also very fortunate that the Penn Bay Medical Center sits right within its borders. Our Rockport crews are able to efficiently do what we call in our field a turnaround, usually in less than 45 minutes, sometimes less than a half an hour given how close we are to the hospital. I'll call on Michelle Lane, we get there, we grab the patient. You can throw a rock, hit Penn Bay, you're there. You deliver them to the nurses and the docs there, Rockport unit is back in service. I myself, many people sitting in this room have thrown sheets on a stretcher and left Penn Bay immediately because another call came in. Redundant calls are definitely, it's not a question of if, it's a question of when this will occur. That's not a situation we want to happen when we've got our primary Rockport rescue responding to a call at the Lincolnville General Store for – and 911 calls are indiscriminate. When the call comes in, we go. So Joe and I are on the ambulance. We get 911 dispatched to a broken toe in Lincolnville. We're halfway into Lincolnville, cardiac arrest comes out in Rockland – or Rockport. There's no other ambulances available. Northeast is out on a call. The next closest available unit is in Rockland with a 20-minute ETA. I revert back to the platinum 10 minutes I was talking about. That's a situation where somebody is dying and in all probability, given medical standards and the American Heart Association's teachings, that person will stay dead. These are hard truths to be realized when it comes to spreading ourselves too thin, which is precisely why this topic was brought up. Splitting the response times from different areas also cuts into the mutual aid and the call volumes of other towns. So speaking with Hope, there's also going to be negotiations with Union, who also borders them, Camden, who also borders Lincolnville. These are these in-between areas, and we have to decide how we're efficiently going to split this area. you this is something that's usually not easily agreed on given national standards with things have been working a municipal service does very well when it comes to depending on these private agencies or even hospital based entities to perform these duties it's becoming a national standard that it's just not working Waterville has gone that route many places in the state of Maine Rangely, Maine is actually in discussions right now of going back to where they were because of the situation that I described earlier where these ambulances go out on these transfers. A hospital-based service is going to do hospital-based transfers. So we end up in the same situation where Rockland is still calling for Rockport to come intercept them because they don't have an ambulance come do mutual aid northeast isn't available camden doesn't have a working unit right now union's on a call okay i guess we're calling warren now these are things that have happened and it's easy to look at a situation and say well could they wait a few more minutes in some cases yes in some cases yes in some cases absolutely not and i revert back to the fact that we at Rockport Fire Department provide paramedic level service on every single EMS call that we run. We staff a paramedic level unit, so our citizens are getting advanced life support. With that advanced life support, three of our paramedics have over 25 years' experience. The last one is also an RN, a registered nurse, and a firefighter. Many of our EMTs have experience in wilderness settings, full-time in other departments. and over 20 years experience in themselves so when you look at a bigger service such as a hospital-based service that pulls from many different areas you end up with a strange phenomenon and there are several things here that come into play a lot of times there's high turnover rates in EMS and that's something that has to be acknowledged what Rockport Fire Department has for it right now is a family unit of people that are content where they are and that have become acquainted not only with the geography of this area, but the citizens as well. We have many recurrent callers that have chronic medical conditions that we go to. It's a pleasing thing to see us walk through the door that means something to the person in trouble. It's easy to sit here and talk about how nice that is and how a person may feel at the same time when I walk into a patient that knows me and trusts me and they're having an active heart attack and my mere presence because they know me and trust me lowers their blood pressure thereby lowering their heart rate thereby lessening the damage on their myocardium reducing in effect the damage that the heart attack is causing and improving survivability of the patient these are things that have to be acknowledged with these larger services and other things like that you have to consider the fact that these people really don't know what they're going they have no connection to the town there is a bit of apathy that can form between patient and provider this can be detrimental in certain ways as i've just described furthermore when it comes to these larger turnover rates and these bigger systems many of these places simply just don't have the experience and when i say that rockport carries a paramedic on every truck as a paramedic i don't want to sound egoic when I say this, but there's a definitive line where medicine crosses when you become a paramedic. There are many things that are extraordinarily difficult to diagnose and treat. If misdiagnosed and mistreated, this ends up oftentimes in harm and or hopefully not but potentially death of the patient. This is where experience comes into play. Every paramedic that you have on a full-time basis has that experience. Several of us have done everything a paramedic can do more than once. Two of them are sitting right here in front of you. That carries its own weight. So the provider that's walked in and has seen this before is going to be much more efficient at patient care. I'm saying this because these are all the good things that Rockport has going for it with this department and they are extraordinarily well managed and the way chief peasley joe moore and other people have used their knowledge of the area and what the people have requested to cultivate this system specifically tailor-made to rockport as far as our total calls from 25 to 26 they're on an uptrend that's not an uncommon thing they're on an uptrend everywhere population is growing, population is aging. Well with more people and a higher age range, you're going to have more medical problems and more emergencies. We were at 584 last year. We're sitting at 523 right now and that just went up to 525 today. We're looking to beat last year's call numbers. Transports last year were 282. This year we're already at 339. Our non-transports were 302 last year. They've dropped to 182. That's significant, and I'll get into that in a little bit. Total bills last year was 282. This year sitting at 339. Last year, inter-facility transfers were at 13. This year, they're at 14 already, and we're only at the beginning of November. So we're looking to beat that number we already have. Our average response times have increased. That is partially due to construction concerns and things that have been going on this year. Meadow Row is being closed down. We also have construction on Commercial Street right now. There are many factors at play, but I will state, once again, I will reiterate that 7.28 minutes is well under the 11-minute standard that is the gold standard for the state of Maine, oftentimes exceeding 18 to even 30 minutes. That's just something we're not having to deal with. That's not a problem that Rockport has to concern itself with. Our mutual aid provided. This goes back to the topic I was talking about, to where we need to exercise great discretion when it talks in talks of spreading ourselves out. Last year we did 29 mutual aid calls. This year we're already at 43. The year's not over yet. That's a near doubling of mutual aid. That's other towns saying we can't handle this. Please come help. Rockport hasn't had that problem, generally speaking. Rockport's not the place that says we can't handle this. Please come help. Could it happen? Yes, but many times when our providers that live in Union and Appleton, Joe Moore and I and myself have responded on a call off duty to pull the second ambulance to a multiple we'll call her pile up on route 17. So our providers do come in when we see that our ambulance is out and Rockport needs another ambulance. So that standard is being exceeded for us. 43 mutual aids. That's Union. That's Rockland. That's Camden. I went to Camden the other night. Below you'll see our BLS rates and what we charge. Now our charging, this is a department specific number that you can look at for each one of these items as we go down these numbers. This was crafted based on comparative analysis of other billing rates of our surrounding EMS agencies and municipalities for what was the general rate of pay and bill out for the citizens of Knox County, Maine. And that was based on demographics, per capita incomes, all that. The billing rates are not the same for Franklin County as they are for Knox County, nor are they for Cumberland County, Washington County, rural places you don't even want to know. Below that you'll see a layout of our large items that we carry. There's many things that an ambulance has to be stocked with. But you'll see that we have our Horton Rescue, our power load stretcher lifts. Those stretchers that we have are a definite price point to be considered, however, they're they're also proven to reduce provider injury. Joe and I remember the days when you had to lift a patient and turn to place them in an ambulance and back injuries was the number one thing that took an experienced provider out of the game. We have to have our cardiac monitors. A monitor is what makes a paramedic a paramedic. That's where we do most of our shining. That's our ability to treat, shock, defibrillate and diagnose cardiac dysrhythmias. Our Lucas CPR devices, which are tremendous life-saving devices. devices. We have one on each ambulances, one on each ambulance. Most departments are lucky to even have one. Our Sapphire IV pumps for advanced life support medications that have to be pumped in. They can't be run in by hand. They must be done by pump. That's a state mandated thing. Our stair chairs in Rockport, we have a lot of people with stairs in their house and this is the way where we safely extricate them from their house. So they're They're basically a stretcher that's turned into a chair and help us move people. So those are our biggest items that we have on the truck. Anything else that needs to be referenced would be Band-Aids, IV needles, standard stuff. And next to that is a list of our full-time staffing, five firefighting EMTs and drivers sitting at eight right now. If you continue to the next page, you'll see our standard rates that I had our billing agency pull up for us. insurance. We work closely with a third-party billing agency. This insures no problems against certain things like insurance fraud. Comstar out of Massachusetts Ambulance Building, this is a standard across the country. Many people use them. And what we have here are your Medicare and your Medicaid rates of what we get, what Medicare and Medicaid or in our state, Maincare, will pay us for a transfer. With our elderly population, Medicare is a big thing. Our Medicaid bill outs in Rockport are not as high as other areas. We're fortunate in this town where we do bill with a lot of private insurance, Anthem, Blue Cross, Blue Shield, things like that. Those numbers are on file at Comstar as well. And then our final list is our inter-facility transfers and the numbers accrued from that. For your review, where we go, where we've dropped them off from, you'll see a lot of these are from Penn Bay to another place or other places needing to go to Penn Bay. Once again, I will reiterate that all these transfers that you're going to see here are local and can be turned around in about 20 minutes from pickup to drop off. And we only do that with a secondary crew. It is our hopes that with a secondary ambulance that is more dependable than the one we're running right now, with that new paramedic inter-facility transfer license that we just accrued this year that we can start serving penn bay on a higher level when it comes to helping them move patients this is a specific request that was brought to my attention by the doctors at penn bay medical center mind you basically stating that the services that we have with our local transfer agencies that are also available for ems calls emergency calls, they're simply not able to keep up and they need more paramedic transfers for areas such as Maine Health down in Portland, sometimes even Boston Bank or even Central Maine Medical Center. So with a more dependable ambulance, we can start doing more of that and helping Penn Bay lighten its load so that when we roll in with a patient, the nurses aren't overwhelmed at Penn Bay. Anyway, we have finite staffing in the state of Maine, no matter how you look at it. In this area particularly, we're doing quite well. That doesn't mean we don't have our struggles. Everything that we're doing is not only to serve the townspeople of Rockport as an EMS service, but to also serve their hospital in delivering better and efficient patient care. As it stands right now, this department is upholding a gold standard on state, local, and national levels, and exceeding that standard on all points, with absolutely no complaints from the citizens or the people that we've transported thus far. So does anyone have any questions for me regarding any of the topics that we've gone through thus far? [40:21] Speaker G (unidentified): Chair Greg Musil. Go ahead, Bill. What would the cost of a new vehicle be to do these transfers? [40:30] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, it's currently in the budget. Well, we proposed it into the budget between $400,000 and $450,000. [40:37] Speaker F (unidentified): Standard cost for a new ambulance. I [40:42] Speaker H (unidentified): just real quick if I could the reason we went over all this is many budget committee meetings many of you brought up questions comments in reference to numbers statistics and what we should do so we've been putting all this together to kind of answer all those statements comments about us going to other towns doing other things so that's the reason I had Corey go in depth on every bit of this to kind of go over what you've been mentioning over the last several one. [41:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Go ahead Bill. Sorry. Can you hear me? Can you hear me? I'm saying there's no question we have the crumb to the crumb of service from the ambulance service. Everything you've presented here tonight is fantastic and great again for the people in Rockport. As you can guess of our budget committee and what we have to look at again the taxes in this town. We look at going like increase of a million dollars over the last four years for EMS is a major concern is how can we maybe get those again expenses reduced so I mean as the discussions we've had on the committee and so forth on how could you sell your services to other towns without again diminishing the service you're going to provide to the residents [41:57] Speaker E (unidentified): in Rockwood so if I can answer that question first that's exactly what got us in the circumstance of having to pursue our own ambulance service in the first place is the provider that we had contracted with that promised and provided services to the citizens of Rockport failed to deliver we're talking about Northeast yes I know that but what I'm explaining is that if we were to try to pursue contracts with other towns more transfers that took the asset that has been paid for by the citizens of the town of Rockport that's expected by the citizens of the town of Rockport out of service more often to try to offset the budget for a 9-1-1 service then we're going to be right back in the same circumstance with people upset myself in particular because i darkened chief peasley's door for quite a few years before this started to gain any traction because sitting in this room i'm probably one of the most experienced people that is aware of how that service wasn't rendered appropriately what the town should have what i expected as a professional for my family when i'm not here and if we continue to pursue those types of ideas simply the idea of offsetting a budget it's we're going to be right back in the same circumstance the bottom line for a 9-1-1 ambulance service is that it's an insurance policy we're not going to make money on this we're not going to come close to breaking even we had that discussion multiple times when we had multiple meetings in presenting this to the town and moving this forward I appreciate that this is that this is the committee's concern but ultimately this is this is the cost of doing this business and providing the service to the to the community any less of a cost or any attempt to try to spread it too thin and we're gonna be right [43:46] Speaker A (unidentified): back where we started three years ago but you what would be the problem with having Camden in Rockport at one email service I mean you were you here we had at Camden First Aid 30 years ago. [43:58] Speaker E (unidentified): I worked full-time at Camden First Aid. [43:59] Speaker A (unidentified): And everybody seemed to be happy with Camden First Aid. [44:04] Speaker E (unidentified): There were a multitude of things that led to the failure of Camden First Aid. One thing definitely that still is an issue is reimbursement rates. Services can bill whatever they want for the services. We're billing for the cost of what it takes to provide the service. We're not getting dollar for dollar back on that. It's me. It's never going to happen not from the insurance companies not from the federal government not from the state Attempting to work with it with another community not just Camden, but teaming with any other community The there are multiple hurdles to overcome there They're certainly not simple and they're they're not they're not a cost savings in the early stages of it at all What are you referring to so that would be more staffing that would be more ambulances? because if we are if we're going to if we were going to combine 9-1-1 services then you have to figure out the way to handle the call volume for the town [45:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Rockport town of Camden there's anyone ever done a survey of what it would take [45:10] Speaker H (unidentified): for yes there have been multiple we presented to who presented to the select boards and Budget Committee several years back on what Rockland Camden and Rockport all together what it would cost to operate and it was more [45:25] Speaker A (unidentified): more expensive okay I'm just talking about what if you did just Camden if we [45:28] Speaker H (unidentified): consolidate with Camden tomorrow morning and started 9-1-1 EMS our budget is not going to change we still have to have the same staffing level you still have to have the same number of ambulances and equipment everybody keeps talking regionalization is going to save us money but you know the Budget Committee wanted a regionalization committee put together there's only three people on this committee and some of them that are leaving now are the ones that are pushing for this and yet there's not a single person lined up at this door to join. You have Joe Moore, you have Craig and one of Craig's clients. That's it out of 3,700 people. [46:11] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm just I mean I never remember a survey going out to the people. I'm just saying I never remember a survey going out to the people in Rockport and saying would you like to have a separate service and pay [46:23] Speaker H (unidentified): a million dollars more in the budget. Then you were not paying attention [46:26] Speaker A (unidentified): because there was no there was no hearing on the EMS yes in this in this [46:35] Speaker H (unidentified): room if I'm there it was in the library across the street okay multiple meetings it was on websites it was everywhere and I stand corrected people [46:42] Speaker A (unidentified): chose not to watch they didn't want to watch yeah why you didn't watch I didn't why no cuz I was not aware of the meeting they were posted everywhere for The way the town voted on this, they voted as part of a budget, right? Correct. It was not a separate item. It was just put in a million dollars into the town budget, and nobody ever had a hearing where they said, let's have a separate referendum for using this service. That's not correct at all. [47:10] Speaker E (unidentified): As a taxpayer in this town who is not employed by the – I don't pay my mortgage from working for the – [47:17] Speaker A (unidentified): It was a separate referendum, just like the sewer issue? No. [47:21] Speaker E (unidentified): It was an increase in the department budget. To provide a service that was not, that was not simply part of the budget that year. That had been a discussion that had come for nearly a year and a half prior October of 2023. I finally, I finally got my wish because I've been, as I said, I darkened his door several times, knowing the issues that were going on with the town, knowing the service that wasn't being provided. I got pretty vocal. local I got pretty tired of hearing it happen so October of 2023 I met with Chief Peasley he asked if I was able to help them do this that's when it started we had an initial discussion with the town of Camden with the two town managers of the two fire chiefs that was in October of 2023 and the plan was to move forward together because the contract increase of more than a hundred percent increase was going to go from 109,000 for the four towns to 253,000 for the total service for the for the total service but once again that was mid contract it was minimal communication and it was absolutely zero increase in service or guarantee of an ambulance now you don't know [48:27] Speaker A (unidentified): those details obviously i just so right i just that's why i was asked i just remember the people in the town were asked to vote on a budget that's that's not a separate so we want a referendum that [48:39] Speaker E (unidentified): was it that was in 2024 though we started this discussion and started public discussions in 2023 there was a huge outcry from the towns of camden hope and lincolnville when we finally made that move because we they were they were going to have to pay more because we were stepping out of the contract i read about that right now all of that was happening at the same time frame it was all part of the same discussion and once again as a citizen i was pushing very hard for this because I knew what the right service should have been for the town of Rockport. [49:11] Speaker A (unidentified): What do you think the opportunities are for us to increase, again, the income from your service? I mean, I look at the budget numbers we approved last year. There's still a huge gap between what we had and what we spent. [49:26] Speaker E (unidentified): And there's always going to be. [49:27] Speaker A (unidentified): But there never was in the past. Because you weren't providing. All of a sudden, one year we flipped the switch. We said we're going to spend a million dollars because our service is so poor in this town, we can't do it the way we've done it for 20 years. Correct. [49:39] Speaker E (unidentified): Because it included increasing staffing, adding an ambulance, and it wasn't 20 years. We had a much better service with Camden First Aid than we ever got with North East I agree with you. [49:49] Speaker A (unidentified): I agree. I was here. So we weren't paying a million dollars either, not with inflation. [49:57] Speaker E (unidentified): This is the cost of providing this service to our citizens. it would it would be great if it was cheaper it would be great if we hit we could get more reimbursement it's just not though it is simply in within the system in the nation it's not the way that it works no one providing 9-1-1 [50:13] Speaker C (unidentified): services makes money almost all okay we got it okay thank you I got it just a second yeah I'm gonna tone it down a little bit because I first Thank You Bill Joe yep Thank You Joe great presentation great presentation it was you know we're not here to do that we're just all here for the same situation we're looking for you guys to help us and before I go there I look around the room and I want to thank the guys that are doing it seriously there's nobody here that doubts what you guys are doing for us nobody here and if they are then they better think about it because I see a lot of faces a lot of them I don't have names for but I know you guys have been around a long time and done a lot of stuff for this time we're looking for you guys to help us figure out how we can keep this and keep it for less if we can that's what that's what my objection here is so i'm going to continue on what we're going to really because we 're not going to get anywhere until we get this thing talked out a little bit and rich i hope i didn't come [51:27] Speaker A (unidentified): off as just being all negative i said you 're the criminal crime you are you've given them the best service we could ask for and that's why we're here we appreciate it and that's why we're here is [51:38] Speaker H (unidentified): my entire team our team watches all these meetings and we're hearing stuff from certain people that are inaccurate faults that are portraying in a different direction that [51:50] Speaker C (unidentified): we don't want what you've got it Jason but hold on I want to thank Bill because you speak for a lot of people Jason want to thank you but we don't do it intentionally when we get together here we talk you can see that the feeling of this meetings a lot different than when you sit there and watch it on TV yeah and [52:12] Speaker H (unidentified): and i get that but you know steve is one of them and then steve just gets up and leaves in the [52:17] Speaker C (unidentified): middle i don't think i need to call anybody out here i hope you're going to take the next level as well but i'm going to you shouldn't be then you've got the mic no you got the mic [52:26] Speaker A (unidentified): for a minute and then you're done okay thank you but i mean i go back to the same thing again the budget committee is looking after the taxpayers 100 and we got to challenge you to get your cost [52:39] Speaker H (unidentified): down and that's what we're doing unfortunately this is not a business where you can cut that's [52:42] Speaker E (unidentified): the problem i don't agree there but go ahead if you if you if you don't agree sir i would i would love to know who on the committee has 30 years of ems experience that has seen staffing levels change and drop significantly the fact that we were able to get the staff that we have with the experience that we have is stunning i work in the city of rockland last three guys that we've hired two of them didn't even have basic EMS licenses we had to put them through the program there is a difference between 9-1-1 service and in facility private transfer services there are two different animals the reason why costs initially were able to be so low for a service like Northeast and why came to the first aid during some of their earlier tenure was able to keep it low was because they subsidized that 9-1-1 service which makes no money it's a money loser it's an insurance policy you pay into it hope you don't have to use it kind of thing they subsidized that with nine with inter-facility transfers where they made a lot more money they also had to pay staff that could pay staff a lot less back then staff wages have increased staff availability has decreased reimbursement fees have our reimbursement costs have dropped significantly compared to the cost it takes to provide the service Northeast initially was a massive service across the state they were able to offer that for at $12,000 because they wanted into the transfer market in the area I was very adamant from the beginning offering to help with this that I didn't care about transfers there are two different things providing staff and providing equipment to do transfers detracts from being able to provide the 9-1-1 service [54:33] Speaker A (unidentified): and that's what's important to the town I'd love to do a survey of the townspeople just ask them would you be willing to have 15 minute wait time instead of a seven minute wait time for this much tax difference in your taxes each year no I'm not just asking I'd love to do a survey of the people in town [54:54] Speaker I (unidentified): I'd just like to ask a couple of practical questions, and then I'll hand it over to you. Yeah, sure. [55:00] Speaker C (unidentified): Hold on for a few seconds, Bill. Yep, I'm good. Go ahead, Sam, and then we've got Helen right after you. Okay. [55:09] Speaker I (unidentified): So you were discussing the original, and Jason shared with me that process about Camden and what happened there. so originally it was cost effective to combine with camden right because you had structured it in a way that camden so if we if we had the luxury of looking out five or ten years could we potentially make a plan that would affect our you know our children you know years from now i mean maybe we're not going to solve this in a year or two or five but is there a process that we can you know I know we can't do it tomorrow it's clear what's done is done but you know you originally looked at it as cost-effective so how can we look at that again in the long term potentially [55:56] Speaker E (unidentified): the first thing that it would take to make that work is for people being willing to work with us I know I know that's and I'm not gonna I'm not gonna I'm not gonna but take any further in that statement but it's impossible for us to make other communities work with us we really tried at the beginning it was it was initially the plan and then whatever switch flipped happened in december of 23 and we were either left to either continue to pay the exorbitant fees that we were going to pay for a service that may or may not show up or go it our own way and provide a service that we knew would [56:33] Speaker I (unidentified): be there for our citizens okay so that's my first question the second one is you know listening to the listening to the dispatch and hearing the kind of calls you guys get i noticed that there's a real difference between them it's pretty stark of you know like you mentioned like the stubbed toe or someone that has fallen that falls frequently and it's a it's a somebody that you're very familiar with those calls versus a cardiac arrest or a stroke with a second ambulance if you know it was restructured in a way that you could have those different tiers like how do you now differentiate those tiers and is there a way for that to be more cost effective so that we're not sending you know you know the entire cavalry when it's a stub-toe there all of those calls [57:25] Speaker E (unidentified): go through get prioritized through the dispatch center they have their they have their own process decreed by the state as to how they determine calls and how they code them and everything else we is the we is the 911 provider or any ambulance service that had that holds the primary 911 licensure for a community is bound to respond they do not they don't have the option to say no they don't have a call they don't have the option to make that wait if they do they could they could face some significant legal ramifications the city [57:57] Speaker H (unidentified): of rock special has a larger crew so if it is a stub-toe they can send an ambulance with just an advanced and not the paramedic right we only have two [58:06] Speaker I (unidentified): people we do not have that in how many staff does Rockland we have we have to [58:12] Speaker E (unidentified): five full five full-time members on a shift with a with an EMS person Monday through Friday seven to five so six during the daytime so we can staff two [58:21] Speaker I (unidentified): full ambulances right out the bat right up right so that's how many so we have eight full-time eight [58:27] Speaker E (unidentified): but that's spread across four shifts and you have how many we have four shifts as well but we have [58:32] Speaker I (unidentified): five per shift they have two they have 22. okay so 22 to nine 22 seems to be like where you can have that more it's not 22 every day though no i understand i understand i'm thinking in terms of budgets okay that's my where my brain is yeah and that's and the whole statement about [58:47] Speaker H (unidentified): if people are good with a 15 minute call but you can't pick and choose a 15 minute call if you're content with 15 minutes that's for your stubbed toe or it could be if you're not breathing i know but you don't get to pick and choose whether it's a fall or if someone's not breathing if you're content with 15 minutes then you're going to wait 15 minutes would you talk about [59:07] Speaker I (unidentified): how i'm sorry no it's okay so 22 so 22 people service how and what is your population that [59:14] Speaker E (unidentified): you're serving we're 8 000 8 000 nighttime population much more significant during the day to answer to go back to answer your question before it sure it is it is something that we could start to plan and work on for you know eight to ten years down the road but there's there's again having people that are willing to work with us is important of course but then it then it also becomes looking at things like the dispersal of call volumes where calls happen what time of day they happen how we need to manage that staffing and when you start to have more than one community making that decision or trying to chime in on how that's prioritized that gets sticky really fast when it's not a standalone agency that was that was the benefit that Camden first aid had that was the benefit the Northeast had that they used to their own advantage at times but people are gonna want the service that they feel that they need and so that needs to then get once again that needs to be a really coordinated effort between multiple communities if that's how it's gonna be it's that's gonna be staffing it's gonna be number of ambulances it's gonna be call breakdowns it's gonna be where stations are in relation to that because if we decided to combine with Camden tomorrow and we're gonna have two ambulances are we gonna have one there and one here so then if we have 24 hour staffing we need to have living quarters for those staff 24 hours a day that's all things that get into Department of Labor requirements and everything else it could be done we need people to work with us and we need to play a long -term. [1:00:54] Speaker C (unidentified): Helen, you're up. [1:00:56] Speaker I (unidentified): Over the years, there has been the issue of [1:01:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Quarry Hill calling to have people picked up. Are we still stuck with that? And the second part too, am I correct that say you go to an [1:01:12] Speaker I (unidentified): accident, but the person doesn't want to be transported to the hospital, [1:01:16] Speaker J (unidentified): do you get reimbursed for that call? [1:01:19] Speaker F (unidentified): so with patient refusals there's no reimbursement for that generally speaking there is recently changed i'm working with comstar right now where there can be a main care payout for certain people if there's a sign off so there's some revenue that can be generated there being that we're talking about numbers here i would like to kind of step back and also answer the question when you talk about quarry hill yes we still go to quarry hill we don't camden does but we still go to Quarry Hill, I've been there several times myself, because once again, mutual aid, other people need our help, an ambulance isn't there to run the call, so someone else has to go do it, which is what we fight so hard to try and prevent here in Rockport. Furthermore, when it comes to the inter-facility transfers, and another question that was proposed is like, what are we doing to try and help? When this service was started, we were strictly EMS. It wasn't until later in the game that we developed the protocol call and the policy and the procedure for how we were going to call people in to generate extra revenue with the interfacility transfers, which is why I've worked to also generate this new paramedic interfacility transfer, which can be, as I said, four to eight times more financially lucrative if we have the ability to actually do it with units and things like that. Being able to do a paramedic transfer to Maine Medical Center in Portland is a great way to move our department forward so we're we are still actively working on things when it comes to that as well that was all based on helping penn bay and cost effectiveness for the department [1:02:52] Speaker H (unidentified): but staffing is the number one staffing is the number one you have to have the staffing to do [1:02:56] Speaker F (unidentified): that with regionalization with spreading out as we've said before staffing's still going to have to be met which is the bulk of our budget anyway with any department that's the way it's going to be so we're going to need more people if we're going to spread out we can't do it with what we got so if we're going to spread out we're going to run more calls we're going to try to build more we're going to try to go out and regionalize this that and the other the elephant in the room is still the staffing and you're still going to have to get those people and you're not going to [1:03:24] Speaker H (unidentified): get those people unless you pay for them and i believe staffing is close to 80 percent of our [1:03:28] Speaker F (unidentified): budget 80 percent of our budget is where our staffing is so if we want to spread out put on a second union well then we're going to double our staffing and if we're going to regionalize [1:03:38] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't mean to be like that, but I can tell what's going to happen when it comes to 8 o'clock. They're going to all look at me, and they're going to say, it's time to adjourn. So hold on for a second. John, go ahead. [1:03:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I guess I'm kind of curious. If we didn't have political boundaries between towns and we didn't have all the personalities involved here, do you guys work with a formula of, like, how much coverage you need? based on is it based on population the geographic area a mix of the two is there a standard formula for you know how to write size EMS department yes [1:04:18] Speaker F (unidentified): there are formulas that are built what we did when this was starting joking [1:04:22] Speaker D (unidentified): before you give me the history of all this is there is a formula yes there is [1:04:28] Speaker E (unidentified): it's good it's called unit utilization hours all right and it's it's based off call volume population reimbursement models there's so we've gone through [1:04:39] Speaker D (unidentified): that exercise and that's how we arrived at where we are that 's where I'm going with my question yes is that a fair statement correct okay so if we add another whatever is the population of Camden that would alter the formula we would be able to pretty clearly see what that would look like and pencil it out right as far as we've done that have we ever done that it's as far as far as just as a theoretical exercise to once again there's there's lots of there's [1:05:14] Speaker E (unidentified): lots of conversations that have been had in the past a couple of them prior to prior to my time becoming involved with this I am I'm not sure I'm I'm honestly not sure I don't know if chief Peasley can speak to that I don't know if it got [1:05:28] Speaker D (unidentified): that far we never got that far okay well i think it would be worth an exercise at some point i [1:05:33] Speaker H (unidentified): don't know how complicated that is or how much i mean based on our call volume and theirs you would more than double what we have you would have at least two more ambulances as a minimum added on to cover both communities keep in mind they have all the nursing facilities the apartment complexes for the seniors i mean their call volume is you know two to three times what [1:05:56] Speaker D (unidentified): OURS IS NOT SUGGESTING THAT I KNOW THE ANSWER TO THE QUESTION I'M JUST I THINK IT WOULD BE WORTHWHILE FOR SOMEBODY AT SOME POINT TO KIND OF SIT DOWN AND PENCIL IT ALL OUT AND SO WE CAN ACTUALLY BE WORKING WITH REAL NUMBERS AS OPPOSED TO JUST YOU KNOW THROWING SOMETHING OUT THAT'S GENERALIZED [1:06:11] Speaker F (unidentified): AND KEEP IN MIND THAT FORMULA WOULD BE FLUID POPULATION OF MID-COAST SUMMER I UNDERSTAND IT'S [1:06:16] Speaker D (unidentified): EXTREMELY COMPLICATED SO THAT CHANGES EVERYTHING BUT WE JUST BE GOOD TO HAVE A BASELINE OF WHAT we're really working with and how the how that moves so that we can all understand that 's just that's all I'm suggesting I'm not drawing a conclusion with it I don't even know the history of time but I think that would be worthwhile the more informed you are so my next question is you mentioned just as a kind of a oh by the way we're gonna be putting a new ambulance request in so we have this we have a brand new ambulance yes we have a second ambulance that we bought for, if I'm recalling, it was around $80,000 or something? Oh, it was only $10,000. Where did I get the $80,000 from? I don't know. But anyway, so we paid $10,000 and we got kind of a clunker. [1:07:03] Speaker H (unidentified): It was, we got it originally to get us by until the original one was delivered. [1:07:09] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, all right. And so then we just have it as a kind of... [1:07:12] Speaker H (unidentified): It goes on, I think it was 26 different calls last year, above and beyond the first ambulance call that was out. [1:07:17] Speaker D (unidentified): So have we done Jason? I'm sure you're you know where I'm going with this on the new ambulance requests How do we have any way to calculate what the return on that investment is in terms of you know over time? And is there any way to even come close to? Assessing you know what the I mean, what's the life expectancy like five years to eight to twelve years? [1:07:40] Speaker H (unidentified): we're shooting for the 12 this one's 20 years old and it was in Linfield [1:07:46] Speaker D (unidentified): Linfield Mass for 350,000 that's the old one the new one I'm [1:07:54] Speaker H (unidentified): talking about I don't know how I mean I'm there may be a way to calculate that I don't I have no idea how we would do that there are a lot of factors [1:08:01] Speaker F (unidentified): remounts you can remount on a new chassis it saves you a lot of money you do that keeping a new secondary ambulance off the street as a primary rescue racks up [1:08:09] Speaker D (unidentified): it's complicated i know it's complicated i'm just saying you know if you're going to put i think i [1:08:14] Speaker C (unidentified): think what you're saying john and i and i got a follow-up of that question is if you buy the new ambulance yes or no are you are you proposing to do the inter paramedic facility yep doesn't that mean adding people i can no all you need is that's based off of our transfer policy we have now where we put a call in to the to the outside people that will come in to [1:08:42] Speaker F (unidentified): anyone off-duty that's willing to come in and sacrifice their time to come and do it then we'll come in and we'll do it we get calls almost weekly to go to [1:08:48] Speaker H (unidentified): Maine Med or further and we can't do it with the backup ambulance so do you guys [1:08:53] Speaker C (unidentified): feel like I'm just coming out and say do you think $100,000 is gonna bring you back $100,000 in a year or two years or three years for transferring people if [1:09:05] Speaker I (unidentified): If you can start going to Maine Med, for example. Yeah. [1:09:08] Speaker F (unidentified): Right. So is the potential there? Yes. Is anything in the field of emergency medicine ever guaranteed? [1:09:17] Speaker C (unidentified): No. No, but you guys have been this. Your knowledge is great. This is great. Great questions all the way around, and your knowledge is great. I think we're all picking up from it, and it's very helpful for me. I'm just thinking out loud. You know, I'm on the same floor that Bill is asking the same questions, you know, Walker's over here saying the same thing that I am, it's like, you just got to see some numbers. And I think running the scenario, okay, if you pick Monhegan to work with, what would the scenario look like, you know? And I think that you're going to have a better understanding from a committee, whether it's our committee or the select board, they're going to ask you the same questions. And I think, you know, we're good. I truly think that you we're very lucky to have you guys very lucky You know and very lucky to have the facilities that we have at the last meeting. We were brought into it was conversation that possibly Camden might be investing a lot of money and that they may want to Take that and put it towards what we could offer That's how you guys on the TV got us all thinking that we're out here are making all kinds of different cuts. We were not looking to do the cuts so much as we were looking to bring money in to subsidize what has already been spent. Did I say that right? Go for it for a second. [1:10:40] Speaker B (unidentified): First of all, thank you everyone for coming, for doing your jobs. I personally am very grateful having had Mr. Bonnevie here at our home once. You know, and I think, as Bill said well at the beginning, you know, we were a budget committee. We were just looking at the numbers, right, and how do we make the dollars and cents work. I think what I've been trying to figure out this whole time really is, you know, the eight full-time staff members, I think, you know, is really, it sounds to me, sized for, you know, 24-hour shifts, seven days a week. Like there's just a fixed amount you have to cover, right? Correct. So, you know, for a small town like ours, that means, you know, we're staffing not necessarily because we have this many residents, but because we have to provide coverage and we provide excellent coverage. So what I'm trying to figure out is really to John's, you know, point, he said very well about what's this formula and is there a sweet spot in terms of partnering with other towns? And I've got a few questions in that direction, you know, like I assume calls are not consistent throughout the day. I assume when people are awake that's probably when there's a little more calls or something But you know if you can get to a certain scale where you can staff more dynamically Is that a way to save costs like you know, and maybe it's not possible in a rural town I appreciate I appreciate you staffing more dynamically. So, you know, it's could you get to a place where? You know say from nine to five or whatever during the workday You have more staff on call because you know to service the larger call volume during the day And then you can scale down a little bit at night because you don't have as much call volume. Like, is that something that happens in larger areas? [1:12:25] Speaker F (unidentified): With greater staffing and more rigs in a more fluid system like Raleigh, North Carolina? Right. Absolutely. They're what they call float trucks that can go out, fly car medics, things like that. They can kind of bolster the system at peak hours as it stands in Rockport right now. It's just too unpredictable. predictable, and if you play that game and you end up with the pile up at 2 a.m. and you're staffed for 9 to 5, that's an ugly side of the coin. Right. [1:12:52] Speaker B (unidentified): I think my question is, obviously, and again, I recognize we can't, you know, budget committee, first of all, can't do anything, and we certainly don't know, you know, we can't, none of this can happen tomorrow or probably next year, but if we think, like Samantha was saying, you know, five years ahead. ahead, if we had Camden, Rockport, Rockland, a bunch of towns, then could we get more efficiencies from staffing more dynamically like that, or is that still too small of a population? [1:13:22] Speaker F (unidentified): Looking in the future, as Joe said, the conversations being had right now are certainly not a bad thing. I'll be the first one to admit that to anybody sitting here. So working towards a more regional system is something that can definitely be proposed in the future, but you have to have people willing to work with you, number one. There's tremendous amounts of studies. We have to integrate all this. I come from an area of the country where everything was a county-based system. It works well. We're not there at this moment in time, and there's no way we can make that work with the way things are set up right now. [1:13:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, and to be clear, nobody here wants to ask for the impossible. Maybe we have asked for it, but I don't think that was ever intended. but we're trying to think you know further ahead and I'm sure we all do a poor job of communicating it at times but that's our questions are mainly you know how can we how can we think further ahead so that you know maybe in five years you know all of the towns can have the excellent service you're providing at maybe a slightly lower cost per resident or even the same cost per resident but you know just a great service that works together so that's and that's where this you know as it starts with the towns I mean it [1:14:34] Speaker H (unidentified): really does it starts whether it's the town managers the select boards of the Budget Committee's meeting and agreeing to work together if people aren't going to agree to work together there's nothing I can do no it's about my pay grade your pig I mean that's the problem there's certainly that are set and what they're doing they don't want to change their boards have made that clear they're content so that's that's what people have to understand I mean we are currently working with Union now on purchasing for our medical supplies we work with the city of Rockland for the same thing we trade supplies we're training with Rockland again and a couple other departments Thursday night so there are certain towns that are all working together there's some that are not that's it's 100% out of my control I hear the personalities you can say what it is it's not the personalities it's the towns can choose to do what they [1:15:18] Speaker B (unidentified): want and some towns are choosing not to know totally understood I know that 's out of all of our hands I think what we as a committee would like to do and you could argue whether we're the right ones to do it or not is try to put get some of those numbers that so that we might make a better case to all the towns right camden included you know because i think you know we all realize that it does take all the towns but i don't think you know anybody's going to i think people want to be presented with a you know the better option and so i think that's what we're trying to draw out of all of these conversations more than anything [1:15:51] Speaker C (unidentified): And I want to follow that with, I personally believe that what you guys have done here tonight, as tense as it's made you or not as tense as you made you, it's going to make it a lot easier to walk down the street tomorrow and say, this is what we got. You know, you can see it. There's been hard questions asked, and that's what happened a month ago. And next month, it will happen again. but when it comes down to putting that budget through next year it's gonna be a heck of a lot easier to put it through after we've had these conversations and have that talk as you guys have got to offer for knowledge to be done and it won't be the question of did you do this you know we'll say yeah and as a committee that's really what we're just asking for and that's why I brought [1:16:38] Speaker H (unidentified): everybody in and we got as many numbers as the committee's asked for over time other than John's new one with another town but hey transfers you know the extra money I mean we put as much of the numbers together and brought everybody here so that if you have questions this is why we wanted to come [1:16:57] Speaker C (unidentified): in and done very well appreciate it I'm gonna ask I'm gonna go hold on a minute I'm gonna go out into the audience come on guys who are who out there what are we not touching on that you want to hear about please don't be intimidated if you're not Jason [1:17:17] Speaker J (unidentified): have [1:17:32] Speaker A (unidentified): you had any conversations with your counterpart in Camden no none at all they're [1:17:42] Speaker H (unidentified): under your contract with a private company so it's there's no working with the private company no but [1:17:49] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean just is Samantha said going down the road just to get the ball rolling you haven't talked to anybody in Camden you're they are they just present they [1:17:57] Speaker H (unidentified): have a five-year plan that they're hiring 18 or 16 forget about the points [1:18:02] Speaker A (unidentified): if you talk to anybody no you're kind of said about what about talking about no [1:18:07] Speaker H (unidentified): nothing there's nothing not at this time now would it be a good idea I don't see any benefit in it at this point now to talking no again from my from my role in this when [1:18:20] Speaker E (unidentified): i started again in october of 2023 the initial discussion was going to be camera rockport working together the divergence happened over the course of two weeks and one meeting that they presented about a ems and fire plan that we knew nothing about we had no idea about and when Chief Peasley asked what happened. He was simply told, hey, we're just not doing this. We're not working with you. We're going our own way. He actually asked for an email to confirm that phone conversation and he hasn't. [1:18:57] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, there are changes though in select boards each of the times and so forth. [1:19:01] Speaker H (unidentified): I understand. If some leadership doesn't change, then... [1:19:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Somebody has to step out and ask, that's all I'm saying. [1:19:08] Speaker H (unidentified): You can't sit here and say... And that's why we're working with all the other agencies around us. But not Camden. I got it. [1:19:13] Speaker J (unidentified): hold on guys Bob we have the talent in the room to achieve regionalization we certainly have the talent to provide the service that the town wants but if there's an issue with leadership and other communities well we have town managers to handle that get the town managers together get the leadership to get I don't care who it is hey you get the people together in the room the right people and start to address it when the town says I don't want to talk about it so we want to talk about you have to talk about it there's so much that could be provided you know we have excellent service not good it's not going to change always going to be excellent service so how can we do it on a regional basis how do we work with the other communities and bring them to the table this happened about it and nobody sitting at the table doesn't get the job done it may take a few years but you got to start the conversation if you If you can't start the conversation, get out of the way and bring in the people that can. Sit down at the table and start to talk. It can happen in so many, it happens so many places. I don't know why it can't happen here. I don't want to talk about it. It's garbage. Get up and make it happen. And I very much appreciate the people who have signed up for this regional nation task force. It's very important. it's going to pay dividends in a number of areas it did in the schools it can help so many places and there's so many models around the country that work can help so let's get moving on it stop talking thank you Bob anybody else out [1:20:51] Speaker C (unidentified): there in the audience before we come back in I thought I hit his hand up no I'm not about force that seriously thought you good questions stuff that it has to be talked about I'm gonna I'm gonna use an example that I used the other day I don't know if the regionalization is gonna it's not gonna happen tomorrow let's face it okay but I think the questions that are happening here are men a lot but I don't think there's a person in this room that a neighbor from over across by the bridge with the dump is it calls it's got a problem like they hit it to Searsmont Mill isn't gonna go help gives me freaking shivers i'll tell you so maybe we could do something before we get to that day that's that's what i'm asking for and i don't know if it's going to be on paper or it's going to be a handshake or what it's going to be but i'm going to give you five more minutes of this conversation because i really think it's been put out well and then i'm going to pull it together and i can hope that you guys will come back to our regular meeting because that's not as exciting but we do talk about regular stuff so one more time first for the audience and then I'm going to go around the board and then we'll we'll pull this one together for the night because when we feed this into chat GPT and set out the meetings for next month anybody else anybody else please maybe okay how about the boy John go ahead Walker I just had a couple you [1:22:45] Speaker B (unidentified): know I think as we've talked about I appreciate you answering the question we raised last meeting directly about is there a way to get more revenue in the near term you know which again you know it was just a question and it you gave a lot of good answers why that particular approach of you know going to hope or something is challenged are there you know inter-facility transfers sounds It sounds like another thing you're proposing as a way to get more revenue. Is this number here, the $7,000 sort of total payment, is that the total revenue we receive from inter? Correct. And do you think, I guess two questions. If we got another ambulance working, how much room is there to scale that up? Could it be a hundred, I think we asked that separately. And then what are the costs associated with these inter-facility transfers in terms of staff? [1:23:32] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, you're going to pay hourly for the people that are there at paramedic pay and at a fire fighter pay or a driver pay. So that's a cost consideration right there. However, like I said, it's sometimes four to tenfold pay as far as a BLS transfer for local to a paramedic inter-facility transfer out of town. This is why these other services lean towards these transfers for these certain things because it is so cost effective for them. if we can do it with a per diem crew we'll call them in if we're available it gets done provided we have an ambulance to do it right but to give you an exact number until we've actually started playing that game with pen bay i have nothing to reference for you [1:24:15] Speaker H (unidentified): it's too difficult you just don't know it's too unpredictable unless we could get crews to sign up how many like monday wednesday friday and let pen bay know we'll have a crew on call monday wednesday friday we could potentially get a large number of volume but then you have to commit [1:24:32] Speaker C (unidentified): people to be on call right payroll sure so how many does bay do a week oh i have no idea that's the question there's people down there that can tell you that there's ambulances coming from all [1:24:43] Speaker H (unidentified): over the state of maine to penn bay on it we see them by the fire station 10 15 times a day yeah [1:24:49] Speaker C (unidentified): so i would i would love to see that data to go along with the study that we're putting out here because i think that's something that would that would support more money for the program [1:24:58] Speaker F (unidentified): i can't give you a number but i have friends that i know personally that i work with that work for maine health which does the transfers from penn bay and they call their unit the meat grinder because they never stop running and that's why we're called because they're always out so my [1:25:15] Speaker C (unidentified): next question would be i'd like to see if you could reach out to those people that you just talked about and say who's interested in this it's not a commitment it's just who's interested in it you know maybe that maybe the guy wants to come in from Appleton you know and get away for the two nights or whatever he's got to do to do it but I think that would help support it as well [1:25:41] Speaker D (unidentified): okay I got a couple just a couple questions but before I say that I want TO COMMEND JASON YOU FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP IN THE DEPARTMENT CORY FOR YOUR GREAT PRESENTATION AND YOUR SERVICE AND ALSO JOE AND THE WHOLE GROUP IN HERE THERE'S NO QUESTION YOU GUYS ARE KNOCKING IT OUT OF THE PARK SO THANK YOU FOR THAT AND I DON'T WANT ANYTHING THAT WE ANY OF OUR QUESTIONS TO TAKE AWAY FROM YOUR COMPANY I DID WANT TO POINT OUT IT HAD BEEN MENTIONED [1:26:09] Speaker H (unidentified): THAT PEOPLE WANTED TO HEAR FROM SOMEBODY OTHER THAN ME THAT'S WHY I HAD THEM COME UP FIRST SO that you guys can hear from somebody who said that i don't know i've heard it kim raised her [1:26:19] Speaker D (unidentified): hand by the way anyway but i think we've there's a couple good questions i hope you think you can take away from tonight's discussion and keep exploring some options i drill down a little bit you have a in some of the data you provided you had mutual aid provided which is revenue coming in and we also have to request mutual aid from other towns how has that changed in the in the last couple years I think we are only at six [1:26:53] Speaker H (unidentified): I'll have to look at my note I think we've only requested at least I think it's only six or seven times in this calendar year yeah and so you don't know you don't know where to come I don't know the exact I can get it but it's [1:27:04] Speaker D (unidentified): it's very small yeah so it's that's that's not an issue it's at this [1:27:09] Speaker H (unidentified): this time but his point one car accident in Rockport and everybody seen our car accidents could get four ambulances from other towns that we're paying for okay [1:27:18] Speaker D (unidentified): and then the other question I had drilled down a little bit was you said we're well below national standard but you never mentioned what the national standard is for response time do you know national standard is about eight to [1:27:30] Speaker F (unidentified): nine minutes nationally okay we're sitting at six or seven between the two years seven point two right now this the average in the state of Maine is [1:27:38] Speaker D (unidentified): somewhere between 11 and 18 minutes okay yeah you did mention 11 but that's actually on the low end [1:27:43] Speaker F (unidentified): of what the standard that's on the low end in the state and the reason why the national average is far more prompt is because of areas like south central los angeles raleigh north carolina austin texas where they've got these massive systems sitting with an ambulance on every street corner and they're hyper responding yeah no these are very top tier systems seattle washington places like [1:28:03] Speaker D (unidentified): like that yep great well thanks again you guys thank you hold on for you guys run off i [1:28:10] Speaker C (unidentified): i might have some bashful people back there and if they are that's okay because [1:28:16] Speaker H (unidentified): my numbers in the book if you came to one of our fire department meetings it would be the polar opposite but so if i could just throw out real quick evan merrifield i just want to let you guys know joined us when he was 16 years old he was a junior firefighter he's been with us the entire time as a volunteer firefighter went into the military came back work for another private agency and Thursday he passed a 14-month walk along class and is now officially 100% a paramedic so I [1:28:49] Speaker J (unidentified): tried to speak earlier [1:28:50] Speaker C (unidentified): he wouldn't speak so but listen if you guys have other thoughts and questions and you don't want to bring it up tonight bring it up to me later if you want to or any one of the members i'm sure will listen okay and you don't have to sit home and brew we got to agree to disagree at the end of the night we're all doing the same thing here for the town of rockport and for the residents of the town of rockport and when they walk through the door like they did tonight and they decide who's going to do what that's what we're going to honor we're not here to make any of those other big changes bill now i just want to finish [1:29:25] Speaker A (unidentified): by just saying all with my starting comments that i said we appreciate everything you've done and we know you've got the creme de la creme service for Rockport we appreciate it appreciate that we're still trying to find out how we can get the cost reduced and I hope Jason that you'll look into what John is asking and just start looking at a model that we can look at as far as maybe reducing the cost for the services that you provide right now thank you look at you look at that [1:29:50] Speaker C (unidentified): model no you John singing do that model and it comes back and the model says you guys wasted my time. It's gonna fly. You guys aren't, nobody's gonna touch the Kremlins. I mean, you guys are good. Nobody wants anybody to go, believe me. Nobody does. And I truly mean that. I mean, I see you guys all the time doing what you do. And you're kind of like salary people. I know you're not getting paid for half of what you're doing. So, thank you. [1:30:20] Speaker D (unidentified): No? I think you covered it. Sam? [1:30:23] Speaker I (unidentified): I just I just want to kind of reiterate and I hope we're leaving on this note that we really are all trying to work together on this and I feel like particularly in the last couple weeks there's been a contentious feeling that like we are trying to cut the staff and that you guys have to have to prove your worth and as far as I'm concerned I think I speak for most people that is that is not the case that we absolutely recognize what you do and it is it's really it is not about trying to cut staff or and I just want to that's been raised several times of that staff are worried it is not it is certainly not my intention I can't speak for everybody but I think I speak for most that it is a matter of you know since I moved to Rockport my taxes have doubled i can i will probably not be able to afford to live in this town for much longer if it continues where the way it is and i think it's very telling that a lot of the staff don't live in rockport because it is a very expensive place to live and i don't want to live in a town that it's all third or fourth homes of people i want to live in town with people who have kids that go to school with my kid and so that 's where i'm coming from i think it's where a lot of us are coming from and we just have to find a place where we can where we can meet with this issue without it being you know and I think [1:31:55] Speaker C (unidentified): you're saying and I hope you're saying it's not just this staff it's the town staff that we're talking yeah it's the town staff and we've heard that we know [1:32:04] Speaker H (unidentified): that the comments haven't been made about cutting EMS staff it's maybe been others but so it's not I'm not saying that it was said about EMS and we [1:32:12] Speaker C (unidentified): We welcome, I welcome, truly welcome you guys. It's, you know, do I agree with them? I almost put myself on that TV and said something wrong. Do I agree totally? No. But do I have to disagree? For the moment, but I can let it go from there, you know. [1:32:29] Speaker B (unidentified): I think Rick's point is really a good one about please don't brood at home. We will say stupid things. We will say uninformed things. None of us are EMS experts. if you hear something that's annoying please reach out and with you know not adversarily we're not trying to be don't wait the month yeah don't let it you will try not to say stupid things actually that should make clear that's not our goal [1:32:55] Speaker G (unidentified): I want to echo what everyone else has said about what a great job you guys are doing and how comforting it is to know that you're there and that you're going to respond very quickly to our emergencies But I just want to clarify one thing, and I think it might help. If you thought about this as your money, you know, if this was your money and you didn't want to reduce the services at all, you didn't want to reduce the response time, and you acknowledge that this is not a money-making proposition, that there's a certain cost to having the quality of service that we have. have. But then now this new idea about transfers, you know, going into the transfer business and using that to generate money, is knowing the cost of the ambulance that it would take to do that, knowing the cost of the personnel it would take to do that, do you think that's something that you would put your money on? Or do you think it's too risky? Or what do [1:33:58] Speaker H (unidentified): do you think about that 's that's where all these private EMS companies make their money is only on transfer 9-1-1 is a 80% loss from the beginning that's why they all do transfers all what we hear continuously is we need to find more revenue we need to find more revenue thus the reason I don't know seven months ago we started doing transfers when staffs available so we're only doing it at a very minimal amount and it's looking lucrative to you i wouldn't say i mean [1:34:32] Speaker F (unidentified): lucrative i mean given our numbers right now we can't make that statement yeah and as far as you know the new ambulance if i had to look at it with it was my money i would also have to look at the side of the coin where i basically have another emergency response vehicle ready to go in the town as well for backup calls which we've had to run as well so that's an extra insurance policy furthermore having to plan for vehicular failures service maintenance and having to replace the primary ambulance in the first place anyway it may come a point where you're you may have to swap them around and make one a backup and make the back up the front line so in the long run it's actually better for the security of the department the safety of the providers the delivery of medical care on an emergent basis to the people the alleviation of the strain of Penn Bay Medical Center, which also benefits the people of Rockport and surrounding areas as well, which is a regional issue. And it also opens the opportunity to open that door to generate a little more revenue with certain types of transfers, which Penn Bay themselves, as I said in my presentation, the doctors at the ER were the ones that propositioned me to start moving towards this. [1:35:46] Speaker C (unidentified): Do they wanna buy the ambulance? [1:35:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, you'll have to talk to them about it. [1:35:50] Speaker H (unidentified): It's sarcastic. They have a whole bunch. Yeah. [1:35:52] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm just serious, because that's the question, you know, and that's what we're going to get asked. So thank you. We appreciate that. Absolutely. Anybody else? Thank you all. And don't feel like we've got to exit all at once. Thank you, guys. Okay. So let's move on to the meetings of the minute. [1:36:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Where's the agenda item to turn on the meeting? [1:36:31] Speaker C (unidentified): thank you guys so we're going to move to take a look at the minutes oh we got an incoming all right good oh thank you thank you i tried yeah are they are they called they call me from home you want to get a crowd Thank you, Jim. [1:36:59] Speaker A (unidentified): We still on? Yes. We're still on. [1:37:03] Speaker C (unidentified): It's a hot mic. It's a hot mic. Yeah, we're still on. So we're going to take a look at the minutes. I was trying to find them here. I had them right here a second ago. Looking for a motion to accept the minutes of the October 3rd meeting. [1:37:19] Speaker B (unidentified): I move to accept the minutes of the October 3rd meeting as presented. [1:37:23] Speaker C (unidentified): Second. Second. Okay. Got a second? Second. Okay. All in favor? I can't vote. [1:37:30] Speaker D (unidentified): Rockport Opera House. I forget that. Rockport Opera House guest, I think, or TOR public. [1:37:36] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. So I guess we're good with that one. [1:37:39] Speaker D (unidentified): Let's move on. We can go. Oh, that's it. I was going to say. [1:37:45] Speaker B (unidentified): One, two, three, four. I was going to say, we're dropping like flies around here. [1:37:50] Speaker I (unidentified): No, he went to the next one. [1:37:52] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. All right. well we'll hold on thank you gang yeah you gotta have a quorum so i didn't see him get up and go so [1:38:06] Speaker A (unidentified): what is next on the agenda well [1:38:11] Speaker C (unidentified): we've pretty much gone down to the discussion of the ems i feel request to change for the fy 2028 budget documents will be the next one on it and fy 28 budget goal and potential savings i'm be honest with you i'm not sure how far into that we want to get think you need a better committee that's what i'm thinking too i might we might we might amend the [1:38:40] Speaker A (unidentified): can we get a motion to adjourn without a quorum or not [1:38:46] Speaker C (unidentified): oh my god can't leave yeah we'll be right here until mr mitchell gets out of the bathroom what we'll do is we'll we'll get the minutes approved we hate to put this on you but we needed you to finish up the forum here so we've got a motion and we've accepted the motion to accept the minutes of the meeting of october 3rd all in favor october 6th yeah october 6th i'm sorry actually i can't vote [1:39:21] Speaker A (unidentified): because i wasn't here correct you can still vote you look at the minutes can he even [1:39:29] Speaker C (unidentified): if he's reviewed the minutes he can't vote but you can he can as long as we have a quorum he can still yeah I think that's true yeah we can still okay the minute so they can be out yes okay thank you and then and then what I guess I'm gonna look for is an agenda consideration change at this point where we'll move all the rest of the stuff on the agenda for a hold for next month but we do need to come up with a meeting for next month it's gonna work because you guys are gonna meet the night that we're gonna we would normally meet I believe yes it's our [1:40:07] Speaker D (unidentified): first meeting with Camden to talk about ideas for regional well sharing services yeah which was that December one yeah so and that's the Tuesday right yes I believe so yeah it's and just to kind of get everybody's expectations in the right place here it's being scheduled an hour before their normal select board meeting so it's it's going to be a pretty tight you guys just going to scratch the surface say hello which is great well we never know we might i'm going to be i'm going to be optimistic yeah you know try to be positive but i'll take any meeting we can get so it's one hour before [1:40:49] Speaker K (unidentified): their select board meeting yeah and they're going to be me are you guys meeting with me meeting over [1:40:54] Speaker A (unidentified): there and they could still have our meeting here then correct john or sam wouldn't be with us [1:40:59] Speaker K (unidentified): we could watch it that's a I mean well I thought this room was being occupied so we know potentially still have our meeting I think we could but I think it [1:41:07] Speaker C (unidentified): be asking a lot for these guys to run from there over to here why I watch it [1:41:12] Speaker D (unidentified): later I was thinking you guys might want to attend that meeting yeah so I was [1:41:17] Speaker C (unidentified): seeing it that do we have other dates December 2nd or 3rd that would work with [1:41:24] Speaker B (unidentified): anybody either the monday wednesday thursday works for me i'm good wednesday thursday so we gotta [1:41:32] Speaker C (unidentified): handle wednesday thursday i'm good you're good greg wednesday thursday doesn't matter so let's pull wednesday six o'clock six o'clock that's the second yes yeah so i sorry what was the date again rick wednesday at six o'clock december 2nd december 2nd okay right here [1:41:55] Speaker D (unidentified): and just to clarify as long as you have a quorum five members that's that's good you've got the quorum and you just need to have an affirmative vote of a majority of the members in attendance okay so that's what you had even if craig is abstained okay good open discussion [1:42:18] Speaker C (unidentified): bill we're going to keep you for last because we know how you motivate okay no you're good [1:42:24] Speaker I (unidentified): anybody have anything open i regret not asking someone from ems and i don't know if they would do it but to be on that regionalization committee joe is joe morrison oh joe is oh okay and this was joe right here yeah i didn't connect that name with the person okay yeah one [1:42:45] Speaker K (unidentified): One thing, if we're moving the bulk of our material from tonight to the next meeting, which would be a goal, what we'd like to see different on the book, it's getting really close to the book. So I would highly invite Megan to join us, where it would be such a quick turnaround. So if we can open the invitation to her, that would be great. [1:43:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Sure, absolutely. I'll reach out. John, can you do that? You and Sam? [1:43:13] Speaker D (unidentified): Yep, I will do that. [1:43:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. That would be good. Yeah. Okay. Any others? Anything, Bill? Me? No? Terry? No. Good. Anything from... You guys all good? All right. Looking for a motion to adjourn? Move to adjourn. Seconded? Second. All in favor? Aye. Thank you all very much. Thank you.