Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): reference oh yeah it's just a reference
[0:04] John DeLeo: okay i'll call the order of the city of elsa planning board meeting from november 4th 2026 board introduction basal the room member john galeo chair greek laws co-chair vice chair
[0:21] unknown: mike king member mark robain alternate yeah brittany merrill city planner robert green code officer don't scare the fire inspector Andrew letter load deputy code
[0:31] John DeLeo: officer item number two adoption of minutes from the October 7 2026 regular meeting additions deletions comments questions yes we've also included the
[0:45] Speaker A (unidentified): workshop minutes in that it's not just a regular meeting
[0:50] unknown: yes we will only vote on what's on the agenda and we can vote on it okay well i think all they do is this is the work this
[1:02] Speaker A (unidentified): is a workshop but it's part of it's part of the minutes there oh if i sign that i sign them both
[1:09] unknown: we can separate them out okay i can do that later
[1:15] Speaker A (unidentified): mine doesn't say draft on it this is an actual minutes those are your
[1:19] unknown: the blank copy is for you to sign after they've been adopted correct and the second page is the workshop information on the workshop oh the agenda for the no i think that's just setting up the workshop it's not the workshop itself yeah it is i was talking about scheduling a workshop from the last meeting is that all it is yeah i thought about the workshop okay we're good okay i stand corrected i have a question i don't know if i just don't read time well but executive The executive session started at 0937 and reconvened at 1419. That might have been... That sounds like a typo. It does, maybe. So we can fix that. Yeah, I don't think we were out for more than a few minutes. Yeah, it wasn't that long. So whatever time that was probably didn't go until whenever that is, 1400 hours. I think it was nine minutes into the meeting and then 14 minutes into the meeting we came back. Oh, maybe it's just worded differently. Yeah, I think it means a five-minute lapse. Yeah, so it just says that we reconvened at 1419. We can make that clearer. After 1419 minutes or something. Yeah, we can clarify. Otherwise, okay. Make that clearer. Is there a motion? So moved with the correction as noted. Second. All in favor?
[2:53] John DeLeo: Item number three, proposed amendments to Chapter 56 Unified Development Ordinance Article 8, section 806 campground performance standards and article 14 definitions proposed amendments intended to strengthen campground performance standards and update definitions for clarity and just a word of advice to the to the board this is our discussion there are any questions comments pertaining just to changes in the ordinance itself not to any specific projects or campgrounds or any specific locations just the ordinance that we worked on is that what you're talking about not as it applies to any campground correct
[3:48] unknown: snap oh are you saying do we have any questions about what we did i don't know i'm just saying
[3:54] John DeLeo: And we can't, in our discussion.
[3:58] unknown: We're talking about the audience. We cannot talk about the merits of any active planning board project at this meeting tonight due to.
[4:06] John DeLeo: Or any specific location. Okay.
[4:08] unknown: So just a caution there for.
[4:10] John DeLeo: Just what's in section 806, basically the revisions that staff has done to section 806.
[4:20] Speaker A (unidentified): I do, I do.
[4:24] unknown: I do have some comments about I know if it's about a specific project a specific planning board project you have to save those comments or questions for that when that project has been agended and noticed properly tonight we are talking about the chapter 56 article 8 section 806 campground performance standards and as they apply to the entire city or campgrounds in this case are rural and urban but you get
[4:57] Speaker A (unidentified): what i mean great so okay does not apply to any specific it just applies to 80610
[5:06] unknown: we are discussing the 806 can we discuss 80610 yeah we can discuss anything in 806 we cannot discuss project specifics or merits of the project that would impact your decision to approve or deny i a project right we are that's a different topic we are on let's talk ordinances and fun
[5:27] John DeLeo: ordinances correct so my concern brittany tells what we're dealing with let her go over the yeah
[5:37] unknown: we're going to do a quick summary you know basically what i presented in my memo we're here We have been tasked by council to look into the campground definition and performance standards of Section 806, particularly where campgrounds abut residential or other incompatible uses. We have workshopped this, both with the council and just as a planning board. and from those workshops you have the proposed changes in your packets so there should not be any surprises you start with the definition basically I'm gonna do like a high-level overview of the changes and we can go back specifically to each one if everyone has questions or something that they would like to revisit and then I'll go into next steps from there so basically the definition we talked about changing the number of sites to five or more sites we had a couple of red flags from both the lawyer and code officer about it why they would advise against that due to a regulatory gap so you'll see it in my red line draft it's changed back to the non red line draft this still has a five in there that was a clerical error so having the two in the non red line thing in there the five in the non red line one is an error we want to keep it at two sites or more. Oh, okay, gotcha. So because it was a two and a five. Okay. Yeah,. And you're saying it's a five once in a while. And I just missed it when I took off the, yeah. To two. Okay. Yeah. So did, you got to fix it down here as well? Yeah. Wherever it says. Oh, because you have two on here,, and five here. It's supposed to be two. Okay. So both of those will be two. So anywhere where it says five needs to be corrected. Two. And that's for legal? And that's, and we can go into that a little bit more later. I just you know it's one of the changes that we'll discuss also with the definition we changed it to align more with the state definition we decided after review and not to include breaking it out into subcategories basically to not needlessly complicate it. In 8064, we talked about adding a manager contact for a 24-hour manager phone number that if any time it changed would need to be updated with code. We also aligned that section so quiet hours would match the city noise ordinance for continuity. We also changed the generator language so that it was not specific to restrict the onboard RV generators that are quiet we also asked that the guests and vehicle numbers be put it put in that rules notice that we're asking if the developer to provide we opted not to I'm trying to follow along where you're at and it's hard because you're so I'm just looking at my memo okay just that I could give the sections right and this is just a quick okay so everyone was that about the number of vehicles as we asked that they put in the number of vehicles per site as a way of highlighting that right over trafficking parking and that will be included on a document that they, a post of rules that the developer will have to have on site along with the manager contact information and quiet hours. And then the biggest changes were in the buffer and screening section where we talked about increasing the buffer to 50 feet, providing screening that needs to be at least 80% opacity and all of these increased changes would apply only to boundary lines that abutted a property that had an existing residential dwelling and then just some language to help strengthen that part and then those are really the only significant changes that we made. We also did some cleanup of making sure that the ordinance was consistent by replacing park with campground so the language was the same and matched our definitions. So really those were oh and rubbish we did include animal proof containers in that requirement and those are all the substantive changes that we made the next steps I would like the board to review and make sure everyone's on the same page or you have questions on anything now would be the time to discuss so we can nail down what we want to propose to counsel if you want to propose it. So your options, as you can see on the last page of your memo, basically are to move to recommend, to move to recommend with changes, to not recommend, or to table. And if the board decides more work is needing to be done and you want to table it, we will schedule another planning board workshop to deliberate if this you decide to recommend to counsel or not recommend to counsel the draft ordinance or the draft ordinance that you just determined tonight will go to the December point the December council workshop and then based on what they discuss it will go on the December council meeting or they could kick it that's their decision so it could be january depends on how full they get but that is basically it in a nutshell so i would remind the board and the member of the guests that are
[12:22] John DeLeo: here that this is a recommendation of the city council it's up to the city council to decide whether they agree with our recommendation don't agree with the recommendation change it so regardless of what we pass on to the council, the council can change it. Okay, so if we said, yeah, okay, we agree with this, it doesn't necessarily mean that 's what's going to be accepted by the council. The council has to agree to accept the changes or the changes to go into effect. That's not up to us.
[13:00] unknown: Yeah, per our city charter ordinances, this is the normal process for any ordinance change. It goes to planning board to review, make their recommendations as the council relies on the planning board's technical experience and expertise. And then, you know, they recommend or not to council, and then council will deliberate and make their final decision on what to adopt. and sometimes it's yes sometimes it's a no this needs more work they'll give you a bit more direction sometimes they'll make their own changes and adopt it so it could be a short process or a long project process there's somewhere in between when we get to the two versus five I can talk more on that the two campsites as opposed to five if you want to we can start there you can start there if you want oh go ahead okay so it i wasn't at the last meeting i had another commitment i had to go to but i would have brought it up then having five campsites creates a regulatory gap where anyone who's a property owner is allowed to have a single campsite on their property that's main law you're allowed to have one if we then designate a campground as five or more locations anyone who could anyone could have two three or four and we have no performance standards for two for two to four campsites so that's why my recommendation after the last meeting was to from take it back from five down to two as we had it before and our attorneys also flagged that as an issue Do we know what other municipalities or whatever do, what number they use, two or five or three? I'm honestly not sure. A lot of them do five. Some I have seen two in other towns. So it doesn't provide any help. No, it doesn't. There's not a lot of examples. Okay. Questions from the board? Well, are we going to go through this one by one, or is that what you're asking now? Well we can either go one by one to make sure everyone's on the same page and just like check off Yes, we agree with this, you know and flag any other further discussion. You might want to have And we can start with definition Is everyone happy with the proposed? definition Any changes and further discussion? Is there any in the definition of campground towards the end, you talk about, well, right where the number of five or more is there, which is, I think, really two or more. It says, or two or more dwelling units. Is the use of the term dwelling units at all problematic? Because dwelling units, you know, have a definition in the code in general. And is this... Should it be a structure? Does this want to be, do you want to use the term dwelling units here? I don't know, personally, and I'm not sure I care very much, but it seems like it ought to be, you know, if what we're talking about fits into the term dwelling units, then that's fine. Otherwise, it should be somehow consistent with other uses. I'm going to pass that one to you from a code perspective. I'm thinking about it, yes, on the fly. I think this sounds like we're trying to distinguish between something like the glamp ground that we have, not that we can talk about specifically. No, I'm just talking about dwelling units because it could be a motel. Yeah, it could be. Yeah, we do have other type of... Well, for example, when we talk about motel or something, do we use the term dwelling units and those kinds of definitions? no those don't those don't generally speaking come to the level of a dwelling unit because dwelling units require cooking facilities bathing facilities and sleeping facilities but okay most the time motel there you have extended stay motels that do have all three of those but generally speaking motels don't have the three requirements of a dwelling unit but and also a size does a campground does a campground site have a have those things potentially yes I mean they may not have bathing it's they may not have a bathing facility it's right what if they just called it like sites units or cabins yeah like that get rid of the dwelling unit so it doesn't I guess it all yeah I'll see well I prefer not to see dwelling units there but you know so would pick a name of your choice so that's could we strike dwellings and just write units or would that let's see here i think that might be okay it's better than dwelling units yes well so as lisa said we could write sites dwell sites units or cabins i think that might circumvent the dwelling and that it would be it yeah i mean the thing is we do we use adus we use D use and you know they have they have a meaning right yeah I think take care of it yeah she 's she's made known something and I'll make sure the board gets copies of all the edits that we make tonight before it gets in the council oh I'll make sure everyone gets a copy of the changes to review before it goes to council okay so in case something gets mister yeah so if we if we make changes like this let's say there's ten of them and we vote on something tonight are we just assuming that you'll fix those ten things well we can use language that we've used before to you know pending all the changes that were discussed tonight as a condition or you can list out all the changes just specifically I would rather go with yeah and remember this is also just a recommendation yeah so yeah this isn't this isn't legally binding like a planning board approval for a project really yeah okay
[20:19] John DeLeo: so why don't we go down
[20:21] unknown: each section we're still talking about definitions yeah I'm just gonna state my concern overall I mean this definition is a viable definition but I still am of the opinion that they should be there should have been a split of the lesser impactful type sites versus impactful type sites I would have I would have liked to have seen us go in that direction so two or three different categories under at least two yeah again what is what is what is the prevailing you know experience out there in ground land it's typically a state definition does not differentiate the state does not differentiate smaller or larger they say anything with five units or more as a campground that's it if we did separate them out we would still have to review them on it with the same criteria so it feels like it would unnecessarily complicate it and given the demand if you were of campgrounds in the area is it worth it to spend you know count you know the time and effort to break out these categories potentially put it on the table of uses which is a citywide mailer you know and we could bump it in with others but it didn't seem like the benefits outweigh the with this would this tend to lead to other land uses being subdivided so what you're doing basically saying is camp runs one thing but we'd really like to have campground A, B, C, and D or whatever. So my question is, does that lead to any other uses in the ordinance that would be subdivided? Potentially. If we want to be having a consistent ordinance, which is what this comprehensive review is about, is to make sure language and the ordinance itself is consistent. Do we want to break out these things and is it worth it? Well, one of the reasons why I felt it was an important thought process is because the impact of, say, a campsite is so much less than the impact of a motorized-type site or a, you know, yurts and restaurant. You know, like, there's a much more impactful-type scenario versus a less. And when you put them all together and then you only have one set of standards for all of them you're actually putting a hardship on the ones with a lesser standard and putting not enough limitations on a higher standard in my opinion that was the reasoning for it and a lot of our standards do have levels if you are a built-in whereas something may not apply to one type of campground because it's not as impactful like septic systems that sort of thing so there is some leveling within the technical built-in technical review so I didn't just like to tease all that out and word do you guys have a feeling one way or the other about that I mean it sounded like you thought it should be something I 'm not sure that it needs to be honestly that a lot of that review comes down to what happens in the TRT meetings the standards that we've got necessary and there's enough flexibility to adapt you know our ordinances are flexible enough of the different projects that if one versus the other came through they're still going to go through that same level of review all these standards still apply okay so it's next question do we do we need to have like a mini you know mini thing here in some sort of vote that says we like that idea or not like that idea as we go through it's more of like are you do you find the current draft with whatever changes we discussed acceptable are you yeah but there's going to be there's going to be disagreement on this particular one there we can vote what's that we can vote if there's a majority that wants to revisit the gavel yeah it's you guys decision we're just here to inform well I think that if it's going to be one standard for everything then maybe some of those criteria that's not in the TRT such as buffer zones and things like that if there was so it's zones are in the TRT though no but I think the separation of this our standard here is one standard for all of them so maybe but the standards are had the definition one thing but then you have you're saying TRT has different standards but the rest of our ordinance doesn't have different standards we don't have different standards for TRT we know we review them to the standard to make sure that everything complies yeah we use the ordinance as our guide and we check but okay I just misunderstood what you said then I thought you said that during TRT would pick up like a lesser use versus a higher use like where it applies to certain like septic systems right exactly so what I'm saying is my concern is more about the buffering is probably the biggest one noise buffering things like that when they're all together you get one dimension we haven't separated out a dimension for maybe a lesser use versus a higher use that's where I was going with that well I would argue that for example noise is noise you know whether it comes from a individual residence or a motel room or a standalone cottage or what we're talking about that I'm talking about the screen a tent site and all i'm saying is that there's a whole bunch of things that make noise and we have a noise standard that shouldn't be exceeded right correct and we'll get to it in buffers too but we do want to recognize you know we can put in some layering in the ordinance and themselves so like in buffers we have it proposed that if it's next to a lot with an existing residence we increase the buffer so we could do you know changes like that I just don't the breaking it out in the definition doesn't it doesn't get anywhere as efficient I mean it seems like if you
[27:22] John DeLeo: have standards for a 50 site campground it'd be sufficient for a five site campground i mean yeah
[27:38] unknown: well i guess i guess regardless of if it was a two or two hundred site campground if you were if you were concerned about the buffering two sites could be just as much of a nuisance to an abutter is I agree but to tent sites versus to motorized sites could be different so the definition itself I don't have a problem with it's how it imparts once we get into the ordinance I think I think you have lots of standards that are for individual things like traffic type stuff and yeah we whatever yes you know those yes they aren't necessarily in 806 but they're in another part parts of the order I get that I get that part you know water facilities toilet facilities septic and all that and I think there's I think there's a problem with making a ordinance too fine right because we could really just go to town subdivision on down like I yeah I think it's okay
[28:44] John DeLeo: I think if we get into a different set of standards for a 10-site campground versus a 50-site campground, then you're going to get into an argument, well, why is it good for 10, but not 50 and vice versa? Oh, no, that's not what I said.
[28:59] unknown: I said low impact versus high impact, not numbers, like tent versus motor. Why are you bringing up tent versus motor? We're not glamping in everything else. you're bringing up certain ones when we're not supposed to bring up certain ones i didn't bring up anything i said you just said you just said two you said john two is our ordinance
[29:24] John DeLeo: this is a general consensus do we want to change any of the wording and the
[29:28] unknown: definition of the camera besides what was discussed with the taking out changing it from well i do have a different question okay yeah And that is, you know, you break out a whole bunch of different kinds of things in there, okay, but you don't, all I'm saying, all I'm asking actually is, you know, Airbnb type things are a separate category that we deal with. Should Airbnbs be listed in here somehow because they're kind of overnight sorts of things and, I mean, I don't know. you're you're open enough I didn't say I wanted to do so Airbnb's are they're not a commercial thing like a campground would be okay so and all the rest of these things that you do break out or list rather are correct so if there's two or more campsites it's a commercial it's a campground it's right so if we listed air B&B so if they had ten or twelve air B&Bs in a location that might be a commercial enterprise they might be lifting them on a site or but they're probably doing it under an LLC that's maybe a little different but generally those are those are drawing units okay so you're saying no yeah generally and also generally speaking you're not supposed to air B&B RV or a campsite or intent side of yours or whatever yeah okay stop now stop competition i
[31:12] John DeLeo: mean other than the typographical change i mean is there any substance of change that someone wants to make in the definition
[31:27] Speaker A (unidentified): we're just looking at the definition yeah and getting rid of the word dwelling
[31:34] unknown: right yeah and it's worth squaring away the number no I just wanted to pull and make sure everyone's happy with the edits and we're good to go yeah
[31:59] John DeLeo: you know say crown just go down through the different section numbers 806 one purpose and applicability any comments or questions about that the only change
[32:11] unknown: there was an addition of the word operation which we talked about you're welcome 806 to other to all campground on 806 dot 1 and welfare and shall apply to all campgrounds campground construction why is the word constructed in there because it was there originally okay let's get rid of it anyway well it's it's talking about constructing the campground because it's to all campgrounds in the city of Ellsworth that's the way we read as opposed to all campground construction in the city of Ellsworth I don't I just don't know why construction is in there yeah it was in there when they wrote it what's that because it was in there when they wrote it in 2012. yeah you're right grammatically
[33:08] John DeLeo: well yeah la-di-da well and actually you know go along with that i mean you're already in the first half of the section established standards for campground construction right
[33:19] unknown: so it should be for all campground construction operations and maintenance
[33:22] John DeLeo: so it just seems like campgrounds you could put a period at the end of welfare at the end of safety and welfare because you've already covered all this shall apply to campground construction on the first sounds in operation and blah
[33:39] unknown: blah yeah do that you
[33:48] John DeLeo: know six to all other codes apply you know six three date self -explanatory you know six for management there's several changes to that any comments or questions on that yeah
[34:13] unknown: do we need to say somewhere in there in that particular line or sentences or whatever refer to the camera operation of the commercial news I don't know exactly where you might fit it in I'm not sure whether it's useful to fit in but I agree with the question well I think I think just by default it's commercial use because no you're not there they're not they're not selling year-round dwelling units we can we struck dwellings from the definition yeah I think it wouldn't be used for residential okay so what you're basically saying yeah no I think it by default it's going to come okay I can 8065 [John DeLeo: occupancy no changes] wait a second okay you here you use owner and or coat caretaker other places you use manager and so forth we can I would sweep the whole thing and make sure that you're using these terms consistently you have a preference on caretaker or manager because they could I think manager might be better I tended to agree with that but I wanted to it must have gotten it wrong nobody's perfect well we already got owners slash whatever change can't take it because the thing is up web above here you talk about management and you have the owner or manager of the campground you know and so you start out using the term manager all I'm saying is make consistency which is the whole point of this review thank you [John DeLeo: general] design standards I have a question before we move sorry on 806 5 within the ordinance we talked about you know it's not going to be a permanent dwelling place it's it's it's I mean some of them could be year-round some of them could be short-term do we have any way to establish control whether a campground is offering permanent residency versus not like how will we control that within code and within the ordinance because it's I think also just like i said about the commercial versus residential i don't know that you could maybe they couldn't establish a residency because it's a campground i think the state has a definition for permanent yeah so if they're if they're there and i know for lodging it's if they're there more than 180 days it becomes a permanent thing and they and they actually lose their lodging license okay so as long as we have no campsite shall be used as a permanent dwelling place that kicks in the definition by the state which is 180
[37:22] John DeLeo: days you have them go back to the campground definition the conversation or indirect conversation for temporary occupancy right but what's the limit of
[37:33] unknown: that so that's that's 100 by state definition 180 days and that's what I want to make sure we're on board with that okay you
[37:50] John DeLeo: know six general design standards 806
[37:58] unknown: 7 location and size yeah at the last sentence in 806 dot 7 campground shall be located on a parcel not less than two acres in size do we need to reference a number of spaces there or a density because you say not less than two acres, but if you, know, it's a lot different if you put four sites there versus 50 sites there. Defaults to the state, they have, the state restricts size of campsites. They say each campsite has to be a minimum of 1,000 feet, if I'm not mistaken. So it defaults to the state. And we're, again, we don't want to restate state rules. No,, that's fine. So the density is managed. Okay, so they cover it, is what you're saying. yeah the state statutes should we have and i realize you don't want to be too redundant should you have a reference there in that particular instance it references it in above where it says like all applicables rules apply all other ways it's in there that basically said the state will supply the dhhs all programs yeah so it does say that okay yeah right we could we could go grab the exact you know title whatever but it those do change i guess i guess i when i registered that like well this is a little strange you know it doesn't have yeah other kinds of limits but in 8066 it does say the campground shall conform to the minimum requirements imposed under state licensing regulation so that's your state rules that okay that's that's physically close and that way if it ever changes letters or whatever we don't have to update it okay would five now that we're five not two like when we were two to two acres seem like a pretty good deal now that we're five would five fit on a two acre parcel or is two acres just not enough in general roll I'm not sure I don't know what the exact number is for minimum campsite is off the top of my head but that would all be taken care of it right yeah but by TRT we would use we'd see if they could fit that many yeah so that doesn't hurt us no you know
[40:39] John DeLeo: six a recreation area I'm gonna read this one I got a question no less than 10% of the total developed area of any campground shall be devoted to common recreational areas with facilities such as playgrounds trails swimming pools or community buildings on suitable land for the stated purpose areas designated as vegetative buffers do not count towards the minimum recreation area i guess i would ask code how do you measure that 10 so if it's a
[41:09] unknown: two acres just use that because we've been talking about two acres at least ten percent of two acres would be a little over eight thousand well i understand that square math you know so you would have to do you'd have to do if they're going to have it if they're going to have a playground or a common area you'd have to see what the what it measured out to if they have a common building it would have to be as a certain size common building and that would be your 10% we'd have to do that we usually they do that sort of thing on the application because yes assume assuming they it's always possible if they represent themselves but assuming they've hired a representative who was familiar with the process generally they go through all these bullet points and prepare the site plan to those bullet points so they would presumably have their 10% of common land built in I can't say that 's always been the case for every developer every developer yeah but it is something that we do check we do check as part of our process because it's an ordinance is there any way to I know I asked this one before we were talking about general things to add to planning board ordinances not so much just campground but on site plans when they're required to do something like recreational or you know open areas we've never really had specific where they have to tell us what it's going to be sort of like there's just an area and marked off on the plan and my question before was and still is couldn't we ask to have them specify what it's going to be so that it's clear on the plan so that 10 years from now when you're retired some of the girls comes in and says where's that playground you know it was supposed to be a playground it's no longer there it's just dirt so i just wonder since we're saying they have to dedicate ten percent can't we ask to have that specify i feel like that's a little asking a little much because the developer could change their mind i mean we give them the framework it has to be a recreational area we give a list of things that it should be but if something you know it's construction things happen a site plan though is supposed to tell us the intensity of what's going on and what is happening wouldn't just the delineation of that area this is the spot where something is going to be able to decide it's going to be a play and most of the time it's just a dirt most times they just say well it's just an open area yeah we've run into that in even in the whatever you don't call planning unit development but you'd call it something else where the plan unit development or the open space the common open space which is part of that thing is way the hell over here someplace and all the houses are over here well clearly that open spaces I mean just it's just a number on a piece of paper yeah so I think showing it on a site plan at least the space is so and I don't disagree with you on that but getting back to more exactly what you're talking about so after a plan is approved it's on the code office myself to determine the plan is done before we give a certificate of site compliance and generally they have to tick off all the boxes and that would include that comment there it's just what I said I don't give it until they've actually determined what it is I wouldn't have to give a site compliance if they say well here's the area but there's nothing there just open it would be up to my determination if that's sufficient or not okay i would i would just prefer that it specify what the intention is it going to be a swimming pool or is it going to be a playground or is it going to be dirt i would prefer that get that phrase like with as much detail as possible or something like that i mean that's the only thing that or intended you intended what their what their planned event i mean people come back to you all the time and say they want to you know change something a little bit so my only pushback exactly so if they say well this is gonna be a swimming pool and then they decide they can't afford a swimming pool and they want to make it a picnic area with benches and tables then they have to technically have to come back before the board and get that approved and that's extra time and cost right but then we don't want the dirt to be 20 acres away that's pointless and that's part of the initial review process because 806
[46:17] John DeLeo: 9 landscaping somebody
[46:26] Speaker A (unidentified): else go first is 806 9 actually is 806 9 actually i would say expanded in 806 10 abc d and e because A, B, C, D, and E, I would assume, talks about the landscaping process.
[46:57] unknown: So landscaping applies to the site generally. Buffering is a little bit more specific. And the proposed buffering is more specific to boundaries that have the residential.
[47:08] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. That was just a question I had.
[47:10] unknown: And I will note that when we get to the review, when we get to the Phase 2 of our ordinance review, view to go through article six and seven with a site plan we plan on cleaning up the differences between landscaping and buffer because there's a little bit of cleaning up to do there so but that's a different project so we'll dive into that more later but it's it's minor stuff that doesn't impact this greatly [Speaker A (unidentified): sounds good] 8069 I got lots of comments as I did before the wooded areas an individual tree shall be preserved the word practical when we were talking about that at the workshop it was noted that they can pretty much do whatever they want there's no restriction on that I would personally prefer that would say shouldn't be removed unless necessary or you know that it's We want to preserve as many trees as possible on properties and not have them just clear because it's easier and cheaper to work the property. So that is something I have a concern of. I know we had talked about that and we're practical. That implies that it's practical, but it doesn't limit us. we can't stop them from doing anything they can just cut down whatever they want so I have a little concern with the wording on that maybe just not removed unless necessary or something like that then I have it says minimize glare when we had talked once before about that mobile home park standards say specifically that the glare has to be nothing you know lights pointed at adjacent properties no lights pointed at the sky and minimize glare doesn't really provide anything other than just a generality and doesn't really clarify exactly what we expect of them so how can we maybe work in a little more words to ensure that it's not just minimizing glare that there's absolutely doesn't someone get covered in our lighting thing I just want to make sure we get there and it's and it's clear because like I said mobile home standards it says it clearly separate I know that's a little redundant that one has a lot of redundancies yeah but and when it comes through with articles in six and seven it's addressed in that lighting which is more robust than this one pair and can you just, could you, like, give me a little info about what that says, and that way it will put it to rest. It's Article 6. Article 6. Or 7. I think they're pretty much the same. But a campground would go under Article 6 for site use. Yeah, I think I have it. And also the state is moving towards dark sky compliance, which are lighting standards. MS. You know, when we get to Phase 2, Article 6, we will also be touching on MS. Okay. MS. lighting. So we can get there. Article 6 says, all exterior lighting shall be designed to ensure safe movement of people with vehicles. Minimize adverse impact on neighboring properties and public ways. Lighting shall be arranged to reduce, minimize glare and reflection on adjacent properties. So that gets us there. And that solves that problem. MR. Yes. MS. And we'll be aligning that with the state's movement towards dark sky compliant plant lights when we get to that okay article in phase two so in reading that article you need to
[50:54] Speaker A (unidentified): understand that works both ways that light emission not only goes from and it says in neighboring properties so it not only goes from residential or from the campsite to the residential but it also goes from the residential to the sand campsite so if the residential unit has lights emitting or whatever that they're impacting the campsite then they're in violation as well correct okay that's what's good for one is good for the
[51:27] unknown: other yes okay that's what I needed to know kind of a general question we used and it comes up right here though we use shall a lot as opposed to should for example and shall presumes that to me that you can measure it and that you will be there you shall do this and you have to say okay here's I go here I go right I have to do that we can what you really want it should no must when we did the ordinance review earlier this year they changed shall to must in a lot of cases okay so what i was talking about shell versus should now you're talking about shell versus must yeah so that's what they told us during the review yeah so shall means that you will do it yeah you have to do it yeah what does it mean must is the same thing it's just it's just it's a little more modernized it's clear oh yeah okay yeah it's less offensive Okay. I can't tell you how many ordinances out there for very different things other than this, you use the word shall, and it is important, you know, in terms of, you know, anyway, it is.
[52:49] John DeLeo: Now, which dictionary does that matter?
[52:54] unknown: Oh, well, you know, there's a lot of them that go in the very front, and they tell you the differences This is between shall and should and must. We'll give it a shit. Top story. So when you go back, my question about practicable, about removing trees within that, same thing. Go back to six, and I think I even read this once before when we all started talking about all these different things. They do intersect, and it's hard because when it just says this, when you just read this, you don't always know the back story. And that's why I said campgrounds are not just this. right this is all these are just specific to campgrounds anytime a project comes through they have to if it's a particular one that has a has its own definition they have to follow all these rules plus everything else that generally applies right so in landscaping in chapter six which is the performance standards for everything landscape shall be preserved in its natural state insofar as practicable by minimizing tree and soil removal yada so it's spelled out clearly somewhere else but we're just mentioning it here yes because we don't want to restate things especially it's okay redundant enough as it is it's already long enough yeah so when we get to that section if they're gonna clean it up if
[54:14] John DeLeo: we ever get there okay you know 610 buffer strips and I'll just there's a lot of readiness but I'll just basically read the first section campground shall be designed to provide a vegetable vegetated buffer of at least 50 feet deep between the front boundary of the campground and campsite and 25 feet deep between campsites and the side and rear boundaries of the park and then there's
[54:41] unknown: a lot of red after that. Can we replace park with campground for consistency? Yeah. So
[54:51] John DeLeo: questions about or comments about the buffer strips? So
[55:01] Speaker A (unidentified): when you say 50 feet deep between the front boundary you're talking about the frontal boundary to the road? Yes. We'll do the road frontage. Okay. And 25 feet deep between campsites and any side property line. Okay. So we're talking, and I do have a question for you. You handed out this piece of paper.
[55:28] unknown: My planning board bite on buffers.
[55:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, well that's what I was looking at because I had a question for you. To get there last minute. and I may be incriminating myself here so residential use from the structure or a structure to the property line is how many feet in that in any in any situation it will depends on the zone okay and residential zone
[55:58] unknown: well they're all technically residential zones okay yeah you have to be a little more specific can you give me a number you know 15 to 20. yeah 15 to 20. yep okay well yeah if we had a downtown campground it would be zero but they're not
[56:10] Speaker A (unidentified): allowed there so it's anywhere from 15 to 20. let's say 15 yeah and then commercial use to the property line same 15 general setbacks there's no difference okay so it's 15 and 15 regardless that would be a 30 foot total so you 30 foot total so what we're looking at from the side of the campsite to any abutting property we're looking at approximately 35 feet of buffer space correct you've got 25 feet and then 15 on either side or whatever well don't confuse
[56:46] unknown: setback with buffer they're two different things the vegetated buffer could be within the setback
[56:51] Speaker A (unidentified): i was going to say the buffer could be part of the setback it would almost certainly be part of so if the buffer is measured from a setback then it's yes it actually added to the width of that entire section correct no we measure the property line
[57:09] unknown: so the setbacks are for structures yeah and a vegetated buffer wouldn't be considered a structure okay so you could you could put your budgeted buffer right up to the property line and that's what I'm saying so yeah so if you had a 25 foot buffer vegetated buffer yep there'd be 25 feet effectively of setback on the campground side and there'd be 15 to 20 feet of setback required for any other use on the other side whatever the abutting property was doing and that's up so that would effectively make a 40 to 50
[57:43] Speaker A (unidentified): okay so just looking at this and then the increased buffer on item a along any boundary that abuts a lot containing a dwelling existing or etc the buffer shall be at least 50 feet deep and then that includes the property line to the 50 feet back so we could we could be looking at a total of about 80 feet possibly or 75 something like that so personally let me finish so i feel that 's a little excessive the middle of october i did some measuring or just after our workshop i went and did some measuring this is for illustrative purposes only for myself south and i didn't really pass it out to anybody but the only two spots in ellsworth as far as streetwise this will give you an illustration as to how wide a buffer it could be at the high school crossing between where hammond lumber is and the duncan donuts that road is 62 feet wide. So if we're looking at 75 feet wide, we're looking at a buffer that's wider than that crossing on State Street. On the Bangor Road itself, the Bangor Road is only 24 feet wide. Now you've got two 8-foot bicycle lanes on it, so that's not even 75 feet. and then we look at the other one that I looked at was High Street High Street right there at Washington Street is 50 feet wide from curb to curb I think 50 feet is a little excessive for a buffer and it needs to be reduced to 25 because you still have a 15-foot property line that you have to maintain from the structure and i think you know the idea of having to plant trees in a 50 foot wide buffer like high street the whole length of it that's a lot of planting and then you have to make sure that you've got trees that are tall enough according to basically our lawyer that are tall enough so that if you have a second story house looking into the campsite that they can't see the campsite because now the 80 percent goes away so there is no 80 when you're looking from a second story window into the campground so the idea is you know i think 50 feet it needs to be a 25 foot buffer because as illustrations as the streets look you don't have 50 foot streets even in the city you could put you can put the bangor road up through a 50 foot buffer zone if you had to so the idea here is I think 25 feet is more than enough I don't think it needs to be any less than that because basically you're looking at anywhere from 30 feet 35 feet maybe 40 feet now with that being said there are some residences that have gotten waivers as far as how close they can build to property lines and i know that's that has happened but the norm is the 15 or 20 foot from the structure to the property line so i think i think 50 feet is a little excessive for a buffer especially for someone that's going to try to develop a you know five or six or seven foot seven site campsite and that 's a lot that's a lot and so i propose that would be changed from 50 to 25. okay looks like a little confusing here you
[1:01:53] John DeLeo: talk about 50 feet and 25 feet being 75 feet i guess i'm not catching where the extra 25 feet comes in i mean the buffer is right from the property line right correct to the campsite
[1:02:05] unknown: he's he's talking about the abutting property also has that same buffer it's the same setback so if it's a 15 or 20 foot setback on the abutting parcel they have to be 20 feet away 15 feet away from the property line and then this the campground would have a 50 foot vegetated buffer so that's effectively a 70 foot setback between our neighbor doesn't have to have
[1:02:29] Speaker A (unidentified): a vegetative buffer no they don't no but what i'm saying is that the setback can be considered a part a buffer and actually it is it's a buffer from a property owner i mean if the structures you wouldn't want me building my house right five feet away from yours so it's a buff it's a buffer setback yeah setback is basically like a buffer is dense but
[1:02:52] unknown: But that's to the structure, but that's to a structure, not to the property use. The property use could go up to the back fence where, you know, people may have swimming pools or playgrounds or trampolines at the fence line. That doesn't affect their – that can be within their setback. It's only structure. So you can only count from the property line to any new proposed use that's inconsistent or incompatible with the neighboring owner. To me, you shouldn't add those two together. The property owner has a right to use their property up to the property line.
[1:03:33] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't doubt that one bit, but they can... I'm not sure, is that true? true you can you can use that property the way you want to up to the property line see so if I wanted to build the garage to the property line no that would be a structure setbacks or structure setbacks so is not is not a
[1:03:58] unknown: pool a pool a pool would be included yeah a pool would be a structure a trampoline would not be included trampoline is not a dog house smaller than the size would not be included but including somebody else's required setback into a new proposed use which is a commercial type operation that is not usually anything that's considered in normal I'm not quite sure why we're
[1:04:24] John DeLeo: considering what the adjacent property owner does for his setback arguing
[1:04:31] unknown: What he's arguing, though, is that effectively that open space does provide some sort of buffer. It's just not the buffer, but a buffer thing, right? It's a distance. It's not opaque. It's not a sound barrier. It's not a light barrier. It's just land. It's just space. It may be. It depends on what that other property owner has done with it. But we can't presume it to be. We can't presume it to be. I'm not saying that we can.
[1:05:02] John DeLeo: Basically what we're boiling down to, I mean, if a campground went into the next-door neighbor, there was no next-door neighbor. We're talking about a 25-foot buffer versus a campground going into a location that has neighbors, and that would be a 50-foot buffer. Okay, so that's just basically. Okay, and it doesn't matter what the neighbor has for a buffer or what he has in the buffer. It's no concern of ours.
[1:05:30] unknown: And to address the other part that Mike said about needing the trees that are a certain height to screen from a second story, E does alternative buffering. You can also, you as the board, could approve some sort of fencing that could block that.
[1:05:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Approval what? A fencing. A pretty high fence. It would be.
[1:05:55] unknown: The second story is a recommendation. it's not specifically in here but it is something we should consider he just mentioned it in his letter to consider what do other folks out there and ordinance land say about buffers and buffering areas and with the buffering strips and so forth is there any like in regard to campgrounds or just in jar are in general you know if they require a buffer what do they require or you know usually it's a vegetative buffer like our ordinances specify I've seen when I was doing my campground research for other towns there were towns that proposed a 75 to 100 foot buffer which on the property line and we're so young and when they did that they're talking about from the property line to the edge of the development site or whatever yeah and we definitely didn't want to go that far with the buffers because we have a lot of skinny locks in Ellsworth especially in our residential areas so if we impose just 75 or 100 foot buffer that would render their lot use you know they wouldn't be able to put a campground there at all and it's like a taking which is illegal so we can't we thought So, yeah, I mean, did you keep track of, you know, what other people were calling a buffer and a buffer width? Not specific definitions, but I do have a tracker with, or an Excel spreadsheet with widths. And the state standard is 15 feet for a buffer. Fifteen? Fifteen feet. And a lot of people. And that's in addition to setback or not? No. They're different. Right. Setback. They overlap, I guess. you want to think about it that way we have state standard for buffers 15 so even so we're in excess of that is we are one by a bunch already yeah you're your own as it currently is in the ordinance we're almost double what the right state standard that sounds like that tends to be that's the kind of a theme of our ordinances we tend to be a little bit stricter from the state in areas like this so my two cents if you're done right you're done oh yeah sure I have another question oh go ahead no it's a different aspect of poverty so let's do this one first so my feelings which I make loud and clear is that I believe that all adjoining properties should have a 50 should be afforded a 50-foot boundary not just where there's an existing dwelling I stand by it I believe it's the right way to go and the reason I say that is a lot of reasons when we talk about the state minimum standards those are minimum standards and they're great for communities that have no standards like unorganized territories and small hamlets that's the minimum allowable this is Ellsworth we're a growing city we're supposed to be planning for our future and in my opinion 50 feet provides protection for all not just existing dwellings but any we had talked about the term incompatible uses it's not just dwellings there are other incompatible uses that don't really need to have the noise and the and the commotion of a campground or RV park in their backyard so I am 100% for a 50-foot minimum irregardless of their own setback requirements and by having a 50-foot buffer with dense vegetation you would remove the problem mostly of the attorneys question about the second story that would probably take away a lot more problems with the second story the longer you go out the higher you can go up and not see through it would take care of a lot of the noise issues it would take care of a lot of the lighting issues both ways because like John said it works both ways so this way the new use which comes in wouldn't be putting their light on anybody else and everybody else they're letting wouldn't come on them the 50-foot is it a buffer it's doing what it's doing it's separating two uses incompatible or not I just think 50 foot is the minimum and so to me it should be 50 foot across the board for a lot of different reasons you know and also one of the other things which we'll get to later another reason why is because of the campfire issue we have fire you know we have the fire department's going to be looking to make sure that they're safe and they're and they're being utilized correctly so they're not causing fires but the smoke is there and 50 foot just gives you that much distance between 50 foot is not very wide the width of the bangor road or an intersection to me is not very wide when you have a noisy potentially noisy hustling community right next door to you so that's my opinion so bottom line you say 50. not just for existing dwellings for all
[1:11:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So if we go with a 50, to go back to your comment earlier, what do you do with lesser use versus higher use? 50 feet for both?
[1:11:48] unknown: Without the split, that's when 50 comes in. If you had a split where you had tent sites, limited tent sites, which is a quieter use, it's not motorized vehicles probably you know just a tenting area you know platform tenting to me that's a lesser use and potentially that could have a lower standard of buffering yes but since we're not working with that we're working with one definition for all so to me you have to make the rules for the highest use not the lowest use if it was tenting by itself okay maybe 25 works but if you're saying a tent site is an RV site is a motorhome site then it should be the highest standard to protect everyone 50 feet minimum I'd like more but 50 is the minimum and what do we say right now we're proposing 50 based off of the conversation at the last work only for if there's an existing dwelling unit on the property also otherwise 25 if there's a vacant lot if there's a church if there's a daycare it could be anything if it's not a dwelling unit it's 25 feet I'm not happy with that I'm not satisfied I don't think that protects the community and I think it's going to leave a lot of room for nuisance phone calls to the police department angry abutters a lot of things 50 feet takes away a lot of the problems doesn't solve them all it just improves them and you think that the buffer should be there all along the boundary regardless of whether there's already in a budding building or whatever yes so if I had a long skinny parcel that went a thousand feet where all my stuff that I was actually proposing to build or use the developed area just the developed area okay just the developed area because you might own 2,000 acres but you're only developing 40 50 60 100 yes develop okay so what you're saying is that it's the developable area that you're developing the developer is developing right okay and that's independent of whether or not there's a building right across the line or not right just 50 feet make it simple 50 feet and if and if they own 2,000 acres of woods and they develop 50 this year and 50 next year and 50 next year then their buffering would be extended as they went well
[1:14:34] John DeLeo: any insight from staff as to why the difference between 50 with a dwelling and 25 it was more about
[1:14:44] unknown: a compromise as our existing buffer is 25 feet it's greater than the state standard and it seemed sufficient to protect neighbors and be reasonable for the developers so it's not a ton of extra cost you know basically to find that balance and then you know to help offer extra protections for neighbors the 50 foot would allow that and be a kind of a compromise and on top of that if it if it's a residential use that presumably you're going to if you were if you were living next to a campground you would be there in the evening you'd be there you know any time of the day you could potentially be there commercial uses technically I generally aren't open in the you know late at night they're not 24 hours they're not occupied all the time so having a different standard there you know it's defensible well we got rid of the wording you know incompatible use we had discussed that word at length where if it's an incompatible use they should all be offered most of the time more or protection. Like I said, it might not be a storage warehouse or a dwelling unit. It might be a restaurant, a school, a daycare center. There could be a lot of different uses. By only pinpointing dwelling, you're just pigeonholing. So as this ordinance moves forward, five years from now, six years from now, 20 years from now, if it's still in existence, we want to plan for the what-ifs, and that gets rid of the what-ifs, things we haven't thought of what if it's next to a daycare don't you want 50 feet so that you know so if you just make it 50 feet then it solves a lot of the potential problems in jumping ahead in terms of you're potentially putting a fence in the buffer area what are the limits of where the fence would need to go I think we put that in there that the fence should go on the inside oh yeah We're practical there was there was that I was thinking about the where I was before in terms of you know How far back in a long sitting property does the fence have to go you said the buffer? I mean we could even put it out that said if you had you know if you have more than a hundred feet of distance between the Developed area and if your land continues That area you maybe you don't have to do anything or maybe that's something we could offer a waiver if they asked like say if they had 2 000 acres they're only developing 50. that back part of the line they've got you know a thousand acres of trees who cares if there's a fence so we could offer a waiver if they wanted to for that area no sense spending money where it does nothing or if it's just dirt and if they expanded the campground then they would need to expand the buffer slash fence whatever right an expansion would come through as a new project right i'm sorry so an expansion would come through as a new project right process again any size expansion as long as if they were making a substantive change to the plan it has to get more approval okay so it's not like it's only I'm only put in one space there but presumably one space would be a substantive change they're adding space so yeah all right and I look at it also that if you have the you can always reduce a standard if there's extenuating circumstances but you can't increase them if they're not in your ordinance so if there was some compelling argument like we have in here that if there's some sort of you know a wetland area we have to say look it's just not going to work here and that's on us to figure that out but as a general rule leave it 50 if there's extenuating circumstances and if it's outside of the area of development then they don't have to do it there's always is the alternative buffer yeah so we're going to vote to leave at 50 or make well we do it what's
[1:19:09] John DeLeo: the so what's the consensus on i'll do it in two parts how deep should the buffer be between the campsite and the dwelling how many people agree that it should be 50. mark okay and not 50. 25 five okay we're going by consensus so we're gonna keep it at 50. now we have the other side the way it is right now would be 25 feet buffer if it's between the campsite and nothing vacant land yeah any other use any other use because it could be some other structure just
[1:20:02] unknown: not a commercial anything yeah institutional another campground like you never know and then there's the third caveat of incompatible so all incompatible or dwelling there's basically three
[1:20:15] John DeLeo: thoughts in my mind but then who decides what's incompatible yeah that 's that we
[1:20:22] unknown: talked about that it's subjective but it's the other thing that's why we that's why it was removed because it's a subjective thing i might find something incompatible but you may not we don't have a definition that would be right then you take the appeals board i guess and see what they think but i mean you could you could break it down to industrial commercial residential that you could go that way i guess but based on the table of uses right now it offers up everything pretty much well i mean you'd have to go by institutional i mean where you go were campground fit in that table but see that's why we're here is because it's in rural that was part of the whole thing because isn't it a commercial but this is the table this isn't about no yeah i'm not speaking to rural i'm speaking to the commercial use of rural that's how it's broken down that table is broken down in columns rural downtown this and then it's industrial commercial residential so campgrounds I believe is in the commercial aspect of that so that would be your incompatible use it would be hey we're doing commercial this is commercial so if it's next to commercial we're not buffering it anymore but if it's next to institutional really which is religious hospitals anything that's not in that commercial group you could do it that way that would kind of make the incompatible use kind of clear because you know that anything in that rural zone in the commercial side of it which I think is like timber farming like stuff like that you could say that does not need to be buffered that would be and then once you get out of that commercial zone you could say okay this is an incompatible use residential churches daycares etc then you yeah it's just it's very so it's residential lodging institutional social and public service facilities rural and recreational commercial industrial and then commercial oh that's it commercial and so commercial and industrial if we said who cares exactly that I have no problem with that so that would be bringing back in incompatible uses and differentiating them based on the breakdowns we already have in the table the campgrounds are under the residential lodging so that would be a residential lodging yeah so that would be a that's where the ordinance is lacking right so that's why residential use was that's why all just takes care of all of it that's that's what you're here to vote on if you would that's how it goes yes if the zoning clarified that this was basically a commercial operation and not a residential that would solve 99% of the problem. It's lodging, which is my definition of commercial use. But it's labeled, so that's why I vote for all.
[1:23:36] John DeLeo: I hate to ask this question, but if the campsites are adjacent to the subdivision, that not all the lots are built out, so you have a dwelling, a dwelling, empty lot, empty lot empty lot how do you maintain that 50-foot I
[1:24:04] unknown: would think you would call that a established subdivision project housing yeah regardless that it hasn't been built yet it's been planned out to the buffer would apply to that vacant lot but I think we would need wording for that right and that's why all fixes it because we have containing a dwelling existing which we talked about if it's a vacant piece of property somebody plans to build a house on we should afford them the same extended buffering I mean if it's in the
[1:24:41] John DeLeo: subdivision I mean I if it's an empty lot I think 25 feet is sufficient but if it borders a residential subdivision that you know it's not totally built out
[1:24:55] unknown: well that comes back to the idea that we get a long city parcel I mean all your development is at one end all your proposed development you know you're getting to a point where you would almost say put that buffer the whole way
[1:25:08] John DeLeo: along that undeveloped piece of land yeah I'm just I mean I'm just thinking know how you can award that to protect the vacant lot that may have a dwelling
[1:25:21] unknown: on it well you we can you know a pre-existing dwelling or against you know providing an approved subdivision than they are may not be I don't know how you'd reward that either I guess but you have to say it somehow we can do a little digging maybe get legal feedback just to get the wording right and then present it again okay just so it's you know yeah have a little bit more time to make it right okay so then the other so could we take it take a vote to see how many people would just vote 50 for all and then that takes away their need to do all that stuff if they made it 50 for all they don't have to worry about the wording of the dwelling unit existing subdivision potential incompatible 50 for all solves the problem I think you could work like pre-approved residential planning board yeah you could work there you could word that as a way that would that would that would remove the requirement for it to be a built-out law if you say if it's adjacent to if it abuts a previously approved residential
[1:26:40] John DeLeo: residential development and at the building point is the 50 foot buffer yes any type of building
[1:26:49] unknown: and the building permit has been pulled that would factor in as well yeah no but I was just thinking how if you wanted to keep the 25 foot for you know compatible uses if that's you know that's not the term you want to use anymore but I was just trying to think on the fly how you could word that to make it well if you did 50 foot for everything except for commercial and industrial pre-existing commercial and industrial uses then they're off the hook so if it was 50 foot for everything excluding existing commercial and industrial uses because there's no reason to have a buffer next to storage facility or a commercial industrial uses which are permitted in the rules up insert certain like well you said industrial was also a church or institutional so it's any commercial industrial so if you were going to build a campground next to something that was a gas station a tire shop who cares give them a great answer commercial uses that are a lot less offensive than gas station retire shops yeah I don't know what the use is so that's that's 50 take 50 takes care of everything but I would think that if somebody had a structure that maybe they could come to us and ask for a waiver from it cuz they're like you know the guy next door makes ten times more noise than I ever will because it's a gas station or a service shop can we waive the buffering we've waived offering issues before sure so it seems like if you go for all you can always give it out within reason then we don't have to pick pocket the details do you guys want to i guess work on that language and come bring it back or you guys are going to vote on the 50 like lisa wanted right well we did the 50 element for dwellings yeah so she's talking about wanting a vote for the 50 all around so you guys should probably just put that to a vote on amongst yourselves on with how you guys want to proceed or to look into it to
[1:29:09] John DeLeo: try to find a way to make it work for so okay so who would like the 50-foot buffer around the side and setback outside and back well yeah it's all around i think yeah 50 foot around the whole
[1:29:26] unknown: thing for all uses or just adjacent residential just oh we already did adjacent residential that's 50 so all takes care of anything else and we can always reduce it if needed can't go higher if we yeah I mean we've done the waivers I think you can well yeah what's the vote I mean I guess I would
[1:29:56] John DeLeo: depend on wording of the way but which
[1:30:01] unknown: we deal with often and you have you have the ability to do that in II I believe in internal alternate buffering where there are site constraints they do yeah but that first line is inclusive enough to almost slip anything in there yeah
[1:30:27] John DeLeo: so let's go back to who wants the 50 foot around the whole piece of property okay
[1:30:36] unknown: so what you were just saying just on top of that what you just said that it's in an e it says the planning board can approve alternate buffering or fencing where other site constraints make compliance with this section impractical so to me we could say it's next to a tire store it's it's redundancy to have them put 50 foot worth of buffering next to a tire store they're they're is there any situation where you're actually protecting the developer by requiring them to do a buffer like a tire store like you know right you could be because you want he wants ambiance he wants the good thing like I said we can always reduce it we can't increase it so if we make it 50 we have the authority as the Planning Board to change things based on the particular situation because like I said we don't know two years from now what situations we're going to be thrown so i guess we kind of like that actually with the caveat that you can gives you a lot of flexibility i'd like to see the writing i guess the intention is there but clarity so what we're saying here though he said 25 foot buffer strip is three rows of staggered evergreen trees and our trees are going to be between six and eight feet tall at least you don't think that's enough you think we need more than that is that what we're acting which we think should be more than that yes so it'd be what eight rows of trees we may have already existing a lot of vegetative buffering on their own they may just have to add to it have you ever seen more than three rows of eight high trees you know existing trees well we're gonna have them planted trees though right now they don't have to chop down the trees that are there so we want as many trees as possible right so let's say they have only 20 foot of trees existing they would have to add to that within the 50 feet so you got to add 30 more feet of trees potentially but all they have to do is come up with 80 percent opacity so if they already have 50 opacity they only have to increase the number of trees to meet the standard that the ceo would go inspect well and fencing really might be a better option fencing trees berms all kinds of things we can allow them who knows maybe there's a hill there and it solves half the problem for the buffering all you need is the distance then 50 feet so you're saying there's a fence that could be 50 feet that would be enough for you it's each individual situation that's what our job is to figure out what works it could be a combination of existing trees planted trees fencing berms whatever it takes but if they're going to plant buffers the standard across the state is three rows of pine trees six foot tall whatever i agree with you currently it's 25 and you want to make it 50 absolutely because it's not we don't like what we have now but let me ask you for e
[1:33:41] John DeLeo: the way i read that you could we could pass a waiver for the 50 foot it offer it to a dwelling correct am i reading that correct that is correct if
[1:33:55] unknown: psych constraints you deem them it's necessary yeah they come with a waiver
[1:34:02] Speaker A (unidentified): for this I don't even grant that can grant that waiver as long as it is equal
[1:34:11] unknown: equal to or greater than that required by subsections A through C. So, it's more of our, like, fence versus tree. I think a fence probably, if you have to do any great amount of 50-foot buffering, a fence will almost always be substantially cheaper, and they would probably come to you with that waiver every time for asking for a fence over. I mean, the maintenance alone, you know, on a whole bunch of trees.
[1:34:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you grant them an eight-foot fence?
[1:34:54] unknown: Technically, there's no limit on the height as long as it's not a spite fence. So they could have a 20-foot tall fence if that was what they needed. In E, it says six foot high. It has to be. I thought we were going to add minimum. Yeah. We can put that in. Yeah, that was, you had mentioned that before. Because six feet is the standard. Yeah. It has to be at least six feet tall.
[1:35:26] John DeLeo: So, I was saying, you know, before we decide this, I mean, I think we're making enough changes that we're going to have to come back to another meeting on this before we send this to the council. I mean, I think we're making enough changes just to get that out there.
[1:35:43] unknown: What does that do to your schedule or whatever, or is it okay? this is my life so I think we determined earlier today that the moratorium deadline is March so we need to get this hammered out by March we were hoping to be done in December but if that doesn't happen it's okay but the point is that there is sufficient time to do this so seeing this language really flushed out and talking about a little bit more it's not a huge hardship anywhere yeah
[1:36:17] John DeLeo: that right that's correct so I would say we consider me in there is we can waver the 50 foot buffer on the boundary that doesn't have any dwellings I think that serves our purpose my time shall we vote on a consensus whether we want to do a 50 foot all the way around sure 50 foot I'm keeping in mind that there is an alternative offering you could waver yeah I'm not sure I'd like to
[1:36:55] unknown: picture it all around but I like it I mean I'd like to 50 feet adjacent to residential uses. I have no problem with that. What about a daycare? What about a church? I don't like churches. I don't know. It's not just residences. But my concern would be with residential uses that are adjacent. And the rest are the rest. I would say right now, not all the way around, unless it's residential all the way around. I would agree with that.
[1:37:45] John DeLeo: Okay, so why don't we do a consensus vote? I mean, so the vote basically is 50 foot as applied in Section A, and then 25 feet other than A.
[1:38:02] unknown: Okay, so I think that's how we have it in there. And no ability to do incompatible use of other kinds that we may come up with. None of it. So if you have a daycare center, 25 feet. Right. Whereas if you had at least some terminology of an incompatible use, you could figure out a way to word it, we could make that determination. I think you tie that back to the table of uses. But that's the problem. The table of uses calls it all the same. Like it doesn't really clarify. If we can find a way, that would be good. and would you be agreeable that there may be some uses that we haven't thought about it could be it could be but we can you know give them a way or two right good we wanted to if there was good compelling argument [John DeLeo: 50 against] presidential uses and okay so I mean and the thing is we're gonna read this at the language so let's see what it looks like but for the record what is the vote on 50 all around I know Lisa's in favor of that what is the rest of the board on that okay that's what we're struggling with okay right this minute gotcha so like I said there could be three you know residential existing residential planned possibly incompatible or nothing so
[1:39:40] John DeLeo: there it's there's a myriad so i'm going to ask for a vote on what as on the paper in front of us that 50 foot on the side that a bunch of dwelling and 25 feet on anything else do you understand say it again that's right 50 feet 50 feet as in section a which is that on the sideline the side that adjacent to dwelling dwellings okay and 25 feet on non-dwellings right and as long as there's
[1:40:19] unknown: also language that gives us some flex and you want it in there that it's pre-approved like subdivisions and pre-approved well they keep up with some language right come up with some language and add that in because i you know i can imagine people playing games with subdivisions Yeah, I can certainly see you adding a, adding a, you know, like spiked, you know, blocks or something. Yeah, no, well, I see you adding a phrase in there, you know, including pre-approved subdivisions.
[1:40:52] John DeLeo: Yeah. Okay, so how do you want to vote? 50-foot on dwelling, 25-foot on everything else. All in favor of that?
[1:41:03] unknown: I'm not opposed to that. I guess I'd like more, but I'm not opposed to that. But I want more. And they have more tumors.
[1:41:12] John DeLeo: and so basically we keep it as is on the sheet right now do you want us to
[1:41:19] unknown: explore anything else if we're gonna meet again or are we happy with these changes to go to council well I mean I 'm okay with doing this some of this by email or whatever personally but that may or may not be but so you are gonna look into the subdivisions that's gonna be there so I think we'll need the
[1:41:49] John DeLeo: language on that I think there's just enough changes we're gonna have to come
[1:41:53] unknown: back for another meeting do you want me to throw my last couple things so we can at least have them like her look into it we talked about walking paths and wider four feet and we talked about what distance from the property line and I think in the conversation we had genuine see protected area yeah we talked about that the I said it should be not within the buffer but I think the conversation was it could be 25 feet within 25 feet or something like that because the four-foot trail walking trail to me should not be near the buff near the property line it should be inside a little bit inside at least well
[1:42:33] John DeLeo: Well, I think if you have that four-foot walking path and you're still achieving blocks 80%, what difference does it make?
[1:42:43] unknown: Well, you don't want it next to the adjoining property owner. It destroys their privacy. So that's why I think it was Andrew that said, how about just put it in the middle, like 25 feet or inside. I would like inside, but 25 feet would be at least a defining factor. I think inside's okay.
[1:43:00] John DeLeo: Could you put it at minimum 25 feet from the property lawn? Something like that? Sure. And my other question is, how do you measure that 80%?
[1:43:14] unknown: Opacity? Yeah. I'm honestly not sure, but we will find it out. Okay. Take his opacity meter. I don't know if they exist, but maybe. Are we pretty much done there? Yeah, and I guess the only other thing is for the fire guy, Thomas, with the issue of the, I guess, you know, you have fires, and I've seen some ordinances say that they have to have, like, smokeless fires or they've got to be in a, can you explain to me what it is that you guys require? it just says that you have to meet your approval what is it that they're going to be able to put at each of these campsites and how are they protected so that those there is a danger of fire expanding and then also what to do about the smoke what is your experience with smoke calls you know somebody thinks their house is on fire but it's really the campsite down the street so, we follow state law. The Forest Reindeer has a very strict size on what can be used for fire pits. As far as fires escaping from fire pits, that's a hard one to say because it can all go on to improper disposal. It can go on to somebody put something too big of a piece of a branch in there and it fell out, caught the grass on fire. Those are too many of the what-ifs. The only thing I can say is that we follow state rules and state law for what it says they're supposed to have and how they're supposed to have it. And then it's on the individual property owners themselves and the persons that start having the fires to maintain them in a safe and effective way. And you require any kind of fire suppressant nearby to help put out problems? No water, no hose, no nothing? so when they have their fire pits it's like you at your own house it's contained it's always good practice to have things next to you we're not going to say you need to have a fire extinguisher that's not going to go well for anybody that's now you just added a chemical inhalant into it they don't know how to use so they throw it in the fire we usually tell somebody is like before you go to bed douse it water it turn it water it again check it make sure it's cool put more water on it just to be sure and get up in the middle of the night at some point or the other check it again do you have complaints about that you know often I get more complaints from people from burn piles from people's homes than I do campfires okay so it's not a continuous type problem I never got called for a campfire I've been called for bonfires that's good to know all right so I just and then smoke hey you can't really control smoke if you've got a bad day where the inversion of the weather is and it's gonna be low-hanging it's gonna hold smoke down low all right the winds can't control the winds you know you try your best to mediate you know you use dry wood versus wet wood different things and different things like that 's creates you want good hardwood versus softwood software creates more smoke camp sites but They're not going to know these things. Because I think I was reading that everything falls back to you guys, and I was reading in some of the ordinances, I read something about that if there's habitual problems, complaints, nuisance calls or something, it said something about the penalties are given to any problems or penalties or notices are given to the person after one complaint or something. After they've had one complaint to the police department, then no? No,, no. So my ordinance chapter four states that if, you have three or more nuisance calls for the same activity for which we're referring to as a fire alarms, if there's complaints on a, on an issue of a concern for a person that is having a fire, we will go up, we'll give you the one warning and then we make you put it out. Is that the, would that be for the entire camp ground? Let's say that the manager is. is not paying attention and it's a nuisance call all the time, or is it directed at each individual campsite person? It's at the individual campsites. Because if I have Lot A, which is all the way down in the southwest corner, and he has no issue, but I've got Lot B, which is all the way in the north corner, and he's the nuisance, then I'm going to address my issue to the nuisance in the north. I'm not going to issue... But they get one nuisance complaint with the write-up? No, they get a nuisance complaint that basically it's a verbal that I will relate to dispatch that they'll put in the CAD notes that says that they have been warned not to put the fire out, keep it contained, keep it low, keep it slow. So I guess my big picture thing is when you have a transient campground where RVs are coming and going, person A could have a complaint tonight, person C could have one tomorrow. there's nothing that seems to organize it to the campground owner because obviously the campground manager you can't you can't you can't do so the campground so if I come in it's my responsibility as that camper to adhere to all rules and regulations that there is that are set forth by the state and by town or city okay that's what i mean if the owner is becoming is the nuisance then i direct it towards the owner but i can't i can't direct to it i can't have the owner i can't go after the owner for the for the camper so the other issue and i agree with thomas
[1:49:03] Speaker A (unidentified): after 41 years in the fire service i can tell you i can't even remember how many times i had to go out and tell someone to put their fire out because the smoke that they were creating was bothering their next-door neighbor that's a state federal it's a state law there's a statute on that concerning nuisance smoke okay when it comes to campgrounds it's very difficult because he can go out and inspect all the fire rings and say they're good to go everything is cleared off all the duff and everything is cleared out around it and I come in and I'm sitting there with my family and having a campfire and the gust of wind comes up and it blows it over towards wherever or to the next campsite and it becomes a nuisance smoke well I apologize and we'll probably put the fire down but the issue is if I have a major fire and a campsite and it's got a lot of smoke and it drifts over into a residential area he could come out and say you need to put your fire down okay so I can do that two days later Robert comes into the same campsite and he has a fire are you going to tell him you can't have a fire in that campfire because I had a fire that bothered you no it's transient every campsite is transient and you cannot control transient campsites, okay? What you can control is nuisance smoke that flops from the campsite to the homeowner. But you need to understand, you can also say the transient smoke comes from the residential unit to the campsite. So what's good for the goose is good for the gander. What they do, and he could come out and say, okay, your fire and your smoke is bothering the campsite. You need to put it out. And he can do that by state statute along the same lines that he can do it with the campsite. So the idea of the statute is not specific to the fire ring. It's specific to the smoke that's causing a problem, whether it's you're burning leaves or whether you're burning sticks or whether you're even having a cooking fire okay now I know many a times we had people that we have to go to the same individual a couple times so you know we did we cancel their burn permit so if they start burning without a permit then you can cite them for burning without a permit okay so the idea is there is there is laws in effect there are statutes that can be can be used but it's it goes both ways and they need to realize that and these guys can be running around all the time especially in the fall when they're burning leaves or whatever so there is a statute for nuisance smoke out there and they tend I don't have that number with me, but they tend to enforce it, and that's what Thomas' job is.
[1:52:26] unknown: Well, that's mostly why I asked that question is because what I want to avoid is having to waste Thomas and the police department's time with nuisance calls because, like you said, you can't control smoke. You can't control every fire. You can't do it. You can't control campers. They're all different. They come and go. They are transient. And that is another reason why I believe the 50-foot minimum buffer would alleviate more of those phone calls, those calls from the fire department, wasting our resources.
[1:52:58] Speaker A (unidentified): And I agree with you there, but I think you're going to find campfires probably more prevalent with tent sites than you do with RV sites. You may still have some, but tenters would have fires more than RVers because that's the way they keep warm. That's the way they possibly can cook their food or whatever. But a tent site only tends to have more of an issue with nuisance smoke and whatever you want to call it, a problem of that size. And we've experienced that before.
[1:53:32] unknown: So that helps my argument for 50 foot for all. but I just want to I mean I wanted to understand it so that everybody could understand what it is you guys deal with and what your limitations are under state law so thank you. One last comment on E the very last phrase preferably on whatever consensus on eat what where it says must be place where they can be easily maintained on both sides preferably on the interior side of the bucket she added that so that they wouldn't be the fence wouldn't be against the property line that was added but you know I'm talking about the maintenance but I'm talking about maintenance and you basically are saying that you have to be able to do this on both sides and it's kind of like now you're saying but preferably on that side well what does that mean it was because Andrew was saying that they could put the fence on the they could put the fence up against the property line no but that's but that's taking care of in the first part of that sentence not necessarily they could put it at the 20 mark 20 foot line or the 15 foot line they could put it anywhere Fences or walls must be placed where they can be easily maintained on both sides. Preferably on the interior of the buffer strip, so not at 10 feet or at 50 feet. I think that's really overkill on, you know, what you do the way it can. Well, I think it was the comment, I think you said something about they could cut down the trees to put up the fence. So then I said, well, then put the fence on the inside of the buffer. It takes away the problem. Put it towards the inside, not in the middle, not on the property line. The neighbors shouldn't have to look at a fence. I don't agree. I don't agree. You can vote on it.
[1:55:30] Speaker A (unidentified): In order to maintain...
[1:55:32] John DeLeo: Moving on to 806.11, utilities. 806.12, water supply. Yep. 806.13, toilet facilities.
[1:55:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, that's a given.
[1:55:47] John DeLeo: 806.14, wastewater disposal. 806.15, campfires. That's a given. 806 16 rubbish disposal so
[1:56:02] Speaker A (unidentified): on 806 15 should we somehow mention for you the state statute numbers no okay just numbers change that's that's the
[1:56:15] unknown: lady that's the lady the reference to open fires during high risk and that's
[1:56:20] Speaker A (unidentified): the smokey the Bears but well the fire chief can actually cancel fires at all campsites if you want to okay yeah i
[1:56:29] John DeLeo: guess just touching back on the 80 percent the letter from tim pease mentions do we do the 80 your butt is locked from the second floor have we talked about that
[1:56:42] unknown: that's has not been discussed as a group yet okay
[1:56:47] John DeLeo: so i mean if that's do you want that discussed i mean are we talking about that's up to you
[1:56:52] unknown: is it something you want to include or if you want to see tim pease's letter
[1:56:59] John DeLeo: his suggestion on the buffering as opposed to achieve 80% view from the butters lot they want to consider whether this applies to all floors of the neighboring structure I don't have a situation that the neighbors have complained about you know I
[1:57:24] Speaker A (unidentified): still think I still think the 80% is subjective
[1:57:27] unknown: number because sorry it's my dog so how do you maintain 80% in the winter when
[1:57:43] Speaker A (unidentified): all the trees when the deciduous trees have lost their leaves if you're counting on just the evergreens to do that you may not have 80% because part of that 80% is the remaining brush that's there that they're not getting rid of and those trees are going to lose their leaves petals flowers whatever you
[1:58:17] unknown: want to call them other than oak trees well that's what Andrew said evergreens and fencing and berms that's why the alternative gives us some alternatives typically it's evergreens I think it didn't we're I thought Andrew were you guys going to talk to the tree people and find out what kind of trees are you just gonna leave it that it has to be evergreen trees and shrubs and leave it at that I don't know I was in the hospital this weekend so okay I just remember it the thing you had said that we were I don't know if you reached out to the arbor commission or not i have not reached out to our tree steward and was not able to reconnect with him okay i'll
[1:59:14] John DeLeo: wait for robert to come back in answer my question well wait for robert any other questions comments i was
[1:59:44] unknown: going to see if the standards had any specifics easier.
[2:00:00] John DeLeo: I'll open the public hearing. If someone wants to come up, come to the podium, state your name, where you live, you don't have to give your exact address. Just keep in mind that if you have a question specifically about Alton Avenue or Anchor Inn, I may gather you down. Okay, go right ahead.
[2:00:25] Kelly Brackett: My name is Kelly Brackett, I live on Elk Nav. So I just wanted to sort of reframe the conversation from the resident's perspective. So over the summer, Campground was proposed next to our residential neighborhood, and this was a residential proximity that was unprecedented in Ellsworth's history. The application exposed the inadequacies of Ellsworth Campground and zoning ordinances, and through resident advocacy and a majority vote at the city council a moratorium was enacted to protect all residents of Ellsworth we're now at the point that these revisions are taking place and I believe we're losing sight of the intention of this process in the directive of the council the goal should be to create an ordinance that is comprehensive enough to protect the public health safety and quality of life and provide clarity for developers not one that leaves important details to individual operators or relies on complaints after problems arise. Tonight you will hear residents requests that we believe will protect all Ellsworth residents from the impacts of living adjacent to a commercial campground. So there'll be several of us coming up. Additionally we have sought representation from Murray Plum and Murray out of Portland and they submitted a letter to Brittany just prior to this meeting, so you guys did not receive it yet, but I wanted to read to you some of the concerns of our lawyers that are representing us.
[2:01:58] John DeLeo: We received it tonight. You received it? Yes. Okay. Okay. You're talking about the letter dated November 4th?
[2:02:04] Kelly Brackett: Yes. Okay. I wasn't sure if you guys got it in time. Yes. So obviously we have some concerns about bias that has gone on in reviewed recorded meetings thus far during the workshop process for the campground ordinance revision. Specifically, there has been repeated statements by Chair John DeLeo about the applicability and consequences of the ordinance revisions to the anchor in campground even though it has been told to him by city staff several times to not discuss these things additionally during the workshop on October 20th city planner Brittany Merrill while sharing her screen sent a Microsoft teams message to Andrew letter low assistant code enforcement officer stating that quote hypothetically the anchored in campground has a space to shift 25 feet to the south and meet these proposed ordinances but we can't tell john that during this meeting so the lawyers are essentially asking that the board consider the bias here and consider recusal of any members who have exhibited this bias during this process i definitely appreciate with the reminder tonight to keep it focused on the ordinance and the city as a whole but that does not change what has already happened so I'm asking the Planning Board to regain public trust by holding John DeLeo accountable for the actions that have taken thus far and to consider if he should continue participating in this process as his involvement creates a reasonable question about the board's impartiality I encourage the board to take a vote to recuse him from all further discussions and voting regarding the campground ordinance revisions and further review of campground ordinances the public deserves the confidence that these regulations are being developed objectively that all viewpoints are being considered based on merit and that no individual application is driving the outcome additionally in the letter to you from our representation there was concerns about the revisions of this ordinance not reviewing some of the key aspects delineated in the moratorium they say in Part A that the comprehensive plan recommends dividing the existing rural district delaying this level of review at this juncture may save in time and money in the short term but it's kicking the can down the road on an issue that needs to be addressed. The city should undergo this broader review now instead of attempting a piecemeal approach that does not adequately address the concerns in the moratorium and the recommendations of the comprehensive plan. Additionally, they have concerns about the definition of campground. That campgrounds range from a collection of campsites with tents to recreational vehicles to permanent cabins. Each of these uses have very different impacts on the surrounding area and should be subject to appropriate standards specifically tailored to these impacts. The proposed revisions do the opposite. They create a very broad definition of the term campground that encompasses all of these uses. Additionally, they believe that the revisions that have been proposed thus far are inadequate and they are minimal and do not fulfill the goals set forth in the moratorium. They focus on marginally increasing buffer requirements and adding screening. These revisions on their own are insufficient to address many of the concerns that motivated the moratorium, including but not limited to traffic congestion and road safety, wastewater management, solid waste disposal, noise and light pollution, and environmental protection. For these reasons, we urge the Board to reconsider its approach to the UDO revisions and take steps to recuse any members and staff from this process who have exhibited bias thus far. This was signed by our representation, Ellen Maselsky. I appreciate your consideration of our concerns and our lawyers' concerns on the approach that is being taken here. We have a couple other residents that will address our specific concerns and recommendations for the ordinance moving forward. I
[2:06:34] Speaker A (unidentified): have a question for you, if you could come back to the podium. So knowing that the workshop was held on that day and that there was no one online watching the workshop and there was no public in that workshop, how did the lawyer get the information as far as the team? It's recorded. It's on YouTube. It's on YouTube. It was recorded? Yes, sir. And who got the recording? public okay I just wanted to know I [John DeLeo: make] a recommendation that John DeLeo continue in the process of this ordinance revision and that we give him a vote of confidence from the very beginning I make that as a motion I had
[2:07:49] unknown: grave concerns during the workshop and I stated so several times that we were veering away from the overall picture for a citywide ordinance for the future of this city and that many of the comments made were specific to an application. I stated that probably five or six times during the meeting. It was very uncomfortable to have to continually know that we were violating our standards of what we're supposed to be discussing. Brittany Merrill was very clear that we were not supposed to be discussing any particular application. This is supposed to be strictly for the future of campground ordinances, and all our future ordinances that we're going to revise have to be clear that we are doing it for the big picture and i was very uncomfortable that it was just kept happening and so it was intentional and it was very clear because you stated your particular your concerns about one particular application you made very clear and made a statement to fact that you were concerned that this revision was going to affect that application in a negative way so I am not comfortable that you are not biased in this matter respectfully because up until then serve you well and serve you with respect but that felt like not we vote on it opinions from staff I honestly haven't watched the
[2:09:41] Speaker A (unidentified): meeting so we got a motion and a second I call for the question all in favor all
[2:09:50] Kristen Braun: opposed motion carries hi I'm Kristen Braun I live on [street] I'd like you to please consider the following recommendations the first one increase the minimum parcel size of campgrounds from the current two acres to at least 10 acres and establish density limitations similar to the approach used in the city's mobile home ordinance. A minimum acreage requirement alone does not prevent a campground from packing an excessive number of sites onto a relatively small parcel. Number two, require campground applicants to identify the specific recreational amenities proposed, their location, and their attendant use. use. Amenities must be compatible with the size of the property and surrounding properties and amenities should be restricted to registered campground guests so that the facility does not become a public dumping or recreation destination beyond its approved capacity. Three, clearly define permanent versus seasonal occupancy, including maximum stays and required vacancy periods. Section 8065 prohibits permanent dwelling use but does not establish a clear maximum length of stay or vacation period. We have heard the applicant of a particular campground express his intent to accommodate full-time seasonal residents. All mobile lodging and any temporary structure should be removed when the campground is closed. Four, recreational vehicles should remain on their wheels and the establishment of additional structures such as lattices, sheds, decking, et cetera, should not be allowed except for an approved campground manager's dwelling. Five, elaborate on Section 8068 requiring 10 percent of developed land to be designated as recreation space is not enough if the actual facilities and their impacts are not evaluated. I want to share that I know a family with young children who is combining resources with one set of grandparents, and they had an offer on a house in Ellsworth, and as soon as they learned about a nearby RV park, they rescinded their offer, and they're not going to buy that property. And that's just the start. Nobody wants to live next to a campground. I can't imagine why anyone in your position would want to devalue any area of our city. On that note, the City of Ellsworth's Code of Ethics and Conduct states that serving as a city official is a public trust and city officials must conduct themselves in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity of city government. And it also says that city officials need to perform their duties impartially. Impartiality has been inconsistent at best in regards to a recent campground application. Remarks were shared at a recent meeting with the planning board proving that the city planner and some planning board members are siding with the developer. developer. Noncompliance with ethical standards is gravely concerning. Fortunately, there is still time for all officials involved in this matter to check their biases and proceed by governing this issue with integrity. Moratoriums exist to pause potentially damaging decisions from being made in haste. Now is the time for you to ensure all campgrounds will be good neighbors to existing homeowners in Ellsworth. It's not time for you to laser focus your efforts on making sure one particular campground gets approved. Hi,
[2:14:03] Kim Smolage: my name is Kim Smolage. I also live on [street]. I want to start by saying that good operating guidelines for campgrounds are super important, but they are not a substitute for good land use planning. I'm concerned that we're losing sight of the bigger issue that prompted this entire discussion. The moratorium gave us a valuable opportunity to examine a much bigger question. Where are campgrounds appropriate and where are they not? We can establish all the rules we want for buffers, screening, and noise, but those measures cannot eliminate the fundamental differences between a commercial campground and a residential neighborhood. neighborhood. The decision to put off addressing rural zoning because it will be time-consuming seems short-sighted. In the meantime, campgrounds could potentially be developed on two-acre lots directly abutting established residential neighborhoods across the city. According to Ellsworth's comprehensive plan, this doesn't appear to be the direction our city wants to go. Turning to the proposed guidelines, we've heard a lot tonight about the proposed 50-foot buffer where campgrounds and existing homes or the draft proposes a 50-foot buffer where campgrounds about existing homes with smaller buffers along other boundaries I don't believe these distances are sufficient particularly given the City Council's previous discussion of 75 to 100 foot buffers other main communities provide examples of much stronger protections Old Orchard Beach for example requires a 100 foot natural vegetated buffer where campsites recreation areas roadways and other improved areas cannot be located. That decision was held up in the courts. Reed Field requires 100-foot setbacks for campground buildings and recreational areas along with screening from property lines, and Wayne's 2025 ordinance requires 150-foot setbacks from campground property lines and 200 feet from neighboring residences. These are examples worth considering as Ellsworth establishes its own standards. I would encourage Ellsworth to establish a minimum of 100-foot vegetated buffer around campground boundaries. Screening requirements also need to be measurable and enforceable. The proposed 80 percent visual screen within five years leaves questions about who determines compliance and how is it measured. I would like to see annual inspections by city staff to ensure buffers remain effective for the life of the campground. Road frontage should receive enhanced screening to preserve the character of the surrounding area. Buffers along residential property lines should also remain protected areas, not extensions of campground infrastructure. Other than necessary utility crossings, intrusion should be prohibited. If fencing substitutes for vegetation, it should provide 100% privacy with clearly defined materials and standards. Finally, the draft addresses separation between campgrounds and neighboring properties, but says very little about spacing between individual campsites minimum campsite spacing and inter-site screening are important to protect privacy reduce noise and prevent densely packed developments that resemble parking lots ultimately buffers must be substantial measurable enforceable and maintained they are there to protect the people who already live next door I feel compelled to repeat that good operating guidelines are important but they're not a substitute for good land-use planning. We've been given an opportunity to get this right. Let's not settle for addressing the easier issue while leaving the bigger one unresolved. Thank you.
[2:17:44] Glenn Smolich: Hi. Glenn Smolich, 31 Elton Avenue. Been there pretty close to 30 years. I had no idea something like this was going to happen in 30 years. I'd like to talk to you about operations, environmental protection, and enforcement of the campground. A campground is an ongoing commercial operation it impacts don't stop once the site plan is approved the ordinance needs to address how the property will be managed every day how neighboring residents will be protected and what happens when the operator fails to comply first management section 806.4 requires a responsible manager and a 24-hour phone number but it does not require someone to be physically present on the property I believe campground should have on-site 24-7 management so the complaints emergencies and violations can be addressed immediately quiet hours should be clearly established by the city at a minimum of 10 p.m. to 8 a.m. the ordinance should also prohibit gas powered generators and establish clear standards for noise between campsites and neighboring properties lighting needs to lighting needs its own requirements I would suggest incorporating dark sky principles and the language in Ellsworth's mobile home ordinance prohibiting lighting directing towards surrounding properties streets the sky or other campsites there should be similar requirements for order odor control constant campfires and legalization of marijuana or weed in the state would negatively impact surrounding establishments. We also need standards for signage, including restrictions on electrified signs and the standard for pets, including leash requirements and prohibiting pets from being left unattended in recreational vehicles. Wastewater and water supply deserve particular attention. The draft references state requirements,, but the City should establish clear expectations for protecting nearby wells, monitoring septic systems, and ensuring that campground occupancy does not exceed the capacity
[2:20:00] John DeLeo: of the approved systems.
[2:20:02] Glenn Smolich: Fire protection should include adequate water supply and require adequate cisterns. Campground managers should be responsible for ensuring fires are fully extinguished and for enforcing fire restrictions during periods of high hazard or drought conditions. Rubbish disposal should follow the more specific requirements in the city's mobile home ordinance, including enclosed, refuse, storage, and appropriate collection standards. Finally, the ordinance should address road capacity, large vehicle access, turning movements, roadside parking, traffic backups, and impacts on local resident roads. state approvals should not prevent elsewhere from establishing additional local standards on road requirements to protect its residents the city also needs meaningful enforcement provisions inspection requirements fines operating consequences and clear responsibility for violations these are not minor details they are the standards that determine whether our campground can operate responsibly and compatibly with its neighbors. The ordinance should not simply establish how to approve a campground. It needs to establish how to ensure that the campground remains a good neighbor throughout its operation. Folks, thank you very much for your time. I appreciate it. Anybody
[2:21:34] Robert Graham: else? I'd like to know if a question is allowed. Could you come up? Is it allowed? Yes. Robert Graham, citizen of Ellsworth. I don't I haven't watched this since beginning but if you put the I guess it's a 50-foot buff around the whole project is that what we're looking at now okay well that's what we're talking about and I hope everybody's sake it doesn't happen but can you get through that buffer zone is it because usually you can't break one how do you develop the backline is that in the ordinance somewhere that you can break that 50 foot or 25 foot buffer zone to get to the rest of the land out back I think it wasn't stated anyway I didn't hear my ears I just think it ought to be considered somewhere before it's all thank you so you can't do build anything in it that it would include a roadway to
[2:22:49] unknown: get to the next piece you have to maintain the 80% opacity so if you were able you could build a road through it and maintain the opacity okay yes but also if you were to do anything on the remaining part of the land you come back and amend the amend the plan to allow that a road through yeah okay yeah as long as you didn't shut it down it's you know that it's all possible thank you 're
[2:23:20] John DeLeo: welcome any other comments questions i'll close the public hearing when you were going i had a question on the memo from Tim Pease about the 80% view from the butters lot any questions does that apply to all floors of the neighboring structure in a situation where neighbors have to complain about views from the second floor that's
[2:23:48] unknown: where you putting in a 20-foot tall fence would be easier than trying to plant 20 foot tall trees I mean if we really wanted to try to enforce that I guess
[2:23:58] John DeLeo: I'm asking, I guess, what's the city's position on, you know, does that 80% mean to the second floor, or just 80%?
[2:24:13] unknown: Yeah, I think that's a question for whether you guys want us to look at that from the view of a second floor, because I don't know. that's a that's a tough again to Lisa's point the 50-foot buffer may fix that problem because I mean or it may not we need a physics engineer or somebody did you have six Pythagorean theorem wasn't my favorite I do know that I haven't ever fielded any complaints about a view from a second sort of window but that doesn't mean there wouldn't be but I don't know how you would be able to view that all that Tim says is may want to consider whether this the applies to all floors of the neighboring structure I would think that it will I have encountered situations where neighbors have complained about views from second yeah I would think that as it's written it doesn't but if you wanted that direction to be investigated then that is something staff could look at but it gets more and more it does exactly and the elevations changed the whole property so it's a moving target yeah that's why if you increase the buffer you potentially resolve those problems well maybe you may see where it actually works the other way around right yeah if it slopes downhill from it the whole way how you're gonna how do you ever fix that I could never if the topography is right you could never chase it on some properties yeah you 'd have to approve an alternate. You'd have to have like a tall wall, a very tall wall. Yeah. And all of those. Yeah. Right on the property line problem.
[2:26:23] John DeLeo: Any other comments or questions from the board, staff?
[2:26:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Where do we go from here?
[2:26:31] John DeLeo: Well, I mean, I think there's enough.
[2:26:33] unknown: So it's your decision on, the whole thing is your decision, on whether or not you want to meet again to discuss further. Do you want us to draft up all these changes and then you vote on it at the next meeting so you have time to review or you vote with what you have me for now I don't want to extend this but I think
[2:26:54] John DeLeo: there's been enough changes to the wording that we should see a clean copy
[2:26:59] unknown: yes yeah so the question is do you want an extra meeting or something to do you want to wait until our next planning board meeting to address this do you want to schedule a special meeting to just focus on this that's up to you guys and we may need to consider some of the comments by the public as part of our fodder so probably we need another special meeting in my opinion I'll leave that up to you guys I mean well you know it depends on how long it takes to do that and what other things are coming up with the next meeting I mean if it's a full house then yes a special meeting if it's not then we'll just consider it the next meeting the application deadline for planning for the december planning board meeting is tomorrow so helpful or doc it is we could potentially have three or four projects we could have none so but you're gonna know tomorrow we'll know tomorrow as of right now you don't have any i've not received any submissions okay or applications so far so i would say included in the next meeting and then we can you know at least tentatively and if you know depending on what really comes in and then that would push it to council in January so we have proper public noticing deadlines to meet but we can still have it on the December workshop or push it to the January workshop shop depending probably legitimately yeah okay so i'll need a motion to table it second no you need a motion no you have to make the motion to table it no they need the motion table up and maybe you need a second floor table motion second to the december meeting perfect thank
[2:29:02] John DeLeo: you item number four proposed planning board bylaws review and consideration of adopting bylaws that establish procedures and guidelines for the organization operation meetings and conduct of the planning board so
[2:29:29] unknown: this we've discussed before we've had a workshop on changes that we discussed were made you can you should be pretty familiar with it now is there any other changes you want to make up or if you make or if you have questions now would be the time that we can go through it yeah I feel like we've looked at this enough for it good but once again some sort of I would really like to see in one of these I think I think that there may well be language in the large ordinance but the idea that there could be some designated Q&A between people comments on a public hearing on any project I mean some of the stuff that said is absolutely spot-on and a real problem and some of the other stuff is not I mean it's a lot of hyperbole unfounded and so forth and I think that rather than just let those things sit in the record forever you know they may well need to be addressing like from my perspective at the time I agree and I think part of that may be poor training for what unions are supposed to be because on our part of their part both okay both not a lot of training went into this job so you are allowed to respond as a discussion amongst yourselves but it's not supposed to be a back-and-forth right so if you have concerns or want to restate to address something that has been said you can do that or you can ask a clarifying question of staff that would help that is sort of the avenue that you have to answer those questions at the same meeting other than that it's you know it could be addressed at the next public hearing after you've had time okay so I believe and I can verify with legal to see but that is the way researching this that's how it's supposed to yeah by ending the conversation we're basically minimalizing everything they've said and it just goes away yeah and it might be something that's important we want to discuss that's true and that's up to you guys to discuss or ask clarifying questions of staff you know that sort of level yeah so yeah if you'd like a point somebody's made redirected it you know as amongst yourself or to us and then when we can we can act on it more directly okay and i know it's harder when there's multiple because then it's hard to respond to each one but you're supposed to all the public comment first and then respond to actors the hearing has been closed and then lack of training on or lack of communication with the public on the city end is this is not the only avenue where people can submit their questions or concern that's part of the ask Ellsworth initiative where people could throw questions there people are more than welcome to come to planning and code offices to talk about processes or you know things that we can talk about project wise so this is not their only Avenue this is more for these are the things I want to state for the record as evidence for your decision-making process so if there are other questions that are process related or like oh I was looking through this prop the project and I had a specific question because I didn't understand it they can reach out to planning so it's again lack of communication about where to direct certain questions but so basically after public hearing we could take a moment and say is there anything we want to discuss but that would be up to you to like spur us on I guess after the public hearing if there's anything we want to discuss because usually after public hearing it's like move on that's what I'm saying is what she's saying is we can then discuss it amongst ourselves not with them not with the people to ask the questions but like if we had a particular question like if somebody asked a question about what kind of trees and then we could say what kind of trees does it we want we could talk about it well it's important without the public you no what she's saying is we redirect their question to us to ourselves we don't go into a banter with the public we go into after the public hearing closes we can discuss topics amongst ourselves and we always do Lisa no after the public hearing a lot of times we move to the next phase do you want to talk about something specific I'm gonna bring it up now no John I think what she's trying to say is that you guys have your deliberations yeah and then once you have your deliberations you have you have public comment in which sometimes there may be something brought up that is worth a discussion that you guys didn't have prior so instead of just waiting to have that discussion say at the workshop or the next meeting you can bring it up amongst yourselves or bounce that question off staff to get an answer out of the ordinance and then while you guys are discussing that the public is getting their in their questions answered as well exactly that is all that is all I think she's trying to
[2:35:18] John DeLeo: let you and I do that excuse me Lisa but I did it tonight John do you have any
[2:35:25] unknown: questions you have any comments John I was just reiterating what Brittany said we haven't been doing that much in the past but it's something we can do that we are permitted to discuss we're going to do a lot of things that's going to bring up everything like that we couldn't have we tend to go on and on and on about the same exact thing new disqualification new items is what she's talking about things that we may not have discussed previous we have the right to discuss them if we choose to you can also clarify like if you know there's some misinformation that was said or you basically it's a skirt it's a way to answer the questions without directing the public comment so for example I mean you know they in this last one there you know there was talk about transportation problems and there were sewer and water problems and whatever and those are things that we routinely spend a lot of time on and whatever so the point is that when that statements made during a public hearing I could easily ask you for example maybe probably you know from G doesn't don't we address that kind of thing when we do the TRT when we do the general discussion of the project or whatever and so it really addresses is what this person has said without addressing them directly and without engaging in it but you do a fair job of especially if it's like one or two depending on the project that's that's what
[2:36:58] Speaker A (unidentified): the trt is for yeah we correct because all those things those items are discussed prior to make sure then that's what the trt does initially is to make sure that those things are addressed or the checkoff list is checked off but not everyone knows that i understand that but we can say the trt has already looked at that and it's already part of the plan it's a done deal done
[2:37:25] unknown: we don't have to say that doesn't address the public it's more of an internal conversation you should be like does the subsurface wastewater ordinance cover that yes does the lighting standards cover that yes does the noise ordinance cover that yes we don't need to
[2:37:41] Speaker A (unidentified): elaborate exactly all you need to do is say it's been covered exactly that's
[2:37:48] unknown: why you have that's why you got the checklist right yes but the public doesn't always get that if they don't request the packet if they want to come
[2:37:55] Speaker A (unidentified): back and take a look at it they have the right to do so we don't need to sit here and deliberate that with the public because has those people not
[2:38:03] unknown: deliberating though well disgusting they don't understand the process and this
[2:38:07] Speaker A (unidentified): helps them understand not only don't they discuss the process they may not know the technicalities of what is going on citizen yeah that's a very common thing they're
[2:38:18] unknown: right without the lighting you know what we've talked about and then they get frustrated when they think that you're not listening to them so this is a way of helping to educate the public to produce further questions or we could point them in the direction of like i'm happy more than happy to answer questions i have not received as many as i thought i would in the last six months
[2:38:40] Speaker A (unidentified): but I'm here to answer questions and I understand that being a member of the TRT for years we spent hours and hours and hours going over stuff with developers to make sure that everything was in order before it came to this body and we were able to check it off because what they had two times to come to the TRT to make everything correct and they brought it back the second time and everything was just where it needed to be it comes to the board the board approves it because it meets the minimum standard of the ordinance for that purpose i don't remember very many times us having to discuss what the technicalities of stormwater was other than we just needed to know a certain cup as far as far as post and pre you know stuff half the people don't know what post and three are but we don't i feel we don't need to do that well you don't need to get
[2:39:38] unknown: that technical but if someone's obviously frustrated by not well they're concerned and we understand that like so we're worried about the lighting or about this we're worried about that 's what we all have all these reasons for so i've always booked for right and you're right about that we've discussed neon signs there's no neon signs yeah so like that's another thing the sign ordinance covers electronic signs and stuff like that so you can you can kind of head off some strife and turmoil by strongly worded questions to staff about what we already have the ability to control correct and even i mean you had a you had a
[2:40:12] Speaker A (unidentified): gentleman that mentioned dark sky requirements how many people in that audience knows what dark
[2:40:18] unknown: sky requirements how many people listened to me when i signed our lighting ordinance i already covered that in article six that's my point towards that well see that's why you just reiterate we just reiterate it's already met period yeah we just have to reiterate and reiterate until further questions look into the ordinance reach out to the planning department you can say that too so you know it's take the burden off of you guys a little you know it's very difficult to make these things not adversarial between the city or the planning board and the people at the end of the day we're all trying to do a good job we have to work on that because it's mostly perception as opposed to yeah exactly and i and i think what brittany is saying is here are some ways to do that there's frustration all around in a project like this there it's and everyone is trying to get through it the most way the best way possible there's mostly misinformation you know and that's the problem well it needs
[2:41:19] Speaker A (unidentified): to be addressed or it's never going to be and i have to be careful how i say this but when they start talking about or for the lack of any term because i've seen it other places when you start dealing with campgrounds and traffic control that's not something that especially if it's on a state road we can't control we can't we don't have any control over
[2:41:45] unknown: that whatsoever no and you can certainly say you know article 6 section or chapter 56 article 9 it says clearly state roads are exempt from and you can word it like unfortunately we have no we have no control over that our hands are tied the state owns this road and they're the ones that say stipulate the entrances and x y and z but actually the main thing of the way we would do that wouldn't be to talk to that person no exactly we would after he's done talking we could very we could say it out loud or we could say to staff we can't do anything about the roads though can we that our hands are tied correct exactly yes and that puts them at ease and it gets us that item off the plate and makes them feel like they were heard and that's all she was saying and I was just reiterating that we should probably utilize that tool more often so long as it's not 50 billion questions because we'd be here all night but if it's something we can address and get it done if it's something we can address let's do that 's why those time limits on speaking are such a it's a toss-up on whether you want to control how long someone can speak or not because if you control how long they can speak you can understand more questions and get more answers out versus a 10-minute... People have already spoken. We didn't cut anybody off. Oh, no, I'm not... And you've been great about that.
[2:43:13] John DeLeo: This is all... We've done the same thing over and over again.
[2:43:14] unknown: This is all just process. I get it.
[2:43:17] John DeLeo: There have been times that a member of the audience has come up, and in their presentation, they've asked questions, and this board has answered them while they're at the podium, and I see nothing wrong with that. Right. Did they answer the question? I know.
[2:43:36] unknown: You answered the question. answer it's a gray area and it's you know we could do a better job at be consistent I don't know what the ramifications are of continuing to do that or doing that when there's a lot of people other than you know it's we do need to be more consistent which is why I want bylaws and so what do you need I need you to vote on it. Is Ray here? -oh, here he comes. Welcome to my life.
[2:44:22] Robert Graham: Thanks for coming. All right. Don't give up.
[2:44:24] unknown: Congratulations again. Doing a good job.
[2:44:30] John DeLeo: I'm glad you're doing better. Actually, he congratulated. I'm going to give you my condolences.
[2:44:44] unknown: So it's up to you to vote as is or if there is any changes you want to make. We will be reviewing these annually and, yeah, that's all you have. Also, I will note the gentleman who was here last time that helped us gave us. yes Ray who helped us in the public comment from the last time we did we let race it at the table yes yeah all right all right Williams he said they would there we go specifically about basically I got a ray version of that okay so is there a motion yes sure yeah I would you know I gave you some comments I should the ugly tiny little things just fix those up and there's their minor there's nothing substantive so i'll take that stuff so are we making a motion yes i think we should talk
[2:45:50] John DeLeo: is there a second a second okay all in favor great staff comment enjoy
[2:46:00] unknown: your evening what did you say after that yes i got nothing you can go home and eat a bowl of ice cream well i actually always just say that i think all things considered that you know you're doing staff and i think the rest of us too are doing a reasonably good job at an increasingly adversarial time and we're not trying to be adversarial at all we're just you know it is adversarial when they come in and call people virtually never mind it's the nature of it's the nature of sure planning and planning boards i mean when you talk about people's property rights you are in for tough conversations any way you look at it when they built those houses they were that was the area we're not talking about that comments thank you all for your work on this for keeping it civil and for having some good conversation i think we made some good progress and there's definitely more fun and ordinance land coming ahead of us
[2:47:06] John DeLeo: The motion will be done.