← Back to MaineScanner

Naples committee weighs road standards, data center bans, and appeals changes

2026-10-21 · 1h 57m · Source: Naples Ordinance Review Committee 10-21-2026 (Town of Naples (Lake Region TV))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Sue Fleck: Good afternoon. I'd like to call the Naples Ordinance Review Committee meeting to order. Today's Wednesday, October 21st. In attendance today we have Sue Fleck, myself, Martina Witts, Kevin Rogers. We have a guest, Doug Webster, who I'll ask to introduce himself in a minute. Kathy Tamborelli is here, a municipal planner, and I think Kathy Eddy will be joining us. There are a couple people with excused absences today. They're traveling. so minutes of the September 16th meeting we don't technically have a form but I didn't see any issues with issues so the next thing on the agenda is subdivision of private road standards so for that we have Doug Webster he's a guest today an expert and I'll ask Doug to introduce himself so people know why he's here [0:50] Doug Webster: share with us thank you I'm Doug Webster I retired from the town of gray I was with gray for 18 years I was the community development director I went to school for planning and I'm a code officer and a plumbing inspector as well and I'm here to hopefully try to help you oh another one of my roles is the I'm the acting planner in Casco and so Casco is working on access waste standards as well and so it just seemed like a good fit to try to see if Naples wanted to work on some access standards and I put together a memo for the committee's consideration and happy to answer any questions [1:44] Sue Fleck: I invited Doug because she's worked with him in the past, so that's correct, as someone to help us through this. [1:48] Kathy Tamborelli: Yeah, I invited Doug because he was my supervisor for seven years in Gray. And we worked on the road tables and minor changes to road standards before, but he's really an expert in this area. And we had also brought Doug on to be back a CEO, so we have a little bit of funds already available to have him help us. and I'm a firm believer in why we create the will if you have someone that knows what they're doing and can help us get to the next step today's kind of a kind of a Q&A so that we can make sure that Doug and us are all on the same page what our goals are and then the next step would be for us to more formalize a draft you know the changes and talk to both Steve Merkel on the deputy road commissioner and the fire chief to make sure that we haven't missed anything that would be important to them and we'll invite them to the next meeting if they feel like they need to come so that's kind of where we are today so if you prepared a memo with some just some questions so we can make sure that we're on the same page the one thing I want to start with is our table is dated I mean just looking at the pavement standards and where I think we're at two inches which is kind of old for now you know most towns are at three and a corridor somewhere around there so we just really need to update that but we also identified three I with him I identified three things that we had talked about one was a lower road standard or a less a lower road starter first in within subdivision for those smaller subdivisions the minor ones currently we require pavement for all roads and subdivision and so it's all is a waiver request that we keep on getting asked the other big concern was the non subdivision roads a minimum private road standard because right now we don't have that and so for roads that get but you know they get built over time there's really knows nothing to hang our hat on as far as you need to at least build this and then the third one is what do we do with subdivisions that are developed on substandard roads we don't have anything that requires them to bring the existing road up to at least some standard before they add another 20 lots to the end of a substandard road so those are kind of the three big items and we want to start slow we're not trying to be super onerous we don't want to create you know something that's going to make it hard for people to develop their land but just to kind of make sure we have those thresholds so you [4:25] Sue Fleck: want to explain to us what you sure yes [4:28] Doug Webster: Thank You Kathy I know and I had some questions I've looked at the obviously the current driveway and I guess it's called driveway and entrance permit ordinance and I've got just had some thoughts as I outlined in my memo there could be some updates to that as an example there's not a definition of what constitutes a driveway in there so you're regulating driveways but you don't say what a driveway is driveway for what so I looked at that I looked at you guys call it the subdivision ordinance but as I understand I and says so even in the text of the land use ordinance but technically I think it's the land use ordinance and it's sort of the subdivision subset if you will of the land use ordinance and I've been working as I alluded to a couple minutes ago I've been working with Casco on some non subdivision access standards and so I have a pretty I'm working with them but I think it would be helpful to sort of gauge where Naples is on this and then what is it that you're targeting and what do you think is going to be you know viable obviously it doesn't make any practical sense to propose something that we know pretty well is not going to make it through town meeting and I think the same could be said for a lower if you will subdivision stay road standard for a parcel that triggers subdivision the trickiest one is really the because it's so subjective and because there's so many different variables the trickiest one is how to handle new subdivisions that are being accessed on an existing substandard road that's That's a really tricky one to solve, but I think that it's arguably time to at least try to put something on the books. And what a lot of towns do is they'll empower the planning board to make that decision. So we could go through the memo. [6:43] Martina Witts: Hasn't anybody solved this before? [6:52] Sue Fleck: Well, there's [6:55] Doug Webster: a lot of times, I mean, what other municipalities have done is said, if you trigger subdivision on an existing substandard road that the entirety of the road leading to the subdivision has to be improved. That's expensive and it's not always politically or economically viable and so the question always comes up is there any middle ground and because there's so many different variables that you could have a new subdivision on an existing substandard road that's only a quarter mile long but in some cases you have roads that are miles long and that 's prohibitive and so it what as a practical matter it prevents new subdivisions from occurring on these substandard roads and maybe that's something that a given municipality wants but if you're it's hard to find some middle ground so it's easy enough to take a stance on it. Standish had a road, I was Standish's planner many years ago, Standish had a road grading classification every road and this is 30 something years ago but every road was given a through F rating and if the road was below a certain grade you had to bring it up so that's that's the middle ground that they achieved gray for a while under its old street ordinance had a provision that empowered the planning board to require the planning board to the planning board was empowered to make the developer make spot which is one of one of the things I alluded to in the memo to make spot improvements let's say you had a particularly problematic crossing that was undersized and needed a larger culvert it needed to be wider or what have you so that's what gray did for their middle of the road but it's it's relatively uncharted waters to answer your question you would think that it [9:02] Martina Witts: would have been solved by now I've seen it just Naples like to think you're the only [9:16] Sue Fleck: pace in the expectation in developer if it's a different ever shared sometimes I guess you don't even know who the person was initially or they may not exist as an entity it can be on a private road it hinges [9:41] Doug Webster: is on the ownership of the road and or if there if an association has been duly formed I know state statute requires that road associations be formed but a lot of times it just doesn't happen the owners of those parties that have rights to the road can force it because of the state statutes on it but it gets but then you're pursuing legal channels with your neighbors and that together with the cost as a practical matter it really [10:18] Kevin Rogers: doesn't happen too often owner of the road is that people have a deeded right [10:24] Doug Webster: to use it or the person who owns the fee either or both it all hinges on how the, those, is there a road association? Is it duly formed? And is the road association the owner of the fee? In many instances, you guys have fee versus easement. Fee means you own the land. Easement means you have certain rights for a portion of it. So in many cases, if there's a big back lot, as an example, this is the normal situation. you've got a town or town road here got a town road here and the and then the developer creates lots along the side these lot owners have easement rights to this road but the developer retains the fee the reason for that is because if you own the fee to the road you have the ability to assign easement rights to others and so that's that's what happens in these situation that's why the developer retains the fee because they can assign easement rights to others as a subsequent phase so but you're right on that the fee versus easement it can be a big it can make things more confusing for sure so in your [11:53] Kevin Rogers: your experience do tenants write ordinance determining who's responsible for that or is that kind of up to the parties involved that's up to the [12:04] Doug Webster: parties involved yeah if let's say you're doing a subdivision on the front portion the Planning Board is concerned that these eight lots have the ability to use the road the Planning Board is not really as concerned if the plan if the developer retains the fee or not they typically do again because in case there's a subsequent phase they want to make sure that they have the right to assign easement rights to other parties it's [12:37] Kevin Rogers: more of a civil issue than a municipal so they need to figure that out on their own before they come to that could just be a box on the list of things is that they need to [12:49] Kathy Tamborelli: figure out who's responsible for what right that they and they do I mean typically they come in and most the ones that we've had there hasn't been any remaining land to develop for most of the ones that we've done at the end of [13:02] Kevin Rogers: this room yeah I don't know they ever had to bring that up to standard or not but moving homes up there so I'm assuming something wasn't there's I don't know, 78 acres on the other end of that road. [13:18] Kathy Tamborelli: You'll have to tell me what that is. I don't know which one you're talking about. [13:22] Kevin Rogers: Yeah, it was a to-do when it happened. [13:26] Doug Webster: And it all depends. There's so many different situations. You can have the fee, in some instances, the fee is owned by the road association. In some instances, the fee is retained by the developer. It's all kind of a case by case. And of course, it gets even more complicated if you're requiring road improvements for, let's say, a future subdivision or a new subdivision because the right-of-way may not be positioned in the correct location to enable the improvements to occur. And let's say you need a stormwater easement, it can get pretty complicated pretty easily. But I think the point of beginning is what, if anything, does Naples want to put on the books for new subdivisions on existing substandard roads and or access to [14:23] Speaker F (unidentified): property that does not trigger subdivision that starts in Wyndham so [14:33] Kathy Tamborelli: the road starts in Wyndham off 302 and someone put a subdivision at the end of that in gray and he had to build a road that was paved you know up to meet the lowest road standard for the number of Lots that he was doing at the end of this long gravel road and there was like a tree here and it was like a king pine or something that everybody was in love with you know so there was like all these emotional things too and so they were able to upgrade the road in a couple spots at the stream crossing past the tree so that they didn't have to cut the king pine tree or whatever it was down but it enabled the planning board to at least have some improvements on that road from 302 down well at least in the gray section once I hit the gray line gray line to the new subdivision and the road was pretty bad I mean it was pretty bad so in your experience [15:31] Kevin Rogers: with the town that started was asked us to understand it with the letter coding on the standard of the road how did that play out was that was that fairly acceptable accepted by the people who are being affected by the decision it [15:52] Doug Webster: was a way and there were and it even got I was trying to keep it simple just to lay the concept out it got a little bit more complicated there were sections of the same road that were a higher classification and then if there was a lower section but the objective on behalf of the Standish Town Council in creating this was to be clear to property owners and developers as to what they were going to need to do should they trigger subdivision so it wasn't an attempt I don't think to be heavy-handed it was an attempt to say hey if you're going to put it if you're going to trigger subdivision on this section of road X you're going to need to make some improvements because you know if you're a developer you're a prospective buyer of a piece of property everybody wants as much certain to understandably everybody wants as much certainty as you can and so it was a way to memorialize the town's intentions if a party were to trigger a subdivision and so can that reasonably fall on the [17:03] Kevin Rogers: in on the position of the road commissioner or the assistant road commissioner whoever that is at the time can they be the authority of that they [17:13] Doug Webster: They could be an advisor to create the classification, but again, the intention, it was memorialized in the, I think it was the subdivision statute, subdivision ordinance, I don't think it was elsewhere, but ultimately it would probably involve some input from a professional engineer and ultimately it would be need to be memorialized in an ordinance if it's going to be enforceable it needs to be in an ordinance and so the groundwork literally to create the classification could be done with the Road Commissioner with maybe some input from a PE professional engineer but ultimately if you were to go that route it would need to that classification would need to be in an ordinance in order for it to be enforceable when and or if a subdivision was triggered on the requisite section of road. [18:16] Sue Fleck: I think you'd want it in an ordinance anyway. I think a developer would want to be able to understand what enables to build something. They don't want it dependent on whoever seems to be sitting in a particular office at any [18:28] Doug Webster: particular time. Yep. You need certainty. [18:31] Kevin Rogers: Well, to rephrase my question, I'm assuming we have an ordinance in place, there's a standard of a equals this B equals this equals this and then there's the Association that knows the issues on the road so they may have some contribution and then maybe the road commissioner in particular expansions of that could be the deciding factor so it doesn't have to go to the engineer because that gets that there you just added a lot of time and money once we bring in the word [19:12] Doug Webster: engineer yep and I think it's important there's a little bit of a bifurcation here because the classification system that Standish came up but that was for public roads and so there's a important distinction here between public and privately owned fee roads so there's sort of two policy questions one is what the overarching question is what to do about new subdivisions on existing substandard roads then it splits how you're going to handle public roads how are you going to handle private roads and so I don't think I don't standish did not apply their a through F grading system to the private roads I forget what they did with the private roads what other towns and again it's a little bit of a harder line gray for instance has a standard still on the books that says that if you're if you put if you're proposing a new subdivision on an existing substandard Road either publicly or privately owned it needs to be improved back to the portion to where it meets the standards public [20:31] Kathy Tamborelli: easement standard yeah 18 feet big that's that's a bridge too far for [20:36] Doug Webster: I think. And that's a tough standard. [20:39] Sue Fleck: Do we have any substandard public roads? Probably. [20:44] Kathy Tamborelli: Probably. We're actually going to have an assessment on those soon. Public roads? Yeah. [20:49] Sue Fleck: Yes. So who's doing the assessment? That's what I meant to say. [20:52] Kathy Tamborelli: Town roads. I think it's going to be Pike Industries for free. [20:55] Martina Witts: I think most of our roads. But so what we're facing is, you know, in my head I see, I think the example I think of is a, it was a family home. It's still, they're still, I think he's still selling lots. And it's a nice, it's a nice, it's a nice, it's a nice, it's a nice, it's a nice, it's put a nice hot whatever and one lot of time and gave it that at one point they gave me would put it in sons and daughters name and this or that it's nice and but in the I had a girlfriend by a lot and they built a house nice house in there and then the spring came and if you had if there was an emergency situation good luck there was a stretch that it was a foot of mud it was a full speed ahead to get through there and so it's how do you got where does it get to the point where you say when they sell their next law that you say really great if you get this up this first for fire and rescue purposes we need to get this [21:55] Kathy Tamborelli: up so standard I think that was the whole thing about this too we're not we don't want to be the heavy hand and make it impossible and expensive public safety is what the whole thing about. And then the other one is to allow these, because we have quite a few small developers. It's just a family subdivision is what it is and they can't wait five years. I don't want them to have to pave their road for their three lot family subdivision. So that one is what answered, but the other part is the public safety issue that you just explained. That's what we're trying to solve without being too heavy handed and not making them build a rural public easement street from the public way all the way to the new subdivision. [22:32] Martina Witts: But like a subdivision being built at the end, the new substandard road is different, because if you want to build a subdivision, it's always been on you to put a road in. Whether there was an existing substandard road or not, you're lucky that there is a substandard road to start with, because you're already shaving off a huge expenditure of your investment by having that to build on. So now the question is, if it's a three lot, [22:56] Speaker G (unidentified): then we really- [22:57] Kathy Tamborelli: At the end of 30 other lots, yeah. [22:59] Martina Witts: So we reel it in so that, yes, they still have to meet those subdivision standards, but then it doesn't have to be a 25 or whatever foot, 18 foot pavement and all that, you know, so. [23:10] Kathy Tamborelli: Yep. So this is my question is what happens when you've got someone that is building a subdivision at the end of this long private road that has been divided over time, and they own, the lot owners are in an association and it's a private road and they don't want, they like their road the way that it is how do you do anything you know how do you deal with that they like their private little quiet road yeah that's right unfortunately that's what it [23:39] Doug Webster: comes down to your diagram that's why developers retain the fee because the those parties that have easements they can object but they can't prevent the owner of the fee from assigning additional easement rights that's that's why it's usually done [24:10] Kathy Tamborelli: I've driven two roads in Naples and I'm like there's no way you're getting down this in the winter there's a couple others I'm sure there's more than that but there's two that I've driven and I'm like holy cow no one's getting down here in the winter [24:21] Speaker H (unidentified): some of them are real scary to go down and there's there's potential [24:25] Sue Fleck: development to happen at the end of those roads is that what you're saying or you just [24:28] Kathy Tamborelli: want to avoid the situation I want to I mean move out I mean mostly moving forward that's just that's all you can do is move forward right but less than [24:48] Martina Witts: somebody that has a project that this is going to cause a problem for at the time it hits the ballot then it'll be accepted as a the reason it was in place was to help I can't so [25:10] Sue Fleck: that's like the really the first question here is that stuff so currently our driveway and entrance permit ordinance which would be me starting a private road only regulates the first 25 feet, is that, and so the question is there a desire to consider minimum standards past that first 25 feet, is that, it's kind of where it starts and we don't even have a definition of a driveway. [25:36] Doug Webster: And then if the answer to that is yes we consider proposing some changes for that then if you go to the last heading on the second page there that 's where you kind of get into the nitty-gritty of that is okay do you want to have what Casco landed where Casco landed on this is there I put together a little table of different standards maximum grade with travel width shoulder width etc and CASCO's in the process of working on two different tables, one for existing accesses and then one for new, newly created. As an example, some existing access ways may not be 50 feet wide. And if you're creating a new access way to put in a new house, then maybe that should be at least 50 feet to meet, I don't know, what's your frontage, I didn't look at zoning. 100 feet, but the road front, what is that 100 feet on? Is it on a 50-foot right-of-way? [Speaker F (unidentified): 50-foot right-of-way.] Okay, because that's kind of the standard. But some of these old access ways are not 50 feet, which is where CASCO landed and said, okay, let's have two different, outside of subdivision, non-subdivision access standards, let's have one table for existing and one for new fifty feet wide for the [27:13] Kevin Rogers: right-of-way right away oh right not the traffic I don't think 302 main turn [27:23] Martina Witts: like a lot of it has to be to have your three feet or shoulder if you have [27:31] Kevin Rogers: overhead power you can have that anyway [27:41] Kathy Tamborelli: well that's what they're doing for the minor ones they're asking for a waiver but that's another topic backing up on the driveway the other thing that we don't have is what's a driveway and what's a road you know what's the how many lot how is it two or three dwelling I don't know I couldn't answer that I [27:57] Speaker I (unidentified): think that's three yeah that needs a definition there's a devil it doesn't [28:04] Kathy Tamborelli: define how many what constitutes a driveway versus a street yeah that was [28:09] Doug Webster: and so if you look at the existing there is a definition of driveway in the land use ordinance but there's not a definition of what a driveway is in the driveway and entrance permit ordinance so if you're gonna have an ordinance that's regulating driveways you should probably they're trying to be mean you should probably say what a driveway is I mean you talking about a commercial development and I have some other comments on the commercial with the what they call the ITE manual where [28:44] Sue Fleck: do you think we should go from here I mean what is it so clearly we need something that's going to help us with these extended subdivisions that get extended he's not he's bad bro we just have one Yeah, something has to, particularly now if it's going to involve, if it impacts water quality, if there's no culverts, you know, stream crossing situations, it's one thing if one house, one or two families are crossing it, but if you're going to have a lot of people crossing an area that impacts water quality, that's an issue. I mean, I know LEA is spending all kinds of money and getting all kinds of grants to improve stream crossings everywhere, so we don't want to. [29:28] Speaker I (unidentified): go against that right and make it worse so the way it's working now is if there's a subdivision [29:34] Kathy Tamborelli: on the end of a substandard road i take the chief and the deputy road commissioner on there and say is this work for you basically you know can they get your fire truck down here can you do what you need to do and that's where we're at right now and i would just like to have that more formalized you know the width the drainage whatever that is the men again the minimum you know not trying to be heavy-handed here, but what's the minimum that we need to do to make sure that this road is satisfactory to be adding three or four more dwelling units? [30:03] Sue Fleck: It probably shouldn't be 12 inch culverts anymore. We're not with the storms that we get now and everything. All culvert sizes are expected to be larger now than they were [30:12] Speaker H (unidentified): 20, 30 years ago. And I believe Steve tells them that when he does, when they do a driveway entrance permit, he tells them right on there what size culvert needs to be in there. I want to say he was using 20. I wanted to say I saw 20 or 24. [30:28] Speaker I (unidentified): It all depends on where it is. [30:32] Doug Webster: I think is the minimum. 12 inch apparently ices up much more readily in the winter obviously than a 15. 15 I think is the standard but if you have any other drainage in the area. [30:48] Kathy Tamborelli: That's on public roads. Is he even doing anything on private roads? [30:51] Speaker H (unidentified): He gives them pointers, but he can't tell them. [30:55] Kathy Tamborelli: They don't do a driveway entrance permit on private roads at all. [30:58] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, some of them have pulled a permit and then he's gone, hey, I don't do this, but this is what we actually do for public roads. This might work for your private roads as well. He gives them advice. I see. [31:10] Sue Fleck: Some private homeowners associations have standards. I know that. yeah just moved out of has expectations of certain sized culverts right [31:20] Kevin Rogers: driveways I think we have to I don't know that we have to reinvent the wheel there's got to be some standards out there of X amount of houses typically have X amount of wear which requires X amount of road and that then you get into the conversation that is thorn in my side about dwelling units versus structure so then you're talking about your duplexes and your whatever plexus that would probably have an impact on the standard well is that addressed in [32:04] Sue Fleck: the trip generation manual that you mentioned here I mean because obviously if you're building a subdivision full of duplexes or something it's going to generate a lot more trips than it would if they were all single yeah that's a [32:18] Doug Webster: new sort of created I mean talk with Kathy about it but in this day and age of multiple housing statutes I think there's going to be some court cases about municipalities not being able to regulate road standards based on dwelling units and so I'm wondering if the trip generation manual might be a way to maybe I agree with I mean the more traffic a road has the better the road needs to be and what we did with Casco where we are with Casco is both for existing access ways and new ones is there's a sliding scale if you will as the number of dwelling units for trips increases so does the road standard and so the thought that let's pick on a new example as this may help so you have someone needs to put in a new access way and they may or may not trigger subdivision in the future so let's get it established with a 50-foot right of way just the right way and let's start with a narrow road and then as the number of lots that right-of-way is serving they can increase the depth of the gravel and maybe make some drainage improvements but let's hopefully set it up at the beginning to allow for those improvements to occur i think that allow them to have a gravel road start and a 50 foot [33:52] Kathy Tamborelli: right away and then if they get to x amount of trips then they got to build they got to improve that road to the next standard so plan ahead especially if the developer keeps the rights to the fee and there's remaining land back there but don't make [34:05] Speaker F (unidentified): them build it at right now it's only two houses now that's fine I think what [34:11] Kathy Tamborelli: you're saying is that you would but rather tie it to the ITP than dwelling units because the ADU factor you can't count ADUs as dwelling units according to the state even though people live there and have two cars and so tying it to the trip generation versus the number of dwelling units politically and legally through according to state statute might be smarter that's that's [34:38] Kevin Rogers: the concept yeah I think it's very going back to the incremental increase in the road standard if I think that condition at the time of expansion to be considered as well because if that road is put in correctly with the right base they may not need to because that thing may be ironclad I own one and I will Well, two fire trucks can go side-by-side up that thing, and it's 26 years old, gravel. It has no potholes in it even because it was built right. So should that have to be expanded? Because I don't think so. Not in my opinion because it's holding up, and it's got 27 years' worth of proof that it's holding up. so I think that somewhere that condition comes in because I get into some and I'm like holy cow I tell people I want you to stand right here and think about how rescues gonna get down here when your kid falls down the stairs you got to get to the hospital but they're gonna die you know think about that before you buy in here and I've said that to people before so [35:59] Speaker G (unidentified): I [36:13] Martina Witts: think [36:42] Doug Webster: most municipalities focus, if it's just a driveway to one or maybe two dwelling units, then it's a shared driveway. There may be some basic standards, but not much. The emphasis is usually on, per your existing driveway and entrance permit, where the focus is on how it connects to the road to the let's call it town road just keeps it simpler to make sure you're not having all types of stormwater and erosion and so forth but the more problematic situations are though are the access ways that provide access to let's say more than two dwellings that's when it really gets tricky and then like we talked about before but the new subdivision at the end of a substandard road I think driveway should match what [37:40] Kevin Rogers: you can subdivide before it goes is what you can break out into lots before it triggers subdivision so whatever that magic number now is I think it's three right that's driveway because what we're going to find in the town of Naples is that because there was a lack of description of driveway and private road, there's a lot of driveway, private road, kind of all one word, driveway, private road, it's like one word, that have been created and they probably are not much more than that three. [38:16] Kathy Tamborelli: Yeah. I had a hard time discerning what's a driveway and what's a road, where's that line? [38:24] Sue Fleck: What do we do when the fourth one wants to be built? I mean, this is what we've been experiencing [38:28] Kevin Rogers: Well then I think that's when the investigation comes in and I think that if you've got three houses and you want to add one more, I don't know that it needs to go to full-on engineering. It could go to fire chief and road commissioner with some standards involved that... [38:45] Sue Fleck: Yeah, what are those standards? [38:47] Kevin Rogers: No washouts, a particular amount of travel lane or passing locations on that road. [38:57] Kathy Tamborelli: I don't think it's as big of a deal when they trigger subdivision because they've already hired an engineer and you know So now let's just look at that road, but it's the question is what is that standard? You know what does that because the engineer can do that and they've already hired and consulted When I worry about is the three lot special with the family, you know that 's where it gets hard They've they've hired just for example Wayne would to draw a three lot subdivision and in some towns three dwelling units is still a shared driveway it's not till the fourth one so that's where we need to make it clear what where is that line and when do we [39:37] Speaker G (unidentified): have to do this so that was an example so then should we be putting how's that driveway gonna be built that's what I'm that's what I'm so that's where [39:46] Sue Fleck: we are right now yeah and do they have to change the drive so you're building the fourth house and do they have to bring the rest of it already up to [39:52] Speaker G (unidentified): stand yeah that's what I'm getting or maybe it's okay yeah or maybe they still have the first time okay well maybe they just have to replace the [39:59] Sue Fleck: column if it already exists I mean really if it was built over the last 30 years it probably was not [40:05] Kathy Tamborelli: if it already exists but I like going forward I want the three to be consistent too the driveway entrance ordinance the subdivision within the land use ordinance and anywhere it's mentioned in land use or even site plan I don't care that there's no kid that's not consistent right now should be so I'm all over the place you know what I mean like what am i triggering here what should I do it's just not consistent and that's typical of town very small towns it's not untypical because you do an ordinance amendment and you forget to check oh I forgot the driveway entrance or do you know or whatever I mean it's [40:35] Martina Witts: very typical so currently the entrance doesn't tie into the driveway only the [40:43] Doug Webster: the first 25 feet yeah so what one of the things that I get it might be a bridge too far for Naples but one of the things that I proposed to Casco four or five months ago we haven't really talked about it on point was a very adding administration I get it was this access standards committee and so what we did so it created different standards for or it were in non subdivision access way standards now one for existing and one for new and so we I came up with a table of standards with road width and shoulder width and so forth and there were standards that were waivable by this access standards committee and then there were the higher waivers like the right-of-way with or planning board waivers so you so the concept with that I created for Casco was you come up with the a table for the template for existing template for new non subdivision access and you have and so in this case maybe we have the fire chief the road commissioner and the code officer and those three constitute the access standards committee and they go up so to get a building permit come in because we're outside subdivision building permit comes through the door the three town representatives go out there and they say okay well let's improve this road crossing and let's increase the depth of the gravel in this one problematic area and that and if there's an appeal the appeal goes to the planning board because the planning board is more attuned to because it's a it's a small road it's a small access way it's a little bit like staff review [42:34] Kathy Tamborelli: committee only not for outside of subdivision outside of subdivision so you're talking about maybe having the planner the deputy road commissioner and one other staff member on this and they refuse your small yeah I first when you talk about that I'm like you're not going to try to get another citizens a [42:51] Sue Fleck: committee are you why would you not send that so if it's being denied by that committee which is has the code enforcement officer why wouldn't it go to appeals for why would it come to planning because the project wouldn't [43:06] Doug Webster: come to planning in the first place because the Planning Board is arguably more attuned with those land use stormwater access types of activities as [43:18] Speaker F (unidentified): opposed to the appeals board I would like to get the appeals board out of the [43:22] Kathy Tamborelli: Planning Board appeals to you know because they because they don't deal with it enough they should be just doing variances and appeals of the code officers decision and not getting into our stuff because they don't have but they don't get in that ordinance enough to be familiar with it so now you [43:40] Doug Webster: convinced me you called that a committee of I just gave I quite access standards [43:47] Sue Fleck: committee that's what I call it 's made up of people that already exist [43:50] Doug Webster: that's right this would be part of it and the reason that I proposed there be a committee as I've seen over the years things like design standards as an example and if you ask the code officer to apply building design standards at the time at which someone comes walking through the door with here's my building permit I want you to sign off on this I got an excavator outside I'm ready to go he's got 50 apartments on his desk so and it adds it adds two more sets of eyes and it makes people I think more accountable if you're part of a very small team for this and so the concept if I'm following the conversation here that the concept would be at the time at which you have your fourth or more new dwelling unit this access standards committee would go on site take a look and we could get input from the fire chief and the road commissioner okay what is your bare bones travel with so we could use their input I'm thinking out loud and we could use their input as a template and come up with a baseline standard and if you wanted to we could have existing and new yeah that's fine but the fourth or more additional dwelling unit on an existing access way would trigger this review by the access standards committee and again if the applicant disagreed they could appeal that to the Planning Board because the Planning Board is a little more attuned to those types of questions I'd love to [45:32] Kathy Tamborelli: see tables I loved it I love my tables I love the table it goes to the list of all the things that are required and the subdivision table needs to be updated and add that new line for a new, but the tables I think, if I were a developer, that's what I want to see. And if I'm a planning board member, that's what I want to see, because it's right there. You're not digging through for words. It's somewhere in the ordinance of words that you must meet the standards in Appendix A. [45:58] Doug Webster: This is what CASPER did. [46:00] Sue Fleck: So tell me again then what happens if there's two structures and you're adding a third? We don't care? There's no standards for that? [46:07] Doug Webster: That's a good, I don't know where you guys want that threshold to be. That's up to you. [46:10] Martina Witts: it seems to me the problem could be with it could be are you look at a building permit and there's one and it's a one residential structure how do you know [46:22] Sue Fleck: so you look at that is it what is it two acres doesn't matter the number 40 acres [46:33] Martina Witts: 40 acres and say I'm old the only house on here yeah anything right I'll do anything but I want a long driveway yeah and then whatever but that's the difference between having two acres in a long driveway and you're the only house or you have 40 acres and you're trying to tell them something that you're not [46:52] Speaker G (unidentified): gonna build you're not gonna put another yeah well they give it to the kids the [46:56] Kathy Tamborelli: kids divide the heck out of it right so because it's one number of acres is it [47:02] Martina Witts: Is it a number of acres that triggers the drive, the entrance or the driveway and the, you know, because. [47:08] Sue Fleck: Because if it's in a real subdivision, your standards are, you're going to have covenants that say this can't be subdividable anyway. So it doesn't matter that your driveway is 300 feet long because you can't subdivide it. But like if you're just, if you have a 40-acre parcel, you can do whatever you want, which is fine. [47:25] Doug Webster: If you trigger subdivision, applying standards becomes much easier. yeah I think from what I'm trying to what I think I understand is that it's the non subdivision incremental development so that 's one because it [47:37] Sue Fleck: ends up being a subdivision it really does you know if it looks like a duck and quacks like it you know at the end of the day it may take a decade but it's a subdivision now you know and if somebody I mean it makes it probably yet [47:53] Kathy Tamborelli: you know yeah it makes it really hard is this the little guy yeah that ends up buying a two or three acre lot at the on there and in naples it's a 40 000 minimum lot size and then he's the one that triggers the subdivision just by dividing off one lot and now he's got this huge crappy road and we're looking at him like what are you going to do about the road that's that's where it's hard you're not really a developer it's just a guy [48:16] Speaker I (unidentified): you know or someone that's trying to divide off a lot let me go back to social if they don't care [48:21] Sue Fleck: should we care so what are we caring about as a town what's the part that we care about the [48:25] Martina Witts: We don't want our $500,000 fire truck in the ditch either. [48:30] Doug Webster: That would be bad. [48:32] Martina Witts: You know, and so we are looking up... [48:34] Kathy Tamborelli: $500,000 and we check the prices later? [48:36] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, really, yeah, really. That's a trade-in. [48:39] Martina Witts: But what about the $4,000 ambulance that's coming? [48:42] Sue Fleck: Yeah, I guess, I mean, because if the owner doesn't care, if the guy, you know, whatever... [48:47] Kathy Tamborelli: Nobody cares until somebody dies. And then everybody cares, and why didn't the town make them have a lower minimum road standard, you know? [48:55] Doug Webster: Most municipalities have very few, if any, regulations on driveways to a single-family house once you get off the road. [Speaker F (unidentified): They really don't.] And they just don't want to get involved with having the standard and what's the standard adhered to and who's following up on it. I think it really, my thought is it really should hinge on once you get into two or more, three or more, four or more. I think that's really where the rubber hits the road. But when they happen, it gets its review, I guess, by this committee. [49:31] Kathy Tamborelli: Yeah, I think that's a good idea. [49:33] Speaker H (unidentified): They build a house, and then they say, oh, guess what? My mom wants to build a house on my property as well, and it's going to be over here. That's maybe where we're triggered about, okay, let's see what the driveway looks like. [49:44] Doug Webster: Two, three, four, I'm staying out of that fight. [49:47] Kathy Tamborelli: What's our threshold for major and minor here for subdivision? Is it four? It's four or more. I'm sorry, I get my sounds mixed up in my brain. I don't it's four I want to say four it's four or more you know so maybe it's four more dwelling units triggers just to have a kind of a line a little bit with subdivision we're outside maybe it's four or more dwelling units now you're gonna get to the view from this committee that consists of three staff [50:12] Sue Fleck: members why isn't it subdivision because it's happened over time it's happened [50:15] Kathy Tamborelli: over time but it aligns with the major system it's cleaner in my strain too so [50:24] Kevin Rogers: it is then subject to this team of the committee and they can make recommendations but it doesn't necessarily mean they have to go get the [50:36] Kathy Tamborelli: engineers right so unless there's questions I think they should have the [50:39] Doug Webster: ability to get it to consult you think sometimes in some instances there's one particularly problematic area and so sometimes just that area might warrant the involvement of a PE to ensure as an example that the culvert was sufficiently sized so when we get the 50-year storm is not going to wash out but and so what I did with maybe that this may help I think what I did with and these are and so those are the so one of those is new for new access ways and once for existing and I came up with some basic standards that's the unabridged version and handwritten you can tell we can read it don't you worry okay and so I came up with this access standards committee concept and so the so let's pick on new access There are some basic standards, right-of-way width, travel width, shoulder width, et cetera. The more minor standards can be waived by the access standards committee, but the more major waivers, like right-of-way width, have to be waived by the planning board. And so you have a sliding scale, I think it shows up there. you have a sliding scale of road standards that are contingent upon the number of dwelling units and then the per the trip ITP that's a new twist for the ITP not the number of dwelling units so that and so the concept is that this access standards committee has the first crack at it and if there's an again like we talked about earlier today if there's an appeal from the access Standards Committee that goes to Planning Board or if there's a heavier waiver request that goes to the Planning Board and so you have a sliding scale of improvements based on the number of dwellings where does it say on this [52:45] Sue Fleck: chart which are the ones that they would have to go to Planning Board before to [52:49] Doug Webster: see review that was the original that was the original oh is that Oh waiver [52:56] Speaker F (unidentified): authority I'm sorry I see it now I see it so let's pick on let's have a real [53:02] Doug Webster: world example I think this is going to help a lot minimum travel way are you looking at new or existing I'm looking at new access standards maximum centerline grade that's the maximum slope and so what I proposed is the Access Standards Committee had the ability to waive that up to 15%, but once you get above 15%, that requires a planning board waiver. So that the more minor waivers the Access Standards Committee can have to try to keep the wheels spinning, and then the more major waivers go to planning board. And again, there's a sliding... and that I tried to put those tables together thinking okay you'll see as the number of dwelling units goes up so does the depth of the road base and the concept with that is okay you're only putting in one house you put in six inches of ground now you're up to four houses it's actually relatively cheap to once you have an existing road if you don't have any drainage problems major drainage problems it's pretty cheap to get some gravel and they crack open the tailgate on a dump truck and they drive down and they add gravel they add road base to it 's actually not too and that's the concept as the number of dwelling units go up so that the standards so that was that's what I and I had a so when there were waivers that were requested for that there's some standard draft additional standards that could be applied when waivers are sought this could either be the access standards committee or a planning board consider a wider access way particularly let's say for steeper sections add a paved section just for the super steep part to take care of the stormwater use reclaimed asphalt for problematic areas better stormwater provisions PE professional engineer involvement just for the problematic areas improve existing stormwater crossings paved aprons which you already have in your [55:34] Kathy Tamborelli: standards so you're saying this could be for either the committee or the planning board so if it can't went to the committee it's a relatively small project and they said you know we just don't know how to handle this section here and you get it they could say hey mr. applicant we want you to get a PE for this little section or they could if they if we say no you can't do or you gotta do this and they say no way they can go to the planning board and then the planning board could tell them the same thing maybe okay it's not that [56:07] Doug Webster: dissimilar you're building a house this happened with my house because we don't have the state code in Casco or we didn't at the time I built many code officers if you've got a set of plans and they've got some beams in the house They say, okay, well, the plans all look good. I just need to make sure that beam is adequately sized. And so just the beam gets reviewed by a structural engineer. In this case, obviously, we're talking about a civil engineer. But that's the concept is don't go too crazy with bringing in an engineer. But the thought is that the Access Standards Committee is savvy enough to look at a situation and say,, okay, this area probably warrants some further input. [56:51] Kathy Tamborelli: Yeah, Steve's familiar with the road. He knows there's a runoff issue here already. We don't want to make it worse. [56:56] Sue Fleck: Isn't there some low-cost support from Cumberland County Soil and Water Conservation, too? [57:02] Speaker I (unidentified): There's a little bit, yeah. [57:03] Kevin Rogers: What if we took this concept here that's, and before it goes to the P.E., we said when we're if we're gonna throw in the travel trips then we've got a lot of fairly well educated excavation companies around that have to meet particular education standards I don't know what those are I would probably embarrass myself I threw them out but one of them will say is shoreline zone you know there's some companies out there that are qualified to do shoreline zoning whatever well there's some out there that have got to be qualified to do stormwater whatever and maybe you would have the opportunity in a certain amount of travel ways and under to go to that construction company that met some form of educational standard that could be considered an authority and maybe you'd have to get two opinions on that and if that you know seems to solve the problem then if not then they'd have to go to the PE I think you could get any [58:21] Speaker F (unidentified): and leave the [58:25] Kathy Tamborelli: committee could ask for import right of [58:49] Speaker I (unidentified): you anyway for stormwater yeah just [58:52] Martina Witts: that just comes when [59:00] Sue Fleck: we talked about getting a PE on retainer yeah it just adds a lot of time [59:14] Kathy Tamborelli: to it does especially since we don't have someone on retainer that we can just call [59:19] Kevin Rogers: you know and if there is a level of education that we could kind of hang our hat on with a company like you're saying Pike is doing a road review I mean they install roads statewide but there may be some people not as high level as Pike [59:40] Kathy Tamborelli: that could do that as well do you have the resource for stormwater because we already use Coeur d'Alene County soils and water so that could probably be a pretty quick turnaround for that but I understand you're saying you just try not to add time and we have also made it with an engineer on contract then it wouldn't take a ton of time to do something like this the time also would [1:00:01] Kevin Rogers: be spent on the on the people with the practical knowledge maybe of how is this going to be resolved and what is the cost associated and can we afford to do this would kind of be the I [1:00:18] Sue Fleck: mean I think this I do anticipate like this being a issue but many times I don't think it's gonna be a lot times when yeah people in construction and our access committee can't handle what I don't see that it's gonna be like a frequent issue not tough for the smaller [1:00:35] Doug Webster: roads it didn't happen often in gray and if it's a bigger road that's it's [1:00:40] Sue Fleck: gone I mean if there's more than before it's subdivision and they have an [1:00:43] Doug Webster: engineer that 's right that's it that's actually exactly the issue in many instances it is more than four because it's incremental oh yeah and if you have enough all day if it's a long taupe road down to water or a you know a mountain view or something that's when it really becomes problematic because you've got this long stretch of road that's expensive to improve that's never [1:01:11] Kathy Tamborelli: been reviewed or anything yeah it's just been created over time yep I don't care that it's two separate documents they just need to be consistent that's all that's what I'm looking for is that it says the same thing in every in all places and then it lines up as much that's why I like the number four or more because it lines up with major subdivision I mean there's just some things that make it just consistent and easier for the developer and easier for staff and easier for the planning board so you don't miss something I don't care that it's a separate document because having it separate I know to look there and make sure that so [1:02:08] Doug Webster: if you if you have good standards in where the new I always call it an access way just eliminates the whole driveway road thing and until we can figure out where that line in the sand is in your current driveway and entrance permit ordinance if you're comfortable with that first 25 feet in the standards that are in there then it might be as simple as adding a sentence to the subdivision portion of your land use ordinance that says the entrance shall be in conformance to the driveway and entrance permit ordinance done it's [1:02:45] Speaker H (unidentified): it can be done by reference several years when she retires another person takes over they can see that and not miss something when they go to go do a subdivision or a yeah business or something you know the table also helps [1:03:08] Kevin Rogers: that the same yeah it helps the person in that for and under not have to hire someone to explain what it says we'll get three places to find the table has I think it has one to two it does one to two three to ten eleven to twenty and twenty one plus yep dwelling units so but I think that to meet the changing world we're in we're gonna have to go to that travel thing because the ID you [1:03:42] Doug Webster: ADUs I think yeah and the reason that I think it works is because it's practical because it really what you're after is what is the cumulative traffic on a certain section of a roadway you know so is there data out there right [1:04:00] Kevin Rogers: now that says you know X amount of passes equals X amount of base or is there are there some standards out there already existing for that or well there's other towns. [1:04:13] Doug Webster: Falmouth for years has had a private way review and they have standards so you could look at what like Falmouth, what Casco's doing. [1:04:25] Kevin Rogers: But there's like no engineers out there that have said hey here's kind of a good formula to go by. [1:04:32] Doug Webster: you can usually a lot of times when you're doing ordinance work like this what you do is you look at okay what is the Falmouth require for one to five twelve dwelling units are just easy easier we can switch over to the trip generation yeah what is Falmouth require for up to five dwelling units what a standish require what is Wyndham require what is cast what's Casco talking about and usually they it's sort of just like it's like any ordinance work you it sort of it crystallizes and there's sort of a calm there is common ground that you can see through what other municipalities already require and [1:05:11] Kathy Tamborelli: sometimes have Wyndham has in-house PE so obviously if they've developed standards they've had their PE take a look at their standards and what's the [1:05:22] Doug Webster: the trend the tar versus the gravel usually it's particularly with a winters that we have had the once you get above 10 or 15 dwelling units usually you need either reclaim or some type of pavement what's happening with the gravel roads in particular the subcontractors that plow the roads, the gravel roads in gray around Little Sevega Lake will tell you what's happening is the ground is not freezing and then so you've got the cutting edge on your plow and it creates a big mess even with a good grip most good gravel bases can't if they don't if the if a gravel road is not frozen it's extremely problematic and so I [Martina Witts: checked] that before today the trick getting back to the chips it says there's the ITE trip generation manual says that there's one peak hour that's what they call it one peak hour trip in the morning and one in the afternoon so every dwelling unit has two [1:06:50] Kathy Tamborelli: trips a day I think tennis I mean right now we require payments on every subdivision road right so regardless of so one two three four whatever it is so we require payment so that will be less onerous if it were ten or more which I like I said I have a goal here is to this safety I think that's the goal safety and yes we get shore land the environmental consideration that hasn't been considered on private roads is there i still go back to the to these roads being [1:07:25] Kevin Rogers: constructed correctly from the beginning and is there a way to put a layer in that says if at such time the road is not holding up then it would require tiring like I'm trying to think Naples marina could use access the new one is gravel and that certainly gets more than a 10 unit subdivision gets for sure between all the commercial entities down there I mean that thing wears like iron it has since they put it in and that was swamp land that one across no bottom to that at all that road is holding up strong if you don't make it some potholes but they can rake those out that's a commercial I said things got to be long if it's not 500 it's seven or eight feet long and [1:08:28] Doug Webster: it's holding up strong well then the look at the road that goes into P and K's pit that's gravel and it takes hundred thousand pound trucks all the time all the time [1:08:43] Sue Fleck: sometimes it's more I mean so the condition of a road isn't just the road bed though right it's the it's the ditching and so I just it's the drainage so I just think back to when I first moved here and Gore Road was still a dirt road and now you know it's been paved for I don't know six it still has washouts it still has drainage issue of it so I there's more to the so there's quality of the road that's what I'm saying is if the [1:09:14] Kevin Rogers: road was installed correctly from the beginning yeah you're not gonna have that which there's examples all around town of that so I don't know that so [1:09:25] Sue Fleck: you're just saying you want to get to the point where you're just saying there's not going to be some blanket statement that says X amount of dwellings and this has to be paid requires tarring yeah because I'm [1:09:36] Kevin Rogers: opposed to tarring because I think it's hard to maintain and I when you're talking about these organic subdivisions they're not going to get they're probably not going to have enough dues to have a fund for retiring and then you're gonna have these massive potholes I know of a road in such state but it's a private road and I can't mention it without the landowners permission but it's a great example of the same kind of travel way and a gravel versus tar and I think that in a lot of situations well for me in particular I mean everybody knows I got a tractor because I drive it downtown all the time and I And I have a rake behind that and I maintain a quarter of a mile of my own driveway. And I believe that rescue and fire can get up there any day they need to, 365. And we made sure of that after we had to have an ambulance because it was a life or death situation. But prior to that we were always cognitive of it. But I think that my road is in good shape. How wide is your gravel? I don't know. it's not it could be wider but I have installed a new road in the town of Naples and it's wide enough to pass and it's made it through that hundred year storm we had it's gravel and it's in pristine condition and I would be wild as a hawk if somebody told me I had to put some tar on top of that because now you've made it so I can't maintain that when I've been maintaining it in beautiful condition. Smooth as a smelt. No ruffles or anything. So do you want to [1:11:30] Sue Fleck: see a situation where we don't have any requirement for paved subdivisions? Or are you just talking about these organic subdivisions that happen? [1:11:37] Kevin Rogers: Well, I'm talking about, I think that road condition should play into it. Because I've been subject to this whole, you gotta tar a road in a 10 lot subdivision. and tarring is not needed at all on it. I can give you the address, and you can short drive on it, and that one is 27 years old. [1:11:59] Martina Witts: How many houses are on it? [1:12:03] Kevin Rogers: Ten, but they're duplexes, so we say 20. [1:12:06] Speaker G (unidentified): And who maintains that one? [1:12:09] Kevin Rogers: It's maintained privately. I do, and other owners on that same road. No association? Well, there's an association, yeah,, but you know it takes care of plowing, but everybody chips in on maintenance of the gravel. But it's wide, it's beautiful, two trucks could go up that any time, and there's no washout issues because it was installed correctly from the beginning. [1:12:35] Martina Witts: So ultimately we want to apply those conditions to wherever it's being triggered. When is that triggered? When does that have to be paved? Is it over 10 or does it undertake it all? It's like, in my head, I'm like three. [1:12:59] Kathy Tamborelli: Or subdivisions on the end of substandard roads, substandard because they don't meet whatever the criteria is. But maybe if it's a good gravel road, maybe just because there's already x amount of houses down there, they wouldn't have to pave that road up to the new subdivision. I hear what you're saying, is that what do you do for roads, especially existing roads? you know you're not gonna come back and say hey you gotta pave this now you've been living here for 30 years on a gravel road but now you've got to pave it I [1:13:33] Doug Webster: think so one of the things that comes up and it's in my mind it's it's often very hard to find where that line is between having a requirement on the books and making sure it gets built that way because the only really because like with a subdivision situation that's easy because the as an integral part of the planning board review process there's a typical road cross-section and there's plan and profile plans that are submitted and there's drainage and the culverts are sized and life is very happy because the PE's have done all this and then there's an escrow and the engineers get involved with the third-party inspections but if now it's bridge over to from a new road person and but that's what you pay for when you buy a lot of subdivisions that's what they're building yeah and so and people oh this is a lot in the town approved subdivision it must be a good road and that's why it's up a bit one of many reasons why lots in town approved subdivision sell for typically more than elsewhere but I guess I'm using that as the textbook example but politically legally practically how do you apply putting a standard on the book for non subdivision access ways and have it actually be built that way do you want to ask the code officer to go out there and say yeah it looks like you've got six inches of gravel you know I mean it's really having been a code officer for a lot of years it's an awkward position to be in because you know you're not a PE at the same time you want some standards so I that was one of my questions in here is how let's say we agree on some standards for non subdivision access ways how does how does that get applied administratively where is that practical line in the sand so you're not overburdening the [1:15:35] Speaker F (unidentified): individual property and the town employees in the town yep so right now I [1:15:42] Sue Fleck: I mean, all the other parts of the building permit inspection. They have [1:15:53] Kathy Tamborelli: Steve goes out on site, looks at it, says it looks good. It's not something that the CEO is looking at as part of his inspection. [1:16:01] Doug Webster: Some CEOs know stormwater and drainage, but most are trained in electrical and plumbing. [1:16:08] Kevin Rogers: They are ex-builders. Yeah, well, I was just thinking you could address it like you do in HHE 200, hundred that they have to go out and see it before they cover it but they've got a design they're looking at to say okay yeah looks like there's six rows of pipe here and or X amount of alginins and whatever so they've got something to go by but they're probably not jumping down in the hole and measuring with a measuring tape see how deep the fill is so one thing I lack knowledge in here and maybe you guys would know is, let's just say you do have an engineered system because it's a subdivision. Who oversees that construction? Is that overseeing in construction the same way the HHE 200s are? Is there- Talk about roads. Like if it is, if there's a subdivision, like a Madison Heights that had to have been engineered, I have to imagine. So when that was installed, who's the authority to say, hey, they installed that right? [1:17:17] Kathy Tamborelli: So we don't, we do not have an engineer on contract, so we ask for the reports from the applicant's engineer. When they go, when it's the roads being built, that it was built to the plan that they developed. [1:17:31] Kevin Rogers: So the applicant, the applicant's engineer has an obligation to oversee the construction. [1:17:37] Kathy Tamborelli: to give us a report that he was there and he saw it being constructed to that standard the standard that was designed for the subdivision in bigger [1:17:46] Doug Webster: municipalities what happens is you have typically there's a peer review of the stormwater element of the subdivision and once the set so the stormwater for the subdivision road is designed by the applicants engineer and then once it gets approved the applicant's engineer will do some periodic oversight but the town's engineer paid for by escrow funds that the developer posts is the independent verification that the road is actually built according to the plans and when the road is all done and it's what they call permanently stabilized there's no you know you don't need any erosion control mix or silt fences it's all stabilized they call it once it's stabilized there's a letter from the town's consulting engineer third party that says this road was built according to the plan and if that road is gonna in other municipalities where they do winter maintenance you can't you're not eligible to apply for winter maintenance unless you have that letter from the town's engineer saying that was built [1:18:54] Kathy Tamborelli: So we send the stormwater over to Cumberland County Soils for a peer review, but we do not have third party inspections because we do not have a contract with the engineer. And I don't see that happening this year. Eventually we will. [1:19:18] Martina Witts: That was on the developer, the third party review to put money into the fire. [1:19:22] Kathy Tamborelli: It's always on the developer, but we don't have a contract with the third-party engineer to look and do the inspections on the applicant's engineer's work. Now, I mean, to be 100% honest, I'm not super stressed. First of all, we don't do a ton of major subdivisions here, one. And two, that applicant's engineer still has their stamp on that plan, right? So I'm not super stressed about it, but eventually we should move to that where we have a contract with a third party engineer i mean from a planner it's amazing because i just the minute the plans come in they just get shot right over to the third party review and they take a look at it and they come back and they say instead of me having to struggle with the memo when you have a really good third party engineer they basically write the memo for you and say i think you need this and this and this and they review it against your road standard and they come back with their concerns and then that goes to the other engineer and they work it all out between them and by the time it gets to the planning board it's done you know the subdivision is basically done by the time it gets to planning board final review and it's all on the applicant's dime so at some point in this town we will be looking to get at least a [1:20:32] Speaker G (unidentified): kind of contractual agreement there was a spot where there was yeah it was a five star [1:20:36] Martina Witts: whatever or who was it was some firm and I always wondered why does it have to be that one why does it why can't they choose we get to be embarrassed you know because then they were backed up then they were too busy and then yeah well it's like that with lawyers too [1:20:50] Kathy Tamborelli: it's like that with lawyers too it's the same contract yeah sure contract for services yeah [1:20:56] Martina Witts: so there was at one point that but it came down to my head again my head was if an engineer stands it and a problem arises they're liable because they're saying it was [1:21:08] Kathy Tamborelli: it's on them it comes in useful too when you get on to the site though and there's unexpected site issues that weren't foreseen and then it's always fun to have their engineer and the town's engineer and I want one case where the guy said and then the developer says well I want to do this and then the town's engineer says well that's how I would have designed it in the first place but it's not my plan it's his you know so that but that's when you can work through these problems on site when you have that type of thing so we'll get there I'm not super stressed about it to be honest but it's good that he knows that we're not doing that right so just so up I understand is [1:21:48] Sue Fleck: Doug going to actually draft this for us or where he's gonna draft he's gonna [1:21:53] Kathy Tamborelli: draft this for us and then we're gonna talk to Steve and chief Cox to make sure that we haven't missed anything that's important to them and then it'll come [1:22:03] Speaker I (unidentified): back to you because it and yeah yes so just because we're approaching for [1:22:09] Sue Fleck: gathering and we still have other things I want to make sure Doug has everything [1:22:12] Doug Webster: I think I've got a punch list if I'm reading the tea leaves properly I just want to make sure I've got it here and right here so before the four number [1:22:25] Martina Witts: I get the whole we're not like we're just a non subdivision trigger that we're searching for here is for too late you know is it like at that point where in a subdivision it's not that's should never be too late because they like we were joking it's like this whole emerald forest thing like it's all laid out by engineering stuff whereas now we're doing we're trying to get a safety net for a situation that isn't subdivision is for it like at that point have they gone too far already and you know now that's i guess it's on them it's not it's i think four [1:23:04] Kathy Tamborelli: is okay especially when you're talking about a new in a new scenario as long as you have enough right away to fix it if they do more than four or whatever yeah well i think that's why you have the table for the new ones it says even when you're doing a new one even it's less than four you still got to have that right away you got to have xyz in the first 25 feet however we land on that has to be this that ensures that you have the capability to do it right when [1:23:33] Sue Fleck: you don't move forward we need to have anything different so for again I just want to go back to the distance because four isn't always the same right you could have four within a half a mile of each other but you could have four with [1:23:48] Speaker I (unidentified): them four miles of each other the way the length of the road they talk dead in [1:23:52] Kathy Tamborelli: roads and all that we didn't talk about that so just there is a maximum length [1:23:56] Sue Fleck: yes on there but yep okay I mean is there is there some other trigger perhaps if you just maybe it has to be at three because maybe the roads just gotten too long I mean I don't I don't know okay I think you gotta have a line [1:24:15] Kathy Tamborelli: somewhere but there could be other triggers that length of before you have a turnaround and there's other ways to deal with some of those I hear her what you're saying so maybe after 1,500 feet you got to have a turnaround that type of stuff that's on the table that's on there okay yeah so I mean if we're [1:24:35] Doug Webster: talking about safety yeah so I've got it I think I've got this here so in opposing here we get some input from the fire chief and the assistant road commissioner and use that as the point of beginning if you will for non subdivision access way standards as well as what the minimum is when you have a new subdivision at the end of a an existing substandard road that becomes the base that becomes the basis a new subdivision possible access standards committee [1:25:20] Kathy Tamborelli: it's a staff it's a staff committee and it means that the like my [1:25:34] Doug Webster: example with the design guidelines it's hard when you're I've been there you're you're trying to apply these standards and just give me the permit it's very hard but if you've got three people that are together and the standards are memorialized in the table then it just works better at a subdivision roads to lower if you will subdivision standard I think I termed it rural yeah just some category there's [1:26:08] Speaker F (unidentified): a fourth cross-section from [1:26:10] Kathy Tamborelli: Wyndham that's good for that okay I think they call it a minor rural street okay we're actually applying it to a subdivision that never got completed [1:26:18] Doug Webster: okay so yeah one of the great things about planning is you can access all of this stuff and it's all public there's no copyright it's amazing when you do ordinance work it's really something else and what I've put I throw on the table for just to plant a seed and we can talk about it a subsequent meeting is that the fourth or more lot triggers review outside of subdivision triggers review by the access standards committee but the formulation but once you get a second building permit on a new access way then the code officer tells the person that okay you're getting out of individual driveway land you're moving towards multiple access way so here are the standards so before you put in the second unit I'm advising you that here are the standards only for the new so [1:27:15] Kathy Tamborelli: once you go from a single-family driveway to a shared dress now you're triggering this new set of standards that's going to be in a table yep and [1:27:24] Doug Webster: And that could be applied, I don't want to speak for Randy, but that could be applied as a code officer. And then once the fourth one goes in with this, they call it leapfrog development, that's what they call it. When the leapfrog development scenario, then the ASC gets involved with the fourth one. Does that sound like a plan to get us to the next sort of conceptual? What I do with ordinance stuff, just real quick, I know you're trying to wrap stuff up. [1:27:55] Sue Fleck: and we need a definition for driveway apparently yes we have one somewhere but it's just not across it is that what you're saying it needs to work it needs [1:28:05] Kathy Tamborelli: to be work and it needs to be referred to in the land use ordinances yep the land use [1:28:11] Doug Webster: ordinance including a subdivision portion as well as the usually driveway and entrance permit ordinance should match as seamlessly as possible and I tend to not when I'm doing ordinance work I like to have bullets saying okay here's the net effect of the standard that we're talking about I don't use it that's usually not an efficient use I touched on this in the introduction it's not usually an efficient use of time to draft actual language until there's agreement on what the standard is going to do let's agree on what the standard is going to do in a bullet format and when we're all on the same [1:28:54] Speaker F (unidentified): page then it gets written up which makes great language for when you've got a [1:28:58] Kathy Tamborelli: memo to explain to the townspeople why you're doing this so that way they know why they're voting on it this is for public safety this is for or whatever it is however you want this lower road standard for subdivision allows a lower barrier to doing a minor subdivision you know those type of that type of stuff but why did we do this in the first place what started this [1:29:23] Martina Witts: what was the impetus that's right all right so we didn't really we haven't approached [1:29:38] Kathy Tamborelli: we just talked about a minor rural standard that will move over to subdivision yeah when they trigger subdivision but [1:29:50] Sue Fleck: to your point like once like the subdivisions that [1:29:59] Kathy Tamborelli: no we're not talking about changing the existing road standards other than looking at the base gravel the pavement how much pavement final pavements going on we're not talking about changing those or changing the names of those because that's confusing too we're [1:30:14] Speaker F (unidentified): talking about adding a new column with a new name unless you absolutely have to [1:30:20] Doug Webster: it's really prudent to not change names to within an ordinance or ideally even sections in ordinance because 20 years from now they're going to be looking back at what was section 101,008.4 on a subdivision plan and so then you're [1:30:40] Kathy Tamborelli: gonna have to go in the vault and find the ordinance look it up and figure out [1:30:44] Doug Webster: what it was it just makes it really messy yeah it's just really messy so unless you're it's not good to read people oh we're just gonna restructure all these alphabetically and then they do that every five years it's a mess so [1:31:00] Martina Witts: So what we are working on is going to allow somebody, because we're trying to say that in a four-lot subdivision. [1:31:25] Doug Webster: Minor subdivision. It's a provision where if you, as long as the right-of-way is wide enough, maybe if you're only putting in three houses, the travel width can be even narrower, and when you add the fourth, fifth, sixth, it gets wider. So [1:31:43] Martina Witts: that's, if it's less than four, it's on a subdivision. And it may never be. It may never be. But either way, they hit at the same, they trigger at the same point at four or something. The three non-subdivision, when they hit the fourth, is where subdivision is also. [1:32:04] Doug Webster: Four or more, or you're adding more to an existing. [1:32:10] Kevin Rogers: And to that section of roads, so back to your diagram you drew, let's just say that the infrastructure was built out at the end, and then additional houses are put closer to the town road city road you'd only have to improve up to the let's say that you go over the threshold of the four and the new construction is between the four and the city road you might only have to expand the road for the first four for the first four yeah so that it might require a hammerhead or whatever, but that the whole thing doesn't need to. So there's some real life applicability to this. It's not, you're not putting the code officer or whoever the deciding factor is into looking at these people and saying, it's what this says in black and white, so you're going to have to do it. It doesn't sound right, but we still have to do it. I think we want to be cognitive of what is the right thing and how to not get too complicated but say listen if you're putting in two homes at the beginning of the road and you're only within the 25 feet threshold of the driveway and it doesn't affect the rest of the road then no you don't have to do [1:33:37] Kathy Tamborelli: the whole entire close up to the entrance of the new access way for the subdivision or the private road because it could work in reverse right yeah could [1:33:49] Doug Webster: I get those two they have a good printer anymore or access to do you [1:33:56] Kevin Rogers: think we could get caught can we have copies with a willing to share copies of [1:34:00] Doug Webster: that oh sure this is the least game cards on the table these are this is what Casco this is Casco's work in progress sure we got to get to keep [1:34:15] Speaker F (unidentified): moving down okay thank you very much I hope this is helpful I'll check I'll [1:34:21] Doug Webster: check back with Kathy but I think we're beginning to narrow the funnel there [1:34:26] Speaker G (unidentified): which is it goes from like just yeah so in gray he did the majority of the [1:34:35] Kathy Tamborelli: ordinance work I did some of the lower hanging fruit but he did almost all of it that's what he was there for and I handled the planning board there was a couple of things we worked on together but for the most part that was his role [1:34:47] Doug Webster: so I said when the staff people with it was called the street construction ordinance review committee and we had engineers and road presidents and so it took us a whole year for all of that so why that's right that's right and it's [1:35:09] Sue Fleck: all public so the next thing on the agenda is the data center follow-up conversation yeah I was surprised to see that on there because I thought we were gonna maybe wait till January and the main advisory council came out with [1:35:31] Kathy Tamborelli: their recommendations but we can still do that yeah but remember when we have the conversation how we have the provision in our ordinance where it says as if it's not explicitly listed that it's prohibited. And so we thought we were kind of covered, and it didn't really meet the definition of industrial use, really. It doesn't really mesh. And we don't have similar use, so they can't use that as a back door. But we need to buy time so we can look at additional standards and see what the recommendation comes out from the state agency thing that's doing their thing. Then I looked at essential services [1:36:04] Speaker F (unidentified): and got a little worried. [1:36:05] Kathy Tamborelli: you know so I think we'll still wait until January because we can't we don't have town meeting until May anyway but I just wanted to throw it out there that maybe we should be working on a general encompassing definition and just insert the definition and then we can hang our hat on the if it's not listed in as allowed then it's prohibited but right now I still feel like there might be a back door and what we've got from the public and from this group and others is that you want to make sure that we're prepared before we have an application [1:36:41] Sue Fleck: land on our doorstep so that but we still wouldn't be able to even add a [1:36:45] Speaker I (unidentified): definition until May okay unless we would have a special town meeting right [1:36:51] Kathy Tamborelli: which I don't see let's do it I'm a little weird that this definitions way [1:37:08] Sue Fleck: too big yeah too encompassing because I don't even know what some of these [1:37:14] Kathy Tamborelli: things are is that we don't even really know how what these things are I do know [1:37:23] Sue Fleck: I do know what a hyperscale data center is, and I do know what a co-location facility is. [1:37:29] Speaker H (unidentified): But that's the definition you should be referring to. [1:37:31] Doug Webster: Yeah, no, I'm a member of Oratory Academy. [1:37:36] Sue Fleck: But I would be a little uncomfortable with the initial... [1:37:39] Kathy Tamborelli: Did you hear that, Martina? We're not saying that we use this definition. I just wanted to throw that out there because there's a lot of words in there that I don't know what they mean either. there but at the same time I wanted to make we got to make sure if we're going to do a definition and then not do anything with it that is broad enough that they can't sneak in under small scale large scale yeah different type you know I mean if it's what we don't want but if that's where it lands and of course we had that longer conversation that maybe a smaller scale would be appropriate we don't know we don't and we don't know enough about it right now to talk about it but it's like we said all the rage on Facebook and everywhere but what he just said is good as if we did a moratorium that the [1:38:15] Speaker I (unidentified): maximum is 180 days so you know we need to use on the moratorium yes select [1:38:20] Sue Fleck: board just do a moratorium without a town meeting vote no I don't think so [1:38:24] Speaker G (unidentified): not too much on your charter we don't have a charter you can't but really but it can be dated retroactive it can be ready courts don't like I understand [1:38:36] Martina Witts: that it's legal but it well it's even just more fun just to wave that [1:38:40] Sue Fleck: moratorium flag as the select board so what can we do with the moratorium [1:38:51] Doug Webster: right now. What is the statute? Just get a motion. So there's no charter? [1:38:55] Martina Witts: And then it will go to vote. All right. Whether it be a town meeting. [1:39:00] Sue Fleck: But again, you can't, I'm not going to the special town. [1:39:02] Doug Webster: Don't leave home without it. The town, the select board can't just vote on it. [1:39:05] Sue Fleck: Right, that's what I thought. Right,. [1:39:07] Martina Witts: But the town, they can establish the word and vote on the word to go on as the article on the ballot. [1:39:14] Sue Fleck: For May. Does that protect us between now and May? [1:39:17] Martina Witts: but then it could be it could be retroactive allegedly it can be [1:39:23] Kevin Rogers: allegedly so you're saying there's no time for November you know oh no we're [1:39:28] Speaker I (unidentified): well past the November deadline we already got ballots so that's what I already printed yep you are voting yeah because of election day isn't just an [1:39:38] Sue Fleck: on election day. That's another topic. [1:39:42] Kathy Tamborelli: So that's why we put it on there. [1:39:45] Martina Witts: Even the town is talking about being in war. Like, let's get a moratorium going, let's get a moratorium going, and then I'm not sure that a couple of people have ever even made it to the ballot. It's just things like the care itself. [1:40:06] Kathy Tamborelli: Organically. The marijuana, what the state requires us to allow right now. [1:40:19] Sue Fleck: Are we talking about marijuana? Yeah. Okay. Only the caregiver. Only, yeah. Because the town, it was an opt-in. The town did not opt-in. Moratorium. It's an opt-in. [1:40:29] Doug Webster: So it looks, I'm not a lawyer, but I play one on TV sometimes. I play an engineer on TV sometimes. From the statute, it appears that the initial establishment of the moratorium, if you were to adopt one would need to be done at a duly advertised town meeting it could be an emergency town meeting and the statute says specifically that the select board select board gotta get these two terms has the ability to extend it so the initial establishment would need to be at a special town meeting and then extended by the select board it could be extended 180 days [1:41:10] Speaker G (unidentified): after the initial one was twice but you need to show that you keep putting an [1:41:19] Kathy Tamborelli: effort in also to be working on the standards that you said you were talking [1:41:23] Doug Webster: about right and those can include those conclude size you could make it do you have special exceptions conditional uses here we don't have conditional uses okay because typically conditional uses or special exceptions give the reviewing authority sometimes it's the appeal board but ideally it's the planning board because like we talked about earlier those types of issues but you can put Standish at this I remember specifically they had special exceptions and you can control the size the scope of the proposed development someone comes in I want a big huge data center you can say okay based on the lot based on your impacts we're only going to let you have it be this big so conditional it would [1:42:11] Kathy Tamborelli: be a conditionally allowed use with standards I would love to see conditionally use here we don't have that right now so you can [1:42:23] Martina Witts: we can we have to change the ordinance it has to be written in the ordinance that you can have and [1:42:31] Doug Webster: you have to have review standards that the reviewing entity to be considered in addition to the site plan standards that's how it goes instead of having [1:42:40] Kathy Tamborelli: the list the uses listed the way they are in each zoning district here we have the list of allowed use what they do is they have a table of land uses with each district across the top and then underneath it will either say code officer plant p for planning board or c for conditional use conditional use has to go to the planning board but the conditional use has a set of standards that are somewhere else at the end of the order or in the section of the ordinance for conditional uses and I love the table it makes it easy again for developers and it makes it easy for the code officer because if someone comes in wants to do XYZ they open up and say oh yeah this has to go to planning board see right here is the P it has to go to planning board so it makes it super simple but the conditional use allows you to add extra criteria to the development in addition to site plan standards in addition to site plan, additional standards. And we have that a little bit. We have that a little bit because we have sea, solar, [1:43:38] Sue Fleck: or, yes. You can't be able to see it from any great pond. [1:43:41] Kathy Tamborelli: But it's not called conditional use. It's just like an extra section in your, yeah. But it would be cleaner if it was, for example, any kind of development on 302 out in the commercial zone or certain types of developments, whether it was data centers or whatever it was, these are conditionally allowed and then you just turn the page and here's the standards for these types of uses so I mean that's that's down the road [1:44:08] Speaker I (unidentified): let's take one thing at a time you can't do it table that table they're [1:44:12] Kevin Rogers: referencing is amazing yeah I think we ought to have one of those tables we [1:44:17] Kathy Tamborelli: just did that for the sign ordinance by the way I mean we did create a table so it's a heck of a lot easier because before it was just all a bunch of words and it's like if you were wanting to have a sign you'd have to read the whole chapter to figure out what sign you could have now we have a table yeah George [1:44:52] Kevin Rogers: the barge was the other one yeah I think mr. Cahill was the one that created that table and then you guys came along and did that nope the table was created by [1:45:01] Doug Webster: the gray ordinance review committee which is now the ordinance advisory committee 2010 it was created in 2010 that was just [1:45:19] Sue Fleck: to get back to the data center thing for a minute that so we can't do anything right now is what we're what we're hearing because I don't know that there's an appetite to have a [1:45:26] Kathy Tamborelli: special town meeting so I think what we do is we need to tell me I'm trying to get on an agenda it's been kind of the judges have been kind of crazy right now but trying to get on agenda to give them an update so first of all we can get some direction from the select board and we're gonna we're gonna present the table that we created showing what we've worked on what's passed what we're and we're gonna give it to the select board say what do you want us to move forward with so we're gonna we've done this initial work with him with an initial work on other things is this an important thing to you are you concerned that a data center might slip in here or you know and do you want us to work on that so I need to get on an agenda hopefully in November to present the table and what we've been working on we already know that they've talked to us about subdivision and road standards so I'm not worried about that one but we come up with these new things and then we have nothing talked to the select [1:46:19] Sue Fleck: board yet on those like I said I brought it up last month just because we It seemed to be the only town not talking about it. And every week somebody else is passing a moratorium, and I just didn't want us to be the town that was caught unaware, and I brought it up to discuss because I thought that our ordinance, the way it's written right now, wouldn't allow it, but now you're talking about it could come up. I'm not sure it's an essential service. [1:46:42] Kathy Tamborelli: I see someone making an argument about that, though. I mean, you've got a cell phone in your hand. Digital data. [1:46:49] Doug Webster: Just like they did with the medical marijuana, the bulletproof way to approach it is to amend the ordinance and look at other uses in the same zoning district where this data center would be allowed and have an on-point sentence at the end of each of those that says this use shall not be considered a data center. Data centers are not allowed under this. [1:47:13] Kathy Tamborelli: yeah and they did that with marijuana it does not include do you do American medical make sure that it's not slipped in under that okay yeah I [1:47:24] Sue Fleck: remember that I guess at this point the only choice we have is maybe for you to bring it up to the select board and then they can decide if they want to do a [1:47:31] Speaker I (unidentified): moratorium they want to do a special town meeting I mean it's up to the [1:47:36] Sue Fleck: select board I can't do anything okay discuss next month's agenda we have you have three things listed under priorities oh my god the street mobile [1:47:47] Speaker I (unidentified): bed I want to talk about docks and mooring ordinance that's what's on the [1:47:54] Kathy Tamborelli: agenda actually so that's good that Doug still here okay I did ask Randy to come to that one to talk about the docks and moorings which Randy the T Thurston okay and the harbor master and the potential review process for tear down redoubt bills so he could just talk to us what his issues are right now as the harbormaster for the docks and moorings and as the code officer for the tear down rate so that's definitely in November that's November so we may not have dug back for a couple months we'll see where we're at yeah so touch communicate and then these other ones are the ones that were on the bottom of the tape the Excel spreadsheet that it created that we just kind of let tracker we kind of let those drop for a little bit okay the appeal process one other that's the one that i added because of right now the appeal process for a planning board decision is the board of appeals the board of appeals really doesn't know much about what's going on in this planning board to be honest i mean this should be fair it just hasn't been their wheelhouse and we have the one that went to them and we know how that all went and then another town nearest the planning board is suing the appeals board in the same town I don't want that and so I would like to get it to know when because the attorneys getting paid first can you imagine the attorney I didn't know I could see the appeal so what I want to do is I would like the appeal process for a planning board decision to go to court not to go to the Board of Appeals and that's and that's a pretty simple change to the ordinance so that one's that one's other that's new too but next month I think we're going to be busy enough [1:49:37] Speaker H (unidentified): plus with the appeal process there was something about the dock and mooring the dock and mooring ordinance doesn't have an appeal process in it so if a dock or a mooring is issued by the harbormaster there isn't anything in our ordinance currently that [1:49:53] Kathy Tamborelli: says how they appeal it which our attorney says that would go to court however it's kind of a weirdness even because we've got a CEO and harbormaster one person wearing the same hat and so some people say well yeah but he's the code officer and that says in here that I can appeal a court officer's decision so our attorney says we're okay but we need to fix the ordinance right so exactly that's what she said with the hats just clear as mud right now and it should be right in the ordinance what the appeal process is if you don't like the decision that the harbor master makes on a dock it's very it's very common to have planning [1:50:31] Doug Webster: forward appeals go to court that's that's the norm actually yeah that's right they said there [1:50:38] Martina Witts: shouldn't even be appeals boards they should go straight to the supreme court other people they would save so much time and like whatever because if they if they if they're so adamant about their cause then they're going to go to appeals and they may not they're not going to [1:50:52] Doug Webster: if they want anyway they just skip it just go straight to this you can't get rid of the board of Appeals because it's statutorily required as an integral part of the Municipal Land Authority. Okay. And also think about if someone did have a [1:51:05] Kathy Tamborelli: genuine hardship variance it would just take so long for them. Right. So people of appeals can do [1:51:12] Speaker H (unidentified): variances and setbacks. Stuff like variances and setbacks. Right. I've got to get a copy of that for all of my planning [1:51:19] Kathy Tamborelli: board members. The one McHod doesn't publish it anymore so I've got to find [1:51:23] Speaker I (unidentified): that for you guys that would be good so the next meeting is November 18th yeah [1:51:27] Kevin Rogers: so that's for sure yeah but the review process for tear down rebuilds yeah I thought we had that sketched out already didn't we worked I think all [1:51:39] Sue Fleck: we have to change is that planning board yeah makes the decision or the or their designee right now it's not yeah the office but he's gonna be here anyway for [1:51:47] Kathy Tamborelli: the other one so we should just check with them while he's here and I don't [1:51:50] Sue Fleck: know if Marty brought it up last night at planning board and I'm sorry I [1:51:53] Kathy Tamborelli: couldn't be there but we're all fine that was a minor yeah I know but I know [1:51:57] Sue Fleck: he can't I went to the regional planning board group the other night yeah and we had Jeff could I can't count it chapter 1,000 yeah it was the greatest practical extent and that you know when we talk about greatest practical extent and moving and tear down some things like that I think that's where it really that when that comes into play planning board is I think I should be involved is the Kalanich on is that video yes it's going to be on they were there to report it will be that's all so are we are we ready to adjourn then [1:52:41] Speaker G (unidentified): everybody. I just want to ask one question before this ends up going to the select board. The discussion of the mooring and docking ordinance has been, every time it's been brought up, the threat of the attorneys saying at least it's elite or what we have isn't it or whatever. That's marine safety, that's the elite, the one that she thinks that we might need to ditch. Marine safety. Marine safety. That's a different ordinance. Yes. We're docking and mooring. We have a docking and mooring ordinance and then we have a marine safety ordinance. Okay, two separate things. [1:53:10] Sue Fleck: Oh, I thought it was the one where we'd be charging slip fees. [1:53:14] Speaker H (unidentified): That's the dock and mooring thing. That's dock and mooring. And then we have a marine safety, which is one that he had created a while ago, saying, oh, you're doing this violation, we can charge you for this, we can charge you for that out there. Kind of like policing the marine safety ordinance. [1:53:33] Sue Fleck: I didn't realize that was the issue there. I thought that the hang-up was with the dock and mooring because we want to charge fees. [1:53:40] Kathy Tamborelli: I thought that's well there's a little portion that might be that could be [1:53:47] Sue Fleck: too but with the with the marinas we kept getting the push back on that yeah [1:53:56] Kathy Tamborelli: we are but there's other issues with the dock and mooring besides just that we [1:54:00] Martina Witts: don't need legal yeah we can start reviewing it yes we can start [1:54:05] Kathy Tamborelli: reviewing docking more not yet no we can start reviewing it because we've got other issues like the planning board threshold what the maximum is boat lifts there's all sorts of other things to talk about our master one that they've [1:54:19] Martina Witts: been getting intertwined somehow yeah mm-hmm yeah now we need to have it [1:54:23] Sue Fleck: separate right well and also I think this whole and this is just my take on it but I mean tax can write their own ordinances and then yeah we'll have legal look at it when we're done with what we want to do why we don't think we don't have to ask a lawyer's opinion on what we want to do for an order on the [1:54:39] Kathy Tamborelli: The marine safety one, we need to make sure that we actually have jurisdiction and that we actually can do what they're saying to do. [1:54:45] Doug Webster: You have to be careful. [1:54:46] Sue Fleck: I thought that was established by the fact that we had a harbor master. You have certain jurisdictions when a town takes on a... [1:54:52] Doug Webster: Yeah, but there are other elements. Commercial entities, as an example, I know this because I have one at my camp. Commercial entities are required to have a lease for the DEP submerged land. the state of Maine claims to own all of the land under ponds and rivers and such not rivers just bonds is it river okay I stand corrected okay so in order for a marina etc to be able to utilize that land the space over that they have to have a lease with the DEP submerged lands program but on the marine [1:55:34] Kathy Tamborelli: safety one that one I'm concerned there's some concerns but we want to make sure that we have what we want in any of these first right where we have the lawyer telling us no we know that we just want to make sure that what we [1:55:46] Speaker I (unidentified): create can is something that she could defend right yes well I know but that's [1:55:51] Sue Fleck: why I'm saying shouldn't start with us and then yeah all I've been hearing is that we have to wait for legal's opinion and nothing's been happening so it's a [1:56:00] Kathy Tamborelli: little I've been told not to touch great safety right now a bullet list of what [1:56:04] Kevin Rogers: you want to run it by the attorney so I must be having a brain cramp I don't know what drinking water standards I'm not heard I brought that up many times [1:56:17] Kathy Tamborelli: times on times and the planning board has been requiring water tests for the planning board before the CEOs go but there was a conversation at that time the ORC tabled working on it so but it was on the list of things to talk about again as with short-term rentals I didn't put that on there because there has been no direction from the select board to talk about that again so [1:56:42] Kevin Rogers: So water tests are being required for new construction? [1:56:45] Sue Fleck: Before an occupancy permit can be given in a new subdivision. They have to pass a drinking water test. [1:56:52] Kathy Tamborelli: Not as part of just a private house, not in a subdivision. [1:56:58] Sue Fleck: Right. So we're putting that as a condition of approval in the last couple of subdivisions. [1:57:02] Kevin Rogers: Because of the forever chemicals? [1:57:04] Sue Fleck: Just in general, because that's part of it. [1:57:07] Speaker H (unidentified): Sometimes where they're housing statutes, [1:57:09] Doug Webster: is that LD 1829 as part of that or was it some of the new housing statutes have a requirement there needs to be sufficient drinking water I forgot how it's phrased I mean lenders require potable I forget so I don't remember the [1:57:25] Kevin Rogers: exact language I guess if you paid cash there is no safety net there our [1:57:30] Kathy Tamborelli: ordinance or in subdivision already does talk about the water need to meet these whatever the state drinking water standards is so the fact that we're asking them to show that they do is not a big deal right but we he wanted to delve into that a little bit more and you guys tabled that all right five [1:57:49] Sue Fleck: o'clock okay we're ready Smith meeting is adjourned yes okay thank you thank you LRT thank you