Durham Planning Board Tables Bowie Hill Subdivision Review Due to Wetland and Mapping Concerns
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:33] Walk up music. That's it.
[1:21] [clears throat]
[2:57] Good to go anytime.
[2:58] All set?
[2:59] Yep.
[3:00] Okay. [clears throat]
[3:03] Everybody ready for some fun?
[3:05] Yep.
[3:06] All right. roll call. Myself, Juliet, Darren. Darren is now has been bumped up
[3:19] motion work permanent member. Thank you very much for helping us out here. Appreciate that. And Alan Purrington, Brian Snicky Snick, me not be here tonight. just an administrative note, George. at the the agenda,
[3:40] if we can just update that to take Sunny's name off and
[3:44] Oh, yes.
[3:44] Change the status.
[3:46] Sure.
[3:49] Pledge.
[3:55] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. [clears throat]
[4:13] Do we have any amendments to tonight's agenda?
[4:24] Seeing none, we'll move on to item number four. acceptance of the meeting minutes from the October 7th, 2026 meeting.
[4:37] Has everybody had a chance to review the meeting minutes?
[4:43] [clears throat] Any comments?
[4:48] I move to accept the minutes from the October 7th meeting.
[4:54] Second. All in favor?
[5:02] You good?
[5:03] Yeah, I wasn't here.
[5:04] Oh, okay. Okay.
[5:09] Okay, that passes.
[5:18] all right. Informationational No, item number five, informationational exchange on non-aggenda items. Mr. Farge, would you care to review your report with us?
[5:30] Yes, I did include my monthly report that goes to the town manager and with and is copied to the select board. recapping the October 7th meeting that you performed as well as a some follow-up work I've been doing from the last interim economic development committee meeting and the next meeting of that group will be on November 9th which I think is next Monday.
[5:56] I've continued to do the artificial intelligence machine training for processing applications and preparing documents and minutes. Currently, I'm just using the general chat GBT but which the town provides but I will be using an add-on called codeex which is much more systematic in processing the materials that we prepare for you.
[6:23] I have finally updated all of the applications on the website for the 2026 amendments. So those should all be current. I just finished this week the private way application. Now that you have jurisdiction full jurisdiction over those plans that now u I have prepared an application that includes a checklist
[6:46] that will be available to applicants. And then finally Brian brought up the issue on the in the report about the historic commission and there is currently a serious gap in the town's administrative capacity with the overhaul of the historic district
[7:09] commission and historic district provisions. A couple of years ago, the thenstanding historic district commission, which was being retoled into an advisory group, they basically all resigned. And so the town has put out a request for people with certain qualifications,
[7:30] engineers, architects, historic preservationists, you really need to review those projects, someone with some level of expertise, which had been lacking in the past. So, I've offered to the PL and at this point CO both the code officer and the planning board if an application comes in
[7:50] for any of the eight properties in town that are on the National Register of Historic Places or any of the abuing properties to those that group is supposed to give an advisory opinion on whether it conforms to the national guidelines for historic preservation to the code officer.
[8:11] and if you are reviewing a conditional new subdivision application for those properties or the ones around them, then the historic commission is supposed to give you a recommendation. but there is no historic commission at this point. And [clears throat] so I've offered a couple of draft options for amendments to the ordinance that would basically
[8:32] u have the planning board fill in in that capacity in the event that the historic commission cannot fulfill its duties or just transfer over the full responsibility for historic preservation reviews to the planning board. And you would just do that as part of your normal review process. And if an application came in that the code officer needed assistance on then you would give that advice to the code officer and recommendations.
[9:02] And we have unlike the planning board the historic district commission never had staff support. So I'm not an expert on historic preservation. However, I have been dealing with it for a long time. I was the manager for the city of Helena, Montana that had like 66 registered properties and three districts.
[9:22] So, I'm very familiar with the program. and if need be, we can always consult with the main historic preservation commission, which we probably would do anyway. So, that's an update. in reviewing that you have already gone through your process of trying to prioritize what issues would be on your plate going up to the town meeting.
[9:46] So I did suggest to the town manager that because it's really an administrative issue for the town for the town manager that perhaps that could be dealt separately by the by the select board directly because [clears throat] again it's just simply fixing how the town is going to administratively
[10:06] process those applications that are in the ordinance. So, I'd be happy to answer any questions.
[10:13] based or not based, what about a third option being that any application that comes forward that needs review by a historic mission or something like that goes to the third party engineer review. Sometimes they have
[10:33] historic people on staff and that it would be the costs and would be born from the applicant them knowing full well ahead of time, right? Hey, you're going to need this just because I think, you know, you brought this up is not many people have this experience.
[10:56] and I mean I have a little bit of it, but not
[11:00] I know I feel like we'd be doing it possibly a disservice in that like if an applicant is, you know, applying to do something that triggers this, then put it on them to
[11:13] go to third party.
[11:17] Yeah. My respon my response to that is that it's it would be good. However, the problem I think would be that you'd have to institute a whole fee structure to cover those costs. Whereas at this point, if we keep it in the in the planning board with my assistance and relying upon the main historic preservation commission for the expertise,
[11:39] there's no charge to that as infrequently as we get it. So, yeah.
[11:43] that would require
[11:45] will the MHPC help us for free? Like the main historic preservation? Yes. Main Historic Preservation Commission offers advice applications and they certainly are qualified. They're the ones that make the determinations.
[11:59] I didn't know that they would help.
[12:00] Yeah.
[12:01] Okay.
[12:01] Yeah. And again, we haven't had one in two years, so the likelihood of it is pretty limited. There was a subdivision, the Windgate subdivision on Moro'sboro Road that was adjacent to one of those properties
[12:12] and so they would they offered to assist on that. So, yeah, I think it'll be coming. main thing is right now having a way if an application comes in they're not stuck because the town doesn't have a store condition.
[12:27] Yeah,
[12:27] we have to fix that.
[12:28] Okay. All right.
[12:30] But that was a good suggestion.
[12:32] Yeah, just a thought like we shouldn't have to like you know
[12:37] you know make something not make something up but we don't know.
[12:40] Well then the standards are somewhat subjective and that's part of the difficulty with it.
[12:44] Yeah. I mean
[12:45] Yeah.
[12:45] Okay. Yeah. So, right now, we don't know if it's going to be a land use ordinance update or if the select board is going to manage it.
[12:52] It would have to be an update to the ordinance, but I'm suggesting that the select board deal with that as opposed to you or the agriculture committee is dealing with agriculture. You're dealing with three other big policy issues. And this is really not a big policy issue. It's more of an administrative issue for the for the town code officer. And
[13:12] so, we would go directly to the select. Now, obviously, they're going to refer it to you for review, but I didn't put it on your plate because you went through your whole process and that wasn't on it.
[13:26] All right. So, this is something that could be added to our list for annual subdates.
[13:32] It would be added as a warrant article.
[13:34] Yeah. Okay. Okay. and when you say applicant, [clears throat] from what I recall when all this went on, there was some ambiguity with the code enforcement officer and as far as what kicks off a review of a historic, a renovation to a historic,
[13:58] like can they if they have to fix some siding or
[14:04] Yeah. if the porch has fallen apart and they need to put up new columns, there seem to be a fuzzy barrier there as to when we would or it needs to be reviewed by somebody other than the CEO.
[14:18] Yeah, there was confusion and part of the issue was the historic district commission process was just fly by night. didn't really have a good set of procedures or standards and you know they would review an application once a year at most and they didn't really have to
[14:38] that's part of the benefit of doing it with the planning board because you have this process already set up you already have staff assistance and we will refer if we need assistance so hopefully the what was done in 2024 I think it was that we adopted that overhaul has kind just streamline the whole system down to something that's much more workable.
[15:02] Yeah, it was 2024. So, I guess it's still up to the CEO to determine whether or not it should go any
[15:10] further than his permitting requirements.
[15:12] Yeah. And the reality is it's it starts on his desk anyway, right?
[15:16] Because they apply for a building permit and he has to look at that.
[15:19] Okay. But if any subdivision comes up that's adj adjacent to any of these properties, that's when automatically comes here.
[15:30] That would be I would need to determine that.
[15:33] All right.
[15:37] Any comments on that? You're all kind of clear. It's been a while. It's been before your time.
[15:45] Mhm.
[15:48] Okay. Anything
[15:59] else to add, George?
[16:00] No, I'm good. Thanks.
[16:01] All right. 5B. anyformational exchange on non-aggenda items from the any residents of the town of Durham?
[16:16] Seeing none. anyformational [clears throat] exchange on non-aggenda items from any non-residents of the town of Durham? Check. Okay. item number six, continuing business. 6A,
[16:34] substantive review of Bowie Hill subdivision phase 2, preliminary subdivision plan application, Matty Lane, map 10, lot 38. Public comment will not be taken.
[16:48] George, would you like to review your notes?
[16:51] Yes, I will summarize those for the board and members of the public. the board determined the application to be complete on October 7th and you have granted you did ask the applicant to bring in additional information to address some of the specific issues related to tree clearing and wetland
[17:14] potential wetland filling. the board did provide a supplemental packet of information on October 6th and then they also provided some additional information on October 21st and then finally on October
[17:35] 26 they had a phase one analysis and then just today I received a updated figure two and So, one of the issues for the board to discuss and decide is whether you will admit any of that information that came in after the 14-day deadline before the meeting.
[17:55] I do think some of it is really important and relevant to trying to sort through what exactly is on the ground out there to help you decide whether you can move forward with the preliminary approval or not. And so again, but technically under the pro policy that was you enacted a few months ago,
[18:16] the 14-day deadline, you have the discretionary authority to consider something, but you have to determine that there's an extenduating circumstance that warrants admission of that information because you don't have an opportunity to review it well in advance. I don't have time to opportunity to process it and get the packet out to meet the deadlines for publication.
[18:38] So, I [clears throat] think pretty much where this is going is you're going to ask the peer reviewer to review a lot more than you normally do. typically it's just the engineering plans to make sure they follow standard practice in the past few month few applications. You've asked them to look at the billing envelopes in detail because some of them have been very questionable.
[19:02] and so in this particular instance, I think we're looking at looking at trying to determine exactly how much street clearing has occurred in both phases one and phase two and make sure that correlates with the calculations for storm water management and phosphorus management because that's one of the issues with the amount of clearing that's done.
[19:26] One of the ways to limit the generation of storm water pollutants and phosphorus is through vegetative buffering through woods or buffer strips. So that is probably most important to be addressed through that calculation process of the size of the filtration basins
[19:47] as opposed to having a ordinance specified limit on how much tree clearing you can do on these cluster lots. there is no specification in the ordinance. The 20% rule that is sometimes applied I think is intended to say the storm water treatment and phosphorous treatment systems are designed for this capacity
[20:11] based on no more than 20,000 square feet being cleared on the lots. So, the applicant in his, [clears throat] for some reason the consultant thought that there was a 20% limit. And so, you saw in the diagram that was submitted as part of the preliminary updated preliminary plan application,
[20:32] some of these building envelopes on there were as small as around 9,000 square ft. So, that's just not realistic and is not required. So the applicant has been working to retool everything and they did a drone some drone analysis to try to determine exactly how much clearing has been done and we still have the issue of the fact that the lots in phase two were cleared prior to any preliminary or final approval.
[21:00] So that is an ongoing issue for the board to try and deal with as we go forward in the process. [clears throat] the applicant in his most recent submissions indicated that there are additional lots in phase one that have had wetland filling without permits and they've indicated that they intend to get in touch with the DP
[21:22] as well as the code enforcement officer to try to resolve those those apparent wetland alteration without permit violations. I did speak with the code officer today and he said he was not aware of that yet. So he has not been notified of that potential issue. There was lot 13 as I understand it and
[21:42] Mr. Bern can clarify for the record when he comes up what the status was of I think it's lot 13 that I think that's the one where you had to adjust the rear lot line because the building was pushed farther back and didn't meet the setback and there must have been some fill associated with that infringed upon some lands.
[22:02] [clears throat] as I said I think it's important that the peer reviewer really drill down deep on this application because of the inconsistencies. just the issue of the verification of the drone analysis which has accuracies of plus or minus 10% and plus or minus 5 ft. So, I think it's important that the peer reviewer take a look at that and determine whether the analysis that's been done is of adequate accuracy for the
[22:33] purposes of the storm water management plan. you did entertain the potential waiver on the road width from phase one which is 20 ft. continuing that instead of the 24 ft into phase two which you seem to be in accepting that doesn't make sense to make the wider road beyond the narrower road but you'll have to include that in your decision making.
[22:59] so I, at this point I did include in the packet enough information, including some draft preliminary plan approval conditions that I attempted with AI assistance to address all of those issues in the draft preliminary approval conditions that are in your packet to really give enough specificity to make sure that any preliminary approval you give doesn't approve anything.
[23:28] in related to the violations or anything of that nature. It'll just enable the process to move on to the final plan stage which they have previously had a preliminary approval and lapsed. So I think the important thing at this point is to move forward as expeditiously as possible for the town's sake as well as the applicant.
[23:51] and I did, as I said, I did have do have draft and I also have a draft motion if you determine that you're prepared to move forward with a preliminary approval based on those conditions, approval conditions as you may choose to amend them or not. If you're not comfortable that the applicant has meant to do burden proof to convince you that their project can meet the standards
[24:18] and you just don't feel it's ready to be reviewed under the current ordinance, then you have that option as well to table it and tell the applicant to come back when they resolve certain issues that you might raise tonight.
[24:34] [laughter]
[24:34] Thank you. Okay,
[24:35] there's a lot.
[24:39] before we dive into it, just getting back to some information that was submitted after the deadline,
[24:46] right?
[24:47] you know, we made an effort to change our deadlines to accommodate some administrative tasks yet. I think we need to stick with that. I think we need to be stick with it and maintain consistency through all of these future and current applications. So I mean anything that was received after the 21st
[25:11] we should not be reviewing or discussing at this point. Is everybody okay with that?
[25:18] Yep. And what you're saying is the 21st is 14 days and that's what our ordinance states.
[25:23] Yes.
[25:24] That's that cut off for 14,
[25:26] right? And there was there was some supplemental information that was submitted on the 26th and it sounds like even more as recent as today.
[25:36] Yeah, just to clarify, I had made a suggestion that what you're looking at now is not even what the applicant is proposing in terms of that diagram showing those 20% clearing limitations. So, I did suggest if you get into it tonight, it might be helpful for the board. You can actually see on the on that air photo the dark shadow areas are pretty much the cleared areas.
[26:01] That's the shadows of the trees within those areas. But again, it's not clear either from the drone footage or from the particularly from the green indications there what they are proposing. So, I did suggest to the applicant that he might want to come in tonight and have some diagram that shows what he's actually what they're actually proposing.
[26:24] But again, if you feel that was not submitted within a time timely manner, you have every discretionary authority to say we're not going to look at that tonight. Come back next month.
[26:37] I have a recommendation. If I could just
[26:40] get right into it. I agree with you. I do think and I don't know if we need a vote right now. I think we should stick with our required timelines needed of submitted materials before meetings just to give everybody time to review and I don't think it's fair for others applications that do stick to those.
[27:00] so I think that is a thing we should stick with.
[27:05] I don't know if we need a vote on that or not. Can I just ch
[27:13] Let's let the board comment on this first,
[27:17] please.
[27:19] What do you think about that?
[27:20] I agree with enforcing the timeline, but I would like to have the applicant's input on
[27:31] why something was late. not that would be justification
[27:36] but it would be an education for us if we need to enhance anything we
[27:43] that's fair
[27:43] impose out there but I agree with right now that's what we have we should enforce it.
[27:49] Thank you. No I think that's that's why I think that is fair. Yeah.
[27:53] Yeah. It 's they put it out there. We can ask the applicant to give us commentary on it. but
[28:03] yeah, we'll leave it at that.
[28:05] and then further I would I would like to say that there's a lot of things that are changing here, a lot of things that aren't complete. I think we need to back up and kind of go through what is needed to fully review
[28:26] this project. I think we're getting ready, if we haven't yet, to send this to the third party reviewer. but we can't yet. Like, these materials are not are not complete, not done. I mean, maybe they're complete, but they're not accurate. we really need accurate submitts.
[28:47] and I don't know if the applicant is confused as to what we're looking for and when. So maybe it would be helpful to like literally go through line by line what we are looking for what we need whether it's like the coverage of the tree clearing wetland delineation which I'll speak about in a second DP
[29:09] response storm water all of those things that we need that need to be accurate and updated and sent in within 14 business days of the next meeting. That's my recommendation is that we don't even really get into like
[29:28] the site plan beyond explaining what we need to see on certain things.
[29:36] Yeah. One of one of the things that certainly concerns me is when I'm hearing that there were related to phase one there were wetland alterations performed and we're still waiting for information from D about that. How until I would see DP's announce of that, how can we even proceed to phase two?
[29:59] Exactly.
[30:00] Yeah. no, great comments. So, we have deemed the application complete.
[30:07] Okay.
[30:08] I said complete. I didn't mean that word. Sorry. I know you guys did that.
[30:11] That's all right. So, now we're into
[30:13] accurate. Accurate might be the more the word I was I needed to use. Not complete. Accurate. the [30:23] materials need to be accurate.
[30:26] Gotcha. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
[30:28] Instead of complete,
[30:28] right? So, we can get into that.
[30:31] would you prefer I think we should have the applicant
[30:37] from them and hear from them
[30:39] and then we can get into I think if as the conversation moves along,
[30:44] we'll determine what's
[30:47] deficient.
[30:50] speech just the barge to keep great notes.
[30:56] You ready for me?
[30:58] I'm Charlie Burnham. I'm the engineer. I'm representing John. He's not here tonight. see if I can attack these all in a row. [31:09] in terms of the timeliness, I think George mentioned it kind of briefly that if there's an extranuating circumstance and I think when we looked at completeness and we looked at the things that were provided,
[31:23] the request came during the last planning board. It wasn't like there was a an outstanding ordinance that I missed and didn't go back. It was it was a request to help clarify what it actually there to do out of out of scope kind of assessment of what's been done out there and the fact that we were able to get a drone survey done and do the best we could at I think the other figures George do a better job of I went and traced out the actual tree limits as best I could by zooming in and the photo is actually super high definition
[31:54] so I can zoom in and it still stays very clear. so I did the best I could to kind of trace out where the trees were, where the trees aren't. As far as the wetlands on phase one, those are those are things that we self-reported to the DP. when I walked out there because John is having a problem with the driveway, I noticed it and part of the reason it got hit is because of that old townhouse that was there.
[32:18] Remember that during phase one, there was that historical building.
[32:21] They came in and demoed that. And when they came in and demoed it, that was their access way in so they didn't punch off of Bowie Hill again. They came down that driveway and zipped right through to the left there through those wetlands. So it was like a logging trail that they had used for demo and so it became less and less identifiable as wetlands. So when John came in or whoever the site guy was, they didn't see the delineations and they just went right through it.
[32:43] We came, we pulled back all that fill, we called the D, we told them what we had done. and because we had the D permit coming through, they said, you know what, just put it all in with that one package. We'll review it all at once. It's not it doesn't hit the threshold of mitigation or any of that. It's not a huge area. And once and we did mitigate it. So, we're like, we pulled it back. So, I don't even know if it 's kind of like this weird area like I don't if it counts as wetland impact because you hit it, you pulled it back, you restored it before they even saw it.
[33:09] We told them about it and they're like, it's restored. So, the other part was that other finger there that we caught during the drone survey. So, we had to update that. See that little slit? That finger that comes up and in there
[33:20] where
[33:21] on lot [snorts] over one. So, it's 13. Is it 12, George?
[33:26] I'll be 12.
[33:26] Oh, a blazer. [33:29] this is why he gets the intro music.
[33:31] This is why [laughter] he's he's got the gadgets and I guess while he's doing that about phase two clearing, what they've done is they logged the road and what we did in the very beginning is we walked this property and found the logging roads and we located our roads along those as best we could while meeting the geometry that we had to which is why like you see where our wetlands are right there where we crossed it on phase two.
[33:54] That's why it's split there is because that road was already built up as part of a logging crossing. So everything we've done has always been to mitigate our environmental impact has always been to be a net zero subdivision and the irony is to do subdivisions well and to do them to this scale you actually don't make a lot of money right so [34:13] there is a rental fee
[34:14] there is see I just told you they don't make a lot of money on these so so this is the one there's that little finger there they went they pushed right into that [34:25] you mentioned there was a new wetland that was found or new.
[34:30] So this is the part that we restored and reported.
[34:34] Uhhuh.
[34:34] The down there number
[34:37] 13, I think. And then this is the part that we noticed when we did our recent drone survey that we had to go and I amended it three weeks ago when I was doing all this. So there was a lot to do in the last 3 weeks just to try to get to this point of being like, okay, yep, we did hit some more wetlands. Again, it's we're we're still below the threshold of wetland impacts because throughout this whole thing, we haven't touched any. and again, that was always our intention was to make this thing as minimum impact as you possibly could.
[35:02] As you can see, there's an enormous amount of open space in this thing compared to what we've put out there. we certainly didn't squeeze everything we could out of it. And, that was always John's intention is to do it well and to do it right. and that leads me to the phase two clearings. They didn't log, they didn't stump anything outside the rightway. And cutting down trees, as far as the D is concerned, isn't disturbance.
[35:23] like once you start disturbing the soil and filling things like now you started to mess with how water flows but just clearing trees actually isn't considered disturbance as far as they're concerned and so part of our idea or part of the vision for the subdivision is like I said these net zero houses and in order to do that you need solar so some of the taller trees were cut to and we'll allow and that's kind of the discussion I'd like to have tonight is
[35:46] George is right I very quickly threw I initially had 20,000 square feet on there I read something that threw me to 20% %. So then I updated the table, slimmed them down and then obviously last meeting's conversation. Okay, maybe it is 20,000. So we went back and we amended that. And then I went and did an analysis on phase one of how much outside of 20,000 did we do?
[36:08] And I think if you were to see that, I don't know if that made it to you guys, the only ones that were above 20,000 are the two the three that we combined. So the total allocation that we had for phase one is less than or equal to what we had asked. And on top of that when we talk about our storm water modeling the way I designate the areas in areas inside of our
[36:31] sub our developed area our new lots is I model them as one acre lots. And in the hydrocad model that assumes 20% impervious and 100% clearing. That means that you stripped it down to the it's grass and 20% impervious. So obviously all of those storm water numbers are extraordinarily conservative. Again, when we talk about forested buffers and that is what provides a great amount of treatment.
[36:55] Every one of these lots is located along a r that road's a ridge and everything slopes away gradually. So all those trees out behind it, the wetlands that will that we're always trying to make fake ones of to treat the road surround this thing, treating every drop of water that comes out of it to a exorbitant amount. so I just want to make sure the picture is painted correctly that this John is not a land ravaging
[37:20] developer. He tried to do it right. He's trying to do it by the books. The reason he logged the forest when he could was to get out of the bat season, right? like every step of the way he was hoping again and that's on me and DP just the back and forth and very long story but the reality is John's always wanted to do it right and it's kind of nice that he's not here that I can say nice things about him he won't ever hear them [37:46] he's recorded
[37:46] yeah he's he won't watch it leave that out of the minutes so again the reality is this subdivision's intention has always been to be environmentally friendly and to leave as little impact. I mean, we pulled this thing back off that Bowie Hill Road 100t further than we had to just to give it that rural feel to get keep it keep it buffered, keep it secluded from the neighbors.
[38:09] And yeah, I just want to make sure the picture is printed properly. And there's a there
[38:15] is there part of the submission that was after the 21st?
[38:17] No, this is this is his submission.
[38:19] The ones after are cleaner. I went and traced each line cuz I thought you wanted me to show you what I had proposed versus what's happened. And George was right. like it just didn't look it didn't communicate what we were trying to communicate clearly. So then I went for a second figure and traced out all the tree limits, calculated the areas that have been cleared for each of the first phase and for the second phase to the best of my ability and then [38:42] again from a storm water modeling standpoint and a and a phosphorus modeling standpoint, we've been extraordinarily conservative across the board. Can you talk about lot seven that's right there in the middle of the screen that's clearly been altered beyond the limits of the wetlands?
[39:03] Yeah.
[39:04] Were you aware of that?
[39:06] No. The house is looks like it's actually
[39:09] I Yeah, the road look at the center of the road. The whole thing could probably be shifted. The picture could probably be shifted 10 feet to the south on this one. If you look at the other Yeah, the other figures are better. This one was bigger. A bigger aerial fit to a larger area. The other one I did smaller aerial was fit to see.
[39:29] Are you saying there's no wetland filling on lot 7?
[39:32] I'm not saying that. I'm saying it's it's not as bad as it looks right there. And I on the second drawing I did, I don't remember having any in that this that figure one and figure two.
[39:44] I have a recommendation, Brian, for us next steps here. I 've written down three things that I think are the biggest topics that we need to get squared away. one, tree clearing, what to do with that, what we need to see for that. Second is wetlands,
[40:05] what we need to see with that. And the third is DP response or DP generally. I that's what I'm hearing are the kind of like the three big topic issues. There's other things that to talk about, but those are the three really big ones. maybe if we go through each one and discuss what we're looking for
[40:28] and the concerns, questions we have, I think that might wrap a lot of things up as far as next steps.
[40:36] Okay.
[40:37] What do you all think? Is there anything else besides those three items? Wetlands, tree clearing and DP or not enforcement but DP. Anything else?
[40:49] No, I think those are the dominant ones which we've been discussing. D per
[40:55] Yeah, D. Yeah. Yeah, that's good. DP peritting. Okay, great. And if I could, I would like to recommend that we do tree clearing at the end and we hit wetlands first and then DP and then and then what we need to see for tree clearing
[41:16] or whatever. It doesn't matter. I guess I was just I think tree clearing is big, really broad
[41:24] and then I can start then.
[41:25] Darren, you okay with that?
[41:26] Yeah. All right.
[41:27] Y
[41:28] for the wetlands. one thing I would like to recommend to the board to think about is that the wetland delineation that was completed for this project that was submitted for phase 2
[41:43] or at least referenced is from more than 5 years ago which pretty much makes it invalid.
[41:52] What was it the year? 21 I believe I think it's July of 21 or something of 21. [42:02] in addition phase one was complete after this wetland delineation was done and it has changed the environment quite a bit in such that hydrarology could have changed and thus that wetland delineation that was completed before phase one is not accurate anymore.
[42:23] So with both of those things being said, I think it would be best if there is a new delineation completed for at least phase two. and that is done by an outside party, third party.
[42:40] Oh, I can't do that. I have I have heard that because of the weather we've been having it's still you can still have this done this year a delineation.
[42:54] Yeah.
[42:54] Is that what you meant?
[42:56] No. When you said third party I think I think you guys hire them or like I'd hire
[43:01] Oh just [43:03] John doesn't do it. No, I think the proper way to do that is have them do the delineation and have G Palmo do a peer review of it, including field investigation if necessary.
[43:13] Yeah. However, we want to work that out is fine, but just
[43:17] that's our third party.
[43:18] Yeah. And then have someone check it, I guess, would be is that what you're saying? Goro will review that just like everything else.
[43:25] Yeah, sure.
[43:27] [43:28] where did you pull it? What's the five years based on? Are we is this a
[43:32] it's it's a [43:36] I think it's what the state relies on.
[43:41] Again, that could be a peerreview issue. Is that wetland u delineation valid either from outdated or because of alterations to the hydraology through phase one?
[43:56] Yep.
[43:59] [44:00] I think I think the only wetland thing that is it's like a if I had an army corps jurisdictional assessment made which we didn't have to do we expired [clears throat] that like determination last 5 years but wetland reports
[44:17] I think when the DP is looking at your application
[44:24] because one of the concerns is that one of these wetlands was crossed with the road that with the phase two that wetland does not end where the old delineation said it did.
[44:40] I
[44:41] So that is one of the concerns that came up.
[44:42] If a second one came back, I promise you they're not going to see anything there now.
[44:47] No,, no. But you can still see hydraulic. You can still see certain bits. I'm just saying this came from the conservation commission and out in the field it was somewhat,
[44:57] you know. Okay. I thought
[44:59] Yeah.
[44:59] Yeah. If we could ask a third party to verify the validity of a wetland survey, that'd be awesome.
[45:07] Yeah.
[45:07] I'd appreciate that.
[45:09] Okay.
[45:10] So, that's one
[45:10] what I'm hearing is instead of being proactive and having a delineation done before it goes to the third party reviewer, a peer a peer review, we're going to send everything to the peer reviewer. Ask them if they think the information is accurate. If they say no, then it just prolongs the process. Is that
[45:31] I think they can send me a two sentence email.
[45:34] Yeah.
[45:34] What is the What is How long do you How long do you consider wetland delineations? I think it's two question. Yeah. I'd hope they can get back to that.
[45:42] Yeah. See what Gor Palmer says. Yeah.
[45:44] But again, I don't think we're talking about having this peace meal peer review. No. When the whole package goes to that
[45:52] 100%. Yeah.
[45:53] But I'm I'm waiting to get there. like we're still early.
[45:56] I'm I'm just I'm just looking out for John's messages to send to spend several thousand dollars to send a wetland scientist out there to do something that's been done that might not that's a worth that's worth an email in my if we could
[46:07] and maybe some spot checks are recommended.
[46:09] Sure.
[46:09] Whatever. Yeah. Whatever our third party thinks. This is over 5 years old and this whole phase one was built around these wetlands which could absolutely change hydrarology in this area. So both of those two things together, if Coral Palmer thinks that,
[46:27] you know, just keep going, then that's Yeah. Okay. So yeah,
[46:31] prior to the full package going to the peer review, we're going to get an a determination from them. No,
[46:37] no. Get an email.
[46:40] Send the whole package.
[46:41] Whatever you want peer reviewed. Again, you can have the peer review of whatever parts of this you want done before you need your preliminary approval or as a condition of preliminary approval. You have either option if you're if you're so concerned with the accuracy of the submissions. Then you can have that reviewed by the peer reviewer
[47:03] before you make any decision. Mhm. But I think what we decided here is that we would send Goral Palmer third party reviewer a couple questions whether or not they think that the current delineation is accurate and something we should rely on.
[47:16] So I'm going to back up from what I said earlier. I think what you if you're saying you don't want to even give this a preliminary approval until these issues are resolved, then I think the track that you're on Yeah. these three issues, I would recommend doing a peer review of those limited issues and then once you get beyond this, then they just check all the other stuff.
[47:41] Yeah, I'm just trying to speed this up as far as fast as possible for the applicant knowing it's November and if we could just get an answer on this delineation question, if it needs it, you guys can get it done before the end of the year. If it doesn't need it, fine. Well, I guess that's the hard part is if the if we're truly trying to speed things along for the applicant. The D thing's always something that's kind of a condition upon final approval.
[48:05] You know, that's that's pretty standard. I think you guys have all done that for us. At least I think on every product I've ever done with y'all. the wetland delineation question, again, I think you're right. That's a two sentence confirmation email that I feel okay about. and I if we could do conditional approval based on that response, I think that's very fair.
[48:26] and the tree clearing limits, again, I think when we talk about wetland delineations and wetland impacts, that's a conversation with the D and again, if they bless everything we've done out there and we're upfront with them, like we've tried to be, I think their blessing kind of also checks that box, right? So really the last big item is the tree clearing limits on phase two
[48:48] which I think is isn't something that is I think the what we have right now to discuss that would be beneficial is what we can what you guys want to see for developed areas back there because again the areas that have been cut are not disturbed and will quickly reveate and be back to unimpacted low growth shrubs to still allow for solar feasibility
[49:11] out there. not feasibility, viability. And I think that I is the forest through the trees is what we're actually going to have out there at the end is not a ravaged stripped parcel like it might seem. I think he tried to stay inside. I don't I don't know.
[49:32] But nothing no damage has, in my opinion, been done yet. There hasn't been any environmental catastrophe out there at this stage. the wetland the crossing there is like I said has existed for 40 years. It was a logging road that we tried to follow and that's why the wetlands split there to begin with. That's why we put the road there to begin with was to not touch wetlands.
[49:55] So I just want to make sure that we are all safe.
[49:57] Can I just say one thing? I hear you when you're you're saying you're trying to avoid wetlands, but we just mentioned there's three lots.
[50:04] I had nothing to do with those
[50:05] on your previous ones.
[50:06] I had nothing to do with those. I'm just saying like, you know, the way you're talking is that the way you guys are building this is to avoid, but that's not what we're seeing on what's already been
[50:16] on the micro scale. There's different players that part, right? There's site guys who don't know and there's mistakes that are made.
[50:21] You blame us when we're kind of
[50:23] I'm not, but I just want to make sure the picture is correct because you are painting that is one way of looking at it. But I think you're pointing the fingers at the wrong people.
[50:29] I'm I'm not pointing any fingers at all. I'm we're trying to do our due diligence.
[50:32] I hear you. I hear you. And I'm I just want you to know that what side the developer has always been on and
[50:36] continues to be on. And I just am scared that there's a there's a sinister story at work that's just not true. It's just not true. He's been so good the whole way through.
[50:50] Italy, the developer is responsible for everything that happens within their project.
[50:54] Totally.
[50:54] Y
[50:55] and I can promise you every development in the neighborhood is similar.
[50:58] Just pause here for a second. I just want to back up. I do not feel comfortable myself approving a preliminary plan at this stage. Even with conditions, I do not feel comfortable because biggest thing here is that all of this is going to go to our third party reviewer. Why would we submit all of this and have that wasted time and money when it's not,
[51:22] at least up to my view, not accurate yet? Why would we do that?
[51:29] This isn't outdated figures. This isn't a good look. and it's too bad you guys said we couldn't look at the newer figures because they are just pictures. They just paint a different picture. so back to the three things that we were talking about, the wetlands. I am recommending a new delination, but we'll talk to Doral Palmer also regarding the wetlands.
[51:50] is the potential for impact to already existing wetlands from phase 2 work. You said that you had only grubbed trees within the road right of way, but we have pictures from sidewalk.
[52:10] It does appear that there was quite a bit of grubbing outside of the road right ofway. So,
[52:18] I don't know if that's true.
[52:21] I've been told by the forester and everybody that the only part that was grubbed was and again, it's dry sandy soil. So, you dig it, you drive on it and it looks it's not like it's thickly forested. You guys all walked it. We walked it beforehand. It's very lightly forested, old growth wooded area. So, you cut down one tree and 50 feet around it all look open, right?
[52:45] It was easy hiking back.
[52:46] I wonder if the new delineation can be done and then Gorl Palmer approves it and then maybe DP or something to do with DP comes out. I think you mentioned you wanted DP to come out to look at the site, right?
[53:04] The D permitting process I've invited them out. They haven't shown any interest yet.
[53:10] Okay.
[53:10] Yeah. In the package here, [clears throat] it stated that the desire was to have the CEO and D out of the site before tonight's meeting. And apparently that's never happened. George, can you zoom out to see more of them phase two, please?
[53:35] That enough?
[53:36] Yeah, I think so. you know [clears throat] the other point I'd like to make is as a with a cluster subdivision there are certain aspects of the building envelope that need to be considered and wetlands
[53:56] steep slopes rock outcroppings
[54:02] and it 's tough to tell but it looks like
[54:10] some of the building envelope might encroach in some of those barriers. [clears throat] so in addition to your list, Juliet.
[54:21] Yep.
[54:22] I think it'd be nice to see
[54:28] Patrick tells a thousand words, right? But, an updated plan that site plan that kind of outlines the proposed building envelope, the 20,000 square feet, if you will.
[54:41] I was hoping you guys can kind of tell us what number we wanted there. I mean,
[54:44] I'm not going to tell you that. Okay.
[54:46] No,
[54:47] there's no Okay.
[54:48] We the definitions for a cluster the definitions [clears throat] of a building envelope and a cluster subdivision are black and white.
[54:56] and it tells you in our land use ordinance what can and cannot be within that building envelope. so looking at this, it looks like some of your lots impede, [55:12] 24.
[55:15] Maybe.
[55:16] Oh, man.
[55:16] Are you talking about the green or the This is such a bad figure.
[55:20] The green is your building envelope, right?
[55:22] It was like conceptual like where we could fit them. It wasn't Again, once you sell the lots, you don't have I mean, I can't tell them where to put their driveway. It was kind of like, hey, these lots are built today. That's all. And then I show it was honestly like stattering the driveways. So you can have driveways coming through each other's driveways. That's always nice, right? So you can see the driveways are all as offset as we can.
[55:42] The ordinance says the final plan has to have clearing limits on it.
[55:46] Yep.
[55:50] Do those clear in your revised one, which the board isn't looking at tonight. Another thing to check is you've shown the cleared areas as they've been cleared. Are any of the septic system test pits outside of those cleared areas? And have the storm water basins, are they included in those calculations? Because one of them looks like it has still trees in it.
[56:13] On this image for sure, again, this whole image is it looks like it's pushed too far to the north or whatever direction it is, west. So when they when you do whatever you're going to do, you need to look at where the septic systems are located and make sure that they're in those cleared areas that you're proposing.
[56:31] Yeah. The Yeah, they've given us kind of a blanket. Hey, all the tests in this area are the same.
[56:42] Very consistent hydraological site.
[56:47] I don't think we're saying anything was malicious. No, but
[56:53] there may somebody who's not paying attention to what's happening on phase one and like George said, it's up to the developer
[57:02] to please that. and we just want to there's been some site alterations done obviously on phase two and to Juliet's point, you know, we want to
[57:14] but this is the precedent we're setting now, right? every second phase that comes through, you got to go back and we got to check every clearing limit. And that's a
[57:23] well ultimately none of it should have been cleared.
[57:25] For sure. For sure.
[57:27] No, I understand. I've never done this before. I've never done this before.
[57:31] But when you when you have some wetland alterations from phase one, it gives you concern when you're looking at phase two
[57:41] that we're the ones who reported them. I mean, that's the only reason this even came about. Besides, if he hadn't logged phase two, if he had left phase two alone, log phase one would have never been discussed and never is in any subdivision I've ever been a part of. You never go back and look at once the lots are sold. It's the it's always it's just how the industry's always done it. I don't I don't think it's right or wrong.
[58:01] Doesn't consider cumulative impacts when they do site location.
[58:07] They're not going to go back and check your They're not going to have you do a review of the whole,
[58:13] but they're not going to ask you to do a day of drone survey and get you what's out there. They're going to look at they're going to go walk it. They're not going to go and check your deliminate delineations and see your clearing limitations.
[58:23] Unless they see issues.
[58:25] Unless they see issues, which
[58:26] which this board has seen issues
[58:29] because we told them.
[58:31] Well, and that's that's what you should
[58:32] I know it is, but I'm just saying this isn't came from the sidewalk. This isn't a precedent that any other subdivision has. Oh, yeah. [snorts] It's I'm fine with it. I think it's the right thing to do. Don't get me wrong. It's just a
[58:43] different when you've been forthcoming on something that has been altered, it begs the question.
[58:51] It does.
[58:53] Okay. So, let's get back to kind of the list of things that we need. we started with wetlands, talked about potential of a new delineation. [59:06] and then there's some things that cross over into the DP as far as like the wetland fill. anything else regarding the wetlands that we want to talk about specifically? Any questions or concerns or needs?
[59:24] [59:24] I think we've addressed them.
[59:26] Yeah, I think so too. Okay, great. So, that was the wetlands piece. Now, let's talk about DP. so this is my recommendation. I would like to hear from them. I'm sure you would too. I would like to hear from them on the
[59:46] Let's see here.
[59:49] Are they 're not reviewing the violation with the trees. [59:53] yes, they that's they didn't even not they've been notified of that. of the of the tree clearing.
[59:59] Yeah.
[59:59] Prior to site location approval, I saw it's all underneath the site location, all the wetland impacts, all the tree clearing.
[1:00:05] Okay. So, tree clearing all right. Okay. So, tree clearing, I want to hear them what they say about that. I do want to hear about wetland impacts, but the new delineation might change that. So, we'll we'll keep a pin in that. See what Goral Palmer comes back with. and then the other thing is phase one wetland fill.
[1:00:29] So, it sounds like you did alert them to that.
[1:00:31] D. Yep.
[1:00:31] Yep. So, it would be it'd be good to hear I'd like to hear what they said say about that. So, phase one wetland fill. [1:00:45] and
[1:00:47] are we have a condition that they need a slow site law like we can give the permit with a condition that the site law is received or
[1:00:57] they can give a preliminary approval but the final approval is supposed to have you a D if they need a site location permit they 're supposed to submit that as part of their application.
[1:01:07] So we they need that before that final.
[1:01:10] Yeah. for final, right? Okay. So, maybe you know a status update on their review of that.
[1:01:16] Hopefully we'll have I mean hopefully we'll have it obviously by final, but that's kind of what I'm getting at. Like a lot of this stuff, a lot of our concerns sit in the D's hands and once they come back and say this is fine
[1:01:28] or not fine, what we want you to do to fix it. I feel like that's where our authority that's that's the best we can do, right?
[1:01:36] Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But I think that one document I think can put I mean they're going to like you said if it's their wetland delineations that they're asking about they'll say the same they'll if it's been 5 years and that's their concern then that's right they'll flag that too. So like a lot of the concerns that we've just raised all hinge on that D approval. So if there's a condition that hey you guys don't get final approval until you get this D approval that has all three of these concerns met feel like that one condition takes care of everything.
[1:02:05] Might if I'm wrong maybe I'm missing something. Mhm.
[1:02:07] But I feel like that
[1:02:09] other than sending pieces to the third parties and seeing getting all these opinions, I feel like the D's opinion is the opinion we care about in my opinion. Right. If they if we satisfy aside from performance standards of the towns, which again I think from a engineering standpoint, those really lie on the road standard and which we've asked the 20 foot waiver.
[1:02:31] So again, and then I guess part of the worst part for me is that we've gotten preliminary approval on this project before and it was just a matter of that debauchery that just set us all the way back to like not even thinking this project's even close. So in my mind, I was like, "Oh, great. Okay, we'll just resubmit again. We'll get our D approval and then we're ready for final because that was the original conditions on the prelim that we first had." [laughter] And so that's what I was hoping we were stepping back into
[1:02:56] and this, right? And so doing the best we can to communicate everything we can to the D, but I do still believe that D approval answers a lot of your big concerns.
[1:03:09] And just to [clears throat] reiterate this point, we can't provide final approval if there are any outstanding violations,
[1:03:18] right? We still got a long ways to go with people blessing this, but from a your ordinance and what you guys are asking for on phase two, aside from the violations, right, which is again on approvals rather than on preliminary.
[1:03:34] I feel like the project meets that part.
[1:03:36] Well, no. So, sort of but the wetlands is not just
[1:03:41] if you think the wetlands have been outdated but again if it is if they are outdated they'll say we need
[1:03:46] D could yeah
[1:03:48] say that too right so
[1:03:49] could but it's not [clears throat] I'll ask I'll ask them if we want to include that in the condition I'll ask the D if they think our employations need to be renewed right I can I can throw that right at them too
[1:03:58] yeah if you want but I do think we're going to reach out to Glor Palmer about it too but yeah you do whatever you would like on that but I do hear you the DP definitely they're they're reviewing much bigger permit than we are for you.
[1:04:11] [1:04:12] and they are professional you know they are very smart in this stuff but it's not everything.
[1:04:18] Sure.
[1:04:19] It's so
[1:04:21] so I guess that is maybe that's the ask. Can we leave the things that are DPS with D for now and then focus on the town problems that I might have might have created or don't have? Maybe I mean my hope is that the performance standards that you guys have in your ordinances we've met those. That's that's my hope is cuz they did once and I haven't changed anything. So hopefully they did again.
[1:04:42] again besides some of these violation ordinances that are like you can't do anything if there's an outstanding violation. So that's [snorts] kind of the area that I that's how I came into this.
[1:04:54] It's a good question about how we separate ourselves from D or not. You know
[1:05:00] you have independent jurisdiction over the wetlands in this
[1:05:03] absolutely no regulations. Y
[1:05:06] you can defer if you're satisfied that the D has addressed the issues adequately you can accept that
[1:05:12] and the peer reviewers certainly would consider that but at the same time D is a perfect either
[1:05:17] no they're not no I'm not saying that at all I guess what I'm saying is the other stuff like the violations and
[1:05:23] yeah that is their
[1:05:25] that is kind of we shouldn't
[1:05:30] are we allowed to continue with prelim approval and maybe even final approval with outstanding violations on
[1:05:36] you can you must continue with preliminary you cannot continue with final until those are resolved or at least giving a decision on final
[1:05:44] okay so I mean it's really up to you if you want like the what could happen here is that we get through prelim we get almost to final
[1:05:53] someone comes back and says oh well you got to do this and then that's going to take you all the way back
[1:05:57] unless I ask for an extension this time which I won't ever forget again
[1:06:01] no I'm not talking about timing you'll run out of time I'm talking about redoing stuff.
[1:06:07] Yeah. I think if that if that's a risk Jonathan's willing to take, which I think I'm it's a risk I'm willing to take.
[1:06:13] I think the things that are have to be redone are going to be some I don't know. I mean, he'll have to pay is what it comes down to. If you hit wetlands that you're not supposed to. It's like $5 a square foot. So, you might be out 20 grand on his mistakes there. He'll pay for it, right? That's how that works. You can I mean, I've seen people blow through entire wetlands and you write a big fat check for 150 grand and carry on. money fixes everything.
[1:06:35] I'm with you. I'm with you. You get that sentiment,
[1:06:39] which has never again has never been our intention of doing this. [clears throat]
[1:06:43] It's not those are not poorly built houses. Those are not flippantly built like they tried working with everything the best they Yeah. It just stinks. Juliet, it sounds like there maybe you're not, but to me it sounds like you're moving towards granting preliminary plan approval with these conditions that we've been discussing.
[1:07:07] I don't know. I don't know about that yet.
[1:07:10] I don't know. I still need to figure I want to hear from you all too. Like figure out all this. So I still the big wetland delineation thing. That's huge. That's huge. Like if this has to be redrawn like why would we go through prelim approval? [clears throat] If I can give you any comfort, there's zero chance they're flagging that part that's been crossed as wetlands again. It's been disturbed.
[1:07:30] It's filled. It's It's
[1:07:32] You can tell. They can tell if it was wetlands. Like, I'm just saying like, does that make sense to you all? Or do does it not matter
[1:07:42] if these lines here aren't correct?
[1:07:46] And so, if they draw Hold on. If they draw their building envelopes and we tell them to stay out of the wetlands, they get that done, but then the wetland line change and now they're in the wetlands, like does that matter?
[1:08:00] Certainly does matter. I mean the, you know, the compounding issue is it's a cluster. there's other rules that apply for these cluster and I'm grateful that we have this ordinance and you know we're ultimately reducing the footprint right
[1:08:20] I'm torn
[1:08:22] well okay [laughter] we chatted with that over coffee beers but but it is that's what is in the ordinance right and so yeah if the if the wetlands have changed then it changes your building envelope and you know again
[1:08:44] there's been damage that's done and we can't really tell what's going on.
[1:08:50] Mhm.
[1:08:53] And I guess again worst case scenario say there are more wetlands up there that they think we've hit. It's more D approval. It's more fines for John. It's more I mean but the road alignment and the lot so sure maybe some lot lines might get tweaked if so be it but the road alignment staying where it is
[1:09:13] treatment staying where it is
[1:09:14] sure some things could stay where it is
[1:09:16] so the impacts aren't that great and it's just moving lines on paper like the actual engineering of it is isn't changing the ponds are going to be where they are it's going to collect it's going to collect so I hear what you're saying that we could be going down a path and of and again I'm not I 'm probably overly confident in the fact that the wetlands aren't going to change cuz we're on top of a ridge.
[1:09:37] So, it's not like we're draining things into it that are filling it up more and things of the sort. we're right on top of this thing. We're right on a divide of two sub catchments going either direction, right? So, what's happened in top of this ridge isn't going to have huge impact. If we were damning things up and crossing and making, right, like if we were creating hydraulic barriers, we can't.
[1:09:58] We're on top of a ridge, so there's nothing to barrier. You're the that little low spot. You come down into a saddle, you dip back up, and again, that's the highest spot going through there, which is why it's no problem.
[1:10:11] So, I mean, I hear your concerns, but I having such an intimate understanding of this site and again being pro environment, I feel good about what's being shown. I'm not scared of what the DP is going to say.
[1:10:31] Okay. Well, so
[1:10:35] we've talked about wetlands, we've talked about DP, and then I think the last thing or you brought up building envelopes, but that has to do with the wetlands. It has to do with your steep slopes. is the ask there for them to at this stage go back and update those or can that wait till final
[1:10:57] the building envelope limit? So, what they're in this current application, correct me if I'm wrong, what they're saying is they [clears throat] would create a building envelope within the cleared areas and anything outside of those limits
[1:11:18] should be untouched.
[1:11:20] Actually, provided that HOA deed, right, from what I from what I've read. Yeah. is that each homeowner you say I don't know how you figure it out put flags out there or something say this has to grow up you can't touch anything unless it gets to 20 ft when it gets 20 ft you can cut it down
[1:11:39] I don't even think that it doesn't I think we say that you can hedge it yeah you say it's due to solar the solar panels you say you can chop it at 20 feet
[1:11:51] I think the idea besides that is I included an invasious a species plant planting kind of document like they somebody had mentioned it I think you mentioned it that the or the commission who had emailed in had requested it so we just went ahead and did that and so I think the idea is to let lower to throw out some lower growing shrub native species that we wouldn't have to shred them
[1:12:12] yeah sounded like it was a way to appease the fact that you guys cleared more than you should have
[1:12:18] no I think it was the hope was that it would ease the angst of thinking that it was it's been destroyed already, right? I think the hope is that you don't look at the tree clear like that area is now decimated cuz it's not like I think there's still pockets of whenever we do stump and grub that'll be lawn but the majority of that will be
[1:12:40] beautiful and it won't take and won't take long. [snorts] That's our hope, right? And again, it's not he doesn't want big blonds. He never it's never been their desire out there. They've always just tried to grade it
[1:12:57] as tight as they could.
[1:13:00] Okay. So, are we understood on building envelopes like what we're looking for?
[1:13:06] Yeah, we need to see them. We need to see and want those peer reviewed, I assume.
[1:13:12] Yes.
[1:13:12] Yeah.
[1:13:13] Okay. And then the last thing I believe
[1:13:19] [1:13:23] was tree clearing. The big one, a big one.
[1:13:31] So the ask that we had was to show where trees have been cleared, right? and this is what was provided.
[1:13:40] I gave a really good one.
[1:13:42] What? that I made a really great figure showing the tree clearing limits. I got it finished just
[1:13:48] so but like the green is this supposed to be tree clearing.
[1:13:55] Those were the old building envelopes laid on top of what's actually there so you guys could see kind of what the sketches were before and then what they are now.
[1:14:04] When we said tree clearing, where does it show tree clearing on?
[1:14:08] Well, no, it 's just the image. You can see the tree clearing was but because again tracing all those lines it took me some time and to figure out those areas and to do all that I mean I got this out I turned this to get a drone survey done and then to turn it around in a week and a half two weeks or whatever the time between the meeting and the deadline were was pretty quick. Okay,
[1:14:27] right that's quick. and so then once I sent it in, I this is the best I could do in that time. But then I went back and did phase one tighter, did another drone survey and or just a tighter drone image of that area, traced the tree lines as best I could, calculated the areas that were developed that were cleared on each lot
[1:14:48] and compared that to what's was allocated. So again, like lot three is a double lot. So it has 30,000 square feet cleared. And so lot one is really lot one/2 and lot three is lot two slash because we did that lot adjustment halfway through. And so those two lots grew by 50% each. So 10,000 extra square feet each.
[1:15:08] And then the other lot 12 is actually lot 11 and 12. So that's why it's twice as big because it actually was double the square footage. And I don't think that's how the
[1:15:21] what whatever the HOA or whatever the deed restrictions are really should have been interpreted. But that's how the math worked out. I'm not even sure John even I'm not sure they did that math, but that's just how it worked out.
[1:15:32] [1:15:33] but there are inaccuracies in this
[1:15:35] that one for sure.
[1:15:37] Lot four looks like the driveway goes through the wetland.
[1:15:41] Oh, so again, those green areas.
[1:15:42] Seven.
[1:15:44] there's definitely some cleared areas. If the green represents the cleared areas.
[1:15:49] No,, this is the bad figure. The good one I sent after that I traced the actual the Okay. So,
[1:15:55] these are the original.
[1:16:00] I know we said we didn't accept, we're not accepting anything within 14 days of the meeting, but would it make sense for us to talk about whatever he said now
[1:16:09] and see how he did it?
[1:16:10] I can actually do one better. I can explain why those are like that.
[1:16:13] Cuz when we impacted lot 13, I went and did a drone survey to show lot 13 when we saw it. I did phase one. Half of phase one wasn't even done at the time. There was still five undeveloped lots. And so those lots just stayed as what the clearing limits had been shown on the original plan or whatever. And so half of those are actual real tracings. Half of them are just what was shown on the original plan.
[1:16:36] And then we went back and I did another drone survey and traced everything. And there you have it.
[1:16:42] I think we all agree that this is not accurate. No, don't look at the
[1:16:45] we all agree that this is not accurate. But does it make sense for us to talk to look at
[1:16:50] the
[1:16:51] or do we just say come back next month and we will look at that and it may it may comply or it may not.
[1:17:00] It didn't it didn't fit the time frame that it needed to fit. Therefore, we should be reviewing it.
[1:17:06] All right. So, we're not going to even look at it and we'll look at it next time.
[1:17:09] Sure.
[1:17:10] And it may not be
[1:17:12] we'll have to we'll have to talk about it.
[1:17:13] Sure.
[1:17:14] That's fine. Yeah, that's okay.
[1:17:16] Great. So that so that's the tree clearing figure.
[1:17:19] Yeah. And you know what? I'll I'll include both those figures in an update to the D and just say I don't know what they want what want with it. because again like I said the storm water bottles are super
[1:17:30] they haven't talked to you at all.
[1:17:31] D they 've asked about street clearing or I told them about street cleaning like I forget what their response was. It wasn't anything of substance.
[1:17:40] Yeah. So they haven't come out. They're
[1:17:45] Wow. Okay. [1:17:49] they gave us a pat on the back for reporting it ourselves. She said, "Thanks for that. Why don't you just take care of that with your site location?" Like you did when we had restored before we even reported it. We he got on it that afternoon. We started pulling that back and the reveation plan is not that complicated, right? Those
[1:18:06] pull it back to native reveated.
[1:18:10] Okay. So, just I'm sorry, Brian. I don't mean to take
[1:18:13] Why are you apologizing? because I feel like I'm talking a lot, but we you all I wasn't here at the last meeting, but you all granted approval.
[1:18:21] let me get this right.
[1:18:23] You deemed the application substantially complete.
[1:18:27] Subject we deemed the application complete.
[1:18:31] Yeah,
[1:18:31] we're going through this substantive.
[1:18:34] Right. Right. Right. Yeah. the application was deemed complete last meeting subject to corrected mapping and tabled substantive review which is what you just brought up. So I would argue that the mapping is not corrected still.
[1:18:51] The image is good.
[1:18:52] And so that was a condition. No.
[1:18:53] So it's not
[1:18:54] the image is mapped. That's mapped.
[1:18:56] No. So
[1:18:56] I didn't trace it.
[1:18:57] I know. I know. It's not correctly mapped. So therefore, I don't even know if we can get into prelim approval yet. Can we
[1:19:04] or can
[1:19:05] to me it sounds like a lot of the outstanding issues that we had, they're still outstanding.
[1:19:10] Yeah. Exactly. Therefore,
[1:19:13] I think we need that before we can get into prelim approval.
[1:19:18] No, we've seen this on previous subdivision. Actually, it was a cluster as well. where we didn't get everything that was requested as a condition.
[1:19:28] Just want to make sure that the applicant is fully aware of what the additional information that we need.
[1:19:35] Yep.
[1:19:36] We don't want to be going through this again another month. Before we conclude here, I think we'll go through that list and make sure that the applicant is on board with what we're asking for
[1:19:49] because I think I prop I did what I said I would do at the end of the last meeting when we asked this. I said I'll do an aerial survey and put the building envelopes on top of it, which is when we say I didn't map it accurately, I there's no ordinance for mapping clearing [snorts] limits. I don't I don't know. But the when you say accurately and appropriately, there's no standard there.
[1:20:10] So it's it's you're saying it's not accurate or appropriate, but it's the best I could do in the time frame I had. And I went back and tried to supplement it with even more additional research. But as far as mapping, I mean, the definition of mapping is representing what's out there on 2D. And that's as perpetual map is that's a if you go onto your Google Earth and say, "Show me a
[1:20:32] current aerial view map," it's going to give you an image. Okay. Well, maybe we need to get into this. we said in the meeting minutes, application is substantially complete subject to corrected mapping of the cleared areas. I don't think that meant a photo, right? I think we were talking about calculations,
[1:20:54] drawing around them, trying to figure out the total, right? Is that what you all were, Alan? I think you might have made that a
[1:21:01] lot of assumptions.
[1:21:04] I mean,
[1:21:09] [1:21:09] you're arguing the definition of mapped appropriately and spend two weeks. That's it.
[1:21:15] This is a photo.
[1:21:17] It's a great photo.
[1:21:18] It's not a map.
[1:21:18] It's an ortho map. It's an ortho photo. Just an orthorrect rectified photo to scale of that's as sick as it gets. It's a two gig photo right there. I mean, if you really want to argue that, then I guess we have to we can probably argue that, but I think it's
[1:21:37] I guess I guess I'm just asking for a little grace in a in a definition that we kind of made up at the end of a meeting and I did my best and I did my very best to even provide more
[1:21:49] information that
[1:21:50] again, it's just a picture. I don't think any of the things that I provided aren't something all of you could have processed in the five seconds you were looking at.
[1:21:56] So, what's the difference between this and what you just provided today? So this is this is the clearing limits as proposed except for like I said the first five lots that were there when I last surveyed it when I did the wetland impact from whatever month that was a year ago. So I traced all those right. So I had these proposed clearing limits for half the lots all of phase 2 and then like real clearing limits for
[1:22:19] those bottom five or six. And so when I went back, I redid the drone images, which is why I lost 13, four, and now those all show the proper
[1:22:30] impacts underneath them, but don't line up with the green part.
[1:22:33] And so it's a it's a mo it's a current
[1:22:36] shows the clearing limits as is the photo with what we had proposed as our developed building envelopes as part of phase two, which is I thought the conversation we were really trying to have. And then I went back and really calculated areas of what we had done on lot one to go communicate to the D to make sure that my calc still lined up. I went and dug into all that much deeper and more thoroughly for both lots.
[1:22:58] And again, I think the conversation for phase two is pretty simple. Like I do understand he cleared outside he they logged outside of the clearing limits, but as far as like stumping and grinding and actually disturbing and fully developing the land. He hasn't done that. and those building envelopes that we have shown there are still our clearing envelopes that we are proposing
[1:23:19] on what has been done. So I'm saying if you look at that image everything outside of those green areas is going to be reveated and that's the picture I wanted to paint. It wasn't oh how many square feet of trees were cut down because it's really irrelevant because they're not impacts as far as anybody's concerned. So can I clarify? You're saying that those green envelopes up there are what you're proposing.
[1:23:41] They're 20,000 ft each. They line up look just like with the phase ones. Look at the same size. They're all the same size. They're all 20,000 ft.
[1:23:49] Lot 18 is 20,000 square feet.
[1:23:51] I think it might be skinnier.
[1:23:53] That's like
[1:23:54] That's like 9,000 square ft.
[1:23:56] Maybe that back right one.
[1:23:58] That's what was on your That's
[1:23:59] Look at lot 16 versus what's in your table.
[1:24:02] That was the table that I was I was I was trying to again that was on the fly.
[1:24:06] Did that table go with these diagrams? So, there's one table that you're talking about and the first t version of that table showed 20,000 square feet per each lot. I redid the math because you said it's got to be 20%. Some I thought somebody said 20%. So, I did a calculation, put the table on there, and didn't do a good enough job really going back and tightening.
[1:24:26] That's not That's not 9,000 ft. Look at Look at lot 9 and compared to lot 19 and lot 18. It's it's right there. Lot eight and lot 18 are right there. Same with they're all 20,000. I'm not I'm not making that up. Look at the clearing limits on phase one and compare them to what I've shown on phase two and they're very consistent across the
[1:24:44] Let's peer review pre-m.
[1:24:47] Yeah,
[1:24:47] absolutely. But I mean I just I 'm trying I'm having a hard time believing that you didn't understand that we were trying to what we were trying to see. I didn't understand the importance of the actual square footage of the trees that had been cleared versus what is supposed to have been cleared.
[1:25:08] That was what I was trying to portray. What is supposed to have been cleared versus what is and then what will be regrown. And I think that does a good job of communicating that those green areas are what we're proposing as the final disturbed areas. Everything outside of those will be ve reveated and be allowed to regrow and undisturbed. That's
[1:25:25] But they weren't disturbed.
[1:25:26] They're not disturbed. They're cleared. There's I guess it's a very I
[1:25:33] That's that's that's that's the crux of it. If you want to call that disturbed, then that's a different conversation. But the D won't call that disturbed
[1:25:42] under the ordinance.
[1:25:44] clearing for development is defined in the Durham ordinance as disturbance.
[1:25:50] Okay.
[1:25:52] Clearing for development.
[1:25:55] Yeah.
[1:25:56] Yeah. [snorts]
[1:25:58] Yep. I mean, I'm seeing notes from our meeting that I wasn't at that says discussion members question the timing and purpose of the clearing, the discrepancy between the actual cleared areas and the existing conditions plans, the relationship to the approved phase one development, and the need for an accurate plan showing disturbance and wetland boundaries.
[1:26:23] So, to me, I wasn't at this meeting. I saw the video, but it's it seems like you all talked about it about what we were looking for. So
[1:26:32] again, I think I'm at phase two as you asked. I think that's what I tried to communicate there is this is what's going to be disturbed. This is what I this is what my understanding of disturbed is. So again, I not you're sitting here saying I'm like I'm being dumb about it. I wasn't. I took the what I defined as disturbed area and what we will have as disturbed area out there.
[1:26:53] I showed that compared to I 've said I don't know how else to say that the area outside those green areas we're allowed to reveate.
[1:27:02] So if we really drill down in these there's going to be more clearing
[1:27:09] clearing.
[1:27:10] Mhm.
[1:27:10] It looks like some of the looks like there's existing vegetation within some of the green areas.
[1:27:16] I thought you said it was a great
[1:27:18] I mean the layover the layover is not laid over exactly. The whole thing needs to be shifted down 10 feet. It looks like the image underneath the road because look at the hammerhead right there. It needs to be pulled the whole scale of it.
[1:27:32] Getting back to what we were looking at.
[1:27:35] But I guess we're asking
[1:27:36] requirement from last month was anything from D any correspondence from D about your corrective actions. and that hasn't been received either. Yeah. Likewise.
[1:27:52] I mean, I've included my emails that I've had with her, I believe, in those correspondences.
[1:27:58] [1:27:59] can I just ask one question for you? When if you're doing a site plan and you're doing your LOD, your limits of disturbance,
[1:28:07] would you include the area that you cleared all the trees or would you only include
[1:28:12] the future cleared areas?
[1:28:15] Say it again. your LOD in a project area. Does that include any areas that you've disturbed? I you cut trees down.
[1:28:23] See, that's that you just I don't consider cutting trees disturbed. DP doesn't. That's that's kind of where my mind was. I didn't know that the town has a different definition of disturbed. But my train my all my life disturbed has meant stumping and grading and disturbing the soil, not disturbing the trees.
[1:28:41] Okay.
[1:28:42] Like,
[1:28:42] yeah, never mind. Sorry. So, [clears throat] I'm just going to throw it out there. You've kind of put us in a tough position by doing all of this pre
[1:28:50] Oh, I know.
[1:28:51] Right. I did.
[1:28:52] And again, I'm getting back to cluster. We want a cluster subdivision. we want to maintain as much of the existing
[1:29:02] property as possible
[1:29:04] and that's been altered. It's it's almost like we actually have the option to say, "No, this can't be a cluster anymore. Right. I don't think we want to go that way, but
[1:29:17] No, I guess you just end up waiting for it to grow back and then somebody would come in and say, "Yep, it's
[1:29:21] Yeah, we just have to hope that the homeowner doesn't take it upon themselves to
[1:29:28] keep that area cleared. It's just a trust."
[1:29:31] I mean, that's the whole that's the whole crux of this of these things. It's like you can't I mean,
[1:29:37] well, there codes can codes can I guess.
[1:29:39] Yes, it is, but nobody does. If you put clearing limits on this,
[1:29:45] those are enforceable.
[1:29:47] Sure. I guess I guess there's no mechanism to do so. I guess is really what it comes down to. It's very challenging to do. Somebody has to come in to do a drone survey, which I've never heard of ever being commissioned. But that's not to say it's not the right approach. And I think it's I think again I've agreed the whole way through is yes, let's get a proper I'll go out there and do a proper survey of this thing and figure out exactly what's been done out there because I haven't had anything to do with any of this.
[1:30:10] I was out of this for the last 5 years. I got pulled into it.
[1:30:13] But you are representing the
[1:30:15] I understand. I understand. And again, I'm I'm representing his best interest and I
[1:30:22] This is such a good subdivision.
[1:30:26] [clears throat] That is It's a good subdivision.
[1:30:34] All right. What else on this? Anything? or should we table for next month?
[1:30:47] I would think that we would table the additional preliminary view until December meeting. I'll make that a motion.
[1:30:57] So, can you clarify? So we're
[1:31:06] defining the substantive review
[1:31:11] of the preliminary
[1:31:13] correct.
[1:31:14] Okay.
[1:31:16] Until December and we have
[1:31:21] provided the applicant with the additional information that we want.
[1:31:27] Can we can we go over that again? I know it's D. I know we want D's stamp of approval. The rest of it I'm still I mean
[1:31:34] D approval. [1:31:36] I don't rest of it.
[1:31:38] Any wetland alteration?
[1:31:40] I think we are Is that on us, George? We're going to send Gorl a question.
[1:31:46] Well, I guess the question what I'm hearing table the whole thing
[1:31:50] the prelim
[1:31:51] let them come in with accurate plans of what they're proposing, what's been done and what they're proposing. then give a preliminary approval if it's satisfactory and send it to the peer review to have it all peer-reviewed or you can have a peer review of that done if you're still not satisfied that it's accurate
[1:32:08] before you give a code we have both options
[1:32:11] right but we had talked about the wetland I had I had made the recommendation that we need a new delineation done yeah and that we had talked about asking Gal Palmer
[1:32:19] if [clears throat] they agreed based on y
[1:32:22] beyond the applicant can contact Palmer try to sort that out and floral polymer gives a letter to the applicant saying that mapping is fine.
[1:32:32] Okay, let's put it on.
[1:32:33] Let them include it. Let them included in their packet.
[1:32:36] Okay. Right.
[1:32:37] Okay. Good. All right. So, the question to Goro Palmer for you is,
[1:32:44] is the you know 2021 wetland delineation acceptable for this review of this project? And then also with the understanding that phase one of the subdivision was already built and since that delineation was completed.
[1:33:08] Yeah. So delineation hasn't been done after the phase one was built. In other words,
[1:33:18] delineation was done when there all the trees were there etc. Yeah. Yeah. If you could get a letter from them, I guess Palmer.
[1:33:31] Okay.
[1:33:33] That was a wetland part.
[1:33:37] DP, you said you understand what
[1:33:41] we need their approval. Yeah. Like kind of the crux of it.
[1:33:48] The third one was accurate mapping of the cleared areas existing at home. email box.
[1:33:57] [snorts]
[1:34:02] Have [clears throat] we received the fire chiefs?
[1:34:09] Do we need No, we don't need anything from the fire chief. Okay. So, I'm just looking at your draft conditions, George. Just going through these to see if there's anything else that we need to include here to make sure that the applicant 20 foot road we're all set. The 20 foot wide road we're all set with.
[1:34:30] [1:34:36] so
[1:34:36] can I can I ask you back one second? I just want to go through this list that George has provided us with. [1:34:46] so one of your [clears throat] [1:34:53] draft conditions George is about clearing limits, buffers and plan restrictions. So this was for final plan. Okay, never mind.
[1:35:04] Yeah.
[1:35:07] Okay.
[1:35:12] Yeah. Mr. Burman, you might want to just go through the draft conditions of approval that are part of this package. just to make sure you dot your eyes. This just gives you a good idea as to what
[1:35:24] this is for final.
[1:35:25] For final. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. [1:35:27] yeah. I threw what I had out
[1:35:29] just to be proactive. Maybe just take
[1:35:31] that's kind of why I included it so we get ahead of it a little bit.
[1:35:36] c can I ask a question about the clearing limit? I mean, I get it for phase one. Let's make sure that we're not in any violations down there. That's a code conversation and with you guys what they come back and say we've messed up or haven't messed up. But for phase two, what are we trying what do you want me what is the goal of that figure to show? What if say I say I you were looking at it and all those tree limits were clear like were traced perfectly.
[1:35:59] What would be our decision or conversation?
[1:36:02] So that's in again this draft condition of approval number four. So what it says is revised plans showing enforcable clearing development envelopes. the
[1:36:16] that's what those are
[1:36:17] 100. That's what those are.
[1:36:21] You expect anybody to enforce that? What can you
[1:36:24] I mean how can you enforce any? I mean with a survey or something survey it
[1:36:29] flag the areas or
[1:36:30] they could flag them. I mean that and that's that's a condition that you guys could totally throw at it. They flag the clearing limits which is something again like that a surveyor would have to go out there and walk all but that's
[1:36:45] that's what those are. I mean in terms of what your question was it's it's when you want to say enforceable we're enforcing it off of a drone image that I just did. So it's enforceable the same way.
[1:36:55] Let the peer reviewers sort it out. Okay.
[1:36:58] Yeah.
[1:36:58] Okay. But yeah letting the peer reviewer sort it out. that seems to me like something that could also I mean our pure view is part of the final that's all so far we put everything on the pure reviewers and the third parties and those come back fine I guess I'm I'm still curious what we're not approving tonight
[1:37:18] the motion has been to table we haven't said we haven't approved
[1:37:22] right anything
[1:37:24] is there a second
[1:37:26] yeah I'll second
[1:37:28] thank you Any further discussion?
[1:37:35] Back to my initial question, what we're trying to communicate. Sorry. Sorry.
[1:37:38] I was just going to say you said that in your updated you have measurements you have cuz I think that's what we're driving at here that what's enforcable. So if you have lot 22 that's 200 ft of that green square. Is that what your new drone image shows?
[1:37:59] I guess I don't want to put a bunch of postage stamp building envelopes out there. And again, we didn't do that for phase one. The whole phase one, every lot was drawn as you guys see them. And obviously, they went outside those kinds, but they did a pretty good job of m of going with what the concept was for each lot. Here's your driveway. Minimize light pollution. Give yourselves maximum buffers. Like it wasn't a flippant conver like I didn't wasn't just they're all orchestrated that the southern clearing is the clearing is to the furthest south of every building at like where the buildings go.
[1:38:28] like there was a lot of thought put into those envelopes. They're not just postage stamps. And I think it actually regardless of how we consider the sizing of them. That is the that was the idea like and I'm sure there was a lot of thought put into phase one. Okay. But again, cluster says your building envelope cannot include a wetland.
[1:38:49] Obviously, that was
[1:38:51] that didn't happen. We put a lot of time and effort into saying what it should and shouldn't include and then it's blatantly disregarded.
[1:39:00] Okay. So that's a Okay. So that's so in every subdivision then the building envelopes are essentially meets and bounds at that point.
[1:39:07] Cluster subdivisions have again
[1:39:11] different rules.
[1:39:11] But is that what I'm saying? Like in the in other cluster subdivisions those meet those clearing limits are beat and bounds measured off and enforceable like as you're describing.
[1:39:21] Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And they're just squares just like right in the middle of
[1:39:26] No, they're funny shapes. There's no squares. Nothing square here. No, not what I'm saying. That's what you want. That's what the other That's what other cluster subdivisions do is they just say here's an enforceable square that you can build inside of.
[1:39:37] Yeah.
[1:39:38] Okay.
[1:39:38] For clusters. Yeah. Yeah.
[1:39:40] It's ugly. it. [laughter]
[1:39:43] Well, then I guess you have an example we could show from Ivy Ridge or I don't think it's a responsibility of the board of staff to educate the applicants consultant.
[1:39:51] I know. Okay.
[1:39:56] But when we approved this as a cluster,
[1:39:59] it the building envelope would have never included wetland.
[1:40:05] No. And again, this figure is awful. I mean, it's the best I could do in a week and a half, but lots the whole image needs to be shifted 10 feet down to the left.
[1:40:13] Also, I just I have to say this thing. So, for phase one, you didn't you guys didn't come in and girls didn't come in and clear and then send us you didn't clear anything. You drew your building envelopes, then you came in and you cleared. What you've done for this is you've gone there and you've cleared all of it pretty much.
[1:40:36] And now you're trying to fit your building envelope into an area where you've already cleared.
[1:40:41] So like this like the idea of the clearing is the impact. So you've gone above and beyond like you've doubled the size of the impact that you would have done if you had waited to clear.
[1:40:57] I'm aware. So, I'm just
[1:40:58] But the impact I think we're debating impacts and I think what you're talking about is negligible compared to the image the picture you're painting inside your head. What would
[1:41:06] Well, no. I'm just seeing from what I can see on the screen.
[1:41:08] I know, but you're talking about cut trees. It's not like it's again I been told they didn't stump and grub. I didn't count the trees before and I didn't count the stumps after. So, I don't know.
[1:41:18] Why didn't you do that here?
[1:41:19] Do what?
[1:41:20] Why didn't you clear the trees here?
[1:41:21] Well, cuz we were waiting on D approval. They thought it was coming imminently and there's that bat window where you can't cut trees between the whole summer. And so when it was still outside of that window, they thought, well, let's have a logger come in and get the trees down so we don't mess with the bats like everything and let's do this thing right. And yeah, you let loggers loose on a freaking parcel of land and they
[1:41:47] and again he brought and he called it a forester. So like you can say it was for development, but it also was like It was it was done by the book. Like he went and talked to a forester, had him sign off on the plan or whatever. I guess I from what he's shown and what the conversations have been portrayed to me, that's how that process went.
[1:42:07] And again, it wasn't let's get ahead of it and get nothing. Again, I model this stuff so conservatively and the storm water treatments are all wonderfully sized and I treat over 99% of what we do out there. got force and buffers along the hole. I mean, the whole thing is buffered and every bit of that road is collected.
[1:42:26] So, the peer reviewer should be very happy.
[1:42:28] He should be.
[1:42:30] All right. So, we have a motion and a second. Darren, any other comments?
[1:42:36] No, I think the peer review and D will shed a lot of light.
[1:42:40] All right. So, you're satisfied with your concern?
[1:42:42] That was my concern. Thank you.
[1:42:45] All in favor?
[1:42:48] Okay. Unanimous.
[1:42:51] Okay, thank you.
[1:43:18] Okay. Still with number six, continuing business B. substantive review of Basset subdivision amendment application, Winter's Way, map 11, lot 41-B. Public comment will not be taken. Mr. Lebarge, would you like to go through your staff notes?
[1:43:42] Okay. So, as the board is aware, the applicant is proposing an amendment to two prior subdivision plans in order to divide one of the lots in those plans to create one new house lot, splitting off the existing home. you granted preliminary approval on October 7th and the applicant submitted a final plan application on October 14th for consideration at this meeting as a new application.
[1:44:11] And I did clarify with the applicant that the deadline for new applications is 21 days. And the supplements that are referred to as what we were dealing with in the prior application where when the board asks for additional meeting additional information at the meeting where they review the
[1:44:32] application that was submitted 21 days in advance. that supplemental information which you've already talked about and are familiar with [clears throat] can be submitted 14 days before the deadline. So this applicant has submitted some additional information to address some of the concerns that were raised at the preliminary approval as well as staff notes and again you can consider whether to entertain that information or not.
[1:44:57] I did not move into the packet. the real issues on this are five. the first one is the road waiver which you've already indicated that you're willing to allow the in excess of 15% braid. the fire chief and the road commissioner have said that for two houses back there
[1:45:18] it's reasonable to allow that existing grade to continue. The fire chief, however, has indicated concern with wavering both the road grade and the fire protection water supply. The ordinance I was always under the assumption that they were asking not to have to put in a fire pond.
[1:45:39] We changed the ordinance back in January to say you can put in sprinklers and that is the basis on which I went forward in the in my staff notes. I was not aware that they were asking for a waiver of that as well, which based on the most recent submissions indicates they may still be asking for a complete
[1:45:59] waiver of all fire protection water supply. So that's something to clarify tonight and make a decision on. the I think it's clear that the road based on their engineers and consultants advice needs some maintenance work done to to rehabilitate it to be suitable for continued use.
[1:46:21] and so the the conditional agreement in lie of a performance guarantee would basically say that those improvement those maintenance items as well as the turnaround at the top would have to be done before issuance of any building permits or andor for sale of the lot.
[1:46:44] the fourth issue [clears throat] is the maintenance agreement and we've at the prior preliminary approval meeting discussions there were three lots that use this or two currently that use Winter's Way. They'll be adding a third one and the maintenance agreement needs to document what the respective rights and responsibilities of all parties
[1:47:05] using the the winter's way have to be clear and legally documented. So, they have submitted a deed that indicates that lot 41C, I think it is, which is out on Snow Road, but has their driveway off Winter's Way. there's a deed agreement. Part of their deed is that they cover apparently the first 200 ft of or so of Winter's Way.
[1:47:30] the ordinance specifies that the maintenance agreement either has to include them, not just a D reference, but or if they refuse to participate in that maintenance agreement, which is allowable, then they're supposed to submit a an affidavit, a legally not notorized affidavit saying that they choose not to participate in.
[1:47:54] And they can have whatever agreement they want based on that. But it appears that the documentation is still not adequate to satisfy the ordinance requirements. [clears throat] it just needs to be clear in the record that the u allowance for the road grade and not requiring a performance guarantee
[1:48:17] does not wave the responsibilities for making those improvements. So any decision that you make should include a conditional agreement of some form and so again to summarize the issues of the road the sprinklers and the maintenance agreement and I did include a draft motion for your consideration.
[1:48:38] Thank you.
[1:48:42] The applicant like to address the board.
[1:48:47] My name is Evan Jones with Jones Associates. [1:48:52] so yeah, for the first point for fire protection, we had initially submitted for a waiver for the full fire protection standard. I know you folks were in the process of ordinance change, right? before we submitted for that waiver, we had some discussions with the fire chief initially on whether or not he would be in favor of waving the sprinkler requirement for a single additional lot.
[1:49:20] and he had indicated that he would be in favor of that if the board and code enforcement favored it. based on these staff notes, it maybe sounds like he's no longer in favor of that, George. Correct me if I'm wrong.
[1:49:37] That's correct.
[1:49:38] Okay. So, [clears throat] yeah, that's just a clarification on the sprinkler system. We had
[1:49:47] applied for the full waiver, had some indications that maybe we could get that. but it does looks like that wouldn't be the case. as far as the road maintenance agreement goes, George is correct. The existing lot has a, provision in their deed that states which portion of road they are responsible for maintenance for, as well as the portion of cost allocation that they're
[1:50:17] responsible for. and the provision for how that cost allocation would change if [snorts] the lot being Steve's lot was further subdivided. so we were under the impression that all of those provisions within that current deed would satisfy those maintenance requirements for that lot.
[1:50:44] based on these notes, I'm getting that lot is being required to be a signatory.
[1:50:56] No. the ordinance specifies they either have to be a signatory or they have to sign an affidavit or a statement that they have been offered and are not and are not willing to participate in it beyond what their current obligation is. that gets notorized and submitted in the record. That way there's a legal determination that clarifies what everybody's rights and responsibilities are.
[1:51:20] That's right in the ordinance.
[1:51:21] So again, you know, apologies if that was our mis our misunderstanding. We thought that their rights and responsibilities were [clears throat] within their deed. [1:51:34] I guess as far as questions on that I would have on this on conditional agreement in this case I think we had asked for a waiver on the performance guarantee so for a conditional agreement and the form of the conditional agreement that would be acceptable to the town.
[1:51:56] Would that just be a note on the plan stating that no
[1:52:02] building permit
[1:52:03] can be issued? Yeah. Right. Okay.
[1:52:05] It's right in the ordinance.
[1:52:06] Okay. I Well, it says a form acceptable to the town. So, I wanted to make sure of that. Okay.
[1:52:12] Can you finish what your sentence?
[1:52:16] Yeah. And so
[1:52:16] no building
[1:52:18] no building permit can be issued until the improvements that are proposed on winter's way are completed. Okay.
[1:52:26] That was the so the construction of the turning right turnound and the cleaning of the ditches that was indicated on the plans.
[1:52:35] Yeah. I think that's the intent of the
[1:52:37] Yeah. And I just wanted to make sure the form of it would be adequate as a note on plan.
[1:52:42] Yeah. and then my other question or clarification on those points is on the exact language of the conditions to be added as notes on the subdivision plan.
[1:53:04] there are there is a section seven and eight
[1:53:12] I guess as well as nine here. [1:53:17] is the except for the last sentence of those sections. Is that the
[1:53:26] exact
[1:53:28] This is this is a draft. This is a draft for board consideration. they will be discussing it. They will take your input and if you want to propose changes to it for your purposes, they will consider that.
[1:53:40] Okay. So the lang the language of the condition gets proposed to us or we propose the language of the condition.
[1:53:49] That's what's proposed currently to as a starting place. It's very comprehensive, very thorough with AI assistance. the board will look at that language and you are free to interact with the board and make changes that you think are appropriate and necessary.
[1:54:06] Okay. No, I just wanted to make clarify where the language would come from. Okay.
[1:54:10] This would satisfy it.
[1:54:11] Okay.
[1:54:12] And just to be clear, you're referring to conditions to be this is part of the staff notes conditions to be added as notes on the recorded subdivision plan 78 and N. Is that what you're referring to? Yeah, conditions to be added as notes and the and the exact wording of the language of those conditions.
[1:54:32] Thank you. I just want to make sure that we're all speaking the same language here and on the same topic.
[1:54:40] And then I guess the other the other language and number nine on that states any has the maintenance agreement and any restrictions needed to preserve access for emergency and service vehicles.
[1:55:03] I know there was another note about legal access of emergency vehicles. is there a specific language requirement for that?
[1:55:18] No, I don't think it needs to be that specific
[1:55:20] other than the road shall remain
[1:55:25] clear and accessible for emergency. Okay.
[1:55:32] Obviously the concern would be if that road is not properly plowed with that grade. It would be very difficult for the fire department to answer a call. I think that's the intent. Keep it clear.
[1:56:04] I think so. Yeah, that was a I just wanted to clarify those before I guess you move forward.
[1:56:10] Sure. Of course. comments from the board.
[1:56:21] Well,
[1:56:25] you know me, wetland, person. Hi. No. so this is in resource protection, right?
[1:56:34] Portion of it. Yep.
[1:56:35] A little portion of it. is this Yeah. North the north quarter here? [clears throat]
[1:56:40] Yeah. You have a perennial stream that is running through and I think I don't have the pointer but it's you can
[1:56:50] Yeah, it's the double dot.
[1:56:51] Yeah, the double Yeah, exactly. Okay. And I believe there's a 100 foot
[1:56:59] [clears throat] setback right from that stream. Oh, wait. No, what is that 100 foot sideline? So
[1:57:11] you're talking about the resource protection buffer. That's kind of a bubble line off from that.
[1:57:16] Yes, exactly. Right. This
[1:57:18] here.
[1:57:18] Yeah.
[1:57:19] That is that it's a 100 foot, but it says side lot line set back. Is that right?
[1:57:29] I can't read it. It's [1:57:38] so yeah that it's it's defined in two different there's an arrow
[1:57:44] pointing to the 100 foot rear lot sideline set back and then there's also a line that is the resource protection district which is 100 ft from the perennial stream.
[1:57:56] Great. Okay. Where is that line that 100 foot from the stream? So that is like this sort of bold line. That is a dot. Yes, that's a dash.
[1:58:07] Yep.
[1:58:07] Okay, great. So this is the 100 foot step set back from the perennial.
[1:58:10] Yeah, it's actually it
[1:58:15] it come the Yeah, the dash line is the 100 foot set back from the
[1:58:19] Okay.
[1:58:24] And to the right is a area cleared for intended development. What is that around test pit and proposed drainage field?
[1:58:38] That circle
[1:58:39] that is the 100 foot well exclusion area. So
[1:58:44] the area that
[1:58:45] was intended for the septic system and then the setback distance for the well from that intended system. So, are you planning to clear or have you already cleared inside that entire
[1:58:58] 100 foot? It says area cleared for intended development. So, I guess I'm just asking if that was cleared.
[1:59:07] That is not entirely cleared. There will still be some additional clearing, I think, that would need to take place for that drainage field that the site evaluator laid out.
[1:59:18] Okay. there's just a small spot that does intersect with the 100 foot setback.
[1:59:26] You see that? Very small.
[1:59:29] the well exclusion zone intersects with the
[1:59:34] Yeah.
[1:59:34] 100 foot setback, but that's just the setback from the septic system.
[1:59:38] Is that not where you're saying area cleared for the intended development?
[1:59:42] No, the area cleared is the is like the it's not that line. So it's the cloud line.
[1:59:51] Mhm.
[1:59:53] See that? That cloud line right here. Yes. That is the area. That's the clear.
[1:59:58] That is talking about this.
[2:00:00] Yeah. So it's talking about this. Okay. All right. So this is just showing. Hey, you can't
[2:00:05] you can't put a well within that.
[2:00:08] You're not you're not like clearing in here. This is what I was getting.
[2:00:11] No. Yes. There. I see where you're
[2:00:15] This is not perennial. This is a
[2:00:17] That's a wetland.
[2:00:18] A wetland. Okay. All right. All right.
[2:00:21] It's all I have right now. Thank you.
[2:00:46] Darren Ellen, you have any questions or comments?
[2:00:53] Yes. No, I do not have any.
[2:00:56] Multiple conditions are well documented.
[2:01:00] Mhm.
[2:01:00] Yeah.
[2:01:10] What is this line here?
[2:01:13] So that's a what building envelope line [2:01:18] LOD
[2:01:20] there it's it's build the building envelope. So setback it
[2:01:27] we get into this with LUPC a lot. there is no setback to forestry
[2:01:34] buffers wetlands.
[2:01:35] so we do
[2:01:37] if we're showing a building envelope
[2:01:39] Yeah.
[2:01:39] on a plan we usually just go 5 ft off and you show that so that people understand that they have to stay
[2:01:46] right. So you're you're not going to impact in between here and the wetland.
[2:01:50] No. No. It's outside. So it's like the same line that the 20 foot side line setbacks are.
[2:01:55] Yeah. Okay. Great. That's good to hear. Thank you.
[2:02:06] flood plane that's in the same area, right? Yep. FEMA flood zone. You can see it. I
[2:02:14] think that's the [2:02:16] that's this thing. This line here,
[2:02:18] I think.
[2:02:22] Yeah.
[2:02:22] Yeah. That's the smaller dash line. Zone A
[2:02:25] right here.
[2:02:26] Yeah.
[2:02:27] Yeah. Okay. Any
[2:02:50] members ready to go through the findings and conclusions that have been drafted here? Mhm.
[2:02:59] Yeah, so
[2:03:23] [clears throat]
[2:03:44] okay. [clears throat] Would somebody like to go through these or shall I? I'm on I don't know where you guys are looking at, but I'm at [2:03:57] the draft findings of facts and conditions. C
[2:04:01] the consolidated findings and conclusions.
[2:04:07] Yeah, I'm there, too.
[2:04:08] Okay. So,
[2:04:09] and again, as we've discussed in the past, it's not necessary to read every one of them, but it is important to acknowledge that you have read them and Brian for you to ask if they propose any changes to any of those, but So C1 subdivision layout natural resources and municipal services.
[2:04:29] There are three findings here.
[2:04:34] there any additions or edits to the three?
[2:04:37] How about a question? Can I ask a question?
[2:04:42] Does that set you back? Did we talk about tree clearing? I feel like we did.
[2:04:50] When are you proposing to clear trees? I guess
[2:04:53] I don't need to clear any trees.
[2:04:55] Oh, you don't need to clear any trees. Okay.
[2:04:58] Would you please state your name and
[2:05:00] my name is Steve Bass.
[2:05:02] Thank you.
[2:05:03] So, all trees are cleared that need to be cleared.
[2:05:06] The lot was logged prior to my purchase. There was very little forestation. There's a lot of grassy paths. A lot of piece of property.
[2:05:17] Okay. [2:05:18] I remember talking about that now. Okay. Question was I asked was because of the bats. I do see your letter from the main department of inland fisheries and wildlife. they do mention bats of course but they do say that based on your project plan they don't anticipate any impacts and they don't say anything about
[2:05:39] tree clearing windows. So that probably is why because you don't need to clear any trees. So we're good there. Thank you. Okay.
[2:05:47] Yes. Great question.
[2:05:51] Okay. Number two, road access, [clears throat] road standards, and fire protection. And there are four findings of fact here.
[2:06:08] There any other comments or questions or edits to the to these
[2:06:34] Is this where we would talk about sprinklers?
[2:06:37] It's in there.
[2:06:39] so sprinklers are in.
[2:06:41] Yes.
[2:06:41] Okay. So, they're they're back in
[2:06:44] for the main house.
[2:06:46] Okay.
[2:06:47] the applicant states that there will be two ADUs in addition to the main house. How many do you
[2:06:56] There's not even a separate building. It's a We're We're planning on doing an in-law suite
[2:07:03] as part of the main house.
[2:07:05] Okay. So the main house
[2:07:08] we will require sprinklers
[2:07:12] for the main house.
[2:07:13] Okay.
[2:07:14] ADUs will not are not required to have sprinklers and that's state law. but since we're they've asked for a waiver on the fire pond [2:07:33] yeah here we're we're asking that the house be sprinklered in L of the fire pond
[2:07:41] and that's okay.
[2:07:44] Okay. Great.
[2:07:48] Okay. [clears throat] Any other comments? Number two. Number three, legal access in Winter's Way maintenance. And there are three findings of fact here.
[2:08:02] Any additions or edits to this?
[2:08:10] No.
[2:08:13] Okay. [clears throat] Number four, financial and technical cap capacity. completion of improvements. There are three findings of fact. Any board additions or edits to these
[2:08:47] D
[2:08:56] this is where we talked about the grade, right?
[2:08:59] Yeah. Yeah. [2:09:03] [clears throat]
[2:09:05] sorry, George is an administrative thing. Should this be five instead of D? Whoops. E, B, C. Okay. Now, D is
[2:09:16] C is the waiver.
[2:09:17] Yeah, the waiver. Okay. Kind of a separate consideration.
[2:09:19] We're rolling it into this consolidated
[2:09:21] consolidated waiver. Gotcha. Okay. [clears throat]
[2:09:27] any board ads or to this?
[2:09:37] Everyone good with the great?
[2:09:39] Yeah. So, we grant this. So, we're granting it. We're not denying it. Correct. Okay.
[2:09:44] Yeah. Right.
[2:09:52] On the existing. Yeah.
[2:09:54] Yeah.
[2:09:56] It's not wave turnaround, maintenance improvements, legal access, and fire protection.
[2:10:05] Justice waiver just for the road. Great. Thank you to let my chair understand. Y
[2:10:11] that's I understand it too.
[2:10:14] Okay. E final [clears throat] plan conclusions and conditions of approval.
[2:10:22] We have
[2:10:27] three
[2:10:29] draft decisions,
[2:10:32] three conclusions,
[2:10:40] the general compliance condition,
[2:10:45] administrative conditions,
[2:10:50] and conditions to be added as notes on the recorded subdivision plan. You all had a chance to review these and
[2:10:59] yes
[2:11:00] y
[2:11:04] did have some questions about some of the specific wording that you might want to review with them.
[2:11:08] Yeah. No, you're Thank you, George. so before we make a motion here
[2:11:15] are you all okay with these conditions of approval?
[2:11:20] Yeah. So you are you making a you're making a motion on all of E?
[2:11:28] well, we'll make a final motion on everything that we just discuss of approval.
[2:11:37] and the final plan conclusions.
[2:11:41] Yes.
[2:11:43] Yeah. So, if you want changes or need changes and the board agrees with them, now would be the time to bring those out.
[2:11:49] Again, this may be overkill. The AI does that.
[2:11:55] And if there's any part of this that's problematic in the wording, you can ask for consideration to be changed.
[2:12:04] Yeah, I guess the in the wording aspect, it under item seven,
[2:12:14] I can take everything but the last sentence and put it on the plan as a condition. [2:12:23] under item eight
[2:12:27] is more of a statement than a note
[2:12:37] on the plan. So it would be it identifies
[2:12:44] as opposed to shall identify
[2:12:49] it would be
[2:12:59] might want to split those into two. It does I think you already have some draft wording in your I think it's in the plan. It's up there, right? That is the recognizing the key is recognize the waiver of the road standards.
[2:13:19] Yeah, we left it broad.
[2:13:22] Yeah.
[2:13:22] Yeah. Yeah. It's very broad there. Needs to be a little
[2:13:24] This is just a little bit more specific. It may be too specific
[2:13:35] for eight, right? yeah, for the eight
[2:13:43] [clears throat] and I mean your board your draft board conclusion is more in line with what I would normally put on a note for a plan. So the board the board grants one consolidated waiver of the otherwise applicable
[2:14:02] which number
[2:14:04] it's in your D consolidated road waiver. It's in the draft board conclusion.
[2:14:12] D is there a number?
[2:14:13] [2:14:15] no just
[2:14:16] the consolidated road waiver.
[2:14:18] Oh okay.
[2:14:24] If that is acceptable to the board, we can certainly put that into it.
[2:14:30] Yeah, I think I think what he's saying is making great sense. Like what we have the language, the words that we have under number eight, right?
[2:14:42] Yeah.
[2:14:43] Just doesn't that doesn't go on a plan, those words. But what he was saying under D, I can see that going on a typically on a plan, right?
[2:14:56] So I think what you do is you strike out in that. So use the draft board conclusion.
[2:15:03] This is on page 146 at the top. you strike out only to the extent identified in the board's motion and then the rest of it is this waiver does not wave the turnaround, maintenance, improvements, legal access or fire protection requirements. So I think it was just strike out only to the extent identified by the board.
[2:15:26] Does that work?
[2:15:30] So the condition would be
[2:15:32] yeah the board grants the board grants
[2:15:35] what is it referencing as appendix one in that
[2:15:39] so 256.9 B14
[2:15:46] is
[2:15:49] 6
[2:15:53] Just don't want to wave.
[2:15:54] Yeah, we're right. Or
[2:15:56] Yep.
[2:15:57] bind us to something unintentionally.
[2:16:00] 6.9 B14.
[2:16:06] It should be the road standard reference to the appendix.
[2:16:14] I think that's fine. I just
[2:16:16] Yeah, let's just make sure it's right. 6.9B number 14 is rope plans meeting the requirements of appendix one prepared by a professional engineer. So you're getting that waiver. Okay. And then the 6 [2:16:36] 6.18D.
[2:16:39] Let's just check that.
[2:16:45] That is 18. Yeah, that's just the similar traffic standards.
[2:16:54] So I think those are the applicable portions of the ordinance that they would have to meet with a full professional engineering
[2:17:01] analysis.
[2:17:04] Okay.
[2:17:04] Yeah.
[2:17:06] And then you'll keep in that last sentence this waiver does not wave the turnaround.
[2:17:11] Yeah.
[2:17:12] So this is C this will be CO number eight, right? substituting for what's down there.
[2:17:18] Eight.
[2:17:19] Yeah,
[2:17:20] that works.
[2:17:21] Okay,
[2:17:24] and then nine
[2:17:26] is under that.
[2:17:28] [2:17:31] shall identify and reference the approved easements and maintenance agreement restrictions. [2:17:46] Yes. So it has to it has to reference the maintenance screen
[2:17:50] not record it but
[2:17:53] yeah typically they do so that someone knows where to find that maintenance screen and maintenance screen does get recorded.
[2:18:00] The maintenance agreement has to reference the recording plan
[2:18:05] usually.
[2:18:06] Yeah. They can cross reference each other, don't they?
[2:18:22] So you're saying it's a chicken and an egg.
[2:18:24] It's a chicken and egg issue. Yeah. Usually we record the plan and then any covenants, restrictions or agreements with reference to recorded plan.
[2:18:31] Well, what you can do is not give the specific reference. Just say new recorded plan. Does that work?
[2:18:39] So the item nine we
[2:18:54] can say.
[2:18:58] Isn't this just saying that you're going to list the easements and maintenance agreement on the plan, right? And then the plan is going to be recorded,
[2:19:08] right? I mean, we can state that a maintenance agreement [2:19:14] shall be recorded.
[2:19:15] Shall be record shall be recorded. Yeah, that would be better. Yeah. To put on the plan shall be recorded you know for the [2:19:26] and the maintenance agreements will reference this plan. Maintenance agreement shall be recorded [2:19:36] and identify any restrictions needed to preserve your own access to individuals and prevent destruction of the turnaround.
[2:19:52] Yeah, I think we can reference that there shall be a maintenance agreement. That's a better way to do it. Then we can reference the
[2:19:58] I'd rather reference the plan in the maintenance agreement that gets recorded.
[2:20:04] Yeah.
[2:20:05] Recording the plan because then the if we don't record the plan first, then the lots aren't created yet,
[2:20:10] right?
[2:20:11] So,
[2:20:11] yeah, you need that.
[2:20:13] Okay.
[2:20:14] So, five owners down the line, title attorneys held as a maintenance treatment.
[2:20:20] Yep. And then seven, are we good there? [2:20:27] seven I was just going to take out the last sentence I think. So
[2:20:33] the new principal struct dwelling construction on lot two shall be equipped with reser system.
[2:20:44] So just do with lessons
[2:20:49] which you already previously said.
[2:20:54] Yeah, I think that covers that if that is the
[2:21:17] Can we take some motions?
[2:21:21] I'd love to hear emotions. Yeah. How about how about I read one
[2:21:25] before
[2:21:26] the suggested road waiver motion to grant the consolidated road waiver described in section D. I don't know if it was amended by the board. upon finding that the applicable section 250-6.35
[2:21:46] criteria are satisfied and subject to the identified safeguards and conditions.
[2:21:53] Second.
[2:21:56] All in favor?
[2:22:04] You're on the roll. All right, keep going. The suggested final plan motion to adopt the consolidated findings of fact, conclusions, and conditions of approval as amended and grant final plan approval for the Basset subdivision amendment subject to the conditions contained herein and the road waiver that we just granted.
[2:22:27] Second. All in favor?
[2:22:34] Thank you all. What 's your procedure and timeline for submitting
[2:22:41] the required items for this?
[2:22:43] So the easiest way is to just make the revised visions submit them and they'll sign at the board ne next board meeting. If there is a problem with that then Brian you had offered that perhaps the plan could be at the town offices and the board members could come in and sign it. Okay.
[2:23:02] You send me an electronic version, I'll look at it, make sure it's okay,
[2:23:05] and then we can drop off and loss once you're okay with the notes the way they are. okay.
[2:23:15] I have a question. [2:23:18] thank God here because none of this in my wheelhouse. My biggest concern is when and hopefully somebody can explain to this. Can I pursue doing the road improvements, putting in my turnaround and then pursue a building permit
[2:23:35] tomorrow? Thank you. [laughter]
[2:23:38] That's what I want.
[2:23:39] Your building permit you cannot pursue until the road improvements are
[2:23:43] correct. Yes. So once those are satisfied and I assume Calvin will y
[2:23:47] sign off on that and then I can
[2:23:49] if you don't want to wait until our December meeting to for us to sign off on your plans. if you want to send them to the town hall, we all can stop in at our when we have a minute and sign the plan that may expedite it for you. Sure.
[2:24:08] Thank you.
[2:24:08] Thank you. Good job.
[2:24:15] okay. Last thing on our agenda, I believe.
[2:24:26] No new business. Number eight, other business. latest ordinance updates. George briefly talked about the addition of the historic commission issues. [2:24:46] and Georgia I'm not sure if you have any other updates on
[2:24:51] I did get a response from the town of Turing including the packet for next month.
[2:24:56] Okay. So, and you can look at what she's say suggesting
[2:25:00] for what for the
[2:25:01] for the affordable housing. I am working on I'm going to include a working paper draft for the amendments for noise, gravitates, and [2:25:12] South House.
[2:25:14] Okay.
[2:25:16] And the agriculture committee is having a meeting or did they have a meeting last week? They should have.
[2:25:21] They had a meeting last week. I haven't heard anything. Okay.
[2:25:30] Great.
[2:25:30] Being no more business, I make a motion to adjourn. I'll
[2:25:33] second.
[2:25:35] Favor.
[2:25:36] Yeah. Thank you all.
[2:25:38] Thank you.
[2:25:38] Thank you.
[2:25:44] Oh, meeting's normal time, right? Day
[2:25:48] next week. Right. I mean, next month is it going to be in December
[2:25:53] second or something or
[2:25:55] I guess
[2:25:57] Yeah, the second. September 2nd.
[2:26:01] December.
[2:26:02] Wow. [clears throat]
[2:26:06] Okay.