Scarborough Transportation Committee Reviews Traffic Calming Concepts for Payne and Two Rod Roads
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:03] Welcome to the Scar Bro Transportation Committee on Monday, October 26.
[0:09] And attendance
[0:13] Tuck
[0:14] here.
[0:14] Roger
[0:15] here.
[0:15] Peter,
[0:18] he's here. He's online.
[0:19] Peter
[0:22] Stannis is here.
[0:25] Waiting on Greg and Jen.
[0:33] Peter again.
[0:34] He was online and now he is not.
[0:37] Oh, did he get cut off? Yeah, he probably got cut off. [clears throat]
[0:45] And we don't have meeting minutes. We have four members. So, we do not. Yes. So, the next one is the meeting minutes. I do not have the September meeting minutes. I do have a draft. and I actually went back through our meeting a couple times trying to pull out the last meeting we talked through Portland West and trying to come up a list of questions or comments for D do D do D do D do D do D do D do D do D do D do DOT
[1:09] and actually had a meeting with them today.
[1:13] I understand.
[1:15] so I have a list of draft questions. So I was hoping that I could email this the group and see what I'm missing. if you thought of other things you want to add that type of thing.
[1:27] I was going to suggest you and Miss Young introduce yourself.
[1:33] They may not know.
[1:34] Sorry. That's a good point. [laughter]
[1:38] I am Angela Blanchett. I am the town engineer here in Scarboro. And tonight on the agenda, we're going to be talking about traffic calming conceptual plans. We hired a consultant and our consultant is here tonight. Introduce yourself. Hey everybody, I'm Ansley Judge. I'm a planner with younger waste design.
[1:59] So I assume that's what everybody or we have some public here tonight. So that's good. so for the last meeting, as I mentioned, Portland West, I have a list of questions drafted. I will send that to the group tomorrow. if you kind of look through it and see if I didn't capture something right or if you've thought of other things since the meeting, that's fine, too.
[2:22] I can add to the list. and DOT and, the town of Gorum are planning to be at your November meeting.
[2:32] Okay.
[2:32] which is the fourth Tuesday. So, that is the Tuesday before Thanksgiving. So, I'm hoping that I have a quorum. Looks like Jen might not be here, but [laughter] that is the plan right now because they are starting in November here. they'll be starting modeling of the scenarios that we kind of talked through.
[2:54] So
[2:57] we'll get an update later on if that's necessary. And [3:06] guess we're moving on to the next agenda item. Are we ready?
[3:11] Want to make sure you're settled.
[3:12] Yes. I'm sorry. I apologize for being late. Thank you for carrying on
[3:17] in my absence. [3:25] yes.
[3:27] The other
[3:29] Okay. Whoops. you were just giving a sort of a brief overview of everything maybe in lie of meeting minutes.
[3:35] In lie of meeting minutes, I was saying tomorrow I am going to send the group the list of questions for DOT so I can give that to them. So they have a month, you know, to prepare. Although I've already gone through the meeting minutes that the notes I took during the last meeting, I have already walked through with Do
[3:56] and we actually met today as an advisory group and talked a little bit more about what this group was looking for and they mentioned that they will be here at their next meeting.
[4:08] Great. and as well as the town planner in Gora Town Warrior will be available. So,
[4:16] super.
[4:18] Okay, great. With that, let's move on to our item number three, which is traffic calming plan review.
[4:29] So, everyone here, I think is aware that, the town had a capital improvement project that was funded by council for a complete streets and traffic calming guidance manual. We had a complete streets policy that was dated.
[4:50] this group had talked about that for a while. So, we did get funding through our regional planning organization through PAX to do that. but because of the focus that we're hearing from the community and from council to try to focus also on traffic calming, the goal was to create a document that was a one-stop resource for any projects whether it's coming through planning board, whether it's a private developer, whe whether
[5:20] it's the town working on capital improvement projects in the future. So with that half of the kind of focus was on traffic calming. So council did accept that in August of this year. There is some recommendations coming out of that trafficcoming section that you guys will visit in the next couple months.
[5:44] But along with that, what I struggle with a lot with traffic calming is how to implement what what we get out of a lot of this text and online we do searches and Google's and Google searches how you get to or how do you implement them in a rural section
[6:05] and so that's where I was struggling a little bit was taking some of the stuff from the document as we were drafting it and saying can we put this in a context that's in a section of Scar Bro that's not a downtown kind of center and what does that look like and so Enley was part of our design group and Neighborways did a lot of the that piece and the traffic calming
[6:30] and so with that I had some money in our operating budget around traffic calming too that we were able to put towards saying can you take what you guys are putting together as a draft and give us some conceptual designs or examples. And specifically, council during the budget process talked about the detour route and now with Scott Hill Road Culbert being closed and
[6:59] the route that takes you from the intersection, which you're looking at two rod and pain road down two rod to Scott Hill and back out to Hygus. kind of looking at that as being kind of that detour route and taking a look at it and how you might implement some of the traffic calming pieces to it. So that's where neighbors came in.
[7:20] So I'm going to hand that off then to you. Can I ask one question?
[7:25] Yeah.
[7:25] I remember when we did the policy recommendation to council and that was what year and a half, two years ago. I just don't remember [laughter] exactly what we said. I know that there were what three types of traffic calming that we talked about. I don't but I do have
[7:45] we have a traffic calming request policy that's in place. it does go through the police department and yes there are three kind of categories for implementation. there's kind of enforcement. There's some kind of I guess what I call kind of lowhanging kind of fruit like there's more like signage or striping kind of lowcost things and then there's implementation of like more heavy duty infrastructure.
[8:14] so those are kind of the three
[8:16] trying to refresh my brain. [laughter]
[8:19] Yeah. And those would be the methods like the action items from our policy traffic calming incomplete sheets guide. So you start with the guide book, right? look at an area, figure out, okay, we have a problem here. and then use the
[8:39] the group and the policy to figure out how to where to where to go, where to do the improvements, and then
[8:49] great. hello everyone again. My name is Ansley Judge. I'm a planner with Neighborways. I got to work on the toolkit portion of the complete streets and traffic calming guidance and manual. And I think it was a great opportunity to immediately on the heels of that guidance to then go into like a case scenario which we have here at Payne Road and T-Rod Road and Scott Hill Road and just to say okay how can we apply this guidance to this setting.
[9:18] So the project area [clears throat] is just about a mile and it begins the focus area was really at pain and two rod as a high crash intersection but then going along two rod road where it meets Scott Hill out to highest parkway as Angela mentioned the that intersection was of note but also with the covert failure there and the detour it became a really interesting piece to look at and see how we can implement some traffic calm devices.
[9:46] Yeah, I should note that this been on the radar prior to the Culbert failure. This has been an area of town in that neighborhood that we've heard from about traffic calming and then also the number of crashes that intersection and looking at ways to be proactive and make that a safer intersection. So, I would say
[10:09] separate from the Culvert failure, this would still be kind of an effort that we'd looked at. I think it kind of broadens it a little bit. We broadened it out along too broad at Scott Hill, but I think that intersection was something along with the intersection at the bottom of the hill at Scott Hill and Payne. those were two that we were looking at with high crash locations.
[10:34] so that's sort of reiterating what Angela just mentioned. We have the manual that went out. We have a high crash intersection at Payne and Trod which was identified in 2025. and then the road closure. And so before we get into the draft concepts, I'm just going to walk through some of the crash data that we were looking at to give you a sense of how we were trying to address the issues that we saw through the data and then through some field observations of the project area.
[11:01] in the complete streets manual, there was a street types map. And so through that we have Payne Road here in this project area as being a neighborhood connector. Of course just further north of here it transitions into a major corridor where we have the exit 42 coming off of I95. Cabelas etc. the shopping plazas. two rod and scatoto hill are rural connectors and both of these are mostly residential streets.
[11:28] looking at the speed and volume data using the main DOT information at Payne Road at this intersection is about 7,000 on average cars per day. Speed limit there is 35. On Twod we have a speed limit posted of 25 just under 1,000 cars per day.
[11:50] Scott Hill Road has a little bit more maybe 1300 on average cars per day and a posted speed limit of 35.
[11:58] And do we refresh my memory on the date of that culvert closure? So like do we know if these volumes are indicative of like pret we tried to figure that out as much as possible. So the co the road closed in 20 May 2025. Okay.
[12:17] I'm pretty sure that the dot data for two rod is actual numbers. and it's roughly the same. On Scott Hill, that volume number is actually an estimate. and Pain Road is an actual number.
[12:34] I can, just fill in a little bit because I have the main DOT public map viewer app. and for two rod road between Payne and Scott Hill before the road closure, so the 2022
[12:51] volume was 535
[12:57] I believe and then after the 530 and then after the closure was 850.
[13:05] Okay. So
[13:06] So yeah, these are taken after
[13:08] Yeah. so it's still considerably it's actually lower than what we define a rural connector road which is between 1,000 and 10,000 which is interesting to note that this could probably looking at a be better categorized as a local road
[13:28] opposed to a connector.
[13:29] I think that's a good point. It has a lot of the characteristics especially when I was out I walked the whole the whole street. It's a beautiful street and it's pretty highly residential. It's functioning like a local street.
[13:52] Okay. So, we had the benefit of being able to look at some really recent speed data collected by Scarboro PD. This was collected in September 2025. So, the posted speed limit on TRA is 25. And where this was taken, there's a tiny green dot on the map. It's at Whipple Lane. so if you're not super familiar with T- Rod, basically from the intersection with Payne, there's a long straightaway and this speed was taken right in the middle of that straightaway.
[14:19] Then there's a sharp bend and some winding roads until Scott Hill. I think of note of a 72 mph speed was clocked. I assume this is an outlier, but I think it goes to show you the potential for really gaining speed on this short stretch of straightaway. but on average, you have
[14:39] the average person is speeding going over 30 miles an hour at least 6 miles an hour over. So, yeah, that was great information to have. and here we're looking at the main DOT public crash query tool to pull these numbers. again that intersection at Payne and Tur Rod you have nine crashes in the last five years.
[14:59] the image so that's the image in the center. The image to the right further it's showing kind of the section further north. So as you're transitioning into the major corridor and you can see there are little pockets of crashes as you're approaching the intersection. I think it's worth noting that right pretty close to the intersection there was a fatality there 2023
[15:21] where women drove off the road and into the ditch. just north of T- Rod and then in the bottom left we have the image from Haggus Parkway you know there's a cluster right at the intersection and then it's a little bit scattered on the parkway itself and there were a few on Scott Hill as well and we'll go into the details on the next slides here which show the contributing factors so at the intersections at Payne and Trod where we saw nine crashes most of these are intersection movement
[15:51] issues so a failure to yield to the right ofway Okay, maybe you can imagine like I the way I interpret it is it's challenging to pull out of two rod onto paint and to be able to like guess where that pocket is to be able to get out. there were also things like following too closely. of getting rear ended. running the stop sign.
[16:11] At Scotto Hill and Haggus, we have three crashes and it's a mix of being rearended, failure to yield, rubber turn. And we'll go into each location in the next few slides, so look out for a lot of tables here. so combined, we're just looking at like the summary of the intersections.
[16:33] and you can really see the numbers where you're failure to yield right of way and following too closely. Those are your big ones. but also exceeding this post posted speed limit, running a stop sign, and some reckless driving.
[16:48] for the non-intersection crashes. So, this is actually the stretch south of the intersection on Pain Road as you're heading towards Shadow Hill where it's closed. there were 11 crashes there. deer come into the equation for this stretch. which may not be a surprise to anyone and it's just showing there's a variety of factors contributing here.
[17:13] and on Scott Hill Road there were six crashes. A lot of these are going off the road. driving too fast. maybe swerving running off the roadway.
[17:32] and then on two rod there's one
[17:35] could be win
[17:38] two.
[17:39] Yeah. So this is data from [18:03] gardening, doing yard work. there was a father pushing his baby in a stroller on two rod. so we had a lot of great conversations that were unexpected. but while I'll start with the intersection here, the intersection is slightly offset as you can see. and in the southeast corner as you turn onto two rod from pain that's a really wide curve radi measuring just under 100 ft right there.
[18:27] the road all the roads in this project area are narrow. there's a pretty narrow right of way and it makes sense. They're old roads. They're really beautiful. this stretch of Pain Road is treelined. The northwest corner that you can't fully see it but there are some photos coming up. there's a pretty deep ditch and that's where that crash fatality took place.
[18:47] and there's also a hill kind of just north of this intersection here. And you may not think of it as a hill, but if you were trying to cross or turn in either direction, there are some limited sight lines. and that becomes clear when you're looking at it just the right angle. So
[19:09] here are just some photos of that intersection. if you're not driving here every day. If you are, you probably know exactly what you're looking at. and the next slide will show the image on the right is sort of the deepest part of that ditch. but that kind of runs along the west the northwest side of the street. on the left image, you see that wide curb radi that I was talking about is turning onto two rod.
[19:37] so yeah, walking along two rod again was really lovely. There's that straightaway, a really sharp bend, and then it's really windy. there were people out gardening. we talked to a father whose children waits for the school bus outside their house at this school bus stop on Scott Hill Road. And so this whole street is on it's on the school bus route.
[19:59] And this bus stop is right at like the crest of the hill on Scott Hill. he expressed concern that you know cars may not be able to see his children while they're waiting for the school bus in the morning. at the intersection here there's a sign as you enter two ride that says no through trucks. Same is true for the other side. There's also a stop sign there right now but that was added once the road was closed.
[20:23] and that right there is another pretty like wide turn into broad. Yeah. And there are the images right there. And you can kind of see just past that white car in the upper right image is where the school bus stop is.
[20:43] Okay. And so Scott Hill Road, again, you probably know this, but it's it's got some curves. It has some grades, so there's a hill. It's pretty easy to gather speed in either direction as you're going downhill. the father we talked to said there were a lot of kids on the street and they all play sports and they like to walk and bike. and you know they walk and bike on Scott Hill but usually they reroute to two rod and try to stay there and
[21:08] just mention that there's a lot of speeding that happens especially before the road closed.
[21:16] and here at Higus Parkway there are no pedestrian facilities here. We did cross the street back and forth and it's really challenging to do so. There's some pretty tall reads that kind of block you because the road does have a little bend right there. one thing I noticed and saw is actually just not too far from here, actually exactly one mile, there is a connection to the Eastern Trail right by Scarbor Public Works.
[21:42] and I used to go to an auto shop was right there, Blackpoint Auto. So, I would take that pathway sometimes waiting just waiting for the a bus I used to drive to be repaired. but yeah, there's the entrance. It's a little bit wider here, but still narrow. do you want to take a question? Peter, do you w to jump in?
[22:04] I guess just on Haggus here. I think about a quarter mile north of here in Haggus there's the beginning of a bike trail.
[22:12] so we have a master plan for Haggus Parkway, but right now the vegan the apartment building on the end complex I should say has built out part of the sidewalk. That's a sidewalk that they have built along a section.
[22:29] and the downs as part of their TMP will expand it towards the other direction though heading towards Pain Road.
[22:37] And our master plan does show a multi-use an off-road multi-use path for the whole length of Hygus to get back one to paint road. So the master plan does have it that bike trail road coming down to this intersection at some point.
[22:56] It would go by it would be the length of PUAS. Yes. So
[23:00] and on this side on this side of the road on the side of the road where Sky Hill Road is.
[23:05] I believe it's on both sides. There's well a sidewalk on one side but a multi-use path is on the opposite side.
[23:11] Okay. Got it.
[23:17] and some images.
[23:20] Okay, so now we get to some of the draft concept designs that we worked on to try to address what we were seeing, what we heard, and the data that we looked at. so the big issue at this intersection is that there are some crashes happening here that we would like to see a lot less of, if any. but there's a hill there with limited sight lines to the northeast.
[23:41] So, what we're proposing here is to add in some vertical traffic combing devices. Vertical traffic combing is highly effective at slowing speeds. and considering that we're transitioning from that major corridor into a more residential area, we're proposing a series of speed raised speed tables.
[24:01] these are spaced about 400 ft apart, which per the recommendation from the town. a series is kind of the best way to get consistent slowing, especially as you approach the intersection. So, there's two in the, north of the intersection and one to the south. They're the yellow rectangles, if you can see those. Okay. and they're also there are white lines next to a few of them, especially in the north.
[24:25] And those are optional guard rails. Those are serving two purposes here. One is a lot of those crashes we were seeing are going cars going off road. So, it's to prevent that. but it is also a way to prevent someone from swerving around intentionally swerving around a speed table which happens. when we don't recommend a guard rail because you don't want those everywhere,
[24:50] you can place them next to a tree or a utility pole or something that's a fixed object already. That can help prevent swerving. the spacing is sort of chosen based on appropriate setbacks from driveways, fire hydrants, mailboxes, intersections, etc.
[25:12] Okay, here's a long-term option or concept. We looked at a lot of different things here. This would be a roundabout. kind of oddly shaped, but so is the intersection. So they're a perfect match here. This would the benefit of this is it reduces speeds for all vehicles without requiring them to stop and it reduces the potential for all types of the severe crashes that you're seeing.
[25:36] it is more expensive which is why it's longer term. it almost fits perfectly in the right of way but the red dash lines that you're seeing are like little clips that you need to be able to get just enough space to safely maneuver around. so that this is a potential option that could help slow and this could pair with raised speed tables in the approach in both directions.
[26:02] You can see the gray rectangles in either direction. it would do really well to have slowed speeds approaching a roundabout. those could also be rumble strips as well. a John.
[26:15] Is that actually a is that a concept that's in the traffic industry? Like is that is that the peanut?
[26:25] Yep.
[26:26] Well, it does look like a peanut. I don't know that 's tech peanuts technically would even take up a bigger space than that, but
[26:36] yes, a roundabout or a traffic circle.
[26:38] Yeah, it's a small peanut. Yeah. So, can we establish that as something important right here? [laughter]
[26:44] Small peanuts. Yeah,
[26:48] Peter has his hand up again. Go ahead, Peter.
[26:51] Just wondering how expensive is expensive or more expensive.
[26:56] Well, I guess I don't know if you have an answer to that, but I guess I'm going to jump in and say at this point, these are concept plans. So, our next step out of coming out of anything is to look at a design. And so designing would give us kind of budgetary numbers to know what that actual magnitude be. I mean we can look at it and say you know based on a square footage that you're kind of rebuilding the road.
[27:21] We just haven't done that yet.
[27:24] Yeah. Just the more greater construction cost just it almost raises more fears than anything. I just don't know how to contextualize it.
[27:36] Yeah. I guess when you're saying greater a speed table is a pretty nominal cost per h it adds up and then we're doing striping and guardrail that's where costs add up a little bit but this is a roadway construction.
[27:50] Yeah. And the speed table I had a question to you. The speed table is would that be a tarmac or would that be rubber or would that be what was envisioned for that?
[28:03] it can be either. So I think that depends on yeah whether you're piloting something or if you're going to vulk going to permanent and permanent would be asphalt. [28:15] okay
[28:15] the benefit of going to permanent is you don't have to do it twice. The benefit of a pilot is you get to test it out. So I think there are real pros and cons to each one.
[28:25] And do we have good data on plowing versus the speed tables? So, we have one, well, we technically have two speed tables in town. One we haven't plowed over yet. but there is one on Maple. There's also one at Ocean U that just went in. And, public works is navigating those.
[28:47] They're they're pretty gentle kind of ramping up and then there's a flat table and it ramps down. So, they're they're navigating it. I think this might be a little more challenging than those side like kind of local streets where they're going. This is a main corridor where they're probably maybe going a little faster, but also trying to clear that a lot of snow because this is going to be a main travel way.
[29:13] Whereas like if you start prioritizing route one is the first priority and then you get to road and then you get to pay road like there's priority lists. So, they're probably navigating this more than they would say the local side streets. but at this point, they have not had issues with the one on Maple.
[29:35] And I will say again this is concept knowing that speed table is one of the options like again it goes back to the traffic calming guidance manual and saying what other you know what that and you mentioned cushions or other things like that is something new that we haven't tried in town.
[29:57] fire chief had some concerns around the cushions, but it might be something we want to pilot somewhere or test somewhere to see how the fire trucks navigate through these kind of things also.
[30:09] No, I just I mean, Pedro is a major road for me all through the year and the plows go through there and they need to go through there fairly quickly because there's so many connections like two rod they have to go on to. So, yeah, that's just a thought. So
[30:28] I have a question. Is it are we looking at this under the excuse me under the assumption that Scarlet Hill Road is never going to be reopened right through?
[30:37] No. That's why well I mentioned at the beginning that I think this is a parallel path that it was always on our radar is this being a high crash location that regardless if Scott Mill Road is opened or permanently closed that [clears throat] this needs to be addressed. and I know we like we said, we've heard from the residents up there before Scott Hill Road closure that this was up an issue that we needed to look at and
[31:03] okay then I guess are we going to be looking at other options other alternatives be besides this is this
[31:12] there's a there
[31:13] ultimate solution
[31:15] well they're just concept drafts so things to be explored there were a lot of iterations which we could look at but have received Yeah. but maybe don't won't work for a lot of different reasons.
[31:29] Okay.
[31:30] Yeah. I mean
[31:31] I ask the question longterm if we widen route one or sorry pain road north of it to the four lane roads like how does this
[31:40] so the fourlane section for [clears throat] pain road is from exit 42 up to road. So the intent is that people we're trying to encourage people coming out of exit 42 to go high guess to route one and not use this as the cut through.
[31:58] So adding traffic would this incentivize that behavior?
[32:02] I would hope so. Okay. Yes. we had a whole study previously around the traffic signals specifically cabelas is intentionally a pain to get through because it's trying to discourage you from going that way if that's more delay. So those type of things even on the other end on the Dunston end is we look at that signal too is making that less convenient to do that as a cut through if it adds time
[32:32] to your travel
[32:38] and just one thing on pain there too is there any thought being given to giving getting more of a shoulder for that for bikers or for other users?
[32:53] it's not at the moment. We haven't done any design, but I think with any roadway project, as our complete street manual looks at, we would want to at least look at shoulders or something in that kind of section. So, yes.
[33:09] Yeah. You mentioned that there's a lot of cars going off the road, but what I notice on there is if there is any if there is a biker, they've got no shoulder to work with and you've got to really almost pull entirely into the other lane to get around them. So, it's it's a tough section for pedestrians and bikers out there in pain.
[33:28] There's a like a long-term consideration like summary map that we'll get to at the end of these slides here that shows some yeah long-term thoughts around that same. Okay.
[33:41] Any kind of shoulder would be a plus. I've written from pain at flarities on and it is scary.
[33:48] Yeah, we measured an 8 in shoulder south of there. Scary.
[33:54] Well, and there's also going to be that sports facility off of two rod road that will probably attract more bikers. so just trying to think about that too.
[34:03] Oh, the rugby. Yeah,
[34:07] that is open.
[34:08] [clears throat]
[34:10] so as we head down to Rod Road, we wanted to look at, the straightaway here, when we were out there in May, there was a, a speed feedback sign. Not sure if it's still there. The speed study that we looked at earlier was just by Whipple Lane. and so the recommendation here to hope that a 72 mph car wouldn't
[34:32] gain [clears throat] that much speed, again, is another series of, in this case, speed humps or speed cushions. So, the reason we did speed tables on Pain Road is because at a speed limit of above 30 miles an hour, that's really preferred. It's a little bit more sloped and gentle, there's more of like a plateau on the top, whereas a speed humper speed cushion is a little bit narrower.
[34:53] So, those are better suited for a road like this that has a 25 m hour speed limit. A speed cushion, as Angela just mentioned, is a slightly different kind. There's a picture of it to the right there. It's the bottom right image. So there's actually gaps between whereas a speed hump is continuous across the street and those gaps are designed specifically so that emergency and fire vehicles can get through without going over the hump and impacting the suspension in any way.
[35:20] the I believe it's that the chassis I think the width of the tire the tire wheels on an emergency vehicle is wider and different than a regular passenger vehicle. So you or I driving down the street, assuming we're not firefighters, would have to go over those bumps, whereas a fire truck would not. so here the spacing is again set at 400 ft per the recommendation in the design manual.
[35:47] And we have a series because again, just one hump won't really do anything. You kind of need repeat humps to help get the message across that we're slowing down. And again, these are cited next to trees. just to help people from swerving around them and going onto people's properties, but they avoid or there are the appropriate setbacks from any driveway, any mailbox, intersection, things of that nature.
[36:12] yeah, so on the next slide, we'll see that third speed cushion in the series, and that's just to the east of Opal Lane and around the bend. So at this bend, we have a recommendation. It's hard to see a little bit, but there are like a bunch of white dots around the bend. Those are called optical speed bars. It's really simple to implement.
[36:33] There's just white paint. and you can put a bunch of them and it gives you the illusion of a narrowing space and so it can kind of gently slow a car through that bend. there's the option to do some center line hardening, which in some places they might use flex posts, in other places it could be like a casting concrete little center island. you could do like a speed bump in the middle there, but that might be challenging for plows.
[36:57] So, just something to kind of make sure that we're not whipping through the vent.
[37:04] then we get to the intersection with Scott Hill Road. really we're just looking at ways to kind of make sure that entering to Rod is gets kind of a gateway treatment. So you could do a center median island there that would be small, that could be temporary or permanent. meaning you could test it or just put in a little casting concrete median there.
[37:25] again there's the school bus stop at the top of the hill. So again, just slowing down traffic as it's going through the curve and the bend there because we are coming downhill if you're on Scatoto Hill as you approach that. the road closure is there. So the stop sign is helping and I think further consideration would be needed tied into the town's
[37:45] process for knowing what to do with that with that cold right there. to do much more traffic calming on Scott Hill Road itself because you have grade changes the hill and some curves. I think you really would need an additional study that's looking at those grade changes and all of those things in order to put something vertical there or any horizontal
[38:08] traffic combing like say a chain or something that can help slow traffic. long-term considerations could be a sidewalk or a shared use path that ties into other things. but it you don't really just want to throw something on that road because you have a lot of other factors going on
[38:29] as you approach the hill. So, this here is like an overview or a summary. So, just to kind of look at everything together on Payne Road, there's a series of race speed tables, the potential for a long-term traffic calming option at the intersection, which could be a roundabout, a small peanut perhaps, on two rod road at the straightaway, a series of speed cushions,
[38:53] some optical speed bars on the bend, and then gateway treatments at either end of Scott Hill Road, which signifies people live here, there are children here, people are walking and biking and just to help slow on either end of the hill going downhill or uphill. and the next slide shows some of the more long-term considerations where if you try some of these and they work, you could extend that series of speed tables if you wanted, you could add in a sidewalk on Payne Road.
[39:23] sounds like there's a shared use path already going in on Higgus Parkway and so thinking about the wayfinding for that along those two roads so the kids can navigate it safely. and yeah, so again, I think there this here is designed to show concepts that offer both near-term solution solutions,
[39:45] long-term considerations, and hopefully tying it all into what the town needs to do for the rest of that area, but also mostly for traffic safety and limited crashes.
[39:59] so we have like I said there's other options that we talked internally through which are some other some future slides we can go through and talk through why those didn't necessarily work when we kind of started vetting them. But I also wanted to point out that this I have added to the town website this is on the transportation page.
[40:27] So, this is available to everyone. This isn't the only time you're going to see it. you can find it on the website. If you leave your email address, I can have I can also email it to you. but trying to get that word out. But I guess we're also just looking for I guess the transportation committee to kind of look at a little bit and to say this doesn't look like it's going to work.
[40:50] This may work. like it 's really about going to the next step is for us to get an engineer involved and to see what is actually viable for options or not but I it'd be helpful to hear say public opinion and as well as the transportation committee to say this isn't going to get off the ground or maybe there's another option.
[41:14] Is this totally funded?
[41:17] Yes.
[41:18] Okay. [41:20] so far. Yeah.
[41:21] At the top of two rod road where the bend is the there was a road that went down to the fishing hole. Has is there any does it make any sense to look at that as a direct connection to the parkway?
[41:43] Oh, you mean over at high? Yeah, that's all private property. Yeah, that's what you mean. they were gonna come and run a planning board and they have not have they years ago
[41:55] years ago
[41:56] on that but
[41:57] it was a very long a very long time ago I have not heard any
[42:01] there's a road there's a road to actually you could drive your car all the way down
[42:05] down to the those points
[42:07] well there is a private way so you can see at the corner
[42:12] is that what you're talking about or are you saying there's another like
[42:15] right at the right at the very top
[42:17] right at the bed by the name of the
[42:23] way.
[42:26] Yeah, it's going straight through.
[42:31] The guy's name was Bob. I can't think of his last name.
[42:33] Yeah,
[42:34] he was he was at the high school. He was the Egyptian.
[42:40] New
[42:41] actually his son his sons
[42:44] his son owns the
[42:45] Scottway is off is straight. So if you're going two rod and you go straight that says it's got a way but if you take goes to the
[42:56] Yep. which there's a lot of
[43:01] appears to be a lot of wetlands and terrain that
[43:04] there's there's a dramatic drop there, you know. Yeah, that's what I
[43:07] But there is a there is a road that does go down there. You know, it's a long dirt driveway, but
[43:13] yeah, I think that would be a lot of land acquisition to make that happen.
[43:17] And then you'd be on the other side of those ponds, so you'd have to get across the ponds also.
[43:22] It could. Yeah.
[43:24] Is that Stuga Road or Stuga?
[43:26] Yeah.
[43:27] Yeah.
[43:27] Yeah. Okay.
[43:29] It is a good point though. I think like in terms of you know our overall goal for improving or at least maintaining connectivity [43:41] where we can and so
[43:43] you know it's not exactly like a home run of a connection but we've seen development proposed for that lot before and so you know I don't know you never
[43:54] yeah it might be good to keep in mind for the planning board if
[43:57] and Scott Hill Road is such a curvy dangerous road actually, you know, going if it were even opened to get up.
[44:10] [44:11] does anyone else have any comments?
[44:14] I have a couple comments if you wanted to.
[44:18] When do you want to Well, I didn't want to interrupt you, but no, I'm good. first question I have in comment is do we need two rod road to be divided with like a double yellow line? because it struck me as how
[44:36] little the traffic volume numbers actually are on that road
[44:41] to the point where when it's below 1,00 generally you don't have a it's not a connector. It's considered a local road. And could that be an option to just take away those yellow lines, bring in your you know, the
[45:01] white strips on the on the side of the road a bit to give you more of thinking kind of like dresser road if you guys know you're familiar. That's a that's a similar kind of road that does connect to roads, but it's purposely made to be more of a neighborhood road than a cut through. because you've taken that double yellow lane away and kind of narrowed it out a bit and that could be a really inexpensive way and it seems like this two rod would actually qualify for that type of a treatment.
[45:31] and honestly Scottell isn't too far behind it. if it is reopened it is more but you could it's it's only slightly above thousand. [45:45] interesting the volume they're nearly identical to the eastern road where we have the shar formalized yes shared lane treatment
[45:54] the advisory links.
[45:56] Yeah. Yeah. I mean it's a really good idea.
[46:00] I love the work we've done. and I will kind of always be on the side of slowing traffic down. I do wonder a little bit how the public may react to pain road speed tables given that 's you know 7 8,000
[46:24] bond traffic and it is kind of considered more of a
[46:29] a more meter road than others. and then the roundabout to my concern would just be the cost and with the limited amount of funding that we have for all the traffic that are needed townwide if that is the most cost effective way to improve
[46:51] things. [46:53] and it very it might be I'm not saying it as critique necessarily, but to make sure we're we're looking holistically at the entire town and all the needs that we have
[47:03] and what amount of funding do we have to cover the whole town and what our priority pain road may ultimately with our vulnerability study end up being the alternate path when route one is being raised or evaluated. waited for flooding in the bar.
[47:24] So
[47:25] when that does happen, is Route One planned to be closed or would will it always
[47:31] when do raises route one?
[47:33] Yeah. Will that be a full closure for a little while or
[47:36] I do not believe so. Their goal was to keep it I mean it's going to be problematic and it will be delayed [laughter]
[47:45] but the intent is not the speed limit.
[47:50] Yeah. probably similar to a Wisconsin,
[47:54] right?
[47:55] But they put it but they still put a curve around.
[47:57] They have some temporary route. Yeah. That you're allowed yet.
[48:00] You want to come.
[48:02] the last thing is kind of echoing what Peter said is getting a shoulder on that section of paint road is priority because that is ideally where talked about how we don't want we prefer that traffic go along highest and route one. but on the flip side of that, we'd prefer that cyclists and runners and
[48:24] you know active transportation take that be road corridor. and ideally a shoulder would be a relatively cost effective way of making that
[48:36] particularly in concert with other speed like traffic something you're lowering your vehicle like where you want them
[48:45] because when you start widing so you say you five foot shoulders out there then the speed goes up is what you'd have you'd have a wide open
[48:52] kind of more of a highway. So we don't want to increase speeds or increase necessarily the volumes to make it that's an easier route.
[48:59] Yeah.
[48:59] Right. Balance that
[49:01] and shoulders in that case I would think would have a positive impact on even vehicle safety because there is not a lot of room for you to recover in an 8 in shoulder. And that's that's
[49:14] and drop is pretty
[49:15] probably why there's so many off-road crashes you know and if you provided even medial amount of space two three four feet while not you know those are not those don't even meet the minimums for you know for safe pedestrian facilities. It's obviously an improvement over what's there would be safer for non-motorized traffic but motorized traffic too.
[49:46] so we live at the top of Scout Hill where that bus stop is. there's no shoulder. literally no shoulder. And the road is has degraded so much that every winter when they plow all the asphalt goes up onto our property and they come back with, you know, a couple guys a bucket of asphalt, throw it down.
[50:09] And the last time that they painted the white line, it was actually in the dirt. so
[50:15] that's a request. Some kind of shoulder there. it's very, narrow and it's the very top of the hill, which is extremely dangerous. One question I have as well is about speed limits. and you can see that's looking at our house right there at the background, right? [50:36] it seems like it should be lower than 35. really if Chro is 25, Scott should be 25 as well. the stop signs that are there that have u come up that have been put up since the closure have definitely slowed the traffic I would say. if
[50:57] if that road is not permanently closed down at the bottom of the hill, [51:05] I would hope that those stop signs would remain there. they're definitely helpful. but I can tell you before those stop signs were there every single day, multiple times a day, there were cars going 70 miles an hour. No exaggeration. accelerating all the way up the hill and all the way down to the bottom of the other direction. both directions.
[51:25] Yeah.
[51:26] So, I guess that's just a request for you know considering the speed limit and I'm not sure what that processes for reducing that speed limit. some cars are stopping at those stop signs. The majority are not.
[51:47] and I'm I've been out there all day every day for the past week watching and 90% of the cars don't stop
[51:56] including some town vehicles.
[51:57] Yeah. And they have to come they coming out of T Rod they do have to stop obviously because it's a dead end and turning left and right. but coming on Scott Hill turning on to T Rod very few cars are stopping and there's never any enforcement. there never has been any horse the speed limits
[52:19] or the stop sign. So, it's it's kind of a tough combination with no shoulder. It's very dangerous for people walking or
[52:30] nobody can really ride a bike safely. they're in the road. there's no way to get off the road. so if cars are if two cars are coming, it's it's extremely dangerous. so I think we had talked about the idea of you know some kind of tables or something. I understand that it's tricky with the great changes of the hills and all that too but some way coming up the hills from both directions to slow the traffic would be really helpful
[53:00] and then also approaching those stop signs
[53:05] slowing down.
[53:06] So I just wanted to respond to a couple of things you had said. So, the stop signs that are in place there. So, if Scow Hill does end up becoming a through street again and that opens up, we will have to do a stop sign warrant analysis which may indicate that it's not warranted.
[53:28] So DOT would require us because to do a warrant analysis because if it's not warranted, we have seen that accident rates actually go up because people are they stopping and they're not stopping or to your point is if the stop sign's there and it's not warranted and people just go through it. We ended up having crashes and we're finding that in other areas in town when signs went in that weren't warranted become more problematic and more of a safety concern.
[53:57] So, I'm not saying that it would or wouldn't meet it. I don't know. It would just be a process. So, it's not necessarily a permanent installation.
[54:06] Yeah, we know now that stop signs don't make good traffic control measures. And we 've learned that the hard way here.
[54:14] Stop signs come out. I would really hope there would be some other kind of
[54:18] Yeah.
[54:20] That might be a good table in case he table similar to what was proposed at Pain Road to really slow people down going into that intersection.
[54:29] I echo her concerns though with the grade and the alignment through there. So, it might be something where she had mentioned about like gateway treatments. So, you could look at kind of I've seen it in other neighborhoods where you kind of can have an island or something. You're coming up to the stop sign or not a stop sign, you're coming through an area. things like that.
[54:50] So,
[54:51] it's just so narrow it's hard to imagine putting
[54:54] Well, you'd have to wipe it.
[54:57] Yeah.
[54:57] Have one of those like really tiny roundabouts that force people to like get down like 10 miles hour.
[55:05] No, there might be some emergency vehicle.
[55:08] I know, but I just wanted one more thing about the speed limit. so DOT sets the speed limit. [55:14] yeah,
[55:15] and they do do that upon the town's request to do an analysis. So typically what happens though is they look at speeds and how fast people are going is one of the p pieces. They also look at the density in the area and how many walkers, bikers and things like that. So they are getting better about kind of looking more holistically at how they do it.
[55:39] However, we've been challenged with where we put our money into traffic calming because that's how DOT has said to do it. You need to invest in these roadways to do traffic coming and then we do an analysis. We spent millions of dollars on Gorum Road and I continually, this committee has continually
[56:02] pushed on having them re-evaluate that. it's very challenging because of just how the mechanism works and so that's why they're doing them speed limit analysis for every road in the state of Maine. So we have to really prioritize and so that's where it's a little bit a challenge that I don't want to request a speed study here and then your speed limit goes up
[56:27] because they want to move traffic. So that's the other caution and we do have a list of roads that need to be looked at. So I just kind of caution around that. [56:38] that actually came up when we're doing the u looking at homes road the planning board over that development out there and the residents out there want the speed limit reduced and I and I recall might have been you I'm not sure but somebody said if main do comes in and takes a look at the speeds
[56:58] and they find out say it's 35 but people are going 40 they may raise actually raise it and not reduce it. I don't know if they've ever done that, but I think they would say
[57:11] I wouldn't say you, but like you said, they would come out of the say 40, so we're going to have it at 35 or something like that. I don't So, yeah,
[57:20] I think to their credit, I think DOT has made some progress in this area.
[57:28] that yeah, previously like to be by the book, there were situations where, you know, they're looking at the 85th percentile speed. So if 85% you know people are traveling, you know, it 's an indicator that like something along this road is telling people that this is a comfortable and safe speed to be at.
[57:49] Like whether that's a good you know that's not whether that's sound or not. That's like those are some of the clues that go into it. And when you talk about redesigning a road or changing a speed limit, you know, they should be considered together. So yes, you know, we all know that changing the numbers on that sign from 35 to 25 the next morning, everybody is not going to be going 25 because the design of the road is still telling them like, "Yep, you're, you know, you can hit 70 on this
[58:19] straight away." but anyway I think I think DOT has made some progress in that area and so [58:27] we need to prioritize our request because it does last takes two years to get through it maybe longer for Gor Road to spin. [58:37] but with that point it's like we're talking about these are the investments. So if we're doing something out on Payne Road or Two Rod or even Scott Hill is making that investment and then requesting for DOT and saying, "Okay, the town's put our mouth out is these are our priorities. Here's what we've done to work towards lowering the speed limit." I think it would.
[58:58] What I'm finding is if I just come at DOT and say, "Here's a road that probably should be slower. It's a non-starter. I can't even get it off the starting line for them because they have just so many that are I think a higher priority for them. That's all. So, but us investing shows a different priority than and kind of increasing that.
[59:21] Now, that intersection is that at the very top of the of the hill?
[59:25] Yeah.
[59:25] Okay. [59:26] just past
[59:27] close to it. and the radi right now. would it not be feasible to make that a 90%
[59:37] you know a you know 90%.
[59:39] Yeah I think so in that call out there it's just a tight turning radi and
[59:44] forcing someone to make a 90° turn close down right now you can just
[59:50] go
[59:53] literally just almost Yeah.
[59:57] to drive homes. It's a really long
[1:00:00] I think it also would probably need we'd want to put some curving or something in there so that because all it means is everyone just drives off the road and it becomes compacted and you end up it will end up back with a wide radius. That kind of happened at the end of high onto pain and public works had to keep going out there and they just kept paving and painting and then you get this wide you end up back where you were.
[1:00:22] [laughter]
[1:00:22] So,
[1:00:23] I just want to note, Maple Lab is the success story. They've got their speed down from 20 30 to 20.
[1:00:32] [1:00:32] 25 to 20
[1:00:33] 25 to 20. Maple Lab has twice the traffic volume as Trod.
[1:00:39] so it would seem that if Maple can do it, certainly Tro should be able to. but
[1:00:50] Scott Hill also is less even before the road closure is lower than midl
[1:01:00] Venice was waiting to or
[1:01:03] I've had my hand up for a while but I know
[1:01:05] Okay. All right.
[1:01:08] Yeah. I just want to go back. It strikes me the two rod and Scott Hill Road would benefit from looking at the Eastern Road solution. And Easter Road also has a a
[1:01:23] circular roundabout which is not that big. It's not a gigantic roundabout, but it works well. and that might be a solution for the for this year. But the idea of having the one lane with two wide bike and multi-use side side sidelines.
[1:01:45] given the volumes we're talking about and given what we're what I've heard in terms of the amount of people who want to use it for biking and pedestrian activity, this would be a clever a clever solve for that. on pain road though,
[1:02:02] I think though or two, which road were you talking about, Peter, for that?
[1:02:07] Both of them actually. From two rod all the way from Payne to Scato and then Scott Hill as well. particularly if Scott doesn't re reconnect
[1:02:19] and maybe in sections but I would think too Rod with the curves I think that would be dangerous and also Scott Hill if we're talking about alignment and grade changes that if you're coming up over not seeing we were talking about
[1:02:32] sharing
[1:02:33] well but dstriping for example I think would also be an equivalent solution and I don't know I if I look at dstripe roads that are not striped through the rest of town. then you've got rows with grade changes and curves. Jasper Street's one of them that I live on.
[1:02:54] curvier, significantly curvier than Scott Hill, but and hillier and have mirror sight lines as well. So I think there are there are examples out there of low volume roads which are attracting and the development on Scott Hill road is attracting more people who would naturally use it as a biking and pedestrian road.
[1:03:18] So the main comment though I really want to make was on pain road. Pain road is screaming for a bigger solution than just trying to figure out some speed reductions and and a peanut. it strikes me that those are false positives. there really needs to be a more holistic look at from Cabela's to
[1:03:42] at the very least well really Cabela's to the to the to Route One. [1:03:49] this the straightaway section is dangerous as it is right now for pedestrians, motorists, you name it. But I think just adding one or two little improvements is not going to help and it probably would only defer a better and longer term solution. So I worry about making little tiny improvements to pain road when what it really needs is something holistic.
[1:04:15] Peter, what in your mind would be a better long-term solution there
[1:04:19] on pain road there?
[1:04:21] Yeah. I well I think the idea of introducing some sort of an intersection at Two Rod and and Payne is a good one, but I think what 's really required is something approaching real shouldering for the entire length.
[1:04:42] and again, it's it's because of how narrow that road is. I think there's a reason why so many of the accidents are swerves into a ditch. that aren't necessarily as true in other parts of town. the other thing I'll note too on Pain Road is that it is actually so narrow that it's it has successfully killed the RV traffic that used to that that goes to Old Orchard Beach from there.
[1:05:08] but that's it introduced other problems. So yeah, I what I'd say is I think pay needs to be widened. How it gets widened, I don't know. I'm I'm I'm a citizen on this committee. I'm not a an engineer, but some sort of widening to make it safer to be a to be a pedestrian and make it even safer to be a driver
[1:05:33] avoiding natural road issues is required. And then once you widen it, I think the opportunities for slowing through an intersection at two rod through a wider vocabulary of slowing instruments along the road kind of opens up. Let's take
[1:05:50] put John on the spot for a minute because I just want to go back.
[1:05:54] Well, no, sorry, John. but I do want to address what Peter said was looking at holistic. When I hear you say that, Peter, I'm thinking master plan like we master planned highest. We master planned the other section of pain road talking about master planning kind of what we're calling I call lower pain road. [1:06:15] but at the same time, I will say in my budget conversations with council, there was very much a focus on this kind of detour route, this section, this high crash location of needing to put something in place in the short term. And there is money in our capital improvement budget that we have in place right now for me to be able to spend money towards this fix.
[1:06:42] And that was the direction I got from council. And I didn't know if that I'm reading that wrong or that
[1:06:48] I think that was the precise direction. And again, I appreciate Peter 's perspective, but at the same time,
[1:06:55] the more the larger this gets, the longer it's going to take until it can actually get done. And I feel like there's problems today that need to be fixed. And if adding a couple of speed tables near term like helps to slow things down so that people can maybe walk a little bit safer while it sounds like the shoulder's still not there.
[1:07:15] I think that's better than nothing. And so in my mind I think it goes back to what Stana said like we have to look holistically through the whole transportation study and decide where we make progress over perfection. And to me this feels like an area of progress. So I would personally as a citizen prefer to see something in there to
[1:07:39] make it safer, make people slow down. John, I just hesitate because the speed table conversation has been locating them such that there would be actually not much room to get to navigate those as a pedestrian in order to maximize their effectiveness as a traffic table. now I agree.
[1:08:01] It's one of the reason I asked the questions. What how much is more construction money? if there are CIP dollars to put an inter intersection in, then that would be great. I think that will be much more effective than a set of speed tables. And I don't think the speed tables will do much for pedestrians. I think it will slow down traffic and that will be a positive. but [1:08:23] that road that road is if you're a pedestrian on that road you're already taking your life in your hands.
[1:08:30] Okay.
[1:08:33] For the peanut what are the alternatives for the peanut
[1:08:39] you want to go to the other ones we did look at the show the other
[1:08:43] question. sorry. So on the picture with the speed tables on Cane Road, I'm curious if has there been discussions with public safety because we sat in Jessica and I sat in on conversations with counselors on Saturday
[1:09:05] with several public safety and we were talking about speed tables and they did not sound like a fan. It's very they said because if they're going at a high rate of speed having to get to a fire to a house for ambulance
[1:09:25] police for whatever and they have to slow down for that speed table that could be a matter of life and death. They did not seem like a fan. and I raised the roundabout that we've talked about at Scott Hill Beachridge.
[1:09:46] And if they can recommend a peanut roundabout in this tiny intersection, a roundabout can fit at Beachridge and Scott Hill and Payne,
[1:09:58] right? Sorry, it'll be more needed. And yeah, but I would be seriously concerned with speed tables on a major route like Payne Road for public safety aside from
[1:10:14] could the cushions could the cushions be used there instead or what's
[1:10:18] I'm just going to say that the first drafts, final drafts, all of these drafts, we I we've sat in our traffic safety panel which is the police chief and the fire chief public works director myself. and I believe the planning director was part of these conversations also.
[1:10:38] and so I'm not hearing that I'm hearing the exact opposite from the fire chief. So I don't know, but that doesn't mean there's not others in the public safety.
[1:10:48] It was it was Chief Home and fire chief and Yeah.
[1:10:55] and deputy. I mean, the three of them. I mean, and I'm glad Jessica's here.
[1:11:00] No, that's what they were like. We don't want speed tables everywhere. I mean, but that might be over. I would agree with that. I would agree with
[1:11:10] I would be really concerned about pain road. I could see like on a maple avenue or on the two rod between two rod and Scott Hill. I can understand that. But pain road. Yikes. If if speed limits are so tied to DOT's approval, I'm guessing a speed table on a road like pain would also need.
[1:11:31] It is a state aid road. So yes, DOT would be part of this conversation and I have also mentioned at DOT that this is kind of some of the directions we were heading towards and so they would continue.
[1:11:43] Are there examples of speed tables on comparable roads main road that you can think of? I can I can flip through that
[1:11:51] just to see how it works and practice. and to that I don't you know I don't drive a police car at speed so I'm in no position to comment on that but I will just more generally say that you know we're having these conversations because our whole entire community is feeling like these roads are dangerous
[1:12:11] and that literally applies to everyone. that incl that applies to the town anyone driving town vehicles. It applies to our plow drivers. It applies to our police officers, too. And so, you know, if we have options at our disposal to make these corridors like this safer for everyone, it means when that person has, you know, if one of our officers has to respond to something at speed, it means someone else isn't coming at them or turning out or off of a road at a
[1:12:41] at a high rate of speed. And you know, ideally it means there's fewer crashes for them on those corridors to respond to in the first place. which again doesn't mean they're not using it to respond elsewhere. there certainly always going to be issues like that. But, you know, there are other communities that have these in lots of places and public safety departments that are in support of them or can probably speak to their effectiveness.
[1:13:08] and so I think, you know, I just think it's part of like a larger conversation as well.
[1:13:15] I mean, they're putting one in front of Thornton on Route One is skinning the table. [1:13:21] what's the one in front of Daring High School has a series of things
[1:13:28] street in Portland, you know,
[1:13:31] these are spec from Maine D's guidance for roads of this speed limit and volume. So it's yeah the spacing and the specs are pulled directly from
[1:13:41] and I think like the speed cushion could be a good like
[1:13:44] compromise
[1:13:45] compromise
[1:13:46] and I guess I also hearing like in context when you start talking about we have had the conversation internal of staff of it feels like anybody who required or asks about traffic calming and there's a need for traffic calming it auto automatically goes to a speed table and then we have a speed table and then it's like
[1:14:06] for I want the concern is yes that it doesn't make sense in every situation and it seems like we were kind of getting into this cycle.
[1:14:17] [1:14:18] if you look at coming back to this group with that policy is now we have the tool which we didn't have until August. It was adopted by council. Now we have a toolbox of other options. It's not an automatic fit for speed table. And I appreciate the fact that you pointed that out with Scott Hill Road, too, is that even on a local road, it might not make sense because of the context and becoming kind of unsafe to drive
[1:14:45] situations. Craig,
[1:14:47] sorry, Peter.
[1:14:48] Yeah, I don't want to lose sight of the pedestrians here, though. The details work great on Maple Road because of sidewalks and the pedestrians already have options here. We've already said the pedestrians have what, 8 in of of shoulder to use. [1:15:06] and we're talking about in some areas using guardrails to deter a swerving, which the guardrails would be would consume the 8 in of pedestrian space. You're basically
[1:15:16] consigning paid road paid road to never be used by a biker or a pedestrian. Is that what we're trying to do?
[1:15:21] I think one deter I appreciate I've noted that shoulders are and I've heard it from others here that shoulders on these roads need to be part of the solution. So I think I think we're hearing that loud and clear and that will part of
[1:15:37] and also that even in a even in a short term or temporary demonstration
[1:15:42] situation
[1:15:44] we can cite those like those guardrails don't have to be and shouldn't be right at the white line like there needs to be some space in between and certainly we wouldn't want to install something like that in the name of making it safer for people to drive and therefore increasing like known danger for providing less space for people to walk.
[1:16:05] So I think it's I think I think it's nuanced about how you how those treatments get designed and put in.
[1:16:11] My point is more is if we have CIP bunny and we have actual dollars available, do we have enough to explore the roundabout at two rotted pain and if we do I think that's probably a better solution than looking at the at the speed tables.
[1:16:25] Yeah, the CI we have in place also has to get me through design. So, I'm going to design and then when they have what we 'll determine a budget and see where I'm left with funding and we can have that conversation with council too, which I have a feeling is not enough for a roundabout.
[1:16:41] Yes.
[1:16:41] Yeah.
[1:16:41] And again, I but without that detail I come back to my original statement which is I think the speed tables are not going to give us a real improvement. They're going to blow the money that we've got. Okay, great. but but they're not going to give us real improvement and actually we will create more problems because no matter what we do we're going to take space away from pedestrians.
[1:17:04] I think I heard from you Peter is that shoulders and part of that 's that's not the doing the big roundabout that's something less
[1:17:12] Yeah. I think for me the question is what is the problem we're trying to solve because we're talking about two problems with pedestrians and slowing traffic. And so
[1:17:23] I feel like what you're budgeted for is more just one, not both.
[1:17:28] And so if we have to make a choice, I think slowing traffic is step one. There needs to be a longer term discussion on pedestrian bike ped what we want to do in that corridor. So to your point, may require a master plan down the road. But again, knowing there's so many other things we need to do in the transport townwide transportation study.
[1:17:51] Again, we 've committed to safety as a town with our vision zero being a number one priority. And so even though this isn't going to create safety for pedestrians, which sounds like is
[1:18:02] I mean I would argue it does because slowing vehicles down and that's the first step in making an environment safer. The second step, Peter, is like you're saying
[1:18:12] providing more space for them to
[1:18:14] I would just echo Peter real quick. When I'm on a busy corridor and walking against traffic, I always have a little bit of feeling of safety that if a car is barreling to me, I can just jump off the road. And when you have a guardrail there, the perception, it just feels so much more dangerous to be on a on that high traffic.
[1:18:35] You will have traffic luckily slowing because that because of the traffic bump, but maybe the compromise is just in those localized spaces, we create better pedestrian infrastructure. So where that speed bump is going to occur and if there's a guardrail there just in that small area we invest in getting off road.
[1:18:54] I just want to point out that the guardrails are listed as optional but they're where they're next to ditches like steep ditches. So even if a shoulder goes in like drainage might have to come into play. and so like in the long-term recommendation, we were thinking maybe a sidewalk would be great cuz then you can add in crosswalks, but a shoulder would be a lot less expensive.
[1:19:17] but I think drainage is going to be an issue on both sides of the road.
[1:19:25] Oh, thank you. Just super briefly back to Scott Hill. I know we've moved back to Payne Road. sounds like the stop signs just legally or probably temporary or you may or may not last if the road is reopened. But given that road would not reopen for whatever the last meeting I went to, it's going to be at least a year.
[1:19:45] It sounds like just because of timing with grant knowledge, etc. Is there any? And so we know we have 300,000 in this budget that was specifically dedicated to traffic calming and mitigation. Honestly, I feel like some of that was committed by town council because of advocates who live on [street]. Not necessarily.
[1:20:05] Not saying that the other slide isn't a dangerous area, but it sounds like the what's been said here is, "Oh, it's too complicated. We're just not going to deal with Scott right now." I would just respectfully request, can we at least get a white line painted at each of those or stop signs? I think that's fairly temporary. Maybe some people maybe people are planning oh I never noticed the stop sign
[1:20:27] get a white line and could we even have just like a temporary speed
[1:20:31] advance there's advanced signage stop sign ahead it's a year of people having safety that's a good point again I feel like there was money dedicated it was in large part because of
[1:20:43] advocacy by me and others so if we could just please that in mind as opposed to it's too hard we'll deal with it later thank you
[1:20:50] yeah I would say trying to meet your needs because I feel like it was Denise and you who came.
[1:20:56] Yeah.
[1:20:56] And that's why we asked to put the money in the budget was specifically
[1:21:01] because you were concerned about
[1:21:03] what's going to [clears throat] happen on two rod with Scott Hill being closed and we needed to make some improvements and you sharing about Scott Hill. So I agree it was that whole corridor section.
[1:21:14] Ideally we would find some solution even if it's a tiny solution for Scott. I think that was the
[1:21:19] the ideal
[1:21:20] situation,
[1:21:21] the white the white lines and also just getting rid of that radius.
[1:21:26] Make it Yeah,
[1:21:28] make that right turn.
[1:21:29] It's pretty.
[1:21:30] You know, there's some way to add a little bit of a shoulder as well.
[1:21:33] Yeah.
[1:21:34] What's the road? What's the lane width on Scottville?
[1:21:38] it's right there. They're 11 foot
[1:21:40] travel lanes at least right there.
[1:21:42] Could you go to 10
[1:21:43] six inches on one side and the other? Could you go to 10 foot lanes and have the rest? [1:21:50] yeah. I mean, two rod and pain are 10 closer to 10.
[1:21:54] So, that would also just be a matter of pain.
[1:21:57] Yeah.
[1:21:57] Is this is this the first rendering of this to the public?
[1:22:02] Yeah.
[1:22:03] Okay. [clears throat] I agree with Jonathan that we ought to do just what is needed to alleviate or the concerns of the people on this portion of two rod and start because when you start talking about pain road I don't know how many people here were around whenas
[1:22:26] went in but that section from down to
[1:22:32] flarity,
[1:22:33] you know, flarities. That was a big bone of contention. And once you start messing around with, you know, reconfigure it, if they if they perceive any improvements is going to make it a runway, I mean, it's it just
[1:22:47] people have expressed that at council meeting. So, I think I think right now we should be talking about making it as safe as possible due to the you know the closure of Scotville Road and then maybe if you want to later on explore other ways of improving Hang Road and everything otherwise
[1:23:11] nothing will get done because it'll it'll just get blown out. Just to just to tie us back because I don't know fully understood it. Right now, council has dedicated 300,000 in this city's budget to traffic calming improvements on Scottville and
[1:23:28] it's it's written for general traffic calming, but it was definitely part of the discussion was
[1:23:34] that we could use it other places.
[1:23:36] 300,000.
[1:23:38] It's important to remember that the reason we were looking at Pain Road to begin with was high traffic incidences and we don't even address any I don't know whether any pedestrian problems were identified in any of those incidences but we're looking at pain road the safety
[1:24:00] and here we're looking also safety but also how to address speed and some other things but paint could do a lot of
[1:24:06] yeah it work that was That was the intent honest was when we were making the decision to budget for Scottville Road for the Culver. We said
[1:24:16] because we know that there's issues in that corridor that we wanted money set aside specifically to address Kane and Scott based on the feedback. So while it's there and it's townwide, I think the intent of it is really to help solve this problem. So, could we like put together that action plan of with that 300,000,
[1:24:36] what can we actually do in the very short term?
[1:24:40] Well, that's what these are.
[1:24:42] Well, I mean, I wouldn't include the
[1:24:44] No, that it's listed as like a shortterm long term. So, the short term would be or the speed tables and science.
[1:24:55] Okay.
[1:24:56] So, okay. It also would be our next step would be going through an engineering kind of piece. So if that's what I'm hearing the direction totally makes sense is to doing like really focusing on the shortterm solutions and getting something implemented which we can do through the current budget. I can we do have an engineer that's ready to go that is
[1:25:20] that I've already spoke to about scenes coming. Could we do a demonstration project with the speed tables on Pain Road before doing the full work or
[1:25:34] [1:25:35] I'm just responding to some of the feedback that like
[1:25:37] yeah the money for those rubber speed tables is considerably more than going and the issue with we've been talking about since we first implemented this temporary speed tables was that it's really time consuming for public works to install and take it out, but also
[1:26:00] the pieces that are breaking and so then we're cobbling together two to make one and things like that. So yeah, it's more about town kind of labor costs and things like that. [1:26:13] upkeep
[1:26:14] and so the public works director has mentioned at the very beginning this is not sustainable. So that again is where we go back to the changes that will be coming through for the policy is probably eliminating some of those temporary. There might be some limited situations where we want to do that. This might be one of them like you said something is like a first time like I don't know if this is going to work or not.
[1:26:38] if we knew like ocean ad we all knew that was probably gonna yeah
[1:26:44] could have lied right. I mean down at Higgins Beach. So those type of things that is a little different than say pain road that maybe there is an instance and actually broke the question. I don't want to put you on the spot but I didn't know if there's any like temporary speed cushions or things like that because that is something the fire chief was a little concerned about too and trying something new. So, it's always good for at least the first one to do like a pilot
[1:27:08] and test it out. whether it's a higher speed or higher volume corridor or just navigating it,
[1:27:19] you can certainly do rubber speed cushions. [1:27:22] Okay.
[1:27:23] Yeah. But might be less time inensive.
[1:27:28] Yeah. To install.
[1:27:29] Yeah. You know, the main DOT's guidance for 35 mph road is speed tables because they have more of a plateau on the surface. So, it's actually safer or easier to get over at a higher speed. I don't know if there are other cushion specs that mimic that, like a speed table cushion.
[1:27:52] but that might be something to look into.
[1:27:54] But I think that's why they're typically seen more on a 20 to 25
[1:28:01] The
[1:28:01] thing about the ste speed tables, if you if you miss one and you go over it and you pay attention to where the next one is. [laughter]
[1:28:08] That's why the series is
[1:28:13] on time.
[1:28:14] Yeah, we need to we have some other things we want to cover, but you had a comment. No,
[1:28:20] okay. just real quickly I was going to the ones that we looked at and discussed internally just so full disclosure. I don't know if you want to walk through any of you want me to walk through.
[1:28:35] Yeah, sure. this is a near-term te so because the intersection is offset a little bit. It was kind of like what if we realign the street to actually tee it up with pain road creating closer to that 90° turn which would slow down traffic and you know you end up with two intersections there but it's fewer conflicts to manage at once perhaps but that yeah ultimately I think there are too many too many conflicts in that image
[1:29:05] to be
[1:29:06] offset intersections a safety concern in themselves when you're trying to you're trying to figure out if you get a gap to get out of pain while you're still worrying about the other side of two rod and it just seemed more problematic. points in point
[1:29:23] more where more road point is kind of the same hill and each is an off
[1:29:34] and this was the four-way stop which
[1:29:39] we not considered but I've also had conversations around where we stopped down and we talked about at the bottom of the hill at beachridge at Payne in Scottville bill this similarly DOT is saying it likely will not meet warrants and so we can go through the exercise but I don't think they would be supportive of that and reasoning is their number one concern is safety and so when you start creating
[1:30:09] an always stop that where people are not stopping or people do stop and the people behind them don't realize they're stopping those and you end up with a lot more kind of collisions and things like or issues around that. So those were the other ones we considered. that was
[1:30:30] then it got really crazy. [laughter]
[1:30:34] Yeah.
[1:30:38] Full realignment. just really separating those two streets and trying to think about yeah what shape roundabout works here. and how to make it fit within the right of way. so these didn't get past the brainstorm draft stage, as you can probably tell right away.
[1:31:02] You know, on one of your earlier screens,
[1:31:05] you had some yellow signs with right arrows with arrows going
[1:31:11] over the roundabout. Yeah.
[1:31:12] Yeah. Can you pull that up for a second?
[1:31:15] Success.
[1:31:20] Yeah, those. Now, I think those would be great at intersections like the one I'm familiar with, which is Pleasant Hill Road and Highland Avenue, because that sort of tells everybody when they approach it. You know, if you both to approach the intersection to the same time, the vehicle on the right goes first.
[1:31:40] Oh, do they have a significant
[1:31:43] specifically around like anything? Right. But you're saying kind of an educational on who goes first. Like they've all come to a stop sign.
[1:31:56] That's also a different sign. Yeah. I'm not sure.
[1:32:01] Give us some
[1:32:04] I actually just saw and saved I can share if anybody wants to a little video. I forget who put it out but it was education on how to approach a four-way stop. something right on
[1:32:16] it was educational
[1:32:21] used to do our little educational thing. I can throw that for social media. I don't recall it because I sit there sometimes and sometimes people are like the video actually addresses when people are too nice.
[1:32:37] Yeah.
[1:32:38] Anyway, I'd be happy to share that. I do want to make sure that we have time to take any additional public comment but also get to some of these project updates before we get on much further. before we do that, thank you to those of you who came to help us. with this challenge.
[1:32:57] They can't they can't believe they can't go wrong.
[1:33:01] There's underneath
[1:33:02] I know there's a roundabout in there. We'll cut out.
[1:33:07] do either of you have any other comments that you'd like to share about the two rod roads hilling traffic? really have a I'm I'm I was gone for a lot of years and came back so I'm used to really old roads. I mean I thought pain road was 45 miles an hour until I got stopped one day which is a good thing.
[1:33:28] Anyway, I wondered what the homes road and beach road success was when that became a four-way stop and I don't know when that happened
[1:33:36] but because the four-way stop
[1:33:40] doesn't seem unreasonable. Yeah,
[1:33:43] it's highly successful and it slows people down
[1:33:46] the reflection
[1:33:47] every stop.
[1:33:48] So that was a DOT specific project. and so there were like you said the safety measure on it to stop signs and things like that were upgraded. So
[1:33:57] it's definitely I'm I'm not saying that's not possible for any of these intersections. It would definitely go through DOT review though and design.
[1:34:05] Speak that one did
[1:34:06] speak a little bit about DOT review. From what I understand, a four-way stop is much more likely to be approved if both roadways are similar in volume. So like Beachision homes have very similar volumes. So it kind of made sense in their eyes with here because Pin Road is so much higher traffic than Tur Rod, they'd probably be less likely.
[1:34:31] But
[1:34:32] I understand that.
[1:34:33] Yeah, that's a good point. There's a lot of those intersections in town where people don't understand why it doesn't warrant a traffic signal or a four-way stop. Same type of thing. You need to have kind of the volumes on the side street in order to warrant that.
[1:34:52] Thank you.
[1:34:53] Interesting.
[1:35:01] after the next month.
[1:35:03] You can rejoin.
[1:35:05] Oh, that's my wife.
[1:35:08] We used to have a see how much fun.
[1:35:15] Yeah. So, they're DOT is trying to get away from those. So, we I know we talked around it with Running Hill Road is one of them.
[1:35:24] They upgraded. but I don't know if you have anything around that, Jen.
[1:35:32] The last faster.
[1:35:37] We picked the right one. [laughter] Pick the right guy.
[1:35:41] He'll beat her home.
[1:35:45] [laughter]
[1:35:46] sorry. Flashing red and yellow lights. You were talking. I understand and are they're trying to get away from those and that's why they went to say the big stop sign with the lights around the stop sign and they're doing those rather than like a flashing light
[1:36:02] but is that still the case?
[1:36:05] I'm not sure. I know they're moving away from
[1:36:10] like effectively the treatment's the same like you as a driver it's the same thing. You still have to stop and yield or going. but I don't know. Sometimes I kind of wonder if like we're just we're all so bad at it that now we have to do something different.
[1:36:26] They want in your face like that one too. They're like we want bigger stop signs. So they actually went bigger and lit and advanced lit.
[1:36:35] The other example of that
[1:36:36] it's like really like smacks the base. You have to really stop,
[1:36:40] right? Again, like back to back to driver's ed, if you're taking a left through a green light, you are to yield to oncoming traffic before you turn left. But really, like nobody does that. Nobody's good at it. And now DOT has started implementing this is where you're seeing the flashing yellow.
[1:36:57] Yeah.
[1:36:58] To turn it. It means the same thing. You as a driver, you do the same thing.
[1:37:02] That's true.
[1:37:03] but it's a whole new like approach to it.
[1:37:07] Yeah.
[1:37:08] So, I don't know. I think and maybe I'll just take a second to share my highlevel thoughts about this which I think a lot of this discussion is really good but
[1:37:17] as compared to our lowle discussion
[1:37:19] well no but like to Stonis and John's point I think a little bit earlier about taking into account the ent like the entire town the entire town needs treatment like this because there are there are issues and you know it's a different argument perhaps about like priority and higher crash stats and whatnot, but realistically like
[1:37:45] everybody
[1:37:47] everybody's neighborhood would benefit from this kind of treatment. And I can't help but look at all of these and just hear the common underlying thread which is traffic calming and extensive amounts of work to encourage people to drive slower. That is free. Actually, driving is free. And so, you know, if we really want to talk about lowhanging fruit, I made notes to myself to talk maybe later about
[1:38:15] an educational campaign, I don't know, just something that would apply more broadly, lower cost, and really drive home some of the points that we're trying to make. And we can even use these as an example be like we spent x thousands of dollars in this other neighborhood and we saw you know incremental benefits but also you could just drive slower for
[1:38:37] [1:38:39] my sister lives on Mjoy Hill and this summer they went through a whole effort their slogan was slow the hill down and they had signs they posted all over they did some of the stuff that you know bumps out the side of the crosswalk a little bit. very different
[1:39:00] know locations being much more urban than anywhere here in Chicago. But it was just that motto
[1:39:09] was real successful in getting the neighborhood to be kind of constantly thinking about this is a neighborhood that we want to be slow.
[1:39:18] Yeah. I was I was been telling people lately like when I first joined council six years ago, it felt like the topic was we need cars going faster. There's too much congestion. Go faster, go faster. I feel like it's really shifted to safety,, safety. And so I do feel like now is the time, Jen, to do some sort of campaign because it is very top of mind for people.
[1:39:40] I was even at an eighth grade class talking about stuff and all the kids were saying the same thing like we're talking about they can't ride their bikes, they can't do these things, cars are going too fast and you know I said the exact same thing like the number one thing that you know we could have more police, we could have all this stuff but at the end of the day is driver behavior and it's if people are not paying attention, if they're not following the rules of the road,
[1:40:07] that is like the best thing to happen. So, I love that idea. I know we've talked about it in the past.
[1:40:12] I know. I think even I actually noted like targeting students in particular because like who is not going to slow down because their nine-year-old in the back seat is like, "Mom, you're going too fast."
[1:40:23] Yeah. Okay. so anyway, I think there's some different angles and maybe that's something we could we can talk about later is that there's so many roads that never used to be as well traveled
[1:40:38] as they are now. Like I live on [street] which is Saco Buckton Raceway past my house and I keep cringing because there's a very sharp S turn right there just below my house and I can't tell you the number of people that have gone off into the brook because they
[1:40:59] didn't calculate that. It's one of the It's the like I think the worst
[1:41:04] [1:41:07] pull this up to make sure I'm not speaking out but it's one of the worst
[1:41:11] for a very long time.
[1:41:13] Yes, I'm I have I have a place on West Beach Road as well,
[1:41:19] but [clears throat] my main house is on Ashwamp Road and that never used to be as traveled as it is now. It's the Saku Buckston throughway because Homes Road got too overcrowded and now they're using Ashwamp Road to get to Route One and
[1:41:40] it's gotten crazy.
[1:41:43] It's one of our if not the worst link for high crash location. Most of our high crash locations are nodes, but that's the
[1:41:54] that's one of the worst links.
[1:41:56] Yeah. so yeah anyway something this group could can maybe think about in the future. okay thank you everyone for your on that.
[1:42:07] moving
[1:42:10] yeah thanks good to see you. Thanks so much everyone. thank you
[1:42:14] yeah you did fantastic. I really
[1:42:16] Yay. You all did fantastic love your ideas. All right. When can I expect to see those yellow signs?
[1:42:26] Even I have to create one.
[1:42:29] What?
[1:42:29] You have to create it first.
[1:42:32] I signed you on. [laughter]
[1:42:37] You have a sign guy right here. I can do
[1:42:40] in the whole of two broad roads be considered like this because I work home sitting my desk and right in the window and cars go by and we get a digital speed limit sign right in front of our house and cars go by 50 60 70 miles an hour every day and we do a ton of work PE I've called them and called them we never seen anybody
[1:43:04] Yeah. Is that a sign or you guys put up yourselves? We paid for it.
[1:43:09] We paid for it. We had to pay for it to get, you know, they wouldn't do it.
[1:43:13] We can't I think twice we've had police. We offer to let them sit in one of our driveways and I think twice we've we've had them there and that's all.
[1:43:22] I'll just And they come at like 5 in the morning rather than at 5:00 at night.
[1:43:26] Time was 5 in the morning. Not
[1:43:28] 5:00 at night. I mean, it's it's dangerous just getting out of our driveway.
[1:43:32] Yeah. I'll just say again, taking away the yellow lines and making it the other thing is just repainted. [clears throat]
[1:43:39] Really?
[1:43:40] Yeah.
[1:43:41] We get a ton of people on bicycles and stuff. We even have one guy that has a little trailer behind his bicycle with his child in it.
[1:43:48] I cringe.
[1:43:49] I do too. When they just It's crazy the way
[1:43:52] we have the Scar Bro cross country. uses too broad and when I see them running a path I
[1:44:01] comes over that hill
[1:44:03] like
[1:44:04] these stories are stories we hear everywhere in town and that's why I think it's like
[1:44:08] your idea
[1:44:09] yes I the answer to your question is yes we should be out there tomorrow fixing that problem for you and in your neighborhood I can kind of fix your neighborhood [laughter]
[1:44:21] neighborhood your neighborhood like because yeah it is it I just like to see a police sc a couple days a week or something for an hour.
[1:44:27] I mean, when Chief Molton was here, if it wasn't a problem, I'd call him up and say, "Hey, can you do this for us?" Sure.
[1:44:32] But what was, you know, they don't seem to care anymore.
[1:44:36] I think they're also stretched in years past too. So, keeping that in mind, the budget process, I'll put a plug in for these officers that we are needed here as we keep growing as a community. And
[1:44:48] it's not just our community, it's it's surrounding community.
[1:44:54] is down.
[1:44:55] Yeah. A limited number of West Roads.
[1:44:58] The neighborhoods west of us are grown, you know. I mean, just I was surprised the other day I went out Spring Street. Westbrook and there used to be a trailer park out there. Now there's a whole bunch of apartments or something.
[1:45:13] Yeah.
[1:45:13] And
[1:45:14] they're going to be coming down Spring Street. You know, it's just it's everywhere. Angela, do other communities pay impact fees when they're growing and increasing the impact on our roads? Because like to your point,
[1:45:31] if it's people growing west and south that are creating issues on ash swamp,
[1:45:36] what authority does the town have to start charging an impact fee to development on that side?
[1:45:41] We don't for a development that's a smaller scale. So it's like death by pets. I will say when a project has to go through DOT which is a traffic movement permit which means 100 trips in the peak hour. It's a pretty big development. We do have it written into their traffic movement permit that they have to pay the town of Scarbor.
[1:46:06] So an example of that is Park North in Saco has in their permit that they have to pay the town of Scarbor for the trips they're heading towards Dunston.
[1:46:16] so it's I think those but it really takes a big project with that smaller ones.
[1:46:24] I think Amazon's going to have to pay something to Westport
[1:46:27] because they're going to be calling out 25
[1:46:31] mark through the TM through the state. So the state can enforce it. Absolutely. And say the town, we know has this in place. So we're going to write it into their I don't have the authority to go into because we've had that issue where
[1:46:46] has not added it to someone's and for us to go get we can't possible for me to go into
[1:46:56] that.
[1:47:03] Sure. Yes.
[1:47:07] But we're we're unique in that we have route one, we have the connector,
[1:47:12] we have like
[1:47:13] I feel like we are very much a pass through community
[1:47:18] compared to those other Yeah. And so
[1:47:21] yes,
[1:47:21] I don't know if there's state like is there state law we need to be advocating for that allows for more
[1:47:29] Yeah. It's a toll.
[1:47:31] Yeah. something toll road like get a toll road to be a toll road at one time
[1:47:37] now residents have a free pass
[1:47:41] and charge everybody else using our roads
[1:47:44] every town would end up doing that
[1:47:46] but maybe that's a good choice I don't like that's
[1:47:51] when I can hear them revving up from Saco and I'm trying to sit there and listen it's like are they coming down Ashwamp or coming down Homes Road and I want to get my little steel strips out in the road. [laughter]
[1:48:10] That's recorded.
[1:48:13] I didn't hear anything.
[1:48:14] Yep. That's it.
[1:48:19] Yeah. Do you do you have want to give us updates on
[1:48:23] Metro Connect? I just want to encourage everyone to try it out. It was fantastic. when I have meetings and at public works, I take the shuttle down and back. still working on the police chief and fire chief to do the same, but that I don't know. We're gonna get them. Working on everybody around here. We can get we can get there.
[1:48:44] I did want to point out though that as they mentioned, they're going to it's kind of a little bit flexible and so looking at if there's opportunities to expand and where they can expand. I'm happy to announce that they have expanded the service to Kaylor Veil and Piper Shores, which I think a lot of you know, but also
[1:49:05] today they Metro announced that they were going into Dunston. So that's like Stewart Drive up around where Dun Tap and Table is and going out towards Broad Road. I know Carpenter Court is the Pedapite, but then just over the highway is some apartments on the left.
[1:49:27] They're they're utilizing that as part of the service area now because they have users out there that want to
[1:49:32] they request that or
[1:49:34] Yes. So users have been are able if they're not in the app able to do it, they can call in and like request and so they've been kind to work with everybody and so they've gotten multiple requests out there. So they
[1:49:48] mentioned that the people that are requesting it are more likely to be users. It's a very
[1:49:54] Exactly. Yeah. This wasn't us looking to expand just to expand. Same thing with the Kaylor Bale. Obviously they came here and advocating for it. I think that's where we're seeing is people are like I'm just outside the line. Can you accommodate me? And so then they've tried it a few times and like yeah this would work. And now they've kind of officially changed the service area.
[1:50:15] There's also one there's also one week left to free
[1:50:20] free ride for free election day is free too.
[1:50:23] Yes Tuesday we get a bonus day. You're right. Good point. but yes until then we can ride the bus for free anyway. Doesn't matter. that's a service Metro provides actually free service for everyone in their entire region on election day. So that's great. but yes, if you It makes it very easy and like reduces
[1:50:44] it's one less thing to be stressful or worried about as you get on like you the pay boxes are just covered up and it just says free service through October. So, it's great.
[1:50:54] Yeah, you haven't tried
[1:50:55] it. And it was super easy and great and they were still working on a couple bugs but they're good there as long as they keep the same drivers moving it around.
[1:51:04] Yeah. safety audit mentioned this group asked for the application to throw into tax for Goret Sawyer. We were awarded that which will happen next spring and that again is us reinforcing yet again which I think was good as we had the conversation here. There's again we had a lengthy conversation because there's so much need in town right for those intersections
[1:51:33] but I think I'm going to utilize this to push on dot even more about the corn road corridor and the and the speed limit along there. So we've been trying to give them hopefully this will give us more ammunition towards that. the packs we did receive officially a vote since the last meeting from PAX for $200,000
[1:51:57] and our we're put $200,000 match for sidewalks on Pine Point Road. that would go from the eastern trail past the school and as far as we can go keep trying to rebuild that sidewalk that has been on public works radar for the past few years. That's their one of their number one complaints they get from residents is that sidewalk.
[1:52:22] And there's a lot of kids blocking the school in that neighborhood and along Pine Point through that section
[1:52:29] speed.
[1:52:30] And we've also in part of the conversations the school department has been coming through the planning board with their updates. The next one we just got today. At the next planning board meeting, I believe Blue Point and Pleasant Hill and Acorners will be as an advisory opinion.
[1:52:51] one of the things we've talked about encouraged from councelor Keane has said in public meetings making sure staff is kind of looking at the front door of these schools as far as the sidewalks or talk about pedestrian safety. I think that's one of the things staff has commented on
[1:53:11] in these initial reviews with the schools specifically Bluepoint and Pleasant Hill is looking at those PED crossings right in front of the schools and those are pretty high volume corridors.
[1:53:27] Can we can we make this more than just an advisory
[1:53:31] thing? Because I when the first school went to ballot, it was really there was a lot of work done around traffic improvements and things like that, which is partially why the cost was so high was because we estimated like $20 million or something like that for traffic. And I know once these schools are going and the traffic increases, it's going to be an issue for the town.
[1:53:55] So, I don't know what needs to happen to make it a more formal request. I can talk to Larry. We have chatted a little bit, but I think this needs to be more than just an advisory view. Like it really needs to be a whole chapter in the project that they need to be thinking more about.
[1:54:13] I kind of wonder like I don't know. I guess I can maybe understand how that came to be. Like if the town's expanding the public works garage and it triggers site plan approval by the planning board, like okay, we you know, we need that need that expansion. and what whatever that is. But and we've seen this before like
[1:54:33] the public safety building went as advisory opinion to plane. So
[1:54:36] see like no that is wild to me the items that came to the planning board for adding a portable classroom at Pleasant Hill School that advisory. Okay, that seems that seems fine to me. I think the scale I think it's the scale
[1:54:52] and and it would be one thing if these projects were coming and they were they all tees were crossed and eyes were dotted and everything was really con comprehensively put forward and like here we're addressing traffic and drainage and all of this other stuff. see you planning board, here's what we're doing.
[1:55:13] And then, you know, I don't know. I think an advisory opinion is appropriate when you're kind of like when it's good to go or it's not a huge scope
[1:55:22] any corners in particular. I think
[1:55:24] in either of those, I mean, that's going to be a whole new school, right? Brand new school building. you know, to John's point, we saw this item fail previously in our community for a number of reasons, but one of those big reasons was because of traffic and transportation. And and so you know I've offered
[1:55:45] through the planning board to this applicant the use of this committee to come and
[1:55:53] I have offered this committee that you specific
[1:55:59] I have said
[1:56:00] like you know I can't
[1:56:02] I can't formally join another committee. it probably would have resulted in divorce for me. And so, that took a lot of restraint because I think it's really important for our community. but I just can't do that. And also, we are wellversed here and so I don't need to be beyond doing that.
[1:56:18] And the number of parents driving their kids,
[1:56:20] lots of lots of people. Yeah. So, anyway, all that is just to say, it 's good to know that there's there's more coming. I think we will be re we will be seeing again right the first round of are there are they not for in the middle school?
[1:56:40] I think again counselor Kane I think is helping in that realm. I think the ordinance speaks to you as an advisory. I think that it's a little different when it was a town project say public safety that we know our ordinances and we were the client and saying you have to hit all of these ordinances. [1:56:59] this one feels different to me. I don't know.
[1:57:01] And if it wasn't hitting something like we had a whole conversation about the tower because that is different. And so
[1:57:11] I think that's where we might be missing something. And I will say staff has spent engineering and planning spent a lot of time going through information going through it with their design team and at least trying to document comments but it really needs public
[1:57:32] process and public I don't know is knows it's coming through planning board. I think that I did ask at the last planning board meeting when the school would have an opportunity for the public because seemed like there was not enough information. They came to planning board without enough information for us to even kind of have a full review and I asked well what are the other public opportunities and I think the superintendent did mention there's one in November and
[1:57:58] like November 17. I'm I'm wondering if it merits and it might be something Angela for you to recommend to the new chair and vice chair of the next council like an actual workshop and it could be a joint workshop between the school committee, the transportation committee, the planning board.
[1:58:17] Well, I can I can I can propose it on my way out. But I'm just saying I'm just saying there needs to be like a coming together because again there was so much done with the school and then once it passed it's been I know and I know the committee's been working and doing a lot of things. So, I'm not saying stuff isn't happening, but now we're starting to be where the rubber hits the road, no pun intended, and I think making sure that the community has an opportunity to hear more like what's coming, what's next, I think it
[1:58:47] could foster some of the conversation and be like, what about traffic in that
[1:58:52] as an as an example, and I haven't seen what they're coming forward with, so this is not this is this is just an example, but there was a m 10 something roughly 10 single family homes that went in off of Highland Avenue like near the hour school like kind of right around the bend there.
[1:59:14] And as part of that project we talked about a number of different traffic safety elements related to the introduction of those homes and people that would be coming in and out of the road. And as a result, there is now a crosswalk and an RFB at the end of a road with 10 I'm close or minus single family homes.
[1:59:35] And I've seen people use it. It's wonderful. But we have the front doors of current schools with two two50 300 students
[1:59:46] and their staff going to school every single day without with just the most basic crosswalk. And so when I saw that going on, I saw someone push the button on that other crosswalk for the first time. I then, you know, continued on and passed the crosswalk at the school. And I wait there every single morning with my kids and there are members of the public.
[2:00:10] It's sometimes it's the same vehicles we see every morning. I have even seen staff that work at the school not stop at a crosswalk for kids waiting to cross and flashing lights would again would not like solve that solution. But this type of project that 's needed today in my opinion and I know the bluepoint people the bluepoint community have been begging for that too.
[2:00:32] It's arguably you know a worse situation on Pinepoint Road. those are needed today. And I think may maybe I'm maybe I'm making this up, but I think the town has probably deferred some of this work for a number of years being unsure about whether these would remain locations for school. We're sure about that now.
[2:00:50] Yeah.
[2:00:50] and so if these projects come forward without those type of like really basic improvements that see that feels like that feels like something the planning board should have more than an advisory opinion on. And so what I thought you were going to say was to come to council and suggest a revisit of that process like what constitutes advisory opinion and what doesn't.
[2:01:12] but maybe that's a topic for another day. [2:01:16] that could be a topic for the council if they interested in taking it. but yeah, no I think I think
[2:01:22] that'll settle. Yeah, I do I do think, you know, this is big enough that I think it merits bigger discussion and I do think I'm sure part of the concern that the school probably has is trying to come in within budget and as they start to think of off- streetet improvements that starts to raise things that take away from the actual facility itself.
[2:01:44] And so maybe that needs to be a conversation if that's the real concern because then we need some CIP in there potentially for things that weren't contemplated. But again, I would I assumed and maybe I assumed wrong that in that what we voted for included some level of offsite improvements
[2:02:05] that you know
[2:02:07] related to my understanding is that there is but to your point there is a back and forth and there conversations you've had internally with
[2:02:21] planning board on you know to your point right taking away school but it's something that everybody that thrives by physically to snap kids into the school is going to deal with the traffic around the school
[2:02:32] and it's something we would we would hold anyone else doing a project like that would require that of them so if we are not willing to do that in our own
[2:02:41] so why is the planning board advisory on the school and not
[2:02:45] like having their full authority
[2:02:47] it's a school project so like sewer district
[2:02:51] any town project any school So the answer with the ADPA council adoption of
[2:03:00] I guess blows up too much though because
[2:03:03] the sewer district has come in front of the planning board. I know they're just doing like pump station stuff but typically
[2:03:10] the comments are it's a package town staff. We do our comments regardless of who the applicant is the same. This is the ordinance. This is what we to your point require. planning board has the opportunity to make those comments and in the past we've seen that people just make those adjustments. I think it's a harder a little bit because there's lack of information
[2:03:34] at this point. so it's it's not clear.
[2:03:39] Yeah. Sure.
[2:03:41] Right. So you're saying that like
[2:03:42] so I would I don't want to blow up and say like everything needs to be full review because I think it has worked to be
[2:03:48] right
[2:03:50] and maybe people will disagree with the public safety building but I know I actually stood at the podium in front of planning board for the public safety building and we talked through the ordinance and if we actually ended up increasing landscaping dramatically along the park and things like that would just things that didn't have to happen,
[2:04:08] right? But there were comments from the planning board and we made those modifications. So I think that's typically that's the public process like you're part of the public. We want to take that input and kind of modify the plan accordingly. And I think that's pretty typical.
[2:04:24] But I think to Jen's point, consistency, I mean, if we're going to require it of a of a neighborhood, you're talking about safety of school students. It ought to be ought to be applied equally. Yeah. At the end of the day though, it all comes out of all the residents pockets, right? Whether it comes from the school budget or if it comes from a future CIP
[2:04:50] like for drive, you know what I mean? Like if that wasn't enough money in the school,
[2:04:55] it all comes out of everybody. But
[2:04:57] sure,
[2:04:57] but it's also like it's addressing a topic that this committee has like traffic safety is sort of at the heart of what we're doing here. And we're not even making that up because we continually hear it from the public. So in across quadrant,
[2:05:15] it's going to become a huge issue all of a sudden.
[2:05:18] Why didn't we don't want to have to go there first? Why didn't Yeah.
[2:05:20] Yeah. Why didn't we have this?
[2:05:22] We know we know better.
[2:05:23] Yeah. May maybe I don't recall this promptly, but when the Wentworth and middle school was before the planning board, didn't didn't the superintendent here?
[2:05:33] Oh, you weren't there.
[2:05:34] there.
[2:05:35] All right. Then I can say something and it'll be a fact.
[2:05:42] didn't didn't they say that they were waiting for traffic review?
[2:05:47] They said they were be they were just beginning their traffic move.
[2:05:51] Oh, I thought about the original process.
[2:05:53] I thought you meant when they originally went in Wentworth. I was here when they just came in front of the
[2:05:57] Yeah, just recently. Yes. they didn't have water or traffic
[2:06:01] with our what planning board. So right,
[2:06:04] you know, from my perspective as a planning board member, when we get like an advisory opinion, you know, request, I 'd like I tend to give a lot of deference to whatever committee has done a lot of work
[2:06:20] up to that point because I 'm not sure unless there's something really glaringly missing, I don't feel comfortable at the last minute saying, well, you know, like throwing a monkey wrench into everything when somebody has spent a lot of time doing this and then and these school projects, they're working with a budget.
[2:06:39] Yeah.
[2:06:40] And for instance, Pleasant Hill, they're working with a land issue. This that's a very small piece of land they're trying to [clears throat]
[2:06:48] cater it to, you know.
[2:06:49] But I think like there are options and I don't I don't know because this committee hasn't been engaged in that process. I don't know what options they engaged, but like there are alternatives to, you know, they can use the right of way there for example in ways that I don't believe they're planning on. I think I think
[2:07:10] and again I don't because I don't know I don't want to
[2:07:13] well the blanks we are asking for sidewalks along like Pleasant Hill frontage. We are asking for a rapid flashing beacon for crossing a highland. Those are things that obviously are a little problematic when you're talking about trying to keep costs down. And so what we have said town staff is that we would try to partner and help with things like DOT sometimes does grants.
[2:07:39] They give away RFBS that our public works department can install. like I would be I'm going to be searching because I think it also needs to be kind of the u the other schools who are kind of looking at it that so for town we obviously want to help the burden on all the taxpayers so kind of looking for opportunities that's why I was excited about getting the money for the sidewalk in front of blueoint like instead of having that sidewalk repair all part of the school project it now is a town because I was able to get funding
[2:08:09] through packs and so I think that was key is making sure it's kind of on the plan that these funding is something maybe we can all kind of figure out. We can look for grants. We can look for opportunities through different avenues. And I'm Yes. And I have made that
[2:08:28] and saying we'll keep looking and finding a way to get this done. Yeah.
[2:08:32] Maybe that is a future agenda item for this committee to have like a joint meeting with that committee to at least hear what they're thinking and provide this committee's expertise.
[2:08:42] Yeah. Because at the end of the day, it to your point, Angelo, like it's going to cost somebody something, whether it's something that we can afford with what we went to bond with and we have to do an additional CIP or whatever. Like I would think safety is paramount, especially for the kiddos and making sure that especially the walk people are safe.
[2:09:04] But I just would like to see maybe some collaboration between the two just to kind of have that conversation, hear what they're thinking, hear what this group would suggest, hopefully leave with some ideas that again they can take with them, but also, you know, if they are good ideas that need to be pursued that we can't afford through that project like is it worth
[2:09:25] a separate CIP in the future that we say look we're going to do these improvements because they're worth it and then the council can ultim ely decide if those types of extra things get funded.
[2:09:37] Yep.
[2:09:40] I know during planning board Jen, you specifically had comments about sidewalk connections, things like that. It's all those little things that are just making sure they're kind of on a plan I think is important.
[2:09:53] No, the thing that's interesting about Pleasant Hill
[2:09:56] is that I in recent years I was picking up occasionally would pick up my grandson there. And I thought they had their system pretty well laid out, you know, with the getting the kids out there with the teacher and everything and all that stuff. The big problem was lack of space. They had cars queuing up on Alan Avenue and then,
[2:10:16] you know, swinging through the park, the limited parking lot. It was just a [clears throat] lack of space. Yeah.
[2:10:21] But then but everything seemed to work fairly smoothly from my perspective. Now, crossing the street, that's another issue. Okay.
[2:10:29] So, but there's no sidewalks anywhere around there. Yeah,
[2:10:33] they're prohibited in that neighborhood.
[2:10:42] All right. the last update just wanted to make you guys aware that there is a an effort around putting together a 10 and a potential like the 20-year lookout for a CIP which I know finance director's been working on for quite some time. [clears throat] I've been I feel like I engineering is in the middle between planning and public works and so I've been kind of going back and forth in clining off both of them but
[2:11:12] I think what we've determined the need is really [2:11:21] culvert assessments. I just kind of want to bring that up because of kind of what happened with Scottville and I will say Scottville Road Culver is on the list of vulnerable roads. We went through that with the vulnerability assessment which is coastal and talking about coastal building and just that's really just the size.
[2:11:43] kind of want to put a plug in with this group is that I can see engineering putting in a CIP request for next year is to look at our inland culverts and the assessing those as far as condition.
[2:11:59] We I feel like we have a lot of ticking time bombs kind of out there and we don't know which one's going to go off next,
[2:12:05] right? And trying to prioritize those is based on the conditions of those culverts. I think we have a lot of undersized culverts. That's one piece. But there's also some that probably are ready to fail. and starting to have get a better handle on that I think is going to be important to start prioritizing start and we did it with public works is looking at picking off say one large culvert crossing a year or every two years design one year replacement the next and we move on and kind of
[2:12:35] can spread that out a little bit rather than kind of everything failing at once. Vermont DOT has a fabulous statewide GIS map interactive that evaluates all of their bridges and culverts for vulner vulnerability. It's
[2:12:55] really cool if you're into that kind of thing. [laughter]
[2:12:57] but it's very easy to
[2:13:01] prioritize. You can go you could be like tell me the top five most critical water crossings we have in the whole state and or like which ones you know would cut off like x number of people but things like that. so I think that that type of information would be really already in the past years we did our closed storm drain infrastructure we did you know and so it's like risk of failure
[2:13:28] or you know implicate implications of what happens if this one fails opposed to that one. So there's all kinds of other factors that go into that. and so you can do that kind of risk assessment that way with your culverts, which is really, I think, lacking. We need a little more with that. And I think the vulnerability assessment really helped with kind of the coastal ones.
[2:13:51] And we have our list of, [2:13:55] well, hundred vulnerable. [laughter]
[2:13:58] The vulnerables. Yeah.
[2:14:00] Right. I think we still need to do a little bit more work on that and assessments on that those but we're making progress at least and so I'd like to look at I think interior I think those are kind of a missing link right now.
[2:14:17] Sure. And you know you had mentioned in the agenda too like and a look ahead at transportation projects but sometimes those things can be helpful to like to tackle in conjunction with each other. So if you have
[2:14:36] the number three badvert but it's top on some other transportation project list. Well, like the next phase of forum room is really the nonsuch process and
[2:14:46] like that's yeah 100 year old kind of start talking about these structures that are getting up there in age. So we start doing assessment with dot and trying to figure that out. So that's
[2:15:00] also the next one.
[2:15:05] Okay. [2:15:08] any other public comment? I do. So, [2:15:14] this bug's over the bug's over there.
[2:15:18] It was great heard that the that the traffic calming plan was adopted in August and that's great because when I'm knocking on doors for town council, I'm hearing about traffic safety at nearly every single one of them. What is the process for a resident to initiate a review or for traffic coming for a specific road or a neighborhood?
[2:15:39] like what would someone do other than tell a stranger who comes to their door?
[2:15:45] So, we do have a traffic coming request policy that went through this committee. it is an application online through the police department's website on our town website there is a link through PD that has traffic calming and you can do it all online.
[2:16:05] You can click on that. It has an application form where it kind of asks, you know, to get gather some information. Also have a point of contact for the neighborhood. They also need part of that has on there is to get signatures from 10 of your neighbors so that just because we get so many is making sure there's like a concerted effort like your neighborhood is or getting organized,
[2:16:31] you have one point of contact, you're kind of all working as a team. and that all goes through the police department. Police then look at collecting data around that and that needs speeds and there is in our traffic coming request policy. There's some criteria around that. for instance,
[2:16:52] if you have a short dead end street that has six homes, it's not going to qualify for kind of additional measures. there's certain things around it. There's also maybe around average daily traffic if something only gets 10 trips a day. That's not one that we're going to prioritize probably through that process.
[2:17:13] those type of things. So there's some parameters around that coming out of what you said with the U council adopted the guidance manual. There is on the very end of that is recommendations for update to the policy which is where
[2:17:35] internally police, fire, public works, engineering are all working internally to come up with some recommendations or red line of that policy based on the recommendations from our consultants that would help us prioritize with our limited funding.
[2:17:55] as you said, every single road in town has some need or want or desire for traffic calming. And how do you kind of prioritize those? And I think that's where we're getting to now. It's that we have so many that we really need to say start I want I don't want to say ranking, but I also want to look at
[2:18:17] it's more about do you have a lot of pedestrians? Do you have a lot of traffic? Do you have need these needs like getting into the nitty-gritty where we're talking about a six inch shoulder things like that we can start looking at the more details of it and actually give it a score. It doesn't mean that it doesn't get funded or addressed.
[2:18:39] It means your score puts you here and someone else's road might be a little higher. but I think trying to do it in a way that is consistent and uniform and it actually addresses the more serious areas in town. I think that's where I think we fall short a little bit sometimes is that
[2:19:03] when we spend money on certain areas of town where we have others that have like very high crashes, right? But we're looking at these other and it's more about prioritizing that. And again, I'm not to say that this is the set order we're doing it in. To Jen's point, if I have a DOT project coming along and this is 10th on the list, we're we're fixing it.
[2:19:26] Like we look for opportunities with that.
[2:19:29] It doesn't matter if it's a town road versus a state road or
[2:19:33] our process doesn't matter. The start of it, the implementation matters. So once pain road for instance whatever we come up with through that process I will be working with region one and do because it is a state aid road and they can say this does work this does work and gives us their review and their recommendations too and the other thing is when the application comes in
[2:20:01] and certainly we heard this about too rod when residents bring up and tell the stories we become aware of things that we may not have ever been aware of. So it is important to hear from people what's going on in their neighborhoods
[2:20:16] and I guess part of that was the 10. So, I live on [street]. I know Denise lives on to Iran. You know, they're big long roads. How geographically where do you need your 10 people? [laughter]
[2:20:29] Doesn't specify.
[2:20:30] Okay.
[2:20:30] I don't think so. it's just yeah just knowing that I think we were before the policy we were getting a person in every street and we tried to address or try to at least look at it and kind of put something behind it as far as data or look at things. It just gives it a little more emphasis on this neighborhood is really concerned rather than
[2:20:57] one or two places if that makes sense. and we also used it as models from other municipalities that were showing that it was working. So we kind of this wasn't something we made up on the fly. It was definitely other municipalities that have shown you know this system works. And I think that's also why the scoring mechanism is the next step is just kind of making it more robust
[2:21:22] to get to an end product is kind of lessons learned from other municipalities how they attack it.
[2:21:30] And will that scoring mate effects be this committee or will that be the internal staff committee I forget the name?
[2:21:38] Yeah. internal staff will come to this committee with a recommendation. based on I would say our experience as far as police and police fire engineering, we were talking about also bringing in on some of the implementation our traffic peer reviewer our traffic engineers as part of that conversation as well.
[2:22:05] but the recommendation would come to this and board committee and then if it was successful through here it would go to council to adopt an update to the policy.
[2:22:20] That's for next month.
[2:22:22] Next month DOT is coming to talk about Portland West again. Our questions we're going to go through.
[2:22:29] So it's a 20 27. So, I mean, we're looking at it as December January hopefully. it's just kind of prioritizing. We won't be implementing any I know the issue is trying to get ahead of kind of the next implementation of traffic coming, but realistically that won't happen until the spring because for the winter months, public works shouldn't be adding any kind of fiscal structures to the rightway.
[2:22:56] So, we do have time to kind of get it right. A recommendation this board.
[2:23:02] Well, I think that's very helpful. You know, like telling a counselor or, you know, calling. It's not the process. The process is the application and getting your neighbors. And John's good about getting that word out, right?
[2:23:15] Every time I knock on a door, I tell them where to go.
[2:23:21] I do. I tell them on the website.
[2:23:23] People don't have a path. Yes. I think that was the complaint we had. It was there was no path. It was like you said it was people would call and who did they call the right person and that's when we started actually meeting internally because the police chief would get a call and the public works director to call and fire and engineering and even planning and we were all just like working so we weren't working in our own bubbles.
[2:23:46] It was okay let's bring them together and kind of have the conversation around them and then council prompted kind of like we need to formalize the process which really has made it a lot easier. It's it's good to have consistency and kind of structure around that. definitely.
[2:24:02] Well, I can see that also as part of the education campaign. Yeah. Like
[2:24:07] we've we've talked at some of these like everybody just go the speed limit annoy everyone else. [laughter]
[2:24:12] It'll slow everyone down. But then also like okay if it continues to be a problem here are some of the things that you can do.
[2:24:18] So an FAQ one.
[2:24:20] Yes. Yes. [laughter]
[2:24:23] It is kind of funny. Something came up today in conversations with residents that I feel like we kind of get a little bit of balance. I know we talk about balance, but I feel like there's some roads that people in their head associated with I need to get from point A to point B and it doesn't matter the speed. Like it's more about like
[2:24:43] survey I think unfortunately said getting around town. And so this past time this committee obviously put in things more about asking a question about safety. I feel like it matters what road almost. It's like someone is saying, "I want it safe in front of my house on my local street, but I can go 60 miles an hour broad turn or something." You know what I mean?
[2:25:03] So, I feel like there's But I have to keep reminding everyone that people live there, too. Like we're talking about lower pain road, that's a neighborhood, but it's really to a lot of people it's a cut through. It's a point A to point B. How fast can I go between those two? And it's kind of changing that narrative a little bit that
[2:25:24] Yeah. It's every road could use it.
[2:25:27] Even broad term, people are like, I'm afraid to turn in and out of my driveway.
[2:25:30] Yeah. Yeah.
[2:25:31] Like you are really impacting your neighbors trying to save those
[2:25:38] 30 seconds you lose at a stoplight anyway.
[2:25:41] Yeah. Yeah, it's true.
[2:25:46] Okay. thank you everyone for your extra time. sorry that this went longer, but I think being able to have the conversation around the traffic calming proposals for two rounds and Scott Hill were helpful and I hope that was helpful for you, Angela. And
[2:26:06] to
[2:26:10] go I could say a couple things since this will be my last. Yeah. so
[2:26:15] for five out of the six years I sat on this committee, the only year I didn't was when I was chair. And so I'm I'm going to miss you guys. I appreciate
[2:26:25] you
[2:26:25] everything you guys do. I appreciate the dialogue, the discussion. Just reflecting back on the past six years, we did accomplish so much, I think, in terms of the traffic calming policy that was mentioned. [2:26:39] vision zero.
[2:26:40] Vision zero safe streets.
[2:26:42] Yeah. And so again,
[2:26:44] town assessment,
[2:26:45] the town assessment was big
[2:26:47] and we went from meeting every two or three months to maybe monthly.
[2:26:50] Yeah.
[2:26:51] Things got busy. And again, I still feel like when you think of the town and you think of the purpose of local government, in my opinion, it's really public safety, schools, and infrastructure. And I while I feel like we've done a lot, I still feel like the infrastructure one is the one where we kind of fall behind. And so my only ask as you guys go forward is continue to advocate for projects and things for budget
[2:27:18] for staff for Angela. Like I know Angela and Autumn in particular work harder than probably any municipal employee in the state with the small resources that they have. And like if we really want to address the traffic, the safety like that costs money. And so that means also balancing where we spend, but also
[2:27:40] thinking about affordability for our residents. It's very tough. But I do feel like this is the one area where check the box on schools. We're building new schools. Public safety is good. We fully funded
[2:27:52] and transportation.
[2:27:53] Yeah. And we have some transportation now. So, we're we're on the move, but I feel like infrastructure and traffic safety and making sure our roads stay with the growth that's happening, not just within town, but around us, I think is critical. And so, in my mind, this committee really is the most important committee that needs to
[2:28:14] have a bigger voice and a bigger seat at the council table. And I hope that you guys get a really strong advocate from a counselor to make sure that you have the right person who can push these things because again I think these are I think this is the moment over the next 10 years for this area. And so I just really hope Angela's funded the way she needs to be funded.
[2:28:35] It really comes down to dollars. So just encourage you guys through the budget process if you're around to continue to advocate really hard for these things. But it's been a pleasure. You guys are great. Well, thanks.
[2:28:46] You're the best committee. Sorry, Jessica. I know you're on a lot of committees, but they're clearly the best committee.
[2:28:52] Yeah.
[2:28:52] Thanks, John. Thanks for your continued advocacy. And I know there's other on others on the council, too, that have been helpful to that end.
[2:29:02] Well, that's yeah,
[2:29:04] thank you.
[2:29:05] Or I heard someone suggest earlier that you could actually just join the join.
[2:29:09] I heard you say the divorce earlier, too. for my mind.
[2:29:18] Ask her if she wants to sit traffic.
[2:29:21] Maybe [laughter] that's a great idea. I can do that.
[2:29:25] Who wouldn't be the first husband and wife?
[2:29:28] I was on our committee. Yeah,
[2:29:33] thank you everybody.
[2:29:35] We get a second. Where did you say that?