York Select Board Reviews Capital Requests for Fire Department Equipment and Facilities
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] budget. Johnson select board.
[0:02] And in the audience we have members of York Village Fire Department and we've got our emergency management director and they'll be coming up later on in the meeting. So, okay, so for York Beach Fire Department lead off with Chief Welch here. I've got copies of his items. I'll hand them around. So, there's two capital items to discuss for the next 2 years
[0:26] and here we go. Jeff, I've handed out generator first. Do you want to lead with that the discussion on that? and you know, Nicole's got well, we might call on Nicole, I think or we'll just speak for her and she can yell if we're getting it wrong, so.
[0:42] okay, thank you. Again, Jeff Welch, fire chief in York Beach. [clears throat] the item I'm discussing is the generator that powers the facility of the York Beach fire station when we experience power outages. Our current generator
[0:57] [clears throat]
[0:57] is 20 years old. we have an annual maintenance plan on it and the company that does the annual maintenance on it has been keeping up with it fairly well, but it's in not great condition due to the salt air and conditions that it lives in out in back of the fire station.
[1:20] it's an essential piece of equipment because it powers all of our radio communications, obviously all the lights, the electricity, refrigerators in the building, living quarters, and it also powers the room that we use at times as an emergency shelter during belts of extreme heat, cold, or storms. [1:42] there are some possibilities. Nicole reached out and said that she may be able to get some grant funding for this, but it wouldn't be until the fall. so there is a possibility that if it makes it through the capital process that we still could get a grant to pay for it sometime in the in the fall time frame.
[2:05] but other than that, it's pretty cut and dry. In addition, you know, to the generator itself needing to be replaced, they're recommending some electrical component upgrades inside the building to meet current codes. Some stuff has changed in the last 20 years on the way that they're set up and so forth, so some upgrades to meet current codes as well as make it [2:29] more user-friendly and more efficient for the building.
[2:35] Does the project cost then include those proposed electrical upgrades?
[2:39] Correct, yes.
[2:41] What's the breakdown?
[2:43] so, I think the generator portion itself was around the $45 to $50,000 mark, depending on what exact model they used. and then the rest was making the upgrades to the electrical components. And some of that is the generator that's there is a little bit on the smaller side for the building.
[3:03] So, in order to accommodate the bigger generator, it needs a different panel and so forth. Welcome.
[3:09] How do you measure use of a generator? Is it by hours? Is it by years?
[3:13] generally, they're measured by hours once you get into a certain size class. There's not an hour meter on the particular one we have. the generator runs every week on a test run, and then it can run from anywhere to zero to a couple hundred hours a year, depending on the you know, the outages.
[3:31] So, will this next version have a the ability to actually look at the number of hours that it's been in use?
[3:38] I don't know if this particular model that they have spec'd has an hour meter, but I believe if it doesn't, it could be added.
[3:45] Okay, thanks.
[3:47] There's kind of two components with generators, so hours is the one if you're in heavy duty. If it's new and you get 20,000 hours on it, you might need to replace it the next year even if it's, you know, good. But age also, some of the components, so housing and fuel assembly and all of stuff play into the
[4:03] Right.
[4:04] Yeah. So, the biggest issue we're facing with ours is like not only is the housing around it rusting away as you would expect it to in that conditions, but like a lot of the motor mounts and so forth is starting to rust and give away on it. So, a lot of the internal components are getting pretty tender on it.
[4:21] And does make sense for a rehab versus a replacement? Just I mean, all Everything's fixable, but at some point you start paying more to fix something than it's worth. Have you guys looked at that in terms of
[4:32] Correct. So, yeah, what their thought was on it was the components the motor itself on the generator is so tender that it's kind of putting good money after bad to continue to put money into it. What kind of got us, you know, focused on it was we had some issues with it the last couple of years as far as it not starting on its weekly test runs and so forth.
[4:53] So, we started to put the needed improvements into it to get us by for a couple of more years.
[5:00] Nicole, do you want to go out on a limb here and talk about the likelihood of the of grant funding for it and whether we should be pushing this off to future year like Yep, just press it. There you go. You're live.
[5:14] yeah, so since we use this as our emergency shelter, it qualifies for a lot of various different grants. they're up through FEMA. It's not the same as the ones we use for a storm. so, those generally open up in May. You do your application usually within about 3 weeks is roughly how often they're open for, and then they usually
[5:36] submit the awards and tell who's been awarded in September for fund release in October for the start of the federal fiscal year. So, grants are or generators are actually one of the easier ones on these. They're pretty cut and dry in terms of what you have for expenses and everything. and it's an easy one to always tie to
[5:59] one of the categories of what qualifies for the grants because it is our emergency shelter. so they're obviously competitive grants always because they're nationwide and it can vary depending on who's applying, how many people are applying, but generators are generally one of the more favored options.
[6:19] So likely to be funded in full or yea or nay? Okay. So that I mean we probably want to think through which year. I know you've talked about it, but you discussed 28.
[6:32] Yeah.
[6:33] it should probably should focus on replacement in FY28, but do we want to budget it and there's kind of two options and we don't have to decide this tonight, but do we want to budget it fully in 28 and then not spend the money if Nicole's able to procure a grant to replace it. Do we want to wait until 29? Plan out wait until 29 assuming we'll get a grant
[6:53] and then if we don't put it in 29 meaning it's a year older or just go ahead with it. So I think those are those are kind of your that's your thought process too, right?
[7:02] Right, correct.
[7:05] Thanks Nicole. Go ahead Wayne.
[7:07] is it a is this a propane?
[7:10] Propane fed?
[7:11] Propane?
[7:11] Yep.
[7:11] And are is the location sufficient right now or would you want to move it to a better
[7:18] no, I believe it would stay in the same location that it's at based off the wiring and panel locations and everything.
[7:24] And as a emergency felt shelter does a generator enough power to heat and cool the parts of the building that would be used for shelter?
[7:34] Yeah, so it does generate enough power to run the heat cooling system and all the lighting and refrigeration for the shelter.
[7:39] Okay.
[7:42] Does it ever make sense to house generators for any sort of whether that's a shed roof or anything like that just to know I mean I realize that the salt air you can't keep out and that it needs to breathe. But is there are there other ways to mitigate the
[8:02] snow load, you know, rain, all that kind of stuff?
[8:05] So currently our generator is located right behind the fire station between what we call our back garage and our ladder bay. And there's an inset in the building for the living quarters where the building steps in. It's set in that area and it's protected by a vinyl fence.
[8:20] Oh, great.
[8:21] for aesthetics and also to keep, you know, the snow and wind and rain and everything from blowing into it. It needs to be open on the top to breathe.
[8:30] Right.
[8:30] And it also has setbacks on the building and so forth in case of an accidental fire. but it's in a pretty well-protected area other than you just can't really cover the top of it.
[8:39] Yeah, got it. Thanks.
[8:41] And is it high enough so that the worst floods you've had don't bother it?
[8:46] It is, yeah. It's up on a on a large concrete pedestal. It's up in the air.
[8:52] Lifetime getting way ahead of the 5-year capital planning schedule though, but lifetime on this generator may significantly outlive the building if they're, you know, I'm talking 20 years in the future. How long is the current one live for? I know you just said 20
[9:08] 20 years, so
[9:09] Yeah.
[9:09] I would I would anticipate 20 to 25 years.
[9:12] [9:13] The only thing that would that would alter that is if it had an extended amount of run time for some reason, which it shouldn't, so.
[9:20] So, in any, like I said, few far beyond the current 5-year planning schedule, but any relocation of the beach fire,
[9:28] Right.
[9:29] this is mobile. It's essentially movable equipment, but you'd have to reinstall it, so there would be, you know, half of the cost would be sunk back into the building if you moved it, I'm assuming.
[9:37] Right.
[9:41] a thought for the committee or the town, usually there's vehicles and other large equipment on your capital plan. This isn't. If you do put this off, then it may come up along with other bigger needs and be
[10:01] a more of a change in the budget. And this way, you know you have to get it get it now so that you don't it doesn't have to combine with another very large purchase that comes up in the future.
[10:17] I do like option one that you outlined about bringing this forward and if we get grant funding then
[10:26] We don't fund it.
[10:27] We don't fund it. Yeah, exactly.
[10:29] It's been an interesting candidate for like fund balance use or something like that. So
[10:35] It's a yeah, separate discussion but
[10:37] Yeah.
[10:39] Probably wouldn't want to authorize it for bond use. That would if we think there's a good chance of not spending the money. So
[10:47] Okay.
[10:49] Good on this item?
[10:52] Yeah.
[10:52] Okay. The next item I'll lead off on side-by-side here just for 30 seconds. So there was a question there's still somewhat of an open question about funding opportunities for this that Jeff and I are working on. Jeff's present I asked him to present this as
[11:14] as a vehicle understanding there's an open question about funding and potential for this year. So do you want to talk about the request itself and then when we get to the alternate funding we can have a little discussion about
[11:28] so this request is for a 6 by 6 ATV utility type vehicle. I believe there's a Sure. Cuz I don't know do you have the picture to yours?
[11:40] should be in the packet.
[11:41] [clears throat] So it's kind of a two-part piece is the vehicle and then the unit that you see that sits in the back of it. what that unit consists of is a platform to be able to lay a patient on a backboard or in a Stokes basket on that platform and move them from areas such as the beach or remote wooded locations out to where the ambulance is waiting for those patients.
[12:05] it also would double as a fire suppression unit because it would carry a small amount of water and foam to be able to deal with any type of wildland fires that we had in town. the biggest need and reason for putting this in the plan is we're seeing an increased amount of calls
[12:27] on our beaches and in the wooded areas of Mount Agamenticus, for instance, and what we're finding is it's taking a lot of personnel to properly get these patients out of the woods. We're having to put them in Stokes baskets and carry them or off the beach, put them in a Stokes basket at low tide if you have you know, a certain demographic of patient, it could require a lot of manpower to move those patients off the beach.
[12:55] we've had some slip and fall twisted ankle injuries by the personnel in the woods trying to move these patients. We've had some of the volunteer call firefighters bringing their units from home to use at these calls to help us get people out of the woods. so, you know, it's been on our minds
[13:16] for several years. It's been discussed, you know, where the need falls for that. And at first, it was a call every couple of years that we were finding we were needing all this extensive manpower and these other resources, and now it's becoming a more regular thing. We could be in the woods, you know, there's some years we're up at the Mount Agamenticus doing these rescues three, four, five, six times a year.
[13:38] And again, you know, the calls on the beach are getting more numerous as time goes on. heatstroke, people not feeling well, people with a broken ankle or leg or arm playing on the beach. so
[13:57] these vehicles like I said, the you could buy the multi the multi-use skid units for the back. The vehicle itself is around $50,000. it's an all-season, all-year-round vehicle. And the unit that goes in the back of it, depending on exactly how you outfit it is another 20 to 25,000.
[14:20] So we talked the other day about this committee or remember most of this committee saw a request from Parks and Rec. and I know you brought this up is if that was something they were asking for this year. So probably haven't had a follow-up discussion with Pete on that since yesterday afternoon.
[14:40] Yeah, this afternoon but
[14:40] Awesome. So there is a conversation about do you want to give your initial thoughts that you told me about
[14:46] I Yeah, to be fair I haven't talked to this about this with Peter yet and I don't know what his plan or vision is for his vehicle but there's a possibility depending on exactly what he wanted to do with his that we could do it as a joint effort but again it largely depends on what his what his thoughts and vision are doing with it daily.
[15:08] My thoughts are in the summertime if it was being utilized by the ocean rescue team getting from point A to point B and moving the management staff of the ocean rescue team around then it would already be at the incident on the beach when we respond down there which is a win-win cuz it saves us a person from having to take it.
[15:29] The only time we would have to take that vehicle back from them is on the off chance that we have some sort of large wild land incident or somebody in the woods that's needing use of that vehicle in the months of July and August. but if we kept it at beach fire is that there at night they came and got it in the morning used it for their for their routine and brought it back in the evening.
[15:50] so it was there for the overnight. something like that would work but again I just have to talk with him about it to see if
[15:56] So I know what he mentioned to us was that there would be obviously an on beach rescue on Long Sands or even Short Sands maybe if there was a short haul that you had to get somebody off of that's probably less of an issue with the distance. but that also would be utilized by the lifeguard got in currently you know to move back and forth
[16:17] through the day. So you heard I don't know if you heard that, but from just from beach to beach not necessarily like, you know, within the low speed zone. so there might be an option there where like she could pick it up in the morning, utilize it, drop it off kind of a thing where the maybe even leave her report location could be your parking lot or something like that.
[16:39] So she doesn't have to worry about where she's putting her car. Again, I'm dreaming all this up. Pete would need to talk with the
[16:44] That would be a win-win if that worked out cuz again the resource would be at the call when we got there.
[16:51] So that So the other thing is that they were kind of envisioning a wider, the smallest possible side-by-side they could get that would put a litter on the back of it for beach use. Looks like this is slightly bigger, so you might want to talk that through with them. I don't know if a bigger one would be usable for them. it would just be like a litter, like a litter holder for
[17:11] Yeah.
[17:12] So you could clamp a litter in. So it's basically to move people.
[17:15] So the reason that we have spec'd the 6x6 version versus 4x4 is departments throughout New England that we've gotten feedback from that have these other beach communities and communities that use them largely in the woods find that when they buy the 4x4 and they put the unit in the back of it that they lose a lot of their steering ability in the sand and in and in the wooded areas on leaves and pine needles and dirt because the 4x4 doesn't keep it propped as well to keep some weight on the front tires.
[17:46] so the 6x6 is again
[17:48] So you'd have a loaded vehicle with a patient that would careen out of control as you're driving it.
[17:52] Right. Yeah, you know, they were finding they had problems. They couldn't steer them, so [17:57] Maybe more of an issue in the woods than in the beach, but yeah.
[18:00] So if you were using it just to carry bags of hose and had no unit in the back or no patients, if you were just using it to move some light material, 4x4 would be sufficient. [18:10] Okay. So I'd ask you guys to get together. It sounds like you're already planning to do that and see if there is an opportunity to combine it. The other question is grant funding, so we've talked I know you and I have talked about it. I've talked with select board leadership, not the not the bulk. I don't think it's been a bulk an open select board discussion at this point, but about the 40,000 remaining from the ambulance grant.
[18:31] Right.
[18:32] But you got me the information from the state, so thank you. I know that the Marlow was party to that, but Todd the select board chair and I were talking about that that discussion. So, we'll look at that. My thought process, just to throw it out here, and you can react to it, everybody can hear it, is that So, we looked at the grant opportunity. We were initially told that the grant is not applicable to the ambulance study that's being done.
[18:55] I'd like to clarify like two It looks like there might be two components. We did a little bit of research on the on the grant itself, the funding opportunity might be applicable to part of that, so I'd probably have one further follow-up conversation with Manny EMS on that.
[19:11] Right.
[19:11] If that's not the case, then I think that there's a good case that could be used for this equipment. So, and to be clear, the it wouldn't fund the full ambulance study, but it could fund a portion of potentially fund a portion of the ambulance study, but I would be We'll have a conversation with select board after that. If that's not If it's not applicable at all, and that's the Manny EMS's answer, then I think there's a good case to apply
[19:33] Right.
[19:34] that grant to this, but we'd have to discuss it with the select board. So, that may reduce this or even remove it from the capital program. So, that's an ongoing discussion.
[19:44] Right. That would cover roughly 50 of the 75,000 needed.
[19:48] Yep.
[19:48] If that if the grant funding were to be used for that, the York Beach Non-Profit Fire Corporation would likely be willing to pick up the remaining 25,000 to buy the unit to go into the back of it.
[20:04] Okay. So, further discussion, I'll update maybe at the end of this process where we're at to the to the group. It's an open question, so.
[20:11] Okay.
[20:12] How do you move this?
[20:13] you drive it down the road. Yeah, they go six They go about 50 to 60 miles an hour.
[20:18] So, to get to Mount A, you would actually drive it on the road. Okay. So, you don't need to require a trailer.
[20:22] Doesn't require
[20:22] no. If it needed to go out of town somewhere, we could put it on a trailer and take it, but [20:28] Is it a This isn't a low-speed vehicle then? This would be street legal? Or would it just be because it's got lights on it, nobody would harass you?
[20:35] so, I don't know if they actually consider them I don't think they consider them low speeds, but I believe the I think there's a municipality exemption for them, so not anybody can register one and put it on the street.
[20:46] Yeah, I'm just thinking like captain the lifeguard captain is at Harbor.
[20:51] Right.
[20:52] Something major happens. Is she going to drive it back to York Beach or does somebody come and pick her up or like
[20:58] She we would want her to bring that.
[20:59] Got it.
[21:01] Yeah, I think it's I don't know what she's doing for transportation currently. I don't know if she's using her car or what.
[21:06] POV, yeah. Or Parks and Rec vehicle, yeah.
[21:09] You know, we would train her so that she could, you know, say she was at Harbor Beach with it. we could train her so that she could respond in an emergency response with it. And yeah, it would be outfitted like a regular vehicle with a light, a siren, and a radio.
[21:24] Got it.
[21:25] And if that was to be used for lifeguard stuff, it could also be I mean, that would be important cuz she could utilize it as an emergency response vehicle for herself if she needed to get to or other lifeguards needed to support other another location. Might open a different opportunity than a yellow light with beach patrol on it.
[21:42] Right.
[21:43] Like I said, for the summer months, July and August, that would be the ideal situation to have lifeguard staff in that daily.
[21:50] I asked it I followed up on Heather's question because with that because I think Parks and Rec talked about that being a low-speed vehicle when it's registered for just Parks and Rec use if it's not an emergency vehicle. It would be And the one that they were looking at was only a 30 35 mph.
[22:06] I might have said 40 mph max. 40 mph max.
[22:10] Yeah, I'd have to look at the limitations. It may very well be able to be registered as one. I'm not sure. I know like the small Kubota they have I think is registered as a low-speed vehicle. I just don't know if this falls into the exact same class. For Bug Warriors.
[22:20] Yeah,. Yep. Yep. So, yeah, so I would I would have that conversation with Parks and Rec as well, so.
[22:28] So, can you Hi, Chief.
[22:29] Hi.
[22:30] can you say again how many how many times now a year, how often this is happening that you need a vehicle like this to respond?
[22:39] So, I would say depending on you know it depends on what the tide is and so forth on the beach, but say the tide is half low or low, you know, times a year that they would be using that, I would say between the woods and the beaches anywhere from [23:00] probably eight to 15 times a year.
[23:04] And so, and how do you divide that? I mean, is it 50/50 half wood or is it more in the beach?
[23:09] and the beach. it really depends on the year, you know, we've had some years where Manomet is like we're going,, going and then we'll go for a year and it's like, "Oh, we only had one call up there." I would say the beach is fairly predictable July and August, you know, you're going to have six, eight, 10 people we bring off the beach during the summer. [23:29] Hand carries now or I know Pete talked about
[23:31] A lot of them are hand A lot of them are
[23:32] four people on a litter, six people on a litter.
[23:35] and they're carrying them. the thing is though, you know, you say you have a patient fall down by the cul-de-sac and they're a patient you want to get in the ambulance and get to the hospital sooner than later. You know, you it's going to take six or eight people and they've got them in a Stokes and they're carrying them and they're bouncing them and you're you're going up a set of stairs with them.
[23:53] Yeah.
[23:53] with this piece of equipment you can set them on the patient carrier and you can drive them down to the ramp at the bathhouse and get them up onto the street and have the ambulance staged right there to pick them up.
[24:02] So, that would be kind of a more of a standard response plan.
[24:06] Correct.
[24:07] So, you're not driving them to the hospital in this vehicle.
[24:10] You are driving them to a pickup point by the ambulance. Would that Would that be the same with out in the woods, Mount A?
[24:17] Correct. Yep. Yep, we can get them out of the woods to where the ambulance is staged. And and put them in the ambulance where the ambulance is staged, so
[24:29] Thanks for clarifying that.
[24:30] You're welcome.
[24:30] So, for the woods rescue, you're using someone's vehicle to do that. Is that what I read?
[24:37] Right. So, a somewhat recent
[24:40] does that look like? What is that vehicle now that you're using?
[24:42] it's a So, the one we had last time the last time we had one of our members bring one to the woods, his is a I don't know if it's a 4x4 or a 6x6, but it's a similar setup. His is a four-seater with a like a dump bed on the back.
[25:00] Yeah.
[25:01] And what we're able to do is put that tailgate down on his, but you've got the Stokes on there, but it's heavily tied on one end because too much of it's hanging out the back and so forth. [25:15] Yeah, be interesting to know whether that's a 4x4 or 6x6. I mean, this vehicle looks
[25:21] to the untrained eye like a little bit of overkill. I mean, it's a big piece of equipment. I just want you know, it's 75,000 versus Parks was talking about 15,000 for the vehicle they need, and maybe they need something more substantial. That's part of your point.
[25:37] Right. Yeah.
[25:37] But, I think we ought to sort of have more of a conversation to see the level of a piece of equipment we need.
[25:44] And yeah, and I don't know what theirs included, but again, the weight is the biggest factor for the 6x6. This vehicle, too, which could be different than theirs. I haven't seen what theirs was specked like. [25:54] This is pretty lightweight, man.
[25:55] This is an in-
[25:56] Yeah.
[25:56] It's an enclosed cab with heat and so forth, and the reason for that is so when they're driving it on the road, whether it be February or in the fall in October, November, if they're going from the station to Mount Agamenticus and they're going 40, 50 miles an hour up Route 1 and up Mountain Road, [26:12] That is substantially different.
[26:14] Yeah, I mean, the Parks and Rec was like
[26:16] it does have a full glass enclosed cab.
[26:18] That was not the case that they were talking about. It was like a windscreen and open, you know, kind of like a standard I think it was a
[26:24] Because they're
[26:25] Yeah.
[26:26] using it on the beach.
[26:26] Exactly.
[26:27] Did you get a picture? Yeah, I mean, they're they're Jeff, they're talking about like a mule.
[26:31] Right, yeah. So, that's where a lot of the cost you would see. I think if you went to a 4x4 in the same model that I'm talking about versus 6x6, you might be talking three or four $5,000 less. A lot of it is in the structural cab and enclosure and so forth.
[26:47] And you also said it had some sort of fire equipment on it as well.
[26:51] Correct. So, in that picture
[26:53] Yeah. We need to have that, I guess, strapped on the vehicle.
[26:56] In that picture, what you see is you see it says EMSD. That's a seat for a provider to sit in. So, an EMS provider sits in that seat. there's a pole beside the seat for hanging equipment and IV lines and so forth. And then where you see it says Q-Tac, that's a flat platform where you slide the Stokes or backboard
[27:17] up onto it and strap the patient right there. And then behind the seat and behind the platform for the Stokes, you'll see there's a hose reel and a small pump. And the forward part of that is like a 30-gallon water tank.
[27:30] Yeah.
[27:31] The patient. So, you're inside the nice cozy heated cabin the patient's out in the elements? Okay. Just want to clarify the design here.
[27:41] [laughter]
[27:41] Right.
[27:42] No, Mount A in February.
[27:46] But they're riding.
[27:51] Yeah, but to get to the M, but yeah.
[27:53] To be clear, they're out in the elements before they get strapped onto this thing. Stay in freeze or come in freeze.
[27:58] Yeah. Okay.
[27:59] the goal is once we get this unit to the patient to have them strapped to it and out of the woods and into the ambulance in 20-25 minutes. when they're in the woods.
[28:08] Introduce budget committee member Christine Brown. Just She'd been in the audience a little bit, but just came up to the table. Thanks, Chris, for to participate. So.
[28:15] Thanks very much. I just was wondering what other towns are using this tool and
[28:21] [28:21] how it's working for them.
[28:22] So, there is a lot you know, a lot of beach communities have them. a lot of beach communities rely heavily upon them to do the same thing that we're proposing doing with it. and, you know, there's I think towns, like I believe the town of Wells has a couple of them.
[28:43] I know Ogunquit has some sort of unit they use, I believe, for their lifeguards. it's similar. It's a side-by-side type vehicle. you know,
[28:54] the 4x4, I was asking about I was going to ask about the price difference, but you said three or four or five thousand dollars less for the 4x4.
[29:03] versus 6x6. Yeah, it would be, you know, a few to several thousand less, to go to the 4x4.
[29:11] In this frame with a cab with a cabin closure, yeah.
[29:14] Yeah.
[29:15] So, the big delta is the equipment.
[29:16] Right. [29:21] you know, the other thing, too, and the reason we kind of thought it would be, you know, best suited to double it as a little bit of a fire suppression forestry unit. We don't have a brush forestry unit, per se, in our station. We cover a lot of area where they're, you know, we're finding they're having campfires and so forth up in the Mount Agamenticus, in our section of the watershed section, and so forth.
[29:45] so, we don't have a pickup, per se. A lot of departments will have a pickup with like a slide-in unit in the back of it. we don't do that. we pretty much do everything with Indian water tanks on our back. you fill these tanks with water and put them on like a backpack and walk in the woods with them.
[30:09] Great.
[30:09] So, would it would it make any sense to have a smaller to have two smaller units as opposed to one bigger unit? So, what, the parks is recommending for the beach, and then maybe we have a smaller unit up on Mount A. Is that where most of your activity is, where people are up there hiking or whatever in the winter, and
[30:28] Yeah, I would
[30:28] if you had one there, you could drive up, get on it, you'd be cold until you got to the person until you got back.
[30:34] I mean, so, driving up Mountain Road at 60 miles an hour with the lights going, you're driving somewhere from Mountain A to a quarter mile, half mile around there by the road or something.
[30:44] where the activity is.
[30:46] Yeah,. And it lives at Mountain A.
[30:48] Right. yeah, the only thing is with that is you'd if it had the fire suppression capabilities, it would have to be in a heated space. Which we don't have at Mountain A.
[30:59] As we've heard extensively.
[31:00] Don't we do have a brush truck in town, right?
[31:03] Ain't the village has a brush truck.
[31:06] Correct. You guys still have your pickup brush truck?
[31:11] Correct.
[31:14] The answer is no plans to eliminate currently, but it's not a new brush truck, I think is yeah, the comment. So, and that's primarily the reason we've never they've had one for years, so we've never proposed buying one. [31:29] I think a little red flag for me on this is [31:35] the this kind of reminds me of buying a lake boat for the ocean water and river rescues in that I'm concerned that perhaps the Parks and Rec vehicle is actually not specked appropriately if what you're hearing is 6 by 6 is what is actually needed on the beach. And then we end up with a vehicle that is not actually going to do what we need to and it's going to, you know, throw sand all over the place.
[32:01] So, I 'm glad that you brought this forth and really will be pleased to hear how you and Parks and Rec can maybe overlap on that.
[32:10] Yeah, and again it would I'll be interested to see what Peter has to say about it because he may have a completely different vision in his mind for what he needs for equipment and a 4 by 4 may very well go fine with what his plan is to put in the back of it versus just that particular unit we have specked for this is is you know, got some weight to it cuz it's the suppression and the patient carriers.
[32:34] My other question was you mentioned that the York Beach Fire Association would be open to helping with some of the funding of this. Would they be open to the funding of it whether we get grant money or not or is that is that dependent on grant financing?
[32:50] So, at one time the thought was to spend the EMS grant funds on this unit in the fire department had informally agreed during discussions that if we bought the unit that the $50,000 grant fund would cover the cost of the actual 6 by 6 side by side and the department would fund up to 20 to 25,000 to finish
[33:16] outfitting it. I would have to go back. That was several months ago. I would have to go back and find out if it doesn't get paid for by the grant if they're still looking to put a substantial donation towards it. I would have to have that discussion with them.
[33:33] Thank you.
[33:34] There's a board that I have to check with.
[33:40] All right. Thanks Jeff. Do you want to stick around? I know we're going to talk really briefly about some other joint stuff afterwards. So, let Dave get up here. Thanks. Yep.
[33:51] Thank you.
[33:55] Okay.
[33:58] Let me just David has three items here.
[34:04] Let me just make sure I get all of them. I can go this way.
[34:17] No.
[34:21] Okay. This one is apparatus replacement. So, that's
[34:30] Yeah, we we got an open spot here. So, we can't go the other way.
[34:35] Sorry, I'll [laughter] just
[34:36] Oh.
[34:38] Yeah, we're good.
[34:39] I only took one.
[34:41] I didn't take the other one away.
[34:42] Yeah. no, not the other one. This one, this two. Here you go. These are the
[34:48] Sorry, what?
[34:48] One set?
[34:49] This is Village water. This is their high end
[34:51] What happened again?
[34:53] And this is [34:57] one, two,
[35:01] three. So, this is the first set of apparatus.
[35:14] Okay.
[35:18] All right, Chief. I've handed So, I've got three sets of copies here for you, Engine 4 turnout gear radios and building upgrade phase one. So, do you want to lead off with apparatus replacement? They've got that right now. So, yep.
[35:32] So, the Engine 4 replacement, that's I attempted to do this last year and was turned down, so I'm bringing it back this year. It's our last big piece of apparatus that needs to be replaced. And all of our big apparatus will be up-to-date. This is a 2001 Pierce pumper.
[35:53] it has doesn't have 100,000 mi on it like the last truck we replaced, but it's still it's reached its retirement age, if you will. We use it specifically for either to get called to a small incident or a blocking unit out on the turnpike
[36:14] where we don't have to bring out the million-dollar aerial truck or our big tanker. [36:23] [snorts]
[36:23] it's used to if main pumper is just the new 2000 26 Pierce engine we just got, if that goes out of service or down for some reason, this truck is it's back up. [36:41] So, yep. Keep Sorry, keep going. I've got
[36:45] I thought you were stopping.
[36:46] yeah, so in our last year I was questioned about our we needed a replacement plan. We did have a replacement. I didn't have it with me at that meeting. The person who asked the question, she had it on her box the next day. it was scheduled to be replaced in 2029. When it says fiscal 29, means that was the year it was supposed to be
[37:07] replaced. Means you have to All these trucks take a couple years to
[37:11] [37:12] get built, depending if we get them spec'd or if we get them custom. so, this we won't don't expect this get this truck now until fiscal probably 30. so, again, I don't want to run into the problem we had where we're dumping money into this truck. If we wait another year, then it's just going to push it out that much further and we're going to have issues we're going to have issues.
[37:35] so, I'm going for it again this year and see what happens.
[37:39] Okay, so,
[37:43] on the cover sheet for the replacement, I just want to note thank you for bringing the price down to 1.4 dollars.
[37:53] [laughter]
[37:55] It's just 1.4, not 1.4. It's 1.4 million. Sorry, that was a That was a joke, Dave. Sorry.
[38:00] That went over big.
[38:02] Two people chuckled. It was great. so, [snorts] can we talk about the just the replacement schedule you put in the back there?
[38:09] Sure.
[38:10] Yeah. Well, and can we talk about what's been replaced on it cuz that's good. Yeah.
[38:15] Just adding on to that and project description 2001 Pierce pumper, you're proposing replacing the 2001 with a new one. You're not proposing buying a 2000 I know, I just wanted to flush that out for the foreman in the audience.
[38:33] Okay, so, with the replacement unit, so, ladder one, so, at the bottom for the replacement plan, this was Yeah, right there. Right underneath your hand. Ladder one is Jeff's truck, right? So, that one is in the replacement queue right now. Order
[38:54] for an order.
[38:57] So, Chief Wells, for those that are watching, said it's expected around April for delivery. So, So, brush 10 was replaced. That is now
[39:07] Rescue 2.
[39:08] Rescue 2. Okay, so you guys repurposed it a little bit in terms of for need as a kind of a front line, a lighter duty front line truck. How's that going for use?
[39:18] out very well. It is a primary rescue for the non heavy rescue type motor vehicle accidents, things like that.
[39:26] So, you took kind of like a the
[39:30] We took the suggestion
[39:31] the from the beach what the beach was running with a lighter engine that's primarily for rescue calls. So, it's mostly medical calls or rescue calls, but then you have fire suppression apparatus on it for s- lighter duty stuff. It wouldn't substitute for a full for a full engine, but this is like in case that you have a crew of two driving back or one driving back from medical call, you have some fire suppression equipment to put on something if a call comes in, correct?
[39:56] Correct. It's proven at 99 Freeman Street. they would come back from medical call.
[40:00] Yep.
[40:00] The truck is equipped with a class A pumper. It was able to pump the majority of the water on that fire. I was just needing to get the additional equipment there to provide the water to the truck.
[40:12] And that's that's Beach's Rescue 1, correct? That's the equivalent of yeah.
[40:18] are they are similar type units. And both those units So, when we say a brush unit, it's it can go into roads into the brush area that are maintained by the water district.
[40:31] Yep.
[40:31] Both those trucks, but if you get into a place where it's not bottom land and you have little tow road,
[40:37] Yep.
[40:38] you cannot get down those roads with this truck.
[40:40] Yep.
[40:40] We did not take our brush truck out of service that this is
[40:43] Yep.
[40:44] the brush truck.
[40:45] Yep.
[40:45] So, you can get that in the places, but plan is not to replace that because we basically use
[40:50] So
[40:50] the essentially what happened is this turned into a Swiss Army knife. The rescue The replacement for brush 10 that became rescue two
[40:59] Yes.
[40:59] rescue two kind of was a squad two replacement and a brush truck. It's kind of like in the middle ground between all of those and is more of a Swiss Army knife for you guys.
[41:07] pumper rescue basically.
[41:09] So thank you. I want to give you credit for that. That was a huge adjustment I think you guys made on the fly and I think it's going to work out really well for your department. so the ladder ones in queue, squad two that's shown on here
[41:20] It replaced
[41:20] It's been replaced with the truck that we just purchased last year that we just received this year, right?
[41:26] Right.
[41:26] Okay. And then engine four FY29 engine four is what we are talking about for you. And for those the audience and those that in at the table, the evens are village apparatus and the odds are beach apparatus and they set that up years ago I think to avoid If they're an odd number it's coming from the beach. If it's an even number it's coming from village for dispatch and scene command to know what's what.
[41:49] Good.
[41:50] So sorry, you said squad two on the FY2027 list?
[41:53] Meaning it was When you're looking at that list, that's the year we want to put it in service. So that we're asking it for the year of
[42:02] The brush truck, you see what year that was asked for? We didn't get it until this year.
[42:08] Okay. So you
[42:10] And we
[42:11] asked for it in 2027 you asked for squad two.
[42:13] And we got it in 2027 fortunately.
[42:16] And I'm sorry, why
[42:16] We have a replacement in 2027. So you asked for it in 2025
[42:21] 25 26, yeah.
[42:23] And then we received it in 2027.
[42:24] I'm really sorry, but I'm having a really hard time following this layout. If we could for the when you're presenting to the budget committee, if you could put this into a table with the with the recommendations. I don't really understand I feel like I just heard two different things on the squad two FY27.
[42:45] You asked for it last year, it didn't go on the ballot, but then we received it this year.
[42:49] No.
[42:50] Okay.
[42:52] This is
[42:53] And this is This is aged, too. So, that's why I'm going through it because this was a 2022 plan that I think you guys had put together.
[43:00] Maybe we need an update.
[43:01] And I'm trying to tick off
[43:02] updated plan with Yeah, that would be really great. And with anticipated receipt dates. Yeah, would be great.
[43:09] Or actual
[43:10] Or actual Yeah, actual receipted received or anticipated received.
[43:15] Maybe calendar date rather than fiscal year.
[43:18] Mhm. Yeah, received.
[43:20] So,, just for those in the room, FY23 brush truck has been replaced. It was not replaced necessarily in '23, but we got it a year ago now.
[43:31] COVID messed up all that schedule going to be in the queue. And also
[43:34] Ladder is in replacement queue. Squad 2 was replaced, and Engine 4 now we are talking about, but that's that's what the request I'm just running through the recent replacement items. Sorry, I'm not trying to reference this plan too heavily, but so everyone understands what we're talking
[43:48] I sort of have to agree with other members. I can't follow all this. So, it needs to be a better layout so that And it would really be helpful if we had something we could see before the meeting so we had a sense of what we're talking about. So, I agree with Heather that we it needs to be laid out better.
[44:13] Does the Engine 4 for FY29, is that something then you'll put into request for '27 of '28 rather?
[44:22] That's what's in the
[44:23] So, the '29, it can be replaced. That's the overall gist, right?
[44:27] These trucks are good you know, coding NFPA standards for 25 years. They're looking at now 30 years on this truck.
[44:36] Yeah, okay.
[44:38] So, I guess I'd also say when we talked about this last year, it was clear that the numbers have almost flipped from 10 to 20 years ago where now 70% of your calls are medical and 30% are fire. So, and that's part of the reason the brush truck became rescue two is that you realize, okay, we have a lot of medical calls, so we need a vehicle that can go and respond to that type of thing.
[45:05] So, one of the questions I'm going to have is we have, and I know they're different, and we talked about this last year, but I don't remember exactly the differences. But, the two fire departments have six pumpers. Do we need six pumpers in this town? That'd be one of my questions. I mean, I know they're separate fire departments, but it's one town, so it 'll be a question I'll have when we have a better, you know, I know the some pumpers do something a little different than others.
[45:33] [snorts]
[45:34] But, it'd be really helpful to understand why we need six when only 30% of our calls are fire.
[45:53] All right. We have two different departments in town. We have the one of them is the separate departments, so we make our decisions we make them by separate departments.
[46:01] I think that's a problem. I think that's a problem.
[46:05] Mhm.
[46:11] All right.
[46:12] Yeah, I just want to say, sorry to follow up on Robert. [46:16] I think many of us have been talking in general about how operations has such a huge impact on capital. And you happen to be the first person where this is really coming up of what is the operational impact of the capital, and what is the are we really in this group only talking about capital, or are we also talking about operations and how things are running?
[46:42] And they're they're so intertwined, and this process is a little flawed in that it makes it sound like capital lives all on its own when you're clearly explaining that it doesn't live on its own. So, I just wanted to give you a reassurance that this is a theme that will be happening for all of the capital requests that are coming in to try and understand
[47:04] is it working? Is the structure working? Are the operational needs being met? And are they being met for the whole for the whole town? So, I just wanted to reassure
[47:15] many projects that the Chief Dawson myself and the officers are working on in combining tasks, working together more, co- cross-training and so forth. But, in the meantime, you know, we just keep moving forward with what we need to do today. And again, you know, we come to these places, you know, we come to you guys, we come with needs, not wants.
[47:37] Our wants are purchased through our corporate upstairs monies.
[47:44] So, clarify capital operations driving capital requests in this case, not capital driving operations, cuz this wouldn't be a change to this wouldn't change any of your operations, but you're talking about does it would it change to the operational structure reduce the need for the capital spend? That's the question.
[48:03] Well, yeah, and I mean, that's a legitimate question. If 70% of our calls are medical calls, what's standing in the way of us having the right equipment for the for the 70% medical calls? And is it the structure of the departments? And I think that's what we're concerned about. So.
[48:28] If there was a greater need, for example, for the six pumpers, and I'm kind of green at this, but the two departments would work together and share equipment, share capital, if they needed to, right? And and sometimes if there's an overload, other towns would be involved.
[48:49] Is that correct?
[48:50] we you know, we rely on mutually quite a bit, but you know,
[48:55] [clears throat]
[48:55] again, we've always you know, it's always been our policy to have a, you know, two pumpers, a tanker, and our ladder. And your pump your primary pumper goes out of service, you need that secondary pumper to fill in that spot. It's It's spot. You know, you don't want to take a $2 million ladder truck down the road.
[49:19] You know, there's many one of the reasons you know, it's hard to get into spots. It's hard to maneuver. And it's just your basic everyday call. you always need that first pumper and that smaller unit to get in there to make your first attack or whatever.
[49:39] Thank you.
[49:44] Okay. All right, so there's a follow-up information request and follow-up discussion request. Anybody have any questions on this item? We've got two other items to talk about. And one Yeah, just want to maybe hit the [50:02] David, the next one would be gear, right? Yeah, so. Hold on.
[50:28] So, I'm on the gear one, right?
[50:31] Yep.
[50:32] Okay.
[50:32] Yep, purchase that, so yep.
[50:35] This is just something I'm throwing out there. And Jeff and I have both talked about this.
[50:41] [clears throat]
[50:43] Firefighter gear costs up to $5,000 a person now to if you want to fully suit somebody. So, it can be the range can be between $3,000 and $5,000 depending if you get in the helmet, you know, all components of it. Sure, we could we could go out and get 10 sets of gear and have them on the shelf but these gear this gear nowadays has a shelf life.
[51:06] They're only good for 10 to 12 years and it has to be replaced when they get worn out or they have to be replaced when they hit their expiration date. We can use the gear for our non-interior firefighters. So we can take some of the take some of the gear all the gear if it's in good shape and use that for our new people coming on until they take the firefighter one or two and have to go in to the internal structure of fire fighting.
[51:33] [51:34] [snorts]
[51:35] So what we need you know really is a fund out there that we get three new people we can go to that fund pull out money for those three new firefighters. We get five we've got the money available. It's hard to budget in your operations money for the that gear because you don't know being in that type of situation
[51:55] with call force volunteers we don't know how many volunteers going to have. So this is it instead of by purchasing the gear and having the shelf not being used this is a way that we can buy it purchase it when we need it. You know you know it's a reoccurring fund that just if you don't use it all it rolls over to the next year and just keep that fund at a certain balance year after year.
[52:21] Radio is the same thing. Radio is 8 to 10,000 dollars possibly more if it's a mobile unit. that's hard to put it in your budget for your replacement of your portals.
[52:34] Jeff do you want to do you want to join this conversation as well as it if it's intended to be joined you know. So goal would be some type of reserve fund establishment. I mean as opposed
[52:51] the department is in Dark Village it's joint.
[52:53] Well it sounded like from what Dave was saying that Jeff would also be
[52:57] Yeah we easily could be a joint
[53:01] account.
[53:01] Okay. Well in the in case it turns into a joint project, why don't you stay there, Jeff? Or give feedback. So, the idea being this would be a This would be a establishment of If we just add it as a capital item, of course, it would stay until it's spent, but we don't like to have stuff floating 5 years out there, 3 years out there. The If the true intent is that we would have a fund with a balance in it for purchase, so a certain amount available per year, and if you didn't add to it, we would then
[53:32] make an appropriate If we didn't spend from it that year, we would leave it as is. If you Let's say we've established the amount that it was supposed to be in there in the level, and then you spent 50,000 out of that and to get it up back up to that level, we'd put 50,000 back in over the next year or 2 years. That's the vision.
[53:48] Yes.
[53:48] Okay. So,
[53:50] Yeah.
[53:50] So, a reserve fund, not a capital fund, that would be funded with
[53:54] You're not on.
[53:54] I don't
[53:55] operating dollars, probably. And we could fund it What I'm This is a question. We could fund it the same way we do our unemployment fund, our earned time fund, and things like that, which is every year we look at the balance, we see what's used, try to try to project what we're going to need as closely as we can for that year, and that's the request the next year.
[54:19] So, it ends up in those two cases being a fairly consistent number from year to year that we request, but it does work well.
[54:28] Yeah. Just So, but at the initial discussion could be
[54:33] capital request for the for the first fiscal year, depending on the amount.
[54:38] It couldn't be bonded.
[54:40] Correct. Yeah.
[54:40] Yeah.
[54:41] Okay.
[54:42] Capital because of the amount, not because of the funding structure.
[54:45] Yes.
[54:47] Or the purpose. How much do you typically spend every year on
[54:51] Be the follow-up, yeah.
[54:52] on gear and radios?
[54:56] I don't know that information. The gear we did fund we did outfit, I believe, five firefighters each year, some of that was current firefighters and few of our new firefighters.
[55:09] So, that would be about 25,000 if it's three to five per person?
[55:14] And Wendy can pull that information. You could probably that would be a good request is like the five-year
[55:22] Currently outfitting firefighters there's a line item in the operating budget?
[55:26] Yep.
[55:26] For that? And you manage to that.
[55:30] And we've got four firefighters that are going to be taking their firefighter one this year that they didn't know about last year.
[55:38] [55:39] Yeah, I think to support kind of the lump sum support to the position, that's you pick a number 18 months before you know what that final is supported and you can't if we you want to bring people on, you can't not outfit them. So, it's kind of like a driven cost based on turnover and membership that you are not aware of when you're making the budget.
[56:00] So, there is some
[56:01] It's a general equipment fund. It's not specific to turnover. So, it's every
[56:06] Yep. And the comment from the audience from Deputy Chief Zach Abgar was it's if comes from the equipment fund, not from necessarily for turnout. It's not just turnout gear or radios, it's the general equipment fund that you guys use to fund all kinds of other purchases throughout the year. So, [56:24] So, would we see a corresponding reduction in the operating budget?
[56:27] Not if this was in the operating budget.
[56:30] You could see a large increase in the operating budget, so that's what I was trying to keep away from.
[56:35] Can I Can I add something?
[56:36] Yeah, sure.
[56:37] [56:38] [clears throat]
[56:39] So, yeah, to follow up on what Deputy Chief Abgar said, the turnout gear is coming out of the general equipment line item in our budgets now. And like generally I'm planning on replacing two to three sets of turnout gear per year. what happens is if we have gear that's expiring and we need to replace those two to three sets, and then we have two to three candidates that come in that we're going to put through the fire one two process.
[57:06] When they come out of that process, they need to be put into a appropriate set of gear. So, now that's turned into three to five sets. And then if you have a call and on the off chance you wreck a set or two or three, there's a possibility where you could get into a year where you're buying eight or 10 sets. [57:24] And other years you're buying nothing.
[57:26] Yeah, generally you figure like I said, we're figuring on two to three sets a year down at the beach station to kind of keep at the minimum pace of replacing what we've got that's expiring. Like we had
[57:37] [57:39] we had probably 15 sets, 12 to 15 sets over the last couple of years that had to had to be disposed of because they were 15, 18 years old, they were falling apart.
[57:49] And just for reference, I know you've got the information here, the required service cycle replacement for fire gear.
[57:59] 10 years.
[57:59] 10 years for bunker for a surface
[58:01] for an interior firefighter.
[58:02] Gloves, pants, jacket, yep, boots.
[58:05] the other thing to consider that would be beneficial to have this reserve account and get this into play. there's a lot of new technology coming out in the manufacturing of the gear with PFAS-free materials. And I would not be totally surprised if we see something come down the line in the near future from NFPA that changes the requirement that you've got to get all your stuff upgraded to the PFAS-free
[58:32] materials by a certain date. and that's going to place a, you know, substantial cost on fire departments to put everybody in those garments, so.
[58:43] Is that because you have foam or other products that have PFAS now and you would have to replace it?
[58:52] There's PFAS in the in the turnout gear material.
[58:55] the gear.
[58:56] Yeah, there's PFAS in the in the garments, so. they're starting to release, they have been releasing PFAS-free gear and it's becoming, you know, more available. and you know, the talk on the street is that eventually that'll be a mandated thing, so.
[59:12] And the gear we've been purchasing is PFAS safe.
[59:14] Yeah.
[59:15] Not all of the parts and pieces, like the gloves aren't completely yet.
[59:18] Yeah.
[59:19] But you know, anytime we have that option, we take the PFAS free.
[59:22] We've got, you know, we 've got some stuff, you know, there's different layers to the turnout gear and they're kind of been working layer by layer. [59:30] So, certain parts of it are certified PFAS free and other parts are still incorporating different components.
[59:35] manufacturers that are making now all PFAS free. We've been kind of taking a step back and watching to see, you know, are these garments now going from 10-year garments to they're falling apart in 3 or 4 years because they're different materials. So, we're still kind of in the studying phase of that, but like I said, I don't think it's real far off that we'll see a mandate come
[59:56] for PFAS free turnout gear.
[59:58] So, this
[59:58] In order to be prepared, am I hearing that you buy gear in advance and sort of have it on hand for when you have new firefighters come in and you're able to outfit them right away, or is it the opposite you get someone new and then you have to order and there's a lead time? Setting aside the budgetary structure issues.
[1:00:19] Because of its Because of its age requirements, we don't want to buy ahead of time and have it sitting on the shelf and not being used. We want to buy it when we need it. The stuff that'll be sitting
[1:00:29] sense. I thought I heard that there was stuff sitting on the shelf that was aging out.
[1:00:33] stuff that'll be sitting on the shelf will be the stuff that's maybe aged out, but is in good condition that we can introduce the new recruits into until they take their Firefighter 1 and 2.
[1:00:44] And so, if you might have stuff sitting on the shelf if you have somebody who joined, passed their Fire 1 2, got outfitted, worked for us for 2 years as a call firefighter, this isn't for me. Now you've got 3-year-old equipment that is a specific size that if somebody comes in that fits, great, you can reuse that.
[1:01:05] If in the very unlikely chance that someone comes in who that fits and you have a spare set sitting around, you don't necessarily buy it, but likely you're going to get once somebody's that many years in, you're going to get several years of use out of it or several sets per firefighter over their career here. you're not going to have a lot of spare equipment that's been turned back in most of the time.
[1:01:27] Is that correct?
[1:01:28] Correct. Yeah. I think this is a good use of a reserve account. I mean, totally makes sense to me. If it's in the operating budget, cuz the reserve account would go could roll from year to year. If it's in the operating budget, is that still something that can be a reserve account and therefore keep going?
[1:01:48] I would suggest I don't personally care for the idea of having reserve accounts where spending is going in and out of the reserve accounts and you're not seeing it. I personally like the idea of what kind of what code does where they budget and then they transfer in what they need. And so it's transparent and you can see next the next year what was actually spent versus what was budgeted.
[1:02:08] So you still have a reserve account, but you're funding it from the operating and it goes into that reserve account.
[1:02:13] Yeah, you if you think you're going to need $50,000 worth of turnout gear, you budget $50,000 worth of turnout gear and revenues from the reserve. If you end up needing $40,000, then you just transfer the $40,000 in. You end up needing $60,000, that reserve is still there, but you see it in the operating budget, so for the transparency.
[1:02:35] So you're you're getting the point of what let me put it here is get the conversation going. However it's supposed to work out, I'm I'm up for it. But the idea you've got you've got the idea of what I'm trying to get out there.
[1:02:44] Yeah, I think that's
[1:02:45] Does the police department deal with the same issue?
[1:02:49] No, not for equipment. They're going through their stuff is
[1:02:52] tasers, radios.
[1:02:54] Their stuff is typically less their uniform stuff. There's more components and it's smaller value and it's replaced more frequently, I think. So it's operating budget. They'll you know, shirts and pants, duty shirts and pants and other than side arms and radios and stuff, but they've they've also got you know, 30 people that they're cycling through per year, so it's easier to It's easier to average out.
[1:03:20] The more people you have in a department, the more average your purchase is going to be every year. So, what you're talking about, I mean, you really get hit with the high cost, you know, of individual equipment and the variable low number that you're planning and that number might be two or might be five. And that's, you know, multiples of tens of thousands of dollars difference.
[1:03:40] If you're budgeting 20,000 a year for it, you need to spend 30. If you're budgeting $20,000 a year, you need to spend zero, those are very different outcomes. So, Well, I mean, I think it's definitely got merit for discussion. That's obviously why I wanted to talk about it here. The question would be whether we had a large capital appropriation into it to start, whether we slightly increase the budget and any savings get earmarked each year into the into a reserve fund like what Wendy's describing.
[1:04:08] That'll be another way to do it. There's probably two different ways that three different ways we could set this up and I think that's a good discussion for us to have moving forward. So,
[1:04:19] I'm sorry to be numb, but I'm not sure I understand if we're still budgeting for each of these items every year. Is the goal of the reserve account to minimize huge increases from year to year in the operational budget?
[1:04:35] Because my understanding of how we do the police vehicles, right, is that we always allocate a certain number of dollars so that they can be purchased within the fiscal year or with or outside of the fiscal year without interrupting the cycle because of the availability of the vehicles. So, I'm I'm trying to make the connection of how this is different from
[1:04:59] having these items in the budget cuz what Wendy just said is that we would still, let's say, $50,000 we budget in the equipment and why does the reserve Why is the reserve fund important?
[1:05:13] Because of the variability. So, that they So, I guess you could have $50,000 in the operating budget, pick the high number of the highest year and put that in every year, but I think what we're suggesting is that you or at least we're discussing cuz I don't know if I'm suggesting it yet or not. the
[1:05:34] that you would put a low medium number in there and when you didn't spend that, would carry over from year to year. So right now it's in the equipment line. If you were to call it out separately and have your So what happens is when you have a high purchase year for protective gear, you are not buying you're holding off on equipment purchases or you have to
[1:05:56] make sure you don't have overtime costs or somewhere else in your budget you defer something until a future year.
[1:06:01] Right.
[1:06:02] If you need to buy $20,000 more in protective gear that you didn't have cuz you need to put five sets of gear on somebody cuz something expired and you weren't expecting it or new people well you know to expect what's expiring, but you don't know what you're adding for new gear or damage in year. So to budget that as a reserve, you would budget a lower number consistently and when you didn't spend that you sock money into the reserve.
[1:06:26] That's what Wendy just described that there would be a reserve that went along with it. So it's still be in the operating budget.
[1:06:31] I think of it a little bit differently. I think of you continue to budget in your operating budget. you fund you get you get that funded. We establish the reserve for $50,000 and then if you need more than what you've budgeted in your operating budget, it's there to transfer in.
[1:06:53] That's kind of the way I was thinking about it, but there's a number of ways we could
[1:06:58] Well, and I think that's why I asked about the offset on the operating budget. Does that mean that instead of you know, just taking a swing and saying, "Okay, well, we're going to go with 50,000 cuz we can't be without three suits." You know, are we still budgeting on the more conservative side and then if we have a influx of volunteers,
[1:07:19] then this budget is available so that they're not going to select board for contingency because that's the only other option, right? Or to do less spending somewhere else. Got it. Thank you.
[1:07:29] In which case though they would they would require a less amount in the reserve, right? Not 50,000.
[1:07:35] Well, they would So, if you had 20,000 per year budgeted in operating, so the way I just thinking on my feet here cuz this discussion's gone three different directions. So, a way that you could set it up is you set up you do your year-to-year across Let's just say it's across all departments. I Maybe it is, maybe it isn't. what your lowest
[1:07:56] minimum floor kind of is that you've spent over the past 10 years, right? Like in that you're Hey, in a minimum year to go, we need three and three sets of gear replaced on our replacement schedule. Like you know there's no year where you're not going to be routinely replacing a certain number of gear. You set the budget amount One way you could do it is you set the budget amount at that and then when you have additional people coming in, there's a what Wendy just described there's a reserve fund established to pull that money out of so that it
[1:08:24] new for unexpected
[1:08:26] Correct. Right.
[1:08:28] Yeah, the way I see this is you're seeding a fund with 50, 100, whatever the number turns out to be. You continue to budget in your operating budget for these things. If you have a need that exceeds your operating budget, you have this reserve available to dip into.
[1:08:42] Yeah.
[1:08:42] I guess the question is if you don't spend that amount, does it impact the reserve? I wouldn't think so. You're simply adding to your budget
[1:08:51] at Yeah, you could set it up at a It depends if you want to set the budget amount at a low So, there's like again, three different permutations. Do you want to set the budget amount at a low, the floor that you think you're going to spend every year, and then always take any overage out of the reserve and always put money back into the reserve when that gets low by town meeting vote, for example.
[1:09:11] Or do you Or do you want to set your annual budget at a medium level, maybe where it is now, and somehow authorize Well, not somehow, authorize money in and out to be lower or higher coming from that reserve, either from or to the reserve. And then you don't have any separate
[1:09:28] for It's a question for years when you have surprises.
[1:09:30] Right. And is it And the question is, do you want to be having individual votes going back to the voters every time that reserve needs replenishment, or do you set the budget level slightly above what you think you're going to spend and there's a pol- I mean, I'm assuming it would be a fund estab- it would be done in the establishment of the fund by vote that when if the amount goes over this, the surplus goes into the like if this is unspent in the operating budget, it goes into the reserve fund.
[1:09:54] I'm not sure that you can do that. I think it has to go into fund balance, but you can you can you can transfer in the overage that you would need from the reserve. And you would budget the replacement of the reserve funds to keep that at a solid level and you still continue to budget as normal in
[1:10:12] So, [snorts] right. So, because it's not revenue, because it would be unspent appropriation, your feeling is that couldn't automatically go into a reserve fund.
[1:10:22] I think I need to do some checking. It doesn't feel like that could happen.
[1:10:26] But you could earmark revenue. Yeah.
[1:10:31] I have a couple more questions. Now, the radios, how does that fit in with the gear?
[1:10:35] sort of thing. It's just
[1:10:36] Every employee needs a radio. It's part of the gear. So to speak.
[1:10:42] inside the building, they should have one. it's It's the way the safety feature being behind it. If you get you know [1:10:54] If you get removed from your you know, lost from your If you get trapped somewhere else and you with your partner, you still have communications and so forth. So, again, it's It's the way things are done now. The issue with the issue is we call mutual aid. Not every town has the same radio frequency.
[1:11:14] We got over that hurdle, but now there's different frequencies. different There's UHF Yeah, different bands. And so we have to have multiple band radios and that is the price of
[1:11:29] Okay, and the other question was now that we're talking about reserves. Are we coming into a place where we have a lot of reserves in the town to kind of cover things? Is that
[1:11:39] No more than last year.
[1:11:41] I mean here we might be talking about adding another one.
[1:11:44] it may be in a different forum. We have to have conversations about reserves because I really personally, I don't know how much weight that carries, but I don't like the idea of having 10 reserve funds. I mean I think we need to budget as best we can budget.
[1:12:02] I'm good with it.
[1:12:03] Thank you.
[1:12:03] Okay. All right. Next item, Jeff, don't go anywhere cuz then I mean I let's throw out
[1:12:11] I'll throw this out. The next item is fire station upgrades. So there's two components to this, right? So there's kind of the long-term we should start with
[1:12:24] Well again, I put this in last and it got cut because of other priorities that you know, the town had. But you know, just starting off with anything, you've got to do some sort of a initial investigation.
[1:12:45] In fact, this say okay, this you know, what this is what this is what we want to do. How are we going to get there and what do you think the cost is going to be? So threw this $50,000 out there just as you know, we just went through it's like a consultant. you know, is it going to be 20,000, going to be 50,000, whatever, but we have to know what we're going to do.
[1:13:05] So there's two there's two components drive. So I'll give some of the background. So people in the audience people on TV and in the room can discuss. So there's two components to this. There was a plan previously there was kind of a medium-term plan to increase staffing levels in the that we've talked about several times both with staff, with chiefs, with management.
[1:13:30] to increase slowly increase staffing levels at both fire stations to get to long-term goal being two people on around the clock just because of called demand. Now, that was the plan was never that in 1 year we're going to add eight full-time people. That would be four in each station to get to two on around the clock.
[1:13:51] But, we had discussed starting 2 years ago, 3 years ago, like until last year could we add one person each year, you know, over a time period to get to there. As we're having that discussion, and I'll this will key into an ambulance discussion very quickly here, which for better for worse. the staffing
[1:14:11] quarters were identified as even if we're just adding staff at the fire department to have two people on around the clock at Village Fire to be problematic. So, at Beach there it's not fantastic, but you have ways as I understand it to make quarters for two to three people with some minor accommodations inside in the living quarters, the separate living quarters that you have there.
[1:14:35] It wouldn't be ideal long-term, but it's something that we could do while as we're planning future facilities, and you know, it might match better with the duration of the life of that station being we'll say for discussion 20 years or less. Village, on the other hand, you have one set of living quarters with the bathroom and a sleeping area that's kind of open like a studio apartment.
[1:14:57] So, it's really designed to house one person around the clock. It's like the best way to describe it. So, assuming we needed equal sleeping facilities at both areas, Beach would be a little bit significantly easier to address by essentially by walls and doors. Doors, really. one wall door kind of sit- situation.
[1:15:18] You don't have the living quarters. You would need to convert some other area of the station to a living quarter sleeping quarter for at least one person if we were to add an additional person on around the clock. Correct?
[1:15:28] For a short time, yes.
[1:15:30] Yeah. But, the But, the long-term plan would be to convert space that you have existing into additional staff quarters.
[1:15:37] Correct.
[1:15:37] Okay. So, now does everybody understand kind of the baseline of where we're at on that? Okay. So, fire on what the long-term plan would be to develop cuz that's what this is, right? This would be to develop staffing quarters.
[1:15:49] Correct. you know, initially it was that an additional full-time employee.
[1:15:54] Yeah.
[1:15:54] But then into the future, we don't know who the ambulance if you're going to go through the process of creating staffing for one additional make it for at least probably four additional for future.
[1:16:09] Three additional, four overall on here.
[1:16:13] And you know, again to do that, we got to have that planning portion done.
[1:16:16] Yep.
[1:16:17] And then hopefully start the implementation next year.
[1:16:20] So, this process that you're contemplating here of adding staffing quarters, we all know I think in the room, but would is independent of the ambulance discussion which we also need to have what that is.
[1:16:32] Correct.
[1:16:32] But for the long term of adding anybody, you would be adding staffing quarters at village.
[1:16:37] Right. You know, it's it's it's well known that the union wants additional people on the floor. We're not against additional people on the floor. you know, we've just discussed quite a bit. We've discussed how to get that additional person on the phone on the floor and yet keep the call force fairly active within the department to keep their
[1:16:57] enthusiasm and know that they
[1:17:01] Yeah.
[1:17:01] are needed. their commitment strong. So, we're ready to move forward with that.
[1:17:08] Okay. So, this So, your vision or I mean, I hope I'm summing up your vision correctly. The long phase process and you have in future years, you have building phases in that cover sheet that you saw that would go into the comprehensive plan in years three two and three. The long-term vision is if we don't need to put people in your station immediately,
[1:17:28] this is how you would like to pursue it.
[1:17:30] need this stuff.
[1:17:30] Right.
[1:17:31] Like I mean, the union can come down and they get negotiations 20 2020 I believe. And if it comes out that they want two people and for somehow they went out on that, we need to be ready. You know, and it's it's there's nothing, you know, the time is here to have multiple people on the floor. But we're not there because we haven't started the process.
[1:17:56] So, may I point out that this is a really good example of capital and operations not being tied together in a way that makes a lot of sense to my brain. So, what I'm hearing and I'm supportive of, to be clear, I'm just asking questions. That you're needing a study to be able to plan for
[1:18:18] future
[1:18:18] when we need more firefighters.
[1:18:21] No.
[1:18:21] What is the timeline with more firefighters, right? More another full-time firefighter.
[1:18:28] No, there's no study.
[1:18:29] No,, that's what the $50,000
[1:18:31] the $50,000 is for. for the building.
[1:18:34] For where to house them, yeah.
[1:18:36] Right. Yeah,, yeah.
[1:18:37] But where in our budget are we hiring more firefighters?
[1:18:40] Not yet.
[1:18:41] It was in the operating budget discussion last year and was and all throughout it and was we did not add additional staff. We had discussions about adding starting a process to increase staffing at the fire department, both fire departments throughout the operating. Did that was that any of that in front of the budget committee or had we already kind of made that
[1:19:03] I think we had made that discussion. We had talked about it the select board level, management level and it didn't go in because of the I mean it was $400,000 is what we were talking about, so yeah.
[1:19:13] Wait, I just I'm I'm this is an example I'm connecting to an operational change that requires a capital investment.
[1:19:21] Correct. Yeah.
[1:19:21] And the operational change hasn't hasn't necessarily made it into the plan yet. So, I guess my question is, do we have is it this budget season that we're going to ask for additional firefighters?
[1:19:35] I'm not going to.
[1:19:38] Yes.
[1:19:38] I'm not going to.
[1:19:40] I'm not going to ask for additional firefighters until I have a place to put them in the station. That's my objective.
[1:19:45] Okay.
[1:19:46] So
[1:19:46] Chicken and egg.
[1:19:47] Yeah. So, well, the reason that this wasn't in the capital program last year, this was in the request This was in David's request. This is This is actually in your This was in the out years. This is in the out years, these items. Yeah. Well, all of your steps were in the out years because it was not put in year one because the additional staffing did not get put in the operating budget.
[1:20:08] Okay. So, when will the additional staffing be put in the operating budget?
[1:20:12] [laughter]
[1:20:13] There's a lot of parts that will determine that we're not out yet right now. So, we may You may have this come out of the capital budget additional staff put into the budget and building funds go into the capital budget request if the if the determination is that we want to add staff this year.
[1:20:32] And this is This is tied to the ambulance.
[1:20:35] It is now. It wasn't It wasn't when It was not last year. Now, it's a two-part this Yeah, now they are tied together, Tim. Yeah. Well, I mean, so I guess what I would say is you probably won't see a plan put forward that adds I haven't been developing I know they haven't been developing into add one person a year for 3 years because we are likely to hit a trip point where either we need to add four people
[1:21:00] per or we don't need to add anybody based on a decision that will be made in the next 2 months. So, yeah.
[1:21:09] I Can I weigh in? so a couple of things. So, you've got over the 3 years 250,000. So, I'm understanding 200,000 is construction and 50,000 is study.
[1:21:23] I have no idea what the cost is going to be, so I have to put
[1:21:26] don't either, but 50,000 out of 250 for studying it seems like a lot of money.
[1:21:31] was I put down 50,000 because we just had a study for the ambulance which was went from 20,000 to 90,000. What's an architect going to cost? I don't know. So, I put down 50,000. Hopefully, it's only 15,000.
[1:21:44] But you're But you're building it within the envelope you already have. You're not adding square footage to the building.
[1:21:49] Correct.
[1:21:50] So, I mean, I don't I don't even know if you'd need an architect to get a design built in there.
[1:21:54] square footage. We can't add square footage to the building there in this location.
[1:21:58] I don't I don't know why we're not
[1:22:05] Okay. So, the So, the comment from Village Fire Department members in the audience, sorry, since I know he's not on microphone is that there's sprinkler studies that would need to be done if you wall If you partition the building differently. So.
[1:22:16] You can't just go and put walls where you want to put them and you know, it's
[1:22:20] I just think this needs to be expedited. I 'm the opposite. I think this needs to be expedited and we need to be doing it more quickly. Is there under So, maybe I misheard, [clears throat] but is there under any scenario where we don't need more full-time fire people
[1:22:36] Not long-term.
[1:22:37] in the village?
[1:22:38] Not long-term, but potentially short-term, yes.
[1:22:40] Short-term, there's may not be a need.
[1:22:42] Correct. But I think long-term
[1:22:45] What that looks like?
[1:22:47] What do you What do you mean?
[1:22:49] What does it look like when we only have one fire person on at a time?
[1:22:53] if So, if the ambulance function does not come into the fire station, which is definitely a possibility at this point, and probably more likely than not, I don't know. if that doesn't happen, we do not we do not need to add staffing. There is there is a
[1:23:13] there is a request to add staffing, which I think is reasonable, and I think there's a long-term benefit [clears throat] to adding staffing and to getting to
[1:23:22] So, we're having a challenge hiring full-time fire people because they're on solely by themselves.
[1:23:29] I would say to some extent, yeah.
[1:23:33] Don't we have an open position?
[1:23:35] Not right now, but we've had an open position for a while, and that was part of an issue, yeah.
[1:23:39] Yeah. So, I just I think that's an issue.
[1:23:44] Yep.
[1:23:45] That under this scenario we're waiting like 4 years.
[1:23:52] Would it be possible to get an estimate of what these this work would actually be because I think to Robert's point, it might make more sense for the architectural study and the sprinkler study to happen sooner rather than later that maybe the select board takes that out of contingency if there are other things that happen sooner because I think for me just seeing a $50,000 kind of thrown against the wall.
[1:24:19] I think if you had an actual quote of what those things could be, I think you might be able to push it through sooner without the capital process.
[1:24:26] Sounds good to me.
[1:24:28] Yep. Yeah, I think that would be certainly supported here and I can't speak for the entire select board, but one of them has just been very vocal that he wants it to see that addressed sooner rather than later. So
[1:24:41] May I
[1:24:41] I just think it's out there that we I mean sort of to Heather's point. I mean
[1:24:47] I just think we have to move more quickly.
[1:24:50] I don't see yeah. I don't see a loss. I don't see a loss in a sunk cost to doing the planning phase. I think timing of that when we actually need to construct that may change by a couple years, but I think I think what Dave's put out here is probably the long-term the furthest outside
[1:25:10] timeline 2 to 3 years when we would envision going forward with it adding staffing around the clock. So it definitely meets that goal, but there are there are a few situations so let's get to the ambulance discussion in a second, but the ambulance discussion would push this forward could push this forward a couple different scenarios.
[1:25:31] Like next summer.
[1:25:32] Potentially as soon as next summer. Yeah. So and then the week it could push forward just not even the ambulance discussion. We could push it forward because of needs because of a change to the ambulance situation that doesn't involve adding staffing to the departments, but we might need people on it certain times to support a different option that's chosen, too. So, the sooner than 3 years.
[1:25:52] So, I don't think that 's bad to discuss doing the design work now because I don't think you're losing I don't think Does anybody think we're losing we're blowing money cuz I don't see a situation like within 5 3 to 5 years where we don't need that study for doing construction work.
[1:26:11] Unless the fire department moves to a different location.
[1:26:13] That is a scenario I don't think anyone's I don't think there's any plan to relocate Village Fire Department in the next 5 years, and I don't think there's any plan to relocate Beach Fire Department. Jeff and I have talked about long-term the long-term viability of the Beach location, and again, for the record, we're talking tens of years out, but is that the correct location long-term for York Beach, and is it for both flood reasons, for traffic reasons, and for central kind of being central to your service area?
[1:26:43] York's has the bigger question mark. But, it's not an immediate I just want to be on the record it's not in the 5-year plan. It's probably not in a 10-year plan, but it is in that kind of horizon that we would start asking those questions, I would think. Does that match your
[1:26:57] Yes, absolutely.
[1:26:58] Yeah.
[1:26:59] So, you just said what that York Village, at least for the next 5 years, will not be moving. So, that time frame for a building and this sort of thing seems awfully short. Is there a chance that in year six York Village Fire Department's not there?
[1:27:15] There's no plan to relocate York Village Fire Department, but yes.
[1:27:18] 5 years is sort of surprised me a little.
[1:27:21] No, there is no plan to move There is
[1:27:24] Because they're talking about a 5-year capital plan.
[1:27:25] We've Yeah, that's exactly why I said 5. We have never had a discussion about relocating Village at this time. I know there've been discussions
[1:27:33] No, but it's a 5-year time horizon.
[1:27:35] No, but I but I'm disclaiming I'm disclaiming the discussion about Beach with there we do need That's why I asked that question when we talked about generator cuz the lifespan of a generator might be within That's what we're having this these meetings for is to make sure we're not making bad investments. In 20 years, we do need to start asking that question and that's not something that would if you were saying I'm putting something that's got a 30-year lifespan at Beach and it's non-relocatable, I might say we might want to wait until we have a long-term
[1:28:03] horizon there. I have no issue with spending money [clears throat] on Village. to be clear, there is no plan to relocate Village fire station. It has not been discussed. People have conceptually discussed it, would it be better in different locations before, but there's not any real work that's gone into or any plan. Unless I'm missing something, Dave, or any of your members of your department.
[1:28:23] of my mouth.
[1:28:23] Okay, good.
[1:28:24] So, when we had DPW here, there was a capital budget request for funds to upgrade their facility.
[1:28:34] Yep.
[1:28:34] And because of the nature of their facility and you brought up sprinkler issue, there might be others, an upgrade to Village fire, perhaps, requires a first step of some engineering architectural study, call it what you want, before you move to construction as opposed to the DPW
[1:28:56] request, which as I recall, was to allocate money to do the work.
[1:29:02] Yep.
[1:29:02] Right? So, is that the case and are they sufficiently different that this proposed approach makes sense for this facility as opposed to the proposed approach for DPW because in a sense, we're talking about the same issue of working conditions for our employees
[1:29:23] Yep.
[1:29:23] that you highlighted the DPW and this really is about working conditions for our employees sort of at whatever staffing
[1:29:34] I would I would say
[1:29:35] level where okay at our current staffing level, but [1:29:39] The biggest difference is that it's living quarters at the fire station, which have very different
[1:29:46] which have which have very different code requirements for sleeping quarters. For fire for sprinklers, for alarms, for all that kind of stuff. Pretty much I'll say it in a non-fire inspector way, so tell me if I say anything illegal so that'll get us in trouble, but if it's not a place where someone's sleeping, where there are people sleeping full-time, the standards, people, fire inspectors, code people look at that very differently cuz you're awake and alert, or at least someone in the building is awake and alert and supposed to be there in an operating An office facility has fire standards.
[1:30:15] are apples and oranges, is what I Or is Or maybe there's some overlap cuz we're talking about working conditions for employees, but
[1:30:26] I don't know what this building you're talking about, but if it's going up going multiple
[1:30:29] This is fun.
[1:30:30] All right. is it going up multiple floors or is just expanding out? If you to put a sprinkler system in there, it would only do protect your investment.
[1:30:40] Yeah, that was that was a little bit It was a little bit undefined as well, I guess, is kind of what I'm feeling. These were This was Sounded like the DPW one was
[1:30:52] had just was just a throw it against the wall, quite honestly, and
[1:30:55] too. And I think your point is
[1:30:57] That's and that is my point, but then I'm thinking through that these are different situations, but [1:31:04] Should they both be construction, is what you're asking?
[1:31:06] I'm not sure. I'm I'm I'm I'm just still processing.
[1:31:09] My name is sleeping quarters, you know, people sleeping there at night, they have them waking up in the middle of the night out of a dead sleep to go to emergency calls. Have to worry about them tripping falling downstairs, lights coming down to the light spots, the sprinkler system like as we talked about, there's many much more to it when you have got people sleeping overnight.
[1:31:29] So, the difference So, what Tim is contemplating is a rehab of existing space for public works, a refinish, which I think to get to the working conditions part of it, there's rough finishes, and you know, it's not the in the best condition all of the components. a major rehab to a structural component being the roof, and then a potential expansion to add additional room.
[1:31:53] So, there's three components to that, but two of them are they would not be any significant change to may not include any significant change to the layout, things like that. So, what we're talking about here is would be a substantial change to layout, relocating certain parts of the building into different areas. mainly the upstairs and the downstairs living quarters and the office quarters would be what's in play.
[1:32:16] That's really what you have for free space over there. and Tim's was absolutely thrown at the wall at the last minute cuz I asked him to include it so it could be discussed because I know people had made requests about living conditions last year and it need to be addressed. Or not living can working conditions, so this
[1:32:37] is very flexible and not to be intentionally vague, but it's very flexible depending on the outcome of your staffing level discussion, which is up in the air right now. I mean, for example, a forced increase in staffing addition, if you need to add people, this has to be addressed in year one, the entire component. Might not be $250,000, but whatever that amount needs to be
[1:32:57] Where's the other 200?
[1:32:59] It's in out here. It's for construction, yeah.
[1:33:01] It's not in this.
[1:33:02] Yeah.
[1:33:02] But it's here. It's here..
[1:33:04] yeah.
[1:33:04] Thanks.
[1:33:05] 100,000 fiscal year 2019, 100,000 fiscal year
[1:33:08] And David broke this out this way last year as well, but it was not done in year one.
[1:33:13] a priority last year. It was we could do it in a stage effort. Now it's a priority.
[1:33:18] Yeah, with the understanding I know we talked about this last year and you kind of put the years two, three, and four as getting this done as hey, you might want need to move these out based on staffing level discussions. I said noted. I think you were very clear about that.
[1:33:29] the purpose of this working group is to give you feedback. And then you're going to develop the plan and bring it back to the select board say in December. So, do you have the feedback you're looking for this purpose? I mean, I don't see this group as making decisions.
[1:33:48] We're just kind of throwing out responses based on right?
[1:33:52] That's what it's for, yeah.
[1:33:53] Yeah, so are we good or
[1:33:56] Unless anybody has anything burning they need to add for this, yeah.
[1:33:59] Not meaning to step in on Dave's time, but just to clarify for Beach Fire in the living quarters. Beach Fire is ready for a second When I say ready two-part, we're ready in terms of call volume and need. We need a second person on the floor down there. We need two firefighters on duty. Which would be an additional four positions, which I asked for last year, but it never made it through the process.
[1:34:20] We are semi-ready in terms of accommodating that second person. There are some shortish set, you know we could get by for a year. If we're going beyond that, we might need to do a bathroom renovation, put some sliding doors in some of the bedrooms. [1:34:41] If the ambulance comes to Beach Fire at some point in time I think at absolute minimum we need to have the living accommodations on the docket to accommodate three to four people. For the when I say long-term, 5 years out from now. So, just
[1:35:02] food for thought, if we're going to have somebody take a look at Village Fire to accommodate four, it might behoove us to have them look at Beach Fire as well and say if four is our anticipated number 5 years out from now, three to four, it just might be good to do that all at once.
[1:35:18] Yeah, I've definitely noted that your good your I'm good situation is only for adding an additional person.
[1:35:23] We could we could do it, you know, in a pinch, but it's not ideal. but I think that if if we get down the road and it looks like an ambulance is coming to the fire station eventually, it might be good now to figure out what our plan is to accommodate the three to four-person model.
[1:35:39] Yeah, and that would be included in if that happens in the next year, that would have to be included in year one.
[1:35:43] Correct. So, I just didn't want to leave that out and then be back here next year and have you guys saying, "Why didn't you mention that last year when Village Fire said they needed some accommodations?" So, [1:35:52] Yep.
[1:35:53] I think it would be good to take a look at.
[1:35:54] So, let's talk about ambulance contingency cuz there's two parts. Can we have that discussion real quickly? So, there's two I don't want to throw hard numbers out, but I want to have everybody know what the thought process is and you can give me feedback. There's two components to it. The first not talking about operating, which is a staffing discussion. Not talking about fuel, not talking about you know, operating supplies, all that kind of stuff.
[1:36:16] We're talking about capital items. there's two components. One is building. So, Village Fire has a would have a significant required component to a building project. You just heard from Jeff what his breakpoint would be a little bit different, but long-term there'd be some upgrades needed. But, you're you would have a significant relocate, rehab, relocation
[1:36:37] of living quarters within your building that would be done. doesn't have to be a significant construction project, but it would be change of the layout that you have now and utilizing different space. So, that's part one that would be included in an ambulance contingency funding. Part two is the financial purchase of vehicles. So, there we've had a ton of discussions about do we get used equipment, new equipment?
[1:37:01] The worst I think the best way to keep this in all of our minds is the worst-case scenario of having and I don't mean bad, but a worst-case financial scenario. the most expensive case scenario would be adding two vehicles that were new and the upper threshold for that at current dollars, as I've been told to say, is in the 500,000 per range.
[1:37:23] Might be lower for smaller ambulances needed at Beach, for example, but the largest ambulance, the heaviest-duty ambulance with the required equipment that we need to add, which are a few components like a stretcher, power stretcher, chair stair chair, that kind of stuff would be in the 500,000 per range for each. So, the way to break that down is 500,000 per ambulance as a bond appropriation
[1:37:47] in year one with multi-year, you know, at a whatever the going bond rate is or a lease purchase, which is in the 4 to 5% range of 115,000 per year over 5 years, that which could be added into the operating budget component. So, that's that's what's bouncing around my head right now. I know we're not at that decision-making phase, but you guys have heard that from me.
[1:38:09] Everyone at the tables kind of now hearing that. So, what we're talking about in year one if in a worst-case financial scenario saying you need to provide ambulance service out of a fire station would be the building upgrades that Dave and Jeff had just talked about and potentially $230,000
[1:38:29] operating for a lease purchase in year one would be the cheapest that it could go or we could decide to bond for ambulance purchases. And I use those numbers cuz they're the big scary numbers and not the we're going discount shopping for three used ambulances that we're going to need to be patching together all the time and that's like the big picture we're buying all new equipment picture.
[1:38:50] So.
[1:38:51] And to be clear or maybe to ask a question.
[1:38:54] Yeah.
[1:38:55] Are we anticipating that the May 2027 vote if we need the ambulance contingency will happen then? So, we're going to be approving that capital before March?
[1:39:06] It could. Yep. Yeah, so in a scenario where we're expecting to start that July 1, which is a very compressed and probably not the most likely scenario at this point, that could be in front of you guys in December or January for the budget committee, December for the select board to talk about.
[1:39:25] And then obviously operating-wise, the additional staffing and the additional revenue that we would generate if we were running an ambulance operation with a offsetting revenue would also be discussed at that time.
[1:39:38] They're they're small There's a small number of items that would be on the table, but they're large in cost.
[1:39:46] Does anybody want more detail on that or I think I'm jumping the gun? I just want to throw it out here that if you know, in a month you hear hey, there's hundreds of thousands of dollars into this that we didn't discuss, that's where it's coming from.
[1:40:01] We have a vote on Tuesday for the near term.
[1:40:04] Yep.
[1:40:04] And we have a study underway that we should get the results by mid-November. To me, those are the near term goal posts, and then we go from there.
[1:40:13] It's really going to steer where that discussion goes, 100%. Yep. Okay. Anything you guys need to add to that? Does that
[1:40:20] I would add to Marla's time frame that I think tonight York Village Fire Department Corporation is voting on loaning Isn't it Thursday night?
[1:40:32] Or is it next Thursday?
[1:40:33] Next Thursday next week and
[1:40:35] Okay. for the SBA loan, which to me is another big huge trigger for what happens
[1:40:43] the ambulance future.
[1:40:47] Good luck.
[1:40:49] Thank you.
[1:40:51] So, is that a week from Thursday? Week from today?
[1:40:53] Just Thursday.
[1:40:54] Thursday at noon.
[1:40:55] Oh.
[1:40:56] Be brought up after the vote results are known, cuz it's kind of dependent on what the future is of the vote. Yep. So.
[1:41:06] Well, I mean Yeah.
[1:41:09] Okay. Thanks, guys.
[1:41:12] Thank you.
[1:41:15] Hey, did anybody have any problem moving forward on some additional town items so we get them off the list? Okay. And Nicole here, hers is kind of dumped on her by me. You're welcome, Nicole. the cliff path.
[1:41:36] I'll do them. Yeah. And we'll wait till everyone comes back in the room. How about that? All right, any questions? No? All right.
[1:41:42] Sounds great. Thanks.
[1:41:44] [laughter]
[1:41:46] Cliff path.
[1:41:46] I think I have it already.
[1:41:47] Yeah, you do have it already. I have it already, too.
[1:41:51] Okay.
[1:42:04] Do you want going us for 2 minutes and just, yeah.
[1:43:27] All right, back on. Thank you everyone. Yes. Should we go there? All right, so Cliff Walk, this is do you have the actual supporting materials cuz I know at least two people might want to grab the studies cuz Wayne and Heather have not received this. You might have heard about it. So, we're talking about the Cliff Walk path.
[1:43:50] [1:43:53] Yeah. So, I put in the executive summary and kind of Nicole had put in some of the history of the options that were presented to the select board. so, this is an outgrowth of the presentation that was done, the study that was done over the summer, structural study, and the engineering work of like, "Hey, what how much of this can be rebuilt and how much of it can be
[1:44:14] is going to be a massive project versus just a structural surface repair. And I think 5.9 million was the number that was thrown if we want to do a full resilient repair of the cliff walk path meaning address all of the underlying issues and rebuild the surface to similar to what is there now to the the sewer pump station.
[1:44:38] Yeah and that number is inclusive of a 20% overall placeholder for engineering. That's typically what their fees would be to do the full design of a repair and then also a 20% contingency just for depending on how long it takes us to get to that point.
[1:44:59] For inflation.
[1:44:59] Yeah inflation and various things.
[1:45:02] So that is the full repair. So that report right there is the analysis. You can
[1:45:09] Read it at my leisure.
[1:45:10] Yeah you've you've heard about it. You've heard about it I'm sure but you haven't even experienced to its full greatness. So Wayne now you have it too. You can have fun with that. But the question is also is an option less than a full rebuild. So that's been circulated quite a bit. We've had discussions at the select board level. The public debates that and deliberates on that as I understand
[1:45:33] regularly we hear from people why aren't you just doing this to this point which is different than the point that we've chosen. You know we get those kind of comments. Why aren't you going a half mile in and stopping there? Why aren't you going all the way? Why aren't you going past the sewer pump station which is not on the table right now. so the I mean that really boils down to Do you want to talk about the first the lower
[1:45:54] option?
[1:45:55] Yeah so the lower option would be going up to There is not an exit point but I use where starboard lane ends as kind of the marker for roughly how far down we would go. Select board members snow cuz it's been a conversation often but there is a little kind of overlook area out there that could be something that's an easy geographic ending point
[1:46:22] and so it would be an out and back so up to that point turn around come back these repairs are inclusive of the washout that we were aware of as well as the revetment that we found to be severely undermined it wasn't anything that we would have been able to tell easily they found it from a very small hole that you could see if you climbed all the way down to the bottom of it and then it goes feet and feet back
[1:46:53] it's hollow essentially.
[1:46:55] It's like a camera like a telescope is that how they found that?
[1:46:58] Yeah they were just poking every little hole they could find and they kept going on that one and that is inclusive of all needed possible repairs including small ones areas that they said you know this isn't an undermined section right now but it is now vulnerable to become undermined so that would make it so that and same with the large number that's inclusive of all extensive repairs
[1:47:23] to make sure that we're really sturdy no matter what pathway we go yeah so that's that one including you know even some of the paved area that we paved recently obviously the water comes up there often so it's something that there's some stuff that they can do there as well but that's the first option.
[1:47:44] That's 900 and sub 950,000 at current prices.
[1:47:49] Yep.
[1:47:52] All right that's estimated at sub 950,000.
[1:47:56] I'm looking at the project submission form and you've got it at the full 5.9 million and you also have a priority ranking of must do which would be an indication that not completing this project will lead to potential life safety issues damage to property or legal compliance issues and I wonder if somebody can explain why must do was chosen as a priority for this proposed $5.9 million project.
[1:48:22] I've a guess, but do you want to
[1:48:24] Yes, so for that one it's because it's a FEMA project. So it's
[1:48:27] Can you speak more to those how that how that works?
[1:48:31] Yep. So with the FEMA funding so this was obviously damaged by a storm. So we've submitted it as part of the public assistance grant process to be able to be reimbursed for repairs.
[1:48:46] We have timelines that they put on repair method for repairs to be conducted. Typically it's 18 months from the start or from the declaration date that they want permanent repairs to be completed. You do have the option to get extensions on those. This storm is obviously from 2024 January.
[1:49:09] So it's been 18 months more. We do have a current extension on it right now to what that was allowing us to get all of the reports that we have now. The next extension that we would be requesting for is going to be for the construction of it. They will tell us though that it is ineligible if we are sitting on it for reasons that are within our control.
[1:49:34] There are some things that they allow if it's anything that's out of our control that we weren't able to get to it. They don't allow lack of funding or just a choice a personal choice to be a reason that we are not actively repairing it because their mindset behind that is that if you are not getting to it now making it a priority then it's not a priority enough for
[1:50:01] FEMA funding to be allocated to it.
[1:50:04] You got it.
[1:50:05] So when does our current extension expire?
[1:50:10] Till the end of the year.
[1:50:12] 12:31
[1:50:13] Yeah.
[1:50:15] And we had talked a likely decision-making time frame of this being with the budget process this year. If we go beyond that, they would likely deny any future extensions because it's not a priority.
[1:50:29] Yes.
[1:50:30] We now have all the information, the cost estimate, and if we make a decision not to budget for it, they'll wipe that off of the project list.
[1:50:37] Yes. If we advance the smaller project at the lower dollar amount, does it qualify for any amount of FEMA funding?
[1:50:45] Yes, the smaller amount would.
[1:50:46] The smaller amount would?
[1:50:47] Yes, yep, yeah. So, that is still considered an area that is part of the
[1:50:51] Not just the big one, but the small one as well.
[1:50:53] Correct, yep.
[1:50:54] At the same at the same amount?
[1:50:56] Yes, yeah. So, we could, go to them and say, "We've decided that we're going to secure it at Starboard Lane. We're going to allow the rest to go with nature, and we're making sure that any of the our previous access points are secured for public safety, so that nobody's getting down there, and that we're only fixing this part." So, they would look at just that section for how much they would allocate for that.
[1:51:20] from that section. So, it's not exactly proportional, but it's only the parts that are tied to that repaired section.
[1:51:26] Yes, yep.
[1:51:27] And is it a hope and a prayer and 7 years later that we get the money, or what's the
[1:51:31] So, this would, it would be dependent on what the actual overall cost ends up being. Right now, the, dollar amount limit for what makes it what FEMA calls a large project is just over a million dollars. So, anything below that is a project that once you get through all of the approvals and everything, which can take some certain times depending on the scope of the project, then the project would be obligated and pushed for payment
[1:52:01] prior to the project being completed potentially. It's not that they will pay you before your project is completed, it's that your project doesn't need to be completed to be paid. So, like with Long Sands sea wall, that's a large project, and so with those, they will not pay until you have your final bill submitted to them.
[1:52:22] That's super helpful.
[1:52:24] Can I ask how much is the matching funds?
[1:52:27] So it's a 75% from the federal and then the state pays 15, so we end up paying 10.
[1:52:36] And if we don't there will be no state or federal money if we delay too far any changes would be all on the town's budget.
[1:52:46] Correct.
[1:52:47] And I think it's this too far is this budget cycle.
[1:52:50] Yes.
[1:52:51] In your judgment.
[1:52:52] Yeah.
[1:52:52] Yeah. I would agree. At that point it becomes we're not making a decision.
[1:52:59] Yes, and FEMA is getting really strict right now [1:53:03] About timelines.
[1:53:03] about timelines on everything. They're not they're not liking timeline extensions There is no rule for how many extensions you can request or if they have to approve them. It is kind of up to the discussion of those who are in charge of the region at the time. We haven't had issues in the past, but my discussions with the state as of even just last week is that they're really pushing to be closing things out because they want to be able to put that stamp
[1:53:33] of look what we've done and put that out there and closed out storms. This storm specifically is not as much of an issue right now because it's only 2 years old, so we have that working for us. but it's just something to keep in our minds.
[1:53:47] What is the length of this? Would it from her from the parking lot to Starboard?
[1:53:52] Well, that's on page 457 in the attached report.
[1:53:54] I don't know if I have that written down easily.
[1:53:56] Sorry, it's not
[1:53:56] [laughter]
[1:53:57] I don't see it in the executive
[1:53:58] Yeah, I don't think I have that part [1:54:01] I can GIS it if you want to give me a second.
[1:54:03] I'm just I guess I'm curious because you know, as I think about the support for this and the fundraising opportunities for example, do they diminish? Does people's interest diminish as the path gets shorter?
[1:54:20] Yeah.
[1:54:21] I think is where I'm curious.
[1:54:25] Is it still like enough of a length to go out and say, "Yeah, this is for me, you know, this is what I did when I [snorts] was a kid." And do you still feel like I'm on the Cliffwalk, or does it like, "Well, now I'm here in front of the reading room, and now I'm turning around."
[1:54:37] Cuz yeah, Starboard Lane does angle back.
[1:54:39] Mhm.
[1:54:40] It does seem like though the choice between doing nothing and closing completely and doing some of it and getting most of the funding now and not a not another chance to do it, that seems like some amount of support could be
[1:55:01] could be raised for some part of this the most crucial parts of it. My second question is there private property that's also in danger there if this work isn't done?
[1:55:14] Oh, certainly. I mean, some of a lot of what it is that we're talking about is retaining walls. so, you know, if a retaining wall starts to fail, then the ocean's still going to be going up that way, so eventually it's it's working its way of damaging people's private property as it moves inland.
[1:55:32] Also something to be made very clear when talking about it in the future.
[1:55:37] Yeah, we'd hate to open it up and then a private landowner be like, "Oh, forget it. You can't actually cross this nice new walkway."
[1:55:43] No.
[1:55:44] You know.
[1:55:45] Or sue the town for not
[1:55:49] doing something.
[1:55:50] The town is protected in that sense. we've looked into it in that [clears throat] with these types of [1:56:01] with how we had the Cliffwalk established in the first place, it's more that it allows the town to access it and repair it if we choose so, but it does not make it the town responsible for repairing it. Correct. Yes, it actually makes neither party obligated to repair it.
[1:56:21] Is there an argument for cuz I had the same question about private landowners to chip in for some like the reading room for example.
[1:56:35] If that wall goes away, chances are their building goes away.
[1:56:38] Yeah.
[1:56:39] You know, is there a potential private partnership with some of the residents or the owners on that on that cliff walk to be able to help offset some of the work?
[1:56:52] I mean, it's certainly something that could be argued. I don't know the logistics of that in terms of financing everything as well as if they're paying for then do they have say over how the town runs access and everything? That's That's a lot of conversations and yes, yeah, a little sticky. but certainly, you know, same thing of it is shoring up all of those walls and that walkway and everything is also benefiting
[1:57:20] benefiting the private property owners because then their property as well as protected.
[1:57:26] And do we have a policy
[1:57:29] of what we restore?
[1:57:31] No.
[1:57:33] So, same thing about the areas in York Beach, right? We don't necessarily have a policy that says because of these three factors, we're going to restore the wall on Ocean Ave.
[1:57:47] Yeah, I mean, we have general kind of maintenance policies. public works has one that they're responsible for maintaining you know, public infrastructure and all of that. this is slightly different because it's a recreational pathway. So, you know, versus Ocean Avenue extension seawall that we're redoing,
[1:58:07] that if we don't redo it, we'll lose the roadway. So, we have that extra added responsibility of ensuring that we're protecting the roadway and there's a sewer line that goes through that one.
[1:58:17] But are we obligated as a town to So, let's say we lose some more, you know, it's let's say on the the north end of Long Beach, right? Those cliffs continue to disintegrate, at what point is the town responsible for fixing those cliffs? Do we have
[1:58:36] So, those ones we're not because that's all private property.
[1:58:38] They never When it hits the roadway.
[1:58:40] When it hits the roadway.
[1:58:41] When the first layer of houses are in the ocean and hits the roadway, you have to make a decision of whether you build a retaining wall to save the road or discontinue the road and only have Noble access from the Broadway.
[1:58:50] So, the difference
[1:58:51] might be 500 years from now, but that's the right decision the town will have to make.
[1:58:55] I'm just getting to the point where it's unclear to me about what the policy like what the direction in the policy is, which feels like which is the reason why I didn't vote for that particular item. And so, this just brings up another question of like, well, is it our policy to fix things before property and
[1:59:13] No.
[1:59:14] No.
[1:59:14] falls in the ocean or
[1:59:16] for that one and correct me, I don't think there is a recreational policy. You know, we have the one for infrastructure, but I don't believe we have one for recreational services.
[1:59:27] Yeah, there's no there's no requirement or even policy or even practice that would that would, you know, past practice that could say at least be consistent, somebody could argue to be consistent with generally that a town or city cares when it hits a facility, whether that's a waterline, a sewer line, a bridge, or a roadway, or sidewalk, that 's when people
[1:59:52] that's when you have to cuz that's when you have to make the decision, do we discontinue the facility we have there because it's been retaken by the elements or do we or do we harden it so that it will survive future impacts, or do we do something different? So.
[2:00:04] so to play it that out then, make sure I understand you, theoretically, those houses that I was just mentioning on the big cliff between Cutty Sark and the lighthouse, the town with its current philosophy would not step in until the road is about to fall in.
[2:00:24] Correct. I don't think any I don't think any municipality would or government would for private Unless there's a facility underneath So, you see this in the West Coast right now with what's going on. So, Malibu and you know, all the areas with drop-offs, where they have public beach facilities below, you see expenditures on replenishment of the beaches or hardening the beachfront, but then with the double benefit of, you know, the $15 million house that's on the cliff above it also receives some benefit from that.
[2:00:52] There has to be a public reason to expend the funds for us. So, it's got to be you know, absent a vote from everyone saying, "Yes, spend all of my our public tax money on saving this shoreland on a private shore." That would be a That would be a really big.
[2:01:08] Yeah, so basically, if this was not a public walkway, a public recreational pathway, we wouldn't be having this discussion. Yeah.
[2:01:15] Ocean Ave. Sorry, go ahead, Marla.
[2:01:17] so, the voters previously approved $180,000 for this project. How much of that has been spent? How much remains?
[2:01:25] so, we for the report for getting this, we pulled that out of the Sorry, disaster assistance funds. So, we haven't spent any of that yet.
[2:01:35] So, the 180 remains.
[2:01:37] Yes.
[2:01:38] if we move forward with the smaller project at 937,000, let's call it 950 or a million or whatever. and we feel good about and we get a FEMA obligation, that would leave the town's exposure on that to 100,000. So, we sort of already have the funding.
[2:01:59] Am I thinking of that correctly?
[2:02:01] We have to spend the money up front, but the long-term Yes, the long-term net we've already spent.
[2:02:10] Yes.
[2:02:10] When you say spent
[2:02:11] Well, not spent have.
[2:02:12] Not spent.
[2:02:12] Appropriated, I'm sorry. Encumbered and appropriated. We have raised the money for the town's portion in the end already.
[2:02:19] Already voter approved for this project and
[2:02:22] So, just using Nicole's numbers, assuming they're true, which is always dangerous when we're talking about assistance money, 10% being local, we already have more than 10% of the cost in hand. We would need to
[2:02:33] That's my That's Yeah.
[2:02:34] We would need to raise and appropriate the money to do the 100 to do the million-dollar repair if we did the shorter amount net of the 180, but that would come back to the town assuming everything
[2:02:46] goes as planned.
[2:02:47] Which is always dangerous. More than we've already
[2:02:50] Before the warrant before we all go through our process in the spring, you're going to know if you have a further extension.
[2:02:59] Yes.
[2:03:00] And if so, to when?
[2:03:02] So, that's where it gets a little tricky right now just with the way that they've been acting in the past couple of weeks. with these larger projects, what we've been working on has been getting an extension until the point of where we're currently at. So, I'll use Ocean Ave extension as an example because it's an easy one.
[2:03:25] we had an extension that was through our anticipated bid. So, I had an extension that goes until next month because we were anticipating a bid going out in October originally. We got it out a little early. So, I just submitted the final extension for that based off of what the contractor's schedule is. So, they like to have a confident reason for your extension.
[2:03:48] could request an extension to June because that would be right after the vote, at which time we would know
[2:03:54] Yep.
[2:03:55] whether we had voter approval, or you could request a longer-term extension to cover both the votes, sort of a milestone-based, both the vote and
[2:04:05] date
[2:04:05] and
[2:04:06] Yep.
[2:04:06] Yeah, all that sort of thing.
[2:04:08] is in what you just said about milestones is the important component. We have got to tie it to something.
[2:04:13] But I guess what I wanted to flush out is we already have voter approved and appropriated what in a best-case scenario for the small project would be the town's 10% responsibility. However, what I'm also hearing is that the town would have to front the entire cost of the project and rely on FEMA
[2:04:34] state and federal reimbursement for 90% of it.
[2:04:38] Yes. Yeah.
[2:04:39] Very
[2:04:39] But the idea of an obligation maybe could be one of our triggers as to whether like we're not going to go forward with this unless we get their obligation. It's a little bit chicken and egg, but I don't know if it could play out that way.
[2:04:52] Yeah, so it can't play out that we don't go forward if we don't get obligation. That's very clearly stated in their rules that you can't make completing a project conditional upon getting the approval of FEMA. and then the other aspect is in order to get that approval, we'll need a full design to have all the details of
[2:05:15] the plan of what the repairs are looking like in terms of time, materials, all of that so that they can cost estimate it and then go through the cost reasonableness processes that they go through to see if they will get to obligation. So, that's going to be the step that we have to do next is getting that full design.
[2:05:36] you can go with design build from a contractor if that's the pathway that we want to go. there 's some options there or you can hire an engineer separately to do the design and then
[2:05:47] saying that the voters would have to step up for with a sort of an unconditional commitment to an additional 800,000.
[2:05:54] Yes.
[2:05:54] Approximately.
[2:05:54] Yeah.
[2:05:55] Okay. That's what I wanted to flush out.
[2:05:57] Yeah, and would you imagine that comes from fund balance knowing that it might not because why would we bond a project if we're actually we've already paid we're going to get repaid for it.
[2:06:07] See well.
[2:06:09] But we're talking about a much shorter time frame here.
[2:06:12] I wouldn't anticipate that coming from fund balance cuz I don't think we have that money in fund balance to con- at least our initial productions.
[2:06:20] Yeah.
[2:06:20] Especially if Tuesday passes.
[2:06:22] [laughter]
[2:06:22] Assuming Tuesday passes, we don't have we 800,000 for other I mean
[2:06:28] Let's look at Wendy for that one.
[2:06:30] [laughter]
[2:06:34] But that seems like a high number for generally what I've seen you guys do with fund balance.
[2:06:38] [laughter]
[2:06:38] But to get to the question of bond, yeah, then you run you run it so you could tax appropriated or you could bond it. I mean, those are kind of you could bond it for a very short period of time.
[2:06:50] We could do a shorter payback schedule, which would Yeah, which would reduce the interest payments and lower interest rate as well.
[2:06:57] And what do they expect usually a time frame for a payback? Like within a year?
[2:07:00] There is not a standard one. Yeah, so when I have really small projects, they come a lot quicker usually. They're coming within 6 months of the storm, like the smaller road repairs, things like that. it has only been 2 years since they changed the It's large project threshold used to only be about 150,000.
[2:07:20] So, anything over 150,000. But now with these small projects being so large and expensive, I mean, a million-dollar project can easily be any form of a type of project that could take 2 or more years to get done. and so, we don't have that precedent yes yet to know with these larger
[2:07:41] end of the small projects, how long payments will take. because typically before they were smaller projects that didn't take a lot of details and engineering work and things like that. but now they potentially can be.
[2:07:57] Ocean Ave extension going well?
[2:07:59] Yeah.
[2:08:00] Nice work.
[2:08:01] We're sourcing stone.
[2:08:02] [laughter]
[2:08:02] I just like to say I It's your It's your plan and your recommendation, but I'm not supportive of 5.9 million, but the smaller amount, putting it before the voters, is something I think
[2:08:14] I At a minimum, yeah, at a minimum, I think there'll there'll be a question put There will be a proposal put forward by me. I so I would say at a minimum, the lowest option that I can find is that. So, if it goes higher than that, would be something that would be discussed with the other three select board members and the two that are in the room if there's support for a 5 million-dollar question or if we just leave it at one.
[2:08:35] It'll be one of the two. So.
[2:08:36] Yeah, and we put this in here. Peter and I talked about it of putting highest case scenario for now knowing that it needs to be something to be talked about at this or that level as well.
[2:08:49] was asked about length. Was that your question, Wayne? 1/4 mile to the first stop point, 1/2 mile to the second stop point. So, it's almost exactly half.
[2:08:59] Okay. So, it'd be a 1/2 mile total at the parking
[2:09:03] From the loop at the parking lot.
[2:09:04] the parking lot.
[2:09:05] So, that's counting the parts that are over Hardy Mason in the reading room as well. But, it's a it's a 1/4 mile walk from parking
[2:09:11] Mhm.
[2:09:12] by the restrooms there to the turnaround. It's probably an 1/8 of a mile to the reading room, another 1/8 of a mile after that, and then a 1/2 mile further to get to the sewage pump station. If that's the longest potential stop.
[2:09:25] And the 5.9 is for how much of it?
[2:09:27] The whole thing.
[2:09:28] From the parking lot up to Millbury where the sewage pump station is.
[2:09:31] 1/2 mile.
[2:09:32] Okay.
[2:09:32] So, a million dollars for the first 1/4 mile, and then the second 1/4 mile would be $4 million.
[2:09:36] Mhm.
[2:09:38] Which is about where all the damage was.
[2:09:40] Yeah, and because that has
[2:09:41] with the amount of damage.
[2:09:43] three to four times larger retaining wall as well as the walkway itself on that second half of it is
[2:09:52] concrete
[2:09:53] all concrete on top of the bedrock versus the first half you're kind of up in the trees a little bit, so it's just nature.
[2:10:00] And the fact that is if it's decided place to stop, you've that includes some of the most dramatic parts of it because it's up high, it's got a steep drop-off. So, as far as if it comes to a little better than nothing, at least that is a very attractive dramatic and you're talking about with that overlook.
[2:10:28] That is a very dramatic part of the of the path.
[2:10:31] Yeah, I agree.
[2:10:32] Yeah.
[2:10:33] So, All right, everyone's comfortable with the minimum. You know a minimum project will be going forward, and maybe a larger one will but that'll be subject to further discussion if that happens.
[2:10:45] Okay.
[2:10:46] We are at
[2:10:48] 12:18
[2:10:48] 12:18, 12:20. I have down IT and planning. However, the planning one has several items that may invoke further discussion. Do we want to wait on those and do them all at a future date?
[2:11:02] Yes.
[2:11:02] Okay. Sounds good.
[2:11:05] Thank you.
[2:11:06] Thank you, guys.
[2:11:07] Best decision today.
[2:11:08] So, adjourned at 12:18.