← Back to MaineScanner

Berwick Planning Board Reviews Mineral Extraction Application Amid Concerns

2026-11-05 · 2h 37m · Source: Planning Board Meeting • November 5, 2026 (Berwick BCTV22 (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:15] [music] [0:27] I [0:39] [music] [0:47] [music] [2:45] The [3:00] [music] [3:06] [music] [4:55] This [4:59] [music] [5:20] [music] [10:37] I [18:48] Good evening, everybody. Welcome to the town of Berwick's planning board meeting for Thursday, November 5th. If you could all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Thank you. [19:00] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [19:20] All right. I'd like to introduce my board members tonight. To my left, we have Jeff, George, Rick, who is the vice chair. To my right, we have Niles and Daniel. We've got Terry Wilson, our code enforcement officer, and James Belissimo, our town planner here tonight. And we will have Mike Zarba from SLR on Zoom soon, I imagine. [19:44] First item on the agenda is the approval of minutes from the October 29th meeting. Has everybody had a chance to read those? You have? The only amendment that I would like It's not really an Well, I guess it is. We're changing it. I would like to be entered into the record at the end of those minutes [20:05] the email correspondence that took place between the board members this week just in the air of transparency. [20:15] Okay. [20:17] For the form? [20:18] For the minutes. Oh, just at the end cuz we were talking in our minutes we were talking about the third party review, and there was a few reply all's emails, and I think those should be entered into the record. [20:31] Okay. [20:33] Any other amendments? [20:35] [clears throat] All right. I need a motion to approve. [20:38] I will make a motion to approve the amended minutes. [20:42] Okay. [20:43] I'll second. [20:44] All right. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? [20:48] All in favor? Great. Thank you. Moving on to the first public comment. Public comment is limited to anything under the purview of the Berwick Planning Board. If you are a homeowner in the town of Berwick and it would have to be something that is not an agenda item. So nothing that you see on this piece of paper or that's an open agenda item for us at the moment. [21:14] but if you have something else, come to the podium. [21:20] All right. Seeing nobody come, I'm going to close first public comment. We do not have a public hearing tonight. We do have unfinished business. the conditional use and site plan review, mineral extraction off Ridgeland Road, R two map R map R two 15 or lot 15 and eight. [21:41] It's in the R three and AP zone. Two Sisters Working Lands LLC. first, Daniel is going to recuse himself, and then I also have a potential conflict of interest, and I'm going to ask my board to make a decision on that. So before we begin, I would like to disclose a potential [clears throat] conflict of interest regarding this application. I'm currently the listing agent for a property in the neighborhood that's adjacent to the proposed gravel pit. [22:07] I was hired within the last two weeks. That property is considered an abutter to this application. I have no ownership interest in the property, but I do have a fiduciary relationship with the seller and a potential financial interest through real estate commission if I sell it. in the interest of transparency and in accordance with section eight of our planning board policies and procedures, [22:31] I would like the board to determine if there's a conflict of interest and that would require my recusal. So I'm going to I would like to say that I believe I can remain neutral, but I would like my board to vote on that. And so at that I'm going to turn the meeting over to the vice chair for discussion and determination. [22:59] Thank you, Nicole. So we have in front of us a discussion about Nicole recusing or not being recused from this project and I'm looking for opinions, thoughts. [23:14] So what is the standard that the town currently uses? [23:18] [clears throat] [23:18] You So the way that the board sets up recusals is if you feel like you have a an interest in the outcome of the proposed development that would either benefit you or hurt you, should request to be recused unless you feel like you can be neutral. [23:42] And that decision is made by the rest of the board. So we can make a decision to say we feel like Nicole can be neutral and remain in the discussion of this project. Or we can say we feel it's too close to home and there's potential conflict of interest, [24:03] in which case we would ask for a recusal. [24:07] Okay. [24:07] So Nicole has already said that she feels like she can be neutral and it's up to us to decide if we feel the same or feel differently. [24:17] I [clears throat] I would agree with Nicole for the following reason. This sounds like just another routine real estate transaction of which I've never kept track, but sure she has done hundreds if not thousands of them. [clears throat] I didn't hear anything that there would be a special treatment [24:37] of this transaction. I've been on this board with Nicole off and on for certainly over a dozen years. I've witnessed her performance to share. She certainly takes her obligation seriously and I am totally comfortable that she will do this appropriately [24:58] and without favor to any side of the issue. So I would vote not to re-choose her. [25:09] Okay. Thank you, Niles. [25:10] What do you think, Jeff? [25:12] I tend to lean the same way. I don't I haven't seen anything and I don't really see reason for not having him to be on this issue. [25:21] Okay. Jeff, thank you. George? [25:24] Yeah, we can vote. [25:26] All right. I actually share the opinion of Niles. I've been vice chair with Nicole for over a year and a half now and I feel like her character is unwavering when it comes to following procedure, not emotion. And our board is required to follow procedure and not become emotional or involved in projects and I've seen nothing but professionalism from Nicole, so I feel the same way. [25:53] So I'm looking for a motion to have Nicole stay on the board for this project. [26:00] So moved. [26:02] Is there a second? [26:03] I'll second. [26:04] All in favor? Opposed? Come on back, boss. [26:09] All right. [26:13] Thank you, gentlemen. [26:17] Next. [26:17] All right. So moving on to unfinished business. we have the applicant's engineer here and I and we also have so we did have a third-party review of this application and we have Mike Zarba from SLR, who is also here with us to help answer questions. Go ahead. A lot of A lot has happened since the last time we've seen you. [26:39] Yes, I just wanted to start I don't think my mic is On? Is this on? [26:42] Yeah, it probably is. It's more for the people at home. [26:45] And I just want to make sure this is a convenient space for this. I can also move it to that side. I just want everybody to be able to see. [26:51] Is it okay for you, Jeff? [26:52] Yeah, I'm fine. [26:53] And I'm Can you see me? [26:55] Yeah. [26:55] [laughter] [26:55] Okay. [26:56] Please keep your voice up. Some of us are old and have difficulty hearing. [27:01] This is for This is being tele- telecast on the Yeah. [27:05] for you to see this. I actually can't be here cuz I can't see you. [27:08] thought that would be the case. [27:09] we can move [clears throat] it sideways, that would be great. [27:11] I can move it. [27:12] Wherever [27:13] Wherever Bobby Joe says to move it is where it should go. [27:16] Yeah, it can go pretty much anywhere, but if you're going to be pointing to it, you need to have a mic. Jeff, I need you to sit up so I can hear you. [27:25] Thanks for Bobby Joe's coming out. Coming out [laughter] getting charged. [27:29] You were like chip here in Norwalk. [27:31] Seriously. Do you have a mic for her? [27:35] No. [27:35] Okay. [27:36] You can take You can take one of these. [27:37] you can take the one on the She can use the one on the end if Just if you're over here pointing. [27:42] here cuz it is recorded. [27:44] talk into that. [27:46] Do you have a pointer? [27:47] Oh, lovely. [27:49] So there's that as well if you want to [27:51] Okay. [27:51] All right. [27:54] All right. My name is Kendra Marris. I am a civil engineer and project manager with Sebagos Technics. Here on behalf of Two Sisters Working Lands LLC, who is the applicant. I guess I'll just start with an overview of where we've been and where we plan to go this evening. So we [28:15] initially introduced the project quite a while back. We then scheduled a public hearing and that was the last time we met together. Since then, we were asked to provide written responses to all public comment that was heard that night as well as respond to letters from abutters and members of the public that were concerned. [28:37] So we submitted that several months ago. and since then SLR has reviewed both our original application and the response to public comment. And after that we submitted a response to those review comments that were received. So the last packet that you received was that formal response. [28:59] we hope that we have addressed all comments to yours to be satisfactory. I can do a little overview of the of the general project if you'd like. [29:12] Yeah, cuz some things have changed actually. So please do. [29:15] pretty few changes since the public comment submission. but during that submission we had also received feedback from IFW about the turtles. And so we decided to hold a 250-ft setback on all vernal pools that were on the site. Typically just the significant vernal pools have that setback. [29:38] There are 13 vernal pools, three of which are significant, but we have put 250-ft setbacks on all of them. that was considered good by IFW. And so that reduced the extraction area from about 67 acres originally to 55. So that where we're at now. [29:57] yeah. [29:57] Yep. And this is 150-acre parcel. We're proposing to excavate the pit 10 acres at a time. So the first 10 acres will be excavated and then it will be reclaimed per our reclamation plans which have been prepared according to the performance standards in the ordinance. And then once that 10 acres is reclaimed, the operator of the pit will move on to the next 10 acres. [30:22] So what you can see on our site plan is that the 55-acre area has been split into areas that are 10 acres or less. [30:32] that's really all that's [30:34] on? [30:34] Sure. [30:35] Does that mean it's no [30:36] longer a 10-year project and it's now a 5-year project? [30:39] No. the intention is it will take at least 10 years to excavate all areas of the pit. [30:46] Well I you know I was not a math major but 10 acres at a time for 55 acres, why does that take 10 years? [30:53] So they're less than it takes a really long time to excavate 10 acres of pit area. There are seven areas shown but a lot of them are actually less than 10 acres. So that 's the math that we're talking about. 10 acres can be open at a time at a maximum but the areas that we've divided these into are a bit less than 10 acres. [31:13] Oh all right. Thank you. [31:15] Yep. so lastly some big things that have happened since we were here are that we've received our DEP permit. That's a notice of intent to comply through the Mining Bureau of DEP. that's been approved. We've provided copies of that as well as we've been approved for a permit by rule regarding the stream crossing for the access road. [31:39] So the only other permit other than a local permit is an Army Corps permit that would be required and that's for the same stream crossing. we will have to file a pre-construction notification with Army Corps but we wanted to get a little bit further in the town process before that's filed. [31:56] That makes sense. [31:57] Yep. do you have anything You had said that you had a Do you have anything for us James? [32:04] [32:05] Because we've gotten some things in we got a letter from code enforcement today. We had a letter from [32:10] There's a few letters that came in that were posted on the website. probably can go over just what Public Works [32:21] talked about. They mentioned that they're not going to be able to police the areas in question and that when the roads are posted they're not They do not want to issue special permits so the pit should be closed during the that the roads are posted. And [32:41] the public works will work with the road commissioners to place the signage. [32:46] And he didn't say anything about like and some questions came up about like wear and tear on the road or anything. I think we were really looking for some guidance on that. But there was nothing that was in this letter about excess wear and tear on Ridland Road or some kind of negative impact to the road with the extra traffic. [33:09] Yeah, I mean Ridland Road is [33:13] in pretty bad shape and obviously trucks will add wear and tear to the gravel roads. It's just a matter of I guess what the board prefers to do there. [33:29] Well, I was just hoping that's why we really wanted to lean on Jody since he's the [33:34] I would think any anything that could be established or proven as damage we'd ask the applicant to fix. It's just a matter of being able to prove that. [33:44] Mm. [33:48] If I remember correctly that's the gravel part of Ridland Road isn't that long to that entrance. [33:54] It's 700 ft. [33:56] 700 ft. [33:56] Yep. Roughly. [34:02] and then Terry had a good letter. Do you want to talk about that, Terry? [34:06] Yeah, I just had concern about how you know using the code enforcement office as a stop gap measure because we just don't have the capacity to do that. They mentioned it many times in the book very soon from policing traffic. Also reviewing reports which I wouldn't be qualified to do. [34:28] Yeah. [34:28] I don't have the expertise to look at a water quality report necessarily or an air quality report and to determine whether it was acceptable or not. So I recommend that we use third party for all of that. I'm not sure what the policing [34:49] of the you know trucks or whatever coming down the road, but it would it would put an unreasonable burden on the on the code enforcement department. I am the only code enforcement officer. [35:00] I know. We have like a one man code enforcement, one man planning department, so I get it. And you guys are I know you're you're at max capacity, so [35:07] Nicole, I can speak to some of the letters we received. We received some letters requesting private monitoring of wells. [35:14] Mhm. [35:14] And I think the applicant could speak to the monitoring well program in a minute. I can I'll just go through the some of the list of the things. [35:23] We got there's interest in air quality and establishing a baseline air quality and then ongoing monitoring of air quality. [35:40] I think there'll be probably more as we go through this. [35:46] There was another one that came in about noise and [35:52] continuous noise even below the decibel can be can provide an adverse effect. So there's obviously a we are we are held to the standards, but it's it's a discussion to have with the applicant. [36:06] Okay. I did read a few emails about monitoring having the applicant pay for private monitoring of wells. And as you heard earlier, I am a real estate agent. And as agents, we recommend that everybody I mean you're you're in charge of your own water quality, that you should really be testing your well every year regardless. [36:28] But that is something that came up in a few emails to the board, so [36:34] Excuse me. Can I just make one clarification? I just want to say that I of course the code enforcement office would respond to any complaints that came in regarding noise or you know things like that. So we would still respond to complaints, just not a not a stop-gap measure. Just to clarify. [36:53] Got it. Kendra. Any ideas on any of those things? [36:59] Sure. so I'll start with the monitoring program. it what is typical and we've described this in our response letter to SLR's memo what is typical is that with DEP we would sit down prior to construction or excavation and develop a solid monitoring plan where they would actually work with the hydrogeologist [37:21] in or geologist, I'm sorry Chris, to determine exactly where those monitoring well locations need to go. We have already placed kind of tentative locations throughout the plan for where they should go. I'm sure DEP will agree but that is typically done prior to excavation. So as part of that those are ports that are installed in the ground that allow a geologist to go out on a quarterly basis, which is what is required by DEP and check the quality and quantity [37:51] of groundwater. it also allows them to measure the groundwater elevation so that we can ensure that we are maintaining 5 ft of separation from the groundwater elevation as required by DEP and the town. So those reports so first of all before excavation occurs that baseline quality and quantity test and groundwater elevation will be recorded and submitted to DEP. [38:16] And then as I mentioned on a quarterly basis that testing will occur and be submitted to both DEP and the code enforcement office. It's really DEP's responsibility to make sure that the pit is in compliance. It's just a courtesy that the records be forwarded along to the code enforcement office. [38:36] So I would say that of course we're amenable to working with a third-party engineer if that's what will be required but really DEP is responsible for that. That monitor. [38:48] she would just so code enforcement would just be like the holder of the records, basically. [38:52] Yep. So if anybody ever had an issue, all those records would be on file locally as well as with the state. [38:58] Okay. [38:58] you hit the nail on the head with people's well testing off site. it's actually much more accurate to test the water on site to develop that baseline. I of course as a homeowner, I would I would recommend that people test their own wells, but I understand that can be a burden to some people financially. [39:18] So where the site is uphill, you know, upstream of all other abutters, on site monitoring is going to be the most accurate option there. [39:32] And that's what the that's what the third party reviewer that's what actually maybe Mike Zarba could pop on if he's if he's really there and comment on that as well. Hi. [39:44] Hey, I'm really here. [39:45] Oh, that's great. I can hear you. I can see you. Hi, Mike. [39:49] Hello. Okay, great. Yep. you just to clarify, you want me to comment on the comment regarding the hydrogeology report baseline? [40:03] That yeah. And the we received a variety of emails stating that abutters would like the they would like the applicant to have their wells all tested for baseline numbers also. and so the applicant is stating that because they are upstream that their monitoring wells would catch something before it would ever get to the wells of the surrounding [40:30] residence. [40:32] Yep. Yeah, I think our feeling on it is, you know, a baseline, you know, Kendra I think just mentioned this, but a baseline set of monitoring wells, you know, should be done before any excavation is undertaken. that will establish, you know, what exists out on site today and or is being created by the site. [40:53] And that then should be, of course, monitored you know, throughout the project's lifespan as well. But certainly you know, we do feel strongly that the the baseline document should be done and reviewed, I guess I would say ahead of time. maybe made public for anybody that has a concern, they can understand that. [41:16] if we have a report, you know, we're certainly happy to review it and provide our comment on it if need be as well. [41:23] Awesome. [41:26] Questions from the board on any of that? No? [41:29] I about [clears throat] water? [41:31] Yeah. [41:32] Great. Let's talk about water. so I have concerns based on both what is proposed and what SLR has put into their report. It appears as though many of the hydrogeological issues before us are not fully complete until maybe some of these wells are dug before excavation and things like that. [41:57] So my concern is that the board is being asked to approve a project without full, total, accurate information on certain hydrogeologic studies and monitors of this water system. And it's hard for me to feel comfortable [42:19] on we're going to do this and we're going to do that without having the data up front. And that's going to be a recurring theme tonight for me because there's many places in both your proposal and SLR's report where things are suggested, things are used as a model, [42:40] but there aren't any clear guarantees that what you're suggesting or modeling is exactly what's going to be used. So it's hard for me to fully wrap around the idea that you know, if we use this crusher, this is going to be the noise level. If we dig this well and test for the water, we won't do anything until somebody else checks it out. [43:07] it's just hard for me to understand why we don't have concrete commitments to things that are very important to the to the neighborhood. water, dust, traffic. you've talked about I'm going to kind of jump around a little bit and get a few things out here. [43:31] you've talked about the traffic study or the the estimate of 20 trucks a day in and out of your of the business. you know, is the applicant comfortable and maximizing that list at 20 per day? And if you go over, how is that going to be monitored or handled? [43:53] because it's easy to say our estimate is 20 trucks a day, and then suddenly we're finding 30 and 40 trucks a day. So I don't know there's a lot that I don't know that I still want to know. So I guess we'll start back with the water, Mike, and talk about in your report how you did say [44:17] many of these things are not complete for you to get an actual final decision. Is that correct? [44:30] Correct. I think that's accurate. It's certainly our first report. I think our follow-up that we saw in response after reviewing the responses from Sobeys. we still yeah, we feel that they addressed many of the issues. However, the finality of a baseline report obviously [44:51] is not done. and you know, there's there's feel that there's two ways to approach that. Obviously, you can condition an approval upon them doing that prior to excavation to have that reviewed by the third party, by your committee commission again, you know, prior to them starting, [45:12] or you could have them do the report before you make any kind of approval and submit that information, which I think is what [clears throat] you may have been just suggesting you know, be done to maybe more complete the application process. you know, we would strongly recommend one of those two aspects be you know, be done with any kind of approval you know, for the for the water quality because [45:37] I think your statement was accurate that it's it's just not complete yet. It's all based on the empirical data that exists out there, but nothing physical in terms of what exactly the site consists of at this point. [45:56] That's what I thought. [46:01] So to wrap up my point on the water, I'm going to need better data to be confident that we have the information needed to satisfy with the water quality situation for the residents who live near the project. [46:19] Sure. I'll just reiterate that we have submitted a hydrogeology report that was done to completion. It is of course a model, but we submit I mean we review you review and approve projects every day that are based on models. That's what we have in most cases. I'll use stormwater for an example. [46:39] When we design a BMP, we do a stormwater model using HydroCAD software. It is a model. It is as close to accurate as we can get it, and they tend to be just that, pretty accurate. and so what we have provided actually is what the ordinance by its language that's spelled out requires. [47:03] So we of course would prefer that this be conditioned. It is a conditional use permit. We are committed to providing that information as we've mentioned and it's a pretty big financial burden to have to drill monitoring wells before you even know that this board will approve the project. [47:24] So [47:27] It's also a pretty big financial burden on the residents if their water is not of the quality that it should be because of your project. [47:37] And before excavation starts what we have proposed is that all of that information will be provided as well as reviewed by main DEP who is very qualified to determine whether or not this excavation will affect the groundwater. It will also be reviewed by the geologist who prepared the original report and is [47:58] he's here with us this evening. Do you have anything else? [48:01] Before you do I just want to say you just mentioned it would be a financial burden to do all that work before you got approval from the board for this project. But isn't it also true that it would be quite a financial burden and investment for you to get the approval, put in your roads, get the infrastructure going, then put your wells in, test them and find out that oh none of this is going to fly. [48:30] Well the monitoring that needs to occur to establish a baseline there is nothing anticipated that will that would cause us to not be able to start excavation. It's just determining what the baseline water quality is and then continuing to monitor whether or not the excavation is causing [48:51] impacts to that. So whether we do it now which is a huge upfront cost with no guarantee that this is going to get approved. Or we do it prior to excavation without that upfront cost and I'll add that the applicant has spent a significant amount of money to get to this point in providing all of the modeling that has been required [49:16] as written in the ordinance. So I don't have much more to [49:21] Okay. [49:22] to add to it than that. [49:23] I have a question about and maybe you can answer it, maybe Mike can answer it, but what besides like a spill of some fuel or something like that, hydraulic fuel or whatever all those liquids are, what else would a monitoring well what would flag something in a monitoring well that you would be like oh no, excavation has [49:47] yes. Bring in the geologist, please. Thank you. Thank you, Chris. [49:55] Good evening [clears throat] everyone. My name's Chris Veasey. I was the original author of the hydro geo report back when I worked at Haley Ward. Now I'm self-employed and I'm working alongside the applicant with this project. just to go back to the question of the monitoring wells, as far as adhering to the performance standards, a big part of this is I'm not the end all be all as far as who should say how many wells and where they go. [50:17] That's why we try to work with the DEP on that cuz I want the public to understand that they you know there still is regulatory oversight as this project moves forward. [clears throat and cough] As far as the findings of facts and the comments from the third party reviewers, you know we agree with those and we're going to you know implement this plan hopefully sooner than later in the month of November or December to hopefully capture the seasonal high groundwater. [50:38] And you know I know how they have some more work to move forward in the spring and that'll hopefully give us another data point. And that along with the water quality data, you know we'll have some good information prior to beginning any excavations. So I'm the person that kind of tells the applicant how far you can dig down based on the 5-ft separation from the seasonal high groundwater table. [50:59] Can I ask you a quick question? we're in a unprecedented drought conditions. Does that affect the seasonal high water table and when we are hopefully someday out of it, will that also affect it and then will your adjustments have to be made based on that? [51:17] Yes. So they 'll adjust based on the amount of precipitation. If we see, you know, a winter with a lot of snow and groundwater levels rise a bunch more, we're going to have to adjust the pit floor based on that. [51:26] Okay. so my other question was like so the monitoring wells are out there and take out like a chemical fuel spill or whatever. What else could affect the water quality because of excavation? I like radon, I think sometimes, but I think that's more localized. [51:47] It wouldn't [51:48] Yeah, that's more of a bedrock concern. If we're just excavating the overburden sand and gravel, there's really not in the way of too many geochemical changes that can occur within the water quality. You know, if they have a fuel spill, that's something else, but we shouldn't be There's no blasting that's going to be occurring with the gravel pits. You know, there's no nitrates to worry about. [52:05] They proposed potential blasting. [52:07] Oh, that's as far as the sand and gravel extraction that the excavating as far as my knowledge, there's no blasting involved in that. But [52:14] they find rock that they can't get through, they could blast. [52:18] All right. So that's a reason to possibly sample for nitrates to keep an eye on that parameter. So nitrates is one of them and they typically monitor for iron and manganese along with your typical water quality parameters like pH, specific conductivity, ORP, dissolved oxygen. The list goes on. So [52:35] Okay. [52:35] and all those you kind of put together to kind of create a picture of like the redox potential of the groundwater and along with the elevations, we can draft the contours to see which way it's migrating. but another issue to watch for things that would be called out more or less is the groundwater elevation itself. If we saw a precipitous drop all of a sudden from one quarter to the next, that would be concerning and something to raise a flag at. [52:55] So [52:58] Any other questions for the geologist? [53:00] Yeah, you talked about the baseline. After the baseline is established, how frequently do you monitor those wells? [53:08] So, that's typically established by the DEP and it varies. there's been some quarries and pits that I've worked on where it's twice a year, sometimes it's quarterly. There's some that require gauging monthly. So, I guess it's all depend on what concerns they find or what's typical with the performance standards, but at least twice a year for the seasonal high groundwater. [53:25] And who which department, whether local or state or federal, will get those reports? [53:33] So, it'd be the DEP Mining Division. [53:35] Will they come locally? [53:37] Yes, those reports will also be submitted to the code enforcement as a courtesy to have on file instead of having to chase them down through the state, but you know, the people at the DEP are the ones reviewing it and providing comments and questions and raising concerns if there are any. [53:51] Thank you. [53:54] Any other questions, George or Jeff? [53:57] No. [53:57] No? Okay. [54:01] so baseline air quality and ongoing air quality was something that James brought up. Kendra, would you like to speak on that? [54:11] Sure. first point to the fact that the third-party reviewer found that to be sufficiently addressed with the measures that we have already described in controlling dust on the site. [54:27] them again for the audience. Thank you. [54:29] so actually something that has changed is I will say by mistake originally we had put in a paved apron. that does not make a lot of sense when you have a gravel access road and you're coming out onto a gravel road. So, that has changed to a construction entrance exit which is made of stone and is just as just as effective in removing sediment from wheels of trucks. [54:58] So, just to be clear, there is no more paved apron. That thing would have been absolutely destroyed very shortly after installing it. So, and that's because it's only proposed at 50 feet typically and 50 feet of pavement with a large truck going over it, 's going to break on either end. I mean that's very typical. [55:19] so the construction entrance and exit is meant for sediment removal removal, I'm sorry. We've also proposed swales that run down both sides of the road and drain to level lip spreaders which are effective in settling out sediment. regarding dust we've addressed [55:40] Mr. Rain's comment that he'd like to see dust suppression systems on the equipment that's being used such as the crusher or the screen plant that will be on site. [snorts] Those I have confirmed all of them come with their own built-in dust suppression systems. They're hooked to what they call a water buffalo, just a water truck. [56:02] and they lightly mist dust during the operation. So it 's very effective in controlling dust. [56:12] Is it effective despite like how windy it is? We've had some pretty windy days. that was one of my questions. Is it effective within that? [56:21] yeah, it's it's very effective. I mean it's a it's a controlled mist that's coming out at all times over the entire piece of equipment. So [56:32] Perfect. [56:33] Yes. [56:33] Can I just ask one follow-up question about that? [56:36] Yeah, please. [56:36] So that mist takes the particles down to the ground. Is that correct? [56:41] Yep. [56:41] And the particles removed from the ground or [56:45] No, they just turn back into sediment and dirt. [56:47] it's nothing toxic in that dust or anything like that? No silica, nothing like that? [56:53] No. The issue of silica is a respirable it's a respirable particle within dust and as soon as it's neutralized by water it becomes sand and dirt again. [57:07] Oh, it doesn't need to be removed. Okay, thank you. [57:09] It's already down in [57:10] the Earth. It's just coming back up. [57:12] It's It's just when it becomes so fine that it becomes dust. That's when I mean, I think I mentioned before though, driving down a dirt road with your windows down, you're exposed to way more silica than you are living next to a gravel pit. [57:27] I believe it. [57:28] Yep. It 's the same thing when, you know, springtime comes and all that sand that's been used on the roads all winter gets kicked up. I mean, there's silica in it. That's That's the fact. [57:40] Is it likely though that same situation would exist on your travel route that your dump trucks going across the 100 ft stone apron could also disperse the silica onto the roadway and other trucks could stir that up? [57:59] So the as I just explained, the respirable silica is no longer there once it's back on the ground as dirt. So yes, of course a truck driving down a dirt road is going to kick up a bit of dust in dry conditions. We've also proposed for dust mitigation the use of water as well as calcium chloride along the road in order to better control that dust. [58:22] That's a very common practice that is DEP approved for dust mitigation. they also if you're looking at like dust clouds that are sometimes created by pits, DEP monitors that by opacity. to be honest, there's [58:42] not really a highly scientific [snorts] way to determine how much dust is being kicked up by a site. So we can put in these you know, mitigation practices that are very common and approved at this point. DEP I know is working on this silica issue, but at this time there isn't a very common way to I say very common. [59:11] There isn't a well-known way to actually measure silica at the edge of a property line for a pit. [59:20] So air quality can't really be measured like the water baseline. You can't [59:26] I think air quality can be measured. I mentioned I think last time that OSHA has standards regarding air quality for and MSHA have standards for air quality for pit workers. there are devices that can be worn. They're little vacuums that are put on their vests and they measure the air quality in the airspace of each employee. [59:49] And it's very rare even for employees that are working right next to these pieces of equipment to trigger the silica levels that we're talking about. They you have to be exposed to it at a certain level for a long period of time in order to for it to be considered dangerous. And that's right in your airspace. [1:00:10] So [1:00:11] Would [clears throat] would 10 years be considered a long period of time? [1:00:15] This is I'm talking a number of hours that you're exposed to a certain level of silica kicked up by the [1:00:23] 12 hours a day, 5 days a week for 10 years be considered a dangerous level? [1:00:27] I work with a lot of pit owners that are they're considered large earthwork contractors in the state of Maine and none of them have ever had employees wearing those silica monitors on them ever trigger dangerous levels of silica. [1:00:47] And there are operations that are open 12 hours a day, 5 days a week for 10 years. [1:00:53] Yes. [1:00:56] Can I just ask a clarifying question? So you're saying that all the all the employees of that are working in the vicinity or inside that pit area will have that monitor on them? [1:01:08] No. It's it is when so OSHA can trying to find the words. OSHA can come onto a site and make the pit operator and their employees wear those if there is a concern or for some other reason they're cited for something else and they're on site, you know, with oversight, that is when the employees would have to wear those. [1:01:35] Some earthwork contractors choose to have their employees wear them just for safety reasons, but it's not a requirement. [1:01:42] Will your applicant choose to make your workers wear them? [1:01:46] That is not proposed. [1:01:48] Can I Can we ask Mike from SLR a little bit more or his thoughts and opinions on that? [1:01:55] I think Can I just clarify? [1:01:57] Please. [1:01:57] The point of talking about these personal devices is to prove that even right next to these machines those levels are not triggering dangerous levels. So the way that the ordinance I believe is written is that it's a measurement of air quality at the property line. So if you are over 800 ft from where this dust is possibly coming from [1:02:20] then how could you possibly be triggering dangerous levels of silica? [1:02:24] We don't know, so that's what we have to answer. [1:02:28] Of course. [1:02:30] Mike, any just further comment on the silica in the air? [1:02:36] I think Kendra's accurate in her description of I think the measures that they've offered are and going to employ are pretty standard industry practices and best management practices I would say you know for maintaining dust control. So if they do it appropriately [1:02:59] you know there should not be the silica should not be the issue. Dust, you know you know to separate the two you know the dust issue from the site could be you know you might see some cloud in the, you know, in the air at times. [1:03:20] but that's typically when they should be implementing whether they're going to water the site, you know, or maybe add some calcium chloride to the water, you know, so that they aren't creating as their trucks and vehicles are driving around on the site, you know, that cloud of dust. But the silica issue, I would agree is not the [1:03:41] with the measures that she's talked about is not is not the problem. [1:03:48] Okay, thank you. [1:03:49] Can I ask one more clarifying question to what she said? you had mentioned that the sometimes a cloud of dust will be emitted, but the DEP has no way of measuring that cloud of dust or what's acceptable. Is that Did I hear that right? [1:04:03] It's it is it is a a visual measurement that's taken. It's It's a measurement of opacity. [1:04:11] What was that? [1:04:12] Is there any guideline at all on that the That is the guideline is that I think it's I'd have to look it up to be accurate with it, but it's like something 20% opacity or more would be considered and I would have to get more information for you in order to answer that accurately. [1:04:29] it sounds correct. [1:04:30] Is there testing for that? [1:04:32] so if there were a concern about dust, DEP would be called to the site to do a visual measurement and decide if the opacity of the dust cloud or size of the dust cloud is considered a problem, and then they would issue a citation if that was the case. Before they issued a citation, I'm sure that the operator would be given the opportunity to try to reduce dust as much as possible. [1:05:00] And that 20% opacity is that the property line, is that correct? [1:05:04] Yes. [1:05:08] You sounded like you had another question. [1:05:10] Probably. [1:05:11] Okay. [1:05:12] big inhale. [laughter] I know that in your application you talked about potentially using calcium chloride with water. is that a product that you put in the water when you lay the water down or you put it down independently? [1:05:28] Yes, it's in the water. [1:05:29] Yes, it's in the water. [1:05:30] And it's preferred to just use water. Obviously, calcium chloride costs money and water typically doesn't. So, [1:05:37] So speaking of water, in a different capacity than the wells, your water suppression system for your crusher and other equipment, as well as watering down the roads in and out and all of that, have you calculated how much water you're going to need for that? [1:05:58] No. it's either if it's not available on site within the internally drained portion of the pit, it would be trucked to the site from a different place. [1:06:09] And if you haven't calculated how much water to bring in via truck, are those truck trips counted in your 20 estimate? [1:06:19] Yep. [1:06:20] So if you have to bring in five truck loads of water, then you're going to [1:06:24] They're The water is typically hauled in on a water buffalo that sits on a trailer that can be pulled by a pickup truck. [1:06:31] Is that what you're committing to? [1:06:33] No. [1:06:35] Okay. Then [clears throat] then likely it could come in on an 18 wheeler pulling a huge tank full of water. [1:06:47] I don't hauling material. There will be five employees most likely on site, so that has been added into the calculation. at it was suggested by SLR that we accommodate those employees in their trips. And we are nowhere near the threshold for the number of trips that would trigger DOT review. So whether it's [1:07:08] I know the public's not going to want to hear this, but whether it's 20 trucks a day or it's 99 trucks a day, it actually doesn't change the permit that's required. [1:07:16] Right. Understood. It absolutely affects the residents and [1:07:19] It absolutely does, but I'll add, you know, you had mentioned earlier that it could be 30 or 40 trucks. There's no possible way that in a 12 hour day they could excavate that much material that would require 40 trucks to be leaving the site fully loaded. It's it's a lot of material. I mean 20 trucks a day is the average of a company like Shaw Brothers or Gorham Sand and Gravel or you know Risbara Brothers. [1:07:46] They're major earthwork contractors that have the capacity to be able to pull out that much material. [1:07:52] That's good to know cuz we don't know that. So that's that's good information. [1:07:56] Speaking of traffic one of the concerns that I have is you're open I believe at 7:00 a.m. in the morning. Is that [1:08:05] Yes, 7 to 7. [1:08:07] And that is a prime school bus time for kids to get picked up and I have a safety concern of these dump trucks on the travel route along with kids waiting for school buses and that kind of thing. And then in addition to that have you [1:08:27] calculated where these trucks if they get there early might be waiting to go into the pit and idling on a roadway? [1:08:36] Yeah, so typically with most operators they are looking to avoid traffic like buses and like people on their you know commute to work. So the intention would be for [clears throat] the trucks to arrive prior to 7:00 a.m. and wait until excavation can start per the noise ordinance. That's where our you know proposed pit hours have come from. [1:08:58] So the intention of course is to avoid conflicts with buses and commuters. I mean Ridley Road is a public road. There are other companies that function on this road that are using this road every day that also have large trucks. So I think it's important [1:09:18] to treat I mean this the truck [1:09:20] I can ask the public to totally leave. So just really. [1:09:24] The turf farm is a perfect example. [1:09:26] I mean, it's in operation, and it has been for a long time. So, we just ask that when considering use of a public road that we be treated the applicant be treated fairly. [1:09:36] I agree 100% but I also don't hear from other applications that are putting 20 dump trucks a day through a residential neighborhood with school buses in the morning, and now you're telling me the trucks are going to get there earlier in the morning and idle while they wait to go into your pit. [1:09:56] I mean, the access road I didn't get to answer that part of your question, but the access road is almost 800 ft to the start of the pit. So, there is plenty of queuing space. Not all 20 trucks that are the average throughout the day are going to show up in the morning. That's an average throughout the length of time that the pit is open. [1:10:15] I And I'm asking [1:10:18] other question. [1:10:19] Thanks. So, if they arrive early, they'll just drive up the access road and do the pit. They'll be gone from the public road and they'll be [1:10:27] Yes, they There's no There will be no idling on Ridland Road. There's plenty of space for the trucks anticipated to be on the access road. [1:10:36] Yeah. So, this for that access point there this they somebody if the truck's coming from wherever there's two major access points. One is the long I think it has part of Ridland Road, and then there's a shortcut right through the neighborhood there. [1:10:53] Yes. [1:10:54] is there any [1:10:56] They are They are going to be no through truck signs. [1:10:59] Correct. Yeah, we 've committed to not using the three I believe there's three roads that cut through highly residential you know high-density neighborhoods. Key Road [1:11:10] Wendy Lane. [1:11:11] Wendy Lane, and then Thomas. [1:11:13] Thomas, yeah. [1:11:14] Thomas, yeah. Thank you. [1:11:15] So, [1:11:15] It's been a moment since I responded to that question, but [1:11:17] Okay. So [1:11:21] there'll be signs that say no trucks through here or [1:11:24] No through trucks is the is the like approved sign that would prevent truck traffic that we're talking about from commuting through those neighborhoods. Yes. [1:11:34] that's on our public works. [1:11:35] what happens when they just ignore the signs? [1:11:37] Yeah, thank you. Yeah. [1:11:38] they would be doing something illegal, so [1:11:43] So who monitor I live on [street]. [1:11:45] Yep. [1:11:46] and Main Rock is quarter of a mile up from me. [1:11:49] Mhm. [1:11:50] They ignore those signs. [1:11:51] Right. [1:11:51] To be honest with you, for either. I don't know I've never called the police to see if they come up and do something about it, but somebody needs to tell drivers don't do it. I mean the people that are filling their trucks because it's going to affect you eventually. [1:12:09] Yeah. we mentioned previously that we're happy I mean of course it would be the responsibility of the operator to tell their drivers that they shouldn't be using those roads and the way that we can police that per se on a public road is to we're offering to pay for the signs. I mean [1:12:31] I think that's all that can really be done in this situation. [1:12:33] bumps would definitely stop that. [1:12:36] so the operator doesn't know everybody who comes with a truck. Cuz people place a order, they're going to send a guy with a truck. Could be anybody who's just doing some transport work. [1:12:48] Yeah. I guess it depends on the size of the truck. So dump trucks I believe and I can look into this the which sign should specify or would relate to what size truck is allowed to travel on the roads. The public works director may have some insight on that. [1:13:09] but you know we could possibly use a sign that identifies like the weight of the truck similar to how weight I'm sorry, similar to how you know the roads are posted in the springtime with a weight limit. [1:13:23] They drive right through those too, by the way. [1:13:26] I mean I and the applicant can't control that. [laughter] [1:13:32] Yeah, but this is a real concern. We're not saying that 's going to be on you, but this is this is an absolute real concern. I don't live far from Jeff, and when the DOT puts those signs up that these big trucks can go through there, they go right. They don't care. They don't They speed. They You know, they And these are independent contractors most of the time. You know, there's a lot of main trucks that come up and down there. [1:13:54] They're You know, they're maybe better, but everybody else, everybody who's coming going in that They're They're You know, [1:14:02] I mean, we can we can offer signage. Maybe it's been mentioned that they'd like to see a stop sign at the end of the access road where people truck drivers will stop before turning onto Ridland Road after exiting the site. So we can propose another sign maybe above or below the stop sign as a you know, a warning to all drivers leaving the site. [1:14:25] I understand what you're saying that dump trucks if they're employees of this operator, they're going to understand that 's not allowed, but somebody that's coming to buy stone, you know, from the site may not. So I We can offer signage at the end of the road as a reminder. [1:14:42] What's going to happen is they're going to look at their GPS, and the GPS is going to route them the most efficient shortest route, which is going to cut right through that neighborhood that we talked about. And then they're going to They're just going to say, well, I was just following my GPS. And if they're not really breaking any laws, nobody can do anything about it. [1:14:57] Yeah, I think the signage that we can offer on site is a bit different than the signage that has to be has to meet DOT or public rights-of-way standards, I would say. so we could be clear in our signage on site that there is no use of the three roads that we have mentioned as cut-through traffic [1:15:18] if that's agreeable. [1:15:21] I mean, I'm I'm taking notes. Oh, Jeff has something. [1:15:25] Somewhere in 470,000 pages of stuff we've got that we had to read, I saw something about hours from 7:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. [1:15:33] No. [1:15:33] No, 7:00 p.m. [1:15:35] 7:00 to 7:00 [1:15:35] So it was printed in one of these pages somewhere at 10:00. So I just want to [1:15:38] That may just be like a citation of our [1:15:42] Noise ordinance. [1:15:44] Oh, yeah. That does because 10:00 10:00 is our noise ordinance. [1:15:47] [clears throat] [1:15:48] Did I hear that you were I'm sorry to interrupt. Did I'm sorry. [1:15:52] Did you just say that in addition to the dump trucks and the employee cars there will be people coming to the site to buy stone? [1:16:00] We haven't proposed retail. Any retail on the site. [1:16:05] say? [1:16:05] That was that was a comment that was made by a board member saying that like if somebody came to the site that wasn't an employee of the pit how are we stopping them from [1:16:19] from not using the roads that we're talking about? [1:16:22] I asked that question because it's a business and if people want to order stone they're going to say, well, you know, you want to come and pick it up tomorrow, bring your truck. That's how it works. It doesn't just go to one customer or one client with one mode of transport. [1:16:39] I mean, depending on who the operator is the intention is not to set up the site for retail for sales of material at the site. [1:16:49] I'm I'm just trying to clarify something here where I mean but if you go sit outside a pit there's trucks with all kinds of signs coming and going from different operators. [1:16:59] Mhm. [1:16:59] So my point is just this. The operator of the pit doesn't know everybody who comes with a truck to get loaded up and those drivers are going to follow the GPS and they're going to see here's a little shortcut and that's what they're going to take. And then the residents are going to be frustrated and they're going to be, well, we were told this wasn't going to happen and this and that and everybody's ignoring the signs. [1:17:22] But what I'm asking is what happens then? Is there's no recourse for that? [1:17:27] The same recourse as what would happen if somebody is breaking the law and speeding when there's a speed limit sign that says 25 mph. per hour. [1:17:36] So, can we actually stop them from not taking a shortcut? I don't think so, right? [1:17:42] speed tables in there, that would stop them cuz it would take that route out of the GPS. [1:17:47] But it affects everybody else who lives there. [1:17:48] It does, yeah. Well, otherwise these people are all going to [1:17:51] Just add that to the list. [1:17:53] though, I think it doesn't affect plowing, does it? [1:17:56] Not as much. [1:17:56] Yeah. we have we have them in we have them in town. [1:18:01] I'm sorry, but can I just ask a question? Did I read that the pit was going to be closed during the when the roads are posted? [1:18:06] Yes. [1:18:07] Okay. [1:18:08] That's that's a long time sometimes during the year, right? [1:18:11] I mean if they can't haul I don't think it's let me correct that. I don't think it's it would be fair to close the pit when roads are posted if they are, you know, loading their trucks at half to meet the weight limits of [snorts] the road weight restrictions, that would not be they wouldn't be breaking any laws. [1:18:32] So the pit will not be closed during when the roads are posted? [1:18:34] but it's typical during that time of year and even in the winter time for operations to ramp down considerably. [1:18:42] It's generally March, February and March where they [1:18:45] Right, but that is one issue that we were having. [1:18:47] Oh yeah, we had a huge issue with that. Yeah. [1:18:49] I complain. [1:18:50] Because they'd rather just pay the fines because they're making so much money doing it. They'd rather just pay the fine and keep going. [1:18:56] Well, that's if they get caught, right? [1:18:59] Yeah. And well, and then here you're going to have the you know, the neighbors are going to be on high alert and they shouldn't be policing the roads. [1:19:04] Mhm. [1:19:05] They should be living peaceful lives. [1:19:06] Well, and the other concern is that if it is a problem, if they do follow their GPS and they go off route and they create a nuisance for the residents, the residents are going to call the PD and the PD is going to be out there frequently. [1:19:26] Maybe. [1:19:26] Maybe. [1:19:28] And [1:19:29] on what else is going on in town at the time. [1:19:31] But if the PD has to do follow the law and there's there's no law that they're breaking, is there? [1:19:38] Mhm. [1:19:39] So PD can't really do anything, right? [1:19:41] Well, it depends on what the truck is doing, right? If the truck is in a no-truck zone [1:19:48] Okay, so you can ticket it. I see what you mean. [snorts] So what do what department do we have to talk to make that a real thing? [1:19:55] It sounds like the PD would have to be actually sitting there and monitoring because by the time they get called that truck isn't going to be there any longer. [1:20:03] Yeah. [1:20:05] So we're saying in the end nothing's going to matter. [1:20:08] Well, I want to I will say that as far as the roads being marked for they can't travel there in the spring and time when it's soft I did complain several times to PD and to the town manager and they did cut back. They were pretty good at monitoring at that point. [1:20:30] But you have to go to that get to that point again to do that. [1:20:33] to the PD? [1:20:34] Yeah. I believe so, yes. I think Arthur went up and spoke with them, yes. Because it did stop for I'm not going to say it stopped completely, but it did really cut back. [1:20:47] Yeah. So I just would like to know cuz I don't remember where we stand with the condition of Ridland Road as it stands now versus what kind of wear and tear might be expected with the increased use. [1:21:05] Well, we had asked Jody who the director of Public Works for to weigh in on this and he did not bring up any concern about Ridland Road. [1:21:17] James did speak earlier about the condition of current condition of Ridland Road [1:21:21] Yeah. [1:21:22] which [1:21:22] Well, yeah, in terms of requiring the applicant to upgrade the road or in terms of having to maintain it or fix it, I think I've seen maintaining or fixing it have to go back to establishing a baseline of what the gravel looks like and understanding what the average wear and tear is and understanding which I think is probably possible to understand like okay Rhyddlan Road is now degrading faster [1:21:48] and having some remedy. We talked about it a little bit but I don't yeah what that remedy is if we establish that Rhyddlan Road's breaking down what is the applicant responsible for? [1:22:02] Did you say earlier that the road is in fair condition or did you say it's in poor condition? [1:22:07] Road is a borough town road, right? [1:22:09] road. [1:22:10] It is, yeah. [1:22:11] And I don't know what the anticipated schedule is for repaving that part of Rhyddlan Road. I just don't know. [1:22:21] Too many thoughts or ideas on the road condition or [1:22:24] a difficult topic because it is a public road. [1:22:27] They're all difficult topics, Kendra. [1:22:29] they are. I'm well aware of that. it's a public road and it's an allowed use and we I feel strongly that we have addressed everything that we've been asked to address. I think that the concerns we're hearing from abutters we have tried to mitigate with signage. [1:22:52] I think we also need to be reasonable and I'll just state that there's a lot of what ifs and you know we could be here all night talking about what ifs, right? And so what is reasonable and what can we put in place that will best solve the problem? I think in the draft conditions that I saw there was mention of this is back to dust but just something that we're of course willing to do is sweeping the end of the paved portion of Rhyddlan Road. [1:23:22] If that means it's on a daily basis then that's fine just to help with erosion control. it's again it's hard because there are other users of this road. It's a public road and people use the road you know in the summertime in the dry season to get to the public beach. And so how can you discern what dust is or sediment is coming from [1:23:47] cars and ATVs that are driving up and down this road and what is from the truck traffic. So I do I mean in other communities where this similar things have come up I've heard of you know taking a video at the start of every year down the maybe down the gravel portion of the road [1:24:08] so that you can assess the condition and then see the difference but that has been on private roads where I've encountered that and where the applicant in that case this was like a subdivision that I just dealt with in a different community would be responsible for maintenance but it's it's a public road it's supposed to be maintained by the town. [1:24:31] Totally get that. [1:24:32] sorry if that's unhelpful but I guess it's really up to you all to condition it appropriately. [1:24:40] Yeah, I think it's I think we have a lot to think about with that. Do you have something else about that? [1:24:45] I guess it's more of just a comment that everything is connected to everything else, right? You have your excavating the land and creating dust. You bring in a truck that travels on the road that may affect the road condition or residence peace of mind. You load the truck, it goes through a apron to get as much of the silica office possible. [1:25:10] It goes out onto Ridley Road and maybe deposits some silica from its tires and then you [1:25:15] no longer silica once it is it is sand again and sediment. [1:25:19] If it's on the ground from silica in the air to the ground it's now dirt, right? [1:25:26] Yes. [1:25:26] Okay. That dirt gets picked up by the truck tires and put out onto the road and you bring your sweeper out and you're sweeping the dirt creating more silica in the air, correct? [1:25:41] No because it we can also use water and calcium chloride in order to keep that dust down while it's being cleaned up. [1:25:48] Do you going to put water down and then sweep the water up? [1:25:51] It then is mud. So it 's [laughter] I mean [1:25:57] I guess what I'm trying to get at is just that it's it's complicated enough that everything connects to everything else. [1:26:03] But they're two separate issues. What we're talking about is sedimentation and erosion control me measures [1:26:10] Yep. [1:26:11] and then there's dust. So again I'll look maybe we should talk to Mike about his thoughts, but he has indicated that we have proposed [1:26:24] satisfactory measures for dust mitigation as far as what is typical for this industry. We have offered to sweep the street where required. That is a typical practice at the end of the day when you see sediment tracked onto a paved road. This is 700 ft away from the entrance to the pit that we're talking about and we're committing to sweeping the paved portion of Ridgeland Road at the beginning of the road, which most likely will have dirt tracks on [1:26:54] it every single day from other vehicles that have nothing to do with this operation. [1:27:01] Totally agree with that. Mike, do you have any ideas on that or or the limiting of the traffic? I don't know if that wasn't really something that we had asked you to look into, but if you have ideas about how to mitigate the potential traffic issues. [1:27:20] that's a very difficult one. I understand and it's a point you know Kendra makes a good point about it certainly. I think all the commission makes a good point about it as well. you know your job is obviously to try to protect the public in the in the neighborhoods that are there and not unduly burden them. but public roads you know typically have this issue unless there's [1:27:45] a dramatic difference in the type of traffic that they're putting on it, which I think is what the threshold that the main DOT, you know, looks for, you know, in establishing the kind of traffic volumes that might be added to a road. That's typically where you where you can make a particularly good point that, you know, there may be some additional needs that the applicant would have to, would have to adhere to put that kind of traffic on a road that doesn't currently have it, but, I don't believe that 's the case here and that makes it [1:28:15] particularly difficult as, you guys have been discussing for quite some time, and I'm certainly understanding. I, you know, spent many years in public works and have dealt with this issue on many different ways as well. it's it's not an easy topic. I guess I could say it that way. but that being said, [1:28:40] you know, trying to mitigate particularly the cut-through neighborhoods, you know, I think having the pit operation do as much PR, let's call it, and then advice to their customers and truck [clears throat] drivers to make sure that they understand the routes that they should be taking and that they shouldn't be taking, I think can be particularly helpful, [1:29:03] you know, as well. And then, [1:29:08] you know, if there's any other time issues, but I think they answered that question regarding you know, morning times or I guess anytime they if they could stack within their gravel drive or gravel roadway off Ridley Road, that 's obviously a huge advantage and I think should be something that you know, would be required as part of their operation to allow if they're going to have a gate. [1:29:34] I don't know if they plan on having one, but if they do, it would be, you know, much advantageous if they had it far enough off Ridley Road that they could stack enough trucks so that show up in the morning prior to them opening. [1:29:50] Agreed. I had did get a I personally had an abutter asked me about maybe just maybe doing two gates, one at the Ridland Road and then one at the actual pit entrance this way. Maybe the Ridland Road end one could be opened up so the trucks could go in, but it would still be a secure site rather than putting a gate all the way 700 ft in at the pit entrance. [1:30:16] but that was just it was something that an abutter had reached out to me about. [1:30:21] Yeah, I [1:30:22] Because it is going to be gated. [1:30:23] It will be gated. Okay. Yeah, there's already a gate at the entrance road. I think we'll have to probably be lengthened cuz the road is widening, but I would say it only one gate would be needed if it would if it was close enough to Ridland Road. [1:30:37] Yes. [1:30:38] I don't think we're opposed to that. I it's a security issue for the operator. [1:30:43] But if trucks are going to going to be getting there at 6:00 6:30 whatever it is and is somebody going to be there that early to open that gate so the trucks can stack I guess is the question. [1:30:54] Yeah, the I mean the employees would have a key to the gate. I think we mentioned that there would be a Knox box on the gate as well for any sort of emergency access. [1:31:04] or anything. [1:31:05] Yep. [1:31:08] All right. something that the third party review brought up was we were talking about the performance guarantee and financial capacity and there seemed to be a delta between the number that you have come up with and the number that SLR has come up with and that's really important to us. so if you could talk about that. [1:31:28] Sure. in our last our last submission which was in response to the original comment we received I'm not aware of another comment so I don't know where Mike stands on what we've submitted, but we did amend our opinion of probable cost for the pit and it is higher than what was originally [1:31:52] submitted. I think it's about $311,000. [1:31:56] Mike wanted 320. Is that? [1:32:00] 350. Okay. Okay. And was that the discrepancy with the cost of a certain of the unit cost of a certain item, Mike? [1:32:10] Yes, it was. Correct on your [1:32:13] Yeah. [1:32:13] kind of was a killer or something like that. [1:32:16] Yeah, I think we cited a unit cost per means which is something that we use for cost estimating on projects at any point in the design process as well as construction process. So did you see that reference and are you we still in disagreement? [1:32:38] That's what I'm hearing. [1:32:40] I did see I did see the revised cost. I think my original and maybe just to help clarify for everybody, I believe the original estimate that I was looking at came from the original application package and it was I would say substantially lower even than where you're at. It was It was somewhere you know maybe the 220s or 250s. [1:33:05] I think you're right, yeah. [1:33:06] exact number. [1:33:07] Yep. [1:33:07] and that you know I don't think that was a fair number. I think we're much closer in 312, 311 whatever we are to 350. [1:33:17] And that number just in a side that original number didn't include reclamation of 10 acres of pit. So it went up considerably after we had that conversation of adding that in. [1:33:30] Yeah. So I you know I think the number's closer you know I would venture to say [1:33:42] you know our the price I think they using I would you know just so everybody is clear on it you know typically comes from an average bid price that we see you know for this for this kind of work. Working [clears throat] on a private site, off-road. I don't disagree. It can certainly be less costly to do it in that capacity than it is on a public road. [1:34:08] you know, where it's a bit more, you know, involved traffic and other issues that have to be dealt with by the contractor. So factoring out those issues, I don't think, you know, we're terribly far off you know, on a number. [1:34:22] We also tried to account for the fact that the person responsible for building the road will likely be the pit operator itself. So there is some cost savings in the unit price of that material as well. [1:34:37] Agree. All of those can be factored in, and I think that 's those are those aren't fair. But I think the number is certainly much closer to the number I would expect for the financing of the roadway. [1:34:49] Might I [1:34:50] at the at the estimate. [1:34:52] Yeah, might I offer that if everyone's comfortable with the financial capacity piece of this, if we can talk about other numbers for the performance guarantee. I mean, it's possible that those two numbers could be different. I think that the applicant has demonstrated both with the 250 and the 311 that we've identified, they have the capacity to be able to construct the road and reclaim the site as required. [1:35:17] so as far as that's concerned, if we can separate the two and it may be a larger number for a performance guarantee, I think we would be comfortable kind of meeting you in the middle on that. [1:35:29] Kendra, is it still going to be a HELOC on a piece of property that [snorts] support some of that money? [1:35:37] That is what was submitted as proof of financial capacity by the applicant. [1:35:44] And there is nothing it was the same proof of financial capacity for the DEP permit. There is nothing written within the town's rules that states that you can't use a HELOC to provide financial capacity for a project. [1:35:58] No, but if the applicant somehow acquired a lien on his property, then his financial capacity is affected and we wouldn't know about it. So [1:36:12] the performance guarantee, which ensures that this project gets constructed the way that it's been approved, doesn't in this case have anything to do with the HELOC. That would be posted as a bond with the town as required. I don't believe a HELOC would be an appropriate way to post a performance guarantee. [1:36:32] So I think that the discrepancy we're talking about is just proof of financial capacity versus how the bond is actually posted. And that would be posted by a It all depends, but likely by a lender. [1:36:44] Yeah. [1:36:44] and it would likely be the pit operator. [1:36:46] Do you have thoughts on that for the performance guarantee? [1:36:51] I agree with that. And the part of that condition would be putting up a performance guarantee for the entire costs. And in my head, I think it would make sense that as construction is confirmed, that bond is reduced in kind. But retaining at least $55,000 [1:37:13] to have the surety to reclaim 10 acres. And there probably should be an escalator in there for inflation or some mechanism to [1:37:22] Yeah, 20% contingency or something. [1:37:28] Anybody have any questions about that? [1:37:32] I have a question, and it's actually something George brought up at the public hearing. And that is something that I think James knows. And what [1:37:42] I want almost like an economic impact statement, but I understand it's not a requirement. But what kind of positive economic impact does this have on the town? How much of an increase in the value of that land is there? How much you know [1:37:59] I think it back My initial conversations with is it's not much. [1:38:04] Mhm. [1:38:05] I think it depends on the actual data they have, and that may change the answer. I think if we understand the I know there's an assessing method that is based on the income a lot generates. so I've only had really early preliminary conversations with assessing, but I can try to get a better answer. [1:38:26] That would be really good to know, I think. It's It's nice to know if it's something that really is bringing a very positive economic impact to the town. [1:38:38] Or if it's not. [1:38:40] Do you have a like a director of economics or any sort of [1:38:44] Director of economics. [1:38:46] [laughter] [1:38:46] I've been working in Sanford a lot. It's me.. [1:38:51] Well, I think for to get an answer to assessing, do you do we have the estimated number of material that's going to be excavated and the type of material? Do you have Do we have anything that's that granular of [1:39:03] very high level [1:39:05] Okay. Yeah. [1:39:06] estimates [1:39:07] Maybe we can talk and I can try to see if I can get It would be an estimate. [1:39:12] Yeah. I mean that Yeah, I don't expect like an actual number, but it would [1:39:16] It's good I As a side note, I think economic impact is probably something we should talk about as a performance standard for future ordinance amendments. [1:39:25] I love it for the future planning board. [1:39:31] okay. more questions? You have more? You're working your way through your list? [1:39:38] Yeah, I just think I was going to ask again about I think you're proposing that you have the applicant starting the project, but it could then maybe be rented to a different operator to run the pit. Is that fair? [1:39:55] Yes. [1:39:56] Okay. And if this new operator takes over, will there be something in place to hold that operator to everything that we are putting out there for approval. [1:40:09] So DEP has a has a process for transfer of the operation from an applicant to the actual pit operator. So we would of course file for that once a lessee is determined as required. you it basically it and it they keep the landowner involved. [1:40:32] they just are identifying that there is a separate operator. [1:40:36] Okay. And maybe this question is for Mike, but let say you go through that process and you have a new operator and the DEP, you know, did the whole thing. If he changes equipment, is there a likelihood, Mike, of significant changes in results for things like noise [1:40:56] and wet suppression systems if an operator changes the equipment that we've used for these models? [1:41:06] There's certainly a potential for it. Would it be dramatic? that's that's an interesting and interesting question. [1:41:19] if they're operating within the same parameters, it shouldn't be dramatically different. If they're looking to change the operation in terms of how much they're producing or mining in any particular time, I think it could be you know significantly different at that point. I don't know that the permits would allow them to do that. [1:41:40] that's kind of beyond my knowledge though with the legal aspects and the way that the permits kind of go, but my understanding is it would be transferable with the property change. So I would think they still have to operate within the same parameters in the same board approval. if they still get it, then that this operator is going to operate under unless they come to the board to change that. [1:42:08] And I [1:42:08] don't know if we Thank you, Mike. And I don't know if this is something that we can do or not, or if it needs to be done or not, but if you rent to a new operator, your landowner is still going to be the landowner, right? The landlord, so to speak, for the gravel pit. I guess I was wondering if there's a way to [1:42:29] disperse the accountability if something does change, if they go outside the parameters of the permit or the approval. is it the operator who may be responsible for that, or is it the landowner who is [1:42:46] both would both would be responsible for any sort of citation that could occur if things are going in wrong. [1:42:54] Mhm. Mhm. [1:42:55] and I will just say that as typical of any site plan review or conditional use application, the conditions go with the property and the use, of course. So if this isn't proposed, but if this was sold to somebody else, then they would be responsible for the same condition to meet the same conditions [1:43:16] and performance standards that, you know, this applicant is. The same goes for a different operator. [1:43:21] Yeah. [1:43:21] Yeah. Just to clarify that. [1:43:25] Thank you. [1:43:27] I'm just looking through the draft findings of fact and a lot of these I think we've talked about, but we haven't talked enough about explosive materials. [1:43:39] Mhm. [1:43:40] so tell me more about that because in May you said no proposed blasting, in September you said blasting may occur, and then you would like you would say it 's not anticipated, but you don't want it to be restricted. So tell us more about if there's blasting [1:44:01] and it's not restricted, how that will be handled. [1:44:04] Sure. So [1:44:07] we Honestly, we shouldn't have said that it wasn't proposed because it's not anticipated. This is by all the models and the test pits that we've done this is sanding gravel. However, it's 55 acres of land. it is possible that rock could be encountered and in order to [1:44:27] remove the rock it has to be blasted depending on the size of it, how much there is there, the depth of course. So to restrict and say no blasting should occur on site would could be a significant hurdle for any operator of this pit. I don't think any operator would want that as a restriction on their property. So I understanding now that blasting could be possible we are willing I think I mentioned in my I guess we were emailing about it but [1:44:57] if it's if we need to address this in some way we're happy to do so. Typically submitting a blasting plan at least a draft blasting plan has checked that box for other communities. as far as I know the ordinance doesn't restrict blasting in any way [1:45:19] but I guess I'll I'll start there that we could submit a blasting plan. [1:45:22] because we haven't seen you and now there's blasting so we do need to know more about that for sure. [1:45:28] and regarding as far as the performance standards that are written in the ordinance explosives are not allowed to be stored on site even in the event that blasting would occur no storage of explosives would be happening on site. licensed blasting companies I think there are only two in the state of Maine. Maine drilling and blasting and I'm blanking on the other one but Maine drilling is [1:45:52] you know frequency area so they would likely be used. they bring their explosives to the site the day of the blast and they take them away. There are state requirements on notification on blast days well ahead of time. That's all determined and there's a specific process for notification of the blast. [1:46:12] that's where I want to [1:46:13] in because it like I said, I live on Old Sanford. Nothing's more exciting than sitting in your house [laughter] and not knowing they're doing it. [1:46:20] Yeah. [1:46:20] how do you notify them because I have James has taken a couple of my calls. I never hear a thing up at where I am. [1:46:27] it's by letter. but I can that would be something that would be included within a draft blasting plan would be the process for notification. So we can absolutely provide more information on that. [1:46:40] Yeah, I think I think it goes without saying that you'll need a blasting plan. [1:46:45] Yep. [1:46:46] Jordan. [1:46:47] We have a geologist here tonight, right? [1:46:49] Mhm. [1:46:50] How much rock is there that's going to need blasting? [1:46:52] We do we don't know. [1:46:54] You don't know [1:46:55] Can they lidar the ground and see the car underneath it yet? Come on. [1:46:59] in New England. I mean God on Sunday you sat back and watched the New England [1:47:02] but I can't. [1:47:04] Yeah. [laughter] Now I lived near a pit in South Berwick. There's a gigantic pit where they're blasting all the time and so I'm very familiar with that. [1:47:11] and [1:47:12] Yeah. [1:47:12] I will say the DEP requirement just for more information if under an NYTC for mineral extraction you can remove up to an acre of rock without actually having to file for a quarry permit. That's what they allow. [1:47:29] [clears throat] [1:47:31] okay, so blasting plan. I think that's a good idea. Lighting no lighting proposed. Landscaping the standard is met. We're going to use wildlife seed mix on all disturbed areas. [1:47:44] and lighting. [1:47:45] Oh yeah. [1:47:46] So explain to me how the operation will go in the winter when it gets dark at 4:30 if there's no lighting. [1:47:55] I would think temporary lighting would be used in the dark months. [1:48:00] is [1:48:00] So it isn't no lighting. It's temporary lighting. [1:48:03] permanent lighting is proposed. The no there we're not proposing to put you know pole lights up the access road. [1:48:10] But there will be lights available. [1:48:13] The equipment also has large lights that you know up the area that you're working in. So there is some level of lighting that will be on site. But it is mobile. [1:48:25] We would want to make sure that lighting is dark sky compliant, down facing lights. [1:48:32] Yeah, I mean we're we're [1:48:34] Well, I mean I mean I mean if they're having temporary lights with like poles and whatever, we want it to be down lighting to [1:48:41] Yeah, that's fine. I any temporary lighting I've ever seen can be cast down. I also remind you, I mean where we've identified the area on the site plan where the crusher and the screening equipment is allowed to be, that's over 800 ft almost from any property line. So I highly doubt [1:49:02] I don't think it's going to be shining into anybody's property, but we do try to do dark sky compliance for other reasons. There's a lot of reasons to have downward facing lights. So [1:49:11] Yeah. [1:49:14] that's a little bit of a hard one. construction lighting, I don't know comes with fixtures that are technically considered to be dark sky compliant. So again, this is kind of that gray area where it's construction. So if you were constructing anything else, you know, road work, let's say at nighttime, I don't think that would be a requirement. [1:49:39] I don't know if it's even possible [1:49:44] for construction equipment or lighting to be considered dark sky compliant, but I certainly have seen them down lighting. That might be the key there. [1:49:53] Perfect. [1:49:55] And the noise in the sixth, that's where the seventh to 10th [1:49:58] That I just saw that. Yeah, I saw that. That's exactly where you got that from. Yeah, noise I feel like we talked about at at length. Odor, off-street parking, refuse disposal, traffic we've talked about a lot and something that we still have to [1:50:17] While we're on [1:50:18] the topic of that. [1:50:18] Yeah. [1:50:19] I was talking to Mike earlier today about possible methodology for tracking traffic. And I don't know if Mike, you want to talk about tied to tracking tonnage coming and going. [1:50:38] I'm sorry things I think that you asked what we were talking about earlier [1:50:42] Yeah, what we were talking about earlier today about the one way of tracking trucks coming and going is [snorts] the tonnage. [1:50:52] Yeah. Yeah, I mean I know there's certainly been some talk about the traffic there and the number of trucks and I can appreciate that. I had the same concerns [1:51:06] because once you issue a you know an approval of it there is no exact way of tracking. So you know my thought is you know if the owner can commit you know basically I mean if that's what they feel is going to be their average of 20 trucks a day you know that I think equates to somewhere around [1:51:30] 500 plus or minus tons. [1:51:36] You know is [1:51:39] qualify the approval based on you know a reasonable tonnage around that production rate. So that you know 50 or 60 or 70 trucks can't come one day and you know if it was going to be an operation where they needed to do that they would you know maybe specifically need to come back [1:52:00] you know or make a range of code enforcement officer do something applicable to you know to the permit so that it's it's understandable that you know you're not going to see a wild difference in traffic than what's what's anticipated by the permit. [1:52:18] How would you how would you track that? Or do you just estimate it based on their weights of the trucks leaving? [1:52:27] I believe the I think they'll be producing scale tickets or some kind of weight ticket system you know for the people coming in there so that they know what they're hauling out of that site and I would think they can provide that to you on a weekly or monthly basis you know showing you the tonnage reports that are you know whether it's day by day or week by week or however you want kind of structured that I would think they can produce that report for you. [1:52:58] Interesting. [1:52:59] Are trucks weighed in when they go in and out? [1:53:01] Yes. Typically there's a scale but I have concerns about that because different materials weigh have different weights. So if you have a truck full of rock it's different than a truck that's full of sand. And so placing a restriction on the amount of tonnage that can come out of a site in a day doesn't necessarily isn't necessarily directly linked to the number of vehicles that are going to be going in and out of the site. [1:53:28] And as I mentioned previously if we had started this and said an average of 40 trucks a day we're going to come in and out of here that would still not trigger the peak trips that we're talking about which would require a different permit through DOT. That it's the peak number of trip I'm sorry the number of trips in a peak hour [1:53:50] has to be over a hundred or greater in order to trigger a DOT permit. So based on the standards within the ordinance whether it's 20 trucks a day average or 40 trucks a day we're not tripping anything any other permit. [1:54:06] I think you said a trip is in and out. Is that how that formula permit is also [1:54:12] trip is yeah one truck in one truck out. [1:54:14] hundred trips it's really a hundred trucks in and a hundred trucks [1:54:20] Yeah the truck that enters the site has to come out. Mhm. and this is considered conservative because what's required with heavy vehicles, heavy vehicle equipment, dump trucks, is that we double the passenger car equivalent. So you're already seeing that number doubled to account for the large trucks that are coming in and out of the site. [1:54:42] But you're not suggesting given what you say is the 100 trip limit that our concerns as a local planning board are relevant? [1:54:53] No. Not at all. I don't think any of this is irrelevant. [1:54:57] Thank you. [1:55:03] All right. Well, we have something to think about with traffic then. sewage provisions. There will be a porta potty emptied regularly. No subsurface sewage disposal system is required. Setbacks and screening. there was that stockade fence shown along an abutter's property. [1:55:25] Signs. One unlit identification sign at the gate. And then possibly we might have some more signs for the traffic. [1:55:39] Soils. We do have that. Erosion and sedimentation control. I feel like we've talked a lot about that. Storage. [1:55:49] No fuel is stored on site. Topsoil is like stored separately and covered or whatever, right? Like they're not shipping out topsoil from this site. The soil like the [1:56:01] center aside to use for like the making of it. That's what I meant. [1:56:04] the topsoil is stored on site. [1:56:05] mentioned fuel. [1:56:07] Look, it says here storage no fuel is stored on site is in our findings or draft findings. [1:56:12] how are you going to operate all the machinery all day long without [1:56:16] They have to bring fuel in. [1:56:18] That's a dump truck. [1:56:20] It's I mean it can come in on a dump truck. It can come in with the employees that we've accounted for in the traffic. [1:56:27] There's no fuel storage on site for both. [1:56:32] I do have a question, and this comes out of just the draft conditions. sorry to skip around, but it number three says materials allowed to be excavated are limited to what has been proposed in the application. What has been proposed in the application? Cuz I want that to be really clear. [1:56:50] Yeah, I do too. I talked about this. Do you want to [1:56:56] No, you I never responded to your email, so we can do this now. This is perfect. [1:57:00] Sure. of course I don't have the email that I sent you, but I we started talking about blasting, and if we do encounter rock, we don't want to be restricted from removing it in order to get to more sand and gravel. So what I wanted to be clear on is that we have proposed a use. That use is mineral extraction, and the definition of mineral extraction within the ordinance includes rock removal. [1:57:26] So I think by indicating the use that we're under within our application, we have been clear about the fact that rock may be removed from the site. Of course, if there are other things we need to address, we identified providing a blasting plan, we will do that. It's kind of a separate issue. but I think that condition should be reworded such that it refers back to the actual mineral extraction definition [1:57:52] Well [1:57:52] for what's allowed to be removed from the site. [1:57:54] then I guess we'll work on that because how it's written I mean, if it's rock and sand, why couldn't we just write rock and sand? [1:58:00] Because there are other things listed with under mineral extraction that are allowed to be removed. [1:58:07] Not a lot of other things. [1:58:08] I would like to see what they are. [1:58:16] Is it under our definitions in the beginning? [1:58:19] 2.2 [1:58:23] Mineral extraction, any operation within any 12-month period which removes more than 50 cubic yards of topsoil, loam, which you're not removing, so I wouldn't want I wouldn't want that in here cuz you're not removing topsoil or a loam. [1:58:37] It is possible to remove topsoil and loam. We just have to keep enough topsoil and loam on site in order to reclaim the site. [1:58:43] Okay, interesting cuz I thought that I read somewhere that you weren't going to be removing it at all, that it was just going to be scraped from the surface, set aside, protected, and left. [1:58:53] the concern with removing topsoil on site? [1:58:56] I just want to be very clear, that's all. I'm just I just want to be clear. [1:59:02] I don't [1:59:03] I think that was that I had read that before. [1:59:06] I don't think that we [1:59:07] to know what's coming in and out, that all. [1:59:09] Yeah, I understand. I don't think that we stated that anywhere within the application. [clears throat] I can double check. [1:59:14] I could be hallucinating it. It really is okay. [1:59:17] could also be wrong. What I'm what I'm trying to get at here is I think it's important to be clear about what's allowed to be removed from the site. I don't see an issue with topsoil being removed from the site if it's in if it under the definition of mineral extraction, it's allowed to be removed and we're keeping enough topsoil on site in order to reclaim the land, which is what's required. [1:59:36] that? [1:59:37] The It has to be removed at a certain depth. [1:59:39] Yeah, so should we like [1:59:40] it has to be reclaimed at a certain depth. Yep, so that's all identified on our reclamation plan and within our notes and details. [1:59:48] It may need a little more clarification cuz if you take you take a topography of say it's not much of a hill, but a little bit of a hill, and then you dig down as deep as you're talking about and you need to reclaim that, is a significantly larger surface area to reclaim than what you started with. So some kind of calculation is going to need to be made to determine that you've saved enough [clears throat] topsoil to reclaim. [2:00:13] If we're talking about what's allowed to be exported from the site, what is the concern with removing topsoil from the site and what it would be the concern with a contractor bringing in topsoil from a different site and reclaiming their site? We understand that it has to be reclaimed to a certain level. [2:00:30] Right. [2:00:30] And that's what we proposed. So I guess the argument that like how do we calculate how much is enough? Well it can If there isn't enough it can just be brought in. In fact it's highly likely that there won't be enough top to your point, right? When you've created much more surface area by excavating down it's highly likely that there won't be enough top soil on site [2:00:53] So it's not taken out. no I was just I've served on this board for a long time and when I see something like this to me that's a context clue that I need to look further into it. When there's a whole condition that says materials allowed to be excavated are limited to that's to me a big red flag and so I want to dig deeper into it. [2:01:16] Absolutely and it was a red flag to me because we were also talking about restricting possibly restricting blasting. [2:01:22] Mhm. [2:01:22] And so I raised the concern that within the definition rock is allowed to be removed from the site and I would not want to restrict the operator from being able to do that by having that condition in there. [2:01:34] Well if we just put rock and sand then it would be in there. [2:01:38] But [2:01:39] Because rock. [2:01:40] [laughter] [2:01:41] That I understand [2:01:42] prevents them from being able to remove and sell top soil from the site which there's no impact that [2:01:50] Yeah I guess well you said that there was no proposed retail operation so you would [2:01:55] Yeah but contractors who would operate this pit are have projects going on all over the place where they can transport material. Like highly It's actually highly likely that is what these materials will be used for are on other sites you know that the contractor is working on. So I just I guess [2:02:14] I just I was just digging deeper into why that was very explicitly stated and I was assuming that James had a good reason for putting that in there. [2:02:24] Yeah I was just to try to capture what was represented in the application. [2:02:29] Yeah. [2:02:30] one point I will make about top soil reclamation is that we will be holding a surety to reclaim a phase. So whether the top soil is there or not we'll have at least $55,000 plus. [2:02:47] I just see like we have so many like we get these soil studies. I'm sure we have one from you that are like pages and pages thick and each soil is that's native to that spot is it's different than what somewhere else. So I'm not sure like I feel like environmentally and I don't know. I'm just a real estate agent. but I feel like environmentally you'd want to keep the top soil there because that's native to what was there and we're very environmentally conscious over here. [2:03:14] Yeah, I understand that as a concern. I think where it would be a concern what the concern would be for the contractor is cost. Obviously using top soil that's that's naturally made there is cheaper than transporting it from somewhere else of course. but we also have specifications within our plans that have been identified at what that loam has to consist of. [2:03:35] So it what will likely happen is if the natural soil on site doesn't meet that spec it will be mixed with something else to make it meet that spec. And that testing you know the contractor would have that material tested in order to ensure that happened. [2:03:51] Okay. [2:03:52] Per plan. As approved. [2:03:54] Perfect. I guess we have to we'll have to look at that condition a little bit more. erosion and sedimentation we talked about that. Storage we talked about that. Storm water management we talked about that because it is an internally drained pit which we learned all about at our last meeting. [2:04:12] toxic and noxious discharges [2:04:17] is met by conditions. No on site fuel storage is permitted. Equipment maintenance shall occur off site as required by condition. Water quality is met subject to conditions. [2:04:30] Which we talked about at length. Water supply. potable water is not proposed or necessary for site use, but you did say that you might be pulling water, just water that's there on site to use. [2:04:43] Yep. [2:04:45] Access to lots is met. It's the Woods Road non-storm water discharge is met cuz we're not using town sewer. Post-construction storm water management is met subject to conditions [2:05:01] of maintenance on an ongoing basis. Safety and sanitation is met. [2:05:09] Any waste will be removed off will be removed off site. [2:05:14] I just wanted to really get through the findings of fact tonight. I don't know what kind of an appetite anybody has for going through [2:05:24] I do all night. [2:05:25] You do? Let's go. [2:05:28] I'm retired, so. [2:05:30] [laughter] [2:05:30] That's great. What time is it? 8:16? Oh, we got all kinds of time. [2:05:39] Hi. [2:05:42] It's very distracting when you guys are talking cuz it like comes right here. So if you could just keep it down. So we as we move through this document, our performance standards 8.10. [2:06:00] So setbacks, the standard has been met. No part of the extraction operation is within 100 ft of any property or street line or within 300 ft of the property line of an existing residence. Natural forested vegetation is kept within the setback for year-round screening. [2:06:18] You agree with that, right? Yeah, you have to. [2:06:21] I'm sorry, I was right. [2:06:22] With that the screening, the forest screening is going to stay all around the [2:06:28] Yes, we're meeting all the required setbacks from property lines. And part of that screening is the fence that you had mentioned earlier. I do want to just provide a little clarification. It said along the property line. It is to a degree. It's not right along their property line, but as far as noise goes, the closer that you have the barrier to the source of the noise, the better it works. [2:06:51] So that's why we proposed it along the road rather than along the property line. I just wanted to clarify that. [2:07:00] Standing water. The standard is met. The pit is internally drained and the pit floor must stay at least 5 ft above the seasonal high groundwater table. If standing water accumulates, the ordinance requires the site to be fenced. Interesting. slopes. The standard is met. Reclamation plan shows final slopes of two [2:07:21] 0.5 to 1 which meets the 2 to 1 or flatter standard for final grading. The plans do not show slopes during operation. The ordinance requires a fence at least 6 ft high wherever the slopes steeper than 3 to 1 occur at the extraction site. Liability insurance is met subject to conditions. [2:07:42] Evidence of adequate liability insurance is required by condition before any earth materials are removed. Top Oh, top soil again. Top soil stock piles. This standard is met. Top soil saved for reclamation must be seeded, mulched, or otherwise stabilized as shown on the reclamation plans. [2:08:02] Erosion and sedimentation control. The standard is met subject to conditions. The plan set includes erosion control notes and details prepared and stamped by a professional engineer. And then C finding 15 which we talked about. Lagooning. The standard is not applicable. No lagooning is proposed. I don't even know what that means. [2:08:24] Hours of operation. The applicant proposes 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. on weekdays and 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Saturdays with no operations on Sundays. is that Are we usually put that as a condition. Are going to condition hours? [2:08:42] I think that's probably one of your most powerful levers in terms of mitigating some of the effects of this use. [2:08:50] Okay. [2:08:51] [2:08:54] Sandish What did I have some over here. [2:08:57] Yeah, please do. [2:08:58] Sandish is 7 to 7 on weekdays and it's 7 to 4 on Saturday. New Field 6:30 to 5:30 Monday to Saturday. They have limited machines on Saturday. Shapley 7 to 5 weekdays. 7 to 12:30 Saturday. There's no Saturday processing. [2:09:22] Acting has no Saturday trucking. Gorham has crushing on weekdays only. So there's a variety of options. And just a reminder, what's proposed is 7 to 7 weekdays, 7 to 5 Saturday. [2:09:37] What's it like over there with Maine Rock? What are their hours and what are [2:09:41] believe it's Monday through Friday. I think they say Saturday's closed, but I believe I'm not going to swear to it, but I think they go sometimes on Saturday, but not I don't think it's heavy, but they're pretty good on their hours. I walk my dog every day and 4:00 their gates closed. [2:09:58] Oh, that's nice. Is there like a proposed like no crushing on the weekend or anything like that you guys have talked about? No? [2:10:08] We haven't proposed that, but [2:10:10] Well, I don't know, so I just want to make sure if you have [2:10:13] it's not proposed, but [2:10:15] Okay. [2:10:15] Of course it's [2:10:16] Something [2:10:17] up to you all. [2:10:19] Something to think about. [2:10:25] Maine Rock lists Monday through Friday 7 to 4. Closed weekends. [2:10:30] Yeah. And they do And like I say, most days I take the dog up that Well, not now it's getting dark, but they are Their gate is closed at 4:00. [2:10:38] Mhm. [2:10:42] number nine under standards access road treatment, this standard is met. A 100-ft stone construction entrance is provided where the access road meets Ridland Road. Number 10 equipment and debris, the ordinance requires equipment and any temporary structures to be removed within 30 days after extraction is completed. [2:11:06] And 11 reclamation, this standard is met subject to conditions. The reclamation plans require at least 4 in of topsoil, seeding and mulching within 30 days of final grading, and final slopes of 2.5 to 1 which meets the 2 to 1 or flatter standard for final grading. The ordinance requires each area to be reclaimed within 6 months of completion. [2:11:32] then we move on to article 9.8 conditional use and site plan standards preserve and enhance the landscape. [2:11:42] This standard is met subject to conditions. Extraction is phased in seven areas totaling about 55 acres with no more than 10 acres open at a time. About 100 acres of the parcel remain undisturbed. Disturbed areas are reclaimed and revegetated per the approved reclamation plan. B vehicular [2:12:03] access, this standard is met. Access is provided by the upgraded gravel access road from Ridland Road. Site distances are addressed in the application material provided. And I think that we could add to our conditions about the vehicle the vehicle no vehicle stacking on Ridland Road. [2:12:24] Parking and circulation, this standard is met. Five interior parking spaces are proposed and interior circulation is adequate for the scale of the operation separating site traffic from the public road. D subsurface water drainage, this standard is met. The pit is internally drained promoting onsite infiltration. [2:12:46] The access road conveys runoff through ditching to level spreaders before discharge. The POA1 increased results from replacing an undersized culvert. Oh, that's right. We're putting in that larger culvert. E, existing utilities. The standard is met. The operation does not impose an unreasonable burden on sewers, drains, water lines, or other public utilities. [2:13:11] F, advertising features. The standard is met. One unlit identification sign is proposed that will need to be approved by the CEO. [2:13:21] G, special features of the development. This standard is met. The crusher and processing equipment are subject to the setback and noise conditions, and stockpiles are located on the pit floor providing the audio visual buffer required by this standard. [2:13:37] H, this standard is met. we do have to change that update that since temporary lighting will be used down lighting. I, emergency vehicle access. The standard is met subject to conditions. The access road provides emergency vehicle access and a knock box knock box at the gate is required by condition. [2:14:03] J, municipal services. I circled this on mine cuz it says this standard is oop. [2:14:10] I think I think just queuing up like is our it is the use does it have an adverse effect or unreasonable adverse effect to municipal services? So in terms of [2:14:23] Okay. So [2:14:24] in terms of the burden put on code or other departments. So that's just something that I think I like the board to talk about for finding there. [2:14:36] Okay. [2:14:37] Yeah. [2:14:38] Is there a definition for municipal services within the ordinance? [2:14:42] I love definitions too, Candice. [2:14:45] typically they're sewer water. [2:14:50] so it says including municipal road systems, fire department, police department, solid waste programs, sewer treatment plants, school open spaces, recreational programs and facilities, and other municipal service and facilities. So I think that code enforcement does fall under that. [2:15:09] Okay. [2:15:09] And public works. [2:15:10] And public works. [2:15:11] Yeah. [2:15:12] And police potentially. [2:15:13] police. [2:15:14] Police. [2:15:15] It's in there. [2:15:17] What's in where? [2:15:18] Police is in there. [2:15:19] Oh,. we don't have a definition for municipal services, but it's kind of defined in that standard. [2:15:26] Yeah, I think right. Some of that is just if we get the conditions in a place where we just have that in mind of the effect to be able to achieve a conditional approval that would not putting an undue [2:15:41] burden on yeah on yeah unreasonable whatever it is unreasonable adverse impact. [2:15:48] Which I think can be achieved through a combination of making sure we understand the agencies that are responsible for enforcing it and third party reviews, escrows, sureties. [2:15:58] Yes. I agree that we can definitely get some definition in there. [2:16:06] K will not result in water or air pollution. The standard is met subject to conditions including the groundwater, fuel and spill, dust and erosion control conditions. The extraction limits are shown outside the special flood hazard area on the plan set. [2:16:26] L has sufficient water available for the reasonable foreseeable needs of the development. The standard is met twice you wrote that so it's really met. [2:16:38] Double met. [2:16:39] Potable water is not necessary for site use. Water for dust control and for the spray systems on the crushing and screening equipment will be supplied by water truck and spray water drains to the pit floor and is reused. No onsite water supply well is proposed. M will provide for adequate sewage waste disposal. [2:17:00] The condition that the standard is met, the site will be served by regularly emptied portable toilet. No some surface wastewater disposal is proposed or necessary. N will not have adverse effects on the scenic or natural beauty of the area aesthetics or rare and irreplaceable natural areas. The standard is met subject to conditions. [2:17:22] The main Department of Inland Fishery Fisheries and Wildlife concurred with a May 15th to August 15th no cut window for bats and acknowledged the applicant's 250 foot buffers around all vernal pools and 100 foot buffers around streams and associated wetlands. The Northern Black Racer survey could not be completed in 2026 [2:17:45] and is to be coordinated with MDIF&W for 2027. The main Natural Areas Program reports no rare plants within the subject or project area. [2:17:59] O The developer has adequate financial and technical capacity to meet the above standards. The standard is met subject to conditions. The application was prepared by a qualified professional team. The applicant's revised opinion of probable cost dated October 21st, 2026 is $311,487 [2:18:21] for the access road, stream crossing, erosion control, storm water measures, and reclamation of 10 acres. A Citizens Bank letter dated October 22nd, 2026 confirms an available home equity line of credit balance of $311,408 [2:18:40] $311,487,000 [2:18:42] in the name of Nathaniel P Sewell. A performance guarantee of 311487 is required by condition before site work begins. After the access road and stream crossing are complete, it reduces to $55,000, the estimated cost to reclaim the maximum 10-acre open area and remains in place until final reclamation is complete. [2:19:09] How did we come up with $55,000? It seems like such a small amount of money for 10 acres. [2:19:14] I believe that was provided [2:19:16] Okay. [2:19:17] It's [2:19:17] And we and review. Yeah. [2:19:19] I mean [2:19:20] Which is probably on site. [2:19:22] Yes. A lot of it is natural. [2:19:24] Perfect. [2:19:25] The process right there. [2:19:26] Oh, we need to add the inflation escalator. [2:19:29] Oh, yeah. I think we're that's going to be in our conditions. There's so many [2:19:34] also already the 20% contingency is already within the cost estimate. [2:19:40] Oh, it is? Okay. [2:19:41] Yeah, so it's already built in. [2:19:43] So the pit gets loam and seed only. There's no cut and fill or anything on that. Is that correct? You don't backfill that [2:19:51] If it's excavated steeper than two to It can't be excavated steeper than two to one per the required ordinance. It has to be put back at two and a half to one, which is less steep, of course. So part of the reclamation is to put the slope back at two and a half to one, which is shown on our reclamation plans. [2:20:08] Right. And you plan on doing that purely with loam and seed, you're saying? Is that I understand correctly? [2:20:13] I think there's a detail for that on our plans, what has to be put back. I don't believe it's loam and seed. I think the loam is just 4 in on the top. [2:20:24] That would be typical, yeah. [2:20:25] Yep. [2:20:28] All right. I don't even know where I was at. Oh,. Okay. P. Whenever situated in whole or part within 250 ft of any pond, lake, or river will not adversely affect the quality of such body of water or affect the shoreline of such body of water based on the standards outlined in section 9.8.5. [2:20:49] 1.J. The standard is not applicable no pond, lake, or river is within 250 ft of the extraction area. Q, low impact design. The standard is met. The pit is internally drained promoting onsite infiltration and groundwater recharge consistent with the intent of this standard. [2:21:11] R, design guidelines and standards. The standard is not applicable. The site is not within the village overlay district or the designated route 4 236 or 9 corridors. I'm not going to go through the conditions because those are we're working on those. Those are going to change I think. We have work to do and it's after 8:30 and my brain starts to shut down after 8:30 so I personally don't find that I'm capable of much more technical capacity. [2:21:39] But happy to take any comments from the board or questions or send Kendra off with some other things if you have any ideas. Anybody? No? Terry, go for it. [2:21:57] I'm just curious as to the regulatory oversight MDEP. How often do they typically come do inspections? What's the is there a standard on that? Is there a how does that work? The compliance [2:22:12] believe there's a frequency in how often they have to visit the site. Typically that is triggered by a complaint. There is a like a renewal that happens once a year where they have to submit I mean they have to keep up with their permit. So I would say it is at least reviewed once per year by this by DEP. [2:22:36] But they don't necessarily come out to the site. Is that correct unless there's a complaint? Is that what I'm [2:22:40] I would have to verify that. [2:22:44] Okay. [2:22:46] Do you have anything James? [2:22:47] I don't. [2:22:48] Oh, you're looking at me in weird. [2:22:50] No. [2:22:51] [laughter] [2:22:52] Like are you trying to tell me something say it. [2:22:54] back at you looking back at me. [2:22:56] I just want clarify that you do not plan on closing when the roads are posted. You just plan on regulating the amount of material the trucks can carry. Is that correct? [2:23:06] meeting the requirement for the posted roads. [2:23:08] Okay. Thank you. [2:23:12] And you can do that cuz there will be a scale on site, so you'll be able to rate [2:23:17] Weigh trucks on the way out? [2:23:20] Because different materials weigh different. I mean, you gave us this education, so [2:23:24] no, I know. I'm just what I was thinking actually is that we don't have the location of a scale shown on our on the site plans. So [2:23:34] Add it in. [2:23:35] Yeah, I Can I get back to you about that particular topic and provide more information? [2:23:40] a few more times, Kendra. [laughter] Don't get my hopes up. [2:23:48] anything else we can send her off with before we move on in our I think we've had a lot of discussion. I think we have a lot of we got a lot of good information. I'm glad Mike was here to answer from the third party review. I all of this is available online. All of the questions from the public hearing are answered and in writing online. [2:24:12] The third party review, the response to the third party review are all online. It's verbose. If you would like any of this material, feel free to grab it from me. but I think we're good. [2:24:26] I have one quick last thing. [2:24:28] Please, by all means. [2:24:29] on the reclamation plan, and I'll have to look back to make sure, but my understanding is and we don't have to get into it tonight, but maybe some research is that doing 10 acres at a time, you have to reclaim the 10 acres that you've just excavated and have that completely reclaimed before you can start a second 10 acre lot. [2:24:50] Yes. [2:24:50] Okay. [2:24:54] Excellent. [2:24:55] See, that was quick. [2:24:56] Yeah, perfect. Thank you. [2:24:57] Short answer. [2:24:58] All right, thanks, Kendra. It's been real. Is Daniel still here? Come on back. I would like to recognize Daniel to rejoin as a voting member. [2:25:17] You don't have to stay for the rest. You absolutely can, but it's late. You can go home. I'm not going to be offended. [laughter] There's no I'm Then please email it into James. [2:25:29] I'm sorry. I don't have the access to online email. I need all this [2:25:32] Okay, then if you All right, then stick around and then you can ask James and he can submit it into the into the record. [2:25:42] Hi Daniel. Thanks for joining us. Moving on to our second public comment. [2:25:50] Opened up to anything under the purview of the planning board. Well, you never know. [2:25:56] [laughter] [2:25:58] Are we pushing the [2:26:00] they're not here, yeah. [2:26:01] Yeah. [2:26:05] I think he has something to say. Yeah, I mean we can. I [2:26:08] One thing for motion. [2:26:09] Oh yeah, I can [2:26:09] That's fine for now. [2:26:10] Oh yeah, I we'll we'll talk to him when we're done. [2:26:12] all right? [2:26:13] Oh right, yeah. I would get one of these packets. [2:26:16] Yes. [2:26:17] Yeah, I was going to say mine is mine's got some other stuff in it. [2:26:19] Some of it some of it [2:26:20] Oh sure. I can't do any questions. You can ask it, but I can't answer it. [2:26:24] wait till the meeting [2:26:31] There is a This is just the process. This is a good question for James about process. [2:26:36] not right. That's not right. You know, it's it really isn't that she gets a chance to You know, [2:26:50] I understand. We've been getting lots of emails and whatnot from abutter, but I have to move on with my meeting. Thank you. Thank you. You too. [2:26:59] you. Think that's all stuff right? [2:27:01] Seeing no public come up, I'm going to close my second public comments. [2:27:06] Good job. [2:27:07] Thanks. [2:27:14] Moving on to informational items. [2:27:21] That is an informational item. We have cupcakes. I do have an [2:27:25] informational items about What is informational items? [2:27:28] Just anything that's just kind of under our purview, but not necessarily something that we're that's like an agenda item. Like [2:27:35] Pickleball news often qualifies. [2:27:37] Yeah, sometimes pickleball news yeah, infiltrate. [2:27:41] for hours for code enforcement to walk in. [2:27:43] I will say that I and I've talked to James about this and I'm talking to the chairman of the Board of Selectmen, but I we as a board have been getting particularly with this application a lot of AI documents coming into us as public comments and as emails to the board. [2:28:05] And I you know I'm very proud of this board in general. We get a lot Holly, if you mind taking your conversation outside, it's just very distracting to my meeting. Thank you. so we've been getting a lot of AI generated documents coming into the to the board. And again, I'm very proud of this board. [2:28:25] We do We get complimented constantly. We get complimented from our the applicants. We get complimented from our engineers, from the public. I feel like we spend a lot of time educating people on our processes. And we spend a lot of time reading and studying. I know all of you do. Everybody comes prepared to our meetings, but I believe it's an undue [2:28:48] burden on the members of this board to have to weed through AI generated comments, questions, and whatever because if you've worked with AI before, I do. I teach AI. I just won an award for teaching AI. you know that a of what comes through is hallucinations. And so when you're working with AI, you have to go in and fact check every single thing. [2:29:10] And I think it's an undue burden on the board to be to have to fact check things that people are generating within seconds and submitting to us as public comments. And so I am requesting that the staff come up with a public comment submission form that just helps to [2:29:32] get the point across without a lot of extra AI stuff in [2:29:39] in the spirit of the board being able to continue to do their homework and do a good job at it without having to weed through nonsense, basically. so I've got some ideas, but I'm also meeting with Mike from the chairman of the select board about it because I think we're seeing so much more of it. AI is it's in all of our lives. There's a wonderful I mean it's it's wonderful. [2:30:00] It's it's a great tool. I use it every single day in my life. but there are I think that when you're a member of the public and you're commenting or you're you're bringing up a concern, it's so much more valid or it feels so much more valid if it's like if it's coming from you as a human rather than a lot of words that a computer chugged out. [2:30:21] And it I think it 's just a better system. And because I'm getting very frustrated. I'm getting AI fatigue and I'm like one AI comment away from [2:30:34] Don't say it. [2:30:35] leaving this board. I told James today. I think I told almost everybody today. I'm just I take this very seriously. I spent hours of my life on this. I've attended over 150 planning board meetings as a member. I've I take this very seriously and I don't want to burden my board with that if it's possible. So [2:30:55] add it to your plate please. [2:30:56] like I like the idea of a form. That's a great idea. [2:31:00] I will say this the municipality is facing challenges with AI and it's frustrating because there's no answer to it at moment. [2:31:07] Yeah. [2:31:08] We're we're we're we're working our way through it. [2:31:10] Is a forum possible? [2:31:11] Can we have AI tell us how many documents coming in are exactly the same and then send us one copy with a number of how many more there are? [2:31:26] It depends on the prompt. [2:31:27] You can have AI do anything. [2:31:29] It would probably If we're going to make use of AI, it'd probably be better to have it as a summary with references. especially like reading stuff, but [2:31:38] to tell me how to think. [2:31:39] I That's That's not what I'm saying. [2:31:41] AI is to tell me there are 173 of these. This is what they say, but I'm not going to send you 173 copies of the same document. [2:31:52] Right. [2:31:53] I think that's minimal, but that would be helpful because even here, I mean, we have repeat exactly the same documents. You know, I only need to read it once. [2:32:04] Yeah. [2:32:04] But when it's public comment, I think verbatim is pretty kind of important as opposed to a summary, no? [2:32:12] Oh, I don't want a summary. [2:32:13] Oh, I thought you were saying a summary like [2:32:15] No,, no. What I want is [2:32:17] of the different documents, viewpoints presented along with [2:32:23] Yeah, I don't I don't want an AI summary. I just want a count of [snorts] you know, there are 72 exactly the same documents. This is what it is, but I'm not going to send you the other 71. [2:32:39] And so I would like somebody to monitor to just you know, that we don't get repeat exactly the same document. [2:32:47] a lot. It's a [2:32:47] want to I want to know how many there are, but I don't need to read 72 of the same exact document. [2:32:55] Just a thought. [2:32:56] Yeah. No, it's a good thought. Just thinking about variables inside those documents and you know, is that something that you would be able to do? It sounds a little burdensome, but [2:33:08] Yeah, I would think it's a little burdensome for a human being to do that. [2:33:12] It just Yeah, I [2:33:14] Do you have any extra time to devote to [2:33:17] I think like [2:33:18] Start with a public comment standard like form would be awesome. [2:33:25] Well, I can just copy and paste it to the standard form then. [2:33:28] Well, you can tell I mean but you can tell when it's I mean if there's if there's seven lines in a standard form or come to the public hearing and talk to us and tell us as a human being. [2:33:40] Yeah, well the public has a right to put in their opinion, comments, you know If people use AI I mean [clears throat] 100 what 50 60 years ago they were trying to ban calculators in some places. [2:33:55] I'm not trying to ban it at all. I'm saying that I'm I'm saying it in the in the spirit of this board and we're volunteers having to if we're really doing our job when AI spits out something it's not always true. [2:34:09] Well, then you can disprove that it's not true. [2:34:11] I'm not I'm not spending my free time to disprove that a public comment isn't true. No, I'm not. [2:34:18] Well, you're going to get public comments. [2:34:21] But just because a public makes a comment doesn't make it true. [2:34:24] I would like to just set a standard where we are where we have [2:34:27] statement. [2:34:27] That's fine. I would like to set a standard and I would like to you to create a form for it and I'm happy to help. I'll create the form for you. [2:34:35] you're going to actually tell the public that you can talk to us but you can't use AI. [2:34:40] No, you can use AI. I want it but be succinct, be accurate. Yeah, I want the public to I want the public to come at me and say yeah, here's here's an accurate statement. Yes, I do. I'm a volunteer in an appointed position. Yeah. [2:34:57] Yeah, no but I think I 'm not disputing that I'm not disputing any of that. I'm just like how are you going to filter What are you going to do? You're going to say oh, Mr. Smith from Rich Lanes gave us this and it's trash. We're going to throw it out because used AI. [2:35:16] I'll tell you that when I open when I open a public [2:35:18] saying that the use of AI in and of itself is to be prohibited. [2:35:23] Okay. [2:35:24] All that some of us are saying is if you go to the same AI and it produces the same document 209 times, I don't need to read 208 of them. [2:35:36] Yeah, nobody [2:35:36] Send me one and send me a I want to know how many people sent it, but I don't need 209 versions of the same document. [2:35:44] wants that. [2:35:46] Or that's all that 's all that I'm asking for, and I think that 's essentially what all Nicole is asking for. [2:35:51] but I mean if one or nine different people send you the same thing, then you know, that's pretty easy to address. You can do that in one statement if it's the same, right? [2:36:03] Yeah, well we don't have to address them at all. We just we receive them. [2:36:09] AI let's say submissions by the public, right? Niles, is that what you're saying? [2:36:14] I just don't want to get 209 copies of the same document. [2:36:18] Well, we can [2:36:20] Okay, that's I think we I think we all understand what we're coming from. [2:36:24] know how many there are, but I only need to read it once. [2:36:28] All right. [2:36:28] Yeah, no, okay, but I don't get your point to be honest. [2:36:31] Okay, well we're not going to stay here we're not going to stay here any longer arguing it because it's 8:50. [2:36:37] And it's obviously something we need to think about model of [2:36:40] we do and which is why which is why I brought it up. Thank you very much. I'm looking for a motion to adjourn. [2:36:45] Motion to adjourn. [2:36:46] Second. [2:36:47] All in favor?