← Back to MaineScanner

Auburn Planning Board Advances Comprehensive Plan Recommendations Amid Public Debate

2026-10-28 · 2h 46m · Source: City of Auburn, Maine, Planning Board Meeting, October 28, 2026 (City of Auburn / Great Falls TV (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Begin the city of Auburn planning board meeting. we will appoint Who was the last alternate to have participated in any voting? [0:13] Okay. we'll appoint Kathy for purposes of this meeting as the voting member. you'll notice in your packet if you haven't already that we have an agenda and an edited agenda for your purposes only with a note at the bottom which suggests a way that we will go through the comp plan comments and recommendations. [0:38] It didn't appear on the general public agenda but it's just for your information. This is how we would propose to proceed this evening. So with that unless there's an objection to what you see at the bottom of your planning board agenda with those notes we will plan to proceed in that fashion. [1:00] Okay. For a roll call for us starting on my left. [1:05] Kathy Shaw. [1:07] Chelsea Eaton. [1:09] Riley Bergeron. [1:10] Bob Hayes. [1:11] Bill Hussein. [1:12] Ed Beara. [1:13] Maureen Hopkins. [1:14] Tim Deroche. [1:16] Thank you very much. Under continued business I have a note on my agenda that says motion needed to move public comment before this item. I would like to move public comment so that if there are any additional comments to be made regarding the comprehensive plan before we begin our deliberative process of making recommendation [1:37] of the plan to the council we have the benefit of those comments. Unless there's an objection I would suggest that we amend our agenda to take public comment at the beginning if that's okay. No objections? Then that's the way that we will proceed. At this point we're going to open the meeting. Do you DeCarlo want to brief us on [2:00] nonetheless on the proposed format for our deliberations even though it's written down here in front of us. Would you like a chance to walk us through that and then we'll open it up to public comment? [2:12] Absolutely. Thank you all for having me here this evening. Thank you all for being here this evening. So today is a special meeting of the planning board. We're discussing the topic of the comprehensive plan once again. We are scheduled to we've we've taken public comment. [2:29] Steve. Steve. [2:33] Thank you. [2:34] Sure, absolutely. You've taken public comment during your public hearing. And now you're back to discussing the topics that you discussed at the prior meeting. So basically what we're what the schedule is proposed is to take public comment during your public comment period here this evening. [2:55] Then afterwards we're going to review items from the last meeting. Questions that you've already queued up that you would like to discuss. So as each item is brought to forward to discuss and is asked basically we're going to ask the question does this item require additional review given the received public comment. [3:16] And so if there is additional discussion that you all would like to take then we would move that item back to when you're discussing public comment and we move to the next item for your consideration for basically for a vote. Because if the answer is no then one of you all would be responsible for motioning for a vote. [3:38] Vote would motion would be offered and then you all would discuss and vote for it. If it's yes then the item is moved to review during the public comment. During the review of public comments received at the at the public hearing a planning board members would identify items for possible recommendation. So staff is not going to go to each public comment received [4:00] we received those to print and at the public hearing and prior to that through different venues, staff will include all written comments in the packet. You all have had that for a number of days. but we do not plan to present individual comments for consideration. we will be here and available to provide additional information and assistance as needed for any questions that you might have that we can answer. [4:27] as a reminder, we might not have all the answers that you're looking for but we will be able to be a resource for the things that we can answer tonight. [4:40] One question that I have is as I understand it, we will we will discuss and decide whether to recommend any of the previously discussed recommendations. [4:52] Correct. [4:53] Previously discussed amongst this board. [4:55] Correct. [4:55] And then we will take up the additional see if there's any more by way of recommendation we want to discuss based on public comments that came in at the public hearing that we had with the comprehensive plan committee or that we received in writing since. Is that right? [5:16] Yes, that's correct. [5:16] So this packet first and then any other items. [5:21] Correct. Yes. [5:22] In addition to any public comment that we might receive right now. [5:26] Yes. [5:27] Okay. And let me just I'll invite members of the public to address the the board regarding any comments, concerns, recommendations they might have for our course of action regarding this comprehensive plan recommendation. since we are taking you up at the beginning, we are going to be mindful of the amount of time that you take, so please make your comments as precise [5:48] and direct as possible. Any member of the public wishing to approach the board, please do so. [5:59] Yes. [6:01] Stephen Beal, 575 Johnson Road. I would like to heartily recommend adoption of the plan as approved by the comprehensive plan committee with there are some copy editorial change a little minuscule typos and things of that sort. with the addition of one additional word change on page 79 of the comprehensive plan. [6:26] there are the word appears that residential development in the ag zone should be secondary to agricultural farming and forestry etc. activities. I think that the preferable word would be to use the word that's presently in the existing ag zone ordinance, the word accessory [6:48] to those uses rather than secondary to. the present planning board is comprised of members only two of whom were members of the board when this sweeping change to the ag zone ordinance was made 3 years ago. It wasn't a comprehensive plan change, but it was so substantial that it amounted to the be the equivalent. [7:10] Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Deroche were members of the board at that time and participated in those discussions. The city council at that time directed the planning board and the planning staff to consider elimination of the income standard as a measure of determining permitted uses in the zone, agricultural income or other forestry related income. [7:34] To consider elimination of strip zones in the ag zone and specifically to expand the types of uses that were going to be permitted in the ag zone. And also substantially to involve the public in those discussions. That directive was followed out. the planning board sought public input. [7:54] There was a very large group of 50 to 60 people with interests in agriculture and forestry and related concerns who participated in a number of meetings and came up with a group of recommendations and presented those to the planning staff. There were then meetings between a smaller drafting committee of that agricultural forestry working group. [8:20] I was a member of that committee. All of the planning board Excuse me, all of the planning staff members at that time, Mr. Cousins, Mr. Blay, and Ms. Cook were participants in that working drafting group, which came forth with a recommended form of ordinance change. As a result of that, those changes were presented to the planning board, were adopted by the board. [8:46] Mr. Sear, who was the chairperson of the planning board at the time, also had some thoughts of his own. He couldn't attend that planning board meeting because of a school commitment to one of his daughters, but upon looking at those comments, his comments and ours were virtually identical. They were adopted by the planning board [9:07] and then subsequently by the city council in the fall of 2023. As a result of that, there are 18 types of uses in the agricultural resource protection zone that are permitted as a matter of right, and another 20 that are allowed by special exception. [9:29] So, there's a total of 38 possible different kinds of uses that are categorized into one of four groups, either farming per se, other types of permitted agricultural uses, recreational uses, and natural resource protection uses, all within that [9:49] defined ordinance. Subsequent to that, there was an ad hoc committee created to assist the planning staff. [9:57] Steve, you're going to run out of time pretty soon. [9:59] Yes, I will do that. Which worked up a progression analysis format for evaluating applications for uses in the ag zone, that progression analysis format has been provided to the staff and is in use at present. The ordinance works well as it's presently written and I would simply [10:20] suggest changing one word on page 69 and otherwise adopting the ordinance as the comprehensive plan committee has recommended it. Thank you. [10:36] Good evening. My name is Mary Moore and I'm an Auburn landowner on the Jordan School Road. and I'm going to speak directly and very succinctly to you this evening. as you may remember, I shared some of my thoughts at the October 14th public forum. Again, I want to thank the planning board and the committee for your hard work on the 2026 [11:01] draft comprehensive plan. I appreciate and value our city's goal to prevent rapid, uncontrolled suburban sprawl and protect our rural heritage. So, it's important that you know that I respect all of that. However, even though the old income test is gone [11:22] and I'm going to speak to the language specifically, the severe regulatory language and restrictions remaining still, in my opinion, unfairly penalize local ag zone landowners. The ongoing policy language carried into the 2026 draft [11:42] sets a framework that locks in rigid binding conditions on a family's ability to build a home in this zone. By maintaining overly rigid caps on building footprints, lot configurations, and non-farm uses, the current language places an undue regulatory burden on citizens. [12:07] This directly impacts ordinary families trying to establish a homestead on land that they own and on which they pay taxes to the city. [12:20] It ultimately undermines what should be a partnership between the city and its residents. [12:29] True conservation is a shared effort with the people who actually care for and pay taxes on their land. [12:40] With that in mind, I urge the board to change the underlying tone of this draft, replacing punitive constraints with a plan that honors landowners as frontline stewards of our rural heritage. Let's ensure [13:00] Auburn's final plan preserves our environment by supporting rather than conditioning a family's basic right to build a home. Let us live, work, and thrive on the land that we care for. Thank you. [13:24] Anyone else care to approach the board offering comment on the comprehensive plan? [13:38] good evening, members of the planning board. My name is John Cleveland. I live at [address] in Auburn. And for the record, I'll also state that I'm the chair of the comprehensive plan committee that's been reviewing this for about 2 years now. I want to make my comments really directed toward the section that you have for consideration a little a little bit later this evening regarding change wood changes to the description and [14:08] land uses specific to the agricultural resource protection area. I also like to remind you that the restrictions that have been in this area are not something new. They have been here in this community since 1960. [14:25] More than 60 5 years now. So, these restrictions aren't something new that were that's being proposed. in fact, as been described, they've actually been loosened up over a period of time and expanded. So, in any individual that happens to be owners in this area have been well aware since the beginning [14:48] of what these restrictions are, whether they owned it or purchased the property at a later time. What I'd like to do is make two points in regards to the comprehensive plan. The committee and those members who are on it know that we discussed this issue at great length at the comprehensive plan committee in regards to what the land use categories should be and where they should be applied. [15:11] Yeah. and in looking at that, they really we expanded the areas in the growth areas throughout this community. They are larger than they were before and they allow for much more development, more intense development than was previously required in the community because we recognize there needs to be space for individuals to grow, for housing in the community, industrial uses, and community uses. [15:41] So, we've expanded those, including those expanding them out into areas that at one time was much more rural or in the agricultural resource protection area while increasing the intensities in those particular areas. I'll give you some examples. Well, there are two important objectives, therefore, that the committee looked at. [16:02] One was to look at the protection of those areas for farming and natural resources within the area of community. and so, that was one important objective in looking at it. Secondly, the and equally important was the sprawl that growth creates within a community. when you open up more land and the more residential development within those land it creates sprawls and it also creates an increased demand for [16:32] public services in there. Over time we have looked at these and there are hundreds of studies that show that the services required by residential growth is far more than for rural growth rural growth. the what they found is that if it's more agricultural and rural [16:56] the cost for services is 40 cents for every dollar they pay in taxes. However, when it becomes residential and grows the cost to the average taxpayer is a dollar and 50 cents for every dollar that they pay in taxes. That 50 cents is paid by everybody else that owns property within the community [17:18] because they're not self-supporting in the services that they grow in demand for. So we this was a balance that the comprehensive plan committee tried to find. That is where should the growth be? Where should we allow it to grow at grow? And where should there be some protection in the community both for the natural resources and farming but also for real [17:40] fact that how it impacts the community and what it costs to run the community. We think we found pretty good balance, a reasonable balance not that everyone will agree to it but I think the far majority of folks do. And the vast majority of folks on the comprehensive plan committee agreed with what we come up for a recommendation [18:04] within that area. so I think it's very responsible balance that we found and I urge you not to make changes to those two categories that I suggested. Thank you. Thank you, John. [18:31] Seeing no one else approaching the podium, we'll move on to discussion of the proposed changes to the or recommendations to the proposed comprehensive plan. I'm going to ask Carlo that perhaps lead us in this if you don't mind. [18:51] if I describe correctly, we're going to start with this planning board recommendations draft updated October 28th. Is that right? [19:00] Mr. Bearer? [19:01] Yes. [19:03] Can you just speak into the mic a little bit closer, please, for me? [19:06] Sure. [19:06] Thank you. [19:10] I'm going to ask if the Carlo can help us go through the proposed recommended changes or not the changes that we have previously discussed which are found in a document entitled Planning Board Recommendations Draft October 28th, 2026. And as suggested by the note at the bottom of our agenda, [19:34] we will as each item is brought forward, a question is asked, "Does this item require additional review given any public comments that we have heard?" and if not, a motion may be offered. And if yes, then we'll discuss further and then a motion may be made. Is that a fair statement? [19:53] Yes, that's a fair statement. [19:54] Okay. You have a perplexed look on your brow, though. Is there a problem with my [20:01] No, there's there's none. Okay. You 've done you've described that perfectly on the way that we would like to go. and Lauren will actually be guiding us through each of these each of these items. [20:13] That's fine. Yeah. Th- That's fine. It was a royal invitation to the both of you, so. [20:17] Absolutely. Yeah. [20:19] Okay. Let's go. [20:22] So, we'll start first on page one under vision goals and policy recommendations, future land use. The proposed language change adds for the municipality under policy one to be direct growth to the high growth area to encourage compact, efficient, and fiscally responsible development for the municipality. [20:47] Can I just ask for a recap of why why we thought that should be changed and what we thought it was adding to the comprehensive plan. I don't remember the backstory on this. [21:01] I'll offer my recollection. I think it the wording as presented to us was fiscally responsible development and we I think that I was one of the people that wanted to add for the municipality. It's a it's fiscally prudent for the municipality. as opposed to necessarily fiscally [21:24] responsible or prudent for the owners of land. [21:30] Thank you. [21:30] Yep. [21:37] So, as a reminder at this portion you would entertain a motion from one of the members if you would like to make this change, but if not, we would go on to the next item. [21:51] I would like to make a motion that we adopt the amended language. [21:58] I'll second. [21:59] Then moved and seconded. Any discussion on this? Would you like us to vote on this or do you just want it by our concurrence? [22:07] please vote. [22:08] We'll vote. Okay. any discussion? Okay. All in favor of the proposed revision? [22:17] unanimous Thank you. [22:28] Our next proposed language change discusses landscape and buffering standards. This would include an action item FLU 2.1.13. [22:40] Amend ordinances to establish city-wide landscape and buffering standards. It can include shade canopy coverage, streetscape standards, stormwater, supportive landscaping. [23:07] Any discussion? [23:12] Looking for a motion then. [23:17] I'll move that we make this revision as written. [23:22] I'll second that. [23:25] Then moved and seconded. After that, is there any discussion? [23:31] Seeing none, all in favor? [23:34] Cathy, did you Are you That's a unanimous vote. Yes. [23:41] Yes, and just as a clarification, this was voting to offer this as a recommendation to the city council. [23:48] Correct. [23:48] Yes. [23:49] Everything that we're doing is if approved would be a recommendation of the comprehensive plan to the city council. [23:58] Thank you. [24:05] We will move on to page three. We're in the community section. This language change would clarify and add more specific language around committee and board engagement processes within the city. The language would read, provide consistent opportunities for boards and committees to provide input and feedback as stated in the city charters and ordinances into capital planning, policy development, and service delivery decisions. [24:31] Ensure defined, timely, and transparent checkpoints of boards and committee engagement in budget and planning processes. [24:42] And if I understand what is in red [24:46] is what you have taken from our discussions as being planning board [24:53] That's correct. Yes. [24:54] Correct, and discussed at the last meeting. This is the language that you wanted for the question. [25:06] Is there a member of the board who recalls being a mover of this proposed language? [25:16] -huh. [25:16] Yeah, I think I remember. I think this is exactly what I kind of had in mind, and was that kind of timetable of what is expected of the boards and of the city administration that comes and guides us along that process. So, this I think would be helpful for that. [25:39] So, if there's no other discussion, I'll make a motion to move to the city council a recommendation [25:51] I mean, should I just say of C5.2.2 [25:55] as presented here. [25:59] I got it. [26:01] Was that a second, Bob? [26:03] I had a what? [26:04] Okay. Been moved and seconded. [26:08] Is there any member who wants to argue with the notion that we should ensure timely, transparent checkpoints? [26:17] All in favor of the motion? [26:20] Passes unanimously. [26:30] We'll move to page four under transportation. [26:35] This stemmed from a comment about addressing e-scooters and e-bike safety, and this would manifest as two action items. The first is T3.1.7, collaborate with partners to create resources and guidelines for micro-mobility devices such as e-bikes and e-scooters. The second action item is T3.1.8, consider regulations requiring micro-mobility devices traveling at speeds of 30 mph or higher to use standard traffic lanes rather than sidewalks, protected bike paths, or designated bicycle [27:05] shoulders. [27:12] I will move the language presented. [27:17] Second. [27:19] It's been moved and seconded. I have a process question, I guess. at the last at the public hearing at the joint public hearing, I remember at least one individual commenting that the comprehensive plan lacked any mention of the Lewiston-Auburn-Portland [27:40] bus service and thought that it should. I'm not suggesting that it belongs here, but will would that be something, since we're under the topic of transportation, that we should discuss now, or should we just discuss later and perhaps you would find a place to fit it in [28:02] in a different location under transportation? [28:05] correct. So, you would take up that item during discussing the public comment section. and so, that would be one of the items that if wanted, you would bring up during that section of the meeting. [28:17] Okay, thank you. [28:24] The language in front of us has been moved and seconded. Is there any discussion? [28:28] Yes. [28:29] Yes. [28:29] second item, T3.1.8. [28:34] To me personally, that doesn't settle well still. I still have just a integral issue with recommending that these micro scooters go on roadway lanes that may not have blinkers, headlights, tail lights. I think we could potentially be inviting more problems. [28:54] I'm I'm not comfortable 3.1.8. [29:03] You're not comfortable with it and I know you read things very carefully, but even if they are devices that go 30 mph or faster. [29:12] Yes, I [29:14] You'd rather they be on the sidewalk. [29:16] I 'd rather they not be on the roads. [29:19] [laughter] [29:19] it 's I think when we take a ve- if we recommend to city council that we think vehicles driven by people that may not even have a driver's permit, suddenly be on roadways without blinkers, without headlights, without traffic lights, I think it's a huge overstep and a huge liability on our part. [29:45] A- and the way you just said that leads me to think that we probably don't have any authority to permit this to occur if it's not lawful, if they're not You think if they're not even licensed, they could be on the roads? Yeah. Okay. [30:03] Okay. [30:04] Oh, great. [30:06] Yes. I Oh, Chelsea. [30:10] I actually agree 100%. well, I agree with what you're saying, Tim. I think it's a really relevant issue and I think but I think the idea [30:25] is that 3.1.7 is saying we want to collaborate with public works, police department, what have you, to create guidelines for these exact situations. [30:40] So, I think your point is actually covered in the idea that we're going to create guidelines for those exact situations by working with the police department, whoever else would have you, bike coalition of Maine, I don't know. But, I agree with you 100% but I think that's kind of also the point of having this. [31:01] [31:04] I don't know what the answer is but I think both of these are helpful and I think the e-bike and the e-scooter situation is a little chaotic in general and [31:19] I just think [31:23] I think this is going to help. [31:28] I totally agree, Chelsea, and I really I recognize and admit your point 3.17 is probably all-inclusive and which would make 3.1.8 that much less relevant and probably unnecessary. I just think it's a slippery slope for any level of city planning to recommend [31:50] make recommendations to city council of things that should really be handled by a police department and state law. [31:59] Riley. [32:00] I think that there is a there will be a lot to consi- or could potentially be a lot to consider but it is that is what it's asking to do is asking us consider regulations requiring micro-mobility. It's not saying implement. And I think there is going to be a lot to consider because to be on the road I imagine they'd have to be in an registered or inspected vehicle and that might lead to having [32:23] sidewalk speed limits or something because a lot of these people are using these because they have lost their license and are using them to get to work. So, I think there's a lot to discuss but this what it's asking is to consider regulations regarding it and I that's I second it. [32:40] What [32:41] Would it be in a way it seems like 3.17 is suggesting that something like section 3.18 eventually be developed, perhaps by people with a little more insight or expertise than we might have. but if we were to [33:03] I think that argues for perhaps not having 3.18 at all. But would you consider 3.18 as reading simply consider regulations regarding micro-mobility devices traveling at speeds of 30 mph or higher? [33:22] And then leave it for leave it for the experts, so to speak, to figure out what that [33:30] I don't know that I would even limit it to devices traveling at speeds of 30 mph or higher. I might just say consider regulations of micro-mobility devices and leave it up to the public safety experts to develop those regulations. [33:47] I think Maureen hits a happy medium there. [33:51] Chelsea? [33:53] Ricardo? [33:54] just as a reminder, you all have a motion on the floor in a second. so you have different options here. if you'd like to amend the language cuz it sounds like you all are actually getting to amend the language or if you'd like more time, you always have the option of moving this further down the line to discussion during the public comment period. [34:20] I think we can work through this. [34:22] Okay. [34:23] I'd I'd like to try at least to see if we get some amendments to the motions that are on the floor and Yes. [34:30] Chelsea? [34:30] I just have one more thought or question, I guess. Where did the 30 mph come from? Like has the police department advised on that? I guess [34:43] I guess where did that come from? Specifically the 30 mph, that seems almost arbitrary, which makes me think it came from somewhere. [34:53] That was from Sam. And so, unfortunately, she's not with us this evening, but I can ask her where she got that information from. Most likely a transportation resource that she's aware of. [35:11] I'm going to ask if [35:16] ask if the person who made the motion and the person who made the second want us to vote on this on the motion or whether you would consider an amendment. Want to ask. And we can do it either way. [35:30] Having made the motion, I would like to amend and maybe change the language. And I guess [35:39] based upon the discussion we've already had, I guess I'd like to add board of 3.1.7. [35:49] And we're talking about create resources and guidelines. I think we do have to move the development of regulations concerning and I agree I think there is an issue why 30 mph. I agree too that [36:12] they're they are a bike, so, you know, bike lanes would be preferable for use as opposed to sidewalks, certainly. But I think that we do need to consolidate language from 0.8 to 0.7. And I guess I'd like to see the word consider regulations [36:34] as well as creating resources and guidelines. [36:41] And Riley, were you the second? [36:44] I was the second and I would also be open to just changing the changing the language of 3.1.8. [36:53] So, should that should we do that by making an amendment to the motion or should we do that by kicking it to the discussion with the other [37:03] Why don't we Why don't we kick it to later? Or you can simply withdraw your motion, withdraw the second, and we'll ask for another motion right now. [37:14] Withdrawn. [37:17] Withdrawn. [37:18] Okay. perhaps not the most Robert's Rules of Order way of going about it, but we've done that and now the question before us is whether we adopt sections 3.1.7 and 3.1.8 or whether we do something along the lines, perhaps, [37:39] of what Maureen has suggested. So, I'm going to ask Maureen if she would care to make a motion. [37:46] I would like to make a motion that we recommend language in 3.1.7 to read collaborate with partners to create resources, guidelines, and regulations for micro-mobility devices such as e-bikes and e-scooters. And that we eliminate the language proposed in section 1. [38:08] 3.1.8 and do not recommend that language. I would also recommend make a motion that we consolidate the responsible groups from 3.1.7 and 3.1.8 into 3.1.7 so that police department, public services, engineering, and public works are also considered. [38:35] Well said and seconded. [38:37] Then moved and seconded. [38:41] Any discussion? [38:46] Seeing none, all in favor of the motion [38:50] passes unanimously. Thank you. [38:55] I'll just add a note to this. The performance metric will also be updated to align with the language the new language in T3.1.7. [39:05] I assume the short terms and medium terms are things that staff alone [39:10] Yeah. [39:10] is doing, right? [39:14] [laughter] [39:17] Don't want our input on that. [39:19] We always accept your input and value your voice. [39:25] [clears throat] [39:30] Okay, we will move to page five. [39:34] This was a discussion on maintenance of pedestrian infrastructure during the winter. There's an existing action item T3.1.3, and here the recommendation would be just to specify the language in this action item to read amend ordinances to prioritize pedestrian safety, ease of access, and year-round usability including provisions for enhanced maintenance of brick, uneven, or ice-prone materials on sidewalks and walkways, and alternatives to sidewalks and walkways constructed entirely of brick. [40:12] The performance metric would also be updated to align with the new language. [40:26] I'll move that we recommend section T3.1.3 [40:32] to the city council. [40:35] Second. [40:39] Any discussion on this item? [40:42] All in favor. Unanimous. [40:55] We'll move to page six. This conversation included regulating a number of parking spaces, exploring parking maximums, and amending speed limits to lower speeds. This manifested in two into two different action items. T3.2.6, which reads, "Amend chapter 46, section 46-175 to reduce design speeds for streets and roads." And action item T3.2.7 [41:20] to amend chapter 60, article V to require off-street parking maximums for all commercial, industrial, and multi-family residential land uses. [41:33] And the associated responsible groups, timeline, and performance metrics would be added as well. [41:45] So, it's just part of the discussion. [41:46] I know in the current ordinance we have parking minimums. How would this kind of go into play with having a parking maximum as well? [42:00] [42:03] I think that it this is a my suggestion and what I'm what I'm trying to get at is there are there are land use guidelines as what the minimum number of spaces you might need for a particular use. whether it's an apartment complex or a shopping center or whatever. [42:26] And I would prefer to see that minimum number be the required number. rather than an unlimited number of spaces which I think under our current ordinance is possible. You know, you might need 96 spaces for an apartment complex and the developer says, "Yeah, but I'd like to have 180." [42:51] And so, you've got an extra two acres of parking because that's what the developer wants to do and our ordinances don't don't give us an opportunity to say no. So I would like to reduce the amount of unnecessary pavement that comes along with development projects. Does that answer you? [43:23] I'll move adoption of T 3.2.6 and T 3.2.7 [43:33] as shown in this document to the city council. [43:38] Second. [43:42] Bob? I guess as written, I would not be in favor if we're maybe to consider have a conversation and maybe consider [44:02] But I guess I know developments that we've had before us that you're right, some developers want to put in some additional parking and I think it's to be expected that as more and more people maybe in apartments, but they still have not just vehicles [44:23] but trailers, campers, boats so I think that it would be tough for us to you know, really set some sort of a maximum. So I'm not in favor as written. [44:43] I agree with Bob. I would not be in favor of 3.2.7 just as someone with a larger vehicle that struggles to find parking sometimes. I wouldn't be in favor of limiting discretionary parking. [45:06] Any other comments? [45:11] All in favor of the motion? [45:16] All opposed? [45:19] The motion fails. [45:27] Do we want to do an amended motion to adopt 3.2.6? [45:34] I made a motion to adopt both. [45:39] Would you entertain a motion to adopt one? [45:44] Yes, I'm sure. [45:45] I'd like to make a motion that we adopt the changes shown in T3.2.6 to amend chapter 46, section 46-175 to reduce design speeds for streets and roads. [46:01] I'll second that. [46:05] It's been moved and seconded. Is there any discussion on recommending to council adoption of T3.2.6? [46:14] All in favor? [46:17] It passes unanimously. [46:27] We will move to page seven. This is the parks and recreation section. [46:31] [cough] [46:33] This conversation was about snowmobiling trails and snowmobile trail maintenance. This manifested into action item PR 1.2.8 that reads, "Coordinate with local organizations and volunteer programs to create and expand awareness, report maintenance needs, and identify improvement projects to maintain trails, and ensure access in all seasons." [46:54] With the associated responsible group, timeline, and performance metric adjustments. [47:04] As [47:05] [clears throat] [47:05] Riley [47:06] to add or not to add to this, but to add to what this could also address is from the public comment of the public hearing cuz this doesn't this is with the snowmobile trails were brought to the discussion up, but this is in the parks and recreation [47:27] under objectives improve park, trail, and open space stewardship and maintenance. And I will [clears throat] want to hope that this also would and I'm going to propose to make these changes, but that this would also address the crowd that was in here talking about the skate park along the river walk and how they could be considered a local organization [47:50] to coordinate with in order to do the report maintenance needs and identify improvement projects. So, and with that I would move to make to accept these to recommend these changes to city council. I have a PR 1.2.8 [48:08] as presented. [48:16] Second it. [48:17] And moved and seconded. [48:20] Can we does is staff able to clarify whether or not this encompasses Riley's concern? [48:27] I was just going to address that. Yes, so I was going to recommend adding at the end of the sentence and identify improvement projects to maintain parks, trails, and open space and ensure access in all seasons would align with the policy one language as well as objective two language to include all three of those, parks, trails, and open space. [48:57] Can I withdraw my [49:01] I with I'm sorry. I withdraw my motion and move to accept PR 1.2.8 including the amendment that Lauren just highlighted. [49:18] Second agrees. [49:21] You mind then just for the record telling us reading it maybe in its entirety. [49:26] Yes. So, this action item PR 1.2.8 would read coordinate with local organizations and volunteer programs to create and expand awareness, report maintenance needs, and identify improvement projects to maintain parks, trails, and open space, and ensure access in all seasons. [49:47] Can I interject a grammatical change? Should we put a comma between the word projects and two? Cuz grammatically it's kind of a singular. If we add a comma, it opens up more variables. [50:05] Yes. [50:07] Everybody willing to accept the comma? [50:12] They call those Oxford [50:17] I don't know if that's what it is, but I never get a chance to say that. [50:22] All right. With that one final non-substantive but substantive suggested change, all in favor? [50:32] That passes unanimously. [50:44] Moving to page eight, this discussion was looking at amending public access to all water bodies and around Taylor Pond. Because Taylor Pond is privately owned and concerns over the Lake Auburn as a drinking water supply. And so, PR 1.1.4 would have an addition to address this. The action item would read, "Identify and assess potential locations for new or expanded public boat launches and waterfront access points across Auburn's major water bodies [51:14] where feasible and in line with community identified priority locations. Incorporate long-term maintenance, safety planning, and operational resilience into waterfront access projects." [51:38] So, the additional language being [51:42] for our consideration is where feasible and in line with community identified priority locations. [51:50] [clears throat] [51:52] Yes, before I ask for a motion, I'll ask That's not our language. That was yours. You came back and said that we couldn't that we couldn't preclude certain water bodies. [52:04] That's correct because it is a state requirement and Taylor Pond is a great pond. [52:08] So, what does where feasible and in line with community identified priority locations mean? [52:14] This is similar to the action items where we have consider or other language that doesn't mandate the city to do something. It opens up the conversation to have with the community and identify areas that would be feasible in order to do this action item. And so, instead of mandating that we're identifying all access points within the city that are could be for boat launches, [52:38] this would make sure that the city follows an engagement process to ensure alignment with what the community would need. [52:46] Is it reasonable to assume the term feasibility would encompass legal property ownership and access? [52:52] I would hope so, yes. [52:55] It is intended to include that. [52:57] Yes. [53:03] I make a motion to approve PR 1.4.1 [53:07] with the revisions as written. [53:10] Seconded. [53:12] Been moved and seconded. Any discussion on PR 1.4.1? [53:20] All in favor? [53:23] Unanimous. [53:33] We will move to page nine. This is the infrastructure section, excuse me. This was stemmed from a conversation about digital equity initiatives and broadband expansion. This manifested into two action items, I 1.2.3 and I 1.2.4. I 1.2.3 reads, "Partner with organizations to inventory and map Auburn's broadband network and digital literacy capacity by collecting data on service availability, [54:02] typical speeds, reliability, and other information, identifying underserved geographic geographies and populations." I 1.2.4 reads, "Develop a digital equity and broadband expansion plan or policy." [54:15] And with the associated changes to the responsible group, timeline, and performance metric. [54:30] I make a motion that we recommend the language proposed in I 1.2.3 and I 1.2.4. [54:44] Second. [54:46] Been moved and seconded. Is there any discussion on I point I 1.2.3 or 1.2.4? Yes, Cathy. [54:56] Thank you. I've had a number of folks ask me to define digital equity. Can you do that, please? [55:04] Sure. I'll take a stab at that. digital equity is a concept that broadband access is on par with utility services and universal access should be a goal in the medium and long term. Obviously, it's not something that can be accomplished immediately, but I think as broadband deployment [55:29] gets a lot of support at both the state and federal level through grants it's imperative that we ensure that everyone in the community has access whether through their own personal connections or through publicly available connections. [55:46] Thank you for that. [55:51] Any other questions or comments? [55:55] If none, all in favor of the motion? [55:59] Passes unanimously. [56:02] [clears throat] [56:16] We will move to page 10. This was about a discussion on a stormwater fee. And so it manifested in I 1.3.9. This action item reads, "Explore establishing a stormwater management utility fee index to impervious area to reduce impervious surface cover and protect water quality." [56:40] I thought we were going to add language that would exclude residential property. [56:49] So we've reviewed the record and reviewed the meeting and you all explored that, but then came up during the discussion about larger subdivisions, residential subdivisions. and then in reviewing the record there was no certainty on whether you wanted to put residential in or not. [57:15] Yeah. And that's actually the reaction that you had when we brought that up at the last meeting as well. [57:22] Perhaps we could make a motion to amend this to include single-family residential properties. [57:28] Exclude. [57:29] Exclude single-family residential properties. [57:37] All residential? [57:38] No, exclude single-family residential properties. [57:43] Riley. [57:43] I think that that would be something that could be considered you know as we're exploring establishing the fee. I think this directive is similar to the other one where we can when we're establishing it exclude at that point residential and have a longer discussion about it if we need to. [58:06] But I think this language allows for both things to happen. [58:14] I would argue for allows for both, there's no reason not to say it now. [58:24] I just have a question. I just I just I'm trying to understand. When you say exclude single-family residences, [58:34] [snorts] [58:34] do you mean exclude a single-family residence being built or single-family residential developments that are putting you know that are putting in 20 or 100 homes? I guess I'm personally I'm just trying to understand very clearly. Thank you. [58:54] I think it was Marine's language, but I would think it excludes the home. It wouldn't exclude the road network built to access the homes, sidewalks and all of that. [59:09] My thought was that individual property owners of single family homes would not be penalized for their paved driveway and maybe an extension where they park their camper or their boat. As the from my perspective the meaning of this is for larger paved [59:31] parking areas and such and I think that delineation is necessary. [59:40] That's That's why I think there's going to I think there's probably even more things that were is it not coming to mind that we might want to discuss with that and that's why I think that exploring and establishing them would be where we'd have those discussions and that's why I would not want to preclude anything without having those discussions here. [1:00:02] I guess this is an opportunity as well as any for me to say that I don't view the comprehensive plan as the straight jacket that I sense some people do. I think this is a concept that either with Riley's suggestion that we not mention single family homes [1:00:22] could or could not include them. If it excluded them, it doesn't mean that it couldn't exclude other things as well. it's the concept of trying to control or in some way establish a storm water management utility fee that is [1:00:44] the thrust of what we're discussing. and I think that applies to all of the other action items in a comprehensive plan as well. including the map. [1:01:00] So, where are we? [1:01:03] We're looking for We don't have We don't have a motion yet. [1:01:08] I don't think we have a motion. No. If you mean If that's what you were asking. We're nowhere. [1:01:17] I would move the language before us. and I think it's important. I think it goes back to again, this will be a way of controlling that extra parking that was subject earlier. So, I think that this is a way of [1:01:41] cutting down on asphalt parking areas, etc. [1:01:48] I'll second it. [1:01:53] Been moved and seconded. Is there any further discussion on this [1:01:56] The motion is for as written. [1:01:57] Yes. [1:02:00] Cathy. [1:02:02] I think that I'm not quite [1:02:12] counseling. [1:02:24] I would I would accept an amendment. [1:02:28] Can we get a flavor of the board before you amend, Bob, just to see if it I 'd like us to be able to take some action rather than to vote no. If it's either I don't want a no vote. But, let's see if we might get a yes vote. [1:02:49] If others want to offer their comments. [1:02:51] Yeah. I'm kind of in the same thinking of Riley. I think you know completing the feasibility study, getting the experts involved will give us those options of what is feasible and what can be done in the city as it relates to the storm water fee. And so, I don't want to exclude single family just quite yet. We want to have those conversations with the experts have those conversations as well. [1:03:18] Maureen. [1:03:19] I don't have a strong feeling about this. I do think that the language as is exploring [1:03:26] gives us the flexibility to kind of kick this to the to the comprehensive planning committee and the council to work with other departments to come up with regulations that they think are reasonable. I don't think to your point that this is [1:03:46] constraining them if we if we don't put any limiting language in there. [1:03:57] You're still the master of emotion, Bob. [1:04:03] No, I'm my motion stands, but if somebody wanted to amend it, of course that amendment could be voted upon before vote. [1:04:17] I make motion to amend Mr. Hayes's motion to include the sentence excluding single-family residential properties. [1:04:29] Is there a second to the proposed amendment? [1:04:31] that. [1:04:32] It's been moved, seconded. Is there discussion on the proposed amendment which would exclude specifically single-family residential property? [1:04:48] Okay. All those in favor of the amendment. [1:04:55] Four. All those opposed. [1:04:59] Three. Four three. So, the amendment has passage. So, the amended motion now is [1:05:08] essentially as written comma excluding single-family residential properties. [1:05:21] Is that a fair characterization? Tim? [1:05:24] Yes. [1:05:30] Okay. Any discussion on the [1:05:36] motion as amended? [1:05:42] Any none, all in favor of [1:05:45] It has passed unanimously. [1:05:49] [clears throat] [1:06:08] So now we are on page 11. This is the future land use section of the comprehensive plan. And last time the committee the planning board discussed recommendations or ideas to change the high density core land use category outlined in turquoise to mixed use corridor, mixed use residential, or compact residential. [1:06:31] I'll remind the board that you can as we've been doing motion for different things that you see for this land use category. So it doesn't as it's listed here, it can be mixed use corridor, mixed use residential, compact residential, move to moderate growth, move to low growth, etc. [1:06:49] As a as a reminder for this item, if a motion doesn't pass, then the map proceeds as is. [1:07:00] Proceeds as is. [1:07:02] And what is that? [1:07:03] And the area in the turquoise is a high density core. [1:07:12] As proposed by the comprehensive planning committee. [1:07:15] Correct. [1:07:17] And we're discussing changing it to [1:07:22] So there was no consensus at the prior meeting and so the understanding was that if members of the planning board would like to change then a motion would be offered with that change that they are offering. [1:07:43] Yes. [1:07:45] So [1:07:50] Yeah, I just wanted to kind of kick off the discussion about this. So obviously me and Riley over there on the other end we representatives are part of the planning board members that serve on comprehensive plan committee and this summer was really a lot of the work and the bulk work of what we were doing was going parcel by parcel [1:08:10] going parcel by parcel and you know looking at the city of Auburn seeing where we want to see those high density cores and everything else within that high growth area right whether that be mixed use corridor mixed use residential compact residential etc. and [1:08:31] much of the discussion [1:08:34] around the high growth area was converting a lot of areas of the city that were originally marked as either core mixed use or mixed use residential to compact residential and the compact residential really throughout that process expanded and that part of the map grew as a result of all of the different deliberations that we had on the board on the comprehensive [1:09:01] plan committee and so [1:09:05] So with that information with that context I really strongly going to urge the board to you know move with the CPC's recommendation of the high core and to really hold the line and to not approve of this change or any change to what the comprehensive plan committee suggested as making this area as a high core. [1:09:30] And of course we can have those discussions about whether it's suitable to be a high core as I know we've had those discussions in the past. again I just to point out to that I would say that this is a exploration of what we want the city to look like in the next 10 years. I'm not suggesting having skyscrapers, you know, tomorrow after this you know, city council moves on with this and adopts this project, but what we best what we want to see is what's where in city of Auburn it's best [1:10:00] suited to have those kind of developments where the land is already you know, right for development. and connected to those you know, water and sewer lines and things like that, you know, so I'll just leave it at that. [1:10:18] Is there water and sewer out there? [1:10:20] Yes. [1:10:21] yeah, everything within the high growth [1:10:22] And it yep. [1:10:23] Yep. [1:10:23] Yep. [1:10:24] like I'd like to concur with Bilal. There was a lot of discussion that went into this. It is especially if you zoom out it is trying to create a third city center. And it and it will need not just the area in the triangle to do that. There's a There again there I've to see further this is all our meetings are still on YouTube from the whole summer, right? [1:10:48] Correct? So there's I recommend anyone curious about a longer discussion into this to watch those meetings cuz there was a lot of discussion about this. And I understand that amount of area will it was it was needed to accomplish the goal. So I agree that we should not make this should not recommend this change. [1:11:11] Can you DeCarlo or Lauren tell us [1:11:19] whether in the current proposed high density core any of the other [1:11:29] uses, I guess I'll call them, such as mixed-use corridor uses or mixed-use residential uses are not allowed. [1:11:38] Those aren't precluded in the high-density core when we're talking [1:11:43] So, I didn't mean to interrupt you. Then so, the high-density core just allows for greater latitude of uses than any of the other alternate ones that are listed here. [1:11:51] Correct. And larger scale structures as well. [1:12:00] And do we know how the comprehensive plan committee chose the easterly edge of this [1:12:12] zoning designation and does that coincide with current lot lines or are we proposing a division of lot lines or when the council actually gets around to amending a map could that very nice straight line be a little more jagged if it were to cover lots as opposed to just a straight line? [1:12:34] So, multi-part question. And so, I want to make sure that we're answering each of those questions. and I'm going to let Lauren give additional information about how the line was drawn to [1:12:48] [clears throat] [1:12:49] to begin with. [1:12:51] So, you'll see on the map here the black outlines are parcel boundaries. And so, I'll turn on the high-density core again. So, you can see a majority of the easterly boundary of this high-density core follows existing parcel boundaries. Where it deviates is as we enter getting near Cameron Lane. [1:13:12] It follows this line here. [1:13:17] Is that [1:13:18] topographical feature that it's following? [1:13:21] It is not. However, if that triangle wasn't included in the high-density core, then you would have a different land use category in there and would separating both the parcels to the south and to the north that goes on the other side of the road. [1:13:41] So, this was a logical mid step in doing so to make sure that there are there are some connecting. [1:13:52] Thank you. [1:13:58] Well, I'll be one to speak in, decided opposition to considering this to be a core, cuz I look at description, high-density cores are located at Great Falls Plaza, Auburn Mall, [1:14:22] and surrounding Interstate 675, which I agree to the other side of the railroad, cuz that does fit in with the, commercial, industrial, and, that whole interchange. But, this other [1:14:44] area south of the, the railroad is quite different. And, so, I'd suggest, you know, again, looking at density and form in a core characterized by the highest intensity and scale in the city. [1:15:07] Buildings generally oriented to the street with minimal setbacks and frequent entrances. [1:15:16] And, [1:15:19] s- and streetscape elements, such as lighting, trees, sitting parklets, and other features that support a sense of place. I To me, this is, creating almost, what we consider more of a the mall area or even this is what destroyed our downtown as we try to create [1:15:44] nodes of activity and in the end the more you stretch the activity out to different nodes, it minimizes the existing nodes. So I and I find it interesting too that course precedes downtown. So again, almost seems like we're trying to create a new [1:16:08] well, a new Danville. [1:16:12] So I have to go to you know, we truly are talking about a corridor. We're talking about route 100 and it's a corridor coming up from Portland through grade, New Gloucester and entering Auburn. [1:16:30] So you know, certainly more interested considering corridor use. But I think even mixed-use neighborhood to me respects the opposite side of route 100, which is primarily residential. [1:16:51] Plus I think it 's an area that really lends itself to some needed residential both could be high-end, could be apartments, could be similar development that we're already approved off with the old Danville road. [1:17:11] So it'd be facing residential behind we have areas that now that are right now in ag zone, so it's wooded. The one purple is actually down over this other side of the hill, which is more in brickyard and you know, more in brickyard I believe has allowed [1:17:34] good open area for development cuz I think they've taken the clay off the right-hand side as you enter Auburn. And I think that area was mined for clay to more and brick. So, it is a good area for development, but I really stress the need for a housing and good residential [1:17:57] that has easy access to route to the turnpike. And I think it goes back again, we need housing. We need people to fill jobs that we have. I think we'd find we'd actually attract residents that are trying to find housing in the Portland market, which is high for real estate values, [1:18:22] that they make it easy access for them to commute to Portland. Eventually, I would see with the growing population, that would bring business and hopefully jobs to the area. And that's to me, this area would grow allow the infill around the other colored area around [1:18:46] the exit, but allow this to be a residential corridor coming into Auburn. [1:18:53] Long term, I could see that we would might create a situation, which we already have on Washington Street northbound, which we're now trying to get traffic off of, because it's not a welcoming corridor for people entering Auburn. [1:19:14] I wonder if in the future, suddenly we're going to find ourselves trying to route traffic around this whole area, and come across the Royal River, and swing around Hotel Road, and avoiding going through Auburn entirely. [1:19:34] Thanks, Bob. [1:19:40] Any other thoughts on what to do, if anything, with the future land use map Exit 75 area. [1:19:54] I will move for discussion purposes [1:20:00] that we suggest this being a mixed-use corridor, recognizing this truly is the corridor into our community of Auburn. [1:20:14] Is there a second to the motion? [1:20:19] Cathy. [1:20:20] I'll second that motion. [1:20:21] It's been moved and it's been seconded. Is there any discussion? [1:20:28] Yes. [1:20:29] So, yeah, I'll just push back on that, Bob. one thing in particular, so if you're looking at the description that you mentioned earlier for high-density core, [1:20:44] so I'm just going to read the land use section of that. So, typical uses include a mix of commercial and residential activities. Some buildings are stand-alone businesses or multi-family residential. Other buildings may be mixed-use with active ground-floor retail, restaurants, cafes, personal services, arts, cultural venues, small-scale grocery stores, markets, and community serving services. [1:21:10] further, it goes into public spaces including plazas, pocket pocket parks, and civil civic gathering areas. So, I really think the high-density core is a all of the above kind of approach for any type of development. And moving in the direction of mixed-use corridor would really limit [1:21:33] the type of development we want to see out there. We want to see kind of an all any development that could even go into there to really be creative in the way it approaches it, whether it's housing, whether that's business development, whether that's all the range of things. And I would just also mention cuz I know this will probably be [1:21:54] a source of a lot of a resource for everything that's going to be talked about is the the Auburn City Council Resolve 03-06152026, [1:22:07] which basically highlights the housing needs study and identifying the need for approximately 1,300 to 1,400 additional housing units by 2030. And so [1:22:21] I don't know where else in the city we can put or create 1,300 to 1,400 new housing units, you know? and if we want to see that much development by 2030, which is almost what, 4 years away? [1:22:34] [clears throat] [1:22:34] We're going to need the highest We're going to need areas that are that have the highest amount of density possible in as much space. And this resol- this proposal from the Comprehensive Plan Committee gives us the gives us more, you know, the more amount of space to be able to have those kind of developments. And so, it really would hinder us to turn away from going from high density core [1:22:59] to a mixed-use corridor where we're limiting our development and housing options in that sense. [1:23:10] Anyone else want to comment? [1:23:16] I for the reasons the reason I asked DeCarlo what is allowed in the high density core and found that all of the other uses that are listed in mixed-use corridor, mixed-use residential, or compact residential all could occur there. And I guess I would just leave it to the market to figure out what the development in that [1:23:38] area ought to be. I would not be in favor of this motion. Would support the comprehensive plan committee's proposed designation. [1:23:58] Anyone else want to comment before we vote? Okay. All in favor of the motion to change the area outlined in turquoise to a mixed-use corridor [1:24:13] raise your hand. [1:24:16] All those opposed to that motion? [1:24:20] Motion fails. Two to five. [1:24:27] Is there [1:24:30] Is there any need Perhaps we should confirm it because we've discussed this for a long time. [1:24:39] Rather than just passing it over and letting it stand, maybe we ought to have a vote. See if there's a vote in support of it. [1:24:49] I guess I'm not necessarily asking a question. I'm asking the board, do we want to make a motion Okay, I'm getting a nod to my right. What would that be, Tim? [1:24:59] I make a motion to leave page 11 map future land use map as shown in our packet unchanged. [1:25:10] Second. [1:25:16] Any discussion? [1:25:17] Is that [1:25:18] [clears throat] [1:25:19] Is it a Is this a necessary I thought I was under the understanding by getting voted down that we are just recommending no changes. Is that correct? [1:25:28] Yeah, that's correct. I believe the chair is getting at this is a vote of support for what the comprehensive plan committee has proposed. [1:25:38] Th- Th- Th- That's exactly right. And I just thought since we'd spent so much time discussing it rather than leaving it sort of blank, we could fill in the blank. [1:25:50] Any further discussion on the motion to concur with the comprehensive plan committee's recommend recommendation. If not, all in favor? [1:26:06] All opposed? The motion has That motion passes five to two. [1:26:17] [snorts] [1:26:26] So, we are on page 12. This item is discussing the agricultural, forestry, open space, and recreation land use category description. Planning board conversations to date have been around adding more residential, allowing more residential development in the agricultural, forestry, open space, and recreation land use category. [1:26:49] I'll add that the language here does not have to be similar to the previous motions. The language that the planning board either rejects or accepts as a recommendation is open for discussion. [1:27:02] And to add on to Lawrence's point, again, just as the last item, if there is not a motion to change the language, the language as written would stand. and I would I would point members directly to how the how the language actually reads today and seeing if that supports [1:27:25] what you all [clears throat] have been thinking of. but you all have been very vigilant about the actual wording of the provisions, and so I do welcome that same type of approach here. [1:27:38] [clears throat] [1:27:39] Okay. I'm going to offer my comments. This is my I guess I'm the genesis of this, and it certainly seems to have generated a lot of comment from a lot of people. [1:27:56] first of all, I'm supportive of farming. I'm supportive of rural and you call it views and all of those things. [1:28:07] [clears throat] [1:28:07] And I don't think that simply allowing a residential use in the agricultural zone threatens farming in any way, shape, or form. I think at present, I just want all board members to think about this for a moment. I want you to think about whether farming, and Cathy, you're welcome to chime in, [1:28:32] on less than 10 acres is really a viable use. And then I want you to think about how many lots there are in the agricultural zone that are less than 10 acres in size. Just get a number in your head. [1:28:46] The answer is more than 600. So, you've got more than 600 lots that really can't be used for anything that's allowed, any viable use that's allowed in the agricultural zone. And you've all seen the map and know how much of our city is encompassed in that agricultural zone. [1:29:09] And the taxes in this city are high. There's no doubt about that. And we're sort of fighting that battle with one hand tied behind our back when we take tremendous amount of land area and say, "No to development. No. No to really any type of development other than farming and a sawmill and forest products." But you don't see a lot of those uses out there. [1:29:33] So, I think [1:29:37] I think that the rest of the taxpayers are actually subsidizing the agricultural zone. The taxes, the land values are depressed. Any active farming, I suspect, maybe not all, but most is probably in a current use tax category like farm and open space, [1:29:57] paying very little in taxes as a result, or certainly not market taxes. And I think as Ms. Moore has pointed out as eloquently as anyone, it's just a shame that somebody can't build a house on their land. And I've heard it said by board members, I've heard it said by members of the public that even the chair of the committee, [1:30:24] well, they knew that when they bought it. Well, you know what? That doesn't make it any less confiscatory. It doesn't. And you've got hundreds of lots, hundreds, that people literally can't do anything with. And I don't think that we're protecting farming by not letting residential development occur in the agricultural zone. [1:30:48] If a farmer decides that his or her last crop is going to be houses, that ought to be his or her decision. [1:30:56] And if a farmer wants his daughter to have a house on the land, seems to me they ought to be able to do that. [1:31:06] We need housing, yet [1:31:10] a large chunk, every time we mention a number of acres, Mr. Beal has a different number, so I won't mention a number, but a lawful lot of land is off limits to housing. We got the watershed area, which is in agriculture as well, where you can build three houses a year. Hundreds and hundreds of acres, [1:31:32] three houses a year. [1:31:38] I think that we're not [1:31:42] undoing anything that has existed for years by simply allowing residential uses in the agricultural district. So, I'm going to move this. I came here tonight saying I'm not going to bother, but if Ms. Moore probably hadn't shown up again, then maybe I just would have folded my tent and gone home, but I at least want to be on record for my reasons for this. [1:32:07] I don't I don't think that we're going to be creating urban sprawl by allowing residential uses in the rural area that we call the ag zone. I don't think that Mr. Cleveland's comment on the amount of taxes [1:32:30] to be expended if there's a residence as opposed to if there's no development at all is a cogent argument at all because if you just got a piece of land out there 9.3 acres and nothing on it, I suspect that not a lot of taxes taxable services are required for that parcel. [1:32:52] But, I suspect that it's not generating squat for revenue for the city, either. Whereas, if there was a half million dollar home on it might be generating a little more money. So, that would be my reasoning for why I'd like to see residential while also accommodating residential development [1:33:13] allowed or a part of our recommendation to the council. [1:33:19] So, to that extent, after listening to me, I'll make that a motion. [1:33:24] I will second that motion. [1:33:27] It's moved and seconded. Is there any discussion? [1:33:30] I disagree with [snorts] a good portion of what you said. and I don't know that it's fair to compare it to just farming because it is the AGRP zone and it includes open space and recreation and forestry. It's not just farms. I do think that extending services is it's a There was a study done. [1:33:52] This is a matter of science that it costs more to extend services out of the center of the city. It's a goal of the city to consolidate the development into the cores that we've identified. I think that the [1:34:08] I 've we spoke about it last meeting as well. I don't I do think this would lead to rural sprawl and I don't recommend making these changes. [1:34:23] I would contest that accommodating residential development by no means says the city needs to run water and sewer there. I would say that if a property owner in a rural area wishes to build a home and they have to drill a well and put in septic, well, that's on them and that's their choice. [1:34:43] The increased number of houses, say in the 600 lots, would be 600 to 800 daily trips on the roads that are already it tasks with Auburn's task with more miles of road maintenance than from road maintenance to drive from here to South Carolina, I believe was our stat. And I don't I that is the service not extending water and sewer, but the extension to how much those roads would need repairs and an already [1:35:09] tasked budget for that. so that I would what I mean by extending services I didn't mean water and sewer. I meant the general city services. [1:35:22] Elsie. [1:35:24] [clears throat] [1:35:28] I'm going to agree with everything Riley has said and I'm going to add that [1:35:38] in my opinion this isn't this is not a farming or agriculture or resource protection issue. I mean it is but by definition this is sprawl. I don't know how you can say that this does not incur or encourage [1:36:01] limitless sprawl to every end of the city. And again, in my opinion, to me, it seems like this very simple and danger in my opinion dangerous wording in the vagueness of it essentially negates the entire low growth zone. [1:36:22] To me, this negates huge volumes of what the comprehensive plan actually does in establishing a high growth, a moderate growth, and a low growth zone for 10 years, essentially. [1:36:38] And it negates what this board voted on 1 and 1/2 hours ago on page 1 saying fiscally responsible development for the municipality. We're not talking about adding one or two or 10 houses. You said yourself there's there's hundreds of lot. This is going to create hundreds of homes rapidly [1:37:01] in every corner of the city. And it's not a matter of water or sewer. You're talking about adding fire departments, fire stations. [1:37:14] And like Danville or something like substations, police, school bus routes. You're adding you Th- This is sprawl by definition, which the comprehensive plan expressly does not want. And it And it really again, in my opinion, the way I see it, I don't know if this is technically correct, but it seems to me it really [1:37:41] just voids the entire low growth zone and kind of turns everything into just moderate growth. And I don't think this is wise [1:37:52] at all. I think this is really [1:37:57] treacherous territory. and I think we need to take into consideration the [1:38:06] hundreds of comments that we've had over 2 years and a 17-member committee that have established high, moderate, and low growth zones for reason and have explicitly agreed that they want to maintain these open spaces and these low growth areas for a reason and specifically limit urban sprawl. [1:38:31] So, I am going to agree with Riley and I'm going to say that this page should be eliminated. The red language should be eliminated. [1:38:48] I don't see the I don't see the horrible hypo that New and Riley anticipate. I don't expect 600 homes will be built, but if so, well, that's what the market is asking for. We're talking I understand that we're supposed to reach 1,300 in a few years. Well, okay. [1:39:09] Let's take some of our resources and devote them to that and I don't expect that would happen. I don't think that by allowing residential uses in an agricultural zone, that you're necessarily going to have a flurry of subdivision activity. [1:39:30] but if you do, you do. Sprawl is occurring right outside our limits. All the roads in West Auburn are in very nice shape for the people in Turner and Minot who have built over the line. I see construction traffic by my house [1:39:52] daily. None of it's stopping in Auburn. They're all building in Minot and they're all using our roads. So, the sprawl is happening. You're just letting it leapfrog [1:40:04] the entire rural area of Auburn and instead be around the fringes of the city. I don't see the calamity that you're all anticipating. And if it were truly low growth [1:40:25] I would have no objection to that because that would include residential uses. But what we're talking about is not low growth, we're talking no growth. We're talking keeping the city as it was 50 years ago because we're afraid of the potential cost involved. [1:40:46] So instead we're going to build apartment buildings that generate a fraction of the tax value that single-family residences would generate. and we're going to struggle to meet housing quotas and we're always going to have one hand tied behind our backs when it comes to generating taxable revenue for the city. [1:41:10] At Ed's point is valid. I don't see an explosion of any kind of [1:41:19] nefarious activity. For me what I see is the opportunity for people that own land that they're not allowed to build on can build their home. Or a home, their home. That argument resonates very deeply with me. it's part of the American dream. [1:41:40] And for people to say you know, you own this property, but now you can't live on it. That's that's contrary to what I think is a core quality of this country. [1:41:57] Anyone else? Kathy? [1:42:00] My turn. [1:42:03] Thank you all. I don't think that there has been one single issue that has generated as much conversation in the past 10 years as this that we're looking at tonight. And just a change of 1 2 3 4 5 words. [1:42:23] You may not think it would be a cavalcade of housing, but I can tell you that it will be. Farming is flexible. Agribusiness is can be immense. Whether we've got 600 lots or 1,000 lots, [1:42:45] you don't have to farm on 100 acres. You can farm on a quarter acre or 1 acre and make a fairly significant living. Our regulations for this zone have been loosened in the past 3 years by hours and hours and hours [1:43:08] of people in our community working to make this a zone that we can look at now and in the future as a preserved area [1:43:23] with a use for our communities. We are seeing more people want to build farming or agribusiness businesses in this area. I disagree with you about housing. [1:43:43] Every week I get conversations, telephone calls, emails, letters from people that want to develop. That's all they want. And they're honest about it. They'll buy that land that I've got and they want to put houses. They don't want to build businesses. They want to put houses. [1:44:05] So, I understand your position. I understand the position of many, people that have also spoken. But we have created [1:44:18] new language that will allow people to build a secondary home, secondary use home on their land. [1:44:28] Every zone we have in our city has restrictions. [1:44:33] Every zone. I can't have pigs downtown, but I can have six chickens, no roosters. [1:44:41] You all have We all live within certain limits, and we all have the right to express our own opinions, and I appreciate this time, and I appreciate all of your opinions. I do hear them, and I do understand them. But I won't support this as it's written. Thank you. [1:45:04] I'll call for a vote. All in favor of the motion? [1:45:08] All opposed? [1:45:11] Could we hear the motion again? [1:45:14] the motion is to adopt the red [1:45:19] what's in red on page 12, [1:45:23] which is while also accommodating residential development, and eliminating, and generally secondary to agriculture, forestry, natural resource, and recreation uses. [1:45:43] And so a vote yes would adopt the language as written right now. [1:45:48] Correct. [1:45:52] Taking out the other We're talking about just [1:45:57] the first paragraph or the second paragraph as well? [1:46:01] It would be to approve page 12 in its entirety as you see it in the packet. [1:46:06] As a recommendation to city council. [1:46:17] I would not be supporting it for sure. I guess for all the reasons already stated. And I think, you know, one was already touched on, but it has an effect on all of us paying insurance. residential insurance, business insurance. again, going back years, I've listened to, [1:46:39] particularly when it comes to fire and police, a big factor in what we pay, all of us pay it for insurance, is, how quickly we can provide necessary emergency services, response time. [1:47:01] The further we stretch out, response time increases. As that time increases, our rates go up. So, that's another hidden cost that quite often we overlook. So, not only do the infrastructure costs increase, [1:47:21] but as a result also, we all pay more cuz our interest our insurance rates will go up. [1:47:31] Well, we were in the midst of voting, I'd offer my thoughts. [1:47:36] Yeah. [1:47:36] Yes. [1:47:36] you know, over the last couple weeks I've kind of really been grappling with this. I think [1:47:46] like leave no stone unturned, you know, you know, I really think and part of the reason why I came on this, you know, planning board was to serve as a way to reduce sprawl in the city. I think sprawl is the enemy. Point blank. [1:48:06] In the status quo, however, I can't say there isn't any sprawl going on. And I don't want to pick out any particular developments, but we see developments happening kind of like how Chelsea described in different corners of the city in the status quo. And if that continues to happen, [1:48:27] I mean, we're already in that. We're already in that kind of scenario that's already been kind of touched upon today. And so, referencing back to the housing study that I mentioned earlier, I think that is a significant need that the city council would be wise to [1:48:47] you know, heavily address head-on. And I think changes presented here today would allow for that kind of you know, steadily moving towards that goal, you know? And so, So, yeah, I'm leaning towards moving in favor of this recommendation. [1:49:08] Well, I guess we 're all commenting further, so I'm just going to offer this further observation. if we were to allow residential use in the agricultural zone [1:49:27] along any road front, so that parcels with road frontage, say, I'll pick an arbitrary number back 500 ft, [1:49:40] they're eligible for residential development. I think that would go a long way. So, I don't think that simply adding this verbage, while also accommodating residential development, is necessarily going to open a floodgate to subdividing [1:50:01] the back 40. it could be that the council would take that recommendation and make all land in the agricultural zone where appropriate available for residential uses if along if along a road, for example. no additional road building taking place, [1:50:24] but allowing people to utilize their land and to help alleviate a housing shortage. And it's a particular type of housing. You know, it's a chance to build a house and build some equity as opposed to paying a landlord rent in an apartment, which is all we're getting these days. [1:50:47] Does anybody else want to be heard before we move to a vote? [1:50:50] Just a quick question. In the resource protection zone, are ADUs allowed? [1:50:59] By state law, anywhere we allow a single-family homes, you also must allow ADU. in the act today, if a single-family home is allowed on that lot, you also must also allow an ADU. but doesn't mean that it doesn't have to be accessory to that primary use that's that's permitted in that area. [1:51:21] one other point of clarification is that if it's a non-conforming use, the house or a dwelling is a non-conforming use, you also must allow an ADU on that same lot within the same types of regulations. [1:51:37] I just raised that question cuz it seems to me some of the issue is that families is a can get along years wanting to maybe move themselves into a smaller unit allowing the younger generation to move in the old homestead. [1:51:57] So, I'm hearing that a lot of these even existing homes in the ag area could see a additional dwelling unit on those lots. [1:52:12] It 's possible and so zoning works on we enable things to happen, but it's based off of the owner of that property actually coming forward and actually proposing something. [1:52:27] Thank you. [1:52:33] Nothing further. All in favor of the motion. [1:52:39] All opposed. [1:52:42] Four. Motion fails by a vote of three four. [1:52:47] We are left with the language as originally proposed by the county [1:53:01] That yet our previously reviewed and [1:53:07] Yes. [1:53:08] Yes. [1:53:09] Yes. so at this time, it would be up to the board and members of the board to bring up any of the public comments that you've heard during the public hearing or any time prior to that to bring up any type of changes that you'd like to, put forward at this time. [1:53:30] Are we Are we going to be, Are we going to be formulating the text that we would be recommending today cuz this is the last meeting we have before [1:53:46] we recommend to city council. [1:53:48] You have that option. and so, this is This is your time to put forward motions if you want to. staff would ask if you have a motion to, say it clearly so we can get the language of that motion. and if not, then it's it's going to be up to your board's decision on how you proceed. [1:54:16] Well, I don't know how the rest of the board members, might want to proceed. We do have a summary of comments that made or received I at some point I think in connection with the public hearing that was held on the 14th of October. and there are we've got those comments and then there are apparently emails that we have received. [1:54:41] I think most covering topics that we've been over but perhaps not all. I don't know how to do this other than to go from the beginning and work our way through it. So I will think I will ask any member wishes to take up an item. [1:55:01] We'll go by page on page one. [1:55:04] The only item I wish to talk about really is item four on page one. I'm curious to hear more about Mr. Romick and Chappelle's inquiry. [1:55:17] Let me just ask if there are any other items on page one that anyone want to discuss. Get them on the table. Riley [1:55:25] Yes, [clears throat] I 'm now trying to find where to appropriately make a word change to include the LAP bus so number one on the on the sheet but I'm trying to find [1:55:36] Okay. One and four. [1:55:39] And we do have guidance for any of the items and so I 'll let Lauren take it from here. [1:55:46] Yeah, in anticipation that each comment would be brought up by the board, we have responses from the planning department on how that might be incorporated into the comprehensive plan or if the comprehensive plan does address that comment and so on. and so we're ready to either incorporate, answer your questions, make recommendations and so on. [1:56:08] So to Riley's question or concern, you have a ready response. [1:56:13] I do. [1:56:13] Okay. that seems like the shorter item to discuss so let's see if we can tick that one off. Start with item one on page one. [1:56:22] Yes, so Joe Felicia from Auburn mentioned that the LAP bus should be included in the comprehensive plan and the LAP bus program should be expanded. He also mentioned the Casco Bay Trail should be explicitly mentioned. And so our response would be the comprehensive plan does explicitly mention the Casco Bay Trail. See page 174 T2.1.4 [1:56:44] and T2.1.5 in the implementation table. The comprehensive plan also mentions the LAP bus in the inventory and analysis section page 409. In the goals, policies and objectives section, the comprehensive plan avoids using organizational names in case of name changes. So if the LAP bus ever becomes the PAL bus, [1:57:06] we're out of luck more or less if we're following it very strictly. and so we avoided using that to keep it broader to multiple different organizations. [1:57:16] If there's a preference by the board to explicitly include the LAP bus in implementation table, that's something we can consider. It was not previous practice by the comprehensive plan committee. [1:57:29] That addresses my interest in it. Thanks. [1:57:34] So when it's I could [1:57:36] Yes. [1:57:36] so when you say Lauren that in the inventory and analysis is it just stated there like the LAP is a you know, is a bus service? There's there's no actual like plan to continue it or support it or anything like that. I think that's kind of [1:57:53] what the gentleman was implying was continuing that service as I know it's on a pilot program with MDOT currently. [1:58:00] Yes, so it in the inventory analysis it states that it exists. the inventory analysis was a point in time data collection for the city. In the implementation table in the transportation section, there are action items pertinent to public transportation and looking at bus services and other active transportation modes of transportation that aside from vehicles, cars I should say, single use cars. [1:58:24] so that was the broader mention, but the LAP bus and expanding it is not explicitly mentioned. [1:58:31] Why not? Did the cut Did the comprehensive plan committee not think it a worthwhile process or did they offer any comment that I Are they sup- Do they have a position? Do we want to have transit like the LAPASS bus service between Lewiston, Auburn, and Portland? [1:58:55] Yes, it was expressed by the comprehensive plan committee in support of transit options between the cities and connecting Auburn to other areas in the state. [1:59:06] Does it just say other areas? [1:59:09] I can pull up the language in the comprehensive plan for you if you'd like. [1:59:12] If you It's a positive [1:59:15] Yes. [1:59:15] statement though, much like I think Joe was looking for. [1:59:19] Correct. It is. [1:59:20] Can you do the same for us regarding the Casco Bay Trail? [1:59:24] Find in the comprehensive plan where it's mentioned. [1:59:27] Or tell us other than it being an inventory item, is that the extent of it? [1:59:33] For the Casco Bay Trail piece, it was explicitly mentioned that the city would like to support the expansion and connection to the Casco Bay Trail through the Washington Street Corridor and other initiatives. it also mentions the East Coast Greenway as a connection point with the Casco Bay Trail. [1:59:52] Really? [1:59:52] Yeah, I guess I wasn't realizing that the specificity of naming one program was what we were avoiding cuz it does in the in the transportation policy section of the first objective to public transportation is mentioned in the first paragraph, and it does cover the needs. It doesn't say expanding of any program, but it says that public transportation plays a vital role in economic activity and quality of life. [2:00:18] Many Auburn residents and employees rely on transit, walking, or biking to access jobs, school, health care, shopping, community services. It goes on, but public transportation is the first word in that paragraph. So actually I'm comfortable with it. [2:00:35] I sense that the board is satisfied with the existing comprehensive plan language on this topic. [2:00:44] And we'll move on to number four on page one, which is a question about a proposed I wouldn't call it a zone line, but a proposed What is that? And why is it where it's located? [2:00:59] Yeah, absolutely. so, this is this came from a public comment during your public hearing, where one of the landowners, who is developing housing, mentioned that in this portion of the map, basically what's going on is that there's only a strip of land that is outside of the industrial district, and the current industrial district, I'm sorry, the industrial land use, encompasses [2:01:25] some areas that have single-family homes on it. residential homes on it. and so, their proposal is to expand downward into the industrial land use the Mishawum Is it Mishawum neighborhood? [2:01:40] Compact residential. [2:01:42] residential. Sorry, it's green on this [2:01:44] The colors are switched around. I will pull up our future land use map. [2:01:47] Yeah. [2:01:48] So, you can see what this looks like in the comp plan here. [2:01:59] Oops. So, the proposal you see this red outline. [2:02:07] This and it kind of pushes the blue towards the existing purple. I'm going to go back to our future land use map. [2:02:17] That red line is along this area where my mouse is. And so, the public comment was to extend the yellow, which is our compact residential land use category, to into this residential this industrial land use category. And so, I'm going to outline it even clearer for you. [2:02:37] to stop for a moment, Lauren. So, what's yellow on the screen is purple on our picture. Yes. And what's purple on the screen is blue. [2:02:45] Yes. [2:02:46] Okay. All right. [2:02:47] And what's yellow is the two properties owned by the people that gave public comment. [2:02:57] So, why is the [2:03:01] Why is the purple, aka yellow, where it is? Is that running along the back of existing property lines? [2:03:12] No, it's it's a buffer from that road that you see on the screen today. And I believe the original intent was it's it's keeping in mind that there are residential properties here today and that we know that we needed some buffering from the industrial uses, but this was a thought of and encompassing all of those. [2:03:32] One thing to note is that there are many properties in Auburn and so, this is just one of those areas that we did not apply the rule of moving the line as we have in other areas. If we would have moved the line to as we have in other areas, I think I think the general rule was 80% you would go to that land use. [2:03:57] And so, that would push this whole entire area into an industrial land use would leave a strip of literal residential uses into industrial. And so, I think this was one of the compromises in between. [2:04:11] Yeah, I'll add that the existing line here between the yellow and the purple follows existing zoning boundaries. So, there was no intention by the comprehensive plan committee to have the yellow extend south east of Poland Road. It was following our existing zoning. [2:04:28] And could you clarify again on the map the specific parcels in question that the gentlemen were you're about? [2:04:34] Yes, I'll go back to this one here. Zoom in. [2:04:41] And this I'll note that the folks that gave public comment that are speaking to this mentioned that they're open to movements of this line. And so, if it's bumping this line here on Breton over to this to the east or to the west, but this is the general gist of what they're asking. [2:05:02] So, well, I think we're kind of putting the cart before the horse. So, they recently acquired these properties knowing the current zoning map and are wishing to do things outside of what they already knew was allowed to occur. Is that correct? [2:05:23] That would be an an accurate description of what they're looking to do. one thing of note though is that because they're residential properties, cuz in residential property is not a permitted use in industrial district. this means that sometime in the past this area did allow residential uses and as such over time moved to industrial uses. [2:05:48] And so, it's one of those things that development it moves in waves. And so, now, you know, you have a you have a in a situation where it is industrial today. Correct? And if you continue to have industrial, the people who own that land can start to do industrial uses closer to the residential uses. [2:06:12] And in fact, it already has occurred. so, in this area is mostly residential uses except for What's it, Surf? [2:06:21] Servpro. [2:06:22] Servpro. There's a building with Servpro that has now been created right in the back and near residential uses. And so, now you're we're in the situation where kind of decisions have to be made as are we going to encourage more industrial uses closest to that residential line or it we going to move the line further back with a proposed change to encompass this area to south of it. [2:06:45] But, this scenario is, "Hey, we just bought this property knowing what we could do to it. We want you to move the line so we can really do what we wanted to do with it." Is that a correct estimation? [2:06:55] I think they've already built on it, right? They've built They've already developed two of the houses. [2:07:00] Correct. Correct. They have built a number of residential dwellings and residential uses within the area that is allowed today. I'm going to leave the description of what they're proposing to you and not to get into that myself. [2:07:15] Well, I Well, I thought from Do you need to say more? I thought from the comments on the 14th that [2:07:30] I don't know who said it, maybe I'm imagining it, but that the land south of the purple to that Is that a railroad at the lower right-hand corner? [2:07:41] Correct. [2:07:42] It is really probably not lending itself to industrial use. I mean, how many how much depth are we talking about between the railroad and the back of those residential lots right now? What 's Can you tell on that map? But, I mean, are we talking 1,000 ft or 500 ft or [2:08:06] So, we can measure from the other map. One thing of note of one thing that they did bring up is that if people wanted to do residential uses in these areas, they would have to go through a residential property to then get to develop anything industrial use. so, that is one point that they did bring up. [2:08:23] Do we allow that? Can you have an industrial use that passes through a residential lot in the city? [2:08:29] I believe in certain situations you can. there are specific provisions that pertain to commercial uses and directions through residential uses. I'm not going to say it's every time it's going to be okay, but there are certain provisions in the zoning ordinance today that directly address that. [2:09:00] Roughly a thousand feet in depth [2:09:04] from Poland Road to the railroad. [2:09:14] And what type of industrial uses can we imagine would occur in that strip of land? [2:09:22] And being appropriately set back from the residential uses that are there, whatever the requirements are for setbacks, etc. [2:09:30] By your provisions today, any of those that are listed as permitted uses. as you can see, SERVPRO has already gone into this area, so how much area you have is what you can what you can put up. It's it's going to be up to the private market to decide. [2:09:47] basically a cleaning company? They've got vans and employees, and they come and they go. They've got a tin building. [2:09:54] Correct. [2:09:54] really an industrial, they're not manufacturing, they're not making smell and noise and dust and what have you. We're looking for residential development in this city. We're looking not to do it in the agricultural zone. why isn't that land better suited for residential development? [2:10:14] What really is likely to happen out there that's going to be an industrial nature, and do we not have enough industrial land that isn't cheek and jowl with residential development already? [2:10:28] So one thing I will note is that you need some buffer between industrial and residential uses, especially in a situation where you have areas that allow residential uses right next to uses that industrial uses are provided. So some type of buffer is recommended in this area. The distance and exactly where that is going to be up to to policy makers. [2:10:52] I agreed. Under understand. [2:10:57] What is the folly in your professional planner here? What 's the folly in making that purple area a immediately and I'm not just interested in the two lots the gentleman came in about, but rather all of that land that extends down to the railroad. What's the harm that you can envision in making that a residential? [2:11:19] The railroad. I would I would I would directly mention the railroad itself. this is an active area as far as intermodal goes. And so, anytime that you are getting close to any type of that situation, there is a potential for adverse consequences. [2:11:40] in this area specifically, you know, you want to have a little bit of protection from rail for any times that a rail derails or anything like that or any type of spills. And so, you know, these are messy things that happen in industrial areas. That's why you have industrial areas in the first place. And so, you want to have some separation between those type of potential uses and residentials [2:12:06] residences. [2:12:08] and if I may, this is public knowledge to anyone that was observant or knowledgeable of the area, that railroad the rail line directly goes into a chemical transloading plant. And all the rail cars are chemical carrying rail cars. It's low speed, but that's [2:12:29] within less than a mile of the plant they're going to. And the concern of [2:12:38] exposure is legitimate. [2:12:41] I understand that, but making a half-mile corridor for a railroad seems a bit excessive to me. Is what you're doing if you think a thousand feet on either side of it is a is a reasonable number. [2:12:55] Lauren, could you pull up what the buffer would be under if there if the proposed change were to occur? [2:13:08] So that's we can't measure that cuz it's not on the GIS. [2:13:13] I can estimate here. If I take this building [2:13:43] I've a question. While they measure that, just out of curiosity, actually exactly where the cursor is, what is that huge giant building? I'm just trying to get my bearings. Does anybody know? [2:13:55] It's a warehouse right on Rodman Road right at the railroad crossing. [2:13:59] Potato chips, isn't [2:14:00] It's potato chips, I believe. [2:14:03] That's the Utz building. [2:14:05] I think. [2:14:08] I think I think that's right. Okay. [2:14:12] Cuz I So as far as distances go, if you go from the end of the right-of-way off of Rock Hill, it's about 370 ft. [2:14:32] So that's I guess that would be the what how I interpret this is that would that remaining buffer be enough of a buffer from residential to the railroad? [2:14:46] I feel like that's the question I'd be asking myself cuz I think that the moving cuz they also mentioned it wasn't a promise or anything, but the reason they that road's being chosen is cuz they could potentially extend that road. And they were and they were willing to pave that like we when we were mentioning a couple meetings ago about new public roads, they had they had I believe installed that road to the extent that it's on right now on their property. [2:15:12] And I think that I guess I guess I'd think that this is enough of a buffer between what would become residential and the railroad track. And so I would be in favor of the this change. Or some format of this change. [2:15:33] So this is the question of risk. And how much risk as a community you're you're willing to take on. [2:15:45] Well, isn't it [2:15:49] entirely possible that if the council wanted to move that zone line 500 ft it would could do so. That would not be inconsistent with the comprehensive plan if it's adopted and the line is where it is right now. And that's my understanding of the case law in Maine. They wanted to nudge that 300 ft to the south. [2:16:13] They could do that. Do you Do you disagree with that? [2:16:18] I don't disagree with it. it is when we're talking about consistency with comprehensive plans, I always look for direct language that allows those type of changes and it's just [2:16:32] I always like to do analysis before I speak on behalf of what I support that type of change or not a bit a being consistency with the comprehensive plan. And I just I don't know enough about the exact language to feel to speak confidently on your question. [2:16:49] Seems like it's the Pownal road situation that we had last meeting we'll have again at the next one where they're extending the line. [2:16:56] Correct. And in that situation, I directly looked into the current comprehensive plan and pulled the exact language that to for consistency. [2:17:04] If it if it if it adds certainty then [2:17:10] Riley I could support an adjustment of that proposed land use map line. [2:17:20] For ease, if that is the case, then I would propose that to making straight lines as we have done in other areas. and in this case, it would be a straight line between the edges of the other proposed. If you can pull up the other map, it's a lot easier to see over there. [2:17:42] And you can see here if you're pulling anything back, the proposal from from staff would extend this line probably to the edge of here and to make sure that there are straighter lines here to corners to make sure it encompasses some range here. It's If not, then it becomes jagged and [2:18:04] it becomes a little bit more difficult to manage. [2:18:10] I would I would not have a problem with that. you can extend it laterally as far as you want. [2:18:18] Okay. [2:18:19] Yeah, I think that's a happy medium. I personally I do not want to see it go to the railroad. I think keeping a section separated is wise and is on the lower risk side. but now I'm I'm comfortable with that cuz I think that [2:18:41] takes it's two birds with one stone kind of deal. I like that. [2:18:46] Before we move any further and in light of your comment about where staff would likely draw that line, can you just for the record, can we identify maybe by map and lot number some in some way which lots you're thinking of bracketing? I can't read the numbers. [2:19:05] Sure. Sure. So, it would be at lots 187048 [2:19:13] to the edge not encompassing but the edge of 188015-001. [2:19:22] and the purpose is extending that line to a straight line backwards. [2:19:29] And the distance from the from the current future land use map the distance into the industrial area is what depth now? [2:19:42] Give me 1 second. [2:19:58] approximately 200 ft. [2:20:03] this is a GIS, so I wouldn't be able to get exact measurements. [2:20:08] I thought we were splitting the difference between the thousand No. No. [2:20:13] Yeah. Yeah. So, I think I think what go if you go back to the last one, we're trying to line it up along the to keep it square so that it matches the section coming off of Poland Road. [2:20:24] Correct. [2:20:25] and I would support that, too, but just as a matter of process. So, for us to recommend this change, we have to have the exact lines drawn out. Is that something that we would have to propose like directing you to section off a trapezoid or is that something that is there a pre- a pre- prepared version of that? [2:20:44] I believe the recommendation would be proposing to extend backwards that line of of compact residential to align with the edge of the lots that we what that we propose. and I think that's going to be suffice as a as a recommendation. and then the comprehensive [2:21:06] the council can decide if that's appropriate or not. [2:21:11] Thanks. [2:21:16] So again the additional land to be made high density compact whatever you're calling that, the yellow. That's about 200 ft. [2:21:27] Correct. You're extending it 200 ft downward. That's not the distance between here and here. It's 200 ft from the existing yellow to the edge. [2:21:39] That leaves 800 ft to the railroad. [2:21:42] that would leave Give me 1 second. [2:21:55] It would leave about 425 ft to the railroad. [2:22:03] So for in accordance with what Riley brought up, the next step would be we would need to see something a little more formal for us to move forward with, correct? [2:22:13] so Riley just brought up you can recommend this change of a of a straight of a straight line or you can request that we present something more formal. you have that option between the two today. [2:22:30] So what I'm getting at is what verbage would I use? What word [2:22:33] [laughter] [2:22:34] Actually, Lauren just said that she could do it today. so if you give us a second, and actually, if you'd like to move on to the next item, by the time that we get back and have this drawn, we would have it drawn for you. [2:22:45] Everyone close your eyes. No. [2:22:47] [laughter] [2:22:51] Then we will turn to page two and see if anything items six through 10 [2:22:58] needs to be dealt with. [2:23:10] Satisfied that we dealt with number six with the an earlier edit to the proposal. [2:23:16] Yeah, I would I think we have included the ability for the skate park in that language in the packet earlier. Yeah, I'm satisfied with that. [2:24:25] Does anybody want to revisit our discussion by talking about number 10? [2:24:32] No? [2:24:41] [clears throat] [2:24:59] Okay, everyone open your eyes. [2:25:03] So, [clears throat] in the outline in yellow can be a part of your motion. [2:25:10] Yellow or orange, however you're seeing that. [2:25:16] Well, it can't be yellow cuz we've already got yellow. That's not the same as the rest of the yellow. [2:25:23] Very true. [2:25:24] We'll call it orange. [2:25:25] Sounds good. [2:25:31] How can I make a motion on a visual aid? I mean, can I even do that? [2:25:38] Yes, and so with the comprehensive planning committee, when they were extending lines, we actually did the same process. And so, it would be it extending the comp the compact residential into the area [2:25:53] To encompass the area highlighted in orange. [2:25:57] Correct. [2:26:07] What does that do to the little cul-de-sac? [2:26:11] Right there, that's sort of a bump out. [2:26:14] So, that's a right-of-way and a and a turn around. and it wouldn't do anything because that's a right-of-way. and so, you can't construct structures or dwellings on right-of-ways. [2:26:28] [clears throat] [2:26:35] All right, I make a motion to consider make a motion to move the compact residential land use category boundary line along Poland Road to encompass the orange [2:26:51] perimetered area shown by staff. [2:26:57] Second. [2:27:02] Seconded. I'll ask first if everyone understands motion. [2:27:09] Here we do. Is there any discussion further on this motion? Cathy. [2:27:15] Thank you so very much. So, my understanding is then that you're going to be extending this those folks not as much did [2:27:30] cross. Is that correct? [2:27:33] And so, the actual the recommendation by the minimum of the public was just to expand it backwards and they weren't to specific on that one thing to do the entire lot. And so, I think that this actually encompasses the ask. [2:27:52] Did my question make sense? [2:27:53] Yeah. Yes. [2:27:54] you. [2:27:56] And isn't it is it feasible for there to be residential development in that additional area? Have we done anything meaningful with that adjustment in that regard? [2:28:09] Yes, I do believe it's feasible. I also believe that the people who recommended that are here. If you'd like to ask directly, but if not, I do believe that. [2:28:20] I think I think that they would probably stand up and say, "Yeah, we'll build a road." And maybe they will, maybe they won't. So, I mean, it would be nice if there was a you know, a loop connecting those two roads that dead end there, right? [2:28:30] Yeah. So, it is it is encompassing all the residential structures in this area. And so, this would encompass the ask. And so, it is feasible that additional dwelling units can be built in that expanded area. [2:28:44] And we're giving more property owners that opportunity. [2:28:47] Correct. [2:28:52] Any further discussion on this item? Not, I'll ask for a vote on the motion. All in favor? [2:29:00] Passes unanimously. [2:29:13] Are we on to written comments that we Anything else on page two? [2:29:20] Or anything on page two? [2:29:34] If not, [2:29:37] I would ask if anyone has any [2:29:40] [clears throat] [2:29:42] any action they want to take based upon any of the communications that you see attached on pages two through [2:29:56] 15. [2:29:59] Or let's let's stop at seven and [2:30:12] [clears throat] [2:30:16] Well, Yeah, I point board's attention to page five. [2:30:26] And I don't know how to go about this. but [2:30:33] this citizen is bringing forward [2:30:39] the section of the comprehensive plan relating to the public library and [2:30:46] really making it a focal point or making it known the things that they do and that they are expressing inaccuracies and information that's old and outdated. So, I don't know what we can do about that or what staff has prepared for us to target that. [2:31:04] So, for the out-of-date data, the inventory analysis was conducted during the winter to spring of 2025, and so that's why that data is out of date with the 2026 data that the person Sharon is referring to. And in this sense, if we were to include data from 2026 from the library, [2:31:27] we enter a slippery slope of lopsided point-in-time data. And so our recommendation would be to keep the inventory analysis data in 2025. [2:31:39] Okay. [2:31:42] And then the thing about the CIP I'm remembering correctly, I think in the policies and actions, the CIP it's [2:31:53] general. [2:31:55] No specific thing. It's like it could be infrastructure, it could be I mean and it's it is targeted for the high-growth area, and the library is within that high-growth area, is that correct? Yeah. [2:32:07] That's correct, yes. [2:32:10] And the library is mentioned in the comprehensive plan as being an integral partner to the city in the goals, policies, objectives, and actions section. It's not explicitly mentioned. so [2:32:26] You know, are there other public buildings that are mentioned in the CIP section? [2:32:33] Not that I'm aware of, no. [2:32:42] Okay. [2:32:48] [clears throat] [2:33:14] Okay. [2:33:15] Just a point of clarification. you all are reviewing up to page seven right now, correct? [2:33:20] Yes. [2:33:21] Okay. [2:33:48] Lauren, I'm looking at Scott Anders note to you. [2:33:58] Is there a reason that you're aware of why the high school wasn't mentioned? [2:34:05] No, in the in the in the implementation table, it breaks out the high school from the elementary and the middle school, and I believe the comment from the school committee was just to integrate those together. And so, from staff's perspective, this is a non-substantive change that we can make to the adjustment of the objectives in the implementation table to accommodate what the school committee is looking for. [2:34:29] You're just going to make an accommodation, but you're not making any substantive change. [2:34:36] Correct. [2:34:40] [cough and clears throat] [2:34:44] Anything else anyone would like to address up to page seven? Look at pages [2:34:52] eight through I just wanted to stop short of this [2:35:06] Okay. [2:35:10] Let's look at page eight and nine. [2:35:21] So, we just did number page eight. Fair to say? With the changes we made. Yep. [2:35:28] Yes. [2:35:29] Yes. [2:35:57] And is staff satisfied that with the tweak that we made earlier in the meeting to paths, trails, and parks, whatever the verbage was, that we've addressed [2:36:10] improvements [2:36:13] to skate parks. They are included in [2:36:16] [clears throat] [2:36:16] They are It is intended that they be included in our [2:36:21] in that section of the comprehensive plan. [2:36:24] And so, this was encompassing any type of improvements to our public parks and trails. so, the change that you made would encompass any proposed changes such as a skate park or anything like that. but, we're again for that section, it's intentionally not specific to any thought of improvement because this is more flexible language that allows us to go forward. [2:36:51] So, you won't find baseball fields or soccer fields mentioned specifically, either. [2:36:56] Correct. You would not find that. [2:36:58] And I'll also mention there's support for a skate park or different types of parks, broadly speaking, in the parks and recreation policy one, objectives objective three, and policy two, objectives one, two, and three. [2:37:13] [cough] [2:37:19] And I just want to ask about the rest of the survey responses that the that are attached to the those are surveys sent out by the comprehensive plan committee. [2:37:31] Correct. Yes. That was survey was open for about 3 weeks between the start of the open public comment period to about a week before the public hearing. [2:37:39] A week before the public hearing that we just went through? [2:37:42] Yes. [2:37:42] Okay. Some of them are colorful. [2:37:51] And only 15 respondents? [2:37:59] I had [2:38:00] [clears throat] [2:38:00] Excuse me. I had kind of thought that same thing and at least and I was wondering why only 15. And this is purely my opinion and really has no bearing on anything, but it kind of occurred to me that postcards that were sent out I mean, I'm getting 15 a day from all the candidates in the election and I have a strong inkling that unfortunately, the postcard probably to a many people [2:38:31] got kind of absorbed in that other stuff and maybe was not seen the way it was intended. [2:38:39] That's total speculation on my part. Just something that I was thinking about. [2:38:48] My optimistic side is hoping that we overloaded people with opportunities to engage and they're happy. That's my optimistic side, but Chelsea, I think you're on to something with the postcard overload. [2:39:00] I appreciate your optimism. Thank you. That's needed and appreciated. [2:39:08] I'll just ask people to give me some sort of a sign if they've had a chance to review these and if so, is there anything that you want to take up that you find in this list of survey responses. [2:39:26] Thank you very much. I think that concludes our review. Am I wrong? [2:39:31] You would be correct. that does conclude your review and of the comprehensive plan and because you've given your recommendations and so we will be taking those official recommendations and sending them directly to the city council. [2:39:47] Okay. You're sending those directly to the city council. I'd like to speak to the chair of the comprehensive plan committee because as you know, at least and I think he does as well. I'm a little confused about the process. So, will the comp plan committee be taking our recommendations into consideration because the comp plan committee has another meeting before the council meets whereas we don't. [2:40:10] so, do you intend How do you intend to proceed now that you've heard our review and our recommendations, John? [2:40:23] [clears throat] [2:40:23] Excuse me. So, the comprehensive plan committee will be reviewing all of the public input and the survey information to see if there's anything in there they wish to address in any way. they will also take a look at your recommendations and have any discussion they think that's appropriate. [2:40:46] Your recommendations of course as required go to the city council. if the comprehensive plan committee has any comment to make on your recommendation, they may submit those as well as what their comment are is in regards to your recommendations. [2:41:05] Would you I- I- if if there are any, would you please make sure that the board receives those? [2:41:10] Oh, sure. Yeah. [2:41:11] Absolutely. I'm sure you would. But, thank you. [2:41:15] All right. [2:41:19] I have no idea where we are in this short of asking if there are any planning board items for discussion. [2:41:28] May I Can I just like to clarify timing-wise? As you know, we're meeting on the 5th. [2:41:34] Yes. [2:41:34] Okay, which is a Wednesday, I think. [2:41:38] Next Thursday. [2:41:39] Next Thursday, yeah. And then the city council is meeting on the 9th, that following Monday. So, there's a very short time period, but as soon as we Our intention would be to get them to you, but you may not get them until about the day that we also send them to the city council. [2:41:58] Understood. [2:41:58] So, it might be parallel. [2:41:59] Understood. Thank you. [2:42:02] [clears throat] [2:42:05] When's our next meeting? [2:42:08] so, our next meeting is November the 10th. [2:42:13] Correct? [2:42:15] We're We're just We're going to confirm that. [2:42:18] I've had a lot of meetings these days. [2:42:20] A lot of meetings, do we have a lot coming up? I 'm I'm I'm really I'm I'm going to say the 10th because the 9th is the the council meeting. [2:42:31] Ooh. [2:42:33] It's not. Wait, it's the 19th. [2:42:35] Oh, it's the 19th. [2:42:37] Yeah. [2:42:38] correct? [2:42:39] I thought we had moved the meeting for some reason. [2:42:45] can I Can I say something? I don't I'm not convinced of that. I [2:42:50] [laughter] [2:42:51] I don't think this is accurate. [2:42:53] I'm [2:42:54] [clears throat] [2:42:54] quite certain we have a meeting of some kind on the 10th, and then again, there's another meeting on the 19th. So, I'm wondering I know there's a meeting on the 10th. I'd like What is it we're doing? [2:43:09] Yes, and so [2:43:10] That's a regular meeting, right? [2:43:11] Yes, and so the 10th is your regular meeting. You had also scheduled a special meeting on the 19th to discuss additional amendments that has to do with housing. [2:43:26] Additional what we call housing amendments, changes that we're having to look at due to the recent state law changes. [2:43:34] Correct. [2:43:35] Yes. [2:43:38] So, if the right the regular meeting on the 10th, if the agenda is light or null, is it safe to assume that 's going to be like a housing workshop? I'm just trying to mentally prepare. [2:43:56] It 's not a light meeting. we do have we have we do have applications for you all to review. [2:44:03] Oh, wonderful. [2:44:06] But I did keep that in mind. [2:44:08] Yes. [2:44:08] November 10 and November 19. [2:44:10] at my schedule, my the first winter market at Edward Little High School is on November 19th from 4:00 to 7:00. So, I will probably be absent from this meeting or come significantly later. [2:44:24] Thank you. [2:44:27] And we'll have the city update, the city calendar. [2:44:32] Knowing that we have meetings on the 10th and 19th, and as Kathy has checked her schedule, does anybody know now that they would have a conflict with either We'll have the regular meeting anyway, but the meeting on the 19th hate to have a meeting and not be able to move forward if we [2:44:51] Looks good. Is there anything else come before the board tonight? [2:44:57] As it relates to the comprehensive plan, as if I won't have another chance to comment on it, but I mean, as you saw here tonight, like there was a lot of compromise, a lot of give and take. That's a lot of the work that the comprehensive plan committee was doing over the last 2 years. and so, I just like to implore our staff, the administration, and city councils and future city councils and future staff with this plan to entrust and feel good that you have the backing [2:45:28] of the community of Auburn and that a lot of input was that went into this and a lot of compromise that came out of this. So, thank you. Yeah. [2:45:39] I'd like to bring up and we skipped miscellaneous, I think. But in with miscellaneous, I think there's a number of us, myself included, our terms end this December and we need to not be complacent if we intend on staying and make sure we reapply. [2:45:59] Probably your veterans know you don't you don't automatically get reappointed. You have to apply if you want to be reappointed. [2:46:09] Anything else? Motion to adjourn? [2:46:13] So moved. [2:46:15] Second. All in favor? Thank you. We adjourn. [2:46:19] Thank you.