Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): And all the members of present except for Chris heard and also Shannon is with us tonight and first order of business is the meeting minutes, you should have received a copy of the October 20 of the meeting minutes for October 26 and see if that is going.
[0:21] Speaker B (unidentified): Minutes now. Yes.
Unfinished Business
[0:27] Speaker A (unidentified): So if you've had a chance to review those minutes we will accept them okay we have a motion by Ford and a second from Steve all in favor I read them okay approved unanimously okay. Thank you. All right. Next, we're open for public comment, but do we have any public members attending? There is nobody online and nobody here. Okay. In that case, we have no public comment. So for old business, we have a number of items that were held over from the prior meeting because we didn't have a chance to get to them, although we've considered them in various aspects in prior meetings. So the first one was document management and storage.
[1:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I have a couple comments to make about that. One is I don't think you have access to the Dropbox yet. We talked briefly about that. And if you, it would be good, Shannon, for you to have access to the Dropbox, But you would need to make an account in Dropbox, and then you can be, and then Chris would invite you to join the group so that you could have access to all of the materials that are in there. So that would be a to-do for you, and then follow up with Chris. All the rest of us have access to it at this point. And has everyone been able to get into the Dropbox and have a look around in there?
[2:14] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm trying to right I looked at but I don't know if I you know I don't think I've gotten into it I don't think I've tried you haven't tried yet I just dealt with you know I sent it as an attachment right but I can't get into Dropbox you think it is a link Dropbox yeah I didn't I have been in it. I saw stuff in it. You should have gotten an invitation from Chris, which would have been as an email, I think.
[2:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes, I believe that's how I did it.
[2:49] Speaker A (unidentified): And then you link to it from...
[2:51] Speaker B (unidentified): But you don't actually need an invitation from Chris. Chris, you can just go to Dropbox and go to the Shared Folders and click on the Shared Folders.
[3:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I use Dropbox Live, but how do I get access? So Chris approved me, so I should see with all my Dropbox folders.
[3:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so in Dropbox, there's Shared Folders, and so it would be one of the Shared Folders.
[3:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Yeah, I mean, if you already have a Dropbox, I believe if you open it up, you'll see it there. You'll see it'll say Wayne Comprehensive Planning Committee.
[3:33] Speaker C (unidentified): And when I open mine, there's a whole bunch of advertisements, and I just go up to my account, click on my face, and there it is.
[3:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Wayne Comprehensive. Yeah. So that's where we're keeping all the documents. Documents and to the extent possible, when we get feedback from on particular documents and edits and so on, the preferred way to do it would be to do it in Dropbox so we're all on the same page. They're all there are alternatives such as when you attach the document, but you know the problem with that is then you wind up with multiple versions with, you know, I didn't change the
[4:14] Speaker B (unidentified): origin. I just getting my suggestions. Yeah, and you can also like Lynette included comments right in Dropbox to the version that was shared, so you can you can you can attach comments to the document right in Dropbox, and the advantage of that is if you know if
[4:42] Speaker A (unidentified): we're all going over a document and five of us make comments, you can see all those comments. You can see what other people have said. Maybe somebody's made the same comment and caught the same thing and say, okay, I don't even need to address it, right? It avoids duplication and
[4:56] Speaker C (unidentified): makes it alive. And when you're leaving comments, it there's a little option that how to sort them, and I sorted mine by page, which I think was helpful in you having and then you referring
[5:11] Speaker D (unidentified): referring to them. So sorting by page was the we had a discussion last week about if everyone can use Word to write. Did that get established? Oh, well, the documents we are working on are all
[5:27] Speaker A (unidentified): in Word so far. Okay, and everyone could use Word. Yeah, I have a league of words seems to work with it. Oh yeah, that's right, that's right. Yeah, okay, I'm gonna get a little computer. I'm drawing it. Oh, you and me both might not want to support it won't support with the water words
[5:47] Speaker D (unidentified): as the nomenclature you started using this debate is the extension on the file. Well, it's not the extension, it's just not yeah, it's the back dot extension, it's the file name suffix of the it's in the file name. You can see it in the agenda. Yeah, the zero or the six one zero two nine. Yeah,
[6:11] Speaker B (unidentified): 20 26, and then the month and then the day. Yeah, which I think that sorts the file name right
[6:20] Speaker D (unidentified): accordingly. Make sure everyone knows that because if you happen to tap on the wrong one, that's going
[6:26] Speaker A (unidentified): to be yeah. Oh, that's but that's why it's a great idea to put that date right out there.
[6:31] Speaker D (unidentified): We just delete, there's one out there that's 6 10 23, we should delete that. Well, I think it's a
[6:40] Speaker A (unidentified): good idea to keep prior drafts. I mean, maybe at some point, but you know, there may be reasons that you want to go back to look at that prior draft. Okay, so in the trans, so what Chris did
[6:54] Speaker B (unidentified): was he created a folder for the chapters, an overall folder for the chapters, and then within that folder he created a subfolder for the transportation chapter. Then within the transportation chapter there are a number of files, but there are two files in there right now for the 2 different versions of the drafts of the transportation chapter that are, that you can tell the most recent one by the date delineation. Yeah, and so those are some of the conventions for using for the document management and storage.
[7:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. I think that, yeah, we should wrap it up.
[7:46] Speaker D (unidentified): I think it'll work.
[7:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Not in Egypt.
[7:52] Speaker E (unidentified): Not in Egypt. After December.
[7:55] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean, it's a nice mechanism for keeping the latest draft, but as far as...
[8:05] Speaker B (unidentified): Once it's final, then the word final will go. At the extension and not the date. Oh, okay. Once it's asked, once it, once we've agreed and voted that the document is finished, then we'll use the word final, and then no further changes would be
[8:25] Speaker A (unidentified): made to it. Okay, all right, so everybody's okay with using the Dropbox, using Word, and, Shannon, you will hopefully get plugged into the Dropbox soon, and then we'll all have access to it. And, Steve, did you say that you have access to it? You're good? Okay. So everybody should be good. All right. Any other discussion on the document management process? No? Okay. So we also had project management software Trello. And I think, Bob, that was your baby, right? Yeah, and I think Trello was going to be
[9:11] Speaker D (unidentified): for managing what we were just talking about. We're going to use Dropbox. I don't see the purpose. Yeah, it's a little more sophisticated. Yeah, I don't think we need that. I mean, for a really big
[9:25] Speaker A (unidentified): project it's great to have all those timelines and you know who's doing what and i 'm not sure we need something that sophisticated or well in many to many relationships where there's
[9:37] Speaker D (unidentified): many people that doing many documents, but we're going to be kind of just one or two documents at
[9:44] Speaker A (unidentified): a time, right? Yeah, that's, that's, yes, yeah, I think it's not working. Yeah, okay, all right, we can, any other discussion about that? All right, so moving on to budget construction and review, and I've forgotten exactly what our disguise, I know we've talked about it before, I just don't
[10:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Remember, yeah, comment on that. We have a budget that was agreed upon or by the town, and so, which was, I believe, $8,000. And I mean, in this unit, we voted to agree to request a budget of $8,000 and a warrant item was approved for that amount. Out and so what we suggested was needed was that we build a budget because we started spending money but we didn't actually create any sort of budget, yeah, and we're not tracking actuals, you know, like the expenditures of that, so we don't actually know how much money we have spent, we don't know how much money we have left, yeah. But when you have a budget, the responsible thing to do is to plan out what you're going to spend your money on and how much you've spent to know how much you have
[11:17] Speaker A (unidentified): left over, yeah. So that's what this is about, and where do we get the idea of
[11:26] Speaker D (unidentified): how much to put in the category unless we have history? Let me go print it off. Oh, you can get
[11:33] Speaker B (unidentified): that immediately. Oh, that's great, thank you. She's going to print off the budget for us that what
[11:40] Speaker A (unidentified): we have, those already, what we've spent already, right? So I understand your point, but I don't, I'm not sure we know what our expenses are going to be. We know we have this much money and we've spent some and we know if we don't spend it all it's okay. Oh, absolutely. I think the, what, go to my economic chapter, yeah. I think maybe I'll hire somebody to do that, but you know what I'm saying, the budget almost can walk along. It's like if I have ten thousand bucks in my checking book and I've been at this property, yeah, well, I know I've got that, I'm gonna go as I go along, but for some left over, yeah, if I run out, bad news. Well, so that's why we need the monitor, so we need to think of what's the expense out there that we don't see, right? Is that correct? Exactly. And I think, you know, the only expenses that I can think of that are coming down the road potentially are associated with public hearings that we expect to have next year over the course of the next year or so as part of the outreach and community contact, and because we've talked about having events where we might actually provide some food and some, you know, some, which is probably not going to be, hopefully not a big expense, but other than that, at this point, because we've decided to do everything in-house rather than farm it out, I can't think of any other expenses that we know of at this point or fully expect. Do you have anybody else thinking about printing expenses? Oh, good, yes, yeah, absolutely, great. There will be expenses, they Will have these, yeah, for sure. Good point, I thought so, yeah, we have history of
[13:39] Speaker B (unidentified): budget last time we did this. Shannon's printing it out right now. Yeah, there will be expenses that come up, like when we do focus group discussions, you know, with various small groups, we may have some small expenses that
[14:00] Speaker E (unidentified): I think they're going to measure a little. I mean, we may have some refreshments for all
[14:05] Speaker A (unidentified): CSDs, you know. Yeah, really, you know, I'm glad you mentioned the printing, because I had forgotten about that. That actually may wind up being one of our biggest expenses, because we're going to have to, you know, when we put the whole thing together, it's going to need to be distributed. Lots of copies are going to need to be made available. 500 copies at that. Yeah, and that, and that can, that can add up real quick. That distance printing is not cheap, especially if it's going to be down in color, and some of the, some of the maps and things will need to be in color, and we put pretty good quality paper in. Yeah, yep, all right, well, while we're, is there anything else we want to talk about while we're on the budget construction and review? Well, yes, we'll wait till Shannon comes back. Why don't we temporarily go move ahead to the potential meeting with the Conservation Commission about the natural, sorry, there was a typo here, natural resources chapter. Oh, here we go, I gotta get some more paper, okay.
[15:16] Speaker F (unidentified): So the budget's at $8,000 at the top. $1,000 has already been expended. The amount, the Every Door Direct Mailer, one of these, Elon Financial as a credit card payment, the $722, so that came out to, I think, $131 plus two payments of $49.50 for additional follow-along mailers. We had to go back to Coffees, et cetera, to get more, and so there were additional
[15:47] Speaker B (unidentified): additional payments, and then I came out for that. Yeah, it was like 500 plus another 200 something, right? Yeah, okay, great, okay, this is very helpful. So we have spent, we spent a little more
[16:00] Speaker A (unidentified): than that, so 6800 bucks. Yeah, do you need more coffee? No, so I'm going to do it, everybody's, everybody see it. Yeah, Shannon, what would be your guess as to the cost of printing if our, if our eventual comprehensive plan is of somewhat the same dimensions as the
[16:23] Speaker F (unidentified): 2016 one it all just depends on how many copies you want, how many colored pages there are. I mean, it really, there are different things you have to look at. So when I was printing off was blood vulnerability assessment, I got a quote on that was a few hundred dollars, and what I found was that it was actually cheaper to print it off here at our office and then three-pole punch it. But then they also, you can get it with a spiral ring, you can get it with a clear coat on the front. It again really just depends on what you're looking for. So the previous comprehensive plan, I think, was printed in bulk in black and white. You can also request maybe one or two pages in color for our town report, for contacts. Yep, that town report. Yeah, that usually comes to a couple hundred dollars or how many copies. I usually get about 70, but it doesn't have any color
[17:19] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah, it's just black and white on the inside, color in the comprehensive plan. Yes, you'd
[17:25] Speaker F (unidentified): want to identify your specific color pages that you want for lakes or natural resources and things like that, and then try to keep everything minimal down to black and white if you can. Okay, yeah.
[17:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. Well, I would think we're going to end up with a draft that we take to the town. And then after that, then you're going to have the final printed copy. So the draft might be black and white and pretty cheap, but the final copy wants to be- Yeah,. Because we've got to submit that to the state. And the final copy, you need a lot of- Yeah. I mean, we've got to submit multiple copies to the state and distribute it here. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Plus it might be a couple hundred people want them. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I'm saying what I'm saying, I think there's two, there's two. Yeah. Yeah. There might be two iterations with that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
[18:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Would it be wrong to have a cheaper paper, a pile of cheaper paper books and then nice and a suggested contribution of 50 cents for a dollar?
[18:32] Speaker A (unidentified): No, if you want to do that, okay, you know, we're forcing this, right, we're forcing this. Isn't a, this isn't a volunteer thing with this, is something we're doing. People need to know
[18:42] Speaker D (unidentified): so we're definitely gonna make that my opinion one of the nice things that we can also do
[18:47] Speaker F (unidentified): Too is like, you said different rounds, like you'll do one in all black, you can do one in with the colors, you can do them digitally too. We'll have it on there, but then like what I've been doing with the annual town report is I'll order 40 or 50 and see how fast those go, and if people want more then I can request more through copies etc. as well. They're really good. Yeah, they're very
[19:10] Speaker A (unidentified): quick turnaround as well, right? Okay, well it sounds like the printing expenses will be manageable. They, you know, they're not going to consume our whole budget at least, so all right, well good. Well and then in terms of budgeting, I mean I hear you Paula in terms of saying ideally we should be figuring out what do we expect to spend the money on and how much do we expect to spend. I don't know that we really have that clear a picture at this point. Yeah, but this is perfect
[19:41] Speaker B (unidentified): then you print it out, now we know what our actuals are, and that's terrific. Thank you so much.
[19:48] Speaker A (unidentified): How much did it cost to print the ones that the old comp plan you printed off, what's it
[19:53] Speaker E (unidentified): all for us and from, I can go look, I've printed a lot of different things. Yeah, I'm just, that might give us an idea. Do you want me to go get chat and see if I can, you think that's what we're doing? Yeah, but
[20:10] Speaker A (unidentified): it does show how quickly things can go. I mean you're just with the comprehensive plan mailers and gone, you know, we've, we've all stuff adds up. Yeah, it adds up quickly. Yeah, so while we're waiting for Shannon on that, there was the idea of scheduling a meeting with the Conservation Commission about the Natural Resources chapter. Who's, Paula, was that a proposal from the from the Conservation Commission?
[20:43] Speaker B (unidentified): So the Conservation Commission are not the, I was not able to attend the meeting in November which was last week, but the week, the month before we reviewed our strategic plan and talked about the various elements of our strategic plan, how that can serve to inform form the Comprehensive Plan and how the Conservation Commission can support the work of the Comprehensive Plan, particularly the Natural Resources section, as well as the other section that have conservation related elements, and so the Conservation Commission is talking and working to prepare for that if the Comprehensive Plan Committee is meaningful to having the Conservation Commission come and speak with them. The other thing, which, you know, kind of like the PLT came and spoke, but this would be, I think, more of a dialogue kind of exchange.
[22:07] Speaker A (unidentified): When's the appropriate time to do that? After we have a chapter to draft or before?
[22:13] Speaker F (unidentified): That's a good question.
[22:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, we already have the letter from the Inland Fisheries and Wildlife, which is an extremely helpful, and I wanted to also mention that I attended the Maine Association of Conservation Commission's conference, which occurred a couple of weeks ago, and Greg LeClair, who is the person who actually wrote that letter presented to at this conference and he was if he is so knowledgeable and so open and so sort of generous in his style he is he is willing to meet with us as well and I think that would be extremely helpful. And so, it might be the most, when this item went on the agenda, it was before I had actually attended the Maine Association of Conservation Commissions. And I think what might be helpful is seeing if we can have Greg come and meet with us and talk about- And would you do that before meeting with the conservation commission have all of us meet and hear from Greg because what he does is he'll review the comprehensive plan and what he says happens is people submit their comprehensive plans and they fail the review because they love that show yeah they leave out stuff they don't address the criteria you know they're not we could fail them yeah we could yeah he says
[24:12] Speaker A (unidentified): like that's why we have to submit the 50 fail wow he said a lot of people fail so
[24:22] Speaker B (unidentified): you know it might be helpful and he said often what he does and what 's more common than not is to have he meets with planning boards and conservation commissions together but i don't think we need to bring the planning board into this at the same time but we could we could have him come and maybe meet with the comprehensive plan committee and the conservation committee together i think that might be an interesting combination then you know we you know i don't i don't think the conservation commission is interested in lobbying the comprehensive plan committee I mean you don't need to do that I just don't know how these things will work out
[25:10] Speaker C (unidentified): so they want to be asked yeah
[25:16] Speaker A (unidentified): If you invite that guy in Greg again, can you extend an invitation to the comprehensive plan at that meeting when we have it? I think that's fine. Yeah, I think it's good for them to hear that. I'll say hear that here in the interchange. Yeah, I think there's two pieces, two. One is the state's view of this, and the other is the local committee, which has very much more specific interests and what they want in their mind. Yeah, we need them both. Yeah, it may not be the same meeting, it may be we can schedule a meeting either way.
[25:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you think Steve that it would be helpful to have them together, or do you think it'd
[26:03] Speaker A (unidentified): be better to schedule them separately? I think together is fine as long as they're because they're comfortable that they can, you know, be more specific about Wayne itself rather than just listen to a spiel, and certainly I can put it input after that meeting. Yeah.
[26:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I think it would be good to have them together so that we can avoid a second meeting where we spend the time saying, well, Greg said, well, Greg said, well, Greg said. Yeah. It would be good for everybody to hear the same. What is his last name? LeClaire. Yeah. At least.
[26:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Slowly. Well, okay, so it sounds like we're in favor of a meeting, a joint meeting, and inviting Greg LeClaire to address us both, and so will you undertake to organize it, and what about the timing? I mean, do you have any preference? Obviously we can't do it before December at the earliest, and probably not until next year, realistically January, probably January.
[27:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Beginning with habitat.
[27:22] Speaker B (unidentified): From inland fisheries and law department of inland fisheries and wildlife.
[27:28] Speaker A (unidentified): That's who he's with. He's beginning of habitat. He wrote that piece then. Yeah, even though
[27:35] Speaker B (unidentified): oh, it was signed by Justin Schlauen. Greg wrote it.
[27:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so we would be amenable to meeting with them early next year, you think? Okay, so. That's for our sample. Yeah, okay. So Paul, you wanna try to line that up?
[28:01] Speaker E (unidentified): And. Motion for that, we're gonna just.
[28:04] Speaker A (unidentified): I think we've got consensus on it. I like motions considering minutes. Yeah, I'll make a motion that when we get considering and natural resources part of this that we invite Greg LeClaire and the conservation commission to a joint meeting. I'm not going to set a time but one whenever we all right the one at the appropriate time seven. Okay, all in favor? Hey, all right, so moved, so passed. If I can go backwards for a second, sure. So she just passed, I said so these copies were 20 a piece, so if we're going To do 200 copies, you're talking about some fair money because it might be less a little, but it won't be a tremendous amount, won't be half price that.
[28:52] Speaker F (unidentified): Right, we do have a new budget season coming up, so if you want to do it in phases as well.
[28:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, we could get, right, we're not ready to do, we won't be ready to do this, I don't think, before town meeting, all right, I'm guessing, right, maybe that'll be good to start.
[29:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Budgeting this though, to make a presentation to the budget committee, so we're going to have.
[29:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Just for, just for, I'm just a gap in here, very not with the information, but so if we're going to have two rounds, you're going to make a couple hundred of these for each round, or for the first round, maybe black one, white, there might be less money than this, so if you want to do a hundred of them, you're talking two thousand dollars.
[29:36] Speaker F (unidentified): You're including all of those, I think it's the pages of color and the spiral bound, right.
[29:40] Speaker D (unidentified): Right, but maybe we don't do all that.
[29:42] Speaker A (unidentified): So I'm just trying to throw out some numbers here. Yes, I mean, so these were running 20 bucks a piece.
[29:50] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, and so the annual reports, I got about 80 at 585.
[29:55] Speaker E (unidentified): So that's the difference when you start seeing.
[29:57] Speaker F (unidentified): And factoring in the color.
[29:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, 8,000, I don't think there's much else to spend on things. I don't think there's a lot. So, and then as you say, we can get into the next budget year. We have to.
[30:07] Speaker F (unidentified): We can start looking into how much it might cost.
[30:10] Speaker E (unidentified): Even doing some here at the office too, yeah, because maybe the earlier ones we do them by.
[30:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Three or four chapters and you staple them together, we put that out, yeah, okay, how does this travel, and you know, maybe in this digital era we can distribute it mostly digitally and not have to produce a lot of hard copies, you might only need 30 copies. Okay, so are we, are we done with the budget construction and review, all finished discussion of that? Okay. And I think we're, we're, we've concluded the discussion about the meeting with Conservation Commission and its regular player. So that brings us to the transportation chapter. Okay.
[31:05] Speaker B (unidentified): All right. The most recent version is in Dropbox. There are two versions in Dropbox. So the most recent version is the most recent date. Okay. And I just got, I got comments from everyone. I'm waiting for, I was waiting for some final input, so it's not final yet. The figure that we wanted to be replaced is not yet replaced yet, because I didn't get the final version of it and the product that's probably good because there was a suggestion to add actual expenditures to the figure about the road budget, remember the road budget and the capital reserves for roads. So we should talk about these 2 suggestions. One was there, and they're both about the ford had suggested that we add information about actual expenditures about road costs. So one was to add to a table where we have the road. Well, the road, the table, maybe have changed because some of the some things have been added. So that might not be table foreign, but it was to add a column with the actual angle road expenditures along with the budgeted amounts.
[33:16] Speaker A (unidentified): That's not table 5, which is now on table 5. Yeah, OK. I didn't. I didn't print a new one at all. I didn't print it either.
[33:27] Speaker B (unidentified): So I guess the first question is, and how many years do we go back on that to FY18? 18. So the question I would have first for Shannon is could we go back to FY18 and get actuals so
[33:49] Speaker F (unidentified): our software goes back five years okay so I could go back as far as I'd say 20 23 yep around there Yes. Okay. FY23? Yep. Either, yeah, FY22 or 23. I'd have to go look exactly.
[34:08] Speaker E (unidentified): Because 27 isn't spent, right? Right.
[34:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, yeah. 27 is just projected. Yeah. I mean- The reason- Okay.
[34:17] Speaker A (unidentified): By thinking of that is that gives, we're trying to, this is a snapshot of where we're at now. Mm-hmm. That gives us a much more accurate picture of what has gone on than the budget. You could either have one, you could have them both, but if I had to pick one, I'd want the actual. Mm-hmm. Just if you want.
[34:36] Speaker D (unidentified): How close do you want Clare to be able to throw the budget in normally?
[34:40] Speaker F (unidentified): So I was asked earlier, actually, last year's budget we had for the operating was $399,117. At the end of the fiscal year, we carried forward $154,940. I would also attribute that to being my first year, and not entirely using some of the stuff that was in the budget that we previously had done. I would expect that would be higher this year more aligned with the budget and this year's budget. We actually have 440,000 budgeted.
[35:14] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, those numbers aren't matching what we have in the in the table, and that's not what's in the annual report.
[35:22] Speaker A (unidentified): for the budgeted funds oh this is the road budget roads these are the roads yeah road budgets 478
[35:31] Speaker F (unidentified): 478 oh expense i'm looking at the wrong one last year was 436 this year was 478. those
[35:37] Speaker B (unidentified): Are what we're spending, that's the expense. Okay, budget. Well, wait, the budgeted expense.
[35:44] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, but not the, not the expense total right here, and the actual. Yes, the actual we spent was 153 3 000 last year. Remaining, we spent 282 000. So there is, there is a significant difference here.
[35:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think that's unrealistic when people could have been able to look at it. Now what happened there, that's what I'm addressing, that we'll just say yeah, this is a fact, this is what happened. So since we only have data that we can verify, as if I heard you correctly, for the last five years, right? Does it make sense? I mean, I don't know that. Yeah, do we really need a 10-year chart or should we just do five years? Yeah, we're using these numbers. Yes, these are the numbers.
[36:32] Speaker B (unidentified): That are reported in the table. Yeah, that's right, the 432. I had an extra the up in the revenues.
[36:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Was an additional 38 000 that we bring in through the local roads assistance program, so.
[36:47] Speaker B (unidentified): So that was the local road assistance program is reported on a separate table. Yes, just below.
[36:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, it's table six. It's recorded on a separate table. I've got it right here, right there. Yeah, like 37,636 for the current fiscal year.
[37:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Yep. And it's all based off of road maintenance calculated formula through the Department of Transportation. Right. And so we just verify the roads that we're currently maintaining. But yes. So we have the $244,000 for contractual, $233,000. I mean, this is all approximate for roads maintenance. So $478,099 for the expenses. And then the $440,000 that I was mentioning deducted the $38,000 for the local roads. Okay. So yes, $478,000 is what we have budgeted.
[37:49] Speaker A (unidentified): And Shannon, why wasn't that as much as $150,000 was unspent? What was the number that was?
[37:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Something like that. For the $153,700 that was not spent.
[38:00] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, is that typical or was that an unusual year?
[38:03] Speaker F (unidentified): I'd say it was just I didn't spend as much on our brush and tree removal. Nor did I spend really anything on gravel, and I would just attribute that to my lack of experience on road maintenance. And so I am learning a lot more and just completed a local road course, actually. And so and we've also just completed eight road paving projects. So there was a lot of preparation that goes into that. And so planning out a five-year maintenance plan will include the brush and tree removal on a certain mileage for roads each year, as well as gravel, which will get incorporated in what's usually creating.
[38:44] Speaker D (unidentified): So that's a nuance. I don't know why we want it in the report. It's not going to happen again. It's a quirk to me. Unless we go back and we get a bunch of years. Maybe five years. You go back five years. Yes. Maybe then. You might have some wrong numbers. This is with the idea of future. And to me, getting those numbers, in my opinion, is looking back and water over the bridge.
[39:13] Speaker A (unidentified): But- Talk to us about the capital reserve.
[39:17] Speaker F (unidentified): So as far as how much we have budgeted?
[39:21] Speaker A (unidentified): How does that get established as opposed to the budget? The budgeted budget?
[39:26] Speaker F (unidentified): Funds so there's also a proposed amount that comes to the select board budget committee for road projects and so I believe a couple years ago before I was here there was a lot larger allocation. Yes, 600 thousands yep was allocated towards roads with the intent of getting more catch up. Yes, this year ended up being that catch-up year so then I'm going
[39:53] Speaker D (unidentified): to revisit. Can you show Shannon the stack right now? What you're saying, Shannon, makes me think we
[40:00] Speaker A (unidentified): should have this stack. So what we have done, so this is, so basically this is going back to this table five. We had a column for budgeted funds and then a column for capital reserve. Okay, in the same year and this is simply a histogram that had to do together with the blue being the budgeted and yellow being the capital reserve, right? And we had some discussion about does this really make sense, are we looking, are we distorting it by adding these numbers
[40:34] Speaker D (unidentified): together? Well if something happened could we spend the gold and the blue together in one year?
[40:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Typically you'd want the blue to be spent in one year, you'd want to, but we have the potential
[40:46] Speaker D (unidentified): of doing both if a catastrophe happened. Well it's not just catastrophe, it's, it's road projects.
[40:53] Speaker C (unidentified): So I asked Eric about this, he's been on the budget committee for a long time and he, I said why do we have two and he said simple answer is the blue, the budgeted funds are what most people would consider maintenance every year, it's plowing, it's tree trimming, it's just it's the back, keep the road in good shape, and the capital reserve is looking down the line at your roads that have those alligator crafts in them that need to be okay like major.
[41:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah I think that's making an argument for staff. No I did, I don't think so. If I'm, you know, nothing, I look at this, hey why don't we spend all this year now? I mean if that's explained to
[41:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Somebody in this thing, so they say, okay, the blues for maintenance and the gold or whatever that color is for more major improvements, capital improvements. Then that's how much we do on transportation, because it is transportation, whether, yeah, it is. There's a capital reserve.
[42:01] Speaker B (unidentified): All transportation, yes, it is. This one, I can, this one, yeah, yes, this capital I just.
[42:07] Speaker C (unidentified): From that last meeting, yes, you have a capital reserve fund in many other departments, but this.
[42:14] Speaker B (unidentified): One here is all wrong, yes, it is, yeah. So you don't show in the annual report right here.
[42:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Separate materials, I couldn't, instead of that, I could not status.
[42:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Put them side by side, maybe that'd be clearer. This is not a big deal, this is just all report.
[42:30] Speaker C (unidentified): No, but I think that's a really good way to do it. I think two stacks, because, and maybe there.
[42:35] Speaker D (unidentified): Should I also think that we should make it a little more clear, because all of us were confused.
[42:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Until you told us, we even have staff members who weren't quite there. You're not the only one, so.
[42:50] Speaker D (unidentified): I'll, I'll redo this and I'll not exactly, I'll not stack them, but I also want to be more descriptive of capital in parentheses, major road, it's called road reconstruction and payment. There you go.
[43:07] Speaker A (unidentified): That's good, but I want that, so it's higher. Is that in the annual report this year, in the annual? Okay, this is, yeah, and I want to play a little more. Okay, I want an in annual report under capital.
[43:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Capital reserve accounts, the amount of money that's allocated for capital reserves for road reconstruction and paving, or the fiscal year budget 25 26 was 450 000, yeah, for FY 26 27 was.
[43:42] Speaker D (unidentified): 250 000. But it's not on this document, I think it has to be on this document, not just that one.
[43:50] Speaker A (unidentified): so i 'm just clarifying yeah so i have a suggestion since we have the load commissioner right here with us and i think that we all have a certain confusion about the difference between what's budgeted which i understand is really more routine maintenance and what goes into the capital reserve which i understand is more major improvement projects could you basically give us a brief paragraph explaining i think what those two you can do i can do that i have it right
[44:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Here in the annual report, all right, I mean it's very clear what the budgeted funds are for, lot plumbing havoc on winter sand, winter salt, sideway plumbing, roadside mowing, road administration, brush tree removal, calcium chloride sweeping, catch basin panel patching, samples painting, culver's.
[44:44] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, well, all right, so if you want to bring your, if you're happy, if you're comfortable doing it, that's, that's fine, but I just think we need to clarify because you write long paragraphs.
[44:56] Speaker B (unidentified): But I do think we need to clarify it. Great, I understand from this discussion it's clear we need to clarify what budgeted funds cover and what capital needs to number, but the question, the question still remains, what do we do about expended funds? That's not a good answer.
[45:18] Speaker A (unidentified): And before we go into the expended, so are we also, or we agree that with respect then, so we're going to have some definitions that clarify these two categories. Do we then want to show them as two side by side columns in the same figure? Figure which is the last discussion I heard over here. Yeah, but now there's four, there's
[45:41] Speaker D (unidentified): four values, there's budgeted, there's capital, there's what was actually spent on the budget, and then what was actually spent under the capital. Now I have four. Well, we clearly, I think, don't
[45:54] Speaker A (unidentified): want all four of those in the same. Right, yeah, but let me just leave aside the difference between budgeted and expended for the moment, just focusing on capital versus maintenance. Do we want to show it? I see a couple different options. One is we have two different figures, one is we show them side by side in the same figure, and in other words, we stack them in the same figure, and I could make an argument for each one of those, but you know, it's just a question of how you want to show up. What's your, what's your thinking about that? I think they should be side by side. I think this is confusing because of the stat.
[46:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. We're still, I mean, we have to tackle how many numbers are we going to record in barcodes.
[46:42] Speaker A (unidentified): That's another complication. Let's take it one step at a time. Okay. So as, but just as to the capital versus the maintenance, you want to show them in the same figure side by side, which will, which will mean we'll have twice as many. Now also though, did we decide we're just going to limit this to five years? That will, that'll make things a little simpler, I think.
[47:05] Speaker B (unidentified): That's fine, but well, we have to, because that's all the data. All right, so we're going to have
[47:10] Speaker A (unidentified): We're going to have five years of data, which means we'll have 10 bar graphs. That's mad. Like, that's management. Let's match forward. Yeah, so I hear what you're saying, so let's switch that a little bit. Let's separate out, if we can do this, I suggest I'd separate out the blue stuff, which is the maintenance and all that stuff, and then one graph, budgeted and actual, for that, and then the other graph have the capital, budgeted and actual. Do we do that? Yeah, rather than putting
[47:45] Speaker F (unidentified): those two in the same thing yeah i think it gets a little tricky when you have the carried forward that goes into the capital reserve as well though so that'll change your balance can you explain that you explain that to me but I'm not sure you explain it the operating so whatever is left over goes into capital correct okay that's a big deal so what I was saying with the budgeted for last year was it last year the 436 117 we still have a remaining balance of 153 000 unspent in roads category for maintenance. Yeah, and so the way we have it set up currently in our town meeting warrant is that balance gets carried forward into the capital reserve, the capital. So it gets moved into the capital for the next year. So even though in a previous year they might have requested 600,000, they might have gotten an extra 153,000 from the previous, I mean, those aren't exact numbers because I don't know what it was that year, but they may have gotten an additional amount. So the capital reserve has a higher balance pending.
[48:58] Speaker A (unidentified): But we see that in the town report. Does that show up that way in the town reports? I don't think it does. That's kind of just mysterious.
[49:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah. So in previous years, actually, I think that the town manager gave a brief over all of the capital reserve account balances. And so that's where you would probably get that number, and I'd have to go back and look and see how thorough those account down reports are.
[49:21] Speaker A (unidentified): We're not trying to do a forensic thing.
[49:22] Speaker F (unidentified): We're just trying to make it so- Just to explain it though, so you have that understanding.
[49:27] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think we definitely want to avoid mixing and matching the maintenance funds and the capital reserve funds, because there's an overlap between them. Yeah. So my numbers that I'm requesting here- Yeah. They may show, I'm going to make some up here, let's say for 26, it was 432, but they only spent 300, so it was 132 left over. We're not showing that or where it goes at all, so that's pretty confusing. Yeah,. So maybe we just leave it alone.
[50:04] Speaker C (unidentified): Is it the job of the comprehensive plan to show that? Yeah. Yeah, actually.
[50:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. It's a snapshot of where we're at, right, from these reports. Well, so let me ask, this is supposed to be a planning tool. And so you as the road commissioner, or the one who above all else would be looking at stuff like this, what's most useful to you in terms of when you're sitting down and trying to figure out what you need expenses for the year ahead and what you need to budget for and what kind of data would you want to see so what Ford was talking about is having the
[50:45] Speaker F (unidentified): actuals from the previous year I think that's important to look at versus even having the budgeted amount just having the actuals I think shows you what was spent in previous years. And then you'll see this next year, well in this current year, we had an increase on our snow plowing contract. This year we're going to have to put it back out to bid for the next three years. So that may increase again because of the relative costs in other towns for snow plowing. And so we're anticipating that. What I saw with your staff numbers is if not as a road commissioner but as a taxpayer it might be beneficial to see how much your taxes went towards because if you're looking at the stacked amount we see an operating amount plus the capital reserve you can essentially put that into a bar graph of what that percentage of the total budget was so of your total budget 40 of it went towards roads so I think as a taxpayer fair that would be interesting for me because I want to know that I mean aside from school but of the municipal budget most of it goes towards roads our roads better be in good condition compared to maybe parks or recreation or general administration that will probably be a high chart right yeah that's how i would expect but looking at that 's what i get from this one as a road commissioner i'm going to go off of your actual data yeah and try to get some
[52:18] Speaker D (unidentified): quotes do we ever exceed the budget do we ever spend more than what's in the budget ideally not
[52:24] Speaker F (unidentified): that's my job to make sure that we don't exceed the budget I mean stop happening well if you know
[52:29] Speaker C (unidentified): you're going to take it from somewhere else well there's also is there a contingency fund somewhere that is available for emergency crisis yeah we have a three thousand dollar contingency that's
[52:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Help us very much. Yeah, so a three thousand dollar contingency fund currently. We should be following a fund balance, we have a fund balance policy to maintain, I think it's three months of our highest paying months or of the percentage of our overall budget. I have to go back and look at that, and our treasurer keeps up on that and I check in with her frequently. We sometimes times drop below our fund balance policy, usually in August and September before we start getting tax revenues coming in and that's where the cash flow, we have to make sure that we can meet everything that we need to because they used to
[53:22] Speaker A (unidentified): have that bargain anticipation tax. Yes, so used to do that. Yes, and you could
[53:26] Speaker F (unidentified): definitely do a tax anticipation note in preparation for, like you put in an application in July or August or a little bit sooner to get money knowing that you'll be able to pay it back about two months later. So right now, if we wanted to get a tax anticipation note for the spring, we'd have a deadline of February to put in a request. So knowing that, we would also have to backdate and probably come to the town to get an approval to submit for that application.
[53:59] Speaker A (unidentified): And where's the funding coming from when you get the tax anticipation note?
[54:03] Speaker F (unidentified): So the funding would come from, they have a main municipal association bond bank that you put in and get a request for, they whatever applications they get however many from different towns and things that will lower the rate if they get more, if it's just our town maybe in one other town it might be a higher rate, but based off of those rates then you can choose to move forward and then the taxes that we get say in January or I mean we'd be getting this in February but we should be anticipating all of our taxes remaining balances in January and be able to pay that back in February or March.
[54:39] Speaker A (unidentified): So it's a loan, but who's, so is it the municipal association that's actually providing those funds and they have a reserve which has been raised from bonds? To my knowledge, yeah. Okay. All right, that makes sense.
[54:54] Speaker B (unidentified): I have a question. So I discovered in the annual report, I've learned all kinds of things
[55:00] Speaker C (unidentified): for routine pay all before,
[55:02] Speaker B (unidentified): for but I found an actual expenditures line in the schedule of departmental operations general fund for highways and roads. The thing is this number here for 2025, this number doesn't match anything
[55:24] Speaker A (unidentified): no it's the actual expenditure so it may not match the budget the budgeted original budget 434
[55:34] Speaker B (unidentified): It doesn't match like 435. It even if you add the local road assistance program to it, doesn't come up like, where did they get that number for it? [Speaker D (unidentified): Versus the actual.] And so what I was thinking was we could go back more than 5 years by looking at the annual reports. Except the budgeted number doesn't match the budgeted funds in the warrant or in this table, because the numbers in this table match the warrant. But the number here doesn't match the number in the warrant or in the table. I'd have to look at that. So I don't know where this number comes from.
[56:25] Speaker F (unidentified): The original budget should be for highways and roads.
[56:28] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll have to take a look at that. Yeah, because it shows an expended in actual data.
[56:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Regardless of how much data we have, I do think we should just go five years. Shannon, you wouldn't go much more than five years. You even said one year. You'd go the prior year, how much we have left over. Yeah.
[56:48] Speaker A (unidentified): But I do think having as many as five years can be useful to see historical trends, like has it been going up 10% every year or what's been happening, or maybe one year was an unusual one as apparently was the case last year.
[57:04] Speaker D (unidentified): So I'm also confused. Did we decide not to stack them?
[57:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I'm not sure. I mean, tell me what I'll do.
[57:12] Speaker D (unidentified): I'll stack them, I'll not stack them on duals. [Speaker A (unidentified): Stack what?] The capital and the budgeted.
[57:19] Speaker A (unidentified): I think they should absolutely be kept separate because there's an overlap between them. All right, okay. That's what I wrote down. And if you have the actual one, Dan, you should be able to see that the lumped over went into the capital on the other graph. That's where it goes, right? Anything that's left over on the road budget goes into the road capital reserve. That's what I'm assuming. Is that correct? Yes. Anything that's left over from the road budget for a fiscal year rolls into the road capital. Yes. But it's not the only source for the road capital. No, but it rolls into it. So your capital can grow from that. Right,. But that was my point that you don't want to add them because then you're- Exactly. I agree.
[58:06] Speaker C (unidentified): And because on the table, you've got the figures that were in the budget. So the capital reserve figures that we're looking at are new funds on top of whatever is in there. And that's the piece that's kind of a little bit of a missed period.
[58:24] Speaker E (unidentified): Period. Yeah. It's all confusing.
[58:28] Speaker A (unidentified): It is thoroughly confusing. Sorry, I saw it. No. It turns out you have a very good point. And, you know, I almost, I'm concerned that, you know, if we put too much information in, it's just going to confuse everybody, you know. Right. But what value, how valuable is it for, I mean, the annual report is like maybe they've added their local roads and systems right now. Yeah, we have purely, we can dip into us. Yeah, this is, yeah, but for, how about it's a plan we're looking at in our morning, you know. We have to make a statement, seems to me, about what we want this to look like for the next five years or ten years. So how much does this guide us in getting to the 10-year plan?
[59:24] Speaker B (unidentified): And how specific do we have to be?
[59:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, you know, I think it's very important for guiding us because particularly in a situation like this, the history is probably the best indicator we have of what our future expenditure is going to be. I mean, we have to adjust for, you know, additional maintenance for whatever reason not been done in the past, which hopefully not a lot of. We have to account for inflation. We have to account for things like that. But we're also not actually going to budget the actual lump.
[1:00:00] Speaker B (unidentified): I think that's all it was.
[1:00:02] Speaker A (unidentified): But your other question is how precise does it have to be? Well, you know, it's not necessarily going to be used as a precise planning tool, but the information that we put in there should be the most accurate possible for obvious reasons. It should be accurate enough to be legit. Yeah.
[1:00:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, you need to say 30-something statistics are bottomless fives.
[1:00:27] Speaker A (unidentified): So, I mean, my own feeling after hearing all this discussion about it is that probably the single most important thing actually is the actual expenditure as Ford originally argued. And that we ought to have a table that focuses on the actual expenditure and maybe just the actual maintenance expenditure. Now we could do, and then we can either add to it or do separate tables, which, you know, we can show the budget we want to, I'm not sure we even want to show the budgeted numbers.
[1:00:58] Speaker C (unidentified): So I think we have to, the only thing we have to be aware of is it's conceivable that we could have a budget of amount of 250,000 for capital reserve but we could end up spending 375,000 if we've spent the carryover in addition to what was
[1:01:16] Speaker A (unidentified): budgeted. A carryover should show up in the capital reserve by next year.
[1:01:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Otherwise people are going to go, you overspent your capital reserve, but we, you at least have to have an explanation of why that could happen. Well, right, and that's part of
[1:01:36] Speaker A (unidentified): the explanation that hopefully we're going to add to clarify on that. You're saying this capital reserve in this table here is what we've voted to raise the capital reserve, so that, so that number's
[1:01:47] Speaker C (unidentified): not accurate. Correct. So that's not the total account. It is accurate because it's what we're raising this year. It's not the total that's in the account. Right, and so it's, it's, it's just the
[1:01:59] Speaker A (unidentified): It's the increment. It's the addition to the capital reserve. Okay, I didn't understand that. That was not at all clear to me.
[1:02:06] Speaker C (unidentified): And I mean, somebody could make an argument at town meeting, if we're budgeting $250,000, but we're carrying over $200,000, somebody could make a strong argument that we don't need $250,000 more. And that would be an argument that probably has happened at town meeting, actually.
[1:02:24] Speaker A (unidentified): If you can see the numbers. But looking at this, you can't even see the numbers.
[1:02:28] Speaker C (unidentified): But this isn't a town meeting. I think at town meeting we do know, we are told how much is rolling over. The question is, do we want to put that in here?
[1:02:41] Speaker A (unidentified): The rollover. I think we do. I think maybe in the language, not to have you write more letters, but in the language you might explain if we, if we put the actual numbers in, which I think we should, and they show up on, in your language say anything left over from the annual budgeted amount that doesn't get spent rolls into
[1:03:00] Speaker E (unidentified): capital. Good. I can.
[1:03:03] Speaker B (unidentified): That might be. But first we have to decide. So more specifically what we're going to put on.
[1:03:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Looking at this, you would have more room in this table. Just looking at this visually. Yeah, there's some blank space. I mean, if you stack fiscal and year, you can move that column right over. Yeah, there's space. I agree with you. So there is, and this one here, you can make that. Sure. Sure. You can find a room to have the extra column for what we actually spent of our budgeted funds. We could split capital reserve and create a column that says rollover and then a third column that says actual expense. So that would be adding actual expense for the capital
[1:03:46] Speaker A (unidentified): capital reserve. Okay, or actually, yeah, capital reserve actual expense. Yeah, actually I call it actual expenditure. Right, actual amount. Right, it's not expense, it should be expenditure.
[1:04:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Expenditure is the correct term. Yes, I think right. Are we talking about expenditure is the term used
[1:04:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Used in the yeah everywhere before yeah you know now are you talking about actually removing any percent change budgeted no we can make that smaller that can't be okay I think we although they also those numbers maybe it's just me but and I'm graph guy the graph communicates a lot better at changes yeah third and fifth column are a bunch of numbers in my brain that don't make
[1:04:44] Speaker A (unidentified): a lot of sense but well I think we're going to do it both ways we're going to have we're going to have the table with the numbers and we're going to have the figure with the with the columns so we've got to cover it each way the only question is you know what's it going to show
[1:04:57] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah and I would like to submit the that if we're talking about adding what how many more columns three that's getting I think that's just too busy I just think that's too busy
[1:05:12] Speaker A (unidentified): And I don't think that percent changed matters much you would make it into two tables then
[1:05:19] Speaker B (unidentified): About budgeted funds and capital reserve funds could do that too well I think that makes a lot
[1:05:26] Speaker D (unidentified): Of sense we've got one we've got one number that's going to be that third one that's the carry over of the difference between budget and an actual fat number. What table does that one?
[1:05:42] Speaker A (unidentified): If you make it 2 tables, you put that in a budget. And it's put that in the budget.
[1:05:51] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm not sure we're really making a good use of our time.
[1:05:55] Speaker D (unidentified): What about a pie chart? Pie chart's good for getting percentage. Let me just play with some graphs. I'll shoot it out, and then we can talk about it then. Yeah. But I don't think a... All right. Pie chart. Well, let me...
[1:06:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Just wonder what we're after in our... I can plan here to show the community, and to me, it's about how much we spent as a percentage budget.
[1:06:23] Speaker D (unidentified): And I'm not arguing that we don't add that, but this is comparing year to year to year, and I don't think you want to have a pie chart year to year to year. We want a pie chart transportation versus school versus blah,, blah,, blah
[1:06:37] Speaker A (unidentified): For a year. Yeah. So let me suggest this. So let's remember that Paula is the principal author of the chapter.
[1:06:48] Speaker B (unidentified): I just want to clarify. Grania Shah was the principal author of the chapter. Okay. I'm the second author. All right. Okay. Fair enough. Who was the principal? Grania Shah from K.B. Codd. He's the one who initially directed this chapter. Fair enough.
[1:07:04] Speaker A (unidentified): But for our purposes here, you're the one primarily working on it. Correct. Bob's reviewing it rather than try to even just rewriting this one section where I think we're having a little bit of a problem coming to a consensus. Can you go back and I know you won't be able to look do this until December but you know can in December can you go back and reconfigure this in the way that you think makes most sense
[1:07:35] Speaker B (unidentified): I need to know whether we are going to use actual or not are we going to use actual so that this is
[1:07:46] Speaker D (unidentified): My itself and this is Bob's yeah peace I don't want to put that on her she's got no Bob is doing
[1:07:52] Speaker A (unidentified): The figure well no wait are you Bob are you redoing you're redoing the table as well as the figure you're doing where you're doing the whole thing yeah I'll take care of well I think your Bob is throwing it right he does the grass right so what I'm what I'm trying to say if you're going to redo the table reconfigure it with additional information such as actual expenditures versus budget it seems to me it makes sense since basically what you're doing Bob is making a picture out of that, you Can't do that until Paul reconfigures the table, right? So that's what I'm trying to do. Read the data. Yeah. Right. Yeah. The table data. Which comes from Chad, right? So what I was suggesting is that in December, after we, in December that you reconfigure the table with updated data from Shannon and then Bob puts it into figure form yeah because but I because it seems to me it's it's it's it's taking it the wrong way around if you're trying to make a figure for numbers that we haven't even agreed or we haven't been finalized
[1:09:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah does that make sense yeah I mean yeah I mean nobody would know they're no kidding I didn't
[1:09:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Pay that okay is that okay right and then the table has to be updated and then the figure can
[1:09:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Be developed yeah exactly all right so and we now know the sort where we can get the data from Shannon right so she'll provide five years of actuals and you've already got them busted is that correct yeah and you'll also provide five years of actual versus budget they got rolled into I'll look into that if you can yeah should be it should be I know we've had a
[1:09:59] Speaker F (unidentified): Lot of reconciling of our accounts since you've got a lot of work on yeah yep we can do that five years of actual data. Great. We're careful.
[1:10:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Good. And this all started because Ford wanted the actual cars.
[1:10:21] Speaker B (unidentified): We're gonna- All right. Okay, thank you very much. So I just want to go back to the questions, add a column with the actual road expenditures along with the budgeted number. Okay? Now, are we going to add the, a column for the actual budgeted funds and a column for the actual capital reserve expenditures as well are we adding two columns i thought you suggested maybe you're doing it two tables yeah but i'm just adding about how many additional columns information
[1:11:02] Speaker A (unidentified): How many right? Whether this would be a separate page.
[1:11:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Correct. Correct. Don't worry about how the tables will be constructed. I'm simply looking for what the data sources are going to be.
[1:11:15] Speaker D (unidentified): I think Lynette said three. The actual budget and actual capital and how much of the budget is carried over to the next year.
[1:11:24] Speaker C (unidentified): And that is what Shannon just said she could probably come up with.
[1:11:28] Speaker B (unidentified): and you can get all three i will do what i can five years of actual expenditure of budgeted capital and carryover okay
[1:11:46] Speaker A (unidentified): and i think in the case of the capital also where are we looking at in effect budgeted capital and expended capital do we have do we have numbers for those i will
[1:11:59] Speaker F (unidentified): we'll try to look into see what I've got for that as well okay yep okay I
[1:12:07] Speaker B (unidentified): think we've got a plan
[1:12:08] Speaker A (unidentified): all right all right so is there anything else on the transportation chapter that we
[1:12:18] Speaker B (unidentified): know we'll have to defer further discussion of this until after right this piece is completed
[1:12:27] Speaker A (unidentified): leave it i think right okay so we will at the next meeting in december we will we will resume
[1:12:36] Speaker B (unidentified): discussion of the transportation except i would like to say that all of your suggestions lynette were excellent and i addressed all of them you did good job thank you it was really nice to have that the way that did you look at it i did and i addressed how i commented about all of them
[1:12:55] Speaker C (unidentified): and i can i could see you i got emails that you were doing it oh interesting oh that might have
[1:13:01] Speaker B (unidentified): been in there every no everywhere no it was great oh super okay well paul is working on it now
[1:13:10] Speaker A (unidentified): so you're saying that the dropbox was automatically generating these emails i didn't
[1:13:16] Speaker C (unidentified): know it was apparently paul didn't know what was happening yes that's what was happening so as i
[1:13:21] Speaker B (unidentified): Once I addressed the comment, I wrote a short reply that said, you know, I agree and comment addressed. And it generated an email. And it showed up in my email. Wow.
[1:13:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Wow. I might be able to do something like this, the difference between these two bars.
[1:13:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. Well, we'll address that in December. Okay.
[1:13:46] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. Well, what I'm saying is that you might not need to add one thousand because you already grabbed. Oh, okay.
[1:13:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So are we done with the transportation chapter for now?
[1:13:58] Speaker D (unidentified): No, I think we should talk about it. Thank you, Bob.
New Business
[1:14:02] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. So moving on to new business, there was just one thing I'm going to be doing. And we already have a draft from K.V. Cogg of the housing chapter, but we need to massage it a bit. We do need to designate, and I'll be getting that out in December or, you know, not long thereafter.
[1:14:25] Speaker C (unidentified): It'll be in December. Did you think you're going to be massaging that chapter? Yeah,.
[1:14:30] Speaker A (unidentified): And we need a, since we decided the procedure is there's one primary author and one reviewer, and I've been designated as the primary author, although we...
[1:14:43] Speaker B (unidentified): The second, the second...
[1:14:44] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm really the secondary author, as you describe, for the same reasons you describe. Anyway, we need a review. So anybody want to volunteer?
[1:14:54] Speaker B (unidentified): We already identified someone for that. Who was that? I thought Chris had volunteered for that. That might be right.
[1:15:03] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Well, since Chris isn't here, we will say it was Chris. Please, you don't have to speak up if you don't understand. That works. I remember you might, you know, you might be right about that. That kind of rings a bell. That's what I remember. All right, well, we'll say it's going to be Chris. Thank you, Chris.
[1:15:32] Speaker D (unidentified): That's right. That's, that's going to make sure I don't listen to medium.
[1:15:37] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, and we already have a, the next meeting scheduled for January, and we're moving to Wednesdays now, which will hopefully make life easier for you. So we have a meeting scheduled for, I thought I would. Yeah, it's there. December 16th. Yep. Yep. Yep. December 6th. Yes. Thank you. So the next one. January. Did we do a January? Yeah. Yeah. That's January. Yeah. Yeah. And we, I think what we had tentatively decided, I think, was to aim for the third Wednesday of the month because that's the only Wednesday available, so the third Wednesday of January. Oh, we already scheduled that. Oh, okay. I, by the way, I just heard from, I just saw a late message from Chris who said he's on vacation and maybe he told us sorry about the delay, on vacation this week, won't be at the meeting. Okay. Maybe he told us that. And we forgot. We forgot. We told him that we volunteered verbally. Well, yeah, we were volunteering him. All right, so the third Wednesday of January will be the 20th. Didn't we already cut? No, we scheduled for December, but not for January. Oh, we did this one and then that one. Yeah, so is everybody okay with January, Wednesday, January 20th? Yeah, all right, just for now. But, you know, I think it's helpful in that area, you know. All right, so we've got December 16th and January 20th, and that is all that I have on the agenda. Are there any other matters that anybody would like to bring up for discussion or action? If not, if not, motion like that. Okay, we actually finished early. No penalty for finishing early.