← Back to MaineScanner

Hollis Planning Board Reviews Cistern Standards and Data Center Moratorium

2026-10-28 · 1h 37m · Source: Hollis Planning Board Meeting - 10/28/2026 (Hollis via SRCM (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[2:02] Mhm. [4:05] Mhm. [7:28] [snorts] [7:29] Good evening and welcome to the town of Hollis Planning Board meeting for Wednesday, October 28th, 2026. I will now call this meeting to order by taking a roll call. To my right. [7:43] Tom Witkowski. [7:44] Heather Sullivan. [7:45] Brett Marquis. [7:46] Mucci Gannett. [7:48] And with four members of the Planning Board, [7:52] we don't have any members on Zoom, do we? No. with four members of the Planning Board, we are at quorum and we will move into the Pledge of Allegiance. [8:07] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [8:23] [clears throat] [8:23] We can move straight into correspondence. We've got two pieces of correspondence tonight. The first one is a town message that the select board has put out and I think I will just read it word for word. this is October 8th, 2026. Important message for the voters of Hollis from the select board. [8:46] To the voters of the town of Hollis, on September 16th, 2026, we held a public hearing for the November 3rd, 2026 special town meeting warrant articles. At this hearing, concerns were raised about Article 3, which would adopt a new codified version of all the town's ordinances. Paul Major, a resident and former planning board chair, identified several problems with the proposed version, specifically the zoning ordinance entries. [9:15] These problems include missing changes that voters previously approved, technical and typographical errors, and differences between the current ordinance and the version prepared for codification. Based on advice from our town attorney, we were informed that the process should be paused so these issues with the zoning ordinance can be corrected. The board cannot remove or change Article 3 at this stage, and election deadlines do not allow time to issue a revised warrant. [9:43] For that reason, our town attorney also advised that the best option is for voters to reject Article 3 and a corrected version be brought forward at a future election. The select board supports the goal of making all our town ordinances easier to search and access online through codification. However, because of the errors and concerns identified, [10:04] we unanimously recommend that voters vote no on Article 3 of the November ballot. This would allow the town time to prepare a complete and accurate codified version for consideration at a future election. Respectfully, the Hollis Select Board. [10:23] Our second piece of correspondence relates to some new business that we have coming up. and so I think we can just we'll hold on that until we get to that part of the agenda. [10:39] next up is reviewing the minutes from our last meeting, which was September 23rd, 2026. [10:47] If anyone has any recommended changes to the ordina- to the minutes, please speak up. [10:57] Otherwise, I'll take a motion. [10:59] the minutes. [11:01] Second that. [11:03] Terrific. Do any conversation? [11:06] Hearing none, Tommy? [11:08] Yes. [11:11] Yes. [11:12] Yes. [11:14] Thank you. [11:18] and next up, so we have now approved the meeting minutes from September 23rd. next up is wondering if anyone had anyone from the town has an optional report to give us. It looks like Ashley, you may have one. [11:36] Yes, hi. I just wanted to get on and publicly speak about the town's heat funds. The funds have been released, so we are actively helping individuals who are experiencing a hardship or maybe on a fixed income purchase oil and wood. there are some funds in the town's heat fund to do that. [11:58] and also we do have the Christmas fund, which just opened up. So this is designed for kids of Hollis who may not get Christmas presents otherwise. And the application can be found at the town hall where you can go onto the website, and under the Christmas fun tab, there's an email address. You can email me and I will send you the application. [12:19] Is that true for the heat fund as well? Is there an application online? [12:23] There's no application for the heat fund yet. So, there's a proposed application that I think we are tabling for next year since it kind of got cold quickly. The funds normally don't release till November 1st. So, it's a little earlier this year. [12:35] if they need heat funds, they should just come in and [12:39] Yep, they can reach out to the phone number. I think it's online. If you go under the general assistance tab, the phone number's there and that goes to a cell phone that I have on me at all times. So, you can call if you're experiencing an emergency or even if you're just trying to pre-plan. You know, once the funds run out, they run out. So, it is first come, first serve. And we are accepting donations as well. [12:59] So, if anybody would like to donate, you can just make a check out and drop it off at the town hall. There are clink bags, too. You can pick up a clink bag and drop that off. You know, that's been a big source of income for the program. And the Christmas fund, there will be tags at businesses like River Tab, Partner's Bank, and there'll be a Christmas tree here. I think there might be another business that I'm forgetting, but you pick up tags that go directly to kids and we package them all up and they pick them up the week before Christmas. [13:26] Awesome. Thank you. Thank you for your hard work on that. [13:30] Tom, could you speak about the sand bucket? [13:35] Yeah, absolutely. We got Lifelong Hollis is doing winter sand bucket delivery for Hollis residents age 65 plus. there's some flyers available at the town hall. We'll be sending out flyers on Friday for anybody that gets free senior citizen pizza in the town of Hollis. [13:56] winter sand bucket delivery is part of Lifelong Hollis. So, if you're 65 or older and unable to get to the town sand pile at the town hall, they will deliver two buckets of sand to your home this winter. Fantastic. to request a sand delivery, email lifelonghollis one word, at gmail.com [14:17] or call 207-298-0271. [14:22] That's the general assistance line, so I assume it goes right back over to what you were just speaking about. So again, if you're looking for sand, you're 65 or older, I believe they also added if you're disabled in any way, too, and you can't get to the town hall, they'll provide you with sand buckets as well. So it's not just 65. If you're If you're unable to get to the get to the salt and sand pile at the town hall, they will they will bring you a couple buckets of sand. [14:47] All you got to do is just ask for them. [14:48] [snorts] [14:50] Thank you. [14:50] Awesome. I don't know Lifelong Hollis, so that this was [14:54] It's a new program they're working on. It's great. Yeah, absolutely. [14:57] Wonderful. Any other reports? [15:04] All right, moving on. now's the opportunity for public comment. so if there are members of the public that would like to speak about anything on the agenda tonight or anything planning related, please raise your hand. [15:24] I don't see any hands raised on Zoom, and we don't have anyone in the room tonight, so I think we can move on from that. under old business, we've got two items. One of them's really quick. we'll go with the sis proposed cistern standards. So a few weeks ago, [15:47] Chief of Police came forward during a during one of our meetings and let us know that he had some proposed updates to the town's cistern standards. the cistern standards apply in situations where developer is proposing a subdivision. And in Hollis, all subdivisions require either a cistern tank or a or the homes to be individually [16:15] sprinkler systemed. So Chief has started to notice or has mentioned to us at least that there are some challenges with the cisterns with the aging of cisterns in Hollis and the impacts of that. So, we asked him to come up with some new standards which he did. [16:35] We have taken a look at these. Our town attorney has taken a look at these. [16:41] From the planning board perspective, you know, we can have discussion about them. We should we have to have a public hearing but after the public hearing we can incorporate them into the subdivision regulations. Subdivision regulations do not require vote by the public. So, we could incorporate them you know, after [17:03] we hear from the residents on these standards. So, I'll open up the floor to the rest of the board. What are you guys thinking about these standards? Do you have any I guess first question would be specific comments about any of the language in the proposal. [17:22] I've got some comments about the drafting pipe. [17:24] Oh, let's talk about drafting pipe. Something I never thought [clears throat] I'd be talking about. [17:29] It's It's toward the end of the paragraph on it. [17:32] Okay. [17:35] There's a place that says manufacturer approved vortex control device and a vortex pipe should be provided at the tank intake. [17:43] Yep. [17:44] That should be outlet, I believe. [17:45] Tank outlet. Okay. And I'll have to [17:47] I'm pretty sure that should be outlet. [17:50] Okay. [17:51] next line down creating damaging vertexing that e should be o. [18:01] You see what I'm saying? [18:03] Okay. Damaging vertexing. [18:05] Vortexing. Should be vortexing. [18:08] see. Thank you. [18:09] [snorts] [18:10] And then down the next section [18:15] I believe it should be drafting connection, not fill connection. As it's talking about drafting connection in the paragraph. [18:27] That Oh, and Oh, so not fell connection, but drafting. [18:31] Right. [18:34] Oh, cuz then it says drafting in it. All right. Butch, thank you. It's very helpful. I know nothing about this, so [18:41] I've got two more. [18:42] All right, done. [18:43] I Yeah, please do. [18:47] My page number's not the same as yours cuz I've had about two or three different iterations of this thing. [18:52] Oh. [18:56] it's my page five, but it's on signage. It's section G, I believe. [19:04] Mhm. I think it is our page five as well. [19:09] six. [19:13] It's It's Oh, ours is on [19:15] Yeah, page six, letter G. [19:17] Letter G? [19:18] Yep. [19:18] Okay, I believe that we should add something in there. There's a list of things we should add in there that signs will be replaced as necessary. you know, they wear out, they get shot up, whatever the case. From to time, they might need replacing. [19:39] Okay. [19:41] On the very next page [19:44] there's a under owner's responsibility list a bunch of things. Says periodic flow testing. [19:51] Mhm. [19:52] I got a note there that said the fire department should do this for training and familiarization purposes. [19:59] I'm going to think. [20:00] That's a suggestion maybe that but I think it that would be fit well in there. [20:06] So, we've got acceptance testing. [20:10] It's just under periodic flow testing, which is number 14 on ours. [20:15] So, you're saying that the fire department's thing, not the home owner's. [20:20] Right. Well, [20:21] Yeah. [20:22] Yeah. [20:22] Yep. [20:22] I think the fire does the [20:25] They're the ones who benefit if it works right. [20:27] Right. They're the ones that do the testing. [20:29] But it falls under owner's responsibilities under H. That's That's a good point. [20:38] I what how would how would you like to change it? [20:43] Do you just take it out? And then it's [20:46] I don't know how to go about changing it. It's It's owner's responsibilities. I don't know if we got a place for fire department responsibilities or not. [20:57] There's fire department operational control. [21:02] I mean, maybe it's a note Maybe the fire chief doesn't want to do it. but I think we ought to provide them. [21:10] So, you're talking about number 14. [21:13] H 14. [21:16] Inspection. [21:17] I'm not even close to where you're at. [21:19] Sorry. Ownership and use is number three. Letter H, number 14. [21:29] What page? [21:30] It's six. [21:31] Okay. So, H owner's responsibilities. [21:33] Yeah. [21:33] And we're saying that we want the fire department to be responsible for number 14, periodic flow testing. Okay. [21:42] I don't know how the homeowner would be able to accomplish that. [21:46] Well, they'd have to They'd have to contract somebody to do it, which costs a lot of money. [21:49] Of course. [21:50] The fire department can do it and it's going to save some money somewhere. [21:53] And they get practice on it. [21:54] That's correct. [21:55] 100%. [21:56] So, when we go when you move into section five, acceptance testing, is does that doesn't it's not covered in that. [22:07] It doesn't say It doesn't say that the fire department will do it. [22:12] it says it below. The drafting test shall be conducted using fire department apparatus. [22:22] Oh, great. [22:25] And [snorts] I And I we can go back the chief and oh, this is Oh, this is says that it's done. It is testing by a contractor that and witnessed by the fire department. [22:35] Right. [22:36] Okay. So, we're saying in section H 14, we want the fire department to do periodic flow testing. And [22:45] I 'd like to have the chief presented with that suggestion. I don't want to tell the fire department what they have to do. [22:53] Yeah, but it's for familiarization. [22:55] a lot of sense for them to do it. [22:59] Okay. And Greg, welcome. Did you want to chime in here? [23:09] Hey, Heather. I think you guys are on the right path so far. fire department doing the annual flow testing, but the contractor doing the initial testing is where that should land, in my opinion. [23:25] [snorts] [23:28] All right. Maybe we make it its own section. [23:33] It's just another one of the requirements, but Yeah, and you know, the owner has to make it available for testing. And then the fire but will [23:43] Oh, great. Hi, Christie. [23:48] Hello. How are you? [23:49] Great. How are you? [23:51] I'm doing well. I have a question about the reserve accounts. it says that there needs to be one in place before this the system is accepted, but it doesn't specify what actually qualifies as established because my concern would be we have the system in place and you're already saying that the HOA is responsible [24:19] for these fees. but is the developer going to put like a specific percentage of those estimated costs in an into an account so the HOA has something established when it first starts because these expenses seem pretty high and if there's just if nothing is established, they're going to walk in and maybe not understand [24:42] the cost associated with maintaining the system. And I think that maybe this is a time where you guys can be specific on, you know, it needs to be established with maybe a certain percentage just to make sure that those applicants have something, you know, in the account in the event that something is wrong as soon as they move in. [25:02] Mhm. That makes sense. I think that is the goal here. but I can see what you're saying about there really isn't [25:17] the there isn't meat that goes along with this that says this is what you need to contribute, you know. It says here that the pricing should be current local pricing. so we've got some planning allowances. I maybe would even consider that like estimates instead of allowances. [25:37] but [25:38] And I also wonder it says that it needs to be reviewed every five years. who is going to review that and how do you guys even ensure that's done after the fact? Like who's following up? [25:50] The homeowners association. It's part of the it would become part of their bylaws that they're going to do that every five years. [25:57] But is the town going to confirm that 's being done? Like is there like going to be an audit or something? [26:03] Nothing in here. There should [26:06] So it's more of a recommendation that they keep those up to date for their HOA bylaws something that they need [26:13] bylaws would be reviewed by the town attorney. [26:17] If you If you go If you go [clears throat] back to section J, maintenance records. [26:24] The owner shall maintain [26:28] and provide an I want to add in there and provide a copy to the fire department and CEO. A permanent maintenance file containing original construction drawing, engineer test. I [clears throat] want those records to be provided to the fire department and the CEO also on that thing. [26:49] Okay. [26:51] That may answer some of the questions that she has. [26:57] I think [26:58] in here the last sentence of the maintenance record, "A copy of all records shall be provided to the fire department, updated on an annual basis or more frequently when notable records are received." Is that enough or did you want it to well, and then we would also include CEO. [27:15] Well, I [clears throat] I suppose it says the fire department back there, doesn't need to say in the front, but we need to add the CEO in there also, I think. [27:22] Yep. [27:23] So, maybe add that last sentence and all that talk where I added. [27:29] [clears throat] [27:31] I think what Chrissy's shooting for is more of the enforcement aspect when the rules aren't followed, whether it's an HOA not following the rules that we've laid out or that we've drafted, excuse me. or you know, a developer not following the rules or you know, what have you. [27:52] how is you know, is there any teeth in this beyond [27:58] beyond just the regulation saying that the bylaws also permit the association to assess fines and penalties against non-compliant lot owners and if necessary, record a lien against such property owners. there's there's no requirement [28:18] So, excuse me, there's no there's no teeth in there for the town to require them to do that. You understand what I'm saying? If they if the homeowners association chooses to just forego all of this, I don't know that there's anything in here and I think Chrissy's pointing out the same thing that allows the town to make them follow these rules. [28:46] Yeah, that's that's basically it. I mean, how are we going to enforce what an HOA does? And I understand, you know, that the purpose of the bylaws and things like that, but I'm just saying that it's just more things that the homeowners have to be aware of and you know, they might may not even understand what the process entails. Like I personally live in a four-house HOA. [29:08] Like [29:09] Right. [29:09] there's things that I have to do just because we have to do it, but that doesn't mean every single homeowner really even understands the scope of the responsibilities. And then like what happens if you don't? Like I, you know, just in my experience, people can still get away with things. You know, people do things that they shouldn't be doing, but then like nothing happens. Like that's kind of where we always run into an issue in Hollis is like we know something's wrong until it gets to the enforcement part and then things just kind of fall off. [29:35] Like, you know, so we're just adding more requirements, but like why? Is there like a real If there's a legitimate reason why this is important, I understand and maybe just educate the homeowners like this is why you should do it, but just saying this is something else that you shall do or somebody's may, you know, say something about it. [29:55] It just seems a little excessive. [30:01] It's a It's a solid point. It's [30:03] Yep. [30:04] Like I said, if what Chrissy, I'm sure you won't mind me using your subdivision as an example. If the town came to your subdivision tomorrow and said, "Hey, you know, your cistern is failing. Your Our rules say that you guys have to pay to replace this." Do you think that each four you have four people in your subdivision? [30:25] They're going to come up with $25,000 apiece to replace a cistern? [30:29] Well, they have to. [30:31] That's That's what she's talking about. Or what? You know what I'm saying? [30:36] Yeah, [30:36] because yeah, they or what? Like there's other things that people were supposed to, you know, follow certain rules and they haven't but nothing's happened. But then yeah, you're going to come to me because you don't have an updated document. [30:50] Well, I wonder [30:51] [clears throat] [30:51] it would have to certainly go through legal. If something needed to be done and there was nobody to do it, the town would take care of it and put a tax lien against the properties in that subdivision for the amount I don't know if that's if that's a reasonable answer to this [31:12] possible situation, but [31:16] Or could we just prevent this entirely because wasn't this in place of just having, you know, the sprinkler systems in the basements and you know, in each house? Like wasn't this an option? So I mean, I think this is something to consider that if we do allow developers to go down this route, it could cause just more annoyances for the residents because at the end of the day we're trying to make decisions that better the life of the residents and this seems more of like something that will be more annoying to the residents. [31:48] So, I'm looking at the enforcement section of the subdivision regulations which are very clearly related to the [31:59] construction. [32:01] Not each phase of construction and not the ongoing maintenance of something, not the ongoing use of something. Yep, great. Hi Greg. [32:14] Hey Heather. So, I think these are all valid points. The expense to install a new let's say 15,000 gallon cistern is approximately $60,000 in today's market. [32:35] I think if we're We're to put these numbers out there, we're going to have to expect the HOA to have that money sitting in an account. And then at the end's annual inspection have them produce a bank document proving they have funds. [32:50] Mhm. [32:50] [clears throat] [32:50] However, that's going to be a tough battle for a lot of HOAs and I think the way around this is much as I'm personally opposed to this idea, but I it might be the best idea is to just not allow cisterns and like Christie said go to the sprinkler requirement for these multi families and subdivisions. [33:13] This that would eliminate the entire [33:17] town burden of repair and replacement even though these HOAs are technically responsible. We've seen in the past and history repeats itself if they're just not going to have those funds available at the time needed. Or the fire department's going to find out at the wrong time that the cisterns failed and leaking. [33:38] You know, they're going to go to the draft these tanks and they're leaking and nobody's going to know for 6 months. You know, they might have passed the annual inspection but they're they do leak over time, you know, it's a even the concrete tanks they're they you know, they're relying on a asphalt base sealant around each joint. You know, that leaks over time or like a fiberglass tank, those crack over time. [34:04] You know, there's no cistern that's going to be leak proof. So the only solution that really is a to avoid the whole problem is sprinklers with annual inspections to make sure those work in my opinion. [34:16] Well [34:16] As much as I hate to go hate to go that route. [34:20] And it and just for my own knowledge, what happens if a sprinkler system fails? It's the individual property owner responsible for it. [34:35] Okay. [34:37] Yeah, so if the if the individual sprinkler system fails it's one house, not the entire subdivision. So, it's it's a lot easier to have the homeowner on the hook for hey, your sprinkler system fails, rather than hey, the cistern fails, now you all owe you know, in 10 years, 20 years, 40 years, the equivalent of a $100,000 [34:59] to replace the tank. [35:00] Mhm. [35:01] it's a much real it's much more realistic ask of the homeowner and requiring that annual inspection is a little bit easier on the homeowner as well. [35:12] Mhm. [35:14] Greg, I agree with you and [clears throat] I'm not crazy about requiring every home to have a sprinkler system in it, but it certainly takes the onus off of the town [35:26] and puts it on the homeowner [35:31] and stops any portion of not having a functional cistern system. So, I have to agree with you there. [35:40] Yeah, Butch, I am personally not for sprinkler systems in homes. However, [35:46] And this would be just in homes that are in subdivisions that come Now, remember, shortly, in another 6 or 7 months, 8 months or so, not all subdivisions are going to come through us any longer. We are going to not see three ones that are three unit, those won't come through us at all. [36:05] They won't be legally called subdivisions. [36:08] There's kids still You're still subdividing. Anytime you subdivide Anytime you split property into more than two [36:14] years. [36:14] Yeah. No, yeah, three Well, [36:18] Well, yeah, twice in 5 years, sorry. [36:21] So, I think that I think Heather, that's more reason to go and I 'm personally against this, but I do In this situation, I think it's the best path forward [36:30] Mhm. [36:30] to protect the town is to not allow cisterns and go individual sprinklers. I 'm personally against it, but I see the value to protect the town and I do think that might be the best way moving forward, especially where we're not going to see all these instances in the future. [36:51] Okay. I think that [36:56] Do you have an opinion? [36:57] It's the opinion the same opinion I've held the entire time. [37:00] So I think that, you know, in order for us to move any of these forward at all, whether that's replacing this in its entirety and just take out cisterns, I think we will have to have a public hearing. So maybe that is the opportunity for members of the public, including developers, and our fire chief, to let us know why [37:22] we should or shouldn't do [37:26] that kind of major change. The language is not in the zoning ordinance, so cisterns are not something that are zoned in necessarily. but I have to say I think that again, same position. I'm not for requiring people to put expensive systems into their homes, although this one is more of a protective system for folks, so it's a little easier to swallow. [37:52] [37:56] so that would kind of so I guess what we would have to do as a board is hear from the public and then make a decision on whether or not we want to do away with cisterns in its entirety. And then we would also kind of have to make a decision on whether or not we felt does that Is that a big enough change that we would actually want to put it to a vote? [38:16] We can put things to a vote if we want to. [38:18] Mhm. [38:18] so I think that's a good I think that's something for us all to kind of think about and keep in mind when we're reminding folks to come to public hearing. [38:30] I've got a couple more changes. [38:31] Oh, great. Go for it. [38:33] the tank installation, I guess. It's it's my page 13. It's my I'll be on your page seven or something. I don't know. [38:44] Page nine, I think. [38:47] Is that the reserve? Where is that? [snorts] [38:51] Well, tank is about A, it's tank a minimum 10-year manufacturer's warranty. [38:55] Yep. [38:55] B is installation. [38:57] Yep. [38:57] A minimum 1-year contract warranty. I'd like to see that 5 years. [39:01] Okay. [39:01] It's not something it gets it's going to get a ton of use to find out if it's going to wear or break out. [39:08] Okay. [39:09] and down in D, under payment, I would like to see that as a 2-year approved design for a minimum 2 years. [39:19] that for me. Okay, so it's B for minimum of 2 years. [39:22] Yeah. Go ahead. [39:24] Hey Butch, Greg. I might push back on the warranty period for the contractor as 1 year is the state requirement. and then that might I don't I don't think it's I don't think we're in the right to go beyond the state requirement there. [39:45] I think 1 year is the standard. [39:49] maybe to hold the contractor the you know, not the contractor but the owner for 5 years maybe but not the contractor themselves. [40:02] Okay. [40:05] Under payment, I'd like to see it 2 years on that, not 1 year. [40:12] Does anyone [snorts] else have a opinion on that one? [40:15] Mhm. [40:17] My same thought goes for the payment. The state standard is 1 year. [40:23] So, I would think we couldn't go less than 1 year. We can't We can't exceed the state standards, I know. And in this case, they're providing a minimum or they're providing a maximum. I don't know. So, I those two suggestions, whatever we do with them is fine. [40:47] Okay, so I think that's one that we that we need to talk about a little bit further. [40:53] Maybe. And then [40:55] [clears throat and cough] [40:56] Section 8 as built requirement. [41:03] And this probably covered somewhere else in here, but it's it's mentioned again here before final acceptance the developer shall provide the fire department and owners and code enforcement officer with the as built plan showing all the stuff tank locations and everything else. [41:23] Okay. [41:27] And the last thing I have is on the last page. And I guess it's [41:34] it's final acceptance. Number 14, the owners have established [41:40] by the final acceptance is that the owners have established its maintenance and replacement reserve. We talked about this earlier with Christie. And I'm wondering [41:56] there ought to be something in there as to how that's accomplished if that's going to be a requirement, I would think. You know, is it going to be a bond or is going to be a letter of credit or something like that. [42:10] Hey guys, if we're going to like allow a reserve I think we should consider a cash reserve. you know, in the a bond is great, but that's renewed every year and it's really not the purpose of a bond. The bond is more of the [42:31] say we're going to you know, perform the work and they guarantee the work is going to get done. This is more of a replacement cost item, so I don't I don't know if the bond is the right tool for that. [42:45] I don't I don't know. [42:46] A letter of credit a letter of credit or a cash reserve I think would be the right tools for that. [42:51] Okay, I just think there ought to be Well, there ought to have some stipulation in there on how we're going to accomplish that. [42:58] I agree. I think the better tool is that we get rid of them completely. But but you're right. If we're going to allow them, we got to have the money in the bank sitting where it sitting somewhere to replace these things cuz they're not free to replace. And it's not the town's responsibility to replace them. [43:23] I know that we had some comments on our on our guarantees that we've not gotten to, but I know that there's there's been some discussion around I guess we would consider these to be kind of like performance well. Are they though? I guess that's the question. [43:45] Are they performance [43:45] So, these wouldn't be performance guarantees. This is a replacement cost. Not So, like the performance guarantee is hey, we're going to build a subdivision. If we don't build the subdivision and the town approves it, here's a guarantee with the money that if we fail, the town can come in and finish the project. [44:08] Mhm. [44:09] So, this isn't a performance guarantee because we're not performing any work. It's a replacement cost. So, it's like a almost an insurance policy would be needed to say if it when it is failed, here's the policy to replace this. [44:26] Okay. [44:26] So, like it's the for- it's not a performance guarantee, I guess, is long story short. [44:32] So, that's why you're saying a cash reserve seems to be the best way to get that accomplished. Is that them you know, the HOA showing that there is cash set aside for this and that it stays there untouched however long. [44:49] Yeah, cash reserve or letter of credit. insurance policy. I don't know if I don't know if I have no idea if there's an insurance policy available for this. Just throwing that out there. Cash reserve or letter of credit is probably the way to go. I just the bond is the wrong tool. I guess long story short. [45:08] Would the even with the letter of credit, would it be the developer, the builder, or the owner? And if it was a say it was a 10-lot subdivision, would it be each owner listed on the letter of credit, or would it be again, like the developer or the subdivider? I just don't know. [45:28] I'm not super [45:30] It'd be the HOA listed as the letter of credit cuz the HOA would own the cistern. [45:38] Okay. [45:40] So, it'd be I don't know this, but like running off the cuff, my thoughts are it would be the developer's responsibility to have those cash funds in the HOA at the time of closing to be able to provide that letter of credit to get the final acceptance to then [46:03] for the town to provide, certificates of occupancy. [46:09] Okay. [46:11] Again, this is just my experience. I'm not a lawyer. I don't pretend to be one. I don't play one on TV. This is where I'll need to run through a little legal. [46:21] I know you have more experience with this than most of us, so it's it's definitely appreciated. [46:28] So, I think we also, like, as Christie was saying, I do think in that 14 as well, we need to spell out what established means. [46:40] So, it's almost like established and fund. [46:43] Right. [46:44] The fully fund or, you know, fund to a What I'm not seeing here is who kind of says, "Yes, you've put enough money in." [46:54] You like, "Yes, that's the right amount." [46:55] Well, we listed bunch of costs back there. [46:58] Right, but those say that they are for planning purposes only. [47:01] Yeah. [47:02] And that cost should come from a contractor. But how do I mean, I guess the question is So, we have situa- we've had situations in the past where costs have come through and our reviewing engineering firm said, "Ooh, those costs seem a little bit low. and we really think it's going to be this much instead. Do we [47:22] I mean, I think that's important at these dollar amounts, we would want to [47:28] Yeah, I think those would definitely need to go to a third-party engineer that the town hires to confirm the amounts. That's just That's just another point. For a sprinkler system and not a cistern. [47:41] Yeah. [47:42] We don't have to worry about any of these questions. [47:45] Because a sprinkler system an individual homeowner doesn't have to put a reserve account aside for it. [47:51] Right. [47:52] Okay. [47:52] But you can't protect people from themselves. [47:56] Yeah. [47:56] If you know, if the town recommends sprinkler systems and somebody builds a house and doesn't put it in and then has a total loss, that's on them. It's not on us. [48:08] Yep. [48:09] you know. [48:11] And we don't have anything that in our subdivision regulations that say you have to have your it has to be working. Like once you could install it and then not maintain it, right? Okay. Yep. [48:24] Just like changing your batteries in your smoke detector. [48:27] Yeah. A little less a little more expensive than changing the batteries in the smoke detector. No. [48:31] That principle. [48:32] [cough and clears throat] [48:33] Yeah, there I think a note to ask our chief is our fire department certified to inspect these sprinkler systems annually. I know some towns are. some towns aren't. [48:49] All right. [48:50] If is our town fire department certified to inspect these sprinkler systems? [48:57] And going back to liability, who does the liability on that fall on? So, I don't [49:02] a lot of lot of sprinkler systems, there's an outside contractor that'll certify them. [49:07] Yeah. [49:08] Not saying that's the way we roll, but it's definitely a possibility. [49:14] So, I'll ask the chief what we're currently doing and whether or not that that whether or not there's someone on the department that is certified. probably him, I would think if there was someone. and then I can come back and report along with, you know, I'll wrap I'll roll this all up to him to get his comments on all the things we talked about tonight. [49:33] Hey other one last thing is who is recording the who is who is record keeping of which [49:47] which home has a sprinkler system that needs inspection? You know, like it's great to put all these things in place. It's really easy to set a rule. The follow-up is really the hard part in anything we do. So, who is doing that and what records do we have? you know [50:08] really whose feet can we hold to the fire when these things are really come push the shove? [50:14] I just think [50:15] I don't I don't want to say we're going to hold his feet to the fire, but I think the code [clears throat] enforcement office would be the one that would have that information readily available when a house is built and when he does the final inspection. [50:30] I think it'd be as easy and he needs a document that the sprinkler system you know, passed a test from a certified contractor before it gets knocked. [50:39] Greg, are you suggesting annual inspections of the sprinkler systems? [50:44] 100%. Yep. [50:46] Okay. [50:47] But I'm guess but my question is who is record keeping these things? Cuz it's like I'm saying, it's it's easy to require these things, but who's keeping track? [50:57] I know there's I forget which town it was, but it was it was one of them around us where they go out first month of every year and the fire department does inspections on the sprinklers, and then they know that those sprinklers are done. I can't off the top of my head remember which town it was, but it was a smaller town like us. where they went out in January and did all their sprinklers or February or June or whatever it was. [51:23] And that way there wasn't a oh, we inspected this one in June, these 12 in February, and these two in this month. It was just a standard they went out and did their inspections, but again, I'll I'll look into it and try to figure out what it was. [51:39] You probably need to talk to the fire chief at some point. [51:40] Yeah, I was going to say I feel like you know [51:42] so much of this that we're [laughter] just We're batting it around. His eyes are just rolling in the back of his head. [51:50] Yeah, he's sitting there watching. He's just going, "Why are they We got this. We know what we're doing." [51:55] D. [51:56] [clears throat] [51:57] any other suggestions? [52:05] Okay, I will get a note over to the chief. [52:10] Oh, Heather, I guess one thing if we do allow cisterns, I would want to allow concrete cisterns. [52:19] You would want to allow what cisterns? I'm sorry, I couldn't hear you. [52:22] precast concrete. [52:24] Okay. [52:25] You say you wouldn't want to allow that. I would. [52:29] You would. [52:29] The chief can [52:30] I haven't seen anybody install anything other than a precast concrete cistern. [52:38] O- okay, the fire chief is asking for fiber glass or composite or steel. [52:46] I understand that. [52:48] Yep. [52:48] As an installer, I've never seen anybody put anything other than precast concrete. [52:54] Right. Right. [52:55] Availability, I've I've just never seen it. I'm not saying he's Not saying they're better or worse. I've just heard some I'll leave it as an installer. I haven't seen anybody install anything other than precast concrete. [53:13] Right. So, do we even know if those like could you Greg, if someone said yeah, we want a different material, could you install that do you think or is it [53:25] [53:26] Is it [53:26] So, personal experience, I recently tried to order a fiberglass reinforced cistern and I couldn't even get a call back from a supplier. [53:36] Wow. Wow. [53:38] Not saying that's standard. this is a very anecdotal case study. in my experience I've never seen one installed that was not precast concrete. And I've I've seen a few. [53:54] I would say that's probably all we have in town is precast concrete. And you know, according to the chief, they're they're failing. whether it's the seal, the plug, or what might be, but [54:09] The chief was not a fan. [54:11] Yeah. Okay. [54:13] Not right. He's not installing them. [54:16] I'm wondering how many of cistern I mean, I guess it doesn't really matter, but I'm wondering how many we have in the town. Total. I wonder if there's a record of that. [54:23] know. [54:23] So, Greg, thank you for your suggestions. Does that information, knowing that it's been challenging for someone to do in their real life what we're are now considering asking a developer to do. [54:43] I think the chief's point when he was designing this was he exhibited expressed frustration with the failure rates of the [54:53] Mhm. [54:54] concrete cisterns that are installed. [54:56] of the town. [54:57] And the cost to the town and he seemed to be like my mind, he was more like they don't work. We would if we were going to accept cistern it would have to be a fiberglass reinforced. [55:12] I know that I [55:13] Do we know the age of the cisterns that were failing? [55:17] I just remember he spoke to us maybe 6 months ago Greg. I don't I don't honestly remember. [55:22] Yeah, no. I agree. I recall what you're saying. I think the thing we need to remember is every cistern is going to leak, crack, or fail. The lifespan is 30 to 60 years approximately. [55:40] So, I guess I wonder what age are we talking about these concrete cisterns failing? [55:45] I think it would be interesting to talk to the chief again cuz I was kind of left after hearing his presentation on cisterns that [55:55] he was really pushing in his cistern regulations. He was really pushing for sprinklers. Because he [56:02] I think that's what we're all the conclusion that I'm getting to. [56:06] Yeah. [56:06] know what everybody else [56:07] Yep. [56:08] but when's the last time you drove by a gas station [56:12] [clears throat] [56:14] and saw the tank getting replaced? I don't know about you, but I see it pretty often. And those are all fiberglass tanks that are getting replaced. So, it's pretty obvious that those don't last forever as well. Just to some you know, just an observation to look out when you drive around and you see gas station getting worked on. It's typically those underground tanks that are getting replaced and those are the same style tanks that we're looking for a cistern. [56:40] [clears throat] [56:40] Just anecdotal. [56:42] I wonder if we can legally the town could just require sprinklers built subdivisions or [56:51] Yeah, we can do that. [56:52] reason that we have to have an option for cisterns. [56:55] I don't believe so. The but I can I can double check that. The reason right now we have to have the option is because it's written into the subdivision regulations that you can either do this or that. so, let me check with the attorney. [57:10] So that just real quick, the towns that towns or cities that require sprinklers in subdivisions, Gorham, Portland, Saco, Scarborough, South Portland, Yarmouth, Falmouth, Cumberland, Durham, North Yarmouth, Lyman, Raymond, Hollis I ironically is in here saying that you can have cisterns. [57:28] Oh, cuz you can. [57:29] Ogunquit and Windham. so it's not an uncommon thing. I remember talking about this gosh, Paul is still here, so you know, three to five years ago, and when the chief came in and said, "Hey, look, this is this is a cost to the town. These costs are falling on the residents, and you know, here's here's the POs for the for the [57:54] fire department having to go out and get bids to replace these. they're expensive. We need to move away from this, but we have to come to you." And then and then we just we started to move towards following what the chief told us, you know, suggested. but I think this is just kind of the second step in that process and going, "Look, these cisterns are still failing. [58:14] They will all fail eventually, regardless of what they're made of. [58:17] Sure. [58:18] they're obviously going to need to replace at some point. Let's let's take that off the taxpayers' dole and put it, you know, on the people who are either developing it or building it." [58:29] Hey Tom. [58:31] Yeah. [58:31] how many of those that require sprinklers have public water? [58:37] Have what? [58:38] I can [58:39] Public water. [58:41] Portland [58:41] Fall under main water, Portland water, Kennebunk water, etc. [58:46] Some of them some of them don't. Yeah, it was I don't know if Lyman does. Ogunquit, I'm sure does. [58:53] I believe Ogunquit has a water district. [58:56] Yeah, most of them arguably most of them, I assume. [59:04] So it sounds like you're going to get a little more information about what other towns are doing and like that water, you know, city water. going [59:10] at other towns. sure the chief's probably got this already pulled up somewhere, but I'll look at other towns' requirements for sprinklers in subdivisions and how they write their ordinances and how they do all that stuff. And then I'll come back to the next meeting with that. And then [59:26] I'll reach out to the chief and get I've got a bunch of notes here. and including just we would really like to get his input in you know, on the bigger question of whether or not just sprinklers, whether or not that's that it whether or not that's really an option moving forward. I have a suspicion it probably isn't is, sorry. [59:49] And then I do think we need to think about enforcement a little bit differently and how we would be able to [1:00:00] get some enforcement in place if we did decide to keep cisterns. do you guys think we're ready for a public hearing on this topic or do you think that where it's too early? [1:00:12] I don't know that we have a definitive plan. [1:00:16] Let's hear from the chief. [1:00:17] Okay. All right. [1:00:18] At least. [1:00:19] Yep. [1:00:21] So we're in lockstep, but we want to all possible. [1:00:25] Okay. [1:00:26] Step with him. [1:00:29] All right. Any anything else we want to [1:00:35] do when it comes to this particular issue? [1:00:38] I don't think so. [1:00:39] Wait. Okay. Thank you. I can give us a very quick update on the state mandated ordinance changes. Those are ordinance changes that require us to allow more dense residential construction in our growth areas. [1:01:01] SMPDC has been working on our ordinance looking at our ordinances to identify where in them need to be updated. And I expect to have their report back in the middle of February middle of November. [1:01:17] And that's getting That's getting paid for with a grant. [1:01:20] Yep, all paid. [1:01:21] And then our prior select board member, Mary Hoffman, was able to get to us before she left. So, none of that falls on the taxpayers. [1:01:29] Correct. [1:01:29] Which is fantastic. [1:01:30] Correct. So, I think that depending on I think we have to figure out when our next meeting is, but we may have to change it so that we can start digging into those at our next meeting. Should be fantastic. I am quite curious to see how extensive the how extensive they really are. [1:01:50] I did spend some time with Jamal, and we did talk about you know, we want the changes to reflect only the minimum state requirements. We're not trying to make it any bigger than what the state is requiring us to do. We're not trying to expand access to housing in Hollis. [1:02:11] so, he's going to have some suggestions for us, and I'm really looking forward to it. any questions on that? The This will be all the voters hear about in the next as far as I'm concerned, in the next 6 months. So, after we get through cisterns, and this next item, on to new business. [1:02:31] Although we have talked about this before, we have our select board has put forth a data center moratorium. moratorium is a temporary ban on the building I don't know exactly how we what language we use. Most of the towns, the language is pretty is pretty consistent. [1:02:52] It's the It's the building It's the siting, installation, operation, [1:03:02] and expansion of any data centers, and there's a definition in the moratorium greater than 25,000 square feet in size. so, I think the definition, it does include 25,000 square feet or greater. one of the things that I think I've heard around town and why I put together this really this two-page [1:03:29] matrix. [1:03:31] I like this. [1:03:32] Yeah. Think so, yeah. Yeah, I did. that's just the only way that I can like [1:03:38] Yeah. [1:03:38] That's the only way I can compare things, right? [1:03:40] to It's It's nice. [1:03:41] so, you know, what I found here and you know, I did not cherry-pick necessarily, but I did not go very far from home when I pulled up these ordinances. So, we I just looked at what Buxton, Gorham, Limington, Saco, and Scarborough do because those are all towns [1:04:05] that touch us. I did not grab Waterboro. I probably should have, but I didn't. [1:04:14] and what I learned was for the most part, the definitions are pretty consistent. it's in a couple places. So, Buxton had just enacted their moratorium. so, I they had just said yes to it at a special town meeting. and another one is got a vote coming. [1:04:34] Oh, no, these are all these other ones are enacted. they are either they either apply to all size data centers or data centers that are above 2,500 square feet. So, that's a pretty significant difference than what our proposed moratorium is, which is a ban on data centers that are 25,000 [1:04:57] square feet or larger. [1:05:03] that's what has come in front of us. we can go back to the select board with recommendations if we see anything in the ordinance that we think it should be different. there's no guarantee that they will take our recommendation or not, but of course, you know, it is [1:05:24] We do have the right or the authority to go back and say, "Hey, this doesn't make sense to us." If we wanted to do that, I did include in our packets just copies of language that other towns use just in the event that you wanted to take a look at it. These moratorium warrant articles are becoming very consistent across [1:05:47] different towns. So, that was one thing that, you know, historically when you would see a moratorium, it would be written very differently. Each town kind of had their own way of doing it, and these look pretty similar with the exception of, you know, a few minor details, but then really that size that size threshold. [1:06:08] So, we are because this would be Oh, hey Greg. [1:06:16] Hey Heather, are we sure that size requirement isn't a clerical issue? [1:06:21] The what? [1:06:21] 2,500 being a standard for every other town and us being 25,000 is wild. Are we sure that's not a clerical issue there with just the an extra zero there, maybe? [1:06:32] Yes. [1:06:33] Yes, we are certain. The select board had a public hearing on it. Was it a public hearing or just a select board meeting? [1:06:40] Just a select board meeting. [1:06:41] and it was [clears throat] it was mentioned and discussed, and I don't know the why 25,000 versus all banning all or, you know, it is only a temporary moratorium. [1:06:55] months. [1:06:55] Yep. And we think six months and we can extend it if once or twice. [1:07:00] And I'm I'm just throwing this out there. If we just banned everything for six months we're not going to interrupt anybody's business. Nobody has one on the books. Nobody is putting an application forth. I mean, all we're Look at me, Tommy. What are you thinking over there, or Butch? I mean [1:07:20] It's It's just saying for 6 months, you know, hold your business, come back, let us get our feet under us, and then come back and see us. [1:07:30] And I don't [1:07:31] We're not even telling the people that are going to write the regulation. They may come up with some It may It may have to be 3,742 [1:07:42] for some reason that we don't know. [1:07:45] I do believe that the select board has formed a committee. Is that correct? [1:07:50] Yes. [1:07:51] A committee is formed to look at data centers more closely and develop ordinances that may ultimately end up banning, may not. You know, [1:08:03] And they may set a number that's based in [1:08:05] What's that? Oh, great. Hi Mike, how are you? [1:08:09] I just correct the record. No committee has been formed. [1:08:13] I can hear you. [1:08:14] I'm sorry about that. You cut out. [1:08:17] Oh, sorry. Yeah, I just wanted to correct the record. No committee has been formed. [1:08:21] Oh, okay. Oh, I didn't realize that. Okay, so you guys did not vote on a committee. [1:08:26] We voted to form a committee, but we didn't we didn't assemble a committee. [1:08:31] seated people on it. [1:08:32] you. I got you. Okay. And Mike, would you want a member of the planning board on that committee as well? Is that [1:08:38] I don't want to talk about like without the select board. I'm I'm not here as a I'm just a member of the select board. I don't want to talk for the board. So, we could certainly ask that question in public during the next select board meeting. That'd be great. [1:08:51] Okay. Yep. Sounds good. so, as a planning board, while this is a moratorium, it is a temporary ban, state law does say that if you are making an ordinance change that is going to ban something in its entirety, you do need to have a public hearing. it is my opinion that a moratorium is not a ban. [1:09:15] It is a temporary action, but I think that given this is a We've been asked to hold a public hearing. We've been asked by the select board to do that. I'm very comfortable with doing that. we do we're good at that. [1:09:30] [laughter] [1:09:30] We have a lot of public hearings. So, I as chair would like to recommend that we have a public hearing. Greg. [1:09:40] Hey Heather. [1:09:41] Yeah, I'd like to make a motion we have a public hearing on this as well as we make a recommendation as a planning board to have a planning board member on the committee. [1:09:53] Okay. [1:09:54] I'll second that. [1:09:57] All right. Any discussion? [1:10:02] We want to talk about when the days are available for a public hearing. [1:10:06] I think have we I is there anything else that we want to look at in the this draft that we would is there anything else other than adding you know, putting the planning board member? [1:10:20] Greg has hand up again. [1:10:21] Yep, Greg. [1:10:22] Hey Heather, yeah, I think we're looking at your document here. I think the 25,000 square feet is pretty wild. I think we want to be more consistent with towns surrounding us and drop down to that 2,500 square feet. [1:10:40] I am I mean these you know, these are recommendations only. I you know, I hope to hear from members of the public. but I am not against that either. I think that you know, Mike I would actually prefer to see if you're going to moratorium something, I would prefer personally prefer to moratorium it completely [1:11:03] while you figure things out. otherwise you're almost giving someone an advantage. Yeah, an advantage. now what became a way to level the playing field so that we don't get caught as a town without appropriate ordinances in place to manage a business. Now [1:11:23] with allowing up to a amount on a moratorium. Now you're giving business an advantage because they might be the only one. [1:11:33] 6 months, they don't have to play by the rules that we designate. [1:11:36] Yeah, well, you have to do You don't even have to get in 6 months. [1:11:38] Well, you can you can [1:11:40] get a conditional approval. [1:11:41] retroactive this thing when you when you do it. [1:11:45] Yeah. [1:11:47] Hey Heather, my thought on the square footage as well as let's say there is a company out there looking for, you know, a data center in southern Maine and they're seeing Buxton, Gorham, Limington, Saco, and Scarborough with all these regulations and we're sitting here with the 25,000 [1:12:07] square foot limitation. They may be looking at that like, "Oh, well, we can just go here for at 24,999 square feet and get this in where other towns are saying no over 2500." That might actually have an adverse effect and draw data centers in during this moratorium rather than [1:12:29] do what it's intended to and deter data centers. So, I think that large square footage is actually going to have the adverse intended effect. [1:12:44] So, we have a we have a motion on the floor. Greg, do you want to modify your motion or take your motion back and restate it to include a proposed change rec- that we would recommend a lower amount instead [1:13:03] So, I guess my motion stands that I motion that we have a public hearing on this. [1:13:09] Yeah. [1:13:10] I guess I make a second motion that we recommend to the select board that the square footage limit be reduced to 2500 square feet. So, I guess I'd have two motions on the table. Butch have having seconded the public hearing motion. [1:13:29] If I'll second the second motion. [1:13:33] And then deal with the first motion. [1:13:34] All right. [1:13:35] Yeah, let's let's do let's deal with the first motion. So, we have a motion and a second for a public hearing. Now, that one also did include that we would recommend or we would ask for a planning board member to be on that committee. Butch, does your most does your Greg, does your motion still stand with those two pieces? [1:13:55] Those can be separated if we need them to have them be separate motions, but I do I guess Yeah, so I make a So, I can I amend my motions. I make three motions. [1:14:05] Yep. [1:14:06] first being a motion we have a public hearing regarding data centers in moratorium in Hollis. Second motion being that the planning board recommends to the select board that we have a planning board member on the data center committee. And third being a motion that we ask the select board to reduce the square footage from 25,000 [1:14:30] to 2,500 square feet. So, three motions in total. [1:14:35] We need a second then we can have discussion. [1:14:40] And you can [1:14:41] Second. [1:14:42] Are you seconding all three? [1:14:43] I'll second all three. [1:14:45] Thank you, Butch. [1:14:46] I'm Butch now. [1:14:47] So, we'll open up discussion for the [1:14:50] public hearing. [1:14:50] I'm sorry. [1:14:51] Let's start with public hearing. That's okay. Start with public hearing. Any discussion about whether we should hold a public hearing or not? [1:14:58] No, we should definitely hold a public hearing. Anybody else? [1:15:02] Okay, let's let's run it through a vote real quick. Greg, you're going to be voting? I'm going to ask you to vote first. Yeah. [1:15:09] Yes. [1:15:09] This is just on the first motion for a public hearing. [1:15:13] Yes. [1:15:14] Yes. [1:15:16] Perfect. You want to pick a date? [1:15:18] So, we have so moved we have approved motion. Yes, let's pick a date right now. we have to give a I think it's a 12-day notice and a 7-day notice. [1:15:28] Well, give us some tentative dates. [1:15:30] going to say we have Okay. So, which date looks good to you guys? We've got it looks like our next regularly scheduled planning board meeting would be on Veterans Day, I believe. so, I don't know if that is the right day for us to hold [1:15:46] Let's push it to the 25th if possible. [1:15:49] [1:15:49] 25th is the day before Thanksgiving. [1:15:52] So, [1:15:53] How do folks feel quickly that [1:15:55] How do we feel about having it on the 24th, which is a Tuesday? So, the day before our regular planning board meeting. We would We would replace our meeting [1:16:05] Yep. [1:16:06] on the 23rd with a meeting on the 24th. [1:16:09] Be at 7:00 p.m. correct? [1:16:10] 7:00 p.m. same time. It would just be 1 day early. I know that's rough on not just us, but public. [1:16:17] I'm good with that as long as there's no conflicts with the meeting room and other committees. [1:16:22] Can it Is there a calendar? [1:16:24] I'm pulling it [1:16:25] I can't make it 24. [1:16:27] You can't Butch can't make the 24th. [1:16:29] No reason not to have it, but I just can't. [1:16:32] We'd like to have you at our meetings, Butch. [1:16:36] Should we entertain the 11th on Veterans Day or [1:16:39] It's got to be either the 24th or the 25th to be able to get to be able to get the notices out for a whole [1:16:44] days notice, right? [1:16:46] Mhm. [1:16:46] This was [1:16:49] Yes, 12 days. [1:16:49] And then 7 days prior to hearing. So, it's 19 days. Is that what you're saying? [1:16:54] No, it's 12. [1:16:56] Yeah, so It's 12 days notice. I mean, is the 11th still in play just that it's Veterans Day? [1:17:01] Mhm. Yep. [1:17:04] I think it's 24th or 25th are the two options that we have. [1:17:08] So, you're Where you're saying we don't have an option for the 11th. [1:17:11] Oh. [1:17:12] We don't have an option for the [1:17:13] But, you wouldn't be available for the 11th. [1:17:14] Okay. I was going to push for the 11th. [1:17:17] But, she was around, but Butch's schedule's tight. [1:17:21] So, they have I don't see anything on the Hollis meeting or [1:17:26] What's What's the objection to the 11th, Tom? [1:17:30] I don't [1:17:30] 14 days. [1:17:32] I guess it I'm going off of what admin secretary Bennett Flinner gave us our town attorney, excuse me. Let me show Let me read this real quick. [1:17:41] Sure, for the record? [1:17:42] Yeah, of course. good morning. At their 10 21 26 meeting, the select board approved the data center moratorium ordinance and set the special town meeting date for Tuesday, December 8th, 2026 at 7:00 p.m. Stick that on your calendars. Our town attorney advised that the planning board hold the public hearing for this moratorium ordinance as it is a land use ordinance that is subject to 30 [1:18:04] AMRS section 4352 subsection 9. Please schedule this public hearing at your next planning board meeting on today. [1:18:14] [snorts] [1:18:14] Because there's a number of holidays in November that fall in your meeting, including 11 Veterans Day, the planning board can schedule the public hearing on either, excuse me, on 11 24 or 11 25. [1:18:26] So, we can't even get in like this building is not open on the 11th. Is that correct? So, that's why we can't do it on the 11th. [1:18:34] Could we reschedule the 11 meeting to the day before or day after? [1:18:41] Either way, personally I'm going to I'll finish reading the rest of this. I would think the planning board would prefer 11 24, but your schedules will probably dictate that. Either way, per state statute, the two ads for the public hearing must be published at least 12 days prior, then 7 days prior to the public hearing. I'd be glad to assist Ashley with this. The select board will be signing the warrant on 11 4 26 [1:19:04] and submitting it and the final proposed moratorium ordinance to the town clerk the next day. [1:19:11] So, theoretically, if we do the 10th, that would give us the 12 day as long assuming [1:19:16] I don't think I don't think we're going to be able to get it in the Press Herald before then. It's usually like a 2 to 3-day turnaround. [1:19:23] What about the 12th? [1:19:25] Because it needs to be 12 days, so it would have to be like the 1st or the 31st, and that's I don't think that would give me them enough time. [1:19:33] 12th, it wouldn't be enough time either. [1:19:35] Cuz it needs to be 12 days, and today is the 28th, so say I email them tonight, they'll I mean they probably won't get it in until maybe next week. I mean, I could always email and see what they say. [1:19:46] the Is the So, is the room available on November 12th? The day after Veterans Day, it's a Thursday. [1:19:52] Or we could actually No, we could also just go the next week, the week of the select board meeting, go Tuesday or Thursday. [1:20:01] Don't love to butt up against that if we can avoid it. Gets us off the Thanksgiving weekend. We might get more participants. [1:20:09] What if Yeah, what if we canceled the 20 [1:20:13] fifth meeting [1:20:14] Mhm. [1:20:15] and move that to the 18th? [1:20:17] The 18th is the select board [1:20:19] We'd have to go 17 or 19, I think, but we could. [1:20:24] Either way. [1:20:24] Yeah. If we cancel the Thanksgiving meeting and move it up a week to the Tuesday or Thursday. [1:20:30] Yeah, I'd be fine with that. is the room available? [1:20:34] 19th is a confer Excuse me, the conservation commission meeting at 5:30. They usually don't take long. [1:20:40] That's next and they do it next door at the rec department. Yeah. [1:20:43] Oh my goodness. [1:20:44] I forgot about [snorts] next door. [1:20:46] I think. [1:20:47] Ooh, would be a throwback to have it next door. That'd be fun. I've only seen them in here, but it wasn't a meeting. It was [1:20:53] Keep that big one. [1:20:54] I vote we have it next door. That'd be great. [1:20:57] so, I'm looking at the 17th. I'm thinking the 17th, a Tuesday. Tuesday the 17th at 7:00 p.m. Is there Is there anything scheduled with the town on that day? [1:21:09] I don't see anything on the calendar. [1:21:11] I don't have anything on my personal calendar. [1:21:14] Wait a minute. [1:21:15] Butch. [1:21:16] I'm good. [1:21:17] All right, Greg. Would the 17th work for you? [1:21:22] I currently have no prior engagements. [1:21:25] Okay. [1:21:26] My 10-month-old might say otherwise. [1:21:29] Oh, yes, she might. [1:21:32] 7:00. [1:21:33] 7:00 p.m. So, that is also going to be the next planning board meeting. we will be canceling the meeting on the 25th. so this is November 17th. I got to put this in my calendar immediately. [1:21:52] [snorts] [1:21:53] Okay. So, I think that we Oh, let's Let's vote on that. [1:21:57] second to that? [1:21:58] Do we No, we didn't have We don't have to vote on that on that. Okay. and we'll do it. [1:22:06] I'll be here. [1:22:06] The 11th, it does have you guys on the calendar for the 11th, so I might want to I don't know. [1:22:11] We're going to have to cancel that one, too. [1:22:12] Yeah, if you want to cancel that one. [1:22:14] I don't think we need to vote on that. all right, let's do We'll do that after. Let's get this Let's get this part done. so that takes care of motion one. Yes. Motion two, was a motion to recommend that [1:22:34] a when recommend that a planning board member be included on the committee that the select board is setting up for [1:22:44] [clears throat] [1:22:45] reviewing the data center. More data reviewing our zoning ordinances for data center. The long-term plan. [1:22:52] The long-term six-month looking coming up with something that public would vote on. [1:22:57] Yes. [1:23:00] we've had a [1:23:02] You already second it? [1:23:03] Yeah, it's already been motions on the table. Any discussion about that? [1:23:06] Great idea. I think we're all in favor. It's a great idea. [1:23:08] All right. so, Tommy, how do you vote? [1:23:11] I'll do Greg first. [1:23:12] Yeah, Greg, how do you vote? [1:23:13] Yes. [1:23:14] Yes. [1:23:15] Yes. [1:23:16] Yes. [1:23:16] Terrific. [1:23:19] We will I will write something up that can get that we will make that recommendation. Third, final motion on this topic is a motion to for the planning board to make a recommendation to reduce the square footage of the moratorium [1:23:39] on data centers from 25,000 square feet to 2,500 square feet. We've had a motion and a second. Discussion. [1:23:48] I heard some discussion in the select board meeting and I had it in the background. but I thought there was discussion around the fact that we could hinder somebody like Poland Springs if we went greater than 2,500, but I don't see that holds a lot of water in the sense that we could we're not retroactively [1:24:12] going after Poland Springs with this. [1:24:15] We can go retroactively with this. [1:24:18] But we don't have to. [1:24:20] No, we don't have to. [1:24:21] Yeah, I mean the goal of this is not to shut down the computer center of Poland Springs. That's [1:24:26] Or anywhere else. [1:24:27] Or anywhere else for that. [1:24:29] And I think the definition is I know there's a lot of people I know when we first started talking about this people were concerned that we would somehow be shutting down [1:24:39] bank [1:24:40] Yeah. Yep. I think the language here, the data center language, where it talks about Yeah, I mean it's just it to me seems much more clear that this is not the [1:24:52] computer room at [1:24:53] Yes, not the not the school's computer. Yeah, it's not the school's computer system or [1:24:58] trying to throw that out there. That's not what we're [1:25:02] Not at all. [1:25:03] discussing. [1:25:04] Not at all. [1:25:08] Okay. So [1:25:13] Thank you for giving us a little bit of color on what kind of what or why this came out at [1:25:20] I heard that discussion. Tom, I think was at the meeting. That was one of the points that came up. So [1:25:29] Sorry, I'm just trying to get this in my calendar before I forget. so any further discussion about this particular [1:25:41] Chrissy has her hand up. I don't know if it's the appropriate time, but it feels like [1:25:44] Sure, let's take it. Hi, Christie. [1:25:51] Hello. I just I'm I'm curious about the the I forgot I just forgot what it was called where you have like the public comment public comment. is there a reason why like the planning board can't have like a joint meeting with the select board to hold this hearing for the residents to come? [1:26:12] Because I believe like this is this seems like a pretty hot topic. And separating them between two different boards and meeting dates like obviously there's already an issue with attendance, right? So is there a way to just have like one big meeting to discuss this? And I believe that their reasoning for not having a hearing yet was because they wanted that committee put together and they wanted to have, you know, facts in place before there was the discussion around it. [1:26:40] But it just seems like this is an important topic, but we don't have like a clear way to handle it. And I think it makes more sense to have one meeting to try to get more attendance than having, you know, one with you guys and one with the select board. And I also think it'd be interesting to have your perspective there, too, because it's different in the select board, you know, meeting with them sitting up there. [1:27:03] But maybe if we have you guys up there as well with your perspective so that, you know, residents can talk with both of you and there can be more of like an open discussion with everybody. Like that may be more productive. [1:27:15] So one of the one I think the arguably the biggest issue is that the select board has to sign the warrant on November 4th. So it I really think it is just a time crunch issue. they're on a timeline and they have a timeline that they have to follow. We have a timeline as well. [1:27:35] And without going too far down the rabbit hole, one of the things that the residents approved last June when the planning board updated their ordinances was the planning board's ability to have excuse me, public hearings sooner or more in advance so that we could reflect the wants, desires, needs, opinions of the public within the ordinances that we're proposing. [1:27:59] this unfortunately it 's just not the case in how this is set up going to a going to a special election. so they have to sign and submit the final proposed moratorium on November 4th, which is I think 6 days away, 7 days away. so there's just not time to get enough notice [1:28:22] for the public to come in and speak. So we are having it [1:28:25] [snorts] [1:28:26] again and what is it we decided the 17th? So we're having it after the final ordinance is already submitted. again, this is something that the planning board was never a fan of. So we proposed a change and the residents said this is a good change and they accepted it in June. but unfortunately this goes back to that [1:28:46] prior, you know, method of conducting business unfortunately. [1:28:50] So I think Christie that I think where the confusion comes in is that not confusion but the select board is not holding a public hearing on this. We are holding the public hearing because we have more time to hold the public hearing. [1:29:05] We're also required under 30 MRS section 4352-9 because it is a land use ordinance that's being changed. [1:29:13] It's not it's being temporarily changed. I'm just I can't help I'm not going to say it. [laughter] So what I can do Christie is yeah it's not a change. What I can do Christie is we will invite the select board to join us at our meeting if they would like to join us. Yeah if they would like to we would love to have them. I might know a guy that makes pizza. He I might be able to convince him to pizza us up. [1:29:34] Greg? No, I'm just kidding. [1:29:37] [laughter] [1:29:38] so we [1:29:39] I make a mean pizza. I don't think you guys want to understate my understating. [1:29:44] [1:29:44] Let me rephrase Let me rephrase that. My wife makes a mean pizza. I eat [1:29:48] You watch. [1:29:50] So I will make sure to let the select board know that we would welcome them to join us for the public hearing. and we will accommodate as many of them that can come as possible. Does that work for everybody on the board? [1:30:05] Yeah, works for me. [1:30:07] They're They're always welcome. [1:30:09] Okay. in order for us to give for us to give recommendations that might possibly make it onto the moratorium language, we do need to make that decision now. like so we do need to have that vote on going from 25 [1:30:29] 25,000 to 2 [1:30:30] the conversation we've It's been motioned and seconded. It's now open for conversation whether we're as a board suggesting 2,500 square feet or if we're suggesting zero square feet. I you know, following [1:30:42] Saco and Scarborough. [1:30:43] Saco, Scarborough, Limington with zero are following Buxton and Gorham with 2,500. assuming that 's un- unless obviously anybody else has any other suggestions. [1:30:57] Hey Greg. [1:30:59] We already have a motion to do that. [1:31:01] I just want to follow up on the comments about like Poland Springs their server room. Under the definitions of data center, it's you know, basically a room for processing, storage, management, mining, hosting, or distributing large loads of digital data, AI, blockchains, cryptocurrency, cloud computing, collation services, enterprise services, or similar high-intensity [1:31:31] computational activities. I'm not really seeing that as a networking server room. But I think the argument that if we drop this down to the 2,500 that we're going to limit how Poland Springs can run their servers. I don't think that's an accurate statement. [1:31:49] And I wasn't I was not making the statement that we were going to [1:31:53] No, I 've also heard it in the public. I just wanted to kind of just clarify why I was [1:31:59] Yeah. [1:32:00] why I'm okay with the 2500 and I just think you know, 10x in every single town around us I can't find any reason to possibly think that we're smarter than Saco, Scarborough [1:32:16] Buxton, Gorham or Windham. Like I just can't think of a possible reason why we would want to 10x any potential town around us that like I said before that could adversely affect us having somebody see us as a vulnerable target where we allow them unexpectedly to bring in this 24,000 square foot [1:32:37] data center that we're we're not ready to we're not ready to properly [1:32:45] administer in the town. [1:32:47] Mhm. [1:32:50] You want Are you saying that you're recommending that we put that language in our request to the selectmen? [1:32:57] To the selectmen? [1:32:58] No, my request my request goes is I stated it simple as that we reduce the square footage from 25,000 to 2500. That was that was my motion and I kind of stand by the simplified version of that. [1:33:16] Good. [1:33:19] Any further discussion? [1:33:22] Motion is make a recommendation to the select board to change the 25,000 square foot minimum maximum [1:33:33] Yep. [1:33:34] and change that to a 2500 square foot and square foot maximum. Greg, how do you vote? [1:33:41] Yes. [1:33:42] Yes. [1:33:44] Yes. [1:33:45] I'm going to vote no because I don't think it's problematic. [1:33:50] Okay, budget. [1:33:54] Motion passes. [1:33:56] So what I will do that's the only recommended change to the ordinance itself. The ordinance doesn't talk about setting up the committee, so that's a separate recommendation. So, the only change that the only thing I will I'll make sure that everybody on the board is also included on the email. So, it'll simply be [1:34:17] we recommend the select board reduces the minimum or maximum, I can't figure out which one it is. to the 2,500 sq All right. I think that's all we needed to do on this. [1:34:32] we asked for a member of the planning board to be on that committee. [1:34:36] That was motion two. Yep. So, that Yes, that's I'm just going to One is a is a recommended change to the ordinance. The other one is a recommended [1:34:48] practice because the committee isn't isn't There's no regulations around it. All right. Good work. Plan for next meeting. We are going to meet not on the 11th of November. We are going to meet on the 17th of November. That is going to be for [1:35:09] We are also going to have a public hearing to discuss and learn from our fellow residents how they feel about the data center ordinance. Ashley, well, I guess the question to the board shh if there is new business or old business that wants to be on the agenda for that meeting, are we holding it as a regular standard planning board meeting or is it only for [1:35:34] public hearing? [1:35:38] [snorts] [1:35:39] I don't see why we can't do both. I mean, if it gets too late in the night, we'd call a halt. [1:35:44] That's Yep, you know me, I don't go past 9. [1:35:46] I know. [1:35:46] so, okay. So, if we have applicants, then they're welcome to join us if they are available on the 17th. Ashley, can you ask [1:35:59] the town to kind of highlight this on the town website and make sure that I think we have to post, don't we? Don't doesn't This is the type of meeting that would get posted. Okay, great. Terrific. so, I think we have a plan for our next meeting, which is going to be on the 17th of November. [1:36:19] and I'll accept a motion to adjourn. [1:36:23] So moved. [1:36:25] Second. [1:36:26] Second. [1:36:27] We are complete. [1:36:29] Thank you. [1:36:30] Thank you. [1:36:39] Yes. [1:36:40] Excellent. I think we've got a We've got it even though Greg didn't hear from Greg. [1:36:43] Thank you, Greg. [1:36:44] Thank you, buddy. [1:36:45] Hey, yes. I vote yes. [1:36:48] Thanks, buddy.