Portland Council Reviews Controversial Amtrak Station Relocation Proposal
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:18] Speaker A (unidentified): The chair will call the city council to order for purposes of workshop regarding rail transportation in the city of Portland. I'm going to go around the horseshoe so councillors can introduce themselves. I will note that Councillor Ali is out of state. He'll be unavailable for the workshop participation. And Council grant may be joining us either by video and audio or by phone because he's also outside the jurisdiction, so with that I'll start to my left for introductions. I just want people to know who you are. We have no, but I am tonight.
[2:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Regina Phillips, here. I'm just surprised. Like, this is new to me. Yeah, I know. It's like, all of a sudden, you're just picking me. Sorry. I represent District 3. There you go.
[3:11] Speaker C (unidentified): And brings the comic relief, apparently. I'm in a bullet. I represent District 4.
[3:16] Speaker D (unidentified): Sarah Michniewicz, District 1.
[3:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Wes Pelletier, District 2. you.
[3:22] Speaker F (unidentified): April Fournier at large.
[3:24] Speaker A (unidentified): It's like District 5. Mark Dion, Mayor. All right, I'm going to defer now to Greg Jordan.
[3:32] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you, Mayor. I just wanted to take a few moments to introduce the item and kind of talk about a little bit about where we're headed tonight for this workshop. So tonight's workshop is an opportunity to review NEPA's proposal to move Portland's train station from Thompson's Point to what we call the main rail line. NEPA recommends a location on the southern end of St. John Street near Barber Foods and the Metro Bus Garage and also adjacent to the First Light Mercy Hospital. The project will cost approximately 60 million dollars. NEPRA has received 48 million dollar federal grant and is seeking at least 12 million dollars in state funding. We recognize NEPRA's role as a state-established agency with the responsibility for managing passenger rail in Maine. We also recognize Maine DOT's principal role in directing state transportation funding. The city and GPCOG also have responsibilities to consider how this investment fits into the broader transportation system, how it compares with other urgent needs, how it supports our residents and community development, and to advise the City Council accordingly. From staff's perspective and for your consideration there are two key questions. First, do the benefits of moving the station justify the funding required given other transportation needs? Second, if the station moves, which location offers the greatest overall public benefit? Well, We'll first hear from NEPRA this evening, followed by GPCOG's Executive Director, Christina Egan, and the City's Planning and Urban Development Director, Kevin Kraft. I do want to explain why GPCOG's voice is important in this discussion. GPCOG staffs PACS, which is the region's federally designated metropolitan planning organization. Portland is a PACS member, along with 16 other municipalities and 12 transportation partners, including NEPRA. PACS coordinates transportation planning and investment decisions with the state, municipalities, qualities, transportation partners, and the public. GPCOG's expertise and a regional transportation perspective are important to this discussion. A new train station is a long-term investment that will affect how people travel around Portland and how Portland grows for many years. So tonight's purpose is to help the Council understand the proposal, weigh the tradeoffs, and consider its position on this issue going forward. With that, I'll turn it back over to the Mayor, or you can turn it right over to NAPRA
[5:37] Speaker A (unidentified): if you want. No, we can ask NAPRA to begin there. That's the morning. Good evening. Is this on? It sounds like it is. Great. Good evening. You might want to bring it closer, Mr. Cohen. All right. How's that? Perfect. Now we can really hear you.
[5:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Now we're cooking. Jim Cohen, pleased to be here tonight. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, I serve as board chair of the Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority. I see that our slides are up on the screen right now so I'll be saying a few I'll be saying a few introductory remarks our executive director Patricia Quinn who's here with us today is going to say a few words Commissioner Dowdy of the main Department of Transportation is on our board and is going to say a few words. Our transportation expert from VHB, David Sinas, is going to say a few words and then we'll conclude. We'll do our best to stay within the time frames. We understand the council has two hours and we hope not to make you be here for that full two hours. So first of all, I do have the pleasure of serving as chair of the board of the Northern the New England Passenger Rail Authority. I just want to make sure that the council knows who we are. We are a state agency. We have a seven-member board, and that board is nominated by the governor and confirmed by the legislature. And with us today include some of the board members. So we have Commissioner Doughty from MDOT is on our board, Commissioner Mike Duguay from Economic and Community Development is on our board, Alan Casavant, our vice chair, is with us this evening. He is the vice chair and former mayor of Biddeford, former state legislator, Allison Harris, is on our board. She's a former town councilor in Brunswick, and Maggie Edson could not be with us today. She is the Assistant Town Manager in Falmouth, as well as Carol Murray, who is a former Commissioner of Transportation in New Hampshire and former Public Works Director in Wells. That is our board. We're charged by state law with operating train service in Maine. We're charged by state law to site trains and stations. And so that's what we're here to talk about today. But along the way we have many partners, and a number of those partners are also with us today. We work with Amtrak, which operates the service, and I want to highlight our station communities. So that in Maine includes Brunswick and Freeport, and their representatives from those communities here today. It includes Old Orchard Beach and Saco and Wells, and those communities have all spoken in support of the process NEPRA has followed and are anxiously awaiting improvements in service. So with that I will turn the floor over to our executive director, who I might add she's been our executive director for a long time, but nationally she's recognized as one of the top people who run regional railroads in the United States, and that comes straight from the federal railroad administrator. So Patricia Quinn. Thank
[9:12] Speaker H (unidentified): you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you for having us here today. As Jim said, my name is Patricia Quinn, and I'm the executive director of NEPRA. I'm going to start just by talking a little bit about the Amtrak Downeaster service, which we manage. So the Downeaster makes five round trips every day between Brunswick and Boston, serves 12 station communities in three states. It's part of our national rail system and is used by people from every county in Maine and nearly every state in the nation to connect them with places within and beyond our borders. The Downeaster transports nearly 600,000 riders a year, and our ridership keeps growing between Brunswick and Boston. And importantly, the Downeaster takes 60 million passenger miles. That's tens and tens of thousands of cars off the roads every single year. 60 million passenger miles a year. A little bit about Portland Station. Portland is a regional station, and it's a hub. Interestingly enough, more than 90% of the people who board the station in Portland live outside of the area based on zip code data, so they're not they so the people come from all over into Portland to ride the service, and very few of the riders actually use this the service to run between Portland and points north. That is mostly people in Portland to go south because the travel time is not competitive headed north. As we look forward, we continue to plan and explore ways to improve Downeaster service. We regularly engage with many publics with the public and stakeholders and groups all along the Downeaster corridor, many of whom are here today, and we found that the public consistently asks for more trains to go more places in less time with more convenient schedules and better connectivity, and we're here to try to make that happen. Just two weeks ago, here's a great picture, cut a ribbon on a new train station in Wells, which was part of a multi-year project that added double track in addition to expanding this lovely station. The project represented an amazing partnership with a number of groups, including Maine DOT in the town of Wells, but also Maine Turnpike Authority, CSX Transportation, and two federal funding partners, both the FTA and the FRA, all of whom participated in that ribbon cutting. With the Wells Station improvement in place, the Downeaster will begin operating a sixth round trip next year between Wells and Brunswick. That's actually going to for the first time have a morning train from southern Maine come into Portland. So a train is going to come from Wells stopping in Saco and Old Orchard and arriving in Portland at 8 a.m. Right now the first train doesn't arrive till 11 30. So this is really going to be a new opportunity for people in southern Maine to access their jobs in Portland without the car, and this can take up to 300 cars off the road in greater Portland during peak rush hour. But of course we're here today to talk about Portland Station, and that's our focus. And you know that the current location in Portland frankly is just a barrier to achieving regional goals. It's located on a branch line about a mile down, and relocating the Portland Station to the main line is really a project of regional significance that's going to benefit communities and travelers throughout Maine and throughout northern New England. Because of the bottlenecks that's caused by the current station location, CSX, which owns the tracks, will not allow any additional Downeaster trains or any expansion of any passenger rail service to any locations in Maine to or through Portland until the station is moved to the mainline. So six is it. We're gonna reach our peak next year. No more trains. Mainline station will also, and allowing the service to grow will allow the downeaster to be more travel competitive with the automobile because it's going to eliminate the 15 minutes it takes to back in and out of the current station, and that impacts travelers in portland and those traveling beyond, and portland travelers will save time as well. So we conducted a formal evaluation of portland station of what it would take to relocate Portland Station around 2018. In 2021, NEPRA contracted with VHB to conduct a formal siting analysis in collaboration with Amtrak, CSX, and a multitude of project stakeholders. It was an extensive process that lasted nearly three years and considered the operational needs of the Downeaster as well as the opportunity and ability to improve connectivity for pedestrians,, bikers, and users of transit. The process, which not only met but exceeded federal requirements, included technical analysis around safety, land, environmental and financial impacts, as well as significant public outreach. We had two formal meetings just on this topic, and at both of those, through hundreds of participants and comments with overwhelming support for the project. At the conclusion, the NEPRA board selected a site identified as preferred from that process, and NEPRA moved forward to seek funding. Following federal law and guidelines, NEPRA completed and submitted a comprehensive application for discretionary funding for the project in February of 2026. And in August, the FRA, the Federal Railroad Administration, validated our efforts and selected the Portland Station Relocation Project for funding. That $48 million in federal funding is going to allow us all to move forward with this project that's going to reduce travel time, improve access to jobs, trails, and attractions, support passenger rail and transit growth far into the future, all while revitalizing the St. John's Street corridor to be safer, more vibrant, and better connected, and to serve as an anchor for development. We're very proud of our efforts, and we're excited to move forward in partnership with stakeholders and all of you to realize these transformational improvements and these public benefits. And I thank you for your time tonight. I will now turn it over to Commissioner Dale Doughty.
[15:34] Speaker I (unidentified): It was mentioned a couple times, a grant that NEPRA has gained. Obviously, that requires match, and I think it was mentioned by Greg earlier, Deputy Minister Strater, Jordan, that would be state match and for the most part it probably will but we're certainly working on a funding plan with NEPRA that may include others and there's there's more in that part of the city that we should talk about as well. It's a priority in the state rail plan. It's been discussed for many years trying to come up with those efficiencies that Patricia mentioned a moment ago. It not only affects Portland but the entire corridor, much of Maine including Wells Socco, Old Orchard Beach, Freeport and Brunswick, the other stations. There's also potential for satellite in Felmouth that we've been talking about for a number of years that would help collect people and bring them into the city in a carless sense that Patricia mentioned earlier. Maine DOT believes it's also consistent with other planning documents like Transit Tomorrow, CONNECT 2025, the state rail plan, and outline goals, outlined in Portland in Motion. I think that there's a number of other things that we ought to talk a little bit about. You know, that part of the city is in an evolution, right? You know, Metro's been in a couple times talking about their expansion and their adjustment. You know, there's a question that we have, and probably some meetings we'll be having with NEPR and Metro. Are there some synergies there where we can make more of a hub? I don't know the answer to that yet, but it's something we're all investigating together. I've called a meeting next week of Metro and NEPR to talk about those sorts of things. Can we meet many of the goals we're talking about in a way of combining facilities? There's also some proposals down on the waterfront that'll change the character of the waterfront. I think all those things should be considered as we look forward. So DOT stands ready. We have not committed funds to this yet. We're hoping that the city and NEPRA can come to some partnership. For many years we've wanted the communities involved as we move forward. And that's why we're here tonight to see how those discussions can go forward. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner. I
[17:57] Speaker J (unidentified): am Dave Sinas with VHB. I'm a civil engineer. I'm very proud to be working on this project. As Patricia mentioned, this is a project that's transformational. I've worked on over 100 projects in the city of Portland, many for the city and the DOT. This is a transformational project. It's something to be proud of. It's going to be huge for the city. It's going to be huge for the region. So, with me at VHB, we're 2,300 people, and our backbone, our founding, is really on transportation and transit. So, many of those people that work on projects in Boston, New York City, D.C., contributed to this project in the evaluations and studies that have been made available and that we've been talking about and will continue to present this evening. So, the new station being along the main line, really the effective benefit of being along that main line is going from a 15 minute through passenger time to two minutes. Two minute stop, parallel tracks, it stops and it goes, just like it will do with the new station in Wells. It's hugely efficient and beneficial to be able to provide the increased efficiency not only for through passengers, but also those passengers coming from the north to make the destination of Portland more attractive and more competitive with passenger cars. It will generate, based on our benefit cost analysis, up to 36,000 more riders per year, taking those cars off the road. One of the slides that we have up here is a visual. We're working with a world-class architect on this, and you can see It from the work that's been done at the well station, where we've used sustainable cross-laminated timber. The design, this design has yet to unfold, but there's going to be a bridge overtopping the track, and that's going to provide a significant benefit for cross-track connectivity in an area that currently doesn't see that. The track is currently a barrier to that. This provides that benefit. Not only does it provide that benefit, but folks like Portland Trails, who we've been working with, see this project as a significant opportunity to establish a more robust connected trail network in Portland's west end by linking the currently disconnected area and making it a better use for underutilized space. That bridge will not only serve passengers but also the public to be able to cross the tracks at that location. This visual gives a good perspective on the future station. You can see the enhancements along the frontage of St. John Street. We'll get into that in a bit. Those enhancements are not just additional street trees, but they're also really safety focused and active transportation mode focused along with transit focused. There's a connection across the tracks and you can see that on this image as well, where the Mercy campus and the Four River Parkway are able to bridge connection over to St. John Street. It's transformational for that corridor. If people are able to come to this location, shave 15 minutes off that trip and land at this location, it's within walking distance to 9,000 jobs. Right on one side of it you've got Northern Light Mercy and then on the other side, a project that I actually worked on fairly recently you've got the main health parking garage which has hundreds of shuttles that go up to the main health campus every single day every single few minutes those shuttles are going up to the main health campus and then also this is served by both metro and biddeford socket orchard beach bus lines both on st john street and in along that four river parkway so there is a transit connection there, and that can be both strengthened and further established as we work out the details here in this couple of years of design. This visual gives a perspective looking the other direction toward Cassidy Point. As noted, there's discussions about a potential rezone there. There's potential for a significant amount of use on that site. It should be considered the proximity of the station to that and its proximity to other uses also, of course, along the Congress Street corridor. This is a great location for many perspectives and many reasons. You can see Veterans Bridge, West Commercial Street, St. John Street, Four River Parkway, and the Four River Parkway Trail are all part of the city's connected bicycle network. This is right along that, and we're working with the Bicycle Coalition of Maine, talking to them about how they can get involved in helping us promote that active transportation component to this, making it safe, providing benefits from the station to the bicycle network of the city. Anchor Coach Lines is also able to access this quite conveniently from the Thompson's Point area right over to this location along the Four River Parkway. For the next, yep, there we go. This gives a good visual, and it's a little bit hard to see for those in the room, but we've got some renderings of what this will look like or what this could look like. Again, the design's going to be further informed. There's going to be an opportunity to really enhance the streetscape and the pedestrian area near the station, along with providing public art, public safety amenities, activating the space. Looking along St. John Street you can see we can integrate things like safe crossings, active transportation considerations related to the bike lanes that are there but enhancing those and of course the transit connections with us. Our schedule really goes from here up through 2031 for construction, but the next two years are important because there's a great opportunity for community input into our design and detailed planning. And we're looking to, we go to the next slide, develop a stakeholder task force with workshops and public meetings that get ingrained into the station building design, the site design, and public art components, and of course that all important active transportation and transit connection to this project. So thank you for your time. I'm going to pass it back to Jim here to close our discussion. Thanks.
[23:56] Speaker G (unidentified): David, so as we conclude our remarks, I just wanted to leave the council with a few thoughts. First, it's been two years since the state agency charged with citing rail stations made a decision. It's more than two years ago. We followed a process that was set forth in law. We exceeded those standards. The process included substantial study and analysis by experts, and David is certainly one of those experts. It considered safety, it considered economics, pedestrian permeability, transit oriented development, cost. It considered the ability to serve the mountain division line in the future should it ever, decades from now, become some form of a transportation corridor, and certainly Wilfrid Trail, and even after the board reached its decision more than two years ago, NEPRA continued to meet with city staff and other stakeholders, and we're here today out of a strong interest in being collaborative and how we can best move forward with a project at the station site that was selected and has now been funded with 48 million dollars of federal money, an award that confirmed the careful work and analysis undertaken by NEPRA. In those two years since the NEPRA board decided to move forward with this project, we met numerous times with city staff. We held two multi-party facilitated sessions more than a year ago. A year ago the sustainability committee asked NEPRA to participate in a mediation with the city, and our board committed to do just that and have board members participate. We were disappointed that the city did not want to go forward with that mediation, so we hoped that the next step, when the mayor approached about the potential for a workshop, that we could perhaps have a joint workshop with the NEPRA board and the council working together and having a conversation. That's obviously not the process that's here tonight, but nonetheless we're pleased to be here and share whatever information we can about rail service and trying to move forward. I think David showed the slide that said there's still a lot of process to go, and we do want to work with the city to make that station as good as we can. Now in our packets we saw on Friday, and Deputy Manager Jordan outlined a different set of criteria, so the conversation that's occurring after us is slightly different than I think what our focus was here today, suggesting that there's a debate between other sites and this. And I want to be clear, there is not a debate between sites. There is one project moving forward, there's one project that's available, there's one project that has federal money attached to it. Now the City of Portland is obviously a very important stakeholder, one of a number of stakeholders, but it's in Portland and we care very much about Portland and working with Portland. Importantly, we're not asking the city and we're not asking PACS to contribute financially to this project. The city does not have to pay a dime for Portland Station. City of Portland actually doesn't pay anything for Portland Station today, which is different than all the other station communities. So taxpayers in Portland will benefit from Portland Station without having to contribute. NEPRA is also not seeking any approvals, land use, zoning, or siting at all. And under federal law, NEPRA has the legal authority it needs to proceed with this project. The 48 million dollars is tied specifically to this site, not any other sites. That have been under discussion are not viable regardless of the stated preferences by city staff. So if this project does not go forward, there's not going to be a new station and there won't be new investment of 60 million dollars in rail in Portland. It's also important to understand that potential sites for a station are more expensive, including the need to build a 20 million dollar parking garage that is not required for our project. The other projects don't have federal support. They conflict with existing uses by Maine Health in Cumberland County who own the land where the other site is located, who have consistently said that they aren't selling their property and for appropriate reasons, which means we can't get it. And let's talk a little bit about safety. For our project no additional rail sightings are needed and the site is very removed from Congress Street, so the gates would be down only when the train is crossing through Congress Street. But at the sites closer to Congress Street the gates would be down the entire time, just as they are in Saco, just as they are in Portland station as you're heading down to Thompson's Point. City staff asked us to consider changing the technology so that the gates wouldn't have to be down. Every time NEPRA has a board meeting, we start it with rail safety. And unfortunately, throughout this country, way too often than it should, people die because of rail crossings. This is not a safe use of space. If the gates are down, ambulances can't get through. If the gates are up, people assume that there isn't a train, or they might try to cross the gates. In a Vision Zero world, the site that the NEPRA board selected is far safer. We now have an historic opportunity to move forward with more rail in Portland, faster service, more frequent service. That's a benefit for Maine, it's a benefit for the region, it's a benefit for Portland, and it's a false choice to say that it's a choice between rail and bus. As the Commissioner said,, we're having conversations about both. Funding rail does not mean the exclusion of funding for buses. We should do both. We hope both happen. And with that, we appreciate the opportunity to be here and we look forward to answering any questions the Council may
[30:24] Speaker A (unidentified): have. Thank you, Mr. Cullen.
[30:29] Speaker G (unidentified): We do have some packets that we wanted to hand out to the Council, which we could do now, whatever is most appropriate.
[30:35] Speaker A (unidentified): If you wouldn't mind giving it to Councillor Sykes and we can distribute accordingly. Okay, thank you. I have Christina Egan from GPCOG. Oh, you're setting up her presentation? Okay. For purposes of the council, it was my hope that we'd let the three parties presenting communicate with us, and after that I'll entertain questions. If it's your inclination, ask, Annie.
[31:37] Speaker K (unidentified): Good evening, Mayor and councillors. I'm Christina Egan. I'm the executive director of GPCOG. Greg already explained who we are, but in short, we're the transportation planning agency for the region, among other things. I am a fan of rail. I spent four years of my career planning a rail line down in Massachusetts. I know the power of rail to unlock economic opportunity. I also know what it takes to get it right. I also depended on the Downeaster for six years to commute to my job in Boston. So The Downeaster connects us to Boston, it also connects us to each other. The question before you tonight is narrower. It's about whether this station in this location at this cost is good for Portland, the region, and Maine. Choices like the one before you will shape this landscape for generations to come. And I'm here because of our role, which is a federally designated role, to plan and program transportation dollars from the federal government. I'm going to offer you three questions tonight to guide as you weigh this project. The first one is, this investment the best use of money? Moving the station costs about 60 million dollars and we know that we need 12 million dollars in state match from Maine DOT to move it forward. These dollars are super precious. They're really, rare and if we use a dollar to match a federal railroad administration grant that's a dollar we can't use to match federal transit or federal highway money and it can unlock this money can unlock at least a dozen projects that we've prioritized for the region and some of these are important these projects would make it safer for people to walk and bike and we know we have an epidemic public safety epidemic on our roads right now and it can also expand economic opportunity to those who need it most and expand racial and social equity. Overall, I think the bundle of projects that we have recently proposed to MaineDOT will make life more affordable, especially for working people. So I've said, Dale already said that there is no state match that's available and I want to leave you with two points is that it's not committed and we also have heard recently from Dale and from others that MaineDOT is advancing a work plan right now it's a three-year work plan that basically spreads two years of projects over three years like peanut butter because it's just not enough money and we know that there aren't that many new projects in it yet it hasn't been publicly released but we know and we've been warned by main dot that it's a very slim work plant so the money is not just sitting around somewhere if it were we've got 11 projects that are ready to be funded with that these are for our buses, they could include Portland priorities like Forest Avenue and Libbytown, and also many Vision Zero projects in neighboring communities across the region. I would argue these priorities need to be first in line for any new money that MaineDOT is able to come up with. Here is the list of the priorities that are yet unfunded. There's about $8.7 million that we need in match from MaineDOT in order to advance these. So the bottom line here is at the bottom right hand end of the slide here, which is that we are asking for about $8 million, and every dollar that's spent on the station is a dollar that's not available for those priorities. So the bottom line here is that there is a very big opportunity cost to advancing this project. My second question is, this a great project? And as you have heard from Patricia, moving the station is going to help the train operations. I'd argue it helps modestly. When we're looking at a once in a generation investment like this, we need it to meet bigger goals. These goals are listed on this slide. These are from the long-range plan that we had thousands of people contribute to tell us what was most important to them. They want a connected system where buses link with trains, link with ferries, and that those transit services link with trails, and that those trails are part of a bigger pedestrian and bicycle network. We want to have high ridership numbers, serving as many people as we possibly can, and importantly we need our system to advance equity. We want to make sure that those who rely on transit most are invested in and also that they have the opportunity to get to health care and jobs, all the economic opportunities that are often too hard to find with the transit system that we have right now. So the test is simple. Is the system going to strengthen the region's trajectory on those goals and this shows you a map of the bus system right now and shows you where the Portland Transportation Center is and also the sites that NEPRA has studied. The Portland Transportation Center is the hub right now. It connects Concord Coach to the train. That's a seamless connection. I used to take it all the time. I take the train down in the morning, I take Concord Coach back at night or vice versa this is going to break the station relocation would break that connection and there's no plan in place right now to provide any kind of a shuttle service to the new site that could happen but it's not in the project budget it's not in the project scope site two splits it still splits the rail from the intercity bus so that's a negative but it is near main med and it's also close to that big spine that you see right there of all of the different bus lines and site three which is circled in yellow here is in the industrial end of st. John Street, it's served by a one-way loop of the Metro bus, and you could also change that and put more buses in there, but that's also not in the scope or in the budget for the project. I want to talk about equity for a moment. First of all, right now the way we spend our dollars in the region, which is federal and state dollars, we are looking at a $24 subsidy per rider for every train rider. That's six times more than what we subsidize for a bus rider, which is at $4. That's a big split. So also, who are those riders? Well, the riders are quite different demographically. What you see here in this data is that 86% of bus riders live in households that have under $50,000 of income. That's compared to the Downeaster of 5%. And if you look at the black and brown people in our community, 45% of Metro riders are black and brown with only 13% of Metro riders. So right now the money is already really heavily tilted towards white, better income people, higher income people. And to put another $12 million of precious state money in that, I would argue would widen that equity gap. This is not against the Downeaster, per se. It's really a call to make sure that we're putting economic and racial equity front and center when we make these kinds of decisions. Here's the last question. Is it a need or a want? And here's the test. What happens if we don't build it? So the first thing is that there is a time savings for about four and five riders, according to the Downeaster's application to the Federal Railroad Administration. administration. It's only riders, however, that live in my neck of the woods between Brunswick and Freeport and Portland. Nobody else is saving time. The other piece is the operational savings. There's about half a million dollars in operational savings according to the train's data. But that would take a century to pay back for half a million dollars for a sixty million dollar cost. So I want to just address two other things that Jim and Patricia brought up. One was we can't add any more trains. Well, we're adding a sixth train. There is nothing in our planning or in our budget to add a seventh train at any time soon. And Jim brought up that we could extend to the mountain division. GP COG already studied this for our rapid transit. We've eliminated that as a rail option. So those two benefits really shouldn't be weighing in your consideration here. What you can weigh is what benefits to staying at Thompson's point would look like. The first thing is that you wouldn't miss the connection between Concord Coach riders and the train. And the second one is that we've invested millions of dollars, both the City of Portland and GP Cog, in redeveloping that site, and there's housing going up, and it's a bustling destination. We continue to expect that to continue. So, sorry, so I want to close where I started here, which is that this project has not been vetted by the region. Of course, NEPRA has the ability to do whatever it wants to do, and it has the legal authority, as Jim said. But the train authority led every step of this study. And in 2021, MaineDOT led a study and actually concluded the Union Station site, two, is a better location, and put out a couple of tests for NEPRA to meet. The first would be, is the city going to support that site? And the second is to make sure that there's a good connection between Concord coach in the train if there is a site that moves forward. Neither of those tests have been met yet. And so when the region is deciding its projects, we decided by comparing projects against one another. And we compare them against goals. The station did not go through that process in the region. And there are so many regional priorities that are waiting for money. And here they are. We have about $61 million in unfunded needs of projects that are ready to go. These are transit, these are trails, these are Vision Zero projects, safer streets, and for comparison to our 61 million dollars the station will cost 60 million. So I will leave you with these three questions. Is this investment the best use of money given the opportunity cost? Is this a great project or even a good project when it splits up the intercity bus from the intercity rail and widens the gap in equity investments? And is this a need of the region or a want of NEPRA? The station we have today works. Trains run, riders connect, so I ask you to compare that versus the projects that will save lives on our streets and expand economic opportunity for those that need it most. This project may not be urgent and it may not be necessary.
[42:43] Speaker A (unidentified): City staff, go ahead.
[43:14] Speaker J (unidentified): Hey, good evening counselors. My name is Kevin Kraft. I'm the director of planning urban development for the city of Portland. You have our memos on the relocation matter in your backup materials and tonight I'm going to walk through our analysis of the potential relocation sites intended to aid in your considerations about an appropriate site for relocating the train station. So as you've heard us talk about before for more than 30 years regional and city plans have called for better transit connections, safer streets, and growth around our transit network. The 1993 The 2023 Comprehensive Transportation Plan even highlighted the importance of creating integrated transit hubs and called for relocating the train station to the Union Station Plaza site. In 2017, the City's Comprehensive Plan Future Land Use Framework identified the Union Station Plaza node and Portland Transportation Center as key growth centers for future development. Both areas are envisioned as mixed-use hubs anchored by strong public transit access with the ability to support multimodal growth. ONE CLIMATE FUTURE, THE CITY'S CLIMATE ACTION PLAN ALSO REINFORCED THE IMPORTANCE OF TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT. ALL THIS POLICY WORK INFORMED THE CITY'S RECODE INITIATIVE AND THESE EFFORTS TO SUBSEQUENTLY ZONE, THESE AREAS WERE ZONED TO SUPPORT HIGH DENSITY MIXED USE TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT ANCHORED BY PASSENGER RAIL AND THE BUS NETWORK ALONG CONGRESS STREET. THIS WORK WAS ALSO INFORMED BY AN EARLIER 2021 MDOT STUDY THAT PATRICIA REFERENCED where the state DOT evaluated sites and identified Union Station Plaza as the most beneficial for a new train station. Building on the 2021 DOT study, NEPA further evaluated the three candidate sites along St. John's Street, as you've heard, and they've identified Site 3 as their preferred option. It sits on the southern end of St. John's Street, wedged between Tyson and Barber Foods in Ferguson Plumbing Supply Warehouse, with an estimated cost, as you've already heard several times of roughly 60 million dollars so in terms of our recode process so support the city's decade of policy work recode rezoned the congress street node as a major mixed use and transit oriented development hub sites one and two offer strong access to jobs services and neighborhoods they provide walkable access to more than 12 000 jobs and Residents within a 15 minute walk, they have access to major employers, hospitals, recreation destinations including Maine Medical Center, the state's largest hospital employer, Hadlock Field, and the Portland Expo. Both sites sit next to established dense mixed-use residential neighborhoods. Both sites are already zoned transit-oriented development 2 and B2B mixed-use, which supports significant density and development intentionally centered on transportation. In both zones, there are no density limits on housing,, and permitted building heights range from 75 feet to 125 feet. Site 3, while it is closer to Northern Light Mercy, the site has a weaker land use context. It is in a historically industrial area characterized by Tyson Barber Foods Food Plant, the Ferguson Plumbing Supply Warehouse, and the Metro Bus Depot and Garage, where buses are stored and worked on by mechanics. SITE 3 IS ZONED INDUSTRIAL MODERATE IMPACT, WHICH PROHIBITS RESIDENTIAL DENSITY AND PERMITS ONLY LIMITED COMMERCIAL USES, INTENDED TO SUPPORT MORE INDUSTRIAL AND MANUFACTURING BUSINESSES. SITE 3, IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT, OR THE CURRENT SITE, IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT TO POINT OUT THE PORTLAND TRANSPORTATION CENTER, AS CHRISTINA POINTED OUT, IS INTEGRATED WITH CONCORD COACH as well as Metro Service, and is also zoned B5 mixed use and is starting to be redeveloped into a TOD hub as envisioned. It is also one of only two city TOD TIFs. While all sites considered for really location would separate rail from Concord Coach, sites one and two are close to the Congress Street corridor. This is the transit spine of Portland, which has seven bus routes and the highest frequency bus corridor in the entire state of Maine. Site 3 would separate rail from Concord Coach, but it offers weaker access to public transit as it sits farther from Congress Street Corridor with minimal bus connections. Sites 1 and 2 have stronger access to the existing transportation network and street grid. They also offer connections to the Four River Parkway Trail and the Union Branch Trail that already exist today. Site 3 has weaker direct access to the transportation network, transportation infrastructure interrupts the street grid, and there is a significant grade change at the Western Promenade that interrupts connectivity to the West End neighborhood. Zooming in on a closer comparison between the three sites, one and two, again, are more integrated into the street and pedestrian network. They connect to existing neighborhoods, trails, but also the existing sidewalk network. Site three, again, has weaker access to the transportation network and less connectivity overall. We do acknowledge that NEPR has stated that there will be a new pedestrian bridge as part of the station that would establish connections to Northern Light Mercy and Four River Trail, but that connection will really only benefit passengers. There's already connections, as you can see, if you're coming from West Commercial Street directly to the Four River Trail, and there are already connections from the Congress Street corridor that connect you to the Four River Trail. That connection will be little utilized. As many of you know, through our presentations to the S&T Committee, the area around Sites 1 and 2 are already seeing major public and transportation investment from the city, but also the state and the region. The Libbytown Safety and Accessibility Project is planned, designed, and has been approved by this council. Although, as you heard, the city lost over $20 million in previously allocated federal construction funding, and we recently learned the project was not awarded funding in the latest Safe Streets for All grant round, staff are still continuing to advocate and work with DOT and regional partners to prioritize construction of this long-standing community-supported project that would convert Park Avenue and Congress Street from one-way to two-way with enhanced bicycle infrastructure and pedestrian amenities. In addition to Libbytown, the new multi-use Union Branch Trail is complete and provides broader connections to Portland's trail network behind Hadlock Field and Deering Oaks Park. There is also private investment flowing into the area near Congress Street, including the new wing at Maine Medical Center, which fronts Congress Street, and recent multi-family housing approvals, including a multi-family project by Portland Housing Authority. authority. Again, Site 3 sits at the southern end of St. John Street, where there are no current targeted transportation investments planned. There are the plans for Metro's bus expansion, but there are no infrastructure improvements more broadly. So when looking at the sites more closely, Site 3 would require acquiring portions of four primary parcels from three separate owners. That does not account for additional land that might need to be utilized from Northern Light Mercy, or any additional land that might need to be taken for the site to function from a layout standpoint. Site three would require displacing several existing small businesses that are located along St. John Street today. Site three limits Ferguson's ability to expand their plumbing supply warehouse, which the owner has indicated there have been plans in the works for several years, and realistically remain. In addition, there are complications with truck access to of the Tysons Barber Food Plants, as you can see within the area highlighted in orange on the screen. In addition, redevelopment opportunities are limited. Tysons Barber Foods is one of Portland's largest employers, and it is an established industrial business not likely to redevelop. Additionally, as was mentioned, Metro is advancing plans for a new and expanded bus depot and garage at its St. John Street location. This would limit redevelopment opportunities from Danforth Street to roughly D Street in the area highlighted in pink. Therefore, even if this Council were to rezone the area to mixed-use or TOD, there's really no opportunity for mixed-use development near this station. Site 2, on the other hand, offers opportunities to work with two property owners, Maine Medical Center and East Brown Cow, one of the city's most prominent real estate developers. The county would also have to be included in discussions if it was determined necessary to utilize any county land. A new station could be built using existing surface parking, as highlighted here in pink, either by sharing the current lots or by constructing a parking structure on one of them without impacting any of the existing businesses. NEPR has provided the staff with information last January that identified a $12 million parking garage could be necessary, but there's been no cost considerations for what a parking structure would count at Site 3. Over time, the scale of Site 2 offers significant redevelopment opportunities. If stakeholders are willing to engage meaningfully, they can share opportunities and challenges, identify where their goals align, and determine how to advance multiple objectives while integrating a station into the broader vision for Site 2. So to better understand Site 2's potential, the city worked with WSP, an international consultant who's working on the Franklin Street project, to conduct a conceptual massing study. The study tested what could be built under the existing zoning, accounted for known concerns expressed by Maine Health in terms of shuttle impacts, and showed how the parcel could advance decades of city and council policy goals for transit-friendly, walkable, and sustainable places. Over the long term, this conceptual Madison study demonstrates the significant opportunity that this site holds. It could accommodate over 300,000 square feet of medical, lab, and research office space, which is the total square footage that main med identified in their ioz a decade ago over 70 000 square feet of commercial and retail space hotel and roughly 400 housing new dwelling units on top of a train station including a structured parking garage which if we were right which could accommodate almost 700 new parking spaces again this is conceptual and those uses could change depending on a property owner's vision, but this layout considered how the station could connect with also other transit infrastructure, such as micromobility, shuttles, and existing bus routes, making it a true hub for Portland and the region. Again, I do want to note, this is a conceptual study, which is plastered across this slide. It is reliant on private property owners and shows what could happen under the existing zoning. So relocation is a significant investment, as you've all heard tonight. The first question is whether the cost benefit is worthwhile. Staff recognize that the current station has shortcomings. That said, considering what the existing location already has, the infrastructure investments made, the fact that it is a TOD TIF, and mixed-use growth to support Thompson's Point is already occurring, the relocation for the cost may not be in the best interest of the city, region, or state. If, however, relocation is worthwhile, Site 2 is the stronger location. It supports decades of policy work, the main DOT 2021 studies findings. IN ADDITION, WE'VE BEEN WORKING WITH STANTEC, WHO'S LEADING OUR COMPREHENSIVE TRANSPORTATION PLAN, WHO EVALUATED THE PROPOSAL IN NEPERS TECHNICAL MATERIALS AND IDENTIFIED THAT FROM A TECHNICAL STANDPOINT, INCLUDING SAFETY AND EFFICIENCY, SITE 2 CANNOT BE ROLLED OUT ON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED TO DATE. IN ADDITION, A STATION RELOCATION AT SITE 2 COULD MOVE FORWARD IN PARTNERSHIP WITH PROPERTY OWNERS WITH THEIR CONCERNS RESOLVED THROUGH DESIGN RATHER THAN THROUGH PROPERTY TAKINGS OR SALES. By coordinating the rail station with nearby infrastructure projects, we can leverage funding and commitments already in place. That could make the additional $12 million in state investment actually worth it. Site 2, again, offers similar rail operational benefits. It's located on a double-track section of the line, which eliminates the need for the reverse movements. It would result in travel time savings as desired by NEPR, and it could be located farther from an at-grade crossing than half of Downeaster's current stations. Within the last year, the Libbytown, Parkside, and St. John Neighborhood Associations have all submitted written comments to this council and staff opposing or expressing concerns about NEPR's proposal to Site 3. In addition, two property owners have provided correspondence to the council and staff that have expressed opposition and concern about NEPRA's proposal to Site 3. So therefore, all properties have site ownership concerns, and it should be based on what investment is best. There are opportunities with Site 2 to convene stakeholders, one of the city's most prominent development firms and one of the city's major stakeholders in Main Med to explore meaningful partnerships that could actually advance the city council's goals. Lastly, if the council ultimately supports advancing to Site 3, the council should better understand what the significant off-site investments would be and there should be commitments to improve accessibility for all modes in the surrounding area before moving forward. Christina Egan touched on the limited funding that DOT has, and it's unclear how any off-site improvements would be improved and where that cost would fall to. In addition, it's important to understand how Site 3 relates to the Metro Bus Depot and Garage and how it could affect the depot and its funding, how bus service could be enhanced without taking funding from current routes, and how the site layout and future parking locations could be settled in coordination with Northern Light Mercy. It's important for this council to understand who would manage and be responsible for those off-site improvements and how those improvements would advance the priorities that have been expressed over the years more broadly. Thank you. Thank you, Director.
[57:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Turn it over to the council if there are any questions or comments of any of the parties.
[57:25] Kate Sykes: Councilor Sex. Thank you, Mayor. So in terms of the grant, I think this is a, I think, Jim, this is a question for you, if you want to come up. Thank you. So have we actually, have you actually advanced to a commitment from the federal government that this grant is going to be funded, or is it simply in an application process at this time?
[57:54] Speaker G (unidentified): It is committed. We have to have a state match, but we have a grant award letter, and I'm looking at Patricia. Yes. So it's not uncertain. The federal money
[58:08] Kate Sykes: is available. It's available, and it's actually committed to this project at Site 3? Correct. Okay. Thank you. That's my only question for now.
[58:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else? Councilor Forna. Thank you. This
[58:22] Speaker F (unidentified): might be for you again, Jim. So I'm looking through the breakdown of the costs of the $60 million for the station. And one of the things that you had talked about is, of course, this should be cohesive with the street redesign for safety, for active transportation, to be able to do cycling, pedestrian. Where does that cost factor in and who's shouldering that cost?
[58:46] Speaker G (unidentified): So I'm going to ask David Sinas to come up. But conceptually, one of the reasons that we're here and we want to continue working with the council is to make sure we understand the priorities of the city so that we can work with the city on all of those kinds of issues but Mr. Sinas can answer the specific questions.
[59:08] Speaker J (unidentified): So the slides that were put up earlier that showed those street improvements and the area of improvement including the connection over on the Mercy campus to the Parkway part of that cost estimate that was carried forward there were also some allocations in their allowances for various off-site improvements but the exact numbers but the what you saw on that rendering was carried forward okay I'm just looking at the budget
[59:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Breakdown, where does that fall in the categories of the budget breakdown? So it falls within the
[59:41] Speaker J (unidentified): building site. I don't know exactly what that line item states for dollars. Okay, it's like INSTRUCTION. THANK
[59:51] Speaker F (unidentified): YOU. ANY
[59:54] Speaker A (unidentified): OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? CONSERVATIVE. UM, YEAH, THANK YOU. I HAVE
[59:58] Speaker E (unidentified): BEEN FOLLOWING THIS FOR QUITE SOME TIME, UM, AND UM, IN THE PROCESS, YOU KNOW, I THINK A LOT OF STAKEHOLDERS NEPRO HAS TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF A LOT OF STATE OR HAS TAKEN UM THE COMMENT FROM A LOT of stakeholders, and it does not feel like Portland has been one of those stakeholders. You know, for an effort to say hey, we want to want to move the station, you know, for me great, that makes a lot of sense, and then they say well, we want to put it in a really non walkable part of town, and I say well, you know, maybe we put it in a more walkable part of town, and I say no, it needs to be 10 minutes away from anything. And my reaction is, well, then don't move it. And then they say, well, we got to move it. And it's just a really weird way to play poker. I want to have a new train station so badly. But we're trying to build a walkable city here. And I don't know who here went to Jeff Speck's talk, but a really key component of a walkable city, a good walk, is that a walk needs to be interesting, and I don't think I'm going to lose that many voters by saying that the walk from the st. John Plaza to where a site through is proposed is interesting. It is not walkable. It is adding another five to ten minutes for an able-bodied person, and that is going to make sure that people in the West End and Libby town and Parkside do not use this train station. Is going to directly hurt ridership levels in a way that is totally avoidable. I'll remind everyone that every single neighborhood organization in st john valley, parkside, west end, libby town all came out against putting this in site three. You know, i believe that there is room to move within this grant, that the grant could be changed to site too. If that's not the case, as Mr. Cohen is saying, then I think we don't move the station. We wait. I am not willing to sacrifice a lot of state funding that could really material, materially benefit the lives and the lives and the livelihoods of our constituents for something that won't, that hard stop will not benefit our constituents. We need to be considered a partner here. I would love to come to the table and actually talk about how we can get Site 2 done. That is something that I'm willing to talk about, but for us to get strong-armed like this, we are not a partner. This is just sort of like putting that they want it one way and it is only going to go that way and I think it's just not going to go that way because we as a stakeholder and as a as a gatekeeper on this have a duty to our constituents to make sure that our and to our staff frankly to making sure that our city is walkable to make sure that our comprehensive plan is adhered to and we cannot just throw that away because we're being told we need to if NEPRA is able to get this done without city funding fantastic you know let's that's we won't have any say in that but if we are being asked to take money from our very slim pool that could be used for such better things I cannot support it any
[1:03:43] Speaker D (unidentified): other comments that's a sex thank you mayor okay I have one other question and I
[1:03:49] Kate Sykes: I don't know who the right person is to answer this, preferably someone from MDOT or the state. So we keep sort of talking about tonight that we're choosing between rail and bus, that there are all these other projects that we could build if we don't steal the money for the train station. But I don't really have a transparent understanding of that and where this money lives right now, whether or not it is actually going to be used for those programs if we don't move the train station. And I will say, honestly, that I really don't like having austerity decisions forced down my throat. I don't love that we don't, that the state doesn't allocate enough money to do all the things that we need to do. And so what I'm asking is, this, can we expect those projects that we're naming to move forward if we don't move the train station? Someone, anyone can answer that.
[1:04:45] Speaker I (unidentified): There's a couple ways of approaching that. First, almost all those projects require federal money. We're in a reauthorization year. We don't know what that's going to look like, and I think most people know what Congress and the Senate and the presidency looks like right now. So we don't know what's coming out the other end. Some of those projects would require special federal funding, grants and things. Libbytown, Christina spoke about that earlier. Libbytown had a grant. Congress clawed it back. The city applied with our help, and we had some match committed to that. They were unsuccessful. Successful. So some of those projects are quagmired in those kind of things. So it's not only state money. Now on the state side, that's a little bit of a problem right now. For us to just maintain the system that we have today, all 8,800 miles, 2,800 bridges, railroads, airports, we need about $240 million a year just to match that basic federal match, that basic federal need just to maintain what we have. In 2029, right now, the way it stands before our state legislature comes back in, we have about $25 million out of that $240 million. So the funds don't exist at this moment. And part of what we need to think about, I think, going forward is really convincing the overall state of all the things that have been discussed here today there is 48 million dollars sitting there waiting to be matched by somebody there are other projects throughout the state that have federal funding that need to be matched so the first thing is we've really got to work with our legislature and our new governor to really understand how we fund transportation in the state so that's that's one problem that's one reason none of this exists today I think another thing that we need to start thinking about is how we advance suites of projects not individual projects how can we improve transit within the city anywhere else in the state but maybe improve train as part of transit as well connect other methods of other modes so all those things are up in the air right now in fact the work plan that Christina talked about is going to call it the skinny work plan it's going to be about a billion dollars less than the previous one we're producing a second document that are those projects that would normally be in the work plan that are not going to be. Many of the ones Christina put up there today, including support for Metro's garage, including the train station, are all in that B list of things that we can't afford to match today. So it's not like one's gonna get it and one's not. I think we really need to look. And then there's all sorts of FLAVORS OF MONEY. THIS MONEY EXISTS WITH FTA. WE DON'T HAVE THE FEDERAL HIGHWAY MONEY AT THIS MOMENT TO ADVANCE SOME OF THOSE OTHER PROJECTS. So it's a very complicated, and I don't mean to try to skirt the issue, but it's very complicated. The state has a problem and right now we're not sure where the federal government's going. But all those things and bring all of our partners together to advance those projects that fit the right fund sources and the right requirements to advance. Why it bothers me that maybe we're pitting transit or projects against other projects is we're going to convince the legislature that we need to raise all boats. We can't be eating our own children. I think we really need to advance. Transportation is important in every aspect of everyone's lives. All the things we talked about today are important. So I think we need to get together, find ways to advance as many as we possibly can and not be pitting one project against another.
[1:08:29] Kate Sykes: I really appreciate that. You've said some things that really resonate with me today, and I've heard from a couple other councillors, and it's clear that some feathers have been ruffled in Portland about this project amongst staff, amongst councillors, amongst constituents, and that's hard, but that's part of our job. And I think it's important just to remember that we're in very difficult financial times right now. These are, you know, we're being pit against each other because of how hard it is in terms of financing the cost of these things. While I don't think Station 3, sorry, I get the numbers confused, Station 3 is the right move in every way, no decision is ever the right move in any way. And when you make a move, things tend to change around it. And so I think that if we have federal money that's coming in and we can use it now or lose it, I honestly think we should use it and try to work together as best we can to make this Station 3 work the way that we hope that it will. It doesn't sound like it has the generational impacts and the huge benefits to that many riders, but it may be a step in that direction. And I sympathize with all of the kind of disappointments that have come along with this. But I personally feel like we should not let this opportunity go despite the fact that it's not the best place for this to happen in Portland. So that's where I'm landing on Council.
[1:10:02] Speaker C (unidentified): Bullet. This is probably a question for Director Quinn or for or for Jim. I just would love to know, what would happen if the city and Maine Med hypothetically came out in support of Site 2 and only Site 2? What would NEPRA decide to do?
[1:10:25] Speaker H (unidentified): Here's, let me just respectfully try to maybe restate that question a little bit. So it's been said a lot that, you know, we haven't engaged and we have engaged with the city all along. We just haven't agreed on conclusions. So I'm going to say a few facts. One fact is that it was alluded that, oh, if a station track is needed, so I'm sorry if I'm gonna get in the railroad weeds here a little bit, but CSX Transportation owns the track and they control that property, and their standard policy is that when a train station is added on the main line that they require a station track, which means a way for a passenger train to get off if they need to get by, so they're not to block both tracks. That requirement has been waived at site three because of its proximity to the mountain division, so a third station track would be needed to support a station at site two, and the way that property is oriented, that track alignment would go out and would require it would it would put it on property that's currently this the county jail, and so county jail property would be needed for a station at site two, and that's documented, and there's some information in your in your books that we gave you that documents that, and we know that the county is not interested in having that happen, nor is Amtrak frankly, so that would be kind of something that so that would be another other thing that would have to happen is we'd have to imagine, I don't know, a different scenario. And then there's also the qualification. You know, last week, the Federal Railroad Administration also announced the award of $1.25 billion in grants to states that were for a program called Railroad Crossing Elimination. And this money was specifically to make railroad grade crossings safer and to eliminate many of them where they could. The fact is the information from the Federal Railroad Administration is that a project that would add another additional track across Congress Street, because that third track would also extend across Congress Street, across Congress Street put a station closer to, you know, and put a station that close to a crossing would be a significant would create safety risk and would likely not qualify for funding, so what would nepra do, I don't know, because the other facts still exist, we could not there is not an opportunity to create that project at site too
[1:13:15] Speaker I (unidentified): your
[1:13:18] Speaker G (unidentified): Question was originally also about Main Health. We've talked to them for years. Their answer has been consistently no,, and no. We sat in a negotiation with Maine Health and with city staff and I think I counted seven separate times where city staff offered what about X, Y, and Z. We would turn to Maine Health and say does that change your mind? They said not only no, but the more we talk the further away we get. We're not getting anywhere close with Maine Health. The other thing I have to add is we do have the power of eminent domain as a state agency. We cannot exercise eminent domain against another government entity like Cumberland County, so when they say no that ends it. The second thing is we legally could exercise eminent domain against Maine Health, but the first thing that they will argue back is there's no necessity, which is an element of a taking and the, and what they will point to is the fact that we selected site three. And they'll go to a court and say, there's no need for NEPRA to take our property because there's another site. So that's why we say there is no path.
[1:14:36] Speaker C (unidentified): So in my hypothetical world that I'm wish casting over here, NEPRA would walk away?
[1:14:43] Speaker G (unidentified): We have no choice. I mean, we say there is no other project because literally there is no other project. We can't make up a site that there is no path to get site control, even if the merits of it made sense, which we disagree with, the land doesn't exist. You're welcome.
[1:15:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Councillor Phillips. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'm not sure if I have a question. I have so many notes I can't even see straight, and I don't even know where to start. They're all on Post-its. And thanks for this. When am I supposed to read this? Am I supposed to like just open it now and just read it but appreciate it most likely I'll give it back to you. So just a couple things. Which is again, I'm not sure if I have any questions. I'm trying to figure out where to start. Appreciate everybody that was here that gave the presentation. Really truly appreciate that. I tend to agree with a lot of things that Councillor Pelletier has mentioned here and a couple of those things are I understand that NEPA went out and applied for this money, knowing, or this grant, knowing that they didn't have all the money. That's concerning to me. I mean, I keep hearing about different things, about this track and that track, and this money and that money, and this project and that project. But the fact of the matter remains, as of today, there's not enough money to do this project. You're $12 million, $16 million short. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's at least what I heard. And not only that, but if there is money out there that the state just miraculously finds underneath a rock, there's several projects that could be used for this particular money, but not all that money has been secured. So as far as the funding, I mean, thanks for the $48 million, that's a lot of money, but you still don't have all the money you need for this project. And there are other projects out there that we could use to help build more safety around the state as opposed to just in one spot at the site. As far as Site 3, 2, and 1, again, I want to get back to Councilor Pelletier's comments, which is leave the track where it is. I mean, we've heard about Site 2. We've heard about Site 3. We've heard a little bit about Site One. I certainly understand, let me be very clear, I understand all the benefits to this project. I understand about the more people, I nobody's, I don't think anybody is disagreeing with that. But there's just so many different pieces to this that's really confusing and concerning. So I'm more of the mindset to leave the track where it is. I like, I like Site Two. I like where it is. I went to Site Two, I was able to go to Site Two and to Site Three to see it. I went there with Council Bullet, we walked around, and some of the things that Councilor Pelletier has said are concerning to me. It's a longer distance from Site Three all the way to Congress Street where things connect. We're four or five businesses have to close. Metro's renovations, Metro only has one route. There's, there's a lot of concerning things that I see with Site Three, oversight two. So but the other thing is, according to Mr. Cohen, we don't have any options here, right? I mean, I'm, I'm with Council Of Sykes here. I don't like to be strung down either, but what I hear is you don't have a choice. I'm not sure why we're here because what you've have just said is you don't have a choice. This is where we're going and thank you. So I guess my last thing is I don't feel like a partner in this and so I don't feel like this has been a collaborative process. You came to an S&T meeting and I appreciate that and then a year later was sitting here saying you've already applied for the 48 million dollars and we don't really have a choice but to go with SITE THREE SO I'M NOT SOMEBODY THAT'S GOING TO UM BE SUPPORTIVE UH OF SITE THREE UM AND UH AGAIN I DEFER TO COUNCIL PELOSI LEAVE IT WHERE IT IS COUNCIL
[1:19:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Michniewicz I'M NOT TAKING ANY QUESTIONS
[1:19:14] Speaker D (unidentified): AND ANSWERS FROM THE AUDIENCE THANK YOU UM YEAH THANK YOU THANKS FOR ALL THE PRESENTATIONS UM It kind of seems like it comes down to some opinions and not entirely clear facts. I am curious what city staff's take was on some of the Maine Med conversations, at the risk of starting a whole thing. Can you speak to that at all?
[1:19:44] Speaker J (unidentified): Yes, happy to. We obviously were in a lot of conversations with NEPR and Maine Medical Center, as Jim Cohen mentioned. And ultimately what it comes down to is we don't think there's been meaningful engagement and the opportunities that come with Site 2 and how that can mutually advance many visions. There's been a lot of concerns raised that have not been supported by FACTS. We did have our consultant for the Portland In Motion, Stantec, national consulting firm, rail operations team who also works in New York, Boston, other cities, evaluate VHB's work to confirm firm, are there technical merits that could rule Site 2 out? And at this stage, they have said there's not technical concerns at this point. So we, again, think that there are opportunities for MaineMed. We have had meetings with MaineMed and the neighborhood associations in terms of what their vision is for Union Station Plaza, and they have continued to say and go on the record that they do not have a long-term plan for those sites. So again, we feel that there are opportunities with East Brown Cal, again, one of the city's most prominent real estate developers who actually owns the Union Station Railroad building who have not been engaged in this process as well to bring folks together to explore opportunities okay thank you
[1:20:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, the word could gets used over and over. They know me. This could be a site. This could happen. So I actually, I'm not entirely sure. I was done with you. What would meaningful, what would meaningful engagement or meaningful collaboration discussion look like for you from the scene the
[1:21:13] Speaker J (unidentified): Process to date, we've seen a lot of why Site 2 can't work and what could be done to make Site 3 work. We've not seen the technical merits of what could make Site 2 work. For instance, the station track, third station track, was new information that was shared later in the process. Tonight was the first time we've heard that it would have to cross Congress Street, so it has felt like the analysis has continued to move. So what meaningful engagement would be would be what's actually on the table so that we can actually start to move the cards around and understand what are the opportunities and challenges with all the sites. I'll stay because you might be third.
[1:21:50] Speaker D (unidentified): It's been going on for so long that I guess I am kind of maybe shocked that those conversations have not happened on that level. I mean, to the extent that we have time, I think that would be meaningful. But forgetting that for a moment, one of the things I think is incredibly important is having a really robust multimodal station and lots of access to buses. So in terms of Sites 3 and 2, where do those lay along the continuum of access with buses or what could be developed in the future?
[1:22:36] Speaker J (unidentified): Again, as we've pointed out, Sites 1 and 2 are directly related to the transit spine of Portland and the entire state with seven bidirectional transit modes and easy access to the Portland Transportation Center. Site 3, again, has one Metrobus route and an Old Orchard line, and similarly you'd have to run a shuttle to connect to Concord Coach. So they're just different, which is why we've highlighted in your memo that if you were to support site three these are some of the other commitments that the city should understand in terms of how could you enhance metro ridership and enhance funding to ensure that you're not taking away resources from existing routes that are serving our community to be directed towards this. Okay, thank you.
[1:23:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, the funding piece I think is incredibly important. And to some of the points that got raised through other folks, you know, the question of whether this money is kind of fungible and you could use it for other projects. And I mean, it seems like there's a broader scope and a greater variety of projects that could be funded. They wouldn't have the same impact. But I just keep coming back to the 15 minutes. I mean, I feel like that seems to be the driving rationale behind this, and I'm not entirely sure that, I mean, if you have an extra 15 minutes, you build it into your time. It's not ideal, absolutely, but it doesn't sound like the network is going to grow exponentially whether or not this happens. So, yeah, I mean, I continue to struggle with this. I guess three doesn't appeal to me much. I guess for me, if there were a way to make site two work, I'd like to see that work. And if not, I'm not sure that the motivation to relocate the entire station makes sense.
[1:24:45] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, thank you. I'm going to go up to technical for a minute. Is the council grant trying to phone in? Before you do that, can you patch him in so he can express his own questions?
[1:25:06] Speaker E (unidentified): Folks, I am here, but I'm in a little bit of an unreliable spot,
[1:25:11] Speaker J (unidentified): so I emailed my questions to Council Fournier to have her ask on my behalf.
[1:25:17] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, then. I'll do that, Council Grant. Council Fournier, can you?
[1:25:23] Speaker F (unidentified): So one of the questions is I've heard, and I'm just a little unclear about, for Site 3, and I think this is maybe a question for you all, is there are current property owners that would be displaced or have to sell their property. Can you talk a little bit about that?
[1:25:41] Speaker H (unidentified): Yes, there are at site three, there are property owners that would be impacted. There's a property owner parallel to St. John Street. There's the property that kind of goes perpendicular that impacts property on which there's a lay down area currently for the Ferguson warehouse. And there's also a parcel on the corner that's where mainly burgers are. And we have been in discussions with those property owners for a number of years, made them aware in the beginning that we were looking at projects. And, you know, there is a legal commitment to if that property is needed for this, that they would be made whole.
[1:26:26] Speaker F (unidentified): So are they being made an offer to sell or are they being made like we're taking the property?
[1:26:32] Speaker H (unidentified): We are not able yet because of where we are in the federal process. The NEPA work, the environmental policy work needs to be completed before we're legally allowed to actually negotiate with the property owners. So it's really put those folks in limbo for a long time as we've been kind of talking about this in a level of uncertainty, which is extremely unfortunate. Okay.
[1:26:55] Speaker F (unidentified): So in the event that they don't want to sell and you want to move forward with site three, what happens?
[1:27:04] Speaker H (unidentified): As Chairman Cohen mentioned, NEPRD does have the authority for eminent domain, but we would work with Maine DOT on that, but I think it would be our hope and expectation that would not be a hostile process, that we try to work, again, continue to try to work collaboratively.
[1:27:24] Speaker F (unidentified): And then one more question from Councilor Grant. He just mentioned that there was a safety concern raised about road blockages at Site 2, about the ambulance traffic towards the hospital. Can you just talk a little bit more about that?
[1:27:41] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, again, you know, the closer, the slower a train is going, the longer it's going to take to move. And so the closer it is to the station, the longer it's going to take to get across. Plus signal grade crossing signal systems are extremely complex, that's the science and unto itself. And so there would be times, for instance, if the train needed to move closer to allow a disabled passenger to border a light, it could trip the gates and make them come down. What happens in many of our station communities is that the gates stay down, and for instance in Saco that happens, we're trying to get that improved by, but it does happen where the crossings are down for an extended period of time while the train is in the station. But remember, this is going to be a three-track facility, so you could literally have a train in the station, and then you could have a freight train and a passenger train coming by. And what happens also, I think an important thing, is just public perception. As Jim said, it happens three times a day in our country that there's a collision between a car or a person and a train because people just don't pay attention. The more complicated it is, the more choices they think they have, the more risk people will take. Oh, that train stopped in the station, the gates are down, but it's it stopped, so I'm just going to go. There's a train coming in the other direction. Happens all the time. Wish it didn't, but it did. And I will just mention also, I know it was just stated that the information about the third track was just newly revealed. That actually is not the case. If you look at tab seven in your binder, there was a formal We've talked about this for a long time. It was in the application, but there was a memo that was prepared and forwarded to all of you and the city staff back in January that fully describes the grade-crossing impacts that are there.
[1:29:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Could I have the commissioner for one second? Are you done with your questions, Councilor Fournier? I am. Okay. Commissioner. Yes, Mayor. Just for purposes of clarity, the idea of the DOT work plan and these competing projects, whatever model of transportation they're looking to enhance or improve or create. Those are fundamentally conversations between your office and the state legislators transportation committee with input from the executive branch? It is.
[1:30:14] Speaker I (unidentified): And it's also in conversations with things like PACS, many cities, we have lots of partners out there.
[1:30:22] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Right. So you're asked to make those kinds of devil's choices all the time in your transactions with the legislature. And they have their own set of priorities that have to be reconciled, which kind of represents 435 towns' view of what appropriate transportation policy should look like.
[1:30:40] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay. Legislature typically sets policy. We choose projects based on that policy.
[1:30:45] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. That's helpful. Thank you. I'm just going to make a comment, then I'll turn it back to Councilor Fournier. There was a building in North Deering, a commercial building that fell into great disrepair a couple years ago, and I received persistent phone calls from constituents as I was the councilor in the district. Do something about that. All right? Do something. Thing and I couldn't do very much, truth be known. Council's powers are limited, and this was private property, and it was a commercial issue. But I made an informal stakeholder outreach to the assigned realtor and explained to her the dilemma and my constant inability to respond adequately to of my constituents. She sympathized, and she made sure a weed whacker at least showed up every couple weeks to make the property look more presentable. But it had nothing to do with my authority as a counselor. And it was a recognition that it was private property and they were to make their own decisions, which is kind of standing, to use a legal term. I didn't really have a dog in the fight, but I tried to participate as a concerned stakeholder. Months passed, and that building is now a cannabis retail outlet. It's a very good-looking building. A lot of value has been added there. And would one suspect the calls have diminished? No, of course not. The calls now say, but we wanted a bakery. And I had to re-explain the fact that I had no standing in that decision. So when I've heard the conversations about the train and my participation in conversations outside this horseshoe, I ask myself, and I'll turn it over to staff first, what is our standing here? Are we actually a decision maker, or are we trying to figure out a way to exercise some understanding of stakeholder, which is an entirely different math? And I want to underscore this, that when I first became involved in discussions with the trains with the director and the chair, I took the problem I, we were fortunate as a city that we were selected to participate in the US mayor's conference on urban design, we one of 14 communities, I represented us there, and during that process, that's, that's what I brought for a project, right? There was no clear answer between. I don't know why we ever had one to begin with, because everyone from everywhere has decided the first proposal of site one didn't make any sense. But it lingers on a list like it has some merit to be there. It was two and three. And we spent three weeks looking at that. And then the professionals, I don't remember all the firms they were from, although one of them was particularly fond and knowledgeable of Portland, they came back and said, look, for a lot of reasons, two makes a whole lot of sense. And if things were ideal, that would be the site that should merit the development. However, three is where it's going to land because of engineering issues, this contest over property, whether or not somebody's actually gonna come forward and be a partner and their advice to me as a mayor and I shared again with the council was look if it is three then do your best as a stakeholder to bring the amenities that are necessary to make it in the best interest of our pedestrians bicyclists and future consumers all right and that and that is the standing unless somebody tells me I mean, otherwise, it's not like we have a veto over NEPRA. Some of us probably wish we could, but we don't. So what's in the best interest of our constituents is a train station. I said it in my State of the City address. I think Council Palatine has advocated for that, as well as Council Sykes. I mean, I think a train station makes sense. But unless somebody can tell me that we have the ability to veto three, then we should devote our energies to provide what we can do to make three the best possible site and see if it happens. I mean, I walk, see, Councilor Phillips edited me out of the story, but we made the visit to both sites. You know, it's about 1,200 feet. So I just, I put that out there to the council, is as we consider next steps, and it'll probably end up being on S&T, we can consider next steps, is what do we want to do? You know, do we want a train station? The county passed a resolution. They said, no, they're not selling the property. And that's a critical piece. It's not a big piece of property, but it is critical to the engineering design. And I have to tell you, frankly, in my conversations with senior representatives of Maine Health, I'll put this as best I can. I received no indication where I would conclude they were anticipating being a partner to the development site, too. Unless we have something a little bit more definitive from them suggesting otherwise or supporting what I just said, it remains an open question, and it should be explored just to be absolutely sure that's the case. That's one man's opinion, but I just wanted to put that out there, so I'll now defer to Council Fournier.
[1:37:08] Speaker F (unidentified): I actually don't have any other questions, but just I really appreciate my colleague's input and as the mayor just put this very well, like we're going to give you our insight, but ultimately we don't get to make this decision. I think I have a little bit of a unique perspective in that in about a month I'm going to be graduating out of this dais and going up to Augusta where I'll be on the legislative side of this decision and discussions. And one of the things that I think of and this reminds me a little bit of our conversations around Congress Square Park and when we think about equity and so when we receive some funds to invest in that park it was great and then oh no there is more cost and then the next year oh no there's more cost and no now things have gone up again or now we have to get a different design or there has to be a different plan and so I think one of the concerns and as the former finance chair for the city of Portland, one of the things that I am very concerned about is those additional costs and how quickly they add up and who has to shoulder those. And so those were my questions about these line items because the economy right now is not getting better. And so while we might have this 48 million and then just need 12 million to do what is set out, what we have also found with a lot of our city projects is once you start digging,, there's all kinds of fun things that are underneath the surface here in Portland from our generations past. So I anticipate a lot of those costs, especially to make the streets safe, to make them connected, are going to go up. But the other piece and the reason that I bring up this Congress Square Park comparison is we spent millions and millions of dollars on a single park when we have a ginormous park system in the city. And so when I think about the neighborhoods who could have also used those funds to improve their parks all over the city, there is an inequity. And so as a state legislator, or soon-to-be state legislator, thinking about we're spending $60 million on a single station. Granted, we are the largest city in the state. But as I find when I go up to Augusta and introduce myself to friends and I say, oh, I'm from Portland, I get the oh. So I'm also trying to be very mindful of what we're setting aside for the city of Portland. Granted, it is a hub and it is working to support all the surrounding communities, but when I see this other list of regional projects, not only for the places that are closest to greater Portland but all over the state, I also have to think about, for that 12 million dollars, where is that equity? And how are we going to make sure that we are really looking at the connectivity of our entire state, not just this simple hub to gain 15 minutes of improvement? And so I know we're only here in an advisory capacity. We can't charge you to do anything. The last piece that I'm very concerned about is the idea if these property owners that currently have their spaces and that's where their businesses are located decide that they don't want to sell that, they would be forced to give up some of their land to me. That's theft and I don't approve of that. So that's where I'll leave it for us, but I really do appreciate all of the information. This is a giant binder. I will be happy to look through because I think it will be informative for my future work, but really thank you also for taking the time to be here tonight.
[1:40:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Councillor Pelletier. Thank you, Chair. Christina Egan, could you maybe give us a sense of what projects that are, like the feasibility of other projects that would be at stake should this funding, you know, should we allocate this funding to this project?
[1:41:09] Speaker K (unidentified): Sure. So the other projects, I mean, the top regional priority that came out of our table, so it's like 17 municipalities, six transit agencies, and lots of other people, including DOT. We have prioritized Libbytown first. There is no grant for that right now. There has been match set aside for that, so that's good news. The next regional priority, highest one, is Forest Avenue, Complete Streets. We don't have funding for that programmed yet. After that, we have the mountain division trail which would fit into a overall regional trail system so that would link up with a Casco Bay Trail which we just got six hundred million dollars to have six hundred million as if I wish six hundred thousand dollars to advance the design on that and that would be part of an overall trail network and then we have lots of intersections that need to be upgraded for safety, places where there could be sidewalks, some places where there's bike lanes or protected bike lanes, those projects are all kind of queued up and ready to go. They've passed our readiness criteria and they also were scored regionally. We have a very rigorous process that scores them against outputs, right? So does it have a climate benefit? Does it have an equity? Does it have a housing and transit-oriented development? Those kinds of things. So those projects have all ranked really high. The station never went through that process. They're going for Federal Railroad Administration money, so they're not technically required to, but as a collaborative partner, it's gonna have such a big impact on the system. I think that's why you have to look at, is this gonna make multimodal better? You know, is this gonna make equity better? The last thing I just wanna say is that while the city does not have standing to stop this, the main DOT in the past does not move forward with projects that cities and towns don't approve of. And that was a condition of the 2021 Maine DOT study and Commissioner Van Notte's note that he said that a condition of moving forward, and at that time it was for the Union Station site, a condition of moving forward would be city approval. approval. So yes, I don't know if you, well, I don't know, Jim would know better if you have any legal standing, but the overall cooperative nature of how we're supposed to do transportation is where MaineDOT comes from and says it doesn't force projects down municipalities' throats.
[1:43:32] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you very much. Yeah, I guess, you know, that was my understanding as well. So, you know, I think veto might be a strong word, but we are being asked to veto other projects that may get funding. I also, you know, I don't think trains go, like, I don't think rail and funding for rail is going away, and I don't think that this is going to be the last opportunity or the last huge amount of money that is put forward. It would be disappointing to lose this, yes, but the grant should have been applied for in a different way. You know, it is basically applied for with the expectation that Portland will get in line and maybe we don't have a veto here. Maybe DOT will not respect, like, we'll just say yep, that's fine, put it there, you've got the money, you can have the matching grants, and that's fine. You know, my, our role as everyone has said is advisory, and you know we will have a vote, and I think it is important if this gets shoved down our throats and we say yep, we're gonna do it in a place that does not make any sense for our city, but maybe it makes more sense for the rest of The state and the rest of the rail. We can work with that, right? Like, that is not something we're going to throw our hands up and give up and cry about. But as a council, I think we need to be voting very specifically and with an idea that, you know, there will be other opportunities that come along. And I think if we have a chance, there's one chance to do this right. And I just don't like the idea of, you know, bunch of people coming to Portland for the first time and you know as I we love we love the industrial zone we love the tax money that we get from Tyson but I don't know that it's the best place to drop someone and we should not have to change our entire city around because of the way that this was approached so you know if things are as it stands and there is no way to move Maine Med and the county now has a new or who has new commissioners on it if there is simply no way to move on this that's okay you know we will have another shot at this and I suspect that we will be in a different place when that shot comes and I don't think it will be that far away. Thank you.
[1:45:54] Speaker A (unidentified): counselor anything else from the council I want to defer to assistant city Manager Greg Jordan. Thank you, Mayor.
[1:46:03] Speaker E (unidentified): I just wanted to address briefly the question of standing that you brought up a few moments ago and recognize certainly that NEPRA has the exclusive authority to run rail in the state into site stations where they would like to put them. I think the matter comes into play with respect to our relationship with the main Department of Transportation. And I may ask the Commissioner to step up if he doesn't mind, because when it comes to major discretionary projects like this, usually it's the DOT's approach when there is going to be a major project in a local community that there is support for that project by the community before we've really even gone too far down the road around major planning and certainly going after federal funding. I don't know if that's a practice set up by the former commissioner, Bruce Van Note, or if it's a longstanding DOT practice. I think it's a very sound practice, and that's motivated some of our thinking here in the city that where we think our opinion matters on this is as it relates to the state's commitment in respect to that history of MaineDOT wanting the host community to be on the record as supportive of a particular project. Am I off base on that, or is that about right?
[1:47:25] Speaker I (unidentified): No, Greg, I think that's probably founded in three or four commissioners ago. I've worked for four before me. I've known all eight of the nine, and that's been a long standing. However, there are times, and I'm not saying this is, that, you know, the state's needs, it's the main Department of Transportation, not the Portland Department of Transportation, where we also have to look at what's good for the entire state. So it's always a balance. That is certainly our desire and our hope through this whole process. Is that the city and NEPRA would have gotten together by now. You know, one of my frustrations, and you're well aware of that, is it seems like we go these long periods without earnest discussion, face-to-face discussion. My hope is, and I've expressed this to the mayor a few weeks ago, is my hope is this is the beginning of a new era where the city, the city staff, and NEPRA can sit down and bring things to the council until we get to that point. So, yes, the state has responsibility to the entire state. Yes, we would like the host communities very much to be on board, but our hope is that we can sit down in earnest, have some workshops, and come to a place where everybody understands and can at least accept wherever we're going. And, again, I'm waiting for that day. Commissioner.
[1:48:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Just for purposes of transparency, you might have been watching the assistant city manager and I huddling over here whispering off mic and the reason for that was to get some consensus between the two of us about next steps for the council so I'm gonna defer to him right now this workshop isn't organized for purposes of making a final decision on anything but at least we can anticipate what we may have to look like moving forward. Before I turn it over to you, I want to say two things. One, I've appreciated the candor and the accessibility that the Commissioner of Transportation has provided me through this process. I really do appreciate it, Commissioner. He's been a straightforward partner in this process. Not to say NEPRA hasn't been, but I've appreciated my conversations one-on-one with the Commissioner. And I have the utmost respect and appreciation for our planning staff. I think you've done the old person's work and trying to get us to a place that we can make an informed decision. That is your responsibility and well GP Gog what can I say I'm on the executive board so I have merit so I think we have three parties here that one the best for the city it's how we get there all right And I had hoped that we could get there as a collaborative stakeholder in order to see this realized. So with that, I'll now defer to the Assistant City Manager. Thank you, Mayor.
[1:50:26] Speaker E (unidentified): So as was included in the staff memo and Director Kraft talked about during his presentation, we laid out three very general options for the council to consider during this workshop. As the Mayor mentioned, this is not an opportunity for voting on anything. but it was meant to sort of help coalesce your thinking and give us a sense of where at a high level maybe where we want to go here. So option one was essentially recommending against proceeding with the train station relocation and seek to express an opinion about the prioritization of state funding to the Commissioner around other urgent transportation needs. Option two is to support site two as the preferred location and request that NEPRA and others collaborate on ways to find a way to make that location work. Option three was to support Site 3 but with conditions to request NEPRA be subject to defined commitments by the agency to make meaningful improvements in the transit network connections, provide connectivity to Concord Coach, enhance walking and biking access, install traffic calming measures. In short, try to approximate at least some of the benefits that exist around the Site 2 location but see if we can make that location somewhat better from that multimodal standpoint and so again in broad strokes so there's some options for you to consider and to give us some direction about how you'd like to proceed further to a possible resolution at a future council meeting or if you prefer to refer it back to s t for further work i
[1:52:00] Speaker A (unidentified): think if i could express my personal opinion, I like that, those three options drafted into a resolution so that we can make a choice as a collective body moving forward. I think we have enough material. Unless the chair informs me their committee wants to revisit the entire matter and make a recommendation of one of the three options, we can discuss that. But other than her willingness to take jurisdiction of the question, I would prefer that we review it for ourselves in anticipation of an upcoming city council meeting. It probably won't be next week's council meeting. Not probably, it won't be. I'll be definitive about that. But at the next council meeting, we would be able to vote on the resolve in order to signal our willingness or at least our posture in terms of the proposal for a new train station. And that'll give us time, as we always do, all of us will be talking to each other and gaining an opinion as to what a consensus might look like. So is there any comment on that?
[1:53:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Pathway Elsa Phillips. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I just want to know regarding our options, is there an option to leave it where it's at? You mentioned three options, but none of the options were to
[1:53:35] Speaker E (unidentified): just leave it alone. From our perspective, that would effectively be option one. Oh, that's option
[1:53:40] Speaker B (unidentified): one. Okay, sorry about that. And I, my second question is, it won't be at the next council meeting, so the meeting after that, is that the inaugural meeting? We will have new counselors. Yes. Okay. Thank you.
[1:53:59] Speaker E (unidentified): Council Palatine. I just would love if we could try to get a representative from Maine Health to be present. It is, you know, much like the county, it is hard to consider ourselves a partner with them when, you know, this is all hearsay and meetings with the mayor. And I would love for a representative of Maine Health to come up and say we will not rent an easement or sell this property.
[1:54:26] Speaker A (unidentified): You want them to testify the next, when we take up the result? That would be fantastic. And I'll ask if they can send us a written documentation in advance so we have some idea what they might want to talk about. That would be great.
[1:54:39] Speaker E (unidentified): Just to have them at this table, we are just talking around them in a very strange way. I'll honor that request.
[1:54:50] Speaker C (unidentified): Anything else? Councillor Bullett? Since my colleague brought up Maine Med, I was wondering if you might do the same reach to the county.
[1:55:01] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't have any objection because they've already created a public record on the question. Great. Anything else?
[1:55:10] Speaker M (unidentified): Mr. Mayor, this is Danielle, City Manager. I just wanted to say that this wouldn't be at the inaugural meeting. It would most likely then be at the second meeting in December.
[1:55:22] Speaker A (unidentified): That's that's fine, whatever works out organizationally. I'm okay with that. It just gives the council more time to consider whatever evidence they'd like, as well as to allow the county and made health to draft their position. Does that
[1:55:43] Speaker M (unidentified): work for you? Same answer, yeah, that's fine. I just wanted to it would be difficult to do it at that inaugural meeting, and I just wanted to have it
[1:55:51] Speaker A (unidentified): reflected on the record. Okay, you see she's watching us all the time, all the time.
[1:56:00] Speaker B (unidentified): counselor phillips sorry mr mayor i just have one question and this is for napper like what is like we're not going to talk about this or do anything to this friend of the month what does that mean for your plans does it hold your hold your like what does that do for you if anything I
[1:56:20] Speaker H (unidentified): think right now what we're trying to do is first thing that needs to happen is the grant needs to get obligated, so that's a process. So we're going to continue to do that, we're going to continue with education and stakeholder outreach. And if I could just respond to your prior question about the book that was provided, because just to provide some documentation from some clarification of some of the comments and testimony that was provided today, that things that didn't exist, and if you look in the book they
[1:56:53] Speaker B (unidentified): probably do. And I didn't mean to say that I don't appreciate it, I very much appreciate it, and now that we're gonna have more conversations about I will look at it's just it's hard to get a book like this, it was when you're
[1:57:06] Speaker H (unidentified): having that conversation, was intended as a resource for you as you formulate questions, a place for you could to go for the answer. So thank you, thank you.
[1:57:14] Kate Sykes: Before you go, could I just ask one more question? What's the difference between having the grant committed to site three and then having to obligate the grant? Can you just explain procedurally what that difference is? Certainly, so
[1:57:27] Speaker H (unidentified): when a grant is awarded, it's for a project, so that's the project that it will fund. The obligation is when we sign the legal documents and take responsibility for, so that's it's a legal process. So you haven't done that yet? No. And what's preventing you from doing that? It's a long process. It's a federal process, so there are a lot of things that go in. It takes about a year to obligate federal grants. We've had many of them, so it's just you have to go through and demonstrate different things, and it just continues to be a process. I think what's obvious here is I'm just asking if you're waiting for us. We're going to move forward with the process as it unfolds. The next step would be that the FRA told us they're going to schedule a meeting to talk about what they're going to request from us. They'll have additional information that they'll want us to provide and different things. And so we'll probably continue to answer questions until the time that we're
[1:58:18] Kate Sykes: not answering the question. What would make you choose not to obligate the grant? There
[1:58:21] Speaker H (unidentified): is nothing that would make us choose not to. Great. Thanks.
[1:58:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Councilor Sykes. If there's no other questions from the council, then I will adjourn the workshop. Final words from anyone? All right. Second. All those in favor of adjournment? We're adjourned.