← Back to MaineScanner

Portland council advances Franklin Street redesign, bans scrubber discharge

2026-11-16 · 3h 13m · Source: City Council Meeting - November 16, 2026 (City of Portland, ME Meetings Portal)
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[2:01] Mark Dion: I'll call the meeting to order. Could you join me in the Pledge of Allegiance? Clerk will now call the roll. [2:27] Danielle West: Councilor Fournier? Absent. Councilor Grant? Here. Councilor Sykes? Here. Councilor Ali? Here. Councilor Pelletier? Absent. Councilor McDevich? Here. Councilor Bullett? Here. Councilor Phillips? Here. Mayor Dionne? Here.
Public Comment
[2:44] Mark Dion: Chair will now entertain public comment on non-agended items. Michael, could you pass that on to Councilor Ali? [3:03] Public Commenters (Shoshana Hose, Marianne Butts): please. Good evening. I'm Shoshana Hose, [address]. The city of Portland touts its generous benefits for employees, but there's a group of workers who are forced into a retirement plan that is ripping them off. I'm here tonight to address that. The Mission Square 457 plan charges exorbitant fees that are way out of line with similar funds. Because the fees are so high, employees are earning almost no interest on the money taken out of their paychecks and contributed by the city to their retirement. These workers cannot contribute to Social Security through their city job, and they do not qualify for better plans such as Maine PERS. Their only option is the Mission Square 457 plan. According to information provided to me through an FOI request, there are about 1,100 city workers and an additional 251 workers for the Portland Public Schools in the Mission Square plan. Those workers are in job classifications such as on-call, temporary, per diem, or seasonal jobs and some contract positions. The city workers include CNAs, nurses, childcare workers, seasonal maintenance workers, and shelter attendants. Some have been in the jobs for years. I'm guessing most have no idea how much they are paying in fees in their retirement fund. I was forced into that fund for five years as a part-time school employee. I earned 1.26% on the contributions to my account, less than half of what I would have earned if that money were in a high-yield money market account. Mission Square fees were 1.33%, or more than 10 times what Vanguard charges for a similar fund. When I retired in August and went to roll over those funds, Mission Square told me that I would have to pay a $58 fee for an electronic transfer. That's more than my total earnings over five years. In other words, that retirement fund, instead of growing in value, actually lost me money. For 13 years, I tried in vain to convince the Portland schools to replace that fund. I even found alternatives that charge lower fees. I'm now fully retired, and I have no skin in this game. This is my last attempt to convince the city and school department to stop what I consider a grave injustice to some of your lowest-paid employees. [5:42] Mark Dion: Anyone above wishing to provide public comment on a non-agended item, just come to the microphone. [5:56] Public Commenter (Mercedes Giang): Good evening. My name is Mercedes Giang, and I'm here today as a former Portland Housing Authority resident and a mother who spent nearly six years raising her two daughters in public housing. Excuse me, I'm nervous. [6:09] Mark Dion: I moved into a brand new apartment on Boyd Street in November of 2020, expecting a safe [6:24] Public Commenter (Mercedes Giang): and stable home for my family. Unfortunately, our experience became years of reoccurring roach and bed bug infestations that significantly affected our quality of life. These conditions impacted our sleep, our well-being, and our sense of safety. My children and I experienced things no family should have to endure in their own home. Although we eventually left, the effects of those years didn't leave us. My children and I carry trauma from that experience, and its effects continue long after our tenancy ended in July of 2026. I strongly believe that living in affordable housing should never mean being subjected to unacceptable living conditions. Having a lower income does not mean we deserve less dignity, less protection, or a lower standard of living. We deserve the same basic safety and respect as anyone else. I'm also here because I personally know families who are afraid to speak out about the conditions they're experiencing because they fear losing their housing. No family should have to choose between advocating for safe living conditions and protecting the roof over their heads. I want to be a voice for those families who feel they cannot speak for themselves. I'm asking for residents concerns to be taken seriously, meaningful accountability when problems go unresolved, and protections that allow families to speak up without fear of retaliation. Thank you. [7:45] Mark Dion: Anyone above wishing to speak? All right, go to the floor. [7:53] Public Commenter (Allison Decato): Counsel, my name is Allison Decato, and I was born at Maine Medical in 68. My whole family is from Maine. My family moved me around for 30 years. I was so happy to come back. At Breakwater Condos for four years on a choice voucher, beautiful accommodations, until an unsightly situation happened January 17th of 2026. The only thing affordable I could find was at Salterra [address], owned and managed by the Portland Maine Housing Authority. That very first night, cockroaches were attacking me. This has been an ongoing thing since the first day of move-in. Government funded all these positions and people in place at the town's level doing quarterly inspections. They have failed. We got this in the note in the doors today, cockroach treatment. As you know, Salterra has an ongoing cockroach problem. From the city ordinance, before renting a dwelling unit, a landlord shall disclose to a prospective tenant if an ejected unit or currently is being infested. A landlord may not offer the rent for a dwelling if they are in knowing that the building is infested. On October 16th, I came into this building and sat down with wonderful people that came to that day on October 16th. And they came in and that same day deemed the entire building cockroach infested. So with code violations and so forth, the Portland Maine Housing Authority operates with a clear mandate to provide long-term affordable housing and supportive programs. programs. The PHA was established in 43 to prevent decent, safe, and sanitary housing for low-income families, seniors, and individuals with disabilities. The mission of Portland Housing Authority to provide and expand affordable housing and services that improve the quality, life, build community, and safety and personal growth. Moving a tenant into a roach-infested department violates the implied warranty of habitability, which legally requires a landlord and property managers to provide a safe clean and livable home to all that has not happened not whatsoever and they sit there and sit there i have reached out to the executive director laura bronze with an email that she will 30 seconds on to good afternoon so the question that i have asked over and over again i'm not getting an answer why in the world with almost two months prior to me moving in April 1st with me sitting down with many officials was I not made aware of an infested building and my and your taxpayers monies are going to fund the Portland Maine Housing Authority this has got to stop I am appalled because I know that the city of Portland is in cahoots and they are supposed to work side by side in order to maintain a dignified place to live and uphold the statutes and the laws pertaining not only to the city of Portland, but to the state of Maine. Thank you. Thank you for listening. Next speaker. [11:19] Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): Stephen Sharpe of [street] in Portland. I have two things to speak to. One of them is the aforementioned issue with the Portland Housing Authority. I want to take it from a different angle, though. So this council chooses all of the members of the board of the Portland Housing Authority. It is your responsibility to make sure that they're doing their work correctly. I have yet to see in the 25 years I've been following city politics any more than maybe one time when that housing authority has come before you, to give you any kind of report as to what they're doing. That is unacceptable. They should be reporting to you on at least a quarterly basis, but at least a yearly basis as to what's happening with their organization. You should be, on a regular basis, learning about the details of what they're doing. The other item I want to speak to, I brought to you this council in the past many, times and that is you have a quote unquote inauguration coming up in a couple weeks and this council has always held that inauguration at noontime. I don't know what time you're planning to do it this year. I haven't seen any notice and then the school board holds a separate one at four o'clock in the afternoon. That makes no sense. You should be united in your efforts. You should be doing one event at whatever time makes sense and I implore this council to begin thinking about doing a combined event with the school board and have unity between the two bodies and go from there thank you next [13:20] Mark Dion: speaker is there anyone else wishing to provide public comment on a non-agenda item all right then any announcements from the council i [13:57] Speaker G (unidentified): was just going to note for the record that the rule it's rule one in the city council rules that sets the inauguration time and it's the first monday in december at 6 pm for the city council and [14:11] Mark Dion: in terms of meeting with the portland housing authority commissioners we did last year's schedule for this year we've had ongoing conversations between the housing committee. We've also, the city manager and I, have had discussions with Federal HUD about conditions in the apartments. We've exercised our due diligence. The statute establishes the Portland Housing Authority is quasi-independent, stand-alone agency, charged with providing income-based housing. saying. So I'm well aware of what's going on in terms of conditions in the building. However, it falls to the jurisdiction of the Board of Commissioners to take some action and or complaints be filed with the HUD office in Boston. That's just a general comment. I'm sure there's specifics that I'm not aware of, but I don't want you to think we're blind to what goes those on there. All right then. Councillor Phillips. [15:21] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I don't really have an answer. I just want to acknowledge Mike Murray. I know he's in the audience, but I just really want to acknowledge him because we all get a lot of emails from folks about the streets and the lights and everything else. And today I got an email from a woman who was concerned about some lights and some crossing on Outer Congress Street. And within seconds, Mike got back to me and got back to her and just said, it's already been taken care of we had people out there today and so I really just want to acknowledge Mike and his staff for just really and truly taking a really hard look at our streets and our lighting and he's always getting back to me and he's always getting back to constituents with an answer and it's always something that's always in the plan so I just really want to let folks know I really appreciate the work that you're doing Mike and it's been really helpful not only to me as i represent the city but also to the residents at livia thank you [16:21] Mark Dion: any other comments from any counselors on any item seeing none clerk will read recognition [16:29] Danielle West: recognition of outgoing city councilor sykes and fournier for their service to the city of portland [16:35] Mark Dion: chair will yield to council grant [16:43] Benjamin Grant: sorry i wasn't sure the program here were you gonna [16:46] Mark Dion: to say some things as well or no i wouldn't allow you to say okay i always speak class you [16:50] Benjamin Grant: know that it's one of the few i did want to honor the departure of my colleague and seatmate councillor sykes i won't go on and on and on but i did want to honor your service to the city and praise the creativity and thoughtfulness you've brought to this work I think we have had some good agreements and some good disagreements but we've always disagreed agreeably and I wish you well in your future endeavors and just want to thank you for your contribution here to the council thank [17:28] Mark Dion: you I'll say something about council Sykes for us I think to the general public we've been adversaries to myself there's some truth to that I think we often see a policy issue from a different perspective. But I want to tell you that's not a bad thing. I admire Kate and her friendship to me and I to hers, because when we're outside this horseshoe, I think we get along quite famously. And we push each other about our thinking, and it's done in the best of spirits. So I consider her a worthy adversary. If everyone that surrounds you is a friend, there's no chance for growth. If somebody is willing to stand firm and press their case, I like that. I think she and I are both comfortable that from time to time we can sit alone and be the only one that votes the way we see fit. And I admire that. That's conviction. It's easier to go along sometimes, but Kate is not one to go along. unless she's convinced I also admire her research capabilities I'm frightened it to what she can discover when she puts her mind to it and she's a great writer and I think being able to communicate both verbally and in written fashion is a treasure to having a colleague so I'll miss our debates I think they've gotten better over time. We both had at the beginning of our tenure together a very different idea process. And I think we've met each other midway and she surprises me when I anticipate she's going to take a left. She's been taking a few right hand turns at the intersections. sections so I have been a better mayor because of your presence and I sincerely appreciate it so you've been a valued colleague even though you make me pull out what little hair I have left from time to time yeah I'm better for that engagement okay so thanks a lot Kate all right so with that i'll have you come up here if you'd like i'd like to present her it's a painting of city hall and i hope when wherever it hangs in your home or otherwise that you'll have fond memories of this place and of us thank you thank you thank you [Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): chair] will now yield to council also say. [20:45] Kate Sykes: Thank you, Mayor. Thank you for your kind words. I appreciate all of everyone's thoughts tonight and also for your camaraderie in the break room when we had dinner together. So I do have a couple of things to say. So I had breakfast with former Mayor Kate Snyder this morning, who is returning to the council just as I'm leaving. And we had a really good laugh about the fact that apparently there's a lot of people in Portland that can't tell us apart. I've had at least a dozen people in my own district tell me that they voted for me this last election and I had to embarrassedly tell them that actually they didn't vote for me because I wasn't on the ballot that was probably the other Kate so this is all just to say that if anyone coming into public office is looking to feel important I have some bad news for you it's mostly just committee meetings and constituent calls trying to find a quiet corner wherever you are on vacation to attend a meeting on Zoom. It's a lot of evenings, it's a lot of weekends, time away from the things that restore you, and time away from the family members who love you and need you, right? And with whom our time is precious and finite. I've learned that this year, having lost my mom. But something that's made this work a lot easier is the extraordinary kindness that I've experienced from city staff. staff. It's amazing to me the culture of this place and how much staff listen to us, take our questions seriously, even when they're incredibly stupid, and help us navigate incredibly complicated issues. There is just a tremendous generosity that I've seen across all departments and I really have to commend the city manager for creating that culture here. It's wonderful to do the work inside of this city. Staff understand how demanding this work is, how emotionally difficult it can be, and I just want to tell all staff that I've worked with that I very much appreciate that. So I came to the council representing the people of District 5, but the work that we do here belongs to the whole city, and I'm proud of what we've accomplished together. We've raised the minimum wage. We've strengthened protections for renters. We've advanced a new model of building housing, social housing, and we've opened the door to what I believe is a stronger partnership with the Portland Housing Authority. And we've defended some very important public health programs that save lives. I hope that we'll continue to do that. I just did a walkthrough of Riverton Trolley Park in District 5, where a piece of Portland's history is being brought back to life as a place for neighbors to gather, children to play, and for the community to make new memories together. If you haven't been to Trolley Park recently, please go there and take a walk around. It's really cool what is going on there, and there's more to come. Not everything that I fought for succeeded. That's democracy. Sometimes you don't have five votes, but I've given this work everything that I have, and I hope that I put some ideas into the bloodstream of the city, started some conversations that will continue after I'm gone but I want to thank my colleagues I want to thank the people of District 5 for the trust that they've placed in me and especially my husband Chris who has had to make sacrifices of his own so that I could do this work it's been a privilege to serve public office is not ours to keep it belongs to the people and we're only entrusted with it for a little while and when Kate Snyder takes her seat next couple weeks I suspect that at least a dozen Portlanders won't even notice that anything has changed so thank you very much I'm [24:35] Mark Dion: gonna close with a few words about counselor fournier she couldn't be with us here tonight she's in Colorado working with Native women post-election about charting their path forward and I think that's important because when I first met Kate I was sitting Kate April you see you're on my mind now okay I was sitting in Kate's chair as a counselor and I was having an off mic but open air conversation with another counselor and I said something offensive and I was totally completely utterly blind to it and she told me she took me aside and she says tonight you gave me a gut punch and it hurt me. And I took note of that, as you would. I mean, I barely knew her. So the fact she had the courage to come up to me and tell me I'd acted in such a foolish, irresponsible manner made an impact on me. And once she explained to me what it is I actually said, I learned from it. And from that time forward, she's acted almost as a big sister to me. me. When I have a problem with the council trying to figure out where you're all going to go and how we're going to talk about it, I take counsel with April, and she's able to help me visit the different perspectives in a non-judgmental way. It makes me a better person again. If you're open to the possibility that you still have things to learn, you actually do and you might have been my worthy adversary but she was my trusted sister and I needed that from time to time on the council and I think for colleagues when she was on the forum she often was the one that could synthesize a lot of our emotional feelings about any particular policy question so I'm gonna to miss her terribly, as I will Kate, for different reasons, and the council will be diminished because of that. April, on the other hand, has decided to Augusta, she's bound to be a state representative, and maybe she can help fix them. If I was a difficult person, good luck with that, but I'll do what I can to support her, because I think she'll She'll be an excellent representative for our community as she takes on a new role on behalf of the City of Portland. So if she's listening, I'll miss you my friend, Godspeed, and thanks from everyone here for being part of our little community called the Community City Council. Thank you for your patience. Also, I have a gift for you on behalf of the council when you get home. With that, Chair would seek a motion to recess the meeting of the City Council and convene the annual meeting of the Corporate of Creative Portland. [Kate Sykes: So moved. Second.] Moved by Councilor Sykes, seconded by Councilor Ali. All those in favor by hand please pass this unanimously. We have a presentation from the Creative [28:08] Public Commenter (Herb Ivey): Portland. Thank you Mr. Mayor. Good evening all. I'm Herb Ivey. I'm the outgoing president. You'll meet our incoming president in just a few moments of Creative Portland. I live and work in Portland. I come to you tonight with our annual report and with a great deal of gratitude for your investment in our creative economy and nurturing our local arts ecosystem. That is our mission and so thank you. We at Creative Portland are at an all-time high in engagement and partnerships and support and you'll see that and can check the metrics on that with the 17th annual report that you have it's been a good year for us you'll hear more about it our arts and culture summit was a sellout at USM mayor Diane was there council Phillips was there and the feedback we got from that day with your presence was that the city's involvement in creative economy discussions is of paramount importance so thank you for being there a bit on our governance structure in 2020 we advocated for a city funded Council on the Arts to consolidate efforts supporting the arts however after three years operating within city government creative Portland returned to an independent nonprofit status that'll let us greater flexibility and fundraising and program delivery so a little perspective on that thank you to our board many of whom are here this evening they are volunteers they have professional expertise in the arts institutional knowledge and a great commitment to our creative economy so thank you on our annual report to our board our current plan our cultural plan update of 2018 is a living action plan we recommend that this serve as a city-led cultural assessment in collaboration with the efforts to update the city's comprehensive plan to identify needs and guide future investment and strengthen Portland's creative economy and we welcome collaboration with the city and hope any change to our governance would be inclusive and respectful of the community we serve again thank you and I'd like to introduce our executive director of creative Portland Dinah Minot-Wibmore more. [30:35] Public Commenters (Dinah Minot, Deirdre Nice): Thanks. I'm Dinah Minot and I'm celebrating 10 years of passionate leadership at Creative Portland. With each new city council, our hope is to strengthen our communication and collaborations with the city. So today, I just want to highlight four areas of progress and promise. One, as Herb mentioned, we have record community engagement and support. Our work is distinguished by our personal attention, our customized approach, and nuanced understanding of community needs. We have 12,000 followers on Instagram, which is double from last year alone, and 70% open rate in our newsletters. This is a tight-knit arts community. Our recent sold-out Arts and Culture Summit and the extraordinary outpouring of support just before Election Day following the nominating committee's discussion of proposed red-line changes to Creative Portland's bylaws and governance without any prior explanation to Creative Portland or consultation with the Housing and Economic Development Department indicates the support we have from our community. Our bylaws cast a wide net. We don't have the capacity to fulfill everybody's needs but overall we stand tall and we take great pride in the positive influence and impact that our organization has had on thousands of community stakeholders. We could get a hundred supporters in here tomorrow to give testimonies to that effect. That's our greatest metric really. People keep coming back to engage in our services and participate in our programs. The second thing we're excited about in terms of reporting progress and promise is that we've had a banner year for grant awards and it all just came in this past month. We've recently received federal, state, and local grant awards that we'll announce in December when we're, you know, allowed to do so. Our grant will fund artists and musicians to activate downtown Portland streets, creating new opportunities for public engagement and cultural vibrancy. As a matching grant, it offers an opportunity to attract city funding and new partners, so we're excited about that. The third thing that we want to talk about is that we deliver high impact programs. Next up is Hear on January 17th at Merrill Auditorium. It's a live talent showcase to a large community audience of over 600 and it brings vitality to downtown on a Sunday evening in the dark of winter. Tickets are on sale now through Portix. But last but not least, we want to talk about our need to expand municipal partnerships and build strategic alliances. At our biennial summits, we hear about some of the most pressing economic challenges facing Portland's creative community and other arts communities around the country, mostly due to the high cost of living and the lack of affordable housing for artists. We'd like to help the city develop a cultural strategy and we'd like the city to consider similar models to say the Jill Doosan Housing Trust Fund by establishing a special revenue account for artist housing. In general, we'd like to collaborate with the city on matching grants and on economic development grants for cultural businesses like we previously had access to from the PDC, the Portland Development Corps, back when we used to be able to get PEDPIP grants, for those of you familiar with that. Before we conclude our presentation, let me briefly introduce you to our incoming President Lee Hartman, who has not a PhD but a DMA, which is a Doctor of Musical Arts, and he is the Director of Advancement for the Arts at the University of Southern Maine. Lee. [35:05] Public Commenter (Resident of Reynolds Street): Thank you, Dinah. Thank you, councillors, mayor, counselor Phillips. I'm a proud resident on 22 Reynolds street in your district. So thank you for your support. I just wanted to say how apt it was to give the gift of a piece of art to an outgoing counselor. I just, that's what the arts do. That's how we communicate to each other. And that's the power of creativity and what we can bring together as a great city. So creative Portland success comes from its independence, its broad community representation, and direct relationships with artists, businesses, and cultural organizations that represent all artistic genres and sectors. The city's nominating committee currently advertises vacancies and appoints 10 board members to our board. Our board and community volunteers bring passion, professional expertise, institutional knowledge, and shared commitments to Portland's creative economy. Backing up what herb said our cultural plan update of 2018 is a living action plan we encourage your input we want to hear what you want to see in this we can all work together on this we recommend that this plan continues to serve as an evolving update the arts can help address things like unhoused populations and public safety we can do that together that's how we get through things we believe our direct communication with the with the city falls under the housing and economic development this is a partnership that has worked well and we would like to that to continue forward we welcome these collaborations with the city and believe any changes to our governance should be transparent inclusive and respectful of the communities that we serve so thank you for the opportunity to present today thank you for your continued support of creative Portland and I'm gonna leave you with this great art deserves a great city and a great city deserves great art thank [37:03] Mark Dion: you this item requires no public comment or formal council action chair would now seek a motion to adjourn the annual meeting of the corporator of creative portland and reconvene the regular meeting of the city council is there a motion so moved second moved by councillor sykes seconded by councillor phillips all those in favor please signify it's unanimous chair would now seek a motion to approve the minutes of the October 26 2026 and November 2nd 2026 City Council meetings moved by councillor Lee seconded by councillor Phillips all those in favor please signify by hand minutes are adopted and unanimous clerk will now read order 2627. [38:09] Danielle West: Order 80 2627 appointing Philip Cruis as a constable for the Portland Police Department sponsored by Danielle West, city manager. City manager. [38:19] Speaker G (unidentified): This is just going to allow this employee who's the animal control officer to enforce our ordinances. [38:27] Mark Dion: Thank you. Chair would seek any public comment on this proposed order. Seeing none, motion for passage in a second. So moved. Moved by Councilor Michniewicz. Second. Second by Councilor Phillips. Any comments from the council? Seeing none, all those in favor signify. Oh, there is a comment? I thought you were jumping on the vote. Go ahead. No, actually. Councilor Michniewicz, go ahead. Thank you, thank you, Mayor. [39:02] Speaker N (unidentified): I just have a couple of questions. So this just to be, cause it just says constable, but obviously this is for our ACO position, animal control officer. How, maybe this is for the city manager. How long has that position been vacant? [39:16] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm actually not positive of the length of time, counselor. I'd have to get that information for him. [39:21] Speaker N (unidentified): Okay. No, it's been a while. Okay. I had a couple other questions, but they're not really, don't need to be asked now. So, okay. [39:31] Speaker H (unidentified): Counselor Phillips. I just want to point out that the dates is wrong on here and i don't know if that matters it says the first reading is on december 7th 2026 and the final option is december 17th so i'm more than willing to vote on it if that if the date doesn't matter on the memo i [39:58] Speaker G (unidentified): believe that the order is correct counselor which is what you're voting on and i think it indicates and the memo may be incorrect and sorry for that error but i think that the order is correct all right no problem thanks okay any [40:20] Mark Dion: other questions or comments from the council seeing then all those in favor signify by hand passes unanimously clerk will now read orders 81 26 27 through 83 26 27 our consent items quarter 81 26 27 granting municipal officer [40:43] Danielle West: officers approval of three of strong spirits application for class three and four fse at 35 5 Diamond Street, sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. Order 82-2627, granting Municipal Officers approval of the NAIT. Application for Class 1A in 41 plus rooms with outdoor dining on private property and combined entertainment at 245 Commercial Street, sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. Order 83-2627, granting Municipal Officers approval of Embassy Suites by Hilton in Portland, Maine. Application for Class 1A in 41 plus rooms at 1050 Westbrook Street, sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. [41:26] Mark Dion: Thank you. City Manager, any comment? I have no comment, [41:29] Speaker G (unidentified): but staff is present for any questions of the council. Thank you. Is there any public comment [41:35] Mark Dion: on any of these proposed orders? You can speak to one or all of them. All right then. Chair would take a motion and a second on passage for all items on the consent calendar so moved second move by council psych seconded by council Michniewicz any comment by the council phillips [42:03] Speaker H (unidentified): thank you mayor i just want to point out publicly that i have a family member that works in embassy suites i don't think it's a problem but if i need to accuse myself i'm more than willing to do so it's [42:19] Mark Dion: your call counselor i don't know what he does there and if you think it influences your vote or he benefits from your vote i do not think her working there influences my vote but again i would all right chair recognizes your concern thank you for your expression you're welcome if he's the bartender then we have a further clock right you mean if she is the bartender and yes she is see how council fornia would help me why did you presume was a he she would say to me if she were here right why did you presume she was a he come on oh that's right I did I'm old it's taking time all right then there's no further comment chair would seek hand vote on the consent calendar are all items passed are any of the owners here how about the notorious hotel referred to by Councilor Phillips. Well, there you go. [43:25] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, thank you for employing my daughter. I appreciate it. [43:30] Mark Dion: Yeah, he's going to go back now and say, who is she? Find this right away. Anyone here from the NAE? Hi. And three of strong? Okay, good. Well, look, thank you all for continuing to do business in the city of Portland. it's important to us you add to our fabric and the diversity of choice that people can have when they come to this city so thank you very much I'll give you the same offer I give every licensee upon securing that document you're welcome to stay for the rest of the meeting just so you can see democracy in action or you can do like every other applicant once approved you disappear quickly through that threshold your choice see the feet don't fail me now right thank you everyone clerk will now read communication title 426 27. communication 4 [44:38] Danielle West: 26 27 greater portland transit district 2027 budget glenn fenter fenton executive director Welcome, Director. Thank you. [45:19] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): Broadcasting, yeah? Great. Okay. Hi, Glenn Fenton, Executive Director for Metro. I have just a brief presentation on Metro's 2027 budget for the council. First, before I get directly into the budget, I wanted to point out a few headlines that Metro had made in the last six months or so, and some of these will relate to the budget. First off, we launched a service in Scarborough in October. Thank the mayor for being at that launch event. We launched a new bus route in Scarborough as well as a microtransit there. That service is fully funded through a partnership with Maine Turnpike Authority as well as Maine DOT, and you'll see how that reflects in our budget shortly. Metro also had a fare increase that went into effect and was voted on by our Board of Directors for August 1st of this year. That increased fares from $2 for our base fare to 225 and our reduced fare for those that qualify went from one dollar to a dollar and ten cents and then lastly over the summer we also introduced the tap to ride technology so using credit cards or mobile wallets to pay on the bus so all of those will be reflected in our budget for next year so metro's budget is a calendar year budget so our board of directors voted to approve the budget our preliminary budget on october 29th we sent out our assessment letters to all the member communities on the 30th and now we're in the review period where each of the municipalities has an opportunity to review metro's budget and should they disagree with that budget they would take a vote to reject the budget and there's a puc process that would be invoked at that point from there our final budget is approved in march that budget is actually there are no changes in our assessment we may move some lines around but the assessment letter that portland has received will continue for that will be the same for them and then our warrants come out in april and then typically assessments are paid in july or august so metro's budget for 2027 will be 23.5 million dollars about a 14 increase over the 26 budget of that increased about 2.8 million dollars of that increase 1.7 million is directly related to that service in Scarborough that we launched and again that's fully funded service so there's no impact on any of the municipal members of Metro in that service wages and benefits are make up the lion's share of our budget about 75 percent of our budget goes to wages and benefits on the wage side we are looking at about a 13% increase. Again, a large part of that is driven by increase in the number of operators we have as we've had this expanded service, and it's being incorporated into our budget for next year. And then we also have COLAs built in for our union and our non-union employees. Similarly, on the benefits side, about a 16% increase over the 26 budget on benefits. Our benefit increase just on the inflation was about 9%, but our overall increase on health insurance was 14%. And again, that takes into the account the larger staff that we have now. Non-personnel expenses, our most significant increase is on our fuel lines. Metro's coming off of a very favorable diesel contract where we had diesel at $2.37 a gallon. Obviously, we won't be getting that next year. we've had to budget significantly higher prices for both diesel as well as natural gas. We have 10 buses in our fleet that operate on natural gas. We saw about a 65% increase in our natural gas prices as our last natural gas contract ended. And then similarly on other consumables like tires, greases, and fluids, we're seeing similar inflationary increases that are largely related to cost, just regular cost inflation, as well as some increases related to the cost of shipping parts due, again, to the fuel prices. On the revenue side of Metro's budget, we have about a 16% increase in revenue. Again, keeping in mind that a large part of that increase is directly set up for the Scarborough service. So this can be a little bit misleading and when you see that we have 11% more federal funding a large part of that funding is directed to that service just through our formula funds which come to our region we got about a 2% increase in federal funding and then on the I'll get to the municipal assessments in the next slide on the passenger fare side about 8.4 percent increase in passenger fares that's directly related to the fare increase that I mentioned earlier and then on the state funding we are largely flat or just down maybe a little bit in state funding no increases in state assistance and then on our municipal funding a little bit down that 's largely our miscellaneous funding is largely advertising on buses so on the municipal assessment overall increase this is across the board about 18% increase in municipal assessments and municipal assessments essentially are what's left after the federal funding the state funding is applied all of our other revenue sources fair run fair revenue the difference has to be made up through municipal contributions historically over the last three or four years the municipal portion of our budget's been about 30 percent of our budget going into 27 we're looking at that increasing to about 30 32 and a half percent again this is largely related to the fact that our costs are increasing faster than our revenues especially as it pertains to state which is flat and federal which is just 2% increase so regarding Portland's assessment 15% increase in Portland's assessment total change of about five hundred and thirty nine thousand dollars in increase assessment total assessment for next year will be about 4.1 million historically Portland's in all of our communities historically have had assessment increases usually around 5% or below 5%. You can see in 24 and 25, the assessments actually went down when we had South Portland join Metro and we had an influx of federal funding in those years. Last year, the increase was just a hair under 20%. That was largely related to the phase out of ARPA funding that was used in Portland to launch new services that's on the routes 9 a and b which have improved frequency as well as the extension of the husky line down to the eastern waterfront and the increased trips on the breeze service that runs between portland yarmouth freeport and brunswick going into 27 the last of our arpa funding and set aside funding will be phasing out of our budget i'll show you the numbers on that here so in 2026 between the remaining arpa funding which was of course one-time non-reoccurring funding and metro's board voting to us to use about 325 000 in carry forward funding portland received about six hundred thousand dollars in funding that was in our 26 budget that will not carry forward to 27. so with that the increase amount of five hundred and thirty nine thousand you can see is of course in line with that other funding sources did backfill some of that but largely I can say that the Portland increase is driven by that one-time funding just expiring or I should say just being depleted at the end of 2026 I think that's all I have I'm happy to take any questions about the budget or other things how's [53:37] Benjamin Grant: the grant oh thank you len talk to me a little bit about the state funding aspect of this because you do a calendar year budget so let's say we successfully advocated at the legislature for more funding in the next state budget would that impact [53:53] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): how would that impact what you're presenting here now that would impact our 28 budget so yeah we're the state amount that we have in our budget in our budget now is we're basically WE'RE WAITING FOR OUR ASSIGNMENT LETTERS, BUT YEAH, THE AMOUNT THAT THE STATE'S INDICATED THAT IS IN THEIR BUDGET, WE ALREADY HAVE. BUT WE'RE HAPPY TO WORK TOGETHER FOR 28, AND WE WILL BE, AND WE ARE ADVOCATING FOR ADDITIONAL FUNDING, BOTH FOR METRO AND AS WELL AS FOR, YEAH, ALL OF THE TRANSIT AGENCIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE THAT HAVE STATIC FUNDING IN AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE COSTS ARE GOING UP SO MUCH. [54:27] Benjamin Grant: okay but it wouldn't impact the 27 budget no okay have any other communities [54:36] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): rejected the communication yet this year no increase no i 've been to yarmouth falmouth had a 30 increase and they didn't they didn't reject i will say that a large part of their transit increase was funded by tiff and so that of course helped them and it's a useful tool for all communities that can use that no and also i'll just highlight the fact that i've been with 13 with metro for 13 years and we've never had a community enact that we do a lot of work both with our board members who are on various committees with metro and then also at a staff level of under making sure that staff understand what increase is coming and that they can fit WITHIN THE COMMUNITY'S BUDGETS. [55:25] Speaker P (unidentified): GO AHEAD, COLIN. THANK YOU SO MUCH, MAYOR DIAN. THANKS FOR BEING HERE, GLENN. THANK YOU TO OUR BOARD, METRO BOARD PRESIDENT, FOR ALSO BEING HERE. I HAD A QUESTION AROUND THE CR AND IF THERE'S ANY WAY THAT THERE MIGHT BE A MAGICAL FIX COME DECEMBER 11TH. [55:44] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): YOU KNOW, I THINK ON THE CR WE'RE... CAN YOU EXPLAIN THAT A LITTLE BIT FOR FOLKS? YEAH. THE CONTINUING RESOLUTION, WHICH IS ESSENTIALLY FUNDING the base funding that we get, the formula funding that we're talking about, I think largely another CR will keep us where we need to be. What we're more concerned about is the renewal of the IIGA. And I'm sorry, I don't know that I can't tell you exactly what that stands for. But I know it's important to us. And I know that what we really need to do is to get the Fed to put more money or to renew that and extend it, because that's really where we get a lot of the funding we used for our capital projects. Really, the large amount of our federal funding, the majority of our federal funding, unfortunately, goes to operating expenses. We'd really love to see more of it freed up for capital expenses, whether that be purchasing buses, facility projects, major capital expenses, because there's just not enough formula funding to cover all of those large capital expenses. [56:45] Speaker P (unidentified): thank you so much for that and I do want to draw my colleagues attention to page 4 of the memo which does show that while 14 increase 14 percent increase does feel high and I agree if you see compared to some of our neighboring communities it's actually quite low compared to like 30 or 27 the last thing I just wanted to mention and I get to say this because I have the microphone and because I'm on the board of directors is that we being the Metro has hired an advocacy director and it's going quite well and so that's one reason why I brought up the federal stuff because I think that there might be some opportunities for expanded funding both state and federally. So just pay attention to what's happening. I think I would say that to all of us and I will continue to pay attention as well and support the advocacy so that we can because two percent feels way too low for public transit for surface transportation. Thanks so much I [57:44] Mark Dion: would like to thank Councillor Bull and Councillor Pelletier for their work on the board. When I went to Scarborough, Councillor Pelletier was there with me, so I want to make sure people understand that sitting Councillors do actively participate in other centers of government in advance of Portland's interests and as part of a collaborative. So I'm going to only have one comment for you. this whole budget thing I'm sure we're going to have a conversation about as part of the Finance Committee is has the board considered I'm looking at my two counselors here has the board considered moving to a fiscal year platform no [58:28] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): I mean not in short answer no we haven't discussed that I think you know from our perspective this works well for us in terms of the timing of our federal funding getting released as well as the timing of the municipal budgets because it's an input to your budget as opposed to being something that's considered in the mix of the budget, but it hasn't been requested by any board members. All right, thank you. [58:57] Mark Dion: That's it. If there's no other comments. Yeah, I just... Go ahead, Councilor Phillips. [59:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you a lot for this. There was a lot of stuff in the back of material that we were able to look at. So I am noticing that you're asking all the other municipalities for an increase. What happens if Portland says, we only want to give you 10? [59:21] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): So if you reject the budget, which you'd have to do by formal action, then we would contact the PUC, and then the PUC would come in and make a determination in the same way that they regulate other utilities. It's because Metro exists in state statute outside of municipal government. that's how it's governed. But in practice I don't actually know how that would be because we haven't been through the process with the POC. Thank you for that [59:47] Speaker H (unidentified): and just one last question which is what is your communication with the state regarding their funding? [59:54] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): Very regular communication with the state actually it drove directly from Maine DOT to this meeting. We're meeting with them regularly. We have a few different requests into the state both for additional operating assistance which would help us in our budget as well as some assistance with major capital items that we need local match on that also of course have the effect of reducing the assessment for our member communities i will say it's been challenging to get an increase there and it's not just metro it's all transit agencies i should say all of the bus transit agencies have been struggling to get an increase there we did have an increase a few years back but again it's just been stagnant [1:00:37] Mark Dion: thank you there's no other comment or question we'll consider the item closed all you do go ahead [1:00:46] Speaker Q (unidentified): wes guys my apologies council bell tear no worries i'll make this brief but yeah i encourage everyone to look at the disparity in funding between buses and every other mode of transportation in the state particularly when it comes to riders served per dollar spent we'll say gp metro is doing the most with the least in a very real way. And I do think we should be advocating for a lot more funding from the state because a lot of people rely on this to get around and to keep the city going. So thank you for your work. [1:01:21] Mark Dion: Anything else from the council? Anything else from the council? What? [1:01:30] Public Commenter (Representative of Greater Portland Metro Board): Mr. Mayor, council members, just wanted to take 30 seconds to thank the Portland representatives on the Greater Portland Metro Board, Two of whom are your colleagues, Councilor Pelletier, Councilor Bullett, who have been very active and committed and engaged on all matters regarding the Metro in general, but specifically the budget. But also Paul Bradbury, who is the Jetport Director. He's just recently stepped down from being the Treasurer and is now Chair of the Facilities Committee for Metro because we're looking at building a whole new facility on our current site. And also Jeff Levine, former city planner, now head of the planning department at MIT, who is actually going to become the incoming vice president of Metro. So I just want to make sure that everyone recognizes and appreciates the hard work that all those members do. And, of course, we have a member, Emeritus, Councilor Lee, who was a longtime member of the Metro Board as well. So thank you for all your service. [1:02:30] Mark Dion: All right, no further action is necessary or public comment. Clerk will now read Resolve 626-27. [1:02:38] Danielle West: Resolve 626-27, approving the Reimagining Franklin Street Plan and Planning Study sponsored by Sustainability and Transportation Committee. Councillor Regina Phillips, Chair. [1:02:50] Mark Dion: Chair would look for comment from Councillor Phillips. [1:02:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I have to say I'm really excited about bringing this forward. I want to first congratulate whoever you are. Sorry for that blank stare. Sorry. Oh yes. Kevin Kraft, Director of Planning, for all of his hard work on this. This conversation has been happening for more than 10 years. It's had some support from the Council, it has had some support from the City Manager, sometimes it hasn't had support, so very excited that we're bringing this forward and I'm not like Kevin take it on but again I'm just really excited we have a real opportunity here to really reimagine what Franklin arterial and Franklin Street looks like by doing some really some safety improvements and supporting new development and housing and that kind of thing and so I'm excited to bring this forward and I'm excited to have Kevin let everybody know what we're doing about reimagining Franklin Street Thank You councillor [1:03:56] Kevin Kraft (Director of Planning): thanks for throwing me off my game there forgetting my name so good evening counselor my name is kevin kraft i'm the director of planning urban development i do want to take a moment just to recognize we have a lot of colleagues here with us tonight from the city planning team we have bruce hyman who is our lead project manager as well as nell donaldson our director of special projects we have ethan hippel from the parks department mark ryland the city arborist there's so many people that worked on this project wsp we have peter dido matt dross is here from MAIN DOT, OUR PROJECT PARTNER, AND I'M SURE I'M FORGETTING SOMEBODY, BUT DON'T YELL AT ME. IT'S A NIGHT OF FORGIVENESS. BUT WE'RE EXCITED TO HAVE EVERYONE HERE TO BE ABLE TO SPEAK TO YOU TONIGHT ABOUT THE PROJECT. SO AS COUNCILOR PHILLIPS MENTIONED, THIS EFFORT HAS SPANNED OVER TWO DECADES. THERE WAS ACTUALLY A PLAN TO EXPAND FRANKLIN STREET TO ACCOMMODATE MORE TRAFFIC AND INCREASE LANES. AND AT THAT TIME, THE COMMUNITY REALLY STOOD UP AND SAID THERE'S got to be a better way to plan for this. There was a lot of advocacy that we should look at the street more holistically, looking at it for all modes, and also looking at opportunities on how we could increase development potential in the heart of the city. That led to the Reclaiming Franklin effort in 2009, which actually established a vision for the street and created three various layouts for the street that looked at a boulevard, an urban street concept, and others. And ultimately that reclaiming franklin street effort and vision led into the 2015 master plan which resulted in refined design all for those three concepts which was ultimately supported by the city council unfortunately the project stalled and fizzled out and paused after 2015 but the city's really changed since that time we've seen significant development we've been in a housing crisis and we have an acute issue with our transportation network in terms of safety So there was a big outcry from the public to perhaps reimagine and re-engage Franklin Street, which is council supported in 2023 and 2024 when the council unanimously supported us working with MaineDUT to update the study. This project kicked off in February of 2025. It has been an extensive process. Many of you have been engaged throughout and we've presented to the Sustainability and TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE THROUGHOUT AND WE APPRECIATE THEIR UNANIMOUS RECOMMENDATION TO THE COUNCIL TO BRING US HERE TONIGHT. THERE HAVE BEEN SIGNIFICANT OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE PUBLIC TO ENGAGE IN THIS PROCESS SINCE THE BEGINNING. WE HAVE HAD MULTIPLE IN-PERSON OPEN HOUSES. WE HAVE HAD TWO IN-PERSON DESIGN WORKSHOPS. WE HELD POP-UP EVENTS IN PARTNERSHIP WITH PORTLAND HOUSING AUTHORITY AT KENNEDY PARK AS WELL AS CULTIVATING COMMUNITY WHERE WE ACTUALLY We met with people crossing the street. We had staff out giving tours of the length of the street. We held online plan reviews. We had over 560 comments on Conveio, an online platform. Don't quote me on this, but I did hear from the platform company that I think it was the highest amount of public comments they've ever seen on a plan, in addition to in-person comments, which brought us to just under 1,000 in the last couple of months. In addition, we held meetings with stakeholders and neighborhood associations, which included the Bayside Neighborhood Association, the East Bayside Neighborhood Association, the India Street Neighborhood Association, and the Monjoy Hill Neighborhood Association, as well as the Franklin Reclamation Authority, Cultivating Community, Friends of Lincoln Park, Noise, representatives of the Armenian Monument, and many other residents and businesses, and I will stop naming them all here now. So for over a decade, it has been clear that Franklin Street isn't working for our city or our community for all modes of travel. As you can see from the two images on the screen, it is an unsafe corridor. It's been identified in the region's high-risk network. And even over the course of the study, we've seen two unfortunate safety challenges that exasperate kind of what we're going through. So goals built off the 2015 plan and were informed by early public engagement on this process and focused on three core themes, which was heal, move, and grow. Move, focusing on how people were going to get through the corridor, whether you're in automobiles or a cyclist or a pedestrian. Grow, focusing on how we could grow into an environmentally sustainable community, supporting both economic development and housing development. And heal, really healing the large scar that urban renewal put in when they built Franklin Street several decades ago. So how could we reconnect and re-knit the neighborhood. So I'm going to walk you through some of the design concepts now. So in terms of the street design concept, we heard multiple, opinions. As I mentioned, we had over a thousand comments in this process, but primarily we heard very similar themes. Folks wanted a smaller, more multimodal street, fewer lanes, and narrower roadways, a reconnected street grid, and a safer infrastructure for people walking and biking. Where opinions differed, where there are strong opinions on whether or not we should have on-street parking, with some advocating for it and others believing that we should not provide any. That informed our street design, which you'll see has a reconnected street grid, reduces lane and lane widths, includes bicycle and pedestrian facilities, and reduces the impact on development potential. So the first slide I'm going to show here is actually how narrow the street gets in this proposal. So you'll see in the top row in the image at the top, in red is the existing crossing distance for pedestrians. pedestrians and green is what's being proposed in this plan. So at Marginal Way, the existing crossing is roughly 101 feet. That would be narrowed down to 70 feet. At Oxford Street, 170 feet today, down to 58 feet. That's less than the walk from the home plate to the pitcher's mound at Fenway Park. 220 feet at Cumberland Avenue, all the way down to 58 feet as well. And 80 feet down to 37 feet at Middle Street, which is even less than a Little League Fields PITCHERS MOUND AND I CAN'T SEE AND 101 FEET TO 42 FEET AT COMMERCIAL STREET IN TERMS OF A SAFER MORE ACCESSIBLE STREET AT MARGINAL WAY WE HAD TO ACCOMMODATE TRAFFIC GETTING ONTO AND OFF OF I-295 IT WAS A PROJECT REQUIREMENT AS WE WERE WORKING THROUGH THIS WITH OUR PARTNERS BUT WE DID NARROW IT SIGNIFICANTLY WE ALSO ARE INCLUDING RACED CROSSWALKS SHORTER SINGLE STAGE CROSSINGS FOR PEDESTRIANS TIGHTER CORNER RADIUSES TO SLOW TRAFFIC TURNING THE CORNERS AS WELL AS TRUCK and truck aprons all to help mitigate safety issues. We included, as I just mentioned, more compact intersections, so smaller intersections. We removed slip lanes and reduced the crossing distances significantly. We also included five raised intersections along the entire corridor, which you can see are circled in blue. So that would be Lancaster Street, Oxford Street, Federal, Newberry and Middle would all be raised intersections to help traffic calm the area. We would have a smaller curb to curb between the right-of-way and fewer lanes with less traffic. The 2015 plan actually had six lanes at marginal way, and we were able to get it down to five, which I know does not sound like a lot, but it's a major accomplishment. We also had a smaller right-of-way getting down to 11-foot lanes. We were able to advocate for and get receive and get four new cross streets at both Lancaster, Oxford, Federal and Federal Street as well as Middle Street and we also were able to get smaller block sizes which many of you have heard from the spec event as a critical aspect to safety reducing the significant super blocks that you see today which exasperate speeding. In addition right now there is no continuous sidewalks or any bike infrastructure along the entire Franklin corridor. This project would add one and a half miles of sidewalks and separated bike lanes at grade. It would be the first in the city. These would all be protected and would extend all the way from Marginal Way to Commercial Street. In terms of development opportunity, we heard one thing, more housing. We heard it a lot. We did not fall on deaf ears. More housing, more housing, more housing. We also heard that folks wanted a more mixed-use 15-minute city with ground level activity and a stronger street wall to define the corridor where opinions differed there was differences opinion on how to handle parcels being created near the board street park and garden some wanted the park to expand others did not want the park to expand and felt it should be used for housing and others advocated for what specifically parcels would be used for in land which we clearly outline in your memos in your packet in terms of unlocking housing and economic development potential. This plan would create over three and a half new acres of developable land which is more land created in the 2015 plan and today where there is zero air opportunity for development. The plan creates more regular shaped parcels compared to the 2015 plan for more adequate development. The plan could result in roughly 530 to 720 new housing units which is a conservative estimate and only takes into account development potential on the new land created and abutting city-owned land and not private property. It would also create over a hundred thousand square feet of commercial non-residential ground floor space for activity and street level activation. We incorporated recommendation for on-street parking from commercial street to congress to support nearby businesses and residences. This plan also took into account bus rapid transit stops working with metro and adding space for food trucks, bike corrals, and outdoor dining. The project, in terms of the work done with WSP, we estimate $1.5 to $2 million in annual property tax revenue. I want to be clear that is a conservative estimate because we did not include all of the new land that could go to park space in those assumptions. We could also get significant parking revenue, over $250,000 in annual parking revenue if metered. We could get an estimated increase in property sales from over $12.5 half million dollars if we were to sell the new parcels created. Lastly, in terms of open space and sustainability, we heard other priorities, more trees and tree preservation. We have a median today with fantastic trees. We also have a corridor that's lined with majestic oak trees. We also heard a clear desire to expand Lincoln Park. Opinions differed. While more people wanted trees, others saw that at odds with housing opportunity and requested no trees or reduction in trees. Others wanted us to expand the medians in the plan. Others wanted us to remove medians entirely. And again, others wanted us to enhance Boyd Street Park and expand it, and others didn't want us to expand it at all. So what you'll see here is how we were proposing to heal the community. With enhanced public parks and public realm, we would be able to expand Lincoln Park to almost its original footprint and increase Lincoln Park beyond the 2015 plan. The current layout out shows an expanded Lincoln Park that would actually result in a or an expanded Boyd Street Park which would actually expand the garden and park space over it today and create one continuous park as opposed to a divided park by a new street. The plan would include over 230 new street trees to help reduce urban heat island effect. It would also include major infrastructure improvements, sewer separation to help reduce combined overflow into Portland's water system, new storm drain systems, and green infrastructure for pretreatment like bioswales and rain gardens. I'll quickly walk you through the renderings of what it would look like through a newer reimagined Franklin Street. Although these trees would probably take a few years to get to this scale, this is what it would look like coming into the city off of 295 and being funneled into a new Franklin Street. As you move along down to the Oxford Street corridor, you can see new housing opportunities flanking and abutting a new Franklin Street with a new expanded Boyd Street garden to the right. Looking back towards Marginal Way at the new and expanded Lincoln Park again with new housing along the corridor and an expanded park. And lastly what the street would look like as you reach Commercial Street again a more narrow urban street with bikeways expanded sidewalks, and tree-laned corridors with bus stops. Again, this would result in over 500 to 720 new housing units, new first floor commercial space, over one and a half acres of new park space potential with over 230 new trees, four reconnected streets that don't exist today and previously existed, one and a half miles of separated bike lanes and sidewalks that do not exist today with five raised intersections and four raised crosswalks again to help improve pedestrian experience at this corridor i'm going to close on a couple of areas that we heard more input on and folks wanting to understand design decisions so the graphic you see here is actually the street layout from the 2015 plan you'll see that there's a slight curve in the street and the black boxes represent the development parcels in that plan while the blue represents stormwater infrastructure that would have been created from new parcel land. This resulted in a strong plan, but it also created irregularly shaped blocks that limited development potential. The Noyes and Franklin Street blocks are already super blocks that are the typical urban size and do not rely on new land to be developable. This also reduced the size of the Boyd Street garden and divided it, and it resulted in a limited street wall between Cumberland and Lancaster because the plan contemplated stormwater infrastructure along the Boyd Street Garden and not housing. It also resulted in less connectivity as they did not have full connections at Lancaster Street or Oxford. So as we went through the design process, we started to look at block configurations. The graphic you see here is the plan before you in 2026. By slightly shifting the street to the south or towards Franklin Towers and Noise, we were able to actually create regular rectangular blocks with greater depths so we could fit double-loaded corridor buildings. We were also able to expand in a continuous Boyd Street garden and could also focus housing on the northerly side while limiting shadow impacts on the garden. This also would result in a stronger street wall because you would have development along Lancaster Street to Oxford Street and it restored again the historic street grid at Lancaster and Oxford. In this area alone we would be able to create over 1.8 acres of newly developed land and a net gain of 28,700 square feet compared to the 2015 plan. So when you compare the two in terms of our design decisions, the 2015 plan did not reconnect the street grid, it did not maximize development opportunities, it did not enhance the street wall, it did not improve public open space or support tree preservation. The plan before you reconnects the street grid, maximizes development opportunities, enhances the street wall opportunities, improves public open space, and supports the opportunity for tree preservation in these areas. I'll move on to parking. As I mentioned, we heard many folks that wanted parking. Others did not want any parking in this plan. We proposed parking from Commercial Street to Congress Street, where the street is narrowed down to one lane. There was a desire for this area to be a true urban street, much like Congress Street. This was also an area that had limited development potential, so on-street parking did not impact the developability of parcels to those outside of the right-of-way. ON STREET PARKING IS A KNOWN TRAFFIC CALMING MEASURE. IT SLOWS TRAFFIC DOWN AND CREATES FRICTION. IT ALSO CREATES FLEXIBILITY. IT CAN BE USED FOR LOADING TO SUPPORT NEARBY BUSINESSES. IT CAN CREATE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES TO SUPPORT CUSTOMERS FOR BUSINESSES. IT COULD ALSO BE USED FOR OTHER USES LIKE BIKE PARKING. AS THIS COUNCIL KNOWS, THE CITY DOES NOT HAVE ANY MINIMUM PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES WHICH MEANS WE CAN MAXIMIZE OUR PARCELS BUT THEN ALSO CREATE opportunities for parking on the street. In addition, working with our parking department, we estimate that we could create over $260,000 in annual revenue if these spaces were metered. So the area that I'm talking about is from Congress Street down to Commercial. And today, many of you probably know, it lacks a lot of activation because that area is already built with many buildings, with either on street or with non-commercial ground floors and parking garages. This is an example from Clyde Warren Park in Dallas, where they actually used on-street parking to support a food truck businesses that anchor the park. They actually pay into a fund that then actually goes towards improvements into the park, but it creates activity and actually creates that street wall that many folks were advocating for. In addition, as I mentioned, on-street parking can be used for other things than just automobiles. It can be used for bike corrals and help visibility as you get closer to intersections. It can also help with outdoor dining and plaza space. We've seen the success of many businesses use outdoor dining for their businesses. For instance, nearby, Eventide has an outdoor dining on Middle Street that takes up two to three parking spaces. By being able to make that up on Franklin Street, it gives us the ability to look at other areas to expand pedestrian realm throughout the city. For instance, as well, the city has closed Dana Street and Milk Street, which used to have on-street parking but those are now dedicated to better uses for pedestrians. This allows us again to more maximize the Franklin Street corridor to support many different uses. And lastly, as I mentioned, it offers traffic calming and protection for cyclists and pedestrians as you see here in Portland, Oregon. And finally, trees. As I mentioned a few times today, we've heard a lot about trees. Again, some folks advocating for preserving as many trees as possible and others advocating for housing this plan again would plant over 230 new trees more than that exists today the city is also mentioned and is included in the report a commitment to assess and preserve the existing tree canopy which i'll show you here in a moment there's also green stormwater infrastructure that's been included and expanded open spaces as we've shown in the plan so i want to walk you through this diagram really quickly here on the top shows the landscaping plan as proposed with the circles in green as each proposed tree throughout the city. The confusing diagram on the bottom that has the pink in the center and the yellow to the sides demonstrates where there are opportunities to look at preserving existing trees that exist, including the oaks that are outside of the right-of-way, and the trees that are going to be more challenging and likely require removal or really taking a hard look at relocation, which is the median there is no alignment of the street in which the median can be preserved but there are opportunities to look at preserving the trees that live on the outside of the street the reason for that is the street is being reduced and is coming to the inside as opposed to expanding outside which gives us more opportunities to explore preservation during the next design and engineering phase as we get more fine-grained with things like engineering and understanding the grades better with that in terms of next steps again we were at the S&T committee last month where we received unanimous support to endorse this plan. Tonight, we're seeking the council's endorsement of the plan to move this into the next phase, which is the preliminary design phase. As we mentioned in the report, and as you may have heard us say before, that phase is already funded with a federal grant as well as impact fees that was allocated two years ago from the city council and a state match. After the PDR phase, we would explore elements such as demonstration and pilot projects and continue to advocate for funding for construction. Again, the project results in a smaller street with fewer lanes, narrower, and reconnects the street grid and reduces superblocks. It creates a safer street with separated bike lanes and sidewalks, raised crosswalks and curb extensions, a new place to call home in one of Portland's most accessible locations in the entire city with more developable land than previous iterations in an expanded Lincoln Park, and a greener, more resilient street, including sewer separation, green infrastructure, and more trees and opportunities for preservation thank you thank you director craft and i'll take [1:24:33] Mark Dion: public comment i'll go up and down go ahead you have the floor above i [1:24:49] Speaker T (unidentified): got involved with franklin when i was in my early well when i was in my 30s and i'm now close to 60 i know i don't look at But it's just a tremendous achievement on the part of city staff, Manager West, Director Kraft, Bruce Hyman, I believe, has seen this project through the entire time, and I believe probably the only person. We didn't get everything we wanted in this plan, but there's a lot to like. I WAS GOING TO EMPHASIZE THE FINANCIAL BENEFITS LONG-TERM FOR THE CITY, BUT DIRECTOR CRAFT DID AN EXCELLENT JOB DOING THAT, SO I'D JUST LIKE TO EMPHASIZE HIS COMMENTS. [1:25:44] Public Commenter (Wendy Cherabini): CHAIR, GO BELOW. MAY IT DIE ON MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL. MY NAME IS WENDY CHERABINI AND I LIVE AT [address] ON THE CORNER OF FEDERAL AND FRANKLIN. I'm strongly in favor of advancing the Franklin Street redesign project into the preliminary design, study, and engineering phase. I want to thank the council, city manager, MDOT, and especially the planning department and its consultant, WSP, for all their work on this concept plan. The design before you is the best plan I have seen in over 20 years of advocating for Franklin. Franklin. It will allow us to re-knit Portland's urban fabric and heal this horrible urban renewal scar in the heart of our city. The concept before you tonight will provide huge housing safety and bike-ped benefits and expand our tax base. A redesigned Franklin will make Portland more vibrant and livable for decades to come, and it will direct housing growth into the city and away from the suburbs. These improvements reflect an enormous amount of public input as Kevin mentioned. Some of the most exciting aspects include reconnecting the street grid at Lancaster, Oxford, Federal, and Newbury, creating over three and a half acres of land for housing and mixed-use development, improving pedestrian and cycling safety along the whole corridor, restoring a significant amount of Lincoln Park's historic footprint, narrowing the street and travel lanes, and planting many more street trees. As with any plan of this size and scope, it is not perfect. I recognize that there are areas where a balance must be struck among completing views and priorities. In particular, I object to sacrificing housing along Franklin between Cumberland and Oxford, excess left turn lanes, and unnecessary mini-medians. NONETHELESS, MOVING THIS PLAN FORWARD TO THE NEXT PHASE WILL CREATE OPPORTUNITIES TO REVAZE IT AND REFINE THESE COMPONENTS WHILE NOT LOSING SIGHT OF THE BIG PICTURE. THERE WILL ALSO BE OPPORTUNITIES IN PARTNERSHIP WITH MDOT TO SET UP DEMONSTRATION PROJECTS AND SEE IF LANE REDUCTIONS AND OTHER TRAFFIC CALMING MEASURES CAN WORK. I LOOK FORWARD TO THOSE DEMONSTRATIONS AND THE DATA THEY WILL PROVIDE TO INFORM THE FINAL PLAN. THE REPORT BRIEFLY NOTES SIGNIFICANT ECONOMIC GAINS AS DIRECTOR CRAFT MENTIONED AND THEY show the project will result in a huge net financial benefit to the city it would be fiscally irresponsible to not move forward in closing i want us all to think about the people missing from this entire process the people who don't live here yet people who will be part of our community living working and playing all along 30 seconds and throughout the city people who will enhance the neighborhood and our city in so many ways i can't wait to meet those folks please support moving the Franklin does redesign forward so we can hasten that happy day thank you anyone upstairs want to [1:28:36] Mark Dion: provide public comment go [1:28:43] Public Commenter (Deb Andrews): ahead speaker good evening my name is Deb Andrews and I'm speaking on behalf of the Friends of Lincoln Park tonight the Friends of Lincoln Park enthusiastically support the plan before you for consideration having followed closely its development and participating at every opportunity providing public comment. Implementation of this truly transformative plan will do much to correct and reverse the wounds created by the construction of the Franklin Street arterial. The Friends of Lincoln Park in addition to the Friends of Lincoln Park have obviously been focused on the plan as it relates to Lincoln Park, which directly abuts Franklin. We're very pleased that in addition to all the other benefits presented by this plan, the plan calls for the expansion of Lincoln Park to close to its original footprint. A little bit of context might be helpful. In 2013, the year Friends of Lincoln Park was established, the park was in derelict condition, neglected, and largely forgotten. This was due in no small part to the impact of the Franklin Arterial Construction, which not only removed about a third of the land area of the park, but removed the residential blocks that surrounded it, destroyed the street grid that defined this area, and severed connection to the India Street and Munjoy Hill neighborhoods beyond it. Since 2013, the Friends have worked hand-in-hand with the City to restore the park's former beauty and to reactivate it. Along with generous funding provided by the City and federal grants, the Friends have raised significant financial support to restore the park. Although progress has been painfully slow at times, significant improvements have been made, including restoration of the fountain reconstruction of the concrete paths that traverse the park installation of benches throughout introduction of pandora cases iconic holiday lighting and perhaps most significantly the ongoing restoration of the cast iron fencing and imposing granite piers that surround it with 30 seconds okay with these improvements we've seen extraordinary increase in usage, now events are drawn to the park. This project, as proposed, will enhance the efforts made today and enliven the space for the new residents that are promised to come as a result [1:31:36] Mark Dion: of it. Thank you. Speaker from the floor. [1:31:43] Thomas O'Boyle (Portland Regional Chamber): Good evening, Mayor Dionne and members of the council. My name is Thomas O'Boyle and I'm the Advocacy Director at the Portland Regional Chamber. [1:31:51] Mark Dion: Mr. Boyle, could you move your microphone? We can hear you, but at home they might not be able to. [1:31:58] Thomas O'Boyle (Portland Regional Chamber): At the Chamber, we believe a thriving business community and a thriving city go hand in hand. Businesses need a city where people want to live, work, and invest. That means planning for growth, creating more housing, and making sure our infrastructure and public spaces support a city that is accessible, attractive, and welcoming. This plan for Franklin Street represents a real opportunity to do just that. the proposal creates the potential for significant new housing in an established urban area close to jobs, services and transportation. It is also an opportunity to make the corridor safer. Franklin Street is identified on the region's high injury and high risk network and the proposed improvements including protected bike lanes, better sidewalks and shorter pedestrian crossings would make it safer and easier for people to get around whatever their mode of transportation. Just as importantly, this is about reconnecting parts of Portland that were divided by the road's original design. Restoring connections to surrounding streets, expanding public spaces like Lincoln Park and Boyd Street Park, and creating a more human-scale environment would help repair that historic division and make the area a better place to live and spend time. We recognise there will be detailed questions to work through as the project advances, but we believe the overall concept, crafted through a thorough public engagement process, deserves the council support. Earlier this year, Portland welcomed Jeff Speck, one of the country's leading urban planners and author of the award-winning book Walkable City to speak at the city's Portland in Motion event. Having reviewed the proposal at the time, he put his assessment rather simply, quote, the plan that you have in front of you is a very good plan, end quote. We agree and encourage council to move forward, move the plan forward. Thank you for your time. [1:33:43] Mark Dion: Anyone above want to speak? I can't see because of the floodlights, so I have to trust noise. Sounds like someone's coming. [1:33:58] Public Commenter (John Grayback): Hi, I'm John Grayback. I've been involved with this project I guess for about 15 years, not from the very beginning. I was on the public advisory committee for the 2015 plan. I also would like to congratulate all the work that the planning department has done, and particularly in garnering so much public input into the development of this plan I generally support it but as a resident of Franklin Towers I have to speak for the for us residents that one of the big problems with Franklin Street now is that the southbound lane which is the one that takes traffic towards the waterfront is too close to Franklin Towers and we get too much traffic noise and pollution coming up into the apartments through the open windows particularly in the summer most of the windows open from the top so it just directs all of that stuff right into the buildings the noise and the pollution and so forth it's especially bad with the heavy trucks stopping for the traffic light on Cumberland Avenue and then having to start up again on a 7% grade going up uphill there's a lot of exhaust emissions and so forth so I did notice I've been arguing throughout this process that I would like to see the alignment revert back closer to what was proposed in 2015 which would have shifted the southbound lane also to the existing northbound lane I haven't had much luck with that but I did notice in the in Kevin crafts memo to the council that they are going to shift the southbound lane 15 feet further away from Franklin Towers I just want to submit that 's really not enough to make much of a difference and I wouldn't would like to see it moved closer to the northbound lane and if main DOT and others feel that the existing northbound lane is too curvy that real kink just north of Cumberland Avenue that goes those close to the Boyd Street Gardens could be straightened out a little bit. And that would give some additional land to the Boyd Street Gardens as well. However, I have to confess that there is a tradeoff between expanding the Boyd Street Garden to the maximum versus moving particularly the southbound lanes, but really both lanes, as far away from Franklin Towers as possible. So that's my one big comment on this. and i did 30 seconds really detailed written comment that's part of the record here it was addressed to counselor and at large councils thank you very much [1:36:47] Mark Dion: anyone from the floor wishing to speak evening [1:36:53] Public Commenter (Avery Yale Camilla): mayor and counselors my name is avery yale camilla and i represent portland protectors we support the idea of removing a highway from downtown portland reconnecting severed street connections, and building bike and pedestrian infrastructure. However, because the current plan proposes to clear-cut so many existing heritage trees, we ask you to either reject it or modify it if you are going to accept it. Franklin Street was built following anti-immigrant redlining that barred properties owned by recent immigrants from obtaining mortgages and loans. the properties naturally fell into disrepair. Then City Hall and developers promoted slum clearing and highway building as the solution. Hundreds of homes and businesses were destroyed, streets were truncated, and residents displaced. The first step of all slum clearing projects was to clear cut and then bulldoze the land. Reimagine Franklin unfortunately follows the same model, clear-cut Franklin and bulldoze the land. All four neighborhoods Franklin cuts through were slum cleared, and as a result, all four now represent Portland's least equitable neighborhoods in terms of tree canopy as measured by American Forests. The Bayside neighborhood with 7% tree canopy is the least equitable, followed by the Old Port with 7%, India Street with 10% and East Bayside with 12%. In contrast, the West End has tree canopy coverage ranging from 27 to 39%. The equity scores take into account temperature and demographic data. In Bayside, where 49% of residents are not white, the inequitable tree canopy creates a heat disparity of 18.8 degrees Fahrenheit in the summer. While the plan indicates all the trees along Franklin and Bayside will be clear-cut and replanted with saplings, which take 20 to 50 years to deliver the same ecosystem services of stormwater management, air filtration, and air cooling the current trees provide, the plan gives Bayside no new parks or public amenities. The most devastating clear cuts proposed in this plan affect the heritage oaks growing next to Lincoln Park and along the side of Franklin between Marginal and Fox. I've spoken with Maine DOT's traffic engineer who said that traffic counts below Congress drop enough to shrink Franklin to two travel lanes, which would allow all the heritage oaks near Lincoln Park to be preserved. But the plan doesn't do that. According to Penn State Extension, a single mature oak can intercept 1,000 gallons of water a year, while a heritage oak cools the surrounding area by transpiring more than 40,000 gallons of water per year. This proposed plan will spend millions to make downtown hotter, with dirtier air in the summer. Please preserve our tree canopy. anyone [1:40:20] Mark Dion: above wishing to provide public comment from the floor anyone else you can form a queue if you'd like just i have some idea who's left good [1:40:41] Public Commenter (Lily Sage): evening my name is lily sage you can move [1:40:44] Mark Dion: the microphone there you go feel free to put exactly where it works for you i live at [address] [1:40:50] Public Commenter (Lily Sage): exeter street and i am here in favor of advancing the franklin street redesign plan i teach in the Portland Public School District, where I recently chaperoned an amazing seventh grade field trip to the Portland Freedom Trail. The Freedom Trail dots the East End and crisscrosses Franklin Street, and I would encourage anyone who has not yet been to check it out. Going into this field trip, I was not worried about students getting lost or forgetting their lunch or neglecting to prepare their essays about local abolitionist history. I was concerned about Franklin Street. If you know middle schoolers' propensity for impulsivity and wiggliness, you may understand where I was coming from. But if you know Franklin Street, its history of multiple fatal pedestrian incidents, its wide lanes, high speeds, and that highway mentality that moves drivers to speed up at yellows and upon taking turns rather than slow down, then you'll really understand why I took the threat of Franklin seriously with my students. I regret that I had to sit my group down for a firm conversation about how we would safely walk across that road. It broke my heart to discuss the dangers of vehicular traffic with 10, 12-year-olds who started their school year under the shadow of another pedestrian mentality in their peer group, but I was glad that I did. Everywhere else on our field trip, in parks and on wider strips of sidewalks, those kids were squirrely. They were running, tussling, jumping around, waving leaves in each other's faces, doing amateur parkour, middle schooler things. Along and across Franklin Street, which needed multiple crossings due to the poor design and lack of sidewalks, they lined up perfectly. They followed all directions and they remained with our group. In short, they were vigilant because one has to be. On Franklin, as a pedestrian, you can sense that it is not your space. It has been designed for cars and that you may pass through walking so long as your transit does not impede much on the speed and ease of vehicular transit. The Franklin Street redesign plan is not perfect, but it is clearly a step in the right direction. Franklin must connect rather than divide our city. It must facilitate pedestrian, bicycle, and bus transit at or above its level of service for private vehicles. I would enthusiastically support a plan that goes even further without on-street parking or extra left turn lanes, a plan that frees up even more space for housing, which is desperately needed, or anything else that panders to car throughput. 30 seconds. But this plan makes Franklin safer for all of us, and rights a historic wrong from the era of urban renewal. I'd like for my students to feel like Franklin Street enables their access to the Freedom Trail rather than acts as a barrier to it on our next field trip. Thank you very much for your time. [1:43:31] Mark Dion: Anyone else wishing to provide a comment? [1:43:39] Public Commenter (John Kaminsky): Good evening, Mayor Dion and counselors. My name is John Kaminsky. I live at [address], right on the corner of Franklin and Federal. I am here tonight to support sending the proposed Franklin plan forward to the design and engineering stage. The proposed plan, as many have mentioned before tonight, will promote many important goals. These include overall pedestrian, bike, and traffic safety, reconnecting neighborhoods and streets to diminish the current Franklin's barrier effect, which divides sections of the city, creation of additional green space and locations that are genuinely usable, restoring a portion of Lincoln Park that was taken when Franklin Street was previously widened. It will also improve the appearance of an important gateway to the city, and I think that's critical. The plan will free up three and a half acres of currently underutilized land for hundreds of units of new housing, which the city sorely needs. needs. Separately from those goals, and very importantly, the next stage of design and engineering position the Franklin Street project to compete for federal and state funding when that funding becomes available. Having a project that is thoroughly planned and ready to proceed will be critical in successfully competing for that funding when it becomes available. The plan is the outcome of a robust, collaborative effort of the City leadership, City staff, the City's planning consultant, MDOT, many advocates, and engaged citizens. There have been many opportunities for public input, both online and in person. Listening to Director Kraft's presentation tonight, we know that it was not easy for the consultants and city staff to weed through the different views that were presented advancing this plan now recognizes that collaborative effort while still preserving the opportunity to later adjust the plan to address any continuing concerns or issues as referenced in the planning department's memo to the council in closing i urge you to move this plan forward tonight night to the next stage. Thank you. [1:46:03] Mark Dion: Anyone else wishing to provide public comment on this proposed order? Go ahead. Well, I could see there's nobody at the microphone. [1:46:17] Public Commenters (Resident, Ian Jacob): Mayor Dion, members of the council, city staff, I fully support moving this forward. I have not been involved as long as some other members here. I think there's a lot of good stuff in this proposal. There's also some not so great things. I would like to see moving forward, having participated in many of these ventures here in the city, forgot to mention that I live on [street], one of our other urban highways, so it's good to see we are reducing that number, hopefully. What I would like to see is greater transparency in the guidance and recommendations that MDOT, our partner in this has. As a way of example, we currently have 23 turning lanes. I know we're getting four reconnected streets, which is great. Proportionally there's no decrease in the turning lanes. We now will have 33 turning lanes. So I'd like to know why is that? And so I know that's in part guided by various things,, but MDOT is one of those people or participants guiding us there. So if we can have that be part of the process, I think that would be really good for those of us who have participated a long time, and also just to see the reasoning since I would argue we're not really seeing a reduction in pavement, we're seeing a reduction in right of way with but not per se pavement specifically with all those turning lanes so yes please do move this forward I think this is great I look forward to it hopefully I'll be alive when it gets finished and thank you all [1:48:10] Mark Dion: right then anyone else wishing to provide public comment on this proposed order checking [1:48:16] Public Commenter (Resident of Casco Street): out you see there is someone up there yeah very off-the-cuff based on that last comment. I'd like to stand representing the subset of Portlanders who are relatively young. [1:48:28] Mark Dion: Can you give us your name, please? Oh, Eleanor. Yeah, sorry. No, that's all right. Thank you. [1:48:33] Public Commenter (Resident of Casco Street): I'm a resident of Casco Street, so I live in downtown Portland. I've lived car-free here for a little over a year now, and it's a very exciting place to live. There are a lot of endeavors and construction projects and so on and so forth around here that I've grown to be really excited about, and I have a lot of pride for my city. Consequently, Franklin Street is something that I've kept my eye on very closely from all of the various incarnations from 2006 to 2015 all the way up until right now. I'm very enthusiastic and excited to see this move forward. I understand that there have been a lot of hurdles in the way. For example, Portland doesn't always lend itself to the urbanist outlook. We get 70 inches of snow per year, and during that time I can't imagine the bike lanes will get a whole lot of use but when the shoes on the other foot this is a peninsula that is defined by its geographic limitations it's only a mile wide three miles long everything else is surrounded by water all those tourists coming in on the cruise ships they don't always have access to an automobile so creating a more car independent culture and a car independent city such as the plan that we will hopefully see move forward here I really appreciate that's all is [1:49:48] Mark Dion: there anyone else up in the balcony that wants to speak remember I can't see the back of the balcony is there no okay that's just head shaking all right on the floor anyone else wish to speak all right then public comment is closed chair would seek a motion and a second for passage so moved second by council grant was that council bullet who proposed the motion thank you [1:50:27] Speaker P (unidentified): council comment i'll serve bullet thank you mayor so there's like three things that are really synonymous with my first term on the council recode vision zero and franklin street reimagining project before the ink was even dry on my petition papers in like 2023 to run marcus miller had found my personal email and made sure that i knew that this was something i had to do and then my predecessor andrew zaro made sure that i knew that this was something i had to do which is really interesting for a district counselor that it was that important to so many people in the community that even though i hadn't won a seat on council people were making sure that I knew this was something I had to do so I just want to express like sincere gratitude for all the public engagement those that emailed me and found me before I was even in this horseshoe and then throughout this whole process both the organized and then the people that have shown up and really surprised us with heartfelt comments I also really want to thank the city staff I mean when I say that they had barely caught their breath after Recode and then immediately had to launch into this very intense process. I mean it. I don't even think they slept. I think they just passed Recode and then the very next morning started on digging into Franklin Street reimagining. So they need to get so,, so much credit for this, all of them. I can't say enough great things about them. So I've had the pleasure of being on S&T, so I know a lot about this. So I'm just going to real quick, run through the things I'm excited about and then remind the city staff and DOT the things I still want to see in this plan. I am supporting it. So I'm really excited about the bioswells. That's like a super nerdy thing I didn't know about until I was on council. And I encourage everyone to go Google it because it's really cool, especially for a peninsula like ours that has had multiple very scary 12-foot tides that should be only 100 years that we've had many of in the last couple years. Really excited about 500 to 700 new housing units, and that's just the minimum. We could probably get more. Excited about 1,200 new square feet of community garden space. That's super exciting. Community gardens are so important, especially when we're going to have more people living in apartments, right? Like having places for them to grow their own food is incredible. Lincoln Park expansion, yeah, can't wait for that. And then this growth opportunity, I want to mention, I know people have feelings about the turning lanes. I do too. What I will say is we're building for what we have now, right, which is like lots of cars, but we also are building something that can flex in the future, which could be bus rapid transit, which could be exclusive bike lanes. So I do want to just give a little glimmer of hope there. And then also the new parking spots are going to be really important. Again, some of these residents will have vehicles. that's just the nature of living in Maine and so we're going to need resident parking spaces we'll also need parking for customers of the businesses that are going to want to move into these places so super excited about all that all right here's the three things I want to see I would love marginal way to have exclusive pedestrian phase that's when pedestrians like you see this sometimes in big cities around the world where all the cars have to stop and all the pedestrians can go I would love that for marginal way I think it would make it much safer that's just me wanting to be a traffic engineer when I grow up but I think it seems like a good idea and then I would implore main DOT and the city to consider really hardcore block the box rules for that intersection whatever it takes I don't care if it's like bright yellow paint crisscross whatever traffic enforcement and then I would also consider no turn on red for the entire stretch. And I would love to see LPIs, which are leading pedestrian intervals, that gives the pedestrian a head start, at every single crossing as well. I do like that the crossings are shorter, but I still think that for people like me with little legs who aren't even five feet, we need a little bit more time. And so an LPI at every single crossing would be great. Thank you for the honor of so much time to speak. I will be quiet, enthusiastically supporting moving this tonight. Thank you, everybody. Thank you, Council. Council Graham. [1:54:52] Benjamin Grant: So, unlike my colleague, I do not want to be a traffic engineer when I grow up. So, I'm going to speak in some more broad terms, but lead to the same result, which is enthusiastic support and urging my colleagues to support this. So, first, I want to commend a few people. First, there are several folks, including some here who have worked on this for a couple of decades. And I really appreciate that dogged determination of citizens to affect change. Your voices are definitely heard and respected here at the Horseshoe. I want to also commend staff. I think Councillor Bullett did a really good job describing why. I would just add the evidence of your great work is in the array of support we've heard from here tonight. Everything from the Chamber of Commerce to a public school schoolteacher to someone who lives abutting the street. That's an impressive bit of work to coalesce that broad swath of people here in town, so commend you for that work as well. Wendy spoke briefly earlier at the mic and could have been looking over my shoulder, stealing my notes. One of the things that drives me here is not just the people who live here, but the people who don't and I think that's a really great way to phrase a project like this our job is to look after the citizens who are here but also the future of the city and provide a place and a community for more people to come enjoy the place that we all know and love so I certainly second those sentiments and then lastly I know councillor Philip Soffing gives me the raised eyebrow when I go into metaphor mode but I'm going to use another other metaphor here since director craft raised fenway park in his talk you know a lot of what we do here on the council is hit singles right we deal with small issue after smallest issue after small issue and that's great that's a lot of the work that we love to do but i'm here and what drives me in part is every once in a while we've got to swing for the fences and this is maybe the most important project that the city will entertain for a long time coming so i think we have to be able to do both so if you'll indulge my baseball metaphor i'll end there and encourage that we support this plan thank you anyone [1:57:18] Speaker Q (unidentified): else right council pellet i'll keep this brief i largely agree with basically everything counselor grant said as well as counselor bullet it i think wendy really did a good job of summing up sort of where we are and i will toss my hat in real quick to get rid of the medians and look forward to opportunities to do so going for going forward in this project but you know staff's work on this really has to be commended working through multiple councils working through a lot of very strongly held opinions about this and that is not i don't think it's a thankless job but it's close so thank you and i am very excited to support this council [1:58:12] Kate Sykes: sex thank you mayor i think this is terrific and i'm really glad that we got to squeak this under my last voting meeting so that i can vote for this i do just have one question for planning I raised this question when we talked in your office about the plan, and I expressed a little bit of concern about the intermodal connection between the ferries and Commercial Street on the south end of Franklin, and I just am curious, I actually was not able to get to the committee meeting, S&T, and I just wonder, has Casco Bay Lines actually evaluated this in terms of future expansion of the ferries? I know that they are already discussing, first of all, they have a 50% increase in vessel capacity for human beings and a 25% vessel increase for cars, but they're already dealing with a finite amount of queuing space on the land side. And so just to avoid having those cars backing up onto Franklin and Commercial Street potentially, I just am curious if you've had that discussion and what fail-safes exist for us to be able to change the plan if we needed to if that expansion due to those due to those expansions or any sort of ferry related traffic surges might arise so if staff could just answer that question for me before i vote i would love to hear that answer thank [1:59:37] Bruce Hyman (Transportation Program Manager): you for the thank you for the question i'm bruce hyman the transportation program manager i'll jump to the close the fail safe is the or the next several phases of design that we'll be going through while we haven't, during this phase, specifically engaged with Casco Bay Lines directly. They've attended some of our meetings, provided some online comments. We have checked in with the waterfront coordinator related to the visioning process that's going on for the main state pier. I know they're coordinating very closely with Casco Bay Lines since they're an abutter to it and several of the businesses we've gotten some really good feedback from Heather the new waterfront coordinator and we will certainly be taking that to heart in the next design phase and that's a very flexible that's probably the most flexible location along the project area within us to respond to that sort of direct input as we as things move along through the process [2:00:42] Kate Sykes: Thank you for your support. [2:00:45] Mark Dion: Elsa McNavish. Thank you, Mayor. [2:00:50] Speaker N (unidentified): Like some of my colleagues, I've been aware of and involved in and following this for over a decade now. This was one of the first things that I paid attention to when I got involved in city issues. It's been a really incredible process. Where it's landed, there's a lot of good things about it. but, and I do want to thank the community who has stuck with it and has reached out and continued to advocate for what they think is the right thing to do, and I also really want to thank the people who have spoken up for things that didn't necessarily make it and who were willing to describe how things affect their lives, people who live near the near the site, and, you know, sometimes those are the people who get left out, ironically. I'm really excited about the expansion of the garden, the Boy Street Garden. I think that's just a really, it's a really important thing to have for, you know, at a lot of units, you need a backyard, you need a place for people to carry out the activities that make urban living a little bit less a little softer and the parking i you know i know we all want to move toward a fewer cars in the city that but parking it just it's necessary i hear a lot of businesses who are losing customers because there just isn't any or we're losing parking in areas where we want to increase retail growth so some of that is necessary the piece that I just said it's never I've never gotten to a place of satisfaction with is the is the removal of the trees I there as Dr. Kraft said there's no version of this that ends without getting rid of some of the trees however I think there's a little bit of at least I was a little bit confused about which trees and where and how many and my understanding at this point and Dr. Dr. Kraft can speak to this perhaps, is that the trees on the west side of the street are not planned to be removed. They are, you know, that's not the side that will be built out. And so there's the potential to keep quite a few of them. The ones in the middle, not so much. And that's a problem. Some of the speakers have talked about this, but the economic benefit, the environmental benefit, the heat island remediation that those trees deliver, it's not going to be replicated by saplings. So to that end, what I'm hoping to see going forward is, and this is going to be sort of a direct ask, is for there to be an environmental study of what benefit we're deriving from the existing green space and trees, what we will lose by the ones that get clear-cut, and how long it's going to take us to get back to that baseline of carbon sequestration or you know management of runoff whatever factors are relevant and if possible to go beyond that and I think this is where that you know the medians I know that's been a controversial point for a lot of people but that is an opportunity not only for trees to make up for what's being removed but also trees do work as traffic calming when they mature enough to cover the lanes a little bit and tree relocation this is I think this is something where we may be able to save some of the trees in the median if there are trees in the areas that are not going to be cut down that are that are perhaps diseased can we relocate trees from the center to there I know that's That can be an expensive and sometimes a low ROI endeavor, but I think it is important that we try to relocate trees where we can and we have some time in which to look for funding to make some of that happen. So that's my ask. So that we not only restore the street grid and create better connectivity and heal, but go a little bit beyond that and make sure that the quality of life that this neighborhood has in terms of the amount of trees and green space is equitable. That's the bottom line of all of this is that creating Franklin Street caused a great deal of inequity. This is a chance to restore that equity. [2:06:01] Pious Ali: Councilor Ali. Thank you, Emilio. I first want to thank those who have been working on this for several years. It used to be once you get elected to the council, you receive a phone call from my dear friend, Marcus Miller, and then you will take a walk. And I've done that walk over and over with him. And I appreciate his continuous advocacy for this project. project. A few years ago, myself and then citizen, now Councillor Phillips, were tasked to find a name, to name Franklin Arturia as Mount Luther King Boulevard. And I had a very interesting but sad meeting with a group of people whose parents, or probably grandparents, parents were the ones who lost their homes. That was turned into Franklin Arteria and they pleaded with me and said please don't attach Dr. King's name to this. But I'm sure that if they are watching tonight they'll be proud of what we are planning to do and so I will be supporting this. I was going to ask a question but then my colleague made it easy who knows about how to relocate trees well how to relocate trees I want to ask a few questions you [2:07:33] Mark Dion: need to come up to the microphone please thank you [2:07:41] Pious Ali: know I have had conversation with two people some of them are worried about the trees and I am too and some of them think that something can be done and I want to have this on a record. Is it possible to relocate the trees? We have relocated house, a whole house here at Kennedy Parkside neighborhood before in the past about 20 years ago so can we do the same with trees? Is it possible to give us an estimate if some of the trees the ones that it is possible to be relocated how much is gonna cost no not right now oh no I'm not gonna do that to you I also [2:08:31] Speaker AF (unidentified): want to go home so I can give a quick example at Evergreen Cemetery we pulled the quote for moving seven smaller fir trees from a planting, just moving them roughly about 40 feet closer to Stevens Avenue for an evergreen buffer, and the price for that, which logistically in the sense of moving large trees is very simple, the price for moving the seven trees there was between $140,000 and $170,000. [2:09:05] Pious Ali: Kim is it possible to share a memo with this council on how many trees can be relocated on Franklin okay that's all I need thank you very much I think we cannot clap right somebody's clapping for me and I said we cannot clap yeah Oh, for him? Okay. Hey, we cannot clap. I'm doubling what I said. And then I lost the second part of my question, but I'm going to support this tonight, and it's exciting to see. Oh, during the next phase of this, can we do any more, because of the tree issue, can we do any more public kind of engagement with stakeholders? [2:09:56] Mark Dion: holders? We'll direct that question to the director. I have an answer but it should come from him. Okay. [2:10:03] Kevin Kraft (Director of Planning): Councilor, yes the next phase would still have engagement. This obviously sets the framework of what we're trying to achieve but many of the things we're hearing here tonight there would be opportunities for additional engagement to see how the plans are refined. Thank [2:10:15] Pious Ali: you. City Manager, today I'm questioning everyone. City Manager, is it public that we have somebody that is supposed to do civic and community engagement for the city yes we do counselor and we make this the number one on the item that they [2:10:33] Speaker G (unidentified): have to start working on she's going to have a potential learning curve and a period of time where she needs to get her feet on the ground but we will definitely have projects in front of her [2:10:43] Pious Ali: within the next year thank you to the two people that met with me i did what i said i'm to do. Thank you. [2:10:53] Speaker H (unidentified): Councilor Phillips. You knew that was coming, didn't you? Yes. I really don't have that much to add. I'm not sure who in this room is from Portland, but I am in Portland, and I see my sister here, Senator Rachel Talbot Ross. We grew up in Portland. I've lived here pretty much my whole life, except for when I went away to college. I remember the old Franklin Street, and I remember the houses. I also remember, I was very young, but I also remember My parents having discussions about what would happen if the 295, Franklin Arterial was built, and all of the people and all the uproar that happened in the city. And unfortunately, as we know, it still went through. And here we are, Jesus, I'm 64. Here we are, probably 50 years later, sitting here trying to reimagine Franklin Arterial to the way it was before. Here's the deal. It should have never happened. I'm so grateful for not only Marcos Miller, but I'm seeing Wendy Cherubini in the back there. And along with other people, I had that walk with Councillor Ali, with Wendy, who was just as passionate. And I'm sure that there were other folks behind Marcos and Wendy that were just as passionate about this. They seem to be the two people that were on the forefront of this, having all of that information. So I want to make sure that we also recognize Wendy on that. And also for their passion and advocacy for this, because this was painful. It was very, painful not only to the people that lived in that area but the people that were living here. Again my family being one of them and so I really truly appreciate people bringing this forward. I know that I constantly thank Kevin in the planning department and don't necessarily recognize his staff and also the people behind this project and so for that, I apologize. I know Bruce has been working really hard on this, and so has Nell, so has Mike and Ethan and everybody else that you mentioned, along with MDOT. And so I'm just grateful that we are able to bring our city back to a place that it used to look like and where we were welcoming people for wherever they were. [2:13:07] Mark Dion: Anyone else? I spoke about the trees over at lunch before meeting with such vigor that one of my colleagues was afraid I was going to torpedo the whole project to save the trees. I have been persistent about trees for the six years I've been on the council. You've heard data points and policy questions, but I always thought the human scale of any neighborhood can be measured by the non-humans in the space, which are trees. That's what makes us feel connected. I know there's a chance of having a bunch of saplings. I saved one 40 years ago. Now it has quite a canopy. And I remind myself that the beauty of trees is not for you to enjoy, but make sure someone who's not here yet literally will enjoy their shade. And I understand the equity issues with Bayside's experience by not having access to that. So I want to thank Director Crabb who allowed me for an hour to vent about trees with him and my expectation as an individual counselor and I take him as his word as the staff's work will move forward will help us to answer those questions but I don't want to stand in the way of what I think is a really important project but you want to take up the baseball metaphor here's what I'll use on base percentage tonight it feels like a home run I don't think it is it feels that way but the reality is Kevin is you and your staff hit a single every single day and you get on base and you were welcomed on base by the community leaders who played their role in the game so yeah I often say, an overnight success takes about five years. Winning a pennant looks like it took 20, but you got there one base at a time. I want to make one final note to the community. Oftentimes we get for feedback that the evil city staff controls everything at City Hall, that we're just minions in their machine. If we could only wake up to that reality, we could take control and do what's necessary for the public interest I think this initiative over a decade is evidence that staff acts in the best interest of the community and we are fortunate counselors that we can ratify that work and that partnership that they've established among our community residents so staff does do good work even when we're not paying attention, right? And we sit here and we can congratulate ourselves collectively for that effort. So I know where the congratulations should be directed. I'm looking at them, all right? And it's my pleasure as a counselor to ratify that effort and validate the fact that staff does work with our city residents, does work for the best interests of Portland, and they always are simply looking for us, Councilors, to support that effort and approve of it whenever we have an opportunity. If there are no other comments, I'm going to call for the vote. Seeing none, all those in favor of passing Resolves 626-27 signify by hand. Passes unanimously. We'll take that. That feels good for them, because usually I would call you to order and say we don't take any kind of behavior that way but i'll grant some latitude with that clerk will now read [2:17:08] Danielle West: resolve 7 26 27. resolve 7 26 27 recommending tariff amendment to prohibit open loop exhaust gas cleaning system scrubber dischargers at city-owned marine terminals sponsored by Councillor Regina Phillips and Councillor Pius Ali. [2:17:27] Mark Dion: Thank you. Chair would ask for comment from both councillors starting with Councillor Phillips. Thank [2:17:33] Speaker H (unidentified): you Mr. Mayor. I'm again very excited to bring this forward. We have been having some conversations about scrubber wash and what to do with them for quite a while and so really again this is another project that has been moved forward from our community and so I want to check I want to thank Joanne Lochtiff I know she's in here she's right there and all anybody else who had a hand in moving this forward basically what we're asking tonight is for the city manager we're asking for a resolution on this for us to not have vessels discharge their scrubber wash in our Bay and so I'll let councilor Ali make some comments as well. [2:18:19] Pious Ali: I thank you Councillor and Mayor I want to thank community members who did most of the work and advocated it for this for almost two to three years now and then Corporation Council and other staff members who work with us to put this together and I'm looking forward to discussing this with my colleagues. Thank you Councillor. Possibly passing it to tonight. [2:18:43] Mark Dion: The chair would now entertain public comment on this resolve. Is this a repeat performance? [2:18:53] Public Commenters (Resident, Ian Jacob): This is not a repeat. There's no cars involved, so... Or street parking. Okay. Ian Jacob, State Street. I watch the cruise ships all summer long when they come in. I actually pin the schedule on my fridge from my place on State Street. I see them coming and going, and often am disappointed that they are actually polluting our wonderful Casco Bay while they're here. So I think this is a step in the right direction and I fully support this moving forward and encourage every Councillor here and the Mayor to do so as well. Thank you. [2:19:37] Mark Dion: I go above now. [2:19:40] Public Commenter (Susanna Richer): Good evening my name is This is Susanna Richer, I live in East Deering. I'm here tonight to thank Councilors Phillips and Ali for their sponsorship of the proposed resolve. Supporting environmental goals similar to port electrification, this common sense proposal would protect Portland's air, water, and residents from toxic cruise ship pollutants without requiring investment in infrastructure or costing taxpayers a dime. As you may already know, air scrubbers eliminate sulfur dioxide by mixing it with seawater and then discharging it back into the ocean. The discharge wastewater contains acidic pollutants that can be harmful to marine life and to the ocean. For decades, my household depended on income from Portland's commercial fishing industry. We experienced firsthand the financial and community devastation that occurs from not prioritizing long-term sustainability over short-term gain at the expense of our natural resources. In the mid-1990s, a depleted fish population due to overfishing forced difficult late-in-life career changes for our household and many others. The government offered retraining, created restrictive fishing regulations, and purchased boats from fishermen in an effort to restore and protect the seafood industry that Portland relies on and that attracts tourists to our city. Though painful at the time, these aggressive restorative efforts paid off and our fishing stock began to recover. However, we cannot survive another attempt to rebuild the already struggling fishing industry. Today we face potentially irreversible threats to our water, air and health in the form of pollution. By allowing the dumping of pollution into our water, we allow risks to our already struggling working waterfront. What would happen to Portland if our working waterfront ceased to exist? Currently scrubbers enable cruise ships to burn cheaper fuel. The air scrubbers would not be needed if the ships used higher quality fuel, which most already carry. This change has been made in other states and municipalities without any reduction to cruise ship tourism. The proposed ban holds the cruise ship industry accountable without costing Portland residents a dime and without reducing any revenue produced by cruise ship tourism it also protects the bay that brings tourists here to begin with which in turn ensures our long-term viability as a cruise ship destination why wouldn't we do this the fact that california connecticut washington and other communities have successfully executed limitations on scrubber use 30 seconds discharge is a sign that portland can and should follow suit thank you in advance for your consideration and support of this beneficial proposal anyone on the floor [2:22:24] Mark Dion: wishing to provide public comment. [2:22:31] Public Commenter (Lissa): Good evening mayor and city councilors. My name is Lissa. I live in the east end and I work in marine conservation. I'm speaking as a resident of Portland, not as a representative of my organization. I'm here this evening to urge the council to support this measure. Portland has a rich maritime history. People who make their living on the water have long called this place home and what happens to our water directly impacts our way of life. When ships run scrubbers in our port, they are taking the pollutants destined for the smokestack, particulate matter, nitrates, sulfates, mercury, zinc, lead, and cancer-causing polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, or PAHs, and rerouting them to the ocean instead. Scrubbers don't make the nasty stuff disappear, they just move it out of sight. But the ocean is not out of sight for us. We are a community that relies on our waterfront and destroying it is simply not an option. Portland Harbor is part of an estuary which means that our water alkalinity is low to begin with and less of the acidity of toxic wash water is neutralized, making us even more vulnerable to these toxins than other places. PAHs and heavy metals are discharged via scrubber wash water into Casco Bay where they concentrate and accumulate in sediments and in phytoplankton. That matters for us because those toxins in scrubber wash don't biodegrade, they bioaccumulate. Which means when phytoplankton is eaten by zooplankton, is eaten by forage fish, and forage fish are eaten by tuna, cod, haddock, bluefish, and striper, they get more and more toxic with every meal. Not only does this hurt our fish, it also threatens our shellfish. Scrubber wash water is up to a hundred thousand times more acidic than the surrounding ocean, bringing the pH level of Casco Bay down and reducing the concentration of carbonate ions in our water. The same carbonate ions that our oysters, our mussels, and our clams use to build their shells. No shells means no shellfish. A ship that cleans its air by fouling our water hasn't solved a problem. It has picked the place that hurts us most, to put it. It's like cleaning your house and emptying your trash into the pantry. Do you really want to eat from there? But what I want to focus on is that we don't have to choose between clean air and clean water. We can have both. Only if we act to make it so. So I urge the council to support this measure. The ocean is our lifeline, and we cannot stand to lose it thank you for your time and your service to our city anyone [2:25:18] Mark Dion: above wishing to speak on this order hello my name is Steve you can adjust it if it works better for you okay my name is Steve Carroll I'm a [2:25:33] Public Commenter (Portland Resident): Portland resident I'll be very short I want to thank counselors Aldi and Phillips for bringing this resolution forward basically I think this is a common-sense no-brainer situation if ships come to our city I feel that they should we should at the very least expect that they're not going to pollute our waters and our ecosystems on a very basic level if I invite guests to my home I don't allow them to throw garbage in the front yard and so I would I hope that we will support and pass this resolution and show respect and pride in our community, our ecosystems. Thank you very much for your consideration and passing this resolution. [2:26:15] Mark Dion: Anyone on the floor wishing to provide a comment? [2:26:22] Public Commenter (Sydney Harris): Hi. Mr. Mayor, members of the City Council, thank you for the opportunity to testify this evening. My name is Sydney Harris. I live in Woodford's Corner and I spend as much time as possible in and on and around Casco Bay every summer. I'm here tonight to urge you to support this resolve prohibiting open loop scrubber discharge in our ports. I agree with the prior commenter this is a common-sense proposal that has already been implemented in major cities around the country from Washington State all the way to Florida. You have an opportunity to make Portland the first port in Maine to keep toxic scrubber waste out of our harbors, something I was very disappointed to learn we don't already do. I'm a marine scientist by training, and I'm just here as an individual tonight, but I also lead a statewide volunteer coalition, which we just converted into a non-profit called Reuse Maine, which works to eliminate single-use packaging and foodware by replacing them with reusable alternatives. We all know how damaging it is when trash enters our waterways, but that's That's just one part of the story, right? Our volunteers for Reuse Maine and many local businesses that have partnered with us in Portland and beyond put in dedicated effort to build reuse systems with us because they prevent marine debris. They care about Casco Bay and that's one way that they can act to protect it, but we already ban gray water, black water, dirty ballast discharge, and we're undermining these efforts and the efforts of all our volunteers working on marine debris prevention by allowing scrubber discharge. This measure is crucial for protecting Casco Bay and it won't stop the cruise ships from coming as we've heard and seen increased cruise traffic and other ports with the same protections in place. So I ask you to vote yes on this resolve. Thank you very much. [2:28:20] Mark Dion: Anyone above wishing to provide comment on this order? [2:28:34] Public Commenter (Sue Anderson): I AM SUE ANDERSON. I LIVE ON DORIS STREET IN PORTLAND. THANK YOU MAYOR AND COUNCILORS FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE TONIGHT. THANK YOU SO MUCH COUNCILOR PHILLIPS, COUNCILOR ALI FOR BRINGING THIS VERY IMPORTANT RESOLUTION TO OUR CITY. AND THANK YOU TO ALL THE FELLOW CITIZENS WHO HAVE BEEN SO ACTIVE ON THIS FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS NOW. I REALLY APPRECIATE IT. I EARNED THIS RESOLUTION FROM MY HUSBAND. you all to vote for this resolution. It's just it's such a no-brainer. Toxic wastewater has no place in our oceans. Harming our ecosystem harms all of us. It harms our future. Please pass this resolution for a brighter future for all of us and I urge you also to think about what oversight will be for this. Thank [2:29:28] Mark Dion: Anyone here on the floor wishing to provide comment? [2:29:38] Thomas O'Boyle (Portland Regional Chamber): Good evening again, Thomas O'Boyle from the Portland Regional Chamber. The Chamber supports the environmental and sustainable goals behind this resolution. Protecting Casco Bay is important to our environment, our waterfront, and the long-term health of our local economy. We believe these goals can be achieved while continuing to welcome cruise ships to Portland, an industry that, according to a new report today, supports around 300 jobs and generates roughly $22 million in city spending in 2025. But we would also encourage the city to give careful consideration to how the proposed restrictions will work in practice. Seattle has been cited as a model for this type of ban and it offers a useful precedent. Seattle also has shore power infrastructure at all three of its cruise berths. This allows ships to plug into the electricity grid and shut down the auxiliary engines, giving cruise ship operators an additional way to reduce emissions and meet environmental requirements while alongside. side currently portland doesn't have that capability and the state is still assessing its feasibility that doesn't mean we should wait for shore power before addressing scrubber discharges but we should recognize that portland isn't starting from the same position as seattle we need to make sure vessels have clear and practical ways to comply with the requirements put forward so while the chamber supports the environmental objectives of this resolution we believe any restriction should be contingent on the city working with cruise operators and relevant authorities to establish how vessels with different scrubber systems can adhere to the proposed rules and how compliance will be monitored and enforced. Thank you for your time. [2:31:09] Mark Dion: Anyone above wishing to provide comment? On the floor, anyone else wishing to provide comment on this proposed order? [2:31:23] Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): Steven Sharper, Brackett Street. I need to ask some questions here because I'm not fully understanding what the process you're you're passing a resolution to change a tariff and so what is the process going forward that tariff gets changed and I don't believe it even can be changed instantly I think it's a process that goes on because the tariff gets changed on an annual basis nobody sat and explained what you're going to be doing, what this resolution calls for. It's just a resolution that was popped up and told to us, posted for people to comment on and everybody's all excited about coming on how wonderful Portland will be after you pass this resolution. I don't think it's going to make all that much difference personally. separately though is that you may be passing a resolution that bans scrubbers but you may be passing a resolution that bans all cruise ships that want to do scrubbing and thus the business that the Portland Port relies on in this cruise ship industry so you may get what you want but you may not want what you get, thank you [2:32:50] Mark Dion: Anyone else wishing to provide comment on this proposed order? Public comment is closed. Wait. Okay, I didn't see you. Sorry. Go ahead. It's not closed. [2:33:03] Public Commenters (Shoshana Hose, Marianne Butts): Give us your name. My name is Marianne Butts. I live on [street]. I am a fifth-generation Portland girl. My family did not, their house did not get raised, but my family lives on [street], and we just recently sold it to the church. I learned so much tonight. I've been receiving emails from Joanne Locklear and I'm astounded by even the international support that she's been able to garnish in terms of science. I urge the City Council and the Mayor to please listen to that. It's solid evidence. I also know that the comments from the other previous resolution is closed but I wanted to tell you, Director Kraft, that you make Old School Portlanders really proud. It's very obvious the work that you've done and I remember the argument going back, you know, since way before I was born and it is no small feat what you've done and also the community. I know some of you are new here and sometimes we don't like that but you've made you've made me proud again to be a Portland girl and you should be proud of yourselves too and lastly I want to thank Joanne Locklear for her incredible efforts on and everybody that spoke tonight again I learned even more and I'm very appreciative and I fully support the [2:34:36] Speaker G (unidentified): ban and I hope you do as well thank you all right I'm going to try it one more [2:34:43] Mark Dion: time is there anyone else wishing to provide comment on this order in the balcony or below going once going twice all right public comment period is closed mr. [2:35:06] Speaker G (unidentified): mayor I just wanted to jump in a couple of questions at the end and I don't know, the city attorney may have to correct me, but the resolution specifically calls on the city manager to amend the tariff. And so if the council passes this tonight, I believe the next step would be to amend it to reflect what the council has passed this evening. So that would be the step. And with regard to specifically impacting any cruise ships that we have that come into port, I'm looking at Ethan. I don't believe this would impact them. Is that correct, Ethan? [2:35:43] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): That's correct. Could you identify yourself? Ethan Hipple, director of Parks, Rec and Facilities Department. We manage the cruise terminal. Yeah, and we have had some communications about any potential impacts with existing, because ships have already booked for 2027. We're not aware of any ships that would be negatively impacted by this. They have other fuel sources they can burn. and in all cases that we're aware of they're already burning that clean fuel [2:36:10] Speaker G (unidentified): so okay that's what I thought so they're already burning that fuel so this wouldn't impact them so I think that answers both of the questions thank you [2:36:18] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): yep I should amend that they're either burning the clean fuel or they're using a closed-loop scrubber which does not emit emissions that have been thank you [2:36:28] Mark Dion: city manager corporation council any comment on the tariff question on the [2:36:33] Speaker AM (unidentified): The procedural issues, I think Danielle just addressed those, but tonight the council is voting on a resolution requesting that the city manager amend the tariff. The changes to the tariff language have historically been done as an operational administrative process. I would defer to Ethan on sort of how they get republished, but it's something that we do make changes from time to time without council approval tonight is a little bit different because it's a specific change being requested by the council does that answer your question thank you corporation council sure [2:37:13] Mark Dion: all right any comments from the council itself council [2:37:21] Speaker Q (unidentified): pelleter i also want to thank you and Ali for bringing this forward I agree this is pretty no-brainer and it's overdue but I'm very glad it's here and I do really want to again thank Joanne Locktove and Portland Cruise Control for really tireless advocacy and work around this it would not we would not be here tonight without their work. So I think that's very much worth acknowledging and want to thank them. [2:37:57] Mark Dion: Thank you, Councilor. Any other comments? All right, then. Go ahead, Councilor Sykes. [2:38:05] Kate Sykes: So do we actually have records of the type of, the records of the type of fuel that a cruise ship burns? Is that something that the city has access to? Good [2:38:21] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): question. That's information we don't currently collect when a ship gets berthing space in Portland. We recently did a survey to collect that information from the ships that have come here for 2025, and that's something we can continue with as part of the normal booking process. [2:38:41] Kate Sykes: I'm just asking, would it be advisable? I'm asking the committee members and fellow councilors, would it be advisable to add this to the resolution that we would request that the city do that as a matter of course, and maybe that is in revising the tariff agreement. I'm not sure where that information would go, but it seems like it would go in that tariff agreement. It seems like we need to know what kind of fuel they're burning. [2:39:10] Mark Dion: Director Hippel, are you aware whether or not the United States Coast Guard Marine Safety Office for the Port of Portland collects that information? [2:39:19] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): I don't. No, they don't. [2:39:21] Mark Dion: You know that for a fact? [2:39:23] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): Well, the Coast Guard does play an enforcement role, but they're enforcing federal rules and so if this is a local rule no i understand it's a local rule but the nature of the fuel i don't believe they are but we can we can double check yeah so i'm [2:39:40] Mark Dion: going to introduce an amendment what i was going to suggest council slags i think the question of fuel grade appears to have been shifting i don't know if we want an amendment it's up to the body to determine that or does the question about fuel classification exist as notice to staff to take a look at as they form the tariff I'd like to [2:40:04] Kate Sykes: propose a motion to add to the resolution is this the appropriate time may I do this no okay thank you I propose that the resolved be amended to include the following be a further resolved that the City Council requests the City Manager to seek scrubber wash operation and discharge records from commercial vessels using City-owned marine terminals, including records identifying whether scrubber wash water was discharged while birthed, and to report the findings to the City Council together with recommendations for obtaining such information on an ongoing basis through legally permissible terminal use requirements. [2:40:39] Speaker AM (unidentified): That's my motion. Before we go on, can I jump in real quick? We don't have a main motion yet on the floor. And so I gather what you're offering is an amendment, but we first need the main motion. [2:40:56] Mark Dion: I'll ask for a main motion because I had a question on the amendment. Move by Councillor Phillips, seconded by Councillor Ali. Going back to discussion. I want to ask Councillor Sykes, who are you proposing to do all this clerical work? [2:41:14] Kate Sykes: It sounds like it's largely being done anyway, but I'm asking for this to be introduced into the resolution so that it's clear that the council supports this. [2:41:23] Mark Dion: Director Hipple, do you have staff that's going to be prepared to do this or is it better to make an inquiry with the Federals to determine if they've already done the work? [2:41:40] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): Yeah, I mean we can certainly check what the federal, you know, the Coast Guard enforcement capabilities are. We do have very limited staff managing this operation. We have two full-time staff that manage this and that you know, so yeah It's it's gonna be pretty limited what we can what we can do with existing resources [2:42:00] Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): Thank you. Yeah [2:42:02] Mark Dion: Is it she's proposed an amendment councillor Sykes. Is there a second? All right discussion on the amendment [2:42:12] Speaker P (unidentified): Go ahead council board. Sorry to do this councillor Sykes. Do you mind reading it again? So I can listen. No problem [2:42:18] Kate Sykes: So, be it further resolved that the City Council request the City Manager to seek scrubber operation and discharge records from commercial vessels using city-owned marine terminals, including records identifying whether scrubber wash water was discharged while berthed, and to report the findings to the City Council, together with recommendations for obtaining such information on an ongoing basis through legally permissible terminal use requirements. [2:42:42] Speaker P (unidentified): Go ahead, Councilman Boyle. Thanks, that was really helpful, and I do think that's a very good idea. I also recognize staff limitations on time. It's something I'm always cognizant of. Mayor, if you don't mind, I see that the harbormaster is here, and I wonder if he would have any other source of information for this kind of thing. You can ignore me if you want. Okay, thank you. So I would propose maybe that we do something in committee that might help the department have the staff capacity for this, But I do really worry about staff capacity at the at the waterfront and at Ocean Gateway for this kind of work [2:43:28] Mark Dion: Councilor Sykes. I have a question. Are you proposing this moving forward without a look back? [Kate Sykes: Correct. Okay.] I Just wanted to be sure in my mind. That's all Any other discussion of the amendment? [2:43:43] Speaker H (unidentified): Councilor Phillips. Oh, thank you. Mr. Mayor. I 'm not sure where to go on this, because I do hear what you're saying, but I also hear what the director is saying, which is that we know at this point in time that nobody is discharging scrubbers at this point in time. So, although I am supportive of it, I'm not sure if it does us any good or gives us any more information. And maybe I'm just not understanding the amendment. [2:44:13] Kate Sykes: I appreciate that. that I just, I don't think, this speaks to enforcement, and I think we're being told that we know that the scrubber wash discharge isn't happening, but if we can't collect that information and we're not collecting it going forward, then it's sort of an enforcement issue for me. [2:44:33] Benjamin Grant: Councilor Grant. A question for Corporate Council. It's my understanding, correct me if I'm wrong, that this is likely to be preempted in the near future, so devoting staff to that type of enforcement may be ultimately much to do about nothing. in this matter of months. [2:44:55] Speaker AM (unidentified): So, yes, Councillor. The federal law at issue that has been discussed at the committee meetings and that you're referring to, it's called the Vessel Incidental Discharge Act. Under that act, the Coast Guard is in the process of rulemaking. The rulemaking was supposed to be complete in October. It's not complete yet. once it has been completed it will preempt and this is something that was discussed at the committee level something that I know the friends of Casco Bay have weighed in on and have agreed with same thing with officials from I believe it was DEP that was at the committee meetings that also weighed in on this issue but yes it was the local tariff this rule in the tariff will eventually be preempted once those Coast Guard rules go into effect. Whether or not we get voluntary compliance is another issue. [2:45:54] Benjamin Grant: But at that point, if that does happen, the Coast Guard would be the enforcement entity? [2:46:00] Speaker AM (unidentified): Under the new rules, yes, I believe so. So we haven't seen, you know, I haven't, the final draft doesn't exist yet, but yeah. [2:46:08] Benjamin Grant: So if I can just finish with a comment. I mean, I raise that question not as a reason to oppose this. I think we need to make a strong statement about our value of Casco Bay. But in terms of this amendment and burdening staff, it seems like maybe an expense we don't need to engage in. Maybe review it next year once we know the result of this rulemaking. So those are just my comments. You probably see where I'm headed with my vote on this. [2:46:36] Mark Dion: ANY OTHER COMMENTS ON THE AMENDMENT? [2:46:43] Speaker Q (unidentified): SO ESSENTIALLY, IF WE PASS THIS WITHOUT THE AMENDMENT, WE JUST SORT OF HAVE TO TAKE THE SHIP'S WORD AT IT THAT THEY ARE USING OR THEY ARE NOT USING THE SCRIBBLERS? [2:47:00] Speaker AM (unidentified): WITH OR WITHOUT THE AMENDMENT? YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT AFTER? [Mark Dion: WITHOUT AN AMENDMENT.] Sure, yeah. Without an amendment, there is language in there. The language that's in the revised draft of the tariff that's included in the backup is language that's taken from the Seattle tariff. There's been references tonight to Seattle's tariff. And so the language in here is very similar to the language that's in the Seattle tariff, and it does require the reporting by the cruise ships of discharges. So [2:47:35] Speaker Q (unidentified): I guess this amendment is just asking them to say what fuel they're asking, right, or using, right? [2:47:39] Speaker AM (unidentified): It doesn't ask them specifically what fuel they're burning. I think the presumption is if they're using scrubbers, they're not burning the clean fuel. And I know just enough about cruise ship fuel to be dangerous, but is that right, Ethan? Ethan's nodding. Right, so if they're using scrubbers, they're not burning the clean fuel. If they're burning the clean fuel, they're not using scrubbers. [2:47:58] Speaker Q (unidentified): So that clerical somebody's doing the clerical work as it is right to establish whether or not the Cruise ship is using or not using discover and record that [2:48:09] Speaker AM (unidentified): Somebody from the cruise ship somebody from staff It I don't believe so not without asking [2:48:17] Mark Dion: That's why I was trying to find out if there alternates sure [2:48:21] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): So maybe I can help clarify so the proposed language in the revised tariff does give the city the right to ask for that information, written confirmation, not just taking word, but getting written confirmation from the cruise lines. So that is contained in this, and that's doable. That's similar to what we did this year when we surveyed the cruise lines. If we're talking about inspections and going in and verifying what scrubbers are on or off, what type of fuel is being burned, that would be like a third party service beyond our capabilities or you know expertise for our staff who are doing that job so but what's in this tariff I think does may address councillor Sykes concern because it does give the city the ability to request that information so basically a written attestation so it seems like it [2:49:15] Speaker Q (unidentified): within the scope of the amendment we're not asking for a third party we're asking basically to seek information and to ask I think this would not prevent staff from just like asking right and you know if they lie to us they lie to us but does that sound like it's within the language of the amendment basically when we ask can are you using this cover we can also say and what fuel are you using [2:49:42] Speaker AM (unidentified): i can if it's helpful i can read the language in the in the tariff is that or i guess [2:49:47] Speaker Q (unidentified): Councillor Sykes I mean so [2:49:52] Kate Sykes: I think that the tariff language addresses the issue that we can ask but it becomes a question of someone sees some cloudy water and then we ask so we don't actually really know right so I think it is more work right I think it is more work because we would have to actually regularly collect that information but it doesn't rely on you know some detective work or something that needs to happen before we decide to ask right and so i'm it is [2:50:24] Speaker Q (unidentified): hard for me to imagine it would be overburdening administrative work to just ask every ship and maybe i'm wrong maybe i don't understand but it does seem like if we were going to be doing the surveying as we've already done it's i don't feel like we're going to need a few more fdes to like send an email and say hey what you know are using the scrubber yes no what kind of fuel are you using so i'm going to be supporting this it does not i don't really understand how it could be that [2:50:51] Kate Sykes: difficult but again i'm a layman so you know perhaps we could ask the city manager what the interface is between the city and cruise ships in terms of the paperwork that they need to provide telling us about their coming into port is that is it already do we already have a loop of communication with them and this would just be added to it director yeah so good [2:51:14] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): question so and just for everybody's knowledge so i mentioned we have two staff that oversee the operation and they do everything from day of operations you know scheduling security staff longshoremen and all the associated services for the ships but they also have you know extensive communications ahead of time, verifying the size of the vessel, where it's going to line up to get passengers off the ship, making sure it fits with our existing gangways. Some ships don't fit at our, or they just don't have the right alignment with their doors to meet where our gangways are. So yes, there is back and forth. And as I said, the language that's in the tariff, in the revised language in the tariff we can do that and that's so it gives us the right to collect the information we would probably add it to either a pre you know their paperwork that they fill out ahead of time or a post visit survey you know just verifying the compliance so that's not a problem we can do that with our existing staff i think beyond going beyond that and doing investigations, that type of thing would require additional resources. I mean, it's possible, but, you know, with our existing resources, that would be not possible. [2:52:32] Kate Sykes: I'm not asking for that. I think I'm just asking for a clear record that the ship is saying we are not discharging in the harbor. I mean, it sounds like we know they're using dirty fuel if they're using a scrubber, so maybe that's even, we don't even need to know what type of fuel they're using. But I think we need something on the record that says, you know, we, I mean, I know it's their word against whatever, but like they should at least say that you're not going to do it when you come into port. [2:53:01] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): Sure. Yeah. I think I understand what, you're getting at and, you know, it's up to, you know, I know council, offered to read the section, but it may be addressed already in the language that you're about to vote on but I'd leave that up to you to [2:53:22] Mark Dion: ask corporation council answer question please does the language of the underlying resolve provide for the collection of information from the ship [2:53:39] Speaker AM (unidentified): it does it's it is the way it's written right now it's optional it says the city of portland may at its option obtained from the vessel captain owners or representatives operational records and vessel log documentation to verify compliance with this provision so the city has the as drafted the city has the option to request it all right then thank you [2:54:04] Speaker N (unidentified): alson mcnavish thank you mayor do we have a sense of when the final rulemaking will be [2:54:11] Speaker AM (unidentified): completed in any sense at all i'm i'm not sure it was supposed to happen last month the original proposal from or the original i think requirement from epa to the coast guard was that it'd be done within about two years which is where we are now so i would expect it to be fairly soon i don't know ethan have you heard any i see some heads shaking in the audience but yeah [2:54:34] Speaker N (unidentified): we don't know at this point okay question two when does cruise season start again it'll [2:54:43] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): start next spring april we've had ships as early as april coming right up okay yeah point being [2:54:50] Speaker N (unidentified): that if the rulemaking is completed before that starts then we just we spent a lot of time having a good discussion about something that may not be necessary is [2:55:04] Mark Dion: there any final word on the yes, COUNSEL PELOTIER. GO AHEAD. YOU HAVE THE FLOOR. [2:55:13] Speaker Q (unidentified): SO WE CAN'T NECESSARILY MAKE AN AMENDMENT HERE TO AMEND THE TARIFF, RIGHT, BECAUSE THAT IS PERVIOUS CITY MANAGER. YEAH, LIKE IF IT WAS ME, I WOULD JUST CHANGE THE KEN TO A WILL, BUT WE CAN'T DO THAT. so yeah I will be supporting this I would like to imagine that we will always ask for the information but we should always just be asking for the information and not have to come back later and find out that we're not that would happen but this just puts in as a place where we can look at the record and we have the record and again I don't think any of the language in the amendment is asking for you know inspector Clouseau to show up it was It's just asking them, so. [2:56:04] Mark Dion: Any other final comments on the proposed amendment? All right, then. As to the Sykes Amendment, all those in favor, please signify by hand. One, two, three, four. All those opposed? One, two, three, four. Huh? Yeah, it fails for being tied. All right. As to the main motion, Resolve 72627. All those in favor, please signify. Unanimous at 8. Clerk will now read Order 782627. [2:57:04] Danielle West: Order 782627, accepting and appropriating an additional $74,572.50 from the Land and Water Conservation Fund and improving the amendment to the sub grant between Portland and the main Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry regarding Riverton Trolley Park improvements sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. Thank you and Director [2:57:28] Speaker G (unidentified): Hippel is present this evening for any questions but these funds will be used for ongoing improvements at the Riverton Trolley Park. It's to supplement and support continued enhancement of park infrastructure and recreation features and of course as I said director Hipple's here for any questions [2:57:48] Mark Dion: Thank You city manager Chair would seek any public comment on this proposed order anyone above Seeing none on the floor. I want to make sure all right No one from the floor public comment is closed chair would seek a motion and a second for passage Move by Councillor Sykes. Second. Second by Councillor Bullett. Comment by the council. Seeing none. All those in favor signify by hand vote. Oh this is for money. My error. No it's good. Go ahead call the roll. [2:58:37] Danielle West: Councillor Grant. Yes. Councillor Sykes. Yes. Councillor Lee. Yes. Councillor Pelletier. Yes. Yes. Councillor McNavidge? Yes. Councillor Bullett? Yes. Councillor Phillips? [2:58:45] Mark Dion: Yes. Mayor Dionne? Yes. It's unanimous. All right, then. Clerk will now read Order 792627. [2:58:57] Danielle West: Order 792627, amending the conditional zone agreement regarding second amendment to the conditional rezoning agreement for property in the vicinity of St. Lawrence Arts Congress Street, sponsored by Planning Board, Joseph Samboni, Chair. [2:59:11] Speaker G (unidentified): I see that Kevin Kraft, the Director of Planning, is here for any questions representing for the Chair of the Planning Board, but you'll see in the backup materials that the Planning Board voted 6-0 to support these amendments to this conditional zone agreement. As submitted, the amendments would allow minor modifications to a previously approved improved development, replacing the Parish Hall Theater, reducing the overall proposal to a single-seat, 424-seat auditorium, and eliminate the agreement's expiration date. And Kevin, as I indicated, is here with any questions you might have. [2:59:52] Mark Dion: Thank you, City Manager. Is there any public comment on this proposed order? [3:00:03] Public Commenters (Dinah Minot, Deirdre Nice): Good evening. I'll try to make this very short. Good evening, Mayor and members of the City Council. My name is Deirdre Nice. I'm the Executive and Artistic Director of the Hill Arts, formerly St. Lawrence Arts. For more than 30 years, I've worked along with a 10-member Board of Directors, volunteer Board of Directors to preserve the historic St. Lawrence Church property and transform it into a vibrant cultural center for Portland. I'm pleased to be here tonight following the Planning Board's unanimous recommendation in support of our proposed contract zone amendment. You guys have all that information, I would just like to say in closing. I, TOO, WOULD LIKE TO GIVE A SHOUT-OUT TO CITY STAFF OVER THE LAST 32 YEARS OR 33 YEARS WORKING ON THIS PROJECT. WHEN I FIRST BEGAN, I THINK GANLEY WAS HERE, THE CITY MANAGER, GANLEY, AND SO MANY DIFFERENT COUNSELORS. BUT THE STAFF AT THE CITY OF PORTLAND, SO MANY DIFFERENT PLANNING DIRECTORS, ET CETERA, ET CETERA. THEY'VE BEEN AWESOME. [3:01:03] Mark Dion: SO THANKS SO MUCH. anyone else wishing to provide comment [3:01:09] Julia Kirby (Hill Arts Development Director): hi my name is Julia Kirby I'm the development director at the Hill Arts St. Lawrence Arts I'm also a resident of Munjoy Hill and I have been mostly since 1997 this theater adds a tremendous amount of culture and economic investment to the area to the east end of Portland to Portland and this addition of 400 seats will make a tremendous community space that's really needed in our community because it's mid-sized, it's non-profit, and it will be very accessible. So thank you Mayor, thank you City Council, and thank you to the planning staff. [3:01:45] Mark Dion: Anyone else wishing to provide comment on the proposed order? My public comment is closed. I seek a motion for passage and a second. So moved. Moved by Councillor McNavish, seconded by Councillor Lee. Council comments? [3:02:06] Speaker N (unidentified): Councilor McNavish. Thank you, Mayor. Yeah, this project has been a long time coming, and it was a good project when it was proposed. It's still a good project, and I fully support this so that we can finally someday realize the full potential of that site with the alterations that have been proposed. [3:02:28] Mark Dion: Anyone else on the council? Councilor Pelletier. [3:02:32] Speaker Q (unidentified): I lived on [street] when I first moved to Portland, and I have been waiting for this to happen for a very long time, so I imagine you have too, so assuming that we pass this, congratulations. [3:02:46] Mark Dion: Anyone else wish to comment? Councilor Phillips. [3:02:49] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I went to church at this church. I know this whole meeting has been about my history lesson but I am I will say I mean I'm from Portland I used to live on the hill when I was younger and so it's just really nice to see that instead of this being turned into housing which is something that we need that it's really being turned into something that the community can benefit from and go and I'm just really excited that you're going to be opening this up to the doors of the folks in Portland as an not odds are not please thank you any [3:03:26] Mark Dion: other comment director nice i expect to find somewhere inside that church a reference to who the original sillies was that's my only ask all right with that chair would call for a vote oh that's you know i gotta give you money that's That's why. No. No, I know. Go ahead. Councillor Grant. I know. I know. Yay. Councillor Sykes. Yes. Councillor Ali. Yay. Councillor Pelletier. Yes. Councillor McNavage. Yes. Councillor Bullett. Yay. Councillor Phillips. Yes. Mayor Dion. Yes. All right. Order prevails. You don't have to run off. You can stay for the rest of it. Clerk will now read Order 842627. [3:04:23] Danielle West: Quarter 84-26-27, accepting and appropriating a $20,000 Maine Emergency Management Agency grant sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. [3:04:33] Speaker G (unidentified): This item, staff is requesting that the second reading be waived because of timing issues, and this would allow for funding for the fire department to attend HAZMAT response trainings and the specific overtime that's required for them to do that. and so that's what this grant would be addressing thank you is there a motion in a second to wave [3:04:55] Mark Dion: second reading so moved second moved by counselor ali seconded by counselor bullet any discussion on the waiver seeing none now i'm correct it's by hand all those in favor it's unanimous any additional comment city manager no [3:05:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Mr. but you do need to get public comment you do need public comment [3:05:25] Mark Dion: you know if they'd only let me fly this plane you know oh you didn't hear that I will take public comment from the two public that are left three public okay seeing none chair would seek a motion in a second to pass as an emergency so moved okay well by councilor Boogalit seconded by councillor Ali any comments from the council at least we're having fun in passenger right I don't know all right this is a roll call now call the roll Yes. Councilor Grant? Yes. Councilor Sykes? Yes. Councilor Ali? Yes. Councilor Pelletier? Yes. Councilor Michniewicz? Yes. Councilor Bullett? Yes. Councilor Phillips? Yes. Mayor Dionne? Yes. Clerk will now read title only, 852627. [3:06:32] Danielle West: Order 852627, approving modification one to locally administered project agreement between the Maine Department of Transportation and Portland for pedestrian and bicycle safety improvements on West Commercial Street, sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. [3:06:45] Mark Dion: Thank you. Chair seeks a motion and second to waive second reading. So moved. Second. Moved by Councillor Ali, seconded by Councillor Bullett. Any comment by the council? Thank God I don't have a sergeant at arms here to control the people on the right side of this chamber, although it's spilling over to the left. [Speaker AF (unidentified): okay this] will be a vote by hand I know I'm trying to move this all those in favor please signify unanimous city manager go ahead Thank You mr. mayor [3:07:30] Speaker G (unidentified): staff was also requesting that this be passed as an emergency and director Murray waited all night for this item and he is available for any questions But this is just asking for additional monies to allow for some additional, I believe, design work to be completed. Is that correct, Mr. Murray? Yes. He is looking at me. And our share will go from $17,000 and change up to about $30,000 and change, so an increase of almost $13,000. The state and federal funding will be paying about $270,000 to allow for these bike and pedestrian safety improvements on West Commercial Street. And Director Murray is available for any questions. [3:08:14] Mark Dion: Thank you, City Manager. Is there any public comment on this proposed order? [3:08:24] Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): Stephen Sharpe of [street]. Before I get in my comments, I want to just point out that it was 20 years ago tonight that this council met until 1.30 in the morning to pass a French, I can't remember what it was, that got repealed six months later. A formula business ordinance that prohibited formula businesses from existing portaling got repealed six months later. So the fact that you're going to end about 9.15 tonight. [3:09:00] Speaker G (unidentified): They started at 7. I'll just note that for the record. [3:09:07] Mark Dion: Everyone's always so concerned how long it takes us. On average, we do it rather efficiently. [3:09:13] Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): As to the matter at hand, the proposal that is in front of you is to extend the bike and pedestrian facilities from Beach Street, excuse me, the improvement of bike and pedestrian facilities from Beach Street over to High Street, and I am fully supportive of that. As you know, I've been involved in the Bike Ped Advisory Committee for 20 years, and they have been fully supportive of doing these things and this thing sort of came up under the radar like our committee really didn't even know is on your agenda until after we last met but what I say that we fully support it I'm a little confused as to why if this is just design money why it has to get happened before the winter starts because I think all the design works to happen indoors so i'm just curious as to why it's it's being touted as an emergency [3:10:24] Mark Dion: in that way so thank you anyone else wishing to provide public comment on this order seeing none public comment is closed chair would seek a motion in a second to pass as an emergency Second. So moved. Second. Moved by Councillor Michniewicz, seconded by Councillor Ali, discussion? Seeing none, just for the record, Director Murray, why does this have to occur as an emergency? You can be brief, given the hour. [3:11:01] Speaker Q (unidentified): As the backup material states, it's for design and right-of-way work. [3:11:07] Glenn Fenton (Metro Executive Director): That's generally survey work. It's easier when the ground's clear than when there's the white stuff all around. All right. [3:11:14] Public Commenter (Stephen Sharpe): Very good. And, Councilor, thank you for the kind words. [3:11:19] Ethan Hipple (Director of Parks, Rec and Facilities): You read them just the way I wrote them, so... [3:11:26] Mark Dion: Always playing his top game, the Director. All right. Any further comment from the Council? Councilor McNavish? [3:11:36] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, so I think it was 2024 when the Bicycle Pedestrian Committee took councillors and candidates on a ride through this area. And yeah, this work is absolutely needed to create and improve the bike infrastructure there. So, oops. So, yay. [3:11:55] Mark Dion: Any other comment? Seeing none, will the clerk call the roll? Councillor Grant? Yay. Councillor Sykes? [3:12:03] Danielle West: Yes. Councillor Ali? Yes. Councillor Pelletier? Yes. Councillor Michniewicz? Yes. Councillor Bullett? Yes. Councillor Phillips? [3:12:10] Mark Dion: Yes. Mayor Dionne? Yes. The chair would seek a motion to adjourn the second. So moved. That's the most enthusiastic you've been all night, Councillor Pelletier, and a second by Councillor Bullett. All those in favor? We are adjourned.