← Back to MaineScanner

Portland Council Approves Warming Shelter Funding Amid Opioid Settlement Debate

2026-11-02 · 2h 31m · Source: City Council Meeting - November 2, 2026 (City of Portland, ME Meetings Portal)
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:34] Speaker A (unidentified): I'd like to call the council meeting to order. Can you join me in the Pledge of Allegiance? To the flag of the United States of America, one nation, under God... Clerk will call the roll. [5:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Councilor Fournier? Here. Councilor Grant? Here. Councilor Sykes? Here. Councilor Ali? Here. Councilor Pelletier? absent councillor mcnovich here that's our bullet here councillor phillips yeah mayor dion here [5:32] Speaker A (unidentified): chair would entertain well let me take announcements out of order because there might be some people that'll want to speak to the very item that'll be addressed by councillor gray you have the floor [5:47] Benjamin Grant: thank you mr mayor the issue of creative portland has bubbled up in a kind of a big way and i wanted to just express that this will be an evolving process i understand there have been some conversations throughout the day and counselor phillips and i will i believe meet with the board at some point in the near future to discuss some of the things we've been hearing some of the ideas that have been put on the table so i want to assure people that nothing's going to happen rapidly i.e tomorrow morning or on that sort of timeline so to the extent people are here to talk about that, we've heard a lot of messages. I've received them, and we're going to slow down a little bit and take in some more feedback. So I think that covers what we had spoke about earlier. [6:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Councillor. Councillor Phillips, any comment? [6:37] Speaker D (unidentified): No, I just really want to appreciate the committee for postponing this. It was a little shocking for the Creative Portland folks to open up an agenda for tomorrow to see that this was on the agenda. And so I was grateful for all the people that reached out again. I'm grateful for the committee for postponing this And so again like council grant says I do look forward to having a conversation With him and members of the creative Portland board so that we can figure out our next steps. Thank you [7:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. And just to add to that for a moment. There was something concerned that we Somehow were devious and setting it for the morning of election I'll tell you that our schedules just roll over. It's just another Tuesday, and I would have postponed it just on the basis of the election, so I want to have my opportunity to stand in line like some of you already have. So I appreciate both counselors are going to reach out to the board, schedule a meeting based on the feedback they collectively absorb from that process. the committee may return to the discussion of the item that was scheduled for the committee so thank you with that chair would now welcome any public comment on a non-agenda item Thank [8:12] Speaker E (unidentified): You mayor Dion I'm Jamie Batista from Falmouth and an intervener and CMP's proposed transmission corridor upgrades first thank you for moving so quickly at the last council meeting you said you'd stand with residents and the city's testimony delivered on that With testimony in the case record speaks for itself. It shows exactly why an independent review is needed and so does what CMP told your S&T committee two weeks ago. Central to CMP's proposal to the Commission is the claim that growing demand in Portland and improving reliability are the core drivers of this project. Now CMP is changing the story. It says the need is here today and it doesn't depend on a forecast. That is because the forecast continues to fall year over year. The public advocate's independent expert raised this in testimony, and so did our technical advisor. CMP also keeps treating reliability and these transmission corridors as the same thing. They are not. National research from the Lawrence Berkeley National Lab shows only a small fraction of the outages people experience start on transmission lines. The overwhelming majority start on the local grid that runs through our neighborhoods. And a new transmission corridor does nothing about these. Then there's the Elm Street Station. The outage that CMP pointed to at your committee meeting, CMP called this outage an equipment failure. That isn't a corridor problem, it's a maintenance problem. Keeping equipment working is the ordinary cost of running a utility. But Elm Street is slated for demolition and replacement as a part of this project, which turns a maintenance problem into a capital project. And capital is what CMP earns money on. That's why we need an independent voice, and we believe it will open the door to non-wires alternatives. The way the system is supposed to work, that system was first championed by Mayor Dion. It worked on the Booth Bay Peninsula, where solar, batteries, and efficiency held off a transmission corridor upgrade, and the predicted load growth never arrived. The same thing happened in Brunswick and Topsom, and even right here in Portland. In 2010, when CMP's proposed Portland area reliability upgrades were carved out, the non-wires alternatives could be looked at first. it worked then and it can work now. ARI will be hosting open houses for residents ahead of CMPs Thursday November 5th at the Falmouth Elementary School cafeteria and Tuesday November 10th at 4 p.m. at Presumpt Scott School here in Portland. We'll talk through these points and where the case stands. You're formally invited and we look forward to continuing the conversation. Thank you very much. I'm sure you're sick of seeing me but thank you.
Public Comment
[11:15] Speaker A (unidentified): anyone else wishing to provide public comment on a non-agended item is free to do so public comment period is now closed i should ask if the council any other members have an announcement that they'd like to share with the community i kind of cut it off short based on [11:43] Speaker F (unidentified): council grant and phillips council bullet well the previous speaker did it for me so now i don't need to share my announcement i did just want to make sure that the public and my colleagues know that the mayor did submit testimony to the public utilities commission and did a very good job so thank you mayor for that and like i said my thunder was stolen so i'll thank you so much [12:05] Speaker A (unidentified): all right there's no other comments chair would seek a motion to recess the meeting of the city council for the purpose of convening the special meeting of the corporator of the portland Development Corporation. So moved. Moved by Councilor Sykes, there's second. Second. Second by Councilor Phillips. All those in favor of recessing the City Council meeting, please show by hand. It's unanimous. Clerk will now read, strike that. Clerk will now read title only. [12:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Order 712627, amending the Portland Development Corporation's Business Assistance Program for job creation guidelines sponsored by danielle west city manager comment from the city manager [12:58] Speaker G (unidentified): the board of directors held a meeting where they voted unanimously to amend the business assistant grant program and this will allow for up we have a tighter time frame to spend the funds and so they would like to increase the amount of the grant from ten thousand dollars to twenty thousand That would be $10,000 per full-time job equivalent created, and to expand eligible activities beyond rent to include additional working capital costs such as payroll and utilities for this program. They believe this will help to encourage people to reach out and apply for that business assistance grant program, and that it will allow for us to spend the funds within the timeframe that we are required to do so. [13:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, City Manager. Is there any public comment on this proposed order seeing none chairs seek a motion for passage in a second? Move by council grant seconded by councillor Ali comment from the council [14:04] Benjamin Grant: Council grant I just briefly want a second The city managers actually excellent remarks This is a really good but small program and it's money that we would really like to get out in the community And we think this will facilitate it in fall. So I encourage my colleagues to pass [14:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other comment from the council? Seeing none, all those in favor of the proposed order, please signify. It's unanimous. The chair would now seek a motion to recess the meeting of the Portland Development Corporation and reconvene the regular meeting of the city council. So moved. Moved by Councillor Grant, seconded by Councillor Ali. Is there any discussion by members of the council? Seeing none, all those in favor, please signify by hand. it's unanimous chair would seek a motion to approve the minutes of the october 19th 2026 city council meeting moved by councillor ali is there a second by councillor phillips any discussion by the council on the minutes seeing none all those in favor please signify it's unanimous clerk will now read by title only proclamation 15 26 27 proclamation [15:30] Speaker B (unidentified): 15 26 27 recognizing November 2026 as Native American Heritage Month sponsored by Mark Dion, Mayor. [15:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Chair would yield to Council Fornia. [15:41] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you so much. This initial proclamation that was published with the earlier packet was a prior proclamation. Time got away from me as everything happening with the elections. And so just for the public's note, the proclamation that's currently online is the updated version. the last one I think was actually updated in 2024 and we've done quite a lot of work with Wabanaki studies and everything since then and so we've made an update to that and so you'll see that updated version good [16:15] Speaker I (unidentified): deal you're good to [16:16] Speaker H (unidentified): go awesome so what I wanted to start with because this is around Native American Heritage Month is just to greet you how would we normally greet each other in Diné which is the tribe that I'm a member of so we would say you have And that's just essentially saying, my name is April Fournier, it's good to see you. I am from the Onakani clan and the Fournier clan, which is my dad's, and I'm just glad to be here as a Diné woman sitting in this place of leadership. So, the proclamation recognizing November 2026 is Native American Heritage Month, whereas the Panawapskek, or Penobscot Nation, Peskotokmokati, or Passamaquoddy Tribe, Mi'kmaq Nation, Wollastokiwik, Holton Band of Maliseet Indians, and Abenaki, collectively known as the Wabanaki Nations, have lived since time immemorial on the land we now call Maine. and whereas the city of Portland stands in solidarity with Maine tribal nations recognizing their existence as sovereign nations and their right to self-determination and self-governance and recognizing the significant contributions history and resilience of Native American communities and whereas the Native American tribes in our country have endured centuries of mistreatment at the hands of the government through attempted assimilation and whereas through all attempts of the government the privileged, and the powerful to erase them, Native Americans have endured, providing time and again their resilience and building back the communities stolen from them. And whereas while work has been done to reverse the unfair treatment, inequity, and racism experienced by the Native American community, there is still much to be done. And whereas examples of this important ongoing work include national initiatives to combat past and present harm to the Native community, including an increased focus on the epidemic of missing and murdered Indigenous women and the federal Indian boarding school initiative and whereas Portland Public Schools pre-k through grade 12 wabanaki studies curriculum has been hugely successful in developing place-based connections and cultural appreciation for students and families and whereas the city of Portland is committed to pursuing equity visibility truth and recognition of our Native American community members now therefore be it resolved that Mayor Mark Dion of the city of Portland and members of the Portland City Council do hereby recognize the month of november 2026 as native american heritage month sign and sealed this second day of november 2026 by mark diane mayor thank you thank you counselor clerk will now read [18:58] Speaker B (unidentified): consent item orders 72 26 27 and 73 26 27 order 72 26 27 granting municipal officers approval of experience main culinary and venue 54 application for qualified catering with outdoor dining on private property and combined entertainment at 54 Danforth Street sponsored by Danielle West city manager order 73 26 27 granting municipal officers approval of the sports bra application for class 1 FSE with outdoor dining on private property at 476 Stevens Ave sponsored by Danielle [19:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Neal West, City Manager. Comment from the City Manager. [19:41] Speaker G (unidentified): No comment at this time. Maybe we'll after this is voted on, though. What? One of my friends is a member of the sports bra, and I'm very happy that she has taken that in front of you, so I'm just excited for her if the council were to approve this. [19:57] Speaker A (unidentified): She shouldn't have done that to you. Because I'm going to call for division now of the consent calendar. which means, in the past, everything that's on the consent calendar is taken as a whole. This time I'm going to separate it. That will come a little later. But in the meantime, the chair would welcome any public comment on any of the two items on that consent calendar. You have the floor. [20:26] Speaker J (unidentified): My name is Tracy Meade. [20:28] Speaker A (unidentified): You might have to get closer to the mic so folks at home can hear you. [20:31] Speaker J (unidentified): My name is Tracy Meade, and good evening all. I'M HERE TO ASK THE COUNCIL TO DENY MAINE EXPERIENCES APPLICATION FOR A COMBINED INDOOR OUTDOOR ENTERTAINMENT LICENSE AT 54 DANFORTH STREET. FOR TWO YEARS OUR NEIGHBORHOOD HAS BEEN ON THE RECEIVING END OF OMAINE STUDIOS REPEATED VIOLATIONS OF THEIR INDOOR ENTERTAINMENT LICENSE AT 54 DANFORTH. IN FACT, OMAINE STUDIOS DECIDED NOT TO RENEW THEIR LICENSE JUST BEFORE THEY WERE REQUIRED to attend a city council hearing on their numerous violations and whether they would be granted license renewal. Now, and I hope you share my unease with this news, a close partner of O'Mean Studios, Experience Maine, behind me, is applying for a combined indoor-outdoor entertainment license, which would now allow this venue to do precisely what two years of effort by our community, The police department, our city councilwoman, and the business licensing office considered a violation of the indoor entertainment code, which is not closing windows and doors during amplified entertainment. I've been informed that Experience Maine says they want to leave only the back garage door open during live amplified entertainment, but who will hold them accountable if they just want to open the front door again? Who will enforce that requirement, that is, if the council even decides to put this condition on the applicant's license? Council members, why set your neighbors up for failure? Why not have Experience Maine first demonstrate that it can be a good neighbor, that they can show that they will not disregard the law that O'Main violated with impunity, that they are willing to begin with an indoor entertainment license because they know and understand the history of violations of this venue why is experience main choosing an entertainment license type license type that disregards and discounts all the past efforts to hold this venue accountable why does experience main believe that is more important to keep the back garage door open during live amplified entertainment than working to build neighborhood trust building trust would be a great place to start I urge the council to ask for a do-over here year and have experienced Maine resubmit an application for an indoor entertainment license only. This is an easy and most importantly, a respectful fix. Thank you for your time. [23:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide comment on either order or both? [23:11] Speaker K (unidentified): I'd like to begin. I'm Roy Strunk from O-Main Studios, and I'd like to just shed a little light on some of the misinterpretation of the facts that as we know it. I've been working on this process for about a year. We've had a major change in our climate here and O-Main Studios doesn't have any windows and we don't have any ventilation and we had a landlord that would be was not going to provide us any relief in putting in air conditioning and until recently so I went to our landlord and said we cannot operate because even when we had people manning the doors ventilation is a very important part of a facility and without air conditioning we just had our hottest June and we literally were not operating events during the summer because we couldn't but yet our rent went up by 33 percent every year so back last year at this time i said this is not sustainable and so it wasn't a knee-jerk reaction i set out of course to find somebody because we have a beautiful facility it's got 8 000 square feet i started as a media company and people started knocking on the door for events and sure you know we'll help pay the rent and stuff like that and it organically grew we were operated for 11 years 10 of these 10 of those years we had no incidents okay during the pandemic there was this push to you know have businesses air friendly there was a whole standards that were put to making spaces more you know free for air and we took those things, we put in a big back door, because our landlord wouldn't put in any air conditioning. So the net of it is, I said, well, we can't operate this venue without air conditioning. So I went to our landlord and said, if we're going to stay there, we have to do this. And if I'm going to stay there, I want to focus my attention on a media business, which we have a great company there, employs several people in the media side of things. So we pivoted, and I found a person that I thought could do a fantastic job because costs have gone up. The pressure in this city in terms of the costs and the operating to do something like this, we said we're going to narrow our focus on media, and I want to find a partner that would come in here and operate a facility that we could continue to have events. over a third of our events are nonprofit we're a small venue we only have 200 capacity and without that there's nothing like that and furthermore there's only been one complaint she makes it like a community we have a wonderful community around us there's only one complainer and we've never violated the totally the actual decimal level ever at one of our events according to the place that have come so there's a little bit of misinformation but I appreciate your time, and I'll have Rachel speak her part. [26:28] Speaker L (unidentified): I'm Rachel with Experience Maine. First thing I want to address is the back door being open. That was never part of the mitigation plan that we put together, so I don't know where that came from, just to address that up front. The only reason I asked for an indoor-outdoor license is because I thought that would mitigate the complaints, because even if the door was open a little bit because people were bringing stuff in and out and some noise traveled, then that was kind of covered. We do not plan to have outdoor music. I have been an event planner for 25 years between Portland and Boston. My business has been in business for almost eight years now as a media meeting planner and event planner. So I feel like I bring a lot of experience to understanding what goes into making sure that the community is covered and that they're not being bothered and that our events are being operated within the law or within the license right and so we put together in that plan some ways to help mitigate that as well which would be making sure that if somebody has an event with any sound requirements DJ band etc it is mandatory that event pays for an on-site staff member to be there for the entire event that staff member will make sure the doors stay closed that staff member will make sure that the decibels stay within the legal range that we're allowed to be in we have created a form and we'll have a mobile decimal meter so every hour that staff member will take reading of the decimals and mark it down and sign it so if somebody does call the cops and they come we can say well look an hour ago it was only at this decibel yes they may have opened the door because you know somebody was going in and out But we're doing what we're supposed to be doing, and we're trying our best. And I think that is a great mitigation plan. And my staff has been in events for a combined 40 years. So this is what we do, and we're really good at it, and we have a great reputation. And so we're confident that we can be a good member of the community and make a positive change there. [28:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide public comment on a non-agended item? don't know strike that you can on this order I was hitting rewind I'm all the way back at the beginning of the meeting that's all right hi my name is Morgan [28:57] Speaker M (unidentified): Schaefer and I'm a current residents over 25 High Street which is the condominium complex directly behind 54 Danforth live there for nine years I can honestly say I've never really been bothered or heard of any events over there that have been troublesome for my wife and I, even our windows being up. So noise over there really hasn't been an issue for me. Second thing is I can vouch for Rachel and her team having worked with them in the Aroma Joes venues at the conventions that we've had up here at the Holiday Inn. Very professional. Their integrity is second to none. When they say they're going to do something, they're going to do it. I was recently at an event, my wife and I were helping planning it, and it was Rachel that really reinforced the fact that we cannot have the doors open, the music has to stop at 11 o'clock, no ifs, ands, or buts. And so I can honestly say the guidelines were presented, they were enforced and reinforced, and we lived up to the expectation. So I'm here to support them, and I can honestly say whatever they say they're going to do, they will do. Thank you. [30:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide public comment on this order or the other one? [30:20] Speaker N (unidentified): Hello, counsel. My name is Robert Bate. I live across the street from O-Main Studios from 54, and, you know, it's on the books that they have to keep the doors closed, and repeatedly the doors have been opened and the music you know there's weddings there are dance parties there are concerts there and the music can be quite loud and especially a bass which really travels throughout the whole neighborhood high streets a little far away from the from the venue but across the street there's a kind of a transitional housing I've talked to some of these people, they complain, but they complain to us, but they don't come here. You know, they 're a little bit more precarious than we are. And, you know, it's like repeatedly, you know, like Oman promised to close the doors and they don't because they don't have somebody there. They don't have, you know, somebody you can't even give somebody a ticket because the you know, it's like the wedding party. Who do you give it to? The bride, the groom, you know, father of the bride, whatever. You know, it's it's it doesn't happen. And there's no responsible person there to accept a ticket, which the police have come by repeatedly. So I stand, you know, I would like Tracy said, I think you should reconsider this and give an indoor only permit for entertainment. Thank you very much. [31:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide public comment on this or the companion order? seeing none chair will treat each order separately so we'll move first with order 72 26 27 do i have a motion on the floor second moved by council grant seconded by councillor phillips [32:25] Speaker F (unidentified): DISCUSSION. COUNCILOR ABULA. I'M NOT SURE WHO THIS QUESTION IS FOR. MAYBE THE MANAGER OR THE COUNCILOR OF THE DISTRICT. WHAT ZONE IS THIS? ARE WE GOING TO HAVE TO PULL UP THE MAP? [32:45] Speaker G (unidentified): I SEE, I'M NOT SURE, ZACH, DO YOU HAVE ANY OF THE INFORMATION SPECIFIC TO THE SITE? [32:56] Speaker F (unidentified): I MEANT, LIKE, IS IT RN, IS IT B2B, LIKE, B2, DO YOU KNOW? OKAY. I CAN LOOK AT THE MAP. IS [33:13] Speaker A (unidentified): THAT WHAT YOU'RE DOING, counselor this counselor calling him mr attorney would seem a little bit awkward but he is looking that up any other comments from the council [33:35] Speaker O (unidentified): Michniewicz okay yeah i do think this sounds like they've got a good plan i think the model before was really tricky in that space and the needs of the community changed a little bit through covid the needs of the venue changed and we just haven't quite reconciled what that looks like. I'm very encouraged by the testimonies and the and the plan that's that's being formed but I am still I would I would like to take a second look at this just to make sure that we're setting it up for success. I don't want to have us come back here in you know six months or a year and have to start from a place of it not having worked i don't want to do that to you and i don't want to do that to the community i'd like this to move forward with a lot of trust that it's going to be handled in a way that makes it successful for everyone council [34:38] Kate Sykes: sykes i think i hear a motion to postpone but before we do that i just I just do have one question. If we were to move forward with just an indoor entertainment license, what would be the procedure for doing that at this moment? Can we do that, or would it require an entire reapplication for the license? [34:58] Speaker G (unidentified): I think it's possible. I would defer to Corporation Counsel. I believe it would probably just be amendment of the license, but I would defer to Michael specifically. [35:09] Speaker Q (unidentified): I'm sorry. I'm multitasking. Can you repeat the question for me? [35:12] Kate Sykes: I'm just thinking that if we want to take a look at the outdoor entertainment license piece of it at a later date, give us a little more time to do some investigating, could we move forward with just an indoor entertainment license for tonight? And if so, what's the procedure? Do we just amend it here on the floor or does it require a new license application? [35:29] Speaker Q (unidentified): I think there are a couple of options in terms of sort of downsizing the request tonight. You could divide the question and grant the catering license and hold back on the entertainment license and I think one other possibility would be to sort of further divide it and I'm I'm looking at Zach there and I think that I believe that the entertainment license that is being applied for is a combined indoor outdoor and so I think you could further divide that into just indoor and I'm Zach am I would that cause any problems on your end that wouldn't cause any [36:07] Speaker R (unidentified): problems for us it's the same application essentially we'd be refunding the difference [36:17] Kate Sykes: thank you zach i'm looking to the district council to see if that's acceptable i'm not sure how far [36:20] Speaker O (unidentified): you want to dial this back yeah i mean i don't have a problem with the catering license at this point and i don't want to hang up the business from moving forward with essential operations it's just the entertainment piece really is the part i'd like to take a second look at and I there were other possibilities that I discussed with Zach that could be the conditions or reeling back around to revisit it in a little bit and making after a set amount of time and making sure that it's working the way we want it to which could you speak a little bit to what that would look like yeah there [36:58] Speaker R (unidentified): I suppose there's a couple options and I kind of defer to Michael on the process of that the council can put conditions on the license there's also a section for the duration of the license which would essentially create a trial period for the establishment those are kind of the two options that you guys have at this at this time or tabling it to discuss it further for another doctor [37:28] Speaker A (unidentified): ANY OTHER COMMENTS? [37:32] Speaker H (unidentified): COUNCIL VORNER. DO WE KNOW HOW MANY DOCUMENTED COMPLAINTS THERE ARE? I DON'T SEE THAT IN THE BACKUP MATERIAL. [37:39] Speaker R (unidentified): IT IS IN THE MATERIAL. [37:42] Speaker H (unidentified): MAYBE I DIDN'T SCROLL FAR ENOUGH. [37:44] Speaker R (unidentified): YEAH, IT'S AFTER THE SOUND MITIGATION PLAN. THERE'S A FEW E-MAILS THAT ARE IN THERE. but one of them is the past couple years of the police reports. I don't have a number exactly, but they're in there. There was a call on April 5th, 2025. [38:13] Speaker H (unidentified): Oh, I see it. April 25th, 2025. [Speaker R (unidentified): So what] I'm seeing, and this is just kind of where my brain is going with this, So this is an allowable use for, I'm assuming this is an allowable use or we wouldn't be taking this license. Yes, correct. So as I'm looking at these calls for service, there's either no notes, they were able to talk to someone on site that said, yes, we'll close the door. And so I guess I'm not necessarily compelled to postpone this further. I feel like we've been given the information. It's an allowable use for the property. And it's something that we can do. My earring keeps falling out. It's what happens when you wear these really giant earrings. It feels like this is something that once they're in business, this should be something that we're able to respond to on an as-needed basis. Clearly, the business owners have now heard, at this point, the concerns from the community, and so should operate accordingly, but I don't see a need to postpone this. [39:15] Kate Sykes: Councillor Sykes. The one issue that I have is that it seems that the license that's being asked for is beyond the actual use that is intended for the space. And it's fine to say we're not going to have outdoor entertainment, but once you have a license for outdoor entertainment, you can have outdoor entertainment. And so that may be an allowable use. We may decide that's fine if you want to have outdoor entertainment there. But I do just want to say, just notice, that we're being told there will be no outdoor entertainment, but we're potentially granting a license for outdoor entertainment. [39:48] Speaker A (unidentified): So that's just. Any other comments? No,, you don't get to comment. No offense taken, but your time has passed. No. [40:05] Speaker G (unidentified): I just wanted to reflect, Corporation Council pulled it up, Councillor Bullett, and it was a B3 zone. Yep, and the acceptable use is a residential business office, low-impact, industrial and creative, but retail, restaurants, hotels, public places of assembly, things like that. It's a downtown business district. Councillor Phillips. [40:31] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'm going to I agree with Councillor Fornia I'm not sure what we would be postponing. I think what happens sometimes in these situations that we get into all the time is you hear from both sides. I heard from two people said it's loud and I heard from other people neighbours that said it wasn't. I've heard that there is a plan in place I don't know much about your venue I'm looking at it right now. I can only trust like Councillor Michniewicz has said that you have a plan, you've put the plan in place and you've applied for what needs to be applied for and I think we need to move it forward. There isn't a lot of complaints in here and if there were and we get to a place in another six months where it's not going to work, then I think we have to look at it at that point in time. But I have not heard anything that suggests that we need to wait on this. You're applying for a license. You went through the process. You have a plan in place. I'm glad that we heard from some of the neighbors. You now have heard from some of the neighbors. I would only suggest that if the neighbors that you've heard from that don't want this, that you guys work together on this, that there be some communication between you and them to work it out. You're all adults and have respectful conversations. If those respectful conversations cannot happen, that's what we have the city of Portland. That's what we have Zach for. So I will be voting to move this forward. Councilman Navage. [41:59] Speaker O (unidentified): So just to be clear, the complaints that the door was being left open, those were [42:05] Speaker R (unidentified): substantiated? Yes, by the police. The police noted that in there. [42:10] Speaker O (unidentified): And that was over the course of a couple of years, is that correct? Yes, that's correct. Okay. And I understand the decibel level was never breached because that wasn't the complaint. The complaint was that it was out of violation, it was in violation of its license to just keep the door shut. That's correct. [42:25] Speaker R (unidentified): It was essentially a violation of the definition of indoor entertainment, which requires doors and windows remain closed. Yeah. [42:37] Speaker O (unidentified): A noise complaint, by definition, means that it's kind of too late. That person's, you know, the person who's complaining for whatever reason, like it's the harm's already occurred to the extent that you want to, if you want to call it harm or not, it doesn't matter. But it's already occurred. It's all reactive. and it you know I feel like we're going into this with a bit of tension already between parties most of the time when we do this it's just kind of straightforward and I 'm so inclined to want to postpone it just as I said to make sure that this starts off on the right foot I think there to councillor Sykes's point granting a license where something can happen on the promise that it won't is a little it's a little too open for me in this particular circumstance so my goal would be to get this addressed very quickly and get it through and just make sure that you know well I'm comfortable whoever else needs to be comfortable with this to go forward is comfortable but I will be supporting postponing this [43:39] Speaker A (unidentified): also McNavid's just for I'm sorry that's right no you don't have to be sorry I just want to advise you there's no motion on the hearing to postpone it I think Councilor Sykes did her best to get you there. [43:51] Speaker O (unidentified): Okay, well, fair then. I am, yes, I would like to make a motion to postpone to the next meeting. [43:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Date certain would be November 16th. [44:00] Speaker O (unidentified): Date certain, November 16th. Is there a second? [44:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I'll second that. All right, there's a second. Now we can have a full-body discussion as to whether or not postponement is appropriate. [44:12] Benjamin Grant: Councilor Grant. I'm going to oppose postponement. I think my colleague has made some excellent points, but coming down on the side of my other colleagues, Fournier and Phillips, and their comments, I'm not really sure what will be gained by further delay here. I think what we were talking about are problems that are being attempted to be mitigated by this new plan. I think more time is just going to lead us right back into the same place that the prior company has brought in a new company to solve these problems. And, you know, I think what we do up here is see who we can find that's credible. And I found the testimony credible from the new owner, who is an experienced operator that has clearly thought this out. And I'm not sure more time is going to improve their answers, and I'm satisfied that it will address the issues that have been raised by the residents. So for that reason, I'm going to oppose this motion and hopefully get back to passing tonight. [45:07] Speaker A (unidentified): like anyone else wishing to comment on the council all right seeing none i'm going to make a quick comment you can sit on zach you don't stand up we've tortured you more questions oh there's a chair right there in case we need you like council grant i appreciate you brought in another company to try to deal with this i'm a little concerned you describe a venue that almost is designed to be counterproductive to the business model that you're trying to realize in that space. There's nothing the council can do about this. I'll also note it's really rare for us to deny a license. Occasionally we've had noise complaints, but it's pretty well documented by the police and it seems to be a chronic condition. But at the same time, I try to support a district councilor who has concern about licensing. licensing, if nothing else, to have an opportunity to discuss it fully with the parties involved so that they can express a voting of confidence into the item itself. So I will join Councilor McNevish for the purposes of at least supporting the council district representative on that question. All right. There's no other comments on the motion to postpone. All those in favor? There are three. 4. Those opposed? 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. The motion to postpone fails. All right then. We have a motion and a second on order 72, 26, 27. Any discussion on this order? Seeing none. all those in favor of granting the license as articulated to those in favor all right it's unanimous it passed good luck you can stay for the rest I say this every councilman you're welcome to stay for the entire meeting and no one has ever taken me up on the offer you're more than welcome all right now, on the matter of Order 73-26-27, is there a motion for passage? Second. Moved by Councilor Lee, seconded by Councilor Bullett. Any discussion? Any final plea from the City Manager? I got that in for you. All right. That's totally out of order. None of my colleagues have opposed that, though, so that's a good thing. All those in favor of this order, please signify by hand. Passes unanimous. Thank you and I know you're packing up to leave so I won't even give you the speech. All right then. Clerk will now read order 66-26-27, title only. [48:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Order 66-26-27, traffic schedule amendment regarding Lancaster Street sponsored by Sustainability and Transportation Committee, Councillor Regina Phillips, Chair. Chair will yield to Councillor [49:00] Speaker D (unidentified): Councilor Phillips for climate. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This is pretty simple. We brought this in front of sustainability and transportation, and it's really just to change the traffic pattern on, or the traffic flow pattern or whatever, on Lancaster Street. So right now it's zoned for commercial loading zone. We want to switch that to make it a one-hour time zone, and not only that, but also have it be one of the approved spaces that Portland High School students can park in. [49:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, councillor. Is there any comment from the public regarding this order? Seeing none, chairs seek a motion for passage and a second. So moved. Second. Moved by councillor Phillips, seconded by councillor Bullitt. Discussion by the council, if any. Seeing none, all those in favor, please signify by hand. Passes unanimously. unanimously. Clerk will now read Order 67-2627, title only. [50:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Order 67-2627, approving the administrative fee increase for parking in the First Light Commons parking lots, sponsored by Sustainability and Transportation Committee, Councilor Regina Phillips, Chair. Councilor Phillips, you have the floor. [50:28] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This is another pretty simple one. We just want to set the parking fees at First Light Commons, and you'll see in your backup material that the proposed fee is $40 an hour, not $40 an hour, but $4 an hour with a daily max of $40 and 25 cents a day. And so, again, pretty simple to just vote on the parking fees. [50:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Any comment from the public on this proposed order? Seeing none, chairs, seek a motion for passage and a second. So moved. Moved by Councillor Phillips, seconded by Councillor Forney. A discussion by the council. Seeing none, all those in favor, please signify by hand. It's unanimous. Chair will set aside the orders regarding shelter and opioid funding and dispose of other business first us and consider those items last clerk [51:45] Speaker B (unidentified): will now read order 75 26 27 order 75 26 27 approving option to extend northeast air ground lease by a 20-year term conditional on the replacement of the existing hangar at a minimum four million investment sponsored by danielle west city manager city manager i [52:05] Speaker G (unidentified): don't have anything to add i think the title is self-explanatory but So Paul Bradbury from the Jetport is here. If you have any questions, I don't know if Paul has anything additional to add. No, but the materials are pretty explanatory, as I said. [52:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there any public comment on this order? Seeing none, chair would seek a motion for passage in a second. So moved. Second. Moved by Councillor Phillips, seconded by Councillor Fournier. Discussion by the council or questions of Director Bradbury. Councillor Phillips. [52:45] Speaker D (unidentified): Hey, director. Quick question. Maybe I missed it. Are they paying us rent? [52:53] Speaker S (unidentified): Yes, they pay ground rent. It's a ground lease. And then they also pay a two percentage of gross [52:58] Speaker D (unidentified): sales. And so how much is the rent? [53:02] Speaker S (unidentified): Right now, it's basically there's a cost per square foot on the leased land, which is existing. It goes up by CPI. So it changes each year, that ground rent. and then there's also 2% of gross sales. [53:15] Speaker D (unidentified): And so that will continue. That will continue. [53:17] Speaker S (unidentified): Absolutely. This is just an investment for new capital and for the new hangar to keep up and reinvest, recapitalize the program and their facilities. Okay, thank you. [53:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other comments or questions from the council? Councilor Bullett. [53:32] Speaker F (unidentified): Thanks, Director. Is that 2% always 2% or is it tied to inflation? [53:38] Speaker S (unidentified): No, it's always, it's a flat 2%. [53:40] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, thank you so much. I assume they're busy, that they need to expand? [53:43] Speaker S (unidentified): Yes, and this, again, it's a 50-year-old hangar, so it's really, you've got to recapitalize your facility, so it's time for this hangar to be replaced, and this just sets the procedure and puts it in place so when they're ready in the next five years, it's ready to go. Yeah, thank you so much. Sure. Any other questions? [54:01] Speaker D (unidentified): Councillor Phillips. Well, I wasn't going to ask, and then Councillor Blunt asked for a question, which is, there a way to, do we want to charge them more money? We don't have any money. City of Portland doesn't have any money. So do we want to charge them any more money? [54:16] Speaker S (unidentified): So for the City of Portland, this rent goes to the jet port, but yes, when you build a new hangar, it is taxable. So the normal tax on this new invested property will be through assessors, right? So they will pay property tax just like every other private entity at the jet port. So this new hangar will be assessed at its new appraised value, which will presumably be significantly higher, and the city will receive more tax payments. I'm done. [54:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Anything else? No other questions? Councillor Sykes. [54:49] Kate Sykes: Thanks, Paul. I'm just looking at the schematic as to where this is going to go. What is it wiping out? It looks like there's a building there already. [54:56] Speaker S (unidentified): Yeah, there's a small office. It was part of the Bath Iron Works used to have a corporate spot, a corporate offices. Now there's a flight school's operating in there, and then there's a small hangar which has been used for postal but those uses will work with northeast air it'll just be a new recapitalized better hanger with more space but great questions thank you any other questions or [55:19] Speaker A (unidentified): comments seeing none all those in favor please signify by hand passes unanimously clerk [55:30] Speaker B (unidentified): will now read order 76 26 27 title only order 76 26 27 approving the purchase and sale agreement between the nordic main llc and portland regarding portland technology park units three and five sponsored by housing and economic development committee councillor pious ali chair [55:49] Speaker A (unidentified): chair seeks comment from councillor ali [55:54] Speaker T (unidentified): thank you mayor this is part of a plot that some properties that belong to the city to industrial park the council the staff took an OFFER AND BROUGHT IT TO THE COMMITTEE SOMEWHERE IN JULY. WE DISCUSSED IT THOROUGHLY AND APPROVED THE SALES AND NOW WE'RE BRINGING IT FORWARD TO THE COUNCIL AND I HOPE MY COLLEAGUES WILL SUPPORT AND SEAL THE SALES. [56:23] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU COUNCILOR. chair would seek any public comment on order 76 26 27 seeing none motion for passage in a second so moved by move by council psych seconded by council for your discussion or questions from the council seeing none all those in favor please signify by hand passes unanimously clerk will now I'll read Order 77-26-27, title only. [57:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Order 77-26-27, authorizing salary increase for Corporation Council, sponsored by Mark Dion, Mayor. [57:20] Speaker A (unidentified): For the public, Corporation Council is one of three employees of this body. Himself, the city manager, as well as the city clerk. work. In prior months we conducted a personnel evaluation of Council Goldman and we had further discussions in executive session regarding reasonable and adequate compensation for services that is outlined here as an amount. So the chair would now seek public comment on the proposed salary. Seeing none, motion and a second for passage. [Speaker F (unidentified): So moved. Second.] Moved by Councillor Bullett, seconded by Councillor Sykes. Any discussion or comment from the body? Seeing none, all those in favor please signify by hand. It's unanimous. Clerk will now, by title, first readings. [58:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Order 78-26-27, accepting and appropriating an additional $74,572.50 from the Land and Water Conservation Fund and approving the amendment to the sub-grant between Portland and the Maine Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry regarding Riverton Trolley Park improvements, sponsored by Danielle West, city manager. Order 79-26-27, amending the conditional zone agreement regarding second amendment to the conditional rezoning agreement for property in the vicinity of st. Lawrence Arts Congress Street sponsored by the Planning Board Joseph Zamboni chair thank [59:15] Speaker A (unidentified): you the clerk will now read the three winter warming shelter items together we will consider them out of order and that will be 68-26-27, 70-26-27, and 74-26-27. [59:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Order 68-26-27, approving the appropriation of $350,000 from the Opioid Settlement Fund for Operation of Emergency Winter Warming Shelter, sponsored by Danielle West, City Manager. Order 68-26-27, approving the appropriation of $900,000 from the Opioid Settlement Fund for Operation of Emergency Winter Warming Shelter at 166 Riverside Industrial Parkway. Order 74-2627, declaring a state of limited emergency at 654 Riverside Street, sponsored by Mark Dion, Mayor. [1:00:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Comments from the City Manager? Oh, my God, you see. You look away for a moment, and now you have an Assistant City Manager. Dina Libnick. Go ahead, Dina. [1:00:19] Speaker U (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Mayor. the conversations about winter warming shelter began this past spring the three items are that you see three orders currently in the packet came as a result of those conversations it began in committee as you know in discussions about the preferred operating model of a city of Portland or a partner's winter when a warming shelter and out of those conversations it became clear that the preference was for a shelter that operated seven days a week and on Peninsula as it was believed to be the most accessible option. No funding was appropriated in the FY 27 budget for this purpose so staff took on the role of facilitating some sort of partnership between a private property owner potentially in a private operator. That effort to facilitate a partnership began around June or July and extended until through October actually until this past week and unfortunately despite conversations with property owners and potential operators no partnership was made possible and this evening's agenda includes the two remaining options before the council for winter warming shelter operations in the city of Portland they both assumed that city of Portland staff would be operating them you have before you order 68 which was first considered by the council earlier this season. That represents operations at 166 Riverside Industrial Parkway and provides funding to that end. Order 74 is the newest of the relevant orders and it assumes operation at the city's Homeless Services Center, really expanding capacity at that existing emergency shelter and Order 70, which has been previously considered by the council as well, provides funding for the city-operated shelter at the HSC. There are also two amendments, one associated with Order 68 and one associated with Order 70, and that adjusts the amounts appropriated through those orders based on updated information we've received from MESHA about what funding may be possible through that organization. Is [1:02:46] Speaker A (unidentified): that all, Dana? That's all. Thank you. One slight comment, just for a matter of fact, not opinion, that'll come later. Myself and Council Bullitt, as Chair of Health and Human Services, did meet recently with 17 representatives from various community partner organizations in the city, and after a long discussion, they are not in a place to operate a shelter, and their staff is stretched to the best they could offer as possible per diem, but that is uncertain and operationally it is hard to have a shelter on the hope somebody might show up to work as opposed to some type of permanent employee. With that, I will turn it over for public comment. You have to approach the mic and say your name. [1:03:40] Speaker V (unidentified): Mr. Mayor, City Council, my name is Robert Demmons. I am a homeless person. I am here to help try to represent them. One thing I'd like to have you guys take in mind is you're only going to have so many beds available, but there's a number of people out there homeless. What about the ones that have the livelihood in their shopping carts? They're given a choice. Do we give it up and stay warm and lose everything we own, or do we stay and freeze with it? I think something closer by, I agree saving as much money on the opiate fund is a great idea, but we've got to think about the people. We need to try to figure out what we can do for everyone, not just 50 people, if possible. I'm one that's been highly in favor of tiny houses for people. You can get enough. They're only probably $500 a piece to make. I've checked that out in Lewiston, Auburn, you could have enough to house all the homeless people, feed them three meals a day, and you could probably get the staffing down to where it wouldn't cost that much. And maybe not everyone would accept it, but the ones that are homeless, which forced them to be homeless, and the ones that care, they would. That's basically what I got to say. [1:05:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wish to provide public comment on these orders? Approach the mic. [1:05:16] Speaker W (unidentified): Hi, my name is Eric Brewer. I'm an advocate with Homeless Voices for Justice. I have a brief statement. In 2025, according to records kept by local social service agencies, 52 unhoused people died in Portland. The average age of those who died was 57. The deaths are due to chronic medical conditions, overdoses, suicide, and vehicle accidents. On average, the unhoused live 28 years less than those of us who are housed. The alternative to not having an adequately staffed warming shelter is dire. Many people will suffer needlessly and will possibly have more possible deaths due to lack of adequate shelter during extreme weather conditions. The former warming shelter opened when conditions reached 15 degrees or below or 10 inches of snow or more. On February 23rd, 2026, when Portland experienced blizzard conditions, the warming shelter did not open, and people had nowhere to shelter from the cold snow and wind. Many of the people living on the street have health problems, and many of the health problems are a direct result of exposure to living outside. Some of the homeless are elderly. Not all will make it through another winter outdoors. Frostbite is one of the hazards of being outdoors in hypothermia. Many people get sick and suffer infections, too. This means more EMS calls in the city of Portland EMS will be dispatched to answer more of these calls, which could be avoided. The worst part about being cold isn't the cold itself. It is the feeling of being invisible and being hopeless, knowing that you might die out there. Being temporarily housed means that a person may not use drugs at night and save somebody from a potential overdose. dose. Many people who are unhoused use a drink just to escape an intolerable situation. When people are housed or even sheltered just one night, they have a better chance of seeking recovery support. Also, there are veterans who are experiencing homelessness and stay outdoors and live outside. They served our country, but due to illnesses sustained in military service, they can no longer function in society. Many of them are now disabled. A warming shelter in the a city of Portland that is open every night could save a life otherwise lost. Adequate planning for such a shelter is critical. Thank you for your time. [1:07:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide a public comment on these orders? [1:07:47] Speaker X (unidentified): Good evening. I'm Cheryl Harkins, an advocate with Homeless Voices for Justice. I'm a voting member of Maine's Statewide Homeless Council and a co-chair of the People with Lived Experience Committee at the COC. Tonight comes a critical decision for people's lives this winter. these humans are the most vulnerable amongst our society right now it's a situation nobody knows how to deal with unless you've walked in somebody's and you've walked in their shoes I have a lot of the community misunderstands that being homeless doesn't mean that you don't have a life you lost a job a family things that you want to repair in your life these people work they volunteer, they vote, just like everyone else. Not everyone's an alcoholic or a drug addict. Many are working programs from tents. HBJ doesn't approve of the location on 166 Riverside Street, yet the hard fact remains clear we need a warming shelter so more people won't die. Homeless Voices for Justice developed a list of necessities for any of your warming centers. Your staff requires much better training of how to address a client's needs instead of just kicking them out into the harsh elements. The warming center has to serve at least 100 people because currently, according to Veterans Services, there's at least 73 unhoused veterans outside. It needs to be open every night from around 5 to 8 a.m. because the coldest parts of the day are currently around six to seven in the morning. The clients don't need to be stuffed in the cafeteria to sleep. The bed frames from before that had been broken down can be reconstructed and that will save money. They need an area, a small area to put their stuff at night and people need to be warm, rested and dry so that they can think and work on their individual situations. situations. Humans need at least one cup of coffee daily in the morning to warm them before they leave, along with a type of a breakfast food, some type. There needs to be a full-sized bus that stops in numerous locations, and I can help with that. I work with the Maddie program at set times so that people wouldn't be left out. 30 seconds. Finally, I'll address the opioid HVJ doesn't agree with spending $900,000 when that's much higher than requested. HVJ would encourage the city to supply funds requested, but we'd also encourage the city to explore other areas of cash flow available, including out-of-city allocations of support monies like the $50,000 that South Portland allocates yearly. Thank you for your time, and whoever's running for re-election, good luck with your election [1:10:52] Speaker A (unidentified): tomorrow. I'll go upstairs now. [1:10:58] Speaker Y (unidentified): Hi. My name is Susanna Richer. I'm a Portland homeowner, and I volunteer with our unhoused community. It's November, and again, we're scrambling to figure out where the winter warming shelter is going to be. I said the same thing here a year ago. We all agree that bringing people inside creates a safer and cleaner community, and that the state and county need to play a larger role in this crisis. However, it's still the responsibility of the city to keep everybody within its municipality safe. It's less expensive to provide accessible shelter than to leave people unable to meet their basic needs. While I'm thankful that the city is offering something, the two options presented are not appropriate. It's time to stop operating on the something is better than nothing status quo. Option one, expanding capacity at the homeless services center is unacceptable given that individuals who need shelter may not be able to access that location. I take offense to the implication that most of the individuals not currently allowed at HSC are violent and deserve to be left out in the cold. Additionally, the community as a whole is safer when everyone has access to shelter. When there is an altercation at HSC, all parties are asked to leave, instigator and victim. One vulnerable individual recently banned for 30 days after they were randomly attacked. This person had no option but to sleep in a tent which was then taken by authorities that cleared the site. Another senior disabled woman was not allowed at HSC for a year because she accepted assistance to move out of state, a move that turned dangerous, forcing her back to Maine with no shelter. She was found in a snow bank in January needing emergency medical assistance. Option two is unacceptable due to the inaccessibility funding source and price tag that could put everyone up in hotel rooms for the winter. The justification to use nine hundred thousand dollars in opioid settlement funds feels like misappropriation or assumes that all individuals that need a warming shelter are struggling with substance use. This is a false narrative. I ask the city to take a broader view. With the increased fuel costs, property taxes, and cost of living, many Portland residents are already choosing between heat, food, and shelter. Some will lose their homes, some already have. Others who choose housing over heat may also need a warming shelter this winter. I'm appalled at the failure to move forward with the warming shelter at Elena's Way. By only considering locations that are outside the peninsula, we are making a conscious decision to leave people sleeping in doorways of homes and businesses in Bayside. This choice puts everyone in the community at risk and significantly increases both direct and emergency costs. I want less of my tax money wasted on enforcing loitering laws and garbage removal and more on bringing people inside and away that are accessible to them. Otherwise, we're just throwing money in the wind. I hope that next year you will identify a city-managed space downtown to offer interested non-profits. A quick search of the tax assessor's database shows that the city owns many more properties than the ones considered for this project. Expecting non-profits to be able to access or afford property in Portland is unrealistic. I hope this council will identify a less expensive plan that allows individuals to access shelter on the peninsula. Thank you very much for your time. [1:13:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide public comment on these orders? Step to the mic. [1:14:06] Speaker Z (unidentified): Mayor Dayan, City Council, thank you for taking the time [1:14:08] Speaker A (unidentified): to hear me tonight. You can adjust the mic up to your height. There you go. Good call, Mr. Mayor. [1:14:13] Speaker Z (unidentified): That's why you're the mayor. Alright, so my name is Ryan Page. I am a personal long-term recovery and the co-founder and director of client and Community Relations for Access Direct Recovery Network. We are a 501c3 nonprofit who is headquartered with our call center in Biddeford. We offer 24-7 call services for individuals struggling with substance use and alcohol use disorders to find direct access to treatment options statewide. We currently receive roughly 3,000 calls a month statewide with nearly 25% of those calls coming from the city of Portland, whether from people who are unhoused going into common space or from the living room, Spermink living room. So lots of calls are coming from Portland and they're asking for lots of things but I can tell you one thing they're not asking for is if they can find a warming shelter. They're looking for detoxes, they're looking for treatment options, they're looking to get into sober living and there is no funding currently in the city of Portland allocated for them to get that. These opiate settlement funds are a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for us to use that fund to help people to get out of the grips of the addiction and to live happier, healthier, more productive lives. So I think it's an egregious waste of the funds to put $900,000 into a warming shelter that will be open for six months with no forward plan. Also, I would like to just note that the City of Portland, I think, operated this last year and from all accounts did a horrible job doing so I say that to say this that if I as a person coming to you was to say I need some funding and this is the thing I'm going to do and I'll come back to you in a year council and I'll tell you how it went I went I got the money I came back and gave the same report that the city of Portland gave coming back last year on how they operated with that funding and how they operated that shelter and then said yeah this is how I did, it was horrible. However, if you give me triple the amount of funding this year, I'll do better. I wouldn't stand a chance to get any funding. I'd be laughed out of the room. I think it's insane that the city of Poland has the opportunity to come back with the same kind of plan, the same track record, and even considered for funding. So that being said, I just really hope you guys come up with some better options. People need chances and options to get help. I think that if we had more people using that funding getting help we'd have less people looking for warming centers and I think that would help on their what it would cost to obviously open a warming center so that being said I'll leave it to you guys thank you so much no [1:17:00] Speaker A (unidentified): no you don't do any of that for against we do you talk to him I don't do bathrooms good evening folks [1:17:17] Speaker AA (unidentified): My name is Eugene Thorne. I am an advocate for our unhoused here in Portland. I'm also a former housing counselor at the Homeless Services Center. Mary Dinah, it's great to see you again. Good to see you. so i worked the i worked the warming shelter a couple times last winter and i've got to say staff the director the assistant director the director of the family shelter they did the best job that they could with what they were given my concern with these two options is the first option, adding more beds to the HSC. That is going to create absolute pandemonium. I mean, after working there and it's already tight, we've already added extra beds to accommodate even more of our folks. Adding more, even for an extra six months, that's going to make it more difficult for the staff and for our shelter guests. The second option, while I don't like it, 's the better option, I believe, because we also have, I think I read a very large number of folks that have been criminally trespassed from the HSC. These are folks that are not going to be able to access the shelter if there's a warming shelter there. I did read that State Street Church was also granted money from Maine Housing to open an 18-bed warming shelter. I don't know if that is actually happening or not but even still we have more folks that can't access the HSC than those 18 beds so even 18 beds is not going to be enough I just ask that y'all please take into consideration our folks that can't access the HSC because these are the folks that aren't literally going to have nowhere else to go so I thank you for your time and for your consideration anyone else wish to [1:19:36] Speaker A (unidentified): to provide comment on these orders. [1:19:44] Speaker I (unidentified): Good evening. My name is Megan Del Nero Moore, but I will be reading someone else's testament tonight. My name is Rylan Najim, and I am writing as someone in long-term recovery and as someone who has experienced the devastating consequences of the opioid epidemic firsthand. I lost both my mother and my brother to the disease of addiction, and I have watched countless friends, families, and members of our community suffer alongside them. The opioid settlement funds exist because of that suffering. Families lost their children, parents, siblings, spouses, and friends. People lost years of their lives to addiction and many never had the opportunity to recover. These funds represent an opportunity to address some of the enormous harm caused by the opioid crisis and to strengthen the systems that could prevent other families from experiencing the same losses. I absolutely believe that people experiencing homelessness deserve access to a safe, warm place to sleep. A warming shelter is a basic human need and an important responsibility for our community, but funding that basic need should be appropriately planned for within municipal and other dedicated funding sources, not taken from a limited pool of opioid settlement dollars intended to address the impacts of the opioid epidemic. Substance use disorder already remains drastically under-resourced. People continue to struggle to access detox services, residential treatment, medication for opioid use disorder, recovery housing, outpatient treatment, harm reduction services, and long-term recovery supports. Families still encounter the same devastating barriers to care that have cost so many people their lives. Opioid settlement dollars provide a rare opportunity to build and expand those resources. Using these funds to cover expenses that would otherwise need to be addressed through the city's general budget risks replacing existing public obligations rather than creating additional substance use disorder resources these settlements were intended to provide. A warming shelter and substance use disorder treatment are both important. They should not have to compete against one another for funding. My mother and my brother cannot benefit from these settlement dollars and neither can thousands of other Mainers whose lives were lost during the opioid epidemic. But the people struggling today can. Their families can. We have an obligation to use this opportunity to make treatment, medication, harm reduction, and other evidence-based services more accessible so that fewer families experiences the losses that mine has. I respectfully ask that Portland protect opioid settlement funds for initiatives that directly address substance use disorder and the harms caused by the opioid epidemic and identify sustainable funding for warming shelters through the appropriate municipal, state, federal, and community resources. Rylan Najim, thank you. [1:22:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide comment? [1:22:43] Speaker L (unidentified): Good evening, Mayor Dion and members of the Portland City Council. My name is Courtney Gary Allen. I am the executive director of the Maine Recovery Action Project, also known as MIRAP. We're a grassroots network of Mainers working on community and public policy-based solutions to substance use. I'm here tonight to urge to express our concerns for using opiate settlement funds to fill city budget gaps. We want to be clear, we strongly support Portland's operating a nightly warming center. These shelters provide life-saving refuge for Mainers during some of the coldest nights, and we recognize their importance to communities statewide. At the same time we must remember why opiate settlement funds exist. Pharmaceutical companies knowingly misrepresented and downplayed the addictive risks of prescription opiates while profiting from their sale. These funds represent a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to address the devastating and lasting harms of the opiate crisis. We have held more than 50 community listening sessions with people across Maine including here in Portland to hear directly from people with lived and living experience of substance use disorder. While Maine has made meaningful progress in expanding access to treatment services for substance use, there are still significant gaps remaining. Many folks still struggle to access inpatient and residential treatment, care for co-occurring disorders with substance use disorder and mental health conditions, employment and safe housing. These funds are finite and mostly front-loaded. committing such a substantial amount to fill an operating budget gap carries real opportunity costs including reducing resources available for prevention treatment recovery and harm reduction services it also risks setting a statewide precedent for using opiate settlement funds to cover large budget shortfalls resulting from planning failures at a time of growing fiscal pressures, sponsored stewardship is essential. We urge the Portland City Council to seek an alternative funding source to fill the budget gap at their at your selected location. If opiate settlement funds are utilized, the city should minimize the expenditure and provide a transparent detailed budget of the costs associated with opiate settlement funds. If the city selects the HSC for the location, we urge the council to look for winter warming options for folks that cannot access this location. Lives are at stake. We can support a life-saving winter warming shelter while also insisting that opiate settlement funds can be carefully invested in programs that mitigate the harms associated with the opiate crisis. Thank you for your consideration. [1:25:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide public comment on these orders. [1:25:47] Speaker AB (unidentified): Good evening. Mayor Dayan, City Manager Danielle West and members of the council. My name is Terrence Miller and I'm the Advocacy Director at Preble Street and I'm speaking tonight on behalf of Preble Street. Preble Street appreciates the city's continued efforts to secure and operate a winter warming shelter this year. With the large number of people unsheltered in Portland it is imperative that the City of Portland has a warming shelter opening as planned on November Preble Street strongly encourages the City to identify solutions that make the shelter as accessible as possible for everyone who needs it. As we have seen, an off-peninsula location for the shelter presents significant barriers for many individuals who are the most in need of a warming shelter. While we understand that there are plans for expanded shuttle services, we recommend extending the schedule late into the night. Late night shuttles operating every hour will be essential to avoid leaving people stranded in extreme cold without shelter. Ensuring that vulnerable people can reach the warming shelter no matter what the weather is or what time it is will save lives. If the location for the warming shelter is at the city's homeless service center, there needs to be a creative solution for the 60 or so individuals on the criminal trespass order list. The hope would be that each of these 60 individuals could be assessed to determine if an appeal of their CTO is warranted. Without this process, that is 60 people who would not be able to take shelter on a freezing cold night or during a winter storm. Finally, we are extremely concerned about the possibility of a warming shelter not opening until December 15th or even January 1st, 2027. last winter the first measurable snowfall came 30 seconds second thank you we encourage the city to explore any and all staffing options to ensure this resource is available as soon as possible it is imperative that people don't freeze to death on our streets we share the city's goal of keeping people safe and warm this winter and look forward to continual collaboration to make this possible. Thank you. [1:28:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide public comment? Chairs inquiring how many other individuals are going to speak? [1:29:03] Speaker L (unidentified): Hello my name is Daniela Liberty I've been a provider on the peninsula for 20 years. The truth is that we need a warming shelter on the peninsula. We know every year that it gets cold and people have potential to freeze to death. One of those options will likely be chosen from the ones that we've discussed today, but I honestly think they both have really major drawbacks such as restrictions, such as costs, such as not being open to volunteers and per diem staff to cut the cost down. I'm also a realist and we don't want people to freeze to death, but I have to say the use of the opioid settlement funds is not okay. It's blood money from Big Pharma. The opioid crisis ravaged generations of families. Orphaned children left their grandparents raising grandkids. It healed many of our friends and it continues to. You have peers, harm reductionists, and the recovery community asking you why aren't we using the money for its intended purpose. It's not meant to fill a funding gap. You missed a great opportunity with an amazing organization, has successfully run a warming shelter in another county. I don't understand how that fell apart. This is a room full of very, smart people. I know many of you personally, both behind me and in front of me. I don't understand why every year we keep coming back. We know that it gets cold and we need to find a long-term solution to this problem. Thank you. [1:30:48] Speaker AC (unidentified): Good evening. My name is Joshua Leonard. I'm a resident on the West End. So first, I do want to thank very much our colleagues in the community who are operating warming shelters in service for the unhoused, because obviously the need is there. I think any of us can walk around the streets of Portland and see the need, and it seems to be growing in pretty significant form. One thing that I do want to consider, too, is kind of a counterbalance of what, you know, nine hundred thousand dollars could go to kind of in a different context so the main association of recovery residences operates a housing subsidy services program which is basically a barrier to entry fund that will cover approximately two months depending on the person's circumstance for funding so they can get into a recovery house you know when they can't afford to $2,000 would kind of on average I think it might be a little bit more but $2,000 could potentially cover the cost for one person to be able to have two months of continuous housing but not only have the continuous housing one thing that we do know for sure and I think it's an important component for people to keep in mind housing first does not mean housing only. The importance of getting people housed is a first step in a much more in-depth process. Integration into additional services, whether it's mental health, addiction services, and the quality of those services is vitally important to be able to make that happen. And those are the things that are happening in recovery houses throughout the state of Maine. MAR has just certified, or we're going to be certifying hopefully by the end of the year, 130 recovery houses here in the state of Maine, which is unbelievable considering in 2020 it was about 40. So these numbers are critically, important. And it really kind of pains me because I give all of you the utmost credit in the world for taking a seat on this dais and having to face these issues because I know I don't have the strength to be able to deal with that but we're gonna find ourselves year over year becoming a triage center here in the state of Maine instead of kind of addressing these issues kind of at its core 30 seconds and I really do think there needs to be a directive at some point where we start steering to a solution based system here we need to get ample funding for recovery services up here. And as far as the opioid abatement fund, it was set up here and it's important to note that not everybody who is unhoused suffers from substance use disorder. It's opioid abatement funds. So that in and of itself is kind of an admission. We probably shouldn't hit the pause on this. So thank you. [1:33:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else wishing to provide comment? Yeah, [1:34:03] Speaker AD (unidentified): hi, Mayor Dayan, councillors. My name is Nick. I, it blows my mind we're here again. People are, like, we didn't, winter didn't get invented yesterday. Like, this isn't a new thing. We keep doing this every year. Oh, let's find emergency funding, let's find emergency funding. And then when the council fails their fiduciary responsibility to appropriately really steward the taxpayer money again year after year after year or maybe they intentionally didn't fund the warming center because it's not a priority for council that's fine too if that's the case then just say so that doesn't then give you the right to go and pillage our blood money for something that is a viable resource but should be in if the city wants to prioritize it prioritize it your budget you have a 360 million dollar budget prioritize it if it's clearly it's not a priority because every single year you fail to prioritize it and then now we us people who were victimized by these pharmaceutical companies who have these monies to get new services and new options for people and new prevention initiatives that didn't exist before that we can build capital to move forward with to continue to abate these harms and to prevent this from happening through another generation we fall on the hook because councils and it's not just you guys, it's all over the state and all over the country, decides that we're just the piggy bank jar that they're going to dip into and steal our money. This is not normal taxpayer money that you guys have responsibility for like every other taxpayer money. This is not some, like, thing that's going to be on some pot of money that's ongoing forever. This is a finite resource that we have an opportunity to do something with, and it's for us to put capital towards recovery harm reduction prevention and how and whatever the other pillar is and it's not to be pillaged like this you guys are gonna make vote on one of these two horrible options anyway regardless of what any of us say tonight so like that's fine I know how this works but like figure it out either a homeless warming shelter during the winter is a priority for the city of portland and it gets put into the annual budget or it's not and then you tell the public this is not a priority for us we're not funding it too bad figure it out stand on what you're prioritizing a budget is a moral document and you guys have clearly continued to 30 seconds for this and so now it's coming to us and it's our money and we're not going to just like sit around and let all these councils all over the state steal it from us this is for us to do what we think we need to do with it and not for council to just take when they can't figure out a budget on their own so you say if portland doesn't have a lot of any money you're 360 million dollars to mess with so figure it out anyone [1:37:01] Speaker A (unidentified): else wishing to provide comment all right then public comment is closed chair would seek a motion in a second patch order 74 24, 26, 27, as an emergency that will require. Second. Moved by Councillor Ali, seconded by Councillor Phillips. Discussion by the council. Go ahead, Councillor Pelletier. [1:37:42] Speaker AE (unidentified): Last year, I was in HHS and asked if we needed a coordinator because every year we struggle to get a warming shelter off the ground, and I was told point blank, we do not. THIS HAS BEEN A DEEPLY FRUSTRATING PROCESS, HAVING WATCHED IT FROM THE OUTSIDE. EVERY YEAR WE AGAIN GET SURPRISED THAT IT'S WINTER AND THEN PANIC, AND SO THIS YEAR I FELT GOOD. WE WERE TOLD THAT WE HAD A PLAN, THAT WE WERE GOING TO HAVE AN OUTSIDE PROVIDER, AND THAT WE DID NOT NEED TO ALLOCATE BUDGET MONEY. THAT WAS INCORRECT, AND THAT IS ON ME. I my trust and staff to be able to provide accurate information has been deeply shaken these the laws that made Elena's way Difficult to do or passed two years ago They should not have been surprising And yet, you know, I should have looked him up. I guess I assumed that someone would and I was wrong in that and by the time we were notified that it was not possible we were up against a deadline I have absolute certainty we will be here next year we'll be doing this exact same thing next year because there is not a will on staff from the city manager to put changes in place to get a project coordinator I will be pushing for that and perhaps we'll get something like that it is clear that there is that the two hands of the city are not talking to each other I do not think that I can I know that I cannot give a million dollars of opiate settlement funds to Kevin bunker I will not be voting for that I do not think that I can vote to do a really flawed plan at the HSC and we are in a position where I have to basically decide do I sell do I sentence people to death this winter or a much larger amount of people by throwing away these opioid settlement funds it's not a good position to be in I right now I'm leaning on voting no on both we need to find other sources of funding and I know that they have been offered from municipalities it has not really been a priority to find those other sources of funding because again i think it is a piggy bank we often the city views use this as a as something we just take money from and that's not appropriate and i really regret being in this position any [1:40:35] Speaker A (unidentified): other comments from the council sex [1:40:38] Kate Sykes: can i just clarify we're talking about the emergency order the loaded emergency for hsc that's correct okay and we'll discuss the other orders later okay thank you i don't have a [1:40:50] Speaker S (unidentified): question any [1:40:53] Speaker A (unidentified): other comments council [1:40:59] Speaker F (unidentified): boy sorry i'm trying to figure out if this is one of the ones with an amendment no i [1:41:09] Speaker A (unidentified): have to respond to council pelletier i appreciate his frustration administration, but staff has done everything they could do. There was a miscommunication about a legal status regarding the number of people that could stay at Helena's Way. What's also involved is the public, the neighborhood, did not want to see it there. The operator declared they no longer wanted to participate because it seems all so political. My reaction is, what in Portland isn't political? All right, so they decided, they were coming from a very small venue, trying to step up to Portland. They made a decision at the final hour when staff and I were trying to convince them to stay on as we tried to work out funding for MESHA, the Maine State Housing Authority. Here's some realities for us to check as we go through these orders. orders. We hired a commercial broker. Staff went to numerous spaces. And for those of you who work in a shelter, you know line of sight is important in order to provide a safe environment. There are very few pieces of property on the Peninsula that provide that access. All right? We want it to be accessible, but we also recognize it may not be for some, so we have to look at transportation, and we're still negotiating that piece. I just want to underscore the fact. A program coordinator could have come in last, pick a day, last February. It would be to no avail. Councilor Bullett and I met with 17 of the key providers in the city, and they're all in a position they wouldn't have been able to help anyways, period. They don't have the space. Their staff is stretched. Their budgets are stretched. There has never been any vote by the general public to stand up a second shelter. There was a motion by one councillor in the last budget cycle to assign some monies to do this and then that was withdrawn and there were good reasons at that time. So I rail at this idea that we can just like fumbling along for the last number of months and oh my God, it's winter again. we know the very day that spring arrives winter's coming back all right so it's a disservice to staff and for those of us who work on this issue all the time to sit down with people to give them a sales pitch to say you need to help out and they go I feel it but we can't get involved and I'm not going to demean the reasons why they don't but they don't all right I've been to the cities to talk to the mayors, they hear what's going on. And I think privately they're happy they don't have that issue in their city. One shelter outside of Portland sent us a communication saying they hoped we'd resolve this so it doesn't have a spillover in their shelter system. Okay? And frankly, the legislature has shown no interest and we battle and we've gone to administrative court to secure funds for shelter operations. operations. So this idea that we would hire somebody and that they could just run through all the paths I've just told you and come back and say, you know what, nobody really wants a shelter. And if we broke up the shelters and send them to each neighborhood, then I welcome all of you to go with me and the district counselor and ask those neighbors, where shall we site it? The HSC on Riverside Street was a result of nine years of meeting, nine years, which every part of the city pushed back saying they didn't want it so if you don't agree someone on this council doesn't agree with the allocation of funds that's a reasonable and rational position to take but i rail at this idea that we're here once again because staff somehow has missed the boat all right winter warming shelters is a city council policy if we want to pass a policy directly and funded then so be it but none of this council or previous councils have ever allocated monies on this particular issue we all labor under the idea that our community partners will step up so with that unless there's [1:45:32] Benjamin Grant: any other comment council grant Thank You mr. mayor break this up into kind of past, present, future. I think we are here centrally because the old model of the community source warming shelter, that model has failed fully and finally. We patched that together. We, meaning the city, I've only been here for two years, but the city has patched that together for years. And it's finally, you know, come up empty. so while I'm frustrated I share the frustrations of a lot of people here I'm not frustrated at anyone in particular there's an old saying that victory has a thousand fathers and defeat is an orphan that's where we are right here this defeat is an orphan, no one owns it other than this whole community owns it together so we're left with no good options here tonight because the people up here have tried very hard for many months to find something to work and they haven't found a solution sometimes you just can't pound any water out of the rock if there's none there to be found so we have solutions here that are imperfect we all agree but we're gonna have to pick one I'm probably gonna side with the HSC model because that at least allows us some opportunity to potentially recoup some money and save some money from the opioid settlement funds. I think that was a persuasive argument. It's not what I want to do. I think there's also time for staff to keep working on it. Winter isn't here yet, so I'm sure that's not what they want to hear, but there is more time to keep having meetings and talking to people in the community. Maybe someone will turn up. I keep hearkening back to all the self-congratulation from people in the community around the pilot discussion about all the great services that are provided in this community and we need somebody now and no one has stepped up that's just a fact of life setting my frustrations aside i think the most important thing is actually reflected in the last gentleman's comments is what are we going to do about this in the future and i think the mayor is right we do have to bring this back to the budget process to have an honest and open discussion with this community are we going to do this on the city budget because the community model here is not working this clearly doesn't work right it's antagonize everybody we have to have an honest discussion in the budget next year is this going to be funded through the taxpayers or not let's have an open honest conversation about that I'm committing to having that conversation on the Finance Committee and I look forward to sorting it out then so I'll just I'll just stop there I think we have to get out of this year as best we can look to the future and do some serious long-term budget planning open discussion with the community so this isn't just put on staff in the spring and say the clock is ticking see if we can fix it fully and finally so I'll just leave it there thank you for the time anyone else [1:48:43] Speaker F (unidentified): wishing to comment council bullet thanks mayor all right I am going to say a couple things and then I will focus on 70 order 74 which sounds like a Star our worst thing when I say it like that but so I want to be really clear I think I speak for the entire council when I say that we don't love either of the options in front of us tonight for those who follow HHS committee meetings there were in-depth conversations about a variety of things you likely know that we made clear our commitment to winter warming and we made clear that commitment in June we also made clear that it would be nightly and that ideally it would be on the peninsula sadly we don't have a magical building that meets life safety code at our beck and call and even more unfortunately the Preble Street property that seemed to fit the bill and entered into an agreement for winter warming and we thought was going to work was not actually legally allowed to be used for that use and then on top of that they failed a licensing inspection. If you follow the finance committee you know that a very significant portion of the municipal budget goes to sheltering operations. Portland shelters and feeds two meals a day to over 400 people a night. Last year, 1,600 unique individuals were sheltered by the City of Portland. This is all in the municipal budget, and it costs over $16 million out of our budget. So to say that the council does not prioritize sheltering is quite frankly offensive. We spend a lot on sheltering, and we spend a lot of our time and our emotional energy meeting with the community to ensure that we're doing it right and doing it to the best of our ability. and still we're here. Let me remind everyone that also we raised taxes five percent and still had to lay off 74 city staff to balance the budget. So at the risk of sounding like a broken record I continue to say that I continue to be flabbergasted that the county government declines to serve as a partner in any sheltering solutions despite having its own public health department and their own tax income the mayor mentioned that we met with a huge group in of community partners on Thursday I want to let you know that the county was invited and they weren't there for the purposes of ensuring warming sheltering happens and happens nightly as soon as possible this year I'm focusing on the task in front of us tonight and so we're on order 74 which concerns the HSC and to that end I have some questions for the assistant city manager if she doesn't mind so my first question is, yeah, do we have a motion? [1:51:14] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you. We do have a motion on the floor, Counselor. Fantastic, okay. [1:51:22] Speaker F (unidentified): So my question is concerning folks that have a criminal trespass order. Should we open the HSC? What does that, what are our options? And I guess this is probably a question for Corporation Counsel and for Assistant City Manager Libner. I want to know our legal options for maybe reversing CTS and then I also want to know what that means for our staffing if you don't mind I [1:51:50] Speaker Q (unidentified): think addressing those specific issues involves potentially confidential information that would be best shared in an executive session is [1:52:06] Speaker F (unidentified): it within the scope of our ability to remove someone's criminal trespass order or is it unique to each individual one it is not something that the council [1:52:17] Speaker Q (unidentified): or any member of the council has the authority to do great that's the answer i was looking for [1:52:22] Speaker F (unidentified): thank you and then in terms of staffing if there was a magical legal wand that allowed people with who had been ct'd to be at the hsc does that have implications for our work what's it called working conditions for our union staff members at the hsc that [1:52:47] Speaker Q (unidentified): is an issue that would be best discussed in executive session are you a lawyer sorry is [1:52:58] Speaker F (unidentified): there a way to answer it in a hypothetical i'm trying to find out if like we're going to have a way to shelter folks that have been ct'd i just need like a bottom if the answer is no say no if the answer is yes say yes [1:53:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Counselor, if you would yield the floor, may I ask a Corporation Counsel a question? Insofar as the criminal trespass orders, they are attached or they have legal significance only at a particular address, correct? [1:53:31] Speaker Q (unidentified): As a general concept, yes. I have not seen any of the criminal trespass orders related to the Home and Service Center. [1:53:37] Speaker A (unidentified): We are just talking in a general sense. Yes. Yes. So I asked that question on the premise that Mark Dion could have a CTO issue shoot against him for purposes of preventing me from entering the space of the HSC because I may or may not have been involved in physical violence directed at staff or others. Mark Dion goes to 166 Industrial Parkway. If the CTO was geographically specific to the HSC, am I barred from entering a warming shelter on the Industrial Parkway? [1:54:11] Speaker Q (unidentified): No, Mayor, you're not. [1:54:14] Speaker A (unidentified): I know sorry who said no okay please you kill the whole thing if you don't let him don't ruin my moment right it'd be like examining a witness and having the jury comment it might make me feel good but it's not good all right so that's part of the discussion that's been occurring in senior staff is how to manage the CTOs does geography as to where they get warm count it may but in terms of specific individuals, advice of counsel is we really can't discuss it at any length because each case is fact-specific. Is that helpful, Counselor? That's very helpful. [1:54:55] Speaker F (unidentified): And this is important because this informs my, as much as the HSC makes sense for certain reasons, right? We have food service. We have showers. We have readily available staff. For me, it's really important that this even more highly vulnerable population has a space that they can go to for winter warming. So I don't support HSC as a solution. And to that end, I won't be supporting Star Wars Order 74. No, I'm kidding. Order 74. [1:55:25] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Any other comments? Councilor Sykes, then Councilor Ali. Thank you, Mayor. [1:55:34] Kate Sykes: Thank you for clarifying. That was wonderful. That helped me understand how we're going to work through all of these. I just want to say that I have watched this for the last several months with just absolute frustration, of course, because we've had some terrible impasses, but also just gratitude for my fellow councillors who, if you are not catching this, we're making sure every single person is in a warming shelter, every single person. That's what we're caring about right here. Not great funding source, wish we could use that money for something else, but I don't think there's any problem with the political will of this council wanting to make sure that our constituents are safe the people in our community are safe every one of them i also will not be supporting this order because i don't think the hsc is the right place to house this particular community again not a great solution but i think that's where we're at i think it's also one other thing i just want to say is that while we'll be using a significant chunk of money that is really not what we want to use it for it is moving us towards a solution that I think, as Councillor Grant has said, has been apparent more and more so over the last couple of years. The community of non-profits and non-government organizations are not capable of doing this. This is something that only government can do, and I think we are clear-eyed about this now. We're going to have to figure this out for ourselves, and this is one step down the path of being able to do that the right way, hopefully next year. Thank [1:57:09] Speaker T (unidentified): you, Councillor. I don't know who will answer this question, but how much is left of the opiate certainty? How much do we have in our coffers? [1:57:18] Speaker A (unidentified): How much do we have in the opiate salary? Yeah. [1:57:23] Speaker U (unidentified): I believe we have about a million or just under a million uncommitted dollars left in the fund. [1:57:31] Speaker T (unidentified): And the Cooperation Council, is there any legal reason why we cannot use this for the warming shelter? [1:57:42] Speaker Q (unidentified): No, our office has reviewed the uses and determined that this is an allowable use. [1:57:48] Speaker T (unidentified): There's no list of things that, because I, from my understanding, maybe settlements have some restrictions on you can use it for these days. is maybe bare people who have lived experience to a program or this thing. Is there anything like that attached to this? [1:58:03] Speaker Q (unidentified): There is a list of uses, and that's how the determination was made, that it is an allowable use. Okay. [1:58:12] Speaker T (unidentified): If, for what, I'm struggling if I should support this, but if for whatever reason we don't use the opiate settlement, are we able to find money from somewhere? I don't know where, but I'm just asking. Maybe assistance in that area. [1:58:29] Speaker Q (unidentified): I'll punt on that one. Yeah. [1:58:32] Speaker U (unidentified): So the only funding, right now there's no funding appropriated for this use. Order 68 and 70 both appropriate funding for it to be operated at different locations. If order 74 passed and funding wasn't appropriated for it, staff could we may ask the finance director to look at other potential sources but right now nothing has been identified as a way to fund this program. [1:59:03] Speaker T (unidentified): Incorporation Council I'm going to ask a question if I start you may know what I'm going to ask if I cannot ask it here you can ask me too. There's been questions in public and two people have asked me direct. that 166, right? Or is it 167? [1:59:25] Speaker Q (unidentified): 166 Riverside Industrial Park, yeah,. [1:59:27] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah, 166 was funded or paid for by the state. Why are we, can I ask that question, or? [1:59:36] Speaker Q (unidentified): You can, yeah, there's nothing confidential about that. [1:59:38] Speaker T (unidentified): Okay, was paid for by state money. Why are we being asked to pay again to use it? [1:59:46] Speaker Q (unidentified): the that was a separate grant agreement the city was not a party to that it was a grant agreement between main housing and developers collaborative one of their entities and it required a three year commitment to operate a shelter there and that time period has passed so the grant obligations have been met as far as I understand and there's no further obligation to use that building [2:00:20] Speaker T (unidentified): for public use. So basically it's like saying that you're gonna buy a bicycle for me and I can carry water around Portland and give it to people after three years I'm not obligated to do any of the obligation that comes with me riding that bicycle and giving out free water. [2:00:43] Speaker Q (unidentified): I mean I think in essence we Again, it's not something... The city right now has no rights whatsoever with respect to that property. Any decisions made about the use of it are determined by the current owner, which is... It's a developer's collaborative entity, an LLC. [2:01:06] Speaker T (unidentified): So the city does not have anything? [Speaker Q (unidentified): Correct,.] I just want that clarification publicly so that those that ask me will... if they are watching i did my what i'm supposed to do i asked publicly so correct if we were [2:01:21] Speaker Q (unidentified): to have if we were to use that building we would have to rent it just like any other tenant would [2:01:25] Speaker T (unidentified): okay thank you very much council phillips i [2:01:32] Speaker A (unidentified): didn't see you did you hand okay all right [2:01:34] Speaker D (unidentified): go ahead council thank you counselor thank you mr mayor so but where is the money i mean, Seeds of Hope, I always want to call them Seeds of Peace. Seeds of Hope was the applicant, right? They have decided that they obviously don't want to play in the sandbox with us. So where is that money? Have we had conversations with Maine State Housing regarding that money and if we're eligible for some of it? [2:02:00] Speaker U (unidentified): In conversations with Misha, they've said that money will be available to the city of Portland because they want a warming shelter. They want to support a warming shelter for individuals in the city. [2:02:10] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, and how much is that? it's 295,000 okay I had another question but I can't remember it thank you [2:02:20] Speaker H (unidentified): also for now thank you I won't rehash what my colleagues have said because I think we have shared our collective frustration but I also want to note we started actually having conversations about expending these opioid settlement funds in 2024 and so after having lots of conversations with people with lived experience with providers and with operators, we came up with the top three solutions of what we agreed would be most useful for use of these funds. So day space, seed funding for an on peninsula methadone clinic, and then a syringe buyback program. And so we've been successfully able to start and administer the syringe buyback program. We have never found an operator or partner for day space that you could use one-time funding to sustain over time because as my budget director finance director has always taught me you don't want to do ongoing operational expenses with one-time funding we learned that with arpa and so for me it's very difficult to look at this fund that we know has a finite life there is an end to it to look at an operating rating expense. But I also think at this point where we're at, we, as my other fellow councillors have said, we want to take care of everybody. And so when we look at this emergency order to expand the HSC, it excludes part of our population that can't access the shelter. And is it the best and highest use of these funds? No. But we also don't have, as Councillor Bullett mentioned, we don't have county support or funding. Unfortunately, the federal administration we have in power right now, this is not a community. They are interested in helping, and we have seen grants and additional fundings be pulled back from there. We've also seen money from the state be rolled back because of the loss in federal funding. So we're in this very awful position until conditions change that if we want to provide shelter and support and we're changing our model also from last year last year it was threshold based now we're moving to we want to operate this seven days a week from hopefully November through April so that is also a huge change in cost and resources in places that will support this to make sure that we're able to support the largest number of people so while I don't love any of our options and I do think this needs to be absolutely a budget item that we're looking at moving forward we also have to think about all of the other sources of revenue that come in to make sure that we don't inadvertently additionally burden all of our other taxpayers in Portland and it's not just the people who are like yes I can absolutely afford to pay more we have lots of single-parent families we have lots of service industry workers. We have lots of people who are working in places that they can barely afford to stay here. And so if we are continuing to raise taxes on everyone, we're going to also displace many more people. And so that's why these discussions are really, hard. We can't just look at a piece of property and say, yes, we're going to spend $15 million on this property and open up a new day space. We've tried to do that. We have no one that's willing to come to the table and partner with us, at least for the last two years that we've tried to do that. And so I'm not in support of the emergency order. I don't want to move forward with the HSC option. I think 166 is going to be our best solution out of what we have available in front of us. Thank you. [2:06:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Councillor McNavis. Thank you Mayor. [2:06:15] Speaker O (unidentified): I don't have a whole lot to add to what my colleagues have said they've kind of covered everything that I would have to say except to just say one more time that this we really did try this was a long haul of planning and there was no, this was never not on the HHS committee's radar, never. I mean, this came up at every turn. And I think this speaks to, it just speaks to the challenge of doing this and trying to pull this together. It's a hard thing to pull together a short time use and, you know, just for six months for anything. anything. I think there's also a part of, I would hope, of all of us that thinks, well, we would rather use this on permanent solutions. We would rather use this for getting people inside and getting people treatment long term. But the reality is that this money is usable for this and the committee did explicitly determine that this was going to be a use that we would have it there for now we didn't think we would have to use it in this way or to the extent that we are the mission money was the first pass but it is where we've ended up I can't get behind the HSC simply because the folks that are trespassed need a place to go and I also want to really acknowledge what it the challenge that it creates for staff when the when the HSC does have extra beds in it 's you know I 'm sure plenty of folks out here remember the days of the of the Oxford Street shelter and what it's like when there is an overcrowding situation and the you know the health and safety risks that come with that it's it's not just as simple as adding beds so I hate to do it but I think 166 is going to be the solution the other the other idea that came up was throughout this process was the idea of like transport to community partners you maybe don't have full capacity but who have some beds. The overflow plan from the original Elena's Way plan was to transport overflow folks to Milestone or to the living room or to the HSC. And so that was an idea that I held interest for me, was if we're going to spend money on transportation anyway, are we able to transport people to specific partners? partners, and none of them would be fully taking on the load, it would just be a handful of folks in either direction. That's a whole other logistical challenge, and there's no doubt it would be really difficult. But at the end of the day, I think in order to most efficiently utilize these funds, that 166 is what we have to do. The only saving grace that I would say is that moving forward, the HHS committee has agreed to create, I guess for lack of a better word, what's called a task force right now. That would be aimed at creating some solutions on the public safety and homelessness spectrum. and that 's an opportunity to drill down on this and for what to look at the bigger picture bigger picture of why this fails and where warming shelter fits into that whole constellation of services or doesn't or who pays for it and having that as a broader conversation with the entire community and with the county and I'm it just it has to be that bigger conversation because as has been pointed out we're not getting there on our own. So I wish we weren't in this position but we are and I am not going to support increasing the number of beds at Riverside, I'm sorry at the HSC. Councillor Phillips. [2:10:44] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you Mr. Mayor. I am not going to say anything differently than what my colleagues have said other than I'm looking at this in a couple of different ways one love to have the conversation in finance regarding the city's budget I'm not willing to have the conversation with the city regarding putting this in the budget if folks aren't gonna come along with us right I mean councillor grant I think you mentioned the fact that we had the option of doing a pilot I was one of them ones that voted it down and because not the nonprofits came to us and said we're there we're here with you and now we find out there was 17 conversations with non-profits and none of them are here we haven't had any conversations with them no one's coming forward to say hey remember us thank you for doing the pilot we're here and we're supporting you right so that's one thing I think that unfortunately we have to continue to have conversations with them and I don't know what that looks like Mr. Mayor but again I think that they we have to try to figure out how they can come to the table and they can support us especially if we're going to have a conversation about it regarding the city budget it the other thing again other people have mentioned is the county the county has to come forward i don't know how we make i don't know how we make them accountable either maybe that's through the governor's office maybe that's through legislators or senators i don't know what that looks like but i've heard several councillors tonight say that the county isn't anywhere to be found either the minute you mention the county they crawl under a rock and so therefore again love to have the conversation but we need to have a conversation with the county and I know we've had these conversations. I know we've had it. And then the other thing is that we've mentioned is the state. Thank you, Maine Housing, for giving us $300,000, but we need $1.2. And so, again, as we sit here and we talk about this issue and we talk about the unhoused and we talk about the homeless, we talk about those who are suffering from substance abuse, it's not just a Portland issue. This is not just a Portland issue. It is not just folks in Portland that are coming to the warming shelter. And so again, this is only going to work if we have nonprofits, if we have common county or the county, if we have the state that comes together with the city to try to figure out this state problem. Not a Portland problem, a state problem. I am also not going to be supporting this. Not only am I concerned about the CTOs, but I'm also concerned about the numbers. We have more than 50. We already know we have more than 50, so again, I think what councilors say, there is no great option. There isn't. Here we are, it's November 2nd, and we don't have any great options. We are out of options, and so the other option that I think we're out of is going to the Warm List Service Center, and so I will not be supporting that either. [2:13:33] Benjamin Grant: Councilor Grant. I've got a quick question. I wanted to interrogate one of the stats that was brought up earlier, and that's the number of people with trespass orders, for anyone who can answer. Is that just the number of people we know who have received them after bad behavior, or is that number tied in any way to those who we know who are also on the street right now? [2:13:57] Speaker U (unidentified): The total number of people who have been trespassed for the shelter primarily due to violent behavior is 52 right now. Staff ran a cross-check of individuals also on our by-name list, so individuals that we know to be living unsheltered in Portland, and there was one individual on both lists. That means that we don't know, we haven't identified that the other 51 are on the street. They may be. Maybe we don't have a relationship or haven't seen them in a while, but there is one confirmed person who is. Okay. [2:14:29] Benjamin Grant: I mean, that probably is a preview of what I'm going to say. I'm still going to support the HSC as a solution here and not 166 because I still think there are ways to have a more kind of devolved, distributed model for those who can't make it out there because we're not talking 60 as far as we can tell. It's something less than that. And I think someone's going to eventually step up. Maybe I'm the optimist after all this talk of being frustrated, but I would rather take and solve part of the problem tonight with the HSC and continue to work on it and believe that we can solve a lesser problem you know in the next several weeks so thanks for the answer [2:15:10] Kate Sykes: any other council sites one other question about timelines can you just clarify how long it's going to take to stand up a shelter at hsc versus at 166. staff feel confident that [2:15:24] Speaker U (unidentified): an expanded shelter at the hsc can be up and running by december 15th that's the amount of time they believe it will take to adequately staff it so that it can be operated safely. If the warming shelter is operated at 166, they will do everything they can to get it up and running in the same time frame, but are predicting that it may be more difficult. It's easier to set up something with an existing infrastructure and staff who can make training easier on site. So realistically speaking, it may take longer to become operable at 166. [2:15:59] Kate Sykes: My follow-up question is, if it turns out we don't just have one person on the street that's criminally trespassed from HSC and there's a lot, right? What is the on-the-ground solution in that moment when we have people outside in the cold? What do we do? [2:16:14] Speaker U (unidentified): In the absence of another emergency shelter in the city, we don't have a place for them to stay. [2:16:23] Kate Sykes: I just, sorry, I want to be really clear about this. They will stay on the street that night. I [2:16:30] Speaker U (unidentified): don't know where they'll stay. If another partner has access or capacity at their shelter, they may, but they will not be able to stay at the HSC. Okay, thank you. [2:16:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other comments? All right, just a quick footnote about what staff does when it happens. The money from Misha, once it was approved, it was approved with the anticipation of having an operator assigned. Once that started falling apart, hard. The state reminded us we had a deadline because there were other shelters in the state that had bids on that money if it fell apart for us. So it took a cycle of negotiations, more than one, reaching out even to the governor's office to try to influence Misha to keep the money on hand for Portland. Okay, that's the county. And meeting with the sheriff, everybody wants is community correction center building it's set up with a kitchen bathroom facilities and bedrooms for two people currently it has no operational sewer line and has water problems and it's scheduled for renovations to be a service unit for the mentally ill and or substance abuse disorder detainees that are at the facility there's a lot of talk about the county the county is not necessarily a touch point government that has clients and services. They exist to provide funds for the administrative agencies that make up county government. I've talked to who I anticipate will be the newly elected county commissioner for the city of Portland. Since he's running unopposed, I don't think I'm making a risky guess as to whether or not he'll assume the seat. He's very concerned about this issue and may look for opportunities to engage us so and even to the last moments she and I were talking to two other possibilities one was with a charitable organization for their space and they had to have a full board meeting and we couldn't come to terms I mean that's that's the hard thing you're so close you can taste it. And they decide for reasons that are perfectly acceptable to their worldview that they can't provide the number of days that the state money wants. And they preferred if they did enter it, they didn't want 24-7. They would only do it if it was weather triggered because they wanted to preserve control over their own space. So those are the kinds of conversations. Just because we want something doesn't mean the person who has the resource or sees the world the same, or will agree to that. So those are not good days for us, but that's the reality of the situation. So I will support the emergency order about the HSC just as a step-through process to see what's necessary, and we can continue to research the best we can. And I'm concerned about the CTOs. That's why I've talked about it. and I'm concerned not only for their well-being and the weather but for the emotional and physical security of staff who's already being asked to manage a challenging population to begin with alright so it's we never talk about them y'all ought to think about them for a minute tonight they do a hell of a job out there with folks that most of our residents don't think a lot about so there you have it unless there's no other comment I'm going to ask for a vote on the emergency order regarding the HSC. [2:20:23] Speaker T (unidentified): Mayor, before we go, I'm just going to ask that if we approve this tonight, what do you do with the individual of the CTO? Are we going to have another meeting and figure out, or are we just going to leave them when the weather goes down to be on their own? [2:20:45] Speaker A (unidentified): I think staff has to continue talking about it because CTOs may look for refuge there in the winter if that turns out to be our only solution. You know, it's hard. I remember police officers, we would arrest people in a storm just to gain them access into the safe harbor of the jail. Now, we looked terrible doing it, those awful policemen, arresting somebody for sleeping on the sidewalk. but if there was nowhere else to take them at least we got them there I'm not proffering that as a solution in this instance but we'll have to talk about what to do with clients that have that status and what it means for employees [2:21:31] Speaker T (unidentified): so can we talk about that at the next meeting with [2:21:40] Speaker A (unidentified): the council meeting or are you talking about sending it to Health and Human Services and Public Safety to [2:21:47] Speaker T (unidentified): DISCUSS WHICHEVER WILL KEEP THEM SAFE WHICHEVER WHAT WHICHEVER WILL HAVE THE DISCUSSION SO THAT BY THE TIME THE WHERE THEY START DROPPING THEY WILL BE SAFE WHETHER IT IS BRINGING IT BACK TO THE COUNCIL OR SENDING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE I DON'T HAVE NO PREFERENCE I WANT TO DEFER TO [2:22:07] Speaker U (unidentified): THE ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER OKAY THANK YOU STAFF WILL CONTINUE TO DISCUSS WHAT OUR OPTIONS ARE If someone either is engaged on the street and is in need of shelter, if they request it from staff or a partner, we can't guarantee, to be totally honest and transparent, we can't guarantee we're going to come up with a perfect solution. But I can promise that we'll continue to talk about it and try to come up with a satisfying one. [2:22:39] Speaker D (unidentified): Councillor Phillips. Sorry, Mr. Mayor. there. The other thing that's kind of weighing on my mind, and that's why I'm glad Councillor Ali brought it up, is the opening. I heard you say, Assistant City Manager, that if it was going to the Homeless Service Center, that it would be up and running by December 15th, but if we were going to go to 166, we're really not quite sure when that would open. So I guess my question is, what do we need to do in order to get that open by December 15th, and is it a reality? I just want to be in reality of what we're looking for as far as an opening if we do it at 166 the biggest challenge in opening in either [2:23:17] Speaker U (unidentified): location is the recruitment and retention of staff we currently have I think about 15 vacancies at the HSC already and if we're at 166 the budget includes in either location the budget includes bonuses to help with the recruitment effort as well as to retain existing staff we will use that we will put job postings out there where we'll do our best to expedite the entire process but we can only open as fast as we can hire and train staff thank you for that and so really it's just staffing [2:23:49] Speaker D (unidentified): as far as going in and being able to open it's just staffing and there's no zoning there's no anything other than staff that's right thank you i [2:24:06] Speaker A (unidentified): was just talking this is probably picked up in the mic but for all of you i was asking her what about the beds we have to put together some beds but we'll probably go to Matt's right away just to facilitate entry. All right. Any final comments? All right. This is on Order 74 as an emergency. There's been a motion and a second. All those in favor, please signify by hand. Is this right? Oh, that's right. Go ahead. By roll call. Mr. Fournier? No. [2:24:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Mr. Grant? Yes. Councillor Sykes. No. Councillor Ali. Yes. Councillor Pelletier. Yes. Councillor McNavage. No. Councillor Bullett. No. Councillor Phillips. No. Mayor Dionne. Yes. [2:25:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Motion fails. All right then. Chair would now seek a motion and second for passage on order 70-26-27 which would appropriate $900,000 for the warming shelter at 166 Riverside Industrial Parkway. So moved. Moved by Councillor Phillips, seconded by Councillor Ali. Discussion? [2:25:57] Speaker H (unidentified): Councillor Fournier. I just noticed there was an amendment in the packet. I just wanted to see if you want to speak to that. [2:26:05] Speaker U (unidentified): The amendment in the back of materials updates the amount needed to fund operations at 166, and that takes into account changes to the budget based on our ability to either potentially provide a shuttle or work with a private partner to use their shuttle as well as a reflection of the misha grant funding i believe the updated amount is 735 thousand dollars in [2:27:07] Speaker A (unidentified): light of the motion to amend is there someone that wants to move passage of that amendment it's not moved by councilor Sykes seconded by councilor Bullitt any discussion of that amendment after the explanation from the assistant city manager will the clerk call the roll no you don't have to apologize go ahead [2:27:48] Speaker B (unidentified): councillor Fournier yes councillor grant yes councillor Sykes yes councillor Ali yes councillor Pelletier no councillor Yes. Councillor Bullett? Yes. Councillor Phillips? Yes. [2:28:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Mayor Dyan? Yes. And I'll call the roll on the main motion to pass as amended. Which was it? You said no? Okay. [2:28:31] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. All right. Okay. Easy yes. Councillor Fournier? Yes. Councillor Grant? No. Councillor Sykes? Yes. Councillor Ali? Yes. Councillor Pelletier? No. Councillor McNavidge? Yes. Councillor Bullett? Yes. Councillor Phillips? Yes. Mayor Dionne? Yes. All [2:29:11] Speaker A (unidentified): right. Chair would seek a motion and a second to definitely postpone what? Second. Yeah. I'm going to postpone it. Everybody at this table needs hearing aids, just as... Huh? You too? All right. I'm trying. I'm trying. I try to speak up. All right. Councilor Sykes is going to move that order 682627 be postponed indefinitely. Is there a second to our motion? Second. Second by Councilor Ali. Discussion? Seeing none. All those in favor can signify by hand. Item is postponed indefinitely. Chair would now seek a motion to adjourn. [Speaker T (unidentified): So moved. Second.] Moved by Councillor Ali, seconded by Councillor Michniewicz. All those in favor? We are adjourned.