Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): 14, thank you people in the waiting room. There you go.
[0:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you. Sorry. Okay, so who are we adding to.
[0:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Meredith got Meredith in there. Yes. Yes. Oh, I would love to read maybe. Yeah.
[0:37] Speaker B (unidentified): People already in. Yeah. Mm. Hmm. All right.
[0:44] Speaker C (unidentified): I'll call to order the Town of Mount Desert Planning Board meeting for October 28, 2026 and welcome aboard. We will kick it off with our newfound format, thanks to Alan, and we're going to introduce each of ourselves and our position on the board. I'd like to welcome everybody again. I'm William Manley. I'm the Planning Board Chair and to my left we have...
[1:11] Speaker D (unidentified): tracy keller planning board vice chairman and dalton playing board members dan burke i am
[1:19] Speaker E (unidentified): one of the alternates alan kimberly regular member and i'm feeling awesome my position
[1:25] Speaker F (unidentified): on the board is to the right of the chair and online we have meredith randolph and i am an alternate hey hi meredith how are you good how are you bill
[1:43] Speaker C (unidentified): all right so moving on item two on the agenda tonight we have the approval of minutes and this is from october 14th gail's got the minutes open here if anybody needs to i move approval of the I'll second that. All right. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All right. Good momentum. Let's keep it up. Right. Item 3 on the agenda tonight. Tonight we have a subdivision application and we have a. Well, you know, guys, technically, I've been chastised in the past for jumping ahead. Had so early, we're too early. So we technically, we have 3 minutes to kill because the public hearing is scheduled for 605. so. Anybody got a story to tell way,, way too many stores.
[2:44] Speaker G (unidentified): Don't don't don't don't.
[2:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Has basketball started? Not quite yet.
[2:51] Speaker A (unidentified): That'll be, I don't know, mid-November.
[2:59] Speaker E (unidentified): I like Gail's story of the run-in with the blue nose.
[3:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Very good. You got two minutes to tell that Gail. I can talk about my engine swap decline you could talk about your engine swap Alan what was the bird you guys were talking about they're talking about Martin nice Mcgangers Bill didn't know what they were I did not know what a footed Mary dancer was diving Yeah, is it a big bird?
[3:47] Speaker H (unidentified): Small, but a little mid sized American duck.
[3:52] Speaker C (unidentified): So, it's like a salt water duck or.
[3:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, they're in fresh water. That's 1. I mean, I mean, fish catching.
[4:14] Speaker I (unidentified): I set it down. I don't know if they can put them inside.
[4:22] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm not sure what's going on, but the video is a little wonky there. I'm not sure if the owl is not on.
[4:29] Speaker C (unidentified): long work I there's a little well it's oh we're recording well we're recording the video looks
[4:38] Speaker A (unidentified): good just from my Observer opinion thank you I still look so fine yeah I don't understand why
[4:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Why it ends to somebody on online like this, you know. See, but we've got Meredith back. All right, 605. Here we go, so item number 3 subdivision application. It's a public hearing. It's 605 and it is a revision to a previously. approved subdivision plan and final plan review. This is subdivision application first one of 2026, 001, 2026 and the owner is Bruce A. Marcus. The agent is Dakota Dunphy and location is 16 Pine Ledge Lane in Hall Quarry. It's tax map 19 lots 040-006 and 040-007 the zone is residential one and the purpose is to amend the James W Grant subdivision recorded July 11 1978 file 15 page 115 and it is to merge a 1.44 acre vacant lot a budding lot for within the James W. Grant subdivision, and everybody should have their application before them, and you have to first make sure that abutters were notified, and this one was advertised.
[6:32] Speaker D (unidentified): This was advertised in the Ellsworth American on October 15th, 2026, and the Mount desert islander also on october 15th 2026 and abutters were notified by letter of october 9th october 9th 2026.
[6:53] Speaker C (unidentified): with that is there any conflict of interest on the board with this one none here no all right well then i'm gonna turn it over to the agent to make a presentation about the application please it's a little unaware of the presentation part
[7:10] Speaker I (unidentified): I'll just walk us through it okay this is a pretty simple drive we're erasing a line there's the old subdivision which is James grant the land that we're combining with the James grant subdivision is also a former James grant property they were all James Grant it was the subdivision was divided this property was separate Bruce bought the property both properties and he's just trying to delete that line that you see in the middle between lots oh seven and oh six
[8:00] Speaker B (unidentified): on let's see here the
[8:09] Speaker I (unidentified): maps part so the current driveway pine ledge lane he has a roundabout part of that roundabout was on the other property as well that will none of that will change no roads are going to be changed it's it's just it's it's literally just deleting that line the updated subdivision survey shows here with me the updated survey shows both the lots with the dotted line down the middle the old 1976 I believe you said it that survey shows three lots that was divided in 2000 and probably here again I wasn't perfect for a presentation so I'm not in order here yes I guess what do you guys what would you like
[9:28] Speaker C (unidentified): to know in specifics so the well I guess we'll be sure to ask all kinds of questions if there are there but I think one of the things is just in do you guys have a clear picture about
[9:42] Speaker A (unidentified): what they're adding or combining to the no i can't match up those two maps yeah
[9:48] Speaker C (unidentified): and i assumed it was me but so what i was thinking of asking the applicants we have the survey from 1977 yes the entire subdivision and then we have the application Not dated survey. Not dated survey. Perhaps the applicant could approach the table and just, you know, yeah, come on up and just kind of outline.
[10:22] Speaker I (unidentified): So this is the original subdivision, James Grant. Here, I'm going to hold it like.
[10:28] Speaker J (unidentified): so basically there was james grant who owned the whole part of halls quarry he had divided where i bought the house that sits at 16 pine ledge that was four lots two were owned by the coaches jan coats and her sister on one i think it might be in a trust but that's who the owner are and they know they were notified for it and then the other one kim get the gans own that property so i own one of the one of the lots within the subdivision then there was a non-conforming lot that i also purchased as part of the purchase three years ago right so i have two i just want to combine my two lots so i can build a garage that would straddle the two
[11:16] Speaker I (unidentified): lots so this is bruise's lot here yeah this what i was explaining before there was a piece taken out of it this was divided yeah and that was not run through any of planning board or subdivision committee if there was one at the time but there is a division here and this is where bruce's house sits this property here which you don't see right now because this wasn't you know this is the first one this is the original this is the this is this part here you see that little part that is that part that goes down to the road this small right of way here
[11:54] Speaker C (unidentified): is right here it almost should look like the lot was originally divided and then you
[12:01] Speaker A (unidentified): took a portion of the lot next to it no i didn't take the portion that was so when i purchased it
[12:08] Speaker J (unidentified): that had already been divided my understanding was that was divided in the 90s can you draw
[12:15] Speaker I (unidentified): draw on this one yes this is yep so this goes about it here I know this is it's been quite
[12:24] Speaker J (unidentified): interesting sometimes we need visual tools yeah part of it is like so this is Halls Quarry Road and I own only up to here on Halls Quarry Road but if you look at your maps this driveway was never really put on any of the map yeah and
[12:45] Speaker G (unidentified): this is the law this was this is his this is his
[12:48] Speaker I (unidentified): house property this was split by somebody else and was this part of the original subdivision or is this a set of things that was his I believe that was James Grant's personal property yeah exactly
[13:00] Speaker J (unidentified): yeah right it's a separate thing and that was the non-conforming that's what we're trying to get added and that lot right here is this they're actually trying to add to the subdivision So the bounds in a way. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. I guess you could. Well, I'm trying to combine my two lots.
[13:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. But by doing so, the bounds of the original subdivision are increasing.
[13:25] Speaker J (unidentified): I guess that would be a factual statement. Right. I guess I don't know what the subdivision does. Right. Because, I mean, the reality of life is we don't have an HOA. you know both jan and the ganses were invited to here you know jan had jan had sorry jan coates had given permission to the owner before me to actually build a driveway when he was going to develop on this lot but i have no desire to develop it i own this lot to protect my deal Yeah, and I'm
[14:03] Speaker C (unidentified): going to open it up to the public too. There's any.
[14:08] Speaker J (unidentified): Sorry, this is your map. Yeah.
[14:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you very much. So, if there's any questions about this application for the public. Now's your chance we have a large size print out to the entire subdivision. stuff is anybody raising their hand out there in zoom world so i can see can we get like a yellow hand that pops up can we try just to tile it up there this we're trying the variations i know i know but i'm just maybe it's different this time go to the gallery is going to be oh that's weird we go to gallery and we just get
[14:59] Speaker B (unidentified): Larry the speaker the immersive is the key no oh boy that's not going to help us I don't know what's going on but apparently it's recording and you can be seen out there I just can't see
[15:16] Speaker A (unidentified): I just get a glare screen yeah you have a little arrow on participants yeah is there any options
[15:24] Speaker B (unidentified): is there for you
[15:27] Speaker C (unidentified): no those tools for participants well
[15:40] Speaker G (unidentified): let's not get from here yeah
[15:43] Speaker B (unidentified): all right so i'm not seeing anybody i think the hand pops up outside of the view screen so
[15:50] Speaker C (unidentified): not seeing anybody raising their hand online i'm not seeing anybody raising their hand in the room
[15:57] Speaker K (unidentified): room ma'am hey your name yeah can we see the 1990 1997.
[16:12] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah let me turn mine over yeah so this would be old of division four locks this is a part that he owns and just adding
[16:26] Speaker A (unidentified): i do not do that it's just which now looks like this one's kind of 109 said too that this
[16:35] Speaker J (unidentified): no i'm 16. oh we're not on how far we're going but my property plus almost yeah like my
[16:43] Speaker A (unidentified): rosary the actual last footage yeah that's the 90s one that she was talking about looking at
[16:53] Speaker J (unidentified): So this slide, you know, Richard, when we decide on this one, which is this one, I believe there's one more map in there.
[17:02] Speaker I (unidentified): Black and white. And that is the Yeah,
[17:09] Speaker A (unidentified): I've only got one of them.
[17:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, that's just bigger.
[17:21] Speaker G (unidentified): You mean that organizing this paper?
[17:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Are you? Are you going to have them all? all colored with tags oh no why don't I go with that so I can keep my hair that one there is yeah I mean I own six hours yeah what is that this is tax map as of this year and I actually can read it because it's kind of small yeah this is the one that I was this is the tax yeah I don't have this you know no so yeah so yeah okay i don't know really little because okay so here
[18:10] Speaker I (unidentified): now it's kind of upside down and the way i look at it that's why so that is the property he's looking to add to that little square there and this is the rest of the subject thinking
[18:21] Speaker J (unidentified): not at least not this you want to keep my view oh that's it okay yeah she's going like this
[18:30] Speaker G (unidentified): last person had bought that and what are we seeing here because i don't
[18:35] Speaker C (unidentified): i'm just for the record we need to have the conversations like on the record so yeah, is it is there a question you want to ask ma'am about this about which strip of what, land we were talking about.
[18:54] Speaker K (unidentified): And how it affected my property and it doesn't so I'm happy is what you had discussed earlier. Yes.
[19:05] Speaker I (unidentified): If you guys want to, it's just what this 1 is, I believe this was the. surveyed in the 90s I believe I'm not yeah I know that's the first time but this one is this one I got from your the records here in town I didn't get this from online I got them from the records that I found here right I don't think they were in a packet from the ninth that's
[19:28] Speaker G (unidentified): all but there is reference from that from the 90s this was in the backpacker yeah oh okay he
[19:33] Speaker A (unidentified): He just followed up to it. Oh, okay. So we're any
[19:39] Speaker C (unidentified): additional questions for the applicant. Anybody online last chance. All right, I'm going to close public comment and let's. Figure out if the application is complete.
[19:57] Speaker G (unidentified): I move that we find the application is complete.
[20:00] Speaker C (unidentified): all those in favor so relative to the checklist on this one so I think we're gonna be beta testing our new stuff subdivision checklist really no motion here I guess short form or long form as
[20:24] Speaker A (unidentified): we have one form so going to be so you want a motion to approve the subdivision
[20:35] Speaker G (unidentified): amendment i'm going to approve the subdivision amendment as applied for second all right now
[20:42] Speaker C (unidentified): we press the pause button and we go through the review of the application and then we'll circle back to the approval vote so I've got the checklist I've got the application and got these plans and 77 and 2026 plan we've got a copy of one from the 90s and we've got larger format plans if anybody needs them and let's wade through the checklist all right so we are this is the subdivision land application review checklist this is the James Grant subdivision and we are in section 4.1.7 revision to previously approved subdivision and what this says is if the revision adds lots or dwelling units it must undergo full subdivision review attending at least two meetings completeness and compliance so the review and what this the criteria here is number one the revision does not significantly alter any of the previously reviewed criteria who maintains compliance with the review criteria of section 4.3 and 3, the revision does not interfere with the intent and purpose of the subdivision ordinance.
[22:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, one of the questions is, this adding another lot of a subdivision?
[22:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Is this increasing the bounds of the existing subdivision? It sounds like it is. Yeah. I would assume it is. Yes, absolutely.
[22:35] Speaker A (unidentified): it doesn't seem to be adding another lot to it 's not adding another lot but it's changing
[22:41] Speaker C (unidentified): the boundary of the subdivision and
[22:49] Speaker G (unidentified): your testimony is that the subdivision doesn't actually function as other subdivision bylaws or rules or it just was subdivided at some point and by the grants by the grants and it got approval from the town at that time well i mean he got
[23:04] Speaker J (unidentified): some approval yes it's obvious a lot was divided that never went through the approval right so right i can't fix that right well i guess i have a question i don't know if it's appropriate to ask now or at some point why is it still called the grand sub he hasn't owned it in
[23:27] Speaker G (unidentified): 40 years because that's how it's registered in the registry of deeds Yeah,, yeah, sure. Will in perpetuity be the grant, like, the Lincoln Memorial who keeps
[23:47] Speaker C (unidentified): referring to section 4.3 throughout all of this checklist. And section 4.3 is comprised of many different sections here.
[24:02] Speaker G (unidentified): here and I think what the applicant has submitted is a claim that none of it's relevant because it's simply erasing a property loan it's removing a property none of those factors are going to
[24:16] Speaker A (unidentified): change yeah I mean you would that you
[24:23] Speaker C (unidentified): know the much of much of what the applicant is has submitted on this application is relative to section four three and it's you know it's everything from going through like the general project information the location of the project the size the current zoning the existing use are there any bodies of water is there a portion in the shoreline zone flood hazard area that kind of stuff and then it goes on to yeah it talks about ownership you know do they have any legal interest in the flooding property well it sounds like they do and when you they've got the attached deed and then and then it asks when was the last time the subject property was divided and they talk about you know the division in 1991 on book in book 1849 page 52 and that was without review or approval by the planning board and that you know there were no statute of limitations on that according to the MRS 38 title 4402 which is noted on the subdivision plan there is a statute there is there is some yeah thank you and then subdivision information you know they go on to talk about the proposed use of the subdivision it's that it's not a new subdivision it's an amendment to a previously approved subdivision and it's a residential single-family development the number of existing lots within the James W Grant subdivision in 77 there were four Lots the number of Lots to be created they're they're not creating new Lots right number of existing dwelling units there are three on three Lots and one lot is vacant the number dwelling units to be created they're not creating they're just merging land number of existing non-dwelling structures that's there are none they're not creating any it asks about the existing structure footprint that they're just merging land proposed new structure footprint it's merging land And, you know, these are all structure questions about footprint, post product, post project, building floor area, building, you know, total floor area, you know, existing impervious surface area. Yeah, it's just, we're merging land here. Does this, and then it goes on to ask about utilities. you know does it require extension of public infrastructure they say no what's the estimated cost estimated cost of infrastructure there is none they go on to identify the method of water supply to the project development it's all on individual wells and identify method of sewage disposal it's all individual septic systems it's not connected to public water or sewer and then under other information they ask about is there a dedication of any common land no are there any restrictive covenants placed on the deeds no there's no new lots being created is the applicant requesting any waivers doesn't sound like it so then it goes on to compliance with ordinances see attached receive final code enforcement or planning board approval applicant must provide a narrative explaining how the proposed project complies with the subdivision ordinance so we've we've got a lot of this here where they're they're here we go even more sections section 3.5 dimensional requirements section 5 conditional use approval section 6a general performance standards section 6b and 6c and some subdivision projects must comply with the subdivision ordinance and provide the narrative again this first page need to be signed also along with the one that is signed yeah so it was just i think that wasn't one of one of the general things so if we get there tonight we need to be signing the i asked kim about this that's what the larger format plans yes or yes that we need to actually sign and they need to record any amendment this was just a
[29:59] Speaker A (unidentified): substitute for his terms and it's not something we can do right did you get that from the original
[30:06] Speaker C (unidentified): okay so it looks like we need another signature from the applicant on the original application
[30:14] Speaker D (unidentified): whoever signed this you know yeah
[30:19] Speaker G (unidentified): my sense is that they signed a separate page and to substitute
[30:22] Speaker D (unidentified): to but it doesn't you want to sign both of them yeah i think they should both so better more we're
[30:27] Speaker J (unidentified): signed are you looking for me as they all yes can you sign this line as well can i read it yep sign and date yes you can read it so this is just what i this is just a component of what i had
[30:41] Speaker D (unidentified): signed yeah that's the same form it's just a complete the opposite it's been a
[30:48] Speaker J (unidentified): learning process do you want me to date it today or as of the 8 28 date oh oops today good question well I just saw that had a different date right so 28th right
[31:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, very much so you guys
[31:26] Speaker C (unidentified): are not in a shorter zone. Here's the narrative, right? So back to the checklist and these things. All over the place, but we're in section 4.17 and what it's. what it's talked about here and the finest of facts that proposed revision to a previously approved subdivision has provided information providing compliance with the criteria section 4.3 and then the conclusion law the checklist is looking for is that it meets all requirements of the subdivision ordinance as necessary i
[32:14] Speaker A (unidentified): point to one piece of the ordinance that might shorten this review for you guys? Please. Okay. Section 4.1.4 revisions to previously approved subdivision plans. Yes. I can read it into the record if you want. Yep. Okay. There will be times that a previously approved subdivision plan needs amended. Purpose of allowing a separate review for revisions to an approved plan is that small changes do not force an applicant to go through the entire subdivision review process a second time however if the project is changing in a substantial way that would increase dwelling units or lots the previously approved plan must go through preliminary and final review again otherwise only one meeting is needed so perhaps
[33:06] Speaker C (unidentified): we first have a finding if you guys think we need this requires the full review of section 4.3
[33:16] Speaker G (unidentified): i move that we find this application complies with paragraph the first paragraph of 4.1.4 of the subdivision ordinance in that it is a small or minor change that does not force the applicant to go through the entire subdivision review process a second time
[33:37] Speaker C (unidentified): I would second that right any further discussion all those in favor all right so we're not going to wade through all thank you Daniel yes thank you get the gold star so you know I think that's going to negate most of this checklist the conditional use yeah I mean as we're going you know well this is the land application review checklist so maybe I don't know I think we should well let's see what you guys think I mean so revision to a previously improved subdivision so it doesn't significantly alter it you know we just determined that about section 4.3 that we don't have to go through all of that and it doesn't interfere with the intent and purpose of the subdivision ordinance so I would say met yes and the three check options are met not in NA so I'm going to say met and the findings are fact or that the proposed revision the previously for subdivision has provided information providing compliance with the criteria section 4.3 and the conclusion law is that the revision meets all requirements of the subdivision ordinance as necessary so moved second all those in favor aye right and then going on we'll see it goes from 417 right to 43 so what and so I'm gonna you know just to complete the check the checklist you know at 43 it's asking about a buffer strip so we just determined 43 three is not at all though it's na 432 pollution na sufficient water na erosion na we'll talk about land mergers here traffic is 435 na 436 sewage disposal NA and you know we've we've got the narrative here to you know describing this
[36:13] Speaker G (unidentified): which I think these have all been listed in the in the application yeah and they advocate it's
[36:20] Speaker C (unidentified): not applicable they're not applicable 437 solid waste disposal NA 438 aesthetic cultural and natural values and farmland it's not farmland and a river streams and brooks there's no
[36:43] Speaker B (unidentified): did
[36:45] Speaker G (unidentified): you do four point three point nine without the laws there's financial capacity on i think you may have missed the page
[36:56] Speaker A (unidentified): page those four three before it was just a natural value yeah thank you yeah thank you
[37:08] Speaker C (unidentified): four three nine conformance with other laws regulations and plans state and federal laws site location development and most recent and a financial capacity is 4 3 10 and a 4 3 11 surface waters you have the survey and there are none in a groundwater there are established wells there are na flood areas that's not in a flood floodplain, NA, 434 freshwater wetlands, 43.14. Yeah, thanks. And then it jumps to 4315 farmland, 4-3-16 River Streams and Brooks, N.A. 4-3-7-17, N.A. 4-3-18 Great Pond, Bosworth Concentrations, N.A. a 4-3-19 subject to liquid liquidation harvesting and a 4-3-20 spaghetti lots prohibited and a 4-3-21 ditches and catch basins and a 4-3-22 easements or
[38:46] Speaker G (unidentified): sewage drainage utilities
[38:48] Speaker A (unidentified): utility department is in any a minute or
[38:58] Speaker C (unidentified): 324 it was n a yes and then or 324 common area provision and a or 325 wells and a Doug Wells yeah for 326 don't need a performance guarantee and a for 327th Street design and construction there is none proposed in 4328 solar energy systems access to sunlight you have access to sunlight so the findings of fact that the application contains required materials necessary to provide compliance with section 43 which is in their narrative and the plan submitted And the conclusion was the application meets requirements of section 4, 3, which we just voted. Did not apply due to being a land merger. So, I'm sure the law is. See, above, I guess so. [Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, new discussion.] All those in favor.
[40:34] Speaker G (unidentified): The public theory is that there may be activities that are brought before the board for our consideration that actually are affected by some of these, all of these, one of these provisions that we just went through. This is trying to account for everything. Usually it accounts for almost nothing in an application, but we have to go through it to make sure we're meeting our responsibilities here.
[41:00] Speaker A (unidentified): You know, just why is this so,
[41:06] Speaker C (unidentified): you know, there's reference to the, now to the land use standards of section six, a B and C and session five, nine.
[41:16] Speaker A (unidentified): And I,, because if you're doing a subdivision, I'm really doing a subdivision, you would
[41:21] Speaker C (unidentified): have to go through that, but, we're, so I think we should, one easy one would be to have a motion relative to 6A, B, and C in slide nine. But I think we could parse it further and say that section 6C and section 509 don't apply because you're not in the shoreline zone here. And then we could just quickly go through 6A and B.
[41:54] Speaker G (unidentified): So I'm going to find 6C and 5.9 not applicable because this is not in the Schrodinger zone.
[42:00] Speaker C (unidentified): I just hear Kim in the back of my head saying, why didn't you guys go through 6A, B, and C, and 6A not for conditional use? It is, but why is it relative to?
[42:16] Speaker G (unidentified): Because it would be, it's not relative to a raising a foundry, but it is relative, potentially relevant to a subdivision, actual subdivision behavior.
[42:26] Speaker C (unidentified): So I think maybe there's just diligence in our motions that we'd say, well, the obvious ones that since it's not in the shoreline zone, 6C and 59 don't apply, there's the motion. Let's start with that.
[42:41] Speaker A (unidentified): that so all those in favor all right and second Gail said yes yeah okay so then we can have
[42:51] Speaker C (unidentified): another motion about 6a and 6b and you know and just for the record you know it's a section 6a in the land use ordinance you're talking about like general performance standards compatibility, erosion and sedimentation control, highways, town services, outdoor lighting, yeah, land suitability, outdoor lighting.
[43:18] Speaker G (unidentified): I move that none of the provisions of 6A and 6B are applicable to this application.
[43:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Let me just read Section 6B really quick. So Section 6B, we're looking at agriculture. culture you know you're looking at beach construction the boat storage and campgrounds and driveways and the signs and cell towers and animal husbandry and mobile food vendors and room houses and it's it's none of this so
[43:59] Speaker A (unidentified): what we see your motion i move we i'm gonna be fine that
[44:03] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, there's a funding factor conclusions a lot are the 6 and 6 B are not applicable to this application.
[44:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, any further discussion all those in favor.
[44:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so there's anything there's that.
[44:20] Speaker D (unidentified): No, that's our product. Yeah,
[44:24] Speaker C (unidentified): it's that's office use only.
[44:28] Speaker L (unidentified): oh great
[44:32] Speaker G (unidentified): and there's like so much do we need a vote on gail and alan's motion to approve
[44:42] Speaker C (unidentified): as presented so we do i think we're there yet i just tracy just handed me that back and so we're back to that vote and but prior to that are there any approval conditions on this
[45:00] Speaker G (unidentified): Not that I'm aware of. Obviously, the gentleman mentioned he may want to build a garage, but that's subject to a separate action, an application to the code enforcement officer.
[45:09] Speaker A (unidentified): That's not a condition. Yeah, all
[45:15] Speaker C (unidentified): right. All right, we get half of Larry. Okay, all right. So no, there are no conditions to approval. So then let's go back and press play on the approval motion. All those in favor of approving the application as submitted.
[45:44] Speaker J (unidentified): It has been a longer process than I thought it would be.
[45:48] Speaker A (unidentified): A couple of grains of paper. Yes. So, we also need to...
[45:59] Speaker G (unidentified): And you need to record these, the subdivision documents. Yes. In the registry. I
[46:13] Speaker A (unidentified): don't think we have to do we have yeah it has to be within a certain number this night is it 90. how what do you can you explain recorded like your history is in ellsworth kansas county okay so i need to you can just bring it there i think it's fifty dollars to record the plan they'll look at it approve it take your money and can it in then you're recording the new properties that will show yes so the matter if i or m do
[46:56] Speaker I (unidentified): that just don't hold it i did my best i have that rolled up so i don't know how it got folded the
[47:04] Speaker A (unidentified): way it did they won't they won't take something that's full yeah i don't know even around i don't
[47:15] Speaker G (unidentified): It sounds like it's time to get your arm out. These two names.
[47:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, record. What's that? Yeah,
[47:32] Speaker I (unidentified): I would think we would. It's it's not sedimentation or plans, and then [Speaker A (unidentified): those on the] arts of bill requires a long-sighted. Require you know,
[47:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay.
[47:55] Speaker D (unidentified): What was that? i'm going to sign all these even
[48:00] Speaker A (unidentified): with the checklist that just that there was one
[48:02] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah okay
[48:09] Speaker C (unidentified): just manage the table i think it's in paper i mean and it's kind of
[48:13] Speaker A (unidentified): i think that's the reason that option in the dragon right so yeah we can make investments oh tomorrow and those are the hard changes i completely did No, it's if we did an amendment to a set market, so it's your, it's my, a minor is this amendment. That's just my, you know, we have.
[48:50] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, so if those, and I do want to find it and I drop it.
[48:55] Speaker M (unidentified): Yep. Appreciate it. Nice to meet you. You too. Hey.
[49:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. They take these. Hey. Yeah. Oh, okay. Gotcha. [Speaker G (unidentified): Don't we keep] don't we keep one after it's recorded yeah that's that's what our visiting consultant just so like
[49:33] Speaker I (unidentified): like it right yeah so you only need to take one and then the other one and one of you so they'll
[49:43] Speaker D (unidentified): they'll record it and they'll date stamp all of them yeah and then we'll keep then we get one
[49:49] Speaker I (unidentified): and then I bring one back and one is for the owner yeah I'm just making sure no one
[49:57] Speaker A (unidentified): else needs one no we don't i mean the town does that's true registry keeps one we get one
[50:05] Speaker I (unidentified): and the owner should probably have one awesome anything else that i need with me i'm 16. no thanks for the appellate you know thank you guys i appreciate it thank you
[50:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, it's hard to make a couple of copies for Bruce, just to be sure. All right, we're all sitting up street conditions.
[50:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Moving on item four on the agenda tonight, we have a conditional use approval. This is conditional use approval 19, 20, 26. And the owner is the Nocella Realty Trust, and the agent is Greg Johnston, G.F. Johnston Associates. Location is Narrows Road, Mount Desert. Tax map 11, lot 32, zone is Shoreland Residential 3. This is the purpose of Section 3.4 and 6C.7, permanence, docks, piers, wharves, bridges, and other structures and uses extending over or below the normal high water line or within a wetland. And this is to construct a 50-foot long by 6-foot wide permanent pier with a 50-foot long by 3.5-foot wide temporary ramp and two 16-foot by 15-foot and 25-foot by 16-foot seasonal floats. It's a communal marine structure shared by two properties. properties we had a site visit at three and we're a butter's notified and this one advertised it's
[51:48] Speaker D (unidentified): advertised in the Ellsworth American and on October 15th 2026 and the MDI Islander on October 15th 2026 and letters went out to a butter's dated October 9th 2026. any conflict of interest
[52:06] Speaker C (unidentified): interest on the board and here none heard and Ann would you like to report upon your observations
[52:14] Speaker H (unidentified): from the site visit so we walked down an established path to the Shore's Edge Greg Johnson there and he explained to us that the pier would be attached Foundation to the ledge that's already existing in that site and go out to the low watermark we observed the area the main
[52:41] Speaker C (unidentified): shoreline yeah rocky with ledge rocky with ledge any other observations right well then I will turn it over to the applicant.
[52:54] Speaker L (unidentified): Just to geographically locate it, 's about 1,000 feet north of Barlow's Landing. It faces towards Blue Hill. Establishment means the shortest distance to the water. There has been a bathymetric survey done. There's no tidal flats there. It is ledge. The pile, one single fixed 50-coat section. is piled set right at low water. So it's not much well below what the maximum is. Instead, it's in a seasonal ramp and float, which extends about 50 feet beyond the water.
[53:34] Speaker C (unidentified): So there's no need to get further.
[53:37] Speaker L (unidentified): We're a breach what you guys observed as a fairly, steep slope. The owners have agreed to share with another property in Bartlett and Arrows. And I think that 's the gist of it. It's an elevated pier, so you can walk below when we choose. It's not on a green grid that's going to affect the ebb and tide. It's on high sports. But with that, I pass it over the board for any questions so we can continue our review. if
[54:11] Speaker C (unidentified): we were there today for the record it looked like we were we were just about at high tide
[54:21] Speaker L (unidentified): you're probably two hours i think of before high tide we're about two hours three or four
[54:26] Speaker C (unidentified): feet from high tide yeah someone's in the waiting room see
[54:38] Speaker A (unidentified): the name i need the name I
[54:50] Speaker C (unidentified): will open up public comment. If there's any public comment, questions about this application, now's your time to ask.
[55:06] Speaker M (unidentified): I'm here as a stakeholder. I'm a fisherman.
[55:09] Speaker A (unidentified): I fish there. Can you give your name?
[55:12] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, my name is Ailin, spelled A-I-L-I-N, and my last name is Rafferty, R-A-F-F-E-R-T-Y. And I probably make about a third of my income in that spot. That area just north of the landing, going all the way up to the point where you exit the Narrows, is really productive fishing bottom. it always has been ever since the 1800s a lot of scalpers use that place I think when you do your site surveys you have to take into account that a lot of people work seasonally here you're not getting a full picture of what's happening you went at high water well at low water you have a better view of those ledges because if you look at that chart you'll see that the channel middle there is 300 feet wide, so there's only a 300-foot width for vessels to pass. So you're talking about a 50-foot ramp and a 50-foot pier and then a 16-foot float, but you're kind of being disingenuous, too, because to have a float, you're going to have to have chains that are at least 75 or 80 feet long going out to granite flocks on the bottom to tether it to the bottom. So now you're talking about almost a 200-foot footprint and a 300-foot area that's heavily trapped all summer long, sailboats, sailing vessels, we had a boat come through this summer, the Areva, 65-foot wide, so you know, sailboats need to tack, there's extreme tides there. It was first settled in the 1700s and the settlers went to bottomless landing and there's a reason why they did because it's not a harbor, it's not a good spot for boats. That shoreline just above there, and I'm sure you observed it today, there's moorings there, 's floats already, there's three properties there that have seven moorings and two floats. The town of Mount Desert itself says that a property is entitled to one marine structure, and they say that a float is marine structure or a mooring. so you have three problems not all that bottom used to be total bottom people made a living there you know and I think people that don't fish they say well why don't you just go somewhere else well there's a reason you know because that is a bottleneck it constricts and creates an eddy and where there's an eddy there's life you have scallop settlement there's lots of trash right there and for a fact that people lobster in right there always have a couple hundred years so you know it's it's it's something to take into consideration is that there's people's livelihoods and you're talking about something that these people are probably here two months out of the year maybe and they just want to have a place to have their boat and that's great but you know there's some other considerations to take into effect here because that legend you know it's pretty treasured this area where i tow it there's a lot more amateur boaters or people who do not have an experience anymore you'll see sailors come through and they hug that ledge you know because they're trying to pass it and do the best they can as far as they know rules of navigation and things like that and then they realize that dog legs out underwater and it gets scary so they zip over so it's just a very constricted area it's not a good spot i mean those mornings i don't even spot the morning the tide runs eight knots there like So it's just something to take into consideration.
[58:41] Speaker C (unidentified): When we were there today, we observed another ramp and float still in the water to the north there. Yeah. Can you comment on how does the presence of that ramp and float affect things there?
[59:01] Speaker M (unidentified): Well, I mean- Similarly? Similarly because it's taking up bottom, you know, and that's bottom that can be fished where and it's productive lucrative bottom too because that's that's pin gravel something that fishermen look for and so yeah I mean anytime you put a structure you know we work a lot around lobstermen and things like that because we're towing and so I have a 300 foot cable coming out the back of my boat and I have to take into account the wind tide if somebody's coming at me if someone's coming up behind me and all those things make you know like more difficult but then when you have these structures like you know i'm pretty used to them and i can see them on my machine i know what to pick out and things like that but traditionally that whole area was prime and bottom for fishing you know and you're just seeing it more and more where people are they i understand you buy a beautiful property and you want your beautiful boat out in front of it but you know is there is there a seasonal
[1:00:09] Speaker C (unidentified): consideration to what you're doing in the water and what they're doing in the water like do you guys overlap or how does how does that work well the thing is that you know it's it's funny because
[1:00:21] Speaker M (unidentified): the people there for the most part have been very kind and like understanding like i try not to be a nuisance we put a lot of time on that shore and i and so i've tried taking to consideration that these people they pay a lot of money for their houses they bring a lot of money in taxes and they are a part of things and so i try to be considerate with how i fish seasonally it doesn't make a difference because the moorings are there permanently so you can take the floats out you can take your grandpa but you still have 75 foot of chain on two moorings crossing over like on bottom you know so that's a huge swath that you know i avoid which is fine you know but it's just then the next house wants then the next house wants it and then where does where does it go from there personally i think that what i'm seeing is that bartlett's landing is a beautiful harbor has tremendous potential people come from all over to come down have a look you know people love it there and it's grown down and it's it's not being tended to i think a lot of these people would probably be content having their vote for something in bartlett's landing but the fact of the matter is that there's a couple of bad apples that have made it miserable for the community and people don't want to go there anymore so and why would you know so it's it but there is a reason why christopher bartlett which when he showed up i was like no boat there you know because it's not maybe two months out of here yeah it's beautiful but it's not a good place for drawings and stuff but it doesn't matter to people who don't make a living on the earth you don't understand that you know i just came to share some of my insight onto it and i don't care if it gets approved they put it in i work around it you know i try to get along with everybody and that's fine it's just the way things are but you know there's definitely some more considerations than just going down at 3 p.m on october 28th and taking a peek and you know it's a really dynamic place it really is and not only that i got for sculptor as well so and there's several fisheries you know but i do have about a third of my income for bringing that spot yeah it is what it is so i figured i'd come and say my fees
[1:02:45] Speaker C (unidentified): you hear you and perhaps the aging i'm going to say i think this is the you know there are a
[1:02:52] Speaker L (unidentified): lot of competing interests i hear the comments i think then we as we've gone down these different times most times yeah there's been a lot of plots right there but the gentleman has stated about driving that's why we planted it inside the cove and inside those other warnings in doing so. I can say, detracting from him, I'm going to explain our own process, that we had contacted the harbor master about Barlow's Narrows. He has a letter in there if we want to look at the letter from the harbor master where he said, you know, there is no room there for these boats in Barlow's Narrows. That's in your practice. And to minimize what that is they're very normal they're allowed to have a restructure to meet those standards and we've gone through the due diligence to try to do that we plan inside of any of those chains and warrens i also would point to the application on page this isn't my words i'm not stating in uses, but page 54 of the application, where we have gone through, and these are the page 54 in the plain application, it's already works with the fishermen. We work with the hardware master, we've done everything in planning. page 54 of the application is the states where EMR and I'm not detracting from the statement but DMR on their own accord not from us DMR stated the project as proposed would have little to no long-term impact marine resources and habitat for traditional fishing that's their statement I didn't make that statement I'm saying so there has been some due diligence in sharing to how these harbors work i heard the statement about it being 700 feet across we have an exhibit in there that yes 50 feet is 50 feet of 700 feet of channel the town has standards the standard issue can be more than a third across that which would be 33 percent and so you're around 10 percent of that those standards may not align with how other people should use to harbor but we have talked with the folks who adjudicate green resources we use observations and surveys inside of what could be in the construction and i think we're within the standards of the organs but it's a balance and so i don't i can appreciate the comments i think they can be understood it has to go through it but i think we've gone through the process of five spans in the organs did
[1:05:47] Speaker G (unidentified): you want to i heard i saw you thinking your head about the size of the channel and also yeah i think that is kind of a bone
[1:05:56] Speaker M (unidentified): contention because i mean i'm sure when you were there today you saw the ledges across the way right but you're not looking at an audible chart where you know you can only get so close to those ledges so in reality it's a 300 foot channel i mean you could say 700 or whatever I mean, that's fine. But, you know, I think what is happening is, you know, on a chart, you have, you have what is called the Great Ledge, you know, which is a solid actual ledge, and that would be 700 feet, I would imagine. But, you know, whether it's 300 feet, 700 feet, it's somewhere in that area. It's not a large area, you know, and I wouldn't say that is inside of those moorings because it's actually quite well outside of the cove. I wouldn't even call it a cove. I call it like a little cut and it's well outside of that and it's well to the west of the moorings.
[1:06:59] Speaker A (unidentified): i'm looking at the pictures he's just giving me and i guess how about we have him come up here
[1:07:12] Speaker C (unidentified): and show the board where the primary concern is like in the show if you want to just use Here's the one that come up here and show us like, I don't know, like, yeah,
[1:07:30] Speaker M (unidentified): trying to make anything 39,.
[1:07:36] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm looking at page 39 and page 37. Yeah, page 39, I think, is a good aerial. Yeah, that's 39.
[1:07:50] Speaker M (unidentified): So, if you were to look at a metric chart. I mean this is can't go over this you know what I mean and that would be a hundred feet from where they're proposed and that would be what you have left to work with vessels just light area right here that light area would be would be shoal bottom that would be treacherous to go over and right that purple pin to that red pin would be a hundred feet so that yellow is not ideal but it gives you an idea and that's rough you know what I mean and I'm not what is
[1:08:24] Speaker A (unidentified): that yeah we don't have that any day chart plotter that you know Garmin makes them anyone so it shows
[1:08:33] Speaker C (unidentified): you the bottom profile yes yeah so I think we're just pointing out I appreciate the comments and
[1:08:40] Speaker L (unidentified): we're not trying to be combative but we are these are the other moorings and the other peers in here and we've planned inside of those realizing they're for only how do you figure that
[1:08:50] Speaker A (unidentified): is inside of those well if you were dragging up through it's it's shore side of those my toes go
[1:08:56] Speaker M (unidentified): north to south like this or they go over this way there's there's a channel here i'm following i can't go into the into the rocks i mean it's you know the other thing too taking consideration is the tide i mean i have to tow at two knots and i have to maintain two knots because if i go faster my drag comes off bottom if i go slower look it fills with rocks and so you know and the other thing too is that this is completely filled with lobster gear that i'm working around as well so there's there's not a lot of room for error i guess is what i'm saying and a lot of times you know what i'll see too with boats is that they'll come down through here i guess i wish can bring up a bigger picture but the narrows opens up here and they'll come down along these ledges like this because they think they're making a straight shot and as soon as they get to here they see that dog legs this way and they immediately go that way and it happens constantly like on a daily basis there's something to think about i mean i'm not totally opposed to this project either but i'm just did ask about tacking well that's the thing too and i'm not a sailor but i do know that sailboats oftentimes this tide will be running out and they will be beating into the wind and they make tremendous i mean tacks like this you know because that's the only way they can maintain momentum honestly none of this should be here i mean this is all this is very productive bottom and they say we'll go somewhere else what this is doing is because the way it shoals up here it's creating that channel comes right down to a bottleneck and it creates a back eddy and that's what that's where life settles you know that's what creates that's where you find things and you're you're basically cutting off you know you're constricting the neck of the bottle you know but so you i take it you're one of things
[1:10:56] Speaker G (unidentified): you're saying is that there's a disconnect with dmr and dmr rules that from dm when dmr says that this application would have little to no effect on traditional fishing well yeah i mean once again
[1:11:08] Speaker M (unidentified): i'm sure the dmr sent a represent the representative there and they came at a certain time on a certain day and they're like oh yeah nothing happening you know what i mean but i think it takes a little more than that to see the full picture because once again like i said a lot of people we do four or five different fisheries and you know so it's constantly changing but this is our bread and butter so and you know ultimately I'd like to get away from this place I mean I don't I don't even like fishing out of Bartlett's Landing because it's it's a horror show and as far as I've been fishing out of there four years I've never seen the harbor master there in my life so I don't even I don't know what the guy looks like I am on the
[1:11:52] Speaker E (unidentified): harbor committee and we do talk about Bartlett's Landing and I am on the waiting list yeah i am a it's postcard license captain it's i am too i'm a licensed captain and i used to be
[1:12:05] Speaker M (unidentified): yeah well i'm hurt in good standing but you know barless landing it's sad because it has a
[1:12:12] Speaker E (unidentified): lot of potential i think it's a really nice place and it's now have buyer's trucks that are coming there now that we've okayed oh yeah well so it's so his comments about the
[1:12:28] Speaker G (unidentified): floats when they're removed there still will be a the moorings for them right because he's not
[1:12:34] Speaker L (unidentified): giving you the full picture of that oh no i'm not the chains to go out they'll they'll put winter toggles on just like the rest of the moorings out there yeah for dragging yeah
[1:12:49] Speaker E (unidentified): they have two outer granite stones that crisscross yeah to hold the outside of the float yeah
[1:12:56] Speaker M (unidentified): I have a very small boat, too, and my business, I keep very small because for me, that's my business model. I try, but I do know that other draggers have quite big boats with big gear, and, I mean, it's nothing to them to come and move those moorings for you, know, and they will. well I mean so it's the other thing with Marlins too is that there's you know there's a winter group of people that are not native to our island they don't they come from away and they set up in Bartlett's and they spend their entire winter there they don't have the consideration that I think local would have so they give you awful hard-on things as well but it's just you know, it's just that battle over bottom. I mean, it's like fishermen go through every day. So whether it's another fisherman or, you know, developer or whatever.
[1:13:58] Speaker C (unidentified): What, how is your, how is the proposed pier here relative to the other pier that's there? Is it?
[1:14:08] Speaker L (unidentified): Inside of it only because the land slightly dips in. It's, it's.
[1:14:12] Speaker C (unidentified): Because of that, oh, it jumps in a little bit.
[1:14:16] Speaker L (unidentified): And then we're not going to move in the Marine Cove, but it dives in. You can see it on the aerials. It's inside of that.
[1:14:22] Speaker M (unidentified): So it's a cove and it's not a cove, and it dumps in, but it's outside. It's a little...
[1:14:26] Speaker L (unidentified): Okay. It's smaller than what you would expect. Yeah.
[1:14:29] Speaker M (unidentified): It's inside of it. And I'm curious about the communal aspect, because like, you know, can I tie my boat up there? Am I part of that community?
[1:14:37] Speaker L (unidentified): Or is there a non-community? I think that 's where we have standards, and I do want to get into the sounds, like the fishery is part of it, but we can get into each one of the standards.
[1:14:45] Speaker C (unidentified): as we can talk about it so the community the communal use of it is between two properties
[1:14:53] Speaker M (unidentified): two shared properties and they have signed by blood or marriage or business i think
[1:14:58] Speaker L (unidentified): the ordinance says that two shared property owners i think you gotta the way the word is written which can change says two drop-down property owners may share doesn't say blood Well, it doesn't say that's just for the organs, but that's what it says.
[1:15:16] Speaker G (unidentified): And the goal is to have fewer total box. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I, would think, I mean. Oh, we didn't look, we're going to get fewer by building more because they were both. My understanding is they were both looking to build a dog.
[1:15:29] Speaker L (unidentified): we looked with the other one and it was butt flat up in the cove and too far said a few two folks it is it is one large family who owns multiple lots and said don't put one there it's too far here you have steep slope you can get to low water you don't need to go out beyond the water with your with your prick section i think the facts that are there are standards we can apply in the ordinance and we may have more conversation on several of the
[1:15:59] Speaker C (unidentified): items but okay so from here once public comment is closed then we 've got a we've got a fair amount of criteria then to wade through in reviewing the sorry no that's what i said That's that's what public comment is for. That's why we're all here. So. It's all good. Yes. So. Is there any additional public comment at the moment? Any. No, 1 on line. I'm not nobody knew that. We've seen. Not seeing any hands up online. Anybody on zoom Meredith. I
[1:16:46] Speaker F (unidentified): just have a quick question from what Greg just said was that the that the ordinance says that properties that are adjacent to each other can share what exactly was the wording of that again.
[1:17:00] Speaker L (unidentified): i didn't say adjacent under section 679 term is page 1648 additional square footage if two or more shorefront homes choose to share a community structure the applicant may request additional square footage right in the data what was the
[1:17:33] Speaker F (unidentified): what's the category again for that you know you know list is separate in that
[1:17:40] Speaker G (unidentified): it's it's for it's 6-48 it's 6c7 the pier dock orphan bridges which is what we're considering tonight and you know there's a section of a communal dock or
[1:17:56] Speaker F (unidentified): this floats in the table right I just was noting that the looking at the site map that the two properties aren't actually the property that the pier is being put on isn't adjacent to a next door to the they don't they don't have to be okay
[1:18:17] Speaker M (unidentified): just really quickly i do want to point out too that the thing that gray gear provided to says the maximum length of their entire structure is 225 feet so where he's talking about well it does it says right there next month of your entire structure it's 125 so that's what it can
[1:18:37] Speaker A (unidentified): be that's what it can be that isn't necessarily what it is if i'm not and we'll we'll see outer
[1:18:43] Speaker C (unidentified): limits of everything okay yeah and we're we're gonna you know we're gonna get there yeah if i'm mistaken you're proposing a hundred and sixteen feet yep then plus the change
[1:19:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I don't know how that's gonna mean they're out there.
[1:19:06] Speaker M (unidentified): You see what I'm saying? Sure. Yes. Yes. All
[1:19:13] Speaker C (unidentified): right. Any additional comments out there? Anybody?
[1:19:19] Speaker F (unidentified): Meredith, it does say at the end that has to demonstrate the need. Did they have? I haven't heard any demonstration of, or is that just in the application? We haven't gotten to it yet.
[1:19:34] Speaker C (unidentified): You can get there in the application. I'm sure. Okay. All right, I'm not seeing any hands up out there in zoom world. I'm going to soldier on, I'm going to close public comment and now we're going to. Get on with the review of the application, so I guess we got a 1st to determine.
[1:20:01] Speaker A (unidentified): If the application is complete, I'm moving for the application complete. Okay.
[1:20:05] Speaker C (unidentified): 2nd, all those in favor. I. Lots to review and think that the short form checklist is still going to give us plenty to review. I movie is a short format checklist for this application. All those in favor, I. Then your favorite motion.
[1:20:31] Speaker G (unidentified): I know we find the application complete. I mean, we approve the application. Yeah.
[1:20:36] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and we press the pause button, we're not approving it and now we're going to review the entire application. You have to have something to discuss. So now we're in the discussion of the approval. And got my short form checklist. I've got the application. We've got our land use ordinances. We've got this. 24 by 36 plan of it all let's yes let's wade through this and i'll follow along in the application all right so this is a conditional use application so we're going through section 6a b c and 5.9 because we're in the shoreline zone and we kick it off with section 6a general performance standards. And the first section we're looking at is Section 6A1, compatibility. And under compatibility, we're looking at things like physical size. And this is where the applicant says that the length and size of the fixed sphere is minimized to a 50-foot length pier, which can reach to a water depth suitable for the owner's boats. The length is far less than the maximum allowed of 150 feet. The total structure length to include permanent and non-permanent components will be 116 lineal feet. The height is set above the FEMA VE elevation of 14 feet. Then it goes on to talk about visual impact. The construction of the pin pier landing to the existing ledge outcrop and slenderness of the 12-inch diameter socketed piles will allow for visibility and walk-through access below the pier. The piles are similar to the adjacent pier and are not a new or foreign element to the Bartlett Narrows area. The dark cobalt color of the pile protective coating will blend the structure into the dark background existing along the shore. Can you describe, Greg, for the record, what is a socketed pile?
[1:22:58] Speaker L (unidentified): A socket pile is a set of wood piles, a steel pile.
[1:23:02] Speaker C (unidentified): And they just pound it into the...
[1:23:04] Speaker L (unidentified): They auger a hole, put the socket in, grab it into the wedge.
[1:23:12] Speaker C (unidentified): And it's 12 inches in diameter, and you have two of these things under the... Four. Four or two? [Speaker J (unidentified): Two. two four] of them four of them and then they come up and they then and then they're tied together with the cast in place concrete half yep proximity to other and that's shown on your on your 908 plan submitted then section 6a goes on to talk about proximity to other structures
[1:24:01] Speaker G (unidentified): And what did you say for compatibility? See application or.
[1:24:05] Speaker C (unidentified): We're not there yet. I'm sorry. Almost. Proximity to other structures currently, there are 5 existing peers along the shoreline within a half mile radius of the site. You've got a half mile radius aerial exhibit. of it on page 39 density of development similar uses exist within the narrows traditional recreational boat use in fishermen boat use is common in the district evidenced by existing peers the
[1:24:49] Speaker A (unidentified): comments on compatibility no okay i'm
[1:24:56] Speaker C (unidentified): gonna say c application 6a2 erosion and sedimentation control. The applicant says that the shore is rock and ledge and not susceptible to erosion. Rock socketed piles to be installed. Pier landing to be pinned to the existing ledge outcrop. Silt fence will be installed down gradient of the shore side abutment. see application 6a 3 highway safety applicant says construction the pier will not increase traffic work will be performed by barge and there's on-site spaces for workers and residents incidents. So, C application. 684, impact on town services. No new services requested. What do you think? NA or C application? C application. Land suitability. So, the applicant talks about that the photos demonstrate that a rocky beach is present. Rocky beach is suitable for the construction of the pier the pier landing will be pinned to the existing ledge outcroft there is an existing foot prep leading to the pier landing location and there's photos on page 46 of that so see application 6a6 lightings outdoor the applicant says that controlled low voltage lighting that is switched will be installed the safety lights for walking are far less than the 1800 lumens lights will be fully shielded downward pointing lights with remote operation from boat or home walkway lights to illuminate footpath will not cast down onto waters the cct color appearance of the lights will be warm and not exceed 3000 kelvin and there's a on page 59 it shows what that is c application can
[1:27:36] Speaker G (unidentified): i ask a question about the lights is there any reason to indicate that these lights will not to believe that these lights will not be on when it's not actively being used
[1:27:47] Speaker L (unidentified): That's fine. That's why they're remote operators.
[1:27:50] Speaker G (unidentified): So they come in the dark, they turn the lights on. Yeah, exactly. When they're done, they walk away, they turn the lights off.
[1:27:55] Speaker L (unidentified): Right. And they're only at foot level. It's not to make it, like, up and go to the bridge. It's just so people can see where they're walking. Right. So they come in late. And considering they have multiple islands and neighbors to attend to, they can be switched off from the bottom.
[1:28:15] Speaker C (unidentified): 687, stormwater. Then it says N.A., no increase in impervious service and decking boards are gapped for expansion, but they checked N.A. 6.A.A., vegetation. They say N.A., no clearing. And then 6.A.9., dust, fumes, vapors, odors, and gases. The construction of the pier is completed off-site. Right. So, the findings of fact are that are as presented by the applicant in the attached application, and the conclusion was that the proposed use is in compliance with all standards of Section 6A, for which the standard has been met.
[1:29:06] Speaker L (unidentified): So moved. Second. All those in favor? Aye.
[1:29:10] Speaker A (unidentified): So,
[1:29:14] Speaker C (unidentified): moving on to section 6B, which I think is going to probably be almost all N.A. except for 6B.7. So, I'm just going to go through this. 6B.1, agriculture is N.A. 6B.7, excavation or filling.
[1:29:41] Speaker G (unidentified): All right, can I just say that 61 just bookkeeping on my copy, but yeah, he hasn't checked.
[1:29:47] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, Greg, do you want to come up in? So we just need to edit that. Thank you from doing out here and this is the original. This circle that.
[1:30:01] Speaker L (unidentified): Box isn't even there.
[1:30:06] Speaker C (unidentified): So, 67, thank you. Applicant says small excavation, less than 2 yards required for shore abutment. Erosion control silt fence will be in place during hand excavation of the shore abutment. And they say applicable standard met. I'm going to check C application. 6b-8 fences and walls. There are none proposed. proposed 6B16 and yes, and a 6B16 sign regulations and a 6B18 wireless communication facilities and a 6B19 animal husbandry to and a 6B20 mobile food vendors and a 6B21 rooming house, N.A. 6B-22, hotel and motels, N.A. 6B-23, solar arrays, N.A. So the findings of factor that the proposed use will include none of the specific activities or land uses described in Section 6B except for Section 6B-7, and the conclusion law of Section 6B B is not applicable except for Section 6B-7, for which the standard has been met. So moved. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Now, since we're in the shoreline zone, shoreline zoning standards for review by the Planning Board. This is Section 6C. And the first one is Agriculture and Animal Husbandry, which is NA. And then 62 archaeological sites. So we've got a letter from the Maine Historical and Planning Commission saying that there's no impact to these resources, and that's on page 50. 50, so C application. 65, essential services. Evidence says N-A. 66, parking areas. N-A, there's none proposed. And then 6C-7 is why we're here. So 6C-7 is piers, docks, wharves, bridges, and other structures and uses extending over or below the normal high water line or within a wetland and what we're you know there's so what we're looking here is that the there could be a requirement from the planning board just to note that the planning board or code enforcement can require the submission of an environmental impact assessment or natural areas and may require mitigation measures such as changes in the design or location of the marine structure or changes in the magnitude of activities on the marine structures and bridges and other crossings not involved in earthwork do not require a permit and then the performance standards for the peer review are as follows so one is access from shore the access has to be developed on soils appropriate and minimize soil erosion, and access from shore to the marine structure shall be placed on bedrock. So you have an erosion control plan, you're pinning the fixed section of pier to bedrock exposed on the shore grid and all that.
[1:34:24] Speaker L (unidentified): And Paige, if you want to follow along, page 29 also has the narratives as to what the application 6, 7, 8, do you have one in your area? Page 29, please stand, because it's not going to confirm the application.
[1:34:44] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, all of that.
[1:34:47] Speaker C (unidentified): So I'm going to do that. I'm going to flip between. So access from shore, we just talked about that. And the next criteria is interference with existing uses and beaches. The location of the marine structure shall not interfere with developed or natural beach areas, nor access to existing marine structures or points of public access, or unreasonably interfere with the use of other marine structures or landing places. The applicant says standard met. No developed or natural beach areas are located at the project site. the shore is rocky steep slope. Proposed pier system will not intrude on any existing mooring locations. The concave shape of the ledge code chosen for the pier avoids any impact to the moorings. As observed in the half-mile radius aerial exhibit on page 39, an existing pier on the north of Buddinglot lot wise, 275 feet from the proposed pier. The proposed pier falls outside of the navigable channels. Height of the pier, which is planned with its lowest horizontal member one foot above the flood zone, and the slenderness of the four steel piles will allow for easy walkthrough below the pier.
[1:36:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Do you have a map or chart or something showing the navigable channel?
[1:36:24] Speaker A (unidentified): we looked at that earlier yes we'll get the width of the waterway
[1:36:34] Speaker L (unidentified): we have the we looked at depending on the subsurface channel you can see where the concrete number which is that well yeah page 41 exactly all
[1:36:52] Speaker A (unidentified): right 42.
[1:36:58] Speaker D (unidentified): sure and
[1:37:06] Speaker G (unidentified): your argument is that whole 750 feet is navigable
[1:37:11] Speaker A (unidentified): is that what you're saying why or i mean just ask a procedural question to
[1:37:20] Speaker C (unidentified): why do you use aerial photos and not like a marine chart for that so i think we talked about it on
[1:37:29] Speaker L (unidentified): this site and now we'll check whether we're talking about a army core channel or what it
[1:37:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Is it an Army Corps channel?
[1:37:38] Speaker M (unidentified): Because they would have to be here if you're going to build it in an Army Corps channel.
[1:37:45] Speaker L (unidentified): We absolutely can show in the channel. It's just a way to present it in the context of other geographic features that you're familiar with. And you can see that the topography on the plan, as you get towards the float, it continually dives and in fact gets much, steeper.
[1:38:11] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, that hill keeps going. It keeps going.
[1:38:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Hey, that was review criteria number 2.
[1:38:24] Speaker M (unidentified): Would you like to see a chart really quick? Oh, I. I can bring 1 on my phone now, and you can see that.
[1:38:31] Speaker E (unidentified): But you're talking about a sheer bluff that drops down to 50 on the phone. Yeah. Yeah, the chart needs to be big.
[1:38:38] Speaker C (unidentified): We're getting there. Okay. Yeah. And, you know, we've got to have, you know, to base a decision on anything, we've got to have, like, submitted material we need to base a decision on. And let's think about the chart submittal. But anyhow, let's item three on the review criteria. criteria. So, effect on fisheries and wildlife, etc. Here, the review criteria is that the marine structure shall be designed, sited, and constructed and minimize adverse impacts on fisheries, significant wildlife habitats, or unique natural areas, including but not limited to thin fish and shellfish fisheries, salt marshes, eelgrass beds, shorebird and nesting habitats critical fish spawning and nursery areas applicant says standard met the proposed design will avoid rockweed growth in the inner tidal zone by having an access ramp that spans over the rocky shore the location the only pile set is to be below the rockweed area no eelgrass shorebird habitat deer wintering areas or inland waterfowl areas are present or near the site. And there's a eelgrass exhibit on page 42. Low tide photos depict the area plan for the pile set. That's on page 46. Tidal, waterfall, wading bird habitat generally exists in the area. And we've got an exhibit on page 43 about that. Maine DEP confirms the standard has been met by stating based on the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife and DMR comments the department finds that the activity will not unreasonably harm any significant wildlife habitat Freshland water wetland plant habitat threatened or endangered plant habitat aquatic or adjacent Upland habitat travel corridor freshwater estuarine or Marine Fisheries or other aquatic life and this is the from the in the main DEP nerpa permit on page 52. goes on to talk about that the intertidal area is comprised of pure rock and not clam flats the pier is well elevated it across the intertidal area does not span over mudflats. Main DMR shellfish closure maps indicate closures nearby and south of the site in areas of shellfish harvesting. And there's a shellfish closure exhibit on page 44. DMR does not acknowledge the project site as a shellfish harvesting site. This is consistent with the project site being comprised of rocky shore and lacking mudflats. Can you describe for the record again the fisheries you fish through there yeah scallop diving that's a productive
[1:42:13] Speaker M (unidentified): scallop spot i'm also my primary fisheries are i collect marine specimens so there's four or five different things that i harvest from there you know it's it's prime substrate it's
[1:42:31] Speaker C (unidentified): what we're looking for when you mentioned your bread and butter earlier what is your bread and
[1:42:36] Speaker M (unidentified): butter in a nutshell dark fish i fish for starfish primarily and so that's that's a starfish and seasonal scallop diving yep we also harvest sea anemones several other species but that's starfish is the main one is that all done through the dragging of or primarily now yeah dragging I died for them as well when we started this we were hoping for it to be a dive fishery and then it just hasn't worked out that way mostly because of logistics so
[1:43:21] Speaker C (unidentified): So scallops, you're diving or dragging? Diving.
[1:43:25] Speaker M (unidentified): Diving scallops. Yep. So I use a combination of tools. Sometimes it depends on.
[1:43:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Scallop season is a winter season, isn't it?
[1:43:35] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, from November 15th until April. Yeah.
[1:43:38] Speaker C (unidentified): What are those other fisheries?
[1:43:42] Speaker M (unidentified): Are those regulated? That I participate in? Yeah. I have a general commercial fishing license. license. So, for the most part, they're underutilized species that nobody really cares about, so there are no regulations on them. And so, but I have always carried a commercial license anyway just because it's, you know, wise to do. But, yeah, no, it's what we do.
[1:44:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Can I ask the applicant, how does the DMR determine that there's not an impact on local fisheries? What's the process?
[1:44:26] Speaker L (unidentified): Well, they keep track of harvests, right? That's a drop. They issue licenses, they do catches in areas, they visit the areas, you submit the information to them. You could go to, say, to an extent, like, who's the authority? We understand that there's a balance, and we don't get to adjudicate it. You could say, RW3 doesn't allow peers, our committee could say, we don't want private peers out there. And I think it's the balance. We don't get to make up the rules, the standard is there, and we say, okay, what are the effects? And they study it. they take six months to look at it and come back and ask several questions because the site even asked the determination if they didn't have the determination we'd be talking about something else and i think a secular concern when there's five other peers there i can understand the rampant floats which are out in the winter and scalloping you know i think this impacts in many ways to what happens and you know it's about one
[1:45:35] Speaker M (unidentified): thing I will point out though is that the DMR only requires reporting on lucrative fisheries that you know there is they probably manage 80 different fisheries there's only about five or ten of them that require reporting and things like that because those are the ones that are of their most concern do you have to report your a scalpel your scallop i do yeah harvest to them yeah i do yeah which you know is kind of a drag but no pun intended yeah no pun intended but it's you know i obviously the dmr is i mean personal opinion is there a joke i mean they're they're they become such a bureaucracy now that they can't manage anything they're failing fishermen whatever that everybody knows that but it's gone to the point now where 10 years ago there was one woman when you did your reports when you had a question she was in charge of sculpts you talked to her now she has two underlings that draw a salary almost as much as her that are unavailable all the time on the
[1:46:48] Speaker A (unidentified): phone all right well that's a whole another discussion oh the thing is that's the dmr is
[1:46:54] Speaker C (unidentified): not there they're not yeah you know so it's you have to your lucrative fisheries you have to
[1:47:00] Speaker A (unidentified): report some of you don't yeah right not the starfisher right so i really want to ask
[1:47:09] Speaker G (unidentified): us something about what the market is for stuff yeah what's the employee
[1:47:20] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah so yeah so guys just bear with me yeah yep continued story time here so size this is where we talk about the size of the pier the facilities shall be no larger in dimension than necessary to carry on the activity and be consistent with the surrounding character and uses of the area. The temporary pier dock or wharf shall not be wider than six feet for non-commercial uses. The applicant says standard met. The pier is no larger than necessary to carry on the need for the proposed use. The height of the pier is one foot above the flood zone. The linear dimensions have been developed for the most suitable location on the property reach a minimum water depth beyond the exposed rock the floats were designed to accommodate multiple users narrower floats orientated lengthwise reduces footprint while maximizing birthing space for shared users the length of the pier is planned during a minus tide event with site observation conservation and bath and mirror survey the shore is comprised of large angular stone down below the mean low water line we walked this location on foot with a marine contractor and surveyor to determine the closest and flattest location in the piles the length of the pier was driven by accomplishing the shortest distance the low water line referencing the photo section the large angular stones on the shore from the base of cliff just above the mean water low water line the lo the location chosen avoids mass movement of stones which would occur elsewhere the pier was only extended to meet the flat spot determined during the intertidal survey and no further the width of the access ramp is only three and a half feet the width was chosen for handful sample carts for goods and tools they minimize the ramp width of the ramp allows storage within the fixed portion of the pier and it ex it eliminates the need for pulling the ramp and floats ashore so five no new structures this is yeah what do you anticipate the need for the
[1:49:48] Speaker G (unidentified): depth of water at the at the at the docket and what do you why have you asked it where it is so
[1:49:55] Speaker L (unidentified): literally you got to get the load part right there yeah and the standard ramp their boats draw upwards of eight plus feet and that's just getting a seasonal ramp there's no place
[1:50:11] Speaker A (unidentified): you replace the i guess what i guess what i'm actually asking is what boat what size boat they've
[1:50:20] Speaker L (unidentified): got a 40 foot boat a 24 foot boat but i mean in terms of what they draw what you need at the dock
[1:50:26] Speaker A (unidentified): for a low for low water eight feet as well okay thank you sorry i didn't ask that's what i was
[1:50:33] Speaker C (unidentified): asking so for the record how much water do you have below the float at mean low water on the
[1:50:40] Speaker L (unidentified): outside it's 24 over the inside it's more like 10. okay
[1:50:51] Speaker C (unidentified): five no new structures this is essentially saying you can't you're not building anything on top of your ear right six no new permanent piers and docks so this talks about that non-tidal areas and that a temporary peer doc is not feasible, then you've got to have the DEP approval. And applicant says standard met, the DEP NERPA permit has been received for the shared peer on the 28th of August of this year. A seasonal float system is considered. The system would be hard to maintain due to constant wave crashing up on the shore in the V zone. Areas exposed to considerable lateral forces of tide into Bartlett Landing. The fixing of restraints for a temp system to withstand these lateral forces result in a web of chains and moorings. and the temp system in a harbor are considered a hazard at night and in the fog by fishermen. Conversion to dwellings, you're not doing that. Height limit, you know, that the structures built on are abutting. Yeah, you're not proposing to build anything on the pier. Interference with natural flow. flow. This says interference with natural flow of any surface or subsurface water shall be minimized during the construction and use of the marine structure. Afghan says standard met the site was evaluated using engineering principles to determine the most appropriate support system to minimize impact. The steel piles have a marginal direct impact of 3.14 square feet compared to 144 square feet of a 12 foot by 12 foot stone crib steel piles were chosen as they allowed the least amount of interference with natural flow and while meeting the overall purpose of supporting the piers on next review criteria we talked about encroachment on navigation the marine structure shall be designed, sited, and constructed so it doesn't approach upon officially designated navigation channels. The applicant says standard met. The proposed pier falls outside of the navigable channels. No ACOE recorded channels are present. What's ACOE? Hermicore of Engineers. Hermicore of Engineers. engineers we have inquired with the harbor master about the pier project and they have no stated objection there's a letter from the harbor master on page 51. the pier extends only 15 percent of Bartlett Narrows and does not impede waterway travel and there's a coastal wetland dimension exhibit on page 41.
[1:54:23] Speaker G (unidentified): I would point out that the letter from the harbor master says that there are no current mooring spaces available in Bartlett's Landing, and they're guessing that the size boats that the property owners have, the waiting list for mooring might be seven to 10 years. That's his best guess.
[1:54:40] Speaker H (unidentified): But it sounds like in this question, they're more asking, does the harbormaster think it will disrupt navigation flow in this area?
[1:54:50] Speaker G (unidentified): And the last sentence is, I have no concerns about a pier at this location.
[1:54:55] Speaker H (unidentified): it doesn't directly say because of other fisheries or no that's all it says
[1:55:02] Speaker G (unidentified): page 51 from the harper master i have looked at your proposal for here at block 032 on narrows road there are no current mooring spaces available the wait list for broughtless landing for the size posts they have is seven to ten years at my best guess i have no concerns about a pier at this location
[1:55:21] Speaker A (unidentified): that's what he says dimensional
[1:55:28] Speaker C (unidentified): limits yeah i've been under waiting us for years right so the marine structural show structures shall comply with the dimensional limits listed below we'll go through the boring areas oh thank you 11 mooring area the planning board shall request comment from the harbor master in cases where the applicant proposed to build a marine structure in an officially designated mooring area and it's applicant says the pier is not intruding on an existing mooring locations I just want to point out that there
[1:56:05] Speaker M (unidentified): was a mooring existing there and it's actually in this photograph that he provided but they moved it a couple of weeks ago out of there in preparation of this process but it's the app
[1:56:18] Speaker A (unidentified): applicants speak to that I don't know about like you know it was cleared there but they
[1:56:25] Speaker M (unidentified): cut down the trees in there last winter and then they spent the last couple weeks pulling up all the scum so it is clear there because they cleared it you know but
[1:56:37] Speaker C (unidentified): for the goose right now we're just considering existing warning locations well that is the existing location
[1:56:46] Speaker E (unidentified): It's not a town mooring field that is listed, such as Bartlett's, which is closed because there's no more available spaces. When you get out of a place like that, Northeast Harbor, Seal Harbor, Somes Harbor, Bartlett's, it's a defined area that is a mooring field.
[1:57:12] Speaker L (unidentified): you're allowed to have.
[1:57:13] Speaker M (unidentified): I would point out too that Barlitz Harbor, there's about 20 empty moorings there that are derelict now that are in different stages of sinking or have people's gear or floats on them that the harbor master isn't doing his job in looking into these moorings. There's people who have stopped fishing half a decade ago who moorings are still there. So there's- It'd be an important consideration,
[1:57:36] Speaker G (unidentified): but that's probably the harbor committee and-
[1:57:38] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, but there's plenty of mooring space and they're trying to make the point that there isn't space there and there's absolutely plenty of space there's just nobody is doing the process of putting those more arms forward that's a reasonable question
[1:57:51] Speaker E (unidentified): generally speaking people are allowed two mornings they can have a morning in front of their house and they can have a mooring at a harbor yeah somes harbor is 70 empty because it's people up and down some the whole I'm talking about people I know personally who are tired from fishing and are no longer even and the people use that only as a storm mooring if there's a storm and they need to move their boat away from their house this sounds good like great this is
[1:58:21] Speaker C (unidentified): conversation yeah you could come to the Harbor committee come to the Harbor committee but let's talk about the dimensional limits on the here at the moment so just again jumping into what the summary of what we're looking at here and is that you know we're getting we got to comply with the dimensional list limits list below it's no larger than necessary its size and construction shall not change the intensity of the joining land use and by no means shall it exceed the total distance of one-third the width of coastal wetland or water body when proposed for coastal or inland waters, notwithstanding the dimensional limits below. In areas where horizontal distance from the normal high water line to the mean low water line is in excess of 160 feet, no permanent structure will be allowed. So the applicant says the length only as needed to reach water depth suitable for the owner's boats. structure will not exceed a total distance more than one-third the width of the coastal wetland length of the structure will span 15% of the what width of the waterway is measured to the waterways nearest ledge outcrop pure height is planned for the resilience the flood waters shared access agreement has been established with tax map 11 lot 34 for the pier size and construction the proposed spear will not change the intensity of the joint land use horizontal distance from the normal high water to the mean low water is not in excess of a 160 feet and here just running down the dimensions max maximum length of the entire structure allowed is 225 feet. They're proposing 116 feet. The maximum length of all permanent structures is 150 feet. They're proposing 50 feet. Max length of all non-permanent structures is 75 feet. Applicant has 66 feet. The maximum width of the pier walkway is six feet applicant has six feet maximum width of ramp is six feet they have three and a half feet the maximum square footage of floats is 400 square feet and the proposed dimensions are see the communal pier standard we'll get to that the maximum square footage of floats for communal, piers, docks, and wharves. Two property owners is 800 square feet and they're proposing 640 square feet. And then we get on to the communal dock standard. When proposed by the applicant, new subdivisions may provide a communal dock in lieu of the development of docks on individual lots. plots the applicant may request additional square footage of floats as long as there's a demonstrated need shown so the applicant says standard met on the onset of the project planning our office was approached by a second property owner to evaluate appear on a nearby property the neighbors had considered constructing appear at their residential property as well it has been determined through topographic research of their shoreline that's a shallow sand beach at that location will require construction at pier of extreme length to reach the water's edge the geographic condition of the shared site consists of steep lead shores of rocky beach with the deep water with deep water to provide a much more suitable location for a pier with minimal impacts the applicant nosilla realty Trust and lot 34, lot 5BN, LLC family have agreed to share access, construction costs, and maintenance of the pier location.
[2:02:35] Speaker G (unidentified): And then the... I have a hypothetical question. Sure.
[2:02:40] Speaker H (unidentified): If sharing the dock and they get in a little squabble or some sort, and then the other owner decides they want to go back and build their own pier, that's just a hypothetical, not these particularly what would happen like because now it's built to the size of two families and then
[2:02:57] Speaker E (unidentified): what and one decides they would have to remove we'd have to float to get it down to 400 square
[2:03:04] Speaker C (unidentified): feet you know they'd have to reduce it to the non-communal doc standard but i also refer you to
[2:03:11] Speaker G (unidentified): the additional documentation that greg pressed this evening that kim had sent to us last week And that has because this is a question I asked at the site they are proposing a docking system use agreement that they would each sign, and it looks like it will be recorded, and that would allow the other property owners to access that doc is not just it's not just it's not just verbal and it would run to the land and I would say that probably as a condition of approval. We would want to make sure that got executed.
[2:03:52] Speaker L (unidentified): So, I think I think is 1st, we know the order doesn't have these mechanisms and we know that it's important for people to know how they're going to operate. That's a good discussion for the advisory committee. What if we realized that document would be signed and recorded based on that before we could apply for a building permit? So this… It would be recorded. Correct. It would be executed and recorded. There's no time to record it until we have traction, but that's proof to the building department before we actually get a permit to construct. Correct. We'd have to show it recorded. Okay. Good.
[2:04:28] Speaker C (unidentified): it so if this other abutter if this other user of the communal pier is not a direct abutter there's no requirement or let's not say that in the ordinance
[2:04:41] Speaker L (unidentified): it doesn't even say it sure it does not even say any more shared waterfront owner you read the ordinance it says a another property owner anybody in town yeah look at this you just say shared short run owner this happens to have a shared to a front owner who can walk there and they have an easement and a right-of-way because they're in the same
[2:05:06] Speaker C (unidentified): well that's what i was going to snacks and those that it's specific review criteria but just since we're on the communal dock section how are they going to get to the dock i mean do they have like a fly in the way. Yeah. Right. Yeah. That's all part of this. Right? Yeah. They live further up in the narrows.
[2:05:28] Speaker G (unidentified): They said they have a right to park a vehicle. They have a right to access the property. They have a right to. They're going to share the expenses of maintaining it and so forth. It's in.
[2:05:41] Speaker C (unidentified): they're maintaining liability walking right away from that non-available property you
[2:05:47] Speaker L (unidentified): know how to park down no we drive to this property and walk down that path the
[2:05:58] Speaker G (unidentified): easement for ingress and egress to the docking system and for parking of one vehicle shall be over the existing driveway on the marcella property with the parking area to be designated by the grantor together with the pedestrian easement from the parking area over the path along the short of the docking system all
[2:06:16] Speaker C (unidentified): right so i think the last review section is limit on number there can't be more than one marine structure on a wall they say standard met one marine structure proposed so for section 67 i would say c application 69 roads and driveways
[2:06:50] Speaker D (unidentified): i got a you got you have a question yeah it's page 22 at the top does something have to be because all land use activities within the shore land zone shall conform with the following greg can you come it just a very top line here
[2:07:20] Speaker C (unidentified): So Roads and Driveways is N.A. Yeah, it is N.A. 6C.11 Water Quality is N.A. Thank you. So the findings of fact will include none of the specific activities or land uses described in Section 6C, except for Sections 6C.2 and 6C.7. and the conclusion allows that section 60 is not applicable except for section 62 in 67 for which the standard has been met so okay all those in favor I right now we kind of go through it all again with section 5 9 28 yeah so section 5 9 is, you know, just, again, the specific shoreland standards. So, here we have Section 591 will maintain safe and healthful conditions. See application. 592 will not result in water pollution, erosion, or sedimentation to surface waters. See application. 593 will adequately provide for the disposal of all wastewater, N.A., it doesn't produce any. 594 will not have an adverse impact on spawning grounds, fish, aquatic life, bird, or other wildlife habitat. Applicant says, sea application. 595 will conserve shore cover and visual as well as well as actual points of access to inland coastal waters African says sea application 596 will protect archaeological and historic resources as designated in the comp plan see application will not adversely affect existing commercial fishing or Maritime activities in a shoreland commercial district you're not in the shoreline commercial district but you say see application 598 will avoid problems associated with the floodplain say see application 599 is in conformance with the provisions of sections 6 a B and C which the standard has been met the findings of fact are at see above in the conclusion laws that all requirements for section 5 9 have been met all those in favor aye
[2:10:09] Speaker H (unidentified): can
[2:10:12] Speaker G (unidentified): i just ask you to break in the documents you provided us those additional documents you had an exchange with kim about the other use of the property and how that here ties to that, what the primary use of the property is. I know Kim's not here, but you, from your perspective, could you explain what that conversation was about?
[2:10:38] Speaker L (unidentified): So the question is whether or not a
[2:10:43] Speaker C (unidentified): marine structure is a primary or accessory use.
[2:10:47] Speaker L (unidentified): That, I mean, summarize it. Our position is that it doesn't need to be accessory to a residential dwelling it's simply enough that you go into the allowed use table of the land use ordinance and it lists the allowed uses one of the allowed uses in this district is a marine structure doesn't say marine structure as an accessory to a residential structure it lists it as an allowed use and that's on page 311 so on our supplemental submittal no I don't
[2:11:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, I mean, I mean, in our table three,, section three,
[2:11:32] Speaker L (unidentified): four lists allowed use the question was, what does the accessory do? Well, it can be primary because it is lifted as a primary allowed use in the table. That was the substance of it. Right. Right.
[2:11:44] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah. I was just trying to understand what that was about that. Yeah.
[2:11:48] Speaker L (unidentified): And it's even more interesting if you consider it, not a subset because the house is under planning and possibly construction, but it also has the shared user yeah that has a five bedroom home so we considered it needed to be accessory for residential use which we don't that house is using in the five bedroom on it right so that was the discussion around that point the last part on the draft because we looked at it you said well is it primary is it accessory when you look at the definitions in the ordinance functionally water dependent use is a very specific narrow category it's not accessory it's not primary here's one of the only things that's defined as a functionally water kind of use which really takes it out of the category of being potentially accessible it's the only thing in there so yeah my position was it doesn't need to be it doesn't need to be accessory it's primary in the table right okay thank you so
[2:12:58] Speaker C (unidentified): now we're on to the permit conditions
[2:13:03] Speaker G (unidentified): did i understand what you're in terms of permit conditions i understand what you're saying about how there's nothing in the ordinance that requires that agreement between the parties bodies to be able to share the dog does that mean you have a concern about making it a condition of
[2:13:21] Speaker C (unidentified): that you get that we no we think it's important because we the you folks need to find
[2:13:30] Speaker L (unidentified): that just the people who share it have obligations yes and those need to be documented they're not going to say when are you coming over my house what how are we maintaining our driveway so that's going to be recorded we just are going to it you can make that a condition that's our intent okay
[2:13:46] Speaker A (unidentified): all right we should have a copy of the it's in the it's in the it's in this but a copy of them
[2:13:56] Speaker G (unidentified): well then yeah but they're going to have to get the permit for the dog we would we would record
[2:14:00] Speaker L (unidentified): it the condition of the approval was the evidence of the agreement because to the building
[2:14:05] Speaker C (unidentified): departments before we could acquire this part of the permit yeah okay what about another permit condition where just i think they could be a little bit more specific on the length of the pier in proportion to the channel out there that we heard so much about tonight and that instead of it being demonstrated on an aerial photo, that they just show it on a navigation chart where it's this-
[2:14:38] Speaker L (unidentified): I think you've made that vote. But I would hear what you had to say. I think the third word we often heard in the ordinance, which was mixed a little bit, is it says the third of the coastal wetland. We're happy to hear what may entertain the board.
[2:14:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I don't know. I'm all ears.
[2:15:01] Speaker C (unidentified): And I know it's always...
[2:15:03] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, there's a lot of talk tonight about the navigable channel there. And we don't know what that is exactly. I think that's the... And I think what's on the bottom plays a big role in determining what the navigable channel is.
[2:15:20] Speaker E (unidentified): Generally speaking, a channel has buoys that take you from one to another to another. other and it takes you through a channel where this is more like a cut through okay the island
[2:15:38] Speaker M (unidentified): that's the difference between a channel and an navigable channel is now I'm describing an
[2:15:44] Speaker E (unidentified): navigable yeah channel where you have markers that take you through that area safely so like
[2:15:51] Speaker A (unidentified): commercial throw percent yes exactly very good muscle rich muscle rich that's a really pretty one
[2:16:04] Speaker C (unidentified): any thoughts i just want to go back to that standard you know only because your
[2:16:09] Speaker L (unidentified): director potential manual is a lot of discussion with it and again it's a balance that the board has to do but it also says encroach on navigation channel the marine structure shall be designed cited and constructives do not encroach upon the officially designated navigation channels yeah i'm going to add a lot of section 16 7 10. yeah on page 647 or maybe the harbor master needs to manage the margins or maybe they need to designate a channel but the rules that you guys are
[2:16:43] Speaker A (unidentified): applying uses the term officially designated channel right okay so it's not an officially
[2:16:49] Speaker E (unidentified): officially designated channel right okay they don't even have a buoy to mark those ledges
[2:16:59] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm not going home all
[2:17:02] Speaker C (unidentified): right so the one permit condition we have then is just that the
[2:17:06] Speaker A (unidentified): the common use agreement that the docking system use agreement could be executed before
[2:17:12] Speaker C (unidentified): construction commences any other permit conditions any other discussion no
[2:17:25] Speaker G (unidentified): I guess I just want to say I hear your concerns there in the back of the room I hear your concerns our job as I understand it as a planning board is to assume that whenever it's possible a landowner's use as defined by the ordinances will be allowed we don't we don't get to freestyle on that at all and i mean the whole idea is people have in this people have a right to use their land as they want and we are in this ordinance encroaches on that it constrains that and we're not allowed to read any more into that than what we how we read the order and so voting on this does not mean for me voting on this does not mean i don't hear your questions or concerns i just find i mean i'm more or less
[2:18:21] Speaker M (unidentified): it doesn't buy you lunch i'm indifferent if i build this thing or not you know honest with you and as far as fishing i'm used to working around people i'm used to making things work and i just came more or less to the voice of my concern that you know if a chance somebody's gonna get hurt or lose some life or property here yeah but i mean and the other thing too is that i mean where does it stop i mean because you got what like eight lots there and everyone heard people kind of want one you know as soon as it did where and so that's all that's i'm not i didn't understand
[2:18:57] Speaker C (unidentified): what happened i'd like to think that 11 years on the board that our board you know has very open and it's been a board policy to hear comments and let the comments, you know, run the course.
[2:19:14] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, I appreciate you guys letting me talk. I think you guys did a great job. And I mean, I know Greg's just doing his job, too. I'm not like, you know, but...
[2:19:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I think you should go to our Harbor Committee meeting.
[2:19:24] Speaker M (unidentified): I probably will. I mean, yeah, I probably will check one out.
[2:19:30] Speaker D (unidentified): But you're on record.
[2:19:33] Speaker C (unidentified): on record you've been heard it's you're in the you're in the minutes yeah all right all right so let's circle back now to the to the vote so all those in favor of approving the application as submitted with the current permit condition? Aye. Aye. Aye. Right.
[2:20:00] Speaker G (unidentified): Construction. Oh God, you really want to hear from me? No. No. Here's what I will say though. We had a LUSO meeting in which we struggled over what the new requirements are going to be that we have to act on and the next day i wrote to katrina about something and she said i have to apologize i really wasn't focused on what was being said last night and i wrote back and said i was focused and i still can't tell you what these requirements are i can't keep them in my head so just a heads up like i've got the documents with me we'll discuss them at some
[2:20:44] Speaker A (unidentified): point soon but be prepared to be concerned you guys are just getting moving well we're into it i mean we started but yeah this is a good point you know you said it's what's planned
[2:20:58] Speaker M (unidentified): sorry but it's pretty cool they can do what they want on it but they actually don't own the ocean they don't go below the watermark so yeah i mean something this is true
[2:21:08] Speaker C (unidentified): did you adjourn anyone we haven't yet we're not adjourned no we're gail's telling us about the
[2:21:16] Speaker G (unidentified): land use no i'm not going to get into it but it's nitpicky but significant changes to density allowances which is different types of zones and i wouldn't get any further than that but just the circles and errors and the paragraph from the back of each of these documents getting a little bit confused there did i write before instruction yeah so that's all i'll do because you've had
[2:21:38] Speaker A (unidentified): we've had enough and go on but i don't want to and you know if you can connect with multiple
[2:21:45] Speaker B (unidentified): state agencies and they still can't provide you any clarity any more than the little press releases
[2:21:50] Speaker G (unidentified): oh man i thought like katrina doesn't get this oh i am i am never going to get this
[2:21:56] Speaker C (unidentified): is anybody coming to be here advising you guys on that yeah no one's there no one's there no one's
[2:22:03] Speaker G (unidentified): there and he's explaining it to us and then i like i get it for like when i'm there but it's one of those maybe i do need to tell you at some point what it is and then maybe teaching it will
[2:22:13] Speaker E (unidentified): help i mean do we need a motion to adjourn we do a motion to adjourn yes i'll second that yes
[2:22:22] Speaker A (unidentified): am i supposed to sign something we'll just get past all those in favor yo hi what is it something i'm supposed to are we supposed to sign this document bye meredith
[2:22:35] Speaker G (unidentified): okay you guys here we didn't sign this yeah is this the one what is this is what you're