← Back to MaineScanner

Bangor Tree Board reviews urban forestry plan, fall planting logistics

2026-10-21 · 54m · Source: Tree Board 10.21.26 (City of Bangor YouTube)
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:00] Karen S. Marysdaughter: yeah like mine falling out yeah oh yeah the door yeah okay folks we're live [1:05] Speaker B (unidentified): are you joining us today is ben coming or there he is right on time what's [1:28] Karen S. Marysdaughter: your day okay so we're live welcome to a regularly quarterly meeting of the tree board greg edwards want to go around with our three that's our three committee members i'm karen [1:43] Gregory Edwards: mary's daughter's member dominica is our member [1:51] Speaker B (unidentified): sophie cameron to be a vanguard horse technician [1:56] Karen S. Marysdaughter: everyone had a chance to look at the minutes that got sent out okay all favorites i don't know if we ever talked about whether we needed to do that but thanks for creating them forestry division by the numbered report right [2:23] Speaker D (unidentified): third quarter at fourth division was pretty productive just like any other city division we have a secret fix request that come into the office this quarter we were able to get at phase 8 sequence requests closed in addition to all the other work we just have to make throughout the quarter preventive pruning which includes identifying streets that need pruning in addition to paving corridors that we already pruned we were able to complete all of webster avenue venue, Fifth Street, all of West Broadway, and then all of Crestmont. In addition to preventive fruiting, part of the typical thing that we do is tree removals. We have a larger amount of tree removals due to the fact that we're implementing the MLF board management plan. The plan called for the removal of poorly formed ash trees throughout the city. In total, the tree removals Forestry Division has done within the third quarter adds up to 41, 29 of which my in-house crew has removed. Two, Burson Power was kind enough to remove due to the potential impact to their utilities and they were outside of our minimum approach distances that our in-house and contracted staff have some contractor for three division ads on hand and removals were completed by i've also listed the addresses and pertinent information proposed by I see it. That's the witch trees. [4:26] Karen S. Marysdaughter: Where are the numbers the diameter? Yes. Yeah, failed [4:34] Gregory Edwards: means they're completely dead. They were completely dead. [4:38] Speaker B (unidentified): The other thing is poorly formed, but also those that are like in hazardous locations such as the Versant ones which were on Garland. yes and they were over somebody's house but also over the three-phase power so if they were to start falling and dropping big branches they would have been dangerous are there a lot [5:01] Karen S. Marysdaughter: more ash trees that need to be through yes you know what we have we probably have about [5:12] Speaker B (unidentified): 200 ish more yeah it's a lot i think staging it out the way we have been in is good because it means that there's less of the landscape change all at once happening so [5:25] Gregory Edwards: it'll take us a couple of years so is that something you do through the winter or you won't [5:30] Speaker B (unidentified): do that yeah and obviously the rate at which that happens depends on folks and snow because our arborists do also plow and [5:50] Karen S. Marysdaughter: this includes the numbers pre-planted right yeah so [5:56] Speaker D (unidentified): i don't add that to there but for trees that were out planted this season we planted 77 which [6:08] Speaker B (unidentified): combined with what you guys did is more than has been accomplished since 2006. yeah [6:15] Karen S. Marysdaughter: Yeah, no, it's noticeable. [6:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so we're very proud of that. [6:20] Karen S. Marysdaughter: Amazing what you can do with STEM. [6:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah,, definitely. And switching over to the bare root was genius. I mean, it makes everything go so much faster, just even getting them out of the gravel pits and then getting them into the ground. Like, one person can do that instead of two people, which is excellent. and I think it also really will help with soil compaction stuff and do we have a number of over [6:51] Speaker E (unidentified): the past number of years how with the removal of trees and planting how we moving ahead how is Bangor fairing are we making headway on being on the plus side at some point I mean obviously with the ash trees 200 more trees plus the one that's not it's gonna be a dip [7:13] Speaker D (unidentified): I feel currently we're ahead as far as planting more than we've been able to remove, but those firm numbers I can definitely share. [7:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, there has not been excellent record keeping since Roland left. So I don't know that we have any planting numbers after 2006 that I've been able to find in our records and i don't know that we have removal records either so it's hard to know but i can also for the next meeting pull those numbers for 2023 onwards just so we can kind of have a [7:50] Karen S. Marysdaughter: full report if that's something you guys want i think it would be interesting to hear that and i [7:55] Speaker E (unidentified): know things have been prone to in regard to different diseases and stuff like that but i imagine that at some point hopefully we'll get through those and then we'll start to be on the [8:07] Karen S. Marysdaughter: surplus yeah more yeah right and it would be nice to have it as a chart so we could see it [8:13] Speaker B (unidentified): right baseline or yeah i can definitely prep something like that for you guys [8:17] Karen S. Marysdaughter: now that we have the tree inventory somebody could spend a little time to like show all the trees broken out into the different species and we'll see like ash trees going from 20 down to yeah like over time yeah and yeah so it's it's numbers like that would be for sure more digestible for everyone this is really helpful [8:42] Speaker B (unidentified): for us but yeah everybody else yeah and it can be something that we add onto the website too yeah i'll keep that in mind nice winter desk project yeah i had a question on state [8:57] Karen S. Marysdaughter: street i can only see like three that look like they're like boulder story like canopy trees they're mostly on the storage trees which like there are areas with no electrical [9:10] Speaker B (unidentified): yes yeah so the other piece like i was saying we're trying to sort of stage it out so we're not planting everything at the same time so we don't end up with an even age system with state street the esplanades are not huge so it's hard to justify putting in something that's going to get super wide so we're opting for more narrow species that'll get tall such as the hop horn beams even though they're listed as a medium species tree and yeah spaces will be filled in sort of as things continue the easiest thing to do because it's such a busy road and we didn't want to do a lane closure was to sort of go up one side and down the other and just budget wise it was easier to kind of go down towards downtown and do all the short trees on the side where the utilities are but it's definitely on the radar because we want to get more shade on that road and there are some spots where I know there's going to be we're talking about future pavement removal but that corner on Oak not Oak Broadway and State where it switches over to Broadway that's getting developed as a bank and they have a really robust us landscaping plan. We've seen that. So that will provide some shade sort of down towards that end. And I don't know if they have submitted plans for the new shoe place. Yeah. So that will [10:38] Karen S. Marysdaughter: also help. Yeah, I was just curious because I we lost a large oak tree there. Yeah,. Yes, but it's our surprisingly large. Yeah. Yeah, there is clearly space. [10:50] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah we put a hop horn beam in there and that so that should get fairly tall the other thing is probably ease of operability especially along that road for maintenance and stuff but yeah [11:07] Speaker E (unidentified): heard all right are there areas and just in general like where maybe a sidewalk might be bigger than it yeah usually is that you could at least you want to talk about that yeah yes [11:17] Speaker D (unidentified): so we have been in talks and sophie has really been leading those talks as far as pavement removal and coordinating those efforts and ensuring that forestry division puts it in to a budget because the manpower and equipment hours needed for pavement removal would not only benefit the forestry division but it is something that we are asking for so forestry division we built the build for the pavement removal we're really working with planning division to ensure you know that we're meeting all the needs as far as funding and the resource funding and state street is wonderful yeah highlighted yeah and talking to [12:10] Speaker B (unidentified): engineering too to make sure they you know are on board with that kind of stuff and then yeah like ben said just the manpower of getting it done we're also trying to sort of partner pavement removal projects with when those sidewalks are supposed to be redone anyway to sort of make it one big project as opposed to sort of we're going and we're doing this and then we got to go do something else and then we're coming back and redoing this you know plus that would reduce the amount of damage to newly planted trees like say they just went and fixed up the esplanade and made it plantable we put trees in and then they got to come back and do the sidewalks two years later you know the risk there is pretty high that something [12:52] Karen S. Marysdaughter: gets hit so yeah I think it was three or four years ago when they repaved State Street I like definitely nudged yeah Aaron and engineering at the time and they've removed a fair amount of asphalt they weren't as aggressive as I would have been yeah but they were open to it did they redo [13:10] Speaker B (unidentified): do the sidewalks at that time they like patched it okay yeah so the sidewalks i believe where we landed in that meeting was that they are probably within the next couple of years due for a full redo so that's sort of what we're waiting on because it's a dot road and there's some sort of complicated mumbo jumbo with that i don't understand because i don't do roads [13:35] Gregory Edwards: okay so i had to communicate with sophie somebody on our street pulled out a tree [13:43] Karen S. Marysdaughter: almost immediately so how much is that happening that's the first one we've had since 2023. [13:51] Speaker D (unidentified): one resident has removed a tree however we have had residents cut trees in our neighborhood as [14:01] Speaker B (unidentified): well yeah not any of the neighbors that i know but we also have had some issues with trees just kind of being hacked at on union and first street which don't like i don't know why there's another one missing from first street i drove by and i think that's just the hazard of being a tree downtown so yeah we're keeping and i'm trying to keep a pretty close eye on them i try to go out and see all of them like once a week just to make sure presence is seen around them in my head there's this idea that i put up a cute little sign that says please don't hurt me but i don't know [14:43] Gregory Edwards: how feasible that is you could put an under surveillance note on it yeah even if it's [14:49] Karen S. Marysdaughter: not true i suppose yeah we did that with the little the first year we did tree watering bags we were like they were designed to be unzipped and I was concerned someone would just unzip them and walk off with them so we like put a little cute sign on it that's yeah I'm a little [15:05] Speaker B (unidentified): watering bag for this baby tree I might try it in the spring and see if it gets us anywhere because I mean you don't get what you don't ask for so I haven't asked them not to break the trees off that's [15:23] Karen S. Marysdaughter: it for our numbers okay questions [15:31] Speaker E (unidentified): so for the division we [15:35] Speaker D (unidentified): have been pretty small for a number of years since i started we have finally hired an arborist one to take up an existing vacancy so as far as tree service staff at we are full so now forestry division is composed of an arborist one an arborist two heavy equipment operator one downtown custodian downtown landscaper marcia and in addition to that obviously forestry technician and myself forestry division supervises the care and upkeep of the four municipal cemeteries we lost our cemetery sexton probably the first week of august so i've been doing double duty assisting with burials supervising cemetery maintenance and supervising the crew the crew has been very good about helping me with that job and getting me the paperwork timely and things like that but we have hired an in-house candidate for the cemetery sexton and that was as of last week [16:56] Speaker B (unidentified): cool that's kind of amazing well we've been up for yes so we're currently at full staffing yeah never happened in the 14 years i've been out [17:14] Karen S. Marysdaughter: yeah that's great is it is it like just because you put in the effort or is it also like support [17:23] Speaker D (unidentified): from Public Works? Support from everybody has been tremendous. [17:29] Karen S. Marysdaughter: And it's something we can maintain. [17:31] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, yep. Between Human Resources, the union, and you know staff at Public Works, we were able to [17:39] Speaker B (unidentified): modify and enhance Orchard Division staff. And it's a really good crew of folks, which is nice. [17:51] Karen S. Marysdaughter: that's really good all right moving on and forgot sarah was here sure are you here [Sarah Lilly: yes i'm here] yeah our next up is the urban forestry management plan which we all have the latest drafts sitting in front of us there do you want to reintroduce yourself to [18:20] Sarah Lilly: everybody and show over it oh sure yeah so i'm sarah lilly i'm urban forestry consultant with eoc and environmental and been working with all of you to some extent on this project i did put together some slides that i can share i'm not sure if i can share on a screen [18:40] Speaker B (unidentified): you should be able to maybe there we go can you see that hold on let me see if i can get it to work up here [18:56] Sarah Lilly: my internet might be a little slow but now again oh great yeah so just a really quick run through of the document in about 10 slides a summary just a basis of how we started the project and we've been working together for about a year or so we're into this nearing the completion we looked at what does bangor have as far as resources what the city wants and what the people want as far as managing the trees how to get what is wanted with the trees and incorporating some feedback in there to make sure that what you want is being accomplished published. And I actually just switched this picture out because you're asking about tree species. But we looked at the tree inventory data, which was updated, thankfully. And there are just over 9,000 trees of 106 species. And I included this, the species and genus and family. There are a lot of maples, especially Norway maples, and those ash trees. I'm sure this ash tree percentage has decreased a little bit as ash trees have been removed thanks to the EAB response plan there is a recent uptick in newly planted trees and we ran the data through i-tree eco to find a 7.4 million dollar replacement value just of those inventory trees and from that some recommendations were to increase diversity of course don't plant invasive Norway maples and continue, I have to move a window, continue increased planting. So I really enjoyed hearing the planting numbers that you shared. That's so exciting. And prioritizing maintenance and maintain trees proactively. So there were maintenance recommendations associated with trees, but building in a prioritization level in there just to be able to better split them out on what needs to be done immediately versus potentially later and then with full staffing hopefully starting to maintain trees proactively. We did a canopy assessment and found that Bangor has 51.2 percent tree canopy cover with the lowest being downtown and canopy cover we compared it against the spot group so we could incorporate population and income levels so canopy cover is inversely related in general to population density and income so some recommendations that came out of that is to plan for tree planting we did a walking tour downtown and there aren't many places to plant trees and as you heard there are sophie and ben are already working with engineering streets planning on incorporating tree planting into future designs maintaining existing trees because larger existing trees provide the most canopy and but also you know planting new trees to replace trees as they age out and die and also creating protection measures for trees on private property so the tree canopy assessment looks at all the trees across the city not just the inventory trees so trees on forested lands and in people's backyards we did a review of Bangor's municipal code. This is just a snapshot of what that looked like and you'll see it in the plan. So just compared, looked at the code for the different areas. So public trees, shade trees, and buffer zones. And we also ran the code through the urban and community forestry tree code assessment matrix just to identify potential recommendations. And a few of those are on the right here. here. We benchmarked Bangor's program against a national survey and we compared it to either communities of a similar population size or trees in the north or cities in the northeast. Here's a snapshot of what that looked like and we looked at these five different categories for community and staff, budget, management operations, volunteers, partners, and contractors. And so this was just a snapshot of the tree management benchmarking. So how does Bangor compare as far as insect disease readiness plan? I would say you guys are above peer group because you have your EAB plan and Red Pine scale plan. [23:35] Gregory Edwards: Can I ask who are our peer group? [23:41] Sarah Lilly: So it was a population group we compared to initially. And let me see. this doesn't show both of them but the population group was 25 to 40 to 50 000 people so i know bangar is on the low side of that population group and in some cases we also compared against northeastern region thank you yeah no good question so we also did interviews using SWOT, a SWOT analysis that strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats, just to get a pulse of how the tree managers in Bangor, what they think of the program. And those are included in these benchmarking tables just at the bottom. I called them SWOT thoughts. So for example, in this one for volunteers, partners, and contractors, I would say there's a really strong coordination between the Forestry Division and you guys, the Tree Board, Bangor Beautiful, University of Maine, and the Audubon Society. There was a large community outreach component to the plan. These are the different ways that we interacted with the community and based on discussions and from the public forum and the survey responses, we developed this vision statement. So Bangor will be home to a resilient and evenly distributed urban forest that helps residents thrive in every neighborhood with a 55% tree canopy goal. Just a reminder, it's just above 51% right now, and that's across the city. Public trees will be recognized as a vital part of city infrastructure, providing environmental, socioeconomic, and health benefits for all present and future inhabitants so that kind of guided what came next as far as how to get there so there are a couple of different strategies we did develop some work plan tables so just taking the inventory data and the EAB response plan and what's happening there as far as treating and removing trees to determine on a five-year cycle if you wanted to tackle all that maintenance just planning it out over five years with costs that came from the forestry division and then also we broke it out into three main goals and for each goal there were several strategies and then actions to build out those strategies so these three goals were to grow the forest to reach that 55 percent canopy goal manage the trees for safety and efficiency and then collaborate with the community for long-term success and using those strategies and actions we built out this implementation matrix to make sure that things are happening so i grabbed the snapshot of the longer term time frame so there are things like update the canopy assessment on a five-year cycle to make sure that you're moving towards that 55% canopy goal. And I just wanted to give a brief update. We're nearing the completion. We're gathering final edits now and I wanted to thank everyone here. I think everyone here has played a part in this and as you can have heard already, Ben and Sophie have already been hugely proactive in pushing the program forward and it's an exciting time in Bangor and we're looking to present the to the infrastructure committee in December [27:35] Karen S. Marysdaughter: well I [27:46] Gregory Edwards: I guess for me the question of maintenance is the biggest looming one yeah it's a lot of trees to plant and we've been having droughts the last two summers and how do we realistically even water all those trees, let alone any other maintenance that they might need? Because it certainly is intuitive that if we want to have tree cover, then we need to preserve as many trees that we plant as possible. [28:19] Speaker D (unidentified): We have switched how we do plantings. We've done more and will do more corridor planting. I'm sorry identifying streets where trees can get planted and doing more bulk planting versus former planting practices which were scattered all about all throughout the city and it was tough to maintain our house staff check in on a water room this [28:51] Speaker B (unidentified): is it is a newer system i think this is our first full year doing it actually i'm keeping a record of maintenance log just so i know where everything is and when things get checked on we'll see how it goes moving into the future because obviously like we have a lot of stuff to do and keeping up with it is however we're doing it sort of on a three year period for each tree so from the year that they're planted they get three years of sort of maintenance which is restaking trying to get them to grow correctly preventative pruning if they need soil amendments because it seems like they're just not getting enough water or nutrients or whatever and then going around with watering and we've created a pretty ingenious watering setup that's actually really affected so you'll see it tomorrow so we're hoping that makes things a little bit easier but we are also aware that like if it's not working we'll need to start to think about other strategies that we can employ such as like signage for homeowners if they have a tree out front to say like give me some water kind of deal but that was actually my [30:11] Speaker E (unidentified): going to be my question or business if people want to you know yeah there's a business there I don't think it would hurt I know it takes time to ask a shopkeeper yeah could you please [30:23] Speaker B (unidentified): throw a little water on this yeah and some people have been doing it voluntarily which is excellent that being said it is you know public property so we can't make anybody do that so we can't necessarily rely on it but it might help so that's a strategy that we're we're also thinking about employing if it seems to get too much for us in-house well it would also help their business [30:43] Gregory Edwards: having a healthy tree in front of it too so yeah the goals from the plan 3a4 3a5 provide education to homeowners and how to care for trees using resources from partner organizations and increase community engagement opportunities and it i this has the little that it's cheap to do that the little one which if that's if you can get partners who are doing their time but really to educate the city about the importance of trees and how to care for them is a big job i think it would be an excellent job i think we have better tree canopy sure if we really you know adopt a tree in your neighborhood and here's how you care for it and somebody's checking up on it but that really is time-consuming. [31:31] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, and we are in, I'll look at you, Tracy. Since I'm jointly hired with Parks and Rec, there is like a outdoor education component of this that I'm really trying to start working on some programming for. We're working on doing forest field tours and we've been partnered with Maine SAF now for about a year as well. So getting folks out to see sort of the urban forest and what we're doing is definitely a priority but yeah that's another sort of part of my job [32:06] Gregory Edwards: that's a fun another fun winter project yeah I was thinking in my neighborhood you planted all these lovely trees that if somebody had gone through the neighborhood a couple weeks before and did little door hangers we're going to be planting or you did the signs the trees are going to be taken down maybe just some signs and stuff we're about to plant a tree here yeah we could give that a go in the is one thing well anyway just some public education oh i know labels on the trees what they are because i know somewhat about trees but i'm throwing them down the street i wonder what this is i wonder what this is so just even yeah saying this is serviceberry this is i think would be another [32:54] Speaker E (unidentified): and with i understand the whole point of planting corridors and that's great But like if there were in residential neighborhoods, perhaps if people, I don't know how, again, you would necessarily do this, but are you still getting requests by homeowners to have a tree put in front of there? [33:14] Speaker B (unidentified): And we try, we plan our corridors. Like we have specifically, for example, we had requests for two requests on West Broadway, one on Lincoln and then one over on Butel. So those are all in the same neighborhoods like I treat that as a corridor because that it's just about ease of access for us at that point. So we do when we get enough requests, then those requests are filled like by neighborhood. [33:41] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I guess the second part of my point is what Karen was saying that perhaps approaching these people who are putting in the request and say, would you be okay with being a guardian of the tree? I'm sure it's most important in the beginning few years of a tree, yeah totally, the watering part and that's again easy to do if they have a garden in the front yeah they could easily squirt a tree you know yeah I think maybe that's part of the process yeah the gears are turning [34:13] Speaker B (unidentified): and I think formalizing more of a request program would be super useful as well as our signage [34:20] Gregory Edwards: and stuff like that you can even have a little app that said I watered the tree today so it was I'm not an app designer I do think your newsletter is great I don't know what your circulation is but that's a great it's actually pretty good we have 180 subscribers [34:38] Speaker B (unidentified): deal for me no I think that's I appreciate it yeah I try to keep it fun [34:49] Gregory Edwards: and that there but there may be like communities that have Facebook pages for the community is a place to put information we're going to be planting trees in your neighborhood does anybody [34:59] Speaker B (unidentified): want to adopt a tree yeah we have a little our hands are a little bit tied because we can't use our personal Facebooks to do anything like that so well yeah we would have to figure out what the logistics of that are but you know Tracy has contacts with all the people that are friends of whatever park that they're friends of so those folks we've reached out to and spoken with on some occasions recently chape and park we had a long conversation about all the ash trees that unfortunately have to come down in there because they're not looking great and that was really productive and they were very receptive to that so i think that's super valuable is using [35:45] Gregory Edwards: and community groups as well and have tree block parties after you've planted and get everybody together walk down look at the trees say what they are that sounds like a you job greg i'm not volunteering to do it but i think it's a great idea because if you're doing corridors yeah and you have the natural neighborhood yeah to bring people out yeah absolutely that's a great [36:07] Karen S. Marysdaughter: idea so i have a question for sarah i assume you've seen these plans be developed what would be the best way for us to keep an eye on these goals and strategies and actions that we've outlined so that it just doesn't become a plan that sits on a shelf can like could this come with a like a spreadsheet of the like an easier to read version that sophie and ben could update us on like each year and then we could see if there's progress being made yeah no I think that [36:41] Sarah Lilly: would be great to add and really beneficial I think that would be the best way to do it honestly maybe prepare this annually for a tree board meeting yeah definitely Sarah we can talk about [36:54] Speaker B (unidentified): that when we meet next week because I think that would be a pretty easy worksheet to develop [36:58] Sarah Lilly: like just a yearly report I also wanted to mention that I know there's been a lot of great ideas that have been discussed just in the past few minutes and i think going to the partners and community forestry conference sophie you will get so many great ideas on how to promote trees and i love the bangor block party idea i think that would be really fun i [37:24] Gregory Edwards: didn't have a chance to go through all of these goals and all but i like the one that says that fines and penalties should be attached to the actual value of the tree in some way because sometimes I mean these people around the corner for me who took down two huge mature trees that appear to be in fairly good health and are they gonna be fined $100 you know those trees are worth way more than that 's a process we're working [37:55] Speaker B (unidentified): through right now is figuring out how to properly administrate it should be [38:00] Gregory Edwards: required to plant x number of trees to replace yeah i don't like punitive things but i've been [38:07] Speaker B (unidentified): reading a lot of ordinances and work we're thinking about strategically how to best approach that so i know it's a lot and if y'all get a chance to read through this and have comments you can shoot me or ben an email and we can just sort of throw them into the word doc [38:32] Gregory Edwards: talk for Sarah and she can address them the new land use codes that are about ready to come out do they meet all the recommendations we've been working with Anya pretty closely [38:44] Speaker B (unidentified): we're trying to what is the word unify our approach to things yes we're making [38:53] Speaker D (unidentified): in a more efficient municipal machine trying to you know coordinate efforts so you know undo things the other departments really can make sure their ordinances are followed within the city ourselves because sometimes city departments actually end up violating city ordinances due [39:16] Speaker B (unidentified): to lack of communication or just like counter-intuitive things that exist within our current ordinance, which is nobody's fault. It's just the idea of having a living document that changes all the time. Yeah, and planning division seems super on board with all of this. Anya comes to all of our meetings for the development of this. [39:39] Speaker E (unidentified): That reminds me, I do watch the planning board meetings, I watch all the meetings, but anyway, and I think once in a while I do to hear that they refer, that Anya would say, [39:49] Speaker D (unidentified): she talks with the new guys.
New Business
[39:51] Speaker E (unidentified): And I guess I have a thought now, when the new, like say the bank going in on the corner of Broadway and State Street, and any new business that's coming in and planting, following through with that, do they have to make certain that the tree survive? Like if a tree does die, do they replace it? And I'm sure it depends upon if it's on their property or a street tree but like how does that work yeah so it is different there [40:18] Speaker D (unidentified): are screening standards that businesses depending on which district they're in they need to maintain downtown district is fairly strict and I'm not in the planning office so I'm sure I'm asking you over all the details but as far as far as maintenance, I'm not 100% sure. Anya would be the better person to ask that specific question, but there's definitely screening yards between different uses, and with us now being on the planning team, per se, we're able to look at different plan submissions and give suggestions for what trees should go where, finding all the little details yeah okay [41:16] Karen S. Marysdaughter: yeah impressive thank you yeah good job everybody well one committee meeting and one yeah one city council yeah [41:35] Speaker B (unidentified): it should be we're not concerned we also have the operational plan which i can send to you all individually but we don't like have a meeting between now and when they bring it to council [41:46] Karen S. Marysdaughter: but we'll send that out to you guys to check over yeah is the operational plan just how the [41:51] Speaker B (unidentified): operations work or does it include like planting standards it includes planting standards it includes our updated species list for public we can only mandate public plantings and then it also includes sort of we're developing a yearly calendar of like when things happen at what time including like plantings and you know like we know we need to check in with you this month about what you guys are doing you know so it sort of just like a map of how which will be helpful for the new people coming in yeah i remember another question i had [42:35] Gregory Edwards: was about protecting trees on private property and how that gets accomplished yeah we're trying [42:44] Speaker B (unidentified): something new out it's not required but we did our first kind of trial run of it and it went fairly well. Ben and I are both trained in using aerial imagery to sort of determine tree species and location and whatever that is. And that allows us to kind of look at the lots where things are going in. Because we go to the meetings now. So we know what's coming down the pipeline. And we talked with Anya and Anne about it. And they said they from now on in the pre application meetings are going to offer to those landowners, if you would like to have Ben or Sophie we come out to identify trees that should be preserved for like either to save you money on your screening purposes or they're like over a certain diameter set up a time with them and they'll go do that and we did that for the first time on broadway and it went very well so and that's on lots under 20 acres just because it isn't like feasible for us to go out to a hundred acre property and like you don't have any of those left well yeah okay i'm back thinking about the big woods but no so that's hopeful at least and it seems like folks are at least in this one scenario they bought into it fairly easily because it's at no cost to them so thanks [44:11] Karen S. Marysdaughter: sarah thank you all thank you thank you hey i'm not saying anything else i'll move us on to bangor beautiful fall tree planting which was going to be last friday but because of cold wet rain is tomorrow sophie emailed earlier today we're not doing the one median that currently exists because they're planning to add a second median they're gonna do all three oh they're gonna great even better yeah we're gonna build out the other two medians which are currently just asphalt salt and traffic paint into fully functional, like, stormwater processing islands. [44:59] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, parking islands. No, we're not doing full bioswales, just because that would cost a lot of money. And also then we would have to do some very fancy drainage stuff. Essentially where we landed is we're going to try doing just granite curbing. it'll hold up better against the snow machines and then it'll also allow for us to create like kind of gaps in the curbing to like have water drain through it and then out the other side so that there's an opportunity for water to pass over the roots and whatever gets absorbed gets absorbed but we are going to do all three everyone seemed very on board with it so should be we're planning for next spring but we'll see and then if all goes according to plan we'll be [45:49] Karen S. Marysdaughter: able to put trees in it next spring so there will be less to plant there will be 15 there will be 14 around that 19 around there were five in the one median okay but because they're talking about doing heavy construction in the area it's best not to put trees out in the middle [46:14] Gregory Edwards: only 15 maybe you'll have them all planted by 10. yeah just come admire them because we've got [46:18] Karen S. Marysdaughter: double the time this time we thought we were doing twice the number over which you know i don't know i'm not a professional volunteer coordinator so maybe a lot of people will show up out of community spirit but maybe we'll have the same kind of you know six to twelve some of us are [46:38] Speaker E (unidentified): non-committal we just show up anyway we don't commit to ahead of time saying we're gonna yeah [46:42] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah i do know we have a main audubon volunteer and a friend of mine is coming yay [46:49] Speaker E (unidentified): two of us can be leaving like now yeah oh right thank you for serving our and picking [46:56] Karen S. Marysdaughter: games i'm probably available for the next meeting okay and this time this works fine [47:02] Gregory Edwards: especially now that the k-bar bus is back to running to run i can actually take the bus [Speaker B (unidentified): to do in] here no [47:15] Karen S. Marysdaughter: longer have a quorum but i don't know if that we're not actually making any decisions can i get an update on the invasive species downtown because that was part of what we were thinking about doing at abbott square was addressing the large burning bushes growing on the hill and if you to if your department's tackling all of the invasive downtown no that [47:43] Speaker D (unidentified): so invasives we're working with downtown bangor partnership i believe she has lists and locations of where the invasives that they have noticed are currently at least in abbott square my crew has very nicely approved said invasive but decorative species so i'm going to hold off until spring as far as removing them but we have identified you know burning bushes and barbarian things throughout downtown that are going to get pulled but we just need to have an idea of what is going to go in their place in those beds and some of those beds are also within parks and rec's purview so not pulling in anything before we discussed with Parks and Rec and, you know, other downtown [48:41] Karen S. Marysdaughter: regions. The plan is to get them out. Yeah, because like, I mean, especially just the [48:46] Speaker B (unidentified): highly visible ones, the ones in Farm City Hall. Yeah, those are already on the docket. And not [48:51] Karen S. Marysdaughter: huge, and the burning bushes, I mean, just cut them down to stumps and treat the stumps. [48:57] Speaker B (unidentified): They also seem to pop out really easily. I've noticed, which is interesting. [49:05] Karen S. Marysdaughter: Okay just curious because we obviously want to see those gone and as we're doing perimeter plantings you know we could put those close up to where the shrubs depending on I know some of them are like down on a severe swam. Okay yeah [49:24] Speaker B (unidentified): and I'll be out there earlier than 8 tomorrow if I mean you don't have to join me but I'm gonna bring all the trees over and just sort of do some layout of like where things are going yeah and you'll be there right yes yeah and then we also have Marcia and Tyler so we should honestly kind [49:46] Karen S. Marysdaughter: of fly by but I say that yeah I mean I don't know what the digging will be median I was expecting to be the hardest spot the perimeter it's still probably [49:57] Speaker B (unidentified): gonna be filled yeah there is in that meeting that we were talking about we're doing the islands where the pay or the scanner is with the arms when you go back into the permit lot there is a wire that is not mapped that goes under that little jet out so we need to kind of be either change the placement so that it's further back or just be super careful so and Park Emerson who not runs the thing but he maintains all of our public parking lots he's aware that we're doing it and there's a sort of an informal parking ban that we're doing in the morning so yeah we should have some space [50:49] Karen S. Marysdaughter: that's the last i mean we have no resident tree removal requests so this is the last thing on the agenda we're missing for tomorrow i think should [51:02] Gregory Edwards: go pretty well yeah i think it'll be great [51:04] Speaker B (unidentified): and we'll have water so i think are you going to bring potentially oh no tomorrow is [51:11] Karen S. Marysdaughter: the snowplow program i could bring my trailer with 90 gallon water but you can fit it 's probably a good statement oh my god it'll work yeah it will so one time like 10 years ago when they were redoing west market pickering square now west market square when they were doing the construction the sewer department had just a temporary like spigot locked spigot hooked up to a fire yes so like if you're doing corridor plantings could you get the sewer department the water department to go in and put a locked spigot on so that you know Marsha could fill up her truck right there as opposed to having to drive back yes like that would be and that [51:59] Speaker D (unidentified): is surprisingly enough something I have just talked about with the water department because we've been tasked with Pickering Square so they will provide us with a meter but we do need to provide I believe our own backflow device which we had Marcia set up with the hose to fill her but we were we did not have a backflow device so okay so that is something [52:25] Karen S. Marysdaughter: that is possible and you know could even be done okay cool because that's it's always getting you know water is really heavy if you've got if you've only got an 80 gallon tank you're not going to go that far. Yep. So cool. That's nice. That would be cool. Well, I don't [52:51] Speaker B (unidentified): have anything else. Do we want to discuss scheduling? Oh, yes. [52:56] Karen S. Marysdaughter: We had a pattern going. It was like second, Wednesday, but this is third Wednesday. Yeah, I've had something last week i was bored i think we right because they had been elsewhere and then they came back so we moved in the pink was smooth so third wednesdays yeah for me october so the next one january that sounds right yep and just starting yeah first month of the quarter 3rd Wednesday 4-5 yeah assuming council chambers are free well good job easy [54:03] Speaker B (unidentified): all right thanks folks are you getting it I will thanks [54:11] Gregory Edwards: for coming Thank you for coming. We have some dinner.