← Back to MaineScanner

Bethel Zoning Board Denies Appeal Over Deck Setback Stop Work Order

2026-10-27 · 1h 35m · Source: Board of Appeals 10/27/26. (Bethel Maine Live via W.H.A.T. (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): I guess we are where we need to be. [0:10] Speaker B (unidentified): You can hear us, right, Courtney? Yes, I can. All right. [0:26] Speaker C (unidentified): That's it? Yeah. It's official? All right, we're over. [0:32] Speaker A (unidentified): We have some little business on the side here first, and then we'll get going. I guess we'll get the chairman checked out. Opening statements. What we're going to do is each group will have some time, bring their case, and we'll talk about it, see where it goes with it. As far as this meeting goes, we're going to have separate groups saying their piece. I'd appreciate it if everybody just listens until it's their turn, and then when it's all done we'll open it for everybody to have any questions that works for you guys first may okay we have approval of minutes but we haven't so there was some from march 5th of [1:41] Speaker B (unidentified): 24 which is the last time you guys met right and those are in your pocket they're very short it [1:46] Speaker D (unidentified): IT WAS A VERY SHORT MEETING. [1:48] Speaker B (unidentified): I HAD TO GO BACK AND WATCH THE VIDEO ON YOUTUBE. [1:53] Speaker A (unidentified): SO, I'LL MOW APPROVAL. ALL IN FAVOR? HE DID. OH, OKAY. I DIDN'T HEAR HIM. I'M GOOD AT THIS. COMMUNICATION. OKAY, COMMUNICATION. THIS IS THE POINT WHERE WE INVITE CRITCHEN AND LAURA, ARE THE ONES WHO SUBMITTED THIS, CORRECT? YES. So I'll give you the first one. [2:40] Speaker E (unidentified): Do I have the time limit? No. So the first question I have is I have these documents here that are the same as the ones that you have, but they're in the order that I'm going to present them. Would you like to have them, or would you rather just shuffle through the exhibits? Do you understand what I'm asking? You're all of it. So I have these for each of you. They are the same exhibits that I've already given you. I'd like to know if you'd like them because they're in the order that I'll be presenting them. So stop the shuffle. I've got them all. Okay, you have them all? [3:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Yep. We have about 70 pages. [3:17] Speaker E (unidentified): That's what I'm trying to solve. [3:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. Some of it's repetitious. Go ahead. [3:23] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. So is it my turn to go? Yes. So I'm going to start by saying that I'm Richard Cumbert. My wife Laura and I are abutters of 1 Mill Hill Road and we live at [address] and our property is directly, our line is, we share that with 1 Mill Hill. We're here because we are appealing the code enforcement officer's decision to lift the stop for corridor on a deck before it was proven to be in compliance with both setback distances as required by 966C1 and its own permit. The town attorney has argued that we cannot appeal the original permit because the 30 day appeal limit has long passed. We're not here to appeal that permit. We're specifically appealing the CEO's September 21 decision to lift the stop work order and allow the neighbors to actually remain inside the 10 foot setback. We plan to demonstrate that the CEO had not approved the mentions on which to base the decision to allow a violation. Understood? Do I need to, I have standing, I can see that there's no one stopping me from saying what I'm saying, right? You're fine. Okay, so I'm moving on to this. So in your packet that you had for me, there are the application for the permit and a letter from Mr. Wheeler. So that's exhibit four for me and exhibit 19 and 19A and B. Okay. So this first one is the, that's the letter that was attached to Mr. Wheeler's application and he outlines three changes, the modification of the roof line, the new addition on the back of the L, and the change in the windows in the barn. And the only reference to the deck is the statement at the very bottom that says, the deck is proposed to replace previous ones removed by the previous owner. There are no dimensions attached to that and there's no indication that they can be found anywhere else. That's all there is on there. And the rest of the permit is on the back, right under where it says there is a textbook setback requirement. The list of variations that it's going to do not include the deck. So the only reference to the deck is this one, and it has no dimensions. I remind you that what we're doing here is looking for dimensions anywhere in this application or anything presented to the planning board when they were making this decision. So, the one thing that, the packet that was in the town attorney's receipt is all of the elements in the supporting documents folder. The supporting documents folder is all of the things that are submitted ahead of time and are available for public review. So those are the things that were present at the planning board meeting right there in those chairs those were the only things there were no dimensions no dimension drawings there were no dimension drawings of any kind so that's what they were facing when they were making a decision about what they were going to do with this application here are the minutes from that meeting i'm going to read them they are andy wheeler the representative of katherine and sam mcdonough gave the board a brief description of the project jim bennett a motion to read the deed for Catherine and same knowledge in the record to Travis logic seconded Auburn favor Travis logic look motion to approve the finding the fact document is drafted and then the reason for standard F to say the new shape is still compatible with the district Danielle Horton seconded over here Jim Bennett motion to add a condition of approvals stating existing black shutter locations will remain Aaron Osterhage seconded promotion passed with four I's and two A's, Dana Horton and Travis Wood. Now, in that, there was no mention at all in that meeting of any dimensions for the deck. In fact, there was no mention of the deck. And so that's, in my mind, we have not yet found any dimensions for this deck. There was on that packet that the town attorney sent you that was the, there were elevation problems in there. Remember seeing them? The elevation going, they show what could be interpreted as a deck, and it probably is a deck. However, there are no dimensions on that deck, and there isn't even an identification that it is a deck. So that was one of the elements that was in front of the, and the town attorney has put two of them in there. There was only one in the package. So right now, Mr. Brown, you're looking at what the town attorney has added. Those are not things that were in front of the... You're looking at Exhibit B, are you? I'd like you not to be looking at Exhibit D, because that is not the one I'm talking about. I'm talking about Exhibit C. And that one has only the things that were in front of the planning board. Mr. Brown, are you looking at Exhibit C? Yes. [8:53] Speaker F (unidentified): That's Exhibit C? I think so. It's not listed in Exhibit C. It is on the front. Does [9:03] Speaker E (unidentified): it say Exhibit B? Oh, okay. So that's not the one I'm referring to. Exhibit C is the one that was in front of the Board. What you're holding right there, the Board never saw that. Never. Not once. It's an important element of this. Anyway. One of the things I'd like to read to you is the, it's on the,, I don't know if the finding of facts it's 96 7 d2 the granting of this proposal is dependent upon and limited to proposals and plans contained in the application and supporting documents submitted and affirmed by the applicant any variation from these plans proposals and supporting documents is subject to review and approval prior to implementation the key words in there is that the that what has to be in front of the board are the proposals and plans contained in the application and supporting documents. Nothing else can enter this. It is not possible for a last minute flash of a document to be part of a valid procedure. Am I making sense? A [10:11] Speaker A (unidentified): little bit. A little bit. Yes, I think that. It's a lot, too. It's a lot. [10:15] Speaker E (unidentified): But all that I'm trying to get through is that the planning board did not have in their possession any dimensions for the deck. None. They had no knowledge. I don't think that they were even talking about a deck. I was here. I didn't know. And so there were no dimensions for the deck in the material that they were given. And there were no dimensions for the deck anywhere at all. [10:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Richard, am I looking at the wrong place here? Yeah, there's a deck here, which I assume is under contention, that has dimensions of 22 by 33 items. Am I looking at the right? [10:57] Speaker E (unidentified): Right, it's confusing. Let me talk about those, if you don't mind. [11:01] Speaker C (unidentified): It's a long part of the structure. [11:04] Speaker E (unidentified): So these two documents here. Right there. Yes, is that it? Right there? [11:09] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, it's on here, what you're holding in your hand. And just from my perspective, the lower left-hand [11:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, I'm very familiar with it. [11:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Those are dimensions of 22 and 33, is that correct? [11:27] Speaker E (unidentified): That's right. So these dimensions, though, I think that the point that I'm trying to make is that the playing board never saw this. That's key. They voted without ever seeing this. Understood? Understood? [11:42] Speaker C (unidentified): That's... What... What is that... What substantiates that statement? [11:49] Speaker E (unidentified): That... That I'm making? Yes. It wasn't in the, packet. The... Exhibit C. That's why I wanted to give you these. Exhibit C has,... That's the town attorney. Exhibit C shows you only what was in the packet of supporting documents. If you find Exhibit C and look only at that, do you have it? No. [12:12] Speaker C (unidentified): I...... I want to... I want to... through all these pages twice a day, and they are not particularly well-labeled. Matter of fact, I'm really confused at this flat map, the property of William Scott [Speaker E (unidentified): in total name.] I have trouble orienting myself to it, and trying to figure out, is your property with Fred Moultrie and Sandra Bycroft in it? No. That does not count? No. OK. I have no idea why this particular item is in the packet, because I can't relate it to anything. OK. [12:59] Speaker E (unidentified): So if I can, I'm not sure how to help, but do you have what the town's attorney sent you? [13:07] Speaker C (unidentified): I have what the town attorney set this [13:19] Speaker E (unidentified): picture. Looks like this. It's on October 20th. [13:23] Speaker G (unidentified): That's right. They're attaching it to. Did you see that? [13:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you see that? [13:31] Speaker C (unidentified): That which the town attorney can adjust. That there is a time constraint involved here. OK. In terms of the stop oral law or appealing this law fast enough, there was something that was not mentioned. [13:52] Speaker G (unidentified): So that's true. I'm happy to talk with the board about that a bit after you've gotten sort of the facts teased out. I'd suggest sort of working with Mr. Tummin to tease out what his argument is and then.. [14:06] Speaker C (unidentified): I have this sketch. [14:11] Speaker E (unidentified): OK, so let me go to the sketch. Yes, because it's kind of important that we understand what the problem is. [14:16] Speaker C (unidentified): I have no substantiating evidence where it came from, whether the planning board had it or not. It took me a while to figure it out. [14:28] Speaker E (unidentified): Can I just explain that the planning board never saw this document. Okay. And the reason they didn't see it, you don't have to take my word for it, is what was in front of the planning board were the contents of Exhibit C from the town's attorney. Not B. B is what the town attorney has introduced to diffuse this issue. The items in Exhibit C are what the planning board saw. And that's a very important piece of the public. This was not in the... Well, I'm not sure why you can't confirm that statement. Can I, need someone to help me here because you can confirm that statement, it's in the, it's right in the information that the town's attorney sent you as Exhibit C. [15:33] Speaker H (unidentified): Can I come up there? Can I, can I go up there? Sure. Yeah. And I know you want me to wait until it's finished, but I can tell you how they're looking here. You can see in my letter where I introduce Exhibit B and it explains what that document That document or the plans that were shown at the board meeting itself. [15:51] Speaker E (unidentified): So this is Exhibit C. We all have that one. So Exhibit C, this is what the plan board saw. Anything that's not in this exhibit is something the plan board never saw. So this is a deed for the Valiant's House. This is a letter to the Butters. This is a list of the Butters. This is a letter that was sent to Anna that has the information I mentioned earlier that mentioned the deck right there. Also in here is a few photographs of the building before any work was done on it. I'm not sure what it is, but it is information that has any dimensions on it. Now here we get to this one. So it's important that you get this. this is the only dimension drawing that the planning board saw the town's attorney has introduced four more or three more that they never saw so if they if you saw this would you be able to tell [16:52] Speaker G (unidentified): the dimensions of it probably not mr timon it might be helpful for the video as well as those in the audience for us not to crown the dance okay so i do have to get them to understand I understand, but it's all in the package that they've, that everyone has a copy of it. [17:12] Speaker E (unidentified): But they were using a packet with the two packages all in one. And so do we all understand that we have no dimensions other than what's here, right? So the rest is the finding of facts and a few other things, but none of it is without dimension. When we move to the town's attorney, the town attorney's Exhibit D, that's where we run into all kinds of documents that were not at the Cleansing Board. So I'm going to bring this up, if I can, but these two images, this is a document of the old deck, and this is the architecture drawings for the project. The first time I saw these was when Courtney and Ms. Jackson pulled them out and said that they were from the tax file and that these were the decks, these were the dimensions of the deck. And we were also told that because they were in the tax file and they were paying taxes on them, that they had a right to rebuild this deck. The deck was removed four years ago. Any deck abandoned four years ago has no right to be resurrected, but that's what they said guaranteed it with the fact that there were taxes. This one is a completely different one and the town attorney says that they match. Let me just find where that is in here, run off trail a little bit, but we'll get back. So the town attorney is claiming that these two documents are what we're supposed to be looking at. that neither of them was anywhere near the packet when the planning board was talking about them. Does that make sense? When [19:01] Speaker A (unidentified): was this all taking place? Yeah, I'm trying to get right now on what you're asking for, what brought all this on, because it seems to me you're asking for a stop work issue. [19:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Right. Can you get to that? I can't, because I think it's important to know these things, But the reason that we're here is because the deck was built long after that 38th window was closed. And we were surprised to find that deck was about 4 feet from our property. It was supposed to be a 10 foot setback. So we went to Courtney Fearson and she came out and said, oh, it looks like it's too big. So she and Mr. Wheeler put a tape measure on it and it measured to my garage Do you understand that? Went from the deck, it touched my garage and it didn't meet ten feet then. It was nine feet But it's way too far into the into the setback So what I did was I asked for it for her to Stop the work she did and then after a bit she got an email from Andy Wheeler complaining about how much was costing him to not know what to do and so at that point in time the attorney not the attorney but the homeowner and came and said that he couldn't he didn't have a boundary he didn't know where the boundary was he wasn't willing to agree to one and wasn't going to get a survey and for that reason they listed a stop work order after Mr. Wheeler took two feet off. There are 14 feet between my property line and the house. Mr. Wheeler was planning to put an eight and a half foot deck in there, which is what he did. Do the math. Does that leave 10 feet? 14 feet available, eight and a half feet built into it. Am I making sense? So we had a stop work order and what Ms. McPherson did was that she let him go back to the go back to work after you took two feet off so if you're if you're in this in the setback that far and you take two feet off you're still in the setback so what we're asking is for the board to reinstate that stock order until the property line is found by the owners of one Mill Hill and let them get a survey to find it. Mr. Wheeler, in his announcement, let's see, this is, I'm off trail quite a bit, but that's fine, we can make it fine. So in this document right here, this is the video of the entire process. And in that video, Mr. Wheeler says, I think right now we are 15 or 16 feet from the assumed property line, which is getting surveyed. He publicly promised a survey before they did the work. they didn't bother the survey they just slapped the duck into the setback so we're told we can't appeal that because the 30-day window was passed so from our perspective the best thing a contractor can do is what was done have plans to violate the setback get the permit passed wait over 30 days then build it and then the town will tell you can't even buy it which is what happened we don't think it should work that way I don't know if you agree. Anyhow, if I, 'd like to finish my statement. I know I'm going to leave things on the table if I don't, that we have, there's an email from Mr. Wheeler where he discovers that, or doesn't discover, I mean he says that he has 22 feet, the town approved a 22 foot deck years back, I don't remember when, he said if that's the case, then the town would have had to consider the side of their garage as the property line. that was his whole entire basis for deciding that he had from their house to our garage as free space that the dog is owned. Say that again please. So because Mr. Wheeler said in this email right here which is one of the exhibits that he decided that since the old deck was 22 feet and he and he needed that to be enough we need enough space to put his back in there he simply said that the setback that the property line was at our garage the property line is not our garage I have a survey that we just got the results from the other day because it's exactly where I was saying it was all along exactly the same information I gave the Donegans for the plot line agreement exactly the same information I gave to Courtney so she could have she realized what she should be doing all of that was ignored because they wanted to have the effect they wanted. That's how I see it anyway. The homeowner could have come to me and said look let's make an agreement on this lot line and I'll step ten feet back from that. Or I could get the survey that Andy Wheeler promised when he was right here in his room. He did that. So I don't get it. I don't understand how the builder can build that farm into a setback, that Courtney, the CEO, talks to him a little bit and says, okay, if you take off two, we'll give it to you. And that's what he did. [24:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Let me play stupid for a minute. Not having seen any of this property or how it impacts both groups,. What is so, I don't know, what is so important for a few feet of, I don't get [24:53] Speaker E (unidentified): it. Is it? So are you saying that we should just allow the sit-backs to be? That's not [24:59] Speaker I (unidentified): within our purview. We're not mediating this. Okay, I'm not asking you that. There are very [25:05] Speaker E (unidentified): definite rules that we have to follow. I understand that. I completely understand that, but you [25:11] Speaker A (unidentified): You asked a question. Well, I said it was a dumb question. I just, through reading all this and hearing this, I'm trying to get a picture of all this and the boundary of the two properties. That strikes me, just strikes me a little strange. [25:27] Speaker E (unidentified): What, that he would have started to count out to enforce its rule? [25:31] Speaker A (unidentified): No, that if I had a neighbor, and you're talking about two feet or something, I'd go over and talk with him and work it out. [25:37] Speaker E (unidentified): I tried. I tried exactly that. But the neighbors never spoke to me. [25:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Let me interject something I probably shouldn't. In 1979, when my late wife and I decided to build a house on a wood walk along what's now the North Road, I came in here. I said, I'm going to build a house. I need a building permit. And the town clerk said, okay. And I said, what other codes for building my house? And I was informed, please close it so it doesn't fall down. Here's your building permit. That's a few years ago. And that was how we used to do things half a century ago. Things have changed. People have made in with different ideas. The other example I want to extend to you is that Mark Bennett bought the building of, had an optometric office here in town, which is now Mount Dwight here at 140 Main Street. And Mark Bennett bought the building behind me, and something or other happened with the lot next to him where the survey showed a triangular portion of his building, which was 8 by 24 feet, was on my property. Michael Darnold, who had an office down here on Main Street, was Mark's attorney. He called me up and said, Lenny, his building's on your property. what do you want to do? I said, what are my choices? He said, well, you can have him move the building off your property, or you can have him buy the property. [27:48] Speaker D (unidentified): This is a triangle, [27:50] Speaker C (unidentified): 8 by 24 feet. I said, just write him a deed that'll land under his property, and I'll sign it, and that's it. Well, how much do you want? I don't need anything. It's not costing me anything. So, where you are, I personally am a little confused. You're not within the purview of the appeals board with all this information. We have three things we can do, Richard, and correct me if I'm wrong, guys. Number one, we can approve your appeal for Courtney McPherson lifting the stop order. Number two, we can deny your appeal for Courtney McPherson lifting the stop order. Number three, because we do not have discretionary room here, we have to deal with what's in front of us and what we do we have the option of demanding this to the clearing board for their edification and resolution we [29:08] Speaker E (unidentified): cannot make the decision you're asking no all right can I tell you the decision I'm asking for is exactly the ones that you just described well not to deny one but I'm I'm asking you to either reinstate the stockbroker until the lot line is identified. [29:27] Speaker C (unidentified): You can't put an A. You can't put a condition like that on it. But with the information that we have here, we can either approve your appeal or deny it, all right? You can't condition. [29:44] Speaker E (unidentified): OK, but you said you could remand the factory. [29:46] Speaker C (unidentified): 30 years ago we can't put a condition on anything just approve or disapprove well [29:56] Speaker E (unidentified): earlier you said you could remand it back to the board I can I can speak to [30:03] Speaker G (unidentified): them to that point I think for the audience I'm I'm Ben McCauley municipal yes I have municipal attorney at drumwood some of you representing the board I'm happy to talk to the board I want to I want to give I put a little bit of a different spin on things but to be fair everybody here what I want the board to give mr. Tummin the chance to answer all of your questions also want to give the town attorney a chance to present on behalf of the code officer and then I'm happy to work with the board on what your options are here [30:46] Speaker E (unidentified): So I haven't said all that I have to say and I'm not sure that I'm getting through with it but maybe it's my poor delivery but one of the things that I'd like to get to before we close this out is that what I'm telling you is that these documents were not in front of planning boards. So my point is that we have, they approved the deck. They just approved no dimensions for the deck. They were, this diagram here was never in front of the planning board and neither was this one. These are the only dimensions that anyone has ever produced for the size of the deck. Neither of them was ever in front of the planning board when they voted on that, on the building of that deck. So in my opinion, there are no dimensions for this deck. and that therefore the CEO is not in a position to say that any number is allowed in the setbacks. And I, although I hear some of you saying that the setbacks that I ought to be saying, well 20% of the setback I can give to them. Our garage is legally non-performing. It's very close to the line. That this deck now is a very,, very close to the line. And so it is not something that enhances our property in any way at all it is a anyway so it is not our intention to say well what does it make it makes a bit of difference to us and we think the town has a 10-foot setback for reasons it's buyer safety it's access to for emergency in emergencies isn't something that can just be tossed off I didn't think we could even say, and I don't mind, it's fine. I don't think that was a possibility. But, just to make one point that I think is for the others to get, is that the town attorney is saying that, and Courtney is saying, and Emma is saying, that this dimension here is the dimension of the deck. Now this dimension, this deck is quite a bit larger than the old deck. if the old deck is what they were supposed to be replacing as it says in the application for the permit they're replacing an old deck that was this size they can't replace it with a larger one that's not on the permit they have no dimensions in the permit so this one is either the one that they build but this one is not but the they claim that Annie Wheeler presented this at the planning board, which she did not. So I say there's no dimension to the deck and I think that the... I've supplemented. Where's the question? What is the question? [33:57] Speaker A (unidentified): If we had a copy of that, I'd say yeah. [33:59] Speaker E (unidentified): You have a copy of this, but it's in the town attorney's exhibit D. That's what she is saying should have been in the packet, or I'm not sure what she should tell us, I guess. But this was not shown on the planning board. What they claim, what Courtney and Emma have claimed, is that it was spoken about, that Andy Wheeler presented them, and there's a video that shows that he doesn't. And you have access to that video, except there's one in the small hyphen section. So try reaching what Andy Wheeler said when he was showing the things that he was showing that we can't see in the video. you understand what I'm about to read you these are any real as words at the planning board meeting as he was showing the architects drawings [34:57] Speaker J (unidentified): what am I showing you [35:06] Speaker C (unidentified): I [35:12] Speaker E (unidentified): don't understand what I'm reading any Wheeler stood at the planning board meeting right about here that camera did not see him and he was holding up architectural drawings and what the town attorney and everyone else is saying is it showing those drawings for a few minutes is the equivalent of introducing them to the left so what Andy Wheeler said you're listening for listening for dimensions this is what Andy Wheeler said so you can see not a lot of changes in the front of the house I don't have an easel so I'm going to hold this open but those of you who don't have it especially the neighbors right here you can see not a whole lot of difference in front of the house of the new windows so the house is right in the corner you can almost see it from here smack dab middle of the historic district essentially i outlined the three major changes with you guys the fenestration on the barn and the changing of the roof profile and reusing some of the space out back that basically had an unsightly addition an even more or less attractive fire escape and i'm sure that the neighbors could never have and doesn't finish that sentence original box which is the big house on the corner is all the original windows the original double doors and all getting restored to the middle section which connects to the oldest section but there's nothing there it really can't be saved at this point this part is partially caved in the ground the one change right now if you look there is continuous roof line from the main house on the L over my architect here dropped that which looks way more appropriate to me it sort of gives the big house little house back house barn look and you can see these connected structures administration of the barn the double windows are probably not typical of barns in my opinion far more attractive than the picture window and the entry doors which you go around any barn in this town you do not see two entry doors in front of it and then the space out back is basically one story edition, taking up the footprint of the previous edition, and the aforementioned fire escape that was there before, which does meet, I think right now, we're at 15 or 16 feet from the student property line, which is getting surveyed. I'm asking you, did you hear any dimensions in there? Did you hear the word deck? So that's the presentation, that everyone's claiming was sufficient for the planning board to make a decision about the size of the deck. THE DECK WAS APPROVED, AND WE DON'T DENY THAT, THE DECK WAS APPROVED WITH NO DIMENSIONS. I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'RE GOING TO PROVE THAT THEY WERE DROPPED WITH DIMENSIONS. DO YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT I'M SAYING? OKAY. [37:56] Speaker A (unidentified): WELL... YOU'RE ALL SET. WE MOVE ON TO THE NEXT GROUP. YES, I CAN BE. UM... DID YOU WANT TO GO THROUGH THAT FIRST? [38:09] Speaker G (unidentified): I THINK IF THE BOARD HAS ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. TUBMAN AT THIS POINT, I WOULD BE GOOD TO ASK AT THIS POINT. after that I think move on to presentation from the code office I know that the town attorney is here and then same procedure ask any questions that may come up there and then up to the board as to whether you want to allow public comment or then but at some point either before or after opening up to the public I think you need to give mr. Tomlin a chance to provide any further the comment rebuttal for anything that's raised but it can go on to the onto the code enforcement officer and her representative [38:47] Speaker I (unidentified): and then repeat the procedure okay who's [38:52] Speaker H (unidentified): up hello mary costigan with bernstein sure the town attorney and courtney is here by video because she's not feeling well tonight so i'm gonna hi guys sorry i couldn't make it there i'm gonna talk to you about the legal aspects of this and the facts, as I understand them. But I'll let Courtney expand a little bit on the facts, because I wasn't there a year ago. And I believe the landowner's contractor is somewhere in. So I think what's important here is that all of this was approved a year, over a year ago at this point. And what happened a year ago is it was a residential rehab of an existing building. Typically it doesn't actually require planning board approval, but the planning board in this case only did the historic preservation review. So this is not a site plan review where they're going through details of measurements of plans. they're looking at the reason why he was talking about shutters and windows and etc and roof line is because that's what the planning board was reviewing in order to do the historic preservation and they have to do that before it then goes to the CEO to approve the dimensions the building etc so that the historic preservation review happened on October 8th I think and then the building permit which approved rebuilding the deck and doing some rehab to the building i'm gonna i don't want to mess this up there's any additional so in my packet it's the last i believe it's the last page it's the actual building permit that was issued so permit number 408 it doesn't have an exhibit number on the top because i'm just not good at it on this and this document is changing things if i put it up there so it wasn't working out it says the application The location date says 9-4-25, it says permit number 408, and then you'll see that renovation, it is existing structure, original footprint, adding 256 square feet on the back of the aisle. and the when you're talking about okay well what was that you know original footprint plus the 265 feet that's when we look at that exhibit a which is the tax drawing that's the best because it's true the deck was not in place at the time of the application a year ago. The CEO did allow them to rebuild that deck in these dimensions. I believe it went a little bit further. I'm gonna do it this way. I think it extended a little bit further this way, but in terms of, this is the property line we're talking about, you know, the left-hand side of that page as we're looking at that. So we have that dimension. We have that 22 feet from the existing house, so we can use that dimension that was here and that's the dimension that she was using. And so all of this happened a year ago. And my understanding is that the Tibbetts, the Tummins, did participate in the procedure, so certainly knew about this. And they had 30 days to appeal. They had 30 days to complain that there were no dimensions. They had 30 days to complain that their deduction had been approved. But it was. It was. was. Their project was approved by the CEO. When Courtney received, and I have a case law in here and Ben can talk to you about that and what that means. And a lot of what you heard tonight was all about what the planning board did. Well, again, that was a year ago. So let's talk about what happened this year and what they're claiming to be appealing. So, when Courtney received the complaint, she went out and talked to them. She didn't actually issue a piece of paper that was a stop-for-reporter, it doesn't exist. She had a conversation and said, you have to stop building. I see that the dimension went beyond this 22 feet, and you're actually two feet too close to this line, you're two feet too wide. and so she 's been using this existing measurement from the existing building she's been measuring that way and not measuring from whatever the property line seems to be in this way you understand what I'm saying because it's it's easy because we have the existing building we have existing dimensions and that can be used so like sort of where the property line lies is not a measurement tool that she was using because what she was using was an existing diagram and so when the time came she said well it's not 22 feet it's 24 feet you gotta knock off the two and then you can keep going and that's exactly what happened I want to address a couple of things that were raised my understanding I'll have Courtney explain a little bit more. This exhibit C that I have, that was exhibit D, excuse me, I'm sorry, exhibit B, which is the more detailed drawings with the measurements, that does show the deck, it shows it's 22 feet out, these were, my understanding, the documents that were shown at the playing board. and yes if documents are shown at a planning board meeting and the CEO is looking at them and people are looking at them that is part of the record and so that is knowledge that the CEO had when she was making the decision in issuing the building permit the next week you will see on these that they are the plans are dated october 3rd 2024. so they you know these are plans that existed at the time and i would actually be surprised if someone didn't use these plans and coming to the planning board and ceo to get an approval they were in existence at the time of that the approval was granted let me just see if there were other Are there other issues that were brought up that I want to address and take some notes on? Yeah, I mean it really all comes down to a lot of what you, pretty much everything that you heard tonight was disagreements with what the building permit allowed and what the planning board allowed. And it just, it is just too late. And there was, and I also want to explain, it wasn't brought up tonight but it was sort of in the appeal. real. There was some discussion from Courtney's perspective when this all came up about the property line and she was talking to them about maybe, you know, getting some sort of measurement, but then she called me. She did that before she called me and my direction to her was, you have issued the building permit a year ago and all you can do at this point from an enforcement perspective is make sure the project is consistent with the building permit you can't require them to do anything else because that permit has been issued it has not been appealed and the court case that I gave you said even CEO has 30 days to figure out if they made a mistake as long as like I'm not saying she made a mistake but in the event you know she made a mistake and she was like oh maybe I shouldn't have issued that it's too late, because people have to be able to rely on the building permit side for an issue to them. And that's what the law is. It's a longstanding law, and it's what we practice all the time when we tell our CEOs. So to the extent that she might have said something inconsistent before she talked to me and then after, that's the explanation. She had some conversation before she talked to me. And I'll just ask Courtney if she has anything factual to add or anything you wanted to sort of correct IF ANYTHING WAS MISSPOKEN BY ME OR BY MR. TUMMING. [47:33] Speaker B (unidentified): NO, I THINK YOU HIT ALL THE POINTS I HAD. THE ONLY THING THAT I DID WANT TO POINT OUT WAS EVEN IF THE MEASURED PLANS WEREN'T THERE, THOSE ELEVATIONS WERE THERE, WHICH CLEARLY SHOW A DECK ON THE BACK OF THE BUILDING. I DON'T KNOW WHAT EXHIBIT IT IS. SORRY, I DON'T HAVE MY PAPER PACKED AT HOME, I THINK. BUT IT DEFINITELY SHOWS THE ELEVATIONS AND IT DOES SHOW THAT DECK. respond [48:01] Speaker G (unidentified): to any of that 's next step at some point but I want to make sure that the board doesn't have any questions for the town attorney and then I want to give the board the opportunity to ask I know that the property owners representative is here too but you'll absolutely have a chance to respond so [48:19] Speaker H (unidentified): I'll just to Courtney was referring to the so exhibit my exhibit B is the planning board. Exhibit C, sorry, my Exhibit C is the planning board packet, and that does, it has some pictures of the building and it does have some elevations that show deck. [48:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Correct, yeah, that's the one I was talking about. I [48:44] Speaker A (unidentified): don't know the other group, the other side of this affairs issue folks. [48:48] Speaker H (unidentified): This is the contract, did you raise your hand earlier? [48:51] Speaker J (unidentified): Oh, just to identify myself as the contract. I will say I answered all the questions that were asked me at the meeting the deck was put in the letter it was actually the very last sentence in there realizing the incredible scrutiny it's been under since I probably should have worded that we did not all we had to start with concrete piers in the ground and the architect and myself both can deduce the same messages dimensions based on those piers and the fact that the building still had the deck ledgers so after 35 years of doing this I think we're pretty able to nail down the deck measurements which the exhibit 5 is exactly the 22 feet out the 33 down where I should have worded that slightly different was right in this area here was a three-story fire escape that filled in this area so we brought the deck down that area keeping in mind that this deck extension here goes no closer to the Tummins property this is parallel to the disputed line and basically it's the side of the garage so I did go back and look at the wording and probably footprint would have been better to justify the last 12 feet we added on the deck and I know the fire escape was there because I took it down the air before because their insurance company was going to drop them if that thing did not go down on the ground and then you know Richard did bring up the fact that this has been compounded by the fact that his garage seems to sit anywhere from two to four feet of that property line so apparently would be up there done against to make all the conceptions for an emergency vehicles to get behind there which I would probably go back to your good neighbor policy at the beginning I mean most of the staff is on the side of a garage with one window on it but aside from that I think I answered the questions I was asked I did not get a survey because it was not in the findings of that I left that meeting and I was like okay they don't require I'm [51:01] Speaker C (unidentified): fine and that's how we proceeded from there yes I and I did very [51:17] Speaker J (unidentified): arrogantly push it two more feet correct it's probably 45 well I don't have that exact measurement you might Richard but yes but no closer to the property we did go down and again to incorporate the area and i do have pictures of the fire state and all the pierce around the back of the house the property right somewhere [51:41] Speaker H (unidentified): in the office here right now correct so i just to really quickly follow up on it thank you for bringing this up because i meant to point this out in so exhibit c again is from my packet is the planning board application also the material that courtney looked Mr. Wheeler's email dated September 16, 2025 is in there, and the second page of that, right before his signature, it says the decks proposed are to replace previous ones removed by the previous one. So it should not have been a surprise to anybody that decks were part of this project. It's right in my life. Thank [52:27] Speaker G (unidentified): you, Wano. No, at this point I think your rules do provide an opportunity for public comment generally, so I. [52:34] Speaker E (unidentified): Can I respond to the? [52:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, I'll leave that up to the board. I think the only thing for efficiency's sake is there may be other comments made by the public that Mr. Tummin wants to respond to, but I'll leave that to the board's discretion. You can give him one or two opportunities to respond, but I think we need to provide equal opportunity for everyone involved. [52:54] Speaker A (unidentified): So we open it up to the audience now. [53:09] Speaker D (unidentified): I would just like to point out that I believe, based on this information, that there was clearly an understanding of decks to the previous dimensions and the deck as I understand it here tonight doesn't match the previous dimensions it was made larger by some feet to take up space that was covered by a fire escape in my mind I think in fairness to the to the Tummins this should be remanded back to the planning board so that they can properly evaluate the size of the deck because I don't think that actually one can say that was totally considered and I think that is the right thing to do the issue of the setback I believe that as a community resident I would like to be able to rely on the fact that a setback is part of the ordinance it is not something that we want to think are regardless of its two inches or four feet are going to be disregarded and I do think I do understand that you are not a conditioning board but I do think we're manding it back to the planning board gives the planning board the opportunity to re-look at the issue of setback and I think in fairness to sustaining an ordinance that we all rely on that this should go back to the Planning Board on those two matters thank you very much for the opportunity [55:01] Speaker K (unidentified): to speak thank you anyone else sir my name is Scott Cole I live at [address] to mechanic street i agree with the lady's comments how can the board here knowingly condone through your vote a setback violation you've got a 10 foot setback it doesn't matter if the neighbors get along or not 10 feet 10 feet if the landowner in violation represented by the contractor yeah they know they're knowingly encroaching at that point now that we all know i don't see how the code officer can defend i don't see how the town attorney can defend it for that matter. So thank you very much. [55:40] Speaker I (unidentified): And my question is actually to both attorneys. We hear the argument that it's past the 30 day time. And I wonder if there are ever exceptions in law about when you can say 30 days is not sacred and we can actually look at a longer window of time to address issues such as this. true [56:09] Speaker A (unidentified): but as it holds now there are certain things we have to hold to which I'll get to in a second if you want to finish there's somebody else I still [56:19] Speaker L (unidentified): want to say something I see you done I live in Bethel ask was there ever a site walk done did anybody even go out and look at this or did they just assume the planning board did anybody look at her did you have you driven by and [56:35] Speaker C (unidentified): looked at it I think Richard I don't know Courtney Richard can answer that [56:48] Speaker B (unidentified): the [56:52] Speaker L (unidentified): planning board did not do a sidewalk the other thing is if they were shown something different than what was built how do they have how are they supposed to respond within 30 days if there is something different which clearly was larger than it was supposed to be. [57:11] Speaker J (unidentified): No, the deck-only plans were the exact same size as the deck we built. When I added the two feet, we've already fixed that. [57:19] Speaker L (unidentified): So, but you didn't know where the property line was. [57:22] Speaker M (unidentified): And it's not 10 feet from the building, it's 10 feet from the property line. [57:26] Speaker C (unidentified): What? Nobody knows where the property line is. [57:29] Speaker L (unidentified): Yes, actually, they had a survey done, I think. You just said that earlier. earlier. So those are the questions I have you know I think it needs to go back to the planning board and look at again a [57:47] Speaker E (unidentified): couple things about this deck that are talking about this deck right here so first of all at the end this deck was never permitted when it was built on the sitting there was never permitted. The 22 feet that it had was not grandfathered in. It was gone for two years. There's no 22 feet guaranteed by anybody. We all understand there's an unpermitted deck. I have Courtney, 's email somewhere. I guess you can find it. This is Courtney on September 11 of this year. She says, I looked in the file and did not see anything for a deck previously approved. There was no permit, I've looked myself, there was no permit for this deck in the town file. So they're relying on the measurements of an unpermitted deck that was non-conforming when it was sitting there and it's been gone for three years. In Maine, two years is the maximum time that an abandoned structure can be resurrected. So I don't understand how these are such sacrosanct dimensions. mentions and in addition to that I asked Courtney have you measured the deck Courtney this McPherson have you measured the deck to know that it's 22 [59:05] Speaker B (unidentified): feet sorry I had to unmute myself yes I measured it the day I went out there and met with Andy I don't have my notes here would have been probably the [59:18] Speaker E (unidentified): beginning of September I believe after it was after was pulled back you measured it and what was the exact measure i don't know i don't know my stuff with me you're claiming it you're claiming that if we went out there today and measured it would be exactly [59:33] Speaker B (unidentified): it met what the tax records had for the distance that's what it came from the original structure out to the edge of the dock i [59:50] Speaker E (unidentified): don't think it's 22 feet but it is 22 feet [1:00:01] Speaker J (unidentified): I just [1:00:04] Speaker N (unidentified): have a quick point to make, and that is that if the planning board approves, I'm Steve McConathy, 71 Paradise. If the planning board approves a plan that doesn't have dimensions, that doesn't imply that the person can build any dimensions that they can go now violate because a plan was approved it didn't have dimensions the deck didn't have dimensions at that time it doesn't give them permission to build within a setback right because those laws still exist that's my only point [1:00:46] Speaker C (unidentified): there's a lot of good ideas here about what could be and should be but we're getting kind of far away from what's on the table here [1:00:56] Speaker F (unidentified): I got a question of the attorney. The Planning Board didn't do a site plan application for this, right? They did no site plan. Nobody ever looked at the 10-foot setbacks. There was no requirement to look at 10-foot setbacks from day one. that's why it was never done and I presume that's why Courtney went with the existing footprint you know we're blaming the planning board but I love [1:01:31] Speaker H (unidentified): that they did they never looked at this they never had to right they didn't do cycling that's correct so then it is the ceo's building permit that allowed the building to be built in its dimensions of the prior footprint of the prior deck so mike and you had 30 days from the date of the building permit to tell courtney i don't think that should be allowed and it's just too late to complain i hear you saying that because it's just that is the law okay i understand if i could follow up too just for a [1:02:20] Speaker B (unidentified): minute i know there's all the talk about the property line i mean technically i still haven't given been given anything showing exactly where the property line was almost a year later i was given a survey that was done by mainland and i believe there's a note on there that said something to the effect of we can't find the property line you and your neighbor should get together and make an agreement that was done i believe in 2022 an agreement was never reached and then the cummins provided me with a survey of their lot but it's just pins i'm not a surveyor I don't know there's there's no building shown on that plan either there's or their neighbors, so I Still I still don't even know where the property line is exactly [1:03:21] Speaker G (unidentified): You're still in a portion where public comment is loud I know there are a lot of competing back and forth But I think it's important to make sure that everyone gets up their information out in the orally fashion and that Mr. Toman has sort of last word as the appellant. Questions? I suggest that if there are questions for different parties, they'd be asked through the chair, if they're for Courtney or for Mary or for others, just to keep things. [1:03:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, I didn't want to cut anybody off when I said that we should [Speaker K (unidentified): pay more attention.] Anybody who wants to please speak up, except for Scott. [1:04:00] Speaker E (unidentified): May I have a few words here about this? So a lot has been said here about this. A couple of things that I'm not sure I'm getting through is that the deck was unpermanent. An unpermanent deck that's been gone for four years is not a, it cannot be resurrected. So when we say that this 22-foot measurement is somehow a lock, I don't see how it is. I think there's a law regarding that. Plus, the deck here says it's 33 feet along the line. Am I making sense? 33 along our parking line is 45. They changed this from that so to say [1:04:42] Speaker J (unidentified): that this is the dimension. The blueprints, original blueprints show 45. Say what? I said the original blueprints show 45. [1:04:49] Speaker E (unidentified): But you're saying that it was built for this. [1:04:51] Speaker J (unidentified): No, that's an old tax map that corroborated what we have. I didn't use that, I never submitted that. That wasn't part of it. [1:04:57] Speaker E (unidentified): I know you didn't submit this, but my point is that if it's supposed to be replacing an old deck and you have the dimensions for that old deck, how do you end up with a bigger deck? [1:05:08] Speaker J (unidentified): But that's not my paperwork, Richard. I didn't submit that. I saw that when you started the appeals process. [1:05:15] Speaker E (unidentified): But your permit says you're going to be replacing an old deck. [1:05:20] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, well I explained that. Part of that went into where that fire scheme was. [1:05:24] Speaker E (unidentified): But you can't change the shape of that deck if you replace an old deck, as far as I'm concerned. Anyhow, that is an unpermitted deck. And I'd like to make that point. And I think that a couple other things that we can find on it. [1:05:39] Speaker A (unidentified): I think we're getting to the point where I've got to make a couple. I [1:05:46] Speaker C (unidentified): think we've heard all the comments from everybody. [1:05:49] Speaker A (unidentified): He did. He was waiting for one column after that. [1:05:52] Speaker I (unidentified): A quick question with regard to the permitting process. It's only because I don't know. Is a permit required to be posted on the building? And should the permit be also posted on the internet so anyone can read it? And the reason I'm asking is because I've watched the house, and I have not seen a permit posted on the house, so I wouldn't know myself what the size is and what's being planned, and I can't find it on the internet either. I need the planning stuff. So, the question becomes, how can you say you have 30 days to contest a permit if the permit is not viewable for contestation? [1:06:37] Speaker A (unidentified): That's it. Just for those people who don't know, our group, Board of Appeals, we are not part of any of these meetings or any of discussions. Discussions were sort of kept in a little room so that we can come and hear things without being biased by anything. I've looked at these things. I've listened to a lot of good discussion. When it comes down to, really, I've heard it said a couple times, it's a little bit too late. You have 30 days. if you do anything like that if you take away you stop you're basically that's basically illegal if it's illegal if somebody is already building property building a building and then all of a sudden oh wait we're gonna change this you can't do that I'm looking strictly from that point of view and that's that's what we're that's what we're here for yes I have one comment and that is [1:07:46] Speaker D (unidentified): what my husband has forgive me I have a voice disorder my husband has a comment about the case that the attorney brought forward which was Juliana and Juliana actually allows you to gave the board the authority to look at an over bill without actually attacking the original permit and that's what we're trying to do we're not attacking the original permit we're saying that it's above and beyond what was built and Juliana allowed the board to look at that the [1:08:31] Speaker C (unidentified): Board of Appeals I [1:08:40] Speaker F (unidentified): mean that's exactly the point I was making which is [1:09:03] Speaker H (unidentified): is you have 30 days to appeal. And Juliano is about the fact that a code officer, in Juliano it was like the previous code officer made this decision. It was like two code officers later was like, I don't like what he did. I don't think you should be able to do that. And the court said a code officer can enforce a project that is not consistent with the actual building permit but once that building permits been issued even if the prior code officer made a mistake that is the gospel and as long as they're building like in accordance with that building permit then I can continue I understand there is disagreement as to what they believe Courtney approved but my understanding from Courtney is she approved the full extent of the deck that's being built today, that two feet was bad, the two feet is back. She approved the extension over around where the fire escape was. So all of, everything that's happening now that two feet is gone is consistent with [1:10:12] Speaker D (unidentified): what she allowed in the building permit. [1:10:16] Speaker H (unidentified): Even if, you know, someone came and said you should not have allowed that, it doesn't matter or is because that's been issued and people are allowed to rely on [1:10:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I will [1:10:33] Speaker G (unidentified): certainly provide an opinion to the board for a finality sake and we don't need we don't need to get to the end you certainly can ask for more information from the parties if you need to I just suggest maybe exhausting the comments that you have in the room first don't want to don't want to jump like a [1:10:54] Speaker A (unidentified): place in line but okay I guess I'll be quick it's almost all right [1:11:00] Speaker O (unidentified): just like seven mil the 30 days is irrelevant because the permit said the original deck they didn't add on the original deck until probably October so 30 days has nothing to do with the appeal of the permit, it has to do with the construction of the property. If the permanent deck was to replace the original deck, then when you build it two foot over, what's the 30 days have to do with anything? You're not appealing the permit, you're appealing the fact they didn't build what was permitted. Pretty simple to me. if there's a setback you abide by the setback if you decide that after you get the permit you can do whatever you want that's what you're allowing send it back to the planning board and say what did you approve exactly and that's what should be done that's the permit and setbacks are setbacks if you're going to start changing setback rules you're going to cause a lot of problems right [1:12:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Sharon, did you have something you wanted to share? [1:12:14] Speaker M (unidentified): I do. Sharon Lyons, 70 Broad Street. The setback is 10 feet from the property line. If we start changing that randomly, how can we do anything in our town? We have to abide by those rules, and I think Jett said it exactly right. They approved the original deck. It ended up not being that and there is the mistake it doesn't belong on the Tumans responsibility because they didn't know it was going to be different [1:12:50] Speaker J (unidentified): there's some confusion here the original that is back to the way it's supposed to today, not any close to the property line, [1:12:59] Speaker E (unidentified): just as it was presented to the town. Oh, OK. [1:13:05] Speaker C (unidentified): I've been up since 3 o'clock. I got out of the prison just after 5, taking an eye doctor. I have a clinic at the Federal Correctional Institution on Tuesdays in Burlington, New Hampshire. I have time now to get home, answer two phone calls, return two phone calls, and get here. We're getting way far away. We have been here for over an hour. From my point of view, as just a guy who hasn't had something yet, I've heard an awful lot. I don't think there's anything more germane coming out of anybody here that is applicable mr. Timmons you've said the same thing at least half a dozen times we've all heard you I would like to move on to but the attorney has to say that the other members of the board think I'm stepping [1:14:22] Speaker L (unidentified): out of line charge aren't you okay Jeff is he allowed to talk again okay [1:14:40] Speaker E (unidentified): to point out is it was said earlier that the planning board was only meant to be proving what they what affected the integrity of the historic district well I think a deck falls in that category so the deck is something that the planning board should have been given plenty of information about and they should have been able to make some sort of decision about that and its dimensions so I'm not sure that it's possible for something like that in the historic district to get a deck in there without the playing board having a very clear [1:15:13] Speaker I (unidentified): understanding of what it is oh yeah you better remember too we're not here to [1:15:19] Speaker A (unidentified): fix things we're here just to us to look at all I'm asking you to do is to send [1:15:24] Speaker E (unidentified): it back to the playing board yeah that's all I'm not asking you to vacate the permit I'm asking to have the deck ripped down and it's asking for a body that can, I assume, can make some decisions about where we go from here, I know the town would love to shut this down tonight. [1:15:42] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't believe that 10 foot setback, the planning board had any reason to look at it. I'm not saying they didn't. That's what they were doing. They didn't have any reason to look at it two years ago, why would they have any reason to look at it now? [1:15:55] Speaker E (unidentified): It was about, I think, having the dimensions of the deck, the dimension of the deck in [1:16:00] Speaker A (unidentified): the historic history we're seeing final thoughts finally get done in okay so I [1:16:17] Speaker G (unidentified): want to there have been a lot of questions about and points about appeal periods and the like and so for the record this is my opinion in my opinion only so the board ultimately is making a decision here but I think it's important to take a step back and understand what this appeal concerns what it can concern what it can't concern so as I understand it the Planning Board and I'm only I am NOT the town attorney for Bethel and so if I am completely misconstruing what the town's land use ordinance says then I'll defer attorney and the code enforcement officer but the Planning Board is only involved in this process because of the location of the building in the historic district and so in section 96-7 subsection C of the land use ordinance there are a set of criteria a through G that the Planning Board is looking at and I think it's been mentioned a number of times those are not traditional site plan criteria. They involve things like the height of the proposed structure and visual compatibility with adjacent structures, width and height of windows, and compatibility with buildings, public ways, and places. These are, to put it bluntly, they're aesthetic characteristics. So, it's a prerequisite in the historic district that before the CEO can issue a building permit, no matter what that building permit is for, that the project needs to be reviewed for historic compatibility so that but I think it's been said before there would have been no reason and no authority frankly under the ordinance for exact dimensions of a building to be reviewed and approved once that happens the code officer then has the authority as with any other building permit to review the planes that are submitted and either approve them, approve them with conditions or deny them. Both of those reviews happened in 2025. And I completely agree with Mary that the Giuliano case, which is still good law, even since 1999, stands for the proposition that once a building permit is issued, all parties, including the town that issued it, including the property owner that received it, including any person who may have standing to appeal that, have whichever appeal period is set forth in the ordinance to appeal that building permit in Bethel and in most municipalities that's 30 days once that 30-day mark is up except in very limited circumstances and I will point out I know Mary has familiarity with the good cause exception I'm not going to go down that road because the Board of Appeals in Bethel has no authority to even can consider what that is for those who are interested it's a general proposition that goes to someone's lack potentially of notice of the issuance of a permit something a court can look at it's something that this board cannot so for your purposes if you're satisfied that 30 days has gone by from the date that the building permit in question was issued that building permit cannot be modified by this board. You don't have the jurisdiction to do that. Now, the question then is what, if any, authority or what your options are. I think Lenny had spoken to this earlier. I don't think you have the authority to remand this matter to the planning board. For one, I think the easiest explanation for that is the appeal, you have jurisdiction over the decision that is being appealed from. the decision here was courtney's decision to rescind a stop order so this board has the authority to look at that decision and decide whether courtney correctly made that decision right and to recall you've heard evidence to suggest that the stop work order was issued because it was discovered that the constructed deck exceeded the width that the permit allowed by two feet of the board has to decide whether you've heard any evidence that suggests that problem wasn't fixed if you have concerns about that you can ask more questions about that but ultimately you're looking at that stop work order was it correctly rescinded you can't you can't remain this to the planning board one because you aren't looking directly at the planning board's decision and as we talked about before the planning board in fact didn't issue any decision that solidifies boundary solidifies boundaries and solidifies dimensions solidified I think the best way that I can the semantics of it is your ordinance says that building permit cannot be issued by the code officer in the historic district until the planning board has done a historic review so it's a prerequisite for the building permit but it's not the building permit itself i understand the board has heard lots of information on both sides about questions about what that building permit authorized if now or in the future there are future questions about whether what is being built or has been built i don't personally know the status of these renovations i don't think they're finished yet at this point maybe they are but if in the future there are there are questions about whether something has been built again that's not in compliance with the building permit then the code officer has the discretion to go out and issue a notice of violation or another stop work order to get that corrected the last point I'll make about the Giuliano cases because I know it was brought up before it is true the procedural posture of the Giuliano case is quite different from what we were looking at here that was as mary mentioned a situation where a previous code officer had issued a permit the new code officer looked at it from disagreed and tried to issue a decision that rescinded that permit far outside of that appeal period really once a billing permit has been issued the only question in the future is going to be whether what is built there eventually will be a certificate of occupancy that is issued And if that certificate of occupancy exceeds in somebody's opinion or doesn't match correctly with what was permitted, there may be at that point in the future another right of appeal. But I want to center in on what this board is being asked to decide and what it can decide tonight. And again, your job is only to look at the stop work order. that stop work order was issued because of a two-foot discrepancy with what was built vis-a-vis the issued permit and your job is to decide whether that decision was correct or not I understand there's a desire perhaps to use this as a conduit to look at the permitting process before but I agree I think the law is extremely clear on this point that once you're outside of that 30-day window which would have expired in November of last year all parties involved regardless of their opinion on the matter are locked in effectively to I will say for the board you haven't closed public comment I think at some point just for procedural clarity it would make sense to do that you can certainly ask whether there are further comments you want to hear from the room So once you've closed that, it's up for the board to deliberate amongst itself and reach a decision. You are a, one thing I'll point out, you are a five-person board. So what that means is that in order to grant an appeal, you are going to need to have a unanimous vote. You're going to need to have three votes in favor of granting that appeal. [1:24:47] Speaker A (unidentified): You didn't tell me that last time. I didn't? [1:24:49] Speaker G (unidentified): I think you had four last time. No, we got through it. Well, pardon my memory, it was a couple of years ago. You're going to need three votes to grant an appeal. Even a 2-1 vote to grant an appeal would be insufficient. The other thing to keep in mind is a written notice of decision. By law, you are required to issue a written notice. And the law is very unkind to boards of appeals. You need to issue that within seven days of the date of your vote. You may recall from 24, what happened then is typically in these situations, I'll go back and put together a draft decision, but this board is going to need to meet in a week's time to review the draft decision, whatever your decision is to make any edits that you think is necessary, and then sign off on that. It doesn't need to be Tuesday evening at 6 next week. It can be any time, as long as Emma has enough time to post a notice of it. It is an open public meeting, but a comment wouldn't be heard from the public. Probably wouldn't have attorneys here either. It's really for the board to look at a draft that's put together, make any edits that you feel are necessary, and then go from there. So I've spoken far too much, and I haven't answered any questions. that you have otherwise we'll deliberate but not decide tonight well so you have two options you certainly can vote tonight if you vote tonight if you feel you're in a position to do it i don't think there's any reason not to do that you have to vote again to adopt a written decision within seven days of tonight your other option just kicking the can down the road a little bit but also a possibility is to delay if for some reason you can't meet in seven days well you could also do is continue this meeting without a vote to a point where you can all meet again in person vote on the decision and also review and adopt a written decision at the same time it's really all about timing if everyone thinks that they can be in this building at some point over the next week for 15 20 minutes however long you think it will take to go through a draft and make changes then i don't see any reason why you wouldn't vote tonight but that's ultimately a Just for my purposes being the stickler, nay is fine, but we'll go with an affirmative motion. So your motion, I would suggest, would either be to grant the appeal or to deny the appeal. [1:28:31] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that the motion that you're trying to say is that I move that the board deny [1:28:43] Speaker G (unidentified): the appeal. Lenny, is that your motion or are you suggesting that? That's fine. [1:28:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. That's what you're trying to say by now? Yes. OK. So do you want to second my motion? I'll second. Senator Archie, the ball is in your park. No, Senator. [1:28:59] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, might I ask, just for everyone's edification of my own decision. So you've had a motion and a second. So at this point, the motion is open for discussion. So it would be helpful to just hear from the board members a bit of reasoning as to why you feel the motion should be, [1:29:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I have great respect and admiration for the time and effort that Mr. Kimmins has put into this. But we're dealing with the time constraint here. And that supersedes all the effort that you've put in here, Richard. You spent an awful lot of time, an awful lot of energy on it. But it's too late. You ran out of time. And that's what we're constrained with. We have to go by the law. You have the option of taking Mr. Coyle, I believe. Is that correct? but we have to deal with what's put before us and we're constrained on it's not the amorphous property line it's not who built what ran and who took off two feet or who took down a fire State. Both Reggie and I are firefighters in Afton, but we're old guys. And the reason for the 10-foot setback is so we can get a fire truck if we don't. And I understand the importance of the setback. But from my point of view, it's simply a cut-and-dry matter of two-way. [1:30:57] Speaker A (unidentified): That's basically it, I was very blown away by all you brought in front of us, it's a lot of work. I know when I was reading it through at home, I read it twice because I'm not sure I was, we are bound, certainly that's why we're kept away from all the other, they don't want us biased we do we do have something [1:31:59] Speaker F (unidentified): I was going to say, we need to, we have a motion and a second, we need to have a vote. [1:32:06] Speaker G (unidentified): And I will correct my previous statement just so we're all clear, because I was correct back in 2024 and not now. Your rules do provide that a majority of the quorum present is needed to pass any motion. So, I appreciate the opportunity to correct myself. off so two will be sufficient in order to adopt any motion and i 'll leave it at that [1:32:32] Speaker C (unidentified): yes yeah so we should vote on the motion [1:33:16] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU, FOLKS. [1:33:19] Speaker G (unidentified): LAST POINT, YOU NEED TO SCHEDULE A MEETING. YEAH. YOU NEED TO SCHEDULE A MEETING IN THE NEXT WEEK. [1:33:27] Speaker D (unidentified): THEY'LL JUST GO OVER WRITTEN DECISIONS. [1:33:29] Speaker L (unidentified): THEY'LL TAKE THEM OUT. [1:33:32] Speaker G (unidentified): YEAH. HOW ARE YOU? [1:33:36] Speaker B (unidentified): HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU HAVE? [1:34:40] Speaker O (unidentified): They just condoned it. You can get a permit and then build whatever you want. That's basically what they just said. [1:34:48] Speaker K (unidentified): It doesn't matter what the people say. [1:34:55] Speaker O (unidentified): And as far as I'm concerned, if they made a permit that said and you build whatever you want, you're not following the permit. [1:35:03] Speaker N (unidentified): Setbacks mean nothing and a code enforcement officer doesn't look at anything.