← Back to MaineScanner

Wiscasset Forms New Committee to Guide Wastewater Plant Relocation

2026-10-29 · 1h 1m · Source: WWTP Outreach Advisory 10.29.2026 (Town of Wiscasset (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:07] Recording. [0:10] Running progress for official. Welcome everybody to the first meeting of the wastewater treatment plant outreach advisory committee. I'm Cassie Rose. I'm delighted to welcome you all as the members of this new and very important committee. [0:28] I'm the software to this group and so I will get us started on the agenda until we select chairperson [0:37] which we'll go to in second. But I thought we could start off with introductions going around the table so that we will get to know each other a little bit better. I know not everybody knows each other, but it's always really helpful in my experience to just know each other as people and build our relationships [1:02] before we really jump into that work and so we can build a trusted relationship with each other when we have some tough conversations and be talking about some big issues. So I find it's really helpful to know people as human beings before you know we have those conversations [1:22] that we always see the person behind you know the comments or the questions. [1:30] So I can get started and then maybe we could go around the table. I'm Cassie Rose. I am on the board. Also I'm a liaison to the climate action team which I was the former chair of here in town and I proposed the creation of this committee which is why I wanted to join it and [1:55] I proposed creating an outreach committee because I saw a really substantial need for both education, outreach, and to create a vehicle for all the members of our community to communicate on this really big issue of relocating the wastewater treatment plant. [2:16] I've heard a lot of questions over the years and I think this group can really identify what are the key questions and then work to make sure that we are getting answers to the committee. so the third question that I would love you all to answer and I'll answer for myself is I love to both knit and crochet and I didn't make this but I'm learning how to do better at making sweaters. [2:41] We can sure use a lot of them here in Maine. [2:46] No shortage of sweater weather except for those in March here. [2:50] Well [2:51] [laughter] [2:54] They're lovely. [2:54] was a nice day. [2:56] [clears throat] [2:59] It was pretty warm. [3:01] Now I have my jacket on. [3:04] Yeah. Maybe I could turn it over to Rob as our town staff liaison. [3:12] My name is Rob Lally. I am the superintendent of the sewer department and I'm one of the ones who's been involved in the entire operation of bringing it into the public eye and the need to move the sewer plant and trying not to lose track of operating the department and the plants while doing those things. [3:39] So anyway, I'm on the committee as per Dennis Simmons and he would like me to lend whatever expertise I don't know that it's going to be any more than any of you know or particularly Jim but I will lend what expertise I can and [4:01] it's an important thing I guess with the sewer plant, you know? we're lucky to have one, I guess. [clears throat] because some communities don't have one and it's all septic systems. Or there are other communities that don't own or have control over their own sewer plants. [4:23] So it was that's a real advantage because sometimes when it becomes a district or it becomes a different kind of entity, the town itself doesn't have a whole lot of say over whether sewer rates go up or whether things change or and I don't know how a decision to move a sewer plant would occur if you're a district and the town [4:44] wouldn't have as much importance as a So anyway. Now tell [4:50] Favorite hobby? [4:52] I like kayaking I guess, but of course that's only part of the year. But I do love doing that. My wife and I go out and like Chickaloon very near Wasilla. there's a lot of places you can go. So [5:09] Can you volunteer? [5:11] I'll volunteer. Yeah. Hey. I'm Jim Crowley. I'm a Skwentna resident. I've spent 45 years plus in the environmental science and technology and engineering. most of the time in wastewater management. my background is in chemistry and business. [5:34] I've worked for private industry. I've been the superintendent of the 13 million gallon day treatment plant. in perspective Rob's plant is a 300,000 gallon day type facility, so this is a little larger. and a little more because it was a pulp and paper mill. I've been with the DEC for a 20 plus year stint regulating wastewater treatment plants throughout the state of Maine, running the pre-treatment program [6:03] doing technical assistance and sometimes enforcement. And I've been involved in wastewater treatment plant engineering projects and upgrades for all lifetime. boy, I can go on and on. I'm not a bad shut up This is something that's near and dear to my heart and I have I have a pretty deep tool set when it comes to this kind of stuff. [6:28] I also have a very wide familiarity with wastewater treatment plants and they and what works and what doesn't work and what the communities are like that host them, where the issues are. speaking to something Rob said, having the town in control of the wastewater treatment process or the if it's being a town department has its pluses. [6:49] It also has its minuses. So on the business management side, it depends on all the things that it depends on which is the individual town, the board and the situation of the treatment plants I have to give Rob credit. He and his folks do an excellent job running this plant. It's an old plant. It's a run-down plant, not because he's mismanaged it, because he hasn't. [7:10] And he's done a great job doing the best he can running what he's got to work with to keep his town compliant and out of hot water or hold the water or at least dirty water. favorite hobby for me is singing. I like a variety of different kinds of music. I like to perform. [7:30] I will perform at the drop of a hat in front of a very bunch of people with no musical sort of, right? [7:37] [clears throat] [7:41] [laughter] [7:43] Love that. [7:46] You thank you very much. [7:49] I'm Cindy Viam, also [7:53] I'm not hearing any capacity from work. I work for DOT. I'm the stormwater program manager there. Previously I worked at DEP with Jim supervising the municipal and industrial wastewater program, better known as the MITHY program. and way back when I worked at in a laboratory for a small [8:18] paper mill back in Massachusetts, so I have some laboratory experience. I like waste water. It's interesting to me, so takes a certain person I guess. [clears throat] and favorite hobby is probably gardening. I like any kind of gardening. [8:36] Amazing to me. [8:38] I do prefer heirloom tomatoes, but looking to get into bringing back the American chestnut. So [8:45] Oh yeah. [8:46] Nice. [8:47] So that's that [8:52] Are we looking to go around the room as that's [8:54] Yeah, my name's Dennis Worley. I just moved here. I moved into the Acabonac House across the street. [9:00] I remember that. [9:01] Okay. And that's started my interest in it because you know we were looking at the plan trying to figure out what was going on with it. Then I was a special education teacher and Dean of Students at Hartford Public High School in Hartford, Connecticut for 11 years and a special ed teacher in Washington D.C., Baltimore, and Hartford for the past 29 years. [9:23] I just retired last year. And just the part of the reason that I wanted to do this is that being the Dean of Students at Hartford Public High School, we had to do community outreach which just about everything that we did. So we got really good at that kind of stuff because we had to. So we understood the way that we did it. We were actually finally got good at it. [9:45] It took it took some time to figure it out, but we finally got fairly decent on it. And you know trying to explain to the community what was going on at Hartford High and because there was you know always a few problems. There's always something happening in Hartford High. We had you know we got police officers out pretty much every day. So we tried to tried to keep everybody that wanted to know something we kept everybody in the loop as much as we possibly could. [10:07] And favorite hobby I'm still a pilot, so [10:10] Oh, very cool. [10:12] Trying to get into it. then it was a bit rough for a while there when I was teaching. So, and then I'm retiring and started back on it. [10:21] Okay. [10:22] How Yes. Yes, I'm originally from Middletown, Connecticut. So, my, Cassie asked me to join the committee. I think probably because I'm kind of a community activist in some ways. I am an environmentalist, but my background is in healthcare. I was a I'm clinical and working in clinical labs for many years. [10:45] I did graduate studies in medical technology. Then I went to OT school. So, I worked with disabled individuals for about 20 years in the Boston area and then got into hospital management and case management. So, I'm interested I don't know. I'm interested in wastewater kinds of things. [11:06] When I had young children, we, my former husband and I volunteered in Edgartown, Massachusetts around you know, water cleanups, river cleanups, and WRA, community activism around building a taking a dam down, building a fish ladder, you know, doing all that kind of stuff. [11:34] So, got a little more friendly with it then. But interestingly enough, when I was I wanted to add that my first sort of community activism project at St. Mary's, school in Middletown, Connecticut for the civics club was actually just after the Clean Water Act. Just passing there actually building their first [11:56] plant informally all the wastewater in the at in the Connecticut River. All the towns in Connecticut just dumped their waste in the Connecticut River and Middletown sits on the Connecticut River. So, it's a huge deal. [12:11] 1973. [12:13] yeah. Yeah, it's a long [12:15] I remember when you were just building it and I remember we actually went down and took pictures with our little instamatic cameras of the waste water going in and so. This in the middle town I have many hobbies. Singing is one of them. I really also being a retired person enjoy learning about art in a way that I haven't and I am very social kind of person so I canvas for candidates kind of for fun [12:45] and I really enjoy it so I just got finished canvassing for this so long. So hi, that's me. [12:53] Well, thank you all. it's [12:55] It's a lot to get done. [12:57] [laughter] [13:02] [clears throat] [13:03] So I'm Shannon Bacca, West Tactic resident for I think going on nine years now. my husband works for the town and we were located across from the original plant in where that was supposed to go so I was one of the initial people that spoke out about some concerns that I had. [13:26] This is my first time serving on a committee like this but part of the reason that I wanted to do that is because I have I'm also an occupational therapist. [13:36] Right. [13:37] a big interest in public health and also getting communication out to people, right? through this process I think on all ends there are lots of rumors that got circulated some of which are you know not true but because there is so many layers to this really trying to be able to get a well-rounded [14:00] idea of all the risks versus benefits depending on where it goes and being able to really get information out there to the people that is real fact-based and not politically driven, right? because [clears throat] people deserve information and, you know, I'm excited to be a part of this and be with such a group of knowledgeable individuals cuz, you know, this is intimidating. [14:28] Some of this is absolutely going to be a learning curve for me, but I'm excited to be a part of it. and again, the big thing is coming together and getting facts and giving those to people to stop the rumors so people can make an educated decision and hopefully engage people [14:50] who otherwise don't engage, but like to talk, right? And bring a little bit of [14:59] [clears throat] [14:59] Save that story for [15:03] So you know, that's that's the where I'm coming at from this. And hobbies, I also crochet and love gardening in the summer, but I'd say probably my favorite hobby when I have time between work and other things is I have my very first grandchild. She'll be two in January [15:24] and she's at that age where they don't talk back to you yet and everything they do is cute and wonderful. So I'm eating up every moment of it. mom threatens to sell her and I said absolutely I will take her when she starts to talk back. [15:37] And then you can have her [15:38] I've done my service four times, so. [15:42] [laughter] [15:44] Thank you. [15:44] Yeah. [15:45] Thank you all. well, as you've gathered, we have a really diverse group here of folks with wonderful lived experience, expertise, and that's on purpose. That's by design. This committee was brought together to make sure that we are hearing from a variety of perspectives, people who have expertise, but who feel people who also have a lot of questions, [16:10] engage with their community, and can bring your perspectives here. So this group is here not only to share your perspectives, but to help give that lens to different parts of our community and bring that all together to help help the select board and town to really work through information and put forward a proposal that has buy in from the entire community. [16:38] This is a little bit of a new model for this town. It's actually a kind of model that I took from my time working in Governor's office on a statewide kind of planning process that worked really well. And so we're going to road test that a little bit here and I also hope that we are going to figure out how better to engage the community and communicate with everybody because that will really help the town communicate with [17:08] all of our residents all of the time on a lot of issues, which is a persistent challenge. so thank you all for taking the time to do this. I think it's it's really helpful to get to know each other and I know I'm going to go to Tomato Tips. Singing and all of the [17:30] [clears throat] Very excited. [17:35] [laughter] [17:37] Singing only happens in my car when I'm pretending I'm auditioning for American Idol. [17:45] [laughter] [17:47] Love it. so this was not formally [17:55] apologies for not getting this formally on the agenda, but it's laid out in the directive that this group will elect officers at our first meeting. [18:06] Is there anybody on Is there anybody on this [18:09] Yes, we have two people on. [18:10] That are members for [18:12] no, members of the public. we have Greg Wood and then Susan Johns. [18:18] Okay. That completes the DDP people from Wisconsin. [18:25] [laughter] [18:34] And he is somewhat familiar with this. [18:46] So, there the town committees generally use Robert's Rules of Order. I haven't read that since high school, but generally known not to be dangerous here. And so, in order to make [19:05] a motion, you would say I move to blah and to nominate whoever as chair, vice chair, secretary. That then has to be seconded. And then the five members of this committee will vote and I will record that. At that point, I will turn it over to the chairperson, but I'm also help happy to kind of run this meeting so far and then talk with the chairperson [19:30] Sure. [19:33] So. [19:35] Do you want to clarify what those the expectation of those roles are? [19:39] Yes. So, the chairperson [19:42] will be responsible for helping to set an agenda, making sure that is pulled together and communicated to the town in time for posting on the web at least a couple days ahead of public meeting of these meetings which are open to the public. The vice chair can help with that as well. [20:03] The chairperson runs the meetings and generally helps make sure things are happening on time with support from the two liaisons. The vice chair can take over if the chair cannot attend the meeting for some reason. The vice chair could step in and do those duties. [20:25] And then the secretary would record any actions taken which typically are if there are votes that are taken or just a broad summary of what happened at the meetings. And I'm happy to sort of walk through all of that with whoever needs but that's the overall [20:47] Okay? [20:47] Yeah. [20:49] Okay. So can I get a motion to open the floor for nominations? [20:56] I move to nominate Jim Crowley for chairperson if he is willing. [21:01] I second the motion. [21:04] Vote okay. [21:05] Yeah. Okay. Any questions, discussion? Jim are you willing? [21:09] Well I 'm willing. That being out is and it's just my personal life choice. I am a Luddite when it comes to social media and things computer. I am not on social media. I do not have a I actually have a flip phone that's off all the time in my pocket in case I get in an accident or something. [21:30] But I am absolutely incompetent at electronic communication. So I would I can I'm willing to take a management role but somebody is really going to have to hold my hand or do electronic tasks for me. I can write I mean I can use a computer and type in Word and whatever. So I can do that. [21:49] Can you write up an agenda? [21:50] I can write an agenda yeah but don't don't expect me to be fluent in anything that has to do [21:54] email me the agenda I can get it into a document on [21:58] Okay. Then I accept. [22:03] Discussion. [22:06] Any other nominations? [22:09] Do we need to vote on this cuz the motion's on the floor so [22:12] The motion's on the floor. Okay. So all in favor of not nominating electing Jim Crowley as the chair of this committee raise your hand. [22:26] They both myself [22:31] So, we've got five zero. Okay. Congratulations, Mr. Chair. [22:38] Thank you. [22:39] Would you like to run the rest of the meeting or would you like [22:43] I want you to take this one. [22:47] We're fine. Okay. So, next up is the vice chair position. Can I get a motion? [22:59] Motion to [23:00] You can also self-nominate. [23:02] I will self-nominate. [23:06] I guess I'm nominating myself as vice chair. [23:10] I second that. [23:12] Sounds like a plan. [23:13] Any [laughter] discussion? Any remarks, aren't you? [23:19] I might be able to help you with your letting stuff in. [23:23] [laughter] [23:30] Not seeing any other comments or questions. All in favor of appointing [23:40] as vice chair. Please raise your hands. [23:45] we don't vote actually. Yeah, we don't vote. [23:50] That's good. [23:51] [laughter] [23:56] Okay. Congratulations. [24:00] Okay. And last but not least, we have the secretary position. [24:09] Can I get a motion? [24:11] A motion to nominate Sorry, I'm not going to remember your name. [24:14] Dennis. [24:15] Dennis. [24:17] Is that you willing? [24:18] Sure. [24:19] Okay. Thank you. Any questions, comments? Okay. All in favor of electing Anne Sperling as secretary of this committee, please raise your hand. [24:35] Okay. Congratulations. You have elected officers. Such a productive group. [laughter] [24:44] Okay. Fantastic. We are doing well. [24:51] So we're going to move forward to a brief please overview of [24:58] was [25:00] putting a few bullet points on an article that I already written many years ago. [25:04] and for awareness, I have to turn into a public meeting at 7:05 so that is [25:14] basically I'm just going to give a brief overview of the history of the sewer plant in Wausau. Wausau was among the first communities in May to construct a secondary treatment plant and we're talking all the way back in 1964. The original plant part of it is still existing [25:38] but that part was just I guess a little bit of aeration and a little bit of settling and then right out into the Sheboygan Scott River went the cleaned up water. And yes. But anyway, this was in 1964 and that's before the Clean Water Act which was enacted in the '70s to improve waterways in America. [26:05] the plant in 1992 was upgraded and it was in bad shape at the time because they had a lot of high flows during storm events and the plant could not handle them so water came rushing through untreated out into the Sheboygan. [26:27] So that particular upgrade is the way that the plant is today. [snorts] [26:33] It was originally designed to handle 110,000 gallons a day, and that really didn't allow for any growth in this cassette. And of course, you can see the business is down in room one. [26:46] You know, they just couldn't handle it. So anyway, these issues were addressed and a engineering company put together a plan. That plan included two new aeration tanks, conversion into coarse bubble or into fine bubble aeration. And they added two new 40-ft clarifiers, which are covered with the domes that you ever see over there. [27:08] And then they also chlorinated and dechlorinated the effluent, meaning that it was killing extra bacteria on the way out. [27:20] We have a belt filter press over there, which is a little bit outdated, I would say, as technology goes back. But that's what happens with the sludge. It's dried, the water is basically squeezed out of it on the belt press machine. And then we take the load of dried sludge to Juniper Ridge landfill, which is in Old Town. [27:42] That location is dictated to us by the DEP. It's 124 miles away. And previously, we used to be able to deliver our sludge loads to Casella Composting, a facility that was only 74 miles away. So anyway, things are changing a bit. But what's happened now is we're in a similar position that the plant was in 1992. [28:08] And that is that all the equipment is 30 plus years old. Things are wearing out. And the engineering firm called Olver Associates had done the climate study and an examination of all the infrastructure for the sewer department. And that was done in 2022. [28:29] And what they did find was that the sewer plant needs do something to improve change or upgrade all of this equipment. Around the same time, we were also told to make the climate study, which was done. And that of course looks at future tidal events and weather events and global warming, whatever the [28:55] climate issues are. And you have to look at your plant and say, hey, are you going to be able to withstand a hurricane 50 years down the line, 75 years down the line? And the study found that indeed there would be more significant storms that we deal with and that there were [29:16] good possibilities that the plant would be completely inundated if climate predictions are correct, that the tidal issues and the water levels would rise over time. And whether anybody believes in the climate changes or not, we are receiving much more significant storms recently in the past few years. [29:43] I've been here since 2019 and some of the storms have been outrageous, having five or six inches of rain. And when that happens, your treatment is, you know, you're barely able to handle the amount of water that's coming through inflow and infiltration into the system. And it's also a threat to inundate the plant. [30:05] And you can see on the screen the plant, we're on this little island. And that particular photo was taken at the tide is going out. [30:13] It's low tide. [30:14] Yeah, but I will tell you just last week we had some full moons with the higher tides and it was like our driveway, then you see the long driveway that comes down towards the plant, that water was lapping up on the top grassy area threatening to go onto the driveway. It didn't. [30:34] But [30:35] any storm. [30:36] Yeah, there was no storm, there was no significant rain or anything. So, anyway, in Alver's study, they said, hey, we're going to give you a couple of options. You can move the plant someplace else or you can put a seawall around it and move everything in basements up. Well, the DEP, of course, has to be in on any of that kind of planning. [30:58] And when we spoke to them about it, they made it clear that the seawall idea was not going to fly. They told us in a recent meeting with the chairman, the chairperson of the DEP in name, she said, we cannot make you move that plant. [31:21] But we will not give you one cent [snorts] to put a wall around that and to move everything up and out. So, in that meeting, our manager, Dennis Simmons, said, well, you're giving money to Boothbay Harbor, who we're putting a wall in. And the chairman said, we're not giving them one cent for that. [31:41] If they want to put a wall around it, they can pay it for it out of their own pocket. But construction is going on down there. What's going on? Oh, they've got some kind of a DOT grant to move things up out of basements so that it wouldn't be affected by floodwaters. But we're not allowing them one dime to put up any kind of a seawall. [32:03] And we would have to approve the plan for that. We would license their plan. We could go ahead and say, well, we're not licensing it. So, they're not putting out a seawall. And then Dennis Simmons said, well,, Gendron's putting up a seawall. And they said, no, they're not. And so we said, well, you're kind of I don't want to say blackmailing us into [32:28] but by holding back the funding, hey, you know, how are you going to pay for something that's 40, 50, 60 million dollars? So, anyway, they said, look, we'll do our best to give you over funding that your town needs. But it's not going to be 100% but it will be a significant amount. So what they're thinking of doing is taking a plan where the whole thing gets financed [32:53] through the DEP, meaning the whole thing your 60 million. And then you go for the grants as the construction goes along. And you can get I mean I don't know what percentage it would cover but you can get a lot of grants. So anyway a lot of it could go towards that and that's the way that you could propel the project along instead of going well I have 5 million dollars, what can I do for 5 million dollars you know? [33:19] So anyway that is the state of the state that we're in right now. The ship has sailed on putting up a seawall and we're now just in the position of okay moving forward and of course the first step will be where will we put the sewer plant? So anyway you've gotten the up-to-date [33:39] status and I'm hoping that sort of least brings you into the window of understanding why we're in the position we're in. [33:47] I have a question. Just so I understand the note to the seawall the DEP is funding the I'm going to pay for the seawall but other people can pay for the seawall [33:57] Yes. [33:59] Because I know that question was going to come. Just wanted to show up. [34:03] Yes. And the amount for the seawall I think was 35 million. [34:07] The total [34:09] Yes. So anyway you're still talking a chunk of money even if the town had that kind of money laying around 35 million is a lot of dough. [34:18] Well and the seawall still doesn't address the aging infrastructure. [34:21] No it does not. Yes. And it just incidentally I believe the DEP study the cap study where they said hey the sewer plant still needs it was like 26 million dollars worth of upgrades or repairs or replacements of stuff that do just aged out. So even if you had 35 million to do the [34:42] project and move everything up, you still have to replace this and that. So you're still talking roughly the same amount of money, 50-60 million. [34:49] Yeah. [34:50] Can I just ask a question? Is there a timeline for this? [34:53] Well, sooner rather than later. [34:55] I know. I was just wondering [34:57] If the site was picked tomorrow, we'd be talking five years, Jim. [35:02] Yeah. I 'd have to review the plans on the actual plant itself to understand what construction of general would be. but I would say that yeah, if we said go [35:13] Yeah, tomorrow. [35:14] Mhm. [35:15] It would probably be at best four to five years out. [35:20] Okay. [35:21] Okay. And it might even be longer depending on whatever situation we're going to be dealing with. [35:26] And keep this in mind as well. The design phase has not even been entered into because we don't know what the size of the lot or the land will be, and we don't know if the town fathers will want a certain type of plant. Where we are activated sludge plant over there which uses ancient technology, there are new filtration plants that are much more efficient. [35:49] They are a bit more expensive, but there's new technologies out there. The plants run quieter with less or not no smell, but almost none. And there are energy efficient ways of running pumps and drives and things like that we don't have over here. So [36:08] My thoughts make a comment that one of the things that Rob mentioned was people feeling people sort of personally feeling blackmailed by the DEP not being willing to spend money on a seawall. DEP has probably 10 times [36:30] the amount of requests for funding for water projects. The state revolving loan fund and for water projects gets far in excess the amount of money they have in terms of annual requests from the on for help in their treatment systems. And there's a complex, but I think a very good, very legitimate process that the engineers in the division have to analyze the request and say, okay, they rate them against it. [36:57] We're all rated against everyone else in the state. And they have a way of determining, okay, how much money could we give with casting or Augusta or Jack Men or Lewis Norbert depending on what project is and how they're rated. So the concept that the DP's giving somebody else money that they're not willing to give to us and is a very, elementary, incorrect approach to understanding why the money is disturbed distributed the way it is. [37:28] Thank you for bringing that up. [37:30] Yeah, that's important Yeah. [37:32] We don't want the mess we'd have to disburse for people. [37:35] Absolutely. [37:36] Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. So taking a couple of notes here, but we'll get around to potential meeting topics that we can get into and share gathering. Thank you very much, Ralph. Appreciate it. Moving this along here so we make sure to get through our agenda. [37:56] Okay. So wanted to just quickly go through the committee directive and the relocation selection overview that was recently adopted by the select. And so these were distributed to everybody ahead of the meeting, but the basic directive is that this is an outreach advisory committee and so it is primarily [38:21] tasked with advising and supporting the town of Wiscasset with public engagement and education on the relocation of the wastewater treatment plant, which includes information sharing, community outreach, and consensus building or the ultimate selection of the location for that new plant. What we're aiming to do really is to build consensus in our community around a new location so that we don't [38:47] continue to have delays because as we know the impacts are accelerating and we want to make sure that there's nothing bad happening with it. [38:56] And they're getting more expensive every year. [38:58] And getting more expensive every year, exactly. [39:01] So is the assumption that upgrading the plant in situ as this right now off the table? [39:09] Yes. [39:09] Yes. [39:10] Okay. [39:14] And so recently at literally two weeks ago the select board adopted a site review plant site review and selection plan. This lays out a 12 up to 12 month process of how exactly the select board will be [39:36] identifying and putting forward a recommendation to the town voters for location. And it's very critical that the members of this committee understand that if you have any questions I'm happy or happy to try to answer them or connect you with our town manager to go through them. [39:57] But this plan outlines the role of this committee which will primarily be to review information relevant to the relocation of the plant, identify community concerns for potential relocations and costs and to provide recommendations and feedback without directing the consultants, the engineering firm that's supporting the town on this research and site review [40:26] or replacing any of the above listed authorities. And so ultimately what this means this isn't an advisory committee, this isn't the committee that's going to be you know making that determination, but we can really provide a lot of very valuable input and community [40:47] communication into that So any quick questions based on your review all one together? [40:55] Yes, I've gone through this very thoroughly and I think I would like to at some point I think we need to talk our way through what these all mean because I can see where there are plenty of possibilities to interpret things in actually diametrically different [41:16] interpretations. So I think we need to be clear and maybe even get a little bit of post facto input that is or the selective just what is or what is not possible given this plan. [41:32] Absolutely. [41:32] Which document are you referring to the What is this [41:36] Is that the one you have [41:37] Yes. Okay. I was unsure if it was that or the right [41:40] Yeah. Well, this is pretty complex and complete thorough, but I think it bears some dissection. [41:47] Yeah, certainly. so I'll make a note that it would be helpful to have that discussion and perhaps at our next meeting if has capacity we could go through that and talk about that so that we're on the same page. It is complex, absolutely. I one thing I wanted to highlight as a near term decision for the select board that I think this committee could really help with is the board is being asked [42:17] to identify an affordability threshold for the decision of that patient. So what I interpret that is as is the total cost of that project and what we consider an affordability threshold. So that's not defined and I think that's that's something having a discussion with this group will be [42:38] Affordability threshold is set in advance of our decisions or after we've gone through and assessed our options. You see what I'm saying? [42:50] Yes. [42:51] Is it a Is it limiting up Or is it a [42:55] That's a good question. I think that this will be a conversation to ask for a little more clarification that I have a question about. [43:02] Yeah. [43:03] There's also the affordability of the rates for the sewer plant customers, you know, what is considered an affordable rate. I think the part that is also part of that, so we'll have a conversation about [43:16] Yeah. [43:16] all of the aspects. [43:17] This is a remarkably complex set of things and it also represents effort on the part of the town that the town has never experienced before. [43:25] Yeah. [43:26] Really? [43:28] Yeah. And the whole thing about affordability versus what's happening in a lot of the world and how it's affecting our individual people in our town, the costs of living and all that kind of stuff. I mean talk about not affordability, not even being able to afford heating oil. [43:46] Yeah. [43:47] And the sewer rate increases every year. It's It's a lot. [43:51] Absolutely. Absolutely. [43:52] And groceries. [43:53] Yeah. [43:54] Everything else. [43:55] Certainly. And it's speaking as a somebody who's training in climate science, we're not the only community going through this and it's only going to accelerate. And so what we're doing here is going to be a real pilot for other communities who are going through this exact same experience or will. [44:14] And at the risk of being potentially political, the question I'd like to put to the group because this will get banked around. It's kind of a political thing. Sorry. But are we in general agreement that the preponderance of the signs that's out there indicates that this is actually happening and it is going to exacerbate and get worse going into the future? [44:40] Or do we have people that are some of us maybe don't believe that's the case? [44:46] Well, do you know what? I had a lot of feedback when we had the flooding, remember two years ago? And how many people told me, I've lived here for 60 years I've never seen anything like this. I never got water washing across my street. I never had water coming across the yard. And they had it. And that wasn't even a hurricane or a, you know, it was a big storm, but it wasn't a hurricane and it was the super tide contributed to that as well. [45:14] But to think that, you know, when we had the picture of the plant up there on the island, you know the railroad tracks run right next to the sewer plant. And they were underwater about 2 ft. I mean, think about that, you know. [45:27] So are we all basically in agreement with the preponderance of the science that's out there? [45:32] Yes. [45:33] That's that's good. [45:33] By experience. Yeah. [45:35] Well, yes, empirically. [45:38] And I would I'll say this when we talk about our future meetings, but I would love to hear from all of you what questions are you hearing of what do you have about the reasons behind because I get I hear questions about what does sea level rise have to do with this? What even is that? What about these vibrant rain events? And I think there's a lot of room to [46:00] consolidate all these questions and then go through them, learn as a group and then share that information [46:08] and I'm a huge nerd so I always love to talk. That's my that's my that's my [46:19] Okay. So I will commit to confirming we can get in Denit or calling up Dennis to get him in to have a discussion about that one. Okay. So that actually brings us to our brief discussion of future community work which involves quite a few things. [46:39] I think we're going to be pretty busy and so this committee information review, so that will involve addressing community questions and concerns and I think we can outsource what those questions and concerns are as a group and out through our networks to solicit them. some potential topics that Rob and I brainstormed ahead of this meeting were modern plant designs that could involve a field trip to a modern inspired [47:09] treatment of lands. flooding and environmental considerations, what do we need to plan for into the future and why, discussion about affordability thresholds and so on. So I would love to hear from all of you what those topics are that you think would be valuable as a committee to go through for information gathering. [47:33] We can invite people into present to this group. this is this is kind of a micro this is a stakeholder group and so presentations here allow us to get that information and then we can also work together to think about how do we then disseminate again. [47:50] Next is public engagement. So we are not only going to meet together but we're also going to be getting out into the community. And so I'd love for you to share take a couple minutes here to share your initial ideas and to discuss future work that we can do which can include in-person events, going to Lincoln County Television, [48:13] you could be doing polls of the community, writing articles in the newspapers, doing social media for those of us who like social media or don't like it but do it. [48:24] That's right. [48:26] And then ultimately the soup will be providing recommendations to the select board specifically about how best to do public outreach and communications and then summarize [48:37] so we will be moving towards the point where we're synthesizing everything we've learned, everything we're hearing for the board as the board is considering that recommendation of here is the site we want to poke you for the bonus. [48:52] I envision when I'm leading it myself setting up overtime visits to the treatment plants that they could be Maybe they should be too far afield because I kind of disturb those people. But we have a good number of treatment plants that are within easy commuting distance of here. And Stroudsburg treatment plant too, frankly. [49:12] Yes. by the people with concerns about treatment plants in other communities or what's it like to have a treatment plant in your backyard and whatnot. I would love to lead interested groups of people. I know all these people. I've worked with them. And I could set up site visits to any treatment plant in the state. And I 'd be willing to do you know maybe we're not going to blitz to do 10 a month or something like that, but maybe a couple a month as we're doing this part of our public outreach can be everyone who's interested and maybe some [49:42] of you who should be interested but aren't yet. let's go to a treatment plant. Ask questions. And experience what it's like to be there and be in those communities. [49:53] That's fantastic. And actually I forgot to mention this before, but some perspectives that we weren't able to get so far here are student groups and businesses. And I know that there's a student group right from who studied the [50:07] Yes. I was shocked to see it in the newspaper. I have seen a school bus down the end of our driveway. And all these young people with the a few adults and they were pointing and looking and all that stuff. And if I had known they were doing that, I would have said come on take a tour of the plant. And so it was in the newspaper a student group goes to look at climate effects and the need to move the sewer plant. [50:32] So apparently that was what their subject matter was. [50:34] I think that's a group we Yeah. [50:40] So thank you Jim for being [50:43] I'll really dive into that too. [50:45] It would be fun you know having them come through and see how it works and you can see some of the antiquated equipment that's over there too. We have some stuff from 1962 and it still works miraculously. [50:57] And this treatment plant is very different from the one in Scappoose. [51:02] Yeah, it's a little The one in Scappoose is a lagoon treatment system. [51:05] Yeah. [51:05] It's a different set of Yeah. That's another thing I can do. [51:07] do that as well. [51:09] I can do this with the group at some point and we can do like waste treatment 101. Not right now. [clears throat] But we I can kind of bring up the speed with what the typical technologies are. [51:19] That would be great. [51:20] Yeah, that would be fabulous. [51:21] Yeah. And you want to know something? A lagoon plant is much simpler and [51:25] Easier to run. But you need big tracts of land to do it because the ponds have to be so many acres and we just don't have that at the moment in Wisconsin. [51:35] little more fair fertilizer, 27 million gallon lagoon capacity. [51:39] that. [51:40] But it's got territory all over the place, big flat open spaces. [51:44] Yeah. And it's [51:46] until everyone's getting excited. [51:50] Yes. I'm really I'm really glad. Yeah. This is your part of the meeting that I'd love to get your You know, what are the what kind of information would you like to gather and talk through as part of coming up to speed in Wisconsin? What would be helpful for everyone? [52:08] I think one of the first things is because everyone has said, no matter what the issue is in Wisconsin, communication seems to be the first and most important step and often it is lacking. [52:21] Yes. [52:22] And I think as far as communication I mean when you have like television, social media, all that stuff, I mean whatever the recommendations of the select board are and we want to get that information out to the public, I think it has to be more than what we're doing now. [52:43] Well, and I think in line with that though is bite-sized pieces for people because a lot of people, you know, research shows especially in the age of social media, if you put something on social media that's more than x amount of time long, people turn off right? So, you know, [53:04] some of the younger generations who typically do not engage with political things, you know, don't didn't grow up in the generation of reading newspapers. They want soundbites. Like it's quick and easy. So breaking it up into what are the topics, but also putting it in a language that's easy to understand because even, you know, the last vote that we had, the word rescind [53:27] threw off so many people. Otherwise, you know, I was getting feedback from some people who are college educated people and, you know, oh, I voted the wrong way cuz I didn't know what rescind meant. And then in my brain, I'm also like, there's this thing called Google, right? Your phones aren't prohibited from a voting booth. You could have looked it up and said, what does this word mean? [53:50] But you know, we have a large working class here as well. different levels of education. So making sure that the information we're conveying is in a way that's easy for people to understand and be able to formulate a question in response to. [54:08] I think we should start with the low hanging fruit. In my mind, it's why do we need a new treatment plan? There's got to be at least three bullet items that would just answer that very quickly. And then the next one is why is just fixing the current one off the table? What are the top bullet items for that? [54:29] Why is that off the table? [54:33] When you're talking about that, then you got to start talking about money with people too. [54:37] Mhm. [54:37] And how much is it going to cost them? And I think that's part of the low hanging fruit. I think that's the biggest interest for a lot of people is how much is this going to increase my bills? How do we as a city or a town mitigate the costs? And are we doing the best job that we can to mitigate the cost to the people of town? And I think that's going to be huge with people as much as work and my best where it goes but why it's going someplace that everybody knows we have to move it or we do it. [55:05] Everybody in town knows that but how much is it going to cost me and can I afford it? [55:10] Well, Mary, you know, your point with some of the low-hanging fruit, some of the low-hanging fruit with why we need to move it is not as low-hanging as you might think because of all of the people who disagree. So how do you convince people that climate change has actually occurred, right? How do we convince people that the plant itself is at risk? [55:34] and some of that is, you know, research and again, those sound bites that they can understand. [55:44] I wish they'd believe some of the data well. [55:46] So I guess you know, some of what I've heard from people is you know, I've lived here all my life. That happens every 10 years or so. This isn't new. [55:58] Okay. [55:58] So but you know, [56:00] off the table completely because you can and just say it's not about climate change, it's just it will cost us $30 million to upgrade, DEP won't help us at all. [56:11] Yep. [56:11] It's all our money. So it's just back to the money there, not [56:15] that is true. It's it's happened. It's not Well, we're still debating that. That's happened. And it's now a question of where will we go and doing an assessment of those potential Yeah, I think you're exactly right. I think for those people that don't believe that climate change is real, you know, the decisions already been made that we're going to move the plant because it's antiquated [56:37] and it needs to be redone. We're not going to redo We're not going to redo it in the same spot that it was. So that decision's already been made and it's got you know, for people that don't believe, you can actually say it's really not a lot to do with climate change. It's a lot to do with the plant [56:49] I fear you still need to regardless of whether the folks understand the technical detail of what needs to be done, you have to be able to talk with them enough so that you even if you disagree with something fundamental like that [57:04] Yep. [57:05] that they realize that the decisions that are being made are being made in a technically valid way with their most with their interest financially and otherwise in mind. [57:16] And so with that thought, one of the things that I think about is yes, you know, we're talking about cost, but there was somebody and I'm not going to pull the name off the top of my head who recently wrote a newspaper article about if we just decided to pay for it out of pocket, right? Pay for this wall and the upgrades and they gave all of these numbers. [57:39] Yeah. [57:41] But truer in truer not, for the people that read that and bought that, we have to show numbers that are contrary to that because that's the only way you're going to convince others. [57:53] And technological expertise because that's misguided. And technically it's misguided. They I mean you could say we're all entitled to our own truths, but that those things that were said were based on inappropriate understanding of the technology and people. We have to be able to present why what we're suggesting is technologically appropriate. [58:16] Yes. [58:17] That this is how it's done. [58:19] and that's I think in part screening for when those things are coming out, when we see something hit the newspaper and you not ignoring them, but then issuing a response that gives that information like what you're talking about. We understand why somebody would believe this. However, [58:36] this is the trick. [58:37] Right. [58:38] And that I like it. Sports analogy here. I like I always played defense all my life, catcher, [laughter] fullback, not [58:48] whatever. Never mind, lacrosse. [58:52] It's good to play defense, but you also got to play offense. And by offense, we have to come not only do we have to speak truth to the situations that are a little shady, we also have to be presenting people with what we see as the fundamental objective truth. [59:07] Yes. [59:08] They've got to they got to get it from both sides. [59:10] Yeah. And I think [clears throat] [59:15] Or we just have a couple minutes. [59:17] Oh, go ahead. [59:18] it will come up at another time at all. [59:24] Thank you all for the rich discussion. I apologize if we don't have a long [59:31] However, I'd love to ask you all these send your ideas for future discussion topics to Jim, Shannon, Stacy, me. And we will file them and talk about meeting schedule. I want to see next [59:52] and last in our agenda, we have some public comments on anything not on the agenda. We do have somebody Greg Wood and Susan Gons. Do you have any comments on that? [1:00:08] All set. Thank you. [1:00:11] Yeah, I'm all set also. Thank you. [1:00:13] Thank you very much for attending. Okay. [1:00:17] Can maybe send out the contact information for everyone so we can send stuff back and forth? [1:00:22] Yes, you do have everybody's email under on the on thread. okay. Well, thank you all very much. I'm going to ask for a motion to adjourn at 7:00 p.m. [1:00:36] I motion we adjourn. [1:00:37] Are we going to talk about next meeting time before we adjourn? [1:00:40] Yes, we can when we [1:00:47] is this fourth Thursday the play of this kind of stuff, folks? [1:00:53] Yes. [1:00:54] Okay. [1:00:56] I believe so, but I don't [1:00:58] Is it the next one Thanksgiving by the way? [1:01:00] We can [1:01:00] Well, yeah, we can maneuver around that. Okay. [1:01:05] Thursdays are usually good. [1:01:07] Yeah. [1:01:09] I think the next two months we will have to adjust for the holidays. So [1:01:15] and suggest a time so we can run that like have probably be the 19th. [1:01:21] Okay. [1:01:21] November 19th. [1:01:24] great. Well thank you all. Can I get a motion to adjourn? [1:01:29] I motion that we adjourn. [1:01:33] Favor? [1:01:39] Thank you all. [1:01:41] Thank you.