Portland Historic Preservation Board Approves New Construction at 43 St. Lawrence Street
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[8:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Michael, can you hear us? I can hear you. I'm sorry I'm not gracing you guys with my presence tonight. I'm sure you miss me. That's okay. There's nothing I can do about it.
[8:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Dearly, we miss you dearly. Yeah.
[8:22] Speaker C (unidentified): You look very dramatic. Yeah. Because it's all dark. You're all in black.
[8:26] Speaker A (unidentified): You're just your face. It's like a floating head.
[8:29] Speaker C (unidentified): It's a floating head. It's very impressive. Yeah, right.
[8:55] Speaker B (unidentified): The bell has not yet chimed. Are you expecting anyone else from your team?
[9:45] Speaker D (unidentified): The owner is driving here. Okay. Pretty quickly, but I told him we'll get started with that one. Okay. There's a few houses. There'll be a few houses. Yeah.
[10:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I think the city needs to upgrade its camera. You guys look really blurry.
[10:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, you look blurry.
[10:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Wait, do I really?
[10:13] Speaker D (unidentified): No, not really.
[10:14] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it's actually more of the screen than the TV. leave and give it another minute or two doesn't appear we're holding up any members are
[10:43] Speaker A (unidentified): we waiting on brad or kip brad will not be here [Speaker E (unidentified): rob] is this your last meeting no i don't think so
[11:05] Speaker F (unidentified): two more two more no one more one more one more field trip on the 17th okay
[12:35] Speaker G (unidentified): Good evening. I'd like to call the meeting to order. Today is Wednesday, November 4th at 5.02 PM. And this is the Historic Preservation Board of Portland, Maine. And let's start
[12:47] Speaker H (unidentified): with the roll call and declaration of form Mr. Schultz yes Madam Vice Chair Hilary Bassett here
[12:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Tessa Carty here Kip Desair is not present Michael Hutchins there I mean here yeah thank you Rob Whitten here Valerie Paquin-Gould here and Chair Miller had reported he would be absent since Chair
[13:10] Speaker G (unidentified): Miller is absent I'd like to take I'll be taking the role of temporary chair and we'll be doing nominations for temporary vice chair. Would anyone like to nominate someone or nominate themselves for this position for the evening? I'll nominate myself. We have a second? I have a second. Do a full vote on that one? Yes. Okay, roll call. Yes,
[13:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Madam Chair Pro Tem, Hilary Bassett, Tessa Carty, Michael Hutchins. Yes. Rob Whitten. Yes. Yes. Yes. The election is carried. Great.
[13:47] Speaker G (unidentified): So, item number two, report of attendance at the meeting held on October 21st, 2026. It was a public hearing, review of the recommendation to the Maine Historic Preservation Commission regarding National Register nomination for a Harvey Gamage docked at 100 West Commercial Street. Street. Attendees were Bassett, Deseris, Hutchins, Miller, and Papagoel were present, and Carty and Witten were absent. Are there any changes to this record? Hearing none, item number two is the workshop review of new construction 101 and 105 Winter Street. 105 Winter LLC see an HSM development applicant's plan number HP00123-2026. Attendees were Bassett, Deseris, Hutchins, Miller, and Paiklin-Gould were present, and Carty and Witten absent. Are there any changes to this record? All right, hearing none. Item number three, reports of decisions at the meeting held on October 21st, 2026. Item one is review of the recommendation to the main historic preservation commission regarding national register no is that hello it's correct nomination for the harvey grammage the board voted five in favor none opposed to recommend that the main historic preservation commission support the nomination are there any changes to this record hearing none number four communications and reports
[15:16] Speaker B (unidentified): are there any communications reports mr yes we have one just communicating to you all the meeting dates and filing deadlines for 2027 since we are beginning to run out of 2026 meeting dates and filing deadlines. So that was provided to you in the packet, the document that will then go up on the website for sort of public information.
[15:41] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't think there's anything
[15:42] Speaker B (unidentified): to note. All the meeting dates are pretty standard. Sometimes they adjust if there's a holiday, but that didn't happen this year. So that is being communicated to you. I'm happy to answer any questions if there are any.
[15:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Great. Any questions on that item? All right. So item number five is a public hearing. So it's the review of the construction of 43 St. Lawrence Street, 43 St. Lawrence Street Development, LLC, and Tregunter Real Estate Management, LLC, see applicants plan number hp-00108-2 2026. before we start that i just want to confirm and see if there's any sort of declarations or computer certain disclosures about this particular
[16:32] Speaker F (unidentified): item yes i'm rob quinton here i live four houses down from the applicant at 23 st lawrence street i know the neighborhood well the building had been on the site prior to its burning and [Speaker E (unidentified): demolition not] have any conflicts with regards to the owners of the building or interested in it at all i think i can be a fair and unbiased participant any questions or objections
[17:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Any questions or objections? No objections here. [Speaker A (unidentified): No objections. Excellent.] So for this item, the process will be, we're going to start with the presentation of the proposed plans. Then we'll move into clarifying questions from the board. Then we'll have public comment, board deliberations, and board vote. So we'll now start with the presentation of the plans.
[17:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Great. And I welcome that applicant to step up. I'll also pull up my brief two slides. Are you seeing that, Michael? Great. Okay. So, yes, before this evening is a public hearing for proposed new construction at 43 St. Lawrence Street. There's the site kind of generally indicated on an aerial of the peninsula. Here is a map of the Munjoy Hill historic district showing the location a little bit more in detail. As board members may recall or be aware, this site is along St. Lawrence Street, but at the corner of Gilbert Lane, which is a historic brand favorite street that is a public right of way. This is the site in its kind of current condition. The lot is vacant, as Member Whitney had alluded to. There was actually a contributing building here, which unfortunately burned down in a tragic fire, which then has made the site available now for this proposed development. And then just very briefly, I don't know if the African will also have some images, but this is one of the kind of main renderings that were provided in the workshop that the board held in August of this year. And so with that, I will stop my presentation and welcome the applicant to provide their presentation.
[19:28] Speaker E (unidentified): There we go. All right. Good evening. I
[20:45] Speaker D (unidentified): feel like I'm getting. OK, that's probably as good as I'm going to do, but thank you for your patience. So Ryan Senatore, the project architect, thank you for having us tonight. tonight. We're looking forward to presenting the project. I have Herbert Moore here with me tonight, the project owner and developer. And just to give you an update of kind of where what's happened since we last saw you, we had a few meetings with staff and some various discussions back and forth. So I think we've developed a design based on your comments at the last workshop as well as those subsequent meetings we've met with some neighbors and had a neighborhood meeting and made some design revisions as based on those that neighborhood feedback as well and then last week we had our public hearing with the planning board and had our project approved so we're looking forward to presenting the kind of revised design tonight I won't go through every slide because i think you've seen most of them at least once but maybe i'll just highlight kind of the revisions based on the last meeting we've had and at any time stop me and ask questions or however we you know things go on i'll just go through kind of the introductory slides some of the new information the floor plans are very similar to what they were before, some minor adjustments, which I'll talk more about in the 3D massing. So here's the facade on St. Lawrence Street. One of the revisions we made were to the center decks, which is more of a color tone change, so we revised that. Before, they were more of a charcoal color. We revised them to match the siding color, which is a white color on each side of it to kind of make those decks less prominent, which is one of the comments we heard last time at the meeting. You'll see we've kind of highlighted the base of the building and added stronger kind of first floor level, if you will, by creating a darker siding color and creating a strong kind of horizontal at that level. so you'll see that kind of carrying that brick around the corner and then into that darker gray siding so really highlighting that kind of base grounding element of the of the building which turns around the rear of the facade as well and you can see it as well on the gilbert's lane side lighting details section As part of the more recent request from the city, we've provided some more details on some of the elements. So I don't have time to digest those, but really kind of outlining how the building's put together, especially the details fronting the street and then streetscape. Here's an additional rendering that was requested, basically from Atlantic, so kind of showing how the building massing works along Gilbert's Lane from the rear side of the site. So we feel it's an appropriate scale and fits well into that rendering view. And then here's a rendering, more massing rendering, if you will, just due to the tree, the existing tree canopy, but kind of showing the massing and how it fits in with the street skid and then here's a revised visualization of the building you know some of the things we revised were moving the roof deck railing and edge back from the facade so you can i don't know if you remember when we saw about five minutes ago with that roof railing is much more recessed recessive from the street view as it was before so it's about four foot six fixed back from that roof edge and we added a projecting bay on Gilbert's Lane so as you can see here to really break up that facade and carry that rhythm of the front facade around so having a nice architectural element on that facade and it also provides a little bit of weather protection above that door below but we thought that was a nice pretty powerful design change as I mentioned before that you can see the gray siding on the first floor so really creating that strong base to the building you know one of the one of the neighbors concerns I probably show it in plan view but was having a fence on the you can't see in this rendering but adding a fence to protect car headlights into her property or their property so we've added a fence between the properties on the sidewalk line and then expressing the cap of the building a little a little more adding detail and see the section details but adding a multi trim piece freeze around the building to really emphasize the cap of the building and then further refining the detail of the projecting base of prior they were kind of a continuation of the lap siding around the building, but we decided to do a panel and got a trim detail for the projecting bays, which is kind of, it's a store kind of precedent in the neighborhood, so we thought that was successful. It's the same color as the body of the building, but really giving a different detail and highlighting them. And here's a rendering looking up the street, so kind of showing how all those pieces and parts relate street scheme and then I guess you can kind of see in this image the last comment which I mentioned a little bit before was kind of de-emphasizing that central bay and the decks a bit so we carried that the high roof eave straight across versus it bumping out like we had before to minimize that visual we pulled the front edge of those projecting decks back about six inches so they're a little more recessive and then changing their color to the white railing and trim edge to have it kind of blended the facade on each side. I think that kind of highlights the revisions we've made so I think at this point maybe open up the questions and comments. Thank you and of course if Herbert wants to say anything as well oh no that was nice the only the only small point on those front decks is they're they're actually set farther back than the canopy itself sometimes it's tough to see
[28:18] Speaker E (unidentified): from the from the elevation to what they're set back up almost can't be certainly farther back
[28:34] Speaker G (unidentified): great thank you so now we'll move into clarifying questions from the board have any questions to start yeah
[28:46] Speaker I (unidentified): i think you noted that the different sighting material on the window bays were a precedent in the neighborhood did you have example pictures of
[28:54] Speaker H (unidentified): where of like other precedents that pair from the house i don't have a good image
[29:03] Speaker D (unidentified): of it but that if you it's hard to see but the bays on the house in the adjacent neighbor does have a panel with frame details i don't know if it i don't have a grease a great scale here i guess yeah there's panels but if you look at the building on the right the second floor has kind of a panel and frame siding below the windows [Speaker E (unidentified): for others yeah] i guess the bay on the smaller structure two houses up has panels
[29:41] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you. Do
[29:48] Speaker G (unidentified): we have any other clarifying questions? I
[29:53] Speaker C (unidentified): have one about the bay on the Gilbert Lane side. Is that flush with the edge? It looks like a misrendering. The cornice line, does that plain follow straight down? Relatively. So it's not super deep. No. But it does give some articulations. Yeah. I guess how deep?
[30:15] Speaker E (unidentified): I think we had it at 18 inches.
[30:19] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it is. Do you have the section number? But
[30:27] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe it was at about 18 inches. Were
[30:48] Speaker C (unidentified): there any other material changes other than just the addition of the deep tampa?
[30:54] Speaker D (unidentified): No, I think the material palette is pretty similar.
[30:59] Speaker F (unidentified): Your applicant indicated that it was real brick, a structural brick on the lower bottom. Great. Yeah, four inch.
[31:11] Speaker A (unidentified): I had a question. What material is that band that caps the brick there?
[31:18] Speaker D (unidentified): It would be pre-finished fiber cement material, so like a hardy trim.
[31:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Oh. Yeah. Yeah, I think that's what we...
[31:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you have a close-up of that at all?
[31:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, so we call it a 1x10. 1x10 piece of trim. And it does have a slow trim cap on it. So that would match the siding material.
[31:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, got it. So that cap, as it wraps around the side that's opposite the Gilbert Street side, [Speaker E (unidentified): i] noticed that it just kind of stops abruptly where the where the brick is it doesn't keep going
[32:17] Speaker D (unidentified): it does the top in here the top the top cap doesn't but the one by ten will continue
[32:26] Speaker A (unidentified): oh i think on the rendering it doesn't show that okay yeah or if it did i just couldn't see it on
[32:32] Speaker D (unidentified): the render but that yeah the top one by ten will continue all the way back to the parking garage
[32:37] Speaker E (unidentified): awesome and
[32:40] Speaker A (unidentified): then on the other side too same thing yeah okay that's really all i had are
[32:51] Speaker G (unidentified): there any other clarifying questions let me move into public comment yeah
[33:00] Speaker B (unidentified): so if you would like to are you
[33:04] Speaker H (unidentified): here to offer comments on this item? No, I'm not here for this item in particular. I'm here just for the meeting and I don't have any comments.
[33:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, so those attending in the room did not have any comments and I don't think we have anyone else attending remotely, so I
[33:22] Speaker H (unidentified): think no comments to begin with. All right, so then we can move right into
[33:25] Speaker G (unidentified): the board deliberations. Anyone like to start? Sure, I'll start.
[33:35] Speaker F (unidentified): I would like to sort of speak to a trend in this historic neighborhood that we're seeing, which is the overall mass and scale of those new residences. Typically, these lots are not only 50 by 100 feet, and the residents that are there take up about half the lot, and the other half of the lot is left as green space, parking, and other potential uses. Who knows what's in the future? Also, the preponderance of homes in this neighborhood are with a two-story EVE. Yes, there are some with three stories. Yes, you can make a case for one being a four-story with an occupied lowest level. But overall, we're seeing an increase in mass and scale of the buildings that are infilling the neighborhood. And it's totally permitted by zoning in terms of height and setback and lot coverage. But it does run a little counter to the historic fabric, which is green space, residence, green space, residence, green space. It was a rhythm and a pattern that I think manifests itself all over the hill. It is part of both the livability of the hill and the charm and the scale of the hill. That being said, I see an African who's checked all the boxes and has obviously sailed to the planning board. So it's not a lot I can really say about it except an observation.
[35:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I agree with you, Rob. I think that this does kind of check all the boxes. I don't, nothing really jumps out at me in terms of scale, solids, voids, context. context I but I mean I do agree and I but the this board has already you know green light green lighted plenty of buildings just like this already so yeah I think it's a if it's a successful design it's nice what are the Florida floor Heights if you don't mind my asking I
[35:50] Speaker E (unidentified): I think we had 10, six, eight, nine, 10, six.
[35:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so it's like a nine foot ceiling height, roughly.
[36:00] Speaker E (unidentified): So it's a little under, yeah. Yeah,.
[36:06] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't really have any criticisms.
[36:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, no, I think that's the changes that have been made to this design based on the feedback that you received. this board have added positively to the design. I think the articulation especially of the front bays has really helped with making a more interesting facade and I also do think the side bay does help break up that massing given what Rob has said. I think this building fits into the neighborhood and the use of that base, essentially the base with the three floors and the strong corner slot. It's a good approach that works again to try to mitigate the scale in that context. And it is a pretty eclectic context. You've got small scale buildings, you've got three story, three and a half story, to the stories of different stylistic approaches. So I think that it can work [Speaker E (unidentified): and that would] support this application.
[37:40] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I'm also thinking along the same lines of the other board members. I think the changes that were made to set back the roof structures and railings help with the overall visual mass of the building, which I know was one of our concerns last time. and I think that was a successful change and I note that in the draft findings in fact all the standard or the staff has proposed that all the standards seem to have been met and I agree that going through the standards it seems like this design is consistent.
[38:21] Speaker G (unidentified): So I'm also in agreement that the updates you have created have definitely worked towards meeting those standard requirements overall very thoughtful about the design and have added some excellent design elements to it especially that bump out on the side and really thinking about transition around the building and then we have so I'm also in support of this so we do have the draft findings of facts I just want to check with everyone that you are in agreement with the way it is written I find that it does meet all the requirements, but if we have any suggested changes to that, [Speaker H (unidentified): that are uncomfortable] with the draft finding and the facts that are written.
[39:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Can I ask one more question? Sure. What's the overhang at the bay, at those bay bump outs from the topmost piece of fascia to the edge of the roof? roof it looks like pretty minimal. Yeah it's about four inches. Oh is it four inches? Okay.
[39:47] Speaker G (unidentified): Do we have any other questions or comments? I guess we could take a motion.
[40:01] Speaker I (unidentified): Yes I move to approve application HP-0089-2026 for new construction at 43 St. Lawrence Street on the basis of submitted documentation plans and specifications information provided in the staff memo and the attached findings by the historic preservation board as written that the project meets subsection 16.6.4 standards for review of additions and new construction
[40:33] Speaker E (unidentified): we
[40:37] Speaker G (unidentified): have a second okay great
[40:41] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah hillary bassett yes tessa cardi yes michael hutchins yes. Rob Whitten. Yes. And Valerie Pickwin-Gould. Yes. Motion carries, all present in favor.
[40:54] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, congratulations on your application, and thank you for all of your hard work.
[40:58] Speaker H (unidentified): That's definitely reflective of the time.
[41:02] Speaker D (unidentified): I really appreciate it.
[41:06] Speaker G (unidentified): All right, so under Section 6, next, we don't have any other workshops. Are there any other items of business, Mr. Hubbard? it nope not this evening okay so with that we could take a motion to close the meeting sure
[41:21] Speaker B (unidentified): and just note that the next meeting will be a little unusual because there'll be a site visit at 9 00 a.m on tuesday november 17th the day before the meeting and then there'll be regular meeting on wednesday at the 18th at 5 p.m where the item for the site visit will then be discussed so there'll be more guidance just on how that site doesn't work and then I'll post it for that I'd
[41:51] Speaker A (unidentified): like to make a motion to adjourn
[41:55] Speaker C (unidentified): so moved we're so seconded
[42:01] Speaker H (unidentified): right there you go alright have a good night
[42:14] Speaker G (unidentified): next agenda do we know how many items are on
[42:17] Speaker H (unidentified): besides just the one