Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, I can see we're live streaming. Are we set to go?
[0:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, we should be all set.
[0:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Andrew, are you we using a overflow room? Are we using an overflow room? Are we just in this room? No, we're not. Okay, all right, welcome to the planning board meeting for November 10th, 2026. This meeting is being held via Zoom and in person. Before we begin, I'd like to address some housekeeping issues regarding public comment. Any written comments received prior to this evening were made available to the board for their review. In order to provide public comment during the meeting this evening, it must be provided verbally. Members of the public attending the meeting remotely via phone or computer do not have speaking privileges when joining the meeting. In order to provide public comment, members of the public must indicate their interest in speaking at the appropriate time. If participating in the meeting with a computer, you'll use the raise hand feature to indicate your interest. This is turned on and off with the hand icon located at the bottom of your screen. Please make sure that you are logged into the meeting under your real name, not an alias or username, so that we can call on you properly. If you're listening to this meeting on a standard telephone and you'd like to offer a comment, you can indicate your interest by pressing star nine. In either case, you'll wait until you're called on. The moderator will ask you to unmute yourself. Once unmuted, please state your name and address. You'll have three minutes to provide your comment. At the end of the period, your microphone will be muted again. If you experience problem problems during the meeting, you can email planning at portlandmaine.gov, and we'll try to monitor the email and respond as appropriate. With that, Andrew, can we have a role? Yes, Mr. Chair. Everly Hulanick? Yeah. Austin Smith? Here.
[2:12] Speaker C (unidentified): David Self? Here. Nicholas Messina? Here. Eric Den? Here. Kelsey Robertson? Here. And Joe Zamboni?
[2:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Here. Thank you. We are starting off with a workshop today. But I did want to just take a straw poll quickly. It sounds like both Kelsey and I might be unavailable next week. And I know we will be having board meeting next week because it's a holiday month. I just wanted to see if anyone else will not be available because I want to see if we're going to have quorum. So I think five folks will still be available. Okay, great. So tonight we will do start with 92 Cassidy Point Drive. Hearts of Pine is the applicant. The Planning Board is holding a workshop to consider a zoning amendment application to rezone a portion of the parcel at 92 Cassidy Point Drive from Waterfront Port Development Zone, WPDZ, to B5 Urban Commercial Zone. The applicant is also seeking a text amendment to allow stadiums as a permitted use in the B5 zone to facilitate construction of a stadium. A project and plan summary are available for viewing on the city's CSS portal by referencing Plan ZN-003675-2026. For folks in the room, obviously, I am remote this evening, so our Vice Chair, Kelsey, will take care of all matters in the room. And with that, I'll pass it off to the city. Thanks.
[3:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Good evening, Chair Zamboni and members of the Board. Today we are hosting a second workshop for proposed MAF amendment for 92 Cassie Point and a proposed text amendment to permitted uses in the B-5 zone. The applicant on this proposed MAF and text amendment is Parts of Pine LLC, represented by Encorn Engineering. The subject property involved in this application is 92 Cassie Point Drive, which is currently zoned Waterfront Port Development Zone and has portions in the Shoreland Overlay Zone. The proposed MAF amendment would rezone a portion of the subject property to B-5 Urban Commercial. The proposed text amendment would add stadiums as a permitted use in the B5. For purposes of this review, the Planning Board is evaluating the proposed map and text amendments for consistency with the Comprehensive Plan to ultimately make a recommendation to City Council following a public unit. The subject property is located along the western waterfront and is approximately 23 acres in size. The site is currently improved with industrial terminal facilities including warehouse storage, open air coal pile, and marine related infrastructure. The site is accessed via Cassidy Point Drive from West Commercial Street and is in close proximity to the intersection of Four River Parkway and Veterans Memorial Bridge, which both provide direct access to Algae Lake. As mentioned previously, the subject property is currently zoned at WPBZ. The area within close proximity to the subject property spans a variety of different zones, including WPBZ, B5, B2B, IM, a contract zone for Northern Light Mercy Medical Campus, and an industrial contract zone. a portion of the site also falls within the shoreline overlay zone there are no proposed changes to the shoreline overlay zone as part of this application as a reminder to the board the applicant is proposing to rezone approximately 13 point acres of the subject property from wb pdz to b5 retaining approximately 9.2 acres on the southern and western edges as w the area currently mapped wpdz including the subject property encompasses 25 parcels totaling approximately 96 acres of land. The B-5 zone is currently mapped in areas including Paulson's Point, West Commercial Street, Marginal Way, Franklin Street, the Root Institute campus, and Martin Point Medical Campus. In addition to the proposed map amendment, the applicant is proposing a text amendment that would add stadiums as a permitted use in the B-5 zone in Table 6-C contained in Article 6 of the World Youth Code. The existing language in Article 6 permits stadiums open space zones as a conditional use only. Based on board feedback from the first workshop, staff are recommending supplemental use standards for stadiums in the B5, which would require stadiums to be located on a law of at least two acres in size. At the prior workshop, many of the public comment and board discussions centered around waterfront operations and economic impacts. Since that workshop, staff have coordinated with the city's waterfront coordinator, who is here with us and will be giving a presentation shortly. The applicant has also provided an economic impact study, which was included in the packet material. The board had also asked about the feasibility of a contract zone for this proposal. Staff had considered this, but state law requires that a contract zone establish rezoned areas that are consistent with the existing and permitted uses within the original zones. Because the permitted uses in the waterfront core development zone are narrow and do not currently include stadiums, the applicant would need a text amendment to the WPDZ to pursue a contract zone that meets these three state requirements. Since the prior workshop, staff have also provided the board with an initial comprehensive plan analysis. This analysis includes the goals and strategies from applicable policy guides within the comp plan, including environmental, waterfront, economy, recreation, and open space, transportation, and future land use. 48 written public comments have been received by the city since the initial workshop. The applicant has held their neighborhood meeting on August 27th, 2026. All public comment, including that from the prior workshop and this workshop, and the neighborhood meeting materials can be found in the provided packet. I will now pass it over to Heather Moretti, the City's Waterfront Coordinator, for her presentation.
[8:21] Speaker E (unidentified): My name is Heather Moretti. I am the Waterfront Coordinator with the City of Portland. I work in the Department of Economic Development, and I've been spending the past few weeks for your request to pull together some data on the Portland Pervert. We'll take a look at the existing economic data, the most recent economic impact study, which was done in 2020, as well as some specifics on operations today and the Western Waterfront. So first off, before we head into Portland's existing waterfront, I want to help everybody have the same baseline, have some context around the historic waterfront. A lot has happened here over the past 400 years. We've seen a lot of evolution along the waterfront in particular. From Portland's origin as Falmouth Neck in the 1600s, European cod trading set up on the peninsula. We head into the 1700s through the 1800s and Portland becomes a significant trading port. We export all of the goods that Maine will come to be known for. The fish, the lumber, the canned goods, we're even importing molasses and producing our own rum. We get into the mid 1800s and things get interesting because we become really important as far as rail goes. There's quite the explosion here in Portland and the northeast. We are strategically located for trade all across the country thanks to this rail. And for Canada in particular, we become their winter port. So they cannot access their ports during the winter. Portland becomes the go-to location for exporting Canadian grain to Europe and essentially serving as a hub of trade with international sailings every single day out of Portland to Europe and Canada. World War II does come to Portland. As I'm sure we all know, the harbor is protected. It's got deep water. It ends up being a great location to build nearly 300 liberty ships. Military personnel also set up on the Portland waterfront itself, and the population of greater Portland falls to over 30,000. The post-war decades see an industrial transition and Portland becomes crucial to the entire northeast region for petroleum imports. In the 80s we see renewed interest and investment into the fishing and seafood industries in particular after several condos were built on former working waterfront piers. And from the 70s through the 90s we see major efforts to clean up the harbor after decades of unmanaged industrial activity. Most recently global trade returned to Portland in 2013 through the partnership with Ameskip, an Icelandic shipping company, which was the first time in 30 years that Portland had, over 30 years, that Portland had direct transatlantic container service to Europe. So all of this has led us to modern day Portland and the current waterfront zoning. The balance we have is one of the most studied in North America as far as land use planning goes, but it was not always that way. In 1978, the federal government actually declared Portland's waterfront the most dilapidated on the east coast. That led to nine million dollars being invested particularly into the fishing infrastructure. And so the city releases a ball and issues a bond to revitalize it. We get from that we get the Portland fish pier, which is still in existence today, and the fish exchange, which opened in 86. Both are alive today and crucial to the ground fish industry across the state. The fish exchange sees 90 of the ground fish that landed in Maine. One year after the exchange opened the city ends up passing a five-year moratorium on all non-rain development in the waterfront after two condos on built are built on what was working worth property. And in the 90s the waterfront zone is created. As a result of all of this we then get the eastern central and western waterfront zones in the Mid-2000s, each with their own goals for particular uses. In 2008, we began the waterfront zoning planning process, which results in the 2010 waterfront overlay zone along Commercial Street. This allows for compatible non-marine uses, no hotels or residences, but non-marine that meet performance standards to facilitate marine uses on the piers. And all of that has gotten us to this, a resilient balance along the waterfront that we know today. Day. We've got ground level marine protection with a 45-55 split. This prioritizes water dependent and water adjacent uses while allowing for other compatible users. The 45-55 split indicates that 45% of waterfront zone property must be dedicated to marine dependent uses. I'm sorry, 55% of that. And the 45 can be other uses as long as they are compatible. Second, we've got the upper floor cross-subsidization. This is really important as we do allow for commercial and office unrelated marine activity to occupy space in the waterfront zone, and those rents can help fund costly pier repairs and waterfront infrastructure needs. All of this in all of the zones, however, must not interfere with any working waterfront operation. That is outlined in the land use planning code for each of the three zones. And you can see we've also got, of course, our hierarchy of uses pyramid here that clearly shows the priority. So what does this look like in practice? Along the waterfront, we've got a number of activities going on. We've got the Portland Fish Exchange still in operation today. It is one of the last remaining seafood auctions in the entire country. We have the Portland Net Yard. This is the only place in Portland where fishermen can haul their nets out and their equipment and make repairs, mend their nets. Nets. This is very hard to come by and it is very much in demand. We have a lot of fishing and bait infrastructure on our piers and wharves. Bait is its own fishery and is equally as important as a lot of the other well-known fisheries. There's a photo of Custom House Wharf. We had a fire there around Christmas time last year and it's being rebuilt. So the owners are very much in support of the working waterfront and they are rebuilding the fishermen's workshops that were burned down. You can see we've got all kinds of tour, as I'm sure you know, on the waterfront. We also do educational boat tours. This one shows new Mainers getting to learn more about the bay, and we really do have mixed use in action along the waterfront. The bottom left shows commercial vessels right next to office space and restaurants and a fish house. And then, of course, we've got operations that are imperative to a functional harbor, including ferry to the islands that are inhabited year-round, as well as our city fire boats and our police boats. So I want to start with, we're going to dive into the data here a bit. I'm starting with a study from 10 years ago by the Casco Bay Estuary Partnership. They took a look at Casco Bay as a habitat, as an estuary, to understand the contributions that it supports. 10 years ago they found that the ocean economy supported by Casco Bay is valued at over 700 million dollars. Getting into each individual sector, we'll start with the cruise industry. We had a report come out just last month, actually, from Visit Portland that illuminated some of the economic impacts from just last year, 2025. So you can see that 22 million dollars was the total estimated economic impact just for Portland from the cruise industry in 2025. The direct spending breaks down to about 6 million on food and beverage, 5 million on shopping, and about $8 million spent by cruise lines directly to the city through, by way of port fees and municipal taxes. You can see what that brought to the state, about $17 million to the state's GDP, over 300 local jobs were supported, and $2 million provided in state tax. We did have three maiden calls this year as well, so that's a shipmaking calling on Portland for the first time, which signals that there is continued interest in Portland as a destination. Nation. Moving on to the seafood economy, we are taking numbers here from the 2019 CMAID report. CMAID is the Seafood Economic Accelerator for Maine. And they took a look at Portland in particular, seafood economy. We can see that direct output totals $222 million. The total output, indirect and direct, is at over $311 million. This supports over 1,100 jobs. And you can see in the graph how that breaks out by sector. So seafood processing is really important here in Portland. We do quite a lot of it. There's a lot of value to be had there directly and indirectly. And on the right hand side, you'll see that we actually account for 32% of the seafood processing happening across the state. So aside from seafood processing, we're also an important destined hotspot for seafood wholesale and logistics, the seafood retail markets and restaurants, and of course the harvesting itself. So this is the most recent data we have, the 2020 economic impact study of the Portland waterfront done by ACOM. They identify 95 marine businesses, which do not include individual fishing vessels. Those are considered their own individual businesses, but they weren't included here. They found that these businesses generate over $650 million in revenue and provide for over 2,200 jobs. You'll see that the major contributors here are the marine transportation and port services sector as well as seafood manufacturing and wholesale. In total, the ACOM 2020 study estimated that $800 million is produced of economic output directly or indirectly from the Portland waterfront. This is the Portland side, not the Portland Harbor at large, and it's through a variety of different segments. So this graph shows you the top 10 of those contributors. We've got marine transportation and port services followed by seafood, followed by recreation, construction services, and professional services as the top ones. Another look here shows us the contributions by revenue on the left and employment on the right. You'll see that again a large portion of the pie there in terms of revenue is taken up by the marine transportation and port services as well as the seafood manufacturing wholesale and processing side of things. You'll notice both of them represent a large portion of the pie in employment as well as do retail and food and both. So for comparison we're looking at AECOM looked at non-marine businesses as well and you'll see that these businesses have about half the revenue impact of the marine businesses but they do employ double the people seeing as these are heavily service-based industries, your hotels, restaurants, breweries, bars. Okay, so to answer the question of what goes on in the waterfront, this is a list of all of the businesses along the Portland waterfront. It's the most recent inventory completed last month. This is the entire waterfront from Ocean Gateway to Cassidy Point. There are over 100 businesses and they represent a vast variety of sectors. Okay, we are going to look at investment on the waterfront next. This photo is taken from last winter's dredge project of the harbor which is a significant investment made by a number of partners. So the goal of this project is to restore depth, safety, and birthing capacity to the harbor by removing decades worth of sediment buildup, including contaminated sediment from historical industrial activities. So we had a lot of partners come together. This took over a decade to actually make happen. We've got the a state involved. We've got the city, both cities on either side of the harbor. The EPA brownfield program has been crucial and everybody kind of pitched in to make this $27 million project happen. At first we had to build a CAD cell. It's a confined aquatic disposal site, basically a large hole in the seafloor of the harbor to dispose of the contaminated material. It's the first CAD cell in the state of Maine and it's working beautifully because it's surrounded by marine clay, so it cannot, the material cannot disperse. The first season, which was completed last year, 25 through 26 winter, saw we did just primarily the Portland Harbor side of, Portland waterfront side of the harbor, and we dredged, we restored over 10,000 linear feet of birthing along the waterfront and pulled out 45,000 cubic yards or 4,500 dump trucks worth of material and relocated it to the cad cell. This is really important because in some slips, the material had not been dredged in 70 to 100 years and we had lost a lot of berthing. A lot of vessels were beginning to bottom out at low tide, not to mention the safety issues. So this year we'll be resuming dredging December 1st and it will primarily tackle the South Portland side of the harbor as well as the East End Beach. Speaking of berthing, I wanted to give a snapshot of the deep water berthing terminals in Portland Harbor. So deep water berthing refers specifically to specialized dock and port basins that have sufficient water depth to accommodate large and heavily laden commercial vessels, your tankers, your cruise ships, your cargo vessels. Typically they require at least 30 feet in depth and they've also got reinforced bulkheads and heavy-duty pilings that can handle these large vessels. We've got a number, as you can see on the visual here, a number of them across the harbor. They are designed for different uses. So the red ones indicate terminals that are designed to handle petroleum products. That infrastructure varies greatly from the cruise ship infrastructure. So these are all deepwater burning terminals across the harbor. I mentioned we did a harbor dredge project. These terminals dredge periodically, otherwise they would not be able to continue doing business. So these are the existing deepwater ones. We've got petroleum. We've got a couple cruise ship ones on the Portland side of the harbor. We've got the International Marine Terminal, our port. It's the only port in the state that can handle containers. And we've got Turner's Island as well as Merrill's Marine Terminal at Cassidy Point that handle bulk cargo. ago. Okay, now we're going to look more closely at the western waterfront, which is where we find Portland's waterfront for development zone. Like much of the waterfront, this area has seen a number of uses from a sugar factory to a rail yard to an energy facility and a ferry terminal. We can see how things have changed even in the past 20 years, but it has remained working. And where the ferry terminal is seen in this photo is now the International Marine Terminal. That's our port terminal, and there was a great deal of collaboration and investment in order to bring that to fruition. On that property today, we have the International Marine Terminal as our port. For context, container technology was launched in Boston in the 60s, but it didn't reach Portland until 1980. by then we had already lost our shipping route to europe and the northeast and were no longer seen as competitive amidst all that the main d.o.t developed a three-port strategy to promote the three primary ports in Maine, Portland, Searsport, and Eastport. Like I said, Portland's the only one that can handle containers in the state. In order to better enable the success of the port, we saw a transfer of ownership in 2009. So when that terminal was home to the Scotia Prince Ferry, it was owned by and operated by the city. The ownership transferred to the state in 2009, and the DOT also received a grant at that time to develop and build out port infrastructure needs. They've also spent additional funding investing in port infrastructure, including the 2023 freight road. About $3.5 million were spent on constructing the heavy haul road. It runs alongside the railroad, connecting the port property to Cassidy Point with the goal of streamlining efficiencies between those two properties and making it easy to move cargo. In 2013, we see the arrival of Ameskip, an Icelandic logistics partner that brought us major expansion to the port. So European service was restored for the first time in 30 years. They actually chose to make Portland their U.S. headquarters of operations, and it ended up leveraging another $40 million in investment for ongoing port improvements. So here are some numbers that kind of speak to the significance of the port. You can see that Portland Harbor, this is the harbor at large in the graph at the bottom, does approximately $4 billion worth of trade every single year. This is on both sides of the harbor. Compared to Searsport and Eastport, that is very significant. Now for the IMT in particular, it acts as the primary port of call for Ameskip, who provides direct transatlantic container service from New England to Atlantic Canada, Iceland, and broader Northern Europe. We've only seen the container throughput grow since Ameskip arrived here. Originally, 5,000 TEUs, essentially a container load, to over 40,000 to 50,000 each year. And they bring in everything from surgical equipment to seafood. And it gets dispersed across the entire country via the rail network and the highway system. We've also got cold storage infrastructure, which I'll touch on momentarily. That really opened up opportunity for our logistics network. It allows seafood, agriculture, food products, and other temp sensitive goods to be able to ship from Maine and not have to go to another state. We've got on dock rail connections at the port, and that really does connect us to the rest of the country for moving that freight across, not just the US, but also Canada, all of North America. So, this is looking at the IMT in particular. This is the International Marine Terminal. You can see on the left, we've got some numbers from a 2019 study that indicate the growth just from 2015 to 2018. We can see just about everything has doubled, the employment, the labor, the value-add and the output. On the right-hand side, we see the growth in port revenue. This is, again, just the IMT we're talking about, and while it's fluctuated, it has essentially doubled since in the past six five years. So the IMT has opportunity of course to do to do more trade, but we are limited by space. So I also want to know that the revenue we just saw, which is that approximately 3 million as of last year, is direct. So there is obviously indirect impacts from the port. Every just about every container that arrives at the port gets on a truck and goes elsewhere. We see some of those spillover effects locally. So the Portland pilots and longshoremen, you know, they've only seen their activity go up. The Portland pilots saw 620 vessel movements this year, and that was as of October, I believe. So that will certainly pass past years. And then the ILA, the International Longshoremen Association, has seen their hours worked and their number of working members go up over the years as Portland does more business. In order to expand trade opportunities, we built a cold storage facility. In 2022, the city rezoned Western Waterfront to allow for this to be built, and it was really in response to the need for cold storage. So a lot of cold storage facilities that exist around the region are at their capacity, and they are also logistically not the easiest. So the city rezoned to allow for this, and it opened in February 2025. Their monthly revenue is at approximately $240,000 a month. They've got 45 active customers. You can see on the right-hand column who those are, the largest by volume, fruit, seafood, bait, pharma, and other. They're at about 50% of their usable capacity today, with plans to increase to 75% of that next year and 100% over the next three years. Okay, so on the horizon, we can see several opportunities and limitations for the port, the IMT in particular, and the western waterfront. The IMT has a single berth, 785 feet in length. It can accommodate just one vessel at a time, and they have had to turn vessels away because of that. They are approximately a 14-acre property, and they're limited physically by the space. It's at capacity between warehousing on-site, equipment storage, the trucks that have to load and unload, and the cargo itself. Containers, as you can see, are currently stacked three to four high. Five is the legal max for empty containers, but that would require the purchase of a new about $12 million crane, and it would reach the height of Casco Bay Bridge. So as we think about the future of Maine's marine economy and Portland's role in it, we can study some interesting port examples from other parts of the world. Some Nordic ports are being looked at as an energy transition hub. So in the Port of Gothenburg in particular, they're looking at producing, storing, and distributing hydrogen-based fuels there. We've also got an interesting example just over the border in Halifax. They've got Peer, which is a living lab where companies can come and test their new technologies. They can utilize the port infrastructure. This is starting to happen increasingly, particularly in North America and the U.S., we've also got Arctic shipping on the horizon. So the U.S. Coast Guard has contracted 11 new Arctic security cutters, four of which are currently being built in Finland, which really does kind of indicate that there is an interest in utilizing Arctic crossings for trade. And then, of course, we've got growth of the blue economy. Everything from ocean technology, marine biotech, carbon capture and sequestration, aquaculture and seafood companies, this does include domestic as well as international firms, are really looking at Maine and Portland as a launching site for this new blue economy segment. So looking ahead, there are additional opportunities for the Western waterfront where we have marine industry and they're here. You can see there's a lot of opportunity from the federal government at this time for investment for funding and investment in the infrastructure. structure. We are also seeing state interest in the blue economy in particular. We had a blue economy week for the first time just at the end of September. There was a gubernatorial declaration that is now the first blue economy week and it will continue to be. And the state has created a center for the blue economy and their director took the helm this summer. And they've already released a report on just what those impacts are. And then, of course, we've got Senator King urging the Coast Guard and D.C. to look at Maine as a home port for those new Arctic security [Speaker F (unidentified): cutters. Finally,] I will leave you with a quote from the Island Institute. This is actually from 10 years ago, so we're working to get updated numbers next year. But they indicate that approximately 20 miles of working waterfront access remains on Maine's 5,300-mile coast. So hopefully that puts in perspective the significance of the remaining bits of working
[32:28] Speaker F (unidentified): waterfront thank you thank
[32:33] Speaker A (unidentified): you ms moretti that's a really great presentation we appreciate all the work that likely went into that anybody else from the city no
[32:45] Speaker C (unidentified): that's all staff said okay
[32:47] Speaker G (unidentified): go ahead can i ask a quick question just describe your you have a title but for the public it might be helpful to know what your what your role is you're a city employee and what your role with the waterfront coordinator?
[33:04] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, sure. As the waterfront coordinator, I am essentially the avenue between City Hall and the waterfront. So any concerns that are happening on the waterfront, I bring to City Hall and vice versa. Any new city initiatives that come from City Hall, I bring to the waterfront and I'm speaking as the voice of the waterfront.
[33:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Other clarifying questions? All right, let's go over to the petitioner applicant. Sorry, maybe
[33:40] Speaker C (unidentified): we got some slides we're going to pull up here but I'm Kevin Shoal, I'm president Hart to Pine. You met Jonathan and Gabe last time. I'm here to represent the club as we give you some updates since our last workshop. We've had a lot of time spent with a lot of good experts, and I'm thrilled to have learned a lot from that presentation. Thank you, Heather. I'm relatively new to Portland, been here a couple years, so being able to learn that much about the waterfront on this break. Yeah, since we last met, that. We've been moving ahead with our evaluation of the site, and we've been working to answer the questions that came up last time. So I'll summarize a little bit of it, but then we'll have some of the experts speak. You know, as we think about why we're doing this, what is this for, right? This is a club that has brought a lot of joy to people in Portland, people across Maine. You know, we're big believers that bringing people together, having connectedness, having places to commune, having recreational space is super important for the city's vitality and the city's well being. And we hear from people all the time, you know, finally there's something to do in Portland. And that feels a little rude. There's plenty of other things to do, but you know, there for some people this is, you know, their special place when they, when they come to our events and come to our games. And so You know, as we go through the submissions that you've had in the packet, we'll cover a little bit of site selection. You know, why are we planning to build a stadium? That casts a lot of information not in the packet on that. There's certainly a lot of good stuff as it relates to the community impact and the wellness Gabe talked through a lot of it last time. I don't want to, I don't want to belabor that point, but I do, you know, want to emphasize that, you know, we're here representing thousands of people who are excited about this club. And you know, we believe that it, that it meshes very well with the comprehensive plan, and Mary Kotz can talk about that a little bit as requested. And as promised last time, we have the, be a result of our economic study that Camoin Associates will walk through. We've got some more detail about the site history from the current owners of the site at Sprague. And then in the packet, although a little early in the process overall, there's some early information, some great information from our parking and traffic consultants. So yeah, we're here to bring joy and to sit through, you know, plenty of these meetings as many as we need to, because ultimately, you know, we're focused on the upland portion of this site. But since last time when we met on September 22nd, you know, Sprague has found a great partner, a neighbor of ours on this site to inherit the pier. So the deepwater pier there will be inhabited and purchased by McAllister Towing. And so we think it'd be kind of fun that there's, you know, this sort of potential there as it relates to things that McAllister can do that coincide with the site. But even on days when it's not really coinciding, having that tugboat activity, having that other warehousing activity and other things that they grow into in this space, we think will be a great use of that here. Here, and with that sort of sold off as we think about the upland portion of the site. Of course, we believe that having this stadium will be exciting, and not just for the men's Hearts of Pine team. But the other big update that we've had since the last time is that on October 15th we revealed the brand for our women's team, Main Wildness. So had a, had a great event and celebrating women's soccer and excited to bring this team to the market. At Fitzpatrick we're only able to play a short season, an amateur season. There's a, there's sort of a six game home season, but as we look ahead to Cassidy Point, as we look ahead to having a stadium that we can manage the events for year-round, you know that allows us the opportunity to create, you know, a fully professional women's soccer team that we can grow into as we grow into the site of Cassidy Point. So lots of good excitement from the city, from the community for that brand and for our Hearts of Pine club. You know, we've sold out every single game that we've had at fitzpatrick when we put tickets on sale they're gone in a minute or two the number of people on the wait list is 9100 something it's something 9135 or something i saw a little further today and that's on top of the 4000 people that are already season ticket members so even when we open a new stadium of you know roughly 10 000 seats there will still be a wait list of people trying to be season ticket members and it shows you that the power of what we're doing here and the feeling that we're giving as people come together for these games. On women's side we had 5,000 ticket deposits that went on sale, they were gone in an hour, and you know 4,500 of those converted into season tickets for next year at this project. So lots of demand, lots of, you know, need for how do we get more people to be able to experience this, how do we show this off, not just the people who live in Portland or the Portland area, but coming from all corners of Maine, coming from all corners of New England, people from around the world wondering what the heck am I hearing about this stuff in Portland, Maine, with, you know, how much this community loves this team. So we're excited about where we stand, but I think, you know, more than anything, as we've heard from people, as we've done the town halls, as we've talked to our fans, as we've, you know, really gotten deeper into the design process, you know, we're excited to make sure that there's a 365 day use here at this site, that this site instead of Coming over the bridge and no fencing this break energy logo right there and this and this sort of old industrial site being able to have a new front porch as people enter Portland and representing kind of a new era new vision for that part of the waterfront you know just like you have on the east side of the city and the eastern prom and there's people and they're and they're looking at the water and they're sitting and there's food trucks and things like that we want to bring something Similar to the west side and be able to access that and have the walking trails you know have a food hall there and something that people can enjoy all year round giving new access for recreation to this part of the waterfront and while still having the marine use and industrial use there at the at pier so you know this is kind of the vision of what we're building and you know happy to take questions later and always eager for input from people as to what more we can do with this site but You know I think now as we step through we'll want to hand it over to some of the experts and learn some more about what we can about the economic side of things from Camoin and then we'll move it on to the other
[41:04] Speaker H (unidentified): Two after that thank you great hi good afternoon everyone my name is Tom Duretsky I'm vice president director of research at Camoin Associates we're an economic development firm with a presence in Maine and he's done work nationally to do market analysis and industry analysis for real estate development in many locations in Maine and across the country we've been asked by our supply to prepare a market viability assessment of waterfront industrial we've all seen that study in the packet I'm Going to hit the highlights so the question that we're trying to answer with this study is there a strong market reason based on the attributes of the site and the demand for waterfront industrial sites in Portland Harbor to keep the Cassidy Pointe Pumpland reserved for waterfront industrial use. So as part of this study we reviewed the terminal's history, harbor industrial market trends, potential cargo and marine businesses, and other sites that might handle some of these needs. We spoke with operators and other market participants and reviewed available data. Essentially this was a market assessment to understand how market realities impact the future potential of the site for industrial use. I'll start with the main finding. The site has useful industrial features including rail, waterfront access, and a location near the international marine terminal. But the cargo business that supported the original terminal has changed, and the buildings and marine facilities would need investment for many future uses. We did not identify a specific industrial potential plan with customers and investment to sustain the whole upland portion of the site. So in our view, there's a reasonable economic case for allowing the same proposal on the upland while keeping a separate tier in green use. That doesn't mean that there's no industrial demand in Portland or that no future industrial use could work here, but rather the market evidence currently doesn't support an economic case for an industrial use of that portion of the site in the [Speaker I (unidentified): force as] has been presented. Parts of time proposed the stadium and related facilities on the upland portion of the site. The separate pier along with the retained work buildings would continue to serve commercial marine uses under the recent zoning and California identified peer operator. So there would be an industrial use attack point making use of the tier that does not require the [Speaker J (unidentified): full upland portion] to touch on a brief history of the site that Jim will spread will go into more detail after me. The terminal was built to serve cargo handling mills and other industries in Maine and northern New England. Those customers have changed. Mill closures reduced whole business, newsprint demand declined, and scrap exports moved increasingly through other ports. Vessel calls fell from roughly 30 to 40 per year in the early 2000s to fewer than 10 by 2020. Attempts to develop other business, including short-seed container shipping and wood fiber exports did not prove cost-effective. Even if new customers were found, the facility would need significant reinvestment and the business potential of the site would need to justify that cost. Renewed heavy cargo activity could also require substantial investment and that investment would need to be supported by the revenue from the new users. Jim will go into more of those details in a minute. This chart gives a broader picture zooming out to Portland Harbor as a whole. So total cargo fell from about 18 million short tons in 2010 to about 4 million in 2024. That large decline is mostly crude petroleum. Cargo other than crude changed also declined from about 4.5 million to about 3.9 million tons for a drop of about 13% over that period. And these figures represent the entire harbor, not just Cassie's Point,, but they show the changing economic backdrop of marine cargo in the greater Puyallup area. Now we'll look specifically at container activity in Portland Harbor. Container activity at the International Marine Terminal rose from about 12,000 TEs in 2015 to about 40,000 in 2025, so that was below the 2023 peak. Since about 2022, change in container activity has been relatively flat. These are different services from the bulk and break-bulk cargo that historically supported Cassidy Point. This is specifically containerized shipping. More containers at IMT could create a need for storage and logistics nearby, but it would also need a substantial increase in volume and revenue to justify any private investment in storage and logistics while we're seeing relatively little change in year-over-year container activity over the last few years. Ameskip reports about using about 130,000 square feet of warehouse space at Cassidy Point. The location near the IMT is useful because it does reduce handling and trucking costs. Ameskip also said that moving to more expensive buildings or hauling products farther could make some shipments uneconomic and reduce cargo. That is, of course, an important concern. And when we acknowledge, at the same time, the value of inexpensive existing warehouse space is not the same as a business case for building new facilities or otherwise reinvesting in the site. New warehouses would need enough customer revenue to cover construction and operations, and we did not identify a financially viable waterfront industrial reuse plan that would be best. In our study, we considered a range of cargo and industrial uses for the site in assessing future market potential. We looked at what it would take to bring a major cargo or industrial operation to Cafferty Point. For bulk and dry cargo, the challenge is finding enough business to pay for the facilities and keep them running. Sprague has been searching for a replacement for lost business for many years. For large cargo like wind components, the problem is the site itself. Space for staging components and the roads for moving them make the operation difficult here. For shipbuilding and marine manufacturing, any potential interests haven't translated into a specific operation with a workable layout or a plan to pay for specialized facilities. And for general manufacturing distribution, inland sites can often provide better truck access and room to expand. So those businesses would need a clear reason to pay for water complication. We also looked at marine uses that could occupy a smaller part of the site. The clearest example is McAllister's tugboat operation. It needs a place to tie up crew access and support space. That separate pier can serve that business with much less land than the old cargo terminal needed. Wind maintenance could also use a berth, but that business depends on projects and service contracts. Offices and parts storage can be inland. Seafood and aquaculture boats need to place the land their catch or harvest, certainly, but larger processing and distribution operations can often find better space and utilities inland. Marine research, a program that works with vessels or draws seawater main direct access but a lot of the lab and office work could happen elsewhere so taken together these uses show the pier certainly still matters we didn't so we didn't find a combination of operators and investment that would make industrial redevelopment of a full upland likely under current conditions when considering the increased cost and visits to springfield we also looked at other sites that could handle certain industrial needs there are several ways that Portland Harbor can continue to serve waterfront industrial businesses. Some uses may fit at other properties, including potential warehouse development in South Portland and some heavy cargo activity at Turner's Island. At Cassidy Point, the separate pier can continue serving commercial marine activity alongside the stadium. And the harbor's industrial needs and immediate market opportunities can be met across several sites. So to conclude, our assessment supports allowing the proposed stadium and related uses on the upland at Cafferty Point while preserving a separate pier for commercial marine activity. The central finding of the study is that the industrial business's property was supposed to support has fundamentally changed. The loss of its traditional cargo customers happened long before the stadium was proposed. Efforts to attract or place a business has not been successful and returning the property to substantial industrial use would require significant investments supported by customers willing and able to pay for it. And we looked at a wide range of potential industrial marine uses. There are industrial opportunities in Portland Harbor, but we didn't find a commercially viable plan for industrial redevelopment of the site that could support the investment required. And so that's the important distinction. Keeping the current zoning does preserve the possibility of future industrial use, but it does not create the demand or investment needed to make that use happen. And with that, you know, the stadium represents a practical way of moving forward for this property, and I'll turn it over to Jim to talk a little bit more about Spray's experience.
[50:35] Speaker G (unidentified): All right, and contrary to what you just heard, I won't spend a lot of time talking about the history of the site. I'd refer you back to my written testimony before the last meeting. Just giving you the story of this terminal was built 40 years ago for a very specific purpose, and that purpose has left. left. And I will mention it just quickly, though. There was some question at the end of the last meeting about the types of goods handled, some of the terminology. There's really two major categories of product that we handled there was dry bulk, the first. Of those, it started with scrap and coal. Coal is now gone. Scrap left quite a while ago and got consolidated in Boston. So the remaining dry bulk commodity is rock salt. And I'll actually show you some pictures of how that's handled what's happening when you leave here just look down you'll see some lights on that's actually a salt that's a lot floating right now at the terminal and then the other category of products handled there were what we call break bulk or heavy lift project cargo you can see that's actually newsprint sitting in the warehouse at one point in time newsprint is kind of like gasoline and the production of a newspaper happens all at a few Press houses, and it just has a different name on it when it comes out. So what happened is we supplied those press houses. So if you were reading the Wall Street Journal, the New York Post, a lot of local paper, it actually was originating from this warehouse. Bring the product in, the warehouses were climate controlled, so that the press house could call us today for what they wanted to run tomorrow night, and we would actually ship that out the next morning. It arrives, they run it right away. But if you let that paper dry up, it would break into production. It was a large part of our business. We had a cargo a month for 25 years. Unfortunately, you've all got PCs in front of you. Very few newsprint happens, and when it does happen, it's much smaller size and much shorter papers. And then the other major component was wood pulp being exported. A lot of it early on was exported to Europe. Eventually, with time, it started to be more exported to Asia. Asia. There was a trade war that started in 2016. Much like the newsprint, wood pulp went away very quickly. So most of the main wood pulp manufacturing facilities have closed down. There's only a couple left, and they mostly supply their own needs. None of that's being exported. And then project cargo, which is, you know, we did do one set of wind towers through Portland. We didn't do it at our terminal, we did it at the IMT working with the ILA. That was very early on in the in the wind utility wind market. Those are very small units compared to what they have now. You'd have much difficulty, and I'll talk a little bit about that when I talk about the things we've kind of looked at. So we saw this coming, you can see it on the graph, we've seen it coming for quite a few years. The last 10 years we've worked intensively, and I should mention that's what my group does. You know we have the energy side of spray i'm on what we call the material handling side we have a business development group. We participate in trade shows. We travel around the country and the world looking for other alternatives. One of the things that we spent a lot of time working on was wood biomass export, primarily wood pellets. We brought the biggest consumer of wood pellet in the world to Portland. They stood on our dock, looked at it as an alternative. But at the end of the day, when we looked at Portland and Searsport, is just much more functional towards closer to the wood basket. It has much better rail capability, and you want to deliver that product in rail. We still work with that manufacturer or that consumer. We think that they may come when they do actually need main wood pellets. When that happens, it's gonna happen in Searsport. We did have engineered designs for these two massive domes sitting on Cassidy Point and then an automatic shift loader to load it out, but it just doesn't make sense there compared to the alternative. And then we have been handling land-based wind components for over 20 years now. We started, we handled the first project, which was Mars Hill. we have a lot of experience in that the reality is you just need a massive amount of land to be able to do it and the other thing now is that in order to get the federal subsidies that you need to make these things viable it's got to be a u.s component so the majority of the product has to be made in the usa and so a lot of the stuff we handle in the seersport we actually bring in by rail not by vessel we offloaded rail we use seersport as a staging area we work with the with the developers who are building the projects much like we do with newsprint. We're delivering today for what they want to put up tomorrow, so they don't have to clear massive areas of land. But handling land wind from here would be extremely difficult. You just don't have the rights away and the amount of land to be able to handle the size of components, you know, that are grouped in size compared to the first ones. And then we've also spent a lot of time on ocean winds. State of Maine did as well. The state of Maine determined that in order to be in the ocean would market, they needed to build a new terminal on Sears Island. We think we have a competing vision in Sears Port. But at the end of the day, I refer you back to the state study, which shows that for real ocean wind handling, you need 65 to 100 acres. You don't have that at Cassidy Point. You don't have that in all of Portland. You don't have that in South Portland if you take over the land of the pipeline facility. And so the reality for ocean wind is all you could really do here is support. And I'll talk a little bit about the partner we chose for the dock because they're already doing support of a ocean wing. And then we also have spent a lot of time working on Blue Highway, used to be called short sea shipping. We actually ran a sea tipping barge operation for a year and a half maybe, loading them out through the IMT. And primarily it was wood pulp going into containers, going back to Asia. Containers that normally would have gone back empty anyways because the balance of trade is such that most stuff is coming in rather than going out. But unfortunately that same thing happened there, and now that wood pulp is gone. And at the end of the day we could not find enough product going back and forth to have it be viable. Now we haven't given up on that. There's actually a lot more effort lately on blue highway. There's a group that has opened up or purchased the rights to the facility where the fish market is in the Bronx. And what that group is hoping to do is start a blue highway along the East Coast or New England coast. So we thought, you know, it's a fish market, it's the biggest fish market in the, in the nation I believe, or at least in the East Coast. And so we've got fish exchange here, we've got a freezer warehouse here. We, the owner of that group came up bet with us, we introduced them to Chelsea because at the end of the day that's a container operation doesn't make sense to be done at cassie point other than you could actually handled the barge at Cassie so that you had an extra barge capability and towards that end again McAllister I'll talk about a little bit it's a perfect partner for that and we've had a lot of one-off manufacturing opportunities that we've looked at that just again make more sense this year's fourth with 145 acres there 's 100 acres nearby at the GAC facility that are tied to ours by rail. If you really want to make massive manufacturing capabilities, that's the place that it would make more sense. And by massive I meant we were actually looking at trying to attract people to be able to do ocean wind component manufacturing right here in Maine. So that still exists. And then I don't have it here, but on the warehousing side the issue with our warehouse is they weren't designed to handle heavy truck traffic going in and out onto the roads. And so we only have a few doors on each one. Even with IMSCIP using them today, you'll see in most days the trucks have backed up waiting to get to the docks. We only have two or three. If you go down to the Hannaford facility there's a hundred different doors for trucks, that's what you really need. And so we tried to attract warehousing and our buildings are just not designed in a way to be able to get into the domestic warehousing market. So we do have a plan we think to preserve everything we currently do and have the same Growth capacity as we currently have, and not impact the working waterfront directly. One of those is the dock, and maybe the easiest way is just to go through the next few slides on this. Repeats, so you know, we chose McAllister as the partner. You know McAllister from the tugboat operation that you see. In this, will allow them to be more efficient. So McAllister actually runs crew boats on the east coast. They work with the ocean wind developers, bringing out crews and bringing out supplies for the wind units that are out there in the water now, and they actually run a barge service, a short sea shipping version of a barge service, and they would be the perfect partner long-term if that golden fish market venture works out. So one of the things that happened to us is that at the end of the day, it was the barge that left us. They weren't getting enough capacity or enough volume. We think that with McAllister as your partner, they're going to be working much harder to try to get back and forth traffic. Don't know if it'll work, maybe a few years, but if that blue highway comes forward, that's what it is. And then on the warehouse side, what we're really doing for the rest of our business, businesses looking to consolidate it on the South Portland side. So first of all, what we've done is look at South Portland. We have many areas where there's tanks that are empty now. So all those white areas you see, those are occupied by empty tanks that are no longer needed, just because the market has changed so much. One example, there's actually going to be more squares to come, because one example is when you look at heating oil and diesel, heating oil, diesel, the same product. Any diesel can be used as the heating oil in your home. What happens is one is dyed red, and there was some residential announcement over that, and one isn't. And it was done by the IRS to be able to track the different taxes, to make sure nobody's cheating on taxes. So they've come up with a scheme that allows us to now, rather than have to keep two separate products in our tank, we can keep one clear product and dye it at the rack as we put it out into our customers' trucks. So if anything, we're going to see that we need less diesel fuel, heating, oil storage capabilities, and there'll be more areas. Areas, but we've identified over 16 acres in South Portland where we could do other projects, have other lay down, and that's, you know, replacing the 13 that are coming out on this side of the Harbor. And then as an example, in the next picture you can actually see where we propose the facility, you know, I'm skip is using about 130,000 or it's actually 120,000 in the two buildings that are coming down plus a little bit on the dock. So what we've done is we went back and we looked at trying a proposed facility, new built facility for them that could also be their headquarters, and we identified an area that is available for development there. It's right adjacent to a rail siding that hasn't been used in a lot of years, but it would allow them direct rail transport capability if they wanted to. The next slide I'll actually show you what that facility looks like. You know, we had engineered plans, we've we've met with them, we've made a proposal, we even then met with the main port authority, made that same proposal because it's not one of the issues that we heard from my skip is it's hard for them to commit for more than two years. So what would typically happen in this kind of environment, the ford authority would be the leasing agent, and then whoever their customer is within the terminal, they would sublease the warehousing space. And so we've presented that opportunity for a new build, very modern, nice looking, with a lot of truck bay doors as you can see, and both are still considering it, but we're not ready to know whether or not they're going to want to move forward with it. Then the last few slides just talk more about the last commodity, salt or bulk materials, and it's important to point out that before we bought PD Marrow in the early 2000s, we did salt in South Portland in the 1990s, and we'll we'll continue to do salt after this next year. You know, our plan is just to fall back there and to consolidate our resources on one location rather than trying to maintain two when two can't be sustained. And so I can show you the picture of how we did it. This is what's called a self-unloading bulk vessel. Those squares you see on the top of it, those rectangles, that's where product is originally poured into it. In this case, this is actually gypsum rock that goes to a wall board facility in the Portsmouth area. What that chip has is underneath and throughout the entire length of it has a reclaiming conveyor, a lifter conveyor, and then the product comes out. So it automatically offloads itself. That arm can extend depending on the vessel you have, two to three hundred fifty feet. And so it allows you, as long as you can get the vessel close enough, to do a direct offload into a hopper, which then you have trucks running down. That's what we used to do at South Portland. That's where we consolidated our operations. We said, okay, let's move all the bulk and break bulk to one facility and the liquid to the other, and that's the way we operated while it made sense to do that. So that's our immediate fallback option. That's what we plan to do, but we've also decided to go to the next one, look at a couple other options. This is our Newington, New Hampshire terminal, where we do a lot of bulk material, both gypsum and road salt. And what happens there is it's just so the vessel docking facility is so far from the land that a cell phone loader could not reach far enough to be able to use it. So this is a typical bulker. I like this picture because it shows you how simple a bulker is. It's essentially just five large holes in the middle of the vessel. They all get loaded up with the product. When the vessels arrive, we tie them up. Each hole has a crane that's digging out the product. That's what you can see down there right now. And in the top picture or the second hole down, you can almost see a little bit because it's actually a dozer working inside. Because part of the problem is that you need to try to get it to the middle where the person is digging. So there's just somebody spends all night and day going in circles pushing product towards the middle. But what we did there is we just installed hoppers and conveyor systems right on the dock, and then there's a central conveyor that brings it on to land. So that's an option we're looking at, working with engineering groups to see whether or not it makes sense. And then there's a third option that actually came out of these discussions. I don't know why we didn't think about it before, and that's the fact that the IMT could be doing the same thing we're doing now at Cassidy Point. They have the exact same kind of dock set up. All we would, if you go down our dock and see what's happening, you'll see that we have these two enormous hoppers that the crane operators are putting product in and trucks are going under the hopper. There's a hopper operator that's just turning it on and off based on when they fill it. When the truck's full, they shut it off and they keep going. There's no reason that can't happen at the IMT. The IMTs essentially occupy two days a week. A typical bulker would be four or five days a week. So we could get, and now it's not every week though, we'll maybe see eight vessels a year on a more typical year. So you could move that over. If that would require ILA participation, we're willing to do that. We've actually brought the first, the main port authority up to Searsport to watch an offload so they understand how it works. Today we had two different groups come in, or two different people come in from the ILA to look at our offload, and our intent is to move forward after this vessel to just try to figure out, you know, is the ILA willing to do the work. And then you heard earlier about the haul road. Currently what happens is you can see a balker working at our portland dock you'd normally follow that route and the product gets laid down in south portland the difference would be that it would instead come from all the way on the right it goes on the hall road so it never has to go on commercial street and then comes out at the exact same place and does the exact same route so there'd be no impact the traffic on commercial street from doing it this way that could start immediately so we're going to continue down that road with both the main board authority and the ila to see if they have a willingness to do this their desire to do this and then the last thing we used to do a lot of on our dock but we had to discontinue because the dock is just not in shape to be able to handle the heavy load primarily or especially the cranes that were needed to do this on the dock and you'll see on the bottom left that's actually currently happening that's a movement out of the j paper mill that those units have been coming down main highways and going to turner island and then he gets put on a barge and the key is Turner Island doesn't have the depth be able to have a big deep vessel but whether or not that products going to go on a barge or not on a large vessel depends on where it's going if it's going domestically then because of the Jones Act it's probably going to go on a barge there isn't there aren't large u.s. built Jones Act requires that a vessel moving product between two u.s. ports has to be u.s. built u.s. crew There are not a lot of Jones Act vessels, very few Jones Act vessels in existence. And so most product that moves between two U.S. ports moves on a barge. All that product can be moved going through Turner Island. That would be the norm. If something came in that had to go international, then it could go to Searsport or it can go to Eastport, both of which has happened in its time. And then on the right, you see those are units actually I think manufactured in Ditterberg. And we historically would load those on as well. When we had to downgrade our dock, we put them in contact with the project, and now they load that with food turners on well.
[1:07:58] Speaker C (unidentified): And what about the cold is gone? Yeah, I think for you know just as a reminder, right, the other big piece of the work that spray got operated at that site is holding coal, and I don't think there's many people in this room who want that to continue, and it's not allowed to continue. So I think you know, that was one of the last remaining things that will make sense to do at Cassidy Point and has now been legislated away. That it wouldn't talk history. I guess it's not history, yeah.
[1:08:30] Speaker K (unidentified): All right. Thanks, Jim. I'm going to be very brief to wrap this up, but you received a Mary Costigan, representing the team. I provided a letter regarding the comp plan. It's dated October 30th. Hopefully you took a look at that, just getting hit some kind of high points, and really talk to you about the lens through which you are tasked with reviewing this information, right? So really what you're, a lot of information, but at the end your recommendation will have a component as whether this proposal is to be considered. That's your analysis when you're looking at any zones changes, I'm sure, on this report, but as a reminder, the standard is whether zoning is pursuant to and consistent with the comprehensive plan. That is not an easy thing to interpret, so the law court has done that for you, and the law court has said that the, it has, it means that the rezoning is in basic harmony with the comprehensive plan. Admittedly it's a pretty low bar to be able to justify that zoning is consistent with the plan. Again, the law court also said the rezoning need not perfectly fulfill the goal, like each and every goal of the plan. You're not looking at that because inevitably you're going to find one goal that you're going to be like, oh this doesn't actually fulfill that goal. But you're looking at it as striking a reasonable balance among the various zoning goals. So as you're listening to this, you're listening, you know, a lot of this is waterfront focused obviously, because we're talking about the waterfront zone, but the comprehensive plan has a lot of parts and pieces to it. So I just encourage you to remember that as you're looking at this from a holistic perspective and the messaging of the comprehensive plan. This is a great example, which is not just an example, it's really a guiding tool of the comprehensive plan, which these are the vision themes, if you will, of the plan. And so this is where it all kind of comes out from. And I'm just going to quickly go through each of those very quickly. It's also in my letter. But this proposal to rezone the uplands of E5 and add stadium use to that zone really hits on each one of them. Equitable. You've heard us talk about the new Maine Wildness team and the fact that you know the women's team won't get as much available play at Fitzpatrick they need in order to elevate into professional league hopefully someday they need more time and space and equitable access to the field in terms of equity you know we've also talked to you about the fact that we really want to have an urban setting for the stadium that provides equity for folks who can walk, bike, take public transportation you don't need a car to get to the game sustainability so you know talking about the early setting also allows for multi-modal modes of transportation to get to this stadium and we're also proposing a cleaner site which is really going to be a great aspect of this pre-zoning dynamic if you've ever been to a hearts game you know that it is dynamic it is a vibrant and welcoming experience and certainly upholds that vision secure when the plan talks about secure is talking about investment in a Resilient economy and certainly an investment in this type of activity. Mixed use on the waterfront is supporting a resilient economy that can change with the times and the desires of the day. Authentic, so this section of the division talks about investing in the local economy, maintaining our character. It is also the aspect of the vision that talks about the watercraft, and we've talked about it a lot today. You know, there is a lot of discussion about the working waterfront, and I understand those comments and concerns. Again, we are proposing to rezone the uplink and retain the edge of the water front, the piers and the edge of the waterfront, all in WPDZ. And you know, when we're talking about the waterfront, yes, we're talking about the working waterfront, but a lot of this comprehensive plan is talking about public access to the waterfront, other uses of the waterfront. This proposed rezoning to allow some mixed uses on the on the waterfront, including marine uses, there are marine uses in the B5 as well. You know, it's it's opening to the public an area on commercial, on West Commercial Street or on Commercial Street on that end at all that has been closed off to the public for I think as long as anyone's been in this room. I don't know how long it goes back, but I don't know how long it's been to get down there. Finally connected, the rezoning and the upland will create the opportunity again for the public to access the waterfront, and we're hoping that it will also be connecting bike and pedestrian access and really get folks moving around. Great, so that's just one aspect. There's so much in that comp plan. I know there's a lot in the report, and just again, just remember that what we're talking about is basic harmony with the plan as a whole. So I just want you to keep that in mind. There are aspects of the plan, economy, recreation, open space, waterfront, and we talk about all of that in our application spirit. Finally, the COMP plan itself really is intended to be adaptable to changing economics. And I talked about it in my letter, but it's true. I mean, when this COMP when this COMP plan was drafted, and it started being drafted in 2017, or probably before that but in 2017 Gabe Poppin Johnson is the only one who knew that they were going to be really successful. Nobody knew about it. Nobody thought about it. Wasn't moving on the radar. And now we have it, you know. And I think it's a unique opportunity. I think, you know, all the information that you've heard today, I think leads us to a situation where we utilize this comp plan. We look at its adaptability and see that this proposal really does fall in direct harmony throughout the plan, and that is it really is
[1:15:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so that kind of concludes our prepared materials. You've got the packet as well. We look forward to public comment, and the hope would be that we provided everything needed to be able to advance to a hearing as soon as you think that it's ready for it. I know that there's a conversation of what we need to take place at the council level as well, and so we're going to continue working on our parking traffic study. We're continuing down the design process and the public feedback process, you know continuing to continuing to evaluate the economic side of things, but you know all things considered, we're sort of ready for a hearing, right? I
[1:15:49] Speaker A (unidentified): really appreciate the applicant's thorough presentation and from the city. So we're doing a workshop tonight, and we will obviously talk about hearing, but what I think we should do is I'll ask the board members if you have any preliminary questions you want to ask them, and then we should probably get into public comment. So any preliminary procedural questions for applicant or city? All right, so folks, if you're in the room and you can hear me, I'm passing this off to our Vice Chair, Kelsey. She is going to moderate the comment in the room and then folks online, I will take care of that after. So I do see a hand is up. We're not quite there yet. Online folks, we'll let Kelsey run the room first.
[1:16:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Great. So folks that want to speak in the room, please come up to the podium and state your name and address. You have three minutes for comment and Carter will let you know when there's 30 seconds left. And I just want to note that any comments submitted in writing prior to the meeting have been recorded in the record and read by the planning board as well so we can get going and welcome folks in the room
[1:17:02] Speaker J (unidentified): I have
[1:17:07] Speaker L (unidentified): no comment thank you hi my
[1:17:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Name is Vanessa Keeter, and myself and my partner Bryce of Lead on the Street Food Truck. I just want to remind the board that when you talk about the Harkapine and the Wild Lift and the team, it goes beyond just the team as an organization, as a business. There are 10 to 15 very small businesses like mine, we don't even have a brick and mortar, who benefit and rely on their organization and have been so welcomed and a part of it. We do everything from the Kennedy Park soccer day to every open house Harkapalooza, you name it, we're there, we're a part of it. So we will be going with them for sure, are whether it is a, you know, in the food hall and or still having the truck there, hopefully both, because the demand is there. We do over 220 orders per game. It represents more than a quarter of our entire annual business, and it's something that like I have personally worked for all three of the sports teams in the city, and what we're seeing there is just magic. So I just want to remind you and from there it trickled down even more back into the maritime. All of our seafood comes from upstate trucking, from, you know, we raise lots of funds from everybody. So, and that's something that we are able to offer. So, it really is something that follows it all the way through. So, when you're thinking about it, don't just think the one hard to find. Remember all the little small guys that are part of it, too.
[1:18:44] Speaker D (unidentified): The next person who would like to speak in the room.
[1:18:56] Speaker M (unidentified): Hello. My name is Peter Bissell. So I don't live in Portland, but I have two businesses here and employ a couple hundred. And I own property here. I own a 38-year circum place at Thompson's Point. So I just want to speak in favor of the proposal. It's actually really interesting to hear sort of the background on the working waterfront and the spray corporation's activity down there in particular. I don't really know much about that, but I do drive by the site almost every day and have for well over a decade at this point. It seems to me like a good use of the space. I do have some experience developing Thompson's Point from a sort of industrial site, former industrial site in decline, where the industry that it services sort of passed the site by into something better than it was before. forward i definitely see some parallels with this also that again as was outlined tonight the demand for access to witnessing these sports teams is through the roof and definitely think that town would benefit economically and culturally from you know allowing more people to get access to it 's been crazy what's happened over the last couple years and that combined with the fact that what seems to me again from a place of relative ignorance to seem that the most active part of this site that is tied into the working waterfront is going to remain seems kind of like a no-brainer, but maybe, you know, maybe that's an aggressive statement, but yeah, it seemed good to me. Definitely all for it, so I just wanted to state my support, you know. All right, I don't, good
[1:21:00] Speaker I (unidentified): evening. My name is Jack Humanek. I represent the International Law Charmers Association, it's members here in Portland, for an organization that has been incorporated and existed on Portland waterfront representing working people since 1880, and so we have a lot of history here, and rather than getting into a lot of, there's a lot of stuff that I would take issue with, but one of the things I think is that this is really the wrong format in which to be looking at this, and I and I say that because it is a very important issue and it's a bigger scope then I think what's being looked at here tonight this is not about one little parcel of land or one type of business it isn't working today it didn't work 20 years ago this is kind of a land use and a direction that was set in motion by the comprehensive plan as to how we wanted to see the Portland area developed, and particularly its waterfront. This process was, I mean, it's of course very serious now, was looked at deeply and extensively by the entire committee that was set up, not that long ago, but lay out the plan where you had the eastern waterfront, central waterfront, and then the western waterfront, they're they're all the, you know, waterfront zoning, but there are different things within each one of those subsections. You can't get into the real analysis of whether you want to train change direction and language policy on a Portland waterfront. In a format like this, there's no give and take, there's no questions, there's no information you can go out and get to come back with. And that takes time, because if you just look at one little issue, it's not about soccer, it's not about Hearts of Clients, it's about the direction of the land use to this area for the next 50, maybe 60 years, maybe longer, because when, particularly in this instance, where it's it's waterfront land. That doesn't go back. The economics don't allow you to say, well, okay, if that didn't work out, we'll re-change the zone back to waterfront use. One thing, if I quickly can say, the reason that I asked for a different process and that we set up, you table this, send it to the city council, set up a committee of stakeholders, business holders, interested parties, council members, planning board members, to get together and thoroughly debate this, because it's a much bigger issue than just one company and one little business. And if I could just close up, that statement was made earlier about there's 5,300 miles of coastline in Maine. Only 20 miles of it. 5,300 are in Morgan Waterfront use. So think about that and the importance of the decision this is. Others
[1:24:33] Speaker D (unidentified): in the room that would like to comment before we move on to online. And once we move on to online commenting, we'll kind of close commenting in the room. So now is your chance. If you want to come up to the podium, please do so. Hey, Joe, I'm not seeing anyone else in the room come up. So we can move to folks on the phone.
[1:24:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I would like to comment. Yeah, we've got one hand up. So folks online, again, you want to toggle the raise hand feature if you want to have a comment. If you happen to be on a phone, you're going to press star 9 and that will raise your hand. Make sure that you share your name. Make sure that your attendee name matches your name so that we can call on you. And just like in the ROM, you'll be told when there's 30 seconds left.
[1:25:35] Speaker B (unidentified): All right, Annie, you should be all set to unmute.
[1:25:38] Speaker N (unidentified): Awesome. Thank you very much. My name is Annie Simpson, and I do not live in Portland, but I partially own a business on the working waterfront in Portland. And I just wanted to say that I am absolutely in favor of the Heart of Pines doing a stadium like this. I do not feel that the working waterfront is the exact location that it should be. And the reason being is that we need all access to working waterfront. And I know it's been drilled down that the access will not be taken away and that there will still be access. However, it's not just access that we need. And I own a seafood company. It is also buildings around there. Being able to distribute the seafood, process the seafood, you know, we can't just take it off of a wharf and then drive it an hour inland because that's where a cheaper place is going to be. We need all of the access that we have, which includes the buildings that are around the working waterfront. And it is very hard to find any sort of business growth or anything that we currently have here in Portland. And we are struggling constantly with that, just being bought out by bigger companies and being pushed out. So it has been very difficult. And I just want it to be known that the location, I feel like, is probably not the best location so that we can still preserve the working waterfront here in Portland, but also if we can compromise in a different location and still have it, you know, close and walking and all of that, because I do agree this, the amount of people that it brings in and the sense of community and all of those things that absolutely stand for just not eliminating other a huge part of Maine's history Portland's waterfront or anything like that and we desperately need that space and it can absolutely be utilized for additional growth in the current businesses you know as a business owner I had no idea that space was even remotely available so I don't know about how much it's been, you know, discussed previously, but we have been in business for, we've owned it for about 16 years and been in business since the 90s. And so we've, we've had our own challenges as far as space and infrastructure and being able to grow. And if we are able, if we are able to have some additional space, like that area, then that would definitely help the waterfront thank
[1:28:21] Speaker B (unidentified): you herb you should be all set to unmute thank you hello everyone i'm
[1:28:30] Speaker O (unidentified): herb ivy i live off danforth street i've worked in town portland for several decades and as a west end resident i'm incredibly excited about the possibility of a hearts of pine stadium at Cassidy Point. This team has brought our city to life in a new way. If you have ever walked through Portland on a hearts match day, you know exactly what I'm talking about. That walk for us from Danforth Street to Fitzy has become a new ritual for our family. You see green jerseys everywhere and families walking together and kids with scarves and friends meeting up at restaurants and pubs and people spilling out into the sidewalks all heading in the same direction and there's this wonderful sense of anticipation and excitement and the whole city feels like it is part of something. And I now imagine bringing that same energy to Cassidy Point and imagine transforming a place that most Portland residents have never really had the opportunity to enjoy joy into a place where thousands of us can come together, not just on match day, but on every day. And that's one of the things I love about this proposal. It's not just a stadium surrounded by acres of parking somewhere outside the city. It's woven into the fabric of Portland itself. And I do appreciate that this vision recognizes the importance of the working waterfront. I love that the pier is going to be there. The working waterfront is an important part of who we are, but I gotta believe we can preserve the meaningful maritime activity while opening up these new opportunities for public access and community life and maintain, someone said it earlier in the presentation, that resilient balance that we have in Portland. Finally, I think the Hearts have shown us what, on any metric you want to look at, what they can do for our city. I've, I've been in Portland for 40 years. I have never seen anything like it. And now we have this opportunity to build on that success. And to me, that's not just a soccer stadium. That's Portland at its very best. It is time for a new life for Cassidy Point. And I look forward to that 25 minute walk, that new ritual that I have with my family and thousands of others as we walk through this city to the new stadium at Cassidy Point for the Hearts and the Wildness. Thank you all. Thank you.
[1:31:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Peter, you should be all set on mute.
[1:31:25] Speaker P (unidentified): Can you hear me? Yes. My name is Peter Morrill. I live on [street], and I just wanted to make a couple remarks in favor of the Hearts rezone at Cassidy Point, and I can't speak to the needs of the working waterfront, so I'm going to focus on myself as a fan and as a pedestrian in the city of Portland. One, those who know me know that I like to walk everywhere. I walk from the East End to Fitzpatrick on match day, and if it changes to Cassidy Point, I'll walk there too. And the, I mean, I tell people that I try to, try to, you know, emulate a European lifestyle in America, which is really hard to do in most cities besides, you know, Portland. And if you are a walker and you're showing someone around the city, you walk down, you know, from the East End to the Old Port, and then you get to Becky's Diner and that's kind of it. And so I think this stadium location, harkening back to the connectedness goal of the comprehensive plan, is a fabulous way to connect the central waterfront to the west waterfront. And then just another thing I wanted to mention is that, you know, this team has so much momentum that there's already people coming from all over the country and all over the world to see the team. And with this stadium proposal,, there will be people who come to see the stadium because it's going to be unlike anything else that we have. As someone mentioned, most stadiums, you go to MetLife in New York and it's just a parking lot in the middle of New Jersey. And there's really nothing, nice to see around it. And this one, it will stand out in a way that I can only compared to stadiums in Europe that have, you know, sort of this type of setting to watch as well. And yeah, just the last thing that I wanted to mention, I was involved in the hearings all the way back and one other great thing about this solution is that Portland High gets their field back for their exclusive use and all the other people that use that are able to.
[1:34:29] Speaker B (unidentified): Kevin, you should be all set for a meeting.
[1:34:36] Speaker Q (unidentified): Oh, can you hear me? Yeah. All right, great. My name is Kevin. I live on [street]. And I also can't speak to the working waterfront. I'm not somebody that works in the maritime industry, but I did want to just make a couple of points. I work in architectural graphic design, so I've had the chance over 15 years now to work on a lot of redevelopment and mixed use kind of neighborhood projects, and I've had the chance to see how those projects in other cities really can bring an area to life and really bring a lot to a city and a community. And it just feels like a huge opportunity here to see that in Portland and bring something like that to us. So, yeah, I can't speak to the exact upland use of a maritime site, but it seems like trading a coal pile for something like this that would be such an asset to the community is just a real no-brainer. So definitely in support and I hope you will also vote in support. Thanks. Thank
[1:35:44] Speaker D (unidentified): you, Kaylee. You should be
[1:35:48] Speaker R (unidentified): all set on mute. Hi everyone, can you hear me? Yes. Hi, my name is Kaylee. I grew up in South Portland. My dad has worked for the city of Portland for a long time as a firefighter. I no longer live in Portland, but I still feel a great attachment to the community. I am opposed to rezoning this property and building a stadium on it. I want to say that I think that what the Hearths of Pine are doing is fantastic. They're bringing a lot of energy to the city, and that's really, great. However, I do believe this property should remain entirely dedicated to working waterfront uses. It should be allowed to continue and evolve to serve the needs of the Port of Portland as these needs change, especially as sea levels rise and our shorelines change, preserving every bit of working waterfront that we have is going to become increasingly important. I'm glad that an earlier presentation brought up the Island Institute statistic that approximately 20 miles of working waterfront access remain along Maine's 5,300-mile coastline. I work for a nonprofit that is dedicated to preserving working waterfronts in Maine and supporting coastal communities. And I can tell you with certainty that number has in fact declined to less than 20 miles of working waterfront. So it would be a shame for Portland to rezone this property and contribute further to the loss of the working waterfront. And I also think that it would be a shame for the Hearts of Pine to be part of that loss, considering their perceived dedication to reflecting the community in Portland and Maine as a large. So thank you.
[1:37:27] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you for your comment.
[1:37:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Kelsey, can I make an announcement real quick? Yeah. Guest services has just informed us that some folks are parked in loading zone out, I believe on Myrtle Street, and if you are parked on in a loading zone can you please move your car? You'll be towed. I'm not sure if it's relevant to anyone in this room, just wanted to make that announcement.
[1:37:47] Speaker J (unidentified): Thank you. Apologize. Continue. Kevin, you should be all set to unmute.
[1:37:51] Speaker I (unidentified): Mute? Yeah.
[1:37:53] Speaker F (unidentified): I think Kevin already gave a comment.
[1:37:59] Speaker B (unidentified): Sebastian, you should be all set to unmute.
[1:38:07] Speaker S (unidentified): Hey, y'all. Can you guys hear me? Yeah. Awesome. Thanks so much. My name is Sebastian Pettit. I am not a current Portland resident. I have been several times over the last decade. I've also currently worked two jobs and study in the Portland area. I wanted to speak tonight in support of this measure and in support of Hearts of Pine. Apart away from Hearts of Pine, I'm one of the co-chairs of Deergo Union, the supporters group of the club. Our main focus is growing the main soccer community, though number one is direct support of Hearts of Pine. We do other things such as going to support other local soccer teams and soon to be Maine Wildness. We did some supportive Maine footy this summer as well and just really wanted to speak about the growth of community over the last couple of years away from what hearts are doing fantastically because of it. We've amassed a community of about 1,200 to 1,300 soccer fans, people who really enjoy the community that's grown over the sport of soccer in the last five years, and a lot of really great stuff has come from this. There's also two other fantastic supporters groups, the Lightkeepers and Halyard, who are predominantly focused on Maine Wildness coming next year. These people in these communities have grown because of this club and because of the things in this city apart from you know Cassidy Point City improving quality of life. I really don't think that the city has to choose between a working waterfront and a stadium, you know. I think that there's a lot of room to share and I think that the if you look back at how things have gone with the Portland high school teams and Fitzpatrick and how that usage has remained there and how word has been kept i think that you know a lot of the same points that the club are sharing in their presentation to you guys kind of show that this is possible and without taking much of anyone else's time this evening I just wanted to speak in a support of a yes vote. Thank you guys for your time, appreciate it. Thank you folks.
[1:40:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Online I don't see any more hands so this is your last chance for comment tonight. For folks listening that did not comment this is probably not your last chance to make a comment i
[1:40:41] Speaker B (unidentified): see two hands going up. Kreml you should be all set to unmute. Grandma we can't hear at the moment you should be all set to mute i
[1:41:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Still can't hear you at the moment. Yeah, it says you are unmuted but we can't hear you and your microphone is not picking up any audio. So we'll go to the next one. We'll try you again.
[1:41:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Carl, you should be also on mute. Hello.
[1:41:26] Speaker T (unidentified): Can you hear me? I can. Hi, my name is Dr. Cara Peruccio and I, well, I'm a Bangor resident. I spend many weekends and days throughout the year in Portland, first as a Hearts of Pine season ticket holder and now as a season ticket holder for the Maine Wildness, and I'm the president of one of the supporters groups for Maine Wildness, the Light Keepers, and I'm speaking in support of the Cassidy Point Stadium because as I'm sure many folks have mentioned tonight, we really need a larger space for building. this community and I think it brings many benefits to the city of Portland again I'm not a resident but I'm someone who spends a lot of time down there and in the Portland adjacent area One thing that's very important for me is, as the president of one of the main Wilderness supporters groups, is that we have the chance to elevate women's soccer on the global scale. Dale. The USLW League is pre-professional. It supports, or the players will be mostly college students. And so the opportunity that we could have players from UMaine, Colby, who's headed to the Division III National Championship tournament, that we could have players from around the country wanting to come be in Portland, and then potentially even move here if their soccer careers don't progress beyond the USLW or college. The Cassidy Point proposal would, I think, have us, it's at 11,000 seats if I'm not mistaken, and that's currently larger than the planned stadium for the Boston Legacy, the region's. Only NWSL pro soccer team, and so I think it would bring in not only giving an opportunity for new young people to experience Portland, to experience Maine, but also bringing a lot more tourism that's invested in sports. It's impossible for fans to get tickets day of or even when single game tickets go on sale, so I just think about the number of people who would purchase tickets, purchase merch, come to restaurants, also explore for Portland and see how amazing of a city it is. 30 seconds. Oh wow, okay. And then the last thing, my mother-in-law for lack of a better term sent me this note earlier about what she would say, and she said that as the holidays approach, I hope the planning board will think of approval of the stadium as a gift to Portland instead of finding the existing coal pile in our proverbial stockings. So I think she said it better than I could. So I would encourage you to support the efforts to build Cassidy Point Stadium and really transform our community for the better and for all soccer fans. Thank you.
[1:44:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Not seeing any hands or a hand go back up. Last chance online or on the [Speaker G (unidentified): telephone, okay.] I'm going to close the public portion again for the workshop and open it up to board members for questions, comments, thoughts as we think about next steps here. I
[1:45:15] Speaker G (unidentified): think this is, at least for me, I looked at this as what information could the council want to have in front of them because ultimately the council makes the decision. You know, there's a path, it's one way or going this way or going that way, and they're going to have a choice to make, and both choices are probably rational and reasonable. So it all depends on vision and what you value. So I think this is helpful because it helps with the economic piece of what's working, what is, what's working, what may not be working, what's out there, and I guess I just had a question. So the main port authority is out there as well as an entity. And so they don't have to weigh in on anything. I'd be interested to know their kind of perspective on the future of this site. I mean, you're losing a de-birthing facility. I mean, the report we got from the applicant identifies some of the strengths of the site, but the brokers and the person doing the report is not optimistic about the foreseeable future for the site for various reasons. We have some more optimism from some of the things you observed in your report. And that's good for the council to have that. There's no doubt that the applicant's proposal and the vacuum is wonderful for the city. I mean, there's no doubt about that. I mean, we're blessed to be in a city with something like that is rising up from the surface and being successful, so I mean, there's no issue there. It's just a tough decision between, you know, taking out of service a site. Are you mindful that the folks may still, and you know, how does that coincide with whatever vision the members of the council now in terms of Portland evolving? So that, I guess, I thinking about it in terms of information for the council to have, that would be a piece to have as well. And the only other thing I thought was the one thing I think maybe for the public hearing that I had out there was there's certainly a level of state and federal money that's gone into development, creating development opportunities in this area. And when I read the report, what I found lacking in the report was a lack of recognition of the contributions when the opportunity has arisen, whether it was money, you know, you look at the various grants, federal money that's come in when there was a proposal for extending the rail line for the cold storage facility. Facility. It's been kind of, I view the working waterfront to be a mixture of not just private enterprise over the years, but clearly a mixture of state and federal money, whether it's dredging, whether all the improvements that have occurred. And, you know, when I first came to Portland, it was, you had a lot of fishing boats coming in. I mean, you know, it was a fishing fleet. And that's gone mostly. And then you evolve to cargo and it evolves. And so I guess when I read the report, I guess I missed my initial observation. It was very helpful to have. I just didn't see the wading into the evaluation, the degree in the past of state and federal involvement in contributing to the next evolution, perhaps. And maybe there is no evolution. I mean, at some point you evolve or die. And I think I listened very well to what you had to say. So I'm not discounting any of that. I'm just giving some feedback. And you know ultimately, you know, so I guess my feedback is it'd be nice if they don't have to, but it'd be an ideal world to be nice to hear from the Port Authority as well, some thoughts. I mean, they're looking at the entire harbor operations of the harbor, things that are going on. They're mindful of investments that have been made in the harbor. And you know, if at the public hearing, I appreciate everything you had to say. I think was really helpful. I guess the piece I wish I had a little bit more on was do you not you don't have to answer it now do you not see that level of contributions continuing is it is it is a project dependent unless something springs up it ain't going to happen I don't know you don't have to answer that now but that was just the kind of I really enjoyed it was very helpful but that was a little piece that was missing there and then you know we will we'll have a public hearing but i'm just looking at it from when this goes to the council when you put together What's excellent about the council, what you put together, I think is excellent for council. It's a choice, and you know, clearly under the comp plan you can decide anything. I mean, and we know from recent experience the council doesn't, you know, that we give them information whether it's for the live or the art museum, and they kick it around and they make their decision. And so we do the best we can to give them good information, and it does have thermifications, and you are taking something out of circulation partly, and you know, but at the same time, you know, maybe it's time, and that's the question. So that's more of a kind of an observation. I don't have any specific
[1:50:48] Speaker D (unidentified): sort of questions. The Port Authority did submit a comment yesterday, a letter. It might not have, yeah, I mean, they were against the zoning change. It might not have had some of the specific information you were looking for in terms of future and government involvement, but they did
[1:51:06] Speaker C (unidentified): have a little bit of comment, I think, from Jim's side, you know. He's, you've talked to the Port
[1:51:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Authority over the years many times. We work closer to the Port Authority. We've traveled the trade shows at the fort authority. Federal money gets routed mostly to the state-owned facility, so we haven't used this federal money in our facility. That the dragons, we've got to pay to dredge our own earn. We did think at one point in time we had gotten part of a grant to fix up one of the two warehouses, but at the end of the day the cost overrun on the other work that was going to happen if the IMG was so high that one of you thought was coming. I said that I was staying at
[1:51:46] Speaker C (unidentified): the end of the evening. That's all the reality of running your monitor, and I think they work closely with us. We tried to develop, yeah, I think a perfect setting for the public hearing for Chelsea to be able to speak to that. I think, you know, our conversations at the state level would suggest that the state's very aware of that plot of land and very aware of how it could tie into the work that there's not money, you know, that anybody wants to allocate towards, you know, securing that piece of land, especially when the existing facilities are not operating at capacity. And, you know, so I think it's helpful for people to actually speak to that themselves rather than my hearsay. But, you know, our sense is, yeah, they wish that the economic mentality was such that it was a no brainer for the court to hold on to extra land and grab extra land. But the reality is, you know, they've had opportunities to buy land and they
[1:52:43] Speaker G (unidentified): do nothing. We didn't meet with Commissioner Bando 2022 on this topic when we were first thinking that maybe we have to sell it. Is they didn't have the money, you know, potentially maybe, but something could happen, but it didn't happen. I
[1:53:01] Speaker U (unidentified): think the thing I'm kind of struggling with is, yeah, my heart's on one side. No, I don't think anybody's disputing that you're doing great things in this town. We've kind of risen out of nowhere in a way that I haven't seen before. But on the other side, you have the working waterfront that is really highlighting a scarcity of resource 20 miles or less than 20 miles here in the middle coastline. The overlap is the question of whether there is economic vitality of that site, and I feel like I get very different things from the two reports. So we have like a scarcity of space, increasing revenues, but also decreasing cargo volume. So those are, those are conflicting things that are addressing the only point of overlap for this project. Like there's nobody on the working waterfront that is against the hearts. They're in support of water. So I feel like there's not, I don't know, I find the information challenging and contradictory. I
[1:54:07] Speaker C (unidentified): had some of the same thoughts actually seeing some of it myself, although I was thinking a lot about how there's a slide from 2016 that talks about this 900, whatever the numbers were, like large dynamic impact of the waterfront, and like 70 of it was tourism and recreation. And so I think you think about what people now are looking for as Portland residents and what we're looking for in terms of the vitality of people coming in from Bangor or from wherever, like that tourism and recreation element is actually a big part of what the waterfront can be. And so when we think about the scarcity of what land is allocated to the working waterfront, first of all, I'm not suggesting any of it goes away. The pier will be part of the working waterfront. Second of all, we're going to be working there, too. So I don't want to diminish, like, how do we define what work is the right type of work for the waterfront? But, you know, having the Tugboat Company, having McAllister there at the pier and having us in the outland is the hope to find the right harmony in that dilemma, which is how do both happen there? If SPRAIP can solve all the economic things with no impact to the overall general port, we add a community asset and allow for that period of stay in maritime use. That's the hope, is that works well for everybody, and we'll see what the council has to say.
[1:55:35] Speaker G (unidentified): We think McAllister is a fantastic partner for the things we haven't been able to identify. We have worked hard to find every opportunity we could for something else to happen there.
New Business
[1:55:46] Speaker U (unidentified): I think that's the other the other thing that I'm struggling with is there hasn't that much time between clearing the coal piles and finding a new business for the space and so I feel like there's not there hasn't been a ton of time for them for the market or demand to adjust to the fact that it's not like a remediation site.
[1:56:08] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah I mean a coal pile is an acre to an acre and a half out of the 14 acres i mean it was the biggest contributor financially but it's a small piece of the rest of the property nobody we didn't run into anybody who said we don't want to be
[1:56:22] Speaker C (unidentified): there because we don't want to be next to the coal mine okay i'll just add in regards to the port
[1:56:28] Speaker E (unidentified): authority they i don't want to speak for them and i'm hoping that the comments submitted from the last workshop and this workshop will help answer the question but there is interest from the court authority and the state for this property. They, have reached out to city leadership. There's interest, there's nothing that's happened yet from it. But there's interest on behalf of, their, you know, operations. And the one other thing that I'll agree with is some of the information may seem conflicting. And I think it's important to think about, you know, Sprague Operations and their business, I don't doubt that their business model is facing challenges. But that doesn't necessarily mean that's representative of the full harbor and the full port. And, you know, it really is, yes, there's a lot of revenue being generated from tourism activities. And, you know, that's kind of the question at hand. It's not, you guys know this, it's not coal pile versus parts of pine. It's, you know, whatever other future opportunities. And, you know, somebody said it earlier, do we want to be a tourism city or do we want to have more of this waterfront balance? Do we want to retain the particular zones for their particular uses? That's what's at hand.
[1:57:46] Speaker U (unidentified): One more note on the co-op, I felt like in the last workshop, it was kind of highlighted as being kind of a key problem with the site, but that's different than the problem for the residents. Incident, yeah, key problem in the world with finding a buyer site, that was what I
[1:58:05] Speaker G (unidentified): took away. So the coal sits on a compact concrete layer, will not be easy, not be hard to clean that
[1:58:14] Speaker C (unidentified): cola. Okay, but I'm just like, it was just that was the only thing keeping enough financial, by financial, by adobe, and then it was legislated away. Oh, I understand. Okay, David
[1:58:29] Speaker V (unidentified): and the last workshop, at the end of the workshop he introduced the concept of the contract zone, and that really caught my attention because it would allow us to control that. We could specifically forbid hotel, residential, we could limit the amount of commercial space, and it would be for stadium use only. And this whole conversation about the zoning change absence Hearts of Pine, no one supported the change, they supported specifically because of Hearts of Pine in the stadium. And as David pointed out, we make this zone change, if something should happen, we have allowed, we've introduced hotels and residences and condominiums in a place that was really precious to us. We're making this argument specifically for the Hearts of Crime. If we choose to support this, and I guess Kevin, I'm going back to you, is there another method? Could we change this to another zone such as open recreational specific or stadium so that only a stadium could be built there and it would limit other options? Yeah, that's actually a really interesting concept in terms of if you
[1:59:42] Speaker C (unidentified): would consider instead of the B5, the open space recreation zone. I think that's something that our staff can take a harder look at in terms of what are some of the other auxiliary uses that would be associated with the stadium to ensure that those would be permitted in that open space zone. So that may be something that could be on the table, and I want to speak on behalf of the applicant applying for this, but that could be an option. The other option could be pivoting to a contract zone. I know we Outlined what that would take again. We're not requiring the applicant to go that direction, but there are some avenues that could probably put some restrictions on what types of uses could be introduced and trying to eliminate some parts of that. Thank you.
[2:00:21] Speaker K (unidentified): So the typically and Taylor hits on this on her slides, but a contract zone has a different standard than just the result. So for a contract zone has to be in addition to the comp plan has
[2:00:38] Speaker J (unidentified): has to be consistent with existing in that zone.
[2:00:42] Speaker K (unidentified): So the contract zone is kind of an overlay of the underlying WPDV. And WPDV and stadiums don't match. So it would be very difficult to do that there. One thing that I thought about, because I know that there are concerns that you've expressed, like I've heard people say, well, if the stadium doesn't even happen, what are we going to do? do. It could be, this is a very easy geographic location to, if you were to have a B5, you could have certain uses in that B5, you went down that list, hotel, for example, and you could put in the column and have no hotels on this side of Commercial Street. Like you could easily do that and just eliminate certain uses because there are ancillary uses that Kevin talked about that would be, you know, there's other building space there. There would be an indoor recreation center. There's another building for other uses. It's possible that there would be, you know, a marine office space. Who knows? But, you know, there's other opportunities on that site. I wouldn't want to just say this is open space [Speaker J (unidentified): and eliminate stuff.] I think it's a better exercise to go through to say what do you not absolutely not want there and then you could eliminate it that way. Thank you.
[2:02:04] Speaker V (unidentified): I was going to apply the same issue. I mean, it seems like we need some way to narrow this up and really tie it to the Hearts of Pine stadium. There's a lot of permitted uses in B5 that if that was the end product, you know, it has a not nearly as clear cases alignment with the comp plan as parts of Pine Stadium specifically. And I heard in public testimony people travel with great distance from Bangor. I know there could be pressure to accommodate visiting teams. It seems like a natural like to have a hotel
[2:02:33] Speaker C (unidentified): within the site. There's actually, you know, we don't want a hotel. There's no real ability to build a hotel because of the flight path. But I do agree with your premise. I mean, we want to stay with Mary. I don't want anything else there. It sounds like everybody else. So I think you know Mary's been thinking about this a lot. We've talked about this a lot. What is the right way to narrow it so that's the right question I guess. I don't know, I don't know if there's a you know council guiding that or if that's a prior council. I think a part of a recommendation
[2:03:12] Speaker V (unidentified): part of the recommendation I think our staff, we have to coordinate with the applicant following
[2:03:16] Speaker C (unidentified): this meeting but I think you know as the report outlined to the contracts and while it would be a slight pivot and I'm not advocating for that if you need to have discussions I just want to also alleviate that it's not as drastic as it may sound either in terms of for the board if that was something the applicant decided to go with that was I don't think simply but it would be a change to the purpose statement which is already addressing not working water for an industrial uses but also the open space recreation component they would have to look at. We would have to look at doesn't incorporate things like stadiums or entertainment in that sense and then you would have that use as conditional so be very similar or just take a different approach. I just wanted to make sure to clarify that the board is aware but those are some of the things that we discussed with the applicant in addition to what Mary Costigan
[2:04:01] Speaker D (unidentified): mentioned about the B5 well in the WPDZ zone doesn't I mean the B5 zone doesn't allow for some marine adjacent uses that the WPDZ does and I don't know any of those would come up but when you talk about ancillary buildings on the site, they get switched to B5. There's some marine usages that are not allowed in B5. That would limit those adjacent uses being a part of the overall
[2:04:31] Speaker K (unidentified): new read-along.
[2:04:34] Speaker U (unidentified): And I brought up that last workshop about the fact that you know stadium stadia are allowed in the OSR. So like that seems to make more sense to me as a rezone versus to rezone the B5 and having stadium as a use but I think I also want to voice my support of working more on contract zones or contract zones for this if it were to go forward. I think that the statute says establish rezoned areas that are consistent with the existing permanent uses within the original zones and that is ambiguous to me but there are more trends you can help figure that one out but yeah I'm curious whether our contracts don't work here on
[2:05:19] Speaker D (unidentified): Another note, I just wanted to mention that the comp plan consistency report was very helpful, having that specifically called out, since that is my very purview of our board's recommendation is at the end of the day the comp plan consistency, so it's nice to have it laid out really clearly how you see the reason being consistent. Thank you for that.
[2:05:49] Speaker V (unidentified): I wanted to thank you both for all the thorough background information. It was really very helpful in both cases.
[2:05:56] Speaker A (unidentified): I agree. Thank you very much. Great presentations. And thank you, the city's presentation about the waterfront. It feels like there's a little bit more to explore here. And that's just my sense, but board members can disagree with that. Do we have what we need? I think so.
[2:06:27] Speaker C (unidentified): For staff, I think, I don't want to speak on behalf of the board, I think tonight there was one of the goals here to say a lot of economic data and a lot of information. We got some really good feedback from the board in terms of getting to some of the zoning
[2:06:39] Speaker D (unidentified): nuance, I'd say, in this meeting.
[2:06:41] Speaker C (unidentified): And it seems like we have a clear direction in terms of working with the applicant to hear what they've heard from you and maybe bring forward your options in terms of our recommendations, so yeah, we don't see it, we'll refer to you in terms of, I think that needs another workshop, but we think that's something we can also work on, bring back. Yeah, do what you want to do, I'm
[2:07:00] Speaker G (unidentified): uncomfortable, I mean, at the end of the day the recommendations, even if we say a, the councils will want b and c spelled out, so the work you do is really going to be helpful. I mean, I do, you, everything we're doing is really just setting the, really being helpful with the council, so the council, you know, we say if you do, you know, if you do rezone, we suggest a contract zone, and here's the kind of parameters of what that would be and how that would work out, so regardless of how we vote they have that vented and ready to go. Yeah, so from a process perspective, what happens
[2:07:34] Speaker U (unidentified): at a hearing, like what are the athletic hearings and how does that get passed, so you the board
[2:07:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Makes a recommendation, there could be simple motions of the board if you're going or doesn't recommend the V5 or zoning, and whether it's positive or negative, it still goes to the council and they take your recommendation to inform their deliberation. So there could be, as David mentioned, several kind of recommendations in this instance that say the board looked at V5, we also provide staff memos that we work with the chairs on that kind of summarize the board's deliberation of you're on the process, they looked at V5 or something about this, the board requested to look at these options, whether it's open space or V5 or contracting, and through this operation the board is recommending that the council group pursue this direction, and they could take that or completely dismiss it and go in a different direction. I think in this instance one of the things that is important with the planning board and why we're talking about something like
[2:08:34] Speaker H (unidentified): a variety of options.
[2:08:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Generally, the council, you want to keep them within scope. So has that been discussed here with the planning board so that they decide B5 is perfectly fine or not fine? That's something this board has discussed in giving guidance on the council that the board, council discusses contracts and they think that's the right approach or not. This board has discussed it and provided some information. So I think that's why that menu of options makes a lot of sense. If the council brings up something completely new that this board never heard or discussed, it usually gets referred back to the planning board and you have to hear that if
[2:09:11] Speaker V (unidentified): I had my brothers and this is one of the public comments, this is such a significant issue for our city, I would prefer it go to the city referendum so the city itself could decide the future one way or another. It just seems like this is really important. I don't know, I'm sorry, no, that's not on our, that's the, I know, I know, but you know, I think it's a too big a decision for the city council as well and once the recommendation from the point
[2:09:40] Speaker C (unidentified): of where it goes to the council, I mean that will be their prerogative in terms of how they want to, whether they hold workshops, if they want to refer the topic to a committee. I think the council has that prerogative. Right now we have the private applications, we have to follow that process, but the council couldn't go in this direction. Let me say one more thing about the
[2:10:01] Speaker K (unidentified): Contract zone because I had in my head I couldn't remember the list of things that were prohibited in the WPBD, so I pulled them up and again, conditional zone different than zoning has to be consistent with the existing accelerated use in the underlying zone. Specifically prohibited in the WPBD is restaurants and bars, and you certainly have food service and also auditorium civic centers, convention centers, other V8 facilities because I think, you know, it's taking a bit of a dirty mile with all that stuff. So to have specifically prohibited users in the underlying zone to try to track contacts on over that doesn't really pass muster. Even if you were like, if you were to delete those things while you're doing the contract zone, that's just not legally, like, it just isn't pass restricted. It really should be, you shouldn't be changing the underlying zone to make the contract zone fit. It
[2:10:54] Speaker J (unidentified): SHOULD THEY SHOULD JUST BE THERE THEY SHOULD BE ABLE TO FIT WITHOUT THIS JUST
[2:11:00] Speaker G (unidentified): WANT TO YOU KNOW WHEN YOU WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT THIS IT'S THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN A LOT OF WAYS AND WORKING MORE ON ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE CITY'S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DOES THE COUNCIL STILL HAVE A SUBCOMMITTEE ON THAT HELD THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE SO WILL THIS I MEAN IT DOESN'T MATTER WE DO WHAT OUR JOB WILL THIS HELP WILL THIS GET KICKED TO THAT
[2:11:22] Speaker C (unidentified): subcommittee or committee that'll be the council's decision to decide if they want to send that to their committee for what it's worth like when we've had much smaller way smaller issues than this if the council has asked that committee to hold whatever workshops or processes that they want before they hear it at the council so sort of assuming there's going to be a few of those for
[2:11:51] Speaker J (unidentified): me I still struggle with the idea that this is the only location available in the state. So, I know that last time it was brought up that there were other things explored, and I'd like to hear more about that.
[2:12:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so that memo's in the packet. I can speak to some of that if you want.
[2:12:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Does that help? Yeah, it's in the packet. We have the memo.
[2:12:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I can speak to it a little bit.
[2:12:24] Speaker V (unidentified): The drink wasn't available.
[2:12:26] Speaker G (unidentified): The gown wasn't available.
[2:12:27] Speaker C (unidentified): You know, so Jonathan Culley, you know, researches plots of land for,, for as a hobby and as a job and spare time. And, you know, he's been looking for, six years, and knocking on doors that, are closed. And even in this case, if you didn't know, that the door would, open, and it did, which was great, but, there's, it's hard to find eight acres of land. And if anybody knows of another spot I think it'll vary all years, you know, the peninsula is pretty full. So I think this is really one of these once in a generation kind of moments. And a lot of cities, you know, do use former industrial sites along water to put a stadium because it's sometimes the only plan that is available. So as you know we've looked, it's not just where is it possible to put a stadium, it's possible to put a stadium at the main mall in the parking lot or something, but you know where is it economically viable for us, where is it a place that our community can thrive and connect. And you know Fitzpatrick is definitely one of those sites that's unfortunately constrained and not possible to do what we need to do there, and it's city owned and not available, but we've proven out the concept there. And as it relates to what is our permanent home, we feel like Cassidy Point is a great fit for our permanent home that we don't know of any other places that would be able to give us the same magic that Fitzpatrick has in terms of, you know, being woven into the fabric of community, not needing all this extra space for parking, not being somewhere that's outside the scope of buses and transit and these other things. And, you know, we love the idea of being, you know, core to what Portland is and what Portland can be. And this site allows us to do that. And, you know, for more of the details on some of the other sites, and I suppose for others who want to check that out. And even just to add, I guess, one of the things I was thinking about as Jim was talking about, hey, we can relocate some of this industrial activity to the South Portland side. There's all this, man, we look at it all the time, there's all these oil tanks. If we can move some of that activity, it would stand to reason you could keep the solid activity in Portland and put a stadium on the South Portland side. And South Portland has asked, but that's not what our fans want. Our fans want to be walking from the West End. They want to be, you know, on the bus lines. They want to be, you know, in Portland and no offense to South Portland, no offense to South Portland. But that's not what our fans are asking for, and that brings its own challenges. And so for us, you know, the economic reason to have our own stadium really is to be at the heart of Portland in a way that can't be just, you know, moved across the river or across it.
[2:15:43] Speaker U (unidentified): How close have the midtown parcels to working like if you were to be able to absorb from the parking of the parcels on the parkway does that does that make those wait sorry which area
[2:15:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Like a long march over one block uphill yeah there's not it's not it's not wide enough
[2:16:01] Speaker U (unidentified): For the field and seeing itself and not including parking yeah not including parking
[2:16:07] Speaker C (unidentified): But I mean Jonathan's has done that for probably many things and it's also not to not to get too far into it but like that's probably a good place for housing whereas this Cassidy Point site one of the reasons that it's in this weird spot is it's not super desirable as they went to market the site it's not like there's people wanting to buy this site and a lot of that has to do with the planes flying directly overhead and some of the other factors that you know we don't we don't hide the soccer Stadium that's common in other cities too where you have a soccer stadium that's basically in the flight path because nothing else wants to be there okay
[2:16:59] Speaker B (unidentified): City
[2:17:02] Speaker W (unidentified): You
[2:17:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Feel like we you have what you need
[2:17:13] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah I think we have clear
[2:17:16] Speaker D (unidentified): Direction maybe James I mean that
[2:17:23] Speaker J (unidentified): Direction public hearing is almost there all right
[2:17:27] Speaker C (unidentified): We got the sense of doing some digging into different zoning mechanisms but it seems like public hearing acceptable to the board it seems like we have some work to do in terms of everyone
[2:17:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah I mean you usually have a pretty good sense of whether it's complete or not as long as you're comfortable yeah I mean if you need a vent you want to vent it more than you do
[2:17:52] Speaker J (unidentified): It or anywhere I have a preference to move faster than slower I think that we should do that as a city anyhow because I think developers need to either succeed or fail fast because they're spending money and so that's my preference always it amazes me that we had so many meetings for every project one meeting one meeting get it done maybe two yeah
[2:18:29] Speaker C (unidentified): We appreciate that, and we'll work with the city here on the specifics and make sure we're ready for a hearing this as soon as possible. I think we really welcome the discussion and the representation of the citizens here, and I feel your pain as it relates to never knowing what council is going to do, but I do think the faster we find that out the better. It sounds like if we can get the
[2:18:56] Speaker A (unidentified): information together we can have a hearing in December is my is what I'm sensing. Okay, so this is a workshop. I want to thank everybody. I'm bored probably you want five minute break before we do Winter Street, so let's do a five minute break so that the applicants can switch out. Thank you folks who are online. Are we ready? Okay, welcome back. So we are now in the public hearing portion. We have report of attendance and report of decisions from October 27th, 2026. Any amendments from board members? Not hearing any. We can move to new business and so we have 105 Winter Street. 105 Winter LLC is our applicant. The board is holding a public hearing this evening to consider a major site plan application at 101 and 105 Winter Street to facilitate the construction of a five unit residential building and four unit residential building for a total of nine units with 13 parking spaces. Subject property is split between the RN4 neighborhood residential and B3 downtown business zones. Project and plan summary are available for viewing on the city CSS portal by referencing plan number PL003623-2026. And with that, I will pass it again to Taylor.
[2:27:04] Speaker D (unidentified): Good evening, Chair Zamboni and members of the board. Tonight we are hosting a public hearing for the proposed development at 101 and 105 Winter's Falls. The applicant on this project is 105 Winter LLC, C REPRESENTED BY EGG CORN ENGINEERING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY HAS SPLIT ZONING BETWEEN THE R AND 4 RESIDENT LABORHOOD AND BUSINESS BOTH LOCATED WITHIN THE WEST END RESORT PISTOL THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TO DEFINE THE PARCELS AT 101 AND 105 WINTER STREET TO FACILITATE THE CONSTRUCTION OF A FIVE UNIT BUILDING AND A FOUR UNIT BUILDING FOR A SCHOOL OF NINE UNITS WITH 13 STRUCTURE THIS ADVOCATION IS BEING REFERRED TO THE PLANNING'S WORK FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE CITY OF PORTLAND'S LAND USE CODE SITE PLAN STANDARD SECTION 13.6, THE APPLICANT WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED to receive historic preservation approval, which has been recommended as a condition. The subject property is located within the west end and there's approximately 27,000 square feet in size. The property at 101 Winter Street is a southerly parcel zoned B3 Downtown Business and is partially developed with pedestrian walking paths. The property at 105 Winter Street is a northerly parcel zoned R and Ford Residential Neighborhood. It's currently developed with a surface parking lot and garage. The area immediately surrounding the subject property is primarily residential as nature with neighborhood community needs to survive. As mentioned previously, the subject property has split zoning between the R and Four and Degree. Staff attributes the proposed development for dimensional standard requirements against the zones of the portion of the building and boss all within there have been no substantial changes to the proposed development since the initial workshop. The applicant is still composing to merge the parcels at 101 and 105 Wonder Street TO FACILITATE THE CONSTRUCTION OF A MULTI-FAMILY BUILDING FIVE UNITS IN BUILDING A AND A FOUR FAMILY BUILDING GO TO BUILDING B FOR A TOTAL OF NINE UNITS. BUILDING A PROPOSED ALONG THE PROPERTY'S WINTER STREET FRONTAGE AND WOULD FEATURE A PROMENTED STREET WALL WITH AN AUTO PORT TO THE REAR OF THE BUILDING. BETWEEN BUILDINGS A AND B, A TOTAL OF 13 PARKING SPACES ARE PROPOSED AS STRUCTURED PARKING WITHIN THE BUILDING. FOR DISCUSSION AT THE PRIOR WORKSHOP CENTERED AROUND THE REQUESTED WAIVERS TO FACILITATE A ONE-WAY VEHICLE DRIVEWAY DESIGN, THE BOARD was generally supportive of these papers. There was also some discussion regarding implications of the heritage street removal permit, which was still under review. This permit has since been issued and the applicant has maintained the original design that was shared in the board about the initial workshop. As a reminder to the board, the three waivers requested by the applicant included the number of driveways. The applicant is requesting two curb house driving and one driveway spacing. The applicant is requesting a spacing of 23.5 feet long fan left and 36.9 feet long fan right. And curb reveal. The applicant is requesting a minimum curve reveal of five inches. Again, the board seemed generally supportive of these waivers at the initial workshop. Staff have since further reviewed this request and are supportive of the requested waivers. Taking surrounding contacts and anticipated traffic volume of these proposals, staff are recommending three conditions of approval associated with the approval of this application, including adequate soil installation for student trees, the storm preservation board approval and ability to serve letters from utility. No written public comment has been submitted to the city at this time. The applicant held the neighborhood meeting on August 1st since 2026. Comments from the public centered on street design and furnishings design elements of the proposed buildings, disruptions within the right-of-way, the site and street lighting, and the height of the proposed buildings. I will now pass it over to the applicant for their
[2:30:39] Speaker C (unidentified): presentation. Thank you very much Taylor and the rest of the staff for all the help you've given us in the last several weeks to guide us through the rest of the process. I've changed Johnston. I'm representing Monoply Flora LLC, City of Flora ID's Pete Heil of Inflator Engineering. Since our last conversation, there have been limited updates, but we did sit in front of the Historic Preservation Board in late October and have another scheduled hearing with them in early December. That conversation largely revolved around brick coursing and the size of fenestration. They were very supportive of the project and candidly it got into a very architecture school-esque conversation, if I do say so. But it was really interesting. It was really interesting to sort of see their perspective on this problem. That'll pass to Pete with other updates. Yeah, again, thank the staff and everyone working through the process. Limited updates since the last workshop that, as Taylor mentioned, with the City Arborist on the heritage tree removal process, working with him on updating the species selection and the quantities, which we shared last time just ahead of the workshop as well. Minor technical stuff for the street trees and the soil modification which we have submitted as of last Friday just ahead of this meeting, but working with the arborist as identified as a conditional approval. Not much else has changed. Nine Units, all of the infrastructure, water, sewer, underground, power, communications, gas services, one-way circulation, working with the fire department to ensure that adequate circulation for emergency vehicles, and then are requesting the three waivers, as Taylor mentioned, and just clarifying that the five inches is really just at the prime point as we're having to meet these easy grades and elevations of the curve, but the majority of the street frontage will be the standard seven inch for Dealing with that any preliminary
[2:32:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Questions from board members can folks can the applicant take down the screen share? Sorry, just so I can see the room. Let's open it up for public comment. Anyone
[2:33:27] Speaker D (unidentified): In the room like to public to comment publicly, you can head up to the podium. You have three minutes to speak. Please just say your name and address. Be
[2:33:37] Speaker F (unidentified): Quick. We have one person in the room. Job, which is I'm a neighbor
[2:33:44] Speaker L (unidentified): To this project. I have been to the neighborhood meeting. I support this project. I think it's a fantastic design. We've been through a lot of development in the neighborhood and this is refreshing, and I speak for some of our neighbors that feel the same way, and I'm excited that these two lots are finally being utilized. They've been empty for a very long time and I have lived on the top of Winter Street since 2001. So I say I've seen it come, I've seen it go, we've lived it, we continue to live it and it would be nice to complete the top of Winter Street and especially with this project that really fits in really well with the two zones so I'm in
[2:34:31] Speaker J (unidentified): Full support of this. Thank you. I
[2:34:37] Speaker W (unidentified): Think we can turn to online comments. We do have just a handful
[2:34:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Of folks still online. If you would like to speak for this now would be the time to use the raise hand feature or press star nine on your phone and I will keep it open very briefly. Not seeing any, I will close the public portion and open it up to board for questions, comments, concerns. The
[2:35:11] Speaker G (unidentified): Staff memo on the applicant have worked through the any issues and it seems from reading the staff memo that the applicant has met all the all the standards and addressed the concerns that were quoted earlier, so I think we need to beat that around any further so I think
[2:35:30] Speaker V (unidentified): I think I'm ready to ready for a motion. I'll add it is a very attractive because I agree with you
[2:35:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. I'll also add that we do not have any more written comments [Speaker I (unidentified): So] Does the city want a vote on each of these waivers? Yes, Mr. Chair. Okay, so let's open it up
[2:36:00] Speaker W (unidentified): For a proposed motion when you all be together or I think you do a and one and then we'll stop and vote. All right, all right, thank you. Sure, I will make a
[2:36:16] Speaker D (unidentified): motion on a waivers based on the information the application plans reports and other information submitted by the applicant findings and recommendations contained in the planning board report for the public hearing held on November 10th, 2026 for application PL-003623-2026 relevant to the site plan standards of the land use code and Portland's technical and design standards and other regulations and testimony presented at the planning board public hearing. One, driveway spacing. The planning board finds based upon the planning staff's review that extraordinary conditions exist or undue hardship SHIP MAY RESULT IN STRICT COMPLIANCE WITH TECHNICAL MANUAL SECTION 1.5.1.C, WHICH STATES THAT LOCAL STREETS SHALL HAVE A DRIVEWAY SPACE OF 50 FEET, THAT SUBSTANTIAL JUSTICE AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST ARE SECURED WITH THE SUPPOSED VARIATION OF THE STANDARD, AND THAT VARIATION IS CONSISTENT WITH THE INTENT OF THE ORDINANCE. PLANNING BOARD WAVES TECHNICAL MANUAL SECTION 1.5.1.C TO ALLOW A DRIVEWAY SPACING OF 23.43 FEET AND 36.92 FEET FROM THE NEAREST OF
[2:37:22] Speaker W (unidentified): budding driveways we have a bunch do we have a second did
[2:37:28] Speaker A (unidentified): i miss it yes any further discussion not hearing any can we do a roll yes mr sheriff beverly elenik yeah oh yes
[2:37:43] Speaker C (unidentified): austin smith yes david silk yes nicholas messina yes eric dim yes kelsey robertson yeah joseph
[2:37:51] Speaker D (unidentified): of Zamboni yes open for further motions I will make a motion on a waivers to curb reveal the planning board finds based upon the planning staff review that extraordinary conditions exist or undue hardship may result in strict compliance with technical manual figure i-11a which requires a curb reveal of seven inches that substantial justice in the public interest are secured proposed variation the standard that variation is consistent with the intent of the ordinance for planning board waves technical manual figure i-11a to allow a curb reveal of five inches
[2:38:28] Speaker A (unidentified): is there a second motion a second any further discussion not hearing any can we do a
[2:38:36] Speaker C (unidentified): roll emily yes austin smith yes david silk yes eric jim yes kelsey robertson yes joseph zamboni
[2:38:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, and we're open for motions.
[2:38:50] Speaker D (unidentified): We make a motion on A, Waiver 3, Number of Driveways. The Planning Board finds, based upon the Planning Staff's review, that extraordinary conditions exist or undue hardship may result from strict compliance with Technical Manual Section 1.5.1.a, which permits no more than one driveway, that substantial justice and the public interest are secured with the proposed variation in the standard, and that variation is consistent to the intent of the ordinance. Planning Board waves Technical Manual Section 1.5.1.a to allow two driveways. I think it was a copy. Yeah. Air, so I said it.
[2:39:29] Speaker A (unidentified): I second the motion. We have a motion, a second. Any further discussion? Not hearing any, can we do a roll? That really you living? Yes. Austin spent here? David? So yes.
[2:39:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Nicholas Messina? Yes. Eric in? Yes. To Kelsey Robertson? Yes. Joseph Zamboni? Yes. And open
[2:39:54] Speaker D (unidentified): for motions. Make a motion on site plan review. Based on the information, the application, plans, reports, through testimony, a Planning Board hearing, and other information submitted by the applicant, the Planning Board adopts the findings, conclusions, and recommendations contained in the Planning Board report for the public hearing on December 10, 2026 for application PL-003623-2026 relevant to the site plan regulations and find that the plan is in conformance with the site plan standards of the Land Use Code subject to the following conditions of approval. Prior to applying for a building permit, once through two as written, and prior to issuance of a building permit free as written. Do we have a second?
[2:40:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Any further discussion? Not hearing any, can we do a roll? Federal League of Living? Yes. Austin Smith? Yes. David Silk? Yes. Nicholas Messina? Yes. Eric Jin? Yes. Kelsey Robertson? Yes. And Joseph Zamboni? Yes. Do we have a motion on the decision?
[2:40:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, I'll make a motion on the Planning Board decision that on the basis of the findings, conclusions, and recommendations contained in the Planning Board report from the public hearing on November 10, 2026 related to application PO-003623-2026 for 101 and 105 Winter Street, which is attached to the draft approval letter and incorporated therein, Planning Board adopts the approval letter as drafted as the Planning Board's decision for application PO-003623-2026 and authorizes the Planning Board chair to sign the approval letter.
[2:41:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Is dropped. Second. Motion in a second. Any further discussion? Not hearing any, can we do a roll?
[2:41:36] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes. Austin Smith? Yes. David Silk? Yes. Nicholas Messina? Yes. Eric Den? Yes. Kelsey Robertson? Yes.
[2:41:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. And that brings us to the end of new business. Thanks everybody.