Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[57:42] Speaker A (unidentified): That corruption in the White House.
[1:03:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Welcome to the planning board meeting for October 27th, 2026. This meeting is being held hybrid, in Zoom and in person. Before we begin, I'd like to address some housekeeping issues regarding public comment. Any written comments received prior to this meeting remain available for the board for their review. In order to provide public comment during the meeting's meeting, it needs to be provided verbally. Members of the public attending the meeting remotely, through phone or computer,, do not have speaking privileges when joining the meeting, and were to provide public comment, members of the public must indicate their interest in speaking at the appropriate time. If participating in a meeting with a computer, you'll use the raise hand feature to indicate your interest. This is turned on and off with the hand icon located at the bottom of your screen. Please ensure you are logged into the meeting under your real name, not an alias or username, so we can call on you properly. If listening to this meeting on a standard telephone or cell phone you can indicate your interest at the right time by pressing star 9. in either case after you're called on please wait till the moderator asks you to unmute yourself once unmuted please state your name and address you will then have three minutes to provide your comment at the end of the period your microphone will be muted again if you experienced any problems during the meeting you can email planning portlandmaine.gov staff will We'll try to monitor the email and respond as appropriate. And with that, Andrew, can we have a roll call? Yes, Mr. Chair. Beverly Ulenick. Here. Austin Smith. Here. David Silk. Here. Nicholas Nacina-Absen. Eric Dim.
[1:05:29] Speaker C (unidentified): Here. Kelsey Robertson. Here. Joseph Zimbon. Here.
[1:05:34] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll just note for those reading the published agenda, the 41 Ashmont Street, this item has been tabled to a future date at the request of the applicant. count so we will start tonight with communication and reports and portland comprehensive plan 2040.
[1:05:51] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah well just a quick overview of this you'll read through this in detail with the communication but we're announcing our kickoff of the comprehensive they also decline that portland plan 2040. the previous one was called the portland side 2030 so we'll continuing that legacy and staff has been working hard and we're looking to get some more details out to the public in the next week or so but for now i want to bring to your attention that the planning board will be designated as a planning committee for this process so you'll be responsible for reviewing and along them and review along the way
[1:06:40] Speaker E (unidentified): i'll be
[1:06:42] Speaker C (unidentified): be gone by how this unfolds but i do remember the how it unfolded last time it was a lot a lot a lot a lot of work good work a lot of engagement and part of it was i think because the last time the city had done a comprehensive plan like that was a long time ago so i guess it leads me to ask the question do you build from i mean the this complaint we worked on seems like yesterday is a very good document it certainly can be updated and amended and revised but do you kind of start from scratch again do you start from somewhere in between scratch and you know just rubber stamping what's there and i'm just kind of curious how do you how you how you see how you tackle it yeah well i think in many ways we see this as an update to
[1:07:37] Speaker D (unidentified): what we have now we still feel that a lot of the goals that are kind of but for instance 2030 continues to be relevant but you know we want to make sure that we're updating it changing where things are needed and responding to changes that have occurred in the past decade so yeah we're certainly not throwing it out we're certainly not sorting over but this is going to be
[1:07:59] Speaker C (unidentified): a you know a in-depth look and the other question one of the major items in the room when we did the comp plan was the need to do a recall because the old land use ordinance was 1968 whatever it amended here and there and then they did a whole comprehensive through that out and so the comp plan was really helpful when we went to the recode process but we're not looking at doing a recode 2040 this would be
[1:08:39] Speaker E (unidentified): to build on tinkering
[1:08:41] Speaker C (unidentified): changing amending depending upon what revisions are made to goals yeah exactly yeah I think you're right we're certainly building off the current comp plan i think in many ways it's still very modern and still there's a lot of big goals priorities that the city has but that being said it is still going to be an intensive public engagement process you know we're anticipating a year or two years now to actually get from this point to where we have a finished around the public outreach engagement with various stakeholder groups so it'll still be a complete refresh of the, but now I think we are in many ways. I guess my last question out of one question was when the recode 20,, 30 was done to Sean, I think was the liaison for the planning board, Sean Dundon. And, he spent a good, amount of time going to meetings and facilitating and interfacing and then he would come back to us and keep and i don't know whether just in terms of more for your benefit long term in terms of planning are you going to be you're going to be look at looking at maybe having someone from the planning board kind of in a similar type of a role yeah and so we so we are still putting together our kind of stakeholder group and how we want to we understand that there's going to need there's going to need to be internal stakeholders you know from across the city as well as external stakeholders you know we've talked a lot about you know and the planning board being the committee for the conference and the primary body by which you know chapters and recommendations through kind of finalize what those recommendations look like yeah in terms of having a like a board member of liaison to the plan something else that we have also discussed we're hoping to again put some more thinking into you know what you know what's the best use of everyone's time how can we make sure that we're close to incorporating for that discussion so at this point we don't have any definitive guidance in terms of where you know from that perspective if there would be a similar kind of liaison to the conference effort but
[1:11:13] Speaker E (unidentified): you can have this conversation yeah so back a question for you and for kevin were you on staff when the 2030 plan was done i was i were okay yes i'm into the tail end of it ah so i was not on the planning board yet but i know how much effort when i did i was mentioning that but then it would be nice to have a critique of the previous plan what public engagement worked what didn't what was the most effective tools for reaching people because i remember like they were at the farmers markets and surveys and yeah you know what was the most beneficial yeah that's a good point
[1:11:49] Speaker D (unidentified): and it's something we've been talking about with matt yeah now who's part of that process as well so yeah that's definitely something we're considering and andrew just suggested i mentioned and i think that's a good point of just the framework of this in addition to wanting to maintain our that the planet today is updated and relevant for our use it's also part of the makeshift that's under underlying are we supposed to have materials
[1:12:22] Speaker B (unidentified): in our folder like a memo or something there is a memo that was part of the packet but it's not in
[1:12:28] Speaker C (unidentified): that the board could be driving it is up on the agreement that's
New Business
[1:12:43] Speaker B (unidentified): great and i will just say when it was being rolled out i was on the zoning board and i think we all would have dedicated more time to lead us to there's a lot of folks that go back and forth between pending or voting or yeah have a lot of planning experience so we're free to reach out with them i think like great yeah okay so we have in our meeting minutes reports of decisions of the meeting element november 13th that was six more times do we have any edits board members for those minutes not seeing any new business thank you let's start with 43 st lawrence street St. Lawrence development is the applicant and they'll just come and take a seat. Board is holding a helicare to consider a major site and to facilitate the construction of a four-story, seven-unit building with seven structured parking spaces at 40 East St. Lawrence Street. zone rn4 neighborhood residential a project and summary are available for viewing on the city's css portal by referencing my number pl zero three six five three dash twenty six and with that i'll pass it off to the city thank you eric
[1:14:17] Speaker A (unidentified): good evening chairs and voting members of the board as stated we are here for the major site plan application at 43 st lawrence street this application is being brought forward by st lawrence development llc represented by acorn engineering as well as ryan senator architecture the subject property at 43 st lawrence is located within the rn4 neighborhood residential zone as well as the monjoy hill historic district as stated this application involves the construction of a four-story seven-unit multi-family building with seven off-street parking spaces as well as associated site improvements. This application is subject to site plan section 13.6 as well as historic preservation section 17.7.1. The current site is within the Munjoy Hill neighborhood in the east end. It is at the intersection of St. Lawrence Street and Gilbert Lane which is a city accepted right-of-way, although not a formal city street. This property was previously home to a three-story molten family building, which was damaged in a fire last year and was subsequently demolished. The site currently consists of a small amount of vegetation as well as the foundation of the previous building, which still remains. The site plan, as shown here with St. Lawrence Street on the bottom, the building's primary entrance would front St. Lawrence Street with a lobby area as well as a trash room and the utility room at the ground level of the building. The front of the building would be flanked by vegetation which would extend up both sides of the building along Gilbert Lane and along the eastern property boundary. The primary vehicular access as shown here to the seven unit parking space parking lot would be off of Gilbert Lane. There would be a 8-foot tall canopy, 8-foot tall privacy fence, which would wrap around the parking area at the rear and the eastern edge of the site to provide visual screening from the parking lot to surrounding properties as well. the upper stories of the building would be entirely residential with each unit having a small balcony and the roof level as shown here in the elevations would be an accessible roof level with access to utilities as well as a residential amenity space as well i would also note that the sidewalks along the frontage of the property are proposed to be resurfaced with concrete tree. This is a condition that the Department of Public Works is supportive of. There would also be one new street tree planted along St. Lawrence Street as well. Shown here is the south elevation, St. Lawrence Street elevation, showing the front of the building. And then shown here is the west elevation along Gilbert Lane, showing the entrance to the partially covered parking area, as well as a bit of detail of the privacy fence as well. And a perspective rendering of the proposed building looking along st lawrence street the applicant held their neighborhood meeting for this application on september 9th this was held at the hill arts center at 76 congress street there were approximately 14 members of the public in attendance public comment focused primarily on building landscaping and site buffers hvac and utility placement the building height and massing construction management as well as access and circulation on gilbert lane staff are recommending approval of this major site plan application there are several conditions of approval detailed below one of which involves establishing a public easement over a portion of the sidewalk that is within the property boundary receiving a certificate of appropriateness from the historic preservation board and the preservation of historic cobbles on gilbert lane that may be impacted during construction and with that we can turn it to the outcome hi
[1:18:21] Speaker C (unidentified): thank you very much for your time this evening my name is herbert moore i am part of the development team here for 43 st lawrence i own and operate premier construction we are a commercial general contractor we're actually just wrapped up a similar project of 18 units primarily residential we're looking forward to this i've really enjoyed working with Sam and Ryan and their teams. Thank you very much, Eric, for all of this time and we're excited to present it to you here. See you next.
[1:18:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Thanks, Herbert. Sam Wobel with Acorn Engineering. Pleased to be here tonight as always. So first, just wanted to kind of give a quick snapshot of the neighborhood. So on the right-hand side of the screen, you've got where Forestry kind of morphs into the Eastern Prom. On the east side and then on the west side of the screen, you've got Congress Street running up and down so we're kind of mid block just off of st lawrence street and kind of back to the old bfw zooming in a few frames you can see the frontage here on st lawrence street as well as the frontage onto gilbert's lane as eric mentioned this is kind of a funky street designation where it's a public way but not a city accepted street and so traditionally it's kind of acted almost as a shared vehicle pedestrian kind of bicycle way obviously just local traffic providing access to those who front and live directly on the street in the center of the frame here you can see the old structure that existed prior to the fire and demolition it was a three-story four-unit building you can see kind of near the corner and the intersection a portion of the building actually encroached within gilbert's lane you can see its existing parking here to the rear flipping to the proposed site plan you can see we are looking to kind of recede from that corner a bit respect you know at least the five foot setbacks this tan color would represent the proposed floor plan at the ground level and then the proposed driveway coming off of Gilbert's Lane providing parking for seven spaces the internal drive aisle here that I'm I've got the mouse on as well as the four parking spaces but in the building would all be covered so up above that pavement you have levels two three and four with living and then these four parking spaces at the rear would be uncovered external parking spaces. We've worked hard to really kind of fill in the perimeter and the main entrance here off St. Lawrence with some pretty healthy landscaping. Those would be accompanied by planters. As Eric mentioned, we are looking to rebuild the entirety of our frontage with a concrete sidewalk. That's what's on that side of the street today. It's also a bit safer in the winter especially on a steep street like st lawrence we'd also be rebuilding and creating an ada accessible pathway across gilbert's lane and then chasing the sidewalk another 15 feet up the hill so really looking to kind of bring this intersection into conformance with accessibility standards additional accesses or access would be provided off gilbert's lane to this stairwell here and as well through the covered parking next to the 88 parking space the overall impervious area we're pleased to be able to actually show a net reduction when looking at the existing condition which had quite a bit of kind of compacted gravel in addition to the former structure all new utilities would be coming in underground including the electric and communications under sir lauren street stormwater perspective i mean just by virtue of reducing the impervious area as well as bringing some robust landscaping back into the mix we expect an improvement there as well we have made space for four external bicycle parking spaces internally as well as one on the street that would be available for public use And then to round it out, we're looking to maintain the existing street tree near the intersection and then install a new one as part of this overall reconstruction. So that kind of sums it up for the site component. I'll let Ryan speak to the building, and then we'd be happy to answer any questions.
[1:23:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Good evening, Ryan, Senator of the Project Architect. Glad to be back before the board. So just to start, this project is within the Munjoy Hill Historic District. So we have had a formal workshop meeting with the board as well as at least two staff meetings. So really going back and forth, patching this out, really working with them collaboratively to develop the design we're presenting tonight. We did have some meetings with neighbors on site as well as the formal neighborhood meeting. again, really making adjustments, answering questions, and really trying to present the best project we can. And so with that, this is where we're at. We are scheduled to go next week back for a public hearing for the historic work. And so this is kind of a precedent study of some of the similar massing and kind of formal structures in the neighborhood of multi-story, multi-unit buildings kind of with express kind of bases and then lighter frame wood frame tops so a lot of them have a masonry base half a story or a story so we kind of pulled some of these elements but you know some bays on the front sides as well figure ground you see the building the kind of massing and blends in with the other figures in the neighborhood. Here's the, we actually do the slopes on the site. It's actually a pretty decent slope from front to back. We do have a basement on St. Lawrence Street. So down there we'll have some storage functions, elevator, machine room, et cetera, and the utilities coming in. This floor plan is the first floor plan,, which has an accessible entrance on St. Lawrence Street. And then we have some nice active program on the street with some nice fenestration really connecting to the sidewalk in the street. And then you can go back into an elevator, which is actually a dual-sided elevator. So that makes up our grade transition to the upper level, which is the access from the parking. So that's how we're handling accessibility across the site. So this is the second floor. So this has three units on it one facing the street one kind of on the side elevation and the one in the rear providing you know nice bright units large windows projecting bays some porches so really trying to create some nice amenities and break up the massing of the structure you know one of the one of the results of the historic board meeting was we actually added a third bay along gilbert's lane to kind of break up that massing and you'll see that in some of the renderings and so we thought that was a good positive contribution to the design. This is the third floor so this has two units on it so these are a little bit larger but again accessible from a common corridor and then the egress stair each have an exterior space exterior deck. The fourth floor is very similar to the third but we do have two spiral stairs so those will access the roof decks above so that's an added amenity for these units. So they have a private roof deck for each unit up there. We are planning to have the HVAC equipment kind of sandwiched between those, so green from public way as well as salmon, so we thought that was a good place to put those. Here's the elevation on St. Lawrence Street. So you can see the kind of strong symmetry of facade but having two projecting bays kind of a recessed stack of decks stacked porches in between and then a nice strong entry element with a canopy part of the part of the site design was really maintaining the existing street wall that would be similar to the structures adjacent to it but also holding the street edge and so that's why we have the projector the planters that come out hold that street edge as the building is step back a bit to make that so we thought that was a nice way to transition from the sidewalk to the building facade it also adds a nice landscape element here's an elevation this would be kind of up to the abutting neighbor but just kind of shows the brick base along st lawrence street and then a darker siding color really delineating that first story and then the lighter siding material on the floor spot, the rear elevation, which would be behind the view. Yeah, the view, that's the view of the view property and kind of a building sector, the opposite facade. So it's showing that bay, the brick returning and then that parking entrance and then kind of technical building section to show how it all works together. and then a streetscape so showing how this building matches with adjacent structures on the street and a rendering this is from Atlantic Street so showing the massing from the rear of the building and then the massing looking down St. Lawrence Street. So how it kind of fits into that street scheme. And then a nice rendering of the proposed structure. So showing the two bays on the front, the bay on the side elevation, and then the porches, nice strong cornice, and a nice brick facade on the base of the building, and then the lighter flat boards on the upper parts of the structure. And then a rendering looking up the street. so kind of showing those planters kind of a nice landscaping around the structure and how it all kind of fits together so thank you very much great
[1:29:30] Speaker B (unidentified): so we will do public comment but
[1:29:34] Speaker E (unidentified): preliminary questions people questions for board members there were some contradictions in the drawings and there was a public comment about heat pump units that sometimes directly at grade based on the neighbor are those still there no so though they were there maybe that was the contradiction they were on that it's called the easterly facade and we met with the neighbor on site that was one of our concerns and then so we move those up to the roof level so that's what they are now okay thank you okay
[1:30:13] Speaker B (unidentified): let's move in public comments so we'll start in the room if you're in the room you'd like to have comments come right off the podium those of you who are online we will get to you shortly and just you can use the raise hand feature again if you're on the telephone you're going to press star 9. i'm not seeing anybody in the room so online if you have a comment now is the time once public portion
[1:30:44] Speaker C (unidentified): is closed we are not taking comments and that includes questions and suggestions last
[1:30:56] Speaker B (unidentified): call for in the room last call online okay so public portion is now closed and i open up to board members for questions thoughts of applicant and the city thank you for presentation
[1:31:15] Speaker F (unidentified): i have a question for the city about gilbert lane like how are those two questions about how heavily is it utilized now and then can you talk me through the difference of the city accepted railway versus is the like not formal railway who maintains Gilbert Lane and plows it's maintained by the
[1:31:37] Speaker A (unidentified): city okay and Gilbert Lane it does function it's approximately 16 feet wide it's a very narrow shared street that is cut between Atlantic and St. Lawrence streets you did review that and look at it from kind of an access circulation use perspective given you know the context it's a very slow street it does essentially function as a shared street now this application proposes to maintain that condition and we were supportive of that as well and we did draft a condition we understand there are you know some historic elements to the cobblestones within Gilbert Lane so you know ensuring that if those are impacted during the course of construction that they're you know preserving reset because that was identified as a priority is maintaining
[1:32:19] Speaker B (unidentified): those calls yeah and just to continue with what Eric's saying it really also is functioning like can malleable urban context mostly it's mostly for vehicular access like in a way of a shared driveway concept they're accessing it more from a vehicular perspective rather than pedestrian however of course people do obviously walk down as well so in this case there's a bit of a safety concerns it's been operating like it has been historically quick follow-up on that and so from a setback perspective, I see they pulled out a five-foot setback, but our report doesn't have a corner side setback. So is this, would this be considered an interior side or a fuller side?
[1:33:06] Speaker A (unidentified): It would be considered an interior, I believe.
[1:33:12] Speaker B (unidentified): So they're going to have to go through a zoning review again when they go to permit as that's just part of the process, even though zoning is reviewed during the site plan process. process. And so that's something that would be contributed by the district. But I think that wasn't anything that necessarily was a...
[1:33:31] Speaker A (unidentified): It was not raised during the initial review and it was kind of reviewed as an internal. Okay. At
[1:33:41] Speaker B (unidentified): the back of the property, there seems to be a hazard vegetation buffer. Was it going to be along the park in there? Yeah, so due to the spatial constraints of the lot and the parking, we opted for a privacy fence there because there's really not enough room to get any substantial vegetation. So that would be the one side where we weren't quite able to get it.
[1:34:20] Speaker F (unidentified): yeah and based on the public comment that was received it seems like a lot of the concerns of the public comments were have already been addressed there was one thing about i think in the memo about coordinating with the property owner on a proposed brick wall removal on the
[1:34:40] Speaker C (unidentified): southern boundary have you already worked with the neighbor on that yeah so essentially the wall looks as if it was built the same on both properties we're proposing modifying hours on our side of it and what we had proposed to her is that we modify hers in the same way free of charge and she's amenable to that okay and planning staff would be that as a private
[1:35:04] Speaker A (unidentified): property matter yeah now
[1:35:09] Speaker B (unidentified): let's note that there is only one comment this august 30th so something it's been a while feels like we're comfortable entertain a motion
[1:35:33] Speaker C (unidentified): i'll
[1:35:41] Speaker F (unidentified): make a motion on site plan review so based on information in the application plans reports through testimony at the planning board hearing and other information submitted by the applicant at the planning board adopts the findings conclusions and recommendations contained in the planning BOARD REPORT FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING ON OCTOBER 27, 2026 FOR APPLICATION PL-003653-2026, 43 ST. LAURENS STREET, RELEVANT TO THE SITE PLAN REGULATIONS AND FINDS THAT THE PLAN IS IN CONFORMANCE WITH THE SITE PLAN STANDARDS OF THE LAND USE CODE SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL. PRIOR TO ISSUANCE OF A BUILDING PERMIT ONE THROUGH THREE AS WRITTEN AND PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF A CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY FOUR AS WRITTEN.
[1:36:28] Speaker B (unidentified): We have a motion. Is there a second? Second. We have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Not hearing any. We'll roll on that one. Chair, Beverly Huland-Pink. Yes. Austin Smith. Yes. David So. Yes. Nicholas Messina-Abson. Eric Din. Yes. Chelsea Robertson. Yes. And Joseph Zimboni. Yes.
[1:36:53] Speaker F (unidentified): the motion on the planning board decision that on the basis of the findings conclusions and recommendations contained in the planning board report for the public hearing on october 27 2026 related to application pl-003656-2026 at 43 st lawrence street which is attached to the draft approval letter and incorporated therein the planning board adopts findings and conclusions the October 27, 2026 Planning Board Report and their approval letter as drafted as the Planning Board's decision for application PL-003653-2026 and authorizes the Planning Board Chair to sign the approval letter as drafted.
[1:37:32] Speaker B (unidentified): Motion. Do we have a second? Second. Motion and a second. Any further discussion? Not hearing any.
[1:37:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Beverly Ulinink? Yes. Austin Smith? Yes.
[1:37:44] Speaker B (unidentified): David Silk? Yes. Yes. Nicholas Messina, absent. Eric Dim. Yes. Kelsey Robertson. Yes. Joseph Zamboni. Yes. You're very welcome. Good luck at H-E. Nice meeting you. Yeah, thank you. Take care. Good job. Yeah, you as well. As folks move around, we'll be moving to 76 Congress Street, Hill, Arts, Friends, St. Lawrence Church, which is the applicant. They will join us up here,
[1:38:14] Speaker G (unidentified): playing board, who's playing computer,
[1:38:15] Speaker B (unidentified): are an amendment to the additional sewing agreement d-58 76 common street pool as a modification to the other building and remember this inspiration date project component summary are available viewing on the city's rss portal by referencing that number cda zero three seven one two dash twenty six and we're done that's the title right all
[1:38:53] Speaker D (unidentified): right thank you Chair Zamboni, members of the board. My name is Rhonda Kauster and I'll be writing an overview of the 76 Congress Street amendment. The applicant is the Hill Arts Organization and this application is a conditional zone amendment or amendment to a conditional zone agreement. The subject property is located at 76 Congress Street and it is a proposal to amend conditional zone C-50. The project, in summary, proposes to modify the newly visited Parish Hall to the Hill Arts Center and eliminate the agreement's exploration area. The project is located in Portland's East End neighborhood in the Lakeway Hill Historic District. The project is located along Commercial Street, which hosts mixed-use commercial and neighborhood as well as the Metro Lumberland Runtime. There's also the Eastern Front and Backhoe. The existing structure, also referred to as a parish hall, is the site of the former St. Lawrence Church. There was also a larger sanctuary building located on the corner of Congress Street and Longevity Street that has been demolished. I believe that was in the mid-2000s, and that portion of the plan. As far as the background, the original conditional film agreement was approved by the City Council in 2010. And this was pursued by the applicant to reconstruct the sanctuary with a 400-seat performance space as well as a renovation to the parish hall. In 2015, the agreement was revised and the design altered, the timeframe was extended, and the applicant pursued major state plan review and approval which they received in 2018 and 2023 designs they've also received a one-year extension to the agreement and the applicant commenced site work and accorded 2003 major site plan approval however the conditional zone agreement will expire if that sidewalk block is back in front of you today to as I mentioned renovate Parish Hall remove the back of house programming to that portion of the structure eliminating that 120 seat venue and then slowly increasing the number of seats in the performance However, probably most important is this proposal tonight requests the elimination of the time frame and establishes that the agreement will be null and void if the developer fails to complete it. Just for a bit of background, this is their preliminary site plan that was submitted as part of their proposal showing the addition in the support for the space of the former sanctuary as well as the programming of the existing parish hall and lastly for your consideration all conditional zoning agreements must be bound to be consistent with the plan so this has been the case for all of the agreements and the amendments to the agreement so far but tonight great to your attention at new goals from Poland in 2030 that relate to the arts and culture, emphasizing arts and culture, promoting growth of cultural institutions, supporting mobility and historic structures. The applicant held a public meeting on October 5th, 2026. Thank
[1:43:25] Speaker G (unidentified): you, Roman. I'm Julia Kirby, I'm the Development Director at
[1:43:30] Speaker E (unidentified): personal arts michael coin archetype architects sending the architecture project so kind of just two things off ron did a great job sort of explaining what we're looking to do ultimately the primary goal here is to get support time we have been working at this project for years and julia can speak to a little bit more of an update on the financial side and fundraising aspect. But our goals right now are to get more time into the project so that we can develop it into a new scheme that more aligns with the budget that's realistic to date. So that's sort of the overall bulk of what we're looking to do with this contract amendment. I'm happy to speak to some of the design elements we've implemented to date that was submitted as part of this just to recap what we're looking at overall it's a simplification of the previously submitted and approved theater again to really get more alignment with the realistic budget to get this project to the finish line and continue construction i want to give maybe a
[1:44:40] Speaker G (unidentified): brief overview on how we practice where we are we're keeping the core vision of the project which is to provide a mid-sized, non-profit, state-of-the-art theater that our research has shown us community arts partners not only need, but very much want, not only for their programming, but to support their bottom lines, and that this particular theater does not exist in Portland. So we have very large theaters like Merrill Auditorium or Hora, and then we have smaller theaters like our own Parish Hall Theater and Mayo Street Arts. So this fits that sweet spot of a mid-sized theater. We do not run a theater company. We are open as a community arts space, providing creative space for nonprofits and other artists, both those in our community and those that we will bring to Portland. And then another core value of this project is to support the historic structure that is surviving today. As Rowan mentioned, the sanctuary was demolished in 2008 and the historic side that exists the parish hall theater requires a lot of maintenance and restoration that's quite expensive and with the 160 theater that can prove very challenging for non-profit so this provides an earned income stream that will support the historic side so those two things will still be major leading components of the project things that are going away as Mike mentioned speak to the budget more so we're going to be more in line with the fundraising goals that we've already hit and a small fundraising client that we know we can achieve to complete the project so that's where we are okay and really to round it out as Rowan
[1:46:28] Speaker E (unidentified): mentioned you know we still believe the project meets the government's plan for the city we don't on who cited that so what we need is time to get this concept to fruition for working with the contractor on board right now to keep everything in alignment and this allows us that avenue to maintain and preserve the spirit of the project but we just tailor it to a more
[1:46:55] Speaker B (unidentified): realistic budget thank you are there any questions from the board before we do a couple comments I
[1:47:08] Speaker C (unidentified): just got a question. I think it's a great idea. The absence of an expiration date is a concern to me. These are usually done as an exception to the underlying zoning and they always revert back to the underlying zoning when and if the project doesn't happen and you're eliminating that provision. vision. That's a concern to me. I don't know why you need to give them another 10 years. Right now, it just says it lasts until, unless they fail to complete the project. And what is that? I guess as long as there's someone saying we're going to get it done, that means forever. And this is, I mean, this meets the comprehensive plan. It's a great project. I was on the plan we're back when this got initially done you know but i guess i my only caveat for me is the absence of a date where we were back and i would feel better we're not approving it goes to the city council you know the day but i guess i want to know more why is the elimination of say another 10 years i mean if this doesn't get done in 10 years it's been 20 years and at that point you know should we work back to the underlying zone i mean you know the purpose of it is giving them a window of opportunity to do something unique that is consistent but i've never seen one that didn't regroup back if it ultimately didn't get completed within a certain period of yeah we so we discussed this and just you know the court's record i mean it's it's not a requirement that any of these contract zones have an expiration date so that's something that is set by the municipality you know as we've gone through this i think we 've seen again this has been a contract zone that's been in place for a long period of time there's been repeated support for the project to proceed it has gone through this kind of administrative step of So from our perspective, we're comfortable proceeding with it and not having an expiration date. The board is fine to recommend expiration dates.
[1:49:42] Speaker B (unidentified): So there's nobody in the room. If you're online and you would like to offer a comment, now would be the time to raise your hand. I will keep it open unless I see no hands are raised. If you're on the telephone, you would press star nine.
[1:50:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Alyssa, you should be able to unmute.
[1:50:14] Speaker H (unidentified): Yes, can you hear me? Yes. I am a member of the Monterey Hill community and live across the street from this project. project it's currently a bit of an eyesore and has been for i think almost a year now and you know i agree with the with what the gentleman was saying earlier i'm sorry i don't know your name about like what is the point of having these expiration dates if they're not going to be enforced or honored and i think monday hill has changed a lot since 2010 when this project was proposed and originally approved to some extent. And the population's probably close to almost doubled. And I think bringing in a venue that brings in 400 people at a time to the neighborhood is going to be a huge stressor on the neighborhood. parking alone will be stressed and it's not that i don't love the arts i do and i agree that a 400 seat venue probably would you know do well or portland would benefit from a venue that size but i also think a venue that size would do a lot better in an area of portland where there is more parking, accessible parking, lots, garages, more restaurants to cater to these people that would be attending. And I just don't know that corner is the same corner it was in 2010 and that it really can fit this project or should fit this project at this point. and it has been going on for so long 16 years is a long time to work on a project in the neighborhood so that's just my two cents may
[1:52:44] Speaker I (unidentified): i speak my hands up i think i'm a panelist i
[1:52:53] Speaker B (unidentified): believe deidre is part of your team correct yes no go ahead oh thank you i will i thank you
[1:53:01] Speaker I (unidentified): you all, Chair and members of the Planning Board. As many of you know that we've been working on this project for more than 30 years, and I think that we've been working hard to preserve the historic property that we operate our 160th theater in, and we've been trying to bring this vibrant cultural center online for quite a long time. These changes that we have proposed tonight are really a commitment to creating a more compact and efficient and financially sustainable project while preserving our original vision and providing this much-needed performance space for Portland artists, the arts community, and organizations. We do meet all of the elements of the city's comprehensive plan, and we appreciate your time tonight and welcome any and all questions. Thank you. Those
[1:54:04] Speaker B (unidentified): are the two hands I saw.
[1:54:08] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, we got one more. Carol, you should be able to unmute. Unmute. Hi.
[1:54:16] Speaker I (unidentified): I don't know why my picture is not up there, but that's okay. As a creative artist in Portland on the East End, we just finished a show at the Hill Arts. We could not find a venue that was not more than 100 seats in Portland that could accommodate our show. And so Portland desperately, in my opinion, needs a mid-sized theater because Mayo Street has 75 seats. Yes, Portland Stage has 200, but they use it all the time. And so they have been working on this for many, years, which I think goes to their belief in how much that this is needed in Portland. And so I don't know. I mean, I haven't been here for 20 years and I don't know how Portland has changed, but I don't see that is a problem. I mean, it will bring in more people. There are new restaurants on Washington. It will bring more money to Portland to have people come and see some great stuff. So I am absolutely in favor of this, especially since it has been approved by the planning board and all they're trying to do is, yes, reconfigure it. and i live oh i live on mondor hill so to me you know the parking they have plans for that and we just had a show and nobody had a problem parking so that's actually all i can say is that i'm absolutely as a creative performing artist in favor of this project thank you
[1:56:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you. Other hands?
[1:56:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Alicia, you've already had an opportunity to speak. I can't recognize folks twice. Others? Okay, not seeing any others. So I'm going to close the public portion. We can get back to questions from the board and for the city.
[1:56:54] Speaker C (unidentified): and that you
[1:57:01] Speaker F (unidentified): had mentioned that you had already done fundraising and you're close to being ready closer to being ready to go what is your projected time frame for starting the pre-construction
[1:57:17] Speaker E (unidentified): process takes yeah we're looking probably over the next six eight ten months to develop this plan through pre-construction deal with permanent and all of that so that's sort of the process we're starting from this process so we would be looking to go the first half of next year through that pre-construction process to get to a point where we can permit the revised
[1:57:43] Speaker G (unidentified): and proceed from that construction that would be the goal so and during that time we'll be closing
[1:57:50] Speaker F (unidentified): our fundraising so shovel on the ground still in 27 or in 28 i think that's the hope is 27.
[1:57:58] Speaker E (unidentified): that's sort of the rough outline that's been presented so we're trying to get sort of back into that what needs to happen this obviously being the first step and then from here we can start working through what amendments have to happen to planning historic and obviously
[1:58:21] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't want to ask for confidential information in terms of your fundraising, do you have a percentage of how far you are? How close are you?
[1:58:35] Speaker G (unidentified): Let's say we're about 80% there with the funds that we have in hand. We've already expended a significant amount on the project, but we've worked with our contractor to understand which of those funds are applicable to this new redesign and the figure is very promising that you know a good chunk of that will be but not all of it right part of the process is understanding going through it and learning
[1:59:08] Speaker F (unidentified): and it's like it's an expensive process and no construction had commenced for the previous is version of the project like when the public commenter mentioned like sort of an eyesore at the corner that was more from the demolition of the previous building or had some construction
[1:59:30] Speaker E (unidentified): commenced there has been some site work what was done in the past year was essentially opening up the street and utilities to the site so that we made the destruction that would happen in the brought everything to the site and closed everything. And then a fence has been constructed around the site for protection.
[1:59:53] Speaker F (unidentified): The conditional zone previously had said if work stopped for 12 months, that would, we're removing that portion.
[2:00:01] Speaker B (unidentified): We issued advanced site work last year, which the department can do, basically giving some authorization to do some site work, as the applicant team has stated, to advance at least to be able to be within that time frame so that they can come for here and ask for this proposal to amend yeah don't eliminate it but from 12 months from that start basically they're at the end of that yeah so advanced network window where they're gonna
[2:00:31] Speaker F (unidentified): now potentially lapse i'm assuming maybe some of the intent of that was to not prolong construction impacts in the neighborhood to have that, construction doesn't lapse
[2:00:44] Speaker B (unidentified): for 12 months? Correct. Yeah. Yeah.
[2:00:46] Speaker C (unidentified): And that's just a, that's a general site plan requirement that site plans expire if there's a lapse of construction.
[2:00:57] Speaker E (unidentified): So David raised the issue of a time limitation. And it sounds as if, we did, rather than an open-ended approval tenure, that you would be well within that. you seem very confident that within the next two years at the most construction will start
[2:01:17] Speaker G (unidentified): it would be i there was discussion when we met with planning staff about eliminating the time frame because it has been something that has been a bit of an obstacle for us as a non-profit as we've moved through this process and so it just seemed to make sense with our a particular project since it wasn't a requirement to just take it off the table so that it isn't something that in front of us anymore i
[2:01:51] Speaker E (unidentified): i do recognize the neighborhood concern that this construction fence has been up for a decade it seems and you know
[2:01:59] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, a year, roughly a year, yes.
[2:02:06] Speaker G (unidentified): It has a rough level.
[2:02:08] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, there was a sort of issue. Yeah.
[2:02:13] Speaker B (unidentified): We just make a recommendation.
[2:02:15] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, I correct. You know, I think it clearly meets the comprehensive plans and system with the findings that were made initially did. but i feel more comfortable with it you know where this has already been a significant amount of time and they need more time and you know the goal is to either something happens or if it doesn't it falls back to what the underlying zoning is and i don't see a good reason to delete to not continue that approach i mean that's the quid pro quo which is you get something you get you're the time to try to actualize it and then goes back but i don't have a problem between the other five years ten years i just think this should be different to date and not have this be you know you've got great intentions and hopefully pull it off some of them later but at some point you know the neighborhood i think there's some element of comprehensive plan too that would favor you know something happening with the property as opposed to having it sit in limbo for a long period of time so i you know i certainly recommend this to the council i guess i would my two cents would be to have some include some time limit whether it's five years ten years i don't really care i just don't think it should be open i
[2:03:42] Speaker B (unidentified): agree with that i think the fail to complete the project is a little to beg for that to be triggered for burning but i think we i have no problem being generous with the time and you could yeah
[2:03:59] Speaker F (unidentified): feelings you could see the project could almost be worse could be a half done never again yeah i'm comfortable recommending that we add a time frame okay
[2:04:24] Speaker B (unidentified): all right so do we want to be technical in terms of complete the project in 10 years
[2:04:29] Speaker C (unidentified): language? I think it's more just the, you know, the site plan has their own site plan. I mean, no one, people let site plans expire all the time and they come back in. The only difference is whatever's changed, you got to meet the new standards, whether it's a, whatever, and that's fair. I think it's more just say, what was the language that was deleted? It was, it says commence construction in 10 years from the day the council approves it this 10 years should be extended for one additional period so they had a deadline to commence construction within 10 years so have you considered have they commenced construction yet i mean did you consider the site plan work that was done we considered the advanced site work that was completed because the site planner that is currently active was approved in 2023 so that we considered that site plan work to have commenced with the start of the advanced site work which was the playing out of utilities i mean on the street so that i think what we've been discussing earlier this evening is that lapse there's likely to be a lapse in construction activity due to that having happened a year or plus ago. So at that point, then that's, I think. And at that point, would that, I guess it's a good question. I guess I'd like to see it's substantially completed within 10 years. I mean, it's something that you just, you get it done. And you have something out there that says you've got to get it done. Or, I mean, it's just, there's a balance here that, you know, encouraging and helping you all do what you want to do.
[2:06:14] Speaker I (unidentified): but this is a balance too in some way we are entirely comfortable with that thank
[2:06:23] Speaker C (unidentified): you but the something that says that the project shall be substantially completed you know this agreement shall expire unless the whatever it's something that says would the board be
[2:06:35] Speaker B (unidentified): and what was most titling a new process so like the issue of civilian permit or a certificate of occupancy announcement that's tied to like an actual documentation that will allow them to like you know people can go and perform at that point yeah and i think certificate of
[2:06:52] Speaker F (unidentified): action is the right one not a permanent right because that says it's not right
[2:06:59] Speaker E (unidentified): yep and in my mind a time limit would help with fundraising you know we don't have another 20 years to raise funds we've got to get it done right
[2:07:11] Speaker C (unidentified): that's okay because that book are
[2:07:19] Speaker B (unidentified): you looking at the proposed motion yeah okay i was going to say if you wanted completely just because yeah the proposed motion yeah the first amendment five which i don't want to mess this up
[2:07:33] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah that should be give me a moment i will i'll get something i
[2:07:44] Speaker B (unidentified): apologize you can consider that a question from the chair if you wanted to open further what was the question sorry no i just Since public comment was closed, but you're also kind of part of the African pool, I didn't want to cut you off, but I also wanted to follow protocol. So if you wanted to add something, it's fine.
[2:08:04] Speaker D (unidentified): Oh, it
[2:08:08] Speaker I (unidentified): has taken a long while. We recognize that we're very dedicated. We're near the end of this project. We don't expect it to take another 10 years, but it doesn't hurt to have additional time. you know for those of you who are not familiar with the project you know we originally wanted to fix the sanctuary that was there we had a catastrophic collapse that's why it came down it took two years to get through all the historic preservation departments including the city the state and the federal, and then took another two years to recreate a plan. I mean, this little nonprofit that is honestly just has a few staff members has been a little engine that could. And, you know, additional time would be fantastic for us. We don't expect it to take that long. But the reiterations and the tenacity of not only myself, but the board and folks that have been trying to bring this building online. We have jumped through many, hoops. We've done, you know, we've been good neighbors. And, you know, the construction we started last year, just for whatever it's worth, you know, we've done so many different 180s to try to make sure that we could bring this project online for the city of Portland. And so I guess my comment would be that we do appreciate the partnership that the city of Portland has extended us all these years. I mean, literally since 1993, when I first bought the building on my own with a small inheritance from my father, which most people in the world don't get, and then formed a non-profit. And it's taken a really long time, no doubt. But again, I would just like to say this. We're a small non-profit. The original budget for the archetype plan that we have in site plan, which is still completely permitted, was $20 million. We're reducing it by half, so we're really nearly there with fundraising. We have a bit of work to do before the spring and then perhaps a summer construction, but it's all been done in good faith by this little group, so thank you for your time. We appreciate it.
[2:10:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you for being here, and thank you for your comments. It's just 2008, my best friends lived in the apartment across the street. We sat on the curb as it was demolished with our copies. I remember it very strikingly. So I'm glad that something's going up there.
[2:10:48] Speaker I (unidentified): I was across the street as well, crying. But now I'm thrilled that we have this new, we have what seems like a really doable project in front of us. And it's been a long time and we're nearly there. So buying a little more time is very helpful.
[2:11:07] Speaker C (unidentified): So I have put a draft red line to the motion here for the board to consider. One thing that came to mind as I was writing this is the, again, it sounds like this will not be an issue, but tying it to the certificate of occupancy, one of the concerns there is that the project could be well under construction at that point. And then, for instance, the contract zone expires while it's under construction. So the board wants to consider tying it to a building permit or, you know, faking in some allowance for. No one's trying to set a trap. We're just trying to have a. Right. Even abroad, you know, 10 years. I mean, anyway, so I defer to you on that. it's more just having some someone is looking at this let's say it's not forever
[2:11:59] Speaker B (unidentified): all
[2:12:05] Speaker F (unidentified): right i will make a motion that on the basis of materials submitted by the applicant the city of portland land use code portland's comprehensive plan public comment and the information provided in the public hearing on october 27 2026 for the application dn-003712-2026 and or other findings THE PLANNING BOARD FINDS THAT THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE CONDITIONAL ZONING AGREEMENT C-58 IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR THE CITY OF PORTLAND. THEREFORE, THE PLANNING BOARD RECOMMENDS TO THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPTION OF THE CONDITIONAL ZONE AMENDMENT AS SHOWN IN ENTACHMENT FIVE AND FURTHER AMENDED TO INCLUDE A TEN-YEAR TIME LIMIT FROM THE DATE OF EXECUTION TO THE DATE OF RECEIVING A CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY
[2:12:52] Speaker B (unidentified): PLAN. DO WE HAVE A MOTION TO HAVE A SECOND? SECOND. DO WE HAVE A MOTION TO HAVE A SECOND? is there further discussion not hearing any can we do a role yes austin smith yes david silk nicholas messina absent eric dinn yes kelsey robertson yes joseph zamboni yes thank you for being here thank you for your presentation thank you jira thank you all that is the end of our business we do not need a motion to end the evening Thanks a lot. Great.