Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:08] Speaker A (unidentified): And we're alive. Thank you, Adam. Good evening, everybody. You have found your way to the November 10th meeting of the Health, Human Services, and Public Safety Committee of the Portland, Maine City Council. My name is Anna Bullett. I represent District 4, and I am the chair. This evening, we will be missing Councilor Fournier, who could not make the meeting, but we have our other members here. So, Councilor Michniewicz, if you want to introduce yourself, and then Councilor Pelletier, that would be great. Sarah Michniewicz, District 1. [Speaker B (unidentified): Vice-Piloteer, District 2.] And Assistant City Manager Jordan, do you want to have staff introduce themselves, if you don't mind?
[0:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Sir, hi, I'm Greg Jordan, Assistant City Manager, and I'll turn it over to Chief DuBois.
[0:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Good evening, everyone. Mark DuBois, Police Department, and give it to Ethan. He's a special guest tonight, I think.
[1:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Good evening, everybody. Ethan Hipple, Parks, Rec, and Facilities Director. I
[1:15] Speaker F (unidentified): think I'm last on that list. Good evening, everyone. I'm Maggie McLaughlin, HHS Director.
[1:20] Speaker A (unidentified): And I'd be remiss not also to mention that we have Adam running the tech for us tonight, and he is wonderful, and we appreciate his service to the city. The first thing on our agenda this evening is to review and approve the minutes from last meeting. If I could get a motion, that would be great. So moved.
[1:43] Speaker B (unidentified): I think Sarah's seconding, but is muted.
[1:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Moved by Councilor Pelletier, seconded by Councilor Michniewicz. Councilor Pelletier, how do you vote? Yes. Councilor Michniewicz? Yes, and I am a yes. So let the record show that the minutes from the October 13th meeting have been approved. The next item on the agenda tonight, and one that I assume many members of the public are here to hear about, is the winter warming emergency shelter update. date. And so for that, we are going to turn to the director of HHS, Director McLaughlin. Thank
Referrals
[2:18] Speaker F (unidentified): you for being here. Sure. And thanks for the opportunity to talk about this. So after council moved forward a vote to progress with winter warming at the 166 Riverside location, we've been busy with preparations to make that happen. Our biggest constraint is staffing and hiring up as quickly as possible. So we've sent out staffing and basically recruitment flyers to all the partners that are up at every campus, major campus in the greater Portland area. And we've also been promoting it internally amongst staff for staff referrals. We have nine folks lined up for interviews this week, and we'll have another staffing fair early next week. Other than that, we've just been progressing the various different contracts and orders that we need to get in place in order to have the supplies ready for the December 15th opening date.
[3:14] Speaker A (unidentified): That's it on my side. Thanks for that update. If you don't mind sending us the flyer to the council email, that would be great. Some of us specifically, Councilor Pelletier, have very big social media followings, and so it would be good if we can do some cross-posting. Are there any questions for Director McLaughlin? None? Okay, great. My only question is if the HR department has, I know that the mayor asked in a meeting that Dina and I had with some community partners, if our HR might be able to like move fast. Are they showing partnership
[3:58] Speaker F (unidentified): in that? Of course. HR has been doing everything they can to fast track any requests that are coming in for winter warming. I can say across the city, there's been really great interdepartmental work going on to make sure this remains a priority. All right, great, thanks so much. I'd love to hear
[4:14] Speaker A (unidentified): departments working well together, so fantastic. If there are no other questions for the director, we will move on to our next item tonight, which is an update on the Cotton Street food distribution. And for this, I think it's going to be Assistant City Manager Jordan.
[4:31] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you. That's
[4:34] Speaker C (unidentified): right counselor just give me a second here okay so we discussed the operations over at the cotton street food distribution center the last couple of meetings beginning with a report from really maggie and her team back in july about how things have been going and also zeroing in on some of the impacts that we've been seeing over there and may need to take a take some steps to mitigate in terms of neighborhood impact related to increases in litter and trash potential security related needs and also additional support for those who are who are attending there, making sure they're getting the attention and referrals that they that they need. And so we came back in the meetings in September and again last month to talk some of that through. And at the meeting in October, there was, I believe, some consensus around suggesting a referral to the Finance Committee for consideration as part of the FY28 budget to include for consideration the addition of two additional outreach workers to help with the continuity of their presence at this location so that we had people there at least most of the time if not all the time including on weekends so that was one piece that the committee I think expressed some support over the other piece was a minor increase in the public works staff of about a half time FTE to provide additional assistance with trash removal litter management things of that nature that's also something that I think the committee agreed might be something to put forward for budget consideration. I wanna clarify, cause we did have some feedback from the Portland Downtown District that I'm not referring to the ambassadors here, I'm referring to Public Works staff that do focus on the downtown area and do support the Cotton Street area. As you know, that operation is roughly half funded by PDD. And so this addition, we're not necessarily saying has to come from that side. It would be on the city side and go through our budget process. Also at the committee, I think there was not enthusiasm for adding additional constables. So we've not included that in the conclusions. I'm sorry, I should have referred to the conclusions section of your memo. Most of the memo is a repeat of last month's information. But if you scroll down to the conclusions section on page four, it kind of summarizes kind of where I think we were headed. So if the committee wishes you could take action to make a formal referral to the Finance Committee of those two items, again, the additional outreach workers and the additional litter and trash management assistance, would also say that would include roughly $10,000 in expense for additional containers that Mr. Murray over Public Works suggested could be helpful. There was also some conversation around the long term and whether and how we get to a point where this operation, this location is in a place that's more permanent and more maybe appropriate for the operation. That's obviously a longer-term prospect, but I think that there was some interest in having staff investigate options and bringing that back to a future meeting to move that forward as best we can. So that's my summary of where we have been and I think where you want to go, but certainly happy to answer any questions and make changes before you take any action if you wish.
[8:39] Speaker A (unidentified): That was great. Right. And yeah, I was like waiting for you to jump to the conclusion section. Question. If we are taking action and referring this to finance, do I need to take a formal vote? And if so, do I need to get a motion and then take public comment?
[8:54] Speaker C (unidentified): We did list it for public comment for that very reason. And I think all things being equal, it's probably better for the finance committee to have a formal referral or recommendation from this committee to consider once the budget process kicks off in February.
[9:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, agreed. Okay. So, to my colleagues, do you want to ask some questions now, or are you okay with doing public comment and then coming back?
[9:21] Speaker G (unidentified): After this time. Yeah, after this time.
[9:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, cool. So, at this time, I do see that there's attendees here. Not sure if they're here for this item, but we will open the – should I take the motion first?
[9:36] Speaker C (unidentified): I think public comment is fine first.
[9:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So we will be taking public comment on what the action we're considering right now. And that action is to send the conclusions summary of this memo and the fiscal impact note to the finance committee. So that's what we would be seeking public comment on. You need to say your name, where you live, what area you live in, and you have three minutes. Adam, if you don't mind keeping time, that would be fantastic. past it. We have one person with their hand up. So Michael, go ahead.
[10:17] Speaker H (unidentified): Mute. Hi, can you hear me? Yes, we can. Okay, thank you. So this is public comment regarding Cotton Street. I'm going to address this from the point of view of Bayside Neighborhood Association, Bayside itself. So based on the analysis of Cotton Street, we know that it's a little bit of a problem it's a mess it's tough wouldn't you say the same about Bay Street is a Bayside is what I would say and so I think ideally everyone's looking for a building or something there's assumptions in here but I'm preempting by saying let's keep in mind we won't want it in Bayside probably right and that's going to come up Prebble Street I'm not Prebble Street we just found out I just found out that Dyers is for sale And Pebble Street got a 1.1 million, they can't spend it on that, I don't believe. But things are coming together that could look like something, like there's a place we could put it. So I want that to be noted that these things have been considered. I think there's an acknowledgement in there of what the topic is, that a concentration of homeless people, unhoused people, creates a bit of a problem. And it's right now it's unable to be managed well, maybe you might say. So now everyone has an idea what happens in our neighborhood. Please take that into consideration. There's no real ask here, of course. I'll take feedback if you don't have anything.
[11:59] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll move on to the next public commenter. Thank you. Susanna R., if you could state your name and where you're from. You have three minutes. You'll need to unmute. And Adam, can you move Michael off? Thank you.
[12:23] Speaker I (unidentified): Sorry about that. My name is Susanna Richer. I am a resident of Portland, live in East Ering. And I'm glad that you're discussing the Cotton Street location. I think the idea of having additional caseworkers, outreach workers down there makes sense or wherever, because I know that if somebody is not on site, they are missed and people are asking for that connection. It makes sense and benefits many to offer consistent food and social services in one accessible location. This is why the Cripple Street Resource Center was such a beneficial resource to the community, a loss that's left a void that still needs to be filled. If your wish is to provide food and support with dignity to those who are at the lowest point in their lives, then feeding them outside in a very public place surrounded by businesses and tourists is not the answer. Being on public display while experiencing poverty is humiliating. Being forced to be fed outside adds tension to an already stressful situation. Throwing more money at garbage patrol is not productive or fiscally responsible, in my opinion. Moving people along that have no place to go is also an exercise in futility. Giving them a place to go is the goal. So once again, bringing people inside and solves or reduces many of the trash and public safety issues that are of concern, whether, you know, no matter where that is, it's safer if people are inside than outside for everybody in the community. And it's much more productive investment in the long run to invest in an indoor space instead of trying to manage this constant flow of outside conflict and garbage. So just to wrap up, establishing a day space downtown should be the primary focus of this committee. Not having it downtown doesn't make sense because that's where these folks are and that's what's accessible to them. But I think if people are inside, it's safer than outside. Side. So, thank you for your time and consideration.
[14:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you so much. At this point in time, if there is no other attendees who are putting their hand up. Oh, Joe McNally.
[15:04] Speaker J (unidentified): Go ahead, Joe. Hi, my name is Joe McNally. I am the Director of Homeless Services for Milestone Recovery, and I'm also a resident of Vesper Street in Portland. Milestone has been a part of the Cotton Street pilot since its inception. We are very proud of the work that it has accomplished and all the people that have been fed and have been referred to other services. I fully understand the issues that it can cause as well, but I really would like to focus on the positive that it has accomplished and all the people that we have helped along the way. Cotton Street has been a great place for the hope navigate gators to meet with those that are unsheltered and to move them into permanent housing. And I understand that it is not a good long-term solution, but I do feel in the short term that it is very effective and is doing its job well. And Milestone will continue to support it in whatever capacity we can. Thank you.
[16:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks, Joe. We appreciate you being here. If there is, oh, Assistant City Manager Jordan, can I close public comment first or do you need to say your thing? Okay. Michael, your hand is still up, but okay, good. You already went. So with that, I will say going once, going twice, and public comment is closed. Thank you everybody for being here this evening.
[17:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Assistant City Manager Jordan, go ahead. Thank you. I should have noted earlier that Director McLaughlin's staff had done some outreach to our various partners in this work to get feedback on the ideas that we had just talked about before you went to public comment, and in general there was support for the potential addition of outreach staff, some support for trying to do a better job containing and corralling the litter, and more specifically about improving our coordination and interaction between both PD and the constables and city staff that are down there and the food providers that are down there in order to work together and try to create the safest space possible. And so I think from a management perspective, we'll certainly be pursuing that independent of what you do here, so wanted to chime in on that. Yeah.
[18:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks for that update. No, it's always, we always assume that good community partner engagement is happening, but it could be, it's, we like, we like to hear that it has. All right, so at this juncture, I guess if there's questions for any of the city staff from my colleagues, that would be great. Seeing none, I can take a motion to vote on this to move it to the finance committee. [Speaker B (unidentified): So moved. Second.] Moved by Councillor Pelletier, seconded by Councillor McNovich. Councillor Pelletier, how do you vote? Yes. Council McNovich, yes. And I'm a yes. So we have voted to move this item to finance for consideration for the fiscal impact for the next budget year. Also acknowledging that separately, this committee will continue to work to find an inside location that could serve this purpose in a more holistic and safe approach. Thank you so much. We are moving on. The next item is also Assistant City Manager Jordan. And you're doing some heavy lifting tonight, Greg. And it sounds like this will be less of an in-depth overview just because we've had a lot of other urgent issues. And so I will give it to you so you can tell us where you're at.
[19:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Sure. Thanks. Yeah. After the meeting from last month where there was consensus around establishing a task force to tackle the interrelated problems of both unsheltered homelessness and downtown public, not downtown necessarily, public safety, mostly in our more urban areas. Is. And so with that direction, we began work on trying to provide some draft language around a charge of that group and other elements related to how it would stand up, how it would do its work, and bring it back to you for review, comment, and helping us move towards some sort of resolution that council would act, enact to stand up that body. As Counselor Bullet mentioned, we've had some other commitments going on, and so we haven't quite gotten it into a level where as a fully fledged draft document. It was ready for discussion. However, I do want to share a couple of slides and get your feedback if it's okay on some of the core ideas or parameters of such a task force that we would want your general feedback on, and so we can have a quick conversation about that. And I'm just going to share my screen and take you through a couple of the high points. Everybody seeing that okay? All right, I'll just start with the broad goals and authority of a task force. So the starting point is at least at this point the policy goals that were previously suggested by the HHSPS committee I think two months ago now, which were to identify not necessarily in this particular language but in terms of a committee a task force charge identifying recommended policies to reduce unsheltered homelessness and then also recommend policies to improve the safety and accessibility of public spaces. And so it's worded slightly different than what you had seen in prior committee meetings but it's functionally the same thing. The question for all of you, I guess, to provide some feedback on is, these are pretty broad policy goals. And I think the question is, should they be somewhat narrowed in order to give the task force as concrete a task as we can and set them up for an outcome that can move back to council and hopefully move towards some level of attention and implementation? And so the more narrow we can tailor the charge the more the better chances I think we have that we'll see success. And so I'll go through a couple more things I think we can go back and take your comments and questions about some of these concepts. The next section general authority, I think we would all probably agree this is this is an advisory to the City Council and assignment, the assignment would be to recommend policy direction and priorities to the city council for further action from there. And so no major question there I think that's pretty common sense. Getting into the specific charge of the task force and so these are some elements that the task force could be charged with, this is just a starting point and again you Know getting your ideas about what would make the most sense and also be at a high enough level that you know they're able to sort of assess the landscape of what's happening and be able to recommend priorities and policies for the council. And so the one thing that we do think from a staff perspective might be useful is to use a prior task force's work as a starting point. Wouldn't mean you have to do anything specific that was in there, but just sort of check in with where that left off and what's been done and maybe what's not from there. And so there is a section on the city's webpage that covers all of the materials that particular task force did quite some time ago now, 15 years ago now, but could be a useful starting point. The second major element prepare an assessment of current conditions and gaps in service, essentially mapping the gaps as we have often talked about, to understand where we may have to be very clear about where we need to work to fill in those gaps. Since this is very much tied up with the issue of public safety, you know, prepare an assessment of current safety trends of public spaces and see where that's lining up in relation to our other issues that we're facing. The committee had some, I think, strong opinions about the need to engage our partners around the state including the region, the county, and of course the state, because they have roles in this whole issue and to seek their cooperation and support. And so having the task force you know identify where those areas of support could come from and then again help inform the council on how to best take action and focus our energy in those areas. The last thing which is really the goal of the whole task force is to recommend a limited set of priorities and policy proposals for council consideration. And so again, as a starting point, and we can sort of talk about how this could be evolved before we come back next time with a more fully fledged charge. The last piece of feedback I'll ask from you is on participation. This is just a list of the I guess the major areas that could be represented on a task force, and so seeking your feedback on our on these areas. So City Council, individuals with lived experience, providers from the behavioral health and substance use area, homeless response and housing services providers, public safety, impacted residents, impacted businesses, potentially city staff, county or state government, and any other ideas you think we should consider as we kind of begin to flesh this out. And so those are really the three to four, I think, main areas I wanted to get some feedback on. It would be enormously helpful for us as we try to sort of narrow that charge down to something that can come back to you in January and then move on to the full city council for enactment by resolution, hopefully also in January. I realize this is not in your packet but we can we'll certainly put it there to make sure it's there for the public to see but I'll stop sharing for the moment and can go back to it you know I'll keep it open and we'll just kind of go from here if that's okay let's go back to the beginning and I'll turn it back to the chair and you can help us navigate some of these questions. Yeah, thanks
[26:47] Speaker A (unidentified): so much I really appreciate that and I appreciate all the different very large projects that have been on the plates of the department heads of late as we, you know, wrap in construction season. And, you know, we had this like thing happen last week that also has taken a lot of attention. So I have a couple things I want to say, and then I want to ask my colleagues for their input. So when it comes to goals in my day job, I've been working really hard to make sure that my goals are positively worded rather than negatively framed. And then also like, somewhat measurable. And so, for that first one, obviously, you alluded to this. It's very vague. It's, you know, very what. And so, I like the framework from the Durham Strategic Plan, which, and I think that their number one goal is to make homelessness rare, brief, and non-recurring. So, I'm just throwing that up there for you to do a little research on with the team. And then another one that sometimes I've seen in other frameworks is the goal of eliminating chronic homelessness using integrated care. Also vague, though, and like not necessarily measurable. So I'm just like putting that out there. But I will say the two places I would recommend looking the most would be the Durham strategic framework from Durham, North Carolina, and then the federal all in plan. land. I think those are two really good references with lots of toolkits. And to that end, to that end, what I would say is I think for some municipalities, from my research, it seems that having an academic institution as a partner can be really, helpful. And so I don't know who the best person is to do that sort of outreach, especially if we're not showing up with research funding. But I would be remiss not to say this could be an opportunity for the Cutler Institute or for USM School of Public Health or UNE School of Public Health. UNE has incredible researchers and epidemiologists. They have a whole division that does really cool reporting. And I would just say it's possible that we could expand our capacity without having to pay for academics to be involved if we partnered up and went after a research grant so that was something I've been like sitting with the last month too as I thought or as I was trying to think about how we could do this in a way that was like really results and data driven without it costing us a ton of money to like hire a consultant but also include like a local academic institution so that they get it, right? We're not like having someone come in from somewhere else. So those are the high level things I just wanted to say. And then on that last one, the only thing I saw missing from the task force member list was a health system provider. And I don't mean a behavioral health provider. I mean like an ER doc or nurse practitioner, you know, physician's assistant who's working with this population that maybe is coming in for infectious disease or wound care or something like that. So that's what I would add. Sorry, that was a lot. I've just been, like, laying awake at night thinking about this for the last two months, and so I had a lot to say. So with that, I will be quiet, and I will ask my colleagues, Councilor Pelletier and Councilor Michniewicz, what you have to add. Go ahead, Councilor Pelletier.
[30:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Can I get clarity on what the impacted residents and impacted businesses might be?
[30:27] Speaker C (unidentified): I think from a public safety standpoint, it's residents and businesses, I think, particularly on the peninsula, that may be experiencing the impact, the public safety related impacts associated with the broader problem. I think that's the idea of having that sort of balanced, I guess, viewpoint of all sides
[30:50] Speaker B (unidentified): of the issue. Right. Yeah. I don't know. Like, I don't know if that's worth it where it's, you know, they're not going to want, they are going to not want to see homeless people around. So, like, it may be good to have a session in which that's taken into account, but, you know, I guess it couldn't hurt to have impacted residents and businesses on, but it does seem like it is just, you know, to say that we listened to residents and businesses. And, you know, I would like to hear, I would like this to be more data driven and more solutions focused rather than what we tend to hear, which is I don't want to see services in my area. Yeah. So that I don't know what you can do with that, but that is that is going to be a hurdle should we try to, you know, specifically fold in people that do not want these services in their area into the into the task force.
[31:52] Speaker C (unidentified): I like what you said specifically about being solution focused. And I could very easily see that being something called out in the charge and the scope that all participants have to come to the table with that kind of hat on.
[32:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Right. I think also defining a solution is important. Like, do we, are we just going to build a big building to put homeless people in? Like, is that, like, you know, I think, and I don't know that, I think it may be the job of the task force to define that, or it may be the job of, there should be some thought into defining what a solution looks like. Because, you know, many would say we have a solution right now. So.
[32:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I think that kind of takes us back a little bit to the goals to conversation. Right. Right. How do we want to how do we want to set this up to achieve something that is achievable, both maybe in the short run, certainly, but also a little bit more in the long run? And then, you know, I think I think the purpose of the task force is to figure out those solutions, right, that they think might achieve those end states that we're all after.
[33:00] Speaker B (unidentified): Right. Yeah, I think we're having a philosophical discussion, and I think this is a great proposal, so I endorse it and also support the chair's suggestions.
[33:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks. Councilor Michniewicz, your thoughts and questions?
[33:18] Speaker G (unidentified): Great. Thanks. Yeah, I'm glad to see that this is coming along this way. I think this is a really helpful framework. I appreciate the way it's been laid out. I do want to recenter this, though, on the fact that we are here specifically because of the public safety implications. And, you know, as folks on this committee have said, it's become a serious public health and safety issue and violent incidents are part of the impetus for even bringing this forward. And that's obviously not the only issue here, but I just want to make sure we are balancing both of those. This isn't strictly about, you know, solving homelessness, which is a we're not going to do on our own. That's that's part of why we want other stakeholders in the room. But the I will I will push back on the idea that businesses are and then residents are incapable of having a balanced perspective or caring about the people that are that are sometimes involved with the issues that they are complaining about. out, that is categorically not true. And I think there are a lot of very compassionate and very informed people, residents, business owners, and that's part of the constituency we're serving. I don't see how we get to a good solution without involving folks who are experiencing this from that perspective. To me, that is a very important constituency. And I've talked to plenty of folks who their first priority when they bring this up is that they want to make sure that the solutions are helpful for the people who are, even as they may be speaking, you know, involved in something that's causing them stress with their business or their life. So that,, that to me is non-negotiable, that 's someone, that's a population we need here. The, 2012 task force, I will point out that had some good structure and some good ideas. that did focus strictly on the, this homelessness prevention, which clearly we didn't work out so well. So we need to, just keep in mind that this is a broader charge. I, don't, I mean, broader in general, I think it's, it does make sense that we want to keep it pretty specific, as to the point on the first slide. The, let's see, the, I really do appreciate the suggestion about an academic institution. I think the Cutler Institute would be a good one. They are the ones who conducted the study on traffic stops, specifically in Bayside, and just did a really great job gathering data on traffic stops and race. And I generally speaking having sort of some neutral data gathering is going to be really helpful and important in making decisions. Let's see here, can you go back to the, actually wait a minute, sorry, you forward again, the, yeah, there we go, yeah. I mean, I don't know if that's the right source for kind of assessing the conditions and gaps in service, but it's regardless of who that is, that's that's a kind of where we have to start so that we have the, so we know what we're working toward, yeah, I think that kind of covers it. Can you go to the last slide? Okay. I think that all makes sense. Good.
[37:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, counselor. And as you were talking about the importance of someone from impacted businesses or, you know, residential parts of the peninsula, the other thing that, I mean, I agree with you, but the other thing that came to mind was, and maybe this could be one of like the council appointed positions or the mayor appointed or however we decide on the framework, Greg, but I would like to see representation from the library if possible, you know, like a staffer who's been there a long time or even a patron, I don't know, like, but just thinking about or having them involved if they're even maybe not a member on the task force per se, but I just don't want to, I don't want to leave anybody out. I also want to keep it nimble and like able to move things. Go ahead, counselor
[38:23] Speaker G (unidentified): McNovitt, she has something to add to that. Yeah, the in terms of behavioral health and the, you know, the because I see we in terms of public safety, the behavioral health unit is going to be, I think, a really good resource, specifically the Bridget Slewak, I mean, if she's willing or somebody within the behavioral health unit, because they really do bridge those two pop, those two areas of, you know, public safety and public health, and you know, well, you know, Council Bullet, you were in the same meeting I was with Rachel Talarash and British is great. I think she would be a really good addition if or if she were willing, not to start naming people specifically, but you know, that's really that connective tissue between the two areas that we're we're hoping to address, and I think that's it, thanks.
[39:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, go ahead, Greg, I think
[39:30] Speaker C (unidentified): Counselor, bullet to your last point about the library and needing to keep the task force, you know, as efficient as we can in order to get to results. I think could also imagine, you know, that the task force has a pretty robust, you know, sort of stakeholder or public involvement sort of component to it, where we could bring in, meet with, listen to those more specific entities that, you know, maybe they don't necessarily belong in the task force itself, but we want to hear from them. And I think we could make sure we structure that in the right
[40:10] Speaker A (unidentified): way. Yeah, absolutely, that's a great point. And the other thing I wanted to mention was the continuum of care from the state absolutely has to be involved in some way, not as a task force member necessarily, but to your point, like a, you know, a stakeholder that's really engaged and knows what's going on. And it sounds like the state might have just noodled around that contract a little bit, and it sounds like Pebble is holding it, so that's good, because obviously we are friends with them, so we can find out what's going on there. Council McNovich.
[40:44] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, the only thing I wanted to add is I think that's a good point about having specific institutions maybe, you know, coming in and speaking, but on the on the task force itself, it, you know, like Portland Downtown is sort of at that juncture as well, kind of like with the BHU, and that would be a really helpful touch point I would think for direct membership. Yeah, I almost think assistant
[41:14] Speaker A (unidentified): city manager that we're going to need to do some sort of like public noticing of like open call and like ask for input, like it did, you know, here's what we're thinking, did it, did we miss anyone, just to cover our bases, right, and like you said, we'll find a way for them to be engaged if it doesn't make sense for them to be like a active member of the task force, but I absolutely think we should do some sort of open call to action for participation in the especially
[41:42] Speaker G (unidentified): as it gets going. Okay, yeah, and I would just add the, you know, I'm thinking again of the social housing task force and how that worked, and you know, bringing in, bringing in certain stakeholders and having, you know, kind of this plotted arc of what type of work we're going to engage in, and so we'd be able to, we have a base of folks who are interested in the beginning. We can then, you know, refer back to that to bring folks on board for those specific days or topics. And there was one other thing and it's escaping me, so I'll move on.
[42:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. So we've put a lot on you, Assistant City Manager. I hope it was helpful. I will just not to belabor the point, but I do think seeking out some sort of framework, you know, not just of stuff we've done in the past, but also that is out there. And that might have already been validated and researched or whatever, is also a great place if you haven't already done a dive there. Or go ahead. I just remembered what I was going to
[42:47] Speaker G (unidentified): say. Yeah. Cause we had talked before about potentially, like GP COG facilitating the way they did with,, the social housing task force and just, you know, providing support in that way. And, they just did a really fantastic job of kind of keeping us on task and making suggestions and being a connective tissue with the state, the county, and having a more regional perspective that was really helpful. So in terms of facilitation, that might be a good resource.
[43:21] Speaker C (unidentified): If I could just jump in, I think I should have put it on here. I think we assume there needs to be really strong facilitation services provided to the task force. And GPCOG has proven itself over and over again. And I think, Councilor McNevitz, you mentioned, too, they have that connected tissue across the region, across the county, and into the state level, too. So I think they're independent enough from the issue, but they have the skills and those connections, I think, to be helpful. But we could certainly consider other avenues also. But I do think that they're probably a place to start. I concur.
[43:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Her anything else on this item before we invite our parks department to share with us
[44:06] Speaker C (unidentified): The last thing I'll just know I it's it's hard to sort of get those goals a bit more tailored so if the committee is okay with it we'll take a crack at some narrowing and when we come back with and this is all really great feedback we'll do our best to incorporate this into the written and scope that we'll come back to you with in January and try to do a little bit of narrowing of the goals, policy goals too, if that makes sense. So December, we're not going to address any of that? We don't typically have committee meetings in December because of the change in council and everything else. So the first, the next committee meeting, at least currently is, will be the second Wednesday and I'm sorry, second Tuesday in January. Okay. Yeah, that makes sense.
[44:50] Speaker G (unidentified): sense. I mean, it's been a little challenging because we haven't had materials ahead of time on this. But that in between now and then, if there are suggestions, I guess we can forward them on to you in terms of the specific policy goals. Absolutely. And certainly for the January
[45:07] Speaker C (unidentified): meeting, you'll have that document well in advance. Great. All right. Thank you.
[45:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks so much, everybody. And thank you, Assistant City Manager Jordan. This is a really great starting off point. So next on our agenda, and thanks to the members of the public who have stuck around to listen to this conversation and who I know will make themselves heard as we move through the process. I see you on the attendee side, so thank you for being here. Moving along, we have Director Hippel from Parks and Recreation here to talk to us about, it looks like the memo is specific to before and after care registration. And so I will let you go ahead, if that's okay, Director Hipple, and then we'll go from there.
[45:51] Speaker E (unidentified): Great. I'll just give a brief overview. So, good evening, everybody. Ethan Hipple, Director of Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Department. I think most of you all know this, but just a quick overview of our department to kind of set the stage for what I'm talking about tonight with our recreation division. We have four divisions in our department. Parks, which is obviously all the parks and playgrounds and et cetera, in forestry. We have a public buildings and waterfront division, which oversees pub, Portland's public buildings, such as City Hall and Kanko Road and, Merrill Auditorium, is also, you know, as well as our waterfront. We have our public assembly facilities division, which oversees our cultural institutions, Expo, Ocean Gateway, et cetera. And on all the programming at Merrill Auditorium, And then last but not least, what we're going to be talking about tonight is our recreation division. The rec division oversees all of our community programming from toddler swim lessons to senior adult trips. They oversee our aquatics facilities, so our three city pools. schools. They oversee our community centers, our four community centers throughout the city that are co-located at schools, but run by the city. And they oversee our Riverside Golf Course. That's a big recreational facility and activity. So tonight, I just wanted to give an update in some kind of an update on our before and after care program that's run by the Rec Division. It's It's one of our larger programs. The program, we run it at all nine school sites. So eight mainland elementary schools, as well as Peaks Island School. And historically, the city has run this program for decades. It's been very popular. We have approximately, we're budgeted, thanks to the council. Council in boosting our budget in recent years and adding staff. We're budgeted to be able to handle about 450 kids in a given year across those nine sites. And some programs are bigger than others, like Rowe Elementary has a very large program. It's a bigger site. There's more room. There's more demand in the neighborhood. And some sites like East End and Presumpt Scott have lower enrollment. It might be 20 to 30 kids at those sites and, you know, 60 or 70 at some of the larger sites. But overall, about 450 kids is what we are budgeted for staff-wise. We've got a great group of staff that administer the program and run the program on-site. Each site has in between two and five staff, depending on how many kids we have enrolled there. Those are our programmer positions. A few years ago, we, in order to better attract and retain staff, as well as to build the quality of the program, we changed the staff ratio from one staff to 15 kids down to one staff to 13 kids. That's done a lot, I think, to improve the quality of the program. You know, what we've always said is we're we're not a warehouse program for kids. This is a recreational program, and there's a program to it. There's there's planned activities that change week to week and day to day, and so having that lower ratio really helps us deliver a quality program. And so that is borne out in our registration numbers. So every year we get our spots all fill, and we have significant wait lists of which I know the city council and I and others hear about from your constituents and our constituents. The public has really come to depend on this as a core city service. There's also other after before and after care options in Portland run through community organizations, churches, you know, other schools, Breakwater School, there's there's several churches that run aftercare programs, and some of them provide transportation from the elementary schools to sites off-site. But despite that, there's still greater demand than there is capacity for collectively for all of these organizations to provide, including the CITES program. So, even when we, you know, have enough staff to run the program, you know, to our budgeted numbers of about 450 kids, we still have wait lists. In recent years, in the past five years, there's been a couple years, including this year, where we have not been able to attract enough staff to deliver the full 450 slots. So, this year, to stay within that ratio that I talked about earlier at each site, we intentionally limited enrollment to about 380 when we did enrollment registration during the summer months. As we got closer to school start date and we were able to hire additional staff and move slots around to different sites, it's a fluid process. We were actually able to let in about an additional 20 kids off the wait list. So right now we're at about 400 kids have been enrolled into the program across the nine sites. And that does change week to week. We do have people who stop going for whatever reason. We can let other people in off the wait list. And when we're able to add, you know, a staff member at a site, we're able to let in roughly 13 kids off of each wait list or off of that site's wait list. So, you know, we here, and so that's why I'm here tonight is just to talk about that and, you know, the fact that every year parents, you know, they really depend on this program. Some of these are single parents, Some of these are parents where both parents need to work, and they really depend on this core city service. And so what we are interested in doing is, in our putting forward here, is just ensuring fairness and kind of an equitable distribution of those, the slots that do exist. fist. So, you know, whether we have the full 50 or whether we have 380 in a given year, hopefully we're able to get creative and aggressive on recruiting and retaining staff. And that's kind of a separate effort. But assuming we fill all the staff slots and we have enough to let in the 450 kids, there's still going to be a wait list and there's still going to be, you know, families who are wait-listed. So our current registration process is that people create an account in our software that we subscribe to, the registration software that many cities across the country use. It's called MIREC. They create a MIREC account for their family and for their child. And then at a set time, you know, usually it's in, you know, it's been in July. We're looking at moving that earlier and I'll get into those reasons as we go along here, but the, you know, at a set date at 6 p.m. registration opens and all of those 380 or 450 families go on and click the buttons as quick as they can to get a spot. It's like buying concert tickets and, you know, that the concert is going to sell out, so you're trying to do it as fast as possible. So that's how the software works. That's how we've done the registration. And that does, you know, that could leave certain people out who maybe don't have as fast internet connections or access to technology or awareness of the registration date. So we're looking at ways to kind of create a more equal playing field in the registration. And that involves a lottery. That idea has been proposed over the years by many, just as a more fair way to distribute the available spots that we have. So this won't address capacity, but it will address fair distribution of the spots that are available. So under our kind of proposed plan here, we would actually start in early April by publicizing an open registration period that would last at least six weeks. Weeks. And during that period, we would do intensive outreach to neighborhood associations, immigrant associations, work with the natural helpers program, public housing, the school district, guidance counselors, all of our traditional partners that we work with across the community, Boys and Girls Club, you know, and partners who do some of the same work that we do, but just publicize the fact that we're having an open registration period for before and after care. And there's a multi-week period, six weeks in which to sign up. After that period ends, so we would cast a wide net during that period. After that period ends, we would hold a lottery, probably a day or two after the period ends, and then divide the spots up per site based on those who had registered. So people would still use our registration system because that's how we communicate with our program participants and handle medical information and all the other things we need to know. So they would still have their account, but they would just register during an open registration period. And then we would hold a lottery to distribute the existing sites. And that would happen. The lottery timing would be held in mid-May. That's a request that we get frequently from families is by the time they found out they didn't get a spot. It's too late to go find another option. So we've been over the past couple of years, actually moving the registration date earlier every year to respond to that feedback. This plan would move it even further to mid-May. I think this year it was mid-June. So we'd actually do a month, a full month earlier. And so that lottery would take place in mid-May. That gives people the entire summer for either a spot to open up with us if we are able to add capacity or to find another spot elsewhere. So I'll leave it at that. That's just a primer on how our program registration works and what we're proposing to, you know, to make it more fair and, you know, more equally distribute the sites or the spots that we do have. So yeah, with that, I'm open for questions. Thank you so much for that great
[57:34] Speaker A (unidentified): overview. Assistant City Manager Libner, do you need to take public comment on this? Is this a vote or is this just a communication?
[57:42] Speaker K (unidentified): That's a great question, Chair. This is a communication to the committee. There have been specific... You had actually asked and recommended a lottery. And that prompted staff to look at it more closely and evaluate it. And it turned out to be a great match given the high demand for this program. So this is just to update the committee and the public, although we'll do much more when it ramps up and people need to register for the lottery. But just to let you know the plan for this administrative change.
[58:13] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, cool. Are there any questions from my colleagues? No? Okay. I had just one question, Ethan, and that was, if there is a way to hold back spots in case there's like McKinney-Vento kids, so these are kids that are protected by the law around children who are homeless and accommodations that they have to be afforded by the school department. So wondering if there's a way to sort of always make sure we have a couple of those in our back pocket that you have as needed in the last minute.
[58:57] Speaker E (unidentified): Absolutely. Yeah. Within this system, we've we've accounted for spots that we would withhold for fee waivers. So that's our version of a scholarship. That's how we call it. It's just waived revenue, waived fees, as well as McKinney-Vento spots. We coordinate with the school department. Just today, our staff were working with the school department on new enrollments, McKinney-Vento enrollments. So we always accommodate those and those would be accounted for in this.
[59:29] Speaker A (unidentified): So great. Love to hear it. And I know that maybe this is for some people that haven't been through this. This is actually a really monumental change. I mean, like, this is reminding me that, oh, it's almost December, which means I have to play in summer camp. Like, this is like one of the most stressful parts of parenting in Portland is like, is figuring out care outside of the workday or during the workday for your kids. And so the other piece I don't want to lose sight of, Ethan, is and this would be more for a finance committee but to figure out that part-time challenge right the fact that we have a hard time staffing mostly because they're part-time positions and people are looking for full-time work and so if there is a way that we can be really creative around getting some of these positions to have dual roles or whatever but so that they're like full-time at 30 hours with the city so that they're you know easier to fill I think that would be really phenomenal and I know it's not just you guys right it's Head Start it's other forms of child care all over so that was my one thing is like keep noodling that around and hopefully maybe we can bring something to finance committee around making some of these positions but I you know counselor Phillips it has a vested interest in this too. She thinks that they should work at the Barron Center in the morning and then go work after care. But that's, I'll let her explain her theory there. And then the third, the last thing I wanted to say is the other thing I envisioned that I would just really love for our community, and I don't know if it needs to be on the city website or somewhere else, but it's some sort of landing page for families that really wraps it all up to show the care options, right? Like right now you're like googling or you're getting that like kids count book or whatever to see like what even is there 's you know we all know if we've had kids in the system that there's portland community squash and there's boys and girls club but then you find out about one that you didn't even know about and so what would that look like to create some sort of landing page that we just have links to everything and that we keep it updated on a yearly basis i would love for us to be able to coordinate that somehow. So just putting, I'm wish casting to use a counselor pillow to your word, so just putting that out there into the into the universe. That's actually
[1:02:02] Speaker E (unidentified): being worked on. That's something we can do is be a clearinghouse. Like even though we may not run a program or endorse it, you know it's out there, parents can look at on it into it on their own, and we are aware of a lot of the options. And so and we do give that information out when parents ask us, but that it's a very easy step to take to just put it out there. So yeah,
[1:02:25] Speaker A (unidentified): it would really be cool especially if then there was emphasis of all of these other care providers to maybe like follow your lead on the lottery or to line up their registration dates. I mean in a perfect world that is you know what we would be looking at to really get to equitable solutions. All right. I won't belabor this point with all of my parenting woes, but if there's no other questions, it sounds like we don't have to vote. All right. So thank you so much for making this happen. I hope the community gets some benefit from it and I look forward to seeing how it works out. Me too. Thank you. Have a good night. You too. All right. I think we have one more thing on our agenda and that would be a update from the police chief. Thank you for being here with us.
[1:03:19] Speaker D (unidentified): Good evening. I will start with the current status and then move on to the it was a request to just talk about the recruitment in the current process. We have 26 vacancies right now as you we're budgeted for 158. We have 26 vacancies and two pending retirements in December, which will give us 28. We also have two people on military leave and a couple more going, and that's a year-long deployment. One of them being Major King, which is going to be a huge loss for us for a year. So he leaves January 1st for, well, January 4th, but he'll be out for the whole 2027. We also have seven people out on some type of family medical leave, such as having a baby or injured on duty with it just in a recovery mode. And then we had five out with officer involved shooting, three returns. So two are still out. And that's essentially through the attorney general's office they have to give us the clearance to let them return to work so they're going to be back in a couple weeks we have a date scheduled for them so as those are the vacancies we did hire the last two recruit classes just to give you some perspective 17 people but nine remain so we lost six or you know eight actually eight throughout the process for a whole host of reasons we currently have six in the academy as part of that number so Essentially that gives us 45 operational vacancies is where we're at when you kind of add everything up. On the flip side our whole process is geared towards when the state runs their police academies they do two a year. The one we're currently in started like the first week in August. They graduate around December. I think it's 18th, but I'm not exactly sure. The next academy will start February 1st. So we deal with our process based on those two dates. So knowing that, we have one officer who started yesterday so when we when we get somebody through the whole process and get them ready for the police academy we bring them in and just kind of get them started by learning all kinds of things that they're going to need to know anyway so it just kind of gets us a head start on it and it secures their spot so we have one start yesterday we have one starting next week so those are new hires in the process that we're in currently we're kind of Winding down because we just don't have enough time to complete everything by the February 1st start date, but there's a few things coming up. So the process, some of the statistics, we had 162 applications for this current Academy, which is February 1st. They initiated like a online application. They have to complete a few things and submit some documents. And so that ultimately resulted in 42 people coming in and taking the written tests, which we do pretty much at their convenience. Based on that, we had 36 people pass it and go to the fitness test. And not everybody passes that, but if they get fairly close and we think we can get them over the hurdle for the academy, because it's a requirement at the academy to do certain things, which we don't have any control over. We work with them, but as a result of that fitness test, we had 31 candidates get interviewed. And it resulted in the two that are hired, and there's eight candidates currently in the background process, which is pretty comprehensive, but that takes some time. And that's really what really takes the most time when we're hiring people. People and we've had 14 written in fitness testing dates so far for this academy so we try to do them as often as possible we kind of set a date and fill it up and then have everybody come in and just kind of keep it moving so it's pretty fluid we have some set dates like you know every like Thursdays we'll do it and then Saturdays but we've had 14 for this academy class the recruitment piece of it I think the applications is really online so that's like the epic recruiting that we've we've Contracted with I think we get a pretty good response from them it's been pretty effective you know with the with that amount of people it's just getting them through the next steps the recruitment team is a sergeant and is about I think six or eight officers that are what's considered our recruitment team. So they're required to do certain things throughout the year to be on the team. So they attended for this academy class. They've done nine career fairs or events. They've done seven presentations at colleges and high schools. We had one dedicated hiring event that we hosted that we tried to get everybody through as much as we could in one day. So we get people from out of state that come in and we try and process everything we can for them and the upcoming events so they have two more classroom discussions at one at UNE and one at St. Joe's criminal justice programs and we have a two testing dates scheduled Saturday this coming Saturday November 14th we have 15 people scheduled to take the written test and they'll take the physical at the same time most of them sometimes they differ but and then Tuesday November 24th we have three people scheduled so far and they have interview dates scheduled in like a couple days after that so they'll do the written test they're physical and when they get through that then we have to bring in based on civil service requirements a couple people for the interview. So we don't do those the same way. And that's where we're at. It's an ongoing process. It never stops. We have people that are working on it. I would say actually every day between the police and dispatch. dispatch. We don't have the volume in dispatch, but we still do quite a bit with them also. Yeah, that's pretty much where we're at right now. We've kind of stopped what we're doing only because the process takes so long. We didn't actually stop, but we'll stop scheduling stuff until probably after the holiday season because the Academy starts February 1st. So we will start working on the july academy probably after the new year so it's like i said it's just constant constantly revolving subject
[1:10:53] Speaker A (unidentified): to any questions yeah great that was really comprehensive thank you it does sound like it's constant between the leaves and the 24 7 365 nature of it I can only imagine the Tetris that is happening on a regular basis.
[1:11:13] Speaker G (unidentified): Councilor McNavidge. Yeah. Thank you for that overview. I really appreciate it. Always makes me think what I think I've probably asked this before, but what is, what is like the magic number that you feel would cover everything and you'd have enough for the buffer for when people are out?
[1:11:31] Speaker J (unidentified): Like a total number. Yeah.
[1:11:34] Speaker D (unidentified): I've said this several times I don't know in this setting but I think our number if we were to do everything that we should be doing probably close to 200.
[1:11:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay so that would be like there'd be a buffer there'd be like coverage for traffic enforcement that the at the level that people would like to see.
[1:11:56] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean a perfect example and we run into this quite honestly very often is detectives we have 12 and they really have to pick and choose what they can work on and follow up on and it ends up really being the most serious cases so some of those things that people probably shouldn't have followed up on we just don't have the resources for that traffic's another one i mean we deal with this constantly traffic's a challenge to get people Because the officers that are out there are really stretched with calls for service. And the best example, I would say, or a very common example, is we have people come into the lobby to, say, file a report. And they'll call dispatch to schedule somebody to come in. And the people can sit there for, honestly, easily an hour. Because what will happen is somebody will be heading in, and then something else more serious will occur, and they get diverted, and it just kind of gets bumped back based on the seriousness of the calls that we have pending. So we do get complaints about that. Well, I think when we explain it to people, they understand, but you know, it's frustrating for them waiting in the lobby not knowing, you know, when someone's going to show up. Yeah, I mean, it takes a big chunk out of
[1:13:18] Speaker G (unidentified): of a day to have to go through that process. So I think if, did you say they were down to like
[1:13:27] Speaker D (unidentified): three on crew or something, like three? Yeah, one of the things that we've done to try and supplement this is we have what we call kind of like standing overtime. So we 've kind of put it out like basically part-time assignment, so they have a people that just work on crew, and they The crew's supervisor, the crew is the crime reduction unit, for people who don't know. We give them, like, you can have so many hours of overtime with people, so they kind of pick and choose when they schedule people to come in and work with the other people that are assigned there full time. But that used to be, I think the mayor told me when he was in it, there was like 17 people in it back a while ago. But I mean, three is certainly not enough. Yeah, well, and then that comes up when people talk
[1:14:25] Speaker G (unidentified): about, you know, why you hear this, why aren't, why are we going after the drug dealers, why aren't, why are we, why aren't we going to kind of further up that food chain, and that's who would be
[1:14:34] Speaker D (unidentified): addressing that. Yeah, the crew unit, they, I mean, simply put, is when we get complaints of suspicious activity at an apartment or a street corner or, you know, habitual issues at one location, they'll go and spend as much time as they need to try and resolve it, whether it's, you know, somebody dealing drugs or just whatever that tends to be what it is, but it could be a lot of other things. So we kind of have to prioritize those complaints with the amount of time the officers have to go sit there because it does take time. I mean, you have to sit there and watch and kind of figure out what's happening before they can take action and resolve it.
[1:15:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, good. That's helpful. I think it's just good to have context for the things that people wish we could be doing for overall street safety. And then my last question, I feel like I ask this every time too, is are you getting any more lateral hires or is it mostly coming through
[1:15:39] Speaker D (unidentified): The academy at this point it's it's a little bit of both, but I would say the majority are new hires. They're not we have some people from out of state that are in the background process right now that are police officers elsewhere that we don't have to send to the police academy, so we do get a few of those, but the vast majority are our new hire police officers that need to go to the
[1:16:04] Speaker G (unidentified): academy. And where do you where do you do you track where you kind of get the most bang for your buck, like where you've had hiring events or where you've done recruitment that have panned out
[1:16:14] Speaker D (unidentified): the best or is does it even work that way? No it does, the recruitment team kind of works with that where they might get a lot more success at certain schools, and also epic recruiting really tracks we get a lot of analytics from all the social media advertising where you know where we're getting applications from, so they'll they'll spend more time doing that kind of stuff, you know, localizing where they put in the ads. That's something they review monthly with the recruitment team, so you try and stay on top of it. Okay well yeah I really appreciate the update, it's a
[1:16:57] Speaker G (unidentified): huge differential from where we ought to be and where we are. Yeah I agree, so yeah I appreciate the continued effort. Any other questions
New Business
[1:17:12] Speaker A (unidentified): anything else? I was here I'm good. I really appreciate it, and I think that I obviously we're not you know adding anything to the work plan in November, right, but this is definitely something for the council to consider as it moves through the goals process right next month. And then think about work plans and what it would be to like help this issue, right? What would the policy action be instead of continuing to like live in this cycle of us all being stressed and frustrated by it? And then figure out where do we go from here and how can the council help you go there? So just, you know, putting that up there, put that up there so that you're ready with some with some thoughts in January to help inform that goals that goal setting and the and the policy work plan process if you don't mind. No sounds good, look forward to it, thanks so much. So that concludes our agenda for the evening, our as I mentioned as assistant city manager mentioned there is not a meeting in December, so the next meeting will be January 12th, which is wild to be talking about, but that's the Reality we are in. If there are no announcements or other new business from my colleagues, I will take a motion and then bid you all adieu. Second, moved by Councillor Michniewicz, seconded by Councillor Pelletier. Counselor, how do you vote? Yes. Counselor Michniewicz? Yes. And I am a yes. Thank you, everybody. We are adjourned at 6:51 p.m. Have a lovely evening, and we will see you Monday at chambers for full council.