← Back to MaineScanner

Planning Board issues advisory opinion for Blue Point Primary School expansion

2026-11-16 · 1h 22m · Source: Scarborough Virtual Planning Board Meeting - 2026-11-16 (Town of Scarborough (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[17:18] Chair of the Planning Board: I see we welcome to the November 16th 2026 Planning Board meeting. All those that are able, please rise and join us for the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Doreen, would you take the roll? [17:50] James Hebert: Rick Mining King? Here. James Hebert? Here. Roger Bealey? Here. Jennifer Ladd? Here. [17:56] William Sedlick: William Sedlick? Here. [18:01] Chair of the Planning Board: All right. Next order of business is the minutes from the October 19th, 2026. Doreen provided those in our packet and it's been online. line I would entertain a motion to enter those into the record so moved second all right thank you James and Roger any discussion I'm going to abstain from the vote as I was absent and enjoying some Wisconsin cheese and so therefore I won't vote on the minutes but saying no discussion I will ask Doreen for the roll. [18:47] Lisa Solwin: Yes. Yes. [18:54] William Sedlick: Yes. I think if I can't hear you. Yeah Doreen we can't hear you but I vote yes also. I get it. There you go. [19:03] Chair of the Planning Board: All right thank you all. For those online and in the audience in case we have others outside the looks like all school folks. We are tabling the action item or item for consideration on 4.02, the five lot conservation subdivision. Got a little work to do on an easement, so it's likely they'll come back to us soon. But tonight, our only item for consideration is 4.01. Harriman Associates on behalf of Scarborough Public Schools is requesting an advisory opinion for site plan review for the Blue Point Primary School that includes renovation, classroom expansions and site upgrades at 174 Pine Point Road Assessor's Map U28, Lot 2. Erin, you want to introduce this one? Sure. [20:01] James Hebert: So this is another school project we've seen come before us and there will be more to come. There will be a 12,000 and change, square foot expansion, proposed classroom and cafeteria expansion. We are removing the classroom, the portable classrooms, sorry, and some exterior redevelopment, including the pickup drop-off areas for both the buses and the passenger vehicles. And this will accommodate an anticipated enrollment from 216 students to 232 students in the years to come. So I believe there are several members of Harriman and the school department here I'd like to also make a [20:45] Chair of the Planning Board: presentation all right thank you Erin and for the school district good [20:54] Diane Netto: evening I'm Diane Netto I'm the superintendent here in Scarborough and I want to start off by thanking all of you for taking time again this evening I know that we are filling your date card in the next several months and so I really do appreciate that time. Before I invite my colleagues from Harriman to discuss the details of the project, just want to kind of ground us in the Blue Point project where this is the one that we're looking at this evening. And thanks to Erin for kind of kicking that off. So just to lay some background. So Blue Point School is a school that was built in 1965. It had a renovation of right around 50% of the school in 1993. And then in 2014, as a district, we started working on a long-range facilities plan to take a look at all of our schools. Also, four portables were added in 2001. And so this project is a renovation addition. It is really to right-size spaces more than it is to accommodate increasing enrollment at this site the goal is to remove the portables and to right-size the spaces for the needs of today's learners certainly in 1965 and i would argue even in 1993 schools were not tasked with the same responsibilities or student needs that we are now planning for and so spaces that are well undersized or not existing at Blue Point much like some of the other schools that you'll hear us talk about in the coming months include spaces for support interventions special services delivery to accommodate needs of today Blue Point also has a cafetorium, which is a cafeteria plus school gym. And so that really sets limits on the programming that we can have for physical education because it has to operate around our breakfast and lunch schedules. This is a school that also has a shared classroom space for music and art. On its face, that probably doesn't sound like a major issue for folks. But when you start thinking about the needs of each of those programs that are very unique, very hard in an undersized classroom, to be able to have things like musical instruments and the like, along with all of the art supplies and needs that a child would need for that class. this project also adds insulation which is like interesting in of itself right the original 1965 section of this school had no insulation and so that is going to be addressed along with air conditioning we have a lot of individualized student needs according to plans that sometime call for students to have to be in a more climate controlled room. And certainly our facilities director, Todd, can talk about the challenges, given the way the windows are organized in this building. You can't just pop an air conditioner in because they are tilt out windows. And so that in of itself just presents a problem. And then lots of issues around site safety that are going to be addressed as a part of this plan, including student drop-off and pickup, you know, taking a look at the way that the seals are between the walls and the roofing. And so we're really excited that the community came together and acknowledged the need and that we were able to rethink because I think as most people are aware, this was the second time at referendum before we got approval and we really went back to the community and did some hard thinking and conversations about what the people in this community wanted for their schools and how could we design around that so you know with that all said I will kick things off to my partners. [25:22] Lisa Solwin: Good evening my name is Lisa Solwin I am a partner in principal at Harriman I lead our pre-k through 12 design studio and the principal in charge of the Scarborough Project. Diane covered a lot about Blue Point. Just bigger context, this is one of five projects. The projects look at right-sizing the facilities for today and the future projected enrollment. As you saw, Blue Point does not have a significant increase in population. It is more of a right-sizing. At all the schools, we're looking to take the portables away. So the addition out back is to replace the portables. There'll be kindergarten classrooms as well as art and other support spaces related to special education in that space. There will be an addition if you're facing the front door to the right-hand side that is a cafeteria which is now separate from the gym which Diane had mentioned is a huge scheduling challenge when you have them combined. And so then we also have the separate art and music spaces there are selected renovations throughout remind folks that this is a project of a lot of needs and we really had to balance the needs versus the wants so we're not able to touch everything but it does a good job of balancing safety and security as well as right-sizing spaces and we take that all the way to the site where we prioritize separating the bus and parent drop-off so we don't have students crossing lines of traffic to get to the school and you'll see some other modifications that frank will go over in regards to sidewalks and crosswalks as well with that i'll turn it over to frank i'm [27:09] Frank Crabtree: frank crabtree civil engineer at harriman and this is cora mclean civil engineer at harriman car is going to i think i'm trying to share my screen okay if you want to use that would be probably just as easy the basic project has already been covered very well but we pretty much take care of everything outside the building and just want to do a brief overview of what is what are the major points the traffic control traffic revisions has been a big part of the project And aside from the building, which is one of the larger impervious features, traffic, the new bus loop off to the left is the other larger impervious addition. Right now, traffic comes in and out through one main entrance in the front and the other side entrance on the side street, and the buses and the parent drop-offs are fairly closely intertwined, which we really don't like. When we design a school, we really try to separate those as best we can. This has become a very good separation, where the buses have totally their own access drive and loop away from the parent drop-off. In doing that, it's also freed up space to improve the parent drop-off, because now the buses aren't in it, so the drop-off to the right-hand side is now totally a parent drop-off. it's gone from approximately eight or ten car capacity in the drop-off loop to about 18 cars so quite a large increase which we hope is really going to improve the traffic flow parking there's been about 12 cars added in the parking as well so the improvement on the parking and parent drop-off has been significant of the added impervious is about a half an acre total and it's being treated in two vegetated stormwater treatment basins they're not wet ponds they're dry basins that will fill up with water and then drain back down through the ground through the sandy soil. One is in the middle of the bus loop and the other is off to the side on the right hand side of the new building addition. The treatment of those is about double the new impervious. So in other words we're treating more than we're needing to and what's exiting the site as far as stormwater is cleaner than it is currently as far as number of square feet of area being treated so that's a really a plus we've been working with the town staff for a couple of weeks a couple weeks couple months on comments and responses to those comments we had a great meeting about two weeks ago i think with the staff prior to this meeting. Going through those questions, many of them come in through the third party inspector. And of the 40 review questions or so, we pretty much are on the same page with all of them. And coming out of that meeting, we pretty much had them all taken care of. I don't want to go through 40 comments. Just to hit a few of them, some of them were test pits on the plans for stormwater ponds something that hadn't been done yet the pits hadn't been provided we have those now and they're going to be on the new set of plans a bike rack was suggested so that's being added in the landscaping plan was done but it didn't have the plant list wasn't caught up with the with the plants so a few of those little things which weren't really very significant one that's being worked on right now in fact this morning we had a really a good meeting around traffic is a raised crosswalk across pine point road this had been requested with flashing beacons so that would be a safer crossing there is a crosswalk there now, but this one is going to be raised probably five inches or so with sloping sides coming up on either side and the flashing beakers on either side. So we think we've got that design pretty well nailed down now so that we can put that together for the final plan submission. That is pretty much everything that I had planned to talk about. I know it's brief, but i'd rather answer questions if there are any that's [32:57] Chair of the Planning Board: that's your presentation yes okay super is this one for public comment for advisories okay all right so as a matter of routine we're going to open this up for public comment i don't think there's going to be any but i have to open it up we'll see is there anybody online wishing to make a comment i don't see any hands online all right then i will close public comment and turn it over to my colleagues and james was kind enough to indicate that he works for harriman associates so we don't want to put him on the spot nor does he want to put himself on the spot so we thank you for bowing out and I won't ask you to make any comments. With that, I'll turn it over to anybody online, Jen or William, Roger. You wanna? Sure. [34:11] Roger Bealey: I assume seeing we just received this paper, at least I did the paperwork on the peer reviewers that planning department is pretty much satisfied with everything that was raised in you know both the you know Haley Ward as [34:32] Doreen: well as the traffic yes if you all include we're recommending that they meet all those comments okay all right I [34:44] Roger Bealey: think I think that's a good presentation here i the traffic you know has always been kind of an issue down there so i don't have any problems with anything here i am kind of curious about the cafetorium or the cafeteria so you're basically going to be building another gym a separate gym or how's [35:10] Diane Netto: is that going to work so what the plans indicate is the existing cafetorium or capponesium we have all kinds of cute little words that we use for that but the existing space would continue to be the gymnasium for gym class and then we're going to build a cafeteria just to the if you're looking straight ahead at the school like bump it out to the right of the school Cool. Yes. That would be the cafeteria. OK. [35:43] Roger Bealey: All right. So the kids, if they're going to go eat, [35:46] Diane Netto: they have to go right to the gym. No,. There'll be a separate hallway for that. [35:52] Roger Bealey: OK,, OK. All right. The only other thing I was thinking about is the turnaround for the bus loop. Is that, do you see that infield being used for the kids? Do you mean in the rear of the? [36:11] Diane Netto: No, right in the front of the building. Right in the front. So what's going to happen is we're going to move right now, that is one of our playgrounds, right in the front of the school, to your point. So that's going to get relocated to the left side of the school. Okay. So that it wouldn't serve as a main play area for students because again right as we're reconfiguring the designs for the facility we're trying to increase student safety if you will. Okay all [36:40] Chair of the Planning Board: right okay I'm trying to find things to say okay well you don't always have to say something jen you want to go sure [36:56] William Sedlick: okay hold on a second i'm sharing one relatively small screen here okay oh my first question is it wasn't mentioned but i know that it's been like something our community has been talking about for a little while. And so I was just curious if any of this work is intended to include pre-K space or not. [37:29] Diane Netto: So the design of the project did not include pre-K. And that's because at the time that the referendum occurred, we were working against a lot of constraints to try to bring together the needs of five different schools in one project at a price point that the community said that they would support. And so, you know, for example, at this time, we have one public pre-K classroom at Blue Point because the population at that school freed up a classroom. As we move forward next year, we're taking on all of our CDS responsibilities, which means that we're going to be responsible for programming special education services for three and four year olds. And so our responsibilities as a district will increase, but not unlike other districts, our plan moving forward is to do a combination of public pre-K classrooms as there is opportunity and space that's provided in each of the schools. And then also to work with public private partners as we have been doing for the last three years. We have a public-private partnership with Shooting Stars in Scarborough right now, and in the coming months, we're going to be talking with other potential community partners about expanding those partnerships. And that is a really common way that school districts in the state of Maine have been approaching those pre-K needs. it's not universal public pre-k it is really under the umbrella of ensuring that special education services for students are met that being said we have been in a good position this year we expanded the number of public pre-k seats that we had and we actually didn't have enough community interest to fill them and so you know we have some wonders about that whether that is because families are choosing those models that have served their kids since birth and they want to continue that relationship a little bit longer, whether it's a matter of our schedule because our public pre-K is a half-day program and that's really because of some financial constraints that you can imagine that we have. But that's something that we're continuing to look at. but we're really excited about the potential of continuing to grow those partnerships in the [40:05] William Sedlick: community sure okay thanks you're welcome also curious how many buses service the blue point school now and it doesn't it's this like you said all of you said previously you know this isn't like a huge expansion in terms of capacity so right it sounds to me like one and a half or maybe two, I don't know. [40:29] Diane Netto: Yeah, so we have three buses that go to Blue Point right now, and that's just because we have a consolidated K-5 bus route, right? So the buses that drop off at Blue Point also drop students off at Wentworth because of the population needs, right, and trying to be the most efficient with our transportation services. So it is projected that we would continue to have three buses at this site. And, you know, that's why that depiction, if you will, includes three buses staged in that bus loop. [41:05] William Sedlick: Okay. Thanks. You're welcome. There was also, let's see, just a quick, your plans, I think, are different than ours. And it sounds like that's relative to sort of ongoing or late stage conversations around the proposed raised crossing on Pine Point Road. Right. And again, recognizing our role here is advisory and not the same as it is perhaps on standard projects and more typical projects. But, it looked, but I think the, Frank said that, it might be a five inch raised crosswalk. but it looked like the plan said three inch, it looked like the plan said three inch high speed crosswalk. And so I, that really caught my attention. High speed table. [42:02] Diane Netto: And so I can certainly invite Frank to come back and talk about that more, but, you know, As he alluded to earlier, we literally had a two-hour traffic planning meeting with our friends on the town side this morning. And so, you know, I appreciate that you recognize that we're continuing to make shifts, you know, to the benefit of the community and to make sure that we're getting this exactly right. [42:28] William Sedlick: Yeah. So I think in theory, this is a great addition. I'm excited to hear or at least draw the conclusions I think that our town staff and public safety officials are also supportive of this I know like for years I feel like we've been hearing about people that have concerns about using this crosswalk people that observe frequent you know drivers driving through it with kids in the crosswalk waiting to cross etc et cetera. And also, you know, the stretch of Pine Point Road is particularly straight and so speeding. Anyway, so I just think it's all like good things in the right direction. But I am curious if there was any conversation given to sort of thinking about the context of Pine Point Road in the broader sense about whether there was any thought given to sort of bookending this school zone perhaps with additional raised elements within the roadway so that this isn't the only one which would kind of help reinforce the school zone itself and also prepare drivers for this for this race crossing and I mentioned that because the race crossing certainly helps, like has advantages, but in terms of speed mitigation, it doesn't really do very much because by the time you're going up and over it, you're, you know, you're already up and over it. And so just curious, perhaps a question for staff about whether or not there are any conversations around sort of- I'll have Frank come up. [44:14] Diane Netto: And while he's on his way up to the podium, I will just add that the traffic planning team that we have had has included our partners from public safety. So both police and fire have weighed in on that. But I will let the expert be the expert. [44:34] Frank Crabtree: the at this point we were reacting to the request from staff to raise a speed table not a high speed table which is funny how you put words together and you don't really notice until it's not supposed to be a high it's three inch high speed table got it anyway that's but no, that was basically the question we had is, do you actually want a raised speed table on the road at all or just leave the crosswalk flat like it is now? So the conversation never went any further than that, other than just saying, yes, we're going to raise the existing crosswalk to the school. [45:18] William Sedlick: Well, I know town staff certainly has done a lot of work of late, really getting into the detailed designs in terms of how we're going to deploy these here and elsewhere around town so I'm I'm confident that through you know continued conversations with them I think I'm sure that you know I don't have concerns around maybe the particular designs here I will just advocate though I think for or either additional raised elements, and it doesn't necessarily need to be crosswalks, but maybe speed cushions or something outside of this one to kind of help create a zone of safety as opposed to just that one localized location and the preemptive signage and pavement markings that should go along with anything raised, which you'll probably get to, but just saying that for the record. [46:16] Lisa Solwin: well i will reiterate that there are the flashing beacons too that are being added on either side and when speaking with and i don't want to speak for the fire chief but he was hesitant on speed tables but realized that in this location it made sense and so we went around this location was the area they focused on with the beacons trying to be the mitigation [46:37] Jennifer Ladd: to slow folks down sure and i'm going to add in jen with part of that conversation i was just going to say the same thing and after our meeting this morning we had separately a traffic safety coincidentally this afternoon and again chief kinlin has come back and said that when we look at speed tables this was something that he definitely supported we did not get into looking at it more holistically for the corridor though jen just pointing that out [47:10] William Sedlick: that did not come up in conversations yeah i don't just to be clear i'm not i'm not necessarily advocating for the whole corridor but just because of where this sits within an otherwise pretty long straight stretch of road that i think everyone is probably familiar with you know it's it's very easy posted speed limits 35 miles an hour it's very easy to go quite you know, quite a bit over that. So anyway, just trying to think about, you know, making sure that there's some advanced indication for drivers. And I think oftentimes, you know, we've talked about this too, like oftentimes these are most effective in unison, you know, in sort of duplicate or multiple applications. And I really only picture sure that within the context of the school, so whether it's the limits of the school zone or just shortly outside, whatever kind of spacing might make sense. Just curious if that was talked about given the sort of like higher speed, higher volume nature of this roadway versus some others that perhaps our other schools are located on. [48:30] Jennifer Ladd: The additional, like you said, physical in the road structures were not discussed it was discussed kind of universally with the other schools too because i think you'll see that at pleasant hill was another one that i would say probably is very similar and we had the same conversations and not looking kind of i guess on as you put it book bookends but that can be part of the conversation and other treatments maybe I'm I'm not sure it just hasn't been discussed [49:06] William Sedlick: so any suggestions that yeah I think first I do just want to say I'm so I'm really happy to hear that our fire chief in particular and other public safety staff are supportive of this because I feel like a lot of times there's instances you know elsewhere not even just in our community where these treatments make a lot of sense and they kind of die they kind of die in public safety so we did talk about in our later in our traffic [49:34] Jennifer Ladd: safety meaning was even painting like pavement markings or something in advance of it to or things like that yeah i think that's a good i think that's a good idea Yeah. [49:46] William Sedlick: Okay. Another comment that I had was about the driveway separation here and that there's actually two driveways and they feel relatively close together. And knowing that the intent is for one of them to be used for buses, all but a very low number of buses. Buses are more difficult to see around than other vehicles. And so just curious if there had been any conversation about the distance between these two driveways, the sight lines for people exiting the car, the student drop-off lane versus, you know, can someone see coming out of that student drop-off lane if there's a bus queued at the other exit i guess it's it's a detailed question but more broadly i'm curious about the driveway separation here and number of driveways yeah so the parts of the driveways that [50:49] Speaker J (unidentified): you're looking at right now we originally these were even shown closer together when we originally came up with layout options for this school but as it's kind of tough to see with the lines on here but your property line on this side runs right underneath this dark black dash line and then we have this tree line approaching the other abutter on this side so we really tried to maximize the space that we could between those exits knowing that we wanted to keep the bus and cars as separate as possible and then oh yes and then so this is obviously this is one way out first student car drop off on this side and then up here that's a one-way in entrance as well for the drop-off area so you have the student drop-off coming in on this upper entrance area come through here this will be the drop-off area this is also connecting to the parking area in here which cars can exit back out the drop-off lane, and then they circle back and come out Pine Point Road. [52:08] William Sedlick: Okay. And so I guess, you know, understanding there's property line implications and tree lines and everything like that, but are we certain that proper site distance is met in both of those instances distances for people exiting onto the road, onto Pine Point? [52:34] Frank Crabtree: Well, the site distance shouldn't be any different than it was before, and the two driveways are separated as much as they can be. The bus is very infrequent. The bus loop on the left should be only those three buses during the times of the morning and the afternoon drop off and pickup so that driveway is really you know very seldom be used during the time when most of the cars are coming and again they're only coming out not in so with all the restrictions we really felt that this was you know the best that we could stretch those apart okay [53:24] William Sedlick: i just this feels like something that we would comment like in a you know on any project that's something that we look at so I it just caught my attention and understanding that the bus trips exiting the site are infrequent but they still happen and so that's just something that you know I think that we should check and make sure that the simple site distances are met it could be you know you could have i don't know there's any number of instances where there might be more buses or the buses aren't aren't clearing out of there you know it's a field trip day whatever the instances are it'll be important for particularly because it's exit only if it was entrance only and the loop ran the other direction, that's, it's really not an issue. But I think that given the proximity of these, I think, you know, that's why we have, that's why we have driveway separation standards is to try and kind of help with that conflict. Jen, I really appreciate your comment. I'm [54:34] Diane Netto: wondering, you know, if this might be addressed even procedurally, as I think about some of the routines and procedures that we have in some of our other locations. We have, you know, say for example, at the middle school, we call bus students and we wait until those buses are populated and drive off before we call, you know, students who are being picked up or walkers. And so, you know, what is your thought in terms of that? Yeah, I think, I think generally that's [55:07] William Sedlick: a good like fix right that's a good that's a good a good option if you're not otherwise kind of starting from a clean slate here which you know you all of you sort of spoke in different ways to how this project offers an opportunity to revisit site circulation and safety concerns. And I would, you know, I think this falls, this falls within that category, particularly with a crosswalk right in the middle. you know, there will be other elements and, you know, obviously, by and large, your buses and vehicles will be exiting during, times when the reduced speed limit is effect. And so people should be crawling through this area in a way that, you know, makes it easier for them to enter out into the main line. But I just, you know, I don't know, there's snowbanks in the winter. There's, you know, you have an event at the school with more buses or a different pattern of transportation. I feel like it's our due diligence to just make sure that it's not just safe most of the time, but all of the time. And so, yes, I do think that's a good approach. it can be a good approach particularly you know for an existing site but you know we just want to make sure it's that way all of the time yeah appreciate it thank you all said jen i think just kind of my last comment maybe sort of loosely related to that but you know there was there was mention given to the number of there was an i missed the actual number X number of additional parent drop-off spots provided here. And I just want to say that, you know, looking at this plan, like from a whole zoomed out plan view, the amount of impervious area that's being allocated here for three buses is really significant compared to that which is being provided for sort of all of the other parking areas. is and i don't know it's just it you know i feel like we hear we see a lot of projects come across this board where and we i feel like collectively we work really hard to try and guide projects in town to improve their connectivity to the rest of town and to you know encourage sort of discourage to the extent that's possible like we all have to do it So, you know, zero isn't the number we're looking at here, but to kind of, you know, encourage more active modes of transportation, encouraging people to walk and bike here. You know, I think this crosswalk is a great example of that directly opposite this crosswalk off the page connects into, you know, a whole great residential neighborhood. And hopefully with these improvements, you know, a few people will choose to walk here instead of instead of driving. And every one of those people that drives to drop their kid off results in another space that needs to be provided on site. This location also has the immense benefit of being incredibly close to the Eastern Trail system, which is such a gem for our community and a really great way for folks to sort of get across town by bikes. and certainly, you know, putting a kindergartner on their bike and sending them down the trail to get to school is probably not realistic, but, you know, we, should be looking for those connections when and where we can. And I just, this, a lot of the, intent here seems to really sort of be geared more towards, accommodating current behavior as opposed to taking the opportunity with this redesign option and really investing in and encouraging our community to be a little bit more thoughtful and sustainable about how we get around. And that includes how our kids get around and, our busing system, you know I know there's a lot of challenges that go along with that. I have two kids that are frequent bus riders myself. And so I'm, you know, keenly aware, But I think that to the extent that we can, it would be really exciting to me for these projects to come forward and help reinforce that behavior in the same way that they're coming forward with creative redesign of spaces to, you know, to move us into the kind of the next generation of learning inside the buildings. We can do that outside the buildings too. So anyway, with that, 's all I have to say. [1:00:23] Unidentified Planning Board Member: all right jen thank you william yeah jen i just want to say i really love the concept of zona safety and just like advocating for that as a more expansive kind of understanding of it and so just appreciate that and underscore that as we think through this i think they would love the applicant to speak about the haley ward memo in particular and i think this is this is one where you know if this wasn't an advisory opinion if this was a developer looking to build closely to the marsh i would have significant concerns especially after reading this peer review memo and so i guess i just hope in detail that the applicant can review how you plan on addressing the comments in the peer review memo and if the superintendent could speak to how we plan on educating their children at the site about their responsibilities of living next to the marsh and what kind of amenities are planned on site considering how close the building is going to be to the marsh and this is one is it is it you know stream tables are a great option when i just built at an elementary school on the presumptive river so just would love to hear first the applicant engineers about the peer review memo and kind of the specific the two kind of concerns that were not addressed and how they will be addressed and from the superintendent about how we'll be educating students on site. They're about living next to the marsh. But [1:01:50] Frank Crabtree: which specifically were the comments you were talking about? [1:01:54] Unidentified Planning Board Member: Yeah, so I'm looking at the Haley Ward memo from November 2nd, which is the most recent one I have. And maybe there's been updates here, but some concerns about peak flow and about the, oh goodness here, I have too many tabs open, the lack of test pits. yes and maybe i just yeah go ahead sorry remember [1:02:25] Frank Crabtree: something yeah this is yeah this is this one do you which do you have a question number on there as far as the test bits go they are done they will be on the next set of drawings that come out so the test bits are all set cool and has the hydrocad model been updated to verify the pre and post-development peak rates yes there were of all of the 40 or so questions comments that we've been going through with Haley Ward and the town staff there were a few that dealt with the HydroCAD model some of them were just confused language and others were small changes in or differentiating between what was shown on the plans and what was shown in the written calculations. So those are being worked on to correct those. They're small items. They can be corrected. We just haven't got the final drawings done yet. [1:03:37] Unidentified Planning Board Member: Wonderful. Thank you. And Superintendent, I guess the question for you is really like this is a unique opportunity to be teaching so close to the Marsh. How do you plan on seizing that opportunity for them and what kind of investments will be made on that education front next to the [1:03:54] Diane Netto: Marsh? Yeah, I think, you know, you're raising a really great question for me to take back to the team. You know, certainly I think that there are always opportunities that we have at, especially at the primary level, to educate our students about the community in which we live. And that certainly is part of the curriculum in terms of me addressing specifically about what are our planned efforts today in terms of educating that. That is something that I'd like to be more thoughtful about and do some planning with our team. But I certainly very much appreciate the question. We'll take that back. Wonderful. Thank you so much, Superintendent. [1:04:36] Unidentified Planning Board Member: Absolutely. I think that's it for me. I mean, Mr. Chair, I don't know what our... I mean, being this is an advisory opinion, kind of what hooks we have for learning more back. My hope is, you know, I'm very proud to be in this district. I know that the superintendent is a woman of her word. And so just I look forward to that and look forward to seeing those in the coming years when my child visits that school. So that's, I think, the two items I wanted to address tonight. [1:05:06] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. Thanks, William. We won't be seeing this project again. [1:05:10] Unidentified Planning Board Member: That was what I would figure. So those are, I just wanted to get those on the record. And I know Casio Shoop is on as well right now. And so just putting that into the ether. [1:05:21] Chair of the Planning Board: Will do, sir. I just have a couple of, just making some notes online here. A couple of questions. I noticed on the plan that you're moving the propane tank to the front of the building on the curve where the buses go and wondering why that's going there. and not necessarily behind the school where the kitchen and the gym and all of the large spaces are. You show it on the plan, and I believe it's on the landscape plan. Yes. And you've got one, two, three bushes around it. And I'm wondering why it can't be stationed more where the new [1:06:17] Lisa Solwin: building addition is going well we'll take a look at that I think that might be an oversight on the drawings but we'll take that back to our engineers [1:06:23] Chair of the Planning Board: okay because I agree with you just for curiosity I noticed through the elevation and architectural rendering on that new addition where the cafeteria is are those window curtains that you intend on installing so it drives the light into this space or is it just a cosmetic it just appears like well if there's not any window curtains or sun I forget the terminology that's the one thank you sunshade you're talking about the [1:07:06] Lisa Solwin: the cafeteria edition yeah so right now it's it's part sunshade part aesthetic as well okay yeah it i was just verifying and i will just comment on the i think it was william who brought up the how is the staff going to kind of connect to the natural surroundings we did a lot of visioning with the staff and each school came up with their own design statement and blue points in particular is rooted in nature blueprint nurtures curious minds through care compassion passion and community so the rooted in nature piece is really important to them so i would imagine there's going to be a lot of connection to the surrounding natural environment thank you [1:07:44] Chair of the Planning Board: for that yeah it's great to see that insulation and tightening up of the envelope will occur with this project and you mentioned air conditioning and i know a great way that you can get heat and air conditioning at the same time. And it's not rooted in water source heat pumps because we don't have a way to do geothermal here. So is my dream coming true that a school is going to have VRFs? You've just made my night. I want to, well, good thing I live just across down Broad Turn Road. So I go down to Pine Point quite a bit. [1:08:33] Speaker L (unidentified): I don't want to get you too excited, but a portion of the building will be VRF because in the 65 wing, the ceiling height is not high enough to put in a traditional ducted system. So the new cafeteria, the 1965 wing, which is the original building, will all be VRF for the DOAS dedicated outside here. [1:08:55] Chair of the Planning Board: Yeah. Well, you're going to do ERV? [1:08:57] Speaker L (unidentified): yeah and then there will be an energy recovery and then on the 92 wing it will be an air to water heat pump system also for primary cooling and heat and then the boilers because they're brand new they will be we're actually repurposing the boilers at eight corners which is being raised i just replaced them so they'll just be in reserve for backup heat if needed and they're dual source oil and propane which they're still they're still bad i know but it's better than yeah i just out two hundred thousand dollars worth of boilers that the [1:09:36] Chair of the Planning Board: taxpayers just paid for so yeah we understood but you know these are some great opportunities to rethink and given the nature of what was just said about the environment and everything watching our carbon output is you know part of part of our comprehensive plan part of the vision of the residents here in scarborough because it does affect the marsh and all that wonderful nature that we're we're really proud to have in our town i don't disagree at all i know i know i just feel like i need to say this on the record so that when you're You're doing your dot in the I's and crossing T's and you're deciding whether you want this fancy archway or you rather have, you know, a well insulated building with good airflow and an ERV. I think the ERV and those kind of things should win every time and not the always the aesthetic look of it. I just need to get that out on the record. grid that's all i have roger yeah just a quick question and it goes back to what jen was [1:10:56] Roger Bealey: talking about on the driveways is there going to be a sign at the end of eagle's nest indicating that 's where the vehicles are going to go into yeah [1:11:13] Frank Crabtree: we don't have all of the signage finished yet but yes we can put signs to make sure we people know what's in what's out especially with a direct exit only there'll be no entry sign there so they'll they'll know they've got to move on and go up eagle's nest i mean i realize that most [1:11:37] Roger Bealey: parents will know where to go but occasionally there'll be somebody else maybe your grandparent or a friend of somebody picking up right yes okay all [1:11:49] Chair of the Planning Board: set roger william i see your hands up [1:11:51] Unidentified Planning Board Member: i was trying to be polite this is i just i want to say i really appreciated the inclusion of the design statement from the staff and i think just knowing that we this is the second of these that i've heard this fall and i think there's probably more to come So rooting the plan and the presentation as much in the engineering as the philosophy of it goes a long way for me. And so I would really encourage the school department to think about, like, really rooting these presentations in the what and the why and how it's responding to the staff's needs. And that, like, that design sense and where that's showing up and how that's showing up and how it's going to look and feel is really important. important and it's something that I as a planning board member really request and so just would encourage that for future presentations as we review it for advisory opinions thank [1:12:51] Doreen: you William I [1:12:55] Diane Netto: do really appreciate that comment we have spent significant time with each of our staffs at all of the schools with these design statements and also having them look at different design patterns within the school that support those types of, that type of thinking and that type of planning for education. And so I will definitely make sure that as you see the next two schools that we'll build that in. So appreciate the feedback. Really appreciate that. Thank you so much. Oh yes. And I can use this as an opportunity for some PR. We are having a community forum tomorrow evening at the public safety building. It also will be hybrid for those people who want to be online and it really is to just update the community on where we are on all of the building projects because we certainly recognize that to date most of the work and the plans and getting everything ready to go out to bid have not been super public and so we want to make sure that we're celebrating with the community and letting them know what the efforts and the support that you have provided us have been have allowed us to move forward so we're really excited about the opportunity to do that tonight tomorrow night to talk about each of the schools and to also elicit some feedback and answer questions we're gonna have some first-time renderings of the projects and i know that for some people that is more exciting for than not right some people love to geek out and look at all of the blueprints, but some people want to say, what's my school going to look like? So hopefully we're going to be able to whet everyone's appetite a little bit tomorrow evening. It is from 6 to 8 o'clock. [1:14:59] Chair of the Planning Board: If we're all set with comments, I have a short memo here to enter into the record. In accordance with the Town of Scarborough Zoning Ordinance, the Planning Board has reviewed the proposed classroom and cafeteria expansion, approximately 12,600 square feet, expansion being 10,800 to the north and 1,800 to the east. The portable classroom removal and the exterior redevelopment of the Blue Point Primary School. The site changes at the school includes modifying the existing student drop-off, adding a new bus loop off Pine Point Road, and adding firetruck access for the new north addition the school expansion will accommodate an anticipated enrollment increase from 216 to 232 students the school is located in the r2 zoning district per chapter 3b3 of chapter or section 2b3 of chapter 405b municipal buildings or uses are exempt from site plan review but shall be reviewed by the planning board for an advisory opinion to the town council or to the applicable town department the planning board has reviewed the proposed expansion and finds it meets the relevant criteria set forth in the zoning ordinance with the following recommendations one address recommended items for discussion in the staff memo dated 11-16-26 address the remaining items in the Haley Ward memo dated 11-2-26 consider additional raised speed bumps potentially as bookends to the raised cross rock and finally consider relocating the propane tank from the front to the rear of the building we don't vote on this are my colleagues all set jen you got your hand up i would like to ask [1:17:12] William Sedlick: formally that the site distance be evaluated at the two exiting drives onto pine point road i [1:17:22] Chair of the Planning Board: will amend the advisory and add that language jen to ensure site distances are met between the bus path and the bus drive and the automobile driveway got that all right with that we'll see you again thank you for your time good job the students should be very proud when this is all done all right that ends our items for consideration tonight and we'll move forward with a staff report minor development reviews none to report any administrative amendments [1:18:20] Doreen: none to report how about correspondence then received oh non-correspondence but i did want to update you all we do have a revised chapter 405b our site plan ordinance the town council took final action on some changes last wednesday that included updates to our tree preservation and tree clearing requirements and also changed the way we perform site plan review so added some additional ceo review code enforcement officer review staff review and really made it clear what type of projects fall into what category. So if you would like a paper copy for your book, send me an email. If not, it should be online in the next day or two. [1:19:07] Chair of the Planning Board: Thank you, Autumn. That was good work. Now we're at planning board comments, and I want to just throw this out to my colleagues. And this is in response to your email, William. William is going to resign from the conservation commission and the planning board typically has a liaison for that commission and i'm just throwing it out there to anyone interested in filling those shoes [1:19:42] Unidentified Planning Board Member: that william is vacating i'll just catch it's a fantastic group and i'm really sorry it just This doesn't work out with my child care schedule for Wednesday evenings. Yeah, I can figure it out. All right. [1:19:54] Chair of the Planning Board: James, really appreciate that. So do you need me to send you an email, Autumn? Handle it from there? Okay. Super. And my other comment was I'd like to thank James for chairing the meeting last month. You had a lot of public comment. I read the minutes and started listening to some of the video or the recording. and I was six beers in, and I said, that's enough. I know. But anyway, I appreciate you stepping in. My pleasure. I had a good time. Any other planning board comments? Right. Then I guess we'll enjoy the Thanksgiving holiday. We'll see you in December. That's a wrap.