Saco Planning Board Opens Public Hearing for Cloverleaf and Gas Station Projects
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[2:02] Mhm.
[4:05] Mhm.
[9:27] Good evening, everyone. Ladies and gentlemen, esteemed members of the planning board, and valued community representatives, I welcome you all to this evening's of the assembly of the Saugus planning board. As chair, it is my privilege to convene this gathering dedicated to the thoughtful planning and development of our community. Today, we come together with a shared commitment to shaping the future of our city in a manner that reflects our values, respects our heritage, and fulfills the needs of our residents both now and in the future.
[9:56] Our agenda tonight contains important matters, each requiring our careful consideration, expertise, and collaboration. As we engage in our deliberations, let us remember the profound impact these decisions will have on the lives of all, keeping in mind we're residents like you. It is our duty to maintain transparency, fairness, and inclusivity in our proceedings,
[10:17] ensuring that the voices of all are heard and respected. Together, we must embrace the responsibility entrusted to us by our community, working diligently and thoughtfully to chart a course that fosters growth, prosperity, and harmony. And with that, I would like to call this Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026 Saco Planning Board to order. I look forward to the productive discussions and meaningful outcomes that lie ahead.
[10:40] Thank you.
[10:45] With us this evening, myself, Matt Provensal, the chair of the board, and to my left we have our vice chair, Joyce Leary Clark, along with Planning Board members Jeff Brochu, Katherine Peltonen, and to my right, Jim Moyer and Chris Gagnon.
[11:02] Our staff members with us this evening are our city planner, Charles Tillman, along with our planning compliance manager, Lisa Harmon. And as always, we welcome our city council liaison from Ward 7, Nathan Johnson.
[11:25] Our first item on our agenda this evening is our review and approval of our meeting minutes. We have a few here, one from October 20th from our Planning Board, and then we have three site walk notes and meeting minutes.
[11:46] Do board members have any questions, comments, edits on any of those documents?
[12:04] Jeff.
[12:05] Mr. Chair, I had no comments. I thought everything was good. just in the thought of if we're trying to make a motion for acceptance of all of them continuously, I like to try to keep Silver Pines Drive as a separate item just because I need to abstain cuz I wasn't present for that one, but if we want to we can make a motion or I can make a motion, I guess, if no one else had any reason they needed to abstain.
[12:30] So, with that, I would move that we accept the draft minutes for the December 20th Planning Board December 20th, 2026 Planning Board, the 335 North Street Sidewalk minutes, and the 0 Remick Drive Sidewalk minutes as drafted.
[12:50] I'll second. Just to note, it's it's a October 20th.
[12:57] I think you said December, but
[12:58] My apologies. Corrected. I edit my motion to include the October 20th, 2026. [snorts]
[13:06] Great, thank you. one edit if we could make on 0 Remick, just my name down in the bottom of the body. There's a
[13:21] for the Sidewalk notes, yeah.
[13:28] Which page? Sorry.
[13:29] Oh, I can tell you the page. It is
[13:35] first page, second to last paragraph.
[13:42] Oh, Matthew?
[13:43] Yeah.
[13:45] [clears throat and cough]
[13:45] Oh, yeah, we can fix that.
[13:48] It's how my grandmother would say it, but I need the H in there.
[13:54] Any other thoughts, discussion items?
[14:00] All right, those in favor of adopting the minutes from October 20th from our Planning Board meetings, and then Sidewalk minutes for 335 North Street and 0 Remick as amended. Those in favor, Chris?
[14:16] Yes.
[14:17] Jim?
[14:18] Yes.
[14:19] Joyce?
[14:20] Yes.
[14:20] Jeff?
[14:21] Yes.
[14:22] Catherine?
[14:22] Yes.
[14:23] I'll vote yes as well. Motion passes 6-0.
[14:27] Mr. Chair, I move to approve the minutes from the site walk at 0 Silver Pine Drive on October 27th.
[14:39] Second. [snorts]
[14:41] Thank you for the motion, Joyce, and the second, Jim.
[14:46] Any additional discussion on that item?
[14:53] All right, those in favor, Chris?
[14:55] I abstain.
[15:00] Jim?
[15:00] Yes.
[15:02] Joyce?
[15:02] Yes.
[15:03] Jeff?
[15:04] I abstain as I was not present.
[15:07] Catherine?
[15:08] Yes.
[15:09] I will I was not there, but I'll accept the minutes. I read them thoroughly. So, we'll go four zero and an abstention with two abstentions. Yes, that's six.
[15:29] All right, our next item on our agenda this evening is the review of our after-the-fact packet. It looks like we have one item here.
[15:42] Yes, Charles, go ahead.
[15:44] We received one public comment related to 986 Portland, so the Cloverleaf development, and then we did receive one after our deadline from Inga Brown related to the Ecology School that has been emailed to you and we'll include it in the virtual packet. It was just after our deadline, so we didn't print it out.
[16:04] Okay, thank you. Board members, any questions on that document or that memo?
[16:13] I just note that Jim is my brother, but I know I've disclosed that before in connection with this project.
[16:23] Great, thank you, Joyce. Jeff.
[16:25] I just wanted to you know that's up for public hearing, right, tonight. So, that I think that's the more appropriate time that we can kind of reference that. his concerns I think it'll be appropriate to address. So, thank you.
[16:38] I agree.
[16:42] All right, so we will
[16:45] we will review that document and include it in our deliberations. So, with that continuing along, excuse me, continuing along,
[16:56] our next item is item five, and this is our consent calendar items. And we have one here this evening, and that is for 40 Burnham Road. This is map 125, lot 21-1. And this is an application of completeness for preliminary subdivision and site plan for five-lot residential subdivision
[17:18] and an approximately 1,495-ft private roadway. And this is within the RC rural conservation district.
[17:37] Any thoughts from board members, questions?
[17:41] The I'll just add a little background. One of the big pieces that we have we list as more information required are the draft homeowners association documents. the applicant has kind of reached out to or the their team has reached out to us, and they're kind of on the fence about homeowners association road maintenance agreement, trying to figure out what's the best path forward. That's something we typically require at the time of final subdivision application anyways, because, you know, that's what kind of what how we the how it's been going for a while now.
[18:10] so, at least on the draft homeowners association documents and any easements like a road maintenance and or agreements like the road maintenance they're still looking into that. but I didn't want that to hold up the project, so it's put here as more information required as they are at least have noted it in their application. [clears throat]
[18:27] Okay. Thank you, Charles. Any questions? Jeff. So, Charles, I would presume, you know, I was just kind of a little taken that there were seven more information required boxes checked. some of them, you know, pretty substantial, not really having a waste disposal plan. you know, we may want to be talking
[18:49] about, you know, the [18:54] [clears throat]
[18:55] the hydrogeological assessment where everything's going to be private. so, if you haven't if your office hasn't received any more information than that, I tend to feel like even though the applicant's working forward, it's not really at a point where I would view it as complete. This is, you know, seven items that are pretty substantial. In fairness to all applicants, I think we should really stick to it that they need to be submitted to find it complete.
[19:21] Yeah, the on the hydrogeological assessment, that's not an application submission requirement. they did provide their test pits for that. So, what we're saying here is that, they these aren't I mean, the one thing to say is that this checklist isn't a one-for-one things from our ordinance because of like hydrogeological assessment is that example where
[19:43] they provide the test pits and typically we would go to the planning board to ask for hydrogeological assessment. In this case, we've already said you're going to need it most likely because you're on well and septic. things like that. But again, like there are a couple things in here. They're things that we look at, like a topog- topography's included in their boundary survey.
[20:05] and there's a couple things here that we think that they could bring for- when we give them their comments, for their review, they'll resubmit and it's things that are relatively minor. like the more information required on the applicable local and state permits. They submitted their applications, but we're going to need the final approval before a our final approval.
[20:28] but I'll leave that up to the planning board to decide. So, that's why we kind of put it as more information required and kind of absent because it's noted or there's just you know, minor things that are outstanding, but we would probably request before they even were scheduled for a public hearing.
[20:47] Thank you for the clarity, Charles.
[20:52] Any other thoughts from board members? Questions? Joyce?
[20:54] I guess I thought one I thought the whole purpose of application completeness review was to determine, okay, the application is complete. Now it can be scheduled for public hearing.
[21:09] sorry, I just can't see. Are you looking at me, Joyce?
[21:11] I know.
[21:12] [laughter]
[21:13] [21:13] I was looking in that general area.
[21:15] Yeah. I also can't see, so.
[21:17] but yeah, so I guess I'm mistaken about the
[21:21] Yeah, we're not
[21:23] These aren't This isn't tied to the scheduling of a public hearing.
[21:27] No. the public hearing we're scheduling once the applicant kind of provides that resubmission. once we send out a round of comments, they provide a response, provide any like final outstanding things or clarifications. for example, we looked at this in application completeness and we noted that we found that their stormwater management report had used the wrong soil for modeling.
[21:50] they did submit it, so it is part of this, but they would need to you know, resubmit that and they already have as part of that. So, we did a preliminary check. while we have or while the city has historically done application completeness as an item with the planning board and then moved to schedule public hearing that same night, what we found over at least what I found over the last 6 months or so is that
[22:15] forcing these to go forward means we weren't we don't have enough time to review the application. So, we're doing application completeness as part of the consent calendar pretty much saying that they have everything that we see that or the planning board see needs to be fit or if you put more information required like before you come back to the planning board, we certainly need this. and then once they have kind of done a round of reviews with the city, we're ready then we would schedule them for a public hearing and they've provided their response.
[22:42] It's just giving us stronger applications by the time we get to the point like the two applications tonight follow this process.
[22:51] But again, it is your prerogative to find it complete or not complete. and if these are kind of things where you would want to see more completion application completeness, we can do that. but for what staff is putting here, it's we don't think it's incomplete. There's just a little bit more information needed. So there's enough for at least us to go forward.
[23:11] Sure. Jim. So, for Charles, I was wondering the same thing that Jeff was that the number of more information requested. could you just help us understand are any of the items
[23:32] labeled as more information requested, are they so deficient that that they it 's not just that they need a little bit of clarification. It's like they've completely not checked the box at all. So that's that's one question and the second question is
[23:54] once we find the application complete, what's the timeline for us to be required to hold a public hearing? Is isn't there some time period we have to be careful about there?
[24:09] for subdivisions, there is some sort of there is some pending proceeding involved. I'm quite frankly not too concerned with it. really what I've what I'm looking at kind of going back through our projects over the last year, what the planning board had been doing has been scheduling six or seven items on a night.
[24:33] Sometimes you get through a lot of them. Often times you guys were tabling applications. and that's happened far less as we kind of moved to this more this system where we have stronger applications. By the time they come to public hearing, we have a round of review. A lot of the feedback I had from engineer teams is that they were sitting here
[24:53] with three or four items scheduled and not being seen. We're wasting applicants money, applicant time. So we've been able to narrow down our to keep our agendas tight, more productive conversations, more time for the applicant to respond. and what we found is sometimes that subdivision
[25:14] is limiting. the 30 days from a public hearing to make a decision often isn't the case. you typically to continue your public hearing anyway, but there's also could be some concerns with continuing public hearings indefinitely as well. so what we're doing is trying just to have a more the most consistent process that gives the applicants time to
[25:38] respond to comments without feeling pressured to resubmit. What that does it is allow the planning staff who are reviewing these projects to create a stronger memo for the applicant team and gives us more time to review because we were often receiving submissions Thursday at 5:00 p.m. for meeting on Tuesday and it's just hard to keep doing that. So the way we've been doing things is kind of just saying
[25:59] when the application is ready to go forward, it's ready. We can hold it up in application completeness. we're still putting this out for comments, too. so what the alternative I considered is before even bringing it to application completeness to with the planning board was to do a full round of review so we could weed out a lot of this.
[26:21] instead this kind of gives the keeps the application moving forward at a steady pace. and when it's ready for a public hearing, we don't have to go to application completeness, then wait two to four weeks, go to public hearing, wait four to six weeks. This kind of gives a little bit more process back and forth and time for review.
[26:39] So if I understand what you're saying, the it sounds like what you're saying is that if we were to find the application complete tonight, that would not be a problem in terms of scheduling the public hearing. And it sounds like you're also saying that the items that are listed as more information requested is they're
[27:01] not necessarily ones that well, in some instances aren't aren't completeness issues at all, like the hydrogeologic
[27:11] Yeah.
[27:11] assessment. but it sounds like you're confident that enough information is here for us to determine the application complete. Am I understanding that correctly?
[27:24] Yeah.
[27:24] Great. Okay, thank you.
[27:26] I think for some of these things like a hydrogeological assessment, because though we would, you know, add as part of application completeness, we're saying yes, we need that. We need the hydrogeologic assessment. We've already sent that to the applicant cuz it's it's near a bunch of resources and streams. So we're already aware that this is a kind of a unique area as well.
[27:47] but it also gives us time to send over some comments, get them back to the applicant, have them resubmit, and then be scheduled for a public hearing.
[27:56] Thank you.
[27:58] Thank you, Jim. Any other thoughts from board members? Jeff.
[28:02] Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I just want to be clear. I feel like there's a lot of things, you know, so I get it. The hydrogeological assessment it is a case-by-case. But the applicant submitted information, their limiting factor is somewhere always between 12 and 13 inches and it was groundwater or hardpan, right? And our ordinance often times kicks us to a 48-in
[28:23] evaluation, right? So we can ask for that and I get it, right? That's the board's purview. We can ask for that. The applicant's going to have to understand if we request that. there are other unique things on this parcel, easements and proposed easements, covenants and deed restrictions. I'm going to ask, I want to know more clarity about that lot number one and an existing cemetery and how they are planning on developing that and allowing
[28:47] for that state you guys probably know better there's a state law that says there has to be a reasonable access for the descendants of the people who might be buried in that cemetery. How are they planning on playing that out? So, if the majority of the board feels like you want to find it complete, that's fine, but I want to be very clear that we're not I don't want to feel rushed to get our, decision 30 days after cuz I'm going to want some clear answers for those unique situations
[29:13] that are very unique to this site, right? I mean, we have our typical water disposal and then the solid waste plan. What is the solid waste plan for a nearly 1,500 ft private way and where is that waste going? Where are those trash receptacles going to be placed? Who's bringing them out? I think those are very, important topics and we as the board have very collectively worked through them on previous applications,
[29:38] but there's a majority of them on here that haven't really been addressed yet. So, as long as we don't feel pressured, I kind of feel like we're making it harder for Charles's team to have checked all the boxes to keep that efficiency he was talking about if we're going to be now going back to the applicant saying, "Hey, you need to get us this item, this item, this item." and we're at six or seven items.
[29:59] it would be nice if they would have had the luxury of telling the applicant, "You bring that forth before it comes to us." That and that's kind of my point. Seven items, let's maybe make kind of a statement, "No, we want that to be addressed before staff has to even present it to us." So. Thank you.
[30:18] Thank you. Excuse me. [clears throat] Thank you, Jeff. Any other thoughts from board members? Joyce.
[30:26] Well, just Charles, to clarify, I can see you now. these applications have been sent for department review and we don't have the comments back, right? So, that the department review are in process. So, we're we're going to get comments back from public works, I'm sure. But
[30:46] Yeah. And we've already caught the cemetery piece of this. So, we already know, but they did submit their like for example, they submitted their MHPC, the main historic preservation commission, their certification, but there's no noting of the cemetery, for example. So, it's submitted, but it's not like 100% accurate. So, we're the comment that we're going to send to them is, "Hey, like we need this." [31:11] and that's kind of one of our first comments, but it is submitted and there's other things here that are also comments we could give to them, like their waste disposal plan, but those are typically part of the homeowners association. That's where that lives, especially because this is proposed as a private way. so
[31:32] I see how either way you guys can view this and it's helpful for me if you guys would prefer it to be more complete at this point cuz then I can just say, "We'll do a full round of review before even bring it to application completeness." but we're trying to figure out the best way to make it easier so we're not scrambling. We can get you guys a complete application.
[31:53] What we found is this is kind of jarring the lot. This is kind of the lines because if it's not a complete application, I'm not even going to bring it to the planning board. but I'm only going to bring it to you guys when I feel it's complete, really. cuz we also do a staff level of completeness review. and this is an application where we did hold this up for about 3 weeks because they were missing certain elements of their application, too.
[32:15] So, we felt that it was good enough to move forward so we can give the applicant some sort of way to proceed, but if you guys think there's not enough to start that level of review, then that's also within your authority as well.
[32:27] Great. Thank you, Charles. Chris.
[32:32] [32:33] [clears throat]
[32:33] had a couple quick questions. there's an existing structure on that lot. Is that going to be incorporated into the new plan or are they planning on just eliminating that structure?
[32:47] I think they're going to be converting that into a duplex, but I don't think that's a question that is I mean, if it's Is that Is that something for They're going to be It's going to be a turned into a duplex.
[32:58] Okay. Yeah, I was just more food for thought rather than the actual application completeness. And then as for the consent calendar and finding this application complete, my feeling is if the city staff is bringing it to us, they feel comfortable that with
[33:19] their back and forth between them and the applicant that they can get the information and that you know, they Charles will obviously take the feedback that we've provided tonight into moving forward with the applicant. I'd be fine going ahead with it and finding the application complete. [33:39] it's I have a hard time cuz it's not fully complete, but if there's enough there that the city staff is feels confident in it, then that's kind of enough for me to go, all right, then I see I think we can move forward.
[33:57] Great. Thank you, Chris. Any other thoughts from board members?
[34:02] Mr. Chair, I'll
[34:04] [clears throat and cough]
[34:05] just to move it along, I'll move that we approve the consent calendar and find the application complete.
[34:12] Thank you for the motion, Jim.
[34:16] I'll second that.
[34:18] Second by Chris. Thank you.
[34:22] Any additional discussion?
[34:26] All right, those in favor. Chris?
[34:28] Yes.
[34:30] Jim?
[34:31] Yes.
[34:32] Joyce?
[34:33] Yes.
[34:34] Jeff?
[34:35] No.
[34:36] Catherine?
[34:37] Yes.
[34:41] I'm going to say yes. Motion passes 5-1. So, with that
[34:49] Charles, you have from the discussion we had a lot of good points brought up from board members on some of these items and I think I think you have that and you've started on some of that discussion now, so I think with that
[35:08] And then the second thing I want to confirm on this is a site walk. this isn't a spoiler to it, but we no longer have a site walk the week of the 17th or the week of or on November 17th. So, the applicant had noted that 11:19 at 8:00 a.m. works for a site walk.
[35:30] I have said no for the week of Thanksgiving, just unless you guys want to do a little turkey trot that morning. that's fine, but 12:01 December 1st at 8:00 a.m. also works. but if you guys want to skip 11:24, which is the week of Thanksgiving, I've already kind of put that out there that I didn't really want to do a site walk those 3 days just in case people are traveling or feel compelled to travel or
[36:00] are prepping for Thanksgiving.
[36:01] So, that's the 17th Hobson Lane has been removed from the calendar completely.
[36:06] Yes, that'll be a planning department update.
[36:10] So, either the 19th or December 1st.
[36:14] Any preference from board members?
[36:21] [clears throat]
[36:23] I think I think Mr. Chair, it depends when it's going to snow first, so I think my preference would be the 19th of November just cuz a little less likely to snow.
[36:35] Seeing some head nods. Let's do the 19th then.
[36:38] [clears throat]
[36:39] All right.
[36:42] And that'd would another 8:00 a.m. site walk.
[36:46] I assume we want to keep doing 8:00 a.m.
[36:48] I think that works well.
[37:02] And the other piece of that is do you think we would want advisory review from the Conservation Commission?
[37:08] Yes, please. Yeah.
[37:24] All right. So, continuing along item six on our agenda this evening is our Planning Board public hearing guidelines. This is a document developed by the board and city staff outlining the procedure in place for our public hearings held. This explains the purpose of the public hearings and the outline procedure of reviewing an application, public comment presentation, and meeting duration.
[37:45] If anyone has any questions on this, please let us know. This document is available online and hard copy here in the auditorium as well.
[37:57] And with that, number seven on our agenda this evening is our public comment period. Our public comment period is an opportunity to hear from members of the public. We limit this agenda item to a total of 15 minutes for items or topics not under Planning Board review. The Planning Board appreciates public comment and recognizes that public comment about matters before it can help the board understand neighborhood concerns, review an application,
[38:22] or help understand additional items. Those wishing to make statements about an application currently under Planning Board's review are asked to provide those statements during the applicable public hearing period. Comments are limited to 3 minutes per person. However, if there are multiple members of the public looking to speak, we may reduce that time per person to accommodate all speakers.
[38:42] So, if anyone is with us this evening that would like to speak, please come to the podium and state your name and address for the record. We will collect comments and address them accordingly.
[39:07] All right, seeing no members of the public available to participate this evening, we will continue along with item eight on our agenda, which is our planning application review and public hearings. Our first item is 986 Portland Road. This is phase two. And this is map 63 lot 3-1.
[39:28] And this is by Cloverleaf Development LLC for public or excuse me, preliminary subdivision site plan and conditional use for the development of 126 dwelling units across eight buildings, a commercial out parcel along Portland Road, and solar array.
[39:49] And this is within the Portland Road zoning district. Anything to add on this item before we begin, Charles?
[39:57] no, not at this time. just a reminder we did receive one after the fact item. As you guys talked about, we should talked about once we open up the public hearing.
[40:07] Yes, great. Thank you. Board members, any conflicts or disclosures on this item before we begin?
[40:16] All right, and with that, we'll turn over to the applicant.
[40:26] Thank you. Tony Panciocco with Terradyne Consultants.
[40:31] Excuse me. As you're aware, this is a public hearing, so I'll probably just keep this kind of short and sweet here and just kind of go through a little bit of the updates on the permitting. and then we probably get into some questions and if there's any public comment to take it from there. We do have in your packets we've got project has gone through so far two rounds of peer review.
[40:55] and I understand we're we're in the process of the third round of peer review which will also include peer review for the solar I believe. Is that correct Giles? Okay. in your packets we did receive our DEP permit. that is in there. Since submitting our response comments from the last meeting and round of comments we did receive our sign off from the main coastal program on our coastal resiliency review.
[41:25] And we've also received a conditional approval from Army Corps of Engineers. They've signed off on the review. they then kick it over to EPA and they have a 30-day period to review it before they issue the actual permit in hand. currently traffic movement permit is still pending.
[41:48] And I think that's pretty much the the full array of permits that we're we're in the process of getting as we continue to move forward with this project. So, I guess public comments and/or board comments and we go from there.
[42:06] All right, great. Thank you, sir. Board members, any questions for the applicant?
[42:13] Any questions for city staff?
[42:21] Jim.
[42:23] [cough and clears throat]
[42:24] [42:26] for the applicant, I understand that you have a number of, of open space areas that you're including in the plan. And I'll looks like a pickleball courts, community center, some playground
[42:47] areas and can you just help us understand I think that's your effort to provide open space opportunities for people who live there. can you explain that a little bit in a little bit more detail as to why you think that answers that question as to whether or not you're providing adequate open space.
[43:10] well, but we're also we're also providing open space in the retained land as well through the lots. So, it would include it would incorporate obviously the amenities such as the pickleball courts and the community building. And then additionally it would be the remainder of the land out and around
[43:31] the solar area. Of course, that's fenced so you can't go walking through there. but it would it would encompass and it would be a like an easement for all of the residents that live there so they can go walk off in the woods or use the amenities you know, to how they see fit. There's also a dog park so that they can walk their dogs and that type of thing. So.
[43:52] That's all.
[43:52] think and we've updated actually we've updated the those calcs too. I believe that was a comment from the last round of the open space calculation. So, those are on the current set of plans that you have as well.
[44:04] That's that's helpful. Thank you. and then for the city planner I know there was a question about the city attorney determining whether or not the planning board had authority to grant certain waivers.
[44:18] [snorts]
[44:19] And do we have any updates on the city attorney's advice?
[44:23] Yes. So, what I put in the memo is kind of where we stand with that. while they are looking for certain items, it doesn't appear that this is something that is waiveable especially given that it is in our zoning ordinance and chapter 180 doesn't really have any it's not really standards.
[44:46] It's just you know, further rules for it and there's no language in there that allows the planning board or anyone to waive those. Those are just requirements. Then I we are understanding that they're not asking for relief for you know, because they don't want to do it, but it's because of the in the intended use of the solar is to be in perpetuity.
[45:09] So, we looked into it, but it does not appear that the planning board has the authority to waive the you know, to provide relief in the way that the applic- applicants are seeking. Well, they haven't they've kind of given some waiver requests for the future conditions plan, the financial guarantee. There's also items in 180 where they would also have to I have hypothetically request relief and I we don't Based on what our attorney was saying is we do not recommend
[45:38] providing that relief. I think part of our next round of review is working with the applicant to understand how to how to move forward from that.
[45:46] So, it sounds like Charles, you're saying that the city attorney saying we don't have the authority to grant those waivers.
[45:52] Yes.
[45:52] Right. Okay. That's great. Okay, thank you. Great, thank you, Jim. Any other questions? Joyce.
[46:03] Also, just to follow up with that, Charles, you would mentioned that there were still some review comments.
[46:10] Yes.
[46:11] Coming in from the city. So, that's that's one of the
[46:14] Yeah. I would say that we've only done one complete one high-level round of review for this because we did receive the initial phase one and phase two application at the same time. working with the previous applicant attorney here. working with the previous rep from Teradyne, we were we moved forward with the understanding that we'll finish phase one first.
[46:34] and through that, we had a couple rounds of peer review on the wetland back and forth and that does apply to the wetland where this development is. we have sent this out for peer review again and we have also requested specific review for the solar system the solar energy system as well as the battery storage. So, the that's so, both of those we're going to have review as, you know, part of this.
[46:57] We had brought an expert to kind of review that for us.
[47:02] Great, thank you. Any other thoughts from board members?
[47:10] So, one I had Charles and we started to talk about it I thought we were going to get more info and maybe that is still coming is the it's the gate at Appletree and sort of circling back on that conversation and was there any more thought on that or is that still coming or in the works?
[47:33] So, there wasn't a clear indication of exactly what how it came to be based on discussions with the applicant the applicant team who've been working on this for a couple years and city staff is that both of those parties agreed to restrict that connection except for allowing emergency vehicles with an Knox Box at the gate.
[47:56] So, that's something that the applicant team and city staff had discussed long before. I think couple years previously. the only comments I received is that final gate design and access management are reviewed by the fire department. I think the understanding is that yes, there will be a gate there. No, we don't want the traffic to go through there.
[48:18] I'm still looking for final language on the TMP as well about what does the TMP say about access through the site in connection to Appletree. and I would expect that it has similar findings in there as well because if they'd gotten to this the TMP is far enough along where if they had requested the [48:41] what's it called the gate to be removed. unfortunately we haven't had many discussions on the TMP since I started a year ago so I don't really know where the current status of that is and we just reached out to DOT for an update because another TMP in this area is all a different direction as well which kind of impacts this TMP as well.
[49:01] So, there's a couple moving parts on the transportation side. Nothing major has changed, but what I have found at least as it pertains to the gate is that city staff are supportive of it and the applicant has said that this is something they added after discussions with city staff. And this dates back a couple years ago. I don't know, Tony, if you were able to get any more information from Jeff.
[49:25] Okay. Cuz I'm it's very confusing to me. I guess I
[49:33] I don't understand it. I 'm not in favor of it. I mean, we have so many discussion about, you know, the connectivity and extending roads in almost every project we want to know about future connection, and here we're creating a connection and then we're putting a gate on it.
[49:54] And we have a smaller project recently that we required, you know, two connection points. And we have other projects in town that have two connection points. So, I'm I'm still perplexed why that's there. And then I guess learning from maybe
[50:15] fire and police, I mean, there's
[50:20] I'm trying to understand a scenario where there's
[50:25] it doesn't seem like a good convenient quick way to go in through that back emergency gate. I don't know. I'm just I don't I don't understand. I don't understand the gate, but
[50:39] I mean, it's that seems to be the based on the conversation we had at application completeness a couple meetings ago. That was a general feeling from the board that I think a few of you had noted that. So, what we could do is look into more information exactly why. Otherwise, it matter you saying that you would prefer not see the gate there.
[50:58] I don't Yeah, I don't see a reason for the gate. I don't
[51:02] Can I make a comment?
[51:03] Yes, please.
[51:04] I think the main reason for the gate is to prevent cut-through traffic from entering the entering the project, going to Appletree, then going over to Flag Pond, and making that loop to the light. You know, and it really that is a it's a parking lot. It's a low-speed parking lot for the for the apartment complex.
[51:24] Like you really don't want people zipping through there. you know, to prevent that whole loop. And I don't And the people on Appletree Lane obviously don't want it either. the other thing you might want to take a look at the correspondence with the fire department in your packets. he responded to me and he said, "Thank you for the turning templates and thank you for showing the gate and the lock Knox Box." So, he's acknowledged it's there and that they were requesting it as well.
[51:51] So, I just I don't want to throw that out there.
[51:55] Yeah, I All that makes sense. I follow the parking lot.
[52:04] Yeah, [52:11] It is I guess I don't understand if it Is it something that the fire department is requesting the connection? It I mean, so we're we're going to create a road and then no one's ever going to use it. I'm not
[52:26] Right. It's it's essentially if for some reason you can't, you know, the entrance to the to the complex is blocked for whatever reason, car accident or something, on Route 1, and you have to get in there with an you know, emergency vehicle, you can go back around and go up the access road and open the gate and drive in.
[52:43] Yeah, and then it's it's only for if there's a Knox Box that I don't think the police department carry Knox Box keys. Maybe they do, I don't think they do, but so then it's only fire department. I'm I don't know. I'm not I'm not I guess I'm not I understand not wanting folks to go through and it turning into a racetrack and I mean I see the way that this is designed.
[53:10] I think there's been care put into it. [53:16] I'm just having a hard time with we're looking for connection and we have a connection and you're building a connection and then it will just get overgrown and no one will use it and it I don't know. That's just I still don't know the Anyway.
[53:38] Any other thoughts from board members?
[53:45] Are you talking about the gate or just in general?
[53:48] just in general. Yeah, just in general. I mean it can be about the gate. You can keep talking about the gate.
[53:54] Yeah.
[53:54] I mean cuz I as I recall it was I mean objections from the people on Appletree and Flag Pond Road that was going to increase traffic in their neck of the woods and exactly that. I mean I don't know how many people would actually use this as a throughway because it seems much slower than just continuing on Route 1 and turning onto Flag Pond Road, but
[54:18] sometimes people's plans don't make sense to the rest of us.
[54:22] Yeah, I mean it seems like a nice way to get to North Saco and [54:29] we're talking about connectivity and then we connect it and then we're can't use it. That's
[54:34] But I think the city wants people to stick to the main roads that are built for traffic at higher speeds. And this is not being built to accommodate cars going 35 mph, which is hypothetically what the speed limit is on Flag Pond Road.
[54:52] Sure. So I'm playing devil's advocate for a moment. So why the connection? Let's
[55:00] I think it's just fire safety though. I mean I it seems like that was the discussion. This was a couple of ago, but the fact that
[55:07] This is a long Yeah, this is a long road and the people the people on the on the border of Appletree Lane are pretty far in from Route 1. So, provide another opportunity, a more convenient opportunity for them to be reached if they need to be. I don't know. I mean, I remember that there was a discussion about it and I don't think it was us who decided on the gate.
[55:31] I think it was the city who decided on the gate.
[55:34] Yeah, I think you're right. I think we've all still not quite understood why the gate I mean, I think there we have traffic and we have traffic discussions all the time. We have speed discussions all the time. it's just peculiar that all of a sudden on this one we just Let's just put a gate.
[55:57] We'll just stop.
[55:59] But, we're not calling it a dead end.
[56:02] And we're not calling it a dead end. So, yeah, I'm perplexed on that one. Chris.
[56:11] Yeah, I also don't think the gate makes a whole lot of sense. pretty much every project we do, it's connectivity,, sidewalks, roads. and if the whole idea is, "Hey, we don't want cars zipping through here." I mean, you could do speed bumps, signage. I mean, there's a million things that are done throughout the city that are done to help mitigate speed
[56:37] related issues and to me it's it seems perplexing to go, "Well, it's such a hazard that it's such a long road. We need access for emergency vehicles." But, if you're a resident and some the main thoroughfare is blocked, you're just stuck. And that's a lot of people
[56:57] that could end up just being stuck with nowhere else to go. so to me it seems like if you couldn't make the connection for some reason, there was no way to get to Appletree Lane. I think there would be other restrictions that would be on this.
[57:17] and where there is a connection minus a gate, it just seems incongruent with our general philosophy of what we're trying to do in the town. I could see why people who live on [street] or Flag Pond Road would be like, "Hey, we don't Last thing we need is more traffic."
[57:38] but I think if we're going to develop something like this, I think having the most ways in and out is would be the goal and then doing whatever we could on the back end to mitigate those traffic things through signage and or speed bumps or whatever would make sense is a better way to do it rather than just
[57:59] block it off. Yeah, if there's a fire, trucks can get it in, but other than that, it's basically a long dead-end road. So, that's kind of my view on it. and I for me as well, where there's the large solar array being proposed as well, I see that as a potential
[58:20] hazard in a sense because you're going to have large trucks working on those and when they install them, if the proposed plan is that they're going to be there perpetuity, maintenance of those, you're going to have a lot of cars moving back and forth and trying to fit all that traffic on one road could be challenging.
[58:40] and anytime you have more things that could go wrong, there are things will go wrong. So, that's kind of my overall view on the situation.
[58:51] All right, thank you, Chris. Any other thoughts from board members?
[58:57] Jeff.
[58:58] Well, I guess I'll throw my hat in there. I agree with both of you. I mean, cuz it is about always about connectivity. and you know, to Joyce's point, yes, we want to try to keep traffic typically on main heavily designed roads, but we have a new traffic light at the end of Flag Pond Road, that's less than 5 years old, that the last review was already a level of service E.
[59:21] You know, so it's like we're going to ask everyone to go through the new traffic light that has extremely poor service already. So, to Matt's point, if somebody wanted to go to North Saco, we're going to ask them to go back out on the Route 1 to go through a poorly functioning signal to go out, they're going to go down Flag Pond Road anyways, right? But if I was an owner on Apple Tree Lane, I probably wouldn't want the traffic in my backyard.
[59:43] My other fear is it's a fairly long road if it remains gated, is that going to end up midway down like a dumping area because there's no traffic, people kind of go down there, dump stuff on the side, there's not a lot of activity. So, I can kind of see both points. We're going to have to iron that out. So,
[1:00:02] And it's a lit road. We have lights along it.
[1:00:05] It is lit, but there it's lit and forested, right? I mean, it's not like it you could still go down there and it helps somebody who wants to unload their truck for their old TV, they can see better. Whether they do it, I don't know. but having had land that had a road in the past that people would drive down and dump their trash off, it 's not a great situation.
[1:00:27] I'd rather have some path through there. And And now, did I hear you correctly when you say there's a battery array in it or a battery bank in addition to the solar farm as well?
[1:00:39] That is correct.
[1:00:40] So, to Chris's point, now much more concerned about emergency response if we're going to have a battery array in here. I kind of don't want the gate there so that when something's going wrong and I have and our first responders, particularly the firefighters that have access to the Knox Box, are addressing an issue, that the residents can get out. We want them to be able to get out of that area.
[1:01:00] That gate might not be the best of ideas. So, I see both sides. Kind of leaning towards questioning why the gate's there as well. Thank you.
[1:01:10] It is a question. I mean, we've been directed to put this gate in.
[1:01:15] Mhm.
[1:01:16] So, the question then becomes is how do we resolve this?
[1:01:19] Of course, yeah.
[1:01:19] Do we do another CDRC meeting and meet with the, you know, police and fire and go through that process or how do we come to a resolution on this?
[1:01:29] Yeah, that's No, it's a great question, Tony. That Yeah, thank you. So, Charles So, I know it was a little bit it's before Tony's time, before Deputy Chief Duross's time. but I think was it a
[1:01:49] I think I'm just going to take a fresh look at the gate. I need I'm curious what the TMP specifically says about the gate. I hear the planning board's concerns and again, if the planning board is generally saying why, that's a good enough reason for me to go back and just I'm just going to go say why. So, that's a city thing cuz it might I think we are all I'm in agreement with the applicant that this is something the city had previously requested.
[1:02:13] And I think it makes sense when you're thinking about what Merrill Drive was originally, there wasn't really contemplation. So, I think long-term, the plan was no connection to it, but it is does seem to make more sense. At least in from what I'm hearing from the planning board, starting to change my mind on it, too. so, we'll go back to city staff, police, fire,
[1:02:34] but also look at it from a transportation perspective, too, because I know that there certainly would be concern concerns from the Appletree or residents and the Flag Pond Road residents. We heard from them earlier this year about potential impacts on Flag Pond Road. So, I assume this is effectively no different. but what we can do is look at it because especially with the battery energy storage, like doesn't
[1:02:59] make sense to have a one-way emergency gate that only the fire department can open. So, I think the easy It's easy solution The easy fix thing to say tonight is we will discuss it. It'll be I think we're It's a something I'm going to flag and to quick meeting.
[1:03:19] Okay.
[1:03:20] Thank you.
[1:03:21] Jim. So, I'm I'm not as troubled about the gate. I think that's fine. I understand the con- connectivity. And I think that's an important goal that we should you know, try to accomplish as often as we can. but
[1:03:42] I think we have to be really careful thinking about this because I recall those earlier meetings when Appletree Lane residents showed up and they were very much opposed to having that be like a regular roadway that anyone could come through. And I think people on Flag Pond felt the same way.
[1:04:02] So, from their perspective, they're thinking unless they're watching TV tonight, or they may be watching something else on TV, I don't know. But, they are they're already thinking they don't have to worry about their Appletree Lane being a throughway.
[1:04:22] so if board were to you know, majority of the board wanted that to be a throughway, we better let all those residents know about it so they can show up at the next public hearing and express their concerns. because I think they're all thinking that's not an issue anymore.
[1:04:43] So, I you know, I have feelings about the throughway. I get safety concerns. It would be great to have a second access, but there's a number of projects in town where they have gates for emergency access only. So, this is this would not be the first one.
[1:05:05] So, I those are just my thoughts.
[1:05:08] No, thank you, Jim. I think it's good and you bring up great points and I agree with you as well. I
[1:05:18] Yeah. I 'm optimistic that other techniques could be used to discourage folks from trying to make that a throughway. I understand concerns. I'm trying to understand why someone might even though with a failing intersection, why someone might
[1:05:40] not go to the intersection at Flag Pond if they're coming from North Saco to go through here to try to exit on an unsignalized making right hand doesn't make any sense to then making a left hand turn at an unsignalized condition when you could stay on Flag Pond to make a signalized turn.
[1:06:01] not sure what rational person would make that decision. So just like fresh eyes like Charles said and I think looking at it if we were look at it from again maybe a first time I don't know why anyone would I don't know. I'm still confused about the gate, but
[1:06:21] there could be signage. We could say cloverleaf, you know, community, you know, maybe some maybe some tools and Yeah, and discourage it and it Tony knows there's all kinds of things we can do with fun stuff you can do in the road to
[1:06:37] [laughter]
[1:06:38] make it unpleasant for people to you know, to traverse it, but at least you can go through it. I guess I don't know. Anyway, okay, that's probably enough fun for me on that anyway, but
[1:06:49] Can I bring up something
[1:06:51] Yes, please.
[1:06:51] different?
[1:06:52] Yes, of course, please.
[1:06:53] the letter in the after the fact packet talks about extending the fence along the property line along phase two and you may not have seen this letter yet because it came in today. so I was wondering if that was a possibility. There's supposed to be I think it's a stockade fence
[1:07:14] along the northern property line to keep people from going into the fields.
[1:07:20] Oh, all right. I'll have to I'll have to a look at that.
[1:07:22] Yeah, Tim suggested somewhere in here. we'd like to see the fence installed and if necessary continued to prevent access from the next phase of the development. So, he was asking about having the fence extended along the property line to keep the tenants from going into the
[1:07:43] into the Appletree Lane?
[1:07:45] No, into the fields to the north.
[1:07:47] Okay. Yeah, if you could wouldn't be along that email, Charles, at some point.
[1:07:53] Yeah, it's it's going to be available. I think there's a copy in the back of the room as well.
[1:07:57] Okay.
[1:07:58] And it'll be online. [1:07:59] You have this one for you.
[1:08:01] Yeah, it's already on the website, too.
[1:08:02] And excuse me, Charles, are you running the machine?
[1:08:07] Yes.
[1:08:07] The so, Tony, you want to point to that area on the screen there.
[1:08:15] So, to the left here, I think it's
[1:08:22] Yeah, right along that line length there that Yes, that and I believe that vertical leg as well. I think that's
[1:08:30] I
[1:08:32] Right, phase one is supposed to have Carrie Anderson was here at that meeting and he agreed to put in a stockade fence along the property line for phase one to the north separating phase one from that property showing is now or formerly of Vendem, Larry.
[1:08:54] Right,. no, in the in the Well, yeah, you're talking about the Yeah, the top of the screen. I think I think that's what he's talking about cuz that's where the vegetable fields are.
[1:09:05] And the trail connections as well he was concerned about.
[1:09:09] Yeah, different issue. I don't I don't think he I don't I don't know. I think he's talking about the fencing being along the fields.
[1:09:17] No,, no,, no, I No, I
[1:09:19] Right.
[1:09:19] I think he I think he's talking about that very top line.
[1:09:23] Right. Yes.
[1:09:24] Yes, that top line because there are agricultural fields on the other side and he doesn't want residents, you know, with their animals and stuff just going through that. you know, it's a food safety issue.
[1:09:36] Right. He's I don't I don't think he's talking about the trail. The trail is a different is a different issue.
[1:09:45] Okay. Jeff.
[1:09:47] I just didn't want to get too far off. I mean, if we're kind of wrapped up, I think it's important if we could open the public hearing and one of us I could read Tim's letter into the record and then we could have some discussion about it cuz that's a topic I'd like to touch on and maybe we can find out from city staff if that was a condition of phase one that wasn't met. or give them time to go pull that back. so, sure.
[1:10:09] Yeah, I don't think you need to read it. It's part of the record. It's submitted public comment. it's a part of the after-the-fact packet. but we can give the applicant a moment to read it and I can drive us over there real quick.
[1:10:22] So, with that, Mr. Chairman, if I may, I move that we open the public hearing for 986 Portland Road, Cloverleaf Development.
[1:10:29] I'll second that.
[1:10:31] Thank you for the motion, Jeff, and the second, Chris. Any additional discussion on the motion to open a public hearing on this item?
[1:10:39] All right, those in favor, Chris.
[1:10:41] Yes.
[1:10:42] Jim.
[1:10:43] Yes.
[1:10:44] Joyce.
[1:10:44] Yes.
[1:10:45] Jeff.
[1:10:46] Yes.
[1:10:47] Katherine.
[1:10:47] Yes.
[1:10:48] I vote yes as well. Motion passes, 6-0. If anyone is with us this evening that would like to speak on this item, please come to the podium and state your name and address for the record and we will collect comments and address them accordingly.
[1:11:03] So,
[1:11:05] Jeff brought up a good point. just to jump in and we shared that document with Tony, you were able to read that briefly.
[1:11:14] Yes.
[1:11:15] and I think Charles here is
[1:11:22] just providing a little graphic here.
[1:11:25] Yeah, just showing where I believe. So, if you This is going to be hard to see, so the head of Sylvan Trail, which is currently closed, I will just say, trail goes basically here to here. The And then, I think eventually the plan is to go further back if it would is, but don't know too much about that right now. so, that's the first part of the comment.
[1:11:47] I believe there is a fence zooming in on phase one that runs along the border. You can kind of see it here as part as an example. You can kind of see that fence here. I believe there was a fence part of phase one that extended to here.
[1:12:07] So, my guess is that the applicant or the public comment was saying to extend it here as well. One thing to note is that the
[1:12:23] This is also This is also required to be fenced in, so this will be fenced in.
[1:12:30] We do show the fence.
[1:12:34] Okay, I'll have to take a look at that.
[1:12:37] Yeah.
[1:12:40] Jeff, I Yeah, I just wanted to touch base particularly if that whole phase one should have had a fence to make sure that was installed. this is something that I kind of came about, you know, we often times talk about high density development and how it plays in and its benefits. I had the opportunity this week to be in another community that's doing this, and it seems like the green space is never enough because with the high density comes a high amount of pets.
[1:13:11] And these pets are used in the landscaped areas as their facilities. And it was like borderline disgusting. It was kind of like a public health issue. Is that there's this reeking odor of people that are taking their pets. And commend you for phase two, much bigger, much more active space.
[1:13:33] There's a lot of room within your development that I think that will contain a fair amount of people. but in this particular case, when Mr. Larry's saying, "Hey, we're growing food products in the field and people are using it to take their dogs for walks or animals out there." that's a pretty big concern. and I think that it in good neighbor standards, it would be very prudent that we make sure that this fencing takes place.
[1:14:00] And then for phase two, to continue till it would abut up to the required fencing for the solar array. I think that would do a really good job of mitigating anybody's temptation. And maybe it's just the kids that are playing and damaging the crop when they run through there and they're playing whatever games outside they might play. But I think having that physical boundary is very important to be a good neighbor.
[1:14:23] And that we need to be aware of that when we have such drastic uses from a high-density residential next to an agricultural piece. So, I really would encourage if we can get a definite confirmation from the compliance officer if that was a requirement in phase one. Was it done? And if it wasn't done, we should be evaluating that for, you know, approval of the applicant for phase two.
[1:14:47] and then we can see the applicant's willingness to continue or to install for phase two, the continuation to keep that buffer between that parcel to the north.
[1:14:57] Yeah, and it's not just Sorry to interrupt you, Jeff. It's not just creating a nuisance to the farm. I mean, there's also health safety concerns. You don't want people's children and pets in an area that's been sprayed with pesticides.
[1:15:13] I mean, that's a that's a that's a real concern for
[1:15:18] Right.
[1:15:19] your development's residents.
[1:15:23] But yeah, I it's I mean, I remember Carrie Anderson being here and talking about some sort of fence. I don't remember what type. And I didn't it wasn't you.
[1:15:35] Well, I'll I'll go back and check and see what see what's in the files.
[1:15:44] Catherine.
[1:15:46] I have a question about public comment cuz Jim brought up a good point about Appletree Lane and parts of Flag Pond. Were they noticed as abutters for this?
[1:15:59] Yes.
[1:15:59] Okay. And if the gate sort of plan is changing, is that something you would re-notice?
[1:16:12] Like make it clear to them that this is like a substantial change from the original plan.
[1:16:17] I want to I've been I think it's part of what I'm going to look at. I mean the answer is probably yes, we will re-notice because this is getting ahead of ourselves. We don't We're We don't have an I wouldn't have you continue this to a certain date or else we would just be again getting into that cycle of continuing it indefinitely. So, or continuing I will ask you to continue it indefinitely, which we will notice the project again.
[1:16:38] just so we can do another round of comment response before we look to make a decision. So, we'd probably notice it anyway. I think there's a the nuance with this is to what Jim was saying. If there are previous conversations and they have given previous public comment and it has been clear that for the last, you know, 3 to 4 years there would be no through connection and their concerns were handled, I want to make sure that if that direction has changed, then we
[1:17:09] look into not just noticing them because at this point they may be ignoring the notices, just doing some more direct outreach to those abutters, especially if they had given comment and we had already given direction that there would be an access gate there. And if we are changing it, which is fine, things change. making sure that they know that this is a change that's coming. So, I think it would be depending on
[1:17:32] how we got to the gate, I think it would just be good practice, good planning to Yes, we will notice them, but that doesn't mean they will look at the notice because they might think it's a done deal.
[1:17:45] Okay, perfect. Yeah, I just It seems like it's such a substantial change for over the years. I just wanted to make sure like you know, before [snorts] if So, we're not closing the public comment tonight. Just making sure they have a further opportunity to speak. Okay, thank you.
[1:18:02] Thank you.
[1:18:05] Any other thoughts, Jeff?
[1:18:06] Tony, could you just point out, for clarity, where the battery bank for the solar array is it going to be located near the solar electrical housing in the first turn somewhere around C20 next to the playground? Is that where it would be?
[1:18:23] Yes. It used to be in the last set of plans prior there was a battery building out by the solar panels.
[1:18:31] Yeah.
[1:18:31] in coordination with solar we realized that 's getting moved over to right where we have right there.
[1:18:37] Okay.
[1:18:43] It fronts on Merrill Drive.
[1:18:45] So, Charles, if we could, if we, you know, part of my concern, and we could have the fire department when they weigh in on the evaluation of the gate is that if something were to go awry and there was thermal runaway of the battery bank, you know, that obviously would shut down access to Merrill Drive completely
[1:19:06] until it burns itself out or unless SACOG has some special, equipment. Usually those fires can be very long lasting.
[1:19:16] Yeah.
[1:19:16] how do we get those residents out safely? And that would be part of the argument that I would want to weigh in for the gate.
[1:19:22] Yeah, there's I think part of our solar review and the battery energy storage system review is looking at our local ordinances which are pretty tight. the fire emergency safety response which is part of it, but also some of the state best practices coming out of the fire marshal's office related to battery energy storage. I know that they just released kind of a handbook for municipalities and they specifically added battery energy storage to that.
[1:19:47] So, we're definitely looking at that. And our third-party reviewer actually pointed out, to me at least, that 's what they're going to be looking pretty closely at, the battery side. The solar stuff is pretty straightforward at this point.
[1:19:58] Well, it's nice because we finally have an applicant that's going to look at something cuz they're trying to bring the conversation that this is truly to subsidize the use needed the demand for their development. The only way to truly do that is with battery storage. So, and a lot of them don't want to do that. So, rather than creating more issues for our community on the grid, this is kind of a good thing, but now we need to protect storage.
[1:20:20] So, this double we're weighing up both sides.
[1:20:30] Does the I think one question just here for the planning board. Do you guys have any concerns about the playground next to that?
[1:20:38] I'm looking at that right now and my I guess
[1:20:44] the proximity is on my radar, but I think the I guess my first thought was vegetation. And I guess is there
[1:20:55] are there two pieces to that to that area, Tony, or is there just one? I guess I just happened to notice on the landscape and there are looks like two gates.
[1:21:11] Well, there's there's a gate on the solar.
[1:21:14] Sorry. Charles, if you went to sheet L1.0
[1:21:21] which is
[1:21:26] probably towards the end, but No, I guess right here.
[1:21:38] It'll come.
[1:21:39] I believe.
[1:21:43] There's also three different plan sets which I could pull from.
[1:22:15] Is this the one you're looking for or you're looking for three?
[1:22:16] go one more north, please. L 1.0.
[1:22:26] I believe it's this one.
[1:22:43] It's coming.
[1:22:44] It's coming.
[1:22:47] I have a little my 17 set if you want.
[1:22:52] I'm buying myself a new computer.
[1:22:57] It's the only one that just doesn't want to load.
[1:23:01] Yeah, and it doesn't [1:23:05] it doesn't show up on the on that enlarged detail, either. So, I suspect it's I suspect it's maybe just an old thought.
[1:23:20] What sheet L 1.0
[1:23:22] it was L 1.0, yeah.
[1:23:25] I got it. I got it.
[1:23:45] As soon as you can
[1:23:49] But there's two gated enclosures.
[1:23:53] No, it's one it's one gated area with two units.
[1:23:57] One gated area with two units. So that top that top one is kind of a flyer and old thought.
[1:24:04] Yes.
[1:24:05] Okay.
[1:24:06] The gate I think that gate didn't get moved when we sweep we separated these a while back.
[1:24:13] Okay.
[1:24:13] The gate just needs to be moved to the front.
[1:24:15] So back to the original question was
[1:24:22] I was thinking about or I was curious about the landscaping from the playground to that area. it's closed, it's locked, it's gated. [1:24:36] I know kids are curious.
[1:24:38] Oh, that one there. Okay, that one that one's That is showing double.
[1:24:43] Yeah, you see what I mean now.
[1:24:44] That's what I mean. Yeah. The lower one is the correct one.
[1:24:47] The lower one is the
[1:24:48] Right.
[1:24:48] That's the one proposed.
[1:24:49] We had an issue with the other one splitting the property line.
[1:24:52] Sure.
[1:24:53] And there was a comment for that, so we pulled it into the lot. And you had to go by it to get to the playground before.
[1:24:59] Yeah.
[1:25:00] Now we've separated them on either side.
[1:25:11] So the So the power
[1:25:14] the power comes out to the road and then makes its way to that location. Is that
[1:25:18] comes out to is a
[1:25:27] I need individual sheets.
[1:25:32] Okay.
[1:25:35] Sure. But generally So it solar array inverter along that pathway out to the main paved road and then it along that road to the battery, and then it
[1:25:50] magically goes everywhere else, but
[1:25:52] Right.
[1:25:52] it 's nothing underground straight shot to that area. It's It's along the road. [1:26:00] I guess you answered Charles, you asked that question, the proximity. [1:26:06] Yeah, I Sure. So, my question would be is there Is there flexibility in maybe
[1:26:15] Is there flexibility in that location? Opposite What 's opposite it directly?
[1:26:41] I think that's just an electrical vault looking at the utility plan.
[1:26:48] I mean, there is flexibility to move the playground.
[1:26:51] I guess that will probably come back as part of the review, I'd imagine.
[1:26:55] There's a you know, minimum separation or something similar to that.
[1:27:01] Sure.
[1:27:01] We could still move the playground to the left.
[1:27:04] I was just going to suggest that is perhaps maybe it maybe it shifts to the other the opposite side of move your cursor up a little bit to the left.
[1:27:16] clicked. It's your fault.
[1:27:18] Into that open area. Yeah, right there. Yeah. Maybe it works there.
[1:27:26] Yeah, I mean, there's a there's a few areas there that are open to move it and wouldn't result in any additional wetland impacts.
[1:27:35] Sure.
[1:27:44] Sorry, that was a long-winded answer and discussion. Any other thoughts for board members, Chris?
[1:27:54] [clears throat]
[1:27:54] Yeah, I'll just say right out of the gate, I might be a little biased cuz of my electrical background. but that was the first thing that jumped out to me was the playground right next to the battery storage cuz to Jeff's point, if those things go, it's it's a big fire, it's hard to contain, and I definitely wouldn't want my family right next to it when it happened.
[1:28:16] now, there's all sorts of safety procedures and things to mitigate that from happening. and if that was the only place on the whole site where you could do it, then I think it'd be better to have one than not have a playground. But if there's anywhere else where it can reasonably go, I think it just makes sense to just move it, remove that hazard altogether.
[1:28:40] and I get you know, from an electrical standpoint, why you'd want the batteries there because I'm guessing where it ties in with the main power coming in, so that if the solar panels aren't producing enough electricity to run the whole complex, you need to have that backfill capacity from the main grid. That you wouldn't want that all the way at the back of the lot because of various reasons.
[1:29:03] [snorts] but again, where that's the only way coming in and out, it does open it up to a hazard if something again happens that you're not going to want to drive by that for a long time. so I definitely I think it's a good idea to Jeff's point, a lot of the solar projects you see, they kind of just pass the grid part of it on to
[1:29:33] everybody else, and you know, a lot of people are left kind of holding the bag. So I like that you're trying to implement the battery system to make it a more integrated system. I think that's very forward-thinking. and like I said, there are lots of safety things that go into managing that risk, but if God forbid anything happens, it's going to be quite a show.
[1:29:56] So, I would I would recommend moving that playground. even, you know, to some of those open spaces not too far away. cuz I think it does keep it in a central location for the overall site and just gives it that little separation of boundaries.
[1:30:17] I'm not as concerned about in normal operations someone getting in there. I think people have the common sense to kind of avoid those type of buildings and as long as there's enough fences and gates and things to keep people who are determined out, I think that should be safe, but just my concern would be if there was a catastrophic failure,
[1:30:38] you know, mitigating any immediate risk cuz if it does fail, they tend to go quickly. It's not like a oh, you have some time to figure it out, you know. but yeah, that's my only thoughts on that.
[1:30:50] Great, thank you. Any other thoughts from board members?
[1:30:55] one last thought and then I'm done. The during the conversation about the gate, if that gate were powered and residents had access to open that and close that gate, you know, if that's a topic of discussion, how does that come into play?
[1:31:16] Is it you know, how does how do folks feel about that? So, then it's not it's only residents that go through that road. It's not everybody. I don't know if that changes anything, but just putting it out there now than opposed to later.
[1:31:41] Any other thoughts from board members?
[1:31:46] Okay, so and again, Tony, not to take away from I mean, there's there's a lot here. I think you guys have done a great job putting it all together and working with staff and questions and the conversation back and forth. So, not to make it seem like this discussion is
[1:32:07] We're trying not to go backwards, but trying to understand how to keep moving forward, but anyway, so we still have the public hearing open, and then Charles, we don't have a quite a date set in stone yet. but if the board wishes to, we can continue to a another date that staff will notice and advertise.
[1:32:30] Okay. I think that'd be the best course. Just we don't know how what the solar review would bring, and I think there's a couple items we can really button up before bringing this back for any decision on preliminary. I think you guys have given pretty great feedback tonight. and it seems that there's just a couple I mean, the solar and battery review will handle a lot of concerns.
[1:32:51] I think that's something we knew coming into tonight. some questions on the gate for staff, and we can coordinate with the applicant team to figure out what's a what was the reasoning, and then find out that. and then there's some questions about some of the public comment we received from the abutter. So, we can look at that.
[1:33:11] And I think that doesn't seem to be any many more questions related to this.
[1:33:21] That sounds good. Thank you.
[1:33:23] Mr. Chair, oh I'm sorry. Catherine, you had a question.
[1:33:26] I was just going to ask, do we want to I know we're going to postpone or continue indefinitely, but do we want to try to do a site walk sooner just so we're not dealing with weather issues whenever this comes up again?
[1:33:45] Up to the board if they want to do a site walk. [1:33:55] I know.
[1:33:56] I think I don't I don't need one, but I think it's thoughts from board members. I don't know.
[1:34:07] We did do a site walk for phase one. [1:34:11] Correct.
[1:34:12] I can't even tell you how far back we went. I don't I don't know if we went as far back as any of phase two because that was all pretty forested and swampy. I bet it still is. [1:34:25] I would imagine.
[1:34:26] So, yeah, it's it's hard to judge how far back we went. but it seems like we got a I thought we had a pretty good idea of the of the property and the slopes and the wet areas. That being said, I mean, I'm if the majority wants to do a site walk, that's
[1:34:47] fine with me.
[1:34:49] I'm fine either way. We had just mentioned at the other meeting that we would discuss it tonight. So, we can bring it up.
[1:34:58] Chris.
[1:35:00] I don't have strong opinion either way if whether we do a site walk or not. I would lean towards doing it sooner rather than later just for snow and stuff like that cuz I think yeah, it'll be probably a challenging site to walk. It's large. There's lots of wetlands and stuff. So, doing it before the snow definitely helpful.
[1:35:20] My only reservation would be you know, again, biased, but my main thing I would want to look at is like where the solar is going, how that's going to get laid out. So, if that's not fully buttoned down, that would be my only hesitation in doing it sooner rather than later. yeah, I don't really have a strong opinion one way or the other.
[1:35:43] All right. Thank you, Chris. I if the board if the board does want to do a site walk, I think we need to compile specific questions and in an agenda and what we'd like to achieve by doing a site walk on this one. There's [1:36:04] quite a I mean, it's a large parcel. It's a large project. So, I just want to make sure that we can communicate to staff and the applicant if we do want to do a site walk, what our goals and intents I
[1:36:21] It's quite a quite a large parcel. It'd be randomly walking around, but have specifics on what our concerns are or what we want to specifically see that we feel is unresolved or needs additional resolution, but Jim.
[1:36:39] So, I'm I'm I'm not sure we need a site walk, either. I mean, just looking at the plan there, it looks like all the development's going to be in the higher higher areas, not in the swampy areas. But, the concern I have is trying to site walk a site like that, it's just so large.
[1:37:00] We're just going to be walking through the woods. We're not going to know where we are at any particular point in time, although I know the applicant will do their his best to point it out to us where we are. but, I'm not sure we're going to end up seeing anything of significance while we're out there, given how detailed these plans are.
[1:37:20] So, I'm I'm fine with the plans without the site walk.
[1:37:27] Thank you, Jim. Any other thoughts from board members?
[1:37:34] Jeff?
[1:37:36] I usually like site walks, and I think this is a big project. however, given the unique nature and they're following the contours of the land, which puts them in the center of the parcel, there's not a lot to be concerned about buffering from other areas. I think it's pretty self- contained, and they've already been through the rigors like three times with the wetland delineation when we had that subdivision for the phase one and then creating So,
[1:38:01] and I haven't seen a lot of DPW comments concerned about environmental stuff. So, it's pretty much what we see on the plans and in that regard I would be fine operating off from these very detailed plans that they've provided. Thank you.
[1:38:14] Great. Thank you, Jeff.
[1:38:18] Mr. Chair, I'll move to continue the public hearing in this matter. Generally, I guess.
[1:38:27] For lack of a better word.
[1:38:28] I'll second.
[1:38:32] Thank you for the motion, Jim, and the second, Joyce. Any additional discussion?
[1:38:38] All right. Those in favor, Chris.
[1:38:41] Yes.
[1:38:42] Jim.
[1:38:43] Yes.
[1:38:44] Joyce.
[1:38:45] Yes.
[1:38:46] Jeff.
[1:38:47] Yes.
[1:38:48] Catherine.
[1:38:49] Yes.
[1:38:50] I'll vote yes as well. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you, Tony.
[1:38:55] Thank you. Quick question for Charles.
[1:38:57] Yes.
[1:38:57] I'm assuming we're talking about after we receive the next round of comments and respond to them. Is that
[1:39:04] Yeah. I think it's hard to know without knowing the full scope of the solar review and we do have to iron out a few of those items. So,
[1:39:12] Okay, but that's tentatively Sure. And I guess with that, Charles, would that be a scenario with the report back to staff, would you provide draft findings of fact or conditions or anything during that
[1:39:29] Yeah.
[1:39:29] time? Okay.
[1:39:30] Yeah. Unless during the during that final review it comes back that we need the planning board to decide I would anticipate drafting full conditions and findings.
[1:39:40] Okay.
[1:39:40] based on that.
[1:39:43] Okay.
[1:39:46] Great. Thank you, sir.
[1:39:47] Thank you.
[1:40:19] All right, continuing along our next item on our agenda this evening is 335 North Street. This is map 68 lot 13-3. And this is again a public hearing for site plan and conditional use. And this is to construct a gas station and convenience store with an apartment above.
[1:40:40] And this is within the highway business district. Charles, anything to add on this one before we begin?
[1:40:48] no, so I will just say that there's also kind of going along the same time is the traffic movement permit the TMP review. so that's going with the going along with the state. At this point we've only had our scoping meeting and I believe the applicant team is working towards that next resubmission and the submission of section seven.
[1:41:12] So I don't have too much updates beyond that on the traffic movement permit. But other than that, no, there is no further comments. Stan, I believe the applicant's here to speak.
[1:41:22] All right, great. Thank you. Board members, any conflicts or disclosures before we begin?
[1:41:29] All right, and with that we'll turn it over to the applicant.
[1:41:37] Am I able to share my screen? Is it this little thing?
[1:41:50] Okay. Thank you.
[1:42:00] Yeah, I had some additional things that I thought might be helpful to share in case people weren't familiar.
[1:42:12] Just go to your file explorer.
[1:42:16] And then go to the that thing, yeah. Just run the execute.
[1:42:22] This one?
[1:42:23] Yeah, sure. Yeah, that one.
[1:42:26] Okay. Oh.
[1:42:28] Interesting.
[1:42:28] [1:42:30] The one below it, yeah. The one below it, sorry.
[1:42:36] And then it'll load
[1:42:40] at some point and then you can just choose what to share. Either your desktop or the individual windows, so.
[1:42:46] Desktop.
[1:42:47] Cool.
[1:42:56] All right, I'll get started here. My name's Aaron Hunter, a civil engineer with Sebago Technics. Here on behalf of the applicant, Brenda LLC, for site plan and conditional use review for the construction of a new gas station convenience store with a residential apartment at 335 North Street. [1:43:16] Just give a overview of the project for everyone and anyone of the public that might be interested. Starting off with the existing conditions of the site, displaying your just a aerial image overlaid on top of the survey. So, there's two existing buildings on site,
[1:43:36] a existing redemption building and a existing beverage store building. There's The site has frontage along North Street and Lund Road with an existing full access entrance on North Street. [1:43:58] The site's about just under an acre and there's a small area of wetland over on the behind the store, the beverage store, adjacent to Lund Road. I think it's important to just highlight kind of where we've come from in the process. the project was initially reviewed
[1:44:19] at sketch plan back in November of 2024. this is just a the sketch that was presented. We were proposing to keep the existing beverage store and add the convenience store and fueling station adjacent to the residential condo development adjacent to the project. [1:44:41] We've since revised that to eliminate the beverage store and reorientate the site. One of the big items that was brought up at this meeting was you know, it being adjacent to the residential development and making sure that we're considering that in terms of providing buffering and distance from the fueling station.
[1:45:05] and then also traffic was a big concern and one of the concerns was about having fuel deliveries and larger vehicles having their main access point be from Lund Road and being able to navigate into the site and out of the site back onto Lund Road. so we've tried to accommodate that.
[1:45:27] I'll show here the site plan rendering of the current proposed site. So you can see we have the convenience store building, the fueling station with the canopy. there's six fuel pump cabinets that will serve 12 fueling stations. and then there's a loading area for the proposed convenience store
[1:45:51] over on the rear of the property. that's where the access to the apartment will be as well. You can see that we have added that entrance onto Lund Road. We've worked to narrow that down to 33 ft to not need to request a waiver for that.
[1:46:13] we've also restricted the turning movements from North Street to a right in right out only and added a median to direct traffic to only take a right out of there so it'll be just a raised slightly raised concrete rollover island that would allow for larger vehicles to pass over there as necessary when entering the site.
[1:46:39] [1:46:44] we've also added pedestrian connections from North Street going into the site to access the convenience store. we've also delineated crosswalk or a pedestrian area to go between the
[1:47:04] fueling station area and the convenience store. in terms of landscaping
[1:47:14] we're adding landscaping throughout the lot and along the site edges to strengthen an existing buffer between the residential area and the proposed development we're retaining an existing fence along the boundary with the residential condos and then retaining existing fence
[1:47:35] between the property the gas station and our property. you can also see we're adding a mixture of different plants to provide screening and trees to provide screening from any sort of mechanical equipment and just
[1:47:55] general use of the site.
[1:47:59] for utilities we're going to be running utilities from Lund Road primarily we will be connecting to an existing sewer service that goes into North Street but we're proposing to keep all of connections out of North Street to not impact the road that's recently been redone.
[1:48:24] And then for storm water, we're doing a series of three different storm tree filters. one over here and then two over near the access on London Road. and that is paired with a subsurface underground detention system. that will be used to detain the storm water prior to outletting to the low area of the site where we're impacting
[1:48:50] some wetlands in order to outlet the storm water. [1:49:03] In terms of lighting, we have pole-mounted light fixtures to light up the parking areas and surrounding areas. Ceiling-mounted fixtures for the covered fuel canopy. And wall packs along the building as needed. Solid waste, we have a dumpster that's located
[1:49:27] adjacent to the gas station area that's going to be enclosed with fencing. And then in terms of permitting, we've received a DEP Natural Resources Protection Act permit permit by rule for the outfall to the wetlands.
[1:49:49] we currently have a are under review with the Army Corps for nationwide general permit for impacts to the wetlands. We're at the latest comment we got was just to provide some additional forms that they require. So, we're working through that and expect to have approvals from them here shortly. And then the other big item obviously is the traffic movement permit with Maine DOT.
[1:50:12] as Charles said, we had the scoping meeting back towards the end of September, so we've identified what they're looking for additional information for the traffic study. ask It's quite a bit of information that we're being asked to look at, so we'll be in the process of gathering that and preparing that submittal to DOT and working with the city and any other parties to provide all the information that's necessary to evaluate traffic efficiently.
[1:50:42] [1:50:45] That's really the gist of things. I have some additional plans of the building that I can quickly share, but I won't get too in-depth into it. have a floor plan that was included for the convenience store. Some elevation views.
[1:51:07] This would be looking from North Street what the building would look like with an entrance. and then looking towards the rear of the property towards the adjacent self-storage building. You can see the residential access. This lower portion of the building here would be for the access to the storage for vehicles to drop off merchandise
[1:51:32] and load into the store. this is the side of the building that would be seen from the residential development. So have varying roof lines to add interest to the building and to make it look appropriate for the area. And then this is the elevation looking from Lund Road.
[1:51:54] So this is the really the I'd say the main entrance to the store that's facing the fueling station canopy area. And then just some high-level drawings of the fueling canopy. So happy to talk about those any more, but really just looking to get some feedback and understanding that we're have a little bit of a process here with the traffic movement permit, and we're going to be continuing to work with you all [1:52:24] to hopefully work towards approval. Thank you.
[1:52:29] Great. Thank you, sir. Board members, any questions for the applicant? Catherine.
[1:52:36] I have two questions.
[1:52:39] During the site walk, there was some discussion and it had been discussed that you had reached out to the Shell station about trying to do a shared driveway on Lund. Has that gone anywhere?
[1:52:54] I've communicated that to the applicant, the owner, and asked for an update, and I'm I'm still waiting on some additional information on that. I know they've talked to them in the past and haven't had any success. And so regarding that, I assume the intent is that we would provide some sort of a
[1:53:15] easement or access for them to close off their entrances. Is that the intent what the common is related to that? Because I
[1:53:27] So, when we were on the site walk when we were over on that edge on Lund. Oops, sorry. That was really loud. there was a line of cars to go straight or to turn right onto North Street, and a car had come out of the Shell station sort of in the middle of that, and one car put on their brakes to stop, and the car behind it almost hit it.
[1:53:50] So, I'm concerned that you're going to add a bunch more traffic there to add to that line where people can't necessarily see or understand what the people of the Shell station are doing, and it's going to just add a lot of confusion to that intersection where it's going to make it more dangerous for people turning left onto Lund from this station
[1:54:12] with traffic already trying to turn left from the Shell.
[1:54:18] and then my second question was the dumpster. I'm not really familiar with like trash hauling. Does that usually happen at night or during the day?
[1:54:27] so we've kind of outlined a couple of different options in the application materials. the preferred option would be at night just due to the situation due to the location and the angle of loading. alternatively, it could be done during the day if they were to roll out the [1:54:47] roll out the dumpster from there and load it into the into the garbage truck. so it's not it's not defined at this moment exactly when, but we would like the flexibility to do it as necessary.
[1:55:04] Okay, that's cuz it's it is sort of in the major right of way if it's during [snorts] the day. Okay. thank you.
[1:55:14] Great. Thank you, Catherine. Any other thoughts from board members? Chris.
[1:55:22] just for a point of reference, do you know roughly what the existing bottle redemption building height would be? Or is, I should say.
[1:55:31] it's it's one story. our proposed building is, I believe, like almost 32 ft. So probably half of that. Well, I think actually I don't remember what the bottle redemption is, but yeah, it's I couldn't tell you for certain.
[1:55:50] Yeah, no worries.
[1:55:56] Jim. So on the
[1:55:58] [clears throat]
[1:55:58] the height of the new convenience store building when we were out there on the sidewalk, I think we were all kind of guessing the height's going to be about the same as the condos right next door, right?
[1:56:11] Yeah, I know that was that was mentioned. [1:56:14] Cuz it looks like you have some windows on the second floor of the convenience store and so it's really a two-story building, but so are the buildings right next to it.
[1:56:24] Yeah, and so the convenience store, the second floor of that would be for the apartments, so it would be similar use to next door. there's no windows on the back side of the first floor facing the residential.
[1:56:40] And so [clears throat] this is more of a comment rather than a question, but I when we went on the sidewalk, I know some of the members of the board were thinking about that, you know, trying to tie the Shell station entrance onto Lund a- along with your entrance. you know, I mean I live in North Saanich, so I go to that Shell station all the time.
[1:57:03] And so I'm I'm familiar with the difficulty getting in or out, and the people fig- figure it out pretty quickly, I think, and I don't think any particular way in or out is more dangerous than the other as long as people are paying attention. although on our sidewalk not someone wasn't, right, that day?
[1:57:24] but when I use the Shell station I take a left out onto Lund Road. I mean, if there are cars stacked up on Lund Road, of course you got to wait till the light change. But then it's pretty easy to get out. So I don't I don't really think it's going to be a huge problem cars turning left if people just have a little bit of patience
[1:57:44] waiting for the light to change. And in the same way, the second entrance on North Street I think is a very good idea. You know, the right in right out makes perfect sense, and again when we went on the sidewalk I used that right out, and you can't always do that depen- if the traffic's all backed up, but you know, then you would go over to Lund Road instead. But I think again people
[1:58:07] will learn to figure that out in a safe way. So I'm I think the plan that you've come up with in terms of the entrances and exits is a very good plan, and so I think good job.
[1:58:20] Thank you.
[1:58:22] Great. Thank you, Jim. Any other thoughts from board members? Jeff.
[1:58:28] Yeah, so I had kind of a few things and I noticed that the your comments, your narrative had described the solid waste pick up you were planning on doing that at night. I think we just need to double-check our zoning ordinances about time of operation for those vehicles to pick that up. Cuz if not, then if it's not permitted, it could create some conflict with your turning movement in the parking spots.
[1:58:50] the other thing I thought on a site walk we had talked about the building being sprinklered because of the mixed use but in the latest narrative and this could have just evolved, it looks like am I correct in understanding the apartment is sprinklered to meet the requirements of a mixed-use building, but the entire store area is not and you're using a 2-hour fire separation.
[1:59:14] Is that correct? So they
[1:59:15] Yeah, so yeah, I was just reviewing that actually as well again just to make sure I had that correct and yeah, we did coordinate with the architect and based on their preliminary review of the code, the residential would be required to be sprinklered and the convenience store wouldn't wouldn't be required to be. that's obviously
[1:59:36] something that would be further need to be further reviewed by fire department and
[1:59:40] So I mean so we can as we get further along, we'd probably request that from, you know, the deputy chief to confirm that. Staying along fire suppression, is that the applicant's opinion is that there's no need for a cooking hood exhaust hood because of the type of food prep that they're doing here or the minimal amount of it. if we can just make confirmation that the type of food prep that they're doing doesn't require a few a hood, kind of summarizing with the fire department.
[2:00:08] And I believe that Deputy Chief Duros was working on confirmation about the clearances and then probably you touched on this. from the residential units, right? The residential use, the storage tanks and the trucks delivering. Just to give us some confirmation that all those, you know, setbacks have been met. [2:00:29] you were relocating the electrical that would feed the Shell station, correct? Cuz you're shifting that overhead line. near the dumpster according to one of your plans.
[2:00:41] Yeah, so we are I'd have to look at the utility plan here real quickly, but yeah, we're there's some coordination that's going to need to be done between the
[2:00:52] the parties.
[2:00:53] between the two parties to allow that transition to take place.
[2:00:57] Yep. the other thing that I and thank you for putting on the HVAC units on the backside, so we kind of know where they were and kind of get a sense of the buffering from the residential units. so all your refrigeration is self-contained within the building.
[2:01:18] apparently, you just have the two units for the spaces, the retail space and the apartment space. [2:01:29] Getting back to the traffic, I'm glad that the traffic movement permits are working on that. I was the one a little bit more, you know, vocal. I would love to see just a right in from North Street and no exit at all, just say no exit cuz the real challenge with that light system and they're still actually working on it right now. They're making modifications to it.
[2:01:51] And that was why I was so adamant to ask staff, "Hey, make sure that we get real-time data on this not." We had for other planning reviews a lot of modeling data from the Turnpike Authority and the MDOT for the light sequencing, and it hadn't really been built out yet, and I don't think it functions as,
[2:02:13] you know, the way I was explained it was going to function currently. So that was, you know, to try to get the queue lengths. We have a very large queuing issue at these traffic lights have been added on 112. So anything we can do to minimize cars trying to cut into that queue is important. That was why I had suggested if we could only do a right in from North Street and anything we could do to really shift
[2:02:38] your entrance and exit on Lund Road as far to the north of that line as possible and I realize it would create more impact because that Lund Road in particular has a very short queuing area because of the entrances of your driveway and if we could work with the Shell station and get them to all kind of funnel along so as Jim indicated then people aren't cutting out trying to get in between the queue.
[2:03:02] It does, you know, currently a lot of the locals figure out how to make that happen. The bigger challenge is that they have a lot of sporting events and when those tournaments are going on we have tons of locals which we like in our community for the tourism event but it's very confusing at that intersection and that can actually pile up, you know, 20 cars deep down Lund Road and now you have this kind of gridlock agitation of people trying to get out but it does sound like Charles and the team
[2:03:33] the and your team has a lot of information to work on that moving permit. So the more information that we can get would be helpful for us as a board. Other than that I felt like you had done a pretty good job addressing a lot of the things that we discussed at the site walk and it was very informative. So thank you for your work so far.
[2:03:51] Thank you.
[2:03:53] Great, thank you Jeff. Any other thoughts from board members?
[2:03:59] Yeah, Aaron, my biggest question, thought and concern was traffic as well. I just understanding how that you know what the info was going to come back and say and some of the comments and thoughts just trying to understand that. [2:04:19] and then for staff this is going to be a hard question. I know that Shell station has been there for a very long time. but there's been so much work in that area and I'm I'm trying to understand [2:04:40] how it's come to be where there's no curb cut into this into that property and there's just a little island and how does that Are there tools that the city has or that staff has to work with that applicant or
[2:05:02] create some sort of better or safe condition and I'm I'm trying to understand how do the you know how does the traffic pattern how does everything get evaluated when it's kind of like the wild west out there with cars with you know going in and out of that site. How does that You know a lot of our concerns is generally for the area and I want to be specific and fair to the applicant you know to do what [2:05:33] to be specific with their responsibility but overall for the city making sure we have a good safe condition and that sort of trying not to digress but
[2:05:44] No I know you're saying it's hard as part of the TMP we're looking at this all the uses in this area. I think we're going almost down to the industrial park intersection. I know you're not working directly on it but in that scoping meeting we were looking at it and one of the hardest things to kind of accept is the existing Shell station.
[2:06:06] I think if it wasn't my you know again I wasn't here when that new exit was added I would expect that to be something that they fix during that. As we are getting further and further into this TMP I'm kind of realizing it's not within the scope of we may look to like
[2:06:26] it's already been noted that it's a better condition and I think the applicant team is aware that if the Shell station connected through here and we close that access on Lund Road it would be a better outcome. To your question of what are the tools, there aren't many. They're illegally existing
[2:06:44] site that is, you know, is it ideal? No. From a lot of different from like a pedestrian's standpoint, from a traffic standpoint. but there's not a ton that can be done here. I think as part of this TMP, we're going to be looking at how to improve this one. It doesn't appear that property owner is, you know, interested in participating that much.
[2:07:08] so it's not clear what tools we have to clean that up. But I know that as part of the TMP, we're looking at kind of how this site operates with the surrounding sites, and I think that's part of the equation. Is, you know, can we make an can we make improvements to this intersection? It's kind of hard because the TMP is tied to this site.
[2:07:29] and this is already illegally existing site.
[2:07:34] Sure. And then, final hard question. The
[2:07:41] there must be little to no documentation or files on that for that particular property that says what it Meaning I'm I'm sure it wasn't approved in the condition it's at now. I'm sure it wasn't approved like that.
[2:07:59] I mean, it's it 's hard to, you know, it being built 40, 50 years ago. it definitely didn't contemplate a new turnpike exit being the corner of a turnpike exit. it 's it's tough to even look at like to even consider looking at that site and being like, yes, we can like if this site was improved
[2:08:24] or connected, I think the applicant team has already kind of done that legwork even before they submitted to try to work with that property owner. It just doesn't seem that it's doing I don't know what like one thing that I think that I want to ask for the TMP is with that TMP meeting and I brought up at the scoping meeting, it was like there needs to be some sort of general design change with this intersection.
[2:08:49] I think one I don't I forget the word I just I don't I forget the word I used at the scoping meeting, but from like a not a traffic engineer perspective, whenever I go that way out into, you know, North Saco or trying to go home using that northbound exit there, it just doesn't I'm I'm queuing for hours. It's like a some days are worse.
[2:09:09] and my question to the MTA, and we don't have the answer to the MTA and the turnpike, is what are they looking at? Like that is the that is an issue with this intersection with this intersection, especially when it comes to like pedestrians. So, I think what we want to look at is can we improve it? what can we do, and where are we limited?
[2:09:31] I don't think as part of you know, this site plan application, we can tell them to like narrow their entrances. Cuz I just don't think something like that is within our scope, but it might be within the scope of the TMP. And that's what I'm hoping to see some more clarity on. but I think it is a tricky element to this.
[2:09:52] Sure. the good thing is it looks like there is some
[2:10:00] property that sidewalks could be extended by someone else in that area. Right? In the in the roadway?
[2:10:13] Does that make sense what I'm alluding to?
[2:10:16] Potentially. I think that's kind of one of the things that we want to look at as part of the traffic movement permit. One thing that again, one thing that I was bringing up is people are walking to school. you have the middle school. This is kind of on that route to the middle school. and I just don't
[2:10:36] think it's great.
[2:10:39] Sure. okay, that's all I had. Aaron, the last thing you showed those mechanical units on the rear of the building, that's good. We talked about that the site walk, I guess just ensuring that you have the specs on those to show that they meet the sound attenuation level at the property line.
[2:11:00] I don't recall what those values are off the top of my head, but yeah, I think yeah, it's coming along. I think it's yeah, just curious to see the traffic outcome, that's all.
[2:11:20] Chris.
[2:11:22] Yeah, not to beat a dead horse, but I think clearly the applicant can't force the Shell station to make things better, but I think if there was some sort of easement or something that say the next owner of the Shell station or theoretically
[2:11:42] they put a sidewalk down Lund and then it closes off that section for some reason or there's some legal way the city can force the issue, I think just opening that up so that there doesn't have to be all right, now we have to rework the existing this new applicant's site to meet that new condition.
[2:12:03] I think if we can figure out a way to set it up for a perfect world and then if it never gets built, it never gets built, but at least there's a plan. I think that would be at least some way to somewhat resolve the issue.
[2:12:17] Thank you, Chris. Jeff.
[2:12:18] Thank you, Mr. Chair. I hear you, Chris, and some of this though is going to fall on the board as to have the vision for how far in the future that we're looking. And if you look on some of the sketch plan reviews just a little before you joined, the opposing corner has two applicants of very high volume.
[2:12:40] And they too are not in a super great position to get into the queue line on Lund Road, but it's better, right? So, now we'd be looking at offset intersections. At some point, we need to say, "Does this work? Do we permit it at all as a board?" To give you a little full circle, we here we are
[2:13:02] 45, 50 years later questioning the Shell station that was put there because it was directly off the turnpike entrance. The current turnpike entrance back in the '80s was the Saco exit. So, the reason that these locations are selected is because of their access to the location.
[2:13:23] That's why all these people are now competing for the current real estate there. And now we're having the hindsight of saying, "Oh, well, that Shell station never had any curb, never had this." The only thing that was out there, it was a two-lane road that was like quieter than Boom Road. It was so desolate when I was a kid. And it was just one I think one business down at the end was Saco Steel cuz they were relocated from the train station area down here, right?
[2:13:49] They were put out of town. And that's how quickly things change. So, I just think we need to be trying to be that forward-thinking, not saying, "Just hey, how does this one applicant make it work?" And "It'll be acceptable." We need to think a little bit bigger because there's a lot of people with interest in putting investment in this area
[2:14:10] between, you know, the hotel, the possible indoor water park that they want to do, the two sports complexes and the traffic they bring in. There's a lot that takes place here. And I think that's what we need to be kind of diligent on. And let's try to really push. I know the applicant's done a lot of work, but if it doesn't work, we might need to say that it doesn't work.
[2:14:33] So, cuz I don't want anybody looking at our work in 40, 50 years saying, "That was ridiculous having that high volume in these two offset merges." You know, we have very strict standards about intersection and alignment. And it would be great if there this applicant would go, "Hey, we cut out a deal with, you know, property owners to the east and we can move our entrance down Lund Road."
[2:14:57] Now we have a lot of options, right? but they understand we have great concern about traffic and we're all communicating that, so let's kind of see how it plays out and let's see what the state has with the traffic movement permit. So.
[2:15:12] Thank you, Jeff. Is the date for continuing We still looking at November 13th for
[2:15:20] Don't Don't we need to have a public hearing?
[2:15:22] We need to open it.
[2:15:24] I was ready to close it. I'm sorry.
[2:15:25] [laughter]
[2:15:27] So.
[2:15:28] with that, Mr. Chair, I would move that we open the public hearing for 335 North Street.
[2:15:34] I'll second that.
[2:15:35] Thank you for the motion, Jeff, and the second, Chris. Any additional discussion?
[2:15:42] All right, those in favor of opening the public hearing, Chris.
[2:15:45] Yes.
[2:15:46] Jim.
[2:15:46] Yes.
[2:15:47] Joyce.
[2:15:48] Yes.
[2:15:48] Jeff.
[2:15:49] Yes.
[2:15:50] Catherine.
[2:15:50] Yes.
[2:15:51] I'll vote yes as well. Motion passes 6-0. So if anyone is with us this evening that would like to speak on this item, please come to the podium and state your name and address for the record and we will collect comments and address them accordingly.
[2:16:12] So, Chair, just while we wait for someone to come up, I do just want to note, I think one thing that I talked with the applicant before this meeting is that the application review is moving It's pretty far ahead of the TMP review.
[2:16:32] and I really don't have any I don't have a good pulse on this. I don't think any of us have a good pulse on the TMP review right now just because the scoping meeting brought in so many different elements. The applicant's working on it. so what I had told that the applicant that what I feel is the best way to move forward with this review is to table the application
[2:16:53] continuing the public hearing indefinitely in a similar manner. We're providing comments on the resubmission and then what we said we want to wait to see where the TMP goes with this before we really go further into site plan review site design just because there could be some minor changes. Could be major changes.
[2:17:14] Could be minor changes. It's hard to say what it is right now. Especially given if there any future impact fees or impact fee from the TMP. So I think the plan and I think the applicant is understanding of this to see where the TMP goes and then bring this back with a response to city comments response to some of the comments tonight
[2:17:35] just so that the site plan review doesn't you know get approved or get too far out of line out of sync with the TMP review especially given the context.
[2:17:49] Mr. Chair. So Charles, you're saying we want [clears throat] to continue this public hearing generally as well?
[2:17:55] Yeah, this is it's a different reasoning for it but it's kind of more of a you know I figure we'd bring this at least once while we have while it's fresh recently after the site walk. We get some of the high level site plan site design stuff that aren't really the traffic but ultimately traffic is a primary component of this.
[2:18:18] and it's kind of outside of all of our hands. You know the applicant team is working to get some of the data do it. It's just a significant amount of data that was requested and that I think we expanded the scope a little bit as well. which so I think we're going to get a really good you know TMP process out of this but I don't know what that's going to entail in terms of like site access like moving it further away down Lund Road changes to the shell station if possible.
[2:18:46] Like a lot of these could affect site design. but it's hard to say what direction. So I think our recommendation is just to it indefinitely. and just to bring it back once we know more about the TMP. cuz right now we wouldn't want to condition this approve this with a condition on the TMP when we don't know what 's going on. So.
[2:19:05] So that so that sounds like a yes. So I'll I'll move that we continue public hearing generally.
[2:19:13] I'll second that.
[2:19:15] Thank you for the motion Jim and the second Chris. Any additional discussion?
[2:19:23] All right, those in favor Chris?
[2:19:25] Yes.
[2:19:26] Jim?
[2:19:26] Yes.
[2:19:27] Joyce?
[2:19:28] Yes.
[2:19:28] Jeff?
[2:19:29] Yes.
[2:19:29] Catherine?
[2:19:30] Yes.
[2:19:31] I'll vote yes as well. Motion passes 6-0.
[2:19:37] All right, thank you Aaron. and we'll look forward to
[2:19:42] having another discussion.
[2:19:44] Yeah. Thank you. Appreciate it. Was just helpful to hear everyone's feedback on the latest iteration just to make sure that we were trending in the right direction and we'll we'll be back when we have some additional updates on traffic.
[2:19:55] Yeah.
[2:19:55] Great. Thank you.
[2:20:06] All right, our next item on our agenda this evening item nine general correspondence. We have the one the email from one of our residents and then there was another one Charles that you had mentioned that came via email.
[2:20:20] yeah, the planning board received another email public comment on an item that was general correspondence from or last week or planning board updates related to the ecology school. So there's there's just some additional public comments on that. You guys were all included on that email in your Saco Main email addresses. but we received it after our deadline so it's going to be posted on the website tomorrow
[2:20:43] morning. Or posted on part of the agenda in the more section. but it wasn't about any of our items tonight.
[2:20:52] Okay. Great, thank you.
[2:20:56] And then item 10 are planning department updates and discussion items. Any advisory body updates? We do have long-range planning is meeting tomorrow evening.
[2:21:08] Yes, so long-range planning continues to work on the implementation of LD 2173. So we should be getting some updates December January to the planning board. conservation commission is going to have a pretty busy November meeting with their advisory reviews. so we're kind of working alongside that. the conservation commission and the planning department had the open space listening session.
[2:21:33] So a few board members came out to that. I do appreciate those who came. and it was a good way to you know start the public participation process for the open space plan. So we had some really good questions, good feedback. I'm excited to see where that goes, but really that's kind of it. just so you're aware, the 11/17 planning board meeting will most likely be canceled.
[2:21:54] we don't have any agenda items. we have a lot of projects awaiting resubmission. kind of based on what I was saying earlier tonight, the applicants really do appreciate not rushing to get a resubmission, but also when we give out resubmission. The other piece is that the applicant for five Hopson has withdrawn their application.
[2:22:15] So we're canceling the site walk and the public hearing that was scheduled for that was continued to that evening.
[2:22:38] Any thoughts or questions from board members on any of those items?
[2:22:47] All right, moving to item 11, planning board comments. Thoughts? Jeff?
[2:22:53] Mr. Chair, I just wanted to take a moment. I know I reached out to them today, but I wanted to let Charles and Lisa know I think that the site walk notes that have been taken for the last four or five site walks with Madison and Lauren are very well done. I think it's really important. I mean you guys know me that here I like to have our meeting minutes pretty detailed and yet it makes sense that we refer them back to the video record which is great.
[2:23:19] A site plan as you know doesn't have that and I think they do a really good job capturing the intent, the focus of the board, kind of where we're moving on sites and the questions that we're asking. So I think that they are doing a great job summarizing that for anybody from the public that wants to kind of see what was or read about what was going on. So I just wanted to give some kudos to them and as a supervisor I thought you should hear it as well.
[2:23:43] So they're doing a good job.
[2:23:44] No, that's great. No, they've been enjoying going out and I think it's good getting them in the field and I'll pass this on to them. Appreciate it.
[2:23:52] Well, I'll I'll I'll echo what Jeff had to say but I'll add that I particularly on the last few site walks in particular Lauren has asked a number of questions of the applicant. Very particular questions having to do with the plan. Some of which that I hadn't even thought of but they were very [2:24:14] they were very well thought out questions and I thought it was very helpful for the board to have the applicant respond to her. So that was that's good as well.
[2:24:30] Great. Thank you everyone. Any other final thoughts before we adjourn?
[2:24:37] All right. Well, thank you everyone for joining us and we will adjourn here at 8:16 p.m. Thank you again.
[2:27:07] Mhm.