Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:01] Speaker A (unidentified): It is Tuesday, November 10th. It's 6:30. This is the regular select board meeting and the select board members present are all present along with their town manager and go to boss event. I said I'm gonna pull this meeting to order and we will begin with the pledge of allegiance. That flag is over here.
[0:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Pledge of allegiance to the flag, the United States of America, to the republic which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all that.
[0:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Frequently the agenda.
New Business
[0:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Tonight I'm going to attempt to keep things moving along. Additional business not included, Shannon just alerted me. We need to add a donation from Aging at Home and a expense for the Wayne School Consultants. So we will do those in item 7. The warrants and donations is 7E and 7F. Is there any other business that we need to include on the agenda tonight? Nobody's got anything else? Are there any conflicts of interest with the agenda tonight? I don't like sitting in a row. Okay, we're going to begin with the meeting minutes. I'm going to suggest a motion to approve the minutes for October 20th 2026. We have a second. Any discussion about the minutes from October 20th 2026, which problems concerns? Those in favor of approving the minutes, I think we'll move on and do the words and then actually I'd like to flip the old and the new business because we've got a lot of, we have people here that make no sense maybe to do some of that other. Business, but let's do the warrants and donations first. First up, Rhodes Capital Reserve account. Shannon, what can you tell us about this?
[2:27] Speaker B (unidentified): So I sent out a memo regarding this. I had been receiving several complaints for Fairbanks Road after the completion of the paving on that. And just due to the impacts on individual vehicles and the time constraints for that, I received two quotes from companies organizations that had the shoulder smoother smoothing equipment. And so I received those two and I would request to move forward with the quote from CH Stevenson for Fairbanks Road and seventeen thousand nine hundred and seven dollars and fifty cents to do all of the shoulder work on Fairbanks Road.
[3:08] Speaker A (unidentified): So therein is a perceived conflict of interest. I have no financial or influential business with C.H. Davidson, but I am going to remove myself from the discussion. Can somebody make a motion and move this forward?
[3:27] Speaker D (unidentified): Sure. I'll move to approve and authorize an expense of the amount of $17,907.50 cents from the roads capital reserve account for shoulder work on Fairbanks Road. Second. [Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion?] Shannon, are the rest of the paving roads that are being paved, are they also going to do shoulder work? So we didn't have it
[4:01] Speaker B (unidentified): schedule in our contract that would be a separate contract the quote that i had received from ch stevenson to do all eight roads amounted to about a hundred thousand dollars just given the expenses that we've had in the last two months it wasn't something i was prepared to tackle instead we're just looking at potentially having them go out and do as needed in and so i do have several roads on a list or excuse me driveways on a list that i do need to ask them to go out and do as well
[4:36] Speaker D (unidentified): They've all been identified and it's where there might be a sleep drop off for example and there needs a little bit of gravel and then I've got several
[4:44] Speaker B (unidentified): on Pond Road on my list currently, Shannon.
[4:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you talk about any recommendations from the
[4:55] Speaker B (unidentified): infrastructure, the infrastructure committee would recommend doing all of it and looking to have it paid out potentially at a later date. That was something that C.H. Stephenson had offered. So if that's something that is feasible, looking at doing in January. Our treasurer is currently out. We've had a last week with elections and this week is on vacation. So I figured we'd look into that further once you get the facts.
[5:27] Speaker A (unidentified): And the reason I ask now is whether or not we do anything different with the motion that was already on the table but if there's no other discussion do you want to vote on the motion that's on the table those in favor well zero and I'm abstaining moving on so Shannon are you putting that on next the other roads on next week's agenda
[6:06] Speaker B (unidentified): I can yep if
[6:10] Speaker E (unidentified): you do that please all right
[6:17] Speaker A (unidentified): moving on payroll somebody like to
[6:19] Speaker D (unidentified): they can all see that payroll number 19 please payroll number 19 the amount of 11 199.6 cents
[6:30] Speaker A (unidentified): and then anything unusual in this no any discussion those in favor six five zero really next up is accounts payable
[6:46] Speaker D (unidentified): under 20. So if you approve the accounts payable number 20 in the amount of 91 817.83
[6:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Shannon anything to tell us about that's payable number 20. So looking at the accounts
[7:00] Speaker B (unidentified): Payable, you'll notice the first payment for the road filing has begun. I think that's in due time considering we have snow on the forecast for Friday. There are two payments for the public safety answering point. Those were quarterly payments. We're not sure how we missed the first one, but that includes the two out of the four. And then also the roads and winter salt. I think we had mentioned previously in a select board meeting that you would be seeing that on an accounts payable. That's 24,000 out of the 27,500 that we have
[7:32] Speaker C (unidentified): that you did any
[7:37] Speaker A (unidentified): discussion was in favor, five zero. Moving on to donations for the rec center.
[7:51] Speaker B (unidentified): So the recreation center received the, excuse me, it wasn't part of the recreation, it was aging at home.
[8:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Never mind, I'm skipping ahead. Let's do D with the rec center, which is on the agenda first. Thank
[8:05] Speaker D (unidentified): you. Somebody like to move accepting the donation for the rec center. Move to accept donations in the amount of five hundred dollars to supplement the existing appropriation for lad recreation
[8:15] Speaker A (unidentified): center programs. Second. Any discussion? Anything unusual here? There's a bit. Janet, did they do it?
[8:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Did y'all get an eleven thousand dollar contribution? I think that was on the last
[8:30] Speaker B (unidentified): leftward meeting. I think there were two. There was the eleven thousand plus another twenty, 20,000. You had, I think, 38,000 for a lab rec center on the last one. Okay,
[8:40] Speaker C (unidentified): we'll check the minutes. No, I believe it. I think I don't see. No, maybe this is for the six.
[8:54] Speaker D (unidentified): There was a lot of donation, I think, last meeting. I think maybe, and I don't know, you'd have to, you and I and I, and they might not have specified what they wanted, but just something to keep in mind. I sort of have heard through the grapevine that they wanted the 11,000 to go into their reserve account, and we could have accepted it for that, and I don't know if we did, if we accepted it for programs or if we accepted it in the reserve account. Was this for the October
[9:26] Speaker B (unidentified): 20th meeting? Was that designated for playground? No, well, I don't know. I know there's been some
[9:32] Speaker C (unidentified): discussion about on the playground. Let's just skip it and move on, but that's the last meeting.
[9:39] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't know if you're expecting another one soon. There might be another.
[9:44] Speaker D (unidentified): We should check the math to make sure whatever people are talking about adds up to what we
[9:50] Speaker A (unidentified): We've we've acted upon it and see if anything 11,000 fell through the cracks. We should definitely take a look at it. Yeah. So, in the absence of facts and data, we accepted donations last time. Shannon, could you check the math on that? And follow up and make any adjustments in the agenda next week. Yep.
[10:17] Speaker D (unidentified): Didn't Lynn say when she was coming by? Thursday. I was afraid. You're related to the labs. You need to vote.
[10:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. That was part of the discussion. We went a little bit off track. Those in favor of accepting the motion, we'll keep saying 5-0. Okay, so we added. Shannon, help us out. A donation for Aging at Hope.
[10:44] Speaker B (unidentified): So I'd ask you to consider approving donations in the amount of $50 to supplement the existing appropriation for the Aging at Home program.
[10:52] Speaker D (unidentified): Someone wants to accept a donation of $50 to supplement the existing appropriation for the Aging at Home program.
[10:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Any discussion? All in favor? And Shannon, tee up the Wayne School Consultant expense, please.
[11:09] Speaker B (unidentified): And I'd ask you to consider approving an expense in the amount of $825 for Wayne Elementary School Consulting and to authorize a payment from the Wayne School Consulting Reserve account.
[11:20] Speaker A (unidentified): So moved. Is there a second? Second. Any discussion? Is there anything further to say about that?
[11:29] Speaker B (unidentified): Pending approval, then that would be added to the accounts payables for next week.
[11:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Did I see a hand waving?
[11:35] Speaker F (unidentified): I can just add that we're preparing for our forum coming up on November 15, so the consulting fees that we've gotten are kind of in the lead up to that forum. She's helping us back check some of the things that we've prepared.
[11:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Any other discussion? [Speaker D (unidentified): All right,] we're going to flip old and new business and take new business first. First up is the keep it blue committee presentation. Well, and then actually,
[12:22] Speaker D (unidentified): let me just introduce this by saying 1 year ago yesterday was the first forum and way presents for him on the end of Scott and like, galaxy with 160 almost 160 people participated that and it stimulated all the things that it's going to take two of us to explain what happened in the last year so go ahead good
[12:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Evening everyone. Sarah Lane pull in one of the eight members of the Andrew Scoggin Lake steering committee also a member. So as you mentioned right after that forum last year December 2025 we formed this community group to help focus different lake efforts on the specific issue of recurring algal blooms on Androscoggin Lake. And so we just wanted to give you kind of a year in review of what we've accomplished so far and what we're looking ahead to. So since we formed that group in the spring of 2026, we also worked to assemble a group both technical experts lake science experts several main dep staff engineers and staff from 30 mile formed a technical advisory committee and then also hired ecological instincts and bhb to assist with data collection and analysis both of lake science activities but also engineering aspects related to the dead river dam in june we held another community forum. We had about 100 attendees in person and online, and those presentations Q&A are recorded and available online. And then in the summer, we kicked off seasonal monitoring and data collection. So you know there's been, for many years, monitoring and data collection efforts related to the dissolved oxygen in the lake and the bacteria that causes algal blooms, but this year we really ramped up with a lot of additional types of data collection. All of this is to inform the development of a watershed-based management plan and this is a plan that we are working to develop and ultimately plan in 2027 to submit to the may vep if we have an approved watershed-based management plan that would basically make us eligible to apply for mitigation dollars from both the state and from the federal. So, this is kind of a really critical plan that lays out what the sources of phosphorus are. What's kind of the balance of. Inputs to the lake from all those different sources and then what are potential solutions to address this in the long term. And we can share some additional information with as well, but some of the new monitoring efforts included, we had a. Monitoring buoy that's at the deep hole station in the lake which reports 24-7 observations of a bunch of different factors. But that really was able to show us when the lake was about to tip into an algae bloom. It did bloom again this year but much later than last year. So it was October I think second to 20th the lake bloomed but it was not as severe as it was in 2025, which was considered a harmful algal bloom. So that data is being analyzed fully over the winter. Also, Maine DEP and 30 Mile staff collected sediment samples at 17 different locations on the lake, including a couple of larger core samples, which will really give us a good idea of kind of the existing phosphorus and layers and some historical information about those inputs puts into the lake. They also did dissolved oxygen transects, a land cover watershed analysis, and then BHB Engineering has been doing a peer review of the 2002-2003 EPRO study on the dam. And so what they're helping us understand is whether we need to update additional analysis. So we can kind of continue to work off that information. Again, all this information collected over the summer is going to be analyzed this winter by ecological instincts. And so by the spring, we'll start to really have more conversations about what is this telling us and what does that mean about potential solutions that we can pursue. On the funding side, for this effort, about $150,000 has come from various state and local funding sources. So there's a $25,000 Maine Outdoor Heritage Fund grant. ALEC contributed $25,000 from their Healthy Lake Fund to this effort. So you know about the main Dp. Grant about $80,000, and then both the town of Wayne and the town of Lee. It's approved at their town meetings funding towards this project. We are also have a fundraising campaign that is seeking individual donations from community members in Wayne, and it's towards this project, and that's a $75,000 goal. So, total goal of 225,000 dollars to complete this watershed based management plan, and get it to a point to submit to DP next year.
[18:07] Speaker D (unidentified): So I think those are the highlights I wanted to give you, and I'll just mention 1 thing that we were really proud of, the fact that there was a fantastic article in the journal on this program, which brought really positive and good news to Wayne. And that was really, met 2 of our goals. So the rest of the story is where we go from here now. So we get the watershed based management plan, which will tell us what we need to do and where we do. By the way, the next visible thing that you'll see is a chart which I don't have, but it's called the loadings chart, which shows it's a pie chart. It shows the proportion of the phosphorus loading that's internal to the lake, which means it's already in the lake. The portion that comes from weather, the portion that comes basically from wildlife, mostly birds, and the portion that comes from external loading such as runoff from camp roads and other things that are around the lake that comes into the lake, including from upstream. So that chart will then tell us really where to focus the mitigation practices on. We don't know what the mitigation practices are yet. We know what other people do, but this lake, keep in mind, this is extremely unusual. This is the only lake in the whole world that has two feeds with a serious amount of water that comes in from the other end. That water is not good water. And we've calculated that every foot of water that comes into the lake from Indus-Dargan has two billion gallons of water and it can't leave as fast as it came in. So typically the floods are around 11 to 12 billion gallons a year. This year there was no flood, fortunately. Who knows whether it contributed to our success or not, but just keep in mind that's a lot of water. Anyway, going forward, as Caroline mentioned, we're studying the, what do you call it, the samples, the sediment samples that were taken and have to be called spring. And in the meantime, we're gonna keep going with communications. We need to keep this in the forefront of people's minds. It could take the form of our teams doing research and figuring out how to better explain what phosphorus is, where it comes from, how you mitigate it. We don't really anticipate any action by any government entity this year. We wanna put together the whole package before we come back and say, well, we need to address these five or six things, but we knew we needed to get the community really behind us in terms of their information the other thing that i wanted to mention was that well i can't read my writing in my pen died so i won't but the fundraising is coming along and we do hope to have a focus on things that might be useful to address that town meeting we don't want the issue of the lakes to be absent because then people will think, well, compare that, we don't need to worry about it anymore. It's a very big thing still out there, but we're nibbling away at it.
[21:06] Speaker C (unidentified): We're doing a good job. We got great people. Thank you. Yeah, and we continue to engage people both
[21:13] Speaker B (unidentified): in Wayne and leads, and got kind of a target list of people to keep talking with, including the different camps and facilities around the lake, through the winter months to continue, you know, educating them as well. And also asking them to be engaged in this fundraising effort and mitigation effort.
[21:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Any ideas. Welcome question.
[21:38] Speaker F (unidentified): Do you guys have like a mailing list that people can subscribe to for updates? It would just be great to hear this more regularly. Yeah, so we don't have a mailing list, but there
[21:48] Speaker B (unidentified): is a dedicated page on 30 miles website, which is 30mile.org slash andrewsgoggin dash bloom, where we've been doing periodic updates about activities throughout the whole last year. That's also where there's a link to donate to the fundraising campaign. But we've also put together this year in review document, so we'd like to, you know, leave some copies of this at the town office and around once we finalize this. So in terms of really outbound communications
[22:26] Speaker D (unidentified): we do try to have an article in messenger every month. We do have alex mailing list that, you know, it uses 30 mile has a mailing list, they use yacht club certainly has a mailing list. If it relates to this, they can use, so there are lots of ways to keep people focused on this issue. And I think everybody, it's one of those things, you know, there's an issue you just don't want to know too much about. I think that you've had, you get sucked into it, but it's a very significant issue, and if we spend the kind of money we're thinking of to get the lake under control, that's just step one. Then we've got to make sure it doesn't get out of control again. So down the road, all kinds of watershed things need to be addressed. Thank
[23:10] Speaker A (unidentified): You thank you. Any other questions? Shannon, was there anything online? There are two individuals online. No comments or opinions. Any, I'm gonna just open the floor briefly on that. Any questions or comments for Caroline? All right, moving on to code enforcement. You have enough update for us?
[23:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes ma'am. All right, so I sent out my report which is attached to the agenda. I don't know if you guys want me to go through the whole table, but I could try to briefly do that. We had in the first quarter from July to September of the fiscal year 27. We had 30 permits total, which was a total of 3 255.78 and local revenues. We had two new residential homes, four residential remodels or additions. We didn't have any commercial construction in the first quarter. We had five accessory structures, no solar projects for other buildings, which I but there's what there was a couple erosion control projects in the shoreland zoning. I had a demo permit and a driveway entrance permit. We had three subsurface wastewater permits out, one for a complete system and two replacement complete systems, and I had six internal plumbing permits for fixtures, and one was for a replacement water heater. So the code enforcement and plumbing have been active as the outdoor building season comes to an end. There's been a wide variety of projects in town from new homes to additions and renovations, accessory structures and water quality projects. projects. On the FDI side, we had one new subsurface wastewater, which I already said, and two replacement systems, and a handful of internal plumbing permits, both for the new homes and some of the renovation projects, because there was a couple kitchen remodels. As we move into the colder weather, the projects actually, I might help you to slow down a little bit. When you're obviously going more to the indoor projects, I'm going to be working on more administrative projects and a lot of filing and organizing and catching up on some of our enforcement issues in town that have been kind of hanging around for a little while. So most yes, that's pretty old administrative. I did recently reach out to our town attorneys is Phil Socher and Brady Barnes and spoke with both of them in reference to two of our different legal issues in town, one of those legal issues Is for an illegal auto junkyard. You guys probably well aware that one is in the consent agreement, so I spoke with the lawyers to see what the next step is, especially coming into the role kind of in the middle of the legal issue. So they've instructed me with this one as well as the other issue, which is the property on the Fairbanks Road. So between those two properties, they suggested that I send them both courtesy letters, just sort of introducing myself, reminding them what the issues are with our statutes and LUO references, and giving them a timeline, as well as, you know, letting them know what the next steps will be legally from the town. So those letters are going out. I still have, that's two of the issues. There's still a couple of other issues that I am researching and just kind of collecting the information on those, so that stuff is moving towards enforcement. And yeah, I'm always open for people to let me know what's going on in town that I'm not catching, because I'm not out on the road all the time. A lot of the time I am in the office, and that's most of
[27:06] Speaker B (unidentified): what I have for you tonight, unless you have any questions. So I just want to highlight that the reporting period that was listed on here was from July 1st to September 30th, and although Angelica said that it's starting to slow down, she did just have three permits issued today, so I think that's interesting. But so she's planning on coming back in January to give another update and keeping it quarterly, so she'll be covering the period of October 1st through December 31st, October, November, December, to report in January. Is there anything that you would like her to specify or provide more information on?
[27:47] Speaker D (unidentified): Specifying or providing more information. But when you talked about in the code enforcement issues and you sort of bucketed that,
[27:54] Speaker A (unidentified): then you talked about some of the specifics,
[27:55] Speaker D (unidentified): for example, with multiple vehicles and those issues. I totally appreciate the fact that you're talking to, you're getting legal advice on, hey, what should we do here? Knowing that these are long processes, as soon as you get that legal advice, if there's a way to almost have a form letter ready to go, okay, because every, you know, like I said, yeah, everything takes time. Oh yeah, but when you've got something that's been a lingering issue, it's been around for a long time, help yourself, right? Unless you tell me that this is something you've already got taken care of, suggestion would be get it turned around. Just get it out the door, stamp it, mail it out. So you know that then a clock is ticking to get to the next point. Yeah. Because those aren't fun things to do. Right. But if it's a typically a standard formula, just get it out and then you just watch the calendar. Right. Likely not to get a response. No. So that's just whatever the second step is and the third step is and then get prepared for whatever the enforcement
[29:00] Speaker G (unidentified): Exactly. Yeah, I think we're kind of waiting off the clock with those notices because, like you said, there's a good chance we won't get a response. So then it's like, okay, well, that time's up next. So, and I'm letting them know the time limits that I'm giving them to respond as well in those letters.
[29:14] Speaker D (unidentified): Even understanding what teeth we have to be able to enforce these things and figure out if you need more teeth. And that's something I think we'd all like to understand if it comes onto.
[29:24] Speaker G (unidentified): Sure. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I can't get more specific on those dentistry issues for sure. I just never know how much of that I can put out in the public.
[29:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, that's the confidentiality. Generally speaking, generically, a little more specifics on a few other compliance issues. And I know you're going to be digging into a bit more of an understanding about how many of those there are and what the status is, where they are.
[29:53] Speaker D (unidentified): You asked for some specificity on the generically speaking.
[30:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other questions or comments commentary?
[30:13] Speaker D (unidentified): The other eye doesn't have a scar over it yet. Yeah.
[30:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Okay, next we're going to move on to appointments to the planning board. So, Shannon, can you help tee this one up, please?
[30:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. So about a month ago, I'd say, a couple of weeks ago, we had a resignation of one of the planning board members. And so the planning board chair reached out and asked us to advertise, knowing we had October 20th. It was a very short turnaround in order to get applications. We put out. A November 6 deadline for receiving applications for planning board. With the vacancy that leaves a vacancy for a full time position. And that would take it until, for the remainder of the term until 2020, 2029. Nine and then there's an alternate position and so you could appoint one person to the alternate and one person to the full-time. We did receive two applications and I forwarded those each to you. I included the redacted applications in the packet. The Planning Board chair members did respond to both of them saying that they both seemed like excellent candidates, so it's to
[31:39] Speaker C (unidentified): The software so
[31:42] Speaker A (unidentified): It is in the packet. We have a full-time and a alternate second setup. Any anybody either want to make a motion or do you want discussion of any kind of background on the candidates list are
[32:05] Speaker D (unidentified): we making a motion on which would be the back bill standing position which would be alternate for I think I got two motions so I'm for the one to fill the finding board position and one to fill the order yeah correct well I
[32:22] Speaker B (unidentified): just didn't add the second one so
[32:25] Speaker F (unidentified): both applied to be the member not the alternate member or is
[32:30] Speaker B (unidentified): there any preference between the two applicants it wasn't specified on here okay it just says expiring term of June of 2029 so the remainder of open seat I would say take that as the full term I also found the 1994 planning board ordinance which says to fill the appointment for the remainder of the expiring term and that the alternate positions also have a term of five years I don't know when those started in order to keep them alternating so I think if you appointed did somebody to an alternate position you could set that fee okay so one of these positions one
[33:09] Speaker A (unidentified): of these individuals is currently an alternate and the other one is new to the board new to not on the board currently there we go somebody else motion well
[33:26] Speaker D (unidentified): I would move to appoint Richard Mackley to the vacant planning board position second is that the full motion yes second any discussion you know I think Richard's quite qualified his legal background seems like it would be helpful he's been an alternate and has sat on the board he's also I believe the chairman of the comprehensive plan committee and is the planning board's representative on that committee so I don't see how we could do much better than that I think it's almost a, it seems to me to be an easy choice. Yeah. I would observe, although I fully support Richard and will vote yes, I'm not sure that technically we complied with our policy. And maybe we need to go back and look at it and revise it and make it simpler because I don't think we've complied with it just about ever. And so it's our policy we don't even need it we could we could rescind it we can change it but we ought to do something that will comply with
[34:45] Speaker A (unidentified): just as an observation okay so let's pack that and Shannon can you add that
[34:51] Speaker D (unidentified): To the list of how is it out of compliance? Well, it says that the applications are supposed to be forwarded to committee, and the committee has includes the chair of like the planning board, and I'd have to go look at the policy and see how else it's done. I think it would be fine to just change it and say forward the applications to the chair of the board and get their recommendation. I know we those email communication that we got because I know that Andrew for example that of the board he commented on both candidates being appropriate. I suggest let's just take a look at it. Maybe it's maybe it's too, hey, I'm guilty on what it says. Maybe it says too much and we need to make it simpler.
[35:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think let's table that conversation and come back and take a look at the policy, and if we either need to commit to following it or commit to making it more easy to follow. I think we've got two great candidates, but given that Richard is currently on the alternate member you know I think that has some weight and we only have one
[36:00] Speaker D (unidentified): week to wait before we revisit this so I guess it's okay no I 'm ready to vote yes for him oh are we doing that I thought we were going to table the whole no
[36:20] Speaker A (unidentified): We're going to get back on track with the with the published. We're already got a table looking at the policy. So we have a motion on the table. Any other discussion about the motion, which is to prove Richard back early to the
[36:39] Speaker G (unidentified): to the planning board.
[36:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Those in favor? I don't see any no.
[36:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Passes five, zero. Would somebody, oh, I'm sorry. Did I just get you in my hand? Would somebody like to make a motion for the alternate planning board member?
[36:55] Speaker D (unidentified): Motion to accept, recommend, point. Caroline Poland, Hollande, as the alternate to the planning board.
[37:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Your second? Second. Discussion, Caroline, I see you're in the audience. Would you like to say anything?
[37:17] Speaker D (unidentified): You're the Caroline. Yes, go on. Go on. Go on. Oh, there you go.
[37:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, thanks for considering me, interested in continuing to. Be involved in municipal activities, and in terms of the planning board. Work of a public policy background and very pretty well versed in state statute, mostly in energy areas, but understand state statute and just generally interested in ensuring that our ordinances continue to be or can be improved to be more accessible to the public and that they comply with changing state laws of the housing laws and other issues as they evolve further.
[38:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you. Carolyn, you're okay with the alternate
[38:15] Speaker C (unidentified): position? Yes. Any other discussion?
[38:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Those in favor? Those in favor? Those who cares? Thank you, Carolyn, and we thank everyone who sent send him forward and volunteers for any appointment or position. Now we need to talk about the Wayne Elementary local school committee. Shannon you want to see
[38:41] Speaker B (unidentified): this one up so I reached out to the local school committee regarding any bylaws that they had for appointments. I had put down an expiring term of June 30th of 2029 but for school boards and things I think that it goes until the next town meeting of which then it would go until 2029. In any case we did receive one application and the local school committee seemed very supportive of that and they sent an email showing their endorsement for it and I believe you have that resident in the audience as well
[39:18] Speaker A (unidentified): and I'm not sure Henry are you trying to say something no I'll wait I'm quiet for the minute. Catching some catching some open there. Taylor, would you like to,.
[39:34] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I think the descriptions in there, but it's, I'm happy to fill the vacancy for the remainder of the term and then help the.
[39:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Advisory committee, I suggest we have a short discussion on this before the motion is made. Okay, hey, I think Taylor would be great. And I'm ready to vote to put them on there if I can do that since it's on the since it's on the agenda and there's a motion about to be made I'm assuming somebody has checked to see that we have the legal authority to do this do we I
[40:11] Speaker B (unidentified): asked the school committee if they were to be the ones to appoint it they seemed I'm sure. And so I said, Buffy, if they had a recommendation or I mean, I also sent the applications to them, then said to send it back to this left board.
[40:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Did Tegan resign? She did. Now they appointed Tegan. Correct. and if somebody has some authority to point to I would be happy but I don't believe we have the legal authority to do this. There's a statute that says they do it and we have a we have an ordinance that says we don't appoint members to school committees and it's in the mma manual what the statute says in there and there may be other authority that I don't know of that's why I'm asking. The statute says that the remaining school committee members appoint a replacement to serve until the next election they should do that within 30 days if they fail to do within 30 days then the select board calls a town meeting to
[41:32] Speaker F (unidentified): elect a new board member and this is for local school committees the statute you're talking about
[41:40] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes ma'am, actually if it was for the RSU school board we do appoint that person. Yeah, which brings us to a to a point of process on do we want to have some do we want to have some mechanism when we want to do good work to ensure before we do it that it's within our legal authority, and if we think that's something we should be doing how do we intend to do it?
[42:24] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think we have to separate those. One is the process, but the other is based on the facts you're providing it does appear that we do not have the authority, and you just cited some specific
[42:38] Speaker D (unidentified): references. Yeah, I don't have them, I don't have them printed, but I can tell you hang on one
[42:43] Speaker A (unidentified): second. Do we have either of the local school committee online by any chance? Well they're
[42:49] Speaker D (unidentified): going to have to have a meeting that they advertise, you know, it'll have to be an advertised meeting with the quorum. Could
[42:59] Speaker A (unidentified): you ask Sue if she has any comment please? Yeah,
[43:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Sue is not online.
[43:08] Speaker A (unidentified): That doesn't sound like says my name is Sue.
[43:13] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, the it's it's 20-a MRS section 2305 talks about local school committees, and it has filling a vacancy may be filled by the school committee within 30 days. The term of a member appointed by the school committee to fill the vacancy shall expire at the next annual meeting or whenever the remaining members of the school committee fail to appoint a person to fill a vacancy by election at a town meeting called for that purpose. We do have an ordinance on filling elected vacancies, and I think it says we don't fill school positions or school committee positions. I don't have it on my machine.
[43:57] Speaker F (unidentified): So anyway did you happen to look at the reorganization plan? Yes, if it speaks to
[44:04] Speaker D (unidentified): it, yes it does, it's
[44:15] Speaker C (unidentified): a yeah I'll get it for you, have it on your phone, it
[44:22] Speaker D (unidentified): is, you want
[44:32] Speaker E (unidentified): to come back next week? Well I
[44:42] Speaker A (unidentified): think I think Taylor we going to need
[44:46] Speaker D (unidentified): to, I think
[44:51] Speaker F (unidentified): I just see that it says school committee member shall be
[44:55] Speaker C (unidentified): elected in accordance in accordance with the statute, that's about yes that's it,
[44:58] Speaker D (unidentified): it in the sense that I just read to you. Yeah, all right, so table the
[45:08] Speaker A (unidentified): appointment, and based on the research you've done we need this local school committee to follow the process and appoint, so I'd recommend that applicant reach out to
[45:27] Speaker F (unidentified): them. I'm just worried if we table it then we will exceed that 30 days, and do we know what that 30
[45:34] Speaker D (unidentified): day period is no one Keegan resigned or if we've accepted her resignation, you know, hey, the statutes, the statute, but I'm, I'm less likely to think there's going to be an issue on 30 days than there is on an agency on a group that doesn't have any authority at all for anyone one, but I don't know when Tegan resigned or if a resignation was accepted, maybe she's still an involuntary servitude to the board, I don't know, I
[46:09] Speaker A (unidentified): don't have any of that information.
[46:14] Speaker D (unidentified): And what I'm suggesting is what we did in July, and we talked about it in July, and that's how we did it in July, I don't remember, what did we do in July, Henry, remind me, we said the school board or the school committee does it, and they did, they appointed TV, so I think, I think we had this, we had
[46:36] Speaker F (unidentified): this, we had this discussion in July, yeah, and so we can just tell them to pick whatever they want.
[46:44] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, but it needs to be an action that they do at a meeting that they noticed, like to call them up on the phone and ask them.
[46:56] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think it's gonna work. So Shannon, can you go back to the remaining 2 members, ask them to schedule a meeting with reasonable notice that you can publish for the action of appointing somebody to fill that process, fill that vacant spot, and let them know that they've got a, well, they obviously know they've got a interested person. And this was just posted on our website. It was. so if there were other people they had the opportunity to apply, yes, so we're not doing
[47:38] Speaker B (unidentified): like those things, that's the better, yeah, Keegan resigned on October 26 and I reached out to Sue and Theresa, they said to send any applicants to them, they'd recommend this so on board, but I will have them, I will direct them to 15 days, tons of time, but just to clarify, you want me to direct them to schedule a meeting to appoint somebody, yeah, that will be given reasonable public
[48:04] Speaker A (unidentified): notice is
[48:09] Speaker D (unidentified): that a problem, no, I think that's, I think that's the way to do it, consider it done.
[48:16] Speaker A (unidentified): And we thank everybody who puts their applications in for any position, moving on, local school committee update is this, who's speaking about this.
[48:32] Speaker B (unidentified): so originally theresa and sue had sent out a update on the read field select board they sent out their agenda and sent it to the select to our select board informing them that read field had met with the rsu 38 to let them know what their concerns were with the community and with the current situation and so teresa then requested to give an update but then she and sue both would be unable to attend at this meeting or on the 17th as well so she reached back out to the superintendent and requested that the Strategic Planning Committee follow the procedures that they had lined, up in their presentation. And so the Strategic Committee will be meeting with each of the communities at a scheduled time later. So Teresa and Sue requested to meet with the Select Board, the Town of Wayne Select Board, in December to start drafting a letter of concerns to present to the school board and the Strategic Planning Committee in January. And so that's all I have as far as an update from Teresa and Sue can
[50:00] Speaker F (unidentified): I add to that please so the RSU met last week I think time is moving really fast I think it was last week and to give some more context the read field select board wrote a letter to the RSU that they then read during public comment but it essentially said we should start the school closure process now it's a two-year process we'll start it for all four schools we think that the school board should budget money to begin this product process now as you can probably guess that concerned a few citizens here in Wayne and so the RSU decided at the meeting last week that they would have each of the town select boards come and have the opportunity to present their opinion about that letter I think they indicated at the time that they would hear from all of the towns before they would make any sort of comment about what refields letter said so when is that supposed to happen i have not we asked that question and the superintendent basically did not give like a clear timeline of when we would be making any presentations and who would be making the presentation. I wasn't sure if there would be a formal request that would come to the Select Board for us to do that. I don't know if you've gotten that or not, Shannon, but that is, that is just what's happened at the last meeting that they had. I don't know if we want to start thinking about what we would say. I think personally saying we should probably wait until the end of the strategic planning process that all of our taxpayers are currently paying for before we make any steps towards closure would be my personal preference of what we present, but it would be up to the select board what we said.
[51:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you give those time frames again? The strategic plan comes in January.
[52:01] Speaker F (unidentified): Right, I think it should be released. For some reason I have March in my head, like the spring is when it was going to be released, and it's going to inform kind of budget decisions for this upcoming next fiscal year, so the current budget session and
[52:18] Speaker A (unidentified): the commitment was that the RSU will listen to all the select boards and no timeframes are given?
[52:24] Speaker F (unidentified): No timeframes are given.
[52:34] Speaker D (unidentified): I may not have remembered it correctly, seriously, but I thought I saw a reply from the district, from the RSU, that this is a strategic plan process. I thought I saw a reply that kind of was negative towards this Reedfield position on jumping ahead with deciding on school closures. Did I, did I
[53:06] Speaker F (unidentified): imagine that? The local school committee, so Teresa and Sue, they wrote kind of a memo responding, and I think they sent that to the school board. The Mount Vernon select board, I'm also aware, has sent the school board a letter as well, so I don't know which one you might be referring to
[53:26] Speaker D (unidentified): but it hasn't come from the district the district hasn't the district hasn't hasn't said anything positive or negative on this read field proposal they've been very specific not to respond to it
[53:38] Speaker E (unidentified): Baby Taylor's, yeah, I've got a letter here that basically states that they listened to the letter without discussion, and then they were voting a couple of weeks ago to allow each of the other member town select boards to select one or two spoken people board on their work, and their response to the other communities, and those would also be heard without discussion. Once every community has had the opportunity, they'll timeline the board who discussed the matter at a subsequent meeting and Evo would come after that discussion. Support members would have time to process before taking action. Thanks.
[54:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, and it does, it does cite March 27th, so retail's action. The faction seems very premature and curious about their authority to recommend closing all the local schools.
[54:36] Speaker D (unidentified): I'd like to take a comment. I would just recommend to you that the letter that the Mount Burns like the board sent to the Rsu is really compelling. telling good fact based letter and you really should read it for your own information and
[54:58] Speaker F (unidentified): if it's helpful context that letter called for all four towns select boards to meet with the RSU board and to have a joint meeting to discuss the issue did that go out to us so somebody sent it
[55:13] Speaker D (unidentified): to me so I'd be happy to read it but I don't believe I've seen one or if I did I forgot about
[55:18] Speaker A (unidentified): it i think i might have seen it but i don't know which channel it came in so shannon could you share that with all of the board do you have it i do not do you have it i can find it i can get it can you send it to all of the board please so i don't think we can take it if you find it send it
[55:35] Speaker C (unidentified): to us also you don't want it from everybody i can do it
[55:44] Speaker D (unidentified): so i'm not sure that we could take
[55:47] Speaker A (unidentified): specific action on this today because we've got nothing to act on until we have more facts and data and
[55:58] Speaker D (unidentified): one little more comment to what you said i think that whatever you do in terms of what how you develop a position you really should involve the school of options evaluation folks they're looking at basically reading this of whatever letter
[56:13] Speaker A (unidentified): involve which group though they can't quite hear you the options group the optional options group the options group same
[56:23] Speaker D (unidentified): it's all the same issues but they're working specifically on that.
[56:32] Speaker A (unidentified): So there's going to be a future agenda item, but I've got to get some data together. Was that it for the local school committee update? Yes, I think so. All right,
[56:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Shannon, can you move along to the grading contract? Yes. So we had a grading contract that expired this year. And it was previously a three year contract. The infrastructure committee asked that i request from the select board to extend it for one year it's currently awarded to ch stevenson and just due to the late lateness in the time frame trying to get them out there to braid as soon as possible i reached out to ch stevenson they said that would be feasible
[57:24] Speaker A (unidentified): so pending your approval all right so hearing that i think somebody's going to take up a motion please to have a motion are you going to have conversation first Henry but we can we can
[57:40] Speaker D (unidentified): approve the extension of one-year contracts on the grading one year on the grading contract second discussion yeah what is the term I'm looking to try to find it right now what is the
[57:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Term of that contract, Sandy, I believe that went to June 30th of 2026. It was a three-year. Okay.
[58:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. So it's already, so it's already, it's already expired. Correct. Okay. Yeah. I asked to see the contract. I got it finally, which is fine. We got it yesterday. I don't know what we plan to do. I think everybody should see the contract. That would be my recommendation. I don't know that we ought to be voting to extend contracts that we haven't seen. The contract basically says that it's executed by the select board on behalf of the town. It says the select board does things that really the town manager and the road manager does. I mean, the contract, if we were going to have a contract, it's probably should it should be should be revised. And also extending this contract for a year is really saying we want to do a sole source procurement with Stevenson for this one year. I mean, that's what it is. The contract doesn't provide for and that's okay if there is a good reason that we can't get competition. How much is
[59:20] Speaker B (unidentified): the contract? Do you remember it went up by 1 000 each year, originally starting I think at 21 000 or excuse me, 20 000, 21, 22 000. You know, I don't know if we're going to adopt our new purchasing
[59:33] Speaker D (unidentified): policy or not, but it basically said contracts under 25 000 would be like three, just three books. Correct, if I'm, if I remember, if I remember what I wrote, which I don't always. And so the process, if you decided to get a quote, would be rather informal, but if there is some exigency on getting them out there, I don't think the passing of the seasons and the passing of the calendar really snuck up on us. So the fact that we haven't, we haven't procured a new grading contract, I guess, I guess that's the reason I have, I have qualms. I want to get the roads graded, and if that's the only way we can do it, maybe that's the only way we can do it. I suggest we call it what it is. It's a sole source contract with Stevenson for one year, and when we amend the contract to extend it, I suggest that we clean it up, if that's what we're going to do.
[1:00:52] Speaker A (unidentified): So given that we haven't approved the new purchasing policy, I'm looking at the old purchasing policy to see what the guidance is around sole sources. I don't think there is any
[1:01:04] Speaker D (unidentified): guidance on sole source in the old policy. If I'm mistaken, if you come up to something, show me. But I and it required, it required bids, formal bids over a very low dollar amount. I mean, we'd be in formal bidding territory under our, under our current policy.
[1:01:27] Speaker A (unidentified): what 's the infrastructure's take on when they need to do the grade eight as soon as possible so don't really have time to do formal bidding is what i'm hearing shannon did you say how much
[1:01:42] Speaker B (unidentified): this year like extending it for one year how much is that is that so they just do it twice a year once in the fall and once in the spring so they're looking at trying to get it done now before it
[1:01:50] Speaker F (unidentified): snows no i mean like dollar amount so it was 22 000 and 26 but is it 23 000 this year yes so that's
[1:01:59] Speaker D (unidentified): So that really to take care of your fall grading, you're talking about eleven thousand five hundred dollar contract. Yes, I mean there is no reason to go sole source on the spring grading, is there, or is there? You're talking about breaking it up. Yeah, I'm talking about you. Well, you're, yeah, you.
[1:02:21] Speaker F (unidentified): Could extend six months instead of a year and fix it after the six months. I, you know.
[1:02:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Again, select board, if we're in the business of extending contracts that we haven't seen, then I guess that's our business. Yes.
[1:02:53] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm more okay with it because it's extending an existing agreement, and so I would be under the assumption that somebody has already approved this and okayed it, and I'm just extending that approval, and especially if it's for six months, we can clean.
[1:03:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Of the issues that you're raising restarted at the next. So I would say in the next six months we are looking at putting out for bid again our snow plowing contract, our roadside mowing contract, our would be grading contract. We'll have to put back out the pretty much every contract that we have because all of them were for three years previously, started in 2023 and ended in 2026. So we just extended the snow climbing contract for this year. But that'll be a big one that we also have to focus on. So as far as drafting RFPs and getting them done, we're also still looking at paving and road work in the spring. So based off of the recent eight roads that we just completed for the two parts of roads, there was also tree trimming that came with that. There was also ditching and culverts that came with that. There was also, now shoulder work that comes with that, all of those have to be drafted for RFPs and put out for contract. In addition to the contracts that we currently have for grants. So we have one with 30 Mile River that we're going to be looking at. We've also got school projects coming up. We've got the budget season starting. So I'm just pointing out that there are multiple things that do need to go out for RFP. But based on the restriction of time, I have met with the infrastructure committee and I did get updates for the grading contract back in September. It's just a matter of being able to get that implemented with the hiring of a new town clerk and doing the election. So I'm just saying as far as time, we are restricted on a lot of time. Things and I would say that the priority in the next couple of months will be the snowplow contract as well as any other paving contracts that we need to do considering all the RFPs that support that and.
[1:04:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Go into it. Well we have a motion on the seconding on this right. And yeah I think we're just in discussion now right. Yeah and Lauren's point though on it's it's just a simple extension of time to allow us to get this work completed without going through a process. There are no other changes to the contract other than extending the time frame for us to be able to get this work done given the workload that would prolong this and push it into nothing getting done in this calendar year. I think it. Might make sense. I agree with we should be reading a contract before we do anything to amend to extend. But if it's nothing more than a date extension I'd like to trust the past action as well. But it is more than the date extension it is a purchase it 's a It's a yearly requirement, like buying fuel for a year or buying something for a year. We buy it on a yearly basis, but it's a service, and it is the same service. But it's a new procurement. It's a new year. It's just like if we said, well, let's just extend the snowplow contract. Because it's extending the same contract, it's just extending it for another year. Here I mean we can avoid all these RFPs just extend everything. I do think that with respect to the roads that these ditching culverts all that stuff the road committee should have advised us to put that in the RFP that we went out with in the beginning. And we shouldn't have separate RFPs for all these things that are ancillary to paving a road. We ought to have it in one. I would suggest that should be in one requirement and yeah that it's multiple work to put to put it out the way we did but I. Think that the answer to that is re-look at our requirement and our purchase description and think about what should go into a road solicitation.
[1:07:10] Speaker A (unidentified): So I'm going to draw us back, because that's going a little bit off track on, you know, coulda, woulda, shoulda. I think what Shannon's pointing out is there's a lot of wood. What Lauren said is really this, if it's just, and I think Tom was agreeing, if it's just an extension to get us through what the critical work that needs to be done on what would be a lower priority RFP and not was it 11,000 is that what you said so not a particularly high value you know but it's
[1:07:49] Speaker D (unidentified): all years you're like you're doing it for the whole year right and then even still it's not
[1:07:52] Speaker A (unidentified): high value it's 23,000 a year yes so 11,000 for the remainder of the year for half for fall grading
[1:07:59] Speaker D (unidentified): It would be half of 23,000, approximately, instead of buying a fall and a spring grading. But anyway, I'm running out of breath, Chair. I think there's been a motion and a second call vote. All right.
[1:08:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you capture the motion? Could you reread it, please?
[1:08:21] Speaker B (unidentified): So consider approving a one-year extension on the grading contract. Contract motion was made by Select Board member Saunders and seconded by Mater and because it's to
[1:08:33] Speaker A (unidentified): ch Jameson I am going to abstain on this but I'm going to call for the vote as requested by Mr. Steck those in favor those against and those abstaining so it was a 3-1-1 motion cares you
[1:08:51] Speaker D (unidentified): know who did what in our minutes also I said no who did what in our minutes I'm sure you will yeah I think good conversation and in parallel we should be noting that Henry's points about cleaning the process up and moving forward bundling things together not having ancillary contracts that we wind up having to spend plans talking about individually makes perfect sense
[1:09:19] Speaker A (unidentified): but we can do both things in parallel it does make perfect sense and unfortunately what we're dealing with is a legacy of procurement, decisions and contracts and things that were done in the past, best time to plan later, trying to clean up as they surface.
[1:09:39] Speaker D (unidentified): In parallel, in parallel.
[1:09:41] Speaker A (unidentified): They believe they have a good intent, including cleaning up the purchasing policy, which is also quite evident. Where are we at I believe we're on to abatements let's skip something you skipped old skipped old business but let's just get the abatements out of the way all
[1:10:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Right, so the abatement 2526-03, I can't remember if I sent that to you. Our assessor came out last month, and so that was just basically, okay. That was filed by a local resident. They had done some legwork looking at their deeds and paperwork and the surveys that they had. They found that they have been paying an extra, I think, 25 feet of property. So submitted that information to our assessor. Our assessor determined that is correct. And so he put forth this abatement for the total amount of $191.25.
[1:10:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I'm gonna move to approve abatement 252603 in the amount of 191 dollars and 25 cents. Second. I've got it. Any discussion? Who's in favor?
[1:10:59] Speaker D (unidentified): I'll measure out myself now. I have to send.
[1:11:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to tape measure out here. That's all I'm going to. Punch you on the shoulder. I know this is the bad one. All right, I have been called out and we skipped the old business, so now we're going to go back to the old business and discuss the purchasing policy draft. So to set a little bit of context around this one, this is something with subcommittee of Henry and myself with review from Shannon as tab manager and road commissioner and Taylor as fire chief and a lot of help from what's your friend on AI's name who is your friend had an AI friend. I think this it's in the packet. I think probably we don't want to go through it line by line, but Henry, would you like to talk about the major cleanup activities
[1:12:02] Speaker D (unidentified): or process or well it's I mean it's a different purchasing policy. See, I let's just talk about the procedures that apply to purchases by amount, okay. Purchases under twenty five hundred dollars, those are small purchases. Competent competitive quotes are not required. We just have to make sure that the price is fair and reasonable. Everything there has to ensure that there's sufficient uncommitted funds, and the cash flow is appropriate. And if something is going to be paid from a reserve fund, these the required approval needs to be secured before the purchase is made, not after the purchase is made, and ask for approval when it's time to pay the bill that has come in. The town manager, who is the purchasing agent under the statutory town manager plan under this policy, can delegate purchasing authority to town employees. She can delegate authority to make purchases up to twenty five hundred dollars. They don't there's nothing About department heads, it's up to whoever the whoever the town manager decides. Besides, she can delegate authority in the amount that she deems appropriate, up to $2,500, and place whatever restrictions on that delegation that is deemed fit. Fit. As we go over that amount, purchases that are over $2,500 but do not exceed $25,000, they would go to an informal bid process unless there's an exception to competition, which I'll talk about in a minute. In that process, quotes are requested from at least three vendors. The quotes can be written or electronic or by phone. If they're oral, it provides that you have to record the information. If you can't get three coats three quotes the that's okay, put a brief explanation of that in the file, and the award is made to the responsible bidder providing the best value to the town. If you're making an award to other than the low bidder, there should be a written determination of best value that's included in the file. Okay, and for example, if this were passed, this grading contract that we're talking about probably would be less than twenty five thousand dollars. It wouldn't be if necessarily a formal IFB, it could be informal. The informal bid process purchases over fifty thousand dollars go to competition in a formal bid process where you have a formal advertisement or solicitation for bids or proposals. The bids are publicly opened and recorded. The contract's awarded on the basis of the responsive bid that provides the overall best value to the town based on whatever factors are put in the solicitation. If you're going to make an award other than a little bidder, the town manager must prepare a written explanation and the select board must approve the award.
[1:15:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. I'm just going to pause you on that one. I think I heard you say purchase is over 50 000 but that's purchases that's over 25 yes 5 000. I should have said
[1:15:33] Speaker D (unidentified): 25. If I said 50 I'm sorry. Now over 50 there are some additional requirements that over 50 is has the same things that I just said, but in addition to that it provides that the town manager should notify the select board of pending purchases over fifty thousand dollars. The notice can be written or given orally as part of the town manager's report in a select board meeting. It says the town managers should determine how they want to do this and just stick with whatever means they decide and that is Simply to a price that nobody's asking for any pearls that's simply to keep us informed about major purchases that are on the horizon. If the purchase is over a hundred thousand dollars the policy provides that the town manager should provide copies of the bid package to each select board member prior to issuing the bid package, and the purpose is to give board members an opportunity to review that and decide whether it should be discussed at a select board meeting. I'm not saying we all have to discuss everything. If an IFB is going out for an RFP and it's for a snowplow contract for $250,000 or more, an advanced copy of that should be sent to each of us each of us can decide whether we want to read it or not read it but it gives us an opportunity to read it and see if there's something in there that we think merits discussion and meeting contracts over a hundred thousand dollars require legal review before signature unless the select board weighs the requirement for legal review then there are reasons that it you would want to waive contracts over a hundred thousand dollars have to be approved by the select board prior to signing. Now exceptions to these competition requirements all of them the informal competition everything there's an exception for sole source if it's only one person that can provide it if after reasonable investigation it's determined that only one practical source is available or competition's not workable for some documented and reason then you can do a sole source if the amount exceeds 25 000 a request and justification should be submitted to the select board for approval. In all instances a written explanation be should be prepared explaining why the sole source application applies and that should be put in the in the contracting file. There's an emergency purchase exception and this applies to purchases over twenty five hundred dollars because under twenty five hundred dollars there's no competition requirement if competition is not possible because something unexpected or urgent requires prompt action like a boiler goes out in the winter something of that nature you don't have to get competition. The town manager should attempt to secure price competition to the extent that's practical considering the nature of the emergency before making an emergency purchase. The town manager should provide notice to select board members just notice if failure to reach one or more select board members before the action is taken doesn't prevent the emergency purchase from going forward if delay increases the risk to health safety property essential services of time town finance so you know town manager thinks that we need an emergency purchase of 75 000 for x that should go to all the select board members and if somebody says wait that's not an emergency we can call upon the chair to have a special meeting or an emergency select board meeting and discuss it if we think that's important enough but if you can't get a hold of anybody you go ahead and act the emergency has to be taken care of. Standard commercial items that's an example of a of a exception to competition and that's if something is commercially available and customarily sold to the general public in a posted catalog market or advertised price. An example is we've committed to purchase a bunch of chairs for the for the last you know it's over twenty five hundred dollars I'm suggesting we buy those off Amazon. Actually, I've ordered four for us to look at. That should be here before our next meeting. In that particular case, I don't think there's much of a point in sending Jeff Bezos a request for a bid. I don't think he's going to answer us. Those are purchases that can be made without requesting bids. Competition comes from the marketplace since they're sold at catalog or market prices. Then there's orders under existing state or interlocal contracts that you don't have to get competition for that. There's a section in here that doesn't, it's not an exception to competition, it's kind of a special method. And it basically says the town manager may do this, and it's on-call purchases for minor repairs. Repairs and the idea there is you make agreements with three bidders or so to conduct minor repairs on an on-call basis. If something comes up this tree needs to be taken out of the road this culvert needs to be unclogged they've provided you with labor rates and whatever their material markup is and it's a it applies to small jobs under twenty five hundred dollars and it's just to provide a an expedited mechanism you already can purchase under twenty five hundred dollars from whoever you please it's just it's just a suggestion for a procedure that might make things simpler on some of our recurring maintenance problems. And then there's a separate section on procuring professional services because those are usually not procured on the basis of price. I have in there, the policy is quite long. And I thought there might be some issue about, oh, well, you're getting too much select board involvement in this. So I've summarized what select board notifications or approvals are required. If the purchase is made from reserve fund, you got to approve the fund before the purchase is made. That's that's nothing to do with this policy, that's the law. If the if the contract is over 25 000 and it's going to someone other than the low bidder, you have to prepare a written explanation and we have to approve the award. The select board has to approve the award. If you're going to buy something, if you're planning on buying something over fifty thousand dollars as an informational item, you should inform the select board of the pending procurement action. If it's a request for bid over a hundred thousand dollars, provide copies to the select board members so they can look at it and see what they want to do. If the town manager wants to waive a requirement for legal review on a contract over a hundred grand, that causes select board approval. Select board approves contracts over a hundred thousand. Written justifications and approvals wheels are required for sole source purchases over $25,000. There's the notice of emergency that I talked about. If you've got a standard commercial item over $25,000, there should be an approval of the select board that, yes, we agree. That's a standard commercial item. Go buy it. If you want to waive insurance requirements that are in this package, that requires select board approval. Approval if there's a if we want to have the town indemnify a contractor in a contract, that requires a select board waiver and the that also requires a legal review. If we have grant funds, there's a provision in here for grant funds that says any grant fund contract over fifty thousand dollars needs a legal review. If you want to have that way, that requires select board approval. Legal reviews are required for contracts over a hundred thousand. Contracts requiring the town to indemnify contractor And contracts over fifty thousand that are funded by state, federal, or grant funds, there are provisions in there on insurance and bonding. That's about, that's kind of the, that's kind of the thumbnail sketch of the, of the policy. It's, it's, it's long, 18 pages, but, you know, procurement regulations for, entities that are not that small are long. And there's the matters that we discussed but didn't, didn't get put in there. I suggested that we may want to have a provision that says any bidder who is delinquent in the payment of taxes to the town is not eligible unless they make arrangements to pay their delinquent taxes i think that 's a common provision and it makes sense but it re had it there was some opposition to it so i just you know actually it's fine we put a place over in there for that yeah
[1:25:26] Speaker A (unidentified): And it's, and I'm fine without it, new section to be determined, to any and all bids may be rejected in whole or in part if the bidder has delinquent taxes or outstanding debts owed to the town. Away, and that language came from one of the, one of the other towns around or several other towns around here use similar language to that, so we lifted that for discussion and decision by the board. So there are a number of things in here that were not completely wrapped up. That was one. There was a little bit on conflict of interest and whether we needed to make the conflict of interest language either more clear or maybe depend more on the ethics policy. And then I'm trying to think if there was something else that was left over, the insurance, whether or not we should put cyber liability, which was silent in the original drafts, so there's a placeholder to determine that. Unfortunately, this copy does not have the comments alongside, so it's difficult to pick out where we left, where we left things open. And my friends would love this because I'm reading the policy backwards. I feel like there was one other minor place that was not fully resolved. Looking at Taylor, because, so the other part of the rationale on the conversations with the fire chief, the current purchasing policy says, excluding the fire department. And yet nobody could point to what rules govern the fire department. So we collaborated with Taylor, well, by chief perspective, to see whether there were any exceptions that wouldn't, wouldn't work for by type purchases. And then the other thing that's in here is a pretty extensive list of definitions, which, you know, I think helpful to understanding the whole. It takes up several pages, but that's helpful to the whole policy. So, I think my suggestion on this is, I don't know if the board had time to look and had specific questions. I was not expecting to make a vote to pass it. This is kind of the first read. So looking to see whether you had any immediate feedback or if you want to take some time and look at it and redline anything, Lauren.
[1:28:09] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I just I want to say thank you for putting this together because as part of the options task force, when we had to figure out like what consultant to hire, it was super complicated about how we were supposed to do that. And this would have been really helpful, at that time. 1 question I do have is that, there's a requirement for legal review for any contract over 50,000. I wanted to see how many contracts we have that are over 50,000, and if that would, like, increase our legal costs significantly, or if that's not a worry.
[1:28:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Most of them tend to. Pursuing to the public roads. Rose maintenance, in construction. even just the recent ones, we had trees, I would expect that to be higher than what it was stitching and culverts was about 123,000. Each of the payment contracts well, the 1, but each of the segments were about 250,000, plus the,.
[1:29:10] Speaker C (unidentified): what was the last part?
[1:29:15] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm trying to think what else we had to do. Yeah, the chain culverts, that. No following contracts. Any road, like, yeah, summer.
[1:29:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Warren, the requirement for legal review of contracts is $100,000 or more. $50,000 if it's a grant contract. Because you've got the terms on you got the issue on compliance with the grant terms but it's in 563 the legal reviews of contracts of 100 000 or more and that can be waived so the town manager may request a legal review of any proposed contract or procurement of a value of less b wage maybe the best legal abuse yeah i didn't i didn't say ask can be weighed that's that's i need to highlight that incomplete thought but for example the road commissioner and or the town just put out a contract for Roads and there's a contract that went with that road paving contract. If next, if next spring they put out and in assuming that contract has been reviewed by the by league and they said yes this is okay, next spring if we've got the same contract terms in there, I could see the town manager saying I don't think that this is worth the legal review, it's the same thing we just had. I want to wait and then the select board could decide to wait. Legal reviews cost money and sometimes there are questions involved about and so you would want to have
[1:30:58] Speaker F (unidentified): to pay too many of them. Yeah that was kind of just where my yeah concern was, but they're pretty
[1:31:05] Speaker A (unidentified): standard contracts then. I think Shannon any reflections or things you want to say on the practicality or the limits that are going to require coming in front of the board
[1:31:25] Speaker B (unidentified): nothing that we hadn't discussed already in the subcommittee draft. Well but Shan if you have
[1:31:32] Speaker D (unidentified): an input on it that you disagree or think something should be changed, let's have the whole board here if they manage. I think we want to take that into consideration
[1:31:41] Speaker B (unidentified): consideration. I hadn't made any notes on this since our discussions and what was changed
[1:31:47] Speaker D (unidentified): and what was discussed and everybody's email. Hazel should have these comments on it. I mean this is what I emailed so if you can pull it up on your computer you'll see the comments on the
[1:31:58] Speaker A (unidentified): file. Yeah anybody else from the board want to say anything? I'll take a brief opportunity for public comment on this. Can you just follow our rules that I haven't been enforcing and just tell us your name please.
[1:32:19] Speaker D (unidentified): If I recall, there's a contract that we may still be under. It was a Snowplow contract. And if I recall correctly, that contract called for the implementation of interpreting consumer pricing index for price increases. If I recall there was a misunderstanding of how to interpret the consumer price increase. So what I would ask is that if that CPI is used in any contracts there's a clear understanding of both parties as to how we'll interpret it because I believe across the town somewhere in the neighborhood of eighteen thousand dollars because that was not interpreted by the same way by both buyers
[1:33:02] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you. Is there any comment online? No comments. So next steps on this, we do have a meeting next week. Do you think we'll be ready to approve the purchasing policy, see we'll have any significant conversation on it by next week, or do you want to wait till the first meeting in December to wrap this up? I
[1:33:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Won't be here first week in December, not that matters. You guys can wrap it up with that thing. Is there a way to have a shared document so if I went through for example and just capitalization, I wanted to make sure that all capitalization was consistent, something I'm just
[1:33:51] Speaker A (unidentified): to make it as simple as possible. Can I do that? It is not, we do not have like a Google site where we're collaborating within one document. We've been, I'm just trying to get one person, yeah, one person, and we kind of transferred it back and forth in which is the working copy but
[1:34:11] Speaker D (unidentified): if you take the if you take the last one that you were sent and you make changes to it should come up in a red line format and those changes should note out on the side as your changes and there could be a box that you can make comments now everybody would have to everybody does if everybody does it simultaneously it's going to be yeah it's going to be confused iteratively
[1:34:33] Speaker F (unidentified): otherwise it'll be smart enough that you can make track changes with multiple people
[1:34:38] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, so as long as we're well, but if we're sharing documents, if we, if we take them offline and then we wind up sending a document, then things are going to get very nice. I'm happy for anybody that knows how to do it to take this thing, you all have the file, put in whatever form it needs to be put in so we can all work on it at the same time. I don't know, that's what I mean is the
[1:35:00] Speaker C (unidentified): problem, I don't want to do that. So we could all access it as long as we're working on it we have
[1:35:09] Speaker A (unidentified): have that capacity to do, we have any kind of Google Doc sharing between us now, we'll figure it out
[1:35:18] Speaker D (unidentified): We could say I own the pet today, you own the pen tomorrow, we can do something a little bit well we
[1:35:23] Speaker A (unidentified): can I know Word is smart enough, whether I'm smart enough to take all the versions and accept them all except all and get and combine them, I don't know if I can do that, but maybe I, AI or
[1:35:36] Speaker D (unidentified): chat and I have a, you can help me. I have a suggestion, if any of us puts comments on here and says these are that I want you all to consider and discuss at our next meeting, that's okay. If we start with a collaborative document on Google Maps or Google Documents and start changing it and responding to each other's comments, now we have a violation of the of the open meetings provision of Maine law where we're basically conducting business without letting people see what we're doing. It is, but it is true, yeah
[1:36:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, so from a time frame perspective, we really we only have a week until the next meeting. We're going to get the most changes out for review. We normally post the packet on Friday, so it puts the puts the bonus on the select board if you want to get changes out so we can have them available for next meeting. We'd kind of be looking to getting
[1:36:45] Speaker F (unidentified): it in the next few days. I'm okay to do that. I would rather get this done in summary is super
[1:36:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so we're going to put it on the agenda to try to finalize and approve the policy next meeting. Put your edits into redline in word. So they're all in word document not like emails that we then have to try and splice into the world document. So that brings us to the end of the whole business. And it's this to public comments.
[1:37:36] Speaker B (unidentified): We're being online. What's the panel? You have 2 people online, no hands raised. I hear nothing public
[1:37:44] Speaker E (unidentified): comments. I kind of you would ask me to bring back some names for a subcommittee from fire department to work with people on a fire holding the town. I don't know if that was for this meeting sometime in November so happy to I'm happy to bring that up at the next meeting the subcommittee from the fire department and schedule that's meeting where I can bring those names now and schedule next meeting whenever it's beneficial to you. I don't think the names make a difference scheduling.
[1:38:11] Speaker A (unidentified): So this was around the fire ordinance that's the name it's actually called the fire ordinance.
[1:38:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Ordinance I don't think that you we I don't think that we've come up with a name yet to replace the
[1:38:22] Speaker A (unidentified): existing one so you're coming up with a name for that and we'll need a subcommittee from the select board to look at that rather antiquated fire ordinance
[1:38:36] Speaker D (unidentified): I thought we had a working name we've already changed the fire department ordinance and there was a even a bit of a draft that had happened right I think that already we've made some progress there. I sent out a draft that would be an example and to show why what we have is problematic. And actually, I think what I sent out would be fine, but it wasn't a, hey, this is it. This is a possibility. This is a possibility. So as a starting point, we'll use
[1:39:12] Speaker A (unidentified): was that yeah but yeah thank you Taylor for offering up some names but you could
[1:39:18] Speaker D (unidentified): use a committee probably like we did with the purchasing policy yeah anybody got a burning
[1:39:24] Speaker A (unidentified): desire oh that was terrible anybody got a desire to be on that committee my work is complete all right i we can talk about it next time we can talk about it next time we'll talk about it
[1:39:45] Speaker D (unidentified): Next time. Anything else in public comments? Fire department. Yeah, two of us and people from the fire department, and they can have as many of them as they please. All
[1:39:58] Speaker A (unidentified): right, so Taylor get back to us. Anything else in public comments? Some more public comments and manager report.
[1:40:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Starting off from the road commissioner. So the last meeting you had was October 20th. That day in the 21st and 22nd I participated in the local road supervisory force. That was the second half of it. The other, the first half was in September. So this part portion went over primarily measurements, legal advice, risk assessments. We had a lot of great speakers that came in, talked about asphalt, talked about paving. We went out and did some measurements of slopes and calculating the distances for things, and it was very informative. Hike Industries completed their ditching culverts, reclaimed paving, and the driveway hot mix asphalt. I met with them on Friday to conduct kind of an after action review, invited members of the infrastructure committee. And so we talked through the process on what that looked like as far as putting out the RFPs. We talked about amendments and how the communication went. It was their teams overall were very responsive to the requests of the town and the infrastructure committee. And I'm very grateful for the infrastructure committee members that did come out and provided insight for that. Culberts on Maxim Road and Mount Pisgah Road were both cleared from beavers. There was some buildup down there under a Tempe Bridge and a culbert on Maxim Road. That was in your accounts payables for today that you just approved. The shoulder work on Fairbanks I'll be following up with our local contractor for that was scheduled this past week, so thank you for your quick response extension of the grading contract. So we just did that. I'll be working on an amendment for it this week. Switching any questions regarding road commissioner? Okay, so switching over for the town manager report. Last week we conducted the election, 795 ballots were cast for that. That also included the local referendum question secret ballot for the amendment to the code of the town of Wayne. And that passed with 494 votes. And I just want to take a moment just to thank all of the election clerks and the warden and our incredible staff that helped with the entire process of the election beginning back in September, all the way through absentee ballots October 6, all the way up to the election on November 3rd. So it's a very smooth streamlined process from everything I heard from residents. Also last week we just have a new town clerk Sarah Sessler she joined us October 27th, excuse me, the week prior. She came in just in time to partake in the election primarily overseeing that while I still remained as the town clerk in that position, but she did take notes for the next election. She will be conducting BMV training next week and then we'll be moving on to dog licensing. Speaking of dog licensing, that is now open for registration and the deadline for it is January 31st. After that time then residents will receive a $25 late fee, so make sure that you get in and register your dogs. The Comprehensive Plan Committee met last night so I was happy to join them for that. They are making excellent progress and looking to invite a member of the Kennebec Valley Council of Governments for their next chapter. And they're gonna be meeting again on December 16th. The office will be closed tomorrow for Veterans Day. And so that went out in a notice on our website and through the email. Your next meeting is scheduled for November 17th, as you've already recognized at the Ladd Rec Center. And so on that schedule right now, I am looking at a visit from Lady Robbins, executive director of 30 mile river for the grant contracts i did send that out to the select board for the review and i've received some input so i forwarded that to lai so we're going to discuss that we're meeting on friday morning to go over that also on your schedule is the emergency response task force discussion that was something that came up from the read field select board had sent out a resolution to all of the neighboring communities. So town manager Eric Dyer he is planning to attend with the fire chief and their select board chair to give some more information on that and they did confirm that there will be there. Also in preparation for that I'll be meeting with the Winter Ambulance Advisory Group on Thursday in Winthrop at 1pm and all the select board members were encouraged and invited to attend. Please let me know if you're interested. Stood so roads and shoulder work is also on your agenda for Next week, boards, Commission, committees, policy is on your agenda. The purchasing policy to finalize and approve is on your agenda, and you also have executive sessions scheduled for November 17th and for December 1st to go over the town managers performance review. With that, 's all I've got. Thank
[1:45:06] Speaker D (unidentified): you. Any
[1:45:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Any questions for Shannon? All right, board member reports?
[1:45:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Nothing from staff? Nothing. Henry, nothing from state?
[1:45:20] Speaker F (unidentified): I would just like to say that the Wayne Options Task Force will be having a community forum to discuss our research to date. It is from three to four at the Ladd Center, and did I say November 15th? It's on Sunday, but it should be there. We'd love to hear what the community has to say. Will you guys be reporting what you've found so far? We'll be. Yep. We're planning on having a handout that we can give so people can reference that.
[1:45:50] Speaker A (unidentified): And nothing from me.
[1:45:52] Speaker F (unidentified): 3 to 4, after the Patriots game, I think the Patriots are playing earlier. I made sure the Patriots weren't on at the same time.
[1:46:04] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, take a motion to adjourn.
[1:46:08] Speaker D (unidentified): Move to adjourn. All in favor? All right, thank you.