← Back to MaineScanner

Ogunquit Marginal Way Committee Revises Bylaws and Approves Minutes

2026-11-02 · 1h 32m · Source: Marginal Way Committee - November 2, 2026 (Town of Ogunquit (CivicClerk))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): we can do that. [0:02] Speaker B (unidentified): However, I can take notes. I think Joyce will be here, but if she can't, [0:09] Speaker A (unidentified): I can do it. Okay. Okay. That would be good. Thank you, Jane. All right. Good afternoon, everybody. November 2nd for the Marginal Way Committee meeting. We are some virtual and some in person, so it'll be an interesting meeting as we go back and forth going through all of our topics. The first thing I would like to do is have us approve the minutes from October the 5th. And I did not see any corrections needed making, but if anybody else noted something that we need to change if you can let us know i [1:00] Speaker C (unidentified): already sent my changes to joyce and she put those in so i think she did yeah if he has any other changes i'll make a motion to accept the minutes from october 15 2026. [1:15] Speaker D (unidentified): so i'll second it do [1:20] Speaker A (unidentified): you need to do a roll call vote i think we do all right yeah all right do you want to start with your table who's at the table [1:30] Speaker C (unidentified): louisa gillespie who has it you just have to say yes or no to the motions [1:36] Speaker A (unidentified): for the minutes for the minutes oh yes i thought we were doing vocal yeah jane green yes [1:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes. Elaine Cooper. Yes. [1:47] Speaker A (unidentified): And OK. And then I'm a yes. Gail and Gail. Yes. Yes. All right. Very good. All right. Thank you very much. I have very little to report since I've been pretty much completely sidelined with a back injury. so I did contact civil consultants which had given us this is to get some new estimates for a survey so that I can go to the town manager and give him a general idea of what this would cost us but they have not gotten back from a new minutes the ones from 2024 came in at almost $70,000. And that was for the whole length of the marginal way and all of the eight access paths. I think what I'd like to do is also have them add in the lot, the Winkler lot that is on the left side of or the north side of the Briar Bank access path since the town owns that and we're working that as if it was also part of the marginal way. So that would have to be an additional piece of land that goes into the survey as well so we're just waiting on that jackie and mike last week did some transplanting for us of some larger trees a pine tree that we put south of the geology sign we transplanted a small cedar we transplanted a beach plum. And so Jackie has been responsible for saying that they got water. And we are hoping that maybe by the end of this coming week, we're supposed to have a little bit of rain and that will take that chore away for her. I had asked the CEO to give me an update on when we spoke to him about doing work with the Sparhawk and the Anchorage, and I don't have anything new on that front. Elaine, could you elaborate? You spoke to him after the last select board meeting and got some information about what he's negotiating with the hotels. [4:06] Speaker C (unidentified): We spoke for a few minutes, and he has gotten approval from the Sparhawk. They will be repairing tearing the wall. It's on the right-hand side as you walk towards the ocean. They're going to be probably cementing that together so it won't be movable anymore. And they will be working with an arborist on the bushes on the other side on how much they can cut back so they don't kill it. And then they'll determine whether they are going to replace them or whether they'll continue to cut it back they also will take care of all of the invasives at the fence line that's on their property as opposed to where we've removed everything and the anchorage is agreed to keep the walking path side of the fence line clear of invasives so he was able to do that he will continue to work with them and i believe louisa will be also doing things to make sure or the speech mirror is taken care of. So that was what Tyler told me. We only had a brief conversation, but.
Unfinished Business
[5:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. And when I asked him for a further update, he hasn't heard back from them. So he doesn't think that anything has been done yet, either on the wall or the big hedge at the Sparhawk. He was going to walk in and give me a report, but I haven't heard back from him before this meeting. So I'm assuming it's still status quo, and we'll keep pushing just to be sure that everybody moves on widening these paths until we get to some bigger, let's say, engineering problems. And that's really pretty much all that I have before we go into some old business. [5:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Before we do that, I just wanted to recognize that Joyce is now online. like. [6:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Joyce, good to have you here. Jane started to take some notes. We just approved your minutes from the last meeting. Okay, great. They were very good. Thank you for that. Very complete. [6:17] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll send you what I got, Joyce. I'll send it to you. But you can pick it up from here, Joyce. [6:23] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, I can. And Elaine, are we going to get the AI notes? Yes. Okay. [6:32] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Very good. So when I asked Tyler also to get his input on what we should do with the hazard report, the big one that was put together by Gail and Jackie, he really recommended that we speak with our liaison. But I guess I'm assuming that Heath is not present at our meeting today. No. All right. And so he felt that it had to go through our liaison to the select board rather than through him at this point. So when I'm maybe a little more able to manage a couple of meetings, we'll begin to push this again. So I'm going to move on to the monitor. I think, Elaine, you did a sort of a seasonal report that you gave to your monitors. And would you like to just sum up what the work was today? [7:35] Speaker C (unidentified): I sent out a thank you note to all of the monitors about two weeks ago. And I let them know what the annual was. It has to be adjusted a little because people are still going, even though they're not assigned. And they keep asking, can I do another walk? And I say, go right ahead. It's great. Great. And what I found out in sending out in the last month's reports and in responding to people, almost every one of our new monitors has sent to me, I'll be back next year, no problem. Oh, wonderful. October, we did 29 and three quarter hours, picked up 23 gallons in 18 walks. And for the year, which, as I said, may have to be adjusted a little, we did 119 no 219 and a half hours 153 gallons of trash in 147 walks and that's down about 100 gallons of trash from last year so that's so hard and my assistant on the marginal way of repairs amy was out again last week and did a bunch of different things and we're just waiting to hear whether the public works department will be replacing the bolt that's missing on the bench the front slat of the bench on bench 18 because it's it's cracked underneath and we don't want to put in a bolt that will end up cracking it more because then they'll have to replace the whole bench replace the whole thing so but very successful year people are very happy to participate very happy to do extra walks and again we'll be back next year elaine was that [9:24] Speaker E (unidentified): a meeting that you had or you said you sent out a thank you note you sent out a thank you note [9:30] Speaker C (unidentified): but i also every time i get a report every single whether it's three four five six reports a week i always answer back to every monitor so we have an ongoing conversation throughout the [9:43] Speaker A (unidentified): the season okay marvelous it has turned out to be an extraordinary program really it i mean it does so much and it's been so beneficial not just to keep the walk tidy but i think it just really gives a lot of visitors somebody to talk to and you know contact and ask questions and learn more and so it's been so useful really yeah and i think more and more people are asking [10:16] Speaker C (unidentified): questions and getting responses and it's been a nice interaction between visitors and monitors who are getting their understanding the marginal way more and more knowing more of the history [10:31] Speaker F (unidentified): because people are asking them so many different questions do you think we could extend the season a little bit further into fall if maybe not do it as often but because you would [10:44] Speaker C (unidentified): have less people each of the last two years we've gone further and further and don't forget just a couple of years ago we had a storm by now so there was about well that's yeah the weather would [10:55] Speaker F (unidentified): dictate you know that would end them all but up until then and as i said people are saying [11:01] Speaker C (unidentified): whenever they go out once you become a monitor you never walk the marginal way the same again And this time, because the foliage is off fairly early, a lot of trash got ticked out of the bushes that you couldn't see before. [11:20] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to ask you to put together from the year that you first started measuring or weighing the gallons that we took. Look, give me the numbers for, you know, there's at least four years, I think, at least, right, that you've been collecting the gallons. And I want to put that into a graph, you know, so that we kind of see just how significant the drop has been from the beginning that we can use. I am, Jane, putting together a newsletter. letter i think we're going on to the quarterly instead of the month which is just fine it's fine but i thought that it would be interesting to see a little dramatic graph that just shows the drop and the change in the amount of trash that we are actually collecting so yeah that's great [12:18] Speaker E (unidentified): you'll send me those accurate numbers that you just reeled off yes okay no problem i can't [12:25] Speaker C (unidentified): tell you two years ago we had like 539 513 to 539 I don't know the exact number last year we had 249 and this year we got 153 so the last three years has been a significant drop exactly [12:44] Speaker A (unidentified): well maybe there's going to be a year when they don't pick up anything who knows but i doubt it but still it's kind of extraordinary it's it's great i'm susan was coming in late and so i'm going to switch and put her a little bit later because she also sent out a thank you to her weed warriors and is asking them for a that she's going to do a survey with them to see if they have any ideas about how to improve the groupings. And I will say that if we actually get started on the big planting project down near Bench 28 and where the middle of Fazer Pastor access, we are going to need quite a few more weed warriors because that's going to become a huge area that now needs to be monitored and taken care of as well. So hopefully, maybe we can persuade some of these excess monitors to switch over and be weed warriors at least for a year or two. And they can get some training before they go back to walking again, because I think we'll need that. But I'll let Susan do her summary. Louisa, do you have any updates or any events coming up for Preservation Fund? [14:06] Speaker G (unidentified): yes on november 11th that they're going to do another veterans day ceremony down at seminary point last year was the first year and it was so successful they decided to do it again and it's there's usually a musician and some prayers and people are invited to come and give a little brief about their loved ones that died in the war or a war. Wow. Very nice. They're also having a meeting next week, and so I'll have more information in the December meeting on what occurred there. [14:57] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. Do you have a time, Louisa? Time? On the 11th? Oh, [15:07] Speaker G (unidentified): it's not a regular meeting. It's a special meeting. So, no, I mean, it's Serenity Point. Oh,, oh. [15:16] Speaker A (unidentified): For the veterans, the Veterans Day. [15:19] Speaker G (unidentified): I think it's 10 or 11. Let me check. Sorry. [15:29] Speaker A (unidentified): They'll probably, will they, will Allison send out a, like a notice, a general announcement about it? [15:39] Speaker G (unidentified): oh yes yeah okay with the time yeah but i don't have to say anything you know i don't know if it's 10 or 11 but i'll find out at the special meeting and [15:52] Speaker A (unidentified): pass the word along all right okay very good okay so next what i'd like to spend some time on is the bylaws. We may not get it all finished today, but I'd like to start. And I hope people, I had some, made some copies and now I'm not there. So that's not too helpful, but I hope some of you have got your copies. And Joyce, I printed off, I believe you had sent your amendment version, which I now have to find. I think that's what I have here. So I'd like to, I think, just go through this section by section and then we can kind of discuss some of the changes. And if we can start with under membership, we never really, I think, had a final discussion about whether we do want to enlarge to nine from seven. If we go to nine, do we want to also keep two alternates as part of the committee? Or does anyone have any other suggestions for the membership? [17:17] Speaker E (unidentified): I would make a motion that we go to nine and keep the two alternates. I mean, how are we doing this? Are we voting on each bit? [17:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think we can. Why don't we discuss and go through section by section? I don't know that we have to vote on each section. Let's just discuss. And if everybody, let's say, is in agreement that they like the nine plus two alternates, we can then just move on to the next. And then at the end, we can hopefully that we've come to agreement on each of these clauses or paragraphs, then we can vote whether we want to approve these new amendments. Then it has to go, if we approve it, then it has to be submitted by our liaison to go to the select board for their approval. It never was last year when, so in 2025, when we did alter the second clause that was talking about who is a resident of the town, that it wasn't strictly a voting resident. We had approved that section, which I still have in red, but it never was taken. Our liaison never forwarded it on to the select board, so it never got officially approved at that time. So that's still pending, and we've added more changes since then that we're working on. Does everybody else in agreement with Joyce's idea of going to nine with two alternates? Any other ideas that someone wants to suggest? [19:09] Speaker G (unidentified): I think it's a good idea. [19:12] Speaker B (unidentified): I also, I don't remember the discussion. I remember when Heath was here, him asking why nine. It seems good to me, too. I don't remember what the discussion was about why nine. remember when he said that yes of 12 or yeah and i don't know it seems good to me too i just thought i would bring that up because i can't remember what the discussion was about [19:37] Speaker C (unidentified): we had talked about it because our alternates are so active yeah that they should become voting members okay and we always would like to have alternates if we can yeah we're learning the system and getting used to being a part of it perfect and as people may leave the committee you have people that are prepared or if we don't have a quorum whatever they get moved up to vote so perfect i remember now thank you yeah i'm all for it okay john [20:09] Speaker G (unidentified): yes i did some i think it's because we have we do so much more work now than we did, two or three years ago that, there's plenty of work to pass around and, it would be good to have more members. [20:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. I agree. all right. So I will then cross out. So we're going with nine members, nine full members and two alternates. That is everybody is in agreement on that? Okay. All right. So that will be sort of finalized. I don't think there was too much else in the next clause where I, what I did add into this as stated in the town charter and giving both the article and the section of that, because we were quoting from the town charter, the type of person that could be on the committee and it did not have to be a registered voter it could be any resident and it could also be people from adjoining towns and that they're the only restriction is that it does have to be a again just a residential property owner they have to be the majority of this committee and one of them has to be the chair And so that's the only restriction to who can actually be a member on the committee. Does anybody see any other, I don't know, question or problem with that next paragraph? [21:54] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't think so, because it's directly from the charter. It's right from the charter. [21:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. And I put the quotes on it this time. I thought at least that lets everybody know that we're not making this up, that it is coming from something that's already been approved by everybody. Okay. Then what some of these ideas about experience for volunteers came from Susan, who had sent me an email after our last meeting when we began to talk about all this. And she listed the way she thought that some people that we should look to getting experience on the committee as a participant, as a volunteer. And so that is why the next two paragraphs, I decided to spell it out in more detail. And we have always said that we wanted people to, if they're going to be a candidate for full membership, We want them to be coming to meetings so that they're familiar with what they do, because a lot of times people have said that it seems overwhelming. There's financial issues, there's ecological issues, there are political issues. And so we're juggling a lot of different things within this committee. And that's why it's good that they have several sessions where they just listen and see the type of projects that we're working on and the scope of the work that we're doing. Are there any changes that say in the paragraph that starts with nominees must have previous experience? Joyce, go ahead. [23:44] Speaker E (unidentified): head. So I just wordsmithed it. Okay. And I thought that it wasn't a good idea to list the specific things like weed warrior or because we may change those categories. So I wordsmithed it to nominees must have previous experience volunteering for the marginal way committee or participation on a marginal way subcommittee. Nominees must have attended at least five or more marginal way committee meetings within the 12-month period prior to their nomination. [24:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Did everybody else see? Joyce, had you sent your edits to the whole committee? Okay. All right. So if you have seen it, if you either printed it off or if you have it on your computer, how does everybody feel about these edits it's just simplifying it and in a sense including you're just including everything that we're doing without having to specify or [24:50] Speaker E (unidentified): list them in the whole in the thought that maybe there'll be some other things you know like you also have this what did you call those the special forces yeah so emergency group or whatnot but right you know you may we may have other things that will qualify so just to leave it just to a whole umbrella that volunteer experience volunteering i agree i like the simple [25:17] Speaker B (unidentified): the simplicity of it joyce i really i liked her edits a lot on that paragraph [25:25] Speaker G (unidentified): okay i think we should i think we should be careful on requiring five minutes five meetings because then we're going to have to review, so say somebody only comes through four meetings. Now I remember when we first began we were desperate for members and we would look at anybody that would like to come and help us out and it wasn't as specific as all this so I think putting these things down but not making them accountable to meetings might soften it a bit for somebody that was interested in coming on our committee so change instead of [26:05] Speaker C (unidentified): five change it to two or three i mean or even just several on the application that people submit it [26:14] Speaker H (unidentified): says a minimum of two yeah this is susan i susan's actually here just not on video ah okay i think i think we should have at least some minimum expectation of attending meetings. The meetings are so uncrowded that the likelihood is we would recognize a new person coming in. For instance, I think Arlene is there. So I know that she's attended. We could check the minutes, but at least two. And I'm okay with five over the course of a year. But five is almost half a year. So maybe we settle on at least three meetings, something like that, or some effort to be a volunteer so that they actually know something about what's happening with the Marginal Way Committee. [26:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Or I heard somebody say, just using the word several instead of a number. [27:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, that would be okay. [27:09] Speaker A (unidentified): amenable as my co-chair who's big on bylaws and wording does the code the vice chair [27:19] Speaker C (unidentified): have an opinion as i said the application that people fill out says a minimum of two meetings but i know that a ton of people that have put on committees have not attended any meetings whatsoever but i think we would like people to have at least come to some of them [27:38] Speaker H (unidentified): so the definition of the definition of several is more than two okay i'm just looking it up on so i'm okay with the word several that's good [27:51] Speaker F (unidentified): if you make it five you're gonna have to wait five yes right several is good all right you might scare people off several sounds you know you might scare [28:06] Speaker B (unidentified): How about two or more? I mean, I don't know. Yeah, I think it should be two or more or at least two. All right, whatever. [28:13] Speaker A (unidentified): ever. Well, then I would say, okay, I think it needs to be three. Two is not enough. Two doesn't give even an idea because I know that a couple of years ago when I invited what I thought was a very promising person to come on the committee, I think she came to three meetings and she said it was just too much. It was too complicated, and she ran from it. I mean, she works, she's, you know, one of our volunteers, but I think it needs, I'd say, three meetings as a minimum. [28:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, and there's, I think we can also take, I can't read it because of my eyes, but we can always see the people that are on our Zoom meetings up on the screen. So people can attend that way also. Yes. Oh, absolutely. Right. So it's not as difficult to attend a meeting. You don't have to be here in person. [29:19] Speaker G (unidentified): There's too much competition in town for all these committees. [29:22] Speaker E (unidentified): We never put that in the minutes. We never put in the minutes people who are not committee members who are attending the meeting. [29:32] Speaker F (unidentified): No. I don't have a record of that. [29:35] Speaker C (unidentified): For a while, I was writing them down. But as I said, I can't read them. [29:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think it doesn't have to be in the minutes. I think maybe we can try to internally keep a list just so that someone, because we do know that there's several people that do listen in repeatedly. and so maybe we just keep a record of those people who we notice. I mean, we can't tell if someone is watching, streaming it on their television or even on their computer, if they haven't registered, the only names that we see are the people that have actually registered for the meeting. And so there could be many other people that could watch it, but we would have no idea of who they are. [30:22] Speaker B (unidentified): maybe it needs to be the honor system i mean yeah you know let's not worry too much if it's you know three at least three and hopefully when you interview them they can sort of tell you they'll you know get a feeling for what they know but i feel weird about you know were they on the meeting or not on the i mean i think we just need to honor them honor system i don't know Now, that's my feeling. [30:51] Speaker A (unidentified): That's fine. That's fine. I don't think we're really going to say, aha, we don't think you've been, you know, we haven't seen your name up there on the screen. So we're pretty sure, you know, you don't know what, I mean, by asking them questions, we'll find out, you know, how familiar they are or where they would like to, where they think they can fit in and contribute. And that's what we're looking for. We're just looking for people that will have the skills that we need to keep on doing the work that we're doing. That's all. Or added skills that we don't have now. That's all. And I think. All right. So I think the consensus is we like the entire rewrite that Joyce did in the section three. We'll call it, starts with nominees. [31:42] Speaker E (unidentified): Except we change it to three. [31:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Three, yes. We change it to three. All right. The next paragraph, preference given two. [31:56] Speaker B (unidentified): I like it. You know, I've been talking the whole time. I like it. I think it's, you know, it's important that people that have some experience with that will be drawn to the Marginal Way Committee. And I just think, you know, it's important to let people know what we're focusing on. [32:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. And I think we want to say what we need or hope, you know, that we can add to it. And if we get, I mean, heavens, if we actually got an engineer on board, I think it would be tremendously helpful. Or even if we come on as just a consultant, I think we're looking for these kinds of people. And at least it lets people know the range of interest. [32:39] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah that we're covering i think it's also not it's just saying preference so that does not exclude somebody who may not have these particular skills but is just really interested in learning about the marginal way and being a being on the committee as an alternate to start [32:55] Speaker H (unidentified): yeah that's important yes elaine is that on the application so people who might apply to be on the committee see this so they know we're looking for is it just stay in the bylaws [33:08] Speaker C (unidentified): it's it's because the interviews are done by the select board you're going to hope that your liaison will bring forward some of these points okay we're hoping that the liaison will also know that we hope you're not just putting somebody on without discussing it with the committee because we have a list of people who are interested that we know about so right you don't want them to just say oh there's a person interested in my committee okay let's put them on okay so good so it will be up to our talking to our liaison and making sure they know this and the full select board is going to be have to vote on this in the first place so okay great thanks elaine yeah because it's a [33:55] Speaker A (unidentified): town form that goes out to anybody for any committee type of thing so it's very generic [34:01] Speaker C (unidentified): nothing specific they can do just a committee they're interested in or they can put their preferences so they could list one two three four five committees if they're so inclined [34:16] Speaker E (unidentified): but typically before that happens joan people have interacted with you and have come to some meetings and you've had some discussion before they get to the point of at least that's how it worked for me before I got to the point of filling out an application and had an interview. So wouldn't you beforehand? [34:39] Speaker A (unidentified): We would probably, I mean, yes. I mean, what we have done, I think with everybody who's here, nearly all of you kind of got invited or asked if you'd be interested in coming on the committee. I mean, Louisa predates me and i think now louisa and i are have been on it longer and everybody else has come on right afterwards but it all started by knowing people and then asking them because they had a skill or you know they showed an interest and then we pretty much invited them on and let them get used to the idea, come to some meetings. And then if they were still interested and felt that, you know, they would like to contribute, then we ask them to apply. It doesn't always happen that way on all the other committees, but I think ours is sort of unique enough and that we're looking for people that can do special things and what we need done. And that's why we kind of almost invite people to apply to come to join the committee. [36:01] Speaker G (unidentified): So we had an engineer at one time because Paul Brinton was a civil engineer. [36:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. Exactly. So, I mean, everybody, you know, had some niche interest or a talent or something in which they contributed. And so it works well that way. All right. So our next clause is the last clause in this one section. And this is the to avoid the conflict of interest clause. And I see that has, I'm going to need to put a light on soon. It's so dark in here. And that Joyce, you would prefer leaving that out. [36:52] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I'm in the dark here. Yes. I don't know if other people have any comments about that, but I thought it was redundant because I thought we did a very good job in the bylaws of explaining a conflict of interest later on, and that there was no need to single out one committee because there could be potential conflicts of interest with many different kinds of multiple memberships with different committees, whether it was the Marginal Weight Preservation Committee or another town committee. But I thought it was all covered in conflicts of interests already, and we didn't need this additional one. [37:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Any other opinions [37:37] Speaker B (unidentified): from people present? I agree with Joyce. Yeah, I agree with Joyce. It popped out at me like,, I don't understand why we're putting it in here. And maybe somebody can explain better why it's a conflict of interest with the Martial Way Preservation Fund. I just, I feel like it was weird to me. And I, it made me just, I felt like it shouldn't be in there. That's how I felt. But maybe somebody who believes it should be out of there or in there can explain to me. I just, I don't know. it seems like, I know there are, we've had discussions back and forth. I know there's underlying issues with the two groups, but I feel like the interest is the same. It's like parents that have a baby, you know, the baby is the marginal way. And I, kind of feel like, you know, parents are arguing about how to take care of them. I mean, I don't know, that's a silly comparison but i just feel like it to me it and again i'm just going out on a linear it felt like it was feeding into the conflict rather than rather than trying to solve it or heal it that's just me being right out there and i'll just [38:56] Speaker G (unidentified): in [39:00] Speaker C (unidentified): terms of it is it is covered in the conflict of interest however if you read the conflict of interest section it has the member has an ownership interest or position of control or directly represents so if we have a committee member who's directly representing one committee how can they directly represent the other committee if there's a conflict so, and I am not pointing fingers at anybody or saying, because we know it means it does both of us. Right. The issue becomes, if we're in disagreement between Marginal Way Committee and Marginal Way Preservation, how do we find a balance between that if we don't lay out that person? And I'm not saying if this committee decided to make this change, I would recommend that we not make that right now. and take that away from the from Louisa who's doing both of those because she's been in that position but down the line I believe that a person should have served on two committees that could have a different interest related to the module way and both committees as you say it's a baby you want the best for it Certainly you're working toward it, but will the vote be, will it be a vote that, let's say we have nine people on our committee and we're four to four, we have the fifth vote. The person that's on the other committee will automatically, depending upon which committee is their favorite, can have a big effect on the outcome of that vote. That's all I'm looking at. they don't want to see a conflict with them but we did we did have a big conflict we had a difference of opinion over things so in my mind you can lay it out or that means that if you have a person of both committees anytime any issue comes up related they can't vote they will lose the above well [41:27] Speaker E (unidentified): well what it says though what it says is that if there if an issue does come up it's discussed and then if it is deemed that person shouldn't be voting they would recuse themselves from that because i could imagine i mean when we were talking about the comprehensive plan we said okay well there are some things in there that they put on other committees and we thought no that's really marginal way committee so that there are a couple of town committees where we both are concerned i can't remember which one it was sustainability or whatever so i think there's i don't see a reason to single out the preservation fund as a conflict of interest i don't i can't even imagine in a scenario in which that would be a conflict of interest that was not handled by our general guidelines around conflict of any of us conflict of interest because many of us serve on other committees other town committees right [42:30] Speaker G (unidentified): i was on the comprehensive planning committee while i was serving on the town committee and i didn't experience conflict of interest when we discussed the marginal water goals I think that the argument turns on the word liaison and the purpose of having a liaison is to collaborate and I think that in the long run holds a positive argument for not restricting the person to one or the other committee. Our liaison from the town simply is a select man and serves on the marginal way. [43:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, the only thing I guess that I would say, and the reason that obviously I included it, is because it seems that the two, not that I think this is going to cause more of a conflict, But I think the two groups are busy doing, have two different lines of action, which basically ours is kind of a maintenance and theirs is fundraising. And I think they are distinctive and can easily be kept distinctive, even though we're working toward the same goal. but we have had some conflicts in the past of about the expansion plan and things like that at serenity point and it just seems that it's not sort of a necessary thing to even be discussing we're we've we are so busy with the scope of work that we're taking care of that and when we need We work with the preservation fund having a liaison, but it doesn't mean that the liaison can't just be a member of the Marginal Way Committee. They don't also have to be a board member of the preservation fund. So I understood that the other part of the conflict area, when we get to conflict of interest, covers it, but it doesn't really clean it up. up and that's i just thought that this was a way to separate the two that we just we're we've got all our things that we're handling and they do theirs and we send a liaison when we're working with them on particular projects just the way elaine is working with allison on a separate project has really nothing to do with the marginal weight work that we're doing right now we can hold this i suppose in abeyance and see how we continue to manage with the two committees if we can smooth out some of the issues that we've been working through and i get a feeling that the majority of the committee is would prefer to take this paragraph out. But then realize, then I want to be sure that we're strong enough in the conflict of interest to prevent any sort of undue influence into what we need to do coming from another group that is saying that we should be doing this versus that. So I think that's the reason I was just trying to [46:26] Speaker H (unidentified): divide up the two committees this is susan i get why you're putting this in and i feel like a lot of there's a lot of trust issues between our committee and especially after the many of them showed up at our meeting and took over our meeting in august which was not okay with me and certainly strengthening up when you come as a guest you get to be asked to talk not just take over a meeting but I think I'm okay with deleting that I think it makes it doesn't give us any grace it looks like we're still pursuing a con this conflict with them and really they're just doing their own thing and I don't want to be so explicit but I am very aware that they have meetings board meetings where things come up about our committee or other issues and we don't get to see their meetings or watch their meetings we have no idea the only person who knows is Luisa and then I just feel like if there's a conflict and Luisa would know that just divulge it tell us what it is and abstain from the vote rather than And because I think that also creates a level of trust within us about what we're discussing. I'm looking at the conflict of interest section. I'm not sure how much more clear it can be that if our committee is trying to do something that the preservation fund doesn't want us to do or they had a vote in that they need to abstain from voting on our committee issues. but i don't i think i'm with jane and her comments at this point it just feels unnecessary to put it there it's more provocative than it needs to be but we all need to pay attention to our conflict of interest because we serve on a number of committees in the town and we're aware of different town issues and louisa happens to also serve on the margin preservation fund and we're aware of that all [48:48] Speaker A (unidentified): right so i gather the consensus from everybody is we will delete that paragraph i believe that's correct i think so all right okay very good let's go on to well b is i think what is in nearly all the different committee bylaws that people can be removed by the select board ahead of us. We go now into Section 3, which is officers and duties. [49:24] Speaker C (unidentified): Did we decide we were going to vote on each section when we finished it? [49:29] Speaker A (unidentified): No. Well, I mean, you can, but I get the sense from what everybody has said, from joyce susan louisa jane that 's the majority to take out that section no i we're [49:44] Speaker C (unidentified): now finished with that particular section so do you want to i mean you want to vote on just that [49:51] Speaker A (unidentified): section two membership yeah i thought we would read that when we got to the end [49:56] Speaker C (unidentified): of each section we would vote in. [49:59] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. So let me just summarize to go back again. We're going to nine members and two alternates. We are in the next bullet points. There was no change in, as stated in the town charter. We are using Joyce's edits in the nominees must have previous experience. experience we've made no changes into the preference bullet point and we are deleting avoiding the conflict bullet point number five there and we go and we have no change in b as to member being removed by select board all right delete and we wait a minute and we deleted [50:46] Speaker H (unidentified): C, one non-voting liaison. [50:50] Speaker A (unidentified): That's deleted. Yes. I mean, I don't think we need to say. Yeah, I don't either. We get a liaison or sometimes we have them, we don't, whatever. So [51:00] Speaker H (unidentified): that seemed unnecessary. Okay. And we, the only other change in terms of previous experience was at least three or more instead of five. Correct. Yes. So I'll second that motion, Joan. [51:12] Speaker A (unidentified): all right okay so can we for this again we have to have a vote why don't we start with the people in the room louisa do you want to go ahead yes if you yes jane yes elaine yes okay joyce gail yes and i'm a yes and i'm a yes [51:41] Speaker H (unidentified): Yes. And Susan's a yes, so it's unanimous. [51:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. Okay. Very good. Okay. All right. Now, officers and duties. There was no change at all into the first paragraph, A. In B, I added the section that a chair, because in every committee, it's basically the chair is the one who goes and has direct contact, either with a town official, a department head, or something like that, and so unless giving somebody else permission to go ahead and make that contact or act as a representative for the committee, and we hadn't put anything like that into our original bylaws. Are there any questions or changes that you want to have that section that's in red. The chair is the only [52:39] Speaker E (unidentified): member. Joyce? Okay. Yeah. Again, I wordsmithed, but with an intent. Oh, wait a minute. Okay. Sorry. Let's see. So I was suggesting, I thought it was overly broad as if we members could not even discuss anything with anybody else ever. So I was suggesting wording that said once the Marginal Way Committee has approved an action, the chair is the only member authorized to propose such actions to town officials unless such authority to represent the Marginal Way Committee is delegated by the chair. There was something about the language of the only member to propose or discuss to outside groups, representatives, you know, it felt unnecessarily constrictive. It didn't seem like that's what the intention really was. Yeah. Right. No, I like this, [53:44] Speaker A (unidentified): especially unless your authority to represent has delegated to someone else, correct? All right, did everybody understand or do you have a copy? If you want me or Joyce to read it again, what her edit is. [54:03] Speaker C (unidentified): No, I think that was a good suggestion. [54:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I like it too. I think it's a good suggestion. [54:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, you're very good at wordsmithing, Joyce. thank you all right okay so we accept that we take that part in there all right the vice chair [Speaker F (unidentified): ] all right and i think we just added that one section assuming all other duties the secretary stayed the same the treasurer i did have to add in this case the only reason that joyce i see you put a blue mark in the marginal way i didn't want there to be a mix-up with the town treasurer and the marginal way committee treasurer but if you think that 's being redundant you had oh i see i didn't under treasurer about [55:11] Speaker E (unidentified): i get that i mean i'm fine with that it's just that was the only that was the only time otherwise it just kept saying the treasurer the treasurer so that's why i took it out but if you think in that instance when you're talking about finances that there might be confusion i'm fine with having it there all right i was just trying to be consistent i know with the rest of the sentences we should take out the word currently because these are bylaws so you know it keeps saying the treasurer this the treasurer this and so just starting that sentence with the treasurer rather than currently the treasurer okay [55:50] Speaker A (unidentified): right because all this though can change if the next treasurer does not wish to handle all the extra jobs that Gail is now doing. Right. We might even, you know, delegate to break some of these jobs down into smaller responsibilities at some point, but that's fine. Okay. But do you [56:15] Speaker E (unidentified): think that it is important in the bylaws? I mean, Gail is doing that, but is it important in the bylaws to assign those tasks to the treasurer role or can it be left open like another committee member could do that in the future or? [56:36] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, it's it all I like the idea that it's all bundled with numbers. And if that person is willing to do that, I think it's simplifies it because she's having to run a system just to get the people counter and things like that. So I guess as long as the, what are you, the numbers recorder thinks that it, just seems to make sense to bundle all three jobs together for now. And we can change it at some later date. [57:16] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that's why the word currently should remain in there, because we can change it to somebody else later. But at least it's outlining what the treasurer is doing now. [57:30] Speaker F (unidentified): currently with room to change yes i [57:34] Speaker H (unidentified): think can we just note that the treasurer the treasurer is respond oversees these following things and can allocate them to other marginal weight committee members and then we don't need to change it so at some point if we get a new treasurer but we have nine members and somebody else is going to deal with the people counter and somebody else is going to do some of her functions that the treasurer just oversees the allocation of that work right now gail is taking it all on but this would allow us not to have to change the bylaws again it's just within that 's a scope this is under her purview but not right but not necessarily responsible for so that if the treasurer the treasurer oversees making sure that things are tracked, that money's depart, you know, but she may, he or she can delegate those jobs to other members of the committee if it's necessary, something like that. [58:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Without our having to change it. As long as she's overseeing, she could make that change and we don't have to change this. [58:47] Speaker H (unidentified): That's what I'm suggesting, is that this is the scope of oversight doesn't mean that they necessarily have to do that work. And maybe Joyce could figure out if she agrees, how to wordsmith that in there. [59:01] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I do. I do have help in the winter from Jackie. Right. On the people counter. Yeah. [59:08] Speaker H (unidentified): Right. But if we're going to add two more members, it might be possible to delegate some more, like you don't have to do that at all. You just make sure it gets done. [59:17] Speaker A (unidentified): somebody else goes and checks yeah i don't know yeah no i like that 's i think that's a good suggestion to have her the overseer puts the responsibility within the treasurer the numbers all that business because she is doing financially certainly with the volunteers she is calculating and telling us a dollar value that goes to the town so that should be under the treasurer as versus it could be anybody else doing it. [59:48] Speaker H (unidentified): But we could end up with an Excel spreadsheet officiato who the treasurer just delegates that work to, make sure it gets done, but doesn't have to do it his or herself. Okay. [1:00:01] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. That's a very good suggestion. [1:00:03] Speaker C (unidentified): I just have one question on that. I like the suggestion, but does the treasurer have the ability to delegate or does it have to be under the vote of the co-committee with approval of the whole committee that you can delegate that yeah with the approval [1:00:19] Speaker H (unidentified): of the committee treasurer can delegate certain tasks to other marginal way committee members is [1:00:31] Speaker E (unidentified): that true of other is that only for the treasurer or are we saying that could be [1:00:41] Speaker A (unidentified): i think that's only for the treasurer because if the vice chair takes over she assumes all the responsibilities of the chair, and therefore she can delegate, she can create a subcommittee, and she would have any of the powers that the chair has. So I think we are, in a sense, giving the treasurer, well, except we are approving. Yeah, I just wonder if we should [1:01:13] Speaker E (unidentified): just leave it with the chair. You know, the chair is the one who does that. The treasurer can come to the chair and say i don't want to do these two things anymore can you find somebody else on the committee to do it and maybe it's just cleaner if it's the if it's only the chair it just it seems a little odd that just under one category but then if we if we step forward [1:01:40] Speaker C (unidentified): and the treasurer doesn't want to do those anymore the chair can't just say oh jane or Amy, or anybody, okay, you're going to take that over. The committee probably needs input into it, or you need to be asking the person, not just assigning it to them. [1:02:00] Speaker E (unidentified): I guess I agree with that, but I'm guessing who is that person? Is it the treasurer who does that, or is it the chair who does that? [1:02:11] Speaker C (unidentified): You know what I'm saying? I think it's the chair that probably should do it, but with the approval of the rest of the committee. [1:02:20] Speaker D (unidentified): so if i can't do it at some point i am going to come to the committee and ask for somebody else to take over one or both of these functions but right now i'm doing it so i don't see why i can't just stay the way it is until such point that i need somebody to take over and then we can change [1:02:43] Speaker B (unidentified): this and when you when and if you ever did that then there would be people saying i move that so and so or you know you could take a vote right it doesn't have to be a pointy line right so right [1:02:57] Speaker A (unidentified): you want this to be a separate clause do you want this to be f where it describes that currently the treasurer tracks these two, has these two extra responsibilities so that at some point, if the treasurer, and please don't get any ideas, Gail, but if you were to change, we would then assign, we would talk about it and hopefully somebody would put their hand up and they then would be doing the one job or the other. [1:03:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, so my suggestion here is just leave E as treasurer, make F number recorder, and just say what the function is of the number recorder, and it doesn't matter whether or not it's the treasurer. Oh. How is that with everybody? [1:03:58] Speaker E (unidentified): That's okay, but now we have, that's like another officer, though, or another official. [1:04:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, they're not going to be, they're not going to be executive committee. committee let's see because executive committees are usually you know a president a vice president this and a secretary and a treasurer there's there are only four people usually so where else i don't i don't think we can put it somewhere else because the rest is general of what all members are supposed to do i [1:04:36] Speaker D (unidentified): think just leave it the way it is and we'll change If it needs to be changed, then. [1:04:46] Speaker G (unidentified): So, Joan, you haven't assigned any overall duties, as you just said, for the officers. The officers, we've spelled out specific duties for each of them, but maybe the officers should have authority to reassign the duties. Do we really need to go to the rest of all of us for that? [1:05:11] Speaker A (unidentified): the whole committee yeah see [1:05:18] Speaker G (unidentified): it just says the officers in it under a they just did what they consist of but we haven't given them any duties to work together in case of [1:05:31] Speaker E (unidentified): a change in positions well we've never really done that we've never really had an executive committee met separately to come with the agenda or whatnot usually it's the chair and the vice chair we've never done like four of us meeting to decide we don't we've never needed to do anything [1:05:50] Speaker A (unidentified): like that it's just it just is describing a job and what the what that encompasses so i think maybe we can go ahead and we could divide this into f as the number reporter elaine is that sound feasible or is that getting too wonky for bylaws no i don't think so [1:06:20] Speaker C (unidentified): you're laying out the offices but the duties doesn't necessarily have to be specific to officers because we all have duties all members are listed so if you want to break that out [1:06:32] Speaker A (unidentified): well do you not want to have this in there at all then if you're saying i mean okay we're not We're not saying that Amy is going around and sanding benches. We're not saying that there is somebody who's creating the newsletter. We're not specifying anybody else as to the kind of job they have. [1:06:52] Speaker H (unidentified): have so i think i think these are important things that the treasurer oversees so what if we just and i don't want to have to come back and change the bylaws when gail doesn't want it because the select board has to approve these it's a big deal so what if we just said yeah the let's see i'm starting where joyce's red is the treasurer oversees the tracking of donations the lighthouse cash box although they oversee it all now right now they oversee it because Joyce is doing it but that allows us the ability to give the new treasurer the authority to find some other people working with the executive committee who can do some of these jobs just like we did this last summer or winter when Jackie was doing the people counter right exactly but if we just say oversee then it's not their responsibility necessarily they just oversee and make sure it happens with other human beings or they themselves and then we don't have to change things around when joy when gail decides she doesn't want to oversee this [1:08:06] Speaker G (unidentified): stuff anymore and [1:08:09] Speaker A (unidentified): then it's fine with me to leave it right to leave it sort of loose and unspecific And just that she oversees, the treasurer oversees these two things and leave it at that. And if she changes, if she's not doing it, 's not saying that she's even doing it by overseeing it. [Speaker H (unidentified): Right. Exactly.] Now, we know that anybody could do the work and be assigned to do that. And the treasurer, I don't think that's asking too much that the treasurer would just see that there is a report generated. if she doesn't do it then someone else does it right is that if that means everybody [1:08:49] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah yes that was good all right [1:08:55] Speaker A (unidentified): so that i'm sure we are keeping all of this within the treasurer part e correct we're not dividing this up now again yes right yes okay all right fine okay so that i'll i'll change out and oversee and i may send it to joyce for her words if i put too many words in she could cut them all out afterwards okay all right let's go to f which is all members are expected to is there anything that anybody, once changed within all of this. I decided that we did need to put in all of the documents that we currently sort of official and unofficial, because every committee member, even the alternate should be familiar so that it gets them used to what we're dealing with. And so that's why i listed all the standards and green books and protocols everybody okay with everything that's under f okay yes i am yes yeah all right elaine do you want to do you want an approval then of section three of officers and duties and hopefully we'll get the wording right for the final version which we're going to approve hopefully in december once we get this truly finalized with all the edits in it so i will make a motion i'll make a motion that we accept [1:10:50] Speaker C (unidentified): section three offices and duties as discussed second okay go ahead joyce you've said yes gail [1:11:00] Speaker A (unidentified): you approve louisa and approved yes jane yes and elaine yes okay and i approve all right and susan yep susan approved all right okay great wonderful next is number four meetings do you want to i do have a question for you i mean historically it has always been a four o'clock meeting is that fine with everybody would you want it a little bit earlier does three o'clock the only reason i sort of suggested even though it breaks into a day or an afternoon for a lot of people would be it could be easier for us to get a town official to come to a meeting. If they're still, they have to work until four, at least they'd be at the start of a meeting and would be maybe more likely to come if they weren't having to stay for extra time, sort of off the clock. But any opinions one way or the other? Joyce has written in blue, instead of the time, at the time and location listed. So that kind of lets us do whatever we [1:12:22] Speaker E (unidentified): want if we want to have done that sometimes we have had it at three o'clock because it wasn't a meeting other times you know we've had to switch it so why not just give you the flexibility [1:12:34] Speaker G (unidentified): maybe we should ask the liaison what they would be preferable does the time need to be in the [1:12:42] Speaker H (unidentified): bylaws i don't think so i think we hamper ourselves again we may need to change the time If it's in the bylaw, I just think what Joyce did, she crossed out the time, at a time and location, listed on the agenda, allows us the flexibility without having to go to the select board to approve a new time for us to meet. I think we should leave it vague. [1:13:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. I agree. I think that's another very good edit there. So, all right. So, we're going to use that. All right. On to the next page, where you speak, we talk about special meetings and cancellations of meetings. meetings i don't see anything any changes that anybody had unless somebody has an edit they want to mention now are we okay all [1:13:47] Speaker B (unidentified): right so i like the addition yeah i like the addition [1:13:50] Speaker C (unidentified): that you made you know in red yeah i mean it's right all right and then we go to [1:14:01] Speaker A (unidentified): adjourned meetings d i made with a small change there because we've never talked about the tabling and calling for motions the quorum what the quorum is the quorum will now get larger since we go to nine so it'll take more people having to be present required to keep everybody there. I can unbold the open meeting. I think that was to be sure that people understood that in these bylaws, in our bylaws, we have stated, and actually I didn't realize it until I read these a month or two ago, that we actually are saying that we have the right to, there was always public comments and we can invite at different points if we want the public to speak but otherwise they speak when we open it up ourselves so we 're not bothering with doing the asterisks and things like that because we have this in our bylaws that explains how we run our meetings and then down to what the agenda is which is what we follow now and then we did specify in here which we had not done before i think i had i should have put this in red we've never actually mentioned that if everyone is present in the room together it can be a show of hands but when we are split if it's a virtual meeting and anybody is online then it always has to be a roll call vote and i've been fairly lacks on that as far as in the past, because I just let people vote by hand, but it is a rule and Robert's rules that it has to be done that way so that everybody is sure that everyone has a proper vote. Are there any changes to any of these on this whole page from B down to H? [Speaker D (unidentified): no] we good yeah okay all right and then we get to conflict of interest and i'm sort of missing i'm getting mixed up on my pages here all right any changes to the kind of the description for the conflict of interest does that cover everything and anything i think there's never going to be an interest that has to do with the financial for us, but it's more, I guess, a determination between if you have an interest that coincides with the type of work or the issue that we're actually dealing with for the marginal way. [1:17:03] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that conflict of interest comes basically out of the charter also. And Rubella. [1:17:12] Speaker D (unidentified): All right. All right. [1:17:14] Speaker A (unidentified): So is there any change that anybody would suggest? Are you fine with the conflict of interest section? [1:17:24] Speaker G (unidentified): I think it's good. [1:17:25] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Why don't we do then to, what section is that? All right. So for section four, for meetings, which covers all of this from A through I, can i have a motion that we're we're voting for this we approve everything under the set this section four [1:17:52] Speaker B (unidentified): i make a motion that we accept section four through section i right yes i'll i'll second it hopefully with the [1:18:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So let's vote. I'll start with Joyce. How do you vote? Yes. Gail? Yes. Yes. Okay. Louisa? Susan is yes. Yes. [1:18:23] Speaker B (unidentified): Jane? Jane is a yes. [1:18:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Elaine? Yes. Susan? [1:18:31] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes. Okay. Somebody's talking to you on your phone. [1:18:34] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Very good. So when I make these edits, then I will at our next meeting, which is December the 7th, that'll be the date that we can do a final review. I'll send it to you ahead of time and that we vote on this. And so that will be the date that we as a committee would approve these new bylaws. And then at that point, then I will send them to our liaison Heath and let him take it forward to the select board for final approval. So that'll be over and done with. so all right very good everybody thank you very much that's good i'll need joyce to help me get through all the final edits here but i've taken notes and i think we're all set on all of this so that's great that's wonderful what i'd like to do let's see we're running a little long but i did want to go over did everybody have a chance to really look through the whole collaboration draft that we sent in i was hoping that heath would be here so that we could have discussed with him a couple of points i don't know when the select board is going to bring up their discussion about this collaboration project and whether there's going to be any opportunity for the committees and the select board to go over a lot of these points with them. It would be helpful, but I know that on the spreadsheet, the worksheet that we put together that was this big Excel spreadsheet. I made a lot of additions to it because what was in the comp plan didn't begin to really show the amount of work or what we're doing. And I think it was, as Jane said, there were places where the conservation commission was in charge of something that really was for the marginal way so i moved them over into a resource and put us in as the major responsibility and i've added what i think should have been unfortunately in the comp plan that wasn't that we are doing a lot of outreach and education and so we've got our three major pillars, which are the public safety, the horticultural side of it, and then the outreach. And I think that is and will be always our main function and what we do. I mean, it starts with the safety part. And that's why Gail's report was so, Gail, and what Jackie did is so important. and that's the next thing and again Tyler the CEO suggested that we need to go through Heath on that report to get that to bring that forward to the select board so he felt that it wasn't his place that it has to go through our liaison and then Heath has to take it to the select board and whether that means that we give a presentation to them or just give them the report you know we're we're going to have to now meet with Heath separately and try to figure out what are the next steps on all of that. [1:22:19] Speaker D (unidentified): But we also. [1:22:20] Speaker F (unidentified): Can I interrupt for one minute? I'm sorry. I have to leave. And Jackie's giving me a ride. So I'm very sorry to have to leave the meeting, but I will be on zoom from, for the next few months. and so everyone take care get better yes everybody don't don't get hurt no slipping on ice or snow or anything so we all go with behave yourself strong work all of you i appreciate you all thank you amy thank you 're welcome jackie we'll talk except that i'm not going anywhere [1:23:06] Speaker E (unidentified): So Joan, I thought what you worked up as our input on that collaboration plan was excellent and should go through whatever the next steps are. I realize there's going to be some pushback or there may be changes or whatnot, but in terms of a draft document right now, I thought you incorporated the input that was given to you and that i thought it was like good to go i mean i think now go ahead i agree and i [1:23:41] Speaker B (unidentified): was just going to say that you know they haven't voted on it yet as you know so it's not the idea was that each committee gave their reason their comments their thoughts their work plan and then the select board collects them all and just looks it over and sees is this feasible is this something that's working for committees so we don't need to do another presentation or thing we've already done our work now they decide it's out of our hands it's not a binding thing that we think it's just a they're going to gather all the things that the committee they're going to decide is this going to work do most of the committees think this is going to work what are the you know what are the problems with it what are the issues what are the good things and then they'll let us know like they'll vote on it so that i think we can kind of if what's possible i think we can kind of relax just a little and you know that's we got we've [1:24:40] Speaker C (unidentified): done what we needed to do and you did a great job i know the select board had said at the last meeting when they discussed this that they would be discussing it sometime in november they hope but there's only one select board meeting in November, so they may actually not even get to this till December. And I asked Heath briefly after one of the meetings if committees would have any direct input with the select board members, and he said he didn't know. [1:25:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Are they meeting tomorrow, or is it the next Tuesday? The 17th. The 17th. The 17th. Oh, okay. All right. I think one of the main I mean, we pretty much are just doing what we've always done. And I think that our work is more organized and more sort of fully, you know, put together in our own strategic plan. So whether or not it is in their both a comprehensive plan, which, I mean, we did at the time, I think Elaine and I met with representatives from the comprehensive plan, gave them all of the same things that we're doing now. And yet they came up with a much smaller version and maybe not really as accurate as I would have hoped of what this committee is responsible for. So that's why I brought that out. I think the one point that I am concerned about is this whole financial reporting. And that's why I spent a lot of the written narrative report saying that if once a committee presents a budget and goes through the whole process of working it out ourselves, taking it to both the budget review and to the select board, and then that gets approved by voters, then this micromanaging by having everything approved ahead of time and going through town managers and things like that. I mean, in all these, since we first got ourselves a budget in 2015, we've never approved or had to go to the town manager and said, may we spend this? I mean, it was always within the whole description. And we're only asking for what we're describing as part of our mission. So I think I'm not quite sure why they went to such detail as to how everything had to be approved ahead of time, voted ahead of time and all this when it's already within the scope of what would work. I mean, if I was saying that we're going to have a luncheon somewhere to congratulate ourselves on having had a good year, I mean, obviously, you know, we're not spending money wildly. We're doing it. Everything has to do with the mission and the projects that we work on. So I hope at some point before they still approve some of these very detailed financial requirements that there's a chance to have a conversation about it and have some flexibility. I think it was Louisa who came up with a very good word of asking a reasonable latitude, which I took literally right out of her comments that she wrote, because, I mean, all these committees are working as hard as they can and being as responsible as possible. And so I would hope that they would trust these committees that they're going to use the money responsibly and that is something that can be altered and changed, that I'd like that very much to happen before they just vote overall that, you know, everything that they've written is going to be the final word. [1:28:49] Speaker G (unidentified): well if they do that they're going to have to assign add another assistant treasurer to the town if everybody has to submit detailed details of how many stamps they bought [1:29:04] Speaker D (unidentified): exactly I think it's really good [1:29:08] Speaker B (unidentified): that you put this in here and other committees will say what they need to say but it's important that you outline it as detailed as this so that they get your feedback actor. It is important. [1:29:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I mean, they're asking for it, whether they're actually going to listen, but I think they should hear. And we, along with, I think, what, Parks and Recs, we spend a lot of little money. I mean, all through the year, we probably have, I don't know, at least maybe over a hundred transactions, things that we buy or the invoices that come in for both Mike and for Steve, for other work by other people, if that's necessary. So we have a lot of little things going out. We're not holding on to a reserve fund where we're going to buy one piece of property that's going to cost, you know, $100,000 or a million dollars or something like that. So we have an active account. I think Parks and Rec does. I don't know how many other committees are as actively spending in little bits and pieces through a whole year as we are. But I think in this case, it makes it difficult and it would be very restrictive. And we've never had a problem and we've never been questioned by either the town manager or the town treasurer about any of these expenses. So I just see what they're describing both in the handbook for committees and in this collaboration seems more than necessary. That's all. [1:30:51] Speaker E (unidentified): But I think there's general agreement that the way you wrote it is good and giving that input is good. So, I [1:31:01] Speaker A (unidentified): guess now we'll wait to listen to see what the reaction and, you know, what are the summary of the select board as to, you know, how they've responded to all the committees and what they've put together. Okay. Absolutely. Since it's 530, I'm going to say that we table the idea for the NRT is a new program. I had Elaine look at this. It's a designation for trails that could have some financial benefit for us. But let's save it for, since we've done a lot of work today, let's save it for December. And we'll call it a night with all this work. I'm very pleased that we've got the bylaws settled. That's out of the way. and maybe we can have a an easy meeting and have cookies and well for the people that are here you'll all everybody in florida will have to have their own cookie somewhere so if there's nothing else if there's no other business i'll ask for a motion to adjourn [1:32:19] Speaker H (unidentified): it looks like they've already adjourned they've adjourned all right [1:32:26] Speaker B (unidentified): I vote yes. [1:32:28] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, very good. So we are adjourned. See you December 7th, everybody. Safe travels to the people that are going to be away. And you'll have to show us some...