Ogunquit Conservation Commission Approves Minutes and Discusses Land Funding
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:20] Speaker A (unidentified): okay we're live hey good morning everyone and welcome to the conservation mission meeting my name is wendy i'm the chair let's take a roll call please george bond member
[0:39] Speaker B (unidentified): amy kelly vice chair elaine jean brandeis member joanna mannequin secretary jeff missouri member
[0:48] Speaker A (unidentified): And to be noted, we are, we're, we're missing Audrey. So there is not here. Okay. I hope everyone had a chance to read the October 7th minutes. Did everybody get a chance to read those. Let's have a motion to approve those minutes if nobody has any changes to make.
[1:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Make a motion to accept the minutes.
[1:24] Speaker A (unidentified): George Blum moves. A second? I wasn't here. Jeff Masorti. A second. Jeff Masorti. No voting. I wasn't here. for you yeah one two you we're good we can vote okay let's have a roll call vote to approve these minutes wendy levine yes jeff masori yes joanne mangers yes amy kelly yes joanne bomb yes motion passed all right so now we're on number three which is three one mission
[2:14] Speaker B (unidentified): statement and today we're proud to
[2:19] Speaker A (unidentified): do the oh my goodness right i'm in a bit of a coma so let's stand for the political reason
[2:29] Speaker B (unidentified): and there's a i have one on the computer thank you there is one on the computer thank you oh there we go i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands one nation underdrawn and invisible with liberty and justice for all yay
[2:56] Speaker A (unidentified): the initial statement for the Conservation Commission reads as follows. The Commission's goal is to protect our waterways, beaches, dunes, and wetlands, to map, index, and preserve Agunquit's open spaces including marshes, wetlands, and wildlife habitats, and to support a conservation land fund for the acquisition, development, and citizen's use of public conservation areas.
[3:29] Speaker B (unidentified): yes thank you yeah
[3:39] Speaker A (unidentified): good never mind what was the date when we went to the main conservation commission conference it was a week ago saturday ago saturday yeah amy and i we might remember we voted to spend a hundred dollars to join the Maine Conservation Commission Association and they invited us to a statewide conference of all Conservation Commission people. We drove up there to where? Brunswick. Brunswick. Which I had never even heard of. I had no idea. Bates College? Yes. Oh, that's where Bates is. Yes. Okay. Yeah, we met in a library. I had spoken with the chair of this organization multiple times. That's why I wanted to join because he had helped me many times when I had questions and I could just pick up a phone and call him. This was exciting because it was conservation chairs and vice chairs and people from all over the place. And we- There were a lot of towns from neighboring towns?
[4:59] Speaker B (unidentified): People from neighboring towns? Yes.
[5:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Not as many as I would have thought. Tivus, York, were not there.
[5:07] Speaker B (unidentified): York was not there, but the closest that were near us were Kittery, Elliott.
[5:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Not Wells. They were not there. So the smaller. Berwick. Yeah.
[5:19] Speaker B (unidentified): I believe it was one of the Berwicks and not so much.
[5:21] Speaker A (unidentified): but we 're kind of famous for a lot of things so we are because of our you know pesticide ordinance everybody loves that and how to do that and so it's just an example of how things worked there because others had things that were like whoa oh, how'd you do that? And it was very,, very inspiring. It was very interesting. We were able to break up into small groups, talk with each other. There was networking. There was a nice luncheon served. It was really special. I'm very happy that we went. Every town kind of stood up and said what we're proud of, what we're not, what we're trying, what we're working on and if we had something we were working on and somebody else had an idea about that and we i have lists now that people is this an annual meeting i think so i would guess so fred was very he was very excited to be hosting it he's a nice guy we had two incredible speakers and they too were like hey here 's our name here's our anything you want questions call us so I thought it was a spectacular day I was really happy that we went there and as I said I think we represented ourselves well there are things here that they know that we have and they appreciated that so particularly the pesticide ordinance any questions about that day amy drove because i knew that i would never have found it
[7:23] Speaker B (unidentified): so one of the towns jump in one of the towns shared what they've done regarding how to promote their town their natural resources and so i picked up their pen which they shared with everybody. I picked up at the town of Bremen and the Conservation Commission put together a pamphlet. And one of the tasks deemed in our COMP plan was to, you know, share and enlighten the community for, you know, what's ongoing here. What gives, Tom Montgomery has in regards to natural beauty and so on. So I thought that perhaps I could share this here year and maybe we could model some of what we want to do and our commission with that so that was a plus and finding out that other towns have worked on tree ordinances molesticide ordinances and land acquisitions it was very enlightening so we're glad that
[8:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Are we far behind with land acquisitions compared to... Well, we haven't funded it in years. The fund is now zero, so it has to go pretty... Or do we still have $25,000, maybe?
[8:43] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, we've got to have a breakdown, apparently, on what we have in finance. We need advice. We're not in that.
[8:52] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, we don't have enough money to buy everything. But we used to fund it yearly. it was always on the ballot $25,000 and they've taken it off so we need to really push to get that back on the ballot a yearly contribution so that fund that's how we got to Boston land
[9:10] Speaker B (unidentified): we had one so at the bottom of our plan work plan there is an item for $25,970 what the breakdown of that is it's not clear because you know we need to know what's designated for what
[9:27] Speaker A (unidentified): So, conservation land always has to be voted on regardless, but if the funding is not there we can't even put it on the ballot.
[9:39] Speaker B (unidentified): But it is, they did put that in this document. Exactly. That's good. That's all good.
[9:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you want to talk to us about this document?
[9:53] Speaker B (unidentified): or okay so one attempt to explain there was a date that was delivered to us from the chair and the select board regarding which date was it october 15th and we had our meeting directly after that date but we really didn't touch on what the process would be how to address the material regarding our responsibilities so i briefly in order to comply with their request put together an informal letter didn't date it didn't put our insignia on it we were out of town but i did send a letter forward up here i suppose i could you want me to read it out loud for the record and then we can vote if you want if you deem this good we can vote on it and then date it and insignia and so on make it good so dear select board the conservation commission briefly reviewed the select board's request and given the limited time frame and requested response date would like to offer the following priorities for consideration we appreciate the opportunity to provide itemized record of our interest for the Comprehensive Plan. This could be a positive way to keep the Select Board informed of our priorities, highlight related financial needs, identify areas where legal guidance may be helpful, and support the Commission's project needs. I have aligned some of the Comprehensive Plans in the work for Lisey Attached as well. They had asked for suggestions as well as we believe that shoreline signage should be improved to help protect Agunquit's natural resources, expand the amount of protected land in Agunquit through a coordinated acquisition strategy that preserves the town's natural resources, address budget implications through an annual ballot referendum that would contribute funds to a dedicated land purchase account. As well, we could consider conducting community outreach to explore creative acquisitions options, including land donations and private philanthropy. Give residents opportunities to create a lasting conservation legacy and consider establishing a charitable gift designation specifically for land acquisition. Lastly, a suggestion to be establishing a pollinator garden on town land. Thank you for considering these comments. We look forward to working with the Select Board as the Comprehensive Plan moves forward to promote conservation and a... excuse me, warm regards, Amy Kelly, Vice Chair, Conservation Commission. Commission. So that's what I sent. That's what you sent. I would like suggestions on how people feel about that response to the Select Board and if there is need to be an improvement or an addendum added to it. I would like to open in this discussion oh
[13:31] Speaker A (unidentified): first and foremost thank you for doing it and i think that you probably are one of a few who jumped right on it and did it 's what you do and i am forever grateful for that i have no problem with anything that was on there i think you covered who we are what we do and what we want so i personally have no yeah it sounds really good thank you nicely done yeah i thought it was good thank you so do you think we need to vote on it just so that we can make it kosher and legal keep it kosher and not be the only person responsible all right well then we i need a motion that says let us let us approve this work that amy has done for the select board somebody went on i need a motion to approve amy's letter to the select board i'll second it okay that's motion made by elaine grande seconded by george blum and let's have a roll call vote george blum how do you vote yes amy kelly yes elaine gian grande yes joanne amandacus yes jeff massour yes wendy levine yes unanimously passed well done thank you i will date it but today Okay. I had this planning board application on the end of the agenda. I moved it up because she was thinking she might join by Zoom and or come. So is anybody here then? No. Okay. Then we can put it.
[15:39] Speaker B (unidentified): that's my right oh did we didn't have it around the edge it was number five on the back side okay we do not have to move her up okay perfect i'm sorry go ahead so going back to the work plan. I don't know when you want to discuss and assign the conservation commission's plan and strategy. And there are some that align with us specifically. There are some that align with watershed that we need to publicly say this falls into their gap, their wheelhouse rather than ours so we could just briefly discuss that let's let's do that in under new
[16:40] Speaker A (unidentified): business okay very good because we're still on we could do it here
[16:50] Speaker B (unidentified): because we're still there all right now let me see if i can find the one that's not in the
[16:57] Speaker D (unidentified): a thought of space. I was thinking
[17:02] Speaker A (unidentified): about this last night as I was watching Electromanagement Returns. We've talked multiple times about actually assigning it's winter's coming. We're not as busy as everyone is in the summer or the fall. It's time to hunker down. And I think that each of us really needs to figure out what they're passionate about and what parts of our initiatives you feel like you would really like to grab and go and manage and make it happen. There are several ordinances, possible ordinances, we're going to talk about those later and know that there are plant people. I know that Audrey is you know passionate about planting I of course am always trees and I think Amy's probably the conservation land person I have gathered several ordinances from other towns and so we have some starts starting verbiage but the process to pass an ordinance is we produce it. It goes from us to the planning board. They approve it or not. If they approve it, goes to the select board, who then must approve it to get it actually on a ballot. So that's the process, and it does take time. So if we want this on the June ballot, it's time to get working now. We have helpers. Tyler will help. He vowed that he would help. Just in wording and legality, he knows. So we do have helpers. So I think in the past, we've talked about land, water, and water wildlife the birds yes and there's a four there trees land that's land so is that people feel comfortable being able to say i want to do that is that is this a time
[19:33] Speaker B (unidentified): when you would feel comfortable out of the chair yes i'm a little bit confused on these work plans
[19:39] Speaker D (unidentified): is this a new process and there's a new process so anyway i also have a new committee watershed committee so that's right what do we understand about the intersection of overlap with that because most of these are also on the watershed yes that's correct so how do we pick something I want to do that is for that one or more of these or is it that the categories you just described
[20:06] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that well Amy knows better than I but I think that the watershed group is more concerned with estuaries perhaps so the watershed
[20:16] Speaker B (unidentified): is concerned the watershed committee from my understanding is well it analyzes the health of the water system from outside of Agamkwit and in Agamkwit, and all the rivers and tributaries that go through Agamkwit River and then come into the outfall of the Agamkwit River. And they test along the way. They're trying to gauge what are pollutants, what's healthy, what's not healthy. They're trying to raise public awareness and do outreach within this town and the surrounding towns that are part of the Gunquit River Watershed. So what they do is they are testing, the town of Gunquit has been testing at the pipes that drain into the Gunquit River to the best of their ability, the testing equipment is still being worked out and sided on. on. So that's, that's what they're concerned with. So yeah. So that's where there's overlap, there's overlapping. And that's what I was going to discuss regarding water resources. But let's say item number eight, it says water resources continue to assess the current catch basins help to decrease pollution, that would be the watershed committee, number eight. To the best of my ability, I haven't had a chance to chat with their chairperson on this, but it's a good idea to touch base with them. Also, number 14, I believe that number 14, water resources, no, actually that's us, I take that back, number 14, water resources to continually inform the community about the town pesticide and herbicide ordinances, and amend the ordinance and adopt a safe fertilizer ordinance. That's something that's probably a little bit of overlap that we could work together on. I wrote down as a remedy to that water resources remind and encourage the citizens about the pesticide herbicide ordinance as well as education information describing the important impacts of these products on the environment as well designate acceptable alternatives explore future notification options such as including my idea was to include a notice with the tax bills. since that's already going out, that's a way to reach citizens. Public cable TV, channel three, perhaps they could put notices on pesticides, what's good there or what's not good there. So channel three, as well as post a link to the ordinance on our Conservation Commission webpage. I wrote down that's an ongoing item. how do people feel about that does that does that answer a question do you see where it's an overlap because it does touch into what your watershed is doing and what we can do to assist and help so there's that what else and they always make it clear if they're having some
[23:57] Speaker A (unidentified): special project they we know it's not the only place that overlaps we often overlap with sustainability but yeah but and for me for a very brief period of time the watershed committee was under us right but then when it when it was clear that they would be dealing with other towns then it's it that had to split apart right so this predates that right because they
[24:27] Speaker B (unidentified): don't appear in this exactly it doesn't it has not been designated so i wanted to hit on two more things. So number 16, it says water resources continue to work with the Agunquit Sewer District to identify faulty sewer lines. That's precisely what the Watershed Committee has been working on very vigorously and diligently, and they're doing an amazing job with that. And that seems to be
[24:53] Speaker E (unidentified): their biggest pollutant is septic systems, you know, dog waste, things like that. That's where
[25:03] Speaker B (unidentified): the bacteria and that's yeah here i'll work from that and we do we volunteer with hero you know every two years so it's you know we collaborate and volunteer and help with for the better community all of our people do so and then number 17 water resources us all should go to the watershed committee i'm sure that they've taken that on encourage landowners to protect the water quality, contact information with municipal office for water quality, best management practices. That's not us, that's watershed. But the rest of, much of this is conservation commission, integrity, the integrity of what we've been doing. We're concerned with sea level rise, number 10, climate change, encourage the planting of additional trees on town property and residential property to provide shade and conserve energy that's got everything to do with climate change so we want to encourage tree planting and i wrote down about the sea level right we have two people in the community they're assisting with the king tide so thank you jeff and we have lent here so I'm not going to, the other day, give him the information regarding aging men as well.
[26:29] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, there's not too much to the sheet, so.
[26:31] Speaker B (unidentified): No, you've got to get into the website. If you want, I can help walk you through that.
[26:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, no, I went up there. So there's, yeah, so the King Tide's 25th through the 27th coming up. Yes,. It's the middle of the day, so. Yeah. They're at midnight, but. No,, it's all.
[26:49] Speaker B (unidentified): so the thing about the king tide is do not be a hero do not get wet do not put yourself in harm's way stand back take pictures there's a subjective list of notes that they ask of you identify yourself when i did it a couple of years ago i didn't even say i was on the conservation commission to up and i just i'm a citizen but right put down conservation commission or what your identity is you know on that but keep yourself safe and oh yeah so i can show you pictures that i've taken in the past so that you can maybe use that to follow along so that we can see if okay yeah from you from the vantage from your vantage you can see they can track that yeah what else do you want to go through some more or do you want to assign things right now or do you want to take this till next meeting and like
[27:53] Speaker A (unidentified): digest it and look at these things look at the things on there and decide what is your yeah no i think it's a good idea it'll be another month away that we you know take the ball down the road but i think people need to think carefully what they want to do and this
[28:22] Speaker B (unidentified): should help and point people in the right direction i think it's a really good tool to really and you know it encompasses everything that we care about and gets us good not good starting point to you know just move the ball forward and i agree the top of the mountain that
[28:45] Speaker A (unidentified): went and wow i agree okay then we'll put it on our next agenda and hopefully people by then we'll we'll have decided good discussion thank you thank you
[29:05] Speaker B (unidentified): that's really helpful yeah to you know to really start thinking about it right
[29:10] Speaker A (unidentified): right yeah we haven't just fyi we didn't get to plant our pollinator
[29:20] Speaker B (unidentified): go ahead and that's actually in our call plan and i did i did say that you know and i marched
[29:28] Speaker A (unidentified): into matt's office when i came and saw everything already planted when we were supposed to be able to choose plants and yeah where was this supposed to be we thought it was going to be here
[29:42] Speaker B (unidentified): so i wrote down at the back this where the project's currently on hold until we hear from the town manager where the space would be where is our space we put it in our budget we already had
[29:55] Speaker A (unidentified): it all lined up we wouldn't have a rain barrel to take care of it and all this and he did in fact say that the landscape was sad because they were hills he had to plant something or all the dirt was just going to run and it does it totally does and they're pretty they're pretty they are and i you know i was just a little stunned and so now i just want to say
[30:22] Speaker B (unidentified): okay where is our pollinator there's no room not here yeah but someone else has a lot of space i don't know where our public land is but we should we should put the spot and make it happen because
[30:36] Speaker A (unidentified): because it's important it is it is it's it is got one of the questions on the other survey they wanted us to take which is where do you see yourself in the conservation world and what are you doing it's a survey i didn't fill it out yet it's i will did you bring that with you I see, it's on my phone, but you know, one of them was planting native, that was on the list, how are you teaching your population to plant native and perennials and non-annuals and all that. So it was, the list that they gave, we do, we really do every bit of it. So I was proud, No pesticides, no this, no that. The list, we do it. We try to conserve land. We try. The tree ordinance that I would like to propose when we get that far should save trees. It should definitely save, especially the older ones. And right now, there are some rules and ordinances about how many trees you can take down if you are building a project in other words more than one dwelling that there's an amount that you can take down for that but that amount is different from what you can take that 's controlled if you will so i don't know if everyone wrote everybody knows what they did right before the transfer station so that's three new homes but they sold the plots, they sold the lots before they built the houses. So he didn't own it. And so they could just mow it down, which they did. The people who bought the lots could have said, no, I would like them to stay, but that's not what happened. They're all gone. They're all gone. Oh, forest right there. so that's something i personally truly want to want to stop right now because we're we're just destroying too many too many trees and it impacts everything from the water to the air to the animals to the trees protect everyone everything and everyone so that's my that's they're beautiful they are beautiful my neighbors hate my oak trees especially right now oh my god we're waving in the leaves they're ancient they're huge they're hundreds of years old i want a friend working back so and acorns and they're a mess they're a mess they're an absolute mess don't cry but all i say is yeah i keep i keep the leaves under the trees and that so i those are all left there and they are you're breathing air that this tree has soaked up all the co2 out of the air for you 're having shade you're not using all these other you don't have to heat your houses how anybody who bought a lot would want no shade is beyond my imagination like why you wouldn't want to have a place to go outside and be able to see any shade somewhere where they just they're gone so yeah there's that 's a tree ordinance i have one i have i think it's a it's from your so i have starts of things to work on here it was from south
[34:29] Speaker B (unidentified): portland yeah i didn't bring i did i have single
[34:40] Speaker A (unidentified): use plastic with your But in this draft, I might have it in a different way, we'll find it, 's not a problem. But this is a true ordinance draft. So when we get there, whoever wants to join me, I can do it. So that's where we are, that's where we are. and we'll get these ordinances on the June ballot assuming that they make it to the planning board
[35:21] Speaker E (unidentified): and the celebrity is the ordinance for somebody's building something they have to keep x amount of trees or is it if I remember right at the meeting last month I don't and I don't know who mentioned that somebody might have something about frontage there could be a compiler yes and he mentioned some whether it was york or maybe wells had done something interesting that they could save a lot of trees are there be two separate ordinances or he seemed to think it would be it might have been tyler he seemed to think it would be an easier thing to manage and maybe get it won't bang for the puck.
[36:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that's a little, yes, that's very possibly true. And of course, it would mean that Tyler doesn't have to go to every single place that he would not, because he would have to be the enforcer. It helps him.
[36:26] Speaker B (unidentified): That's the difficulty, is, you know, observation and enforcement. And that's so hard. It is. Natural resource coordination.
[36:38] Speaker A (unidentified): i know don't i know don't i know yeah okay where are we on the agenda do we have anything else oh we do have to write the little note for the planning board it's very simple we have no conservation concerns she's not digging up anything she's not doing anything she's not even cooking so she's basically making a little wall there exactly and combining two stores it looks like there will be some merchandise as well as food inside but then she wants you to just kind of sit outside and pretty and enjoy yourself and she's she's all in we can't we can't force her to use these products i don't know if we even need to put it on the memo because she promises she will
[37:33] Speaker B (unidentified): do and it's always only it's in the past our letters has always stated we suggest or we
[37:40] Speaker A (unidentified): encourage we hope something to that and so we should vote on sending that to the planning board it will be the same as multiple ones that we've sent before we no environmental concerns no conservation concerns. We hope that you will use and move to some biodegradable. It's the planning board. And just check us out.
[38:06] Speaker B (unidentified): I moved to send a note on to the planning board regarding I don't have the it's Paul Gunquit. It's Paul Gunquit at 33 Shore Road at Gunquit, Maine, that we have no concerns regarding conservation issues. Issues. My second.
[38:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Seconded. Yes, seconded. How do you vote?
[39:06] Speaker C (unidentified): George Blum, yes.
[39:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Amy Kelly, yes.
[39:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Elaine Giangrande, yes. Joanna Vanegas, yes. Sori, yes. Wendy Levine, yes. Unanimously. We'll take care of that and get it to the planning book for their meeting. They can check us off. I don't think there's a meeting. That's why I wanted to get one. I did, by the way, call her because technically we are not supposed to discuss an applicant without their presence here. I asked Marianne about that and she said, do I know Beth? What? I don't know if that makes any difference. But she said, as long as you call her and invite her, it's up to her to come or not. Or she could say, I don't want you to talk about me if I'm not there, but I can't make it. You're going to have to reschedule. Those are her choices. And she said, I'm perfectly fine. So we covered our bases there. This is work she'll do next spring though right i'm not even sure i and by the time it makes it through everyone i don't know yeah right i don't know it looks like they've done a lot of work already it's a cute little place adorable and when i said it looks bigger for a region cafe she said yeah that was special oh i love that we're just on the phone if that's really adorable i don't know what bees are maybe we could recommend that she have a pollinator garden i know but do you want to be drinking tea with all the bees around oh that's true because i thought i mean my gardens are all
[40:47] Speaker B (unidentified): all them weren't interested in the thing totally are if it's a real pollinator garden they don't
[40:51] Speaker A (unidentified): want you 're not as sweet as the flowers they're everywhere okay very good where do we have Does anybody else have anything we want to bring up that we left off the agenda or would
[41:24] Speaker B (unidentified): like to add now? I don't think so.
[41:28] Speaker A (unidentified): I have a question. Go ahead.
[41:31] Speaker E (unidentified): So I know last time we talked about the one from compostable to biodegradable. Yeah. so i made the mistake of going down that hole just to see what was what was involved there so i start i started with just looking at it from a cost perspective so if you ask somebody whether you do it through an ordinance or what would we would be asking them to do so you know just say from a food container perspective takeout containers things like that so it looked like it's somewhere between 15 and 25 percent more expensive to get compostable things and you might be you know if you do it more volume you might be able to get those low etc and you can probably do some things they can sometimes they can ask people to pay a little extra for green containers and things so there's things you can do to lower those that cost difference can you ask a question
[42:32] Speaker B (unidentified): do you mean compostable or biodegradable are there is there a big difference i mean so i know there's a difference but that's what you researched was a compostable
[42:41] Speaker E (unidentified): or biodegradable so this is compostable okay i know we moved on to biodegradable right because everything compostable is part is under the biodegradable umbrella so compostable is one thing biodegradable is even grayer just because it's such a poorly defined you know there 's a certification you can get but so what i found was that whether it's compostable or biodegradable unless it compostable and naturally lettuce or whatever you bring you know to a compostable pile or do in your backyard if it's any type of manufactured compostable it has to go to a certain compostable so if we don't have somewhere for people to bring it that's going to get it processed like that it's actually worse for the environment because if it goes to a landfill you get methane from it and it doesn't really do what it's supposed to do so before we'd ask people to do it whether i started looking at it from a cost perspective but then do is there a way for it to be disposed properly i talked with
[44:00] Speaker A (unidentified): with Chris at the dump, at the transfer station. I'm sorry. They do have a compost pile. They- It won't work. It won't, because when people are just bringing a little bucket of their own compost, it's just a little bit. And, you know, there can be many little bits, but if you started selling biocompostable containers it would overrun the good stuff which is it would just cover it all up and you wouldn't be getting the good stuff you'd be getting you know 40 percent of containers instead of actual compost yeah so he said he they couldn't handle it there's no way they can't have a second compost pile of that so he said biodegradable that way at least it's going into the trash it will biodegrade it won't be in the earth forever more it will i don't know about that if it's in eight plastic bags because you know now you have to i mean i have a plastic bag under my sink and that goes into my big trash can in a plastic and now it goes into a green plastic bag at the dump. That's three bags already right there, which hurts my heart, but there's no choice. So that was his take on it, that it has to be the biodegradable.
[45:34] Speaker E (unidentified): So I don't know that 's accurate. Okay. It's, from what I read and do more research, you have a similar problem with biodegradable. Well, A, it's not well-defined. So again, compostable, it's a subset of it. It's something is labeled, there's one defining label, but even the ones that are labeled officially, it's like a BPI label, it has to go to a certain biodegradable processing unit. You put it in a landfill, you'll have different but similar problems to compostable. if it doesn't get the air that it so you're not helping anything the breakdown science is
[46:22] Speaker B (unidentified): very complicated and it what if what if there was a place for it at the dump like there's a
[46:30] Speaker A (unidentified): place for cardboard and there's a then there's somebody that would be fine but they'd have to
[46:34] Speaker E (unidentified): have a place that they can ship it to that does biodegradable air so yeah and i don't yeah so i guess my question was what was our ultimate goal in doing it what's our end goal isn't to reduce faster yeah so then i said okay these don't seem great to me what else could we do so you know i did an informal survey and did some couple of take out things to see what people are using. They're all everybody they use plastic a lot but they're all you know category five plastics which we don't take right so our recycling is one and two period recycling right and so you could ask them to go to one and twos right but our one and twos, they don't take things like clamshell, you know, which is where you would get from businesses and they can't quit. And the other problem is that none of our trash pickup to recycle. cycle so when i looked at that they said towns york had success going to because they have to get approved to do trash pickup in your town they have to get on a license and they can be it can be suggested because they say the trash pickup folks it's easier for them to just do us you know not do recycling but if the town strongly suggests it to continue to operate there so this might have been tried in the past I don't know but it seemed like you know before you go down root of asking people like, oh, maybe we should ask people to go from plastic fives and things for their takeout containers and go to the ones that could be recycled in our thing. I don't know what the percentage of people that use our recycle center versus do trash pickup, but it seems like the best bang for the buck in that general area that we're talking about might be you encourage the trash pick up to start doing recycling I
[49:13] Speaker A (unidentified): don't I don't have trash pick up but a lot of my neighbors do and I see them bring out a trash can and a recycle thing and they just toss it all in there I don't think there's any separation whatsoever I think they just no
[49:29] Speaker B (unidentified): No, there is, because I saw, I don't remember where, a news article, where the trucks actually, it looks like everything goes into one, but the trucks are now made, one half is general trash, the other side of it is the recycle of refuse, and you can't tell from the outside that the truck does that, but the trucks today are built so that they don't have to go out twice. they don't have two trucks coming two crews they do it all into one truck so that's but the truck is split in half so one side takes one thing and the other side takes the recyclables or the biodegradables and what have you that's what i learned the other day because i was
[50:17] Speaker C (unidentified): i don't know where i saw it but driver control that which one gets done yeah he takes one can and puts it in on one side and grabs the other can and puts it in the other side and one side is garbage and the other is to recycle.
[50:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Does anybody have trash pick up? I do recycle now but when I used to just come up here in the summer I'd have to get trash pick up and I couldn't find anybody that would do recycling they all just they do all single
[50:57] Speaker B (unidentified): and then sort they claim they sort at the facility they told me that's what I believe that my community does I live in a yeah so the disposal of the container is one piece
[51:12] Speaker A (unidentified): of the story but so is the manufacturing of the container and the hot walk of food that goes into plastic and we get the plastic right so there's something also for in for me i won't buy anything that's in plastic i won't use anything that's in plastic i don't have any plastic in my house so i mean even for storage i everything is stored in pyrex glass so there's that side of the equation as well if it's hot food and first of all you had to make the plastic container and now you're going to put hot food in it so there's going to be some interaction there you're going to be eating some plastic is it at least a step up to get rid of that plastic
[52:10] Speaker E (unidentified): on the front end probably on the back end maybe you're probably losing out so it depends on what again that's why i went back to what our end goal is right so if our end goal is something like health whether it's microplastics and etc that's one thing but i think you'd want to define why you're doing it that's a good point absolutely that's a good
[52:34] Speaker D (unidentified): point i have another thought too realistically where is all of this stuff being consumed and disposed of this is a very small community of old-time residents who use a dump right isn't it mostly hotels restaurants that are disposing of this stuff in the big green bin there and then
[52:58] Speaker B (unidentified): the public sphere i mean we have in the summertime the beach everything is take out and it all ends up in the trash cans and for public works to take care of and pick up and they we do have cardboard box containers down at the beach, and we do have bottles. They are separating that down, as I recall, and general trash. They have a pizza box, cardboard. And so the town is making an effort. When I travel around, I do certain things. I like to see when i can take out you know you know who uses the you know biodegradable plastic and the biodegradable straws i have to take more plastic out and what type of containers my goods are served and i you know i see other communities i did what last summer i was in provincetown they have they don't allow any plastic bottles they've gone to this cardboard covered white container for water. Straws are now biodegradable there. They take their shoreline and the sea life, you know, if anything goes into the ocean, they take that extremely seriously. And so other communities that are coastal communities do a much better job but then we're able to hear so i think that a little bit of research to go forward you know seeing what other communities that are identical have the same implications being along the coast you know what we would benefit from what they've learned yeah so
[54:47] Speaker A (unidentified): this i did i did notice even hannaford's now if you go to the hot bar that which i do sometimes
[54:56] Speaker B (unidentified): times you know some spirits i don't want a whole thing of spirits there's not a couple
[55:01] Speaker A (unidentified): you know what i mean that's now in cardboard right it is absolutely in cardboard and i wash it and i put it in with my cardboard recycling and throw it in the cardboard so i would think that would be doable i like amy i'm thinking like at the beach that's really where there's just slews of it just so much that gets thrown out that feels easy that you could just make that cardboard and have a cardboard cut like they have a pizza I it I love all this thinking and I think baby steps is not a bad thing necessarily but yeah it's just I don't that's just where i'm coming from i have also i spent some time in central america in belize costa rica and those places i go for diving and it's amazing how little waste they have they you cannot get a bottle of water or soda or juice or anything in plastic they're all in glass bottles glass bottles and then when you finish your in every place there's there's milk cartons old-fashioned milk cartons and when you finish your drink you put your bottle in there they sanitize it at work and first my daughter and i were like
[56:38] Speaker B (unidentified): you know it we never got sick we you know up until the 60s or 70s everything was in glass
[56:46] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah and they sterilized it and they reused it there were no paper menus there were there was no paper you used the qr code for a menu there was just no paper anywhere really conscious but you know you're you're a rainforest here you gotta protect it so i don't want to give it up completely, especially if it can be cardboard and that could be separated out and put into cardboard. They actually get paid for cardboard at the Dome. Yeah. Oh, excellent. So if that's what it is.
[57:31] Speaker E (unidentified): Do they accept it now? I don't know.
[57:33] Speaker A (unidentified): If that's what it is, does it have to be corrugated? I don't know. But I've put mine in there.
[57:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I don't know if it's depending on the paper itself. A lot of the papers used in shipping today is basically the same as cardboard and composed the same as cardboard. So I know Amazon, when you get a shipment in the cardboard, that paper is cardboard. Cardboard, and if you get it in a regular shipping envelope, that shipping envelope is cardboard.
[58:20] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, it might be worth asking, that's what you said, I'm saying, Liz, to see, because I don't know. He's a great guy. If food containers, whether they.
[58:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, because unless it's washed out.
[58:33] Speaker E (unidentified): containers that are cardboard right but do they have to be clean where they take that information i mean take the cardboard they probably have rules about what where if food has been in it you know where i used to live you can't we take all kinds of cardboard but it can't have food in it beforehand so just because where they bring it won't accept it so again it and then it ends up just getting broken out so it feels good when you're putting it in there but if it doesn't end up where you want it to end up it's it's not it's not beneficial so it's just good to check it i will and he likely doesn't know
[59:21] Speaker C (unidentified): he would find that true but the and the only plastic bottles that i use are returnable
[59:31] Speaker A (unidentified): so right i'm not sure what happens to them then i don't like to think about it but
[59:36] Speaker C (unidentified): i don't know but i know that the town gets a nickel for every one of them i know oh i know
[59:43] Speaker A (unidentified): oh i know yeah no i 'm aware that of course there's still the issue of drinking the plastic
[59:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. And again, it makes over $65,000 a year on returnables. Is that right? Yeah. Very good. Well, most of it is wine bottles. It's what? Wine bottles. Wine bottles.
[1:00:11] Speaker E (unidentified): So I think it could be a good first step, but there could be more. Do you go to the dumps? Yeah.
[1:00:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Chris, ask Chris. He's sweet as pie, and he'll figure it out. He really will figure it out. Whatever questions you have, run in and ask him. Have we had any hands raised, or do we even have anybody watching us?
[1:00:41] Speaker E (unidentified): No, there's no one on Zoom. I wait. All right.
[1:00:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else have anything to think about today? except what happened last night. I digress. I think we're doing great. I'm excited. I'm excited that we're even getting out of our confines here and getting more involved with our adjoining communities. That was exciting.
[1:01:21] Speaker B (unidentified): question yeah the pollinator pathway survey that they sent oh yeah something that we should discuss and perhaps fill out as a whole together or do we want to get involved and be on that
[1:01:36] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah some sort of a list and will it be endless that's the other it's a it's a simple survey it is a simple survey so this came from the pollinator pathway just simply another place so I am a member like Audubon and everywhere else and they are asking us to is your community doing something unique to protect pollinators we want to hear all about it 's short a five to ten minute survey why are we asking compiling a comprehensive list of all local level or ordinances blah if it's easy i mean it's 10 minutes should we do it
[1:02:22] Speaker B (unidentified): jointly i'm happy to do that i suggest that we discuss this and go through the list and just check off what we are doing and put that down as a record for them and send it off yeah this is informal discussion as well as what is your first
[1:02:50] Speaker A (unidentified): and last name okay can i say i found good conservation patient sure probably not well
[1:02:59] Speaker B (unidentified): since i you know who you are maybe we can send this to each and every one of us i don't know what's the last name let's try it is that what okay go for it they're gonna want some
[1:03:13] Speaker A (unidentified): kind of email when you signed up for the main this is just pollinator pathways right but the main one that you signed up for how did you sign up under your name yes to the main conservation
[1:03:25] Speaker B (unidentified): it's difficult to get information sent to the conservation commission in general we tried that with Audubon, and I never even heard back regarding how to join as a group. So I joined a couple of years ago, and Wendy joined this year, just because it was suggested that we as a commission join, and we did so. Okay. so we each get individual no you know brochures to her and this one came to her yeah the autobahn comes to me and she gets it as well because we're both individuals we didn't know
[1:04:15] Speaker A (unidentified): how to do it as permission but i would get permission to spend fifty dollars or something
[1:04:21] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah yes it is ridiculous it's prohibitive to try to do it any other way okay native plan ordinance. Oh, okay. Are you filling it up? No, I can read it out loud if you want. Okay, so what state are we located? Maine.
[1:04:46] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm reading what is the name of your city, town, or neighborhood?
[1:04:51] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, so you'll be on that. Okay. Host the Palliative Pathways Community protection and peace of the campus. Well, actually, we're not, many of them.
[1:05:12] Speaker A (unidentified): I can do this as a human, not as conservation. I can't really.
[1:05:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Let's just go through this. Let me read it out loud. So many United States municipalities or state counties have ordinances, permanent local law, resolutions, formal declarations of policy programs or initiatives in place that directly or indirectly protect pollinators. These can include local pesticide restrictions, bans, especially, oh boy, a scientific word, neo...
[1:05:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, yeah, that is an herb. A neo...
[1:05:57] Speaker B (unidentified): I can't remember how it's called.
[1:05:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Those are the really bad things. Okay, bad things.
[1:06:02] Speaker B (unidentified): organic land management programs native plant ordinances distribution of native seed
[1:06:08] Speaker A (unidentified): we don't have a native plant ordinance no
[1:06:10] Speaker B (unidentified): distribution of native seed mixes etc we are curious if your community has any of the following impact by them we do not have a native plant
[1:06:22] Speaker A (unidentified): ordinance we have guidelines for resolution
[1:06:25] Speaker B (unidentified): native plant policies we have guidelines for resolution
[1:06:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Evasive plant ban or restrictions. Yes, they're in the, done away doing that right now. I mean in the park. Ban or restrictions on specific pesticides. Pesticide-free parks.
[1:06:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Community gardens and or organic land management program.
[1:06:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Sort of. I mean, they still spray the houses, but it's organic. organic.
[1:06:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Managed natural landscapes are pollinator gardens, except for local vegetation restrictions. You should by restricting, registering your pollinator garden within a city. Well, we're trying to do that. Native pre-protections. Yes. Pollinator-friendly solar standards. and we don't have mass distribution of native seed mixes. Earth Day! [Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, we did.] We've invested in that and we will in the springtime continue to spread the spread the native seeds.
[1:07:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Adopt a spot, adopt a planter, or adopt a pot program. We haven't really done that. We let people take it home and have it at their own house. That's a great idea.
[1:07:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Partnership programs with schools, churches, or youth organizations to create a maintained pollinator habitat. Wonderful ideas. Perhaps you could take that into the school. And I'm not sure what policies my community has in place to protect pollinators. We're not. If yes answered to any of the above, please provide details if possible. So that's what's going on.
[1:08:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, they got enough details up there. Do you know of anything unique happening in your community being done to protect pollinators or native transfer that we have not included in our list? I don't. What do you see as the biggest threats to pollinators? Or roadblocks. Yeah. Apathy. Should we say apathy? Yeah. Well, what do you think? Yeah. I just think... I hear a lot that they don't want bees in their yard. I hear that. What
[1:09:00] Speaker D (unidentified): don't they want? They don't want bees. Oh, come on.
[1:09:06] Speaker A (unidentified): The bees are so busy pollinating that they never... You're not their father. I have pollinated plants all around me. I have bees too. And they never come near me because they're very busy.
[1:09:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Bees and bumblebees? Yes.
[1:09:20] Speaker A (unidentified): i don't know the sneak books oh i hate staying fun all right i'm gonna look at this before i
[1:09:29] Speaker B (unidentified): send it yeah absolutely but that's what's that's what's going on in the world of pollinating concerns it's a true story yeah thank you for i you know i think that's important to share here. Rick, are
[1:09:46] Speaker A (unidentified): we done? I think so. I think so. Is anybody particularly interested in writing ordinances? That's a question. I'm happy to try. I know nothing. I will just pick on Tyler and he'll be fine. He'll be fine. He will be fine. Or Freddie.
[1:10:15] Speaker B (unidentified): no oh it depends on what you're talking about but that's something you know maybe two minds should work together here to work on because i'm happy to be one of them anybody else want to help with
[1:10:29] Speaker A (unidentified): that everybody you know think about what you want to do be ready next time to say okay i decided yeah good excellent awesome and we're seven we are still seven i'm loving it i'm loving it 's a first for me i've been on this for years and you've never been full ever this is exciting seven good did i only miss one month i feel like i've been here so long i you did miss it's a couple i think so because i heard i knew it but how long have you been here like i haven't seen you who are you last month yeah i think i just messed up yeah i think you were yeah for a minute we had his wife also or they both applied she's on points and rights but we only had one seat one could be an alternate one could have been an alternate and we have
[1:11:33] Speaker B (unidentified): interest also audrey has someone who attended the meeting and she's apparently still highly interested so perhaps we have an alternate it's always good to have an alternate one and
[1:11:45] Speaker A (unidentified): there's at least one of us missing about that okay so do we make connection to the jerk Eric, you adjourned? I seconded.
[1:11:56] Speaker B (unidentified): George, how do you? Yes. Yes. Amy Kelley, yes.
[1:12:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Lacey and Crockett, yes. Joanna Pettigrew, yes. Jeff, I'm sorry, yes. Sandy Levine, yes.