Waldo County Budget Committee Reviews 2027 Health Benefits and Budget Adjustments
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): I call to order the Waldo County Budget Committee on October 30th of 2026 at 6 p.m. Roll call. Mary Mortier. Elizabeth Lenhardt. Linda Payson. Ian Silver. Lori Greely. Sandy Cameron. All right, let's review the minutes of October 16th and 17th.
[0:23] Speaker B (unidentified): You missed me on roll call. Sorry.
[0:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Brandi Bridges. Thank you, Brandi.
[1:30] Speaker C (unidentified): Laura, I guess I have one. On October 16th, on the very last page, motion out really requested the county's general fund balance and K-Con referred the committee to the 2024 audit for this information and so we didn't have the 24 audit so i don't know if carrie had said referred me to the audit three years ago to get the general fund balance or if he said 24 a mistake i'd have to go back and listen to it because i'm not sure so either way it would be incorrect because we weren't given the 24 out i we i couldn't go back and look that's my point at the 24 audit
[2:23] Speaker D (unidentified): was it maybe 23 and it's a typo that's at least i remember saying 24 and i remember the look at the audits i don't know if it's available on the state website and i'm not sure if it's on our it's not on our website okay and i haven't been given the final audit yet yeah i was assuming
[2:49] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, maybe it was a mistake. I watched the commissioner's meeting, the last one, when he was presenting at least a rough draft.
[2:56] Speaker E (unidentified): That was the 24 audit. Yes.
[2:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, and so I don't have the final audit from him.
[3:03] Speaker C (unidentified): So just an error there. Okay.
[3:13] Speaker F (unidentified): I'd like to make a motion if we accept the amended minutes for the October 16th meeting. I second.
[3:27] Speaker A (unidentified): All in favor? Yes. Okay. Okay. Motion to accept the October 17th minutes.
[4:32] Speaker F (unidentified): Motion to accept the minutes as presented.
[4:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. All in favor? Okay. Employee benefits, which is $20.25.
[5:07] Speaker G (unidentified): First and foremost, I have behind me Bucky Bannigan, who is a broker from Paulson Insurance. And he's going to come up here and do a presentation to kind of go over the difference between being fully in charge versus being self-funded. He's going to talk a little bit about stop-loss, and he's going to say how we found the numbers for our estimates for the benefits for 2027.
[6:25] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, thanks, everybody, for joining. My name is Bucky Gahagan. I work for Cross Insurance. insurance. I've been in the insurance business since 1989. So I've been doing this for a long time. Wanted to go through, as Tracy said, kind of went to the difference between fully insured and self-funded. And if we're going, I mean, I don't mind you just asking questions. I like to keep my meetings very informal. So please ask away. So essentially this side-by-side, I know it's hard to read up there, but it's very hard to read. That's as big as I can get. it here but essentially what we're going to talk about is what's fully insured and what's self-funded a fully insured plan is where you pay an insurance company they assume all the risk you pay every month and then at the end of the year if your claims are good then you get a good increase if your claims are bad then you're going to get you know a much higher premium increase that's essentially what it is insurance company takes on all the risk for the claims but again at the end of the year you are you know still held to what your claims are the other thing too with fully insured is you do have to adhere to all the state mandates on that and there are a lot of them in maine and then any leftover funds if you have a really good year then those funds stay with the insurance company you get zero monies back okay self-funded you are basically self-funding your plan so you're paying the claims as they come in and as they go you hire a third party administrator which would be likely the insurance company to manage those claims so as claims go into you go to the doctor the claim gets submitted to the third party administrator they process it just like an anthem or an app or harvard whoever it is and they basically you are funding those claims you can design your plans however you want to so there's a lot of freedom with designing your plan you don't have to adhere to all the state mandated benefits at the end of the year if you have monies left over then it stays in your bank account right that's the essential big difference here you can kind of see it a little bit more where again you're paying the premiums carrier takes on all the risk self-funded and you're taking on part of the risk and we'll talk about stop loss you hire a third-party administrator really that's just a company to manage your claims Most of the third-party administrators we work with are typically owned by Anthem, Aetna, Harvard, Cigna anyway. So like your current one, Maritain, they're actually owned by Aetna. So we have access to Aetna's network across Maine and the country. Stop-loss insurance, I think, is a very important part of self-funding. So the financial risk that you're bearing from a fully insured plan, again, carrier absorbs all the risk. unused premiums they keep renewals depending on how you're running your rates can be increased or remain the same or on very rare occasions you can see that they can be decreased but one thing I will mention in Maine and across the country we all know the cost of care is continuing to go up we're finding it much more so in Maine very rural state not a lot of competition so the cost of care continues to rise. With a self-funded plan, you basically have the ability to design your plan, as I mentioned, however you want to. From the self-funded piece of it, 's, again, you pay as you go. So if you have good claims in a month, good claims two months, three months, you're not paying out of your bank account. Unlike a fully insured plan, you're paying the premiums every single month. Stop loss, you buy stop loss insurance. So there's two aspects of stop-loss insurance. There's individual stop-loss, which basically would say that the County of Waldo is going to choose an individual deductible. And for us, it's $130,000. And that basically says that the County of Waldo is responsible for the first $130,000 of any claim. Once it reaches $130,000, we bought stop-loss insurance that picks up anything from the $130,001 all the way up to, it doesn't matter, it's unlimited, right? Part of the ACA is you can't have caps anymore. So it's unlimited. So the insurance company takes care of those. We are seeing a lot more high cost claims in general, more cancers, high prescriptions with the biosimilars biologics that are out there. So again, these are just components that are driving our costs. The other insurance that you buy is called aggregate insurance. What that protects you is if you have a combined claims under $130,000, that hits a maximum liability because the insurance company says, all right, we're going to basically say, here's your maximum claims liability. And if you pay up to that, which is all claims under $130,000, then again, they're going to pick up any claim thereafter all the way up to another million dollars on your behalf. So that's what stop-loss insurance does for you. Fully insured, again, carriers taking on all the risk. There is no stop-loss because they're taking on the risk to do that.
[12:02] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes. With stop-loss though, I mean, something that we discussed at length last year was that there's a lag between when those happen and when we receive the reimbursement for the stop-loss. That's correct. And we don't, we can't exactly predict how long it will take. That's
[12:17] Speaker H (unidentified): That's right. Yeah, a lot of that, and that's a great point and a great question. With stop-loss, once somebody hits that $130,000, then all the claims that come in, the third-party administrator is basically putting those in, we'll call it an envelope, and they're giving it to the stop-loss insurance company to review. They have to make sure all the documentation is there, the doctor's notes, the bills, and all of that. So sometimes that can take a little bit longer. Some of them or cut and dry it all depends on the complexity of the claims at hand but on the front end
[12:50] Speaker E (unidentified): we're responsible if it was a two hundred thousand dollar bill we're paying that and we're waiting
[12:54] Speaker H (unidentified): for the 70 to come back no you pay up to the 130 000 yep and there is a threshold that all stop-loss carriers have even once you hit that some small claims might come in usually it's up to the next five thousand dollars that you could have to fund those are still going to be reimbursed but they just don't they won't fund any small claims until they hit a threshold so once it hits the threshold then they cut you a check same thing you know if there are more small claims come in you pay those until it hits the threshold and then you get reimbursed as well so you know that is a little bit of a of a downside of self-funding but the bigger thing is you know If you design a plan, you have good claims, you win in the long run for that. Again, I know this is really hard to read, but essentially all we're saying is that, as I mentioned, the county wall chose a deductible of $130,000. Now, if you lower that deductible to $100,000 or to $80,000, all that really does is increase your premium to the insurance company. And we thought that this was a pretty good medium. This was a really good area for us to be at because it reduced our fixed costs and the banking on the fact that statistically 92% of us don't even hit $1,500 in a calendar year. We're kind of betting on the fact that there's not going to be many that hit the $130,000. One thing I did want to point out, and I don't know why that is up there. Is that mine or yours? Oh, it's gone. One thing I want to point out, it's hard to read it in the second bullet down, but the premiums for the aggregate piece of it, so that's the piece that if you hit your maximum liability, we call that sleep insurance. It allows you to sleep at night because if you did have a lot of claims that added up over time, which I've seen this, once you hit that max liability, then everything is reimbursed. If you look at the third bullet down, for the county of Waldo, for our renewal that we're looking at for January 1, maximum claims liability is $2.443 million. That's a function of our claims that we've had, the trends that are in the marketplace, our plan design comes into play when they're setting these dollars. That's our maximum claims. If, by chance, every claim, $130,000 and less, hit that liability, then anything over is reimbursed up to another million dollars. They build in a margin of about 25%, so they expect you to be 25% below that. And statistically, again, only 4% of companies ever hit their maximum claims liability. So the insurance company is protecting themselves some for that catastrophic or the 100-year flood, we call it. But this was exactly what our numbers were looking like. These numbers will change as you enroll more people or people leave and come off the plan. Those will fluctuate during the year. But that's where we were looking at this point in time. And again, any leftover funds at the end of the year, it stays with your bank account. So some of the key advantages of being fully insured, highly predictable, budgetable, simple to administer because you're paying the same premiums every month based on the enrollment. If there's any big claims that come up, you don't have to worry about them. It's basically just you're paying your premiums, the insurance company is taking on all of that risk. Self-funded, the pros, lower long-term overhead, tailored to plan design, so again we can design our plan however we want to. Exemptions from most state premium taxes under ERISA. And then self-funded plans, you do have the ability to get more claims information to help you design the plan and help maybe steer people to centers of excellence, lower cost facilities, things like that. Some of the critical takeaways or trade-offs from being fully insured is you have a higher baseline cost. So the administrative costs and what they charge you is going to be higher than self-funding because they know they're taking on all the risk. You are restricted to the plan designs that they offer. There's a little bit of flexibility with some of the carriers, but for the majority of them, it's pretty cut and dry that you can't waver from the plan designs that they offer. No financial return when you have good years. Again, self-funded. One of the cons is cash flow, because if you have zero claims in the first three months, and then all of a sudden a half a million dollars comes in and claims, well, you fund those, right? That's how it works. Big thing is at the end of the year, you have the money's back. So the middle ground level funded plans are out there too, and we will look at those when we can. That gives you kind of and in between. Plan design, they're still pretty much the same as a fully insured plan, but at the end of the year, they basically review your claims. And if there's a surplus, you can get up to 50% back. The administrative cost, though, for a level-funded plan is close to 50%. So when we look at those plans, I always tell my clients, I know you heard me say you might get some money back, but don't plan on it. Think of it as a bonus at the end of the year. If you doesn't happen very often just because that level funded piece they are taking on all that risk those costs tend to be lower than a fully insured plan because it is self-funded if that makes if that makes sense so this was i mean there's no reason to be able to read that this is exactly what i do behind the scenes to help develop the rates to present to your team here years and basically it's broken out by two sections the top section is your fixed cost fixed cost would be your premium for your specific deductible that you have to pay right that's the insurance for that specific deductible you're paying the premiums for the aggregate that sleep insurance then you have your admin is paying that third party administrator to manage your claims. Included in that is case management, prior authorizations. You also have, depending on the third-party administrator, is the pharmacy benefit manager. So who manages your prescriptions? Those are included in that. One thing that's not shown right there, but there are some required payments that you have to make being self-funded in Maine anyway, like the Megara fee that you have to pay, the quarry fee you have to pay as well, those, I always put those at the bottom because they fluctuate depending on the year, and I'll throw them into our fixed costs, so the fixed costs are all those things that I talked about, right, those add up to about 20% of your total cost, right, 80% of your cost is claims, which is the bottom section, and how the insurance world, the stop-loss companies, or the fully insured plans, set their rates or set their factors, is reviewing your demographics, which is your employees, how old are they, male, female, where do you live in the state, what's your plan design, and then they basically say, based on that information, plus your historical claims data that we can get, they come up with what they believe your plan will run on an expected basis,. And then they add their margin in for that hundred year flood, right? That's the bottom section. That's the part that you have control over. Control over by educating your employees on the tools and resources that are out there to help them be a consumer of care. And there are a lot of them. Plan design. You can design your plan however you want to, line by line by line. It really doesn't matter. We've been very creative with some of our other clients in sending people to centers of excellence for things like joint replacement. You know, I can give you an example. A joint replacement in Bangor is around $60,000. I have clients that send people down to New England Baptist, right? It's $24,000. Why would they do that? Because New England Baptist does the most in New England, and their quality is better, and their costs are better. Now, that's a double-edged sword. I live in Bangor. I grew up in Carewood. We have a big hospital system. You still want to support them, right? Right. But at the end of the day, they are not able to be as competitive. And some of our clients are saying we can't afford we can't afford our costs. So we need to be creative in doing that. They don't make people go there. They give them they give them the carrot. If you go to Boston, for instance, for that joint replacement, then our plan will cover it at 100 percent. You pay zero. So, again, plan design wise, we can do all kinds of creativity to help. get at that 80 of the of the of your cost that's pretty much so can you explain speaking
[22:24] Speaker G (unidentified): of that 80 can you talk about what it looks like when you're going out to bid with these fully insured companies and what they're looking at some of the challenges yes so to go to market
[22:34] Speaker H (unidentified): we have your census information which is who is on your plan now they also want to know who's waiving coverage because those people could join our plan. And then they want your plan design. They want your claims experience. And they evaluate it just like any insurance company would. And they determine based on where we are today, because we have to provide them with current rates. I will tell you the insurance world now, the carriers are asking even for the renewal. rule. They want to see exactly what the renewal is before they will issue a quote. From my perspective, I think that's very cool, but an insurance commissioner needs to take care of that. And that's every single insurance company. So they evaluate it and they basically say, yeah, this is a good risk. Yeah, it looks like we can be competitive. So here's our rate. Or, unfortunately, no, your claim's too high, we can't match your plan design, and we can't be competitive through what you're currently paying or you're removing. And that's what we face every month with every client every year. And it's constant. Some are good and some are not. Some carriers won't be competitive one year. The next year, you send them the information, and all of a sudden, they're competitive. so it is one of these things that we have to watch every, when we watch your claims every month, that's our job behind the scenes, to be prepared to send it out to market. which we, which we do now, the other, the other thing I'll point out too, it's not advantageous to go up to market every single year either because the insurance companies say, Oh, County of Waldo again. Now, last year I was really competitive. They took my numbers. They gave it to their incumbent. They didn't come with me. Year two goes by, well, we'll try it again. Well, we're pretty competitive. Same scenario. They didn't come to us. Year three comes by, and they'd be like, County of Waldo, we're going to set them right over here for right now. We're not going to provide a quote. Or we will just decline. I've seen them do that. Tough thing in Maine, we have five insurance carriers that do the full insurer. Anthem, Aetna, Harvard, Cigna, Community Health Options, they have six, and UnitedHealthcare. That's who the players are in Maine. And that's it. So, you know, it's tough. It's really tough. You know, this has been the first renewal year since I've been doing this. And the renewals are very, high. I can tell you I've had four two weeks ago, 48 percent, 39, 37, 28. And carriers aren't potent. I send it all out and they decline,, decline,. client you know so we're at the mercy really of the marketplace where we are i think you have more opportunity being a self-funded plan than you do fully insured because you can design a plan you can build in the incentives for people to go to centers of excellence or provide the educational opportunities with the tools and resources to help again get some of those small hanging fruit that are out there you know and i get it i see it every day i deal with claims every day when people are sick they want to be better and i totally get that and we're not we wouldn't ask anybody to go to boston if you don't feel good you know go get your services done but if you have something that you can go and you can think about it and you can plan it an mri cat scan there are all kinds of independent facilities throughout new england in Maine,, especially we're getting a lot of more companies doing that in Maine, freestanding labs, lab work. You go to Quest Lab in Bangalore and you get a lab done there. You go to the hospital lab, it's four or five times more expensive for the same exact lab. And I see that day in and day out. So we try to give folks that education on where you need to go. up. Some of my clients will even go as far as saying, hey, we're self-funded. We're all putting money into the same bucket, right? When money comes out of that bucket at the end of the year, if more money comes out than what was put in, then we would expect a large increase. So our goal collectively with our team at whatever company is to use the tools and resources that we have in the plan design to try to mitigate some of those legal problems. If somebody has, unfortunately,, cancer, then we want them to get care. Then we want them to go to the cancer care in Brewer. Absolutely. But if there are things that you can do and you have a choice, that's kind of what our strategy is, just to try to beat medical trend. Medical trend right now is around 10%. Pharmacy trend is 14. That's year in and year out. Everything you see on TV for commercials, those are all specialty medications. Humira, Stelara, Emeril. My wife was on Humira. It's $5,000 a month for two shots, right? There's Yosemite that's out there now. It's a biosimilar. It's $670 a month, right? So we try to get people to say, well, okay, maybe you should consider moving from Humira to Yosemite, Stelara to their biosimilar they have. because if they stay on those medications those that all that money comes out of our bucket that makes sense so any questions at all i mean it's it's complicated but it's not right i mean we know that you're putting money into a bucket and if more money comes out then it's we're all it's like if you have auto insurance and you get five speeding tickets you're probably going to get an increase right it's sort of the same with health care but there isn't but there are a lot of things that we can do behind the scenes if we're allowed to if that makes sense laura
[28:43] Speaker A (unidentified): hi i
[28:44] Speaker C (unidentified): have a question i'm trying to understand the stop loss insurance so the individual deductible is for say i am in an accident or something it will the county would have to pay up to the first 130 000 and then after that the stock loss would kick in the county once i reach that 130 on the individual deductible the county does not need to pay above that 130 that's the liability
[29:22] Speaker H (unidentified): But there are times, as I mentioned, there's a little delta that, depending on how the claims come in, if they come in less than $5,000, then the stop-loss carrier will have you pay them. And then they're gathering those, and they know that you're going to get them reimbursed. Once that claim has been approved, and then they send that, say, $5,000 in, it's a pretty quick turnaround. Okay. It's just more that once you get to the $5,000, they go through all the information to make sure that it is approved, and then they pay the bigger piece of it. Some of the smaller ones that come in after, there can be that little bit of delay in time, which I think you brought up exactly correct, that can be a little bit of a nuisance.
[30:04] Speaker G (unidentified): I also mentioned the deductible. The deductible for the stop-loss.
[30:09] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, that's exactly what she mentioned, the $130,000.
[30:11] Speaker G (unidentified): The additional aggregate deductible.
[30:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I was going to ask that one next. So that's like collectively.
[30:18] Speaker H (unidentified): You could pay that on one person or you could pay it on several or you could never pay it. So and what it is, it's a $70,000. I call it's a gamble, but it really isn't because it's a dollar for dollar trade off for your premiums. So you've got your $130,000 deductible that you've set. Then what we go to the stop loss carrier and say, OK, we want an aggregating specific. Pacific. And they'll say, what would you like? OK, we want another $70,000. OK, perfect. They take $70,000 right off our fixed costs. And we hope that maybe we won't tap into that. But if we do, at the end of the day, we would have paid it in fixed premiums anyway versus claims as it goes are on the way. I've got some clients that really like that. And I have some that said, you know, we just we want to pay our dollar amount and that's it. Once we hit that, then we don't want any other liability for anybody else just each person if that makes sense for that and again I like it because it's a dollar for dollar trade-off and I would rather not give the insurance company premium dollars because I've never had an insurance company give me a suitcase full of money to bring back to my clients you don't get those monies back by gambling a little bit if you have to pay it out you would have paid it in fixed cost anyway.
[31:38] Speaker C (unidentified): So everyone doesn't have that. It's a choice. I would think. Okay. All right. What
[31:48] Speaker H (unidentified): else? Fire some questions off.
[31:55] Speaker I (unidentified): How do you go about establishing an incentive plan with whoever is managing? I mean, obviously, there's a lot of production and media information, websites that employees could go to. I mean, there's some pretty significant development and upfront costs to put this out to a group of employees. Or is there already pre-designed suggestions that you offer to different people for these type of incentive plans? And it sounds like it's a shifting target with the different costs and the different medical facilities that are available. So how do you manage all that? It really is.
[32:38] Speaker H (unidentified): And it's kind of twofold, right? Take GoodRx, for instance. Everybody's heard of GoodRx, the app that you use for pharmacy. That is a great app. You can go on the website, type in your prescription, your zip code, your dose. It'll tell you all the pharmacies in that area and what they would normally charge. So we educate folks on using that. Anybody can download the app, right? But then every insurance company also has behind the scenes tools and resources that they make available. So for instance, Maritain, their website, they basically have the ability to go online, sign in and get your own login information. And you can probably shop things around as well. You know, I need a lab. Well, they have a cost and comparison tool. You can type in, I need this lab. Oh, where should I go? there's concierge services out there that you can bolt on to your plan being self-funded that you can have your employees call hey I'm they're telling me I need an MRI on my knee and I heard this insurance guy say you know I shouldn't go to the hospital MRI facility are there any freestanding around they'll look it right up I'm diagnosed I gotta have heart surgery I'd like a second opinion in Boston can you help me pick somebody right you can do that on the pharmacy side it's really working with the good rx's of the world and the pharmacy benefit manager and some of them out there are pretty darn good where they have levers that they can pull for instance they can their technology is getting to the point where at point of sale you go in to the pharmacy it'll recognize that there's a coupon available and you will automatically get the coupon price you don't have to search for it anymore on good rx right the technology and those things are building over time. So to answer your question, is it hard? We don't make it the normal things if you're sick and you go to the doctor because you don't feel good. No, we want people to do that. But if you have something that you can think about, an MRI, CAT scan, and it's not an emergency situation, then we try to give folks the option to shop around. I mean, we shop around for everything else in this world. and we're on our phones under Amazon and we're going to buy a TV, we'll shop the heck out of that thing. But when it comes to our own health, we won't do the same, you know. And it's tough. It's hard to get people to do it.
[35:00] Speaker I (unidentified): I guess human nature to me is that you go to your doctor, your doctor says you've got to get this done. And usually the doctor will recommend who you need to go to or where you go and their office will schedule it for you. most people aren't in the mood to search around and question the doctor where they're sending them so how do you build that sort of incentive because the patient works with the doctor that's personal relationship and typically you don't want to break into that by trying to send them someplace else or suggest or even have them question where the doctor will help you just follow the doctor's advice you're right so how do you build that into your insurance program where or your claims process so that the patient feels that they have the power to decide where they want to go and what they want to do.
[35:48] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, sure. So it goes right back to, like I said, the carrot approach. You look at your plan design, it has a deductible. You know, your plan here, the one that we have right now, it doesn't, but 99% of plans have a deductible to me. And what we would say is that if you needed that MRI,, instead of running to the hospital MRI, where your doctor is telling you to go, because they're an employee of that hospital system, they're trying to drive revenue through their whole system, which I totally understand that. But you say, look, if you're willing to call this number, have them help you schedule your appointment, you can get that for free just across town in Bangalore at First MRI, right? Well, the First MRI is actually in Northern Light, but it's things like that. It's not every single item out there. It's some of the things that can really make a difference. It's thousands of dollars for an MRI, or you can get it for $1,000 versus paying $3,000. And if it's going towards your deductible as a consumer, then I would much rather go to the place where I might be paying $600 versus $2,500, because I've got to pay that out of my pocket.
[36:56] Speaker I (unidentified): care so do our consumers right now have a deductible no so there's no incentive for
[37:02] Speaker E (unidentified): they will for next year but that deductible amount sorry if i may is going to be less than the cost of an mri probably at most places so i don't know how much of a carrot that is if you're if you're managing a four to six thousand dollar deductible then you're then you're thinking about these things but if you're if your deductible is a thousand dollars or something like that you 've eaten it up in the first thing that your doctor refers you to
[37:25] Speaker H (unidentified): too, really. Right. And our state of Maine plan has a little bit higher on pocket maximum. So again, you can kind of, even though the deductible is a little lower, you can still give them that choice because you know they're going to pay the deductible. But then there's the co-insurance. They still have to pay up to that maximum out of pocket. So if the education is there that you can go to certain places for certain things, that would be less than absolutely. Absolutely. And then I know we've introduced an HSA, a high deductible health savings account plan. I would say probably 90 percent of my clients have those. Those are great plans. Going back to what I said, the 92 percent of us don't even hit fifteen hundred dollars in a calendar year. If you make that plan from a premium perspective, more incentive to choose. and then you fund some of those HSA dollars on the first year or two for the members to build up some money, HSA dollars roll over from year to year to year. Well, I might be a smarter consumer to say, this is my money. And my employer is saying, hey, if I go get the MRI over here, I don't have to pay anything. I don't have to have anything come out of my bucket. And that bucket rolls over from year to year to year, and I can build it up and build it up over time. So when I do have a big claim, I've got all the money there. My employer can put money in. I can put money in. It's all pre-tax. It rolls over from year to year. Money in the account, you can use for my own expenses as the employee or any qualified dependent, even if they're not covered under my plan. You can use it for dental vision. It's a really, good tool. And again,, I go back to what I see year in and year out is a handful of folks usually are the ones that are sick during the year. It's not many in a population. The majority are less. So, again, if you can get people to understand the value of that and what it means and how easy that money can grow over time and what they can use it for. and if it's less money out of their paycheck again when we do employee meetings sometimes people ask first thing what's coming out of my paycheck what's my prescription benefit they don't really worry too much about the $4,000 or $5,000 max out of pocket because they know that the likelihood of them hitting that is not going to happen year over year. A person has a hospital stay once every 10 years, statistically, so.
[40:07] Speaker I (unidentified): What's our demographics look like? Is there statistics for our customers?
[40:13] Speaker H (unidentified): You mean for the county?
[40:16] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, do we have an idea of where we're at? Are we mainly in a bolder crowd with an expected higher expense, or are we somewhere in the middle?
[40:25] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't have the data right here, but I think the last time I looked at it, that you are a little bit under what the state average is so that's not a bad thing which is a good thing you know you have a high male population too so that's you know in the world of insurance that's a good thing too the bad thing is guys don't go until they're really sick right then the claims are bigger but the reality is over time the majority of us don't don't need it hopefully not only all knock on wood but that's what insurance is there for you know and I go back to what I said before why would I want to pay a premium for no deductible plan when I'm never going to use it versus if my employer is willing to give me some money into a bank account that I could use whenever I might need it over time then I think that most people if they understood how it really worked and there was enough premium difference then you would have the majority of your people move to that type of plan and i see i've seen it for years you know my plan at cross is an hsa and i've had it since i've been there you know and i fund it and fund it and i had heart surgery in 2021 i had enough money in there to cover my max out of pocket that year but no gum would i haven't had anything since and i really didn't have much before you know same thing with my family you know and are we lucky you know maybe but insurance is there for the people who need it which is i think we have a good plan for that but i think there's a lot of things that could be done too laura
[42:08] Speaker C (unidentified): so county employees have a max out of pocket we do okay and employees pay for the insurance each week.
[42:22] Speaker H (unidentified): So they do pay a portion of a portion.
[42:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. OK. And also, I was just wondering how many I heard the auditor say one of the commissioners asked for some comparison with other counties and heard him say that he didn't really have that because other counties aren't self-funded.
[42:45] Speaker H (unidentified): so do you cover other counties or do you i do the county of penobscot they're not self-funded
[42:51] Speaker C (unidentified): they're fully insured okay i mean self -funded ones do you do any others like us or
[42:58] Speaker H (unidentified): is no okay no i don't know how many others are self-funded either i think that again budget wise it's probably easier to have a fixed cost every single month but then the trade-off is you don't have the flexibility in the plan design. Fully insured, they still have all the tools and resources behind the scenes from an education perspective, but the design itself, you can't really design it the way that you can on a self-funded plan to incentivize people to go wherever. Now, you can get around that by choosing a very high deductible fully insured plan, let's say a $6,000 deductible people see six thousand dollars but there's also what they call health reimbursement arrangement out there and it's kind of like a self-funded piece of it that the employer can fund part of that deductible so i'll give you an example one of my clients has a six thousand dollar deductible they tell the employees you meet the first thousand dollars we'll pick up the next twenty five hundred we'll pick up the next three thousand and then on the back end if there's any more then you would pick that up that middle piece of it captures a few that go over that average so you can you can design that way too even in a fully insured world you just give up some of the really being able to steer people to the centers of excellence but it's still a good tool i've had clients with hras for 30 years and they work and they don't get rid of them they like it. The employees like it because we're banking on the fact that the premiums, the deductibles are higher. So the premiums are lower. And, you know, the employer taking on the risk of picking up some of that, it's not it's not a lot for that. Just before I came, I'll tell you real quick, I just did an analysis for one of my clients. I looked at all their deductibles and I added them all up. and I said if you your employees picked up the first two thousand dollars of your deductible and you paid the rest what would that cost you if for this group they have 65 employees on the plan it was 80,000 bucks to pick up and that was how many few people the average deductible for that group was thirteen hundred and sixty dollars right that was the average so again you had just a few that went over the deductible. So there's a lot of things that you can do plan design wise and you know having a plan with no deductible is you're the only client that has no deductible.
[45:37] Speaker E (unidentified): So the no deductible is changing though for next year. Correct. And the HSA is coming on for next year. Could you talk a little bit about how since you've been working with us like the process of sort of reviewing what we've had going on and the problems with it and then like helping us figure out where to go from here maybe because even one of the things you brought up was about going out to bid for example and that's something that the community is like what are you doing you're in this awful expensive self-funded plan and you know we did go out to bid again but then we hear there's a downside to that and so i don't know if that whole process is kind of interesting and maybe cue people in on like what we've been trying to do to change this moving forward where we're still not marketable to a lot of insurance.
[46:26] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I think I think you hit it right on the head is that we do go to market for you. We do go to the fully insured carriers to see if we can get a plan. And we do it two ways. One, maybe it's a better option for you from a budgeting perspective. But two, you also can use if you get a good rate, as I mentioned before, you can use it for leverage. right you if you were with a carrier you're you're hopeful that you don't have to move every year right that's a that's cost a lot of money to move and disruption to your employees so the idea is trying to get with a carrier to partner so our process behind the scene is we watch your claims every month and usually four months five months before the renewal date we start the process of gathering our information talking with the administration here looking at hey what would we like to quote for plan designs what do you think might work and you know we came up with the state of Maine plan I mean the state of Maine plan all the state employees have so why is that not a good plan I think it is a good plan and then I do think that having choice is also an important factor is giving people a choice to have more than just one option right and the HSA gives us that opportunity to give people choice so we do go to market and as i mentioned before if your claims are high or you have a fair number of high cost ongoing claims then the marketplace is looking at that as risk right they're in the profit they're in the business of managing risk and if they don't feel they can manage it any better than what you have, then they just decline, right? Or they might give you a rate. I can give you an example. I have one of those groups I talked about that had the 38% increase. Well, we went out to market, and we, lo and behold, we have Harvard Pilgrim that came in at 25. Now, 25 is still a big increase, but it's a heck of a lot better than 38, you know? And we'll use the 25 to leverage the 38. and they may say well we'll come down to 30 and then we collectively the client myself would have to say does it make sense to move you know and or do we just stick it out and pay it a little higher what are we giving up and what are we getting and we would do that when it's right but as i mentioned you just have to be careful about doing it every year you know some industries that's their business it's every single year bidding on product and insurance is a little bit different in that you can't go to market every year because there's too few carriers and again if they give you good rates a couple years in a row and you don't move to them you know then the underwriters aren't going to waste their time yeah they want they want to earn your business obviously but if they keep seeing you over and over and over and you do it every single year and you don't move to them then they just eventually say sorry we're just declined so
[49:27] Speaker G (unidentified): the bigger the bigger problem is when you're already fully insured and you just keep trying to shop around versus when we're just trying to get on to the fully insured no well it's kind
[49:38] Speaker H (unidentified): of both it's twofold even where we are now trying to get to fully insured is that still the right thing or is it not i mean if our claims are running really good then no maybe this is still the best thing you know again we would want to evaluate that based on the recommendations from your team and what your needs are and then we come up collectively with a strategy on how to market it what the plan designs are and you know hope that somebody gives us something but again fully insured i'm going right back to those groups that i were telling you about their renewals this year were really high because their claims were high you know and you know if they were self-funded, maybe they wouldn't get quite as big of an increase because it would be more in their expected claims liability versus the insurance company saying, we know that this is, we're taking on all this risk, so we're going to price for it. And, you know, sometimes it's, you know, do they want that business or did they not? Do they like that industry this year or do they not? and it's it can go year to year every couple years or but that 's essentially that's our job is to really work on your behalf to know the markets cross insurance is huge we're the largest in new england we have access to right to the underwriters and if there's something that we need for a favor then we'll ask and sometimes we get it that sometimes they you know they say look what you have we can't compete you know it's it is what it is and then we have to say well it's not doable anymore so what can we do with what we have and that's when we start to look at plan design incentives you know premium share hras hsas that approach laura
[51:33] Speaker C (unidentified): so how do we how do we get to a place then that fully insured would accept us if you know we're in a market where people are needing more care we have a lot of claims so many that we are not nobody wants to take us that just seems like that will continue how do we get out of this that would be one part and then if we did what is really the cost difference i mean what if right now we were fully insured is this you know is it a lot cheaper
[52:12] Speaker H (unidentified): than what we're looking at now what they're telling us is our increase this year was around 16 17 percent the insurance companies out there the fully insured are saying we can't compete with that well our rates would be higher so it's not necessarily lower it really it really depends and you know i think you brought up a good point how do you get there sometimes it's luck you hope that your claims stabilize versus having continuously you know big claims and so some of my clients are just unfortunate that they just can't seem to get out of that claim after claim after claim used to be cyclical every six seven years you'd have a bad claim for a year or two it would go back down you could shop around get better rates it doesn't seem to be quite that way now just because of the cost of these claims that are out there just the cost of care in general you know if you said 30 years ago what was a hip replacement well it wasn't sixty thousand dollars right so we're battling that it's all these new medications that are out there you know those are costly and you know that's what they look at too well you don't have a lot of big cancer claims but you've got several people who are on one of these very expensive medications and in your plan design i don't see any incentive for you to get them off it so we got to price it that way knowing that 's no risk right unless that person leaves we're going to be paying that meaning the insurance company is saying that so you just you kind of hope that you get to that point you know and i think i think if we could get to a fully insured plan to see how it goes i've had clients get to fully insured and it worked for several years but then their claims got really good and it was better for them to go back to cell phone you always can go back to it's not like you're stuck in one well it worked for like 15
[54:10] Speaker F (unidentified): years for waldo county exactly and then it very much didn't right so it's like it's like are you
[54:17] Speaker H (unidentified): in the 100-year flood right now and you know I will tell you it's starting to come up you know our claims are improved which is showing in our renewal here so is that a good thing yeah I think that 's a good thing and I think that if we change our plan designs we educate folks on the HSAs and we get people to move then we'll just see that continue and then we will have options you know to at least evaluate and you may say no I don't want to go ahead we kind of talked about
[54:46] Speaker J (unidentified): deductibles next year there's going to be do we have any numbers on the deductibles that will be
[54:52] Speaker H (unidentified): introduced next year yeah so we have it's an $800 individual deductible per person and it's two times that per family so $1,600 per family and once one person hits the $800 then co-insurance would kick in so they would pay 20% of the cost plan pays 80% until they hit their max out of pocket. I can't remember off the top of my head, 3750 what the max out of pocket is. So that's the maximum that employee would pay out of their pocket for just their own care, not including premiums, what they would spend in potential medical costs.
[55:31] Speaker G (unidentified): But then in the state of Maine plan, there's also HSA.
[55:34] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah. And the HSA plan, this was a really good plan. It's $2,000 deductible, but that's also your max out-of-pocket. So it's a lower maximum out-of-pocket than the state of Maine plan, right? And there's some funding that's going to be done into my HSA account. So does 800 seem crazy low? It's very low, yeah. In my world, the average deductible probably today is $3,500. So who came up with the $800 number? We took the state of Maine plan Because we felt that was a better leveraging position to present to your team to say, look, you have no deductible now. It's a copay plan to a very low out-of-pocket. To ask somebody to go to a $3,500 deductible, that's too drastic. Right. Right. And it didn't make sense. So introducing something with a little higher out-of-pocket, but also I think introducing the HSA with the generosity of how that was designed. mind. If I was an employee here, I would choose that HSA every day. It doesn't matter if I knew I was having something big come up, it's still $2,000. And under the other plan, it's $3,750. So why would I choose that plan? Yeah, if I go to the doctor because I don't feel good, I'm going to pay an office co-pay. Under HSA, I'm paying the full deductible. But there's telemedicine out there. Anybody heard of telemedicine, Teladoc, doctor on demand? van well you can have a virtual visit with a doctor from the convenience of your home we could call right from here tonight because they're extended hours it's around 55 to 60 dollars what's the cost to go to your primary care doctor for a sick visit anybody had one of those at all recently it's your bill partnered up with your explanation of benefits to see what it costs i had a client of mine she said yeah i had sinus infections i went to the my primary care doctor and she showed me the bill and it was 400 and something dollars that they charged but the allowable rate so the Aetna discount there with Aetna 2 was still $240 and I said well why did you use telemedicine she's the HR person dude I got in my binder here I know it's 55 to 60 dollars that goes right towards your deductible towards your out-of-pocket I
[57:53] Speaker K (unidentified): just want to say my own personal opinion. I think a lot of people would be less apt to do the tele-doctor or the online doctor versus their primary doctor, because the way I look at it is I know who my primary doctor is. I can see his credentials on the wall. I talk to him. I know that he has an education. That person on the other side of the computer that you're talking to doesn't mean they graduated at the top of their class well it's true i mean you in that are you actually getting the best care
[58:26] Speaker H (unidentified): well think of it this way though and again i'm i just kind of think of this from my perspective is if i think i might have a sinus infection is it ticked by something like that okay if i call my primary care doctor they might say yeah we can get you in a couple weeks from now well that's not going to help me right so then they'll say well just run down the community Comedian MD. Well, I have a 20 year old son who played sports. Well, comedian MD, they know him by name or injuries, but then he started to say, he's don't feel good. Dad can't get into my primary care doctor. Should I run down to community MD? That's $240. I said, no, here, your ID card, doctor on demand. You can actually look up to see what doctors are on call. You can say, I want to mail and you can wait for that person. It might say this person's an hour wait. They'll They'll call you back in 20 minutes. It's just for those things. It's not for everything. But to me, I'd rather pay $60 for that visit. And I know they can call in a prescription for me because they will. Yeah.
[59:28] Speaker K (unidentified): And just to clarify, I'm not saying those outfits aren't good. I'm just saying, I think being a native Mainer, we tend to be, oh, no, we're not going to go that way because that's the high-tech thing. you know we want to have something just like shopping we want to go in the store and be able to touch and feel what we're getting we don't want you know a lot of people are very apprehensive yeah i've dragged my feet about going online to the amazon thing even though they're a wonderful place yeah okay i'm just saying i think it's progress is very hard for a lot of people
[1:00:07] Speaker H (unidentified): it's it's education it's really given examples but one thing that those telemedicine doctors do too is they do send your regular primary care anything that you called they it automatically goes over to them in the electronic filing so they know that you called in and they know that you were there and then so when you if you didn't it didn't work and you're still sick a few weeks later and you say look it's not working can I come and see you they're going to see what you did they're going to see what medication you were on and they may try something different but again I just I think of it as you know it's tough to get into your primary care doctor these days we don't tell people you have to do it we just say here's a resource here's an option for you to consider mental health right mental health in maine very tough to find a provider that participates with anybody because they're sole proprietors they can't negotiate with insurance companies so they don't participate with anybody telemedicine now is being expanded into an in network provider that has to be licensed in the state that you're in even the doctors and you can have access to somebody. That's part of the plan. It's a network provider. You know, and I think that's a big, progression in that world of telemedicine. I only see it getting bigger. Dermatology is another one that they've added. I have not got dermatology in my client. I said, all right, I'm going to ask you guys telemedicine dermatology. Really? He said about 80% of the time it'll work. So I'm going to do your phone. Is that a tick bite? Is it a rash? What it is, you know, Well, I know they're laughing because it can be funny things, but that's what, but, and I said, does it work? And they said, yeah, about 80% of the time they it'll work and they'll call them the topical creamer. And if they can't, then they're going to refer you back to your primary care or urgent care or wherever anyway. And you don't have to pay. So going back to sort of what we talked about education and getting people to understand. I know that if I just take myself and my family, I'm on a $3,500 HSA plan so it's $7,000 for our family I'm gonna go to pay the $60 versus the 240 if I don't feel good and if it doesn't work then if I have to go somewhere else then okay I'll do that but hopefully nine times out of ten I won't have to but it's all education on the tools and resources to be a consumer of care and that it's hard because when we're sick we want to be better and i totally get all that but it's just trying to get people to understand there are
[1:02:39] Speaker L (unidentified): options that make sense good questions i like a lot of just i'm trying to gather all this and
[1:02:47] Speaker I (unidentified): i guess what i'm hearing and i just wanted to confirm do all of the employees for wilder county who didn't cross the bargaining and so they're all sharing this same equal medical benefits plan man yes they are okay so everybody gave the nod and got on board with the bargaining units and everything else that's pretty amazing thing to do it's moving still there's still there
[1:03:14] Speaker G (unidentified): there's been a whole bunch of communications and conversations and there's some votes still pending but so far it seems to be moving in the right direction we've got one unit already agreed we have another vote next week we have a couple we're just waiting you're waiting to hear back from another one that because they're set up to do bargaining with us and then the third one is where i just give them some more information and they're coming back and digesting that so two are very much on board one's already fully agreed of those two there's a third one that's about to hold a vote that seems pretty positive and then the fourth one is we're still in the process of kind of discussing and making sure they understand and have like he was saying that
[1:03:53] Speaker I (unidentified): that education. Right. And that's your whole approach to the self-funded is that education is where the savings is going to be, essentially. Even fully. If you're managing a group of people that are with different benefits, then it becomes a whole lot more of a challenge when an individual is calling in and somebody is trying to deal with them to steer them in the direction to do something. So I just wanted to clear that up. The other thing that was mentioned is the employees actually have a month have a monthly payment for their insurance premium yeah how does that be
[1:04:25] Speaker H (unidentified): how's that self-funded well because when you have all these factors that come up yeah we basically come to the bottom line and we say all right well we gotta make we gotta give your team here working rates what's what would it cost for an employee for this plan what would it cost for an employee spouse employee child or children or family so we develop myself develops four working rates we call it right and then your team takes that working rate and they determine what part waldo picks up and what part the employees pick up on a per pay period basis yeah all right so
[1:05:00] Speaker I (unidentified): their premium is just to put it in kind of a weird way is that it's mainly they're covering the load but when they go to the hospital they actually start we have to pay the hospital that's coming from Waldo's pocket correct okay yeah and what is the load cost for this when you say load as far as the management of the insurance and the incentives that provided in the packages and the education and there's somebody behind all that before Penny is spent to the hospital
[1:05:29] Speaker H (unidentified): or a doctor so under our plan right now if you had zero claims you had zero claims at all to see here. Your cost will be $538,445. That's the annual fixed cost. And then anything above that is all claims. And then the claims liability, as I mentioned, they expect you to be at 1.954, 1.955 million. That's where they expect your claims to be at based on your demographics, your plan designs, the claims experience that we already know that's there, things of that. And then they build in that margin that's at 2.443 million that I mentioned, that's the maximum claims piece of it.
[1:06:25] Speaker G (unidentified): So it's- That's what I have for the claims actual, is that maximum?
[1:06:28] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, and it's smart to fund towards maximum Because you never are going to have to come back. You can't go back in the middle of the year and say, sorry, employees, we didn't, you know, we're not taking enough out of your paycheck. We're going to we're going to take more. But you really can't do that. So if you fund to the maximum liability, that builds your bucket up because, again, everybody's chipping into that bucket. Right. And as claims come out of it at the end of the year, if you fund to the maximum, you hope that you're going to have 25 percent or more of that still in your bank account, because they build in that 25% margin of maximum claims liability for that 100-year flood. And let's just say six months into the year, you see that there's a nice surplus there. You have the ability to say, well, we're not going to charge any premiums this pay period for the employees. We're just going to forgive that. I mean, you don't have to, but you can. You have to be very careful, too, about having too much money in that bucket because then And the government says, hey, wait a second, are you just really funding this thing because it's a nice deduction and you got all this money sitting there, you need to be spending it on your plan, right? So there's that piece as well, but that doesn't usually happen. Good questions, I like it.
[1:07:46] Speaker I (unidentified): And our stop loss for individual is what was mentioned up here.
[1:07:50] Speaker H (unidentified): $130,000 per individual, yep. And then we do have that $70,000 aggregating specific. specific that could be one person or a combination of anybody any number of people over the 130 but it's only paid once so it's only a one-time 70 000 liability thank you Liz
[1:08:11] Speaker E (unidentified): math bring yep just to kind of put a finer point on it the 2.443 that's in this budget which is the maximum for the aggregate, that maximum liability. That's the thing that Waldo County has not been funding since we started going over basically our premiums back in like 2021. I don't know how much because you've dug into the history with us. But, you know, every week that this group meets, every week that commissioners meet, we all feel the pain of this decision to not fund that number, basically. and not funding that number is what eats into the general fund year after year when we underfund that number and that's the thing that keeps me up at night and i just wanted to share
[1:09:06] Speaker H (unidentified): that i think i think it's a good point because if you're fully insured you're paying those premiums every single month anyway if you design it to say we're going to fund to our max liability at the end of the year if there's money left over well it's still in your bank account you didn't fund it to the insurance company and you had a banner year and they kept all of it and if that
[1:09:27] Speaker E (unidentified): is in a help fund you could use that to offset next year's maximum liability absolutely which
[1:09:33] Speaker H (unidentified): would be a much nicer position for us all to be in yeah and i've had clients that have done that especially just moving into self-funding first year or two they fund to the max to build up some sort of reserve knowing that okay eventually we'll be able to use that money to offset future costs you just can't use that money for anything else that's the only downside i've had people say can i buy new trail truck with that like oh no you can't yeah okay so
[1:10:02] Speaker C (unidentified): so brianna so last year we funded that right no it says approved so the claims actual they said the approved budget last year was 25 84 983 on that line we did not end up
[1:10:21] Speaker E (unidentified): funding between the budget committee and the commissioners and all the back and forth we did not fund everything that was asked for actuals last year we shorted it some in our desperate attempts to bring us from a initially proposed so 36 percent increase down to 16 okay
[1:10:39] Speaker C (unidentified): So how do how do we know here is a budget committee? It says the approved budget was twenty five eighty four nine eighty three. But that was the approved budget for twenty six and that the actual expense for twenty six was two zero four seven two six.
[1:10:59] Speaker G (unidentified): So. So far, this is as of October.
[1:11:03] Speaker C (unidentified): okay so we did fund i mean we did we did vote and we budgeted for 25 84 993 last year
[1:11:15] Speaker E (unidentified): this is better directed at tracy i mean i'm just looking at exactly i don't know we have any other
[1:11:20] Speaker G (unidentified): questions for bucky because now i can take over and start talking about the numbers and what's
[1:11:24] Speaker A (unidentified): going on with us anyone have any more questions for bucky only a million but
[1:11:27] Speaker H (unidentified): hey i can come back again i don't mind it's been very good questions and it's it's very good conversation you're all in the same boat you know i'm in the same boat as you and you know it's it's it's tough but i think that we can continue to do things to help the step that we're doing right now with the two plans i think is definitely going to help in the right direction okay so thank you i appreciate everybody's time if you do think of questions after make sure you ask again if i don't have the answer off the top
[1:12:02] Speaker F (unidentified): of my head i'll find it for you okay this is really beneficial yes we appreciate you coming
[1:12:07] Speaker H (unidentified): and presenting to us thank you i'll be more than happy to come back again if you need
[1:12:11] Speaker F (unidentified): all right thank you very much
[1:12:15] Speaker M (unidentified): hey
[1:12:23] Speaker A (unidentified): tracy hello
[1:12:28] Speaker G (unidentified): all righty so as we were kind of talking about that one of the reasons why you didn't get the budget until right now is that we had a meeting with the finance advisory committee this morning and they actually had me go back and change some of the formatting on this budget in the past like for last year when we presented it we presented okay so hang on let me take a step back the premiums that you're seeing that's the county health cost and the jail health cost that is what the whole premium is that's the premium that goes into so here's my dollar bill so the whole thing This is the holistic picture. This is the premiums that we are using to fund our health insurance. So this is the whole picture here. The county, we break it up so that we have 85% is paid by the county. 15% is paid by the employees. So for last year, when I presented it, I only presented the 85% that was funded by the county. I didn't present the 15% that was funded by the employees. And last year when we met and we did the budget committee, the budget committee said that, well, we need to factor in that 15%. And they proceeded to say that was a revenue and that needed to come off of the numbers we were seeing. So in essence, what was approved by the budget committee last year was only 70% of this entire 100% that was our premiums. So there was an additional that 15% that was taken off as revenue. ended up representing $315,000 that we were underfunded this year. So I talked a little bit about that in the very first meeting that we had when we were meeting for about the budget committee, but we were underfunded by about $315,000 for this year. And that's why if you take a look down at the claims overage, the actual expense for 2026, see how we're already over the approved budget for 2026, and we're still in October. October and part of that is because we were again underfunded by $315,000. That overage is the amount of times that we, like we received a bill one week, we received a bill for $158,000. We had $1,000 in our bank account, in our health account. So we had to pull $157,000 out of our general fund in order to pay for that. So that's what you're seeing there on the claims overage is the amount that we have had to pull out of our general fund just to pay for the health insurance that is not covered by the claims that were that was not covered by the premiums that were approved so this morning when we met with the finance advisory committee they were saying we need to avoid that being a potential issue again for this year's budget committee so this morning i went back and redid everything and now all that you're seeing is the cost to the county so that way if we were not taking off any additional from the cost to the county this is the true cost to the county that you're seeing for the county health insurance cost and the jail health insurance cost. This is the true cost to the county for the premiums. I did make sure that I built that back in again. It's hidden, but when we go back into the claims overage, that does still include the portion of the employee's pay. So we're not viewing that because this is what we are focused on here. What we're looking at for this budget is what does it cost the county. So that's why we went back and redid that. That's why you didn't get it until today because I was literally really changing things this morning so that we have an accurate representation of this is the cost to the county for these benefits yes
[1:15:57] Speaker F (unidentified): mary so it's showing a negative number for the department
[1:16:04] Speaker G (unidentified): request yeah isn't that amazing that means we're going to have one week of premiums to spare well i want well sorry one week of claims to spare at the end of the year if everything goes well we'll have $58,000 in our health fund for the first time since 2021, if everything goes well. Yeah, that represents $58,000 in one week of claims.
[1:16:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Laura, so what are these actuals for 26 as of what month? October. As of October. Correct. So as of October, it's that $2,044,000. That is what the actual expense has been. Correct. Okay. So then we still have like $540,000 for the next two months.
[1:17:08] Speaker G (unidentified): All of October, all of November, all of December. Yeah.
[1:17:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Right. So that was just saying. so we did fund that yeah okay so
[1:17:25] Speaker G (unidentified): do you want me to like do you want to how do we want to go about doing this because I know this is a very complicated topic do you want me to go line by line for this and explain how it all works together okay please all right so first off we're looking at the county health insurance cost again that is the portion that the county is paying for the county level employees and then there's the jail health insurance cost that is that 85% portion that the county is paying for those who are working in the jail. So those two together represent like the total 85% of the premiums that we're paying to access the health insurance. So now here's another thing to think about is when we are looking at these numbers, when we're looking at the premiums. So here's how the premiums work. So you've got, let's say this is the premiums, you've done a payroll. So this is the premiums that count for that payroll. So here is the whole thing this is the employer and the employee portion of the premium from this week's payroll we go ahead and we put that into our bank account okay great all well and good we got a hundred dollars in our health fund then we get the weekly claim and it's 170 dollars so that means we have to then pull that 70 dollars from our general fund in order to have enough money to cover that weekly claim so it's not like we're only paying 70 dollars when that comes out that's the whole 170. So even though you're seeing the premiums there, that's still a cost to us. So we're still paying those premiums in, and then we're paying this on top of it. So when you're seeing the premiums and the claims, the premiums are not an offset to the claims. We still had to pay that money in, and then we use that money. So it ends up being almost like a double debit. So we have to pay it, and then actually we got to pay that too. So does that make sense as to how I was explaining that so that when you're paying it in that's still that hundred dollars still came from us and then when we have the claims that's another seventy dollars we have to put in too so it's not like we're only paying 70 we've already put the hundred in but it's still that whole 170 came from us when we're looking at funding these claims does that make sense
[1:19:34] Speaker C (unidentified): when so when do you apply the employee it's part of abortion so this was the premium this
[1:19:43] Speaker G (unidentified): This was what we pulled from a payroll. So this is already included in this.
[1:19:48] Speaker C (unidentified): OK, I'm sorry. I'm trying to understand. I thought that I thought that you said that. Oh, sorry. I thought that you said last year when we budgeted for the cost, we did not budget for the employees 15 percent.
[1:20:05] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, we took it off of the employer. Right. We took it off of this. Right. So that is, I mean, I still did calculate it. But again, it was a hidden file in here and I used that to calculate our claims overage. So that counted. That was an extra that was calculated into our overage. So, okay. How do I explain this a little bit better? okay so when I was doing the numbers here so okay so here we've got the county here we've got the jail and then this part here was hidden so I hid this part because we're only concerned about this is what we are paying as a county but then when I looked and I calculate the actual overage I added this back in so the overage has that employee portion added in but we are not looking at what the employees are contributing we are looking at what the county is paying so this was still added in so this is still there the employees were not forgotten we didn't leave out three hundred thousand dollars and we were doing our addition it's just that we are looking at this part and so this part is hidden into our calculations as to what our overage is does that everyone understand that as far as i'm saying now yeah i love the official okay so again that's the county health insurance cost and the jail health insurance cost. We are adding a vision plan. We've had one kind of included in our health insurance, but it was really bad. I had a lot of complaints about it. And let's be honest, I would really like my 911 operators to be able to see the screens. I would really like my sheriff's deputies to be able to see license plates. So I was really all about making sure we had a good vision plan for our employees. So I'm very excited that we're actually adding in a good vision plan for the very first time so because it is the very first time we have no idea what the enrollment's going to be I did do a worst case scenario for this so I looked at the very most cost this is the absolute most that these costs would be for the jail and for the county when it comes to our new vision plan anything on vision plan okay all righty dental costs same thing we have that broken out into both the jail and the county and I was very glad that we were able to get a reduction of premiums this year that was fantastic still the same coverage level but we were actually able to it's nice to see a number go down when you're doing insurance yeah any questions about the dental we broke out you see last year we had just broken out the dental as a whole this year we're breaking out the jail as well so it's all about visibility so we can see what's going where thank you for that all right stop loss i'm really excited about this our stop loss premiums have gone down pretty considerably cross has done a phenomenal job going out to bid and they did they came in a little bit last minute but i was really thrilled that he was able to get this renewal with a different stop-loss company that was going to save us a lot of money over what we're currently paying in 2026 it's amazing any credit stop loss no all right so then the claims actual like bucky was saying i just pulled the number there i used exactly the formula that bucky gave me that same thing that he had on the screen that's what i used i took the number straight from that and put it straight into the spreadsheet because that is the maximum that we are going to be exposed to like he was saying we're funding to the maximum so if we manage to do all of that, then we see we end up with $58,000 in the bank at the end of 2027. But the big thing to consider with all of this, when I'm looking at the premiums, when I'm looking at all the costs, this is based on our current enrollment of our employees. So if we have any changes, if we have an employee turnover and then another employee comes in and they have a richer plan, all of this goes out the window. That is the problem with using actual costs when you're looking at creating a budget. So if everything goes according to plan, this is our numbers. But we are looking at actuals. So if anything changes, these numbers are going to change. And we also, we're just now starting open enrollment. Open enrollment starts Sunday night. So we don't know what our enrollment is going to be yet for 2027. So the numbers may change there as well. So the really hard part of trying to do a benefits budget is there's so many variables involved and things can change as soon as the employee changes.
[1:24:33] Speaker C (unidentified): I have a question about that, Laura. I thought he told us that if we budget for the maximum amount and it comes below that, we can't use that for anything else, but rather it has to stay in that account. So do we have a reserve account for that?
[1:24:53] Speaker G (unidentified): There is no reserve. The health fund is a live living account. That's the one where we have to pull from the general fund in order to make our claims. All the claims come from there. All of the dental comes from there. All the vision comes from there. Anytime we have a payroll, it goes into there. So it is a very live active account there. It's not a reserve. It's our active living account for all of our health insurance.
[1:25:16] Speaker I (unidentified): insurance when we
[1:25:22] Speaker C (unidentified): ever see i guess that's just is probably when the finance director gives what like the warrants or whatnot that figure we don't ever see that on the budget anywhere what that balance is maybe from one year to the other we can't we don't see that i don't know
[1:25:38] Speaker G (unidentified): what it is week to week literally every single week i get the claims on every tuesday morning every single tuesday morning i pull the claims i go to care we check the balance we see do we have to fund that. This is an insane amount of work because we have been so underfunded and we don't have anything in that health account. We are funding a $4.5 million benefits budget paycheck to paycheck right now.
[1:26:06] Speaker A (unidentified): And we're here. The purpose of the budget committee is to review the budget that the commissioners have put together and see if it is a responsible budget not to look at reserve accounts or
[1:26:19] Speaker C (unidentified): other fund accounts you don't you don't think we should see reserve accounts well no we're not
[1:26:26] Speaker A (unidentified): here to monitor reserve accounts and see what the commissioners are doing with reserve accounts they can monitor reserve accounts we're here to see if they have made a responsible budget and to who pass a responsible budget, not to monitor how they use reserve accounts or how they use their
[1:26:46] Speaker C (unidentified): funds? Well, first of all, I'm not going to say their funds, right, because it's the people's funds. But saying that, I don't understand why we as a budget committee wouldn't want to see how much is in a reserve account when we have perhaps an overage at the end of the year or a paddage where that's going to and i and there are some you know statutes that do have requirements for when the commissioners use those i mean it's somebody needs to know right well yes okay
[1:27:23] Speaker A (unidentified): but it's not up to us to ask or inquire what a reserve account is i mean it's not for the budget committee who we cannot it's not up to us to manage that it's not up to us that's right
[1:27:45] Speaker C (unidentified): they with statutory requirements can manage that but as a budget committee i mean you know that seems like to me part of the problem from a few years ago when we were funding hundreds of thousands of dollars for an id it department and the budget committee didn't know no one knew i mean i that to me is part of transparency why wouldn't we and why would anyone want to know
[1:28:14] Speaker A (unidentified): that we have commissioners that are very transparent we do for now interrupt but the
[1:28:19] Speaker G (unidentified): moonstone reservation also is that is this relevant to talking about the health insurance
[1:28:24] Speaker C (unidentified): no i was asking because it's funky is that his name had said that it couldn't be used for anything else and so i think i have a legitimate question elizabeth to say if it cannot be used
[1:28:36] Speaker A (unidentified): where does it go and when did we get to see it and you were starting yeah terry the finance director would never give that to us i'm sorry what that might hear you
[1:28:53] Speaker M (unidentified): moving on until eddie and i think we i think we talked about this before and this mystery of the reserve funds okay the finance advisory committee spent the most of two meetings going through the reserves some were fine red some were way unfunded But, Finance Advisory Committee has recommended to the Christians that we do not reserve funds for budgetary everyday business. Of course. And in the past, and we'll move on from the past, but in the past, there was too much of a budget funded. IT last first year, we saw an IT project last year, right? Well, for 25 years, I've been wondering how do we pay for IT services? Now we know it came out of reserve funds. Well, some of the reserve funds have gone. They're very restricted, and there was a hard recommendation to the commissioners that do not use it to fund operations. It's the intent, as stated by the law and the reserve fund, to leave it for that reserve fund. And I can only equate it to when I was at the 9-1-1 suburb. And I said to the parishioners, I had a reserve fund of $30,000. A pair of microwave radios cost $55,000 to replace, but they went, they went. my question was how am i going to get them and the answer was well we'll find the money well that is the way i run my business but anyway that's what it was but we're moving on from the past and i said it last year and i'll say it again today i've been around here too long this is the most transparent bunch of commissioners that I've known of in 27 years and adding the finance committee I think we're a legitimate committee doing good work we've got some recommendations for the commissioners and but I think I don't want to get shot at the same as but I think at some point there's got to be some trust managing reserve funds the way they should be managed by law we don't have enough been some of them. There's no bulk that's going on here. We're not going to dip into reserve funds. Well, I can't say that. I don't control that. We're not going to dip into reserve funds for expenses. It's too long. Too long you went that way. We're not going to do it anymore. You remember 1% increase, 1% increase, 2% increase in budgets. I was part of that process. is how you do that and operate a business those days were what we're going to fund the county the way it needs to be funded we're not going to rely on reserve funds but there's got to be some trust that we're doing right and the auditors have said that we're doing it right we get through 23 without scratch or poop out of a scratch and i was i was surprised but very happy so thank you
[1:32:20] Speaker G (unidentified): yeah okay all right moving on so we do have a 457b retirement account and we do match that but only if someone is not a part of main person and this is exact this is the number of people who are currently enrolled in the 457 that's the request there is based on the number who are currently enrolled again if we have any changes that could change as well main state retirement that is our main PERS. The big concern with main PERS is that we haven't got the quotes yet for 2027. They change every July 1st. They change the percentage and the rates. So the numbers you see here are based on the current percentages and rates. And if they come back with a higher percentage of rate in 2027, then we will be underfunded for these accounts. So again, that's not something we can predict yet because we're trying to look into the future. This is based on actuals current actuals I have a massive spreadsheet literally lists every single employee in the county looks at their enrollment looks at their salary looks at any overtime looks at I mean it is this poor thing my poor computer like every time I opens it because I have to go through that's how I calculated all these actuals is I literally went person by person looking at the rates for every single person looking at the enrollments for every single person and that's how we came up with the numbers for these charts down here. So again, we have main PERS, that's the actuals, but that if there's a change in July 1st, so 2027, then it's not going to be covered.
[1:33:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Then next time... I have a question about that. Does the county, once an employee retires, is the county done paying on that person or do we continue paying something towards that person
[1:34:10] Speaker G (unidentified): so are we talking the people that like where their pensions they've already fully retired
[1:34:14] Speaker C (unidentified): they're no longer working is that what you mean oh yes i would assume if someone's retired they're
[1:34:21] Speaker G (unidentified): not working some people retire and come back to work we have several employees who have retired
[1:34:25] Speaker C (unidentified): and come back to work oh okay so then my question I guess would be if they've retired and they're receiving the pension and then they come back to work are we do we need to are we paying towards that pension still that they're collecting there is still a requirement to
[1:34:44] Speaker G (unidentified): pay for them towards a pension even with those who have retired and returned to work okay so we it's okay yeah it's much lower it's a much lower percentage than if it was someone who was still actively working but there is still a requirement to pay towards main purrs
[1:35:00] Speaker C (unidentified): for someone who has retired and returned to work why does someone retire and return to work and
[1:35:06] Speaker G (unidentified): we have a lot who do that there's a few there's not a ton but there's a few you know maybe they left they thought they had some stuff going on and they recovered and they were like i'm bored I can't stand sitting at home anymore and they came back. Tracy how many years until you can
[1:35:21] Speaker E (unidentified): take Maine PERS retirement because a lot of imagine you start working for the county when you're 20 years old and then how many years before you can start taking your Maine PERS
[1:35:28] Speaker G (unidentified): retirement? Well it depends because some of them were you know you had to be 20 years the folks who had been here a long time some of the plans when they entered it was only 20 years now some of the plans are going to be 25 so it really depends on when they entered with the county when they were able to retire and return to work what plans they were in also plays a part there 's an insanely complicated it's if you main pers has pages and pages and pages of
[1:35:54] Speaker L (unidentified): formulas to calculate these things yeah andy are they eligible to collect from the second pension
[1:36:02] Speaker I (unidentified): if you will as they come back to work they start contributing to another pension they're eligible
[1:36:07] Speaker G (unidentified): to collect on that i'm not sure if that's a second pension or if it's just paying into what they're already receiving you'd have to ask main pers i'm not sure why they are collecting that yeah
[1:36:17] Speaker E (unidentified): thanks they have their own we'll leave that one it's kind of weird it's a nice gig if you can get it right we all should have started working for waldo county when we were 20 years old
[1:36:31] Speaker G (unidentified): okay all righty so the main purse is broken out by both the county and the jail The group life insurance, again, they do change their rates on that. So that's usually, I think, June, they'll change the rates on that one. So that's based on actuals right now for both group life insurance and jail group life insurance. FICA. So that is based on salaries. So, again, I've sat there with every single employee's salary. I've sat there with estimated payment time. I've sat there with stipends. Anything that could be taxed under FICA, I've sat there and calculated that in to get you the actual exact for the county employees and for the jail by go okay main pfml so this year we have a private plan with the standard and so this year because of the private plan we weren't required to start paying until main first may 1st because we had already set that up with our private plan and that's the way that they were initially calculating it for us next year we don't really have that provision that's going to be the full cost for the entire year for next year. So that's why you see the jump from this year to next year for main PFML. So you see that for the county and again for the jail, both of them have a pretty significant jump because now we're paying for the whole year instead of only, what, seven months. Workers' comp. This was going to be a lot, higher. And then we went out to bid with a couple of workers' comp agencies, and we will be changing to a new workers' comp provider in 2027. And they were able to get us a much better rate. I know it doesn't look better, but it was going to be, it saved us about, I think it was $16,000 straight off the bat. Medical eye care, I'm cutting that back because now we are providing that new vision, optional vision plan. So I don't think that's going to need, that really won't need to be as heavily utilized because we're going to have that new optional vision plan. And then discretionary, that's employee recognition. recognition. That's if someone passes away, we send flowers to their family. That's kind of a little slush fund kind of thing that we use to recognize our employees and their families. Did we not go over jail workers compensation? That's part of it. That's the whole, we broke it up. It's the whole number was what they gave us. And then we based it on the proportions that you see for the jail in the county. So it's all part of the same deal. It's all the same workers company. It's just that since we are breaking everything into county and jail, we broke the same proportion to get out to your jail and that's really a big driver of our workers comp costs is the second you talk to any workers comp agency oh you've got a jail yeah they get banged up a bunch so questions for tracy yeah
[1:39:32] Speaker J (unidentified): just a general jumping off what laura said, and I'm sorry to kick a dead horse, but if
[1:39:42] Speaker H (unidentified): any of us wanted to see
[1:39:44] Speaker J (unidentified): reserve account numbers, do we have to put in a forward request?
[1:39:48] Speaker F (unidentified): What do we do? Yeah, we got it.
[1:39:50] Speaker J (unidentified): Okay, we already got it. Okay, that's all I wanted to know.
[1:40:08] Speaker L (unidentified): Actually, Sandy. It's a little diverted, but
[1:40:12] Speaker I (unidentified): in the reserve accounts, these are the ones you're trying to get down to six, I think. This is the goal eventually to get 26 down to six or eight accounts. Am I hearing the same thing?
[1:40:26] Speaker L (unidentified): The advisory committee?
[1:40:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Kevin, we've sat down, we've talked. That is the ultimate goal, is to get down to six to eight accounts.
[1:40:35] Speaker L (unidentified): It would be superb.
[1:40:37] Speaker D (unidentified): It's going to be a long process.
[1:40:39] Speaker I (unidentified): No, that's what I was going to say.
[1:40:40] Speaker D (unidentified): But, you know, there is a goal. We've talked about it. There are certain accounts that need to be left alone. Opioid is in its own account. It's not a reserve. it's special funds that we have that are governed by state it's a settlement fund and it's governed by state statutes rules the health fund it's its own account it's that's all it's for is what we feed into it what's taken out of it by the you know our insurance company that's it that's okay
[1:41:13] Speaker I (unidentified): you don't have to run through everyone yeah big picture how long your best you know while I'll guess, and I'll hold you to it, how long before we take 26 and turn them to a smaller number?
[1:41:26] Speaker D (unidentified): It's been a slow process because we have to go through the state for the reserves. We have to provide a plan. Last year, I think I submitted something in November, and it was almost February, March, before I heard back for their approval. This year, I submitted an updated plan, which affected some more accounts based off our Finance Advisory Committee. I emailed and gave a hard copy, sent a hard copy in the mail. He did respond to email. He came back and asked some different questions. I sent those, and it's been radio silence since. And I think maybe it's been two or three weeks at this point.
[1:42:07] Speaker E (unidentified): So this doesn't reflect our most recent attempt or application to further reduce.
[1:42:13] Speaker I (unidentified): So it sounds like you have a goal. It's just that you don't know how long it's going to take to get there. There's just really no guessing. because you're working with all these different agencies that have different timelines and they're not responding. Because, I mean, this is a thing I've heard out in the street is the number of accounts and then where we're supposed to be getting to and how long is it going to take.
[1:42:33] Speaker D (unidentified): And a lot of this is my time, too. I mean, this is not...
[1:42:37] Speaker I (unidentified): Yep, you're the pivot man in this, yes, I get it. Two? A year ago?
[1:42:44] Speaker G (unidentified): 44 a year ago. Okay. So these are the state auditor running for election, right?
[1:42:49] Speaker D (unidentified): this wasn't always and i will say this wasn't always this way right there was a lot less accounts four years ago one person did that okay and trying to fix it and you just have to go through that approval process i mean there's discussions decisions is it right
[1:43:15] Speaker I (unidentified): So, yeah, thank you. And like I said, I just needed to get a feel for what we were working with them. Thank you.
[1:43:23] Speaker C (unidentified): I would just comment on that. I know we had this and I know I've spent many, hours this week reviewing the audits and trying to compare from one year to the next. And so I guess what probably last year with the budget committee had wanted was we wasn't going to approve the budget until we received all the audits. So we knew. But you had referred me back for the fund balance to 2023. So how do we if I'm to go back to find out the fund balance from 23, how are we to know that these figures are even?
[1:44:07] Speaker G (unidentified): The figures. I'm so sorry. Are we are we done talking about that?
[1:44:10] Speaker E (unidentified): i assumed we were since other people asked her a question yeah i sit down for it yeah thank you
[1:44:19] Speaker D (unidentified): laura you just gotta have to take my word when i say those are the numbers those are there i went back all week based off the reconciliation that we have the auditor do and compare it to everything i am 95 accurate on those numbers these are the current numbers yes
[1:44:39] Speaker M (unidentified): they're
[1:44:43] Speaker C (unidentified): not made up they're not petition oh no i thought thankfully they're not well i wasn't in i wasn't insinuating that i'm just wondering if they were from 23 or those are current
[1:44:55] Speaker D (unidentified): no those are current to date can
[1:45:04] Speaker C (unidentified): i ask one thing of the of the commissioners as i've watched the meetings with the auditor you know since you guys weren't here right so it's not on you guys when all of that happened and all the funds being used from a reserve accounts. Did you guys, do you find it concerning at all that in the 23 audit and also the 24 audit that the auditor didn't address the fact that so much money was being used from a reserve account that wasn't even set up for IT that he didn't point that out are you guys do you guys have concerns about that I don't I don't necessarily view that as I can tell that from
[1:46:02] Speaker E (unidentified): from looking at the audience audit or understanding you know what's happened in our through our minutes and hearing about what's been going on in county government so I see that as something for me to learn from, not necessarily something for the auditor to, you know, give us a naughty list of, you know, this vote or that vote that was made around the use of reserve funds. I can see the data and tell what happened and know that we're not trying to repeat that. I don't know. Are you asking that because you think we should have a different auditor or something that would put a finer point on it?
[1:46:37] Speaker C (unidentified): No, I was just wondering if there had been any discussion on that. I just find it interesting that the auditor didn't discuss it all. And I don't believe the auditors get a list of every transfer that's certified. certified. And I just started digging when I found out that the county didn't have a contingent fund and wondering then if that had led him to looking at all of those certified transfers, if there were certified transfers. So if that's something that you guys are looking, you know, ahead to setting up something for maybe a day when you're not here, that would bring more
[1:47:21] Speaker N (unidentified): accountability on that first of all it's not you guys it's commissioners commissioner thank you 're welcome you know i can't speak to the past you know we struggle to get the 21 22 and 23 and 24 audits done the auditor that we have what for whatever reason that we have them he audits 11 other counties so the amount of auditors out there that will audit counties is very limited even though we did go to bid in 20 I think in 24 you went to bid or 25 24 20 sorry 20 for the
[1:48:05] Speaker D (unidentified): 25 audit we sent out correct 21 bids oh that was 20 24 towards 20 30 bids 30 bids so you know
[1:48:15] Speaker N (unidentified): trying to get an auditor just to audit a county is extremely difficult and that's the reason a lot of counties are going to pre-audits and that's what we're going to have to head down to because you they just won't take on if you look at the 21 22 and 23 and 24 audits the auditors are taking on more risk and they're trying to get out of the risk business and put the risk back on the county so we're going to have to do pre-audits for the future you know is it concerning to go back to you a question yes it is were we transparent last year yes we were i think it's to my detriment that we were too transparent you know after over 100 budget meetings last year and after 14 meetings with the budget committee we finally passed the budget we went into march without a budget that was that wasn't passed so it's difficult to look back in a crystal ball and take it and say Is it concerning? Yes, it is. But are we trying to do better here? Yes, we are. And so, you know, I think it goes back to the county treasurer that, you know, there has to be some level of trust. And was there trust back then? I don't know. It wasn't here. Can't comment on it. I can tell you that I was here in 25 sitting in the audience where the audience is sitting now listening to their motions. Would I have made some of those motions and voted on them? I think I would have tabled them and did a little bit more research. So when you're talking about the reserve accounts, I think we're putting the information on the table. Is it concerning about the past? Yes, it is. But I'm concerned about the future of the county and where we're headed and when there's services that we're providing and the cost of those services and we spend a lot of time looking at that and me personally i'm the only one that's not fully employed so you know it falls to me to take up some of the slack for those other commissioners that they're they have time constraints and so it is concerning but we're doing the best we can if you've got suggestions put them on the table i don't i don't want to sit here and discuss just statutes, because I know the statute. I've read them, and I think we need to move forward.
[1:50:31] Speaker C (unidentified): That's my comment. Yeah, I'd like it to go on record that I do not understand the sense of resistance from the chair towards me and others when, as a budget committee member, remember, I am doing what I believe I am called to do, which is to represent the taxpayers to ask some of this. I don't believe the commissioners should take this personally. So much of this happened before your time. But there will be a time that you are gone. And I am simply inquiring instead of blindly trusting, ensuring that there are methods in place, contingent accounts, things in place so that it doesn't happen again. I don't think it's too much to question how we spend all of that money and where we're at. And to be treated sometimes in such a way simply for questioning the finances is a little bit offensive thank you
[1:51:49] Speaker A (unidentified): laura i apologize if you feel that way and i did not intend to upset you or no you didn't upset me i'm just saying how it is that's all i just did not want to get stuck on reserve accounts when we have no control over reserve accounts and or for video to change anything like that is we can look at them yes and we have looked at them we have asked for them we have gotten them in the binder and then we have gotten them again so moving forward with the budget process our duty is to look at the commissioner's budget that they have provided and prepared for us and to decide if it is a responsible budget and to vote on that. And that's just what I was
[1:52:44] Speaker E (unidentified): trying to do. Hey, I apologize. I'm a pretty sensitive person and I hear a lot of your questions and work very hard to not take them personally because I recognize that we both understand why we're here right and so i don't i don't take it so offensively when i hear you asking about guardrails for the future but i think that you know other than trusting that the people here are very interested in following statute are very have learned from what we have seen and what we know to be the mistakes of the past you know we are more we are on video we have someone in the audience that comes to all our meetings and other people who come to our meetings and write about them and write to us about them. I feel very watched, and I don't see that as a bad thing. I think that 's a good thing that people are paying more attention to county government than they did back in those days. If people had been paying more attention to county government in 21, 22, 23, we'd probably be in a very different position than we are right now. So, I think that you do, you know, you have a lot of questions that, to Liz's point, don't always pertain to maybe the most productive work of the Budget Committee, but they're very valid questions as a community member and as somebody who cares about the finance of this county.
[1:54:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Now, can we move forward with moving on to voting on employee benefits? Yes, please. Awesome. Thank you, Linda. So how do we want to vote on this? Do we want to go through each one individually or do we want to vote on it as a whole budget committee?
[1:54:39] Speaker F (unidentified): Mary? I think we had pretty good presentations from our HR department and from Bucky from Cross Insurance. A thousand times more information than we've gotten prior. prior. I agree. And including the teacher's show and tells. Thank you. So I personally think we can vote on this one as its whole. We're doing it tonight. We're doing it following a long time of presentations. Okay. Still fresh in our brains. I'd like to recommend that we do it as a whole and not line by line. Fantastic.
[1:55:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Would somebody like to make a motion? Make that as a motion. I'll second it. Okay. So then we have a motion and a second. Any discussion? All in favor? So we have four for it. All opposed?
[1:55:51] Speaker F (unidentified): Nobody opposes?
[1:55:54] Speaker C (unidentified): I wanted to ask a question about the difference in what we was first given for figures and what showed up on here.
[1:56:04] Speaker A (unidentified): year so are we talking about the budget for this yes for the employee or beyond question then yes
[1:56:13] Speaker G (unidentified): i am really thrilled you asked that because we did not get the quotes from the insurance companies until monday okay so i did not have the real numbers until monday it's been a week i've been a little crabby that's why i have this today
[1:56:35] Speaker E (unidentified): is this a motion to approve the department budget or to approve the idea of approving it as a whole and not line by line i was wondering yeah to approve it my whole my motion was to
[1:56:47] Speaker F (unidentified): approve it as a whole okay i would want to approve it as a whole okay yes that's what but the motion is for.
[1:56:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, four. Four,. And two, nothing. Okay, so now motion on the table to approve 2025 employee benefits for $4,566,592.
[1:57:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, I'm sorry. You're reading that number. Yes. Sorry. Okay. Starting over.
[1:57:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Motion on the table to approve Department 2025 employee benefits for $4,566,592. Start all over. I screwed that up. One more time. Three times a turn. Motion on the table for Department 2025 employee benefits for $4,566,592.80. Do I have a second? Yes. Mary seconds. Any discussion? No. All in favor? Four in favor? All opposed?
[1:58:19] Speaker J (unidentified): Okay. I can't. I can't. I can't approve. I can't. I have to oppose.
[1:58:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So four in favor, one opposed. And are you abstaining from voting, Laura?
[1:58:35] Speaker C (unidentified): I feel like I would have. I'm going to oppose for now. I think I would have liked to have had more of time ahead of time just to really go over this so yeah for now i'm going to oppose i'm opposing
[1:58:47] Speaker A (unidentified): thanks so warren favor and feel cool oh brandy are you voting for oh my god
[1:59:16] Speaker B (unidentified): sorry guys i was participating i thought you counted my hand
[1:59:24] Speaker A (unidentified): she's five so five four thank you brandy thank you all right keep your mic on though because we're talking about making further meetings and i need to know what you are available for
[1:59:46] Speaker B (unidentified): all right i did send that to you by email earlier to elizabeth i sent you the dates i was available for november okay i will have to look at my email let me i'll double screen it so i can i had my work calendar open when i did it so okay
[2:00:12] Speaker A (unidentified): we need to set up future meetings in november and we need to reschedule the sheriff so november fridays and saturdays i know what mary can work i got what linda could do i got That was Sandy. I got your availability. Brandy, what is your availability?
[2:00:38] Speaker B (unidentified): For Fridays, 11, 13 and 11, 20, I'm available. And then 11, 14 and 11, 21 for Saturdays. But I have family coming in the last week of November and I have a, my brother with cerebral palsy is being scheduled for surgery this month. and I'm at the mercy of Northern Light Surgical Unit for the date on that, so I'm not sure. Okay.
[2:01:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Ian, what is your availability?
[2:01:11] Speaker J (unidentified): I can do pretty much any Friday. Any Friday.
[2:01:39] Speaker A (unidentified): It's going to be not going to work. So, we would just make five with the six. You can't do the 13th? No. The 13th only has three people? we would have six if we did the 20th so let's do laura you're not available the six or are you friday evening the six i am you are okay perfect awesome so let's do the six and let's do the 20th and the 27th and then in december let's try to set make our public hearing i just thought i should
[2:02:59] Speaker G (unidentified): throw out there that 26th and 27th are county holiday i'm just throwing that out there
[2:03:07] Speaker A (unidentified): it's the thanksgiving holiday and it's the 26th and the 27th by the county holidays okay how about
[2:03:14] Speaker J (unidentified): the oh yeah i don't know if i would be available on the 27th okay all right and that's fine i'm
[2:03:22] Speaker A (unidentified): sorry no that's okay we can take the 27th out of there because it's a county holiday okay december what is everybody's availability in december we're hoping that with the six and the
[2:03:36] Speaker F (unidentified): 20th give you a sheriff on hopefully the sixth if he's available and the 20th is the vote so you
[2:03:43] Speaker A (unidentified): need right if we could do the finish the votes on this 20th of everybody
[2:03:49] Speaker E (unidentified): ready i'm not available the 25th i'm sorry no i don't think anyone's available the 25th of december what is this december it was like we had a vote on new year's eve a couple years
[2:04:06] Speaker L (unidentified): sorry it wasn't a good joke it's not funny i guess i'm not worried
[2:04:14] Speaker J (unidentified): december i'm pretty flexible
[2:04:17] Speaker A (unidentified): you're pretty flexible okay this would be for the we should schedule two one for a public hearing and one just in case we have business that we need to finish up so friday the 4th is a holiday
[2:04:32] Speaker F (unidentified): for some people so you don't want to schedule a public hearing on friday the 4th okay december 4th is a holiday for some people yes so could we do a tonic it's not on my phone my phone has like
[2:04:47] Speaker K (unidentified): Like every holiday. Well, mine sure starts on the 5th, but it actually starts at sundown on the 4th.
[2:04:53] Speaker A (unidentified): How about if we schedule, would people be available on the 12th?
[2:04:58] Speaker K (unidentified): On a Saturday? On a Saturday.
[2:05:01] Speaker A (unidentified): You're not?
[2:05:02] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm out of state on that day.
[2:05:04] Speaker A (unidentified): How about, are you available on the 11th? Okay. Is everybody else available on the 11th? I'm good. You're good? Everybody's good. Okay. So we'll do 11th. That's the public hearing. Well, that is any other business that we could potentially close up.
[2:05:22] Speaker J (unidentified): So what time will that be at? Same six? Yeah. Six to nine.
[2:05:25] Speaker D (unidentified): Can I throw this out there? Could you schedule the public hearing on the same day, do your business and then move into public hearing? Okay.
[2:05:37] Speaker F (unidentified): The three hours on the 20th to go through the ones we haven't voted on shouldn't take the three full hours.
[2:05:43] Speaker A (unidentified): okay if everybody feels confident that we can get through the budget process and just do our public hearing on the 11th
[2:05:53] Speaker F (unidentified): because also you're getting into serious holiday time we are people are not we are participate in public hearings and you wanted you want people to be able to
[2:06:01] Speaker A (unidentified): participate we do okay
[2:06:07] Speaker J (unidentified): so we've got two meetings before actually three and right three meetings the sixth the 20th right but we're using the third one as like wrap-up business and then
[2:06:19] Speaker A (unidentified): go into a vote? Hopefully we'll have everything done on the 20th and then the 11th will be public hearing. Okay. That's what we're hoping.
[2:06:30] Speaker J (unidentified): So we've got the 6th and the 20th? The 20th.
[2:06:33] Speaker E (unidentified): And that gives people three weeks to digest the public hearing announcement and information. Right.
[2:06:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Does everybody feel good about that? Or do you feel like we need to squeeze another one in there?
[2:06:51] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, the problem with that is going to be squeezing we have a follow-up meeting after the public hearing we're already getting tight
[2:06:57] Speaker A (unidentified): we are getting we are getting tight so we can discuss that after the public hearing if we feel like we need to squeeze another one we'll just make it happen we're gonna have to okay all right everybody's feeling good i'm i feel good so the 6th the 20th and both of those are Fridays so we'll do the 6 to 9 and then the 11th will be our public hearing
[2:07:36] Speaker I (unidentified): still 6 to 9 we still have to do what we missed the last which is
[2:07:42] Speaker L (unidentified): sure are they going to be available on these dates I am sure hoping yes they
[2:07:47] Speaker A (unidentified): will okay he said he was available to six so we will do the sheriff on the [Speaker M (unidentified): six. All right.] Is there anything else anyone wants to discuss? I just want to make another
[2:08:02] Speaker C (unidentified): statement for the record. While I am appreciative of the finance, the new committee, I do want to say that I don't think that in any way an appointed group by the commissioners should take away any bit from anything that the budget committee requests that's to do with reserve accounts or any other information from the elected board that we are. Okay.
[2:08:42] Speaker F (unidentified): So everybody's busy. And I'm concerned with us not having a date on people's calendars for after the public hearing. which is on the 11th of December, and that's two weeks before Christmas and the week before New Year's. And where are we going to schedule a meeting? There's all profitability. We'll need to. And the closer and further away we get from day and the closer we get to those holidays, the harder it's going to be for any of us to be available. That bothers me. That concerns me.
[2:09:20] Speaker A (unidentified): So would you like to go ahead and schedule another one? I'd like to try.
[2:09:24] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. Okay, we may not be able to get there, but I'd like to give it a try.
[2:09:28] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, so looking at December after the public hearing on the 11th. What about the 18th?
[2:09:36] Speaker I (unidentified): How soon after can we go for it? I mean, is there a time? Can we do it the next day?
[2:09:42] Speaker K (unidentified): On the 12th?
[2:09:44] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I'm not there. On the 12th? Yeah. Oh.
[2:09:53] Speaker I (unidentified): The 18th is fine with me.
[2:09:54] Speaker F (unidentified): may saturday so let's let's all try friday the 18th yeah i'm good with the 18th ian linda i'm
[2:10:02] Speaker A (unidentified): brandy december 18th i will try to be there okay the 18th it is six
[2:10:15] Speaker B (unidentified): to nine also yeah
[2:10:29] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, Beth, make everybody feel good?
[2:10:45] Speaker J (unidentified): I'll share the vision.
[2:10:47] Speaker F (unidentified): I hope so. We need to feel good. I know, right?
[2:10:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. With that, I make a motion that we adjourn at 8-11. Be in seconds. All in favor? Aye. Thank you, everyone. Thanks for being here. Thank you, Tracy.