← Back to MaineScanner

Westbrook council censures Councilor Turcotte, updates on landslide study

2026-11-16 · 2h 0m · Source: 11/16/26 City Council (City of Westbrook (Vimeo))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:14] David Morse: I'll to order the special City Council meeting for Monday, November 16th I just want to remind council in the public that if we our expectations are Include raising your hand and waiting to be called on prior to speaking and confine your comments the merits of the issue and avoid using personal comments and I'd like to just note for the record that the special City Council meeting for this evening was called by Mayor David Morse on Friday November 13th 2026 notice was posted on the city website and at City Hall and for the land acknowledgement statement the Westbrook City Council understands honors that acknowledges that the city of Westbrook is located on the traditional and unceded homelands and waters of the indigenous people of the presumptive Scott River we recognize that the Wabanaki people have been displaced by the advancement of colonization yet have belonged to this LAND FOR COUNTLESS GENERATIONS AND THOUSANDS OF YEARS AND THEIR PRESENCE CONTINUES IN MAINE TO THIS DAY. ROLL CALL. COUNCILOR MCCAMBRIDGE. HERE. VICE PRESIDENT SHAWNESSEE. HERE. COUNCILOR CHAO. HERE. COUNCILOR TURCOTT. HERE. COUNCILOR FAULKIUM. HERE. COUNCILOR REARDON IS ABSENT. AND PRESIDENT MONROE. HERE. PLEASE JOIN ME IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. TO THE FLAG. we have several sets of minutes to approve from august 17th september 14th september 21st october 5th october 19th and november 2nd is there any discussion from the council if not they'll be approved as is okay and on to the mayor's message thank you i want to begin by congratulating two members of our police department who were promoted today brian olson to captain and nick wrigley to Sergeant. These are well-deserved promotions, and I thank both of them for their service to Westbrook and their willingness to take on new leadership responsibilities. Congratulations to you both. I also want to offer a brief thank you to Captain David Thompson, who retired last week after more than three decades of public service, including 17 years with Westbrook. Through his leadership, his work with our K-9 program, and his mentorship of so many of our officers, Dave has made a lasting contribution to this department and to our community. And thank you, Dave, and best wishes for a wonderful retirement. I also want to recognize an outstanding accomplishment by Deputy Fire Chief Brian Langerman, who has become a fellow of the American College of Paramedic Executives. Brian is just the 97th person in the whole world to earn this distinction, and it follows more than 35 years in emergency services and approximately 18 months of dedicated preparation, including written and oral examinations and an extensive review of his professional work. This is a very remarkable achievement and reflects the experience and dedication Brian brings to our fire department, and we're very fortunate to have him serving in our community. Congratulations, Chief. Since our last meeting, 9,762 Westbrook voters cast ballots in the November 3rd election, a turnout of 68.3% of our registered voters. Thank you to everyone who participated, whether by absentee ballot or at the polls on election day. And thank you to city clerk Ellis Ledoux, the clerk's office staff and the election workers and all the volunteers whose hard work made that possible. There's a tremendous amount of preparation and care behind every election and I appreciate everything that you do. Last Wednesday, I had the honor of reading our Veterans Day Proclamation at the ceremony here in Westbrook at Woodlawn Cemetery. I want to thank the community members who organized that ceremony each year and everyone who came out to honor the veterans and their families. Year after year, our neighbors show up and that says something meaningful about this community. Thank you also to our Veteran Services Officer, John Lee, for the work that he does throughout the year to support those who have served in our community. Just a reminder that Westbrook is still the only municipality in the state of Maine to have a veteran services officer. I have an encouraging quick update on the student metro program. As of last Friday, students had taken 646 rides so far in November, and daily boardings had already exceeded 100 on two occasions this month. Principal Garrett shared that he counted 20 students getting off of the Route 3 bus at Starwater and Monroe one morning last week. That's the most he's seen in his weekly check-in so far. It's exciting to see students making use of this opportunity and becoming more comfortable using public transportation to get around. Thank you to our partners at Metro and the schools for helping make this program work. I also want to thank the more than 60 people who attended last Thursday's Main Street streetscaping meeting. It was wonderful to see so many residents looking closely at the plans and asking questions and sharing their ideas with Maine DOT. This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to help shape the future of Main Street. It's an opportunity to make it safer and more welcoming for people to walk, bike, and visit Riverbank Park, enjoy our restaurants, spend time downtown. I'm very excited about that opportunity and grateful that so many people are helping to shape it. The plans are still being developed by DOT, and if you could not attend, there's still an opportunity to review the proposal on the DOT website and submit feedback back to them through the project website. I believe that you have until November 25th to do that. Jenny Franceschi is shaking her head yes. So that we have until November 25th to be able to submit comments through the DOT's website. On Friday, I had the opportunity to attend the Friends of Presumpt Scott's annual meeting at Mass Landing. I'm always inspired by my friend Michael Shaughnessy hears talks about the river, his knowledge of its history, his love for it, and his belief in what it can become remind us how much progress has been made over the years and how much that progress really depends on the people who care enough to keep working at it. We heard about the efforts to restore native fish, improve water quality and fish passage, and give more people, especially children, opportunities to get out on the river. Here in Westbrook, we can see the importance of that work at Sacarapa Falls and in the growing connection between our downtown and the river. Thank you, Michael, and all the volunteers and supporters of Friends of the Presumptive for your years of dedication. That brings me to an opportunity that exists this week to learn more about the Riverwalk North project. The city will hold a second public meeting this Thursday, November 19 at 5 p.m. in the Oak Room at the Westbrook Community Center. Our project design team will provide an overview and explain the natural resource protections included in the design, including measures to minimize impacts to wetlands, floodways, floodplains, and sensitive soils, and to manage invasive species. I encourage anyone interested in the project to attend, learn more, and bring your questions. Looking ahead, I just want to highlight two upcoming holiday celebrations. celebrations first is our annual tree lighting at riverbank park which will take place on sunday december 6th at 6 p.m i hope you'll join us for this wonderful westbrook tradition as we gather with friends and neighbors to welcome the holiday season and then also the following evening monday december 7th at 5 p.m habad maine will host the westbrook hanukkah celebration at the westbrook common that's 850 main street there will be a public menorah lighting music donuts latkes and chocolate gelt. I look forward to joining everyone and offering a few words. Thank you to the organizers of both celebrations for bringing our community together. And finally, I'd like to invite Robin Saunders and friends to the podium to share what we have learned about landslide vulnerability in our area and what that means for our community. [8:38] Robin Saunders: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I have several handouts for the council. first I am going to have Brenda Zalich hand out copies of this evening's presentation for you all Brenda is our policy analyst and this is Teresa Patton from Cradery Associates she's going to hand out a frequently asked questions sheet that we plan to put on the website the city's landslide website within the next couple of days and then last but not least i have two 11 by 17s for you all one is why do a landslide vulnerability assessment and the other one is where we studied where we actually studied so while they're handing that out i'm gonna get to work and just let you know that it's not just the three of us that are part of this team i'd say that we've got a lot of other people here in the in the audience who've been part of it and in fact we just finished a three-hour meeting internally to identify what policies we can use internally to protect against the loss of life and property so we're here to provide an update on the landslide vulnerability assessment project that's been evolving since 2020 and why 2020 you all may remember that it was in 2020 when the warren when there was a landslide of about three acres on warren avenue that took place and the mayor at the time asked the army corps of engineers when they came to assess the landslide when and where will landslides occur again in the city. And the Army Corps suggested that, well, we just don't know. The best course of action is to develop a comprehensive geotechnical investigation to understand why landslides occur in Westbrook. And that's what I was tasked with doing. So I developed a scope of work with the Maine Geologic Survey and the University of Maine to pursue funding through first a FEMA grant that's building resilient infrastructure in communities and then we didn't get that funded so then we did a FEMA hazard mitigation grant and that wasn't funded but then MEMA said no you really this time you're gonna you're gonna submit a congressionally directed spending grant application and that was that was funded and so there's a quote on one of the 11 by 17s there from former Senator Susan Collins about the reason why we pursued this to understand the root cause to prevent similar natural disasters from happening. And so fairly early on in the study, it was really important. The first thing for us to understand is, you know, why were landslides happening? What was the culprit? So the landslide experts from both Maine Geologic Survey and the University of Maine identified the culprit to be a very sensitive clay soil this should be familiar because I just came in front of you in July last this past year and also last year to let you know that this sensitive clay known as presumptive formation is really the cause of the vulnerability or the susceptibility in Westbrook and throughout the Presumpt-Scott River corridor. So it's not just a Westbrook problem. If you see the map up on the screen, you'll see everywhere that there's blue on the map in blue is mapped Presumpt-Scott formation in Maine. And that is, presumptive formation is basically remnants of glacial marine slurry that's just left behind from icebergs, you know, giant glaciers as they retreat into the ocean. And so at the end of the last ice age, 12 or 17,000 years ago, they left this sort of glacial slurry known as Presumpt's God Formation all over the town of Westbrook and other parts of Maine. So that's what we know is causing the landslide vulnerability. So that's not news to you, right? So you've heard me say it's really about landslides. and as we reach out and talk about landslides in the community people are like well landslides are just one and done right so we're safe the rest of the rest of eternity so to speak so rip patton from crederi made this graphic for us to let us know that there have actually been nine landslides in york and cumberland county since 1960 so that averages out to be about one every seven years, and there was actually a landslide in Argyle up on the Penobscot River that the University of Maine is actually studying as a companion project for the work that we're doing here in the Penobscot River, and it's actually been a really good learning experience for them that they've been able to draw a lot of parallels to. And you may recall back in July when I was here last with Brenda, this lady over here. I introduced you to these two experts at the University of Maine, Dr. Aaron Gallant, who is an associate professor of civil and environmental engineering. And he is a geotechnical engineer specializing in landslides. And he is overseeing a PhD candidate named Sabah Seer. And together, they were in Westbrook for two months last year. And they had drill rigs, cone penetration contractors, and all kinds of other sort of specialty nuance folks in town to just do all this work that Teresa is going to talk to us about, the technical part. but tonight my update here is a result of the University of Maine's technical teams making progress on that analysis of all that field work that they did in 2025 and although they have months of lab work left to do and lots of data analysis after that they were at a place where they felt like they could help us understand some of the stability analysis and where we should focus our policies so that's the second reason that we're here is to just let you know a little bit about our policies and so why was it important for us to do this study? Well, the north side of the river, there have been a lot of fairly large concentration of landslides. And the University of Maine said, let's focus all our energy on that north side of the river. And I was like, guys, we have this grant from the federal government that says we should be looking at the entire Presumpt-Scott River corridor. And the river corridor goes all the way from Portland all the way up to Standish. Why are we focusing here? And so I said, maybe what we need to do is we need to have what's called in engineering a peer review. So we reached out to a whole bunch of subject matter experts, geologists like Lindsey Tice from the Maine Geologic Survey and other geologists and geotechnical engineers and they all agreed that exactly where we should be looking is exactly where the University of Maine suggested. So if you look at this on the 11 by 17 that I gave out to you, the neighborhood where we were looking is on the north side of the river and if you look to the north of that neighborhood there's an there was an 1831 landslide on the presumptive scott river in portland and then you go further down see where the arrow says devon and sanford 1990 that's the neighborhood where we did lots and lots of investigation there's another landslide below it that's called the fuller slide and the age of that one is over 2200 years old. And it's called the Fuller Slide because it was discovered by a geologist by the name of Fuller. And do you guys know how you date landslides? Very carefully. No, just kidding. You actually look for, when you go and you sample a landslide, you look for any like woody debris that might be in there, whether it's from a tree or from herbaceous material from around the ground, and you carbon date it. So you have an idea of when the land got sort of plowed up together or tilled into the ground. So that one, that landslide there was, you know, over 2200 years old. and then if you look further down across the river it says age question mark we don't know how old that one is because we've never been able to find any carbon based material to actually do some carbon based carbon dating there so but you'll find further down the stream there the 2020 landslide was in that area there was an 1868 landslide there and you know there's there's lots of records about that one where everyone at the mill stopped the mill stopped and everyone picked up shovels and started you know clearing the river for that but all of the all of the work that the that has been happening technically has been focused in this area and we just wanted people in that neighborhood to know that there's something special about their neighborhood because everything has been sliding around it except their neighborhood. So Councilor McCambridge and I and Rip and Teresa and Mo Cornett, we've gone out the last few Saturdays and handed out flyers to people saying come find out about the landslide vulnerability assessment because your neighborhood has allowed us to learn so much about the city. So there are quite a few people here. I've noticed a few people who have the flyers in their hands and have come to ask some questions maybe. be. But in January, we're going to start an actual stakeholder process and talk a little bit more about this. And Brenda's going to talk a little bit more about the policy. But without further ado, I want to allow Teresa the opportunity to talk a little bit about the technical work that we found out about. [20:18] Teresa Patton: My name is Teresa Patton. I work at Cordaria Associates. And Robin stole a little bit of my thunder with this slide, but that's okay. It's okay. It's it's fine. It's always repetition is always good. So the big thing was, yes, Robin was tasked with this and I have to say kudos to Westbrook to pursuing this funding. It's huge. Like, I mean, the fight, the amount of site specific data that you guys are getting is just amazing because that's the first thing you want to get. And you're getting a lot of it kind of for free because it's a grant, but, even though I know the city's doing a lot for it, but, so that, 's just fantastic. So the question again, why Westbrook? So I'm going to reiterate a lot what Robin said, is that she just went over where all these landslides were. And that's why, if you look on the, I guess it's the right side of the slide, that, and it's a little hard to tell, but all those little red dots, those are where historic landslides have occurred, that have been recorded, that we know about in Maine. And when you really look at the, most of them are in southern Maine, they do line up with where the Presumpt Scott formation is. So, and again, if you were to hone in on it, you come to Westbrook, which is a perfect place for it because of exactly what Robin talked about. We have historic, prehistoric landslides, and we have this surrounding a neighborhood that has been unaffected by them. And that's huge because there's something special going on there. We want to know why this neighborhood has not succumbed to the surrounding areas. Okay, so that was a huge focus of UMaine. We want to know why it didn't fail. So the other thing you have to do is, well, is the material we've identified that this presumptive formation, we know just from studying landfills for over the years that it's susceptible to a lot of things and can lead to landfills and instability of slopes. so is the same material in this area that failed in the area that didn't fail that's one question that needs to be answered okay so that in that initiated what do i do i hit enter sorry i'm not good at this stuff okay so this is a zoom in and i think you have this and what i'm going to tell you on this is every one of those little dots is where we did a subsurface exploration so we did a boring it could have been a boring where we collected soil samples where we did some in situ like in the earth ground testing different things that happened but all that really matters is that we did a lot of them and what i'll tell you is where those orange lines are is where the landslides were the historic ones or the you know so you can see that some of the explorations are in where the landslides had occurred and then some are in this neighborhood on this north side that you know has been uninfluenced by the landfills landslides I'm sorry so that's where they specifically did the study and why they did that because they wanted to draw that comparison so I said one of the first questions is the material that failed the same in these neighbors and yes the materials there okay but that doesn't mean we're gonna have a failure what it just means it's the same material and it also gets to that other question of why didn't it? Because it's had all the same, it's been exposed probably to the same things. We don't know exactly what caused the prehistoric ones. Even back in 1868 and 1831, we don't really know what caused those. Okay, we can conjecture and all that, but we don't know. Okay, so we need to know why. It usually comes down to the geometry. So the next phase of what UMaine did is they did stability analysis, okay? So it's a very complicated thing. I'm going to try to make it as simple as possible, okay? Let me go to the next slide, okay? This is going to be a very brief landslide, sort of 101 on kind of what happens. When you look at this figure on the left side. We have a slope and there's a formula there. Sorry. There's a formula and basically it has the resistance force divided by the driving force. Gives you a factor of safety and that's essentially what these computer models do. They figure out what the resisting force is. They divide it by the driving force. They come up with a factor of safety. Above one, good. Below one, bad. We like to see 1.3 to 1.5, okay? That's what we like to see, but that's general. To get you an idea of what resisting forces is and driving forces is, I could say if I was standing here and I was pushing on a rock, I would be the driving force. The rock would be the resisting force. I can push on it and the rock doesn't move. We're in equilibrium. Everything's fine. everything's good wonderful my factor of safety would probably be well over one because my resisting force the rock is a lot stronger than me pushing on it this makes sense right so one of the things we could do to change that to go from this equilibrium state of where I'm or I'm putting pushing on the podium to change that what would I have to do there's a couple things I'd have to do one I could say Robin can help me push this rock and then maybe me and Robin can both push it, but our factor of safety still might be over one. If the rock doesn't move, everything's still fine. So it's kind of those ideas of, and how would that look on a landslide? Me and Robin pushing the rock would be like, if I built a building on top of that slope, because now gravity, we all pretty much know what gravity does, it's pulling down on the slope. So that would be changing the condition, putting something at the top of the slope. Might mess up the equilibrium. might not that building might be fine because that resistance the soil is so strong it can handle a lot of stuff okay so one of the other things we could do is if that rock was on a hill i could potentially push it easier so i've changed some condition that would be like making that slope even steeper so gravity has more effect it's making my driving force stronger and my resisting force less. And that's kind of what happens in a landfill, but something had to happen. There has to be a trigger. There's lots of things that can trigger. This is, I can mention a couple of those things, increasing your slope, increasing your weight that's at the top of the slope. But there's other things out there. There's man-made triggers and there's nature-made triggers. Okay. Nature-made, I'm not going to really get into that because I don't control that. There's a higher power out there that's controlling that. We can deal with that on a different level and that might be more of a preparedness thing. But these man-made triggers, we have some control on, potentially. And that's something that Brenda's going to talk about later. How can we deal with that? This is just to get you to understand what happens with that. So back to Humane's research, they did their stability analysis and they did a lot of stuff. This is just one little part I want you to look at to get you an idea on where they are in their research, okay? That's really what we're doing here because they have a lot more to do, Robin said, a lot more soils that need to be analyzed, a lot more stability analysis that has to be looked at. So this is the first pass to help target them to make sure they're going in the right direction, you know, because you have to ground truth kind of what you're doing. So I mentioned that they know the materials there. Well, what else about this slope can we learn? So they have to do a computer model. You need to base your computer model in reality. so we're really lucky again why rest book was such a great location to do this as you had this 2020 slide and that happened so recent we have some indications of some of the factors that may be contributed to the failure over there so we can model that we can put that in our computer model to see if we're modeling the behavior of the clay correctly okay and that's what's important to do so we did that on the south side they did a pre slide stability analysis it's just a computer program you put stuff in the big thing you put in there is how you model the strength of the clay which is information that they got directly from borings that were collected in West Brook so they know the materials there they know how strong it is they put it in the model they came up with a factor of safety there of one point two three worry, okay? Really don't worry about that last number so much. And it's above one. It's not as good as I said on the previous slide. I said we like to see 1.3 to 1.5, but again, we're just trying to see if everyone's on the right track, if we've got the right model, and we're modeling the information correctly, okay? And we kind of want to see how we're doing that. So then what we did is they looked what we would consider post-slide or right before the slide, would the slide occur. How you change things. When you're in the lab, you can take clay. You can get the strength of the clay and the soils down there. You can also model what would happen when it goes to this disequilibrium state. They can model that in the lab. And they can come up with a test. And they can say, before a landslide, your clay is this strong. After a landslide, your clay is this strong. So we know that. So they put that into the model. That's the only thing they change and the factor of safety drops okay i mean in this case they did add some a little bit change some changes in geometry because there was some outside circumstances there but the factor of safety went from 1.2 to 0.58 what we're looking here is the relative difference in the number it went from stable to unstable so what i hear from that is our model is good the data we have is good the way we're analyzing the data is good the way we're treating the way the clay behaves is good so now we can do that information we learned from this landslide on the set on the south side and put it to the north side in that neighborhood that's standing okay and do the same thing so we did that or they did that on the north side and they ran the factor of safe they came up with a factor of safety of 1.28 which most people would say based on the limitation of the model. That's 1.3, okay? Which is still not the 1.5 we'd love to see, but it's showing that it's stable and that's good. And it's not even close to one, which is what we expected because it's standing. We know this. We know it has been subjected to the same environmental influences that other areas right next to it failed. So we know this about that. so then we said well let's pretend something happened that made our clay lose all the strength just like we did on the other side and what does that do your factor of safety it brought it down to 1.1 again I acknowledge not the best number in the world but it's above 1 and it is certainly a lot higher than 0.58 so what does that show is that this neighborhood stable there's a lot more that we have to learn about why it's stable. It's not just the clay that maybe is making it stable because we made the clay lose all its strength. So there's something else going on there. I said, so what do we want to keep it in? And that's just where they are in their research right now. So they're going to go and they're going to investigate that more. They're going to get more data. They're going to do more sophisticated analysis. They're going to try to get more answers to those questions. Okay. What does that say for the next step of the vulnerability study, which is the policy side. I mentioned earlier, you're in this equilibrium state moving to a disequilibrium state. You have to get there somewhere, a trigger. How can we prevent triggers? Here, we're stable. We want to make sure we don't go to 1.1. Is there things that the city of Westbrook can do to make sure you don't go from one situation? Or not make sure, but help it not go in that direction. And there is. And that's the stuff what Brenda's going to talk about. There is policy things we can do because we talked about man-made triggers and nature-made, and there's a lot of man-made things where there's some place where we can have input, and that's one of the focuses of the next part. Also, just so you know, what we're doing right now in that neighborhood is we've put in some instrumentation to help us identify if a change in condition is occurring. okay i could go into what it is it's a vibrating wire presometer and how it works but just to know it's there and we've been monitoring it for a year to see if there's been any change and there hasn't and exactly what it's monitoring is exactly what we modeled in the computer model and like i said i could go on to it but you're already glazed over so i will leave [33:25] Robin Saunders: thanks Teresa you know so really with us facing still so many unknowns really what it comes down to is focusing our policy on what we can control and what we and instead of worrying about what we can't control but real quickly the things that we are controlling are who's reviewing all of our science-based policies and that is still again the subject matter experts and how do we make so and the other thing that we can control are making sure that our decisions make sense and they're firmly rooted in science and so I'll have Brenda come up and talk with you because we really third the last thing we can control is the risk and making sure that we de-risk our decisions that you all have to make about you know the policy that will come in front of you within a few short months as we develop it because as counselors i know that you want to protect against loss of life and property from you know city administration from david and Angela and Jenny down to department heads like Rebecca Spitella and Eric Dudley, who are guiding development review. We're trying to put it into those areas. And managers like Catherine Kelly and Doug Eaton, who ask their crews to put their safety on the line throughout town when they go into areas that, you know, we're not sure of. And perhaps most importantly, our public safety professionals what we've learned is that you don't respond to a landslide emergency the same way you do a fire or any other emergency when it comes to natural hazards they're not all the same they're very different and we've started an ad hoc monthly group to talk about landslides and how first responders can protect themselves from the inherent risks associated with landslides and i'm so proud and grateful for the to be working with these outstanding professionals in public safety in westbrook they single-handedly developed the state and perhaps new england's first emergency response plan for landslides and we hope to expand and include some regional training with Cumberland County EMA and MEMA so that we can keep not only them safe but all the people of Westbrook safe so Brenda you want to come and talk about the other policies that we're planning for new and existing development excellent thank you so much for being willing to listen to us talk about landslides and I get to talk about the practical element of okay so we have these test results we know that landslides have happened in Westbrook they could happen again we don't have the ability to say they're gonna happen at this location at this time so that makes it a little more challenging to be able to do preventive measures be great if we could do that but the science does not give us that capacity. So what we did, I am a policy analyst and I am the president of Resilient Roots LLC doing policy work, but I'm also faculty at the University of Southern Maine in their public policy area. And so one of the things that I did was bring to the table the structure for doing a professional policy analysis using Bardock's Eightfold Path which you don't need to know about but it is important because it goes through a set of steps that allow us to do the work that we need to do. So the very first part which we talked to you about last time was we when we last met we had just finished the policy scoping document where we looked at federal state county and local municipal policies from that we identified 26 policy options. We then also did a number of stakeholder interviews. We did 20 interviews talking to different people, everyone from Riverside homeowners to businesses, commercial property owners, people from recreation and natural resource organizations and so forth, understanding what are their major concerns. We then did a work session with the city where we were able to look through and see what for the specific context and site-specific circumstances and the regulatory systems that the city has, what makes sense for the city to pursue as far as policies. Many policies don't work that are from other areas. For example, a lot of landslide policy is managed at the county level in other parts of the country. With Home Rule, we mostly do municipal-level policy. and other things like that. So we took into consideration a wide array of circumstances and then we did what's called a trade-offs analysis. So taking those policy options that we had reduced it down to that were viable within the city of Westbrook, we then did a trade-offs analysis. So the city identified from the criteria that I brought to them, which are normal criteria, things like looking at efficiency and effectiveness and implementability and other elements like that. We did a trade-offs analysis identifying pros and cons for those specific policies and then did a comparative analysis. We just completed, literally hot off the press, we're a little bit tired and worn, three hours of work sorting through the options that we brought forward, and we're very pleased to say that we have moved forward with a number of elements that we're going to be able to present to stakeholders in the beginning of Right now, we are preparing to bring things to stakeholders. So we're going to have stakeholder roundtables in January and February, which we're very excited to bring these policy options forward and hear from the people of Westbrook. we're going to have one that focuses on homeowners and another one that focuses on businesses and we'll be prepared and be able to receive a lot of feedback and input once we do get that input the city is going to make some final decisions going to craft the actual policies and then you will be able to see those as they move forward and we hope very much to develop this our planning to develop this into a replicable toolkit so there's been this process that's been very structured that we've gone through. We're documenting all of that and bringing it forward to other communities in the region. So what did we learn from our stakeholder interviews? One of the things that was unanimous was that most people didn't know anything or much about the 2020 landslide. So there were a few people who remembered that it happened, but people couldn't recall a whole lot of details or whether or not they thought it whether or not they had not thought about whether they would happen again so most people thought it was a one-and-done and so people did not think you saw like every seven years there's a landslide in southern Maine that is definitely not on people's minds they do not think that landslides will happen in Westbrook again and as you just saw there have been many over time so I wanted to let you know that all interviewees that I spoke to stated that they would want to consider landslide risk in their decision-making. This is not something they take lightly. People want to understand what the impact is to them. They wanted to know the risk for their specific property. So this is one of the challenges of course that there's a lot of information that needs to go into that kind of decision-making. So the city is trying to think what can we provide to people as they're trying to make decisions and what is not possible and how can they be protective but not take away rights, all that fabulous balance that public policy brings. They want to act to reduce landslide risk. So every single person that I spoke to said that they really want the city to do something to make the city safer. They also feel that they are comfortable with some form of city regulation or permitting to protect the community. So 20 interviews isn't the whole community for sure, but it's enough of a conversation to say that there is an interest in doing something. And they did not have a clear idea of what those municipal actions could or should be. And that's because people don't know what landslides are, what they can do, what policies are available to them. So we're starting at ground zero with the policy planning that we're doing, but we want to help you understand and the people that you serve to understand what is it that we can do. So there are two different focuses that we can have. How do we protect existing development? So that's the bigger challenge. It's easier to tell people as they're planning to do something new what it is that they could do to prevent it but when you're talking about what you can do for existing development there are fewer things that we can do but one of the things we can do obviously is increase landslide awareness if you don't have any idea that something might happen you're certainly not going to be planning or thinking about it we can do emergency planning and preparation and we just heard about the fabulous emergency management folks public safety folks that are working with us on that we can secure funding and technical assistance to support property owners now one of the challenges with that and that was a deep conversation today was that we don't want to raise taxes for people or add permitting fees and things like that so how can we bring external funds into the city for that we can consider landslides during practices around drainage excavation stormwater management grading soil erosion and sediment control. So we're looking at best practices around that and how can we make people aware of what it is that they should do. We can also help interested property owners find access to insurance. So one of the things is that is very frustrating for most folks is that when a landslide occurs, it is considered under normal insurance policies to be an act of God. And because it is an act of God. It is not covered. So any losses, any harms, any reimbursement, none of that happens if it has been caused by a landslide. And so we want to have people think, wow, what could I do to increase my coverage? And so that those losses are not so severe. And so there is something called difference in condition insurance. And we're exploring what that means and how we can share that information with the people of Westbrook. There's also the idea of voluntary real estate disclosure and we have conversations about that you're going to have a chance to weigh in with definitely and we the city does not have jurisdiction to be able to require real estate disclosure and also to consider landslides when thinking about land use and open space in community planning and especially the city's upcoming comprehensive plan review process. So as we do planning, thinking about it, making sure that we're making smart decisions. So then also how do we affect change in new development? And this is where the options expand a little bit. We want to use information from technical reports to inform decisions. So we're always talking about having science-based policy, evidence-based decision-making. Informed, de-risked, all of those good words. And one of the things in policy analysis, you're often asking, should I do this or should I do that? And because of the circumstances specific to this, we actually want to create an additive policy environment where we have a tool belt of making sure that there are tools available to do the most appropriate thing in the right context and space and site. So we are, instead of saying we're going to do, you could say in another place, like we're going to do a subsidy or we're going to do a tax incentive. Obviously, neither of those relevant for here. But usually in a policy analysis, you're like, should I do this or should I do that? That's not what we're doing now. It's like, do we want a hammer on the belt? Do we want a screwdriver? Do we want a drill? What do we want available to us as tools? tools, not necessarily saying we would use any of those tools for a specific purpose. So what potential tools? Some of the things that are available to help with new development include subdivision and site plan review process considerations, building and blasting permit considerations, open space planning, and also the decision, having a decision tree framework. So one of the things that we're working very hard, I'm helping facilitate the city working very hard on is developing a process map and having a decision tree that allows people to understand where their risks are and then make appropriate decisions. And rather than saying no or denying permits, the ability to say, okay, you can do this, but you have to have these specific things in place if you want to. Again, de-risking the decision, helping understand what the additional cost and so forth might be. So we want things clear, simple, predictable. We want them designed to de-risk decision making, we want to avoid any unnecessary blanket requirements, and we want to use evidence to determine any extra considerations that are needed. So the next steps, as I mentioned before, are outreach and stakeholder engagement. We will have formal outreach, community outreach to communities in December. So there's some conversations that will be held in December and as well as some circulation of some new outreach materials like FAQs. We received, I have compiled a large number of questions that have been asked over time, and we're working away on answering those. And we also have some fact sheets that are going to be coming your way soon. And then we're going to have community informational meetings, which were starting very shortly here before the holidays, where people are going to learn about landslides, understand the process, and be invited to winter stakeholder meetings. And then in the very early months of 2027, we're going to have that homeowners or public and business community in March stakeholder policy roundtables. And at these, just to give you a little exciting moment here, I'm sure you're like, oh, I have been wanting to see this grid my whole life. On the left, you can see this is a policy tradeoffs grid with pros and cons by criteria. criteria, you will get to see the different policy options on the left-hand side, and then you're going to be able to see rated whether it's a strong outcome, a medium outcome, or a poor outcome. You'll get to look and compare by criteria so that you'll have the most informed capacity to make decisions. And then over on the right is an example of a decision tree. Actually, this is not the decision tree that we will be using, but it shows that we are constantly trying to make sure that people have the least amount of regulation possible. If you can show us that it is not at risk, if you can show us that what you're going to do is going to make this stable and safe, we are more than happy with you moving forward. So again these are going to be the kinds of tools that we use with stakeholders to help them understand exactly what their decisions they have in front of them. So I'm going to hand this back over to Robin. So the two things I want you all to remember, too, is this project is going to be over in September 2027. And our grant calls for us to share our findings with the five other municipalities in the Presumpt's Got River corridor. That's, you know, Portland, Falmouth, Gorham, Wyndham, Standish, who are all very much looking on to see what we're doing and interested. And we talk with them fairly regularly and second this is not just a westbrook issue right and it's not just a presumptive river corridor issue so it's a it's a coastal main issue it's a central main issue and so on and when our grant sundowns it would be fabulous to have an agency such as one of these on the screen to sort of pick up the baton and run with it because we have some really great information here and so far we've got main geologic survey who's ready to curate and validate all the landslide data we've got the main office of community affairs who's who has the state resiliency office who's interested very interested in all those policy tools that Brenda just talked with you about so that other susceptible communities can use the same model we've we've been using. And the main emergency management agency is updating their five-year state hazard mitigation plan and plans to include everything that we've done here in the state hazard mitigation plan, which is more than I had expected. So I'm pleasantly surprised. But in general, I just want us all to sort of understand that, as Councilor McCambridge said, we're all on this journey together. We're all learning together. And as we know better, we'll all do better together. And I just thank you from the bottom of my heart for your time and for the opportunity to work on this public safety and hazard mitigation project. it's really been a labor of love and the team that I'm working with is really truly amazing and the community that we are protecting is I think near and dear to all of us and I really appreciate your time and attention to this and thank you are there any questions Jen I just want to say thank [52:35] David Morse: you guys thank you to you and the team for pursuing the funding to look into of this and to dig so thoroughly into this. I think our community is safer because of the transparency and information that you guys are gathering. So I really appreciate what you're doing. Thank you. Thank you. Robin, excellent presentation as always. I do love the science and the math. So thank you. I appreciate that, Teresa. So you were watching in the audience or you're watching at home and you had questions about this presentation. How do I ask more [53:07] Robin Saunders: questions yeah so you can we have what is it community dev at westbrook.me.us or you can email me at r saunders at westbrook.me.us i'm happy to be the point of contact for questions because they are so complicated when they come in i'm happy to do that Is that what you're getting at? [53:38] David Morse: So, yeah, just if people have questions, I don't want to end here. Yes. Don't let it simmer. Just let it out. [53:47] Robin Saunders: We've updated the website so that it includes pretty much everything that you all have here. Tonight's presentation will go on the website. And we have a tentative list. My apologies. I meant to bring it. We have a tentative list of all the stakeholder meetings that we plan to start in December, January, February. kind of a thing that we're running around and we're passing around to everyone to have them take a look to make sure that the people that need to be there to help be presenters can be there. So I hope to have that to you all by the end of the week too. So this is not the last time people can participate, Councillor. Thank you. Thank you. [54:29] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): Yeah, I'd like to echo what President than Munro said and just convey my thanks. This has been a very comprehensive project. I think I've said it before, but I think Westbrook has led the way here. You know, you mentioned that other communities are waiting to see what we come up with. I think one of the hallmarks of good government is not kicking things down the road. And, you know, 2020, the landslide occurred. We could have just carried on, but we chose to look into it. And, you know, some of the information might not be what everyone was hoping for, but I think it's better to be informed. Just a specific question, the FAQs, and I've seen a draft of it, and it's very comprehensive. And I'm just wondering if you can give us some idea as to when people can expect the FAQs to be available. [55:18] Robin Saunders: Yeah, so I sent the FAQs last week to Maine Emergency Management Agency, main office of community affairs and others and if you all don't have any edits or anything on them, I'm happy to post it tomorrow. And understand too, counselor, where the FAQs came from are the stakeholder interviews that Brenda had done with the 20 or so trusted voices in our community and so the questions were generated there and as you know, there was like a list of 60 questions. And so these were just the preliminary questions. So this is part one. These were the easy ones that we can do. We'll have a part two probably after we get our technical advisory panel together of subject matter experts. So we'll have in another month, we'll have some more questions that we can answer. And people should really just go to our website, which is westbrookmaine.gov backslash landslide. Yes. Thank you, Mel. [56:25] David Morse: Councilor Shaughnessy? Yes, I'll just echo what they've said before. This was an amazing report. It's very, I love the science of it, if only it's so much to go into everything we look at. Must have had an academic in there someplace. But the words vulnerability is always something that kind of stuck with me. This is really, it's not saying that there is any landslide eminently going to happen anywhere but that they have certain soil stability components that would make them less stable or more stable and so I think you know for the public to think I live in it there's a lot of red out there and a lot of those areas that they're not likely to have a landslide but they have [57:18] Robin Saunders: have certain soil conditions correct that is correct and we all should get used to this map here with the blue and the green because we all live you know where there's presumptive formation you know so it's the presumptive formation goes hand in hand really with that vulnerability kind of a thing counselor to your point yeah so vulnerability doesn't mean that it's imminent a landslide is imminent. It just means that there are certain sensitivities that we should be aware of. [57:58] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): Yeah, and I don't want to mess with the format, but I know there are, I think there are some people here tonight, and there are probably some people watching on Zoom in terms of if they have questions, is that something we say to the public comment, or how do we? [58:14] David Morse: Mayor's message. So what triggered that 2020 landslide? What was it? Please state your name. Please state your name. Oh, I'm sorry. Ken Boston. I'm a resident of Westbrook. So what actually triggered that I'm curious [58:34] Teresa Patton: It's it's complicated what triggered it the exact cause okay, and there's lots of papers out there It's all free. You can just google it and read as much as you want about it, but in a nutshell There was a change in condition Okay, I mentioned that there was a stability analysis that was done before there was any activity at the site. And I mentioned there's things that can trigger it, and one of it's increasing the driving force. One way to increase the driving force is put a building or maybe a large stockpile of soil. Soil weighs a lot more than people think. It's on average 120 pounds per cubic foot is how much soil weighs. This is why they have OSHA standards that you can't go in an excavation that's deeper than four feet, because if that soil falls on someone they probably will die okay so soil weighs a lot so that's a huge thing but there's the other thing which the presumptive formation is really sensitive to is shaking when you shake the presumptive formation because of an earthquake because of some kind of vibratory construction equipment it will turn to water essentially and water can't resist any forces, okay? So that's what you want to prevent happening. You want your presumptive formation to stay solid because it's strong if it's not disturbed, okay? And actually there's some other really good things out there that happen to the presumptive formation, the way it formed. There's this thing called the clay crust and it's really strong. And that's why you can build a lot in Maine because that clay crust is really strong and a lot of times the softer gooey part doesn't even know you built anything okay so if you add a load and you add shaking and you maybe do some erosion at the toe of your slope we had that picture that diagram that had a slope imagine if at the bottom you decided to do some excavation to maybe put a road in or a building you've now removed some of that resistance that would be like me taking that rock that I talked about me trying to push, or this podium, and I started hacking away at part of the part that's holding it up. It would make it easier for me to move. So those, it's a combination of a lot of things. I think there's also talk about that we were in a drought situation at the time, which means the water level was lower. Believe it or not, the water holds back the banks. I mean, we all see that when the tides go out. Sometimes it sloughs when you're, if you're over by the ocean somewhere. So that water helps. So if you're in a drought situation, you might, you're not going to have as much resisting forces there. Okay. And then say you get a big rainstorm. Water weighs a lot more than people think too. That's 62 pounds per cubic foot. So it's pretty heavy. So when the water rains on the top of a slope and it's just sitting there, it hasn't gotten into that equilibrium state. When everything's in equilibrium, everything's fine. it's when you make sudden changes and clay can't handle sudden changes free draining material what you say to put under a road when you're building a road or if you built a driveway in your house or you wonder why things you don't get potholes it's because there's free draining materials can handle clay doesn't do that so much so there isn't one thing that made that happen there were several things that made that happen and that's where it comes in with the policy because several of those things you can prevent. Certain things you can't. The rainstorm, the drought, can't prevent those. Those are going to happen. But potentially building at the top of a slope or construction at the bottom of a slope or certain vibratory equipment or blasting or something like that. So I don't know if that completely answers your question or gives you much of the answer you want. [1:02:30] David Morse: Can you come up to the podium? Excuse me, can you come up to the podium? I want the public to be able to hear your question. You know my name, so. The question is, I mean, was there a significant event that happened? Did it all, did it happen at once? Was it a landslide that occurred over a period of weeks or months? Was it, you know, acute, chronic? I mean, I wasn't living in Maine at the time. That was the question. [1:02:55] Teresa Patton: I'm sorry. It was acute. It happened right away. The activities happened relatively quickly in the sense that I mentioned clay doesn't react very quickly. So what was going on at that site probably went over a couple days and then accumulated to this. Anyway, so that's... Was there anybody online? [1:03:25] David Morse: No. No hands online. Okay. Thank you, Robin. That's all from me. Next, Ronda, City Council Messages. Does anyone have anything they'd like to share? Oh, Councilor Chauncey. I just got to say thank you for coming to the Friends of the Presumptive Scott, Mayor Morris, and it was great having you there and thanks for your kind words and you've actually made much more of an explanation than I had the chance to before my wife dragged me off at the meeting. So there's a lot to talk about. Dr. Chow? Yes, I want to invite everyone and anyone you know to the Westbrook High School senior class. They're having a project graduation fundraiser. They're doing a 5K this Sunday. There's going to be a kids' race before that, and then there'll be a 5K. We have everything planned. We have a DJ. We have all kinds of fun things going on, and we're looking for someone to run it now. So we have the volunteers, but no runners. So please join our 5K. It's for the Project Graduation 2027. This is so we can have a safe event for the graduating seniors of 2027 and a fun place to go after graduating. So please support the 5K. You can find out more information online. If you do a Google search of Westbrook Turkey Trot 5K, you should find the link to that and sign up. So please run and please walk or crawl or however you want to do that or just pay for the ticket and don't come. We do need more people to run the race. But thank you. Anyone else? Okay. No student council update. On to our first public comment. If you'd like to come up and speak, please state your name, whether you're a resident of Westbrook, and if you wanted to share what ward you're in, we can follow up with you, and you will have three minutes. Is there anyone online? There are no hands online. Okay.
Unfinished Business
[1:05:37] David Morse: There's no unfinished business, and on to Orders of the Day, Second and Final Reading, Order 2026-122. This is Order 2026-122, found on page 43 of your packet, authorizing sale of 12 Water Street. What are the wishes of the Council? Councillor Chau? Yes, I'd like to make a motion for the following two orders for second and final reading. These will be read by title only as we have discussed this in detail in other meetings. Order number 2026-122, authorizing sale of 12 Water Street. And order number 2026-123, approving the 2026-2029 collective bargaining agreement with the Westbrook Essential Services Unit. Is there a second? Councillor McCambridge? ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE COUNCIL? ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC? OKAY. ROLL CALL, PLEASE. COUNCILOR MCCAMBRIDGE? YES. VICE PRESIDENT SEANESSEE? YES. COUNCILOR TROY? YES. COUNCILOR TURKOT? YES. COUNCILOR FAULKIUM? YES. AND PRESIDENT MONROE? YES.
New Business
[1:06:43] David Morse: ALL IN FAVOR, NONE OPPOSED. ON TO NEW BUSINESS. THERE'S NO BUSINESS LICENSES. ON TO RESOLVE 2026-19. THIS WAS RESOLVED 2026-19, FOUND ON PAGE 109 OF YOUR packet. Centering City Councilor Anna Turcotte. What are the wishes of the Council? Councilor Shaughnessy. I'll move Resolve 2026-19 censoring City Councilor Anna Turcotte. The Westbrook City Council believes that free and open debate between differing opinions is central to a functioning city government and ensures the best outcomes for Westbrook's residents. evidence. Productive discussions are only possible where issues before the Council are evaluated based on their merits and positions and opinions of the public. Other Councillors and City administration are treated with respect. The City Council adopted the Rules of Order to foster discussion and debate. However, those rules are only effective when Councillors respect and abide by them. During the city council meeting held on October 19th, 2026, Councillor Turcotte breached the rules of order. Councillor Turcotte made statements that did not address the issue before the council and instead directly attacked and demeaned the personal motivations and intentions of the city administration, calling them disgusting and corrupt. Additionally, Councillor Councilor Turcotte failed to honor repeated calls to points of order. Statements in conduct of this kind violate failed to honor repeated calls, failed to violate Section 5 of the City Council Rules of Order, undermine the function of the City Council and City Administration, and do not advance the entrance of Westbrook's residents. The City Council strongly disagrees with and does not condone Councilor Turcotte's statements or conduct. The City Council hereby censors Councilor Anna Turcotte for the above violations of Section 5 of the City Council Rules of Order. The City Council urges Councilor Turcotte to reflect on her statements and conduct and to offer an apology to the Council and City Administration. That's the first and final reading. Thank you. Is there a second? Councilor McCambridge? I JUST WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO SPEAK ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF THE RESOLUTION AND MORE BROADLY THE STANDARDS THAT WE HOLD OURSELVES TO AS ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES OF THIS COMMUNITY. IN THE PAST FIVE YEARS AS A COUNSELOR, I HAVE DISAGREED WITH ALL OF MY COLLEAGUES AT ONE POINT OR ANOTHER. I THINK THAT IS A FUNDAMENTAL PART OF WHAT WE DO IN ORDER TO MAKE CHANGES THAT ARE BEST FOR THE CITY. I BELIEVE DEEPLY IN OPEN GOVERNMENT, TRANSPARENCY AND THE ABILITY TO CHALLENGE ONE ANOTHER. we are not always going to agree and we shouldn't healthy debate difficult questions and differing perspectives are essential to good governance in fact they are part of what makes our responsibility as elected officials so important on october 19th during the debate on the recreation and conservation commission ordinance i called a point of order and asked counselor turcott to return to the merits of the proposal section 5a asks each of us to stay with the question before the council and avoid abusive language and personal attacks I brought this resolution forward because I think the council has a responsibility to uphold the rules we've all agreed to follow especially when debate gets heated there was a distinction between challenging an idea questioning a decision proposing new ideas and making personal attacks we can disagree strongly without making these disagreements personal we can hold each other in our administration accountable while still treating each other people who work for and serve the city with dignity and respect. Our rules of order exist for a reason. They provide a framework that allows every member to participate, ensures discussion remains productive, and protects the integrity of this governing body. Those expectations apply equally to every one of us, regardless of our position, perspective, or level of disagreement. This resolution asks us to acknowledge that there are standards of conduct that come with serving in public office. It also The council reinforces that our responsibility extends beyond representing our individual opinions. We represent an entire community, and the way we conduct ourselves reflects on the city of Westbrook as a whole. As council president, I take seriously my responsibility to ensure that the council operates in a respectful, professional, and productive manner. That means allowing difficult conversations to happen, but also ensuring that the rules and expectations we have established are respected. ULTIMATELY WE SHOULDN'T BE ABLE TO LEAVE THE CHAMBER KNOWING WE HAVE TREATED OUR COLLEAGUES, OUR NEIGHBORS, AND OUR PEERS WITH RESPECT EVEN IF WE DISAGREE. THAT IS THE STANDARD OUR RESIDENTS DESERVE AND THAT IS THE STANDARD WE SHOULD EXPECT OF OURSELVES. ANY OTHER COUNCIL DISCUSSION? I JUST WANT TO SAY I HAVE GIVEN THIS A LOT OF THOUGHT AND SOMETHING LIKE THIS IS NOT SOMETHING THAT ONE TAKES slightly in any regard. I also want to say this is less about Councilor Turcotte as a person. I have a deep respect and regard for Councilor Turcotte. She brings a lot and has brought a lot to this council. She brings a depth of knowledge, insight, amazing life experiences, and phenomenal skills and compassion and although one may or may not agree it's not even about the concerns that were at the root of the sentiment expressed it is about the particular comments stated and how they violated our rules of order and Robert's rules of order the refusal also to comply to the leadership of the council to bring focus to the comments is an issue as well this is regrettably necessary because they both sort of demean the individuals that they were the cut that the comments were addressing the council as a whole and I think this us as an example of public service, it can tarnish that in the eyes of many. This is really a reprimand, sadly it's a vote against one of our own members for this misconduct, for an unbecoming behavior if you will and it is kind of a collective call for civility And sadly, in this day and age, it's something that needs to be done. It's uncomfortable, but regrettably, it must be undertaken. Any other councillors? Councillor Turcotte. [1:13:49] Anna Turcotte: All right. Tonight, the Westbrook City Council is voting to censure me for statements the city administration, the mayor, and the city council president did not like. Productive discussions are not possible under our constitutional guarantees. grantees when the elected members of the council are silenced. The rules were not followed by the president herself. You can't state point of order to interrupt someone without citing to the rule that's being allegedly raised. I've been elected to this seat four times by an overwhelming majority of the vote, facing many strong opponents. My constituents trust me, appreciate my service, and my direct style. In fact, I receive an outpouring of support from constituents who are Democrats, Republicans, and Independents after my statement. In my public statements, I did not insult anyone. I asked hard questions, and I offered my honest opinion, that sometimes is a dissenting one. I have been elected by the residents of my ward to ask hard questions and to give my honest opinion, and that's what I have done, and that's what I will continue to do as an American. I would further note that no part of my comment was aimed at any member of the council, nor the council itself. Therefore, it would certainly appear that this criticism of me comes from outside of the members of this council. Having said that, I will continue to represent my constituents in the same manner as I have for the last 11 years and with all due respect to consortiancy you've known me for close to 10 years my last name is turcott please pronounce it correctly counter [1:15:37] David Morse: show yes all right so granted i've never read robert's rules orders and but there's a thing called respect and we need to show respect to one another and it doesn't matter what the opinion is i have really crazy ideas and opinions. You guys know that. I don't care what you guys think, quite frankly. It doesn't matter to me. Hopefully, I'm always speaking for my constituents. I'm always watching out for them. I want to make sure they're protected and not harmed, and the city is in good shape. I really think the constituents of Westbrook, they want a good government. They want it functioning well. They want things running well. They want things done on time. They want their roads plowed. They want their trash picked. They want all the great things. They want a good government. I don't know if they care who's behind the seat. They just want things running well. and like it or not it's not us that make the city run well when you think of the city of westbrook hope you don't think of us because we're just temporary here we come and go all the time and you know and you know it's it's not the real city of westbrook is the administrators start with city administrator angela holmes jerry bryant starts from the top then it goes to department heads and their employees those are the people who make the city of westbrook great it's not us they do all the work when it's cold and stormy at night eric will pick up his phone and make sure that things are all right during covid that the phone everyone's phones are ringing 24 7 and the administrators were answering the phones dealing with issues Our employees are the natural resources of Westbrook. And we all should honor and cherish them. They are amazing people. I'm so proud of the department heads we have here, the employees, everybody. And all these department heads are just so, modest. When I say good job, they say it wasn't me, it was my employees or whatever. But they all do a great job. Everybody from top down does a great job. So when we attack our employees, that one sets a bad example, and it creates instability where maybe the employees feel like they can attack their department heads because the city council does it. I'm not sure, but our employees are the jewels of the city. You want to ask the city of Biddeford how easy it is to find a city administrator. They went through two just recently. It wasn't easy to get that job. We're lucky to have the staff we have here. And everything that we do up here should support the city staff and make sure that they're well supported and they have what they need to do a good job. They do a great job. They love the city. They work so hard. I'm just so proud of everyone here, all the employees. You guys do a great job. So, whatever happens, I hope, you know, if you guys want to beat up on me, that's fine. I have real thick skin. But please leave the city employees alone and thank them for the hard work they do. And that's the only message I want to say here, that we need to make sure that we have a good government by having stable department heads and stable employees. Because who's going to work here? If they see some meetings on TV or attend meetings in person, knowing that anything of this, all these things could happen, it's going to be hard to find employees if we allow this to happen. So I'm not a big fan of saying anything bad about anyone, especially our employees. I will not be voting for censure, though, after this long speech. I apologize. I've been a subject of some sort of city council action myself. And I will not put anyone else through that. I went through hell for having a different opinion on how the city should run. And I just don't think it's fair. So I will not be censoring anyone in my terms. But that doesn't say I don't support our employees, our staff, our city administrator. She's awesome. So that's all I have to say. Anyone else? [1:20:29] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): Council Member Cambridge? yeah i will be supporting this resolve i mean i want to echo what councillor chow said about the city administration like i've been on the finance committee for the past year and i have found them to have great dedication and integrity i mean i admire councillor turcotte and i have a lot of admiration for her but and the point of order stuff i think that's to me that's heat of the moment the what crossed the line for me was the remark about corruption I thought that was in my opinion that was baseless and unwarranted so I will be supporting the resolve thank you anyone [1:21:08] David Morse: else I was wondering if the city solicitor come up and kind of explain the port of order for the public and the councillors and whoever else is tuned in good [1:21:25] Cameron Ferrante: evening Cameron Ferrante city solicitor so a point of order in terms of like parliamentary procedure is basically like a pause button so you can use it to correct mistakes or to bring someone back into compliance with the rules so say you know someone makes a motion out of order or you call for a vote before there's been a second someone could call point of order to bring you back and say hey there needs to be a second on this before we can proceed and then you have an opportunity to correct you can also use a point of order to cease debate on something if there's a continuing violation of the code of conduct or the rules of parliamentary procedure. And that would be the type of a point of order that was called on October 19th. And generally, when a point of order is called either by the council president or the chair who's presiding over any committee meeting, debate ceases. It can It can also be called by a member of the council generally in the event the council chair or the committee chair or the council president doesn't call for a point of order themselves. So the way it works is the point of order is called. It can be called generally. It can be called with specificity towards the rules. But debate at that point ceases. Discussion ceases. The council president then rules on the point of order. if the person against who the point of order was called disagrees they can appeal it and then it goes to a vote of the council or the chair themselves or the council president herself could also request a vote of the body to sustain or overrule the point of order but essentially it's a pause button once somebody calls a point of order debate stops you can then request further clarification on the issue to be addressed and then rule on it or you can send it to the full body for an appeal or a decision to sustain or overrule thank you any other discussion [1:23:23] David Morse: from the council any discussion from the public if you'd like to come up you have three minutes please state your name and whether you're a resident of westbrook yeah my name's anthony [1:23:38] Doms: doms i live at [address] i'm in ward 3 and i can't believe i'm about to do this I say that only half-kidding. I ran against Councillor Terracott the last time the Ward 3C was up. It's more than fair to say that we don't see eye-to-eye on some things. When I saw the agenda for tonight, I'd look at most of the agendas. I saw what was on it, and it caused me to go back and watch most of the October 19th meeting. What I saw was someone passionate about preserving power to citizens, a philosophy I generally agree with I think censoring a counselor for what happened in that meeting is an irresponsible use of that tool I believe we should be able to criticize government at all levels and if you're going to work for the public you need to expect to be criticized from time to time it's part of the job we have to make tough decisions and not everybody's going to agree with all of those decisions i think that's the healthy part of our of our government i didn't think the language in that meeting rose to a level that merits a censure and i hope that when you consider my words you'll weigh the fact that i'm probably the last person that should be up here defending counselor turcotte thanks thank you anyone [1:25:06] David Morse: else please state your name and what you're a resident of Westbrook. [1:25:17] Chuck Ellis: My name is Chuck Ellis, and I'm a resident of Westbrook Ward 5, I think. And I'm here tonight because I find the council's decision to censure Councilor Anna Turcotte deeply troubling. And I would like to thank Victor for agreeing that it's not a good idea to censure her. I think that's the right decision. I don't always agree with Councilor Turcotte. I think I've had a couple of arguments with her husband as well. But, you know, when this council voted to eliminate the Recreation and Conservation Commission, a body that had served the city since 1970, she was the only person willing to stand up against it. And she was right to raise those concerns. More than 50 years of public service were erased in a single meeting. No meaningful opportunity for the public to weigh in. a first and final reading, which those seem like, you know, I'm a novice here. But those are supposed to be reserved, I believe, for emergencies and routine housekeeping, not decisions that fundamentally change things in such a significant way without giving people the opportunity to participate, including the members of that commission. I also want to address something that Victor said, that the administration is more permanent and the council is temporary. Well, While I think that is true, it fundamentally misses the point about our form of government. The administration is responsible for carrying out the city's work, but the counselors are the people elected by the residents to provide oversight and direction. You are the authority elected to oversee the administration. I appreciate your care and concern for wanting to take care of your employees. I do appreciate that. But the reality is the city council needs to be able to meaningfully discuss things that are done by the administration, and there are arguments about exactly how that should play out. But I do think that it's really important for the council to be able to talk that stuff out, which you guys are generally required to do in front of the public. Maybe not every situation. Obviously, there's executive session. But I think this is a bigger issue. And I think focusing on a few comments by Councilor Turcotte is a minor issue compared to what happened with the commission. So that's what I have to say. Anyone else? [1:27:34] John Turcotte: Good evening. My name is John Turcotte. I also live in Westbrook. I just wanted to fill in one blank that was left by the city's attorney there which is when a point of order is raised the person making the point of order has to indicate what their inquiry is whether it's a Rule, it's a procedure. It's a point of order. Mr President and you cite whatever the question is you can't just say point of order to interrupt people and I know your council agreed That's not actually allowed Normally when a point of order is raised by a member of a board the chair then resolves in this case the president in this case the president said point of order and nothing else. And if you watch the video, which I hope you did before you vote tonight, in each instant, Councilor Turcotte paused, nothing else was said. So I just want to be very clear, when you do a point of order, if you're going to play by Robert's rules of orders, and this is said to every municipal attorney who practices, you've got to play by the rules. Thank you. Anyone else? [1:28:36] David Morse: Ken Fawson, resident of Ward 4. Good evening, council members. I've moved to Westbrook almost two and a half years ago. As time has allowed, I've watched or attended some city council meetings, not nearly as often as I would have liked. Frankly, I'm shocked at the lack of diversity of opinions expressed in these meetings. It is obvious that you come to these meetings just to rubber stamp some things that have been discussed in private, not in the public. okay that's not how a democratic republic runs you are to debate things in front of us and argue and have differences of opinions that's what we expect of you your discussion and your decisions and debates need to be made public as they are as they are in washington so we know not only the decisions that are made but the thinking process and motivations behind them On the October 19th meeting, Councilwoman Turcotte expressed opposition to the change in the planning board to a committee and expressed the reasons. It was a rare example of a contrary opinion by a board member being made in public. Very rare. I think I've only seen it one other time. In her talk, she expressed concerns about motives. could that be because she saw what was going on behind the scenes is that possible now i see where you are bringing up censoring her for the meeting so i went back and i reviewed that video at least five times i listened to it very carefully okay i read section five of your rules of order and see nothing wrong with what she said that evening nothing did she question motives yes Is that a violation of these rules? Absolutely not. It is not a violation of the rules. I'm 66 years old. I used to believe that there were good people and bad people. But I've been a Christian for 40 years. And I came to realize there are not good people and bad people. There are only bad people. It's just some of us are better at hiding it than others. That's the truth and the reality of the condition of man. Okay? Each of you has power over citizens as a result of your position. Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Her questioning of the motives is justified, and it's not against the rules to do that publicly. In fact, it's her duty. Thank you. Sentry, Ms. Turcotte, is an attempt to send a message that you better not speak up publicly against the will of this body, or you will be punished. That is not how a democratic republic works. We need to see more actions like that in this committee. Now, you may want to have your things tempered a little bit the next time. Okay, I understand that. But there needs to be dissent. Thank you, Ms. Turcotte, and God bless you. You're welcome. Anyone else? Is there anyone online? I see no hands on Zoom. Okay. Roll call, please. Councillor McCambridge? Yes. Vice President Shaughnessy? Yes. Councillor Chau? No. Councillor Volkham? Yes. President Monroe? Yes. I'm sorry, do I? Councillor Turcotte, excuse me? Absolutely not. And President Monroe? Yes. Four in favor, two opposed. On to Orders of the Day, one review required. This is Order 2026-124, found on page 118 of your packet, WHAT ARE THE WISHES OF THE COUNCIL? [1:32:46] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte): I MOVE ORDER 2026-125, AUTHORIZING ACCEPTANCE AND EXPENDITURE OF DISTRACTED DRIVING ENFORCEMENT GRANT THAT THE WEST BROOKS CITY COUNCIL HEREBY AUTHORIZES THE ACCEPTANCE AND EXPENDITURE OF A MAIN BUREAU OF HIGHWAY SAFETY DISTRACTED DRIVING ENFORCEMENT GRANT IN THE AMOUNT OF $10,390 FOR DISTRACTED DRIVING ENFORCEMENT. as outlined in the attached exhibit grant funds to be credited to the stated line except expenditure to be deducted from the stated line is there a second i [1:33:20] David Morse: just would like to clarify this is order 2026 124 oh yep we're under orders for one reading required 2018 on [1:33:35] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte): what i'm reading it's written 120 it's 2026-125 on what i am reading to go up one more [1:33:42] David Morse: to the previous order. [1:33:54] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte): Got it. Sorry. So what's the procedure? Do I just read the correct one now? [1:34:02] David Morse: Yes, we'll just have you read the correct one. Okay. [1:34:04] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte): I move order 2026-124, accepting unappropriated funds report for first quarter fiscal year 2027 that the Westbrook City Council hereby accepts the unappropriated funds report for the first quarter of fiscal year 2027. in accordance with order 2021-121 thank you sir second councillor shaughnessy any discussion [1:34:31] David Morse: minister homes so [1:34:37] City Administrator / Staff: this is part of the quarterly unappropriated funds report for first quarter of fiscal year 2027 this is in accordance with order 2021-121 which is adopted back in 2021 these are the transactions that are reported to council on a quarterly basis Unappropriated funds in the amount of $5,000 or more do require council authorization. So this includes a summary of all of the unappropriated funds received and expended and is for your review this evening. [1:35:13] David Morse: Any discussion from the council? Any discussion from the public? Roll call, please. Councilor McCambridge? Yes. Vice President Shaughnessy? Yes. Councilor Chau? Yes. Councilor Turcotte? Yes. Councilor Falchion? Yes. And President Monroe. Yes. All in favor, none opposed. On to Orders of the Day, two readings required. Order 2026-125. This is Order 2026-125, found on page 122 of your packet. Authorizing acceptance and expenditure of distracted driving enforcement grant. What are the wishes of the council? Councilor Shaughnessy. I'll move Order 2026-125, authorizing acceptance and expenditure of distracted driving enforcement grant that the Westbrook City Council hereby authorizes the acceptance and expenditure of a main Bureau of Highway Safety distracted driving enforcement grant in the amount of $10,390 for distracted driving enforcement as outlined in the attached exhibit. Grants will be placed in the credit to the following stated budget lines. Thank you. Is there a second? Councilor Chau, any discussion? [1:36:26] City Administrator / Staff: I WOULD LIKE TO GIVE A SHOUT-OUT TO OUR POLICE DEPARTMENT FOR SECURING ANOTHER GRANT TO ASSIST WITH OUR DRIVING ENFORCEMENT DETAILS HERE IN WESTBURG. THIS IS FOR $10,390 FOR THE MAIN BUREAU OF HIGHWAY SAFETY. THANK YOU. [1:36:42] David Morse: ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE COUNCIL? THANK YOU TO CHIEF AND YOUR DEPARTMENT FOR FINDING THESE GRANTS. YOU GUYS ARE REALLY, SUCCESSFUL AT THIS. WE APPRECIATE IT. ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC OR FROM THE COUNCIL? COMMUNITY? OKAY. ROLL CALL, PLEASE. THIS CAN BE A SHOW OF HANDS. OH, YES. SHOW OF HANDS, ALL IN FAVOR? ALL IN FAVOR, NONE OPPOSED. ON TO ORDER OF THE DAY, ORDER 2026-126. THIS IS ORDER 2026-126, FOUND ON PAGE 126 OF YOUR POCKET, AUTHORIZING AWARD A BID FOR PARKING GARAGE SNOW REMOVAL. THANK YOU. WHAT ARE THE WISHES OF THE COUNCIL? [1:37:23] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): council member cambridge i move for the first order a first reading of order 2026-126 authorizing award of bid for parking garage snow removal that the westbrook city council hereby authorizes an award of bid for snow removal services at the riverfront garage and downtown parking garage to glidden excavating and paving ink of gorham main for a period of three years with a two-year mutual option extension as outlined in the attached exhibit funds are available in the [1:37:54] David Morse: stated budget line thank you is there a second councillor chow any discussion administrator homes [1:38:02] City Administrator / Staff: so this is an item as councillor mccambridge read into the record authorizing an award of bid to glidden excavating and paving for snow removal services at our two garages the riverfront parking garage and the downtown parking garage for a three-year period with a mutual option two-year extension. Historically, we've brought forward an RFP, a request for an award of bid for snow plowing at the Riverfront parking garage. This one this year also includes the downtown parking garage. We were asked to consider including this garage for these services so that our employees can be redeployed out in the streets for snow removal services. So we bid the RFP that way, and we are asking for your authorization to authorize that award of bid this evening. Funds for the snow removal service at the downtown parking garage are available this year in the public services reserve account, which has been funded with $50,000 through the garage operations and maintenance reimbursement received through a settlement agreement THAT THE CITY OF WESTBROOK, CITY COUNCIL, VOTED ON IN ORDER 2026-55, AND IN THE FUTURE, SNOW REMOVAL SERVICES, FUNDS FOR THAT WOULD BE INCORPORATED INTO THE ANNUAL OPERATING BUDGET. SO THIS IS FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION THIS EVENING. THANK YOU. [1:39:26] David Morse: ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE COUNCIL? I DO HAVE A QUESTION. GIVEN THAT SNOW LOADS AND SNOW FALLS AREN'T PREDICTABLE, IS this one set, and if it goes, there's a lot heavier or it's a lot lighter? [1:39:48] City Administrator / Staff: So the way that these bids are structured is that they are responsible for all snow removal for the entire season. No matter the amount of snow that lands on the roof of these garages, it needs to be removed as quickly as possible because as the sun melts it during the day and refreezes at night, that can really cause damage to the concrete and to the sealants in between the double T's. So this is all-inclusive of those. Plus, during the snow events, they're in there treating with calcium-magnesium acetate, which is really the safest de-icer that you can use for the concrete. It attacks the concrete less than other alternatives, so there is an expense for that as well. [1:40:33] David Morse: I get that. But my question is, if you have four snow, major snow events, or if you have eight major snow events, this is one set amount. Is there any variation relative to that? [1:40:47] City Administrator / Staff: No, there is not. We're pretty consistently between 20 to 22 storms a winter. I don't think we see much less than that and sometimes a little bit more. You know, it's, I mean, varies maybe as little as 18 as matches 25, 26. Yeah. [1:41:09] David Morse: Any other discussion from the council? Yeah. Councilman Cambridge? [1:41:13] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): And the primary driver for this is the time, is to get those roofs cleared so that other surfaces can then be cleared? Like, what's the primary driver? [1:41:26] City Administrator / Staff: That's a great question. It's a few things. One, especially when it snows and, you know, at periods of time, we get back-to-back-to-back storms. storms. And so our crews are battling that storm, plowing the streets, plowing the sidewalks, getting those things cleared during the storm. And so they need some recovery time to be able to like get ready to go and then do snow removal at the parking garage. Also, we try to get to like the ADA ramps on all the downtown crosswalks as quickly as possible because those can be really challenging to get during a storm. And then we start to remove snow from the sides of the streets in the downtown business district on Main Street and the parking lots and then over onto Brown Street as well. And we found in the last two winters when we're in there doing the snow removal after the storms at the downtown garage, we're slower to get to those other important things. And so adding those things together, we feel that it's a reprioritization of our own crews to be able to meet the residents' and business owners' needs. Okay. Thank you. [1:42:39] David Morse: Elder Chow? Yes, thank you. Through you to the administration, just to clarify, we have two garages in Westbrook. One's the Riverfront Parking Garage. Where are the funds coming from for it to do this? So the funds for the Riverfront Parking Garage are partially [1:42:54] City Administrator / Staff: offset by the lease agreement that we have for the Riverfront Parking Garage itself. [1:43:00] David Morse: Okay. And the same thing goes with the second garage, the downtown parking garage, they're offset as well. [1:43:06] City Administrator / Staff: So these ones are offset by a slightly different format. So the city of Westbrook received through a settlement agreement with TDB LLC $50,000 in the garage and operate garage operations and maintenance reimbursement amount. And so those are the funds that we will be allocating towards the year one costs of this parking garage. And in the future, parking management plans that we adopt in the future for our downtown parking garage, revenue from that will help offset any of these maintenance costs. [1:43:47] David Morse: along that we anticipate that this will save us money than having to hire more staff or buy more equipment to meet the demands and the needs and help respond to our downtown needs [1:44:02] City Administrator / Staff: specifically within the city as eric mr dudley just explained it allows us to redeploy our resources more effectively to have our streets cleaner in a more timely manner and help make SURE THOSE PRIORITY AREAS DOWN ON THE STREETS ARE CLEARED. [1:44:18] David Morse: THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE FROM THE COUNCIL? ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC? OK. SHOW OF HANDS, ALL IN FAVOR? ALL IN FAVOR, NONE OPPOSED. ON TO ORDER 2026-127. THIS IS ORDER 2026-127 FOUND ON PAGE 144 OF YOUR POCKET, AUTHORIZING EXPENDITURE FOR NEW FLOORING AT WESTPORT COMMUNITY CENTER. WHAT ARE THE WISHES OF THE COUNCIL? Councillor [1:44:50] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): Mcimbridge. I move for the first reading of order 2026-127 authorising expenditure for new flooring at Westbrook Community Centre at the Westbrook City Council hereby authorises an expenditure of $19,999.86 to Sherwin Williams of South Portland, Maine for the purchase and installation of new flooring in the media centre within the children's wing at the Westbrook community center as outlined in the attached exhibit funds are available in the stated budget [1:45:20] David Morse: line is there a second counter chow any discussion administrator holmes so this is an item that has [1:45:28] City Administrator / Staff: been brought forward by our director of community services greg post who is here this evening to replace the flooring in the media center for those of you that attended westbrook junior high This is the old library, and the flooring in there is carpet, it is ripping, it is buckling, and it needs to be replaced to be more usable. It is used right now for some of our learns before and after programming, access through the children's wing hallway, but those doors can also be locked and it can be accessed through the public accessible hallway as well. So in replacing the flooring, Greg, if you wouldn't mind coming on up to help address this, community services had a suggestion that not only should we replace the flooring, but let's enhance its usability by providing some alternative recreational options for people. The demand for indoor recreational space has exploded as seen through the success that we've had at the Westbrook Community Center and the programming opportunities that the staff there have on offer for our community. And so I would like to allow him to speak to that, if you don't mind, and to address the funding source for this as well. Yeah, thank you very much. Yeah, as alluded to, we opened up our Todd the Room almost four years ago. That'll be January of this coming year. And in that time, in four years, it's crazy. It's been way greater than we ever thought. We've done 444 birthday parties, and we're coming up with just shy of 10,000 drop-ins. So the ability to generate some additional revenue just exceeded $150,000 in just under four years. It's been way beyond our wildest dreams in terms of just taking a room that was underutilized and kind of transforming it. the thing with that is it's it's a preschool it's a toddler it's really it kind of maxes out at age six so one thing we've looked at with this new space is we've reimagined it kind of in a in a sense that it does as mentioned it's it's part of our learns program our before and after school program it's part of our camps our summer our summer camp but it also has public space as well so rather than trying to kind of fight those two and see it as a challenge we've really kind of looked at a way to embrace that so we've really taken it on and tried to find a way to really find a way to bring it into really all these different opportunities so continuing to use it for our before and after school program, vacation, summer camps, tying it into our Redwood Society program where we can actually activate this for programming for our seniors in our 50 plus program. Our project graduation events, it's some additional revenue because now we can activate some additional space for that. Some corporate team building events, public use during the day, very similar to what we do with our treehouse room and our toddler open play during the day. But it really fills this void, this niche for our 8 to 12-year-old birthday parties and kind of that void that we aren't currently filling. The way we envision this is to include a turf bocce court, shuffleboard court, three-hole mini golf, table tennis, pop-a-shot basketball, and some other additional recreational activities. So when we're utilizing it for our children's programs, we open it up and we access it from the children's side. Otherwise, that side becomes closed, and then we're able to activate it from the public side as well. Staffing is minimal for birthday parties. We're able to, again, activate it with our Gaga Pit, which for some reason I don't get it, but that thing is insanely popular. We've also got the tables. So for us to be able to activate two spaces for birthday parties works out really well. But very much like our gymnasium floor this past year, the funding source for this would be 100% through donations. We've got great community partners here. Our partnership with Colette Tours, we've done trips, music cities, Ireland, Portugal. All these things have been able to generate some donations through Colette back to us. for programming. We've also got Convenient MD, Westbrook Warren Church, Westbrook Warren Rotary. They've dedicated some money towards our Redwood program for our adult program for seniors to be able to activate some things for them. Friends of Feral Felines each year does a fundraiser and they provide a small donation back to buy some children's supplies or to do some additional children's programming so we've got these different partnerships that we've been able to activate that are really excited about this opportunity that we're able to kind of build this space out tap into something we never have before and really activate it for all these different opportunities and different demographics so we're pretty excited about doing that and if approved we can get underway really quickly and turn this around for a January opening and that would give us six months of usage and revenue before we turn this [1:51:10] David Morse: fiscal year over. So any questions? Incredible. Thank you. I'm really excited about this. I saw all the different types of flooring and it's exciting what you'll be able to do with this [1:51:21] City Administrator / Staff: space. Our staff loves it too. We went in, we ripped out the carpets, the cove base. What else? We ended up saving ourselves about $5,000 by doing some of the work ourselves. So we're like good at this it's like an hour it was perfect save five thousand dollars in an hour it [1:51:36] David Morse: was pretty good thank you thank you guys for that work councillor chow yes i want to thank director post for running the community center it's it was not easy and you've done an amazing job people come to this community center and all kinds of activities i see posts from the all the trips you do for the seniors and the veterans and just that area is so wonderful my wife goes there every morning to exercise kids people go swim every day ready kids and just the amazing job that you're doing is wonderful we thank you for transforming this old dilapidated school into this wonderful fun place that the community didn't go to we're just yeah it's a it's a great spot and thank you for leading the charge [1:52:25] City Administrator / Staff: thank you no we're lucky you guys have always been great and our staff is exceptional so thank you [1:52:29] Anna Turcotte: yes i wanted to reflect on just the a decade of changes that i've seen personally having kids in that facility and seeing the leadership change and really APPRECIATE THE STEADINESS OF YOUR LEADERSHIP AND KIND OF THOUGHTFULNESS. I THINK THAT THE TIMES WHEN MR. DOMS AND I WERE BUTTING HEADS ARE LONG GONE, AND I'M REALLY PROUD OF THE COMMUNITY CENTER THAT IT IS NOW. SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I APPRECIATE THAT. THANK YOU. [1:53:08] David Morse: ANY OTHER COUNCIL DISCUSSION? OKAY. ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC? Okay. All those in favor, show of hands. Six in favor, none opposed. On to last order of the day, Order 2026-128. This is Order 2026-128, found on page 151 of your packet, authorizing expenditure for non-union compensation study and pay structure development. What are the wishes of the Council? Councilor Chau? Yes, I'd like to make a motion for Order 2026-128, authorizing expenditure for non-union compensation and study pay structure development that this westbrook city council hereby authorizes an expenditure in the amount of eight thousand nine hundred seventy dollars to career management associates of scarborough for the non-union compensation study and pay structure development project as outlined in a tax exhibit funds ANY DISCUSSION? [1:54:17] City Administrator / Staff: THIS AUTHORIZES AN EXPENDITURE OF $8,970 TO CAREER MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATES WHO WAS THE LOW BIDDER IN THIS PROJECT. AS OUTLINED IN THE INCLOSED MEMO FROM OUR DIRECTOR OF HUMAN RESOURCES, AND AS MENTIONED DURING THE FISCAL 27 BUDGET REVIEW PROCESS, FUNDS WERE INCLUDED IN THE H.R. BUDGET this year to outsource the study of the compensation pay scale for non-union employees. As you may remember, year to year, we consider cost of living adjustment increases for non-union employees. We've done periodic adjustments to bring certain employees that fall below a 10% variance of average market rate for a certain position to back within what we consider to be that equitable standard, a 10% variance above or below that market average. However, what we haven't done for at least 15 years now is to reconsider the framework itself. We traditionally have grade levels and steps with certain number of years assigned to them, and certain positions are allocated to certain grades. Over the years, we've had compression that takes place. This is something that for unions, we typically look at when their three-year contracts come up for review. For non-union employees, it's been over 15 years now since we've looked at that framework itself. So through the fiscal 27 budget development process, our HR director, Joe LaPallo, who's here this evening, and can help answer any questions that we have. She asked for funds so that framework review and the development of a new framework could be incorporated into this year's budget. She solicited quotes. CMA, Career Management Associates, is the low bidder on this project, actually coming in under budget, which is fantastic for us, to help build that new framework. I'd like to note, this is something that we discussed during the budget review session that this funds the development of that new framework but not the implementation of that new framework that would need to come in the next fiscal year so this spreads it out over a two-year period this is to do the study build the new structure and then next year it would be implemented and this would get us back in line with best practices for compensation for our non-union employees. [1:56:54] David Morse: Thank you. Any discussion from the Council? [1:56:59] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): Councillor McCambridge? Excuse me. I just have one question. I'm not sure if it's for you or for Director Lopalo. Is the use of such a framework, is this like an industry standard? That's probably not the right term, but is this a common practice? [1:57:19] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte): It is a common practice to use a consultant. They have the expertise and know the best practices. There are area municipalities that do this regularly. Biddeford just engaged a full compensation study that included some of the stuff that we do internally. Other municipalities in the area also do. I know Bath did. Kenny Bunk did a couple years ago and actually used CMA. So this is something that occurs regularly. Yes, it's best practice. [1:57:53] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): And is it accurate to say, and tell me if I'm oversimplifying here, is the ultimate end goal here to ensure that the city is paying competitive salaries? [1:58:06] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte): That's correct. We do benchmarking internally to get data from other municipalities that we are competing for talent and to see what they're paying and see if we're on par. And that's what Ms. Holmes mentioned, plus or minus 10% of the market average. So we know where we stand, but we need to develop a framework to place these positions in these grades and steps to make sure that they're competitively paid for recruitment and retention, and also to see that there's not compression between positions, between the grades, and also the spread of the steps. So from beginning to end, to make sure there's enough growth within one's career. [1:58:51] Council Member (likely Victor Turcotte or similar): Okay, thank you. You're welcome. [1:58:52] David Morse: ANY OTHER DISCUSSION FROM THE COUNCIL? ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC? SHOW OF HANDS, ALL IN FAVOR? ALL IN FAVOR? NONE OPPOSED? ON TO OUR SECOND AND FINAL PUBLIC COMMENT OF THE EVENING. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO COME UP AND SPEAK, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND WHETHER YOU ARE A RESIDENT OF WESTBROOK. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES. IS THERE ANYONE ONLINE? THERE ARE NO HANDS ONLINE. WE HAVE NO REFERRALS, NO COMMITTEE REPORTS, AND WE ARE going into executive session i have a request to enter into executive session pursuant to 1mrsa section 405-6e for consultation with legal counsel concerning the legal rights and duties of the city council inviting the following individuals to attend mayor city administrator assistant city administrator city clerk director of emergency communications and i.t city solicitor and legal Council second okay all in favor okay we're an executive session